Social Welfare (Insurance) (No. 2) Bill, 1950—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–210 of 398. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 39 of 1950 ›
I have one deep regret in this matter and it is that Deputy Flynn has given notice of his intention to withdraw his amendment. I am sorry to see him leave the House now, because I should like to put a few figures before him. There are in Deputy Flynn's constituency in Kerry some 21,000 farmers, if we can call them farmers, living on less than 30 acres per family. The Deputy's amendment says that no provision is made in the Bill for the payment of benefits to small farmers and casual workers who are not included in the Bill as at present constituted. I wonder whether Deputy Flynn considers that the 2/6 promised to the old age pensioners in Kerry, and which he knows as well as I know can be screwed out of the Minister whether this Bill passes or not, is a full justification for throwing overboard these 21,000 farmers who live on less than 30 acres per family in County Kerry. Is the Deputy prepared to do that? That is a question which I should like the Deputy to ask himself before he walks into the Lobby. The total income per family of these men would not be £3 a week and Deputy Flynn knows that as well as I know it.
We have heard talk about the workers. Any one of these 21,000 men —we have altogether over 250,000— living on holdings of less than 30 acres will do more work in one week than any of the so-called workers who are to benefit under the Bill would do in their whole lifetime. There is a wide difference between the man endeavouring to rear a family on the ten to 30-acre holding in this country, as a worker, and the gentleman who dishes out tickets in some trade union office and who is called a worker, and there is a wide difference between the amount coming into the household of each of these men's families in any one week and the amount coming into the household of the other man. The man in the Transport Union offices in Cork does not expend much sweat dishing out members' tickets every week and I can guarantee to Deputy Hickey that the "bucko" dishing out these tickets will knock down three times as much as any of the men who are completely knocked out of this Bill and have no benefit whatever to gain by it will get.
These men have no means of increasing their income. If any one of these trade union gentlemen finds that the cost of living has gone up, he immediately puts in his demand to his employer for an increase and he gets it, or knows the reason why, but if these farmers come even to their representatives here and appeal to them, they will find marching into the Lobby against them, to prevent them getting the increase in the price of their agricultural produce to which they are entitled, not alone the Labour Party en masse but the so-called representatives of the farmers over there. They are the same people who are now prepared, on this second occasion, for the sake of the fruits of office, to throw overboard and sell out the unfortunate people whom they pretend to represent.
An attack was made here last night on Deputy Dr. Ryan, particularly by Deputy O'Leary who is from the same constituency, in connection with the insurance company of which Dr. Ryan is a director. I can promise Deputy O'Leary that whenever he lifted the thimble off any of Deputy Dr. Ryan's insurance bills, the pea was there. If the pea was found very often under Deputy O'Leary's thimble, he would not be here at all.
I am not prepared at any time, for any Party, to vote for any Bill that will put on one side 500,000 of our people. The total number occupied in any manner in this country is 1,300,000 and that includes even the three-cardtrick man. Of that number, 503,000 are farmers, their wives, their sons and daughters over 14 years of age, working on the land; 358,000 of that 500,000 are working on holdings under 50 acres and, under this Bill, they are to be cut out completely from any benefits whatever but they are to have the pleasure of paying so that others may benefit. The unfortunate fellow who has 15 acres of Kerry bog will wake up on Monday morning and find that when he wants his little plug of tobacco for the week there will be an extra bit on it. To pay for what? We are told by the Minister for Social Services that there will be £4,500,000 taxation in the first year. That has to be paid for by this unfortunate fellow. When he buys his ounce of tobacco, he has to pay his share of that £4,000,000 odd. When he buys an ounce of tea or a grain of sugar for his children he will have to pay for it and, if he ever succeeds in getting together the price of a pint, he will have to pay for it in that also. Who will he benefit? Under this Bill, Sir, the general manager of Córas Iompair Éireann will have to pay 3/6 a week out of the public purse. We all know that Córas Iompair Eireann are bankrupt and that we have to find the money for them. When you have men such as Deputy Davin as chief officers, it is no wonder they are bankrupt. The taxpayer will have to pay 3/6 for Deputy Davin. We should be quite clear on that.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Davin deny that that is so? A Deputy tells me that he has retired. Thank God. I withdraw completely as that is the case. However, the present general manager of Córas Iompair Éireann comes under this Bill and the unfortunate devil that I have described, with an income of less than £3 a week, with 15 acres of Kerry bog, who is trying to drag out a livelihood, trying to support his children and trying to put boots on them to send them to school, will have to pay his share of the £4,000,000 odd that is to help to give an extra pension, along with all the other pensions he will get, to the general manager of Córas Iompair Éireann and to every bank manager. When there is so much shouting about the workers, let us examine who will benefit. Take the ordinary worker who, year after year, has had deductions from his wages for the purpose of a fund out of which he will get sickness benefit and a pension at the end of his period of employment. Now he will be asked to pay, in addition to his present contribution, a further 3/6 a week.
Comment on this
I know I am getting under the hide of these well-fed, fine looking gentlemen, with their fine soft hands that have no blisters or cuts on them, who represent the workers in this House.
Comment on this
It is a most dignified debate. It is time somebody told you where you got off—you people who come in here pretending to represent the worker and maligning the ordinary worker. Look at this beauty who is getting up now.
Comment on this
Very well, and you keep your children quiet. Take the poor old country blacksmith, who is a good, hard worker, who did his part in his parish for his people. Where is he now? What will Deputy MacEoin and Deputy McGrath do for their class here? The country blacksmith is completely cut out under this Bill. Of course, he could not be recognised by the Minister for Social Services. What has the ordinary country blacksmith to do with the collar and tie gentlemen in the Post Office? Take the case of the country carpenter, who carries out all the local repairs. What is his position under this Bill? He is also cut out. Take the country shoemaker. I said to the local shoemaker: "You are all right now that you have the Social Insurance Bill." He replied: "I do not benefit under that at all. That is for the bank managers." They have taken the people that I have referred to out of it but these people will have to pay. For whom? Where do the people in Deputy Seán Collins' constituency, who live along the Beara Peninsula, come under this Bill? Are they expected to pay £4,000,000 odd a year so that men who are at present earning £6 10s. to £12 a week may benefit? There is no trade unionist earning less than that now.
Comment on this
I will deal with the farm labourer in a minute. He has been my baby a long time before I ever heard of Deputy Dunne and he was always well looked after by me. You will find that when you come down my way. You will be welcome any time you come but I think you will go back much wiser than you came. You will not be dealing with the "haw-haw" farmers around Dublin when you come down my way. Where do these unfortunate men, the fishermen about whom Deputy Collins expresses so many regrets from time to time, come under this comprehensive Social Security Bill? The poor old carpenter, the ordinary job carpenter, who goes around to the country making a cart, a butt or a pair of wheels and who is classed as what is known as self-employed, does not come under it. The blacksmith who puts shoes on the old horses, the ordinary mason who goes around building sheds, does not come under it. All these, the whole lot of them, are cut off. The only class who benefit by this are certain types of collar-and-tie labour.
We hear a lot about the fellow in the attic. I think the fellow in the attic is pretty well provided for at the present day. Houses are being provided for them at the expense of others. I was inside an ordinary labourer's cottage recently and there were two men in that house earning. That cottage was let at a rent of 1/- a week, plus rates, and these two men had between them an income of £14 or £15 a week.
Comment on this
The poor devil whom Deputy O'Sullivan left below in the 15 acres of bog in Kerry will pay for them. These are the classes who are cut out of this Bill. If you take all the people who are supposed to be self-employed in the first instance, take the 500,000 farmers and the relatives in the second instance and then every little shopkeeper and every man who happens to be an employer out of this 1,300,000, what have you left? Whom will this Bill benefit? There is very little use in Deputy Dunne referring to the agricultural labourer. He has gone, gone like the wind. No man would be idiot enough at the present day to work for £3 per week while he can get anything from £5 to £10 for doing nothing. These fellows are gone. You can see that by the fact that we had to buy Brian Boru's butter the other day. These classes are finished and, judging by the attitude of this House, there is now a sinister determination to finish off the last productive class in the community—the class producing the bread, butter, milk and sugar for the drones, producing these commodities at a wage, roughly, of £3 per week. The price of milk at the present day would allow of a wage of only 33/- a week for a labourer, yet Labour, led by the nose, went into the Lobby to vote that that price should not be increased.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the sections of the community who are kept outside the provisions of this Bill.
Comment on this
I do not want to hear it again. The Deputy will deal with the measure before the House.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Would it be in order to move the adjournment of the debate to give the Deputy an opportunity of reading what is in the Bill?
Comment on this
The Deputy read the Bill more often than Deputy Davin and probably read it a lot more intelligently.
Comment on this
I had not the particular job that Deputy Davin and others had of going round from Deputy to Deputy in this House saying: "What will we put into the Bill that will get your vote"? I had not that job. We had a glaring instance of the result of that here last night in the withdrawal of the amendment by Deputy Flynn. We wonder why.
Comment on this
These are the objections I have to this Bill. I am not at any time prepared to support legislation introduced here to crucify the hardest workers and the poorest paid section of the community to-day, and that is what this Bill is doing.
Comment on this
I think possibly it would have been better if Deputy Corry's contribution to this debate had never been made because we are coming to grips with a problem that will have to be tackled objectively on its merits. We have got to decide first and foremost whether we accept the principle that social service is necessary, and I think on that there is complete unanimity on all sides of the House. It is true that some moralists and theologians, acting and talking for themselves alone, and in many cases actuated by a deliberate bias that excluded from consideration the merits of any problem, have made far from worthy contributions to the general atmosphere that was built up round this piece of legislation before it was actually introduced. I come here to analyse, as best I can, what I feel should be the rational approach to the whole problem.
I think it is a common adjunct to the modern conception of the duty of a democratic State that there must be provision to help certain sections of the community, particularly the aged, the blind, the widows or those who are suffering from temporary difficulties owing to sickness. Now, there is a furore about this Bill. Most of it, of course, has a political background. Has anybody sat down and realised yet what this Bill really is? Its purpose is the co-ordination of a tremendous number of services already in existence, bringing out of a chaotic complex system of confusing Acts one solid workable Act to cover old age pension schemes, national health, unemployment benefit and unemployment assistance. But as well as doing that it is adding some new benefits. Let us examine these for what they are worth. Is there any Deputy who is not consious of the necessity for improved maternity benefits, and for the introduction of mortality benefits? Nobody is going to deny the Christian basis for giving better grants towards the mother in the period immediately prior to and subsequent to the birth of the child.
Is there anybody in this House who, in conscience, can object to the removal of the dread spectre which obsesses so many people during their lives that, in the end, they may find a pauper's grave?
These two principles are the main new departures in this Bill outside of what is already in existence. We had the extraordinary speech of Deputy Corry which dealt with everything but what is in the Bill. He talked about the agricultural community, which both he and I have the honour to represent, as if it were a down-trodden, brow-beaten, suffering community. Unquestionably, the agricultural community is enjoying more prosperity to-day than it has ever known in living memory. It is true that the Bill may not be as wide as some of us would like. What we have to consider on the Second Reading Stage is the broad principle of the Bill. There will be a later stage when the combined intelligent and constructive opinion of the House can be brought to bear on the Minister if we feel there are ways in which the Bill can be improved. But, surely, on this stage we have to face the simple issue whether, in fact, there is the onus placed on the State of accepting the responsibility of looking after certain sections of the community who are ill-fitted to look after themselves, and whether or not it is a good principle, a principle which is based on a contribution basis, to ensure that any person to whom this Bill applies, having given a reasonable lifetime of service to the benefit and advancement of this nation, may not, on reaching a certain age, be assured, at least of this, that he will not be cast aside on the waves of charity.
It is true that there are many people to whom this Bill will not apply. Some of them were referred to by Deputy Corry—blacksmiths, travelling carpenters and various self-employed people. I am quite certain that these people will not be in the least bit grateful to Deputy Corry for his contribution to this debate. It is true that it might be possible to press for their inclusion, but if one looks at the scheme which is being operated in England one will find that the contribution of a self-employed person would be practically twice that which is being asked on the highest scale from anybody in this Bill. Nobody is going to suggest to me that either a journeyman carpenter or a blacksmith in the country is anything like the poor down-trodden individual painted for us by Deputy Corry. These men are doing extremely well in my area. In the country, it is extremely hard to get one of these journeymen carpenters or a journeyman handyman to do an odd job of reconstruction or repair about a farmer's place. I do not want to approach this Bill on any basis other than that of analysing what is the duty of the State towards those members of the community who have worked for a weekly wage over a long period of years in the service of the State when they retire. I want to analyse how far our responsibility goes to those people. Fianna Fáil say that they want social services, that they want bigger and wider social services, but they got a woeful belly ache on the morning the Minister came to the Dáil——
Comment on this
——to make his announcement in connection with the long delayed and long merited increases for old age pensioners, widows and orphans. Since then, Deputy Lemass, on the one hand, and Deputy Dr. Ryan on the other, with occasional bleatings and conflicting opinions from their back benchers, have been trying to mend their hand. They now do not know where they are because their social service idea is like the alleged blue-prints of the scheme which Deputy Dr. Ryan meant to have left behind him in the Department of Social Welfare, but which could not be found. We are here, elected representatives of the people, to deliberate upon a measure which is going to bring benefit to sections of the community that I hope to prove merit our favourable consideration. It is common case that we have a responsibility to the old age pensioners who can no longer work and who are not in a position to support themselves. It is common case that we owe a duty to the family who may have lost their bread-winner in tragic circumstances. We owe it to the widows and to the orphans. Nobody will quarrel with the fact that we owe a duty to the blind. Nobody in this House will have the courage to stand up and quarrel with the fact that we are going to improve conditions for the expectant mother. I do not think anybody in this House is going to quarrel with the fact that we are going to make available to people a certain grant to ensure that when their last remains go to their place of burial they will go at least with a reasonable respect and with the reasonable equipage that we associate with the burial of our dead in this country. What are we quarrelling about here? The quarrel at times seems to be that Labour is swallowing Fine Gael. The next quarrel is: "Oh, if Fianna Fáil were there we would have given you a better one." You were here too long and we got none.
Comment on this
That is not true. We increased the old age pension and we provided children's allowances, in addition to doing other things. We will tell you all about it.
Comment on this
The position is that we in this House, as the custodians of authority in this country, as the people who put Governments into office, owe a duty to the people we serve. I think this Bill shows a courageous advance towards the acceptance of responsibility that must ultimately be that of the nation to people who, through years of toil and sweat, have helped in the development not only of the economy of the country but who have helped in the full development of the nation in the broader sense. A coordinating Bill, giving further and additional benefits in certain recognised and accepted worthy cases, has caused this mighty furore. Why did the Deputies representing the farming community not come in here and tell the truth? There is one tremendous advance in this Bill that the Opposition seem to be deliberately ignoring— possibly wilfully shelving. With this Bill goes one shocking iniquity that oppressed us in rural Ireland for too long. I refer to that iniquitous system that prevented the old man or the old woman from transferring their holdings to the young and getting their pension, unless the young man in the place was married.
Comment on this
You must not have read the Bill, a chara. That is an iniquity, the removal of which is long overdue. It is true that it would be hard to find a scheme which could be broad enough to include small farmers. Undoubtedly, however, an effort is made in this Bill—and I am inviting my friends on the other side of the House to come forward with a constructive and intelligent scheme to include these people and we will analyse it in this House. We can only suggest at the moment that they can band together in the co-operative union through which they can become members of this particular scheme. If you have something better in this wonderful, unfound and unfindable scheme of Fianna Fáil's to put before this country and this House for its consideration, now is the hour. It has not come so far.
Comment on this
If one calls the diverse views of the ex-Tánaiste and the ex-Minister for Social Welfare a constructive plan, I do not.
Comment on this
It is best to forget him. It is true that there are defects in the way of making the scheme apply in an over-all way to the community. The thing that irks and annoys me about this complete measure is that while the basis of it is common case and while the principle is admitted, instead of getting together here as reasonable intelligent people to try and improve still further and enlarge the scheme, we come in here as a group of petty little schoolboys jibbing and gibing at each other. Immense charges have had to be met in this State up to now to enable us to discharge our obligations to certain sections of the community. We accept and the House unanimously accepts that principle. Why have we bickering and childishness on the Second Stage of the Bill when we should be getting the Second Stage through and getting the House, together with its collective intelligence, to try and make this Bill, the principle of which is accepted, a better Bill for the country in general? I think that we would be doing infinitely more service to the nation if we were to do that.
On what basis can one object to a scheme which is based on a three-way contribution—one part by the person to benefit, another part by his employer and the third part by the State? If the man is self-employed it would straight away present the difficulty that his contribution to the scheme would have to be twice that of the man who is employed. It is true that it is the aim of all individual industries to try and get some pension scheme for their employees. That is a principle that is growing more and more rapidly in our modern State. What quarrel should these people have if they are asked to fit into a national plan and if they want, above the general national plan, to make special provision, extra to that, for their employees? There is nothing in this Bill which will stop them from doing it. But is it immoral, as was suggested by some people purporting to be theological experts, to try and fix a minimum standard that is going to be something above the horrible and miserable subsistence level that some of the most necessitous classes in this country have had to face in the years gone by?
Is there something wrong, something indecent or something improper in trying to make the future a little bit brighter than the very dull past? Mind you, I am not afraid to go down to West Cork and answer the questions I will be asked on this Bill because I believe that we are bound in duty to do as much as we possibly can for the necessitous classes. If a practical and reasonable way can be found of including small farmers and their sons in the social services, I feel sure that we will get an opportunity of enlarging those services or of introducing new legislation. I have been trying to get a solution for the problem myself; I am not enamoured of a Bill that cannot be more general in its sweep, but I say squarely and honestly that this Bill is stepping out in the right direction and I will step with it. If not in the year or two before us, I hope that with a proper approach to the question, we may find unanimity and commonsense to meet a problem which at present is being put into the field of petty politics. This is a bigger problem than politics. God knows, none of us knows when the boot may be on the other foot. We do not know when we or ours may find ourselves through no fault of our own forced to make use of either the sickness or old age benefits set out in the scheme. Is it unworthy that we should remove from continuing mendicancy these unfortunate people? I think it is a worthy act. It is true that you can pinprick the Bill in many ways but on its principle we are all on common ground and believe that some type of social service is necessary. Fianna Fáil say it is necessary; they say that this is not good enough, but as yet they have not given us one practical suggestion for its improvement except: "Take out the increase in old age pensions so that we can vote against it; if you leave it in we are hobbled".
I speak as a person who is generally interested in finding the best solution possible to the problem. I take it that the Bill is put forward as a type of social security and that there will be ready agreement to its improvement if practicable. I take it that it is put forward to give a lead to the House so that if possible it may be perfected before it becomes law. I make an honest appeal to the House to get away from wondering whether you are going to lose Mick McCarthy's vote or Liam Hayes's vote and consider how to make social services practicable, workable and available in the most generous and general way to the people who need it. That is our duty as legislators.
The extraordinary thing about this measure is that while many people of different religious denominations have purported to denounce it no authoritative condemnation has come from those who are recognised as the directors of religious thought, either the Catholic or the Protestant bishops. We have had airy vapourings from one worthy gentleman who was absolutely slashing in his condemnation, but if he had removed from his poison the bias and prejudice of political allegiance and disillusion there would have been nothing left for him to say.
This Bill will give a measure of justice to some at least and I hope we are not far from the time when it may be extended throughout the country. I do not at all agree with the suggestion that this Bill will keep drones. The drones of our system are not among the lowly paid or the working class. The sooner we realise that and are fair to those decent hard-working people the sooner will credit redound to us all. It is horrible to suggest that these people are drones living on the oppressed, depressed and harried agricultural community. In their day and generation they contributed as much to this nation as any class in the country.
Let us get at this Bill and improve it where we can. Let us not impede it just through frustration, anger, prejudice or bias. Let us face with commonsense an issue that we must face some day. Let us find a way to make things better for the type of person Deputy Allen and I represent, the small farmers, the people of the rural areas. If we can find a way to do that I will press for its implementation. Let us get together and find a way to make this a better Bill and let us not tear down something to which we can offer no alternative.
Comment on this
Since this Bill was introduced and circulated, the Tánaiste has announced on the Second Reading his intention to amend it by making certain provisions for old age pensioners, blind pensioners and people in similar classes. There is, however, nothing in the Bill itself which makes any provision for those sections of the community not covered by contributory insurance. If any Deputy feels that the principles involved are so bad that it is necessary to vote against the Bill on the Second Reading, he can do so knowing full well that he is not voting against any proposal to increase non-contributory old age pensions or the other benefits which the Tánaiste has promised to introduce at a later stage.
Everyone will agree that, having regard to the manner in which the cost of living has risen, during the past year in particular, and even during the past few months, there is urgent need to give at least an additional half-crown to the old age pensioners. The additional price they have to pay for fuel will more than absorb that additional benefit. Therefore, there is no disagreement on that question. I think that a reasonable proposition was put up to the Government by four independent Deputies—Deputies P.D. Lehane, Sheldon, O'Reilly and myself. We asked the Government to embody the provision for an increased old age pension in a separate Bill and have it passed through the House immediately.
It could have been passed before Easter, if the Government had been prepared to meet our request; and those increased pensions could be on the way towards being paid almost immediately. There is nothing to prevent at any time the giving of this increased benefit, except the unwillingness of the Minister for Finance; but once the Minister for Finance and the Government have announced that they are prepared to concede the additional money required to meet an increase in the old age pension, there should be no delay whatever in giving that pension. It has been announced in the public Press that that increase of 2/6 is to be forthcoming and it is unfair to the aged and to the blind and to those in need, the weakest section of the community, to keep them waiting in suspense while a difficult and complex Bill is under discussion.
Comment on this
I thought of it immediately, as soon as the proposition was made to hold the old age pensioners to ransom, to use them as hostages, so as to ensure that a Bill which is bad fundamentally in many respects should be rushed through the House. If the proposal to give an increase to old age pensioners were an honest or sincere one, it should have been embodied in the Bill when it was being drafted. Long consideration was given to this Bill. It has been under consideration, I presume, since the White Paper was issued more than a year ago. There have been, as we know, two Bills announced. This is the second draft of this Bill that has been introduced. There was ample opportunity to embody in the Bill the provision for increased old age pensions.
It seems to me that it was only when the Government suddenly realised that there were so many independent Deputies prepared to vote against the Bill as originally introduced, that they decided that they would be forced, in order to get the Bill through, to offer this additional half-crown. That is not the way to treat this House. It is not the way to treat a very important piece of legislation. If there is anyone who can claim credit for the fact that this additional half-crown has been promised, it is those of us independent Deputies who made it clear that we were not supporting the Bill as introduced. So when Deputy Sheehan asks when did I think of this, it is necessary to ask when did the Government think of it. Why did they not think of it sooner than when they realised at the last moment that they could not get the Bill through without giving this concession to a very needy section of the community? I think that this is a dishonest proposal, and I want to assure the House that if they meet the demand which has been put up by four independent Deputies here, and the demand which is also embodied in a motion which I have tabled, that non-contentious legislation containing this half-crown be introduced into this House, then there will be no difficulty whatever in getting such a Bill through.
Comment on this
I have made it clear at the outset that the half-crown is not in the Bill. The Government had not the moral justice or the sense of justice or fair play to the old age pensioners to put this half-crown into the Bill and it was only when they were coerced by us independent Deputies that they made this promise that it would be introduced subsequently. I do no agree with that dishonest type of procedure in introducing a Bill of this kind, which is of such immense importance. It is a Bill which embodies many dangerous principles, principles which have been very properly criticised by those whose function it is to study legislation and to study administration from the purely Catholic and religious point of view. Those people have studied this proposal very carefully, and I consider that their reasons were presented very moderately, very fairly and very carefully, and presented with a view to offering some guidance in this matter. They have never wished—and no fairminded person would wish—that an attempt should be made to rush this House into supporting a contentious Bill by putting in a half-crown for old age pensioners.
I challenge the Government now to bring in a Bill with this 2/6 and I can assure the Government that it will be passed as speedily as possible through the House. Then we can get down to consideration of this Bill. The Bill before us, which has been printed and put into circulation, contains no provision for the 2/6. We could consider it and after careful consideration decide whether on its merits it is worthy of support. Leaving out whatever the Minister's intentions may be with regard to amendments on the next stage, this Bill on balance is a bad one.
Comment on this
It has fundamental faults and fundamental virtues, just like every other Bill. There are always some good points in every piece of legislation, even the worst piece introduced here. Everyone will agree that it was urgently desirable that the sickness benefit should be increased, particularly that it should be increased in cases where the insured person has a family depending upon him. That was urgently needed and I think every Deputy will agree that that particular provision is a good one.
The Tánaiste, however, could have gone a little further in that respect. He should have included in the disability benefit all insured persons who suffer disability through injury or accident, apart from those who suffer disability due to illness. Workmen's compensation liability should have been included in this Bill and the general community would have welcomed such a change and such an improvement. Whether a man is incapacitated from work because he has met with an accident in the course of his employment or because he has contracted some disease is immaterial. He should receive the same benefit while he is unable to work. That is a point which deserves reasonable and fair consideration.
As I said, there are bad points in this Bill and those bad points outweigh those which are good and desirable. There are three main faults in this Bill. In the first place, it seeks, and seeks very successfully, to concentrate in the hands of the central Government functions which should be, in a right society, performed by the family and some of which could also be performed by a local organisation, particularly by a vocational organisation. Secondly, it is bad because it seeks to provide certain services which in my opinion are both unnecessary and undesirable. It seeks to compel the ordinary working man to pay a substantial contribution which is just the same as any other form of direct taxation, and he has to pay that for the specific purpose of keeping a large section of the community in complete idleness.
I hold that the first function of a Government in regard to the workers is to see that they have constant employment. The usual Socialist slogan is, "work or maintenance." I hold that the slogan of a good Government should be work without the alternative of maintenance. I hold that a properly constituted Government, a Government constituted on sound principles and acting on sound principles, should be able to provide work for every citizen able and willing to work. If they fail to perform that function, and only then, they should finance the provision of maintenance, not out of compulsory contributions from the workers, but out of general taxation. I do not agree that any worker should be compelled to insure himself against the incompetence of a Government, because it is only incompetence that produces unemployment. Therefore, if it is necessary to provide maintenance for the unemployed through the incompetence of the Government, the Government should provide it by other means than a direct levy on the workers and their employers.
Comment on this
I was expecting that interruption. I know that there are a lot of things which have been wrong since this State was established and before this State was established; but if a thing is wrong that is no reason why it should be extended to such an extent that it can never be redressed. An evil like this on a modified scale is not as harmful or as dangerous as it is when it is extended and made universal. That is one of the principles upon which I am opposing this Bill— that we are extending and expanding the whole system of unemployment insurance to such an extent that we are creating a vested interest in unemployment, that we are compelling large sections of the community to contribute so much of their weekly income to insurance that they will naturally feel they are in some way entitled to recover the money which they have paid. As I say, if you fail to perform the important governmental function of providing full employment for our workers, there is only one thing you can do and that is to provide the assistance for them out of general taxation. I want to get away from the bad principle which the Minister has mentioned and which he now seeks to extend and expand so as to cover every section of the community.
Then there is another section of the community for whom the Minister has made provision in this Bill, namely, able-bodied persons of 65 years. I do not know what percentage of the total population these people form, but they must be a very considerable section, and I am certain that the provision of this retiring benefit, as it is called, will impose a very heavy liability upon the whole insurance scheme. I do not think that that service is either necessary or desirable. If we had a position in this country in which the volume of output was so high that we could not find a market for it either in this country or outside, if our external balance of payments was so favourable that it would not be necessary to increase our agricultural or industrial output, then there might be a case for shortening the working life, just as there might be a case for shortening the working week or the working day. But we have not that position here. We have the position in which we are unable as a nation to pay our way because our volume of output does not keep pace with the volume of consumption. Therefore, we are seeking to introduce by this Bill something which will retard the output of the nation and something which will impose a very heavy burden on the insured section of the community and also of course on the taxpayers.
There is no reasonable case for this retirement benefit. Under the health insurance provisions heretofore in force, and particularly under the health insurance provisions in this Bill, a worker of 65 years who is in poor health, a worker who is medically unfit to go to work, can receive benefit. On the other hand, it is the duty of the State, either in this Bill or otherwise, to make provision for the unemployed. Therefore there can be no justification for this provision which seeks to induce healthy, able-bodied persons to retire at 65 years. The whole trend of all legislation in this country should be to encourage people to work as long as they are able, as long as their doctor advises them they are capable of working, and in that way make their contribution to the general pool of goods in the country, and thus contribute to the raising of the general standard of living of the entire nation.
There is another very serious defect in this Bill. It leaves out of consideration almost half the working population of the country. I regard the health benefits and the provisions for widows and children as important and desirable but under this Bill those benefits do not apply to more than half the working population though the entire population will have to contribute towards the general taxation in order to provide them. That seems to me to be very unfair to the small farmer who may have to meet heavy liabilities through prolonged illness. So far as the middle classes and the small farmers are concerned I have never believed in providing them with completely free medical services but, if they or their families have to face prolonged illness or avail of specialist and institutional treatment involving heavy expense, I think then they do need some assistance. I think the small farmer and the middle-class farmer should benefit in that respect, the middle-class farmer who pays one or two men and who has to work hard with his own brain and muscle to provide a living for himself and his family and wages for his one or two men. That man is brought under this Bill only in so far as he is registered as an employer. He must make a fairly substantial contribution to the finances of the Bill but he cannot draw any benefit from it. The struggling farmer who employs one man and who must pay out 3/6 per week in respect of him may have very serious commitments to meet should he or any of his family fall ill. But he cannot turn to this Bill in such circumstances for assistance. There is no social security for him. In that connection, I would like to refer to the opinions of some Catholic clergymen who have considered this matter very carefully.
Comment on this
Do they stand over those opinions now, the opinions expressed a couple of weeks ago? They have not opened their mouths for the past month and will not do so again.
Comment on this
You are in favour of some sort of social welfare scheme; so are we and, therefore, they are all wrong.
Comment on this
As far as social welfare is concerned, we are all in favour of certain social services. Everybody knows that. Surely we have always had some social services ever since the introduction of old age pensions.
Comment on this
I take it Deputy Captain Cowan thinks that the best way to prevent me making my case is frequently to interrupt me and possibly bring interruptions from elsewhere in the House, too. I do not want to be side-tracked. This is an important matter. It is important for every section of the community. I do not think these clergymen would have given the matter the attention they did give it if it were not so important. They would not have set down their opinions in writing if they did not think grave principles were involved which should be considered objectively and seriously here and I take it it was mainly with the intention of ensuring that this Bill would get the consideration it deserved that they set down their opinions in regard to it.
I want to quote now from Rural Ireland, the annual issued by Muintir na Tire. At page 101 of last year's issue Father Phelim Ó Briain refers to a statement made by the Bishop of Clonfert. The statement is as follows:—
"It is strange that in an agricultural country like ours, no account is taken of agriculture except that a comparatively small number of agricultural labourers (about 70,000) is included; but the farming community generally is excluded—the community that forms our greatest industry, employs the most workers, produces the most wealth and, as a class, receives so small a fraction of the national income. All are definitely excluded; they may not enter the scheme even if they wish."
Father Ó Briain went on to refer to the farmers' income. He said:—
"Specious and quite fallacious attempts to make a case against farming in favour of some other class are completely refuted by certain elementary economic facts that should be known to everybody. The most recent public estimate of our national income has put it at about £300,000,000. Of this sum, only £100,000,000 went to the agricultural community.... The last census shows the rural population to be more than 63 per cent. of the total population. But only 31 per cent of the whole national income reaches the farmers."
That is a complete answer to those who say that the farming community are so prosperous they have no need to fear social insecurity and they have no need for social security.
Just before I left home this week I was speaking to a small farmer with 20 acres of land. He has three pigs for sale and he found that the price he expected to get had been reduced by £3 per pig. That means that there is £9 gone out of the little income that farmer hoped to derive from fattening these pigs. There is very little social security there.
Comment on this
Reference has been made to people living in tenements. How many of them are excluded under the terms of this Bill? How many small traders and casual workers are excluded?
Comment on this
So long as the Deputy does not refer to Moore Street and the Coal Quay I do not mind.
Comment on this
I have no intention of referring to any of the select quarters Deputy Captain Cowan knows so well. I do not think this Bill provides any comprehensive insurance against the hazards of life for all sections of the community There are many struggling people in the urban and rural areas who will derive no benefit under this measure. This Bill is a drastic step in the direction of State control in every walk of life and over every section of the community. It is a long step towards socialism in its simplest form.
We all know that the first fundamental consideration of any Government is to respect the rights of the family. In this Bill, certain obligations are being imposed upon a section of the community compulsorily to pay increased contributions and the whole scheme is centralised around the old bus station or the new bus station or whatever it is in Store Street. Why should we not have every function that could be transferred to the family, so transferred? I have spoken to people who have studied the social question from a moral aspect and they have said that the only justification for the State coming in to make provision which ought to be made by the head of the family is that social conditions are so bad that it is impossible for him to do so.
Comment on this
I have outlined the manner in which the Bill is bad, and I have outlined the good aspects, and I have suggested to the House the provisions which are good and which should be extended to the sections of the community who are excluded. I instanced the case of the person who pays a worker weekly and who has to contribute insurance in respect of that man, the ordinary struggling farmer. I instanced the case of the small farmer who may have members of his family seriously ill. There is no benefit provided for those people in this Bill. That is the type of provision which I would like to see made more comprehensive. I also referred to people who are excluded from the Bill, people who suffer a disability or who are incapable of working owing to injuries. They should also benefit under this measure. In other words, I am asking that the health benefits of this Bill should be extended to all sections.
I am not asking that the compulsory insurance should be extended to the small farmer. He is never unemployed. I have never asked that he should be requested to contribute towards that. I have objected to the agricultural labourer, to the small farmer and the farmer who employs an agricultural labourer having to contribute jointly towards providing money for unemployment insurance. In my view, unemployment is due to the incompetence of the Government and if they fail to provide full employment they should provide the money from other sources rather than impose a direct tax upon the lowly-paid worker.
Since references have been made to certain matters—I think Deputy Cowan is developing certain attributes as a theologian—for his benefit I think it might be no harm to quote the words of the Most Rev. Dr. Dignan, Bishop of Clonfert. He said:—
"If I were a member of a trade union consisting of men in secure and constant employment, and if I were asked to draw up a scheme for my union without considering the rights or needs of others, I would be inclined to adopt this scheme. But if I were asked to draw up a ‘national' scheme—and this scheme is supposed to be national—I could not look upon it as a model to follow. The proposals, in my opinion, violate distributive justice in imposing burdensome taxation on the whole community to pay benefits to a new privileged class. The trade unions themselves stand to benefit financially from the scheme."
Comment on this
The date of this particular volume is October, 1950. The Bill had been circulated at that time.
Comment on this
I have indicated the extent to which this Bill is founded on false principles. I have indicated that it seeks to provide two services which it is not desirable that the ordinary worker should be compelled to pay a levy in order to finance. There are some people who suggest that those services would not involve very high expenditure. For that reason I want to show how much of a saving could be effected if we were to delete those services. I believe if we deleted those unnecessary and undesirable services we would not need to increase the contributions payable by the worker and his employer and we would not need to increase the State contribution; at least, we would not need to increase the contributions payable by the worker and the employer and we would not need to provide any more out of State funds than is already provided under the Bill.
The services which I consider it is undesirable that the worker should be compelled to insure against are unemployment and retirement. The retirement pension could be deleted altogether with advantage to the entire community. It serves no useful purpose. It is no benefit to the worker and it is an injury to the State. I live among farm workers who would much prefer to work to 70 years and in some cases even beyond that age.
Comment on this
There is a strong inducement offered in the Bill to workers to retire at 65, and there is an indication that this inducement may be supplemented. There is also another aspect, and I am open to correction in this respect. I understand when this Bill becomes law people over 65 will not be entitled to draw the health benefits that are provided. If that is so, it is almost coercing them into accepting retirement at 65. With regard to unemployment, I hold that that service should be financed out of State funds.
Comment on this
I hold that the amount required would be very small provided this country were properly governed and if every man who can work was provided with work. The sum provided in this Bill for unemployment benefit and for retirement pensions amounts to £5,150,000 out of a total of £8,800,000; that is, very much more than 50 per cent. of the money that will be extracted from the worker and his employer will be spent upon services which could, with advantage to the State, the workers and everybody concerned, be dispensed with. Deputy M.J. O'Higgins asked whether the employment benefit should be provided out of State funds or general taxation. My contention is that, with proper local organisation and effort by all concerned, we could provide almost 100 per cent. employment for all our workers. It is only a matter of getting down to the work.
Comment on this
There is this. You will extract from the worker by compulsory measures 3/6 per week to insure him against unemployment. Is it not natural that that man should expect some benefit from that? Are you not creating a situation in which you have got to give that benefit?
Comment on this
Do you appreciate that before the first Unemployment Insurance Act was introduced in 1911 and when that levy was not collected there was much more unemployment than now?
Comment on this
The Tánaiste is not as innocent as he pretends to be. Very much later than 1911—in 1928 or 1929, I think—we had Ministers in this country—some of them are now associated with the Tánaiste and the Tánaiste is now supporting them—who claimed that it was not the function of the Government to relieve unemployment in any way.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan claimed that the State had no function in regard to employment. The State has a very definite function in regard to employment. That function is to provide employment without any reservation or qualification. That was not accepted as the obligation of Government in 1911. In 1928 or 1929 it was not accepted by Deputy McGilligan. It was not accepted until recent years. It is now generally accepted by Governments in all countries that they must undertake the function of providing employment for those who find it impossible to secure employment. If we deduct this unnecessary and undesirable expenditure from the provisions of the Bill, we can avoid the necessity for increasing the contributions made payable by the workers and the employer and it will not be necessary to add anything to the expenditure of the State so far as the services of the State are concerned.
I have indicated that I disagreed with the Bill on the ground that it makes for more intensive centralisation of all social activities in the hands of a centralised Department. The Bill takes away many of the responsibilities which could be left in the hands of the head of the family. It takes away a lot of the responsibilities which could be left with great advantage to a locally constituted body such as a parish council or a parish guild. We ought to approach this question on Christian lines. We ought to approach it on the lines indicated by people who have studied those questions from a Christian standpoint. I believe in the philosophy that is embodied in this volume of Rural Ireland issued by Muintir na Tíre and in this volume of Christus Rex issued from Maynooth.
Comment on this
It was suggested some time ago that there were two St. Patricks. Maybe there are two St. Patrick's Colleges also?
Comment on this
The individual is a member of St. Patrick's staff, but he is merely an individual there.
Comment on this
I never intended to suggest that he was infallible, but I said I agreed with the philosophy he had set down.
Comment on this
I believe those people are proceeding on the right lines and I believe that our socialist philosophers of the Labour Party are following blindly the philosophy of the British Labour Party and that of the Socialist Parties on the continent.
Comment on this
I was impressed by the little volume which was issued by the Minister. He thought, perhaps, the White Paper was too difficult for the ordinary Deputy to understand. That was why he got out a little blue book. It shows us a nice little family, a young man and woman and two children. That apparently is the ideal family from the point of view of size according to British socialist philosophy. There is set down in the book all the benefits it is proposed to give to the different sections of the community.
Comment on this
You have misunderstood the significance of the two children. You have only made two statements and both are wrong.
Comment on this
The Deputy should be permitted to make his speech. The five yapping yahoos are trying to prevent him.
Comment on this
It is hard on our legal gentlemen that they cannot get the ordinary farmer into the Dáil and cross-examine, browbeat and silence him.
Comment on this
I am not worrying about Deputy Hickey. I have said that I understand and agree with the philosophy of Muintir na Tíre and of Christus Rex. I do not want to add anything to that or to take anything from it. I think it is a sound philosophy and one which we as a people would do well to study more closely, instead of aping the fashion of the British Socialist Party. We often talk about the Six Counties having to keep in step with the Government in London, but we are keeping in step even to a greater extent and perhaps trying to keep a step ahead occasionally.
It would be well to ask where we are going, in what direction we are going. It would be well to ask where is the terminus, where is the end of the journey. Is it not a complete Socialistic State, in which everybody is eating out of the Government's hands, in which the Government supplies everything to everybody and takes everything they have from them, or, rather, takes before giving because no Government can give anything to the people but what it takes from them? We ought not to allow ourselves to be rushed headlong into this measure of so-called social security——
Comment on this
——which provides no social security and no security of any kind for a large section, which excludes a large section from the operation of one or two provisions which are good and which, on the other hand, compels ordinary workers to make a substantial contribution out of their week's wages, which levies a tax on them, because there is no difference whatever between the weekly contribution which is compulsory and the contribution he pays through taxes. It is collected compulsory and for that reason one may put it in the same category as any other tax. We are asked not to give this Bill careful and deliberate consideration and not to pay any attention to clergy or such people, outsiders, who are not politicians. We are not to give their views any consideration whatever and we are asked to vote blindly for this Bill and to rush our country blindly into a system of so-called social security from which it will be difficult to retrace our steps.
I have indicated that the one justification which one clergyman with whom I discussed the Bill offered was that, if a large section of our people are poor, the State must come to their assistance. If that is the justification for the Bill, it would be a justification only for a temporary measure, but this is a permanent measure. Take the case of the boy of 16 who has left school. Week by week, a sum of 3/6 is collected from him for the remainder of his life and that contribution is collected from him on the understanding that he will be provided with the dole, if he happens to be unemployed. That is a situation of which I cannot approve.
We would do well to advance cautiously in regard to this measure. We could very easily provide for a bettering of the health benefits and the benefits for widows and orphans. That, I think, is the greatest hazard the ordinary man in weekly employment has to face—the hazard of sickness and death, leaving his dependents unprovided for—and I would be in favour of these benefits being increased to the extent to which they are increased in the Bill, but, so far as the other services are concerned, I am against them.
Comment on this
The maternity benefit is only a small amount which does not matter very much. I have no objection to it. Deputy Collins, by his interruptions and his speech, seems to exaggerate the extent of these benefits, but they amount to a very small portion of the total expenditure involved in the Bill.
Comment on this
The main items of expenditure in the Bill are unemployment and retirement benefits which represent nearly two-thirds of the total expenditure, and for that reason there is not very much in the others.
Comment on this
I do not like to have to keep on educating Deputies as they come in. They probably heard that I was giving a lecture here and came in for education, with the result that I have again to go over the ground I have travelled for the benefit of other Deputies. I want to inform Deputy Davin that I do not think it is right to coerce a worker into insuring himself against the incompetence of his own Government, into insuring himself against unemployment.
Comment on this
In view of the limited benefits which the Bill provides, the very undesirable services it seeks to introduce and the unfairness of the measure towards a large section of people who have to contribute, both in taxation and in weekly contribution, Deputies opposite would do well to advise and encourage the Tánaiste even by their votes to withdraw the Bill and to introduce a more acceptable measure. I have indicated the lines on which a Bill would be acceptable. I have indicated that improved health benefits and improved pensions for widows and allowances for orphans would be desirable. I have indicated that the contributions collected from the agricultural worker and the farmer need not be any higher than they are before the passing of this Bill. I have indicated also that I would make an exception in that respect, if the Tánaiste were prepared to include workmen's compensation. In that case, the former employer would be prepared to pay a higher contribution than he is paying at present. These are the suggestions I put up and I say that, because of its many faults which far outweigh its benefits, the Bill is one which ought to be condemned and the Tánaiste for that reason ought to be advised, and, if necessary, compelled to withdraw the Bill and to introduce a measure more acceptable to the House and to the people.
Comment on this
I do not propose to detain the House as long as some of the other speakers have done. I do not do that as a rule. I can understand, of course, the reasons for the exasperation that has been in evidence on the other side of the House with the speech of Deputy Cogan. They have not succeeded in bringing him in under their Coalition wing in connection with this measure.
Comment on this
It is only natural, then, that these members on the Coalition Benches would be inclined to show a certain amount of impatience and exasperation with the remarks of Deputy Cogan. While I do not agree entirely with the remarks of Deputy Cogan, I must admit that there were several very sensible things that he said.
Comment on this
He made, to my mind, a very sensible and very constructive contribution to the debate. Apart entirely from Deputy Cogan or anybody else, I must say that I am opposed to this measure. If there were nothing else to arouse my opposition to it than the way in which it was introduced, that would be quite sufficient for me. One would think from the furore that took place over there that this was the first time this country had heard of social security, social welfare or social insurance and, according to the speeches which were delivered, by Labour Deputies especially, one would think that the Fianna Fáil Government never did anything for the poor, the needy and the unemployed.
Comment on this
It is just as well to remind the House at this stage that, before the advent of the Fianna Fáil Government, there was no such thing as widows' and orphans' pensions, no such thing as unemployment assistance, no such thing as a minimum wage for agricultural workers——
Comment on this
We had an over-all majority here and we were in a position to do exactly what we thought was right for the Irish people.
Comment on this
Nobody forced us to do anything. We did our own work and we did it well in the circumstances. These social schemes and others that I need not recapitulate here were introduced by Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
And all that the Minister is doing now is going along the road a little further with the social benefits.
Comment on this
But going along the road in some directions, I admit, that I do not approve of. I said that the method of introduction of this Bill was sufficient to make me vote against it but I also submit that there is an atmosphere of blackmail surrounding this Bill that should not be there. Deputy Davin sniggers at that.
Comment on this
There is political blackmail surrounding this measure and certain Deputies are being coerced to support it, to vote for it, because there is an inducement held out in the background, an inducement in the shape of 2/6 increase in old age pensions. I characterise that as political blackmail and I agree with Deputy Cogan and the other Deputies on these benches who said that the Government had no right to befog the issue in that way.
Comment on this
If I would be allowed to proceed, I would say it was dishonest procedure on the part of the Government to come in here with a Bill of this description without a single word about an increase in old age pensions in it and, when they found that there were certain members on their own benches who were in danger of voting against the measure and defeating it, they came along then with the afterthought of an increase of 2/6 in the old age pensions, for, I submit, it was only an afterthought.
Of course, any intelligent man looking at this, any man outside watching the procedure here, could see that, that it is only as a matter of expediency that the Minister and the Government are now promising 2/6 increase in the old age pension. Why was not the section inserted in the Bill the first day?
Comment on this
The Minister and the Government had ample time to consider it. The fact of the matter is that they had no intention whatever of doing it until they found that there was a possibility, and more than a possibility, a certainty, that certain members on whose support they counted would vote against this Social Welfare (Insurance) (No. 2) Bill, as it is called. Why do they call it the Social Welfare (Insurance) (No. 2) Bill? Because No. 1 Bill had to be relegated to the waste-paper basket for the reason that I have mentioned.
I was intrigued to hear Deputy Collins speaking on this Bill. I always like to hear him. Frequently he makes useful contributions to the debates but, having regard to his Party and his Party's past history, I thought he was inclined to be a bit over-enthusiastic about it. He said he would have no objection or no hesitation to go down to his constituency and stand over this measure. Deputy Sweetman also spoke from the Fine Gael benches. They are the only two Deputies who have spoken so far from the Fine Gael benches.
Comment on this
We shall wait patiently to hear what they have to say. It is very strange that, despite this enthusiasm and this wonderful spirit which the members of Fine Gael are now showing for the downtrodden, the poor and the sick, they did not mention a word about this in their election manifesto.
Comment on this
We have heard now from Deputy Rooney and we also heard from the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach that they put it before the people in 1937——
Comment on this
——that they included some social insurance scheme in their election manifesto in 1937. If they did, what became of it in 1938, 1943, 1944 and 1948?
Comment on this
If they had any such proposal as this in their minds in 1937, how is it that they let four subsequent general elections pass without referring to that so-called manifesto?
Comment on this
We have not seen the manifesto. I should like to see a copy of it even now, to ascertain what the social policy of the Fine Gael Party was in 1937. In any case, any thinking man must come to the conclusion, even if they had a social insurance or a social welfare scheme in their election manifesto in 1937 and forgot about it in the succeeding general elections, that they were not very much concerned about it. That is why I say that the concern and enthusiasm displayed by the few speakers from the Fine Gael benches within the past couple of days seem very unreal. The funny thing about this measure is that nobody seems to be in a position to tell us what its full implementation is going to cost the country. The Minister mentioned some figure.
Comment on this
I think the Minister mentioned something like £10,500,000 for the 1st year apart from any provision for an increase in old age pensions. I may be wrong.
Comment on this
Apart entirely from the Minister's guessing, my guessing and the guesswork of any member here, there are no financial provisions in this measure for the implementation of the Bill.
Comment on this
We are taking, in my opinion, a leap in the dark. We are committing the country to a scheme and the extent of the financial liability involved we do not know.
Comment on this
I am discussing the Minister's scheme—at least I am trying to discuss it. Of course I realise that I am also entitled to discuss Deputy Dr. Ryan's scheme and to discuss the amendments that have been put down by Deputies Lehane and Flynn.
Comment on this
Even though Deputy Flynn has withdrawn the amendment it is still there for discussion; it is on the Order Paper. As the Deputy has mentioned Deputy Flynn's amendment—I was not going to make very much reference to it myself— I must say I was very glad when I discovered that Deputy Flynn had down this amendment because I thought it meant that one individual over there on the Government Benches realised his responsibilities to the small working farmers of this country. Deputy Flynn, like myself, represents a good many small industrious farmers in Kerry and naturally I was interested to observe that there was one Government Deputy going to stand on his feet to champion the cause of these small farmers by insisting that the small farmers of the country would not be forgotten in any measure put through this House. What happened? He has decided to withdraw the amendment because pressure was brought to bear on him by Deputy Davin and a few others.
Comment on this
I am disappointed that the amendment has been withdrawn but, of course, that is entirely a matter for the Deputy himself. I, for one, would not be the person to try to interfere with the liberty or the judgment of any Deputy here.
Comment on this
Are you alleging that I was responsible for making him withdraw the amendment? I am not worrying but the Deputy has no grounds for that statement.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan and others have been referring to statements that were made outside. I do not think that Deputy Cowan has spoken yet in this debate.
Comment on this
Deputy Collins made reference to certain pronouncements that were made on this social insurance Bill.
Comment on this
I specifically said that there were no pronouncements made by the people who should make them.
Comment on this
Certain opinions were expressed by eminent sociologists in this country. Can anybody here deny that Father Phelim Ó Briain is a sociologist of importance and repute?