We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Local Government (County Administration) Bill, 1950—Committee Stage.

Contributions 126–250 of 250. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government (County Administration) Bill 1950
Lapsed

No. 20 of 1950 ›

If the Deputy wanted a Dublin county officer or county manager, I am sure he could have devised some amendment other than this.

Comment on this

It is in the Bill, if my amendment is carried.

Comment on this

The deletion of Section 5 will not get you a Dublin county manager right away.

Comment on this

It will, immediately.

Comment on this

I have no doubt that some other legislation covering that point would require to be repealed. To the ordinary person coming from far away from Dublin, it would appear that almost all of County Dublin is part of the city, and the day is soon coming when we will have legislation enacted here setting out that all the existing County Dublin comes within the city, plus the township of Bray. Deputy Cowan should keep in mind the fact that all in the country who can get into Dublin, County Dublin and into Bray are getting in, and the people will have less elbow-room in the future.

Comment on this

That is why I want a county manager for ourselves.

Comment on this

As a city man, I am sure the Deputy would like to take in all the county as part of the city, but I do not think he will get it through this amendment. Some other amendment is necessary to provide separate city and county officers.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan's amendments has led to a good deal of discussion, although it refers to Dublin City and County, about which some of us do not know very much. He castigated the former Minister's lack of knowledge of local administration and drew a contrast between the present Minister's experience and Deputy MacEntee's lack of experience. It is a remarkable thing that, with the Minister's experience as a member of the Limerick Corporation, he is not interfering in this Bill or in any other measure with the present Management Act in operation in Limerick City. That, as I say, is a remarkable thing in the light of the Minister's experience of local administration. It would be just as well for local administration if we had not had this Bill foisted on us to waste our time, but when it is before us, we have to discuss it and do the best we can with it. With regard to the amendment, perhaps the present arrangement is not absolutely ideal, but I do not know that Deputy Cowan's new arrangement would be anything better. It might be just as well, as in the case of another amendment we discussed to-day, to leave very well alone and allow things to work as they are working.

Comment on this

I am perfectly satisfied that Deputy Cowan is out to do the best he can for the improvement of this Bill and to make it as efficient and satisfactory as possible, but notwithstanding that he speaks as a member of the corporation, I suggest to him that his proposal would not meet with anything like general approval and certainly would not make for any improvement. Notwithstanding all he says about there being no co-ordination, I find it difficult to accept that suggestion in view of the undoubted success which has attended the housing officers' efforts and the health assistance officer, and, even if Dr. Hernon has to proceed from one office to another, if there is, as the Deputy suggests, a sort of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde aspect involved, could anyone better than the same individual be suggested as a go-between in relation to two bodies? If he is transacting some business as between the county council and the corporation and he is actuated by a desire to do justice to both sides, it makes for harmonious working to have the same negotiator working through himself.

Comment on this

In fact, it does not. The theory is all right, but the practice is not.

Comment on this

The Deputy suggests that there is no co-ordination except in theory. I do not think you could possibly make a comparison of Dublin with any other county. In Dublin, with its teeming population, overflowing into the county and with its institutions hinging on each other, it is almost impossible to avoid having integration and consequent success. Since becoming Minister, I have had abundant evidence of the satisfactory working and close integration of this functional approach for the County and City of Dublin and it would be a very serious matter to attempt to disturb that position. I personally would be very slow to do it. I have no evidence except evidence of harmonious and satisfactory working and we ought to leave very well alone. The city manager and county officer is well supported by four assistants who have been delegated their functions, and each and every element of their functional duties are fairly and properly covered without the imposition of any undue strain on the county and city manager or on any of the assistants.

The Deputy mentioned officers and staff in the county council. That is correct. They are all working in coordinated fashion under one head, and, having regard to the contiguity of the metropolis to the small county of Dublin, it would be unthinkable to upset the arrangement. It would be a disadvantageous and retrograde step if we were to attempt to do that, and I suggest the Deputy should leave the Bill as it is.

Comment on this

I am sorry the Minister does not see the point involved. We have a very excellent housing director in Dublin City, Mr. O'Mahoney, who is also housing director for the County of Dublin. The city manager is also county manager, and one of them is here to-day and there to-morrow, out to Dún Laoghaire and back again, When the housing director is dealing with his contracts for sites and so on in the City of Dublin, he devotes all the time he can spare to it. When he has finished with that, he goes up to the county council and has to change his functions completely. I know that he works as many as 16 hours on some days. There is no co-ordination between the two bodies. That is what I wanted the Minister to understand, whether he accepts the amendment or not. When Dr. Hernon is acting as county manager of Dublin County, he is cribbed, cabined and confined as county manager, and can carry out no other functions. Similarly, when he is acting as city manager, he can carry out no other duties. We are in the fortunate position that in Dr. Hernon, Mr. O'Mahoney, Mr. Keane and others we have excellent officials. I am sure the Minister will find, and find very soon, that it would be a more satisfactory arrangement if we had a county officer in Dublin County who would deal with the portion Dr. Hernon deals with and also the portion Mr. O'Mahoney deals with, leaving us in the city—where we have such an enormous population and such tremendous responsibilities—with the full services of these two, the city manager and assistant city manager.

I am sorry that people cannot see the facts, but I cannot do more than try to make them be seen. The Minister is quite right when he says it is working satisfactorily. That is so because of the competence and efficiency of the people concerned, because they are working long hours, as many as 16 a day. That is why it is satisfactory. It is not satisfactory because the system is satisfactory but because the particular officials are excellent men. This is like many other matters I advocate: it takes a long time for ordinary men to understand them. Perhaps in a year or two we will have the Minister introducing the particular amendment I am trying to get him to accept to-night and when he does that I am sure that his principal supporter will be Deputy MacEntee.

Comment on this

It is a great pity that all Deputies are not gifted with the vivid imagination of Deputy Cowan. We have listened to him while he detailed at length how the city manager acted as city manager and how he dealt with the business of the Dublin County Council. I am not aware that Deputy Cowan has been a sort of "doppelgänger" of the person who occupies the dual post of Dublin County Manager and Dublin City Manager. I do not know if the Deputy has had the privilege of sitting upon that gentleman's shoulder when he was sitting in the Dublin City Hall or when he was exercising his functions in Parnell Square. In fact, I doubt very much whether Deputy Cowan was there on any occasion when the Dublin City Manager was in the City Hall acting as city manager or in the Dublin County Council offices in Parnell Square acting as Dublin County Manager. I doubt whether Deputy Cowan will now aver that he was. So all this argument is merely a figment of Deputy Cowan's fertile imagination and there is no substance whatever in it.

The only realistic argument I heard the Deputy advance in support of his amendment was that the Dublin City Manager would write a letter to the Dublin County Manager which would be received by the gentleman who had written it, when he was acting in his capacity as county manager. The change that Deputy Cowan proposes to make is that the letter will be written by one individual in the City Hall and received by a different individual in Parnell Square.

Comment on this

Precisely.

Comment on this

So we shall have two individuals dealing with the one letter, instead of one individual dealing with the same problem. We shall have two individuals dealing with one problem, instead of one. That will be the practical effect of the amendment. Yet it is put up here solemnly as if it were a great epoch-making discovery in the realm of local administration and this gentleman, with all the magnamania which characterises, I understand, Uncle Joe and which used to characterise the late German Fuehrer, now comes along to tell us that sometime, in two, three or four years, all the world will accept the principle which he is advocating now and look up to him with admiration. I will not be one of his adorers.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment being withdrawn?

Comment on this

Say: "postponed for three years."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may re-table it on the next Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:—

In sub-section (3) to delete all words after "manager" in line 2, page 8, to the end of the sub-section and substitute "by Order direct that the said person shall become the first county officer for one of the said counties that the said person himself selects".

This is a simple amendment and I do not think many cases arise under it. It deals with the person who is manager of two counties. Sub-section (3) provides that the Minister shall consult the two counties and then decide to which he will appoint the particular county officer. I do not know how many instances will occur. I know there is Leix-Offaly and Longford-Westmeath.

Comment on this

And Sligo-Leitrim.

Comment on this

And Tipperary, North and South Ridings. There are about five.

Comment on this

The amendment I propose is simply that the Minister shall by Order direct that the said person shall become the first county officer for one of the said counties that the said person himself selects. Where you have a county manager in a place like Longford-Westmeath the county officer should himself have the right to say for which of the two counties he will act. It is a very simple amendment and one which should, I think, appeal to the Minister. It gives a reasonable discretion to the county officer. If you have a man who has been carrying out the duties of county manager for two adjoining counties the Minister may appoint him as the county officer for the county to which he does not want to go. It would be reasonable to give him his choice and let him select the county, leaving a vacancy in the other.

Comment on this

I wonder if the Deputy has looked at the other side of the picture? What is proposed is that the Minister must consult the councils of the counties which have been served by the county manager; they also must be consulted. He must also consult with the manager so as to be satisfied as to his acceptance. The amendment would hand the appointment over to the officer himself and allow him to make a selection. You may find that where he has been dealing with two counties one county may be anxious to retain his services and he may not be anxious to remain there. Another county may be anxious to get an outside man and I suggest in justice to the man himself and to the council he is going to serve that it would make for a more harmonious atmosphere if there were consultations between the Minister, the council and the officer himself and get them to agree. According to the amendment the officer could say he was going to one particular place and no one would have control over him, neither the Minister nor the council nor anyone else. It would mean more harmonious working if the councils and the officer himself discussed the matter before the appointment was made rather than to give the officer carte blanche to go into a county that might not perhaps have a very great welcome for him.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the Minister's approach to this matter is a reasonable and practical one, and I am surprised that Deputy Cowan should put down an amendment of the kind which now appears on the Order Paper. Let us consider what the section which he proposes to amend prescribes. It prescribes that in respect of a county which is one of a group of two counties the Minister, before appointing a county officer, shall consult with the councils of the county. Mark that the practical effect of Deputy Cowan's amendment would be to delete the words "consult the councils of the counties". That is what Deputy Cowan proposes to do, but that is what Deputy Cowan is afraid to say he is proposing to do, and all this verbiage we have on the Order Paper is to conceal the fact that this sea-green incorruptible democrat, who is supporting the Bill because it will restore democratic control and limit the power of bureaucracy, seeks in an amendment to prevent the Minister from consulting the councils and to give him power to appoint a person to the most important post in their administration without consulting them by the old Ministerial fiat. That is what Deputy Cowan proposes to do and he cannot put any gloss on it. I know that he will get up and drag a red herring across the trail and that he will refer to myself in terms quite as cogent as those in which I have referred to him.

Comment on this

I will not, in fact.

Comment on this

Let us not, because I have introduced this personal note, get away from what Deputy Cowan proposes to do. If he can square that with the democratic principles that were embodied in The Vanguard he can do what mathematicians and eminent minds have sought to do for generations, that is to say, he can square the circle.

Comment on this

I looked at this Bill as a whole and it provides that where there is a county manager he becomes county officer for the county when the Bill is passed. Where you have the position that you have in three or four cases and you have one county manager for two counties, the Bill provides that the Minister will consult with the councils and appoint him county officer of one or other of the two counties. It is not a case of sending him anywhere. Let us see what may happen: the County Management Act was passed in 1940 and a man may have been county manager for ten years of two counties and carrying out his functions there. Like any other man he may have a home and family and may have a family attending school. To send that man from the county in which he lives, as can be done by the Minister, to another county may have very serious repercussions on him and on his family life. It may mean that he must dispose of the home he has built up and make alterations in the education of his children. I think that these are material and important matters and if a man has been a good official as manager of two counties then the least he ought to get under this Bill is the right to say in which county he prefers to stop. I am prepared to argue with anyone that that conflicts in no way with the principles of democracy. I do not think that he should be a chattel to be ordered from one county to another by the Minister. The Minister has no right to do that. There has been a lot of talk about the homes of the people and the fundamental right of individuals, but in this amendment I am trying to preserve the homes and fundamental right of individuals. I am going to press this amendment and I would ask the Minister to accept it.

Comment on this

I think that it will be agreed that while Deputy Cowan started as super-democratically as we would all like, he turned into rather a dictator in this debate. The object of the Bill as it was introduced, we were told by the Minister, was to give more power to local authorities.

I am surprised that Deputy Cowan should be the first member of the House to set out to restrict the rights of local authorities. He proposes to delete certain words but, for some extraordinary reason he wants to delete the words "consult the councils of the counties." I am surprised that Deputy Cowan will not allow the councils of the counties, where this manager or county officer has been functioning, to be consulted. I doubt if Deputy Cowan fully considered this amendment before he put it down or fully understood its meaning. We should like to see the councils of the counties consulted by the Minister before he makes the county officer or county manager for either one of the counties. We should like the Minister to consult both counties in respect of such an officer. The Minister is also going to consult the person, who will be involved. He is not going to act as a dictator in this respect. He is going to consult the person, whose future he is determining as to which county he should serve in. The local authorities under and with whom he served will be consulted. I think there is nothing undemocratic in that procedure. However, there is a most undemocratic viewpoint expressed in Deputy Cowan's amendment or proposed amendment. I believe the Deputy would be wise, before this debate goes any further, and before the undemocratic nature of this amendment is exposed any further, to withdraw it.

Comment on this

I think it would be well if we had some glossary of terms, some dictionary, some common understanding of what terms mean. As I understand democracy, it means the giving of rights to an individual, and in this amendment I want to give rights to an individual. He may be only a county manager but to me he is a human being with the rights of a human being, with a family and with a home to be considered. Let us see where the democracy is in the Bill or where it is in regard to the appointment of county officers. We have 26 counties: I do not know how many county officers we have. With the exception, probably, of four, the remaining county officers are automatically appointed by the Bill and the county councils have no right or say in the matter. There are four exceptions. We will take it that four is the correct number of dual counties and that, therefore, eight counties are involved. In these eight counties—or seven counties if we count North and South Tipperary as one county—there are four managers. These four managers will be appointed to four counties and there will be four vacancies. The four vacancies in question will be referred to the Local Appointments Commission. The four managers will be appointed for the four counties in question and the four counties will have no say, good, bad or indifferent, in regard to the appointment of these men. We are left, then, with four individuals —and the alleged democrats say: "Let these four individuals be bundled around. Let their homes be upset, if needs be. Let their arrangements in regard to their family be upset, so long as the Minister consults the two councils."

Comment on this

——and the person.

Comment on this

There is nothing about the person in this Bill.

Comment on this

There is. Read it. The Deputy has not read it.

Comment on this

I want to put it to you in a practical way. Suppose one county says that they want the man and that the other county says that they do not want the man, and that the man himself says that he wants to go to the county that does not want him, whose will is going to prevail there? Where is the Minister going to send him?

Comment on this

That is a hypothetical case.

Comment on this

Where would the Minister send him, in such an event?

Comment on this

I should hope that the manager would not go anywhere where he is not wanted.

Comment on this

Hear, hear, unlike Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

The manager may not want to go to the county where he is not wanted. Some managers have not been wanted in particular counties for a short period. There may be some little "nark" that passes over after a very short time. However, under the Bill the manager may be sent into a county to which he does not wish to go. In other words, he has not even the same rights which he would have if he were not a manager because, for instance, if the county officership of the County Meath arose, a particular individual may not apply for it, but under this Bill these four people may be sent into a county to which they may not wish to go. There is some talk about democracy. Is it democratic to break up a man's home against his will? I do not think it is. I think that where you have a county officer acting in both counties the Minister will probably find himself in the position that both counties may want the particular individual concerned. That situation may well arise. If such a situation should arise and if the county manager says that he wants to go to one particular county, will his view prevail?

Comment on this

I should say so.

Comment on this

That is something. I feel, at any rate, that it is wrong to talk about the democratic rights of local authorities in regard to that matter because, as far as this Bill is concerned, it is simply a matter of four individuals. It may be that there will be no trouble. However, what I want to ensure is that the county officer will go to the county which he is serving at the moment and in which he desires to remain. A principle which has been accepted in a very wide field is the principle that, in the event of conflict, the rights of the individual shall prevail. It is for the purpose of insisting that these rights shall prevail that I put down the amendment.

Comment on this

I want to remind the Deputy that the manager is manager not for one county but for both counties.

Comment on this

For the two counties.

Comment on this

A group.

Comment on this

He will not, therefore, be going into any foreign country at all no matter which one he may go into. The only thing is that he will be de-grouped now and that a new appointment will be made. The method suggested is that of consultation with the two county councils and with the manager himself. The Deputy has posed the question of what would be likely to happen where both councils are anxious to have the services of the particular individual concerned. The Minister could determine where the manager wants to stay, and that would be that. Then again, a council might be averse from letting him go and there might be a conflict. The most reasonable solution is that which is suggested—and there is not the least danger of the inviolability of democracy being tinged or tainted either against the county council or the individual. There are only four group counties altogether. I can visualise no difficulty whatever in the carrying out of the terms of transfer as set out in the Bill. However, the Minister has to have regard to the wishes of the two county councils and to the wishes of the manager concerned. He has to have regard to the question of the subordinate officer, as to his suitability to take up the position. It does not follow, as Deputies suggest, that they will have to have appointments made by the Local Appointments Commissioners. That is not automatic either. There is the other point of the suitability or willingness of the assistant county officer or county secretary to take up the position also. These are points that would have to be gone into in consultation with the county councils. The manager himself will be helpful in advising the Minister and the council. I do not think there will be, any difficulty in making that arrangement. It would make for friction and trouble if the manager were to be imposed upon a council without consultation with the councils. I suggest that what is being done is in the best interests of all and in the interests of the working of the future county officer. There will no hardship inflicted upon anybody, I can assure the House of that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:—

In sub-section (5) to delete "not less than" in line 12, "by the council" in line 13, and all words after "Act" in line 14, to end of the sub-section.

This is a very simple thing. Where you have a county manager appointed county officer, the Bill provides that the remuneration to be paid to him by the county council shall be not less than the remuneration paid to him as manager by the county council immediately before the commencement of this part of the Act, or, if he was then manager for two counties, than the aggregate of the remunerations then paid to him by the councils of those counties. The amendment is simply to delete the words "not less than". I do not know what reason the Minister had for saying that the remuneration was to be "not less than". I take it that if a man is acting as manager and becomes county officer, under the Bill, it would be reasonable that he should be continued at the same salary. The Minister says that he will be paid not less than the salary, which would leave it open for him to get an increase in salary immediately, but I do not think it is intended to give him an immediate increase in salary in the case where a man has been county manager for a county and is appointed county officer. The only meaning of my amendment is that he would be paid the remuneration that he was receiving as county manager. If the Minister thinks there is any reason for inserting the words "not less than" I would like to hear what it is.

Comment on this

The Deputy is pushing an open door, but I think he is pushing it to the detriment of the individual by the deletion of the words "not less than". He is assured of getting what he has had as manager for one or both counties but, if you delete "not less than", it would not be possible for that man, unless by a special Act of Parliament, to get an increase of salary, if wage increases took place. The insertion of these words entitles him to any advance that may be made and protects him from a decrease.

Comment on this

Are not the salaries of county managers to some extent dealt with by the Minister?

Comment on this

The Minister at the moment can provide by order for increases in salaries? I know he can do it in the case of a city manager.

Comment on this

He can do that all right, but I suggest that the wording in the Bill is for the protection of the county officer.

Comment on this

I thought that under the law as it stands there was provision for increases in salary and, so as not to have any woolly words in the Bill, I simply provided that he would be paid the remuneration paid to him as county manager immediately before. If the Minister thinks there is any virtue in the words "not less than," I have no objection to them.

Comment on this

It is only an added safeguard. We are both pushing the same door.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:—

Before Section 12 to insert a new section as follows:—

The Minister may by order (after consultation with the local authority concerned) create the office of city officer in respect of the council of a borough, and the duties and functions of such city officer shall be the same as the duties and functions of a county officer as defined in this Act.

The purpose of this new section is to permit borough councils to have a city officer of their own, to carry out the executive functions now carried out by the county managers. As many people know, there are some large urban areas which are not county boroughs but which are very close to that position in population and valuation and which have immense difficulties which require the attention of a whole-time officer who would carry out the executive functions of that area. Such is the case, for example, in Galway, which led me to put down this amendment. There you have a large growing city and also a very large county. It has very many difficult local problems, which require the attention of a full-time officer. The present system which allows that work to be done by the county manager, who is an official of the county council, is not, in my opinion, satisfactory. I think anyone would agree that in a large county like that it is nearly impossible for one individual to give sufficient attention to the problems that arise. The county manager has to look after the county council, Ballinasloe Mental Hospital, the Central Hospital, Loughrea Children's Home, Ballinasloe Urban Council, Tuam and Loughrea Town Commissioners. It is a physical impossibility for that person to give attention to a town like Galway when he has so many other particular duties on his hands.

There is one very important feature of the whole matter. As many people must know, the relationship that exists between urban councils, borough councils and county councils is sometimes rather difficult because borough councils contribute to the county-at-large charges, not on services rendered but on a fractional basis which is the valuation of the county health district divided by the borough valuation. I am sure the Minister knows that there are many urban areas and borough areas which find this a great burden. They have to pay on the gross valuation, not on the collectable valuation.

Take a manager for both bodies. Every action of the manager for the county council becomes a burden on the borough council of which he is also manager. The result is that when the borough council meets to discuss matters which are inter-related between the borough council and the county council, they have to deal with a manager who is also acting for the county council and it is practically impossible for him, unless he is a person of split mind, to dissociate himself from his main employers, the county council. I believe that many of the urban areas, and particularly the borough areas, could be more efficiently run if they had an officer of their own carrying out these executive functions.

I do not want to delay the House on this matter, but I think the Minister will agree, particularly as regards the large borough areas, in view of the fact that the relations sometimes— more especially the financial relations between the counties and boroughs— are of a rather difficult nature, that it would be better if the borough council had a particular officer advising them so that they will be better protected and they will get better value for their money and that the county council contribution will be as they think fit.

Comment on this

This proposal is cutting right across the general principle of the Bill, which is really an effort at integration. We were dealing earlier with the Dublin County Council and the city manager and this matter was then argued. This proposal is to set up a city officer, evidently with the same powers as the county officer. The county manager is the officer for the county and all the institutions therein. The county officer will have the same functions and if you set up a city officer in the boroughs I do not believe you will make for harmonious working. I think you will be making for friction rather than for integration.

The case made for the boroughs could equally be made for some provincial towns that have not become boroughs. The boroughs are Dún Laoghaire, with a population of 44,674; Galway, 20,370; Drogheda, 15,715; Sligo, 12,920; Wexford, 12,296; Kilkenny, 10,291, and Clonmel, 9,857. There are certain urban districts with a pretty high population, such as Dundalk, 18,562; Bray, 11,085, and Tralee, 9,990. The case that can be made, if there is a case made, for the appointment of a city officer, could also be made for those towns with such a big population, with a population quite as big and perhaps bigger than in some of the boroughs.

I do not see what necessity there is for the appointment of a city officer. The county officer will be there. If he is overloaded there is provision made so that we can appoint an assistant county officer. This particular proposal will not, in my opinion, make for harmonious working but will lead inevitably to friction. I do not see that there is any point to be met at all. If there is too much work for the county officer an assistant county officer can be appointed. I do not see the need for a city officer who would not be a help but who would be rather the reverse. They would be working against rather than with each other. It could not be confined to the boroughs and for that reason you would ultimately have additional costs imposed on the ratepayers. These officers would be appointed on top of such officials as town clerks, and that will lead to more burdens on the rates. I think the Deputy ought not to press this amendment because his point is already sufficiently covered.

Comment on this

There is a big difference between what I am trying to get at and the point in the discussion about the Dublin City Manager and the Dublin County Council. They are autonomous bodies; they are not inter-contributing. The difficulty about most large urban areas is that they have to contribute to the county council on a purely fractional basis and at times there is a tremendous amount of disagreement as between the two bodies and the one manager.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:—

To insert ", at the request of the council of the county," before "by" in sub-section (3), page 8, line 51, before "one" in sub-section (4), line 2 and before "by" in sub-section (5), line 4 and to delete sub-section (7).

The proposal in the amendment is that, at the request of the council of the county, the Minister may, by Order, increase the number of assistant county officers for the County of Cork, create one or more than one office of assistant county officer of the county, and amend or revoke an Order. There are some other amendments covering that point.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 15 meets the point of amendments Nos. 16, 18 and 19.

Comment on this

As the Minister knows, there is a whole mass of legislation by which it is left to the Minister finally to provide equally good standards in respect of administration throughout the country. He has any number of Acts by which he can make quite sure that there is equally good administration. A whole hierarchy of officers and minor officers is provided, all with the object of having a high standard maintained. The suggestion originally was that the Minister shall have the final word. That is not with the view of preventing the Cork County Council or any other body from deciding the number of its officers, but with the view of maintaining a good and proper standard.

It seems to me that the Minister's amendment is a little bit illogical, because he can provide by other Acts for officers of every kind, arrange for their numbers and make regulations in regard to their appointment. There is a whole series of Acts going back some 20 years on that subject. I think, as local authorities are ultimately bodies delegated to do their work by the Oireachtas, the Minister should have the final say as to the preservation of a standard of administration. It is not always possible to imagine that a particular authority would be right in its decision. It might think it is right, but from the point of view of preserving a good standard I am not sure that the Minister ought not to have the final say.

The suggestion here is that, after consultation with the council of the county, he could appoint assistant county officers for Cork, and for other counties. I have no objection to any method adopted by the Minister to ensure that every county council would be entitled to express its point of view, but if a county council has to have its a county medical officer of health or other officers, I think the Minister should have the final word.

Comment on this

One of the differences between this Bill and the procedure which operated under Deputy Childers before is that, under sub-section 2 of Section 29, the council are now given a chance of determining whether they want an increased number of permanent officers. Before this, and even as the law now stands, the situation was that the council had no say in the matter. As I say, under sub-section 2 of Section 29, the council are now given the absolute power of determining whether there is to be an increase in the number of permanent officers. The amendment which the Minister has introduced in this section is merely bringing the position of additional county officer into line with the procedure the Minister has laid down in sub-section 2 of Section 29, under which the county officer cannot ask the Minister to increase the number of permanent officers without the permission of the council. It seems to me that, far from attacking this proposal as being illogical, the Deputy should give the Minister credit for correcting one of the worst tendencies of the present system which was to give us, in local authorities, too many officers and too much approach to Government Department instead of more work being done across the table by the various officers concerned.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister has brought in this amendment which covers the points I intended to raise on amendments Nos. 16, 18 and 19.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 17:—

In sub-section (4), line 3, to delete "of" where it occurs secondly and substitute "for."

This is a purely drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 22:—

In sub-section (1), lines 38 and 39, to delete "the Minister may, by order made after consultation with the council of the county" and substitute "the council of the county shall by order."

There are two other amendments, amendments Nos. 23 and 26, which deal with the same principle as this amendment. I think the Minister should accept this amendment as he has already agreed to the principle in the amendment accepted in regard to the appointment of temporary county officers to fill a vacancy. This section deals with the transfer of functions to a county secretary. It states:—

"Where the office of county officer for a county is vacant at the commencement of this part of this Act by reason of no person becoming appointed to the office by virtue of Section 10 of this Act, or where the office of county officer for a county becomes vacant after such commencement, the Minister may, by order made after consultation with the council of the county, transfer the functions of the county officer to the county secretary...."

The Minister has already agreed to the principle of the amendment which I moved, that where there is to be a temporary appointment, the council may make the temporary appointment and it will be sanctioned by the Minister. The very same principle arises here. The amendment proposes to delete the words "the Minister may, by Order made after consultation with the council of the county" and to substitute the words "the council of the county shall by Order". In other words, there is the principle already accepted by the Minister, that temporary appointments will be made by the council and not by the Minister. Obviously, of course, they must be sanctioned by the Minister.

Comment on this

Is there any significance in the fact that the Deputy makes use of the word "shall" in his amendment, as compared, with the word "may" in the Bill? Does the Deputy intend any difference?

Comment on this

I do not think it matters very much.

Comment on this

The purpose of this amendment is to amend Section 16 (1) by providing that the council of the county and not the Minister shall make an order transferring the functions of the county officer for the county to the county secretary. The amendment is objectionable for a variety of reasons. It puts the members of the county council in the invidious position of being open to canvassing on behalf of a county secretary or an assistant county officer who, when the post of county officer becomes vacant, wants to get the post. It is better that the Minister should be in a position to decide the issue as to whether or not the county secretary should be appointed county officer. An Order made under the provisions of sub-section (1) of Section 15 is equivalent to an Order for the amalgamation of the offices of county secretary and county officer. Provisions enabling amalgamation of offices to be made were included in the 1941 Local Government Act and were repeated, with some slight amendments, in the 1946 Act. These provisions in the 1946 Act, Section 36, give the power to amalgamate offices to the Minister. The effect of the amendments proposed by the Deputy would be to give the county council power to amalgamate the offices of county officer and county secretary while the Minister would have power to amalgamate all other offices. The section provides for consultation with the county council. If the county council holds strong views they will not be slow in conveying them to the Minister. The Minister cannot disregard the views of the county council, except in face of very compelling reasons.

The point is that consultation should take place between the Minister and the county council when any proposal of this kind is contemplated. That would be more effective, seeing that the Minister has responsibilities for amalgamation in regard to other offices. There may be contenders for the offices and it would be much better to have the matter decided in the manner outlined in the section than under the proposal of the Deputy. It is being done in consultation all the time with the county council. There is no infliction of the Minister on top of them.

Comment on this

I should have liked to have the view of some other Deputies on this section.

Comment on this

I should say that, normally, the position would be filled by the Local Appointments Commission. That is the normal position except in the initial stages.

Comment on this

I just want to make my mind clear on this point. It is intended gradually to abolish county officers and to have the functions carried out by the county secretary. Where the office of county officer is vacant at the commencement of this part of this Act, the Minister may transfer the functions to the county secretary. In view of what I have proposed already, and what the Minister has agreed to, I think that what he ought to agree to here is that the council may transfer those functions if there is a vacancy. I am not worried at all about the question of a canvass because I think we have agreed that there will be no improper canvass in regard to matters of this kind under our local authorities as now constructed.

Will the Minister say if this section is intended to be part of the machinery for the abolition of the county officers? In other words, is it part of the machinery to change county officers into county secretaries under this particular section? I think once you have that principle established, that is what is to be done. I think that the councils themselves ought to do it. I can see that there will be a difficulty in a case where there is an assistant county officer. I do not know of many counties in which you will have an assistant county officer. There may be one or two. The machinery that is going to operate, as I understand it is, that once a county officer dies, resigns or retires and there is a county secretary there, to transfer the functions to him. That is what is intended. Therefore you may not have any more county officers. In such cases, I think the councils should make the order themselves. That is why I deliberately put in the word "shall" into the amendment.

Comment on this

I take it that this section deals with group counties such as Kilkenny-Waterford and Carlow-Kildare, where you have no county officer in existence at the moment. In these cases, will it follow automatically that the county secretary will become the county officer when the present county manager elects to go to another county?

Comment on this

He may be appointed. The Minister will consult with the members of the council.

Comment on this

I think the Minister could meet Deputy Cowan by telling us a lot more about Section 15. It is a very fundamental section of the Bill. I should like to know, for instance, in what circumstance the Appointments Commission will deal with these vacancies. The Minister, I think, said that in certain cases the Appointments Commission will appoint the county secretary. In certain other cases it would appear that they are to be automatically appointed. I think, in order to clear up the matter, it would be well if the Minister would give us some more information on the section. If we had that information I think we would be able to proceed further with Deputy Cowan's amendment.

Comment on this

The purpose of Section 15 is to enable the offices of county officer and county secretary to be amalgamated under the latter title according as vacancies arise. In the case of existing managers and county secretaries the amalgamation will not take place without their consent. The local authority will be consulted in each case before an amalgamation takes place.

The first five sub-sections of this section deal with the case where the office of county officer is vacant at the commencement of this part of the Act. They enable the duties of county officer in certain circumstances to be transferred to the county secretary or an assistant county officer. The simple case will be in counties which have no assistant county officer. If the county secretary was appointed before the commencement of this part of the Act, his consent will have to be obtained before amalgamation takes place. If the county secretary was appointed after the commencement of this part of the Act, it will not be necessary to obtain his consent. If both posts are vacant at the commencement, then the Minister can make an Order under sub-section (1) amalgamating the posts of county officer and county secretary, and the new appointee will hold both offices under the title of county secretary.

In counties where there are, say, two assistant county officers and a county secretary the Minister may, instead of transferring the duties of county officer to the county secretary, transfer them to one of the assistant county officers. If the post of county secretary becomes vacant subsequently, the assistant county officer will assume the duties of county secretary as well as county officer, and his title will be county secretary. The Order made by the Minister can, by virtue of sub-section (8), include a provision that the other remaining assistant county officer will then be known as assistant county secretary. Sub-section (5) provides that an Order cannot be made transferring the duties of county officer to an existing assistant county manager without his consent. You cannot load on to him an additional job without his consent if he has been there before the passing of the Act.

Sub-sections (6) and (7) deal with the opposite case, that is, where the office of county secretary is vacant at the commencement of this part of the Act or becomes vacant thereafter. The Minister may, by Order, after consultation with the council of the county, transfer the functions of the county secretary to the county officer and change his title to that of county secretary. If the county officer was previously a county manager, then, by virtue of sub-section (7), the Order cannot be made unless he consents thereto.

Sub-section (9) links with sub-section (3) of Section 9. It enables the Minister, whenever there is a vacancy in the office of county officer, to appoint a person to hold temporarily the office of county officer until a permanent county officer is appointed or until an order is made under this section amalgamating the office of county secretary with that of county officer.

Sub-section (10) provides that the provisions made by or under this section shall have effect notwithstanding any other provision of this or of any other Act. This is necessary because, by virtue of Section 9 of this Act and the 1926 Act, a permanent county officer would have to be appointed through the machinery of the Local Appointments Commissioners.

Comment on this

I think we are getting into a fog as somebody says. We are certainly getting into pretty deep water in regard to this particular section, and so I think it is well that we ought to understand where we are and try to get some foothold at the moment. At present we have county managers. When this Bill is passed they will all become county officers. That is the first step. It is intended by the Minister that we will reach another stage of development when the county officers disappear, because then all the work will be done by the county secretaries. I think we need some guidance from the Minister as to when that second stage of development is to take place. Let me admit at once that it is some time since I read the Bill completely. It has been before us for quite a good while now, but as I see it, under this section you can start the process of changing a county secretary almost at once.

Comment on this

Provided there is a vacancy.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

In the case of the group counties, as Deputy Walsh has suggested.

Comment on this

In other words, in the case of the group counties there will be at least three vacancies. I think there are four group counties.

Comment on this

If there are four group counties, there will be four vacancies.

Comment on this

I was thinking of north and south Tipperary. You have one for the two parts of Tipperary. That will become two and that leaves four: it is a matter of principle to decide if we are going to go right away on to development of the county secretary where we get the opportunity or are we not.

Comment on this

As soon as possible.

Comment on this

If that is so, then under Section 15, where a vacancy occurs or there is a vacancy and there is a county secretary——

Comment on this

We will amalgamate them.

Comment on this

——I say my amendment meets the case exactly; that the county council makes an order transferring the functions to the county secretary and the Minister has no function in it at all because, once we have agreed on that principle that you have to go right on to the county secretary at once, it is unnecessary for the Minister to have consultation with the county council and it is unnecessary for the Minister to make an Order. We can make it by law now and the county council, the moment they have a vacancy, shall make the order declaring that the functions are to be transferred to the county secretary of that county. That is why I think this is an important section in which we can deal now with the vital problems involved in the section.

Comment on this

I can see very little use in either the section or the amendment. I do not know what work this county officer and his assistants are going to do while they are waiting to step into a dead man's shoes or waiting until the secretary resigns or retires or waiting to know which of the two will peg out first. We are roughly spending £8,000 in County Cork on a county manager and three assistant county managers who are now to become county officer and assistant county officers. What are going to be their functions? I want to know what work these four men are going to do during the period which will elapse before the county secretary retires or resigns which will make room for the county officer or before any one of the assistant county managers retires or resigns to make room for his assistant. What are these men going to do for the £8,000 they are going to get if the Minister is rendering these officers redundant, as apparently he is? I admit they do not become redundant until a vacancy is created for them. What work will they do in the meantime? If they have work to do in the meantime, who is going to do that particular job after the county secretary retires or when the county officer disappears? Are we going to pay two men for doing one man's work? Is that the respect the Minister or the Government has for the ratepayers? I want to know where we stand. Is this man to have no work to do from the date this Bill becomes law until such time as the county secretary gets out and makes room for him to get work to do? If he has work to do and if the Minister holds that he is to be a fully employed man until such time as either the county secretary gets out or the county manager himself drops out and both functions are vested in one man, does the Minister expect one man is going to do two men's work?

Let us take a case in point. Supposing the Secretary of Cork County Council retires or resigns three months after this Bill becomes law. So far as I understand it, the county manager, or the county officer as he will then be, would take over the county secretary's work. Who would take over the work that the county officer was supposed to be doing in these three months? Are you going to create another county officer or are you not? That is what is puzzling me about this matter. Apparently, there is so little respect for the ratepayer's money, as has been amply proved during the past couple of years by that Party over there, that now we have come to the position that, no matter how many of these boys are paid, you are creating a bunch of redundant officials.

Comment on this

They were created by the previous Government.

Comment on this

You brought in the Bill here. You now have a bunch of these thousand-a-year boys all over the country and you have no work for them and you say to each of them: "Sit down comfortably in your armchair, draw the £1,000 a year and wait until so-and-so dies and you will get his job." That is this Section in a nutshell. I want to know from the Minister if that is the way in which he considers the ratepayers should be treated. If the Minister and the Government are genuine in their argument that the county managers are not required and that this Bill should be passed to abolish them or remove them or call them by another name, then give the men whatever is coming to them and let them go. Do not hold these men there drawing full salary from the ratepayers and waiting until the county secretary goes in order to take his job. Apparently, whichever of the two goes first the other is to take his place and one man will then be able to do the work of two. It is about the craziest thing I have seen in legislation yet. We have an open public admission that these men are redundant, that there is no work for them to do, but that they are to remain there and draw a full salary and wait until the county secretary moves out of their way or until they go and the county secretary takes up their functions as well as his own. I have seen many crazy things done during the past three years in legislation but this is the craziest yet. I would like to have the Minister explain to us what this officer will do until the county secretary goes and who will do that job when he takes over the county secretary's position.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government (Mr. Corish) Labour Party

Deputy Corry said that we were admitting here that there were a certain number of officers in Cork who were absolutely unnecessary. I submit that if they were absolutely unnecessary they were absolutely unnecessary for the past ten years. What this Bill proposes to do is to cut them down more quickly than Deputy Corry would have them cut down. Does Deputy Corry advocate now, apart from his playing to the gallery, that either the Cork County Manager or secretary be sacked immediately? Does he want that? Has he the courage to say that?

Comment on this

I have said that. You have not the guts to do it.

Comment on this

This Bill proposes to have the affairs of County Cork administered by one of these gentlemen.

Comment on this

One of them will do it now and you are going to pay two.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan suggests that when a county officer resigns, the position should automatically be filled by the county secretary. I think that was one of the points he made—that if the county secretary goes out of office, the county officer shall become county secretary automatically without any provision by way of ministerial Order or consultation with the council. That might work to some extent, but I would like to submit this. It might not always be suitable or appropriate that the present county secretary should be the county officer in the event of the county officer resigning or, if you put it the other way, it may not be desirable that a county officer would assume the rôle of county secretary. I think there would be an objection in that.

Comment on this

On a point of order, are we discussing the section or the amendment?

Comment on this

It might be better if we discussed the section with the amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am in the hands of the House.

Comment on this

An Leas-Cheann Comhairle is finding it difficult.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am prepared to let the House discuss all the amendments together, so far as they are relevant to the issue. There are some points in them which make me doubtful as to whether they can all be wrapped together. I allowed the Minister, on Deputy Childer's request, to make a statement regarding Section 15 because Deputy Childers said it would help them to come to an understanding.

Comment on this

We on this side of the House have always been prepared to make some alteration regarding the conduct of local administration by county managers. We have always considered that there was a great deal in this Bill that was pure hypocrisy designed for political purposes and designed to satisfy certain members of the Coalition. There is a great deal in this Bill which can be construed as a deliberate effort to demean the position and reputation of county managers. That is our fundamental view. We are opposing Section 15, the principle of Section 15, but we want to look at it in a different way from Deputy Corry. What Deputy Corry said was that if the Government do not really consider that the county officers are necessary, they certainly ought to abolish them now and only have county secretaries in the smaller counties. That is a reasonable proposition but he cannot have read the rest of the Bill. When you go to the end of the Bill and see the Minister appointing a fantastic number of committees, turning county councillors into professional civil servants, having so many committees that will require the attendance of the county officer, it is our view that it is ridiculous at this stage to presuppose that you can do without a county manager and that only a county secretary is needed.

I would like to ask the Minister, in view of those sections of the Bill which deal with the appointment of these committees, how often he thinks that the executive committees, the individual health committees and the sub-committees appointed by them and the advisory committees appointed by them are going to meet; how often he thinks the attendance of one of the chief executive officers or county secretaries or county officers will be required at these meetings; how long he thinks the county officer or county secretary is going to take to arrange for the administration of the work of those committees—to read the minutes, to get everything into order, to provide all the information for members of the local bodies. Has he made up his mind regarding Section 15? To what extent will executive committees or individual health committees transfer their functions to the county officers? I would like to know what he thinks is likely to be the practice in respect to the placing of draft orders before the committees.

Comment on this

On a point of order, might I point out that the remarks being made by Deputy Childers are more appropriate to Section 16 than Section 15?

Comment on this

I am relating the decision of the Minister in advance of viewing the effect of this Bill on local administration to abolish each county officership since he can conveniently do it in single counties and to amalgamate that with the office of county secretary; in other words, that there will be one officer instead of two. I have asked the Minister what he thinks the effect of the administrative work will be when they all get the work; whether he thinks he can have only one officer instead of two at any time, when the full effect of this Bill is felt, when it is fully in operation and when all these committees are working. From what I learn from discussing the matter with members of local bodies and with officers of local bodies, the work of the county officer is going to increase enormously, or the work of the person who will replace the county officer is going to increase enormously, as a result of the provisions of this Bill, and he will have far more to do than before. I should like to hear from the Minister the circumstances in which he believes he can make one person do the work of two in the future, when this Bill is fully in operation.

Comment on this

I have no fear that the county councils will be unable to carry on. If the work is too heavy for the county secretary, it is optional to get an assistant county secretary appointed, but, with the proposal in this measure of handing back to the elected members and executive committees the functions formerly discharged by the county manager, I have no fear that they will be unable to carry on with a reduced number of officers. If, however, the county council feel that they are unable to do so, there is nothing to prevent them appointing an assistant to him. If they want to make a reduction in the staff and feel that they can make that reduction, they are at liberty to do so. It is not mandatory and, as I say, if they feel that the work cannot be done adequately and efficiently, they can appoint an assistant to the secretary. There is a huge volume of work done by the manager which is being handed back to the elected representatives and the Deputy has an amendment further down the list, the purpose of which is to call these committees advisory committees. If that were to be so, I would agree that it would be difficult, if not impossible, for the one officer or two officers, to carry on, but with these executive committees having executive power to deal with day-to-day important matters formerly dealt with by the manager, there will be no difficulty. Where an assistant is appointed, that appointment, coupled with the work done by the committees, will distribute the load so as to have the business efficiently and easily carried on.

Comment on this

It will be agreed on all sides that the main objective of the Bill is to demean and lower the status of existing county managers.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand that it was agreed to take Section 15, with the amendments thereto, and not the whole Bill.

Comment on this

I propose to relate what I am about to say to the section. I am concerned with Section 15, but I have to make some opening remarks before relating what I have to say to it. Section 15 is fundamental in what is proposed in the Bill, that is, eventually, within 30 years at least and probably longer in some counties, to have the principal officer in these counties county secretary. It may take 30 years to reach a position in which there will be no county officer in the entire Twenty-Six Counties. That is not impossible. In future, we are to have the principal officer in County Wexford as the secretary of the county council and we will have in the neighbouring County of Carlow the principal officer as county officer. In Waterford, he may be the county officer and, in Tipperary, the county secretary. That is the type of local government law we are to have in the future. At the moment, every county manager performs somewhat similar functions and he has the same name in every county. The principal officer in each county is the county manager and the next is the county secretary, but it will not be so in future under Section 15, because one county will have a county officer, while the neighbouring county will have a county secretary as principal officer. If this legislation is not altered, and it will definitely be the duty of Fianna Fáil in a very short few months, when they become the Government of the country again——

Comment on this

Did the Deputy say "a few months"? Was that a slip of the tongue for a few hundred years?

Comment on this

A few short months— there is no doubt about it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not in this section.

Comment on this

Unless a dictatorship is being set up in the country, which is going to function, there is scarcely any doubt about it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is that in the section?

Comment on this

It has a good lot to do with it. What I want to stress is that the object of Section 15 is to lower the status of the existing county managers.

Comment on this

To abolish them altogether.

Comment on this

To lower the status of the principal officers functioning in each county. The county secretary of the future will be asked to perform the functions of a county council, the executive functions or such executive functions as the committees to be set up under the Bill may ask him to perform, and I have no doubt that in most counties they will be asked to perform almost all the functions that the county manager is performing at present. Members of local authorities at the moment, and the majority of those who will be members of local authorities in future, have to earn their livelihoods in some way. They will not be whole-time officers of local authorities, as they will need to be under the Bill. The only types that will be able to give full attendance at all the meetings of the committees to be set up when this Bill becomes law are those who are so wealthy that they can retire and devote their whole time to local authority administration. Desirable people who could give portion of their time—a small portion, I agree—to helping to administer the affairs of local authorities will not in future be enabled to offer themselves as members of local authorities.

The complaint is often made at present that the most desirable and best persons in the community cannot see their way to become members of local authorities, mainly for the reason that they have not got the time, but it will be found in future, when the Bill becomes law, that such members must be whole-time members of local authorities. In addition to performing all the functions of the county council, this secretary of the future will also have to perform functions as chief officer of the other local authorities, urban authorities and town commissioners, of which there may be four or even six in some counties.

The Minister has said just now that the council can appoint assistant secretaries. Two or three may be required, but the chief officer will be absent from his principal office dealing with other duties, with local authorities in the area, for a good portion of his time and will leave in the office a junior official to deal with very important work. That work may be performed over the phone with the Department or with citizens of that particular county. The chief officer will be going around the county. At the present time, in the absence of the manager you have the secretary, but when Section 15 becomes law the manager will become secretary and will have junior officials under him to take responsibility for many important matters.

I think the Minister, the Government and those who support it should at this stage shed the hypocrisy of this whole thing. This Bill was brought before the House and this section was embodied in it in a fit of pique. It is unworthy of any Government to set out to demean and belittle a set of officers who have served this country well for a number of years. During the recent emergency, the county managers, as we had them then, performed very important functions. At that time, in the event of a major emergency they were entrusted with the full functions of government in their respective counties.

Comment on this

Dictators.

Comment on this

The world—including this country—may be faced with a major emergency in the near future. These principal officers would be called upon by the Government of the day to perform very important functions. This Parliament, on behalf of the people, is being asked now, in legislation introduced by a Minister, to lower the status of those officers and to belittle them in the eyes of the community. The Minister admitted that in his Second Reading speech. That is the object of this Bill and that alone. That is why the Bill, and this section in particular, is bad and should not be made effective.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy quote where I belittled the managers?

Comment on this

I certainly can. I have not the Official Debates here.

Comment on this

The Deputy will find it difficult to get it on the record, as it is not so.

Comment on this

I will quote it, before this section becomes law. I hope the Minister will reconsider the whole matter of lowering the status of those officers and will have the laws made in the interests of the country and of the whole community. Certainly, this section when it becomes law will not be in the interests of the community.

Comment on this

I wish to make clear my own position in relation to the remarks made by Deputy Allen. I am sorry he could not substantiate the allegation he made, that not only was it the deliberate purpose of the Minister and the Government and those supporting it to demean and belittle the personnel now filling the posts of county managers, but that that had been made clear as the object of the Government by the Minister in his Second. Reading speech. I do not believe that charge can be substantiated. I sincerely hope the Minister made no such utterance and I do not for a moment believe that he did.

As a member of a local body, acquainted with many members of local bodies in the City of Dublin and throughout the country, I would like to make it quite clear that there is no animosity personally against those holding these particular posts, as far as members of our Party are concerned and, I think, as far as the Government as a whole is concerned. It is one thing to look on the post: it is another to consider, as Deputy Allen and Deputy Childers endeavour to do, in discussing this section, the particular occupants of the posts. I think it is quite improper—subject to the ruling of the Ceann Comhairle—to indulge in a debate on this section along those lines. Possibly, both Deputy Childers and Deputy Allen are aware of that and aware that the Minister would not propose to follow them along that line.

In so far as the grievance is against the Minister and the Government for seeking to abolish the office of county manager, I believe it is the right thing to do. It was one of the major blunders of the Fianna Fáil régime and I think Deputy MacEntee was responsible for extending this particular managerial system to the counties. It was unfortunate that the first Government—I think the present Minister for Education was in charge of local government at the time—ever hit on the particular phrase "city manager" to describe these particular officers. It was an unfortunate description and one which certainly should not have been perpetuated. If this Bill did nothing but alter the title of the principal officer, it would be well worth putting through the House. The whole theory of local administration, as it is known here and in Great Britain, is that representatives are elected locally to carry out the administration of local affairs. The alteration of this system, so that the officer became a manager rather than a servant, is one which every member of the Fianna Fáil Party—and particularly Deputies MacEntee and Childers, who had close connection with local administration— knows very well was resented not only by local representatives but by a big body of public opinion throughout the country.

As far as I am concerned—and I think I can speak for nearly everyone occupying these benches, on this point —we are not approaching this Bill or Section 15 in any spirit or desire to insult or demean any of the present occupants of these posts. I would like to make that clear, because that has been the suggestion made by Deputy Childers, followed immediately by Deputy Allen, in their remarks on this section.

Comment on this

I understand that Deputy Cowan has moved amendments Nos. 24, 25, 27 and 28, and that we are entitled to discuss these amendments on the section. I propose just to say a few words in comment upon the starting change in attitude on the part of Deputy Cowan which these amendments suggest when they are contrasted with amendment No. 11. All of us who recall Deputy Cowan's performance on amendment No. 11 will undoubtedly have called up to their minds the image of the walrus who, after he had repleted himself with a feast of oysters, took out his handkerchief and wiped his streaming eyes. That, you all will remember, was the precise way in which Deputy Cowan painted the luckless position of county managers under sub-section (3) of Section 10 of the Minister's Bill. He told us what was going to happen if the Minister consulted with the councils of the counties before deciding to which county he would appoint the county manager: all considerations of justice and humanitarianism would be wiped away. He was thinking of the man who had established a home and whose family were being educated in certain schools; he pointed out what a hardship it would be to him to be appointed to a certain position, a very lucrative position, I may say. What has Deputy Cowan proposed to do under the amendment which proposes to delete sub-section (4) of Section 15? Under the Bill as it stands the Minister proposes to make an Order under the principal sub-section of the section:—

"Transferring functions to the county secretary of a county and such county secretary was appointed to that office before the commencement of this part of this Act, the Order shall not be made save with the consent of such county secretary."

One would think that that was a very harmless proposal, an equitable and just provision to have included in the section, but Deputy Cowan proposes in his amendment to delete the sub-section so that the Minister may make any Order he likes in respect of the officer without even consulting the officer concerned.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not read amendment No. 22.

Comment on this

Oh, I have read amendment No. 22, but I do not see that they are related to each other; they stand separately. If the Deputy wanted to amend the section substantially he could have proposed to delete the section and substitute another. I am not responsible if the Deputy was too indolent to draft an amendment that would have disclosed this intention. When he put amendment No. 11 on the Order Paper he put it in such a way as to conceal his intention; I do not say he is doing that now, but merely through indolence he drafted these amendments or perhaps they were given to him and he flung them at the House.

Let us leave that aspect and come to another one. I notice that Deputy O'Higgins has left the House. If there is one thing that has characterised the manifestations of political unity which we have been experiencing from the Government Parties during the last few months it is the way they stick to one another and occasionally they try to stick knives in one another, but I have not heard any dagger and cloak attack upon any Minister such as we have listened to to-night from Deputy O'Higgins. Deputy O'Higgins got up here and ascribed all the follies, all the misfortunes, all the evils, of the managerial system to that bright particular self-described star of the present Government, the present Minister for Education.

Deputies who were present at the Fine Gael Árd Fheis will know that I am not in any way exaggerating the opinion the Minister for Education has of himself in the political firmament of Ireland. Here we had Deputy O'Higgins blaming Deputy Mulcahy because it was the Cumann na nGaedheal Administration that introduced the managerial principle into Irish local administration. I am not going to say that merely because Cumann na nGaedheal introduced that principle it was a bad principle. On the contrary, we approached this problem in an objective way and decided that it was a good principle and that if it were good enough for Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Waterford it could equally be applied to County Dublin, County Cork, County Limerick, County Waterford— yes, and all the other counties in Ireland. That was done in 1940 and it is merely a manifestation of the utter ignorance that characterises the pronouncements of Deputies who support this Bill that Deputy O'Higgins did not even know what Deputy was Minister for Local Government when that Bill was introduced. I do not say that with any idea of refusing to accept responsibility for the County Management Bill when it was introduced by Deputy Ruttledge who was then Minister for Local Government. I do not refuse to accept responsibility, and full responsibility, for the fact that the Bill was introduced because, when Fianna Fáil was governing this country we had a Government which honoured the Constitution and which accepted collective responsibility for everything a Minister did and for everything a Minister said. The doctrine of constitutional responsibility has long been thrown over but the mere fact that it has been thrown over does not excuse Deputy O'Higgins for getting up here and making a statement which, if not deliberately misleading, was founded on ignorance.

Let us come to Section 15.

Comment on this
James Matthew Dillon Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Dillon) Independent

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Section 15 is a rather extraordinary section to appear in this Bill. I unfortunately had not the advantage of being in the House when the Minister for Local Government was introducing it, explaining it to the House and disclosing the purpose behind it, but it seems to me to be a curious section and quite an unnecessary section unless, of course, there is an ulterior motive in the minds of the Minister and the disunited Government of which he is a member. Why is it necessary, first of all, to declare in the Bill that the county manager will now be called "county officer" and, in the second place, to take power under Section 15 to turn him into something else? Surely that is a procedure which should be explained at some length so that we may see precisely what is the purpose behind the Bill, because I do not think the purpose is being disclosed.

I move to report progress.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In the discussion of this section, not on the whole purpose of the Bill.

Comment on this

If I am permitted to do so I move to report progress.

Comment on this