Committee on Finance. - Central Fund Bill, 1951—Second and Subsequent Stages.
Contributions 1–128 of 256. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1951 ›
On the Vote on Account, the Minister concluded with a boast of what Fine Gael had done by saying at column 1619 of Volume 124 (10) of the Official Reports:—
"In the end, we were able to get the moneys necessary to finance our programme. That is what is hurting the Opposition Deputies."
At the end of that paragraph, I said:—
"Unfortunately, you are not paying for it. It is the future taxpayers who will have to pay for it. You are just passing the buck."
The Minister then said:—
"It is a question of the ‘know how'."
He added that I did not know how and said that he did not want to put too great a strain on me by asking me to try to understand. He suggested that I wait for another year or so and it might dawn on me. This Government has, in its three years of office, spent a fair amount of money. It will have added this year to the national expenditure for ordinary housekeeping expenses £28,000,000. The national debt. according to the Minister's estimate at the Budget, will be up by £54,000,000 and, in addition, the dollar debt will be £41,000,000 or £42,000,000. To complete the overall picture of how the Minister got the money, we have to add that our external assets were reduced by £60,000,000 in three years and we assumed a debt to America of £42,000,000. It is a fact that the yield of certain taxes has increased and it is also a fact that the Minister has put on a number of new taxes.
Comment on this
I am simply dealing with the point made by the Minister that we did not know how to get the money, on which he dwelt for several columns. I want to show that we realise that the Minister got the money in certain directions. We also realise that, if the Minister had inflated somewhat more during the past three years, the yield of taxation at the same rates would have increased very much more. When the Minister introduced this system of borrowing for what was normally paid for out of taxation, I and others warned him that the result of carrying out that operation in an inflationary period would be to increase the cost of living, and also, seeing that we were not a closed economy, to increase our imports, with a consequential diminution in our external assets.
Borrowing for what a person should pay for out of his annual income is not something new. Many people borrow and run their families into debt, instead of living within their annual income, but the children have to pay the bill. Borrowing, instead of meeting their annual expenditures out of current revenue, is an old dodge of weak and unscrupulous Governments. The "know how" of spending what the Government are afraid to collect is as old as Methuselah. The Minister knows how and he has not hesitated to put into effect his knowledge of how to avoid the political difficulty of taxation by passing the problem on to future taxpayers, and by inflating, which is a tax on the income of every consumer. The Minister tried to liken his inflationary campaign of these last couple of years to that of the late President Roosevelt when he assumed office. I think the Minister missed the bus in that regard. If there were two Governments who had the same financial outlook on the world in 1928 to 1932, they were the Governments that existed in this country, supplied by Fine Gael, and the American Government, under President Hoover.
We had in America and elsewhere, as a consequence, the spectacle of prices falling rapidly, Government expenditure being curtailed, bank loans being curtailed, so that the queue of unemployed men grew ever longer. We had in this country the spectacle of 30,000 people a year going out of the country, over 1,000 factories closing down, the worst housing situation in Western Europe, and we had the financial outlook of the then Government being expressed by General Mulcahy, who was then Minister for Local Government, when asked to give Government grants for the building of houses, to embark upon a campaign of rehousing our people, when he said that no such campaign could be entered upon until the cost of labour and the cost of material fell to a point at which houses could be built at such a cost that they could be let at an economic rent. That was the old deal of Fine Gael.
The fresh outlook brought to that problem by the Fianna Fáil Government enabled us to put State credit behind all productive enterprise. The Industrial Credit Corporation was started with fresh funds. The Agricultural Credit Corporation was encouraged to go ahead. Housing grants were given on a large scale. Fianna Fáil, in 1932, knew how to reverse the disastrous policy of Fine Gael up to 1932 and, during those years, we did much to restore the confidence of our people in themselves and in their ability to produce at home things which formerly had been imported.
Comment on this
Our policy, prior to 1932, in 1932 and to this day, is to make the greatest possible use of our own resources in men and material, to build up the higher standard of life that the people are willing to produce. We do not believe in miracles. We do not believe that it is sufficient to wish for a thing to believe that it is either physically or financially possible. We believe that what is physically possible is financially possible, but we do not go as far as to say that anything that is physically desirable is financially possible. My quarrel with the Minister for Finance, in his effort to hang on to office until a judgeship or a chairmanship becomes vacant, is that he has operated the finances of this State to please all the tailends of the Government and to try to satisfy them altogether and to keep them going from day to day, week to week, and month to month. If the Minister did not know what he was doing, I would have more sympathy with him, but the Minister deliberately embarked on an inflationary policy during an inflationary period, with his eyes open, knowing what the consequences would be, knowing that the consequences of pouring more money into an inflationary monetary situation, inevitably, must be to drive up the cost of living, to drive up costs of all kinds and to wipe out, for rather useless purposes, a lot of our reserves.
Other countries have gone to great trouble in recent years to build up their monetary reserves, that is, their reserves of foreign currency or other valuables, such as gold. In the last couple of years we have been acting as if our reserves were burning our fingers. That was because the Minister would not face the political consequences to himself and his Party of acting truthfully and faithfully by the people. We have always believed, and acted up to the belief, that wherever there was an opportunity of building up our reserves we should, if necessary, translate our external reserves into internal assets. We did it all during the periods when it was possible to do it. During the war it was impossible, and a reverse process took place. In the last couple of years the Minister succeeded in getting rid of about £100,000,000 out of a possible net external asset reserve of £220,000,000, or thereabouts. In three years he has almost succeeded in getting rid of half. That was not bad going. It did result, I admit, in keeping the Coalition in office for the three years and will have that result for some time longer. The Minister knew the consequences of that policy. Not only did the Minister know it, but his Leader, the Taoiseach, Mr. Costello, knew it. On 5th August, 1948, when the Taoiseach came back from London, with the British Agreement of that year, he said—column 2146, Volume 112, Dáil Debates:—
"In the intervening period"—that is from 1938—
"the adverse trade balance has gone to an extent which must cause anybody who thinks about it for one moment or who looks at the figures the utmost alarm for our economic and financial stability. The balance of payments between this country and Great Britain has, in recent years, become completely disordered. When we took office some months ago and became aware of the actual position in regard to the adverse trade balance and the nature and the alarming extent of that adverse trade balance it was one of the problems that gave us the greatest possible cause for dismay. We felt that it was essential, if this country was to retain its economic stability, that steps must urgently be taken to redress that adverse balance of trade and to try and restore order into our disordered balance of payments. That was one of the big factors that we had to keep before us during our negotiations with Great Britain. I am glad to say that we have been able to achieve agreement, embodied in the agreement that is before the House, as to the methods by which we will be enabled to deal with that very alarming and very urgent problem."
That was the Taoiseach in 1948. Now, lest it might be thought that the members of the Government were as disunited in their outlook on this problem of the adverse balance of trade a couple of years ago as they are on many other questions, let me quote what the Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan, said on the 4th May, 1948, in his Budget statement, as reported at column 1050, Volume 110. He said:—
"The direct State debt of £104.8 million at 31st March last compares with £100.8 million at 31st March, 1947, and £37.6 million at 31st March, 1932. We have been fortunate in not having been forced into debt to the same extent as other countries, but £105,000,000 is a large total."
In that large total debt of £105,000,000 was £10,000,000 which went into the Ultimate Financial Settlement with the British, under which we got rid of an annual payment of £5,000,000. In it also were many millions of pounds advanced to all sorts of public concerns, of advances to the Agricultural and to the Industrial Credit Corporation and to other people for the building up of agriculture and industry here. The Minister then said that £105,000,000 was a large total. That total has been driven up in less than three years by the Minister's estimate of £58,000,000. The Minister was aware, back in 1948, that the disappearance of external assets, without any corresponding upbuilding of our internal capital here, was something to be avoided. The Minister also knows that the building up of State debt simply for the purpose of avoiding taxation is also a disastrous policy.
The Minister, when replying on the Vote on Account last week, quoted what he said, through one of his colleagues, at a bankers' dinner on the 18th November, 1950. He said:—
"But this I must stress—the value of money must be tenaciously defended if we are to preserve the incentive to work and save and ensure orderly economic development."
Speaking directly here in the House at column 1620, on the same day, he said:—
"Last year we tried to get the people to understand what our purpose was. We said that we were about to indulge in a particular capital expenditure programme and we hoped we would get our return in the following manner; productivity would inevitably rise by so much as would bear over a generation the increased cost required to remunerate the moneys borrowed. If we get that, the borrowing will be easy. If we do not get it, the borrowing will be a bit of a headache; and, if the country's productivity fails completely, then the borrowing may be, what it is now described as being, a millstone round the people's necks."
Now, when the Minister is on the Bench or in some chair in a couple of years, the headache will be somebody else's. The result of inflation in other countries has been where the ports are not as open, as they are here, to drive up the cost of living very much more rapidly than it has been driven up here. I pointed out to the Minister two years ago that in France, in the year 1947, the mere borrowing of a few billions of French francs and the spending of them, resulted in one year in the cost of living being doubled The cost of living has not doubled in this country in the last few years because people were not confined in spending the increased amount of money pushed around on the limited quantity of goods produced within the country, but because all our ports were open to the inflow of a lot of useless products upon which the money was spent. The result is that the cost of living has gone up only a few per cent. so far, but the tendency is there, and do not let the Minister or any of the other Ministers, tell me that the increased cost of living to date is a consequence of the war in Korea, or of any other war, or projected war.
Comment on this
The price freeze has been held on foodstuffs, and the great increase that has taken place in certain raw materials has not yet come into operation. We may take it that if by any chance our imports were to be closed off, instead of going down the cost of living would go up very much because the money that would be spent on purchasing foreign goods, thereby liquidating our external reserves, would be concentrated on buying the products available within the country from our own resources, either from our current production or from the stocks in the shops. If such a thing happened, we should see prices rise in style.
The Minister indicated in his Budget speech of 1949 that he realised the consequences of the action he took in 1949 and 1950 in borrowing for what should have been met out of taxation in an inflationary period. In that Budget speech he said:—
"The scope and scale of State capital projects raise questions which have a vital bearing on Irish monetary stability and the avoidance of inflation in the methods to finance these projects is a consideration of high importance."
The Fianna Fáil Government was not behind any Government in seeking to build up our productive capacity so that we might have an increasing standard of living for an ever-increasing population. However, we realised the consequences of trying to do more than we could do. In an inflationary situation we were prepared to compel our people to save for the building up of our productive capacity in industry, agriculture and social matters such as housing. In our last year of office, notwithstanding that it was unpopular, we collected £3,000,000 in taxation for farm improvements and housing grants. The Minister proposes to borrow £12,000,000 this year for these purposes and he borrowed £12,000,000 last year also. We want these things done but we want them done without having ill-effects on any other portion of our economy. The worst way to tax the ordinary working man, the person with a fixed income of any kind, is by inflation—and the £12,000,000 that the Minister is raising by borrowing for this expenditure is a taxation by inflation.
The cost of living has gone up 4 or 5 per cent. in the past couple of years and that rate of increase is due to the Minister's inflationary policy. If he had not permitted inflation to that extent, we would have had a decrease in the cost of living rather than an increase. It is all right for Deputy Cowan and those who are pushing the Minister for Finance along these disastrous lines to encourage him to proceed not only to the ruination of the people who have fixed incomes at the present time, but also to place a heavy burden on future taxpayers. The people who want to see this country progress in an orderly fashion will urge the Minister to pay his way as he goes.
Comment on this
I want to give as high a standard of living to our people as we can afford. If we attempt to give a higher standard of living to our people by giving them more money with which they can purchase less goods we are doing harm instead of good.
Comment on this
Let us take the figures. The Taoiseach viewed with the utmost alarm the extent of our adverse trade balance in 1948. It was a cause for dismay. It was something that must urgently be reversed. From 1939 to 1946, we built up our external assets by £140,000,000. In 1946 they had gone up by £20,000,000. In 1947 we reduced them by £20,000,000. It was that, I think, that gave the Taoiseach cause for alarm—the fact that we had dropped a mere bagatelle of £20,000,000. Inside the past three years we have dropped £60,000,000 and we have increased our external liabilities by £42,000,000. Effectively, we have dropped £100,000,000. That is a direct consequence of the Minister's inflationary policy. If we had not imported that £100,000,000 worth of goods and if the inflationary expenditure by the Minister had not occurred, the cost of living, instead of going up 5 per cent., would have dropped by 5 per cent.
Comment on this
A decrease of £20,000,000 in our external assets in 1948, a decrease of £10,000,000 in 1949, a decrease of £30,000,000, according to the Minister's estimate, in 1950, totalling £60,000,000. We must add to that the £42,000,000 external debt in the shape of American loans. That adds up to £102,000,000, if the Minister wants to be accurate. We have reduced our net external assets by £102,000,000 in three years as a consequence of the Minister's policy.
Comment on this
I believe that it is no bad thing to have a few pounds laid away by either an individual or a nation.
Comment on this
That is why you reduced the interest on post office savings I suppose, in case people would be attracted to them.
Comment on this
I am dealing with Deputy Cowan. If Deputy O'Higgins wants me to deal with any question of finance I will deal with it as far as I am able. I believe that it is no ill thing for either an individual or a nation to have some reserve. I also believe that it is foolish for an individual or a nation to keep a reserve of money in the bank or invested if by investing that money within the farm or business of the individual or within the territory of the State it can increase the standard of living, that is if those savings can be translated into productive assets. I think it very foolish, however, for a country or an individual to spend the reserve just to go on a spree. If an individual has a few pounds in the bank it would be very foolish for him to spend it simply on giving his friends a good time for a year or two, and then to have to go into debt in the bank, leaving his children to meet the bill. It is very foolish for a State to spend its reserve and go into debt to give the Government's friends a good time for a couple of years. I must admit that from the point of view of avoiding headaches and of taking things easy, the present Government have had a good time. They have had the spending of money——
Comment on this
——which they did not earn. Unfortunately the subject is so complicated that it is hard for the ordinary citizen to understand the consequences of the Minister's action. Certain people who understand it support the Minister for political reasons, in the disastrous financial policy which he has undertaken.
Comment on this
The people of the country should know the consequences to themselves of the Minister's policy. They can note that as a result of it our external assets have gone down and our national debt has gone up to the point where they will have annually to pay in taxation of some sort a sum almost equal to the amount collected by the Supplementary Budget introduced in 1947 to meet an emergency.
Comment on this
We could have borrowed that £4,000,000 or £5,000,000 more easily or just as easily as the Minister has borrowed £24,000,000 in the last couple of years.
Comment on this
We could have borrowed it and made the plea that it was a sudden emergency which we hoped was temporary and that we were justified in borrowing instead of introducing a Supplementary Budget.
Comment on this
I want to put on record the point that the sum of money which future taxpayers will have to pay annually for even this three-year spending spree which the Minister for Finance has indulged in will be as much as was collected in the Supplementary Budget. Think of all the screaming about the Supplementary Budget. The poor fellow with the pint was going to die with thrist; everyone who wanted a drop of whiskey was lying in an extremity of death and could not be saved except by that drop of whiskey which we were putting out of his reach; people would cough themselves to death if they could not get cigarettes cheaply. These and all the other disasters which were emphasised at that time will occur for the next 30 years because of the Minister's inflationary policy. It has had three consequences.
Comment on this
We put the O'Higgins's where they could get the pickings. It put you over there. We could have stayed there if we had been prepared to pay the dishonourable price which the Minister for Finance and his backers are prepared to pay. We, however, were not prepared, in order to get a few votes, to give the country a policy which would increase the cost of living, reduce our external assets by a half inside a couple of years and add 50 per cent. to the national debt, and ask the people for all of the next 30 years to pay that national debt with an annual sum for interest and sinking fund amounting to the total of that Supplementary Budget which so delighted Deputy Cowan.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present.
Comment on this
I do not want to go back over the ground covered so well by Deputy Aiken in the discussion. Provoked by Deputy Cowan, I would like to say a few words on our attitude to the supplementary taxes imposed in October, 1947. I would like to repeat what Deputy Aiken said, that we are not ashamed of having imposed those taxes and that in vast areas of the country the people showed by their votes that they understood the nature of those taxes and continued to give confidence to the same number of Deputies of our Party as they had given in 1944. I regard it as the lowest kind of politics to try to win an election on the price of stout or the price of tobacco. I regard that as the lowest kind of politics, a thing all of us should try to avoid, since once you bring politics down to that level it is impossible for any elector to consider the many complicated issues before he makes his final choice. If he has always to be driven to the point of considering his immediate selfish interest, we should have no nation. no advancement, no reconstruction, nothing. Everything would depend on simply satisfying the selfish desires of any one individual.
I have to record again in this House for, I think, the third time, that I myself told everyone in Westmeath and County Longford that I could speak to at that time, that if, because they would rather smoke five cigarettes instead of four, they were prepared to throw the Government out, we did not want them to vote for us. That was a frank way of speaking and it did not result in our losing any votes, noticeably, in my constituency. If that point had been stressed even more in other areas, we would probably have lost less than we did in those areas where we lost a few seats. It is the frank way of telling the people. They will discover before they have finished that, as far as this Government is concerned, there are worse ways of dealing with the money a man spends than taxing his beer.
As Deputy Aiken says, the cost of living has been going up as a result of the Government's inflationary programme and it would have gone up more if it were not for the fact that we have been rapidly spending our external assets, as the Minister for Finance says, on unnecessary luxuries. I should like the Minister for Finance to give us a little exposé of his present financial views, what he really believes. On the Vote on Account, he hinted that we were borrowing more than we were saving and that we were spending too much on unnecessary luxuries abroad. He made a vague appeal to stop buying luxuries. It is an idiotic thing to do, as you cannot alter consumption habits on the part of a people by making one reference, one appeal, in a debate which lasted for days and in which we noticed that none of the other Deputies in his Party made the same appeal. There was no national appeal to reduce the drain on external assets. There was the Minister's pitiful, solitary appeal to the public to stop spending money on goods which were not necessary and which were reducing our external resources.
It is just as well, since we hear so much from Clann na Poblachta about bringing back external assets, that we should give the Fianna Fáil point of view about it. The only result of the Clann na Poblachta campaign for bringing back external assets has been a wasting of them on unnecessary goods. The Fianna Fáil view is perfectly simple. First of all, it is a very good thing to have a reasonable reserve in a country with whom you trade, for buying goods. That is a reasonable thing to state and it has been to our immense benefit for years and years. Secondly, it is much better to invest whatever money we have in Irish industry and production, if we can do it in a sane, sensible way. I suppose the simplest and most elementary description of the Fianna Fáil view on the repatriation of external assets would be this. If you have £100 invested in British war loan and you are getting £3 a year on it and with the £3 you buy a pair of British boots, it would be much better to spend that £100 on boot making machinery, bring it over here and set it up in Ireland. That is a sound policy on repatriating foreign assets. We do not believe in spending them on unnecessary goods or that we are wasting our assets in bringing in machinery of that kind which would have the effect of increasing production.
I should like to ask the Minister for Finance again whether he can give any idea of the proportion of those external assets which was spent on vital stockpiling or on machinery useful to production. He told us in the course of the Vote on Account that he was unable to give figures accurately, but he feared that a great deal had been spent on unnecessary articles. Has he in the interval been able to get any further information? If a large sum were spent on stockpiling for a possible emergency one could justify the expenditure, but he did not give us that reassurance. He was not able to give it. He could not say if this money were spent on wool or cotton cloth or agricultural machinery, on parts, or on materials for defensive warfare or anything of that kind. He was extremely pessimistic and we would like to hear if he has any new information.
We have been challenged by Deputy Cowan and others as to whether we approve of an increase of 2/6 in the old age pensions. It is not a question of whether we approve or not. The question we have to face is that the Government, so far as we can gather, have no real over-all financial plan. We never know when a new Estimate is coming in, in order to maintain the Coalition in office. We have no objection to an increase of 2/6 in the old age pension. We increased it ourselves by 5/- in 1947. We added 50 per cent. to unemployment insurance and unemployment assistance and national health insurance in 1947 without charging the contributors. The charge was put on the contributors afterwards, by the present Government. We are quite used to increasing social services. We started the children's allowances. We know all about spending money on social services. When we start to raise questions about expenditure, it is because the expenditure is unplanned. We never know when it is going to stop. We have had expenditure estimated at £1,000,000 for old age pensions, £12,000,000 for the mother and child scheme and £2,000,000 or £3,000,000 for the social security scheme. We never know when these increases will stop. Most of them are carried out by Ministers who themselves on many occasions declared against, and completely against, the extension of social services.
We can all argue about a Coalition having marginal differences of opinion on policy. I do not think it is good for a country's stability or for a country's political honour, to have views so different as those that obtain between Fine Gael, the Labour Party and Clann na Poblachta in regard to a matter which is vital to this country, the extension of social security. I am going to quote again the Minister for Finance because he cannot be quoted too often. He is reported in the Irish Press of March 19th, 1949, as having stated in Dublin:
"He wished that he could get the opinion expressed at meetings where social services were claimed as being something good that they were nothing of the sort for the bulk of the community. They were not anything to be clamoured for."
Again, on the same occasion, as reported in the same newspaper, the Minister for Finance said:
"There was a danger in the development of the social services that the people would lose their sense of independence. Social services were not something to be proud of. They should be used like medicine and kept in a locker until they were required to treat disease or illness."
As I said, we on this side of the House do not object to the increase in the old age pension. The Government have raised the cost of living so much that the old age pensioners no doubt will deserve that increase. But we do object to the trotting out of Estimates involving huge amounts solely with a view to maintaining in office a Government consisting of people who differ very widely on matters of fundamental importance, because there may be, as I said, differences on matters even more fundamental which would shake the fabric of the country. I wonder whether Deputy Cowan agrees with the Minister for Finance's views on the social services.
Comment on this
Does he think the Minister could alter his views fundamentally on a question like that in so short a period of time? In discussing all these questions, I should like to challenge the members of Clann na Poblachta to beg the Minister to reverse his financial policy to the extent that there will be some external assets left to spend on production and on machinery for industry, because at the rate the country is going there will not be much left to spend on the objects for which Clann na Poblachta stated the money should be spent. We should like very much to hear them appeal to the Minister and say: "The spending is going the wrong way. You are not spending on machinery or on increased production; you are frittering it away on luxuries. You should reverse that and see if we cannot get the money spent on capital goods."
Comment on this
We have always had that point of view. We were not too extreme. We had a balanced point of view about finance; by not borrowing too much and borrowing if we thought it was a wise scheme of national reconstruction, and not to trot out expenditure to the tune of £16,000,000 in the course of a few months in order to maintain our Government in office. We simply planned our expenditure as well as we could. We did not have, comparatively speaking, boom days for agriculture. We did not have a Government in a position to negotiate a price for butter such as the Danes got. We have heard a lot about that already from Deputy Corry. We did not live in an atmosphere of being able to negotiate for famine prices. We had an economic war to face and we had even a world war to get through. My own view is that when history is written 50 years from now, allowing for the social and economic conditions under which we worked, it can be said that, in the expenditure of the money we spent and the money we borrowed, we did more national building than will be ever done by this Government in the course of their lives.
Comment on this
I listened to Deputy Aiken and Deputy Childers discuss this Bill. One thing which, I think, Deputies probably do understand now regarding the Fianna Fáil policy towards spending money—I should like to be challenged on this by Deputy Aiken if I am incorrect—whether the money is being spent on projects of capital development or ordinary current expenditure, is that they say that their policy is to get all that money by taxation. In recent years the only exception to that rule which has come to light as far as Fianna Fáil were concerned was their project with regard to the erection of new parliamentary buildings in Dublin. I think it was conceded by Fianna Fáil Deputies that as far as that was concerned, as far as knocking down a vast area of the City of Dublin, including some churches and hospitals, was concerned, they would permit that type of work to be done on borrowed money. But, as far as housing for the working classes and as far as other matters for which the present Minister for Finance is borrowing money are concerned, Deputy Aiken, Deputy Lemass, Deputy Childers and the other occupants of the Fianna Fáil Front Bench have time and again made it clear that their policy would be to get that money by taxation.
Without endeavouring to discuss the social security scheme, I want to make a passing reference to it in connection with this matter. In so far as the Fianna Fáil Party claim to have an alternative to the social security scheme as produced by the Tánaiste, their alternative is that all the money to finance that scheme is to come out of taxation, that none of it is to be obtained by increased contributions. I think it is quite clear that if the Fianna Fáil policy is as I state, that all the various matters are to be financed out of taxation, the people of this country should be invited to consider what their plight would be at the moment if the Fianna Fáil Government were still in office. I think it will be admitted by Fianna Fáil Deputies that the Supplementary Budget taxes would not have been removed.
On the Vote on Account, Deputy Aiken startled me somewhat by claiming that the Supplementary Budget taxes on beer, tobacco and entertainments were intended to be for one year only. But it seems quite clear, from the few words which Deputy Childers spoke here this evening and Deputy Aiken before him, that the argument was merely used as a debating point in discussing the Vote on Account, and that it was shot out by Deputy Aiken without any very mature consideration. I understood Deputy Childers's speech this evening to be in effect, not alone that he was not ashamed of the Supplementary Budget taxation, but that if Fianna Fáil were there still, the Supplementary Budget taxes would still be in existence. I think it is a fair assumption that if Fianna Fáil were returned to office the people could expect a reimposition of those taxes. Deputy Aiken and Deputy Childers have made it quite clear that their policy is to tax the people. Whatever development is to go on in this country, whether of a capital nature or not, whatever improvements of social services are to be given to the people of this country, all of that must come out of taxation, according to the enunciation of Fianna Fáil policy which we have heard from Deputy Aiken and Deputy Childers.
Deputy Aiken spent some time in discussing the reduction of our external assets and the manner in which that money was being used, the type of imports which came into the country in the last year. I think it is true that the Minister for Finance did express some disappointment that a large proportion of the imports were of a non-essential nature. I think he would express very much more disappointment if he reflected on the type of imports which came into this country when Deputy Lemass was Minister for Supplies and Minister for Industry and Commerce. All of us remember very clearly, particularly the ex-soldier who was induced to put his gratuity, as part of the Fianna Fáil resettlement scheme, into the manufacture of confectionery, the type of imports which were allowed by Deputy Lemass. I think he remembers the various types of sweets and chocolates which flooded the Irish market just when some hundreds of ex-soldiers and officers were being persuaded by Deputy Lemass's colleague, Deputy Traynor, as part of the Fianna Fáil resettlement scheme, to engage in the manufacture and production of confectionery. I think, too, that the workers in the boot factory in Drogheda remember how, in the years 1946 and 1947—at any rate, I would be surprised if his colleague, Deputy Aiken, had not remonstrated with Deputy Lemass about this—the Irish market was flooded with imports of foreign boots and foreign shoes. I think they remember that at least one of the factories in Drogheda, if it did not shut down completely, was reduced to the position of only being able to work part-time. I do not know what the reduction in staff was, but I know there was a considerable reduction due to the policy of the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce in allowing in certain types of imports.
We all remember, too, how the market here was flooded immediately after the war with fancy breakfast foods from America. Indeed, I think the present Government has a right to regret bitterly the manner in which dollars were wasted at that particular time. Dollars are valuable now; they were also valuable then. All of us remember that for a considerable period —I do not think the imports stopped until the change of Government, though I may be wrong in that—fancy American breakfast foods were imported in large quantities under Deputy Lemass's administration. I could give various other examples but I think I have said sufficient to indicate the general type of imports which were allowed by Deputy Lemass, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, and by Deputy Aiken, the Minister for Finance, in the closing stages of the Fianna Fáil régime.
Whatever may be wrong with the imports brought in last year, the manner in which the external assets were spent, it is right to say that no Deputy on the Fianna Fáil benches, and particularly the two Deputies who were responsible for the Department of Finance and the Department of Industry and Commerce respectively, is entitled to be critical of the type of imports to-day and the manner in which our external assets are being used having regard to their own record and to the hardships they imposed on many sections of our people because of their activities in the past.
Deputy Childers said he was not ashamed and he did not think that Fianna Fáil as a whole should be ashamed of the Supplementary Budget. Perhaps they are not ashamed of it, but I doubt very much if they like to be reminded of it too often. Deputy Childers spoke of the difference between the Fine Gael outlook on social service and the Labour outlook. He quoted a speech made by the Minister in 1949. Had he been a little bit more diligent he would have been able to give the House the benefit of other speeches made by the Minister when he was Deputy McGilligan. I do not believe there is anything either contradictory or inconsistent in the speeches made by the Minister for Finance when he was in opposition and the speeches made by him since he took office.
I do not think anyone can claim that there is any inherent good in State social services as such. The Minister's point of view as expressed by him time and time again, and it is one with which I fully agree, is that if you can get on without State social services by making your people more prosperous, by giving them good employment and good conditions, by raising the national income and the general standard of living, and by encouraging your people to make provision for the future, you will reduce the necessity for State social services and I believe that ultimately that is what we should aim at; I am not saying now that we can do without State social services at the moment. While they are necessary, I believe we should endeavour to make the schemes as good as possible. I do not think there is any inconsistency whatever in the two points of view. I hope to have an opportunity of disillusioning Deputy Childers when the Social Welfare Bill is being further considered; he is completely wrong in endeavouring to make the case that Fine Gael were at any time opposed to a comprehensive scheme of social security. That has been a prominent point in Fine Gael policy as printed in their literature in the past and enunciated by their leaders from time to time. Deputy Childers took credit for the fact that the Fianna Fáil Government introduced the children's allowances scheme. I think they are entitled to credit for that, but I think the present Minister for Education and the present Minister for Agriculture are also entitled to credit as being the instigators of the idea here.
Comment on this
I think the House should allow Deputy O'Higgins to proceed without further interruption.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass is very brazen at times. He believes there is a lot to be said for chancing one's arm from time to time. But he will not always get away with it.
Comment on this
Up to a few weeks ago Fianna Fáil Deputies were firmly convinced that their Party directive was going to be to vote against the social security scheme. I do not know whether the same directive stands to-day.
Comment on this
I wonder does Deputy Lemass remember the 27th October, 1947? Why did he vote against that motion?
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass's memory might be refreshed. I believe Deputy Davin will keep me right if I am wrong in this, that the 27th October, 1947, was the occasion on which a motion tabled by the present Taoiseach and the Minister for Industry and Commerce was under discussion here, dealing with some modification of the means test as applied to old age pensioners.
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil Ministry at that time estimated that to carry into effect the proposal contained in the motion would cost something like £500,000. There was a division on that motion, and Deputy Lemass and his supporters in the Fianna Fáil Party voted solidly against it.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass might be reminded of this also, that was at a time when the pension was 10/-.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass was perfectly content to lose half a million or more every year for prestige purposes, flying aeroplanes between this country and America. He was not so much bothered about the means test, but he was prepared to lose money in that particular direction. I have wandered somewhat from the point I was on.
Comment on this
Deputy Childers claimed credit for Fianna Fáil for the introduction of the children's allowances scheme. I am prepared to give him credit for that, but I think the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Education are also entitled to some credit as the people who prodded the Fianna Fáil Ministers into doing something in that direction.
Comment on this
Deputy Childers did not seem to be quite as enthusiastic as his financial leader, Deputy Aiken, on this idea of taxation for everything and for everyone, taxation for all the schemes that are put into operation. I think the Minister will probably deal with some of the results of Deputy Aiken's thinking, when he was thinking aloud here this evening. It did seem to me somewhat far-fetched, coming particularly from an ex-Minister for Finance, that, in the absence of the Deputy Leader, who had spoken at length with his usual assertiveness on the Vote on Account, Deputy Aiken should come out with that proposition.
It will be remembered that, when dealing with the Vote on Account, Deputy Lemass had the grace to admit that the various items of capital development, the various projects which the Minister was standing over as proper items of capital development, were all good projects, all proper projects of capital development, and that they were all sound investments. I think the very use of the word "investment" with regard to them would seem to indicate that Fianna Fáil were prepared to consider them as such and they were prepared to invest money in them. I think money invested in these schemes of capital development obviously should be borrowed and not taken out of the people's pockets in any one year.
I would like the Minister for Finance at some time to while away a happy hour totting up what would be the bill if he were to take the advice of Fianna Fáil Deputies at its face value. If he were to allow all these schemes of capital development to stand, what would finance them? Would it be all out of taxation in the same year? If, in addition to that, he was to allow to proceed the various Fianna Fáil schemes which were either discontinued by the present Government or which were just bubbling to the surface and had not quite reached the surface before the change of Government, such as the scheme for a new Parliament building, how would we find the money?
Comment on this
That was the idea of Deputy Dillon, the Minister for Agriculture; he told us all about it.
Comment on this
I think you may give Deputy Lemass credit for some imagination. It took a lot of imagination to plan that scheme.
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to do a little sum in arithmetic some day and give the House the result. The people are entitled to know it. We must remember that Fianna Fáil seriously put themselves forward as an alternative Government, with an alternative policy. If they were serious in that, I think they would be the first—being the honest men they are—to admit that their policy should reach the people and the probable effects of that policy should be considered by the people before they are called upon to cast their votes at a general election. Obviously, the ordinary elector will have some interest in knowing whether he can expect increased taxation or reduced taxation by the return of a Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
I was astonished here this evening when Deputy Aiken, a former Minister for Finance, made a very wide and roving examination of the things that have happened over the past 30 years. He expressed himself as proud that he had the honour to introduce the Supplementary Budget of 1947, the Budget which was ultimately responsible for removing the Fianna Fáil Government from office.
Fianna Fáil in office was a tough bird, a tough nut to crack, and many efforts had been made over a number of years, but it took the intelligent effort of Deputy Aiken to cook the Fianna Fáil goose. What was the Supplementary Budget? It was an austerity programme going back to the hair-shirt idea of a few years before.
Comment on this
An austerity programme. Tax amusements; tax beer; tax tobacco. That was the austerity programme of Deputy Aiken in 1947——
Comment on this
——a couple of months prior to the general election. We have kept the price of those articles down without that particular Budget, and we have kept them down for the last three years without that Budget. That Budget was expressive of the state of mind of Fianna Fáil. In other words, they had got into the state of mind that they could not be defeated. They saw opposing them Fine Gael, Farmers, Labour and Clann na Poblachta and I suppose, reasonably, they came to the conclusion that it would be impossible for these Parties to come together and oust them, and at the back of their minds they had the programme which they intended to put into operation, the programme which was to make slaves of the industrial workers of this country, the programme drafted actually into the Bill which would prevent wages being increased.
Comment on this
They would make it a penal offence for an employer to give a shilling increase in wages to a worker unless it was done with the consent of the Fianna Fáil Party. That was the mentality which was behind the Fianna Fáil Budget. They thought that they had reached the stage when they could say: "Damn the consequences; we can rule with a rod of iron. We will make the people suffer and make the people pay." Fortunately, it was possible to bring about a state of affairs whereby in a democratic and constitutional manner that Fianna Fáil Government with that mentality was put out of office. Immediately there was a sigh of relief all over the country.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil said it could not last. It was impossible, but the impossible did happen and the Government remained in office not for three months as the Leader of Fianna Fáil said, but for three years. It is admitted to-night by Deputies Aiken, Boland and Lemass that the Government is going to last until it decides to declare the general election at the time most suitable to the Government. Deputy Lemass knows that. We will go to the country——
Comment on this
We will go to the country when we think it is right to go, and when we think we can get the most political advantage for ourselves.
Comment on this
I know this about it, that I am satisfied that when the Taoiseach is taking that decision he will take it in the best interests of the country which happens to be the best interests of the groups that form this Government. There is no doubt about that.
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil idea was austerity, emergency Budgets and the dictatorial aspect of mind to opposition, to the people and to everybody.
The attitude of the new Government was to improve conditions for the people generally twice in three years. We have increased the old age pensions. We increased old age pensions immediately we got into office. We removed the taxes within this Supplementary Budget and carried on without its taxes. We increased allowances for all other classes that may be considered within the social welfare scheme. We increased allowances for the unfortunate workman who might be injured during and in the course of his employment. We increased his compensation from 37/6 to 50/-. We increased wages all round for every section of employees, whether civil servants, Gardaí, Army or otherwise. We increased pensions, and not only permitted but encouraged an increase in wages for all workers whether they were employed by private individuals, by firms, by local authorities or by Government Departments. Is that a bad record?
Comment on this
In addition to all those increases we engaged in schemes of capital expenditure to reclaim the land and to make it more productive. We have more men employed on drainage now and doing effective work than were ever employed on drainage in this country. The whole of the middle of Ireland is being drained at the moment. In a very short time schemes will be in progress on the coastline, in Galway——
Comment on this
The whole County Galway will benefit from this, also Kerry and Wexford. All those are things that we did. We did everything that could be required in regard to the land, fertilisers and lime. Every facility to purchase machinery has been made available by this Government under their capital expenditure programme.
Before we came into office—before Fianna Fáil were defeated—there was not a bed for a patient suffering from tuberculosis anywhere in the country.
Comment on this
We have created a new scheme of hospital building which ensures that no person suffering from tuberculosis will have to suffer or fail to get cured because of lack of hospital accommodation or lack of beds.
I should like to mention one very vital matter—a thing which I think was never done before in this country nor in any other country. When we came to deal with the transport situation, with the railway, with this difficult position of Córas Iompair Éireann not only did we deal with it by providing the finances for it but we gave a guarantee of continued employment to every one of those 20,000 workers who were engaged in the Córas Iompair Éireann concern. Could Deputy Lemass ever even have thought that it was possible to give such a guarantee to workers in any industry in this country? Deputy Davin reminds me that the Fianna Fáil programme, the Lemass programme, the de Valera programme, to deal only with politicians, was to dismiss 3,500 railway workers.
Comment on this
Permanent way workers. How many are employed in permanent way work now? Do you know?
Comment on this
Deputy Davin will be speaking subsequently and he will give the exact figures. Our policy was to guarantee employment to the workers and not to hold up the spectre of dismissal. That was an important thing. It shows the mentality that is on this side of the House and the mentality that is on the opposite side.
Somebody mentioned the cost of living. We have reached this stage in regard to living in this country that for the first time the complete butter production of this country has been consumed by the people.
Comment on this
We sold some of it, believing the people could not eat so much but, when we found they were able to eat it, it was not a question of cutting the ration, as Fianna Fáil would have done. The Minister for Agriculture imported the quantity of butter necessary to ensure that the people could eat as much butter as they liked. Ten or 12 years ago— and I remember mentioning this from various political platforms at the time —we were exporting 400,000 cwt. of butter every year. We were paying a subsidy on that butter so that John Bull could buy it much cheaper than we could buy it here. Why did we export these 400,000 cwt. of butter? Because the workers of the country had not the wages to enable them to buy the butter, cheap and all as it was, at the time. We had to export it and to pay John Bull to eat it.
With regard to housing, can Deputy Lemass or anybody in Fianna Fáil say that we have not made extraordinary strides in the provision of housing in the past three years? In a very short time, there will be no housing problem in the rural areas in this country. In Dublin we are attacking the housing problem; the corporation is tackling it and they are getting every facility and co-operation from the Government and the Department of Local Government. Anyone who is in touch with people who are looking for houses can see the vast improvement there is in the situation from day to day. In another few years we shall have solved the housing problem in Dublin for the first time in the history of the city.
I have only touched on a few of what I might term the main headlines or outlines of Government activities for three years to show the difference there is between the inter-Party Government and the Fianna Fáil Government, but that is not the end of it all. We have introduced a social welfare scheme, and it is a scheme which is going to look after the worker from the cradle to the grave. Because of certain criticism from certain uninformed sources, it was thought by Fianna Fáil that it would be a good plan or policy to wreck this Government on that scheme, but they were just as mistaken as they were in 1947. In spite of Deputy de Valera's visit to Cavan to give his opinion of the social welfare scheme, we have now reached the position that when the Second Reading of the Bill comes to this House, there will be no opposition to it from Deputy Lemass or anybody else. I defy Deputy Lemass to vote against the social welfare scheme on its Second Stage in this House. Then we have the other scheme which is announced as an ancillary to or part of the general scheme of social welfare—the mother and child welfare scheme. Those are the indications of the mentality behind this Government, the mentality of trying to run the country in the interests of the country. That may offend the financial concepts of Deputy Aiken. It may offend the financial concepts of Deputy Childers, but when it is a matter of happiness and prosperity for the people of the country, I say to hell with financial concepts. On that note I finish my contribution to the debate.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan has referred to the Government's social welfare proposals, and he did so for the purpose of suggesting that Deputies on the far side of the House are more concerned with the interests of the people who need State assistance than Deputies on this side. I want to make a proposition to him in regard to the increase in old age pensions. In regard to the main part of the Government's proposal, to make it effective all they need do is to change one word in the Old Age Pensions Act. I invite the Government to get a Bill making that change drafted to-night, to ask the Dáil to meet to-morrow, and to submit it to the Dáil. It can then be passed through the Dáil to-morrow, and become law next week. Is that not a fair offer?
Comment on this
I will tell you exactly why you are doing it. You do not care a rap about the old age pensioners.
Comment on this
You decided to put that into the Social Welfare Bill, even though the Bill, as originally drafted, did not provide for it, in order to overcome objections to that Bill which had been expressed by Deputies who normally support the Government. You are not changing the amount of the old age pension because you want to improve the lot of the old age pensioner or because you want to restore the purchasing power of the pension to what it was before the war. You are doing this in order to overcome the political difficulty which you anticipated if you proceeded with the Bill as it was originally drafted. Is that not true? If you are trying to pretend that the increase in the old age pension is the outcome of any concern for old age pensioners, then I invite you to come before the Dáil to-morrow with the one-clause Bill necessary to make the change, and I guarantee to you that it will be passed into law before a week is out. You will not do that because you were not interested in the old age pensioners at all until you began to realise that there was a likelihood that you might lose your jobs if the Social Welfare Bill were proceeded with in its original form. Is there one amongst the Deputies opposite who did not profess themselves to be satisfied with the Social Welfare Bill as originally introduced without any provision for the old age pensioners?
Comment on this
You were sweating behind the scenes. Your knees were shaking behind the scenes. You thought you were going out of office, as you would go out of office if there was a general election. Then you went to the Minister for Finance, the Minister who promised to cut down Government expenditure before he took office, and having the same anxiety as you had, he coughed up £1,500,000 to enable you to increase these pensions.(Interruptions.)
Why did you not hold out for a 25/- pension? The Deputies who are interrupting me promised the old age pensioners a pension of 25/- a week. They could have got it just as easily as the £1 per week. All you had to do was to hold out long enough and he would have given you 25/- per week. Are you satisfied with 20/-? Do you think it is enough? Will one of you answer me?
I came in here on this debate expecting to hear a discussion upon the Central Fund Bill which the Minister for Finance has proposed consequential upon the introduction this year of Estimates for Government services which establish an all-time record. Instead of that, we are discussing the Fianna Fáil Budget of 1947. Whatever Fianna Fáil did in 1947 is done. Whether it was wise or foolish, it is over—it is on the record. Whether it got us votes or lost us votes, there is nothing we can do about it. We are discussing the administration of the Coalition Government in 1951, a Government who opposed that Budget on the ground that it imposed an intolerable financial burden on the Irish community. It involved governmental expenditure that year to the level of £59,000,000. This year, it will be £83,000,000. If £59,000,000 was an intolerable burden in 1947, what adjective describes a burden of £83,000,000 in 1951? Do you not think that the occasion of a Central Fund Bill of this character should be taken advantage of by some Coalition Deputy to explain just why it is they failed so dismally to fulfil their promise to reduce the cost of Government services, to fulfil their promise of a policy of retrenchment? There is still plenty of time before the Dáil adjourns to give us that explanation, if there is one.
Deputy Cowan knows the right answers and, not being subject to any Party whip, was not deterred from giving them, because the whole administration of Government since the Coalition came into office has been directed to one purpose and one purpose only—to keep it in office. Whenever any political danger threatened the Government which could be averted by spending money, the money was found, the policy of retrenchment was forgotten, and more will be found, and the only thing on which I feel like commenting in that regard is the reluctance of the Labour Party to use their power in full. Why have they trimmed down their demands? Why have they forgotten the programme they fought the election on? Every single item of that programme can be put into effect now, if they want it.
Comment on this
Where? But, of course, the answer is as I have said: they do not quite know how far they can push without risking a situation that will cause a general election and they want that general election, as Deputy Cowan confesses, only in circumstances that are likely to secure electoral victories for themselves.