We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1951-52—Motion by the Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 193–372 of 372. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

According to the list before me, Deputy Con Lehane has spoken already.

Comment on this

I was only looking for information.

Comment on this

We have had a Social Welfare Bill, which was much publicised and on which lectures were given by State servants. It is the first Bill introduced here on which civil servants had to be sent broadcast throughout the country at State expense in order to popularise that Bill before it was introduced.

Comment on this

How do you broadcast a civil servant?

Comment on this

In the 30 years' existence of this State it is the first time any measure introduced by a Minister of State here was lectured on by lecturers from the Minister's Department, sent broadcast throughout the country before its introduction.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is criticising legislation that has not yet passed this House.

Comment on this

Reference was made to the Social Welfare Bill. I am criticising to-day what has been done, and not anything that is to be done in the future.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not law and therefore it does not arise.

Comment on this

He is not even referring to it.

Comment on this

Let me put it this way. In the taxation that was provided for the past year, some of those moneys were utilised to send State servants of the Department of Social Welfare to give lectures on the Social Welfare Bill.

Deputy Lehane asked me what my attitude and the attitude of this Party was on the matter of the increase proposed in old age pensions on last Friday for the first time. It had nothing whatever to do with the Social Welfare Bill. Before that extra 2/6 or 5/- can be given, there will have to be a law passed through this Dáil other than the Social Welfare Bill.

Comment on this

No, it is in it. That is the Deputy's difficulty.

Comment on this

Further, it will be No. 3 Social Welfare Bill.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy in favour of it or against it?

Comment on this

Wait and see.

Comment on this

We have been waiting half an hour.

Comment on this

Last Friday the Minister for Social Welfare, who came in to introduce the Social Welfare Bill, introduced also something that was not in the Bill before the House. There was no section, clause or heading in that Bill covering a proposal to increase old age pensions.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is that in this account we are dealing with?

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance has interrupted me on a number of occasions in the ten minutes. I am speaking——

Comment on this

Half an hour.

Comment on this

——to inquire what my attitude was on the proposed increase in old age pensions.

Comment on this

I did not ask. I object to that. I did not say anything of the sort.

Comment on this

Someone did.

Comment on this

I did.

Comment on this

The Government have all the power they need without waiting for any legislation here to give 2/6, 5/-, or 10/- extra to the old age pensioners, from next Monday morning if they wish. They need not wait to send State servants out to make the publicity they are hoping to get from this extra 2/6. The House and the country know why this was announced last Friday, why it was not announced the previous Friday or six months ago. Everyone is fully aware that the extra £1,000,000 was provided for one purpose. It was not for the interest of the old age pensioners, but to keep the 13 Ministers together in that Coalition Government. It was the price that was paid, the latest price, and it will be charged against the country, to keep the Coalition together. Is not that a well-known fact?

Comment on this

It is public knowledge that the price was paid for four or five votes on last Thursday. I do not disagree with old age pensioners getting 2/6 or 5/-.

Comment on this

You took a long time to tell us.

Comment on this

You are not enthusiastic about it.

Comment on this

It was announced by Deputy Ryan last Friday that it was a good thing to do. Everyone will agree with it. You would not find anyone in the country objecting to it, but the method and the necessity for doing it is what the country objects to very strongly.

Comment on this

I can sympathize with the Deputy's annoyance.

Comment on this

It was estimated to have cost £300,000 to buy 44 members of the old Irish Parliament to carry the Act of Union, but it cost £1,000,000 to buy four or five members to vote for the Social Welfare Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

It gives benefits to 160,000 old age pensioners.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen is not very happy.

Comment on this

I am not very happy at all. That is the price this country is paying for its so-called liberty under its Twenty-Six County Republic. Included in this bill before the House is money that it is proposed to vote out of the Counterpart Fund for certain financial expenditure on land rehabilitation and under the Works Act. I want to say, with a full sense of responsibility, having seen these two Acts of the Oireachtas in operation, that the big proportion of that money is being badly spent and will bring no return whatever to any section of this community. The works Act, it is true, is providing much-needed employment for many men who had no other employment in rural areas. To that extent only it serves useful purpose. There may be here and there a minor drainage scheme of certain utility and of certain advantage to the community being done but, taking the work, by and large, that is being done in order to spend this money, it is of no utility whatever and will give no return. The Government would be wise to apply for the authority of E.C.A. to spend this money in other ways. It could be spent by the local authorities with great advantage on the country roads, on tourist roads, if you like.

Comment on this

You do not need their authority to spend it.

Comment on this

The Minister should use his influence with the Minister for Local Government to divert a big proportion of that money from the so-called drainage and the waste that is going on to county councils to reconstruct county roads. We are providing in a Supplementary Estimate which the Minister for Industry and Commerce will be introducing this evening almost £1,000,000 to subsidise the transport company of this country— Córas Iompair Éireann, as it is known. We do not know how many millions the State may have to provide in future years in order to keep that transport company going. But everyone in this country does know that the traffic formerly carried by Córas Iompair Éireann has all been thrown on the roads which were never planned for such traffic and which cannot be maintained at present out of local taxation.

This money that is being spent under the Local Authorities (Works) Act could more usefully have been diverted to building up the county roads. We have thousands and thousands of miles of them in the country. There is no doubt that, if a major emergency does not arise, motor transport has come to stay and that the goods of this country will be carried on the roads in future. The railways may be performing a useful service in a limited way, but some future Dáil may have some doubt as to whether the railways justify the expenditure on them. Personally, I should like to see the railways maintained, but I say with all responsibility that if the cost of maintaining the railways, with no traffic on them, is to be borne by the taxpayers, the taxpayers also will have to bear the additional burden of building up the roadways in order to carry the traffic of the country. It cannot be done otherwise. We have thousands and thousands of miles of country roads and many hundreds of miles of ordinary main roads which must be built up and which will cost anything from £2,000 to £4,000 a mile to make them suitable for carrying the traffic that is being carried on them at present.

This Counterpart Fund could be more usefully spent in the interests of the whole country rather than continuing with this drainage work. It would give as much employment to people living in the rural areas as it given at present to men who have to work in rivers in the depth of winter. These men could not have carried on for the last three months up to their hips in water without keeping themselves warm by taking shelter and getting paid at the end of the week for that. That is all the majority of them have been doing. We do not blame them for that. That Works Bill was forced through this House. The scheme may have served a purpose in the first year by the carrying out of some drainage, but, from what I have seen of it over a wide area of the country, there is no responsible person in public life who would recommend its continuance on the present basis. The money has been literally thrown down the drain. It has given employment to many thousands of men who had no other employment, but that is all it has done. If that money had been given to these men for the carrying out of some useful work it would have been all the better.

I hope the Minister will take note of that and that he will consult his colleagues and the Deputies sitting behind him who know what is going on and how this money is being spent. It may be that in the Midlands or in the flatter areas of the country an amount of useful work has been done, but a serious check up on that should take place. The money should not be spent purely for the purpose of giving employment. It should be expended in a way which will give a return to the nation. It certainly will not give such a return by being expended in the way I have seen it expended for the last three years. I have no objection to spending money on giving employment. I only wish there was more money available for the employment of more men. But it is not giving any return to the nation in the way in which it is being spent.

There are also mixed feelings amongst the people as to whether the money which is being spent on the land rehabilitation scheme is going to give results. It is certainly not going to do what the Minister for Social Welfare claims in the little Blue Book he issued boosting his Social Welfare Bill in which he claimed that the £40,000,000 which the farmers would get under the land rehabilitation scheme would put them in a position to be well off enough to pay the 3/6 or the 6/- extra per week for their employees.

I should also like to advert to the policy of the Government in importing products that could be produced in this country. I refer especially to the policy of importing the wheat that we need when much of it could be produced at home. A very drastic change is needed in that respect. No one man in this State has the right to determine what the national policy of the country in any direction should be.

The Minister for Agriculture was opposed to the growing and producing of wheat in this country. He has made no secret of that. Recently he announced in this House that he was having last year's Irish wheat ground into animal feeding. I wonder if it is good national policy to degrade the product of our land. No Minister in an Irish Government should degrade any product of his own country whether it be from field or factory. Least of all should the wheat that is necessary for the maintenance of the human being in the country be belittled, ridiculed and damaged in the eyes of the people.

I suggest to the Minister for Finance that the policy of importing wheat at £32 a ton and offering the Irish farmer only £25 a ton is a bad financial and a bad national policy. It should not be allowed to continue.

Comment on this

It is nearly as bad as importing it at £50 a ton.

Comment on this

It is bad under any circumstances. The matter of £50 per ton for wheat can be discussed separately and on its own merits. It has been useful propaganda for the Coalition to talk about £50 a ton for wheat and about the fact that in 1949 with a lesser acreage of wheat there was a higher yield as compared with the year 1947.

Every farmer who lived on the land in this country in 1946 or 1947, whether he is 60, 70 or 80 years of age, if he is still alive, knows quite well that the most serious year in his lifetime from the point of view of farming was 1947. Every farmer will admit that no matter what his politics are in other directions. The yield from all products of the land in 1947 was down to zero because of the severe winter of 1946 and the bad weather in 1947. It is a well-known fact that the turf crop could not be saved that year either. It is also a well-known fact that the cow population of the country that year did not give the produce it would give in a normal year. It is wrong altogether to be using the year 1947, as it has been used, for propaganda purposes only and comparing the yield that year with the normal yield over ten, or 15 years previously.

The highest yield in cereal crops was obtained in this country in 1949. That is an admitted fact. When the Minister or any Minister or anybody else compares the year 1949 with 1947 I would say that is wrong and damaging the national interests.

I will not go into the matter of the tomato crop. The Minister for Agriculture set out to kill wheat, tomatoes and root seeds growing. He has succeeded in all three directions. He has succeeded admirably. It is extraordinary that with a Party of over 70 sitting behind him the Minister for Agriculture is allowed to get away with it.

I do not want to hold up the House or the Minister any longer. This has been a prolonged debate. I want to say that the bill with which the Minister has faced the country in the present year is a colossal one. Much of the borrowing he proposes to do in the present year is for services which were provided by the previous Government out of taxation year after year. That colossal bill will damage the future interests of this State. Labour Members who sit in this House should take serious note of it because it is the workers, when this money is expended, who will first be affected through loss of employment, reduced standards of living and reduced earnings. The end of it will be the emigrant ship. That must be the end of this mad hatter scheme of finance, borrowing and colossal spending which is the policy of the Government.

Comment on this

There are two occasions at least in the year on which Deputies of Deputy Allen's type of mind are given an opportunity to rave over about a week. Just think of the phrase on which the Deputy closed— this country is being reduced to misery and unemployment.

Comment on this

It will be.

Comment on this

It will be, leading to the emigrant ship.

Comment on this

That is a preliminary.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy said he was not going to delay the House any longer. Deputy MacEntee told us in the same terms that under the present Coalition Government the country would be reduced to economic servitude. That is the note of the debate, the country is being reduced to economic servitude.

If we have not immediate mass unemployment, low wage conditions, depressed conditions both in agriculture and industry and the emigrant ship, we are certainly going to have them in a couple of years. That was the moaning which was started here on the Vote on Account in 1948. It deepened its tone in the Budget of 1948. It was repeated with monotonous regularity on the two occasions last year, and here we have it again.

Deputy Lemass, dealing with the Book of Estimates, the foundation for all this wailing and moaning, told us in a speech at column 1035, Official Dáil Debates for Thursday, 1st March, 1951:—

"I said here last year in the debate on the Vote on Account that I had gone through the Book of Estimates and that I had examined every Estimate in it with a view to ascertaining whether there were any specific economies I could recommend and that, a part from cutting out some follies and fripperies, there was nothing I could suggest which would make any significant difference in the total figures."

Deputy Lemass said here on Thursday that he was not in a position to indicate any significant economies; that there were a few Coalition follies scattered around the Book of Estimates but that they would not be significant in relation to the total bill of £83,000,000 because when one talks in terms of a saving of £25,000, and that was the only thing put up by the Deputy who said that he could pick out a few follies here and there and that the tot was in the region of £83,000,000, it shows exactly how genuine he is when he says he can suggest no economies in the bill. He went on to say:—

"I agree also that many, if not all, of the genuine capital projects upon which the Government proposed to embark were desirable; that in fact its investment programme was on the whole desirable apart from borrowing to meet Budget deficits or to defray the costs of various recurring grants which would create no Exchequer assets."

So, there we are. He did say also on 6th March that:—

"The level of borrowing is a different matter. The Government has a special responsibility to safeguard the national resources entrusted to them."

—and then came this significant comment from Deputy Lemass:—

"There is no doubt whatever that the public of this country want investment in housing, hospitals, electricity, telephones, afforestation, land improvement, in all the things which were on the list given by the Minister when announcing his capital budget last year."

The public want these. There are no economies in the Book of Estimates that can be suggested and as far as capital projects are concerned the public wants these things.

I will deal with his comments on borrowing in a moment. Later he said, when interruptions brought him back to what he said in 1948 when he had condemned me for what he described as championing a policy of austerity— I quote again from his speech on 6th March:—

"I said in 1948 that in the circumstances of that year there was no need in this country for a policy of austerity. I was assuming that the Minister for Finance in outlining his policy in that year meant what he said. I have not yet discovered that he was speaking then with his tongue in his cheek. I argued strongly that in the circumstances of 1948, having regard to the sound position of this country at the end of the war year and having regard to the general expectation of an improvement in economic conditions throughout the world, that we did not have to embark on a policy of restriction such as the Minister for Finance appeared then to be foreshadowing."

I would ask to be allowed to make this comment on that. Have the circumstances of this country improved since 1948, since the day when Deputy Lemass ceased to be a Minister and became an ordinary Deputy? I suggest they have. I suggest that every economic statistic we have bears out that fact. Therefore, there was no reason for a policy of restriction such as he thought I was then foreshadowing. But Deputy Lemass went even further on 2nd March and stated that he did not think circumstances had arisen to justify a policy to which the name of austerity could reasonably be applied. I took that statement by Deputy Lemass as setting the discussion here in its proper framework and one member of the Opposition at least, after indulging in the same volume of lamentation that Deputy Lemass set as an undesirable precedent for the rest of his followers, paid attention to it. Deputy Lemass admitted there was nothing in the Book of Estimates that he could cut out. One knows what that means. There is nothing in the Book of Estimates that he will not stand over if anybody suggests the excision of a particular service because Deputy Lemass knows that at least these services are popular.

When it comes to borrowing, he is of the view that there is nothing in the programme outlined that the people do not want, and as a corollary to that—and I expect Deputy Lemass to accept the corollary to his argument—there is no project that Deputy Lemass would hesitate to go on with: to put it positively, any Government, even if Deputy Lemass were a member of that Government, would continue with all these projects. The only difference between us then is that Deputy Lemass would carry out these projects, or most of them, by means of taxation. Yet, Deputy Lemass and all his faithful followers complained bitterly throughout the debate that taxation was too heavy. They told us that the present rate of taxation is having the effect of depressing business people. Deputy MacEntee actually said that people had been "stood off" because of the Price Freeze Order.

A picture was painted of a failing agricultural industry. It was said that there had been no increase of any kind except in unemployment, emigration and depression. We were told that all that is due to taxation. Yet, the very people who tell us that these ills are due to taxation tell us in the same breath that they would carry out our programme by means of taxation, instead of trying to limit, as we are doing, in a reasonable and prudent way, the weight of taxation upon the generation in which we live. That is the chief contradiction that appears in the Opposition speeches.

Now, that is the first point to which I would like to address myself in concluding this debate: is it or is it not reasonably prudent when we are faced with the necessity of carrying out so many schemes, schemes that are thought so desirable not only by those who support the Coalition but by their opponents on the Opposition benches? Possibly we shall have this matter debated here on another occasion in a more reasonable way, when we can get away from the lament that there is something imprudent in doing what we are doing. Is it worth while taking such a risk as undoubtedly attaches to the great capital development programme upon which we embarked last year, and with which we are proceeding this year?

I would like to deal, first of all, with some of the minor matters that were raised here before I deal with that important point. Deputy Lynch spoke in this debate under the handicap of being a professional man because he had to speak after his would-be leader had told him that the most stupid of men he, Deputy Lemass, had ever met outside the law were the lawyers themselves. The result was that Deputy Lynch spoke with considerably less verve than he usually does. I presume the reason for his loss of verve was because of his leader's comment. He did, however, harp on the plaint that he and Deputy McGrath have in relation to the fuel situation in Cork over the Christmas period. I understand that the situation was that in the early part of the year, a few days after the New Year dawned, Deputy McGrath and Deputy Lynch sent a joint telegram to the Department of Industry and Commerce to the effect that fuel supplies were short. In fact, they said they were at famine point in the City of Cork, and that fuel should be made available immediately, particularly for the poor. Inquiries were straightaway made by the Department the day after the telegram was received.

These inquiries revealed that certain firms in Cork had over a week's supply on hands and were supplying consumers freely. One merchant in Cork stated that no one need go short of a bag of coal. The Department followed up that investigation by sending an inspector down. The results of his investigation showed that, while some merchants had run out of coal, others had stocks of coal on hands and were selling it freely to domestic consumers; and, in any event, cargoes of Polish coal were due to reach Cork a few days afterwards. Those cargoes did reach Cork a few days afterwards and since that time there has been no complaint with regard to the fuel situation there.

What is abundantly clear from all this is that this was merely another scandalous attempt, similar to attempts that have been made over the past three years, on the part of Fianna Fáil to make political capital out of the exigencies of a situation, no matter how unreasonable their action might be and no matter how easy it might be to view the situation in its proper perspective and adopt a sensible attitude towards it. Deputy Aiken led off with a complaint; Deputy Lemass followed him but I think it was left to Deputy Derrig to make the chief burden of his song a complaint with regard to the development of the cement industry. The precise statement was made here by both Deputy Aiken and Deputy Lemass that they had plans in hand before they left office for the expansion of the cement plant at Limerick. I have turned up a famous minute that has been often referred to in this House but mainly in connection with the matter of turf production. It is of date 12th February, 1948, about a week before Deputy Lemass left office. It is a record of a conference presided over by Deputy Lemass.

To that conference there came, amongst a number of other things, a report with regard to cement. It stated that the cement company had indicated that they were planning a development—that they were planning a development—and the decision that was taken by this departmental conference, on the 12th February, 1948, under the presidency of Deputy Lemass, was that the cement company's scheme for development would be examined when submitted. On the 12th February, 1948, they had not even got a plan for it and there was no expansion promised. There was a mere recording in a minute that the scheme for development would be examined when submitted. Despite that, the scandalous perversion is chanced here that there was a scheme for the development of the cement industry in Limerick and that we had upset the plans which the Fianna Fáil Government had in train for that.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not think that perhaps the plans were drawn up on the same night as the wheat was ordered—17th February?

Comment on this

That was a very hurried week.

Comment on this

It was like your plan to reduce the cost of living.

Comment on this

On the 12th February, 1948, the scheme for development would be examined when submitted. At the same conference of the 12th February, they discussed turf —I will come to the details of that in a moment—and they decided that no provision was to be made in respect of hand-won turf in the 1948-49 Estimates. They, presumably, discussed wheat on that occasion too but it was not until the end of the week, I think about the 17th, that the decision was taken, of course, to pay the £50 a ton for the Argentine wheat.

Deputy Lemass spoke of the rural electrification scheme and again the attempt is made here to confuse Deputies and to have it represented that there was a grand scheme, with detailed plans, for progress in that rural electrification scheme, made out by him, and that that progress has been interrupted. In fact, the situation is that this matter started in the year to the 31st March, 1947. I am speaking, in each year, of the year to the 31st March. In the year to the 31st March, 1947, the scheme was just barely getting under way. In 1948, if I take the mileage of lines strung, there were 700 odd miles strung; the number of consumers connected was 2,200; there were seven areas completed. The advance that was made for rural electrification was £550,000. For the year to the 31st March, 1949, the miles of lines strung was 1,730; the number of consumers connected was 9,262; there were 30 areas completed and the advance made for rural electrification was in the region of £900,000. In the year to the 31st March, 1950, there were 2,083 miles of lines strung; consumers connected rose to 13,688; there were 45 areas completed, at a cost, by way of advance, of £1,050,000; and as between 1st April, 1950, and the end of December, 1950, there were almost 16,000 miles of lines strung, which is, roughly, the same progress as in 1949; 116,786 consumers connected, 34 areas completed, and the amount of money provided by way of advance was £1,300,000.

People will not understand these figures as I read them but they may look at them in the Official Report when published. There is nothing there on which anybody can possibly found a complaint that there is not the progress being maintained in connection with rural electrification that was decided upon.

Another complaint is with regard to Irish Shipping, Limited, and here again it is sought to delude the Dáil into believing that there was a plan to have the tonnage of the Irish mercantile marine increased to the point that all our seaborne traffic could be taken by ships of Irish Shipping, Limited. It is a fact that in 1943, as far back as that, a Cabinet committee agreed that Irish Shipping, Limited, should proceed with the preparation of plans for the development of an Irish mercantile marine on the lines outlined in a previously prepared memorandum and it was aimed to make the aggregate tonnage of the company's fleet not less than 250,000 tons dead weight. That was 1943. But, in 1947, Deputy Lemass, then Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking in this House, said that provision was being made in legislation for increased capital so that, if necessary, the company could call upon it to implement fully their plans for the establishment of a worth-while merchant fleet composed of modern ships. No such capital provision was made by Deputy Lemass while he was Minister for Industry and Commerce, and the matter remained there until the present Government took it up. They have added—to a slight degree only—to the tonnage of Irish Shipping, Limited. It is not an easy matter to decide as to what tonnage they should eventually aim at, but all that I can interject in this debate is that there is no question of progress or arrangements or plans being made by the last Government which the present Government interrupted. There was no provision by way of money for plans, but the acceptance in an academic way of a plan, which was toned down by the then Minister, Deputy Lemass, when he said, not that they were aiming at the 250,000 dead weight tonnage, but that the aim was to get a worth-while fleet.

I am not competent to deal with the many matters that have been discussed here with regard to agriculture. I have been irritated during the course of this discussion by the numerous falsehoods that have been tossed into the debate by members of the Opposition with regard to agricultural production. It will take many repetitions, I am sure, of the particular figures I have here before the situation with regard to butter in this country will be clearly disclosed. The fact of the matter is, as the Minister for Agriculture has so often said in recent days, weeks and months, that in the year 1950 there was more creamery butter produced and consumed in this country than there ever was in the history of the country since it became a country. More butter was produced and consumed. There were other occasions when more butter was produced. In the year 1950, the home consumption of creamery butter was 745,000 cwts. odd. In the year 1934 the production of creamery butter was more than that and for a number of years about that time—1934, 1935, 1936, 1937 and 1938— the production, in thousands of cwts. was as follows: 769, 827, 837, 758 and 766 but in those years there was an export which ranged from 454,000 cwts. of creamery butter in 1934 to 327,000 in the year 1938. There was an average of about 430,000 cwts., I would say, exported in each of those years and it was exported bearing a heavy subsidy, the fact of the matter, then, being that the people of this country could not afford to buy and consume the amount of creamery butter which was produced, as nowadays they can. That is the big improvement in the country.

It is very difficult to get a proper line with regard to wheat. It did appear to me as I listened to certain Opposition Deputies debating the Vote on Account that their anxiety was for ploughed fields and if you could get a statistical return that there were so many acres under the plough, it did not matter what those ploughed acres produced.

Comment on this

If anything.

Comment on this

If anything. The whole ideal appears to be, can you get a statistical return showing a greater area of earth in this country ploughed? In any case, these figures appear to be relevant. One way in which this is challenged is, is not it a poor thing to be paying money abroad for such things as wheat and flour?

In 1947, when the country was under the control of Fianna Fáil, the net imports of wheat and flour cost £7,742,000. In 1950 the imports of wheat and flour cost £5,668,000. There was £2,000,000 less spent.

Comment on this

That was the bad year —1947.

Comment on this

There was £2,000,000 less spent than in 1947. Now I will come to the bad year. In July, 1947, the Fianna Fáil Government had to prepare a reply to the Food and Agriculture Committee—that was a committee of the Commission on European Economic Co-operation—and they gave a forecast of what the national production would be in respect of certain crops. Their forecast for the year 1950-51 was that they would reduce the wheat acreage to 247,000 acres. Last year, in the year in which they forecast 247,000 acres of wheat, we grew actually 366,000 acres. Deputy Kissane mentioned that that was the bad year, and he was excusing these comparisons with 1947. There is the programme that Fianna Fáil was aiming at, that in the year 1950-51 they would sow 247,000 acres of wheat. We had actually 366,000 acres.

It is quite clear that one should in this matter look to acreages. In 1947, in the Fianna Fáil period of office, within this bad year that is talked about, 579,000 acres were under wheat and that acreage produced 313,000 tons of wheat. In 1949 we had 366,000 acres of wheat and we produced 360,000 tons of wheat. Does Deputy Kissane want us to go back to the 579,000 acres, almost 600,000 acres, almost half-yielding acres, or would he not rather have the 366,000 acres producing the 360,000 tons of wheat?

Comment on this

Will the Minister go back to 1945?

Comment on this

I have not got the figures just now, but we can get them if necessary.

Comment on this

They would be more revealing.

Comment on this

Let us have one figure to argue on. If the Deputy wants the figures for 1945 we will get them. Will he now tell me, if 1945 had a bigger yield or if 1945 had a better acreage, why was the forecast for 1950-51 made out and sent to the European Commission as 247,000 acres? Why did the people around the Deputy advise the Government to forecast to the Food and Agriculture Committee that the acreage would be reduced to 247,000 acres? That apparently was their plan. It is all very well to talk about the plans for the Irish Mercantile Marine and for turf and cement and to put forward complaints that Fianna Fáil plans were not carried out. Here, in any event, was a target that they set for themselves. Their target was 247,000 acres, and that is the figure I bear in mind when I hear any complaints about reduced acreages for certain crops.

Some Deputy went so far as to suggest that the numbers in live stock were down. Cattle numbers are up. In the figures here, in the calculations made in January in each of the years 1947, 1948, 1949, 1950 and 1951, there is an increase from 3.7 million cattle to 3.9 million cattle Sheep also show an increase. Pigs show a slight decrease from 1950, but a definite increase from 1947. Poultry show a decrease from 1950, but a definite increase from 1947. In all these increases of live stock, making a comparison with the last year of the Fianna Fáil Government, there has been an improvement in every grade. There have been ups and downs with regard to sheep, pigs and poultry, but in all cases the figures are well over the returns for January, 1947.

There was another complaint voiced in the House. It has been made often and it was made as recently as the 28th February this year in the Seanad when Deputy Corish, the Parliamentary Secretary, was speaking there on the Rates on Agricultural Land Bill. I think it worth while to put the figures on record here. Deputy Corry stated during the debate here that an effort was being made by the Government to transfer a lot of the burdens that were previously paid for by the Central Government on to the local authorities. Certain figures were given by the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Corish, on the 28th February, in the Seanad—column 474 of the Seanad Debates—and I will mention a few of them.

He said that in 1947-48 the total rates collected amounted to £9,111,000 and State grants were £8,230,000. I am taking that as the last Fianna Fáil year. The rates exceeded the State grants by about £1,000,000. In 1948-49, the total rates collected were £9,500,000 and the State grants were £10,749,000. In 1949-50, the total rates collected were £10,900,000, but the State grants came to £13,649,000. The Parliamentary Secretary summed that up by stating that it meant, in effect, that the State grants equalled only 60 per cent. of the total rates collected in 1939-40, and in 1949-50 they equalled 120 per cent. of what was taken from the ratepayers.

Deputy Corry, speaking here and hurriedly flying from the House the moment the Minister for Agriculture rose to reply to him, made the burden of his song the money which is being taken by customs and excise duties on certain matters connected with motoring, the money collected through the revenue derived from petrol and the road tax, as it is known. The burden of the complaint was that not all these moneys went to the local authorities. So far as I remember, his calculation was that there was about £2,000,000. There was a sum of money collected in the various ways I have mentioned which exceeded by £2,000,000 the amount provided for the roads by the Central Government, the Road Fund, say, and by the ratepayers. In that the calculation is about right, but Deputy Corry goes on the assumption that the duties levied on petrol were put towards the roads. They never were, neither were the customs and excise duties on tyres, etc. They never went towards the roads. The only thing that went towards the roads was the produce of what is called the road tax.

That road tax was increased in the Supplementary Budget of 1947. The duties on mechanically propelled vehicles were increased in that year. In that year, introducing the Supplementary Budget, the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Aiken, said:

"The Government have decided to provide additional subsidies for the purpose of reducing the prices of flour, bread, tea, sugar and fertilisers and to meet the cost by imposing the necessary taxes."

One of the necessary taxes was to increase the road tax on cars so that the tax on an 8 h.p. car became £12, on a 10 h.p. £15, on a 12 h.p. £20. The Minister added that it was proposed to appropriate the additional yield for Exchequer purposes. Deputy Corry, speaking in the debate on the 15th October, said:

"There is no doubt that the attempt made by the Government in this Budget for the relief of the ordinary wage earner in this country will be welcomed by all."

Twice the Deputy marched into the Division Lobby in order to support the Minister in carrying that particular Budget. It was quite clear from the statement of the Minister for Finance in those days that the road tax, amongst other taxes, was intended to provide the Minister with money for the payment of the subsidies which were then introduced. Speaking in particular of the road tax he said—I am quoting from the debates of the 15th October, 1947, column 395:

"——and appropriate the additional yield for Exchequer purposes."

Deputy Corry now tries to put the bluff across on his colleagues of the Cork County Council that he is against the appropriation of any part of the road tax to the Central Fund.

This matter of who stopped the turf schemes and when they were stopped has often been debated in this House. I am not going into it again in detail, but it was a matter which agitated the mind of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health of the last Government as early as the year 1946. There are many memoranda which proceeded from the Department that year. Towards the end of 1946, on the 18th October, the Minister for Local Government writes to his Cabinet colleagues in this way:—

"The Minister would not merely object to any enlargement of the scope of the functions of his Department and of country councils in regard to turf production but also to any intention of continuing beyond the current year his present responsibility for turf production through county councils. The principle of making local authorities responsible for turf production came into existence only as an emergency measure and it would seem proper that local authorities should be informed as soon as possible that they have been released from these exceptional responsibilities."

In fact, as we know, a letter went on the 18th August, 1947, from the Custom House to the secretary of each county council, telling the county councils not to participate in the production of turf after the 31st December.

When the matter swung over to the Department of Industry and Commerce with a view to seeing how Bord na Móna was to be helped, we come on to the meeting, to which I have already referred of the 12th February, 1948. There were three items on the Agenda dealing with turf. One was a complaint about the quality of turf supplied to the Department's offices. The second was the turf development programme for 1948. I read from the minute and I shall give the decision afterwards.

"In connection with the preparation of the Estimate for the Department for 1948-49, a decision was requested as to whether provision should be made for hand-won turf production in 1948. If the Bord na Móna scheme were not proceeded with, no unemployment would result as the workers would be absorbed in the machine-won scheme or other schemes. It is not known, however, what the effects of a cessation of hand-won turf production by the county councils would be."

Note the date—12th February, 1948. a rather critical date. The clouds were gathering round the heads of the the Government. They seemed to be pretty certain of their doom but they were hoping against hope that the consolidation of Parties which was then taking place would not hold together. The decision was that no provision should be made in the 1948-49 Estimates for a Bord na Móna hand-won turf scheme and that the question of the discontinuance of hand-won turf production by the county councils should be further examined.

The Local Government Department had already written down to the county councils to say that the scheme was finished but apparently, on the 12th February, in the critical situation which was then about to develop, it was thought well to say: "Well we shall have a look at that then", but, one thing certain was, that there was going to be no provision made in the 1948-1949 Estimates for Bord na Móna hand-won turf. In face of that, how anybody can say that the last Government had decided to go on with the hand-won turf scheme beats me.

Deputy Aiken and his colleagues have often given many excuses with regard to the Government Buildings that were proposed for Dublin. I think it fair to enumerate four of the excuses that were given. One was to deny that such a scheme existed at all. When the file was produced, and they were no longer in a position to deny it, we were told this scheme would give employment. We were later told—I think it was in an inspired utterance of Deputy Lemass—that there had been in the old Cumann na nGaedheal days a proposal lodged in the Office of Public Works for such a scheme. I have asked the Office of Public Works for any minute of that decision but so far they have not been able to discover any. The third excuse was that it would be nice to have such public buildings. Finally it was said that the scheme was not proceeded with because it was suggested to Leaders of other Parties that they might agree to it and that, on disagreement being registered, it was decided to abandon it. In any event, let us see what actually happened.

There was such a scheme. The deliberations started in January, 1936, and I have here a file which dates from that time. One of the memorandum deals with the scheme in the following terms:

"Before any such scheme becomes acceptable to the general public which will have to pay for it, and to put up, over a number of years, with the disturbance which it would necessarily involve, the Government would have to win the support of the Dublin Corporation which would be vitally affected and to gain the approval of the growing body of town planning opinion and of the professional associations interested in such a project."

Later on it says: "It might be even said in criticism of the scheme as a whole..." This I quote for the purpose of countering the argument that this was a plan more or less blue printed and left aside for the purpose of meeting a big unemployment period, unemployment in the building trade:

"It might be even said in criticism of the scheme as a whole that one effect of putting it into operation would be to postpone inevitably the solution of the problem of the housing of the working classes."

That was the choice. There is no doubt that would have been one effect, to postpone inevitably the solution of the problem of the housing of the working classes. That was weighed in the balance against this scheme for £11,500,000 and, having been weighed in the balance, it was decided to go ahead with, at least, the deliberations for the scheme.

When I hear complaints in this House about projects for which I have asked to be allowed to borrow £12,000,000, I can only reflect on how insincere these complaints may be rated, coming from a side of the House which supported a Government that proceeded to deliberate on a scheme of that kind. It is there very definitely to be seen in the memoranda of that time:

"Before, however, any decision is taken on the points enumerated in the preceding paragraph, there are certain of the financial implications——"

which are referred to here.

The memorandum goes on:—

"It is obvious that the necessary funds which, as shown in paragraph 6 would, at a minimum, be in the neighbourhood of £3,000,000, would have to be found by borrowing."

That, of course, was a very meagre scheme, but, at a later part, it became a scheme of £11,500,000. It was then £3,000,000. What is said here with regard to the £3,000,000 scheme applies with more effect to the £11,500,000 scheme.

"It is obvious that the necessary funds which, as shown in paragraph 6, would at a minimum be in the neighbourhood of £3,000,000 would have to be found by borrowing. A loan floated specifically for the purpose of the scheme which, in effect, is merely the provision of palatial buildings for housing Civil Service staffs would scarcely be attractive from the point of view of investors in so far as the asset created would be regarded as entirely unproductive."

That was the sober comment, that the asset was regarded as unproductive. Yet, that was considered a good project for the flotation of a loan, even though the asset was to be so unproductive. Some years later, in 1944, the figures as to cost were given, but with this warning that the figures of the cost to the State must be purely conjectural. The following figures may be taken as an indication of the size of the project: acquisition and compensation for disturbance, £2,500,000; demolition of sites acquired, £500,000; building works, £7,500,000; furnishing and equipment, £1,000,000. These figures give a tot of £11,500,000. Just after that was proposed, there is a record of a conference with the Taoiseach and the then Tánaiste in Government Buildings. A difficulty which emerged at that time, one of the matters that was under consideration, was that there were so many buildings that would have to be exempt or excluded, and the board were to reconsider the whole problem. Here are some of the buildings that were going to be demolished or, if not, they would either have to be exempted or excluded from the scheme: Holles Street Hospital, St. Stephen's Church, the convent chapel at Merrion Square and Fitzwilliam Street corner. There was also the fact that it was recognised that Merrion Square itself had been spoken of as the site of a new cathedral, and the people considering that were not sure whether the ecclesiastical authorities might not still have the cathedral project in mind.

That is the scheme which was to cost £11,500,000 and which it was recognised was not going to be of a very attractive nature for the public. It certainly could be criticised on the grounds that it was going to result in an entirely unproductive asset. Yet it was contemplated, a scheme leading in the end to the extravagant sum of £11,500,000.

At the end, of course, it came to a different point. The difficulties about building in Merrion Square had by that time been discovered to be serious. At that point the architects in the Board of Works were switched over to the Phoenix Park and to the possibility of siting these Government Buildings in the Phoenix Park. That was brought under consideration in 1945. In the end, the Board of Works got one of its architects to prepare a layout which is rather humbly stated "to have some merit." That is all set out here, the building of an enormous new House of Parliament and a whole block of Government offices in the Park. The question then arose as to whether it was proper to deprive the people who enjoyed certain amenities in the Park of those amenities. The further extravagant idea was then mooted that the great thing to do in return for the taking away of certain of those amenities in the Park, as described in the layout for the proposed buildings, was to provide extra acreage elsewhere. That led to a grand scheme going up the river from Kingsbridge to Chapelizod, the taking of land on either side of the river, stripping it of buildings and putting into it some sort of playing fields and then handing it over to the public in return for the amenities of which they had been deprived in the Phoenix Park.

Will people remember that the Government which considered that, and which was prepared to go on with it, are now, as members of the Opposition, severely critical of the plans to embark money on houses for the people, on electrical development and all other sources of investment which Deputy Lemass said the people desired to have, but still they are critical of that being done by borrowing? They intended to borrow £11,500,000, and the figure was only conjectural, for the provision of these particular amenities.

The second big matter under discussion in the House was the question of the Order freezing prices. That has been criticised on a variety of grounds. It was said to be a panic Order. It was said, first of all, that it was not meant seriously, and was not to be taken seriously. Secondly, it was said that it was a drastic Order, that it was a setback for every trader and industrialist in the country, that they could not find it possible to make forward purchases, that they were entirely hamstrung in the way of making extra provision against an emergency ahead, and that the whole thing was iniquitous. It was particularly iniquitous for that reason. The burden of the waspish attack that was made on the Supplies and Services Bill was to the effect that it was completely unconscionable to ask traders to produce records of their business and allow anybody to look at statements which would show if they were making profits or what profits they were making.

Comment on this

No one ever suggested that.

Comment on this

It was first said by Deputy MacEntee that there was no power to do such a thing, and that it was scandalous.

Comment on this

I said the objection was not to producing records to public servants, which has always been done, but to producing them to a part-time committee of persons with other business interests.

Comment on this

Part-time?

Comment on this

A non-official committee.

Comment on this

I do not know what you mean. Do you confine "official" to civil servants entirely?

Comment on this

Civil servants are bound by the conditions of their appointment to preserve the secrecy of any documents which they may receive. Other persons are not so bound.

Comment on this

Other persons can be by Acts and Orders. Will you agree that if they were it would be all right?

Comment on this

I would not.

Comment on this

I have a few of the Deputy's records here, in any event. The prices Order was then removed, or thawed, in regard to certain things. The Irish Press, no doubt guided by the Deputy, wandered into the statement that meant that merchants had now complete liberty to charge whatever prices they considered proper. That is the Deputy's reading of the situation? I am putting that to him as a question.

Comment on this

If there is another interpretation of the decontrol of goods.

Comment on this

That is the Deputy's view of the removal of the Orders in part. Then merchants have complete liberty to charge whatever prices they consider profitable. I thought it might disagree with the leader writer in the Irish Press.

Comment on this

It is true of some of them.

Comment on this

I wonder will the Deputy say what he thinks is the result of the withdrawal of the price Orders?

Comment on this

I think you made a thoroughgoing mess of the whole business.

Comment on this

I thought that at least that would be an easy way out, for the Deputy to say that. The Deputy, in am ambiguous phrase he used when speaking about the speech the Tánaiste made, referred to what he called his "rushin' " tactics. He explained afterwards that the word he used was "rushing" and had no reference to Moscow. I take that to be the case. Nevertheless, the line he has suggested all the time is that there is a completely anti-social point of view displayed by the Tánaiste and those who support him in connection with this price freeze, that we are trying to get people into the frame of mind of being against private industry. So he said at the Federation of Irish Manufacturers' Dinner:—

"There was a persistent and apparently organised campaign against private-owned industry, which was being represented as necessarily anti-social, whose owners displayed inordinate selfishness and disregard for the public weal and were responsible for all price inflations and for the social injustice, the discontent and disorder which followed from that."

That is his line. A price freeze would not be too bad, but, in the framework of, say, the Tánaiste's speech, it was something approaching what Moscow would do. That is the insinuation that is all the time around it when the Deputy is speaking on this matter. We used to be told, and it was one of the complaints the Deputy voiced in the past couple of days, that there was good price-fixing machinery when he left the Department of Industry and Commerce and that, in fact, all that is happening is that his successor in the Ministry is avoiding his responsibilities, that if he had worked that machinery everything could be done. I think that was the Deputy's complaint. Does he agree?

Comment on this

Certainly. He decontrolled 28 of the materials, the prices of which he is now trying to freeze.

Comment on this

It was possible to decontrol with the Deputy's old machinery. The Deputy, in 1945, had other views. He then got his Government to get the length of a white print of a piece of legislation called the Emergency Powers (Unlawful Profits) Bill, 1945, and the memorandum which accompanied that piece of legislation contains a few comments which the House might be glad to hear. I am sorry that Deputy Childers is not here for the opening bar of it. Deputy Childers has committed himself to the view that prices have nothing to do with profits, and I think that even Deputy Lemass has given himself over to that idea from time to time. At this time, he was against that thought. The memorandum says:—

"It is the aim of the methods of price control adopted by the Minister for Supplies to restrict profits within reasonable limits and thereby to keep down the level of prices...."

So that, in 1945, there was some relationship between profits and prices. It goes on then to speak of the price Orders he had made and the way they worked—generally informally, by getting the decent business men and industrialists of the country to give an undertaking and relying on that, but it does say that there are certain defaulters:—

"The importance of the issue cannot, however, be judged relative to the number of defaulters, since such default, if tolerated, would likely be claimed as unfair to other traders and would almost certainly lead to a general failure of the system of control adopted.

Later, he says:—

"There is no doubt as to the traders who are deliberately evading control, but it is in this sense that any legislation must give the Minister for Supplies the fullest discretion in deciding what defaulting traders or firms deserve to have penalties imposed, and what traders or firms have erred unintentionally and are to be required merely to rectify the position when subsequently framing their prices."

Of all the undesirable pieces of legislation that ever may have been introduced, this surely ranked as the worst. Power was claimed and power was going to be given for the Minister for Supplies to have complete discretion in deciding what traders he would mulet. One could see the subscription list to the funds swelling with a little bit of manipulation of that power. But that is what was proposed—complete discretion. The Minister was to choose the defaulting traders who deserved to have penalties imposed. The scheme was that the Minister for Supplies would by an Order say to the firms whom he chose: "You have made unreasonable profits", and would state what the amount of the unreasonable profits were and would demand these profits from these firms. But they would have leave to appeal from him to an appeal tribunal, which was to consist of a chairman and two ordinary members. "Of the three members of the tribunal, one at least should be a practising barrister of not less than ten years' standing and one at least shall be a person having knowledge and experience of accountancy"— these are not civil servants; they are taken from outside—"and they shall be appointed for such period not exceeding one year as the Government may think proper".

Think of what the Deputy has said in answer to a question of mine—he objects to traders books being investigated by anybody except established civil servants who have a vow of secrecy on account of their office or people who will be put under a vow of secrecy.

"The appeal tribunal," this memorandum says, "would have full powers of investigation, including powers to obtain all relevant documents, accounts and information and would, on completing its investigation, give a decision confirming, altering or modifying the determination of the Minister, or imposing additional penalties, subject to a maximum of twice the amount of excessive profit earned, as decided by the appeal tribunal." The memo states that "since it would be the policy of the Minister to confine the exercise of this power to cases in which discussion and negotiation have proved a failure, in which the conditions of gross profiteering is obvious and in which the sums involved are substantial, it follows that the amounts to be collected by way of penalty would be substantial and it will therefore be necessary to provide wide and drastic powers for collection of such sums." One of these powers was the power to put in a receiver and the memo says with regard to that receiver:—

"It is intended to make provision in the Bill with regard to the powers of the receiver to carry on the business as a going concern and to indemnify that receiver against any act done under the provisions of the Bill."

There you had a pretty scheme. The Minister was to tell chosen traders: "You have defaulted in your arrangements with me and have made unreasonable profits. I will tell you what the amount of those unreasonable profits is. I make an Order, and, if it is not appealed against, it becomes a civil bill collectable in the ordinary way." If there was an appeal, the appeal could go to three people not civil servants, who were to be appointed very definitely on a temporary basis and yet that body was to have power to examine books and records and the Minister wanted drastic powers. one of which drastic powers is dealt with later. According to the memorandum:

"It is not intended that there should be any appeal to the ordinary courts against the decision of the Minister or the appeal tribunal as the case might be. The Minister feels that recourse to court proceedings and the delays which are unavoidable in such proceedings would greatly nullify the deterrent effect of the exceptional measures which it is proposed to take."

After that, does the Deputy want to complain?

Comment on this

After that, the war ended and the Bill was not proceeded with. That was a wartime measure.

Comment on this

The whole burden of your complaint is that we are now in an emergency.

Comment on this

We got instead an Industrial Efficiency and Prices Bill, 1947. It was a bit of a change from this undoubtedly, but a great many of the features are exactly the same. One of the points in this measure was that the Minister had power to make Orders with regard to control of prices, profits and trading methods. The Bill never advanced beyond Second Reading, but it set out:—

"The Minister shall not make any Order under this Part in relation to a commodity or service unless

(a) the commission have recommended it or

(b) the Minister is of opinion that.

(i) unduly high prices are being or are likely to be charged for the commodity or service, or

(ii) owing to the scarcity of supplies, there is a possibility that unduly high prices will be charged for the commodity or service.

In these circumstances, if there was a possibility that because of the scarcity of supplies, unduly high prices might be charged, the Minister could make an Order freezing prices. Will the Deputy who had that in his mind say why he objects to the freeze Orders brought forward here recently?

Comment on this

Will the Minister say why he voted against that?

Comment on this

I will, because of the very objectionable features that were in the Emergency Powers (Unlawful Profits) Bill, because it gave the Minister power to snoop and to pick and choose as between individuals. We thought that that was wrong.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain to us why the Tánaiste voted for it?

Comment on this

Probably because he thought that it was better to get after the traders on the question of high prices. In the miscellaneous portions of this Bill we read:—

"For the purpose of obtaining the information necessary for the exercise of any functions under this Act, the commission may, from time to time, publish in such manner as they think fit a notice requiring persons who carry on the business of producing or selling a specified commodity or of providing a specified service to furnish them at such times as may be specified in the notice such accounts and returns relating to the business as may be specified in the notice."

Of course, "the purpose of obtaining the information necessary for the exercise of any functions under this Act" was the fixing of prices or profits. They could get accounts there. This was not supposed to be a permanent tribunal. Then we read also:—

"For the purpose of obtaining the information necessary for the exercise of any function under this Act, the Minister, the commission or the chairman may, from time to time, serve on a person who carried on the business of producing or selling a commodity or providing a service a notice requiring that person to furnish at such times as may be specified in the notice such accounts and returns relating to the business as may be specified in the notice."

Why all the trouble about the freeze Order and this undesirable process of making manufacturers produce to a tribunal documents relating to their business when, in fact, the Deputy, as Minister, had intended it in 1944? He brought his views before the House in 1947.

Comment on this

I am not objecting to it now.

Comment on this

You object to it for the sake of an objection. I should like to put this freeze Order back into the framework in which it was put by the Tánaiste on the night on which he spoke on this matter in the Dáil in connection with the Supplies and Services Act. The debate is reported in Volume 123, Nos. 8 and 11. I need not quote at length from the speech made by the Tánaiste on that occasion. I have quite a number of points marked here to which I could refer. A brief summary of what he said is that it was proposed, because of the possibility at any time of a scarcity and an unduly high price being charged for certain articles, to take precautions by establishing an advisory body which would be armed with certain powers and, if necessary, power to call for the production of traders' books. A trader need not produce them but if he did not he would suffer the same consequences as a trader who would refuse to produce his books for examination by the Revenue Commissioners. There was nothing in the proposal to make traders produce their books for inspection at a public sitting. If anybody thinks that that has been done I ask them for an example—and when the first example comes we can take cognisance.

The Tánaiste went on to say that he proposed that this tribunal would have power to look at the grouped profits of industries, that is, not revealing the individual profits. I think that recently a group of jam manufacturers went before that particular tribunal. It was thought proper, and it is a suggestion that I stand over, not that the profits of X, Y or Z should be produced publicly but that the public should know that that industrial group were making profits and that some comparisons should be given. I do not think it is necessary here to go into the question of grouped profits. I get grouped profits given to me for the purpose of investigation. Each Minister for Finance gets these grouped profits for the purpose of preparing his Budget— in order to enable him to see how revenue is bearing up, and so forth.

For years back, the Minister for Finance has got that information. He never gets individual profits because that would be entirely wrong but he gets the group profits. Take a particular group of manufacturers who go before the Prices Tribunal to have discussed in public whether the price proposed to be charged is reasonable. Would it be proper to have, say, a comparison made between the group profits of a particular group of industrial traders in 1939, when standard profits were taken, and, say those of the year merely preceding investigation? I have here particulars of one group whose standard profits were taken for excess corporation profits duty during the war years. The group profits, which were in the neighbourhood of £600,000 in the peace years prior to 1939, had risen to £2,018,000 in 1949. Would that be a relevant consideration, without mentioning an individual firm? I think it would. There are many other such comparisons which could be given.

It is necessary to get the matter of profit-making and profit-taking into a proper framework. I have already read a point in the memorandum from the Department which was under the charge of Deputy Lemass when he was Minister that he then considered profits had something to do with prices. When profits have risen from something in the neighbourhood of £600,000 to over £2,000,000 after the war is over, it is at least something to be taken into consideration. As far as I know, individual traders will not be asked to or coerced into giving any indication of their trading profits or their secrets in public. I should hope that it will become the practice that, as that tribunal meets, the proper setting will be there—that when the individual comes along, though he may be a poor member of the trading group or the exploiter of the trading group, he will be allowed to take his place amongst. his colleagues. When they come to the tribunal and ask for an increase in prices, the public, through the tribunal, will have the information. Here is the setting. They used to make £600,000 and now they are making £2,000,000.

On the debate on the Supplies and Services Bill, Deputy Lemass said that one of the reasons why price control was relatively ineffective was because there was not public confidence and one of the reasons for that was that the public had no information, but that if the public could be induced to take an interest in it and have some idea as to whether a price should be raised or not, things would be different. They would then be informed, and if they had to submit to an increase because of increased labour or raw materials charges, they would know where they were and they would be better able to bear the cost because they would know that the prices had been discussed publicly and declared, after examination by an independent body of people, to be justified. That is our aim. There is no panic in what we are doing. The only panic is amongst our opponents. They do not want this system of fixing prices. I believe they would prefer prices to go up, because it would damage us as a Government. They would not look to the good of the community for having prices kept to the lowest possible point. Therefore, they objected to the idea. Then, when the prices Order was brought in, of course there were fulminations throughout their kept Press regarding the way business was to be impeded by this. You were presented with this as the system of the business community: that a business man in this country bought for sale almost the next day, and certainly the next week, and that if he could not see his prices rising the week after, he could not buy although the finished goods would not come into use until somewhere around next autumn. That was the impression we had from the Irish Press and from the other side of the House.

Comment on this

Do not talk such nonsense. The cost of materials used any day is the cost of replacing those materials.

Comment on this

The Deputy says that it is the cost of replacing the materials, although he thought at one time that there was a possibility of providing against that by getting inspectors to go in and get the books and investigate them for him. I do not agree that the cost of the replacement of goods, if those goods are to come into use six or even 18 months hence, should be the price charged next day across the counter.

I have heard my colleague the Minister for Agriculture speaking of what he thought and of what I think was the unreasonable drive for very unreasonable increases in wages made by certain parts of the community in the autumn of last year and the winter. The reason why a lot of those people moved in that way is, I know, what they hear from their colleagues who are assistants in shops. I am told over and over again that shop assistants have reported that articles which are in the window on display with a price ticket on them are taken out of the window, put into the back of the shop, kept for one week and then put back into the window with the price doubled.

Comment on this

That was done with regard to suit lengths.

Comment on this

Yes, and with regard to any number of things. First of all it is made the burden of the complaint of Deputy Lemass and others that that is happening, and then when we freeze prices for a time until we get an opportunity of reviewing the whole system, we get panic.

Comment on this

Nobody objected to your freezing prices; what we object to is your defreezing them now. We also object to the cumbersome machinery which you have set up to deal with them.

Comment on this

Nobody objected to the defreezing. When the Deputy has done his own job in the Irish Press he might read what his editorial staff have turned out. In the Irish Press of Monday, March 5th, the editorial is headed “Quite a Thaw”, and the end of it reads:—

"The Government have now given up in despair and bestowed on the large majority of the merchants affected complete liberty to charge what prices they consider profitable."

That, of course, is a desperate untruth.

Comment on this

What is the truth?

Comment on this

That is not the truth.

Comment on this

Then tell us the truth.

Comment on this

The truth is that whatever was released from the prices freeze Order of the 2nd December is still subject to the price fixation system which the Deputy himself when he was Minister thought effective.

Comment on this

The Price Control Orders I made were rejected by my successor and you did the rest.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy after a lot of consideration think that that is a true phrase?

Comment on this

Yes, in the main it is true.

Comment on this

It is an Irish Press truth.

Comment on this

Some of those articles are still subject to control but they are only a few.

Comment on this

In the Irish Press some were quoted as being decontrolled which are in fact still controlled.

Comment on this

If so it is due to the ambiguous wording of your advertisement which was so worded that nobody could understand it.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass clamoured for the decontrol of those articles in this House and in the Irish Press.

Comment on this

Quote that.

Comment on this

There is no need to quote it; it is on record.

Comment on this

Where is that record?

Comment on this

I cannot come in armed with everything necessary to pin the Deputy down to the numerous falsehoods he has told.

Comment on this

Bring that quotation in.

Comment on this

The man with a load of mischief is one thing but the man who tried to prevent the mischief of the Deputy would have a still heavier burden.

I think this is a decent endeavour in the interests of the community to prevent the only thing that can be prevented, namely the abuse which may normally be expected in a time of scarce commodities and rising raw material prices. In such a time there is not merely a possibility but a probability that unduly high prices will be charged and we will do our best to prevent that abuse. We are doing it with the system which we have got with some modifications and there may be more modifications. I believe that with that we will get a good tribunal with good machinery geared to its proper purposes. I would ask its help to see that the consumer is protected while at the same time, as the Tánaiste said in his speech, industrialists are allowed a proper profit.

I want to say one thing about industrialists. One speaks regarding the people who were not behaving properly in the industrial line and in the trading line and, of course, an opportunity is immediately offered there to papers like the Irish Press to parade that in a placarded and distorted way. You are attacking Irish industry because you mention what is known: that there are rogues in Irish industry, as there are rogues nearly everywhere. A lead has been given to the rogues by the Opposition. I do not know how many meetings there have been of semi-political bodies masquerading as industrialists and business people, but several times we have heard about the prices freeze Order being exceeded all over the country by business men. Deputy Childers added whatever little bit of fuel his faint voice could add by telling the country that he knew that the Order was being disobeyed up and down the country, that people were making their profits and were continuing to make them. That is said all over the place.

I have spoken in the same tone since 1948 with regard to that. The last tax in the world I regard as a good tax is the excess corporation profits tax. Its reimposition at the present time would cause great difficulty. In any event, it would run counter to the other policy and the other policy I believe to be the correct one, that is, letting people make reasonable profits and using whatever is in excess of reasonable profit to reduce their costs and give a lower price to the community. I would far rather get the benefit of excess profits spread in that way to the community rather than get a wad of money by slicing off any profits above a certain level.

This boasting, this arrogance in the face of a Government Order that people are disobeying, would certainly drive one to punitive measures against the people who are behaving in that way. For three years this Government have resisted the temptation to reimpose that particular Order and have hoped instead that the people who are making these profits would see reason and reduce their profits.

On the last opportunity I had of meeting industrialists as a group before Christmas, I met one group of traders with a very definite appeal, phrased in such a way that I do not think it could be regarded as anything but sincere. I made it in the most pointed way, addressed to those people, that they would content themselves in time of scarcity with a less profit than what they considered the normal profit they would be entitled to make in ordinary periods. There was a good response from part of the group I met. I have the feeling that some people for political purposes have tried to stampede the group. As Deputy Lemass has said, there is the bad example of some people getting away with it, when others say because of that: "It is unfair; we are abiding by the regulations and other people are running away from them." That sort of thing may have to be met by the reimposition of taxes of that type. It will be the last thing I will approach. Certainly I would approach it with the greatest possible distaste, as I would much prefer to get industrialists to realise how greatly they are in debt to this country and to give some token of that in their attitude in a period of scarcity and of crisis. I say that of industrialists here in this country, because I do not know of any country in which industrialists are better guaranteed their profits than they are here.

We have a wide range of tariffs. The height of the tariff barrier is extraordinary. There are quota arrangements to prevent even anything that might flow in over this extremely high tariff barrier. There is aid given to people in business and particularly in manufacturing industry by way of credits, Governments credits, Government aid in every possible way. In the end what it comes to is that this Government and the last, both Governments, have thrown the consuming community at the mercy of the industrial groups who are getting such heavy protection; because when there is no competition, because of the extremely high tariff barrier, then they could charge more or less what they liked and, in particular, in certain cases they could make it easier by making rings within the country, and a lot of them were doing it.

Whatever may be said with regard to the rights of capital in other countries, whatever may have been said in this country many years ago about the rights of capitalists and their rights to secrecy in connection with profits made and what the capitalist does with profits, that has very little application to this country in these years. Most of those industries are not trading on their own capital: they are trading on possibly a small amount of capital that they put into the business themselves, but largely increased by their having the consumer put at their mercy. To a very big extent it is the ordinary people here who buy the goods in the shops, who are definitely responsible for the big accumulations of capital that large industrialists have got. In those circumstances, I am less inclined to be troubled about the delicacy of some of those people in producing before tribunals, particularly in private, their books of account. I think they ought to show their books in private to the people who are set up there to examine them, because if they are honest people and have profits they can stand over, the best way of evidencing that is by showing their trading accounts and showing how they got their profits.

The other side of this matter of prices is the labour charges. I know that in many departments where the Fianna Fáil organisation has its roots, there are many complaints about the increases that have been allowed to workers over the last three or four years. It was not what Deputy Lemass had in mind for them—the freedom that we have given. Deputy Lemass, before he left office, had brought into memorandum form and Draft Bill form, a piece of legislation that was to be called the "Industrial Emergency Bill" of 1947. I understand that when this was spoken of recently by my colleague there was incredulity expressed from certain Deputies that such a piece of legislation could be there. The draft legislation was there. It was to freeze wages as they were on the 15th October, 1947, with certain additions. The scheme was to make it illegal for an employer to pay more, and the only additions that were to be admitted were whatever increase would be warranted by the relationship of the new cost-of-living index figure to what it had been previously, a rise measured by that. That is the index figure that is now so much derided by Deputy Lemass. It was to be the measuring stick of this.

Comment on this

That was the dictatorial mind.

Comment on this

Why does the Minister not tell the whole story?

Comment on this

We do not know how dictatorial it was. The main part of the proposal—it was supposed to be an ingenious scheme and there is a minute from the Minister himself indicating the unusual features of the scheme—was that the burden was to be put on the employer, the employer was to be guilty of an offence if he gave any wage increase. He could give a wage increase measured by the cost of living figure, or if there were an agreement between the employer and employee; but only if such agreement had not been come to under the threat of a strike or a cessation of work. If there were a strike or cessation of work to make the employer give that increase beyond the measure allowed, then the protection of the Trade Disputes Act was going to be withdrawn from any employee who went out on strike.

Comment on this

Going to put the workers on their knees.

Comment on this

This is all an untruth.

Comment on this

I have the Minister's minute in the Minister's own hand.

Comment on this

It is true to the extent that the Bill was framed, that the trade union congresses were informed that the Government desired to get agreement between them and the Government in regard to wage rates and in the event of there not being agreement we would have to consider legislation. In fact, there was agreement and the legislation was not proceeded with.

Comment on this

A memorandum I find in Industry and Commerce summarising all this, summarises what I have said. Then it says there was a meeting with the two congresses. The two congresses did not agree to the Minister's proposal. A memorandum for the Government was prepared on the 10th November, 1947.

Comment on this

Just before they were put out.

Comment on this

This is not a secret. It was discussed in the Dáil in November, 1947.

Comment on this

Discussion was then discontinued.

Comment on this

I want to read this.

Comment on this

The Dáil was informed.

Comment on this

When the election started.

Comment on this

The two congresses did not agree to the Minister's proposals and a minute for the Government was prepared on the 10th November, 1947, in which the decision of the Government was requested for the introduction of the draft Bill. It was, however, decided just at this time to hold the general election and the whole matter was dropped. At the same time Deputy Lemass published a letter in the papers announcing that the matter would not be dealt with until after the elections—but that is what was in store.

Comment on this

There was no secret about it.

Comment on this

Dictators do not make secrets.

Comment on this

I got the agreement of the trade union congresses also.

Comment on this

No, they did not agree.

Comment on this

They did, both congresses. It took place before we went out.

Comment on this

I never remember having discussed in public any piece of legislation which had in it a clause to remove the protection of the Trades Dispute Act if a strike took place for wage increases. Does the Deputy say there was such a discussion?

Comment on this

There was, and it was a provision of the law for years before that.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy say this Dáil ever got cognisance of any projected piece of legislation?

Comment on this

No, but the Dáil was informed that legislation was being prepared if there were a refusal to negotiate.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass would have gone on with it if the tyrants had come back to power.

Comment on this

We would not—and the answer is that the Bill was an alternative to a refusal to negotiate. They did refuse to negotiate but, in fact, agreed in principle to the proposals made to them and the whole matter dropped.

Comment on this

The minute does not say they agreed.

Comment on this

There had to be some alternative to a refusal.

Comment on this

Anyone who thought that up should be put on trial.

Comment on this

They were put on trial and the jury gave a verdict against them.

Comment on this

We got twice as many seats as Fine Gael and six times as many as the others.

Comment on this

How many would you have got if the full facts of this had been let loose on the public?

Comment on this

Try it to-morrow.

Comment on this

We will try it in good time.

Comment on this

There is not the slightest chance you will.

Comment on this

Will you vote against the old age pensions increase?

Comment on this

Not at all; we are in favour of it.

Comment on this

There are the proposals under two heads, by those who complain and object to the wage freeze and are full of anxiety about the consumer and are against the consumer being mulcted in increases. They were very much in favour when in Opposition of allowing the industrial workers as a section of the community to get benefits, but they did not give them any benefits while they were in office. Perhaps some members of the Trade Union Congress or the Congress of Irish Unions who met the Minister may have had read to them the full purport of that Bill. I wonder how many workers down the country knew about it. How many people in Deputy Lemass's city constituency knew that he was proposing to get back to pre-Napoleonic times and to withdraw the Trade Disputes Act protection if there was a strike to enforce an increase in wages over what was being paid on the 15th October, 1947, with the addition of the cost of living index increase?

I said before that the people who are facing me have got to the end of their tether. I think that is not a bad description of them. They talk of this bill of mine. Before Deputy Lemass came in—I am sure his memory will not need any reminding of the matter—I read that he had said there is nothing in the Book of Estimates he would quarrel with except the borrowing and, so far as the borrowing programme is concerned, the objects of the investment are quite good, but what he objects to is having these put on the long finger, having an investment policy. I take it that the Deputy does not disagree with that as a summary of his speech. If he cannot find anything to reduce in the Book of Estimates and if he is in favour of the capital programme, he will have to get the money we are looking for one way or another. If he will not borrow, he must tax. I understand that that is the position. He will take this Book of Estimates and, instead of deducting the £12,000,000 and the amount for loan service, he would put them on the taxpayer to-day. I understand that is the Deputy's policy. That is the policy, I understand, of Fianna Fáil.

Deputy Briscoe added up this bill of mine and he was followed by Deputy MacEntee and, instead of £83,000,000, they got £100,000,000, whatever way they got it. In any event, if it is £100,000,000, it will be £100,000,000 to be made up by taxation, according to Deputy Lemass's plan. He is certainly out for a much more expensive type of social services than we are. The mother and child service, in Deputy Lemass's mind, is only deficient in not being in operation already and not being expensive enough. The social security plan of the Tánaiste is only deficient in the fact that it is asking people to pay contributions when the taxpayer ought to be asked to pay. How many millions will that add to the £100,000,000? Can the Deputy chance a figure? That is the Fianna Fáil programme for the new election and I suppose we will return to the Emergency Industrial Bill of 1947 and, because increases in wages are undoubtedly inflationary, we will probably try to get the workers pegged back, as they were during the war years and as the Deputy intended to have them at the end of the war years, to the nearest date he could find.

I noticed in this debate that, as each Deputy stood up and made his complaint, at some point or another an interjection stabbed into him: "What will you reduce"? I waited for any reply but nobody gave it. This money has to be found. Deputy Lemass objects to find it by borrowing. He says it is inflationary. He says that last week I deluded the people by saying that I got it all out of taxation. I said nothing of the sort. I indicated five sources of financing: small savings through the savings banks, a national loan, balances on various funds awaiting investment, the American Loan Counterpart Fund, sales of sterling investments of Government funds. I said with regard to the last two that I brought these under criticism as being "unrelated to current savings". I distinctly said in regard to these that any resort to them would undoubtedly be of an inflationary type and, therefore, caution in resorting to them had to be exercised. I was gibed at for saying that, particularly by the Deputy who now is insisting that I tried to delude the public. I tapped these various sources and I admit that I said in my opening statement that, in so far as I did not get finances to the point that they were related to current savings, to that extent some regard had to be had to inflation. I pointed out, however, that we had a very good foundation on which to rest, that production was increasing, both on the industrial and agricultural side. I pointed to the yield of the crops that were in the country; I was not bothering about the acreage. I talked about the numbers of live stock there were in the country and the increase there had been. I pointed out that we were coming somewhat nearer the end of those schemes that cost so much money. I pointed to the fact that there would be more houses built in 1950 than ever before; and 12,000 houses, 1,000 houses per month, is not a bad record. We did that as a result of this expenditure, or some part of it. The people who have gone into industrial occupations in the last three years, the three years in which we have had control, amount to 1,000 persons a month over every month of the three years, or 36,000 persons. I pointed to the mechanisation there was on farms, particularly in the Leinster area; the abundant use there had been of fertilisers within the last two or three years, and to the fact that the fertility of the land had been restored. I put all these as indicating that there is a good background to this programme of ours.

I have quotations of what was said, such as: "This madcap policy of finance"; "finances in peril"; "entering a wild period of inflation". These are the phrases of Deputy Lemass. He went on a tour ranging from some parts of the south to Cavan about April or May last year raging and tearing about demoralisation, depression, forced emigration and so on that would be caused by this "madcap" scheme. He is bleating the same old tale now.

I want to repeat warnings I have made, warnings for the future. I intended to say, but a colleague said it for me, at a bankers' dinner on the 18th November last year—I am going to ask the House to listen while I gallop through two pages:—

"I am afraid that the world in which we live does not offer monetary stability. The value of money has fallen steeply since 1914. Rearmament is likely to carry this depreciation further. We are forced to surrender, however reluctantly, the objective of stability and to choose instead the imperfect ideal of restricting the depreciation of the currency as much as possible. But this I must stress—the value of money must be tenaciously defended if we are to preserve the incentive to work and save and ensure orderly economic development. The recent upsurge in import prices is mainly the result of a scramble for essential raw materials. We need these materials like other countries, but the goods we have to offer in exchange are not in such strong demand. Our earnings will not, therefore, go as far as before. The idea that more money all round will make everyone better off is, in the circumstances, completely illusionary. We will only open the door to inflation by seeking to compensate ourselves for a rise in the cost of living. Particular classes can, of course, maintain, or even better, their position by securing more money for themselves, but only at the expense of weaker members of the community. The situation called first for an increase in home production and exports to counteract the adverse turn in the terms of trade and, secondly, for acceptance by both employers and employees equally of some disimprovement in the standard of living if prices internationally continue to rise. The policy of the Government is to maintain fair shares in the distribution of the temporarily constricted national income and, as part of this policy, they are determined to prevent excessive price increases."

What was Deputy Lemass's perversion in regard to the phrase, "Particular classes can, of course, maintain, or even better their position, by securing more money for themselves"— that that was clearly the trade unions I was driving at. In any event, he said:—

"Look at what is promised you— some disimprovement in your standard of living."

That was supposed to be a sober comment.

I have said with regard to the last Government that they were at the end of their period, at the end of their tether. In the year 1947, the then Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, spoke here on his Estimate in July, He said:—

"Agriculture is the main industry in this country. If anybody can give us a solution to the difficulties of agriculture we will be very glad to consider it."

He spoke about the agricultural conditions here and said:—

"They can only put between 200,000 and 400,000 families on the land. They will have a rural population of between 200,000 and double that figure.

The flight from the land was happening in every country where people were being attracted to the larger communities in the cities. They had reached a point where they had only 500,000 to 1,000,000 acres of land available for distribution and that land was practically required for two purposes—for bringing up the adjacent farms to an economic level and for dealing with the problem of congestion. Although they had done their best to increase the population on the land they could not increase it beyond a certain point. When they had done the best they could, there would still be a drift from the land to the cities or to emigration. There was no other way for it. Their policy had been to give the farmer stability and to put as many on the land as it would economically hold, as rapidly as they could, and to give land workers an assured market for their produce."

Later, he said:—

"In agriculture, there had been a constant downward trend, there being a drop of approximately 43,000 people in the last 15 years. Is there any way we can stop it? If anybody can give us a solution we will be very happy to consider it."

That was the man who came in on a full flow of promises in 1932. He is here, pathetically looking at the Dáil. He told us previously in other speeches that this policy of subsidies was a rather vicious policy and only adopted as an emergency. Am I right in saying that the people who spoke that way were certainly not holding out any prospects to the people? They were at the end of their policy.

Comment on this

How many left the land in the three years?

Comment on this

When we started on this policy of development, I did reduce taxation when I came in here.

Comment on this

You did in your hat!

Comment on this

If I had your hat, it would be a valuable one, if it equalled the reduction in taxation.

Comment on this

£28,000,000 increase.

Comment on this

We will come to the revenue. I am talking about rates and taxes. Is it denied that, in the first three weeks of this Government's life, we reduced the beer and tobacco tax? That was £6,000,000 returned to the people.

Comment on this

You shoved it up on bread and sugar.

Comment on this

The income-tax was reduced by 6d. That was giving away £1,000,000 and there were other modifications in the income-tax which amounted to £250,000. People may talk how they like about the yield of revenue and the revenue coming in, but there is no doubt about it, as far as people drinking beer, smoking tobacco or paying income-tax are concerned, every single person knows he got a reduction in his taxation.

Comment on this

He did on beer, but he paid extra on bread.

Comment on this

We increased the old age pensions by £2,500,000 for a start. Civil servants and other public servants, guards, teachers and the Army got increases which amounted to over £1,500,000—£4,000,000 between all these things. We gave an increased ration of tea which cost £500,000 in a full year. Last year, I brought in a Bill which increased the rates given to certain pensioners. They are additions to the extent of £4,500,000, which, with the other additions and modifications of the beer, tobacco and income-tax, cost £7,250,000. If I had not been persuaded by my colleagues to give the extra tea ration, the new aids to the old age pensioners and to the Guards, teachers and Army, we could have saved that £4,500,000. I am told that the revenue is going up, and so it is. Supposing the situation arrived in which I am able to reduce income-tax to the figure it stood at when Cumann na nGaedheal left office in 1932, 3/-, or 3/6 less than the present figure, and that there was then so much in the way of income being earned that the 3/- tax would give me the same revenue as 6/6 does now, would the Deputy accuse me of raising taxation?

Comment on this

Until such time as it does bring in that revenue, you will go on inflating as you are doing at present.

Comment on this

I am taking that as an example to show that taking off the 6d. did not lose me anything.

Comment on this

The French are collecting as many billions to-day as they collected millions in the past.

Comment on this

In the end, we were able to get the moneys necessary to finance our programme. That is what is hurting the Opposition Deputies. I think it was Deputy C.Lehane who interjected when Deputy MacEntee was speaking to find out what was wrong with him. I am quite certain that the Opposition Deputies are annoyed because they see our programme being carried out despite all their gloomy prophecies, without either the appearance of disruption or any approach to it. What irks them most of all is the fact that it is we who are carrying out this programme and not they.

Comment on this

Unfortunately you are not paying for it. It is the future taxpayers who will have to pay for it. You are just passing the buck.

Comment on this

It is a question of the "know how."

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Deputy Aiken did not know how.

Comment on this

A thimble-rigger.

Comment on this

I do not want to put too great a strain on Deputy Aiken by asking him to try to understand what is going on now. Let him wait another year or so and it may dawn on him. But there is the situation. It is not an easy situation. It is not one that will induce anybody in charge of finance to rest very easy in his sleep at night. It is attended by risks.

Comment on this

If you faced up to it you would not sleep at all. You are just passing the buck. That is all.

Comment on this

I asked Deputy Lemass about that. Apparently Deputy Aiken would just bash his way through like a bull in a china shop and take not merely £100,000,000 but an additional £1,200,000,000 or £1,300,000,000 to finance his various projects; and he would collect all that in the way of taxation and would not borrow a penny of it.

Comment on this

Why borrow at all?

Comment on this

We put forward a proper programme. We drew up that programme and we decided that we would subject it to a year's trial and criticism. At the end of that year we find Deputy Lemass saying that there is nothing wrong with our investment programme except that, strangely enough, we are borrowing for that programme. That appears to me to be quite the maddest type of finance; one should not borrow for investment purposes. It has been said that we have got no direct return. I never said we would if one thinks in terms of pounds, shillings and pence collected in one's hand. Last year we tried to get the people to understand what our purpose was. We said that we were about to indulge in a particular capital expenditure programme and we hoped we would get our return in the following manner: productivity would inevitably rise by so much as would bear over a generation the increased cost required to remunerate the moneys borrowed. If we get that, the borrowing will be easy. If we do not get it, the borrowing will be a bit of a headache; and, if the country's productivity fails completely, then the borrowing may be, what it is now described as being, a millstone around the people's necks.

Comment on this

It is only an excuse to avoid taxation.

Comment on this

The Deputy in his own hard-headed way puffed along here for about an hour and a half. Silence becomes him better. Productivity is increasing and it is bearing the cost of these projects. Productivity is rising. The bill that has to be faced is considerable. Deputies can compare for themselves what appears on the face of the Estimate this year with last year's. They can look at the revenue, if they want to have a peep at that side of the picture. The Central Fund Services will be up about £1,000,000 this year. Deputies will have to bear in mind—it will certainly be impressed on them by me at the beginning of May — that the new £1,250,000 for old age pensions and the modification of the means test will have to be found by taxation unless there can be retrenchment under some other heading.

Comment on this

And, if you can borrow, you will.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding that fact, I am still in favour of the programme, weighing one item against the other and taking all the risks into account. Our situation to-day is not unlike that which existed in America when President Hoover left office and President Roosevelt came in. President Hoover had been telling everybody that he was governing the country according to the dictates of strict finance; the country had great recuperative powers and one day the country would recover; prosperity was always around the corner; no matter what street President Hoover went down there was still a corner around which he hoped prosperity would be found. The people were hobbling along. Men were queueing up in bread lines. Suicide reached a truly remarkable figure. President Roosevelt came in and he inaugurated what he called his "New Deal." I do not suppose there was a banker in the whole of the United States of America who did not howl his head off and hurl at that new deal the same kind of criticism that I have been listening to over the last couple of days.

Comment on this

Prices were falling then.

Comment on this

The Deputy is very uneasy. What is wrong with him.

Comment on this

He must be sitting on a pin.

Comment on this

Prices were falling.

Comment on this

President Roosevelt proceeded with his plan. He met the bankers in conference. He told them quite frankly that he was taking risks. He proposed to take those risks. He might disrupt their economy, but he would take that gamble. He was asked what the prospects were and he said that if he could occupy human labour and material resources, those two things welded together might give him the productivity which would carry the cost of the various schemes he proposed to introduce. Events have proved how right he was, because we are at the point to-day where American production not merely won the greatest war in history, but is now facing a condition which, according to a newspaper correspondent, will make America three years hence so strong in production in every way that she will equal every nation in the world, friendly, unfriendly and neutral. That was done through the programmes inaugurated by a man who was condemned, as our policy is being condemned. President Roosevelt said on one occasion that he was very proud that he was providing schemes even in this untried way; and, in any event, he hoped to rescue human beings, who happened to be American citizens, from economic ruin and moral ruin, because that is what they were sinking into under the bankers' régime and under Hoover.

Comment on this

You are giving them 3½ per cent. You put it up to 3½ per cent.

Comment on this

You cannot do anything about that.

Comment on this

Even with the terrible burden of paying 3½ per cent., I am merely trying to rescue human beings who happen to be Irish citizens from sinking into moral and economic ruin. That is the plan on which we are proceeding.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 70
·
Níl 56
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?