We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–164 of 329. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

When this debate resumed I spoke on the matter last night. I would like now in view of further information I have got since from the Minister's replies to-day to apologise to this House for wrong statements I made last night. I do not pretend to be a financial expert of any description, but I intimated that the spree of the inter-Party Government during the past three years cost the country £5,000,000 per year in interest and sinking fund. I want to apologise to the House for that in view of the figures I got now from the Minister for Finance, and inform the House of the unpleasant news that £856,000 per year must be added for that little spree they had. In addition to the £5,000,000 a year that the people will have to pay for the money you borrowed and spreed, they will have to pay £856,000 a year. The actual interest and sinking fund to be paid now, over the sum that was paid in 1947-48, is £5,856,166.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputy Corry please address the Chair and use the third person?

Comment on this

I apologise.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Use of the second person leads to continuous interruptions.

Comment on this

Having dealt with that blunder on my part—I have not the exact figures and I am sure nobody can blame me for that—I would like to get back to where we were last night with regard to Córas Iompair Éireann. I quoted last night a statement made in the House by Deputy Cosgrave, who was then Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. At column 2104 of the Official Report, 15th March, 1951, Deputy Cosgrave said:—

"I conclude by expressing the hope that the coming year will be no worse than the year the company has passed through."

That was on a Vote for £980,000 to cover their losses. A month afterwards, Deputy McGilligan comes along and, with an airy wave of his hand says— column 1903 of the Official Reports, 2nd May, 1951:—

"It is questionable whether Córas Iompair Éireann can in the immediate future attain a position in which it will be able to meet all its operating expenses and discharge as well the interest on transport stock. The board has a statutory duty—

‘so to conduct its undertaking as to secure as soon as may be, that, taking one year with another, the revenue shall be not less than sufficient to meet the charges properly chargeable to it.'

This duty will, I hope, be discharged with the utmost expedition."

He provided nothing for Córas Iompair Éireann losses last year. In reading the Official Report of the 2nd May, 1951, column 1903, I missed the storm that we had here last week and I did not notice in this report that any Deputy jumped up to know whether the forcing of Córas Iompair Éireann to meet their full liabilities by whatever means they could or, at least, as Deputy McGilligan put it—I do not like to misquote him—

"so to conduct its undertaking as to secure that, taking one year with another, the revenue shall be not less than sufficient to meet the charges properly chargeable to it."

would mean an increase in bus fares. We did not hear any wail or moan that time about the increase in bus fares which would be caused by compelling Córas Iompair Éireann to find that money. There was no talk then from Deputy Alfred Byrne about the extra 3d. or 5d. that the poor little children of Dublin would have to pay in the bus if this thing was done. There was complete silence then.

If that £1,800,000 which has now been found to be the Córas Iompair Éireann losses for the last 12 months, and which was unprovided for in last year's Budget, were put on to the bus fares and railway fares, I wonder what the increase would be in fares. We had complete silence then on this matter. Although the Minister for Finance at that time, Deputy McGilligan, knew very well that there would be a gap of well over £1,000,000 at least, no provision was made for that in last year's Budget and, therefore, that must go on with the other little items that I mentioned last night; that must go on to be found this year in addition to our usual housekeeping bill. The £1,800,000 Córas Iompair Éireann losses and £433,000 interest on stock make £2,000,000 odd more that should have been collected from the people last year and was not collected and was not even paid out of the millions of American loan about which Deputy Dillon informed us we did not know how we would spend it quickly enough before the 31st March. Even if it were devoted to paying their debts, there would have been some excuse. It was not so devoted.

I do not know exactly the position in regard to the £2,700,000 arrears of fuel subsidies. That, however, has to be found also. Apparently it was not found in last year's Budget. It has to be added in.

That, Sir, is roughly a total of £9,400,000 that should have been provided for in last year's Budget if the State were to remain on anything like an even keel. That must be found this year in addition to our ordinary housekeeping. Where is it going to be found? I know very well that if I were a member of a board of directors who had plunged the company into near-bankruptcy—as those people have done—and saw another unfortunate team here endeavouring to find the money to pay their debts, I would not have all the howling about how the money was to be found.

Comment on this

You would take control of things.

Comment on this

We have taken control.

Comment on this

Far from it.

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey is not plucky enough to keep his mouth shut. I wonder what is the exact amount of the bill represented by the little letters that I read last night that were sent out after the dissolution of the Dáil. I have not it now, but I hope to have, for the Deputy's information, next week, the amount of the money that falls this year on the ratepayers of Cork City.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What has that got to do with the Budget?

Comment on this

This is what it has got to do with it; we have had to provide in the Budget £855,000, or nearly £1,000,000, to meet portions of the money given by those letters—about one-fifth of it. The balance has to be found by the ratepayers of the country —£2,000,000 odd. This was an action which had the result, undoubtedly, of being on the border-line of bribery.

Comment on this

That is a very serious charge.

Comment on this

A Minister of a Government which had just announced its dissolution came along and dished out over £3,000,000 to local authorities to be paid to their officials a week before those officials were due to go to the polls. No doubt, our slender majority here is partly due to those letters which had the effect of working a little influence because of the £125 lump sum they placed into the local authority officials' pockets a week before the poll. I wish them joy.

Comment on this

The charge of bribery is a very serious one as between the officials and the Government.

Comment on this

What else is it? I always call a spade a spade.

Comment on this

Have some regard for the civil servants.

Comment on this

What regard had a Minister of State for anybody when, the day after the dissolution of the Dáil had been declared, he dished out this money I have mentioned to the local authorities.

Comment on this

Do you mean to say that civil servants were influenced or bribed by that action?

Comment on this

I am saying it was done for that purpose. To do them credit, all of them were not influenced, but many of them were, I am sure.

However, I would like to pass on from that nasty picture of what was done on the eve of an election. I have not heard from Deputies opposite, up to the present, any denial of the figures quoted by the Minister for Finance in this House, the figures which I have given, item by item, here to-day. I have not heard any denial of the fact that the Government then in office knew that these commitments would have to be paid. However, they made no provision for them because they were going to the country. I am wondering whether those Deputies opposite did, in fact, know that £9,000,000 and practically £6,000,000 extra interest which was piled on by them while in office had to be found this year—last year's money which was left unpaid, and the money needed for this year. Of course, the present Minister has a very simple way out. He could declare, like Deputy McGilligan: "I am not going to take responsibility for the decision of the arbitration court last year. I will leave the civil servants without their increase in pay of £2,600,000." That is the decision that was announced on the 24th May, a fortnight after the Budget had been introduced. The present Minister for Finance could adopt the attitude which was adopted by Deputy McGilligan towards the arrears of the Fuel Fund—£2,700,000. There was a glorious announcement the week before the election: "Civil servants, you are about to get £3,600,000. Local authorities, you are about to receive £2,000,000. Come along and vote for us." That is a grand picture, but the piper must now be paid.

We are hearing moans and groans and general uproar about the position of the unfortunate people just now. If that £3,600,000 had been provided for last year and paid, it would not have been necessary to put an extra 3d. tax on the "pint," it would just about fill the bill. Then we have that £1,000,000 which had to be put into this Budget as a result of the four letters I have mentioned. If those had been provided for in last year's Budget, it would not have been necessary for us to put an extra 6d. tax on the whiskey. I hope Deputy Hickey who is the financial genius of the Labour Party will think over this.

Comment on this

You are getting on fine. I find you most interesting.

Comment on this

If I said anything that is untrue I will be around here for the next fortnight waiting to hear Deputy Hickey contradict it.

Comment on this

You would not do anything like that.

Comment on this

We have had to find this year all those millions of pounds I have recounted which were left unprovided for last year. Unfortunately we will have to find the same amount for next year because the evil which men do lives after them. The present Minister for Finance, in addition to having to pay the £3,600,000 left unprovided for the Civil Service last year, has to pay the same amount this year. He has to find money for Córas Iompair Éireann losses. I do not know what was in Deputy McGilligan's mind when he made a statement to the effect that Córas Iompair Éireann would have to live up to their responsibilities. Perhaps he hoped at that time to induce Deputy Davin to take over control of the company. I feel sure Deputy Davin would not have made half the mess that is being made of the company at present.

I suggest now that it is time we trimmed our sails a bit, and that when we talk about subsidies, the time for subsidising as far as Córas Iompair Éireann is concerned is gone. If you put any body of men there and tell them: "Carry on lads whatever way you like, and whatever losses you may have at the end of the year I will pay them"—when you put a firm or an individual in that position it is an inducement to extravagance. It is a definite incentive to them not to look after their business.

Comment on this

Is that why the farmers are getting subsidies, because they do not look after their business?

Comment on this

Let the Deputy not draw me out.

Comment on this

I am only asking.

Comment on this

I am dealing now with the matters that are in the Budget, and with the £1,800,000 that is down here, and that I say could be put down at £10,000,000 or £11,000,000 when we take into consideration the stops and the obstacles that were put against private enterprise in the transport line in this country. Having stopped lorries and, in fact, every means of transport in this country in order to drive all transport into the hands of Córas Iompair Éireann, we have a position that would remind you of nothing but the Dáil restaurant. I suggest to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who is in charge of transport, that he take very serious notice of this situation. I remember a few months ago here having to deal with a position in which this company were running six trains a day out of Cork City to Dublin for fun, most of them, because the passengers that are carried in the six trains could just as well be accommodated in two or three at the most.

Comment on this

Are you advocating to do away with all subsidies?

Comment on this

I am putting up a case for this £1,800,000 that the State must find for the debt you created last year and the £1,300,000 this year.

Comment on this

You want to do away with all subsidies? Is that agreed?

Comment on this

I have pointed out the position and I feel very strongly on the whole matter. I have not heard from either side of the House up to the present any suggestion or proposal for reducing that huge bill that is coming before us each year. There is being created a regular octopus to grasp the finances of the few who are working or producing in this country.

I asked the Minister for Finance a question here last week in regard to the number of civil servants in State and local employment. I received the reply yesterday to the effect that in the year 1939 there were 26,775 civil servants employed and on the 1st January, 1951, there were 35,287—an increase of 11,000 drones. If 26,700 civil servants were all that were required to run the country in 1939 what are the 11,000 more doing to-day?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Could that not be raised more properly on the Estimate rather than on the Budget statement?

Comment on this

It arises, Sir, on the ways and means by which this alarming sum that is before us can be reduced.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

You cannot travel over all the Estimates in that fashion and discuss all the expenditure under the various Departments. The Civil Service comes under the Department of Finance.

Comment on this

I do not intend going further into it. I do not wish to have any man put out of his employment but I would suggest to the Minister that he should stop recruiting for the Civil Service and return to the 1939 figure.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Is it right that the Deputy should call civil servants and working people in this country drones?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Very hard terms are employed in this House.

Comment on this

If I have said anything derogatory, I am sorry. However, I regret that Deputy Byrne was not here a little while ago when I was speaking. I did not hear him pleading last year when Deputy McGilligan announced that he was going to compel Córas Iompair Éireann to increase their charges last year.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy need not repeat his speech for the benefit of Deputy Byrne.

Comment on this

There are other matters with which we are seriously concerned. As far as we can judge, the method of collecting the dance tax was very expensive. I am suggesting that he find some other means of collection, for instance, a licence duty on the owner of the hall. In this connection, as in the cinema entertainment tax, I have in mind the health of our people. In 1947, we had some 90 odd patients in the sanatorium in Cork. At present, there are 387 and 96 on the waiting list. I suggest that that is largely due to the dance halls and the cinemas. That is proved by the fact that in 1943 the receipts from entertainments duty in respect of cinemas were nearly £387,000, while last year they amounted to £1,186,000. That is something that could bear an additional charge. Even if the additional charge had the effect of bringing in less revenue, it might help to halt the alarming and disgraceful position which we see in our towns and cities. Deputy Hickey is well aware that even in the middle of the day in Cork City, from about 2 o'clock onwards, we see a queue 200 yards long waiting outside a cinema to go into the pictures. There is something very unhealthy in a situation where, on the one hand, we have these long queues of people while, on the other hand, the agricultural community are unable to find the labour which they require.

I have heard Deputies from various Parties complain about the number of unemployed people in this country to-day. Do Deputies not think that there is something radically wrong——

Comment on this

Of course there is.

Comment on this

——when, on the one hand, you have thousands of men lined up at the labour exchange to draw unemployment assistance while, on the other hand, farmers throughout the country cannot get the labour which they require?

Comment on this

And there are lots of work to be done.

Comment on this

I feel rather strongly in regard to this matter. I was one of those who had to travel from school to school in part of my constituency for some 15 meetings during the past two months, taking the names of farmers who required labour for singling and harvesting beet, and who found they could not get that labour. While those thousands of men are lined up at the labour exchange—unemployed, mar dheadh—and drawing unemployment assistance, we have to go to Connemara to hire men who in the ordinary course go to Britain, and pay their fares down to Cork in order to get them to single beet. We have to go to Connemara to get men to do that work in Cork while, at the same time, we see men there drawing the dole at the labour exchange. There is something radically wrong and unhealthy in a State in which that condition of affairs exists. It might be said that these unemployed men in Cork cannot do that particular kind of work. I am a farmer and I have personal experience of these types of men. I remember that on one occasion at least when I had to bring them down to do pretty skilled work they did it and did it successfully.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What is the relevance of all this to motion No. 11?

Comment on this

The relevance is the bill with which we are presented; the means of rectifying the size of that bill as well as we can so as to prevent a recurrence of a bill of such a size every year. We want to lighten the burden on the producing population. We want our producers in this country to produce more. We do not want to have them held up in their production by the want of labour while, at the same time, thousands of men are unemployed in the country. I think that any Government should give serious attention to that state of affairs and endeavour to remedy the position.

I have another suggestion to make to the Minister as regards taxation. I asked for certain information in connection with the figures and the Minister very kindly gave it to me. I find that in 1943 the betting tax brought in £121,000; now it brings in £660,000. I suggest that this is a fiéld which the Minister might very profitably explore. I consider that this is a tax on the poor devil who goes into a bookie's office and puts a couple of bob on a horse but who has no money to go to the races and no money to go to the grand stand. The Minister charges 7½ per cent. duty on that poor devil's winnings. What is the position of the gentlemen who go to the races and who can afford to go to the grand stand and also of the ladies with the fur coats who go to the races? Their winnings are taxed at the rate of 2½ per cent. because they go to the races while the poor devil who cannot afford to go to the races and goes instead to the bookie's office must pay 7½ per cent. I suggest that that taxation procedure should almost be reversed. The ordinary city man who goes into a bookie's office invests 5/-, 2/6, 2/- or 1/- each way, but the gentlemen who go to Baldoyle and to other racecourses bet in £5, £50 and £100. Undoubtedly there is a wide field there for the Minister's activities.

The gentlemen who frequent the grand stands at these racecourses set out in their big swanky cars for race meetings in various parts of the country and bet in £20 and more. Those gentlemen can very well afford to pay 7½ per cent. or even 10 per cent. on their winnings. They can afford it much better than the unfortunate devil who is bitten by the betting bug but who cannot afford to go to the races and who invests a few bob in a bookie's office. If the Minister takes my advice in this matter his revenue from the betting tax in 1952, instead of being £660,000, will amount to a couple of million pounds. As a matter of fact, it would be as good as the sweepstakes to him.

I would further strongly suggest a very heavy tax on cosmetics. Is it any wonder that our young men remain bachelors when they see one of these ladies all dolled up and with £5 worth of paint plastered over her features? Is it any wonder that there is no inducement to a man who looks at a painted face to get married? I do not know how that face might look if it were washed. There is no use in expecting a man to go and take charge of that type of lady for better or for worse—mainly for worse. I certainly consider that there is undoubtedly a pretty wide field there in which the Minister could wield his axe and bring in some extra money to pay the debts of my dearly beloved departed friends opposite. I am sure that as far as those things are concerned, there is definite room for further taxation which could be used to relieve the burden which the people are bearing under other heads.

I regret to have held up the House so long. I think I have dealt with all the matters with which I intended to deal. I only hope that the people will not for many a long year be again afflicted with the gentlemen who came in here three and a half years ago and threw this burden on the unfortunate people of the country. Remember it is not alone a burden for this year; before people in this country can get one penny for themselves in future they will have to find, because of the activities of these gentlemen for three and a half years, close on £6,000,000 to pay the interest on the money that was borrowed to be squandered. The total amount of revenue raised from beer plus the total amount of the tobacco tax would not clear the debt that these people put on the country's back. Then they have the nerve, the cheek and the impertinence to come up here shouting and howling: "Oh, the poor people, and the Budget, the outrageous Budget of Seán MacEntee. Look at what the poor people have to pay." They have to pay because of the squandermania that existed in this country for three and a half years. They have to pay for Deputy Dillon's idea: "Oh, our only trouble was whether we would manage to spend the money from the American loan before the 31st March this year." He even boasted that he succeeded in spending £5,500,000 in an hour. Now the people must pay the piper and they will have to continue to pay for whatever period the loan runs—for 20 or 30 years. That burden is there to be borne by us and by our successors for the next 20 or 30 years as a result of the three and a half years' squandering craziness. In conclusion, I should like to say that I want to return on behalf of the people of this country grateful thanks to the local government officials of the country who did not swallow the bribe of £3,000,000, that would have to be paid—£1,000,000 by finding it here and £2,000,000 to be found by the ratepayers of the country—a bribe that was handed out a week before the election by the defunct Ministers or ex-Ministers opposite.

Comment on this

I think the Minister for Finance, as a result of the speeches made outside, some of the speeches made by the Opposition in the course of this debate and particularly the speeches made from his own benches, is fully aware of the very great severity of the Budget which he has introduced. A lot of the criticism made by the Opposition I consider to be extravagant but some of it was sound. I hope that, going through that welter of debate, he will pay attention to that part which, stripped of the virulence of political feeling, places in fairly true perspective the effects that this Budget must have on our people. Curiously enough I consider that one of the best analysis of the Budget was made by Deputy Norton. Some of the figures which he produced were particularly effective in showing the result and hardship that must fall on old age pensioners particularly, as a result of the provisions of the Budget. In listening to that speech and appreciating its good points, I could not help feeling how very sad it was for the country generally that Deputy Norton's performances in office had fallen so very far short of his professions in the Opposition Benches. However, I do not think that that detracts from certain points which he made.

I do not know if it is possible these days to introduce successfully a deflationary Budget. The Taoiseach, in answer to recent questions, pointed out that the cost of living must inevitably rise as a result of the removal of the subsidies. I think an inevitable sequel must be further wage demands. They must come and they must be expected and in order to obviate or mitigate hardship on the ordinary working people of the country, those demands will have to be met. Those demands will, therefore, mean increased prices and I do not see how it will be possible to avoid the very evil which I think the Minister intended to avoid by this Budget.

Certain questions have been asked outside the House and I wonder if I might put them to the Minister on behalf of the ordinary people, people who do not pretend to be economists. I am one of those. There are plenty of people who are quite prepared to give this Budget a fair crack of the whip if they could understand some of the reasons for certain of the impositions and the reasons why certain impositions were not made. I would be grateful if the Minister would let us know whether or not it would have been possible to produce a Budget which would have given a greater semblance of justice and a more equal distribution of the burden. Deputy Corry mentioned some taxes that he thought might have been imposed in addition to those already provided for in the Budget. He mentioned an increase in the betting tax and an increase in the tax on cinemas. Indeed, there are others to which he did not advert, and I would like to know if the Minister considered them. He may have had very good reasons for rejecting them.

There is one tax that I think might prove useful and that is a tax on tourists. I am well aware that that will immediately call forth the reply that we are trying to develop our tourist industry. One must however approach this matter from a realistic point of view. We know that many of the tourists who will come in this year will come because of the limitations imposed on continental travel. Would it not be possible to make provision for some form of poll tax or landing tax on these incoming tourists?

There are other taxes worthy of consideration. There is the corporation profits tax. There is the excess profits tax. There are luxury taxes which could be imposed. I think we are all anxious that our State should develop in such a way as to provide an equal opportunity for all our people in every grade of society. We are all anxious to see an improvement in social welfare. We are all anxious to have improved health services. Very few of us would object to the imposition of taxation for these purposes. Because of my experience with the Fine Gael Party, I think it is possible that they might be the exception. As far as I personally am concerned, I have no objection to the imposition of taxation provided the need is quite clearly defined.

What are the objections to a capital levy? In this Budget, the Minister has hit the old people very hard. That, indeed, is, I think, incontrovertible. These old people are coming to the end of their days. Many of them are living in very straitened circumstances. There are many of them in our county homes. There are many of them living quite alone. They will be hit very hard by this Budget. Those of us who are younger can accept the burdens imposed by this Budget and must accept them. I would make a special plea to the Minister to reconsider the implications of this Budget on the old who are, when all is said and done, a special charge upon us. It should be our greatest endeavour to cushion the aged against the impact of rising prices and the hardships which modern life imposes.

Why has the Minister not come down very much harder on luxuries and on the business community? Why has he not come down harder on those who can afford to pay more for their entertainment, who can cut down their horse racing and greyhound racing, their smoking and their drinking? These people can impose self-rationing. Bread, butter, tea and sugar are the essentials of life where the old people are concerned and from that point of view there is no doubt that this Budget will hit them very hard.

There were some very unrealistic speeches from the Opposition. If the Opposition wants to get political kudos and buy votes they need only go out on a platform and recite this Budget. It needs no comment. The Minister must have been fully aware of the implications behind it and his reasons for introducing it must have been very sound indeed because he must understand that it is an extremely dangerous Budget from the political point of view.

While there has been some objective and honest criticism from the Government Benches, I think that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs will have to move a little away from that sliderule mentality he has developed towards human problems and the effect of cutting down on the necessaries of life. He has told us that we smoke too much. He has told us that we drink too much. I feel that the time is not far distant when he may tell us that we eat too much and, following upon that, he will tell us that our old people live too long and that is the reason why he is in favour of the elimination of subsidies. We must have an end once and for all to this approach to the problems affecting the daily lives of the aged and of the average man and woman in our society as if human beings were mere digits in some mathematical conundrum and as if by the process of addition and subtraction we could solve all their problems.

There are some points in relation to taxation generally about which the man in the street is striving to question the Minister. Why did the Minister not tax this? Why did he not tax that? Why did he tax nothing except bread and butter and the necessaries of life? Why hurt most the people in our society who are least able to defend themselves? I think it was Deputy MacBride who suggested that this very severe Budget is due to the fact that the Government has picked a quarrel with the American Government, or something like that.

At any rate, whether that is true or whether it is untrue, there is a general impression abroad that the Taoiseach —the Government—has decided to insist that we shall establish, without doubt, the economic independence of our State, and that this very severe Budget is necessary not only because of the immediate needs of the country but so that we may create a situation whereby we can be independent of any outside interference or any outside commitments. Again, that is the view of the man in the street. I would ask the Taoiseach, or the Minister, if that is so, and if he is trying to fight for the maintenance of our national integrity and independence, that all he has got to do is to tell our people that these serious and hard impositions which strike at everybody, from the youngest infant right up to the oldest amongst us, are imposed in order to maintain our independence and our national sovereignty as a result of the existence of our economic independence. If he does that, then I am quite certain that he will have, without any equivocation, any holding back, the whole strength and power of public opinion behind him in his intent to maintain our independence from any entanglements in the east or in the west.

Deputy Costello introduced a point which, again, has caused a certain amount of disturbance in the minds of the people. He suggested that the Minister is budgeting for a surplus in the region of £10,000,000. Now that is a very serious charge indeed. It is quite possible—I am sure indeed—that Deputy Costello made that charge conscientiously believing it to be true. I feel that the Minister in his own interests would be well advised to deal with that point by showing us that there is no question that this Budget, with all its stringency and with all the resultant hardship which will follow from it, has not been imposed as a result of his concern for indulging in some small political trick whereby the Government may get votes at a later election, be able to balance its budget and have a surplus to mitigate taxes and relíeve old age pensioners. That, indeed, if it were true, would be a very shabby and a very unworthy trick to play on our people. At the same time, the charge has lodged in some quarters and has done some damage. I would suggest that the Minister might reassure us that that is not so.

There is one other serious aspect of the Budget—serious defects in the Budget proposals or Budget statements—which, perhaps, the Minister felt he could not, or should not, deal with. Again, I feel that if he had done so it would have, to a considerable extent, cushioned the serious effect of the Budget. The point is this, that this Budget, or this serious deficit, is in my view a fairly normal result not so much of the three years of inter-Party Government or of the 16 years of Fianna Fáil Government, or of the previous period of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, individually, but is the cumulative result of all three Governments. The fact is that we have pursued an economic policy that could only lead to this very serious position in our economy.

The Minister has not told us, he has not given us any idea or any plan even in broad outline, as to how he proposes to provide that a situation such as this will not recur in the coming financial year or in the next year or evermore, as far as the taxpayer is concerned. Has he, or have the Government, any plan in their minds for a co-ordination of industrial development expansion, under the able handling of Deputy Lemass, with an expansion of agricultural production, that will provide the State with that prosperity wherein it will be possible to provide some more of the money which is at present being asked from the taxpayer? Is there any real intention on the part of the Government to provide for full employment? How can the country be healthy, how can it have a healthy economy when there is— under the inter-Party Government the number of unemployed was 50,000 and now it is 70,000 odd—that considerable proportion of able-bodied men able to work and I think in spite of what Deputy Corry has said willing to work if work is provided for them? In addition to these, we have the usual current number of intending emigrants—20,000, 25,000 or 30,000. Again, they are able to produce wealth for the community, but they are lying idle, and worse than idle, drawing from the national purse, through no fault of their own, unemployment assistance or the dole or whatever it may be. Has the Minister, or have the Government, any comprehensive plan, even in broadest outline, for the absorption of those people into productive employment either in industry or on the land? It seems to me that we can never develop to a state of reasonable security, prosperity and economic independence until the Minister and the Government—whatever Government happens to be in power —are serious about the elimination of these very serious evils from our national life—unemployment and emigration.

There is another form of unemployment, in my view, to which I have referred recently in a number of questions, and that is the insistence on a continuation of manual labour to be used on road work and in the building of roads. I think that this is due to a neglect on our part to find productive employment for these men. I think it is quite wrong that a man who has been educated—and most of them are intelligent men anxious and preferring to do productive employment—should be employed digging holes in the roads and filling them up again when a machine would do the work just as easily. I know quite well that remark can be misrepresented. It has already been misrepresented by that great pseudo-revolutionary, Deputy Dunne, who accused me of disrespect to the road worker because I felt the road worker should be provided with proper employment. I do not think that I am particularly concerned with Deputy Dunne's opinion of me. We are all aware of that vocal and vociferous rebelly red robin who so rapidly became a quietly chirping pet canary when the vested interests opposed him and opposed a progressive measure in this House.

One of the closest friends whom I admire most happens to be a road worker and it is because of my interest in that man that I think it is quite wrong of us to accept that we shall continue this form of famine era unemployment simply because we are not getting down to reorganising the State in a proper way.

Again, I wonder if there is any attempt on the part of the Government to try to find some way of getting more money from the farmer. Plenty of Deputies here will no doubt object strongly to that proposition. At the same time I think it is unquestioned that the farmer does very well for himself even under this Budget. He gets the advantage of children's allowances and is not very seriously hurt by removal of subsidies on either the bread or the butter. He gets the annual advantage of paying little or nothing in income-tax. I wonder if the Minister does not consider that the problem is a sufficiently serious one, to merit inquiring into the fact that the farming community are fairly heavily subsidised out of the national purse in various ways.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy know about the farming community?

Comment on this

I know enough about it. There are plenty of grants by way of subsidies paid out of the national purse to the farmer. I think it is only fair that the farmer should make a fair contribution to the national purse and that he should take his share of the burden of running the country and running our social services.

This whole question of subsidies is, of course, a very complex and complicated one. I wonder if it would be possible for the inter-Party bloc or sections of the inter-Party bloc, who may be sufficiently courageous to give an independent opinion, to say what they will do or would do were they returned to power in a multi-Party Government about this question of subsidies? Would they restore the subsidies in full or in part? That is a fair question and I think they ought to be able to give a straight answer.

They have made a tremendous howl throughout the country on this whole matter. All right. That is a fair game. That is politics but at the same time it is irresponsible of the Fine Gael group if they suggest by this howl that they deprecate the removal of the subsidies and at the same time, were they returned to power, they would also remove them.

I can only gather in the House from listening to Deputy O'Higgins who interjected a remark in reply to Dr. Ryan, Minister for Social Welfare, and said that the only people who intended that the subsidies should go on indefinitely were Fianna Fáil. I may be drawing too much from that simple remark. If I am I apologise to the Deputy but it gave me the impression, as he was speaking for Fine Gael, that he did not consider the subsidies would be continued.

Some of the most impressive arguments which I heard against subsidies came from some of the members of the Fine Gael Party. At the same time, a lot of them seemed to hinge round an argument which I considered to be a specious one which is that you are providing cheap bread for the very rich person. If the rich person is paying taxes I do not see why he should not get some of the benefits of those taxes. In addition, I consider the argument largely to be like the one about the Connemara lady paying for the Fitzwilliam Square medical services, the old argument in favour of a means test. Our concern should be with what is the impact on the poor person or the person with limited means. If the other person happens to benefit I do not think you are justified in penalising the poor person in order to try and "get at" the rich one. At the same time, the removal of the subsidies will impose a serious hardship. I feel that the Opposition would greatly strengthen their case against the Budget proposals were they to make a clear, definite statement as to whether they would or would not remove the subsidies and reimpose the subsidies should they be returned to power.

I think the tax imposed on the licensed business is an acceptable tax. It has always struck me, as I said before, as curiously anomalous that the licensing trade has such a very strong hold on successive Governments and has exerted such a strong hold and such a strong influence in the making of policy here in Ireland. The Minister is to be congratulated on taking a stand in relation to this particular tax.

I find it difficult to understand how the Labour Party can justify their refusal to vote for the taxes of different kinds imposed. Are they against taxation even for the provision of social services? I can understand Fine Gael voting against them and I can understand the Sancho Panza of the Clann na Poblachta remnants voting against taxation. But I cannot understand the Labour Party, if they are to implement their policy of expansion of social services in different ways, voting against taxation. I think they have followed too closely the lead given to them by their Fine Gael mentors in the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Will the Deputy stand for the removal of the dance taxation?

Comment on this

I think the removal of the dance taxation was extremely foolish. I simply cannot understand it. I think it is a very foolish thing to have done. Politically also, I think it is a very foolish thing to have done. I think the Minister will come to feel that it is a very foolish thing. I do not see how it can be justified, but perhaps the Minister may be able to provide his own explanation. He will most certainly need it on the hustings, if the Opposition is worth a damn.

There are a few points by which the Minister could help to strengthen public opinion in favour of this Budget. One of the things is some attempt to make reality out of the prices tribunal. I have nothing to say against the members of the prices tribunal. They do their job extremely well within the powers given to them, but I think their powers are too limited. Recent inquiries before that tribunal, while carried out most conscientiously by the members of the tribunal, have proved completely ineffective by virtue of the obvious collusion amongst those seeking increases in benefit. There is the most recent example—I do not want to comment on it very much—in relation to an increase of insurance which was completely unjustified. But the prices tribunal are in a very difficult position because they are not in a position to call for confidential information from business houses. Another case is sub judice and I will not comment on it.

The people do believe, rightly or wrongly, that a lot of goods are overpriced, that a lot of industrialists are making too much. Everybody wants them to make a fair profit. Many of them are only taking a fair profit. But there are some of them, businessmen and industrialists, who are doing considerable disservice to the good name of Irish industrialists by their avaricious grasping of opportunities given to them by a society which will not gratuitously pry into their affairs. If it is shown, as I think it has been shown on a number of occasions, that this gentility on our part, if you like to call it that, is being exploited by these trade rings and the different organisations and industries, then this House should give the Government the powers to meet the needs of a properly functioning prices tribunal which can call for any documents it wishes and, on the information provided, make its decision. The prices tribunal was set up in a burst of exuberance by the inter-Party Government, probably with the best intentions in the world, but it is completely ineffective. If the Minister were to give proper powers to such a body, alter it how he wishes, it would help considerably towards the establishment of a greater sense of confidence on the part of the people in this Budget.

Naturally the backing of a Budget such as this has serious implications for all of us for which we are fully aware we will at a later date be answerable at the bar of public opinion. The public will accept the burden. As a race, we are used to hard times. As long as we feel that this Budget, with its impositions and its hardships, is necessary and that the Minister has exhausted every possible device known to his very able officials in the Department of Finance before he has touched, or felt that he has had to touch, the old people, then there can be no alternative but for us to accept it. My own view is that in the end we would inevitably in the inter Party Government have had to face such a dilemma. I believe that the plan was the introduction of the Social Welfare Bill, then an election, and then a McGilligan Budget the severity of which would make the Minister's production pale into insignificance with its harsh and cruel impositions on all sections of the community.

Comment on this

That is a piece of pure invention on the part of the Deputy.

Comment on this

I do not intend to try to compete in the art of invention with Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this

The Deputy does it naturally without any practising of the art.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, order! Deputy Dr. Browne.

Comment on this

I would require to be very seriously provoked before I would vote against this Budget and for the return of an inter-Party Government. My memory is not so short as the memory of the public possibly is. I do not intend easily to go back to Deputy Everett and Baltinglass, to Deputy MacEoin——

Comment on this

You were the one Minister who applied for more jobs than any other. I have your letters on my file.

Comment on this

——to Deputy MacEoin and the Legal Adoption Bill——

Comment on this

I kept your file.

Comment on this

——to Deputy Costello and the medical association and the sell-out of the mother and child scheme——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You have not been so hot since.

Comment on this

——nor do I wish to go back to Deputy McGilligan, the then Minister for Finance, who made the proposition that I should collaborate with my colleagues in providing a faked Budget.

Comment on this

That again is an untrue statement.

Comment on this

That has never been repudiated.

Comment on this

I repudiate it now. It is an untrue statement.

Comment on this

The reason I would not return that Government is that I would be failing in my duty to the people——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Are we discussing a Budget that would have been introduced in certain circumstances or a Budget which has been introduced and which takes £20,000,000 additional out of the people's pockets by way of taxation, on the one hand——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is making a speech.

Comment on this

——and increased food prices on the other?

Comment on this

To pay for your spree.

Comment on this

I ask if we are discussing the Budget before the House or an imaginary Budget, which, in different circumstances, might have been introduced.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy, I take it, is relating one to the other.

Comment on this

I will conclude by saying that I concede this Budget to be a very serious Budget, with particularly serious implications for all of us. At the same time, I believe it to be the product of the minds of honest men. They may be wrong and they may find that they are wrong. At the same time, it has that germ of honesty of purpose which is a lot more than I could say for the Budgets I have known.

Comment on this

I should like very much to reply in detail to a number of the points raised by the last speaker.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

You do not have to—he is in the net.

Comment on this

I hope, however, that, in the way in which I propose to deal with this matter, these questions will indirectly be answered. As I have already said, shortly after we came into office, we became aware of the fact that our fears in opposition were fully justified, and more than justified. Every sign and every indication we had were corroborated by the facts that we were able to establish definitely from figures as time went on. We saw very soon that there was not the slightest shadow of doubt that the Government was faced with expenditure far in excess of the revenues provided to meet it.

We tried to get the public to realise the situation. We knew that when the hour of reckoning, namely, the new Budget period, came, the public were going to get a rude shock. We did not get a shock to the same extent, because we had been following events fairly closely in opposition and were being prepared for the situation that had to be dealt with by the events from day to day and by the accounts from day to day; but when we tried to get the people to realise the situation the Opposition raised the cry that we were trying to frighten the people, that there was no such situation as that which we were describing and they warned us of the effect our statements might have on public opinion and public credit. They did everything that people who really understood the situation should not do.

We found when we came into office that a large number of Supplementary Estimates, amounting to some £11,000,000 odd, had to be introduced. Taking away the disputed amount in respect of fuel losses, there was still something in the neighbourhood of a sum of £9,000,000, for which the only provision in the previous Budget was £1,500,000. The result of it all was that when the Minister for Finance and the Government came down finally to consider the Budget for the coming year, it appeared that, comparing the estimates of expenditure of the previous year with the estimates of expenditure for the ensuing year, there was a difference of something like £20,000,000 and that the only offset to that was a possible increase of about £5,000,000 in revenue. When the closest estimates were made, that appeared to be the final result also. There was between anticipated revenue and anticipated expenditure a gap of £15,000,000 which had to be bridged.

That was no pleasant prospect for the Government. I remember that, in the pre-war years and even during the war years, we would have shuddered at the idea of having to meet one-fifth of that amount, knowing that it would have to be met by increased taxation. Listening to members on the opposite benches, one would think that the Minister for Finance was a sort of ogre, somebody who took sadistic pleasure in imposing hardships on the people. Why should a member of any democratic Government approach his task in that spirit? Everybody who has paid any attention to politics either here or in any other country, or who knows of politics even through books, knows perfectly well that the danger with democratic Governments is not that they will impose burdens on the people heavier than the people are willing to bear, but that they will not do their duty to the people and to the community in getting from the community the means necessary to run the services properly. That is the danger, and it was that danger that made the previous Government run away from their duty of providing last year for expenditure which they could have largely anticipated. It was not possible to anticipate to the nearest decimal point of a million the amount necessary, but it was possible to get a rough estimate, an estimate which can be provided by people who are expert in providing such information over a period of years, who have got the facts on which to base their judgement so that their estimates—guesses, if you like— are informed guesses and not stupid ones. The previous Government, by its failure, have left to us to do in one year a task which, if it had been divided over two separate years, would still have been a difficult task and would have presented to the Government that had only to deal with half of it a difficult problem.

As I have already said on other occasions, there was only one way of dealing with it—either reduce expenditure or increase taxation. There is, I think, general agreement in the House that we ought to meet current expenses from current revenue. We may differ on a particular item as to whether it is or is not proper to be met by current revenue—in other words, whether it is one which we would call generally a capital item or not—but there can be no difference of opinion that the £15,000,000 about which I have been talking is £15,000,000 that affects current revenue and current expenditure. We have excluded from it the £9.27 odd millions which the Opposition, according to their system, would class as proper to be met by borrowing. I can say this, that some of us believe that a considerable portion, which might even amount to one-half, of that £9.27 millions would not properly be met by borrowing. However, we excluded the £9.27 millions partly so that the differences here and the difficulties here might be met by direct argument on a common ground and partly because we fully realise that if you are moving in a car at 80 miles an hour or so you cannot take a right-hand turn and hope not to get upset. We realise fully that to deal even with the £15,000,000 is an extremely difficult task and will impose heavy burdens on the people. We do not object to the Budget being classed as a severe Budget. It is a severe Budget, so severe, as I have said already, that no democratic Government in its senses would dream of introducing it for the paltry reasons that have been suggested by the Leader of the Opposition. No Government would dream of introducing a Budget of that sort were it not that it felt that the national interest demanded that it should have been introduced.

I have said that I believe we are at one in regarding this £15,000,000, this balance, this difference, as affecting current expenditure and current revenue. We are also at one, I think, in the agreement—I have already mentioned it—that current expenditure should be met from current revenue.

It is no harm, perhaps, that we should think for a moment of the items that go to make up this £15,000,000 or £20,000,000. I will try to enumerate a few of them. There is, first of all, something like £3,750,000 made up between the increase in the flour and bread subsidy and the butter subsidy. There is something like £4,000,000 made up by the £2,000,000 on social welfare, the £1,000,000 in grants to the health services and £1,000,000 in old age pensions. There is another £3,000,000 in increases in salaries of civil servants, teachers, gardaí and so on. There is about £1? millions subsidy to meet the losses on Córas Iompair Éireann and Great Northern Railways. There is £1,000,000 for contingencies. There is, of course—I will have to refer to it later when I deal with Deputy Costello's points—the £2,000,000 increase in the service of the public debt. These are only some of the items.

Now, it is all very well for us here, for the Opposition and others, Independents, to cry out when Budget time comes along and when we are asking that the money to meet these services should be raised. That is not the time to cry out. Again it is one of the weaknesses of democracy that when the cry should come it does not come: it comes only when the commitment has been made and when the debts have been incurred and when the inevitable hour of reckoning comes. It is coming back from the riotous holiday to the sober everyday work. It is the morning after the night before. It is expressed well in the Gaelic: "is milis fíon, ach is searbh a íoc." We all like to provide good things, we all like to have splendid social services, we all like to see that the servants of the State are well paid, we all like to keep on our railway services. We all like to do these things and whenever there is a proposal made by the Government for an increase of any kind the criticism of the Opposition is always that it is not enough, that more should be provided. The very urge to be popular with one section or other of the nation influences both the Opposition who have no responsibility and very often even Governments who have responsibility and drives them to seek popularity for the time being and to hope that when the day of reckoning comes they will not have to incur the blame.

If we want not to have severe taxation, if we want to be in the position that when it comes to the day of reckoning we will be able to meet the reckoning, then the time to look out is when the proposals for the expenditure of public money come before the House. My own belief is, considering our means, that from this day on, from this time on, we will have to be careful. To me at any rate, looking at what was happening as we saw it when we got into the Government, it seemed that if we were to continue that pace for very long—and it would not even be very long—we would come to a very abrupt end which would mean the severest hardships, hardships for which we would not be easily able to find a remedy, for every section of our people. Our view was that while there was still time to change that trend we would change it even if we were defeated here in our effort to do so.

The question of the independence of this country was raised. It has not been raised in the way in which I want to deal with it. As far as we here were concerned and as far as I personally was concerned, we have been at one with a number of our colleagues on both this and the other side of the House in our aim to establish the independence of our people and we realised the extent to which political independence can be sapped by economic dependence. We want to do everything in our power to see that our people will not be reduced to the position in which they will have to go hat in hand to try to get from others things which they could produce themselves. There are things which we can produce ourselves; most of our needs can be produced here and as to the things which we want to get from outside we should be able by our efforts here to secure enough surplus to give in exchange for them. We do not want to see our position here so worsened that the reserves which give us this economic independence will be frittered away. On the current side we want to see to it that we live decently within our means and that we will strive so to bring it about that when we pass on we will leave things behind us better than we found them.

It has been suggested, if you please, that all this unpopularity which we are prepared to face was caused because the Minister for Finance wanted covertly to bring into the current account the capital items which, for the reasons I have stated, we have presented on the capital side for the moment, that is the £9.27 million. Is there anybody with any political sense in this country who would believe that? It was, of course, necessary to try to find a motive. The Leader of the Opposition is an excellent advocate well versed in all the arts by which the worst can be made to appear the better cause. He has tried to look for a motive because he knew instinctively that the jury of public opinion would be looking for a motive in this case. The only motive he could suggest was that the Minister for Finance was so wedded to an idea, if you please, this idea of the £9.27 million being treated as current instead of capital, that he was willing to bring himself and the whole Government into the political situation which we must face on a Budget of this sort. Nobody would accept that.

Of course, the first thing you do if you want to plead a cause well—I believe it is commonly understood by advocates and lawyers—is to convince yourself that your cause is right, for then you can go forth to battle with all the fervour of a righteous believer. Deputy Costello has mentioned six points and I do not think that a baby in politics would accept a single one of the six. I will try, as far as I can remember them, to deal with them. The first point was that we had underestimated the saving in subsidies by something like £2,000,000. Then he proceeds to work with averages to arrive at this underestimation. There is not a single teacher of averages in any national school who has not, in the teaching of them, to impress his pupils with the danger of handling averages and nobody who has opened a book on statistics will have gone very far before finding again that warning under a variety of headings. The danger the schoolmaster would have taught, the danger of introducing proportionality in matters of that sort——

Comment on this

It was the Minister for Finance who introduced the average of 1/6 being taken off 2/-.

Comment on this

Exactly, and because an average of that sort was introduced, instead of taking it on its face value as what it was, it is used to make calculations giving results that are millions of pounds out in a total of £15,000,000. If the Deputy waits I will meet these points. If you are going to take proportionality in time there must be some equality of flow before you can do it.

Comment on this

What does that mean?

Comment on this

If the Deputy is not able to understand that then he is too dense for me or anybody else to go into it——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Fraud.

Comment on this

When I say things I try to speak simply and do not get off in the ethereal air as the Deputy does from time to time.

Comment on this

We want an explanation in figures.

Comment on this

The Deputy will get an explanation in figures if he will wait for it.

Comment on this

I will wait.

Comment on this

Very well. You do not require figures to see that if a situation completely changes in the last three-quarters of a year from what it was in the first you will not get correct results by taking the whole year, dividing by four and taking that as the average.

Comment on this

We want figures.

Comment on this

You want figures?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That was an unfortunate change of Government.

Comment on this

You are getting figures and you will not take them; you are getting the principles that underlie the figures and you will not take them.

Comment on this

Figures we want.

Comment on this

The figures are these: in the portion of the year in which there will be reduced subsidies on flour and bread the situation is completely changed; you are losing in that three-quarters of the year the money you would have got in subsidy by way of the sale of white flour which is £1,000,000.

Comment on this

That is not the figure we are looking for.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants me to go over all the figures that the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of Finance put up regarding these things. I am giving the fact that the subsidy on white flour means a difference of £1,000,000. It brought £1,000,000 into the Exchequer which will not come in the new situation.

Comment on this

The subsidy on white flour brought in £1,000,000?

Comment on this

The subsidy on white flour in three-quarters of the year is more than £1,000,000. That is the overcharge.

Comment on this

Not the subsidy.

Comment on this

The overcharge brought a subsidy to a subsidy so to speak. It relieved the Exchequer to the amount of £1,000,000. Also there is to be a better flour for the three-quarters of the year. Instead of 85 per cent. extraction there is to be 80 per cent. extraction. That better flour is going to cost something over a third of a million.

Comment on this

Surely the people will buy less of it because of the increased price.

Comment on this

That is not the point; it is what we are losing; it is what it would have brought in. There is at once £1? million which Deputy Costello coolly ignored. In other words, he did not try to see whether the circumstances were going to remain the same, which would be essential in order that his arguments should be right. He lumps together bread and butter and tea. They vary differently. Suppose that this question was asked: A man has a house, the yearly rent of which we suppose he pays in a lump sum, just for the argument. He pays a yearly rent, say, of £200. He pays it, let us say, in November. Suppose the fuel and light for a year, say, the preceding year, have worked out to be £80. If you ask an innocent child, he might possibly tell you that, if that man left his house vacant for three months, you could get the amount that he had saved, or the amount that he would have to pay for the three-quarters, by simply taking a quarter of the whole. Of course, that would be absurd. Suppose it was under lease. You can easily see that the rent was a charge that he would have to pay whether the house was empty or not. The fuel charge would depend on the months. It would vary with the months. If he were away in the summer time, it is quite clear that he would not save a quarter of the total yearly cost, which would be obtained by simply dividing the £80 by four. The light and the fuel might not vary in the same way at all. It is possible that he would use a greater proportion of the light in the summer time, relatively, than he did of fuel, that the rate of fuel consumption in the winter time would be relatively more.

In fact, the question should not be put to us, to show in detail where our figures are right, but it should be put up to the person who proposes that short cut to a thing which in the nature of the thing has to be intricate. Dr. Ryan went through it in the case of butter, cold storage and so on, and indicated the influence of these things. These things cannot be worked out in a short rule of thumb.

Comment on this

Is the Taoiseach indicating that the subsidies cost less in the summer?

Comment on this

I am indicating this, that in relation, to the savings which Deputy Costello was talking about, in relation to our savings generally, he has made no provision for the fact that there was already a saving in the offset to the subsidy from the sale of the white flour, and that there is also a further expenditure ensuing from the reduced extraction, namely, that the Exchequer was losing on one hand and would have to pay more on the other. It is losing the subsidy on the white flour and it has to give more to the public, so to speak, and therefore will incur a heavier charge in the lower extraction of the better flour. These two items together amount to £1? million.

In this House, up to the present anyhow, when a Parliamentary Question is asked, we have not to go and give all the details by either the Statistical Department or the various Departments of State. It is given here on the authority of the Government as the best information that they have on the matter, the best information that can be got after the checks and rechecks and I can say honestly that whenever I have been concerned in regard to figures, when they come up to me I have, time after time, if ever I was going to use them, asked for them to be checked and rechecked.

Comment on this

Very wise.

Comment on this

It might be wise. Homer sometimes nods. Departments of State sometimes make mistakes. I am not saying that such things cannot happen. Most careful scrutiny sometimes lapses and you find sometimes mistakes occur.

Comment on this

They do.

Comment on this

But they are rare on the whole—rare. What I would have imagined would be the natural course is, instead of taking for granted that the mistake had been made, to ask a question: "Is it possible that this mistake had been made?" But, of course, it is very much better to assert, assert and assert again and, if you are proved wrong, reassert and pay no attention whatever to the way in which the mistake has been exposed. We will hear again, of course, that these six points are right.

Comment on this

Indeed you will.

Comment on this

I am sure I will, from the Deputy. I have not the slightest doubt that we will and, therefore, the implication is that the Departments of State that have furnished these mistakes to us, are collaborating with us to deceive the House. That is what it means.

Comment on this

Ministers can speak for themselves.

Comment on this

Ministers speak for themselves. We are speaking for ourselves and speaking after check and recheck and the figures that I have got are that the total savings were £6.668 million and, therefore, that, in fact, to the extent of the difference between that figure and £15.24 million, we are in this year subsidising food to the extent of over £8,500,000. So, when people talk of withdrawing the food subsidy, will they please remember that £8,500,000 is being distributed in subsidy at the moment?

Of course, those who do not want to see will not see and those who do not want to hear will not hear. If I were to produce the detailed figures of the Departments and furnish them here to the House, we would still have people who would say: "Oh, no, they are wrong. Our rough-and-ready rule will do it. We can tell how much the person would gain in three months by being absent on holiday from his house, say, for three months, by dividing the £280, which is the total amount he would have to spend if he were in the house, by four, and we will know at once what the gain is." That is the type of calculation we are asked to accept as representing the truth whereas, if you wanted to know the actual case, you would have to look at the man's previous year's accounts, as the Departments have done in dealing with this question of subsidies. They must look at the previous year's account, see how it varies from month to month, see how the charges come for payment. There has been no question on Deputy Costello's part of dealing with arrears that come from one year to another the corresponding arrears on one side balancing with the outgoing payments on the other side.

Comment on this

Would the Taoiseach be prepared to accept the accuracy of the figures on the example he gave of butter? Dr. Ryan's figures differ from those of the Minister to the extent of no less than £300,000.

Comment on this

Before I could commit myself to a statement of that sort, I would have to have the figures side by side.(Interruptions.)

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach should be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

No person could deal with these complicated figures without having the various calculations.

Comment on this

That is our trouble. We have not got them.

Comment on this

At least you have the same information as you have for the same item in the Book of Estimates.

Comment on this

We have been given conflicting figures. One says £3,550,000——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach must be allowed to proceed without interruption.

Comment on this

I have said the basis on which Deputy Costello proposes to deal with that matter is a basis which is fundamentally wrong and can be shown to be fundamentally wrong. Only by an extraordinary accident could they be right. If a teacher got that answer and it was the right answer, and he saw that method of doing it, he would immediately suspect that the boy had cooked it. It is easy to present a wrong solution and ask a person: "Show me what is wrong in that?" I have myself on more than one occasion been presented with that device. It is a very common thing in, say, the trisection of an angle. It is necessary to search for hours to see where it is wrong before you find out the exact mistake that has been made. In problems of that kind you would have to go through every detail.

I have pointed out, to the comprehension of any ordinary person with intelligence, that if you included items such as were included in the case of flour and other items in the case of butter, you could see at once that only by an extraordinary coincidence could the answer that was given by Deputy Costello be right.

The next item that he spoke of was in regard to the social welfare services. He said that £3,000,000 was put down for that whereas the Minister for Health stated that the cost was only £2,000,000. He conveniently forgot or neglected to give the phrase in full: "Social welfare and other services." That is the one contingency item that there is in the whole Budget statement —"other services". We realise that you have the possibility, the likelihood, the extreme probability, if we are to take the past into account, that there will be some supplemental Estimates. One million pounds is a very modest provision for this. I hope that when we come to the end of the year we will not find that it is as inadequate as was the £1,500,000 which was allowed for contingencies or supplementary items last year. I hope that is clear to Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this

I will be talking to you about that later.

Comment on this

He will be talking about a lot but he will be unable to point out that there is any deception in that.

Comment on this

I want to link up the trisection of an angle.

Comment on this

We do not want to get back into those controversial topics. We have quite enough for the present. I hope that point has been dealt with. The next point Deputy Costello dealt with was that there should be £1.8 million for reserve stocks as there was in the previous Budget. He did not condescend to tell us why the provision this year for stocks should be precisely the same as last year. A great deal of our difficulty, we were told, was from stockpiling of various kinds. Why should the figure this year be the same as last year? Yet, of course, you must take some figure and it is considered good enough to raise a matter of that kind and bring it in without any explanation whatsoever.

Unfortunately I am not dealing with these matters in order as I would have liked, but I hope I will cover the five or six before I finish. The next was that there was no provision made for saving, that the experience in the past was that we could rely on savings of £1,000,000 or £1,500,000, or some such sum. Can we? Deputy Costello made one statement which was incorrect in that connection. He said that such a deduction was always made. It was not always made. When we were in Government we did make provision for that; when there was proper estimation and a proper attempt being made to make the Budget something of reality there was a practice of trying to allow for overestimation in that way. But what has been the result of the last couple of years? Has it been overestimation? I spoke at the beginning of the amount by which the Budget was unbalanced. Last year, leaving out the items that the Opposition, the former Government, wanted to have treated as capital items, actual expenditure was about £7,000,000 in excess of anticipated expenditure. That is, instead of having a subtraction for saving there should have been an addition for overspending. The previous year the figure was £1,500,000. Therefore, if you take these Estimates, by and large, the chances are that the £1,000,000 for contingencies is not enough. Therefore, it would be ridiculous, under such circumstances, to arbiments—which trarily take off a sum for overestimation. Of course, in the case of sums for overestimation and buoyancy of the revenue—another of Deputy Costello's points—you could write down a figure of £4,000,000 just the same as you could write down £2,000,000 or £3,000,000. In fact, in cases like this, you could write down anything you pleased and endeavour to justify it. Buoyancy of the revenue has been mentioned by Deputy Costello as one of the matters for which inadequate provision was made. The provision for buoyancy was, in fact, about £2.7 million. That compares fairly well with the £3.1 million estimation for buoyancy in the previous year.

It is very difficult to estimate precisely what way revenue will go. In the previous year there was a certain element that came into revenue by way of arrears of income-tax which helped to swell the revenue for that particular year. It was due to the bank strike and the consequential failure to pay income-tax, and it could be described as a windfall. Are we to budget on the basis of windfalls, or are we to judge the Budget on as accurate an estimate as we possibly can get?

All the points I have mentioned are without foundation. Let me now come to another point—overestimation for the service of the debt. The service of the debt is up by £2,000,000. It is up by £2,000,000 because of extra charges that come for payment or have to be met under that head. There are four or five of them. First of all, there is this one: Ways and Means Advances last year were regarded as temporary advances, advances that could be dealt with on the basis of temporary borrowing. We have gone beyond that and the funds from which these Ways and Means Advances are drawn will have to be dealt with on the basis of long-term borrowings, which means increased rates. Therefore, one item is the increased rates on these advances. Next, there is a loan in the offing, and a certain element of the interest on that loan will have to be provided this year. The interest on Marshall Aid is another item which falls to be met.

There is a fourth item. These four items taken together offset certain savings which are effected by the conversion. Even if one puts the savings on conversion as an offsetting factor, there is still £2,000,000, and that £2,000,000 has come from this side of the House with the same authority that any figure would be given here in reply to a parliamentary question. The other day, in reply to a parliamentary question, when I was giving figures for emigration, I was asked where were they published. There has been a practice since this House first sat that, when parliamentary questions were answered, the statistics so given were regarded as having been published. However, the amateur statisticians on the other side of the House are, of course, now not prepared to accept this basis. They are being given these statistics on the same basis which was always adopted, but, in their eyes, they are not right. They were quite right, however, when they were published in this manner by themselves. I am giving the figure given by the Minister for Finance in this House as the figure which has to be faced—the estimate of the anticipated extra charge that has to be met for the service of the public debt.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach did not mention the fourth one. He mentioned Ways and Means Advances, a loan this year, and Marshall Aid interest. He was going to deal with the fourth item, but he did not mention it.

Comment on this

The Deputy would help me immensely if he could give me the four items.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said there were four heads, but he only gave us three.

Comment on this

The fourth is the annuity which has to be provided for the sum that we agree, for this year anyhow, is to be regarded as capital. The capital item is £9.27 million, and there is an annuity to be provided to meet that.

These are the four items, and even when one has subtracted the saving on conversion it gives one £2,000,000. I do not know whether I have omitted any item. If anybody tells me which one of Deputy Costello's points I have omitted, I will be happy to deal with it. There is not one of them which is justified. I have dealt with all these points at considerable length, and I am sure there are a lot of other things I have to say, but they will have to be left over. We have to meet a deficit of £15,000,000. When it came before us for consideration, as I have already said, we had either to reduce expenditure or to increase revenue. Neither is popular. It was "rogha an dá diogh" to us—the lesser of two evils.

We were responsible for introducing bread subsidies when in Government before. We introduced them as a temporary expedient to meet a situation which in 1947-48 we thought would be temporary. Earlier, we had introduced them partially, when there was a question of trying to prevent the cost of living from rising and of trying to maintain price and wage stability and general monetary stability. However, extraordinary things were happening in 1947-48 on account of the effect of demand for the goods which could not be obtained during the war. We thought that once that temporary situation was passed we would get back into a level situation again.

In order to keep down an increase in the cost of living we proposed to increase food subsidies. By this means we hoped to keep prices steady as we had in the earlier part of the war. Originally we thought we could limit the food subsidies to £2,000,000, but we had to go further. We thought that the best way of meeting this, and of getting the money that was required —it was a substantial sum—was from taxation of things that were less essential than food. When we did that what a different tune we had from the Opposition. Then, of course, the subsidies were a sham. They meant nothing. But the taxation was a reality and the taxation was the thing that was harped on. From every crossroads and every hustings we were denounced as people who were taxing the simple amusements of the ordinary man.

Then we were the hair-shirt people —the puritanical-minded people who could not be happy if they saw people enjoying themselves in any way. The fact that we were subsidising the food for the homes was a matter to be waved aside. Now it is quite the other way. These food subsidies have gone up from £2,000,000, which we thought might be the original ceiling, to £15,000,000. I have not asked for a recent calculation—I shall ask for it, now that it occurs to me—of the proportion of British expenditure which is devoted to food subsidies. They are sometimes held up as an example to us. A sum of £15,000,000 is a substantial proportion of our bill. I had a calculation in respect of British subsidies but it referred to the period before rearmament began and the rearmament programme may have upset the figure. At that time, we were subsidising food to a greater extent than they were in Britain. As I say, I am not sure what the position is at the moment by reason of the rearmament programme. I do not know whether or not our proportion is higher at present.

Whenever the question of food subsidies has been considered, the ultimate conclusion is that inasmuch as the payments have to be met by taxation, which is as universal as the benefit, what you are doing, in the main, is not redistributing income but, in actual fact, robbing Peter to pay Peter. It is not a question of robbing Peter to pay Paul; what you are doing is robbing Peter to pay Peter—and, in the meantime, there is the matter of waste in respect of the administration, and so forth. I do not say that that argument is a conclusive argument but it is an argument. We came to the conclusion that if there was to be any reduction in the services provided by the State for the individuals of the community the proper place to look for that reduction was in the food subsidies. It was a mere accident that they amounted to £15,000,000. You did not have to impose any taxation whatever if you cut out all the food subsidies. Therefore, if the attitude of the Government was simply that of cutting out the food subsidies we should have saved ourselves from the odium which attaches itself to the imposition of taxes on beer, tobacco and so forth. We should have saved ourselves all that odium simply by wiping out the food subsidies—and we should have balanced our Budget. But we did not do it. Why? We did not do it because we felt that the sudden change would be a very great hardship on certain sections of the community and that the greatest hardship would be in relation to bread.

Therefore, instead of cutting off all the food subsidies, and stopping at that, we left the subsidy, to a very great extent, on bread. We might have come down a little lower and left more of the bread to be subsidised were it not that we had to be very careful, if we were going to get the advantage of abolishing rationing, that the price of bread and flour would not be such that they would be a cheaper animal food than other available animal foods. We had to be very careful that the bread and flour would not be wasted by being given to animals so that we would be subsidising not human food but animal food. The authorities gave us the price of 4/10 a stone as the critical point at which flour would not be economical as an animal food. Roughly, that price corresponded to the charge of 9d. for the 2 lb. loaf. That was the position regarding the fixing of that particular point in relation to bread.

We wished to end rationing. We must get back as soon as we can, if possible, to normal conditions of living in this country with as little State regulation as possible. We felt that there was no reason why we should continue to subsidise tea and that the price of butter would have to be left to find its own level. This year, we are spending slightly over £8,500,000 on food subsidies—£8.572 million or something like that. Therefore, it will be seen that, deliberately, we did not go the whole way in respect of removing the subsidy on bread because we had regard to the poorer elements in the community. Not merely that, but also we had regard to the old age pensioners. We have proved successively on various occasions that the needs of that section of the community are as present in our minds as they are in those of any other political Party. Within the means of the community— with a full realisation that these moneys have to be taken out of somebody's pocket and that the number of rich people in this country is not so very great—we have had regard on all occasions to the needs of the old age pensioners.

I am tempted to speak further on this matter when we hear so much about taxing luxuries and the rich at this moment, but perhaps I should not do so. In this case we try to minimise the effect, on the old age pensioners and also on other classes, of the reduction of the bread subsidy, by increasing the rate of pension by 1/6 a week. We tried to come to the relief of large families by adding to the children's allowances. Instead of 2/6 for each child after the second, we have provided an additional 1/6, making the allowance 4/- for the third and subsequent children and in order to meet the case of families which are not large, we are allowing a payment of 2/6 a week for the second child. I do not want to say that these are anything more than averages; I recognise that the average is the mean between things above the line and things below the line and there will be people for whom the average amount will not be full compensation. We realise that, but we have got to get the money somehow and, consequently, we felt that that was the best provision that it was possible for us to make. If people feel that old age pensioners still want some further relief that will have to be considered separately. I clearly do not want in any way to be regarded as making any promises; far from it, because the trouble is that I believe that we should make no more promises about matters of that sort until we see how they will be provided for. What I am saying is that if this question has to be dealt with, it will have to be dealt with separately. It cannot be dealt with as part of this measure. We have gone as far as we possibly could go to meet the claims in this Budget.

There is one class in the community that has been ground between the upper and the nether millstone for a long time, that is those people who would be regarded as having moderate incomes now. They are called upon to pay to the full for everything they get. They are supposed to get no benefits from the State, except those that are universal, and they are supposed to pay fully as private families for whatever they have to get. The charges that fall on every member of the community have to be met by them. We felt that the reduction of the bread subsidy would be a matter of considerable importance for them and we tried to come to their aid by reliefs in income-tax. No single person who has at present a salary of less than about £900 will have to pay anything more than he was paying before. Many such persons will be paying much less, but no single person with a salary under £900 will be charged any more as a result of the new rates. That is obviously a relief, not for the rich but for that section of the community that has been ground down between the upper and nether millstone by State action for a considerable number of years past.

No person who is married and who has a salary of less than £1,069—I think that is the critical figure—will have to pay more in income-tax in the present year than he has been paying up to the present. No man with a wife and three children whose salary is less than £1,348—I think that is the critical figure in their case—will have to pay more in income-tax under the new arrangement. I hold that if we are to admit that the money has to be got, if we are to go on at all, we shall have to face the situation that whatever Government is in office ought to pay its way and see that the State pays its way. If we are to pay our way at all, we have to get the money and there must be hardships in connection with the raising of that money. It does fall severely on numbers of people, but I hold that nobody can fairly claim that this is a Budget designed for the rich. That is untrue, an obvious falsehood. We on this side of the House, from the time we came into public life, in all our actions have given proof of the fact that we were anxious for the welfare of the weaker sections of the community. We have constantly shown by our actions that we had that concern and what we have done in this case shows our concern for them because we have come to the help of the weaker sections. However, as I say, the money has to be found and we shall have to get alternative methods of finding, not small sums but substantial sums, if we are to deal with the situation.

A total of 170,000 out of the 188,000 income-tax payers in this country will not have to pay one farthing more as a result of this Budget: in most cases they will pay much less and they are getting reliefs under the new provisions. Is that something designed for the rich? Is it not quite evident that the 18,000 at the top will have to pay and bring in the extra money to the Exchequer that will come out of income-tax?

Before I leave that, perhaps I might deal with the idea that has been mentioned of the taxation of luxuries. Successive Ministers for Finance in Governments here and throughout the world have gone most carefully into this matter. One might almost say they have examined with a microscope ways of raising revenue either with the least unpopularity or with the least hardship to the community. The things that have been suggested here to-day have come to the minds of successive Ministers for Finance and they have generally been rejected for two or three obvious reasons. The amounts they bring in are not sufficient. The cost of collection is relatively too high and generally such taxes are not worth while. In order that a tax will bring in an appreciable amount of revenue it must bear on goods which are almost universally consumed and used. Taxes on luxuries have been mentioned. It has been suggested that we should tax fur coats and that type of article in order to limit imports. The total amount of revenue which accrues from such a tax would scarcely be worth the cost of collection. The revenue collected would not go any distance towards meeting the bill when one is talking in millions of pounds.

In order to reap sufficient revenue in present conditions we are compelled to tax the articles and commodities that are universally consumed and used. But in imposing such taxation we have to ensure that it bears as lightly as possible on those shoulders that are least able to bear the burden and, in order to do that, we have given some measure of relief. We have to do our best. It is not always easy to do one's best, since one can never be certain when proceeding on general rules that one does not perhaps bear a little too heavily on one individual or one small section and too lightly on another. All one can do, therefore, is one's best.

Successive Ministers for Finance have been driven back to these commonplace methods of taxation when they wanted substantial sums of money. Whilst we recognise that this is a severe Budget, it is at the same time a Budget designed simply and solely to enable us to meet our commitments and to pay our way as an independent State. Nobody who has objected to the removal of the subsidies is prepared to enlighten us as to how we can otherwise reduce expenditure. On what other forms of expenditure can we reduce? Are we to cut down on any one of these items I mentioned at the beginning in order to meet this bill of £15,000,000?

Comment on this

What about the dance tax?

Comment on this

£110,000 in a bill of £15,000,000.

Comment on this

Increase the tax.

Comment on this

When dealing with a revenue-producing commodity such as tobacco I assume that the Minister cannot get down to the smaller fractions. If he finds that he has got the revenue which he wanted and if simultaneously he finds that there is a tax to which certain objections were made, the question is should be impose that tax merely for the sake of imposing it? We have heard a good deal from the Opposition in relation to taxing amusements. If these are suggested as substitutes, may I point out first of all that the taxes on these were considerably lower in the past. If that is a good method of taxation and a lucrative method, why then did not the Coalition Minister for Finance turn his hand to raising revenue from these sources? If they are better methods of raising revenue, why did he not turn his hand to them? I have no doubt that if he had succeeded he would have been regarded as an excellent Minister for Finance. We tried the imposition of such a tax in a very simple and straightforward case and we found ourselves in the position that we could not carry out our policy. If there was such great virtue in taxing amusements why did not the previous Government when in office impose such taxes?

I can assure the House that we do not wish to tax too heavily and I think that my personal views in relation to these would be shared by most members of the Government and probably by the majority of the members of this House. It is not however a question of wishes. It is a question of the best means by which one can reap an effectively substantial revenue to enable us to pay our way.

I mentioned a figure of £110,000 in connection with the dance tax. I was wrong in that. When there is a remission for only a period of the year I think it is £110,000. I do not know whether or not more is collected in one period of the year as against another period and therefore I do not know whether the figures would be absolutely correct. I understand this remission will operate from 1st August next. In a full year it would be £140,000.

From the beginning the Revenue Commissioners have urged successive Ministers for Finance to get rid of this tax on dancing. It was represented to us that it was costly to collect. There were continual attempts at deceit and evasion in connection with this tax Many of us know that it is through the medium of dances that small local communities finance a number of projects of local interest, both cultural and utilitarian. Dances are about the only way they have of raising money to finance various local objects. I think at one time there was a rebate in connection with dances run for charitable purposes where the expenses were less than 30 per cent. of the proceeds; recently I think that was raised to 50 per cent.

Successive Ministers for Finance had been urged by the Revenue Commissioners to get rid of that tax because it was an unprofitable tax. Indeed, it was more in the nature of a demonstration rather than anything else. Because the revenue involved was so small and because of the attitude we had taken towards it in the past we felt we could justifiably drop this tax.

If the suggestion is that there are substitute taxes that we could impose we should be told what these substitute taxes are and the revenue they will be likely to yield. If any Deputy makes suggestions I shall have these carefully examined. I shall have the revenue bearing possibilities of any suggested tax examined and I am sure I shall be able to give quite reasonable answers to those who put up these suggestions. Deputy Dr. Browne referred to alternative methods of taxation. No doubt all these methods which have been suggested would not amount to more than £2,000,000 in any financial year. One must take into consideration then the cost of collection; in the long run the actual revenue might be very meagre indeed.

It has been suggested that we are budgeting for a surplus. We are doing nothing of the kind. My fear is that when the financial year closes and we come to balance our accounts, instead of having a surplus, we will in all probability find that there is a deficit. We will do everything in our power to ensure that that will not happen but one cannot plan ahead to meet every contingency that may arise and one cannot be absolutely certain that one will not have to bring in one or, perhaps, two Supplementary Estimates. As far as this Government is concerned, I can assure the House now that Supplementary Estimates will be very few because we are not in a position to meet further commitments.

We are not budgeting for a surplus. We are not working on any theory as to whether there is inflation or deflation, or which is the most to be apprehended. Indeed, I doubt if anybody could say with any degree of certainty whether we will have to face inflation or deflation. I can see tendencies in both directions and I have heard arguments which would lead one to conclude that we were approaching inflation one day and other arguments which would lead one to conclude that we were approaching deflation another day. If one put all the arguments down side by side in two columns it would be a very wise man indeed who could draw any definite conclusion.

We are told that we have been dictated to by the British Chancellor of the Exchequer. It is interesting to observe the ease with which British Chancellors can be quoted by the Opposition when it suits them and when they want to set headlines of a certain type. They do not then hesitate to indicate what is being done on the other side of the water.

I think our whole history as a Party is proof that we have been able at all times to take, and are taking, an independent line of action. As I had to say on one occasion, we are not, because the British happen to go upwards or heavenwards, going to go in the opposite direction just for spite and for the sake of doing something different. If they are sheltering from a shower, we are not foolish enough to sit out in the shower just because they happen to be sheltering from it. We do here the things which we consider right in our own interest. Naturally, we see what other countries are doing. Most of the difficulties which we have here are difficulties which are paralleled in other countries. It is sometimes very interesting to see an experiment in these countries, something which you think might possibly work here and to see how it turned out, to see how such an experiment, with the necessary modifications to meet our circumstances, would work here. We shall not be above examining the means which other nations take to shelter themselves from this universal shower and asking ourselves whether these are right or not in our case. I am not going to complain that there is any inconsistency in anyone saying: "Well, the Chancellor of the British Exchequer thinks so and so." I will admit that they have a much better chance of judging world trends than we have. Therefore, when there is a question of world trends, if I thought they were expressing exactly what they felt and that there was no special reason why they should say anything different, I would be inclined to look sharply if they indicated a danger threatening which would affect us.

It is suggested by Deputy MacBride that the real Government here is a conclave of bankers in Foster Place. Does Deputy MacBride believe that?

Comment on this

I believe that every single step advocated by the Central Bank in its report has been slavishly implemented.

Comment on this

I will use again the example of the shower. If there is a shower, and the Central Bank sees certain places of refuge from it and indicates these places and if common sense indicates the same places, does it follow that you are following the dictates of the Central Bank because you happen to shelter in the spots which they happen to have indicated? Surely it does not. That is not common sense.

Comment on this

Following that analogy, the Central Bank say that there is inflation which is the equivalent of the shower. The Taoiseach says that he does not think there is inflation.

Comment on this

I am only pointing out that there are times when common sense, when A, B and C, the average man in the street, will, from a set of facts, come to the same conclusion. If they come independently to that conclusion, surely you are not going to say that they are just following the leader. There are circumstances which suggest that everybody should follow a common course. If one is living beyond his means, whether it is the State or a private individual, in Heaven's name is there anything strange or wonderful in that person suggesting to himself that he should go and try to live within his means by cutting down his expenditure and increasing his income? Surely, there is nothing extraordinary about that. As I have said our Budget, as far as I am concerned, was not related to any ideas of inflation or deflation. I would have been very cautious if there were suggestions that it was simply to deal with inflation as such.

There are inflationary tendencies. If I am told that such and such is an inflationary tendency, I have got to close my eyes if I do not want to see it presented in a certain form. But I cannot help seeing it. I know, for instance, that if you have widespread capital expenditure in this country, wholesale capital expenditure—suppose you had that and that it was not immediately productive and not likely to be—surely you are putting out purchasing power in advance of the goods that were to be purchased, and you are creating an inflationary situation. That is clear to anyone, provided, I admit, that there is an understanding on the whole question of what is inflation. There are, I know, many shades of difference between people in their acceptance of that. But take it in its broad sense. It is generally accepted as meaning this, having more purchasing power than there are goods to meet the claims. That would have the effect of sending up prices and so, generally speaking, would have an inflationary effect.

Now there are inflationary effects. I see some deflationary ones too, a certain number of them. Therefore, my attitude as one member of the Government has been this. I am not going to go on any theories either inflationary or deflationary. Whilst I understand these things in their general sense and what they mean and what they mean to any observant person, I am confining myself and will confine myself to a very simple piece of work, namely, to make ends meet and to see that our income will meet our expenditure, to see that we have capital resources to enable us to do the development which I think ought to be done in this country and which. I think, is capable of being done. I will admit to anyone who may differ with me on this—the difference should not come from this side of the House or from the Labour people; it should or ought to come from the dyed-in-the-wool Fine Gael—I do not know what they are now—that I could not deny their contention that expenditure, even the large capital expenditure that we were contemplating ourselves in the past, would in the present world circumstances lead to inflation.

Therefore, the Government will be in the difficulty of choosing carefully its road so that, on the one hand, the necessary development will take place and that, as far as it is possible, employment, the end to which our greatest efforts should be directed, will be available for our people so that they will not have to emigrate. These are the fundamental things which we have got to aim at. I will admit that we have there the danger that, if we try to remedy the evil, we will introduce this other danger of inflation by over-capital development and over-capital spending.

Comment on this

Can there be inflation if there is always a sufficient amount of goods available?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not know perfectly well that there are not sufficient goods available for all the things that we want in this country? Does the Deputy not know that perfectly well? What is the meaning of all these imports?

Comment on this

That is another matter.

Comment on this

It is not. If we were producing all the things that we wanted we would not have to import. Our policy is to try as far as possible to produce here the things that we have to import.

To come back to the conclave of bankers. Now, who are the bankers and who appointed them? My recollection is that the present chairman had been originally appointed Chairman of the Currency Commission. When we came into office and when the Central Bank Act was passed, our Government appointed him as governor of the bank. He had no loyalties anywhere except to this country. I did not agree with many of his views. I am perfectly certain—perhaps I ought not to say this—that, if his political views were canvassed at any time that I know of, he probably would not have supported our Government. From our point of view, he would have disagreed with our policy, but he has a right to have his own opinions, provided he behaved as a man with responsibility would behave. I am sure that judges with political opinions are able to give impartial judgments.

We have civil servants who daily advise Ministers in various ways. The Ministers can accept their views or reject them. If the Minister rejects the views put up by the heads of his Departments, his civil servants or his advisers in certain matters, they are supposed to carry out the policy of the Minister as well as human nature will let them do it. We do not expect people to be absolute angels and above human feelings but their duty is to carry out the Minister's intentions and directions as he gives them. If they do anything else they are not acting as proper public servants. Their duties stop when they have used all their powers of persuasion with the Minister to adopt what they think right.

When a Minister differs from them he ought to be rather careful. There is a constant danger for every one of us who are in office through public favour and through elections to do the popular thing, often at the expense of what is the wise thing and the right thing. The civil servant is not a candidate for public support. He is able to make an independent judgement. Although I have differed, perhaps, as much as any man is likely to differ from the opinion of advisers and public servants in the past, I have never done so without asking myself this question: "Am I sure that my judgment is not somehow affected by the fact that I have to stand in judgment before the people for what I do?"

I know that the theory of democratic Government consists to a large extent of going before the people who will consider you on your record. They will pass judgment upon you. That is your judgment and from that point of view you have to have regard to what the people think, feel and want. But there are times when the desire to win popularity can lead one to courses which are bad for the country and the community as a whole. I think, therefore, that the civil servant, as an adviser, is at least removed from that.

I would say that the chairman of the Central Bank may have views with which I do not agree, but they are honest views and he has stated them and given the reasons for them. If you want to disagree with his views, do not suggest there is a sinister influence at work. Do not suggest he is subject to some rulings of another country. I regard him, at any rate, as a competent honest Irishman. I say that in the past I did not agree with a number of the things in the Banking Commission Report which was set up in our time. I did not agree with it then and I do not agree with it to-day. As far as he was concerned, however, I believe that anything he thought and anything he said were done in good faith. I regarded his views as the opinion of an expert in his own line, one who is charged with the safeguarding of the currency here.

We are trying to see that the £ will keep its value, that our currency will be accepted here and that it will be stable as far as its international convertibility is concerned. These are the considerations that he has to deal with. I, therefore, believe that it is a most unfair attack on him, as an individual, to suggest—I will speak of his colleagues afterwards—that there is any ulterior motive in anything he said. What he said he regarded to be in the interests of the country and he is giving the best advice he can.

Comment on this

Is it not open to one to consider that that advice is against the national interest and treacherous to the national policy?

Comment on this

Do not say treacherous. What do you mean by "treacherous"? One is treacherous when one deliberately does a treacherous action. You cannot be treacherous by accident or unconsciously. If a person is treacherous he is treacherous consciously. I think it is a horrible word.

Comment on this

Not from the Deputy who used it.

Comment on this

I am used to it but I am in a position in which I can very well enter a defence for myself. It is a different thing for a man in a position which precludes him from a personal defence. He is not a banker, or at any rate he was not until he was made a banker in a very special sense. He has no axe to grind.

Let us take his colleagues. Who are they? I remember when we appointed William O'Brien as a member. William O'Brien was one of those men with whom I was very glad to be associated in the old days when the fight for independence was on. We lay beside each other in Richmond Barracks the night before some of the trials took place. He has been in the Labour movement and interested in the interests of labour all his life. I find it very hard to use language to express my contempt for any man who would suggest that he is a member of a conclave of bankers who are really the rulers of this country and ruling it for any interests other than those of the Irish nation. He was a Labour representative. He was put on as such, not as an official Labour representative chosen by Labour, but as a man who would see that public credit was directed for the good of the community as a whole and directed, in particular, towards safeguarding the interests of the working classes. Mr. Malachy Sweetman is a farmer who comes from a family which had some very creditable work to its credit in Irish life. Are we to say that he is a member of a conclave of bankers ruling this Government and the country for sinister purposes? He was put on to represent the farming interest.

Then we will take some of the economists. Professor Smiddy was put on because he had wide experience of economics in general, as he was a professor. He represented this country both in the United States and in Great Britain. He was chairman of a tariff commission which we had here. Probably there is no man who has a wider knowledge of Irish industry and Irish financial affairs than he has. He certainly has had an opportunity of adding tremendously to the theoretical and other work which he did as a professor of economics. Is he another one of this conclave of bankers? I did not agree with him politically. He was chosen by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party of the day to be our Minister in Washington and then our High Commissioner in London. He certainly could not be regarded as somebody who was conspiring with this Government to rule this country in the interests of another country. Then there is Mr. James Meenan, a young economist. He was put on by the previous Government.

I think that nearly every one of those I have mentioned was reappointed by the previous Government of which Deputy MacBride was a member. Is Deputy MacBride going to say that he consented to the reappointment of these people who were treacherously inclined? That is a bit hard to believe. In any case I do not know Mr. Meenan at all. I did meet him a few times. I do not think that politically he has the same views that I have. In any event, he was appointed by the previous Government and I think it was a good appointment. He was appointed because he was an economist and would naturally be specially interested in the economy of this country.

Then we have the Secretary of the Department of Finance. He has served under successive Governments from the Cumann na nGaedheal Government onwards. I never tried to find out what his political opinions were. I know that his appointment was made before our time. I have often had different views from his, but I do not believe that he has at any time had any motive except the welfare of our people. If I ever had, in my own mind, any fault to find with him—and I think I mentioned this before—it is that he is so anxious for the welfare of the country and its good repute and sound standing that he would feel responsibility for things which were really not his but the Government's, and that he would accordingly go to the greatest possible lengths to press his views on the Government.

That is a good fault, if it is a fault. But I have never found, and Ministers for Finance in our Government have never found, that when a decision was taken he did not loyally accept that decision and see that it was carried out.

I have mentioned six of the members of the Central Bank Board. Let me now come to the banking representatives. They are a minority of three. They represent the three commercial banks. I have told you on what basis the others were appointed. They were appointed because of their expert knowledge as economists or because they represented some important interest in the country, namely, labour and farming. The bankers' representatives, as far as I know, were reappointed by the previous Government. If they were the sinister body that Deputy MacBride suggests, why did he not see that they were got rid of?

Comment on this

If the Taoiseach will look at the files he will see that I did object.

Comment on this

If I were a member of a Government who were going to appoint somebody who was going to be a traitor to this country, I would not stand for it; I would break up any Government that would do it. That excuse will not satisfy anybody. The fact is that the charge is unfounded, that the charge is false, that the charge is one that should never have been made.

Comment on this

I did not say they were traitors to the country——

(Interruption).

Comment on this
Deputies

Order, order!

Comment on this

I insist on my right——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Taoiseach does not give way——

Comment on this

On a point of order.(Interruption). I did not use the word “traitor” in regard to the governor and directors of the Central Bank. I said the treacherous policy of this Government—the pursuit of a treacherous policy.

Comment on this

I hate to hear the word come to the Deputy's mouth. I do not want to attribute anything to him he did not say. I only wish it was not said.

Comment on this
A Deputy

He did not say it.

Comment on this

I am glad to be wrong. It was our intention that, as well as the experts, we should have labour and farming represented. Then there was Mr. Punch representing one of the banks. We were very glad to see him as one of the banking representatives because he was interested in the development of Irish industry. We felt that we had there a body on whom we could depend to carry out their fundamental duties properly. The other two banking representatives were reappointed by the previous Government. The truth is that no matter what Government were here they would probably reappoint those people because they were able to do their job, because they felt that they were people who would do their job properly.

Then in regard to giving their opinions in reports—that reminds me of what was said about tourism. You cannot go in two opposite directions and hope that people will make progress. I will admit that sometimes a brake is useful. As a rule, however, it is better to make up your mind in what direction you will go and try to travel in that direction. We want to develop tourism and we propose to do it. We do not want to stop it by putting any tax on tourists. When I was in the Department of External Affairs I remember that a lot of complaints were made about visas and things of that sort which stopped tourists from coming here. I do not think that a tax on tourists would be desirable. It is most important that we should develop the tourist industry.

With regard to the Central Bank, we believe that the people there are doing their duty. At one time when industry was developing I had the idea that the time would come when industry would be reasonably well developed and we would be no longer dealing with infant industries but established industries which had to get a certain amount of protection to save them from unfair competition from outside, that we should put up some independent body to examine the advantages and the special privileges given to them in the way of preference, etc., and see that that was properly used and that it was to the advantage of the community. When I was thinking along those lines, one of the things that naturally occurred to me was that that body should be an independent one, capable of furnishing an independent report which would not be influenced by political considerations of any kind. It would be very well for the public if they did have an independent body which would go into these things and examine them, a body having no political axe to grind, so that the public would have an impartial report on these matters. If the report was wrong the Government could not be affected by that, and could take whatever line it liked.

It would be a very useful and valuable asset for the community and for a democratic Government, bearing in mind the dangers it has to meet in the running of its affairs, that such a body should be in existence. We probably have not arrived at the stage in which it would be desirable to set up such a body. In the case of monetary control we have such a body, and it is only right that they should, in the performance of their duty—it is provided for in the Act—be able to call public attention to trends and give the necessary warning, as experts who spend their whole time studying the subject. They ought to be in a better position than the average member of a Government to know exactly what the trends are and to warn the Government and the people of the difficulties. That is precisely what the Central Bank has done in its report.

Comment on this

Beyond that, they have no power to do anything.

Comment on this

They have powers and they can exercise them in a certain way. I was in at the framing of the Central Bank Bill, and I know the circumstances in operation then. I know my own views in regard to it and I am aware that every power necessary in order that they should do their duty properly was given to them. I feel it a good thing for any democratic country that there should be some check on these matters. It is the natural desire of all political Parties to try to keep out of difficulties by manipulating the currency. This is a very, very serious danger, and it is most desirable that we should have an independent body to deal with trends in financial matters. Do you not think, placed in the position that we find ourselves to-day, that if we had control of the banking situation, we would not have been strongly tempted to avoid an unpopular Budget like this and have resorted to more easy methods of financing?

Comment on this

If you had control of the banking situation, we would trust you.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy would.

Comment on this

I would trust you just as much as those gentlemen who have control of the banking situation at present—the people who are responsible to nobody.

Comment on this

They are ultimately responsible to this House. The powers which they have have been given to them by us. They have all the powers they need to do their work, in my opinion. If this House thinks it desirable to give them further powers it can do so. I do say it is a good thing that there should not be easy methods of financing for a democratic Government.

Comment on this

I did not suggest that.

Comment on this

I have listened to the Deputy on this question of finance over a good many years. I do not mean to be insulting in any way but I believe that the Deputy is simply picking up catch phrases and that he has never really studied the matters carefully. That is my opinion and I am sorry to have to give it.

Comment on this

You are entitled to that opinion.

Comment on this

I am, and the Deputy can have his opinion about me. Deputy MacBride patronised me the other day in regard to my knowledge of economic matters.

Comment on this

The people in your front benches would act no less honestly if they were controlling the banks than do the people in control of the banking system in this country at the present time.

Comment on this