We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Defence Bill, 1949—Second Stage.

Contributions 109–224 of 224. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Defence Bill 1949
Lapsed

No. 43 of 1949 ›

I asked him to stand over these charges when he was on his feet.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am going for the figures.

Comment on this

I knew he would run.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am going for the figures.

Comment on this

I knew he would run.

Comment on this

You chased him.

Comment on this

The position is that when the inter-Party Government came into office on the 18th February, 1948, the Book of Estimates for that year was already prepared. It was a Book of Estimates which, if the previous Government were doing their duty, had been vetted, and meticulously vetted, by the then Minister for Defence, Deputy Oscar Traynor.

Comment on this

His father's voice.

Comment on this

It is quite true.

Comment on this

At any rate, it is not a case of "his master's voice," which we heard so often. The fact of the matter is that, if the Deputy who was then Minister for Defence was doing his duty — and I am not going to make the charge against him that he was not — he would have gone very thoroughly into the Book of Estimates which was prepared before this Government took office. That Book of Estimates provided for a particular establishment. It did more than that. It provided for the amount of money which would be voted by this House to maintain the Army for the year under discussion.

Comment on this

Did it provide for 12,500?

Comment on this

What was the position? I refer the Deputy to pages 377 and 378 of the Book of Estimates for the year 1948-49. On page 377 the cost of 1,090 officers was given at something over £400,000. On the same page provision was then made for deducting a certain figure from that, on the basis that the sum was not going to be used, because the Government had decided that the full establishment was not required.

Comment on this

On the basis that we would not get the personnel.

Comment on this

On the basis that there would be fewer than the establishment in officers. Is not that the truth of the matter and will Deputy Oscar Traynor or Deputy de Valera have the gall to deny their written record, which they left behind them?

Comment on this

A Chinn Chomhairle, I think the Deputy, if he starts to quote the Estimates, ought to quote the peace-time figure, which was 12,500.

Comment on this

I do not know whether Deputy Traynor is being honest about this matter or whether——

Comment on this

We are dishonest and saboteurs and everything else the Deputy likes to call us.

Comment on this

The fact of the matter is that you had in the Book of Estimates for 1948-49, first of all, provision made for a maximum establishment of——

Comment on this

12,500.

Comment on this

——of 1,090 officers who were to cost this State in that year £428,000 odd. You then had provision made for deducting £67,000 because the Government had decided that the full establishment was not required and not going to be filled.

Comment on this

Not possible to secure.

Comment on this

That was a reduction of in or about one-seventh of the total. In other words, what they actually provided for was, not 1,090 officers, but 920 officers.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

All ranks.

Comment on this

On page 378 of that Book of Estimates, we find that in N. C. O. s and men the full establishment was to cost something over £1,170,000, which provided for 10,980 N. C. O. s and men and then a reduction was made under this heading also of more than £300,000 because, again, the Government were not going for the full establishment figure; they were going for something considerably less. Instead of a total of 10,000 or 11,000 men, in fact what they planned for, what they asked this Dáil to provide, and the only sanction which they proposed getting from the Dáil, was for an Army in the region of 8,000 men, not 10,000 or 11,000 men.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

According to your own Minister, Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, it was 9,000 men. Your figure is wrong, according to your own Minister. I shall get the quotation for you.

Comment on this

I am waiting. I hope the Deputy does not quit again too quickly.

Comment on this

You know more about quitting than he does.

Comment on this

The Deputy must have mixed his briefs again. However, that was the position in 1948-49 — the year after Fianna Fáil had prepared their Estimates and then relinquished office. They proposed an Army of N. C. O.s and men to the number approximately of 8,000 and 920 officers. Despite the fact that that written record is there, on pages 377-8 of the Book of Estimates for the year 1948-49, we have had Deputy Traynor, possibly through ignorance, Deputy de Valera, Senior, and Deputy de Valera, Junior, ranting around this country that the Fianna Fáil plan was for a bigger Army, that Fianna Fáil kept us out of the war and that this new Government were letting defence go by the board. Nothing is further from the truth. I believe each of the three Deputies I have named, two of them at any rate experienced parliamentarians, are capable of reading the Book of Estimates. They knew very well what the position was. Although the former Minister for Defence of the inter-Party Government drew Deputy Traynor's attention and the attention of Deputy Eamon de Valera to the mistakes they were making, I have yet to hear either of these Deputies having the grace to acknowledge that they were wrong or, in the words of another Deputy, that they were caught out.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Would the Deputy mind if I give him the quotation now? It is from column 716, Volume 110. This is a quotation from the then Minister for Defence:

"The peace establishment is 15,500. The number estimated is 10,570. Subtract the Construction Corps from that. The number in the bigger estimate was 9,600; the actual strength in January and February last was 8,672."

I then interjected: "All ranks?" and the Minister went on:

"Yes. The strength I am budgeting for is approximately 8,500 without any Construction Corps or 100 Construction Corps taken into account."

That is the quotation. We budgeted for a definite strength to build up to and you budgeted below strength and the strength has fallen since. These are the figures.

Comment on this

The figures are set out in the Book of Estimates.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

This quotation was from the speech of Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, Minister for Defence, on the Estimates.

Comment on this

The fact of the matter is that the Deputy cannot alter the Estimates.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

You were budgeting for an Army——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Higgins should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Read the Estimates.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Higgins is in possession and should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Deputy de Valera has spent three years and four months trying to alter the Book of Estimates which Deputy Traynor prepared before he left office. He is not going to get away with that. He might get away with it behind the closed doors of a Fianna Fáil cumann or at a meeting of the Comhairle Ceanntair somewhere in Dublin North-Central, or he may drift into Dublin North-East to give Deputy Traynor a hand. He might be able to get away with it in some such circumstances but when he is brought face to face with the Book of Estimates, prepared by Deputy Traynor, giving the maximum establishment and giving the deductions made in the year 1948-49, because Fianna Fáil planned a smaller Army——

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is simply not true.

Comment on this

These are the facts.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Deputy admits it would take some years to build up the various establishments to the Fianna Fáil number.

Comment on this

I have been in this House a much shorter time than Deputy Major de Valera but I am in it long enough to know that the Army draws its pay from funds provided on the basis of the Estimates presented to this House and not a penny more than that. If the Government comes in here and asks the Dáil to vote a particular sum for the Army, that sum and no more is spent.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy ever hear of a Supplementary Estimate?

Comment on this

Deputy Traynor planned, before he was put out of office, to come in here and ask the Dáil to provide him with the amount of money set out in the Book of Estimates for the year 1948-49. No one in his sane senses can deny that. Deputy de Valera may be trying to deny it but I would not grant that he is in his sane senses if he does. However, once Deputy de Valera gets on to this particular line it is just as well to examine it. It is just as well to see what are the respective records of Fianna Fáil and the present Government in relation generally to the question of national preparedness.

Fianna Fáil came in as a Government in the year 1932. There was a world war in the year 1939, seven years later. Let us examine the position which existed in 1939. Let us ask some questions with regard to the in-flow of materials, the availability of equipment, the efforts made, and whether the efforts were successful or not, to get material and equipment for the Army in the year 1939. Whatever can be said about the present international situation, Deputy de Valera and a number of his colleagues have spent three years prophesying what the future holds; they have set themselves up inside this House and outside it as people closely in touch with the international situation who are able to give an accurate forecast but they were in a much better position to do that prior to the year 1939. They were then members of a Government with diplomatic representation abroad, with military advice available to the Government. They were members of a Commonwealth of Nations which had military attachés, for practical purposes, all over the world, and they had available to them the advice of these attachés. In the year 1939 — I challenge contradiction on this — the permanent force which Deputy Aiken — I think it was he was responsible at the time — provided for gave this country something slightly over 7,000 of a personnel.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Somewhere about 7,500 on mobilisation. It went up during the year.

Comment on this

The position was that it was something over 7,000.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Practically the same as it is at the moment.

Comment on this

There is a very great difference and Deputy de Valera, if he is honest, knows it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It was quite inadequate and we admit that. We are honest enough to say that we could not get through with it were it not for a good Providence.

Comment on this

No, the cry was that "Dev" kept us out of the war.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Anybody in that situation will appreciate how fortunate we were to have an opportunity of learning from these lessons. That is why we are pressing you now to learn from them.

Comment on this

I am very glad to hear that statement being made.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Even that position was inadequate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair would like to hear Deputy O'Higgins without interruption.

Comment on this

However, that was the position of the permanent force after seven years of Fianna Fáil Government, seven years when Fianna Fáil Ministers had sources of information available to them, seven years which, perhaps, were far more hectic in the international sense than the years since 1945 — the years of the Anschluss, the years when we were reading about Abyssinia and other matters of that sort. These were years of sanctions of one kind or another, years, at any rate, when it was perhaps not entirely prudent to suggest that you were going to have an infinity of peace in front of you, years when Fianna Fáil Ministers and a Fianna Fáil Government had those sources of information available to them, and yet their Army at the outbreak of war in the year 1939 was 7,000, and something over it, of a permanent force. It is agreed there were in existence A and B Reserves which totalled something slightly over 5,000. In the year 1939 on the outbreak of war, and only on the outbreak of war, when all political Parties and all national leaders joined together, and went together on a common platform to appeal for recruits——

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That was not until 1940.

Comment on this

Then we had the L. S. F., the L. D. F., and subsequently the F. C. A., but, at any rate, in the year 1939 — I do not want to be unfair to the Deputies opposite — they had the A and B Reserves, they had the permanent force and they had the Volunteer force which was roughly equivalent to the permanent force. That was the position in the year 1939. Deputy Vision de Valera saw fit to taunt the present Minister for Defence and his predecessor with figures for the present strength of the F. C. A. As a person who served as an officer in the F. C. A. right up to the end, I would like to say that you would have a far far bigger force now had that particular body of men received any kind of adequate treatment, even courtesy, from the Fianna Fáil Minister for Defence when the world war finished. However, according to Deputy Vision de Valera — he had the grace to admit that there was probably something very nominal about it — a year after the war, you had a paper strength of something in the region of 40,000 F. C. A.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

48,000.

Comment on this

The present strength is something in the region of 28,000 effectives, and that is the great distinction.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Minister gave me the figure of 30,000 effectives in 1949. If you had that number of effectives in 1949, then you have lost 2,000 effectives.

Comment on this

I believe that the Deputy or at any rate some of his associates claim to be mathematicians. If I deduct 10,000 from 33,000, I get 23,000. The figure that I mentioned was 28,000, which is something like 5,000 more.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The actual answer which the Minister gave me was that the total effective strength of the F. C. A. on the 1st March, 1949, was 30,333. If it was effective, then you are down.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I am just wondering whether this debate is being conducted by Deputy Vision de Valera as Minister, or are we to understand that he has already taken over office?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

It is a point of disorder if you like.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not a point of order.

Comment on this

Suggestions were made by Deputy Vision de Valera in the course of this debate——

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I have interrupted and I am sorry.

Comment on this

That is a classical understatement.

Comment on this

The suggestions were that everything in the garden was rosy until the change of Government took place in 1948, and that from that on there was a serious deterioration here in the position regarding our Defence Forces — that there was a sharp drop in the numbers of men, of personnel in the Regular Army, and that we were dissipating anything which we had in the nature of Reserves or F. C. A. That is not true.

I think that Deputy Vivion de Valera might possibly apologise once more before this debate is over, and recognise the fact that he and his colleague, Deputy Traynor, have been playing politics over the last three years. They have been playing politics in a most dangerous way in reference to the question of national defence. Mind you, it is a very dangerous thing to play politics with. It is not only dangerous for the members of the Force, but it is dangerous nationally. Not only did the Deputy and his colleagues play politics in that particular matter, but I am not at all sure that some of their references in relation to that particular matter, and in relation to the conditions existing in the Defence Forces, were not at any rate, to put it mildly, helpful. They certainly were not intended to be helpful towards the preservation of peace and contentment in the ranks of the Army.

Let us not forget that it was a Fianna Fáil Minister for Defence, and a Fianna Fáil Government, which abolished anything there was in the sphere of civil defence. So far as the ugly but, probably, effective air-raid shelters which disfigured this city were concerned, they were ordered to be demolished. Many of them were, in fact, demolished during the years 1946 and 1947. Any further demolition which took place after that was merely carrying out and tidying up the orders given by Deputy Traynor as Minister for Defence.

I referred in a rather sketchy way to what I believe was one of the reasons why the F. C. A. is not even stronger than it is to-day and the fact that that organisation was not treated properly by the then Minister for Defence. However, the position in the year 1950 was that you had an Army greater in size, more efficient and better equipped than you had in the year 1939. You had A and B Reserves at a figure which I think was some 600 larger than in 1939. You had in 1949-50 an F. C. A. effective strength, as Deputy Vivion de Valera pointed out, of something in the region of 30,000. That was not there in the year 1939. You had the Sluagh Muirí in the year 1949-50, numbering 300 odd, which was not there in the year 1939. You are also in the position that you have in civilian life in this country many thousands of men who, during the emergency years, passed through the Army or the L. D. F. or any one of the other defence units which existed during the emergency. You have those people, particularly those who came out from the Army and the L. D. F., trained to a high degree of efficiency in military matters. Those people are not on the establishment to-day, but they are there as a potential reserve for any new emergency which may break out.

In addition to those who passed through our own Defence Forces here, you have thousands — and there were many thousands of them—who served overseas, particularly in the British Army, the British Navy and the R. A. F. You have many thousands of young Irishmen who passed through those services here in this country who are available as another reservoir of strength from which we can draw if another emergency faces us. These are facts which cannot be denied. In every case, this country is in a far better position of national preparedness than it was in the year 1939, when the last war broke out. I believe that we are in a fairly effective position for a peace-time period. Deputy Vivion de Valera, possibly unintentionally, misquoted the present Minister for Defence as saying that we were perfectly ready to withstand any attack.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I think what I said was that he was reported as saying.

Comment on this

Of course that is a slippery way of getting out of it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

He was.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence is a man who has very great experience in the art of defence. His experience dates back to days which were far more trying than the days in which Deputy Vivion de Valera got his experience. If there is to be a question of choosing between the opinion of General Seán MacEoin and the opinion of Major de Valera, I am prepared to accept the opinion of General Seán MacEoin. I make no apology for that, and I do not mean any offence to Deputy Major de Valera when I say it.

I dealt with some of the points raised by the Deputy. I should like to finish by dealing with another matter to which he referred in a broad sense, and that was the question of equipment. His colleague, Deputy Childers, frequently refers to this question. Again, I think, he does so in a most dishonest way. The former Minister for Defence in this Government very frankly and bluntly told this House, both by means of parliamentary answer and on the occasion of the Estimates for the Department of Defence, the difficulties which stand in the way, and have for the past few years stood in the way, of securing equipment which no one denies it would be desirable to acquire. He told this House of the efforts which he and his Department have made in that direction. Notwithstanding that, we have to-day, the 1st May, 1951, Deputy Vivion de Valera coming along with the same carping criticism, criticism which is even more dishonest to-day than it was when it was first circulated to this House by the Deputy and his colleagues some years ago. If the equipment can be got, of course we should get it.

In the last year — I am talking from recollection — I believe the Minister for Defence, in introducing his Estimates, made it clear that it had been possible to get some, if not all, we desired. At any rate, it is right that the House should appreciate what the position is and that the country should get a chance of appreciating it in a fair and honest way without misrepresentation, either innocent or deliberate. It has been the policy of this Government to give that kind of information, and to give it freely, whenever it was requested by Deputies. That was not the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government.

As far as they were concerned, in regard to all these matters dealing with defence, it was stated that it would not be in the national interest to disclose the figures. This Government have given figures; they have been prepared to let the people into their confidence. Even at this late hour, it is time that the campaign of vilification and misrepresentation which Deputies opposite have indulged in in relation to this matter should cease; if not in the interests of public decency, at least in the interests of public safety.

Comment on this

As usual, Deputy O'Higgins has lectured us in his own inimical way. He has wrapped himself in a cloak of honesty and decency and apparently thinks he has a monopoly of such virtues in this House. He charges us with misrepresentation in regard to practically everything we have said about defence.

Comment on this

Do not quit, Deputy O'Higgins.

Comment on this

Wait, I have a few things to say to you.

Comment on this

There are others here.

Comment on this

Yes, the second edition of His Master's Voice is there. The Deputy started by taking the Estimates for 1948-49 and tried to show that Fianna Fáil were not estimating for an Army even as big as their successors did. The Estimates there showed distinctly, on what Deputy O'Higgins read out, that we were estimating for an Army of over 12,000 officers and men. Deductions, such as any reasonable man would make, were made——

Comment on this

That is good enough.

Comment on this

——because of the fact that we knew that in all probability we would not be able to bring the Army up to that strength during that year. As in most other things, Deputies on the Government Benches like to forget that there had been such a thing as a war. We were following immediately on a war period. We had mobilised over 40,000 men. Naturally the men were inclined at the end of the war to go back to their homes and their civilian occupations. The men in the Regular Army were particularly anxious to go back. As happens in every country there was a turning away from army life to civilian pursuits. That is quite a natural thing. Because of that the Army fell considerably in strength. It was not easy to get recruits, but we at least had a recruiting campaign in swing. We were doing all we could to get recruits in the circumstances in which we found ourselves.

The first step taken by the new Minister for Defence in 1948 was to cut out the recruiting advertisements and by a policy of silence try to stop recruiting. In fact, the Government let the public know that they were not concerned with recruits and that they would be just as pleased if nobody offered himself for the Army. In that Estimate of 1948, to which Deputy M. J. O'Higgins has referred, the total estimated number was 9,600, after subtracting the Construction Corps. At column 715 of the Official Report on 11th April, 1948, Dr. O'Higgins, Minister for Defence, said: "The strength I am budgeting for is approximately 8,500, that is 1,100 less." That figure does not take into consideration the Construction Corps either.

How can Deputy M.J. O'Higgins, in face of that statement by his own Minister for Defence, now say that they were not trying to reduce the Army or that they were providing for a bigger Army than Fianna Fáil were providing for before they left office? Admittedly we did not get the men, but we were certainly trying to get them. We would not have been satisfied until we reached an established strength of 12,000 men. Over and over again we have offered to co-operate with the Deputies on the Government Benches, but they cannot expect to get that co-operation from us until they face up to the fact that we had learned from our experience in 1939 and, while trying to economise as much as possible, had decided that the minimum established strength must be 12,500.

The present strength of the Army according to the answer given by the Minister on 5th April last at column 174 of the Official Report is: Reserve, First Line, 5,528; Reserve, Second Line, F. C. A., 22,597; An Sluagh Muirí, 191. Compare that with the position as given by the Minister when he took over. The number of regular officers on 1st March, 1949, was 1,057; regular N. C. O.s, 2,387; regular privates, 4,562, making a total of 8,672. The Reserve was 5,528 and the F. C. A., according to the Minister, was 48,000 men on 11th April, 1948, as shown at column 718 of the Official Report. In view of that no Deputy can honestly say that there has not been a deterioration in the last three years as far as the Army is concerned. I do not think it will do any good to try to represent otherwise.

We budgeted for more men than we actually had hoping to gain about 900 to 1,000 during the year. The new Minister for Defence in 1948 budgeted for less thereby showing that there was no intention of increasing the strength of the Army. Deputy M. J. O'Higgins was, of course, quite aware of all those things. He said we knew what the position was but apparently he knew better than we did and he twisted and misrepresented facts to his own liking. The Bill itself is not one on which there will be any disagreement. Undoubtedly, there are points to be dealt with, but they will come better on the Committee Stage. It is in itself more a compilation of all the amendments to the Defence Acts over the years— with a few notable exceptions.

There is one point — that of the Council of Defence, the members being appointed for five years — which the Minister should seriously reconsider. When I read it at first, I thought there was something in it, but having considered it very fully I have come to the conclusion that there should be definitely some provision that that might not be enforced during an emergency. We might be in a position in which we would not like to have to change horses when crossing the stream. The Minister should make some provision for an emergency and Deputy Traynor suggested certain words here to-day which would go a long way towards that.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to Section 11?

Comment on this

No, to Section 12, subsections (2) (d) and (g). I think I should leave over anything further until the Committee Stage, as the time is running out. I do not foresee that there will be much disagreement, but there will be some amendments to be considered then.

Comment on this

This Army Bill is a step forward, but like all Army Bills in the last 30 years I do not believe it is a permanent one. There will be no permanency in the Army until we have a united nation and there is no need to try for permanency until then. The Army over the last 30 years deserves every credit from the nation for its loyalty. It has gone through critical times from 1922 to 1932 and on to to-day and it has stood the test of time. One of the great factors is that we can depend on that small but solid body of men to weather any storms, to do the job when needed, to fight and to fight well. Talk as we like here — and some do nothing but talk nonsense and ballyhoo — we must be satisfied that in this small insignificant island surrounded by water we cannot live on ourselves alone. Yet over 30 years we have not made the slightest effort to build a factory or provide machinery to give us equipment for our Army. Is it not true that we cannot make even a water pistol, let alone a .22? Yet we talk about taking on every nation, taking on all comers. That is what sickens me. I am one of the veterans—there are not many of us in this House — who has been tried and tested in the art of war and is alive still. When I listen to young recruits like Deputy Vivion de Valera talking as we heard him to-night, a man in the jitters, I often ask myself if Commanders Eisenhower and Montgomery were in a panic like that when they landed in Normandy what would have happened. Thanks be to God, they kept their heads. I would ask Deputy Vivion de Valera to keep his head and not be selling the game. He has talked about treachery and disloyalty on this side. The greatest treachery I can see here over the last 16 weeks lies in the speeches and questions of Deputy Vivion de Valera. He is irresponsible.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not refer to questions as treachery. They are not allowed if they are not in order.

Comment on this

I withdraw that.

Comment on this

His point is that Deputy Vivion de Valera said I was guilty of treachery.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He said that Deputy Vivion de Valera's questions were treachery. They were down with the sanction of the Chair.

Comment on this

I concede the point, a Chinn Chomhairle. This Army debate over many years is unreal and a good many speak with their tongues in their cheeks. The people should be told the true position, instead of high-falutin nonsense, trying to lead them astray. Very few of them, however, will be led astray. The people in the country know the position far better than any of us. Wherein does the strength of the nation lie? Is it in the Army or in the army of men on the tillage fields or in the bogs? That is a question I would like to hear answered. We have a small, compact Army. It cannot be very big as the nation could not carry it. I would rather see us getting down to real matters, so that we may know exactly where we stand. Our small Army will play its full part if an emergency arises. I am satisfied that, even if we make it as big as we can, it will stand the shock only for a day or two, for a battle or two, and then must go underground. In other small countries, with 40,000,000 or 50,000,000, they had to go underground within a few weeks. Our small Army would have to do likewise.

In case an attack should come, we must look around to see where our friends lie, and we must have some idea as to the people who may be able to give us help. At the present moment, there is a definite line-up in the world on major principles and I believe it will come to a clash at perhaps no far distant date. In that line-up, we must play our part somewhere. We can talk of neutrality — I would love if we could stay neutral and, perhaps, by God's Will we may, as God saved us the last time — but we must consider the position and if we cannot stay neutral where do we stand? There should be a tentative arrangement whereby there can be a line-up if a crisis comes on top of us.

I am satisfied with our military strength, small as it is. Perhaps our brethren across the Border will be our greatest strength if there is an invasion of this country. I am confident that they are the first men we will call upon and that they will respond, as all Irishmen will, be they orange or green, to the defence of the motherland.

As regards the defence of this nation I believe that there should be some prior talks and arrangements and that politics should not play the major rôle, as they are playing at the present time. We are facing war clouds and we must make plans. You cannot plan in a small island that cannot, as I said before, produce a water pistol, unless you have contacts with some mighty Powers outside who are able and willing to give assistance. The last emergency, as we all know, was an eye-opener for this country and an eye-opener we will never forget. We had a fair number of men here, well-equipped, as we thought, and on the field ready for combat.

When the facts were discussed in this House and in other places it was discovered that we had thousands of men lined up with blank ammunition in their rifles. Millions of rounds of blank ammunition were sent into this country by so-called allies and were loaded in our soldiers' rifles. Was not that a grand state of affairs? If there were an invasion, we had tens of thousands of our young soldiers ready to die with nothing to defend them.

That was a disgraceful state of affairs, and I certainly think that it calls for a public inquiry. It was very unfair that such a situation should have arisen. There is no use in talking about keeping out an army, we could not keep out a swarm of flies if our soldiers had nothing but blank ammunition. These things did not happen under the inter-Party Government but under the Fianna Fáil Government, the Government which never made mistakes. They stand up here and talk big about what we should have and should not have. I want to see a proper spirit in the nation, with every man telling the truth so that we will know where we stand, and people who come to our aid will know where we stand.

Many estimates and figures are produced by Deputies on both sides of the House, one side repudiating the other. We ordinary men in the back benches do not give two hoots about figures. We are living amongst the people; we know the people, their strength and their troubles. We know also that they are as much concerned with the fate of the country as we are here. It is my belief that there is far too much politics being played in this House. We should settle down to a reasonable debate on these major issues. A great deal of political ballyhoo has issued across the floor of the House from Deputy de Valera to-night. He was not one bit concerned about the strength of the Army, but only with slipping it across the inter-Party Government in order to bring the people to his side. The Deputy need not worry about that. We will go to the country in our own time and we will return here as the Government and fulfil our programme. We are too fond of trailing our coats. Over the last 20 or 30 years very few have stood on our coats. We will trail them once too often.

The puny soldiers of to-day will not be found in the lead. It is the farmers' sons and the country boys who are out tilling the land to-day and who are producing turf to keep the home fires burning who will man the gap of danger and lay down their lives gallantly and bravely as the people who went before them have done. That is what should be counted in this country. For a good number of years I have advocated compulsory military service for every young man from 16 to 18 years, be he rich or poor, in order to give him a chance of forming a proper character. As far as I know, many of the youths of to-day and yesterday between the ages of 15 and 18 years went wrong because of the way they were managed at that critical time of their lives. If we had compulsory military service for all young men, giving them the benefit of training which would develop character, military deportment and so on. I am satisfied we would have in this country a compact body of fairly well-trained men, who would be brave and courageous because they come of a race of brave men, and who could be mobilised into an army fit to take part in battle.

We seem to be always rushing into things when there is an emergency coming, and we forget all about the people when the emergency is over. Where are all those young men who left the Army ten or 15 years ago? Many of them had to trek to England to beg for their bread so that they could send back a few shillings to keep their wives and children from hunger. I have seen many of the Old I. R. A. veterans who gave this country its freedom 30 years ago having to cry out for the small pittance to which they are entitled, and many more of them dying in the poor house. Now we are calling on another generation to make the supreme sacrifice and I suppose as happened before, there will be blank cartridges in their rifles. To speak about these matters here would be more in keeping than speaking about politics.

I am one of those who do not believe in that ballyhoo of giving ribbons and medals to almost every man in the country. There were no ribbons or medals given to the men who tilled the land and produced the turf for a meagre wage, but the men who joined up and drilled for a few hours a night per week got bars, medals and ribbons. Credit is due to those decent and honest men who joined up and did their duty, but thousands of men joined the L. D. F. and the L. S. F. for nothing more than to get a good pair of boots or a top coat. Of course, it is treachery to mention these things.

There is throughout the country a compact body of men who will patriotically go out and do their job, expecting nothing in return, but there is a vast number of men who, if they see anything going for nothing, join up to get it. The personnel of the L. D. F. and L. S. F. played a noble part, but the men who are out night and day producing the food of this country played an equally noble part. If one side can get medals, I do not see why the other side cannot. No medals or ribbons are given to any man in this country unless for military service. The men of the Old I. R. A. were fully entitled to their ribbons and medals because they did a critical job and did it well. We would have more respect for our Army if we settled down to more solid facts. We know our strength and there should be less talk about whether the strength of the Army should be 10,000, 20,000 or 40,000 men. Let us get down to the ground-work and, henceforth, train every young man from 16 to 18 years of age so that he can develop proper character, discipline, deportment and a proper knowledge of what his military duties are. When he has his few years' service completed, he can return to his work and carry it on efficiently whether it be in the field or in the factory. Then another batch of young men could come forward and be trained so that we would have in this country a disciplined, manly force of Irishmen with proper character and discipline who would know how to carry out their duties, and who would not be in the position that they were going to look for something for nothing. They would be trained in the art of real patriotism. There is a good deal of sham patriotism in this country to-day.

I do not want to say much more. I will reserve it for the Estimate. I am satisfied that this Government has done its duty by the people. It has put the country in as good a shape of defence as any small, impoverished island can be put. I am not worried about neutrality. If there is a fight and it is our duty to be in that fight, and whether the fight takes place here or elsewhere, I would not be afraid to take part in it. I would not be afraid to look for allies either. I know my friends and I know my enemies. I would not cross the streets of Dublin either in the van or behind Deputy Vivion de Valera because he is no more than a jitterbug. Such a soldier! I do not know how he got through the emergency and why he was not drowned crossing the streams. I wish to God he would take a headline from his father who fought, and fought nobly, with long years of service, and prison service, too, and can sit back and laugh at the nonsense that goes on here. I would say to the Minister: "You are on the right lines so far as getting a Bill through that will be of a semi-permanent nature." The day when the orange and green will blend together is coming and will come sooner than is expected. It is for that day we ought to be making our arrangements. All that is heard in this House is that England is a brute and that America is trying to muscle in, but we are damn glad to get American dollars.

Our enemy to-day is Communism. We must face Communism. I fought before and I would fight and die if need be to put down the Communist beast. I do not want to be neutral if it means crawling along with the Joe Stalins butchering and brow-beating every form of Christianity. We have got to fight and destroy Communism and advance against those hordes as the Crusaders did of old. That is what I believe. No man should be afraid to die. One has only to die once.

Comment on this

The matter which impressed me most, listening to Deputy Vivion de Valera, was the fact that Army figures, equipment and plans were debated and brought to light. I remember that in years past, when questions were asked concerning the Army and concerning equipment, the answer which Deputies got was that it would not be in the national interest to disclose those facts. I think that was the right view. It is very disappointing to see that, in order to get some kind of political advantage, if there is any to be gained, the Fianna Fáil Party has departed from the appreciation of the value of keeping secret these facts and figures concerning our Army. Instead of that, we have seen, during the past few months particularly, questions being put down constantly by members of the Opposition asking for figures concerning the Army, asking what the Army strength is, what equipment we have, what equipment we are likely to get, and expecting that that information should be made available to them. Probably if we refuse to give that information they will say we were not prepared to face up to facts. Instead of that, we have given them the information they asked for. Across this floor again and again our position and our Army strength have been criticised and debated.

I believe myself that it does not offer any advantage to the general public to know what the position of our Army is, what its strength is or anything else. I believe that it is a matter for the Government to make sure that we have the strongest Army which the Government can afford in peace time or in the event of any approaching emergency. I believe that any Government democratically elected can be trusted to keep and maintain in this country an Army capable of defending our country effectively in the event of any emergency. For that reason, I am disappointed to hear the members of the Opposition, particularly, quibbling over figures, stating what our plans are, criticising what our plans are and what the present position is. I believe it is not of any advantage to the general public — and it certainly is a disadvantage if there are outside powers desiring the information — to know exactly how we stand in this country in the matter of our Army.

We found Deputy Colley claiming that it was the Fianna Fáil intention to aim at a strength of 12,500 men. When the change of Government came about, the number in the Army was very much below that figure. We found in the Estimates that no provision was made for an Army of 12,500 persons. Looking back, we can remember that in 1946 a very large part of the Army was disbanded. Many men, in fact, were put out of the Army and encouraged to leave the Army in 1946. This was very much to their disadvantage because when they had left the Army, some of them with a promise of employment or with a prospect of employment, they found they could not join again. They found that only persons who had been in the Army on a certain date could be considered for recruitment at a later stage. Other persons who served in the Army during the emergency years were married men. When they were encouraged to leave the Army in 1946 and go into civilian life they found it very difficult—in fact, impossible in many cases—to get back into the Army again owing to the fact that they were married men and because it was not the policy to take into the Army men of a certain age or married men.

All this war talk seemed to develop after the change of Government because if we look back we will see that Fianna Fáil were planning for peace. The beginning of that plan was the disbandment of a large number of persons from the Army in September, 1946. They followed that with the demolition of the air-raid shelters in Dublin City in 1946 and 1947. It could not be said at that time that they felt there was any emergency facing this country and it could not be said that they considered it necessary to consolidate our position in the matter of defence, so far as the maintenance of these shelters was concerned. In the event of an emergency in future, it will be necessary for us to reconstruct air-raid shelters as they were during those emergency years or in some other form.

I am advancing that argument to show that Fianna Fáil were planning for peace and they need not try to tell the public that at all times they wanted to expand the Army. It was obvious that they wanted to bring the Army down to a certain strength — probably the strength at which it stands at present, or even lower. We have at present a sound Army and we have in that Army well-trained men who were encouraged to join the Army or to remain in the Army by Army conditions. We have men in the Army who have taken up the Army as a career and it is the men who take up the Army as a career who are the leaders in the event of its being necessary to put up a defence, as we have seen in other countries. In these countries, it is the men who made the army their career who were the leaders in military operations.

The attitude of our Government towards the maintenance of the Army and the defence of this country was to encourage recruitment, to attract men into the Army, to bring them in, not by means of conscription, but by the provision of better conditions and higher rates of pay. That is the real proof of our desire to improve the Army, to improve our defences and to improve conditions for those who are prepared to serve the country in the Army. We must remember that, since the change of Government, 50,000 extra persons have gone into industry. If they had not done so, they would have no alternative, apart from registering at the employment exchange, but to seek a position in the Army and we must ask ourselves whether it has been better to encourage Army recruitment by the provision of better conditions or to provide employment for those who wish to go into industry by the establishment of more industries.

That is the attitude we have adopted, because we realise that, if we have 50,000 extra persons manufacturing the goods required by our people and providing a surplus for export in competition with other countries, it is the better policy. We know that every able-bodied Irishman, if the necessity arises, will answer the nation's call to come to her defence, and we will have for such men trained personnel, men who know their job, who will be able to lead these volunteers or recruits in the event of the need to defend our freedom arising. I believe that there was never a higher level of morale in the Army than there is at present. That is due to the fact that every effort is being made to improve conditions for the men in the Army, as every effort is being made also to add to or to replace existing equipment. I believe that we now possess some tanks. We never had these tanks here before. I see that Deputy Childers is surprised to learn that.

Comment on this

He blames us for not having the atom bomb.

Comment on this

We now have tanks, although Deputy Childers thinks we had tanks before. I hope he will let us know what the position was, so far as our defences were concerned during the previous emergency. Deputy Giles revealed a very alarming position so far as the Army was concerned during those years, and it is to be wondered at that the Army personnel were not aware of it themselves. We have at least 2,500 non-commissioned officers and 4,500 privates. The prospects of promotion in this Army are far greater than the prospects of promotion in the British or American armies because we have so many non-commissioned officers. These men, after a few years, are in a position to get further promotion, which naturally gives an opportunity for promotion to the privates.

The present rate of pay for a single private in the Army is £100, plus £45 in rations, uniforms, lodging and medical treatment. That is a very encouraging figure for the young man who wishes either to take up the Army as a career or to go into the Army until such time as he can secure remunerative employment in civilian life. The young man going into the Army on that figure can at least feel that he will have something to meet ordinary current expenses, especially when we compare the packet of cigarettes at 1/8 with the packet of cigarettes at 3/4 in Great Britain. I make that comparison because I believe the figure for a private going into the British army is about the same as that for a private going into the Army in this country. I hope that this Bill will go through. I am glad to note that there is general agreement on it and that it is the desire of all Parties in this. House to give to the Army the best possible Bill that can be devised in the circumstances. I agree with the Deputies who said that it is a step in the right direction. It is not a final Bill but it is a Bill that will carry us on to such a time as we may find it possible to improve conditions and to alter the Army to meet with modern requirements. Certainly, the Korean war has created in the minds of our people the impression that we ought to be very much on the defensive.

The Korean war is along way from here and, apparently, with the growing strength of the nations within the United Nations' army group, there appears to be growing confidence amongst the nations of Western Europe. That is a welcome development. Certainly, so far as this country is concerned, we are sympathetic to the United Nations' armies who are determined to stop the onward march of the Red hordes. They are marching at the moment in the East but apparently the United Nations' armies are determined to put a stop to the march. There is a danger that they might begin to march in this direction. If they should do so, our little Army here is well trained and well equipped. It is ready to go into the field and command a very large number of volunteers who will readily go to the defence of the country, if necessary. In the meantime, we have our young able-bodied men working in the fields and in the factories, producing food, clothing and various other essentials for the nation. If we had these men in the Army now — if we took them out of the fields and away from the factories and put them instead into the Army — the nation would be so much the poorer for their services, and taxation would naturally be very much higher in order to maintain the men in the Army and they would not be producing either goods or food. Those men are there and ready to come into this orderly Army which is being very carefully maintained and strengthened in the matter of equipment and morale by the policy being personally pursued by the Minister for Defence. We all know that it is difficult for us to obtain the equipment we require either from Britain or from America. I think, in a general way, we can say that these are the only two sources from which we can expect to get supplies. Naturally enough, with these two nations rearming as rapidly as possible so as to be ready in the event of an emergency, we cannot expect them to make a very large quantity available to us but we can continue expecting and hoping that they will be prepared to make a certain amount of equipment available to us.

The one difficulty so far as armies are concerned, particularly our own, is that in these times army equipment is constantly going out of date. A modern weapon to-day would be out of date to-morrow. Therefore, we must try to keep in step with modern methods, modern equipment and modern warfare. I feel sure that the nations of Great Britain and America, realising that we as a nation are amongst the Western Powers and that we might find it necessary to defend ourselves in the event of an advance in this direction, would ensure that we would be given a certain amount of equipment. I have no doubt that this Bill will improve the position not alone for the Army but for the country in general. We can have full confidence in the policy being pursued by the Minister for Defence. He is well aware of the world situation. He is well aware of the need for a well-equipped and well-trained Army. I believe that he is going in the right direction when he brings a Bill of this kind to this House.

Comment on this

It is very interesting to hear some Deputies of the Government Party talking almost as though they had taken notes from speeches made by people such as Monsieur Blum in the French Government in 1936 and 1938, and by people in the Belgian Government at the same period, and as though they had almost made an intimate study of the speeches of all those who surrounded Mr. Stanley Baldwin in 1936. We hear the same sort of facile phrases. We hear the amazing defence of the Government's defence policy, that the men are better at work in the fields. That is one of the oldest clap-trap arguments in the world for not having an army put forward by every kind of person who did not face up to reality about defence. It is the simplest thing in the world to say that the men must work in the fields, that we do not need an army and that therefore we must not have one. The Deputies who make these facile statements fail to take account of the fact that there are a considerable number of men in the country who could join the Army and still leave enough for food production.

About half the people in this country are men and, so far as I understand, about half of them are at work. There are plenty of people to be drawn into an army if the conditions are satisfactory and if there is a general policy, understood by all the members of the Government and accepted by all the members of the Government, for the encouragement of recruitment. There are 58,000 unemployed in this country who might be encouraged to join the Army. There are two Parties in this House who, when this Government came into office, promised to end emigration. Any of them who got seats got them illegally or partly because of a scare they introduced among the people that we were responsible for emigration. One of the ways of preventing the emigration of 40,000 people, which took place in the first two years of office of this Government, might have been to offer very attractive conditions in the Army, to offer them the alternative of a really interesting career in the Army at attractive wages. In fact, there should be no need to worry about taking men from the fields if the Government had carried out their promises to end emigration. There would have been plenty of man-power in the country if only the people had been kept at home, rather than leaving in their thousands, and if some of the unemployed were taken. Even if some of those who are now in the fields were taken into the Army, there would still be enough for agricultural production, and the position would be more reassuring.

We heard another argument from Deputy Rooney. He seemed to imply that since the Korean crisis there was a sense of growing confidence amongst the Western Powers, the wealthiest of whom believed that it would be possible for them to prepare for the defence of Europe in time before the outbreak of war. He went on to develop the theme that undoubtedly they would come to our rescue if war began and we required arms. I must say that from all the reports I have received there is no sense of confidence among the Western Powers; they all believe that they are working against time and are doing their utmost to arm themselves knowing that the danger grows ever nearer.

When it comes to the amount spent on defence by some of the other small countries of Europe the figures again show that the Government here apparently are not prepared to spend the same amount on defence as small European countries such as Belgium, Denmark, Norway and Sweden. The money spent here on defence represents about 5 per cent. of the Budget while in other small European countries it varies from 17 per cent. to 21 per cent.

Deputy Rooney suggested that there was something unpatriotic about the questions asked by Deputy Vivion de Valera, suggested that he was in a state of jitters. That was also a common cry in European countries before both world wars: people who asked questions about rearmament or about the strength of the army were in a state of jitters. It is the most usual form of defence to reply that anybody who shows an unusual interest in the army, in the number of guns or the amount of material in it, must be in a state of jitters; the oldest cry in the world is that of the person who tries to escape from reality about a nation's defences. It is true to say, I think, that this country's armed defences are so small that there could be no harm in disclosing all the figures, no harm in the Minister for Defence or some other Minister giving the full facts to the country about the position of our defences. Even in countries such as America there is an astonishing lack of secrecy with regard to the main elements of defence in the American armed forces. An amazing amount of information is freely given to the American people. Information is not given in the ordinary way about secret weapons, but in so far as the strengths of the army, the air force and the navy are concerned a great deal is told to the people perfectly frankly.

I feel obliged to say in this connection that I hope and trust that if the new Minister for Defence continues in his office he will do his utmost for the Army. He is a person of great reputation as a soldier and should know all the facts. I am even prepared to admit that his first statements were of a very reassuring kind. They were made possibly with a view to relieving the anxieties of the people of the country, but I do believe that the present Minister, if he chooses, has the capacity to do a great deal to improve the Army. I say this perfectly frankly. I am not a colleague of his; I fight across the battlefield against him at election times, but I believe that the Minister has within him the capacity, and I only hope that the members of his Government will allow him to do what he wishes.

He is much too reassuring in what he has said about the Army. It may be the desire of a new Minister to start off on the right foot because he knows as well as we do on this side of the House that men, arms and defensive equipment of all kinds are very gravely lacking. I quite realise also that it will be very difficult for the Minister to secure the necessary arms but I believe that a Government led by a great statement could secure them still and maintain the present position and I state unequivocally that if the present Government cannot secure arms they should give way to another that can.

The position at the moment is that we are a liability to every other nation around us, a liability because we are actually at the moment the weakest spot in the defence of Western Europe.

Comment on this

I do not think it is wise to say that.

Comment on this

We must be a cause of anxiety to all the nations around us and it is our business to persuade them that it is right and proper for us to have arms to defend ourselves so that whatever policy we adopt here in connection with our desire to be neutral at least we will not be a liability to other people, that at least we could hold any defensive position for a considerable time in the event of any attack being made on this country.

There are other difficulties facing the new Minister for Defence. He not only has the Army to think of but he has to think of all strategic defences of an economic character. We have no underground bomb-proof fuel oil storage with which to fuel the Army let alone agricultural tractors. The main repair facilities for both the bus company and the railway company are concentrated in two areas. There has been no attempt at storage dispersal; no plans have been made for storage dispersal so far as I know unless the Minister has made a plan since he took office. There is no way as far as I know by which the economic forces of the country could supply the Army in the event of any bombing. It is extremely difficult to distribute supplies unless storage is created and maintained particularly with regard to fuel oil and petrol.

Another difficulty facing the Minister is the fact that the members of his own Government quite obviously differ with regard to defence policy and, if not the members of the Government, the members of the Coalition groups as a whole. You have every type of person from Deputy Dillon, the Minister for Agriculture, who clearly indicated that it is definitely impossible, definitely wrong and definitely unchristian for us to be neutral in the next war, and who has made use of statements of an almost religious character to defend his ideas.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is outside the scope of this Bill surely.

Comment on this

I am merely pointing out the difficulties of the Minister in improving the defences of the country having regard to the fact that he is supposed to have the support of his Government.

Comment on this

We have been all around Korea already.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I agree that the scope of the Bill has been widened considerably.

Comment on this

Dissertations upon anyone's religious expressions, an academic thing like that, might just as well be left alone.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture did not leave it alone.

Comment on this

I do not think he should have done it either.

Comment on this

I was only quoting the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Quote away. All right. You will find that he is quite orthodox.

Comment on this

You have other members of the Government Parties who have made it quite clear that not only should we be neutral but that we should be neutral even if Partition were settled; that it is not our war; that we have no connection with the war, no responsibility for it; that no statement of any kind should be made by the Government that there was any possibility of our taking part in a war even if Partition were settled. Those are two points of view in connection with any effort by the Minister to secure more arms than we have.

Intermediate points of view have been stressed by other members of the Government Parties. Some think that if it were possible to amend the fourth section of the Atlantic Treaty, the one in which we guarantee the territorial integrity of the other powers, then we could subscribed to the Atlantic Pact and in turn secure arms possibly through the intervention of the present Government and without the help of a great statesman such as we have in this Party.

The Minister, therefore, has many difficulties to face. As I said there is this confusion of mind between those who believe in military neutrality and in mental neutrality to quote one Deputy of the Fine Gael Party and those who believe in absolute neutrality to quote other members of the Government Parties.

A suggestion was made by the former Minister for Defence who, I think, about last November, implied that the clouds of war were passing away. We have also had a statement by the Taoiseach that we could pay too high an insurance for defence. Such statements make it difficult for the new Minister to adopt a progressive defensive policy. The Minister will recall that during the Anglo-Irish conflict members of the Old I. R. A. did not sit around and wonder whether they were paying too high an insurance for defence. I do not believe the present Minister desires to consider that kind of thing, or that it would be possible for him to persuade his colleagues to allow him to improve our defences, if it is done in the atmosphere of considering whether it is possible to pay too high an insurance for defence.

We should be quite frank about the position. The world situation is a serious one. Everyone else, except some people in the Government, believe war is coming closer, believe that only a miracle can avert war. In this country a great many people, I think largely induced by the smaller Parties in the Government, tend to imagine that possibly we could escape, or that we might be left by ourselves as we were in the last war. That may be true but remaining virtually unarmed, and with very few defences, will not encourage people to leave us alone. One of the things the Minister well knows about our position is this, that it is quite possible to envisage a state of affairs whereby the whole western part of Europe might be invaded by the Russian army and Ireland might at that point become one of the most vital territories in Europe — the place it was not easy to invade, at one fell stroke the place that might be the final battleground, the place that might just be the strategic territory, enabling some sort of stand to be made on the wester no coast of Europe, a stand that could also be made in Spain, while the armies of the West regroup their forces and prepare for the long period of doing again what they did in the last war, namely, the invasion of the European Continent.

In fact, as the Minister knows, a number of important strategists, both English and American, declared publicly that they regard the territory of the whole of Ireland and the territory of Spain as, so to speak, the territories that should be held and that could prove of vital importance in a war in which the Russian armies were at first victorious. I quite realise that places us in a most difficult position. I do not mean to pretend that it is possible for any Government here to arm us sufficiently to face that type of situation, but there is a great difference between a complete state of defence which we obviously could not undertake, and a state of defence in which we could fight a delaying action up to the time when we would be open to receive some sort of assistance in the event of an actual invasion taking place, and it might make all the difference to the final result if we were well armed and defended.

I do not think I have much more to say in connection with this Bill, except that I think the Minister for Defence could agree with those people on this side of the House who claim that the argument about allowing people to continue to work in the fields is not really a sound one. Agricultural production has gone up in England since the war: agricultural production has gone up in other European countries, and they have been still able to recruit either temporary or permanent defence forces. In actual fact, members of the Government Parties suggest that a very great increase in production has taken place in agriculture, but even with the people in the fields at the moment, we have a very long way to go. There has been no remarkable increase, even though a labour force that otherwise would not be available is, in fact, available.

The Minister knows very well that the question of labour and agriculture is to some degree a flexible one and I think it would be much better if that argument were left out. It is a completely escapist argument, for a country with an increase in population of 24,000 a year. I think there are between 19,000 and 21,000 young men coming to the age of 21 years every year and it is an unrealistic argument to say they could be better employed elsewhere. Nobody on this side of the House suggests that the permanent Army should be 100,000 or that the F. C. A. should be 100,000. Within the limits of the total number of men from 18 to 30 years, the Minister for Defence should well know that he can obtain the necessary recruits.

I should like to ask the Minister, now that he has been newly appointed, whether he believes that under present circumstances the pay in the Army is sufficient?

Comment on this

It never was.

Comment on this

I am very well aware we were not perfect in that, although we made great improvements. I am aware that improvements have been made in pay under the present Government, but I ask the Minister frankly, when one considers the pay of a private, £100 a year plus £45 for rations, is it sufficient? There are two elements to be considered. There is what you might call the economic value of the money and then there is the natural disinclination of people who live far away from war situations, who live in a country where for a large number of years there never was a large army, who live in a country which has been associated with civil war and the atmosphere of civil war for some time. I ask him, frankly, whether he thinks the pay is high enough and, thinking of those psychological factors, whether he believes he could get a larger Army if he were to increase the pay? Face up to the issue. We have a Budget which has risen from £22,000,000 to £110,000,000 since the foundation of the Irish Free State up to now.

Comment on this

Or from the British times, from £8,000,000.

Comment on this

The Minister will have to admit the present Government have spent money lavishly and £1,000,000 now counts for a good deal less in the minds of some of his colleagues than £1,000,000 used to count for in our day. Maybe in an ever-growing Budget he might manage to arrange for higher pay. My own belief is that it is based almost entirely on instinct; just comparing £100, and making allowance for rations, with the wages received by other people, £100 is not enough any longer. He will have to pay more if he is going to get the men. I should like to ask his views about that, because it is very important in connection with the general development of our defence and with the discussion that is taking place on this Bill.

Deputy Rooney referred to the fact that in 1946 we started demolishing air-raid shelters, that the previous Government began to show that they believed that peace was coming. I suppose there has never been a great war in history after which there were not at least three or two years in which the Government of that day was compelled by forces against which they could not prevail to assume, for the moment anyway, that there was going to be peace. Certainly, the British Government demolished air-raid shelters. Certainly, all over the world, in every country except perhaps Russia, there was a sort of effort made at demilitarisation, perhaps futile, perhaps unwise, but the normal and human thing. It is equally true that from about June, 1947, onwards people began to realise the grim truth that there was likely to be another war, and it is equally true to say that most other European countries have made, and continue to make, more preparations for war than we have, both in the military sense and in the economic sense. I do not think that Fianna Fáil can be blamed for the fact that during a short period after the war they indulged in the same wishful thinking as other countries, for whom information on the state of Russia was more accessible and more definite, other countries who had more actual experience of warfare. I do not think there was anything wrong about doing it, but I do think it is wrong, once the position becomes grave again, not to do more about organising our defences.

I should like to ask the Minister to take the House into his confidence in regard to how far he has refused to accept arms of certain patterns on the ground that they were obsolete because, although it is quite true that obsolete arms are of little use in defensive work, nevertheless, to refuse certain kinds of arms that may be relatively speaking out of date, may be preventing us from making just the temporary kind of stand we might make in the event of invasion. I would like to ask him to take the House into his confidence in regard to the position of his effort to secure arms and to say a little more about it when he concludes the debate.

As I have said, I am eternally an optimist in politics and always shall be and I hope that the present Minister will do better than his predecessor. His predecessor did not seem to me to take the interest he should have taken in our armed forces. I think it is true to say that the present Army has a very high morale, with the men enthusiastic to do the best they can, but I know also that there is a sort of concealed and private despair within the ranks, particularly in the higher ranks, of the Army. It is no good denying it. The Minister can find it out for himself. There is a sort of private despair within the minds of the higher ranks in the Army particularly, because of the difficulty in getting arms and because of the small size of the Army. They will never say it in public, never show it in their actions in public. They are men of the highest morale but the private despair is there just the same and I hope the present Minister, having regard to his career, will be able to dispel that sense of a very private and secret despair which certainly affects the officers of the Army because of the position they find themselves in.

Comment on this

If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery and I were inclined to flatter Deputy Childers, I would be tempted to follow him around the world in answering his arguments. Little had he to say about this Bill. In that he was not alone. It seems to be the general tenor of this debate that the further you are removed from the Bill the more relevant are your remarks.

Comment on this

Is that a reflection on the Chair?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I hope the Deputy will not follow the bad examples.

Comment on this

I am restraining myself with the greatest courage. There are some points in Deputy Childers's remarks which are worthy of attention and with which I would be in accord. I would support his question, if not contention, that an improvement in Army pay, Army conditions, might result in giving us a better Army, an Army which will be in a better position to perform its functions. I agree with him also that the previous Government acted not unwisely in demolishing the flimsy air-raid shelters which in Dublin and elsewhere were more an obstruction to traffic than a protection to the civilian. If war should come, most competent observers would agree that shelters for the civilian population should be deep underground shelters, not surface structures such as we had in the last emergency. Only on these few points could I find agreement with Deputy Childers.

On other points, I feel the utmost dismay that a member of this democratic Assembly could utter words such as he used. He described himself as an optimist in politics, but surely he reached the depths of despair and pessimism in his contribution to this debate. Were it not that we are exceedingly lenient in our democracy, I should be inclined to arraign Deputy Childers for treason. He has talked about Europe and the state of preparedness forced upon certain of the Western Powers in Europe. Where, I wonder, would he find among the representatives in the democratic Assemblies of these States a Deputy to reveal to the world the very private and secret despair in the hearts of the higher ranks in the Army? If that is not treason, I would like to know what is. Surely that is an open invitation to any enemy of this State to make use of this private and secret despair which is permeating the hearts of our higher officers for their own advantage. Such language from a responsible member of the Opposition would cause in any country amazement and in some countries very swift and drastic action against him who uttered it. But Ireland is a democratic country.

We permit the greatest latitude in political debates and, knowing the character of the Irish people, I am sure that, if there are close observers who are anxious to know the state of mind of our military forces, they will not take Deputy Childers's pronunciamento too seriously. For Deputy Childers to obtain knowledge of this private and secret despair in the hearts of the higher officers is surely bordering on the work either of a very high-class psychologist or a magician, for no officer of any competence in our Army to-day, no Chief of Staff, Adjutant-General, Quartermaster-General, nor any of those holding high rank in the Army, I am sure would be guilty of revealing to a member of the Opposition, responsible or irresponsible as he may be, what lurked in his heart as a private and secret despair.

Comment on this

The Deputy is perfectly right. They never say anything.

Comment on this

How then does Deputy Childers suggest that it exists? What does his colleague, Deputy Traynor, think of those whom he left behind in the Army in responsible positions who are cherishing such inward treason to the State that they have such little confidence in the present Minister for Defence as to harbour this private and secret despair? I do not believe it exists. I am perfectly certain that the members of the Army, the hierarchy in the Army, have as much confidence in the present Minister for Defence, General MacEoin, as they had in his two predecessors.

Comment on this

I never said anything to the contrary.

Comment on this

The implication in the Deputy's remarks was to that effect, that they despaired that the present Minister for Defence would supply them with the weapons whereby they could endeavour to carry out the defence of the interests of this nation. That is surely a lack of confidence in the Minister who refuses, as was suggested by the Deputy, to take even obsolete arms from other nations to put into their hands to carry out the defence of their native land.

This general discussion may be very much beyond the confines of the Bill but it is useful as giving us the background to the whole question of the Army. I would consider this as the most extraordinary Bill that has ever been put before the House. I am perfectly certain that the present Minister for Defence was not the author of it because it is not a soldier's Bill. Far from it; it is a hotch-potch of meaningless legal irrelevancies and I do not think that the Minister should have bothered the House with it. We have been up to the present accustomed to an annual Bill enabling the Government to carry on the armed forces of this country. Some felt, and indeed I am sure expressed dissatisfaction with that temporary arrangement but presented with this Bill as we are, I think it is even worse than anything we had before. Without going into a very full examination of it, I would say, that as far as the ordinary Deputy is concerned, the more he reads it, like Alice in Wonderland, the more the wonder grows that any set of people responsible for an army could produce such an ill-assorted effort as this. Some members may not have read the Bill: I am sure there are a good many in that position because it is a portentous volume of a size calculated to frighten any Deputy away, particularly after arduous labours in other directions, such as on the Social Welfare Bill and other measures of that nature.

Here we have a Bill of something like 316 sections but in this Bill for some mysterious reason, which perhaps the Minister may explain to me, there is no mention of the word "soldier." Why we should be so careful and so tender in our regard for words, that we are unable to use the word "soldier" or "volunteer" in this Bill, I do not know. It appears to me to be a gross reflection, as if those who drafted this Bill were of the opinion of Samuel Johnson that a soldier was a hired assassin and, therefore, far be it from them to call anyone who was in the Defence Forces a soldier. We have in the first part of the Bill, which is merely one to give a legal basis for the establishment and the maintenance of the Army, definitions of the usual type of practically everything that one would expect to find in a Bill, definitions which always fills a layman with amazement. For instance we are told that an absentee is a person who is absent, as if he could be anything else. You are given such wonderful education in the meaning of words that you are told "the word `man' means a person who is for the time being a member of Óglaigh na hÉireann but does not include an officer."

We have here a contrast between the ordinary meaning and the technical meaning. Ordinarily anyone would think that an officer was a man but evidently according to this Bill an officer is not a man. He is a sort of superman, perhaps. There is then such an utterly out-of-date explanation as that "the Adjutant-General means the Adjutant-General of Óglaigh na hÉireann." Surely to goodness this Bill cannot be deemed to apply to Timbuctoo, Uruguay or Paraguay: we must be considering the armed forces of the Irish Republic.

What is the necessity for this continuous reiteration of statements such as that "the Chief of Staff means the Chief of Staff of Óglaigh na hÉireann," and "the Quartermaster-General means the Quartermaster-General of Óglaigh na hÉireann," and "the Judge-Advocate-General means the Judge-Advocate-General of Óglaigh na hÉireann." By taking each one in turn we are wasting paper and the time and the labour of the draftsman. All this continuous nonsense comes very ill from a Department which should be concerned with the organisation of the defences of the country. It would seem to me that they are more concerned with trying to twist words in the English dictionary into meanings that were never intended for such words. Again many things that should be defined in the Bill are not defined at all.

There are many instances in which there is a lack of clarity in the Bill. There are many sections of the Bill that are not extended far enough. I could go through parts of it, and if this were not a Second Reading, show to the Minister conclusively that this is not the type of Bill I expected to serve as a permanent Bill, governing the life of the armed forces of this country. To give one or two instances, there is a section here dealing with the Judge-Advocate-General.

In a few sub-sections of that section — Section 15 — they tell us what shall be the functions of the Judge-Advocate-General, what he shall be and what he shall not be, and how he holds office. When we turn over the page we expect to see a further enlargement of his duties and of his functions, but in that we are sadly disappointed because it abruptly ends, as many of these things do as far as lawyers are concerned, with this fact that his remuneration shall be paid by the Minister with the consent of the Minister for Finance. What are the functions of the Judge-Advocate-General?

I think there is too much assumption in this Bill from the point of view of the civilian. There is too much assumption that those who are dealing with the Bill should know everything about the organisation of the Army, about military law and martial law. What the soldier himself, or the civilian who might be concerned, would be really interested to know in extenso, that is to say the functions of certain of those higher generals and higher officers in the Army, is not set out at all. At any rate, you just get the scantiest outline of what their duties are in relation to the soldier's life, his well-being, transgressions in the Army and so on. They have defined nearly everything in this Bill. They define what a man is and what an officer is, that an officer is not a man. They define a deserter. We are told that “the word `deserter' means a person who deserts,” as if it could mean anything else. When we turn to page 60 of the Bill we learn something that hitherto had escaped the knowledge of the ordinary public, that is, when we talk about the persons who are subject to military law. Section 118 contains certain sub-sections dealing with men who are subject to military law. Then it goes on to deal with another person who is subject to military law in these terms. Paragraph (d) says:—

"Any person, not otherwise subject to military law, who is a follower of or accompanies any portion of Óglaigh na hEireann which is on active service."

Well, I never knew that the Irish Army boasted of followers. When I turned back to the definition section, I find it is silent on what a follower is. We are told what the "enemy" means in the definition section. It says that "the word `enemy' includes armed mutineers, armed rebels, armed rioters and pirates". We are not, as I have said, told what is the function or what is the nature of this creature who is referred to as a follower in Section 118, and who is subject to military law. The camp followers of old are not the type of people one would expect to be following an Irish Army. All that came as a tremendous shock to my civilian mind.

It is, therefore, obvious that this Bill is not one that should commend itself to the Dáil. I think it is one that requires further examination. Deputy Vivion de Valera speaking, I presume, with a military mind rather than the mind of a Deputy, suggested that certain sections of the Bill dealing with military offences—that is if I took him up correctly—should be relegated to a small committee of the Dáil. He did not think that the time of the House should be taken up with them. I submit that would be a very grave breach of the democratic practices of this House, and I urge on the Minister not to entertain that suggestion for a moment. All the parts of this Bill which deal with transgressions or offences by the ordinary military personnel require the greatest scrutiny and examination. The forms of punishment in an army, as a result of such sections in an Army Bill, have led in the past, in other armies, to very grave abuses. These forms of punishment have, as I have said, in other armies led to abuses and to a deterioration in the morale of the army, to an undermining of the respect that the civilian public have for the army. In many States, they have resulted in the army becoming completely divorced from the people of the country and, under certain types of officers, of the army becoming degraded, of the personnel becoming debased and debauched without any protection from the civil arm of the State.

In our case, starting off as we are as a young State, with an Army such as we hope to have and such as we have had in the past, one which was closely allied to the people, we must not permit any usurpation of the functions of the general law in the matter of punishment for transgressions except under the very greatest safeguards, safeguards which we are thoroughly satisfied are in the order of equity and of civil justice.

When considering this Bill we should, I think, have some regard to what is the real function of an army and what we may expect from an army in this country. There is a great deal of sense in the very direct and homely thrust of Deputy Giles when he suggested that a great deal of ballyhoo was talked on both sides about our Army. As I understand it, an army is an instrument of force. The function of an army is to exert force to enforce the will of the Government as the executive committee of the ruling section of the State, whatever it may happen to be for the time being. It has a function, both internally and externally. In many countries the army has been used against the civilian population internally in the State, as well as externally against the foreign enemies of the State. In this country so far we have the happy position that the Army has not been used against the civilian population, except in one slight incident under the Fianna Fáil Administration when it was used in order to break the bus strike some years ago. That was not of any great moment. I do not think it left any great bitterness amongst those who felt the weight of the Army that time. I myself got a month in the "Glasshouse" in the Curragh, not for taking up arms against the Army but for defending the strikers on that occasion.

On the whole, the relations of the Army with the civilian population in this country have been harmonious. It has not been used as an instrument to oppress the civilian population as it has been used in some totalitarian countries. The soldier, the volunteer of the Irish Army, to call him that instead of calling him, according to this Bill, the man who is a member of Óglaigh na hEireann, is one who has been charged with the defence of this country. He is not equipped, and he cannot be equipped on account of the faulty and undeveloped economy of this country, with the highest technical weapons such as some Deputies might demand. To my mind, he is to be one of a corps which should act as a kernel for the organisation of the whole of the population in a time of emergency against any danger which would threaten.

The Army itself is not capable or sufficient, nor would it be intended by any sane Government, to defend this country on its own. When the previous Government, quite rightly, within limitations—they may be criticised as much as some Deputies on this side wish to criticise them—acted on the principle of enlarging the scope of the Army by bringing in the civilian population to the greatest extent in harmony with the armed forces they were on the correct path. That principle will be followed by this Government or any other Government. In other words, this Army is the basis, as I have urged in the past that it should be the basis, for a citizen army of armed citizens, of the workers from the fields and the factories and the workshops who should combine their skill in other occupations with soldierly qualities, who should be properly organised and who should be found a place to act in conjunction with this Army.

Rather than talk so much about military weapons and obsolete weapons, the Minister should take steps within the confines of this Bill, when he lays down regulations as to Army training, to see that the Army is trained, especially and more particularly now than ever, in methods of guerilla warfare, in warfare such as was waged by civilian armies throughout Europe against the totalitarian hordes who were oppressing them, denying them nationhood and occupying their country as conquering forces. More than that our Army cannot be asked to do and more than that no Minister for Defence can be asked to do. He can use the Army as a peace-time weapon to get ready for such eventualities as that. If he has grandiose ambitions, if he leans back like Deputy Childers to consider a vision of what may happen in future with millions of armed men marching across western Europe and doing this, that and the other, he might consider bedecking himself in Napoleonic robes to organise an Irish Army to make one grand defence against an enemy. But everyone knows that that is merely comic opera. It does not have any basis in reality to-day.

The best thing that the Minister for Defence can do in case of any attack on the liberties of this country by any nation, near or far, is to disappear as a Minister for Defence and to go on the run, as he is well accustomed to doing, or as his successors would be accustomed to doing, and see to it that most of the Army went on the run to take up a position to make impossible a continuance of any occupation of this country. It might be possible, if we could stage, as has been suggested, a fairly good scrap, to prevent a landing on our coast, but everyone who has any acquaintance with modern warfare, the slightest civilian acquaintance, knows that we would be incurring the heaviest sacrifices for the least possible return for the good of the country.

Rather than do that, we might very well think of trading space for time. We might be so drilled or trained that we would get the maximum support from the civilian population and we might make it impossible, or so very costly for an enemy to continue in occupation of this country that he would think twice about doing that, particularly as he would not, no matter which side he came from, be permitted to make his landing or to continue his occupation peacefully. We must see to it that the Army is an army which has the greatest confidence of the civilian population so that they can both harness their efforts to defend the neutrality of the country to which all Parties in the State are pledged. We should see to it that any country infringing that neutrality will be given to understand that it is a dangerous and a hazardous thing to continue to disrespect the declared wishes of the Irish people in reference to this whole question.

The training of the masses of the people may not come directly under the scope of the Bill, but it certainly is a matter of supreme moment. It is difficult, I am sure, for a Minister for Defence, particularly when he is a soldier himself, to get the military under his command to look at these matters in the way that would be most effective from the point of view of the arguments that I am advancing now I do not know whether it is a good thing for a General to be a Minister for Defence. I doubt it myself, though I have the greatest respect for the present occupant of the office and I think he is more of a civilian than a militarist.

I move the adjournment of the debate.

Comment on this