Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–178 of 562. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
The Tánaiste told us to-day, Sir, about the extra cost of wheat, and he pointed out that the extra price payable for home-grown wheat would impinge upon the subsidy next autumn. He did not go on to tell the House that freight rates on foreign wheat have in the last month fallen by 50 per cent. Tramp shipping rates from the Atlantic coast and the Pacific coast and from Australian ports have fallen by 50 per cent.
Comment on this
Might I direct the attention of the House to the fact that the Minister has his back turned to the Chair, which is discourteous in my opinion?
Comment on this
Does not the Tánaiste think that if he directs the attention of the House to an element in the price of wheat which he expects will raise the price, he has a corresponding duty to tell the House of an element in the price of wheat which he knows brings down the price? He does know that because the price of imported wheat is fixed by an international wheat agreement made by our Government at a maximum of $1.80. The only element in the price of foreign wheat that fluctuates is freight. Freight rates went up by more than 100 per cent. when the inter-Party Government was responsible for the bread supply of this country. They have fallen by 50 per cent. in the last month.
Did any Deputy note the explanation of why bread rationing is coming to an end? "Because," says the Minister, "by removing a part of the subsidy on bread, we brought the price of flour and bread above the price of animal feeding stuffs. I believe the gap will widen as the year goes on." What does that mean? What did that mean? Did it mean the price of bread was going up still more or could it mean that the Minister for Agriculture had promised to bring down the price of feeding stuffs? If he has, Deputy Blaney says that there ought to be enough feeding stuffs produced in Ireland this year for all the needs that may arise. Is the gap going to be widened by bringing down their price? I have no doubt that the vigilant and independent eye of Deputy Cogan is fixed upon the Minister. He will want to know——
Comment on this
——what is going to happen feeding stuffs to come down? Is this the compensatory tax on the farmers of this country? Is this the way of ensuring that the Minister for Agriculture does his part to ensure that the peasants will not eat too much or buy radios?
Comment on this
The Deputy had to be prompted. He did not know that until Deputy O'Sullivan told him.
Comment on this
Oh, there is one blessed feature about Deputy Cogan. We need never worry ourselves when the division bell rings. He will be respectful and respectable in the Fianna Fáil Lobby.
Comment on this
Oh, they will not do that but they will keep him in the Lobby until the general election in June 12 months.
Comment on this
I suppose Deputy Cogan has not got much to do with the Resolution right enough. The Tánaiste practised the age-old hoary device—it is unworthy of him as he is too resourceful a gambler—of challenging the Opposition to show him the place where economies might be made or how taxation might be reduced.
I will show him, after a cursory perusal of the Book of Estimates, two items which are manifestly, openly and incontrovertibly fraudulent. There is in the Estimate for Agriculture a subhead provided for the loan of £400,000 sterling to Comhlucht Siúicre Éireann for the purchase of superphosphate to be sold to the farmers within the financial year. The money must come back into the Exchequer.
There is a provision for £300,000 for the lime subsidy, which is to be financed ultimately out of the Grant Counterpart Fund, which is at present lying in the Central Bank. Technically, the Minister may cover himself by an Appropriation-in-Aid or an extra Exchequer receipt in respect of the £400,000, but there is no corresponding receipt in respect of the £300,000 for the lime subsidy. He has not told this House that he abandons the American Grant Counterpart Fund at present. He cannot touch it on account of their own laches in completing the necessary formalities, formalities that should have been completed before the 8th June. I believe they will get it owing to the friendship of the American Government.
Our people are going to be taxed this year to produce the surplus which the Tánaiste intends to employ in his election campaign in June 12 months, after the Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, is in the ash can with Deputy Dr. Ryan, the present Minister for Health. It is part of the gamble that the present Minister for Finance shall be party to the rotten political confidence trick that is going to throw many into unemployment and close down small businesses during the next 12 months, so that the present Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, will have the wherewithal to invite the electorate of this country to make the same bargain with him next June that he has successfully negotiated with the dance hall proprietors this March.
"Everybody," says the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, "clamours for social services, but they cannot have social services if they do not pay for them. Look all around the world and you will see that the social services have increased. Yet in Ireland the prices of tobacco, beer, spirits and petrol are lower than anywhere else in Europe."
I wonder did Deputy Lemass, the Tánaiste, or the Minister for Finance ever hear the name of a man called Eisenhower, popularly known as "Ike"? Did they ever hear of an institution called N.A.T.O.? Do they know what General Eisenhower and N.A.T.O. have been interesting themselves in—tanks, guns, armaments and aeroplanes for the defence of Europe? Do they know that the tanks, guns and the planes cost money? Do they know that Ireland has no charge on its Exchequer in respect of that?
Is it not queer that in Europe these high taxes finance N.A.T.O. but it is only in Ireland that these high taxes, plus the reduction of the subsidies on all foodstuffs, go to furnish forth a Social Security Bill which does not levy 3/6 a week on the poor working man, like William Norton's criminal Bill, but only increases his subscription by 5d. a week but which raises his subscription by from 8/- to 10/- a week in the Budget introduced the day after? Is it not funny that all over Europe tobacco, beer and spirits and all the rest have grown dearer to purchase guns and ammunition — they have better social services, according to the Tánaiste, than we have in Ireland or are about to have—but in Ireland all this extra money is needed simply for the social services that our petulant people keep on crying for?
Are Fianna Fáil Deputies so blind as not to see through that? I think they see through it. I think they have been sold the grandest gamble that a politician ever staged in Ireland. I think that the Tánaiste's game is like that of the ragged, down-at-heel man who came up to Joe Lee, the Scots bookmaker, at Aintree and asked him what odds he was laying on a horse. Then he said: "How much will you take?""Any sum you can lay," said Joe Lee, and the ragged man handed him up £10,000. The horse won and Joe Lee paid him. Somebody asked Joe Lee what was the explanation of that and he said: "It is very simple. That was the last time he could safely put his hand in the till, and it was either £330,000 for him or the Mersey."
Now, as certain as we are in this House, the Tánaiste's game is this. If he can pull off the gamble of holding that motley collection together for the next 12 months, he thinks he has backed a red-hot outsider and that he will come steaming down the electoral Grand National course at 33 to 1, scattering largesse wherever he goes, while the four hopeful jockeys are decking themselves out in red, white and blue to come trotting after him. That is lots of fun for the Tánaiste and the passengers. But I am thinking of the small business men in this country who will have to shut their doors. I am thinking of the individuals who will have to take single tickets to the armament factories and the mines because it is much more important to earn sterling so that our invisible exports will be enhanced to maintain the balance of trade than it is to multiply unduly ambitious peasants on the insufficient resources of this island. Remember, that is the Treasury point of view— there are too many of them and they eat too much. Public finance is a science and one of the difficulties about indicting at the moment what this Fianna Fáil Government have done is that public finance is a science which a good many people fail to comprehend.
We made up our mind as a Government quite deliberately three and a half years ago that it was possible to develop the resources of this country so as to raise the national income to a level which would justify the standard of living our people now enjoy and to keep it there. We had strong advice to the effect that we were attempting the impossible, that our people aspired to too high a standard of living and there was no solution except to bring down the standard of living within the capacity of the people to bear. We heard that advice with respect and rejected it and proceeded to build up a programme of capital development, taking what people might call the risk that that investment in Ireland and our people would in time yield a profit amply sufficient to sustain the standard of living which we thought was the fair and minimum standard that the people of this country should enjoy. To do that we had to make provision for the current annual recurring expenses and for the money we intended to borrow each year for capital development.
We brought before this House for the first time in its history a Book of Estimates which stated on the cover, before there was any question of a Budget discussion: "This is what we intend to borrow." Now what happened? We were held up before the country as rogues, twisters, deceivers and people who borrowed to balance the Budget. This little man here had the impudence to stump the country and say that his sense of financial rectitude was all upset because of this wicked departure from orthodoxy. I respected the poor little man and said: "He is silly and narrow-minded and vain and maybe he believes it, and you have to respect him for stumping the country and stating what he believes, even if you despise his intellect." But he comes trotting in yesterday to announce, having denounced this procedure up and down the country, that he had changed his mind. He got his mind changed for him. The ball and chain that accompanied him to Downing Street rattled and he was told: "Brother, I am boss now. You toe the line or go out now, whether it suits you to go or not." It did not suit him to go. Deputy McGrath, of Cork, was recently sent by Deputy Corry for his visit to Canossa. The Tánaiste has sent the Minister for Finance, naked except for his hair shirt, to the Canossa of his own Budget statement.
Look at his Book of Estimates. It is adorned with eloquent protestations that to have recourse to the method employed in the previous Book of Estimates would degrade the noble citizen who now defends our finances. The ball and chain have rattled since that document was circulated and the Minister came in yesterday to ask our pardon for having failed to present the Book of Estimates in the correct form, and he told us that that notwithstanding he proposes to proceed on exactly the same basis upon which his predecessor had proceeded. Have they no shame, the Deputies who are sitting behind him? Do you not think that a man who can change like that, who can be kicked about like that, do you not think that it is time that he quit being Minister for Finance? Next to the Taoiseach, he is supposed to be the principal adviser to the Government of the day. Can you appreciate an adviser of the Government of the day who gets kicked all around the oblong table every time the Tánaiste goes out to find someone he wants to kick around?
We built up, and I want to tell the House how it was created, a credit creation device to serve this House and the country for the next ten years, and it consisted of the small savings of our people; the annual national loans that we estimated we needed, and for which we could get support; the Marshall Counterpart Fund, the Central Bank's Report, and behind that by the reserves of the joint stock banks, and behind that again, a judicious section of the currency reserve. These, in fact, provided ample reserves for the next ten years, and we bound ourselves, under the 1950 Finance Act, to charge on the Central Fund for 30 years an annual annuity every year to amortise in 30 years every penny borrowed in that way.
Comment on this
And you were charging to the next generation what you should have paid in the last three years.
Comment on this
I cannot see that, in 30 years' time, you have the next generation. Many of the Deputies here will still be around in that time, and the Minister and I will possibly still be here, though we may be hobbling a little. I would be prepared to pay a tax in 30 years' time on my own and the Minister's bath-chairs as a contribution to the building up of this country instead of accumulating mythical assets in the sterling area.
That is the difference. We had provided so that we could amortise each year's borrowing in 30 years. Is that passing it on to the next generation? I think it is not; I think it is bearing it in this generation.
What does this man do? He came into office in the month of June, and in one six months he spent the whole of £28,000,000 Counterpart Fund. Observe our plan when we decided to borrow. We first went to the small lender; we then went to the market and took off the consumer market of this country as much purchasing power as we could induce the people to subscribe to a national loan, in so far as that was wanted for the development programme. If we found that we did not get as much in this way as we wanted, we then borrowed from the joint stock banks, and then, if we required to do it, we would come into the House to use the guarantee of the currency reserve. By the Minister's action, the Marshall Counterpart Fund, which was the first reserve, has now gone.
Comment on this
The Agricultural Credit Corporation have announced to-day that they have increased their rates by 1 per cent. to 6 per cent.
Comment on this
That is the damnable position into which we have got to-day. We had the position that if we decided to borrow £10,000,000 or £14,000,000 we could go and get that and it was our job to advise the House against getting too much in any given year lest it would upset the balance of our economic capital but this House is no longer the person to decide. If this House wants to borrow the £15,000,000 to bridge the present gap where is it to get it? The only place you could get it is from the banks, the moneylenders, and they will tell you what you have to pay and how and when you will pay it and whether or not you will get it. We have no resources left to us whereby we could say to them "do not get tough because we can continue without you". When the bank rate was raised in England that issue was raised and the Minister then told us that there was no use in trying to restrain the joint stock banks because the money would go to the English banks and for that reason he had to give way. That is all being done to advance this Party political racket to make Deputy Lemass the Taoiseach when Deputy de Valera retires. Is it not criminal to have done that especially damaging act? I am convinced, and saying this carries no political advantage, that if we were returned to power to-morrow we would not be able to repair the damage that has now been done to this country. Deputies should not laugh lightly when I say that I am making that statement as an ex-Minister of the Government. Deputy Morrissey and myself and the others were elected members of the Irish Government by the people, and it would become Deputies of this House to respect the position of a Cabinet Minister even if they do not have respect for the person himself. I am proud to have been a Minister of an Irish Government, and Deputies should not grovel at the feet of any British Minister or French Minister or Greek Minister or Sudanese Minister, and then presume to despise an Irish Minister. As I have said, I do not believe that, if we got back to power to-morrow, we could repair the damage which has been done to our financial structure. That is one of the most tragic features of this whole business.
How is it that when discussing the balance of trade in the 17 pages devoted to it in his statement the Minister, when discussing exports in the context of balance of payment, deals not with volume but with prices? I want to direct the attention of Dáil Éireann to this. There was reference in this Budget statement to the balance of visible trade, January and February. Did the Deputies in this House notice this interesting fact, that we have not got these returns yet; they have not been published? It is said here they are not reassuring.
What are the facts? The value of our imports in January, 1952, are 44 per cent. higher than the value of our exports in January, 1951. The value of our exports in February, 1952, are 40 per cent. higher than the value of our exports in February, 1951. Why then is the adverse trade balance on visible trade the same? Because the imports being brought in nine months after the Fianna Fáil Government took office are substantially greater than they were this time 12 months ago. If our blood is to be made run cold with the imminence of disaster, may we not legitimately inquire of the Minister who has cried havoc for the last six months: If you believe that that is the method of putting right what is wrong, why let the imports run at their present level? We never advanced the doctrine that you could correct the economic problems of this country by cutting down imports. Our thesis was: Draw surplus purchasing power off the market by prudently administering national loans, raise the production and exports, and restore equilibrium by raising the value of our exports, visible and invisible, and allowing your imports to meet the requirements of your people as they develop, and control price inflation which must supervene if you allow excess income to chase diminished supplies of goods.
If the Minister for Finance's policy is physically to check imports why does he not do it? Why does he conceal from the House that the increasingly adverse trade balance is not due to stability in our exports, but to an increase in our imports representing the 44 per cent. increase in our exports in January and 40 per cent. in February.
I want to remind the House that the Minister for Industry and Commerce— the Tánaiste—has given us the official Government view on whether we are dealing with a problem of inflation or deflation. Speaking at column 241, Volume 130, No. 2, he said:—
"Deputies opposite have been talking about the present situation in which we are and in which other countries also find themselves, without reference to the changes that are taking place right now and the changes that have taken place during the past month or six weeks. There have been critical changes in the whole world situation in the past few weeks. Almost every country in the world which, like ourselves, was concerned at the beginning of this year or towards the end of last year, at the danger of the inflationary forces, which were then active, getting out of hand, are now no longer worried, any more than we are, about the danger of runaway inflation. They are beginning to get much more worried about the possibility of deflation, of the downward spiral beginning to move."
At column 246, he said:—
"These dangers are quite considerable. I will concede—and Deputies can make any point they like out of it—that right now they look to be very different in character than what they looked 12 months, or even six months ago, but they are not less serious in their significance."
The Tánaiste, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking last week, warned us that he is getting apprehensive about the danger of deflationary forces beginning to operate which may multiply unemployment and expedite emigration from this country. The Minister for Finance yesterday said at page 5 of the Budget statement: "The Government cannot force consumers to buy." At page 6, he said: "Provided the price factor is favourable, trade should revive as soon as the individual need for more consumer goods in the form of clothes and footwear becomes significant and expresses itself in a resumption of individual purchasing."
Take the case of a woman who has four children and a husband to provide for. She makes up her mind to-morrow that the time has come to buy two pairs of shoes for the children, and she goes out with £2 to make the purchase. She finds that the impact of the increased charges made upon her as a result of this Budget will leave her nothing out of the £2 wherewith to buy the shoes. Is the hopeful development envisaged by the Minister for Finance going to take place? No. The only difference is that a month ago the woman had the money but she thought she would not get value for it if she went to buy the shoes; she waited till she would get better value for the money. To-morrow she will not have that question to resolve at all. She need not worry because, whether the shoes are dear or cheap, she has not the money to buy either and she need not even go to price them. From the point of view of inflation or deflation, employment or unemployment, it does not matter what reason prevents that woman from going to that shoe shop; the shoes still stay on the shoemaker's shelf and the man who hopes to make their replacement can leave for Bootle, Liverpool, Birmingham, the armament factory and the mine. No doubt Mr. Butler and the Minister for Fuel will be glad of the opportunity to announce amidst murmurs of approval from the Tory Benches that the problem of labour in the mines is not so stringent as it was heretofore. Doubtless the Minister for Finance will be proportionately gratified by the murmurs of approval.
Some people may doubt that there was ever a Treasury view expressed in this country that our people ate too much. On page 11 of the Minister's oration yesterday, the following statement is made:
"In other words, as a result of the excessive increases in consumption in recent years and the corresponding diminution in saving, the additions to internal assets which have taken place—mainly, I may say, in nonproductive capital such as houses and hospitals—have been effected largely by drawing on our external investments and by incurring external liabilities."
External liabilities? What did he mean by that? He meant to fool the poor silly-billies who sit behind him into believing that the Marshall Loan represented a net debt on our people that there was no asset in hand to meet. And, God help them, they believed it.
Deputy Cowan said that the Minister's speech should not be circulated in manuscript form. I do not agree with that because I think it is a most valuable document. The Minister for Industry and Commerce contributed to our deliberations to-day. He went all pious in the middle of his speech. I do not know if the Deputies noticed that he suddenly assumed the mantle of Fr. Mathew and of the Pioneer Association and said that percipient Deputies who could not divorce from their minds the hidden purpose in the Minister for Finance's action to contribute to the uplift of the public morality by the taxes he proposed to impose on beer and spirits, of which he felt too much were being consumed in Ireland. He said that, apart from fiscal reasons, there were certain moral considerations which would commend this tax to the far-sighted moral citizens of Ireland. He must have forgotten what was in the manuscript because the Minister for Finance was assuring us of special concessions to the smaller brewer which were designed to ensure that he would brew as he never brewed before.
Yesterday was spent in hearing the Minister for Finance say "No" and the Minister for Industry and Commerce say "Yes," but the Minister for Finance was determined to have the last word and said: "You will get no undertaking from me," as much as to say: "Whatever the other yob gives you." Are we to look upon the Minister for Finance as a Fr. Mathew, as reported by the Tánaiste, or as a cunning villain trying to promote the consumption of alcohol amongst the weakly Irish? "You pays your money and you takes your choice." Those who want to think that he has the motives reported by the Tánaiste will look upon him as the spiritual child of Fr. Mathew, but those who think about him as I do will see in him the offspring of "Demon Rum."
I will now quote from page 51 of the Budget statement in which the Minister says: "I am obliged to forgo the customary £300,000 because of the need for increased outlay on the roads, a need so great as to render inevitable an increase in rates of motor taxation in the near future." I understand that in England they have reduced the taxation on motor cars to a level £12 10s. 0d. I also understand that that country is on the verge of collapse, fiscally and economically. We are the largest creditor nation in Europe. Per head of the population we are the largest creditor nation in the world at the moment.
We are going to raise the taxation on motor cars, having already put 4d. on the gallon of petrol to be company for the other 2d. which we put on it last year, and which caused our versatile Minister for Finance to lament.
Now comes the crowning glory of the Budget. In effect, tea has been taxed, butter has been taxed, also bread, beer, tobacco and cigarettes, and motor cars will be taxed. However, dances will be free. How understanding. Picture the whole community yearning to rush out on to the streets and dance in jubilation at this new birth of freedom. We are to shovel our substance into the Tánaiste's election chest for 1953. To crown our aspiration, there at the door stands the Minister for Finance, like the good fairy he is, saying: "Strike up the fiddle, proclaim a jubilee and join us in the dance." The Mock Turtle of Irish politics says: "Will you, won't you, will you, won't you come and join the dance?" He is like Alice in Wonderland, or, if you like, Alice Through the Looking-glass. Do you remember that picture of Alice and the Mock Turtle? The Mock Turtle says: "Won't you come, won't you come and join us in the dance?" Then we see Alice and the Turtle prancing around in a soup tureen enjoying the dance. That is a ridiculous sight, but is it so ridiculous when it transpires that the Minister for Finance, who has decreed universal austerity, was obliged to include in his Budget this most egregious concession? When he was asked why, here is his explanation: "I am proposing a concession as regards entertainments duty. Dancing has been the victim of varying fortune in this regard. The duty on entertainments was first imposed in 1916 but payments for the right to take part in dances did not come within its scope until 1932. In 1946 the tax as applied to these payments was abolished, but was restored by my predecessor in 1949. Dancing is the only amusement which is discriminated against by levying a tax on active participants as distinct from spectators." Can you picture the heart of the Minister being moved at the jubilation of the dancing? All-in wrestlers have to pay their levy, but the dancers are to go free. That is the explanation given in the Budget speech to an Irish Parliament: all-in wrestlers have to pay their levy for groaning and rolling on the floor, or rather they are free and it is only the lunatics who want to go and watch them who have to pay. Hereafter we may all go and look at the populace prancing around the floor glorying in their freedom from taxation, on the grounds that the Minister for Finance has come to the conclusion that these and the all-in wrestlers are entitled to a square deal.
This justification might be used for providing a free ration of beef to the lions in the Zoo. What is the truth behind this? That is the best he could cook up for what was bound to cause a growl. That is all he himself has to tell us, but what was the truth? The truth was that the Secretary of the Dance Hall Proprietors' Association had a letter from the Tánaiste saying: "If you will vote for us, we will take the tax off dances", and when the noble five, now shrunk to four, in stalled the native Government, the credit did not go to the "busted flush", but the dance hall proprietors turned up for their pound of flesh and the astonishing thing to me is that, in that set-up, they were able to get it. I want to ask any Fianna Fáil T.D. in this House will he justify the removal of this tax from dancing on the ground that it is not paid by the all-in wrestler?
If he does not accept that explanation, does he think it was becoming for the Tánaiste to put the jack-boot on the Minister for Finance and to say:
"No matter how ludicrous it makes you look before the public, you have got to pay my piper, for I said I would pay him if he would pipe the proper tune." He did so to the tune of £100 subscription to the election fund. I think that is rather disreputable. It does not surprise me much. I am accustomed to seedy and disreputable goings-on wherever Fianna Fáil appear. They are a seedy lot.
What distresses me about this is that we had started on an enterprise in this country which was fun. It was fun because, for the first time, we had succeeded in getting a Government that believed in this country, our people and their potentialities. For the first time we had a Government that correctly valued and set a high value, quite genuinely and without any irony whatever, on the Treasury view cogently, resolutely, even ferociously put, who recognised it for what it was, the Treasury view to be carefully considered by a responsible Minister for Finance, who would consider it in evolving his policy, sometimes complying with it, often departing from it. We had established that, in the last analysis, the wealth of our country came from the land and we had declared, to the admiration of every stranger who came to the shores of our country, the right of an Irish Government to invest our people's savings in their own country and not to be afraid to do it. The first fruits of our spending visible to every man's eye were 200,000 acres of arable land that were not there, just were not there, three years ago.
Comment on this
You aspire to be a Melba, perhaps. Deputy Walsh, the Minister for Agriculture, told me about it. Has the Minister studied the return circulated by Deputy Walsh? He said there were 200,000 acres of land rehabilitated or in the process of rehabilitation. Does the Minister deny it?
Comment on this
Born on the agricultural horizon of West Belfast, I cannot expect from the Minister a clear or cogent appreciation of the value of agricultural land, but I am obliged to admit that not infrequently I feel that the Fianna Fáil Government accept the views of Falls Road and Capel Street as coercive in all matters of agriculture, and reject as contemptible a view on that matter which comes from Kilkenny or Mayo. I prefer the Kilkenny outlook on that. I think it is more likely to be right than the outlook of a man who was born, bred and reared in a city and never saw the country except when he was on a holiday, a man that would not be able to walk across a ploughed field without falling and getting lost in it, and having to be dragged out of it. That is no disgrace to him. He is a city-bred man. He is always accustomed to have his food come to him in a packet or a bag or a jug.
I am approaching this from the point of view of the people who live on the land and get their living on it. They know the difference between land that was rehabilitated and land that was not. The Minister, if he goes out with any of his colleagues, would see this—and this he will understand—land that is green to-day that was brown four years ago. That is a simplification that would appeal to him and that simplification has so fascinated him that he has authorised one of his junior Ministers to undertake a great new national enterprise for which he is providing thousands of pounds. Can you conceive what it is? The Falls Road agriculture, growing grass on the bogs of Bangor-Erris. There are 11,000,000 acres of arable land in Ireland better than any other land in Europe for growing grass, but Fianna Fáil economics have spread their sails and set forth for the bogs of Erris whereon to grow grass for the purpose of drying it to sell it in Northampton. That is what he calls land rehabilitation. That is what I call Bangor-Erris midsummer madness. That is the difference.
We have 200,000 acres of land that we had not here before. We have farm buildings. We have machinery. We have this interesting fact, that our exports are rising and that our people are eating more than they ever ate before and that in every international survey that has been made one thing has stood out, that the people of Ireland are better fed and better provided for than any other people in Europe.
What has changed since this time 12 months? Everybody in this country felt they were going places this time 12 months. Everybody in this country who was working felt that, in addition to the monetary reward for his work, he was taking a share in something that was worth doing. There were more people working in Ireland 12 months ago than there had been for years and years. I have told the story and I will tell it again, of the men working on the land project who had come from Africa and Suez to use their skill at home on our own land in the land project. Fianna Fáil was on this side of the House and often troublesome. It was jealous of what we were doing. Even Deputy Allen used to grind his teeth at me for hours at a time to prove that I was not doing anything at all. What is happening to the country? On what side of the House to-day is there jubilation about anything? Where is there a cheerful face or a confident man? Of stiff upper lips I see aplenty. I never saw such an array of stiff upper lips in my life as I have seen in the last few days on the Fianna Fáil Deputies, but it is whalebone they have in them.
Comment on this
It is hard to keep up one's heart, because I do not think that the damage that is now being done can be repaired in my time. It will be repaired, perhaps, by those who come after us. The Minister and myself are getting on. He cannot expect a fool's pardon at his age; the time is long passed for that; neither can I. I never concealed that, for me, it was fun to be a participant in that work. I am sorry to see it wrecked as it has been wrecked. I am sorry to see the country faced with the dilemma with which it is now confronted. I wonder, when looking at the Mayor of Drogheda, who is now about to launch a considerable new industry in Drogheda, for which capital will have to be raised——
Comment on this
——if he is as sure in his mind that that industry will have a prosperous future as he was six months ago?
Comment on this
The Deputy is going to establish that industry because I was in power. He is going to establish it for the dead meat trade and the canning trade in the United States and in Great Britain. The danger is that these things will perish under the wintry blast of Fianna Fáil administration.
Comment on this
That is a hope which the Tánaiste shares. He hopes to be riding high, wide and handsome on that gamble. If he set sail for Monte Carlo I would wire the casino: "Close your doors. Here is the biggest chancer that ever crossed your threshold. He will either skin you or leave his coat and trousers on the premises." If that were the measure of his exertions it would be his own business but I take it amiss when, in the casino of politics, he feels himself justified in staking not his all, but our all, on a spin of the wheel, and that is what he is doing. It is the wickedest thing which has ever been done in this country. I doubt if we can repair it and it is certain that before we get the chance to try thousands of our people will suffer bitterly from what Fianna Fáil is doing now. I have no hope that the busted flush will come to realise their duty and prevent what is about to be consummated. I have really no hope that there is any element in Fianna Fáil who will do it either. My one hope is that the endless resilience of our people and our nation will survive the third war which Fianna Fáil has declared upon the Irish people. They led us through the civil war and the economic war and now we are going to have the dollar war. We have survived the first two; God grant that we will survive the next.
Comment on this
It is natural with such a subject as this to find the Opposition exploiting it to the full from their point of view. Nevertheless it is noticeable that hitherto in this debate, although most members of the Opposition have spoken, few have really addressed themselves to the problem which faces the country and which must be faced by whatever Government sits on these benches at this time. It is all very well to complain of taxes. No tax is popular. It is never popular for a Government to have to find the money necessary to run the country in times when it is difficult to find it and when the trend is adverse, but nobody has suggested any alternative. Now Deputy Larkin, who was perhaps the most sober and objective in his approach, very rightly remarked that it is the privilege—I am paraphrasing him—of an Opposition to parry such a challenge from a Government. He was the only person, however, who went any distance to meet that challenge when he frankly suggested that he would consider deficit financing. It is a hard fact, however, that apart from complaints and, I might say, the understandable exploitation of the situation as they find it by the Opposition, there has been from that side no examination of the problem as it exists or the Minister's proposals for meeting it, and no contribution towards the solution of that problem.
Perhaps then I might be permitted to try to supply some factual basis for the discussion for the rest of the way. No matter whose fault it is or what the historical facts are, there is a situation at the moment where a considerable gap has to be bridged between the revenue and the expenditure estimated for the coming year. It is not sufficient to hope that circumstances will improve, as there has been at least one year's experience to show how far the situation can deteriorate. There has been a picture of a growing disproportion between State revenue on the one hand and State expenditure on the other. The problem is what to do in that situation. I do not think that anybody in this House will suggest that money is something which can be printed off, or that you can simply scrap the financial system. Nobody has gone that far. The furthest the Opposition has gone is to say that we can borrow. Nobody suggested that the money is not to be found or must not be found. Assuming for the moment that we are agreed on that premise— because I freely concede that if you take that away we are in a different line of country—the problem is how that money is to be found and for what purpose, how far that money should be found from current resources, and how far it is legitimate or prudent to pass on the burden to the future or, if you like, to mortgage the future of the country. A mortgage can be a perfectly justifiable business transaction, and I do not use the word in a completely condemnatory sense, but it is an accurate description.
This problem is one which, as Deputy Larkin pointed out, cannot be completely answered on a fiscal basis. It is one in which we have to take into account social and other factors. Broadly speaking, for a Government in this country at the moment——
Comment on this
——for any Government, the factors to be considered are —how far, in meeting the gap which has to be met between the money at present returns available and the expenditure you envisage, can you actually effect monetary economy—in plain language, how far can you cut down expenditure. On the other hand, if you are not going to cut down expenditure, what policy will you adopt to find the money for the expenditure which you think you should maintain?
Comment on this
Deputy Leary should not interrupt. He should allow the Deputy to make his own speech.
Comment on this
If Deputy Leary wants me to depart into a comparison between people's statements and their performances I will do that to oblige him, and the balance, I think, will be on my side, but for the moment I would prefer to try to deal with the problem and its solution, and I will be obliged if the Deputy allows me to do so.
With regard to approach, there would be one group which might go far in saying that we should economise. But when you say that you are going to economise, are you going to stop the development which is undoubtedly necessary for this country? In other words, you are up against the question of how far right will you go or how far left in that approach. I think there is a rational and prudent answer to that in this country as we stand to-day. There is still a need for development here. There is still a need for expanding our own resources and limiting our dependence on outside. While that situation is still there, we must go as far as we can with the development programme, and we have to find the money to do it. That is, broadly speaking, the answer, that we cannot solve the financial problem completely on the balance sheet basis of reducing the gap between expenditure and income by cutting. We have rather to face the problem on the basis that a certain amount of development has to be provided for; in other words, life has to go on and the money has to be provided.
If you adopt that approach, you must answer the final question: how are you going to find the money? I am pausing there again, because it is there, logically, that the parting of the ways can come. It is there, logically, that certain people whom we used to associate with Fine Gael in the old days might say to you: "Cut down," and that other people might say to you: "Go very much further." I am accepting the position, which I think the Government had to accept in this respect, that certain things had to be provided for, both on the current and the capital side, that there was a limit to the economy that could be effected there, that progress and even the maintenance of the State demanded that the funds required for this purpose should be found and, therefore, the Government had no alternative but to find the money.
That is limited by another proposition. It is limited by the capacity of the community to find that money in whatever way it choses. I have not yet come to the point of discussing the methods of finding the money. Any community, big or small, will have a limit to its overall capacity and there will be a limit, after it has provided for its current living needs, to what it can make available for investment for its own development. The parallel there is close enough of the ordinary individual in more than floating circumstances. Let us take the case of the man who can provide for his ordinary living expenses and those of his family from day to day. That eats up a proportion of his income and must be provided for first. He has a certain amount over for providing for capital betterment, if I may put it that way, for his future, for improving his house and other such purposes, but there is a limit to his capacity to provide these things, and, if he goes beyond the limit, he can only do it by getting into debt, and even in the process of getting into debt he is putting a further commitment on himself. Very soon, you find that there is an overall limit to his potentiality to provide what would, in his personal life, be the analogy of capital services where the State is concerned.
Assuming for the moment that the bill for this year is within the capacity of the country for any one year, taken over all—and that, I think, is a matter that could bear examination at another time and in another place—it is proper, subject to that reservation, to provide for what has to be provided for, and then I say we are back to the problem of finding the money. I should like to put this to the members of the Opposition, not by way of a challenge but by way of a hard, cold question that must have faced them if they were sitting on these benches as it faced the Government. Faced with money as you have it—and as I said earlier, nobody has challenged that—faced with the discrepancy between estimated expenditure for specified items, both current and capital, on the one hand, and estimated revenue on the other, what are you going to do? You have only one of two courses to choose from—you either cut the expenditure or you raise the money to meet the deficit.
Let us take the first alternative. If you are going to cut expenditure, what are you going to cut it on? It is fair to ask that question and I am not asking it specifically of the Opposition as an Opposition. I am posing the question as one for us to examine here in the House. Are you going to cut some of the capital development envisaged, like the development of our power resources, the first primary in any industrial development? Are you going to cut services which are not really in the nature of capital development, the social services for which we have all been clamouring? Are you going to cut any of the other items provided for? Are you going to cut the size of the Civil Service or cut remuneration? If you are going to save you must do one of these things concretely and it is only fair to ask that the particular items to be cut should be specified. I have not yet heard from anybody any concrete suggestion for cutting the expenditure on that side.
If we are to have that expenditure, we must provide for it. If we are to have an expenditure over all of approximately £133,000,000 in the coming financial year, we will have to provide for it, and if our revenue is going to fall short of that by something over £40,000,000, then provision for that £40,000,000 will have to be made. There is no escape from it unless you start playing with the whole monetary machine. I have not heard anyone suggest that yet in this debate, and if anyone does suggest it, I would take this opportunity to say: We will consider it if you get down to a real hard and fast concrete proposal. At this stage of the nation's history, this is no time for theoretical and half-baked assertions in relation to the financial machine. Any suggestions will have to be considered in the same hard, concrete way as we have to consider taxes.
That bill of £133,000,000 has to be met. The money has to be found. I will be bold enough to say, and justified in saying, that I think we are agreed on that. We are agreed that that bill has to be met. How is it to be met? The Minister cannot print banknotes.
Comment on this
I hope that reluctance to interrupt the Deputy is not taken by him to mean tacit consent.
Comment on this
It is very difficult to know what Deputy Dillon's attitude to anything is. I am assuming this, however, and I think it is fair to assume it, that from what has been said so far, nobody has asserted that the money should not be provided. As I understand the hostility and the opposition to this Budget, it is based on three heads—(a) the money is raised in the wrong way.
Comment on this
(b) You are raising too much money, raising money unnecessarily.
Comment on this
These are the arguments and I will try to answer them in a moment—(c) by borrowing, all the problems of the State could be solved. Lastly, there is another suggestion. Much of what Deputy Larkin said in this debate is worthy of attention—he was the only person who went so far as to make a concrete suggestion and he said—face a deficit. We should consider that, too, I suppose.
The money has to be found. How is the Minister for Finance to find it? He must raise it from the public or borrow it. He has to do pretty well the same as any private individual—raise the money through his own efforts or borrow it. That hard fact has led to what is a general feature of public finance nowadays—the Minister normally has to employ both methods. The fairly common-sense principle has been developed and evolved—and I have not heard anyone assail it very seriously—that where it is ordinary current living needs you raise the money directly.
Comment on this
I would not like to adopt those words unqualified. The analogy which I admit is broad and undefined is, in the circumstances, a more accurate vehicle for conveying the general idea than a technical definition. On the other side, where you want money for something which will give a return, it is legitimate to borrow, on the theory that what you have built, or what you have invested the money in, will give you something, when exchanged—that it will give you the money to pay back your debt and your interest, so that at the end of the transaction you have a net gain or at least no loss.
Like all such propositions, these are quite simple in the clear cut cases, but you meet that undefined "no man's land" where it is difficult of definition. Consequently, over the years there have been variations from time to time in the approach of different people to what is or what is not properly chargeable to current revenue. In one sense, that is very relevant to this debate here to-night. On the other hand, as the Minister pointed out in his Budget statement, it is not so vital, having regard to the size of the sum to be found. For that reason, I do not think we need pursue the point.
The practical fact is that there is a figure round about the £40,000,000 mark to be provided. The Minister, like his predecessor and like that Minister's predecessor, has but two ways of finding that sum—by borrowing it or raising it through current taxation. Of course, the solution has to be a combination of both methods. The discrepancy is a very great one. One may argue as to how it came about, but the fact remains that the money must be found. It is not loading it excessively on the current side to divide it in the proportions in which the Minister has divided it. I grant you that that is a financial argument, but let me get down to the more concrete aspects of the matter. Having regard to the capacity of the country and to the Minister's borrowing capacity, having regard to his actual position, I do not think he could have cut his deficit on current account to anything less than he has cut it. Having regard to the items comprised within what he has allocated to current account, he could not cut it.
There is the significant point in this, and I think the Opposition should appreciate it, that although we have not forgone our point and the differences we have had with you on the question of what is properly chargeable to capital account and what is properly chargeable to current account, nevertheless, for the purposes of this transaction your method of reckoning has been adopted, and even on your method of reckoning there is still this deficit. It is to meet the deficit on your method of reckoning that these taxes have to be raised.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy think that this would be an appropriate moment to make some retribution for all the abuse that was heaped on that method in the last three years?
Comment on this
If the Deputy asks the question I will be frank in my reply to him. I think not—and for the following reason. I still maintain that much of what has been considered, if not all, and eventually passed off, if I might say so, as capital in the former Estimates is hardly properly so chargeable. It may be necessary to charge some of it as a matter of expediency. In principle, I should say that it is not chargeable at all. From a practical and a social point of view, it might be necessary to have some of it so charged.
I want to make the point that, on your method of reckoning, there is a deficit of £11,000,000 to be made up and that the Minister, having provided for that deficit, currently, still has the over-all problem of providing for the balance of the £40,000,000 mentioned. How you are going to do it is the problem. You are in opposition and it is your privilege to criticise the Government without putting forward a concrete proposal here. But in a matter of such seriousness, if you can show some other practical way of dealing with this problem, I assure you that the Minister for Finance and the Government would be very relieved because in the imposition of taxes of this nature it is no pleasure to anyone to have to meet a problem like this in the way it has to be met. We have yet to hear the alternative proposals. Faced with that position, I have got it down to this: that, on your method of accounting, a deficit of £11,000,000 had to be met from current account. I understood Deputy Costello, the Leader of the Opposition, to make the case that much of this could be written off. I will join issue with that viewpoint in a moment, and the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, has already done so. What I say now is said in a full realisation of the points made by the Leader of the Opposition and the answers made to him.
We have got this far: that this money has to be found and that it is on current account. The next question for the Minister for Finance is: "How am I going to tackle this problem?" It is a pretty hefty sum of money to have to find. It has to be got from the community at large. Nobody will believe the fiction of a few rich people or a few companies from whom you can take it. Deputy Larkin pointed out that the number of well-off people in this country is not sufficient for the purpose. The fact is that the money has to be got from the people at large. What should be the social concern of the Minister? It should be the social concern of the Minister to see how he can adjust the burden so that it will fall lightest on the people who can least afford it—and then, of course, he has to take into consideration the over-all interest of the entire community.
I do not think anybody will deny at present that the hardest pressed elements of the community for the last few years have been the families with the lower middle incomes. Many of us have mentioned their case in this House before. It is the people with salaries of, say, under the £700 mark, and corresponding people in other strata of society with comparable incomes, and so forth, who are in the most straitened circumstances. After that there would be certain people such as the aged. What reliefs could be given or how could you adjust the burden you will have to impose so as to treat them as equitably as possible: that was the problem which faced the Minister for Finance. Unfortunately, the hard facts of our financial situation being what they are now, it is not, this year, a question of being able to give benefits. It is unfortunate, but that is the way things have developed over a number of years. It is not a question of being able to give benefits. It is a question of having to find money to maintain your existing standard of living, if I might call it so, for the State. If that is so, it is then primarily a question of trying to adjust the burden.
What has the Minister done? I think that what he did is very commendable. In the first place, coupled with the social service provisions which are coming and will benefit the class which is more immediately liable to the repercussions of an economic situation, as we know in the past, a good measure of protection is being given to them by these provisions. Secondly, the Minister has provided for children's allowances—not only increased allowances for the third child onwards, but also the introduction of the allowance for the second child. Then the income-tax provisions are an important relief in that regard. It is rather difficult for a private Deputy to make calculations in this connection, but from such figures as are available, it appears that the actual increase in income-tax will operate largely by way of a redistribution of that tax rather than an over-all increase in tax. Admittedly, it will lie more heavily on the people in the upper income grades.
The man earning a higher salary will pay more, but, with compensatory reliefs on the lower scale, it will benefit the people in the class of which I have been talking. It would seem, offhand, that the bulk of income-tax payers in the country will pay less tax than formerly, notwithstanding the fact that the rate has gone up. From figures which have been made available to me, it appears that about 188,000 individuals are liable to income-tax at the moment and that, of that 188,000 individuals, 170,000 will pay less tax than formerly in spite of the increase of 1/-.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy seriously suggest that the effect of the increase in the rate of income-tax will be to reduce it for 170,000 income-tax payers?
Comment on this
From the figures available to me, I understand that 170,000 persons, out of 188,000 persons, will actually pay less tax than formerly, but that 18,000 persons will pay more. That substantiates the point I am making for the Deputy though the Deputy may not have appreciated it. This increase in income-tax is not an increase in the over-all sense; it is an adjustment.
Comment on this
How can we take it as true that the result of increasing it by 1/- is to reduce income-tax for 170,000 out of 180,000?
Comment on this
May I intervene? The result of increasing the standard rate of income-tax by 1/- without making any further changes in the income-tax structure would undoubtedly involve an increase in the over-all tax upon everybody. We, however, are making such significant changes in the earned income relief and in the reduced rates relief that in fact the people who are in the lower income groups will pay very much less next year as compared with what they paid last year.
Comment on this
There is no need to get cross. I merely want the truth. It is an admirable point if it is true—170,000 out of 180,000 will pay less.
Comment on this
I am giving the Deputy the figures available to me. If I am wrong the Minister will undoubtedly correct me later.
Comment on this
That is so and, following it up a little bit further, the bulk of the people paying under Schedule E will actually pay less income-tax though, as the Minister has said, the Exchequer will get more.
Comment on this
It is particularly beneficial to the married taxpayer in the lower income group. Over 95 per cent. are Schedule E taxpayers and that 95 per cent. will be better off under this Budget.
Comment on this
Of 27.5 thousand married tax-payers without children approximately 22.5 thousand will benefit; of 25.5 thousand married tax-payers with children almost 20,000 will benefit. Because of the adjustment of rates, in spite of the increase in the standard rate, an unmarried person with an earned income up to £850 a year will actually be better off from an income-tax point of view than he was last year. In other words, if one takes the income-tax paid for last year and compares it with the income-tax that will fall due for payment in the current year the difference, large or small, will be in the tax-payers' favour. In some cases it may be £10. In other cases it may be small. Beyond the £900 level there will be an increase.
Comment on this
An unmarried man with an earned income of £200 per year would have paid, in the year 1951-52, £3 5s. In the year 1952-53 he will pay £1 10s., leaving a net difference of £1 15s.
Comment on this
The differential is as much as £10 13s. for a single man under the present system; where in the year that has just gone he would have paid £61 15s, he will only pay in the current year £51 1s. 10d. That gives a differential in his favour of £10 13s. 2d. I am dealing now with the single man. In the case of a married man on a salary up to £1,000 per year, he and his family will be better off by sums varying from £1 to £13 up to £14. In the case of those between £550 and £800 the income-tax relief will amount to anything between £10 and £14. A married couple in the income group from £600 to £900 and up to £1,000 will get relief varying from £10 to £15, or £16, and so on, with comparable results in regard to other categories.
Comment on this
It will be very easy for the Deputy to get accurate figures from the Minister who, undoubtedly, will supply them to the Deputy on request.
Comment on this
I think I am accurate in the point I am making.
Comment on this
If Deputy Dillon will put down a parliamentary question I shall be glad to give him a reply for circulation in the Official Reports.
Comment on this
I think I am accurate in saying that the effect of these proposals is rather an adjustment in the incidence of income-tax with a consequential benefit to the Exchequer than an increase in actual income-tax rates.
Comment on this
These income-tax reliefs are particularly favourable to married people, but even unmarried people will also receive some benefit. There will be reliefs in regard to the wage earning classes up to roughly £1,000 a year in the case of a married man. There will be some benefit—it may be small or it may be substantial— depending on the variation from last year to this year. Above that level of £1,000 a higher rate of tax will be paid. The people who are earning over £1,000 a year will pay a proportionately larger tax.
Deputy Dillon says that if I am accurate I have a good point, and I think he will find that I have been accurate in my over-all description. Now, that was a rational step for the Minister to take. These burdens have to be borne by the community and, in imposing them, the Minister has very properly made some adjustments so that they will fall heaviest on the shoulders best able to bear them.
The Minister has given what relief he could to the disabled and so on. We have heard suggestions here about the tax on the poor man's luxury. When the 1947 Supplementary Budget was introduced, I begged the then Minister for Finance to forgo the tax on the pint. I know we shall hear more about it now. I think there is a point there but, nevertheless, the gap is so big now that it almost seems as if the Minister has no alternative but to go to the sources to which he has gone in order to bridge that gap. He has, however, made the burden heavier on the higher income groups. Everybody will have to bear them but heretofore everybody, rich and poor, had the benefit of the subsidies. Now everybody will have to forgo these, and it is only on the higher income groups that the income-tax burden will fall. That is a point which might be remembered.
I am not going to repeat either the social services or the reliefs, the very substantial reliefs, given by the Minister in regard to income-tax, what I shall call the overall benefits. Unfortunately, we are faced with straitened circumstances and it is not so much a question of conferring benefits as of minimising the disadvantages of the situation in which we find ourselves and I think it is good that the Minister has been able to make these adjustments. I think it is good that he has been able to envisage a programme for next year and to maintain such provisions for a capital development as are included in the Government's programme. But, as I say, if you are going to do it you have to find the money.
Perhaps at this stage it would be no harm if we soberly looked, without any recrimination, at the general trend of financial history in this country for the last four years. I have here the Finance Accounts going back to the year 1947-48. There are some general trends in them which are worth examining and worth adverting to, both from the point of view of seeing how we got to the position in which we are and also from the point of view of seeing what would be your future, if you continued on the road on which you were going.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not quarrel, I think, if we try just to find what was the position. It is not a question of apportioning blame or a question of recrimination, so far as I am concerned, but I think it is very relevant to know where we stand and where we are.
Comment on this
It would be all very nice if we could arrive at that position in this House, but seeking motives that are not properly inferable from the facts does not help us to get there. The Finance Accounts for the year 1947-48 disclosed the situation that you had a total revenue of £65,000,000 and a total expenditure of £73,000,000. There was for that year a discrepancy between total revenue and total expenditure, as shown on the right hand side of the account, of £8,000,000. We move then to the next year, and we find that the discrepancy between total revenue and total expenditure has jumped to £27,000,000. In 1947-48 it was, as I have said, only £8,000,000. In 1948-49 the total revenue was £71.7 million and the total expenditure was £99.4 million or £99.5 million to the nearest point. Thus the approximate discrepancy between total revenue and total State expenditure—I have not subtracted the small balance items, but I do not think they matter for the general argument—was £27,000,000. That expenditure included Central Fund, Supply Services and capital expenditure.
We then come to the Finance Accounts for 1949-50 and again we find that the discrepancy has risen by an additional £2,000,000. It jumped from £8,000,000 in 1947-48 to £27,000,000 in 1948-49, and then there was a further addition. We find that the revenue in 1949-50 was £74,000,000 odd and the corresponding total expenditure was £103.5 million, showing a discrepancy of £29,000,000. In other words, the gap has been widened very significantly between revenue and expenditure.
We come, then, to the last set of Finance Accounts available, that for 1950-51, and we find that, while revenue was £77.4 million, expenditure reached £109,000,000. Subtracting, we get a gap of £32,000,000; the discrepancy has jumped again. Then during the last year the figures, if my memory serves me, show that total revenue was £83,000,000 and total expenditure £129,000,000, disclosing a sum of nearly £40,000,000 as a discrepancy. The House will pardon me if I read the sequence of these figures again. Beginning with 1947-48 the sequence for revenue was £65.2 million, rising to £71.7 million, rising to £74,000,000, rising to £77,000,000 and, finally, to £83,000,000. While there was that, shall I say, ordinary or normal expansion in revenue, corresponding to external monetary conditions largely, you had on the expenditure side the figures rising from £73,000,000 in 1947-48 to £99.5 million, to £103.5 million, to £109.6 million, to £129.7 million, and then you have your estimate for the current year.
What is the feature of all this sequence? The feature is a widening gap between revenue and expenditure. Although revenue was increasing somewhat, expenditure was increasing at a much greater rate and, of course, that was reflected in what the Government at the time had to do in regard to money raised by the creation of debt. The other receipts shown in these accounts are insignificant and I think we can ignore them. They are less than £1,000,000 in any particular case. If one looks at the money raised by the creation of public debt in these years one finds that in 1947-48 the total of the money raised by debt was somewhere round about £8,000,000—£7.8 million—roughly corresponding to the deficit. By Ways and Means Advances there was only £3,500,000 raised. We come to the following year, 1948-49, and we find that the money raised by the creation of debt had jumped to £27,000,000, of which Ways and Means Advances were a substantial portion. There was an Exchequer loan which, I think, in that case was fully subscribed. You close the gap by the creation of debt and your Ways and Means Advances have gone up.
In the next year, 1949-50, you are up to £28.2 millions. You have roughly balanced the gap between your revenue and your total expenditure, but Ways and Means Advances are up now to £15.9 million. Of course, in the bonds second issue the public did not subscribe just as much as was wanted, and the "kitty" started to run dry. In the final year, 1950-51, for which I have the financial accounts, Ways and Means Advances amounted to £13.5 million. The total borrowing, the money raised by the creation of debt, was £31.5 million, which roughly corresponds to the £32,000,000. To complete it for last year, the money raised by the creation of debt rose to £44.9 million. What do all these figures show, and these are accepted accounts? There was that growing, widening gap between expenditure and revenue. In order to meet expenditure, that gap had to be met by increased borrowing, and was met by increased borrowing.
Now, could that go on? Before we go into the actual figures relating to the particular case, in principle could that thing go on? Take the simple case of an individual. Can he go on and on when he gets into debt and still finds that he wants more money? Can he go on and get further into debt, even supposing that his bank manager will allow him to do it? Supposing that the source from which you are going to do the borrowing still continues to be available, are you going to be able to do it, and, if you try to do it, will you get the money?
These are the problems that are in it. Now, over these years it is quite apparent that, for whatever reason or motives, we were increasing the indebtedness of the State. That is shown by the figures. The figure relating to Ways and Means outstanding at the end of the financial year, is a very interesting one from that point of view.
Comment on this
Yes, but there was a very interesting figure published the other day. It is an indicator if you like. It is a simple indication of the amount of your overdraft, so to speak, or of how much was outstanding at the end of the financial year. The Ways and Means Advances on the corresponding dates for two years had risen from £20,000,000 to £57,000,000.
Now, it has been perfectly clear from all that that we had got to the point whether either expenditure had to be cut or where the proportion of the money that came from current revenue, is not going to be sufficient any longer. Let me put it this way: that you cannot go on any longer by simply letting expenditure drift up or go up, and just trust to the normal fluctuations of expenditure, hoping to fill the gap completely by borrowing. That just cannot be allowed to continue any longer. The gap has already got too wide and already there should have been, in previous years, a corrective applied to that. If there had been, we would not find ourselves in quite the same position as we are in to-day. It has now got to the stage where remedial action has to be taken.
Remember this, that even on the figures which the Minister has given himself—nobody, I take it, is challenging the accuracy of the accountancy returns furnished to the Minister— there is that deficit over all in the region of £40,000,000. Granted that the Minister finds the £11,000,000 which he is going to find by taxation, there is still £35.9 million to be found. Perhaps that may be misleading, and that I should say there is the substantial figure of well over £30,000,000 to be found by borrowing anyway. It will be for the Minister a question as how to get it. It is questionable whether the capacity of the State can ever be expanded to bear an annual sum very much greater than the sum which the Minister has here.
Now, have regard to that figure and the sequences which have gone before. We have already got the capacity in the last published accounts of two years ago. As far as the accounts are concerned for 1950 and 1951, on the borrowing of £13,500,000 for that year, the Minister was forced to seek £13.5 million by Ways and Means Advances and only got a little more approximately—£14.8 million by a loan.
In order to get that loan, he had to put up his interest rates. As a result of his having gone to the well for water earlier, he had to put on another ½ per cent. on his rates to get the money. Though I have no figures to guide me, my impression is that the Government of that day did not get that loan fully subscribed, and had to have resort to practices which, no matter how we look at them, were inflationary, and they had probably to realise important revenue bearing investments to meet the liability there.
Comment on this
Sterling assets, if you like. I will deal with that in a moment. I am glad that the Deputy reminded me of it, because there are some interesting points in regard to it. The fact is—I am putting the argument in another way—that, on that showing, already two years ago, we had probably got to the limit of our borrowing capacity. That seems to be borne out by the subsequent history, for the sum to be provided is equal to that. Two years ago we had got to the limit of what I may call our annual borrowing capacity, so that, even if the Minister provides the £11,000,000 on current account, he still has a sum to meet on capital account by borrowing, which is in excess of that sum which was indicated as the limit by the accounts of two years ago. It seems, therefore, on that showing, that there would be no chance, even if the Minister tried to do what some Deputies allege they would like him to do—that is, go and borrow the lot—of his being able to do it.
There are very serious grounds for wondering as to whether the Minister could get that money and could borrow on economic terms. I am using the word "borrow" there as distinct from frittering away existing assets—that is eating in on your capital, which is not borrowing. Now, add to that the current difficulties in the financial market, and I think it will be conceded that the Minister, no matter who the Minister is, has not a pleasant task in facing the raising of a loan.
Whether we like it or not the whole condition of securities in the sterling area is the one that will rule and not any local conditions here. When one has regard to the various facts of the recent past, including the fall in Government security prices and the tendency for investors to go towards the higher-yielding stocks and shares, one feels that borrowing is becoming an increasingly expensive process as well as everything else. Let us not forget that borrowing is loading an increase on to your expenditure side in the Central Fund services. Already the charges for the service of debt have increased over the period of years to which I have referred from £3.5 million to over £7,000,000, that is, double itself. £3.5 million merely to pay interest and Sinking Fund on debts incurred in the last three years would be a substantial relief to the Minister if it could be taken off now.
Comment on this
I do. If the Minister for Finance had not to pay £3.5 million more on money borrowed for the service of debt he would have to raise £3.5 million less.
Comment on this
I think those are the figures for the service of the public debt, £3.5 million to £7,000,000. I grant the Deputy that, perhaps, that is not an accurate description, but I shall put it this way, which is accurate, that the charge for the service of the public debt—I think that is what it is called—has risen from £3.5 million to £7,000,000. I think these are the figures.
Comment on this
I am speaking from memory but I think that is the figure and it has doubled itself roughly. That represents an increase in the amount that has to be paid in relation to debt. The amount will continue to increase the more you increase your debt. That is the simple argument I want to make out of it. As I say, unfortunately, in giving that figure, I am speaking completely from memory but I would be surprised if I were wrong.
Comment on this
One can get the figure from the bank accounts can not one?
Comment on this
Yes, I can get them from the Finance Accounts.
Comment on this
Central Fund Services, Service of Public Debt, Interest, £6.3 million, Sinking Fund, £1.7 million. That is over the £7,000,000 I mentioned and the interest is higher. Had the Deputy asked me on the spot I would have told him it would be less. The proportion is £6.3 million. If you look back on the accounts you will find that the corresponding figure was £3.5 million three years ago. The point I want to make in all objectivity is that borrowing is not an unmixed blessing even if you can get away with it. Already in three years the Minister has a burden of £3,500,000 more approximately in relation to debt than he had three years ago. If that £3,500,000 could be taken off the £11,000,000 he has to meet by taxation his taxation would be correspondingly less.
I think it is a fair argument to say— it is legitimate criticism without any-bitterness-that fundamentally our financial criticism of the Coalition Government was that it failed to see where the drift was going. The drift was one where expenditure tended to outpace revenue although revenue was buoyant. The trouble was that the expenditure tended to outdrift the revenue at a fast rate.
In regard to housing, I am taking it as an incontrovertibly good thing to have done in those cricumstances, but by adding to your expenditure side in regard to capital, items which, strictly speaking, were not capital in the sense that they were going to give you a money return that would pay for themselves, you were aggravating that gap and allowing that gap to widen and the drift to accelerate. In allowing that drift to continue and that gap to widen this year it inevitably drifted towards the position where some day some Government would have to bring that up with a jerk.
That is what we are up against. We are feeling the jerk now because the necessary controls were not applied during the three years. In 1947-48, there was only a gap of £8,000,000. That was almost met in a routine way but it had widened to a gap of £40,000,000 this year. The corresponding borrowings had risen to £31,000,000. But it is significant that it is not even what you might call straightforward borrowing. You have the mix-up of Ways and Means Advances coming into the picture.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked me to go into the mater of the Grant Counterpart Fund. I shall not forget to do so. You had that situation of drift, the widening discrepancy between revenue and expenditure. The result is that we are faced with the ultimatum, if you like, or the dilemma, that £40,000,000 has to be found. What proportion are you going to raise on current account and what proportion are you going to borrow? Only £11,000,000 on current account is very far from being either orthodox or conservative. I think we will agree with the Government that they are right to keep the programme there and that the Minister was right to make the adjustments in the incidence of the burden which has fallen upon the country largely as a result of the drift I have mentioned. I say objectively and without meaning to hurt anybody that, largely as a result of that drift, this burden has to be met and the Minister has made the best effort he can to place it on the shoulders that can bear it.
Comment on this
The Deputy was not here when I dealt with the whole question of income-tax and showed that the burden was placed upon people with over £1,000 a year and that those with less than £1,000 a year actually got reliefs.
Comment on this
If the Deputy came down to my constituency he would have no doubt about the truth of what I have said.
Comment on this
I have no doubt there will be complaints and that the Deputy and many of his colleagues will do their best to aggravate those complaints. It is legitimate, and one expects the people will complain. I would complain too, if the Deputy likes, because what we are faced with is the legacy of three years' drift and a widening gap between expenditure and revenue. If the Coalition Government had only tried to keep revenue and expenditure comparable, then we would not be faced to-day with the gap with which we are faced. They, first of all, let the years of opportunity, 1948 and 1949, drift. Then they got into difficulty and let the cost of living and other things get out of control.
Comment on this
Yes, let the cost of living and these things get out of control. You must remember that the cost of living rose six points. I am sorry that it has been necessary to take this tone with Deputy O'Leary. I was trying to deal more objectively with Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Dillon. If Deputy O'Leary wants me to follow on this line he can have it. Deputy O'Leary knows very well that, having failed to exercise any control, the Labour Party cannot talk about it. They could not even get their Social Welfare Bill without getting wrecked with the Coalition, and they came out of office discredited.
Comment on this
I will admit that there has been a certain amount of misfortune in the way things have happened. It has been a misfortune for the world and for this country, for instance, that things turned out as they did at the time of the Korean war. If the situation had developed differently, we might be talking about facts differently. The point I want to make objectively——
Comment on this
——is simply that it was the failure to keep that gap closed which has led us to the position where one has, so to speak, just to come up against it and cross it. It is perfectly evident that Deputy McGilligan, while Minister for Finance. was apprehensive of this. The only criticism I shall levy at the Coalition for the moment is that fundementally, with their divergent views, coalitions are weak. The indications are here in Deputy McGilligan's own approach even to this problem. They are worth noting and, for that purpose, I propose to put some matters on record in connection with this debate.
Comment on this
I have not been speaking anything like as long as Deputy Dillon.
Comment on this
That is a matter of opinion. On the 28th February, 1951, Deputy McGilligan, then Minister for Finance, when presenting his Vote on Account, said:—
"It would appear that the increase in the consumption of essential goods is put at 9 per cent. while the consumption of drink and tobacco have gone up by 16 per cent. The consumption of other goods, as the phrase is used has probably—it would certainly mean non-essential goods—increased by 32 per cent. Taking these two tables together it would appear to be the case that the standard of consumption is being maintained by imports, such imports not being paid by current earnings or by current savings.
The details of the situation will be known to Deputies, but there are one or two I should like to stress. I said already that the lack of the balance which has figured in the 1950 accounts is partly the result of a rise in import prices and that rise is not yet matched by a corresponding increase in the return for exports. The rise in import prices is to some extent the product of devaluation. Certain delayed effects of that began to make their appearance in the early summer of 1950. But, more particularly, the rise is due to rearmament and the scarcity which that caused."
Then he goes on to deal with the ratio of prices.
Comment on this
Volume 124, column 786 of the Official Reports. He went on:—
"The developments in 1950 are, of course, disquieting and it is clear that we could not for very long expand consumption at the present excessive level without inflation in the limited sense of price increases. Most of the blame can accordingly be put on external forces outside Government control."
It is quite obvious that the Minister at that time was nervous of the way things were developing. As I say, it was probably unfortunate that things took that particular turn at the time. But already at that time, as he pointed out in the part I have quoted, the terms of trade were going against us. On March 8th, in closing the debate, as reported in column 1614 he refers to five sources of financing. The last two of these five are the American Loan Counterpart Fund and the sales of sterling investments of Government funds. He said:—
"I said with regard to the last two that I brought these under criticism as being ‘unrelated to current savings.' I distinctly said in regard to these that any resort to them would undoubtedly be of an inflationary type and, therefore, caution in resorting to them had to be exercised."
It is clear that at that particular stage Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Finance, was apprehensive about the turn things were taking and that becomes more clear when you come to his Budget statement a year ago. It might be interesting to Deputy Leary to read this passage for him. As reported in column 1877 of Volume 135, he said:—
"I refer later to the need for moderation on the part of all sections of the community—employers and employees alike—in the pursuit of higher monetary incomes unrelated to increases in prices."
Later on he said:—
"Increases in remuneration offer no escape from this unwelcome development...."
That was that we were not able to produce enough.
"...indeed, they can only accelerate the process of inflation and cause social injustice as between those able to improve or maintain their position and those who cannot enlarge their incomes and are, therefore, forced to assume an undue burden of hardship. For this reason, the Government ask for restraint in the putting forward of wage and salary claims and have taken measures intended to limit price increases to those justified by increases in costs."
That is, by drawing on our external assets to pay for consumer goods. As reported in column 1882 he said:—
"It is still proper and eminently reasonable to draw on our external assets if thereby we speed up the process of capital development at home. What is abnormal and, if it persists can be seriously damaging, is to use up our external resources for consumption purposes. Have we been doing that?"
Comment on this
Unfortunately, the tea and the sugar depend on this and if Deputy Leary realised that, we might be able to make better provision in regard to these matters. As reported in column 1884 he said:—
"The conclusion to which the analysis leads is that, while the extra external disinvestment we incurred in 1950 was balanced as to roughly two-thirds by new home investment and increased stocks, there still continues to be a substantial use of past savings merely to lever up standards of consumption. Making all allowance for the exceptional conditions now obtaining it is to be feared that we are not producing and earning enough to pay our way. The implication is obvious. We cannot have both consumption and capital development on the present scale unless we save more and produce more."
It is obvious from these quotations that the Minister for Finance at that time was already feeling the seriousness and gravity of the situation which we had to face. Unfortunately, however, no adequate provision was made to meet that situation. Nothing was done to adjust the revenue position in those three years. I know it is difficult for any Coalition Government to meet matters of this sort. It is highly unpopular for anybody and for any Government to do it, but the trouble is that if we do not do it sooner we must do it later and cause the greater suffering as a result. That is the situation which has to be faced now.
All the other palliatives and barriers have been exhausted. There was the Counterpart Fund, to which both Governments resorted as a buffer. However, the moneys under that fund must be paid for and will be paid for but the advantages of that barrier, such as it is, are not there now. What was that dollar loan spent on but things for which mostly there is no large return, and the answer of the Minister given in the Dáil was that it was mostly on wheat, flour and grain. These figures are familiar to most of us but the important thing is to what extent it was spent on capital equipment and machinery and such matters. Only 6.9 or approximately $7,000,000 out of a total of $146,000,000 was spent on those important items. Further sums were spent on raw materials which may have been justifiable in the circumstances of the time, but if we take off a sum for these we find that two-thirds of the money was spent on consumer goods.
It is an old argument as to the advisability of spending dollars in America for the purchase of grain and other foodstuffs which could be grown at home. We have gone into that argument often. The fact is that this was a dollar loan and a commitment which, no matter what distinction Deputy Dillon makes, must be met. It is a loan and a commitment for this country, no matter what way you work out the financial transaction. I think it was seriously wrong to spend this money on goods which we could have produced at home, and Deputy Dillon knows that I think that is so and there is no use in mincing words about it. It was a considerable factor in the situation in which we found ourselves. That money has to be paid back and it is a payment on the wrong side for us, and the goods are gone.
Comment on this
They are gone. It was spent on consumer goods.
Comment on this
It was spent on consumer goods at a time when there was a shortage of dollars and a serious situation, and it was a serious thing in such circumstances to spend the money on consumer goods.
Comment on this
There is the situation, and we are limited in borrowing. I have some notes which I took some time back which show that the 3 per cent. loan which was issued by the previous Government was not subscribed from the public to the extent of more than 50 per cent. The Government then unfortunately resorted to inflationary expenditure. The rate was raised to 3½ per cent., but still the public did not subscribe to the extent of more than 60 per cent.
Comment on this
I did not, but I say if that had continued it would have led to a very serious situation. These are all factors which we must take into account in this difficult situation. We are not trying to pretend that this taxation can be anything but a burden, but our people will realise that one has to pay for the things that the Government can give them in spite of the fact that they have been misled in so far as some irresponsible people in certain quarters are concerned; and I am not referring to Deputy Morrissey in this connection, because Deputy Morrissey has been very responsible in these matters here frequently in the House. There are, however, others who have not been responsible in representing to the people what the situation actually was.
The money for the social services and capital development and other purposes has to be found, and if it cannot be provided out of revenue it must be provided by some other method. I think the Minister and the Government are trying to provide for a continuance of the development programme, but there is a limit to the country's capacity to do that. I would rather take the view that we will find the money to do the work rather than that we will only do the work for which we have money available.
While taking that attitude we can make the remark that again, unfortunately if you like, there is much to show that the orthodox economists have a lot of right on their side in post-war economic development. These are the hard facts which must be taken into account and faced, whether we like it or not. We will hear much about these taxes and much about this Budget, which is designed to meet a situation where there is a gap between income and expenditure and where the State was living beyond its means. Not only the Fianna Fáil Party were saying this. Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Finance, had his fears that the State was living beyond its means from a consumer point of view and that we were borrowing more than we could afford.
Comment on this
The situation was getting to the point where we would have to face up to it.
What I am proposing to say now is not quite germane to what I have been saying all along, but it is interesting. I think it was Deputy Dillon who said something about the new taxes aggravating emigration. I wonder how far these taxes can do that? Although it is necessary to say that this Budget will impose a strain, still there is a big discrepancy between the prices of petrol, cigarettes, whisky and stout in the Six Counties and in the rest of Ireland. Although petrol will go to 3/6 per gallon here, it is 4/3 per gallon in the Six Counties. I feel the Deputy will concede that there is a practical problem, unfortunately, resulting from Partition, where big discrepancies in prices on either side of the Border are involved. Where there is a big discrepancy in price there is an immediate problem. I am not suggesting that this is a major consideration with regard to the Budget but it is one to which we might advert. In the Six Counties and in Britain the cigarettes are around about the 3/6 mark per packet, whiskey is 5/- per glass and stout 1/11 per pint.
Comment on this
I agree, Deputy. We have said the same thing before. We should not condition ourselves and we do not condition ourselves to circumstances in Britain. That can be said in fairness to both Government and Opposition. Unfortunately, if you like, we are associated in the one financial structure; we are part of the sterling area and certain comparisons are therefore, legitimate as regards prices and living conditions in both countries. Quite frankly, I do not see the force of Deputy Dillon's argument that we are encouraging our people to emigrate and chasing them out of the country in view of the differential between prices and living conditions in Britain and here. In my view, that problem is rather one of another sort which we can discuss at another time.
Lastly, I would like to refer to a remark made by the Leader of the Opposition, which I jotted down. He said: "We had created a financial structure of impressive strength." I must say that I fail to see the strength of a financial structure which is characterised in the widening gap between income and revenue, which I have demonstrated from the accepted figures which I quoted. I fail to see the impressiveness of the structure which is built largely, if it is a structure at all, on a debt basis. I fail to see how a situation in which one has to look to borrow money and at the same time increase the cost of borrowing so as to get the money at all, could be called impressive; a situation where, at the same time, the balance of payments, which is fundamental to this picture, as the Minister has said, was going against the then Administration in the way in which it was; a situation where, coupled with that financial structure, the Government responsible for it should go out of office handing over at a time when the cost of living had started to soar and trends had started to go wrong.
As Deputy McGilligan, when Minister for Finance last year, said in his Budget speech: "Many things are outside the control of the Government." The experience of everybody in this House, acting in or behind a Government, shows that there are great limits to what it can do. I think we are all agreed on that. In these circumstances, frankly, I fail to see that, in the first place, there is any great credit due to the inter-Party Government or, in the second place, that there was anything very impressive about their financial structure. However, I suppose it is too much to hope that this matter can be approached on a hard factual basis. It seems a peculiar thing that, apart from Deputy Costello making certain deductions and making the case that there was overtaxation, there has been a great evasion of figures and facts by members of the Opposition. This is not a challenge, but I feel it would be helpful for us all if those very facts and figures in the Budget with which I have dealt had featured more in this debate. We could have found grounds for commendation or criticism of the Minister if that had been done.
Comment on this
Just now Deputy de Valera challenged us to give more attention to the figures and the facts— the accurate figures—which the Minister had given us.
Comment on this
I am glad the Minister is here. This morning Deputy Costello described this Budget as being not merely a cruel Budget but an unjust one. I want to go further. I want to say that in this Budget there are figures that are neither true nor accurate. In this Financial Statement—the most important document that issues from the Government of this country in any year—there are figures which are false. I ask Deputy de Valera not to leave the House now, because what I have to say will be worth waiting for. The figures in the Budget statement are not correct, and they are the figures upon which the Minister has sought to justify one of his major impositions on the people of this country.
I refer Deputies and the Minister to page 50 of the statement issued yesterday. I quote the Minister's words:—
"There has also been a spectacular increase in the registration of motor vehicles, which numbered 99,662 in 1939, 173,234 in 1949, and 223,444 in 1951. In the light of these figures, we may assume that petrol will readily bear an additional 4d. per gallon."
May I again draw Deputies' attention and the Minister's attention to the statement: "There has also been a spectacular increase in the registration of motor cars." Some of those figures are out by as much as 50,000. The figures given in this Budget statement, upon which are reared impositions on the public of something in the neighbourhood of £50,000,000 additional taxation, and the preparation of that statement by the Minister, are fraught with criminal negligence.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Deputy has purported to quote from page 50 of my Budget speech. He has stated that I said there was a "spectacular increase in the registration of motor cars". I said nothing of the sort.
Comment on this
The Deputy deliberately used the words "motor cars", which is quite a different thing.
Comment on this
If I did, I apologise to the Minister. I meant to say "vehicles" in any case. It does not correct the figures. I accept the Minister's correction and I apologise to him for inadvertently using the word "car" instead of "vehicle". I say the figures are completely wrong and I will prove it. The Minister says that the number of motor vehicles registered in 1939 was 99,662. Actually-and I quote from the report of the Department of Local Government and Public Health for 1939-40, page 209- the total number of vehicles, all classes, in that year registered was 73,813. But the total number of driving licences issued was 99,662.
This is the Budget statement in which every figure is supposed to be checked. That was 1939. The Minister told us yesterday that the number of motor vehicles registered in 1949 was 173,234. Again wrong, wrong to the tune of 51,000, because the total number of vehicles of all classes-and I hope that is comprehensive enough for the Minister-registered in 1949 was 122,536, but the total number of driving licences issued was 173,234.
Comment on this
Accuracy of figures. Let me go on to 1951. We are told that in 1951 there were 223,444 motor vehicles registered. Actually it was 70,000 short of that figure. The number registered was 155,982, but the number of driving licences issued was 223,444.
I feel, Sir, that this is an unprecedented happening in this House and I would venture to say in any other Parliament wherein a Budget statement, particularly a Budget of this type, that there is such a glaring and a major blunder made. It is quite obvious that in respect of at least one of the major impositions the Minister based his decision to impose that tax on false premises, on a foundation that was not there. I venture to suggest that this debate ought to be adjourned and this financial statement ought to be withdrawn until such time as the Minister and the Government have an opportunity of checking both the figures I have quoted and the other figures which are given throughout the 71 pages of that statement, so that the House may know what they are really dealing with. At the moment we do not know.
I would suggest with respect, Sir, that having regard to the immense importance of this, not merely to this House but to the people outside, this debate should be adjourned, that this financial statement should be withdrawn and the Minister given an opportunity to correct it. I make that motion now, Sir.
Comment on this
If there is anything more preposterous than facing this House with a Budget statement—
Comment on this
I certainly will make it and the Minister will not stop me, but this House is not going to base its decisions upon a series of false figures.
Comment on this
I am putting a motion. I am sorry in a way that it should fall to your lot instead of the Ceann Comhairle, and may I respectfully ask, Sir, that you send for the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
If you do not then I, and every other Deputy in this House, must endeavour to continue the debate on this Budget, to continue the examination of the impositions which the Minister is seeking to inflict on the citizens of this country without knowing whether those figures are true or false. I have suggested, with respect, to the Acting-Chairman—and the Acting-Chairman is not supposed to do it; therefore I do not wish to press it —that it would be more in keeping with the dignity of this national Assembly if on a discovery and disclosure such as I have now given, the Ceann Comhairle was sent for. It would certainly come more properly from the Minister than from me in the circumstances to suggest that the adjournment which I have proposed should be agreed to.
Comment on this
You can put that to the Ceann Comhairle. He will be here in one minute.