Nomination of Members of Government: Motion of Approval.
Contributions 1–164 of 338. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Tairgim:—
Go gcomhaontóidh Dáil Éireann leis an Taoiseach d'ainmniú na dTeachtaí seo a leanas chun a gceaptha ag an Uachtarán chun bheith ina gcomhaltaí den Rialtas:—
That Dáil Éireann approve the nomination by the Taoiseach of the following Deputies for appointment by the President to be members of the Government:—
Seán F. Lemass,
Seán Mac an tSaoi,
Séamas Ó Riain,
Proinsias Mac Aogáin,
Tomás Ó Deirg,
Gearóid Ó Beoláin,
Oscar Mac Tréinfhir,
Seán Ó Maoláin,
Pádraig Mac Gabhann,
Erskine Childers, agus
Tomás Breathnach.
It is not necessary that I should indicate the portfolios. I have had very little time to decide on these finally, but for the moment, with certain provision which I have mentioned, we have the following: Seán F. Lemass to be Minister for Industry and Commerce, and I propose also to nominate him as Tánaiste; Seán MacEntee to be Minister for Finance; Séamas Ó Riain, to hold provisionally the two portfolios of Social Welfare and Health; Prionsias Mac Aogáin to be Minister for External Affairs; Tomás Ó Deirg to be Minister for Lands; Gearóid Ó Beoláin to be Minister for Justice; Oscar Traynor to be Minister for Defence; Seán Ó Maoláin to be Minister for Education; Pádraig Mac Gabhann to be Minister for Local Government; Erskine Childers to be Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, and Tomás Breathnach to be Minister for Agriculture.
Lest what I have said about reservations would be misunderstood, I wish to say that I had not an opportunity of doing this with the care that I should exercise ordinarily if I had time and therefore these appointments are to be regarded as not finally fixed. I expect that they will in fact be fixed and that there will be very little change, probably no change at all.
In regard to Social Welfare and Health, I think these two portfolios are too heavy for one individual to carry for any length of time, but it is desirable in regard to these Departments that the Minister who had been in touch with them should hold the joint office just for a short while, until we understand what the situation in those Departments is. I want to point out to the Dáil that these are not fixed.
Comment on this
The motion is: "That the Dáil approve the nomination by the Taoiseach of the persons named, for appointment by the President to be members of the Government."
Comment on this
When the Dáil has approved of the appointment of a Deputy as Taoiseach, it would be normal and natural that it would be left within his discretion to appoint the members of his Government and to allocate to those members so appointed their different portfolios. I appreciate the difficulty which the Taoiseach has in finally announcing the allocation of his portfolios amongst the various members of the Government to-night. Accordingly, I do not wish to criticise or in any way comment upon that allocation. I feel bound, however, in view of the peculiar circumstances in which this Government was formed, to register a protest against it.
During the course of the discussion to-day on the nomination of Taoiseach, various Deputies took the opportunity in their speeches to give their interpretations of the results of the General Election. So far as I was personally concerned, I interpreted the result of that election as a direction to me, so far as it was possible, to form a Government on the basis of an inter-Party Government.
In offering myself, or allowing myself to be nominated, I felt that I was doing what the majority of the electors desired me to do. I have no doubt that the vast majority of the electors desired an inter-Party Government. I have equally no doubt that some of the Independent Deputies who voted against the inter-Party Government were voting against the very people who elected them to this Dáil even as Independent Deputies. It is, therefore, because of the action of these Independents rather than anything to do with the Taoiseach or the members of his proposed Government of his Party that I am to-night registering a protest.
I want, if I may, a Chinn Chomhairle, with your permission, to refer just briefly in passing to a very outrageous suggestion that was made by Deputy Peadar Cowan this afternoon against me. At the time, I intervened very hurriedly but I hope emphatically to state that there was no truth whatever in that suggestion. I want to repeat here in public to-night that it was a false, shameless and foundless suggestion, giving a real impression of the type of Deputy who was capable of making that charge. I was personally thanked and my colleagues were thanked by the particular individual concerned for giving him merely information which he asked for last night at a late hour from me and which I gave him. I made no offer whatever to direct his choice. I gave him facts for which he asked; I gave him information for which he asked, and I was personally thanked this morning by him on the telephone for what I had done. That Deputy Cowan should have made such a charge against me. I repeat, is outrageous, false and utterly without foundation and I want to have that repudiation both of the charge and of Deputy Cowan's action in making the charge on the records of this House.
We as an Opposition approach our task and duty as an Opposition in the same spirit as we approached the task of forming and carrying out the inter-Party Government of this country three and a quarter years ago. We joined together as a group and my colleagues did me the profound and lasting honour of asking me to lead them with the sole purpose and desire of doing what was proper and good for the people of this country and for the Irish nation. There was not one single one of us that wanted any office for ourselves. We wanted to give whatever contribution we had to give in the circumstances existing three and a quarter years ago. I believe that we gave a notable contribution to the history of this country, to the economics of this country and to the prosperity of the people of this country.
When I found myself in the position that I did find myself in as a result of this General Election, I made no bargain with anybody. In so far as I was concerned, there was nobody on offer for me. It was perfectly plain from the manner in which I had conducted the Government of this country for three and a quarter years that I was available for anyone that wished to consult with me, to confer with me or to have any information from me. That was the attitude I adopted in connection with the formation, or possible formation, of a Government for anyone who wanted to see me. Nobody got any offer or any guarantee from me. There was no Independent, so far as I was concerned, that was on offer to me or was capable of being sold to me. I was prepared to do what I believe the Irish people wanted me to do, if it was possible, to form an inter-Party Government in accordance with the mandate they had given. I make no suggestions as to the motives which affected any Independent Deputy in what he did. That is a matter between him and his constituents and his own conscience but I do register the protest here against the action of these people who, I believe, have acted contrary to the mandate of their electorates. They have put the Government in a very difficult position, a position in which the Taoiseach was elected by the slenderest majority in the history of this House, a majority which probably would not have been secured had we not felt it our duty to do what perhaps we might not have done, to nominate a Ceann Comhairle. We felt that even by doing that we had lost what might be regarded as a valuable vote in the subsequent voting that had to take place. We felt that we were bound to carry out our public duty and to see that the business of the country was carried on.
Now, just as we approached the task of forming a Government three and a quarter years ago in that spirit of giving our services to the Irish nation and the Irish people, with that same spirit we approach the task of carrying on the Opposition to the present Government. I think it is a good thing in a democratic country that there should be an Opposition. To this present Government, formed as it is, with the tail that it has, it is a very great safeguard to the Irish people that we have a strong and united Opposition. As we were in a Party Government, so I believe we will be in opposition and we will not, I believe, do what the Fianna Fáil Party did, when they were in opposition, oppose for opposition's sake.
So far as we are able to give any contribution in assisting the Government in tasks that are necessary and proper and for the benefit of the people, they will get every assistance and co-operation from us. But we will, I believe, be a vigilant and a very watchful Opposition. We will take care that the liberties of the people are safeguarded so far as we can secure it, and I believe it will require the utmost vigilance on our part to see there is no victimisation and no encroachment upon the liberties either of free speech or free expression of opinion or freedom of association in whatever period this Government may retain office. That assurance I wish to give to the Taoiseach and his proposed Government, that we will not oppose merely for opposition's sake, that we will give them co-operation so far as they are carrying on the policies of which we approve and which we believe are in the interests of the country.
We have ended to-day, or rather, I should say, put a period to an unfinished chapter of Irish history. It is a bright chapter in Irish history, I can say, for myself and my colleagues. It is an unfinished chapter, because I believe the Irish people will again at the next election, be it sooner or later, in no uncertain way, emphasise what they wanted at this election, an inter-Party Government of the type that had carried on this country for three and a quarter years with such beneficial results. Therefore, the record that we leave behind us is a record of unfinished work. We have had a very short time within which to carry on the work we set out to do. Short as it was, we did beneficial work. We hope to see that the present Government will continue that work and we will be watchful to see that it is continued properly, efficiently and well.
In particular, one of the outstanding features of the work of the last Government was the work of a capital nature, capital projects financed on the basis on which they were, by means of capital repaid by an annual repayment which appears in the Book of Estimates each year. We will see as far as we can that those capital projects shall be continued and brought to fruition and we will be vigilant and watchful about the course of the works which we have started to see that they are well and truly carried through.
With your permission, a Chinn Chomhairle, I would like to finish what I have to say — I believe it to be relevant in the context of the unfinished work which the last Government left behind them — by paying a tribute to my colleagues in that Government, to each of those colleagues, to each of the Parties which are unbroken here to-day, who worked so hard and gave such loyal service in spite of certain people who acted in their own selfish interests for the purpose of keeping their own seats in the Dáil. We are here to-day as an Opposition with those Parties united; we were never beaten as an inter-Party Government; our Parties never broke away from one another; we faced the country as an inter-Party group and we abide by the result of to-day's decision in the Dáil as an Opposition united and stronger by reason of the association and interchange of ideas we have had during the past three and a quarter years.
I think that we can make a valuable contribution to the welfare of the State in the years that may be before the present Government whether they be long or whether they be short. From all my colleagues, with the exception of one, I got profound loyalty and the hardest work which I believe has ever been put in by a set of people in the interests of this country. We got loyal, faithful service and they spared themselves neither effort, work, time nor energy. No words of mine could express the feelings I have for those people: for William Norton, of the Labour Party, for my colleagues of my own Party, for Joseph Blowick and his colleagues in Clann na Talmhan and for my old friend and loyal colleague, Seán MacBride. For the former Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. I have a special esteem and regard. He was slandered and defamed by people and by Press unjustifiably in connection with a particular incident; his constituents have given the answer to those slanders and those libels. I have left to the very last perhaps the outstanding person in my former Cabinet, James Dillon, the former Minister for Agriculture. The work which he has done will prove to be of lasting value to the farmers and to the general prosperity of the country, not for decades but for centuries to come. He has left a beneficial mark on the land of Ireland and has pointed the way to the future prosperity of the agricultural community. He, too, has received what may possibly be regarded as a tribute from the defamers and slanderers; he has been defamed and slandered and that is the best tribute which anybody can get as a politician in this country. He has left the mark of his genius, his constructive imagination and fertile brain on the agriculture of this country, but we who have sat with him day after day know that he gave a far more valuable contribution than his contribution to agriculture because his mind, his experience and his integrity were always at our disposal in the very difficult problems we had to face during the last three and a quarter years.
I cannot end without expressing the profound gratification and satisfaction which I have, and which will last with me until the end of my days, that I was associated with the Labour Party in an inter-Party Government for the first time in the history of this State. It was to me a matter of profound satisfaction that I worked and worked in the closest harmony, with a unified policy, with no dissensions, no divisions, and no bargaining with the members of the Labour Party, that we in Fine Gael, who were supposed to be conservative, the close-fisted Party, the representatives of the rich if you please, were able to work and find ourselves in close sympathy with the representatives of the working people of this country. That is to me personally a matter of profound satisfaction which will be to me a memory for the rest of my life.
Comment on this
For the past 30 years no Government has even taken office in this country under more favourable circumstances than those in which the present Fianna Fáil Government takes office to-night. Thanks to the work of the past three years we have brought to this nation of ours a domestic peace that it has never known before; we have brought stability to the nation, and we have given our people a standard of living incomparably better than they had in 1947 under the administration of the Government now in office.
One of our first acts on taking office was to repeal the penal taxes which the present Government imposed in 1947 on cigarettes, on tobacco, on beer and on cinema seats. We gave back to the people £6,000,000 per annum by the repeal of these taxes. If the present Government had been in office during the past three and a quarter years they would have siphoned out of the pockets of the people no less than £20,000,000 in taxes on these commodities. We remitted these taxes; the people, therefore, are £20,000,000 better off than they would have been if the Fianna Fáil Government had continued in office since 1948. I want to know now from this Government whether on the minority which they got in the recent election they will reimpose these taxes on the people because they managed to manoeuvre themselves into office to-night. The country is entitled to an answer to that question.
During the past three years the last Government's record in respect to housing has completely eclipsed anything which was done in the realm of housing in this country during the past 30 years. Not only did we gear up the housing machine which we found rusty and creaking in 1948, but we have built during the last three years no less than 24,000 houses which are to be seen in every part of the country. The new Minister for Local Government, on going to the Custom House to-morrow, will find abundant documentary evidence of the fact that the outgoing Government built 24,000 houses for the people during the past three years. Remember that the new Minister for Local Government has good reason to thank Deputy Keyes for the fact that there are 12,000 houses in course of erection and that there is no reason in the world, if that machine is not interfered with by the Fianna Fáil Minister for Local Government, why we should not continue to produce houses at the rate of not less than 12,000 houses per year for the years to come. We have now reached the situation that, given competent government and no niggardly approach to housing, we can solve for all time the housing problem in the large town, in the smaller town, in the village and in the rural area within three years from this date. We can now so organise our housing activity, thanks to the housing machine which Deputy Keyes and his predecessor, the late Tim Murphy, built up, as to ensure that housing will not be an issue in any general election held three years from this date.
Look at this Government's record in respect of employment. We have, during the past three years, put 37,000 additional people into insurable employment. The records are there and they can be examined. Deputy Dr. Ryan can go into the Department of Social Welfare and he will get there to-morrow statistics that will convince him that during the past three years we put 37,000 additional people into employment. There are more people to-day in industrial employment in this country than at any time in the past 30 years. So far as unemployment is concerned, we have reached now an all-time low record. There are less people unemployed in this country to-day than at any time in the past 100 years, and that fact cannot be gainsaid either. Therefore, in the realm of employment or in the realm of unemployment, not only have we put more and more people into work but we have succeeded in keeping our unemployment figures down to a level that we never attained in this country in the past 100 years. That is a record of which we are entitled to feel proud.
Take this Government's record in the field of social services. While our predecessors could not afford a miserable £500,000 for a modification of the means test for old age pension purposes in 1947, we in 1948 introduced the Social Welfare Bill which not only modified the means test but increased old age pensions, blind pensions, widows' and orphans' non-contributory pensions. On that measure alone we spent not the £500,000 we asked Fianna Fáil for in 1947, but an additional £2,500,000 which has gone into the pockets of old age pensioners, blind pensioners and windows and orphans during the past three years and for each of these years. We increased workmen's compensation during our period of office by no less than 33 per cent., bringing the rate of benefit to a higher level than it had ever reached before.
We have given to this Government a cut and dried Bill on social security. It passed through this House on the Second Reading. It is the best Bill this country has ever seen in the sphere of social security. For the first time it gives our people a comprehensive scheme of social security. It gives them benefits they never had in the past 30 years — benefits they did not get under Fianna Fáil's 16 years of office. I want now to ask Deputy Cowan if he has got a guarantee from the Fianna Fáil Government that that scheme will be proceeded with. Has he got a guarantee that that Bill will not be dropped? Has he got a guarantee that the opposition to that Bill, manifested by Fianna Fáil when they were in opposition, will not be pursued by the same Party when it is functioning as a Government? That Bill assured the working people of greater sickness benefits, greater maternity benefits, greater widows' and orphans' pensions, increased unemployment benefits, new death benefits, new retirement pensions, old age pensions of £1 a week, blind pensions of £1 a week, a further modification of the means test and the conditions so modified as to permit thousands of additional persons to qualify for old age pensions who do not qualify under the existing code. That Bill is there. It may be reintroduced into the Dáil next week and it will have the support of the Labour Party and, I hope, of ever other Party concerned with giving a charter of social security to the toiling masses of our people.
We were told by Deputy Lemass in 1948 that Fianna Fáil had a cut and dried scheme on social security in the Department of Social Welfare. We were told that, when Deputy Dr. Ryan was leaving office. I searched the Department's records from top to bottom and I got officials to search the records from top to bottom and the only thing I could find in the Department was a document the size of a quarter of a foolscap sheet of paper on which Deputy Dr. Ryan had written about 20 words not connected with social security at all. The Department is there now. Find your scheme when you go back. You will not. Only one single document of the size of a quarter of a foolscap sheet, with 20 words about social security, in fact, about statistics, could be found in the Department of Social Welfare — showing the abiding care and the deep thought which our predecessors had given to the problem of social security. Produce in this House next week your 1948 scheme. I defy and challenge you to do it now. Not a single thing had been decided. You left us the job of deciding about 500 issues which had to be decided before a scheme of social security could be introduced. Produce the scheme you are supposed to have left there — or apologise for the misrepresentation of 1948. I bet you will do neither.
Look at our health services. In 1947 we were spending £615,000 per annum on our health services. Look at the 1951 Estimates — £4,225,000 made available by the outgoing Government for its health services. Never before was there such a substantial increase for health services as during the period 1947-51.
Look at the national income. In 1947 it was £318,000,000. In 1950 it was £363,000,000 — all denoting the progress and the courageous approach to problems which characterised the Government with which the Labour Party was associated during the last three years.
Turn to our exports. In 1947 our exports were £39,000,000. In 1950 they were £72,000,000 — nearly twice what they were in 1947.
If we turn to economic matters and look at wages, what do we see? We remember in 1947 statements made in this House and statements made on the platform by spokesmen of the Fianna Fáil Party that if the trade unions or workers demanded further compensation than the inadequate compensation which, up to then, they had received for the rise in prices during the emergency, the Fianna Fáil Government would introduce legislation for the purpose of freezing wages. That was the intention in 1947. You even left behind you the draft proposals which you intended to bring before the Dáil to freeze the wages and to prevent the trade unions from exercising the constitutional rights which they have exercised in this country for 75 years, if they dared to try to get compensation for the workers for the depreciation in their standard of living due to the wage freezing policy practised by Fianna Fáil during the emergency. Wage freezing was no part of our policy. Not only did we kill, and I hope kill forever, the wage freezing mentality of our predecessors but, in addition, we dealt liberally, broadly and generously with demands for increased wages wherever these wage increases necessitated Government approval or Government sanction or Government regulation in one way or the other.
The position to-day is that every class of worker in this country has a wage level immeasurably better than he had in 1947. We killed wage freezing, and we killed the mentality behind wage freezing. Our people can now negotiate freely and conclude collective agreements with employers. While we were in office there was never any danger of the Government with which we were associated lending itself to making the trade unions impotent, while the employers were free to fight with both hands, as the last Government planned to do. We have given to our people to-day, and it is acknowledged by everybody who has any contact with the workers, a standard of living immeasurably better than they had in 1947. Organised bodies like the teachers had striven for arbitration for 30 years and civil servants had striven for arbitration for a like period.
We have given arbitration boards so that disputes between them, on the one hand, and the executive Government on the other hand, may be arbitrated upon, free from the element of coercion and free from any suggestion of injustice — arbitrated upon and pronounced upon by an independent chairman mutually acceptable to both sides. By that we have brought into the teaching profession and into the Civil Service a measure of contentment that never previously existed. They know now that the last word does not rest with the Minister. They know now that an independment mind will be brought to bear on their problems, on the injustices under which they may suffer, and that, subject to the overriding authority of the people's Parliament, this Assembly, they can now get a verdict implemented once they secure that verdict from an independent arbitrator.
Let us come to the field of agriculture. We have brought to agriculture a prosperity that it never previously experienced. You can get as much to-day for a rabbit as you could get for a calf when Fianna Fáil were in office. We have brought to the farmer a prosperity that he has never previously enjoyed. We have given to the agricultural worker increased wages, and, if we were in office for another week or two, he would have got a further increase in wages. We had given him holidays with pay, and we have given him a weekly half-holiday. These three things have been done in three years, and not a single one of them was done during the 16 years that the Fianna Fáil Government was in office.
Yes, and we have done more than that. We repealed the External Relations Act——
Comment on this
——the greatest fraud and make-believe that was ever inflicted on this country. The Labour Party can claim this pride and this privilege that when that Bill was going through the House we voted against it then because it was a deception. It was a make-believe, and we have had the privilege of seeing it off the Statute Book of this country, maintaining all the time the same consistent line in 1949 that we had adopted in 1938, when we tried to persuade that Government not to proceed with such an odious Act of Parliament.
We now, at all events, have made our constitutional position clear before the world. The murkiness and the muddiness of our constitutional position is gone, and gone for ever. We no longer have to explain to a foreigner the kind of Republic we are because they could never understand the kind of Republic which kept the President in residence in the Park and in the background, while we used a British King to accredit our representatives to foreign countries. That type of magpie republic is gone. The bird is now one colour. This Republic is one colour. It has got a President. He is the domestic head here, and he is the external head who accredits our representatives to foreign countries, and we have dispensed with the services of his Britannic Majesty.
I listened over the last three years to speeches made by members of the Fianna Fáil Party regretting the repeal of the External Relations Act. I challenge them now to reintroduce it and stop the lamentations about it having been repealed. Let them reintroduce it, and let those opposite who dearly love a king have something to play with for their short period in office.
We cleared up that mess. We put the President in his rightful place in this country. He is our domestic head and he is our external head, and nobody now doubts his authority. We have ceased to have to explain the unusual kind of Republic which, as I say, kept the President in the background and which found a British King as the organ of our external relations with other Powers. That make-believe is over. There is no further need to worry about our constitutional status here. The world knows it, and if you leave the situation as it is to-day you will never get yourself into the same mess that you were in from 1938 until 1949.
Yes, and we have done more even than that. There is not a single political prisoner in an Irish jail to-day. This was the first Government for 30 years that never passed a coercion Bill through this Dáil, and our Government was the first Government which had no executions. We had no military tribunals, and because of that we brought to the country the peace which it knows to-day. Leave that position so. Do not get lonely, and do not go hankering after the strife, the bitterness and the acrimony which had disgraced public life here for too many years.
I want to put this to the House, that nowhere in the long and chequered career of our people has more progress been made than was made during the past three years and made under difficult circumstances, under circumstances which were not conducive to large-scale spectacular programmes. Will Deputy Lemass look up the speech which he made in Letterkenny in October, 1947? He said that, surveying the international and national scene, in his view, the four years — 1948, 1949, 1950 and 1951 — were, in his own words, "to be the hardest and the grimmest years in Irish life". It was against that background that we took office. It was against that background that we managed to make these near-miracle achievements. It was against that background of promised hardships and grimness that we were able to do the things which we have done during the past three years.
Comment on this
There was no grimness or harshness for the past three years because, in so far as it was a correct diagnosis of the situation, we shielded the people against it.
Comment on this
Look up your Fermoy speech now. We go out of office to-night. I, speaking for the Labour Party in this matter, am proud of our record over the past three years, proud especially of the part which the Labour Party played in the outgoing Government and proud of the things they succeeded in getting done under the auspices of that Government. I want to say to the new Taoiseach if you intend to continue that good work, if you intend to introduce in this House measures which will make for the betterment and well-being of our people the full support of the Labour Party may be assumed. I have to say at the same time that wage freezing or repression will not be tolerated by the Labour Party and governmental indifference and indolence will not be tolerated. We will give support to every good measure, to every progressive measure and everything aimed at improving the standard of life of our people but we will be no party either to an activity or to the enactment of measures which are not calculated to improve the lot of our people. This Government has a hard task to live up to our record.
Comment on this
Well you know it. I bet you this. You will not be a month older until the Taoiseach will be telling you that.
Comment on this
I bet you that within a month's time you will be anchored to the hair shirt economics of the Fianna Fáil Party. However, we can watch the efforts of this Government with more than usual interest because it is a rare and strange combination.
Away back in 1948 Deputy Cogan gave utterance to these views when the Government of that day was being elected. At column 33 of the Official Dáil Debates, dated 18th February, 1948, he said:
"There are two logical courses before us. We must adopt either this idea of representation of all Parties or abolish the system of proportional representation. The two things do not fit; the system by which the people elected the Dáil, the system of proportional representation, does not fit in with the idea of Party Government. We must either abolish one or the other and I am hoping that to-day we will, for all time, abolish the idea of Party Government in this country."
Deputy Cogan, whatever his other deficiencies may be, cannot say that somersaulting is one of them. In the same speech he described the present Taoiseach as King Herod who sought to annihilate small Parties just as Herod was anxious to annihilate small children.
Comment on this
And he prayed then that Deputy de Valera would not again be given the power to wreak possible vengeance on the Deputy Cogans who are merely managing to live a rather hazardous existence. He said more than that. He selected Deputy MacEntee for special mention. The other Deputies and the Ministers in the Fianna Fáil Party ought not to get unduly jealous of this, especially when I read the tribute to Deputy MacEntee.
Comment on this
It will bear repetition. Deputy Cogan then said:—
"When I tried to instil into the mind of that senile delinquent, the Minister for Local Government, some sense of responsibility and when I reminded him of the danger of midwinter election which would inflict a grave injustice on a large section of the rural population by depriving them of their right to vote I was told by that gentleman that I was suffering from cold feet."
Deputy Cogan's feet apparently have not warmed since then.
Comment on this
The reference, Sir, is at column 30 of the Official Dáil Debates of the 18th February, 1948. That is the view Deputy Cogan has of Deputy MacEntee, a senile delinquent and that is what he is going to vote for this evening—a senile delinquent, as the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Let us be clear on this. Let Deputy Cogan's constituents be clear on this. He has voted to-day for the Taoiseach who thought so little of Deputy Cogan's views that he has come back here this evening with, as Minister for Finance, a person who Deputy Cogan said was a senile delinquent in 1948 and God knows what deterioration has set in in the meantime. Is that what Deputy Cogan's electors authorised him to do? Did they give him authority to vote for a person certified to be a senile delinquent by the said Deputy Cogan. I certainly would love to see the rather touching and tearful reconciliation between Deputy Cogan and Deputy MacEntee. One can imagine what that reconciliation would be like. I would like to know from Deputy Cogan to-night whether he is going into the lobby to vote for the person he described in such rude and vulgar terms in 1948 and to elect him as Minister for Finance now. Deputy Cogan owes it to the House and to his constituents to say whether he asked them for votes to vote for a person who is so deficient in qualifications for a post as Deputy MacEntee is in the eyes of Deputy Cogan.
Deputy Cowan told the Taoiseach yesterday that the reason he was voting for Fianna Fáil was as a protest against the Irish Bishops' interference in politics.
Comment on this
I can go to my constituents and get a renewal of confidence every time because they know me. Deputy Cowan a few years ago was frequently criticised and, indeed, on many occasions, blackguarded by Deputy MacEntee for being the Czarlike chief of the Vanguard organisation which Deputy MacEntee wrote down as the wildest and most irresponsible Communistic organisation in Europe. Deputy Cowan knows how he was abused by Deputy MacEntee about the Vanguard organisation, and Deputy Boland, the present Minister for Justice, took a hand in lambasting Deputy Cowan as well about the Vanguard organisation. We all know that.
Comment on this
Why has Deputy Cowan so many defenders on the Fianna Fáil Benches to-night? Does not everybody know that Deputy Cowan was lambasted by this House because of his associations with the Vanguard organisations. He is now engaged in propping up the Government composed of the people who did the lambasting, and he has demoted himself from being the Vanguard of the people to being the mudguard of Fianna Fáil. There will be another touching reconciliation when Deputy Cowan meets his lambasters.
I remember on one occasion, I think it was in 1948, when the present Taoiseach spent a substantial amount of his time and energy in a denunciation of what he described as mixum gatherum Governments. Is this the kind of Government you had in mind? He has got a collection of every kind now, political flotsam and jetsam to try to keep Fianna Fáil in office, and I am telling you that I wish him the best of luck with some of them. I would not have the support of some of the gentlemen at any price.(Interruptions.) You are now going into office. Conduct yourselves. Now that you are a Government Party you cannot go round doing the rowdy.
This Government will take office now. Deputy Cogan and Deputy Captain Cowan both hope that they will last for five years because elections are perilous things for them and they will do their best to hang on to the Fianna Fáil lifeboat and keep it up, no matter how tempestuous the seas may be.
Comment on this
I do not think that the lifeboat will ride the seas so very long. I prophesy for it a short and ineffective career, and I wish you and the tight-rope walkers that are supporting you the best of luck.
There is one warning I will give you. While you remain in office, short though that period may be, keep your hands off the workers' wages and keep your hands out of the people's pockets.
Comment on this
I am intervening because of a very bitter statement made by the Taoiseach against me this evening. I will now quote from the Official Report what I said to-day. Deputy Dillon, when speaking, made the suggestion that certain Independents who, apparently, were for sale had found themselves in the Fianna Fáil shop windows. I consider that a rather nasty suggestion. It was a suggestion that was pursued by Deputy O. Flanagan and other Deputies subsequently.
Comment on this
A dirty campaign was carried out against those Independents who had the courage to do what they thought right. I was never asked by any body, Fianna Fáil or inter-Party, to vote for them until to-day. I was asked definitely—and I must say this—would I vote for the inter-Party if a Labour man was nominated as Taoiseach. I said I had my mind made up and I would not.
Comment on this
That was at 3 o'clock. At 3 o'clock I was fawned on by everybody. At 4 o'clock I was a dirty scoundrel. Now here is the official record of what I said to-day after Deputy Dillon spoke:—
"Captain Cowan: In case some of Deputy Dillon's speech might be misinterpreted, I think that if we were to have a discussion with three of his colleagues—the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and Deputy Dr. O'Higgins —we would find how difficult they found it in the early hours of this morning to persuade a young Independent Deputy to act against his conscience and his convictions.
The Taoiseach: A Chinn Chomhairle, I wish here and now to repudiate the suggestion made by Deputy Cowan. There is no truth whatever in it.
Mr. Dillon: The Deputy knows that it is not true.
Captain Cowan: No interviews with an Independent Deputy this morning?
Mr. Dillon: Did I not say we interviewed you and everyone else and were proud to do it, but scorned to say we would buy them.
Captain Cowan: No one is talking about buying, but to persuade a young Independent Deputy to act against his conscience."
That is the Official Report. I ask Deputy John A. Costello and Deputy William Norton, who has just left the House, and Deputy Dr. O'Higgins did they this morning see a young Independent Deputy and spend hours with him. If they did, for what purpose? In the early hours of this morning when all decent Deputies were asleep in their beds getting ready for to-day were the inter-Party interviewing this young Independent Deputy? For what purpose? Was it to get him to vote for the inter-Party set-up or was it not? And then Deputy John A. Costello has the temerity to stand up here and make the offensive and bitter speech he made against me here a few moments ago.
Comment on this
It is absolutely true, and it was not half bitter enough.
Comment on this
No. There is nothing too bitter for me in doing what is right, namely removing people from the Government side of the House, people that I think are not fit to be in Government and putting them over there in Opposition.
Comment on this
The bitterness was founded upon the Deputy's allegations and the unfounded charge made against me and my colleagues.
Comment on this
The Deputy heard part of it. Then the Deputy comes in here to make a bitter, nasty speech against me. I do not mind that. I am used to bitterness in public life. I am used to being maliciously and slanderously attacked. I have survived it so far and I will survive it in the future. It is shocking to think that in this inter-Party set up there are types such as some of the types that appeared here to-day with their dirty muck and mud slinging just because I did what I thought was right. Had I voted for Deputy John A. Costello and kept him in Government I would now be a very fine fellow and anyone that would dare to attack me would get their answer from my colleagues. Colleagues! I am only learning something now about the dirtiness of political life and the alleged friendliness and loyalty of colleagues.
For the reasons I stated to-day I made up my mind that I would vote against the inter-Party Government. I made no promise to my constituents that I would support the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
If my constituents understood anything at all they understood that I had brought about the general election and I had caused the inter-Party Government to go to the country. I was completely astonished at that Government's attitude in the Dr. Browne crisis. I thought that a Government that acted as they did in that crisis was not fit to be a Government in this or any other country. I gave due and solemn warning here when the Estimate for the Minister for Agriculture was being debated that I would vote against it. Had I and some of my colleagues voted against it we would have defeated the Government. In order to avoid defeat the Government postponed the Vote and then went to the country. No one can say that I went before the electorate to support the inter-Party Government. Had any one of my constituents asked me the question during the election I would have told them that I would have to think twice before I would vote for an inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
I was asked what would I do and I told them that I would do what I thought was right and I would explain my reasons for my action in the right place, namely, in this House. I have done that to-day. I can laugh now when I hear Deputy Costello and Deputy Norton talking about the great Opposition they will be. Do we not all know that the half of them will never appear in this House again?
Comment on this
I shall be here doing my duty in this House but I can say that a very large proportion of the Deputies over there will be very seldom in this House in future. I know they will be looking after their private business as they did when they were in Opposition before.
Comment on this
There is one set of people who will not bring about the defeat of this Government and that is the group that is over there.
Comment on this
Maybe. It is one of those things about which I do not think anybody need have any qualms of conscience. If the Fianna Fáil Government bring in a measure, which I think is not right, I shall say so and I shall vote against it. I do not think anyone need have any doubt about that. If, on the other hand, I think it is a good measure and that it should be supported, I shall support it. In doing that I shall be carrying out my rôle as an Independent Deputy who is tied neither to Fianna Fáil, to Fine Gael nor to anybody else in this House. Deputy Norton refers to the flotsam and jetsam. That would have been very welcome to Deputy Norton to-day. He would have clutched at it, and held on to it to-day if he could, but he did not. I am sorry about one thing. Here we had an inter-Party Government. They seemed to be very fine fellows, very nice, very courteous and gentlemanly while they were over here but now that they are over there what are they? Cornered rats.
Comment on this
Certainly, I withdraw it. I am not concerned with who laughs at it or who does not laugh. As I have said, they were very nice, courteous and gentle on one side but we see another aspect when they are on the other side. We see bitterness obtruding itself and bubbling out over there. We hear the snarl. If that snarl reminds people of anything, well let them have their own thoughts about it. Anyway I intervened only to nail that suggestion of Deputy Costello that I stated anything that was wrong here to-day. I stated the truth and he knows it.
Comment on this
Let me take it by stages. I want to know did they interview this Independent Deputy for hours this morning?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins will answer you if he gets the opportunity but he will answer in regular fashion and in accordance with the rules of parliamentary procedure.
Comment on this
I shall leave that answer to the judgment of the House for Deputies to make their own deduction from it. In other words, in the early hours of the morning they were down explaining to this Deputy what a fine fellow he was for acting in accordance with his conscience in voting against them.
Comment on this
Three Deputies interviewed this Independent Deputy this morning—a Taoiseach, a Tánaiste and a Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
I am taking it step by step. First, I am satisfied they were there; secondly, I am satisfied that that morning exercise was not just for the sake of their natural health although it might be of some advantage to their political health. However, I do not want to say anything about it. Three Ministers saw that young man this morning. This man, it was known, had been elected for a particular purpose. They were not there to suggest that he should vote against his conscience — not at all.
Comment on this
I think I have exposed the bitterness of the attack made on me to-day by Deputy Costello. I did not expect that form of bitterness from him. I was prepared to leave what I said to-day on the record.
Comment on this
I was prepared to leave it as it stood on the record. I am prepared to leave it there now and to leave it to every person who is listening to me to judge who was and who was not correct.
Comment on this
Statements have been made and insinuations and implications put forward by Deputy Cowan with regard to a young Deputy who has entered this House for the first time to-day. I do not know that young gentleman personally. I met him last night for the first time. I believe him to be an honourable gentleman and I would be prepared to leave it to that Deputy to ram these untruths down Deputy Cowan's neck. The circumstances are these. A representation was made to the then Taoiseach that there was one young Deputy who had to cast an important vote to-day, the first he had ever cast in the nation's Parliament and that he wanted to know as clearly as he could what steps were being taken with regard to the mother and child scheme and to what extent it had progressed. The Taoiseach, as I think his successor would do, agreed to meet that young Deputy and to give him all the information that he possibly could. He asked me to be present as a medical Deputy and as the person who had been in touch with the Medical Union and our late colleague, Deputy Dr. Browne. We met that young gentleman together with a businessman of repute and standing in this city who, I expect, will answer Deputy Cowan in the public Press. We gave that young gentleman, who is a member of this House and can speak for himself, all the information that we could with regard to the health scheme and the Taoiseach refused to attempt to prophesy the developments of the future.
The Deputy understood his position and we understood ours. In the whole of that interview, he was not asked for his vote by any one of us. He said he wanted to know the facts and the circumstances, get the maximum amount of knowledge and then make up his mind for himself as to what he should do. One remark I did make. I said:—
"You are a young Deputy, a professional colleague of mine. You have just come into the Dáil. You have got as much information as we can give. Do not make the mistake of lying ‘doggo.' I shall have respect for you if you go into the other Division Lobby and vote for Deputy de Valera. I will have none if you lie ‘doggo' and go neither to the right nor to the left."
Comment on this
I do not know what is the intention of the Government in regard to the Adjournment. Normally, the procedure would be to adjourn now as it is 10.30 p.m.
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I respectfully submit that it is manifestly unlikely that those who wish to contribute to this debate will find it possible to do so within reasonable limitations of time to-night and, without the slightest desire of unduly protracting the business, may I suggest an adjournment? I take it from the Taoiseach that that will not seriously inconvenience him.
Comment on this
There is, I suppose. The point is, is it desirable that you should have a Taoiseach on one side and members of the Government on the other?
Comment on this
It is obvious that there could not be a division after half-past ten without agreement. Of course the House can do anything by unanimous agreement, but it must be unanimous.
Comment on this
Would it be possible to agree to sit in the morning at 10.30 and undertake to-night to finish by a particular hour to-morrow?
Comment on this
Would it not be better if we could finish to-night? There are Financial Bills to be dealt with.
Comment on this
I think it would be better if we could finish to-night. I do not know whether it would meet with the approval of the House that we should sit until 2 a.m. or not later than 2 a.m.
Comment on this
This is a matter of very great importance, and I think the House, especially the Government, would be unwise in limiting the time for the discussion. I am sure the Taoiseach will agree that this is something which should be finished to-night. We have started it and let us get through it even if we have to sit until 6 a.m. It is public business of importance and we must go on with it. I think Deputies should not be prevented from speaking as long as they like. If a Deputy desires to speak for hours, he should be permitted to do so.
Comment on this
I take it it is unanimously agreed to put the question not later than 2 a.m. There is another matter I should like to mention for my own convenience. I assume that the House will agree that the Deputies who act as Deputy-Chairmen should continue to act.
Agreed.
Comment on this
I had not intended to take part in this debate and I only intervened on that one point. I regret very much that the gallant Captain, who was so free with his charges 20 minutes ago, has beaten a retreat in face of a challenge and I ask that that should go on the records of this House. When he asked me as one Deputy to answer certain points and give a certain account and that was in process of being given he skedaddled. But, as I said earlier, I am prepared, in the main, to listen to the Deputy who voted against this Party to-day— Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll. At no time during that interview, which was not sought by the then Taoiseach or any member of the then Government, was there any attempt whatsoever made to influence that young Deputy to vote in our favour or against his conscience, as stated. What we were determined was to give him the fullest information as to the progress of the mother and child scheme in the belief, and in view of the propaganda that was used during the election, that if there was full knowledge of the progress made and the rapidity with which the work was being dealt with he, in his own judgment, and one colleague of his at least who campaigned on the ground that there would be no mother and child scheme, if he were honest, would change his attitude with regard to the continuation of the life of the Government.
Moreover, as evidence that there was no attempt to influence that young Deputy or his vote, he asked, on leaving the room, was he free to give to Deputy Dr. Browne all the information we had given him last night. The answer he got was that he was not only free to give all that information to Deputy Dr. Browne but that he was free to give it to anybody or everybody else; that there was no prohibition, that he could publish it in the public Press. He thanked the then Taoiseach profusely for his kindness and courtesy, in view of the very heavy strain on him at that time, for having given so much of his time to explaining the position. He rang up this morning again to thank the then Taoiseach, Deputy Norton and myself for what he referred to as our great kindness and patience in dealing with him. That is the answer to Deputy Cowan. I do not believe there is a Deputy that doubts the truth of what Deputy John A. Costello stated and what I am stating now. When you read the name of the outsider that was there with Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll and when you read his statement as against that statement, you can measure the worth or the worthlessness of Deputy Captain Peadar Cowan.
Comment on this
I said to Deputy Cowan, when he was speaking, that, consciously or unconsciously, he was disgracing himself. I am certain that, when he has perused all that falls to be said of the incident to which he referred, he will be ashamed that he so far amazed those who knew him from afar only, and who heretofore have felt that, though he might often be misguided, he was straight and honest in speaking of things as he saw them. I do not mind confessing he took me in, but that is the way he seemed to me. He can never seem so again, and I do not think he can blame me for amending my evaluation of him by his disreputable performance this evening.
I want to intervene, Sir, in respect of something which is very precious to me. When I entered the Department of Agriculture I found installed there Deputy Patrick Smith's ten fields of inspectors. They were scheduled for the annual axe which was to throw them into temporary unemployment in June to be remustered in October for the chastening of recalcitrant farmers throughout the country. I abolished their functions but was happy to get Government sanction for their permanent employment, not in the role of bailiffs and emergency men, but in the role of land project officers who considered it a privilege to call on farmers at their invitation and in the proud capacity of public servants. Deputy Smith nailed his agricultural policy colours to the mast in eloquent, incisive and picturesque language. I would remind the Taoiseach, when he asks in such moving accents for co-operation from the Opposition to-day, of the six blessed hours that I sat in front of his new Minister for Local Government while he regaled me with variations on a theme of ten fields of inspectors for recalcitrant farmers when my Estimate came up for discussion in this House.
One of the most significant things that happened since Deputy Lemass was sent to Tipperary a month ago to announce that Fianna Fáil had abandoned compulsory tillage is the announcement to-night by the Taoiseach that he has abandoned Deputy Smith and that Deputy Smith is now in the dog house on the quay — the agricultural prophet, Deputy Smith, whose prospective occupation of the Department of Agriculture moved Deputy Jack Flynn, the champion of the small farmer, to see in Upper Merrion Street a little farmer instead of a 50-acre rancher like Deputy Dillon. Deputy Flynn must feel distressed to discover that the little farmer from Cavan has been thrown overboard with his ten fields of inspectors and his policy. But, appropriately enough, if one can envisage him with an anchor tied around his neck, he has been relegated to the quays as Minister for Local Government. What humiliation, what degredation will prove excess for the faithful servants of Fianna Fáil? Will they be required to lie down in public to have boots wiped on them before they revolt against the dismal discipline of the solid Party?
I felt that when my wretched predecessor was repudiated contemptuously by Deputy Lemass at Tipperary he would have approached his leader and asked him to redress the situation in the country. But he did not; he took it like a man, or the Fianna Fáil notion of a man. The man who was going to break down the farmers' fences, burst in their gates and bring them to the subjection of his illuminated will spoke prophetically because he bowed his neck for the yoke; when political expediency directed Deputy Lemass and Deputy de Valera to hold on to the two sides he bowed his neck to have the yoke locked about him. I do not mind his disappearance—his grotesque disappearance to the quays; he was ludicrous as Minister for Agriculture; he will be a harmless joke in the Custom House.
I note that he was replaced by a Deputy who, when he was named, caused the whisper to run around the benches: "Who is this fellow? Where did he come from?" because Deputy Tom Walsh had suddenly developed into "An Teachta Tomás Breathnach". Now Deputy Thomas Walsh could not bid the cat good morning in Irish. His knowledge of Irish begins with "A chara" and ends with "Mise le meas mór," and I doubt if he knows the "mór." But he is now an Teachta Tomás Breathnach. Having identified the Gael as Deputy Tom Walsh of Kilkenny, I discover that he is Minister for Agriculture. Now, contemptible as has been the prostration of Deputy Smith and his chastisement by Deputy Lemass and Deputy Childers, what shall we say of Deputy Walsh who was brought crawling to Castlecomer in his own constituency, bidden to attend before Deputy de Valera and in his presence to say that he had never advocated compulsory tillage, that all he had done was, when rebuking Deputy Dillon for his lack of foresight and prudence, to say across the floor of the House: "Should you continue in this reckless way, you may create a situation in which no tillage will be done save under compulsion." I challenge Deputy Thomas Walsh to deny that he said that in Castlecomer. I have the report of it and I will produce it on request.
That is the man who on the night before the last Dáil adjourned said that he was proud to say that he had always believed and then believed in compulsory tillage as the right agricultural policy of this country, and who when the House re-assembled on the following day — it was Deputy Tom Walsh who moved the adjournment — and when he was called upon by the Chair to resume the debate — this is all in the Official Record of this House — said that since the previous night he had been jibed for that somebody in the heat of debate had goaded him into espousing compulsory tillage, and he wanted to say now, after a night's reflection, in cold and calm deliberation, that whoever else in the Fianna Fáil Party might have views on that subject, he wanted to say what his view was, and that was that compulsory tillage should be a permanent feature of the agricultural policy of this country in fair weather and in foul.
That is a legitimate view, and I do not condemn him for staunchly standing for his view. I disagree with him, but where are we going if a Deputy, who on the eve of a general election makes such a statement, goes before his own constituents with these words on his lips and in the knowledge that, as was the annual custom of the Department of Agriculture, the Official Report of the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture would be sent to every county committee of agriculture for their perusal, and in the knowledge that these statements are on record, submits to the grotesque humiliation of being dragged down to Castlecomer in the middle of his own county, and not being allowed to say: "I am sorry for what I said in Dáil Éireann. I withdraw it. I have changed my mind," but being compelled to say: "I never said it." The reward for perfidy of that kind is that this country is told that that unstable, undependable, wretched servant of a tyrannical taskmaster is to occupy what, in my judgment, is the most important office in an Irish Government after that of the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste.
I want to ask the Fianna Fáil Party again have they no shame? Surely to God they are not going to start out on this their period of office, be it short or long, setting the standards of the gutter. Surely they are not going to start out by demonstrating before the country that their own members are required to perform like dancing poodles in a circus. Surely they are not going to publish before the country that one of their own members should stand where I am standing and pledge his faith that this is his belief and that, popular or unpopular, he proclaims it, born of his experience as a farmer, and, as the price of office, to get up in the presence of his own neighbours not to recant his folly but to deny he ever uttered it. I am asking the Taoiseach now — he was present at Castlecomer and he heard Deputy Walsh speak there in the presence of his constituents and he knows that the report of Deputy Walsh's speech on the last day this House sat is substantially true — to answer for presenting that man to this House as Minister for Agriculture.
I impute no blame against him or Deputy Smith for reneging on their policy of compulsory tillage under the pressure of an election campaign. They had a right to do that. They had a right to get up before the people and say: "We have changed our minds; we have been educated and we stand the political tempest of admitting the mistake in the presence of the electorate and, admitting it, we withdraw from our position hitherto held and now for ever reject compulsory tillage as a permanent feature of Fianna Fáil policy." That is a legitimate honourable procedure and it tells the people all they are entitled to know; but I am asking the Taoiseach, who protests his desire to maintain decent standards in the public life of this country, how he justifies recommending to this Dáil as. Minister for Agriculture a man whose only recommendation for the post is that he was prepared to prostitute himself politically on Deputy de Valera's platform in the midst of his own neighbours.
I think I have a right to ask for a guarantee from the Fianna Fáil Party that, when they have sought the suffrages of our people on the representation that compulsory tillage is no part of their policy, they will require an Teachta Tomás Breathnach — preferably in Irish and, if he does not know it, then in English — to get up in this House and withdraw the opinions which he is on record as holding on the last day on which the 13th Dáil sat.
Until he does, I cannot understand how a Party which has jettisoned compulsory tillage can recommend him to Dáil Éireann. This is not the occasion to cover a wide field: I limited myself to two topics on which I have said all I desire to say. One is that I think Deputy Cowan has disgraced himself to-night and the other is that if there is any decency in public life the Taoiseach will do something about the outrage of presenting Deputy Tom Walsh to this House as a Minister for Agriculture even under the disguise of An Teachta Tomás Breathnach.
Comment on this
I cannot help feeling a deep sense of regret that the Taoiseach who has been elected to this House to-night did not choose to do the biggest act of his life, even if it was to be the final big act of his life by responding to the appeals which I made to him some days ago and to-day again, to cast aside the bitterness and the hatreds of the past and to provide a nationally representative Government — which is what the people want. I challenge the Taoiseach to dissolve this House to-morrow on that issue and to go to the country. I guarantee that 80 per cent. of the people of this country would vote in favour of a nationally representative Government if they were given the opportunity.
I have respect for the Taoiseach. I have known him and worked with him; I have followed his leadership during the civil war and before the civil war; I have probably from this side of the House a greater degree of respect for his political attitude in the course of the last 30 years than any other member on this side of the House. I think I have been able to divest myself of any particular prejudice concerning these past events. I think that the people want to forget those past events. I do not think that any useful purpose can be served now by seeking to apportion blame on one side or another. Probably, in 50 years' time, some historian will pass judgment and in that way blame will be apportioned. We are far too close to the situation to be able to write the pages of history now.
Let me say this—even if it sounds cruel, it is not intended to be cruel. The Taoiseach has had a long active life, he has done many things for this nation with which I agree; he has done many things with which I profoundly disagree. He has been the bone of contention in the public life of this country for the last 30 years. A great many people have respect for him. He is not getting young. If this Dáil were to last its full term, I think I would not be doing anything but facing realities if I said that he was not likely to be desirous of being reelected Taoiseach in five years' time. Why not, therefore, do the big thing, the generous thing, and help, once and for all, to bury this bitterness? Why not do what he knows, as I know, the people want done — form a nationally representative Government composed of representatives of the four leading Parties in this House, pledged, above all, to bring about the unification of the country, and, secondly, pledged to the economic development of the country and its economic reconstruction?
It has been said in criticism of me on a number of occasions that I had raised too much optimism, while I was Minister for External Affairs, on the issue of Partition. I now say this, with a full sense of responsibility, with a full knowledge of the position as it is and as it has been for the last year, that I am satisfied that if the Taoiseach were prepared to get together with the other Parties in this House and form a nationally representative Government, on that basis Partition could be ended within two years.
Comment on this
Like what other thing? Like the repeal of the External Relations Act — which could not be done, he told us, and which has been done? Why not try it, at least? Is it not obvious? We are a small nation, we have a tremendous national objective to achieve; is it not obvious that the united effort of the different parties will make the task easier to achieve? Is it to be cast aside because of prejudice? Or because of pride? Or because, possibly, a few Party members want jobs? Are they the consideration? Surely Eamon de Valera of 1916, of 1921, of the civil war, should be able to rise above that? He knows that the Irish people want him to do that. He knows that he would get the co-operation of the people in doing it. As I said earlier to-day, a lot of this is artificial. In social contacts, people who took different sides in the civil war, who belong to different Parties, can mix together, can dine together, can play bridge or golf together. They can go to the same churches. They can take part in charitable works. They can belong to the Gaelic League together and work together in that. They can belong to the G.A.A. and work together there. Why is it not possible to do it when it comes to running the affairs of the country? Why maintain these divisions which in most cases are devoid of reality? We heard to-day from Deputy Lemass reference to a statement which was issued after the election by the Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, a statement of policy which, word for word, had been taken from our policy, mainly from the policy of Clann na Poblachta. It was done advisedly, as a result of some bargaining that was going on behind the scenes. That we know. But, it illustrates the lack of reality of political differences that it should be possible, after an election campaign, for a main political Party to produce a programme of 17 points taken practically word for word from an outgoing Party. Yet, when it comes to placing the national interest before the interest of Party we are told "No, it cannot be done."
Are we not entitled to know why it cannot be done? Are the people not entitled to be told why Deputy de Valera will not sit around a table with the leaders of the other Parties and run the affairs of the country? Is there any secret about it? Why not tell the people what the answer is?
I am sorry if I am speaking with some heat on this. I did not intend to introduce heat. I am earnestly anxious to see this done. I believe it is essential for the national welfare. I believe it is essential for the purpose of bringing about re-unification of our country. I believe it can be done. I have faith in it. I feel the people have faith in it. I had hoped that Deputy de Valera might have availed of this opportunity. I had broken the ice to a certain extent by participating in the inter-Party Government during the course of the last three years. I know that there are some people in his Party who are opposed to it, more opposed to it than he is, but surely he should be big enough to rise above those differences. Surely, he should be big enough to tell his Party or to tell whatever members of his Party are opposed to it that every political leader must be prepared to place the interests of the country above the interests of a Party. I have urged it strongly in the hope that possibly still Deputy de Valera may revise the attitude he has adopted in relation to this matter either now or within a short space of time.
As to the Government which the Taoiseach proposes to us, I would like him to consider this point of view: I agree entirely with what Deputy Norton said earlier when he pointed out that the country had never been in a stronger position economically, politically and socially than it is to-day, that from every single aspect of our political, economic or social life the country is better off to-day than at any other stage in its history. I agree entirely with that but, while I agree that no Government since this State was founded has ever been handed over a better national position than is being handed over now to the care of the Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, I would say this, that no Government probably has undertaken a more dangerous task than the task which Deputy de Valera is undertaking now because he is undertaking to try to run this country with a minority support and with the majority of the people definitely opposed to his Government.
This is a minority Government. A majority of the people clearly expressed at the poll their opposition to a Fianna Fáil Government. By a decisive majority they reflected their view by the T.D.s which they elected and sent here belonging to the different Parties, even allowing for probably one of the most dishonest hoaxes that was ever played upon the Irish people by a number of Independent Deputies who sought their votes on the pretence that they were independent of the Fianna Fáil Party. The first thing we find is that even in this House it is only by using a subterfuge — quite a legal subterfuge, quite a constitutional one — that you avoid the position of having a tie. It may be correct legally, it may be correct constitutionally, for the Ceann Comhairle to avail of his legal right to vacate the Chair in order to provide a vote and to take part in the division. It does not rectify the position that this Government will be a minority Government. That is going to create many, many difficulties. It is the Government of the country and as such is entitled to the support of the people, to the support of this House. It will get my support in any constructive measure that it takes but I think it is well that the Taoiseach and this House should appreciate the delicate and dangerous situation on which this Government will tread as a minority Government. I was glad when I heard Deputy de Valera say this evening that the names which he had submitted were only provisional.
I do not want to say anything which may sound like a personal attack on any Deputy in this House but I must say — I think it is my duty and my responsibility to say it, as I have considerable experience of this particular matter — that the Deputy whom the Taoiseach proposes as Minister for Justice, in my view, is constitutionally incapable of being a responsible Minister for Justice. I have had in the law courts of this country experience of that Deputy as a witness and I have had experience of his activities as Minister for Justice. I cannot forget that it was under his ministry that a young man was allowed to lie naked in solitary confinement for months until he was driven practically insane and on hunger strike under conditions that were described by the prison doctor as conditions under which the doctor would not allow his dog to live. I do think that it would be a fatal error for the Taoiseach to place that particular Deputy again in charge of the Department of Justice even if he were a reformed character. I know that when that announcement will be read in to-morrow's papers it will have reactions throughout the country and the Taoiseach must bear in mind throughout the lifetime of this particular Government that he has not got the support of the majority of the people and is treading dangerous ground. I am prepared to give him all the support I can in order to ensure that we will have peace in this country, that we will not revert to the position which was originally created by this particular Deputy, that we will not have military courts, executions and a new cycle of repression, but I do think that it is an act of provocation to restore that Deputy to the Ministry of Justice because I think that Deputy constitutionally unfit for that post and that he will be so regarded by the Irish people. As the Taoiseach has indicated that these nominations are purely provisional I hope that he will consider what I have said and consider it seriously and take it as a sincere expression of my view in the matter.
I am very glad that the Taoiseach has decided to appoint a Minister for External Affairs and I am glad that that Minister is Deputy Aiken. I was afraid that no separate Minister might have been appointed.
I think it was a wise step to take and I can assure the Taoiseach and Deputy Aiken that they will have my full co-operation in anything I can do to be of assistance, and I hope that my criticism will be of a constructive nature in dealing with our external affairs.
I doubt whether the appointment of Deputy MacEntee to the Department of Finance is a wise one. I say that not because of any objections to Deputy MacEntee — his bark is usually worse than his bite I think and certainly worse than the effects of his bite — but I do think that Deputy MacEntee's concept of finance belongs to the last century, that is if one is to judge his financial views from various articles written by him from time to time. Go right back to the middle of the Victorian era; sterling assets — build them up; starve this country of investments; have plenty of unemployment and emigration — that is the policy that he has been advocating so far.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy MacEntee has possibly reconsidered his financial views since he wrote in the Sunday Press some time ago. Certainly if that is his policy it is one which will be disastrous for the country. Deputy MacEntee might be quite a good Minister in another Department, but I do not think that Deputy MacEntee will be a good Minister for Finance.
I do not want to add anything about Deputy Smith. I do not know Deputy Smith well enough. I have seen Deputy Smith's behaviour in this House; certainly it is not the type of behaviour which I would expect from any responsible person.
I do not know whether the omission of Deputy Little from the Government has any significance.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy Little was a good Minister in many respects and I think that he would be a better Minister for Posts and Telegraphs than Deputy Childers. I would prefer to see Deputy Little in control of our radio station than Deputy Childers. Frankly I would not be very happy to see Deputy Childers in charge of our radio station. I think it is a pity. I hope, therefore, that it may be possible to include Deputy Little in the Cabinet.
I am not saying these things by way of being provocative; I am saying what I know a great many people will think when they open their morning papers to-morrow. As far as I can I shall try to ensure that any criticism I may have to offer from time to time in this House will be constructive criticism and in so far as it is the policy of the new Government to work for the economic development of the country, to work for the re-unification of this country, to pursue broadly the policies which we have been advocating, this Government will receive my co-operation and I will not indulge in destructive criticism. I would again ask the Taoiseach to bear in mind that while he is receiving the country in better condition, his Government has taken over a very difficult job because of the fact that he undoubtedly has not got the support of the majority of the people.
I think I should probably give a word of warning to the Taoiseach as to some of his new supporters. Many things have been said in the course of the election campaign, and many things have been said in this House to-day with which I have not dealt publicly and with which I do not propose to deal publicly to-night because it is too late. Some day I shall deal with them. I ask the Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, to take this from me for his own protection. In the course of my life I have lived through a couple of bad national splits and I have seen a great many different types of people. I was in jail and I was on the run with many different types of people, and I have seen many political difficulties of one kind or another. I have never met a more cynically, maliciously disposed person than the leading Independent, who is now supporting the new Government. I do not in any way blame the Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, for having obtained his support. He is entitled, I take it, to accept support from wherever he may get it. However, I think that, in fairness to himself, he will take that assurance from me until he finds out the fuller facts for himself. The controversy and crisis which occurred in connection with the mother and child health service proposals were only side issues in a treacherous conspiracy which had been afoot for some very considerable time before but had little or no relation to the mother and child health service proposals. These proposals were used merely as a convenient weapon in a given situation.
I am not quite certain but I think that the Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, said that the appointment of Deputy Dr. Ryan as Minister for Health and as Minister for Social Welfare is only a temporary measure. I hope that the Taoiseach will find it possible at the earliest opportunity to separate these two ministries again.
Comment on this
I had expected that the people who were so anxious to-day for all Parties to come together and to help out in the difficult position in which we found ourselves would have adopted a different attitude in this House. They did not. Attacks have been made here to-night on a number of Independent Deputies. Why? What is an Independent Deputy? To my mind an Independent Deputy is a Deputy who gets up on his own two legs in a constituency and, independent of Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour, Clann na Poblachta and of every other fellow, says: "I am the man you should elect."
Let us examine the circumstances under which this Government left office. This Government left office because Deputies Dr. Browne, McQuillan, Cowan, Finucane and Lehane had definitely refused to support them any longer. It was, therefore, a case of get out or be kicked out— and they left just because they could not take it. Each one of these Deputies went back to his own constituents to give an account of his action in connection with the putting out of the Government — and each one of them got the decision of his constituents that he had done right and he was sent back again.
I am not going to dwell now on the campaign of calumny and lies which operated up and down the country — barefaced lies in many instances. I have here just one instance to put before the House. In a report in the Irish Times of the 22nd May, 1951, the ex-Minister for Lands, Deputy Blowick, is reported as follows:—
"Referring to the new House of Parliament which at one time Fianna Fáil proposed to build at a cost of £11,000,000; Mr. Blowick said: ‘The House we have at present is all right; its the boyos and the buckos who are going into it who are all wrong.'"
Comment on this
That is a good description of the elected representatives of a National Parliament. I was wondering who was the lunatic who was mad enough to dream of spending £11,000,000 on new Houses of Parliament. I cast my mind back and I searched. After a bit of searching I discovered it. I knew at the outset that only one man would be guilty of that kind of a game. Remember that these are the Houses of Parliament that Fianna Fáil were going to build. Here is the quotation from the Official Report of the 25th May, 1945, Volume 97, column 1027:—
"Now, in connection with building, I have a few brief remarks to make. There is plenty of work to be done in regard to building, and I think it is a terrible mistake for us to shy away from undertaking great enterprises in the immediate future because they appear to cost a lot.
This is a time when we should mobilise credit and use it boldly and resolve, if necessary, to repay it over the next 100 years. The extension of credit should not deter us from embarking on bold schemes at the present time, always provided that they are good schemes. As a start in that direction, one good thing would be to build a new Oireachtas, and it would prove to be an economy in the long run. We are eternally patching and tinkering with these buildings in order to make them adequate to fulfil the functions of an efficient Parliament. It is common knowledge that half the Deputies cannot find accommodation in which to write a letter. Even the Ministers' rooms are inadequate and they have not proper facilities. We are trying to get our meals in a restaurant which is built on top of the boiler house and in which no person could sit in the months of August and September. The permanent officials are obliged to sit in cramped quarters up at the top and their teeth are made to chatter with the noise of the machinery in the basement because we are trying to dislodge a beetle through the medium of a vacuum cleaner in the roof. I understand that the roof is now infested with beetles and that it shall have to be rebuilt."
I wonder was it beetles in the roof or bats in the belfry James was suffering from.
That statement was made quite solemnly in the Dáil on the Estimate for the Office of Public Works on the 25th May, 1945. I need not tell any member of the House who was the lunatic who was mad enough to make it. It was Deputy James M. Dillon. That was Deputy James Dillon's statement on a new Dáil building in respect of which we were to borrow boldly and repay in a 100 years, not, mark you, to build houses for workers, but to build new Houses of Parliament for the boyos and the buckos alluded to by the late Minister for Lands. Now, these were the kind of lies and frauds by means of which these Deputies succeeded in crawling back here. Fancy any responsible Minister of State getting up at a public meeting and referring to the new Houses of Parliament which at one time Fianna Fáil proposed to build at a cost of £11,000,000, and stating, as Deputy Blowick did: "The House we have at present is all right; it is the boyos and the buckos in it who are all wrong." Now, there is one of the lies nailed. I made a search. I am a fairly good hand at poking out things. I said to myself: "I wonder is there any fellow now who would be bad enough to make a statement like that," and I hit immediately on James.
Comment on this
I hit immediately on Deputy James Dillon, the ex-Minister for Agriculture. That is number one. I could speak here for three or four hours dealing with all the lies. I heard Deputy Norton speak about Labour and the number of people that had been put into employment. My mind goes back a bit. I will be bringing pressure to bear on some of my own gentlemen some of these days. I make no bones about it.
I have a memory of what the position was in my own constituency when the Fianna Fáil Party came in as a Government. It is a pretty long memory and a pretty sad memory. We had flocks of crows roosting in the flour mills in Clondulane. We had the machinery in the Midleton flour mills measured for removal. We had a scrap heap on the island of Haulbowline giving employment to 20 persons. We had a caretaker in Rushbrook dockyard. We had to change all that. It took time and hard work on the part of the greatest Minister for Industry and Commerce that we have ever had in this country, Deputy Seán Lemass. I went to work on that, and the day on which we handed over there were 400 persons employed in Irish Steel.
We had 220 in constant employment in Rushbrook dockyard, and an oil refinery at Haulbowline. There was also, on the wall of the general manager's office in Irish Steel, a plan for converting the furnaces into oil-burning ones which would mean an enormous reduction in the cost of the production of steel in this country, with a guarantee by Deputy Seán Lemass for an extension of sheet steel there. I have spent the past three years in this House begging and craving those friends of the workers who came in here to endeavour to get something done and to get the guarantees given by Deputy Lemass carried out. But what did I find? I was told that the matter was being investigated, that this was a serious matter and was under very close investigation. I was told that it was handed over — the Lord between us and all harm — to the Industrial Development Authority. These were the answers that were given to me here over the past three years.
What is the position to-day? We have seen in Henry Ford's, in Cork, men being sacked in tens and twenties because there is no sheet-steel. I should say that three-quarters of the machinery required for the sheet-steel mill was purchased by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1939 and was placed there ready for erection. The balance of it was to be purchased by Deputy Seán Lemass in 1948 as soon as the machinery became available. This is 1951. Where is the employment for the 420 men? Deputy Norton told us of the increased employment which they had given. We saw none of it in my constituency. This is what we saw. We again saw attempts to create a scrap-heap, and to have what was going on in Haulbowline from 1927 to 1932 — an auction of essential machinery every six months for scrap, while the oil refinery was being removed. I raised the matter in the Dáil early in April. I was then told by the late Minister for Industry and Commerce that he was not going to interfere in preventing the removal of the oil refinery. After the election was announced we had belated statements being made. When the Clann na Poblachta chairman of the Cobh Urban Council made a public statement that the staff and the workers for the taking down of that machinery for removal were in the town of Cobh, we had belated statements being made by two Deputies that that was not going to be so for the present—until after the 13th June.
That is the kind of game that was being played in my constituency as far as employment and industry are concerned. It took me and the Fianna Fáil Government nine months before I could get the Clondulane mills reopened in 1933. It took me only one interview, thank God, with the owners of the Midleton flour mills to stop the removal of machinery from it.
That is a tough history. I see that Deputy Hickey is troubled. Let him consult the general manager in Henry Ford's to-morrow when he goes back and he will tell him that the sheet-steel that could be produced for the past two years out of the sheet-steel mills in Haulbowline is now impossible to get for any money. It cannot be got. If Deputy Hickey had bestirred himself for the past three years he might have got the Minister for Industry and Commerce to pay some heed to my appeal in that matter.
Comment on this
Before I finish dealing with Deputy Norton, I would like to refer to an extract he read from a speech by Deputy Cogan. Deputy Cogan at that time had not the experience of another jockey in the saddle.
Comment on this
He found that the Herod out-Heroded Herod. To use a simile of the Minister for Agriculture— Deputy Dunne and a few more of the boys opposite should have found the same thing — I often met an old farmer in my country who had a sow and a litter of bonhams. He went out in the evening and the sow had a litter of 15 bonhams, but when he came out after the tea he had only ten. That is the most apt description of the Fine Gael boys opposite. They are like the sow and the bonhams. Five are gone. Like the sow who ate the bonhams, they ate or absorbed four Labour and six Clann na Poblachta Deputies' seats.
Comment on this
Those are just two items from a pretty long list that I wish to deal with here. I now come to agriculture. The inter-Party Government put a Minister in charge of the Department of Agriculture who had publicly stated in this House that the beet was gone up the spout after peat and wheat, God speed the day. That is the Minister who was put in charge of agriculture in this country.
Comment on this
Be careful now. You are treading on dangerous ground. Now tell us why Deputy Smith was dropped.
Comment on this
They are the fellows who are sent into the bakeries. We know what happened to them all right, 10½d. a stone black market tax on white flour.
Comment on this
On a point of order, will Deputy Corry state if he is prepared to give 1/6 a gallon now for milk.
Comment on this
Deputy Keane will sit down. That is not a point of order.
Comment on this
I will deal with every point before I finish, even at the risk of holding the House up after 2 a.m.
Comment on this
I know it is touching the Deputy fairly closely. I ask the Acting-Chairman to see that I am not interrupted.
Comment on this
If the Deputy did not look for interruptions he would not be interrupted so frequently.
Comment on this
I am going to deal with the question of beet just as we found it. In 1948 we had an interview with the general manager of the sugar company, who agreed that beet growers were entitled to an increase of 4/6 a ton on beet. That had to get Government sanction, and Government sanction was refused.
Comment on this
That was for the 1949 season. The result was a reduction in acreage of 6,600 acres of beet. In February or March, 1950, the Minister darted out on the world market to provide sugar instead. He purchased that sugar from the Chinaman in Formosa for £12 a ton more than he paid the Irish farmer or the Irish labourer for producing it at home in the field and in the factory.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey can tell us who did it. As a matter of fact I will go further and say that there was a complaint that the sugar was costing too much and one cargo was sold at an enormous profit on the high seas.
Comment on this
By the general manager of the sugar company on the Government complaint that it was costing too much ; £12 a ton on 36,000 tons of sugar of the Irish people's money was grabbed out of the pockets of the working farmers of this country, out of the pockets of the labourers, Córas Iompair Éireann, and out of the pockets of the workers in the four beet factories.
Comment on this
In March, 1950, I put up an appeal to Deputy Morrissey—it will be found in the Official Report—to call a conference of the beet growers and the sugar company to see if we could not succeed in discovering some means by which we could increase the acreage of wheat and get the sugar produced by our own people in our own country. He refused to do so.
Comment on this
Three months ago this gentleman who refused to be blackmailed by the Irish farmers went out and purchased in Cuba this time 74,000 tons of sugar and paid for that £1,387,000 more than the Irish farmer or the Irish labourer or the Irish factory worker got for producing the sugar at home. Let us examine this to its logical conclusion and let us see the so-called prosperity of agriculture. This past Government was prepared to pay to the Chinaman £12 per ton more and to the Cuban nearly £1,500,000 more for producing sugar than it paid to the Irish labourer, the Irish farmer and the Irish factory worker for producing it at home. That Government paid for that sugar with the Irish people's money.
The next item I will deal with is milk. I happen to be a member of a milk producers' association in Cork. That association went to the trouble in the Fianna Fáil Government's time of getting the costs of production. Deputy Smith, then Minister for Agriculture, increased the price of milk on those costs of production. He was neither afraid nor ashamed to meet the milk producers' association. It was not the creamery suppliers he was meeting. He was even prepared to meet a small little milk proprietors' association from County Cork. He increased the price of milk in March, 1947. Since then appeal after appeal has been made here in connection with the price of milk. Deputy Cogan tabled a motion asking to have the price brought up to an economic level. A vote was taken here on that motion and we had these friends of the workers, plus the friends of the farmers—the Lord between us and all harm—trotting into the Lobby. For what? To vote against the farmer getting an economic price for his milk.