We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 1–146 of 297. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I have very little to add to what I said last night except to deal with one statement made by the Minister. At column 1649, Volume 124, of the Official Reports, the Minister said:—

"Open confession is good for the soul. I never realised that our people were capable of absorbing as much as they did. They got more butter from native production in 1950 than ever was eaten in Ireland since Brian Boru was killed at Clontarf, and frankly that took me by surprise."

Frankly, that surprised me. Knowing the wild statements made by the Minister, we decided to check up on that and yesterday the Taoiseach was asked the following question: If he will state the total production of creamery and farmers' butter for each year since 1933? In reply, he gave the following particulars: In 1937 there were, 1,227,000 cwt. produced. I will not say that they were eaten at home, because I understand butter was exported in that period. In 1940-41 there were 1,177,000 cwt. produced; that is, 639,000 cwt. of creamery butter and 438,000 cwt. of farmers' butter. In 1945 there were 606,000 cwt. of creamery butter and 471,000 cwt. of farmers' butter; that was 1,077,000 cwt. altogether and every blooming lb. of that was consumed here at home. Not a lb. of it left the country.

For the year 1950 the space for farmers' butter is marked "not available". In 1949, 1,084,000 cwt. of butter were produced in this country; that is, 688,000 cwt. of creamery butter and 396,000 cwt. of farmers' butter. That was only 7,000 cwt. more than was produced and eaten in this country in 1945.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and, 20 Deputies being present—

Comment on this

I am glad Deputy Donnellan has brought in the Leader of the Farmers' Party, Deputy Halliden. I am sure he will be most interested in these figures. On the basis of what I have stated, there was no justification for the export of 37,000 cwt. of butter. The total quantity produced in 1945, between creamery and farmers' butter, was 1,077,000 cwt. and the total quantity produced in 1949 was 1,084,000 cwt., just 7,000 cwt. more. Whether the Minister expected that the people had become so impoverished under his Government that they were going to consume 37,000 cwt. of butter less, I do not know.

As I pointed out last night, it was in the carrying out of an enormous bluff, a most contemptible bluff, that he endeavoured to force down the price of milk by 2d. a gallon. I had not the advantage last night of those figures. This question was asked only yesterday and it was answered by the Taoiseach. It was impertinence on the part of the Minister to stand up here in his usual flamboyant way and tell us there was never so much butter consumed since the days of Brian Boru. Then he was responsible for bringing in here what to us looks very like butter that was taken out of Brian Boru's tent in 1088.

Comment on this

The Deputy means 1014.

Comment on this

It must have been kept it cold storage in Denmark ever since, but, at any rate, it was brought in here for consumption by the Dublin people and paid for by James Dillon, the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

You do not know good butter.

Comment on this

To approach it you would need a gas mask, something like the Minister told us about some years ago with regard to Irish butter. Those figures I have given disclose some very significant facts. There has been a reduction in the production of farmers' butter in the years between 1944-45 and 1949. In 1945 we produced 471,000 cwt. of farmers' butter and in 1949, the latest year for which we have figures available, we produced 396,000 cwt. of farmers' butter. That shows a reduction of 75,000 cwt. In future when we are taking into consideration the supposed increase in creamery butter we have also to consider the very definite reduction, year by year, in the production of farmers' butter.

Comment on this

Why a reduction?

Comment on this

Obviously because the subsidy was cut off.

Comment on this

There was no price. As a matter of fact, if you take later years you will find that in 1948 there were 417,000 cwt. of farmers' butter produced and in 1949, only 396,000 cwt., a drop of 21,000 cwt. in one year. The Minister does not know what quantity of farmers' butter was produced in 1950. If he did, surely he would have given the information to the Taoiseach. Have the Department gone back to that incompetent pitch, since it left the good hands of Deputy Patrick Smith, that they do not know yet, in March, 1951, the quantity of farmers' butter produced last year?

Comment on this

They do not want to know.

Comment on this

Is it that the Minister has the figures and dare not make them known even to the Taoiseach or this House? This flamboyant Minister comes in here and tells us that there was never more butter consumed since Brian Boru was killed at the battle of Clontarf, in an effort to gull not alone Deputies but the farmers, who, he knows, are nothing better than slaves on the completely uneconomic price he is allowing them at present for milk.

Comment on this

You do not look like a slave.

Comment on this

If proof of that were wanted, we have it in the figures for 1938-39, the last normal year, as compared with the complete figures for 1949, which show that there is a reduction of over 100,000 cwts. of butter produced, in spite of the fact that we have more cows than we had since Brian Boru. I do not know what they are milking. We are faced with this kind of camouflage and bluff, a rather contemptible bluff, on the part of a Minister who endeavoured to beat down, with that kind of raméis, the unfortunate farmers, instead of giving them the increase he was bound to give them for their increased costs of production since the price of milk was last fixed by Deputy Smith in 1946. The price as fixed then was 1/2 per gallon at the creamery for the summer months. Deputy Halliden and other Deputies of the Farmers' Party, who were then on this side, complained bitterly that the price was uneconomic and they had a motion down before we left office demanding an increase in the price. Deputy Halliden will find it still stuck in one of the pigeon holes. If the price was not good enough in 1947 and if there has been an increase in the cost of production, as Deputy Halliden knows there has been, of over 30 per cent. since then, where is the justification for his sitting behind that Minister, representing the farmers of North Cork and holding him up and helping him out in scourging the farmers whom he pretends to represent here?

Comment on this

There is not even a Minister present now. They are not interested.

Comment on this

These are the facts, so far as butter and milk are concerned, and these are the facts in the light of which the House is asked to vote an extra £479,000 as a subsidy to the Danes and New Zealanders. What did the Minister do when opening his case for this Supplementary Estimate? He told us that we got more butter from native production in 1950 than ever was got in Ireland since Brian Boru was killed at Clontarf.

Comment on this

That is the fourth time you said that.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister made that statement, because it brought me back a little and enabled me to find out where this Danish butter came from. The Minister is now engaged on a new scheme. He says he is not going to have Jerseys, Guernseys or any of these Pekinese breeds, as he called them some time ago. Now he is shifting the Kerry cows up to Donegal and I suppose he will inseminate them above with a Jersey bull. "Anybody familiar with the congested areas," he said, "will remember the perennial difficulty of providing West Donegal"—he is shifting them very near the Border—"and parts of Connemara with the type of cow which could give a decent yield of milk under the very rigorous conditions that obtain there." He went on to say that he had in Kerry a breed of cattle unique in the whole world. These quotations are to be found at 1633 of the Official Reports of 8th March last. He said that when he learned that certain sophisticated farmers in the country were bringing in Jersey, Guernsey and Ayrshire cows, he apprehended that they would start bringing in Abyssinian cows. I suppose that was to pay for the muck barley he brought in last year. He said that he hoped to embark the first contingent for Aranmore, if it had not already gone there.

Deputy Halliden will remember the pressure that used to be brought by certain portions of West Cork and the greater portion of County Kerry for permission to keep other bulls than Kerry bulls and other cattle than Kerry cattle, which were prohibited by the Department of Agriculture at the time, but now we are spreading them out and they are to go travelling. We have done more than that, because we have gone off for the alternative market, and —you would never believe it—the Minister tells us that he is going to breed Kerry cattle for shipment—of all the places on God's earth—to Palestine. That is the latest, and, in addition, there is no Irishman fit to breed these Kerry cattle. It would never do for anybody down in Kerry to start breeding these cattle and getting in touch with Deputy Bob Briscoe and sending them out to Palestine. "I am very glad to inform the House," he said, "that one of the most distinguished breeders in Scotland hopes to establish a modest farm in the south-west of Ireland whereon to assemble consignments of Kerry cattle for shipment to Palestine where a profitable market exists for them for precisely the same reason as they are proving a success in West Mayo and West Donegal."

I remember the Minister for Agriculture, when he was a wild bad colonial boy sitting over here, telling us of the exploits of a case of poultry which went to one of these fly-by-night markets that the Fianna Fáil Government were looking for on the Continent, instead of looking for the glorious market that Mother England was providing. Lo and behold, that Minister now has not alone gone to the Continent but, as he told me in this House recently, every ambassador of his throughout Europe is marching along from door to door with a basket of eggs in his hand, and is hammering at the doors trying to sell the eggs.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Eggs are not in this Estimate.

Comment on this

Just in passing.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Eggs are not in this Estimate.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Very good.

Comment on this

Will you find an egg in that Estimate? At column 1634, Volume 124, of the Dáil Debates, the Minister, in introducing this Estimate, stated that he was assembling consignments of Kerry cattle for shipment to Palestine. I, Sir, have a very rooted objection, which is shared, I think, by a large number of Deputies. I wonder what Deputy Commons would say about this Scotsman that our Minister for Agriculture is now bringing in to the south-west of Ireland.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is repeating himself.

Comment on this

I do not know if he is a Jew.

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Allen; he will tell you what to say.

Comment on this

I do not know if he is a Jew, but a Scotsman is the next thing. I suggest to the Minister that in a case like this, if he has found a market for Kerry cattle, some Kerryman with a bit of land in Kerry could be found competent and able enough to take charge of the assembling of these cattle for export, and that he need not and ought not to go to Scotland to find somebody.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is again repeating himself.

Comment on this

Realising what the situation is, Sir, I do not wish to take up the time of the House further. I will have an opportunity, please God, at a later date, but I would just again call the Minister's attention to the figures given by the Taoiseach to this House yesterday, and I hope he can reconcile those figures with the wild statements he made in introducing the Estimate.

Comment on this

I am sure the House would be grateful to Deputy Corry if, in the course of his remarks, he could avoid making contemptuous references to other nationalities. I cannot conceive why he should go out of his way to offend our Celtic brethren in Scotland.

Comment on this

Did Deputy Connolly ever meet the Cameron Highlanders that they sent over here? I did.

Comment on this

There have been Irishmen whose deeds in history have been worse than that of any Scotsman I know of. That does not at all give us grounds for casting aspersions at Scotsmen, whether they are breeders of cattle or carry on other occupations. These offensive remarks of Deputy Corry, of course, carry very little weight and do not illuminate the discussion very much.

Comment on this

They are not half as bad as the remarks made by the Minister for Agriculture on the Irish people in his speech. Will Deputy Connolly read what the Minister for Agriculture said at column 1635:—

"I do not know why our people have that supreme contempt for the neighbour's son or the neighbour's beast"?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not be interrupted unless he gives way.

Comment on this

I am merely asking——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not, unless Deputy Connolly gives way and, as he did not sit down, he did not give way. Deputy Connolly.

Comment on this

I am sorry, I could not follow the remarks of Deputy Aiken.

Comment on this

If the Deputy gives way for one second I will put the question.

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture, at column 1635, in opening this debate, said, about Irish people:

"I do not know why our people have that supreme contempt for the neighbour's son or the neighbour's beast, but the interesting thing is that the neighbour's son or the neighbour's beast from this country conquers the world when it gets outside Ireland, but at home, the people have contempt for it."

Comment on this

Are you quoting now?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Finish the quotation and do not put in any trimmings of your own.

Comment on this

"when it gets outside Ireland——"

Comment on this

"and it very often is driven out of this country by the contempt heaped upon it by these neighbours."

That is in reference to Irish people. They have nothing but contempt for themselves. That is worse than anything Deputy Corry said about people in any other country.

Comment on this

It is well I prevented you putting the trimmings on.

Comment on this

Let Deputy Connolly address himself to that. Is he agreeable?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Connolly will make his own speech.

Comment on this

I cannot find any offensive content in the remarks of the Minister at column 1635, which have been quoted by Deputy Aiken. I was referring to offensive remarks in connection with our neighbours in the world.

Comment on this

The Deputy thinks that is a proper appreciation of the Irish character?

Comment on this

It is an appreciation of the way in which they estimate the relative value of the different types of cattle, as far as I understand.

Comment on this

People—neighbours' sons.

Comment on this

The portion of the Minister's remarks in introducing this Estimate, to which I wish to refer—I hope in a constructive manner— has to do with the question of hides and pelts, to which the Minister makes an opening reference at column 1638. He gives figures to show a remarkable expansion in the number of animals slaughtered for the dead-meat trade under the Agricultural Produce (Fresh Meat) Acts and, while he is pleased with this remarkable expansion, he laments that it has the unsatisfactory feature in it that the hides and pelts of these animals are retained for processing in our own country. I do not quite follow that that is an unsatisfactory feature in itself. The Minister, I am sure, must intend to say there that it is unsatisfactory in reference to the conditions which he mentions later on. That is, that the slaughter of cattle is materially conditioned by the price realised for the hides, and, only for the peculiar feature of this matter, he believes that we could greatly increase the number of beasts slaughtered for this purpose and, therefore, we could considerably improve or increase the exports of this industry. He states that "a sum of £5 per hide deducted from the price of the cattle because they are being slaughtered in Ireland and the meat exported has resulted in great difficulty in my expanding the dead-meat trade which would bring grist to our mill in Ireland." I am afraid it is very hard to understand that sentence. Perhaps the Minister would explain what he intended to convey.

Comment on this

I think, if you put a comma after the word "exported" the meaning is quite clear.

Comment on this

The Minister goes on to show that that is the result of manipulation by a certain ring. If the matter could be remedied without disturbing the market and the tanneries, and giving a boost to the price of leather, which would adversely affect the price of shoes, he could materially expand this dead-meat trade. But, unfortunately, the Minister has been unable to find a way out. He says that if he could find a way out he could double, treble or quadruple the number of cattle slaughtered in this country for the dead-meat trade, and that a remunerative market, which waits on this expansion, is in America, Canada, Great Britain and on the Continent.

The Minister said he would be very grateful to any Deputy, on either side of the House, who could resolve that dilemma without, of course, increasing the price of every pair of boots by 5/- and without closing down the tanning factories. Well, it is a challenge, I suppose, to most Deputies to try to assist the Minister. I was wondering whether a method of approach to this problem did not occur to him. If, as he states, the resolving of that difficulty will enable the dead-meat trade, and those in charge of it, to increase their exports by four times surely some impost could be borne by the dead-meat trade to its own advantage. It would appear to me that, without penalising the farmers but by enabling the increase to be given to the farmers, in fact, without having them to subsidise the tanning industry—the boot and shoe industry enjoys high protection to the extent of £1,000,000, according to the Minister—the dead-meat trade might be persuaded to bear some of the cost of this subsidy without influencing the price of boots and shoes. It should be possible that some charge could be put on the exports of the dead-meat trade. There should be some way of taxing them by regulation or otherwise so that they could bear some of the difference between the present price of the hide and the world price. According to the Minister, the world price is about 2/10 per lb., while this Hide Improvement Society is paying the farmers the princely sum of 10d. per lb. for the hides of beasts slaughtered in this country.

There is evidently great difficulty, according to the Minister, in changing the set-up, though he stated a stroke of the pen could alter it. Evidently, he has no desire to use the pen in this manner. Therefore, he should address himself to other means to regulate this question.

Comment on this

Where are we to get the £1,500,000?

Comment on this

It occurs to me that if the Minister and his experts put their minds to this in a more detailed manner than it is possible for me to do, and if by so doing the situation could be remedied, the exports would go up according to the Minister's contention. The people who would benefit thereby would be those who are at present profiting from the dead-meat trade. Surely, there have been, in other countries, methods by which one industry will facilitate the export trade of a section of that industry or of an ancillary industry in much the same way as that was started in Germany in regard to the export of sugar. Surely, it would be possible for the people now drawing profits from the dead-meat trade in this country to pay, according to the quantity of their products which they exported, some amount which would ease the difference between the 2/10 per lb. and the 10d. per lb.

Comment on this

The dead-meat trade would cease to be profitable to them and they would not go on exporting.

Comment on this

It seems to me to be a fundamental axiom of trade that if you can expand your production four times your on-costs and overheads are bound to be reduced.

Comment on this

Not by £1,000,000.

Comment on this

No. I find it impossible to get figures. There was a question addressed to the Taoiseach to-day in relation to the number of hides received by the tanneries. No information was available regarding the number of hides and pelts received by the tanneries. Figures were given with regard to the number of cattle and calves slaughtered in Ireland in the third and fourth quarter of the year, but even here it appears that the information is very difficult to come by. But, if there are cattle available, if they could be slaughtered, and if the export could be quadrupled, it would appear to me that in quadrup ling it they would not only make the same profit per unit as at present, but they would considerably increase the profit on the increased turn-over. It appears to me to be a very peculiar situation in which the increase which is desired evidently by the Minister would lead to an increase in the losses to the industry concerned. The Minister could hardly, if I read him correctly, contend or desire that the business should quadruple its losses.

Comment on this

Then the mystery is even deeper than I considered it when listening to the Minister in his opening remarks. It appears to me that there should be some possibility—I leave it to the Minister to examine that—of regulating the export of the dead-meat trade in such a profitable market as exists, a remunerative market according to the Minister, not a market in which a loss is made, but a market which is remunerative, and, therefore, I can only assume, remunerative to those who are handling this trade—that they are making a profit and not a loss. If they are making a profit, some portion of that profit, it appears to me, could easily be diverted by regulation or legislation or otherwise in such a way that the farmers would receive more than they receive at present at the rate of 10d. per lb. for their hides and yet, at the same time, the price of shoes would not be adversely affected, would not rise by 5/- a pair. However, I shall leave it at that and the Minister may probably get some little thought on it.

Comment on this

I have been thinking about it for 18 months and I cannot find an answer.

Comment on this

Has the Minister thought of it in that direction?

Comment on this

Then we shall have to leave it there. As one who has no desire to confess as knowledge of agriculture. I should like to say that the remarks made by members of the Opposition with regard to this butter question, to my mind, as a mere layman and not an expert, were absolutely uncalled for and merely made for the purpose of getting a bit of Party capital.

Comment on this

Not a word about it.

Comment on this

This unfair comparison with Danish butter is a matter which might be finished once and for all if the Minister would give the House some comparative figures and facts in regard to the calorific value and the vitamin content.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Is not Irish butter the best butter?

Comment on this

Not necessarily. It is not necessary for Deputies to be jingoistically national or to think that it is the best.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The people of Dublin think it is.

Comment on this

The people of Dublin find that there are cases where some members of a family prefer Danish butter to the Irish and, again, where some prefer the Irish to the Danish. If Deputy de Valera wants to tell us that every person in Dublin has the same taste in butter, surely he is trying to butter the House. I am quite certain that the Minister could provide a very sufficient answer to this. Even if it were shown that the butter is not 100 per cent. as nutritious as the Irish, yet the margin by which it falls short would be very little. It is an accepted fact that in Glasgow, a city with which I had acquaintance and with which I have very many connections, Danish butter is always preferred to Irish; when Danish butter is available, the Irish butter does not get a ready sale. Deputy de Valera, if he investigates the matter, will find that to be perfectly correct, even amongst the members of the Irish section of the community there, patriotic and all as they may be, and they are generally more patriotic when away from home than we are here. But the case made against the butter is very flimsy, and I wish the Minister would give the House some actual scientific solution of this problem.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

There is one matter related to one sub-head of this Estimate which I would like to mention to the Minister. My information is that the Minister, apparently through the Flour Millers' Association, caused the distribution allowance of wholesalers to be discontinued very recently.

Comment on this

I am hoping to do it, but I have not quite succeeded yet.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

My information is that some days ago the Minister gave instructions to this effect and that the effect is to withdraw from those wholesalers the distribution margin or allowance that was customary heretofore. I understand that there are some 200 firms involved in this——

Comment on this

In the whole country?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Yes—that they perform a useful established service in the distribution of these milling offals —bran and pollard, I think, were mentioned—and that the effect of this step of the Minister's will be very prejudicial to this element in the distribution machinery. I understand that this step in cutting out their margin and, as I understand it, charging the same price as would be charged direct to the customer, will have a very prejudicial effect on their employees——

Comment on this

There is no proposal to charge the same as the customer.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I may have misunderstood that. At any rate, the wholesale distribution allowance is to be no longer allowed.

Comment on this

To this restricted group of arbitrarily chosen persons.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Here are the factors I want to put to the Minister. No matter what may be the ideal in any particular set of circumstances, no matter what a person in the Minister's position or any Government wants to do, one must necessarily take into account what the de facto situation is.

In fact you have that particular element in the business organisation concerned. If my information is correct, I think there are very legitimate grounds for complaint in relation to the Minister's approach to this matter. That approach seems to have been made without any regard to the interests of the people concerned. I do not want to get into the very involved matter of distribution. I simply put the case for these people, who are entitled to fair treatment. They are performing a useful service under the existing order of things.

Comment on this

That is begging the question.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I do not think it is. These people would not have had customers had they not been performing a useful service to the community. I think it is safe to say there was nothing abnormal in their case. They secured their position in the normal development of business. They did not enter into that business without there being some merit in it and without their performing a useful service to the community.

Comment on this

That is a very considerable presumption.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Nevertheless it is a fact. The Minister takes this step without any reference to the people concerned and the inevitable result will be to prejudice that section of the community represented by these people and their employees. I fear this is just another precipitate decision on the part of the Minister where the Minister, I assert regretfully, acted without reference to the situation as a whole and to all the facts.

Comment on this

Was it not recommended in the Lavery report?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Minister brings me to the flour milling report. It would be all right to base oneself on that report had the Minister either accepted it or rejected it in toto. The fact is that parts of the report have been accepted by the Government and parts have been rejected. It is hardly fair to blame the authors of the report for the consequences when one accepts some bits of it and rejects others.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

One can hardly maintain then that one is acting on the report. However, that is beside the point. This matter has been brought to my attention. I understand it happened only a few days ago. I think the method by which it was done is per se objectionable. Hypothetically, I can see a number of approaches to the problem but I admit quite frankly I have not had an opportunity of studying them in more detail. I recommend the matter to the Minister for his reconsideration, taking everything into account and, in particular, allowing, if necessary, for transition phases.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry referred to hides. Apparently Deputy Corry does not understand the position. There is a fixed price for our live stock and for our dead meat. There is a difference in price for our hides and it pays one better at the moment to take the live weight. There is something wrong in the hide business. I cannot understand the situation. The week before last, in Manchester hides were making 4/0½ per lb. Last week I was perturbed at the number of lorries down my part of the country on their way to the North of Ireland with hides. I understand that one can actually afford to lose one's lorry, costing £850, and the hides, and still make £1,600 profit. There is a ring in existence. I was in Cork on one occasion and a butcher told me he could not dispose of a quantity of hides. I rang up Carrick-on-Suir and I was told that they could not accept hides from me because I was not an agent. The agent at the moment is netting 1/11 per lb. for himself and the butcher is getting only 10d. That is where the trouble is. The people who kill the animals should sell the hides themselves and do away with the man-in-between.

I do not see why the boot and shoe industry should receive so much protection. I see by the Press that Irish tanneries are a good investment. When the people become sufficiently awake to the situation there will be no hides for the tanneries unless the rings are done away with. It pays better to sell a beast live weight because the price for hides at the moment is unremunerative.

Comment on this

The fact that this Estimate was referred back by almost 50 per cent. of the elected representatives of the people proves that there are some unusual features in it, and that it needs more than ordinary attention from the House. It is not often that a Supplementary Estimate is referred back at the close of the financial year. The Minister, in introducing this, thought fit to introduce many things besides just the present needs of his Department. He raised the matter of hides, the price paid for them, and the loss sustained by the farmers. He set himself out to persuade the farmers that they are losing £5 per beast on every beast slaughtered. The Minister knows that is not an established fact. He knows quite well that there is an open market here for all our cattle so far as Great Britain is concerned. If a hide is worth 90 per cent. more in England the English buyer here calculates the value of that hide when competing against the Irish buyers in our markets. Is not that a fact? Is it not a fact also that we export more than two-thirds of our total production of cattle?

The Irish farmer receives, in respect of every beast, whether killed here or exported, the world market price for the hide plus the meat. There is no question about that. Deputy Fagan knows quite well that the English buyer is aware, when he comes to the Dublin market on Wednesday morning, of the price of the beast's hide and he gives the value of the beast in England, the meat plus the hide. The Irish butcher must pay that price against him, otherwise he will not get cattle. Let that bubble be burst, once and for all.

I do not know anything about the middleman of whom Deputy Fagan talks, the man who handles the hides. The Minister called those people crooks here. He said they formed a ring and they were crooks. As usual, everybody engaged in industry of any type is called a crook by the Minister. For the Minister to call any group crooks is, I am sure, just the same as to call them gentlemen. I hope the Minister will not continue trying to fool the farmers that they are subsidising the tanneries to the extent of £5 for every hide. They have no such subsidy and no one knows that better, or should know it better, than the Minister.

Comment on this

I hear the voice of Gorey speaking.

Comment on this

There is an open market for our cattle and the price is paid for the meat plus the hide. Deputy de Valera mentioned just now that the Minister proposed to do away with wholesalers of offals and that he will take whatever livelihood they have from some 200 wholesalers of offals here without due notice. He intends to wipe them out with one stroke of the pen. Why not wipe out the middlemen Deputy Fagan refers to, also with a stroke of the pen? The Minister for Agriculture has killed many agricultural industries during the past three years. At one time he talked about the bacon producers and the manure manufacturers as crooks. He referred to the cereal people and the people who produce root seeds as crooks. He said the people who produced pedigree wheat seed were crooks. Everybody who had anything to do with agriculture was a crook, according to the Minister. I hope we will not hear anything more about the £5 subsidy for the leather merchants or the boot and shoe manufacturers. They are not receiving any such subsidy from the Irish farmers. The ten cwt. beast is worth the same price at Birkenhead as in Dublin, plus the carriage.

There is provision in the Supplementary Estimate to pay more by way of subsidy on butter. I have on numerous occasions raised the question of farmers' butter with the Minister. Yesterday the Taoiseach referred to the production of butter here. I am sure the Minister is not unaware of the production of creamery and farmers' butter all down the years. He must have noticed that the production of farmers' butter has fallen very considerably in the past two or three years. He talked ad lib about the increase in the output of creamery butter. In 1950 it was little greater than in 1937.

Comment on this

That was when we were paying the British to eat it.

Comment on this

The Minister has been paying the British in the past year to eat our bacon.

Comment on this

The devil a much of our bacon they got last year. I wish we had more to send them.

Comment on this

If we had a little less noise from the Minister probably we would get on faster. The fact remains that the Minister has set out deliberately to kill the production of farmers' butter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is nothing about farmers' butter in this Estimate. It concerns creamery.

Comment on this

There has been a slight increase in the production of creamery butter in the past year, and in that connection the Minister is seeking a considerable extra amount in this Vote.

Comment on this

To enable our people to get it at 2/8.

Comment on this

He is asking for £479,000 extra in the present financial year— that amount is being sought as a subsidy. He reduced the price of creamery butter to the consumer. This is a production subsidy, but there is no production subsidy for the producers of home butter. The farmer-producers are being put out of existence. They are selling off their cows. They are putting in calves, and maybe the Minister desires that. I know farmers with ten to 20 cows and they are not milking them now.

Comment on this

Since the Shelbourne creamery closed down.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will come down to the Shelbourne area. He has made no attempt to address the Shelbourne farmers. He will take good care not to go down there. I challenge him to go down there. The Minister has been requested from all sides for many months to increase the price of milk payable to the farmers who deliver to the creameries. He has obstinately and deliberately refused to give any increase to the farmers for their milk in the present year. He must be aware that very heavy charges have been put on the farmers over the past three years. I think it was in 1946 his predecessor fixed the price of milk delivered to the creameries at what it is now, 1/2 in the summer and 1/4 in the winter. It was agreed by all sides of the House at the time that the amount proposed to be paid to the farmers in 1946 was not exorbitant, that it was as low a price as could possibly be justified, and an unanswerable case exists for an increase in the price of that milk at present.

Comment on this

Of how much?

Comment on this

Rates have gone up; wages have gone up; the price of agricultural machinery has gone up; the price of manures and seeds of all kinds has gone up; and the farmers cost of living has gone up. He must buy boots and clothes the same as everybody else, and his cost of living has gone up as much as that of any other section of the community in the matter of his ordinary workaday life. His food, clothing and drink have gone up in price, just as have those of Deputy Cowan or anybody else.

Comment on this

I do not grumble about the means by which I make my living.

Comment on this

We are not grumbling about it. We are proud of the means by which we make our livelihoods. The farmer is proud of his method of livelihood, but when the State steps in and fixes an uneconomic price against him, he must growl and kick. He should not be put out of existence, and he is entitled, as a good citizen of the State, to the cost of production of whatever he produces. The policy of this Minister is to deny to the farmers an economic price for their milk and his efforts are directed to reducing their standard of living.

Comment on this

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

The inevitable result of that effort of the Minister to reduce the standard of living of the farmers must be to reduce the standard of living of the agricultural worker. There must be fewer of them employed or they must work at a lower standard than their present standard. That is the inevitable result of the Minister's deliberate pursuing of that policy—a depressing of the living of the agricultural community. I am precluded from referring to the price of milk delivered to cities and towns, but I will have an opportunity of discussing it on another occasion.

There is a considerable sum in this Supplementary Estimate for subsidies in respect of flour and wheaten meal. Arising out of the Acts under which these subsidies are paid, the price of wheat is fixed, and we charge the Minister with being dishonest with this House and with the farmers because he has not seen fit, before 14th March of this year, to increase the price which farmers will receive for the wheat when they harvest their crop next September. The present price was fixed by the Minister's predecessor in October, 1947, and announced in the public Press. What the Minister did when he came into office was to say: "Very well; if any group of farmers is so insane as to want to continue to grow wheat, we will fix it for five years. We will blister them and let them see whether they want to grow it after five years or not." As I have said, the cost to the farmer of producing wheat from every point of view has gone up since 1947. It is the lowest-priced cereal that can be produced from the land to-day.

Comment on this

And they are getting twice as much off each acre.

Comment on this

The Minister is prepared to pay the Irish farmer only £25 per ton for producing the best quality wheat, while he is prepared to pay the Canadian, the Australian and American £32 per ton.

Comment on this

The Deputy adverts to the difference between green and dried?

Comment on this

Dried wheat. I am not one of those who believe that green or wet wheat should be delivered to any mill. I want to see wheat of fair quality delivered by the farmers, and if they are encouraged properly to harvest their wheat and deliver it, and if they are paid a fair price for it, they will do so. Since taking up office, the Minister has been a great advocate of increased machinery. Any green or wet wheat which went into the mills in 1950 was the result, first, of the wet harvest and, secondly, the increased use of combined harvesters. Fortunately or unfortunately, for better or for worse, combines have come to stay and their number is increasing year by year, but I can see nothing the Minister has done to increase the drying facilities down the country where the wheat is being grown. In Wexford this year we have four or five times the number of combined harvesters—at least, there will be four or five times the number before the harvest—that we had two years ago. There is not a single extra kiln in that part of the country to dry the wheat, which must go immediately to the mill from the combined harvester.

If it is a very dry season, it is all right, but if it is a wet season, like last year, more wet wheat must go into the mills. If the farmers are forced by circumstances, by labour and other conditions, to use combined harvesters to harvest their corn, facilities must be provided to have it dried, and dried right away. The Minister has done nothing whatever to organise these facilities which are so urgently needed. In the counties of Leinster and Munster which grow the corn, the combined harvesters are doubling in number from day to day and the corn will be going into the mills green or dry, according to the season. If it is a bad harvest like last year, it will be wet.

Again, I appeal to the Minister to take into consideration the fact that the farmers are entitled to at least as much as he is paying the foreigner for wheat and they should be offered over £30 per ton to grow wheat this year. A big proportion of the land being tilled is unfit for growing barley and unfit for growing oats, but it is most suitable for growing wheat, and the farmers living on that type of land are entitled to their cost of production for producing wheat. There is not a man, woman or child in the country to-day but knows what the Minister's attitude to the growing of wheat in this country is. He has made use of every adjective and every adverb he could find to belittle the growing of wheat. He has done that time after time and he has used his position in this House in an effort to switch Irish farmers off producing wheat. He has been doing that consistently over the years and in deliberately depressing the price paid to farmers this year, he is trying to kill that industry, as he has already succeeded in killing other industries, notably the egg industry.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has nothing to do with this Estimate.

Comment on this

I know, but I make a passing reference to it in order to emphasise a point.

Comment on this

Just because he loves me so much.

Comment on this

I merely want to emphasise the fact that it is the deliberate policy of the Minister to strangle the Irish farmer. The Irish farmer is a great man if he is producing cattle for export to England. That is the Minister's only concern. He admitted only a few days ago——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is nothing in this Supplementary Estimate about the export of cattle.

Comment on this

I think there is. There is something here about hides which are closely connected with cattle and the export of cattle.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What number?

Comment on this

The Deputy was wedding the dead meat to the hides and blowing a soul into them.

Comment on this

I will quote from column 1638, Volume 10.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Estimate is before the Deputy. Will he give me the reference?

Comment on this

I will just refer you to the Minister for Agriculture's opening remarks on this Estimate in order to get authority to continue on the matter of the export of cattle. The Minister, at column 1638, made reference to the fresh meat and the number of cattle that we send out as slaughtered cattle, and he proceeded to point out——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

All I want is the reference to the export of live cattle—cattle on the hoof.

Comment on this

The export of live cattle, the export of Kerry cows, was mentioned here. He was sending them to Palestine. He mentioned that in his opening remarks.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

To come back to the fact, the export of cattle does not arise, except special Kerry cows to special places.

Comment on this

Hides are affected by the export of cattle. You cannot send out cattle without sending the hides with them, unless they are slaughtered at home. They must go out alive.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy ought to think seriously.

Comment on this

I have the Estimate. I am on wheat. This is the last opportunity, probably, that the Minister will get to come before the House on an agricultural matter before the Easter Recess. We hope and pray that the weather may allow the farmers to have their cereal crops planted before we reassemble after Easter, and we hope that at this season of goodwill, Easter, the Minister for Agriculture may look to the agricultural community and provide them with fair and remunerative prices for their butter, wheat and other products. If he does that, he will have the prayers and the goodwill——

Comment on this

Of the Deputy?

Comment on this

——of the agricultural community in this coming Easter time, if he will do justice, even belated justice to the farmers. He has not done that. It is his duty to do justice to the farmers, to the creamery supp liers, to those who will produce wheat in the coming year and to give them a fair price even for farmers' butter. It is his duty to wring from that Government, with the support of the Deputies behind him who represent agricultural constituencies, a fair price for the agricultural community. If the Deputies who sit behind him, who represent agricultural constituencies and farmers' interests, will only do their duty, the Minister will succeed in getting from the Government a fair price for agricultural produce, such as wheat, milk and butter.

We have to wait another day to deal with eggs and other matters. We will have a day for that before the year is out. It is interesting to note that in the Estimate for the current year and in the Estimates for the last two years the Government have provided £1,600,000 extra for civil servants.

Comment on this

How much was provided for the farmers?

Comment on this

Nothing.

Comment on this

That is for the consumer, for you and the like of you.

Comment on this

The farmers are subsidised in order to give cheap butter to the consumers and that £1,600,000 which was provided in 1948, would have given 2d. a gallon extra for all the milk delivered to the creameries.

Comment on this

It is an exhilarating experience to serve you.

Comment on this

As a member of a Government that have been benevolent to some sections of the community, the Minister should try to hold the scales evenly between all sections of the community and keep a balance. That is his duty.

Flour and wheaten meal have been referred to. Some time last year the Minister announced in this House that he had purchased on the Pacific coast cheap wheat that he proposed to hand over to the millers to mill into pollard and bran, that is, feeding stuff. He even repeated that on another occasion in the House. He was asked the country of origin of this Pacific wheat and he said, with a sweep of his hand, the Pacific coast. Where did that wheat go to, may I ask now?

Comment on this

It is on its way.

Comment on this

It was never brought in. The Minister announced, in answer to a Parliamentary Question that I asked him last week, that no wheat was brought in specially for grinding into animal feeding in this country. He announced, in reply to a Parliamentary Question, that no wheat had been brought specially into this country for the production of animal feeding.

Comment on this

It is ploughing the vasty deep, on its way here—No. 5 Manitoba.

Comment on this

He is planting it in the Atlantic.

Comment on this

He announced with a great flourish of trumpets, within the last fortnight, that the wheat being ground for animal feeding at the present time was Irish-grown wheat. Those are the Minister's own words.

Comment on this