We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1951-52—Motion by the Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 1–192 of 372. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

In considering this Vote on Account it would be no harm to refer back to three years ago when this Government took office at the behest of the electors of this country. We are now celebrating the third anniversary of the election to office of this Government. No matter what the Deputies opposite may say, it must be agreed that this Government represents the views of the Irish people and at the last general election the electors made it very clear they were tired of Fianna Fáil and that a change was necessary. Despite the statements of the Deputies on the Opposition Benches that the people are dissatisfied with this Government, anybody who goes through the country and hears the views of various people as individuals and as members of organisations will be assured that the people have no desire to bring about a change of Government at the moment. Agriculture has never been so prosperous. When Fianna Fáil left office there were fewer cattle, sheep, pigs and poultry on our farms than ever before. During the past three years our live stock population has increased by leaps and bounds and the position now is that we have more stock on the farms of Ireland than at any time since the famine years. Every opportunity has been given to the farmers to reclaim and refertilise their land so as to enable them to bring about greater production in the years to come. Owing to world conditions to-day it is very necessary that the Minister for Agriculture should make every provision to enable farmers to produce sufficient crops and stock of all kinds to enable our people to live during a serious emergency if we cannot bring in anything from abroad. The best way to do that was to provide that the land would be drained and fertilised and then to make agreements with our nearest neighbour, always our best customer, England, on a long term under which she is willing to buy all our surplus stock and produce from the land.

While the Fianna Fáil Party believe in compulsion, we of Fine Gael, and I think every Party supporting the Government, believe that the best way to entice people to produce more from the land is by giving remunerative or economic prices. Fianna Fáil Deputies speak frequently of the growing of wheat but during the emergency the regulations were such that people could grow wheat on any type of land and were not obliged to grow it on the land which was bound to produce the best crops. If they ploughed ten acres there was no obligation on them to sow more wheat on that land than would cover one acre, so a certain type of people took advantage of that. While in 1946 over 600,000 acres of wheat were grown in this country the produce last year from half that acreage was greater. No matter what Deputies opposite may say about the position of agriculture and of the Irish farmers, I feel sure that they are perfectly satisfied at the present time.

Coming to the industrial arm, while I will admit that the Fianna Fáil Government did its best to improve our industries and also set up many factories here and there throughout the country, still at the present time more people are engaged in Irish industry than ever before, something in the neighbourhood of 220,000, whereas when Fianna Fáil left office the figure was about 68,000. Also this Government has made agreements not only with England but with continental countries by which we will get a sale for our surplus industrial products, and that is the first time that has been done in the history of the new State.

A great deal has been said from time to time by Deputies opposite by questions and in other debates to the effect that in an emergency this country is not prepared to defend itself. I do not think that it is a good thing for Deputies to try to draw information about our defence services, because after all if there were a war it would be well if potential enemies did not know our position. Some of the speakers opposite, and especially Deputy Major de Valera, who is apparently the shadow Minister in a future Government—he seems to be making an attempt in that direction— are continually raising the question of defence just as if this were a powerful nation, and we could defend ourselves independently of world conditions. It has been fully understood that in future wars our position must always be as far as possible to maintain neutrality.

It may be said that certain nations have a benevolent neutrality, but there is entirely too much talk about defence measures. Instead of bringing our young men into barracks to have them, as the Minister for Defence stated, knocking sparks out of the barrack squares, they should be working on the land or in the factories producing all the surplus goods possible so that we may stockpile and have vast surpluses for any emergency that may arise, when we cannot bring from abroad the goods we are unable to produce at home.

While the last Government did a great deal in connection with building houses there has certainly been no lack in that respect with the new Government. More men are employed on housing to-day than ever before, about 14,000, and we have built more houses. The object of this Government is to place a house at the disposal of everyone who requires one either in town or country.

From the point of view, therefore, of agriculture, industry, defence and housing, everything possible has been done for the welfare of our people. We have also been able to carry out very important drainage schemes under the Local Authorities (Works) Act and all over the country to-day farmers are taking advantage of that drainage scheme as well as of the land reclamation scheme. The arterial drainage scheme has also been put into operation as quickly as possible in so far as the machinery available will allow.

I think, therefore, that while the Vote on Account may seem a big sum of money, still the people to-day are so prosperous and are being given so many advantages and opportunities of improvement that even the Opposition cannot show any item which might be reduced. The various services require the sums of money allotted to them and no matter what may be said I think that the Opposition themselves are fully satisfied in their own mind that if they were in office to-day the Vote on Account might exceed £100,000,000 instead of the £83,000,000 we have at present.

After all, it is the wish of all Parties forming this Government, as I am sure it is the wish of Deputies opposite, that everything possible should be done to enable our people to live in the greatest form of prosperity. This Government has done much not only for the farmer but also for the industrialist, the industrial workers, the agricultural workers, the road workers and workers of all kinds, and has improved their position in every possible way, both as regards wages and conditions of service generally. So, in spite of the fact that Deputies opposite may criticise the supporters of the Government in the different Parties, I can assure them that never before during the three years that this Government has been in office has there been greater harmony and unanimity between the various Parties forming the Government than there is to-day.

Comment on this

On this Vote, as is perfectly permissible, the discussion has ranged over a very wide field. Last night we had a contribution from Deputy MacEntee in regard to the form and type of Government that is most suitable for a people. Deputy MacEntee made the point that, in a Coalition Government comprising Ministers representing several Parties, there cannot be progress, whereas the facts are that, under a Coalition Government comprising many Parties and Ministers representing different Parties, there has been a record of substantial progress and improvement, in spite of great difficulties during the past three years.

There is undoubtedly a fundamental difference between the type of Government we have now and what I might term the Fianna Fáil type. The present Government is a democratic Government in the proper sense of that term. The Parties in that Government can combine together to bring about benefits for the people. The most recent example of democracy in action was the decision of the Government to increase old age pensions to £1 a week——

Comment on this

They waited a long time before they anounced it.

Comment on this

——and the decision to amend the means test so as to bring a greater number of old age pensioners within the scope of the Old Age Pensions Acts.

Comment on this

A sop.

Comment on this

There was the further decision of the Government to make very substantial provision for members of the Old I.R.A. who were in receipt of those special allowances or members of the Old I.R.A. and the Army who were in receipt of disability pensions. The decision to bring about these improvements for these substantial sections of the people was due to the fact that we had a democratic Government in office, a Government that would not be deflected or prevented by the demands of financiers from doing their duty to those important sections of our people. The present Government is an example of democracy in action.

Clearly, in that form of Government there will be different points of view on many matters, there will be different stresses from time to time; but so long as the Government as a whole consider that their function is to operate in the interest of the public good, then that form of Government is the best form to have. What would the alternative be? It would not be a Government of people with different ideals each stressing a particular point of view, but it would be a Government ruled like a rod of iron by an individual, supported by a group of "yes-men" whose only anxiety would be to be loudest in their shouting of "yes" when the chief said "yes" and "no". when the chief said "no". That is the problem that is worth discussing on this particular Vote on Account. Are we to have the Government we have at the moment, democracy in action, or are we going back to the tyranny and the dictatorship of the one-man Government?

Comment on this

It has worked very well for some hundreds of years, anyhow.

Comment on this

Well, it did not work very well for 16 years.

Comment on this

The people thought so.

Comment on this

That is a problem that is worth considering. That is a problem that the country ought to consider at the moment.

Comment on this

Why do not you give them an opportunity?

Comment on this

The Deputy would die with fright if there were an election in the morning.

Comment on this

The country at the moment is considering whether this inter-Party arrangement is better than the system of one-man Government we had prior to that. We know that under the present system a worker, whether he is an agricultural worker, a road worker, an industrial worker or a worker of any other type, has freedom to express his political views. He has freedom to belong to any political Party he wishes. He knows that even if he is loudest in his condemnation of the inter-Party Government it will not affect his employment or the benefits to which he may be entitled from the State. The old age pensioner down the country for a long time lived in fear and trembling——

Comment on this

Nonsense!

Comment on this

——because of the political propaganda that a change of Government might affect his old age pension. The unemployed man who considers that his unemployment benefits might be affected by a change of Government knows now that, instead of having a Government which will interfere adversely with these benefits and allowances, he has a Government that is endeavouring to improve them. The road worker has not to be whipped into a Fianna Fáil club and has not to produce his Fianna Fáil membership card for the purpose of getting employment on the roads.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

He will not get a job.

Comment on this

The road worker is a free individual to-day, the agricultural worker is a free individual to-day, the industrial worker is a free individual to-day, and that freedom has been brought about by the inter-Party Government. Do Fianna Fáil think that the public memory is so short that the public have forgotten during the three years of inter-Party Government what it was to live under the one-man dictatorship of Fianna Fáil? Do those people who experienced that want to go back under that form of dictatorship and that form of tyranny?

Comment on this

Give them a chance to try—try them out.

Comment on this

Under the Constitution of this State, the people are entitled to be consulted by the Government when, having, as they have, the confidence of this House, the Government choose to go to the people and consult them.

Comment on this

And the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

This Government, having the support and confidence of this House, will go to the country at the right time; they will go to the country when it will be possible to put an end once and for all to this false idea on the Fianna Fáil Benches that there is nobody except Fianna Fáil fit to rule as a Government in this country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy come to the Vote on Account now? The Deputy was quite right when he said that that was referred to yesterday by Deputy MacEntee, but Deputy MacEntee did not devote his whole speech to it.

Comment on this

A substantial part of it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No, I listened to it for an hour. I did not prevent the Deputy from following, but not the whole of his speech surely.

Comment on this

The points that I have put before the House are, in my view, the important points that will be considered and are being considered by the country at the moment. It has been mentioned in this House already that this Government have introduced the Social Welfare Bill and I described that Bill as a charter of freedom and liberty to the workers of this country. We were told that when this Bill was introduced there would be an end to inter-Party Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy knows that legislation must not be discussed on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe got away with it.

Comment on this

Is that a reflection on the Chair?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is fairly well used to that from certain quarters, and they are on two sides.

Comment on this

It is in the Official Report.

Comment on this

The social welfare scheme has been discussed all over the country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And the Bill was referred to also. I do not want the Deputy to go into the Bill.

Comment on this

I will not follow on the lines of the Bill; I will just deal with the scheme.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is a very nice distinction, of course.

Comment on this

"A rose by any other name."

Comment on this

The social welfare scheme is a charter of liberty and freedom for the workers of this country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is existing legislation, not prospective.

Comment on this

I am not going into it in great detail, but the point I want to make in regard to it is that we were told that that scheme was going to bring about the end of this Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There will be lots of opportunities on the Bill which is in course of discussion.

Comment on this

Anyway, it will not achieve that. There are very sorry people on the opposite benches at the moment.

Comment on this

Who are they?

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party, who are the only people on the opposite benches in this House.

Comment on this

There are a few more.

Comment on this

There are no more. There was a hope that there would be more, but there are no more.

Comment on this

They are there all right.

Comment on this

Bring, them up from Clare.

Comment on this

I can assist Deputy Boland and Deputy Derrig by telling them that there will be no necessity for at least another 12 or 15 months——

Comment on this

We were well aware of that. That is not information.

Comment on this

——to be preparing for a general election. As long as we are agreed on that——

Comment on this

We are well aware that you will never be here again.

Comment on this

If we are agreed on that, let us have no more talk about elections and, in the meantime, let us work quietly, each in his own way, for the benefit of the country. Let us hope that all these allegations that we have had in recent weeks and months about jobs and jobbery will cease also.

Comment on this

The allegations or the jobbery?

Comment on this

That the allegations of jobbery will cease. We have all some responsibility to the country, and it is wrong that we should have these allegations bandied about from time to time. Fianna Fáil were in office for 16 years, and during that period they never held that there was anything wrong with appointing a person to a public or other office simply because he was a supporter of the Fianna Fáil Party. They never held that that was wrong. In fact, one of their Ministers, the then Minister for Lands, Deputy Moylan, laid it down that the loyalty of the individual to the Fianna Fáil Party was one of the matters to be considered, all other things being supposed to be equal. I take it that, having fixed up any appointments of their camp followers over a period of 16 years, the Fianna Fáil Party cannot understand what has hit them in the teeth that they cannot do it still, and they are annoyed that some person who has not a Fianna Fáil card in his pocket is appointed to some job. It is a great matter for the country that somebody other than a member of Fianna Fáil can get an appointment. That situation ought to be accepted and it ought to be faced. If it is accepted and faced, we would have less of the allegations that are being made from time to time in the House.

A complaint has been made in regard to the Vote on Account that the sum necessary to run the country efficiently is too high. At the same time as we have that viewpoint expressed, we have claims and demands for increased expenditure here and increased expenditure there. Everybody realises that in the matter of defence every reasonable step ought to be taken by the Government. Fianna Fáil wants us, wants the Government and wants the country to spend millions on buying armaments and equipment—which may be entirely out of date and useless in a year or two from now. Those speeches and declarations that we have heard in regard to defence are not concerned with defence at all. They are concerned with politics. They are playing politics pure and simple, demanding on the one side that you reduce expenditure and on the other that you increase expenditure by spending millions of money on armaments, which might be useless in a conflict that might take place in a year or two from now. This Government from its inception worked on the basis that war was not inevitable.

Comment on this

So Stalin says.

Comment on this

Time after time I have expressed my view in this House that there will not be a World War. If the world is so foolish as to go to war in the immediate future, with the dreadful instruments of destruction that are available, it will be an end to civilisation. Responsible statement and responsible authorities are endeavouring to find day after day how peace can be achieved. While that is the attitude of responsible statement all over the world—when it is the thing for which His Holiness the Pope is praying night and day—we find the Fianna Fáil Party telling us that war is inevitable.

Comment on this

Are we against the Pope then?

Comment on this

Make preparations for war, spend millions of money on useless armaments, take the young men out of industry, take them out of agriculture and train them as soldiers.

Comment on this

And then they will criticise you if you do it.

Comment on this

That is an attitude of mind which ought to be exposed in the country. I said yesterday in regard to the Supplementary Estimate for External Affairs that we are inclined to forget we are a small country. We are inclined to forget that we are a small country of 3,000,000 or 4,000,000 inhabitants, and we want to talk and swagger as if we were a nation of 100,000,000 or 200,000,000 inhabitants. It is, perhaps, a good thing that we are not part of the North Atlantic Defence Organisation, because we would have this Government twitted day after day from those benches if some naval, military or air force commanders were not from this State. When Deputy MacEntee was talking last night, he was repeating the speeches of Mr. Winston Churchill in the British House of Commons——

Comment on this

And Basil Brooke, his pal.

Comment on this

——repeating word for word the language of Mr. Winston Churchill as against the Labour Party that is in power in England.

Comment on this

The Deputy quoted Joe Stalin a few minutes ago.

Comment on this

I did not read that yet.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Deputy Cowan was very fond of Winston Churchill at one time.

Comment on this

I am afraid that Deputy Brennan may be innocent but, nevertheless, there is a basis of viciousness that ought not to be in a Deputy of his years.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I cannot blame myself for that. I cannot help it.

Comment on this

A Deputy of Deputy Brennan's years ought, perhaps, to be a bit charitable. In a particular period in the history of this country, he had the courage of his convictions and I had the courage of my convictions to stand on the other side.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must get back to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I just wanted to say that. There are men on the Fianna Fáil side of the House who were my comrades in the Army in those days.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

They were led astray, like a lot more.

Comment on this

They were with me. I understood that the Fianna Fáil Party was organised to abolish the bitterness of that period and to encourage the people of all sides to come together.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must endeavour to come back to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I am endeavouring to do that. I am trying to deal with interruptions. A foul mentality is pervading that Party there and however it may claim to lead the Irish people it will never lead anything more than a partisan section of the Irish nation.

Comment on this
A Deputy

It stood for the Republic all the time.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Cowan is entitled to make his speech without interruptions.

Comment on this

I suppose that the Republic and Republicanism has something to do with the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Government policy, financial and economic policy.

Comment on this

I can assure you and the House that never again will there be the disgraceful episode in this country, of Deputies being called together by these alleged Republicans to nominate an English king as king of this country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Now the Deputy must come to the Vote on Account or cease speaking. That is all.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it not a fact that this Vote on Account includes a sum for interest charges incurred during the Fianna Fáil Administration?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It has been pointed out clearly by the Chair that the financial and economic policy of the Government are the two items to be discussed on this Vote and not detailed items.

Comment on this

Surely it is wider than that. That is the general rule— that the discussion is confined to financial and economic policy—but surely the Chair does not intend to confine it strictly to that. It has never been done.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It has always been done.

Comment on this

It has never been strictly confined during the 26 years I have been here. We generally tried to facilitate everybody by saying what the main points for discussion would be, but Government policy as a whole has always been discussed on this Vote. This is one of the main debates of the year.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Cowan on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

Then make that quite clear.

Comment on this

I was dealing with the point that this Government has abolished a policy of sham and nonsense and has adopted the policy of facing up to realities instead. When the Taoiseach faced up to realities in Canada and announced the decision of the Government to put an end to the sham and establish instead the Republic of Ireland, where did he get his support? He got his support on these benches, the benches occupied by the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this

Because you were always a partitionist. That is why. We have a Republic of the Twenty-Six Counties now.

Comment on this

We must work step by step. We declared a Republic for the Twenty-Six Counties.

Comment on this

Indeed, you did.

Comment on this

And it will not be long until the Republic for the Twenty-Six Counties will have its jurisdiction extended over the 32 counties.

Comment on this

You disestablished the Six Counties.

Comment on this

That day will come.

Comment on this

When you get your army going.

Comment on this

And I sincerely hope that Deputy Brennan will be here to take part in the national rejoicings when that day dawns.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

God forbid, that I should be in the same company.

Comment on this

You will be there. If we are not in the same company in this world, I hope we will be in the same company in the next.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I would like to see which side you would be on in the Valley of Justice from a national point of view.

Comment on this

I was always on the right side anyway.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

We will not begrudge it to you but, at the same time, there will be a stone around some people's necks.

Comment on this

It is very difficult in discussion to know where exactly certain individuals stand.

Comment on this

Including yourself.

Comment on this

If I was on the right side in 1922 and someone else was on the other side and that someone else comes round to my side, would I not be inclined to think that I was always in the right?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair thinks the matter is not relevant at all.

Comment on this

I agree, and I accept the ruling of the Chair. I think it is quite out of order and out-of-date; but when Deputies, like Deputy Brennan, make these observations naturally I have to answer them. One of the objectives of the people who established this State was to establish democratic Government. For a number of years an effort was made to establish that democratic Government and then suddenly we found ourselves with our democracy gone and with a tyranny and a dictatorship established in the guise of democracy. We had to exist under that for 16 long years.

Comment on this

May I ask when the Deputy says we had a democracy?

Comment on this

I will answer that when I have finished my speech.

Comment on this

It was certainly not a democracy in 1924, 1925, 1926 and 1927.

Comment on this

I am talking about democracy. There were 16 years in which we had no democracy. At the end of that period we have again a democracy in practice.

Comment on this

We had seven elections in that period.

Comment on this

Before that we had a fake democracy.

Comment on this

I will admit that we had seven elections. General elections are most interesting.

Comment on this

Dictators never have them.

Comment on this

If one studies the history of France——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Not on the Vote on Account surely.

Comment on this

I would have liked to answer Deputy McCann's interruption.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am sure the Deputy will have an opportunity of doing that elsewhere.

Comment on this

I was about to say that elections can give one a democracy to-day and a dictatorship to-morrow, an empire to-day and a republic to-morrow. But I shall not go into that now. Probably another opportunity will come in which I can explode this myth about elections.

Comment on this

The electors will explode you.

Comment on this

That is the trouble.

Comment on this

That is right—that is the trouble.

Comment on this

We have now reached the point where everybody in the country is discussing what is happening. Go into any public house—I do that on occasion; I hope there is nothing wrong in it—and one hears there the ordinary people discussing what is happening in the Government and what is happening in the Opposition. The people are taking an intelligent interest in the affairs of the country as a whole.

Comment on this

Go down to Westland Row and see them going across to England.

Comment on this

Not so many now.

Comment on this

A great number of them.

Comment on this

We have quite a number of them coming back now, quite a number of those who left during the Fianna Fáil régime. Not only did they leave under that régime but they were forced out. They were booted out. Every facility that could be given to them to leave was given. They were forced out by the back of the neck. The returns show more people employed in industry now. That is proved by the statistical returns. But what is more important than all that is that the people are now taking an intelligent interest in what is happening. There cannot be a meeting in the Taoiseach's room now at 11 o'clock at night that is not discussed in every tavern and pub and hall all over the country. Is not that democracy? More important still, what is said at the meeting is known to everybody.

Comment on this

That is a revelation!

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil fully appreciate and realise the seriousness of that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy now relate all that to the Vote on Account?

Comment on this

Government policy —democracy. Government policy is to establish and maintain democracy. The Opposition wants to re-establish its benevolent dictatorship. The country does not want that benevolent dictatorship.

Comment on this

How do you know?

Comment on this

Give them a chance to show it.

Comment on this

By the time they get the chance they will have discussed the matter so fully that they will never make the same mistakes again that they made in the past. I think that is very important. I think it is vitally important.

It is vitally important and every democrat—I am glad to be able to express my faith in democracy—will be glad to know that that is the position in the country.

While we can maintain our democratic form of Government, the moneys voted by this House will be used in the interests of the people, and properly used in the interests of the people, and we will not be tied down by old ideas of so many shillings, so many pounds or so many millions. Money is not the be-all and the end-all of everything. Money is simply a vehicle or instrument by which people can render service to the community and receive from the community benefits in return. Whether the bill is £80,000,000, £90,000,000 or £100,000,000 matters nothing. What does matter is the happiness and prosperity of the people.

I am very proud to stand here to-day and accept the very dirty challenge that has been thrown out by the Fianna Fáil Party, with all these allegations of corruption that they are raising day by day, by this filthy conduct that we see from the Front Bench, of investigating in public the private and family affairs of public officials.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This has nothing whatever to do with the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I am finishing on this note——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I hope it is relevant.

Comment on this

I am glad to avail of this opportunity to answer that challenge. I am proud that we have found it possible to bring before the people this great social advancement, this new social welfare scheme. The next election will be fought on that scheme. It will be fought on the benefits that that scheme is providing for the people and the people, sensible as they are, will realise that the Government that gives them those benefits is a good Government and they will never go back to tyranny and dictatorship again.

Comment on this

I am very sorry, as a Dublin Deputy, that Deputy Peadar Cowan did not avail of this opportunity to voice the feelings of his constituents. He is in touch with most people, he says. He has been in taverns and elsewhere. I have been elsewhere but not in taverns but I have my agents in taverns.

Comment on this

You miss a lot.

Comment on this

I can tell the Government, if they do not know it, that what the average man in the bus queue, in the tavern or at the football match, or wherever else he is in Dublin, is saying: "How long more is this crowd going to hang on?" That is what he is saying.

Comment on this

That is a fact.

Comment on this

No more and no less. The people of this city and the people of this country have no longer any confidence in the groups that form the minority Inter-Party Government. The inter-Party Government is the coalition of a number of Parties, but they are in fact kept in power by a number of Independent Deputies. Sooner or later—and the sooner the better—the Independent Deputies must go to the people. The people want to meet the Independent Deputies who are keeping this minority inter-Party Government in power. The sooner a general election takes place, the better for this House because I am certain—I never was more certain of anything in my life—that if there was a general election in the morning the Fianna Fáil Party would come back with an overall majority.

I shall not go as far as the Iron Curtain on one side or any other distance on the other side. I think that Deputy Peadar Cowan or any other Deputy who speaks here should voice the feelings of his constituents. If Deputy Peadar Cowan thought more about Fairview, Marino, and the North Strand than he does about the eastern direction, it would be better for all concerned. The electors of this city had a specific promise from the people who constitute this inter-Party Government that the cost of living would be reduced. The biggest question confronting the average citizen to-day is the cost of living. The people who sit behind the Government on the Government Benches are the best indication and illustration of that—Deputy Jim Larkin and those who are actually officers of organised trade unions. I could give a whole list of organisations of workers that would refute the statement of the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce. Deputy Morrissey, that we are the best-off people in the world. Recently we saw in the City of Dublin a hunger march, if you please—that is what it was called—by the Post Office Workers' Union. A general meeting was called to demand increase in wages and as far as I know, the only person who did not attend that meeting of the Post Office Workers' Union was their general secretary, Deputy Norton, the present Tánaiste. Why? Why did he not attend the general meeting of the Post Office workers who were demanding an increase in wages having regard to the cost of living? Why does not he go back and face the people from whom he has got a livelihood over a great many years? Why does not he face the workers of Dublin? Why do not he and his colleagues in the Government decide to face the people when they know that the people are saying what I have said they are saying, that they are hanging on to office and will hang on as long as they are able?

The sort of talk that we heard from Deputy Peadar Cowan about the dictatorship that existed under Fianna Fáil is the greatest nonsense and the greatest rubbish, but, unfortunately, there were people who fell for that sort of foul propaganda before the last election, just as they fell for it when they were told specifically by Deputy Peadar Cowan and his co-candidates in Dublin North City that the cost of living could be reduced by 30 per cent. They promised to reduced the cost of living by 30 per cent. "Defeatists will tell you it cannot be done. It can be done and it will be done"—that is from their own election address. I would ask Deputy Peadar Cowan to ask any worker in this city how does the cost of living now compare with the cost of living before this Government took office.

The unemployment question was to be solved overnight. It is not yet solved. I read figures yesterday in the daily Press which gave the figure around 68,000 unemployed. Approximately 70,000 people are unemployed in this country and approximately 20,000 people emigrated from this country last year. For the first nine months of the year the figure was 15,000 as published in the daily Press, and it is safe to assume that a comparable number left in the last three months. My belief is that many more left. Deputy Alfred Byrne and other Dublin Deputies who are in the House know the people who are coming to them and other Dublin Deputies every day of the week, the people who are literally and starkly on the bread line, who have no work and for whom we cannot get work.

In my opinion, and in the opinion of those who have followed events in this country over the past 16 or 19 years, the unemployment question would be infinitely worse if the Fianna Fáil policy of industrialisation had not been carried into effect. They know the people would be infinitely better off if that policy of industrialisation had not been obstructed. What is now admired and taken over, and what is spoken highly of by the present Government, the industrial position here, was referred to in other terms in years gone by. During my 11 or 12 years in the House, I heard Deputies talking repeatedly about the workshops and the factories as the sweat-shops and the back-room factories.

I say that it is largely due to our policy in the past that there are not a lot more than 70,000 people now out of employment here. The people who form the present Government told us at one time they could sweep unemployment away overnight. As it is, they are still sitting there clinging on like limpets to a rock, holding on to office, and refusing to take the opinions of their constituents, the opinions of members of various organisation that have worked for them and that have since resigned, organisations that helped to form this inter-minority Party Government.

Those people are still hanging on to office and we, in Dublin, who are in touch with development works, know that there cannot be any considerable expansion of the industrial policy of Fianna Fáil because the majority of the people in this country have no confidence whatever in any part of the policy of the present Government.

We hear a lot about emigration and we were often told that it was Fianna Fáil that caused emigration. There was nothing at all said, when these gentlemen were going before the electorate, about the exodus that occurred under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. Only Fianna Fáil could cause emigration—that was the cry during the war period when it was impossible to bring in the raw materials of industry. The fact is that since the inter-Party Government were formed, emigration continued just the same. Has there been any reduction in emigration? They set up a commission, but that commission has not yet reported, and the exodus goes on, to the tune of at least 20,000 per annum.

I did not hear Deputy Cowan adverting to the position of vocational education in the City of Dublin. Deputy Cowan is as much in touch with events in Dublin as I am. He, too, is a member of the Dublin Corporation and he must know that the Government have done nothing whatever to extend vocational education in the city. Representatives of the City of Dublin Vocational Education Committee have gone to the Government to ask what their policy is and where the money is to come from to put into operation the building and other plans already prepared. They were told: "Go to the Dublin Corporation and see what they can do for you." Last year the Dublin Corporation put up £130,000 for this purpose. This year they have been called upon to put up another £125,000. That is what I want to hear Deputy Cowan and other Dublin City Deputies talking about— the apparent policy of this Government reneging its responsibilities and putting them on to the rates.

I am not satisfied that any great proportion of the millions that Deputy Cowan says are being spent, is coming the way of the Dublin ratepayers. So far as I am aware, no very significant or proper proportion of that money is coming our way. We were asked in the Dublin Corporation only a few weeks ago to reimburse a sum of £3,000 for a temporary health clinic.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Would that not be more appropriate on the Estimate?

Comment on this

I do not want to follow Deputy Cowan or any other Deputy who strayed many thousands of miles away from this Vote on Account. My first effort in this House when I came here some years ago was on a Vote on Account after I had listened to Front Bench Fine Gael Deputies who travelled practically all over the globe in the course of their remarks.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has indicated that detailed matters of administration are more appropriate to Estimates and are not usually discussed on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I regard Deputy Cowan's arguments on defending, or rather not defending, this country as the most fallacious I ever heard. I cannot quite see his reasoning and I cannot agree with his idea of not defending ourselves against outsiders. He tells us the equipment we would buy would be obsolete in a couple of years and his suggestion is we are not to do anything to defend ourselves. It would appear that while he is thinking of that in the international direction, he is at the same time thinking about a little private army that he may or may not have. Where he is going to get the weapons—even obsolete weapons—for that little army in order to undo Partition, I do not know.

We should be prepared to defend ourselves here in this part of Ireland. We should be prepared to put on the hair shirt, if necessary, and spend to the limit on defence. The people who talk about not defending this country obviously have not been in the Irish tradition at all. I would advise them to read Griffith and Pearse, to read anybody, any revolutionary particularly, who ever wrote on this question. What is the use in winning freedom only to lose it, Davis said. We must arm to the utmost.

I do not attribute this to any Deputy in the House, because I have no evidence, but the only sense I can see in some arguments advanced is that some people would prefer to see somebody else either conquering us or defending us. That is as much as I will say on it. I believe we should defend ourselves and spend to the limit, even until it hurts us, in preparation.

We have heard all this rubbish about war being inevitable. Fianna Fáil is not saying that war is inevitable. Fianna Fáil is saying what every sensible Party and every sensible leader the world over says. They hope war is not inevitable but at the same time the people who say that are arming to the teeth, arming in defence of their rights and their homes. That is what I understand as being free and guarding freedom. There is no other way of guarding freedom except by arming.

We are not against social welfare schemes. If Deputy Cowan or any other Deputy talks about Fianna Fáil being against social welfare schemes, I say that that is not so. The criticism directed against us by the biggest Party in the present inter-Party Government was that we were spending too much in our time on social welfare schemes. I remember well in my early years in this House the Leaders of the Opposition talking about the squandermania of Fianna Fáil. I remember clearly the occasion when an Opposition Deputy was asked by the then Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, would he be prepared to cut down on houses and what would the people do without houses and that Deputy replied: "Let them go along to Hell and do without them."

That seems to be the opinion of that Party, that we were spending too much on social welfare, that we were creating a spirit in the people of ne'er do well, and that we were responsible for doles and everything that was un-savoury in life. They cannot have it both ways. We are not opposed to social welfare and I am not going to attack the scheme or the Bill. We, in fact, are the Party who introduced the social welfare scheme in this country and the Leader of this Party and the men who form the Opposition Front Bench, are the people who can best be looked to, to operate social welfare schemes when we are again returned as a Government which I hope will be soon. If the present Government have any honour left in them at all, they should go to the people. The people want them to go to them so that they can turn them out of office.

Comment on this

This Vote on Account is only part of the total bill which the Minister for Finance hopes to present to the House for sanction in the course of the next few months. In introducing the Vote, the Minister gave a concise explanation of the various sums included in it and stated the reasons for the increase in the various Estimates for the coming year. One of the points he made should, I think, command the serious consideration of Deputies and of the people of the country generally. That is, that you cannot have increased social services and increased expenditure unless you have more production and still more production; in other words, we cannot have our cake and eat it. The Minister referred to the fact that there was a good deal of extra money in circulation during the last few years, due to a very large extent to the fact that we have repatriated a good percentage of our sterling assets. He expressed the view that that could be a good policy, so long as the people spent that money on essentials but he issued the warning that, so far as his judgement went, he was afraid that a good part of these assets were being spent on non-essentials. In other words, whilst we hear a good deal about the high cost of living, any man who has given any thought to the position, who keeps his eyes open and sees what is going on around him, must come to the conclusion that there is another factor responsible as well as the high cost of living and that is, the high cost of pleasure. It may be an unpopular thing to say but it is, nevertheless, true. Therefore when one hears about the high cost of living one should keep in mind what is happening in other directions so far as amusements and pleasure are concerned.

Personally, I think that Deputies of all Parties should hearken to what has been stated by the Minister for Finance. Deputies opposite may think that it would be good propaganda for them to quote some of the statements of the Minister for Finance but I, personally, think he would be falling in his duty if he did not, in view of the responsible position which he holds, sound a note of warning as to the course we are pursuing in this country. That refers to the people as a whole, the people who voted for Fianna Fáil as well as those who voted for the inter-Party Government.

I am one of those who always believed in the divine precept that man must earn his bread by the sweat of his brow. It is not by passing Acts of Parliament that this country can be made prosperous. I believe that there is no use in magnifying out of all proportion any little inconveniences from which the people of this country suffer at the moment.

I am not going to say that the inter-Party Government are infallible or that they have turned this country into a land flowing with milk and honey but I do say, as one who has studied the position of the country from every angle, that, taking a general view, the people of this country enjoy as high, if not a higher, standard of living at the present time than the people of any other country in the world. I think we should all be thankful for that happy state of affairs.

Comparisons have been made here between the policy pursued by the Fianna Fáil Government and that at present pursued by the inter-Party Government. Let me say, as I said when Fianna Fáil were in power, that I think they did the best they could, taking into consideration the set of circumstances which existed during those years. I gave vent to my feelings on many occasions during those years. I wish to give vent to them again on this occasion and to tell Fianna Fáil that, when all is said and done, a great part of the policy which they pursued for those 16 years will be pursued, and must necessarily be pursued, by whatever Government succeeds them. It would be a very sad state of affairs in this or any other country if a change of a Government meant that everything that the outgoing Government did was wrong. I think that is an aspect of the matter that should be recognised by Deputies of all Parties. There is no use, therefore, in wasting time in speaking to Deputies regarding the policy pursued by Fianna Fáil, especially as it affected industrial production in this country. They pursued it at great length and made a success of it. We are pursuing the same policy and if as a result of the efforts of the Minister for Industry and Commerce during the past three years, the numbers engaged in industry have increased and production has increased. I think that should be a matter of congratulation for all concerned, including the Opposition because that is a factor that is going to affect the prosperity of the people who support Fianna Fáil as well as the people who support the inter-Party Government.

As regards other matters which have been discussed on this Vote, I made up my mind that I must obey the Chair on this occasion because it would be unwise to dwell at length on the different items that comprise this Vote. We shall have many occasions in the next few months to deal with these questions on the Budget, but I would appeal to members of the Opposition to cease belittling the efforts that have been made in particular by the Departments of Agriculture and of Industry and Commerce. Such criticism is not good for the future of this country. The Fianna Fáil Party consists of 66 or 67 members and, assuming that each Deputy received between 5,000 and 6,000 votes, that Party represents a very considerable section of our people. Neither this nor any other Government can do very much unless they have the co-operation of that large section of the people. When a Government is established, all Irishmen who are anxious for the welfare and prosperity of the country should do what they can to assist in reason the efforts of the various Ministers. Therefore, I deplore some of the references that have been made, particularly to agriculture. While I may not be a farmer, I come from farmer-stock. I do not wrap myself up in a box all day, but move about a good deal. I do not think there is any Deputy who moves as freely as I do amongst the people in the constituency I represent. I am not going to say that the members of the farming community are all millionaires, but I can honestly say I see, on all sides, in their case a degree of prosperity which has never been equalled over the last 40 or 50 years. I say that honestly, but I may be wrong. Human nature being what it is, I know, of course, that you will always find some people who may not be doing well. You will find that in every sphere of life. The human factor being what it is, you will find that some men cannot succeed no matter what they have. But, leaving politics out of it altogether, I would say that the farming community, as a whole, are to-day enjoying a degree of prosperity which has never been surpassed in this country over the past 40 years.

I am not attributing all that to the efforts of the inter-Party Government. The circumstances which exist at the moment may have a lot to do with it. Above all, I would say that the chief credit for it must be due to the farmers themselves, including those who support the Fianna Fáil Party. That again, I suggest brings home the force of my argument that you must have co-operation if you want to have prosperity in the country. Therefore, when I hear a Deputy say that the farmers are a depressed class my feeling is that such as statement is not calculated to do a good service to his Party, to the people as a whole or to the country.

References have been made to the question of unemployment. There, again, that is a matter which cannot be solved overnight. Since I became a member of this House almost 24 years ago, I have been preaching that there is no such thing as a solution for unemployment. The human element enters into that, too. You will always have unemployment as you will always have emigration. I have made that clear in every election which I have fought. I have never promised the people that I had a solution for that problem. It is a problem which will always remain not only here but in all countries. Therefore, there is not much use in quoting statistics as to the number who are or who are not employed. About 19 years ago, when the present Leader of the Opposition was in opposition, I remember him making a statement to the effect that he saw no reason why this country could not support 9,000,000 people. I was only a back bencher at the time, and I said to him that sooner or later, he would have to go back on that statement, which he did. I give him every credit for doing so. He found later that it was a much more difficult question to solve than he then thought, and I give him credit for having made that admission. As a back bencher at the time, I knew that it was one of the things which could not be solved, and that never will be solved. The only thing a Government can do is to keep down the numbers as far as possible. There, again, the question of its solution, even in a partial manner, will depend to a very large extent on the Government and the Opposition working together in providing the ways and means of giving added employment to those who at the moment are unemployed.

The last point I wish to make is one which I have repeated many a time from public platforms during general elections. I want to emphasise it here and now. The point is that there seems to be an inclination on the part of the people of this country not to recognise the fact that this is a small country, and that we can give a certain decent standard of living to the majority of our people, that is in the physical sense—not from the point of view of pleasure or amusement, but from the point of view of physique and good health. If people would only recognise that fact this could be one of the best and happiest countries in the world. We cannot give a standard of living to certain of our people, one which, to say the least of it, would not be good for them. We have to remember that this is a small country of about 3,000,000 people. It depends in the main on agriculture. We must admit, when all is said and done, that agriculture is the mainstay of the country. When we see how the people engaged in that industry live, I think we must come to the conclusion that, though we are a small country, we are enjoying here as high as a standard of living as can be found in any other part of the world.

The warning that I want to issue is that, if we want to maintain that standard of living we can only do so by hard work and by increased production, and by more production, to use the words of Sir Stafford Cripps when he was Chancellor of the Exchequer in a Labour Government in England a few years ago. Acts of Parliament will not make this country prosperous but rather co-operation between employers and employees, together with the doing away of class distinction, the mistrust and the selfish spirit which seem to be creeping in amongst the people of this country, and which, if persisted in, will do more damage than all the guns or airplanes of an enemy or of an invading army.

I think that, taking everything into consideration, this Vote on Account, although it only represents something less than one-third of the total amount which will be necessary to carry on the government of the country during the next 12 months, is one that should be examined very carefully by all Deputies. We should not forget the fact that we can only give the money to whatever Minister is in power as we have it.

The best way to have it is to work for it. I should like to say also with regard to taxation, especially on the farming community, that I was surprised and pleased to hear the Minister for Social Welfare stating that almost 75 per cent. of the moneys given by way of social services, old age pensions and so on, went to the rural community which proves that all the moneys raised for carrying on the social services of the country do not go merely into the pockets of those in the cities and towns.

I make this final appeal, that, if we want this country to prosper, there must be more co-operation and less carping criticism. This talk about a general election is all moonshine. It may provide a certain amount of excitement for the Irish people—we are an excitable people and we like excitement—but general elections are not just good paying things. As to the people being bubbling over with a desire to get this Government out, I might remind Deputies that I am in my constituency almost every day and I have never met one man yet who said that we should get out. If we are as bad as we are made out to be, I should imagine that there would be howling mobs with bludgeons outside the gates to meet every member of the inter-Party Government. I do not see these things happening. Let the Opposition wait for another year and a half and all Parties will have an opportunity of putting their respective programmes before the people. This being a democratic country, the people can put this Government out. We will give them the opportunity, but we will not go until the time is up, because we believe we have a duty to carry on for the five years for which we were elected.

Comment on this

When the Minister brought in this Vote on Account, he scarcely had in mind the matters of which Deputy Coburn has reminded the House, that we are a small, poor country of about 3,000,000 population, that the only way we can afford to pay this Bill is by working hard, that we are mainly an agricultural country, and that all these millions, or the main part of them, must come from agriculture. I wonder if the Minister, in preparing the Estimates represented by this Bill, I had all these things in mind. We have heard people in this House described as having faces of brass. It is a popular phrase with the Minister for Agriculture when referring to Opposition Deputies.

I suggest that the Minister for Finance has a face of brass in coming before a country of 3,000,000 people, a people who are mainly an agricultural people, and asking them to foot the bill set out here in the Book of Estimates, plus another £10,000,000 or £11,000,000 for Central Fund Services and large amounts for borrowing.

Although when they took office, each and every group represented in the Government was pledged to reduce taxation, to reduce the cost of living and to make the country a better, a cheaper and an easier place to live in, in the three years during which this heaven-sent Government has been in office, the cost of Government has increased by £28,000,000. In addition, £54,000,000 have been borrowed in the same period, plus £41,000,000 made available out of the Transition Development Fund, which is borrowed money also. That means that £95,000,000 of borrowed money has been at the disposal of the Minister in the past three years. The national debt has increased by almost 100 per cent., leaving aside the American counterpart fund, in these three years and the service of debt has gone up practically 100 per cent. There are the Minister's figures and I am sure he will not deny them.

Can the country afford to continue increasing the cost of Government each year? When this Minister took office in February, 1948, the Book of Estimates was just being issued and he incorporated in that Book of Estimates the now famous blue slip stating that the Coalition Government were repudiating that Book of Estimates, that they were not accepting it and did not propose to provide moneys to honour it, but, in spite of that, we find that in three years he has increased the cost of Government services by £28,000,000 over and above what it was in the last year of the Fianna Fáil Government.

The Minister, in his opening statement, gave no justification whatever for that huge increase, for that alarming and frightening increase, in the cost of Government. Remember that this sum of £28,000,000 adds nothing whatever to the wealth of this community. It is true that it may be providing a livelihood for a large number of people, but it adds nothing to the community's wealth. It is completely non-productive and will return nothing to the Exchequer, except what comes in in the shape of income-tax. The capital and other services of this State have gone up from almost £59,000,000 in 1947-48 to over £83,000,000 in 1951-52, and capital liabilities have gone up from £100,000,000 to £183,000,000. While the Fianna Fáil Government in their 16 years of office borrowed £38,000,000, the Coalition Government in three years have borrowed £39,000,000. In addition, they have borrowed 128,000,000 dollars and they also got 16,000,000 dollars in grants. Is it any wonder that we have the claim that there is prosperity in the country, whether there is or not. There should be prosperity of a type hitherto unknown in this country when all these millions are being let loose. If we have not got prosperity when all the millions being screwed out of the taxpayers' pockets, not to speak of the amounts taken from the pockets of the ratepayers, and all the millions being borrowed we are being let loose in the spending spree we have had in the past three years, we will never have prosperity in this nation.

It never can, because it will be agreed even by the Minister for Finance that this borrowing and going into debt cannot continue. This nation cannot continue on the basis of borrowing and of increasing the public debt, in addition to increasing taxation—taking people's earnings year by year. We see the colossal sums that the Minister is demanding for the present year.

During the course of the debate which has ranged over many problems, charges were made against this Party to the effect that when we were in office we did not provide money for social services on the same grand scale as this Coalition Government now proposes to do. It might be interesting to throw our minds back over a few years and to see what Fianna Fáil did during its term of office. One of our first actions in 1932 was to restore the shilling to the old age pensioners which our predecessors in office had taken from them when they were hard up for money. Just imagine that there was an Irish Government, less than 20 years ago, that took a shilling from the old age pensioners—and the majority of the members of that Government are now sitting on the Government Front Bench to-day. However, Fianna Fáil restored to the old age pensioners in 1932 the amount which they were getting previously.

Comment on this

You kept them down to 10/- all during the war.

Comment on this

We will get the sucking bottle for you. Before we left office we gave an additional 5/- to the old age pensioners.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Minister for Finance (Mr. McGilligan) Fine Gael

You refused 2/6 to them.

Comment on this

The amount from public funds to old age pensioners in 1947 was 15/- per week and the only increase they have had since was 2/6 from this Government. The Fianna Fáil Government brought in the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Act which has been in operation for many years. They brought in the children's allowances.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture forced you to do so.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Rooney object to that? They also brought in many other social benefits for the poorer sections of the community. There is, further, the question of unemployment assistance. Many of us can remember that less than 20 years ago a man, if he was not in industrial employment and happened to lose whatever employment he might have had, had nothing to fall back on but home assistance. That was so in 1927, 1928 and 1929 and it affected many fine young agricultural workers in the country. If men employed in towns in nonindustrial employment happened to lose their employment, there was no public fund except the Home Assistance Fund to draw on—and what they got from that was not capable of keeping body and soul together. We also brought in a Wet Time Insurance Act, which operatives in the building industry hailed at the time and which is praised at present as being one of the best Acts ever introduced. Numbers of people engaged in the building industry have told me that during the past winter, because of all the bad weather and frost during December of last year and January and February of this year, they would have found themselves in very serious difficulties were it not for the Wet Time Insurance Act which enabled them to draw two-thirds of their ordinary rate of pay during all the broken weather in these past three months. In addition, we increased unemployment insurance benefit by 50 per cent. in 1947. We increased national health insurance benefit by an extra 50 per cent. and both without any extra charge to the insured person.

One of the first actions of the Coalition Government was to steamroll an Act through this House forcing the employees and the employers to pay extra on stamps each week. At the time the Labour Party in this House were as quite as mice, as the Minister for Agriculture said. They allowed this Act to go through without a protest even though it imposed an extra burden on the workers of the country. We introduced a Holidays Act to give holidays with pay to many sections. of the workers, for the first time in the history of this country. Our social legislation at that time was in advance of that of any other country in Europe. We gave the farm workers, for the first time ever, a charter which entitled them to a minimum rate of wages. That social benefit affected many thousands of farm workers and it is still regarded as a great benefit by the agricultural workers of this country.

During the term of office of the Fianna Fáil Government an extra £9,000,000 was provided for social services, while only £4,000,000 was provided for that purpose by their predecessors in office. At the time we left office £13,000,000 were being paid out in social services to the different sections of the community. We built 34 hospitals and tens of thousands of houses. The great Health Act of 1947 was put through this House by a Fianna Fáil Government. Under that Act, full benefits were provided for the first time for those who are unfortunate enough to be suffering from tuberculosis, and also for their families. It has taken three years, a lot of noise, hot talk and nonsense before any further section of that Act has been put into operation. The mother and child section of that Act was ready to be brought in when the present Government took office. It is not going to come into operation yet.

Comment on this

Was drafted?

Comment on this

It was provided for in the 1947 Act.

Comment on this

It is still there.

Comment on this

It was in the course of being drafted.

Comment on this

What was in the course of being drafted?

Comment on this

If the Minister for Finance gets his way I am sure that it will not be brought into operation.

Comment on this

What was in the course of being drafted? I thought it was there?

Comment on this

The Act was passed the previous year and many social amenities were provided in that Act besides the mother and child scheme which the Minister does not want and which, I am sure, he would not like to see implemented, because in addition to the bill which he introduced, the mother and child scheme would cost us £4,000,000 or £5,000,000.

Comment on this

We are looking for that draft of yours.

Comment on this

We have not a bit of doubt about it.

Comment on this

We have not got the draft.

Comment on this

It is a bit of an annoyance to the Coalition. The mother and child scheme gave them many a sleepless night.

Comment on this

Looking for your draft? The draft is not there and never was.

Comment on this

The members of the Government are like the mother without a child, if such a thing could be.

Comment on this

Without a draft.

Comment on this

For two or three years we understand that a draft has been prepared.

Comment on this

Was it in your time?

Comment on this

The Minister for Social Welfare published a scheme in 1946. When he was Deputy Norton he announced it in this House and told the country about it. He published it during the general election campaign, but it was almost three years before that scheme saw the light of day. He was not then, however, simple Deputy Norton, but Minister for Social Welfare. What happened to the scheme of plain Deputy Norton, the Leader of the Labour Party in this House, the scheme published in 1946 or 1947 that was going to cost only £26,000,000 or £28,000,000? Lo and behold, this one is going to cost £6,000,000. That was a big climb down, and I am sure that the Minister for Finance had a big hand in paring down that wonderful scheme which the Minister for Social Welfare had prepared and on which he fought the election in 1948 and which he had published a year before in pamphlet form. Deputy Fitzpatrick may have seen it.

Comment on this

Let us hope that you will not try to pare it down any more.

Comment on this

I am sure he read the £26,000,000 scheme. I do not know whether he approved of it or not.

Comment on this

Tell us whether you approve of the Vote on Account or not.

Comment on this

The cupboard was bare of any scheme when we went there.

Comment on this

The scheme has not been implemented yet, and we have no indication from the Minister for Finance that he will provided funds to implement the mother and child scheme this year.

Comment on this

You have not read your Estimates, boy.

Comment on this

There is nothing in this Book of Estimates to provide for the social welfare scheme or the mother and child scheme, and when those two schemes come to be implemented it will mean an addition of at least £7,000,000 or £8,000,000 in the present financial year. No provision whatever has been made for either of those schemes.

Comment on this

You are entirely wrong. The Department of Health Estimate carries the mother and child scheme expenses.

Comment on this

We know quite well what you will do; you will borrow more.

Comment on this

And break your heart.

Comment on this

To finance those schemes you will have recourse to borrowing if you can find anyone who will give you anything. The counterpart fund, of course, is at the Minister's disposal and is not all used up. He can draw on that for a while, but, unfortunately for the country, the day of the spending spree will come to an end very shortly and well the Minister for Finance knows that. Our sterling assets, about which there has been so much talk in the country during the last three years, are being brought home, but they are being brought home via luxury goods, not for capital investment. They are being depleted and spent on luxury goods. That is not what the country and the House would like to see.

Comment on this

What goods?

Comment on this

All you have to do is to read the Minister for Finance's opening statement on this Vote on Account and you will see that, while he is very perturbed, he has not succeeded in influencing his colleagues in the Cabinet about the seriousness of the situation. I am sure that he has told them time after time that this colossal borrowing cannot go on. There has been much talk about general elections, but the people are more perturbed about the colossal borrowing and the money which is being spent like jackstones by this Government than about anything else.

Any family knows quite well that if it goes into debt it is only a matter of days, weeks or months until it must go bankrupt. If a family goes on spending more than it earns in any week or year it will be pile up debt and credit comes to an end in a short time. The danger is that our credit, because of this colossal spending and borrowing and the dissipation of our assets abroad, must come to an end in a short time. In introducing the Vote on Account the Minister for Finance said (column 789, Volume 124, No. 5):

"The disturbing feature, of course, is the deficit in the balance of payments, particularly when that is marked by the great increase in consumption here, especially when that great increase in consumption is attached to the non-essential goods. The continuance of such a situation for any period would be highly dangerous."

What is being done to stop that situation from continuing? He went on:

"It would jeopardise the policy, popularly, I think, approved of, to repatriate sterling assets. But repatriation of sterling assets is only of use if they are used solely or mainly for investment and development."

Were the £30,000,000 sterling assets which we brought home last year used for development or investment at home? The Minister for Finance seems to think they were not? He goes on:

"If the development policy must be continued, that policy can only be continued without danger if the savings of the community are increased."

Are the savings of this community being increased at the present time? Is our agricultural output greater now than it was in 1938?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It just barely reached the 1938 figure and is not increasing. The indications are that the increase which took place since the end of the war has now ceased. Referring to the repatriation of our sterling assets, the Minister also said:

"They can be increased if people refrain from expenditure on non-essential goods. There is a tremendous margin over what was spent in 1938. There is plenty of slack to be gathered in. That is the chief lesson to be learned from the economic trend of 1950."

I hope the Minister will seek to gather in that slack. It will be necessary to gather it in from somewhere. It will not be got from the Phoenix Park, as all that is gone.

There is no doubt that the country is disturbed because of many serious factors in Government policy. It is well known to every section of the community that this Government, and many members of it, are being driven along a line they do not approve of. It is a well-known fact that, day after day, month after month and year after year, this Government, in order to maintain its position as a Government and keep itself together, had to pay out to one or other group of its members, in one form or another, by giving way in this direction or that, in order to keep itself together.

Comment on this

Half-a-crown a week extra on old age pensions.

Comment on this

I will deal with that in a moment and am glad the Deputy reminded me about it. There were many pay-outs to the groups forming the Government, in order to keep them together for the last three years, very many pay-outs at the expense of the community, at the expense of the taxpayer. That is a well-known fact, which is disturbing the people more than anything else. That is why they are wishing for a general election, wishing for an opportunity of putting in place of the present Government a Government of responsibility.

Comment on this

Can we take it that the Deputy objects to an increase in old age pensions, widows' and orphans' pensions and so on?

Comment on this