Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).
Contributions 179–372 of 562. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
May I again call Deputies' attention to the Minister's words which followed immediately on giving the figures? He said: "In the light of these figures"-mark those words—"we may assume that petrol will readily bear an additional 4d. per gallon." May I ask the Minister whether, in the light of the fact that those figures are shown now to be untrue, he is prepared to withdraw that imposition of 4d. per gallon on petrol? Or does he want the House or expect the House to go on discussing this Budget statement and, in particular, the Resolution which imposes this 4d. per gallon, in view of the fact that he imposed it believing, as I am perfectly satisfied he honestly believed, that he was dealing with the real figures of registration.
I want to make it perfectly clear, in case there might be any misunderstanding about this, that not for a moment do I suggest, or has it entered my mind, that there was anything deliberate in regard to this matter of the figures. But I do allege negligence, negligence amounting almost to the verge of being criminal, in bringing in such an immense impost as this on the citizens of this country, that figures of a major kind such as that would not be properly checked. I cannot understand it. It is beyond me.
An Ceann Comhairle took the Chair.
Comment on this
In your absence from the Chair, I pointed out to the House and to the Minister that, on page 50 of the Minister's Budget statement yesterday, there was a mistake, a major mistake, in figures which bear great importance in relation to the Minister's whole Budget structure. The Minister stated on page 50:—
"There has also been a spectacular increase in the registrations of motor vehicles which numbered 99,662 in 1939, 173,234 in 1949 and 223,444 in 1951."
I am not going to weary you, Sir, by going into it as fully as I did go into it in your absence, but I will say that these are not the figures for motor vehicle registrations; these are the figures for the issue of motor licences, which is a completely and entirely different matter. The Minister went on to say, immediately after these figures:—
"In the light of these figures we may assume that petrol will readily bear an additional 4d. per gallon."
A major blunder of this magnitude in a Budget is unprecedented and I respectfully suggest to you and to the Minister, but first to you, Sir, that I now make a motion that, in view of that, either the Dáil adjourn or the debate on the General Resolution be adjourned to give the Minister an opportunity of having his Budget statement further checked and represented to the House. I think, Sir, with all respect, that that is not only a very reasonable request but, unless it is acceded it, it will not be possible for the members of this House usefully to continue the debate on this Budget.
Comment on this
Having listened to the very serious statement made by Deputy Morrissey, and having been as convinced as the Minister obviously is by Deputy Morrissey's statement, I would like to second that motion.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Deputy Morrissey having put his point, are we going to have a debate?
Comment on this
It would seem to me that Deputy Dunne is availing of this opportunity to create a debate on it.
Comment on this
Matters of this kind, perhaps not to the extent to which it is alleged they arise here, come from time to time into the proceedings of the Dáil. These are matters of fact, matters of fact which are in dispute, perhaps, on all sides of the House.
Comment on this
These are matters of fact upon which I cannot offer an opinion or decide, without allowing myself to be drawn into the arena of political dispute, which I am not willing to do. Whether the tax is being imposed on the figures as submitted or not I cannot say. The figures are merely submitted as an argument by the Minister in making his case as I understand it.
Comment on this
If that is the position and if that is the line the Minister is going to take, I regret it very much.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Minister thinks in respect of this matter. I am only saying that, to me, these figures are merely arguments put forward by the Minister in support of his case. I cannot decide what is right or wrong.
Comment on this
All I want to say is this that any point of substance that Deputy Morrissey makes, I shall deal with in my reply, as is usual.
Comment on this
I would not think the occasion requires or justifies a motion such as Deputy Morrissey asks me to accept.
Comment on this
Very well. That is your opinion and to that I bow. The Minister seems to think that he has gained a victory.
Comment on this
The Minister talks, in that little cheap way of his, of dealing with these matters when he is replying.
Comment on this
If the Minister did occasionally hit the desk with his fist instead of using his tongue in the way in which he sometimes uses it it might be a lot more wholesome.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey is in possession. I hope he will be allowed to continue without interruption.
Comment on this
May I restate the position for the members on all sides of the House who were not here when I raised it? May I first express the view that I regret, for the sake of this House, that the Minister has chosen to take the line which he has chosen? The Minister has not denied, and the Minister cannot deny, my statement that those figures which he gave in his Budget speech are inaccurate and wrong. He cannot deny that. The Minister stated in his Budget speech that he had based his decision to increase the tax on petrol by 4d. a gallon on the figures of registration of vehicles which he gave.
Comment on this
Let me read his own words. It only shows you the absolutely irresponsible man we have dealing with this amazing Budget. Let me read his own words:—
"There has also been a spectacular increase in the registrations of motor vehicles which numbered 99,662 in 1939, 173,234 in 1949 and 223,444 in 1951."
Comment on this
On a point of order. I think it is the custom that when a Deputy quotes from a document, he quotes the document as a whole. I would ask you, therefore, to require Deputy Morrissey to quote the sentence preceding the one he has just quoted.
Comment on this
The point of order is that I am to read 71 pages. The Minister says it is the custom to quote the whole document.
Comment on this
The only argument for that is that I would read it in better style than the Minister did yesterday. I am giving him chapter and verse.
Comment on this
The Minister has shown that he was so criminally negligent in the preparation of this Budget statement, if he had any part in the preparation of it—which the line he is taking forces me to say——
Comment on this
I have asked before that Deputy Morrissey, who is in possession, be allowed to make his speech without interruption. Interruptions are disorderly no matter from what side they come.
Comment on this
I would like that remembered by every Deputy in the House. Therefore, Deputy Morrissey is entitled to proceed without interruption except on a point of order.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is Deputy Morrissey not obliged to address the Chair? He seems to be addressing his remarks to me.
Comment on this
The Minister should not flatter himself. The Minister should be ashamed. Instead of trying to make little smart cracks in the hope that they will be published at least in the Irish Press——
Comment on this
May I respectfully submit that I am not contravening order in any way? I am not going to be side-tracked by any of the little red herrings which the Minister seeks to introduce. I have stated the facts; I have quoted figures from the official documents and have given the reference; they cannot be challenged. I was prepared to invite the Minister, any of his colleagues on the Front Bench or anybody in the House to challenge the accuracy of what I have said. How am I to know, how is any other Deputy in this House to know, that the same blunders and mistakes were not made in relation to the figures on which it was decided to remove the subsidies? Deputy Costello showed that this morning to the tune of £2,000,000 in respect of subsidies alone. How do we know that we have not the same miscalculation, the same wrong sets of figures, basing the decision to put 1/- on income-tax? I do not know. Is there any member of Dáil Éireann on this or on the other side of the House who will get up and, in the light of what I have now exposed, say that any of the other figures in the Budget statement are watertight and have been checked and re-checked to make sure that they are absolutely sound? Of course there is not. The Minister is trying to be cheap in jibing at me. If I were in the Minister's position and that major blunder were disclosed in this House, the first thing I would do would be immediately to tender my resignation to the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Ministers, in particular Ministers for Finance, have tendered their resignation, and have had it accepted for considerably less.
Comment on this
That is unfair to Mr. Butler. I have listened to Deputies on my own side and in the Labour Party making the allegation that the Minister was following in the most slavish way the line laid out for him by Mr. Butler. I want to repudiate that. Mr. Butler's Budget to the English was milk and honey compared with the Minister's Budget to the Irish people.
Comment on this
I say that this is a fraudulent Budget and I am going to prove it. I am not concerned with Mr. Butler's Budget——
Comment on this
——but I am very much concerned about this Budget. We must assume either that all the rest of the figures are correct or that they are incorrect or that some are correct and some incorrect, but in view of the fact that the Minister will not take the obvious course for a man in his position in the debate on this Budget, then I must go on. I listened for an hour and a half to Deputy Vivion de Valera.
Comment on this
The Deputy made the best effort of which he was capable to prove that, instead of being a burden on the majority of the people of the country this Budget was conferring benefits on them. He was just following, or attempting to follow, the line set for him this morning by the Tánaiste. Those of us who know the Tánaiste over a long period of years were not a bit surprised at this line: having regard to the compensation provided in this Budget and in the Social Welfare Bill for those on lower incomes, they would be better off when the Budget became law than they were yesterday. Is there any Deputy even on the Fianna Fáil side who will swallow that an old age pensioner who gets 1/6 under this Budget is going to be better off next Friday than he or she was last Friday? Does anybody believe that for one moment? Does anybody believe that they will be better off after the 1st July?
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan does not believe it, and there is no man in this House, whatever he may say, who can more readily grasp the full implications of this Budget and realise to the full how it will hit the people of the country, particularly the poorer people, than Deputy Cowan. Do not make the mistake that Deputy Cowan is anybody's fool. Do not make the mistake that he is not an intelligent man. Notwithstanding all that, however, I will lay you 100 to 1 which lobby he will be in. Johnny, do not draw me any further on that.
"We are going to be better off." When I was Minister for Industry and Commerce Fianna Fáil Deputies and other Deputies used to tell me, just as they told my predecessor and successor, Deputy Lemass, that 6 lb. of bread per head per week was not enough for the people of the country, particularly the people of rural Ireland. We recognised that, and met that point of view—both he and I as Minister—to the fullest extent possible in the circumstances, by making available not merely to bog workers and others, but over the whole harvest period, additional supplies of bread. Let us say that a fair ration would be 7 lb. per week, 1 lb. per day per head. Allowances are to be increased by 1/6 and the 2 lb. loaf is to be increased 2 ½d. Just take that without taking tea, sugar or butter, and let us forget for the moment any idea of a bottle of stout, a pint, an ounce of tobacco or a packet of cigarettes. Does anybody think for a moment that 1/6 per week will compensate for that enormous load which starts now, but the impact of which will not be felt until after the 1st July?
We had cheap little interjections from the Minister and from Deputy Vivion de Valera to the effect that the Minister was going to give more to the poor and was getting after the rich. Robin Hood! Deputy de Valera also set out to prove that everybody with a salary under £1,100 per year would, as far as income-tax is concerned, be served by this Budget rather than injured by it. How many rich people have we in this country over that ceiling?
Have we enough to give us an additional £15,000,000 taxation? Is it not all sheer nonsense? I listened on many an occasion to Deputies behind the Government, when they were on this side, bleating about the cost of living. I read a debate two years ago that was dragged out for the best part of three months by Fianna Fáil Deputies on the cost of living, on emigration and on unemployment. How did the cost of living then, which they said was unbearable for the people, compare with the cost of living after ten months of this Government, even before the introduction of this Budget?
Does anybody in the House believe for one moment that the full effect of this Budget is not going to have a more severe impact upon the real cost of living in the country than any single action or group of actions has had in our time? Do we not know that, due to the gloomy speeches, due to the the depressing speeches, due to the untrue speeches, before this Budget hit the country at all, business in certain lines had been brought practically to a standstill; that production in most of our factories had either almost ceased altogether or had slowed down very considerably; that distributors were finding it almost impossible to get buyers for their goods; and that unemployment, or rather, disemployment of persons who were in what they thought to be safe and secure positions has proceeded in the past nine months at the rate of 1,500 for every month Fianna Fáil has sat on that side of the House?
Is there any Deputy who has any knowledge of the economic or social conditions of the country who is in any doubt as to what is going to happen almost immediately? Are we not being thrown back by this Fianna Fáil Budget into the position out of which the inter-Party Government brought this country in 1948—let Deputy Allen allow me to finish and he may smile on the other side of his face—back to the time when we had the old vicious circle of prices and wages chasing each other? Does anybody believe for a moment that there is a working man or working woman inside or outside a trade union who will not demand increases, or insist upon the leaders of his or her union furnishing demands immediately to their employers for increases, sufficient to meet the additions which are being imposed by the Budget? Does everybody not know that, and, as was said earlier by Deputy Dillon, how many of the employers, without still further increasing prices, will be able to meet and pay the increases which their employees will be seeking and insisting on getting? Is there anybody in the House or outside who believes that this will not increase rapidly and by thousands still further the number of unemployed? Does anybody doubt that not merely are we going to have the old vicious circle back, but that it will be a circle more vicious than anything we had before?
I invite some of the Deputies on the opposite side and some of the Ministers who read some of the speeches they made two, three and four years ago inside and outside this House before they seek to justify this Budget. I am perfectly satisfied that a great deal of this taxation is entirely unnecessary. I am perfectly satisfied that this country and its people are in a much worse position to-day than even 12 months ago to meet and cope with this very heavy imposition, whether they be workers, shopkeepers or anybody else. I hear some adverse comment on that and I can only suspect from where it comes. All the long talk, all the quotations and all the repetition by Deputy Vivion de Valera does not change it one iota. I invite Deputies who know the country just as well as I do, who are as conversant with the lives of the people and the sort of life the average person lives as I am and who have as intimate a knowledge of the life of an ordinary working man and his wife and family, and the way in which they have to work their household economy as I have, to get up here and say that the proposals offered in this Budget will more than meet the impositions contained in it. The compensations would not meet the increased charges and the increased prices of the essentials, much less adding in what some people talk about as necessaries and others, depending on which side of the House they are, describe as luxuries.
Deputies cannot cod themselves that the compensations offered for the poor are going to compensate them, because most of us know that it is the poor who will be hit, and the poorer they are the more they will be hit by this Budget, because the poorer they are, the more bread, the more tea, the more sugar, and, in so far as they can, the more butter they will use. They have to use proportionately much more of these items of food than the better-off person and Deputies know that. I want to ask the House, as I am sure everybody in the country is asking himself, what has happened in this country to bring about this economic revolution. The Minister and some of his colleagues, such as Deputy Vivion de Valera, glibly speak of world conditions, world forces.
In some of the countries which have to provide for European defence and perhaps even far beyond what is required for defensive measures and which are spending immense sums on armaments, there has not been as revolutionary a change in their Budgets or their financial structure as there is made here in ours by this Budget, and the impost, the increased impost, over a period of 12 months on their people, not excluding provision for armaments, has not been as considerable as it is here. This Government and the Party behind it know quite well that this is a bad Budget, that the country will be dead against it. They would not dare to face the country on that Budget to-morrow morning. They would not dare to seek a mandate for it, because they would not get it.
Comment on this
I am certain. So certain am I that I assert with confidence that not merely would the Government be beaten but the Fianna Fáil Party would be almost wiped out. Deputy Allen has not been at home yet.
Comment on this
I am telling the Deputy what he knows and his colleagues know now, and what they will know much more clearly before they reassemble here. This is a bad Budget, a Budget that is going to place a savage burden on the people, a Budget that will make unquestionably for more unemployment on a very big scale, a Budget that will hit very hard our industries and the whole manufacturing and distributing organisation. I am as sure as I am standing here that, when they learned of the details last night and when some of them read them in the papers this morning, men and women working in shops and offices throughout the country said to themselves: "That is enough, we have not been doing enough for the last month, three months or six months in some cases; this is the final straw; I wonder will I be getting my week or fortnight's notice with the pay envelope on Friday or Saturday next." Does any Deputy think that is an exaggerated picture? Does any Deputy think there are not hundreds, if not thousands, of working men who are wondering whether this Budget will mean not only an increase in their cost of living but deprivation of their weekly wages and the substitution therefor of the queue at the labour exchange?
Let us not try to pretend that there is nothing in this but sugar and no pill inside. Let us remember the increases that will come upon the people on the 1st July—an increase of practically 40 per cent. on sugar, 100 per cent. on tea, practically 25 per cent. on butter, 30 to 35 per cent. on a loaf of bread. In the face of that, I am prepared to say, and I do not care how it is misrepresented, that the imposition on the pint and even on the tobacco is not as serious. May I remind the House of what Deputy McGilligan said yesterday, truthfully, that when the present Ministers were in office in 1947 and introduced a Budget to impose taxes very considerably less drastic than the charges in the present Budget, they sought to justify them on the grounds that the money they would receive by imposing these taxes they were going to use to subsidise essential foodstuffs. When we came into power, at a cost of somewhere in the neighbourhood of £6,000,000, we reduced or removed the additional taxes on beer, tobacco, cinemas and so on imposed in the Supplementary Budget and we did not reduce the subsidies by one brass farthing. Not only that, we increased some of the rations without increasing the subsidy price.
Comment on this
Do not forget that a very important part of this Budget— in case the Deputy has not read it or did not listen to the Minister—is the Minister's proposal to borrow a very considerable amount of money this year—which those of us who have some interest in the country and some concern for those to-day employed in capital development schemes, hope will be fully subscribed.
Deputy Allen sometimes takes the Minister for Finance as his model. I would not care to see Deputy Allen— for whom I have a very fine respect, notwithstanding the cracks we may exchange across the House—modelling himself too much or too often on the Minister. This particular Budget not merely puts on increased taxes over and above those which were put on in the Supplementary Budget but it puts on a number of new taxes that were not even attempted in the Supplementary Budget; and on top of that it removes almost entirely the food subsidies.
I want to put this to Deputy Cowan —and I am not trying to put him in any particular corner. He made several contributions to the debate. How can he seek to justify voting for that set of circumstances that I think I have quite fairly and I hope pretty accurately outlined, that he would have denounced as vehemently and as effectively as he did the comparatively mild proposals in the Supplementary Budget? As a matter of fact, we could thank the Supplementary Budget for giving us the honour of the Deputy's presence in this House. I hope we will not have to thank this Budget for depriving us of that presence.
I do not want to go back to where I started in relation to the figures I quoted. The Minister heard them, the House heard them and they are on the record. I gave page and column for the figures which I gave. I assert that this is not a true Budget, that it is based upon a wrong set of figures, conclusions drawn from figures which did not relate to the registration of motor vehicles, which did not come, in one of the years, within 70,000 of the number. I am sorry that the Minister refused to adjourn to have this further examined so that Deputies might at least approach the Budget and make their contribution in the knowledge that the figures which they were using and criticising or trying to analyse were true and accurate figures. The Minister has chosen to take what I conceive to be the wrong course. However, that is a matter for him.
Comment on this
The Chair did not pass any remark or any criticism whatever on Deputy Morrissey's statement. The only thing the Chair said was that it would not accept a motion to adjourn the Dáil in respect of what Deputy Morrissey urged.
Comment on this
And it would be inconceivable that the Ceann Comhairle would describe the figures as ridiculous.
Comment on this
My motion was overruled by the Ceann Comhairle in the exercise of his judgment and his duty in the Chair. All he said was that he would not accept the motion which I tendered. By the time this is finished, the Minister will be fully welcome to whatever kudos he can get out of it. I only hope for the Minister's own sake and for his reputation, as well as for the sake of the House, that he will not try to suggest that the figures which I have quoted are other than accurate. I hope that he will not try in any way to justify and prove as accurate in relation to their context the figures which are in his financial statement. The facts are there and the figures are here. They can be quoted from official documents.
No talk, no eloquence, no flights of fancy can make this a good Budget or can make it anything but a harsh and a savage Budget—a Budget that will have a terrific impact on the whole economic and social life of this country. It is a Budget that will leave us much poorer in relation to money and services and infinitely poorer in relation to our boys and girls many more of whom, I am afraid, will now be forced to leave this country.
Comment on this
It is obvious, from the tremendous noise that Deputy Morrissey made about his discovery of some figures which he alleges are not correct, that if there were any more figures in the statement that were not correct we should have heard about them. I wonder if Deputy Morrissey realise that an extra sum of £15,000,000 has to be found this year? Deputy Morrissey did not advert to that matter at all in his statement. He spoke as if there was no need whatsoever for any sort of additional taxation. Apparently, he has even thrown over his leader who has admitted for months past that there is a problem to be faced.
Nobody on this side of the House will contend that this Budget is something that anybody would like to impose if it could be avoided. However, the facts of the situation must be faced. I do not want to repeat the quotations which Deputy Major de Valera read out here this afternoon of speeches made over the past few years by Deputy McGilligan when he was Minister for Finance, pointing to the trend in financial affairs. Deputy McGilligan spoke about that trend, and drew attention to it, but apparently he allowed the Government of which he was the Minister for Finance to do the other thing. We are now facing the result of that default on his part. One need not be deeply versed in high finance to recognise that if the trend were allowed to continue for a few years more, what would have to be done then would be infinitely worse than what is being attempted to-day, and would have infinitely worse consequences for the country. I think that the members of the Coalition Government, in view of what their own Minister for Finance told them over the years, must have been aware of this trend. They must know that the present situation is, to a large extent, the result of the policy they pursued, and they ought at least now face the facts and try to find a way out. Maybe our method is not the best method, but it is a method, and the Coalition Government did not try to remedy the situation at all, but just let things drift.
We have not heard any constructive suggestions from the Opposition Benches. Instead, there has been an attempt to ignore the position that does, in fact, exist to-day. An attempt was made to tell us that a number of the statements made by the Minister are not correct. Take, for example, the question of income-tax. An attempt was made to assert that the Minister's statements last night, and elaborated on to some extent to-day by Deputy Major de Valera, are not correct, and that the bulk of the people will have to pay more under the rearrangement of the income-tax code. I have some figures here which have been worked out. I do not want to bore the House, but they are worth bringing to the attention of the House. Let us examine Schedule E, earned income.
We find that an unmarried man earning £500 a year will actually have to pay £10 2s. 6d. less for income-tax in the coming year. At £600 a year the reduction would be £8 and at £800 the reduction would be £3 15s. At £900 a year he will actually have to pay 5/- more for income-tax than he paid last year. All the above figures are in respect of an unmarried man. Now let us take the figures for a married couple. At £400 a year the husband gains £3 10s. At £700 a year he gains £12 17s. 6d. At £800 a year he gains £10 15s. At £1,000 a year he gains £2 15s. and at £1,100 a year he will have to pay £1 5s. more than he paid last year. The figures for a married couple with one child are as follows. At £500 a year they will gain £4 5s. At £800 a year they will gain £4 15s. At £1,100 they will gain £2 15s. and at £1,200 a year they will have to pay £1 5s. more than they paid last year.
A married man with two children earning £600 a year gains £5; on £800 a year he gains £15 5s.; on £900 a year he gains £14 15s.; on £1,200 a year he gains £2 15s. and on £1,300 he will have to pay 25/- extra. A married man with three children earning £900 a year will actually gain £16 3s. 6d.; with £1,200 a year £5 18s. and he will have to earn £1,400 before he will be asked to pay £2 2s. extra. A married man with four children earning £800 a year will gain £6 18s. 6d.; earning £1,000 a year he will gain £16 12s.; and earning £1,400 a year he will gain £1 1s. 1d.; and he will have to earn £1,500 a year before he will be asked to pay £2 19s. extra.
Let us hear no more about the ordinary man having to pay extra income-tax under this Budget for the ordinary man is getting a fairly substantial relief. In some cases that relief will represent the equivalent of at least 5/- per week to make up, admittedly, for what he will have to pay because of the removal of the subsidies. In addition to that—and this is something I have not heard mentioned here to-day although I have been in the House almost continuously since 12 o'clock—there are increased allowances for children. I remember that Deputy Dillon, when the first Children's Allowances Act was introduced, praised the then Government for its introduction. In future, instead of having 2/6 for the third child there will be 2/6 for the second child and 4/- for each subsequent child. I regard these allowances as one of the best social services we can give our people. From the Christian point of view, it is an excellent social service. In relation to the extra burden which will fall upon families because of the removal of the subsidies these allowances will go a long way towards making some compensation; I have not actually worked out the details but it is clear that they will go a good part of the way towards meeting the increased cost of food.
Nobody on the Opposition Benches while I was in the House referred to that particular aspect of the matter but we had several people telling us that it was the poor who would have to bear the burden. I think an honest attempt has been made in this Budget to face the fact that money had to be found but the burden has been placed, as far as it was humanly possible to do so, on the shoulders of those best able to bear it.
Deputy Larkin referred to Fianna Fáil in relation to its social security programme and its social services as being pushed from behind and only taking one hesitating step at a time. It seems to me rather extraordinary that a Labour leader, who was so recently linked with the Fine Gael Party, should try to insinuate that Fianna Fáil did not do anything in connection with social services. As Deputy Dr. Browne said the other day, social services started in 1933. Because we were not foolish enough not to take account of our finances, because we tried to live within our means and not kill the goose that laid the golden egg, we proceeded bit by bit and parctically every year saw some new aid for the under-dog.
There are £3,000,000 provided in this Budget for the implementation of the Social Welfare Bill at present before the House. Under the Coalition Government Deputy Larkin's leader was in charge of that Department but he did nothing in the three and a quarter years he was there. Instead of being a Welfare Bill it was, as some of us predicted, his farewell Bill. Even if he had remained in office for the remainder of the five-year period it would still have been his farewell Bill because the Coalition Government never had any serious intention of putting it through.
Comment on this
There were too many differences of opinion about it. Perhaps it was not Deputy Norton's fault. He was in earnest about it, I believe, and I give him credit for it, but it would have been another matter to get it through the Coalition. We have heard a good deal about the removal of the food subsidies but those subsidies are being replaced by a permanent increase in social benefits. Food subsidies were always regarded as being of a temporary nature and nobody contemplated them as a permanency. They will now be replaced for those who really need them by permanent social services. I think every reasonable Deputy will agree that that is right. I think every reasonable Deputy will agree that it was time we got away from the position in which the poor were actually helping to pay taxes to give subsidies to those who could well afford to meet prices. That is what we were doing up to now.
I have dealt with the change in the income-tax code. That change will affect every tradesman, the lower middle classes, the white collar workers, the lower civil servants and the huge bulk of those who pay income-tax. Under Schedule E, of 151,000 income-taxpayers 145,000 will pay less. Only 6,000 will pay more and therefore 95 per cent. of the working people who pay income-tax will actually benefit.
Deputy Larkin also referred to the increases in the cost of living over the last nine months. As I pointed out here, the cost of living was rising even before the Korean war. Undoubtedly the Korean war and the world situation had their effect on prices in this country. So far as that goes, I am not blaming the Coalition Government, for no Government could avoid the consequences of that but there were certain other things which happened here. We know that they were elected on the plea that they were going to reduce the cost of living and the only attempt that was made, was made in panic when the Standstill Price Order was brought in, an Order which had the effect, to my own personal knowledge, of legalising the profiteer in the City of Dublin.
Comment on this
That Order, to my own personal knowledge, legalised the profiteer and when we asked what were the legal prices on the 2nd December, the date set out in the Order, we were told that they could not be given, that it was not feasible to give them. That was the attempt of Deputy Norton and the men who came into this House and told us all about what this Order was going to do, to deal with the price situation while they were in power. Deputy Larkin knows perfectly well that every increase, except one or two that were refused for policy sake by the then Government, has been sanctioned and approved of by the Prices Advisory Committee set up by the Coalition Government. He knows that a large number of these Orders were already in the hands of the Minister in the Coalition Government before the change took place and he knows that the present Government had to face the odium of putting those Orders into operation. If they had not been put into operation, we would have had to face another problem, with places closing down completely and not being able to carry on. Surely nobody is going to suggest that the Labour representatives on the Prices Advisory Tribunal are agreeing to those increases unless there is necessity for them and they have been justified. Nothing that this Government did at that time could possibly have increased prices.
I think it is time, considering all that we heard about the matter in 1948, and the lack of effort there was on the part of the Coalition Government to carry out their promises to the electors, or to deal with the question of prices at all, that they would keep silent about it. We all have to face the fact that this money must be found. Facing that fact, I think that anyone who tries to examine this Budget as impartially as he can must be driven to the conclusion that it is a courageous and a good Budget, that it is trying to meet the appalling gap in our finances by putting the cost of meeting that gap on the shoulders of those best able to bear it. I do not think we shall gain anything by trying to run away from the fact that these deficits have been accumulating over the years and that the sooner we face up to this the easier it will be for the people, hard as it may now seem—and I am not denying it is going to create a certain amount of hardship—to get over the present difficulty. I think anybody who examines the position will realise that it is much better to face it this year than to postpone it to next year, or a year later, when the hardship would be far greater.
Comment on this
I miss the portly figure of Deputy Burke from these deliberations. At least, if he could not give any advice to his Minister in his great trouble, he might do what he does for his constituents now and again— he might lead the Fianna Fáil Party and its adherents in supplication. I think the nearest point he hovered to the Chamber since the debate began was to put his head inside the door to see how things were going, to see was the Dáil dissolved yet and had we to go to the country. Of course, this is a Budget of a sadist. It is a Budget that could be conceived only in the mind of a man who was completely cut off from the people of the country, who cared nothing about what the people felt, how they had to live, how they had to work, what they got for working or what their problems were. Not, indeed, that there is anything new in Deputy MacEntee's displaying these sadistic proclivities when it comes to dealing with the working people.
There is nothing new in that. Those of us who have any kind of memory will recall the days when men were compelled to do what Deputy Dr. Browne has described as unproductive work, and inferred in a certain fashion as being a despicable occupation—when men were compelled to take up road work, and there are thousands of them who have to do that work because they can get no other. It is not very long since, when these men were seeking an increase in their wages of 37/6 per week, the present Minister for Finance said: "A shilling a week is enough for them" although the cost of living was sky-rocketing at the time. It is no great surprise therefore for us to find Deputy MacEntee in his capacity as Minister for Finance coming in with this savage onslaught on the people of Ireland. All the vaporising that went on here yesterday and this afternoon when we were treated to a sample of Deputy Vivion de Valera's eloquence for over two hours, about the balance of payments, the dollar gap and our external assets—all that airy effluvia that went on, is of very little good to the people of Ballyfermot or the people of my constituency the bulk of whom have to find their living by the sweat of their brow and many of whom have to find their living in underpaid white-collar occupations. When they picked up this morning's paper they read "Bread gone up again by 50 per cent." I suppose the Minister for Finance has not been in the household of an agricultural worker or a road worker since he was down inciting the small landholders of Kilsallaghan some 25 years ago to get the Carter estate divided amongst themselves.
Comment on this
It was the start of a long political career and Deputy Dunne may have the same sort of career, now that he has started.
Comment on this
Now, we have the Minister's defender. In my comparatively short period as a member of the House and my short experience of politics, I have seen a couple of examples of political somersaulting.
Comment on this
The Lord bless and save us. Did anybody ever conceive that Deputy Cowan, whom I listened to myself in the Engineers' Hall on an occasion that he remembers——
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is this a debate on the virtues of the honourable Deputy Cowan or on the Budget?
Comment on this
That is not a point of order. Deputy Dunne should get back to the discussion before the House.
Comment on this
I will. I never thought, Peadar, that I would see the day. I am glad to see my colleague, Deputy Burke, has at last arrived.
Comment on this
I think that is a small, petty point. Deputy Burke is as often in the House as Deputy Dunne, if not oftener.
Comment on this
I would appeal to the obdurate Deputy Cowan to try and keep his temper, because, in discussing this Budget and in criticising the Fianna Fáil Party, I do not, unlike Deputy Burke, say a thing behind a man's back, as he likes to do about me.
Comment on this
I want to say, on behalf of the people of the County Dublin, whether they are living in the suburban areas of the city, or the thousands who reside in Ballyfermot and who have to find an occupation as best they can in industry in this city—hundreds of them are now unemployed as a result of Fianna Fáil policy—I want to say on their behalf and on behalf of the thousands of agricultural workers who are trying to eke out an existence on £4 5s. per week in County Dublin, on behalf of the industrial workers in the town of Balbriggan, whom Deputy Burke has tried to mislead on many an occasion, and on behalf of the small, working farmers in North and South County Dublin, because I know I am speaking their minds regardless of how they voted the last time, whether they voted for or against me or for or against Fianna Fáil, that they regard this Budget as a criminal imposition upon them, and that they are longing to-night for the opportunity to go to the polls and banish this Minister for Finance, who has been inflicted upon this country by a minority Government, from political life for once and for all.
Comment on this
Well, I am sure if anyone ever undertakes that national task Deputy Cowan will be at hand to defend him. I think, so far as that is concerned, Deputy Cowan should not indulge in any reference to his militaristic activities. We all know his record in that direction.
Comment on this
I was two years of age at the time Deputy Burke is talking about. Of course, everybody knows that Deputy Burke sports a medal, but nobody knows how he got it. We have a good idea.
Comment on this
That is not relevant. The Deputy should confine himself to what is before the House.
Comment on this
There has been, as I have said, a good deal of reference to the gap which is stated to exist between the income and expenditure accounts as presented to this Dáil, and to the need for bridging that gap. I say "stated to exist" because I want to bring the minds of members of the House back to Deputy Morrissey's revelation here this evening where it was proved beyond yea or nay, and not contradicted by the Minister for Finance, that the Budget figures are not accurate and cannot be relied upon in relation to the number of motor registrations in the country. If that is true of one set of figures in so important a document as the Budget, then, as has been truly said, what reliance can be put on the rest of the figures that have been brought before us for our consideration?
Of course, there are some figures that represent hard facts that we cannot get away from, such, for instance, as those relating to butter. Deputy Colley when speaking, referred to Deputy Larkin's speech which was made this morning. Deputy Colley said that there had been no increase in any commodity since the advent to power of this Government without the prior recommendation of the Prices Advisory Body. Deputy Colley has a short memory. Do we not all remember that, in a frantic effort to curry favour with the farming community, the gentlemen now in government were not there two days until we learned that butter was going up by 2d. per lb.? There was no reference to the Prices Advisory Body. The people of Dublin could pay it; they were going to be made pay it, and there was going to be no examination of farmer's costings or anything else. There had to be ground recovered which had been lost, or at least an effort made in that direction. There was political ground to be recovered, and the farmers were given 2d. per lb. of an increase within a couple of days of this Government's re-election.
Comment on this
That was followed, of course, by an increase in the price of milk, and, again, who was going to pay that but the ordinary working people? "Sure, they will put up with it as long as we are doing it; we are the party which represents all the people," as Deputy Burke is so fond of saying—all things to all men, mar dheadh, on every side of the fence at once.
However, that was not enough. It was not enough that the working people of this city were asked to pay exorbitant rents in many cases in the new housing schemes at Ballyfermot and Finglas. It was not enough that these people have had to work for so little wages and found the cost of living during the past 12 months making it next door to impossible for them to live. It was not enough that those people should have to pay another 2d. per lb. on butter, bringing it up to 3/- a lb., but along comes this sadist of a Minister to put 10d. a lb. on butter yesterday. I will be happy to see the acrobatics that Deputy Burke and a few more of the gentlemen on the Government side will go through in the next few months trying to explain that away.
Sugar was likewise increased by almost 25 per cent. We were told this morning by that impartial political organ, the Irish Press, which is famous for its absolute impartiality and for the degree of fairness that enters into its political articles, that tea will average 5/6 a lb. and that the price of the loaf of bread will be increased from 6d. to 9d. Have they no conscience at all? Is there no stir of independence in the minds of any member of Fianna Fáil that they would troop into the Lobby, just like so many sheep, and vote for this crime against the people of this country?
Comment on this
It would be much better to get the people increased wages to meet those increased prices. That should be the policy of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
The only thing that I can suggest for Deputy Captain Cowan is an interview with a psychiatrist. I make that suggestion in all charity. Of course, there are people who will say that cigarettes and tobacco are luxuries and that people can do without those things. My view always has been that, when a consumable commodity comes into widespread use among normal people and among average people, then it is no longer a luxury. It does not enter into the category of being a necessity. People can live without it but, nevertheless, it is no longer a luxury. In putting the impost of 7d. on the packet of 20 cigarettes an added burden of immeasurable proportions has been placed upon the working people. Of course, it does not matter to those who have plenty of the world's goods and plenty of money. Another 7d. on the packet of 20 cigarettes does not mean so much to them but it means a great deal though to the thousands who live on a wage of £3 10/-, £4, £5 or £6 a week and who try to bring up a family at the same time and who have always been used to indulging in a cigarette or, perhaps, a pipeful of tobacco or a pint of beer.
It is of interest to note that there are in this country approximately 150,000 farm workers working for wages, the average wage being between £3 10/- and £3 15/- per week.
Comment on this
Words are lightly spoken. What is the use of talking about inadequate wages when you walk into the Lobby and vote to have a higher charge put on these men for the bare necessaries of life?
Comment on this
If Deputy Killilea wants a discussion on that basis I will get down to it and he will come out of it the worst.
Comment on this
What is being done to to help the agricultural worker by this Budget? This Budget in my view—I say this as seriously as I can and with as much knowledge of and contact with the agricultural workers as any man in this country—will decimate the number of people working on the land. It will drive them from the land. It will drive them from the land the man who is earning £3 15s. a week throughout the country and who is living in a county council cottage. That type of man, as we know, is a good Christian and tries to live as he does and walk upright through this world. Everybody knows that the people of whom I speak are the decentest that God created.
Comment on this
I was about to say that these people are usually blessed with large families. I suppose that the average family of a farm worker would be four or five children. How is he out of £3 15s. to pay more for his butter? Many farmers do not give him butter at all although some would try to give the illusion that they do. He has to pay more for sugar and tea and he has to pay half as much more for his bread. If that type of man is in the habit of smoking a cigarette he can forget about it now. If he has gone off the cigarettes for Lent, the rest of his life will be Lent so long as Fianna Fáil remains in power. The same applies to beer. However, he has the tremendous satisfaction of answering the appeal of the Minister for Finance to save his money and put it in the Post Office Savings Bank. When he has paid all these increased taxes, fed, clothed, educated his children and sent them to the university out of the £3 15s. he can put the rest in the Post Office Savings Bank!
Comment on this
I would suggest to Deputy Cowan that that remark comes strange from any individual in this House or outside of it who walked into the Lobby and put greater hardships on the agricultural workers by increased taxes and who not so long ago walked into the Lobby and voted against a motion to increase the wages of agricultural workers.
Comment on this
The wages of County Dublin workers. They were to get more than agricultural workers elsewhere because they were Deputy Dunne's constituents. That was the motion. Give more to Deputy Dunne's County Dublin workers and less to the workers of Meath. That was political hypocrisy.
Comment on this
He has completed the full circle on the question of budgets and on this Budget in particular. Does the Deputy remember the encounter between Deputy Burke and Deputy Cowan at Swords in the by-election of 1947 and the compliments that were exchanged about the emergency Budget?
Comment on this
I was going to say that this Budget has been met throughout the country with absolute consternation by the people.
We have had a good deal of talk about political honesty and the desirability of letting people know what the actual economic situation is. In the 1914 war, the slogan used was that it was to make the world safe for democracy.
Comment on this
I was going to add, if the Deputy will be sufficiently orderly to allow me, that this present Government is trying to make Ireland safe for hypocrisy. When I hear certain Deputies talking about political honesty and consistency, it tends to make me physically sick. How anybody can justify a Budget which grinds further down the ordinary mass of the people and at the same time takes the tax off dancing, so that when the people are reduced to a condition of near starvation, they may indulge in the terpsichorean art——
Comment on this
I make you a present of that. I will spell it for you sometime. Any Government which would introduce a Budget such as that is completely out of touch with the people. It has been obvious to those who sat through the long, dreary homily of the Minister for Finance yesterday that very few people knew what was in the Budget. It is quite obvious that the Tánaiste was very perturbed over the Budget and, being the wily politician that he is and knowing how the political winds blow, he was not in love with this policy which was obviously forced on the Cabinet by the Minister for Finance, ably abetted, I am sure, by the Taoiseach, because nobody will suggest that the Taoiseach is in touch with the lives of the ordinary people.
He lives in a world of his own, held up there by the Party in a kind of cocoon. He is inviolable and dare you say a word about him. I recall that some years ago, when a Deputy now supporting the Government ventured a word or two of criticism, he was almost assassinated by some of the gentlemen with whom he is now consorting.
It is obvious that this Budget represents the imposition by the Minister for Finance of his peculiar atrophied outlook on life upon the Fianna Fáil capitalists, who, regardless of whether or not they care for the people, have one thing in common —they care for their own political self-preservation, and that instinct for self-preservation was obviously thrown to the wind yesterday by the Minister for Finance. It was a study to look at the faces of the Fianna Fáil Party while the document was being read. Deputy Burke could hardly stomach it and had to leave the House. If we have an election very shortly, I hope he will not have the unfortunate experience of leaving it permanently. The Budget, in all its aspects, shows the complete failure of the Fianna Fáil policy.
Last week some Deputies took part in a discussion about social welfare. It was boasted then that the present Government were bringing in a Bill to provide social welfare benefits, but they were not half as good as those set out in Deputy Norton's Bill last year. The most important provisions of that Bill, such as death benefits, increased maternity benefits and attendance allowances were left out. It was boasted then by the Minister for Social Welfare that he was only looking for 5d. additional contribution from the workers——
Comment on this
I only want to say that the additional 5d. now becomes something in the neighbourhood of 10/- or 12/- a week as a minimum, because until yesterday the plan that Fianna Fáil had in store for the workers was concealed from them. The workers are to be asked to pay 5d. additional per week, but Fianna Fáil propose to rob them of every single advantage which had been won for them by Labour and trade union agitation during the last 20 years. They are to be deprived of the subsidies on butter, sugar, tea, bread and flour and the price of cigarettes, tobacco, beer and spirits is to be increased and no matter what Deputy Colley may say, there are many workers also who will have their income-tax increased as a result of the imposition announced yesterday.
It is perfectly plain now that the social welfare benefits which are supposed to come into operation on July 1st will be paid for over and over again by the workers of the country. When Deputy Norton wanted a contribution of 3/6 a week, that was a crime. This butcher of a Minister for Finance we now have, who is picking the bones of the workers of the country, demands anything from 12/- to £1 from every household. I cannot find any more adequate words to describe the activities of this Minister. I regret that he is not here. Perhaps his presence might inspire me to greater heights in regard to a suitable description for him. But, as surely as we are in this House, this Budget will reduce to a "new low", the standard of living of the people.
There have been challenges thrown out to the Government to have an election and some Deputies who support the Government have announced that they will not advise having a dissolution for at least another 12 months. I suppose we will find a difficulty in forcing this Government out. We all know very well that they will hang on for dear life at least until the terrible impact of these things wears off and the people become a bit drugged again. I make this challenge to my colleague —I will charitably describe him as my colleague—in County Dublin in regard to this Budget: I will resign my seat if he will resign his, and I will fight County Dublin on the issue of this Budget.
Comment on this
He is asking the two of them to resign and fight for two seats so that both of them could be elected again.
Comment on this
This Budget represents a terrible tyranny brought in by people who do not care anything for the ordinary people of the country. Some effort must be made to bring them to a realisation of their responsibility. We cannot put them out by discussion or debate because they will hang on like barnacles because they know that the next election will mean their political doom. It is impossible to express adequately the feelings of the people whom I represent on this matter. I am speaking on behalf of the people of my own constituency of County Dublin but I think I can also say a few words on behalf of the vast majority of the rural workers throughout the country who as I have indicated are living on bare subsistence level and in many cases far below it. Many of these men trooped to the polling booths to put many of the Fianna Fáil Deputies where they are.
Comment on this
Do you not think there is any limit to human stupidity? Do you think you could fool the people all the time? Just give them the chance and if you do you will shake the dust of Leinster House from your heels no matter how long you have been here and you will never see that august building again.
Comment on this
I think that, politically, this Budget may be described as anything but a popular one.
Comment on this
That, I think, will be accepted by everybody in this House and the introduction of a Budget which is not popular suggests some sense of responsibility. Any Government that is irresponsible may introduce what is known as a popular Budget, but a Budget is simply financial provision for the year based on the facts and circumstances at the time the Budget is introduced. If the Government is satisfied that the facts and circumstances justify increased taxation and, because of a desire for popularity or a desire for political success, do not make the provision in taxation that is necessary or which they consider necessary, that Government, in my view, would be irresponsible.
Comment on this
I think any Deputy who has considered the matter will come to the conclusion that that is so. Last night, in a short interruption, I made what I intended to be a joke, and which was regarded by the House as being a joke and accepted as such when I said that, in the circumstances, I would not advise a dissolution for at least 12 months.
Comment on this
Clearly, that was accepted by everyone as a joke, but I only mention the matter to-day because Deputy Larkin has used that observation in a way entirely different to what I intended to make the case that it was a cynical comment on Irish politics that my approach to the Budget was that it would not suit me to have an election in the next 12 months. That is what he said to-day.
Comment on this
That is not what I said last night. Deputy Larkin and I were associated in many undertakings and activities over a period of 20 years, and I always considered that he made a reasonable approach to problems. I feel to-day, having listened to him make that statement, that he has degenerated a lot in the last 20 years. I want to say that, having known him so long, having known his ideals and objectives, I have been as disappointed with him as have many of the people who had faith and confidence in him in the Labour movement. I do know that, over the past ten or 15 years, as far as Deputy Larkin is concerned——
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is an attack on Deputy Larkin relevant to the matters we are discussing?
Comment on this
You were appealing to the Chair to protect Deputy Larkin some years ago, when Deputy Everett said he was a Communist.
Comment on this
Many people like myself have been disappointed at the abject surrender of his ideals and responsibilities by Deputy Larkin. When Deputy Larkin comes into this House and, in the course of a debate such as this, refers to what he terms my cynical approach to the Budget, I find it necessary to answer him bluntly in this House. Everybody knows that at this moment within the Labour Party there is a campaign going on to remove Deputy Norton out of the position of leadership and to install Deputy Larkin in his place.
Comment on this
I listened here to Deputy Dillon speaking on this Budget and what did Deputy Dillon introduce? He said that this was the third attack made by Fianna Fáil on the people.
Comment on this
The first being the civil war, and he was applauded for that by the Deputies on those benches.
Comment on this
No. Deputy MacBride was not here nor were some of the Labour Party Deputies. This shows the solidarity of this Opposition. There is nothing in common between Deputy Dunne and the speech he made there a few moments ago and Deputy Giles, Deputy Rooney or any of the Deputies there. They represent two different parts and aspects of Irish life.