We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 214–439 of 439. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I admit you know what it is.

Comment on this

The Minister, on coming back from London, told us that was a reasonably satisfactory price, if my memory serves me rightly. But the Minister, when on these benches, never tired of reminding us that, if only the Fianna Fáil Ministers had the courage of their convictions and crossed over to London to meet their opposite numbers, they could make a satisfactory long-term agreement without more ado. The Minister himself, before leaving to make this very satisfactory agreement which leaves us with the price of 2/- a dozen for eggs, announced that he would rather sell our Irish products to his old and valued customer at prices less than the world market price, at less than he could command from the fly-by-night boys from the Continent of Europe. The Minister set forth to insult the representatives of various European countries who were coming in here and thereby serving a very useful purpose.

If the Minister were wise, he could have used these very same gentlemen in his bargaining with the British, but with all his plamás and soft soap, when he went across to Britain he found that he had to deal with a business people, to deal with the representatives of a nation of shopkeepers who make no soft bargains and who, possibly, are the hardest people on this earth to make a bargain with. The Minister came back, delighted with himself, having reduced the price of eggs from the 3/- a dozen which obtained as a result of the hard bargain made by his predecessor, to 2/-. Yet, we have Deputies sitting behind the Minister boasting that the country was never more prosperous and that the farmers never had so much money as they have at the present time.

Comment on this

Is that not true?

Comment on this

That, I suppose, is why so many families are fleeing from the land? They are fleeing from this prosperity. Does the Minister or any of his supporters hold that a man living in the West on a £10 valuation holding is prosperous at the present time?

Comment on this

He is better off than ever he was under Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Despite the 2/- a dozen for eggs and despite the 1/2 a gallon for milk? I make him a present of the fact that the price of milk is to be 1/3 a gallon during the summer months. I would point out that milk and eggs are of greater importance to the man on a £10 valuation than any increase in the price of beef. I take it that the Minister will claim full credit for the increase in the price of beef—that it is due to his energies and activities. Some of his spokesmen, at any rate, make that claim. I suppose the Minister will also claim that the increase in the price of wool, which has soared to such enormous heights, is going to benefit the smallholder in the West on a £10 valuation—the wool which is making 28/- per lb. in Australia and New Zealand? I suppose the Minister will claim that that is going to make those men in the West extremely prosperous, and that they should be grateful to the Minister who has wrought such a miracle.

Comment on this

It is 6/- per lb. in Ireland.

Comment on this

I was speaking about the price of eggs and the promises which the Minister made to the farmers' wives that there would be a guaranteed price. At the time the Minister was speaking the price of eggs was 3/- per dozen. The inference, therefore, to be drawn from his speech was that for quite a long while at all events that price was going to continue. The fact, however, is that the Minister made his bargain with the British and the price of eggs flopped. There was a little publication, a copy of which I used to get occasionally from the Minister's Department. It was known as P.E.P. The pep is gone out of the eggs now.

Another prophecy made by the Minister was contained in the famous speech he made at Portumna when he gave an undertaking to all whom it might concern. He said on that occasion: "I am your Minister for maize," adding that in no foreseeable time the price of maize would not go up by, I think he said, a brass farthing. But the price of maize has gone up and the price of feeding stuffs generally has gone up, with the result that eggs cannot be produced profitably at present-day prices.

With regard to milk, when the milk producers, as a result of the Minister's invitation, accepted a reduction in the price on being guaranteed 1/- a gallon for five years, and when the producers were driven to organise themselves, the Minister, in order to evade meeting the organisation, described it as "a Fianna Fáil ramp". One gentleman, who claimed the credit of forming this organisation in the County Limerick, was a very prominent supporter of the Deputies sitting behind the Minister and of the Minister himself when he was at one time a vice-president of the Fine Gael organisation. But, of course, the Minister is not very much concerned when making remarks of that kind, especially when he hopes or thinks he can get away with them.

Comment on this

The Deputy will agree that it was an insult.

Comment on this

I do not agree because I do not know exactly what the Deputy is driving at.

Comment on this

To be called a Fianna Fáiler.

Comment on this

If it was an insult, his insult was given to supporters of the Deputies sitting opposite. He is welcome to do that. The more of these insults which he flings around the better, I suppose, it will be for our Party, and the more it will drive people towards our Party.

There is another matter to which I want to direct the Minister's attention. It was brought to my notice recently that, due to the extremely bad harvest and the exceptionally severe weather conditions which prevailed in the last eight or nine months, the hay saved last year after the month of June is of exceedingly low nutritional value, with the result that the milch cows fed on it are so emaciated that considerable losses are being suffered by small farmers up and down the country as a consequence. These cows are so thin and emaciated that they are incapable of calving and losses are being suffered all over the country. I am not accusing the Minister in connection with that, although when he was on these benches he accused Fianna Fáil of all the crimes in the calendar because of the exceptionally bad weather in 1946-47. Unfortunately, we have had a repetition of these weather conditions in the year which has just passed. A number of smallholders are losing their cows therefore through no fault of their own and it would be well for the Minister to get his officials to inquire and see what can be done to save these people who can very ill afford such losses.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy suggest I should do beyond making available abundant supplies of feeding stuffs?

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister might do what Fianna Fáil did in a similar situation.

Comment on this

Replacement of stock.

Comment on this

Why not prevent them from dying instead of replacing them?

Comment on this

Why does not the Minister prevent them from dying at present?

Comment on this

What does the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this

Replacement.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Collins should not be interrupting his own colleague.

Comment on this

I would be obliged if the Deputy would suggest something that might be done.

Comment on this

I am not trying to make political capital out of this. I am bringing this matter to the Minister's notice and I am sure that some of his admirers behind him are also aware of the fact. Deputy O'Higgins, apparently, is aware of it, and it is only fair that the Minister should be informed.

Comment on this

What can you do except provide feeding stuffs?

Comment on this

When confronted with a similar situation, Fianna Fáil provided a heifer loan scheme under which replacements could be made.

Comment on this

Is that not waiting until the cattle die and then giving a loan?

Comment on this

The Minister is waiting until the cows are dying.

Comment on this

I made feeding stuffs available to them in shops all over the country.

Comment on this

Why are they dying then?

Comment on this

Why do you not tell me what I can do to help in County Clare to prevent them from dying?

Comment on this

It is too late now, as they have died.

Comment on this

Because of the fact, as I have pointed out, that we have passed through a very bad winter and the hay saved last year was of such a quality that it is unable to nourish those milch cows and keep them in such a condition that they would be able to get over the calving period in safety.

Comment on this

Can they not give them mashes of Indian meal, pollard and bran?

Comment on this

It is not there.

Comment on this

There is a vast surplus. The mills are packed with it.

Comment on this

What is the price?

Comment on this

About 30/- a cwt. Surely you would not let a cow die for the sake of 30/-.

Comment on this

It is 25 per cent. admixture and the rest sawdust.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Grady is in possession. This conversation is getting us nowhere.

Comment on this

If I had been allowed to proceed, I would have finished by now; but if these questions and answers are to continue, I shall probably be kept here for the rest of the evening.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should be allowed to make his statement in his own way.

Comment on this

I do not mind interruptions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do.

Comment on this

I am not asking for them. I was making a statement in order to bring home to the Minister facts which have come to my knowledge and that statement was fortified by his colleague sitting behind him who pointed to his own red tie and intimated that he had brought that matter to the Minister's notice. It was the Minister began the question and answer business. I merely made the statement and I qualified it by saying that I was not accusing the Minister or trying to make any political capital out of it, because we have been passing through a period of bad weather over which the Minister, with all his great power, had no control, although he accused his predecessor time and again of the ill effects of a similar period of bad weather and all his colleagues, whenever they want to make a comparison with regard to production or the yields of farm produce always refer to the year 1946-47 and never have the decency to point out that that was one of the worst years in living memory. It was the worst year in my lifetime, and I can remember as far back as the disastrous year, 1903. Since then we have not had anything similar until the present year.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy permit me to ask him a question? When the Deputy tells me that, to his knowledge, cattle are threatened with death or are dying in County Clare for the want of foodstuffs, I want him to suggest anything I can do to help to prevent the cattle from dying; not to replace dead cattle, but to prevent them from dying.

Comment on this

Replace them.

Comment on this

I have supplied the foodstuffs in abundance in every town and village in Clare. Is there anything else I can do to bring within the reach of the smallest farmer in County Clare a means to carry his cattle safely through until the grass grows? If there is, I want to know of it so that I can undertake it.

Comment on this

Replace them.

Comment on this

In other words, wait until they die.

Comment on this

I would rather save the cattle than replace them. I want to save them from dying.

Comment on this

I drew the Minister's attention to the fact that it was milch cows that were dying.

Comment on this

I want to save them.

Comment on this

The reason being under-nourishment and malnutrition because of the season through which we have passed. I was not holding the Minister responsible for the weather which brought about a condition in which the hay saved during that very rainy period was unable to maintain the cows in a proper condition.

Comment on this

If it is supplemented by mashes of Indian meal, pollard and bran, will it not carry them over until the grass grows?

Comment on this

The trouble is that at the price at which these are available the ordinary small farmer could not afford throughout the winter to feed them to his cows. He may have been unwise in that. It may be bad farming, if you like, but the fact remains that the very small-holder, the man with a holding under £10 valuation, cannot afford to supplement it in that way. Oftentimes he has not even enough roots. A well-to-do farmer may be able to do it.

Comment on this

Surely the smallest farmer would not allow any cow to die for the sake of 30/-?

Comment on this

This has been occurring since the cows were put in in November. Perhaps the farmer did not understand that the hay was so deficient in nutrition that it would leave his cows in such an emaciated condition that when it came to calving time these losses would occur. The only cure I see for it is that where cows are lost in this way they should be replaced by some scheme such as the heifer loan scheme, introduced by the Minister's predecessor some years ago to meet a somewhat similar situation. I bring that matter to the notice of the Minister not for the purpose of making political capital out of it but in the interests of those whom I represent and of whom the Minister claims to be the honoured servant. I hope he will take note now of the needs of his masters down the country who are appealing to him to do everything he possibly can to lighten their loss.

Comment on this

The heifer scheme is there but what I really want to do is to save the cows before they die. It is the daftest proposition I ever heard of to let the cows die.

Comment on this

Then there must be a great number of daft people. Those who lost their cows will not be grateful to the Minister for the use of that expression. If they were as well off as the Minister is and had the same resources behind them that he has behind him, there is not a shadow of doubt but that they would not let an animal die.

Comment on this

None of them need go short. If they are within reach of a co-operative creamery anywhere in Clare, none of them need go short of credit in order to keep a cow in hay and roots—not one of them.

Comment on this

Be that as it may, the facts remain. The Minister need not take my word for it. He has numerous officials of his Department in Clare and elsewhere. This is not confined to Clare. Deputy T.F. O'Higgins must have had the same experience in his constituency.

Comment on this

And we organised a credit scheme and we went down and fed the cows. The same thing happened in North Leitrim. We organised the local creamery and they provided the people with fodder for their cattle. We will do the same in Clare.

Comment on this

Did you say North Leitrim?

Comment on this

Yes. I brought hay from Donegal.

Comment on this

You did, but it was too late. What was the report of the veterinary surgeon there to your Department?

Comment on this

Did we not do it just as soon as we found out?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us hear Deputy O'Grady to a conclusion.

Comment on this

It is a matter of some importance and I want to find out if these things are happening.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I know it is a matter of some importance but the particulars will not be discovered by every Deputy intervening. One Deputy should be allowed to finish his statement and those who wish to raise the matter can make their statements also in due course.

Comment on this

I am probably one of the oldest members of this House. I rarely intervene and, when I do, I try to be as brief as possible. It is disconcerting that I am not allowed to make my contribution of about 15 minutes' duration without having the Deputies on the Government Benches, assisted by some of those on my own benches, trying to prevent me from making that contribution.

The facts have been given to me. I cannot swear to them. I have not seen any of these things for myself. Nevertheless, I believe that my information is correct, and I hope the Minister will use the elaborate staff he has to check upon it and find out whether or not my information is correct, and then try to find a remedy. He has a very able staff of officials to help him. Yet, he wants me pronto to suggest a remedy across the floor of the House.

Comment on this

Tell me any area where you think there is serious trouble in Clare so that I may try to do something there.

Comment on this

I appeal to the Minister to take note of what I have said, and get his officials to inquire into the matter. It is up to him and his staff to devise the best remedy they can in the interests of these small holders. Well-to-do farmers can afford to purchase foodstuffs and they will not suffer any loss. It is the man under £10 valuation who is hardest hit. He finds it hard enough to feed his family without having to go out and purchase feeding stuffs for his animals at the prevailing high prices.

Comment on this

One pleasant feature of this debate is the fact that the Clerk of the weather has shown during the past few days that he at least is pleased with the work of the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Then he must have been very displeased indeed for the past twelve months.

Comment on this

Whether it be a coincidence or not, since the introduction of this Estimate the sun has been shining all the time. Beautiful rays have spread an invigorating warmth over this House. I am sure that the sunshine is as welcome to the farmers as it is to us, those hard working farmers who are serenely oblivious of all the nonsensical speeches made here within the past three days.

I wish to refer now to the remarks made by my colleague, Deputy Aiken, on the subject of the potato industry as it affects the farmers in the Cooley area. During my 24 years' membership of this House I do not remember any occasion upon which I was compelled to cross swords with my colleague. But I must cross swords with him to-night.

His remarks in relation to the potato industry can only be characterised as ill-timed, ill-judged and, in relation to the officials of the British Ministry of Food, grossly ill-mannered. There is an old adage that: "Fools rush in where angels fear to tread." Deputy Aiken's entrance into this debate in relation to the question of potatoes in Cooley at this particular juncture was one which I certainly did not expect from him. I would like to draw the attention of the House to the fact that Deputy Aiken is not an ordinary member of this House. He has in the past carried the portfolios of Minister for Defence, Minister for Lands and Minister for Finance. Because of the experience which he must have gained in those offices he should never have given expression to the utterances he made here last evening on this particular matter.

It is a well-known fact that whenever there is a dispute between two Governments and a decision that the question is sub judice, it is most unwise and improper for any reference to be made that would interfere with or affect the outcome of those deliberations. Deputy Aiken came in at the last moment completely ignorant of the situation, otherwise he would not have made those remarks. If he were aware of the situation, it would have been quite easy for him, as a responsible Deputy, to walk across to the Department of Agriculture and get from the officials there certain facts regarding the Cooley area and other areas concerning the export of potatoes. It seemed to me, listening to him, that his one ambition was to down the Minister and damn the consequences. He gave me the impression that he was not concerned with the 2,000 or 3,000 tons of Banners that still remain unsold on the hands of the farmers of Cooley, so long as he got a dig at the Minister. I happened to be in on this question very early on. I have kept in touch with it and I know the position. I know the negotiations that have been carried on and I personally, on behalf of the farmers of Cooley, wish the Minister luck in his negotiations. Judging by his past experience and by his previous deliberations with the British Ministry of Food, I know that a satisfactory solution will be found.

I wonder why Deputies opposite, including Deputy Aiken, cannot bring themselves round to pay even a small tribute to the Minister's work. Deputy Aiken was well aware of the very satisfactory agreement the Minister made for potatoes last year and the year before, when the whole of the potato crop was exported at from £7 10s. to £8 10s. per ton and the farmers of Cooley were quite satisfied. In my opinion, Deputy Aiken—I am sorry he is not here—would have been much wiser to wait a few days before passing the remarks he made yesterday evening.

Speaking generally, the condition of agriculture is satisfactory. In striking contrast to the attitude of Fianna Fáil Deputies on this occasion, I have always made it a point to pay a tribute whenever it was deserved. I was always prepared to recognise difficulties, but seemingly Fianna Fáil cannot recognise difficulties. They avail of this discussion as a sort of dress rehearsal of the speeches they intend to make in the event of a coming general election—which they have been told by their Leaders is to take place. Everybody knows—except the person who does not want to understand—that the figures there are in the White Paper, which gives the whole policy pursued by the Minister through his officials. There is no secret about it. It deals with every aspect of his policy, and anyone who takes the trouble and time to study the White Paper will see the progress that has been made. Large funds have been placed at the disposal of the farmers to improve their land, to reduce the mortality in cattle and to improve the agricultural industry in general.

The all-round revenue derived from the exports of cattle, poultry, eggs, sheep and everything else amounted roughly to £46,000,000 in 1950 as against £25,000,000 in 1947. I readily admit, of course, that there has been a difference in prices, but I ask, in answer to the doleful speeches delivered here that farmers are down and out: "Why do Deputies opposite always find delight in making little of their own class?" I never could understand those on the opposite benches on that point. How could the farmers live for the last three years, if their plight was as desperate as one has been led to believe? I know the farmers as well as anyone else, as men of courage. Would they not meet the Minister at every crossroads with the old shillelaghs as they did of old, and would not every Deputy on these benches be met, when he returned to his constituency, and told of their plight? I mix with farmers as much as any Deputy opposite. I do not say they are all millionaires, but I hold they are tolerably prosperous at present and so long as they mind their business, as they are allowed to do so, they will continue to be as prosperous as in the past three years.

I enter an emphatic protest against some of the complaints made from the opposite benches regarding the Minister's policy, especially on tillage. I was amused at Deputy Cogan twitting the Minister that he was discouraging tillage, when every paper in the country carries advertisements exhorting the farmers to till all the land they can. The Minister made it clear that, this being a democratic country, he is not going to apply compulsion. Does not commonsense tell anybody that no one can look after a man's business as well as himself? Surely the farmers know what kind of economy will yield the best results. They can be depended on, by their husbandry and their long years of experience, to get the best return. Deputies opposite expect the Minister not alone to provide moneys to help farmers to till their land but they want him to sow their oats. If there happens to be a stack of oats left unsold, there is a hullabaloo about it, but the moment the Minister makes arrangements to dispose of it, those opposite twit him for having exported and sold all the oats, leaving the farmers short. It is very difficult to please the Deputies opposite. It is generally agreed that the Minister is doing all he possibly can to improve the position of the farmers.

It is the duty of Deputies opposite to give all the help they can in regard to the rehabilitation scheme and all the other schemes that have been set up under the aegis of the Department of Agriculture. In order to help the farmers, it is the duty of the Deputies opposite, instead of engaging in a campaign of destructive criticism, to, at least, do a little by way of cooperation and advise the farmers of this country to take advantage of the many facilities which have been placed at their disposal by the Minister for Agriculture. In that way, we can face the future with courage, fortified by the thought that, come what may, we can depend upon our own efforts. By co-operation, we will be able to come through whatever difficult times lie ahead.

I am not a bit alarmed at this prospect of a war referred to so often by the Deputies opposite. The farmers do not require to serve five years in order to switch from the growing of oats to the growing of wheat. It is simply a matter of rotation. They can change overnight, as they have done before and, if the worst comes to the worst, they will be ready to meet any situation that may arise in the future. We can have absolute confidence, owing to the ability of the Minister, aided by the very efficient staff, that we will be able to do in the future as we have done in the past, namely, provide for our people the wherewithal for a decent standard of living.

Comment on this

The year that has passed has been a very severe one for the agricultural community. It is not the farmers alone who will suffer for that very bad summer and winter. The whole community will be affected. In contributing to this debate, I do not stand up to plead for the farmer. I feel—in this debate on agriculture— that it is not the farmer alone who will be affected by our agricultural policy but the life of our community.

This is an agricultural country and the development of our agriculture will mean prosperity for all sections of the community. I felt sorry for the Minister when I heard him say that he did all he could to help the farmers when they were short of fodder and feeding stuffs during the past year. I am sure he did. I believe that the Minister was sincerely worried. I did not envy the Minister his position nor do I envy him his position at the present time. I do not want to be destructive in my criticism, but I feel that I cannot throw bouquets at the Minister for the policy that he has carried out during his three years of office. It is not for any political reason that I say that. The Minister has been very disappointing. He is a disappointment to the people who were opposed to him in politics. The farmers of the country of all shades of political opinion have lost faith in him. In his early period of office, I thought that the Minister had a grasp of the agricultural situation and for a time I believed that he would avail of the opportunities that we now have to build up agriculture and lay a good foundation. The Minister was not in office during a period of world depression in agriculture. He came into office in a very good time. There is money in agriculture now.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! A Daniel come to judgment.

Comment on this

If we had a policy that would take the most advantage of the present situation, there is money to be made out of agriculture. Whatever prices we have at the present time for our agricultural produce, the prices of cattle are high. The Minister believes in the cattle trade. I also believe in the cattle trade. I believe that our cattle trade is a very important part of our agricultural economy. I believe that had we developed our cattle industry as it should have been developed and as the Minister for Agriculture has neglected to develop it, we could bring great wealth to the farming community and to the country as a whole. But the Minister has done nothing about that. He has sat back and claimed the credit because the world prices of meat are high to-day. He did nothing about the matter. During his period of office, millions of pounds have been lost that could have been made out of the cattle industry.

I spoke on this Estimate 12 months ago. We had passed through a very mild winter. The winter of 1949-50 was very mild. The previous year, the people were short of fodder and the farmers had a very lean time but, the winter being so mild, they got through with their cattle alive. In the spring of 1950, if one went through the fairs of the country, one could see that the cattle were thin because they had not been lined with the feeding that they should have been getting during the winter months. The result of that was that it took them a very long time to pull up for their losses even in a mild winter. A big number of cattle could have been matured if they had been properly looked after during the winter of 1949-50. The cattle remained on the land until late in the year. As a result, I saw throughout the country last spring, that the farming community were not able to hold up their meadows and the cattle that should have been kept off the meadows were roaming over them. The hay season was late. The cattle were out on the meadows too long and they had to let the meadows grow on late and when the bad weather came, the hay was lost. The farmer who was in a position last year to take the cattle off in time and had his meadows fit to cut in the early part of June, got very fine weather for making hay and obtained hay of the best quality, but these farmers were in the minority.

The Minister came down to a committee of agriculture meeting in Kildare about last October and boasted there that there were more cattle in the country then than there were within living memory. I thought that a very foolish boast on the part of the Minister. Comparing 1947 with 1950, he pointed out that, in 1947, there were less cattle in the country, but we all know that the winter of 1946-47 was very severe and that there were big losses. I believe we have not seen the full extent of those losses yet, because it is not the cattle which died that are the real loss to the country, but the cattle which were emaciated and reduced and which will take another year or year and a half to recover. That is where the loss to the farmer and to the country comes in.

The Minister, I think, was dishonest. He knew that the 1946-47 winter was a very hard winter and that cattle were reduced by reason of that hard winter and that it was not due to the policy of any Government. When he got into office, he should have learned from that experience and should have done something about it, as he could have done. He had the greatest opportunity ever presented to a Minister of doing something for the cattle trade about which they talk so much, but for which they never did anything but allow it to jog along in its own way, letting the cattle roam over the ranges in the old way and develop up to three or four years old, which was the policy in the old British days. That is their policy, and that is all they did for the trade about which they talk so much.

Great amounts of money were made available to us through Marshall Aid, and all over the country schemes were started which, we were told, would bring vast improvement to the land. We had drainage schemes and the rehabilitation scheme, for which we got great machines from America. I presume all that money will have to be repaid, but many farmers through the country to whom I have talked say that a very large proportion of that money was wasted and that agriculture is not any better off. If anyone who knows anything about agriculture or land travels around the country—and I go around a little—he will see, even in areas where they have the best land, that the land is impoverished and has been impoverished for a long time, and that much more could be made out of it. The Minister has initiated a scheme whereby a farmer who wants to get his soil tested can pay so much an acre and send a sample for test. He will then be told what his land requires. Such a soil analysis may be necessary on land on which the farmer is putting too much artificial manure, but in the case of most of the pasture land of this country, which has never seen artificial manure within living memory, which has been grazed and meadowed for generations, I do not think such a soil analysis is so very necessary. So far as most of the land I see is concerned, one would not be running any risk of throwing away money if it were given a dressing of semsol or phosphatic manure, at the rate of ten or 12 cwt. to the acre, or potash, even without an analysis. It would vastly improve that land.

The Minister and the Government with all this money at their disposal could have done a lot for themselves, if they had used that money to buy artificial manures. They could have made it available at a very low price and could have given it out to farmers of all valuations, because whatever you give to the farmer you get back from him. It is all taken back from the farmers in the long run. We are building houses, improving our roads and providing very elaborate social services and a very large part of this burden is placed on the farming community. The farmers are not able to keep ahead of the high rates and taxation which they have to pay, notwithstanding the high prices for agricultural produce at present. I believe, however, that if the Minister had persuaded the Government to put all the money available three years ago into artificial manures for putting on the land, the grassland of this country would have carried double the stock it carried and there would have been so great an increase in fertility of the land that more land would be available for tillage. I believe he would have done much to improve our cattle and improve their value. We could have had extra tillage—extra wheat, extra potatoes and extra root crops. We could have employed more people on the land and there would not have been any difficulty in getting very much better wages for the workers employed on the land. If the Minister had approached the problem in that way agriculture would be in a sound and prosperous position now. He neglected to do so, however, and the farmers are disappointed.

Many farmers in this country are not in very good circumstances. There are farmers whose land is poor and they find it very difficult to pay their way. They are living from hand-to-mouth all the time and, to a great extent—and I must say that I think this is unfair— they are carrying on with the aid of the unpaid labour of their families. I think farmers are very foolish to work their families without at least putting by for them the agricultural rate of wages which is fixed. Very many of them do not do that and their families work long hours. Unfortunately, that is the position with a very large section of our farmers; that is the way they have made what money they are supposed to have made. A trade unionist would describe that condition as one in which the farmer's family work for nothing. We talk about family labour. Many people seem to think: "Oh, it is all right, that man has his own family." I think we should get away from that idea and that we should see to it that the farmer's family will get as good a standard of living and as good a return for their day's work as any trade unionist. I know that it is the farmers' own fault because they do not look for it, but it is time for them to do so.

I think, with regard to the land rehabilitation project, that the Government and the Minister have made a very bad mistake. We had a farm improvements scheme under the previous Administration that met the situation adequately.

Comment on this

For drainage?

Comment on this

For farm improvements. That scheme was adequate in many cases. A very large amount of the arable land of this country is not productive to its full capacity. The land rehabilitation project will not appeal very much to a farmer who has land of that type. He will say: "I have 30 or 40 acres of land that could produce more if it got some artificial manure," and he will consider that that is a more economic proposition than the land rehabilitation project because the reclaimed land will never be as productive as the refertilised arable land.

The Minister will point out that there is a credit scheme and he will ask why the farmer does not get the artificial manures. I know farmers who use artificial manures and who do everything in the most up-to-date way, as recommended by the Department of Agriculture. They follow closely all the experiments. These people may not have capital. When the end of the year comes they sell their crops but by the time the merchant is paid for his seed and artificial manures, and they pay for the labour and their rates, there is very little left for themselves. They run the risk all the time of incurring a debt for a very slender return. If a bad year comes they may lose everything. Farmers are not anxious to get into debt and they have very good reason for wishing to avoid it. When a farmer borrows money and puts it into his land it is a long time before he gets it back again. A slump may come and he may be caught out in the meantime. He is not like an industrialist who can get his money back more quickly. There is an inducement to the farmer, in practically every one of the Minister's schemes, to get into debt. The Agricultural Credit Corporation is there and he is asked to borrow money and pay it back on the instalment system. He is asked to buy milking machines, and so forth. On top of all that, his rates are increasing year by year. His position is anxious enough. He has very good reason for not wishing to incur more debt. His costs are going up year after year.

I think that the Minister has failed completely to improve the lot of the farmers. Three years have been lost and the country must have lost millions of pounds, not so much on the cattle that died, as because of the delay and the set-back they received for the want of proper provision being made for them. I realise that the Minister could not do very much last year but I hold that if the Government had faced the situation squarely —instead of wasting a lot of money on drainage schemes and the land rehabilitation scheme, which they talk so much about—the country would now be in a far better position than it is and the farmer would be able to pay his rates and pay better wages, and so forth.

I come now to the question of wheat. I notice that during the past week or fortnight wheat has been put at the top of the list in the Department's advertisements as the crop which it is most necessary to grow. In previous years the Minister advised farmers to grow potatoes, oats, and so forth, and in a little footnote to the advertisement he would mention wheat or beet or something like that. As a result of the Minister's recommendations, the farmers rushed into potato production. I know farmers in my constituency who never grew potatoes before, and who did not do much tillage of any description because they did not care for that type of farming. However, they were loyal supporters of this Government, and they said that they would give a hand and give some encouragement and follow the Minister's advice. I know one man who put a fairly large acreage under potatoes. I asked him what he was going to do with the potatoes, and whether he was sure of a market, and I said that it would have been wiser to have grown beet. His reply was: "James Dillon will get me a market for my potatoes." I suppose that many farmers throughout the country felt the same way. Then the potatoes were there and there was not a market for them. Similarly with regard to oats. Farmers had rushed into the growing of oats—but, of course, the oats were needed. Unfortunately, these people could not wait when the harvest time came. They had to cash their oats to pay their bills. The Minister told them to put their oats in stacks and to thatch the stacks. One thing followed another. Take, for instance, eggs. We were told that the more eggs that would be produced the better off the country would become. The Minister went the wrong way about everything which he tackled. He has discouraged the farming community. Wheat is now at the top of the list. Only a fortnight ago the Minister announced that he would give 67/6 a barrel, weighing 61 lb. to the bushel, for wheat. The Minister should have made that announcement last September and, even so, I do not think that the price is sufficient.

If I remember aright Britain is giving a better price to her farmers for wheat than 67/6 and I think that artificial manures in Britain are much cheaper than they are here. If the Minister had announced last September or October that he would give that 67/6 for wheat that would weigh 61 lb. to the bushel it could have been an inducement to the farmers to put in some winter wheat. I think it has done nearly more harm than good at the present time because in the case of most of us who sow spring wheat there is a lot to be put in yet and I think that very little was put in before the 1st April. It is a bit late now and every farmer who sowed wheat in the past week feels he is taking a chance and a gamble. If it is late the wheat will not get sufficient time in the ground and the yield may be low—this is the way farmers look at it—and it will not bushel so well. What the Minister should have done is——

Comment on this

To change the weather.

Comment on this

He would have no hesitation in promising to do it.

Comment on this

——to put in no stipulation at all as to bushelling this year. We may consider the year before last when any wheat would bushel 61 or 62 lb. because it was a good season but there are years when wheat bushels only 56 or 57 lb. and this may be one of them. In 1947 after the late spring wheat bushelled badly and the yield was low. Farmers cannot look forward to this being a profitable year for wheat and with high wages the increase of 7/6 is not really an increase at all and is no inducement to farmers to take the risk. They may want a good deal more if they are to get a profit out of their crops this year.

There has been a lot of talk about compulsion: "Everybody is free now and can do what he likes with his own land." Fianna Fáil never stood for the compulsion of farmers.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil were forced to bring in compulsion.

Comment on this

Ah, the poor things.

Comment on this

They were compelled to do it by the attitude of the Fine Gael Opposition, particularly Deputy Dillon. This will just give an indication of their mentality and of the harm done by Fine Gael and of Deputy Dillon when in opposition: if you go back to the files of local papers in Kildare and other counties in the Midlands as well you will see advertisements declaring that land should not be used for the growing of wheat, that wheat impoverished land and ruined soil. That was the attitude of large farmers at the time when our people were in danger of starvation and we could not bring food into the country. It was Fine Gael propaganda that brought that about and if Fine Gael had not adopted that attitude the farmers would not have been misled as they were and we would probably have been in a much better position. They would have been anxious to help in growing wheat and food for the people if it were not for that attitude held particularly by Deputy Dillon who did everything he could to discourage land-owners from helping out.

I have my wheat vouchers for the past year still. I have been watching the papers for an advertisement to see when the Minister is going to give us 2/6 for them but I did not see it yet— I may have missed it.

I am sorry that the Minister has wasted three years in which agriculture could have been made prosperous. I remember the first great war and after that war farmers thought they were very well off. Everybody said that the farming community were very prosperous. When the farmer has money he spends it and lives well and sometimes he even makes out that he is better off that he really is. The slump came in 1921 and everything was depressed. Prices fell and we were dependent not on our own market but on the foreign market. Now we are back to that policy again and I hope it will not end as it did after that period of prosperity between 1915 and 1921.

Comment on this

Deputy Harris has just stated that there is money in agriculture now, Deputy Harris being Fianna Fáil representative of County Kildare. If it were one of the Deputies supporting the Government who made that statement everybody would feel that he was just boosting the Minister, but apparently Deputy Harris is an honest man. As far as I could gather he put the onus on the farmers and said that if a man works his land there is money in agriculture. That coming from a Fianna Fáil Deputy is a great tribute to the Minister.

I would like to congratulate the Minister on placing his trust in the Irish farmer and I can say that in Kilkenny that trust is not misplaced. The farmers who have suitable tillage land will till not only the quota but much more provided they get a fair return for their crop, and I think that the Minister is giving that at present, especially since the increase in the price of wheat. I was very surprised to hear Deputy Walsh last night coming out and stating that he was in favour of compulsory tillage. I take it for granted that he was representing the view of the Fianna Fáil Party. Apparently Deputy Walsh is not prepared to put his trust in the farmers of County Kilkenny. When we had compulsory tillage before what did the Government do? They gave the farmers 35/- a barrel for barley although it could easily have been sold for 55/-, and I am sure that if Fianna Fáil were still in office the farmers would still be receiving that sum, but thanks be to God they have got a fair chance and the £1 increase which they could have got during the whole of the war if the Government had allowed Messrs. Guinness to pay it. Farmers are only too anxious to till provided they get the money but really the only people I know who are anxious for compulsory tillage are the people who are taking conacre. They do not want to pay the price for conacre but want to get it cheap. They will work the land, run out the land and leave it impoverished so that it is not fit for the growing of grass or for tillage.

Farmers are helping the Minister and he should help them to get ample drying facilities for this year. The number of combines coming to my county and all over the country as well has been very large during the past year but you cannot expect the corn from those combines to be in the same condition as corn cut by a reaper and binder and stacked, so you require many more drying facilities.

I trust the Minister will make every possible effort to give the farmers facilities for drying corn and also for storing it. In 1949 we had a very good yield of barley and some farmers had to hold on to it until the December of that year although they had not much storage. Some of them were compelled, not alone to store it in a very bad way, but also to be out of their money for some three months, money which would have been useful to many of them in paying their way. I trust the Minister will do all he can to provide good storage accommodation and drying facilities.

I am very pleased that the Minister has adopted the policy of giving farmers the benefit of world prices. Everybody thought when wool prices went up this year that the Minister would have stepped in and halted that increase so far as this country is concerned. I am very glad he has given a fair chance to our farmers. When the wool prices went up throughout the world our farmers got the benefit of that increase. I wonder did the Government of the day subsidise the farmers when they were selling wool at 2d., 3d. and 4d. a lb.? The farmers then had to put up with low prices and now when the prices have gone up they deserve to get the benefit.

This year turkeys went up to 4/- a lb. and the farmer got the full benefit of that price. In the days of the last Government when turkeys were 2/8 a lb. the then Minister put a levy of 8d. a lb. on the turkeys leaving the country. They imposed that type of tax on the farmers and it was a considerable one when you consider the turkeys on an average would weigh 15 lb.

Comment on this

What did they do with it?

Comment on this

Yes, that is the point.

Comment on this

They subsidised the price of eggs, and well you know it.

Comment on this

The present Minister for Agriculture has given the farmers the full benefit of the increased price for turkeys, and the farmers appreciate that. Likewise with cattle. As a result of the agreement with England our cattle will go up another 10/- a cwt. The Minister will give us the benefit of that too. In that way he is giving our farmers a good chance. As Deputy Harris said, there is money in agriculture. The Minister has put the agricultural industry in that position and we must thank him for it.

As far as lay in his power, he has also given guaranteed prices to the farmers. The farmers have to work in the open; they do not labour in a workshop or any industrial concern. They have to take chances with the weather and also with the prices they get for their crops when they have them harvested. So far as lay in his power, the Minister has given them a guaranteed price for wheat and beet, and now for milk. There is a guarantee of 1/3 a gallon for the next five years, come what may. He is about to arrange a guaranteed price for pigs.

There is one matter I would like to bring to his attention, and that is the present grant for farm buildings. Take a cow house. The grant at the moment is £4 per cow. In a way, that is very small. It was all right a few years ago when building costs were not high, but now, allowing for the increased cost of building, the £4 grant is rather small. For ten cows it would be only £40. A house to accommodate that number of animals would cost £300 to £400. I suggest he should increase that grant.

I will again bring to his notice the need, especially for the coming harvest period, of supplying ample drying facilities for corn. Last year the mills were not able to handle all the corn, and people had to hold it, sometimes for a period of three weeks. The mills could not handle it because of the lack of drying facilities. I trust he will be able to provide better drying facilities and better storage accommodation in the immediate future.

Comment on this

My main purpose in intervening in this debate is to refer to a matter of urgent importance in my constituency and, indeed, generally throughout Connacht. I refer to the hundreds of cattle that are dying from starvation. It is a very serious matter for the people I represent. It is very serious that cattle are dying. They are contracting disease due largely to bad nourishment, to bad hay and fodder, throughout the counties of Galway and Mayo, Roscommon and Leitrim, and in certain parts of Sligo. Something should be done for these people. In some cases their stock have been completely wiped out overnight. The least the Minister can do is to make available interest-free loans, as his predecessor did during the bad year of 1947, when sheep in mountainous areas were lost in the snow.

While I do not propose to blame the Minister for the bad weather, I have no doubt that he would have no hesitation in promising good weather if he thought it suited his book. But this is a matter the Minister got due notice of here, because on 30th November of last year there was a motion tabled, not by Fianna Fáil racketeers, as the Minister calls them, but by different Deputies, including Deputies Cogan, P. O'Reilly, J. Flynn, Cowan, Flanagan and Maguire. That motion read:

"That, in view of the grave danger of a shortage of animal feeding-stuffs in many areas during the coming winter and early spring as a result of the almost complete loss of the hay crop and in order to prevent great suffering to animals and serious loss to farmers, Dáil Éireann requests the Government to take immediate and adequate steps to deal with the situation."

That motion was debated by the House. What was the Minister's attitude and what was his answer to that motion when it was brought before this House and when he was solemnly warned as to what would be the effect at that time of the year on the farmers' stock? A typical example of the Minister's attitude was that all these fears were groundless. He suggested that the motion was put down for a particular purpose. The Minister for Agriculture always finds a particular purpose for any motion put down here for consideration. Let me quote the Minister in that debate. I refer to Volume 123, column 1692, 30th November, 1950. He said:

"What I am trying to do is to arm all those who share my anxiety, lest hard-working small farmers be bluffed or defrauded into throwing stock away, with statistical material to reassure them that there is not the slightest need, that if they hold them to the normal time the price will be good, the demand will be strong, and there is no possibility of a situation arising in which our cattle will die or even be injured."

That was the attitude of the Minister on that occasion to that motion, when he was solemnly warned by Deputies that this very situation of which I am now speaking would arise.

I have received various complaints and other Deputies, particularly Deputies from western areas, have received specific complaints of cattle being wiped out, particularly calving cows, due to bad fodder at this particular time and, as a specific and typical instance of the letters I am receiving, I will read for the House one that I received this morning:

"Dear Mr. Moran,

Mrs. John Kilgallon of Chancery, Turlough, was in with me to-day and informed me that all their stock had died due to the bad winter and bad hay.

Her husband has a small holding at Chancery containing about 17 acres, and owned one four-year-old horse, one cow due to calf, and four other cattle about three or four years old. The whole lot have died and Mr. Ryan, veterinary surgeon, told them that it was due to the bad winter and bad hay. They are now completely destitute and have no way of tilling the land or planting any crops for themselves.

Would you see the Department of Agriculture and find out if there is any possibility of their getting any grant to alleviate their suffering?"

That is a specific instance.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy see the Department?

Comment on this

I have not seen the Department yet but I will go. I would have no business seeing the Department but no doubt Deputy O'Higgins is well got there and possibly may get some grant that there is no provision at law made for, as far as I am aware.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows well that there is a scheme in existence.

Comment on this

What about a bit of order?

Comment on this

The Deputy, apparently, was not prepared to place that information before the Minister.

Comment on this

What is the scheme?

Comment on this

The same as existed in 1947.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Deputy Moran, without interruption, unless he gives way.

Comment on this

I want to get from the Minister, for my own information, and for the information of the Deputies who are interested in this situation, as I am, and for the public, if there is such a scheme whereby people like Mrs. John Kilgallon, of Chancery, Turlough, Castlebar, can be assisted. I am sure the Minister must know that particular area. Is there a scheme whereby, in cases like this, where stock has been completely wiped out due to the bad fodder and due to the fact that the price of feeding stuffs was prohibitive so that people of her type were not in a position to purchase them, even though the cattle were starving, can be assisted? I want to know from the Minister now, before the conclusion of this debate, whether this imaginary scheme mentioned by Deputy O'Higgins is available for people of that kind.

This Mrs. John Kilgallon comes from Chancery, Turlough. It is quite obvious that the Minister paid no attention to the motion here last November and that this woman is put in this position by the Minister for Agriculture. Her whole stock is completely wiped out. That is due to the fact that no attention was paid to the warnings that were given to the Minister in this House and that the Minister's attitude at that time was that there were no possibility of a situation arising in which cattle would die or even be injured due to the bad fodder and the bad hay and it is due, in my opinion, mainly to the fact that the Minister threw overboard his undertakings to the Irish farmer that, while he was Minister for Agriculture, the price of maize would not be increased.

The position of the small people that I am speaking of is that, where the hay was bad, where they had been discouraged to till due to the Minister's policy, and they found themselves in the position that the price of maize and feeding stuffs shot up, they were unable to purchase feeding stuffs to keep their stock alive, and had to let them die. They are dying in Mayo, and this is not one isolated instance.

I only hope that the Minister for Lands, who has listened in particular to this letter and generally to my assurance that I am getting these complaints—possibly the Minister for Lands has also got complaints from our constituency—will prevail on the Minister for Agriculture to come to the aid of these people who, through no fault of their own, find their stock completely wiped out, due to the bad winter we have had and due to the lack of feeding stuffs for their stock.

As far as the Minister's policy generally is concerned, I do not propose to keep the House very long on that. As far as the small farmers in the congested areas that I represent are concerned, what the Minister has done for us can be summarised very easily. The Minister has failed to keep feeding stuffs at a reasonable price so that our people who are accustomed to producing poultry, eggs and pigs, in the West of Ireland, could continue with their ordinary economy. The Minister has succeeded in ruining the poultry industry for us, in ruining the egg industry for us, in ruining the dairy industry for us, in ruining the tillage industry for us, in ruining the bacon industry for us.

Considering the trend of the times, it is a good indication of the position of this country that we have already got Danish butter; that bacon has gone under the counter and eggs are getting scarce. Unless the Minister goes—and Ministers have a habit of disappearing in this House with very little notice in recent times—inside six months, the Dublin housewife will be compelled to fry African eggs with Chinese bacon with Danish butter in her pan. The Minister, by slashing the pig prices, has destroyed the bacon industry. There has been no stability. Pigs were allowed over the Border to-day; they were stopped to-morrow. Prices have been cut down and now we are told there is going to be some kind of agreement whereby the pig will go out on the trotter the same as cattle. If we want to know the reason for that, we have to go back to the Minister's last agreement with the British and it is quite clear to everybody in Ireland who read the recent questions in the British House of Commons what the position is.

Whether we like it or not, all our eggs are now in the British basket, due to the Minister's policy. The position in this country will be that inside six months, one basket will hold all our eggs. We are bound hand and foot by the agreement the Minister has made and it is quite apparent that, irrespective of the price we can get for beef, eggs and bacon, particularly beef. outside the British market, we are forced to go to the British market. At the present time there is a very strong demand for dressed beef in the United States. We are sending over some small sample shipments. The real position is, as we saw by Mr. Webb's answer in the British House of Commons recently, that this country will not be allowed to develop a frozen meat industry here and I do not think that we will be allowed very much to develop a canning industry because the British will insist on keeping us to that unfortunate trade agreement that the Minister made. So that, whether we like it or not, whether the Irish farmer likes it or not, irrespective of world conditions, we find ourselves in the position that our stuff must go to the British whether the price is economic or not.

Comment on this

That is wholly untrue, as the Deputy knows, being himself engaged in the business.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister, when replying, to deal with the answer given by his opposite number in the British House of Commons during the last fortnight.

Comment on this

I was listening outside the door. There is not a syllable of truth in what you are after saying, not a whisper.

Comment on this

The Minister was not here to hear half of what I said. I have no doubt that, no matter what I said, be it the truth or otherwise, the Minister would deny it anyhow. At all events, thanks be to God, the people can read and the people can appreciate what the British Minister said when he assured the British House of Commons that, irrespective of what meat might be canned here or what market might be found for dressed or manufacturing meat in the United States of America, the position of Britain was quite safe with the good agreement he had made with the Minister in this country——

Comment on this

You are trimming your sails now.

Comment on this

——that the amount of meat that could be exported from this country would have to be limited under the agreement. The Minister is in the position, under his own agreement, that he is tied hand and foot to the British market as far as beef exports are concerned, no matter what shape or form that export takes.

Comment on this

That statement is untrue.

Comment on this

The Minister knows and cannot deny—I challenge the Minister to deny—that there is at the present time a profitable market for dressed or manufacturing meat in the United States of America.

Comment on this

In which you are making a good income.

Comment on this

Whether I am making a good income out of it or not, the Minister is getting an excellent income from the Irish taxpayers. I would not mind paying the Minister twice as much if I thought he was worth it. I consider that when the Irish taxpayers' money is wasted in the payment of the Minister for Agriculture, by providing him with his thousands a year and a free car, it is time we should call a halt. If we were getting value for our money, I would not mind, but I do not believe in paying a man if he is not able to do his job.

The Minister has succeeded since he took office in ruining the poultry industry, the egg industry, the dairy industry, the bacon industry and in ruining tillage, and I think then it is about time that the Irish farmer should ask the Minister for a reckoning. Notwithstanding the fact that, as I proved, the Minister was solemnly warned, even by some of his own supporters, here on the 30th November last that cattle would die of starvation, the idea was pooh-poohed by the Minister. He said that no cow would die or even be injured. Notwithstanding the assurance with which the Minister spoke on that occasion that prophecy came true. Although on that occasion Deputy Cogan asked: "Will the cows be able to digest that?" and Deputy Maguire asked: "Will the empty haggard not have an impression on the feeding stuff position?" the Minister was insistent that something would happen to relieve the situation because Deputy James Dillon was Minister for Agriculture, and that, irrespective of good or bad weather, no cattle would starve.

I asked the Minister's colleague when the Minister was outside the House to convey to him the fact that cattle in my constituency and in adjoining constituencies are dying of starvation, that I had got a specific complaint that the stock of a certain farmer had been wiped out and that a local veterinary surgeon had certified that they had died from malnutrition because of the fact that they had not sufficient fodder. I want to ascertain from the Minister now what he is prepared to do in that situation to assist these people to restock their land in view of what he said in his reply to the motion which was debated in this House on the 30th November last. I again ask the Minister to read that statement and to say, when he is cleaning up the job, what he is prepared to do for these people who were misled by the Minister's attitude on that occasion. These people have had their farms denuded of stock because of the fact that they have Deputy James Dillon as Minister for Agriculture.

There is just one other matter to which I should like to refer and I take it that it comes within the ambit of this debate. I want to draw the attention of the House to the fact that certain persons can call themselves agricultural contractors, whether they own a bog, a piece of land or whether they own nothing, and they can come along, I presume under the Minister's direction, to the Agricultural Credit Corporation and can get loans up to £5,000, £6,000 and £7,000 to purchase bulldozers, calf-dozers and all kinds of American machinery without one ounce of security except the machine itself, whereas if a small farmer in the West of Ireland wants to raise £25 from the very same corporation to buy a cow, a cart or a horse, not alone is he supposed to put a mortgage on his farm but in most cases the Agricultural Credit Corporation will insist on two of his neighbours going security for him.

We have these American machines being bought with American dollars, I presume out of Marshall Aid or out of some of the dollar loans we are getting from America, and any chancer can come along to this corporation and without any security except the machine can get up to £7,000 and be handed out one of these machines. What is the security there for the Agricultural Credit Corporation? If any of these gentlemen who calls himself an agricultural contractor comes along to the corporation, gets a loan and purchases one of these machines and works it for six months or 12 months and does not wish to carry on any further, he can say to the corporation: "There is your bulldozer" and the Irish taxpayer will have to pay for it because the only security he has is the second-hand bulldozer. I am not satisfied in the first place that some of the work done by these machines could not be done as well by the many unemployed men we have in the country but, if we are going to make these machines available, I think there should at least be some type of security provided by the person who is to get them. It amounts to a present of these machines under the present system from the Agricultural Credit Corporation, particularly having regard to the fact that the same Agricultural Credit Corporation insists that any small farmer who wants a loan must mortgage his land up to the hilt and supply other securities.

Finally, I want to appeal to the Minister in respect of those people whose stock are being wiped out or whose stock at the moment are dying like flies owing to the shortage of fodder. I think that in view of the Minister's attitude to the motion which was discussed in this House on the 30th November last it is his duty to come to the aid of these people. These people were certainly misled, deliberately or otherwise, by the Minister.

Comment on this

Listening to Deputy Moran one could only conclude that he does not know exactly what he is talking about. With regard to the purchase of bulldozers, I got a form from the Department of Agriculture for a person who is interested in buying one of these machines and on these papers there must be the names of two sureties before the application is considered. In fact I know that the standing of one of the sureties, whose name I sent on, had to be verified. What is the use of misleading the House by saying that one can get one of these machines without security? You definitely must have two sureties. Statements such as that made by Deputy Moran merely show that he does not know what he is talking about. In regard to his picture of the circumstances of the person in Chancery, I do not believe it to be a correct representation of the position. He mentioned that this person apart, from a horse and a cow, had four other cattle about three or four years old. If he was a good farmer he would have sold the younger cattle in order to get the necessary money to provide feeding stuffs for the cow and the horse. Any man who allows an in-calf cow to die of starvation, while he has three or four three-year-old-cattle, deserves very little consideration. In my opinion the whole thing has been manufactured by Deputy Moran himself.

The Deputy also made reference to the agreement we made with England in regard to cattle and he blamed the Minister because so many of our stock had to go to England. We at present can send 10 per cent. of our total exports all over the world, if we decide to do so, but I think it is a very good thing for the farmers of this country that we have a market for 90 per cent. of our cattle in England. The Minister made that agreement in 1948 and he tied the English Government to the extent that no matter what increase in price the English farmer got for his cattle, the Irish farmers must also get the benefit of it. We saw a few weeks ago where the Minister of Agriculture in England stated that Ireland would not get the benefit of the rise that was then given in the price of beef but he forgot about the agreement our Minister made in 1948 which provided that we must get the benefit of any such rise and we got the benefit of that rise last Monday. Other Deputies have also spoken about the fact that we have to send 90 per cent. of our exports of cattle to England but the 10 per cent. which we are allowed to ship elsewhere was, I think I am correct in stating, not fully taken up last year.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

Then we have Deputies talking about this 10 per cent. If we were not allowed to send our cattle to England where would we be? Deputy Moran talked about our being tied hand and foot to the 10 per cent. arrangement, but we cannot get a market in other countries even for that proportion of our exports. What is the use of people who know nothing about these matters talking nonsense? So far as the dead meat trade is concerned, it may have been all right during the emergency to have a dead meat trade but I, as a farmer, am all out against the dead meat trade. I think it was a great blow to the farmers of this country that we ever got into the dead meat trade. People say that with the dead meat trade you would have the offal and the hides.

What is happening with regard to our hides at present? We are getting £2 5s. each for them. The reason is that we are bound by an agreement made by the previous Government with the tanneries. If we were allowed to export them, we would be getting £10 or £12 each for them. That is the danger we will be in if we have a dead meat trade in this country. The tanning factories will be in danger as well. Old men have told me that they are against a dead meat trade here. They remember that when we had tanning factories, a buyer from each went into the market during the first six months or so and they bid against each other. The competition that prevailed made production uneconomic. To overcome that they formed an association and appointed one buyer to make purchases on the market morning. That is the position in which our farmers will find themselves if we have this dead meat trade here. It is useful at present; if we decide to have it the farmers will be at the beck and call of three or four abattoirs or chilled meat factories. I know what I am talking about. What I say happened in South America. My friends and relations were in the dead meat trade there. When someone in the trade got strong enough financially he bought up all the dead meat factories. The result was that the farmers in the Argentine had to get out of cattle raising and start growing maize. That is why so many cattle are not now being raised in the Argentine. The growing of maize has proved more profitable to the farmers there. They can get two or three crops of maize off the land in a year. There are people clamouring for our farmers to go into this dead meat trade. They will rue the day if they do.

I was very much perturbed to hear —I do not know whether it is true or not—that a company was being formed to build a big abattoir or a chilling factory at Finglas. I have been told that no one could be a shareholder in that company unless he put £25,000 into it. There has also been some talk about starting one in Dundalk. I suggest it will be a black day for our farmers if that ever happens. If the cattle trade ever falls into their hands, the result will be the same as it was in the Argentine. You will have one buyer going into the market, and there will be no competition for the cattle which the farmers send in. At present we have no trade except the American trade. We would not have that if it were not for the dollar position. When that position corrects itself, that trade will collapse. We have no European trade except the Dutch trade. We had the French and the Italians coming here for a few years but at the moment the Dutch are the only people who are buying. People say that we made a mistake by keeping only 10 per cent. of our cattle under the agreement. That 10 per cent. was not filled last year.

Comment on this

What was the reason?

Comment on this

Because there was not shipping to take it.

Comment on this

There was not a market. The Belgian people got a quota and they did not fill it. Deputy Cogan spoke about the farmers here being badly off. He spent over an hour in criticising the Minister. If the farmers are not well off, I am of opinion that they should be because they have a market and a price for everything they produce. I know that the farmers in my county are not complaining. As I have said, Deputy Cogan spent an hour criticising the Minister for Agriculture. I want to say that we have never had a Minister for Agriculture like him. Any time he stands up in the County Westmeath, I can guarantee that the farmers there will come out and cheer him.

Comment on this

They are not farmers.

Comment on this

We are not milk and water farmers such as you are. What are we exporting from this country but cattle? I claim that we in the Midlands are the backbone of the country. You people are living on the subsidies that we are providing for you. You are asking for subsidies for this. that and the other. We are providing them. We are standing on our own feet and keeping the country going on what we are exporting. That is the position as regards the Midlands, that the production there forms the backbone of the country.

The boot and shoe factories that we have are all right, but they are costing us £7 for every hide that is retained in the country. We are subsidising your shoes. If the English boot factories had to give £10 each for the hides that we produce they could still sell their boots and shoes here at a cheaper price than the boot factories we have. The position is that we are keeping the country going.

As regards cattle prices, I think that at the present time the English farmer gets for our cattle which go to the English food controller 124/9 per cwt. Our price is fixed at 1/10 a lb. for grade A cattle. The calculation is somewhat complicated but, so far as I can make it out, on that price of 124/9 per cwt. we should be getting something better than 1/10 a lb. I think it should come to 2/- and something less than a farthing. That is a matter which should be looked into. It has also to be taken into consideration that, in addition, the English farmer gets the offals of the beast, which should be worth in or about £10. The Minister, I think, should look into that and see whether, on the figures I have given, we are losing. A lot of people seem to think that we are. There is another matter which the Minister might look into and that is the way the cattle are graded. We are at a disadvantage in that respect. It would be a great advantage to our farmers if, instead of the present arrangement, we could, when sending cattle to Manchester or Glasgow, get them graded at the ports, and so be put in much the same position as the farmers in the North of Ireland who send cattle to the other side.

The Minister and the Government should look into the question of hides. At present the tanneries are paying £2 5s. 0d. each for hides. If the butchers were given 3/- per lb. for the hides it would be a help so as not to increase the price of meat to the consuming public.

The farmers in County Westmeath maintain that the Minister's policy in regard to tillage is the best policy—not to have compulsory tillage —because if you have to compel a farmer to till he is no use to the country. I say honestly that if a farmer does not till a certain amount of his land the land should not be left with him. He is a menace to the country; he is no good to the country. Those farmers who do not follow the Minister's policy of tilling the land and producing all the foodstuffs they want should not be left with the land. Compulsory tillage, however, is no good.

We in Westmeath are going in largely for the Minister's new barley scheme, as Ymer barley is suited to our county. It is a barley which will not fall down. The Minister must be congratulated on introducing that scheme into this country. I know that since farmers in the North of Ireland heard about the Ymer barley they are all clamouring for it. They never heard of it until the Minister for Agriculture brought it in here. It has been a great success. I should also like to ask the Minister when agents will be appointed for Westmeath in connection with the parish plan. Westmeath and a few other counties were the first to fall in with that parish plan and to urge that it should be started.

I heard some Deputies criticise the Minister for advocating the use of tractors as against horses. The Minister said he did not go that far. If he did it, it would be a godsend to the country. Coming up to Dublin a fortnight ago one noticed that nothing had been done on the land. But during the last week there were so many tractors out working that great progress has been made. If the Minister had not advocated the use of tractors, where would we be now? It is a good thing that we have them there. I should like the Minister to tell us when we are going to get the parish agents in Westmeath because we are waiting anxiously for them. I hope he will also look into the other matters which I have mentioned.

Comment on this

When talking about tillage, Deputy Fagan suggested to the Minister that farmers who would not till their land should have the land taken from them.

Comment on this

I stand by that.

Comment on this

I agree with him.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will take note of that and that he will tell us whether he and the Government agree with that policy. It seems to be the policy of the Coalition that if a farmer will not till his land the land should be taken from him. Fianna Fáil have been accused of having compulsory tillage during a time of emergency, but they have never gone as far as that—to dispossess farmers of land. The Minister has issued a White Paper giving some statistics as to the estimated produce of crops and some interesting facts are revealed by these estimates. We find that we had a decrease of 500,000 acres in tillage last year compared with three years ago when the Minister took office. In February, 1951, when in a normal year most farmers would have a good proportion of the land prepared for tillage, for the first time the Minister woke up to the fact that tillage was necessary in this country this year. It is unfortunate that at present, with an emergency looming in the distance, the present Minister for Agriculture should hold that portfolio. From the time he entered this House up to the present day the country has been aware of the Minister's hostility to tillage. Time and time again all down the years he has shown his hostility to tillage crops. In office and out of office, he has advised farmers that they were using their land in a wrong way by growing tillage crops. Therefore, it is unfortunate that the Minister occupies that post at present, because an appeal to the farmers to produce more tillage crops would produce a ready response. The farmers are no fools and they appreciate the dangers that lie ahead in this country. But there is no use in the present Minister for Agriculture making that request to them because he has so often in the past suggested to them that they were fools to be growing any tillage crops. In three years he has succeeded admirably in reducing the land under tillage by 500,000 acres.

Comment on this

There is more land under tillage now than in 1939.

Comment on this

There is a great difference between 1939 and the present day. There is more of an emergency at present than in 1939 or 1940.

Comment on this

Where are your brains?

Comment on this

There is far more of an emergency because materials are much more scarce and food is much more scarce in the world to-day than in 1939, and the Minister knows that. He is aware that in parts of Asia there are millions of people on the verge of starvation. He is aware also that the estimates are that the American wheat crop will not be a great success.

Comment on this

As the wheat crop is not yet sown, I do not know how the Deputy makes that estimate.

Comment on this

The estimates are that the winter wheat there is almost a total failure.

Comment on this

Is not that the Minister's excuse for asking farmers here to grow wheat?

Comment on this

The Minister is aware of that. It was only in February, 1951, that he asked farmers to increase their area under tillage crops this year. He did it in the most peculiar way. It was not done through the usual Government information service. It appeared as an exclusive interview given by the Minister to the Sunday Independent about the first week in February. In that interview it was stated by the Minister for Agriculture that the nation needed more tillage crops this year. In the following weeks that was accompanied by a nasty type of threat to the farmers to the effect that if they did not till more this year, they would have compulsory tillage next year.

Comment on this

It was a temptation to them not to grow anything.

Comment on this

He, the Minister for Agriculture, as a free man would never occupy and sit in the seat of the Minister for Agriculture and bring compulsory tillage into operation here; that was the suggestion to the farmers —that they need not grow it while the present Minister for Agriculture held office.

Comment on this

And Deputy Allen says that is a terrible threat.

Comment on this

It was a temptation not to grow anything.

Comment on this

That is not what Deputy Allen thinks. He thinks it was a most dreadful threat.

Comment on this

In one way he asked them to till but, in another way, he told them that so long as he remained Minister for Agriculture there would never be compulsory tillage. Deputy Fagan says that if they do not till the land should be taken from them. We know to-day that even in the dreadful days of the emergency the cereals position was never so serious. Next winter there will be food for neither man nor beast. During the last two years we have had great boasting from the Minister of the marvellous increase in the cattle population; he said it was never so high in the history of the country. The peculiar fact is that after three years the cattle population has increased by only 250,000; sheep have increased slightly over 250,000. The Minister at one time intended to double and treble the pig population; to-day it has increased by 88,000.

Comment on this

Where did you get those figures?

Comment on this

They were published in the White Paper.

Comment on this

They were not.

Comment on this

They were. I will give the Minister the particulars. In the 1951 Live Stock Enumeration (January Census) there is a total——

Comment on this

Of live stock, now— cattle.

Comment on this

Pigs: 530,000, including sows for breeding, 59,000.

Comment on this

As against 369,000 in January, 1948.

Comment on this

In January, 1947. I am taking the two outside columns of this document issued by the Minister.

Comment on this

Take the column when you handed it over to me. Take 1948, when I took office.

Comment on this

In January, 1947, there were 454,000; in January, 1951, there were 530,000.

Comment on this

There was another year of Fianna Fáil blight on them.

Comment on this

An increase of 89,000.

Comment on this

Look at January, 1948, when you handed it over to me.

Comment on this

It is peculiar also that we have 1,000,000 less poultry to-day than we had in 1947.

Comment on this

Why do you not take January, 1948, when you handed it over to me?

Comment on this

It is really most extraordinary. The Minister has persisted in taking 1947 as the yardstick by which to measure everything that has happened here for many years. He uses it as the yardstick in relation to wheat production and compares the yield in that year with the yields in 1948, 1949 and 1950. That is the only comparison ever made by the Minister.

Comment on this

But you do not save wheat in January. You do not cut wheat in January.

Comment on this

Would the Minister stay quiet now and we will get on better. After three and a half years of this heaven-sent Minister for Agriculture we have not yet brought our agricultural output up to what it was pre-emergency.

Comment on this

We have.

Comment on this

In many directions we have not.

Comment on this

We have.

Comment on this

In many directions we have not.

Comment on this

In what directions?

Comment on this

We have succeeded in reducing the tillage by 500,000 acres.

Comment on this

But we have increased the yield.

Comment on this

We have an increase in grass.

Comment on this

We have increased the tillage yield.

Comment on this

The Minister has not increased the yields. The average yields of wheat in the three years were roughly 17 cwt. per acre.

Comment on this

We got more wheat out of 366,000 acres in 1950 than we got out of 579,000 acres in 1947.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is the Minister for Agriculture conducting a dialogue? I thought he had already spoken in this debate. Every sentence uttered by Deputy Allen is interlarded with a silly interjection from the Minister.

Comment on this

It is deliberate misrepresentation.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee has not improved the situation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Whatever may be thought about Deputy Allen's statements by the Government Deputies, he is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Even from Deputy MacEntee.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

In the three years 1937, 1938 and 1939 the average yield of wheat per acre was roughly 19 cwt. If the Minister looks at the returns he will see that. I am sure he will have no trouble in getting them. He probably has them on his desk or somewhere convenient to his right hand. The wheat yields in the three famous years 1948, 1949 and 1950 were roughly 17 cwt. per acre. The Minister has nothing whatever to boast about. For the sake of accurate statistics in the future I hope that the famine year of 1947 will be omitted. When the Minister is talking about increasing yields in future he can leave out that year. He can compare the yields with any other year Fianna Fáil were in office. We will then be quite satisfied.

Tillage has been reduced by 500,000 acres. Pigs, cattle and sheep have increased by very little, unfortunately for the country. In appealing to the farmers now to increase their tillage the Minister has spent a considerable sum of money since last February in advertisements. For the first six or seven weeks wheat and beet were scarcely mentioned. In the last two or three weeks, after someone kicked the Minister in the pants——

Comment on this

Figuratively speaking.

Comment on this

——he has put wheat and beet at the head of the list. Food for human beings now takes pride of place and food for animals follows after. That is as it should have been originally. The Minister should not insult the farmers by asking them to provide for their animals before asking them to provide for human beings. We hope the Minister will not again commit the unpardonable offence of calling on the farmers to utilise their land for the provision of foodstuffs for their animals before they make provision for human beings. We hope that will never happen again.

Farmers throughout the country are perturbed at the present time because the Minister failed to provide out of Marshall Aid a subsidy for the purpose of cheapening the price of artificial manures. They hold that a large part of the moneys being spent on the land rehabilitation would have given a better return to the nation as a whole if it had been used for the purpose of bringing down the price of artificial manures.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not like that scheme?

Comment on this

Some of that money should have been earmarked for that purpose. This Party has consistently advocated over the past three years, since the money became available, that some of it should be used to subsidise artificial manures and pay the carriage on ground limestone to the farmer's yard. After three years' agitation and thanks to the E.C.A. representative here, Dr. Millar, who first announced it at a meeting in the Shelbourne Hotel saying he had offered the Minister about $5,000,000 and suggested that some of it be used over a five-year period to reduce the price of lime to farmers, the Minister accepted that and the farmers are well satisfied with that scheme. They are not at all satisfied because a further portion of the money is not being spent to reduce the price of artificial manures, which are beyond their reach in sufficient quantities to increase their output. We hope that in time, as a result of slogging and pressure on the Minister, he will suggest to the E.C.A. that it would be a good way to spend portion of the money. It will be still more than the Minister would spend over many years on rehabilitation, land drainage and so on. It is all important that tillage crops this year would be the largest ever. I am afraid they will not.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants me to go begging to the E.C.A. for money for fertilisers for the farmers of this country?

Comment on this

The Minister is not begging anything. The money is available for investment in Irish agriculture and if there were a wise Minister sitting there three years ago he would have succeeded in getting portion of the E.C.A. funds to reduce the price of fertilisers, knowing that it would have given good results.

The price of milk has been a burning question for some months. Efforts have been made by the farmer, by pressure, by deputation and otherwise, to persuade the Minister to provide an increased price for milk sold in towns for human consumption and for milk delivered to creameries. The pressure has succeeded to the extent of a 1d. per gallon—one-eighth of a penny per pint. That is the increase farmers will get over last year, for the summer period only. It will amount to 30/- per cow on the average. Surely farmers' costs have gone up much more than 30/- per cow. A farmer who keeps a dozen cows finds his expenses increased more than £18. If he keeps 25, they have gone up much more than the 30/-. That increase of a 1d. is the only return the Minister will give the farmers to cover expenses, cost of labour, machinery, bindertwine, manure, feeding stuffs and maintenance of machinery, and to pay his own personal cost of living and that of his family, which has gone up for every section of the community. For that fundamental item the Minister has failed to get an economic price. We do not know what could be done about it, but sitting behind him is a group calling themselves farmers' representatives, Clann na Talmhan, the men of the land——

Comment on this

What do you call them?

Comment on this

I call them a pack of duds, nonentities, yesmen, who have failed to get anything from the Government but two tokens of appreciation for services rendered, in the form of the Minister for Lands and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should get on with the estimate and the reference back.

Comment on this

The farmers' representatives joined with the Coalition to keep it in office and that is all the service they have rendered to the agricultural community. If they had been as active as their colleagues in the Labour Party——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is the activities of the Minister for Agriculture that are being discussed now.

Comment on this

Yes, but I can refer also to those who keep him in office.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That would make the estimate very long.

Comment on this

I bow to your ruling, but I think I am entitled to refer to those who keep the Minister in office. It is all-important on this occasion to realise that he is kept in office by a group.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not going to discuss any group.

Comment on this

Where ignorance is bliss, 'tis folly to be wise.

Comment on this

We hope that the Minister, at this late hour, before the 1st May, when milk production increases from that on for a few months of the year, will alter his present decision and do justice to the farming community by giving them an economic price. It is all-important that they be not forced, as they are being forced at the present time, unfortunately, to put calves on cows. It is unfortunately a growing practice to put two or three calves on a cow and turn them out in the fields. They are making a six-day week out of dairying. They have found a way of having cows and having a six-day working week, by turning the calves out in the fields with the cows. That is a growing practice and a most undesirable one. If any collapse comes in the price of cattle, that practice will pay very bad dividends to the country.

There is another type of butter, home-made or farmers' butter, of which about 500,000 cwt. is produced each year. I want the Minister to pay particular attention to what I am going to say, as it is important in the present year. Farmers in the non-creamery areas are putting the calves to milk the cows and not making but ter any more. The farmers' butter that would ordinarily be made will become an important factor this year in the amount available for home consumption in this country. As things look at the moment, the Minister may find that before next winter he is much more short of butter, even the ration, than in the present winter. If he does not take advantage of farmers' butter by utilising it during the months of peak production for the off-the-ration butter, he may be in difficulties.

I suggest in all seriousness that he has a duty to provide an economic living for producers of farmers' butter, just as in the case of creamery butter, to keep up production, as he will need it this year much more than previously in order to fill the ration. I suggest that during the peak months he should not allow off-the-ration creamery butter to be put on the market and should compel the people who need off-the-ration butter to buy farmers' butter during that period. He must fix a fair price, something comparable to what a creamery supplier is getting for his butter at present. It is only fair that, if he is not prepared to provide a subsidy, he should at least provide the market, retaining the home market for that butter at a certain period of the year. That will give more creamery butter for the ration during the coming winter. If he does not do that and farmers' butter has to be sold this year at 1/6 a lb., as it was last year, he will be needing 50,000 tons of Danish butter next winter. Enough has been said to convince the Minister that he is dealing unjustly with the farmers.

Pigs and bacon have been discussed and the Minister has adverted to them in his White Paper. He says he hopes to make a permanent long-term agreement with Britain soon for 220/- exfarm, dead weight.

Comment on this

Is not that what the Wexford County Committee asked me for?

Comment on this

They did not ask you for it. You told them.

Comment on this

There was a resolution on the agenda asking for 168/- a cwt. live weight for pigs.

Comment on this

I never saw it. It was not on the agenda that I saw.

Comment on this

God forgive you.

Comment on this

I say that 220/- a cwt. will be no encouragement to the farmers to increase pig production, at the present price of cereals, pig meals and so on.

Comment on this

What is the present price of pig meal?

Comment on this

The Minister gets the returns every Monday morning in his office from all the agricultural instructors, as to the price of pig meals and so on in the principal towns. It would be in the Taoiseach's office or the Minister's office and he would have no trouble in getting it if he asks for it. In making this agreement, has the Minister considered what way it may affect the bacon necessary for home consumption. Is he aware that we have little, if any, over our present needs, that we have no surplus bacon to export? He must be aware of that. Does this proposed agreement mean that live pigs will be sent out? The country would like some enlightenment on that. The workers employed in the bacon factories would like to know if their interests are being safeguarded? Is the Minister safeguarding in this agreement the interests of the people generally, those who have sunk their capital in the bacon factories, and the other interests concerned?

The question that occurs to most people is as to the necessity for making any agreement. In May and June last year, the Deputies asked the Minister: "Why not open the Border for the export of pigs?" and he answered Deputy Maguire and Deputy Smith that owing to an arrangement with Britain he could not take any such action, and he said there were only two points where pigs could be exported from this country—I think they were Manchester and Liverpool. Then, without notice to anyone, on a certain date last October, the Border was thrown open to the free export of pigs. We had races from Kerry, Cork, Waterford and the farthest points from the Border, every lorry being pressed into service, to send not alone the suckers across the Border but the fat pigs also, at 285/- a cwt. The Minister has at this moment a ready-made way of getting an increased price for pigs, with one stroke of the pen. He can open the Border, as he did last October, and allow free export. We on this side do not think that is desirable, but instead of the tedious negotiations since last April twelve months about the price of pigs, the Minister can as he did last October open the Border by a stroke of the pen and get 285/- instead of 220/-. Why does he not do that? Who advised him last October to open the Border without notice to the trade, to the bacon factories, to the producers or anyone else? He kept it open for three weeks and the only result was that the farmers got an increased price during that period, but the unfortunate consumers of bacon in the towns and cities had to pay up to 8d. per lb. more than they should be asked to pay. The price of pigs will go up and down week after week, £1, 30/- or £2 a cwt. Farmers do not know where they are with the result that they are, unfortunately, generally getting out of keeping sows in many parts of the country.

While we have the type of policy that was operated in the matter of pigs by the Minister for Agriculture, the pig population will not increase in the country. We find ourselves now, this Minister having been in office three years, almost where we were at the end of the emergency, with plenty of maize and plenty of cereals of all kinds to feed pigs. He flooded the country with maize in the first year of his office. He was going to double and treble the number of pigs in the country but he has not succeeded in doing so. The country has to pay dearly for maize at the present time, not for exporting bacon, but for the simple purpose of keeping bacon available for the Irish people. Under the Minister's tillage policy, it became necessary, in order that our people would have bacon, to import maize from the ends of the earth at a huge price in dollars. Eggs are a commodity that are unpopular with the Minister at the present time. He does not like to hear anything mentioned at all about eggs or the price of eggs.

Comment on this

What about the dual-purpose hen?

Comment on this

As late as 1949, the Minister addressed a meeting of the Irish Countrywomen's Association in the Shelbourne Hotel. The Minister for Agriculture appeared in a photograph in the daily papers the following day holding a countrywoman's basket of eggs in his hands and he made a pronouncement. "I stand or fall by this," said James Dillon, Minister for Agriculture, with the basketful of eggs in his hand. We wonder that the Minister has not fallen by now, because the price of eggs has fallen and the Irish housewife has gone out of producing eggs and is going out of doing so very fast. We wonder why the Minister for Agriculture lost quite suddenly his negotiating ability with his opposite number or the Minister of Food in England. He went over to England in 1948 with a great flourish of trumpets. He told the British then that he was going to drown them in eggs. I am afraid the drowning is over and the British need no longer fear being drowned by the Minister for Agriculture of the Irish Republic because we are scarcely producing enough eggs in the present year to supply our own needs. Egg production is falling and falling very considerably because of the Minister's failure, as Minister for Agriculture, to negotiate with his opposite number or the Minister of Food in Great Britain an economic price for eggs.

The Minister was going to provide maize. He was Minister for maize. He declared on one occasion: "While I am Minister for Agriculture, I am also Minister for maize and I am going to see to it that the price of maize will not increase beyond 20/- a cwt. in this country." The retail price of maize has now reached the figure of 38/- a cwt.

Comment on this

It is not maize.

Comment on this

It is not maize. It is a bastard maize called milo maize. "Sell every egg to the eggler." That was his slogan at one time. Now he is going to give the British no more eggs and he is not prepared to subsidise the export of eggs from this country. He is not going to pay the British to eat our eggs and he is not going to give an economic price to our Irish producers to produce those eggs.

What advice is the Minister giving to the farmers of this country? What help can he give them with regard to the live stock in the coming winter? What are the indications as to what will be available from the root crops? Will it be sufficient to maintain the present live stock and the cattle that may be on farmers' hands next November? Would it not be wise for the Minister for Agriculture to advise farmers, who have cattle fit for marketing, to market them early this year and reduce the number of cattle that a farmer must carry over next winter? We have a good hay crop.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

Under sub-head M (11)— Land Rehabilitation Project and Water Supplies—we notice that the number of officers employed in the Minister's Department has increased from 305 last year to 427. I would like the Minister to give us some information, when he is replying, of the necessity for increasing the number of administrative officers in his Department for this purpose. It is quite evident from the figures given in the sub-heads that the farmers are getting a very small proportion of this £40,000,000 that is being spent. In the first instance, of the £275,870 for officers of this branch of his Department, travelling expenses are estimated this year to be £75,000. The amount in respect of purchase of machinery and implements is £153,500, and for grants towards the purchase of machinery and equipments, £60,000. Lime fertilisers amount to £778,000, while grants to farmers are £475,000 only. Less than £500,000 of this sum of £2,500,000 goes direct to the farmers. The figure for materials for drains and fencing is £160,000 and payments to contractors, of whom I am sure very few are farmers, £375,000.

I should like to challenge the item of £8,000 in respect of advertising and publicity. After three years of the operation of the scheme, it is time the Minister saved on that sub-head. Surely the scheme has got enough publicity, and, if the project is in operation in a particular county, the farmers in neighbouring counties will be able to decide whether they should apply or not, and the Minister should cease spending money on such publicity and advertising at this stage. The amount in respect of payments to the Office of Public Works is £26,500, and for water supply schemes, £100,000. I am not objecting to that, but I suggest that, although the Minister and his colleagues make propaganda with the suggestion that the farmers are to get £40,000,000 under the land rehabilitation scheme, not one-tenth of that money will ever give any service whatever to the farmers. It will be spent on officers, on travelling expenses, and on large purchases of machinery. We have spent over £500,000 on machinery already—I suppose these machines are necessary—and we are to spend this year £153,000 more. I suppose that individual farmers in many instances are getting service from this scheme, but many people seriously doubt whether it is justifiable to spend the large sums which are being spent from this borrowed money in the direction in which they are being spent. Ninety-nine per cent. of the farmers will reap no benefit whatever from them, and they will not increase agricultural output over the next 50 years by one-eighth of 1 per cent.

It is about time that Deputies sitting behind the Minister, who are responsible for the expenditure of this money, paid some attention to the manner in which it is being expended. They can easily satisfy themselves that it will not return to agriculture the benefits, or anything like the benefits, they claim for it. The overall increase in output as a result of the spending of this money in this way will be very small, if it adds anything to the total moiety of agricultural produce. The Minister would be well advised even at this late stage to set aside a portion of this money for subsidising the price of artificial manures. It would give a much better overall service to the farmers than its expenditure in the direction in which it is being spent.

I should like to know if the Minister is satisfied that too many horses are being exported from this country. It is an important matter. Many people are perturbed by the fact that farmers have ceased to breed the working type of horse. These horses have been replaced in use by tractors, but, if anything were to happen, if, say, Deputy Dunne were able, in the month of April, to organise those who deliver petrol and so prevent the delivery of petrol to farmers, these tractors would cease to run. That could happen any year, and it is possible that we could waken up, when the season for sowing crops was over—it is only a matter of two or three weeks in the year—and find that we had missed the tide because there were no petrol supplies to run the tractors. We all hope it will not happen, but a major emergency could come on the world and, in such circumstances, no petrol supplies would be available and we would find ourselves in a position different from that in which we found ourselves when the last emergency began, with neither tractors nor horses. It is something which the Minister and the Government should always keep in mind as a long-term policy for the safeguarding of the interest of the nation under all conditions. It is doubtful if it is a wise policy on the part of the Minister to allow all the horses of the country to be exported, for human consumption probably, in some continental countries. He should indicate to the farmers that their long-term interest and the long-term interest of the nation is the maintenance of the horse population to the extent of safety.

Comment on this

And export the asses.

Comment on this

You would be gone long ago.

Comment on this

We all know who would be in the first consignment. But this is no joke and the Minister should pay heed to the fact that we are on the danger line at present in the matter of the number of horses we have.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy prohibit the export of horses?

Comment on this

I want the Minister to take serious note of it.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this

I want him to take serious note of the fact that horses are not being bred.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this

I am suggesting that the Minister, as a member of a Government who should have the interest of the country as their primary consideration, should indicate to the farmers that it is in the interests of the nation that they should continue——

Comment on this

This is very lucid advice.

Comment on this

——to breed horses and not allow the working horse population to be eliminated completely. These horses may be required—they are required in fairly large numbers still—and in the light of the possibility of an emergency, in the light of a possible hold-up of petrol supplies during the sowing season or some similar circumstances, it is absolutely necessary that the horse population be maintained at least to the degree of safety. It is the duty of the Minister to indicate to the farmers what, in his opinion, is the soundest and safest line for the country to take. A great number of farmers went out this spring to buy working horses but they found that they were not available at the markets, fairs or any place else. For the past two months people have been coming to me and mentioning the fact that they have difficulty in getting working horses. They are reaching the stage now where they are expressing fears about the position.

Comment on this

God knows, any man who would buy a farm horse in April is a fool.

Comment on this

They were not available in April or in March.

Comment on this

I suppose that if he went to buy an umbrella in a rainstorm there would be a shortage too.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will give his attention to the matters which I have mentioned—the price of milk, the price of farmers' butter, the price of pigs, whether his policy in exporting live pigs is wise, and the maintenance of sufficient supplies to keep the factories going in this country. The Minister has a different outlook on the matter of tillage from that which is held by many people. I do not think I mentioned the price of wheat. In April, 1951, when, in the ordinary course of events, nine-tenths of the wheat would be sown——

Comment on this

And was not.

Comment on this

——and was not, unfortunately, the Minister indicated that the guaranteed price for wheat of the 1951 crop, in certain conditions, be increased by 5/- a barrel. I am afraid that the higher bushel rate which is necessary in order to obtain the increased price is very seldom reached. The Minister knows that, too.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

The increased price of 5/- a barrel could have been announced, without conditions, on 1st April this year because it is an emergency year. There should not be any conditions whatsoever. Does the Minister want to encourage the farmers to keep their wheat in stack until the spring of the year and not to thresh it until then? If so, he should have offered them an increase of more than 5/- a barrel. He should have indicated that it would be in the national interest if farmers did not thresh their wheat until the spring and he should have given more than an increase of 5/- to farmers who deliver wheat to the mills from February onwards. We must bear in mind that we have not storage accommodation or extra drying facilities for the very many farmers whose wheat is threshed by combine harvesters. We shall find this year that matters will work out the same as last year. We shall find that the mills will refuse to take wheat that has been threshed by combines and the farmers will be at their wits' end to know what to do with the bags of damp wheat that was threshed all in the one day. We know that scarcely anything has been done to provide extra drying facilities to cope with the increased number of combine harvesters that have come into the country and that will harvest the corn this year. It is all important, even at this late stage, that the Minister should see to it that a sufficient number of drying plants are made available to farmers next August and next September to dry their corn which has been harvested by combine harvesters. If he does not do so, a crisis may arise and much of our valuable cereals may be lost just for the want of drying plants. We in the corn growing areas —in Wexford, Kilkenny, Cork and so on—know that nothing whatsoever has been done since last year and even the year before that to increase the drying facilities that will be required next autumn.

In conclusion, I appeal to the Minister to give immediate consideration to all the agricultural matters which need his immediate help and assistance.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present. House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

On this Estimate we have heard a great deal from the Deputies on the benches opposite which, I am afraid for them, will in the years ahead, when the remarks they have made will be quoted against them and when they are there on the record for all time, cause them to be sorry that they gave forth the stupid sentences which they have uttered in the past three days.

Comment on this

What about all that James did?

Comment on this

We heard Deputy Corry. We could not help hearing him, unfortunately. Deputy Corry started off on this Estimate as if he was going to have a field day, and as if we were going to get the type of four hours' speech to which we have become accustomed to hear from him in the past two years on this Estimate. Then suddenly he realised that he was on very weak ground, and he threw in his hand on the second day.

Deputy Corry must have a very short memory. He must think that the farmers of this country have a very short memory. He spoke about barley—but we all remember what his Government did to the farmers, when they were in power, and particularly in regard to barley. South Kildare, which I have the honour to represent, is a barley-growing district. The farmers there are not as stupid or as forgetful as the Deputy tries to imagine that they are. When Fianna Fáil were in office we know that the price of barley was deliberately depressed: we know that the farmers were allowed to be paid only 35/- a barrel for their barley while Messrs. Guinness were willing and prepared to pay 70/-, and that they did pay it to the English farmers. We can remember the time when the Fianna Fáil Government were requested to allow that money to go into the pockets of the Irish barley growers in South Kildare—and we can remember that Deputy Corry trotted up those steps there to ensure that Irish farmers would not get that higher price which they could have got for their malting barley. Deputy Corry must think that the farmers of this country are all fools, that they have no memories, and that they do not remember these happenings—or else Deputy Corry must hope that they do not remember them. The fact is that the farmers remember very well the treatment which they received from the Fianna Fáil Government. They have reason to be thankful now for what they are getting from this Government and for what they will get from this Government in the months and in the years that lie ahead.

I move to report progress.

Comment on this