Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1950—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–126 of 247. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 34 of 1950 ›
The Taoiseach has thought it best to keep out of the House during the course of this debate. But yesterday he went down to Wexford and he made a statement, according to to-day's Press, which, if he believes it, should have been made here together with an indication as to what the Government proposes to do to meet the situation he outlined there.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I was in possession when we adjourned the debate on this matter.
Comment on this
Yes, but the Deputy would not rise when called on. He was talking to somebody. It is not my fault. I regret it.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach stated down in Wexford: "There is no ground for foolish or presumptuous optimism." He went on to say that "throughout the entire period of the last four or five years it had been difficult to avoid being disturbed by the threats of yet another and more terrible war. It was, however, to misunderstand the events of these years to imagine that the spectre of war made its first menacing appearance only recently in Korea. In one aspect or another that spectre has been haunting the world since the present uneasy peace began."
Comment on this
That statement made by the Taoiseach in Wexford is a most amazing statement in view of the fact that it is only a couple of months since he was denouncing as warmongers——
Comment on this
——those people who were asking the Government to do something to prepare against the menacing world situation. Yesterday he talked about the "presumptuous optimism" of those who thought we could avoid the effect of wars in other parts of the world. On 14th July last he stated that the Government's policy was based on the "hypothesis of continuing peace," and he said "we did not require to take any steps against the mythical war that Deputy Lemass thought was coming." He denounced more than Deputy Lemass on that occasion in relation to this "mythical war," as he called it. Yesterday, according to his speech in Wexford, those people who did not see that the world situation was dangerous and that the Korean war was merely an incident in the general situation were "foolish optimists" and blind people. What are the people to do under the guidance of a Government like that?
Comment on this
The Government are proposing that we give them powers in this Bill to authorise them to make Orders providing for the regulation and control, by or on behalf of this State, of any of the supplies which are, in the opinion of the Government, essential to the life of the community and also for the provision and maintenance of such essential supplies. Another clause in the Act which this Bill proposes to renew enables the Government to make such provisions with respect to the cultivation and use of land which, in the opinion of the Government, are necessary for increasing or maintaining the production of articles essential to the life of the community. Another clause authorises local authorities to take steps in connection with the maintenance of supplies and enables them compulsorily to acquire land. If the situation is such, as the Taoiseach denied most vehemently it was in 1950, and as he said yesterday in Wexford it is now, what use are the Government going to make of these powers? The Minister for Social Welfare said that they were going to freeze prices, that they were going to freeze the price of blankets at 100 per cent. more than a year ago. To the person who is looking for blankets to keep himself warm at double the price they were a year ago, all I can say is that I hope the weather keeps mild. To freeze prices at that level is very small comfort for the people who are short of blankets.
Comment on this
Deputy after Deputy got up after the Parliamentary Secretary spoke and tried to deny that he said that the price level had remained static
Comment on this
Up to mid-August. I did not say since.
Comment on this
One at a time. I shall take the whole lot of you, one by one. The Parliamentary Secretary said, as reported in col. 1267 of the Official Debates for the 23rd November:—
"It is, however, a matter of some achievement that, despite devaluation and despite the rises that occurred elsewhere, in this country in the last three years the index of retail prices, which is in fact the cost-of-living index figure, has remained static."
Comment on this
This is blatant dishonesty. The Deputy knows he is dishonest. He is only quoting part of it.
Comment on this
Not only did the Parliamentary Secretary say that, but the interpretation put on the statement by the principal paper supporting him was that he said there had been no rise in prices.
Comment on this
In the last couple of weeks Deputy after Deputy tried to cover up the Parliamentary Secretary and suggested that he had not said it.
Comment on this
I want to say first of all that the Parliamentary Secretary used these words, that prices had remained static for the last three years. He went on to say that—
"the improvement which has occurred in our economic position has been achieved at a time when the cost of living has been kept stable and the prices of essential commodities maintained at the same level at which they stood in mid-August, 1947."
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary was put in here by the Government to make the best of a bad job. I think it most extraordinary, on a Bill of this nature, at a time which the Taoiseach described yesterday in Wexford as so serious, to make that sort of speech.
Comment on this
The Deputy is entitled to speak without interruption. If anything he says is not correct it can be corrected afterwards.
Comment on this
The trouble is that what I am saying is correct, but they want to deny it and they want to try to put me off the track. Deputy Davin is now saying that the Minister for Social Welfare did not say that they were going to freeze prices. Perhaps he has ratted.
Comment on this
He said he was going to freeze prices and he gave that undertaking. It is poor comfort to the people to say that they are going to freeze prices at double what they were a year ago. We know that Deputy Davin and other members of the Labour Party are running as fast as they can from these words. They ratted on everything they said before.
Comment on this
They ratted on every promise they made to the people about the cost of living and everything else. They are trying to fool the people a little longer, by opening their mouths wider and making bigger promises about what they are going to do in future. The Minister for Social Welfare promised to freeze prices only three days ago and now Deputy Davin is ratting on that.
Comment on this
To come back to where I started when Deputy Davin interrupted me, what use are the Government going to make of the powers under this Bill to provide essential commodities in a situation in which the Taoiseach said that it would be foolish optimism to think that the international position was not going to interfere with us to our detriment? Surely if that is the situation, we should be making some preparation, but instead of making a preparation for it, instead of asking the people to grow more wheat and beet and to produce more turf, the Minister for Agriculture went down to Connemara and his only solution was to threaten to shove the Twelve Pins into the sea. He also promised that he would make nylons for them out of the seaweed. From the time of Silken Thomas such a speech was never made until Nylon James went down to Connemara. The Clann na Poblachta Party used to advocate a 30 per cent. decrease in the cost of living and free fertilisers for the farmers. Yesterday the Taoiseach was down in Wexford complaining that under the Fianna Fáil Government, during the emergency, the land had been depleted in its essential manurial constituents. What has the Government done about it? Nylon James promised that he will make artificial manures out of the rocks of Connemara, some time between now and Tibb's Eve.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it correct for the Deputy to refer to a Minister as "Nylon James"?
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture went down to Connemara and promised that he would make artificial manures out of the rocks, some time. Clann na Poblachta said that they would give manures free. Yet, what Deputy Davin and Clann na Poblachta and the Minister for Agriculture in fact did was to stop the subsidy that Fianna Fáil had for artificial manures. Now, when the Taoiseach has changed his mind about the war situation, when he no longer thinks it is the mythical war that he denounced Fianna Fáil for talking about a few months ago, he talks about manuring the land and repairing the damage that was done to the land during the emergency.
I ask the Taoiseach to come in here before this debate is over and to give the country some indication of what he means to do in relation to the provision of the essential supplies that we are empowering him to make Orders about under this Bill and what proposals he has to make for the use of land for the production of essential supplies about which also we are empowering him to make Orders. We know that there is nothing being done about encouraging our farmers to produce the wheat that we might so badly require—nothing at all.
Comment on this
You did in my hat. If we were producing more last year, why did we import more wheat?
Comment on this
The Deputy is now trying to make the speech that he was afraid to make on his feet. He got an opportunity to make a speech.
Comment on this
The Government are doing nothing in relation to the production of wheat. The Minister for Agriculture tried to kill wheat production when he came in. He did his damnedest to prevent people from growing wheat. He issued advertisements asking them to grow oats. There was not a word about wheat. He tried to get out of the contract that Fianna Fáil had made with the farmers for the wheat for the following year and he probably would have succeeded in getting his way in that regard from Deputy Davin and Clann na Poblachta if the wheat prices in the world market had not turned upwards.
Nothing is being done either to produce the wheat within the country or even to store wheat. When there was a threatening situation in 1937 or 1938 the Fianna Fáil Government, so much denounced now by Labour and other people, took steps to store various essential supplies. We were denounced then by Deputy Dillon and he is making certain that nobody can accuse him of doing what Fianna Fáil did before the last war, that is, trying to stock up in a reasonable fashion against an uncertain future.
No matter what the Taoiseach says about "foolish and presumptuous optimism", the Government certainly are acting in a foolish and presumptuous way in regard to the essential supplies of which our people may be very badly in need.
That declaration by the Taoiseach is worthy of being repeated in this House. It should have been made in this House because it is a declaration of a state of emergency, which the Taoiseach up to now denied existed. He said in Wexford:—
"It was, however, to misunderstand the events of these years"
—that is the last five years—
"to imagine that the spectre of war made its first menacing appearance only recently in Korea. In one aspect or another that spectre has been haunting the world since the present uneasy peace began."
If that is true, if he really means that Korea is only one of the first incidents in the third world war, his place is to say that in this House and to outline a programme to the House and the country that we should follow to meet the menacing situation. Even Deputy Davin has not the impudence to say in reply to that particular statement of mine that I am talking about a mythical war. Whenever his leader, the Fine Gael Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, opens his mouth, Deputy Davin has to stay quiet.
Comment on this
It is now, I think, admitted by implication by the Parliamentary Secretary that he was wrong when he said there was no rise in prices.
Comment on this
I was not, but the official reporters were here and put it down in black and white and, not only were the official reporters here, but the Independent reporters were here and they stated that he said there was no rise in prices.
Comment on this
I will vote for it. I am waiting for it to give relief to the people outside, not talking about wars.
Comment on this
If Deputy O'Leary does not keep quiet, the Taoiseach will be coming down on him. In Wexford the Taoiseach was talking about foolish optimists who could not see the situation.
Comment on this
What do the Government propose to do in relation to the rise in prices which the Parliamentary Secretary denied existed, a few days ago, but which he now admits, along with Deputy Davin and the Minister for Social Welfare, does exist? What do they propose to do about it? Freeze prices at the present stage.
Comment on this
We will come back to the wages afterwards. They propose to freeze prices. They will only leave the people paying the present exorbitant prices for numbers of essential commodities without any addition to their wages so far as we know or without any additional subsidy from the Government to keep down the cost of essentials. Fianna Fáil had to meet exactly a similar situation as that which this Government is up against. In 1947 prices suddenly started to shoot up. At that time the financial crisis was due to the British putting an end to the Washington Agreement and the free flow of sterling to dollar countries. Prices started to rise.
We could have dodged the situation in the same way as the Parliamentary Secretary is dodging it at the present time. We could have denied there was any rise in prices. We could have dodged the situation in the way the Labour Party prefer to do it by promising to freeze prices. We could have dodged the situation as Clann na Poblachta, Labour and Fine Gael propose to do it by promising to set up a commission, an advisory body, to examine prices some time in the distant future. Instead of doing that, we took our courage in our hands and we did the honest thing. We told the Dáil that there had been an increase in prices; we admitted to the people that there had been an increase and that the only way out of the situation was to collect subsidies from the taxpayers and give them to the consumers. We do not expect a Government formed as the Coalition Government is formed would have the courage to do that. They have been running round in a cage for the past two and a half years. They probably will run round it for three years, no matter what happens to the people. We do not expect them to take any such steps as would indicate that this situation of rapid price increases should be met by subsidies from the State Exchequer which would be collected by taxation.
Apart from the price rise, what are the Government doing in regard to the supply of those essentials which our people must have in peace or war? We had a certain amount of fuel in the Park when we left office. The Government, I think, in order to make a political scandal out of losses, dispersed that turf that we had in the Park at very much below its economic value. They wanted to make the claim that they had lost millions on a Fianna Fáil hare-brained scheme. I remember that last July Deputy O'Higgins talked to me across the House about the dirt that was in the Park—that was the American and African coal. I said to him: "You might be very glad of the dirt yet". Now the dirt in the Park is being hoarded like gold dust; nobody will get it.
If the situation is as the Taoiseach said in Wexford, that anybody could have foreseen it in the past five years, that, in fact, we had no settled conditions and that peace was at present in grave jeopardy, why did the Government within the past three years disperse our reserves of fuel and why were they so contemptuous about our small efforts to build reserves of American and African coal? If the situation was as it now appears to the Taoiseach, why did the Government do their utmost to kill the production of turf? They did everything they possibly could do in that direction. The Minister for Industry and Commerce the year before last shut down the small automatic turf-winning machines and he made a great song and dance here, that if they kept the scheme on, they would have to sell it for 39/6, whereas it cost 41/6; they would have to subsidise machine-won turf to the extent of 2/- a ton.
Instead, they preferred to shut those schemes down and to send our people to England where they could produce British coal. We are paying a subsidy of 25/- a ton to the British Coal Board. Our Government refused to pay a couple of shillings by way of subsidy on Irish turf. If they had only done so they could have kept our people at home. Now we are paying a subsidy of 25/- a ton on English coal. They are employing Irish workers there to dig the coal. We saw in this morning's paper where Mr. Noel Baker, the British Minister of Fuel and Power, stated that he was going to build camps for more Irish workers who would dig coal. What will our Government do in that situation? I do not expect the British Minister of Fuel and Power made that statement in the House of Commons without having some word beforehand as to the attitude of the Government here.
Comment on this
He had no word whatever. The implication behind that statement has no foundation, and the Deputy knows it. Whatever statement the British Minister made, he made it entirely independently.
Comment on this
Therefore there was no conversation with this Government with regard to the recruitment of Irish workers to fill these camps?
Comment on this
If there were no such conversations, there might have been some conversations with the workers in Ireland with the object of employing them to dig turf.
Comment on this
We were thousands of workers short in the turf camps this year. We published advertisements time and again.
Comment on this
Deputy Flynn was speaking about people from the ends of Kerry who were offered a job in Kildare. When Fianna Fáil were in office those people were offered jobs to dig turf at their own doorsteps. Much as I want to see the machine-won turf scheme going ahead as rapidly as possible, if we are to deal with this situation we will have to try and encourage everybody to produce fuel and other essentials of life where they can best produce them, and that is as near as possible to their homes. The solution for a fuel emergency next year will not be found in offering somebody from Connemara or Kerry or Donegal, who has family ties, who has to run his own household, a job digging turf in Kildare. It will be found in giving him employment in Kerry or Galway or Donegal.
The Minister for Social Welfare had the impudence last week to talk about the excess corporation profits tax. Three and four years ago the Minister for Social Welfare, Deputy Davin and Deputy O'Leary were ranting round the country as to what they would do with the excess corporation profits tax. When Fianna Fáil took off that tax, following a similar tax being taken off by the British Labour Government in England, we were denounced as racketeers and the friends of racketeers. It was said that we were giving back £3,500,000 to the people who had fleeced the consumers of the country. Well, if we gave back £3,500,000 to the racketeers who had fleeced the consumers of the country, it can be said that Deputy Davin and Deputy O'Leary gave back at least £12,000,000 or £14,000,000 to them, and there is not a mumbling word out of them about it.
Comment on this
There is not a word from them about the iniquity of their own Government, which gave £14,000,000 to these racketeers. It is only when the Minister for Social Welfare gets into a political difficulty, of having to cover up the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, that he comes in here and rants, as he used to rant, about the racketeers who were fleecing the consumers, and now says that he is going, at some future date, to impose the excess corporation profits tax on them again. He will in my hat.
The Minister for Social Welfare and Deputy Davin have kept as meek as mice about the excess corporation profits tax for the last three years, although they had made very definite promises to the people that, if they were returned even as a strong Party, they would see that it went back. If Deputy Davin wants some quotations as to the many occasions on which that statement was made by the Minister for Social Welfare, and others, I will give them to him. The statements were made all through the country, from one end of it to another. They spoke about the excess corporation profits tax, and of what they would do if only they had the power. During the last three years the Labour Party had absolute power to insist, if they wanted to, on that tax being put back. If they insisted the Fine Gael people would have surrendered, but the Labour Party are as meek as mice now. They are going to try and fool the people coming up to another general election, because we are in the straight for another general election, as we can see by the various hedge hoppings that are going on over there.
Comment on this
We are, as I say, in the straight for a general election. We can see all the shifting that is going on over on those benches. The Minister for Social Welfare comes into the Dáil and opens his mouth as wide as ever about all that he is going to do at some future date. They had the power to do it within the last three years and they did not do it, although they promised the people that they would do it.
Comment on this
I want to call the attention of the Chair to the fact that Deputy O'Leary, on three occasions, has broken the order of the Chair not to interrupt. Deputy Davin, of course, like all the rest of the Labour members, is quite prepared to play the game for another few months, or even another year, and so they will continue to promise the people what they are going to do some time in the future in the hope that, in that way, they will scrounge a few votes at the next general election. The Minister for Social Welfare not only said all that he was going to do about the excess corporation profits tax, but he had the temerity to say that, when the present Government came into office, they sought to make amends to the workers for all the sufferings which Fianna Fáil had imposed on them. They started off, he said, to provide compensation by a generous approach; they had given increases to public servants and to workers generally, showing that their policy was to enable the workers to get compensation for the increase in the cost of living. What are the facts of the matter? They are that the Labour Party, the Fine Gael Party and all the other elements which go to make up the Coalition were growling about the standard of wages and the standard of remuneration under Fianna Fáil. They came into office on 18th February, and from that date until the Minister for Finance introduced his Budget, not a single penny of an increase was given to any public servant. Not only that, but the Minister for Finance said, in his Budget statement, and it was applauded by Deputy Davin, that:—
"The substantial wage and salary increases already secured by all classes of workers"
—that was under the naughty Fianna Fáil Government—
"with such further advantages as shorter hours, paid holidays, children's allowances and other increases in social services, have gone as far as is possible, in present circumstances, to meet the claims of social justice."
That was what the Minister for Finance said three months after the Coalition came into office, three months after they had completed the campaign in which they had denounced Fianna Fáil as being unjust because of the standard of wages, remuneration, salaries and so on; but three months afterwards the Minister for Finance came into the Dáil and said that the standard of wages, remuneration and salaries were as high as social justice demanded. That statement by the Minister for Finance was applauded by Deputy Davin. Now, three years after that event, the Minister for Social Welfare has the temerity to say that when the Government came in they increased the remuneration of civil servants and others. Now that Deputy Davin is going out he might send in a couple of others to take his place.
Comment on this
Now that you have mentioned that I will ask for a count so that we may get in some of the intelligentsia to listen to the Deputy.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present—
Comment on this
The other night, when Deputy Allen was speaking about the Prices and Efficiency Bill which was brought in by Fianna Fáil and asking why the present Government did not go ahead with it, although the Labour Party had voted for the Second Reading of it, Deputy Larkin, who is the Leader of the Labour Party in the House, I understand, said that it was because it was no good. As I pointed out to Deputy Larkin, the Labour Party had voted for the Prices and Efficiency Bill and for the last three years they have been content to leave the law as it stood when Fianna Fáil left office. They were content to allow the Prices and Efficiency Bill to go by the board. Now, when we are coming into the straight for a general election——
Comment on this
Now, when we are coming down the straight, they are making a promise that they will set up an advisory body under this present Bill and that that is going to cure the evils of the prices rise. This particular section in this Bill has a curious history. There was no word about it when the Bill was introduced. At that time the Government had decided to take the line that there was in fact no prices increase, that anybody who thought there had been was under a delusion, just as the people last July, according to the Taoiseach, were under a delusion if they thought there was any danger of war. But, when it came to the point that they saw they could not bluff it out, the Government decided to introduce this section of 20 or 30 words in the Bill to deal with the situation. That section is to replace the Prices and Efficiency Bill which contained many clauses.
Fianna Fáil had long experience of trying to wrestle with prices and decided in 1946-47 that the proper way to deal with fair prices, fair to the manufacturer and fair to the consumer, was by the Prices and Efficiency Bill. We all know that, if we are to have commodities manufactured here and expect people to put their money into machinery and premises and to hire skilled people, they must get a reasonable profit. The Prices and Efficiency Bill gave the manufacturers a right to have their case examined before a conclusion was arrived at. It also gave the consumers a right to have their case examined. In order that that might be done on a basis of justice, not only to the consumers, but also to the people who had risked their money in investing in Irish business, a long and very complicated series of clauses was necessary in the Bill which the Fianna Fáil Government put before the Dáil. But now, as a last resort in order to meet a political situation and with nothing else but a political purpose in view, the Government throw in this section which they thought of after they had introduced the Bill. They withdrew the original Bill and then threw this Bill at us. The clause reads:—
"A Minister may from time to time by Order provide for the establishment and constitution of bodies of persons to advise him in relation to all or any of the powers conferred on or delegated to him by virtue of the principal Act and any such Order may contain such ancillary and supplementary provisions as the Minister thinks proper."
Even the word "prices" is not mentioned in that section. Every time the Government have got into a difficulty since they came into office they set up an advisory body or a commission. They ranted about emigration, and when they discovered in their first year of office that emigration had started again, they set up the Commission on Emigration. When people complained about the price of flour, they set up an inquiry into flour milling. On several other occasions they have met difficulties and criticisms by setting up commissions or advisory bodies. They could not handle the situation in the Department of Industry and Commerce even with a Minister and Parliamentary Secretary. They hesitated to handle and deal with the various propositions put up for the starting of industries or even to deal with the list of industries which had been left to them by Fianna Fáil. When they were being pressed they set up another advisory body. They used to be great people for doing things in one day with their mouths when in opposition, but for three years, or 1,000 days, they kept quiet and did nothing to see that prices were reasonably just to all concerned. But when we are coming into the straight for a general election, they throw in this little clause as another promise.
What would be the result of setting up an advisory body in regard to prices? They will advise. The situation has been apparent to everybody that prices were going to rise, even without war, after the devaluation of the £, although that was denied by the Government and by every Minister of the Government. They did nothing about it. It will take them some time to set up an advisory body and the advisory body will be as slow to act as the Industrial Development Authority is slow to act. They have been at it for 18 months and nobody can get a reply out of them about anything. It will be the same thing with this advisory body in connection with prices if it is set up.
Why cannot the Government act up to their responsibilities? After all, they have been three years in office and if the situation is as the Taoiseach described it in Wexford yesterday, it is time for the Government to live up to their responsibilities and act instead of trying to pass the buck on to some advisory body or another. If there are undue price rises, the Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister for Industry and Commerce have at their disposal officials who are able to tell them whether there are unjust price rises or not. It is up to the Government to take action themselves now. They should have taken it long ago, but it is up to them at least to take it now instead of passing it on to an advisory body to be done some time next year or the year after.
If they do not want to deal with the situation, if they are not men enough to act up to their responsibilities in that way, let them face the situation by a prices subsidy. Of course, we know that they do not like the collection of taxes. They set out to borrow £12,000,000 this year which they should have collected in taxes. Another £1,000,000 or £2,000,000 would be very little extra for a prices subsidy. I want to end on the note on which I began: it is due to the House and to the country, when the Taoiseach has so radically changed his mind in regard to the international situation, as he has done in the last few months, that he should come into the House now, not only to describe the situation as he sees it, but to give some outline to the people as to how best that situation can be met. The people are prepared to co-operate with any Government in the present situation in order to ensure that we get together a better supply of essentials than we have at the present time. All during the war, when things were very much worse than they are at the present time and when we had to appeal to the people to make great sacrifices both with regard to prices, wages and everything else, the people co-operated with the Government when the Government dealt candidly and honestly with them. Fianna Fáil never tried to deny that there were increases in prices when, in fact, prices had increased. We took the unpopular step, politically disastrous but nationally very beneficial, of asking the people to meet the situation that arose in 1947.
Let us hope that even if Fine Gael have lost all respect for the people and are prepared to tell them any untruth in regard to the world situation and the prices situation, some small group in the Coalition Government will bring pressure to bear upon the Government. After all, the Clann na Poblachta Party had ten members returned on their promise to the people that they would reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent. Surely they have some little sense of shame left in them. Surely they will not stand idly by when the cost of living, instead of being reduced by 30 per cent., has in fact been doubled in relation to some essential commodities. They claimed that they were so powerful they made the Government introduce the Republic of Ireland Bill. We know that the legal authorities have said that that made no change; that, in fact, there was no change from the Constitution of 1937. But the Clann na Poblachta Party made a great song and dance about it. Let them now, if it is in fact true that they brought pressure to bear to get the label changed, do something with their powers to force the Fine Gael Party to meet the present situation and make provision to meet its disastrous consequences so far as those with low wages and incomes are concerned. Indeed the farmers are also concerned. I do not know how they will meet the increased cost of living in certain essentials accompanied as it has been by decreases in the prices they are getting for their commodities.
Comment on this
The Deputy from North Dublin is concerned, of course, with the graziers. They have done fairly well. Let us take any example. Let us take the whole farming economy. Under the Fianna Fáil régime eggs were fetching 3/- per dozen. In a few weeks from now they will fetch 2/- per dozen. At the same time as eggs fall from 3/- to 2/- the price of maize has gone up from £18 per ton to £27 per ton, or £30 per ton in certain parts of the country. Does anybody think that the average small farmer whose ready cash is mostly procured from the sale of eggs will be in a better position to pay twice as much for blankets as he did under Fianna Fáil when his eggs go down from 3/- to 2/- per dozen and the price of his feeding stuffs goes up by 60 or 70 per cent.?
Comment on this
You know he is. Can it be proved? Get up and prove it. Go down the country and tell the farmers that.
Comment on this
Are you forgetting the price of poultry and the increased production. You are only killing truth.
Comment on this
The 3/- per dozen will be reduced to 2/- and the price of feeding stuffs is up by 60 per cent.
Comment on this
We are getting feeding stuffs by borrowing dollars. In my opinion it is a crazy idea to put a dollar debt on this country for the purpose of gaining a sterling asset. The Parties on the Government Benches were growling about sterling assets when Fianna Fáil was in power. In the last year or so they have become so keen on sterling assets that they are actually borrowing dollars in order to procure them. They are borrowing dollars to buy maize and to sell eggs at two-thirds of the price that Fianna Fáil got for them in order to build up their sterling assets.
I hope the Taoiseach will explain to the country, before this debate concludes, the situation as he sees it to-day, and I hope that he will ask all our people to co-operate with the Government in ensuring that this Bill will not be in vain, and that steps will be taken to secure an increase in essential commodities so that, whether there is peace or war, our people shall have the security of having within the country a fair supply of essentials at reasonable prices.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary should have been called when this debate opened to-day. He was not called. I call on Deputy O'Leary now to conclude his statement.
Comment on this
The only thing Deputy Aiken has told us about is the coming general election and what certain people said in the last general election. Deputy Aiken's Supplementary Budget in 1947 put him and his Party on the other side of the House. I want to quote a statement made by the ex-Taoiseach in 1947. It appears at col. 389 of Vol. 108 of Official Reports, 8th October, 1947. The ex-Taoiseach asked the trade unions at that time not to support the demands of the workers for increased wages. I hope Deputy Aiken will tell the people to-morrow where they can get eggs for 2/- a dozen. If he does that we will have thousands of people with baskets looking for the eggs at 2/- a dozen. I wonder how he can make such a statement when we all know that eggs are 5/6 a dozen in the City of Dublin at the moment. Does he think the farmers are prepared to feed their hens for nothing?
We all admit that the cost of living has gone up in the last few months, and the trade unions of this city and the congresses of both unions are awaiting this measure, which should have been passed, not this week, but last week, in order to prevent profiteers from fleecing the people. Fianna Fáil, of course, do not want prices controlled, because the people who gave them £50,000 in the 1948 election would not support them the next time if they supported a Bill to freeze and to control prices.
Deputy Aiken talked about war. He came in here when this Government was formed and he asked the Minister for Defence what he was going to do about the men who were carrying rifles down in Dundalk. Now he has gone over to the war in the Far East. I thought we were going to have immediate and terrible war here at the time he spoke of men carrying rifles in Dundalk. It is deplorable for any workingman in this House who knows the needs of the people to have to listen to statements such as were made by Deputy Bartley last week when he said that our people were well fed and well clothed. That just shows all he knows about the needs of the people. We have thousands of people throughout the length and breadth of the Twenty-Six Counties in a very bad way, yet these people have to listen to foolish talk of that kind by ex-Ministers who had the control of the country in their hands for 16 years.
Foolish questions are repeatedly put down here asking Ministers for information on matters which do not matter one bit to the people. Of course, one does not mind what anybody says when one remembers the statement made by Deputy de Valera, the ex-Taoiseach, on a certain occasion in regard to which I have a cutting here from the Sunday Independent. The statement was made in reply to me when Deputy de Valera was referring to speeches made during the general election. I reminded him of the statement he made in Tipperary before the election about breaking stones, and he replied: “It does not matter what I said”. What Deputy Aiken said certainly does not matter when we have the Leader of the Party making a statement of that kind. Surely we ought to get better advice from members of the Opposition. If they were honest with the people they would vote without hesitation for this Bill. The country is crying out for it in order to deal with profiteers who are fleecing the unfortunate poor, above all others. The man with the money does not care, as he will always be able to get his loaf.
I have here a cutting from a paper of April 26th last which contains a letter written by a man dealing with food rationing. In that letter he said that tea was rationed at one time at half an ounce and that there was a universal complaint as to the quality of the tea. In June, 1947, the price was increased from 1/2 to 4/10, but if one was prepared to go into the black market and pay 25/- to 30/- a pound it could be got all right. Have the members of the last Government any conscience when they look back on these matters? Sugar was rationed, according to the writer of this letter, at a quarter of a pound at that time, and people had to resort to the black market, whereas to-day additional supplies are available at a not unreasonable price. In regard to bacon, he says:—
"This formerly flourishing industry was virtually wiped out of existence by the Fianna Fáil regulation. During the war the common rasher was almost unobtainable—a luxury."
Is that not true? Is it not a fact that under the Fianna Fáil Government the people could not get one half-pound of rashers except in the black market? They allowed that to go on and when the new Minister for Agriculture came into office, he had to take steps in Dublin to prevent the operations of what were known as the silent slaughter houses. That was allowed to go on under the leadership of Deputy de Valera, the man who said in 1947:—
"The Government is not giving any guarantee that the cost of living may not rise."
Listening to Deputy Aiken to-day I was reminded of the time when he said he did not care if all the damn ships were at the bottom of the sea. I was reminded also of the statement of another ex-Minister who said that they had whipped John Bull. Now we hear them crying out about British coal. The people of this country are really suffering from the effects of petty statements by political Parties in this House in their efforts to score off one another. We heard some references to the speech made by the Taoiseach in Wexford last night. I was listening to him in Wexford and the people of Wexford were listening to him. The biggest people in the county were there and there is nothing wrong in what he said. If Deputy Aiken can make no speech except to quote what the Taoiseach stated, he is doing a lot of good because the man who says something that annoys other people is bound to produce some good eventually. We heard the Deputy refer to the condition in which the country was when we took over. We did not find it in a very healthy condition. The Deputy should remember that in 1947 when he was Minister and when Deputy Byrne and myself with a number of other Deputies made a plea on behalf of old age pensioners, Deputy Aiken stated that the country could not afford it, even though they had brought in a Supplementary Budget and imposed additional taxes. The Coalition Government was formed soon afterwards and the taxes imposed under the Supplementary Budget were removed. In spite of that £6,000,000 was found for the relief of old age pensioners and widows and orphans, money which could not be found when Fianna Fáil was in power.
I think a Coalition Government is the best type of Government for any country because you have the voice of the people expressed both in the Cabinet and on all sides of the House. Under a one-man Party Government such as had been controlling this country for some years prior to the present Government, the Deputies in that Party were scarcely ever allowed to get up and speak. I scarcely ever heard their voices until they went into opposition. Now they are at the old game of mud-slinging across the House. We want this Bill passed quickly in the interests of the plain people so that we can freeze prices. What did the last Government do? They brought in a Standstill (Wages) Order, although Deputy Aiken said at that time in the Dáil that prices were rising. They were rising in 1947 when a standstill Order was passed by a majority to freeze the wages of the workers and it was only when the change of Government took place that 11/- was granted to the workers.
Comment on this
It was there. Why should it ever have been there when you allowed black-marketing and everything else to go on? We hear a lot about blankets. There were blankets sent to European and other nations in 1946 that some people in this country needed. Millions of blankets and food of all kinds were sent out while our own people were in need.
Comment on this
Does that arise? Otherwise, we will have a debate on the value of national charity and the circumstances under which charity is granted.
Comment on this
My belief is that charity always begins at home. We should look after our own people. Deputy Bartley also said that we should keep the goods for our own people but he did not advocate that when he was in power. Everybody realises that something must be done to control prices. The Government and the Deputies on this side of the House know what is happening in the country. Every day there is a new increase in prices. That is because there is nothing to control prices. I would suggest to the Opposition that the sooner this Bill is passed the better it will be for the people who are looking to us to save them from the effect of high prices. It is all right for organised workers who can go on strike and demand an increase in wages and get it, but we must consider those who are not organised, the aged, the small pensioners, some of them I.R.A. pensioners or British pensioners who are trying to exist on small pensions and who can get no increase. We want to come to the aid of that class by curtailing prices.
I know of a certain place where yesterday the price of coal was advanced by 1/-. Before 6 p.m., one of the clerks in the establishment was sent out to give back the 1/- to the people who were overcharged because the directors became afraid, knowing that they had done wrong.
That is happening in regard to other commodities. Every day in the week there are increases in prices. The price of goods is increasing but wages are not increasing. That is our biggest grievance, as members of the Labour Party representing workers. We want to protect the workers, but it seems that Fianna Fáil are on the other ditch; they are more interested in the industrialists, the people who are building up funds and putting thousands in the banks at the expense of the working class.
We were told that Fianna Fáil were the poor man's Government. If they were, they should join now in the Coalition and pass this Bill without further discussion or opposition so as to give the Government the power to say to those who are responsible for increasing prices: "You will not rob us any longer by high prices." If that were done, there would be no unrest in the country or in the trade union movement. If a man gets an increase of five shillings in his wages it is no good if the prices of the goods that he needs for his home and his family also increase. There are clothing manufacturers and shopkeepers who do not know what to charge for a shirt, a suitlength or children's clothes. There is no control and they can do what they like. The Government must stop that. It is happening throughout the country. Deputies may call names across the House about the Coalition and attack the Minister for Agriculture, but I do not think the farmers will fall out with the Minister for Agriculture. As far as I can see, he is the best Minister for Agriculture they ever had, because he is getting the prices.
We want to control the prices of goods when they go into the shop and across the counter. Deputies opposite have talked about the Act they had in 1947. It was like other Acts. It was only on paper. It is all right to say: "We were going to do this and that". They did not do it. We are asking them now to help us so that we can do it, because, without co-operation, we can get nowhere. This country cannot go on unless there is co-operation in this House. We are all sent here by business people, workers, small farmers and others to voice their grievances here. First of all, we must be honest with the country. Deputies have quoted ex-Ministers' speeches and the speech made by the Taoiseach last night in Wexford. As long as he is head of the State they will have to recognise him as such. That is democracy. He is the people's leader, whether it is for five years or ten years, as the case may be, and anyone who slanders him does not do any good to his own Party. We could all make use of slander if we wanted to do it.
I hope this Bill will become law before the Recess. It is most necessary. If we are to do anything for those we represent we must control prices. People are crying out for that. Fianna Fáil do not want it. They are opposing it. Why are they doing that? They are talking about the cost of living. Deputies are asking us to give a bigger price for milk and, at the same time as they are putting down motions to increase the price of milk, they are making speeches about controlling prices and saying that the cost of living is going up.
As far as I am concerned, as long as this Government help the class that I represent, I will keep them here. took a decision on that. They have done a certain amount of good up to now. The price of goods is going beyond the reach of a certain class. We must stop that immediately. So long as the cost of living goes up, wages will have to follow; otherwise strikes will take place. The most necessary thing to do is to keep the cost of living down.
I do not like to see the Parliamentary Secretary being attacked by some ex-Ministers and other Deputies. It is very unfortunate that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is not able to be here to answer for his Department. Deputies should be honest and fair with the Parliamentary Secretary and he should not be placed in a false position. He quoted the figures as he found them. Of course, the papers flashed it: "The Parliamentary Secretary says there is no rise in the cost of living." That was very good propaganda. He did not say that. We all know the cost of living has increased in the past few months and it is still increasing and that is because there is no control of prices as regards the traders. We want to see price control.
The trade unions are crying out for some such control. According to a trade union publication, they would welcome the inclusion of a provision for the establishment of a prices advisory tribunal with consumer representation. They say, however, that the work of the tribunal might prove to be an impossible task if prices are allowed to continue their upward trend until the tribunal is established, and the Irish trade union congresses strongly insist that the Government should freeze prices as from the date of the introduction of this Bill.
Comment on this
If Deputy O'Leary's picture of the state of the country is correct, it is a damning indictment of the Government. They have been in office almost three years. They have all the power they require. So far as prices are concerned they have a war measure, a measure that the Minister who brought it in described as one that should not be placed in the power of any Minister in peace time—that only war could justify. They have had ample power to exercise and we have the result as pictured by Deputy O'Leary.
I admit it is hard to follow Deputy O'Leary's mental acrobatics, but so far as I could follow him he painted a very bleak picture of the position to-day. That Act is there for the Government to use. Every Party in the Government Benches promised not alone to keep the cost of living level, but to reduce it. What actions did they take when they got power? Their first action was to give back to the people who have been found to be profiteering the licences that were revoked by the former Minister. Their next action was, according to the Minister, to withdraw the pip-squeaks—that they were not going to have them any longer.
I am very sorry the Minister is not here. I would be glad if he were, because I want to refer to certain things. I hope he is well on the way to recovery, and that he will soon be back. When he was here he referred to pip-squeaks— that was shortly after he took over office—and he said they were going to withdraw them. That was a nice term to apply to the inspectors in the Department whose job it was to see that price control was enforced. The Government then remitted prison sentences and fines that had been imposed by the courts for breaches of the price control regulations.
That was how the Government set out to keep their promise to reduce the cost of living. With that beginning, one could naturally expect certain things to happen. Prices began to rise. The Parliamentary Secretary or members of the Government can keep repeating as long as they like that prices remained stable until August of this year, but they will not get one housewife to agree with them. Last May, on the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce, I gave a list of articles that had risen in price and not one of them was contradicted. I challenged the Minister on his complacency and I pointed out that it was quite evident last May that prices were again rising.
In these circumstances this is what the Government did, and I would like Deputies, Deputy O'Leary in particular, to note this. Where commodities were rising in price the action of the Government was to de-control. Thirty-six different items in the controlled list were de-controlled since the Government came into office. In every case the price rose immediately. The Government were not going to be unpopular by admitting a rise in prices. Instead, they de-controlled items in the price list and tried to escape responsibility in that way.
Do not think for a moment that the public have been fooled by this device. I have been wondering, as a matter of fact, if some of the Deputies opposite think the people are being fooled by the arguments that have been put forward. The people of Dublin, who are very concerned in this matter, learned last year how prices were going up. Last winter in Dublin eggs and potatoes reached a record figure. That is what happened under a Government that promised to reduce, not to mind keeping stable, the cost of living. I know there is a feeling on the opposite benches, particularly among Labour Deputies, that election promises do not matter. That belief has actually been given expression to here and I commented on it before. The chickens are now coming home to roost and Deputies will know all about it when the opportunity offers. That will not be long either if I am to judge the temper of the people.
We have had from several members of the Labour Party an attempt to excuse the action of the Government on the question of controlling prices. The excuse was that they were operating the Fianna Fáil machinery. When they went before the people they gave them to understand that we had failed absolutely in that respect and that they had the remedy and would make sure that there would be no further profiteering. But the only action they have taken is that which I have already described. In view of the definite promises which all the Parties supporting the Government had given to the people on this question of price control, one would imagine that they would set out immediately to put the great plans which they had set before the people into operation—that they would find out the defects and cure them. They had not even to do that, because before the election they promised the people that they would produce the remedies. But three years have passed and the Fianna Fáil machinery is still in operation. Whose fault is that? As far as I can see, it means that there were not any brains in the Government to improve the measure which was there to make it more effective. I am not saying that in any disparaging way, because the Bill before us is so drastic that I think anybody would find it hard to make it better.
Deputy O'Leary seems to be under the impression that this Bill is going to make the price control machinery more effective. According to him, it is going to do wonders. The only change which it is going to make in what has been in operation up to this is to appoint an advisory committee before which applications for increases will be heard in public. That may be all right, but how is it going to affect the machinery of price control?
Heretofore, when people got permission to increase prices they, I have no doubt, had to prove their cases up to the hilt, and they will be able to prove their cases in public also. The only result that I see from this Bill is that we are going to have further delays in price fixing, because this advisory committee will have to take a lot of time going into details. The committee is to act in an advisory capacity. It will advise the Minister. In practice, that will mean that its advice will go back to the officials who, hitherto, have had the fixing of prices. That as I say will mean more delays. The Labour people have been claiming that it was the Fianna Fáil machinery which they have had to operate. Therefore, I cannot see for the life of me who they think they are fooling. What were they doing for the last three years? In view of the promises which they had made to the public, it was their duty to set about remedying the situation at once.
There have been several references to the ration of 2 ozs. of butter. Everybody knows that when that ration was fixed we had passed through the most abnormal winter in living memory. What would happen if such a thing should happen this year? We have had three or four years of full and plenty, but when that ration was fixed it followed on six years of scarcity, due to the war. Deputy O'Leary does not seem to realise that, or that at that time we were in the centre of operations. If conditions now were as bad as they were at that time I am afraid there would be a great many other things much worse than the 2 ozs. of butter. Now, we are beginning to come up against what seems to be a serious world position. In that situation our fuel position is bad. There was a period in this House when we had jeers and gibes from the Deputies opposite about the extravagance and waste of having fuel dumps in the Park. I remember dealing with Deputy Michael O'Higgins about that myself. I wonder how he feels about it now?
We have not yet reached a war situation, and we are not in the centre of operations as we were before. The Government should be very glad if they had those fuel dumps in the Park now. If they had any sense, they would never have parted with them. They sold them off at any price just to gain political advantage. As I have said, the chickens are coming home to roost.
We are the only country in the world which is rationed in bread. The excuse given is to keep it from being fed to greyhounds. That seems to me to be like getting a sledge to swat a fly. During the last four years this country had not much trouble in getting supplies. Yet we have bread rationing. I should like to refer to some of the off-the-ration supplies. We have before us the report of the Bread and Flour Inquiry Committee. We can gather from that report how every item that can be bought off the ration imposes concealed taxation.
This report was issued in 1949 and the committee worked on 1949 figures. On page 93, Table 4, there are, however, some interesting figures. We are told that the economic unsubsidised price for white bread at that period was 11?d. per 2 lb. loaf. The price charged on the 1st January, 1949, for the white loaf was 1/-, so that there was a concealed tax of ? of a penny on every 2 lb. loaf. Just before that the people of Dublin were allowed to go through a fortnight's strike for the sake of a farthing a loaf, but there was a concealed tax of ? of a penny on the white loaf. The committee tells us that the economic price for white flour was 6/7¾ per stone. The price charged was 7/-, or a concealed tax of 4¼d. per stone. The economic price of butter was 3/4¼ per lb. and the price charged was 3/6, or 1¾d. per lb. concealed tax on butter. The economic price for tea was 4/7½ per lb., and the price charged was 5/6, or 10½d. per lb. concealed tax.
Deputies will notice that I am taking the prices charged at that period, 1949. Since then there has been another 6d. put on. I have not the figures, but unless there is an increase of 6d. per lb. in the cost, there is a concealed tax of 1/4½ per lb. on tea now. The economic price of sugar was 6d. per lb. and the price charged at that time was 7½d., or a concealed tax of 1½d. Unless there has been an increase in the cost price of sugar, the tax is 2d. now with the increased price to the consumer.
Labour Deputies try to make out that they are the real watchdogs for the poor. I know that we on these benches have the reputation of being the profiteers, but the Labour Party like to boast that they are the watchdogs for the workers and the underdogs. With no attempt to control prices while all that was happening, I wonder how they carried out their obligations. Those figures which I have extracted from that report prove that, in spite of the tremendous increase in taxation that we know about, there was a whole series of concealed taxes on the necessaries of life for the people. Nobody will say that, five years after the war ended, we should still be tied down to a meagre ration of those commodities. In some cases, the ration is the same as it was during the war, and people have not alone to pay an increased price, but pay a concealed tax on every one of these necessaries which they have to buy in order to keep themselves going in anything like normal circumstances.
In various speeches Deputies have tried to make out that Fianna Fáil put a standstill Order on wages and never allowed any increase in wages, and that any increases which have been given were given since the present Government came into office. Again, I would ask, whom do they think they are fooling? We all know that even during the war there were increases while the standstill Order was in force. We all know that as soon as the war ended the Labour Court was set up, that the standstill Order was withdrawn, and that the biggest part of the increases which the workers got was given while Fianna Fáil were in power. Since the present Government came into office the only increase which has been given, so far as I am aware, amounts to 11/-. Why an attempt should be made to fool the people in that way is beyond my understanding.
Deputy O'Leary quoted the ex-Taoiseach about not giving any guarantee that the cost of living would not rise. Later on he told us that we must be honest with the people. But he blamed the ex-Taoiseach for being honest with the people and he supports the present Government who made the most lavish promises that they would reduce the cost of living and who have not been able to keep it stable. The Deputy had to admit that prices are going up now, but he supports them and talks at the same time about being honest. One thing that must be said about the ex-Taoiseach is that when he said that he was honest. He was not playing politics or fooling the people. The Deputy told us that the ex-Taoiseach would not give any guarantee. But the guarantees were given by the people opposite. Are they being carried out? We know that as a result of it we are embarking on another series of increases which undoubtedly will be followed by further increased prices and the vicious circle will go on unless something like a standstill Order is introduced. The British Government, a Labour Government, after trying the other system are now back to the standstill as a result of their experiences. I am one who suffered under the standstill Order but I have the sense to know that it was for me the lesser of two evils. Probably some of the Deputies who have talked so volubly about it, if the present situation holds and if the present policy is persisted in, will realise before they are many years older what a godsend the standstill Order was to them instead of being, as they appear to think, an incubus.
The Tánaiste intervened last week and treated us to his usual frothy utterances. Apparently he was brought in because of the way things had developed in relation to this Bill. He proceeded to talk of the manufacturers as if they were profiteers. He told us what he was going to do. I have a recollection that that is not the first time the Tánaiste has told us what he was going to do. I have here a cutting from the Sunday Independent of 23rd January, 1949. He was nearly a year in office at that time. According to this report he said:
"If you saw the balance sheets of some of these companies these boys have certainly got away with money since 1939. While other people were undergoing the hardships of the emergency and suffering the privations of rationing, there was a small group of unscrupulous people lining their pockets thicker and thicker with money raked out of the pockets of the consuming public. I do not stand for an industrial development policy which permits that to happen. I think that in a well-governed country gentlemen of that kind ought to be the guests of the Government in power in the thickest walled jails we have."
On the Government side of the House Deputies can think what they like. Everybody on these benches will deal very severely with any proved profiteering. The Tánaiste spoke on that occasion as if he had definite proof. Two years have elapsed. During those two years the Tánaiste had at his disposal the most drastic powers. He is the deputy-head of the Government. He has a Party behind him which would have helped him to force the Government to take action, if he really meant what he said. But two years later the best he can do is to come along and repeat himself. He is going to do it. If that position really exists, and I doubt very much that there are any people who answer the descriptions given by the Tánaiste, why has the machinery in existence not been used against them during the last three years? Why did the Tánaiste not insist after that public speech that the machinery should be put into operation? Why should he come along now, three years later, and tell us that it is going to be done? There is nothing in this Bill which will confer upon the Government any greater powers to deal with these alleged profiteers. If the Tánaiste had wanted to deal with them, he could have dealt. with them at any time since he took office. I do not think it will produce any good results in relation to the development of our industry for men in the position of the Tánaiste to come along and talk as he did last week about our industrialists and yet not produce a scintilla of proof in support of his statements or take any positive steps to deal with the alleged situation. One is driven to the conclusion that he is either not sincere or the position is not such as he has painted it.
We have tried to point out world development for some time past on these benches. In fact so far as defence is concerned, we have tried to point it out from the very first Estimate. We have tried to show the threatening world position. But we were told by the Taoiseach that he intended to legislate for peace. He seemed to change his mind on that last night. With the threatening situation that faces us we want the help of every individual to bring us through any crisis that may arise. As far as I can see no steps have been taken at all up to this to provide for such a situation of crisis. It ill-becomes the head of the Government to make public speeches like he did, and not follow them up by action.
In my view this Government will only delay matters. If the Government was really in earnest they would put the ordinary powers they possess into operation. I have no objection to their doing it. If they continue on the present line, they will only succeed in making the control of prices much slower. Considering how far upward prices have moved even since last August, I do not think this is the time to start trying to delay control. Instead of getting panicky and sending in the Tánaiste here to make a statement such as that he made last week, they ought to get down to the hard facts of the situation and use the machinery at their disposal where necessary. If it is not effective they can bring in amending legislation to improve it. In doing that they will get the support of this side of the House. Let them get on with the job. Let them get down to the job, even though it is three years late, of fulfilling their promises.
Comment on this
After four or five days' discussion on this matter there is very little left to say that could be considered new. I have heard criticisms from all the speakers on this measure. May I say that none of those criticisms was of a constructive nature? I did not hear anyone make any suggestions as to what should be done now to help those outside to meet the difficulties with which they find themselves faced as a result of the increase in the cost of living. Whatever claim may be made by the experts in relation to the cost-of-living index figure, nobody will deny that the cost of living has gone up. The index figure is wrong, and the sooner it is amended the better it will be.
The experts should get busy and give the House and the public some opportunity of deciding once and for all what the proper figure should be on which to base the cost of living. Take the average Dublin housewife; no matter what she goes out to buy she finds that to-day it is up a halfpenny, to-morrow something else is up a halfpenny and the next day something else is up a penny. Remember, we have on the agenda here notice of motion under the name of a Fianna Fáil Deputy asking for an increase in the price of milk.
If we are to have an increase in the price of milk so that producers may get a fair profit—and anybody who produces an article is, of course, entitled to a fair profit—we should remember that that is one of the main items in the diet of a working-class family and that it will mean an increase of 1/6 per week in the household budget of a man with four or five children. From that angle, it should be remembered that we cannot have it both ways. If Deputies demand an increase in the price of certain commodities, they must remember that automatically it means an increase in the cost of living. We are also told that the price of gas will be increased shortly. Every tenement house in Dublin and every workman's cottage has a gas stove and if the price of gas is increased the outlay of the man with four in the family will be increased by another 1/6 a week and therefore, through no fault of the Government, the cost of living will go up by at least 3/- per week so far as gas and milk alone are concerned. Can anybody from the opposite benches who has criticised the Government suggest a remedy? Gas workers because of the increased cost of living have had to demand increased wages. We are told again that the price of fuel is going up and that increase will again mostly hit those who are paid small wages. It will add another 1/- per week to the family budget, probably before Christmas.
I want to put it to the Government that if any Labour Court or inquiry decides that the cost of living has gone up to an extent which would warrant say an increase of 12/6 a week for any group of wage earners, who because of their organisation and because of the fact that they can embarrass the consuming public by going on strike, are able to enforce their demands, the Government should make an Order that that increase should apply uniformly to the lower-pay wage groups— to the Gárdaí, members of the Army, postmen, teachers and others. Above all the Government should not forget pensioned teachers and Guards who have a very limited income. It is not right or proper that such increases should be confined to workers who can create a certain amount of inconvenience to the public if their demands are not conceded. The other classes I have mentioned have to buy the same milk, the same coal and the same gas as workers who are granted increases. The Government would be doing a noble day's work in deciding that an increase of, say, 15/- granted to any particular group because of the increased cost of living, should be applied to other wage groups who have to suffer the same hardships.
Many civil servants, for instance, are not able to live on the same small incomes which they enjoyed five or six years ago. We all know that the salary or the pension of five years ago is not able to purchase the same amount of goods nowadays. For instance, I remember a Gárda saying to me about two years ago in a district not far outside Dublin: "Alderman, if we could cause the same amount of inconvenience as people who are in a position to strike, we would get an increase in our pay and we would have got it long before now." I think that the time has come when the question of the pay of the Gárdaí should be reconsidered.
The cost of living has also gone up for classes such as blind pensioners and old age pensioners. I admit that they were given a small increase about two years ago but it has been admitted by every member of the House that the cost of living has gone up enormously since. As I say, these people cannot enforce their demands in the way that workers who are organised can, by submitting the general public to the inconvenience of a strike.
One further matter I should like to bring to the Minister's notice is that people who have been moved to new houses in areas such as Donnycarney, St. Brigid's Gardens, Reynolds House, Ballyfermot and Cabra have now to pay twice and three times the rent that they paid before they were moved. That, of course, is largely due to the differential rents system. It is a heartbreak and is the biggest grievance these people have at present and rents should be reduced.
Comment on this
The point I want to make is that rents influence the cost of living. I will not refer to corporation rents again. An increase in rents and rates is felt more than a penny extra on a pint of milk or on a tin of sardines.
Take the price of fish. The working class people in Dublin cannot buy fresh fish. They look for substitutes. During the emergency they were in the habit of buying sardines or tinned salmon as a substitute for fresh fish. They find that the price of these commodities has increased by a couple of pence. These are problems which the Government must face.
I am sorry that the Opposition is not more favourably disposed to this measure. On the whole, I think we ought to give the Government the power to appoint this committee. This is not being done because Fianna Fáil forgot to do it. In their time they had certain proposals that met a certain situation. It is now found necessary to appoint this tribunal. I hope the Minister will insist on having the housewife with a large family represented on the tribunal. There are various women's organisations in this city. There are the Irish Housewives' Association, the Legal Adoption Society, the Save the Children Society, the Child Welfare Society. Members of these societies can inform the Government about the cost of living better than any member of this House. I implore the Government to get the views of these organisations when they are dealing with the matter. I implore the Government not to forget the old age pensioners, the widows and orphans, the teachers, the Gárdaí and those people who have to wear clothes that are brushed to a polish because they cannot afford to pay the prices of new ones.
Will anyone in this House tell me why the cost of boot repairs has increased by 50 per cent? Is that due to an increase in the cost of material or what is the cause? I have heard that it costs 7/- to sole and heel a pair of boots.
Comment on this
The complaint has been made that the cost of boot repairs has increased considerably. The cost of margarine has increased. The penny candle is now 2d. The penny tin of pepper is now 6d. The price of a tin of sardines has increased by 2d. Margarine has increased by 5d or 6d. I know that these matters were outside the control of the Government.
I do not think there ought to be the opposition that there is to this measure. I think the opposition to the Bill was in order to put across various points of view. There were some very good contributions to the debate from all sides of the House, drawing attention to the position. Deputy Bartley said last week: "Let us forget all these things and go back to the teachings of Fianna Fáil." I do not want to get into a political controversy but I do remember that when prices were going up Fianna Fáil said they would freeze things and they brought in a standstill Order. I remember voting against every clause and in every division on that measure, and I would do so again if the present Government were to attempt to bring in a Bill freezing wages. I would find myself having to vote against it. I hope the Government will never be tempted to bring in such a measure. Let a court decide what shall be done, but in no circumstances should they bring in a Bill to freeze wages.
To-day Deputy Aiken read an extract from the Official Report. He was contradicted by the Parliamentary Secretary who said: "Cannot you read the whole paragraph?" He did not read the whole paragraph. He said that the Tánaiste, Mr. Norton, said last week that he was going to freeze prices and that he was freezing them at a high level. The Tánaiste said no such thing. The Tánaiste said that he would freeze certain prices. I ask any of my colleagues to read what he said. He said he would freeze certain prices and bring down others. At the time we were referring to blankets. He said he would freeze certain prices and bring down others and that under no circumstances would he freeze existing prices where prices were raised within the last month or two. I hope he will go into that matter. I would ask the House to consider this matter in a reasonable manner and give the Government the support they deserve.