We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1950—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 162–332 of 332. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1950
Enacted

No. 34 of 1950 ›

We cannot understand you.

Comment on this

No, we cannot understand you; that is right. Deputy Larkin wants a tribunal set up to have public hearings into the prices of every item. Why does he want it?

Comment on this

Because there is no confidence in the present system.

Comment on this

To kill time.

Comment on this

He knows very well— and I will prove it—that it cannot be done. His speech was inconsistent. At some stages he says: "You cannot do this" and later on he advocates: "Why not do this?" I suggest that Deputy Hickey has not read Deputy Larkin's speech.

Comment on this

He was here the whole time.

Comment on this

But listening to his speech and reading and studying it are two quite different things. He wants a public hearing because he wants, as he says, public confidence. What is this tribunal? How is it going to have a public hearing? He admits that it is not the manufacturer who is to be brought before the tribunal primarily. It is the middle-man he refers to.

Comment on this

Have you a quotation for that?

Comment on this

That is a misrepresentation.

Comment on this

He did say it was distribution, anyway.

Comment on this

You were not here.

Comment on this

I read it through.

Comment on this

I will quote some gems from that speech, from column 1354 of the Official Debates:—

"The Parliamentary Secretary has pointed out to us that there are two main lines of approach to price control. I think it would be much simpler to put it this way. A manufacturer makes a particular product and charges, say, 4/-. Then we have to take the wholesaler and on that product we have to guarantee him his couple of shillings."

Of course, that is wrong, as there is a prices section which controls the margin of profits to the wholesaler, and it certainly is not 50 per cent.; so Deputy Larkin is wrong when he said "a couple of shillings." He went on:—

"and then the next wholesaler or the sub-agent takes it over and we have to guarantee him something. Finally, the retailer gets it, and he has to get his guarantee. All this is piled upon an article which originally cost 4/-, and by the time the unfortunate consumer gets it, as Deputy Jack Lynch has pointed out, it probably costs 8/-, 10/- or 12/-."

He does not know. We have manufacturers; and we have distributors, called middlemen; and before the customer gets the goods the manufacturer has a very restricted profit and if this public tribunal ever is established, I venture to say to Deputy O'Leary he would be the first to say: "Give the poor devil another few pounds, as you are not giving him enough."

Comment on this

You remember the blanket case.

Comment on this

I took the trouble to find out the price of blankets.

Comment on this

What about Guiney?

Comment on this

I am not referring to individual firms here, but talking generally. Deputy Larkin continued:

"Nothing is added to the value of the article, no additional service is rendered except the simple one of distribution, but somewhere along the line a whole group of middlemen have managed to get in."

There are manufacturers in this country who supply their goods to a wholesaler, as they have not themselves the means of distribution nor have they in their costings a charge for distribution. There are wholesale houses, large houses, who buy goods from factories in bulk and they have an organisation of workers who handle these goods and pack them. They have travellers out, who call on houses and sell these goods——

Comment on this

All for nothing.

Comment on this

No. Just as the porter who packs the case is entitled to his wages in that middleman's house, so also is the traveller who works in that firm entitled to his wages.

Comment on this

His whack.

Comment on this

I notice that a lot of people who talk about business and whacks in business are not in business themselves and do not understand business.

Comment on this

It is very easy to understand what a whack is. We have only to see those who are travelling around the country every day.

Comment on this

The Deputy has only to tell the commercial traveller, who has a car at his disposal to travel around the country in all weathers, to try to make a few shillings on commission, that he is an unnecessary evil, that he is only getting a whack out of something.

Comment on this

The majority of them are trade unionists, too.

Comment on this

There will be a meeting of the commercial travellers probably, who will tell those opposite they were speaking out of turn when they were speaking here. This is a system which exists in this country and which is necessary. Small shopkeepers in the country rely on certain wholesale houses to select for them what in their opinion happens to be a good line or an article worth the money; and they could not, not having the time or anything else, come up to the big city, visit factories and bring home under their arm whatever they are buying. These institutions amongst us here are big ones—some of them are very big. Then there are the retail shops. Is it intended that the retail shops should be abolished because the owners or workers in them are getting a whack out of selling across the counter something that costs them a little bit less than they are selling it for? I do not understand the mentality that tries to argue a point not realising what is happening. Take Deputy Larkin. His union, I understand, caters for the drapers. Deputy Larkin's union sees that the workers get reasonably good conditions. Recently I know that there were negotiations over a protracted period with drapery firms and certain things happened. It would be very wrong of me to describe a welfare worker who up until recently was a paid union delegate as a middle man. However, this concern pays him and he sees that the workers have good conditions, that their canteens are run properly and so on. Recently I understand that the latest demand of Deputy Larkin's union was that the man previously known as delegate and now welfare worker will participate physically at the annual board meeting of the company in which these workers are working so that the workers will get their fair share and whack of the profits made by the concern in the year. It is extraordinary——

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

But it is a fact.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think that Deputy Larkin made even as mild a form of attack on the retail shops and travellers as he tried to suggest? You know that that is untrue.

Comment on this

I did not say that he made an attack on them.

Comment on this

You may have been led away by interruptions. I am not blaming Deputy Briscoe, but he was trying to show the inconsistencies in Deputy Larkin's speech and said that he made an attack on the shopkeepers.

Comment on this

I said that Deputy McQuillan made an attack on the shopkeepers.

Comment on this

Deputy McQuillan did not make an attack on the shopkeepers. I said that they were getting their whack out of it.

Comment on this

Deputy Corish says that I am unfair to Deputy Larkin. Deputy Larkin refers in the debate to middle men as rats running in and out of their holes. That is not an attack of course. That is patting them on the back. I would be far removed from calling a person a rat running in and out of its hole if I did not mean to cause some afront to him.

Comment on this

Read the whole of the extract.

Comment on this

I will read the whole extract about the figures.

Comment on this

Read about the rats.

Comment on this

I am coming to that too. He says:—

"I understand that the cost of distribution in this country in recent years has represented something like 17 to 20 per cent. as an addition to the cost of manufacture."

That is a long way off his previous figures of a couple of shillings for one wholesaler and another bit for another and the middle men in and out too. I agree with the final figure that the cost of distribution would be something like 17 to 20 per cent.—clamped down by the prices section of the Industry and Commerce Department. Do you want to abolish the cost of distribution? If you abolish the present system we should never have Deputy Davin here who was on the railway which was a part of the cost of distribution.

Comment on this

Is your point that we should leave things as they are?

Comment on this

Oh no. A lot of changes are needed on both sides.

Comment on this

You think so?

Comment on this

There is criticism in that suggestion.

Comment on this

The criticism has been there for a number of years and we know what the criticism was. I want to understand the mentality of people who, under present circumstances, regard the situation as not being serious for the ordinary individual. Deputy Davin is quite happy—or was up to recently—that the increased cost of living charges were adequately met by increased wages.

Comment on this

"More than counter-balanced," he said.

Comment on this

Quote my words. I am being misrepresented all the time.

Comment on this

I am not misrepresenting you at any time. Deputy Davin gave us to understand in the House that the increases in wages which had been accorded to the workers met the increased cost of living at least up to August last. New increases have caused a new situation.

Comment on this

I did not speak in August and neither did you.

Comment on this

You spoke in this House about six months ago and you said that the increases were more than counterbalanced.

Comment on this
Patrick Joseph Halliden Acting-Chairman (Mr. Halliden) Clann na Talmhan

Deputies must address the Chair. We must not have this controversy across the House.

Comment on this

Deputy Larkin went on:—

"Therefore, roughly, out of every 25/- we are spending on products, we are paying something in the way of 5/- to a group of gentlemen to hand those articles to us from the manufacturers."

Is there anything more unreasonable than that? As I have said before, a factory produces goods. The wholesaler comes and buys those goods at the factory. He has his own premises and his own staff. He has to pay railway charges and distribution, and it appears to Deputy Larkin that that is what is wrong. What is behind that? What does he want? Does he want the factory to be available to the public off the streets for each one to come and pick his or her pair of shoes?

Comment on this

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

He knows it is nonsense.

Comment on this

How are we going to abolish the middleman?

Comment on this

Abolish his profits.

Comment on this

Abolish the fees of legal gentlemen. They are also middlemen.

Comment on this

He would talk about legal gentlemen. He would talk about anything now.

Comment on this

I am telling the truth. I am not filibustering. I will filibuster to interruptions, if you like. I want to understand what Deputy Larkin's speech in this House meant. I have said before and I will say again that it meant a defence of himself and of the Labour group for their continued support of an intolerable inter-Party Government and of the repercussions it is having on the public at large. There is no other interpretation. I am not going to paraphrase or analyse his whole speech, but I would recommend you all to read it. Deputy Larkin says that the moment the price of wool rises in Australia, quicker even than wireless, the price has gone up here. I happen to know——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——that irrespective of how prices rise or fall outside there is a very strict and rigid control on manufacturers by the prices section. First of all, if the manufacturer has a store of raw material he cannot in his charges to customers apply a new price to the wool stock.

Comment on this

It is done though.

Comment on this

I am telling Deputy McQuillan that it is not done.

Comment on this

It is done every day of the week.

Comment on this

If Deputy McQuillan can bring a single instance of it I challenge him to bring that single instance to the Department and they will deal with it.

Comment on this

Go down to any shop.

Comment on this

If there is one instance——

Comment on this

I will give it to you.

Comment on this

I do not want it but the Department wants it. I know what I am talking about.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Order!

Comment on this

You say that the Government is doing everything all right?

Comment on this

I am dealing with a particular reference made by Deputy Larkin and the position is that no matter what raw material comes into a factory, it is rigidly controlled by the prices section and they see under certified auditors' reports how the material was dealt with, and if the next batch which comes in is at an increased price evidence has to be submitted and the prices section grants an increased price for the next delivery.

Comment on this

Is that what Deputy Lynch said?

Comment on this

He is talking about a different thing. The next step is that the wholesaler gets these goods and the wholesaler is supposed to keep within his margin. The retailer then gets them and he is supposed to sell them at a price which allows him his margin.

Comment on this

"Supposed" is the key word.

Comment on this

There always will be people who will black market, who will take advantage of the situation confronting their neighbours to benefit themselves at the expense of the hardship of their neighbours. If Deputy McQuillan or Deputy Davin knows of a case where a retailer sold blankets at the new price, as if the raw wool had cost 18/- per lb., it is his duty to write to the Parliamentary Secretary. Let them do it and let them not talk about something, unless they can produce proof. If there is any doubt in the Deputy's mind, there is a way for him to write in. I am associated with a business concern and I happen to know that there are people always ready to write in about our concern to see if they can find anything wrong. It is done all the time and the Deputy can do it.

Comment on this

So everything in the garden is rosy?

Comment on this

Everything in the garden was horrible when we were over there and you people were going to make it rosy. The people who make up the inter-Party Government were going to make everything rosy having got us out, to the extent of a reduction in the cost of living of 30 per cent., with a public hanging almost of all the racketeers and profiteers whom we had let run loose round the country during our period of office.

Comment on this

There are a lot of them loose yet.

Comment on this

You have had three years in which to carry out the public hangings. Why not do it?

Comment on this

We cannot do it with your machinery.

Comment on this

This House, with your majority, cannot bring in legislation to change the machinery?

Comment on this

You would oppose it.

Comment on this

Are we to take it that the attitude of the Deputies who compose the Government Parties is that whatever they cannot or will not do cannot be done because we are likely to oppose it? Surely they have a majority, and, if they are unanimous, why can they not go ahead and do it? If we think it wrong, we will express opposition to it and vote against it, but we cannot stop the majority doing it, if they want to do it. Let them not try to make themselves still more ridiculous in the public eye by saying that they cannot do something because Fianna Fáil would oppose it. The people of this country are not idiots. The vast majority have a very sound understanding of what is happening and they realise that they are in a far bigger mess with regard to the cost of living now than they were in 1948. They are beginning to express their opinion on it. Shortly after he took office, the Taoiseach talked about the country groaning as a result of the high cost of living. The people have ceased to groan now—they just creak, because they cannot groan.

I do not want to go into the whole subject, but I want to say that I cannot understand Deputy O'Higgins. He says that there is more money for more goods and there are more people in employment. It was I who in this House—my lonely self—pointed out that we would have devaluation and nobody believed it. When devaluation takes place, commodities rise in price, and, when they rise in price, there is a tendency to inflation and consequently a larger circulation of money, but it does not mean that you are more prosperous.

Why do some of the Deputies opposite not take elementary lectures in economics and learn that, if an article which previously cost 1/4d. now costs ld., and if that article is consumed to the same extent as before it does not necessarily mean that you have four times the amount of these goods going around, but that you have the same quantity at four times the cost and that, therefore, you have more money in circulation but nothing to shout about? If the reverse were the case, it might be something to be proud of. That is what amuses me—all these figures they are producing to show that we are better off, while the simplest form of economics is as far away from some people as it possibly can be.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy not agree, as a man in business, that 15 per cent. on £100,000 is better than 15 per cent. on £10,000, without any additional cost?

Comment on this

In ordinary mathematics, if a man has 15 per cent. on £100,000, he will have more than he would have if he had 15 per cent. on £50,000. There are, however, two answers to that. The first is the value of the money. Has the money the same value and will it get him the same amount of commodities as before? Why do the Labour people want more money for their workers? Would it be fair for me to say to Deputy Davin that workers who had £7 a week five years ago are better off to-day because they have £8 a week? Would he not say that that was nonsense, that they are worse off because they can get less goods? There is also this real answer to it, that the prices section effect control on a man's profits not on that basis at all and that is why you have a falling-off in the development of industry here and why people are not attracted into starting industries. The prices section take the line in most cases I know of that the amount of profit is restricted to a percentage of the invested capital and bears no relation whatever to the turnover. If your turnover is three times what it was pre-war, because your cost of materials and labour costs are up three times, your profit is not up three times, and that is one of the grievances which industrialists have and that is what has stopped expansion and prevented new people coming in to start business.

Comment on this

That is a very innocent answer.

Comment on this

It is a truthful answer. I ask the Parliamentary Secretary to say if it is not correct.

Comment on this

There never was such expansion in industry as in the past three years.

Comment on this

I ask whether my approach to what the prices section does is correct.

Comment on this

It does not stop the development of industry, anyhow.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary admits, by implication, that what I have said about profits control is correct. He disagrees as to the expansion that has taken place. I heard Deputy McQuillan asking the Parliamentary Secretary recently whether certain factories had started in Mayo and how many people they employed, and, listening to the Deputy, I feel that he is highly dissatisfied with the progress made in Mayo in the establishment of industry. One is convinced from hearing him that he is not satisfied that as much as could be done has been done in that regard. We either have to go completely totalitarian, whether it is red or blue totalitarianism, and have a dictatorial method of control, or we have to continue to admit that we are living under a system in which private enterprise and private property are still the orders of the day.

Comment on this

At the expense of everybody else.

Comment on this

It is not at the expense of everybody else.

Comment on this

At the expense of the workers.

Comment on this

And not at the expense of the workers. Everybody has a different view as to whose expense it is. We have to face facts. We are a democracy and we have a Constitution, under which certain controls are exercised by Parliament; but we have not yet reached totalitarianism, whether red totalitarianism, the Hitler type of totalitarianism or any other type.

Comment on this

In other words, you are quite happy with the Parliamentary Secretary?

Comment on this

I am quite happy with the parliamentary system and with our Constitution. I am trying to see how the Labour Deputies can put into effect all their demands inside the framework within which we live. I say that it cannot be done.

Comment on this

What about the drones Deputy Corry talked about? Do you not agree with the member of your own Party who said there are too many middlemen?

Comment on this

Be very careful. He was talking of a different type of middleman. He was talking of the type of middleman that Deputy Davin was in his younger years when he was between the producer and the consumer engaged in the transport of goods. But in doing that he was an essential cog in the wheel of industry.

Comment on this

A necessary evil.

Comment on this

No. I would not call that an evil. He was a middleman, one of those rats that are knocking around, according to Deputy Larkin's speech. It is a matter of opinion as to who is a middleman. Who is a middleman or what is a middleman?

Comment on this

There is no one better qualified to define it than yourself.

Comment on this

I say that a middleman is an essential cog in the wheel of industry.

Comment on this

There are too many cogs in it.

Comment on this

You do not know a single thing about it. You are not in any business nor have you any knowledge of it. The Deputy is trying to fool this Dáil as he fooled the constituents who voted for him by making statements that he could not stand over for five minutes. He has not any practical experience whatever of this and does not know anything about it.

Comment on this

Not of the inside of the kind of stuff you are talking about. I know nothing about that.

Comment on this
Patrick Joseph Halliden Acting-Chairman (Mr. Halliden) Clann na Talmhan

Order!

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey asked quite a legitimate question. He considers that I am qualified to define what a middleman is. I say that a middleman is an essential person who, in the scheme of things, comes in between the producer and the consumer. All kinds of things enter into that, such as the delivery of goods from a store by means of a lorry and a driver to another man's premises, the carrying of goods in bulk, the packing of them into separate items, the distribution of them in accordance with the orders given by one person to another.

A man goes through the country for his firm and gets orders, and it is the business of somebody else to supply those orders and deliver the goods. Railways and railway employees are all part of our distribution system. You cannot put goods on a train in Dublin and send them to Mayo without paying freight on them. That is all part of the cost of distribution.

Comment on this

What about the fellow who gets 6d. a ton on the importation of coal from South Africa simply for signing his name?

Comment on this

Can you buy coal without money? If a man puts up the money and takes a risk in doing so he is entitled to 6d. a ton and more. The 6d. a ton would not pay him.

Comment on this

Just for signing his name?

Comment on this

There is more than that in it. The Deputy may very soon be chasing people to try and bring in fuel to this country.

Comment on this

I will not chase you.

Comment on this

You are getting personal.

Comment on this

You are getting personal.

Comment on this

You are quite entitled to get personal. The Deputy is one of those gentlemen who will spend his own money on cables, telephones, correspondence, and typists, and who will find a source of supplies of materials for this country. He will arrange to put up the money to do that, or will get it through a bank, to bring in the materials, and he will do it all for nothing. I certainly would not. I would want to be paid for my knowledge and labour. I would have just as much right to ask to be paid for my labour and services as a solicitor would to ask for his fees for his services, or that a labouring man would expect to get for his services.

Comment on this

Would you agree to pay for your mistakes, too?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Order!

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins thought that the people were doing better to-day in the way of rationed goods than they were when Fianna Fáil were in office.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Deputy Rooney was not in the House when I dealt with subsidies on rationed goods earlier. I pointed out that the subsidising of rationed goods was introduced during the war years when enough goods were not available to give an even distribution all round.

Comment on this

That was a war measure that was introduced in England and followed here.

Comment on this

If we had not done it there would have been a different story. The subsidising of rationed goods is different elsewhere. It depends on your own resources and your requirements of certain commodities. That, of course, is quite true. When the war was over and the emergency had ceased, there appeared to be a reasonable hope that not only would materials become more readily available but that prices would fall. It is true that the Government changed the ration in regard to certain items. Take the case of butter. It is subsidised. People get the ration at the subsidised price but they can buy all they require in addition at the non-subsidised price. That is wrong, in view of the fact that we are exporting butter. Of course, it brings about a saving to the Exchequer on the rationed and subsidised goods. I say that is all wrong. I suggest that the gentlemen who sit on the Government Front Bench, not all of them, should read the contributions they made on this matter in 1947. If they do so, I think they will adopt the line which was adopted by Deputy O'Higgins this evening when he said: "Do not try to score political hits; let there be a recognition of the position which is there, and be fair to us." I do not know whether we have been unfair, but certainly the people opposite were unfair with us.

In my opinion, the Government is not taking sufficient notice of facts as they confront us, or as they exist in the world, as the Parliamentary Secretary said. I remember that when we were discussing the Taoiseach's Estimate this year he was annoyed when Deputies on this side warned him that there was a war atmosphere, and when we begged and pleaded that certain defence measures should be taken to meet a situation which might easily arise. The Deputies on this side were quite serious in their approach on that. The only satisfaction we got from the Taoiseach was to be told that we were wasting the time of the House discussing a mythical war. Now, the Korean war presents us with a really serious situation. The Parliamentary Secretary referred to it at least three times in the course of his speech. Some people may have believed last week that the American troops would be home by Christmas. It looks now as if they will not, and that the situation there is going to become much more widespread.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Korean war is very far away from this Bill.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give the date of the Taoiseach's speech from which he is supposed to be quoting?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will go to the library he can find it for himself. It was the debate on this year's Estimate on the eve of the adjournment of the Dáil for the summer recess.

Comment on this

There was no Korean war then.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Korean war seems to be very far away from this Bill.

Comment on this

Except to this extent, that the necessity for the rationing of food and the increase in the price of commodities during the last war were directly related to the fact that war was on. It was the war which was the cause of all that. We are now, in my opinion, approaching a very serious situation in world affairs. We have not taken, and we are not taking, any steps to meet the repercussions which must result either from the present war or the preparations that are being made in connection with it. The price of wool was discussed here, the tremendous and rapid advance in price. Why?

Comment on this

The Korean war.

Comment on this

It was bought long before the Korean war and for war reasons.

Comment on this

For starting the war.

Comment on this

Yes. Now that the war is there, at least let us recognise that it is there. Some people can read the signs, but other people have to see an actual conflagration taking place before they can recognise its existence. Tin jumped from £300 to over £1,000 for the same reason. Many other items will be affected both as to price and as to supplies. The present Government will be faced with serious problems, not only in trying to keep the cost of living down as expressed in figures, but also in being able to provide for the needs of our people to save them from undue hardship as the result of a shortage of essential commodities.

We are not entirely self-sufficient. It was the intention of the last Government to make the country as self-sufficient as possible in regard to certain essentials. We started off by wanting a recognition by the people and whatever Government existed that there were three essentials—food, clothing and shelter. To the extent to which we can make this country self-sufficient in these items it is becoming more apparent as time goes on, if we value our position as an independent little unit in the world, that we should make every effort to attain that goal in the event of a situation arising such as arose some time ago, so that we can nourish ourselves without having to sell our birthright for a bit of bread. I feel that we have reached the stage where this Government have missed the boat.

Comment on this

The bus.

Comment on this

Whatever you like to call it. Perhaps Deputy Davin might have used his influence in this way. I said in this House two years ago, in relation to reducing the adverse trade balance, that in my opinion that would not be a good thing as time went on. If this Government, when they saw the signs looming, had bought large quantities of essential commodities, such as wool, at the then ruling price——

Comment on this

Kept the wool here.

Comment on this

If the Deputy listened to the Parliamentary Secretary's answer to a question to-day he would have discovered that all the wool we produce in this country is not suitable for the making of clothing and that a large quantity is exported for carpet making. The fact is that we are dependent on the importation of a great deal of wool for our requirements. If the Government had done that, instead of trying to juggle with figures to reduce the adverse trade balance, which is now increasing, we might have now under the control of the Government a sufficient quantity of wool to supply all our blanket manufacturers for the next five years at the then ruling price and the Government could not be accused of buying for the sake of making a profit.

We are living in a State where we are operating all kinds of normal time controls. This is the time when people should be allowed to bring in what, in their opinion, are necessary supplies of commodities likely to diminish in quantity and increase in price as time goes on. There should be a slackening of the rigid quota control, particularly in relation to articles not made here. We hear talk about keeping prices down. It is very interesting to hear people say: "Forget about the world price of leather; let us produce our own leather at our own price and keep the price down irrespective of what it makes in the world at large." We forget that there are commodities which have an international value and that prices rise and fall.

Our main agricultural export is beef. We are selling beef to the world at our domestic price which is not comparable with prices elsewhere. We have to do that because the supply and demand situation is such that we can be squeezed into keeping to a price or our customers will not buy. From the point of view of a supplier we have not any great strength. We are, of course, important when it comes to requiring materials for our own needs. Because we are only an infinitesimal purchaser in the world markets we cannot affect the price at which we buy by refusing to buy. We have to take what the world offers at the price which rules at the time when we need goods.

Deputies who spent so much time before and during the last election abusing the Fianna Fáil Government for sins of omission and errors in regulating commodities for supply to the people are going to have a nice headache from now on mainly because they did not adopt precisely and entirely the scheme of things put into operation by the Fianna Fáil Government when the last emergency started, and by the time this emergency is over that will have to be done.

The cost of living has become a political matter because those who now occupy the Government Benches promised to reduce it in relation to the earning capacity of the people and, particularly, in relation to what they were going to have to eat and to wear and in relation to the kind of shelter they were to have. The inter-Party Government have failed miserably in keeping their promises and in keeping the people satisfied. From my contact with people I am satisfied that under the Fianna Fáil Government, even in the worst time of the emergency, the people were better off than they are to-day.

Comment on this

It is regrettable that a subject like this should be dealt with in the political way in which it has been dealt with, not so much by the last speaker, as by Deputy Lemass and Deputy de Valera, Junior. It is very difficult to be patient with statements made by Deputy Lemass and Deputy de Valera, Junior, when they speak about the control of prices. We cannot forget the price control exercised by Deputy Lemass and the Fianna Fáil Government during the emergency and up to 1947. We cannot easily forget also the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Government in regard to the demands of the workers when they looked for an increase of wages to meet the soaring cost of living, due to lack of proper control of prices. We were told by the then Taoiseach that if the workers did not limit their demands for wage increases the Government would take certain action with a view to preventing that. It was interesting to hear Deputy de Valera, Junior, endorsing that attitude here last Thursday when he said:—

"When the previous Government was faced with the problem it had to face in 1947 it had the courage to make a decision and did get results."

He went on to say: "As a supporter of that Government I shall feel proud every day that I am in public life that at least we did our duty."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What is the reference.

Comment on this

I have not got the reference. I do not think it is published. He spoke here last Thursday. Let me say to Deputy de Valera and the other members of the Fianna Fáil Party that we are not unmindful of the fact that when the change of Government did take place we were able to secure an increase of 11/- in wages for the majority of the workers without any threat of Government interference. I feel proud that the leaders of the trade unions did their duty to the workers in taking a stand against the threat of the Fianna Fáil Government and the opposition of the vested interests in securing that increase in the purchasing power of the masses.

I do not agree with the Parliamentary Secretary when he states that the cost of living had not increased since August, 1947. I know he based his case on the rise and fall of this precious cost-of-living index figure, on which the wages of thousands of workers have been based for years, and on which Deputy Lemass insisted during the standstill Order on wages that our claim for the maximum bonus should be based. That index figure has never been accepted by us. With all due respect to those who introduced it first and to those who have continued to keep it in force, it is little more than a statistical fable. It does not fit the actual cost of living of a single family in either the urban or the rural areas. It contains that statistical assumption, a fair average. That cost-of-living index figure is based on a series of working-class household budgets complied in 1922. Each item in this ancient document is brought up-to-date in price and calculated by statisticians. It is wrong to apply an average to thousands of people. It is assuming that the average represents the normal conditions of the majority. Every housewife must spend her own income, not an abstract average. If three housewives have incomes of £10, £5 10s. and £4 10s. respectively per week, there are two of them who will not find comfort in the statement that the average income is £6 13s. 4d.

I suggest that nothing effective can be done until we change that index figure. I have listened to Deputy Briscoe to-day. His whole contention was that things should be left as they are. He would lead one to understand that no undue profits are being made. He talked about the effective control exercised by the Department of Industry and Commerce. I have great regard for the officials of that Department and for their honesty, but the majority of the workers never had any confidence whatsoever in the price control exercised by that Department. I do not blame them for that because I listened to Deputy Lemass here in 1941 when speaking on Resolution No. 24, the excess corporation profits tax. This is what he said:

"I want Deputies to bear in mind that the existence of profits, even excess profits, is not a proof of profiteering."

During the same speech he said:

"There is that characteristic of the slave mind—it objects to the advancement of a neighbour's child. If anybody in this country promotes a new enterprise and makes good, then all the slave-minded people rise up at once to tear him down."

I could understand the position of the officials of the Department of Industry and Commerce trying to make a decision while the Minister in charge expressed that viewpoint. We had a similar case recently when the Industrial Authority Bill was introduced on the 9th March. Here is what Deputy Lemass said on that occasion:

"If we are not going to allow the profit motive to work you will either get stagnation or you must turn completely to State socialism."

Deputy Briscoe spoke in somewhat similar terms to-day. Deputy Lemass went on to say:

"This Industrial Development Authority is going to investigate the operation of protective tariffs. For what purpose? Is it going on a hunt after profits? Is it going to decide that the firm should be penalised which is making profits, even though it is producing goods of good quality and selling them at a reasonable price in relation to the price of similar goods sold in other countries?"

How could we expect confidence in the officials of the Department when the Minister expressed that viewpoint here? I say that the time has come when this Government will have to take courage and ensure that so far as price charging is concerned there is some body with the knowledge as to how it is worked out. I can give no better reason for that than this: here is a tag from an article purchased by me; the article states that the maximum price is 25/6; without asking for any reduction, the price I actually paid for that article was 19/6. In 1941 and again in 1942 I mentioned that I saw articles purchased with the controlled price marked but actually sold, without the purchaser asking for any reduction, at 2/6 less than the controlled price.

I suggest there is no effective control of either profits or prices, and it is because of that that we have disorder and dissatisfaction among the masses of our people. Deputy Major de Valera spoke for two hours. He merely quoted articles in the Press in an endeavour to score off the Government. He never suggested one thing that should be done. He merely told us we were passing through a very grave situation. Looking back now on 28 years of native government it appears to me to be years of gross and glaring injustice; men, women and children were denied a decent existence because they lacked a sufficiency of food. Money dominated everything else and no attempt worth mentioning was made to try to remedy the position. What are we to think of a system of society in which an honest and hardworking man can toil all his life at work that is socially desirable for a wage on which he cannot keep his wife and family, and then when one thinks of the worthless speculator who can amass a fortune in a few years, one wonders whether there is any justice anywhere. It is necessary to consider from the ground up the social organisation in which we are living with a view to finding out whether any change can be made for the better or whether it can be adapted to the changing needs of our time. Unless some change is made I think there is very little hope of any effective control by any Government so long as vested interests get priority over the needs of the masses of our people.

Deputy Briscoe talked about the price paid for money for housing. I often wonder why people are so fearful of referring to that matter. I know that the Cork Corporation borrowed £200,000 recently at 4 per cent. interest from the banks in order to build houses. These houses are costing anything up to £1,400. That means that the rent for interest charges alone will be over £50 a year. Will anybody suggest that is not a matter when considering the cost of living?

I do seriously suggest that the position in this country for some years past has been very far from what we expected it would have been. We listened to Deputy de Valera speaking here for about two and a half hours this evening, in his efforts to demonstrate all the defects of the present Administration, but he and his colleagues cannot shelve responsibility for the condition of affairs which developed in this country during the 15 years when they were on this side of the House as a Government. What do we find? A picture of the present conditions in the country may be drawn in this way. Imagine 100 persons, of whom two are rich, eight comfortable, 60 poor and 30 very poor—a leisured ten owning as much as the working 90. That is how the wealth of the country is distributed to-day. Of course the leisured ten, owning the Press, ceaselessly tell the people that any interference with them or any disturbance of their position would be disastrous for the country as a whole. These are the problems we have got to tackle.

I think it is hardly fair to treat the present position in the manner in which it is being treated to-day with a succession of speeches of political character in which one side tries to score debating points over the other. There is no use in telling the ordinary housewife that the cost of living has not gone up. I know that for years during the régime of the Fianna Fáil Government, when wages were pegged down, in 1943, 1944, 1945 and 1946 they did not peg down the profits made by certain people in this country. If anybody has any doubts as to that, he has only to refer to the statement made by Mr. S.T. O'Ceallaigh, the then Minister for Finance, in the Seanad in July, 1941. The case was then made that the making of extra profits could not be called profiteering, and when he was asked by a member of the commercial class in the Seanad to remove some taxes he said he could not possibly do it. He quoted the case of private company A, which had a profit standard of £10,000. It writes up its premises and goodwill, he said, by a fictitious amount of £50,000, which it credits to a reserve fund, and it then capitalises this reserve by the issue of 50,000 ordinary shares at £1 each to shareholders. He went on to describe a somewhat similar procedure in regard to private companies which he called B, C and D.

The figures which he quoted are there to be seen by anybody and they disclose the absolutely scandalous position which has been allowed to develop. Then we are told that there was an effective control of profits and prices during that period. I suggest to the Government that they should take strong and drastic action and that they should give the necessary power to this advisory body to see that profits are reduced to a fair and reasonable level. If that is done and if the workers feel that they can have confidence that the necessary efforts will be made to keep the cost of living in check, then the workers will be prepared to make any sacrifices that they may be called upon to make in the interests of the country as a whole.

Comment on this

In reference to this discussion on the cost of living, I want first of all to say a few words in regard to the speech made by Deputy Larkin in which he tried, in a most shameful manner, to cover up the present attitude of the Labour Party towards the Fine Gael section of the Government by blaming Fianna Fáil for having been the original cause of all the trouble. Deputy Larkin may possibly have been stung to action by the very severe defeat which his Party suffered in the local elections in Dublin, a defeat, I think, largely occasioned by the complete and absolute disappointment of the workers of Dublin at the failure of the Labour Party to carry out their election promises in regard to the cost of living. They certainly saw the writing on the wall in that election. A suggestion has been made that, during the war, in some way or other the Fianna Fáil Government allowed prices to rise too high and that even the Coalition Government, magnificent and all as they were supposed to be, had failed to bring about a reduction, largely because of the policy of the previous Administration. The position, in fact, is that Fianna Fáil achieved wonders during the war in maintaining the cost of living at the lowest possible level consistent with the circumstances. Their record was one of which the country can be proud. Prices rose only for the last few years of the war owing to the higher cost of raw materials and to the circumstances of the emergency. One of the most remarkable features of that time was the fact that from 1943 to 1946 prices remained almost stable. I admit that the price of certain commodities such as boots, shoes and clothing went up slightly but, taken as a whole, the cost of living was, in a predominant sense, pegged during the end of the war and remained pegged largely until 1946. That was a fine record, something to boast about, something that cannot be controverted or set aside by the wishy-washy nonsense of the Labour Party in regard to our being responsible for the present cost of living.

By 1946 we were in the position that out of 67 countries in the world, who record proper statistics, the cost of living had gone up less in this country than in the case of 50, had gone up about as much as in the case of seven and had gone up more than in the case of ten countries. We in Fianna Fáil are prepared to stand on that record. We are prepared to challenge anybody who questions the validity of the figures supplied by the League of Nations Economic Bureau at that time. We consider that a fine effort on our part. In the case of the ten countries, where the cost of living had gone up by a smaller amount than here, in most cases there were good reasons. Some countries for reasons of their own paid subsidies of double the amount per head of the population than we paid. For example, in the case of England, subsidies were generally running at the level of £10 per head of the population whereas they were running here at the rate of £3 to £5 or £6 per head. In these countries, however, taxation, not only of the rich but of the worker, was very much higher than here while the cost of what might be described as semi-luxury commodities, such as tobacco and alcohol, was very much higher than here. As I have said, we are perfectly satisfied to stand on that record. We claim that the standstill Order, condemned so much by the Labour Party, worked reasonably well and that along with the excess profits tax and the excess profits corporation tax imposed by the Government, it did maintain prices at a figure which could be expected having regard to the fact that there was a world war on.

In 1946, about August, prices started to rise owing to post-war inflationary conditions and they rose, if I remember rightly, about 10 per cent, from August, 1946, to August, 1947. In October, 1947, supplementary duties were imposed on various commodities and services in order to do what was being done in other countries who ran their economies intelligently, to collect the hot money that always arises after a war when money becomes released and when there are not sufficient goods upon which money can be spent. It was a perfectly normal temporary measure, designed by intelligent economists to bring about a given result. It brought about the result. The cost of living came down by about 3 per cent, if I remember rightly, within four months of its imposition and the hot money ceased to circulate in the same way.

I personally am proud that Fianna Fáil imposed those taxes. I am proud that we left office having had the courage to do something unpopular that was good. One of the interesting things about the present situation is that at last the tide is beginning to turn against the Government among people who were delighted with the fact that they were in their different ways prepared to please everyone at everyone else's expense. They have seen fit to do nothing since they came into office that could possibly appear to be unpopular to any particular section of the community. The Irish people in the long run will always respect people who are prepared to do unpopular things for the sake of the common good without having to refer to sections of the community to see whether any particular act is likely to be unpopular among them from the point of view of vote-catching. We are beginning to see the end of that régime and the sooner it comes the better for the morale of this country.

In 1948 we had a general election. The present Government succeeded in arousing what might be termed a definite hysteria amongst certain groups of people, particularly in Dublin, who came to believe quite sincerely that the cost of living was being upheld as a result of pressure brought to bear by financial interests on the Fianna Fáil Party and that the cost of living was like a bubble that could be burst if only the Fianna Fáil Government could be driven out.

I remember sitting in buses some time or other during that election or just prior to it, simply in order to hear what people were talking about because I had been told that we would have to be prepared to face very severe criticism in Dublin owing to this business about the cost of living. I remember hearing people talking in the buses about the cost of living as though it was a scandal, a really serious scandal, something about which there were liable to be astonishing revelations overnight.

It was a most successful campaign in so far as Dublin was concerned. It failed almost completely in the country parts where people have more time to reflect on the truth of such statements as are made during elections. I remember standing one evening near a tram queue. Two or three big Dodge cars passed by and the people in the queue were talking about the fellows in the cars as though they were some of the boys who were protecting Fianna Fáil, giving big money to the Fianna Fáil funds, and they were saying that they had been out during the day with their baskets, shopping, and that the cost of goods was high only because of those fellows in the big cars, that they should put them out and see what would happen. The hysteria went on and, as I have said, it was successful in Dublin among a certain number of people who, like all of us, occasionally made mistakes in judgment. We have all made them. Many of us have seen far-off green hills in our lives and bitterly regretted that we did not take a second look. These people were affected in that way.

I suppose from a purely personal selfish point of view, one of the greatest satisfactions I have had in a comparatively short political career has been to hear at last another political bomb burst in Dublin successfully. I just think of the last four or five years of political conflict and battle and remember the hysteria and the bombs bursting in 1948, when I wondered whether it would ever be possible to have another hysterical cry in Dublin aroused in some other way and perhaps at the expense of the present Government.

The bomb burst the other day. If anybody was sitting in a tram or a bus or any other public vehicle, or listening to people in queues, he would have heard the talk over again about the cost of living, and all the talk was the result of those beautiful headlines in the daily newspaper which said there had been no increase in prices. The following day, people began to wonder whether the Government had gone crazy, whether it was possible for a responsible Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to make the bald announcement that there had been no increase in prices. Of course, you have to be awfully careful, when you speak about the cost of living, to measure words, and it is possible to make a few statements that are going to receive particular attention from the public and then to try and back out of them by making all sorts of reservations afterwards, which have no effect. That is what happened in this particular case.

The Parliamentary Secretary would have been far wiser if he had followed the course of the former Taoiseach who several times during his career was prepared to get up and speak for an hour on any matter in which he felt he had made a mistake in judgment honestly and sincerely. If the Parliamentary Secretary had simply said: "We know now that everything we said in 1948 was wrong; the prices section of the Department of Industry and Commerce had not been instructed by the Minister to disregard the accounts of businessmen who are supposed to be filling the Fianna Fáil war-chest; the cost of living, we discovered after all, could not be reduced substantially and, not having been reduced substantially, when world circumstances changed, inevitably it started to rise again; let us forget the past and let us now get on with the work and see what we can do"—if that had been the attitude of the Government, they would have received a considerable measure of support from what might be described as the floating vote, the people who are inclined to change from election to election.

But, of course, it is very difficult for the Ministers or the Parliamentary Secretaries of a Coalition Government ever to admit mistakes, particularly those that are made by the smaller Parties upon whom they rely for their support. I suppose one of the most scandalous promises made in the election history of this country was made by Clann na Poblachta when they promised to reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent. Equally scandalous is the statement made by Deputy Lehane that he still believes in some vague kind of way that it is now possible to reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent.

I think I had better repeat what I have said several times in the past— the Parliamentary Secretary can get the figures from the officials attending upon him—that if you wanted to reduce the cost of living at the moment by 30 per cent. you would have to give away free tea, sugar, bread and milk. I forget the exact quartet of commodities—I have lost them in my notes— but at least four of the principal commodities of life would have to be given away free. That would be a great election promise to make. It is possible.

The Government have already run into £12,000,000 deficit last year on the accounts. If they want to borrow £30,000,000 for the sake of subsidising the cost of living to that tune, there is nothing to prevent them doing it, if they can come here and get the support of the House and afterwards see if they can somehow bulldoze the banks to supply them with the money, if they offer a loan and it is not subscribed by a no longer gullible public. Because, as Mr. MacBride, Minister for External Affairs, could easily have discovered by one telephone call to the Statistics Branch, before the general election, the subsidy required to bring down the cost of living by 30 per cent. in 1947, would have amounted to no less than £30,000,000 more than the existing subsidies.

It was a lovely, beautiful promise to make, and apparently it did do some good to the Clann na Poblachta Party. Another consolation in my own political career was seeing the Clann na Poblachta Party getting only three out of 45 seats in the Dublin Corporation elections, instead of the 11 or 12 seats which they should have got if they received the same support as they had during the general election. There are loads of people who have not the time to study statistics, and there are some people who would not understand them or accept them. There are people who are prepared temporarily to try a new Party when a really good, thumping promise is made, whether it may be fulfilled or not. That is what happened in the case of the Clann na Poblachta Party.

I have heard references in the debate suggesting that no one should talk about the promises made during an election. Statements made off platforms during an election can be forgiven, we are told, in some way—that these are election speeches and that one can expect candidates to talk in any manner during an election. My own belief is that the world is strewn with dictatorships resulting from wild promises made and never kept, and that is true to a great extent of countries formerly governed by coalitions, where everybody is trying to win votes at everyone else's expense by promising a particular policy that they think will appeal to the electors. The people of Dublin are having an excellent post mortem examination. We can see the result of the election promises made by groups prepared to form a coalition.

Already the electors in any election have a difficult enough task to choose a Dáil. They have to consider what general policy they like best; they have to consider if some particular enthusiasm which they feel deeply about is included in a Party's policy, and whether they would not vote for another Party solely because of that enthusiasm. They have to consider whether the men at the head of a Party are good men, whether the leader of the Party is a good man. They also have to consider all the local circumstances in their constituency and, lastly, they have to consider whether they might not have to vote for some personality over and above Party considerations. It is a hard procedure for the average man to make a good choice.

On top of that, the electors have to decide, first of all, in regard to Parties, knowing every Party except the Fianna Fáil Party will have two policies, the policy they might put into operation if they got into office and the policy they will agree to put into operation if they have to form a coalition. I believe that we in Fianna Fáil can look back on the whole on a very fine record. There were no false promises. In the 16 years we were in office we had a great record in that regard. In 1932 and 1933 there were practically no plans in existence; everything had to be started from scratch. I would like any Deputy in the Government Benches to go to the files of the newspapers and to take out the official policy of Fianna Fáil, the published plans, and note the extraordinary restraint in what was promised. Very few promises were made. Occasionally one person may have said something indiscreet off a platform. One of the well-known indiscretions is said to have been made by one person, who denies having made it, that we would bring back people to work in this country. We took a long time to do it, but we did it in 1947, in our last year of office.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What is the relevancy of all this?

Comment on this

I am trying to relate it to the general question of making promises at election times.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a bit of a strain.

Comment on this

I can, without straining the limit, relate it to the promises made by the Government Parties with reference to the cost of living. Mr. Norton, who is now Minister for Social Welfare, and whose Party lost seven seats in the Dublin Corporation election, said on 17th January, 1948:—

"The return of a strong Labour Party would be a guarantee that profiteering and high prices would be dealt with ruthlessly."

On 2nd January, 1948, he is reported in the Irish Press as saying:—

"The first task of the new Dáil will be drastic legislation to control prices and punish profiteers, to reimpose the excess corporation profits tax."

Mr. MacBride, the Minister for External Affairs, according to the Irish Press of 28th January:—

"The increased bread subsidy was provided to swell the profits of some bakeries."

We have not yet had published the report on the effect of the subsidies upon the bakery and flour business, nearly three years after the Government got into office. That was a nice statement to make. Then we had Mr. Norton at Mullingar on 29th January, 1948:—

"The excess corporation tax ought to be retained to subsidise the prices of essential commodities."

I wonder whether the Government would reimpose the excess corporation profits tax? It would mean £3,000,000 a year and if they dared to carry out the promises solemnly entered into by the Labour Party they could use that £3,000,000 to bring down the cost of some commodities. It might help them politically and tide them over the difficult period that is coming; they will be taught a lesson by the electors should they ever consult them.

Then the Minister for Defence, speaking at Clara, as reported in the Midland Tribune, on 10th January, 1948, said:—

"We advocate a scheme of subsidisation of essential commodities as a step to alleviate the burden of the cost of living."

I wonder what the Minister for Defence meant? We see no sign of an increase in subsidies. We had Dr. O'Higgins, as he then was, saying again:—

"This may mean costly subsidisation of food prices so as to help the producer and the consumer in reducing the cost of living. Such moneys can and will be found by economies in other directions where ample scope is obvious."

What is the result of that? A Budget of £106,000,000 and a deficit of £12,000,000 and no increase in subsidies. We now have a delightful subterfuge being practised by the Government in regard to existing subsidies. The public are being taught the idea that the rationed sugar at 4d. per 1b. is what the community needs in the ordinary way and only the rich buy the unrationed sugar. Very few of them know that nearly the whole cost of the subsidised sugar is being found through the profit created by the sale of unsubsidised sugar at its present price level. Dr. O'Higgins, the Minister for Defence, far from increasing the subsidy, is saving the Budget a certain sum on subsidies by collecting a subsidy from what is supposed to be the better-off section of the community, particularly in the case of sugar. What are the facts in regard to that? The facts are these: that the housewife goes for the day to a market town in her horse and trap or donkey cart; she has to have a meal in a restaurant, so she goes into a restaurant and has her meal, for which she pays quite a sizable sum. All the catering sugar for that meal is sold to her at the unsubsidised price. She pays the extra price and then she goes to the shop and buys her weekly ration of sugar-having already paid part of the subsidy for the ration out of the money paid for the restaurant meal. Further, as far as I can gather from reading the nutritional surveys, one of the commodities which is not a luxury commodity is ordinary jam. In all the families where, alas, there is still a very high proportion of bread and spread meals, jam is bought along with other things; it is one of the little luxuries people with low incomes can afford for themselves instead of having a meal of two courses, meat and so forth. The whole of the sugar for that jam is sold to the jam manufacturers at the unsubsidised price and when the housewife buys her pot of jam she is helping to pay for the subsidy on the rationed sugar. I hope that the people of Dublin appreciate these facts. They are very important, particularly when we recollect that Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, now the Minister for Defence, promised to increase the subsidies for food if he was elected to office. It is rather strange that the Clann na Poblachta Party, even though they could not bring about a reduction of 30 per cent. in the cost of living, could not at least persuade the Fine Gael section of the Coalition Government to tuck on a bit here and there in the subsidies just to create a little effect—to help the housewife over the present difficult position.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy say what is wrong in principle with taking the subsidy off part of the ration?

Comment on this

There is nothing wrong with it in principle. It is just a scandalous breach of promise.

Comment on this

Did we not raise the standard of living by 30 per cent.?

Comment on this

There is nothing wrong with it in principle. One can always juggle with subsidies. One can always take money out of one pocket and put it into another pocket. I am relating to the transfer that takes place in regard to the price of sugar for jam and sugar for poor persons' meals. I said it was a scandalous breach of promise.

Comment on this

There is nothing wrong with that?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If you pay for the subsidy through having a higher ration price, then having a subsidy on the rationed commodity is just a sham— and all shams are wrong.

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, now the Minister for Defence, certainly let himself go on the cost of living during the election. He is reported in the Irish Press of 12th January, 1948, as having said: “The first thing to be done,” said Dr. O'Higgins at Cork, “by the new Government would be to reduce the cost of living.” Then we have Deputy Liam Cosgrave, the present Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach and to the Minister for Industry and Commerce—whose bombshell burst on the people of Dublin the other day: it was so grand to hear the people at last really talking against the present Government, their eyes being fully opened—reported as saying at Dún Laoghaire on 9th January, 1948: “High national expenditure was a direct contributing factor to the high cost of living.” Deputy Cosgrave's Party, as far as I know, increased the Budget to £106,000,000, and created a deficit of £12,000,000—all of which has an inflationary effect and none of which relates to the promises to reduce taxation and the general cost of Government.

The Minister for Social Welfare, Deputy Norton; as reported in the Leinster Leader of 31st January, 1948, said at Leixlip: “The people groan over rising prices. Wages are buying less goods every week. Malnutrition abounded and their chief exports were men and women.” I hope that the people of Dublin will remember Deputy Norton's saying at Leixlip during the election that the people were groaning over rising prices and that their chief exports were men and women.

Then again at Brownstown, the Curragh, Deputy Norton is reported in the Leinster Leader of 17th January, 1948, as having said: “The Government has got cold feet over prices control. They had dropped the new Prices Bill recently in the Dáil. The Minister had now decontrolled coal.” I hope that the people of Dublin will remember Deputy Norton's saying that the Government had got cold feet over prices control when they remember that 26 articles or commodities are no longer subject to control by the prices section of the Department of Industry and Commerce and that in nearly every case prices have risen.

I think I should quote again, because the more often it is on the records of the House the better, the statement made by Deputy MacBride, now the Minister for External Affairs, at Carlow and reported in the Leinster Leader:“Subsidies should be sufficient to bring about a reduction of at least 30 per cent. in the existing cost of food produced and consumed here and should be accompanied by a strict control of prices.”

Comment on this

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

That it was not done.

Comment on this

Then the Government came into office. Very soon after they came into office some of the members of the Labour Party began to complain that nothing was being done to break the cost of living. One of the curious things about the Labour Party is that at one time they will defend their attitude by saying that wages went up by 10 per cent. and that the cost of living remained stable. That has been said to one section of the community. When, however, they want to appeal to another section of the community they say that they know that the cost of living has not been reduced in the way in which they believe it should have been reduced and that they are going to do something about it. The workers of Dublin are now beginning to rebel against that kind of claptrap —one voice saying: "Things are not too bad. Prices have not gone up very much. We have stabilised the cost of living. Wages have gone up by 10 per cent. in a great many industries. Therefore, you may take it that we have fulfilled our promises." While, two weeks later, at the same union meeting, you arouse a frenzy of protest by saying: "We know the promise has not been kept. We are going to do something about it because we believe the cost of living can be lowered." No Party on earth can go on behaving in that manner for any length of time: they always receive their reward from the electors—just as the Labour Party received it in the recent Dublin Corporation elections.

Comment on this

Just as Fianna Fáil got it in 1948.

Comment on this

And then, after the election, we had the spectacle of the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Social Welfare having a nice little dispute together in the Dáil on the occasion of the debate on the Budget. It is well for the public to remember this statement, which was made by the Minister for Finance in the course of his Budget speech:—

"The substantial wage and salary increases already secured—under Fianna Fáil—by all classes of workers ... have gone as far as is possible, in present circumstances, to meet the claims of social justice, and I would make a most earnest appeal to all employees not to seek further increases. ... Recent experience confirms that the benefit of an increase in money incomes is rapidly swallowed up by rising prices."

That was the statement by the Minister for Finance in the course of his first Budget speech, and he was speaking of wage and salary increases that took place before the present Government took office.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Can the Deputy give the reference?

Comment on this

I am afraid not, but it is part of the Budget speech. In the course of the same Budget debate, the Minister for Social Welfare said:—

"Present wage standards are quite inadequate to provide workers with a decent standard of living."

So one can see that from the beginning there was already some kind of clash between the two principal Parties, each of them having a different point of view towards our economy, each of them trying to put forward and into operation a different policy in regard to our economy, one policy being a deflationary economy, the other policy being increased wages for workers, possibly merited in many directions and to a certain degree, but always asked for irrespective of whether in the ultimate the result might not be a still higher cost of living.

On September 20th, 1948, Deputy Larkin became restive and in the course of a report that he made in connection with some trade union meeting said that the Minister for Finance should impose the excess profits tax, "that the public had no faith in departmental machinery in the control of prices". I should repeat that statement of September, 1948, "the public had no faith in departmental machinery in the control of prices". It had operated for the last eight years and the same officials were operating it. No matter how well-intentioned they were, they could not convince the workers that prices could not be broken. It is now nearly December, 1950, and two years have elapsed and there has been no suggestion during any of that time that the existing price control system was not operating satisfactorily. I hope that the same officers have been left in control, as we knew they were honest, decent men doing their work well. We suddenly have announced, with a week's notice, the formation of a tribunal which is supposed in some way or other to check rising prices. The thing I want to refer to is the fact that the suggestion was made by Deputy Larkin two years ago and has never yet been implemented, although there was all that time to make preparation and consider the matter. The answer, of course, was: "A typical Coalition bargain." My own belief is that the effect of price control machinery can be very limited.

One of the worst features of this debate has been the sort of generalised statement that because one particular group of industries is profiteering all manufacturers are profiteering, that because there may be restrictive practices in certain trades there are restrictive practices in all trades and because there may be a particular retailer here and there who is making too much profit all retailers are making too much profit. That is good socialist talk. We hear quite a lot of it. It is not called socialism in the Dáil, as very few members of the Labour Party dare call themselves socialists. It is the kind of talk that goes very well—the impression is created that if there were very few rich, if their wealth were distributed and their profits taken away, the result would be the ending of poverty. It is the cheapest and loudest cry of the socialist—and socialists all over the world have had to learn very bitter lessons when they started to put it into practice.

One of the statements made in the course of this debate gave the general impression that manufacturer's profits have largely affected the cost of living and that if manufacturer's profits were reduced, the effect on the retail prices would be noticeable to the consumer. Well, I defy the Parliamentary Secretary in his reply to quote the profit element, the manufacturer's profit element, in any one of 60 commodities at his choice, to show that it could possibly affect to any great degree the retail cost of the commodity. The Minister for Industry and Commerce— who is ill and whom we all hope will recover successfully from his illness— in the course of a debate, when he was on the other tack, mentioned the fact that when the price of shoes was about 35/-, the manufacturer's profit was 8d. That is one of many examples. I suppose the best example was given by Sir Stafford Cripps, the former Lord Chancellor of the Exchequer in the British Government, who, during the crisis in 1947, when England was nearly going bankrupt for the third time, made an appeal to workers not to go too fast in regard to demands for increased wages. He admitted in the course of his speech that there were certain trades that were depressed, where wages should be increased. We would, of course, admit that in this country there should be increases in certain trades where the wages and profits are irrelated. He admitted that they would have to go up according to some plan in relation to the cost of living. We would also admit that, if it were done intelligently and wisely and not in a way which would hurt the workers. But he galvanised the trade union movement in England by making an astounding statement, that if in 1947 the whole of the profits of industry, including the dividends, the salaries of all the employers, all the profits assessable after the taxes had been paid on them, were transferred wholly to the workers, the workers would receive 4d. more on every £ in wages. It certainly astonished the Socialist Party in Great Britain. I suppose if any one of them had been asked to guess the figure, he would have multiplied that figure by ten. It is an illustration of how easy it is to talk glibly about profiteering, the idea being that as long as you soak the rich enough you can reduce the cost of living.

Of course profiteering by a group here and an individual there may have a marginal effect on living costs and this factor must be borne in mind. But whether a prices tribunal, sitting and taking most of its important evidence in private, is going to do much to delay the effects of the Korean crisis, of the rearmament of the world, about that I am very, very doubtful. My own belief is that in the long run the history of this country will show that the direct responsibility of a Minister for his Department is the important thing. If the Minister does his work well and if he is a member of a united Government, he can do more to convince the public that the best is being done for them under the circumstances than any number of tribunals sitting more or less in vacuo. One thing I always like to say is that which was said frequently by the former Minister for Industry and Commerce when he was in office, that it is so easy to make generalisations about profits and costs. One of the astounding things in economic life is the fact that some of the companies, both British and Irish, that make the largest possible profits, that look very like profiteering, sell their goods at the lowest possible prices and achieve the very highest possible quality, and that some of the most highly costed goods are sold by companies who do not make half enough profit or pay half enough wages to their workers. You can find plenty of evidence of that throughout the length and breadth of this land, of America and of Great Britain.

One of the dangers of the ordinary routine system of price control is any kind of cast-iron system which tells a man that he cannot make more than a certain amount of profit in a year in relation to a particular commodity. The result is to dissuade him from putting in better machinery and to remove the incentive to make a higher profit and he tries to take it out on his workers if they are not protected by a really excellent trade union. They may be the first sufferers from unwise price control.

Comment on this

The Deputy is drawing his inference from one of the generalisations to which he took exception.

Comment on this

Nothing I say can be regarded as a generalisation, but it frequently happens. As an example, there is a very large company in this city—I will not mention the name— which makes enormous profits, enormous profits by any standards. They make goods of a most excellent quality and pay their workers well. I am saying that because this glib talk about profits can be so false.

To go back to this beautiful history of the efforts of the Government to carry out its promises with regard to the cost of living, we had Deputy Larkin in September, 1948, saying that he believed that prices could be broken. Then we had the Minister for Industry and Commerce on October 29th, 1948. I think that this statement should be repeated and I hope that the newspapers will publish it in their wisdom in this debate to-morrow morning.

Comment on this

Is that a tip to the Press?

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce said in October, 1948, as reported in the Irish Press:—

"I intend to do what I can to see that costs are reduced but there are definite limits to what any Government can do to control prices."

And then he threw up the sponge beautifully and completely by saying:—

"The remedy is really in the hands of the public."

It is no wonder that the Parliamentary Secretary spread great headlines across the Independent when he said that there had been no advance in prices because he was obviously trying to protect his Minister, whom I am sorry not to have in this debate. I hope he will be with us again. He said it to protect his Minister, who two years and two months ago threw up the sponge and said definitely that the public could decide the issue. If the public refrained from buying expensive goods —he did not say this—the effect would be that the price of those goods would inevitably fall.

Comment on this

That is exactly what Deputy Aiken said.

Comment on this

I do not know how this view can be related to the proposal to have not only the prices section of the Department of Industry and Commerce operating, not only the Industrial Development Authority operating, but to appoint another new tribunal to sit and consider prices. Has the Minister for Industry and Commerce changed his mind? I would like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary that. Does he no longer believe that the remedy for the high cost of living lies in the hands of the public. That is an interesting question and an important question. Let him tell us what circumstaces have caused him to change his mind or whether it is merely the effect of pressure by one of the Coalition groups upon him. Has he no belief in it? Does this section in the Bill represent not his own belief but the belief of one of the groups of the Coalition? That is a fair question and I would like to have an answer.

Then the Taoiseach, in December, 1948 (Volume 113, column 726), answered a question by Deputy Cowan. Deputy Cowan asked him whether it was possible for him to slash prices and the Taoiseach made this statement, which is really magnificent in the light of all that followed:—

"Every effort has been, is being and will be made by the Government to reduce the cost of living.... The remission of taxation which was effected by the Government immediately after their entry upon office must, in itself, have acted as a significant contribution towards reducing the cost of living. In addition to this, constant supervision has been exercised over prices and profits. All possible precautions have been and are being taken by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to ensure that the profits earned by manufacturers' agents, importers and distributors are reasonable having regard to costs. ... The principal consideration which prevents a fall in the general price level is the high cost of imported commodities and raw materials."

Well, the Taoiseach took a year to learn a truth which should have been as obvious in February, 1948, as it was a year later. Then Deputy Cowan asked again if he were prepared to slash the prices of essential articles and the Taoiseach said that he could not promise, and I think that that may be regarded as the final surrender of the Government with regard to their efforts to carry out their election promises. As a nice little humorous tit-bit, of which it is well to remind the Dáil and the public, in reply to Deputy Aiken's question whether the Taoiseach would implement the Clann promise to reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent., the Taoiseach had a delightful reply.

Comment on this

You are very fond of Clann na Poblachta.

Comment on this

He said that he would give an answer to that question if he thought it was serious. In other words the Taoiseach thought that we should never have considered a Clann na Poblachta promise serious, and what therefore was the use of asking him?

Comment on this

That is not the meaning of the reply at all, and the Deputy well knows it.

Comment on this

I might add again that the promise was a very remarkable one, and was talked greatly about by the people. I can remember people of considerable intelligence and considerable education grilling me by the fireside in ordinary friendly talk before the October by-election. They asked was it not possible to lower the prices of goods in the shop. They told me to go to this shop or that shop; and they asked why a shirt would cost 30/- in one while the same shirt would cost 25/- in another. "Was it not all true," they asked, "that prices could be brought down in a rush? You had better be careful," they told me, "of all the money you are getting from the profiteers in order to allow them to maintain high prices. You might lose the by-election. We know that you are a very good Party and that you have done excellently——"

Comment on this
Deputies

Oh!

Comment on this

:——"but Clann na Poblachta is right and it is quite possible to reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent. if you try. Go back to the Government and tell them that." I heard that talk and it used to annoy me——

Comment on this

I am sure it did.

Comment on this

——as an ordinary individual. Now we see that every one of those promises was brought to nothing. I do not think that the Government have been able to produce a single profiteer from the bag. I do not think that any group or single businessman has been held up to obloquy because he and they were lining the pockets of Fianna Fáil at the public expense. I am very glad that the whole of that false nonsense has been burst very successfully by the present Government.

I thought at the time that it might be possible to bring about a very small reduction in prices. Any new Minister for Industry and Commerce might be able to do a little. He goes into office and simply starts to call for paper and stir things up. He has cases examined and prices examined and reminds the officers of the Department of certain factors regarding price control. It surprised me that they were not able to do a little simply by virtue of the fact of one person taking office from another person. The fact is that they were not able. The cost of living remained stable and then started to go up quite steadily after a short time in respect of a whole series of commodities of great importance to the public. The result of the whole thing has been simply the ending of a shameless campaign of misrepresentation carried on against the Fianna Fáil Party for which the Government is going to pay in the long run by a loss of confidence among the public.

Comment on this