We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 137–310 of 489. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

At the same time, I object to misrepresentation, and the Minister has to put up with a lot of that. Unfortunately, a lot of Deputy Walsh's friends are misguided in that form of misrepresentation which is published in their own tied newspaper. There is more tillage at the present day than there was in 1939. Therefore, much of the argument put forward that the Minister had adopted a policy quite opposite to the policy of mixed farming, has no basis. If we were to be guided by the Fianna Fáil wheat policy, we would, in 1950, have had 240,000 acres of wheat instead of the 365,000 acres that we had. That was Fianna Fáil wheat policy.

Comment on this

When did Fianna Fáil stop the farmers from growing wheat?

Comment on this

That was in your own O.E.E.C. programme.

Comment on this

The Deputy's Minister for Agriculture indicated to O.E.E.C. a couple of years ago, when he was asking for finance for this country, that in 1950 it was estimated——

Comment on this

It was estimated.

Comment on this

Well, we will accept the estimate, but he indicated that 247,000 acres would be grown in 1950. Instead of that, under the present Government, there were 365,000 acres of wheat grown, and that was almost 50 per cent. higher in the matter of acreage than the figure that was anticipated by the Fianna Fáil Party. We may take it that that was their policy in relation to wheat.

Comment on this

It was not estimated that eggs would be 2/- a dozen, either.

Comment on this

The figure is 1/5.

Comment on this

I am in favour of the policy the Minister has adopted in relation to farmers. It is not a policy of compulsion; it is a policy of encouragement. Some people have said that his encouragement has been too successful and that people have learned to be disappointed but, taking them on the average, it is better to encourage them and work for them as willingly as the Minister has worked during the last few years than to be a prophet.

We had very bad weather since last October. It was impossible for our farmers to plough the land and get it ready for seeding. We had not two successive days without rain since last October. Probably compulsory tillage will be referred to by Fianna Fáil next harvest if it is found that our farmers have not cultivated a large acreage, but they will be able to remember, as I do, that it was impossible since 1st November for our farmers to plough land. It is only now they are getting into their stride. They are doing their best to seed all the land they can. The good weather of the last few days has given our farmers an opportunity to show how willing and anxious they are to serve the nation by cultivating all the land they can with the limited time and resources at their disposal and with their limitations in the matter of gear and help.

I was surprised to hear that Deputy Smith claimed he was the representative of the farmers and that his views represented the views of the farmers. No doubt he was speaking for his Party, but we all know that Fianna Fáil are the traditional enemies of the farmers. They were scarcely five years in existence here as a Party when they became the Government, and they immediately started the economic war and left the farmers to pay for it. Everybody knows that the amount of annuities could be redeemed many times over by the losses of the farmers and also by the taxes collected by the British Government from that time on the goods exported from this country. We have not seen any seizures, we have not seen any sheriffs or bailiffs and there was no confiscation of land during the last few years.

Comment on this

Or Blueshirts, either.

Comment on this

They had no connection with the seizures.

Comment on this

We saw you wearing one.

Comment on this

It was well for the liberty of this country that they were worn.

Comment on this

They tried to sabotage this country.

Comment on this

There were Brownshirts in Germany, Blackshirts in Italy and we had Blueshirts here, but the Minister for Agriculture did not wear one.

Comment on this

At the present time our policy is to get the best price we can in foreign markets. The only handicap is that we have not got the goods. We have only one-third the number of cattle that we could sell. A similar position applies in respect of sheep, poultry and pigs. The shortage of cattle is due to the fact that the cattle population was brought to such a low level shortly before the war commenced. At that time the price of live stock doubled, but the live stock were not there and the farmers were not in a position to avail of the substantially increased prices. There is no knowing the measure of prosperity which could have been enjoyed in this country by all classes of our people if, when the war commenced, our land had been stocked to the hilt with sheep, pigs, cattle and poultry.

Comment on this

And no bread for our people. That is what you wanted, was it not? Starve the people.

Comment on this

Surely it is not suggested that we should feed bread to pigs and poultry?

Comment on this

Or feed the people. You cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Rooney should be allowed to speak without interruption. Every Deputy has that right.

Comment on this

It would not be wrong to feed it to greyhounds?

Comment on this

Farm horses appear to be becoming scarce, due to the fact that farmers are not inclined to keep horses when they can manage their farms by means of tractors and when they find that it is more economical to mechanise the farms than to keep horses. At the same time, there is a certain need for horses, even amongst farmers who keep tractors, and I feel that they are not making provision for the future. Therefore, I would like the Minister to consider devising a scheme whereby pedigree horses would be located in various parts of each county to ensure that farmers who so desired can keep foals which will eventually meet the need.

Comment on this

We do that.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not remember the Minister's statement regarding the yokel that was following the horses in the field.

Comment on this

Was that about the stick tied to the ass's tail?

Comment on this

Yes. That was one of them.

Comment on this

Apparently, the farmer would prefer to keep a tractor.

Comment on this

On the Minister's suggestion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Walsh is constantly interrupting.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister should insist on the use of asses with sticks tied to their tails, if the farmers wish to use tractors.

I was glad the Minister indicated the value of silage and the uses of silage in comparison with hay. Our farmers have not yet realised the value of silage in comparison with hay and the better economy it would be to use silage instead of hay. Some farmers produce hay for sale, but those who require food for live stock during winter would be better advised to use silage.

In regard to the question of bacon production, I hope the Minister will succeed in adopting a plan which will enable him to guarantee the farmers a certain price for a pig of a certain weight. The guaranteed price has a very valuable psychological effect. Those who engage in production like to be able to anticipate the price which they will get for the finished product. Certainly, 220/- per cwt. for pig producers for pigs that are fed on homegrown cereals or any kind of feeding stuff at £20 a ton or less, in my opinion, would be a paying proposition. I hope the Minister will succeed in getting into a position where he can give that guarantee, because it will result in the expansion of pig production. World meat prices are inclined to move upward. The same applies in respect of bacon. In years gone by, the British market was regarded as a valuable one for our surplus agricultural production. I suppose that still applies but, in recent times, Britain has shown that she is not in the financial position in which she was in previous years and the British Government has adopted a system of bulk buying which certainly has not had a favourable result for our farmers in the matter of egg production and I think also in the case of bacon production.

It appeared to me also that the British Government were prepared to give a better price for bacon to the Danes than they are prepared to give the Irish farmers. I believe that is only a temporary attitude and that a remedy can be found whereby at least our pig producers will get terms similar to those given by the British Government to the Danish producers.

Apple production, to which the Minister referred, should be encouraged. Last year the North Dublin and East Meath fruit growers came on a deputation to the Minister asking if he could do anything to steady the prices for their fruit. At that time the Minister indicated that if they were prepared to form a co-operative society his Department and the Agricultural Credit Corporation would then be in a position to finance the establishment of such a society which would enable the farmers to store apples instead of putting them all on the market at the one time and selling at sacrifice prices. Strangely enough, although the producers can get only very poor prices at the fall, fruit, particularly apples, sells at a very high price to the consumers at Christmas and after Christmas and there would be a great advantage in having a co-operative society which would enable farmers to store apples and to release them for sale according as there was a demand for them, instead of having to implore retailers and handlers to take the fruit from them. If possible, the Minister should encourage the production of apples and the establishment of these co-operative societies.

I believe Irish fruit growers can grow apples as good as and even better than the apples which are imported because the consumers cannot get Irish apples. Certainly, the price of apples to the consumer is very high. The Irish producers would be very glad if they could get even half the price which the consumer must pay for imported apples when there are no Irish apples available.

The Dungarvan project has been a great success and many fruit growers will be watching the progress made by the co-operative society. It is a new venture, which was established in a very suitable locality, where there is a tradition of fruit growing.

I would like the Minister to consider the possibility of any kind of cottage scheme, to be operated through the committees of agriculture in connection with poultry. There is a poultry scheme operated in a general way through the committees of agriculture, but I am hopeful that the Minister may be able to extend that scheme.

The same applies in respect of sows. I understood that the Minister would distribute about 1,000 sows throughout the country—through various committees. I believe that if the Department took that matter in hand and sent these breeding sows out—through the various channels—probably through the committees of agriculture—the system of pig production would be extended and that we would have a more uniform supply, depending, of course, on the amount of foodstuffs produced in this country.

One result of the agricultural policy carried on by the present Minister is that conditions for people on the land have improved. The income received by those who work and live on the land has been doubled, perhaps trebled in many cases. Farm workers who were receiving, I think, £2 1s. 6d. per week at the highest in 1946, have had substantial increases in their wages. Nobody can say that the farm workers do not deserve the highest increase that the farmers can give them in relation to the prosperity now being enjoyed on the land.

I had hoped to see the parish plan in operation and it was regrettable that it did not proceed as first announced by the Minister. I hope that the alternative scheme which he has in mind will soon come into operation because, in these difficult days, when the farmers are striving to get seeds into the land and to organise the whole position in relation to their economy for the coming year, and particularly in relation to the harvest, it is regrettable that they could not have the assistance which would be afforded by an organised parish plan in every locality. I believe that, if there was an organised parish plan, the efforts of the farmers could be further helped in these difficult few weeks. The position in springtime is different from that in harvest time when we can call on the people in the cities and towns, if necessary, to come to the rescue and save the harvest. The position is almost as serious now when farmers are putting forth their best efforts to get seeds into the ground but, unfortunately, they cannot call on the people of the cities and towns to come to the rescue of the nation and to assist in that work because it is a very different process from that of harvesting. I feel that if the parish plan had been in operation, the difficult task now facing the farmers could be considerably eased.

Comment on this

Why not try the co-operative movement?

Comment on this

I leave the Minister to reply to that question, but I think that the parish plan would be the first step in that direction. The output on farms in this country as compared with that on farms in other countries is low. Our farmers have a particular way of life and work on our farms is not conducted on the highly commercialised basis which is followed in other countries. The turnover, for instance, on a British farm of 100 acres is many times greater than the turnover on an Irish farm of a similar area. Again, that may be due to the difference between the attitude of our farmers towards their occupation as compared with the attitude of farmers in England and other countries. At the same time, there is a constantly increasing world population, and there is no doubt that even if production were expanded in this country, there would be an ample demand for our surplus. The question of price, of course, arises but, if farming methods were improved, I have no doubt that extra production would result and in the long run it would be better for our farmers to have higher production than higher prices. Generally, higher prices are only a temporary expedient, but higher production, if maintained, in the long run will add to the wealth of the nation.

I was glad to see from the figures that the Minister, to a certain extent, has developed the dressed meat trade. I would be very much in favour of a further development in this trade if it is possible to bring it about. I believe that there is a prospect of carrying on such a trade with the United States and Canada, and on that matter I should like to hear something more from the Minister, particularly in view of the fact that the price of meat in these two countries is much higher than the price on this side of the Atlantic.

At the same time, the price of meat for consumers in this country is very high while butchers find it very difficult to make ends meet for about two months each year. I think these months are May and June. I am hopeful that the Minister will, in some way, take some action regarding the question of hides. The butchers, I think, get only 10d. per lb. for hides. Then they are not allowed to sell hides to the tanners. They must sell the hides to the fellmongers who take another 4d. per lb. profit before they send it to the tanners. Then the tanners get their whack out of it before the leather eventually goes to the boot factories.

I mention this matter because I believe butchers across the water receive something like 4/- per lb. for hides and Britain is prepared to send to this country boots made from these hides, for which the butchers get 4/- per lb., at a lower price than that at which boots manufactured in this country can be sold. As I say, the price paid to the butcher here for the hide is only 10d. per lb. while the butcher in England receives 4/- per lb. If you start to count that up, you will see that for years there has been something wrong somewhere. If the difference between 10d. per lb. and 4/- per lb. did not go to the farmers, it would go to the butchers and it would have the effect of relieving the position for consumers in the matter of meat prices. That is a matter, I think, that should be examined, especially when we realise that Britain was prepared to send boots to this country at a lower figure than they can be produced here although, as I say, the butchers here receive only 10d. per lb. for the hide.

I mentioned previously in the debate that the farmers would like to know something about a uniform price for pigs, some kind of a guaranteed price, so that they could base their economy on that figure. They could produce barley, oats or other foodstuffs suitable for pigs and try to make a profit, taking the figure of 220/- per cwt. as the basis of their calculations. At the same time, it will be difficult to satisfy farmers when they see the black market price which is available for pigs across the Border. There is an inclination to try and take advantage of that extra price, which is only temporary. It would be better for the farmers and the Minister to take the long-term view and base their calculations accordingly rather than on the black market prices or temporary prices which may be available during a time of shortage.

I see also that the Minister has decided to encourage the production of wheat, although he got 365,000 acres of wheat grown last year as compared with the Fianna Fáil estimate for that year of 247,000 acres. He has asked the farmers to give him more than 365,000 acres of wheat this year, and, as an inducement, has offered them a higher price on a better scale. He has asked them to produce good-quality wheat by giving a preference in the matter of price for best-quality wheat as compared with wheat of an inferior quality. Similarly, malting barley will command a good price during the coming year. He is also encouraging them to grow Ymer barley as a feeding barley. If that is done, it will enable him to go ahead with an expansion of pig production.

The Minister's attitude in relation to barley is very different from what the attitude of Fianna Fáil was towards that cereal in the year before they left office. We know that, at that time, the Fianna Fáil Government made it illegal for maltsters to pay more than 35/- per barrel for barley, and made it illegal also for farmers to ask or expect more than 35/- a barrel at that time. Certainly, the present figure is very encouraging when compared to the 35/-. I have no doubt that, if they get the time and the opportunity now, our farmers will grow a very much greater acreage of barley, particularly when they realise that we cannot depend on imported feeding stuffs, and that if we do we will definitely go out of the production of pigs and of poultry and other animals.

Last year, many farmers were encouraged to go into the production of turkeys, and it resulted in a very good profit for the wives of cottagers. There was much criticism some time before Christmas about the price of turkeys. It was said that farmers were getting a good thing out of this form of production. It is only right to say that it is not the large farmers who produce turkeys but the small farmers and cottagers. I, certainly, think it was a grand thing to see a farm labourer's wife get as much as £100 for 30 or 40 turkeys last year. That, certainly, was a handsome Christmas gift. It is one that a farm worker's wife is not accustomed to. I think that the market for turkeys in the coming year will be just as good as it was last year.

Comment on this

Every bit as good this year, thanks be to God.

Comment on this

And the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

I can tell Deputies that the feeding of these turkeys, mainly by country women, is not carried out on a commercial basis. They are fed out of hand by these housewives who take great pains in bringing the birds up to a proper quality.

Comment on this

Let them start boiling the nettles now.

Comment on this

I will tell them that. The price of 4/- per lb. for turkeys represents a great improvement. I remember the time when turkeys were available at 9d. per lb.

Comment on this

I saw them sold at 4d. per lb.

Comment on this

That was when you had the blue shirt.

Comment on this

Yes, and when I took the 4d. a lb. off the turkeys.

Comment on this

And when we took the blue shirt off you.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that from the Minister. The farm workers' and cottagers' wives will be glad to hear it, too, because they are the people who are mainly engaged in the production of turkeys. The money they receive for them helps them to buy little things around the Christmas season.

With regard to the land project, I am glad to see that, with the aid of this money, it is proposed to reclaim something like 4,500,000 acres of land. That, certainly, will represent an addition to the national wealth. One problem which I see confronting some farmers is that they find it difficult to avail of the land project when the question of drainage arises. Sometimes, there is a stream which annually causes a certain amount of flooding on the land. From experience, I have found that the officers of the land project are inclined to ask the farmers concerned to put the onus on the Board of Works, or perhaps on the county council of releasing the flow of water in that stream before they will recommend the spending of money on the project.

I agree, of course, that it is necessary to release the waters in the stream before going ahead with the land project. I would like to see the work carried out under the land project scheme instead of telling the farmers that they had better apply to the arterial drainage people or to the Board of Works, or that the matter was going to be dealt with as a local authorities' works scheme. That is a problem which has arisen in North County Dublin. It may also have arisen in other constituencies.

If we are to judge the progress made in the Department of Agriculture, and in relation to farmers generally, we have only to examine the table of figures relating to the value of the exports of various commodities during the past few years. Taking the 1947 figures, and comparing them with the figures for the last available year— that is for 1950—we find that the value of cattle exported increased from £15,600,000 in 1947 to £22,200,000 in 1950. The value of horses exported in 1947 was about the same as in 1950. The value of dead poultry exported in 1947 was almost £2,000,000, while the figure for 1950 was £3,900,000. The value of eggs in shell exported in 1947 was £1,500,000, compared with £5,100,000 in 1950, in spite of the bad price. Of course that has only arisen in the last few months. The value of the exports of condensed milk was £490,047, compared with £753,000 in 1950. The value of the wool exported in 1947 was £890,000, compared with £3,500,000 in 1950, that is four times as great. Probably during the present year there will be a drop in the price of wool, according to the international trade figures. There was not a pound of bacon exported in 1947 and people were very lucky to get a pound of bacon even in a shop in this country. But we find that £994,000 worth of bacon was exported in 1950

Comment on this

When you opened the Border.

Comment on this

That does not arise. These exports went through official channels. The value of tinned beef exported in 1947 was £752,000, compared with £1,540,000 in 1950. The value of chocolate crumb exported in 1947 was £472,000, compared with £2,784,000 in 1950. If those figures mean anything, they mean that the position of the farmer and prosperity in agriculture have continued to improve and are improving under the guidance of the present Minister in spite of much criticism. Naturally enough, everything does not go right. Of course, you cannot judge the Minister on a single item. You must judge him on the all-over picture and from that all-over picture you can see that agriculture was never so prosperous and continues to prosper.

Comment on this

No one would be so foolish as to judge the Minister for Agriculture on any single item of the various commodities which come within the scope of his Department. As Deputy Rooney said, he has to be judged by the all-over picture presented by the state of agriculture in the country. Undoubtedly, in the last few years there has been an increase in the gross agricultural output. We have not got the net figure in recent years and we have to deduct from the gross output on farms those things which the farmer buys for the purposes of his farm and from the gross national output of agriculture those things which are imported and used on the farm. Judging the effect of the Minister's policy from that point of view, we find that between 1949 and 1950, to take only this last couple of years, we have been increasing the gross output on our farms, which is reflected in increased exports of cattle and live-stock products, without adding anything to the national prosperity, the prosperity of this nation vis-a-vis other countries, its ability to purchase things from abroad through its exports.

The Minister boasts from time to time about the increase in the export of one or other of the commodities. He boasted about the increase in the export of cattle last year as against 1949, the export of eggs and the export of other agricultural products. But what did that amount to in the long run? Live-stock products increased last year over 1949 by about £6,000,000 and our import of cereals increased by £5.9 million or nearly £6,000,000. Therefore, if you take the £8,000,000 for maize and the £5,000,000 or £6,000,000 for wheat, they were largely the result of our borrowing dollars, and this increase of £6,000,000 in live-stock products is balanced on the other side by a dollar debt. We borrowed dollars and sold the increased live-stock products for pounds. I think that is bad business.

Comment on this

Dollars are a soft currency now?

Comment on this

The Minister must be soft in the head if he thinks dollars are a soft currency.

Comment on this

Because they are not a soft currency.

Comment on this

Is not gold flowing out of America?

Comment on this

Gold is flowing out of America to a very slight extent. A couple of Deputies behind the Minister spoke with great enthusiasm about agriculture. Deputy O'Gorman stated that everybody must be satisfied with it; Deputy Rooney had much the same thing to say. They both had the wrong idea that the Minister was providing them with 14/- a lb. for chickens. The Minister could not stick it any longer and he corrected Deputy Rooney, but 14/- a lb. for chickens was the idea that Deputy O'Gorman and Deputy Rooney had about agriculture, not 3/6 a lb. Through their rosy glasses they saw 3/6 a lb. for top quality chickens being translated into 14/- a lb.

Comment on this

14/- a bird.

Comment on this

14/- a lb. was what Deputy Rooney and Deputy O'Gorman said. I took a note of it. They may change it in the Official Report, but that is what they said. Deputy Giles stated that Fianna Fáil had changed their tune about agricultural production. I think Deputy Giles accuses the Fianna Fáil Party of having said that wheat and beet had gone up the spout and peat was going and, please God, it would go soon.

Deputy Giles, in his new-found fervour for the policy of Sinn Féin, accuses us and not the Minister for Agriculture of using those words. Deputy Giles is labouring under the misapprehension that it was the Fianna Fáil Party that said it would not be found dead in a field of wheat; that wheat and beet were all cod. He thinks those sayings were our tune and not the tune of the Minister for Agriculture. Indeed, we were delighted to hear the change of tune from the Minister for Agriculture. It took a long time to make a Sinn Féiner out of him. He has gone Sinn Féin at last, Republican flag and everything else. Now he will go galloping around the country shouting: "Up beet; up wheat; up Sinn Féin."

Comment on this

That flag was brought here 100 years ago, long before the Deputy was ever heard of.

Comment on this

The Minister, as Deputy Dillon, thought the flag was a dirty rag, a dirty rag that he would not salute a couple of years ago. Thank God, we have at last made him salute it. Why on earth, when the Minister decided to change his tune, did he not change it before 1st April? For several months past various people who were alarmed at the situation in relation to the supply of bread appealed to the Minister to ask the farmers kindly to grow wheat. Those of us who were a little bit more enthusiastic appealed to ask them nicely by giving them a little bit more for it. But the Minister refused to do that. Up until the 1st April he spent thousands of pounds in advertisements appealing to the farmers to grow food for cattle; the farmers were warned that the cattle would starve if they did not grow more barley and more potatoes. There was never a word about human beings who might go short of sugar or short of flour. There was no request from the Minister for Agriculture to the farmers to grow beet and wheat. Indeed an advertisement little short of blackmail appeared in one of our morning papers on 10th March: "Farmers are earnestly requested to consider the prospects for animal feeding-stuffs." Farmers were to consider the poor cattle; that was the tune. There was no consideration at all for the poor human beings who might go short.

Then somebody kicked the Minister for Agriculture into asking the farmers to grow wheat. He did it very reluctantly. The extra that he offered them was very small in comparison with what this Government has spent on other sections of the community over the last three years. The Minister for Agriculture always makes the poor mouth when farmers of one kind or another come to him. Instead of giving dairying farmers something additional for milk, he offered them 2d. per gallon less. When it came to the point that he was compelled to import butter he offered them an increase of ¾d. per gallon on the average for the year.

Comment on this

With a five-years' guarantee.

Comment on this

This same Government, according to the Minister for Finance, has given the civil servants £1,800,000 extra. As many members of this and other Parties have pointed out, one official has been given as much as £1,000 extra. This was in one fell swoop.

Comment on this

I thought it was all going to arbitration.

Comment on this

There was no arbitration about the £1,800,000.

Comment on this

Are we not a wonderful Government to be able to do that and take off all the taxes as well?

Comment on this

I will tell the Minister what arbitration there was. Let us examine the matter for a few brief moments. The Minister for Finance came in here with his first Budget and he said the salaries and wages of civil servants were as high as social justice demanded and as much as the country could afford.

Comment on this

The immediate relevancy of this to the Agricultural Vote is not at once apparent.

Comment on this

Before May was out the Minister for Finance gave the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs an extra £30,000 for a small group of post office workers. The minute others saw that, they said: "This is a political squeeze and we can squeeze too," and they squeezed and squeezed and squeezed until they squeezed £1,800,000 out of the Minister for Finance. But the Minister for Agriculture, instead of being able to squeeze a single penny for the dairy farmers who are supplying the butter, could only offer them a reduction of 2d. per gallon.

Comment on this

And £40,000,000 on land reclamation and free lime.

Comment on this

The £40,000,000 for land reclamation is benefiting farmers who are producing practically nothing on the land. Some of that £40,000,000 is benefiting the worst farmers in the country. The farmers who are prepared to work hard, milk the cows and farm their land to the best advantage are getting nothing from the Minister. All they have been offered is 2d. per gallon less for their milk.

Comment on this

I hope Deputy Allen will tell that to the Macamore farmers.

Comment on this

They know all about it.

Comment on this

They do know all about it.

Comment on this

The Minister wants to boast now about his land reclamation scheme. I would advise him to think over what the present Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, said a couple of days ago about another scheme—that it was a lot of hot air and propaganda that had been put over on the people for two years. The Minister for Agriculture boasted and bragged up and down the country about the £40,000,000 he intended to spend on land reclamation. It was said that 4,500,000 acres would be reclaimed within ten years. What have we in this year's Estimate? After all this boasting about 4,500,000 acres in ten years, costing £40,000,000, we find that, even though this money is coming out of Marshall Aid, and even though this Government is borrowing and is spending what it has never earned, grants to farmers amount to no more than they did in the year 1947-48, the last year Fianna Fáil was in office. There is roughly £500,000 for grants to farmers.

Comment on this

What about the work that is being done by the Department for farmers?

Comment on this

There is no doubt that the Minister is spending money on bulldozers, but his Estimates show only £500,000 for grants to farmers. What happened that £500,000 the first year the Minister was in office? He stood there in the Front Bench and said that he could not give this money because the country could not afford it, but he would give it if he could get it free from Marshall Aid. The land reclamation scheme was put out of commission the very first year this Government took office.

Comment on this

That is absolutely untrue.

Comment on this

That is absolutely true and the Minister knows that.

Comment on this

The Deputy is stating what is not true.

Comment on this

We will ram that down the Minister's throat. I want to put it down in my own speech now lest the Minister might correct what he says himself. The Minister has denied now to the knowledge of the Deputies present that he did not postpone that scheme.

Comment on this

You have only two dejected witnesses.

Comment on this

There are two others behind the Minister. I know Deputy Flanagan would not be a very reliable witness. His word would not be taken in court. However, there are several Deputies here who heard the Minister denying that he postponed the land reclamation scheme, the spending of the £500,000 which Fianna Fáil had in the Estimates for the year that we went out of office.

Comment on this

For the land reclamation scheme?

Comment on this

For the land reclamation scheme—the Land Improvements Vote.

Comment on this

The Deputy is rambling.

Comment on this

We have it on the record.

Comment on this

The farm buildings scheme also.

Comment on this

And the farm buildings scheme.

Comment on this

Now Deputy Allen is trying to salvage Deputy Aiken. Deputy Aiken is referring to the land reclamation scheme and says I cancelled it the year I came into office and he is going to wrap that round my neck now, and Deputy Allen is trying to undo the bow.

Comment on this

I was not as severe on the Minister as I could have been, as he also postponed the farm buildings scheme. It was only a matter of a mere £250,000 extra.

Comment on this

Deputy Walsh is coming limping back now.

Comment on this

The Minister does not mind being caught out in a falsehood. He is accustomed to that and has too thick a skin. As a matter of fact, when the Deputy beside him was found out in a falsehood of that kind in court, he sent him a telegram of congratulation before the whole people. However, we will get the quotation for the Minister and we will show what he was prepared to do for the farmers here. The Minister for Finance would have to raise it in taxation. He was going to spend all the dollars he could. He was quite prepared to borrow.

Take the whole matter of agricultural production since 1947. According to the figures the Minister has given us in the various official journals, we had a drop of something like 546,000 acres of tillage crops, root and corn and other green crops. Take a very low estimate of the yield of an acre. There was a couple of hundred thousand acres' reduction in wheat between 1947 and 1950.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy go on to give the yield now?

Comment on this

We will come to the yield.

Comment on this
Patrick Joseph Halliden Acting-Chairman (Mr. Halliden) Clann na Talmhan

It would be better if Deputy Aiken were allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

If the Minister thought that I had not got the figures——

Comment on this

I prepared them and gave them to him, in the White Paper.

Comment on this

The Minister did not give these particular figures.

Comment on this

I did. I gave the acreage and yield for each year, 1947, 1948, 1949 and 1950.

Comment on this

I have them made out, thank you. There was a drop of 217,000 acres in wheat.

Comment on this

And the yield?

Comment on this

Let me make the argument; we will come to the yield afterwards. There was a drop of 212,000 acres in oats and 33,000 in potatoes.

Comment on this

What about barley?

Comment on this

I have not got the barley figure, but the decrease——

Comment on this

There was a drop of 22,000 acres in barley and the yield was up 30,000 tons.

Comment on this

The decrease in acreage total for corn, root, flax and fruit— flax was 7,000 acres and fruit a couple of thousand — was 546,428 acres. Taking it on a very conservative estimate that you get £20 worth of foodstuffs per acre——

Comment on this

We have the yields. Read them out.

Comment on this

Taking it that we get, on a very low estimate, from an acre of tillage, in these various crops, £20 worth—it was in fact, worth very much more——

Comment on this

Why estimate, when you have the figure?

Comment on this

——that would amount to about £11,000,000.

Comment on this

The Deputy is rambling. He has the yield there.

Comment on this

£11,000,000 decrease in tillage crops. All the fuss the Minister has been making about a few millions extra——

Comment on this

The yield was up.

Comment on this

The Minister wants to put me off my speech, but I will make it, even if I have to talk till to-morrow night, and he may interrupt as much as he likes. The Minister has boasted about the few millions extra, from £15,000,000 to £22,000,000, the increase in cattle exports between these years; but the decrease in tillage crops was at least £11,000,000.

Comment on this

That is untrue

Comment on this

£11,000,000 worth.

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this

There was a drop in the acreage.

Comment on this

But not in the yield.

Comment on this

If the acreage had been kept up it could have produced another £11,000,000 worth. We could have produced more, as the Minister has pointed out that the yield per acre would have been very much more. As the O.E.E.C. pointed out, 1947 was the worst year that Western Europe had in living memory, for 100 years. The Minister may smile and talk to the Deputy who condemned him yesterday and try to put me off my speech——

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

I do not know whether there is a new mood to-night or not. I want to point out that 1947 was the lowest yield on record, not only in this country but in any country of Western Europe, from the time that statistics were taken for agriculture. The yield is up since 1947. It is not quite as good as other years during the war with regard to wheat or other crops, but it is up very much. We have great additional facilities for the importation of manures and in spite of the fact that the Minister did not help the farmers very much up to now, the additional manures the farmers purchased and put on the land——

Comment on this

I bought 100,000 tons.

Comment on this

The farmers bought it and it was the Sugar Company, the thing the Minister was going to put up the spout, that brought it in and distributed it. The Minister had to call on the Sugar Company to do that.

Comment on this

He did call on them.

Comment on this

I do not know whether they were called on or whether they themselves suggested it to the Minister. However, it was brought in and the yields went up. If the tillage area had been kept up we could have been producing £11,000,000 worth more of barley, oats, wheat and potatoes and this greatly increased price for maize abroad would not have affected us as gravely as it did. However, the Minister has changed his tune. He has come at last to the policy of Sinn Féin and we welcome him to our bosom.

Comment on this

O horribile dictu! Where is Deputy Walsh?

Comment on this

If he does not like that, we can give him a kick in the place where he and his Party will get a kick if the people get a chance.

Comment on this

Where is Deputy Walsh with the records?

Comment on this

He is on his way here, in his own good time, not the Minister's time.

Comment on this

I hope Sister Anne is keeping a look-out for him.

Comment on this

I want to come back to a little affair that affects County Louth and other constituencies. It is the question of potatoes. The Minister will remember in his earlier enthusiasm as one of the young oldsters in the Government, or as one of the old members in the young Government that the Taoiseach was talking about recently——

Comment on this

Spare my grey hairs.

Comment on this

——that in 1948 when he came back with the trade agreement he said that "it provided for the farmers of this country a sure and certain market at remunerative prices for any conceivable product that the land of Ireland could produce." That is from the debate on the trade agreement — I have not got the exact column —in 1948.

Comment on this

On the records of the House?

Comment on this

It is on this record here. Does the Minister now deny that he crowed in this House and all through the country that the agreement of 1948 was going to provide a guaranteed remunerative market for everything that the farmers of Ireland would like to produce?

Comment on this

I glory in that astounding achievement.

Comment on this

Astounding pronouncement. Indeed, there was another pronouncement the Minister made in that regard that he will remember. He waved his arms here one day in the House and he said: "I have created a situation when every farmer's wife in the country can look at the egg and say, when she sees the bill of the chicken coming through, ‘If you are a pullet, I know every penny you will fetch me during your remunerative life as a layer."

Comment on this

That she was.

Comment on this

For two years ahead he was going to tell the farmers exactly what they were going to get for eggs. Six months had not elapsed when the Fianna Fáil price of 3/- fell to 2/6 and then to 2/-. What turned out was that the farmer's wife had been telling lies to the pullets. They are not morally to blame because it was the Minister for Agriculture who persuaded the poor farmer's wife into telling lies to the pullets. Not only did the Minister for Agriculture make that pronouncement in that debate, but the Taoiseach said that "the agreement provides for the first time in our history a sure and certain market at remunerative prices for any species of agricultural products which will be produced in the land of Ireland."

Comment on this

Eggs were never mentioned in that agreement. They were covered by Deputy Smith's agreement of 1947.

Comment on this

The Minister said that it provided for the farmers of this country a sure and certain market, not for conceivable products excluding eggs or bacon or anything else but a sure and certain market at remunerative prices for every conceivable product. Surely the Minister, because he was going to drown the British in eggs, must have known what he was talking about.

The Minister got up here about the beginning of April, 1948, when he was just six weeks a member of the Government, and he boasted that in March, 1948, he exported twice as many eggs as his predecessor had in March of 1947. The Minister bellowed that it was no ill thing that he, as a young Minister for Agriculture, was able to double the quantity of eggs exported in the month of March, in the first month of his office, beyond what his predecessor had exported in the corresponding month of 1947. The Minister was not only able to conceive of eggs being a farm product, but he boasted about that and he tried to make the country believe that he produced a chick that would lay in two weeks.

Comment on this

It is as clear as mud.

Comment on this

For the last three years the Coalition Government have boasted——

Comment on this

What about the potatoes?

Comment on this

I will come back to potatoes.

Comment on this

Like Deputy Walsh, you will come back some time.

Comment on this

The Minister and his colleagues were boasting for the last three years about the great feats of production for which they were responsible and the amount of eggs that were being exported each year. Deputy Rooney here to-day, not knowing that the Minister was running away from this question of eggs, boasted that we had exported four times as many eggs in 1950 as we had in 1947.

Comment on this

He was getting his pin feathers then.

Comment on this

That is right. Of course, we do not expect the Minister for Agriculture to admit that he deceived the farmers and the farmers' wives. All we can do is to let the farmers' wives judge the Minister for themselves. I think they can do that pretty well.

Comment on this

Do not say that Deputy Walsh has brought the wrong volume with him.

Comment on this

It is all right so long as it is a big volume.

Comment on this

Any volume that you may open will do. The Minister for Agriculture is mentioned everywhere.

Comment on this

Deputy Walsh has brought the wrong volume!

Comment on this

The Minister need not console himself that he has brought the wrong one.

Comment on this

The Minister is full of sympathy.

Comment on this

I wish to continue until Deputy Walsh gets the quotation I want.

Comment on this

Probably Deputy Allen is looking for it at the moment.

Comment on this

The Minister made the statement that I quoted about the sure and guaranteed market for everything that the farmers could produce back in 1948. A lot of farmers in my constituency like to engage in the potato production as against a lot of other crops and for the last few years they have been growing potatoes. This year they find themselves in the position that they cannot sell them.

Comment on this

Sell what?

Comment on this

Potatoes.

Comment on this

Ah, go fish.

Comment on this

The Minister need not try to ride off that horse with me. I asked the Minister a very simple question yesterday at the end of his speech. I asked him: "Have you anything to say about the problem of potatoes?" The Minister got up and said: "I did not want to mention the subject, but the Deputy has forced me into saying that the potatoes which we sent over to Britain were boast in the heart." The Minister and Deputy Flanagan make a nice pair. They are peas in a pod. The Minister yesterday tried to make out that by asking the simple question dealing with a matter which is causing great perturbation in potato exporting regions I was in some way embarrassing him with the British Government. The Minister, when he gets into a difficulty, always has to have a baby in his arms.

Comment on this

Look at the mother and child over there!

Comment on this

They got too many babies in their arms on that occasion. The Minister on this occasion had a problem presented to him in relation to what the farmers in County Louth who wanted to export potatoes were to do with the potatoes they could not sell.

Comment on this

What potatoes that they cannot sell?

Comment on this

They were all bad ones.

Comment on this

If the Minister will meet a deputation from the Cooley farmers— they have asked him to meet them— he will find out all about it.

Comment on this

I know all about it and I know that you are trying to make mischief now.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair knows that these interruptions are disorderly.

Comment on this

The Minister is trying to get a baby into his arms. I am not going to make mischief——

Comment on this

That is what you are trying to do.

Comment on this

——but I am going to try to undo some of the mischief the Minister made yesterday. The Minister tried to make the case that the reason these potatoes were not being bought by the British was that they were boast in the centre.

Comment on this

That the British said they were boast. I was contending that they were not. You are trying to make the British case for them and you are a mischievous person.

Comment on this

The Minister is now going off on another plea. He need not try to put me off like that, because I remember exactly what he said, and I love to make the Minister show himself to be the liar that he is before the people.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will withdraw that expression.

Comment on this

Very well — the teller of untruths that he is. Yesterday the Minister said that the case he was making was that the potatoes were good and then, because I asked that question, he had to drop that and admit that they were boast in the centre and go on to plead that they were up to contract standard. The Minister said yesterday that they were not, but I want to tell the Minister that the farmers in Cooley, County Louth, deny what the Minister asserted yesterday, that they were boast in the centre. I was talking to one farmer who said that the potatoes had been inspected by the Department of Agriculture and by the representative of the Potato Marketing Board, and that they had taken out of a sack 12 potatoes as being all that could possible be rejected and that, when they split them, all they could find were two which were boast in the centre. The farmers in Cooley assert to me that the potatoes which were sent out from that area at least, inspected by the Department of Agriculture, and by the Potato Marketing Board, were in every way up to standard.

Comment on this

Are two out of 12 not 16 per cent?

Comment on this

Two out of a cwt.

Comment on this