We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 311–489 of 489. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

You told me it was two out of 12.

Comment on this

There were 12 taken out of the bag for test, selected as being of the worst appearance, and two out of those——

Comment on this

Two out of 12 you said.

Comment on this

Two out of a bag.

Comment on this

You are making as much mischief as you can.

Comment on this

The Minister yesterday tried——

Comment on this

He said two out of 12.

Comment on this

They are sending telegrams to each other now as to their credibility.

Comment on this

Stop making the British Ministry of Food case.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

May I remind Deputies——

Comment on this

Is the Deputy lonely for Maximo and Eindiger still? He should have forgotten them by now.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps Deputy Flanagan will allow me to say something some time? Discussion here is by way of speech and not by way of interruption or debate across the floor. Deputy Aiken is in possession and is entitled to speak. He ought to be allowed to do so.

Comment on this

Deputy Aiken knows well that I am engaged in negotiations and arbitration with the British Ministry of Food as to whether potatoes consigned by us to them conformed to the terms of contract or not. He gets up in this House now and purports to describe a transaction which declares 16 per cent. of the potatoes in a certain district of this country to be boast. Surely, if there is any sense of responsibility left in public life at all, a Deputy representing County Louth is not going to say that his information is that 16? per cent. of the potatoes in the Cooley area are admitted by the growers to be boast?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister has got in that statement now. Obviously, the Chair does not know whether what Deputy Aiken is saying is correct or not——

Comment on this

Or the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

——but the Minister will have an opportunity of challenging it when he rises to speak.

Comment on this

When the damage is done.

Comment on this

Yesterday I said that 12 potatoes were taken out of a bag as being all that was liable to be rejected and that only two out of the 12 were boast.

Comment on this

16? per cent.

Comment on this

Two potatoes out of 1,000 or a couple of thousand potatoes. The Minister said yesterday that all the potatoes were boast, not two out of a bag. We all heard him. He has tried to accuse me now of saying that, because two potatoes out of a bag were not up to standard. 16 per cent. of the potatoes were boast. He said yesterday that they were all boast. He is trying to establish an alibi for himself.

Comment on this

Mischievous malice.

Comment on this

The Minister is one of the best judges of mischievous malice in this country. He has been maliciously mischievous ever since he appeared in public life in this country and he has sitting beside him a person whom he has tutored into being almost as bad.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must confine himself to the Estimate.

Comment on this

Why should my presence here annoy Deputy Aiken?

Comment on this

Because of the speech the Deputy tried to fool the people with from this side of the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This is not relevant at all.

Comment on this

The Deputy is where he belongs at present—sitting beside the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will deal with the Estimate.

Comment on this

And the Minister is sitting where he belongs when sitting beside Deputy Flanagan. I want to say this, in conclusion on that subject, that my information is that the potatoes which were exported from Cooley were in every way up to standard, and the Minister has no right to drop or to depart from the stand which the Cooley farmers wanted him to take in asserting and proving before the world that these potatoes were up to standard. The belief in Cooley, and it is my belief, too, is that the reason the British are rejecting these potatoes is that they have more potatoes than they want. I warned the Minister last year, when two cargoes were exported from Carlingford which were cut by a £1 per ton, that he should be up and doing, that he should be fighting with the British authorities to maintain that, when the potatoes were passed by his inspectors, they should be accepted by them as standard potatoes. The Cooley farmers and the farmers in Donegal are going to suffer because the British are using their central purchasing powers to reject potatoes which are up to standard. I want to say that I regard that as a low-down trick on the part of the British and the Minister can tell them I said so.

I want the Minister also to tell them, when he is negotiating with them, that he made a bargain under which the British would accept these 50,000 tons of potatoes at a certain price, that they are not keeping that bargain and also that they are falling down on the other side of the bargain under which they promised to sell us a certain quantity of coal.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What has coal got to do with this particular Estimate?

Comment on this

It was in the same agreement.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister has no responsibility for it.

Comment on this

He boasted of the agreement under which we were sending potatoes. They are sending us bad coal but we are not allowed to say that it is bad. We must take it and pay the full price for it. But even though the potatoes which we sent them are good potatoes, if they can do without them, they can say that there is boast in the centre of them.

Comment on this

It is criminal for the Deputy to say that. He is pre-judging the case which is at arbitration.

Comment on this

I am pre-judging the matter in our favour — not as the Minister pre-judged it yesterday in favour of the British. I am judging it in favour of the Irish people — not as the Minister judged it yesterday to the disfavour of the Irish people and to the favour of the British.

Comment on this

What the Deputy is saying is mischievous.

Comment on this

Another agreement which was made by the Minister has led us into great difficulty. It was part of the same agreement. Under it, we could not send to any country other than Great Britain more than 10 per cent. of our cattle exports. If the Minister read the London Times of the 17th April he must have read that the British Minister of Food is boasting of that agreement and of how he has the Minister for Agriculture of this country tied up so that no matter what price we might get in Belgium, Holland, Western Germany or the United States we cannot send any more than 10 per cent. to these countries—an amount that would not be sufficient to embarrass the British. I raised that question when the Minister came back with this agreement. I pointed out that on many occasions the British had wanted to tie this country to such an agreement — that we could not send more than 10 per cent. of our exportable surplus to countries other than Great Britain — but that we had never agreed to it. Even though the British are falling down on part of their coal pact, and have sent us to America to import coal for dollars, we can send only a tiny fraction of our beef to America for dollars.

Of course, the Minister for Agriculture has a certain outlook in regard to the British market. He goes over and tells the British how much he loves them and how he loves selling to them. But all the Minister's palaver does not soften their steely blue eyes when they give 2/- for the eggs and keep him right on the spot of the 10 per cent. of our exportable surplus of cattle. This Minister persuaded the Minister for External Affairs that it was a good proposition. The Minister for External Affairs, way back in 1949, interviewed the Manchester Guardian and pointed out to that newspaper that we could have got a very much better price on the Continent for our cattle were it not that we had agreed to give the British 90 per cent.

I think that the Minister should point out to the British that they have fallen down on their part of the bargain—and he can tell them from me that I think they have behaved disgracefully in this whole matter of the coal that they were sending to this country, of the price that they are giving the Minister for eggs and of the rejection of good sound potatoes just because they have enough potatoes at home.

Comment on this

Did you go over with the Minister?

Comment on this

Oh, God forbid.

Comment on this

Why is Deputy Davin not talking in this debate? Deputy Davin used to speak here for hours——

Comment on this

Now you have drawn him on you.

Comment on this

——on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture. There is no doubt about it, there must be something in what the Minister for Agriculture said about the Labour Party being as meek as mice.

Comment on this

I will come again, Sir.

Comment on this

That is a foul and dishonest misinterpretation—and it is well that Deputy Aiken knows it.

Comment on this

They have got Deputy Davin and Deputy Hickey to agree, inside three years, to a reduction of the tillage area of this country by 500,000 acres. Deputy Hickey will keep on the bench too. He has a nice soft seat there, and he will keep it as long as he can because he knows that if he leaves it he may not return.

Comment on this

We will keep you where you are.

Comment on this

I should much rather be here. Anyone could have paid the same dishonourable price that the groups over there have paid in order to stick together for a few years.

Comment on this

It is time that Deputy Aiken rose above the level of abuse.

Comment on this

It is all out in the open now. The Taoiseach told one member of the Coalition what he thought of him and that member of the Coalition told the Taoiseach what he thought of him.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Aiken, without interruption.

Comment on this

He is very provocative.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

He has company.

Comment on this

The twin Deputies — the Minister for Agriculture and Deputy Flanagan—have been sitting side by side on the Front Bench for the past hour. In view of Deputy Flanagan's speech yesterday he had better keep quiet until I finish making my point. The Minister for Agriculture has been informed by me of the situation with regard to potatoes in Cooley. I should like to remind him that from the 1st June the potatoes will be practically useless for conversion into alcohol because of the large amount of carbohydrates that will have disappeared.

Comment on this

You have done as much mischief as you can.

Comment on this

I want the Minister for Agriculture to sow something with these potatoes so that they will not rot if the British fool him on this question. When Fianna Fáil were in power a price of £4 10s. 0d. per ton was given for potatoes going to the alcohol factory. Notwithstanding the fact that the Government could find £1,800,000 extra for civil servants, they cut the price of potatoes going to the alcohol factories to £4 per ton. The Minister has behaved towards the farmers down there as he tried to behave towards the creamery farmers. Fortunately, the creamery farmers are a little bit stronger than the farmers whose potatoes are sent to the alcohol factories at a reduction of 10/- per ton. It is unfair — if the people in that part of the country and, indeed, in Donegal and Sligo cannot sell their potatoes in view of the fact that the Minister asked them to grow these potatoes for export —if the Minister proposes to give less for the potatoes, because they are going to the alcohol factory, than Fianna Fáil gave for them. I will let Deputy Cogan join in my appeal for somewhat better treatment than the Minister has given the farmers in that matter.

Comment on this

Deputy Cogan has given me as much help in the past two days as Deputy Aiken has done damage in the last half-hour. That is the difference between you.

Comment on this

Do not say it is the wrong book again.

Comment on this

This is Volume 111, column 2591. About Marshall Aid he said:—

"The House has learnt, as proposed by the Government of the United States of America and by the administrator of the Marshall Plan, that the assistance available to this country should be by way of loan only. I must confess that this seems odd to me. We are one of the only countries in Europe who are in a position to say, if Marshall Aid be made available to our country by way of grant and a consequent fund created for expenditure in this country, that with the expenditure of that fund on the development of our agricultural industry, the rehabilitation of our land, the reconstruction of our farm buildings and the reequipment of our farmers with modern implements and modern methods, almost 100 per cent. of the consequent increased production of necessary foodstuffs would flow directly into the vacuum which exists in Great Britain and on the Continent of Europe at the present time — a vacuum for food which, if it is not in part filled by us, will ultimately have to be filled by the United States of America. And yet we, being the only nation in Europe in a position to say, ‘if given Marshall Aid in the form of grants, all our extra production will tend to lighten the burden of the princely generosity of the American people', are one of very few nations in Europe to whom the administrator thinks it right to say: ‘In your case no grants will be made'."

Comment on this

What has this got to do with my suspending the farm improvements scheme?

Comment on this

The Minister suspended the farm improvements Vote and said if he got a grant he could spend it on land rehabilitation.

Comment on this

Is that the best the poor Deputy can do?

Comment on this

That is not the best; I can do better. I am on my feet now and have not time to examine the speech. I must give him the best I can.

Comment on this

You are doing splendidly but I believe that Deputy Walsh is betraying his colleague.

Comment on this

This debate will go on to-morrow and we will get more accurate quotations——

Comment on this

You will certainly want them.

Comment on this

——than I can give from memory. I have to give the Minister the reference and the column of what he said and it will be done. I only marked what the Minister's denial was for the purpose of the record.

Comment on this

What has this got to do with Deputy Aiken's allegation that I suspended the farm improvements scheme when I came into office? That is the allegation.

Comment on this

Yes. That is what the Minister denies?

Comment on this

The plea was that the Minister did it—and I will prove it out of these books.

Comment on this

You have not proved it yet.

Comment on this

I have partially proved it.

Comment on this

"Partially."

Comment on this

Only by inference in that sentence, but we will get it, not only from the Minister's words but from the Minister's deeds; we will get it from Finance accounts.

Comment on this

The Deputy will apologise if he is wrong?

Comment on this

There will be no necessity to apologise.

Comment on this

But he will if he is wrong?

Comment on this

Sure, but the Minister will not apologise if he is wrong. If he were wrong he would expect Deputy Flanagan to send him a telegram to congratulate him.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Aiken on the Estimate.

Comment on this

It looks as if Deputy Walsh will be busy to-morrow.

Comment on this

He will want to do better than he is doing to-night.

Comment on this

He may speak himself.

Comment on this

He would be better speaking because he is a bad messenger.

Comment on this

I hope that the Minister will have better news for the people of Cooley than he had to-day.

Comment on this

Than you had.

Comment on this

I do not intend to stay very long on the subject.

Comment on this

You have not got time.

Comment on this

I have been listening to some of the Deputies speaking to-night, and even if they were only remotely concerned with agriculture they got up to praise the Minister. It did not matter where it came from, if they could establish even a remote connection with the land, they had to speak on agriculture.

My main concern is with the Minister's last efforts to have wheat grown in the country. As Deputy Aiken pointed out, there has been a remarkable change of front in the last few years. At one time he told the people of the country that he would not like to be found dead in a field of wheat.

Comment on this

I am sure he would not.

Comment on this

No, nor anywhere else, thanks be to God.

Comment on this

When he discovered the wheat acreage going down, like a drowning man grasping at a straw, he found a way to increase the price. He met a deputation on, I think, the 13th February, and when he got even a slight suggestion of a way out he jumped at it with the result that we will now have the graded system of payment for wheat. I do not think that the Minister will deny that we gave him the suggestion. It would not even occur to him if we had not suggested it.

Comment on this

The Deputy was a very gracious guest.

Comment on this

I heard Deputy Rooney talking about mechanisation on the land. One thing that the Minister has done by the grading of wheat prices is to throw back the development of mechanisation to its position of a few years ago when only a very few people went in for tractors and up-to-date machinery. I think that Deputy Hughes, my colleague from Carlow-Kilkenny, will bear me out on this: people who use combines for instance cannot have their wheat in the same condition as the man who cuts it in the ordinary way with a reaper and binder, stooks it for a week or less—or even if he does not stook it makes stacks of it immediately afterwards and leaves it to dry. It will be in better condition going into the rick and in threshing than wheat cut with a combine early in the morning when the dew is on the corn. There is nothing wrong with wheat cut early in the morning; neither does it contain more moisture, but as a result of the graded system the man who cuts his wheat with a combine and takes it to the mill will not have the same bushel return at 11 in the morning as he would have at 3 o'clock in the evening out of the same field of wheat. I am not saying it is a good system or a bad system. My experience is that it would bushel less than 61 and the wheat in my district always bushels 61 anyway.

The increase in price of 5/- per barrel is not sufficient to meet the increases in the cost of production since 1948. Of course this price was fixed in October, 1947, for the cereal year 1948. There is not anybody on the opposite benches — and very few of them who speak on agriculture know what they are talking about—will contradict me when I say that the cost of production has gone up by far more than 5/- a barrel which is the increase now offered. However, a great change has come over the Minister for Agriculture. I do not know what has happened to him unless it is the result of the questions put to him recently in the House.

The position in this country is, as Deputies now ought to know from the answers supplied by the Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture, that if an emergency occurred in the morning, our position regarding flour is a most unsatisfactory one. The consumption of wheat here per year is 480,000 tons and, with 366,000 acres of wheat grown this year and producing a ton per acre, we would run out of flour in June, 1952 — that is, if an emergency occurred. If an emergency occurred we would not be able to continue even until then, because I understood from the Minister in reply to a question that 97,000 tons of wheat have still to be delivered in this country.

One of the reasons given by the Minister for not producing more wheat is that we have not storage. But wheat can be stored without having buildings in which to store it. If the system were adopted which was in practice before, that is, that an additional price be given for wheat during the months of December, January and February, and if there were an inducement held out to the farmers who may not want cash after the harvest time and who may be able to hold wheat in ricks and thresh it in the spring, there would then be no necessity to build extra storage. Far better wheat would result by keeping it in the ricks until the spring. Any practical farmer will know that what I am saying is true.

I have said that the position is dangerous if more wheat is not grown for the people who are depending on our farmers to produce food. These people are in a dangerous position and the Government, individually and collectively, are charged with the responsibility of providing food for the people. The Minister for Agriculture, in his abhorrence of wheat-growing, in his vanity and pride and prejudice against wheat-growing, is running the risk of denying our people bread if an emergency occurs. That is the net effect it will have on our country. No inducement is being held out to grow human food, but every inducement is being offered and thousands are being spent on advertising for cattle foods. We have advertisements relating to Ymer barley. We have seen advertisements asking the people to grow Ymer barley, oats and potatoes in order to provide cattle and other animal food so that we can produce more beef and more bacon to send to John Bull.

There is no regard for the people of whom the Minister often speaks, the people living in Dominick Street or in many of the other streets in Dublin, or for that matter in Limerick, Cork, Waterford, Galway or any of our towns. There is no regard for the people who cannot produce sufficient food for themselves. I challenge Deputy Davin and the members of the Labour Party to ask the Minister why he has left it to this hour, until it is now too late to encourage the people to grow wheat, to offer a price that might induce the farmers to grow it. It is their responsibility as much as the Minister's. They are keeping him in office. If the people are denied bread, the Labour Party must take the same responsibility as the Minister for Agriculture.

There is another danger. We have been through one war and there is the possibility that we may have another. With the unanimous consent of this House and of the people we declared our neutrality in 1939. The same thing might occur to-morrow, but our efforts then might be futile if it were the case that we had not bread or other food for our people. It is no use having an Army, no use arranging the forces of this country and getting young men into the Army or the other Defence Forces, if we are unable to feed them. What would be the result of such a position? Our position would be weakened considerably.

I do not want to be uncharitable, but it strikes me very forcibly that the Minister's love and his spiritual interests are in England and he has weakened the position so far as this country is concerned; if he does not produce food for our people he will have weakened the country from the defence point of view. There is no use in having an Army if you have not food to feed that Army. Food is every bit as essential, and it may be even more essential than ammunition to go into the guns. There is a danger, and the great statesmen of the world say to-day that there is a danger that we may be confronted with another war. Our Minister for Agriculture has made no provision to feed our people, to have them supplied with a sufficiency of food.

Comment on this

That is good news for the enemy, is it not?

Comment on this

It is helpful.

Comment on this

The enemy know it.

Comment on this

And the enemy are producing food.

Comment on this

Our enemies are the first people who will take advantage of the situation here. The Labour Party must know that we were in a different position in 1939. It took us eight years to develop wheat growing. We were then in a position to go ahead, but to-day, even if the people were willing to grow 600,000 or 400,000 acres of wheat, we have not the seed to put into the land. That is admitted in the Minister's statement. The Minister is not in the House, and I am sorry that he is not here to listen to what I am saying.

Comment on this

How does Kilkenny stand in this?

Comment on this

Kilkenny stands well, and always stood well so far as producing food is concerned.

Comment on this

You ploughed up the Nowlan Park.

Comment on this

We produced as much wheat as did ourselves and also the people of Laois.

Comment on this

You ploughed up the Nowlan Park.

Comment on this

They did not need it. They produced all their requirements without any help from Deputy Davin. It will be very illuminating, I am sure, for some Deputies when I tell them that in 1945 we grew 662,000 acres of wheat and in 1950 we grew 366,000 acres. This year it is very doubtful if we will have 280,000 acres.

It has been my experience, and I am sure it is the experience of other Deputies from rural constituencies, that malting barley is getting preference this year over wheat. I have been speaking to farmers, maltsters and seed merchants, and in all cases the output of seed barley has increased, while the output of seed wheat has decreased. They use malting barley to make stout. That is largely the purpose for which it is grown, and the price is 3/7 per stone, while the price of wheat was 3/1½ per stone until the Minister made the announcement yesterday. That is the reason why our farmers are growing barley in preference to wheat.

Comment on this

What about Smithwick's?

Comment on this

It is a going concern, giving good employment, but at the same time the people of this country can exist without Smithwick's or without Guinness's if they have a sufficiency of bread. Without bread, ale and porter will not keep them alive.

All through the years I have heard comments regarding the amount of barley that was produced. In 1945 we grew 170,339 acres of barley, notwithstanding the fact that we grew 662,000 acres of wheat. In the past few months the Minister has issued advertisements in every paper printed in this country asking our people to produce more cereals. In 1945 we grew 170,339 acres of barley. Last year the acreage was reduced to 123,000. In all cases of wheat, barley, oats and potatoes, the net returns show that the tillage area has gone down considerably, and, as Deputy Aiken pointed out to-night, when Deputy Rooney was complimenting the Minister on the amount of money that had come to this country as a result of the export of live stock and live-stock produce, putting one against the other, our exports are just balanced by our imports.

We cannot produce bullocks on a field that is growing barley or wheat. If we have one, we cannot have the other, and it is a matter of choice between grazing and tillage as to which in the long run gives the best return to the country. I argue, from my point, that tillage is better than producing beef for Britain, that the policy of Sinn Féin, the policy of self-sufficiency and the export of our surplus is a better policy than exporting beef, mutton and bacon and importing foodstuffs. The latter policy has been enunciated by the Minister for Agriculture and has been supported by the farmers, by the Fine Gael members and by the Labour members of the Coalition Government. That is the policy, the policy of grass, that has been condemned in this country for the past 50 years. That is the policy that has caused the flight from the land and that has driven our agricultural labourers into the towns and cities, and that is the policy which, if it is pursued, will one day have Ireland within ten or 15 miles of Nelson Pillar, leaving nobody on the land.

Again I say to Deputy Davin, you and your Party are as responsible as Mr. Dillon, the Minister for Agriculture, as the Taoiseach, as the Minister for External Affairs. All of you have collective responsibility on the matter and when the time comes that you have to render an account of your stewardship to our people I hope you will make no apologies for the action you are now taking.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should use the third person.

Comment on this

What does he want? Compulsory tillage?

Comment on this

We do not know yet.

Comment on this

He is silent on that.

Comment on this

I am not silent. Yes, compulsory tillage for this country. It has been said many times in the past by Mr. Dillon, Minister for Agriculture, that due to his management, due to the amount of fertilisers he brought into the country since the emergency, and due to no other factor, the wheat yields have gone up. He has chosen the worst year in the history of farming in the past 30—and I can remember 30—namely, the year 1947, to compare with the years that have followed. I remember that in 1947, in my own locality, there was not one sod turned on the 24th April. That was the first day that a plough and horses could go into a field. There was no winter wheat sown and the spring wheat was more than six weeks late and, having regard to the late sowing, it was a mystery and a marvel that any crops were sown that year. That is the year that the Minister for Agriculture has chosen to compare with the years 1948, 1949 and 1950.

Notwithstanding that, taking the average yield for 1938, 1939 and 1940, immediately before the war, our production of wheat was 19.2 cwt. per statute acre and the average yield in 1948, 1949 and 1950 was 17.9, showing that, notwithstanding the flooding of our country with artificial manures, the yields had gone down. Nobody from the opposite benches has mentioned that fact.

Comment on this

Why did that happen?

Comment on this

I wonder why it was that the Minister for Agriculture did not mention the fact that the yield of wheat—in fact the yield of all cereals —has not yet come up to the average yield of 1938, 1939 and 1940. He will not answer it now, I am sure.

Comment on this

I will answer it when the time comes.

Comment on this

"When the time comes." The same applies as far as all cereals are concerned. If a suggestion that has been made in this House on a number of occasions had been carried out, if the good land that had been growing wheat for the past nine, ten or 11 years, had been fertilised as it should have been, the yields would have improved. During the war, fertilisers could not be obtained. Some lands had to bear two, three or four crops of wheat or other cereal, without receiving any artificial manures. If the Minister, when he got all the money he got under Marshall Aid, had subsidised artificial manures and had given it to farmers who were prepared to till their land, he would have been doing something far better than trying to drain bogs and spending on the drainage of bogs more money than the land would be worth when he would be 100 years dead. It will be there as a monument to him.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Not the kind of one you think.

Comment on this

I have been told on very reliable authority that in some cases the drainage of bog lands under this scheme is costing as high as £70 per acre. A residential farm in my county—and I believe that the land in it is as good as in any county in Ireland—would not make £70 per acre if put up for sale.

Comment on this

We do not drain bog land under this scheme down the country.

Comment on this

I have seen your machinery working in bog lands—lands that could produce only a very bad quality grass.

Comment on this

In Kilkenny.

Comment on this

What place?

Comment on this

In Tullaroan.

Comment on this

On whose bog?

Comment on this

There are strips of several farms availing of the scheme which can never produce anything but a very poor quality of grass.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy say where he saw drainage being carried out on bog lands?

Comment on this

I have told you. There is another at Poulaphouca.

Comment on this

On whose holding?

Comment on this

I cannot give you the names of the owners of the farms but I can give you the parish.

Comment on this

I should be obliged to the Deputy if he would.

Comment on this

There is another one I have passed several times coming up —near Baltinglass.

Comment on this

Maybe the Minister will hedge on the word "bog". Say "swamp".

Comment on this

Now Deputy, you know what you are to say. Say "swamp". What a loss it would be to the Party opposite if it had not Deputy Aiken to tell Deputies what to say!

Comment on this

The Minister would be well advised to avoid the swamps.

Comment on this

Say "swamp".

Comment on this

They have a knack of holding you and sucking you in.

Comment on this

And sucking in a lot of Marshall Aid.

Comment on this

Say "swamp" and be a good boy.

Comment on this

As regards the advertisements that appeared asking people to produce more cereals, Ymer barley is mentioned as one. I am taking this opportunity to challenge the Minister regarding the advertisement he had in the papers in reference to the yield in County Kilkenny. It is the first opportunity I got because it was only recently I was able to get the proof and the proof is in the report of the committee of agriculture. Six plots were grown in County Kilkenny on average land. One of these plots was where Swede turnips had been grown in 1949. It was heavily manured in that year and in the following year Ymer barley was sown.

Comment on this

And it failed on turnip land?

Comment on this

It did not fail but it was dressed with a 4-4-2 ratio dressing in the springtime and it yielded 40 cwt. to the acre.

Comment on this

4-4-2 of what?

Comment on this

Four cwt. of potash, four cwt. of super and two cwt. of nitrogen.

Comment on this

Four cwt. of potash to the acre?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That was a great dressing. Deputy Allen could give you a lecture on that.

Comment on this

Perhaps it should have been .203.

Comment on this

If the Minister had any knowledge of agriculture, I can tell him it was the Department's recommended dressing 30 years ago.

Comment on this

Four cwt. of potash, four cwt. of super and two cwt. of nitrogen?

Comment on this

I am telling the Minister that it was recommended by the Department 30 years ago for corn crops.

Comment on this

That may have been so 30 years ago.

Comment on this

And it gave as good results as the Minister is getting to-day. Do you remember what you told us last year down in Kilkenny about the lady, the harp and the greyhound?

Comment on this

I thought you did not remember. However, it is on record. We took the precaution of having a record of your speech that day.

Comment on this

That was very polite of you.

Comment on this

You told us all about the lady, the harp and the greyhound. However, that is not the point. The point is that we had five other plots.

Comment on this

If they were dressed in the way the first plot was dressed, I am sure you had some peculiar results.

Comment on this

They were not all dressed but they were on average land. The results where the swede turnip had been grown and where the heavy dressing was applied, gave two tons to the acre, and the average for the other five plots was 27 cwt. per acre. These plots were under the control of the county committee of agriculture and were supervised by our agricultural instructors.

Comment on this

Was the soil tested?

Comment on this

Yes, in all cases. The average yield on these five plots, as I say, was 27 cwt. to the acre. I have been growing barley for many years and I can tell the Minister that if I applied the same dressing to Spratt Archer barley——

Comment on this

You would be daft.

Comment on this

I would not be daft. I would not turn cattle in on wheat as the Minister did. If I applied the same dressing I do not say that I would get two tons per statute acre but I certainly would get a crop of malting barley that would pay me far better than Ymer barley.

Comment on this

If you apply 4 cwt. of potash to the acre, you would get the queerest crop you ever saw. It would have whiskers on it.

Comment on this

If I put it on wheat——

Comment on this

I thought we were talking of barley.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This is supposed to be a debate, not a conversation.

Comment on this

I want to challenge the Minister on the statement he issued to the Press and the advertisement published all over the country that the average yields of Ymer barley in Kilkenny were two tons per statute acre. That was your statement.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy might use the third person.

Comment on this

That was the Minister's statement.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy got the statement?

Comment on this

I will send you a copy of the statement.

Comment on this

You will read it here, my boy.

Comment on this

I will send you a copy of it and if you wish I will get it from the Press for you. However, that is the position. I should like to see Ymer barley grown in the country if it would give a fair return to the farmers but I believe that, at the price that is being offered, a sufficient inducement is not provided to people to grow it. Just the same as the acreage under the wheat crop is going to drop this year, the acreage under barley will drop because the price will not induce farmers to grow it. Neither will it induce them at this late hour to grow wheat. As I mentioned already, the Minister is grasping at a straw like a drowning man.

Comment on this

What are the Fianna Fáil farmers going to grow now?

Comment on this

We are growing wheat, barley and oats just as we did always. In fact, at the present price, I would still prefer to grow wheat.

Comment on this

In spite of all you have told us.

Comment on this

I move to report progress.

Comment on this