Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 1–213 of 439. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I would like to ask permission to interrupt Deputy Tom Walsh's speech in order to give the quotations to the Minister for Agriculture which he asked me to produce yesterday. The Minister, when I was speaking, denied that——
Comment on this
I am not preventing the Deputy from making a second speech but, obviously, anyone who has not yet spoken is entitled to speak before a second speech can be made by a Deputy.
Comment on this
I am only giving a series of quotations, which the Minister asked for and which I could not produce yesterday.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy will have to wait until everybody else who wishes to speak has spoken. It is in the nature of a second speech.
Comment on this
When I was finishing my speech last night I mentioned to the Minister that, personally, I would prefer to have wheat grown rather than barley. I have many reasons for that. One particular reason is that it is much easier to harvest wheat than to harvest barley, but I was influenced by a greater motive than that, and so are the farmers of this country, even though the Minister for Agriculture may not desire it or never believed in it, or does not believe that the farmers are still nationalists. It has been his policy, not merely since he came into office, but during the emergency period, to do everything he could to nullify the efforts that were being made by the farmers, by advice, by example, by statements, and everything else. I believe that his one sole ambition is to see this country subject to Britain again and that that is one of his reasons for not asking our farmers to produce the requirements of food for this country.
Comment on this
With profound respect, on a point of order—if the Deputy will excuse me—is it in order to charge a Deputy of this House, never mind a Minister, with treason?
Comment on this
It is not a charge of treason. This House is not a competent authority to decide what is or what is not treason.
Comment on this
Certainly, it is treason to seek to supplant the Government of this country by a Government of a foreign country. If that is not a charge of treason, I do not know what it is. I do not think it is a charge which should be made.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister does not deny that he made treasonable statements in this country during the war period?
Comment on this
It is known from one end of this country to the other the statements that were made and it is a continuation of that——
Comment on this
On a point of order. Would it be in order for a Deputy to charge another Deputy with murder? In my respectful submission, treason is as grave a crime as murder and punishable by the same penalties under the criminal law. The Deputy not only implies the charge but now specifically makes the charge. I respectfully submit that a Deputy must not charge another, within the rules of order, with treason.
Comment on this
The Deputy has said that the Minister was guilty of treasonable statements, treasonable utterances. This House is not a competent authority as to what are or what are not treasonable utterances. The House has no evidence of whether they were made or not. I take it the charges are political charges.
Comment on this
I am not competent to say whether it is a criminal charge or not. It is not my function to say whether a charge is criminal or not. If there were a definite charge made which I knew was criminal, I certainly would ask the Deputy to withdraw. I do not think the charge made by Deputy Walsh is a criminal charge against the Minister.
Comment on this
I will go further now and I will tell the Minister that the policy pursued by his Department as regards the production of human food is treasonable.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy might be going a bit too far. The Deputy can deal with the Estimate without making such allegations as he is making at the moment.
Comment on this
I mentioned last night, in reply to Deputy Davin—the admission was not forced from me, because it is my own personal belief—that we should have compulsory tillage in this country. When the Minister was speaking in Clonmel to the South Tipperary Committee of Agriculture he stated that this country was carrying 12 months' supply of wheat and that a survey was being made at the moment of the whole tillage area of the country so that it would be possible in 48 hours, if there was war, to tell each individual farmer the type of crop he would be required to grow on his land. I wonder if anybody has ever heard anything so ridiculous as that. Imagine asking the people to produce, for instance, wheat, in the month of May. Imagine asking them to produce barley or oats in the month of May or June.
If the Minister had any conception of what he is charged with and the responsibilities that are attached to his office, he would know that it is not in the month of April he should tell the farmers he will give them an increased price for their wheat. He would have made an announcement, such as had been made during all the years that Fianna Fáil were in office, in the month of October, in order to give an opportunity to farmers to prepare their land for spring sowing. The Minister comes along and makes the statement to intelligent farmers in South Tipperary:—
"In the event of an emergency, I will see that the people of this country will not be short of food because even if it is in the month of July, I shall ask them to grow more wheat."
That is what it amounts to.
Comment on this
Well, it is like a good many other of the statements I am sure that have come from your office that you will deny also. Of course we are not surprised at that. We have been told that we have some abnormal people in the Government, so I suppose we may have another one sitting on the opposite bench now. The Minister went on to say that this was entirely different from the procedure in the last war when every farmer was required to grow the maximum quantity of wheat irrespective of the varying effects on the land. The scheme that was put into operation by the last Government ensured that every farmer in this country was going to produce at least sufficient for his own family. What was wrong about that? There was nothing wrong about it, but there was this right about it, that the ranchers who never wanted to till an acre of land were compelled to grow at least something. If the Minister would adopt the same attitude as was adopted by Fianna Fáil these ranchers would not be allowed to concentrate on the production of beef and mutton alone. They would have to till their land.
Comment on this
"When I start compelling people," he went on to say, "it will be a very detailed and drastic procedure because you will grow what you are told and grow it right."
Comment on this
I am quoting from your statement at the South Tipperary Committee of Agriculture on 30/9/1948.
Comment on this
From a report that appeared in the Irish Independent. So that the Minister in 1948 believed that in times of emergency it might be necessary to compel our farmers to carry out the wishes of his Department. He had got away at that period from the pip-squeak inspectors we heard so much about before.
Comment on this
It does not matter what the Deputy read out. The Deputy should use the third person. It would lead to more decorum.
Comment on this
I mentioned the fact that we were told before that we had some abnormal Ministers. I thought it possible that we might have another as a result of your denial of that letter. However, I shall come to other letters later. I have dealt with wheat. There is another subject about which I should like to say a word and that is the price of milk. We all remember last year when the Minister went to Dungarvan, County Waterford, and made a statement to representatives of the milk producers and creamery suppliers in that area. He told us he was going to circularise every creamery in Ireland asking them to accept a price of 1/- per gallon for a five-year period. That represented a reduction of 2d. per gallon. I understand that, out of 100 creameries that were circularised, three were agreeable to accept the Minister's scheme. However, it was rejected and this year the Minister has increased the price of milk by one-eighth of a penny per pint.
Comment on this
I suppose it is in pints the Deputy delivers milk to the creamery. It is like what he would do. He would, perhaps, deliver it in naggins, if he could.
Comment on this
Was it ever conceived that milk was produced only in summer time and not in winter time? When the Fianna Fáil Minister for Agriculture was fixing the price of milk in May, 1947, he had the good sense to make provision for the person who was producing milk in winter time. He was encouraging winter dairying, but the Minister apparently does not care what happens to the man who tries to produce milk in the winter time even though it is far more expensive. That is something which the Minister should know, but I do not know whether he does or not. Any ordinary, intelligent man knows that it costs much more to produce milk in winter time than in summer. Now he comes along to increase the price by one-eighth of a penny per pint for the milk produced this summer.
Comment on this
It does not matter how much. It will be less under your scheme. Whatever percentage is produced, less will be produced in winter in future because no encouragement is held out to these people who are prepared to go in for winter dairying. Does the Minister consider that a price of 1/3 per gallon is sufficiently attractive and a sufficient inducement to have more milk and butter produced? Does he realise that the cost of production in creameries has gone up enormously? To quote one instance alone—I happen to be closely connected with a creamery——
Comment on this
It is doing very well, though not as well as the chocolate crumb factory in Carrick. You know all about it.
Comment on this
I did not. I did my best to help it, but there are other people who have practically destroyed it.
Comment on this
The price of machinery, as I have said, has gone up enormously in the last few years. To take one instance alone, a creamery separator of 1,200 gallons capacity, which cost £85 some years ago, has gone up to £560. I am letting that sink into the Minister's brain. Other costs have increased, though maybe the increase has not been in the same proportion. They have increased since 1947 far and away beyond the increase which the Minister now considers good enough for the dairy farmer. Boxwood has gone up; parchment has gone up; oil and petrol have gone up and wages have gone up, but the farmer must now take a lesser price for his milk than in 1947. If the Minister had his way 12 months ago he would have had to take 2d. a gallon less.
Last night we were told by Deputy Rooney that when this Government came into office in 1948 the people were on a 2-oz. ration. If my memory serves me aright, and if my hearing was correct at the time, I think the Minister agreed that we were on a 2-oz. ration then. I wonder did the Minister agree with that statement last night?
Comment on this
I thought he did. It was statements like that of Deputy Rooney that put the Government where they are sitting to-day. These statements were without foundation, and were based on lies, trickery and deception because when the Coalition Government came into office the ration of butter was six ounces and not two ounces as the Minister stated last night. For his information, I will go back over the years and give him the ration of butter since 1942. In part of 1942 it was eight ounces and in part of the same year it was 12 ounces. In 1943 it was eight ounces. In 1944 it was eight ounces part of the year, six ounces for another part of that year and for a further part of the year it went back again to eight ounces. From January until February in 1945 it was six ounces. On the 1st February, 1947, it was reduced to four ounces, and from March, 1947 until May, 1947 it was reduced to two ounces. It was again increased in May, 1947, to four ounces, and in January, 1948, to six ounces.
Last night, when speaking on the comparisons that were being made by the Department of Agriculture, I mentioned that the year 1947 was the worst year that we had in the past 30 years as far as agriculture was concerned. I stated that not until April of that year could ploughing be started. Cattle were dying. In fact, the Fianna Fáil Government had to introduce a scheme in 1947 to replace the numbers of cattle that had died as a result of the severe weather we had during that winter. Consequently, the production of milk went down, and so we had less butter. I have already said that Deputy Rooney and other Deputies have tried to tell the people of the country that Fianna Fáil had reduced the ration of butter to two ounces all through that period, and that it was only two ounces when this Government came into office.
Comment on this
The Minister said it was 2 oz. in 1948 when his Government came into office. That is wrong, and there has been no withdrawal of it, but, as I have already said, it is because of statements such as that, and for no other reason, that the Minister finds himself on the Government Benches to-day. I would remind him that the Irish people have a way of dealing with those who deceive them.
Comment on this
The Minister has already challenged me regarding some statements which I have read. I am now going to read another one for him. It is in connection with Danish butter. I suppose most Deputies have seen in this day's Independent an article regarding the distribution of Danish butter. I have here a circular letter which was sent to the creameries. It was written on the 9th March, 1951, and is as follows:—
"Sir,
I am directed by the Minister for Agriculture to refer to the distribution by the Butter Marketing Committee of imported butter to creameries to meet their rationing requirements, and to point out that where imported butter is made up into rolls on creamery premises the use of printed wrappers bearing the inscription that the butter is Irish creamery butter is illegal. Such butter should be wrapped in plain paper or in paper on which a proper description of the butter is printed. If, however, supplies of suitably printed wrappers are not available, creameries may, as a matter of expediency, use their own printed wrappers provided they are overprinted clearly, by rubber stamp or otherwise, with an appropriate description of the butter such as the word `imported' in letters at least as large as the largest printed lettering on the wrapper.
It should be clearly understood that imported butter may be disposed of only in accordance with the rationing regulations, and that creameries may not, under any circumstances, sell such butter in the official wrappers prescribed for unrationed Irish creamery butter."
That circular was sent to the creameries on the 9th March by the Department of Agriculture. On the 6th April, 1951, another letter was sent to the Irish creameries which reads as follows:—
"I am directed by the Minister for Agriculture to state that, with a view to reserving all available supplies of Irish creamery butter for ration requirements, it has been decided to discontinue the issue to creameries of supplies of official wrappers for unrationed creamery butter. Arrangements are being made to make available to creameries supplies of imported butter for sale off the ration. Supplies of suitable official wrappers for this purpose are being obtained and will be distributed very shortly to creameries."
Now, the first letter dealt with the distribution of butter, and it warned the creameries that, under no circumstances, should they put wrappers around the imported butter.
Comment on this
That was done to meet the reasonable representations which had been made to me by Deputy Vivion de Valera. The Deputy can now consider the whole scheme as being off.
Comment on this
I thought that the representation which was made to me was perfectly reasonable, but it failed.
Comment on this
Yes, I did my best to meet Deputy Vivion de Valera's reasonable representations, and despite my best efforts I failed.
Comment on this
Very well, the Minister did not want the imported butter to be distributed by the creameries in March but in April he did. The Cork people — the creamery suppliers — decided that they were not going to use the Danish butter. It, surely, was enough for them to have their ration of butter reduced from the 14 ounces that were given to them all through the war and the emergency by the Fianna Fáil Government without having to use the Danish butter. This fact should be made known, that every farmer supplying milk to the creameries got from ten to 16 ounces of butter per head during the ration period. It did not matter to the suppliers what the ration was, they still got that quantity of butter. But the Minister decided that the Irish farmer who had been producing food for the nation during the emergency was not entitled to get his own butter back from the creameries, with the result that he was put on the same strict ration as every other individual in the country. If he required any butter over and above the ration he had to pay 3/6 per lb. for it.
Comment on this
I wonder what changed the Minister's mind regarding this new scheme which he had in mind, and which he has now admitted to be a failure. I wonder was it the following advertisement which appeared in yesterday's issue of the Cork Examiner?
Comment on this
Did I not announce on the day before yesterday that I had to give up the scheme as I could not make it work?
Comment on this
Almost every time the Minister is doing anything he flashes in the papers what he is going to do. He is spending thousands of pounds advertising his Department and himself. Here was something that he now admits to be a failure and he tries to hide behind some bush with it. He does not tell the people that it has been a failure. We had to elicit that from him to-day. This is the advertisement issued by the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association:—
"Irish creamery butter, the farmers' property, is being requisitioned under Departmental Order from our creameries and foreign butter is being substituted."
The Minister is going to take the Irish creamery butter that had been supplied by the farmers away from them and bring it up to Dublin and to the other cities, I am sure, looking after his people in Dominick Street as usual and giving them Irish creamery butter and asking the farmer to fill himself with the Danish butter which cannot be eaten by the people of Dublin. That is what the Minister wanted. The advertisement continues:—
"Is this constitutional? Irish creameries refuse to become distributing agents for foreign butter? Meeting in Town Hall, Mallow, on Saturday, 21st April, at 2.30 p.m. (S.T.) to consider situation and joint action by creameries and farmers. Representatives of all creameries and branches invited."
I am sure the Deputies from Cork were invited and that Deputy Keane will be there telling the people he will give them wholehearted support.
Comment on this
He is a nice dairy farmer. One of them is an old age pensions officer and the other a sawmill proprietor.
Comment on this
Does the Minister deny the right of Irish farmers to employ any man they like to act for the creameries?
Comment on this
Why quarrel about this matter? He is carrying out the duties for the people who put him there.
Comment on this
This debate must not be carried on as it is at present. We must have order or abandon the debate. You will have to allow Deputy Walsh to proceed without interruption—that goes for every part of the House.
Comment on this
As a result of that notice, I am sure, we have a report supplied, even though there is nothing official about it, through the Irish Independent. It is most significant that it does not appear in any other paper. I wonder why the Department of Agriculture did not get in touch with the other Dublin papers and give their readers an opportunity of knowing what is at the back of the Minister's mind. To-day's Irish Independent carries the following article:
"A proposed scheme for the allocation of imported butter has been abandoned, an Irish Independent representative learned.”
I wonder where.
"The Minister for Agriculture had hoped to distribute imported butter outside Dublin, and draw more on the southern creameries, so that Dublin might have a fifty-fifty supply of Irish creamery butter and imported butter.
This scheme, it appears, was found difficult to operate, and has been dropped. For about a month Dublin will be obliged to take whatever butter may be available. Home production is much below normal now because of the recent severe weather."
"Because of the recent severe weather." But Deputies on the opposite benches when they came into the House and wanted to make comparisons about the production of our cereals, of our milk and everything else always conveniently forgot that 1947 was one of the worst years in the history of agriculture and it was on that year that they based their comparisons. Now they are making alibis for the next harvest. I hope there will not be any necessity, but they are trying to do it already by talking about the bad spring we have had in order to save themselves.
Last night Deputy Rooney talked about the increase in the consumption of butter. There is not such a remarkable increase in the consumption of butter as Deputy Rooney would have the House believe. My figures for the consumption of butter pre-war are 18 lb. of creamery butter and 16 lb. of farmers' butter. To-day that has been increased to 41¼ lb. It is easy to account for that as we know that the price of bacon has doubled.
Comment on this
41¼ lb. per head per year. That is between 13 and 14 oz. per head per week. During the war it was 12 oz. or thereabouts. That is easily accounted for owing to the scarcity of bacon. If the Minister's policy is pursued of asking people to produce pigs at £11 per cwt. which cost about £12 10s. 0d. per cwt. to produce we will have more butter used—that is again taking his own figures. I want to ask the Minister how he has conceived the idea of fixing the price of milk at 1/3 per gallon for the summer and forgetting about the winter production. There is an easy way to increase the price of milk for farmers substantially. He mentioned 13½ oz. of butter as being the consumption per head per week. If he works out in detail what that costs the consumer he will find, if he puts a ½ oz. to it and makes it 14 oz. so as to make it mathematically easy, that butter is costing the Irish consumer 3/1 per lb. at the present time. If he increases the price of butter from 2/8 to 3/1 and continues the subsidy he will find that he will be able to increase the price of milk by more than 1d. I am not asking the Minister to ask the consumers to pay one fraction of 1d. more than they are paying. These figures are based on his own statement. Every man, woman and child in this country is getting something like 13½ oz. of butter per head per week. To make the calculation easy, I am putting it down at 14 oz. For 8 oz. of that butter the consumer was paying 1/4 and for the other 6 oz. 1/9, that is before the 2d. was put on. That makes a total of 3/1 per lb.
Comment on this
It will not fetch 3/6 per lb. in the months of June and July. It certainly should not fetch 3/6 then. We know the way in which the Minister reduced the price of farmers' butter when he removed the subsidy. The Minister should know all about that, too, because it was he who put these people out of production.
I must refer now to another statement of Deputy Rooney's. It is indeed odd to see how Deputy Rooney gets these silly ideas into his head. He said the production of milk has gone up and that more milk is coming into the creameries. Did Deputy Rooney stop to consider why more milk is going into the creameries? He does not have to be a genius to find the right answer. The Minister must know that numbers of people who were producing home-made butter prior to his removing the subsidy were unable to get an economic price and consequently they have to send their milk to the creameries. That accounts for the increased milk production reaching the creameries. The Minister has never come in here or gone round the country telling the people the true reason for these increased supplies of milk to the creameries; but he gets Deputy Rooney to come in here and talk about increased supplies and also about the dual purpose hen, a bird we heard so much about some months ago. It is a pity Deputy Rooney did not get away with that.
I would ask the Minister to consider the suggestion I have made to give the farmers an increased price for their milk. As I have already pointed out, the Minister will not be asking the people in Dominick Street, and the other streets adjacent to it, to pay more. When the Minister came into office he stated publicly that he intended to be Minister for Agriculture and for nothing else. My belief is that when he was appointed to that office his first responsibility was to ensure that the farmers would get a fair crack of the whip. I am sure he has been told often enough that he has not done anything like what his predecessors did for the farmers. The Minister's predecessors made the farmers prosperous and independent. The present Minister is pursuing a policy which will only have the effect of making them once more dependent on the gombeen man and the shopkeeper. In other words, he will put them back into the position in which they were prior to the advent of Fianna Fáil.
I will now deal with the price of bacon. The Minister has told the people that he has made an agreement with Britain to supply Britain with bacon at 220/- per cwt.
Comment on this
That has been published in the papers, If that is not so, then what has the Minister done? What do these statements about 220/- per cwt. mean?
Comment on this
Do you not know the difference between bacon dead weight at the factory and the live pig at 220/- per cwt.? Would somebody take him out and instruct him?
Comment on this
For dead-weight pigs, irrespective of whether it is the yard, or in the sty and not in the factory. I grant that much. Has the Minister forgotten the statements he made in 1947, when he talked about maize at 2/- and 3/- per stone and how impossible it was for the Irish farmer and cottier then to produce bacon? He stated at that time that the cost of production was far in excess of what the producer was getting. Let us come back to the present. He is now Minister for Agriculture and surely he will not deny the statements he made before he became Minister for Agriculture. I know he has already denied letters that have issued from different committees under his control. Surely he will not deny now that the price of pig feeding is round about 35/- per cwt. and that it takes about 7 cwt of admixture to produce 1 cwt. of bacon. It is then only a matter of calculation to find out what it costs to produce 1 cwt. of bacon and discover the difference between that and the price the farmer would obtain for it. There was only one period during which the Irish farmer was given an opportunity of getting a decent price for his pigs. That was a few months back. In May of 1950, at column 2226 of the Official Report, Dr. Maguire put down a question to the Minister:—
"To ask the Minister for Agriculture if he will arrange to facilitate the export of pigs to Northern Ireland in view of the high prices prevailing there."
The Minister replied:—
"The British Ministry of Food, which is the purchaser of all fat pigs exported from this country, accepts such pigs only at designated centres in England, namely, Liverpool and Birmingham. There is no approved purchasing centre for our fat pigs in the Six Counties.
The future position as regards exports of pigs as well as bacon is at present under discussion with the Ministry of Food and pending the outcome of these negotiations it is not considered desirable that there should be a departure from the present arrangements in regard to the export of any classes of pigs."
Some time around October then the Minister had a meeting of the clan— the Molly Maguires up in Monaghan. The bacon curers were represented at that meeting and it was suggested to the Minister that the ban on the Border should be lifted. They were perfectly right. The price of pigs up North was around 285/- per cwt. They are that price to-day. The price of pigs in the South is 220/- per cwt., a difference of 65/-. Why should they not ask for the lifting of the ban? All pig producers would regard it as a reasonable request. Indeed at the time we did regard it as reasonable and lorries were hired all over the country to send fat pigs across the Border when on the 25th October the ban was lifted. I wonder who it was who advised the Minister to lift the ban. But three weeks later the Minister clamped down and the southern farmers were once more denied a legitimate price for their pigs. The northern price was a legitimate price because the people there were ready and willing to pay it. They wanted first quality bacon in the North and they were prepared to pay for it.
When an intimation came that it was proposed to reimpose the ban, lorries were hired in Waterford, Clonmel, Carrick, Kilkenny and everywhere else to transport pigs across the Border in an attempt to beat the ban. In fact, there was actually a race. Two lorries of pigs left Waterford at one o'clock in the morning on the day on which the ban was reimposed in a desperate attempt to get across the Border before closing time. Subsequently, the Minister came in here and said that nothing but suckling pigs went over the Border. Why has the Minister now to go to England? Why has he to incur the expense of sending representatives over to deal with the British Ministers and the British officials when all he has to do is lift the ban on the Border and allow our pigs to go across to the people who are prepared to pay 285/- a cwt.?
If he were carrying out the promise he made to the farmers, that he was going to be the Minister for Agriculture and nothing else, he would say: "It is my duty to stand by my people and get the best price possible for produce; I will take off the ban and let the pigs clear out." He has not done that. Why has he not done it? Is he concerned about the farmers? It looks to me as if he is not, but there are many sections of the community about which he is not concerned. The dairying people, for instance, are asking whether they will get an economic price for milk or not, but no statements that can be made here will induce him to give a better price. He did not want to give a better price for wheat, but it was forced from him, as, if we had not wheat next year, possibly the people of Dominick Street would be after him and would tie kettles out of his tail, if they did not do anything worse. He did not interfere in fixing the price of barley. That had to be done outside him, and the Beet Growers' Association had the price of barley fixed.
There is nothing he has done, and he has gone even further in the one and only agreement he made, that is, to ask our Irish farmers to sell their fat cattle at a lesser price than they could now obtain. We are compelled to send 90 per cent. of our fat cattle across to England when there is a market on the Continent prepared to give us a much higher price than the English are prepared to pay. It can be written down by the people, and particularly by the farmers, that of all the Ministers for Agriculture that ever sat in this House the man who now occupies that position will go down in history as being the worst.
There have been advertisements all over the country regarding the land rehabilitation project and the amount of money being spent and to be spent, £40,000,000 in ten years to reclaim 4,500,000 acres of land. I have put one question to the Minister on several occasions, namely, why not make the good land better, why not make the land capable of producing more food better than it is, so that it will produce more? Why waste money on land that will not produce more or, if it does, very little, and where unless it is carefully watched and minded, in ten years' time the money now being expended will be a dead loss. I know that in many cases throughout the country most of the people who are availing of these grants under the land rehabilitation project are large farmers in the main who for years past have neglected their farms. Having allowed the drains to choke and bushes of every description—furze, briars and hawthorn— to grow out into the fields, they are now asking the people of this country to borrow money to rehabilitate that land.
Why would the Minister not consider giving a subsidy on fertilisers? I believe it would not amount to the sum now being spent on some of our bogs. I do not know offhand what amount of fertilisers were used this year, but pre-war it used to run round the 250,000 tons mark. If £1,000,000 were spent on the subsidisation of those manures, I could give a guarantee to the Minister that he would have greater production. Fianna Fáil were criticised by the Minister and other Deputies for introducing the voucher scheme. It was one of the best systems ever introduced and it was a pity it was not continued, not at the value put on them when they were introduced in 1942 or 1943, but at an increased value. Those vouchers were issued to people who put their land under the plough and when they came to get the value they bought manures. That is what should be encouraged. It created a benefit for those farmers who were growing wheat during the emergency and a benefit that was richly deserved. If the Minister continued the policy, I could guarantee to him that not merely would he have more cereals produced, but he would have a greater quantity of milk and beef. That would be done by looking after the good land and forgetting about the bogs that will never come to anything.
I would make one final statement, regarding the Minister's offer at Dungarvan last year of 1/- a gallon for milk. It has been stated here that we have abnormal people in this House. The Minister was either abnormal then or he is now, as he has readily agreed now not to give 1/- a gallon, but to give 1/3 for the summer. When was he right—in 1950 or 1951? He has to answer that question. We all agree that the price is not sufficient to attract our people to produce more milk and at this price more milk will not be produced. The Minister need not get up—neither need Deputy Rooney—and say it was altogether because of the bad spring. Next summer, it does not matter how good it comes, the Minister will find that milk production is not on the increase —because of the price, and for no other reason. The farmers are prepared to produce food if they are paid for it, but I cannot see why every other section of the community can run to the jackpot and pull from it while the farmers cannot pull at all. They have realised their position and they know that there is no jackpot there for them, that they can pull only from the general pool and that the Minister is not doing anything to help them get proper prices.
Comment on this
I will be short and if there is any point in the Minister's policy with which I disagree I will tell him so, and if there is any praise I intend to give him I will do that here also. I have not a loud tirade of fault to find, like the previous speaker. I do not think Deputy Walsh is fair and is telling the truth. The farmers of Kilkenny and Wexford were always good farmers. They had a reasonable acreage of good land to till and they cared their land well. If I were to pick out the better type of farmers of the 26 counties of this Republic, I would go to Deputy Walsh's constituency and to Deputy Allen's, as they have the three things I have mentioned—better land, reasonable acreage and men willing to work. These are the three things which always make a good farmer. These are three things, one of which, at least, we have not in the constituency I represent. I remember some time ago, when there was a motion in this House asking for more credit for farmers, I jocosely said to Deputy Walsh, who was then speaking on the motion:—
"If you say the small farmers are getting all the concessions nowadays, how about a change over? We will go up to the east and let you down to the west."
I think that would not be accepted here. As far as the smaller type of farm is concerned—I have in mind farms in my constituency of 22 acres under £10 valuation—we must admit that they have been getting a reasonable proportion of the prosperity that is floating around. Matters are, in the main, good for them. Whether it is due to world conditions or the policy of the Minister for Agriculture, there is definitely more money in the small farms now than at any time during the past 40 years or within living memory.
At the outset, I would like to pay a compliment to the Minister for Agriculture in regard to drainage. The Minister made reference to the arterial drainage and also to the land rehabilitation project. In doing so, he told us of a number of rivers on which temporary relief schemes are being carried out and which he believed will be carried out during the coming year. I was very pleased to find out that he mentioned the river Moy in County Mayo as one of those rivers which would benefit by drainage under these schemes.
Comment on this
A survey will be made to have temporary relief brought within the coming year. I say this to the Minister, that that alone would ensure my whole-hearted support of the Minister's Estimate, irrespective of what else was done wrong by him in his Department. I say that, because in the County Mayo, where our valuations are so small, where our acreage is so limited and where a big percentage of our land is wet, we have looked for a good many years to get the levels of some of our rivers lowered so that it would be possible to carry out drainage schemes of some sort on the small farms, the land of which is so valuable to us. I can assure Deputies that life is a constant struggle on a farm of 25 acres, seven, eight or ten acres of which are wet or marshy. It is a case of trying to keep the wolf from the door.
As a result of the land rehabilitation project, which first came into operation in County Mayo, a large amount of very good work is being done. Money should be devoted to the development of fertilisers to make the land better and make the fertile land produce more. The farmer who owns fertile lands and fields is a very poor farmer if he does not put artificial manure on those lands and pay for it out of his pocket, particularly if the lands are capable of growing good crops. As a man closely associated with farming, I can say that by this time to-morrow I will be in a field doing farming of one type or another. If I were the owner of 40 or 50 or 60 statute acres of good tillage and arable land, I certainly would consider myself lucky and I would not be asking for a subsidy on artificial manures to make me produce better crops. That would be all right, but we must take into consideration the people who have to struggle on the wet land. I think it is only fair that we should give a chance to the smaller farmer with the wet land. He should get a concession to rehabilitate his land and make it fertile. Very good work is being done, but a very good percentage of money is also being wasted with the land rehabilitation project.
The land rehabilitation project consists of two parts. Under the first part, the farmer, by his own labour, carries out his own work under the supervision of the Department of Agriculture. In that case, the work is very well done and is supervised by the Department's supervisors. Every help that can be given is afforded to the farmers and where a farmer may have contracted to have one, two or 15 acres rehabilitated and is unable to do so within the time specified, he has the sympathy of the official in charge and of the Department of Agriculture. He is allowed a further period of time to compensate him for bad weather. He can carry on and still benefit by the grant and by the assistance he gets from the Department. The work of the land rehabilitation project is being done very well.
Under the second part of the land rehabilitation project, the work is done by the Department of Agriculture for the farmers on the payment of a certain sum of money by the farmers concerned. The largest number of applicants applies for this scheme. On those schemes we run up against problems which were not envisaged by the Minister or his officials when they decided to attack the problem of land rehabilitation. In one area in particular in Mayo, where excavators, bulldozers and machines do the quickest amount of work in the shortest possible space of time, everything seems to operate against the work. I have seen with my own two eyes a bulldozer employed for three days doing nothing else except pulling an excavator out of a swamp where it was stuck. That was no fault of the Minister for Agriculture or anybody else. It just happened but I doubt if it is wise to rely too much on having a good job done cheaply with machinery. Where heavy machinery is used in swampy ground and sinks it cannot be taken out by manpower, particularly when the manpower available consists of only a few men.
Comment on this
I will. When the machines are bogged, the only sensible solution is to try and pull them out with another machine. In fairness, however, to the same machinery, I have seen land reclaimed which I thought nothing on earth could possibly reclaim. I have seen acres of scrub and furze shoved completely out of the way and the land now shows the first real sign of grass for 200 years.
I am glad to see that even the smallest farmers are going in for this idea of making their fields larger. The levelling of ditches and embankments and the filling up of sand pits and so on is being carried out and carried out very well. I will admit that machinery can do a much better, a much faster and much cheaper work in that respect than any type of manpower, but, in the case of drainage schemes, it is doubtful if the heavier type of machinery is suitable for operation in the areas where the farms are small. There is also the trouble, as I have been told, in connection with shifting heavy machinery from one farm to another.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy know that the pressure per square foot of the largest bulldozer is less than the pressure of his own foot?
Comment on this
I do, but there is the caterpillar tread which goes round and round in the same track without gaining an inch of ground, even though the pressure per square foot is less than that of the lightest tractor.
Comment on this
Of the lightest tractor, not to speak of a man. Still, this caterpillar tread cannot grip and every revolution sends it deeper into the ground. It is no fault of the machine or of the driver, but it is something which makes Deputies like myself, who claim to have a fair knowledge of this type of machinery, wonder if it would be better if the Minister could purchase a lighter type of machine which would be easier to manæuvre from one small farm to another. I understand that applications are taken in order of merit, and I have no complaint to make about the way in which applications are dealt with and work carried out on farms.
Comment on this
In the order of their receipt. We are told, however, that the county council engineers object to a caterpillar tractor or excavator being driven over a county council road. I do not know how true it is, but I am informed that, at times, when these machines have to be shifted from one small farm around two or three other small farms and on to another, the operator must wait until the low loading conveyor, which may be 50 or 60 miles away, arrives. I have the feeling that, if the officials and overseers were not quite so numerous, the work would get on just as well. I agree that we must have planning, that the farmer must see a plan of the drainage scheme proposed to be carried out and must work in the closest co-operation with the inspector or engineer; but, despite that, we could do with a slightly lesser number of these gentlemen knocking around. However, giving credit where credit is due, any work done has been done very well, and, irrespective of what overlapping there may be, it is work which is of benefit. What gives me the greatest pleasure, however, in this connection is that we have it from the Minister that he and the Board of Works will find it possible to give some relief in respect of the flooding which causes so much trouble in the county I come from.
Turning to farming generally, it might be wrong for a Deputy with very little knowledge of dairying or milk production to delve too deeply into that subject, and it might be wrong for a Deputy from a western county to claim that he knows as much about milk production as Deputies who come from the dairying counties. But these Deputies cannot say that they know as much about the mixed farming carried on in the western counties as we who represent these counties. Seemingly, the most prosperous farmer at present is the man who carries on mixed farming. The man who can succeed by his own efforts in having a balanced economy within his holding, be it large or small, seems to be the best off of any type of farmer we have. We have dairy farmers, cattle farmers, grazing farmers and mixed farmers. I agree with anybody who says that the price of pigs, 220/- per cwt., is not sufficient if a man has to pay the increased price for imported feeding stuffs, and the man who pays for imported feeding stuffs and sells his pigs at 220/- is definitely heading for the high road, because it is not an economic proposition. The man who does not keep a sow, the man who—as is common practice in my area—has to go out and buy two, three or four bonhams——
Comment on this
If, as the Minister assures us, there is an unlimited market for a number of years for pigs at not less than 220/- per cwt. dead weight, it is a very foolish farmer who will not keep, not a sow, but one more sow.
Comment on this
That is where Deputy Allen and Deputy Cogan and other Deputies who come from counties with the good land can be of assistance. It is a strange thing that, a few years ago, there was, if you like, an oats racket, a surplus of oats in the corn-producing areas of the Twenty-Six Counties, while, in County Mayo, at the time, there was an absolute famine.
Comment on this
Just as in Donegal. Why was the same arrangement not made? Farmers in Mayo would gladly have paid 25/- per cwt. for oats. I think the Department paid 12/6 for them and yet there was a market of thousands and thousands of tons among the smaller farmers. The same can apply to those who have land and produce barley.
The Minister talks of Ymer barley I grew some Ymer barley last year— not a big acreage of it, because one cannot grow a big acreage of anything if he has not the land. Any farmer, be he big or small, who does not put down a certain amount of his grain crop in Ymer barley—which he needs to feed his sow, or his one more sow, and his pigs—and who does not try to produce enough foodstuffs on his land to feed his live stock is very foolish and is a bad farmer. It must be obvious that if a farmer has to go to the shopkeeper to obtain the foodstuffs for his live stock, he will find it difficult to make a success of his job. The Minister once said that such a farmer would be better off earning his living in some other capacity, such as tailoring or something like that, because to have to buy foodstuffs for his live stock from the shopkeeper is hot a paying proposition. I think that every farmer should put down even a small amount of Ymer barley and do so in accordance with the instructions of the agricultural instructor. The present Minister for Agriculture is to be congratulated on the fact that there are instructors attached to his Department who are available to give advice on every problem.
There is no use, however, in gambling on it and in sowing Ymer barley without having obtained expert opinion as to where it should be sown and so forth. If a man takes a gamble on it and thinks that he knows where it should grow or can grow he may find at the end of the year that it is not more than four or five inches high and that it will be impossible to cut it with any implement. Therefore, he would be well advised to seek instruction on the matter first. He should bring the instructor of the Department of Agriculture to visit his land, have the soil tested and get advice as to how much lime, phosphates or other types of manure should be applied to it. A farmer may think at the outset that the crop will work out pretty expensively but if he does things well at the beginning he will have cause to be glad later on. Anything done well pays dividends but anything half done is not any good at all. The man who does not take advantage of the free education at his disposal by the officials of the committees of agriculture is very foolish, particularly in relation to the sowing of Ymer barley. I agree with the Deputies who have said that Ymer barley is a peculiar crop which requires more careful consideration than the sowing of ordinary malting or feeding barley. If it is sown properly it will give a good return and it will prove to be a useful addition to the foodstuffs which the farmer requires.
As far as I can see, there is a lack of proper organisation in the Department of Agriculture. I heard Deputy Corry and the Minister praise each other—a thing which is very rare in this House —because of agreement on the price fixed for feeding barley. I think it was 20/- a cwt., or something like that. The people of my constituency would be delighted if they could get feeding barley at 20/-, 22/- or 25/- a cwt. If they could get it at that price, the foreign feeding stuffs could stay where they are. The new type of hammer-mill which has been introduced has proved a boon to the farmers. It can turn out a first-class foodstuff equal indeed to any that is imported. In addition, the farmer has the satisfaction of knowing that when he makes use of the hammer-mill he is keeping his money in this country and that, therefore, inflationary conditions abroad do not affect him so far as the price of his feeding stuffs is concerned.
That brings me to the subject of tillage. I wonder if the majority of the farmers of this country think that they can make money easier or that life can be lived easier on a farm where the tillage policy is not being carried out. A successful tillage policy should not have to be brought about by compulsion but certainly if it is not brought about by good-will it will have to be introduced compulsorily. We have had experience of compulsory tillage. We have heard the Deputies on the Opposition Benches refer to the Fianna Fáil tillage policy. We know perfectly well that the tillage policy was put into operation when the wolf was at the door. Early in the life of the Fianna Fáil Government they recommended the growing of beet and the success of the policy of growing beet was due to the very poor prices that prevailed for livestock at that time. Even the smallest farmer in my area grew a certain acreage of beet because it was the best paying proposition. Live stock were absolutely valueless while, on the other hand, there was a guaranteed market and a guaranteed price for beet.
When a real emergency arose, Fianna Fáil introduced the policy of compulsory tillage—and it will have to be made compulsory again if another emergency should arise. However, it was not compulsory tillage—it was compulsory murder of good land. There were farmers who hated to see one acre of their land opened up and tilled in order to produce food. There are people who prefer to grow grass and who preferred to do so even during the emergency years. In certain midland counties, hordes of inspectors were let loose in an effort to get these farmers to till their land and to produce, first of all, wheat and, secondly, foodstuffs for their live stock. The present Minister does not believe in compulsory tillage. We have often argued with him on that matter. I hope that his appeal to farmers to grow a good amount of food for the country—irrespective of the bad spring and the bad start which we have got—will be successful. I hope that the farmers will co-operate with him in that respect. There are farmers in Ireland who most certainly will co-operate with him. They till for the love of growing crops and because it has been in their blood for generations to do so. On the other hand, there are farmers with equally good land who will not till. Undoubtedly they are being given every opportunity —much more of an opportunity than I should like to see them getting—to till. If they do not do so this year they will have to do it next year.
Comment on this
I am aware of that. I can see that they are not doing it. There is no point in saying that the Minister is to blame. The price for wheat is good. The beet price is very tempting and we are all satisfied with the price of barley. We are told that there is a market for bacon, live stock and for other commodities. Deputy Allen and every Deputy must know that cattle fed from November and sold in the early months of the year are the best paying proposition of all if the foodstuffs can be produced at home to feed the cattle during the winter months. If the tillage is not done to make those foodstuffs available, then we must have compulsory powers. If, however, we should ever have to go in again for compulsory tillage, whatever else he does, the Minister will see that it is carried out in a more efficient manner than it was carried out before.
Last year in this House I got into an argument with Deputy Childers about political pull and compulsory tillage. I quoted for him an instance of a certain aristocrat who is a very good friend of his who allowed 30 acres of wheat to rot on the ground. He wanted it for feeding or for pheasants and he was allowed to get away with it. There is something wrong there and there is something wrong in a lot of other places and I want to impress on the Minister that if compulsory tillage is to come in it must come in fairly; scratching the ground and putting in one, two, or three cwt. of wheat, barley or oats over ten acres of ground must be stopped.
I remember listening to a radio broadcast from a farmer during the emergency. Why he was picked to broadcast from Radio Eireann I do not know, but he told us how he had grown five consecutive crops of wheat on the same land without artificial manure. In the latter end he admitted however that 99 per cent. of every sheaf of the last crop thrown from the binder was either thistles or weeds of some other sort. Why this sort of thing should be put over on the people or why anybody should be allowed to waste fertile land is something which I do not understand.
If we are to have compulsory tillage let us get the maximum out of the land because every farmer in the House will agree with me that the good farmer's nature is to get the most he can out of his land. He will not do it by compulsory powers if he can get away with it but like the fellows long ago will obey the law to evade the fine. If the larger farmers will not till their land there will be plenty of people who will till it for them and the Minister I think is in full agreement with me on that— at least he said it recently.
Deputy Tom Walsh, a very good friend of mind, was inclined to talk too much about the goodness of the compulsory tillage policy. In my constituency a farm of 600 acres came into the hands of the Land Commission in the last month.
Comment on this
I am on compulsory tillage and I am praising the Minister for Lands. This farm during the war years was registered as a stud farm and there was no tillage at all on it. It is now being made available for tillage on conacre lettings from the Land Commission to small farmers and I can safely say that without any compulsion at least 300 acres of this farm will be tilled this year. Let those who talk about compulsory tillage be cautious.
I have a cutting from the Irish Independent of Monday, October 30th, 1950. Mr. Paul Miller, chief of the E.C.A. mission in Ireland in a broadcast from Radio Éireann pointed out the value of tillage in this country. He said:—
"Ireland could save substantially on the dollars now being spent on imported maize through increased production of feed crops to take its place."
Here we have an outsider, an American salesman, if you like to put it that way, who should be trying to sell us maize, telling us instead: "You are very big fools to be spending your money buying maize when you could grow just as good stuff here at home."
There is only one thing wrong: a lot of people who would grow wheat have not the wherewithal to do so. However, that problem will be well taken up if an emergency arises and even without an emergency in this present year something more should be done to increase our acreage of wheat, beet, barley and oats, four very essential crops. Everybody knows that beet is a very good paying crop, having also the advantage that as a root crop it leaves very fertile soil behind it and having even a third advantage which we always knew about in the West and needed no agricultural instructor to tell us, that is the feeding value of the beet tops. Back as far as 1933 not a single beet top was allowed to be trampled or wasted on small farms in Mayo. Cattle would eat them, cattle would thrive on them and cattle got them. The same applies everywhere else but from what we have heard it seems that only in recent years has it dawned on the Department of Agriculture that beet tops are very valuable for food and fodder. It is a root crop which, as well as leaving very fertile land behind it, will grow reasonably well on worn land and is, therefore, a good crop for those who have to use such land.
We have now a great advancement in mechanised farming. As I said last year, the man who invented the hydraulic lift on small-sized tractors did more for agriculture and for farmers than all the Ministers for Agriculture in the world put together. At the present time two millionaires are fighting a legal battle to decide which is the inventor, but whichever wins one of them has done a good thing by giving us hydraulically-operated machinery. Before that a man who set out with a team of horses to do a large amount of tillage had a long and hard job. It was hard because he had to plod day after day on a single furrow and it was long because a lot of useful work could be done in the time he spent plodding after his team of horses. Now, even in small holding areas mechanised farming is coming in. We have, as the Minister said, young people purchasing tractors and going around working for their neighbours. While in fairness to the poor old horse I must say that he cannot be displaced altogether, a lot of the drudgery and heavy work can be taken off the back of the farmer if he decides on increased tillage and increased output. We have the same thing where there is a larger acreage. We have the combines.
Even in the smaller areas one can see reapers and binders in places where these machines were not even heard of some ten years ago. Now they have found their way into everybody's field. A man sitting on his tractor can plough so many acres and get off the machine in the evening fresh and happy. Sometimes when he finishes on his own land he can earn something towards the cost of the machine by doing work for his neighbour's, to the satisfaction of all concerned.
All the implements necessary for cultivating the land can be carried in a unit behind the machine. We all know of the work that was accomplished by the tractor and trailer, the plough and trailer and the harrow and mowers. Nowadays it requires only the pull of a lever and the cultivating implements go into operation. The tractor can cover ten or 15 miles an hour and go from one man's land into another's and when the cultivating implements are in operation they can do two and a half to three and a half miles an hour. Perhaps in some cases the work might be slower but, nevertheless, those machines can do a great amount of work in a much handier way than the old trailer system.
That is why I have great respect for those people who gave us hydraulically operated machines. They certainly did a good thing for the farming community. The older type of farming machinery was somewhat cumbersome, but nowadays the farmers have everything to their advantage in the way of the most up-to-date machinery.
With all these advantages in the hands of people who have land, and with good prices prevailing—even the Opposition are inclined to admit that—there is no reason why there should not be much greater production. The only fault the Opposition find is that the Minister did not announce these new prices in time.
Well, if the Minister announced these prices even last Christmas it would not have served any great purpose because since Christmas the amount of seed that could be put down was very limited indeed. However, with the good weather approaching, everything tends to encourage the farmers to do more tillage and to produce more food. Why people who have land to cultivate and with everything in their favour will not carry out this programme, is something I cannot understand. If they do not do it this year, they certainly should be made do it next year.
Comment on this
They should be made do it and we should be ruthless in our decision to make them do it.
Comment on this
There is one thing which I must draw to the Minister's attention and that is the flop in the price of eggs. In all fairness to him, he has admitted that the price is no good. Definitely, it is of little use to the egg producer. The State subsidised hatchery system was introduced here by Deputy Smith and was put into operation by the present Minister for Agriculture. The foundation, however, was laid by Deputy Smith. I objected to it at the time. I was sitting on the Opposition Benches then and I said it was all right to produce eggs and poultry and even treble or quadruple the quantity that could be produced, but when all the production was at its peak, would eggs and poultry hold their price? I thought then that it was a very wrong policy, and anybody who studies the 1947 debates will see the attitude I adopted at that time.
I thought it very wrong that we should subsidise hatcheries out of the taxpayers' money in order to give some gentlemen a chance of making more. They got a start with the State behind them, and there were pretty substantial fortunes made within the last few years on the State hatcheries. Chicks were produced by the thousand and reared and sold by the thousand. They laid plenty of eggs and then the price flopped. At that time I suggested that if we were to subsidise anybody we should first of all subsidise the provision of ordinary incubators for farmers or farmers' wives so that they might be in a position to increase their flocks of poultry. Those people are the best judges when it comes to producing the right amount which will give them a profit. If you leave it to them, you will not have any overloading of eggs or poultry on the market, and that is the cause of a lot of the trouble.
Now we have too many eggs and there is no market for them in England, and there is less of a market any place else. Egg production at the moment is not profitable, but when we reach the 1st August, they will go up to 3/6 a dozen, and then they will be worth while. But what is to happen in between? In between, we definitely will have a very bad period in the matter of the production of eggs and poultry generally.
A certain amount of credit must be given to the veterinary side of the Department of Agriculture. We all know the immense losses suffered by farmers through the deaths of calves and, later on, of yearlings. In every county, but more particularly along the western seaboard where the land is wet and the grazing conditions are not good, every year there is a great loss through the deaths of year old cattle. It may be that one yearling died belonging to Mr. So-and-so and five or six holdings away another yearling died. Perhaps three or four died in a townland. That may not seem so serious, but when you add up the deaths for every parish and make a tot finally for the whole country, you will find a very considerable figure is reached.
Many head of young cattle, involving a considerable amount of money, are lost in this way every year. I am glad to say that through the intervention of the Department's veterinary staff a tremendous amount of good work has been accomplished and there is a great reduction in the loss of live stock. Every effort is being made by the Department's inspectors, through the use of drugs and doses and medicine, to save our live stock. In that way, much is done towards accumulating wealth for the country. The departmental staff have saved many young animals that would otherwise be buried now. We know they are doing useful work and that is a section of the Department I would like to compliment.
The same applies to contagious abortion. There, again, great strides have been made. Great work has been accomplished because it has been tackled in the right way. There are some of us who criticise the Minister, some of us who are by no means loud in our praise of him; even though we are sitting on the Government side of the House, we still keep that privilege that we can speak our minds about Ministers whether it is liked or disliked. I weigh on the one hand all the good things the Minister has done and, on the other hand, I place all the things not so well done, whether it was his doing or not. As far as my county is concerned, where 82 per cent. of the people are small farmers, I definitely say that we are better off than we were for a good number of years. Again, whether that is the result of world conditions or is due to the Minister for Agriculture, I do not know. In fairness, it must be said that the Minister and the world conditions and the increased price of food have helped to make us prosperous and to put us in our present position.
Comment on this
It is a pleasure to take part in a debate on agriculture in the presence of the fine respectable Minister who is present to-day. It is a pleasure also to take part in a debate on agriculture in weather conditions such as we are blessed with this week. We should be grateful for those small mercies. One of my first duties to-day should be, as a farmer, to express my gratitude to His Grace the Archbishop of Dublin for having so kindly intervened in the farm wage dispute in County Dublin. I trust that the efforts of His Grace to bring about a settlement of that dispute will be crowned with complete success. Both farmers and workers deeply regret that, in the improved weather conditions of this week, their work should be held up. Both sections are equally eager and anxious to get back to work in the fields and to the full operation of sowing the crops which are so urgently needed.
There are people, of course, who say that members of the Irish Hierarchy should not intervene in ordinary economic or social matters. I do not share that view. I think that these men who have consecrated their lives to the highest vocation should be invited to help in solving the difficult social and economic problems which confront us at every turn.
I feel that the wage disputes and demands which have cropped up so frequently during the past year are due in a large measure to the unfortunate manner in which our Minister for Agriculture has misrepresented the position of agriculture. The Minister has gone out of his way to claim that farmers are rolling in wealth. If the farmers were half as prosperous as the Minister claims they are, the workers and their leaders would be fully justified in making even higher claims than they are making.
We all know that the exaggerated claims that farmers are making enormous profits out of pigs, eggs, milk and every other agricultural commodity, tend to create envy amongst the farm workers who are trying to eke out an existence on a very inadequate wage. The fact, however, is that the average working farmer has very little more, and in some cases less, than the agricultural worker at the end of the average week. Those of us who know the working farmers and the agricultural labourers know that the standard of living amongst the ordinary small farmers is as low as that among the paid agricultural labourers. We know that where the farmer's family consists of a number of adults who work on the farm the farmer is pretty prosperous. The same is true of the farm labourer's family. Where there are three or four adults working with the farmers and bringing in their wages each week to the family pool there is a certain measure of prosperity. When people talk about the improved standard of living amongst farmers, they should also admit that there is an improved standard of living amongst a considerable section of the community.
Anyone who examines the position fairly will see at a glance that the increase in agricultural wages, for example, over the past 40 years, if you like to go back that far, is much higher relatively than the increase in agricultural prices. From figures which were produced in this House some time ago, we know that the average agricultural wage prior to the first world war was about 12/- per week. In some counties it was something less. To-day, the very lowest minimum wage is £3 per week. That is an increase of over 400 per cent., although agricultural prices have not increased to anything like the same extent. So, we see that the farmers are not being selfish in regard to their workers and are not grasping an excessive proportion of the income derived jointly by themselves and the workers from agriculture.
One of the most remarkable achievements of the Minister for Agriculture, during the past year at least, is that he has succeeded in some way in winning for himself the unstinted admiration and applause of Deputy Peadar Cowan. The Minister should examine his conscience carefully when he finds that he is being applauded by this gentleman whose policy is the confiscation and collectivisation of land in this country. If the Minister's policy is applauded by that member of this House, then it is quite clear that his whole agricultural policy is, whether he knows it or not, directed or leaning towards the ultimate failure of individual farming and the ultimate nationalisation of land.
The Minister has made frequent attacks upon farmers, carefully concealed at times, but always sustained, and on farmers' organisations, and made the accusation that milk suppliers, if they organise, are racketeers. I think he even went so far as to describe them as a Fianna Fáil ramp. Some of the farmers concerned mistook the word and thought he said a Fianna Fáil "romp"; but I think the word was "ramp". Even that was a disparaging remark and one calculated to arouse anger, particularly amongst those who are not associated with the Fianna Fáil Party, but who are actively associated with the vocational organisation of farmers who are trying to get a better price for their milk.
Is this sustained attack upon the farmer from every angle to be continued, led by the Minister, supported by Deputy Peadar Cowan? I was interested to note that while the Minister was carrying on a sustained campaign of interruptions against Deputy Aiken yesterday, Deputy Oliver Flanagan sat beside him, evidently determined to show his applause and approval of the Minister. At the same time, Deputy Flanagan, by his series of questions on the Order Paper to-day, reveals that he is out to abolish individual ownership of land in the speediest possible time. The Minister has collected around him some queer allies and I think there is no doubt that this support would not come to him if he were engaged in a sound agricultural policy calculated to increase the income of the individual farmer, to increase his security on his farm and to enable him to live and support his family and maintain his hold on his farm. Security of tenure is a right for which Irish farmers have fought over a long period of years. I feel that the Minister has set out to destroy that security, to destroy it ruthlessly by misrepresentation and now further by threats.
A good deal has been said about compulsory tillage but the Minister for Agriculture, supported by Deputy Flanagan and by Deputy Cowan, has introduced a more serious threat to the independence of farmers than compulsory tillage. I think the farmer would prefer to be compelled by law to till a portion of his land rather than to be told by Deputy Cowan or Deputy Flanagan in support of the Minister, and threatened by the Minister himself that his land would be confiscated if he did not comply with the rather vague and indefinite requests made by the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
I am saying that the Minister for Agriculture has made an appeal to farmers to till the maximum amount of their land this year and he has issued a threat that if they fail he will resign. That I do not think is a very serious threat; I think it is more in the nature of an inducement to farmers not to till but in addition to that there is a vague threat, not too definite perhaps, that the land will be ultimately confiscated from them. When the Minister finds himself supported in this House by Deputy Flanagan and applauded by Deputy Cowan who stands for collectivised farming, when he finds his policy meeting with that kind of support. I think he has very grave reason to examine it and to see where he is drifting.
There is no doubt whatever that agriculture, if you like, is somewhat more prosperous as an industry than it was, certainly during the war years and before the war. I do not think that we have ever experienced a period when prices were higher, except perhaps during the first world war. Costs as I have indicated have increased relatively to the same extent as prices. That, in the main, is due to the lowering of the value of money. I think that there are more important considerations, however, than the money value of agricultural produce. I think that if this country is to be prosperous the real output of the land must increase. It must increase in every respect both in regard to live stock and in regard to tillage. When we examine agriculture from that standpoint, we find that the results are very disappointing. It has been stated that the index figure of the net volume of output is 102 for the last year for which figures are available as compared with 100 pre-war-that is an increase of 2 per cent. An increase of 2 per cent. in the volume of agricultural output is not sufficient. It is not sufficient when we have regard to the needs of the present time, when we have regard to the expansion of agriculture in other countries, and to the expansion in our own manufacturing industries. They have shown a much greater expansion than agriculture.
I believe that when the Minister secured office in 1948 he had handed to him the greatest opportunity that was ever presented to a Minister in any country. In 1948 we had definitely emerged from the war period and the grave emergency period. Supplies of agricultural requirements were becoming available in the later part of 1947. In addition, we had emerged from the very serious climatic conditions of 1947 and we were favoured by being included amongst the nations that were being assisted by the United States to increase their production. All these factors were an advantage to agriculturists; all these factors could have been marshalled and mobilised in order to ensure that the output of agriculture would be rapidly expanded but after three years' experience the Minister can only show an increase of 2 per cent. over 1938. As a matter of fact, the net volume of agricultural output is 10 per cent. lower than it was in 1945. That of course was the period of maximum compulsory tillage and there was an increased output as a result. I do not know that that year is altogether comparable but certainly the position is that there has been only a very slight increase as compared with the last pre-war year when agricultural conditions were not so good or agriculture was not assisted to the same extent from external sources as in 1949.
I believe that a fundamental mistake was made by the Minister in his attitude towards tillage. It is possible when he entered office that he had a deep-seated prejudice against tillage farming. At any rate he certainly treated tillage farmers so badly during his years of office that he has reduced the acreage under tillage by over 500,000. He brought down the number of acres under tillage by 500,000 in the course of three years. He brought about that reduction in the main by refusing a reasonable market for the surplus produce that was produced in 1948. As I have said, the Minister took office when circumstances favoured him. There was a large acreage under tillage. Farmers were finding it difficult to maintain that acreage but if it was desirable—and I think it was; I am in agreement that it was desirable—to get away from compulsory tillage, it was urgent there and then to substitute for compulsory tillage a new policy, a policy of inducement for tillage.
I believe that policy would have achieved results if it had been introduced promptly and carried through effectively. Instead, however, we found that when the bountiful harvest of 1948 was ready for the market the Minister ruined the market completely. by announcing that he would import into this country cheap maize. I heard Deputy Commons say that the farmer who would depend on going to the shop in order to buy feeding for his pigs or to rear his poultry would be better off by getting out of farming, but what about the nation which goes to the shop for its basic food supplies? I think that nation would be better off to get out of agriculture. That was the policy which the Minister strenuously advocated during his first two years in office. I believe he would still be strenuously advocating it if it were not for the fact that supplies of imported maize are not now available.
I would say that it appears to be the deliberate policy of the Minister to force down the acreage of tillage by something like 600,000 acres. He claims sometimes that he has succeeded in getting an increased yield from the reduced acreage. Now, the Minister had as much to do with the yield secured from our tillage area in the last three years as the clock on the wall. I can prove that to be a fact.
I asked a question last week as to what was the yield of wheat during the past three years and the Minister replied 17.6 cwt. per acre. I asked what was the yield during three similar years under the previous Government, the three years ending in 1940, and I was told it was 19 cwt. per acre. That is nearly 2 cwt. per acre higher than in these past favourable years. I went into the matter a bit more fully myself. I had secured the average acreage of wheat over the whole period that Fianna Fáil were in office. I was not going to leave anything to chance, and I found that the average yield per acre of wheat during the whole period that Fianna Fáil were in office was practically exactly the same as during the past three years.
I think that does not prove very much, except that Ministers have not power over the weather, the climate, the land, the soil and over agriculture generally which they claim to have. It proves that agriculture functions, to a great extent, independently of ministerial control. In spite of all the Minister said about the increased yield of wheat which he had secured, we find that the yield was exactly the same under the despised Fianna Fáil régime. I think that is the supreme reflection. I think, too, it is about time that Deputies on both sides of the House would come to realise that the agricultural industry is bigger than political Parties and bigger than Partition. I think that for too many years the agricultural industry has been made the plaything of Party politics. We have had people on one side of the House denouncing beet and people on the other side of the House denouncing wheat.
We have had a lot of anger and heat aroused amongst farmers by different sets of politicians trying to lead them astray and to bewilder them, each political Party telling them it had some marvellous and wonderful solution for our agricultural problems. The plain fact of the matter is that whether we have a Fianna Fáil Government or an inter-Party Government farmers have got to work their land at every available opportunity, just as they are doing in the fine weather we are enjoying this week. They, through their efforts, will produce the maximum if only they are given a reasonable chance. That is all they ask. They do not want to be patted on the back by any Minister for Agriculture and told that they are good boys and are doing quite nicely. They do not want to be insulted or abused by the Minister for Agriculture as they have been repeatedly insulted and abused by our present Minister. Governments can help, if they are willing to help, but they require to have the will to do it. They also require not to be blinded by silly prejudice against particular crops or against particular sections of the farming community — by silly animosities of that kind, or by the tendency, particularly on the part, I think, of the present Minister to blame every misfortune that may occur upon his political opponents.
I remember the time when I was trying to secure a market for the surplus produce that we had. Deputy Commons referred to that period to-day. He said that during it there were farmers in Mayo who were finding it difficult to secure enough feeding oats and barley for their live stock. I asked the Government then to intervene in that crisis and help to ensure that those who had a surplus would secure a market for it, and that those who required to make purchases would have grain made available for them. I asked that, after these requirements had been met, and if there was a little surplus left over, arrangements should be made to hold it until the following year when production might be less bountiful.
That was the substance of the scheme which I put up to the Minister, and that was the substance of the scheme which was accepted by the Government in the absence of the Minister. When they got his back turned they succeeded. They were able to adopt a scheme which I had suggested. That was the scheme which the Minister sabotaged afterwards by exporting to Germany at a reduced price the surplus of oats which had been purchased under it. It is difficult for farmers to get the best out of their land and to till the maximum proportion of their land by the growing of essential crops if they are hampered and obstructed by their own Government. That has been the position, and I am afraid that is the real cause why we have to-day great difficulty in maintaining our live stock.
I think that the Minister, in his opening statement, was inclined to jeer at some of us who have suggested that the position in regard to live stock during the winter months would be severe. We made suggestions to that effect early in the past winter. The results have shown that live stock to-day are in a very poor condition. I have seen herds of cows that are very weak and I know that, while sheep have survived well and are in fairly good condition, cattle generally have suffered from the severe winter and farmers have suffered very considerable losses. It is always very difficult, of course, to estimate the losses which farmers suffer as a result of a shortage of feeding stuffs. Usually, when cows are weak, a certain number of them will perhaps be unable to survive. There have been very substantial losses, but there are no figures available to prove to what extent those losses have been suffered. If we had had a better-balanced agricultural policy since the end of the war, however, I think we might have avoided much of that loss.
We also know that the position in regard to bacon supplies is not so good. There has been a very substantial reduction in the number of pigs reaching the factories, and the factories are finding it very difficult to carry on and to meet the demand of consumers for bacon. That, again, could have been avoided if we had, linked with the pig producing industry, a sound policy of mixed tillage. I can trace that back to the failure of the Minister in the first years to give reasonable encouragement and support to those who embarked on a fairly substantial amount of tillage.
Up to the present, even in regard to the coming season, it is very difficult to know where we stand with our present Minister. Early this year he launched out into a nation-wide publicity campaign, starting off with an interview given to the Irish Independent. In that campaign he called upon farmers to produce more food for live stock. The Minister was then beginning to wake up to the fact that we had not been producing enough food for our cattle and pigs and he was further supported in that view by the fact that we have to pay such excessive prices for imported maize. It struck me as rather strange that the Minister would not make an equally emphatic appeal to farmers to increase the acreage of wheat and the acreage of sugar beet. I was further surprised when I found the Irish Sugar Company, which is a State-run company, launch out on another advertising campaign calling upon farmers to increase their sugar beet acreage. It seems strange that a State-subsidised company should be forced to launch out on a campaign like that while the Minister and the Department of Agriculture in their publicity campaign made no appeal to increase the acreage of either beet or wheat.
I put down a question to the Minister and I raised the matter on the Adjournment, but I did not get any satisfaction. As usual, I got a certain amount of abuse, but no assurance that the Minister was going to do anything to amend or improve the publicity campaign he had embarked upon or to do anything to improve the price for wheat. It was quite obvious that we could not expect the same acreage of wheat as last year in view of the fact that the prices of other tillage products had advanced beyond the price for wheat. The guaranteed price for wheat up to a month ago was 62/6 a barrel, which is 25/- a cwt., while the guaranteed price for malting barley was 28/9, and the price of good quality oats ranged from £3 10s. 0d. to £4 per barrel, and the prospects were that the price of oats next year would be reasonably good. In view of these circumstances, it seemed to any person of ordinary intelligence that unless something was done by the Government the acreage of wheat would decline, but nothing was done.
It was not until after the 1st April that the Minister issued an appeal to farmers to grow more wheat, but it is satisfactory to know that he did issue an appeal after the 1st April to farmers to grow more wheat and more beet. His notice in the Press, however, was much smaller and less impressive than the notices which it succeeded. It was less characteristic of the Minister. It looked more like something he had been forced or coerced to do. It lacked the "splash" which the Minister usually introduces into his advertising campaign. I do not know who forced the Minister to embark on this publicity campaign to grow more wheat so late in the day. Some person's attention must have been drawn to the fact that he was endangering the national position and that something would have to be done about it. After the 1st April, when normally all the wheat would have been sown, the Minister announced that he wanted an increased acreage of wheat and he agreed to offer a slighly improved price. It does not bring the price of wheat up to the top price available for barley and it is doubtful if it will bring it up to the price which is likely to be available for oats if there is no reduction in the price of imported feeding stuffs.
It is deplorable that the Minister for Agriculture, in a country depending upon agriculture and where the majority of people live on the land and by the land, should allow himself to be blinded by silly prejudice into standing against and obstructing the best national interests.
On frequent occasions during debates on agriculture, particularly in the closing stages of the debates, the Minister announces that those who criticise his policy are influenced in some way by personal ill-will, hatred or malice. Nothing could be more childish, silly or vain than that accusation. Apparently, the Minister is under the impression that nothing wrong could be found in his policy except through malice or ill-will. He has upbraided certain Deputies for allowing themselves to be influenced by personal ill-will towards him. I do not think the Minister can expect anyone to take that suggestion seriously. I have criticised the Minister very considerably during the past three years, particularly since we had our first clash in regard to the marketing of tillage produce in 1948. I do not think the Minister would seriously suggest that I have any influence with him. I had many clashes with the Minister on matters of policy when both of us were here on the Independent Benches. That did not prevent me, however, from supporting the Minister's election to the office he now holds. Any disagreement I may have with him on matters of policy will not influence me in the slightest degree in my personal attitude towards him.
I believe that he has allowed himself to drift into the adoption of an attitude towards agriculture which is not calculated to build up and improve that industry and expand its production. The fact that output is static and that we have made very little progress over the last few years is clear evidence that the Minister's policy is failing to deliver the goods. Possibly that is one of the reasons why Deputy Captain Cowan in his zeal for collectivised farming is so enthusiastic in his approval of the Minister. He says the Minister for Agriculture is a good Minister, just as facilely as he says the Irish Hierarchy are wrong. He has given his views on these matters very forcefully and very dogmatically. If Deputy Captain Cowan thinks the Minister for Agriculture is a good Minister, those of us who believe in a Christian society, in a democratic society and in farmers using their own farms independently must feel a certain amount of uneasiness with the present Minister's policy.
The Minister has submitted a White Paper to the House purporting to show certain increases in various branches of the agricultural industry. I admit there have been some increases. In the overall number of cattle, for example, there is an increase; but in, the number of in-calf heifers there is a reduction. That reduction is a disquieting feature in relation to our cattle trade. I know the problem is somewhat difficult of solution. It is one to which the Minister will require to give considerable attention. One cannot have cows without in-calf heifers. Because of the present prices for store cattle there is not much inducement to the ordinary dairying and tillage farmer to keep good heifers for breeding purposes. I think the Minister should direct his attention to that problem. I think he could cope with the problem if he would set his mind to it.
With regard to pigs, there has been a substantial reduction over the past 12 months. In 1950 the total number of pigs was 644,000. It is down to 530,000 to-day. The number of poultry has also reduced. That is inevitable having regard to the unsatisfactory prices available for poultry produce.
Speaking of pigs, I was interested to notice that last year the Minister introduced a new form of sport. It has been described as cross-country pig-racing. He opened the Border for a short period and permitted the export of live pigs to Northern Ireland. The result was a rush of pigs to the Border and the consequence is a reduced supply of pigs for our bacon factories at home. I do not think that is a sensible way of dealing with pig production and pig marketing. Stability is most important in an industry which entails so much expense and labour. A high price for a couple of weeks followed by a collapse does not help anybody. One or two producers here and there who had pigs to sell when the ban on the Border was lifted got away. The remainder found themselves worse off.
The trouble with our pig industry is that the Minister is trying to enforce on our producers a price considerably lower than the price which producers with similar production costs are obtaining in the Six Counties and in Great Britain. The price of pigs has been fixed in Great Britain—and, I take it, in Northern Ireland, too—at 280/- per cwt. The Minister expects us to go into rapturous enthusiasm because we are being offered 220/-. I do not think there is very much difference between our costs of production and the costs of production in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. There is certainly not a difference of £3 per cwt. The Minister seems to think that our farmers should be happy with a very low standard of remuneration for the finished product. In fairness to the farmers, I think the Minister should notify them now if and when he intends to institute another cross-country pig race this year. The farmers may then have to consider the problem of producing a dual-purpose pig, a pig that will give a good side of bacon and, at the same time, have a turn for speed so that they will reach the Border quickly when the Minister again decides to lift the ban.
I do not think the lifting of the ban was a sound policy. Stabilised fair prices are the best inducement that can be offered to increased production. I am in wholehearted agreement with Deputy Commons and others who said that the pig industry should be based on home-produced barley, potatoes, roots and on a balanced ration. Unfortunately the Minister, in his enthusiasm for maize, started off by discrediting home-produced feeding stuffs. Though the eventuality may never arise, I would like to know from the Minister what his attitude would be if feeding stuffs could be imported at very low prices? Would he allow them to depress the market here for home-produced grain?
I know that may be a difficult problem to solve, but it is one that should get reasonable consideration. Fianna Fáil tried to deal with it by means of what they call the admixture scheme. I never liked that scheme because it produced for the most part an unbalanced ration. Just as there is a solution to every problem, there is a solution to this. That solution can be found by having a certain measure of control over imports so that their impact cannot depress the home market and drive the tillage farmers out of tillage production and into pasture. I believe that the shortage of foodstuffs all over the world, and the shortage of feeding stuffs also, will tend to drive up the acreage of tillage. It may be too late this year, but that will be so next year; and there ought to be a long-term policy to maintain the acreage under tillage, so as to ensure a balanced farm economy and a mixed system of farming.
I am not in agreement with those who suggested that tillage should be made compulsory. There are inducements which could be offered to the tillage farmer which would be more effective than compulsion. I have often wondered why, in the subsidisation of certain requirements of farm agriculture such as fertilisers and ground limestone, the benefits of that subsidy should not be related to the percentage of the farm under tillage. The Commission of Inquiry into Agricultural Policy, which sat for a considerable time during the war, presented three conflicting minority reports, but the three agreed on one point and one point only, that fertilisers should be subsidised. The Minister has never agreed to that. I do not know why. There does not seem to be any valid reason now why you should subsidise lime and not cheapen the price of artificial fertilisers.
In regard to subsidising lime, the Minister's policy has been equally erratic. When he took office, ground limestone and burned lime were carrying a subsidy, paid out by the county committees of agriculture. The Minister, for some unknown reason, decided in 1949, to abolish the subsidy on ground limestone and retain the subsidy on burned lime. I was a member of a committee, the Carlow Committee of Agriculture, which considered that question and could see no justification for abolishing the subsidy. We sent a deputation to the Minister and the Minister made his case for the abolition so well that he convinced the majority of our deputation that he was right. I found myself in the embarrassing position of being the only member of the committee who was not carried away and converted completely to the Minister's viewpoint that there should be no subsidy on ground limestone. That has been the position for the past two years. Now suddenly—whether, as in the case of his belated decision to improve the price of wheat or for some other reason, it is that he has been subjected again to benevolent external pressure he has decided to grant a subsidy on ground limestone. That, however, requires explanation. Why now has he completely somersaulted in regard to his attitude two years ago when he decided there should be no subsidy for ground limestone, only for burned lime; now the position is reversed, ground limestone is to be subsidised but burned lime is to be left to fend for itself, to decline gradually and disappear.
I do not see any valid reason why one particular type of lime should be in and another not. The urgent need is to get lime in any shape or form into the land as quickly as possible and the more burned lime you get in this year the better. Ground limestone is excellent for improving the land and removing acidity, but it is slow acting and with land in its present cold condition it would be extremely desirable to get as much burned lime as is available into the land. In any case, the amount of subsidy required for the small amount of burned lime available will not be much, and I do not see why a distinction should be made between the two types. Each is good in its own way. I agree that, in the main, the ground limestone is the more important and the form in which lime will be applied in the greater proportion. Nevertheless, the other form of lime is useful also. Personally, I have found that the by-product of the sugar factories, what was once regarded as a waste product, the factory lime, is also an excellent fertiliser for the land and certainly much more quick in acting on the soil than ground limestone.
In this connection, a question arises as to why the freightage subsidy on ground limestone has been given in its present form. Why should one company be singled out to derive all the benefits? Is this a subsidy on ground limestone or a subsidy to Córas Iompair Éireann? Surely any firm that is prepared to carry lime to the farms should be equally entitled to the subsidy. At present a number of companies have provided themselves with fleets of spreaders which can carry and deliver the ground limestone without any rehandling, thus avoiding additional expense.
Why have those companies been refused the benefit of the subsidy which would enable them to expand their business of providing an increased number of spreaders and thus ensure that the production and distribution of ground limestone would be carried through in a most efficient manner? Surely every branch of agriculture and industry calls for the highest degree of efficiency. The most efficient manner of distributing ground limestone is by the use of spreaders, which eliminates the necessity of rehandling. Nevertheless, the Minister for some reason—there may be pressure again there which influenced him—decided to subsidise Córas Iompair Éireann while purporting to help the agricultural industry. If we accept the view —and we must, of course—that this subsidy, such as it is, reduces the cost of ground limestone to the farmer, is there not an unanswerable case for reducing the cost also of foreign fertilisers? The commission which impartially considered all aspects of agricultural policy, the Post-War Agricultural Commission, did definitely agree unanimously that the price of fertilisers should be brought down, by whatever manner could be found possible. They recommended a 25 per cent. subsidy, and I think that they would have been even stronger in their recommendation if they knew that prices would substantially increase as they have done.
It is a matter of grave concern that a very large proportion of our land is deficient in phosphates. The yearly intake of phosphates into this country is utterly inadequate. If you were to spread the total imports of phosphates over the 11,000,000 acres of land in this country, you would have less than three stone per acre. Having regard to all we imported during the last year, it can be readily understood that only a very small acreage has been treated with phosphates. At the present rate of progress, the deficiency in phosphates will never be overtaken. One is up against the difficult problem of supply—a problem which, I suppose, will be aggravated also by a shortage of sulphuric acid and other ingredients. At any rate, we should take such measures as may be necessary to bring whatever phosphates there are available to the poorest land. Everybody engaged in agriculture or who moves among the agricultural community knows that it is better to use the maximum amount of phosphates on our vast areas of poorer land—areas which have never got their fair ration of lime or phosphates. If supplies are limited and if phosphates are to be expensive in the future, some effort should be made by the Deparment to ensure that the poorer land would get its requirements in the way of phosphates.
I advocated a credit scheme in this respect last year in the course of this debate. When concluding the debate, the Minister indicated that he intended to implement that suggestion and to introduce a scheme which would enable farmers to get lime and fertilisers on credit. I found, however, that the Minister apparently adopted this scheme reluctantly and in implementing it he imposed impossible conditions on those who applied for this amenity. First, there was an acreage fee and then it was necessary to pay down 10 per cent. of the cost. In addition to all that, there was a requirement that the farmer would have to accept the Department's estimate in regard to what his requirements were. In the case of the farmer who felt that the Department's estimate and costs were too high and who only required to do a smaller proportion than the Department suggested in order to test out the scheme, his application was turned down and he forfeited his initial application fee. If the Minister looks into the figures, he will find that, while there was a considerable number of applications under the scheme, the number of people who actually availed of it was very limited. Only a small proportion of the total number who had applied under the scheme have actually implemented it.
On this whole question of credit, we had a discussion in the early part of this session on a motion which I introduced asking for better credit facilities for agriculture. There is a wide feeling amongst many sections of this House and, I think, a very widespread feeling amongst members of the inter-Party Government that credit facilities are essential if agriculture is to expand. I have heard many members of the Labour Party and some members of Fine Gael strongly advocating that view. However, when I raised this matter by way of motion in the Dáil, the Minister met me, in the main, with abuse. He concentrated his abuse mainly upon the Protestant minority in my constituency. He attacked major-generals and the company that begot them. I suppose he thought that by attacking a denominational minority he was attacking a section of the community who were weak and could not hit back. It is possible that he was feeling a bit sore over his defeat in the battle of Baltinglass and wanted to get back in some way by his reference to the major-generals.
Comment on this
The Minister knows that if this country is to survive as a nation and if it is to become a united nation, we ought to have a reasonable amount of respect for the people who are in a denominational minority in this country. We all respect our own religion and I think that it is our duty to respect the religion of others.
Comment on this
The suggestion, that in some way those people are discreditable and that decent people like myself ought not to associate with them, is a contemptible one.
Comment on this
I listened to the Minister fiercely and bitterly attacking the Protestant minority. Either he probably has decided that he does not want the support of the Protestant minority any longer in County Monaghan, or that he may have decided to contest a seat in County Mayo, County Galway or somewhere else.
Comment on this
If the Minister wants to attack decent farmers in my constituency he will be answered.
Comment on this
The Minister did not say anything about them on the Estimates. Therefore, the matter is not relevant.
Comment on this
——of concluding the debate in which the Minister made these sneering references to the Protestant minority here.
Comment on this
I have referred to the fact that, when I was dealing with the question of credit facilities to farmers in this House, the Minister, in his soreness over his defeat at Baltinglass, introduced the question of major generals.
I want to get back to the question of credit, a question which I raised on a motion, the debate of which was not concluded. The Minister has controllers in his Department over various credit facilities which are available both to his Department and subsidiary bodies. I am indicating that these are completely inadequate to provide for those who really need better credit facilities.
The man with plenty of money can get all the money he wants. The man who is well to do and prosperous can get all the help he wants, but there are always a number of people, particularly young men, who are anxious to make their farms better, to improve their stock, to improve their soil and perhaps to improve the buildings on their farms, and these are the type of people who should be encouraged. There is no use in handing out credit to old people who have accumulated quite substantial bank balances. They can always get all the credit they want, but there is the other section, the young struggling farmers, who are trying to build up their homesteads and who, if assisted, can do a considerable amount to add to the volume of agricultural output.
This whole question will have to be reconsidered. The scheme I have referred to, the scheme for the distribution of lime and phosphates, would require to be revised. It is not acceptable; it is not suitable; and it does not meet the need it was intended to meet. There are other types of credit available to farmers who want to mechanise, but, in the main, they are types of credit which involve fairly high rates of interest, and the term of repayment is altogether too short. The man who may have barely sufficient land to enable him to keep a tractor may not have the capital to buy it and the man who has not got a very large farm will care for his tractor and equipment and will keep it in repair and get a return over a good number of years. Since that type of man is often in need of credit, it should be made available to him over a much longer period than that which obtains at present.
I have touched on the question of mechanisation. I believe that it will continue to expand, so long as tractors and tractor equipment, as well as fuel to drive the tractors, are available. The horse, however, will still be a necessary evil, if you like, on the farm, although I do not regard the horse as altogether an evil. The Minister on one occasion suggested that he would make the plough pulled by horses illegal.
Comment on this
The Minister is very touchy about the exact words he used. If my recollection serves me, he said that he did not believe in compulsion, but——
Comment on this
He expressed the view that he would like to see it eliminated. I personally think that, before we eliminate the horse, we have to consider the question very carefully. Supplies of fuel for mechanised farming are entirely imported, and, in the event of war or other somewhat similar circumstances, supplies will not be available. This question will require to be examined with a view to the preservation of a number of horses in this country. Deputy Rooney suggested the establishment of what he called horse farms, where, he hinted, a reserve of foals could be accumulated. I do not know how he proposed to keep these foals in a state of perpetual youth or prevent them from growing old, but he may have some secret of his own in regard to that.
I am also in agreement with the suggestion made to-day by Deputy Commons, that, to supplement the mechanised units for field drainage and reclamation work, we should have some units of a lighter type. I know that the heavy excavator and bulldozer can work in very difficult conditions, but sometimes they fail, and, in addition, the difficulties and expense of transporting them from one farm to another are relatively heavy. We are, to a certain extent, only in the experimental stage in regard to this matter and more efficient machines for our size of farms and our type of land may be found.
I should like the Minister to tell us what is the position in regard to drainage pipes. Irish-produced concrete pipes were condemned some time ago, but I understand that the departmental decision in that respect is being revised, and it would be desirable to have a decision on the matter.
Comment on this
Certain defective pipes were condemned. Concrete pipes made up to the specification fixed by the Bureau of Standards are perfectly acceptable.
Comment on this
We know that what happened was that concrete pipes had gone out of use altogether, but they may be brought back again, and that would be a good thing from every point of view. We would avoid sending considerable sums out of the country for the importation of pipes, and in addition, the production of concrete pipes is a small industry which could be established in many of our towns and villages and which would provide useful employment. If these pipes could be produced in the areas in which they are required, they would probably be much cheaper than the imported goods. The cost could be very much reduced and the pipes could be supplied in the areas where they are produced at a very reasonable price.
I do not want to say very much on the price of eggs. That matter has been referred to by other Deputies, but there is one very remarkable feature about this whole question of egg production and marketing which does require a full explanation by the Minister. The Minister has stated during the past year that one of the reasons for his difficulties in regard to the marketing of eggs was an unwise expansion of production initiated by his predecessor. If that were true, it would perhaps be some justification for him, but the fact remains that the Minister did a very considerable amount to encourage an expansion of egg production during his first year of office. He was loud in his appeals to farmers and farmers' wives to produce more eggs. He wrote to every farmer's wife in the country, and even sent his photo along with the letter in order to impress them further, urging them to produce more eggs and stating that the more they produced on their farms, the higher the price. Now he blames his predecessor. I do not know why the Minister always looks for someone to blame. The decent thing would be to say that he had made an error of judgment, that he had made it with the best of intentions and that he was sorry, but one cannot get that admission from our Minister.
Last year, in introducing this Estimate, he announced a new agreement with regard to the price of eggs. The price was 3/- when he took office. Subsequently it was reduced to 2/6. Last year he announced that, as from 1st February, 1951, until the 31st August the price would be reduced to 2/-. As reported at column 1795 of the Official Report of 15th June last, the Minister said:—
"Twopence an egg: I remember when it was the top price for eggs...."
That statement was made publicly by the Minister at a time when he was actually negotiating with the British to secure a better price for our eggs. What would you think of a farmer, who, when you had offered him a price for a beast, would turn around and say publicly and in your presence that the offer was a good one? What prospect would he have of getting that offer increased? Yet that was the position.
I found, by way of question, that the agreement fixing the price of eggs for the present year was signed only last August. Therefore, long before that agreement was signed the Minister was publicly proclaiming that the British were making a very good offer of 2/- per dozen for eggs. I think that that was a reckless course for the Minister to follow in regard to a vital product. I think that the Minister should not have lauded that inadequate offer of 2d. per egg before the agreement was signed. We all know now that the Minister has found out—too late, of course—that the agreement which he so strongly recommended this time 12 months ago was a bad one and that the price which he accepted with such joy was a poor price. Can we hope that when the Minister goes over to Britain again his attitude will be firmer and that he will not go over there prepared to laud any price which they offer and prepared to commend it to the Irish people as he did last year? As a result of his reckless action he has inflicted a very grave loss on the farmers' wives and on the farm workers' wives in this country, so far as the poultry industry is concerned.
I come now to the price of milk. The Minister, in dealing with the price of milk, launched a fierce attack upon the Creamery Suppliers' Association. He declared that that association was "a Fianna Fáil ramp". I think he went even further, during the present week, and described it as a "racket". But who established that association? The Minister himself. Twelve months ago he announced that he was going to reduce the price of milk to 1/- per gallon. He brought the strongest possible pressure to bear upon all the creameries to accept that offer. The creameries unanimously turned it down. However, the fact that the Minister had made that move alarmed the farmers in the dairying industry and led them to form some sort of a defensive organisation. The Minister refused to meet the representatives. He said that the chairman of the organisation was in some way connected with the saw-milling business and that the secretary was a civil servant. But the Minister met another organisation—which is also a very reputable organisation—of the dairying industry. At the time he was meeting the representatives of that organisation he knew that the chairman was not a full-time farmer, though I understand that he is well qualified to speak for the dairy farmers. The secretary also was very well qualified to speak for and represent the dairy farmers, although he, too, was not a full-time farmer. Why the discrimination between the two organisations? Why this attempt to introduce rancour and bitterness into what should be an ordinary business transaction? Why drag politics into the matter?
I do not know whether the Minister knows the political views of the members of the I.A.O.S. I am sure that the individual members of that association hold various and perhaps conflicting political views. The Minister was willing to meet them but, because of some little personal prejudice or something else, he refused to meet an extremely representative organisation of farmers—and by so doing he has created a position whereby additional fuel has been added to the general discontent which prevails in the dairying industry. At any rate, the Minister has made a very miserable offer to that industry. I do not want to dwell on it at any great length except to refer to an unjust statement by the Minister in which he quoted costings figures in regard to the dairying industry. He said that these costings figures were produced by Professor Murphy. He mentioned a price of 8½d. for milk produced in the summer months. I had a look at these costings figures. I do not know if they were publicly circulated but certainly I had a look at the figures in question. I found that though the cost in the summer months was 8½d. it was 1/6 in the winter months. I must admit that I am speaking now from recollection and that it is some years since I read that paper. Those two figures would mean an average of something like 1/2 the whole year round. But the Minister wants milk produced only in the summer. I think that 8½d. for that particular year would have been a reasonable figure for the summer months provided that the cow that produced the milk would be taken up to heaven on the 1st November and returned again to the field on 1st May, complete with her calf. Otherwise, I do not see how one can base any costings figures on a six months' period. There is no such thing as a cow that lives only for six months and produces a calf at the end of the six months— the Minister did refer to the value of the cow. I think it is a pity that the Minister allows his enthusiasm for scoring little freakish debating points to obscure his vision and to interfere with the operation of the ordinary common sense which a Minister should possess if he wishes to deal with ordinary everyday problems. There is no such animal as a cow which is milking only for six months and will not require to be fed, will live on air, for the other six months of the year. That is where the Minister's whole approach to the dairying industry was hopelessly wrong, biassed and irresponsible.
He told us a few months ago—early in the session—that he had no intention of revising the price of milk. However pressure again has been brought to bear on him, desirable pressure too, and has forced him to give way to the extent of granting 1d. a gallon. I do not think that even the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society can be expected to agree to that increase as being adequate or sufficient.
There is another section of the milk producing community with whom I am very much concerned, the producers of milk for Dublin market. Those people have also, like the man in the Scriptures, been given 1d. When we realise the value of 1d. at the present time when it comes to purchasing goods we can understand the value of the increase which our milk producers in the Dublin supply area have secured.
Two years ago and even last year the case was made against the milk producers that their business was too remunerative and that they were flooding the City of Dublin with milk. I do not think that the Minister can repeat that suggestion; I do not think that there is any surplus milk in or about the City of Dublin at the present time or that there will be for a long time to come. I think that those engaged in that industry are finding it extremely hard to balance their budget having regard to the present cost of foodstuffs and the increased cost of labour.
Unless the Minister meets the people in a more reasonable mood they will tend to get out of dairying and concentrate on dry stock. With the present meat situation in Britain we can reasonably foresee a demand for beef for a long time to come and as long as that is the position there will be a natural tendency for farmers to adopt the type of farming that gives them the most remunerative return. For that reason the Minister should reconsider the position with regard both to the suppliers to the city and the suppliers to the creameries.
The Minister's eyes should be opened this year to the fallacy which he so frequently announced, that is that the month of April is a summer month. I wonder would anybody who produced milk on his farm during the past month regard April as a summer month? April, as most farmers agree, is the most expensive month in which to produce milk and yet there is a reduction of 9d. per gallon in April as compared with the winter months. If the Minister, without reducing the prices for the rest of the year, were to give a concession for the month of April it would be appreciated by the people in the dairying industry for the City of Dublin.
I have indicated that over the past three years many grave mistakes have been made by the Minister following his first fundamental mistake of forcing down the price of tillage produce. That has led to a chain of evils which farmers have suffered up to the present day. It is hoped, with a world situation in which food and feeding stuffs of every kind are at a premium, that that position will rectify itself. It is hoped that an increased effort will be made, both by the Minister and by farmers, to produce throughout the length and breadth of the country a system of mixed farming by which farmers will grow most of the food they require for their live stock and also a substantial amount of food for sale for human consumption because such a system of farming is fundamentally sound. It does not require compulsion or force; it requires reasonable cooperation on the part of the Department with the farmers and reasonable enthusiasm on the part of those engaged in farming operations.
The Minister should even now realise that in many ways his whole attitude towards farmers has been mistaken. Many of the things which he dogmatically asserted have been proved to be wrong; many of the things which plain plodding farmers have told him and which he repudiated in an intolerant way have been proved to be right. Farmers suggested that we should grow most of our grain for live stock; the farmers were right when they suggested that we should grow a substantial proportion of the beet for our own sugar factories and of wheat to supply our own bread needs, and the Minister on those questions has been proved to be wrong. The farmers were right when they told the Minister last year that his proposal to reduce the price of milk was ridiculous in the face of rising costs and the Minister has been proved to be wrong.
With such a formidable list of mistakes to his credit or to his discredit, the Minister should be more inclined to co-operate with farmers, to meet them as ordinary human beings and not to treat them as if they were serfs. Since becoming Minister, I do not think he has met his fellow Independent Deputies once in council. He, of course, will always be willing to receive an individual Deputy and talk down to him, but he has never met the Independent Deputies as a group. During the past three years he has never met the Agricultural Productive Council. It would not appeal to his vanity to meet a body of ordinary farmers, hear their views and argue out the various questions of agricultural policy with them. He prefers to act as a small dictator. I think that attitude is wrong; it has been proved to be wrong. A list of the mistakes he has made proves that his own judgment in these matters has not been a safe one. He may, like another great dictator, rely on his own personal intuition; but he should remember that that great dictator came to a sad end. In a democratic country like this, a Minister is much better advised to accept the view that he is only an ordinary human being. It was said of Roman emperors in the old days, when they were parading in triumph through the City of Rome, that each emperor used to employ a slave to whisper into his ear "Thou art only a man". The Minister would do well to have some junior official, not, perhaps, to whisper into his ear, but to slip him a note reminding him he is only an ordinary human being and that he, too, could make some slight errors of judgment.
The Minister has been so busy sounding his trumpet that he has never been able to hear the voices of his best friends advising him, or of his more competent officials trying to give him directions. He has wandered from blunder to blunder. He was exporting oats at a time when there was a great shortage of foodstuffs; he was exporting butter at a time when there was a butter shortage here, and then he started importing an inferior product. A lot has been said about Danish butter. I believe the first consignment was rather inferior. We all remember some of the farmers' butter which the Minister exported during his first year of office. We all remember how he came into this House and gave an impersonation of Jimmy O'Dea, when he described how he had to call out the fire brigade to conduct the farmers' butter from the store to the quays. I suppose he had to call out the same fire brigade to conduct the first consignment of Danish butter that arrived here. I dare say if some other Minister had imported it this Minister would have given us a description of how the fire brigade had to be called out to get it off the boat and conduct it to the various distributing centres.
The Minister mentioned that he was having some trouble with potatoes. He said that the British Parliament suggested that some of our potatoes were suffering from a disease that might be described as boast. I do not think that was the word used, but if it was it is a kind of disease which only those potatoes that would come in contact with the Minister himself would be likely to contract. In many ways he has reminded me of a variety of potato which flourished——
Comment on this
Will you leave the Minister out of it and talk about something else? Why talk about the Minister all the time?
Comment on this
This variety of potato was described, strangely enough, as the farmers' glory. It was noted for the fact that it produced a very heavy supply of leaves and blossoms, but a very bad crop of potatoes. I think it will be admitted that in some ways the Minister would remind you of that particular variety of potato. We have all observed the great amount of publicity in regard to what the Minister has done, is about to do or is thinking of doing, but when we come down to bedrock we find there is very little visible evidence of anything being done by the Department. Whatever is being done is being done by the ordinary farmers. Agricultural output is 10 per cent. lower than it was during the war years. That is clear evidence that very little is being done for the agricultural industry.
If the Minister would only listen to the constructive suggestions I have made, he might benefit by them. It may be that Deputy Fagan has missed some of them. I have put forward a number of constructive suggestions which, if adopted, would lead to an improved agricultural output and to better conditions for our farmers and farm workers. The workers can, through their organisations, secure better conditions at the expense of the farmer. The condition of the farmers must also be improved. They can improve it by enforcing higher prices upon the consuming public, but the average farmer prefers stability. He likes a stable condition of affairs in which, through industry and efficiency, he will be able to increase output. It is to increased output that we must look if we are to hope for any improvement in agriculture and in the standard of living of people on the land and in the towns and cities. While Deputy Fagan and Deputy Giles and others of the Minister's admirers may be a little intolerant of criticism, I think a little criticism is good for everyone.
Comment on this
The fact of the matter is that I was one of those who selected him to be a member of the Government and who voted for his election. I selected him because I believed he was a very able man. I knew his brilliance as a debater here. I knew also he had made many wild and irresponsible statements in the Dáil as a Deputy before he was elected Minister, but I had great hope that once the responsibility of office was placed on his shoulders he would change completely, turn his back on the irresponsibilities of the past and become an efficient and responsible Minister, applying his undoubted talents to the development of agriculture. If I have been disappointed, it is not my fault. I have no reason to be jealous of the position he holds, a position which exposes him to very considerable criticism, I must say, and it is a position of considerable difficulty. The suggestion that there is jealousy on my part is absolutely absurd. I have more reason to be jealous of Deputy Giles, who represents with such efficiency a very worthy constituency. I think it is time that that silly approach to criticism of the Department was abandoned. It is time that suggestions put forward by Independent and other Deputies were considered on their merits, not through the smoked glasses of Party animosity, or through a veil of prejudice.
If the Minister will agree to extend to fertilisers the subsidy for ground limestone, that will be appreciated. If he will agree to meet milk producers in the Dublin City area and in the creamery areas and give them a better price, comparable to their increased costs, that would also be appreciated. If he would announce that, come what may, he will never expose tillage farmers to the risk and loss to which he exposed them in 1948-49, he would, I think, be applauded for so doing. But if he adopts the attitude that he is invaluable, if he gets some Deputies to lick his boots and to accuse everyone who criticises him of being inspired by some unworthy motive, the Minister will make no headway in the development of agriculture and the farmers will only wait impatiently for an opportunity to replace him.
Comment on this
I do not propose to speak at any great length on this Estimate. Nevertheless, it is of such importance—it is possibly the most important Estimate that comes for consideration here—that I cannot allow the occasion to pass without drawing the attention of the Minister and the Government to a few matters which I consider of vital interest.
One of the Minister's admirers, speaking from the benches behind him, paid him some left-handed compliments. In fact, I was intrigued listening to the speech of Deputy Commons who, to my mind, was paying him a tribute with the left and giving him an uppercut with the right. For instance, with reference to the rehabilitation scheme, about which we have heard so much, and on which Deputy Commons had some favourable comments to make, he passed the very significant remark that a big percentage of the money was wasted under the rehabilitation scheme. If such a remark came from these benches we would be accused of prejudice and of a departure from the truth but, when it comes from such an ardent admirer of the Minister as Deputy Commons, I do hope the Minister will take serious notice of it and try as far as possible to prevent this wastage. The money, eventually, will have to be paid by the taxpayer.
The Deputy went on to refer to the pig industry and the production of bacon. He stated that the price which the Minister is offering now, as having been obtained from the British, of 220/- a cwt. for pigs leads farmers to the high road. If that be so, following the decrease in the price of eggs and the very low price of milk, it is a poor lookout for the thousands of small farmers along the western seaboard.
Deputy Commons referred to the fact that there are 22,000 farmers in County Mayo whose valuation does not exceed £10. In Clare there are 10,000 farmers whose valuation does not exceed £10 and, with the present low prices for their produce and the present high cost of essential commodities which the farmers use in their industry, it is little wonder that the people are leaving the land.
Some months ago His Lordship the Bishop of Ardagh and Clonmacnoise deplored the fact that the people were leaving the land. It was not the departure of the young people that shocked him so much, but the departure of whole families. I would ask those Deputies, particularly those on the Labour Benches, who never tire telling us about the amazing prosperity of the farmers, is it as a result of prosperity that these farmers are abandoning their holdings and running from them?
Comment on this
Have you seen all that are looking for land? There was a queue outside the door on Sunday. I am telling the truth.
Comment on this
Deputy Fagan may be prosperous. I can assure him that he knows very little about farming conditions in the West of Ireland and I am sure that, if I had time to look up the figures, I would find many thousands of these smallholders in Deputy Fagan's own constituency.
Now that the Minister has returned, I would like to direct his attention to another matter. Deputy Commons referred to the growing of Ymer barley and advised farmers to produce as much as they could of it. I wonder if the Minister is aware that some farmers at least have found it extremely difficult, within the past week or fortnight, to obtain the necessary seed. A few cases have come to my notice in my own constituency and in County Dublin, where farmers have been waiting and could not obtain the seed. I hope the Minister will look into that matter before it is too late.
Deputy Commons also stated that the Fianna Fáil policy of tillage was embarked upon only when the wolf was at the door. For seven years before the wolf arrived in the shape of World War II, Fianna Fáil had been endeavouring, by word, action and example, to induce our people to adopt a policy of increased production of our essential requirements, as far as it was humanly possible to do it. I am glad the Minister has at last come around and has accepted that point of view and that, even in the eleventh hour, he is now making a somewhat similar appeal. My only regret is that the Minister's appeal has come rather late in the day.
Deputy Commons also spoke of his anxiety to have compulsory tillage. This is a point upon which there are a great many points of view, and different Deputies in different Parties hold different views. My view is that you do not need compulsory tillage provided you can make tillage compulsory by inducement. If you give the farmers the prices which will enable them to market their products at a fair profit to themselves and to pay reasonable remuneration to their employees, there need be no question of compulsory tillage and the farmers will produce what is required of them.
I noticed recently where the Minister's opposite number in Britain made an announcement regarding guaranteed prices which he is offering—and offering apologetically—to the farmers of Britain. Our Minister boasts that he is the proud servant of the farming community but recently the milk producers organised, because of the Minister's refusal to meet them to discuss with them the prices at which they could produce and sell milk. That organisation came into being following on the Minister's request to the milk producers to reduce their price from 1/2 to 1/- per gallon over a five years' period and the Minister did not, even in that offer, refer to the possibility of an increase in the cost of production. His opposite number when offering minimum prices to the producers in Britain was, as I have said, apologetic. He stated that the farmers' leaders had met him in the same spirit—that is a spirit of goodwill. He asked those who might be a little disappointed to remember that all classes were being asked to make a sacrifice. He was afraid the consumers would not be left wholly out of the sacrifices. In reply to another questioner, the British Minister said that the negotiations were carried out on the basis of figures prepared by the university economists and that, in the main, they accepted those figures. What were the prices offered and how do they compare with the prices here? Mark you, that in every other sphere of life, in industry, in business, you have the wages, salaries or earnings, whatever they may be, stepped up to a level corresponding to the level of the opposite numbers in Britain. The one exception is the agricultural industry.
If it is right and fair that wages and earnings here in industry and business should be brought up to the level which obtains across the Channel, I should like to hear an argument put forward by somebody proving that it is not right to bring up to the corresponding figure in Britain the prices which obtain here for agricultural produce. The new prices in Britain will be as follows: Wheat, 29/- a cwt., or 72/6 per barrel as compared with 62/6 here with the promise of 67/6 now for grade A wheat; feeding barley, a guaranteed price of 23/- per cwt.; oats, 20/8 a cwt., or 2/7 per stone; rye, 21/6 per cwt.; potatoes, £11 8s. 6d. per ton; sugar beet, £5 8s. 8d.; milk, 2/11½.
Comment on this
Even taking it that it is for human consumption, that price compares more than favourably with the price paid to the producer of milk for any purpose in this country. We shall now get down to the humble egg which is for human consumption. The average price of hen eggs in Britain is 4/3¼ per dozen and the Minister described 2/- per dozen on his return from Britain, as a satisfactory price. If the farmers of this country could obtain these prices for their agricultural products, the Minister need not go to the trouble of publishing any appeal for extra tillage or extra production. It would come about overnight and we would not have the Minister's colleague and supporter leading a strike in County Dublin at present. The occasion would not arise because the farmers would be in a position to offer a reasonable wage to agricultural workers, a wage to which everybody will admit they are entitled, as much as industrial workers because they are engaged in possibly the most important industry there is in this country.
Deputy T. Walsh when speaking reminded the Minister of some broken promises. I should like to carry the Minister's mind back to the famous occasion on which he visited my constituency. Whether or not it was that he was so delighted with the reception he received from the agricultural committee—he probably expected that he would get a hostile reception, but in fact he was received with every courtesy—I do not know, but whatever the cause, he made a certain promise to a deputation who waited on him on behalf of a number of tenants in the Sixmilebridge area where the banks of the river had broken. I am not now pretending that that is the Minister's responsibility, but what I should like to remind the Minister of is that he did make a promise, or at least so it was reported in the Press at the time, that within a month, or possibly two, if nobody else would do so, he would see that the repairs were carried out. From that day to this nothing has been done.
Comment on this
That is not correct. I asked the county council would they undertake the maintenance of the bank if it were repaired. If the county council are prepared to undertake the maintenance of the bank, I should be very interested to hear it.
Comment on this
I should like to hear from the Minister how he asked the county council when it was the committee of agriculture he was addressing. I do not know of any occasion on which the Minister visited the county council to put that question to them. Be that as it may, the Minister gave an undertaking, which those who were listening to him regarded as being on behalf of the Government, that something would be done, but nothing has been done.
Comment on this
Discussions are proceeding with the county council to ascertain if they would undertake the maintenance.
Comment on this
I am giving the interpretation which has been placed on the Minister's statement by the ordinary man in the street.
Comment on this
The Minister would not miss, perhaps, £10,000 or £20,000 out of the £40,000,000 which he is using for the rehabilitation of land, some of it of very doubtful quality. I would direct the Minister's attention to these self-same banks along the estuaries of the Fergus and the Shannon. It is hardly fair to expect the ordinary farmers to maintain these banks. Provision should have been made at the time the lands were being vested to have sufficient funds set aside for the maintenance of these banks.
Comment on this
In a great many cases, that was not done. At the same time I should like again to remind the Minister that, outside of these banks and further west, there is an area of approximately 17,000 acres of possibly the richest alluvial land there is in this or any other country. I have pointed out to him a cheap and easy way of reclaiming these lands. I would ask him now to take even £1,000 out of the £40,000,000 which he has at his disposal and expend it there on an experimental scheme. It is not such a wild experiment either. Twenty-three years ago I was instrumental in getting a scheme of that kind carried out. It cost the County Clare Committee of Agriculture £6. As proving that the scheme shows a reasonable chance of success, I might mention that people in other lands, particularly in East Anglia and the east coast of Holland, used this scheme as a model for the purpose of reclaiming land subjected to tidal flooding. I am glad that the Minister is bringing over a Dutch expert to have a look at this same problem and I should like if he would also get in touch with some other expert who would be an authority on the growing of rye grass there. There are such experts not terribly far away and they would be agreeable and willing to come over here to consult the Minister if he gave them an invitation to do so. This land is well worth reclaiming. One hundred years ago, the Fergus Reclamation Syndicate was established to reclaim portion of this land. I have known some of the allottees on the land to grow mangolds which are possibly the severest crop that could be sown on any land, without farmyard manure. They grew three crops of mangolds in succession and grew them successfully without manure. I know of no other land in this country that would be capable of doing that.
Comment on this
That may be, but I merely mention the fact to show that whatever may be thought of the methods of farming pursued there, the land is at least equal, if not superior, to any land in this country. I say to the Minister that it is worth spending money to reclaim it from the tide and that it will give a better return for the money expended on it than many other schemes. The Minister promised that more ground limestone would be made available, but, despite repeated questions to him, and despite the guarantee given by the Clare County Committee of Agriculture to purchase 500 tons of it as requested by the Minister, it took him until the first week in April before any machinery was moved into the quarry to provide this very necessary lime for the farmers.
Comment on this
Is not that rather an ungracious way of recognising the fulfilment of my undertaking?
Comment on this
It was a fulfilment which came too late in the day. The Minister should know that the month of April or May is not the proper time for putting lime out on the land. I should like to know further from the Minister if he demanded or obtained a similar undertaking to that given by the Clare County Committee from any other county committee in the country?
Comment on this
Did the Minister demand a similar undertaking from any other county committee before he moved the plant into the quarry?
Comment on this
If the Minister would allow me to proceed, we might get along more rapidly. The Minister might like to be reminded of another promise which he made at one time. He reminded the farmer's wife that when she saw a pretty little chick poke out its pretty beak from the egg shell, she could say to herself: "There will be a guaranteed price for every egg you lay during the laying period."