We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Office of the Taoiseach (Resumed).

Contributions 461–709 of 709. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Carry out the instructions of Article 45 of the Constitution.

Comment on this

Quite right. There will be no difference between Deputy Hickey and me on that. There will be no difference of opinion between Deputy Dunne or Deputy Davin and me on that. But there will be a tremendous amount of difference between those Deputies and some of the gentlemen across the way.

Comment on this

You will frighten the life out of the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

We will say it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cowan should be allowed to proceed without interruption.

Comment on this

The trouble about this problem of finance is that when it was first mooted allegations were made that it was going to interfere with savings, that it was going to take the little nest egg that is in the Post Office or the bank. That attack has been made on it.

Comment on this

It was communistic then.

Comment on this

We will leave that out. It has been suggested that Deputy Davin and I were Communists, but I look upon that as a joke.

Comment on this

No one ever did say it.

Comment on this

The man who did say it is in front of you.

Comment on this

I think the Labour Party would do a tremendous national work if they would go around propagating and explaining that particular idea —influence more people to talk about it and educate the people. I think they would do a lot more national good in that way than by doing what they are doing at the moment—lamenting the fate which has put them in a position to gain the freedom of their own consciences.

Comment on this

Apply that to yourself.

Comment on this

I thought we were to have to-day a very important discussion on this problem of Partition and whether or not the elected representatives in the Six Counties would be able to come into this House and take some part in the proceedings. I think Deputy MacBride was very unwise in getting these motions interlocked with an important debate on the Taoiseach's Estimate involving as it does all those problems of finance and economics and the general policy of the State and the Government, because the result of that ill-timed action has been that very little of the 12 hours' debate has been available for serious consideration of these motions. I suggest to Deputy MacBride and Deputy MacEoin, who have spoken on this matter, that there was a certain illogicality about their attitude. They want Sir Basil Brooke down here—at least they say they want him. When I addressed an observation to Deputy MacBride to-day, he made a slightly bitter attack on me because I disagreed with some actions of our Hierarchy. If Sir Basil Brooke comes in here, he cannot be tied down to accept everything that is said by the Hierarchy, and the sooner that is accepted the better. The sooner we have all this nonsense——

Comment on this

On a point of order. I am afraid the Deputy is misrepresenting what I said. I said that I thought——

Comment on this

I will not give way. It is not a point of order.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not a point of order. Deputy Cowan is in possession.

Comment on this

It is not a point of order.

Comment on this

It is not in order for a Deputy to misquote what another Deputy said.

Comment on this

I ask for your protection, Sir.

Comment on this

Are you afraid to hear what I said? I said I thought it would be better if the Deputy did not avail of this House to use a falsified document to attack the head of the Church. I do not think Basil Brooke would do that, but you did.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order! Deputy Cowan to continue.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride must feel rather ashamed of himself.

Comment on this

He is well able for you though, and he would want to be.

Comment on this

Yes. He dealt with me in the way he would have dealt with the Deputy a few years ago. He was only able to expel me. He might have been a little more severe on you.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is not it over a year since the Deputy was expelled from the Clann na Poblachta Party and this Vote is dealing with the last year?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a point of disorder. Deputy Cowan to continue, without interruption.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Deputy Cowan just stated, Sir, that you were expelled from the Clann na Poblachta Party by Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this

Is fíor dhuit.

Comment on this

I did not think the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was in the Clann na Poblachta Party.

Comment on this

This is very clever. When I came here three years ago myself, I was just as clever.

Comment on this

But now you are as innocent as a bumble bee.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Go bhfoiridh Dia ort.

Comment on this

I want Deputy MacBride to realise this, that as far as the North of Ireland is concerned, there is a very big and a very serious problem there. He appreciates what that problem is and he understands it, but he will not help to end that problem by using certain situations down here against individuals that he does not like. It may be all right, it may be a passport to political oblivion, to use the Hierarchy against an individual who endeavours to express his own point of view, but look at what damage that can do to the national interest. I want Deputy MacBride to understand that.

Comment on this

I understand it only too well, the damage you and Deputy Dr. Browne did to the national interest.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

I think it might have been better if this particular motion was discussed in a closed House——

Comment on this

Take up your courage now and vote.

Comment on this

——behind doors——

Comment on this

I must finish what I want to say.

Comment on this

And then vote.

Comment on this

——so that certain viewpoints that may damage the national interest may be kept from the public.

Comment on this

That is an extraordinary revelation.

Comment on this

In other Parliaments there have been matters of importance discussed behind closed doors.

Comment on this

For example? Where? In Russia—that is the only place.

Comment on this

I am not going to continue Deputy Flanagan's education. I am not endeavouring to improve Deputy Flanagan's education. A Deputy of this House ought to make some little study of procedures in other democratic Parliaments.

Comment on this

I repeat Deputy Flanagan's question and I am as sophisticated a character as the Deputy is.

Comment on this

It has been done.

Comment on this

I would like the reference.

Comment on this

How often has it been done in Britain during the last war?

Comment on this

In France.

Comment on this

It has been done in France and in other democratic Parliaments.

Comment on this

Where military strategy is under discussion.

Comment on this

Matters affecting the national interest. Those matters might have been discussed but Deputy MacBride wants, as far as he is concerned, to use the Hierarchy here to deal with his political opponents and to tell the people in the Six Counties that the Hierarchy have no power or influence down here. That is the big problem and we have just got to face it and we will face it by being honest with ourselves.

Comment on this

That is a peculiarly disgusting slander.

Comment on this

I do not mind what Deputy Flanagan may say about me here or elsewhere or what Deputy MacBride may say here or elsewhere. What we want to do is to bring about an end to Partition. That is what we want to do and I think that if that unfortunate and regrettable episode of a few months ago had not taken place we might have been nearer to the end of Partition.

Comment on this

Tell that to Noel Hartnett.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride, Deputy Norton and Deputy Costello say that on any issue on which they receive a direction from the Bishops they are going to carry it out. Then they say there is no trouble about coming into a Parliament. I have made it perfectly clear that that was the major reason why I put the inter-Party Government out, or helped to put them out.

Comment on this

And Fianna Fáil in?

Comment on this

I make no bones about that.

Comment on this

Look at them in Russia.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Cowan should look on the smiling faces.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think Deputy Dillon should allow Deputy Cowan to continue.

Comment on this

Let him look at the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

What we want here is the freedom to express our views on matters that we are sent here to deal with, and I have endeavoured to do that.

Comment on this

You would not vote for that a few nights ago.

Comment on this

I am not going to be drawn into supporting Deputy's Dillon's disorder.

Comment on this

It is my disorder; it is the Deputy's liberty.

Comment on this

I will describe it as disorder.

Comment on this

You have given a shock to your friends on the other side.

Comment on this

We have had a lot of talk in this House about Partition, how to end it, how to approach it. The attitude of the last Government in regard to the matter that I was just discussing was certainly not the right attitude. It was not the right way to deal with it. It was not helpful. I have indicated that very clearly and I want to indicate it again, because of what has been stated by Deputy MacBride here to-day—it has been stated by Deputy MacEoin—that force is not the means to end Partition. We were told that 30 years ago. Deputy Dillon's father, respected man, told us that force was not the way to gain freedom in this country.

Comment on this

Do you think we might let the dead rest?

Comment on this

That was 30 years ago. We were told that. We did not believe it. We knew it was wrong and it was wrong. I say that those people who have grown old, experienced, and tell us now that force is not the method for ending Partition are just as wrong as these elderly gentlemen were 30 or 40 years ago. We want to end Partition and I have considered it from all its angles and all its aspects and, if Partition is to be ended in our time, it can only be ended by the enforcement of our will on the will of our fellow citizens in the Six Counties.

Comment on this

By your army?

Comment on this

I do not mind what army it is or who does it. It must be done, and force can end Partition. Is there anyone in this House who will say that any Nationalist in the Six Counties who wants to use force to end Partition is to be condemned for doing it? Will any Deputy, Deputy MacBride or anybody else, say it would be wrong for the Nationalists of the Six Counties to rise and by force put an end to the present régime up there? Is there anything wrong in any individual from this part of the country going up there and joining with them in the effort to put an end to the Six County Administration?

Comment on this

Very few go up.

Comment on this

I only wanted to have the matter thrashed out. Is there anything wrong in any individual in this country going up and doing that? I defy anyone to say that there is anything wrong.

Comment on this

I am going to say it now. There is everything wrong in the Deputy stunting down here and encouraging young men to risk their lives when he does not mean a single word of it himself.

Comment on this

Let us not talk about stunting because we are discussing now a motion that has been interjected into this debate for stunt purposes, stunt purposes only.

Comment on this

That is why it was put in—for stunt purposes.

Comment on this

Because it denies Deputies an opportunity of contributing to the debate on this motion.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It is your pal, the Taoiseach, did that.

Comment on this

There were 12 hours allowed for the debate on the Estimate for the Taoiseach's Department.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Talk to friend, Eamon.

Comment on this

Into that, Deputy MacBride inserted these particular motions.

Comment on this

No, the Tánaiste did.

Comment on this

On a point of order. That is not true. These motions were introduced into this debate by the Tánaiste.

Comment on this

At the request of Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon. That is not so. I asked for Government time in which to discuss this motion. The Tánaiste then decided that Government time would be available in the course of this discussion. It was not at my suggestion.

Comment on this

Of course, that is complete misrepresentation of the facts. The facts are these, that these motions were far down on the Order Paper, that Deputy MacBride asked that they should be taken out of their order and given precedence, apparently because of the fact that, he having put them down, he attaches overriding importance to them and wants to be at the head of the queue. When this plea was made by Deputy MacBride a compromise was reached. We had not the time in this session to give him the particular period which he wanted, and he agreed that they would be debated on this Estimate.

Comment on this

I drew the attention of the Taoiseach to the fact that an assurance had been given by his predecessor that Government time would be made available, in the course of this session, for the discussion of these two motions. The Taoiseach then asked me to repeat the questions next day, and on the next day I was informed that they would be taken in the course of this discussion.

Comment on this

Anyway, I think the facts in regard to it are perfectly clear. There were 12 hours available for the discussion of the Taoiseach's Estimate. If Deputy MacBride had not his motion discussed to-day, it would have been left over, and public time would have been made available for it, I have no doubt, at the earliest opportunity.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Next November.

Comment on this

It would be better next November with sufficient time for all of us to participate in it.

Comment on this

You are getting time now.

Comment on this

We have had an example of this inaction. Deputy MacBride has suggested that what we should do is to invite the Deputies to come down here, and sit in, with no right to vote, but probably the right to intervene in discussions. Now, during the period of office of the last Government, we had one Senator appointed from the Six Counties. I take responsibility for the election of the Senator to the Seanad.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

He was not elected; he was nominated.

Comment on this

I take responsibility for it.

Comment on this

He was not elected.

Comment on this

I take responsibility for it, and Deputy MacBride knows why I say that.

Comment on this

I do not know. I had nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

Anyway, that particular Senator has been in the Seanad. The idea was that he would represent Six County interests. He was suggested by the Clann na Poblachta Party, and that was a Clann na Poblachta idea. Now, he is actually a member of the Seanad, entitled to participate in everything relating to the whole of the 32 Counties.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I think there is a well-established rule of our two Houses that we do not criticise one another outside our respective Houses. We do not criticise Senators, and Senators do not criticise us.

Comment on this

I am not criticising anybody.

Comment on this

You are commenting.

Comment on this

I am certainly not criticising the Seanad or the Senator for whom I have respect. What we have to consider is that the Clann na Poblachta Party had the idea that that would be a step in the right direction —to invite such public representatives of the Six Counties as would come in here to come either into the Dáil or into the Seanad, where they could participate in discussions on matters affecting all Ireland. Now, undoubtedly there are practical difficulties in the way. I look on it, as I did at the time it was first advocated, as an excellent gesture to our people in the Six Counties, and as an evidence of our determination to do all that we can to bring an end to Partition.

Comment on this

Why do you call it a stunt, then?

Comment on this

I said that a motion introduced without an opportunity being given to everybody to participate in it was a stunt.

Comment on this

Some of us got no opportunity.

Comment on this
Mr. Coburn

When Deputy Corry was speaking, Deputy Cowan said he was wasting the time of the House and depriving other Deputies of the opportunity of speaking. I have not had an opportunity of speaking yet. I speak very seldom in the House. Deputy Cowan is deliberately wasting the time of this House although he himself objected to another Deputy doing the same thing. I claim the right to speak in the House to-night before it adjourns. I do not want to be listening to a discussion on the rivalry that exists between Deputy Cowan and Deputy MacBride. We are here to discuss the Taoiseach's Estimate, and I am not going to listen to jealousy and envy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Every Deputy has the right to speak if there is time.

Comment on this
Mr. Coburn

Let them go outside and settle it, as I would do, in a manly way.

Comment on this

Deputy Coburn represents a point of view—he represented it to-day in an interjection—a point of view which makes it very difficult, I am quite sure, for himself and Deputy MacBride to lie down together.

Comment on this

The Deputy should get on to some higher plane.

Comment on this
Mr. Coburn

It is all rot.

Comment on this

Deputy Coburn never ran away from anything yet.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Cowan, without interruption.

Comment on this

I am trying to get finished, but unfortunately I am not permitted to do so. I was just on the straight for home when Deputy Coburn intervened.

Comment on this

On the straight?

Comment on this

On the straight for home. That crack from Deputy Morrissey, looking back on his own past, is one that I think might not be made.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should come to the Estimate.

Comment on this

It has been a very straight line for the 29 years that I have been sitting here.

Comment on this

At an earlier stage to-night I just referred to some of the passages, the friendly passages, at arms that passed between Deputy Morrissey and Deputy McGilligan in the past, just the type of thing that Deputy Morrissey is endeavouring to suggest about me now.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not relevant now.

Comment on this

It is not relevant, of course.

Comment on this

It seems to have got home.

Comment on this

Some day I will come into the Dáil with all these tabulated and read them out.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Not to-night.

Comment on this

I want to say in conclusion, as far as these two motions are concerned, that the intention behind them originally, when they were first considered, was a genuine effort to do something practical in the way of ending Partition. As one of the persons who advocated that idea through the country I, naturally, support both resolutions, but the danger I see in this form of resolution is that it might take people away from the fundamental problem that is there, the problem of ending Partition. We can invite people down for 20, 30, 40 or 50 years, but that will not end Partition. There is only one way in which Partition can be ended. It is the way in which the measure of freedom we have in this part of the country was achieved. It was achieved against all types of enemies, both foreign and domestic. When we were engaged in the struggle with the British we were not just fighting the British only. We had to fight on other fronts, and we fought on those other fronts.

Comment on this

What service did you give?

Comment on this

Leave that element out of it. I admit that the service which I gave to this country was very small. It was service given, because it could only be given, when I was less than 17 years of age. Perhaps if I were a little older, I might have been able to give more service, but, as little as it was, I am not ashamed of that service. What I do say is that, just as we had to fight these foreign and domestic enemies, we still have to fight foreign and domestic enemies, and until the youth of this country make up their minds that they want to put an end to Partition, it will not be put an end to, but will be the plaything of politicians who will use it for their own personal interests.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

May I say that it has been decided by the Dáil that the Taoiseach will be called to conclude at 11 o'clock? I hope that Deputies will not misunderstand that.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Pádraic Ó Domhnaill Fine Gael

Ba mhaith liomsa a chur in iúl don Taoiseach go bhfuil Teachtaí anso go mba mhaith leo labhairt ar an Vóta seo. Sé mo bharúil go mba cheart go rachadh an díospóireacht níos faide ná meán-oíche chun seans a thabhairt do na Teachtaí gur mian leo labhairt ar an rún tábhachtach seo atá os comhair na Dála.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Ní féidir liomsa é sin a dhéanamh, pé scéal é.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Proinsias Mac Aogáin Fianna Fáil

Tá sé socraithe.

Comment on this

I do not propose to follow Deputy Cowan along the lines of the speech which he made. Although there is much difference between members of the present Government Front Bench and myself, they will agree with me that it was one of the most nationally damaging speeches made in this House for a long time and one which, I am afraid, might be responsible for bloodshed.

I want to say a few words about the economic position and the Government's policy in that regard. When I came in here this evening, I heard Deputy Corry declaiming about the policy of the previous Government in regard to the production of wheat and I remembered looking not so very long ago at a plan and scheme submitted by Fianna Fáil in July, 1947, to the Committee on European Economic Co-operation. I remembered what they had set out in their scheme, what was sent under the signature of Deputy Smith, as Minister for Agriculture, and later, of Deputy de Valera, as Minister for External Affairs, to Paris to the Committee on European Economic Co-operation as their programme for the production of native wheat in 1950-51, the year which has just passed, the programme of what they intended to do if they had remained as a Government until 1950-51. It was that there would be 100,000 hectares of wheat to yield 144 metric tons last year.

That went under their signatures as their plan and scheme. One hundred thousand hectares are equivalent to 247,000 acres and 144 metric tons to 129,000 tons, as we speak of them. That was their plan and scheme and we heard Deputy Corry to-night chastising Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture for having failed to reach the Fianna Fáil standard. What is the truth? The truth is that, whereas they said they were going to produce 247,000 acres of wheat we had 345,000 acres and where they spoke of 129,000 tons, we had approximately double that amount, 260,000 tons. These figures are vouched for in the statistical survey issued by the Taoiseach's Department to-day. If Deputy Corry is to come in here and purport to discuss the details of agricultural administration on this Estimate, he might at least find out that his details were correct and might be careful to make certain that his own leaders had not let him down and had not furnished facts and figures of which he and the rest of the rank and file were never made aware, because they were to be sent out, as they have been sent out during the past three years, on a campaign of scurrility and abuse on that very subject.

Last night, we heard a pitiable wail from the Minister for Finance, and the Taoiseach to-day, in introducing this Estimate, omitted to make any reference to or to give any review of the economic position as it is and as he found it. Some of us were at considerable loss to understand why that was so, but, quite by accident, some of us discovered the reason. To-day is the 19th of July and yesterday was the 18th, and on yesterday the statistical survey was tabled as well as the report of the Land Commission. The report of the Land Commission was furnished to every Deputy, but the statistical survey was not so furnished. When Deputies went to look for it about 5 o'clock, they could not get copies, but eventually one copy was got in the Library, and afterwards further copies were obtained.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting that I had something to do with that?

Comment on this

Oh, not at all.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that the facts were available to the Taoiseach, if he wanted to introduce them.

Comment on this

I have facts here, independent of those.

Comment on this

The facts were available and they are now here, and this statistical survey, issued by the Director of Statistics, whose office is a section of the Taoiseach's Department, gives the lie, if I may use the word in that context, to the views expressed last night by the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Read page 2.

Comment on this

I propose to read various extracts.

Comment on this

Page 17, for instance.

Comment on this

If the Deputy does not think, when I have dealt with them, that I have covered them all, I will willingly go back to them. It starts off, as any statistical survey must start off, and shows that the national income had increased to a sum of £363,000,000 in 1950, compared with £318,000,000 in 1947 and £158,000,000 in 1938. Undoubtedly, some of that increase is due to increases in prices or a decrease in the value of money whichever way you like to put it, and this survey deals with that very point. It shows quite clearly that the view of the statistical department is that, even allowing for the decrease in the value of money or the increase in prices—it does not matter much how you describe it—there has been an increase of 24 per cent. since 1938. That is the view of the Director of Statistics apparently as shown by this survey—an increase of 24 per cent. over the last year pre-war, allowing for changes in price levels. If Deputy Briscoe considers that that is something which it is desirable for me to bring out, I entirely agree that it is eminently desirable.

One of the next items the survey deals with is the question of personal expenditure. It shows in a table on page 7 a steady increase in personal expenditure, an increase which Deputy Norton mentioned in his speech. He was interrupted by Deputy Colley who adverted—and he was quite right in doing so—to the fact that part of the increase mentioned by Deputy Norton was due again to increases in price levels or a decrease in the value of money. Deputy Colley was perfectly right in that regard. Deputy Norton had only just got the survey in his hand.

If he had had the opportunity I have had since then to study it, he would have seen that the Director of Statistics, who published this brochure —again taking into account the very keen point made by Deputy Colley— has shown in his survey that, taking the price level of 1938, that is, a figure of 146, the figure in 1950 at the 1938 price level was 185, showing a welcome increase in the standard of living of our people. The significant thing about it is that that increase has come cumulatively, progressively and steadily during the three years of the inter-Party Government, for which these figures have been compiled.

We pass on from that—I do not want to exceed the limit of time allowed— to the volume of physical capital formation and we find there that whereas, again taking the 1938 price level, the 1938 figure was £14.2 million, the figure in 1950 was £22.7 million, or very nearly double what it was in 1938 at the then 1938 price level. Of course, if you take into account the existing change in prices, it comes up from £14.2 million to £54,000,000.

We pass to the return made in regard to the production of industrial transportable goods. We find that, taking the 1938 prices as the level and taking the figure there as 100, in 1947 that 100 had only increased to 120—and I am not blaming Fianna Fáil altogether for that—but from 1947 to 1950, in those three years it increased not merely 20 points but 46.4 points up to 166. Therefore, there has been onethird as much again industrial transportable goods produced at the end of the three years of the inter-Party Government as there was at the time when we took over the reins of government in 1948.

We can follow on from that to the figure for gross agricultural output and, incidentally, on that aspect I have not yet seen the Dáil Report naturally of the Minister for Finance's speech last night, and therefore can only go by the newspapers, but it would seem to me from comparing the newspaper report of what Deputy Aiken, the Minister for External Affairs, said, and what I heard Deputy MacEntee, the Minister for Finance, say last night, that they seem to be in two different minds on the figures of agricultural output. Anyway, the facts in regard to that output are set out, and we find that in this table issued by the Taoiseach's Department, we can compare the figures from 1938 up to the present time and we can see exactly what the position is in regard to gross output and net output. In considering the figures for net output we must remember that, during the years of the war— certainly it was not the fault of the people opposite—the war made it impossible to get fertilisers and during those years the land had to be mined. But when you compare, in the table on page 17, the gross output, and deduct from the gross output the allowance, for example, that there is in the year 1942-43 of 18.1, which is all that the farmer could buy, you will see naturally that it was possible to get a net figure of 108, because in fact what was happening was that during those years the farmer was not able to get artificials.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give the figures and not go skipping over them?

Comment on this

I am trying to keep the understanding which was made but which the Deputy broke yesterday. I am trying to keep to it to-day.

Comment on this

Give the index numbers.

Comment on this

I am making my speech according to the understanding made and will not break the bargain as the Deputy broke it shamelessly yesterday and then more shamelessly tried to stand over the breach. What is clear from the figures is that you have 108 as net output in 1942-43 and that net output is arrived at when taking only the figure 18.1 in respect of the purchases of the farmers, because during those years fertilisers were not available, there was no proper agricultural machinery or anything else available for them and, of course, there was bound to be a huge drop because at the time the machinery was going out of date and the land was being mined. What has happened? We find now that we have gone successively up the scale of farmers' purchases. From 18.1, which was the depth to which we sank during the war years—through no fault of Fianna Fáil—we have gone successively up 30, 35, 36, 51, 55, 70, 86 to 97. When one takes into account that these purchases, properly weighted, are able to produce properly a figure that is comparable——

Comment on this

It is not comparable at all.

Comment on this

Make your own speech.

Comment on this

Craw thumper.

Comment on this

——to what was produced in the earlier years, is it any wonder what has happened? It is there in the table for any one who wants to read it intelligently. If the Minister for Finance permits me, I would point out the answer to that question. It shows quite clearly that what has been happening during those years is that the farmer has been going back to the position in which he realises, and is able to realise, that the best bank that the farmer can possibly have is the bank of land in which to sink fertilisers and other weapons of the capital of husbandry. It is perfectly clear from that what the position is.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt Deputy Sweetman, but it was understood that I was to get five minutes to reply.

Comment on this

Very good. I will keep to that understanding. Would the Chair allow me to finish in one sentence first?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a minute off someone else.

Comment on this

I want to refer to the weekly bulletin issued by the Department of External Affairs, for 16th instant, and therefore under the ægis of Deputy Aiken as Minister for External Affairs. There is a comment at the foot describing Ireland and Switzerland as the most prosperous of European countries visited by Mr. Maurice Tobin, the United States Secretary of Labour, who said:—

"Each time I come to Ireland, I see remarkable strides in the economic wellbeing of the country, but this time she seems to have advanced beyond all expectations."

Mr. MacBride and Mr. O'Donnell rose.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is in a difficulty. There was an agreement here that the Taoiseach would be called on at 11 o'clock. There was also an agreement that Deputy MacBride would get five minutes.

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman stole them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I was of the opinion that Deputy MacBride would ask to speak at five minutes to 11. Deputy O'Donnell has been seeking for some time to speak. I do not know what the House intends.

Comment on this
Mr. Coburn

Am I not entitled to get a few minutes? I made no agreement.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Could we have half an hour more?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The House made an Order, which I am not entitled to break. Deputy MacBride was to be allowed five minutes.

Comment on this
Mr. Coburn

There was an agreement made last night in connection with the motions and there was no time given. I think the Minister for Finance persevered in refusing time.

Comment on this

Does the Taoiseach require a full hour?

Comment on this

I will give five minutes, provided it is not wasted, off my time.

Comment on this

As a Northern Ireland Deputy of this House wishing to discuss the methods of ending Partition, I vehemently protest against the method in which these motions have been treated to-day. The Taoiseach has told us that he had no policy for ending Partition, but Deputy MacBride has put before this House methods of ending Partition and we are being strangled in the discussion of them.

Comment on this

My difficulty is that I have not heard any arguments from the Government Benches against my two motions. I have not heard one single Minister give any reason against these motions. I am sorry that the motions had to be discussed in this somewhat hurried atmosphere. I would have liked that we should have had a much longer time to discuss them. As I indicated when I proposed the motions, it was my desire that this matter should be considered objectively by both sides of the House. Frankly, the views I expressed this morning are confirmed by the discussion that has taken place in the House. I do not think that there is any valid reason against these motions. I think it is largely a question of prejudice—possibly prejudice is a strong word—but largely a question of minds having been set against a proposal of this nature for a certain length of time. That objection, if you like, was reached in different circumstances. I hope that it will be possible, in the course of a discussion in this House, to review the matter objectively.

I am prepared, at this stage, not to press these motions to a division if I get any indication from the Taoiseach that he is prepared to review the position objectively and afford this House an opportunity of discussing the matter at an early date next Session, giving us full time and opportunity to consider them fully. These are motions which I would like to see passed unanimously by the House.

Another course that I would suggest to the Taoiseach—and it would enable me not to ask the House to divide on these motions, if he is prepared to tell me or tell the House whether he is willing to consider it—is that we should have a referendum on this question. It seems to me an ideal question upon which to seek the views of the Irish people. It would be an easy matter upon which to have a referendum. If the Taoiseach gives me any indication, in the course of his reply, that he is prepared to consider either of these propositions, then I will not press these motions to a division. If he does not, I am afraid I will have to ask the House to divide on them.

Comment on this

On the question of Partition, which is, as everybody admits, the most serious problem, from a national point of view, that we have to deal with, no Government that is representative of the Irish people would fail to give the fullest possible consideration to any proposal that holds out any promise of putting an end to that situation. Naturally, when motions of this sort come up—and I have, in regard to that particular one, considered it time out of mind—one has to ask oneself the serious question: "Will it or will it not help towards solving Partition?" The decision that I have come to is precisely the decision that was reached by the Head of the recent Government, and that is, that it will not. I came to that conclusion many years ago. It is not that my mind is set on the matter. If conditions change or a new situation arises in which it is clear that this would be a step forward, then I would be all in favour of it.

Deputy MacBride says that no argument has been put forward against it. It was the duty of the mover of the motions, I suggest, to put arguments in favour of it and show clearly that it was going to be a step in the right direction. He has not done that. I thought, in answer to a remark by Deputy O'Donnell, that a great deal of to-day's discussion would have ranged round that question. From what I have heard myself and from information as to what transpired afterwards it did not range around that question. Why? Because there was not made by the mover of it any positive suggestion or positive argument that was going to help towards solving our problem.

Comment on this

Surely that is not correct.

Comment on this

That is the position. One of the arguments was that in 1919 the First Dáil was open to all the elected representatives of the Irish nation. That was quite right in the circumstances of that particular time, but a lot of things have happened since, either fortunately or unfortunately, according to the way you look at it, and we have a situation to-day in which this part of the country is completely free, with a functioning Parliament, with a representative democracy in which every member here represents a particular area in our country. That is a fact and it is that which has made it quite impracticable from the point of view of dealing with the representatives of the North here as we would have dealt with them in that particular area because we did try to function and to exercise our de jure jurisdiction not in this part of the country alone but over the country as a whole. The position now is that we are not in a position in which we can exercise jurisdiction over that area.

Comment on this

De jure?

Comment on this

De facto. We are not in a position to do so and as far as the Constitution goes, we are limited in jurisdiction pending the reintegration of the country with the area of the Twenty-Six Counties.

Comment on this

But we claim jurisdiction over the whole country.

Comment on this

If claiming was going to solve it, then there was not any difficulty. The fact is to make good our claim. How are we, by a gesture of this sort, to make good our claim? If we were able, for instance, when we had representatives of the majority of the people of Tyrone, Fermanagh, South Down and Armagh here to say: "The people whom you represent will be effectively under our jurisdiction", there would be a great deal to be said for the introduction of these motions.

Everybody knows that with a heart and a half we who represent the people of the Twenty-Six Counties would welcome the people from the North in here in a united Parliament. There is no question of any division of opinion between Parties or in the nation as a whole. I am perfectly certain that to-morrow, without any arguments of any kind, at least 90 per cent. or nearer 99 per cent. of the people in this part of the country would vote for the unity of our country if it were put to them.

How does the introduction here of members from the North help that? At first the proposal was that they be allowed to vote here but that was ruled out because of constitutional difficulty. As the Leader of the Opposition, however, quite rightly says, if that was all that was in the way we could easily get rid of it because the Constitution could be amended and any laws which follow it could also be amended so the constitutional difficulty would not be a difficulty.

The difficulty would be that we would have people here able to cast their votes on the matters that come up for decision with a feeling very different from that of the other members. They would be in a specially privileged position because the results of their action would not appear in the form of taxation or burdens on the people of the area they represented. They would be able to get neither advantages nor disadvantages for those people seeing that our jurisdiction does not extend over that area. For that reason, we could not ask them to come in here. If they did, they would be a very short time here when they would probably take sides and that would mean that certain antagonisms would be created.

At the present time we are all unanimous in desiring to bring about the end of Partition, and if any way of doing it was shown you would not need a national Government to do it. If anybody on any of these benches were able to show to-morrow a pactical way by which Partition could be ended he would be the Leader of the Government without any delay because that would be a sufficiently important political matter to give the leadership to him and to those who supported him. It is because nobody has been able to point out a definite practical way by which one would ensure that Partition would be ended that the difficulty arises, and that difficulty arises with the people in the North. That is why they are very often at sixes and sevens themselves regarding what policy they should pursue. If they were represented here they would create antagonisms and difficulties between themselves too.

I remember that after the Treaty I suggested to the people in the North not to enter the Northern Parliament because I thought at that particular time that the national attitude towards it could be so expressed. In a very short time the people up there showed that they did not agree with that. They wanted a different policy. There had been waverings to and fro over a period of years and arguments on different sides as to whether or not they should be represented in the Northern Parliament. Their coming down here would raise that question again and again because here we have a republican position while in the North they have quite a different one so they would create antagonisms amongst themselves. This proposal if it were carried out would create antagonisms and would also in a very short time prove its own futility. People would ask themselves the question: what is the use of sending down members to Dublin if those members are not able to affect our daily lives or bring about the end of Partition? So in the full sense of full membership we can see at once that it does not lead us to the goal at which we are aiming.

It would be almost as bad if they were to come here simply with the right of audience. When will that right be exercised? People can by arguments and speeches create antagonism almost as effectively as by their votes. Again, antagonisms would be created. We have nothing to gain. The only argument I saw put forward was that there would be a closer relationship between the people here and the people of the Six Counties.

I think that the proposal of the Leader of the Opposition was one with which I would be willing to agree. If you could get up there a body representative of the attitude of those who are against the partition of the country and if they appointed a small executive group it would be quite easy for a Government group to meet them and consult with them regularly. I would be agreeable to that and support that proposition if I were on the opposite benches and the former Taoiseach were speaking from these. I think it a more practical way of bringing about consultation, co-operation and understanding than the other, though I do say that I have not any great hopes of what would be secured by it, because what would be very likely to happen in circumstances of that kind would be that more danger of misunderstanding than good would be derived. The problem being so difficult to solve, the people in the North suffering as they are suffering, our being unable to bring them the practical aid, they would hold that we are not doing what they think we should do and what we believe it is not possible for us to do.

Long before this matter arose, before I was in the Government at all, I suggested to the people in the North that the first thing to do was that they themselves should decide on a policy up there and get a body which would be fairly representative of their views and co-operate with such bodies as there were down here. I was asked to establish the Fianna Fáil Party in that part of the country but I refrained from doing it because again I believed that it would lead to antagonisms. Instead of co-operating, our political difficulties would be reflected up there and their political difficulties would be reflected down here. Instead of getting closer together we would get further apart and more divided. We are at present as unanimous on the question as it is possible for a body of representatives to be. I have not the slightest doubt that if I or somebody on the opposite benches came in to-morrow with any practical proposition to put an end to Partition, I or he would get the wholehearted support of everybody in the House.

I do not think I can go any further with the question or with the argument in connection with it to show my view. All I can say is that having deliberately considered it in the same way as the Leader of the Opposition apparently did when he was in office, I see no progress to be made by adopting the proposals in the resolution, and therefore if it were put to a vote we would have to vote against it. I say at the same time that at no time will we close our minds to any suggestion whatsoever, no matter from whom it comes, that would help us on our way to end that evil. If I may come on to the other part——

Comment on this

May I ask, before the Taoiseach passes on, does he reject the idea of a plebiscite?

Comment on this

With regard to a plebiscite, the Deputy knows full well that we have no machinery, even by the Constitution, as I understand it.

Comment on this

We could.

Comment on this

I do not think so. I think the Deputy understands that.

Comment on this

Yes, we could.

Comment on this

I will give the Deputy a minute or two. This is an important question and I am anxious about it.

Comment on this

It could be done under the Constitution if the Taoiseach introduced a Bill and if the Bill was referred to the people.

Comment on this

No. There are only two cases, as far as I know, under the Constitution in which you can have a referendum. The first is on a constitutional amendment and the second is when a Bill is going through the Dáil and there is objection by a majority of the Seanad, and one-third of the representatives of the Dáil sign a petition to the President to have the Bill referred to the people. I cannot see how one could manoeuvre to bring a Bill to the President to try to get him to order a referendum. It would involve more manoeuvring than I am capable of.

Comment on this

It could easily be done. In any event, the Dáil would have power to enact a Bill ordering the holding of a referendum on this issue.

Comment on this

The character of the Bill is prescribed.

Comment on this

The Deputy will find that it is not possible.

Comment on this

If it is possible, will the Taoiseach agree to it? That is a question which I am asking.

Comment on this

If I said, first of all, that I can have a referendum I would remind the Deputy that the answer of the man who said he had no guns, when giving some reasons for not firing a salute, was regarded as sufficient.

Comment on this

I believe we can have a referendum.

Comment on this

When I am satisfied that it will no longer be a hypothetical question, it will be a real question then.

Comment on this

Surely the Taoiseach can have a referendum if he wants it?

Comment on this

The Deputy has had his five minutes.

Comment on this

I think that this is a matter which we ought to discuss as fully and as calmly as we can. I am satisfied, and those with whom I have discussed the matter are equally satisfied, that there is nothing of advantage in this motion.

I want to deal now with the other matter—the statement that was made by Deputy Sweetman. I may be wrong but I took him to suggest that, somehow, I was responsible for preventing the circulation of the statistical survey.

Comment on this

I think the Taoiseach misunderstood that point. Deputy Sweetman did not mean to reflect on the Taoiseach in any way. He was making the point that though the stuff was there the Taoiseach did not use it.

Comment on this

There is the possibility that what he wanted to say was that I did not need to go over the survey. I had the stuff.

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman's point was that you were provided with the survey and why did you not quote from it?

Comment on this

Because I had another survey, which was made independently, to deal with it. My attitude was that when we had previous debates here, one of the rules had been that the Opposition would put up certain questions to be considered and that generally led to a very unsatisfactory debate. I was quite pleased when the former Taoiseach introduced a different system and I was between two minds as to whether I would deal with the survey or not. Because we had two motions to-day which I thought were going to be the main substance of the debate, I felt that there was no use in mixing all these things up. With regard to the suggestion of the Leader of the Opposition that I did not do so because it would seem to help the claims that are being made by the previous Administration, I do not think it bears that out at all. It is very easy to take certain dates and use them as reference dates. The year 1938 is a very nice date to take for a number of things.

Comment on this

It is the date your Director of Statistics took.

Comment on this

What about later dates—1947 and 1948? When it suited Deputy Dillon, he was very fond of taking these dates. When we talk about increasing the national income, I think it is interesting to trace it up a bit and not suddenly start at 1938 and leave a gap and forget the changes that took place from the end of the war on. Anybody who studies these statistics carefully and draws a graph will realise at once that the rate of progress which was evident from 1947 to 1948 was not continued. That is what emerges from these statistics, but it will not emerge from them if you conveniently skip from 1938 to 1950.

Comment on this

You chose 1938. We did not.

Comment on this

I did not choose it. I was interpreting the statistics here this evening, like Deputy Sweetman.

Comment on this

You did.

Comment on this

The fact is that if you take the national income, for which the figure in 1938 was, I think, 158——

Comment on this

He does not understand me.

Comment on this

——it is now quoted as 363. It is very convenient to take 158 and 363. But if you continue it and see what it was when we left office you will see that it was 318—so that part of the difference between 158 and 318 has to be accounted for in our time. I am not going to take away from the fact that the increase has been continued. I only say that the statistics prove that the rate of increase has not been continued.

Comment on this

That is a matter of opinion.

Comment on this

It is a matter of statistics.

Comment on this

This is a question of the proper interpretation of statistics.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The proper interpretation—not the interpretation arrived at by taking out a figure here and another figure there and choosing the figures at random. Any impartial investigator who checks that survey will recognise that, from the time the war ended until we left office, there was a rapid rate of increase and that that rate of increase has not even been continued.

Comment on this

Bosh.

Comment on this

It is not bosh, it is a fact. Take, for instance, the increase in employment in industrial production. If you look at these figures again what do you find? You find that there was a rapid increase from 1931 to 1938. Then there was a standstill and in some cases a diminution during the war. At the end of the war we reached a position that was practically the same as the position in 1938. Then it began to rise rapidly, but that rate of increase during the period from the end of the war until we left office has not continued.

Comment on this

Bosh. It is untrue.

Comment on this

It is not untrue. It is a fact.

Comment on this

Page 24.

Comment on this

I have the figures here before me.

Comment on this

From which survey?

Comment on this

I have the figures here from the statistics department which is responsible for them—and I got independently a survey for myself.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Taoiseach must be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

The former Taoiseach said, and I agree with him, that the officers of that department are in an independent position—and the information they would give me would eventually be passed on to the public, just as it was in his case.

Comment on this

Nobody is questioning that.

Comment on this

Wait and see, and at least do not start making suggestions until you discover if the figures are in any way different from your figures. We can question them. I have figures here showing the index of industrial employment in all industries and services. Take 1926, which was the period of the first industrial survey, as 100. The employment in the year 1926 was 100. It became 108 in 1931. By 1938 it was 162. Then, during the war period, there was a change. However, it was back in 1946, slightly above what it was in 1938. It went up in 1947 from 163 to 179, that is, it went up 16 points. The next year it went from 179 to 193 and that represents only 14 points up. In 1949 it went up to 201 and in 1950 to 214. These figures bear out the fact that the rate of increase was greatest from the end of the war until we left office.

Comment on this

The figure for 1950 is 220.

Comment on this

I am giving the figures for 1950 that I have got—and they were supplied to me.

Comment on this

Are these for employment?

Comment on this

These figures were supplied to me by the statistics department.

Comment on this

For employment?

Comment on this

They were given to me as an index of industrial employment, taking the year 1926 as 100.

Comment on this

The figure for 1950 is——

Comment on this

The Taoiseach's figure is an index figure.

Comment on this

I am using an index figure.

Comment on this

Because it suits your case.

Comment on this

It is not a question of suiting. It is the simplest way of relating the results of one year with another year, taking 100 at a certain date. One can then get percentages very quickly from it.

Comment on this

And you are after eating the face off me for taking 1938 for that purpose as a basic year.

Comment on this

But I am giving you figures with which I had nothing to do and in relation to which I made no suggestion or gave no orders. They were given to me and I am simply reading them. The year 1926 was chosen because it was the first year in which there was an industrial production survey. As far as the volume of production is concerned, if one takes 1926 again as 100, because it is very easy to relate one to the other once you have a base and it requires very little arithmetic to change from that to another base in order to check whether I am right or wrong, one finds somewhat remarkably that 1938 is 162, or very nearly the same, so that employment and production went up step by step almost equally. But in 1946 it was 165; in 1947 it was 184; in 1948 it was 208; in 1949 it was 237 and in 1950 it was 258. Those are the figures and they prove, I think, my contention. The interesting thing about the two figures taken together is the fact that the volume of production increased more rapidly than employment; in other words productivity, possibly through the use of machinery or something else—I am not quite sure of what the actual reason is——

Comment on this

Greater efficiency.

Comment on this

Productivity, using the word to show the relation between production and employment—that is the amount of power per man so to speak—has increased. Both of them are creditable. I do not say that the former Government is not entitled to its share of the credit, but let it be content with its own share. Let it not try to grab all and pretend that all this happened overnight by some miracle. It was a continuous progress as a result of the deliberate policy we initiated. When Deputies yonder try to suggest that we are stealing their policy, with far more truth can it be said that they stole ours and we have gone back now to continue from where we left off.

Comment on this

All very laughable after what I went through for three years.

Comment on this

I indicated quite clearly this morning what the general policy is. It is not the policy revealed by these figures. That used to be the policy of the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government. Our policy is the policy that we initiated and started in our early years, a policy that was supported by Labour.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The Shannon scheme and the sugar beet factories.

Comment on this

If you have been converted by Labour, good luck to Labour for doing that.

Comment on this

You are worse than a child.

Comment on this

I am sorry I could not speak about emigration.

Comment on this

You have plenty of time. Cheer up. Who is stopping you?

Comment on this

Another day.

Comment on this