We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Social Welfare (Insurance) (No. 2) Bill, 1950—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 211–398 of 398. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Social Welfare (Insurance)(No. 2) Bill 1950
Lapsed

No. 39 of 1950 ›

We know what you did with him.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Cowan might reserve his statements for his own speech.

Comment on this

One would imagine from what has been said by some of these political men, that we should not listen to advice given by anybody outside. I think that the opinions expressed by an eminent sociologist who has no interest in politics——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Not the man you referred to.

Comment on this

There were opinions given and references made to this Bill by other people also who are not very interested in politics, and I would regard their opinions as being much more valuable than the opinions of politicians.

Comment on this

Why did you not accept their opinions then?

Comment on this

That is a different matter.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The responsibility is ours and not that of the sociologists.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair will have to take serious notice of these interruptions if they do not cease. Deputy Collins and Deputy Cowan have been continuously interrupting Deputy Kissane since he got on his feet.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I got a batter of them myself when I was speaking.

Comment on this

When the Deputy was speaking there was not one interruption from this side of the House.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Do not be talking nonsense. There were bleatings from the opposite side.

Comment on this

I am afraid I must take it that my remarks are proving very irritating to the Deputies opposite. I cannot help that. I am trying to deal with this measure as I see it and as I have read it. I am trying to deal also with expressions of opinion that have been given by certain authorities outside. Now, like my colleagues here, I am in favour of social insurance.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

But, at the same time, I am not one of those people who would say: "Go ahead: give this section of the people this and give that section of the people that," without weighing the consequences and counting the cost. We should all be very careful in our advocacy of a measure such as this so that we will not kill the goose with the golden eggs.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I, like other speakers, deprecate the idea of discouraging people from work after the age of 65, because I know very well that people at the age of 65, especially in rural Ireland, are almost as good at that age as they were at any time. Many of them at that age are better able to work than people who are 30 years younger. While the Minister and other speakers opposite may say that there is nothing in this Bill to prevent a man from working after he reaches the age of 65, still is it not only natural to expect that, when there are certain benefits provided by the State; when there are certain benefits made available by the State to people when they reach the age of 65, the temptation will be there for those people to give up work and accept the benefits?

Comment on this

Does that not show that the scheme is a good one?

Comment on this

But that could be carried too far, especially when we have regard to the fact that the span of life is longer now than it was 30 or 40 years ago. In fact, I would venture to say that the span of life, since the first Old Age Pensions Act was passed in 1908, is at least five years more than it was then because of increased hospitalisation and increased medical services and so on. Therefore, I do not think that any case can be made for this clause in the Bill, a clause which, I should say, virtually provides for the retirement of people from work at the age of 65, when as other speakers have said, every able-bodied person should be engaged not only in production but in increased production. We hear a lot about increased production, especially from the land. I, at any rate, do not think that this clause in the Bill will make for increased production.

We were discussing recently the deficit in the balance of payments, and we discovered that in 1950 that deficit amounted to £30,000,000. What is the only way in which we can rectify that position? The only way is to stimulate production.

Comment on this

How do you do that —by machinery?

Comment on this

By putting more people into work.

Comment on this

And younger men.

Comment on this

Our ambition should be to put more and more people into work and not to take more people out of it. Is that not so? But the latter is exactly what you are going to do under this Bill. Deputy Collins, I see, has gone.

Comment on this

You cleared him out.

Comment on this

He mentioned that there is an onus on the State to provide a measure such as this, but I would suggest that there is also an onus on the State to provide work. There is a much greater onus on the State to provide work for the unemployed, of whom we have over 60,000 in this country to-day. Here we are with no proposals before us, and no indication that they will be before us at any time in the future, to remedy the position and to provide work for the unemployed.

Comment on this

The number of unemployed is getting smaller and smaller every year.

Comment on this

It is getting smaller to the extent that these people are leaving the rural parts of the country.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

You intended to bring back the emigrants.

Comment on this

There has been a depopulation of the countryside, especially of the turf areas, over the past couple of years. Were it not for that, the number of unemployed would be much greater than it is.

Comment on this

Look at all the work the emigrants were to get.

Comment on this

We have 3,000,000 people in the country now—more than were there while Fianna Fáil was in office.

Comment on this

And there is more good employment than there was in 1947.

Comment on this

Section 82 provides for the granting of the old age pension in the case of an assignment of property, up to a valuation of £25. Is there to be any equivalent in respect of personal property? Take, for instance, a potential old age pensioner who sells his land and has the proceeds which he got from the sale of the land in the bank.

Comment on this

Is the valuation £25?

Comment on this

Twenty-five pounds. Will the money which such a person would have in the bank as a result of such a sale of his land—whether that sale would have taken place six months or a year or two years previously— be taken into account and assessed as means?

Comment on this

How many possible cases might arise?

Comment on this

There are many cases.

Comment on this

Not many.

Comment on this

Of course there are many. Apart altogether from the sale of land, there will be cases of people who have a certain amount of money in the bank, which amount of money would be equivalent, say, to the value of up to a certain valuation farm. That type of thing must be taken into account.

Comment on this

Is the means test provision not there?

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

I think Deputy Kissane might be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

We are only trying to get it straightened out.

Comment on this

I am putting that point in connection with Section 82 before the Minister for his consideration. I am opposed to this Bill because a very important section of the community is being left out of it—the farming community, the small farmers, the fishermen of whom there are a good many in my constituency and the self-employed in many walks of life to whom reference has already been made.

Comment on this

Is that not really dishonest when you never intended to bring them in yourself?

Comment on this

I am entitled to make my statement. I am giving my reasons to the Minister and to the House for opposing this Bill. I am opposing it because of the way in which it has been introduced and because of the way in which the issue is being confused in this House. I am opposing it because an important section of the community is being left out of it: they will never benefit from it and yet they will have to contribute to it.

Comment on this

And to your own scheme, if it ever comes about.

Comment on this

I am opposed to it also because I consider that the contributions are too high. I have been up and down the country recently and I have met many workers. I have found no enthusiasm amongst the workers for this measure.

Comment on this

The Party workers.

Comment on this

That is nonsensical talk. I meet every kind of individual when I go round the country. I am talking about the ordinary people who have to work for their hire—the wage earners—apart altogether from politics. They consider that this imposition of 3/6 a week is too great. That works out at over £10 a year.

Comment on this

That is the way you look at it.

Comment on this

That is the way I am putting it. That is the way it is set out in black and white in the Bill. It is over £10 a year and, of course, the employer—whatever type of an employer he may be, whether a farmer or an employer in the cities and towns —will have to clap down another £10. That makes over £20 in the year.

Comment on this

How much does he clap down now?

Comment on this

Many people hold that it would be better in the majority of cases if that money were paid in ordinary insurance. They hold that they would draw more out of it in that way. A good many of those workers will never benefit to any great extent from the scheme because, in normal circumstances, the majority of them will continue working——

Comment on this

And never die.

Comment on this

I am talking about disablement benefit and sickness benefit. They are the two important benefits. There is no use in talking about people dying and burying them when they are dying. We heard Deputy Seán Collins talking about paupers' graves. It is very seldom nowadays that people are buried in paupers' graves. I am talking about sickness, disablement and unemployment benefits. The majority of workers will derive no benefit from this measure if it becomes an Act.

Comment on this

I have listened to the case that has been made by Fianna Fáil against this Bill. It is a typical case. It is a very old dodge to oppose a Bill such as this on the grounds that it is not good enough, that it does not produce adequate benefits and, at the same time, that it is too costly. Many of us are familiar with that state of mind. It is a typical Fianna Fáil approach. We had it during the 16 years that Fianna Fáil were in office. When we endeavoured to get increases in wages for road workers we were told: "You cannot do it; it would seriously upset agricultural workers", and when we tried to get an increase in wages for agricultural workers we were told: "You cannot do it because it would upset the balance between agricultural workers and local authority workers."

Comment on this

On a point of order, I understand now that it will be permissible in the debate to refer to the wage structure during the 16 years Fianna Fáil were in office. We certainly intend to reply to Deputy Cowan's remarks and I should like to have that clear.

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

Deputy Cowan made the remark as a preliminary——

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan is discussing the wage structure under Fianna Fáil; are we permitted to do the same thing?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Deputy Cowan is only making a preliminary remark before going on to discuss the Bill.

Comment on this

We can do the same thing?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

In a preliminary way, certainly.

Comment on this

I am discussing the opposition to this Bill and the mentality behind that opposition. I am not going to discuss Fianna Fáil and all their sins for the past 25 years.

Comment on this

Life is not long enough.

Comment on this

I am discussing, however, in an introductory way the mentality behind Fianna Fáil. Fianna Fáil established the Department of Social Welfare and Deputy Dr. Ryan was sent there as Minister to prepare a comprehensive social welfare scheme. Deputy Ryan spent a considerable time warning the House and the country that the implementation of that scheme would mean increased contributions from the workers. That was his message. All the time he was preparing the people for the fact that if a Social Welfare Bill were introduced workers and employers would have to contribute more. Now the Deputy has somersaulted and says that we do not need any increase in contributions but can raise the necessary funds by taxation. What does that show to me? It shows a Party that is dishonest. It shows a Party which knows, which must know, that it will not assume the responsibility of office again; it shows a Party in defeat attempting to gain the few miserable votes that will keep some of them in Parliament after the next election. That is the total reason for that somersault. Deputy Childers is here. He is a Deputy who, speaking in the country, holds himself out as a responsible individual who faces realities when nobody else does and I am quite sure that when he gave his consent to a scheme such as Deputy Ryan has proposed he knows that Fianna Fáil has gone the way of all flesh.

Comment on this

Nothing of the kind. Have an election now any time you like.

Comment on this

Even with the old age pensions.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass came here last night and said: "Let us not talk politics about this. Let us all get around as responsible statesmen——"

Comment on this

A fireside chat.

Comment on this

"——and get an agreed measure." He holds himself out as the reasonable individual who is not going to talk politics. But what has he been doing in regard to this Bill during the last three years? Since the Minister took responsibility for the Department Deputy Lemass has been demanding the White Paper, the White Paper, the White Paper. When he got the White Paper he wanted to know when we were going to get the Bill, when we would see it, when it would be circulated and when it would get its Second Reading. He had been twitting the Government on social welfare for the last three years and endeavoured to get all the political assistance he could out of the fact that the Bill was not introduced earlier. Now that a concrete measure is before him, he, astute politician that he is, sees the danger to Fianna Fáil in the Bill, and says: "Withdraw it; let us get around a table and talk about it." He made no such suggestion for the past three years, but now when he sees it is about to become law in spite of his Party he wants us to have a chat about it. The mentality there is that nothing is right unless Fianna Fáil does it.

I heard Deputy Kissane this evening talking about some of the social welfare schemes introduced by Fianna Fáil, and he instanced children's allowances. I remember very well when in the general election of 1943 the Labour Party campaigned the country for the introduction of children's allowances, and Fianna Fáil said "No," and refused to put children's allowances into their election literature.

Comment on this

A good thing too, excellent.

Comment on this

What happened? They got a shock to find that while they were the biggest Party they had not a clear majority. At that time the Labour Party very foolishly voted them back into office instead of voting them out of office.

Comment on this

They kicked you out of the Labour Party at that time too.

Comment on this

In 1943, having got that shock, being placed in a minority, being subject to the majority rule of the House, they introduced children's allowances and went to the country to get a clear majority in 1944. I remember it very well because I campaigned all over the country.

Comment on this

You are mixing it badly.

Comment on this

What Party was the Deputy in at that time?

Comment on this

The Labour Party.

Comment on this

The vanguard?

Comment on this

Whatever Party I am in or am not in, I think I have never changed in my adherence to Labour Party philosophy and I defy any Deputy to find any conflict in my views on economic matters in the period since I came into public life.

Comment on this

The Labour Party do not think that.

Comment on this

You know very little about them, so the less you say the better.

Comment on this

Do not be annoyed.

Comment on this

That is the story of the children's allowances. They were put into operation by the electorate who shocked Fianna Fáil in 1943.

Comment on this

What about the Transport Bill in 1943?

Comment on this

That was 1943. Deputy Kissane and other Deputies say it is wrong to give a retiring allowance to a man of 65 who has worked probably 50 years. That is the Party that introduced here and passed into law legislation to give £500 a year pension to Ministers of the Government after a few years in office. Fianna Fáil gave £10 a week to a man after a few years in office as a Minister, yet they say it is wrong to give a retirement allowance of 24/- to a worker in the rural areas or in the city who has worked and sweated over a period of 50 years. Where is the honesty about that sort of thing? I want to know from Deputy Childers or from anybody else in Fianna Fáil where the honesty is in that. "Political blackmail" are the words used by Deputy Kissane; it was political blackmail, he said, for the Minister to provide that old age pensioners would get £1 a week, that the means test would be substantially modified, that those who were in receipt of special allowances under the I.R.A. Acts or pensions for army disability might receive the total old age pension of £1.

Comment on this

That is not in the Bill.

Comment on this

It is, in spite of you.

Comment on this

"Political blackmail" he called it. Those are the words Deputy Kissane used. Does Deputy Kissane remember another phase in the administration of Fianna Fáil in regard to pensions, when they went before the country and told the people that if they were elected to office they would abolish military service pensions? That is what they said they would do and over every dead wall in the country they published a list of honourable men who had served this country honestly and they headed it "The roll of honour." What was that roll? It was a list of men who had received pensions from the then Government for services to this State.

Comment on this

They put their own names to it since.

Comment on this

Having gone to the country on that issue, having put that specifically before the people as an election issue, they came into this House and instead of abolishing the military service pensions they provided military service pensions for a number of other people.

Comment on this

Do you object?

Comment on this

No. I think it was right to do it, but I am talking about it from the point of political dishonesty and dishonest procedure.

Comment on this

Was the plea not put up that the livelihood of those men was based on the pensions they were in receipt of?

Comment on this

I do not care what plea was put up. Having gone to the country and having got a mandate from the country to abolish the pensions, they were morally bound to go to the country again before they changed their decision. I think it was perfectly right to give these military service pensions in the way they have been given under the 1934 Act.

Comment on this

Now the civil war discussion starts on that.

Comment on this

This is political war.

Comment on this

Let the discussion open now and discuss the whole civil war.

Comment on this

I am engaged in political war with Fianna Fáil on this Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy is using the civil war.

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

There will be no discussion, we hope, on the civil war.

Comment on this

The question of military pensions can be answered only by reference to the civil war.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

I am discussing political dishonesty, the political blackmail mentioned by Deputy Kissane.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been discussing the civil war, indirectly.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Deputy Cowan must not be further interrupted.

Comment on this

Deputy Cogan comes in here and says we must be concerned with Christian principles. In other words, the suggestion is that in this Parliament in a Christian State Deputy Cogan is the leader of Christianity. He says it is wrong to bring in this Bill on Christian principles, as it has been condemned by Christian philosophers. Deputy Kissane, while complimenting him on his speech and very sensibly declaring he did not agree with him on a number of points, made some reference to the discussion that has gone on in the country in regard to this Bill. The whole principle of social welfare has been condemned by certain individuals. As far as this House and this Parliament is concerned, I am glad to see that Fianna Fáil adopt the same line as the Minister and the Government, that there is nothing unchristian in the Bill. If we have the Government side and the Fianna Fáil side both agreeing that there is nothing in conflict with Christian morals in it, it is impertinence on the part of Deputy Cogan to say that we are not dealing with the matter on Christian lines.

I have read a lot of the criticisms. I was at home one evening when I was approached by a couple of young ladies and I was asked to oppose this Bill, as a Catholic. I was told it was unchristian and entirely wrong. I asked a few questions about it. I wanted to know if it was wrong to have the old age pensions for so many years, to have unemployment insurance, unemployment assistance, and national health insurance benefits. Apparently there was nothing wrong in having those things, but when you brought them into a comprehensive scheme, when you administered them in one Department under one Minister, apparently there was something wrong. Those two ladies said to me, after I discussed it with them: "Oh, you are too clever for us, but we will give you a document which we hope will convince you as a Catholic that you must vote against the Bill."

The document they gave me was this: The Principles Against State Welfare Schemes, by the Rev. E.J. Hegarty, D.D., M.A., B.Ph., H.Dip. in Ed., Cork. I was interested and I read that document. I found in it declarations that seemed to me entirely unchristian—but it is not for me to say that they are. I explained to those ladies that in matters of religion I would be guided and directed by the declarations, statements and advice that might be given by persons in authority in the Catholic Church, and that as far as I was concerned it was entirely a matter for the Archbishop of Dublin to say that that was a Bill which was in conflict with Christian principles, but nobody else had any such right so to direct me. When I read this document I came to the conclusion that it was written by a person who was not in very close touch with realities. I came to the further conclusion that, instead of being a document of authority, it was a political pamphlet, and I use the word “political” in its broadest and widest sense—not a Party political, but a definite political document. One of the statements in this document is this:

"Tenants of corporation houses are known to saw the rafters off the roof for convenient fuel."

A statement such as that ought not to be made because it is untrue. It certainly ought not to be made by the Rev. E.J. Hegarty. He also says:

"Local schemes for giving allotments and seeds are a dismal failure. The ‘Dole' keeps 40,000 to 60,000 idle at a time when works of national importance are hindered by labour shortage. Those receiving State assistance often spend more actual money on amusements and luxuries than many farming or professional people could afford——"

Comment on this

Is that the whole context?

Comment on this

"——yet their diet, clothing and homes are sadly neglected, while their children roam the streets or are trained to beg for their father's (or mother's) pint."

That is written by the Rev. E.J. Hegarty as a condemnation of State welfare schemes. I say that the Rev. E.J. Hegarty ought to be ashamed of himself, and I make no apology to anybody for saying it. If he enters into the political field to write a political document, a document which I know to be scandalously untrue, I will answer him.

Comment on this

Would not outside be the better place?

Comment on this

I am answering him here because it has to do with this Bill. I am answering this document in this House. This document has this printed inside the front cover:—

"An article from an approved periodical, when republished separately, does not require a new imprimatur. (Code of Canon Law, Canon 1392, paragraph 2.)"

When he uses or attempts to use Canon Law for that sort of thing, I as a public representative will use this House for the purpose of condemning that document.

Comment on this

It would be better to do it outside.

Comment on this

I know where I will use it and Deputy Allen will not stop me. He can go out and make as much political capital as he can out of my condemnation of that document.

Comment on this

Shadow boxing.

Comment on this

The document proceeds:—

"If idlers will get family benefit up to £2 10s. weekly it will only encourage their parasitism, since it would hardly be worth the trouble to work at all for the duration of benefits..."

And again:—

"Better play for safety: do not work, and you get social security."

The ordinary Irish Catholic is not entitled to be condemned in the way he is condemned there—the ordinary Irish Catholic who has the misfortune to be unemployed, who has the misfortune to be ill, who has the misfortune to fall on evil days, who may occupy a cottage owned by a county council or by the Corporation of Dublin. I see Deputy Byrne is here. We have no complaints about tenants in Dublin sawing off the rafters of the roof for fuel. I do not suppose they do it in Cork.

Comment on this

We see to that.

Comment on this

I am sure you do. The reverend gentleman referred to the National Health Insurance Society and the taking over of that society by the State under recent legislation. Here is how he describes it:

"It can well be compared to the Tudor suppression of guilds, etc., and is even accompanied by a corresponding looting of funds (£6,750,000 national health assets are ‘transferred' (!) to the Department of Social Welfare)."

The action of this House in transferring funds, as would have been done no matter what Government was in office here, is described by the reverend gentleman as a looting of funds, and that is the individual who is held up here by Deputy Cogan as a person from whom we ought to take authoritative reasoning. I will not take that sort of reasoning and I hope the House will not take it. I am glad to know that the House does not take it.

Comment on this

He is perfectly right so far as that quotation is concerned.

Comment on this

He even wanders into the realm of land division in this.

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

It is not relevant to this Bill. Even if the author made a mistake, I hope the Deputy will not make the mistake of going too wide on this.

Comment on this

He uses this in his argument against a State welfare scheme. He says:

"Indiscriminate subdivision of estates is no social panacea."

Comment on this

That is also quite true.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not exaggerate that statement. It is quite harmless. It depends on what is meant by "indiscriminate".

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

We are bound by rules of order as to what is relevant or what is not. When that was being written perhaps he was not bound by them.

Comment on this

Then he talks about "the Chosen Ones". The workers who have been successful in organising themselves into trade unions are the "Chosen Ones". I agree there are some of our workers who are not yet members of trade unions, though I think they ought to be members of trade unions. I would like to see all our workers in trade unions. But they are the chosen ones, the trade unions. I cannot help coming to the conclusion that this form of attack has been used in connection with this Social Welfare Bill because the Bill has been introduced by a Labour leader. That is why I say I consider this to be a political document. "Why," the reverend gentleman says—and I think this has been quoted already in the debate—"why ought people to bother with any form of marriage at all if the State will care for them from the cradle to the grave?"—is not that a reflection on our community?—"by maternity benefits, children's allowances, public housing, free education, free medical attention, vouchers for food and clothing and fuel, free dole for the idle, finally a life-pension, a grant at death, and pensions for widows and orphans? If we have all these," he says—and we have some of them at the moment and we shall have more of them when this Bill is passed into law—"why bother with any form of marriage at all?" Then he says: "There is much sober truth in the paradox that we have as much right to free love as to free spectacles." That is the sort of document that has ben circulated throughout this country in condemnation of the principles of social security. I would not object so much if that document had been written by a professed politician or a professed sociologist; but when it is written by a clergyman, when it is supposed to carry on it an imprimatur and when it is circulated by religious organisations, then I think it ought to be condemned here and throughout the country.

If Dr. O'Hegarty, or anybody else, wants to enter into political discussions in relation to social welfare he is perfectly entitled to do so, but he is not entitled to do so under the cloak of an imprimatur and through the medium of certain organisations which believe that they are doing a Christian duty in circulating such a document. Dr. O'Hegarty condemns the White Paper. “It goes the further logical step,” he says, admitting that “schemes of social insurance and assistance ... are, in effect, a redistribution of the national income,” and then he asks the question: “Who gave the State this authority?” Who gave the State authority to redistribute the national income? That is the question Dr. O'Hegarty asks. Professor Ó Briain complained that the national income is not properly redistributed. Dr. O'Hegarty wants to know what right has Parliament to redistribute it. I think Parliament has every right to redistribute it.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan has expressed his opinion.

Comment on this

I have expressed my opinion in condemnation of this political document. Some of the allegations in it are an improper censure on our Catholic people, on the ordinary citizens of our country. These references to the mother's pint and to the cutting-down of the rafters in the houses for firewood would be bitterly resented had they been made by an enemy; I condemn them when they are made by an alleged friend.

It is an extraordinary thing that Rerum Novarum and Quadragesimo Anno have not been mentioned here. They have been in existence for a long time. Both have laid down the models which the Christian State should follow. It is significant that while we praise the theories in these excellent documents we find great difficulty in applying them in practice in our own State. Rerum Novarum and Quadragesimo Anno have been in existence for many years. What attempt has been made to model this State on the lines set out in those documents? None whatsoever. But when we try to bring in this social welfare scheme, when we try to abolish poverty and misery and hunger, when we try to give a new life to many of our citizens, when we try to give them the security to which they are entitled we are immediately told we must not do that but we must rather try to put into practice Christian principles. I have yet to learn that it is a Christian principle to allow people to go hungry, to allow them to be without shelter, to allow them to live in poverty; no one has ever taught me that that was a Christian philosophy or that they were Christian principles. I do not believe they are Christian principles and I do not believe it is a Christian philosophy. In any effort this Parliament makes to abolish poverty and want and misery and insecurity they are doing a Christian duty.

Every Party here has said at one election after another that we must bring our social welfare schemes up to the level of the social welfare schemes in the Six Counties and in Great Britain. Every Party said that was a sound practical step towards the ultimate abolition of Partition. I think that is a very sound view. Our Catholic colleagues in the Six Counties have been living under a social security scheme for a number of years. Our Catholic colleagues in Great Britain have been enjoying the benefits of a social security scheme for a number of years. I would like to meet the individual who, because they are enjoying the benefits of a social security scheme, would suggest to them that they are living in sin. I would like to meet the individual who would suggest to them that they ought to give up these benefits, that they were immoral and wrong and contrary to their principles and philosophy. But that sort of malicious propaganda can be used down here; it can be used down here for political purposes against the Minister and against trade unionism.

This Bill, when it becomes law, will bring us closer to the social security schemes in both Great Britain and the Six Counties and it will help to narrow the gap that divides us from them in matters of social welfare. It does not go as far as I would like it to go. It probably does not go as far as the Minister would like it to go but, in present circumstances, it is a solid attempt to create a sound foundation upon which we can build the finished edifice of social security and social welfare. I much prefer the bird in hand to the bird in the bush. I much prefer the bird that the Minister gives us here in this Bill to the bird that is flying around the Fianna Fáil bush and that may never be trapped.

Comment on this

We have it.

Comment on this

That is what I want, and that is why I want this social security scheme passed. This is not the last Social Security Bill or Social Welfare Bill that will be passed; clearly, it is not the last, and there will be many more of them passed. But we must start off with a solid foundation. There is this solid foundation, and I think it is a wise foundation—the solid foundation of contributions. When the worker contributes to social welfare, when he pays his 3/6 a week into that fund, an increase of 1/7 over what he was paying, he is contributing to a fund to which he has a moral right, a fund which must pay out the benefits that he pays his contributions for; he is not at the mercy of future Ministers for Finance who may, for Budget purposes, reduce those benefits. By the system of contributions, we are putting the worker in the position of being able to say: "I am contributing well to that fund; I am entitled to those benefits."

No politician, no matter what his political views may be, no Minister for Finance, can disturb or interfere with those important benefits. I will not go over them in great detail, but those benefits that are enshrined in the Bill are better than Deputy Dr. Ryan could give us through an insurance company. Deputy Kissane said that an insurance company could give greater benefits. I am quite certain Deputy Dr. Ryan has had this matter examined, and very closely examined, because he has facilities for examination and, taking it that people are going into this scheme irrespective of their state of health or age at the time they go in, I am quite certain that Deputy Dr. Ryan has been advised that no insurance company in this country, on the same contributions, could give the benefits that are laid down in this measure. If he has got an opinion from an actuary to the contrary, I defy him to produce that opinion to this House or to the public.

This is a good scheme and Deputy Dr. Ryan knows it is a good scheme. It is a scheme that will be of advantage to many thousands of our people. It will drive away the spectre of hunger and misery. We have had too much of that hunger and misery in this country for the past 25, 28 or more years. I do not mind what hunger was in this country before we got control of our own affairs, but it has been a lasting disgrace to the country, a lasting condemnation of the representatives of the people, that we should have had hunger and misery during the past 29 or 30 years when we had control of our own affairs.

The moralists will say: "You are asking the farmer to contribute something and he may not get benefit out of it." That is a new one. The political moralists are now saying that it is unfair to ask the farmers to contribute through taxation to this scheme because they may get no benefits out of it. This Parliament has been giving to the farming community in the past 25 or 30 years very substantial sums, amounting to millions. The farming community has been getting that from the taxpayers.

Comment on this

In what way?

Comment on this

They have been getting it in relief of agricultural rates, amounting to millions in the year.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Let us have this clear. Are our farmers not getting relief of agricultural rates?

Comment on this

They are not? Then I would like the farmer Deputies to discuss it with me. All I know is that the Book of Estimates provides for millions this year for the relief of agricultural rates and that money is paid out by the workers of Dublin, the workers of Cork and elsewhere.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

And the farmers are not paying half their share of income-tax, either. They are no paying their fair share of income-tax.

Comment on this

Let me finish on that point. The farmers have no objection in the world to taking that relief of agricultural rates, amounting to millions of pounds and contributed by some of the gentlemen that the Rev. Dr. Hegarty refers to. Dr. Hegarty has no concern about the millions of pounds that such people as the people in Moore Street and Coal Quay are contributing in taxes in order to give the farmers that relief amounting, as I have said, to millions in the year. He forgot that. If we look at the thing in a comprehensive way we know it is right that there should be some relief given to farmers——

Comment on this

Are you not getting cheap food, and be satisfied—the cheapest food in the world?

Comment on this

I am getting cheap food, not because Deputy Walsh wants to give it, but because he cannot get any more money out of me for it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This discussion is becoming very wide.

Comment on this

I am only making one point. This Bill is condemned because the farmers are asked to contribute to it and may not get any benefit out of it. I say that we, as a community, are contributing millions a year through taxation to the relief of agricultural rates, and the farmers are not a bit ashamed to take them from us.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy now come to the Bill?

Comment on this

It is always good to stop on a good point and I think that is a very good point to conclude a speech on. I said to Deputy Childers that this is a war. It is a war; it is a war between progress and reaction, progress here and reaction there.

Comment on this

Between Socialism and anti-Socialism.

Comment on this

It is a war between progress and reaction and progress is going to win now, as it always won. I am sorry to see a great Party like the Fianna Fáil Party, that had such a grand future, slipping back into reaction.

Comment on this

Do not worry about us.

Comment on this

I am sorry to see that, but we cannot stop it. Once Fianna Fáil have taken the line of opposing progress, there is a war on between the progressives and Fianna Fáil and in that warfare Fianna Fáil are going to the wall. They deserve to go to the wall.

Comment on this

I do not know quite how to begin to refute some of the nonsense talked by Deputy Cowan about Fianna Fáil, but I suppose I might start by saying that for the last 25 years we have preached in Fianna Fáil the conception of a progressive advance in social security measures. We started ourselves about half the social insurance schemes of this country. We extended them gradually and we have always adopted the point of view that if associations of producers and manufacturers or workers were unable or unwilling to insure themselves voluntarily against the different risks that occur in people's lives the State would have to do it. That has always been the policy of Fianna Fáil and, so far as I know, it always will be.

A great many of us regret that we did not secure independence at a sufficiently early date so that we could progress by the voluntary method as, for example, in the case of Denmark, where a great many of the social security schemes were started and promoted by co-operative societies, where people began by coming together in districts and insuring themselves against old age, sickness and disease. The principle gradually grew and the services increased until the State found it necessary to ensure a universal standard of efficiency, and found it necessary to provide a contribution for these societies. Unfortunately we only secured independence partially in 1921, and it was necessary for us to catch up, so to speak, on time that had been lost.

I wish to reiterate that Fianna Fáil has always stood for the principle of social security. That does not mean that we cannot criticise freely any Bill that is placed before us in this House. That does not mean that we are not in a position to say that you are spending too much on one particular service and too little on another. It is perfectly legitimate for us in Fianna Fáil to question the whole of the Social Security Bill on the grounds that the Government is increasing expenditure so wildly and with such an absolute lack of plan that the effect of expenditure on social security instead of being to help the worker might simply be to increase inflation and raise the cost of living by the mere fact that it threw another few millions a year into circulation on top of an already unbalanced Budget. that does not mean that we are opposed to the idea of social security.

When you have, first of all, the Social Security Bill, and then the offer of increased old age pensions—I might add, one of the lowest political bribes made in the history of this country in order to maintain the votes of certain individuals—plus an unknown amount for medical services, plus an unbalanced Budget of about £7,000,000, plus all the other plans they may have in mind so long as they can keep in office, we have a perfect right to say what we think about it.

I suppose we may have to repeat again for the hundredth time in this House what we did do about social services because Deputy Cowan talks about this Social Security Bill as though it were the first step in the history of the country to counteract poverty, as though poverty has never been fought before. He talked as though it was the first step to implement the Papal encyclicals. Such appalling ridiculous nonsense. For 16 years Fianna Fáil was in office, and in every year of its existence it passed measures in this House which had the general effect of implementing what might be described as a broadminded middle path interpretation of the encyclicals.

We started widows' and orphans' pensions. We started unemployment assistance. We initiated children's allowances. We initiated wet-time insurance. We increased widows' and orphans' pensions twice during our period of office. We increased old age pensions twice during our period of office. We increased unemployment assistance and unemployment insurance twice during our period of office and we also improved the national health insurance code and increased the benefits in it twice also.

Comment on this

And free milk.

Comment on this

And we did a great many things to help the people of this country on the lines of the Papal encyclicals.

Deputy Cowan, in the course of his speech, made an attack on a leaflet written by a clergyman against this Bill. I think that one of the most interesting and stimulating things in this country is the fact that you can read leaflets on the subject of social welfare written by clergymen of a number of denominations giving their individual points of view with regard to a social problem. I see no reason why they should not do it.

It is a little ridiculous for Deputy Cowan to suggest that when the word "imprimatur” was written on the front cover it was supposed to mean it was infallible. We all know that was a perfectly ridiculous suggestion and that was the idea that Deputy Cowan tried to convey. As I have said, it is a very interesting thing to have stimulating conversations and discussions on this question written by people who have regard to religious doctrine. The more we have of it the better so long as everybody understands that there are various interpretations of these things.

I might add, too, that while Deputy Cowan made this attack on this clergyman who chose to oppose the Security Bill, he did not mention the fact that two of the principal leaders of Fine Gael, in speeches made since this Government came into office, indicated that they agreed substantially with every word written by that clergyman.

Comment on this

Will you quote them?

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

Dr. Hegarty spoke generally against what he described as the adverse social effects of State social security. I have not the reference here but somebody on this side of the House can give it possibly and the reference made by Deputy Costello, the Taoiseach, in 1949, in which he spoke of social services as medicine bottles to be taken out of the cupboard on the rarest possible occasions. Nobody can deny that the speech was made. It has been quoted a dozen times in this House and he has never refuted it.

Comment on this

The statement made by Deputy Childers was that a specific article which was read in the discussion here was approved in statements by two Ministers. He has made reference to a speech made by the present Taoiseach when, I think, he was in opposition.

Comment on this

Possibly when he was in the Government. I would ask the Deputy to give the quotation where there was specific endorsement of the views read out here to-day.

Comment on this

I do not suggest that the Taoiseach directly approved of the pamphlet written by the clergyman in question. What I do say is the view he expressed that social services could be regarded in the nature of medicines coincided to a considerable degree with the general view expressed by the clergyman. I did not say he gave it his specific blessing.

I now have the actual quotation and maybe it is just as well to read it to the House to indicate how far prominent Ministers of Fine Gael are prepared to sacrifice their own point of view in order to maintain a Government in office. Speaking on 13th May, 1947, at column 73 of the Official Debates, the Taoiseach said:

"Money is wanted for social services. That is the justification for all the extravagances that have been perpetrated and inflicted upon this country by Government profligacy in the last six or seven years. ... The existence of social services is an indication of ill-health in the body politic. In any case, as has been said, they are nothing more than a row of medicine bottle showing disease in the household."

That is not the point of view of Fianna Fáil. We have never had any objection to the idea that if associations of men and women of the various professions are unwilling to collect amongst themselves the amount required to provide for the expenses and difficulties of life, the State can come in, and, by way of contributions from workers, by way of State taxation and contributions from employers, redistribute a portion of the national income and, in fact, effect compulsory saving. That is what this Bill does and what Deputy Ryan's proposals do. They both compel people to save for themselves against disaster and against the difficult circumstances of life. It is a compulsory saving Bill and it is just as well that we stopped a lot of the claptrap being talked about it, as though the money were coming from nowhere, as though the people were not paying for it. Like all other measures of social security, it is compulsory saving and nothing else, and people are being made to save in spite of themselves by this Bill. The rich pay a little more than the poor in the way of saving, but the vast majority of the people will be paying for the vast proportion of the cost of these services.

Deputy Cowan suggested that the Fianna Fáil Party, because of its attitude towards the Bill was showing signs of defeat. I am quite agreeable to accept his challenge. I would not mind if we went to the country and had a general election, and even if we went so far as to say that we will postpone the Social Security Bill for one year until we can see if we can find enough money to put this country into a state of preparedness in view of the present emergency. If we put that to the people of the country, I am absolutely certain that we would gain an over-all majority and I would not be in the least afraid of accepting the challenge on that basis. That is my answer to Deputy Cowan when he suggests that we are a Party in defeat.

So far as the details of the Bill are concerned, I want to refer in particular to the absence of any improvement in the children's allowances and to the fact that they are included in the scheme put forward by Deputy Ryan. I am becoming a little ashamed of the degree to which we exploit the old people of this country in order to get votes. I am tired of all the talk that is carried on with a view to attracting the votes of 158,000 old age pensioners and I believe that the vast majority of these old age pensioners are not going to accept any bribe offered to them. I am tired of hearing so much talk about the old age pensioners, who represent 5.26 per cent. of the whole population, or one in 20, and so little talk about the children of the country who have no votes and about whom one cannot arouse the same popular political clamour.

I might add that when Deputy Cowan suggests that the 1944 election was fought on the subject of children's allowances, he was talking the most arrant nonsense. Everyone who remembers the 1944 election knows that it was fought on a number of general issues and that children's allowances were scarcely mentioned in it. On very few occasions did Fianna Fáil specifically offer a particular social service on the eve of an election. Most of the great social services we instituted were either scarcely mentioned in our election programme or instituted during the period in between elections as was the case with widows' and orphans' pensions.

I think it is time we talked a little more about children in this country. We hear a great deal of talk throughout the country about old age pensioners and about the great increase being offered by this Government, but we hear no reference to the fact that the previous Government twice increased old age pensions and we hear still less reference to a far more important subject, the whole question of the support to be given to people with large families. We hear everywhere about old age pensioners getting a half-crown more a week, but we hear very little about the dull and nonpolitical national nutritional survey prepared by a group of experts and presented by the present Government and with absolutely no contentious or adverse criticism by the present Minister for Health, the implication being that there is nothing wrong in the reports, nothing which need be criticised and that the information in them is correct. This kind of stuff is dull and does not draw votes, but in it lies a clue to the solution of a great deal of the problem of poverty in this country.

Every one of these five reports shows that if there is any real grinding poverty left in this community, if there are any adverse circumstances affecting people's lives which require attention, it is in the case of families of four, five and more children. These five reports are full of dull statistics but these statistics are fundamental. They may be dull but they deal with the amount and kind of food eaten by people of various grades of society, of every grade of society, according to the size of the family. They show beyond all doubt that there is too little spent on food in numerous families among the working people; they show beyond all doubt that there are far too many bread-and-spread meals amongst workers' families, small farmers' families, congested district farmers' families and agricultural workers' families, where there are four and more children. They show also that in many large families there is a great and serious deficiency of certain kinds of vitamins and foods. They show that workers who have large families provide a monotonous and deadly diet for their children, try as they will to produce the best they can for them.

Every one of these reports shows that No. 1 upon the programme of the Minister for Social Welfare should have been an increase in children's allowances. There is not the faintest evidence that there is the same condition of poverty or strain of existence in workers' families where there are only one, two or three children. They have their difficulties. The cost of living is very high, but the real core of the problem is among the persons with large families. I want to give it as my private point of view that again I think it is a great pity we were not an independent nation a long time ago, because in relation to a country like ours, where families are large and marriages are late, if ever there was a case for all trade union wages being based on the size of the family, it exists in this country.

I know perfectly well that it would be asking an enormous amount of both employers and trade unions to reorganise the wage structure of the country so that people would be paid, as they are in certain continental countries, on the basis of the number of persons in their family and their marital state. I know well it would be extremely difficult to work out the whole problem of ensuring that there would be no discrimination against married workers and workers with large families by employers. I am not asking trade unionists to do it, because I realise it is an almost insuperable problem; but the only alternative to it is a gift by the people with no family and with small families and by the unmarried people to the people with large families. There is no other solution of the problem of the poverty of the worker with a large family, and my criticism of this Bill to-night is that it does not provide sufficiently or, in fact, in any way, for an increased scale of children's allowances. I am not ashamed and not in the least afraid to say, putting it this way, that I do not want particularly to see £1,000,000 spent on increased old age pensions unless, before that happens, a certain amount of money is spent on increased children's allowances, and if it is decided that we can afford increased children's allowances, I am prepared to agree that, with the present cost of living and under present circumstances, it is a good thing to increase old age pensions by another 2/6 per week but, as I have said, to my mind, the whole question of children's allowances should be considered.

To my mind also there is very great need for an extension of child welfare in the City of Dublin. There is very great need for an extension of child welfare of every kind by contributions to voluntary societies and, if necessary, to societies to some degree stimulated by the State for looking after the children of large families in Dublin. A great deal of the poverty and a great deal of the mortality of which Dr. Browne, the Minister for Health, has spoken exists because of the difficulties of mothers in looking after large families, particularly when the family is increasing or about to increase in numbers, and the Minister for Health's scheme, which forms the subject for another discussion, does nothing to deal with that social difficulty. It is dealt with partly by charitable societies and by the conventual orders. It is not dealt with sufficiently. It still exists, and it all adds to my argument that the children in large families deserve the first consideration of the Government, before anyone else.

I do not know whether it is necessary for me to quote from this report. Not half enough about it has been spoken in the country in general. I do not know whether it is necessary for me to read the figures, in order that they should be recorded in the House, in connection with the differences in expenditure by people with large families and by people with small families. Some of the information is very interesting and it seems to me that it should receive far more study from members of the House. For example, I take the dietary survey of the farm workers' families and I deal with table 4 (b)—the average expenditure per diet head weekly on food in 177 farm workers' families, classified according to the number of persons in the family—and I find that the total amount spent on food per diet head in the case of a family without children, per week, is 19/6; the total amount spent per head in a family of eight, nine, ten or eleven persons is 10/1, which is just about 50 per cent. less. If anybody tells me that there is not need for readjustment of the children's allowances, in face of that simple statement that in farm workers' families where there is a large number of children there is spent about onehalf of that which is spent by a man and his wife without children, I should like to hear the criticisms of the suggestion that more should be done.

In the summary of the Report on the National Nutrition Survey, the following paragraph occurs—No. 2, on page 11:—

"The consumption of meat, milk, eggs, vegetables and fruit increased consistently as income increased, and decreased with almost equal consistency as the number of persons in the family increased....

Milk consumption at 5.1 pints per head per week was low for a rural survey; the figure in Dublin City was 4.8 pints and in farming families was 9.2 pints."

In other words, agricultural workers with large families were drinking half the milk of the farmers living around them and were drinking very little more milk than persons living in Dublin City.

I do not want to take the time of the House by repeating the main conclusions of these reports but they go to indicate what I said before that children's allowances deserve the first consideration of the Minister.

I would like to ask the Minister, in connection with this Bill, what he thinks will be the social effect of the provision in the Bill whereby a farm of under £30 valuation can be assigned without any conditions being attached thereto. I should like to ask him whether he thinks it will encourage the settlement of the farm on younger people or whether he thinks it will have any adverse effect. I should like to hear what views he has to express in regard to that matter.

I am very disappointed that, when the Minister decided to introduce an increase in the non-contributory old age pension of 2/6 a week, he did not reconsider the whole question of the character of the means test. As I understand it, three-quarters of the persons of age over 70 in this country are now receiving an old age pension of some kind or another. They amount to just over 5 per cent. of the entire population. One in every 20 people you meet is getting an old age pension of one kind or another. It is a very large number of people. It seems to me there are two simple courses that should be adopted, either one of which might get over the difficulty of the means test which involves an examination of savings, an examination of the income attached to small plots in the case of cottage dwellers, an examination of all the elements of thrift in the life of an applicant for an old age pension. The first is, to give everybody in the community an old age pension automatically, which would cost a considerable amount of money, which does not on the whole seem fair to me; the second would be a simple valuation limit, such as has been proposed in Deputy Dr. Ryan's alternative proposals. If three-quarters of the people over 70 years of age are entitled to draw an old age pension, is there anything socially unfair in simplifying the means test, particularly in rural districts, in making the means test depend on valuation and having, in addition to that, the question of the maximum amount of cash that can be held? Would not it save a great deal of administrative expense and would not it save, as I have said, the continuous examination of a man's thrift in life? Would it create any abuses? Can the Minister for Social Welfare say in what percentage of cases there might be a very unfair refusal of an old age pension to a person because he happened to be above or below the line? It seems to me this suggestion is well worth considering before the Bill reaches its final stages, because such a huge proportion of the older people do finally get a pension and they amount to such a large proportion of the community.

Deputy Cowan and Deputy Cogan, in speaking on this Bill, discussed the question of unemployment. I cannot understand Deputy Cogan's point of view that the Government must guarantee work and cannot and should not guarantee maintenance in lieu of work. The problem that affects this country is that which affects most countries, the fact that labour is not mobile to a considerable degree. The people will not leave their homes in many cases. Another section of the people in the community like to leave their homes or have to leave them under compulsion. There is a great deal of winter unemployment, while in summer in many areas it is difficult to find workers. Workers have neither the desire nor have they the training, in many cases, to move from one occupation to another. It struck me as extraordinarily old-fashioned of Deputy Cogan to suggest that the Government has only a right to guarantee work and should not guarantee maintenance in lieu of work, because the Government that could provide work for the people of this country to the degree of 100 per cent. all the year round, in winter and summer, in rural and urban districts, if there was a profound depression in England and if there was absolutely no employment for workers who have been leaving this country for many years—in very large numbers under the present Government, I might add—would be a miraculous Government under the circumstances. There must always be some insurance provision, some assistance provision, for those who are unable to find work either temporarily or for considerable periods. In fact, a great deal of what Deputy Cogan said struck me as being extraordinarily old-fashioned, something like what one would hear coming from the British Conservative Party about the year 1910. He seemed to refuse to accept the general principle of a social security plan under which the Government would undertake to provide necessities for persons unable to provide for themselves. In conclusion, I should like once more to ask the Minister to consider the alternative measures put forward by Deputy Dr. Ryan, particularly because of the fact that under these measures provision is made for increased children's allowances where families are large.

Comment on this

The speech of Deputy Lemass here last evening gave ground for the hope that there would be a new approach to this Bill, so far as the Opposition is concerned. The main speech from the Front Opposition Bench, at least in my hearing, since Deputy Leamss spoke was delivered by Deputy Kissane. I must confess that I was disappointed by the speech of Deputy Kissane, coming as it did from a Deputy in a responsible position as a member of the Front Opposition Bench, because the appeal—I think it might be classed as such—of Deputy Lemass seemed to have fallen on completely deaf ears, so far as Deputy Kissane was concerned. The speech of Deputy Kissane on this subject might be described as a purely destructive political speech. I was disappointed in the sense that the Deputy paid very little attention to the Bill or to those aspects of the Bill referred to in such an admirable tone by Deputy Lemass last evening. I had hoped that if Deputy Lemass were to succeed in convincing his colleagues along the lines which he indicated last night, it might best be reflected in the vote of our friends on the Left, were they to allow the Second Reading of this measure to go through unanimously and then apply themselves to whatever improvements might be effected in the normal course of the Committee Stage.

I want to pay tribute also to the manner in which Deputy Dr. Ryan made his contribution to the debate on this Bill prior to the Recess. I should say that it was admirable in tone and, from his point of view, in content as well. Notwithstanding that he was obviously at a disadvantage in not having at his disposal official resources, he evidently gave considerable thought to the proposals he outlined. Deputy Dr. Ryan rendered one extremely valuable service to the promoters of the Bill. He removed once and for all the impression that was being sedulously fostered outside that this Government, and this Government only, were responsible for fastening on the shoulders of the community an unwanted Bill, not only an unwanted Bill but a Bill that might be harmful in many directions. We have heard since these proposals were first promulgated, criticisms and references to such well-known phrases as the "Welfare State", "Socialism", "Totalitarianism", and so on. To Deputy Dr. Ryan's credit and to Deputy Lemass's credit, may I say that they made no attempt whatever to cash-in on the particular atmosphere that was being created.

The service that Deputy Dr. Ryan rendered in my opinion was that he removed any lingering doubts there might be amongst the public outside that this was a one-sided measure; in fact he conveyed the impression that if Deputy Dr. Ryan and his Party had the opportunity all they would do would be to extend the terms of the Bill, even though the extension of its terms might mean, and in fact would mean considerable taxation. I think we are entitled to ask the critics outside, because so far we have not had many critics here, is there anything in this problem of social security which justifies the idea that we should have a different approach to it from any other country in the world?

Social security, as I understand it, is based very largely on four factors— the hazards of old age, illness, unemployment and widowhood. The incidence of these disabilities or these particular conditions is no less severe here than in any other country in the world. One would imagine from the criticisms we have heard that the proposals now before the House are of an extremely revolutionary character. Indeed may I say that it was suggested in certain quarters that they are contrary to Catholic teaching. That is completely fallacious. This Bill is largely a co-ordinating Bill, in respect to social services existing under certain categories at the present time. I am prepared to admit, and I am proud to admit, one revolutionary change, one that we as members of the Labour Party particularly hail with pleasure— the provision at long last of a retirement pension at the age of 65.

At the present time there is provision of a kind for old age. This Bill proposes to improve the provision in two ways, along the lines of a contributory retirement pension at 65 and, at the non-contributory end, to increase the old age pension up to £1 per week. There is also an improvement in the position of the man who is stricken down with illness. Be it said that up to the present the only provision, in this year of grace, 1951, for a man who falls ill is that made under the National Health Insurance of 22/6 per week, irrespective of the number of dependents he may have. The worst feature of that provision is the fact that after six months of illness the law at present provides that the man's benefit drops to 15/- a week. That position is being improved under this Bill.

Under the standardisation which is taking place in the Bill, a standardisation of a welcome character, the benefit is increased to 24/- a week for the man himself, 12/- for his wife and 7/- for two dependent children. May I say that I think Deputy Cogan completely missed the point of the photograph which appeared in the little brochure which depicts the children in the home? The people who prepared the brochure had obviously made up their minds that there was provision for children under the family allowances after the second child.

An improvement also takes place in the case of the unemployed man. It is precisely the same with the man who has the misfortune to be unemployed. Deputy Cogan made the point that there would be no need, or should be no need, for benefit of this particular character, and he is supported by some evidence outside the House, based on the argument that the State should make the necessary provision by way of work. That is a delightful conception but, as a colleague of mine remarked, we are not yet living in the perfect State, and what is the unfortunate individual to do if he does not get work and no provision is made for him? There is an improvement in the Bill in respect to unemployment benefit, which is raised from 35/- a week for a man with a wife and two children to 50/- per week under the Bill. There is a substantial improvement, too, in the case of widows.

It is pleasing to be able to say that there is agreement on the left of this House on the main lines which a social security measure should take. As outlined by Deputy Dr. Ryan the Party on my left did indicate disagreement under two main heads. One is that in Deputy Dr. Ryan's scheme there would be no retirement pension at the age of 65. The pension would operate only from the age of 70. His second main contention, speaking for his Party, was that the scheme should be financed out of taxation.

This Bill takes precisely a different line. As its title indicates, it is a Bill based on the insurance principle. It is one which, I think, will meet with the approval of this House as against the proposal in regard to taxation. It will mean this, that a man will have associated with his pension a sense of dignity on the one hand and of stability on the other. He will feel a measure of independence, derived from the fact that he has made a serious contribution towards the pension which he receives. It is really only on matters of detail that there is a difference between our friends and ourselves. There is, however, that very serious defect to which I have referred in the statement that was put forward by Deputy Ryan. His appeal for the adoption of his case was that he could bring into operation practically the same benefits as are outlined in the Bill without the addition of contributions. The Deputy, I am sure, is not so simple as to have completely ignored the fact that this Bill, and the terms incorporated in it, are based largely on actuarial calculations. These calculations were prepared, I understand, by a very able staff, and the Bill, under the Minister's guidance, is standing the test of what they produced.

Deputy Dr. Ryan, as I say, made the point that he could introduce his scheme, with some additions, but with no increased contributions. He based his argument on the fact that he would not have to give retirement pensions until the age of 70. On this question of retirement at 70 as against 65, Deputy Dr. Ryan made the point that the expectation of life to-day is much better than it has been over a period of years. That is true. It is gradually improving under better social conditions. The Deputy made the point, and there will be some who will agree with him, that people over the age of 65 are in a position to give a contribution towards the national pool and so would prefer to be in the position to earn their regular wages rather than be depending on a pension in the form of 24/- a week at that age. But it was not just enough for the Deputy to leave it at that, to base his calculations for financing his scheme in that way because to do so was to ignore the fundamental fact that the tendency with employers over a number of years past in this country has been to lay off their employees at the age of 65.

Deputy Cogan spoke as if men, in the ordinary course, went on earning after they had reached the age of 65. There are members of this House who can vouch for the fact that some employers, in any case, have been only too eager to seize the opportunity of dispensing with their workers about that age. I have had some experience of that, and I can speak on it with some little knowledge. Over many years it was my duty to pay men in a very large concern in this city. Speaking out of that experience, I can say that the most dreaded years in a railway man's life were the years between 65 and 70. Men were thrown out at 65, very often on a meagre 16/a week, reducible by 10/- when they reached the age of 70, because at that stage the State took over a certain amount of the pension liability. As I say our difference with Deputy Dr. Ryan, and it is fundamental to this Bill and to this whole question, is that in his proposals he makes no provision whatever for men when they reach the age of 65. I personally—I do not know what my colleagues may think about it—would be prepared to say that, provided a man wanted to stay on after 65 with the consent of his employer, I would see no objection to that course—that is provided he had the protection afforded by the terms of this Bill when he retired at the age of 65. I would see no objection to that so long as the man was protected against an employer who wanted to put him out or, on the other hand, if the man himself wanted to retire voluntarily at that age.

There might be an inducement to consider that if we were discussing this Bill in a different atmosphere—that is, that so long as a man was entitled to his pension at 65, he could remain in employment with the consent of his employer for one, two or three years, as the case may be, and so save the State fund the amount of pension that he otherwise would normally take in those years. As I say, if we were discussing the Bill in a different atmosphere, that is a suggestion which might be worth while examining, as well as the point as to whether or not he should get a bonus when he retired at, say, the age of 66 or 67 to compensate him for the years during which he had not been paid the retirement pension.

Suppose he got an extra 2/6 for each year over the 65—that might prove an attractive proposition, and might be worth while considering. All that would be subject to the basic proposition that there must be provision in the Bill for the man when he retires at the age of 65. Having said that, may I say that the Fianna Fáil plan, in my estimation, completely crumbles at that stage. It crumbles also on the question of finance. Deputy Dr. Ryan's case right through was based on the fact that he could cover all this by means of taxation. I think if he were to start with taxation to finance his proposals, he would find that the taxation would run into a figure which would probably frighten himself.

As I have said, there are points of agreement between us and those on the other side. That position was possibly best expressed by Deputy Lemass, whose social outlook, generally speaking, will not be questioned. His idea was that this matter might be examined in an atmosphere which is rarely to be found in this House, in an atmosphere in which all parties might agree on an objective that was worth while achieving. Unfortunately, we have not yet reached that stage. In my opinion, this is a good Bill. It has been carefully drawn and its financial provisions are such as to safeguard it throughout the existence of the scheme. There is to be a contribution from the employer, from the employee and from the State. Some Deputies made the point that the scheme was one-sided in so far as a number of people were excluded. May I say that it was very definitely the desire of the Minister, and I am sure all members of the House will agree on it, too, that all sections of the community who deserved to be included in it should be included, were that administratively practicable.

A reference to the speech made by Deputy Dr. Ryan will show that he said that if this scheme is to be based on a contributory system then the individuals who are left out must be left out: there is no alternative. If that be so, why, therefore, should there be any necessity for a violent opposition as between sections of this House, if that opposition will be reflected in a close division here for or against the Bill?

It has been stated in this House that the incorporation of the item of old age pensions was one which, to repeat what Deputy Kissane said, was tantamount to blackmail. As one member of this House—the various other members may speak for themselves— I can say that since the first increase was given by this Government in 1948 we have been agitating, and we make no secret of it, that the terms of a motion which was defeated in this House in March, 1946, and which was put down by members on these benches, should be implemented at the earliest possible date. The terms of that motion were that old age pensions should be stepped up to 22/6 a week— the figure that was operating in the Six Counties—and that income to the level of £1 per week should be excluded so far as the means test was concerned. We have not reached that objective yet but I suggest that we are on the way to meeting it. This increase brings us very near at least that particular target except that the question of the means test is not as seriously dealt with as we should like it to be. If there is anything that makes an appeal to the members of this House as a whole it is the question of the means test. I hope it will be possible, as a next move and stage by the Government here, to take steps to ensure that this last barrier to that £1 a week income will be removed at the earliest possible date.

I should like to congratulate the Minister on this measure and also those who were associated with him in drawing it up. I appeal to our friends across the way to join with us in improving the Bill in the appropriate place along the lines which they and possibly we also should like in certain respects.

Comment on this

I am glad that this measure has been introduced. When I first heard about the intention to introduce this Bill I was wholly in favour of a further improvement in our social scheme and I indicated that I would give my wholehearted support to the measure. Any improvement in our social welfare scheme deserves all the support and help it can get from the members of this House.

Social welfare, in general, has changed very much over a great number of years. If the people who first drew the 5/- old age pension from the British Government could be alive to-day and see the step-up in regard to social welfare generally, and hear that this Department is getting the attention which it deserves to get, I suppose they would be very surprised. Then again there is the fact that people see social welfare in a different light nowadays. We have heard it said that the first payments of old age pensions were looked on with suspicion and that for many years people who were genuinely entitled to receive the old age pension refused to make application for it because of the dreaded fear of the "Saxon's shilling" as it was called at the time. That deterred them from availing of something to which they were genuinely entitled. However, times have moved on and we now have a native Government. Social welfare is under the care of a Department of State, and it is a responsibility which the Government, whichever Government it may be, must shoulder. While the poor will always be with us we must make provision for them. It is only fair that those who have should share with those who have not. It is the duty of the Government to see that there is as equitable a distribution of the funds as possible, so as to ensure that necessitous people will get the benefits to which they are entitled. In the past 20 years there have been many social welfare advances.

In my remarks on this measure I should like to say that I am going to speak my own mind irrespective of whom my remarks may offend or otherwise. My honest opinion is that the introduction of the widows' and orphans' pensions was as big a step in the right direction as any step that ever was or ever can be introduced in the line of social welfare. That may be something in the nature of a clap on the back to the Fianna Fáil Government, which was in office at the time, but I think it should be said, in all fairness to them, that it was a good move to introduce legislation to provide assistance for a widow to enable her to get along and to provide for her children instead of her having a continuous hand-to-mouth struggle, with poverty staring in at her through the door.

As the value of money has slowly but surely decreased it is only right that the amount of money payable to widows and orphans and to old age pensioners generally should be increased. As the value of money goes down, more money is made available to them. In that way the pensions are brought to such a standard that the people receiving them will be able to purchase to the same extent as they were able to purchase previously with the lesser amount of money which was made available some time ago. I am glad that, under this Bill, the Minister, amongst other things, is providing for an improvement in the old age pension and that it will be increased to 20/- per week. One of the ten points of the programme which this Government decided to implement when they came into office was to improve the old age pension. Deputy O'Sullivan referred to his desire to get the old age pension raised to 22/6 per week. I suggest that the £1 a week is a step in the right direction and that before much longer our hopes that it will be increased to 22/6 may be realised.

We know that contributory and non-contributory pensions differ very widely. We know that it is impossible to ask any Government to provide out of taxation the same pension on a non-contributory basis as the pension which is paid on a contributory basis. Nevertheless when an effort is made to increase old age pensions I know that Deputies must find it very much against their conscience to disagree with it or oppose it in any manner whatsoever. We know that a certain amount of political propaganda can be made—there is no use in saying that it will not—and that a certain amount of votes can be collected because of an improvement in the condition of old age pensioners. To announce an increase in old age pensions is a great catchcry from every political platform, but no matter what political manoeuvring may be done not one should in justice oppose giving an increase in pensions or allowances to old age pensioners.

What is perhaps of greater value to old age pensioners than the increase is the modification of the means test and above all, the almost entire removal of that section of the 1908 Act which was a real barrier to many genuine applicants for the old age pension, that section which provided that when a person, on reaching the age of 70, transferred his property to his children, it was still assessed when he applied for a pension, although he did it in a genuine and honest attempt to settle his family affairs. In this country, where the family circle is held so closely together, it is a very difficult problem, even at the age of 70, for a man or woman to settle the affairs of the family overnight. Where a genuine honest applicant for the pension has settled his affairs by transferring to his children whatever he has saved by hard endeavour during his life he should not, at the age of 70, be deprived of a pension, but up to now that has been the case. Deputies who from time to time must approach the Department of Social Welfare or the Minister on behalf of those people find that the sympathy of the Minister, of many officials in the Department and even of the investigating officer who investigates their means is in all cases with the old age pensioner, but nevertheless the barrier existed in this section of the 1908 Act, and no matter what good intentions were in the minds of the people concerned, the old age pensioner was left and nothing could be done for him. Even when an appeal was made a year or two afterwards, it was found that the means he had transferred to his children were still assessed as his and neither the Department nor the Minister could do anything to help. The removal of that barrier is a greater revolution than the advancing of the pension from 17/6 to 20/-.

We know that all this advancement of pensions means extra taxation because money cannot fall like manna from the heavens and that, in itself, is a difficult problem for the Minister for Social Welfare, the Minister for Finance and the Government as a whole. They must try, on the one hand, to hold taxation level, because everybody admits that it is going slightly beyond the bounds at the present time and, on the other hand, to make life a bit easier for the poorer classes in their struggle to exist.

Increased allowances are made to persons who are contributing. The ex-Minister for Social Welfare and even the present Minister have admitted that a genuine comprehensive social insurance scheme whereby all people in the State would benefit is something very hard to bring before the House and enforce. When I speak on that matter I speak for quite a large percentage of the people who put me here, the self-employed industrious small farmers who never can benefit from a contributory scheme because it would be absolutely and entirely impossible to collect contributions from them. Very often their income is not weekly; such a person may go through three or four months without a £1 note coming in on a Saturday night and then for a month or two a fairly substantial amount may come in. Self-employed people have at least a certain amount of freedom and can say that they are under no obligation to anybody to pay any contribution to anything so as to get an allowance when they come to retiring age. The small landowner or shopkeeper is as well able at 65 to work or supervise his business as he was ten, 15 or 20 years earlier. Because he has that independence and freedom such a man feels that it would be unfair to ask him to pay any contribution whatsoever to any scheme. While in all fairness to them we must admit that they are as valuable to the State as those who are employed they could not possibly benefit to the same extent as people who over a large number of years had been contributing week in week out to an insurance scheme. I had hoped that a scheme might be considered where you would take a very low land valuation and say that irrespective of everything else the means test would be entirely abolished and that anybody with a holding of land under £10 valuation would become automatically entitled to an old age pension when he or she reached the age of 70. That would be as revolutionary for the countryside for the non-contributors and for the rural population as the contributors find the Bill before us to-night.

All these things have to move very slowly. Social welfare of all types has moved slowly enough in past years, yet still when we look back over a short space of time we find that it has moved rapidly, as rapidly as the country could afford. The people who have to pay must be considered as well as those who have not to pay. The beneficiary as well as the contributor in any social scheme must be taken into consideration, when the Government decide to introduce a measure to assist people in need. We have some sections in the Bill for which extra demands will be made on taxpayers, ratepayers and others. I speak for some of those who will have to pay. The ordinary local authority or county council in every county is a very large employer of men, and has on its books a larger pay roll than that of any firm or industry in the county concerned. The increased contribution of 3/6 per week, which the local authority will have to pay as its share towards the pension, must come entirely out of the rates. Ratepayers must realise now that, if they themselves or their sons or daughters who work for the county council on road schemes, drainage schemes or in offices are to benefit by increased pension, by sickness benefits and so on, the father, or perhaps the person in the employment of the local authority, will have to pay not only his own 3/6 per week but, through the rates, the little extra which helps to meet the local authority contribution of 3/6 which must be paid every week for every single individual employed by that authority. However, when one is balanced against the other, the ratepayers who have to meet this extra charge will not complain or grouse, because of the benefits which will accrue to those people who are employed. There are sickness and maternity benefits which come at a time when money is most needed to help the weak and needy.

At the present time we have a national health insurance scheme. Personally, I think it needs an overhaul of some kind. To my mind, it is at present something of a racket, as a person may be a genuine contributor for a good many years, then fall off because of unemployment and then start again as a casual worker making casual contributions and then fall off again; yet when that person is ill and applies for sickness benefit he will find that the many hundreds of contributions paid genuinely and honestly over a long number of years will be of no use to him. They will be ruled out because there has been a lapse of a few weeks or a few months when he was unemployed. It would be hard to expect that he could pay when he was not working. When he was employed, if he did not pay his contributions he was guilty of an offence, he was breaking the law and could be prosecuted. Yet when the scheme is boiled down and he comes to look for benefit, it takes a lot to drag even the slightest benefit out of the pockets of the National Health Insurance Society. That is to be overhauled to a certain extent in the Bill and I am glad of that, as the national health scheme was not working out as satisfactorily as we would have liked.

It is pointed out in the Bill that the liability for the contributions rests primarily on the employer. That may be right or it may be wrong. I am in full agreement that an employer must stamp the card for the employee, but I still think that a certain amount of the liability should also rest on the employee. We know of cases, particularly with farm workers, where the employer has to meet the entire cost at present of both contributions. It is an easy-going system between the agricultural labourer and his employer. The farmer provides the stamps at the end of the week and just does not bother to make deductions. He says: "You have given service to the value of the contribution and I will pay the whole lot." I know from my personal experience that that is carried out in many cases, though not in every case, and the entire contribution of employer and employee is paid by the employer. That was all right when the amount involved was small, but when you have a 7/- per week contribution, which is to be collected now— 3/6 from the employer and 3/6 from the employee—it would be very unfair not to put a certain liability on the employee just as well as on the employer for the stamping of the card.

If an employer pays his 3/6 per week, week after week, and the employee does not, I do not think there is anything in the Bill which will give credit for the contributions when the employee has not paid up. Therefore, I would suggest, in all fairness, to the Minister for Social Welfare that it should be as much of a liability on the employee, who is the beneficiary, to stamp his card each week as it is on the employer. To make the job simple, perhaps there could be some double stamp or a card with a double section, leaving room for the employer's stamp and the employee's stamp. That would make it plain to the officials of the Department who was the defaulter in the case. If the employer had put on the stamp for 20, 50 or 100 contributions and the employee was down by 20 or 30 sections, it would be easy to see who was failing to keep up to scratch. Something will have to be done with regard to that. If this entire burden is thrown, in the present free and easy manner, on the employer to pay the entire contribution, the burden of 7/- per week will be definitely too heavy. I expect that all that will be handled by the Tánaiste when he comes to make whatever ministerial amendments may be necessary. I am putting the suggestion genuinely, that it would be better for both employer and employee to have some such scheme, that it would make for easier administration and for more friendship and better companionship between employer and employee.

The Bill as a whole is a welcome one. The introduction of social welfare is a move which I will support and back up and will definitely recommend to the people of the country. Anywhere I have gone, I have pointed out the many benefits that will be derived from this Bill. There are many other things yet for the Government to tackle so as to provide a really comprehensive scheme. I am not finding fault with the many advances made in social welfare in the past, in fairness to the Opposition. As I said at the outset, I regard the widows' and orphans' pensions as one of the best social welfare schemes introduced in this country. It was even a more valuable and a more necessary piece of legislation than the Children's Allowances Bill which was introduced at a later stage.

This is a good Bill and, while it may not be up to the standard we would like to provide for the poorer paid classes and the less well-to-do classes, it is an advance in its own way. Just as other schemes have advanced in the past, social welfare is advancing now, and I hope it will be found possible at some future time to make further advances. One which I would suggest is that people who are self-employed and whose incomes are small because they have not a way of making a bigger income should be considered even though they are not contributors. Later on it might also be possible to modify the means test still further or to abolish it altogether. When the children's allowances scheme was introduced the question was considered whether it was wise to leave it without a means test. That was done and it has been proved beyond a shadow of doubt that its administration has been made much easier and that the little extra cost has been more than made up for by the absence of the host of officials which it would take to administer it if there was a means test. When the means test can be abolished for old age pensioners everybody will welcome its abolition no matter what Government may introduce it.

I hope the Tánaiste will bear these things in mind. I know it is his intention to try and go even further than he has gone in this Bill. I know he admitted when introducing the Bill that he would like to see even greater benefits bestowed. There are however, certain difficulties with regard to collecting contributions from self-employed people which makes it difficult for him or any Minister to do for these people what he would like to do. However, this Bill is a welcome one. I hope it will be passed and implemented as quickly as possible, particularly with regard to old age pensions. We have been told: "Introduce a separate Bill for old age pensions and it will go through the House in 24 hours." I know it would go through the House in 24 hours. But there are benefits in this Bill, such as maternity benefit, unemployment benefit and many other benefits for the workers, which deserve to be considered as much as anything else in the Bill. The Bill also provides for the abolition of a section of the 1908 Act. It was high time to get rid of that section by which people were debarred from what they were genuinely entitled to. I think this Bill should satisfy everybody. I am well satisfied with it, but I hope the step that is now being taken will not be the final step with regard to social welfare, because there are other things to be done before everybody in need is looked after. I hope that before long a further effort will be made to try and look after everybody who is in need.

Comment on this

I beg to second the motion moved by Deputy P. D. Lehane. I propose to discuss the Bill from the viewpoint of the small farmers of my constituency and, I am sure, of the country. One point stands out at the very outset. The introduction of this Bill does nothing to increase the national income. The benefits that are to accrue to the people who will benefit from it must come through lessening the share of the national income of those who will not benefit but will have to meet the cost. That being so, as a small farmer and a representative of a constituency of small farmers, I propose to point out how it will adversely affect agriculture. To my mind, social justice must precede social welfare. If it is a case of robbing Peter to pay Paul, then it certainly offends against social justice. I could not do better at the outset than read a comment by Very Rev. Felim Ó Briain, of Galway University, when the White Paper outlining the proposals in the scheme was first published, I think at the end of 1949. He said:—

"Three tests which could be applied to any scheme were: would it really ward off distress where it was most felt in a comprehensive way; would it help the common good and the total economy of the country; and would it favour or impede the development of human personality? It is regrettable that on these three counts the White Paper fails. The scheme is not at all comprehensive. It is difficult to see how the terms ‘security' and ‘welfare' can be applied to a scheme which explicitly omits all who are too poor to contribute to it and makes no alternative provision for these unfortunate people. A craftsman with £10 a week or a business manager with £10,000 a year, if they had a wife and two children, would get 50/- a week unemployment benefit if deprived of their jobs, but a poor casual labourer with a wife and six children must prove that he had no more than 15/- a week before he got a dole of 29/- a week. The £12 a week tradesman would get 24/- a week at 65, but a worn-out agricultural worker at 70 would not get 17/6 if his income was more than 6/- a week. A million and a quarter persons were excluded from the scheme and these would include almost the whole agricultural community."

Speaking on the 23rd January last, he said:

"Adjustment of the mal-distribution of national income was one of the first duties of our statesmen. The Minister for Social Welfare proposed to accentuate unfairness by the Insurance Bill now before the Dáil. Those who had long been the victims of economic discrimination would be forced to contribute to the social security of those who enjoy permanent jobs. The Bill took a few timid steps in the right direction but the steps were so feeble as to be of little benefit."

That is the opinion of a person who could have no personal interest in any particular section of the community. I think those words should bear weight with our legislators before they enact further laws which will, as he says, increase the unfairness that already exists.

The only thing that can be said in favour of the present measure of social justice is that this State has gone so far in the direction of providing social security for a particular section of our people that it might now come as a bit of a jolt if it tried to go into reverse. If we were starting from scratch, I would question the wisdom of the State assuming responsibility for providing for all its citizens. In my opinion, the command of God to Adam after the Fall—"In the sweat of thy brow shalt thou eat bread"— holds as much force to-day as it did then. So far as the records of time are available to us, 4,000 years later God's Divine Son came on earth to redeem us from that Fall; He came and dwelt in the simple home at Nazareth where His foster-father worked as a carpenter, assisted by the Son of God, and His Mother did the household chores. There was no State security there. There was no social welfare. From that we have tangible evidence that the Divine Plan was that man should provide for himself by the sweat of his brow.

I may be branded as a reactionary for making that statement. It will not be the first time. Nevertheless, I suggest that the world, and our own country with it, has strayed far from the point where the breadwinner is expected to provide for himself and his dependents unaided by the State. With all our State interference, with all our State assistance, with all our State insurance and all the rest of it is humanity to-day more content than it was? Have we ever had at any period of our history such unrest rampant throughout the world? Have we ever had at any period in our own lifetime such unrest in our own country despite the measure of social security that operates in the country at the present time?

Comment on this

We have not social security. That is the trouble.

Comment on this

Is there more contentment to-day than there was at the beginning of this century when there was no State insurance for anyone? To that question I do not propose to give an authoritative reply, but I think Deputies should consider deeply whether it is not a fact that no matter what measure of State security we provide it will not give our people peace and contentment.

We will come to a point when our people, trained to look to the State to provide for all their needs, will feel that they can never get enough out of the State. I do not pretend to be well versed in international affairs, but I can see that over vast areas of the world to-day where the State assumes complete responsibility for all the needs of its people the point has been reached where there is nothing left except an inordinate desire to eliminate God completely out of the lives of the people. Let us consider then whether in pursuit of this ideal of discouraging the individual to provide for himself and his dependents—a natural obligation laid first upon the shoulders of our first parents—we shall not reach the point eventually where we too may imitate the Russian methods of eliminating God.

In relation to the burdens that will be placed upon the State to provide this measure of security for a section of our people I want to point out that in discussing this Bill we are discussing a Bill in which no mention is made of increased pensions for the old and the blind. Not a word appears in the Bill on that subject. As recently as last February the Minister, in reply to parliamentary questions, could not then say that there would even be an increase of 2/6 per week. It was only when the present Bill was actually introduced that the Minister promised some amendments would be made on the Committee Stage to make an increase available for old age pensioners. It is obvious that that promise was made because of the uncertainty that existed that the Bill, as drafted, would go through the House. That proves conclusively that it was the firm stand taken by the Independent Deputies that compelled the Minister to make that promise. The fear of those Independent Deputies voting against the Bill and defeating it induced the Minister to promise an extra 2/6 per week for old age pensioners. The provisions in the Bill are merely to provide for wage earners.

There was a suggestion that farmers who are members of co-operative societies may be taken in, but there is so little about it, even in the explanatory memorandum or in the Bill itself, that we have nothing definite to go on. The implication appears to be that those members of co-operative societies will pay a weekly contribution and that the co-operative society will pay the employer's contribution. It has not been mentioned what that contribution will be, nor is it indicated what benefit those farmers who are taken in will qualify for. Since the contribution of employees and employers as mentioned in the Bill is 3/6 a week, until some other figure is specified in respect of farmers who may be taken in, we can only assume that they will pay the same amount. If that is the case, the farmer will contribute 3/6 a week and his co-operative society will pay out of his money another 3/6 a week, making a total of 7/-.

I have made some calculations as to the effect of that on small farmers in my own constituency, or at least a section of them, because I have not the foundation on which to make a calculation over the whole constituency. An area of the county, considerably less than half of it, probably not more than a quarter of it, is covered by the co-operative society of which I am a member. The contributions which would be collected from the members would amount to £20,000 a year. The society would have to contribute another £20,000, making a total of £40,000, which would be taken off the small farmers in a small section of the County Cavan.

Comment on this

How did the Deputy arrive at that calculation in regard to the contributions—how did he get it?

Comment on this

I stated that as there is no mention in the Bill of any particular contribution for the farmers who may come into the scheme, I could only rely on the contribution that all those who are included in the scheme are expected to pay—3/6.

Comment on this

It is incorrect to do that.

Comment on this

But as I had nothing else to go on——

Comment on this

Then you took the figures that would suit you best.

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

But it happened to be so.

Comment on this

There is nothing before us in this measure to indicate what the contributions or the benefits will be for those people to whom I refer.

Comment on this

For the very good reason that we have to work out a scheme with the co-operatives.

Comment on this

Until we get a figure indicating the contributions and the benefits, we have nothing to go on. If one or two members of a farmer's family are taken in—and it is only natural to expect they should be, since they are working on the farm—we can double or treble that figure of £40,000, so that I do not think the co-operative societies will be enamoured of the scheme. As a matter of fact, I had a resolution sent to me, dated 5th March last, from a conference of co-operative societies of the Counties Monaghan and Cavan, and the terms of that resolution are:—

"That farmers oppose the proposed scheme of social welfare in so far as the Bill is unjust in imposing the total burden on the agricultural classes who cannot pass on the expense, as can the other sections of the community, its principal beneficiaries."

It is clear that in so far as there is a suggestion to take in farmers who are members of co-operative societies—and bear in mind all suppliers to a creamery are not shareholders, probably onethird of them are not—the position is that for this small section that will be taken in, the figure I have given of the contribution they would make, and that the society would make out of their money for them, would amount to this very big sum.

The burden, in the main, must come on taxation. To begin with, the statement has been made by Deputy Dunne that as regards any contributions organised labour will be called upon to make, their organisations will insist that they get increased wages to cover them. Then again, the employers, in so far as they are in the industrial line, will have their manufactured goods sold, in the main, in this State in circumstances where they will be enabled to add on the employers' portion of the cost. So, if Deputy Dunne says the workers will get increased wages to cover their contributions, the industrial employers will add the two contributions together, put it on to the cost of the manufactured article and send that out to the people of the State who must buy it unless they can import articles from other countries free of quotas and free of duty—and that is not likely to take place.

Let me now quote another statement made by the Very Rev. Dr. Phelim Ó Briain:

"While the fleeced farmer and the underpaid worker must continue to emigrate; while profits soared and well-organised groups of workers could secure terms that tended to impoverish further the vast majority of the underpaid, they could not claim that social or distributive justice existed in this country. About one-fifth of the nation's breadwinners were in registered trade unions. By using their organised force in strike action they could force the community to concede a disproportionate share of the national income that was meagre enough even if fairly divided."

The point I was making was that, owing to the sheltered position of our industrial producers, they are in a position to add to the cost of the manufactured article, which must be purchased by the people of the State, the amount of both the workers' and the employers' contributions. I quote from another quarter. The present Minister for Finance speaking in this House on the 23rd May said:—

"In the British case the industrialists were faced with the difficulty of export in the face of great competition, whereas here they were only manufacturing for the home market in conditions when the home market was never more fortified for them as regards quotas and tariffs."

That statement by the Minister for Finance has not been challenged, so far as I know. Therefore, I think it gives proof positive of my contention that the industrial manufacturers, since they have not to export their products and face international competition, are in the position that they will not be one penny the poorer by reason of any contribution they may have to make either by increased wages to workers on account of their contributions or on account of their own contributions. It would simply be added on to the price of the article. When that article is sent down the country it will go to different sections of distributors, business people and so on. It will even go to different sections of the community. Industrial workers down the country, when they buy that article, can make a point that it will increase the cost of living since clothing, footwear and so on form a big item in the cost-of-living index. They will seek for a further increase in wages against this additional burden. Ultimately, the burden will fall on the farming community and on whom will they shift that burden? Could they stand up and say to the British Minister of Food: "Twopence an egg is not enough for us with the social welfare cost added on to us." The British Minister of Food will snap his fingers and say: "I do not care. If you are not prepared to supply us with eggs at a less price than any other country I do not want your eggs. We can get on without them." That is only a small item. The price of the bulk of our produce is regulated by its export value, but there are many instances where the export value of our produce is much higher than could be realised for it on the home market. The export is limited and the price is kept down so that the farmer is crushed between the upper and nether millstones.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy seems to be widening the scope of the discussion very considerably. One could discuss all industries on the same basis.

Comment on this

I am endeavouring to point out where the burden will fall and where it will be unjust.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

On the basis of that reasoning, everyone could discuss every industry in the State.

Comment on this

I am endeavouring to point out that the industrial sections of the community are cushioned against any of the charges that will be imposed as a result of the Bill before the House. The agricultural community will not be in a position to recoup themselves and in the ultimate the agricultural community will probably bear anything up to 90 per cent. of the entire cost of the scheme. Such a state of affairs, to my mind, is not a step forward.

A nation of small self-employed people is fundamentally much sounder than a nation of employers and employees. If employers and employees are divided there will be a continual tendency towards class warfare. While there is class warfare, we certainly cannot have contentment. The more we can do to encourage self-employed sections of the community to provide for themselves, the better.

Even before the introduction of this Bill, I could see quite a number of small farmers whose families were reared in the early years of this century and who grew up at the same time as I was growing up myself, and I can see a tendency on the part of the present owners of those small farms to neglect the farm and go out and become wage-earners. The reason for this is, first of all, the unequal distribution of the national wealth, whereby the agricultural producer is so penalised and, secondly, on account of the security provided through insurance against ill-health, unemployment both for themselves and their dependents. If that tendency continues long enough, it will cut across the whole national policy of developing rural Ireland and having contented smallholders.

I have seen farms on which families of seven, eight and nine have been raised in the early years of this century being left more or less in grass under the present owners. A few cattle have been put on them to eat up the grass but no attempt has been made to work them as an economic unit. That is the result of the unequal distribution of wealth, the burden of all State schemes and the inducements held out to self-employed people to desert the farms and go in and become insured and take up employment preferably Government employment or county council employment. If we proceed along those lines, we will reach a point where we will have anything but contented people.

The only point that could be made in favour of the extension of State schemes is that we have gone so far in a certain direction that it might cause a serious jolt to go into reverse. We can proceed along the lines we are going and ultimately, probably not in my lifetime or in the lifetime of any member of this House, we may end up in the conditions that have led to the setting up of the totalitarian States behind the Iron Curtain.

I would prefer to see encouragement to the individual to observe his natural obligation to provide out of his own effort and trust in God for himself and his dependents. No one will object to providing for the aged, who, having given a lifetime of service to the State, are entitled to retirement benefits such as old pensions, but even with that system up to the present, there is a means test. We have a penalty on thrift, but in so far as the State guarantees to provide for all the needs of the family, it relieves the breadwinner of his natural responsibilities and furthermore it trains the children to lose respect for the parents.

The children can well say, when they grow up, to the father and mother: "You have no authority over me. You did very little to provide for me. You got half-a-crown a week when I was a baby until I reached the age of 16. You got free boots, free milk, free school meals and many other things of that kind and it is the State rather than you who brought me up, so that I owe allegiance to the State rather than to you." We strike directly at the authority of the parents and we attack the family at its vital source which everyone agrees is the one point in respect of which the totalitarian States made most headway. Let us beware lest we increase still further the tendency in that direction. Its consequences may not overtake us in a year, a decade or two decades, but, as the years go on, we may reach that point.

If the Bill is all that it claims to be by its protagonists, without the sugar coating which has been put on it by the mention of the half-crown a week increase to the old age pensioner— which is not yet in the Bill—why should there be any hesitation about submitting it to a referendum, so that the people will have a chance of expressing their views on it? I am quite sure that there would be a very considerable volume of opinion, even of those who are to benefit, against it. One thing is sure—any person of an industrious turn of mind, who is inclined to work, does not like the idea of making contributions and bearing the burden of providing funds for people less willing to work than himself. I am not saying that there will not be hardship at all times which could, and should, be provided for from State funds, but to make the principle as general as the Bill envisages appears to me to be a step in the wrong direction.

I appeal to the Tánaiste to accept the amendment tabled by Deputy P.D. Lehane and to agree to the suggestion made by the four Independent Deputies in their memorandum to the Taoiseach and the Government to implement the increased old age pension and blind pension by a short Bill and then to put this Bill before the electorate for their views. Nothing will be lost by the delay in submitting it and it will be a useful pointer as to whether the country believes that it is wise or not. If a majority of the electors decide in favour of it, I will support it. If they do not, why should it be imposed on the country? I earnestly appeal to the Tánaiste to accept the amendment and put the question to a referendum.

Mr. Connolly rose.

Comment on this

Is it proposed or desired to finish the debate to-night?

Comment on this

I could not say. It depends on what time is available.

Comment on this

Deputy Kissane is not attempting to interfere with my freedom of speech?

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

Oh, yes.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Reilly treated us to a rather doleful review of the situation in the country in a sincere and honest fashion, as is his custom. If one really believed the country to be in such a state as he indicated, I have no doubt that one could find very strong and urgent reasons for resisting the Bill, or, on the other hand, for being overpowering in one's support of it. The contributions of the Opposition to this Bill have been most disappointing. There have been so far but two contributions of any serious content, that of Deputy Ryan moving his amendment and that of the Deputy-Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Lemass, who approached this question in a very realistic manner.

This question is of such tremendous dimensions, is so huge in its application and covers such a wide field that one can be forgiven, as Opposition Deputies must be forgiven, for not attempting to break a lance with the Minister on it; but, the Minister is to be very highly commended for having introduced the Bill and more important, for having stood up to every challenge against it and having seen to it that it did come before the House for discussion, and, we hope, for enactment. The fact that the Minister in charge is a Labour Minister would undoubtedly induce me, as a Labour Deputy, to speak in his commendation. Yet, as I stated on another occasion, I cannot say that this is the most important achievement of the inter-Party Government. It will rank, possibly, as the second most important achievement. Probably, the other measure to obtain family security and family welfare, the mother and child scheme, which should be taken in conjunction with this scheme, will also rank high amongst the achievements of this Government.

To my mind, the background of the Social Welfare Bill and the thing that makes it possible is the most magnificent achievement of this inter-Party Government and that, as I said on the Vote on Account, is the achievement of political peace for the last three years. That is an attainment of which every member of the inter-Party Government, and every individual Deputy who has had any hand, act or part in bringing about the formation of this Government should be proud. Without that political peace, this social peace, the foundations of which the Minister intends to lay in this Bill, would be impossible, would be a fantasy and a farce. It is on that background that we must consider the whole question in its general aspects.

Several of the speakers, starting with Deputy Dr. Ryan, have gone into great detail in asking what certain sections of the community will get from this Bill. They have treated us, as Deputy Ryan did, followed by Deputy O'Reilly, to an elaborate dissertation on the difference between the manufacturer and the farmer, as to how one is enabled to pass on the costs of this scheme to the consumer, and how the other is not. They find a criticism, which they would believe to be valid, in calling that discrimination against the poor farmer. Reality is achieved only by considering the title in its true context. I do not believe that has been done by any contributor to this debate, not even by the Minister.

These are Government proposals for social security. This is a Bill for social welfare. Most of those who discussed the Bill seemed to regard it as a measure providing some social security for the individual, to insure him against certain risks and contingencies but, in fact, that is merely incidental to the Bill. The real purpose of a Bill of this type, of any Social Welfare Bill, is to provide security to society, to provide security to the State, to the community. It is to provide social welfare, not so much to the hapless individual, the under-privileged, the brother by the wayside, who has to be helped by his better-off brethren, as it is to secure that the fabric of society should continue to exist, should continue to be secure against attacks which threaten to undermine it. I submit that that is the correct perspective in which to examine this Bill. We should consider whether or not it will promote that social peace and security for the community, in the sphere of economics and industrial relations, which this Government has been able to secure in the political sphere; whether security of that type is settled in this Bill; whether attempts are made to lay the foundation for a better state of affairs than has hitherto existed. We should consider it, not with so much emphasis upon whether it has improved the position economically of the old age pensioner, the widow and orphans, the unemployed, the invalided, but as to whether the community as a whole will benefit from the contributions that the Minister has made in this Bill to social security.

Certain Deputies characterised parts of this Bill as being revolutionary in intent. One might dwell, perhaps, upon that matter, particularly in view of the very widespread, vicious, ignorant and uninformed criticism there is of the Bill. It was thought at one time that a proposal such as this, holding out palliatives to the under-privileged or the workers, was of the nature of throwing a crust of bread to the starving man to keep him from revolt, trying to keep the proletariat from some revolutionary advance, and, in so far as that theory was considered correct, all these amelioratory measures were regarded as being counter-revolutionary rather than revolutionary.

Times have changed, however, and now, when we have a better grasp of the essentials of things, we can understand the real impact of proposals of this nature and their effect upon society as a whole. The number of times that we have heard it stated that proposals of this nature would rob workers of all initiative, would deprive them of a desire to earn their daily bread, would corrupt them and make them dependent on the charity of the State, would seem to indicate that those who say these things believe that, by continual repetition, they may convince the uneducated or the unthinking that these criticisms are valid.

But they give no indication of the basis of their belief. They have no evidence from a sociological point of view to prove that any measures of this sort, brought forward with a view to ameliorating the conditions of the under-privileged, have ever actually had the effect which they so glibly talk about. The experience of the last war, as Deputy Desmond has pointed out, shows that Irish workers, and I am sure workers in any other countries, are not to any extent of the type that can be criticised as shirkers. They are not likely to shirk work just because they are asked to accept, as part of the social structure of this State, the possibility of receiving certain contributions during periods of unemployment. That basis of criticism has been exploded quite thoroughly in this country and in every other country but still it seems to persist when no other real sound criticism can be thought out by those who are opposed to this scheme.

The social security that I mention as being the real target of this Bill, the promotion of a social consciousness, would to my mind act as a very energetic stimulus to the worker to increase his productivity rather than to lessen it. When he feels a sense of security for himself during sickness, a sense of greater security for himself when he reaches retirement, a greater sense of security for his wife and children under the provisions of this Bill, he is bound, I submit, to become a better citizen. He is bound to act in a greater degree for the best interests of the country as a whole and that argument, I feel sure, will appeal to thinking people to smash the type of propaganda which has been rampant against this Bill since it was introduced.

The attitude of the Deputy Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Lemass, would require some consideration, particularly as the statement he made was welcomed by Deputy Davin as the leader of the Labour Party, who went so far as to salute him for his declaration of a point of view which evidently ran counter to that of the other members of his Party or, at least as far as we have heard those who followed him, received no endorsement whatsoever from these other members.

Comment on this

We got no encouragement from your side.

Comment on this

We had not an opportunity of providing encouragement when it became evident that Deputy Lemass was speaking with a lone voice.

Comment on this

No, not with a lone voice. He spoke for the Party.

Comment on this

He gave no indication of it. It appeared to me as one who listened to him that it was under stress of the discussion that this idea of appealing to the Minister sprung fully-fledged from his mind. There was no indication that I have read of —and I have taken care to read over Deputy Dr. Ryan's opening statement in proposing his amendment—or no scintilla of evidence that he was thinking along the lines indicated by Deputy Lemass. Deputy Lemass gave as his view that the whole question of social welfare arrangements should be taken out of the field of party politics, and this he proposed should be done by meeting the proposals of Deputy Dr. Ryan, but he could hardly expect, as an experienced Deputy Leader of the Opposition, that the Government of the day, no matter how much it might or might not be enamoured of the alternative propositions of the Opposition, would withdraw its own considered line of policy as incorporated in the Bill and take into consideration the rather tenuous proposals of Deputy Dr. Ryan, not fully thought out or elaborated, and present them as an agreed measure to the House.

We would all, I am sure, particularly the Deputies in the Labour Party, wish that some of the other suggestions of Deputy Dr. Ryan could be implemented. We would all wish that, in contradiction to the terms of his own amendment after he criticised the Bill for not providing a comprehensive section for the needs of all sections of the community, any suggestion of his which broadened the basis of the Bill and extended social security to other sections not covered by the Bill could be implemented by the Government; but it would hardly be the correct procedure for the Government to accept a suggestion of that type, not backed by the other members of the Opposition as far as we can ascertain, because it was carefully noted that Deputy Derrig spoke in a very dissimilar, if not in an antagonistic voice, to that used by Deputy Lemass. Others who followed him adopted the same attitude. If the Opposition were anxious to facilitate the Government they could avail of other means to secure the rapid passage and implementation of the Bill as a whole. They could, for instance, as has been the custom in this House on quite a number of occasions, take off the Whips from the Party and have a free vote.

If that had appealed to Deputy Lemass, perhaps he might have considered it. If, as Deputy Little suggests, they did seriously consider this in Party caucus after their opposition to the Bill had weakened and after they had seen the strength of the arguments in support of it on behalf of the Government, they could, I am sure, have found accommodation with the Government. I am sure they realise that in the Tánaiste they have a Minister who has the greatest sense of accommodation and that he would be willing to facilitate them without in any way violating the principles which he hopes to enshrine in this Bill. If they were serious in that idea of helping the Government to bring forward this measure of social security, then I suggest they leave themselves open to the charge of having this attitude, or this appeal, of the Deputy Leader of their Party being considered as a political trick, a trick to get themselves out of the difficult situation in which they found themselves when they began to understand how the tide was flowing in the country—when the great realisation came to them as to the full meaning of the proposals in this Bill.

Now, before examining in detail some of the criticisms made by Deputy Dr. Ryan, and before taking into consideration the scheme that was summarised so hastily by the Fianna Fáil headquarters and office, I would like to go over some thoughts which I have in respect of this Bill. In considering it, it is, as I said at the beginning, important to bear in mind the background against which it is introduced, a background of political security which I hope will be strengthened by the scheme of security which the Minister proposes in the Bill. As well as that background, the Bill can be examined from the narrower background of the three main insurance schemes which we have at present in operation. Each of these finds a place in one form or another in the Bill. The two oldest are those governing national health and unemployment. The third, and the most recent, which was so highly commended by every Deputy who has spoken so far, is the widows' and orphans' contributory pension scheme. As Deputies know, these three schemes cover widely different groups of people.

The widows' and orphans' scheme is the widest in scope. The legislation governing that scheme shows that it covers all persons, with some exceptions, who were employed under a contract of service, the main exceptions being persons in receipt of salaries of more than £500 a year and certain State employees.

The next one that is widest in scope is the national health insurance scheme, and the third, the unemployment insurance scheme, which is the most limited of the three. As regards scope, the last one covers some 200,000 people fewer than are covered by the widows' and orphans' pension scheme. This lack of uniformity in scope has given rise to many anomalies, some of which were referred to by Deputy Dr. Ryan and other Deputies. It is one of the important functions of this new Bill to wipe out these anomalies by providing a uniform scope for all the benefits. That aspect of the Bill has rightly been commented upon by Deputy Dr. Ryan, while the advantages of it have been made plain by several Deputies. It is only when the Bill is actually in full operation that the advantages and effects of that pattern of uniformity will become clear.

An example of the advantages of this endeavour of the Bill may make this point clear. Under the present arrangement or system, if a man becomes unemployed for a long period, he loses his insurance under the national health scheme, and if, subsequently, he falls sick or if death occurs, no benefit is payable on account of the lapsed insurance. It will be seen from this that the occurrence of one contingency, which is supposed to be insured against, can have the effect of destroying the insurance for another contingency which, when it arises, is uncovered. Now, under the new Bill, as Deputies know who have examined it and its contents, and who have studied the White Paper and run through the explanatory memorandum, that state of affairs, which is so disadvantageous to the beneficiary and so unjust without being purposely so—unjust due to the lack of uniformity in the three main systems of insurance—will be impossible. When a man is sick, for example, his insurance is carried forward by way of credits. These credits are valuable in the event of some later mishap, such as the mishap of unemployment or death. Of all the provisions in this Bill, it would be difficult to overestimate the value of this particular provision. In fact, were the Minister to introduce a Bill containing that provision alone it would be a very noteworthy step along the path to better social security in this country.

The next obvious advantage arising from the new measure is the simplification and the rationalisation which it brings about. Instead of the three different insurance schemes with three different scopes, with different rates of benefit and different qualifying conditions and so on, we now have, under the Bill, a uniform scheme covering all those who can be covered under the terms of the Bill and dealing administratively with them by means of one stamp and one central record department. One Deputy who spoke went as far as to envisage the type of card that might most profitably be used for assessing the legal liability of the different parties, the employer and the employee, to carry through their obligations in regard to payment of the contributions. Whether it is necessary on the Second Reading to go into such details is a moot point but the fact that Deputies are thinking along those lines is significant of the interest in this whole question of social security, as put forward by this Bill. That interest is evident not alone in the destructive aspects of the criticism but also in the constructive approach which members of this House are applying to the consideration of the Bill. The advantages of this one-stamp-one-record idea hardly require to be stressed. The administrative expenses which will be saved by this rational method of unification and simplification will be of real value to those who are most concerned under this Bill, namely, the beneficiaries. That method of rationalisation will leave just so much extra money which will go in benefits instead of in administrative expenses. In other words, the Minister proposes to make social insurance in this country, under the terms of this Bill, an efficient instrument—an instrument which has been so simplified that it can be understood by the man in the street, so that it does not require any great legal mind to interpret his duties and obligations under it.

The next improvement which the Bill brings about is the making uniform of the existing benefit rates in which, needless to say, we are interested. There is to be a substantial improvement. For example, at the moment, under the national health insurance scheme, allowances are payable for dependents. But, under the unemployment insurance scheme, no such allowances are paid. Again, the rates payable under both schemes bear no relation to the rates payable under the other scheme I mentioned, the widows' and orphans' pension scheme, which latter are determined both by the place of residence of the widow and by the type of employment in which her husband had been engaged.

It is hardly necessary to say that these different and differing rates did discriminate sharply against the rural worker and his widow. However, under the new scheme, all this will be wiped out. There will be a basic benefit rate, that anyone can understand, of 24/- for the main beneficiary plus 12/- for the adult dependent, plus 7/- for each of the two dependent children. This means, to make comparisons with the present set-up, that a man when sick or when unemployed will receive for himself and his wife and two dependent children 50/- a week. That is a round figure which is easily remembered and easily understood—and I am sure that it can easily be grasped by the people who are to benefit and who are only too impatient to have the scheme implemented. Compare that position with the present rate of 22/6 which a man would receive under the national insurance scheme or 35/- which he would receive under the present unemployment insurance scheme. No comparisons can be made as regards the retiring pension. The retiring pension and the death grant provisions of this new scheme cannot be compared with any existing scheme because, as Deputies know, at the moment no similar benefits are provided by any form of State insurance.

The next point which requires consideration—it is a point to which Deputy Dr. Ryan devoted some time and in regard to which he seemed to disagree very completely with the attitude of the Minister—is the division of the insured population into two groups (1) those who are in what may be termed the normal wage group, and (2) those who are earning less than a round figure of £3 10s. a week—in the White Paper this latter group is referred to as the low-wage group. I should think that it would be of benefit to the House if the Minister, in his concluding remarks, would give some reasons why he hit on this level at which the division is made. With the fall in value of money, which has been stressed, and with the rise in wages— particularly in the rural community— the figure of £3 10s. appears to me to require consideration and it could be considered with advantage to apply at a higher scale. I move the adjournment of the debate.

Comment on this