We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Nomination of Members of Government: Motion of Approval.

Contributions 165–338 of 338. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

In order to show that the farmers were producing plenty of milk Deputy Dillon, Minister for Agriculture, went looking for a market for butter. He went to his dearly beloved friends across the water and they offered him 271/- per cwt. The Minister came back and he issued an ultimatum to all the creameries. In the meantime the cost of production had gone up by 2d. per gallon.

Comment on this

Be careful now.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Deputy Keane must cease interrupting.

Comment on this

The Minister came back and issued his ultimatum. For five long years you will get 1/- per gallon as against Deputy Smith's 1/2. What was the result? In order to prove that there was a surplus of butter and that the farmers were producing more than the people could eat he went and sold butter on the Continent. Then, lo and behold, he went looking for butter. He could only get "Brian Boru" stuff and he bought "Brian Boru" stuff and paid a pretty hefty price for it. He paid more for it than he got for his own.

In the first six months of 1950 the Danish Government sold on the Continent of Europe 288,000 cwts. of butter at an average price of 436/- per cwt. If any Deputy is interested I will give him the exact particulars as to where it was sold. It was sold, for instance, in France at 463/- a cwt. while our butter was sold by the then Minister for Agriculture at 365/- a cwt. The Danish people sold their "Brian Boru" butter about which our people complained so bitterly at 463/- a cwt. while our butter was sold at 365/- a cwt. Let us examine this coolly and quietly and let us see why Deputies like Deputy Cogan and others thought it was high time to put an end to the high jinks. What is the position to-day? If I state here publicly that we will have to go abroad immediately and purchase more butter on the Continent and pay anything from 430/- to 500/-per cwt.——

Comment on this

You will do what you did before — reduce the ration to two ounces and then we need not import any.

Comment on this

We need not reduce it at all if we buy the "Brian Boru" stuff. The same policy was being adopted in regard to the land of this country. We had the very self-same policy that left the crows roosting in Clondulane flour mill.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not remind me of things that it would be better for him to forget.

Comment on this

I hope to remind Deputy Hickey of a good deal before I finish up here at a quarter to two.

Comment on this

Do you remember the time you said you hoped they would be eating rats.

Comment on this

I am sorry the Deputy's daddy is not here to take him home, give him his bottle and put him to bed.

Comment on this

Do you remember the time when you said you would bring the people home from America? Do you remember that?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Deputy Keane will please keep quiet.

Comment on this

That is the position as regards butter supplies to-day. Deputy Morrissey now makes a very cool suggestion, one we did not hear from him when he was a Minister. He says bring back the ration of two ounces. The ex-Minister for Agriculture, in order to prove that the farmers were producing plenty of milk and were not badly off, sold a share of our butter at 98/- a cwt. less than the Danes got for their butter on the Continent of Europe. I can guarantee this much to Deputy Hickey: it is very hard to establish decent dairy herds here. It takes a very long time for a man to get a decent dairy herd.

Comment on this

Before the Taoiseach leaves the House, may I put a point? Perhaps Deputy Corry would sit down while I am putting my point. The Deputy is long enough in this House to know what order in the House is. The House agreed unanimously on my suggestion, in order to facilitate the Taoiseach in the formation of the new Government, to sit not later than 2 a.m. The Deputy who has just been speaking has announced his intention to speak until 1.45 a.m. If that is his intention, I propose to ask the House to agree to extend the sitting from not later than 2 a.m. to not later than 6 a.m.

Comment on this

Again on a point of order, may I ask if the Chair would not regularise its directions with regard to interruptions——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

That is not a point of order. The Deputy is long enough in the House to know what is.

Comment on this

Has the Taoiseach agreed to Deputy Morrissey's suggestion?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The House agreed to prolong the sitting until 2 a.m. There was unanimous agreement on that and I do not think that it can be altered now without the unanimous agreement of the House again.

Comment on this

That is the reason I am making the point. I am making it only because of the announced intention of Deputy Corry deliberately to obstruct the business and to use up the remaining time of the House.

Comment on this

I should like to say one word before this goes further. With the exception of ten minutes occupied by the Taoiseach in announcing his Ministry, the whole of the time of the House up to the present has been occupied by Opposition Deputies who have got up here one after another in wilful obstruction.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is obvious we are wasting the time of the House now. We had better dispose of the matter before the House.

Comment on this

I do not think that Deputy Corry was serious in the statement that he would speak until a quarter to two. I do not know whether he was or not, but I did not understand it in that way. Perhaps I was not attending sufficiently to the debate. I do not think there was any suggestion that he would speak until a quarter to two.

Comment on this

The Deputy made that statement.

Comment on this

If that were so, I am afraid I would have to agree to an extended sitting. On an occasion like this, it is natural for members of the Opposition who wish to speak to get as much time as they want.

Comment on this

If I am allowed to continue, I shall take only about ten minutes to conclude.

Comment on this

Tell us about the rats.

Comment on this

I can assure Deputies that it would take me a month to expose all the sins committed by the people opposite while they were sitting here. I am not going to take up the time of the House to-night, but I hope to have the pleasure on later occasions of dealing with them again. I was explaining to the House the position in regard to butter and milk supplies in the country. I stated that it takes a long time to build up a dairy herd. I never yet knew a farmer who got rid of his cows and left dairy farming, to go back to it. I say that as one who has been a dairy farmer all my life. We have a difficulty to contend with that did not exist three years ago. You have also the difficulty of Sunday milking. The people engaged in production are entitled to be recompensed for all these additional difficulties. I am one who is convinced that the ordinary agricultural labourer is not half paid, and I state that here above board. I say also that the jokers who got 20, 30, 40 to 60 per cent. increases in their salaries should at least be prepared to allow somebody else to get some increased income. You cannot come along and hold a fixed price — a freeze price, as Deputy Norton called it — over the farmer who has to produce these commodities, while at the same time his costs and expenses are increasing. These expenses were raised enormously while the farmer was held at the 1947 price, until he got the insult of 1d. per gallon last month on the eve of the election.

Comment on this

You will wipe that insult out.

Comment on this

These are the facts. I expected Deputy Dunne and those associated with him to be more farseeing and to look further ahead when Deputy Cogan's motion to increase the price of milk came before the House.

Comment on this

Did you hear what Deputy Cogan did with the half-acre farm labourers when the question of their wages came before this House?

Comment on this

I am not entering into the game of tit-for-tat.

Comment on this

I shall tell you all about it.

Comment on this

Deputy Dunne and his colleagues voted against an increase in the price of milk.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is now going into the details of agricultural policy.

Comment on this

Would Deputy Corry tell the House what increase in the price of milk he wants?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry on the motion before the House.

Comment on this

I am going over, as well as I can, the attacks made on the different proposed Ministers here to-night. I was dealing with the reasons why Independent Deputies made up their minds to get rid of that Government. I say here and above board that an Independent Deputy is an Independent Deputy. He is an individual Deputy. He is not tied to Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil, Labour or Clann na Poblachta. He is here purely as an Independent Deputy elected by the people to voice independent views and, therefore, is not, and cannot be, tied to any particular Party.

Comment on this

What is an independent independent?

Comment on this

You have five years to do penance and you should allow Deputy Corry to speak for a few moments.

Comment on this

That is very good advice. It is a penance to have to listen to him.

Comment on this

There are other matters that I would be very anxious to deal with, but I have said enough to convince Deputies. Judging by the number of interruptions that I have got and the anxiety of ex-Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries to curtail my time, I am getting a little bit under their hide. That always gives me a certain amount of amusement. I do not think I am making an effective speech until I hear the boys over there grousing; then I know that I am getting under their skin a little bit. I believe that this Government will run their full term of five years; I see no reason why they should not. I can say, as a kind of half-independent fellow, as an individual who got more for my constituents out of any Government that sat here than any five Deputies over there, even from the last crowd——

Comment on this

That is right; your bank balance is getting bigger now.

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey alluded to blackmail a while ago. We got 12/-a ton more for beet this year, and the first place the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture saw it was in the public Press and they dare not say "No", because it was still less than the nigger got. I have given good reasons why I went all out here three months ago to get rid of that Government. I spared no effort night or day and I make no bones about it. I was determined that their time had come. I was determined that the unfortunate agricultural community would get some measure of justice, fair play and fair economic prices. I was also determined that, in any emergency, we would have growing on the soil of Ireland food enough for our people. As workers in my constituency had been deprived of employment through this policy of abeyance, through the policy that left the steel mills lying idle, through the policy that allowed ships to be repaired in the Dublin dockyard that should be repaired in Cobh and ships repaired in Germany that should be repaired in this country, I was determined to do my part to get rid of that Government and I did so.

Comment on this

I thought it was Deputy Cowan who did that.

Comment on this

At the end of the operations, we are having a different viewpoint to-night. I do not intend to go into all the reasons that tempted the other Independent Deputies not to support the Fianna Fáil Party. I think that all Parties here should give a little help and see how we will get on. Instead of all the criticism and attacks that we had here to-night, we should have a little of the unity which was talked about this morning. We did our best to help you out; we gave you every assistance in our power. I was in the unfortunate position of having to point out your faults.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Deputy Corry mentioned some time ago that he would continue speaking for a certain period and my colleague, Deputy Morrissey, raised the matter with the Taoiseach. If Deputy Corry thinks he is going to get away with this——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is obviously not a point of order. Deputy Corry said that he would speak for ten minutes or so.

Comment on this

He has been speaking for 20 minutes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He has not. He has been speaking for just ten minutes.

Comment on this

I know that your assessment of time is better than mine, but I am looking at the clock and I certainly——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will resume his seat.

Comment on this

He got more time than he would get on any ordinary occasion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy persists, I will have to ask him to leave the House.

Comment on this

It is not my intention to delay the House further. I have put the points as well as I could and if I have exceeded my time a little the fault lies with Deputies who are carrying on here just the same tactics which they adopted during the elections. I have put the case as fairly as I could. Attacks were made and I only got up to reply to some of them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy said all that before.

Comment on this

I am urging Deputies to help as far as they can to get employment in this country for our people, to see that our agricultural community are fairly dealt with, and by that I mean the workers on the land, be they farmers or labourers. We should give them all a fair "do". As far as work is concerned, I mentioned one incident where men are being laid off in tens and twenties each week at the Ford works for want of steel.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I definitely will be removed from the House if the Deputy is allowed to continue. I think it is very unfair.

Comment on this

Rather than any unpleasantness of that description should arise here on the first day of the new Government, I will sit down.

Comment on this

It is very appropriate that the Deputy should have opened his speech by making accusations of lying against Deputies on this side of the House and finish up himself on a lie. We have got from Deputy Corry what we usually get from him in this House — a speech which was a mixture of hypocrisy, vulgarity and falsehoods. The Deputy is running away as he always does. The Deputy has not the "guts" to sit down and take his medicine. The Deputy is now running away. After "handing it out" for the last three-quarters of an hour, the Deputy is afraid to remain here because he knows very well that I can expose him in five minutes. The Deputy's exit from the House makes it unnecessary for me to continue any further. I have succeeded in showing not merely to the people on this side of the House but to the people on the other side of the House that Deputy Corry is just a craven little coward who gets up under the protection of this House and makes abusive and dirty attacks on people inside and outside the House and then runs away. I challenged the Deputy to stay here but he would not. I have been listening to Deputy Corry in this House for well over 20 years. He has never changed his spots. Deputy Corry, in the interests of the farmers, talked about the Government that was in office and that is in office up to the present moment. As a farmer, Deputy Corry knows — and if he were an honest man he would admit it — that there was more money put into agriculture in the last three years than in the previous 16. Deputy Corry's bank balance is far bigger to-day than it was three years ago. I could deal with the points raised by Deputy Corry and his misrepresentations about Haulbowline and about the position in Ford's, but I am not going to delay the House as there are other people who wish to speak. I have exposed Deputy Corry very effectively and I am satisfied.

Comment on this

Now that there is already evidence that the tumult and the shouting is dying, I think it is time that we got back to the fact that the people of this country have still to live even with a change of Government.

I was interested to hear the announcement of the Fianna Fáil Cabinet. I propose to address myself as briefly as possible to the constitution of the Cabinet in some respects. I want some enlightenment upon what is in store for the workers of this country in so far as some of the members of this Cabinet are concerned. I was elected to this House with a mandate from a certain section of the people. I did not crawl in as Deputy Corry says. I was not like some of the members of the Fianna Fáil Party who managed to get in on other people's preferences. I was elected by the workers of County Dublin in no uncertain fashion. I want to ask some questions on their behalf at this critical juncture in the history of our nation.

As we all know very well, the most important position in any Government is that of Minister for Finance. Who have we in charge of finance? A gentleman, Deputy Seán MacEntee. I do not know what the opinion of the more well-to-do sections of the people of this country is regarding the attitude of Deputy MacEntee in matters of wages of workers. I know what my experience has been during the progress of Fianna Fáil rule. I know what the experience of thousands of county council employees throughout the country was when Deputy MacEntee had some modicum of power as Minister for Local Government. Not so very many years ago—not in 1921 or 1922 as some people were so fond of harping back to during the election time but in my own lifetime—I recall very well when Deputy MacEntee was Minister for Local Government, the late Tim Murphy, God be good to him, one of the best Ministers and one of the best Deputies who ever stood in this House—and members of all Parties in the House will acknowledge that— as a member of Cork County Council represented that the road workers, who were paid something like 45/-, should get an increase of 10/- a week. That proposal was approved by all Parties, and even by that stage Irishman, Deputy Corry, who was present at that meeting.

When that proposal went before Deputy MacEntee for an increase of 10/- a week for road workers—men who are paid a miserable wage—he sanctioned an increase of 1/- per week for these men and for their families. We used to call him "Shilling a week MacEntee." What will his policy be as Minister for Finance in the present Government? Are we going to have the the same attitude of complete contempt working people? Are we going to have the same attitude of complete contempt for the needs of the working class families throughout this nation? We have had nothing but contempt from Deputy MacEntee in the past and now he is in the position — the most important position—of Minister for Finance.

The events of to-day have amazed many people, but nobody more than me. We had supporting the nomination of a Minister for Finance, whose name is a by-word in this country, particularly in rural areas, for repression, for low wage standards, for disregard of the working conditions and for indifference as to whether the working people live or die, none other than the revolutionary leader of Irish labour—Deputy Captain Peadar Cowan. It is not so long ago since Deputy MacEntee spent several hours endeavouring to prove beyond yea or nay that Deputy Cowan was a paid agent of the Comintern. Do we remember that? Of course we do. Deputy Cowan has taken unto himself the right to criticise the Labour Party. Some of us did not come to the Labour Party through other channels, through the media of other Parties: some of us were bred in the Labour Party tradition, were reared during adolescence with a Labour Party background; some of us have learned Labour policy and principles from some of the greatest men who ever stood in this country. I myself had the honour to learn labour principles from the late James Larkin, God be good to him, and I will take no monitoring, no instruction from Deputy Cowan or from anybody else as to how I should act in the interests of my constituents. I do not claim to be on both sides of the fence at the same time as others do. I am not all things to all men. I claim to represent only the working people of my constituency and I take no dictation or instruction from Deputy Cowan who invoked the sacred name of the late James Connolly during the course of this debate and dragged it down to what I consider to be a very low level.

I am not in agreement with the selection of certain gentlemen who were nominated to act in this incoming Government. Many of them, of course, are honourable men, and I do not wish to make any personal attacks on any of them. However, I do think that some of them should not have their names mentioned in the same breath as that of James Connolly. If anybody in this House who cares about the problems of workers, anybody who is conversant with what happened during the last three years, wants justification to vote against the Fianna Fáil Party in this Vote all he has to do is to watch Deputy Patrick Cogan—the symbol of reaction. The Fianna Fáil Party ought to be proud to have him in their ranks. We are proud and glad to give him to them.

Everything that was suggested, during my short term of office here, that was of benefit to the people, everything that might give the lowly agricultural worker a better standard of living—for example the half-holiday, which we fought through this House almost to a successful conclusion, and the Social Security Bill—was opposed by Deputy Cogan. He raised his mournful voice and tried to prevent the implementation of any proposal for the benefit of workers. The Fianna Fáil Party knows that all this is quite true. You should be proud to have him, and Deputy Cowan must feel happy in his company.

I want to ask, as we are discussing the composition of the incoming Cabinet, what will happen now in relation to the underpaid workers employed by county councils, when we have so illustrious and progressive a gentleman as Deputy Patrick Smith in charge of Local Government. Like the Minister for External Affairs, Deputy MacBride, I have not had very much experience of Deputy Smith other than what I have gained from observation of his activities and acrobatics when on these benches, but it gives one to think that, if the fate of the road workers, many of whom voted for Fianna Fail, many of whom voted for the slogans and catch cries during the recent election, is to be placed at the tender mercies of Deputy Patrick Smith, it will be many a long day before they get any kind of a deal in the same way as they got a fair deal from Tim Murphy or Michael Keyes in the matter of wages.

We have an able man appointed as Minister for Industry and Commerce— possibly one of the most able men in the House—a man whose speeches here have at all times been remarkable for the absence from them of personal animus or malevolence which is a rare thing to find in the Fianna Fáil Party in Dáil Éireann, Deputy Seán Lemass. He was responsible during certain recent periods of Fianna Fáil rule for the introduction of standstill wages Orders. When challenged at election meetings during the recent campaign on these issues, he said that Fianna Fáil did not propose to introduce any more standstill wages Orders, unless they were necessary. The much-publicised 17 points upon which some of the so-called Independents have based their reasons, or alleged reasons, for lining up with a single Party in this House made no mention of the abolition of standstill wages Orders and gave no guarantee that we would not again see such standstill Orders. Do we not all know that, whatever may have been said of Fianna Fáil in the first years of their existence, in the latter and last years of their existence they became a Party which was closer to the industrialists and the moneyed classes of the country than to the people.

One Independent to-day, Deputy McQuillan, made a very courageous speech. He took a very courageous stand and made a very constructive speech on the issue which confronted him—whether or not to vote for Deputy Costello as Taoiseach. He said that, so far as he was concerned, there was no essential difference between the larger Parties in this country, that the only difference was a difference of personality in relation to what happened 30 years ago. Is that not true? Is there anybody who can deny it? Is it not a fact that the only difference is the clash of personality which occurred over a split which I do not remember and which many new members of this House do not remember, but which still dominates the political life of this country and which has no more reality than what happened during the famine years? I believe that, to all intents and purposes, the major political forces might well merge. I have never made any secret of my political credo in this House or outside it, nor do I propose to do so in future. I believe that the future of this country lies with the Party to which I belong, but I should like to make some inquiries of the new Administration as to what their intentions are.

Deputy Cogan waxed eloquent and drove away many of us from the House on many a night in despair and boredom on the question of the price of farmers' milk. Are we going to have 1/6 per gallon, paid now by the Fianna Fáil Administration for creamery milk? That is a question I should like to have answered. It is a question which Deputy Cogan's constituents in Wicklow and the creamery suppliers throughout the country would like to have answered. I want to know whether the constructive work accomplished by the Labour Party in the recent Administration, the implementation of the policy of the Labour Party with regard to holidays for agricultural workers, is going to be undone by Fianna Fáil. I want to know whether the proposal which has passed through the Agricultural Wages Board, which has been pushed through by the organised body of the agricultural workers for an increase of 7/6 per week for agricultural labourers is going to be sanctioned by the incoming Fianna Fáil Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Walsh.

These are important matters. These are matters which vitally affect the daily lives of thousands of our people and thousands of my constituents. I want to know whether the housing drive which we inaugurated, and the like of which was not seen in this country before, is to be continued and geared up still further to get a solution of the terrible problem we have here, particularly in Dublin City and County. The only effective answers we can get to these questions are facts and not talk. We want houses built for the people on the same scale as that on which they have been built in the past three years under a Labour Minister. We want them built quickly. We do not want the type of house built in the coming years that was built during some of the years of the Fianna Fáil Administration. If anybody wants to see what type of house I refer to, I will take him to my constituency where he will see labourers' cottages built 14 years ago which are only fit to be condemned and knocked down because they were built with sea-sand and mud.

The attitude and the mentality of those who were responsible was that anything was good enough for the working people. We built houses, thank God—Michael Keyes and Tim Murphy can claim credit, and the Labour Party can claim credit, for building the best class of houses ever built for the working people of this country. We want that continued; we will watch to see that it is, and every member of local authorities belonging to the Labour Party, whether inside or outside the Dáil, will keep a brief on that and we will see that nothing is left undone and that anything which needs to be exposed will be exposed.

So far as we are concerned, this battle is only beginning. I never subscribed to the idea that the be-all and end-all of political effort in this country was all-Party or inter-Party Government. I am an unrepentant believer in the future of my own Party. I was brought up in that tradition; I live in it and I will die in it. At times it may be necessary to make alliances to improve the position of the working people. James Connolly was one who laid it down that were it possible to gain Irish freedom by means other than the use of the gun he would have used those means, that were it possible to gain it by the ballot box in his day he would have done that. He was a believer in realities, a believer in using every tactic that would improve the masses of the people. That was what has governed every act of mine in public life and I believe every act of the Labour Party. I think there has been quite a lot of cainnt in aisce or useless talk during the course of this long day. It is essential that the incoming Government bends its mind to the problems that beset the ordinary people, that it does not give undue consideration to the needs of those who are well enough fixed, that it pursues a policy in the future of trying to help the most helpless section. I hope that the incoming Government will change from the attitude it had some two, three or four years ago when it was asked here in this House by members of the Labour Party to increase old age pensions from 10/- to 12/6d. and it went a unit into the Lobby to say: “We cannot do it; we will not do it.”

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

I have proved it here before.

Comment on this

It is not true at all

Comment on this

It is true and I have proved it here before.

Comment on this

It is not true. We did increase them.

Comment on this

It is true and I will prove it before many hours are out.

Comment on this

Prove it.

Comment on this

If some of my colleagues here will get the quotation for me.

Comment on this

The rest of your argument is like the houses.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

You could not afford £500,000 for old age pensions. Is that not a fact?

Comment on this

What Deputy Dunne says is not a fact.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

For a modification of the old age pensions.

Comment on this

Casual wages should be exempt. Have you put it into your Bill?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

Is it or is it not correct? I do not propose to make false statements.

Comment on this

The Deputy has made a false statement.

Comment on this

I am convinced that it is correct, as I read it in the Dáil Debates. There was a motion down in this House to increase old age pensions some five years ago, possibly in 1946.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Seven.

Comment on this

It was put to the House and voted against by the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

It was done by the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

You did not give it through the home assistance officer. Answer that.

Comment on this

I believe that the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party in the latter days before 1948 was one of complete neglect so far as the ordinary people were concerned.

Comment on this

Yes, but tell the truth all the same.

Comment on this

If I am wrong, no one will be more quick to rush to apologise than I am—but I am not.

Comment on this

You are wrong.

Comment on this

On a point which I am sure you will be prepared to accept, a Chinn Chomhairle, to assist Deputy Dr. Ryan and Deputy Dunne, it was in October, 1947, on a motion proposed by Deputy O'Higgins and seconded by Deputy Costello to increase old age pensions and which was defeated——

Comment on this

No, it was not. That is wrong. The old age pensions were increased in April, 1947, by 2/6 in the country and 5/- in the city.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dunne is entitled to make a statement.

Comment on this

But not a wrong statement.

Comment on this

They went up by nearly £2,000,000 in three years.

Comment on this

On a point of order, would it be right that Deputy Childers refused the right of a Deputy to go and approach the resident officer for the old age pension?

Comment on this

He was perfectly right in that.

Comment on this

And that is the gentleman we are getting back again?

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this

Democracy!

Comment on this

I remember as a very young boy hearing it shouted from every crossroads and every political platform, some time around the end of the Cumann na nGaedheal period of Government, that the old age pension had been reduced by 1/-.

Comment on this

That is a fact.

Comment on this

Let us proceed. Let Deputy MacEntee contain himself. With the advent of the new Messiah of political parties, that was restored to 10/-. Sixteen years of Fianna Fáil administration passed, and I do not think the Fianna Fáil administration could be accused of undue haste to increase the old age pensions.

Comment on this

Social services went up from £4,000,000 to £13,000,000 during our period of office.

Comment on this

During 16 years there was 2/6 increase in old age pensions. Labour increased the old age pension by 5/- to 17/6 inside a matter of a couple of months.

Comment on this

We raised it from £4,000,000 to £16,000,000. The Deputy need not continue quoting figures for us.

Comment on this

Labour increased it to 17/6 and more people were enjoying it because the means test was modified. I have the advantage over Deputy Childers there, inasmuch as I am a member of several old age pension committees—I wonder if he is—and I meet old age pensioners every day of my life.

Comment on this

So do we.

Comment on this

I am dealing with their problems and I know them. I want to know from this incoming Minister for Social Welfare what the policy will be in regard to old age pensions. Deputy Norton made it clear that, in conjunction with the passing of the Social Welfare Bill, it was proposed to increase old age pensions to £1 a week and to modify the means test so as to ensure that persons could be earning or in receipt of a pension of £1 without it being counted in regard to pension. That may not be very much, or seem of very great importance, to Deputies not in touch with realities, but to those of us who are, it is of supreme importance to the old people of the country. I want to know if that guarantee made by the previous Administration will be implemented, and how soon, by the incoming Minister for Social Welfare.

I did not intend to take up so much time, as the hour draws late and I feel there are others who want to intervene. I believe there are certain political elements within the walls of this House who will reckon it a sorry day that they cast their vote in favour of a single, all-powerful, omnipotent Party. I am quite certain that the Fianna Fáil Party which has now become the Government has every reason to compliment itself on the manner in which it has manoeuvred politically the diverse elements which have been brought together and upon whom the responsibility of deciding the fate of this nation was placed. It has often been said that it is a sorry pass that it should happen that the political fate of the nation should be placed in the hands of a handful of people. It is a bad thing in any democracy, but it happened. I believe, as I have said at the outset, that the policy of Fianna Fáil in years to come—that is, if it lasts years; possibly it may only last months; it is immaterial to some of us how long or how short it lasts, but it is not immaterial to some of the Independents—will prove to be the same as it was in the past, a policy whereby working people were made pawns of as voting blocks and forgotten about to a large extent except for an odd sop here and there through the years when it came to practical politics.

I believe the time will come when all these animosities and personal differences to which I have referred will disappear. Irish politics seem to have been based upon personal differences and little else. For the best part of my lifetime, as long as I can remember and for as long as I have heard about, Irish politics were based upon personal differences between leaders. I noticed during the recent campaign, and other Deputies also noticed it, that whereas the electorate were described as being apathetic, they were not apathetic but were listening and thinking of what the candidates were saying. The time when a shout as to what happened 30 years ago was effective is dying fast. The people are beginning to think and are applying intelligence to politics. That is a very good sign. It is a sign that Labour is on the advance because Labour appeals to the logical people.

Comment on this

Is that why it dropped votes? Is that why it dropped four seats? People are thinking and you dropped four seats.

Comment on this

I want to protest against what Deputy Dunne said when he referred to Independent members of this House and against the words used by the editor of the Evening Mail and by our newspapers generally in the last couple of weeks when they said that the Independent members of the Dáil, above all, should be the last to want an early election, or used words to that effect. It has always been known, and the events of to-day have proved, although proof was not necessary, that any man who was returned to this House as an Independent, as was his duty, voted on all and every occasion' according to his conscience, according to what he thought his constituents felt was best, whether it was in connection with a small matter such as an amendment to a Bill or a big matter such as the election of the Taoiseach. I do not know of any occasion in the last 29 years when an Independent member of the House voted otherwise than according as he thought his constituents wanted him to vote. As an Independent member, I want to protest most emphatically against the rotten dirty campaign that has been carried on by the newspapers of this country in the last few weeks.

Secondly, I want to ask the new Government to take a little lesson, if they can, from the fate which befell the last Government. The main criticism which I have heard against the last Government in the last three and a quarter years is the same as I heard for the previous ten and a half years against the Fianna Fáil Government. It was Dublin City to a large extent and the larger towns of this country which brought about the defeat of the Fianna Fáil Government which had lasted for 16 years. The main reason for the defeat of Fianna Fáil in February, 1948, was that they had failed to keep the cost of living for the people of the City of Dublin and the larger towns within reasonable bounds. The same fate has befallen the inter-Party Government of which we have had experience in the last three and a half years. They failed to keep the cost of living within reasonable bounds.

Comment on this

But you kept them there as long as you could.

Comment on this

Rightly or wrongly, the impression has been got throughout the City of Dublin, the City of Cork and the larger towns, that the inter-Party Government endeavoured to outdo Fianna Fáil in pampering and kowtowing to the farmers of this country at the expense of the townspeople and the taxpayers in general. Let the new Government take a lesson.

Comment on this

Will you take a lesson?

Comment on this

Let them bring down the cost of living by 50 points within a few months.

Comment on this

It is not my intention to detain the House at this early hour of the morning. The subject of the debate that is in progress is of the very greatest possible importance for the future of this country. The motion which the Taoiseach has moved concerns the appointment of a number of Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party and the House has been asked to approve their appointment as Ministers. It is our duty now to consider whether those men are capable and efficient or otherwise.

I want first to express my keen disappointment at the non-appearance of the name of Deputy Peadar Cowan on this list. I am at sea as to why the name of Deputy Cowan is not on this list. I cannot understand why the names of some of those who were responsible for the rebirth of Deputy de Valera as Taoiseach are not on this list.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not constructing a Cabinet; we are discussing the nominations that are made.

Comment on this
Mr. Flanagan

The Taoiseach has presented us with a number of Deputies and has asked this House to approve of their appointment as Ministers.

Now let us take them. The name of Deputy Seán Lemass appears on this list and we are asked to approve of his appointment as a Minister of State. Let us be fair in our criticism and let us keep exactly to the motion before us. Deputy Lemass is one of the brainiest men in this House. If there is such a thing as efficiency, Deputy Seán Lemass is its embodiment, and no one can deny that. He must be given credit where credit is due. In all his speeches in this House as Minister or in Opposition I have seldom heard him indulge in personalities and in my opinion he qualifies to be a Minister of State. No matter what else may be said about him he is capable, he is efficient and he has plenty of brains. Deputy Lemass would be a wonderful Minister and would do wonderful work if he had a policy, if he had something to go on, but we find that a good man with common sense, brains and intelligence will be elected by this House as Minister to pursue a policy which does not exist and that will be a difficult task for Deputy Lemass.

Next appears the name of Deputy Seán MacEntee. I have known him for a long time. Deputy MacEntee is a pleasing, smiling, pleasant-looking little man, but there is no knowing the low depths of indecency to which he can stoop. In my opinion, not alone is he unsuitable and unfit to be a Minister but even to be in the company of decent people. He has brought more disgrace upon himself, upon his Party if such were possible, and upon this country, than any other human being who has ever existed. I am greatly surprised that the Taoiseach, who has the name of being straight and honest among those who do not know him and never saw him, has included in his list of nominees such an indecent creature as Deputy MacEntee to occupy the post of a Minister of State.

Comment on this

Is that in order?

Comment on this

It must be in order to criticise the names before me.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There are limits to the criticism the Deputy should indulge in. "Indecent creature" is a term which should not be applied to any Deputy in this House.

Comment on this
Mr. Flanagan

Deputy MacEntee may not be as bad as all that, but he is as near as possible to it. I cannot possibly hurt the feelings of Deputy MacEntee. He has not such.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should not try too far.

Comment on this
Mr. Flanagan

If we are to have Deputy MacEntee in charge of the Department of Finance, it will be a greater disaster and catastrophe for the country than if we were unfortunate enough to have Deputy Smith in charge of the Department of Agriculture, but that disaster will not befall us, thank God. Deputy MacEntee has the name of being decent among his friends. Who his friends are or how many they are is something I do not know and could never find out, but it will not be many weeks before we find out whether Deputy MacEntee will be decent with the various Departments, with Deputy Walsh——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is travelling too far. We are discussing Deputy MacEntee's administrative capabilities as Minister.

Comment on this

He is not Minister and his main qualifications for the Ministry proposed——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that the Deputy should apply himself to that and not to any personal characteristics of the Deputy.

Comment on this

In the event of Deputy Walsh being appointed Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Childers, being appointed Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and Deputy Derrig being appointed Minister for Lands, what sort of frown will be on the face of Deputy MacEntee if those men present him with an Estimate required to run their Departments efficiently, if they are serious in their wish to provide services and which their Departments will need in order to maintain the efficiency of the past three years? I believe that Deputy MacEntee will not be an easy Minister for Finance for any of his Government colleagues to get on with, nor do I believe that the Minister for Local Government to be, Deputy Smith, will have the co-operation of Deputy MacEntee in providing the funds necessary for the upkeep of his Department. Deputy Aiken is mentioned. I do not propose to say anything more about Deputy MacEntee except that I think he is an unfortunate person to be Minister and I am voting against him.

Comment on this

That finishes him.

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. Ryan is on this list. Is there anyone in this House who can stand up and say that Deputy Dr. Ryan is anything but a decent, harmless man? That is my experience of him and I know him since the first moment I walked into this House. Is there a more inoffensive man in this House than Deputy Dr. Ryan? I do not think there is. Could you speak to a nicer man even when he was Minister for Agriculture, for Health or for Social Welfare? He was always helpful. I never approached Deputy Dr. Ryan in years past when he was Minister but I was received with courtesy and with open arms. I believe that he is better as a medical doctor than he will be as Minister of State, decent and all as he is. Remember that Deputy Dr. Ryan is a man who does not indulge in the personalities so frequently indulged in by his colleague, Deputy MacEntee.

Deputy Derrig is mentioned. If there is one "thick" in this House it is he. He is as thick as could possibly be. I have never heard him speak but he murmured or groaned a few words in Irish which even the best and most fluent Irish speakers ever in this House could not understand. Deputy Mongan, God rest him, and the former Deputy MacFadden could make neither head nor tail of him when he spoke in the native language and no one could understand him in English. The right and proper place for Deputy Derrig would be the seat beside Deputy Eugene Gilbride, as far away as possible from the front benches. Now, however, he is being put in charge of the Department of Lands, no less. I wonder will he now stop the division of lands because, during the last few years of the Fianna Fáil Government, land division was completely at a standstill.

Deputy Moylan was responsible for that. But it is all the same who the Minister is. It is "the Chief," as he is called, who dictates the policy. I wonder if "the Chief" is going to close down the Land Commission and say that no more land is to be divided; that it is the policy of Fianna Fáil not to divide land—as it was their policy for the last four years during which they were in office. I have got a lot to say to Deputy Derrig on this matter, but I shall reserve it until his Estimate comes up. I shall then have a fuller opportunity of discussing it.

I regret that the next name which appears on the list is that of Deputy Gerald Boland, who has been allotted the portfolio of Justice, no less. I think that of all the calamities that could befall the Fianna Fáil Party, this is the greatest. Deputy Gerald Boland is a misfit. Some call him a decent man. He seems to be very popular in his own Party, and he seems to be popular with Deputies who are now in opposition. You would hear them saying from time to time: "He is not a bad old skin. He is a decent fellow." I think that I have more brains in my heel than Deputy Gerald Boland has in his head. I think that he is unfit to be a Minister and I will vote against him.

Comment on this

You have a high conceit of yourself.

Comment on this

It is a nice thing to have. It is nice to be a little proud. I think that any Fianna Fáil Government would be mighty healthier without the inclusion of Deputy Gerald Boland. The proof of that statement is the manner in which Deputy Gerald Boland was elected in the recent elections for Roscommon. I have seen him in this House, when he was a Minister, with the perspiration falling from his forehead when he had men under his control and dying from hunger strike in Portlaoighise prison, and when he was awaiting the arrival of a British hangman to hang Irishmen during the Fianna Fáil régime.

I saw the perspiration on his brows at such times, but the perspiration on his brows on those occasions faded into pale insignificance in comparison with the perspiration which was on his brows in Roscommon courthouse at the counting of the votes in the last general election. I think that, if the election were fought again in Roscommon, Deputy Gerald Boland would not be returned as a member of this House because I think that the people of Roscommon, whom he has had the honour to represent for some years past, have at last discovered that he is an unfit person to represent them and that his election on the last occasion was a mere fluke. I have the greatest pleasure in opposing in the strongest possible manner the appointment of Deputy Gerald Boland as a Minister of State.

Deputy Oscar Traynor appears next on the list. Deputy Traynor is, like Deputy Dr. Ryan, a decent, harmless man. I have never heard Deputy Traynor indulge in personalities. If he is elected, I wish him luck. To give credit where it is due, he is another decent man, whatever else may be said about him. But Deputy Traynor is going to have a very difficult job, and not from these benches here, to satisfy Deputy Major de Valera. How he is going to do that, I do not know. It is between them; if Deputy Oscar Traynor is going to comply with all the defence requirements of Deputy Major de Valera, he is going to have a very difficult job. The best place he can go to is Inchcore where he will be as near as possible to the Aspro factory, because he will require them. It is possible that Deputy Major de Valera was not serious in his defence agitations but, if he was, I do not envy Deputy Traynor the difficult task which is before him.

I wonder if Deputy Traynor, if he is elected, is going to have the tramp and the clank of heels on the barrack parade grounds. I wonder if he is going to contemplate conscription. I wonder what he is going to do about the allowances which Deputy Major de Valera has been agitating for, even at an increased rate, for Army officers and members of the Defence Forces.

If Deputy Traynor is elected as Minister for Defence, I hope he will give the Old I.R.A. pensions to the men whom we have arranged to be called up before the service boards or before the referee and the pensions board, and I hope that, now that he is in a position to do so, he will answer the question which he asked while in Opposition, namely: what is the definition of "active service" in accordance with the Military Service Pensions Act? Now that he will be Minister for Defence, will he define the term "active service" and will he tell us who will qualify for pensions and whether the Old I.R.A., for whom Fianna Fáil have wept so bitterly in the past three years, will get the treatment which Fianna Fáil said they would get if Fianna Fáil were returned to office.

I shall not be disappointed with Deputy Traynor. Whatever else may be said about him, I think that he is sincere. However, he cannot give the pensions without approaching Deputy MacEntee, and if Deputy MacEntee is Minister for Finance he will say: "There can be no consideration for the I.R.A. because we cannot afford it unless we put another penny on the stout and the cigarettes." That, in my opinion, is going to provide Deputy MacEntee with a series of headaches. I wish him a recovery from all these headaches. Bad and all as he is, and he is bad enough, I do not wish him any hard luck in that respect.

Deputy Seán Moylan appears next on the list. Deputy Seán Moylan is a man who has a national record. Like Deputy Seán Dunne, I feel that the less I hear and know of national records the better. It would be a good job if the term "national record" were forgotten completely in this House and never again mentioned. I cannot understand how Deputy de Valera, as Taoiseach, chose a man to be a Minister of State who could not be elected to the Cork County Council. Deputy Moylan could not become a county councillor. The Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, does strange things. I know by the frown on Deputy de Valera's face that he is the most disgusted man in Leinster House to-day because he has to ask himself the question: "How am I going to keep Deputy Cowan, Deputy Cogan, Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll, Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy John Flynn in step? What sort of tune must I strike up in order to keep them in step?"

Comment on this

The ragtime band.

Comment on this
Mr. Flanagan

I know by the Taoiseach that he has given some sort of a guarantee to those people that he will not go to the country for a general election. But, despite the fact that he has said to these Independent Deputies: "Come in with us: keep us there and vote for us," one of these days he will say to five or six of his own men: "Stay at home next week. You are not well"—and poor, poor Deputy Cowan and his three or four Independent colleagues will walk into the division lobbies and find that Fianna Fáil have been defeated. The Taoiseach will then say: "It is not my fault. We are beaten now and we are for the country." I see that Deputy Seán Moylan is allotted the portfolio of Education, the Lord be praised. Surely that is not true. Deputy Seán Moylan, Minister for Education. That is a greater shock than to hear of Deputy MacEntee being Minister for Finance.

Deputy Patrick Smith is to be the Minister for Local Government. That man is daft. I shall say no more about him. His performances in this House during the past three years have been disgusting and disgraceful. His conduct and his manners will have to improve if he is again to occupy a ministerial post. I think he is as crazy as any crazy being to-day. Instead of the Deputy being sent to the Custom House it is to Grange-gorman that he should be sent. Deputy Childers also appears on the list. I think so little about him that I will not mention his name. He is unworthy of any comment. His accent is evidence of where he was educated. I will say no more about Deputy Childers, but I will vote against him if it is possible.

Comment on this

If you are not bringing the character of this House down to the lowest level, then I do not know what to think.

Comment on this

You did it to-day.

Comment on this

The next on the list is Deputy Thomas Walsh. I know Deputy Tommy Walsh very well, and I can classify him with Deputy Dr. Ryan and Deputy Traynor as being a decent man. Whatever else can be said about him, no one can dispute the fact that if there is a gentleman on the Fianna Fáil Party it is Deputy Tommy Walsh. It is quite true that he is a decent man. I honestly believe that he has a difficult job if he is going to be Minister for Agriculture. It is only a few weeks since, when speaking on these benches, he said there should be compulsory tillage, while we have Deputy Lemass saying that there will be no compulsory tillage. Deputy Smith says there should be compulsory tillage. This is where I find that Deputy John Flynn has been disappointed. In the course of his speech to-day, he said that one of the finest Ministers for Agriculture we ever had was Deputy Smith. Now, in his first hour of office the Taoiseach has let down Deputy John Flynn. That is a cause of grave disappointment and distress to Deputy Flynn, that the champion Minister for Agriculture is not Minister for Agriculture any more. Deputy Flynn must be disillusioned, wherever he has gone to. He has disappeared. If there is a rat-hole in Leinster House he is there in despair because Deputy Smith is not Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I ask that Deputies should not make references to rats or rat-holes. It is an expression that should not be used in respect of any member of this House.

Comment on this

The only reference that was made to rats was made by Deputy Cowan to-day.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is not discussing who made a reference to rats. Deputy Flanagan says that a Deputy is in a rat-hole.

Comment on this

I said he was gone into a rat-hole.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not see any difference whatever.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no point of order.

Comment on this

I can see that Deputy Walsh, as Minister for Agriculture, is going to be met with serious opposition from Deputy Paddy Cogan if he inflicts compulsory tillage on the small-holders on the slopes of the Wicklow mountains. I can see a falling out if Deputy Walsh does not provide loans for the broken-down farmers in the Wicklow mountains for whom Deputy Cogan has been pleading for some time past. I can see these things coming. I wish Deputy Walsh every success, but he has a difficult job.

Deputy Cowan made a speech in this House to-day that I did not think it possible could be made. I spoke about two months ago and I made certain references to the ex-Minister for External Affairs, Deputy MacBride. I am now beginning to think of examining my conscience.

Comment on this

Oh!

Comment on this

Yes, I have a conscience. Deputy MacEntee envies me my conscience because he has not one himself.

Comment on this

That is information for the House.

Comment on this

When I heard Deputy Cowan's speech to-day and saw Deputy Dr. Browne voting for Deputy de Valera as Taoiseach, I wondered how, in the name of God, did Deputy MacBride tolerate those men. Deputy MacBride has been very bitterly criticised. I am beginning seriously to think whether all the criticism which has fallen on his shoulders should have fallen on them when he had to put up with men who only came out in their true colours to-day. It has been my first experience of what I call real treachery to see the manner in which Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Peadar Cowan conducted themselves in this House to-day.

Deputy Cowan made a speech in the course of which he referred to an interview he had with the ex-Taoiseach, Deputy Costello. I want this House to listen carefully, and I want the new Taoiseach to listen carefully to this of the man that put him into office and that made him Taoiseach. Deputy Cowan met me in the precincts of this House yesterday evening and said: "Is it not a wonder that Costello has not sent for me to talk things over and ask me what I was going to do?"

Comment on this

Are private conversations going to be mentioned now?

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

You mentioned a good deal about Baltinglass.

Comment on this

I want to clear Deputy Costello on this. I said, in the presence of another member of this House, to Deputy Cowan that there was nothing to prevent him from walking in to the Taoiseach. He said: "No, I would like the Taoiseach to send for me." I immediately spoke to the Taoiseach, and said that Deputy Cowan would like to see him. The Taoiseach immediately 'phoned up. Deputy Cowan and myself walked into Government Buildings. We met the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach said these words: "Peadar, you would like to discuss something with me?""Well, Taoiseach," he said, "I thought you might at least have sent for me as an Independent and asked me what I was going to do." The Taoiseach said: "If that was the case I would have to send for every individual Independent, and whether I win or lose I will have no bargaining."

There is a little more. Deputy Cowan sat down and I sat at the table. We chatted and Deputy Cowan said: "Oh, I do not think I will vote for you." He said: "I am going to vote for Fianna Fáil as a protest against the Bishops dictating to your Government." These are the words he used in my presence, that "As a protest against the Bishops ruling the Government, I will vote for Deputy Éamon de Valera". It is because of that Government's stand to comply with the Bishops of Ireland that Deputy Cowan has chosen to vote for Deputy Éamon de Valera as Taoiseach. I was listening to-day and I heard the then Taoiseach use these words in this House which Deputy Cowan attempted to withdraw or deny. Let there be no confusion. To the Taoiseach he said: "My real reason is as a protest because the Bishops of Ireland are ruling your Government." That is how Deputy Éamon de Valera captured Deputy Cowan's vote.

I want to tell the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party that his Government is not in office to-day because of good policy. It is in office because of jealousy, bitterness and hatred. That is why it is there.

Comment on this

That is why you are making this speech to-night.

Comment on this

No. The Government is in office to-night because we were envied the good work we were doing and because Deputy Cogan was jealous of the progress and was jealous of the success of Deputy Dillon in his capacity as Minister for Agriculture. He could not stand it. The jealousy overflowed and he had to get Deputy Dillon out. Believe me—the Taoiseach must agree with me—that a Government which is built on the foundations of jealousy or hatred cannot have the blessing of God, success or good luck. It is because of hatred, jealousy and spite that Fianna Fáil are in office to-day. This Government takes over office in the morning and when the Ministers go into their offices, there is nothing surer than that they will not find there any schemes or plans. When our Ministers took over office the shelves were packed to the fullest capacity with files and plans. The files were weighed down with dust. They were surrounded and covered with cobwebs, but we removed the cobwebs, blew off the dust and disposed of the files and schemes. The schemes were not left to be a resting place for cobwebs. They were put into operation and few schemes were left. Action is what took place.

I hope that the Taoiseach in his wisdom will not again embark on the crazy, daft schemes that Fianna Fáil had in those offices, to pull down all the buildings in Merrion Street and build new Government buildings. Are they now going to remove the Children's Hospital and put a Garden of Remembrance so that the Last Post can be sounded and all the Fianna Fáil warriors can say: "God rest the dead" while the children are left without a hospital. I would like a statement as to whether those crazy, daft schemes are again to be the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government.

I have heard speeches—good ones and bad ones—but the most sincere speech I ever heard came from the lips of Deputy McQuillan. Deputy McQuillan could not be bought. Whatever else may be said about Deputy McQuillan, he has a principle. He is straight. Nothing could buy him. Every possible attempt was made to get Deputy Jack McQuillan to do a certain thing but, unlike Deputy MacEntee and like Deputy Flanagan, he has a conscience. For that reason he acted in accordance with that conscience. He has a principle and he is a millionaire because of that. The reason he is a millionaire is that no money could buy his principles. I hope that the people of Roscommon will bear in mind that, whatever representatives they have, Deputy McQuillan is at least honest, straight, decent, dependable and cannot be bought. I hope and trust that the people of Roscommon will bear in mind the fact that Deputy McQuillan is an honest man.

Before sitting down, I would like to know whether we are now going to have a mother and child welfare scheme with no means test to satisfy Deputy Dr. Browne. Is the Taoiseach now going to sneer and jeer in the face of the Irish Hierarchy? Is the Taoiseach now going to accept the rulings of the Bishops of Ireland or is he going to tell them to take a running jump at themselves and to keep their noses out of Government affairs because he wants to keep Deputy Cowan and Deputy Dr. Browne as the two principal feathers in his tail? The Taoiseach is a Catholic and a good Catholic. Whatever else may be said about him, that is true. I wonder whether he is now going to give this House the mother and child welfare scheme without a means test? That is what I would like to know and that is what many Deputies on this side of the House would like to know.

I am wondering, whether, in order to capture the imagination of Deputy Dr. Browne, Deputy Cowan and, I believe, to some extent of Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll, who is a young man—I met him only once; he is a decent man; he has an honest appearance and it is only as times goes on we will be able to see whether it is his appearance is honest or whether it is real honesty— this understanding has been given to them: "If you vote for us we will give you the mother and child scheme without any means test." How on earth can the Taoiseach say to-night that he is in office, thank God, if it is on the vote of a man who condemned the Bishops of Ireland? I am glad we did not get his vote because we would have neither luck nor grace with it. Will the Taoiseach now tell the Irish people that he has with him the two men who defied the Hierarchy of Ireland? It is those two men who flouted the Bishops of Ireland and put Deputy de Valera, the Taoiseach, into office. The Taoiseach would have been straighter and would have had more public confidence behind him if he had said to Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Cowan: "Keep as far away from me as you can. I do not want to get into office on insults offered to the Irish Hierarchy." If there is one man who has played a big part in insulting the Church and Bishops of Ireland to the disgrace of any Catholic, that man is Deputy Cowan, whose vote has Fianna Fáil in office. Did I ever think that a Catholic Irishman like the Taoiseach would ever get office on the vote of a man who publicly renounced the Bishops of Ireland in no uncertain way on more than one occasion? Office that has been secured on that score is one that can be neither healthy nor lucky, and cannot be crowned with that success, good luck and blessing of God which any Irish Government needs to progress and keep with the times.

I am sorry that this has happened. I am sorry that any Government should be elected by the vote of Deputy Captain Cowan since I believe that, now that Deputy Captain Cowan is behind the Fianna Fáil Party, that Party agrees fully with the manner in which he has insulted our Bishops, denounced their views and refused to accept their guidance and their help. The Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, must be a party to that. All his Ministers must be a party to it since they have in their company now no less a person than Deputy Captain Cowan.

I will vote against the nominees of the Taoiseach for the reasons I have given. I think that Deputy John A. Costello should be a proud and happy man to-night since he can now say to himself: "I have left office. I have gone and thank God, Deputy Captain Cowan, with his anti-Catholic doctrine, has not been responsible for putting me back." We are proud to be defeated by the vote of Deputy Captain Cowan. Certainly I am proud to be defeated.

If there is one man in Fianna Fáil who must be unhappy at this moment it is the Taoiseach because his present company is bad, unsound and unwholesome. There are very decent men and women in the Taoiseach's Party but, as sure as I am standing here to-night, the man who will wreck the Taoiseach and his Government is the man who put him and his Government into power here, Deputy Captain Cowan.

Comment on this

If he had voted for your Party he would be a saint; he would be canonised.

Comment on this

I want now to direct the Taoiseach's attention to the last note I intend to strike to-night. I want the Taoiseach to listen carefully to my remaining remarks. He has appointed a number of Cabinet Ministers. I believe that if these Ministers are to give good and valuable service they should be adequately paid for their work. There are very few Deputies who would have the pluck to say that no Deputy can conscientiously discharge his duties on his present allowance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise here.

Comment on this

I am asking the Taoiseach when he appoints his Ministers——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise.

Comment on this

——to ensure that they will be paid for the work they do.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise on this motion.

Comment on this

Then I hope to have an opportunity of raising this matter on another occasion. As I said, I will vote against the Taoiseach's nominees. I think the set-up is unsound. When Deputy de Valera was in opposition he said, in reference to the inter-Party Government: "They were not elected to office but found themselves in office." How true that is to-day about his own Government: "They were not elected to office but found themselves in office."

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

On a point of order, is it the intention of the Taoiseach to make a statement on policy or are we to take it that the policy of the Government is that published in the newspapers?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

May I remind the House that the Vote must be taken before 2 o'clock? I do not know whether the Taoiseach would like to make a statement in conclusion.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Are we to take it that the 17 points programme published some days ago represents the policy of the new Government or will we have a statement of policy from the Taoiseach to-night?

Comment on this

Irrespective of what Deputy Corish thinks, I have a right to speak.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Vote must be taken before 2 o'clock. I do not know whether the Taoiseach desires to say anything.

Comment on this

I would like to say a few words in conclusion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I am not waiving my right in favour of anybody. I think I have a right to speak.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Keane will resume his seat.

Comment on this

Deputy Keane will not resume his seat.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Then Deputy Keane will leave the House.

Comment on this

Deputy Keane will do that. Deputy Keane could do what Deputy Smith did—I am in two minds on the matter—and be removed from the House.

Deputy Keane withdrew from the House.

Comment on this

There are three or four points to which I would like to refer, but I am afraid that time will not permit me to do so. The first point I would like to deal with is with reference to the former Ceann Comhairle. It has been suggested that there was something improper in his voting to-day on the motion for the election of the Taoiseach. The suggestion was that he did not have to go forward for re-election to the Dáil, and that therefore, for some reason or other, it was not proper that he should vote. Everybody knows that the reason why the Ceann Comhairle is automatically returned to the Dáil is because during the period he occupies the Chair he cannot take part in debates and cannot represent his constituents. The procedure has reference to the time that has passed; it has no reference to the future. The moment the Ceann Comhairle relinquishes office, as has been pointed out by the Chair, he becomes an ordinary member of the House and is entitled to exercise all the rights of such a member.

There is another point in connection with this matter. The former Ceann Comhairle wished to retire for health reasons some months ago. He informed me of that fact, and I asked him not to retire. I think he also informed the then Taoiseach that it was his intention to retire. There is, therefore, no question of his leaving the Chair on this occasion in order to have a vote. There would be nothing improper in his doing so, but the fact of the matter is that notice of his pending retirement was given a considerable time ago.

As I have mentioned the former Ceann Comhairle, I think it is my duty —indeed I regard it is a privilege—as Taoiseach to-night and as Taoiseach for most of the period during which the former Ceann Comhairle served the House to pay tribute to the manner in which he occupied the Chair and conducted the business of the House. I think he gave satisfaction to everybody, and I deeply regret that at the end of his period in office any reflection should be cast upon him such as was cast upon him here to-day.

Comment on this

Since it is an important occasion to have a Ceann Comhairle retiring after such a long period in office it might be desirable to have a formal expression of appreciation when we next meet.

Comment on this

That is perfectly true.

Comment on this

That does not change my view that this was a mean political trick.

Comment on this

It had occurred to me, too, that we should pay formal tribute and we will be able to take the opportunity of doing that in the near future. But I feel I must avail of the first opportunity offered to repudiate the suggestion made.

There are two or three other points. There was a suggestion made about a minority Government and a suggestion of an all-Party Government. I cannot deal with these point to-night but I shall take an early opportunity of doing so.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 75
·
Níl 66
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?