Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1950—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 127–247 of 247. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 34 of 1950 ›
Deputy Byrne has been taking us to task for not being more favourably disposed towards this measure. If we thought that it was a genuine attempt to bring down the cost of living, to reduce the prices of the various commodities that people have to purchase in the shops we certainly would support it, but we consider that it is no such thing. I will go further and say that it is my opinion that this proposal to set up an advisory committee is all humbug, another attempt to throw dust in the eyes of the people.
I have often been wondering during the past couple of years, when the Government were not succeeding in bringing down the cost of living or even in keeping the cost of living at the level at which it was when they took office, that they did not set up a commission early on to advise them, mar dheadh, on the position, but there is very little difference, in my view, between this proposed advisory committee and a commission.
This idea of setting up a commission seems to be an incurable disease with this present Government, but, of course, everybody knows that it is just a remedy to cover their tracks. There is an old proverb in the Irish language that is very applicable to the position to-day: Filleann feall ar an feallaire— Deception recoils on those who practise it—and that is exactly what is happening at the present time. The deception that the members of the present Government practised on the electorate in the last general election is recoiling on their heads.
When they promised the people of the country that they would reduce the cost of living, in my view, they entered into a contract with the people, a solemn contract, and they have broken that contract shamefully, but the worst feature of that breach of contract is that they did not care one iota whether they broke it or not. The members of the Government and the Deputies who support them have been coming into this House for the past three years and have been going around the country during the same period, and they did not seem to be one bit concerned about their failure to keep down the cost of living, much less to reduce it. If there is to be any sanctity attached to contracts, especially a contract entered into with the people of this country, it is time the Government woke up and realised it.
I have heard Deputies opposite speaking on this measure and some of them, at least, seem to resent the publicity that the Parliamentary Secretary's statement got in the Press. One would imagine that the Press of this country, judging by the attitude of some of the Deputies opposite, should not be at liberty to publish what people say here. But the organ that gave it the greatest publicity was the Irish Independent which, of course, as everybody knows, supports the Government.
Comment on this
The publicity given to that statement, in any case, was justified, in my opinion. It certainly startled the people. It was bad enough when the Government had not done anything about bringing down the cost of living, but it was worse when they sought to deny that the cost of living had gone up, when, as Deputy Colley pointed out, every housewife, every householder, knew very well that everything purchased in the shops had gone up in price, and has been going up by leaps and bounds.
I am inclined to think that some of the Deputies opposite are out of touch with the realities of the case. We had an example of that from Deputy Byrne when he said it costs 7/- to sole and heel a pair of boots and shoes. The fact of the matter is that the cost of soling and heeling at present is 10/-. Deputy Byrne did not know that.
He also complained of the scarcity of fish in Dublin and the exorbitant price the people have to pay. To whom does he attribute that? We have a Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries here who told us he was going to rehabilitate the fishing industry and do wonderful things in connection with it. Now it transpires, and we have it from Deputy Byrne, who lives in Dublin, that fish cannot be got in the city.
I have no use for this advisory committee. I look upon it as just another attempt on the part of the Government to run away from their responsibilities. Certain speakers over there want to pretend that the Fianna Fáil Government made no attempt to control prices. Deputy O'Leary said we do not want it even now. The fact is that up to 1947 there was little or no increase in the cost of living. The Fianna Fáil Government succeeded in keeping it down. When, in 1947, the cost of living trend was upwards, and when we took steps to bring it down lower than it was, at least in so far as the main requirements of the household were concerned, no condemnation was strong enough for us from the opposite benches.
We have been speaking here about the cost of living and the high prices of commodities. So much has been said on that, that I do not propose to dwell upon it at any great length, but I would like to say a little as regards the fuel position. Everybody knows that the fuel position in the country is rather serious. I am doubtful if the Government are taking the necessary steps to cope with that position. I remember in the Dáil quite recently the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when replying to a question asked by Deputy Lemass, was inclined to blame the weather. While we all agree it has been a bad year, still I do not think it could be said that the Government have done all they should have done to provide fuel for the people. For instance, last year was the finest year that we had for a long period. If the Government had given encouragement last year to the turf industry, if they had taken all the necessary steps to put that industry on its feet, we would have had ample supplies left over until this year, thereby obviating the necessity of purchasing all the coal that now appears to be necessary.
When will the Government begin to realise the importance of the turf industry? Some members of the Government seem to have an animus against that industry. There was a Turf Bill on the Order Paper for a long time before the Government thought it worth their while to put it through the Oireachtas. Since then what has been done to promote the turf industry? Nothing that I know of. The position is that, instead of taking steps to promote the turf industry, Bord na Móna were instructed to take away some of their machinery from the bogs. That happened in my own constituency. The turf-cutting machines have been taken away from the bogs in certain places. How can the Government account for that? Not merely did they put an end to, and cripple, the hand-won turf industry, but they also took steps to curtail the machine-won turf industry, so that when the Parliamentary Secretary, or any other member of the Government, comes in here and says that when there is not turf available for the people at the present time it is due to the weather, I am afraid we cannot entirely accept that.
The point is: have the Government any proposals now for the coming spring to develop the turf industry? Everybody knows now—it has been clearly demonstrated within the past few months—that supplies of coal henceforth will be very uncertain. Therefore, it is necessary that everything possible be done to get the people to produce turf and to organise a proper market for it. Are there any proposals, for instance, in the Department of Industry and Commerce, or even in the Department of Local Government, to get the county councils to produce turf again as had to be done during the emergency. This is a very serious matter in my opinion, because we have now the extraordinary and unnatural position that supplies of coal are being sent into the turf areas, even into the County Kerry which I represent. I hope, therefore, that the Government will realise at last the importance of the turf industry and do everything in their power to promote it.
Now, coming back again to the cost of living. The Minister for Social Welfare came into the House the other night and delivered a rather abusive speech. He abused the Fianna Fáil Government and he abused the manufacturers. He tried to put the blame on everybody except on the people on whom it should be put. One would imagine from his remarks, and from the remarks of some of the other speakers over there, that the Fianna Fáil Government were still in office. He tried to pretend that a lot of the difficulties which, he says, the present Government are confronted with were created by the Fianna Fáil Government—that it was we who left them the present machinery. The present price control machinery is quite adequate if it were properly used. There is the saying that a bad workman quarrels with his tools, and that is exactly what the Minister for Social Welfare was doing: he was quarrelling with his tools, quarrelling with the machinery which he has at his disposal. Have they made any serious attempt to utilise that machinery? Not at all, as far as I can see. We will find, when this Bill is enacted, that they will have no more power than they already have at their disposal to control the prices of commodities.
We, I think, succeeded fairly well in keeping down prices in our time because, as Deputy Childers pointed out, out of a total of 67 countries in which statistics are kept, the cost of living went up higher in 50 of them than it did in this country, while in seven others it was about the same. That was not a bad record for this country which had to import a great lot of raw materials and so on during a war and its aftermath that had engulfed the whole world. In any case, the lesson to be learned from the whole position is this, that the policy of self-reliance, the old Sinn Féin policy which has been preached by Fianna Fáil and which Fianna Fáil has done its best to foster, is the only policy for this country.
Comment on this
As far as I understand it, this Bill is merely to give the Government powers which it already possesses under another Act that was passed by the late Government. It is simply a continuing measure. As the Parliamentary Secretary stated, most people in all countries thought that after five years of a second world war it would not have been necessary to continue the powers which were granted by the Oireachtas during the stress of the emergency period. He went on to say that, looking at world events and realising the experiences after the end of the war in 1945, he thought no one would question the necessity for continuing the Supplies and Services Act for a further 12 months. That is the issue before the House and it behoves Deputies to approach this matter and give it calm and dispassionate consideration. Let me say at the outset that I do not at all agree with the gloomy speeches which have been delivered by very many Opposition Deputies, and, indeed, by a few Deputies on these benches, with regard to the present position of this country. With regard to the supplies of foodstuffs and the standard of living in general prevailing in this country, I say without hesitation that it is the finest country in the world. The people of the country and the working classes particularly, I am proud to say, enjoy as high a standard of living as in any country in the world. With all the force at my command, I resent such statements as have been made by Deputy Corry in trying to make political points.
He referred to the farmers as a depressed class. Knowing the farmers as I do, I am proud to be able to say that they can hold their heads as high as any other section. I hope that he will withdraw a statement he made, because it is an untruth, that it was a case of the white loaf for the rich and the black loaf for the poor. Is any Deputy or any Irishman worthy of the name prepared to substantiate that statement? Does not Deputy Corry know that that is not a fact, that the loaf which I receive and which other Deputies receive is the same as the loaf which the people of every section receive?
We have been told about the increase in the cost of living. It was stated that the Parliamentary Secretary said that there was no increase in the cost of living. He said no such thing. So far as an increase in the cost of living is concerned, it has been increasing from my early days 60 years ago. It has been going up and down ever since, and we have lived through it all. Here is what the Parliamentary Secretary did say:—
"I want to refer first of all to the situation which has existed between 1947 and August of this year. I want to deal primarily with that period in order to refute any possible suggestions or allegations that there was any rise in the cost of living or in the prices of essential commodities during that period..."
I want to emphasise those two words, "essential commodities".
"I think it is right that we should review the situation up to either the summer or the early autumn of this year and then consider the situation which exists at the present time or may exist in the future."
That is the one important point that seems to have been left out by Opposition Deputies. Not one of them referred to that statement of the Parliamentary Secretary which would convey to any man of common sense that during the past few months a new situation has arisen, not alone in this but in every other country in the world, which requires new methods and more careful handling than has been given to it during the past three, four or five years.
Deputies profess great surprise at this sudden change. They have only got to look at the present position in Korea, for example, where in almost the twinkling of an eye the situation was changed overnight. Most people thought that that war, if it could be called a war, would be finished in a few weeks. To-day the end of it is just as far off as ever. There is no use in saying that the Parliamentary Secretary should have foreseen this or that. The fact is that, due to circumstances over which the Parliamentary Secretary or Ministers have no control, a situation will develop here, as it has developed in other countries, which will require the fullest co-operation and good-will and special measures on the part of the Government if we are to pull through. I am not one of those who talk of war every moment. The Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party, who seems to express such concern about the position of the people of this country, has not thought fit to speak in this debate. Instead, he went down the country and told the people that the one thing that was essential for the future prosperity of the country was to have a general election.
Comment on this
He is a first-class psychologist. Knowing the temperament of the Irish people, that they are remarkable for their impetuosity and enthusiasm, he thinks that the best thing he can do at the moment is to provide them with a little fun and a little enthusiasm. That seems to be the whole basis of the arguments of Fianna Fáil Deputies when they should try and co-operate with the Government to meet a situation which they think is very dangerous and very serious. Instead of that, they have referred to what was said at the last election. Personally, I do not mind what promises were made during the last election. I never made any promises. My headline always was and always will be, man shall earn his bread by the sweat of his brow. I made no promises and, therefore, I am in a position to tell Opposition Deputies that, rightly or wrongly, consciously or unconsciously, the people have entrusted us with the cares of Government, and we are going to carry on until the end of the five years.
Comment on this
As I say, I do not pretend that the cost of living has not increased. I do say, however, that in dealing with the cost of living Deputies are inclined, and in fact the people in general are inclined, to leave out one of the most important factors, and that is the human factor. Deputies opposite have put a certain price on every item which goes to make up the family budget. Are they aware that one mother can run a house on £5 a week while another could not run it on £10 or £20? How are they going to get over that difficulty? How will you get over that difficulty? I admit that the cost of living has gone up in certain cases but, despite all the talk about the high cost of living, I say here and now that tea is as cheap to-day as it was 60 years ago. When I was a boy a half-pound of tea cost 1/4. To-day a half-pound of tea costs 1/4, 2/8 per lb. Anyone who wants extra tea can get it at about 3/6, as far as I understand. As far as I am concerned two ounces are quite sufficient for me and my family, and no member of my family has ever had occasion to buy unrationed tea. We can live on 2 ozs. per person and, therefore, it is not right to say, as has been said here by Opposition Deputies, that poor people have to pay 3/6 a lb.
I do not like to go back into the past but when I hear the taunts hurled at us from the Opposition Benches I am compelled to point out that there was not so much sympathy shown for the poor when they were paying not 1/4 for a half-pound but 1/6 per oz., 25/- or 30/- per lb. References were made to the price of butter. Again, the Opposition Deputies have not been honest. They have fashioned and moulded their speeches according to the way in which they think they will go down with their constituents.
We had a city Deputy criticising the Government because off-the-ration butter is 3/6 per lb. We had a Deputy representing a farming constituency, as Deputy Allen does, saying butter was only 2/3 or 2/4 per lb. Of course that was said lest the Minister for Agriculture might get any credit. We have Deputy Major de Valera throwing up his hands in horror because eggs are 5/6 per dozen as if he did not know, innocent man that he is, that there is always a seasonal increase in the price of eggs in the winter months. Eggs were 6/- a dozen in the First World War, 30 years ago, when wages were only half of what they are to-day. The moment he mentions 5/6, lest the Minister for Agriculture might get any credit, Deputy Ó Briain gets up and says to Deputy Major de Valera: "You are in fact wrong; they are only 2/- a dozen." That is here in the Official Report.
On the one hand, the Minister for Agriculture is blamed because of the high prices the farmers are getting; on the other hand he is blamed if he does not get good prices for them. In other words, Fianna Fáil are speaking with two voices. I say that they are thoroughly dishonest and contemptible in doing that in face of the situation that confronts us. I wonder would Deputy Major de Valera go down to Limerick or Wexford to-morrow, address a meeting of farmers there and tell them they are getting too much for their eggs. I wonder would he go down to Limerick or Tipperary and tell them they are getting too much for their butter. No, that would not do. It would not be politically wise to do that. But he gets up here and he criticises the price of eggs, the price of butter and the price of bacon.
Speaking of bacon, do we not all know that we can get bacon now? Do we not all know that bacon bought and cured by the curers works out at an average of about 2/- a lb.? As the Parliamentary Secretary has said, the standard of living and the tastes of our people have improved. The people want the prime cut now in both bacon and beef. We all know that. The curer when he buys the pig pays a flat rate of 190/- or 200/- for the whole pig, head, feet and everything else. There must therefore be some little increase in so far as the prime cuts are concerned. Taking the situation as it exists we must admit that it is due to no fault of the Government that increases have occurred in certain cases in the cost of living. But the people are enjoying at the moment a higher standard of living. Possibly it is not higher from the physical point of view but the tastes of our people have changed.
We have acquired many new ways of spending a shilling. As the late Lord Snowden once said, what was wrong with the world was that we had all acquired ten, 20, 30, 40 new ways of spending a shilling but not ten, 20, 30 or 40 new ways of making a shilling That is equally true at the present time.
I do not think the introduction of this measure should call forth the type of speech that has invariably been made by Opposition Deputies. They all speak as if we were about to have a general election in a week or a fortnight's time. We do not want a general election. We will not have a general election. We want work. We want the country to carry on. When the time for a general election comes we will go out on the hustings. I will go out on every platform in Louth and Meath and meet any Deputy who speaks about the high cost of living and I will answer him. We have been elected to carry on the government of the country for the next five years. We have carried on for three and, taking all the circumstances into consideration, I do not think we have done badly. If we were to take the Opposition speeches seriously we would go out through the front gate here in fear and trembling. Last week I really thought I would be met at the gate by a mob with bludgeons in their hands waiting to destroy us. That has not happened. I mix with the people in my county just as much as any other Deputy does. Realising that things will become more serious as time goes on there is no use now in throwing up our hands and saying that things are much worse than they really are. No matter what may be said to the contrary, this is as good a country to live in as any in the world. Only last week I had a letter from a young lady across the water in which she wrote in black and white: "I wish to go back to dear old Ireland. There is no place like home, sweet home."
Comment on this
The Bill which is now before the House gives power to the Minister to interfere in every branch of industry. It gives him power to compel manufacturers, shopkeepers and traders of all kinds to produce accounts, to account for every penny of expenditure and to justify every increase in prices or in costs shown on the face of those accounts. The principal Act which this Bill is to continue in operation gives to the Minister for Industry and Commerce the widest possible powers to control prices, powers which should be adequate in every way if they are rightfully and effectively and efficiently used. Notwithstanding that one of the provisions of the Bill is to enable the Minister to set up a prices advisory tribunal. We may well ask ourselves with some astonishment why that should be necessary, bearing in mind the remarkable statement made by the Parliamentary Secretary when introducing the measure that there had been no rise in the cost-of-living index whereby, I assume, he intends to imply at any rate and to convey to the public, if not to convince them, that there has been no rise in the cost of living.
If there has been no rise in the cost of living, why is it necessary to set up this prices advisory tribunal? Some cynical members of the House, remembering the recent history of the Irish Tourist Board and of Córas Iompair Éireann and of the Baltinglass Post Office—above all, I should say, of the Baltinglass Post Office—or thinking of the snug berths which have been found for Roddy the Rover and Mr. Archie Heron, might say that one of the reasons why it is proposed to set up this new body is to give the Government greater powers of patronage—in short, to afford to their supporters more jobs. Others recollecting the Government's stratagem in regard to the vexed question of teachers' salaries and remuneration, the tricks which they played in regard to emigration and the question of the prices of bread and flour, might think of another purpose that the Government had in view when they decided to set up this prices advisory tribunal.
Whatever its failures—and they have been, I think it will be admitted, gross and appalling failures in other spheres —this Government has shown itself adept at what the Americans colloquially describe as "passing the buck". Whenever a difficult question arises which the Government is afraid to tackle, it washes its hands of it. It sets up a commission, that is to say, it washes its hands of it. So far as its public responsibilities are concerned, this Government of moral cowards— because I think we are entitled so to describe it—is continually washing its hands. Wherever an injustice is being done, as in the case of the Baltinglass postmistress, it washes its hands. Where a Minister, who promised to solve the emigration problem overnight, wishes to shirk that issue, the Government washes its hands by setting up a commission to inquire into the causes of emigration, if you please. When we were told that these causes were so well known and could be so easily overcome and dealt with that emigration could be solved overnight, the Government, as I have said, sets up a commission and washes its hands of the whole question. When the Government alleges, as the members of the Government did allege prior to the last general election and since, that there is gross profiteering in bread and flour, instead of curbing this alleged abuse when the power is in their own hands, it decides to set up a commission and washes its hands. Now when the Minister, with the most far-reaching powers ever vested in one person, has not merely failed to reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent, but stands complacently by and alleges that the cost of living is not rising, once again they propose to set up a commission and to wash their hands of all responsibility for the position. When there is trouble about, when difficult knotty problems arise and have to be tackled, the first preoccupation of every member of that Government, of the Ministers individually and collectively, is——
Comment on this
To wash their hands, precisely, for in the washing of hands, Pontius Pilate had nothing on the members of this Government. The Government could give him lessons in the art.
But the day of the washing of hands is over. The days of dodging are over. The Coalition chickens are coming home to roost. They are coming home to roost with the "dodgeem" Government, as the leader of the Opposition fitly described them in a speech to which Deputy Coburn has taken some exception. The "dodgeem" Government have at last had to face up to the issues which they raised in the election of 1948, and to tell the people why it is that they have not fulfilled a single one of the pledges on which they secured their votes. The Government must face up to its responsibilities because these responsibilities are now inescapable, not only for the Government but for those who support them, and particularly for those who claim to represent the workers of this country. I understand, at least I gathered from reading the reports of the debate, that when the question of prices was raised in this debate, the members of the Labour Party, and particularly the present leader of the Labour Party—a post which seems to be out of commission since Deputy Larkin resigned it— viewed this issue with some complacency. I must say, of course, that so far as economic circumstances are concerned, one might say that this Government is perhaps from the point of view of members of the Labour Party the best Government they ever had, because a great many plums have fallen to followers of that Party since the Government took office. However, that is by the way, and I did not intend that that aside should intrude itself. Instead I should like to put some questions to those who are now supporting the Coalition. First of all, the members of the Clann na Poblachta Party might answer this: where is the 30 per cent. decrease in the cost of living which they promised if only Fianna Fáil could be got rid of?
Comment on this
Deputy Timoney says "Oh no." Deputy Timoney's Party is just as powerful in this House with its ten members supporting the Government and with two of its members actually Ministers of the Government, as if they were a majority Party and the whole Government were constituted of its members. The Clann na Poblachta Party, whose support is vital to this Government, have it in their power to fulfil their pledge to the people and to compel the Government to reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent. They can do it, as we managed to do it, and keep down the price of bread very considerably by increasing the subsidies which brought down and lowered the price of bread, butter, tea and sugar to the consumer when we were in power. You can do that if you want to fulfil the pledge of reducing the cost of living by 30 per cent.
Where is the reduction in taxation which we were promised? Instead of taxation having been reduced considerably, as we were told it would be if Fine Gael took office, it has, in fact, been increased by not less than 40 per cent. over the last three years. Where is the freedom of enterprise which we were promised if Fine Gael had the reins of Government? Where is the emancipation of business from the control of inspectors and bureaucrats as they used to describe them when they were in opposition? How many "pipsqueaks", as the Minister for Industry and Commerce so elegantly described them two months after he had taken office, have been eliminated from the Government service?
Comment on this
Now a lot of plums have fallen to the O'Higgins family. Keep from interrupting me now, otherwise I might say things which I might regret later and which you would feel very personally. Where is the reduction in the number of civil servants which we were promised? So far from there having been a reduction, everybody knows that not merely has the cost of the Civil Service and the remuneration of civil servants increased, but the number of civil servants has also increased since this Government took office.
Where is the decentralisation of government that we were promised? When we were in power and we had plans for the orderly housing of the Civil Service and the concentration in economic, efficient and up-to-date premises of the Civil Service which is now scattered throughout the city, occupying buildings that are very sorely wanted for the purpose of private business, it was alleged that we were going to engage in a prodigal and wasteful expenditure upon buildings. What has happened? So hard put have the Government been to find accommodation for this growing and swelling army of civil servants that they have had to take over and divert from its proper purpose the national bus terminal which was intended to serve as a terminal building for the whole transport systems of this country, particularly for the road transport systems. Does not that indicate at least that, in so far as their pledge to reduce the number and the cost of the Civil Service is concerned, they have, like all their other pledges, thrown it on the scrap heap?
Where is the closer association with Great Britain and the Commonwealth that Fine Gael used to promise its thick and thin supporters in the days when it was in opposition? Had not we instead a magnificent speech, delivered in heroic tones and with ponderous gestures, telling the people of Ireland that henceforward we should hit the British in their pride, their prestige and their pockets? What is happening to-day? They are over crawling on their bellies to try to get hold of coal to replace the coal in the dumps that they gave away at scandalous prices last year, to replace the turf that ought to have been cut but was not cut because of the deliberate policy of sabotaging the Fianna Fáil programme which this Government embarked upon when it took office in 1948.
Where do we find the Deputies from the Six Counties who were to sit in the Dáil, according to Mr. MacBride's programme and the programme of Clann na Poblachta? Where is the encouragement to industrial enterprise that we were promised? I could go on but the time at my disposal is short. I could retail dozens of other promises as lightly made and as lightly broken as those to which I have referred.
To-day we were told that one of the causes of the increase in prices has been devaluation, that the soaring cost of living is due to devaluation. When the Government decided to devalue and took upon themselves the responsibility for that, do not let us forget that that operation yielded a very substantial profit to the Government. This extravagant Government has borrowed more millions in the three years it has been in office than the Fianna Fáil Government borrowed during the whole of the period, practically, that it was in power, during the whole of the 16 years, including the six years of war and the seventh year of its aftermath. When the Government decided to devalue last year, it did it knowing that because of its extravagance it was being faced with the task of finding, out of the wages and sweat of the people, a substantial sum to meet its liabilities in respect of the National Loan. One of the consequences of devaluation was to reduce the real value of the people's savings which had been invested in the National Loan and to reduce the real burden of the interest and sinking fund charges payable in respect of that loan.
Another consequence, a profitable consequence from the Government's point of view, was to reduce the real value of every pension payable by the Government under any one of its insurance schemes, and not merely those payable under social schemes but payable from any source.
These were the benefits which immediately accrued to the Government as a result of devaluation, and to-day these illgotten gains of the Government are being reflected in rising prices. If the Government had not devalued, undoubtedly, the cost of living would not have risen to anything like the same extent as it has risen over the past 12 months.
Comment on this
One of the Deputy's pledges when he was seeking election was that they had, that they would break the link with sterling and that they had an option. I am not going to be responsible for trying to resolve the Deputy's dilemma. His leader and his Party told the people that they had an option, that we need not be tied up with sterling.
Comment on this
If we need not be tied up with sterling, then the Government of its own free will decided to devalue. They secured the fruits of the devaluation and the people are now paying for it.
Comment on this
Apart altogether from paying in these two ways and from these two sources, other people have had to pay very heavily too, because the Government, instead of allowing manufacturers and others to adjust themselves to the position in regard to raw materials which devaluation had created, insisted upon freezing prices.
Prices are not being frozen for the first time just now. Retail prices have been virtually frozen since devaluation. So far as manufacturers are concerned who have had to buy raw materials for their industry in a continuously rising market, to-day wool is almost three times what it was this time last year and cotton is up by almost 40 per cent. They have had to buy in this rising market since and sell their goods at the same price level as they were selling them last year. That is only by the way.
The Government have done that in order that they might evade one of the consequences of devaluation, but they can no longer escape it, and now they are using it, having secured the profit from it, as an excuse for the increase in the cost of living which has taken place since. In that connection let me remind the House about one or two things that were said. When it was pointed out that devaluation would inevitably entail an increase in the cost of living, the Minister for Agriculture—I need not mention the ubiquitous Mr. Dillon—stated that there would be no increase in prices within any forseeable time and the Minister for Finance gave the public to understand that devaluation would not significantly affect the cost of living. You can see in these statements what little reliance is to be placed upon the pronouncement of any Minister in the Government.
When the Government gets into a mess of this sort, what do they do? They immediately look around for a scapegoat. In the Tánaiste's disgraceful speech on this Bill he produced a whole horde of scapegoats. First of all, we had the Fianna Fáil Government. I do not want at this time to go into the record of the Fianna Fáil Government. Then we had the Irish manufacturers. The Irish manufacturers are the bête noire of a man who never gave a day's employment to any other man in his life, of a man who never put any person into productive employment, who never did anything to foster, develop or expand Irish industry. His quarrel, of course, with the Irish industrialists is a basic one. The Irish industrialist provides decent employment at decent wages and therefore deprives the Tánaiste, who might be described as the Minister for Blatherskite in a Dodgem Government, of the only ground on which he can build up his political career, because the Tánaiste's political career is based on one thing only, causing disaffection among the Irish people.
Having thought, perhaps, that people would not be taken in by this attack on the industrialists and the Irish manufacturers, he went on to put the blame on devaluation, and this member of the Government which this time last year was assuring us that there would be no increase in the cost of living due to devaluation went on to say something like this:
"Since August, 1950, there has been a change. We are fools if we do not recognise the changes which have been brought about. The first change was devaluation in September, 1949. It was then believed that devaluation would have immediate and serious consequences for those countries in the sterling area which were compelled to buy either manufactured goods or raw materials from the dollar area."
I am quoting from Volume 123, column 1814. Mark what I have read. Here is a Minister whose colleague, the Minister for Finance, told the people in September, 1949, that devaluation would not significantly affect the cost of living. Here is a Minister whose colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, told the people there would be no increase in the cost of living within a foreseeable period, now admitting that in September, 1949, the Government of which he was a member then believed devaluation would have immediate and serious consequences for those countries in the sterling area which were compelled to buy either manufactured goods or raw materials. So much for that scapegoat.
Then he blamed the rise in prices on the war in Korea and in column 1815 of the same volume he says:
"In recent months we have had to face the situation which has arisen as a result of the Korean war. Does anybody suggest that we could have foreseen that and stock-piled against it?"
For the past three years it has been apparent to everyone who had eyes to see, to everyone whose vision was not blinded by deliberately shutting his eyes to the Communist aggression which was sweeping over Europe, that a show-down was coming. It was particularly clear to the Tánaiste, who was in Strasbourg in the summer of 1949, that the one fear which was overhanging the whole of Europe was war, which even in that year seemed imminent.
Had the events in Indo-China over the past years no significance for the Tánaiste, for the Minister for External Affairs, for the Minister for Defence or for the Taoiseach? Had the increased bellicosity of the Russians nothing to convey to the members of this Government, to every man who was a student of events and who was prepared to look at them with an unbiased judgment and who could see that the peril of war was coming nearer and nearer? Even if the Tánaiste could not recognise those symptoms for himself, they were pointed out to him time and time again from these benches. But we were told by the Taoiseach, in a speech which is on record, when the growing menace was pointed out to him, that he and his Government were planning on the hypothesis of peace. Where is the basis of the Government's plan now? Where is the hypothesis of peace upon which their whole policy has been based?
Now when we are faced with a shortage of fuel and of raw materials, when we cannot get coal, what would they give if, instead of sabotaging the policy of Córas Iompair Éireann to try to turn over to oil fuel, they were going ahead with the Diesel-electric project? They can get oil when they cannot get coal. Oil is much more easily and economically and safely stored than coal and the one salvation of the transport system, if a war did come, would be that we would have adequate supplies of oil fuel and properly equipped oil-burning locomotives of one type or another to utilise it. But that policy has been overthrown. Everyone apparently foresaw the danger which was coming except the Government.
The Tánaiste, in recommending this Bill, said it would set up a tribunal of vigilant citizens to deal with a certain problem. Thank God we are going to have some element of vigilance introduced into the Government and into the administration of affairs.
Comment on this
It has been conveyed to the Chair that the Parliamentary Secretary is to be allowed in at 8 o'clock.
Comment on this
Yes. I hope that these vigilant citizens who are going to be brought in on the advisory tribunal will be given the conduct of the affairs of this country, because the country has suffered too long and is in great peril through having had a Government of Rip Van Winkles for the past three years.
Deputy Desmond rose.
Comment on this
It has been conveyed to the Chair that the Parliamentary Secretary was to be allowed in at 8 o'clock.
Comment on this
The Chair does not want to prevent anyone from speaking, but it has been conveyed to the Chair that there was agreement between all Parties that the Parliamentary Secretary would be allowed to conclude the debate at 8 o'clock.
Comment on this
As far as we are concerned, the agreement was that if we got three hours we would be satisfied.
Comment on this
It is quite clear that such an agreement was unknown to us. We are entitled to say our say, especially in view of what little Deputy MacEntee had to say. He had a great deal to say.
Comment on this
If any of the Deputies who are concerned with Private Deputies' time are prepared to give extra time we will agree to it if the others agree.
Comment on this
Is it agreed that the debate will continue into Private Deputies' time until 9.15?
Agreed.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, the time is so short that I cannot go in detail into the figures and other matters that were dealt with in this debate. At the outset I would like to say that Deputy MacEntee, when speaking, brought back to me the lesson which my old school teacher tried to instil into my mind. The words were:—
Hail to thee, blithe spirit!
Bird thou never wert,
That from heaven, or near it,
Pourest thy full heart
In profuse strains of unpremeditated art.
In this case Deputy MacEntee was dishonest enough to tell untruths. He is never ashamed of that. Is not every Deputy on the Opposition Benches aware of the circular that was sent out to the county councils in November, 1947, to stop completely the turf schemes? That is a fact that cannot be denied. It was stated quite clearly here and is on the records of the Custom House.
Comment on this
It was. As a member of the Cork County Council, I heard it read in November, 1947. I believe that it would be a waste of time to speak at length about statistical abstracts and the cost of living. The truth is that we have to face the problem of the cost of living from the point of view of our every-day lives. I believe, as many Deputies on this side have already said, that it is bound up completely with the failure of the system that was introduced in 1947—the price index at that time. Further, I would like to record, for the benefit of the House, that as well as the cost-of-living index being unsatisfactory, there is a further fact to be taken into account, that the then Minister for Industry and Commerce gave to Córas Iompair Éireann the power to charge up to 1?d. per mile on bus journeys from Cork to Crosshaven. The fare then was 1/10. I should like to remind the House that if Córas Iompair Éireann had taken advantage of the offer made to them by Deputy Lemass, who was then Minister, the fare from Cork to Crosshaven, instead of being 1/10, would be 2/2. That is all tied up with the question of the cost of living.
This Bill has been under debate for such a long period that I do not think it would be fair to keep the Parliamentary Secretary out longer from replying. I want to say in conclusion that the sooner we depart from the system which has been operated since 1947 as regards the cost-of-living index, and the sooner this tribunal is set up, even though Deputy Lemass and Deputy MacEntee may not like its personnel when it is announced, and the sooner we have a proper system of inquiry into a proper cost-of-living index figure, the better it will be.
Comment on this
In replying to this debate I think I should at the outset deal with a matter which was referred to by a number of Deputies, and which also received some comment outside. A number of Deputies, in the course of their speeches, said that I had stated in moving the Second Reading of the Bill that there had been no rise in the cost of living. It is quite likely, because of the headings in the newspapers, that the mistake arose; that it was due to the fact that they looked at the heading and did not look at the speech. I made it quite clear, in moving the Second Reading of the Bill, and subsequently by way of interruption on a number of occasions, that I first of all dealt with the cost of living and its reflection in the cost-of-living index between the month of August, 1947, and the month of August of this year. I said—the reference is Volume 123, column 1267:—
"Any rises that have taken place have occurred in recent months and can be attributed to the emergency preparations for the Korean conflict and the resultant preparations elsewhere."
Later in column 1275 I said:—
"I want the House to realise that I am dealing only with the situation up to August of this year. I will come to the future later on, and to whatever problem it may hold, and outline the steps the Government has decided to take to deal with that situation."
Later in my speech at column 1279 I said:—
"Now, since the start of the Korean war this year, a change has occurred. Circumstances have altered considerably, and the future cannot be assessed as regards its effects on the prices of imported commodities."
Later, by way of interruption when Deputy Lemass was speaking, I said at column 1305:—
"I concede that there is a recent rise. I made that quite clear and it is to meet that situation."
I think it is well to refer to that, because a great deal of what was said in the course of this debate has proceeded on a wrong assumption, the assumption that I made a statement here in introducing this Bill which had no foundation. I should say that I have no complaint to make, nor am I voicing any criticism, of the manner in which the speech was reported. My speech is fully reported in Volume 123 of the Dáil Debates for the 23rd November last. I think that if any Deputy takes the trouble to read it he will see that it will amply refute any suggestion that I, in some way, had been misled, by being directed as part of Government policy, to express views that had no foundation, or that were in some way unrelated to present circumstances. It is, of course, true that very often when listening to a speech and subsequently reporting it the heading may give a misleading impression. While I have no complaint to make of the manner in which it was reported, the heading I think was in this instance misleading in so far as it did not portray accurately the body of the speech.
In the course of this debate, a great variety of problems and matters affecting the country has been raised. Numerous matters, dealing in the main with the cost of living and its effect on the standard of living of the people, have been referred to by Deputies on both sides of the House. In dealing with the matter, therefore, I think it is necessary to refer to some of the remarks which Deputies made in connection with the cost-of-living index figure. I want to be quite clear that I have no particular brief in that matter, nor am I qualified, nor for that matter is any person not versed in statistical knowledge qualified, to express criticisms of it. For a considerable number of years that index figure has been the subject of a great deal of criticism, criticism in the main directed against it on the ground that it does not accurately reflect changes in the cost of living, or rather that it does not reflect changes in the standard of living.
As I explained in the course of this debate, the index is an index of retail prices. It is, I think, a matter of note that the British retail prices index, now so-called, was formerly described as the cost-of-living index. Experience showed that a great number of people failed to realise what that index was intended to portray and the various trends it was intended to indicate.
A number of Deputies, Deputy Lehane in particular, said that this index was vague and valueless. The Deputy said that the sooner we arrived at a new method of computing the figure the better. He went on to refer to the fact that The Economist had criticised the corresponding British index. I have not seen that particular criticism, but I think it is well to say that the British retail prices index is based on the 1937-38 standards and weighted accordingly. The Irish index, whether it is imperfect or otherwise, was revised, not by this Government, but by the present Opposition in 1946 or 1947 and, as Deputies are aware, the new cost-of-living index figure came into effect from August, 1947, and the weights are accordingly based on the pattern of consumption then existing and, as I said earlier, it is taken over a range of about 120 towns and over a wide variety of commodities.
Another criticism expressed against the index has been that it does not take into account commodities that are sold off the ration, and the political criticism was made by the Opposition that, in effect, the Government were sponsoring a black market, and that that black market was not taken into account. It is quite true that these off-the-ration commodities are not taken into account. The basis on which the index is compiled is this. In the case of tea, the vast bulk of tea which is being sold is rationed tea at 2/8 per lb. Similarly, in the case of butter, the bulk of the butter being sold is rationed butter at 2/8 per lb. The rationed sugar is sold at 4d a lb. In that connection, I have inquired from the Central Statistics Office if it would be possible to get data which would show the effect of the inclusion of these various non-rationed commodities and sundries, because another criticism of the index was that it did not include a number of articles generally bought by the average household which might be included in it.
As I said in introducing this Bill, it is only a retail prices index of the various items included in it. It does not purport to indicate a standard of living or a pattern of consumption other than that which is regarded as a fair average of the entire community. But, since the start of this debate, I have made inquiries from the Central Statistics Office, and I have got some information which would show that, if the off-the-ration commodities were taken into account, last year approximately 10 per cent, of the total tea consumed in the country was bought off the ration. In the case of butter, only 7 per cent, was bought. Sugar is somewhat different.
Comment on this
Sugar is different. It is 60 per cent., but a great deal of that sugar is bought by manufacturers for conversion into sweets, jams and other commodities. In that connection, both chocolates and boiled sweets, in the manufacture of which a large amount of sugar is used, are included in the index. Therefore, in so far as three items in the manufacture of which a large amount of sugar is used are concerned—chocolates, sweets and jams—these three items are included in the cost-of-living index figure. The figures show that the effect of including both rationed and off-the-ration commodities would be to increase the figure by 0.36 of a point, which would make no real difference. If sundries were included or other commodities which are generally regarded as normal for the average household, the increase would be 1.42. If all these off-the-ration commodities and sundries which are not included were included, it would only show a rise of from 100 to 101. It is necessary to get that on record on account of the rather reckless statements which a great many Deputies made in the course of the debate.
There is no reason why I should proceed to defend the index. But, if statistics are to have any value, then, in so far as they deal with a certain situation or are expected to be or should be considered as dealing with trends in employment or prices or anything else, if a case is to be argued, then there is no reason why the particular statistical data on which it is based should be attacked on the ground that the data are unreliable. It is particularly interesting when we examine the prices to which I have referred.
There has been a great deal of talk in the course of this debate by the Opposition about a black market in tea, a black market in sugar and a black market in butter. They say: "If you had included these commodities that would have produced a different result." They go on to say that people find it difficult to live on the amount of the commodities that are made available. Tea, butter, flour and sugar are all available at the same price at which they were when Fianna Fáil was in office this time three years, with this difference, that the ration of butter is now eight ounces. This time three years it was as low as two ounces. Just prior to the 1948 election it was increased to six ounces. During the greater portion of that year it had never been higher than six ounces, and most of the time it was either two ounces or four ounces. Since this Government came in it has never, with the exception of a short period of six weeks, been lower than four ounces, and it has been eight ounces for the last 18 months at the same price as it was when Fianna Fáil were in office and when the Supplementary Budget was introduced to subsidise butter, tea, sugar and flour.
Comment on this
I am not comparing August, 1947. I am dealing with the question of rationed goods and the black market. Since then we have raised the tea ration from 1½ ozs. to 2 ozs. at the same price as it was when Fianna Fáil was in office. We have increased the subsidy which is paid by the Exchequer by £400,000 in order to make available to the people a ration of 2 ozs. of tea per week and over and above that we have made available to them unrationed tea at 6/- per pound. Is there a single Deputy here or a single person outside who does not know that there was a time when people paid up to 5/- a lb. for butter and as much as 30/- per lb. for tea and that, if one could get sugar, one would pay as much as 2/6 a lb. for it? Now there is available over and above the same ration at the same price as when Fianna Fáil was in office sugar at 8d. per lb.
Comment on this
It was two and a half years over in the autumn of 1947. At least there was this difference: at that time we were moving into peace; for the last couple of years it appears as if we are moving into war and there is a great difference between a tendency towards peace and an indication or tendency towards war.
Comment on this
There have been references to wages and to the recent rise in the cost of living. I admit that the cost-of-living index figure will show a rise, a rise attributable to the causes I have mentioned and to the facts that the Tánaiste mentioned in the course of this debate, the Korean War and the preparations for it, to some extent devaluation, to the general transition from peace-time production in a great number of countries to a rearmament programme, for even though they may not be directly involved they are directly contributing in some way to the present conflict.
Comment on this
Nobody knows better than Deputy Lemass that control makes probably the least difference in any incidence which affects the cost of living. Deputy Lemass will agree with me that the least effectual weapon in keeping prices down is price control. There are plenty of cases where people cash in on a situation and take dishonest advantages of a rise but in the main the rising cost of any commodity is attributable to an increase in the price of raw materials, an increase in the cost of manufacture, an increase in wages or some other factor of that sort.
Deputies in the course of this debate referred to the fact that wages all during the Fianna Fáil period had been kept down and prices had been allowed to rise. It is interesting in that connection to examine a graph which I have here prepared by the Central Statistics Office showing that from the outbreak of war in 1939 there was a continuous rise in the cost of living. Anyone can see the pattern: a gradual rise at first, then a steep rise in 1941, 1942 and 1943, and then a comparative period of steadiness. At the same period the rise in wages was negligible. For one period there was not merely no rise but there was an actual drop in the wages of industrial workers.
Comment on this
The first time that there was any change in the pattern of the economic circumstances of the people and the first time that there was not merely a closing of the gap but industrial earnings went above the cost of living was in 1948, after the change of Government. Since then up to the very last index industrial earnings have remained higher than any increase that has taken place in the cost of living.
Deputy Larkin not merely referred to that fact but he expressed satisfaction with and appreciation of what had been accomplished and of the improvement that had taken place in the standard of living of those sections of the community which, under a wage freeze policy, had had their standard of living depressed when the cost of living was rising and when their circumstances were infinitely worse than the circumstances of workers and wage earners to-day. Yet the Opposition has the dishonesty to come in here and criticise the Government. They have the dishonesty to allege, as Deputy Corry and, I think, Deputy Bartley alleged, that the workers were never worse off. I think it was Deputy Traynor who said that in the course of his activities it was his experience that the people found it harder than ever now to make ends meet. Assuming that is true, what kind of existence had they then in the circumstances that I have outlined, circumstances that are portrayed by statistics compiled on the same basis, with the same knowledge and, in general, by the same people as the statistics compiled by the Opposition when they were responsible for government?
It is true that some of the more responsible Deputies opposite appreciate that a great deal has been accomplished and that it is difficult to expect the Government to control a lot of factors outside its sphere of influence or control. Their criticism was tempered by their experience and by their knowledge. Deputy Lemass did not express the view that any great change could be effected by any other Government or even by Fianna Fáil, if they were in office. Deputy Childers followed on the same line. I shall deal with the matters he raised later. But the least responsible of the Deputies came in here and read out a whole list of prices comparing like with unlike and one period with a different period, even varying it to the extent of taking a period of the year in which there are seasonal changes or rises in price. They expected from that comparison that it would be obvious to the public, misleading though it was to those who were seeking a solution to the problem, that there had been a rise.
Unfortunately quite a number of Deputies on this side were to some extent misled by a great deal of the Opposition propaganda. I think it is no harm to say in that connection that Deputies supporting the Government must be expected to take the rough with the smooth. We cannot always satisfy everybody simultaneously. Listening to some of the views that have been expressed on this measure it is obvious that some Deputies think one can get too much for too many too quickly out of too little. It is obvious that with the great increase that has taken place in production, the substantial rise in the value and volume of agricultural production, the increase that has occurred in the last two and a half to three years in industrial earnings, as well as the increase in industrial output and the substantial increase in industrial employment, that whatever is the position now or whatever the position may be in the future this country, as the Taoiseach said in Wexford last night, is sounder and stronger economically and in a better position to face the future, whether it be war or peace, than it was when this Government assumed office in February, 1948. Nobody knows that better than some of the Opposition Deputies.
Deputy Aiken came in here to-day and he referred to a variety of matters. In the main he dealt with food supplies, the steps we had taken to induce the farmers to produce more, the encouragement we had given them or should have given them, and the fuel situation. He wanted to give the impression that we were in a bad way for food and that we were short of a number of other commodities. In order to encourage farmers to produce wheat and to make it remunerative for them, when this Government came into office we raised the price of wheat from the Fianna Fáil figure of 55/- per barrel, plus a 2/6 fertiliser docket, to 62/6 and we gave them a guarantee for five years. Is there any better way, any proposal more likely to increase production, any policy that could be designed to secure the acceptance of farmers, than to give them an increased price and a remunerative and guaranteed market for wheat? We did that and as a result last year we took in more wheat than in any other year. This year there is some drop because of weather conditions.
Comment on this
The stores in the country are absolutely bulging with supplies of wheat. Our position is that we were obliged to build, and are building, additional storage in the country over and above what was there during the Fianna Fáil time or over and above what was there at any time in the past. At the same time as we increased the price to wheat growers, we lifted the control on barley. There was control of barley by the previous Government. We lifted that control and, in addition, this year we have given a guarantee that those who produce feeding barley will get a guaranteed price and that the barley they produce will be bought from them in order to provide pig producers with their own feeding stuffs so that we can continue the expansion of the pig industry and the rehabilitation of the bacon curing industry. Deputies referred to the fact that at times the price of bacon had risen and that sometimes they regarded the increases as unnecessary, but there has not been a single reference by the Opposition to the fact that their policy eliminated, or almost eliminated, the pig industry in the country. There were hardly enough pigs in the country to enable us to restore the pig population. At the same time they carefully avoided any reference to the fact that they reduced the number of cows in the country by their foolish calf-slaughtering policy. As a result, milk was scarce, butter was rationed at two ounces per week, and cheese was difficult to get. Since this Government came in, we have increased the number of cows, and there has been a gradual and continuous increase in the supply of milk and butter. It is now available at the same price on an increased ration as was the case during the period in office of Fianna Fáil.
At the same time as Deputy Aiken referred to the alleged difficulties in regard to the encouragement to farmers to increase production, he referred to the question of fuel. He said that we killed the hand-won turf scheme. I have here a note which shows that on the 12th February, 1948, six days before the Government came into office, Deputy Lemass, then Minister for Industry and Commerce, took a decision to cease hand-won turf production.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary is purporting to quote from an official record, the statement he has made is not true.
Comment on this
Deputy Aiken alleged that we had slowed down on production. I have here a book which shows for the last three years, and in particular this year, a list of advertisements in every paper, including the Irish Press and the Irish Independent——
Comment on this
On a point of order, did the Parliamentary Secretary say that Deputy Lemass had stopped hand-won turf production?
Comment on this
It was denied by the Deputy that he had made such a decision. Is it not usual in the circumstances to ask that the statement should be withdrawn?
Comment on this
In this case, the Parliamentary Secretary is purporting to quote from official records. I know there is no such record.
Comment on this
What happened was that a decision was taken to close down the Kildare camps operated by Bord na Móna in the production of hand-won turf. The decision so far as the county council scheme was concerned was to transfer these schemes to Bord na Móna and carry them on in 1948.
Comment on this
I made no reference to county council schemes. The record is there and Deputy McGrath knows nothing about it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Parliamentary Secretary says there is a record. Where is it?
Comment on this
The position is that this year we advertised on numerous occasions in every paper that circulated in the country, the national dailies and the two Sunday papers, the Sunday Press and the Sunday Independent for turf workers. At no time were we less than 800 workers short in the turf camps. The conditions in these camps are good. They have been dealt with in the course of a number of discussions in the last few months and during the passage of the Turf Bill. The present position is that despite all we did, we could not get sufficient turf workers. We advertised in every paper and offered to provide transport from where the turf workers resided to these schemes. The book is there for any Deputy who wants to read it. Most Deputies saw the advertisements which were published in the various newspapers.
Comment on this
The position so far as Cork is concerned is that we have endeavoured by every method available to increase production. In addition, we have plans for the coming year to increase turf production. I hope we shall be able to get sufficient workers and that it will be possible to expand production. It is only right to say that the temporary shortage or difficulty which has been experienced in securing supplies of fuel in certain parts of the country is in the main due to the weather. Many Deputies remember the difficult autumn of 1946.
Comment on this
I want to say that not merely have we succeeded in expanding industrial and agricultural production, but at the present time there are over 206,000 persons in insurable industrial employment. When this Government came in, according to the figures published for the end of 1947, the number at that time was 183,000. Since then we have expanded industry and production and increased the employment available. When Deputies come into this House and refer to the fact that we have delayed or in some way postponed or as they allege have not implemented the Fianna Fáil plans and policy on that matter, how can they explain away these figures? How can they show that their policy which was in operation was a better one when the one that has been put in its place has succeeded in increasing the number employed and at the same time giving them better wages?
Comment on this
At the same time that that took place, we expanded the building of houses. I never thought the Opposition would find the facts so difficult to swallow.
Comment on this
When Deputy MacEntee came in, it was the first time that we had seen him almost since the Recess and it was refreshing to hear him talk but the one thing that must have been obvious to Deputies on all sides of the House is that he is as irresponsible as ever and that as long as he can create a good impression it does not matter how far he is from facts. I want to give the House some facts about the expansion in a capital development and the increase in the number of houses built. In 1947, at the 31st March, the total number of local authority houses completed was 691 and employed on that there were 1,452 men.
Comment on this
In 1948 the number of houses was 739 and the number employed on them was 3,079. In 1949, the number of houses had gone up to 1,871 and the number employed on them to 8,353. In 1950, at 31st March, the number of houses was 5,299 and the number employed was 12,955 and at the 31st October of this year, that is a little over a month ago, the total number of houses in course of construction by the local authorities was 10,413 and employed on them there were 12,878.
Comment on this
At the same time as that was accomplished the number of grant houses completed on the 31st March, 1947, was 456, in March, 1948, 773, in March, 1949, 1,425 in March, 1950, 2,667.
Comment on this
Deputies have expressed the view that if there was a change of Government, that if the Opposition was responsible here, in some way or other, things would have been better. At any rate, we have increased on what they did before. It ought to be remembered, not merely by some Deputies but by some people outside, that whatever criticism may be expressed, whatever faults may be found with the present Government and its record, whatever difficulties may be met with in the immediate or in the remote future, the Party opposite were in office for 16 years, we know what they did and what they did not do, they are not untried and that nobody should labour under the illusion that, well and good, if we are dissatisfied with the present crowd we can change over to something better. Their record and the results in connection with industrial production, industrial employment, agricultural production, the increase in the farmer's economy and the standard of living for all sections, the expansion in the house-building programme by local authorities and grant houses show that the position now is infinitely better than it was——
Comment on this
The facts that a number of Deputies have referred to in the course of this debate and the wide range of it make it impossible to deal with everything in the short space of an hour but I think it is necessary that certain matters that were referred to in the course of this debate should be dealt with. The debate ranged about prices, wages, the cost of living, the standard of living, in addition to the matters that I have referred to, to food subsidies, to the assistance which has been given by way of subsidy in maintaining the level of the cost of living up to a certain period, the changes that have occurred since. It is not possible at this stage to forecast what may happen in the future but, at the same time, as these subsidies were provided and as the wages of those engaged in industry and other earnings rose, this Government increased the circumstances of the most needy section of the community by raising the social services. We raised the old age pension to 17/6 a week and at the same time we modified the means test from £39 5s. 0d. to £52 5s. 0d.
Comment on this
In addition, we modified the means test for widows' and orphans' pensions. We reduced the age limit for widows. Widows are now entitled to pensions at 48. Formerly they had to be 55.
Comment on this
At the same time it was possible to provide pensions for blind pensioners at 21. Formerly they had to wait until they were 30. All these increases were granted under the Social Welfare Bill which was introduced at the end of 1948 and became operative in 1949. At the same time, we raised the pay of a whole horde of lowly paid workers. We raised the pay of road workers, agricultural workers, Garda and Army personnel. Retired State pensioners received increases in pension over and above the rates that were in operation when this Government assumed office.
In the case of all these most needy sections, the groups in the community worst hit by the impact of the last war, worst affected by the influence of shortages, rising prices and so forth, we improved their conditions, increased their capacity to meet with the difficulties and to face the problems which they are obliged to face. We felt, and all sections in this House recognised, that they were entitled to get these increases.
Deputies must remember, and it is no harm to remind them, that this time three years ago we brought forward from the Opposition a modest motion to increase the old age pension by 2/6 a week and the Government at that time said it would cost £500,000 and that the country could not afford it. Since then, we have increased the old age pension without raising taxes but rather after we had repealed the taxes amounting to £6,000,000 on beer, tobacco and cinema seats, these supplementary taxes that were introduced in this House by Deputy Aiken in the Supplementary Budget, prefaced by an introductory speech by the then Taoiseach, in order to stabilise the cost of living, in order to subsidise the foodstuffs that I have mentioned. We have since maintained the subsidies, in some cases at an increased ration, and we wiped out all this tax amounting to over £6,000,000 and we enabled the people to get the benefit of that remission in taxation and also the benefit of a reduction in income-tax by 6d. in the £.
That brings me to a section in the community which has not the same representation nor the same influence in expressing their views in Parliament or getting their position recognised, that is, the class known as the white collar worker. That section did receive certain increases under a number of the wage increases that have become operative since the change of Government. We remitted taxation on the commodities that I have mentioned and we introduced a reduction in income-tax. We modified the allowance in respect of income-tax payers and improved their position.
In addition, we made available housing subsidies for a larger and more commodious type of house under the last Housing Act. It is, perhaps, true to say that that section in the community has, since 1939, probably had to face greater difficulties than anyone, with the possible exception of the very lowly-paid sections, or those living on old age or widows' and orphans' pensions. I recognise that their position is difficult and that the problems they are obliged to deal with can only be met by a realisation, on the part of those who have responsibility in this matter, of the changed circumstances.
Deputies must have read in the papers or heard on the radio that, as a result of discussions which were held under my chairmanship in the Department of Industry and Commerce, and which arose out of meetings which the trade union representatives had with the Government, or with certain Ministers, and the Federated Union of Employers, an agreement has been arrived at between the Trades Union Congress and the Federated Union of Employers. A statement has been published which indicates the lines on which wage negotiations are to be conducted, the factors which must be taken into account, the effects which any variation in wages may have on the future economy, and future living standards, not merely of those who are directly concerned, but on the community as a whole.
In that connection I would like to express my thanks and, I believe, the thanks of the country, for the goodwill, the co-operation and the will to find a solution which was obvious at those discussions, and in the statement which was their outcome. I think those who participated in the discussions recognised not merely their responsibilities to those they represented, but their responsibilities to the community. I hope in the future, as regards whatever problems and difficulties and discussions are necessary, that they will be conducted with the same goodwill and with the same type of realisation of the responsibilities of those who represent employers and workers.
The debate has been remarkable for the fact that a number of Deputies opposite appear to be under the impression that the Government in some way or other are under pressure. I noticed that Deputy Coburn, in a very sensible, factual speech here this evening, referred to the fact that the Leader of the Opposition has not spoken in this debate, but that last week-end he took a trip to Roscommon and there expressed the view that it was time to have a general election. Now, there was no greater pastime amongst the members of the Fianna Fáil Party than holding general elections. It was really remarkable. In the space of their period of office they held a general election on an average every two and a half years.
Comment on this
It was quite satisfactory as long as they got back. I am reminded of a circular issued by the Fianna Fáil General Election Finance Committee, dated December, 1947——
Comment on this
I will not trouble the House by reading it out fully, but this is part of what it said:—
"We are about to face a general election, the importance of which to each one of us cannot be overemphasised ...
It is not made clear whether the importance attaches to each one of the signatories or to the Party as a whole.
References have been made both here and elsewhere to the need for a stable Government. If there is one thing more than another that we should recognise it is that during the past three years we have had stable government. During that period economic conditions have been improved; in that same period we have seen more people employed; there has been greater production and there has been greater prosperity than at any time in our history. We have had all that, despite the gloomy prognostications and all the dim forecasts from Deputies on the other side of the House.
Comment on this
The only solution from the Leader of the Opposition is that we should have a general election. In the course of his speech he mentioned the fact that we had borrowed and spent more than they had. The fact is that without any increase in taxation, without putting any greater burden, rather by lessening the burden on the community, we have succeeded in building more houses and in producing more from our factories; we have expanded employment and given more general security. Fianna Fáil's solution of that problem is to hold a general election.
It is no harm to remark in that connection that those who feel they can with impunity criticise or weaken the Government can only do so as long as they have a Government here to criticise. There is a great danger that some people will be misled by petty grievances, by individual disagreements, sometimes even almost of a personal nature, and certainly local in their effect, to withdraw their support from this Government. The result may be that some time or other the Government will fail to have a majority. If that position is reached, then the responsibility will be theirs. I believe there is not one of them who, though at times, he may act in a reckless or purely individual capacity, does not recognise that he was elected to this House to replace the Fianna Fáil Government, and that there is only one alternative to this Government, and that is the Party opposite. If, through any individual disagreement, or by any reckless use or misuse of his voting power in the Dáil, he weakens this Government in any way, or reduces its authority, then the responsibility for the change will be his.
The conditions that have been brought about and that I have outlined—the things we have drastically improved and radically altered in the course of the past three years—might all be nullified by any change or weakening of the position. We face the future with confidence. There may be difficulties, and it would be rash in present circumstances to imagine that because there is a conflict which at the moment appears far away, and which in other days might be regarded as having little influence on conditions in this country, we will not be affected. Modern war and all it means, the implications of modern war in the rearmament of countries not directly concerned, have an immediate effect, and will certainly have a quick effect on conditions in a small country, in a country such as this. The effect is shown in increases in costs, in shortages of materials, difficulties of securing commodities, demands for raw materials that are required for rearmament purposes, and all the other effects of which we have had experience in the past.
In this connection it is remarkable how short memories can become, and how easy it is to magnify some difficulties, elevate them to points of principle, elevate a temporary dislocation of one kind or another to a point at which not merely do people convince themselves, but they seek to convince others, that conditions are worse and that the whole situation is out of control. Nothing could be further from the truth, as the facts I have outlined show.
There have been various attempts made, successfully in places, by the Opposition to create a scare, to create difficulties. These attempts have succeeded in influencing some people on this side of the House. They have succeeded in putting their propaganda across. Anyone listening here to-night to Deputy MacEntee or to the debate to-day when Deputy Aiken was speaking, anyone listening to the whole of this discussion, and particularly to Deputies opposite during the past month—the debate began four weeks ago to-morrow—would be led to believe that there has been a notable deterioration in conditions in this country.
We had speeches in this debate such as that delivered by Deputy Larkin. He recognised the problems and difficulties that had to be dealt with, and at the same time showed that the credit side had still a good deal in hand. The view was expressed that we are dealing with the situation, and that the Government is tackling it on the basis of giving priority to first things and to essentials, and that we can surmount whatever problems, difficulties or shortages that may have to be faced.
It would be wrong to imagine that, because the conflict is remote, we can isolate ourselves from it. We have never taken that view. Over a long period the Government has a Cabinet sub-committee working on preparations. As a result, we have got in supplies of a number of commodities. It is to be remembered, of course, that some of the shortages, as regards raw materials, which we require, are also required by countries engaged in the production of armaments. They are required by them for the purposes of war or for the building up of reserves. It depends on where they are and who has control of them, the amount that will be made available, whether we can get supplies and, if so, in what quantities. We take the view that, as long as we can secure these essential supplies, and so avoid the introduction of restrictions, we will do so. I do not believe the House would expect me to say definitely on behalf of the Government that, if a number of commodities become scarce elsewhere, or if restrictions have to be imposed elsewhere, that it may not be the responsibility of this Government to impose certain restrictions. If that has to be done, then I have no doubt the country will recognise that the present war, the conflict that is now taking place with resultant preparations elsewhere, is not of our choosing.
This country has pursued a policy of peace in its international discussions. That is our policy in so far as we can make it effective in the councils of the nations and on the various bodies on which we are represented. We are anxious to use the influence which this country has—it has been referred to as that of a vast spiritual empire— in the cause of peace. If we are obliged to face more difficult times in the future, then we will face them stronger economically and stronger in every other way than we could have faced them at any time since February, 1948. That is not bad claim. It is no bad achievement for a Government which represents in a unique way all sections of the community, a Government which, of course, has problems incidental to a wide representation.
I want to conclude by saying that we will push forward the plans which we have, in the knowledge that we have public support for them and the backing of the majority of the elected representatives in Parliament. As long as we have that majority, we are not going to put the country to the expense of a general election, or to the dislocation incidental to an election.
Comment on this
The Government here has the backing of the majority of the elected representatives. That majority was expressed in 1948. Since then we have had three by-elections. Two of these seats were retained by the Parties which had them in the past. The other seat was a Fianna Fáil seat, and this time last year an inter-Party candidate won that by-election. Since then, inter-Party majorities have, in the case of a great many of the county councils and local councils, replaced Fianna Fáil majorities. In face of that expression of public opinion, and of the changed complexion of those local councils and of the invigorating effect of the victory in the West Donegal by-election, it is stretching the uses of political debate to have to listen to some of the things which were said here. The Leader of the Opposition went down to Roscommon and said that we should have a general election.
Comment on this
You are all agreed on one thing, that you will never face the people until you have to.
Comment on this
It is no harm to remark that the rumours there used to be have died very quickly. We used to hear the rumour that the Government would not last three weeks; then it was extended to three months and, finally, to six months. The Opposition know that we are adjourning now into the spring, when the Government will be introducing one of its most comprehensive proposals, proposals to increase the social services, and that, in addition, we are proceeding with our Bill to give back to the local councils power to deal with the matters which come before them. I may say that, over the whole range of Government policy in so far as we have the power and responsibility, and in so far as we have been able to minimise the effects from outside, we have sought to implement our policy.
I do not know what is wrong with the Opposition. They must be feeling the draught. Their speeches ranged over every subject in the course of this debate. As Deputy Coburn said, one Deputy opposite talked of the price of eggs and the price of butter, and said the price of everything had gone sky high. Deputy Corry, who comes from Cork, says that the farmers are depressed. Deputy Ó Briain followed suit, and said eggs were 2/- a dozen, and that it was a scandalous price. Deputy Vivion de Valera said that they were 5/6 somewhere else. That is a sort of two-faced policy, one policy for city audiences or for people behind closed doors—to spread false talk, false rumours and give out false dope of any kind, and then go to the country and give the dope there that will suit. This Government has faced up to its responsibilities and its duties. It has served all sections of the community and is concerned to see that the most needy sections are dealt with on the basis that they come first. Others will be taken in the order of priority. We do not accept, and will in no way be guided by a document which says that we are about to face a general election.
It cannot be over-emphasised that the bulk of the signatories to that document are people enjoying protection which is provided by the nation to enable them to provide employment, to give the people of this country the right to earn their livelihood and so provide themselves and their families with a decent standard of living in their own country. We have never taken the view—we do not take it now —that people are not entitled under this Government to get a reasonable profit and reasonable remuneration. So far as persons who are enjoying protection or who are providing employment are concerned, they need not fear, nor need they think they can in some way or another by propaganda create the impression that this Government are out to destroy private enterprise or the rights of private property. This Government believe in private enterprise and have achieved results under that system comparable with or better than those in most other countries. These people need not worry or fear and the Opposition may give up trying to create the impression, either through the Irish Press or the expression of their views in the Dáil, that we are in some way determined to undermine the fabric of this State by, as they stated at one time, being dragged at the heels of the Labour Party or State socialism and, at another time, being dragged at the heels of the farmers or those who want to raise prices for the rural community. They also say that the Fine Gael axe is taking the heads off all these people, but the facts are there.
We have combined and we have succeeded in achieving better conditions for all the people in the country, irrespective of whatever temporary difficulties or problems they have to face, than they ever had in the past. I am glad to be associated with, and proud to have associated with me, the various Deputies who sit behind the Government, irrespective of whatever Party they belong to or whatever policy they had in the past, in a policy which has succeeded in giving this country stable Government and in providing the people with such economic, social and national conditions that they can express satisfaction that it was given to this Government to have the responsibility of guiding the destinies of a free Ireland.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?