We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Central Fund Bill, 1951—Second and Subsequent Stages.

Contributions 129–256 of 256. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Central Fund Bill, 1951
Enacted

No. 6 of 1951 ›

That is their only concern in the matter. Honest men might have thought that, having put one programme before the country and having subsequently abandoned it, they should go back to the electors who voted for them and get a renewal of authority to speak in their name; but Deputy Cowan has no such intention, and Deputy Cowan is fully qualified as a Coalition Deputy by his confession, because they all have the same idea, although they are not stupid enough to express it in public, as Deputy Cowan was.

Comment on this

Honesty is the best policy.

Comment on this

It all depends on what you regard as the best policy. The best policy does not necessarily get the votes. We found that out.

Comment on this

You were found out.

Comment on this

We do not mind. We prefer to stand for the best policy on this side than for the worst policy on the other side. A great deal of play has been made with the various matters the Fianna Fáil Government discussed from time to time and did not proceed with. The Minister for Finance has established a precedent— understand that it is a precedent—of quoting from confidential documents circulated to the previous Cabinet in relation to various matters discussed there, and has endeavoured, upon the basis of these documents, to misrepresent what the previous Government were proposing to do.

I have no hesitation in confessing that many times during my years as a Minister, I put up propositions to the Government of which I was a member which were turned down by that Government, and which were turned down for reasons I accepted, because it seemed to me that the arguments advanced against them were stronger than the arguments I could advance in favour of them. I do not mind confessing also that there were many times when other Ministers brought before that Cabinet propositions which I did not like and the withdrawal of which followed upon the arguments which were advanced against them. If this precedent is to be established in our political life, I am quite certain that some time I will have a most enjoyable time reading the minutes which are now circulated to the Cabinet in relation to various proposals which from time to time raised their heads in the Coalition Benches and were never seen again. I could spend half an hour referring to projects that individual Ministers on the benches opposite stated they were going to embark upon and then forgot about, because, presumably, when they brought these propositions to the Cabinet, they were rejected, and rejected perhaps for a good reason.

I do not care what documents you quote in relation to any of these matters to which reference has been made here. I would much prefer that all the documents were made available for public examination, or at least for examination by Deputies. I do not mind confessing that many times during those war years, or in the two more difficult years that followed the war, we thought it necessary to embark upon courses of action, or to examine the wisdom of embarking on courses of action, which we would not contemplate now, actions which would have no relation to present-day circumstances. Surely, in 1951, we adult men should be able to discuss policy for 1951 with reference to the facts as we know them and not solely for the purpose of scoring some debating point by quoting partially and unfairly from documents relating to ideas discussed four or five years ago.

Comment on this

Like Deputy MacEntee.

Comment on this

I am afraid I do not follow the reference.

Comment on this

He does not know how to quote any document.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He has not spoken on this Bill.

Comment on this

A good job.

Comment on this

For you, yes.

Comment on this

So far as I am concerned, I am quite prepared to let the record of the Fianna Fáil Government during the war years stand as a whole. The Minister for Finance can say that I was in favour of this form of control or that form of control. That may be true or it may not be true. In so far as our aim was to bring this nation through the war with a minimum of hardship for its people, with a minimum of damage to its economy and with the capacity within it to go forward, as soon as war-time difficulties were over, to economic expansion, to the improvement of the social welfare services, I claim we did it and did it reasonably well. We made plenty mistakes, of course—not half as many as this Government are making—but the net result was good, and on the net result I am prepared to stand before any group of Irish electors.

It is perfectly true that I said here during the debate on the Vote on Account that the public of this country want capital expenditure upon housing, drainage, afforestation, telephone development, electricity development and all the things that are in the Government's capital investment list. I could double that list. I could name as many other activities in which capital could be invested usefully and should be invested, if we had it. Deputy O'Higgins appears to think that money borrowed and spent upon these capital purposes is not money taken out of the pockets of our citizens. If it does not come out of the pockets of our citizens, where does it come from? It is quite true that at the present time the nation has the benefit of substantial funds contributed by the American authorities. A sum of £40,000,000 is available in the Counterpart Fund for capital investment purposes here. I often lie awake at night thinking of what we might have done in the years before the war if we had had half that sum made available here by the Americans or by somebody else. Do you really think you are making the best use of it? Do you think that this passing advantage which the nation now has is being availed of to give it permanent advantages which will enable it to pay its way when, next year, that revenue dries up? Is it not true that a substantial part of that money has been dissipated in the higher cost of Government administration? Is it not true that some of it has been used to meet Budget deficits used in that way because of the reluctance of the Minister for Finance to balance his Budget, his inflated Budget, by increasing taxation?

I think that is what the record will be of these five years, a period of tremendous advantage, with the whole world situation favouring economic expansion here, with this tremendous financial asset of £40,000,000 given us free by the great United States of America. Can you show, as compared with the development of the five years before the war, anything comparable as a result of these advantages? We had not a world situation such as now exists. We had every country in the world trying to dump goods on our shores, subsidising exports, subsidising shipping freights, trying to break down our efforts to build up industries by under-selling. We had a world-wide slump. We had an economic war on top of that. We had nobody giving us money for nothing but everyone demanding that we should pay them money. Yet, I would say, the record of that five years will stand in comparison with the record of these last five years and we have no need to be ashamed of the comparison.

I am not going to deny that progress has been made in housing. I will controvert the assertion that that progress would not have taken place under any Government, and I am not talking about the Fianna Fáil Government only. Is housing a political matter, a matter of Party controversy? Has it not been said by people on each side of the House that there is one matter upon which we are not in disagreement, the need to eliminate the legacy of slums that we got from years of British misrule by building decent homes for our people through the local authorities? Is there a single Deputy opposite who believes that there would be one house less built if a Fianna Fáil Government were in office or if a Labour Government were in office or a Clann na Poblachta Government or a Fine Gael Government?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

When Deputy Cowan talks about hospitalisation, is it necessary to lie, to say that there was not a single bed for a tuberculosis patient in this country in 1947? Will Deputy Cowan or any Deputy opposite name one hospital that has been built since that was not begun or planned before the change of Government?

We have now certain problems which are grave enough to be securing the attention of this House without all this effort to score Party points, and it is in relation to those problems that we have been endeavouring in the past few weeks to get some information from the Government. Price control is one of them. I think there has been a complete mishandling of this price control situation, and I am anxious to get from the Government some elucidation of the principles upon which they are working.

We know that an Order was made on 2nd January freezing the prices of a number of goods. Last week, an advertisement was surreptitiously put into the newspapers amending that Order significantly. There was no statement from the Government Information Bureau. There was none of the ballyhoo which accompanied the making of the original Order. An advertising agency came late at night to each newspaper with a vaguely worded Order which merely said: "The schedule of the Price Control Order will be amended by substituting the following list for the list already appearing therein." It appeared in every newspaper on a Saturday morning. It will show how astutely the advertisement was framed when not a single newspaper in this country grasped its significance or made any editorial reference to it. It was not until the following day that people began to wake up to the fact that the whole price freezing Order had been put into the discard, or appeared to have been put into the discard. Subsequently, the Minister for Finance revealed that the goods which appeared to have been decontrolled by that amending Order were not decontrolled at all.

Why was there not issued with that advertisement an explanatory statement of the reasons why the Government was making the change, what the effect of the change was, so as to help the trading community and the buying public of this country to understand the position?

Let me give an example of what I have in mind. The Price Control Order made on 2nd January applied to potatoes and it was expressed to apply to the wholesale and retail prices of potatoes. At that time, the wholesale price of potatoes in Dublin was £11 per ton, but the Order was retrospective in its effect and purported to fix, as maximum prices, those which prevailed upon 2nd December, 1950. On 2nd December, 1950, the wholesale price of potatoes was £9 a ton. The position, therefore, was that, under that Order, the wholesale price of potatoes should have been reduced to £9 a ton and the retail price should have been related to a wholesale cost of £9. By the 2nd January, however, the wholesale price of potatoes had risen to £11 per ton, and it is still £11 per ton. Either by secret arrangement with the Department—because no public notice appeared—or because of the failure of the Department to enforce its Order, the wholesale price of potatoes has remained since at the £11 per ton it was on 2nd January and not the £9 a ton it was on 2nd December. But, every retail trader in this city has been told that he must continue to sell at the 2nd December price, the price which was related to a wholesale price of £9 per ton. Is that reasonable? Does it not indicate the need for creating some organisation within the Government which will explain to the public these apparent anomalies in the administration of their Orders and what precisely the Government is trying to do.

I can tell you, from years of experience in administering price control, that it is impossible to achieve success of it by administrative methods alone. Unless you can get public co-operation and goodwill behind your control arrangements, they will not work. It took us a long time, after the beginning of the war, before public co-operation was forthcoming in any degree. Time and again I had to speak on the radio, to speak in public, explaining the need for that co-operation, pleading for it, endeavouring to get the public to understand that price control was, in the main, a matter for themselves and that, unless they helped to make it effective, it could not be made effective.

We had to supplement these appeals for public co-operation with legislation of a terroristic kind, to make it an offence, triable before a military court, to infringe a price control Order, and to secure the imposition and enforcement of severe penalties. Even with all that, even with the public knowledge that we were in a war situation, with the realisation that commodities were scarce and that rationing and price control alone gave a prospect of fair distribution of scarce commodities, despite the continued appeals to the public for co-operation, despite the existence of the military court, and the heavy penalties imposed by it, nevertheless, I say that price control was not more than 50 per cent. effective. There was a widespread black market —not as widespread as was alleged— but in every part of the country there were people evading that price control and cashing in on scarcity conditions.

If we are now again entering into circumstances in which price control is necessary, do you think it can be made effective by this hole and corner method of administration, this surreptitious publication of advertisements in the newspapers? Do you not realise that, unless the public back you, you cannot succeed? The case I am making to the Government, that I have been trying to make, is that their existing administrative arrangements are ineffective and inefficient and that, if they are going to make price control work in present circumstances—and I think that we must have price control in present circumstances—then, they have got to apply in this year the accumulated experience of the war years and that experience is available to them amongst the officers of the Department of Industry and Commerce. I think it was next door to lunacy to forgo that experience and to entrust this task to people who had no previous contact with it, a part-time advisory committee of people whose main interest is in other matters.

We have now also the prospect of a fuel crisis. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and I had an argument here during the debate on the Vote on Account as to who in the Government was responsible for the supervision of the turf production arrangements. And merely to justify the assumption upon which I based my contention then that that responsibility had been transferred to the Minister for Social Welfare, I want to quote from a report which appeared in the Irish Independent on the 18th January last. On that date there was published the details of a conference held between the Minister for Social Welfare, the Minister for Local Government and all the county managers and county engineers, and to that gathering of county managers and county engineers the Minister for Social Welfare, according to the report published in the Irish Independent, said:

"The Government has charged me with general supervision over fuel requirements for 1951."

Taking that assertion of the Minister for Social Welfare, I said it was a foolish arrangement, that I could not see how the head of that Department, with his current responsibilities in relation to the Government's legislative programme and the absence of any one in the Department who knows anything about the problem, could effectively supervise the turf production programme on the scale required, and that there were available in the Department of Industry and Commerce, and the organisations linked with that Department, not merely competent officials quite capable of exercising that supervision but also, as in the case of price control, with a great deal of experience which would be of inestimable benefit to them.

Comment on this

The Minister was sick then.

Comment on this

That was the explanation which the Parliamentary Secretary gave me, that Mr. Norton, the Minister for Social Welfare, took that conference because he—the Parliamentary Secretary—was absent in Belfast, and because the Minister was sick. But what the Minister for Social Welfare, according to the Irish Independent, is reported to have said is this: “The Government has charged me with general supervision over fuel requirements for 1951.” That is either true or it is not.

Comment on this

That does not take out the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

Again that observation.

Comment on this

In 1946 or 1947 the then Taoiseach took a conference of county managers in the Department of Local Government, but it still did not take the Department from Deputy MacEntee.

Comment on this

Was he entrusted with the general supervision of turf development? I do not care who is in charge. What I am trying to impress on the Government is this—let the public know what they are doing. If there is confusion caused in the public mind by misleading pronouncements such as the Minister for Social Welfare seems to have made let the position be clarified and clarified beyond doubt. I thought that the Parliamentary Secretary had taken some steps towards its clarification by his interjections here during my speech on the Vote of Account, but this afternoon he again confused the issue as to who is responsible for turf production. If there is failure to procure the production in this country of sufficient turf to avoid a fuel crisis next winter who will be to blame? Remember that the fuel crisis we are facing this year was not foreseen by the Government in time. As far back as last August the Parliamentary Secretary to the British Minister of Fuel and Power spoke of an impending fuel crisis in Great Britain. I want to put on record that on the 4th September, 1950, the Irish Press published a leading article referring to that statement made by the British Minister and referring to the possibility of a fuel crisis here and urging upon the Government that they should put into train the measures that were then thought to be practicable to minimise the effect of that crisis upon our people. Not merely was nothing done but the Parliamentary Secretary, when the Dáil reassembled at the end of October said there was going to be no fuel crisis. In the middle of October the Irish coal merchants went to the Department of Finance and asked for an allocation of dollars to buy American coal and were refused.

When the Dáil reassembled the Minister for Finance was questioned on that matter and he said that unfortunately all the available dollars had been allocated and that none could be made available for coal. A few days later the British Minister of Fuel and Power announced that Britain was starting to import coal and immediately there was a realisation amongst our own Ministers of the reality of the crisis and the dollars which a week earlier were not available for coal were then suddenly made available. The Government then took a belated decision to organise the turf production programme. More luck to their turf production programme, but let it be directed with competence, let it be directed by a single authority because you cannot get the co-ordination of all the forces necessary to make it a success if there is going to be a division of responsibility between individual departments. Concentrate the responsibility in one department and let the public know which department has the responsibility, which department will be entitled to praise or entitled to the blame according as their programme succeeds or fails.

These are matters that we should now be discussing. There are other matters perhaps equally grave and equally urgent. Some are referred to on the Vote on Account. They are far more important than the petty debating points which Deputies have been making, far more important than whether Fianna Fáil made wise decisions or wrong decisions during their term of office. I have said that whatever we did is on record and we have got to stand over it. The record of the Coalition is now being made. What you do to-day or next week or next month will constitute your record. Will you at least take the precaution of telling us what you are trying to do so that we will be able to relate your actual achievement with your intentions? We will give you credit for good intentions if you have them.

Comment on this

Will you help us?

Comment on this

But so long as we get this purely political approach, this cynical allocation of funds diverted to solution of Party political problems, this blatant admission that we have just got from some of the spokesmen over there that their sole concern is to win the next election, I promise you our undying opposition.

Comment on this

I hope that after that bullying lecture the Deputy will not leave before I get an opportunity of answering it.

Comment on this

I will leave if I like.

Comment on this

I have no illusions as to which was the better policy as far as these matters are concerned. I had no illusions as to whether it was better to tax luxuries or to come along as one of the present Ministers did and describe here, in his most exuberant mood, the pip-squeak inspectors who were then being sent from door to door into every grocery and bakehouse in the country to see that as far as the ordinary individual was concerned he was not going to get one ounce of bread extra except what he could purchase in the black market. Where did this Government get the money which their predecessors proposed to raise out of taxation on beer spirits and cigarettes? They got it from the black market in tea, the black market in sugar and the black market in bread. So far as the ordinary individual was concerned, flour remained so scarce that the ration had to be kept on for him. But there was a lovely white loaf for the fellow who could pay for it. I want to know from the Minister what did he do with the £7,000,000 worth of fuel that was handed over to him by the former Minister for Industry and Commerce? What did he do with the money when he sold it, and what stocks did he put in instead of it? Seven million pounds worth of fuel. There was a total of 368,000 tons of turf, 390,000 tons of timber and 480,000 tons of coal—and all he has left now is 11,000 tons of turf and 118,000 tons of coal. The balance is gone——

Comment on this

To Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this

——in filling in the gap to make up for the taxes on the beer and the spirits and the tobacco. And now it is going to be replaced. How? How is it going to be replaced and where is the replacement going to come from? You pay more to-day for bringing coal from America into this country than the entire cost of the coal, freightage and all, would have come to 12 months ago. Just consider that state of affairs.

We heard Deputy O'Higgins talk about factories and the unemployment in the factories. I have a kind of a recollection that, about three months after this mixum-gatherum team came in here, two little factories which we had in East Cork were seriously affected because there was a flooding of foreign material into this country. Protests were made to the Minister for Industry and Commerce in connection with it. One of these factories had to do what Deputy Norton did with this Government. It had to close down. When it closed down and all the employees were told that they were idle, action was taken, and it got the protection to which it was entitled. I want to know what this money is for. There is a sum of 19,000,000 dollars for wheat. A couple of million pounds was sent off last year to Formosa for sugar. A sum of £3,500,000 is being sent out of this Vote. The Cuban will get £1,200,000 more for 67,000 tons of sugar than the Irish farmer and the Irish factory worker would get for producing that amount of sugar here. That is what this Vote is for. That is what this money is wanted for. It is wanted in order to pay the foreigner for what our Irish people should be producing— and the Labour Party, of course, stand behind that.

We hear talk about Córas Iompair Éireann. The Labour Deputies know that over 70 per cent. of the total freightage carried by Córas Iompair Éireann is beet and sugar. Just take that 67,000 tons of sugar. You can fancy some 40,000 acres of beet and the employment it would give on the land. The beet would then be taken over by a lorry-owner and transported to the railway station. Just think of the freightage money that Córas Iompair Éireann would draw in respect of it and the extra couple of months' employment that it would mean for 5,000 or 6,000 men in the factories.

Last March I appealed to the then Minister for Industry and Commerce to call a conference in regard to that matter. I was not listened to. When the Formosan sugar was brought in, I appealed to the then Minister for Industry and Commerce to call a conference of representatives of his own Department, of the Department of Finance, of the Sugar Company and of the Beet Growers' Association. I appealed to him to call these four groups of people together in order to see if some method could be arrived at by which that 67,000 tons of sugar would be produced here. I was asked what inducement I thought should be offered. That was the only answer I got. It was 36,000 tons then. It is 67,000 tons now. Just consider a price of £54 12s. Od. a ton to the foreigner as compared with £37 a ton for Irish sugar leaving an Irish factory. That is what the money is for and that is the new policy of the Labour Party. We went from that to 19,000,000 dollars for the wheat. We went to the Argentine for oats, we travelled to Iraq for barley, and then, glory be to God, we would up by buying back Brian Boru's butter from the Danes.

We are told about the prosperity this Coalition Government have given to the people. I wonder where it is. I wonder what the farmers in Mayo feel now about the 2/- for a dozen of eggs after the glorious picture that was painted of 3/6 a dozen. I wonder what they think of the £20 maize which now costs £29 odd. I wonder how they like it. I wonder how the Minister fixes up his costs of production on that basis. When I heard Deputy Cowan repenting, on the stool of repentance, for the bad acts he had done, I saw the Minister writing down his name in the book. I can assure Deputy Cowan that he is going to get something. I have often seen a fairly degrading spectacle, but I have never yet seen a more degrading spectacle than that of the farmers' representatives trotting into the lobby after Deputy Cowan to vote against an increase in the price of milk to the farmers. I have never seen anything more degrading than that—and if that is the depth to which politics have sunk in this country then there is only one cure for it.

Deputy Cowan told us all about the glorious Social Security Bill. He issued his challenge because he had tacked on to the Social Security Bill —what?— 2/6 to pay the difference between the £5 a ton coal which the old age pensioner was able to buy in our time and the £10 that he has to pay for coal to-day. We all know that the aged people are fond of a cup of tea. They can get their extra cup of tea——

Comment on this

There was no cup of tea in your time.

Comment on this

——but they must pay through the nose for it. Then we see the pip-squeaks—to use the term applied by the previous Minister for Industry and Commerce to his employees—who come to the baker and demand to see his list and his ration cards to find out how much bread he has sold for fear the labourer would get one ounce of subsidised bread more than he is entitled to on the ration. If he buys on the black market he can get the stuff.

Comment on this

We doubled the old age pensions.

Comment on this

We all know what happened to the Deputy's tomatoes. A challenge was issued here to-night. We can do it. The Government wants to tie up the old age pensions and use them to say "strike me now with a child in my arms". That old game is played out for a long time. The people of this country are demanding something of us and I can assure Deputy Cowan and the rest that we will kick them out first and look after the old age pensioners then.

Comment on this

Three years ago you wanted to do that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister.

Comment on this

I do not intend to keep the House.

Comment on this

We want to get this finished. Am I not entitled to some time?

Comment on this

There is still an hour to conclude. I propose to speak on the Second Stage, with all due respects to the Minister, and I am entitled to speak.

Comment on this

There was an arrangement.

Comment on this

An arrangement that the business would be completed to-night.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

By half-past ten?

Comment on this

By half-past ten.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister should be allowed a reasonable time to reply.

Comment on this

What is a reasonable time?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not for me to say.

Comment on this

It is not for me to say either.

Comment on this

I do not propose to keep the House unduly long.

Comment on this

In the case of any agreement we made in our day the Minister was the man who broke it.

Comment on this

As long as you admit you are breaking it I do not mind.

Comment on this

An undertaking was given that the financial business would be completed this evening. It will be completed this evening.

Comment on this

With an adequate opportunity for the Minister to reply?

Comment on this

No such undertaking was given or asked for.

Comment on this

I know now why the Deputy was so plucky to-night; he knew that I could not reply.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think I am afraid of him?

Comment on this

I think so. I have seen the Deputy cowering when I was speaking and I will see him to-night.

Comment on this

There is an aspect of this matter which has not been sufficiently brought before the minds of this House and of the public with which I would like to deal for a few moments. To-night we are voting a sum of over £31,000,000 to defray the balance of the cost of the Supply Services for the year which is just ending and we are voting something less than one-third of the estimated total cost of the Supply Services for the year which will begin on the 1st April. That £31,000,000 is already, as the House has been reminded, in excess of the Budgets which Fianna Fáil introduced in the years prior to 1939 which were denounced by the present Minister for Finance, then in opposition, as extravagant and oppressive. I do not, however, propose to dilate on that aspect of the matter.

What I do want to draw to the attention of the House is that this £31,088,031 represents less than half of the £83,000,000 which the Minister for Finance anticipates we shall have to find either out of borrowing or taxation to defray the cost of the services for the coming year. I might ask, perhaps, what this £83,000,000 is required for. Judging by what we know of the mismanagement of the public concerns by the Government since it took office one might sum it all up by saying: "£83,000,000 for a policy of mess and muddle." At the beginning of 1948 they closed down upon the various schemes of national reconstruction which had been initiated by their predecessors, the Fianna Fáil Administration. I do not want to recount them now, the shutting down of mineral exploration and development and of the short-wave broadcasting station, the sabotaging of the transatlantic air service or of the Farm Improvements Fund. There are dozens of them which I could mention. I do not want to discuss them at length but it is is no harm that we should keep these in mind.

Other things have been happening, like the prices freeze Order. It is called the prices freeze Order but everybody knows that it did not freeze prices. The first public announcement of the advisory body which they set up was that it could not freeze prices, that prices were bound to increase. But it did freeze something. What it did free was business, enterprise and industry, and before this emergency passes the people of the country will blame and condemn in no uncertain fashion the Coalition which allowed itself to be led by the nose by the Tánaiste, the Minister for Social Welfare, into that sorry blunder. That is an important point and it is as well that it should be put on record.

It is equally advisable to remind the House, as Deputy Lemass has already done, that in so far as there is a coal crisis at the present moment it is largely due, or at least the aggravation of it is due, to the neglect of the Government to take steps to forestall it, the stupidity of the Government in closing its mind to the indications, and not only to the indications but to the plain public statements of people who are in a position to know what the future is likely to bring with regard to fuel, that is, that we would be facing a fuel crisis before the end of the year.

I do not want to refer to the sorry performance of the British trade agreement under which we were guaranteed to get the coal which we are not getting and bound ourselves to restrict the opportunities which present world circumstances offered to develop our export trade with the Continent.

We can leave these things aside for one minute because I want to come back to what is really the fundamental factor in this situation. We are going to spend £83,000,000. That money is being voted by the Dáil. It is conventional to say that it is being provided by the Dáil, but that, of course, is not the situation. It is being provided by the people, but we take the responsibility by our votes here for that £83,000,000, and taking that responsibility there is another responsibility which is being imposed on us, that is the responsibility of seeing that this money is properly spent and properly accounted for. If we turn to these Estimates we will not see at the head of any statement that the vote for the office of the Minister for Social Welfare, for instance, will be accounted for by the Minister for Social Welfare. Instead, we see that the Vote and the expenditure on the Vote is to be accounted for by the office of the Minister for Social Welfare, which is a very different thing. Even though it may be under the political control of the Minister, he has no power to direct expenditure and he has, in fact, only a certain indirect power, acting through the Secretary of his Department, to control his staff. It applies to every Minister in the Government.

What we have to consider is what steps we are going to take to ensure that the 20,000 public officers who are being paid out of this £83,000,000 of the people's money will do their duty and obey the rules and regulations of the service. What precautions are we going to take to ensure that this £83,000,000 will be spent by the responsible officers for the purpose for which it was provided? That is an issue which has been raised in a very acute and critical form during the past few weeks. Under the Ministers and Secretaries Acts, the man who is responsible for the general administration and conduct of the Department is the secretary of the Department; the man who is responsible for the expenditure of any money provided for the service of the Department out of any particular Vote is the accounting officer for the Department and the accounting officer for the Vote. If the position of the accounting officer is going to be undermined——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think that bringing in one case of a civil servant is——

Comment on this

I am raising the general principle. I am pointing out that, according to the first statement made by the first head, by the first permanent Secretary of the Department of Finance, made to the Public Accounts Committee, the accounting officers are responsible to this Dáil through the Public Accounts Committee.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And they have been.

Comment on this

That is so, Sir. That is the point. Every accounting officer in the State is responsible for the expenditure of his share, for that portion of this £83,000,000, which is allocated to the service of his Department. The Ministers are not responsible except in so far as they override the accounting officer and direct him to obey without accepting responsibility. If they are going to do that, they must put that direction in writing. It is a strange thing that the Government, acting as a collective authority, cannot direct any accounting officer to spend any money that he feels he is not entitled to spend in the fulfilment of his obligations to Dáil Éireann. The Minister, who is the political head of his Department and, indeed, the effective head, too, may direct that officer in writing, having said first of all that he has taken note of the officer's objections and that, notwithstanding those objections, he directs that officer to obey without responsibility and to pay the money as directed. That is the position of every accounting officer in this State.

These accounting officers, in their capacity as accounting officers, are not the servants of their Ministers but are the servants of Dáil Éireann. They are the custodians of the public moneys which we entrust to them for expenditure, and it is their duty to see that those public moneys are properly expended. The first Public Accounts Committee, which was set up here to deal with the public accounts of 1922-23, made the position of accounting officers clear beyond any doubt. They said this—and it will be found in paragraph 9 of their first report:—

"A serious personal responsibility attaches to them if they fail in this respect, for if a post factum application to that Department——"

the Department of Finance

"——does not disclose any grounds justifying the expenditure, the responsibility is likely to come back to that individual."

In the year 1927, the third Public Accounts Committee—which had been set up to consider the report of the Comptroller and Auditor-General for the year 1925-26—disallowed a payment of some thousands of pounds which the then Minister for Finance had directed his accounting officer to make. The then Minister for Finance, I am happy to say, acted strictly in accordance with the regulations that had been laid down. He did not go off and try to get the Government to carry his responsibility. He issued a minute to his accounting officer directing him—let me remind the House of the phrase—directing him to obey without responsibility. The accounting officer, in discharge of his duty and in fulfilment of the obligations imposed on him by the rules for accounting officers, sent the papers to the Comptroller and Auditor-General. In due course, the Comptroller and Auditor-General reported upon this matter to the Public Accounts Committee, stating that he had been directed by the Minister to make this payment—the Minister did not deny it—and what happened? The Public Accounts Committee disallowed that payment, even though it had been personally directed by the Minister for Finance, and in order to clear himself and secure parliamentary indemnity for the breach, for going outside the ambit of the Vote, the Minister, Mr. Blythe, had to come to this House and present a Supplementary Estimate and ask the House to give him the some thousands of pounds necessary, in order that he might be relieved of the responsibility of making good to the Central Fund the payment which he had wrongfully directed.

It is upon that principle that the whole of our public accounting system is based, the personal responsibility of the accounting officer for every penny that is spent from his Vote. In so far as anything is done by any Minister or by any Government which will weaken that principle, which will tend to undermine the responsibility of the accounting officer or indeed weaken the control over his staff, or tend to destroy discipline in the Civil Service, we are bringing this State down to the ground, we are reducing, and we tend to reduce the control over public finances, and it will not be very long until we reduce the whole administrative machine to chaos. I want to raise this issue because I believe it has been very seriously attacked in recent days. It is not the last we are going to hear of it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy stated that he was dealing with a general matter, not a particular case.

Comment on this

This issue has been raised and it will have to be faced in Dáil Éireann when we resume after the Recess.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee has joined groups of people who are out to do two damaging things to this country. He joined with those who are trying to give industrialists and traders every encouragement not to do the stockpiling that their business instincts would make them do and their national instincts would certainly drive them to do in a much more intense way. He also joined with a group of people who are encouraging, as fast as may be, traders to charge prices which they are not entitled to. That championship has disgusted quite a number of decent traders and industrialists and, in fact, even those who are not so decent and not so honest are getting ashamed of the open sabotage which is being done to the knowledge of these two classes. However, these people may well live to rue the day when they listened to irresponsible comment of the type to which Deputy MacEntee has given forth. He has made a long-winded effort which I do not think has done him any good.

The Deputy spoke again from the same polluted source of the muddy waters in which he has been splashing and disporting himself for some weeks past in the hope that he may be able to spatter a bit of the mud away from himself. The Deputy, if he is interested in the matter discussed through a series of questions, ought to accept the definite challenge made to him by the Taoiseach, that if the Opposition want a day to discuss that unfortunate civil servant, who I am sure is now rueing the day that he behaved in such an uncritical fashion, they can get it.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee was refused permission to discuss a particular case.

Comment on this

The Opposition were offered a day if they wanted to put down a motion, but they have not asked for it.

Comment on this

We will have plenty of days.

Comment on this

They are going to ask for it if Deputy MacEntee can work his leader up to giving him a full day's exhibitionism in this House. I hope if he gets this day the Deputy will tell us how long it is since he resumed friendship with that gentleman.

Comment on this

I never have been anything but a friend. I am glad to be able to say that I can consort with him rather than with some of the people around the Minister.

Comment on this

Your choice is a good one because you have very few to consort with. I hope the Deputy will not forget that when he was at the Custom House he had that same gentleman under orders of dismissal for a breach of orders.

Comment on this

That statement has been repeated on several occasions. I never had any reason to tell the gentlemen referred to that I proposed to have him dismissed. If I had told him that, I would have done it, and I would have done it with good cause. I would not have done it at the behest of Deputy Dunne out of spite and vindictiveness.

Comment on this

When that gentleman occupied a position in the County Dublin as a commissioner he had to be brought down to the Custom House under sealed orders and the next morning walked the plank. That was the order. That is the gentleman who is now such a permanent friend of the Deputy.

Comment on this

I was with him before 1921 and I have been with him since.

Comment on this

I am sure you have.

Comment on this

His wife seems to have a good opinion of the Deputy.

Comment on this

That is more than most wives have of you.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry spoke of degrading spectacles. He is a good judge of degrading spectacles and if he develops the habit of introspection he has he will be a better one. I cannot follow his hallucination with regard to the price of what was left in the Phoenix Park masquerading as fuel left to us. There was a debt of over £4,000,000 still to be paid by the citizens on account of what Deputy Corry, apparently, is under a grave hallucination as to what happened.

Comment on this

You charged £9 a ton for it.

Comment on this

Even at that it did not pay the cost of bringing it here or the cost of the commission which some people got for bringing it here.

Comment on this

Is that an insinuation against some people?

Comment on this

There were commissions paid.

Comment on this

To traders.

Comment on this

To traders who were always in the business?

Comment on this

Yes, and nobody else.

Comment on this

I want to direct attention to Deputy Lemass' speech and to ask the House to remember the arrogance of the last phrase, after the Deputy had travelled in bullying fashion over several matters, that his speech was the appropriate type of speech to make and not one about the pettifogging little political things spoken of by others. The Deputy always had a good conceit of himself. He showed himself in his appropriate mood to-night. I want people to recollect the hoarse anger, the vigour, the contempt for everybody, the criticism of everybody who went before him. That was the mood. Add that mood to this, that he was annoyed at its being revealed that he left behind him his plan to freeze wages, making it a criminal offence for any employer to give an increase in wages. He was, of course, going to take in the rise in profits, but only on a selective basis. He would choose for it industrialists who had not obeyed orders about fixing prices according to a profit margin. He would pick them and there might be an appeal for his victims to a certain body and they would be a very select group, selected as much for their political opinions as anything else. When these people were picked, they had a right to appeal to a certain body which the Deputy would set up, but the one thing he insisted upon was that there would be no right of appeal to the courts.

Deputy Cowan is perfectly right. There was in process of making here, by a group of people who forced themselves to the conviction that they were impregnable in office, before the election at which they were defeated, the tightest little tyranny ever fastened on any democratic country. Wages frozen, profits to be taken from the people who had earned the displeasure of Ministers, and then the austerity programme that Deputy Cowan spoke of. In addition to that, in 1947, Deputy de Valera told us: "As for emigration, we cannot stop it. There is a tendency there and it will probably go on to the end of the world. There is a tendency all over the world to drift from the rural areas to the towns and we cannot stop that, either. As far as agriculture is concerned, if any of you people are in a position to give us a plan, we will accept that plan and try to work it." That was the desolation that people were faced with. There was certainly no enterprise in borrowing or spending for the good of the people in that—there was just taxation.

Then we had Deputy Childers coming in here and speaking like somebody you would hear on the Third Programme of the B.B.C. He told us that there was nothing wrong about taxing beer or smokes, that that is something which ought to be considered in conjunction with vast schemes of Government policy. The vast schemes are revealed to be—even announced tonight—transatlantic planes and a short-wave broadcasting station, but, always left out by Deputy Lemass, the grand, magnificent £11,500,000 building for civil servants, a new Parliament House, by the destruction of a considerable part of Merrion Square.

Deputy Lemass seems angered and worked up over what the Tánaiste did with regard to old age pensions and offers this: bring in a single phrase Bill and I will get the House to pass it immediately. Is not that the offer? Yet on the 22nd October, 1947, as Deputy Davin reminded him, when there was not £1,000,000 in the kitty for the old age pensioners but some £500,000, the Deputy and his Party flocked into the lobbies against the proposal made then on the grounds that they could not afford it, and the phrase was used that if they had £500,000 they could afford they would put it to better uses than giving it to old age pensioners. The Deputy is angered by the fact that the old age pensioners will get more money.

I have here an excerpt from two of our morning newspapers the Saturday after the announcement was made. I have the Irish Press saying: “Below in tabular form are the Fianna Fáil proposals for social welfare as outlined by Dr. Ryan.” The Irish Independent put it more honestly: “Fianna Fáil offices last night issued the following announcement showing their proposals.” Lo and behold! there was, of course, in that tabular statement something for old age pensions and something about a means test. They had forgotten that they had circulated part of their proposals before that Friday morning and there was a bit of a scurry that morning to get their proposals back so that they could include in them something for old age pensions. It is there now, and the amusing thing is that, according to the Deputies on the Opposition Benches, it was at one time a bribe on this side of the House, but now, because Deputy Lemass backs it, it is honest politics.

There was a time when I used to amuse myself reading the mythological stories of ancient Ireland and the heroes of long ago. It was interesting to read about the heroes of that heroic period; before they went into battle they used to suffer all manner of bodily contortions in order to work up their enthusiasm for the fight. Deputy Lemass was in that mood to-night The only difference is that mythological heroes were of heroic stature: there is nothing more undignified than the spectacle of a small man in a rage when the rage is such that the small man is unable to contain it. That was the spectacle Deputy Lemass presented here to-night.

Deputy Lemass told us during the course of the debate on the Vote on Account that lawyers were an essentially stupid tribe, outside of their court work. But lawyers have occasionally been hired by business men, and even by politicians, to get them out of trouble when they find themselves in the courts.

Comment on this

We were not in the trouble.

Comment on this

I think there was one man who was. In any event, the Deputy has quite definitely said that lawyers are stupid. From what eminence does the Deputy speak? If the Deputy were remarkable in this country for his performance in the arts, in science or in the humanities, or, indeed, in anything, one might see some excuse for him. For three years back as far as politics are concerned this House has been entertained more often by records of the Deputy's failures rather than of his successes.

The Deputy was in business at one time. Possibly he may tell he has a business stature. There is one business which will be remembered as long as people's memories last. I believe to-day when business men meet around the town they sometimes toast Deputy Lemass and the way he handled the Argentine dictator, Péron. Does the House remember the way he did it? Péron had wheat that had been mouldering over the autumn and through the winter. Deputy Lemass was looking for wheat. Péron raised the price of it. It came to the close of the Deputy's period in office and the Deputy conceived a plan; it was overwhelming in its simplicity, and I think "simplicity" is the operative word. He would offer Péron his price. He did so, and he paid him £50 a ton, the price that Péron asked. It was the worst bargain ever made in the history of this country and, if the Deputy wants to found his reputation on that, I think he should get his reputation established publicily on that transaction.

Comment on this

We paid the same price as everyone else paid. The price was controlled.

Comment on this

It could have been bought much cheaper earlier but, as the stuff went bad, the price went up. The Deputy thinks that price control is difficult and he thinks that the one thing necessary is that it should be done before the public. What are we doing? The Prices Tribunal sits in public. The great trouble the Deputy is in with some of his supporters is that they do not like to appear before a public tribunal and the clamour that the Opposition Deputies set up is that it is a scandal that people should have their business discussed in public or have the group profits disclosed in public. We want public confidences. That was the reason put forward by the Tánaiste in his speech when he spoke in support of the establishment of this tribunal. He said that we must make the public conscious so that, if prices had to go up, at least the people would know the reason for the inevitable increase and would no longer continue to exist in the state of confusion in which they were left in the past, a state in which people crawled around to the Deputy's Department and came out with the results of the machinery of price control working there which gave them unheard of profits.

Comment on this

But we answered here.

Comment on this

The answer was made for nothing that happened. In any event do not forget that Deputy Lemass says price control is ineffective. What has been the clamour since the Prices Advisory Body was set up? That there is no necessity for a new tribunal because there was most effective machinery for controlling prices already in existence.

Comment on this

If it was allowed to work.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy allow it to work?

Comment on this

You decontrolled.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that price control was ineffective. The corollary then is that either he did not work it in his time or it was not effective.

Comment on this

But you decontrolled.

Comment on this

I have examined the method. The manufacturer got a price fixed and then on to that was put a percentage which the wholesaler would charge; the goods went to the wholesaler and, after that, there was a retail percentage fixed and, after that, the goods were marketed. I asked one day what happened where a wholesaler did not exist and I was told: "Oh, you stick it on to the retail price."

Comment on this

What is the system now?

Comment on this

We are definitely getting away from that.

Comment on this

It is exactly the same price.

Comment on this

The wholesale price was allowed where there was no wholesaler. That was the system. As a stupid member of the Bar, I was once asked to advise certain people going before the Department to get a price fixed. I looked at the papers. I was just about to write on them when the papers were collected from me. I asked what had happened. I was told that it was all over as far as I was concerned. I was anxious to find out what happened. I was told that another group of people were asking for a certain percentage of profit. They went into the Department of Industry and Commerce where they were interviewed by one of the Deputy's staff, who told them they could not get more.

Comment on this

You mean one of the officials of the Department.

Comment on this

One of the officials, who told them they could not get more than the profit suggested. But the profit suggested was more than they were looking for.

Comment on this

That did not happen.

Comment on this

That is the story told to me.

Comment on this

The same official is in charge of the prices branch as was in charge in my time.

Comment on this

There was never effective control.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I said.

Comment on this

The only way to have effective control is to get the people to appear publicly and get their profits disclosed and, if necessary, get the individual profits disclosed in secrecy.

Comment on this

What about the university professors' salaries then? You will not tell us about that.

Comment on this

I will tell the Deputy anything he likes. He can go out and link arms with Deputy MacEntee and be quite happy in doing all the dirty work he wants to do. I take it he is annoyed because I am not giving him some attention. Deputy Aiken spoke here about "passing the buck". He applied the phrase to borrowing. I suppose it can be applied to borrowing; anybody who borrows can be said to be "passing the buck". The Deputies passed the buck in their time; there was a lot of borrowing. Where is the good in using a meaningless phrase like that? The Deputy should really address himself to our programme.

We have told him what we intend to spend. We have told him the projects on which we intend to spend the money. We have told him what our objectives are. We have asked the Deputies to challenge them if they did not consider them proper for investment purposes. We waited here through all the long and weary days of the Financial Resolutions and the Finance Bill. Did anybody object to the programme we had laid down? We came to the present year then and all that Deputy Lemass could say in relation to the present Book of Estimates was that there were some flipperies with which he could quarrel, but that when it came to the borrowing programme there was nothing to which he could take exception. The only peculiar thing was that he used the very peculiar expression that one should not borrow for investment purposes. Now that is where we part company. We think our projects are good borrowing projects. We think we are borrowing quite properly for them. Deputy Aiken said on one occasion that costs had been increased by reason of inflation because of all the extra money poured out. Later on he said that costs had not risen and that, if they had, it was only by a few points, and he suggested that few points was due to the impact of the Korean war, and the stockpiling which has taken place since.

Deputy Aiken did see the gap which Deputy Lemass, apparently, did not see. Deputy Aiken says that as long as the ports are open you will get in the goods; you will never have the type of inflation of having too much money chasing too few goods. I deplore the rate at which some of the goods are coming in, but will Deputies put up their alternative proposals? Deputy Lemass wants physical controls in order to stop goods coming in. But then we will have the classic type of inflation—too much money chasing too few goods.

Deputy Lemass would have us going back to the good old days of beer and tobacco and a lot of other taxation, and you are taking the money out of the people's hands so that they will not have to spend it. Deputy Aiken on several occasions said that assets are down by £100,000,000. Some of these days Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Aiken will be coming in arm-in-arm, but they will realise that we have sounder ideas in relation to economics. Deputy Lemass was rather anguished. He spends sleepless nights thinking of what he would do if only he had 40 millions of American money.

Deputy Aiken thinks we have spent it and it is a debt; he thinks it is gone. There seems to be some lack of cohesion between whoever it is who co-ordinates the efforts of the Opposition. There used to be a single mind, but now there are as many minds as there are individuals, now that they are in Opposition. Deputy Aiken finally came to the point of believing that having a bit in reserve was a great thing. He was challenged about the reserve and he was asked was it better to spend it at home or leave your money in fast-declining securities abroad. The only way to get over the difficulty, in his opinion, was to have a good bit in reserve and not spend your money on a spree. Now, it is interesting to observe Deputy Aiken's attitude and Deputy Lemass's attitude in relation to this matter.

According to Deputy Aiken, money is being spent on a spree. There is only one peculiarity over a spree. A spree generally causes a headache. This has certainly caused a headache, but not to the people who are on the spree.

Deputy Childers speaks like a B.B.C. Third Programme. Some of these days he, too, will get to know something about this country. The last Government gave Deputy Childers a naturalisation certificate, but there was some ambiguity about it; they failed to make him a naturalised Irishman. He has no conception of what this country needs.

Comment on this

Having murdered his father.

Comment on this

And he has a much less conception even of what this country objects to. He passes over in an airy way the idea of anybody being aggravated over smokes—over tobacco or beer. He thought we had reached the lowest depths of politics in a parliamentary assembly where actual play was made with taxation which affected smoking and drinking. Even if the Deputy wanders up and down the Irish countryside, he has not yet got himself attuned to Irish conditions. If that is the type of mind he has, and if that is at the background of Fianna Fáil, I wish them luck with him and I hope he will long remain something of a leader amongst them.

Comment on this

Why did you murder his father?

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan is licking his chops.

Comment on this

The last Government came to the end of its tether in 1947. They did not know where they stood with regard to emigration or unemployment. They told us, with regard to our main industry, agriculture: "Give us any plan you have and we will try to operate it". And the background of it all was Deputy Lemass's preparations for a wage freeze and a selective attack on people making unreasonable profits. If it was not for the people's anger over what Deputy Childers thinks is inconsequential, they could have forced that programme home.

Comment on this

The programme had been abandoned long before that. Price control legislation ended when war ended. The wage freeze ended in 1946.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

According to the Deputy, the new programme ended when he met the trade unions before the election, in 1947 or early in 1948. It was a thought in the Deputy's mind up to that point. Is not that so—up to November, 1947?

Comment on this

The Trade Union Congresses met and agreed——

Comment on this

There was no agreement.

Comment on this

The records do not disclose any agreement. There was no agreement.

Comment on this

The final discussion was after the election and they agreed that——

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass was drifting around Government Buildings, keeping in touch with the parliamentary draftsman. He was up and down and he had a scheme. Suggestions were made by his colleagues. There was no overpowering argument that he should drop it, but there were suggestions for changes. And all this is on the file in the Deputy's handwriting. He wanted this new plan hurriedly drawn up in the parliamentary drafts-man's office because he wanted it as a weapon when he met the trade unions. Is not that right?

Comment on this

It is also true that the Taoiseach had informed the Dáil that the alternative to agreement was legislation.

Comment on this

He wanted a scheme bearing on the taking away of the protection of the Trade Disputes Act.

Comment on this

Do not ask any questions if you do not want answers.

Comment on this

I am speaking out of my own knowledge from the files. The Deputy did want this weapon against his meeting with the trade unions. He wanted to have against the two Trade Union Congresses this weapon, with this in mind: "If you do not agree, I have something in store for you." And here it is. No increased wage beyond what was there in mid-October, 1947, beyond that related to the cost-of-living new figure, and if any employer gave more than that it would be a crime——

Comment on this

Or did not give the increase proposed—do not forget that.

Comment on this

If any employee struck to get more than that, then that employee was going to have removed from him the protection of the Trade Disputes Act. If that scheme had gone through it would unquestionably have brought the industrial activities of this country back to pre-Napoleonic days, back to the period when labourers could not combine in order to get themselves betterment in their industrial occupations. Conditions of that description existed in those days, but by degrees civilisation progressed and one reformer after another came along and you got this thing gradually built up and ulitmately you had the protection of the Trade Disputes Act under which any of the people who were looking for improved conditions or extra wages could engage in a proper wage dispute and have an opportunity of making their case.

But what was it the Deputy wanted? If he did not get the agreement he wanted to get back to the conditions that prevailed in pre-Napoleonic times. And if he got his agreement, could he boast that the conditions would be such that people could hammer matters out and arrive at some satisfactory conclusion? No, it was not anything of the kind. It was the biggest piece of coercion ever known in this country for years, and the whole thing comes to this, that there was in the process of manufacture in this country at that time the tightest little tyranny that was ever contemplated by any group of people.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This Bill is a Money Bill within the meaning of Article 22 of the Constitution. Seanad Éireann will be informed accordingly.

Comment on this