Committee on Finance. - Local Government (County Administration) Bill, 1950—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–125 of 250. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 1950 ›
Ar son an Teachta Donnchadh Uí Briain, táirgím leasú 1:—
I leathanach 4, líne 24, "assistant county officer" a scrios agus "leas-riarthóir contae" a chur ina n-ionad.
Is é cuspóir an leasuithe ná animneacha Gaeilge d'úsáid an oiread agus is féidir. Támaid ag fáil lochta ar aicmí áirithe mar gheall ar gan téarmaí Gaeilge d'úsáid níos mó agus minicí. Maidir linn féin, nach ceart go dtabharfamais an dea-shampla i nithe den tsórt seo, go mór-mhór nuair a thagann Bille ós cóir na Dála.
The purpose of this amendment, as I have pointed out, is to change the name of "assistant county officer" to "leas-riarthóir contae".
Comment on this
"A leas-riarthóir contae" and that would be just as easy as saying "assistant county officer". I do not see what the difficulty would be.
Comment on this
If any Deputy can think of a better term than this, nobody will appreciate it more than I will. I think the time has come when we should try to introduce Irish terms as much as possible into matters like this. It has been done before to a certain extent. We have had the title "Córas Iompair Eireann", for instance. We adopted that title in connection with our transport legislation and it has been accepted and used by the general public. If we are in earnest in our endeavour to revive the Irish language and if we want to set a good example to the public, we have an easy way of showing our sincerity and our earnestness by doing things like this. They may be regarded as little things, but they are, nevertheless, an indication of the trend of affairs and they show that we are sincere in our anxiety to revive our native language. I, therefore, commend this amendment to the House.
Comment on this
I am in complete agreement with the principle enunciated by Deputy Kissane, but I think the words he used, which seem to me to be a literal translation of the English title, would be somewhat difficult in application. I am not an authority on terms of this kind, but it is conceivable that a term might be suggested which would not be the correct translation into Irish of assistant county officer. Perhaps the House would agree to defer this until we reach the next stage in order to give the experts an opportunity of finding a more suitable term. I can see difficulty in the use of this term. I can see difficulty in its pronunciation. I do not think it is the correct term to use and I would prefer to leave it to the experts to decide what is the correct term.
Comment on this
Probably amendment No. 2 will be taken with this. As I explained on the Second Reading, the title is of a purely temporary character and we hope eventually to base it on the more homely "runaí contae" which is at present used by county secretaries. The measure indicates here that in the transition period, we are going to have a temporary officer. I do not think any better can be done. Its equivalent in Irish, "oifigeach contae", has been utilised here. It is a temporary provision that we hope will pass speedily in some cases. I would suggest to the Deputy that there is no question of getting the Irish language out of it, but it is a question of what Irish should be used. "County officer", as literally translated, is what we are using. We prefer to see this nondescript English title replaced by a corresponding type of Irish title so that it would become popular among the people.
Comment on this
I must say that I am not satisfied with the statement of the Minister in this connection because it is no argument to say that this is just a temporary measure and that we could do nothing about the question of introducing Irish terms until such time as a permanent measure is introduced here. The sooner we start introducing Irish terms into legislation of this kind the better. I think the Minister mentioned that he had in mind the final introduction of the term "runaí contae", "county secretary", but the fact of the Minister having that in mind need not prevent us from adopting the suggestion, because all that need be done afterwards if we have to have permanent legislation, is to change one word in the terminology.
Deputy Cowan suggested that this matter should be left over until the Report Stage to give an opportunity to the language experts to have the question of terminology examined. I think that is not a bad suggestion and I would be prepared to agree, if the Minister would give an undertaking as between now and Report Stage the matter would be submitted to the language experts in the House for the adoption of the proper terminology.
Comment on this
I think the Minister ought to agree to that. He will probably find a very euphonious description.
Comment on this
I do not see any justification for departing from a proposal to give the position its Irish equivalent to the English as already suggested in the Bill for the temporary position which will be there, but will not be there for very long. It is a question of what is the more suitable Irish. I suggest "county officer" rather than giving a glorified title. We want the title to be familiarised among the people.
Comment on this
The Minister has taken up a very unreasonable attitude in this matter. It should be the function of this House, as far as it can, to popularise Irish terms of important officers either in the State service, or in the local authority service. This officer will, in the future, even when this Bill is passed, be the county administrator. There is no doubt about that. The Minister is just fooling himself in thinking he will not. He knows quite well that this officer will be the county administrator. He will be administering in the absence of a council of a county or of an urban authority the affairs of that council or urban authority. He will be actually responsible for 90 per cent. of the expenditure and for determining 90 per cent. of the expenditure in those particular areas.
I believe that no opportunity should be lost by this House in their legislation in putting a name in Irish and Irish only that will be used in ordinary everyday work. Nobody ever refers to the Taoiseach here as the Prime Minister. He is referred to as the Taoiseach by everybody. It is a name that has been learned by the whole community. He is known as the Taoiseach. The Uachtarán is known as the Uachtarán. The Ceann Comhairle is never called the Chairman of the Dáil. He is known as the Ceann Comhairle. We want to see here that the higher officer in each county will be known by an Irish term and an Irish term only and that there will be no other term used except the Irish term. I think that the House should be unanimous on this matter. I am surprised that everybody is not unanimous on it. I have no doubt that every individual member of this House is anxious to have and to promote the use of Irish terms in every respect. Definitely, we should get a permanent Irish term at this stage. I believe the Minister should have accepted Deputy Cowan's suggestion and agreed to refer this question to the translation officers of the Oireachtas to get a better term than the one here if it is possible. We are not tied to this general term in respect of this officer and we will definitely press if we do not get the Minister's assurance that he will have this matter examined.
Comment on this
All the corresponding titles will be given for every officer. In this particular Bill, there are several officers. What about the other officers? Why particularly select this man. There is an Irish equivalent being given for this officer as well as every other officer in the Bill. What is wrong with "oifigeach contae" as against "runaí contae"? That is the only difference. I suggest that "oifigeach contae" is a term which would pass as would "riarthóir contae", quite apart from Deputy Allen's point with regard to the 90 per cent. If that is at the back of the amendment, it would seem to pose a different proposition entirely and we ought to continue the manager if his argument about 90 per cent. is correct.
I submit that this is a very minor question, as to what is the more suitable equivalent or translation of "county officer" for a temporary and transient position. We suggest that "county officer" translated into Irish is the proper equivalent to use for the time being. It is a matter of "riarthóir" as against "oifigeach" and which is the more suitable. If we are to defer it for the purpose of asking the translation staff to give us some other title—they have probably been consulted already, but I cannot say definitely—we will probably get one of these terms back. It is really a trivial matter and there is nothing fundamental about it. The point of view I hold is that we do not want to entrench this man behind a title which may become popular and familiar. We prefer to wait for the time when we will have "runaí contae" which is in use at present in the case of many county secretaries and will be in use as the term "county officer" passes into oblivion, through retirement or death.
Comment on this
I want to save the Minister from making a very serious mistake. What is suggested here may appear to be minor, but there is a very big principle involved. We will have it bruited round the country to-morrow that the Minister is opposed to the use of the Irish language. I want to save the Minister from that blunder. Other people are making blunders and we are getting into trouble because of these blunders. We do not want any more blunders in regard to this matter. There is a very big element in the country who want to see Irish terms used and there is no difficulty in putting the Irish term into this Bill. There is no principle on which it can be opposed and I want the Minister to agree to the suggestion that it be allowed to go to the translation department, to the experts whom we have. They will find a suitable term and put it into the Bill, but let him not make a tragic mistake.
Comment on this
I find it very hard to follow the Minister's line of argument. He said that there are other officers mentioned in this measure, and, if we are to be consistent, these should also be in the Irish language. But let us make a start with the principal officer. The principal officer will be the person in charge of the county. Whether he is called "bainisteor contae" or "riarthóir contae", he is the principal officer and surely we should be prepared to give him his Irish title. He will be the one officer standing out in the affairs of the county and for the Minister to say that it is only a minor matter is carrying the argument a little too far.
The question is whether we are sincere about the revival of the Irish language or not. If we are sincere about its revival, we will start right now adopting the proper Irish terminology. We had a debate here before Christmas on the position of the universities, and several Deputies made references to the lack of provision in these educational institutions for the promotion of the Irish language. We expect everybody else to toe the line in connection with the language and are inclined to do nothing ourselves. Here is an opportunity for us to show an example. Let us show that example and not expect others to put themselves out and expose themselves to difficulties and inconveniences which we are not prepared to face.
I ask the Minister again to reconsider the whole question. It is a question of vital importance in relation to the language. There are many people watching us here from that point of view, and, as Deputy Cowan has said, we will be judged on the basis of what we say and do in this House as regards the revival of the language. It is a serious matter and I ask the Minister to reconsider the position. I ask him to give an undertaking that, between now and Report Stage, if there is any objection to the terminology proposed here, he will consult the translation staff and have the best possible term adopted.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom go nglacfaí leis an moladh atá agam annseo maidir leis an leasú seo. Níor thuigeas go mbeadh sé ar súil chomh luath sa trathnóna. Tá a fhios agam go bhfuil sé deacair é seo a chur i dtuigsint i nGaeilge don Aire toise ná dtuigeann sé go ró-mhaith í.
My purpose in submitting this and the following amendment —"leas-riarthóir contae" in ionad "assistant county officer" and "riarthóir contae" in ionad "county officer"—was to have the position accepted in regard to these posts that we have generally accepted in regard to the head of the Government being known as Taoiseach, the second in command being known as Tánaiste, the presiding Chairman in the Dáil being known as Ceann Comhairle and his next in command as Leas-Cheann Comhairle. We have Córas Iompair Eireann generally accepted now—the term C.I.E. is probably more often used—and with the progress that Irish is making all over the country, there is no reason why this term should not be accepted and accepted solely for describing these officials in future.
I think the amendment is one that should commend itself to the Minister, to the Government, and to the whole Dáil, irrespective of Party, and I did not expect that there would be any objection to it on the part of the Minister. I am surprised that there is. The words are simple. I took the best advice I could get in regard to the terms I have used before putting down the amendments. I think the words I have selected, "leas-riarthóir", will describe competently in Irish the position that the new official will occupy. I add my voice to that of Deputy Eamon Ó Ciosáin asking the Minister to accept this amendment. I would be satisfied if he were agreeable to examine the term. If he is advised that the term is unsatisfactory and that a better one can be suggested, I will be perfectly satisfied. I ask him to accept the spirit in which the amendment is put down, that it will be a step forward in the use of Irish generally all over the country. He should have no difficulty whatever in accepting this amendment.
Comment on this
I think we should not waste any more time on this matter. We should all be agreed on it, and if a better interpretation exists it can be got. Bord na Móna is a case in point. We are all accustomed to it. I cannot speak Irish, but I fail to see why we should waste so much time over a matter of this kind on which we can all agree.
Comment on this
At the outset, I should like to advise Deputy Cowan that I am doubtful if he is right in saying that I would be misinterpreted. There was never a question of Irish being excluded in this.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan expressed the fear that I was making a tragic mistake and would be interpreted — or misinterpreted—as opposing the Irish language. I made it perfectly clear that it was a question as between two titles for this particular officer, whether he should be called "oifigeach chontae" or "riarthóir chontae". I also adverted to the fact that it was rather peculiar that there were only two amendments down dealing with this. There are other officers—and even the county council itself is not covered by any amendment.
Comment on this
We all know of "Ceann Comhairle" and "Leas-Cheann Comhairle,""Taoiseach" and "Tánaiste,""Dáil" and "Seanad"; but here we have an alteration suggested only for one officer and his assistant.
Comment on this
Other officers are not dealt with. "County council" itself does not appear here. In the 1940 Bill there was no Irish translation of "county manager". We had him there in all his glorification, and also the term "county secretary". Here we are putting in the term "county officer" and its equivalent in Irish. The question of taking Deputy Ó Briain's version or another one is the point. It is an office which I hope will be a transient one. The words "riarthóir chontae" might be interpreted as "county administrator", when we want to keep it as insignificant as possible. We describe him as "county officer" and use that only for the temporary period he is there. He will disappear in time and the permanent officer will not be "county officer" or "riarthóir" or "oifigeach". He will be "rúnaí chontae". My reference was to the fact that we are dealing with a temporary office and a dispute as between one term or another does not seem worth the candle. However, if the movers are very insistent, I am not tied to it and it is purely a minor point to me. If they like I will let it go back to the translation staff to find a word for that particular office and I will accept whatever the translation staff suggests as being most suitable and will bring it in on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I had the word "oifigeach" in mind, but it is one which does not commend itself to me. It is too like the English word, "officer," and looks anglicised, at any rate. It may be from the Latin; I do not know. The word "riarthóir" is a more fundamentally Irish word. That is the sole reason why I suggested it in the amendment. It is an easy word for anyone to get around, after a few attempts.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:—
To add to the section a new sub-section as follows:—
(4) Sub-section (3) of Section 5 of the Rats and Mice (Destruction) Act, 1919, shall cease to have effect in relation to councils of counties or councils of boroughs other than the council of the Borough of Dún Laoghaire.
In this Bill we are providing the necessary powers in the executive committees of the counties to deal with this particular matter. It does not apply in the Borough of Dún Laoghaire and, therefore, we must retain the powers they have to deal with the rats and mice pest.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:—
To add to the section a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) The repeal by this section of Section 60 of the Local Government Act, 1925 (No. 5 of 1925), and Section 13 of the Local Government Act, 1927 (No. 3 of 1927), shall not affect the operation of those sections as applied by any Act passed before this Act.
This deals with disqualifications. In some of the bodies—for instance, agricultural committees and vocational committees—there are powers of disqualification. It is necessary to pass this amendment, to exempt them from any interference under their own Act in this Act. This County Administration Bill has its own terms for dealing with disqualification of members, but the others are different and have to get the disqualification under this amendment.
Comment on this
As we have already had a discussion on the matter of Irish terms, might I suggest to the Minister that on the Report Stage he bring in Irish terms, and Irish terms only, in respect of names of counties, that he make a start right through this Bill and introduce these permanent Irish terms without reference to any alternative English terms?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:—
To delete sub-section (2), lines 9 to 18, and substitute:—
(2) Where the Local Appointments Commissioners recommend a person for appointment as county officer for a county such person shall be deemed to have been appointed as county officer for the county as and from the date of the recommendation.
Comment on this
The Bill provides:—
"Where—
(a) the Local Appointments Commissioners recommend a person for appointment as county officer for a county, and
(b) the council of a county do not, within three months after the date of the recommendation, appoint such person to be county officer to the county, such person shall be deemed to have been appointed on the expiration of the said three months by the council as county officer for the county."
It has happened in the past that officers have been selected on the recommendation of the Local Appointments Commissioners and for one reason or another have not been appointed by the local authority and there was considerable difficulty, considerable delay and considerable interference with local administration. It is clear that it is the Local Appointments Commissioners who, in fact, make the appointment although theoretically they only make a recommendation. The object of the amendment is to deal with the situation and provide that where the commissioners recommend a person he shall be deemed to be appointed as county officer as from the date of the recommendation. The fact is that the commissioners recommend a person who must, according to the law, be appointed, but the Bill provides that there may be a period of three months during which there can be a lot of propaganda and considerable waste of time. It is just as well that we should face up to the situation now. Where there is a vacancy and a person is recommended by the commissioners he should be deemed to be appointed as from the date of the recommendation. That, in my view, would obviate a lot of the difficulties and delays that have occurred in the past and may occur in the future and it is for that reason that I have put down this amendment.
Comment on this
The object of this amendment is to delete sub-section (2) (b) of Section 9 and to substitute a new section. Many objections will be apparent to the House to this procedure. One is that it gives the appointment to the Local Appointments Commissioners whereas it was and is the intention of the Bill to return appointment and removal from office to the elected representatives on the county council. If this is given effect to the commissioners will make an appointment; the county council meet monthly or bi-monthly and they will find the new county officer installed when they arrive. He is sent down with instructions to take up duty and I think that is discourteous and bad business. The county council should at least have an opportunity to receive the recommendation of the commissioners and by a resolution accept their nominee. If this were accepted nobody would know anything about it until he arrived. Also he would be paid from the moment of appointment but usually he would be working in another position and would have to give notice. The county council are entitled at least to the courtesy and respect of getting a recommendation and having the opportunity to accept it. There is no justification for the amendment; it would make for more confusion than the Deputy thinks and would create awkward situations.
Comment on this
As far as this amendment is concerned the Minister has offered two arguments, one of which seems reasonable: that there may be difficulties so far as the nominee is concerned. As far as the county council are concerned they cannot refuse to make the appointment. They are bound to accept whoever is appointed by the commissioners and the passing of a resolution accepting the appointment of the new county officer is purely a formality.
Comment on this
Agreed. But there is an interim period, whereas the amendment says that when the commissioners recommend a person as county officer he shall be deemed to be appointed as from the date of recommendation and he is entitled to take up duty at once. I am not questioning the county council's acceptance of the nomination, but in courtesy and as a matter of business we are bound to give the council an opportunity of meeting and accepting the recommendation.
Comment on this
I think that the Minister in (b) of Section 9, sub-section (2), suggested to Deputy Cowan to put down an amendment. This sub-section is unusual, to my mind. The council have no option whatever. I cannot see any reason for paragraph (b). The Minister did not explain why he saw fit to introduce it into the section, as other legislation has made it mandatory on the council to make the appointment. Otherwise, councils would never make some of these appointments, as they would not agree. I do not agree that Deputy Cowan's amendment improves the position, but I suggest that the Minister himself might well delete paragraph (b), as it is unnecessary.
Comment on this
It is well to face facts, and the fact is that when a man is recommended by the commission the county council have no say in the matter. You may talk about courtesy, but to tell the council that the commission have recommended a certain person and that they are bound to appoint him by passing a resolution does not seem to me to be treating the council very courteously at all. They have no option; they must appoint the person who is recommended and they are called upon to pass a formal resolution of appointment, although they have no say in the matter. That procedure, in my view, is not facing up to the facts at all. What I want to do in the amendment is simply to say that a particular person is appointed on the recommendation of the commission and, therefore, he is appointed from the date they recommended him. I do see that the Minister has made a point that there might probably be some little difficulty about it if he has to take up duty on that day. In actual fact, I do not think there would be any great difficulty about that. It is only a small matter of machinery whereby the Local Appointments Commission can send down the recommendation at the time they are asked to send it down. It may be that the amendment as I put it down is capable of being improved somewhat. However, I think it would avoid a lot of trouble in the future if county councils who have no function in the appointment of their county officers simply received the county officers that are recommended or appointed by the Local Appointments Commission.
I think it is much better to face the situation squarely than to provide that the council are bound by law to appoint the person recommended by the Local Appointments Commission. The Bill states that if you do not do it within three months, then, whether you do it or not, the particular individual nominated is deemed to have been appointed. Where is the justification for that? Where is the justification for suggesting to the county council that they may hold up the appointment for three months? Three months is a very important part of a year. It is one quarter of a year. This Bill suggests that they may hold it up for three months—that the county may be deprived of the services of the person who is, in fact, nominated as their particular county officer. The individual in question may be an officer in another county, doing other work, and he may be waiting from day to day to know whether this county council are going to appoint him or not or whether he is just deemed to be appointed at the expiration of the three months' period. Is it not better to face the facts once and for all so that, when the request is made to the Local Appointments Commission, the person they select is appointed as from the day they recommend his appointment to the local authority? The only reason for using the word "recommendation" in that sense was simply to follow the law as it applies to the Local Appointments Commission. I would rather face the situation instead of suggesting that the county councils can hold up the matter for three months, and at the end of the three months' period the person is deemed to be appointed whether they wish it or not.
Comment on this
You could take my amendment, No. 9, with this amendment. It is the same sort of argument and we could discuss them all together. My amendment seeks to avoid any delay. It is really the same principle exactly. We could avoid a lot of duplicate argument.
Comment on this
I cannot see, from Deputy Cowan's argument, how this procedure will shorten the three months. I may say that there is a precedent for the three months' period. If the council does not move inside the three months' period, the Minister may take action. In this amendment the person selected by the Local Appointments Commission, without any further discussion with or notification to the county council, is an officer from the moment he is appointed. Deputy Cowan's argument is not about the three months' period at all. Deputy Cowan seeks to provide that whether the appointee is working or not, and is appointed by the Local Appointments Commission, he will be deemed to have been appointed as county officer for the county as and from the date of the recommendation. In my opinion that amendment, if carried, would create chaos and confusion. The point in connection with the three months' period is already covered. If the council should prove to be recalcitrant and does not move, the Minister may take certain steps in connection with the matter. I feel that the same courtesy which is extended at present to the county manager and the county officer should be extended to the county council. The Local Appointments Commissioners should notify them and say: "We have appointed X." They can then proceed to install him in office and at the next meeting of the council he can be introduced to the members. That would be better than that a man should just come down and that the members should find him sitting in the office before the assembly of the council. I suggest that the matter is covered already.
Comment on this
I do not know everything about local government law but I should imagine that there is some provision in connection with officials of local authorities. I am quite sure that, within the Department, there are regulations that he would hardly draw pay from two county councils: certainly, he would hardly draw pay from one county council for which he was not working. However, that is a matter which I need not go into. When you are dealing with a Bill there is no question of talking about courtesy. The county council have no function. They apply and say that they want a county officer and they ask the Local Appointments Commission to appoint him. When they appoint him, the county council are bound to appoint him whether they like it or not. Even though they delay, in my opinion, they cannot hold it up three months, at the end of which period he is automatically deemed to be appointed under the Bill. I urge the Minister to take the county councils out of pain. I urge him not to suggest to them that they have any powers when in fact they have not got them. I submit that it is no courtesy to them to suggest to them that they have powers when in fact they have not got these powers. However, if my amendment does not commend itself to the House I shall not push it any further. I say again that it would be much better if we faced realities—it would be much better for the county councils and for everybody concerned —rather than suggest that local authorities have powers when in fact they have not got them. That is anything but courtesy to them.
Comment on this
Could the Minister explain to us why (b) of sub-section (2) of this Section 9 is necessary? Under the present law, would the county officer not be appointed in the ordinary way without any appreciable delay?
Comment on this
Whatever about the powers they are alleged to have or not to have, the fact is that the county council has asked the Appointments Commission to do a job. Do Deputies not think that at least the Appointments Commission ought to reply to the people who ask them to make the appointment? Is that courtesy or discourtesy? Is it courtesy when they will not reply to the county council who have asked them to appoint a man to go down and take up duty? I suggest that it is most discourteous to the county council who have asked the Appointments Commissioners to do the job for them. The Appointments Commissioners ought at least to report to the people who have asked them to make the appointment. They could send a letter saying: "We have carried out your request and appointed X." Do you think it courteous to send a man down to the job without thinking it worth your while to notify the county council? I suggest that notification should be sent to the chairman or the secretary of the county council to the effect that the Local Appointments Commission have appointed a certain person who is eligible to take up duty on behalf of the county council. He could then get in touch with the county council and arrange a date for a meeting.
Comment on this
That is the present procedure.
Comment on this
But it would not be the procedure under this amendment. Under this amendment the county council ask the Local Appointments Commissioners to do a certain job for them, and the Appointments Commissioners simply say to the man: "You are elected." I think Deputy Cowan is not being fair to the men who ask to have the job done.
Comment on this
The Minister has not yet answered my question, which is really an important one. Is sub-section (b) necessary? Why is the Minister inserting in Section 9 clause (b) of sub-section (2)?
Comment on this
While the Minister is looking up that point, I want to ask, if the local authority want a county officer appointed and they ask the Local Appointments Commissioners to appoint one, could not they say that they want him appointed as from a particular day? Cannot they do that?
Comment on this
Deputy Allen has suggested that they might have difficulty in finding him. Personally, I do not think so, because within the local government service you have a very big pool of efficient people who are looking for promotion to these important posts and there certainly will not be any shortage of applicants, in my opinion. Therefore, no difficulty really arises. I do not think anybody else would be appointed but a person who was serving in local government.
Comment on this
That may be so, but I think as time goes on nobody will be appointed as county officer except a person who is in the service of a local authority. Perhaps my amendment might have been better if, instead of using the word "of" in the last line, I used the words "set out in", in other words, that he would be appointed as from the date set out in the recommendation. That would get over all the Minister's difficulties about it. If there was a recommendation to appoint a certain person, the Local Appointments Commissioners would say he was appointed county officer as from a particular date and that would get over the difficulty about his reporting to the council.
Comment on this
Surely the date is usually a matter of negotiation, because it might not be convenient for that man, if he is in another job and there is something very important going on, to drop that suddenly, in the middle. It might be better for him to wait a month, or something like that.
Comment on this
Is not that the present method and the present position?
Comment on this
What is the point in having this provision of three months at all? Why not leave the thing as it is? Has not that worked satisfactorily?
Comment on this
It is for the purpose of cutting out one of the things that the Deputy always likes cut out, namely, any reference to courts of law.
Comment on this
It is to provide against a writ of mandamus proceedings. The normal way of enforcing the appointment of a person recommended by the Local Appointments Commissioners is by way of mandamus proceedings.
Comment on this
These proceedings might be very costly on the councils. Therefore, a period of three months was fixed.
Comment on this
That never has arisen. When the position of county medical officer of health was first introduced, a few county councils in the South, as far as I remember, refused to make the appointment at all. It was not a refusal to appoint any individual, but they did not want the office at all. I do not remember whether the Department proceeded by way of mandamus or not in order to get the councils to make the appointments but, as far as I can remember—I am speaking subject to correction—a case has never arisen where a council had to be proceeded against in order to enforce the appointment of a certain individual to a position such as this. I suggest that the matter should be left as it was.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 8 falls with No. 5. I do not know whether Deputy Childers agrees that amendment No. 9 also falls.
Comment on this
It is rather a different principle. I am not sure whether this amendment is necessary or not.
Comment on this
I am sorry. We have not come to it. Would it not be better to wait until we come to amendment No. 9?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:—
In sub-section (3), line 20, to delete "Minister" and substitute "council of the county."
I do not think there can be any objection to this amendment. Whenever the office of a county officer is vacant, the Minister shall appoint a person until an appointment is made. That is what the Bill provides. My amendment is simply to provide that the council of the county will appoint the temporary county officer. I think there could be no objection to that. If there is a vacancy a person is to act for a period while the Local Appointments Commissioners are considering the appointment of a permanent county officer, or for some other reason. There is no reason in the world why that should be referred to the Minister. That should be done by the local authority and I would ask Deputies who are conversant with local government to insist on the right of the local authority to make that kind of appointment for a temporary period. If we are talking about rights of local authorities, democracy, and all that sort of thing, this is the place where we ought to apply it. I ask the House to agree to the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not know if this particular function would confer any great power on the county councils that they would be anxious to receive. The Deputy has suggested that they have not very much power. This would not give them much power and I think anyone who has experience of working on a local council would be anxious to avoid having to make a temporary appointment. There would be the usual influences brought to bear and there would be a tendency, when the man would be appointed, to prolong the temporary appointment unduly, or there might be. Whereas, the amendment that I have put down —amendment No. 7, which I have put down in order to try to meet the point made by the Deputy—provides for the insertion of the words "after consultation with the chairman of the council of the county." Before making the appointment the Minister would consult with the chairman about the appointment of a temporary officer. There is no overriding of the council there. Finally, the Minister has the control and sanction in respect of this office and there is nothing very wrong about that. I am not trying to introduce myself, as the Minister, unduly into this matter but, in the interest of the effectiveness of the Bill, it would be better to have the Minister and chairman consult about this temporary appointment before it is made and thus obviate the general spate of canvassing of the various members that would otherwise be done by candidates and the tendency on the part of the members to prolong the temporary appointment unduly and to postpone a permanent appointment. I do not think there is any intention in the section to interfere with the powers of local authorities. The power that would be conferred on them by Deputy Cowan's amendment is one that would not be desired by the ordinary members who have experience of working on county councils. Amendment No. 7 goes a fair distance to meet Deputy Cowan in providing that the Minister must consult with the chairman of the county council before making a temporary appointment.
Comment on this
This amendment is one that the Minister should accept. I cannot see anything very revolutionary in it. This is a temporary appointment. If the office becomes vacant, the council of a county would, if Deputy Cowan's amendment were accepted, be given power to make a temporary appointment of a county officer. I can assure the Minister that councils will have no heart-burning whatever about it. What the ordinary council and, I suppose, what every council in Ireland would do, would be to appoint the senior officer of their own county, the secretary, if there is one, or the accountant or the senior officer attached to the local authority. That is whom they would appoint as temporary county officer. There would be no question of doubt about it. I think the Minister should definitely accept Deputy Cowan's amendment. It is most unusual to have a Minister of State appointing a temporary officer to a local authority. It is undignified, and I suggest that the Minister should not lower the dignity of his ministerial office by taking on the job of making temporary appointments to this, as he described it, minor office. He should allow the council of a county to act. After all, they are sensible people, fully competent, and I have no doubt they will make less mistakes than, possibly, the Minister's Department might make. They will have more knowledge of the competency of the officer they put into the position. They will be on trial in selecting an existing officer in the service—he must be an existing officer in the service. Probably it would be better if Deputy Cowan would add words such as "subject to the Minister's sanction". After appointment by the council, he must be sanctioned by the Minister. That should satisfy the Minister.
Comment on this
I am in entire agreement with Deputy Cowan and Deputy Allen. I think it would be very undesirable to have these appointments made otherwise than by the council. I think the point the Minister made could be met quite easily by an amendment something along the lines of amendment No. 9, in the name of Deputy Childers, but I would bring forward the time because I think three months would be too long for them to decide to apply. They could apply within a month of the temporary appointment being made and it would be then a matter for the Appointments Commissioners as to how long the temporary officer would remain there. I suggest the Minister should accept this amendment. Of course, any temporary officer is automatically subject to sanction.
Comment on this
I am pleased to hear experienced members of local authorities supporting my view. When you have a temporary vacancy it is most desirable that it should be filled by the local authority and that it should be filled by one of their own officers. If the Minister appoints, he might not appoint from the officers of that council; he could send in a person from Wexford to Kildare.
Comment on this
And that is what I consider objectionable. County councils have performed very responsible duties. Taking them by and large, they carry out their duties in a responsible way. They are responsible for the expenditure of very big sums. They do their work very efficiently, and I would have more trust in the judgment of local councils than I would in the officials of the Department in the Custom House when they would be considering this matter. In the consideration of it the Minister is only a pure formality.
The Minister talked about influence. When we are dealing with a Bill of this kind the less we say about influence the better. This Bill is designed to give powers to the local authorities because we are satisfied that they will not be improperly influenced in the exercise of their duties. That was the old criticism of local authorities when they were deprived of many of their powers— that they were subject to undue influence. I have a little experience of a local authority and I must say I have been very favourably impressed by the efficient way in which the members of the Dublin Corporation carry out their duties—the very responsible way in which they carry them out.
I think there has been too much of a tendency in local government to tie up local authorities with the red tape of the Department. Everything must go to the Department for sanction, for approval; nothing can be done without the Minister's approval or sanction. As a matter of fact, if all these duties were carried out by the Minister he would have time to deal with the affairs of only a couple of local authorities; he would have no time to deal with all the manifold duties of his Department. In actual fact, the words "the Minister" do not mean the Minister; they mean a very experienced official in his Department. Local authorities should, as far as possible, be free from this, hamstringing red tape that we have in the Department of Local Government. For that reason I am very glad to find that this amendment has received approval from people who are experienced in local administration.
Comment on this
I am in complete sympathy with the ideas expressed by Deputy Cowan in order to disabuse the minds of people in the country that there will be any infliction from above or that there will be any undue importation of officers from outside places. I thought that consultation with the chairman of the county council would obviate the danger of anyone being brought in from outside as long as there was a man in the council's service suitable for the position. I am proposing to continue what was set out in the 1940 Act. Sanction has to be given to the appointment of temporary managers. What is here is the same as what was in the 1940 Act. Provision is made for consultation.
There is this point to be considered. A vacancy takes place in a particular county and the council is not meeting and may not meet for three weeks. Through sudden death or for some other reason the office becomes vacant. What is going to happen? Do you want an immediate or a temporary appointment made? I suppose there could be a hastily convened meeting of the council. I ask you not to leave the county without an officer for any length of time. I suggest that the speediest method and the best way to protect local interests would be for the Minister to get in touch with the county manager or the county council chairman and proceed to make the appointment.
I have not any fundamental objections to the proposal made by Deputy Cowan. I am merely anxious to get the most effective and the speediest way to deal with an emergency, to be prepared for an emergency. You have no guarantee that the procedure will be normal every time. Subject to that, I would not be averse to accepting the amendment. I am merely pointing out certain difficulties. The council might not meet for a month. Even then sanction will have to come from the Minister. You cannot keep him out.
Comment on this
We will try to keep him out as much as possible. We are honestly trying to make a good job of the Bill. I am glad the Minister will accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I will bring in an amendment of my own on the next stage to meet the Deputy's point.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:—
Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(4) Within three months of the appointment of a county officer under sub-section (3) of this section the council of the county shall proceed to apply to the Local Appointments Commission for the appointment of a county officer.
I am moving this amendment just in case it is necessary to ensure that there will not be any delay on the part of the particular county council proceeding to apply for the appointment of a county officer when a vacancy takes place and after the temporary officer is appointed. It may be that under existing legislation there can be no delay. I put down the amendment with the same object as Deputy Cowan —to make sure that everything runs smoothly and quickly with regard to these appointments.
Comment on this
This amendment is unnecessary because the point is covered by the existing law—Section 6 (2) of the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926. That provides that where a local authority does not, within three months after an office becomes vacant or is created, either request the commissioners to recommend a person for appointment or make an appointment in accordance with the Act, the Minister may request the commissioners to recommend a person for appointment to the vacant office. That covers the point I think, and it is unnecessary to have it introduced in the Bill. They do not actually appoint; they recommend for appointment.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 12 and 21 might be taken in conjunction with amendment No. 10. The same principle is involved but separate decisions, if necessary, could be taken.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:—
To delete sub-section (5).
Sub-section (5) states:—
"Save as otherwise expressly provided thereby, the foregoing provisions of this section shall not apply in relation to the County of Dublin and, in lieu thereof, it is hereby enacted that every person who is duly appointed (whether permanently or temporarily) to the office of Dublin City Manager, shall by virtue of this sub-section, stand appointed (permanently or temporarily, as the case may require) to the office of Dublin County Officer."
Comment on this
The reason I suggested that the other two amendments, Nos. 12 and 21, might be debated on this amendment is that they also deal with Dublin.
Comment on this
Yes. I want to ask the Minister what is the justification for this particular sub-section which I want to delete.
Comment on this
That is a rather novel way of getting at it—going in reverse. Under the County Management Act, 1940, the Dublin City Manager was also made County Manager for Dublin County. The Dublin County Council was dissolved in 1941 and a commissioner was acting in place of the council. In June, 1942, that is two months before the 1940 Act came into operation, the County Management (Amendment) Act, 1942, was passed. This provided that the commissioner for the County of Dublin shall, during the suspension of the council perform the executive—that is the managerial —functions of the council as well as the reserved functions. The Dublin Board of Assistance was dissolved in 1942 and commissioners were also appointed, who similarly discharged the executive functions of that body. The Dublin County Council remained dissolved until 1948; when it was reconstituted the Dublin City Manager became County Manager for Dublin County.
The Local Government (Temporary) Act, 1948, dealt with the position arising out of the re-constitution of the Dublin Board of Assistance. It provided that the person who was commissioner should, under the title of chief executive officer, discharge the executive functions of the board. The position in Dublin City and County in 1948 was that the Dublin City Manager was county manager and he had the assistance of the assistant city manager who acted as borough manager for Dún Laoghaire and as manager for Grangegorman. The managerial functions of the Dublin Board of Assistance were being performed by the chief executive officer of that board. The need to concentrate and co-ordinate the housing efforts of the four housing authorities in Dublin City and County and to get the housing drive in these areas under way led in 1948 to the creation of a new job of housing director. This post was filled by transferring the assistant city manager, Mr. O'Mahoney, from Dún Laoghaire and Grangegorman, and appointing Mr. Keane, deputy city manager, Dublin Corporation, as assistant city and county manager in place of Mr. O'Mahoney. The success of the experiment of having one assistant manager for housing clearly demonstrated the value of the functional approach in the discharge of the business of the city and county. The experiment was carried a step further by appointing Mr. Keane as temporary assistant manager in charge of the health services of the city and county and by appointing the secretary of the Dublin County Council as temporary manager to discharge certain functions other than housing and health and some other functions reserved by the city manager to himself.
This Bill will repeal the Local Government (Dublin) (Temporary) Act, 1948, and the chief executive officer of the Dublin Board of Assistance will become an assistant city manager. The administration of Dublin City and County will then be fully integrated and it is intended that generally each of the assistants shall, under the city manager, discharge a block of functions in the whole area. This will make for more efficient administration. Administration on a functional basis in Dublin City and County is now all the more necessary since the setting up of separate Departments of Health and Social Welfare. I am satisfied that if the system of local government is to function efficiently in the Dublin area and to cater in a relatively small area for about 20 per cent. of the country's population then there must be an integration of administration such as is envisaged in this Bill. The point is to have all these matters in a single Bill. The county area is very small, while the metropolitan area is very big, and the present arrangement has been working very satisfactorily.
Comment on this
When I put down these amendments I considered that the responsibilities of the Dublin City Manager were really too many. The city manager has an enormous job as Manager of the City of Dublin. I must say that he carries out his duties exceptionally well; there is no doubt whatever about that, but I do think that if you have a Dublin County Council, that county council should have its own county officer and let the city be managed by the city manager and as many assistant managers as are necessary. You have the position at present that the city manager is Manager of Dublin City, Manager of Dublin County, Manager of Dún Laoghaire Borough and he has also responsibilities in connection with Grangegorman, the Dublin Board of Assistance and other functions of that nature. No one individual can carry all these responsibilities and I was anxious that, when this Bill was passed, Dublin County could claim some independence and be considered a complete county with its own county officer just the same as any other county. At the moment it has not its own county officer. I think it would make for better administration if Dublin County had its own county manager. For that reason, I put down these amendments to delete the three sub-sections which deal in a different way with Dublin County than with any other county. I am sorry that, apparently, there is nobody in the House who is a member of the Dublin County Council, but, if there was, I think he would agree with me that it is desirable that Dublin County Council should have its own county officer the same as any other council.
Comment on this
This is an example of an amendment that ought not to be put down. The speech which we have just listened to from Deputy Cowan shows that he put down this amendment in ignorance. I am not going to say that his ignorance has been very much enlightened by the explanation which the Minister for Local Government gave him; but surely it was open to the Deputy, with all the resources of the Library in this House at his disposal, to have ascertained what was the origin of this proposal to co-ordinate in some way, under one responsible executive officer, the administrative services of Dublin City and County. Any person who knows anything about the intimate relations which exist between the people who live and work in Dublin and the people who live in the county, and the way in which these services are inter-linked and have, in fact, become interdependent, will realise that there was a great deal of good sense and wisdom in the proposal which emanated not from any political head of a Department, and not from any Minister for Local Government, whether the present Minister or his predecessor or my predecessor, because this principle was enunciated in a report which was made by a tribunal, I think, of three persons, one being the eminent lawyer who is now the President of the High Court. Another member of that tribunal was, I think, the gentleman who has since been nominated as chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann, with the support, of course, of Deputy Cowan, while the third member was a person well versed in local administration whose name at the moment escapes me. They reported that some such co-ordinating arrangement as this would be desirable, and that recommendation was, I think, embodied in the County Management Act, 1940.
Now, there is the genesis of the thing, and here is Deputy Cowan coming into this House and, without bothering to satisy himself as to the reason for this arrangement, putting down an amendment of this sort. It is an amendment which, I think, will not appeal to that bulwark of his quondam Party—the Irish Times. The Irish Times has been always breast-high advocating that there should be closer co-ordination between the administration of the local services in Dublin City and Dublin County. Everybody who knows the intimate relations which exist, not merely between the two administrative bodies but between the people who live and work in Dublin City and in Dublin County, will agree that there is a very strong case indeed for this. I am surprised that a Deputy who is actually responsible for a private army to undo the partition of this country should seek to partition the country further by isolating Dublin County from Dublin City.
Comment on this
It is appropriate, and much more responsible than some of the Deputy's publications in relation to the question of Partition.
Comment on this
No, except that there is the rather strange anomaly that the Deputy who wants to conquer the Six Counties by force——
Comment on this
It is just as relevant as the proposal in the amendment to isolate Dublin County from Dublin City.
Comment on this
Very well, then, what is the justification for the Deputy's proposal? Here are two administrative units which are so closely associated with each other that they have to have, in fact, a common water supply. With their many embarrassing problems is associated the question of housing the people in the two administrative units, and yet the Deputy wants to disassociate them from each other and have them completely independent as if Dublin County were situated down somewhere in West Cork. Of course, it is not. It forms part really of the Dublin metropolitan area, and if the Deputy had any sense of organisation, instead of putting down such an amendment, he would allow the section to go through as it stands.
Comment on this
I am very sorry that Deputy MacEntee has entered into this debate at all because we were getting along nicely in trying to make this Bill a good Bill as far as local administration is concerned. I happen to have put down this amendment because I am a member of the Dublin Corporation, because I have some experience of the working of the Dublin Corporation and because I can talk with a knowledge that Deputy MacEntee was unable to obtain during his long ministerial reign. It may be that certain people recommended, some years ago, that there should be such co-ordination as he speaks about. But why are we dealing with this Bill at all? Why are we discussing this Bill? Because the County Management Bills which were introduced and strongly supported— they were introduced, I think, by Deputy MacEntee as Minister—have been found to be a failure, and now we are trying to correct them.
Comment on this
They have not. This thing is all politics.
Comment on this
We are dealing with this Bill on the basis that they have not been a success. I have discovered that, although you may have the one man as city manager of Dublin and county manager of Dublin County, such an arrangement does not make for co-ordination between the Dublin County Council and the Dublin City Council. In the Dublin City Council we do our own business relating to the city. We have nothing to do with county matters. When our city manager is with us, he deals with city matters. When he goes to the county council he deals entirely with county council matters. He may worry perhaps at night when he goes to bed about some of his difficulties. The water supply has been mentioned. The City of Dublin supplies water to parts of the Dublin County Council area and the county council pays us for that water. It is arranged under the regional water supply which has been projected, and which I hope, at some time, will become law, that water may be sent from Dublin as far as Wexford. Does that mean then that the county manager of Dublin will have to be the county manager of Wicklow and Wexford as well? There is no sense in that argument.
Deputy MacEntee got into this discussion to say a few offensive things about me and about Partition. I do not know what good that is to Deputy MacEntee. Whether he can sleep better after having made an observation like that, I do not know. I am only concerned to have this Bill improved as best we can, and I am very sorry that we have not some member of the Dublin County Council here to talk of the system from his experience. The system does not lead to any co-ordination. It imposes unnecessary work on the Dublin County Manager and we have reached a position now that when the Dublin County Manager goes from the City Hall to Parnell Square he changes his title on the way. He is city manager in the City Hall and until he reaches the county council headquarters in Parnell Square and then he becomes county officer. From Deputy MacEntee's point of view there may be something wonderful to be said for that, but in actual fact there is no co-ordination, except theoretical co-ordination by this arrangement. The Dublin City Manager as county manager deals with county affairs only and not with city affairs. These two things are kept just as much apart as they always were. When he moves up to Parnell Square he has the county council staff to advise him on county council matters such as the housing of people in Coolock or the provision of water or sewerage in Balbriggan and he deals with them. He has to forget everything about the city when in the county council office in Parnell Square, and yet I am told that is co-ordination.
I put down these amendments deliberately, having thought the matter over, believing that the city manager is overworked, that there is an enormous amount of work in Dublin City for the city manager and that there is a big amount of work, if we want county officers at all, that can be done in the County Dublin by a county officer and I say to the Minister that he should provide a county officer for the County Dublin. It is for that purpose that I have put down these amendments— not for that precise purpose, because that purpose would not be achieved by the amendments. The amendments only relate in the first instance to temporary appointments. That is as far as Section 9 (5) is concerned which deals with temporary appointments when there is a vacancy. Sub-section (4) of Section 10 deals with the first county officers and it provides that the City Manager of Dublin shall be the first county officer for the County Dublin.
I think it is time that we gave County Dublin a county officer of its own and, if we did, he would have work enough to do and he would relieve the Dublin City Manager of the enormous burden of responsibility placed upon him. No one individual can do all the work that the Dublin City Manager is called upon to do as Manager of Dublin, Manager of County Dublin and Manager of the Borough of Dún Laoghaire. If he can do all that work efficiently, and apparently he is doing all that enormous amount of work efficiently, then we could have one county officer to do the duties of about ten counties elsewhere.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Cowan has confused the question of whether there are enough executive officers for Dublin City with the question of co-ordination between the two authorities. Wherever the physical boundary of Dublin City meets that of the Dublin County Council and wherever the legal boundary, which is a very different thing, in certain circumstances meets it, there are tremendous co-ordination problems. Deputy MacEntee referred to the necessity for having one executive officer who would understand the problems of the two areas. In regard to sewerage, water and every other aspect of local administration it is absolutely essential at the present time to have such a person if there is to be efficiency in administration. As the Minister knows, there are a number of vital fundamental matters still arising for decision by him in relation to an inquiry instituted into the whole question of Dublin Corporation and Dublin County Council administration, fundamental matters for his decision based on evidence which is already becoming out-of-date owing to the fact that Dublin City is spreading so quickly. The whole question of how far Dublin County Council can be detached from Dublin Corporation in regard to administration was involved in that inquiry. I think it is most irresponsible to suggest that because the Dublin City Manager may be overworked there should not still be one person who will have a general view of the administration of the two areas.
So far as the observations made by Deputy Cowan in regard to the work of the councils are concerned, it would be very difficult for the Dublin County Council and the Dublin City Council to start doing the work of determining the matters which require co-ordination. A lot of what Deputy Cowan said underlies the whole psychology in connection with the Bill. There are a great many sections in the Bill which are trying to make civil servants of the members of local authorities. It would be ridiculous to suppose that it would be possible very often for members of the Dublin County Council or the Dublin City Council to sit and debate one way or another on the complicated matters that arise in connection with the co-ordination of the two services. The most they can do is to determine general principles and to avoid as far as possible the creation of anomalies or scandals and to remedy grievances. The idea that a manager can go from one body to another and listen to a whole series of detailed grievances is to my mind fantastic.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan's speech might have passed unanswered if in the last couple of minutes he had not shown that he did not understand his own amendment. He said that amendment No. 10, which we are discussing with amendments Nos. 11 and 12, related only to temporary officers. Amendment No. 10 is to delete sub-section (5) of Section 9. Let us see what sub-section (5) says. I do not know whether Deputy Cowan bothered to read it. Let me read it for him:—
"Save as otherwise expressly provided thereby, the foregoing provisions of this section shall not apply in relation to the County of Dublin and, in lieu thereof, it is hereby enacted that every person who is duly appointed (whether permanently or temporarily) to the office of Dublin City Manager shall, by virtue of this sub-section, stand appointed (permanently or temporarily, as the case may require) to the office of Dublin County Officer."
Deputy Cowan, who proposes to delete that sub-section without any reservation or qualification whatever, says that his amendment is intended to apply only to temporary appointments. Is it not absurd that a Deputy who does not know what he intends to do by an amendment, should put it down on the Order Paper? That is precisely the position in which the House finds itself, thanks to Deputy Cowan. I do not want to traverse the ground already covered by Deputy Childers. I am glad, in order that we may understand the working of Deputy Cowan's mind, that my intervention in the debate evoked from him some reasons in support of this amendment. The only reason which he did adduce was that there was a Dublin City Council, of which he is a member, dealing with problems relating to Dublin and dealing only with those problems within the narrow confines of the Dublin City boundaries, and that outside Dublin we had the Dublin County Council dealing similarly, with narrow vision, with the problems of Dublin County. He said that one body was concerned only with its own domestic problems and the other body was similarly concerned with the problems peculiar to it. The trouble is that these problems overlap.
Comment on this
The Deputy has admitted it. He has talked about the water supply for years. County Dublin was trying to conceive a scheme for the supply of water to North County Dublin and could not do it unless it could come to some arrangement with the Dublin Corporation. Whatever we may say about the burdens which are undoubtedly imposed upon the individual who has to fill the post at one and the same time of Dublin City Manager and Dublin County Officer, at least he has this advantage over the members of the Dublin County Council and even omniscient members of the Dublin Corporation like Deputy Cowan, that he knows both problems and when acting in his capacity as Dublin City Manager, advising to the best of his ability the members of Dublin Corporation, at least he will be aware of the problems with which the members of the Dublin County Council have to deal, and when, conversely, he is dealing with Dublin County affairs, he will be aware how these affairs entrench upon the Corporation of the City of Dublin.
Surely a person of his competence and knowledge will not act, as apparently Deputy Cowan seems to think would be the ideal situation, as if both these councils were in closed compartments. The advantage in having one person as Dublin City Manager and Dublin County Officer is that he has full knowledge of both problems and he can co-ordinate them. He has power to recommend to his council or corporation a scheme which will co-ordinate the services of Dublin City and County and so bring about, by reason of that co-ordination, greater efficiency in the services which are common to both the city and the county.
I think that is the only alternative to setting up one body which would be responsible for local government in Dublin City and County. I think it would be undesirable to have the affairs of these two separate administrative areas administered by one local authority. If we are to have separate local authorities for Dublin City, for the County Borough of Dún Laoghaire and for the County of Dublin, then we must have some co-ordinating link. I cannot see any better co-ordinating link than that which was provided in the County Management Act and which is being continued in the present Bill.
Comment on this
I have often wondered why, when matters were referred to a Department of State, certain decisions were taken. Deputy MacEntee, who has had long experience as a Minister, has clearly shown, in the contribution he has made to the debate, how wrong people can go when they are basing their decisions on theory and not on practice.
Now, let me say briefly what the position is with regard to Dublin City and Dublin County Council. In Dublin City we have a complete administrative machine. We have a city engineer, a city medical officer of health and other city officers. In Dublin County Council we have the same. We have the county medical officer of health, the county engineer and the different county officers. Each body has its own statutory functions. When the city manager is sitting with the Corporation of Dublin; he takes their advice. He is guided by them, and if there is an application from the Dublin County Council for a supply of water, say to Coolock, the City Manager of Dublin will say: "I can give a supply of water. The cost of putting in 10-inch or 12-inch pipes will be so much. Provided the county council pay, I will give it to them." The city council agrees to give it to them, saying: "We will give water to any individual who wants an extra supply of water, so long as he pays for it." He writes to the Dublin County Council to that effect, that is to say, the city manager writes to the Dublin County Council saying he is directed by the city council to say that the county council can have water if they pay so much. Then he goes up to the Dublin County Council, which considers the charge excessive and which instructs the county manager to write back to the city manager and say that they consider the price excessive. Then the county manager writes back to himself as city manager, saying that he considers the price charged to Dublin County Council to be excessive. It is said that that is co-ordination. There is no co-ordination. There is no more co-ordination between Dublin City and Dublin County than there is between Dublin and Kildare. The city manager, when he is acting as city manager, does the job of the city and when acting as county manager he does the business of the county; and he is guided in his decisions in each case by the elected representatives of the people here, either in the city council or in the Dublin County Council. I think that Deputy MacEntee was on sound grounds when he said it may be that Dublin County and City will have to be brought under the one control.
Comment on this
If that were done and if there were one engineer for the city and county, there could be co-ordination; and if there were one medical officer of health to co-ordinate all health services there would be co-ordination. These two—and the Minister knows it well—act in absolutely water-tight compartments and no amount of theory can get away from the hard facts of the situation. I happen to be dealing with the facts as they exist and not with theories formed in Deputy MacEntee's mind during the period he was Minister for Local Government. That is why local government has been a complete failure— because we had Ministers who knew nothing about local administration. Thank God, we now have a Minister who knows local administration from the very bottom up, who knows it for many years and who, when he talks in this House, talks with full understanding and knowledge and does not talk the raméis that Deputy MacEntee talks about co-ordination when there is no co-ordination. Deputy MacEntee may be flippant and abusive about me personally. I do not mind that. I want to deal only with what is in the Bill and with the contributions made by Deputy MacEntee. He will, no doubt, come back and have another attack on me, but that is not very much good from the point of view of the public or of the Dáil. I certainly do not intend to indulge in any slanging match with him. He is welcome to that, and, when the appropriate occasion for slanging comes, we will have it out.
Comment on this
We can arrange to meet on proper ground and we will fight with all the necessary weapons. These are my reasons for putting down the amendment—to give the Dublin County Council its own county officer until such time as provision is made for better co-ordination, but I want to assure the Minister that if he were to ask the city manager, the city manager would tell him that the very fact of his acting in two capacities cannot lead to any co-ordination. In theory, it may seem to do so, but, in actual practice, it does not. He will tell him that he very often has to write to himself, as county manager, refusing to agree to a suggestion he made as city manager to himself as county manager —and that is co-ordination.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan, with his local knowledge and experience on the Dublin Corporation for the past three months, should have been able to devise some other amendment to get a county manager for the County of Dublin, if that is what he is after, and we gather that is what he is after.
Comment on this
I do not want provision made in this measure that the first city manager will be the first county officer.
Comment on this
He is county manager and city manager at the moment. We would be inclined to agree with him if he were still going to leave him Dublin county manager and we might help him.