We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).

Contributions 373–562 of 562. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

When I listened to Deputy Dillon making that speech and recollected that he once voted to put Fianna Fáil into power and when I recollect the attack by Deputy Mulcahy on him then——

Comment on this

What about the price of beer?

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy is interested in the price of beer. That is what we had here to-day. We had an attack on the Government's policy in removing subsidies. When Deputy McGilligan introduced his Budget two or three years ago I spoke on this problem of the food subsidies. I gave it as my opinion then, supporting the then Government and Deputy McGilligan at the time, that I would like to see this whole problem of food subsidies examined—what benefit a household got through the subsidies and how much they contributed in taxation to provide those subsidies, because, if I may use a word of Deputy Seán Collins, I was not "wedded" to this idea of the food subsidies.

I was interested to-day to refer back —I seldom do it—to the debate in 1947 when these food subsidies were under discussion. Here is what Deputy Norton said about them at column 435. Volume 108 of the 15th October, 1947:—

"The highlight of the documents put before us is, I take it, the subsidies to reduce the prices of tea, bread and sugar. I think these are sham reductions."

That is what Deputy Norton said, that the subsidies are "sham reductions".

Comment on this

Read on.

Comment on this

I will read exactly what I want to read and no more:—

"These are sham reductions. I do not think they make any perceptible contribution to relieving the plight of the ordinary working people to-day."

Do you want me to read further? Should I read the whole debate? I am not going to do that. This is what Deputy Morrissey said—this came as news to me. I had some time to spare, so I read this while I was waiting to be called on to speak.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

On a point of order, Deputy Cowan was very anxious last night that references should be given.

Comment on this

I have given the reference.

Comment on this

Read what the Minister said about you last year.

Comment on this

Here is what Deputy Morrissey said at column 641 of the same volume on the 16th October, 1947, dealing with this Supplementary Budget:—

"The people do not know all the blessings that will be poured upon them. The reliefs are spread over three items—bread, sugar and tea. Fortunately, the three of them are rationed, and we know what each citizen is entitled to—6 lb. of bread, 2 oz. of tea and ¾ lb. of sugar for a week. Let us measure the fullness of this blessed relief that the unfortunate taxpayer will get and to what extent the cost of living will be reduced. With 1½d. off the 4 lb. loaf that means 2¼d. on 6 lb. of bread. Each person is entitled to 2 oz. of tea. There is a reduction of 2/2 in the lb. One-eighth of 2/2 is 3¼d. You are entitled to ¾ lb. of sugar and a reduction of 2d. in the lb. is a 1¼d. on that. Tot it up and what do you find? This relief, this blessing, this gesture of Fianna Fáil to settle this dangerous situation, is equivalent to 1d. per person per day. This is the Budget that is going to reduce the cost of living."

Comment on this

And carrying £6,500,000 tax to do that.

Comment on this

That is what Deputy Morrissey said in 1947. I have quoted what Deputy Norton said that day in 1947, and now, when these subsidies are removed, we heard what Deputy Larkin said to-day, what Deputy Dunne said to-night and what Deputy Morrissey said about them this evening. I consider, and I said it on the Budget in the years from 1948 up to last year, that the question of the food subsidies ought to be examined, because I felt, and it has been brought to my notice, that there has been a tragic waste of food under the subsidy system.

Take butter. What do we find in regard to butter at the moment? We find that rations of butter are being distributed from the creameries with a subsidy on them to shops in the West of Ireland. The taxpayers are paying subsidies on that butter, and we find racketeers going to the shops, collecting the butter there, taking it up to the city here and selling it to retailers, who sell it over the counter at 3/10 or 4/-.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

That is preposterous.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Sullivan says it is preposterous.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

You are criticising the administration of the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Sullivan says "preposterous". I am stating an absolute fact. If Deputy O'Sullivan had read the evening papers for the last month he would have seen where numerous shopkeepers had been fined very heavily in Dublin for engaging in that traffic. Is that a desirable state of affairs?

Comment on this

That is good for business.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cowan must be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

But it is not good for the nation. Is that a situation that anybody wants? Is it a desirable situation and in what way can we put an end to it? Only by the steps that have been taken by the Minister in his Budget.

Comment on this

Do you believe that, Deputy?

Comment on this

I do believe it. Credo. Let us examine the question of bread. The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us to-day and the Minister for Finance told us in his Budget statement yesterday that there is going to be a whiter loaf—a more edible loaf. Everybody knows and, indeed, attention has been drawn to the fact very often, that bread, baked in loaves, has been fed to dogs and to pigs because it was such a cheap food. There has been a wastage of bread because people found that when threequarters of the loaf had been cut it was left aside for a while, and that it was difficult to eat the remainder. Therefore, there has been an extraordinary wastage of bread all over the country—bread for which a subsidy has been paid by the taxpayer. I feel that is a situation which is known to every Deputy in this House. I know myself that Deputy Mulcahy is not a great lover of the food subsidies.

Comment on this

What?

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy, as I understand it, and he can correct me if I am wrong, has been opposed to these food subsidies.

Comment on this

What?

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy, as I understand it, and he can correct me if I am wrong, has been opposed to these food subsidies.

Comment on this

That is very interesting. It should have been known before.

Comment on this

I think it was known to the inter-Party Government that it was Deputy Mulcahy's views on Budget planning that these subsidies should go.

Comment on this

But they did not go.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy was of the opinion that it was sound national policy to abolish them.

Comment on this

Is that so?

Comment on this

Some other people thought it was not, so they just hung there until now. Now we will not have a waste of bread all through the city and country in respect of which a subsidy is being paid by the taxpayer. That has been happening long enough, and it is time something was done about it.

On the question of tea. The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us to-day that people will have an opportunity of buying different brands of tea at different prices, that some of the tea that can be purchased will be cheaper than the present rationed tea and that some of it will be dearer. I feel there are many thousands of families in this country who will be glad to be able to get a better quality tea, even if they have to pay more for it, than they are getting at the moment.

Comment on this

And the tea racket will be killed.

Comment on this

The abolition of rationing in regard to these commodities is a good thing for this reason also. Customers will not be tied, as they have been up to now, to particular shopkeepers. They can buy the goods that have been rationed up to the present wherever they like. In my view, that is desirable.

We come now to the other items which are taxed, namely cigarettes, beer and spirits. We had a very valuable contribution last night from Deputy O. Flanagan on this subject.

Comment on this

I am just reading your speech of the 10th March——

Comment on this

What year?

Comment on this

The 10th March, 1948. It is very interesting.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy that he will get magnificent material in that speech, and I can recommend to him some better speeches that I made.

Three main items on which additional taxes have to be put are cigarettes, beer and spirits. Is it not better that a tax should be put on those articles which are, in effect, luxuries than that it should be put on necessities?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Is dancing a necessity?

Comment on this

I am not interested in dancing.

Comment on this

Is bread a luxury?

Comment on this

I say it is better that these articles should bear the taxation necessary to maintain the administration of this State, to maintain employment, to maintain the Civil Service, the Gardaí, the Army and all these other organisations which depend on the Government for the means of existence. If we compare the price of cigarettes with the price in England, we will find that there is a big difference. The same holds good as regards the price of beer and spirits.

Comment on this

It will not be an argument against Partition.

Comment on this

England is our standard.

Comment on this

I am speaking about the countries nearest to us, the administrations nearest to us, and the country with which we have very continuous association. Our people who go over there, and come back after a period, are amazed that they can procure cigarettes, beer and spirits at the prices operating here.

Comment on this

Spirits are low to-day.

Comment on this

The Budget provides for additional taxation, but, if it does, it makes a counter contribution which I consider to be very valuable. The increase in children's allowances from 2/6 to 4/- is a very valuable increase, and the granting of a new allowance at the rate of 2/6 for the second child in a family is a very welcome addition to the finances of that family. There are many families in the State who will benefit by this transfer of cash from the central funds to the family. The increase in the weekly contributions to the old age pensioners, to the widows and to the unemployed will be very helpful to them.

As the Minister has said, and as has been stressed to-day, the alteration in the income-tax code makes very valuable contributions to the worker—the white-collar worker in particular who is earning up to £1,000 or £1,200 a year. The allowance provided in the Budget is very satisfactory so far as the person in receipt of £300, £400, and £500 a year is concerned. What are we to consider when we come to examine the Budget? We are to consider the state of the national finances and the provision that must be made to meet them in the coming year. We have to do as any prudent housewife has to do. We have to do an ordinary bit of housekeeping budgeting.

Comment on this

It would want to be extraordinary housekeeping.

Comment on this

Every family endeavours to live within its means. It is the duty and responsibility of the nation to do the same in the interests of all the people. That is what is being done in this Budget. The Minister has set out to put the finances of the State in order. I consider that it is necessary that they should be put in order. It is necessary in the interests of all the people who depend on the State, old age pensioners, widows and orphans, families who receive children's allowances, civil servants, the Garda, the Army.

Comment on this

What about your own army? Is your own army included in that?

Comment on this

They all depend on the State and if the State does not make proper provision for them, then, we will arrive at a state if catastrophe in the country.

Comment on this

They were disappointed last June when you joined Fianna Fáil, or are they on reserve?

Comment on this

Deputy Flanagan is all right delivering the type of speech he can deliver down in Ballycumber or somewhere like that.

Comment on this

And here, too.

Comment on this

He delivers the same type of speech here as in Ballycumber. There is no difference.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Cowan must be mixing me up with Deputy Boland. Deputy Boland is from Ballycumber.

Comment on this

There is no difference whatever between the Deputy's approach here and in Ballycumber. He just shouts around from those benches the same as he does from the side of a ditch.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

And gets a few thousand votes therefor.

Comment on this

Did you hear what Deputy Dunne said about stupidity?

Comment on this

I never had to sing "Peadar on the Treetop" to get in.

Comment on this

I would suggest to Deputy O'Sullivan, to whom I appear to be some type of red rag every time I get up, and Deputy Flanagan that they might practise the amount of self-restraint that would enable them to hear the truth now and again. Deputy Flanagan announced last night that he is not going to smoke cigarettes.

Comment on this

Not one.

Comment on this

That will require some restraint. I think he ought to practise it while I am speaking. If the Government does not make provision for maintaining the finances of the nation, we are going to have a crisis in a short time. Whom will that crisis affect? It will affect all the people that I have mentioned, the old age pensioner, the widow and orphan, the families receiving children's allowances, every employee of the State, every civil servant, every member of the Army, every member of the Garda and their families. It is better that every one of us should tighten the belt one little bit for a time until we get over the crisis. What is the alternative?

Comment on this

That is revolutionary talk.

Comment on this

Revolution is right. Imagine Deputy Hickey leading any type of revolution. A good follower would be Deputy Davin.

Comment on this

Will you lend me your army?

Comment on this

What is the alternative? That question has been asked to-day. I know that Deputy MacEoin agrees with this because he has stated it so often. If we as a nation do not tax ourselves and provide the money necessary to run the State we have to get it from somebody else and there is only one place where we can get it without any trouble to-morrow. We can get it from America. All the money that we need to balance our Budget, we can get it to-morrow from America.

Comment on this

Who holds our sterling assets?

Comment on this

Try Stalin.

Comment on this

I do not think he is giving away money in that way. I will ask him the next time I see him. If we want money we can get it from the United States of America. We can balance this Budget without any trouble. Some people may say to me, as has been said to me, "You have changed. You are on the wrong side." I am on this side for this reason— because I wanted to make it impossible for the Americans to buy this country—I am satisfied that the Taoiseach and Ministers of this Government would not sell the country to America. That is why I am here. That is why I am on this side and let there be no doubt about that.

Comment on this

The same as the Six Counties were sold.

Comment on this

We can fight out our own battles in Ireland about socialism and all that. We will have plenty of time to do it but we would have neither time nor opportunity for such a fight if this nation were in the state that some other nations are in to-day, tied hand and foot to a big nation like America, Russia or any other country. We want to preserve our freedom. We want to preserve our liberty. That may mean extra taxation but extra taxation is a much smaller sacrifice than men had to render in the past to secure the liberty of this country.

Comment on this

God forgive you.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Many words have been used to describe this Budget. I am afraid I am going to add two new ones. I emphatically assert that this Budget is both outrageous and spiteful, as I will clearly demonstrate in the course of my argument. We have no doubt in our minds that the answer given by the Irish people to the Fianna Fáil Administration as a result of the catastrophic Supplementary Budget that they introduced in 1947 is one of the root causes of the spite that we see in this Budget. On that occasion —and the Provost Marshal may giggle but it will not get him out of this— they introduced taxation for the purpose of paying food subsidies. On this occasion, the "Great I-am" having been transgressed upon, they are going back to the country to impose with a vicious thrust greater and more severe taxation in the same direction and at the same time they are eliminating the food subsidies. That is interesting. It is going to be more interesting as the story unfolds itself, particularly when one appreciates the political background to the mandate that Fianna Fáil now allege they have for their activity.

"Mandate" was a wonderful word of the Taoiseach's, Eamonn de Valera, and I am going to demonstrate in the course of my speech that Fianna Fáil have no mandate for this and that, far from the Independents having a mandate, they were elected, and sought election, on a policy positively, categorically and diametrically opposed to what they are now voting for in the Lobbies.

It was interesting to see the disappearance of the Cork heroes. I have their election address here. The four heroes were Deputy Alderman McGrath, Deputy Alderman Seán MacCarthy, Deputy Alderman Jack Lynch and the Lord Mayor of Cork, who has since seen the light and left the fold, Alderman Furlong. They campaigned viciously and virulently throughout the City of Cork declaring that the last Government was wrong, outrageous and had let the cost of living increase—mark you I am going to quote this document—that everything had gone up under the inter-Party Government. Deputy McGrath, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, Deputy Lynch, and Deputy MacCarthy, all conspicuous by their absence, campaigned, saying that in 1947 beef was 2/- a lb. and under the inter-Party Government sirloin beef had gone up to 2/8. They must not have bought beef since Fianna Fáil came into office, because we now know that it is 3/2. Mutton had gone up according to them by 51/2d. per lb. and reached the astronomical figure of 2/4. Now try and buy a sirloin chop or a centre mutton chop or a mutton joint and you will find that it costs 3/- per lb. They were howling about the increase in the cost of living and this was before any of the impositions which are now to come. They said that under their Government streaky bacon cost 1/11½d. and back bacon 2/11.

They say that we let them go up to 3/4 and 3/7. I would like those "bould" heroes to go out any Saturday instead of their respective wives to buy either streaky bacon or back bacon at the price to which they said we allowed it to rise and which they said was fantastic. This was long before the present impact from our hair-shirt, doleful, mournful, bad-tempered Minister for Finance, who got up to give us his 71 pages of fallacy yesterday. Throughout the length and breadth of the City of Cork these worthy warriors moaned and groaned. They said that backs were creaking, that the burden was getting impossible to carry, but that the housewife was safe in the hands of Fianna Fáil. God help the poor disillusioned woman this morning.

The national advertisement of the Fianna Fáil Party is worthy of note and of a place on the records of the House:—

"Fianna Fáil began the system of food subsidies to keep down the cost of living by reducing the price of essential foods. Do not let the Coalition propagandists deceive you. The workers' interests are safe with Fianna Fáil."

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

"You can trust Dev."

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

We have a new Deputy in the House. I regret that he is not present, but his worthy pal is present, so I will not do anything unfair in quoting from the circular of Deputy Dr. french-O'Carroll to the poor misguided people of his part of Dublin which includes part of Crumlin. I would love him to go there next Sunday and see what the people of Crumlin think of him. He said:—

"If elected by you, I promise to focus attention on the cost of living and to press for increased subsidies on food."

The cerebral gymnastics of Deputy Peadar Cowan are in no way comparable with those of Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll, who walked into the Lobby with his new-found political masters, not to increase the food subsidies, not even to keep them at the present level, but to ensure that the burden on the already over-burdened back of the housewife in his constituency, the working-class person with a small or large family, would be made intolerable. Interesting: he is going to focus all attention on the cost of living!

In the course of his election address he made some further interesting observations apropos of food subsidies. They were his pièce de résistance. He said:—

"All political Parties have failed in their undertaking to the electorate to reduce the cost of living."

The new Lochinvar has come out of West Crumlin.

Comment on this

Is it quite in order for the Deputy to have his back to the Chair?

Comment on this

The same as the Minister for Finance had his back to the Chair to-day.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I can assure the Chair that if my back was inadvertently turned to him it was in the exuberance of the debate and not in discourtesy. He goes on:—

"While Fianna Fáil did endeavour, rather too late, to stem rising prices by subsidising essential foods during their term of office, the Coalition Government, by refusing to increase these subsidies, knowingly permitted a rise in the cost of living."

Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll strolls nonchalantly, boldly, into the Lobby to ensure an increase of 3d. per loaf of bread for the citizens of this country, thanks to his gaining election on a document such as that. I advise the Deputy to be wary in his visits to the Crumlin area.

In the light of the campaign during the last election, where Fianna Fáil set itself up as the custodian, the protector, against the drastic increases in the cost of living, the custodian and protector of the housewife, the poor man's friend, I wonder how some of their Deputies are going to face back this week-end to their constituencies.

Comment on this

By car.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It is true that Deputy Seán Flanagan may be able to go back nonchalantly in his car and say: "I am young at the game. I had nothing to do with it." But some of the hardy warriors around him are going to be in a tough spot. If some of the asides heard going up the steps to the Lobbies last night are any foreshadowing of the future, the Minister for Finance must be more adroit than he has ever been before to explain this away to some of his own supporters. I am sure that there is no doubt in the mind of any reasonable Fianna Fáil person that there is no explanation. The sudden sensitivity on the Fianna Fáil benches only indicated that they were the most staggered, stupefied and amazed people in the House yesterday as the picture of ghastly butchery unfolded itself in all its sadism, designed as it was by a person well known in political circles and in the public life of the country for his lack of concern for the interests of the poorer sections of the people.

You can be proud of your Budget, a Budget that marks one further doleful milestone in the tragedy of breach of confidence by a political party to their electorate. If there was one thing which stood out in the background of the election campaign of Fianna Fáil, it was the issue of the cost of living, and let the Minister not think that he is going to sell the pup of small ameliorations for old age pensioners and other oppressed groups and get away with it. A sum of 1/6 for the old age pensioner, a miserable digusting pittance to offer him, in the teeth of taking with the other hand the 1/6 in his rationed goods, together with 7d. if he smokes a packet of cigarattes in the week or 4/1 if he smokes a packet a day. The Minister's heart is bleeding for the poor old age pensioner so much so that he offers this insult of 1/6, while robbing him with the other hand of not less than 1/- more than the relief of 1/6 he gives.

Then, we have an effort made to boost the Minister's greatness on the flagstaff of increased children's allowances. A very welcome feature is the increase in children's allowances, if it were not a deceptive increase, a bit of duplicity on the Irish people— 2/6 for the second child and an increase to 4/- for the subsequent children. Take the unfortunate working man with a wife and three children who gets, by way of children's allowances, the munificent sum of 6/6. He loses in respect of the abolition of the food subsidies the sum of 7/6 and, if he smokes one packet of cigarettes a day, we can add 4/1 to it and if he drinks a modest four pints of stout in the week, another 1/-, and if his wife, as in many cases the wives do, smokes, another 2/- or 3/-. We find, then, on one side, 6/6 graciously donated by the munificent Minister for Finance, while into the other pocket goes the searching, hungry fist that takes out 16/6. Wonderful economics and a grand story for Deputy Seán Flanagan to tell them in Mayo!

Comment on this

Nearly as good as the figures the Minister gave.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I am coming to that; I propose to deal with the hoax element of the Budget in a moment. We are doing very well. I have another most interesting document for the illumination of the minds of members of the House and the edification of the Irish public as to the beautiful type of political skullduggery that goes on in the Fianna Fáil Party. I shall now put on the records of the House this interesting document, a letter from the secretary of the Irish Ballroom Proprietors' Association, c/o Olympic Ballroom. Pleasants Street, Dublin, and the very illuminating answer from Seán F. Lemass, now Tánaiste.

Comment on this

What is the date of it?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

15th May, 1951

Comment on this

After the Dáil had been dissolved.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The whole story is told in it—do not worry. It reads:—

"Dear Sir,

At a special meeting of the executive of the association held on 8th inst. it was decided to communicate with the Fianna Fáil Party, they being the Party responsible for the abolition of Dance Tax in 1946 and having since vigorously opposed the re-imposition of same by the Coalition Government, requesting them to inform the Association of their intentions regarding the abolition of tax should they be returned to power.

I am to inform all members of the Association that I have received what the executive consider to be a favourable reply from Mr. Lemass on behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party a copy of which you will find enclosed.

Following receipt of this reply from Mr. Lemass, a further executive meeting was held to-day, the 15th inst., when the meeting confirmed their pledge of support to Fianna Fáil.

It will be appreciated that the Association is entirely non-political and that having failed utterly to impress the previous Government or Minister for Finance though it pointed out the hardships caused to ballroom business, to clubs hiring the ballrooms, musicians, staffs, etc., the Association has now no alternative but to support the Party who has indicated that they are prepared to repeal this tax as soon as it is practicable.

The Association has decided that the support to Fianna Fáil should take the form of substantial financial help and also that all members both city and country should lend a hand in every possible direction to secure the return to power of the one Party who has given the Association an indication that they as a Party are opposed to this undesirable entertainment tax on dances.

It will be appreciated that in order to have the desired effect our financial aid must of necessity be generous. I may mention that one leading commercial ballroom in Dublin has headed the list of subscribers to this fund with the generous sum of £250 and other members of the executive have also indicated their willingness to subscribe very generously.

Whilst the Association does not specify any particular amount to be subscribed they request you in your own interests to give as much as possible. I shall deem it a great favour if you will reply promptly as time is getting short before the General Election and if we are to help it must be done immediately.

Thanking you in anticipation,

Yours faithfully,

Kathleen Morris,

(Secretary)."

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Now we know.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

And now the letter from the then Seán F. Lemass, now Tánaiste of a Government who, in a Budget of drastic and crushing burdens on the Irish people, offer relief in one direction only, the abolition of tax on dancing. Let you dance, oh people! —the Minister for Finance thinks you have something to dance about in this outrageous and spiteful Budget. The letter reads:—

"Dáil Éireann,

Baile Atha Cliath.

10th May, 1951.

Miss K. Morris,

Secretary,

Irish Ballroom Proprietors' Association,

c/o Olympic Ballroom Company,

Pleasants Street,

Dublin.

A Chara,

I have received your letter of May 6th which has been considered by the Fianna Fáil Party Committee. The committee's view is that the entertainments duty on dances is an undesirable tax. As to its abolition in the present financial year, however, a decision must necessarily await the detailed examination of the Budget introduced in the Dáil immediately prior to its dissolution, but it would be the intention of the Fanna Fáil Party to repeal it as soon as practicable.

In view of this intimation of the committee's attitude, I assume it will not be desired to pursue the request for an interview with me. It will be appreciated that I could not add anything to what is conveyed by this letter.

Is mise,

SEÁN F. LEMASS."

Comment on this
Mr. Flanagan

He got £4,000 out of it.

Comment on this

Before the Deputy proceeds, the letter which he has just read, I respectfully submit, is one that calls for an explanation by a Minister of the Government. I would ask at this stage that the Minister for Finance be permitted to give an explanation, to confirm or deny the allegation about this tax on dancing.

Comment on this

Stop play-acting. Remember your disgraceful speech of 1948, when you got hold of clients' files and used them for political purposes.

Comment on this

We never accepted political bribes.

Comment on this

The Deputy never proceeded with the writ against me. He dare not go into the witness box.

Comment on this

We never framed a Budget on the basis of bribes. This is a public scandal.

Comment on this
Mr. Collins

That correspondence speaks for itself. It is a tragedy to have to put on the records of the House something quite as obnoxious as that, but I think conscientiously that it is in the public interest that they might know the background of this relief in the tax on dances.

Comment on this

The Deputy is delighted.

Comment on this

Tell us about the five Dublin publicans.

Comment on this

Does the Minister admit it or deny it?

Comment on this

On a point of order, that point was explained when it was stated that the cost of collecting the tax was greater than the tax itself.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

We now turn to a further tragedy in this Budget. This morning, in a quiet deliberative way, we heard a scathing analysis of the figures in it, by the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy J.A. Costello. In that he revealed a situation that bears restating, one that was added to to-day in a devastating way by the revelation of figures by Deputy Dan Morrissey. Whether it is an error or due to carelessness, or whatever the purpose, we see a figure of actual cost for the subsidies for this year described as the savings for the year; and we find that if you substract a figure of £6.7 million from the real cost of the subsidies for any one year you get the figure of the savings, which is £8.8 million, leaving a discrepancy that needs more than a casual explanation, leaving a concealed tax gathered into the coffers of £2,000,000. We have the position revealed, of Deputy Dr. James Ryan, the Minister for Health, announcing and reiterating here that the cost of social services for this year will be something less than £2,000,000, and his colleague in the same Cabinet, the Minister for Finance, in the Budget figures saying £3,000,000—another £1,000,000. These points are worth repeating, as it is time that the public of Ireland were given a full lesson in the real extent of the bluff, codology and stupidity that goes to make up the Fianna Fáil Party.

Then Deputy Morrissey comes into this House and tells us about something that it will be very difficult to wash away. How, in a document 71 pages long, carefully documented, laboriously read to this House, at page 50, can the figures appear that were quoted to-day by Deputy Morrissey, alleged in this statement to be the figures of new registration of motor vehicles, taking the years as he did, 1939, 1949 and last year, and what figures are in fact disclosed? Not the figures of the registration of motor vehicles but the figures of the numbers of driving licences issued to people. As pointed out by Deputy Morrissey, the discrepancy in the first year is only 20,000, in the second year of choice 50,000, but in the last year under review there is over 73,000 of a discrepancy. Mind you, the Minister has emphatically and with his grandiose eloquence on paper adverted to those figures in a very positive way and asserted that they showed him a certain figure.

Where does the duplicity of this Budget end? What figures in this Budget, if any, can we rely on? There is the demonstration in the items taken by the Leader of the Opposition, and in those items of registration of motor vehicles taken by Deputy Morrissey, that there is a complete lack of accuracy in these figures. Is the whole structure and facade on which this Budget is built and sold to the dumb cattle behind the Minister false? Where is the end of the errors in the figures on which these tax estimates are based? How far do the errors go and where do they end? Why is the Minister not anxious to adjourn this discussion to enable him to recheck the figures? Why has he not intervened, when he got the opportunity when he was challenged, to deny that the official figures in the official documents of this House are wrong but that he is right in his 71-page typewritten, doleful elegy of misery, holding out to this country nothing but gloom? We had a wealth of good will at home, a wealth of co-ordinated expansive endeavour by a people confident in their Government, believing in the investment of their own money at home, believing in the gradual building of their own State into something that they had dreamed about; and all that confidence has been dissipated and shattered by the gloom, the misery of people accidentally returned to ministerial posts by the consistent votes of people like Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll, whose sole worry is going to be food subsidies and the increases on tea and butter, or Deputy Peadar Cowan who can always be trusted to do the right thing.

It is indeed significant that in their queer wanderings around the political arenas of this country those weird specimens have wandered home to the arms of a Minister for Finance who was once described in moving eloquence by Deputy Cogan as the "senile delinquent". Permission was sought from the Chair on one occasion recently by his new-found enthusiastic defender, Deputy Peadar Cowan, to know if it would be in order to describe him in a most offensive way. Nice bedfellows. You are fully welcome to him. Unfortunately, the tragedy of this Budget will go far beyond the whim of these people. It is unfortunate that its impact will be felt in every home, no matter how humble, throughout the length and breadth of this State. No effort by a bemused and befogged spokesman for the Government will cloud the fundamental issue that no matter what section of the community may get back 1/- or 2/- they will pay three, four, five or six times over in the indirect yield of taxation which they will have to give back.

This is a cruel and a vicious Budget. If it were even equitable in its distribution of the load, one would not be so scathing in one's condemnation, but it is certain sure that the vicious spite is there that says to the Irish people: "You threw us out in 1948. We are now back a minority Government by the whim of a number of Independents and as long as we are there, you will feel the lash for that affront"—offered to the alleged great "I am" of the Fianna Fáil Party. This Budget is deliberately designed to retard progress. It is deliberately designed to break down the decent financial structure that was being built up.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What about the Marshall dollars?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I shall deal with that, too. You are interrupting a bit too soon. This Budget was designed to break down a financial structure that was built in such a way as to give the people a burden of taxation which they could bear. The Irish people were encouraged under the inter-Party Government to use their small savings for development at home and they were asked for their other savings for the purpose of investment in Ireland—and they gave them.

Somebody has interrupted about the Marshall dollars. The sooner Fianna Fáil wake up and cop themselves on, the better. In their ten months of office they have succeeded in dissipating what was left of the Marshall moneys, £26,000,000 odd, and the balance was all that we had spent in the previous three years. Work it out even on your own mathematical scales. Fianna Fáil should keep quiet about American dollars. What was the reserve of £26,000,000 for? It was there as a cushion against this type of cruel economic and unnecessary impingement on the Irish people. It was there to ensure that we would have adequate money to finance national development and, at the same time, that we would not have to come down with the crushing heel of the oppressor on the taxpayer of the country.

This Budget is simply and plainly unbludgeoned tyranny activated not by the best motives and manifestly activated by a vicious spite. I feel a tremendous amount of sincere regret because this Budget will do damage that, even with all the courage and ability that may come in the next Government to right the wrong, it will take years to overtake. This Budget represents a crushing burden on every section of the community without exception. There was, however, a great flag at the end of it: "We propose to take the tax off dancing." They propose to take the tax off dancing in the light of the correspondence I have put on the records of this House. It is a shameful and disgusting performance. It is a miserable travesty on the Irish people.

I assert that with an intelligent approach to the finances of this country most of this taxation is completely unnecessary. I assert further that the inevitable outcome of this Budget will be increased emigration, increased unemployment and a continuation and increase of the vicious circle of unrest in industry in this country for which the inter-party Government had found a remedy and eliminated. The inter-Party Government had found the basis of conciliation and co-operation between employer and employee. It had found the machinery by which fair demands were made. That put employers in the position that, with expanding industry, increased output, increased consumption, they were able to improve the lot of the workers. Now the vice is clamped down and again we have the mentality of men who once preached that 50/- a week was enough for any man and that £1,000 a year was too much. We now have the mentality of a Minister for Finance who, in a previous capacity as Minister for Local Government, would not sanction an increase of 1/- a week for the road workers in rural Ireland. That is the foul, vicious, dead hand that has come into Irish politics to-day. I say deliberately to the Government: Face again our masters—all our masters—the public of this country, and we on this side confidently await their verdict.

Comment on this

I listened very carefully to the speech made by Deputy J.A. Costello to-day and I must say that his contribution, as a former Taoiseach of this State, was very poor. He said that this Budget was dishonest. That criticism was not worthy of him. He alleged that the present Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, who has had wide experience of public life, and the Fianna Fáil Party in general, are asking for money by way of taxation that is not, in fact, required. Deputy J.A. Costello also alleged that the officials of the Department of Finance and of the Revenue Commissioners are incompetent and incapable of assessing the amount of money required for the coming financial year. I must say that I have never heard a more dishonest speech in this House than Deputy J.A. Costello's speech, especially in view of the fact that he had the honour of being Taoiseach of this country for three and a half years.

Surely he does not believe that the Irish people will swallow his misrepresentations. Would it be proper for any Government to impose taxation if it were not really necessary to do so? The answer is "no". The task of balancing the Budget, which is the task of every Minister for Finance in every country in the world, is a difficult and a thankless task. If Deputy Costello had said: "I am against all this taxation" I would have said that he was an honest man and his criticism was worth having. Instead of that he tried to twist it around—that the Revenue Commissioners and the officers of the Department of Finance were people who were not worthy of the confidence of the people of this country and that they were dishonest. That was the implication of his speech and his general contribution lasting one and a half hours to this debate.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

On a point of order. I am sure that if the former Taoiseach made such a reflection on the civil servants whoever was in the Chair would have ordered its withdrawal.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order. The Chair will protect civil servants as far as necessary.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Deputy J.A. Costello said no such thing.

Comment on this

His statement was to the effect that the Minister for Finance was going to look for £10,000,000 more than he required and that this was a dishonest Budget. That was the theme— gross misrepresentation by the Opposition Deputies who spoke yesterday and to-day. Before I leave the ex-Taoiseach's speech, if he thinks that the people will swallow that misrepresentation he will naturally, of course, have to try to put up some smokescreen——

Comment on this

At 2/4 per packet.

Comment on this

——to cover up the mess that he left the nation in after three years, and I suppose one smoke-screen for Deputy Costello and his colleagues in the Opposition is as good as another. We are in our present position because of the way you have carried on for the last three years and we have to face it now and we have to do the unpopular thing.

Comment on this

Why do you not go to the country and we will have you out of office in 48 hours?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Burke should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

In my absence yesterday, the Deputy made a very uncharitable remark about me. I am alive and well.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear it. How you stuck that Budget I do not know. There were times when I was concerned about you.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Burke on the motion before the House.

Comment on this

I have sat and listened in this House without interrupting anybody either to-day or yesterday. I say now, without any fear of contradiction, that we on this side of the House have to do unpopular things as a result of the mess we have found the country in after three years of your administration.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Deputy would use the third person and address the Chair.

Comment on this

We have to do the unpopular thing and the Minister for Finance has my wholehearted sympathy in having a tough job to clean up the mess that the people on the other side of the House are responsible for having the country in at the present time.

I have heard a number of speeches here to-day. The same type of speech was made in Europe during the last seven or eight years and prior to the last war—the same destructive speech, misrepresenting the facts in certain European countries. It is the type of speech that has made the nations of Eastern Europe subservient to another nation to-day. Do you want this country to stand on its own feet? Do you want us to try and clear up the mess that the previous Government left to us here? Do you want us to do that or do you want us to carry on in the same way as in other European countries that have been made subservient to a foreign power because the same misrepresentation went on when the finances of the country went down and when chaotic conditions existed there? As far as I know we hope to keep this country for the Irish people.

Comment on this

There will be none of them left shortly.

Comment on this
A Deputy

The Jews have it now.

Comment on this

We want this country for the Irish people and we do not want it to be subservient to any foreign power, if we can help it; but apparently that is not the attitude adopted by Opposition speakers. All they are able to do is to criticise but they never ask themselves how was the Minister for Finance to balance this Budget and to meet the outgoings of this State during the coming year. I have seen none of the previous speakers face up to the position good, bad or indifferent. The only thing they were able to do was to pretend that they were crying salt tears because of the position created by them, and by them alone.

Deputy Dillon spoke also at great length here. He is hardly worth quoting or referring to at all. I see one of his mute mice from County Dublin has just entered the House; it was he who clapped him on the back when he killed the tillage and the agricultural industry in the constituency that I have the honour to represent.

Comment on this

Tell us about the Budget. How are you going to defend that in Balbriggan? That is the point.

Comment on this

We will have the revolution.

Comment on this

Deputy Captain Cowan will tell you all about revolution.

Comment on this

Deputy Dunne referred to me on numerous occasions during his speech. At least I have an opportunity now of answering a few of the points that the Deputy tried to make as usual. He is a past master at misrepresentation and, of course, naturally, I have to show how very good the same Deputy is at misrepresenting facts.

Comment on this

I do not go behind your back like you went behind mine.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Deputy Burke is in possession and entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Then he should try to make sense.

Comment on this

Deputy Dunne cried here to-night over the agricultural worker in County Dublin. He held his hands up and roared at the top of his voice to show how concerned he was about them but he was not a bit concerned about them when he clapped Deputy Dillon on the back, when the tillage farmer, the agricultural worker, the tomato grower and the fruit grower of County Dublin were nearly squeezed out of existence. Deputy Dunne was as mute as a mouse when a number of these agricultural workers lost their employment.

Comment on this

That, of course, is a lie.

Comment on this

That is the position.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy used the expression "lie". That must be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I am afraid that, with great, respect to you, I must characterise the statement for what it is—a lie.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy Dunne will not withdraw the expression he must leave the House.

Comment on this

With respect to you, I will leave the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Without any further reference, the Deputy cannot discuss the matter. I will have no further discussion. Deputy Dunne will withdraw the expression or else leave the House.

Comment on this

I leave the House in the knowledge that Deputy Burke will be safer now.

Comment on this

That is good propaganda, Deputy.

Deputy Dunne withdrew.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Burke on the Budget statement and on Resolution No. 11.

Comment on this

I was speaking about what we are trying to do in this country. We are trying to make this country a decent, self-supporting nation. If any citizen inside this House or outside it is misguided enough to believe the misrepresentations that have been made here by speakers on the Opposition Benches criticising this Budget he will have to ask himself a few very pertinent questions.

They will have to ask themselves, "What would I do in similar circumstances, if I were Minister for Finance?" It is easy enough to try to make a cockshot of the present Minister and to call him names across the floor of the House, or to indulge in cheap misrepresentation, but let any citizen place himself in the same position as the present Minister is in to-day and see what he is going to do. Did any member of the Opposition tell us where we could have saved under the Budget? Do they want us to cut down on social services, on the widows' and orphans' pensions or on the numerous social services that we introduced since 1933? Do they want us to cut down on the Army or the Guards? These are questions to which I expected to hear answers from any person who wished to treat the House to an honest sound criticism on the Budget. Instead of that we find them all shying away from these questions. They started to misrepresent the facts and resorted to calling the Minister names. That is the position we are now facing.

I challenge any one of them to get up and make an honest-to-goodness speech and tell the House how they are going to balance the Budget in the conditions facing the Minister to-day. They bring in cheap gibes about letters written at election time. I am sure the Fine Gael Party and Deputy Collins as a member of that Party, knows well enough what the publicans' junta tried to do with the Fine Gael Party and we hear nothing about that from Deputy Collins. There is nothing about the Fine Gael Central Finance Committee which collected money from the publicans to reduce the beer tax and the sell-out they had on that occasion. I heard Deputy MacBride, a man at whose hands I suffered very hard on one occasion, at whose hands I suffered more than at the hands of any other individual——

Comment on this

Yes, on one occasion. I was surprised at you.

Comment on this

This is news. I do not know what the Deputy is talking about.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Burke on the Resolution.

Comment on this

I am dealing with Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will deal with Resolution No. 11.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the reply Deputy MacBride made in support of Deputy Collins.

Comment on this

I should like to know how I made the Deputy suffer?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I shall hear nothing from the Deputy except on the Resolution under discussion.

Comment on this

That is Deputy MacBride's opinion, not mine.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Burke on Resolution No. 11.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride supported Deputy Collins when he was reading a document here a few moments ago about dance halls and he referred to it as dishonest bribery. I want to ask Deputy MacBride seriously did he ever in all his political career in his constituency solicit a vote from publicans.

Comment on this

I certainly did, but I never bought votes. I never framed a Budget on the basis of bribes.

Comment on this

What about a certain lady and her subscription?

Comment on this

I never framed a budget on the basis of bribes and this looks uncommonly like it.

Comment on this

I do not want disorder in this House.

Comment on this

What is this about?

Comment on this

I feel that the letter read by Deputy Collins supported by Deputy MacBride was a dishonest misrepresentation of facts.

Comment on this

On a point of order. When Deputy Collins had read that letter I felt that in fairness to the Government, the Government should be given an opportunity of stating whether the letter was correct and whether they had in fact received subscriptions.

Comment on this

Do stop performing and conduct yourself like a public representative and not like a marionette.

Comment on this

I should like to know how Deputy Burke suffered.

Comment on this

This is the same class of misrepresentation that we have heard since the debate opened. So far as I can see, all the speakers on the opposite side want is to have this country subservient to other mighty nations, to have it begging crumbs from other people——

Comment on this

That is not true and well you know it.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Burke not entitled to make his speech without these unintelligent interruptions?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Burke is repeating himself.

Comment on this

He is walking in his sleep.

Comment on this

If I am hurting the susceptibilities of the gentlemen opposite I can assure you that I am trying so far as I possibly can to be honest.

Comment on this

That must be torture to you.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not concerned with the susceptibilities of the Opposition but Deputy Burke has been repeating himself. I should now like to hear Deputy Burke on Resolution No. 11.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon, the ex-Minister for imports, to-day made a contribution to this debate which was typical. He said that he was anxious when Minister for Agriculture to increase production in this country. The Deputy who has just left the House, and others who are here present and who were here during the session from 1948-1951, know full well the contribution that that honourable Minister made towards increasing production in this country. As I have just pointed out, the tillage farmers, the market gardeners, the fruit growers and tomato growers of my constituency know how he succeeded in almost putting them out of existence. Then the great leader and archangel of the workers, Deputy Norton, had nothing to say about it. He was just as anxious in supporting Deputy Dillon in trying to run people off the land of old Ireland——

Comment on this

They are running faster than ever to-day under Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton was not very concerned about the workers then.

Comment on this

They were all working.

Comment on this

I wonder when will we get in this country people who will be honest enough to face the position as the Minister for Finance is now doing. I know well how the Deputies opposite will go to the chapel gates and the hustings and misrepresent the facts as they are.

Comment on this

You are afraid of that.

Comment on this

If I was, I would not stand up in this House and say what I am saying.

Comment on this

Or at Portrane.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Flanagan should restrain himself and allow Deputy Burke to make his statemen in his own way without interruption.

Comment on this

His own way?

Comment on this

I was referring to the ex-Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon. He was so interested, supported by his colleagues in the Labour Party, in keeping foreign labour going that he wanted to import commodities which we could have produced here.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is there any chance or hope that we shall have a deliberate discussion on the Budget rather than the stuff we are listening to?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

If Deputy Dillon when Minister for Agriculture, supported by the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party, had done his job honestly and conscientiously, the present Minister for Finance would have had a very easy and popular job yesterday and to-day. We have to pay dearly for the mess which these people have left us.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is repeating himself. I have been very lenient with him and he should come to the motion.

Comment on this

He is really finished, but he will not sit down.

Comment on this

The intelligentsia are to be our educators in the future.

Comment on this

There was a lack of responsibility shown by the previous Government. They carried on in any class of way. I have already referred to other countries in Europe which suffered from the same misrepresentation. We are suffering now. I hope that the people will realise that this Budget, no matter what can be said about it, is honest and true, and that the Minister for Finance has squarely faced up to the position. He had no other alternative, and now has to bridge a very substantial gap by borrowing. That shows us what the Minister is up against. He has not tried to put over something on the country—a popular Budget—and let the country drift and drift, until some day we would find all our social services so disrupted that we would have our country in a position where it would be subservient to other countries. To the Minister for Finance I will conclude by saying: "You have a tough job, you have faced up to it and you are doing well".

Comment on this

The proposals which the Minister introduced in the Budget yesterday were the culmination of a lengthy campaign initiated by the Minister and other members of the Government shortly after they were elected last June. The start of this campaign was the Minister's speech to the House on the 18th July. The House and the country will recollect that the Minister's policy was initiated on that occasion in order, according to himself, to rectify the financial position in which the country found itself, and especially to rectify the disequilibrium in the balance of payments.

That was one problem. The other problem was to pay for current expenditure out of current earnings. When the Minister, supported by other Ministers, initiated that campaign, it was anticipated that the introduction of this Budget and of the Estimates this year would mark a departure in the financial policy adopted by the inter-Party Government. A whole series of speeches, emphasising the alleged critical condition of our finances, were made by Ministers at different functions varying in degree and intensity. The country was led to believe that, whatever measures would be adopted, would have as their aim a rectification in the import excess and would result in an improvement in the terms of trade.

The Minister yesterday, in his speech introducing the Budget, covered a great number of topics and dealt somewhat briefly with this problem. He admitted that, in the first two months of this year, the improvement was negligible. There was something approximating to £1,000,000 reduction in the import excess in the month of January over the same month last year. The reduction in the import excess for the month of February was substantially less, and the March figures are not yet available. It is quite obvious that the campaign which was initiated, the speeches which were made, and the public alarm created caused dislocation, disturbance and lack of confidence resulting in serious unemployment as well as in a serious dislocation in the economy of the country, have not, at the end of that period, resulted in any effective measures being proposed or even in any remedy being anticipated. The country has been deluged with speech after speech, at meeting after meeting, by Ministers, all pointing to the serious economic condition of the country.

The country was led to believe that, when the present Budget would be introduced and the Estimates circulated prior to the Budget, a change in policy was likely. It is true there has been a change in policy but it has not shown any accept on the measures designed to improve the terms of trade or the remedies which the country was led to believe would be adopted as a result of the criticism which was voiced against the inter-Party Government's capital development programme or the description which was applied to the method of financing. We were led to believe from the first page in the Book of Estimates, circulated in February, that, when the Budget would be introduced, a change would be announced in the description applied to capital and current expenditure.

The Book of Estimates issued in February contained a note on page (iii). That note referred to the fact that it was not proposed to follow the procedure of designating particular items in the supply services as capital services and that it was only in the context of the Budget that a full estimate of Exchequer outlay on capital and current account would be available.

The Budget was presented to the House yesterday and the Minister dismissed in a few words the distinction that was drawn between capital and current expenditure and the division which was introduced by the inter-Party Government in the dual Budget. It is obvious from the remarks that he made in dealing with this matter that it was not the intention of the Government to make any real change.

While that in itself may not appear to be a matter of any great significance, the country is entitled to an explanation from the Government and from the representatives elected to the House who supported the Government of the campaign which has continued since the Government was elected criticising the capital development programme and which now, when the Budget has been introduced, makes no serious alteration in the method of financing that programme.

It is, indeed, worthy of comment that the Government has not departed from that policy. It is not sufficient to say that they had not time to do it and that it will have to be considered later in the year. It was quite reasonable, in fact, only human for the Government, in the early months and early weeks after they had assumed office, to lay the blame on their predecessors for unpopular decisions, for any deterioration which had occurred in the economy and for any alterations which were taking place. That was fair tactics, even good tactics. But time has caught up with them.

The changes that have since occurred, the measures that have been proposed during the last ten months and, in particular, the measures which have been proposed in the Budget now presented to the House cannot be defended by attempting to cast the responsibility on their predecessors or by refusing to accept responsibility for the proposals now announced for the heavier burdens now placed on all sections of the community, burdens which have been so spread that the leading article in the Irish Independent is headed: “Everybody in the Casualty List.”

Comment on this

They tried to put the Taoiseach in that list on one occasion a long time ago.

Comment on this

Was not the Deputy terribly sorry?

Comment on this

They put the men of 1916 there and Deputy Mulcahy should not forget that.

Comment on this

Deputy Cogan may be in the casualty list as a result of this Budget. The position is that this Budget has been copied from the Budget proposed recently by the Tory Chancellor of the Exchequer. It is customary, when jockeys go out to ride a race, to give them riding instructions but it does not always follow that the instructions are obeyed. When the present Minister for Finance and the Tánaiste went to London they had discussions. They were so modest about the results of these discussions that, with the exception of a very brief statement published after they returned, the country was given no indication as to what occurred.

Judgment was suspended until the proposals were introduced and no replica was ever produced of any original which bore the same similarity of origin which this Budget bears to the British Budget. When it bears that resemblance it is pertinent to inquire what the British Budget set out to achieve. It is pertinent to inquire what caused the British to get into the position that these measures were required.

The British, as many people are aware, recently fought the biggest war in history and their second biggest war in 30 years, wars which absorbed every thing that they had in the way of strength both physical and economic and which utilised their resources to the last drop.

No such war affected this country. It is true that the recent war affected this country in a variety of ways but we were not injured in our economic strength or resources and our assets were not depleted to the extent they were in Britain. In fact, while the war continued, a great number of our economic assets were strengthened. There is no valid comparison between the conditions in which the British people found themselves at the end of the last war and the conditions in which the people of this country found themselves. There is no valid comparison which justifies the imposition in this country of measures calculated to extricate the British people and the British economy from the situation in which they find themselves.

There is, therefore, no reason for similar methods being adopted here in entirely different circumstances. Of course, the real defect in this Budget is that it follows the British pattern without apparently considering what the consequences of that pattern would be if it were applied to our economy.

In recent years a great number of people have become familiar with the word "austerity". The word was first brought into common use by the former British Chancellor of the Exchequer, Sir Stafford Cripps. He was a munificent Santa Claus in comparison with our Minister. No Budget ever introduced in Great Britain was so austere in its effects or so severe in its results as the Budget introduced here yesterday. No measure designed there to protect their economy impinged so heavily, so severely or so unjustly on all sections of the people as the Budget introduced by the Fianna Fáil Government and which has been supported by a number of their satellites in the House.

The proposals propounded in this Budget, while a replica of the proposals adopted in Great Britain, fail to make provision for the impact of the changes which will inevitably result from the drastic curtailment of the food subsidies.

Considerable attention has been given in debates in recent years in the House to the problems of the cost of living. When a far steeper rise occured than has occured since the advent of the present Government, there was very loud clamour through the country, a clamour initiated and fanned by the then Opposition, and, indeed, a clamour that was to some extent assisted by some of those who are now supporting the Government.

When some of the causes of that situation were attributed to external circumstances, very little attention was paid to the reasons then given. Criticism was voiced that the remedies applied were ineffective. It was asserted that the external influences operating, that the impact of world armament and of stockpiling resulting from the Korean war could not have a very great effect here. That type of propaganda was reasonably successful and, no doubt, in the early stages a great number of people were under the impression that it was difficult to imagine how the effect of that war could impinge on the economy of a small island such as this.

When the present Government assumed responsibility for dealing with the situation, the effects attributable to the Korean war loomed largely in the reasons put forward by them for the deterioration of the situation and for the rise which has occurred in the prices of a number of commodities. But all these considerations are subordinate to the proposals which the Minister and other Ministers have suggested to bridge the gap between expenditure and revenue and to correct the import excess. As I said, none of the remedies propounded in this Budget will correct the import excess. In fact, when the increases in the duties on tobacco, beer, and spirits were announced by the Minister it was expected that they would not result in any diminution in consumption, because the revenue expected is based on consumption remaining approximately the same. Consequently, the arguments we have heard about saving dollars and reducing the drain on the dollar pool have no validity in the context of this Budget and no validity when applied to the figures which the Minister gave a couple of weeks ago on the Vote on Account.

The Government hope that the increased tax on tobacco will not result in a diminution in the quantity consumed because, if it did, the revenue from that source would be reduced. No remedy for reducing the imports from the dollar area was propounded either on the Vote on Account or during the discussion on this Budget. It is obvious that the Government do not expect to achieve a saving of dollars in tobacco imports and we have not yet been informed of the other measures which it is proposed to take to reduce imports from the dollar area. It is significant that that aspect of the problem has been passed over in silence.

During the debate it was suggested that we were living on American dollars for the last three years. Deputies opposite must appreciate the damage that statements of that kind do to our relations with our friends in the United States. This country appreciated the help afforded by the granting of American dollars through Marshall Aid. It is not without signifinance that last May the head of E.C.A., who might be accepted as an impartial expert on the problem, expressed the view that Ireland had achieved results in the short space of three years, which otherwise would have taken a generation to achieve, as a result of the granting of American dollars. The fact that we were able to use these dollars for development purposes and to avail of the technical assistance projects provided by E.C.A. cannot but have resulted in an improvement in the technique and experience of those who were enabled, through that assistance, to go to the United States and to avail of the courses provided there. It is ungracious at this stage, when Marshall Aid is ended, to allege that we were in any way subordinated to the decisions or beholden to the Government of the United States in either economic or military matters. The members of the Government know that that was not the case. In fact, it is common knowledge that discussions have been proceeding since the enactment of the Mutual Security Act with a view to availing of the sum of over £5,000,000 which still remains available and which this Government did not succeed in spending out of the Counterpart Fund.

That money is still available and the discussions are still proceeding. Deputies opposite should remember that before they make the allegation that we were in some way or other pledging to act and direct our policy because of the acceptance of Marshall Aid. The only obligation we undertook in accepting Marshall Aid was the obligation, which will be honoured, to repay the loan which was thereby granted.

It is quite obvious that, because this Government is making heavy weather, because the Party opposite find it difficult to defend the conditions at present for which it was responsible, because they recognise unpopularity of the measures proposed, because they appreciate that any straw will be clutched at by a drowning man, they now seek to introduce the suggestion and allegation that, in some way or another, this country, by its acceptance of Marshall Aid, had pledged its independence or forfeited its right to take independent action economically or militarily.

Those, of course, with a knowledge of the facts—and it is reasonable to assume that the present Government have some knowledge of the facts— recognise that that situation and that picture presented by some Deputies opposite and some of their supporters is not in accordance with the facts, but it is wrong nationally and bad the prestige of the country and bad for the welfare of the State that any suggestion should be voiced of the fact that that loan was accepted. It was accepted because it was recognised that it was given in a magnificent spirit, so that we might develop our economy and adopt plans on the assumption that this money was given to rehabilitate the economy of Western Europe.

The fact that this Budget fails to provide a remedy is significant. It is significant because of the harsh proposals incorporated in it, because it came at the conclusion of a campaign in which the country was led to believe that it would result in specific proposals being introduced which would provide a remedy for the import excess and for the reduction in the heavy import excess over the last years.

It is true that this Budget will effect reductions; it is true that it will effect a reduction in the amount of food consumed by many families; it will effect a reduction in the standard of life of large sections of the people; it will affect intimately the lives of every single section of the community, and affect some of them intensely. No Budget in recent times has affected the people so much but the reductions provided for here will not result in any serious alteration in the import excess. The Minister's references to it yesterday showed that he recognised that whatever proposals are incorporated in this Budget cannot achieve any serious change and cannot effect any really important improvement in the situation that has occurred. The Government took the responsibility of bringing in an early Budget in order to clarify the situation.

It is quite obvious the situation is clarified. It is quite obvious that this Government had decided to adopt the remedies proposed in Britain and to apply them to the situation here. But it is also quite obvious that they have not faced up to the results of these remedies or to the consequences which will follow. We had here to-day a defence by the Minister for Industry and Commerce of the increases in food prices and we had the suggestion that, because these increases were to give beneficial improvements under social welfare and children's allowances, benefits would accrue to the community. It was alleged that the increases which were to be granted in these social services would more than offset the increases in food prices. I challenge the Government, and I do not believe they have made any calculation to prove it, to show that these added benefits will offset the rise in the cost of foodstuffs. Does anybody believe that the increases which will follow will in any way be offset by the social welfare benefits? When this Government announced its programme after the last election, one of the proposals in the 17-point memo which was published was one to increase children's allowances. It was not then announced, either as one of the 17 points or subsequently, that it was proposed at the same time to increase the cost of living.

No calculations have been made, or if they have been made they have not been given to the House, with a view to estimating the rise in the cost of living that will accrue. It is quite obvious that the Government was staggered by the estimate of the rise in the cost-of-living index that would result from the alterations in the food subsidies. It is probably only academic to consider what the rise would be. The real rise will be felt by the people who have to pay these increases; the real impact will have to be borne by all sections, and it is obvious from the increases now proposed and which will come into operation that applications for wage increases are inevitable. The Government appears to have avoided any consideration of this problem, or if any consideration has been given to it, then the results that will accrue from these increases have not been fully understood or sufficiently investigated. I move to report progress.

Comment on this