We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Office of the Taoiseach (Resumed).

Contributions 218–460 of 709. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Let us come to imports, During the war years it was impossible for our people to import goods with the result that our imports were down as low as £26,000,000 in 1943. We all remember 1943 and the scarcities during that period. We all remember that it was impossible to get many things which our people wanted to buy. When the war ended in 1945, and when goods began to become available again, our imports increased and by 1947 our imports were value for £131,000,000. Can anybody question that as a normal development in the circumstances? People were unable to get consumer goods or capital goods. It was the most natural thing in the world that after a war which lasted from 1939 to 1946 or 1947, from the point of view of availability of goods, there should inevitably be an increase in purchases of goods of a capital and consumer character in order to satisfy the requirements of our people and to fill the pipeline. The result was that the value of our imports reached £131,000,000 in 1947, £136,000,000 in 1948, £130,000,000 in 1949 and £159,000,000 in 1950, with the Korean war on the horizon and the possibility of embroilment in another global war. These are all natural features in a situation of a deteriorating international situation and a buildup of imports, in consequence of a decline in these imports of necessary capital and consumer goods during the years of the last war.

Let us turn now to the table dealing with the production of industrial transportable goods. Taking 1938 as the base, the index being 100, we find that the production of industrial transportable goods reached 120 in 1947 but by December, 1950, the index had jumped to 171, showing clearly that between 1947 and 1950 the production of transportable goods had risen very substantially and was 70 per cent. more than in 1938. The spurt which was manifest in the production of transportable goods was in the main related to the three years in which the last Government was in office. Is there any evidence of stagnation there? So far as industrial production is concerned, the period from 1948 to 1950 and even into 1951, has been the brightest and best period from the standpoint of increased industrial production in this country.

Let us look at the employment figures. In 1938 the number of people engaged in industry was 166,000; in 1947, 183,000; and in 1950, 250,000—the highest figure that has ever been recorded since we commenced to take statistics on this subject. Again let us look at the National Health Insurance Act. The number of people insured under the Act is to-day an all-time record and has never been previously beaten since the Act was introduced. If you look at the figures for unemployment insurance, you get the same picture. If you turn from that to the question of unemployment and the unemployment problem generally, you find that the percentage of people unemployed in 1938, the year before the war, was 15 per cent., in 1947, 9.3 per cent. and in 1950, 7.5 per cent.—the lowest figure ever previously recorded.

Comment on this

Of course, they were employed in Britain.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You sent them there.

Comment on this

You drenched Britain with our Irish manhood during the war.

Comment on this

Not one quarter of what you sent.

Comment on this

Look at the figures in your own Department and the number of permits you issued.

Comment on this

Read the figures for 1949.

Comment on this

Look at the figures in your own office.

Comment on this

41,000 sent out last year.

Comment on this

Most people in this country know that last year was Holy Year and the Minister for External Affairs would have us believe that everybody who went to Rome went to look for employment.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy say that Birmingham is Rome?

Comment on this

You do not understand figures.

Comment on this

The Deputy has tried to slip it across——

Comment on this

You do not understand your own figures and you cannot understand them.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making a fool of himself.

Comment on this

You do not understand figures.

Comment on this

40,000 went out last year.

Comment on this

To Rome, the bulk of them went.

Comment on this

They went to Birmingham and to Bristol.

Comment on this

We did not open recruiting offices for them as you did. You opened the labour exchanges as recruiting offices.

Comment on this

Not during the whole of the war did so many people go out as went out last year.

Comment on this

A quarter of a million went out during the war.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order! Deputy Norton should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

On a point of order. There is a motion to-day inviting certain people from the North of Ireland to help us in our discussions.

Comment on this

Are you waiting for them?

Comment on this

I wonder is this the way to help them to come.

Comment on this

You will soon be making room for one of them, anyhow.

Comment on this

As displayed here on page 26, the percentage of unemployed for 1950 was lower than for 1949 and, in fact, the lowest figure ever recorded, another tribute to the way in which work was done during the last three years.

Comment on this

Employed in England and elsewhere.

Comment on this

Now, let us look at wages. Industrial earnings in 1947, taking 1939 with the base 100, were 166. By December, 1950, that figure had risen to a figure of 202, and it had done so in spite of the Fianna Fáil threat in October, 1947, to reimpose wage freezing and to make strikes illegal if the workers asked for more wages than they were getting in October, 1947.

Comment on this

You will not deny that.

Comment on this

At the same time it was even threatened that the trade unions would be deprived of their right to take their members out on strike or to use their own moneys to finance a strike to secure an increase in wages. That was the action of a Government which the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said was concerned with promoting good wage standards.

Comment on this

Nonsense, the Minister for Industry and Commerce——

Comment on this

I know it was nonsense, because we put you out.

Comment on this

And we put you out again.

Comment on this

You ought to conduct yourself because you are still a minority Government, and you never know how consistently those boys will run. One of these days you may be double-crossed, and then you will recognise that you are a minority Government here on sufferance! So do not get too cheeky.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton forgets that they put him in twice.

Comment on this

Let me say this to the Minister for External Affairs: I warn you, and the members sitting behind you, to be suspicious of the zealous support which you are getting from Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

If he fails, we will always get you.

Comment on this

You put those boys over there out yourself in 1932.

Comment on this

You can have the honour now.

Comment on this

In 1947 agricultural wages were represented by an index figure of 186, the figure in July, 1939, being 100. That figure had risen to 222 by December, 1950, so that during our period in office agricultural workers were able to get better wages than they ever had in their lives before.

Comment on this

You have silenced Deputy Corry for the first time.

Comment on this

Let us look at the cost of living and the industrial earnings between 1939 and 1940. I say this to the House: this top figure represents the soaring cost of living. This figure here shows wages. You see the gap between one and the other. The lower line represents industrial earnings. This represents the cost of living. While the two figures started at the one point in 1939, by 1944 there was a gap of 50 points between them, the cost of living being 50 points higher than the wage line. That gap represents the sufferings which the workers endured under the Fianna Fáil wage-freeze policy all during the emergency.

What is the position now? Look at the figures. In 1948 they had just begun to meet and now the earnings have gone up above the cost of living index figure, but that balloon would have remained there if Fianna Fáil had remained over there. That position has been changed now. Anybody who wants the facts can get them in this Official Report, and they will see that anybody who depended on wages had no reason to regret the advent to office of the last Government.

Those are the facts, so far as I have time to recount them, published in this official survey. Not only does the survey provide a full justification of the progress made by the last Government, but when the survey for 1951 is available, provided our plans are not interfered with by this Government, the result will be still more heartening so far as most of our people are concerned. If that annoys the Minister for External Affairs I cannot help it. I have, however, to offer him the solace of joining with everybody else on this side of the House in feeling the satisfaction that the nation at last is going ahead, and I am willing to share with him any part of the pride which may justifiably belong to him in that achievement.

I did not intend, Sir, to talk on those lines at all were it not for the thesis which was read for us this evening by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. I intended only to intervene on one matter which I think is of considerable importance to the nation, especially in the cultural and educational field. During the past 48 hours the cultural activities and the cultural life of the nation has sustained a blow heavier than that which it has sustained for many and many a year. I refer to the unfortunate happening which has deprived Ireland of the Abbey Theatre and of the crushing loss which the fire at the Abbey Theatre will mean to art, to drama, and to the cultural activities of the Irish nation. So far as this country is concerned, the Abbey has been the cradle of literature, of art, of drama and of the cultural activities which correctly interpreted the feelings and the patriotism of the Irish people.

The Abbey was to us the cultural cradle of the revolutionary renaissance in Ireland. That modest building kept alive through our darkest periods the flame of freedom, the flame of nationality and the flame of independence when that flame was almost extinguished on the military field. The men and women who graced the Abbey stage made the Abbey famous, not only at home but abroad, and won for our people in the field of art and culture generally an international recognition altogether disproportionate to the smallness of our nation in a territorial sense. These men and women shed lustre on themselves and they brought honour to the nation. It is probably true to say that never before did such a small institution do so much to exalt the name of Ireland throughout the world in a cultural sense.

The Abbey is now no more. It now lies in ashes and its financial position is so parlous that it will be probably impossible and indeed unwise to attempt to rebuild it, cramped as it necessarily is in its present location. But the Abbey in ruins leaves a vacancy in the cultural life of the nation which cannot be filled unless by the recreation of the Abbey in another and bigger sense.

The last Government had under consideration the question of establishing here a national theatre which would truly interpret the cultural activities of our people. It was contemplated that that national theatre could be utilised as a monument to all those who died for Ireland. At the same time, there was under consideration the question of erecting a traditional monument to those who fell in the national struggle in one of our principal streets so that visitors and our own people might, from time to time, be reminded of the struggles of the past and of the sacrifices made to achieve the freedom which has now been won for our people.

There was never, in fact, any issue as between whether the monument should take the form of a national theatre or one of the traditional monuments of stone or bronze. But it was felt that something should be done quickly, and I think the committee appointed to deal with the matter was told at the outset to get on with the task of endeavouring to devise a suitable monument in a suitable place which would, in a traditional way commemorate the struggle of our people for freedom and liberty. That did not mean that the idea of a national theatre was being disregarded or that it was not intended subsequently or concurrently to proceed with the idea of a national theatre.

However, at the time this matter was considered at least we had the Abbey and the tradition and feeling which the living, vibrant Abbey always radiated amongst our people. But to-day the Abbey is no more, and we now stand in great danger of losing the fount which was the inspiration behind the really great cultural talents manifested by our people for the past 50 years. I fear that unless the Abbey is rehoused and rehoused quickly, selfless though the men and women who graced its stage are, the inclination will be for them to disperse into other activities.

That is not unnatural. We can understand the factors which would operate to accelerate that dispersal. I feel sure, however, that patriotism of the men and women who are the life-blood of the Abbey is such that we could steady the position to-day if there could be some assurance given by this Parliament or by this Government that we would accept the principle of erecting here a national theatre to replace the Abbey which is in ashes and that that new national theatre would be regarded as a monument to all those who served Ireland and gave their lives for Ireland.

I know of no more fitting monument which could be erected to commemorate the magnificent sacrifices and the imperturbable bravery of our people than the erection of a national theatre of that character and especially a national theatre which would carry on the tradition which made the Abbey nationally and internationally famous. However much we may disagree on the economic interpretation of the last three years or the last 30 years, one thing we can all agree upon is that the Abbey must be saved for our people, that the tradition of the Abbey must be saved, and that the magnificent people who gathered round the Abbey and were ambassadors in their own special way of Irish art and Irish culture throughout the world must not be dispersed by temptations from other quarters.

Now that the Abbey has been destroyed and we have no real fitting monument of remembrance to all those who fought and fell in the national struggle, I should like to appeal to the Government to announce as speedily as possible that they are accepting the principle of erecting a national theatre to carry on the traditions of the Abbey and to give those who accept the Abbey philosophy a wider and ever-expanding opportunity of advertising Irish culture and art for the benefit of the world and the edification of our own people at home. I think that this is a matter about which there will be a widespread measure of agreement among all Parties in the House and I hope the Government will find an early opportunity of indicating that in the situation which now confronts us, the Abbey being in ashes, they will accept the principle of erecting a new national theatre to replace it and to commemorate our illustrious dead.

Something perhaps may be necessary as an interim measure. It is quite clear that the Abbey with its present financial resources will be unable to carry on for any length of time unless it is assisted by the only reliable donor in a matter of this kind, namely, the State. I hope also that as part of the policy of maintaining and promoting cultural activities among our people and maintaining our reputation in the international field the Government will give such temporary financial assistance as may be necessary to keep the Abbey going until such time as temporary premises are found and until such time as a decent national home is found to perpetuate the memory and the culture of the Abbey and to commemorate suitably the struggle of our people for freedom and liberty.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy a question? After that lovely panegyric, will he tell us why he did not do something about the plans that were there three years ago to build a national theatre?

Comment on this

I felt we were bound to get a cultured contribution from the Minister.

Comment on this

They were there three years ago and, after that panegyric about the ashes, he would leave them in ashes for another three years.

Comment on this

The Abbey was burned down only two days ago.

Comment on this

You lost your vocation.

Comment on this

Thank God, however, I can still pronounce what I want to say.

Comment on this

I want to deal with the two motions that are before the House and that are being discussed jointly with this Estimate. Frankly, I think it was unwise to propose these motions for discussion with the Estimate, but the time-table probably necessitated that they be considered together.

Every Deputy agrees with the aim of having the elected representatives of this country in a single Parliament, but because every Deputy subscribes to that view it does not necessarily follow that every Deputy assents to the proposal enshrined in these motions. I do not think that the proposal which these motions involve of admitting to the deliberations of the Oireachtas some representatives who have been returned in the Six North-Eastern Counties is any practical step towards solving the problem of Partition. Undoubtedly, sentimentally a great deal can be said and a strong case can be made for having these persons who are anxious to take their place in a united Ireland amongst us and taking their place in our deliberations. But the proposal that is involved here, however desirable and however we may all subscribe to the aim of a united Ireland under a single Parliament, does not commend itself to me, because I regard it as merely desirable in theory, but impracticable in implementation.

For some time, I believe, the whole approach to Partition has been based too much on showmanship and not enough on statesmanship, and that a great deal of reckless talk on both sides of the Border has prevented practical steps or, on some occasions, has hindered certain practical steps, that might be taken towards achieving a united Ireland. I suppose that it is hardly likely, when reckless statements are made on one side or another, that rejoinders will not follow. It is inevitable, human nature being what it is, when an extravagant statement is made either by public representatives or others, that statements in answer will be made from the other side. From that point of view, the example in both parts of the country leaves much to be desired.

I think that the proper approach to this problem lies along the lines that have been adopted in relation to the Erne hydro-electric scheme and the Foyle fisheries agreement, and, although there may be some temporary divergence of view, the discussions that took place in connection with the Great Northern Railway. These three instances demonstrate the absurdity of Partition and the necessity for ending it as quickly as possible. They demonstrate, not merely the absurdity of the situation but the inescapable facts that if the maximum benefit is to be derived from the resources on either side of the Border, joint action in a number of cases is necessary and that that joint action is only possible when representatives from the Government here and the Government in Belfast join together to implement a common scheme.

I am glad to have had the privilege of piloting the legislation through this House to develop the Erne hydro-electric scheme. It is quite obvious that that scheme could not have been worked unless the drainage work that was carried out on the other side of the Border was allowed, and the drainage work would not have been possible unless other work was carried out on this side of the Border.

I was interested this evening in listening to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs claiming credit for a number of schemes initiated by the previous Fianna Fáil Administration and he referred to the Erne scheme as one. Nobody has ever attempted to diminish the credit which is due to the former Administration for their work on that scheme, but the whole electricity development programme in this country would have been far more rapid and done at much less cost if the same attitude had been taken up by the Fianna Fáil Party when in opposition and when the Shannon scheme was initiated.

Comment on this

On a point of correction, Sir. The Shannon scheme was initiated in 1924 and the Fianna Fáil Party came in in 1927. The legislation was completed in June, 1927.

Comment on this

I am not giving way to Deputy Briscoe. Deputy Briscoe will be aware of the fact that the present Minister for Finance, who was then Minister for Finance in the Fianna Fáil Government, in 1932 and 1933, described in the Seanad the Shannon scheme and the sugar beet factory as as precious a collection of white elephants as ever drove their unfortunate owners to the state of bankruptcy.

Comment on this

You are changing now from what you said before.

Comment on this
Mr. Coburn

Were not you blowing up bridges in 1924?

Comment on this

I know Deputy Briscoe has a personal spleen against the Electricity Supply Board.

Comment on this

I have no spleen.

Comment on this

It should not be introduced into a matter of this kind. The present Leader of Deputy Briscoe, the present Taoiseach, spoke as far away as Boston against the scheme, and also in Cavan.

Comment on this

In criticism of it.

Comment on this

If the Shannon scheme had been developed as fully and as rapidly as was possible before the war, when raw materials were cheap and supplies plentiful, a far greater supply of electricity would have been available here. We progressed with the Erne scheme. We implemented the work that was already started and I am glad to say that part of the Erne scheme is already in operation and it is hoped that the remainder of this scheme will be completed very shortly. However, that digression has nothing to do with the remarks that I was making.

The argument in favour of admitting the representatives from the six north-eastern counties, I believe, would have some merit if there was any divergence of view in the Dáil or in the Seanad but, however other problems may cause dissension or divergence of viewpoint, on the reunification of the country there is unanimity and on that problem there is no divergence of viewpoint on the aims, whatever about the methods. As I said earlier, the whole problem of Partition has not been approached in a statesmanlike way and there has been far too much talk and far too little action.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

My view of action and Deputy Cowan's are not the same. I know that Deputy Cowan favours the módh díreach but its recruits have diminished.

If we approach this problem by seeking agreement where agreement is possible, by eliminating the differences where it is possible to do so, by recognising that this problem cannot be solved easily or cannot be solved merely by talk, I believe we will go a long way towards speeding the day when a solution of the problem can be achieved.

I do not think that however desirable or attractive the proposal enshrined in these motions may appear, it would achieve any practical result towards securing the early ending of Partition. I must say that, from my contacts with Ministers in Belfast over a period relating to one specific problem, I definitely got the view that they recognised that ultimately Partition will end, that they recognised that a solution of the problem of Partition must inevitably be found some time; but they also appreciated that there are practical difficulties in the way. We here on this side of the Border recognise that a solution will be found, and that the sooner it is found the better, but a campaign designed to heap criticism and abuse on those on the other side of the Border cannot have desirable results, or cannot prepare the ground for a satisfactory solution of this problem.

For these reasons, I do not think that these motions should be pressed to a division. It should not be left to others to criticise the action of the Dáil, as I believe the Dáil will reject these motions. It may be misrepresented and misconstrued outside if these motions are not pressed to a division. After a free and full discussion here, no misrepresentation and no misconception of our position can result. If, on the other hand, they are pressed to a division, I must say that I will be obliged to vote against them because I do not think that the motions offer any practical solution to or improvement in the position.

I agree with the view which Deputy Costello expressed here to-day, that it would be representation without taxation. While something may be said for having expressed here the viewpoint of persons representing some of our people in the six north-eastern counties, nothing is less likely to achieve a solution of the problem of Partition than a make-believe policy or a policy based on wishful thinking. Wishful thinking, however attractive in theory, can achieve little in practice. I do not believe that the suggestions enshrined in these motions can achieve any practical step towards solving Partition.

The only other matter that I would like to refer to is the one that was mentioned by Deputy Norton. I agree with the view that steps should be taken to rebuild the Abbey Theatre. I think there is widespread regret at the devastation which the fire caused. It is obvious to anyone who has a knowledge of the site that it is not large enough to provide the country with a suitable building to replace the Abbey. I believe that, if the Government indicated their willingness to the directors of the Abbey, there would be unanimity here after the Recess to vote a Supplementary Estimate to meet the financial requirements.

Some Deputies may say that there were proposals in the past to build a national theatre. That may be so although I do not think the proposals were ever developed to any considerable extent.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

Yes, there were.

Comment on this

At that time, the Abbey was available. The position is different now. The Abbey no longer exists, and it is obvious that the facilities which were available then are no longer available and that steps should be taken to provide a national theatre to continue the work that was carried on in the Abbey for so many years, with such honour to those concerned and to the country.

Comment on this

One would imagine, listening to Deputy Norton and Deputy Dunne this evening, that wonders had been done during the past three years. Deputy Dunne in particular, representing, I believe, the rural workers—God save the mark—caused a terrible uproar here when the increase of 1d. a gallon on milk was given. When the previous 1d. a gallon on milk was given we had the same uproar from Deputy Dunne and others, but in that very same week margarine was increased by 4d. per lb. and we did not hear any word at all about that. That was put on one side as a natural thing to happen.

I wonder do Deputies realise that the increased cost, caused by the week's holidays with pay, the weekly half-holiday and the recent increase of 7/6 a week in agricultural wages, amounts exactly to an increased cost of production of 1.37d. per gallon of milk. The actual increase in the cost of production since the price had been previously fixed by Deputy Paddy Smith is 3.63d. per gallon—that is since March, 1947, to date. Deputy Dunne can be counting that up because I intend to force it until we get it, and I make no apology to anybody for doing so. Due to that policy, of which Deputy Norton and Deputy Dunne are prominent exponents here, we have had the position that, during the past three years. some 28,000 people have left the land of this country. Whether they went coal-mining in Britain or came into the towns and cities here is a matter for themselves, but the solid fact remains that 28,000 left and did not come back.

We heard Deputy Norton quote extracts from the famous book which he produced here, but Deputy Norton forgot all about page 17, which gives the volume of agricultural output. Taking the net output in 1938-39 as 100, in 1950 it was only 95.7, so that we had a reduction in agricultural output as between 1939 and 1950, the last year accounted for here. I have preached in this House for many a year that the agricultural labourer working on the land is entitled to the same wage as the man working in industry, or any other class of employment, and until that condition is brought about, you are going to have that flight from the land. It is all very well to have Muintir na Tíre meetings, at which learned gentlemen with big salaries talk about the flight from the land, but when we get down to bedrock and find a wage of £3 10s. 0d. or £3 13s. 0d. a week for an agricultural labourer and a wage of anything from £5 upwards for that man if he turns his hand to anything else, away from the land, we must realise that we are going to have that continual drain from the land. There is no use talking about increased productivity while that situation exists. That drain is not confined to agricultural labourers.

It is largely a drain of farmers' sons and daughters who see no future to-day in agriculture but who can see that, if they turn their hands to anything else, they will have a better opportunity and a better chance of going ahead and earning a decent livelihood for themselves. There is no use in this Government or the previous Government digging their heads into the sand and ignoring that state of affairs. The previous Government ignored it for three years.

Deputy Norton spoke about price freeze Orders in relation to labour. We had a price freeze Order in relation to the agricultural community for the past three years. It was only three months before the previous Government left office that we had any increase in the price of milk since March, 1947. We all know that the dairy cow is the foundation of agriculture in this country—the foundation of live stock, anyway—because if you have not got the cow, you will not have the bullock.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Did skim not increase in value by 2d.?

Comment on this

If the children will conduct themselves for a while, they will learn a little.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

All right, daddy.

Comment on this

He would prefer to be slandering somebody outside the House.

Comment on this

That is the position, so far as the previous Government were concerned, and that is what has driven this country from the position of being an exporter of butter in 1939 to the position of being a purchaser of butter in 1951. The farmer of to-day is a far different individual from the farmer of 20 years ago.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

When he finds a line of business does not pay, he is not prepared to carry on at it, as his father did. The moment he finds that it does not pay, he gets out from under. I gave a description some time ago of something I saw in County Limerick from a carriage window as I was coming up here. It was the picture of 14 decent milch cows in a field and 28 calves sucking them. There was no bother about milking or anything else —merely buy calves and drive them out to the cows. Then you wonder why you have not got butter. That is the reason you have not got butter and that is not confined to one or two farms. It is prevalent, I understand, right through County Tipperary.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

I beg the Deputy's pardon, it is.

Comment on this

I know more about Tipperary than Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

Unfortunately the Deputy stopped too long out of it.

Comment on this

I am longer in it than Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

I admit that. I am merely giving what I got from friends of mine there.

Comment on this

They are not very reliable.

Comment on this

I guarantee to the Deputy that they are most reliable. However, that does not change the picture. These are the facts of what is happening. It is either that or Roscrea for the cow, and a gradual dropping out of milk production by the farmer, and that is the one thing it is impossible to bring farmers back to. That is one item which accounts for the reduction and one could place a whole series of items side by side with it. The price freeze Order in relation to agriculture imposed by the inter-Party Government, as we will call them—I do not know whether we call them a platypus Government or not—undoubtedly left this country in such a condition that we had to go, and will be compelled to go, to the foreigner for a lot of what could be and should have been produced here.

Deputy Dunne complained that the Taoiseach had not been wide enough in his statement to-day. What was the Taoiseach's statement? He emphasised one thing, the production in this country of food for our people and our animals. He laid that down as a headline for our agricultural policy. I wonder has any Deputy opposite gone to the trouble of going through the imports of agricultural produce into this country during the past 12 months.

Have they studied them? Have they realised that those imports had to be paid for, not in sterling but largely in dollars? I made a statement here last night, which I have since verified, and which was denied by Deputies over there then, that under the wheat agreement we are expected to produce 50 per cent. of our requirements here, and every ton of wheat we are short of that 50 per cent. must be purchased, not under the wheat agreement, but outside the wheat agreement.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

In the Argentine?

Comment on this

It means the difference between £33 a ton and £35 a ton under the wheat agreement up to £45 a ton outside the agreement. One can count up the acreage of wheat this year and count up whether they will get out of that acreage 250,000 tons—and every ton they are short of that will have to be purchased at £45. I do not know what lunacy induced Deputies over there, particularly Labour Deputies, to agree with Deputy Dillon's figure of £25 a ton for wheat at home, knowing that every ton he is going to be short will have to be purchased in the foreign market at £45.

Comment on this

You paid £50 a ton to the Argentine.

Comment on this

I did not see the Argentine wheat, but I did see the Argentine oats.

Comment on this

The Argentine wheat cost £50 a ton.

Comment on this

I saw the Argentine oats that cost £26 10s. 0d. a ton and that was brought in here.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

We are discussing wheat.

Comment on this

I brought in a sample when I was sitting nearly where the Deputy is sitting now and I sent it right over here into James Dillon's lap.

Comment on this

That was the Canadian.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

"Deputy Dillon", is the term to be used.

Comment on this

Deputy James M. Dillon, lest there be any mistake about the gentleman's identity. He was responsible for paying the foreigner £26 10s. 0d. a ton for Argentine oats that Deputy Morrissey has so kindly reminded me of.

Comment on this

It was Canadian. The Deputy is getting a bit mixed.

Comment on this

Those are the things I would like Deputies to think over. Mind you, it might be possible to convert even yet some of those who are not hardened sinners like the Front Bench. They might realise the foolishness of a nation not paying its own workers. I heard talk by Labour Deputies about the increased wages of the worker, and I remember that those Labour Deputies supported a policy here for the past three years of paying to the nigger £10 a ton more than they would pay to the Irish farmer for producing a better article.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell us why we produced more beef last year than ever?

Comment on this

If the lawyers keep quiet, I will not be long, but if they interrupt I will have to deal with them as they ought to be dealt with.

Comment on this

The lawyers might deal with the Deputy.

Comment on this

I have a kind of recollection of the frame of mind caused by the activities of Deputy James Dillon. I had to take a case up for a bunch of unfortunate farmers.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will deal with the Estimate.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

He is rambling, like his Taoiseach.

Comment on this

He made that statement here before and he had to apologise for it.

Comment on this

I will not apologise for the fact that Deputy Sweetman was wrong.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will deal with the Estimate and nothing extraneous.

Comment on this

The Deputy had the manners then to apologise, but now he has the discourtesy to repeat the untruth.

Comment on this

I will hold it and bring in something that will be in order. Those facts cannot be denied, one after the other. The Taoiseach covered the whole lot here to-day, when he said that it is the intention of this Government to see that sufficient food is produced here for our own people and for our animals as well.

It will be paid for at decent prices and will still be cheaper than what the previous Government bought from the nigger. I do not wish to go beyond that. I heard a statement read out to-day by Deputy Costello in a speech which reminded me of one thing—the old saying that hell is paved with good intentions. Regarding every statement read out, as being given by Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Finance and by the others, the fulfilment was conspicuous by its absence. We were told about the employment that was going to be given and about Irishmen leaving for want of employment. Down in my own local town, in Cobh, I have seen for the past three years not a new industry brought in there but the extension of an industry, in which three-fourths of the machinery is lying on the side and for which guarantees had been given by the previous Minister for Industry and Commerce here, Deputy Seán Lemass, of the money to purchase the balance of that machinery.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

I am making statements here and there is very little use in Deputy Morrissey, who practised in regard to that industry the policy of abeyance, glowering now.

Comment on this

The Deputy's statement is not true.

Comment on this

The Deputy's statement is true—and the Deputy opposite knows it. I waited for something like nine months to give the boys time to have the honeymoon over and settle down to work and perhaps then we would get somewhere. Then I put down my little question. I was told the matter was under consideration—and that was answer No. 1. I gave them three months to consider it and put down another question. I was told that it was a very grave and serious matter and needed further consideration. I waited for six months more and I put down the third question and was then informed that the matter had been referred to the Industrial Development Authority—the Lord between me and all harm.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This is a matter more of administration of the Department of Industry and Commerce and not the over-all policy of the Government.

Comment on this

I am showing the manner in which industry progressed during the past three years, and I am leading up to the point where I am about to demand that something be done.

Comment on this

What answer are you going to get now?

Comment on this

I guarantee Deputy Morrissey that I will get it. Further, I am prepared to make a bet on it with Deputy Morrissey. If Deputy Morrissey cares to come, I shall bring him down to Irish Steel at Haulbowline where he will see 150 extra workers employed in an industry that he put in abeyance for three years. That is a bet, if Deputy Morrissey cares to take it up.

Comment on this

I rely on the Deputy's word.

Comment on this

We do not make flowery speeches about things at all. We do things. We do not put matters in abeyance. We carry them out.

Comment on this

I would not describe your speeches as being flowery whatever else I might describe them as being.

Comment on this

There would have been no trouble in getting plant and machinery to do the work in 1948 or 1949. The Deputy will understand that position to-day. Still, the plant and machinery will have to be got and they have got to be got as far as I am concerned.

Comment on this

You are going to usurp Deputy Cowan's position now in threatening the Government.

Comment on this

I am usurping nobody's position. I can assure the Deputy that this is the most stable Government that came here for many a long year.

Comment on this

Let the people speak.

Comment on this

There is no fear in the wide world that whenever we are short a couple we will either get a few from the Labour Party or a couple from the boys in Clann na Talmhan. If we cannot get a couple from them, Deputy MacBride will give us the support of his quota.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What has this got to do with over-all policy?

Comment on this

I have listened to-day for full half-hours to descriptions of the reasons why Deputy Cowan was supporting the Government and the particular reasons why Deputy Cogan has thrown in his weight with us. These discussions by Deputy Dunne and others lasted a pretty long time.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Where the Government gets a majority does not surely enter into the discussion on this Estimate or on the motions.

Comment on this

It apparently entered into it all day, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It certainly does not enter into it.

Comment on this

I do not mind if you rule it out of order, Sir. I am giving the Deputies a little reassurance that there is no fear in the wide world of it.

Comment on this

You do not know that yourself.

Comment on this

Deputy Cogan will be missing after the next election.

Comment on this

If he is missing so will Deputy Dunne.

Comment on this

Not a fear of it.

Comment on this

Could we not discuss the matter before the House in a more realistic manner than we have been doing for the last half-hour?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is what the Chair is trying to get done.

Comment on this

And that is what I am endeavouring to do, Sir. We have heard a lot of talk about increased employment. I am wondering how much of that increased employment is due to the crazy manner in which goods are distributed in this country. You have a position where you have brought in through Leinster via the port of Dublin three-fourths of our imports. Is that done in order to give increased employment to the boys carting from Dublin to Cork and Waterford?

Comment on this

I did not know that all the boys from Cork came to Dublin.

Comment on this

Another thing is that the goods should be delivered as soon as possible to the purchasers' place of export. This matter in concentrating all in the port of Dublin and then dishing it out is something that should be stopped. It is one of the matters which, I suggest, should occupy the immediate attention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Government generally. In view of the rising cost of living, increased freightage will also be added to the cost of goods sent from Dublin to Cork or to towns where the goods ultimately find their way. The bulk of the butter is produced in Munster, but the butter exported by the previous Minister for Agriculture was exported from Dublin. I want to know the cost of bringing that butter from Mitchelstown Creamery up to Dublin for export. One would think that the butter would be exported from the nearest port at any rate, the port of Cork. That ridiculous situation militates against the ordinary country ports. It also militates against the principal port in this country—the port of Cobh.

I hope to see carried out now the findings of the inter-departmental commission that was set up in 1947 in connection with the deep water quay at Cobh.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That surely is departmental administration.

Comment on this

It is national policy, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is the administration of a particular Department and is not something for which the Government is collectively responsible.

Comment on this

Would I be right in suggesting that the previous Government were largely responsible for the concentrating of this trade in the port of Dublin instead of in that of Cork and that now the present Government will have to be largely responsible for transferring its due share of that trade to the port of Cork?

Comment on this

Or else——

Comment on this

And that is my reason for——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Wasting time.

Comment on this

——pressing this matter of getting back to the port of Cork the shipping trade which has been transferred to Dublin. That can only be done by implementing the recommendations of that inter-departmental commission and putting them into force as quickly as possible. These recommendations were left in abeyance for three years and are lying in the office, I take it, of the late Minister for Industry and Commerce since May, 1948. I knew it was useless to beg to have it put into force. I knew that if I called attention to it even here in this House we would have an evasive reply. There was only one way to do it: to keep your mouth shut until you got a chance of getting away with it. Those are the facts.

When I hear talk about industry there are matters to which I would like the Government to give immediate attention. One is the concentration here in Dublin of shipping repairs.

Comment on this

Will there not be a bit of trouble in the north?

Comment on this

There will, and a bit of trouble when I get the answer I got from the previous Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That surely is administrative. Reference to a particular Department is not relevant to a debate on the over-all policy of the Government. This is over-all policy.

Comment on this

When skilled workers from my constituency are compelled to emigrate to follow the ships although the ships are the property of Irish steamship companies and when those ships are sent to Germany or Britain for repairs and the skilled workers are lying idle or must follow the ships to foreign ports, surely it is the responsibility of the Government to have the matter rectified.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should not pursue that line.

Comment on this

I will not; I have said all I wanted to say. Those are the things that interest me.

I heard a lot to-day about industry in the Gaeltacht. I put up certain suggestions away back in 1940 to the then Minister for Agriculture which would have meant intensified agricultural production in the smaller holdings whether they be in West Cork, Kerry or Connemara. My suggestion was the production there of small seeds which has a large labour content on the land and which brings in a gross income of from £100 to £130 per acre. The production of those seeds in the Gaeltacht areas would undoubtedly help to stem the tide of emigration and would give the man with the small holding who undoubtedly, under ordinary agricultural conditions, would not have a means of livelihood, an opportunity of finding full employment on his own farm in the first instance and of producing seeds which are essential. Unfortunately, instead we see them produced in Meath, Westmeath, Kildare, Cork and other counties where farmers have 100 to 150 and sometimes 300 acres. These farmers do the work which should in common sense be done on the uneconomic holdings of the West. It would be far better and a far more common sense project than to bring any big industry into those areas. That is only my viewpoint but I am putting it. What a benefit it would be can be seen by any Deputy who takes the trouble of going into the quantity of small seeds, turnip, mangold, beet, cabbage and all the rest, that must be imported every year or purchased here. He will see the income that would give to the smallholder.

I am more than anxious to see industries placed in thickly populated areas where you have uneconomic holdings. What I had in mind is only one instance and there are other things which I am sure could be got going in those areas which would give employment to our people. I am sure that the Government would welcome any proposals from any Deputy in that regard.

I am more worried, as one must be in this little world of ours, about my own constituency and my own constituents and I want the Government to give immediate and specific attention to the unemployment position in the town of Fermoy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely that is not relevant.

Comment on this

It is one of the Government's problems.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

So is everything in relation to unemployment and industry. Surely that is coming down to the detailed work of a Department.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I understand that this debate is limited to 12 o'clock and some of us have waited in this House since 12 o'clock to-day endeavouring to make some little contribution. I think that there should be a spirit of reasonableness as far as Deputies are concerned.

Comment on this

In view of what Deputy Cowan has said I certainly will give way immediately. I do not wish to delay proceedings. I am not on the line that since he came into this House I love to talk about him——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Captain Cowan since he came in has not spoken on the Estimate.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan should be known as Moses from this day forward —the man who struck the rock.

Comment on this

It has been as was pointed out to-day by Deputy Costello the established practice that the Taoiseach on a Vote such as this should make a general objective survey of the economic condition of the country and I regret that the Taoiseach has seen fit to avoid that policy because he must be in a position to say whether he found conditions as he and his colleagues painted them during the past three years and he should have told us in an objective fashion whether there was any merit whatever in the previous Administration or whether they were guilty of all the offences with which they were charged. However, in what has been properly described as a wide-open, childish declaration he avoided all the principal parts of the duty he should perform.

The country is disturbed and the people are anxious to know what Government policy is in relation to the Health Act of 1947.

They want to know if it is the intention of the Government to amend that Act, as requested in October, 1947, by the spiritual advisers of the majority of the people of this country. They want to know the Government's intentions relating to matters that agitated the minds of the people and of the members of this House over the past few months. These were two very important items. One would expect that the Taoiseach would take the Dáil into his confidence at this particular stage and let us know the Government's intentions on these subjects.

For the past two years I have been listening to an attack upon the previous Government's policy of capital expenditure. I heard the charge made and attempts made to substantiate it, such as the attempt of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs to-day, that the expenditure was extravagant. My memory goes back to the same type of criticism that was levelled in respect of the expenditure on the Shannon scheme and the beet scheme that was established by a previous Administration. I heard the matter of that capital expenditure bandied all over the country, as if it were a madman's scheme to build the hydroelectric Shannon scheme or the Carlow Beet Factory. A person who is now a Minister described these things as a precious lot of white elephants bestowed by an Administration. One would expect that after a period of office such as that which Fianna Fáil enjoyed, at least some of the Leaders and the Ministers of that Party would get some bit of sense—but it seems that the older they get the worse they become. It is a well-known fact that if the Banking Commission had known that a war was going to come in 1938, 1939 or 1940, their report would have been considerably different because it would have been tempered by that knowledge. If the Government of the day, when they saw that war was imminent in 1938 or 1939, had had the foresight to spend some of the capital assets——

Comment on this

The then Taoiseach said that it was a mythical war.

Comment on this

Will the little Minister for Finance keep quiet and let me tell him what he said to me when I advocated the purchase of ships in 1938 and when I advocated the establishment of a mercantile marine? When I advocated these two matters the present brilliant Minister for Finance asked me how they would keep them on the high seas if they had them. Yet they bought old tubs. They were right subsequently—but they bought the old tubs at an increased cost.

Comment on this

And the Minister for External Affairs wanted to sink them all.

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this

Our experience has been one of Fianna Fáil incompetency over a long period. We heard Deputy Corry talk a few moments ago about 28 calves suckling 14 cows. Is that not a change from the time when they cut the throats of the calves? That is the sort of thing to which we are treated. However, let me come back to the suggestion of capital expenditure. I disagree with certain things which the Clann na Poblachta Party preach but I am in thorough agreement with them that the country that exports men and money is mad—and we have been doing that consistently and persistently since this State was established.

With regard to the sterling assets that Fianna Fáil feel so tenderly about and are so anxious to preserve, dear knows, at one time they would almost have burned them. That is the only indication that some attempt has been made to increase their knowledge. The fact remains that we have not purchased half enough capital goods over the past 15 years.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Would to goodness we had had the courage to do what we should have done. When a Government for the past three years took a forward step the Fianna Fáil Party started howling after us as if we were madmen and as if we did not know what we were doing.

Comment on this

If we purchased 20 ships there would not be anything wrong with that.

Comment on this

But they sold them.

Comment on this

If we had bought 20 ships in 1938 they could have been purchased at one-tenth the cost which we would have to pay for them now, and then you would have sound capital assets, and you would not be faced with having sterling currency that you could paper a room with, but God forbid that the hard earnings of the Irish people should be so wasted. There is only one safe place to have them and that is in the land, in buildings, in factories and in machinery in this country, and thus give our people employment at home. The capital expenditure of the previous Government was housing, afforestation, drainage and land reclamation. What is wrong with that? What part of that programme is the present Government going to drop?

Comment on this

None, I hope.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy sure? Is that the price he got?

Comment on this

Would that not be a good price?

Comment on this

The Deputy can make his speech afterwards. I can only say that when the Fianna Fáil Government were demanding that the policy of the previous Government should be to put certain Deputies behind bars because they were leading tin-pot armies up and down the country, I protected the interests of that poor individual.

Comment on this

Now he is sleeping with the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Now he is hailfellow-well-met with his accusers of the day before. I do not envy him his position.

Comment on this

Or the combination.

Comment on this

Let me proceed with the attack that was made on the previous Administration. I should like to remind the Deputies that, after the election, 17 points of policy were announced by the Taoiseach, the then Leader of the Fianna Fáil Opposition —but he did not say one word about them except in a general way. That policy was announced after the election, which was the wrong time for doing so. If the present Taoiseach had published these 17 points before the election we would then have been able to see how far they coincided with our own programme. I have in my hand a document which they published before the election and they said that the political and social principles of Fianna Fáil are those which were announced in 1948, namely, to freeze wages and to have everything that we had then— the Military Courts, the Special Courts——

Comment on this

And the ten fields of inspectors.

Comment on this

——and compulsory tillage. However, I do not want to develop that point too far now. That was the Fianna Fáil programme, believe it or not—and Deputy Cowan condemned it and stated that he did not agree with it, when he was seeking the suffrage of the people of Dublin.

Comment on this

I did not make one speech.

Comment on this

You fired the bricks.

Comment on this

You had a gramophone record and a band, which was just as good.

Comment on this

"Peadar at the polltop...."

Comment on this

You had the gramophone record, which was just as good. The same is true of other Deputies.

The capital expenditure policy of the last Government was based on a sound financial foundation. If this country does not continue that policy, no matter what Government is in office, the country will find itself faced with some of the difficulties and dangers that Deputy Lemass, now Minister for Industry and Commerce, foresaw before the last election. Our Government believed that the best way to defend this country was to establish in it a sound economic condition both for agriculture and industry, owners and workers alike. I am a firm believer in that. Believe it or not, the best defence this country ever put up politically or nationally was when our people were able to keep their heads above the water. Whatever success we had in 1920 and 1921 was due to the Irish farmer and the Irish people generally who were in a sound financial position and could, therefore, keep us in the field. They were in a position to keep us in their homes and make us all welcome. The Irish people are a proud people and when there is full and plenty in the house you are always welcome, but if they have not full and plenty you are not welcome.

The land rehabilitation project, the development of agriculture generally and afforestation are things which will build up the financial wealth of the nation. Already there has been a decided and positive improvement in the standard of living. Let us hope that will continue. In so far as the present Government continues that programme, as far as I am concerned I will do all I can to help. The only opposition I will offer is when I believe the Government is doing something which will damage the country and the livelihood of our people. I know the present Government will not do that intentionally but, being the blunderers they are, God only knows what they will do. They have done many wild things in the past for which the Irish people apparently have forgiven them. Why I do not know. The people have the right to do that if they want to, but a day of reckoning will come.

I do not know what the policy of the present Government is in relation to the defence of our country. The Government to which I had the honour to belong took the view that the best defensive measure this country could adopt was to raise the country itself to a high economic level thereby putting ourselves in the position that we could put our manpower into the rehabilitation of our land, housing, afforestation and drainage. That is a sound policy of defence. The more that is done along those lines the stronger we will be and every farmer who joins the F.C.A. will be able to do a very fine piece of work if proper use is made of that force.

I do not intend to attack the Government or even the Minister for Finance for their failure to put up a munition factory. When I was Minister for Defence the present Minister for Finance was repeatedly asking was I going to wait until the Ford factory in Cork ran some of the munitions we needed off the lines. The Ford factory in Cork does run some stuff off the lines which is essential for defence. There is one thing certain and that is that the Ford factory in Cork, or any other factory, will do more for the defence of our country than the 30-years planned munition factory that never came to fruition about which we heard so much from the present Minister for External Affairs when he was Minister for Defence. If some of the younger Deputies will read reports they will see how far that munition factory was planned and how far it got.

I am glad that the Taoiseach to-day repudiated the Westmeath executive of Fianna Fáil for recommending the use of arms for the ending of Partition.

Comment on this

Good God, are they split again?

Comment on this

They are. At a Fianna Fáil executive meeting in Westmeath—and I think a lot of them were aged men—they solemnly passed a unanimous resolution, contrary to the wishes of the Minister for Local Government who was present, that the only way to end Partition was by the use of arms. I was wondering whether the shades of Deputy Cowan were not knocking around somewhere.

Comment on this

He must have been there.

Comment on this

That resolution was carried unanimously by the Westmeath Fianna Fáil executive. That executive has been repudiated to-day. I am glad of that repudiation. Believe it or not, the Minister for External Affairs could, like myself, give these "youngsters" some advice as to the wisdom or unwisdom of taking a step like that.

Comment on this

I suppose it is the sort of advice you took from the older people in your young days.

Comment on this

I hope the advice of the younger people will be taken to-night.

Comment on this

I regret that the motions in the names of Deputy Seán MacBride and Deputy Tully are being discussed with this Vote because I think they deserve better consideration. I think they should not be messed up with this particular type of debate.

Comment on this

Senseless, senseless.

Comment on this

I would much prefer that we should approach these motions in a friendly spirit in an effort to find out what is the best thing to do in the interests of the country as a whole and what is most likely to have the best results towards ending the unseemly and unreasonable division of our country.

I throw my mind back to the First Dáil. The Clerk of the House at that time called the roll at every Dáil meeting. He called Sir Edward Carson and Michael Collins. He called Sir James Craig and Alfie Byrne. He called John Redmond and everyone else. The fact that we were all called to an Irish Parliament left no doubt as to what the then Dáil was seeking to govern. All the elected representatives of the Irish people were being called to take their place in the sovereign Parliament of the nation. When I look at the Order Paper, motion No. 6 certainly appeals to me. I should like Deputies to consider it because I think, from the way in which it has been discussed, a number of Deputies just simply approach it as one of the means by which representatives from Northern Ireland can be given a right of audience here. It is however much more than that and, before the House comes to a decision on it, I think it should be examined in some greater detail. I do not know whether or not the mover explained it fully—I was not here, I regret to say—but in case he did not, I should like to stress a few points in regard to it. The motion reads:—

"Believing that, in order to achieve the unity of Ireland, a greater degree of contact and co-operation between the elected representatives of the people of the six occupied counties and members of the Oireachtas is required, Dáil Éireann requests the Government to initiate proposals for legislation in the Dáil or in the Seanad whereby all the elected parliamentary representatives of the people of the six occupied counties of Ireland will be given a right of audience in the Dáil or in the Seanad, as may be determined."

That motion appeals very much to me, as I say, and I think it should appeal to every one of us. Why? If it is passed, I believe that it is an invitation to all the elected representatives in Northern Ireland to come here. In passing it, we shall have taken the first step in showing our good will towards these people.

I am stressing the word "all" but, as I say, I wish this motion was not discussed in this particular way and that it was not mixed up with the Vote for the Taoiseach because, believe it or not, the Vote for the Taoiseach's Department is at present our own domestic affair in the Twenty-Six Counties. Let us hope that at a later stage it will become the affair of the whole 32 Counties but we are not, at present, owing to our political and other affiliations, just capable of approaching the motion in the objective way in which we should approach it. As, however, the House has decided that it should be discussed in this way, I commend it to Deputies in order that the invitation may be sent out and that the Dáil may ask the Government to take the steps suggested in the motion.

I support the motion in the firm belief that it will lead to a restoration of some of my pristine courage inasmuch as it is taking a step which will show to our fellow countrymen in the Six Counties, be they Nationalist or Unionist, Orange or Green, that we do regard them as forming an integral part of this nation, that we do regard them as Irishmen possessing equal rights and subject to equal obligations but that we do not intend to give, and will not give, them any privilege over other citizens.

As I say, this Vote is one on which the Taoiseach should have given us much more information. He should have told us, and settled once and for all, his views on the difficult question that brought about, in no small way, the defeat of the previous Government. He should have told us what reply the Government are going to make to the Hierarchy, and what reply they will now make to the letter of October, 1947, which was acknowledged only in February, 1948. He should have told us whether a positive reply will now be sent so that the people of this country can know exactly where we stand. He should have indicated that this House condemns in the strongest possible manner the action of any Deputy or Deputies who attack in an unmannerly way either the bishops of the Catholic Church or the leaders of any other Church in this country. I want to stress in conclusion that this Dáil has no intention of legislating against any religious denomination. It is true that we are forbidden to legislate for them by the Constitution, but it is equally true that we are not to legislate against them. Remember that the Catholic Church is still a very powerful force in this country. Let the Government realise that; and let them realise, too, that any tin can that may be tied to their tail can bring them grave disaster.

Comment on this

I should like to deal with the obvious illogicality of the Deputy who has just sat down.

Comment on this

That is yourself.

Comment on this

I do not know where the interruption came from, but I should like to warn any gombeen man who is going to interrupt me that I shall answer him back.

Comment on this

Be careful, boys. The army will march soon.

Comment on this

I do not know the Deputy. He has portrayed himself in this House as having all the attributes and qualifications of the gombeen man and if he wants to interrupt me he can have it.

Comment on this

And the Deputy knows what that means.

Comment on this

Is this a dignified way to address any Deputy in this House?

Comment on this

Is the remark in order?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not in order and it is not a parliamentary remark.

Comment on this

Will it be withdrawn, if it is unparliamentary?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It must be withdrawn.

Comment on this

If it is out of order, I shall withdraw it, but I warn the individual all the same that, if people describe themselves in certain ways here, I cannot be blamed for putting correct English on that description. In the course of this debate, I have been subjected to a considerable amount of abuse, simply and solely because I exercised a constitutional and democratic right in this House not so long ago. Having looked up the records, I find that the strange thing is that most of the criticism I got came from individuals who were themselves in their time subjected to the same type of abuse for doing exactly the same thing as I did. Go back and read the records of the House; read Deputy Morrissey on Deputy McGilligan, Deputy McGilligan on Deputy Morrissey, Deputy McGilligan on Deputy Norton, and what they said about one another. This Fianna Fáil Government is in office now.

Comment on this

A minority Government.

Comment on this

It was a minority Government when on two occasions it was put in by the vote of Deputy Norton and the Labour Party.

Comment on this

And Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

God forgive me, I did that once but never again. Mea culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa. I voted for De Valera once, God help me.

Comment on this

The extraordinary thing about it is that they can say these things. They can swivel and twist, but nobody else can change a view if that change does not accord with their ideas. I have heard General MacEoin and other Deputies talking about our concepts of Christianity: Love your neighbour. Since the vote that brought about the change of Government took place, these exponents of "love your neighbour" walk around this House and these corridors refusing to speak to Deputies who voted against them. Love your neighbour! Uphold Christianity! Do not look the side of the road that your neighbour is walking on! That is very relevant to the discussion that has been initiated here to-day by Deputy MacBride and I hope to deal with it in a few moments.

I think it is important from the country's point of view that we should have stable government. It is an important thing for the administration of the country and for the credit of the country that we should have a Government in office that has a reasonable expectation of a period of three, four or five years of life. Some Deputies who desscribe themselves as concerned with the interests and the future of the country refer to the Government as "a caretaker" Government. Deputy MacBride to-day referred to it as depending on "five irresponsibles" and I was the most irresponsible of the five.

Comment on this

I think I said "a few irresponsibles".

Comment on this

But when he was flying around the world he was doing it on my vote and on my responsible action.

Comment on this

Yes, indeed, and it is a source of embarrassment to me.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride said to-day that the Taoiseach's power to speak for this country would be greater if he represented an all-Party Government rather than a one-Party Government, that his power to speak for this country in foreign countries would be much stronger if he had a Cabinet in which Deputy MacBride was a Minister.

Comment on this

He did not say that.

Comment on this

Of course he did not say it; he suggested it. The only inference to be drawn from that——

Comment on this

On a point of order, is a Deputy entitled deliberately to misquote something that was said, particularly when at the time his attention was drawn to the fact that it was not true?

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride has stated on two occasions in this House, since it became clear that the Government of which he was a member would be defeated, that he would like to have an all-Party Government. He made a declaration in which he said he did not seek any ministerial office in that Government.

Comment on this

And when pressed to accept it, refused to give way.

Comment on this

There was no question of being pressed because there was no opportunity of pressing.

Comment on this

You are mistaken. I pressed him and Mr. Costello pressed him, and he would not join. He felt it was not right to join the Government we hoped to form and should have been allowed to form if the dud T.D.s and the busted flush had not prevented us.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride announced very deliberately that he would not seek office. I have never yet met a Deputy in this House who stated that he was seeking office. Not even in the Fianna Fáil Party is there a Deputy that would indicate, or publicly state, that he was seeking office.

Comment on this

Is there anybody in that whole set-up of Parties who would publicly state that he was seeking office?

Comment on this

Yes. I sought office as Minister for Agriculture. I got it and enjoyed every minute of it and wanted to be in it all my life.

Comment on this

That is a rather sore point with one or two people over there.

Comment on this

We need not go into that. I was dealing with the question of stable government and the power of "the five irresponsible Deputies" to keep that Government in office in the interests of the country.

Comment on this

In spite of public opinion.

Comment on this

We were told that this Government would be faced with a very strong, vigilant and united opposition, but it is torn to tatters already.

Comment on this

Wait and see.

Comment on this

It is torn to tatters already. How can the Labour Party support some of the elements that are across in that section on certain issues? How can they do it?

Comment on this

You have been around every Party.

Comment on this

No, not all of them.

Comment on this

You are now on the doorstep of Deputy MacEntee's Party, but he will not let you in. He will use your vote but he will not let you in.

Comment on this

I just want to make this point: as far as the Government is concerned, there is no united opposition against it. I think it is necessary that that should be stated in the interests of the credit of the country.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance blasted the credit of the country last night.

Comment on this

We can see clear evidence of disagreement already on the issue raised by Deputy MacBride, which will be dealt with to-night. Very substantial differences have indicated themselves already in the discussion.

Comment on this

What side will the Deputy take?

Comment on this

I do not want to take up much time, but I would like if Deputies would allow me to make a few simple remarks.

Comment on this

Harmless?

Comment on this

I asked a simple parliamentary question to-day about an individual who is one of my constituents. I do not happen to know him, but I thought it was necessary, having been requested, to put down a parliamentary question. I am aware that this individual is known to members of the Clann na Poblachta Party and to members of the Labour Party, but the privileges of this House were used by a Fine Gael Deputy to do harm to this person whom he never met and does not know, no more than I know him. Nevertheless, he used his bitter malice to do damage to that individual who could not defend himself and who was not here. I do not mind what the Deputies round about me say, or what anybody says, about me, but I do think it is wrong that they should have that attitude or that we should have these references where a man's employment is at stake. I sincerely hope that that Deputy will understand that there are great privileges in this House, but they should not be used to injure a person who cannot defend himself.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Birds of a feather, Deputy.

Comment on this

This Estimate gives the opportunity to discuss economic problems and general problems of financial and monetary control.

Comment on this

Now we are coming to something.

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy Hickey will agree with the observations I am about to make. The Government must take a decision to increase employment. They must take a decision to establish new industries. They must continue and accelerate the house-building programme. They must continue and accelerate the building of hospitals and public buildings. The fishing industry has to be modernised and developed. Afforestation has to be pressed ahead, and it must be gone ahead with on a larger scale than we have had up to the present, although I appreciate and understand the difficulties and why that scale could not have been bigger. But those steps must be taken and, inevitably, the problem arises in egard to the provision of money. I think any economist or any person who knows anything about economics must know that some of the things which are being said about the repatriation of our external assets are all poppycock and nonsense and are being said by people who know nothing whatever about the subject.

What we want, and I recommend it to the Minister, is a policy that I learned when I was in the Labour Party, a policy about which I wrote for Clann na Poblachta and for which we did more propaganda work in Clann na Poblachta than the Labour Party did, and that is breaking the link with sterling and taking over our monetary control. We want credit to do all this nationally desirable work, and that credit must be provided by our Central Bank freed from the shackles of control by sterling.

Comment on this