We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1950—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–161 of 332. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1950
Enacted

No. 34 of 1950 ›

Major de Valera

It is time, in view of developments in this debate, to unmask the pretence that the cost of living has been held steady. In doing that, I want to unmask the pretence that the cost of living stayed steady until August last, the fact of the situation being that, since this Government came into office, the cost of living has been creeping and had risen substantially by August last, in spite of the assertions of the Parliamentary Secretary which, on analysis of the data, will be found not to be accurate. Since August, there has been a further increase in the cost of living. It is important to ascertain the facts in this case for this reason, that, instead of facing up to the problem, this Government has been more concerned with devices to prevent the normal statistics showing the real increase in the cost of living which has taken place and with justifying themselves.

At the outset, I think it is legitimate to contrast the outlook and history in regard to this problem—admittedly a difficult one—of this Coalition Government over the past three years with the outlook and method of attack of the previous Administration. I said on the last occasion and I say it again— and I will substantiate what I say with facts and figures, both from official statistics and other sources—that all this Government has done is to allow things to drift. Where the drift has been favourable, they and the country have had the benefit; where it has been adverse, they have done nothing to counteract the trend in any effective degree. That is the serious aspect of our whole situation when one considers what this country may have to face in the future and when one considers how the tide of world affairs is flowing.

I have said that it is legitimate to contrast the history of the cost of living under two administrations. Before the war, there was a tendency for the cost of living to rise because of preparations and the inflation that attends all preparations for war. With the outbreak of the emergency, the last Government, as well as having to tackle the defence situation and all the other problems of the emergency, were able to tackle the question of the cost of living, and, through methods of price control, wage control, rationing and subsidies, they did in fact, as is very easily seen from the official statistics of November, 1943, stabilise the cost of living, in spite of all the problems of the years 1939 to 1942. During these years from 1943 until February, 1947, the cost of living was held virtually steady.

I gave the history of this matter as far back as 1948 and I do not want to repeat it, but the story will be found in Volume 110, column 373 onwards. The fact, in brief, is that, during the static period from 1943 to 1947, the cost of food items rose a little, but the cost of living generally remained virtually steady, and, as compared with the figure of 294, the old index, in November, 1943, the figure in February, 1947, was 295.

Comment on this

Wages were kept down, too.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

All that was secured by positive action on the part of the Government which faced up to the problem. The methods used at the time, and they were appropriate at the time, were wage control, price control, rationing and subsidies, because they were about the only weapons available. This can be said that what was done at that time worked out to the advantage particularly of the wage-earner during that period.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The subsequent history proves that it did, and the talk of Labour representatives at the moment shows that it did. Now, from February, 1947, to August, 1947, the cost of living rose steeply. It rose because of three main causes. Firstly, there was a large increase in the price of wheat which we had to import, in the price of tea and of other commodities. Secondly, the prices which our producers at home would get for their produce, that is to say, the farmers, rose in sympathy with world trends and, while that was beneficial to them and to the community, in one sense, it was detrimental to the consumer and represented a rise in the cost of living. Thirdly, the standstill Order was removed. It was necessary to remove it—quite apart from pressure—due to the rise in the cost of the other two things, but the removal of the standstill Order contributed to the rise in the cost of living, which was noticeable from February, 1947, until August, 1947.

Now, there is what happened. The steps taken in the early part of the war held the cost of living. When the crisis came, and the war started, the Government of the day did face up to its problems. It did what was appropriate and, amongst other things, it held the cost of living steady during the emergency period. At the end of the war there was another crisis. That always happens, both at the beginning and at the end of an emergency. Again, the cost of living rose, and, again, the Government faced up to its problems. As I said on Thursday, whatever one may say—what was done then largely contributed to the defeat of the Government—this can be said for them, that at least they faced up to their responsibilities when the cost of living was rising to heights roughly equivalent to what it is to-day and no more—a little less, if anything. The cost-of-living problem was tackled and the Supplementary Budget was brought in. It brought down the cost of living. Nobody can work a miracle, and to take action demanded that certain unpopular steps be taken. The steps taken were not popular, and, as I say, they contributed to the defeat of the last Government. But, at least, the last Government did their duty, and the action taken brought down the cost of living by three points straightway. It stabilised it and it remained so for some time.

That is the history of the last Administration. No matter how much you may criticise or disagree with the methods adopted by the last Administration — you may say that they overdid it in the Supplementary Budget or whatever you like—but this you cannot say, that they shirked their responsibility or evaded the problem, or that, when faced with a problem, they did not take some concrete steps to deal with it. The record of what they did is there and it shows that the steps taken were effective.

Let us take this Administration. The Government of this State was handed over to this Coalition in relatively favourable circumstances. The action of the previous Government had held the cost of living and had stabilised it. This Coalition came in on a tide of promises to reduce the cost of living with all the other promises that they had made. What, in fact, has happened? This, that they have done nothing beyond, at this late hour, three years afterwards, they propose to set up an advisory body to advise them as to what they should do in regard to a problem that has been mounting in proportions for three years. Within a short time of the increase occurring in 1947, the last Government tackled the problem, but this Government has not tackled it yet. Instead, they have been more concerned with devices for keeping the statistical representation of the cost of living in this book down than with dealing with the cost of living itself. We have had the brainwaves of the Minister for Finance. It is Deputy McGilligan, the Minister for Finance, who probably more than anybody else, is responsible for this by his device of taking things off the ration and then, because they are off the ration, not having them included in the cost-of-living index, and letting it relate only to the cost of rationed commodities. In that way, the real cost of living is largely masked. But, in spite of that device, the official figures which the Parliamentary Secretary quoted still show a rise in the cost of living.

That is what has been happening, that in spite of the efforts made to throw the burden over in directions which will not be reflected in the official index of the cost of living, the rise is reflected in that index all the same if one looks at it carefully. That is the history of this Government. As I have said, it is a serious and dangerous thing for this country, in present conditions, to let problems drift in that way. We have the same in regard to emigration; the same in regard to the employment figure—let it drift and work itself out. So, too, in the case of the Rent Acts. Now, we have another commission. There is nothing done in regard to it or to the cost of living but drift. In defence we have drift again. Whatever the future may hold for us, we are just drifting into it. It depends on the overall tide of the times on what rock we will be landed, or whether, by chance, we will pass safely through, and ride into harbour. That is the position. Of course, one is not surprised. That has been the story of Coalitions. Deputies remember the story of France under Blum before the last war, the Popular Front and all the rest of it. Because of French Coalitions, what happened to France? We know what the result was. France drifted, so that when the crisis of 1940 came Frenchmen could be heard to say "Better Hitler than Blum." Let us hope that there will not be people here complaining in similar terms at a later date about this Coalition. I know that Deputy Davin does not like to hear this, but Deputy Davin and the Labour Party, and the Clann na Poblachta Party, are keeping a Fine Gael-dominated Government in office.

Comment on this

Are you vexed?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

No, not a bit. If you have any explanation make it to the people who are talking about the cost of living because you are keeping this Government in office, and you cannot escape your responsibilities. You have had three years in which to make them do what you wanted them to do, but you have not done it. The class which the Labour Party profess to represent is being let down at every turn. Is that to go on? I do not mind the Clann na Poblachta Party. They have got what they wanted, a hand in the Government, but you, who profess to be looking after Labour and who profess to be interested in the worker, just look at what you have done!

I will give you a few facts. Coming to the Parliamentary Secretary's speech, as I said I was surprised at his approach. I read from the Government's supporting newspaper of the following day:—"No increase in the cost of living, Dáil told." Then I read further that the Parliamentary Secretary refuted the suggestion that there was any increase in the cost of living from mid-August, 1947, to mid-August, 1950. I had better deal with that problem. I will deal with it on the basis, first, of the statistics and then what the housewives feel. I pointed out already that if one looks at page 176 of the last issue of the Trade Journal, the cost-of-living index for all items rose to 102 before last August. From August, 1949, to last August it was one point higher than it was during 1948, except for May, 1948. That index really represents the food index, because in computing the index the items of food are predominantly weighted.

If one looks at clothing you will see that clothing has gone up from about 101 to 111, that is about ten points. Light and fuel have shown an increase on the average also, though, if one wanted, you could say that light and fuel, as far as the index is concerned, are almost steady. As I have said, that index reflects the food items and the reason that the cost-of-living trend is not more marked is simply because of the off-ration devices to which I have referred.

Now, if one goes further back on these journals and takes out the table associated with the cost-of-living index in regard to food in each issue, one will be able to get the particulars of prices. I propose to give you now the price trends in connection with items of food. I can do that in no better way than to take the meals during the day to see whether the cost of living is up or not. Let us start with breakfast. For breakfast we usually have tea or coffee, sugar, milk, bread, butter, margarine, porridge, which involves oatmeal; bacon, eggs, and sausages.

Comment on this

Not since 1948.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

You will get the figures in a moment. There is dearer oatmeal now and eggs are 5/6 a dozen. Then for dinner you have beef, mutton, bacon, fish, potatoes, vegetables, salt, etc. Then there are also tea, bread, butter, jam, confectionery and sundry foods such as flour, cheese, lard, black and white puddings, grapefruit, oranges and sweets. In all these items, with the exception possibly of pigs' heads, there has been no substantial decrease anyway and most of them have gone up as I will show when I come to go through them in detail. The cost of living, as represented by food, was up before August and is up more at present. Take transport, bus fares, petrol, tyres, oil and grease, clothing, footwear, leather, blankets, haircuts, laundry, insurance, postage, and the rise in catering establishment prices and let anybody tell me that the cost of living is not up.

Taking them in sequences, here are the details. The price of tea was reduced by 2/2 per lb from 4/10 per lb., that is reduced to 2/8 per lb. by the Supplementary Budget. The Fianna Fáil Government reduced the price of tea by 2/2 per lb. The price of rationed tea remains at that level to-day, and the ration is two ounces. However, off the ration tea has been made available in unlimited quantities at the black market price of 5/6 per lb. It was announced in the newspapers round about 29th July, 1949, that unlimited quantities would be available at the black market price of 5/6. There was a slight increase in the ration at one time, but there has been no increase since. In other words, more tea is being bought and it has to be bought at a higher price. That increase in the cost of living is masked because unrationed tea is not included in the index.

Not only was that done with tea, but, at the same time as this brainwave was put into operation, the permit system for catering establishments was abolished. Hotels, cafes, restaurants, and harvest workers were compelled to buy tea at the unsubsidised price and on 25th February, 1950, a further increase to 6/- per lb. was announced. There is the history of tea. Not only did it mean an increase in the cost of living for families who had to buy it in excess of the ration, but it meant an increase in price for people who had to eat out during the day. It hit the white-collar workers very hard. Many civil servants and others who, in the City of Dublin, have to take a meal out during the day take a light meal very frequently. Catering establishments were refused permits and the price went up. I was in such an establishment yesterday where you now pay 10d. for a pot of tea. The unrationed commodity has not increased in price, nor has it been reduced. But, as I say, tea is sold at the Government black-market price and the amount of the ration is such that most people are compelled to purchase it.

The price of coffee jumped up also. I think the present price is almost double what it was a few years ago at 4/6 per lb. The next item is sugar and there we have the same story. Before the Supplementary Budget of 1947 sugar was 6d. per lb. It was reduced by the Supplementary Budget of the Fianna Fáil Government to 4d. per lb., at which price the rationed sugar remains to-day. It certainly has not been reduced. It remains at the price to which the Fianna Fáil Government reduced it and the ration is three-quarters of a lb. Again, the off-the-ration device was employed. The Coalition made unrationed sugar available at 7½ per lb. and that price was increased last October to 8½d. per lb., and then subsequently reduced to 8d. per lb., so that consumers to-day are paying 8d. per lb. for a large proportion of the sugar that they require.

The position in regard to sugar is interesting in this regard. We have not all the latest figures. So far as the figures I have indicated are concerned, the Government have been almost completely successful so far as one can judge, very largely anyway, in subsidising the rationed proportion of the sugar by means of the price attaching to the unrationed sugar. Therefore, the idea of controlling the price of sugar is a sham. By the device of making unrationed sugar pay, because of its larger consumption, for the subsidy put on the rationed three-quarters of a pound, the Government has evaded the burden. Since unrationed sugar does not come within the scope of the index, the cost of sugar to the consumer is being masked and the increase does not appear in the official index. In regard to the extent to which sugar is being subsidised through the medium of unrationed sugar, I am unable to go further because of the absence of figures, but it certainly subsidises a considerable proportion, anyway. I have dealt now with sugar.

Let us take milk. I shall take the Trade Journal figures in 1947 and I shall extract the price in each quarter up to date. What does one find? One finds that, on the figures shown, the average of the price quoted for fresh milk was greater in 1948 and 1949 than it was in 1947; and may I remind the House we have not yet got the complete figures for 1950?

Comment on this

And Deputy Corry wants another increase.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The position is, for the benefit of Deputy Keane, that the Coalition Government has done nothing so far as these figures are concerned, for the consumer. It is quite obvious from the remarks of Deputies and others that the Coalition Government has neither satisfied the producer. It is, again, the story of the old man and the ass: trying to please everybody, you please nobody. Let us take the official list relating to milk. I have here the price lists issued by R.G.D.A.T.A. for November 6th, 1947, and October 31st, 1950. These are comparable dates. What do they show? If one looks at milk, one sees that in 1947 bottled milk was 5d. per pint delivered; it is now 5½d. delivered. Loose milk delivered was 4¾d.; it is now 5¼d. Loose milk in the shop was 4¼d.; it is now 4¾d. On these figures it is obvious that the price of milk has gone up. The result is that, on the figures I have given the House, the beverage, whether it be tea or coffee, that we drink at breakfast, containing sugar and milk, has gone up because every item that goes towards making that beverage has gone up. Now, let us take bread.

Comment on this

Light beer would be down in price, though.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Let us take bread. Before the Supplementary Budget, introduced in 1947, the price of the 2-lb. loaf was 6¾d. On the introduction of that Budget it was reduced to 6d. by means of subsidies in October, 1947. In August, 1948, under the Coalition Government, the price was increased to 6¼d. These figures refer to the 85 per cent. extraction loaf. Not satisfied with that small increase in the price of bread—though when one considers the quantity of bread consumed, it represents a substantial increase—the Government, in this case I think the Minister for Agriculture, was responsible for the introduction of the white loaf, another black market device, if you like. The 75 per cent. extraction loaf was introduced. I think the 2-lb. loaf is almost twice as dear as the ordinary loaf. It runs somewhere around 1/-. Therefore, the price of bread has gone up. I shall deal with flour here, though I am taking it out of its sequence more or less, but, since it is allied to bread, I think it is more fitting to introduce it into the picture at this stage. The Supplementary Budget of 1947 reduced the price of household flour from 3/10¼d. per stone to 2/10¼d.; under that Budget, the Fianna Fáil Government pulled down the price of household flour by 1/- per stone. It has remained at the price at which the Fianna Fáil Government left it.

Comment on this

But the taxes went up.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is the position with regard to 85 per cent. extraction flour. But white flour was introduced at 7/- a stone as from January, 1949, so that bread and the things that go to the making of bread have gone up. The next item is butter and margarine.

Comment on this

Is this a new index of your own?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is a very good index.

Comment on this

It is a pity you did not give it to Deputy Lemass, then.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Creamery butter has remained at 2/8 per lb. since 1947. There has been no change in the price of rationed butter, but farmers' butter, which was the same price at that time, had by September, 1948, risen as high as 3/6 per lb. under the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! And we were told we were putting the farmers out of business.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

At the moment, butter off the ration is 3/6 per lb. The same device was adopted in the case of butter as was adopted in the case of white flour. Off the ration butter was introduced at 3/6 per lb., and the former special allowance made to catering establishments and institutions was withdrawn and these establishments must now purchase butter at the higher price.

Comment on this

What type of institution? Is it public or private.

Comment on this
Matthew O'Reilly Acting-Chairman (Mr. M. O'Reilly) Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The next item is margarine. In May and August of 1947, margarine was 1/6 per lb. I cannot find the figure for November, 1947, but it reappears in December, 1948, at 2/- per lb. under the Coalition Government. I do recollect, though I have not been able to trace it, a slight increase in the price of margarine after the present Government took office. It was subsequently reduced to 1/8 and later still to 1/6 per lb. However, this month it has been increased again to 1/8, and the net result is that margarine has gone up in price.

Let us take now oatmeal and porridge. Taking the figures from the Trade Journal, all during 1947 oatmeal, according to the Trade Journal, was round about 6/9 a stone—6/8¾d. to 6/9. The present Government took office in 1948 when the price was 6/9 per stone. There were certain fluctuations. The price fell a little mainly because of the bloomer about the oats a few years ago, a bloomer with which Deputies are very familiar, but it rose again very quickly. Here is the price for 1950: February, 1950, 7/4 per stone; May, 1950, 7/7¾d. per stone; August, 1950—remember, the cost of living did not rise—7/8¾d. per stone. These prices are from the Trade Journal.

Comment on this

What was it per stone in 1947?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

6/9.

Comment on this

What was it in 1946?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It was 6/9 per stone when you took over. We will take now 5th November, 1949, just one year ago. A rise in the price of flake meal was reported. On the 29th January last a rise in the price to 7/8 was reported. Now let us see the comment made in the Evening Mail recently. I am quoting those papers that support the Government:—

"Oatmeal, an excellent staple food, has now become a luxury from which all but the wealthy are barred. Within the past week two shops in the same district charged for flake meal, one at the rate of 10/- and the other at the rate of 12/- per stone. Why such a discrepancy?"

That is the Evening Mail of 21st November, 1950. Bacon, eggs and sausages—we shall take bacon first.

Comment on this

You can get it now, at any rate.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Yes. Irish streaky, Irish shoulder and pigs' heads are listed in these Trade Journal tables I refer to. I shall give the official return first. In 1947 the price of bacon is listed from 2/10½d. to 2/11 for the four quarters of that year.

Comment on this

Where could you get it then?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

They do not like it. Can you not take it now?

Comment on this

You could not get it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

You will have to take it.

Comment on this

I am sorry for you.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is the trouble, you have to stand over Deputy Cosgrave, the Parliamentary Secretary, but you will have to take it now. In 1947 the figure was 2/11 per lb., and that was the figure handed over in February, 1948.

Comment on this

Where was it?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It had risen by November, 1949, to 3/-. By August, 1950, it was 3/1½d. Irish shoulder shows the same type of increase—handed over at about 1/7¾d. and rising to 1/10¾d. in August. Pigs' heads, I grant you, show a decrease but now listen to the comments as we go along. The price of bacon was decontrolled in 1949. Following decontrol the price rose and the Irish Independent, mark you a great favourite of Deputy O'Higgins, on 16th August, 1949, under the heading, “Increase in the Price of Bacon”, said:—

"The present retail price of bacon is 3/1 per lb. for most popular cuts and for smoked cuts 3/2. The less popular cuts may be purchased for 1/11 per lb. The average general retail prices for some time past have been from 2/11½ for best cuts down to 1/9¼."

Then again the same paper on the 18th August, 1949, had an editorial on the price of bacon which stated that "it seems the more bacon we get, the more we shall be required to pay for it," and suggested drastic action, which has not been taken yet. On May 20th, 1950, the Irish Times reported a further increase in the price of bacon, and a still further increase was reported within a week by the Sunday Press. As I say, pigs' heads were the bright spot, but it is interesting to note that at the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union's Conference, a speaker rejected the suggestion of the Minister for Agriculture that the workers should concentrate on pigs' heads, saying that the workers were entitled to better.

Deputy Corish, the Parliamentary Secretary, replying for the Minister for Agriculture in the Dáil on 16th November, 1950, felt that gammon and ham belonged to the luxury classes, and it is well known that bacon prices had increased.

Most of these increases about which I am talking were up to August last. What is the position to-day? I made a little check of my own to-day and it is a first-hand check as I went into a shop and priced the cuts there. These were the prices I was given. Streaky 3/6, back rashers 3/11, neck 3/-. There is one establishment where the best smoked is selling at 4/1. So there is bacon. It is a luxury and prices have increased steeply. Let us then take sausages. Pork sausages were handed over at about 2/- a lb. in 1947-48. They were about 2/- or a little less all through 1947. According to the official statistics, they had risen to 2/2 per lb. in 1950. At the moment sausages are 2/8 per lb. and in one shop they were 2/10 per lb.

The last item which used to be considered for the breakfast table is eggs. The price of eggs, as the Parliamentary Secretary has reminded me, fluctuates, but it is interesting to note that in November of any year of the four years I have taken, the price of eggs has been higher according to official statistics under the Coalition Government than in 1947. In November, 1947, they were 4/5 per dozen; in November, 1948, 5/2¾d. per dozen; in November, 1949, 5/0¼d. per dozen and they are 5/6 per dozen to-day. So, there is breakfast for you. As far as breakfast is concerned, can the Parliamentary Secretary say that the cost of living has not gone up when you take the quantities consumed and the rise in every item? As I say, you must consider that there has been a rise in the price of such controlled items as tea and sugar, because the black market off-the-ration prices must be taken into account as well as the controlled price which has not been improved upon by this Government. Now let us come to dinner.

Comment on this

Why not call it lunch?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Lunch, if the Deputy would prefer it. In the Trade Journal again there are listed for each year in these tables certain categories of meat and their prices. I shall start with beef, again over the four years. In February, 1947, the price of sirloin beef was 1/11; in May, 2/4; in August, 2/3¾d., and in November, 2/2½d. In February, 1948, the price was 2/2½d. In other words, during the winter period, November-February, the last days of the Fianna Fáil Government in office, the price of meat was steady and controlled at 2/2½d. per lb. for sirloin beef. The Government were only a short time in office when, as a result of a ministerial Order, the price went up.

Comment on this

As a result of an undertaking which your Government had given to the butchers.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I know, but you promised reductions. In the case of sirloin beef the controlled price was up by 2d. per lb. The same picture is shown, generally speaking, in the other categories of beef, so that it is quite true to say that as far as beef is concerned the price has gone up in all categories, under this Government. For instance, shoulder was 1/5¾d. when this Government assumed office. In August last it was 1/8. Brisket was 1/3; in August last it was 1/4¾d.; neck was 1/4½d.; in August last, it was 1/5¼d. Liver was 1/6½d. in February, 1948; in August last, it was 1/7½d.

Mutton shows the same thing. In November, 1947 and February, 1948, it was about 2/3 a lb. In August last, the official figure was 2/5¾d.

Comment on this

You cannot compare different seasons.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

On these figures, the official statistics, it is quite true to say that the price of meat was up by August last. The price of meat was controlled and the price went up, following an Order, in March, 1948. Not only did meat prices go up but in 1948 also the price of boiling fowl went up. It increased from 2/- to 2/4 per lb. I know there was the question of the butchers and meat prices and, again, as in regard to milk, the Government has not been able to solve either party's problem.

The last bit of information that I have in regard to meat is in connection with the Grangegorman Hospital estimates. I think it was on 20th October, 1950, that an item in the Irish Independent reported that mutton cutlets were up from 2/2 to 2/6 per lb. and that chickens were 3/7½d. compared with 3/4 per lb. On that showing, meat is up in price. It is unnecessary for me to add, however, that the ordinary housewife in the city will tell you that these prices do not represent her costs.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy answer a question?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I will make my speech. The Deputy can make his.

Comment on this

I thought you might deal with Deputy Lemass's promise to increase meat prices.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am dealing with the cost of living and I am dealing with the items in connection with which the Parliamentary Secretary and the Government said the cost of living had not gone up. I am anxious to give them the facts. Every housewife knows that these prices do not represent her difficulty, that as far as the cost of meat is concerned and the provision of meat for her family, it is almost prohibitive, especially in the city.

Comment on this

And always has been.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is quite clear from the newspaper reports, which I will deal with in a moment in another connection, that I am not exaggerating the situation when I say that. Now I shall give the Parliamentary Secretary a bright spot. Potatoes are an important item and potatoes, like pigs' heads, have shown a fluctuation that perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary can claim as satisfactory. The price of potatoes last August of 2/6¼d. is greater than the price when the Government assumed office but, in fairness to them, one must admit that the price varied in between the years. The fact is that potato prices fluctuate. This Government have left the price of potatoes to that fluctuation and where the economic factors have operated to reduce the price the housewife has got the benefit but when you look at the figure you simply see fluctuation, and I do not think that one can claim that there has been a contribution to either a reduction in the cost of living or an increase in the cost of living looking at it from an average point of view over the last few years. So that potatoes can hardly be invoked by the Parliamentary Secretary to justify his very extraordinary statement in opening this debate.

Vegetables are a seasonal thing and I leave it to the housewife of the city to say what is her experience in regard to vegetables, but in the case of vegetables that are packed, such as peas, again there is an increase. There is an increase in the price of pepper, in the price of packets of salt and certain types of sauces and condiments.

Comment on this

What about tomatoes?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Tomatoes have been decreased. At what cost, though, in another direction?

Comment on this

Do you want them put up?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Deputy O'Higgins is very clever with that kind of thing. The fact is that the price of Irish tomatoes was reduced by allowing a flood of foreign imports. The Deputy can have that fact, if he wishes.

That is the dinner meal. Take any of these figures and see whether you can claim a reduction in the cost of living in food items.

Now tea, which consists of bread, butter, jam and confectionery. In the poorer quarters bread and spread is a very important item. I have already dealt with the price of tea. Tea, sugar and milk go as for breakfast but the bread and spread angle of it becomes a serious and important thing to people like the poorer classes in Dublin. What is this Government's history in regard to bread and spread? Their history is this: luxury white flour at black market prices for those who can afford to pay for it, some of it forced upon restaurants and forced upon the poorer class salaried worker who has to eat out. Bread, the staple of life, has been increased in price under this Government. Butter, one of the big sources of fat for these people, a very large item on their household budget, the staple of the larger families in the city, has been rigidly controlled at its ration, never exceeding ¾lb.

Comment on this

Instead of 2 ozs.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

And, after the ½ lb. at the Fianna Fáil price, they have to get the rest of it at the Dillon black market price of 3/6.

Comment on this

You gave them 2 ozs.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

They got all that they got at the controlled price. It was not there. There were emergency conditions. Now you can afford to give them the ration. Instead of giving them a decent ration at that price, you are compelling them to supplement the ration by butter at 3/6 a lb. That would not be too bad if jam had not gone up also. Deputy Byrne knows what bread and spread means to the poor of Dublin.

Comment on this

Margarine went up.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am glad the Deputy noted that. This is what the Fine Gael-dominated Coalition has done; here are the Trade Journal figures for jam up to August, 1950. Let the Parliamentary Secretary note. The price of jam rose, from February, 1947, to where it was 1/6½d. It was handed over and remained at 1/6½d. in 1948. In 1949 it was put up 2d. a lb. and it was 1/8½d. in August last. So that tea, particularly for the poorer classes, also represents a meal where the cost of living has gone up. The cost of bread and spread has increased, whether that spread is butter, jam or margarine.

Comment on this

Very often it was not either butter or margarine. Very often they had no spread.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Deputy forgets that this country weathered a war emergency very much better than practically any country in Europe and that to-day and for the past two years, under allegedly peace-time conditions, conditions in which the Taoiseach was legislating for peace, this is the picture you have.

I have dealt with the increase in the price of flour. I forgot fish. Fish is also interesting. This shows also an increase in price, where any changes are indicated. The official returns for kippered herrings show a slight increase in price; fresh herrings are steady, but cod steaks are up. In October, 1950, under the heading "Commodity price rises", the Irish Independent reported that cod, hake and haddock advanced from 2/2 to 2/8 per lb.

Comment on this

A lot of codology.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I do not think a lot of people who have to face this problem, in the cities anyhow, would regard this as a lot of codology. As regards cheese, according to the returns for November, 1947, to February, 1948, the average retail price was 2/1½. Cheese is shown in the Trade Journal as remaining at that price in 1948 and 1949, but it increased by a farthing per lb. in February, 1950. It was then 2/1¾ and it rose to 2/2 in May. Lard remained steady. Black and white pudding went up 4d. a lb. since decontrol. Grapefruit and oranges were also up. So far as the figures available to me are concerned, they show that grapefruit used to be controlled at 8d. a lb., but now grapefruit are 8d. or 9d. each. Oranges were 6d. to 8d. a lb. and they are shown in some lists at 7d., when controlled, but at the moment they are 10d. a lb. Sweets also went up.

With regard to bus fares, these were increased to a minimum of 2d., and the Minister hoped to collect £750,000 through that means. Other transport has gone up. Clothing, footwear, blankets and socks, soap, haircuts and laundry—every one of these items represents an increase in the cost of living and they show an increase prior to August last.

By way of further convincing the Parliamentary Secretary that all these increases have not suddenly occurred, I will give him some instances. I suspected from his approach to this matter on the last day that he was trying to stave off certain things he was not too optimistic about. I would like the House carefully to observe the rake's progress. I will not go too far back. I will go to August, 1948, and I will show what happened in the two years up to August, 1950. This is the period in which, according to the Parliamentary Secretary, the cost of living did not rise. In the newspapers on 26th August, 1948, it was reported that harvest tea was going to cost 5/- per lb.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Cheaper than 30/-.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

On the 16th August of the same year there was a higher price for bread. On November 10th, 1948, the Minister could hold out no promise to increase rations. By 17th November, 1948, according to the Irish Independent, the Labour Party were out to seek a meeting with the Government on this matter. That was two years ago, and look at what you have got! In May, 1949, a union official is reported as saying that the Government plan for living costs was unknown. On 29th July, 1949, there was an announcement of off-the ration black market tea at 5/6 a lb., and 6/6 for China tea.

On 16th August, 1949, there was an increase in the price of bacon, and that was the heading of an Independent story. On 18th August, 1949, the Independent had an editorial on the price of bacon in which it said:—

"It seems now that the more bacon we get the more we shall be required to pay for it."

On 21st September, 1949, the Irish Independent said: “Shoe repairs may cost more.” On 23rd September, 1949, the Irish Press reported the cost of living up a point. On the same day a deputation from the Irish Housewives' Association was advocating action — that was in the Irish Times. They were complaining about various prices which were set out in the report. All this is apropos of the Parliamentary Secretary's allegations. On 3rd October, 1949, the Independent said that petrol was likely to cost more. On the same day fertiliser prices went up, in spite of an undertaking by the Minister for Agriculture that they would not.

On 5th November, 1949, the price of flaked oatmeal went up. On the 23rd November, 1949, the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union secretary was pressing for action—that is just over a year ago. On 24th November, 1949, there was a heading, "Petrol to go up 2d. a gallon." On 1st December, 1949, Deputy Dr. Brennan asked in the House whether the Minister would take drastic steps to protect the public against persistent inflation, and the Minister gave a reply.

On 14th January, 1950, tyre prices increased and on the 20th January, 1950, I read a heading, "Coffee prices soar to record level." On 22nd January, 1950, there was a forecast that shoe repairs would go up and on the same date also coffee was reported to be 4/6 a lb. About the same time consideration was being given to the porridge problem. On the 2nd February, 1950, we saw the report: "Leather up; dearer boots, shoes and repairs". On the 25th February, 1950, unrationed tea went up 6d. a lb. to 6/-. The Irish Independent reported on 23rd March, 1950, that the trade unions were again pressing about the cost of living.

The Irish Independent on the 1st April, 1950, have a news item with the heading: “Living Cost Increase”. On the 11th April, 1950, there is a heading: “Living Costs Going Up”. On the 18th May, 1950, the Irish Times writes an editorial on the question of living costs and deals with meat in particular. On the 20th May, 1950, the Irish Times has an article on meat in which it says:—

"Lamb, which is not controlled, is out of the question for most families. It, too, is of an inferior quality, though there has not been so much candour about this as there has been about beef. Mutton, at 4/- a lb., is also something to be thought twice about. Inferior in quality also, it has the added disadvantage that it shrinks remarkably in cooking, so that a joint of 5 lb. can result in a roast which will yield about 2¼ lb. of edible meat."

And the same day there is a report of the price of bacon up.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

She must be a bad cook.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Times Pictorial of the week ending 27th May, 1950, have a story headed: “Irish Food Costs More When Eaten in Ireland”. Mind you, this is all by friends of Fine Gael—whatever about the other Parties which comprise the Government. On the 3rd June, 1950, we read the heading: “Bacon Prices Go Up Again”. The Irish Independent carries an editorial on the 3rd June, 1950, on the cost-of-living index figure and it makes this comment— which it may well do, too:—

"The point is of major consequence"—

referring to the cost of living —

"because the present Government will be judged mainly on its success or otherwise in bringing down the cost of living."

Yet, here is the Parliamentary Secretary claiming as a great achievement that he held it steady to August—and apparently he is afraid to talk about the present moment. It is a sad change. On the 3rd June, 1950, we read in the Irish Times:—

"Nearly everybody, except perhaps the extremely rich, has to admit and deplore the rising cost of living. Without doubt, everything is dearer than it was a short few months ago."

That was printed on the 3rd June—and that was before August.

Deputy Cowan and Deputy A.P. Byrne were exercised about the problem on the 7th of June last. I do not think they will admit that the problem has only developed since August. The reference will be found in a question reported in columns 1389/40 of the Official Report, Vol. 121, of that date. On the 20th June, 1950, the Housewives' Association Annual Report stated that the hope that the cost of living would show a downward trend this year had been shattered in recent months, and it goes on to complain. On the 23rd June the official information showed an increase in the index figures for the cost of living which was 102 in May. Also, on the 23rd June, the Irish Times carried a story: “Workers Entitled To More Than Pigs' Heads.”

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

How are we going to bring it down? Will you tell us?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

On the 24th June the Times has a heading: “No Hope Of Reduction In Food Costs.” On the 1st July civil servants were pressing for a cut in prices. On the 5th July the Congress of Irish Unions hits at the two-price ration system, and the Irish Times carried a story on the 15th July—I think referring to the same thing—“Two-Tiered System Of Food Prices Deplored.” On the 18th July, 1950, haircuts up.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

How about shaving?

Comment on this

That did, too.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

On the 27th August, 1950, the Trade Union Congress chief, Mr. Sam Kyle, commented on the cost of living—a big increase in the last three months. On the 29th July, 1950, we read that tyres and tubes will cost more.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

On the 29th November, 1950, Deputy de Valera——

Comment on this
Matthew O'Reilly Acting-Chairman (Mr. M. O'Reilly) Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this
Major de Valera

On the 11th August—blankets and socks up. The Irish Independent forecasts, on the 30th August, that footwear prices may increase——

Comment on this

Again.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Again. The Irish Transport and General Workers' general president is again complaining of the cost-of-living confidence trick — as well he might—on the 20th September, 1950, as reported in the Irish Press. The Irish Press of 29th September, 1950, reports that the price of oil is going up. Mr. Alan P. Dempsey, outgoing president, at the Annual Delegate Meeting of the Irish Conference of Professional and Service Association in Dublin is reported in the newspapers of the 9th October, 1950, as concerned about the rise in the cost of living. That is significant.

Soap: Lever Brothers announce increases in the price of soap on the 11th October, 1950. Then, on the 20th October, 1950, the Irish Independent, referring to tenders for Grangegorman Hospital Board, has a story concerning increased prices, and showing “Commodity Prices Rise” as the heading. At the end of the month, the 31st October, the Labour Party is concerned at rising prices and on the 30th October even the glass of whiskey had gone up by 2d.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It had gone up by 8d. the last time we heard about it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I have already referred to sugar. Margarine was reported up 2d. on the 12th November, 1950. In the face of that mass of evidence I find it very hard to understand how the Parliamentary Secretary can try to represent that the cost of living remained static to August and, by implication, suggested that there is no problem in that matter. The sad fact is, as I have said already, that the Government have largely ignored the problem. They have concentrated on trying to hide the rise in the cost of living in the official statistics. They have made use of devices which are equivalent to taxation. The making of the unrationed sugar, through its price, pay a large portion of the subsidy on the rationed price is simply a taxation device. This system has the added advantage of masking the effect on the index and if that index to-day is not a true indication of the cost of living it is entirely due to the devices adopted by the Government. Even in spite of all those devices, that index itself shows a rise in the cost of living. What action has the Government taken? It is all right for the Government to be talking about the rise in the cost of living and about doing something. They have appointed a commission. How many commodities were decontrolled by them since the 1st January, 1949? Labour is talking about price control.

Comment on this

And we have good reason to.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

But on Wednesday, 22nd November, 1950, the answer was given to Deputy Lemass that commodities subject to price control on the 1st January 1949, which had been released from control since, were: Bacon; beef sausages; biscuits; black and white puddings; bicarbonate of soda; canned fish; coffee and coffee preparations; copper sulphate; cornflour; cube sugar; dried figs; enamelled hollow ware; footwear; grapefruit; honey; maize meal; meat meals and meat and bone meals; oranges; onions; peas, dried and canned; pork sausages; rice; sausage meat; soaps, soap powders, soap flakes, soap chips; sole leather; sultanas and currants; tallows and greases; timber—home grown—standing and in the log; whiskey, gin, brandy. In other words, the Government is simply letting these things work themselves out as well as they can, instead of doing anything about them. They have been simply letting go what responsibility they have had in the matter. What is the official attitude of the Government to-day? They started, before they came into office, with rather extravagant promises, of which I can quote a few.

"We advocate a scheme of subsidies of essential commodities as a step to alleviate the burden of the cost of living."

This was Deputy T.F. O'Higgins, as reported in the Midland Tribune of the 10th January, 1948. But, in fact, through the off-the-ration device, they have relieved themselves of the burden of subsidies. The present Minister for External Affairs, Deputy MacBride, speaking on the 6th September, 1947, said: —

"Subsidies provided should be sufficient to bring about a reduction of at least 30 per cent. on the existing cost of all food produced and consumed here. Food subsidies would enable the farmer to pay wages which would stem emigration."

You had those extravagant promises about reducing the cost of living. The Government got into office, but they did not reduce the cost of living. What was their attitude then? In August, 1948, the Minister for External Affairs was satisfied that the cost of living increase had been halted. It had been halted, halted by the Fianna Fáil Government. We find an extraordinary thing in the Irish Independent of the 22nd July, 1949, where the Taoiseach is reported to have said that the cost of living had dropped ten points on the May figures. I have been unable to find authority for that astounding statement.

Comment on this

Why not quote him accurately?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am. This is what is in the Irish Independent:“The cost of living had dropped ten points on the May figure,” and the heading is: “Cost of Living Cut, Taoiseach says”.

Comment on this

The Deputy is giving a lot of snippets, but I do not think he is giving them accurately.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is accurate. The Deputy can check it, 22nd July, 1949.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said that that was on the old basis of assessment.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Deputy may be right, but that is not in this report.

Comment on this

The Deputy is entirely wrong.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The figures I am giving will show whether that is right or not—the official figures in the journal. On the 7th February, 1950, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, as reported in the Irish Times, takes the line that there has been no increase in the cost of living. That is February last—a Labour Minister says there has been no increase. In the Dáil on the 23rd March, 1950, the Taoiseach refers to reductions in a number of items as being reductions in the cost of living, but I am afraid that laminated springs, nuts and bolts, sheet glass, varnishes, putty and similar materials will hardly weigh very much with the housewives in comparison with the rising cost of the commodities which I have already given. On the 25th May last—listen to this for the attitude of the present Government — on the Vote for Industry and Commerce the Minister for Industry and Commerce said this—and you can relate this back to the figures I have already given you over that period — referring to the unions: —

"They must, I submit, agree that the present retail prices situation, while deserving of the close attention and concern it receives from the Government, gives cause for a high degree of satisfaction."

I wonder will many Deputies supporting the Minister subscribe to that opinion. It is indicative of the attitude of the Government—a certain amount of wishful thinking. Then we have the rather extraordinary spectacle—I have already referred to it on the debate on the Taoiseach's Estimate this year—of the Minister for External Affairs at this late stage telling the housewives to do the job themselves. So that is the attitude of the Government.

Now, I have, I admit, taken considerable time in developing certain facts for the benefit of the House, and I have done so objectively. I have made no statement which I have not substantiated with figures, as I realise that this thing is a problem which is not easy of solution. It is a problem which has been aggravated very largely by the Government's approach to it. In the first instance, they secured office on the tide of irresponsible promises, promises to reduce the cost of living and to do very many other things. I grant that they did make certain adjustments in taxation, but they are collecting more in taxation than ever before and at the end of three years they are less favourably placed than they were in the beginning. The cost of living has risen out of control on them and all they do is set up another commission, just as they did when emigration went out of control. They have shifted their ground now, to try to maintain that the index remains steady and the plight to which they have been driven is well shown by the fact that the Parliamentary Secretary, when introducing this Bill, resorted to relying on data published in Reynold's News. Reynold's News and the comparison with England is now to be the basis of our computations — but even there his figures can be controverted. He says.—

"It is important to note that for the 2-lb. loaf the price of bread in Britain is 5½d. and here it is 6¼d."

I do not know why he quoted that. It seems to me that if his figure is right bread is cheaper in England and is not rationed. A quart of milk, he said, was 10d. in Britain and here 7¼d. It is dearer in England but, as I have said, the price of milk has gone up under the Coalition. He gives figures for the price of eggs. "A dozen eggs in Britain cost 3/6 and here 3/3½d.," but neither figure seems related to the reality here, 5/6 a dozen. Butter is cheaper in England according to his own figures. I do not know whether they are right or wrong. He says that a lb. of butter in Britain is 2/- and here 2/8. Cheese in Britain is 1/2 and here 2/1¾d.

Comment on this

It is subsidised.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

A lb. of sugar is 5d. in Britain, he says, and here 4d. Yes, maybe he is right, but he omits to mention that unrationed sugar, any sugar over a ¾lb. ration, is 8d. Bacon, it is interesting to note, according to his figure is 2/6 in Britain while the average of all cuts here, he says, is 2/0½d. I gave the figure for bacon already and it is nearer 3/- than 2/-. He says that there are no comparative figures for coffee but that tea in Britain is 3/4 a lb. and here 2/8. Again he omits the unrationed figure. He might add usefully that unrationed tea is 6/- a lb. here which is greater than the 3/4 in Britain.

Take the Parliamentary Secretary's own approach to this question. Mark his thesis. His thesis is that up to August last there was no increase in the cost of living and then he omits to deal with the present situation at all which savours of running away from the problem. Even on the official index for August last prices were up. In comparison with England, on his own figures, when all things are taken into account and even adopting Reynold's News as a basis, the situation is not so favourable for us as the Parliamentary Secretary would try to maintain. There is another aspect to all this.

Comment on this

Several.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Yes, I agree. In the towns particularly the situation is getting serious especially for the white-collar worker. I mentioned the catering establishments. You will find if you eat out that prices have gone up largely because these establishments are now forced to take tea, sugar and butter at the uncontrolled price and in some cases bread like fancy bread and buns. In addition, in common with the rest of the community they have to pay for the increases that followed the decontrol of the price of commodities in the last few years. What is the result? I noted recently some menus and they show that tea, for instance, was up. A pot of tea now costs 10d. and you have to pay 6d. for vegetables in a not so high-class restaurant. Where even after the war, say in 1947, you could get lunch in this city for 2/6 or 2/9, certainly under 3/-, now the typical price for a meal is about 3/6. There is a rise in the cost of that meal. Pats of butter are now 1d. each. Meat and other items reflect the rise in costs. You used to be able to get vegetables for about 3d. but they now cost 6d., though you can get potatoes sometimes for 4d. I saw in a restaurant yesterday that rashers were 1/- each and the cost of three sausages was 2/-. Buns are now 3d. where they used to be 1½d. or 2d.

That would not matter so much if it was merely luxury, if it was just a question of a boy taking a girl out for an evening—though even then it is hard on him to have to pay more—or if it were merely a case of going to the pictures, but you must consider that in this city many civil servants, especially the junior categories and white collar workers generally, are forced to have their mid-day repast out whether they take a regular lunch or just a snack at meal time to tide them over until they go home. The direct result of the ministerial policy regarding off-ration prices and forcing these prices on catering establishments is that the worker must pay more for these meals and that the cost of his living has gone up correspondingly. That worker largely has to travel in by bus and his bus fares have been increased—another rise in the cost of living.

Comment on this

You handed over a bankrupt Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Even if he drives a car—many travellers must drive a car as part of the expenses of their trade—there is a further increase in that regard. Not only are there increases in prices at home for these unfortunate people, but there are increases outside directly due, directly attributable, to the device adopted in cold blood by this Government of having off-ration commodities at black market prices coupled with a withdrawal of permits and allowances so as to compel these establishments to buy at such prices, therefore compelling the consumers in these establishments to buy at such prices.

Institutions have very much the same story. Formerly special allowances were made but now these institutions have to buy at higher prices. However, I will leave the development of that particular subject to other Deputies who have more specific and detailed knowledge of the working of school meals and hospitals and the like. I have not got the figures but I would like to see them because I suspect that if one examined the figures for some of our big institutions one would find that the cost of maintaining an inmate or patient had risen quite markedly in the last three years. That in itself is a very good indication of the rise in the cost of living and a direct answer to the thesis that the Parliamentary Secretary is trying to sustain in this House.

Wholesale prices also confirm the trend. Up to this I have dealt with retail prices. I have here a list of wholesale prices and the wholesale prices will, of course, be reflected in the retail prices. In addition to the decontrolled items I have mentioned already as increasing in price between 1949 and 1950, here is a list of commodities — I will not give all the prices in detail——

Comment on this

Let us have them.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins wants them.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

These are real increases to the housewife. I was not able to get the retail prices because the R.G.D.A.T.A. people do not publish anything but controlled prices, but, as I say, the retail prices will reflect the wholesale prices. If Deputies are being embarrassed, let them blame Deputy O'Higgins, who, as a city T.D., is very interested in the rise in the cost of living which has taken place under the Government he supports and which was put into office to implement his promises, in common with those of the Parliamentary Secretary and others, to reduce the cost of living.

Comment on this

He is going to bring down the rates as well.

Comment on this

We did.

Comment on this

You did not.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

We will take Bisto first. In 1949, Bisto was 1/3 per dozen and in 1950 it is 1/8 a dozen. Baking powder was 1/9 as against 1/10½d.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy reading from?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

From a list of wholesale prices I have compiled.

Comment on this

From Irish Press sources.

Comment on this

This is the official wholesale list.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I have already dealt with coffee. Rice, in 1949, was 8½d. and it is now 9d.; coconut was 1/6 and is now 3/-. Currants rose from 107/4 per cwt. in 1948-49 to 116/8 in 1950. Sultanas rose from 107/4 in 1948 to 121/4 in 1949 and 133/- per cwt. in 1950. Flakemeal I have already dealt with. Lentils rose from 10d. to 1/- per lb. between 1948 and 1950. Lemon curd rose from 18/- a dozen to 19/- a dozen and mincemeat from 18/9 to 22/- per dozen. Peas, Batchelors, were 9/3 a dozen and are now 9/9. Tinned peas were 6/8 and are now 7/3. Did Deputy O'Higgins say something?

Comment on this

A Deputy on this side asked if you had any sour grapes on the list?

Comment on this

No, they are all over there.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Candied peel is shown as being up about 2d. and cherries about 2½d. Pepper in 1949 was 16/- per dozen and is now 33/- per dozen for the 2-oz. size. It was 9/6 in 1948. Sauces rose from 1948 by 9d. and tins of Cerebos salt were 8/6 in 1948, 9/6 in 1949 and are now 9/9. Tinned grapefruit was 17/- and is now 22/6, while pears, which were 30/-, are now 32/-, so that the wholesale prices show an increase in the cost of living also. I think I have now given enough evidence, or does Deputy O'Higgins want more?

Comment on this

I am prepared to take it all.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am afraid you will have to.

Comment on this

I have some to give, too.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

And then I open the Independent again reporting last day's debate and I find: “No increase in the cost of living Dáil told.” That is the evidence. I have gone into it in some detail in order to try to get the facts before us, because let every one of us realise that there is a problem there and it might have been better for this Government had they realised that, at the time they were making extravagant promises, they were largely contributing to making the problem unmanageable for themselves.

Deputy Larkin has suggested certain approaches. The trouble is that some of his approaches are one-sided and he has not taken all the factors into account. The remedies, whatever they are, will not be completely efficacious, one can be fairly certain. It will be impossible to deal with any such problem in a perfect way, if it is regarded singly and, when all the factors entering into the economic situation are taken into account, the best that any Government can do is to strike a balance. These difficulties, however, are no excuse for not doing something, for not taking some positive line.

My complaint against the Government and the Parliamentary Secretary is that, first, they made extravagant and unfounded promises based on misrepresentation. The statistics now available show us that most of the allegations they then made about the cost of living were unfounded. Following that spate of injudicious promises, they got into office and allowed things to drift. They now seek to evade the problem by setting up another commission. Whereas the Fianna Fáil Government, within a matter of months, could face up to doing the unpopular thing, this Government cannot make up their mind to tackle the problem and they throw it over on an advisory body, and all the time the problem mounts. What is worse, they are not even getting the benefit of their excuses for inaction. Take the question of milk. The consumer has to pay a slightly increased price, but the producer is obviously not being satisfied. In the case of meat, there is the consumer and butcher again. While they are allowing things to drift in that way, they are further trying to bluff their way through on the lines the Parliamentary Secretary adopted in opening this debate, and, in fairness to the Parliamentary Secretary, they are only the lines indicated to him by the Taoiseach and members of the Government before him.

Comment on this

You have been bluffing since 4 o'clock.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I have given facts and I am stating facts. Ask any housewife whether these increases I have given are bluff. When I say and prove that the cost of living has gone up over the past three years, does the Deputy think I am bluffing? I ask the Deputy from Wexford, through the Chair, if he says that, when I say and prove by my figures that the cost of living has gone up over the past three years, I am bluffing? I am waiting for an answer.

Comment on this

All your talk will not stop me.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Am I bluffing? I am not. The Parliamentary Secretary has only been following the line given to him, and I have a good deal of sympathy with him in the very poor case that was handed over to him. It is again an indication of things one can see in this Coalition. We have the Taoiseach talking about the cost of living and putting up a big bluff. He was going to give the answer; he was going to deal with it; and he referred to this particular occasion. When the time for answer came round he left it to his Parliamentary Secretary to carry the baby. I can hardly blame the Parliamentary Secretary for doing the best he could under the circumstances with a very bad case. I suggest that a little over three years ago the problem of a rise in the cost-of-living figure was, unlike the present time, tackled, and the cost of living was held.

Comment on this

By the Supplementary Budget?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Yes, the Supplementary Budget which reduced the price of essential commodities. I will give the figures. It reduced tea by 2/2 per lb., sugar by 2d. per lb., bread 1½d. per 4-lb loaf, flour 1/- per stone, and fertilisers. I would ask the Deputy to remember that the cost of fertilisers was reduced. One would not mind so much if the Government were getting any benefit from allowing things to drift. The agricultural situation, in regard to supplies of fertilisers and feeding stuffs, shows as sorry a picture as any other. There has been a sorry story about emigration. Nothing has been done about it. It is drift, drift the whole time, and nothing has been done.

I might finish on this note, that we are facing a difficult period. It is going to be a difficult period whether the world situation is going to result in another war, or whether the world is able to avoid that calamity. In these circumstances, there is only one thing for a small country such as ours to do, generally speaking, and that is to set itself out to be as self-reliant as possible, and to embark on some defined policy which is coherent in all its aspects and co-ordinated. That the present Government has demonstrably and lamentably failed to do, and, because of that failure, things are being allowed to drift.

As I mentioned before, that drift is dangerous for us. The symptoms are there. My own fear is that, as things get worse in the world, our drift will bring us into an unfavourable situation, and will leave us less able, as time goes on, to face the problems that we should have faced and could have tackled, to some extent, if necessary, if we had tackled them in time. There is always the danger that you can get into a position where the situation will get so out of hand that there will be no useful remedy or choice left to us. That is what we should avoid. It is what we should do our best, objectively, at all costs to avoid. The tendency of this Coalition, which is a tendency characteristic of all Coalitions, is to evade its responsibility, to try and avoid a problem and to try and explain it rather than to tackle it. That is an extremely dangerous thing for us in present circumstances. It can be an extremely dangerous thing if our defence problem, in its broadest aspect, mounts to higher proportions. A Coalition is always in a weak position, I grant you, but it is going to be of little consolation for everybody if these problems are not tackled and the situation gets further out of control. The setting up of commissions will not answer anything.

I think I will leave it at that. Deputies, I think, will agree that I could be far more scathing in my comments if I wished on the material available to me. I should like to finish on this note that these are the facts as I have given them. I say in all sincerity and all seriousness that the setting up of a commission to advise on prices will solve nothing, that it only, in effect, puts the problem on the long finger, and that it is time now for this Government to face up to the facts as they are, to make up its mind what line it is going to take and not let things go on drifting as it has done hitherto.

Comment on this

Deputy de Valera's lengthy speech will, at any rate, have convinced those who have heard it or who will read it that a great number of people in this country would have been in a very bad way had Fianna Fáil been allowed to continue in office in February, 1948. There are two sides to most pictures. Deputy de Valera from his point of view—I am not going to say that he did it unfairly — has painted one picture only. He has endeavoured to show only one picture to the public through the columns of the Irish Press. I want, if I can, to show a little bit of the other picture. I want to remind Deputies of the situation in which many public servants in this country found themselves in the years of the Fianna Fáil Government, and right up to the time that the Fianna Fáil Government went out of office. I want to refer, if I may, to the salaries and wages paid, for instance, to civil servants, to the Gardaí, to the Army and to the teachers. I intend to refer also to the allowances paid to old age pensioners, and I want the House then to consider what would be the plight of those people if the increases which Deputy de Valera cited— from what sources I was not always certain—are all perfectly genuine and I accept it that they are.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Will the Deputy allow me to interrupt to say that, where I have not given him the source, it is the Trade Journal, and that where I have quoted from a newspaper I have given the source?

Comment on this

The Deputy is like one of those digest professors who would not read the entire of what was in the newspaper report but was concent to read merely the heading without going any further. It is there that I disagree with the Deputy.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Is the Deputy going to pretend that there has not been an increase in the cost of living?

Comment on this

I am going to give the facts as I know them. I want Deputy de Valera to bear this in mind — it is a matter that was emphasised by Deputy Larkin when he spoke here last week—that the present cost-of-living index figure system, calculated as it is, was fixed by a Fianna Fáil Government and by a Fianna Fáil Minister for Industry and Commerce. Therefore, in so far as the method of compiling that figure has been put in the dock during this debate, I ask Deputies to remember that it is not the present Parliamentary Secretary or the present Minister who should be standing in the dock alongside it, but the Deputy Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

May I interrupt the Deputy?

Comment on this

That sentence was too long and too involved to be repeated.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

We are not quarrelling with the index but we are quarrelling with the fact that you have taken items out of the index.

Comment on this

There has been no interference with it, good, bad or indifferent.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

You do not include unrationed goods.

Comment on this

Unlike Deputy Lemass, who took beer and tobacco out of it, we took nothing out of it. It is exactly the same as it was.

Comment on this

That falsehood was nailed already by the Minister for Industry and Commerce when the allegation was made earlier by Deputy Lemass. Deputy de Valera, if he intends being as fair-minded about the matter as he would have us believe, will, I think, at least accept the assurance of a Minister of this State when he dealt with that particular allegation already. However, the fact is that the bulk of the complaints from Deputies on both sides of the House has been against the method of calculating the cost-of-living figure as based on the present index. I want Deputies to bear in mind that that method was laid down by Deputy Lemass in the year 1947. If it is an unreliable index, if the method of calculation is faulty, the blame rests on the shoulders of Deputy Lemass. I agree fully with Deputy Larkin when he referred to the cool impudence of Deputy Lemass coming into the House on this debate to criticise the methods of compiling the cost-of-living index.

We should remember also, as Deputy Larkin pointed out, that, up to the present, whatever method of price control was in operation was a system of price control also laid down by Deputy Lemass when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce and I think that it will be found that whatever complaint is to be made by Deputies on this side of the House against the Government will be because they believe the Government may not have been quick enough in altering the system laid down by Deputy Lemass and his colleagues in getting away from the Fianna Fáil method of price control. However, I have wandered somewhat from the point I was making and possibly that is due to the well-timed intervention of Deputy de Valera.

The point I want to make is that there are two ways of effectively reducing the cost of living. One is by actually reducing the cost of goods which are to be purchased by various individuals. The other is by increasing the income of the consumers and increasing their capacity to purchase. No matter what Fianna Fáil Deputies may say in this House, there is no doubt that since the change of Government in February, 1948, practically every section of the community have had their income increased, have been put in a better position to buy commodities, and also have had many commodities made available to them which were not there in the days of Fianna Fáil. Therefore, it is true to say, and I do not think any Deputy will challenge it, that the purchasing capacity of nearly every section of the people has been increased and increased substantially since this Government came into office. Whether it has been increased substantially enough or not, is another matter.

There are possibly many Deputies on this side of the House who will say that a sufficient increase in purchasing capacity has not taken place. However, that may be a matter on which we can agree or disagree. There can, however, be no disagreement with the fact that nearly every section of the people, for one reason or another, since the change of Government, have been in receipt of increased pay or allowances, increased incomes of one sort or another, thus increasing their capacity to purchase. If the increases detailed at some length by Deputy de Valera had not taken place and if, side by side with that, we were to have the Fianna Fáil mentality still controlling the Government in this country and were to have the Fianna Fáil mentality towards, we will say, the old age pensioners, as displayed in the motion discussed in this House in October, 1947, I think the old age pensioners would be in a very bad way indeed to-day. They have already received under this Government substantial increases in the allowances paid to them and other benefits, such as modification of the means test, which go further to increase the allowances. Despite Fianna Fáil opposition which has already been displayed in some quarters, it is quite clear that it is the intention of this Government to see to it that they get further allowances of a substantial nature.

Comment on this

Is that a promise?

Comment on this

The same is true of the Army. The rates of pay in the Army have gone up since this Government came into office. The pay of the Guards has gone up and the pay of the national teachers and of civil servants has been increased. Practically every section of the community, certainly every section which draw their pay or allowance from the State, have had increases of a substantial nature since the people got rid of the Fianna Fáil Government. In addition to that, taxation has been reduced by something like £6,000,000 a year. I am sure it is true, as Deputy de Valera said, that more money is being paid into the Exchequer from the existing taxes. Instead of being a point on which he can condemn the Government, I think that is a further indication of the fact which I have mentioned, that there is more money available, that people have more money, and that they have more goods on which to spend that money.

Deputy de Valera referred to a number of commodities. He referred at some length to the question of meat. I should like to remind Deputies that, when the present Minister for Industry and Commerce was fighting on behalf of the consumer against increases in the price of meat, he was being stabbed in the back every second week in this House by Fianna Fáil Deputies. I challenge them to deny that. The Fianna Fáil attitude was that the price of meat should be allowed to go up and that a greater profit should be allowed to the butchers. It may be that they are quite sincere in that, that they feel that the butchers are not making sufficient profit and should be allowed to make more. Whether they are sincere or not, it certainly is not fair for a Fianna Fáil Deputy to come into the House on this debate and criticise the Government in connection with meat, having regard to what undoubtedly has been the Fianna Fáil policy and attitude in respect of that commodity at any rate.

Let us remember also the outcry raised in this House by Fianna Fáil Deputies, particularly the Deputy from County Dublin, regarding the price of tomatoes. There, too, Fianna Fáil did its level best to try to get the Minister for Agriculture to allow the price of tomatoes to be increased. With regard to butter, which was dealt with at length also by Deputy de Valera, it is appropriate to recall that during the Fianna Fáil days the ration of butter was 2 ozs. per week. At present the ration is 8 ozs., a difference of 6 ozs. in the ration which each individual is entitled to get.

Deputy de Valera also dealt with the increase in bus fares as a matter reflecting on the real cost of living. I agree with him that it does.

But I also remember the fact that this question of bus fare increases was discussed at some length here and I remember the point of view put forward by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in these discussions. I think all of us recollect the appalling picture which he painted of the concern known as Córas Iompair Éireann, and the appalling condition in which it was left when Fianna Fáil went out of office. I do not think there was one voice raised in Fianna Fáil or any other section in the Dáil when the increase in bus fares was being discussed in years past, which, in face of what the Minister for Industry and Commerce said, was able to voice opposition to the increase in bus fares. None of us liked it but we all recognised at the time, and I still recognise, that it was necessary to increase the bus fares. It is all very well for Deputy de Valera or any other Deputy in the Opposition Benches to turn turtle at this stage for the sake of winning a political trick in debate here on a discussion on a Bill dealing primarily with the cost of living.

Remember that there are a great number of other discussions in the course of the year and in nearly all of those discussions we find Fianna Fáil Deputy after Fianna Fáil Deputy, standing up here and subsequently going out to the crossroads advocating increased expenditure by the Government. We find Deputy McCann saying that the Government are not building half enough schools and that millions more should be rolled out to pay for the new schools which he desires. We have Deputy de Valera and Deputy Traynor advocating a bigger Army to cost more; and, in addition to that bigger Army, it is to be better paid than it is to-day, and more and heavier equipment and armaments are to be rolled into this little country. We find nearly every Fianna Fáil Deputy with some pet subject on which he wishes to see more money spent.

Deputy Lemass, when he was talking at Synge Street last August or September, even held out that the Fianna Fáil social security scheme would have been bigger, better and more costly than that envisaged by the present Government in the White Paper. We hear, too, that Fianna Fáil Deputies—I think Deputy Briscoe is one of them—who, since the change of Government, have adopted the viewpoint that a great deal of the rates levied by local authorities are levied in respect of matters which could more properly be borne by the Central Government. I wonder do the Deputies opposite appreciate that, when they talk of spending millions and millions more money, all of which is to come out of taxation, because they have gone on record in a very definite way as being opposed to governing, as they say, on borrowed money, putting this country into pawn and so on, and have made it quite clear that all these millions of pounds which are to be spent on Fianna Fáil schemes are to come out of direct taxation—I do not think any of them will be able to contradict that —I wonder do they appreciate that if the Fianna Fáil policy were adopted a very great increase must take place in the cost of living and taxation must soar to something in the neighbourhood of £10,000,000 or probably very much more than that. Taxation must increase and, in addition to that, let us assume these sections of the community that I have mentioned are relegated back to the Fianna Fáil way of things, that the Army go back to the Fianna Fáil rates of pay, that the Garda go back to the Fianna Fáil rates of pay, that the old age pensioner goes back to the Fianna Fáil rate of allowance and the civil servants and the teachers go back to the Fianna Fáil rate of pay, visualise then the situation under a Fianna Fáil policy.

I am assuming, I may be too charitable, but I am assuming that they are quite sincere and honest about all this and that they want to increase taxation on the one hand and to get back to the Fianna Fáil rock in relation to pay on the other hand. Then we would, indeed, be in a mess, and the cost of living would be such that no one would be able to bear up under it. I think it is quite unfair to make the criticism of the Parliamentary Secretary which was made by Deputy de Valera and by Deputy Lemass that he is claiming that the cost of living has not gone up. He has not done that. He has claimed that up to August of this year there was no substantial alteration in the cost-of-living index figure and I do not think that any Deputy opposite will challenge that. I certainly will not try to make out the case that the cost of living has not increased. It has increased. In so far as the cost of commodities, at any rate, is concerned, prices have risen in respect of a number of commodities. But I do make the claim, and I make it in all sincerity, that by virtue of the policy and the action of this Government people are in a far better position to-day to withstand price increases than ever they were under Fianna Fáil and that, despite increases in prices, I have no doubt that many sections of the people, if not most of them, are better off than they were under the Fianna Fáil Government, even in the days immediately before or six to eight months before the General Election of 1948, and certainly substantially better off than they were during the days of the Wages Standstill Order.

With regard to Section 3 of the Bill, I cannot see why Deputies opposite are so vigorous in their opposition to the setting up of an advisory body, or committee, to inquire publicly into price increases. I know that so far back as January, 1947, when this question of rising prices was discussed, I think it was on a motion of the Labour Party, that Deputy Lemass, who was then Minister for Industry and Commerce, even then opposed any alteration in the Fianna Fáil system of price control. He now says that the idea of this advisory committee to inquire in public into increased prices is a hastily devised one, that it is some kind of innovation which the Government have thought up in order to satisfy or buy-off Labour Party criticism. I just want to place on record the fact that in the discussion on the control of price motion which took place in this House on the 23rd January, 1947, the Leader of the Fine Gael Party, General Mulcahy, discussing the question of prices, advocated that the Government should do precisely what the Government are proposing to do now.

My only regret is that this step was not taken six or eight months ago. I have no criticism whatever to offer in respect of the period before that, but I think that public confidence and the public mind in relation to prices generally would have been eased if some months back the Government had adopted the idea of allowing these matters to be inquired into in public. As I say, that was advocated by Deputy General Mulcahy as far back as the 23rd January, 1947. I agree with the Parliamentary Secretary that it is important that the personnel of the committte when it is established should be such as will inspire public confidence. I think also that the mere fact of allowing this examination to take place in public will have very beneficial results. I agree with remarks made the other night by Deputy Larkin regarding the system of price control as it was operated by Fianna Fáil and as it was continued in operation up to the present. Even when people were not being adversely affected by increased prices, they knew nothing whatever about the method of examination which ultimately enabled this commodity or that commodity to go up in price. Deputy MacEntee when he was writing in the Sunday Press about a year ago explained that a number of commodities go up in price because of circumstances over which no one in this country has any control.

The ordinary person paying an increased price does not appreciate that or, at any rate, he never bothers thinking about it and the whole Fianna Fáil plan of campaign in relation to this Bill is to try to conceal from the people that there are commodities which have increased in price, and which may increase in price in future, over which the Government, whether it be an inter-Party Government or a Fianna Fáil Government, have no control whatever. At least, I believe it will have certain beneficial results if the people who are affected directly by these increased prices understand why an increase has to be made or permitted. If, on the other hand, there is anything in the nature of excessive profiteering, there is no place like the open to show that up and the mere threat of holding these inquiries in public will, I think, act as a very great deterrent to those who would seek to make excessive profits in business or industry.

I want, and I am doing this quite sincerely, to congratulate the Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister for the excellent manner in which they have tackled this general question of the cost of living over a period of nearly three years, at a time when the only policy which Fianna Fáil could offer to the people was to increase the taxes on beer, tobacco and entertainments.

Despite the fact that this Government, before they were a month in office, remitted these taxes, they did hold, until August of this year—and there is no doubt about it, at any rate working on the cost-of-living basis— the cost-of-living figure steady from the time they took over. They did that without having recourse to the Fianna Fáil Supplementary Budget tactics of imposing increased taxes on beer, tobacco and entertainments. They did that despite the fact that they were able to reduce income-tax and give the various wage increases to which I have referred. I think that that was no mean achievement. I think the Minister, the Parliamentary Secretary and the Government generally are entitled to be congratulated on the work which they did in that respect.

It is perfeetly fair political tactics for Fianna Fáil Deputies to criticise the Government because of any increases that have taken place, but if Fianna Fáil Deputies would care to read everything Deputy Lemass had to say on the subject in January, 1947, both in the Seanad and in the Dáil, they will find an answer to a great deal of the criticism which they made here last week and which they are making here to-day. I do not propose referring to any long quotations on the subject, but Deputy Lemass commenced his speech in the Dáil on the 23rd January, 1947, by pointing out that the problem of price control was not a simple problem or was not a problem that could be solved overnight. I would recommend to Deputy Lemass and other Deputies that they might accept that as true to-day, just as it was true in 1947, and to approach this discussion with the object of endeavouring to assist the Government to contain the rising prices, rather than merely use the debate for the purpose of scoring political hits at their opponents. If political hits are to be scored, they can be scored just as easily one way as the other, but I think many Deputies on this side, and the Parliamentary Secretary when he is concluding, will be in a position to give just as much as has been taken from the opposite benches.

As I say I am not going to try to make the case that there have not been price increases. There have been price increases but the people of the country generally have been put in a much better position to withstand these price increases than they were in the Fianna Fáil days. Finally, I should like to say also that the Government and the Minister are to be congratulated on the fact that despite the increases in price which have taken place, there is no doubt whatever that, in relation to many other countries in Europe, this country has been placed in the last few years in a much more favourable position. Production, industrial and agricultural, has increased enormously. The national income has increased. Workers' earnings have increased. The cost of living here is considerably lower than it is in most other European countries and I think a very great deal lower than it is even in Great Britain. I have not got the actual figures before me at the moment.

That situation has been arrived at because you had a Government in office which, instead of displaying the weaknesses of coalitions, about which Deputy de Valera appeared to know so much, was broadly representative and represented all sections of the people. If the Fianna Fáil Government had continued in office I think the situation for most people here would be deplorable to-day. The fact that this Government has done so well, without increasing taxation, is really what is annoying Fianna Fáil speakers.

Fianna Fáil Deputies, as I have pointed out, have sought very much more Government spending. They want more money spent on this, that and the other and they want it all to come out of taxes. This Government have adopted a different attitude. In my opinion, at any rate, they have been very sane and reasonable in their approach to the question of production and the question of Government spending generally.

I would conclude by saying that, whatever may be the Fianna Fáil attitude during the course of this debate to the proposal to establish a committee to inquire in public into the question of price increases, I would at least make this appeal to them, assuming this Bill goes through and that such a committee is established, that they should direct their efforts and energy towards inspiring public confidence in the committee rather than do the work of the saboteur when the committee is established.

Comment on this

I am rather disappointed that Deputy O'Higgins did not give us more to bite on than he has given us. I thought, during the two hours when Deputy de Valera was talking this evening and Deputy O'Higgins was rearing to go, that he had something of substance, something instructive to tell us, rather than this sort of appeal: "Do not be too unfair; do not try to score political hits; give this tribunal a chance and give it your help".

Deputy O'Higgins was not in the House in 1947. If Deputy O'Higgins had been here in 1947 and had heard the political hits that were scored on this very subject, he would have been rather surprised. I would recommend him to read the debates of those days so as to discover how temperate we are here in our efforts to bring to the notice of the Government, to this House and to the country the danger of the present situation, the disappointment that there must be in the realisation that what has been promised has not been accomplished and that, in fact, things have become considerably worse than they were when Fianna Fáil left office and are going to be much worse.

There are three items of importance to the vast majority of our people— food, clothing and shelter. We on these benches subscribed to that particular principle on the formation of the Fianna Fáil Party. We agreed and we laid it down as part of our policy that there were three items to which the Government must give the utmost and the first consideration because of their effect on the vast majority of our people: food, clothing and shelter.

Let us take food first. One would imagine that food subsidies existed when Fianna Fáil took office. Do the members of the Coalition groups not realise that the subsidisation of the essential foodstuffs for the vast majority of our people was a principle introduced by the Fianna Fáil Government?

Comment on this

Because it was necessary.

Comment on this

I will make my speech. When I have finished, get up and make yours. I am trying to instruct some of the people in this House who do not seem to have any memory and do not seem to have any regard for what is correct and what is the truth.

Comment on this

We remember a lot of things.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to ask me a question, I will answer it. If he just wants to growl, grumble and bark over there, I will have to ignore him. The last thing I want is to be discourteous, even to an O'Higgins. It was Fianna Fáil that introduced the principle of subsidising essential foodstuffs so that the vast majority of our people would not be affected as harshly as they might otherwise be by the emergency and the war situation.

When the change of Government came, taxation was not to go up; taxation was to come down. However, the price of food for the vast majority of the people was affected by the system of limiting the ration allowance, not with regard to the availability of any particular foodstuff, but with regard to the extent to which the Exchequer would suffer by a particular subsidy. That, in our opinion, we say quite frankly, was a bad change. In our opinion, with the increased availability of foodstuffs which had been scarce in the war years, our people should have a full ration before the subsidy would be removed and, certainly, they should have a full ration before a subsidised rationed commodity would be exported in order further to help the Exchequer, not to relieve the food situation of the people at home.

I wonder will that sink into anybody as a serious principle, as a serious acceptance by this Party of the first of its commitments to the country and its people, as an acceptance by a Government of its responsibility to protect the people in relation to their food.

Now we come to clothing. I remember, in 1947, when those who are now over there of the Party that at that time was over here talked about the drapers and clothing-selling houses as racketeers and profiteers, and who said that the Minister for Industry and Commerce at that time had given them too great a margin of profit, and so forth, and who promised that they would reduce the price of clothing. Clothing is also a very important item to the ordinary individual. Is there any comparison between the price of clothing to-day and the price of clothing in 1947? Is it not obvious to everybody that, whether it is because of mismanagement by the Government or because it is out of their control, clothing is at least twice as dear to-day as it was in 1947?

I venture to say this, that had Fianna Fáil been in Government when this situation arose of a violent upheaval with regard to the increase in the price of clothing, steps would have been taken, possibly, to provide a utility garment for the people, as was done in other countries when the price of clothing went out of all proportion and out of all sanity.

Now we come to shelter. Shelter is also an important item. These miserable little appeals about what they are doing now for the old age pensioners, and so forth, are all very well, but it was Fianna Fáil that launched large-scale building of houses so that the people would have adequate shelter. Rapid progress was made in that regard up to the outbreak of the war in 1939 or 1940.

We have not yet reached the figures in relation to annual production in Dublin City that were reached in 1938 or 1939, not because the Government do not want to do it, but because it took some time to get back into the country the skilled operatives and the materials that were so necessary. It was only quite recently that these were becoming readily available. I am not going to abuse the Government if, because this mythical war which was referred to in the Taoiseach's Estimate is now recognised as a real war, the effects of it will further restrict the supplies of material; I am not going to blame them if that happens. I hope it will not happen and that they will be able to continue with the job.

I think Deputy O'Higgins does not seem to realise what Deputy Hickey will, I am sure, admit, that the rent of a house in the case of a working man is an essential item in the cost of living. Further, the fuel that is consumed in order to keep a house warm and to cook a man's meals is a very essential item in the cost of living. What is happening? We are building houses in Dublin and they are costing vastly more than in pre-war days. They are costing vastly more for a number of reasons. Working hours are gone down and the output is somewhat less —I am talking of the individual output. Materials are dearer and the cost of money is getting dearer.

Comment on this

We know that that is so.

Comment on this

The cost of money is higher to-day than it was some years ago.

Comment on this

The output per man is slightly better.

Comment on this

Excuse me. I know what I am talking about.

Comment on this

I am telling you it is.

Comment on this

If you reduce the working hours and increase the working man's wages—I am not against that, I am just giving a simple mathematical calculation—what do you find? If people previously worked 50 hours in the week and they now work 44 hours, and if previously they got £4 per week and they are now getting £6 per week, is it not obvious that they are producing less and costing more—not that I am against that, and I do not want that to be twisted?

Comment on this

The output per man is greater.

Comment on this

The output per hour is lower and you have to use more people to-day for certain types of work—the unions see to that. I am not against giving extra money to the working man and I am not against a reduction of hours, but I want appreciation of the fact that if you want better conditions and higher wages, it costs more. I will give this simple illustration. There is one industry in which the raw material is a negligible item in the conduct of the business. It is a trade or business where the workers were very lowly paid and the conditions were very severe until steps were taken to give them better conditions and better wages. I refer to laundry work. Does not everybody know that in order to improve the conditions of the workers in the laundry business we are now paying 5d. in the 1/- by way of excess for whatever wash we send them? What previously cost 1/- now costs 1/5 in order to meet the extra cost.

I will repeat, for fear it will be misstated—as it probably will be—that we on these benches do not object to better terms for the workers, and when the history comes to be written of the 16 years when we were in office, including the war years, and a comparison is made with the years the Coalition Government were in office, the working men in the future Ireland will realise that the best Government they ever had was the Government that recognised all Irish people, including the working men, as Irish citizens, and they will recognise that the best was done for them by that Government.

Comment on this

What about the Wages Standstill Order?

Comment on this

I will come to that. Deputy Davin, who is now the Chairman of the Labour Party in the Dáil, has a very big responsibility. He will be asked very shortly to answer that responsibility. I am coming to the Wages Standstill Order.

Comment on this

I thought you were forgetting it.

Comment on this

I started off by indicating—I do not think Deputy Davin was here at the time—that food was an essential item and in order that it should be available to the people at the lowest possible cost Fianna Fáil adopted and introduced the principle of subsidies. Side by side with that, when the emergency caught up on us and when this country could not control supplies from outside, whether in respect of quantity or price, the Fianna Fáil Government adopted a certain policy. In order that a situation would not develop here, a situation which is now developing because the Coalition Government have not the courage or cannot get agreement, we were prepared to make an arrangement, for the purpose of keeping further rises from developing here from inside causes, to have a Wages Standstill Order agreed upon, but there was a guarantee from the Government that the needs of the people, in the shape of food, clothing and shelter, would be secured and not measured in the sense that some Deputies here tried to measure it, as if we were living in normal times.

I am not ashamed of the policy that Fianna Fáil introduced and operated and that it will, please goodness, be in a position soon again to put into operation. The vast bulk of the supporters of Fianna Fáil happen to be the ordinary working people.

Comment on this

Trade unionists.

Comment on this

Yes, including very many trade unionists. We would not have that support, particularly in industrial areas such as Dublin, if we did not enjoy their confidence and if we had not proved to them that we were not prepared to abuse the trust placed in us to look after the welfare of the ordinary individual.

Deputy O'Higgins gibed across the House and he referred to me in connection with this matter and said I was one of those who stated that a certain amount of charges to be met out of the ratepayers' funds by the Corporation of Dublin and by other local authorities should properly be met out of the Central Fund; he suggested that I was therefore trying to pile up big expenditure on the Central Fund. Deputy O'Higgins is a prominent member of the Dublin Corporation and if he has not yet awakened to the fact —as I suppose happened in Cork—that the Government have been transferring to us, to pay out of rates, charges previously met out of the Central Fund under the Fianna Fáil Government, I do not know what he has been doing. That is what I am trying to get away from and I say that the Central Fund should continue honouring its obligations by meeting the charges that were previously met by them, instead of trying to put them on to the backs of the ratepayers. I wonder if there is any dispute about that statement, which is a fact? Deputy Byrne had a question down for answer on the Order Paper to-day. I want to refer to it to show how people are playing politics and how unprepared they are to face up to their responsibilities as public men. In that question—No. 42—he asked the Minister for Justice to include the local authorities under the rent restrictions control to make it possible for every tenant of the Dublin Corporation to bring the corporation, as his landlord, to court.

We have somewhere around 30,000 tenants at the moment and we shall have another 30,000 if we can continue our house-building programme for a number of years. The Dublin Corporation is not a landlord in the building or providing of houses for a profit. Dublin Corporation belongs to the citizens. It is a liability of the ratepayers. The building of houses is supported also out of rates. But Deputy Byrne wants to have the reputation of being a gentleman who wants to see every individual with his full sovereign rights. I think he would be frightened himself if it were put into effect because we would have nothing but chaos.

I want to refer to the Official Reports. I do not know to what depths this House will sink with regard to facing facts and giving honest answers. Last Thursday Deputy Cogan asked the Taoiseach a question in connection with interest charges and so forth, and in a supplementary question he asked if the State is not the ultimate source of paper money. The reference is column 1217 of the Official Report, 23rd November, 1950. I hope the Taoiseach got the message which I sent to him verbally through one of his officials to the effect that I was amazed at the answer which he gave to that question because it was not correct. I do not say it was done deliberately but if it is allowed to go unchallenged there will be no value in asking a question any more in the House. The Taoiseach said: "I might point out that State aid for local authority housing is, in effect, equivalent to the provision of interest-free loans...." That is a quibble. It is true that the State subsidises the interest charges and also gives a grant for the building of houses. However, as Deputy Hickey and Deputy McGrath and other Deputies are, I am sure, aware, there are two types of grants towards interest charges by the State. In a certain type of priority emergency matter the State gives 66? per cent. of the charge of the interest but for the bulk of the operations of the local authority in the building of houses the State gives back 33? per cent. of the interest charges to the local authority. Therefore it is unfair to let the people think that the local authority is not contributing to the cost of the interest charges. Is this another scheme as to how rates can come down?

Does this House know that every penny on the rates of the City of Dublin equals approximately £8,000 to £9,000 in income and that we are at this present moment subsidising out of the rates our housing at a cost of 3/2 in the £? Multiply 3/2 by £8,000 for every ld. and you will find that the rates of the City of Dublin at the present moment are contributing over £300,000 a year in respect of housing. Nevertheless, with that subsidy—with the grant of the corporation to the cost of building houses —with the £400 per house we get from the State towards the capital charges, and including the grant from the Government which we are not quibbling about but which we say should be properly explained instead of pretending that it is a full charge on the back of the State—with all that—we are now reaching the stage in Dublin City where the cost of a house to the ordinary working man is higher than £1, and in some cases higher than 30/-, per week, and, at the same time, he is liable to a variation in the rates because he is a ratepayer as well. What does all that mean? Does all that not mean that there is an item of cost of living which is not fully recognised in the cost of living examination?

Comment on this

And which has not been for years, of course.

Comment on this

I agree. I want to say, however, that it may not have been as necessary ten years ago as now because the cost was half the price then. It is much more urgently needed to be recognised now than it ever was. In addition to that, compare the price of fuel. It is dearer to-day than formerly but it is also an essential item in the cost of living. I have never considered it worth while advocating a situation with regard to a particular cost-of-living index as compiled on certain items, because, as we know, we are all human beings and no two families— whether they are living in the same street or not—are living exactly alike. No two families have exactly the same commitments. Every family lives its own individual life in its own particular way. You cannot just draw a line and say that everybody spends 2d. on his breakfast, 3d. on his lunch, and so forth.

There are many considerations to be taken into account. Illness comes in one house—quite different from the house next door. The bringing up of children is another matter which varies considerably. You will find one boy who will wear a suit for a year and you will find another boy, perhaps in the next house, who will wear out the same type of suit in a week. I do not attach importance to what is called a cost-of-living index figure. What I do think is important is that there is a certain minimum income to which a person is entitled if he is to have somewhat of a standard of living. I consider that all this talk about who is to be blamed for the cost of living figure we now have—about certain items which were in the previous figure and are not in the present one, and about certain items which are in the present figure and which were not in the previous figure—is no help at all in the matter. It is all nonsense trying to work it out on that basis. I said before, and I repeat now that what is most important is what the individual gets when it is translated into food, clothing and shelter. I am not prepared to argue prices or costs of each individual item, as it is to-day or as it was yesterday, or as it may be to-morrow, because these prices are constantly changing, and they will be changing like eruptions from time to time.

I read with great interest the contribution to this debate by Deputy Larkin. I did not read it once, I read it three times. I tried to put myself, as far as I could, into the mind of Deputy Larkin, to see his approach to the subject to-day, to see if I could recognise any practical remedy, and I found this. My conclusion, from Deputy Larkin's speech in this debate, is this, that he was defending his present position in the support of this Coalition Government, defending it purely to vindicate himself for still giving support to the continuance of this inter-Party Government.

I went through every paragraph of it and he was so anxious to defend his own position that he made mistakes, and very grievous ones, ones that I was rather surprised to see coming from a Deputy of this House. Whether I can agree or disagree with the things he stands for or the pronouncements he makes, I will pay him this credit, that he usually studies carefully what he brings to the House and it is something that you can read, even though you cannot accept it or even if you do not understand his approach to it. Deputy Larkin was the Deputy who first of all found fault with Deputy Lemass because Deputy Lemass had not brought in the Prices and Efficiency Bill. Deputy Larkin apparently forgot that an election had intervened and that the non-introduction in this House of the Prices and Efficiency Bill of which he was in favour——

Comment on this

The Bill was introduced and printed.

Comment on this

It was. It was printed and it passed the Second Reading, but it never became an Act.

Comment on this

Because you put it in cold storage.

Comment on this

We did not put it in cold storage; it was you who put it in cold storage. There is nothing to stop you introducing it now. Labour supports it. Deputy Davin is chairman of the Labour Party now. Let him assert his authority, and have it introduced, or withdraw his support from the Government.

Comment on this

He said it would not counterbalance the increase in the cost of living a couple of months ago.

Comment on this