We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 147–297 of 297. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Yes. Is fior é.

Comment on this

I charge the Minister with deliberately trying to belittle and to lower the value of Irish wheat in the estimation of the Irish people. He is grinding that wheat, for what? For animal feeding, to produce eggs at 2/- a dozen, for export. It is no harm to mention eggs.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is, because they are not in this Estimate.

Comment on this

I have got the means of doing so now, a Chinn Chomhairle. This animal feeding for which the Minister is seeking £1,165,000 extra is being produced from wheat, under some of the Cereals Acts, and some of this wheaten pollard will be fed, I am sure, to produce these "two-shilling" eggs.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Eggs are not in this Estimate.

Comment on this

It is no harm to refer to the use being made of the cereals.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy has no sense of order, having been told three times that it is not in the Estimate.

Comment on this

Would I be in order in referring to the use being made of cereals, under this Estimate?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am not answering hypothetical questions, but eggs may not be referred to.

Comment on this

He must not mention the egg.

Comment on this

Wait for the next election.

Comment on this

Somebody else will be drowned in them by then.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin will be out of public life when that time comes anyhow.

Comment on this

Give him the "eggs-it."

Comment on this

In conclusion, I want to say that the Minister for Agriculture, who, as yet, has failed to shift the glacial rocks from Connemara, is going to shift Kerry cows to Palestine, and he should not fail to provide for the Irish farmers a fair price for butter, wheat and——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Has not the Deputy said that at least once already?

Comment on this

One of the most amazing matters in our public life, over the past three years at least, has been the sustained campaign of abuse and bitterness which has been directed against the Minister for Agriculture. Now, that campaign has been carried on inside and outside this House.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I want the Deputy to deal with the Estimate.

Comment on this

I intend to deal with it.

Comment on this

Eggs are in it.

Comment on this

Yes. I am dealing with this campaign of bitterness directed against the Minister.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Campaign is not in this Estimate.

Comment on this

This Estimate is being used as part of this campaign against the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I think it is only right that there should be some reference to it, and that that reference should be made by a person like myself who sits on the fence and can see both sides of the question.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! Sits on the fence.

Comment on this

They might put you on the bench.

Comment on this

If one considers——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the Estimates, the Minister's salary will be on a Vote. That is the time to discuss the good qualities of the Minister.

Comment on this

I am not discussing the Minister's salary.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No, but the Deputy is discussing the Minister.

Comment on this

I am discussing the Minister's fitness for his position. I am dealing with two days of personal abuse directed in this House against the Minister.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not take up that line, but should deal with the Estimate.

Comment on this

May I say that he has been subjected to great abuse in this House? Take the whole speech that we have just had from Deputy Allen? Even you, Sir, had difficulty in keeping him in order, endeavouring, as he was, to continue this campaign of bitterness against the Minister. Now, on these matters that have been discussed, butter, wheat——

Comment on this

Eggs.

Comment on this

I am not mentioning eggs at all because I am not permitted to mention them. But on these matters, may I put this, as a fair proposition to the House, that the Minister for Agriculture has worked night and day in the interests of the farmers of this country? From the day he assumed office he has endeavoured, as far as the farmers are concerned, to give them the independence and the stature to which they are entitled.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is a rule of the House that, on a Supplementary Estimate, Deputies discuss what is in it. I have heard nothing about this Estimate yet from the Deputy.

Comment on this

That is what I am endeavouring to discuss.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I have sat here for two days while being subjected to a stream of filthy abuse from the Fianna Fáil Benches.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I did not hear it and I was here.

Comment on this

It seems to me odd, if they can abuse me and hurl dirt at me for two solid days without interruption, that anybody who attempts to rebut that campaign of calumny is immediately ordered to desist.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a reflection on the Chair.

Comment on this

If it involves any reflection on the Chair, I withdraw it unconditionally.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is obvious.

Comment on this

I had that experience of being abused by the Deputies on the benches opposite. If it involves any reflection on the Chair, I withdraw it unconditionally, and express my profound regret. It was not intentional.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no question but that the Minister's policy was criticised in many respects. No Deputy that I heard devoted his speech to the Minister. They dealt with the Estimate and criticised the Minister's policy in many respects.

Comment on this

I was speaking for three minutes. I had no intention of devoting my whole speech to the Minister, but I did think it was right to draw public attention to this vicious campaign against the Minister. What has the Minister been trying to do in regard to the items for which he has been criticised? Has he not been trying to do the best he could for the farmers? The farmers are being held up here as beggars by the Fianna Fáil Party, as people who are starving, as people who are unable to pay their way and unable to pay their agricultural workers, and as people who are unable to pay for machinery. The allegation has been made that the Minister has been responsible for bringing about that state of pauperism.

Comment on this

There is no doubt about it.

Comment on this

With £16 for sheep and £60 for cattle?

Comment on this

I think it is only reasonable that, when we have this Supplementary Estimate discussed in this particular way, somebody should endeavour to try to put things right. I am amazed at this new idea that the farmer is to be deprived of all individual liberty. I am amazed that Deputies who are farmers themselves should come into this House and, on this Estimate, suggest that farmers are helpless people, that they are hopeless individuals, that they do not know themselves what is good for them or what is right for them, and that their position of despair has been brought about by a man who has worked almost 24 hours of every day to improve conditions for them. Deputies may laugh. They might prefer to hear that every minute of every day will be ordered for them, that everything they should do in their own interest they will not be permitted to do, but that some Minister will direct them and order them what to do. These are the boys who talk about communism, socialism and everything else.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is the first I have heard of it in this debate What about the Estimate now?

Comment on this

I say, and I am proud to say it, that no person could have done more for the farmers than the Minister for Agriculture has done in the last three years. I say that the farmers of the country appreciate and acknowledge that, and no amount of vilification or abuse can alter that substantial fact. Throughout the country there are more, and not less, agricultural workers being employed; there is more machinery being bought, and more happiness has been brought into the homes of the farmers in the past three years than they have ever known before. That is due, not to the people who have carried out that sustained campaign of vilification and bitterness, but it is due to the person whom we happen to have and whom we are glad to have as our Minister for Agriculture.

I disagree with the Minister for Agriculture on many matters, but I must acknowledge—and I think it is only right that it should be acknowledged—that no man could have worked harder or worked better on behalf of the farmers than he has. If the Minister for Agriculture has difficulty in regard to his markets, difficulty in regard to the things we want to sell, difficulty in regard to the prices of the articles we have to buy, these are difficulties that are due to a very difficult international situation. I think it is a very horrible thing to find in a House such as this, representing the country, that there are Deputies who would be glad to see the prices of our agricultural exports collapse to-morrow if they could bring down the Minister for Agriculture on that issue.

Should it not be the wish and desire of every Deputy that the best bargain that can be made for the farmers of this country should be made? But they know that the better the bargain for the farmers and the better the bargain for the country, the worse it is for them—and they look to their own interests first. I prefer to look to the interests of the farmers. I prefer to look to the interests of the country. Looking at those interests I simply desire to say, and I shall say no more on this Estimate, that we have a good Minister for Agriculture and that we ought to be proud to have him.

Comment on this

It is easy to see that Deputy Cowan represents a city constituency.

Comment on this

I was born in the country; I was reared in the country and I know everything about the country.

Comment on this

But you do not represent a constituency where you have farmers who are in such a state of indignation that it naturally expresses itself in this House. I feel it is my duty to draw the attention of the Minister to something which has occurred in my constituency. In particular, I want to refer to a very large meeting of farmers which took place in Dungarvan. They were extremely indignant about the milk position and I understand that they are turning away from milk production and are going to rear cattle instead.

Comment on this

Or apples.

Comment on this

As a result, our consumers will suffer. If the farmers cease to produce milk and turn instead to the rearing of cattle, factories both in Dungarvan and in Carrick—in which the Minister is interested—will suffer very considerably.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not lose an hour's sleep. I put the factory in Carrick-on-Suir and it will prosper.

Comment on this

The Minister should see to it that it will be able to get the proper amount of raw material to enable it to keep going.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not lose an hour's sleep.

Comment on this

The Minister talked about the consumption of butter in this country. He left one factor out of consideration, the consumption of butter by the tourist trade in this country, which has increased to such an enormous extent over the past few years. Probably the consumption of butter by tourists accounts for the difference between the previous consumption of butter and the current consumption of butter. It would leave the ordinary people consuming just the ordinary amount which they consumed before.

In some parts of the area in which I am interested, especially around Carrick-on-Suir, quite a large number of farms have been advertised for grazing this year. I am aware that a number of farmers' sons who know farming would be very anxious to get an opportunity of getting farms like that and carrying out tillage for wheat and so forth. But apparently the policy of the Minister is so much in the direction of rearing cattle that they are not encouraged, as has already been illustrated with reference to the price of wheat, for instance, to till for wheat.

Comment on this

The farmers are making the choice.

Comment on this

I am also greatly concerned about the leather factories. There are at least three in which, as a Deputy, I am interested. I really think that the Minister should find some solution of the problem. I do not deny that there are great difficulties there. However, it is the duty of the Government to try to find some solution of the problem as between the factory itself which is, after all, anxious to produce leather as cheaply as possible in order that boots may be cheaper, and the farmer and the butcher so that they may get a fairer price. It is not for the Opposition to try and find the solution. That is a matter for the Government who have all the machinery at their disposal. They have full information and they should be able to find a solution of a difficult problem such as that which is involved in the contrast in the price given in another country and that which we have to pay in this country in order that the consumer may get the finished article at as reasonable a price as possible.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this

It is not the function of the Deputy to suggest anything in the matter but certainly it is the duty of the Government, with all the machinery at its disposal, to find the solution.

Comment on this

Whatever the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Industry and Commerce agree to.

Comment on this

There is a matter in regard to which I should like the Minister, when he is replying, to give us some information. I refer to an item of £6,000 for the Faculty of Agriculture. I understand that this amount of money has been expended amongst the professors and lecturers——

Comment on this

If the Deputy will excuse me for interrupting him, I beg to draw his attention to the fact that this is a university grant. I think it is the practice of the House that we do not discuss the internal administration of the universities once the grant is made.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The universities are autonomous.

Comment on this

I was not aware of the custom in bygone years in this regard but I should like to put this point of view. It would have been a good thing if the junior staff and other workers attached to this particular faculty had been similarly considered by the Minister. Will the Minister indicate, when he is replying, whether he proposes to take any steps along those lines in the near future? It must be obvious, for the same reason that has compelled him to take this particular step, that the same conditions must apply to other persons attached to the faculty which I have mentioned. I do not intend to discuss general agricultural policy on this Estimate though it has been done, in particular, by members of the Opposition Party. An opportunity for that will come on the main Estimate.

More than once I have had occasion to disagree with the Minister on various aspects of his policy. With Deputy Cowan, I should like to say that it would be a better thing for this country, and certainly far better for the farmers as a class, if the criticism by the Opposition were more constructive and if less personal spleen and animosity were displayed by the Opposition. The Opposition may think that they are doing themselves and the country a political favour. I do not think they are. We have had elections and by-elections, particularly in my own constituency, and it has been proved very plainly that personal spite and spleen vented in public does not benefit any political Party. I think that the leaders of the Opposition are well aware of that fact. However, the stage Irish antics of Deputy Corry and of some other Deputies may from time to time seem to be expedient though I am convinced that they will spell the ruin of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

Quite a speech on the Estimate.

Comment on this

Deputy Dunne is worried.

Comment on this

Are you talking it out?

Comment on this

I should like to say a few words.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

The last two speakers were from the Minister's side of the House.

Comment on this

I do not object to this speaker.

Comment on this

We have listened to these two archpatriots, Deputies Cowan and Dunne, lecturing us as to the attitude we should take up on this side of the House and it appears now that if we criticise the Minister for Agriculture and find fault with his Department, as we are perfectly entitled to do, we are to be called saboteurs and people who indulge in vile abuse. As far as I can recollect, no vile abuse of the Minister for Agriculture has been indulged in; his policy certainly has been criticised and criticised for certain definite reasons. For instance, the people on this side of the House cannot see for the life of them why it should be the policy of the Minister for Agriculture to import wheat from the ends of the earth at a much higher price than he is prepared to pay the Irish farmer. We believe that that is not a sensible policy and that it is not good for the country.

Comment on this

You did the same.

Comment on this

The same thing app lies to beet. We on this side of the House cannot understand and a lot of people in the country cannot understand why the Minister would not go all out to encourage the farmers to grow as much beet as possible so as to obviate the necessity of importing sugar from the far ends of the earth. If we say that to the Minister for Agriculture and to the Government, is it to be called abuse?

Comment on this

You always brought in wheat.

Comment on this

I hope that I, at any rate, will not be called a campaigner in abuse if I tell the Minister that. I consider that I am telling him the truth. A lot has been said already about the price of milk and that is my chief reason for intervening in this debate to-night. Like other Deputies I consider that the Minister is wrong in not doing something to increase the price of milk delivered at the creameries. I come from a part of the country where the production of milk is the main industry of the farmers, and of course everybody knows that the dairying industry is the foundation industry of farming and if it is allowed to decline that it will be very hard to bring it back. I cannot understand why the Minister has repeatedly refused to meet a deputation from the milk supp liers.

Comment on this

I am meeting a deputation from the I.A.O.S. on Friday morning.

Comment on this

That is a change.

Comment on this

I would not meet the Milk Producers' Federation at the other end of a 40-foot pole.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us what he has against the federation?

Comment on this

They are a Fianna Fáil ramp who are trading on the people.

Comment on this

Anybody or any group of people whom the Minister does not like are called racketeers.

Comment on this

Is not the I.A.O.S. good enough for you?

Comment on this

The producer knows more about milk.

Comment on this

Than the I.A.O.S?

Comment on this

They are producing it but the others are only middle men.

Comment on this

The I.A.O.S. are not the middle men.

Comment on this

The federation is in my opinion representative of the dairy farmers and they are entitled to have a deputation received by the Minister. They are entitled to put their case for an increase for the price of milk before the Minister and if the Minister has a case with which to rebut theirs then he can do so. These are people who have made a study of the problem and understand all about it and they should be received by the Minister. We all recall that after the change of Government the Minister for Agriculture went around telling the people with a flourish of trumpets that he was to be the servant of the people——

Comment on this

All of us are that.

Comment on this

——and that any group of people who had a case to put up to him would be received with open arms at his Department. Is it a fulfilment of that undertaking to refuse to receive a deputation from the Milk Supp liers' Association? I do not think it is.

Deputy Cowan referred to the difficult international situation and proceeded to lecture us and to tell us that we should not embarrass the Minister or the Government in view of it. It is a pity that Deputy Cowan was not here when there really was a difficult international situation when certain members here did not hesitate to embarrass the then Government. If Deputy Cowan had been here he would have learned a lesson.

Comment on this

You would have put Deputy Cowan in jail.

Comment on this

A new technique has been introduced by Deputy Cowan. He tries to persuade us that if the farmers or a certain section of them make a demand on the Government they are beggars. That is a very strange technique indeed, I must say. Have not the farmers of the country as much right to put a case to the Government as any other section of the people? Have not the farmers as much right to make demands on the Government as any other section of the people? Why Deputy Cowan should say that because they do that they are beggars I cannot understand.

Comment on this

He did not say that.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen said it.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan said it.

Comment on this

This speech is for the Kerryman.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

I do not mind about the Kerryman or any other newspaper; this is a speech to this House.

Comment on this

It is to the House, but for the Kerryman.

Comment on this

What about the News of the World?

Comment on this

The farmers of the country are not beggars. They are entitled to put their demands to the Government and to demand an increase in the price of milk. The dairy farmers up and down the country are very dissatisfied with the way the Minister has handled this whole problem. I understand, of course, that the Minister received a deputation recently of Deputies of this House. I do not know what kind of reception he gave them, or whether they extracted a concession from him. My information is that he gave them a blank refusal and that they came away with their tail between their legs. I would like to hear from the Minister whether my version of that is correct or not.(Interruptions.)

Comment on this

There are 20 others talking at the same time.

Comment on this

I would also like to know if, when Deputies who think they represent the farmers, went to the Minister to discuss the price of milk and demand an increase, they were called "beggars".(Interruptions.) Having put my case for an increase in the price of milk before the Minister and before the House, I will sit down.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

We listened a short while ago to Deputies Cowan and Dunne —(interruptions)— at great length trying to defend the Minister for Agriculture. (Interruptions.)

Comment on this

I think, Sir, you should make some effort to ensure a hearing for the Deputy. Deputy Kissane spoke for ten minutes against a continuous barrage of interruptions. Deputy Blaney is entitled to speak without interference from the people opposite.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Blaney is getting a hearing.

Comment on this

So are several other Deputies.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has a fair knowledge of what is a hearing. As far as the Chair can see, Deputy Blaney is getting a hearing.

Comment on this

Would you mind asking him to speak up?

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

What I have to say the Deputy will not want to hear. Deputies Dunne and Cowan came to the rescue of the Minister for Agriculture and condemned in very loud terms the tactics adopted, as they said, on this side of the House, vilifying the Minister. In fact, the language used in describing the Minister's policy is very mild in comparison with that which we have come to expect as part and parcel of that same Minister. It is only a few days since he used terms which are anything but edifying in this House or outside it. He referred to a Deputy here as "a scalded cat". Again, referring to the same Deputy, he talked about his "rôle of galloper for broken-down generals".

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

The charge has been made from the Government Benches that anything that has been said from this side of the House in relation to this Supplementary Estimate was vilification and not genuine criticism.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Whatever qualifications or characterisations the Minister for Agriculture may have indulged in, in respect to other Deputies at a particular time, do not arise on this Estimate. The time to challenge them was when they occurred.

Comment on this

At one time three Deputies spoke here and never mentioned the Estimate at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

Leaving the references which the Minister made some few days ago, let us take the references which he used, in regard to people not in this House, on this Estimate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise either. The Deputy must deal with the sub-heads of the Estimate.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

I am referring now to an item which is in this Estimate and arises out of the sum of money incurred in bringing potatoes to Dublin last year. In reference to that, the Minister explained to the House that that expenditure and loss which he incurred through his own incompetence——

Comment on this
A Deputy

Were you in the ring?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Blaney should be allowed to speak without interruption, the same as any other Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

The Minister charged certain individuals outside this House with bringing potatoes into Dublin and regarded them as racketeers. These people are not members of this House, nor are they in a position to challenge the Minister in the House. The Minister is allowed to use such terms regarding traders legitimately trading in potatoes from Donegal to Dublin, bringing them into Dublin when they were scarce. They are described as racketeers. Then we have Deputies taking sides with the Minister and abusing the Opposition for vilifying, they say, the Minister. If there is one member, one Minister in particular, who gives vent to all sorts of personal spleen, and in no uncertain terms, it is the Minister for Agriculture; and anything which he may get from this side of the House, or outside the House, he very well deserves. The terms which are used in relation to him are very mild in comparison with those which he himself uses to others.

In regard to the £5,000 loss incurred by the Department last year, the Minister tries to give the impression that he came to the rescue of the people of Dublin. His main idea was to excuse the expenditure and make the public believe it was well spent money. He did not go so far as to indicate to the House or to the public that the main reason and the true cause of the scarcity of potatoes in Dublin last year was the reckless bargaining he carried on earlier in the season, when he oversold the crop, with the result that there was a definite scarcity, which did exist and existed purely as a result of his not having true recourse to the facts at his disposal, that sufficient potatoes would not be grown to meet the English contract of 50,000 tons. Therefore, the £5,000 in this Supplementary Estimate is something which the Minister has imposed on the country through his own incompetence earlier on.

Had he risen in the House and told us that that £5,000 was expenditure as the result of a mistake on his part earlier in the season, we could have understood him; but in his true style, his style best known in this House, when there is a mistake made—and God knows there have been many mistakes made by this Minister for Agriculture—he does not try to give us a reasonable explanation as to why those mistakes were made. Rather does he stand up and abuse people who cannot defend themselves, in the House or elsewhere. That is a wellknown fact, both here and outside, yet we find there are Deputies who feel so sorely for the Minister, when he is being duly and deservedly criticised, that they must rise to take his part and abuse the Opposition for making criticism of things which they see to be wrongly done during the past year.

There is also the question, discussed here at great length on both sides of the House, as to the price of hides and how the fixed price adversely affects the amounts which the people get for their cattle. The Minister makes a song about the situation, and holds out to the House and to the public that if there were a free market for hides it would mean £5 per head more per beast to the producer. In doing that, he does not refer to the fact that the prices to be paid for our cattle are governed by that agreement made in 1948 by the Minister and by the Government, which they then described as a very good bargain. That agreement leaves us in the position that 90 per cent. of our cattle must, perforce, be sold to the British market, with the result that we are not now able to sell our cattle in a free market, and the buyers are not in free competition with each other. Britain holds the monopoly, and very recently the Minister himself stated that we were actually losing £4 per beast to Britain as a result of that agreement. Yet, while admitting the loss of £4 per beast sold to Britain, in other words, £4 per head for 90 per cent. of our exports of cattle, he will come into this House and tell us about the ring which exists in the hide trade, at the moment resulting in a loss of £5 per beast to the farmer. He will talk about £5 more which the farmers would get if there were a free market for hides when, as a result of the restricted market imposed on the farmers by the Minister in the 1948 agreement, we are now receiving £4 per head less for 90 per cent. of our cattle. We could get that £4 per head more if we had an open and free market where the buyers would be free to buy what they wanted at whatever price they wished to pay.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What happened in the economic war?

Comment on this

What was the position in your Government's time?

Comment on this

You do not understand the position.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

The Deputy spoke some time ago on this Estimate and his speech has not added to my education on the subject. Whether Deputy Fagan or other Deputies think that I understand or misunderstand the matter, the facts are that we are accepting £4 per head less for 90 per cent. of our exports than we could get if there was an open market for buyers.

Comment on this

We are accepting £4 per head less for our cattle in order to give the people cheap shoes.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

Will the House agree that it would be better for us if we never made the 1948 agreement whereby we are now compelled to send nine-tenths of our cattle to Britain irrespective of what other buyers may require? Is it not a fact that after the war and until the 1948 agreement was made we had a position existing in this country which we had long sought for, namely, that we had buyers from different continental countries competing with Britain for our live stock? That is something which we had sought for years and years and which never really materialised until after the war. What happened after the 1948 agreement? We find that nine-tenths of our cattle are being sent to Britain whether we like it or not. How can any Deputy or Minister maintain that we have the same position now as existed prior to 1948, that there is a free market and that all competitors are on an equal footing, when we are compelled to send 90 per cent. of our cattle to Britain? If there is any answer to that I would be very glad to hear it.

Comment on this

Did you ever hear of a continental buyer who could not buy a beast in Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

If Deputy O'Higgins wants to make a speech I will give way. There is no justification for the position which now exists in regard to the sale of our cattle. Under the 1948 agreement we have thrown away that for which we sought for many years; we have given a monopoly to Britain which she had previously built up over the years and which she was very glad to have. While we stick to our side of the 1948 agreement in regard to sending 90 per cent. of our cattle to Britain, she has let us down in regard to one of the items which we were to get in return, namely, coal. Then there is the question of——

Comment on this
A Deputy

Eggs.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

We can bring in eggs if we wish. We are now placed in the position which we were supposedly rescued from when the Minister came into office. We find ourselves in a similar position as a direct result of the Minister's Order in opening the Border for all classes of pigs. In regard to that action, we should remember how the Minister has been defended by two very able Deputies from Dublin. We should recall some of the slanderous statements made in the House by the Minister in referring to the bacon curers. What particular spleen he has for these people I do not know. It is like his reference to Deputy Cogan as a scalded cat.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I told the Deputy that the time for referring to these references was when they were made and not now. If the Deputy wishes to discuss the Minister, the proper occasion is on the Vote for his Department in which his salary appears. His salary does not appear on this Estimate.

Comment on this

Is it in order to allow Deputy Blaney, in the absence of Deputy Lemass, to defend the bacon curers?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I will hear Deputy Blaney on the Estimate.

Comment on this

Is there not such a thing left as free speech? The man should be allowed to make his speech, whether we agree or disagree with it.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

I am glad that the Minister has now come into the House.

Comment on this

The Deputy is going to speak about potatoes?

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

Absolutely.

Comment on this

What about turf?

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

We shall hear enough about that in due course.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There is nothing about turf in this Estimate.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

Coming to this question of potatoes, now that the Minister is in the House let me quote what the Minister had to say and the terms which he used in regard to certain people who are not members of this House and who have not an opportunity of replying. As reported in column 1635 of the Official Report for the 8th March, he said:—

"Sub-head M (9) refers to the potato reserve scheme. That money was used for the purpose of breaking a racket which was started in this city towards the end of last year. Some enterprising souls got it into their heads that there was going to be a scarcity of potatoes in Dublin about May or June of last year, and suddenly, where there was an abundance of potatoes, to my knowledge, the vanishing trick took place. There was not a potato to be found. The price of potatoes began to shoot up on the Dublin market and mirabile dictu, as the price rose, a thin trickle began to approach the City of Dublin from the general direction of Donegal. I then took precautions to bring sufficient potatoes into Amiens Street to create a situation in which the Great Northern Railway were not prepared to accept consignments of potatoes from Donegal because their storage in Dublin was packed, and, to my great amusement, a number of public spirited citizens sent urgent messages from a number of stations in Donegal asking what, in the name of God, had happened and why would they not take potatoes....”

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy move to report progress?

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

I move to report progress.

Comment on this