We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Office of the Taoiseach (Resumed).

Contributions 1–217 of 709. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

When I moved to report progress I was about to suggest to the Government that there would be nothing detrimental in the effort to conserve the language in our making the Gaeltacht and congested areas economically sound. I believe the Irish language is much more likely to flourish in a prosperous Gaeltacht rather than in a poverty-stricken one. No matter how desirous we may be for the rapid re-establishment and development of our language the Government will have to face the existing problem on the basis of grappling first of all with the economy of the areas concerned. One factor that bears heavily on the people in the congested and Gaeltacht areas is the unreal values that are placed on their holdings. I would have liked the Taoiseach to have given us a reasonable indication of what the functions of the new Parliamentary Secretary to the Government are.

The House owes the country, and the Government owes the House, some explanation for the festooning of the House with five beautiful Parliamentary Secretaries. If there is a Government policy for the Gaeltacht, surely there must have been some plan crystallised in their minds when they decided to appoint this new and special Parliamentary Secretary to the Government itself? What is that policy? Can the Government give us any indication of what scheme, if any, they propose to keep in employment people living at present in the Gaeltacht; what plan, if any, they have for the development of industries that the Taoiseach wants in harmony with the area and not tending to Anglicise it? What are these industries? What are their likely prospects of survival or of economic reality? We are entitled to know that, instead of being treated, as we were this morning by the responsible Leader of the Government, to a shamming, circuitous hour and ten minutes of virtual codology. Never in my short experience have I heard a more inept effort at presenting a case.

We are entitled to know what is Government policy on major issues. Is it to be a continuation of intelligent capital investment? Is the drive for housing to continue at its full impetus? Are the social improvements conceived and designed by the predecessors of this Government to be implemented in full? Above all, we were entitled to a statement from the Taoiseach to-day as to whether that cemented unity and domestic peace which exist at home are to be preserved, as to whether or not he has departed from that extraordinary statement he had to make about the Republic of Ireland Bill— that he did not know whether it was a good thing or a bad thing. We are entitled to inquire and to know whether the country can under this Government hope for a continuation of domestic peace. We are entitled to get an assurance that the special courts and tribunals will not once again raise their ugly heads in the domestic affairs of this country. We are entitled to have, and I am demanding from the Leader of the Government, an assurance to the country that the gun has gone out of politics, that he will strive to maintain the internal position that has been attained, and that he will ensure as Leader of the Government that the seeds of bitterness and disunity are finally laid to rest, and will remain so.

One would have expected, and was entitled to expect from the Leader of the Government a statement as to what is the Government's approach to all the big issues. We had lamentations and exhortations for many months on the issue of defence. We were told that we should raise unlimited cohorts. We were entitled to get an indication, which we did not get from the Taoiseach to-day, as to what is the Government's plan for defence and for the building up of the Army about which Deputy Major de Valera was so vocal for three years. We were entitled to a statement from the Taoiseach to-day in the light of what had been said by Deputy Boland, the present Minister for Justice, when he was on this side of the House, as to the Government's attitude to their new brother in bondage, Deputy Cowan, and his erstwhile army of four and forty fighting men and a couple of stout gossoons.

We were entitled to, but we did not get, a pronouncement on the particular heads of the Government's approach to these problems. We were entitled to get an indication, where special Parliamentary Secretaries have been assigned duties, as to what the Government's intentions and policy on certain issues were. We were entitled to hear, after the appointment of a Parliamentary Secretary to deal with the problem of fisheries, what the approach to the fishing industry is to be and whether or not the Government will face up to the problem of making the fishing industry, not a subsidiary industry but a major industry, self-supporting and of a truly national character. We were entitled to know whether the Government will develop, and aim at maintaining or exceeding, the target set for afforestation. We were entitled to get information as to what the Government had planned for the future. What did we get? We got incoherence, indefiniteness and a complete lack of cohesion in a rambling speech indicating that the zest and the personal vitality of the Taoiseach were suffering with the passing of the years.

I want the Taoiseach, when replying, to let the country know where exactly it stands under this new caretaker Government. I want the Taoiseach to be careful and deliberate in reassuring the country as to where it stands. Does he intend to continue the effort to bring to full fruition the scheme that it took the courage and the vision of a James Dillon to initiate? Does he intend to give to the workers throughout the length and breadth of this country the security they might have hoped for and would certainly have obtained, under the previous Minister for Social Welfare, Deputy Norton? Will he not come into the House now and indicate whether the Minister for Finance, adopting the role as he did last night of the doleful Johnny in the hair shirt, represents the Government view or whether, looking at his own Party organ this morning, he can see the divers tongues of two of his Ministers talking within an hour of each other in this House—one boasting that exports have reached pre-war level again and the other enunciating a tale of woe, misery and impending doom.

We are entitled to know whether the Leader of the present Government, the Taoiseach, has suddenly become wedded to the idea of a Coalition Government, and what has caused this change of heart in one who preached and prated from one end of the country to the other: "We stand alone and we will touch nobody else." What motives, other than those of seeking power and patronage, coalesced him with the "Doubtful Five"? This country was entitled to get, but did not get, a responsible, considered statement from the Leader of a Government, resting as it does on foundations of that type. It is remarkable that, having jettisoned day after day during the election campaign all of its one-time policy, it now comes into the Fourteenth Dáil to assimilate, and grasp at, the policy of its predecessor. It was a good policy and we know it. At least the Taoiseach, as the responsible Leader of the Government, could have had the courage to come into this House to-day and say: "We are in Government again now with responsibility, and we intend to discharge that responsibility by accepting the able and intelligent policy given to us by our predecessor."

I am glad the Taoiseach is back in the House because I want to ask him, as a member of a different generation, why has it become something of an abhorrence or something not to be touched that we should, in the year 1951, want to hold out our hands as a gesture to the North of Ireland and say to them: "All of you, be you anti-Partitionists, Nationalists, or whatever creed or class you like, are welcome to have audience in our Oireachtas"? This view is extraordinary in one who can let his mind go back to the part that he himself played in the establishment of the First Dáil in this country, a Dáil that was ultimately to ensure that the King's writ no longer ran in the present territory of the Republic of Ireland. It may well be that there are arguments against this method, but I am asking the Taoiseach to consider very well whether the crack of his whip to-night, driving his 69 heroes before him to vote against this motion, is not going to retard the progress that I genuinely believe he himself has sought to make in the Partition problem. It does seem extraordinary, when one remembers the situation of an all-Party group in the Mansion House Committee striving for a unified Ireland, that we cannot have unanimity, or at least the exercise of free conscience and of a free vote on this problem. I want the Taoiseach to tell us why. It is common knowledge to us all that to many elements in the North of Ireland, the present Taoiseach is a symbol of greatness and of leadership. Let us see and consider carefully what might happen to whatever goodwill might be built up when this motion is dealt with to-night.

I do not wish to delay the House but there is one further problem that I must deal with before I sit down. It is one that is agitating this country and it is one on which the Taoiseach cannot avoid facing the issue much longer. There has been controversy under the Health Bill; there has been a question of the constitutionality of parts of the 1947 Act; there has been a responsible and considered document served on the Government at the behest of the Irish Hierarchy objecting to certain portions and certain parts within that Act. This House and this country are entitled to know from the Taoiseach whether the boast of Deputy Cowan that he would not be subject to or dominated by the Bishops is to be a reality or whether——

Comment on this

You should give a little thought to your uncle.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

——the Government, in the light of the responsibility it has to the Irish people and in the light of the responsibility that the Irish Hierarchy has to the Irish people, will give a considered and worthy answer to the Bishops, and whether we will now have an opportunity of solving forever a problem that was deliberately put in a wrong perspective by people trying to exploit a situation for their own ends. The country is entitled to know what the answer to that problem will be.

Deputy Cowan's last reference by way of interruption to me is typical of him. If he might some time remember what he once could have been and might have been, he would be a better ornament to this House.

I want to conclude on this note, earnestly to exhort the Taoiseach, in the situation, complex as it is, of Deputy MacBride's motion being taken with his own Estimate, at least to allow the issue on the first motion in the name of Deputy MacBride to be one for the free vote of this House, each Deputy exercising his responsibility in the full national consciousness of what his duty should be.

Comment on this

I do not agree with the suggestion made by Deputy Collins that the attitude and the actions of the Taoiseach in this House to-day were in any way due to the fact that the Taoiseach is ageing. In my view, the Taoiseach is one of the ablest and most experienced politicians we have in this country. I am not saying that in derogation of the Taoiseach. It is because of that, however, that I was puzzled and surprised this morning to see the Taoiseach, at the end of a few perfunctory remarks in which he said absolutely nothing in introducing his Estimate, resume his seat.

It was because of that I was surprised, when he was successfully drawn by Deputy Corish, by other Deputies, and by myself, that he still said nothing though he spoke for one and a half hours. I should like, if I may, in passing, to compliment him for being able to speak for one and a half hours and yet say nothing. He gave this House no indication of Government policy in any respect. I defy anybody who reads the Taoiseach's speech this morning to be able to know what the policy of this Government is at the moment, or what it is going to be.

I was more surprised still to find that, until I asked the Taoiseach what the Government's policy was in regard to Partition, there had not been one single, solitary word uttered from the Government Benches or by any of the Ministers of the Government in relation to what is admittedly the paramount problem of this nation, what is admittedly the paramount objective of the Irish people, namely, the undoing of the unjust and unnatural partition of our country. We were often told, and told rightly, when sitting on the benches opposite that it was part of the function of a Government to give a lead to the people. What lead did the Taoiseach or any of his Ministers give the country in the course of these discussions? Naturally, I sought for a reason. I pointed out that the Taoiseach is one of the ablest and most experienced politicians we have in this country. He cannot have casually adopted the course he did in this House this morning. It was not due to lack of experience or to lack of ability, There must have been a reason for it, and I have been puzzled ever since this morning trying to think what his reason might be.

I could easily, I suppose, make a gibe and say it was because the Taoiseach had no policy, or because the Government had no policy. I do not think that would be the answer. If the Taoiseach had no policy or if his Government had no policy, he would be able to disguise that fact much more ably than he did this morning. The only conclusion I could come to was that there must be a very serious difference of opinion within the ranks of his Cabinet.

There must be a reason for it. As I said before, the Taoiseach is experienced and he knows it is part of his duty as head of a new Government on the last day of this Session of the Dáil to give a lead, to give an indication of the Government's policy to the country. There must be a compelling reason to prevent him from following that normal and desirable course. I do not think that he can shelter himself behind the plea that he has not been long enough in office. He has been in office since the beginning of June. In any case, even if he were only a week in office, presumably he has given some thought to the different problems. He is sufficiently fluent to be able to give expression to the remedies and the solutions which he proposes.

I warned the Taoiseach on the night upon which he nominated his Government in this House that the most alarming feature of that Government was the appointment by him of Deputy MacEntee as Minister for Finance. I did not say that in derogation of Deputy MacEntee personally, whom I believe would be quite a good Minister in some other Department. To my mind, however, the appointment of Deputy MacEntee as Minister for Finance was a clear indication that progress in the policy of development and investment which had been pursued successfully during the last few years was going to be brought to a standstill. The speech that the Minister for Finance made yesterday is I think a clear indication of that in so far as the Minister for Finance is permitted to pursue that policy in the present Cabinet. My only hope is that the Tánaiste and other Minister in that Cabinet will be sufficiently strong to be able to prevent the Minister for Finance's policy from being given effect to, to be able to prevent us from returning to a mid-Victorian form of economy.

The Taoiseach spoke about emigration this morning. Incidentally, if I might digress for a moment, the Taoiseach said to-day that he had not had time to have the emigration figures made up. He made a somewhat similar remark during the general election campaign when relying on figures which were two or three years old. It might possibly be of assistance to the Taoiseach, on the assumption that his statement was a correct one, if I drew his attention to some of the figures which were given in this House and which were readily available to the Taoiseach at any time he desired at five minutes' notice.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy.

Comment on this

Then do not, if you do not want to.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I understand, Sir, that you called Deputy MacBride in the place in which you called him because he has two motions on the Order Paper to propose for consideration in connection with this Estimate. I take it that that was the reason you called him at the time you did and as there is only approximately another——

Comment on this

Long before Deputy Cowan was in this House to-day, I presented myself to speak and was not called upon. With respect, I have been here since 10.30 this morning. Deputy Cowan was not even here.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy MacBride has been called by the Chair just as any Deputy who offered himself to speak would have been called.

Comment on this

We have to consider two motions on the Order Paper. I think these motions are of sufficient importance to be moved and the reasons for them given by the Deputy who has them on the Order Paper.

Comment on this

On a further point of order. Is it not the privilege of every Deputy, no matter where he sits, to review Government policy on this particular Estimate?

Comment on this

But not at too great length, I hope, for everybody's sake.

Comment on this

We all want to say something.

Comment on this

I do not think I am in the habit of speaking at too great length.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must be allowed to make his speech in his own way. The Chair cannot dictate to him as to what line he should take.

Comment on this

Do I take it that the debate must finish at 12 o'clock?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is correct.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy would be better off playing with a few soldiers in Fairview.

Comment on this

I would ask the Taoiseach, if the debate is to go this way, that there should be a further extension beyond 12 o'clock to enable these matters to be properly considered.

Comment on this

You have seven hours now and there is nobody else in your Party.

Comment on this

I am an important Party on my own. Deputy Davin has not a Party at all, and Deputy MacBride has not a wonderful one either.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this

The figures which in no uncertain fashion indicate emigration in any given year are those which are obtainable from the issue of travel permits and passports to persons seeking employment abroad. They are somewhat exaggerated because they do include migratory workers who come back, but no person can leave without such a travel permit. For the information of the Taoiseach, in the year 1948 there were 40,075 such permits and passports issued. In the year 1949 that had fallen to 25,491. In the year 1950 the figure had fallen to 17,356. I think these figures do show that there was a steady fall in emigration in the course of the last three years. I merely draw the Taoiseach's attention to that.

Comment on this

I know about these figures, and knew about these figures, but that is not the latest report at all that I have got from the Statistics Department. I refrained from giving the figures because the Department did not wish to be bound to certain figures. The picture is not quite the picture the Deputy thinks it is from these figures. There were other figures which were supplied in answer to parliamentary questions which, again, do not give us a true picture. It is not easy to get it exactly and the Department is doing its utmost to get the true picture.

Comment on this

I agree that these figures do not give an accurate picture but they show a trend.

Comment on this

They can be very inaccurate, too, but that is another question.

Comment on this

All figures can be inaccurate, but at least people cannot leave the country to seek employment abroad without obtaining a permit or passport.

Comment on this

That is true, but we have a land border which upsets many of these things.

Comment on this

There are people who skip across the Border without any papers. There is no way of dealing with these. The traffic returns are not either a completely accurate indication because people can go across the Border without employing public transport.

Comment on this

Half a dozen of Deputy Cowan's army—they would not be included in these figures.

Comment on this

That would be almost as many as Deputy Davin's Parliamentary Party.

Comment on this

You are not able to count.

Comment on this

May I ask if motions 6 and 7 are to be moved?

Comment on this

Have I the floor?

Comment on this

If they are to be moved, I would suggest that the Deputy who is to move them should move them when he stands up to speak. He is speaking now on the general matter, and I suggest that he must either move these motions or they cannot be discussed.

Comment on this

It is due to the confusing arrangement made.

Comment on this

May I ask are motions 6 and 7 to be moved?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The motions to which the Deputy refers, by agreement of the House, will be moved after the Estimate has been put to the House to-night. Deputy MacBride is quite in order in referring to the motions now without moving them.

Comment on this

Then they can be discussed without being moved?

Comment on this

That has been the ruling of the Chair for days. If the Deputy attended this House a little more he might hear what the ruling of the Chair is.

Comment on this

May I take it that there will be discussion on the two motions when this matter has been dealt with?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No, the discussion is taking place now.

Comment on this

Is Deputy MacBride giving us any reasons for the motions?

Comment on this
Mr. Coburn

That is for the Chair to say, not Deputy Cowan, the know-all.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach expressed regrets, which we all share, in regard to emigration. He expressed regrets, which we all share, in regard to the dwindling population of the Gaeltacht. But the very thing which promotes emigration, which results in the depopulation of the Western seaboard, is the thing which his Minister for Finance is going to promote, namely, the policy of restricting investment, of restricting development here and of building up sterling assets.

There are two different approaches to our economic problems. You may pursue the policy which has been pursued since this State was set up, that of building up sterling assets, of relying on the income from these sterling assets to make up for our adverse balance of trade, but that policy inevitably must result in underinvestment and under-development here. That policy, too, must inevitably result in, and indeed depends for its success upon, the maintenance of a pool of unemployment and a stream of emigration; another concomitant feature of that policy is a policy of low wages.

The alternative approach is that of development of our own resources by the utilisation of our capital for that purpose. The last Government pursued the latter policy for a period of three years, with the results that have been pointed out by Deputy Costello this morning. As a result of that policy, we have had a lower rate of unemployment in the course of the last three years, and particularly in the last year than at any other period in our history. We have had more people in employment in this country than ever before. These developments were rendered possible by the fact that we were prepared to engage in a policy of capital development here and to repatriate sterling assets for that purpose.

We have been spoken to about the dangers of inflation. For the last 30 years, the same old worn-out tags have been trotted out by economists, born and bred in the last century, who have talked to us about inflation. We have no control over inflation in this country. We have not got control of our own currency.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

We cannot influence inflation. The inflation from which we suffer here, if inflation occurs, is inflation that occurs from outside, and over which we have no control whatsoever. Inasmuch as we cannot control either the value or volume of our currency, it is quite obvious that we cannot either prevent or promote inflation. The only type of inflation that has been noticeable in recent years has been inflation in regard to house property. Any inflation there has been in that regard was due to the fact that we had not got enough houses and that scarcity prices prevailed. The remedy for that is to provide more houses. You cannot increase production unless you are prepared to invest your capital here for that purpose. Any policy which will involve either the abandonment or the slowing down of the capital development schemes that have been started by the Government can only result in unemployment and more emigration.

I hope that the Taoiseach was not serious when he made a reference, a casual reference, this morning to our health plans and indicated that they might prove too expensive or too ambitious. He qualified it immediately afterwards, but I doubt if the Taoiseach would have made the reference to our health plans being too ambitious or too expensive, even if he was qualifying it afterwards, unless he had some reason for doing so. I hope it is not an indication that it is proposed to curtail the hospital building programme or the health plans.

Comment on this

We built more hospitals during the period we were in office than you did.

Comment on this

I am not questioning what you did when in office. I am merely concerned with what Government policy is at the moment. I take it that the Taoiseach did not make the reference to the health plans being too ambitious or too expensive for nothing. He may have merely made that reference in case the Minister for Finance said: "We must close down on hospital building." It may be part of the difficulties that he has to deal with in his Cabinet.

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll just walked in at the time.

Comment on this

It was made possibly for his benefit.

Comment on this

This is profoundness.

Comment on this

You are not in his Party, are you?

Comment on this

I had not intended, in the course of this discussion, to deal with matters other than Partition, but I felt that the attitude of the Taoiseach this morning, or rather his lack of attitude, needed some comment. Again, in regard to Partition, I think that the Taoiseach was particularly evasive. He knew that the House was discussing, with his Estimate, the two motions that have been standing in my name for a considerable time on the Order Paper. He knew that these two motions would form the centrepiece of much discussion in the House on his Estimate. Yet, we got no indication from the Taoiseach as to his attitude in regard to these two motions.

There is always the danger that, in dealing with long-standing problems and with long-standing difficulties, one's attitude of mind becomes set without very much reason, or very often it becomes set in the light of the circumstances that may have existed at the time that one's mind was set, but which have long ceased to operate. I think that is what has happened not merely to the Taoiseach but to a great many people in this House in regard to Partition. We have had no normal political thinking, no normal political development. Our political life grew up, if you like, out of the divergencies which arose from the civil war. We have had very little objective thinking in regard to Partition since. Attitudes in regard to Partition became crystallised in the light of those circumstances rather than in the light of the circumstances as they exist to-day.

I do not know whether it would be possible to get the members of this House, particularly the older members, to take an objective attitude towards the two motions which stand in Deputy Tully's name and mine. I feel that if they did, these two motions would be accepted unanimously by the House. I think that the young men on all sides of this House—Fine Gael, the Labour Party and Fianna Fáil— agree with these motions. I think that it is not a question of policy. I think it has become largely a question of prejudice in the minds of some of the older men who took a set attitude a number of years ago and who have refused to look beyond that.

Before dealing with these two motions in any detail, there are a few general observations I would like to make in relation to Partition. Obviously, the best method of dealing with Partition would have been by the formation of a national Government, representative of all Parties in this House and certainly representative of the major Parties in this House. That would have been the best way of showing our determination and our resolve to secure the unity of the country.

That was not possible. At least, so far as the Taoiseach is concerned, he was not prepared to adopt that course. I think that the other Parties in the House would have agreed — not with enthusiasm but would have agreed — to that course. I feel that the country would have welcomed it. There would have been a 90 per cent. support for it in the country. That is really what the people of the country want, but old prejudices die hard!

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy would be good enough to indicate in what manner the formation of what he calls a national Government was going to end Partition?

Comment on this

Certainly. In the final analysis, the continuance of Partition depends on the determination and the ability of the British Government at any given time to maintain Partition. Partition was created by the British Government and Partition can only continue by virtue of the political, economic and military support which the British Government extends to a minority of the people of the Province of Ulster. Therefore, in the final analysis, the task of any Irish Government, if it is to undo Partition, depends upon its ability to make the British Government of the day realise that the Irish people are determined not to allow the continuance of Partition and are determined to use every means at their disposal to secure the unity of their nation. I believe that a reasonable solution, based on the unity of will of the Irish people, on the common interest of the Irish people, North and South, can be arrived at rapidly, once Britain can be persuaded to cease interfering in our affairs in this island.

I believe that, so long as Britain is prepared to lend her political, her economic and her military power to any section of our people, in order to maintain a minority Government, the problem remains insoluble. The first point of attack must be devised to ensure that Britain will let go her hold on portion of our country. When I say "attack", let me clarify it immediately; I am not suggesting a physical attack or a military attack. In that regard let me make it quite clear, too, that I think the Irish people, through this Parliament, through their Government, have a right to use force in order to secure the reintegration of our national territory, if the Parliament, if the Government, so decide. It is not a course I advocate, and I do not think it would be a desirable or a necessary course, but it is well to make it quite clear that we, as a nation, are entitled to use every means at our disposal in order to secure control of our own affairs, in order to establish for ourselves the elementary democratic right of national self-determination.

The problem to attack, therefore, from a political point of view, is that caused by the claim of the British Government to exerise sovereignty over a portion of our island. To my mind, that is the first and main obstacle to the ending of Partition. A powerful State can always interfere successfully in the affairs of a small neighbouring State, if it is prepared to use its economic, political and military power to do so. In effect, the history of the world could be described as an account of such attempts right through the ages, attempts by large nations to interfere in the affairs of their smaller neighbours. To us in Ireland, the power and prestige of Britain when interfering in our affairs, is as objectionable as was the German or the Russian interference in the affairs of Poland and Czechoslovakia objectionable to those nations. I think that, in forcing Britain to alter her policy in regard to Ireland, our first task is to compel a realisation of the issues in Britain; to compel the British Government of the day to understand quite clearly that this nation is determined to end Partition and to secure the enforcement of democratic rule in this island and that all Parties in the State are united for that purpose.

The Taoiseach has asked me how the formation of a national Government would help to do that. It is quite obvious that if the Taoiseach were able to speak on behalf of a national Government, he could to-morrow, next week or in a month's time, say to the British Government: "On behalf of the Irish people, on behalf of a Government united for this purpose, I now ask you to declare that you relinquish your claim to sovereignty over any portion of the island of Ireland," and that he would be able to speak with much greater authority and to command a hearing which he could not command in his present position. It is quite obvious that, so long as the Taoiseach is dependent for office on the votes of a couple of irresponsibles, such as our gallant captain and some of his friends——

Comment on this

It was 71 to 42 on the last count.

Comment on this

I do not think that matters very much. It would be very foolish if the Minister deluded himself into thinking that anybody here looked upon the Government as being a very stable Government in its present position. Obviously, a Government composed of all the different Parties in this House would be regarded as a stable Government and could talk with authority.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to get into that form of Government. That is his whole idea.

Comment on this

That is one of the usual pieces of dirty work which Deputy Cowan engages in. I made it quite clear that if such a Government were formed, I would not expect or accept a seat in it.

Comment on this

You did not say that.

Comment on this

I did say it.

Comment on this

He did say it.

Comment on this

He said he would not expect it, but did not say he would not accept it.

Comment on this

I think that a Deputy who uses falsified documents in this House in order to attack the Hierarchy should be ashamed to open his mouth here. If he went off to play soldiers, he might be better occupied.

Comment on this

This was the marvellous Minister for External Affairs.

Comment on this
Mr. Coburn

He is not a politician on the make, anyway.

Comment on this

We are dealing with British imperialism.

Comment on this
Mr. Coburn

It is pure jealousy.

Comment on this

The British would be pleased to hear us differing amongst ourselves on this matter.

Comment on this

I have answered the Taoiseach, who asked me how and in what way a national Government would work in reaching a solution of Partition. I think that in dealing with the British Government a national Government would be infinitely stronger than a one-Party Government, particularly a one-Party Government which is not in a strong position numerically.

The Taoiseach, in the course of his speech this morning, suggested, I think, that I promised that Partition could be ended within a matter of months. I have never promised that Partition could be ended. I said that, in my view, conditions were such now that Partition could be ended within a reasonable space of time, within a short space of time. That is still my view, if we are in a position to maintain a sufficient degree of unity among ourselves here.

Comment on this

Surely there has been unity of the most complete kind in regard to that question here for years.

Comment on this

I do not think there has been. I do not think that either this Government, or the last Government, for that matter, were in a position of sufficient authority to be able to force a realisation on the British Government that the people of this island were determined to secure the ending of Partition, and were serious about it.

Comment on this

The British Government itself has a very slender majority.

Comment on this

If they had a more slender majority, they might deal out justice to Ireland.

Comment on this

The British Government are not in the position of having portion of their country occupied by another Power. If they were, you would find they would have a National Government.

Comment on this

We have the same views here, in any case.

Comment on this

One of the difficulties in dealing with Partition as far as Britain is concerned is that the British Government has a great many problems of one kind or another. The first essential is to secure the direct attention of the British Government to the problem of Partition, to make the British Government realise that it is an urgent problem that can no longer be put aside. I have talked so much on that aspect of the problem that it may be represented afterwards that I ignore the difficulties which we have here. I am fully conscious of the difficulties we have here. I realise that Partition has two aspects, the aspect to which I have just referred, namely, Britain's interference here, and the other aspect which concerns our own population in Ireland. I think that Partition has become much more real in the course of the last ten or 20 years. We have become detached from our people there, even from the nationalist population; we have drifted apart far more than we should ever have allowed ourselves to drift apart. That is one of the difficulties which I hoped that these motions would remedy.

Before dealing with the motions, I should like to say what the motions do not involve. I have found, in discussing this matter, that all kinds of completely fictitious arguments are used, probably due to lack of appreciation of the factors involved. These motions do not involve any amendment to the Constitution.

This House can, by amending its Standing Orders, admit anyone it likes, to speak or to sit in the Dáil, not to vote in the House. Therefore, these motions involve no amendment of the Constitution, and we have been so advised by the last Attorney-General. I am not asking in these motions that the Six-County M.P.s should be given a right to vote in this House. Therefore, when arguments are used to the effect that it would mean power to vote on legislation for the imposition of taxation which would be unfair to the people here, it is not a real argument. I am not asking that Six-County M.P.s should be given the right to vote. Personally, but this is a purely personal view, I would give them the right to vote in this House; but I know that if I ask for that in these motions I would be handing a weapon to those who see good reasons for not passing these motions.

The House will also have noticed that I did not specify in the first motion whether they should be admitted to the Dáil or to the Seanad. I left that to be considered either by this House or by the Government. I merely asked the Government to initiate proposals to enable them to sit either in the Dáil or in the Seanad, as might be determined.

Now I would like to refer the House to the provisions of Article 2 of the Constitution:—

"The national territory consists of the whole island of Ireland, its islands and the territorial seas."

If this Parliament is the Parliament established under that Constitution, how can we refuse to admit into it the elected representatives of any portion of Ireland? What reason can we give? Let us try and have a perspective on this whole matter. Can the Taoiseach visualise a position in the First Dáil where anybody would have suggested that a T.D. from the Province of Ulster should be excluded from the First Dáil? Why should we, in the year 1951, come along and say: "Oh, we will not allow you into this Chamber; we will not listen to, we will not hear any representatives from the six occupied counties."

Comment on this

Because the Imperialism of England is preventing it.

Comment on this

I do not think it is even that. I think it is sheer prejudice. I think it is due to the factors I mentioned earlier. I do not know whether I made myself clear, but people are inclined to set their minds in a given set of circumstances and find it difficult to change their minds later on when the circumstances have changed. As I said before, I am quite satisfied that all the younger men, and a great many of the old men too, on all sides of this House are in favour of that proposal if they felt free to say so. It is nothing, if you like, but prejudice and stubbornness that prevents this proposal going through.

The next Article of the Constitution provides:—

"Pending the reintegration of the national territory, and without prejudice to the right of the Parliament and Government established by this Constitution to exercise jurisdiction over the whole of that territory, the laws enacted by that Parliament shall have the like area and extent of application as the laws of Saorstát Éireann and the like extra-territorial effect."

It is quite clear from that Article of the Constitution that it is intended that the laws passed by this Parliament shall some time apply to the whole country and, pending the reintegration of the national territory, they shall apply only to a certain portion of the island. If it is contemplated that the laws which we discuss and pass in this House are, at some stage, to apply to the whole country, would it not be only right that the representatives of the Six Counties, who are at present excluded, should, at least, have an opportunity of being heard in this House on these laws, of telling us their views on these laws, of telling us the effect these laws would have if applied to their portion of the island and of telling us the effect they might have on the ending of Partition? Why are we afraid to hear what they have to say? Why are we afraid to consult them? Are we sincere when we say that we want an all-Ireland Parliament? If we are sincere when we say we want an all-Ireland Parliament, why do not we now begin to build an all-Ireland Parliament? We have not heard one good reason against it.

Comment on this

Or one good reason for it, yet.

Comment on this

That is not an argument. That is a flat-footed statement. I have put forward a number of arguments in favour and I hope the Taoiseach will deal with each one of these arguments when replying and not merely try to dismiss the matter casually with the usual see-saw argument that it might be good and might be bad. I think we are entitled to this.

I will make this offer now. I am willing to stake my political reputation, whatever that may be worth, and retire from public life if I am wrong in saying that, if this matter is submitted to a referendum of the people, it will receive the support of the overwhelming majority of the people. If there is any doubt, why not do it? We have machinery for a referendum. Will the Taoiseach agree to submit this matter to a referendum of the people? Presumably, we have included in our Constitution provisions for a referendum so that it could be used, so that the people could be consulted and their views obtained on different issues. Would not this be an ideal issue upon which to obtain the views of the Irish people? Why should we be afraid to ask the views of the Irish people? It is an ideal issue to do it on. We are not raising it as a Party issue. It is not a Party issue in this House. We have been told by Deputy Costello that, as far as the Fine Gael Party are concerned, they will leave it to a free vote of their Party. Why not do the same on the other side of the House? Why not submit this question to the Irish people and let the people decide it by way of referendum? I will undertake to give any assurance the Taoiseach may like that there will not be any attempt to make political capital out of it. He can submit the question himself. We can decide not to have speeches on it if you like.

As far as the nationalist population of the Six Counties is concerned and as far as their leaders are concerned, they complain, and complain constantly, that we have abandoned them. Possibly, that complaint is not justified. Possibly, it is exaggerated but, certainly, we do not act as if Partition was our primary concern. We do not maintain that closeness of contact with the nationalist population of the Six Counties that we should maintain.

I agree, possibly, that the leaders of the nationalist population of the Six Counties have not always provided the leadership they should have provided but I am not certain to what extent we are not to blame ourselves and to what extent we have not left them somewhat rudderless at times. I am sure that a great many of these obstacles could be overcome if the Six-County representatives were sitting in our benches and if they had an opportunity, when the Dáil was sitting, of discussing their problems with us and of our discussing our problems with them.

We know little of their problems. The Ulster T.D.s, possibly, are closer in touch than the rest. I venture to say, with all due respect to our Cork T.D.s, that they know very little of the problems that exist in Belfast and of those of the nationalist population. We would get to know a lot about them if we mixed and mingled with them here. Likewise, I think that the presence of Six-Counties' representatives here would enable us to discuss the future economic development of this nation as a whole.

References were made in this House yesterday by Deputy Costello, junior, to the possibility of a customs union. If a customs union were a feasible possibility, I would agree with a customs union. I do not think it is a possibility because in fact there is a customs union at the moment between that area and Britain.

I do, however, believe in pursuing in economic matters the functional approach, namely, the seeking of individual solutions for joint economic problems and difficulties. There are many problems which we will have to solve whenever we succeed in ending Partition, and I do not think that we have, either as a Parliament or through our Governments, ever faced up to the many problems that will be created by the ending of Partition. I think that it is work which should be undertaken now. We should begin to examine from now on the economic consequence of the ending of Partition; we should begin to plan from now on the economic development not merely of twenty-six counties but of thirty-two counties as one unit; this would make the task much easier when we get to the stage of ending the political division which exists. For that reason I was very anxious that we should, if possible, secure agreement for the setting up of a central all-Ireland Transport Authority. I think that that would have been a useful step forward. It would have benefited the Six Counties and the Twenty-Six Counties, and I would have been prepared to go quite a long distance to achieve such an authority.

Deputy Costello made a valuable contribution this morning, and referred to the proposals which he had made for some form of liaison between a unity council in the Six Counties and the Government. I think that is an excellent proposal; I have supported it and I think it is a constructive suggestion, but I do not think that it is exclusive. I think it is one of the necessary steps. There should be a unity council of all the different groups who are opposed to the continuance of Partition in the Six Counties, and that council should provide the leadership of the anti-Partition movement in the Six Counties. There should be a direct link between that council and the Government, preferably with one Minister charged with that special responsibility, but I do not think that it in any way impinges upon the proposal to admit to this House elected representatives of the people from the Six Counties.

I hope that whatever attitude the Taoiseach and the Government may take regarding these motions they will in any event pursue the suggestions made by Deputy Costello regarding the formation of a unity council and the establishment of some sort of direct contact between the Government and that unity council. I hope that these proposals will be considered by this House objectively. We should be in a position to discuss matters of that kind objectively without reference to past prejudice or to Party affiliations, so let us examine the proposal objectively and take a free decision on it. I hope that those proposals will not be made the occasion by some of our more irresponsible Deputies of making utterances which will do more damage. I think that a considerable amount of damage was done by Deputy Captain Cowan and his announcement that he intended to start a private army to march on the North, and also that a considerable amount of irreparable damage was done by Deputy Dr. Browne.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I think that we must develop here in this House a sense of responsibility regarding such matters and must always resist the temptation to exploit the situation for personal ends without regard to the effect it may have on the national position as the whole.

I would appeal again to the Taoiseach to consider this matter very carefully. If he examines it really objectively himself he will realise that his resistance arises more from the fact that his mind was set against it a few years ago, but conditions have changed since and I would appeal to him to reconsider the position in the light of existing circumstances as I think it would be a help to the nation as a whole.

Comment on this

A number of points were raised this morning on which I would like to say a few words before I go on to speak on the motions on the Order Paper. Deputy Corish asked the Taoiseach this morning for some indication of the policy the present Government intend to pursue in matters of an economic social nature. We had a lengthy rambling statement from the Taoiseach in which he gave us very little information on the lines sought by Deputy Corish, but in the course of that rambling statement the Taoiseach referred to what he would like to see done in the congested areas and what he would like to see done regarding the methods to revive the Irish language. One statement that he made has stayed in my mind and will stay there for many a day. He was dealing with the problem of keeping the Irish language alive and at the same time giving a living to those people in the areas where Irish is the spoken language at the moment. The Taoiseach expressed the fear that, by providing industrial employment in those congested areas, we were in danger of doing damage to the Irish language.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is perfectly true.

Comment on this

Unless we were careful not to introduce English with it — that is what he said.

Comment on this

I think that the Taoiseach himself is the individual who should contradict me, not the Minister for External Affairs.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is not present in the House. I was present when he spoke.

Comment on this

I questioned the Taoiseach when he was in the middle of his statement because I could hardly believe my ears that a man in his position would go so far as to say that in those areas where congestion exists the Irish language must come before the living of the people and that he would preserve the language and let the people starve in those areas rather than harm the language.

Comment on this

We tried to start industries in the West, but you supported for three years a Government which closed them down.

Comment on this

The only industry you ever started in the West was the tomatoes.

Comment on this

And all the other industries which were started.

Comment on this

What industries were closed down? Will you give me one industry that was closed down by the last Government?

Comment on this

Lead toys.

Comment on this

No industry was closed down.

Comment on this

What about the homespun industry?

Comment on this

It was not closed down. It worked better last year than in your time.

Comment on this

It was not closed down. We got markets as a result of trade agreements.

Comment on this

You got single tickets for the people to England and America. That is what you did for them.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy McQuillan, on the Estimate.

Comment on this

When I proceeded to question the Taoiseach with regard to his policy of development in the Gaeltacht areas, he went on to say that we must be very careful how we move in these areas. In other words, he realised that he had put his foot in it by his previous statement. He said that we must be very careful, in regard to whatever development works that were undertaken in the West, that the language did not suffer. He also expressed the view that wherever industrial development took place and wherever industrial employment was given, it tended to change the outlook of the people and that, naturally, as a result of that, the Irish language would suffer. To my mind, that is not sound policy : it is one with which most Deputies do not agree—and that includes many members of his own Party.

The Minister for External Affairs intervened to state that the present Opposition, which was formerly the inter-Party Government, had closed down industries in the West of Ireland. I am not going to throw any bouquets at the inter-Party Government for their work in regard to industrial development in the West but I will give them the credit that they attended to one of the things that was essential in order to improve the position of the people living on small uneconomic holdings in the West—drainage—and, undoubtedly, splendid work has been done in the past three years in the West of Ireland under the Local Authorities (Works) Act.

Having listened to Deputy MacEntee last night and to the Taoiseach to-day, I am inclined to believe that Fianna Fáil or the present Government—I do not know how they should be described, perhaps as a "platypus"— do not intend to pursue an energetic programme with regard to drainage. I believe that when the change of Government took place the people responsible for arterial drainage, and so forth, in the particular Department sat back with a sigh of relief and said to themselves: "We will not have to work so hard in the future." I had proof here to-day that the present Government is not really interested in drainage. I do not want to go into details, but I had a question down about the proposals to drain a river in the West of Ireland. That particular river had been very low on the priority list during the Fianna Fáil régime before 1948.

Comment on this
Patrick Beegan Parliamentary Secretary to Minister for Finance (Mr. Beegan) Fianna Fáil

It is as low and as high now as ever it was.

Comment on this

I know that the height of the river has gone up.

Comment on this

We would have drained it by now.

Comment on this

You would in your hat.

Comment on this

That particular river, the River Suck, was raised on the priority list and would undoubtedly have been tackled in the very near future had the priority list been left as it was.

Comment on this

It was raised only on the election platform.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy say if that is one of the broad issues to be raised on the Estimate?

Comment on this

I spoke about this matter only to point out that I had proved to myself that in my own locality Fianna Fáil were not prepared to go ahead in an energetic manner with the drainage programme which was started by their predecessors. In the future, they will hear more from every platform on which I shall stand in the West of Ireland about their outlook on drainage.

Comment on this

The previous Government blew the whistle on our schemes.

Comment on this

The Minister for External Affairs is very annoyed to-day. If he wants any information about drainage or arterial drainage, all he has to do is to look up the records of this House. He will find that though the Arterial Drainage Act was passed in 1945 not one penny was spent on the purchase of machinery or on the employment of engineers between 1945 and 1948, when the inter-Party Government took office. That was the attempt that Fianna Fáil made in regard to arterial drainage.

Comment on this

That statement is not true.

Comment on this

Everything is untrue, according to the Minister, except what he himself says. I am not satisfied that the inter-Party Government made good progress in connection with industrial development in the West. I should like to take this opportunity of expressing the hope that the promise made by the Tánaiste that all possible steps will be taken by this Government to increase industrial employment in the West and develop that area will be lived up to and carried out. I am afraid that when we compare the statement made by the Tánaiste with the statement made by the Minister for Finance it is very difficult for an ordinary Deputy to convince himself that both statements agree.

To my mind, the statement of the Minister for Finance expressed the view that retrenchment was necessary and that it was his intention to curtail capital development works in the country. If the Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, is going to get a free rein in that regard, I cannot see how the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, can hope to carry out his policy with regard to industrial development in the West. In the three years during which the inter-Party Government was in office I understand that approximately 150 to 200 people obtained employment in industry in the West of Ireland. That is a very low figure. From a question which I asked in this House I gather that only nine new factories were opened in the West out of a total of somewhere near 150 that were opened in the country as a whole. That is a very small proportion for the West of Ireland, when you consider that over 17 per cent. of the population of the country lives in Connacht alone.

The present Taoiseach has nominated a young Deputy whose responsibility it will be to co-ordinate the work of various Departments so that everything possible can be done for the Irish-speaking congested areas, especially in the West of Ireland. When the Taoiseach was appointing a Parliamentary Secretary for this work, the least he might have done would have been to choose somebody from the West of Ireland who would be familiar with the problems of the congested areas, and familiar with life in general in the West.

I am not casting any aspersions on the Deputy who was appointed. As an individual I have a profound respect for him but, in justice to the Deputy himself, I think it was unfair to put him into that position in view of the fact that he comes from an area far removed from the western seaboard. I am sure there are plenty of Deputies in Fianna Fáil who have a thorough knowledge of the western counties and the western seaboard and of the problems that have to be tackled there. However, it is a matter for the Taoiseach and I wish Deputy Lynch the best of luck in his appointment and I hope that the problems outstanding in the West for the past 30 years will receive very careful consideration from him. I hope, too, that he will be successful in remedying even some of the grievances that exist.

In connection with the two motions on the Order Paper I know of no sound reason why these two motions should not be accepted. I am speaking now as a young Deputy who was not born in 1916. In this House before one is allowed to speak it seems to be essential that one should have taken part either in the 1916 Rising or in the troubled years between 1919 and 1922. Repeatedly insults are hurled across the floor of the House and valuable time is wasted on this business of "Where were you in 1916?" or "What side were you on in 1922?" This is the first time I have ever mentioned this matter here and I am glad to have had this opportunity of doing so because this is a very important Estimate.

To the older men here I offer nothing but the greatest respect. They did a good job when it was needed. They have the thanks of the present generation, but I would like them to remember that "Time marches on" and they alone cannot accomplish the unification of our country. A new generation has grown up and that new generation feels it should have some say and some responsibility in this matter. Up to the present that generation has not been listened to; up to the present very few young men have entered political life. Up to the present the older generation have maintained that grasp on politics which to my mind is responsible for much of the bitterness throughout the years.

I understand the Taoiseach is not in favour of either of these motions. He has not given us any reasons for his disapproval. He has asked instead for sound reasons as to why the duly elected representatives of the six northern-eastern counties should be allowed in here. Is it not a sound reason to invite them in here for the purpose of helping us to end Partition? What sounder reason could one want? We all hope the Border will be removed. I know, of course, that if people make up their minds along certain lines all the soundest reasons in the world will not change them; in other words, if they do not want to do something they can always find fairly good reasons to convince themselves that they are right.

The view has been expressed by certain people on this side that Partition could be ended within a short space of time. That is only a view and I do not accept that view. When one looks back over the past 30 years and see how little has been accomtion, one can only conclude that we are no nearer its solution to-day than we were in 1925. Talking about Partition will not solve Partition. It is the duty of every Deputy to do whatever he can to help towards removing the Border.

I think the idea contained in the first of these motions is a sound one. It would at any rate help to break down some of the prejudices that have grown up. I do not care whether the people who come are Orangemen, Nationalists or Republicans. I think they should all be welcomed here and in the Seanad. That is the only way in which we can get to know their minds. I think we have an excellent opportunity now of proving to the world that we are sincere in wanting to bring about an end of Partition, in offering the hand of friendship and equality to those people in the northeastern portion of Ireland.

I think that if we do not pass the first motion we would leave ourselves open to a great deal of criticism outside this country, and that we shall be giving a strong lever to Britain, which she can use against us in the world councils because anybody could get up at any of these councils in which we have functions and ask our delegates: "How on earth do the people in the Twenty-Six Counties maintain that they want to end Partition when Dáil Éireann refused to admit elected representatives from the North to their Parliament?" I think that weapon should never be put into the hands of the British Government. At any rate, I shall do my utmost as one individual to secure the right of admittance for any elected representative from the North to this House or the Seanad.

I say, with all sense of responsibility, that I shall do the utmost within my power, irrespective of the consequences, to see that elected representatives from the North are allowed into the Oireachtas, even for the right of audience alone, although I personally think that that is a very small right to grant them, and that they should be given fuller powers than are indicated in this motion. At any rate, for a start I think that for the reasons that have been already covered by the mover of the motion, it is desirable that they should be given the right of audience. I would urge on the Taoiseach not to divide the House on such an important motion as this. There are young men in all Parties. I have talked this matter over with them and they agree that we should hold out the hand of friendship to the representatives from the Six Northern Counties. I think it is very unfair to prevent these Deputies from expressing their true belief, when it comes to a division. I would ask, even at this late stage, that the Taoiseach should take off the Party Whips and leave this matter to a free vote of the House.

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs (Mr. Childers), General MacEoin and Mr. Dunne rose.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs.

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I draw your attention to the fact that I have been in the House for something like five hours during this debate, and that the Labour Party is the only Party which has not been represented so far in the debate. I think, Sir, that you might take notice of that fact.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair does its best to call on representatives of all Parties in turn. A Minister, of course, gets precedence when offering himself, especially having regard to the fact that three Deputies from the Opposition Benches have spoken in succession—Deputy S. Collins, Deputy MacBride and Deputy McQuillan.

Comment on this

If Deputy Dunne has to leave the House, I have no objection to his being called on now.

Comment on this

I feel aggrieved and I think that there should be some fairness in the distribution of the call to speak.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow that to pass unchallenged. There were three speakers, as I have said, from the Opposition side in succession—Deputy Collins, Deputy MacBride and Deputy McQuillan. Surely the Chair must give an opportunity to some speakers from the Government side to take part in the debate, especially when the Deputy offering himself is a Minister.

Comment on this

I must bow to your ruling, but I think I am justified in drawing your attention to what is happening.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy may not dispute my ruling. As I have pointed out, three Deputies from the Opposition side have spoken; that is three to one. When a Minister offers himself, the Chair has no option at all. I shall call on Deputy Dunne if the Minister gives way.

Comment on this

I do not mind.

Comment on this

The handful of Deputies who were present this morning in the House when the Taoiseach introduced his Estimate must have been impressed by a certain element of tragedy in the Taoiseach's statement. The formal introduction of the Estimate was made by the Taoiseach in a very perfunctory way. The introduction consisted of a couple of hundred words which gave no indication whatsoever as to what the policy of the Government might be in relation to the future of this country. It was only when Deputy Corish and some other Deputies insisted on asking the Taoiseach to let us in on his plans that the Taoiseach made an effort to meet the question.

Everybody here present will have been struck by the sad effort that was made and by the absolute bankruptcy of ideas displayed in the Taoiseach's speech which lasted an hour and ten minutes, but which added up to practically nothing. The Taoiseach said that the policy of this Government was the same policy that Fianna Fáil had always followed and could be put under a number of headings. He went on to talk in vague and general terms of what was desirable for this country under economic, cultural, social and political headings, in a somewhat different order. What he said could have been said by a school child of 12 years of age. The first time that I ever remember those principles being laid down was, I think, when reading them as the principles which were dear to the United Irishmen in '98. They have been repeated by every Irish organisation and Party since that time. They were repeated here this morning by the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

It is not a bad headline.

Comment on this

It is not a bad headline, if you want to talk in general terms of what is good for the country, but if you want to talk about what the Government proposes to do this year for this country, surely it is not sufficient that we should be treated to vague general expressions of what is desirable and what is not desirable. Surely we should be given some concrete plans which are likely to affect the everyday lives of the people of the nation. We did not get any such ideas whatsoever. We got no intimation from the Taoiseach, good, bad or indifferent, as to what this Government intended to do, what its policy was in various matters, other than a policy of carrying on what the previous Government had done.

There were many attacks in this House on every conceivable occasion on the previous Government, so that some sections of the people came to think that the inter-Party Government was made up of a collection of saboteurs whose only anxiety was to wreck the economy of this country. Now we are presented with the position that those who set out to create that impression among the people can do no better than just follow along and endeavour to measure up to the standard set by the previous Government. We were not even told that this morning. The present Government is so bankrupt of ideas that they propose to try to do that as best they can in their own way.

For the short time the present Government has been in office, what evidence have we seen of what is in store for the people of this country? One of the first things we saw was the sop that was thrown out to Deputy Cogan for his vote, the increase in the price of farmers' milk. Before the election the official Government organ was talking about bargaining behind the scenes, about efforts to induce this or that Independent Deputy to vote one way or the other. It was obvious to everybody, when all that talk was over, that the bargaining which was done was not done on this side of the House. The bargaining which was done on that score alone was done entirely as between the Fianna Fáil Party or agents of the Fianna Fáil Party and at least one of the Independent Deputies, Deputy Cogan, to whom I have referred.

What is the result of this increase in the price of creamery milk? There are many farmers' representatives in this country and many farmers in the creamery areas who felt that, even before the increase of a penny per gallon was given earlier this year by the previous Government, the farmers were not doing too badly at all. Although we had Deputy Corry and other representatives coming in here and making the poor mouth on every possible occasion they could, there were honourable and honest people who thought the farmers were not doing too badly even before they got the first penny per gallon. However, in order to meet the well-organised demand that sprang up from the country, the previous Government decided to give the farmers another penny per gallon in the price of creamery milk, and that, as we know, resulted in an increase of 2d. per lb. in the price of butter.

I know very well there is in this House quite a representative group of people whose only concern is to see that every possible penny that can be taken from the urban population and from the working-class people in the rural areas should be taken from them and put into the pockets of those who have property, the farmers, particularly in the South of Ireland. There are people who think that is the best thing that can be done for the nation, people who see no value whatsoever in having some kind of balanced economy where everybody will get a fair deal. There are people who advocate that policy unceasingly and probably believe it. Now we have the position that one of the first acts of the present Government was a further infliction upon the working people of the country in the nature of a further increase in the price of butter in order to make it possible to give the farmers a further penny in the gallon for milk.

What was the first reaction we had from Deputies like Deputy Corry, who urged the present Minister for Agriculture to do that act, which was a kindly act to the farmers but certainly was not a friendly act so far as the consuming public are concerned? What was the first reaction of Deputy Corry and others: "It is not enough," he said. "We want more."

Comment on this

And we will have to get it.

Comment on this

We may anticipate that there are many things in store for the people of this country in so far as the present Government's agricultural policy is concerned. The increased price of milk is one indication of the trends that may be coming in agriculture. Agricultural prices must be driven up, not by a policy of increasing production, or making the land more productive so that the farmers will gain more by reason of getting a greater volume of production from their land. That is not the policy; the policy being pursued now is to give the highest possible price for the least possible production. The net result of that will be that, despite the fact that the people living in cities and towns are making it possible, in the long run, for the agricultural section of the community to live—because it is an inter-dependent economy we have in this country, one which is not made up entirely of farmers or agriculturists no more than it is made up entirely of factory workers or city workers— we will have scales of wages more decidedly in favour of certain interests of the agricultural community, against those who may live in the cities and towns, against the consuming public; that means in the last analysis against the workers of this country.

Another indication of that fact seems to be the appointment to the position of Minister for Finance of no less a person than Deputy Seán MacEntee. I have referred on previous occasions to Deputy MacEntee's reputation in so far as his attitude to the ordinary people of this country is concerned and in relation to matters such as the cost of living and wages. Everybody in Ireland knows, and it does not need me to say it, that Deputy MacEntee was a strong advocate, during Fianna Fáil's previous administration, of keeping a tight fist on wages. His record as Minister for Local Government is ample proof, if proof were needed, that the workers of this country may expect very little sympathy from him in so far as wages are concerned, and, of course, wages are of supreme importance to the vast majority of the people of this country.

I was not present last night when he made his speech but, from what I can learn of it, there was evidence that he had not departed in any degree from his oft-displayed convictions in that regard. The workers of Ireland know, then, what to expect from Deputy MacEntee, and he fits into the picture of the general governmental set-up. On the one hand, there is the progression under agriculture which I have described, and on the other hand we have, as Minister for Finance, and the Minister for Finance should be the dominant figure in any Government, a Deputy who, to say the most charitable thing of him, does not hold the confidence of the people of this country and, in particular, of the workers of this country. I am being very charitable in my remarks about him, far more charitable, I am sure, than he would be in his remarks were he referring to me.

What does the future hold for the people of this country? The Taoiseach did not tell us. I am wondering how the Fianna Fáil policy of laissez faire, which was enunciated here to-day, in so far as it may be described as any policy at all, is going to be aligned with the oft-expressed, progressive socialism of Deputy Peadar Cowan. Deputy Cowan forsook the inter-Party set-up in the belief that he would find a more progressive policy with Fianna Fáil, or so he stated. He took occasion here more than once to take us to task in so far as our Labour principles are concerned.

No effort has been made to explain how Fianna Fáil are going to meet the Socialist principles which Deputy Cowan enunciated here as being his.

In what manner are they going to pay him for his support? Will it be as substantial as the manner in which they have repaid Deputy Cogan, who at least secured for a small section of people an increase in the price of milk? What is going to be done for Deputy Cowan? Can we take it that part of the bargain will be a cessation of the hostilities we used to witness here when the present Minister for Finance, then Deputy MacEntee, used to describe Deputy Cowan as a sawdust Cæsar and a red cardinal from the Kremlin and in endearing terms of that character? Perhaps we will hear no more of that. It may be part of the bargain that that sort of attack should cease. Will we have anything more substantial? Are we going to hear more about Deputy Cowan's social principles, which he stated made him vote for Fianna Fáil, and are they to be put into effect? That is a question I would be interested in.

There are other alignments which give us reason to ask the question: what do they mean? What are we going to get in the way of a motherand-child scheme as to which no indication was given? Will it be a scheme that will meet the wishes of Deputy Dr. Browne, or a scheme that could easily meet the wishes of the former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello? We should like to know these things; these are things which the public would like to know, because all these things fit into the weft and woof of the intrigue which brought about the existence of this Government.

Comment on this
Mr. Coburn

Deputy Corry manufactured it.

Comment on this

The Deputy was one of the chief weavers in that little conspiracy. Prior to the establishment of this Government the cost of living was the subject of very much comment in this House. We have not heard a great deal of it since the Government was established, but the people outside this House have felt its effects considerably. We had an increase in the price of butter within a matter of days. We had an increase in the price of electricity. These and other matters are of tremendous importance to the ordinary people. Shortly after the establishment of this Government, the Tánaiste stated in this House that he had no hope of stopping the cost of living from rising, that the best he could do was to try to restrain it. We set out at least to endeavour to prevent it from rising and very successfully held the cost of living for a long time. If Deputy Corry and others had their way, the cost of living would have been driven sky-high. It will be next to impossible now to prevent it. I dare say the Tánaiste was being realistic in what he said. Realising the nature of some of the gentlemen behind him and the demands made upon him and his Government, in order to keep them quiet he must do something to meet these demands. He must do something to keep Deputy Cogan and even Deputy Corry and others walking in the right direction through the Division Lobby. That means that the cost of living must go up; he admitted that much. The people know what to expect and it has been a matter for very considerable comment throughout the country.

These are matters which were not referred to by the Taoiseach to any extent. He talked about emigration. He said he was in England recently and had an opportunity of talking with Irish exiles and he was astounded and appalled at some of the conditions of Irish workers there which were described to him. I personally do not like to be uncharitable to the Taoiseach, nor would I like to be uncharitable to anybody, particularly those whom Deputy McQuillan referred to as being more or less the elder statesmen in this House. But surely the Taoiseach heard of the Irish workers' conditions in England before this year? For 16 years he was Taoiseach and this will be his 17th year. He has been living more than twice as long as I have. Irish workers suffered intolerable conditions in England and in Scotland in the bothies and other places. The conditions of the long-distance men, the navvies and others were described 20 or 30 years ago as being intolerable. There has not been very much change; in fact, the only change was for the worst.

When our people went to Britain in thousands during the war, as well as having to endure verminous lodgings and low wages, they had to endure German bombs and the terrors of war. Yet the Taoiseach this morning said, "I was in England recently and was appalled to hear of these conditions." That makes me wonder that such a statement should be made by any responsible person in this country. As I say, these conditions have existed for many years. The only steps to alter them were taken by the men themselves and their trade union organisations. I do not recall any Irish Government having made any attempt, beyond a cursory inspection at intervals of years, to see that these conditions were brought to any kind of a decent level. I do recall during the last 15 years several tragedies such as the Kirkin-tulloch tragedy and the hooker sinking with Irish migratory workers after leaving the port of Galway. These conditions were known then when Fianna Fáil had more strength as a Government than they have now, but nothing was done about them and it is late in the day now to talk about the conditions of Irish workers in England.

The Taoiseach indicated that he was not satisfied in regard to certain figures so far as emigration is concerned. These figures, which were quoted by Deputy MacBride, showed very clearly that there has been a reduction in the number of people emigrating during the last few years. The Taoiseach disputed the accuracy of those figures. He is well known to be a pretty good manipulator of figures. Mathematicians, I suppose will never agree as to what figures are accurate and what figures are not. To a nonmathematical mind such as my own it seems that there has been a reduction in emigration, particularly in the period during which the inter-Party Government was in office.

No matter what may be said, one thing is evident to everybody, that from 1948 to the end of 1950 there was a greater degree of employment in this country and, consequently, a lesser degree of emigration than ever before. Although many people will say that most emigrants are people who want to travel, I think the root cause of emigration is the inability of the individual to get a satisfactory job in his own country, one on which he can live. Some attempt was made in the last three years to meet that problem. Workers have been given employment near their homes, or as near as possible, at wages which have been progressively raised. That represented a big change from the previous 16 years, and brought about a reduction in emigration.

I do not want to speak at very great length on this Estimate because, having listened to some very long speeches, I can understand the feeling of those who are waiting to speak. I do want to say, however, that if any proof were needed of the absolute ineptitude of the Fianna Fáil Government in the present circumstances, it has been provided by the speech of the Taoiseach. I hope I am not being too unkind to him when I say that it would have been of tremendous political good to every Party in the entire Opposition if the Irish people had been able to listen to the Taoiseach this morning in the House, because definitely it was a speech that was empty of anything, of any coherent proposals that would benefit the people. It was simply a reiteration of what every Irish leader, from Wolfe Tone to the present day, no matter what his politics, whether he was reactionary or progressive, whether he was on the Left or the Right or in the middle, whether he was constitutional or a physical force man, has said. Every one of them could have subscribed to what the Taoiseach said here this morning, and it would still not mean a snap of the fingers.

I want to refer to the motions which appear on the Order Paper with regard to those who are elected representatives of the people of the six occupied counties and the according to them of right of audience in Oireachtas Éireann. I believe that that is a step which should be supported. I do not think that any more effective step could be taken to bring to the attention of the entire world the injustice of Partition. I understand that the Taoiseach proposes to oppose this and to lead his troops into the Lobby against this motion.

It is interesting in this context for us to recall what happened on a previous occasion when something similar occurred in the history of this country. In September, 1922, when this Assembly was first convened, it was then described by its opponents as the Southern Parliament. The entire question as to whether or not it was to be regarded as a Partitionist Assembly hung upon the question of whether a certain Seán O'Mahony, who represented the division of Fermanagh, as it then was, and a Mr. Ginnell would be invited to sit in the House. Some Deputies here will remember that.

We have a somewhat analogous situation at the present time. These two gentlemen did not take their seats, as far as I can discover, but the Leader of the Government, the present Taoiseach, made it plain at that time that he would regard their reception here as a determining factor in deciding whether this Assembly was Partitionist or not, particularly in the case of Mr. O'Mahony.

We now have the situation that a man has been elected to a constituency across the Border. The constituents in that area were told that, if elected, he would seek the right of audience in this Assembly, the sovereign Parliament of the nation. He was elected. I may say, incidentally, that the Labour Party had a candidate in the same election, on a different programme, but Mr. McGlennan was elected on that strict understanding that he would seek a right of audience here.

I am astounded that the Leader of the Government, the man who, 30 years ago, made it a test as to whether this Parliament was Partitionist or not —a similar test to what is being made now—would vote against the motions which are in the names of Deputies MacBride and Tully.

I feel that every justice attends upon the case which the Northern people who are claiming to sit in this Parliament have. Like others, I do not think that this right can be claimed only for nationalists. I think that every elected representative across the Border, in our lost province, should have the right to come to Dáil Éireann and to speak his mind and should get a céad míle fáilte here, even Sir Basil Brooke himself. It would be a great thing if that could be brought to pass. Some day, please God, it will be brought to pass. There is nothing surer than that. Perhaps not in the lifetime of some people here, perhaps not in my lifetime, but there is nothing surer than that one day there will be an Assembly in this country wherein representatives of all the sections of the people will meet. Let us hasten that day as much as we can. Whatever little thing we can do now to bring that day nearer should be done.

There are many of us who do not agree, possibly, with the social or economic policies that may be enunciated from time to time by our brother nationalists in the North. Some of us would take issue with at least some of the North very easily.

Comment on this

And some of the nationalists in the South.

Comment on this

We are already doing that. Practically everybody in this House is a nationalist or, if you like, a republican, and believes in the integrity of the 32 Counties and in the sovereignty of the Republic of the 32 Counties.

There are differences in regard to social and economic policies in so far as the internal administration of the country is concerned. I do not deny that there are differences between individuals here and individuals who make up part of the nationalist minority in the North of Ireland, but upon the general question of the integrity of the nation and of the right of the nation to unity and to one Parliament there is no difference, there cannot be any difference.

I believe that we would be doing a constructive thing in extending to the elected representatives of the people of the six occupied counties the right to speak here on subjects in which they are interested and which affect the entire country. We have been talking about Partition for a long time. Some people would be inclined to the view that the time for talk is long past. The fact that within very recent years men lost their patience in waiting resulted in their finding themselves in jails throughout the Twenty-Six Counties as well as the Six Counties and in British jails. Some of them whom I recall very well as my own friends eventually met the death of a soldier or the hangman's rope. All these men were good Irishmen. Some of them loved this country, like many before them, not wisely but too well.

If we are to carry on the tradition that has been handed to us by brave men who had varying policies and varying beliefs as to the internal administration of this country, but who all held fast and firm a strong belief in the divine right of the people of this country to unity and independence, if we are to honour those men who have gone before, not alone those who went in 1916, 1920 and 1922, on both sides, but those who went within the last ten or 12 years, if we are to honour them all— God rest the souls of all of them—I believe we should support these two motions.

Comment on this
Erskine Hamilton Childers Minister for Posts and Telegraphs (Mr. Childers) Fianna Fáil

In the course of his observations earlier to-day, Deputy Costello was challenging the Minister for Finance to make clear what the policy of the Government was going to be in regard to such matters as investment and the dissipation of external assets. I think we should be very clear on this side of the House as to our future plans, and as to what we really mean in that regard. The Minister for Finance, in the course of his speech on his Estimate, indicated that there were seven points on which there should be some agreement among us all. He referred, in particular, to what he described as "the unwieldy programme of capital expenditure, the trading position which we had with the rest of the world, and the dissipation of our external assets." He also referred to the very considerable items for which no provision had been made in the Budget.

The thing that I wish particularly to emphasise this evening is the fact that the seven point policy stressed by the present Minister for Finance was, in fact, virtually composed and prepared by Deputy McGilligan, the former Minister for Finance, the only difference being that he was compelled, for political reasons, to refrain from stating in detail how he proposed to put that policy into operation. He was compelled to leave the electorate, at the time of the general election, ignorant of the not perhaps very serious dangers, but the dangers that confronted the country from the financial point of view. I think it just as well to remind the House that Deputy McGilligan realised himself, at that time, that there would have to be a certain re-examination of the Government's financial policy, and that that re-examination was overdue. Therefore, when the present Minister for Finance suggested the necessity for a re-examination, he was really only following out in greater detail, with greater realism, greater truth and with more facts at his command the rather vague warnings given by the previous Minister for Finance.

I do not suppose there is any need for me to quote at great length from the Budget statement of Deputy McGilligan, the then Minister for Finance. He made it perfectly clear in a number of paragraphs in that statement that the position could not continue as it was. The Budget speech is to be found in Volume 125 of the Dáil Debates. Under the heading: "Investment and Stockpiling," at column 1882, the then Minister for Finance had this to say:

"It has been estimated by the Central Statistics Office that the increase in external disinvestment of £20,000,000 in 1950 as compared with 1949 has been accompanied by a net addition of £6,500,000 to physical capital at home."

He added that he was glad to say that not all the balance of £13,500,000 was dissipated in consumption. He indicated quite clearly there that the principle upon which money should be spent—money that was invested abroad —on capital services here, was not being followed, that the whole principle, in fact, had been abandoned, and that we were selling our external investments not only for necessary stockpiling, stockpiling of a desirable character, but also for what are, relatively, luxuries.

We, in Fianna Fáil, have always realised that it is very easy to talk blandly and glibly about the investment of money at home—money that is now invested abroad. If you change the policy in regard to that, you have to make sure of what you believe the results will be. One would think from listening to Deputy MacBride that we, on this side of the House, know nothing whatever about the investment of capital at home in this country, or of encouraging private individuals to start industries by using their capital or using their savings. I do not see why one should have to indulge in elementary economics in this House, but, from hearing discussions on this matter, it would appear necessary for me once more to state the Fianna Fáil view in regard to a return of external assets. The Fianna Fáil view is this, that if I, or anybody else, have £100 invested in British War Loan and I receive an income of £3 a year from it for which I buy a pair of shoes, that it would be very much better if I sold out the £100 of war loan and helped somebody to invest it in boot-making machinery here and, on the interest which I received from the boot factory, to buy my pair of shoes or anything else that I needed.

That is the right definition of economic policy in reference to a return of external assets, but that is not what the last Government has been doing. Money has been brought back home for non-essential purposes and it was that which Deputy McGilligan was warning the House against at the time of the Budget. Speaking, again, at column 1883, he said:—

"The rise in import prices should, in due course, expend itself. It would, however, be optimistic to expect an early reduction in the trade deficit. The outlook for 1951 is, I fear, that the deficit may be even greater than in 1950."

He went on to say:—

"The present position on external accounts is by no means satisfactory, and if it continues to develop unfavourably the application of corrective measures will be called for."

Even since that date, there has been a continuation of the adverse position, and it was not only the present Minister for Finance, but the last Minister for Finance who, driven at last to the truth in some fundamentals, was calling for corrective measures and was warning the public that they would come. He went on to say:—

"While the materials are still available it is right that the State and private individuals should proceed with productive capital development to the utmost extent possible. It is, however, also desirable that the public should transfer to the State for the purposes of its capital development programme a greater share of the purchasing power now being expended on the less essential consumer goods."

In other words, Deputy McGilligan was going further, almost, in detail than the present Minister for Finance in warning the public that he was printing money against no known production, that the printing of money could not continue, and that you could not either raid the Post Office Fund or make use of the Counterpart Fund without, in effect, printing notes for which there was not in advance any evidence of increased production to justify it. He was warning the public that there was a limitation to that kind of thing; that you could, for a time, perfectly easily make use of the Post Office savings to balance the Budget, that you could make use of the Counterpart Fund, and that you could ask the banks to invest their own deposits instead of inviting the public to invest them in a national loan—that you could do all these things, but that the time would come when the whole question would have to be revised.

Neither the then Minister for Finance, nor his Party, had the courage, before the election, to take any definite steps in that direction. They did not even promise a modification of their programme, and they took no definite steps to provide for all the items in the Budget. They left it to the present Government to deal with these problems. That was not opposed in any way by any of the members of the Coalition Parties. They evidently reserved their criticism, knowing that an election was inevitable. The then Minister for Finance, speaking at column 1884, said:

"Making all allowance for the exceptional conditions now obtaining it is to be feared that we are not producing and earning enough to pay our way. The implication is obvious. We cannot have both consumption and capital development on the present scale unless we save more and produce more.

Additional saving would ease the congestion that now exists and causes consumer demand to seek an outlet in imports. It would relieve the pressure on the balance of payments and help to confine external disinvestment—or surplus imports—to what is needed for home development..."

—by which, I suppose, he referred to capital development, the import of machinery——

"... or for stockpiling."

That was a very definite warning by the Minister for Finance. He made it perfectly clear to the House at that time that, although he was unable or unwilling to make any definite proposals, there would have to be changes and that he was only hanging on, so to speak, with his bare teeth to the edge of the rock in the hope that he would not fall, in the hope that something would turn up before there would have to be, not necessarily a very drastic modification, but some modification of the general financial policy of the Government.

One of the difficulties in talking about financial matters is that, in order to emphasise a point, it is very easy to exaggerate, and it is my duty to-night to make it perfectly clear that the Government could not possibly contemplate any violent change in policy, but will simply have to study the situation from month to month during the current financial year. Any violent change made would almost certainly bring about unemployment and any violent change made might have just as adverse an effect on the economy of the country as some of the foolish policy of the previous Government in regard to financial matters. We have to warn the public that the cost of living is going to rise considerably in the future, due partly to this policy which we inherited of increasing the note issue inevitably through borrowing moneys for which there have not been corresponding savings. Practically every country in Europe in the past ten years——

Comment on this

Would the Minister say how the policy of the previous Government is ging to cause prices to rise next year?

Comment on this

Would the Minister be allowed to speak without interruption?

Comment on this

I am dealing with that matter. Practically every country in Europe has had to go through the third phase in its economic life in which they have had to face the difficulties that arise from a series of situations parallel with those which took place here.

Comment on this

Was the previous Government responsible for that situation?

Comment on this

Most Deputies know the order of events: that there was a great scarcity of goods during the war; that plans were made for new capital development after the war; that money is generally released and put into circulation through various political or economic influences before the goods or the machinery are available; that there is generally a sharp rise in the cost of living almost immediately after the war; that that can be checked in various ways; and that then a country desiring to go full speed ahead with new development starts investing and expending large sums in capital development and, sooner or later, finds that it has gone a little too far in certain respects and that certain retrenchments of a minor or major character, according to the conditions obtaining, have to be made. The Swedish Government have been through the process; the Danish Government have been through the process; and so have the New Zealanders. Practically every Government has, so to speak, to take a jerk on itself sooner or later in what might be described as the third or fourth period of post-war economy.

One of the things that has arisen in the case of this country is that we faced one situation which we had hoped we would not have to face, a reopening of an emergency state, increases in prices resulting from what might be termed a semi-war inflation economy. That was the circumstance that arose in July of last year. The previous Government saw it inevitably coming, and, so far as we can ascertain, they took no very noticeable steps to overcome the difficulties that would arise. As I have said, the great thing to do on these occasions is to foresee the difficulty as far as one can and to have the political honesty and courage to put before the people the machinery necessary to restore the balance, to restore what might be called the economic balance, and prevent an increase in the cost of living, through the unwise issue of notes because the people are not saving as much as is being borrowed in any one year.

I might add that Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Finance, for a considerable part of his administration, went far beyond what would be considered wise, in both his borrowing programme and his inflationary programme, by the most Socialist left-wing administrations in Europe. Socialists, because they have always desired to spend the largest possible proportion of the national income in taxation for their own reasons, have learned perhaps more quickly than others—certainly more quickly than Deputy McGilligan —just how far one can go, and, as I have said, Deputy McGilligan and his Government in general, at the end of their three years' régime, were going beyond what were considered to be the most advanced principles enunciated by such people as Lord Keynes and others in regard to the capital investment of the State, borrowing money, expenditure on the Budget and so forth. I want to make it perfectly clear that we, in Fianna Fáil, have no intention of doing anything rapid or violent, and no intention of preventing the natural course of capital development schemes which we hope to continue and in many cases to stimulate far beyond what they are at present.

Comment on this

I take it you have no intention of repealing the Central Bank Act of 1942?

Comment on this

I am not talking about the Central Bank Act. I am talking about general economic policy.

Comment on this

And the bank has nothing to do with that.

Comment on this

The cost of Government administration rose by a very large amount in three years. The State debt was doubled and one of the difficulties we have to face is that, in every speech the former Minister for Finance made, he kept on warning the people that, although the increase in industrial production was very satisfactory, unless the volume of agricultural production increased—not the value of it but the volume—and unless the tourist industry expanded, or at least remained where it was, he could not recommend to this country that the borrowing programme should be continued. He kept on giving these vague, rather quiet warnings to the people of this country and to the members of this House, but he was unable to be emphatic enough in what he said because he would have burst up the Coalition Government. He kept on warning them the whole time.

We know from statements made by the Minister for Finance that the volume of agricultural production only just reached pre-war level in 1949 and went down by 4 per cent. in 1950. We know from figures published recently that there has been a very slight decline in cattle exports and the beginning of what appears to be a partial collapse of egg and poultry production and unsatisfactory conditions in regard to milk, butter and pigs, indicating that the 1950 position, which was 4 per cent. worse than in 1939, is likely to become still more serious, unless corrective measures are applied. That is the difficulty which this House faces. We, all of us, want to expand development schemes in every direction. We cannot expect the volume of agricultural production to expand immediately, but, as I have said, there must be some expansion in due time, some visible expansion, if the policy of borrowing more and more—doubling the State debt, for example, in three years— continues.

Comment on this

Does the Minister doubt that, if the State debt was increased, there were definite assets against it?

Comment on this

I will deal with that later. Certain assets were created undoubtedly by the increase in the State debt both in the previous Government's time and our time. One of the promises made by the Minister for Agriculture in the last Government was that he would increase the volume of agricultural exports by 100 per cent. in five years. It was a colossal boast to make, a colossal prediction, knowing the fact that one of the difficulties affecting the whole of this country since 1912 has been that the actual level of agricultural production has changed very little. It is one of the deepest and most long-term problems affecting this country. The change has been extraordinarily small. It scarcely altered even after five years of economic war. There were changes in certain respects from one period of five years to another period of five years, and then it seemed to fall back to its original level, in spite of many efforts made by Governments of all kinds in the past to stimulate it. He made that very lurid boast and his boast was not justified. There was nothing like a 100 per cent. increase in the volume of agricultural exports during the past three years, and, in respect of most of the important items, that value would not have been reached, even if the Government had remained in office for five years.

To give just one example of the kind of promise that was made, in reference to this prediction of Deputy Dillon's about increasing the volume of agricultural exports by 100 per cent. in five years, the number of cattle exported in 1939 was 482,000 and, by 1950, it had reached the dizzy figure of 494,000— very far off a 100 per cent. increase. I might add, examining again eggs, butter, bacon and pigs, that one can see very easily that that prediction was not made good, but it was upon that prediction that much of the policy of the then Minister for Finance was based.

He hoped that all these things would happen. He hoped that in some mysterious way a miracle would be performed overnight. Another example was Deputy Dillon's lurid boast that he would restore the pig population in 12 months, given the opportunity. The pig population was something just under 1,000,000 at the end of the economic war, and by the end of the three-year régime of Deputy Dillon it had reached just over 600,000. It began to reduce rapidly in the last half of 1950, and showed a very serious reduction in the first quarter of this year.

The last Government has tried to take credit and has tried to justify its borrowing programme by giving the impression to the public that one of its successes was the very great increase in cattle prices that took place, as if there was something new in that, as if no one ever increased cattle prices before. They seek to justify their programme—shall we say, the uncontrolled borrowing, the unorganised, co-ordinate capital development—by the increases in cattle prices that took place. As I have already pointed out, there was not very much increase in the volume of cattle exports, there was some increase in the value; but it is interesting to note that in spite of the rumours sedulously spread through the country that Deputy Dillon was responsible for cattle prices, according to his own figures the prices of most of the principal classes of cattle went up more in the last three years of our office than they went up in the three years of their office. It is a thing so cleverly put in their programme that some people, even on our own side, are almost dizzied by the statement. In fact, according to Deputy Dillon's official statements on cattle prices, issued by him during his term of office, the price of cattle one to two years old and two to three years old and fully fattened cattle, in every single case went up higher in the last three years of our office than in the first three of the Government's office.

Comment on this

Can you give the figures?

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants me to give the figures, I will. I have given them once already. He seems to be annoyed at being told the facts. People do not realise the actual facts, as given by Deputy Dillon. That is a very important point. One of the few justifications for the existence of Deputy Dillon would be if he could claim some very extraordinary increase in the price of cattle, that he was able to effect and which had not been effected by the previous Government, in the three years from the ending of hostilities, from 1945, when shipping became available and circumstances become more normal. If any Deputy would like me to give the figures I will. They are Deputy Dillon's and show the truth of what I have just said. I would mention just one figure. For fat cattle two to three years old, the price in February, 1945, three years before the end of our period of office, was £25; the price went up until in the month we left office it was £36; and in February, 1951, three years later, it was £43. If any Deputy works out the percentage, he will find that it went up proportionately more in our time than in Deputy Dillon's.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

Another statement of Deputy Dillon's was that he would work miracles during his period of office regarding restoring various classes of the cattle population. We were told by him, as given in column 2589 of Volume III of the Dáil Debates, that the number of cattle of under one year old had reached the lowest level in history in the year 1947. That, of course, was the year after two seasons of appallingly bad weather. He said he was going to do something to restore it. The number of cattle under one year old in 1939 was 978,000; and by 1950 it was 983,000—a remarkable increase of some 5,000 from the period at the end of five years' economic war, when farmers were working under very many difficulties. The total number of cattle in this country in 1950 increased by 296,000. The figure is there for all to see, until you suddenly realise that virtually all of them were two to three-year-old cattle and their coming into existence in this world in 1950 could hardly be said to be the responsibility or the work of Deputy Dillon.

Deputy Dillon was speaking about the number of heifers in calf during a great deal of his period of office and saying they would prove the correctness of his policy and of all he was doing. He ceased to talk about it in the last 12 months or so and there were very few references about it at agricultural committee meetings. We discovered that in January, 1947, there were 142,000 heifers in calf and although they increased for a time, in 1950 the number was 140,000. It is just as well to mention these things.

Again, dealing with our difficulty in facing this enormous budgetary position, one of the things we would like to have seen, if the then Minister for Agriculture had been able to perform the miracles which he promised, would have been a great increase in crop yields. Deputy Dillon stated in 1948 that the fertility of the soil had reached its lowest level since the famine. We all can remember the flowery phrase, in 1948, after he took office, and he made it perfectly clear that Fianna Fáil was responsible for that. I suppose Fianna Fáil was responsible for the Great War when no artificial fertilisers were available.

Comment on this

The economic war.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon was opposed to us during the economic war, too, when farmers faced great difficulties. During the economic war, in fact, the crop yields did not suffer any deterioration. There were also the bad winters of 1946 and 1947, as Deputies well know. Deputy Dillon did get an extraordinary answer from Providence in 1948 and 1949, when there were too good cereal harvests and when, in spite of the soil exhausted by Fianna Fáil, in spite of all Fianna Fáil had done to the soil, the yield of crops bounded until it reached almost pre-war proportions, and Mr. Dillon attempted to take credit for the Act of Providence in bringing about that situation. I myself was surprised at the time. I knew there was great fertility in Irish soil. I knew that farmers were conservative and husbanded their soil, but I did not realise that there could be such a rebound in crop yields after only two years' full supply of artificial fertilisers. It was a proof that we did not do so badly after all.

Agricultural production in Europe increased in volume by 10 per cent. during the period when it fell by 4 per cent. in this country, showing that the main problem is that of increasing the actual volume of production per acre. Until there can be some substantial increase there will always come a time when a wise Government carefully and methodically, without necessarily taking any drastic or unpleasant action, changes their borrowing policy, their capital development policy, their budgetary policy and their policy in regard to the utilisation of external assets and the future balance of trade.

We have other unpleasant facts to face. We know that, as already stressed by Deputy McGilligan, personal savings have been insufficient to allow for the borrowing programme to continue. He said it over and over again in his quiet way. He was very quiet about it. He kept on hinting that it worried him. Presumably, he has a knowledge of what real State finance is. He kept pointing out the necessity for increased savings and announced a scheme at the time of the Budget for advertising the value of increased savings which, I think, is now going ahead. As we all know, in an inflationary situation and when there is no actual war and when people are not asked to save for some vital immediate purpose such as war, it is very difficult for a mere appeal for savings to succeed. I hope it will succeed. I hope that the people of this country will adopt the attitude that turf production, electrical production, rural electrification, land reclamation, housing and hospitalisation are far more vital but less spectacular matters than the more dreadful business of defending oneself in war. From the point of view of civilisation it is more fundamental and far more positive in character that they should follow the advice given to them by Deputy McGilligan in quiet tones but given very seriously. They must save more, for not even the previous Government's programme could continue nor our programme of expansion that we anticipate. The warning has been reiterated by the present Minister for Finance, who sees the position even more clearly and who has the courage to make far more definite statements; to speak with greater insistence and to speak with the whole of the Fianna Fáil Party behind him. All of us hope that the people will consider the savings facilities in this country just as they would if we were fighting a mortal war against an enemy, otherwise it will be impossible to continue with the present programme.

Another difficulty we face is that, although the cost of administration went up by £25,000,000 during the course of the last Government's office, for some reason or another some of their most important capital projects appear to have misfired. Less was spent than they contemplated. A very large Civil Service organisation was expanded. Whatever directions were given, the money for very urgent schemes which were claimed to encourage agricultural production and justify their cost seemed to misfire. Only half of all the money to be provided for the Department of Agriculture in 1950 was finally spent in that year in connection with the land project—one of the projects which should result, in practice, in increasing the volume of agriculture, the number of blades of grass per acre and the number of cattle to be fattened. Only one-sixth of the money provided in 1950-51 was spent and of that half went in expenditure for administrative costs.

Only one-fourth of the sum allowed for certain expenditure in health development was spent that year. Only twothirds of the amount provided for turf development was spent and, of course, there were some delays in developing turf to the maximum degree.

Not even all the housing expenditure was fully absorbed. The amount was £14,000,000, but it turned out at the end of the year to be £11,000,000. I am not saying that a great many houses were not built. I am merely showing that some of these more important projects were misfiring in 1950, three years after the Government came into office when the level of capital expenditure could surely have been predicted properly. I might also add that the rural electrification scheme, a scheme which should have had a definnite effect in spiriting agricultural production, was behindhand compared with the maximum desired.

We learned also, during the period of the late Government's office, that a very large number of people left the land. The figure given by the Minister for Agriculture for a recent period was 28,000. A great many more had left before that. The signifiance of that is rather hard to analyse because the Government boasted that workers' wages had gone up markedly, and that they were doing everything they possibly could from the point of view of social services. The fact remains that the flight from the land to the towns continued at a vastly accelerated rate during the office of the late Government.

There were delays in production schemes, all of which have had their effect, and which leave us with the problem of trying to carry on the capital development, in order that production may increase and at the same time provide finance from the savings of the people. At the same time we notice this external disinvestment, not for capital machinery goods, but for goods of far less importance to the community.

Certain Deputies on the Labour side of the House were warning the public that we might be in for a hair-shirt existence. It is well to remind the House of the circumstances under which that phrase was used. We could not run this country normally during the war. The phrase was invented by certain members of the Labour Party to describe, generally speaking, the difficulties we faced at that period, as though everything should have been absolutely normal all through the war, with sometimes only 25 per cent. of normal raw materials coming in, and with very difficult circumstances to face. We, on this side of the House, know that there was never such a thing as a hair-shirt policy on the part of Fianna Fáil. We increased social services continuously during our first period of office. The wages of all classes of workers rose steadily and continuously during that period. I want to repeat again some figures that I discovered, I think, perhaps a little late for the election, and which could have been used in every direction to counteract the "standstill Lemass" campaign that went on—the suggestion that if Mr. Lemass was made Minister there would be a standstill of wages or anything else.

It is just as well to remind workers and members of the House through the official record of the House of the fact that even during the war when there were certain restrictions on wages, salaries and the earnings of companies, wages did in fact increase, and that they increased more from the end of the Standstill Order up to the end of 1948 than they increased in the period after that. I received the final figure the other day taking the wages of men and women in transportable industries. The figures given for these two periods are difficult to relate to an individual wage because they include both men and women in their different proportions. It is well to remind the House that we have no such hair-shirt policy. Wages increased from 43/- in 1939 for women and men to 66/- in 1946, an increase of 40 per cent. The theory behind the increase was that it was possible for the housewife to buy essential commodities at the rationed prices then available in rationed quantities. Most other goods were extremely scarce and dear. If the wage levels were allowed to mount by the percentage reflecting the increased costs the only result would be that more people would seek those goods and the prices would be higher still. The Standstill Order was removed in 1946 and between then and 1948 the figure rose from 66/- to 80/7 and the figure had risen since to 87/7 in three years. That is sufficient to show that this Government was not a government believing in restricting wages. As long as conditions remain relatively normal we believe in free negotiation of wages between workers and employers.

The same thing is true of agricultural workers. Wages went up very considerably during the period we were in office from 1939 to 1947 and they have increased since. The suggestion is being given that there was no increase in the wages of agricultural workers but of course that is ridiculous on the face of it.

Deputy Dunne referred to various matters of interest in connection with this debate. He suggested that we had bribed a certain Deputy of this House by increasing the price of butter through increasing the price of milk. Of course it is convenient for the Deputy to mention that and not to mention the fact that there were three other members who supported the Government who would be hopeful that the price of butter would not increase. One cancels the other but Deputy Dunne gave the impression that it was meant to offer a special bribe to one particular Deputy.

Deputy Dunne referred to increases that had taken place in the cost of living. We do not ourselves know I think entirely how much the cost of living has increased. It depends on whether or not Deputy Lemass, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, has had time to examine all the draft Orders for increases in price that lay on his desk when he arrived. I do not know whether he has gone through the list. Announcements have been made of increases but there may still be a considerable number which he has to examine, which were placed before the previous Minister for Industry and Commerce before the election and upon which no final decision was made although in many cases increases had actually been recommended by the Prices Advisory Body.

I wish to say, too, that we intend to have a realistic attitude towards prices. We have courage with regard to this. When we left office in 1948 an enormous number of promises had been made by the then Opposition that they would overhaul the price control machinery and that drastic reductions would be made. The implication was that the officers of that Department working under the Minister for Industry and Commerce of that day were either not working efficiently or were being directed to work slowly or were disregarding profits in many companies. The Government of 1948 found after a short time that those statements were not justified. There were no remarkable decreases in the cost of living. There were no prosecutions of any kind worth noting against any important firms or groups of firms for overcharging. We at least know that we are going back in the first instance to a fundamental price control system which the former Government was unable to break or to prove ineffective.

Whatever steps we may take by specific measures in view of the present inflationary situation to control the state of the cost of living, we at least have an administration that was proved to have been so effective that no substantial decreases could be effected and no notable prosecutions undertaken by the last Government when it took office in 1948. No doubt any machine can be improved but at least we know that that machine was not half so bad as it was supposed to be. We all of course remember hearing the tremendous accusations which were made against us by Clann na Poblachta and the Labour Party during the course of the 1948 election.

I should like to emphasise once again that we in Fianna Fáil believe in capital development services. We always have believed in them and we always carried out capital development schemes. We left the last Government enough capital development schemes either operating 100 per cent. or operating at half-speed and ready to go into full operation as soon as materials became available or planned and ready for immediate development to last them for the next 50 years.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

We always believed in capital development services.

Comment on this

Where did you leave them?

Comment on this

We left many in full operation.

Comment on this

Give us the figures.

Comment on this

Many have gone on for years. More was actually being given to farmers for farm improvement services during the last three years of the previous Government's office than was given to them by Deputy Dillon under the land project. That is one example. If we had had American Marshall Aid no doubt we would have expanded the land improvement scheme; we would have left certain features as they were and expanded others. Those were services which we carried out on behalf of the people and offered to the people and which were designed to increase agricultural production. All the plans for turf electric power stations were in operation when we left office. I think that the previous Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Morrissey, was very honest in his speech at the opening and said that he must pay a tribute to Deputy Lemass for that scheme. All of the immense long-term plans for Bord na Móna were devised by our Government before 1948 and the Government which has immediately left office had no responsibility for them. There were projects costing millions to drain bogs which take five years to drain before machines can be put on them to cut turf. That policy of far-seeing vision was entirely Fianna Fáil in concept.

Comment on this

What about the Works Act?

Comment on this

The vast majority of new industries and of extensions to industries started since the last Government came into office was due ultimately to the stimulus given by Deputy Lemass during the previous 16 years. A great many of these new factories were factories moving out of Dublin City and being constructed anew and expanded or were the extension of industries partially developed under the Fianna Fáil Government. A number of brand-new industries have been started for which the last Government may take full credit, but the great panoply of industrial production increases since the war has been due to our encouragement of private capital development with enormous success during the previous 16 years. New ships were bought by Irish Shipping, Limited, as a result of stimulation by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. One of the plans we have in mind, if we can get the ships, is to expand Irish Shipping, Limited. There are immense difficulties in that regard. The price of all shipping materials has gone up owing to inflationary conditions. So far as we know, no ships were ordered during the last three years.

Comment on this

Surely that is not correct.

Comment on this

It is about as true as the other statements.

Comment on this

I am open to correction but, so far as I know, no ships have been ordered by Irish Shipping, Limited, in the past three years.

Comment on this

Two are on order at present and one is under construction.

Comment on this

In view of what Deputy Cosgrave says, I withdraw my statement, but I should like to have more details in connection with the matter. With regard to electric power, nobody can deny that the preparation of the plans for the Erne scheme began before the last Government came into office. There, again, there will have to be a great stimulation. Whatever our capital difficulties may be, we shall have to continue the encouragement of more power schemes of every type.

Comment on this

Is the Minister sure that Fianna Fáil did not start the Shannon scheme?

Comment on this

We shall have to examine the position in regard to mineral exploitation. A great deal more will have to be done in the way of stimulating industrial exports. I think that the establishment of some sort of export organisation on a larger scale will have to be planned by the present Government. Certainly we shall have to go ahead with tourist development on a much larger scale. In the past three years we have lost certain chances which we had in regard to tourist development. A great deal requires to be done in the way of improving amenities in every class of hotel not only for Americans but for the ordinary people.

I should like to correct a criticism that was made of the Taoiseach when he referred to the question of the preservation of the Irish language in the immediate Gaeltacht so far as the establishment of new industries is concerned. It is quite obvious that you can establish a number of small factories giving employment in various classes of industry in the Gaeltacht without interfering with the language. I imagine that what the Taoiseach had in mind was that if an enormously large-scale factory, involving foreign technical assistants and foreign keymen, were planted in the middle of an area in which the local people speak the Irish language, it might be a less desirable development than the establishment of industries of a smaller pattern manned by our own people who speak the language. There was no suggestion that economic development would be slowed down in order to maintain the Irish language. It was simply a matter of balance and it is ridiculous to make any suggestion to the contrary. It is just that it might be better if we could avoid placing an enormous industry of that type in the heart of the Gaeltacht and substitute instead the other types of industries which I have mentioned. To suggest that the Taoiseach is going to starve the people of the Gaeltacht rather than to give them an industry is ludicrous.

Many allegations have been made in regard to the 17-point plan announced by the Government after the election. Wide publicity is being given to the suggestion that there was something new about the plan, that it contained only new material and that it was a kind of afterthought of Fianna Fáil. I think that perhaps one of the mistakes we made during the election was that we did not go through sufficiently often what seemed to us to be a wearisome repetition of the permament part of the Fianna Fáil 1948 plan. I do not propose to read it all this evening. It would take about an hour to read the plans we had in mind, the plans we had in being, the plans we had in operation and the plans that were about to go into operation. It all occupies pages and pages of print in pamphlets which were distributed during the 1948 election. These plans were bequeathed to the last Government and were of great assistance to them in carrying on for as long as they did. They included every sort of item in regard to every aspect of national life—the poultry and egg production plan, the expansion of land reclamation, farm buildings grants, the expansion of the production of lime and fertilisers through grants and subsidies—a plan which was delayed being put into operation by the last Government for a considerable time and the main part of which was put into operation only within the last eight months of their being in office: a special subsidy, using American aid, for limestone. We had plans for improved veterinary services, for educational facilities and research, for developing good seed strains, for grassland improvement, for guaranteed prices for cash crops. All these were mentioned in 1948 and there was no need for us to stress them particularly during the election because we imagined most of the people of the country would know about them.

The Fianna Fáil Party have constructive ideas in regard to the national economy. I have already mentioned the plans in relation to turf and power production, land and air transport, the expansion of the Factories Acts, a new export trade organisation, and so forth. Of course, there were plans for more schools and more hospitals. There was also mention during the time of the election of a complete social security scheme and of the development of a mother and child service scheme. Naturally, we also had plans for developing arterial drainage. So far as I know, the plans for surveying quite a proportion of the rivers that are now either being drained or about to be drained were commenced in our time. The then Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, was honest enough in admitting, when he blew the whistle to start the Brosna scheme, that the scheme was due in great measure to the work of the previous Government in planning arterial drainage schemes. He made that admission at the time the Brosna drainage scheme commenced. The same applies to certain other arterial drainage schemes now either in operation or still being planned.

It is just as well to stress the only essential differences between the 17-point plan and the 1948 Fianna Fáil programme. It is as well to record them here. We have not been in office very long and, with the Recess about to begin, it is just as well to record these differences in the House. With one exception, only minor changes have been made between the 17-point plan and the 1948 published programme. That programme included a measure of compulsory tillage, which has been abandoned.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

There is a definite change of policy. Every Government has the right to change its policy in certain regards. Agricultural conditions have changed since 1948. It is believed by those of us on this side of the House that there should be a consistent tillage policy given to the farmers from year to year, with the support of the Minister for Agriculture, which will succeed in producing an adequate quantity of foodstuffs for man and beast in this country.

Comment on this

Did not Deputy Cogan change that?

Comment on this

We have mentioned——

Comment on this

It was Deputy Cogan who changed it.

Comment on this

It was changed long before polling day. The announcement was made that compulsory tillage was abandoned.

Comment on this

It was made during the election.

Comment on this

It was not announced after the election. It was during the election.

Comment on this

Up to that time Deputy Walsh was pro-compulsory tillage.

Comment on this

Deputy Cogan says he made you change it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

The remarkable thing about Fianna Fáil is that we have changed our policy so very little. We have been so well able to see in advance what the country needs that when we do happen to change one item of our policy we are accused of all sorts of crimes. Every sane Government changes its policy in the light of existing events.

Comment on this

35/- for barley.

Comment on this

Moreover, we have done what the Government that took office in 1948 did not do. We have not immediately smashed up every scheme in relation to which we had some very definite prejudice. We have left the great majority of the schemes in operation in order that we can review them at some future date, which is more than the last Government did when it came into office.

Comment on this

The Constellations.

Comment on this

The last Government would dearly have liked to have had those Constellations in the third year of their office. Every single plan that has been enunciated by the recent Government will be tried and tested, because it is always possible that any Government may do many excellent new things for the people and these things should be judged by their results.

We mentioned certain points in the 17-points programme in regard to borrowing and raising national credit. We wanted to make it quite clear to the people that we believed in capital development, had indeed indulged in capital development and increased capital resources by millions of pounds during our 16 years in office and we would have continued to do that, working on certain priciples, neither going too far nor adopting a petty attitude in which we would try—shall we say— to contract any policy for reasons which might appear selfish or unwise.

We also said we would conduct negotiations with agricultural organisations when desired, because the impression was given by the former Minister for Agriculture that he was unwilling to meet certain agricultural groups. That was not really a change in policy. We said we would maintain subsidies as far as we could. We mentioned that because we had to do something to persuade the people that we would not reduce subsidies in a major way while the cost of living was rising.

We also said we would make such defence preparations as we considered advisable. I think the only major change in the policy enunciated in the 17-point programme as compared with that enunciated in 1948 was the abandonment of compulsory tillage. Otherwise, the whole of the statement was merely a retiteration of what we had been doing for 16 years, with one difference; during our 16 years we had five years of economic war and world depression followed by a world war.

Comment on this

The economic war was your own choice.

Comment on this

If we had had the same advantages as were available to the last Government we would have been able to do a great deal more. Two elections have been fought in the last three years. They have been fought with the Parties opposite trying to give the impression to the people that the absence of constructional work and the slowing down of nation-building during the war period were due entirely to the weak character of the Fianna Fáil Administration, to our lack of ambition, our lack of vision and our lack of enthusiasm. The vast majority of the people saw through that argument in 1948. They saw the beginning of the foundations of turf and power stations being laid. They knew plans were going ahead. They knew it was only the war that had prevented plans going ahead for capital development. They trusted us, believing we would go with the plans when the time came.

Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Finance, was unable for two years to put into operation the correctives which he said were essential. Whatever corrective principles we are compelled to adopt, the House can be quite certain that so long as conditions abroad remain relatively stable and raw materials can be secured and prices do not go absolutely crazy we will continue the capital programme we always had; we will expand and speed up the work that was being done too slowly by the previous Government and we will continue with the work of nation-building so long as the Irish people give us their confidence.

Comment on this

I do not know for what purpose the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has been sent into this House.

Comment on this

We nearly lost him.

Comment on this

But the impression created by his speech this evening is that his purpose is apparently to put a new and more cheerful face on the gloomy dirge we heard last evening from the Minister for Finance and to tell the boys sitting behind the Front Bench that things are really not as gloomy as the Minister for Finance indicated last night. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has made a brave effort to show that things are bright and cheerful and we are not as near the cemetery of economic debt as the Minister for Finance gasped out last night.

I have just come into possession this evening of a document described as The Irish Statistical Survey, published by the Stationery Office, which is in the Library but which for some reason or other has not been circulated to Deputies as, indeed, it might have been for the purpose of a debate of this kind. I have not had time to go through it in detail, but I have looked at it sufficiently to enable me to put certain figures before the House and I want to put these in juxtaposition with the figures quoted by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs.

Let us look at these figures and see what the past three years show where statistics for the three years are available, or for two years where only two years' figures are available, taking note at the same time that if the figures for 1951 were available they would show the continued improvement which is manifested in 1949 and 1950. What do we find? In 1947 the national income in respect of income arising from agriculture, forestry and fishing was £95,000,000. In 1950 it had risen to £104,000,000, clearly showing that there was an increase in the national income during that period when we were in office and clearly showing that there was no stagnation from the point of view of industrial and agricultural output taken collectively.

Comment on this

The prices.

Comment on this

Prices and output are two different things.

Comment on this

Did you ever see a national income calculated on prices? You can produce one of those on your own if you like.

Comment on this

It is county council finance he is on.

Comment on this

Let us pass on to Table II, which shows the personal net national expenditure at current prices. We find, in 1947, personal expenditure in goods and services at market prices was £289,000,000 and in 1950 that had jumped to £342,000,000. Does anybody want to take exception to the fact that our people have more to spend, that they are now getting more food, more clothes and enjoying some of the things which were long denied to them and that generally they are enjoying a better standard of living?

Comment on this

It does not follow. It is the prices they are paying.

Comment on this

Deputy Colley's economic contribution to this debate should not be suppressed. The Deputy says it does not follow.

Comment on this

It is the prices.

Comment on this

The figures for prices for 1948 are there also to show the same improvement.

Comment on this

Let me put a question. Deputy Colley will have a ready answer to this. If personal expenditure was £289,000,000 in 1948 does he think that if it had fallen to £240,000,000 by 1950 it would show a better standard of living for the people or necessarily indicate a better standard of living?

Comment on this

Not at all. You are twisting what I said.

Comment on this

I knew you would realise it was that.

Comment on this

Show him the 1938 figures.

Comment on this

The figures are here for 1938.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

I am sorry I should have excited all the statisticians on this side of the House. Does not everybody know that the standard of living of the people to-day is better than it was at any time during the past 30 years. Can anybody deny that?

Comment on this
A Deputy

Not at all.

Comment on this

A lot of people would like to go back to 1939.

Comment on this

Would the Minister think that it would be nationally better and more advantageous to be back in 1939?

Comment on this

The cost of living is so high that there are a lot of housewives who would tell you that they were able to buy far more in 1939.

Comment on this

Many illusionists made money out of people who seemed to see things. Is there any farmer in the Minister's constituency who wants to go back to 1939?

Comment on this

They all want to go back.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan only knows North Circular Road farmers.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheorais Labour Party

He thought a short time ago that James Dillon was the best Minister for Agriculture in the world.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan has suddenly changed his mind. In any case, I have shown that not only did national income increase substantially from 1947 to 1950 but that personal expenditure by our people increased too, showing clearly that they had more to spend in improving their standard of living. It is a fact that when Fianna Fáil was in office in 1947——

Comment on this

The privileged few —two men disemployed for every one employed.

Comment on this

These words are not in the English dictionary, as pronounced by the Deputy at all events. Let us look at personal savings. In 1947 personal savings were £12.3 million and in 1949 personal savings had increased to £17,000,000 showing clearly that there was money available for savings as well as for increased expenditure.

Comment on this

Did you read Deputy McGilligan's speech?

Comment on this

I am reading what is published by the Director of Statistics, matter that is available to the Minister if he wishes to read it too.

Comment on this

He has read it I am sure.

Comment on this