We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).

Contributions 165–329 of 329. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Does the Deputy wish me to be frank?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

If I were in the opposite benches and I saw a Government composed as the last Government was composed I would not give them power to have control of the finances of the country. That is the truth. I believe that from my heart.

Comment on this

That is interesting.

Comment on this

It is interesting. I have some experience in such matters and know something about what happened. Financial machinery of that kind has brought countries to ruin.

Comment on this

Look what they did with the Marshall Aid moneys.

Comment on this

What about the people who are controlling our banking system to-day?

Comment on this

In referring to the commercial banks, the Labour Party talks about nationalising them. I do not believe in that. I do not believe they would make any better success of them than was made of Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this

What a comparison!

Comment on this

It is a good comparison.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Hickey should allow the Taoiseach to make his speech.

Comment on this

We must face the fact that there are strong temptations before a democratic Government to take the easy way out of their difficulties. We have difficulties in procuring money, and if we saw easier ways open to us, we would probably be tempted to avail of them. If such temptations faced us and faced others in the same set of circumstances, I do not believe it would be easy for other people to resist them. We would be able to resist them because we would be able to go out of this House in the morning and face the country. While we are here we are going to do our duty and we are in a strong position. There is no other Party in this House in a position strong enough to do it. Thank God, if we do nothing else, we will try to put the finances of the State on the sound basis in which we left them. The Central Bank has been attacked, and we have been accused of being led by it. The fact that the Central Bank suggests certain things, and that we are examining them from our own angle and our own view and that we decide that some of their suggestions are right, is no reason why it should be suggested, if we happen to take certain courses as a result of our own judgment, that we are necessarily being influenced by the Central Bank. We have read their views. We are aware of the dangers that they have suggested as lying ahead but, apart from general theories, we are at present engaged in something which is the common everyday experience of the ordinary man: "Live within your income. Make ends meet. Cut down your expenditure, or else increase your production."

It is suggested that we are following the Central Bank and that this Budget has been designed from the point of view of the disquieting position of our balance of payments. We have another fundamentally difficult question. It is the question of our balance of payments. It was said that the Minister for Finance's estimate was £69,000,000 or £70,000,000 some time ago; now, when the final returns are available, the amount turns out to be £61.6 million. The people who make those charges of incorrect figures know perfectly well how estimates are prepared. Why are we bearing the expense of a statistical Department and why are we keeping in the Department of Finance and in other Departments people whose sole task is to look after matters of that kind? If we are not going to believe them, would it not be better to cut out the expenditure and get rid of them? We are keeping them for a purpose, to give us informed estimates of what lies ahead and to keep accurate accounting of what has taken place in the past. One helps the other. The accountancy in the items of the past help you to get some sort of fair view of what is going to happen in the future.

I have an officer in my Department and when I ask him for certain details as regards statistical matters, he brings them to me. I question him and cross-question him and ask him to get some further information I want from other Departments, including the statistical Department. If, after all that, we present figures here, surely the members of the House who know how these things are done ought to accept the estimates as given in good faith. There is no attempt to cook these accounts, to cook this Budget or to cook any figures that we give.

Whilst I can make all possible allowance for mistakes, if a civil servant gave me a figure that was wrong, if I was misled or likely to be misled, I certainly would give him a talking to. There was in connection with this Budget a mistake, I think, in connection with the omission of a line in the typescript. In a case like that I would have said here quite openly that we could not afford to have mistakes like that occur. No political Party can afford that and it is not good from the country's point of view that it should occur. I should say that if any officer made such a mistake, he and those who would have checked over the item should be severely censured. I know things like that happen. It happened to a Minister in recent years. He was making a speech trying to prove that the balance of trade was altogether in our favour and he read his exports as imports.

Comment on this

That was Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

That sort of thing may happen. Excuses may be made for mistakes but these things do a great deal of harm. Civil servants ought to be aware of the danger of giving wrong information, and I am sure they are.

Estimates vary. What can a man do or a group of people do when making estimates? Before they get all the information they will give you a result on the information they have. If information comes in it will be given later. In the Statistical Abstract you will see notes—and again I would like to mention to the House and bring to their attention that the Statistical Abstract is the most valuable volume we have.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

They have to put down revised results. It simply means that information available at the time the statistics were compiled is included and the figures they give are the best they could arrive at. Later figures come in and they have to make allowances; but the percentage change is not very great.

I have a mental picture of trying to get the people in the opposite benches to see the situation that is facing us. In order to avoid facing up to their obvious duty, when we have a position which cannot be allowed to continue, they will turn right, left and centre and put their heads in the sand rather than look at it. In the attempt to do that, the Leader of the Opposition tells us that the Minister for Finance estimated several months ago that the external deficit would be £68,000,000 or £69,000,000; now it comes down to £61.6 million. It is a fairly big margin, I admit, but when you take into account the variety of items and the nature of the actual calculations that had to be made——

Comment on this

And the time of the year it was made—August.

Comment on this

Yes, August last year, it was not bad. I will admit, however, that you can for political purposes play with the situation. It is too much to expect that people would not do so. But it is not the essential part of the matter. If it were only £50,000,000 I wonder would Deputy Costello, when he was claiming that we were wrong, have spoken with the same confidence. It is certainly nearer to the £69,000,000 or £70,000,000 than it was to the £50,000,000.

The real thing we want to pay attention to is what it means whether it is £60,000,000, £50,000,000 or the present figure. The balance of payments deficit was £10,000,000 two or three years ago. The next year it rose to £30,000,000. There was a £20,000,000 increase, and of that £20,000,000 increase little more than half of it could be attributed to capital goods or to stocks, so that the balance was clearly money spent on consumer goods. That was an indication largely of an overflow out into the foreign market with money looking for goods. From £10,000,000 to £30,000,000 is a threefold increase. From £30,000,000 to £60,000,000 is double it again. We have six times as big a deficit in the past year as we had three years ago. As a result of these deficits we have cut down our sterling reserves by approximately £100,000,000. There is £100,000,000 less reserves to be used for the future for any purpose we may want them for. We have also lost the annual proceeds of that £100,000,000, which could be used and were used to purchase goods, goods for which we had not to export other things in return, goods which left us our reserves intact and gave us that annual income.

Surely reduction of these reserves for consumer goods is not a thing to be contemplated lightly. That is a thing which must make us sit up and take notice. I gave to the House already the position in regard to our external assets. I showed that they had been reduced from £225,000,000, which was the calculation of the net reserves which was made around 1949. They have been reduced in the last three years down to £125,000,000, which is now the amount of our net external reserves. Two years more of a deficit of that sort and we will have wiped them out. These reserves could have been kept and used for the future and could have remained as a cushion to keep us in the position in which, at any rate, we did not, like the British, have to cut down the food allowances to our people. They have been diminished now to £125,000,000 and in two years more, at a rate of deficit like the present deficit, they would all be gone and we would be changed from the position of a creditor nation to that of a debtor nation.

Does it make any difference whether we are a creditor nation or a debtor nation? We see the difference quite clearly in the case of Britain herself. Some of us who knew Britain in the early days of our lives and in our middle years know that it was hardly to be believed—by the ordinary person, anyhow—that she would be reduced in such a short time to the position in which she would not be able to purchase the food needed for her people. We do not want to be reduced to that situation, because those who are reduced to that situation are almost reduced to the position of beggars. The independence I should like to see preserved for our country is that we will not be in the position of beggars. When we are looking for equipment to defend ourselves or for wheat or for anything else which we may need I want this country to be in the position that we will be able to point to our assets and say that they are sufficient to cover our requirements.

I realise that the convertibility of our assets, and so forth, is another question. I am making full allowance for that matter and also for the views of those people who believe that we ought to use our assets to the greatest extent possible for the development of home production. Some of these schemes have high-sounding names— schemes that could be described simply, and schemes which were given simple names and which were carried out when this Government was previously in office. We have heard about the land rehabilitation scheme. That is a high-sounding title. The Fianna Fáil Government were not out for publicity or for propaganda and we called it the farm improvements scheme.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

There have been certain developments of it and certain extensions. The question is whether or not they are wise extensions. We intended to develop the farm improvements scheme to the point at which we would deal with the land which would give quick results. What we want at present is capital investment which will give quick results. We were out to get quick results first. That did not mean that as we got greater strength and more production we could not go on to these other things afterwards. However, first things first. Always, as a Party and as a Government, we have been in favour of capital development. But we have to get the capital. We shall have to get a substantial amount of capital this year. Last year the Government had to find £38,000,000 for development. How was that money spent? It was spent on projects which, for the most part, we had initiated—turf schemes, electricity development, and so forth. Now this Government has to get this money. How are we to get it? If we are prudent we shall try to get it from the savings of the people. We shall be slow to diminish our reserves unless we can definitely employ these reserves for productive purposes—either raw materials which are necessary, or plant, or for definite productive purposes—but not for consumer goods. If we are prudent we shall employ these reserves only on purposes which will yield something commensurate with the amount of goods that we are able to import with the dividends which we get from these investments at the moment. If the Fine Gael Party has genuinely been converted, and if, they believe in that policy, there is no need whatever to try and pretend that they have any opposition to it.

I have often heard talk about imagination: I think I have mentioned this already. I have heard it said that the people want a Government with imagination. Imagination is an excellent thing if it is governed by reason and prudence, but imagination can lead to rank growth. As I pointed out on a previous occasion, we find quite a number of people with imagination in the bankruptcy courts. We find quite a number of people with excellent imagination in the mental homes and we find quite a number of people with imagination even in our jails. Therefore it will be seen that imagination alone is not sufficient to enable us to do our work properly. We want imagination. We want to have the will to serve our country. We want to have the desire to develop it. We want to make homes here for as many of our people as we possibly can—happy homes and homes in which they will be able to lead comfortable and full lives. Whilst I believe that it is right that we should have a proper conceit of ourselves, let us not be extravagant in what we are talking about—not like the frog blowing itself into the bull. By making exaggerated statements we only make ourselves look ridiculous and ultimately we humiliate ourselves and humiliate the nation as a whole. With a proper conception of ourselves and our means and resources we can do great things. However, we shall only do the great things if, like anybody who wants to succeed in any enterprise, we carefully appreciate in advance the forces and methods and means at our command. If we are foolish enough to attempt something beyond our means then we shall quickly come to an end. That is what I foresaw in respect of the career of the inter-Party Government if they had remained many more years in office. I saw them being brought to an abrupt end over a cliff. Unfortunately, however, not merely would they go over the cliff themselves but they would bring quite a large portion of the nation with them. We were very glad to have an opportunity of trying to set things right before that should happen. I believe that there are Deputies on the benches opposite who, whatever they may think about us, are very glad that we are taking the appropriate steps to set things right.

Our capital investment will have to be proportionate to our means. We shall have great difficulty this year because the "small" savings amount only to somewhere in the neighbourhood of £7,000,000, while we are looking for about £36,000,000. There is a big gap between £7,000,000 and £36,000,000.

Comment on this

Out of pockets that are being emptied.

Comment on this

What did the Deputy and his colleagues do with the rest of that money?

Comment on this

They tried to spend it as quickly as they could.

Comment on this

What did you do with the £24,000,000?

Comment on this

It is being used in the same way as it was used before. Whether or not that is wise, I am not too sure. There are a lot of people in this country who have a false notion that that sum was in dollars—dollars to be kept to buy goods in America. It was not in dollars. The dollars had already been used to purchase goods— and these were the sterling equivalent.

Comment on this

$146,000,000 was spent by the previous Government.

Comment on this

They were spent, by individuals in the main, on the purchase of goods—wheat and maize and things of that sort that, necessarily, were imported. I said that that money was spent. Will the Deputy tell us how the money to meet the commitments could be got? He said: "Go for a loan". We have pointed out that in our opinion that that was not the time to go for a loan, when a conversion was going on, and when a previous attempt to get money from the Irish public got a poor response. We shall go for a loan this year, and we hope that we shall get from Deputies opposite the same help that we gave them in the past. Even when I was not a member of the House, when there was an external loan I did everything in my power, even though I did not agree with the then Government, to make that loan a success. If the people opposite do anything which tends in any way to interfere with the success of this loan they are doing an unpatriotic act.

That money is needed and, from every point of view, it is desirable that the loan should get a good response. It is suggested that, because we have faced facts by telling the people the truth and by trying to put our finances on a proper basis, we are jeopardising the chances of getting a good response to the loan. I do not believe that. I have always believed that, whatever temporary reverses truth may have, in the long run it will prevail, and I believe that our people, when they see they have a Government that is trying to do its duty as it sees it, will rally to the support of that Government. None of us likes to pay money out of his pocket for any purpose; it is much pleasanter to receive than it is to pay, but I believe that when our people see that they have to pay for these things —these social benefits and the rest— they will realise that the Government, in coming to them and asking them to meet these taxes and to make contributions to a loan, are acting as a Government that is trying honestly to do its work for the nation.

We shall have difficulty in getting the £36,000,000. I do not know how much of it the Minister will look for this year, but I hope he will get whatever he seeks. Can we hope, however, to continue year after year with all the capital development that awaits us? We are far from reaching the stage of capital development when we can say that we have arrived at the end. We are very far from arriving at the end. If we are to get to the end or near the end within our time, we must realise that the only way in which we can do that is by greater effort, greater industry, greater thrift and by making up our minds that if we want to achieve these things, it is something worth making a sacrifice for. We would not have reached the position in which we are to-day if people were not prepared to make sacrifices in the past.

Our people must be prepared to make certain sacrifices also in the future. All the Government can do is to indicate the direction and the goal. It is the community itself which must reach that goal and if the community wants to reach the goal—which I am glad members on the opposite benches are indicating now, as we had to do alone in the past—the community must be prepared to make the necessary sacrifices. If the goal is to be the development of our national resources to the full so as to provide to the greatest possible extent for as large a proportion as possible of the people who are born in the country, we shall succeed in achieving that end only if we are prepared to make sacrifices. These sacrifices can be summed up in not having extravagant notions, in not attempting things that are clearly beyond our means, but in adapting our means to the end and the end to our means. If we do that and are prepared to work and be frugal, to be industrious and thrifty, then we can look forward to a healthy development. If, on the other hand, we follow the course indicated by the preceding Government, in my opinion that will not lead us to the end envisaged and desired by all our people.

I have spoken at length and I have gone into the field as I see it. I do commend this Budget to your approval. I ask people who are inclined to think of the hardship it imposes to agree with us that there was no way out in the circumstances if we wanted to do our duty and present an honest Budget. As I say, I commend it to Deputies and I hope the House will pass it.

Comment on this

I would have thought that the House would have heard from the Taoiseach some more reasoned analysis of the position and that the House and the country was entitled to hear from the Taoiseach something in regard to the figures which had been put forward by the Leader of the Opposition. The only comment that was made by the Taoiseach in his speech to that effect was merely that the people were to trust him and to trust Fianna Fáil and that, so long as they did trust him, they were bound to be right. The fact is that since this Government came into power last July every single statement of major importance that they have made has been wrong. It started off with the Minister for Finance who led the merry dance— not of course the type of tax-free dance he is giving us now—on the 18th July last year. He came into this House then and started the scare that was taken up by other members of the Government and other members of the Fianna Fáil Party from that day on. The scare was started then and continued through the whole of last fall for purely Party purposes, regardless of any effect that it might have, regardless of the fact that once you start a scare like that you may not be able to control what you have commenced. The fake scare which was started and the fake crisis then commenced, in fact did a great deal to bring about much of the hardship and much of the difficulties that have been arising since. Really one would have thought that when the Taoiseach was speaking on the position disclosed by the Budget we would have been entitled to get from him some analysis in some detail of the figures and the reasons that are behind it, and exactly what it was intended that it would do, but as I say all that we got was the trite statement that they had officials, that the officials put forward honest views and that they gave these views to the House. Let me quite clearly and categorically——

Comment on this

That is not what the Taoiseach said.

Comment on this

That is what the Taoiseach said.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said figures.

Comment on this

He said that and, so far as I am concerned, I regard the Minister for Finance and his colleagues as the persons responsible for these figures and any comment that may be made is not a comment on the honesty of any official or on the "wellmeaningness", if one may use that word, of any civil servant who produced the figures at the direction of the appropriate Minister.

The Taoiseach referred to it, in passing, and tried to pass it off but the fact is that, so far as documentary evidence was given since this Government took office, the main document paraded around the country and paraded around this House was the White Paper issued last October by the Minister for Finance, the whole purpose of which was to bolster up the Minister for Finance who, as the leader of the hunt, was raising the scare crisis and the fake crisis about which he waxed so vocal at that time.

The fact is that the estimate made at that time, nine months of the year having gone, was £8.4 million out; it was £8.4 million wrong in £70,000,000. I do not suggest that it was made deliberately wrong by the officials of the Statistics Branch who compiled it, if they did compile it, but I do suggest that to be wrong to the extent of £8,000,000 in an estimate of £70,00,000 renders it perfectly fair and perfectly legitimate for anybody to make the comment now that in this Budget, where 11½ months have still to run, the figure may be out in the same proportion as that estimate made after nine months of the calendar year had run their course.

Deputies and members of the Government, other than the Minister for Agriculture, whose views on arithmetic seemed to be so peculiar last night, can make their own estimate and find out what proportion £8.4 million is of £70,000,000. It is not a very difficult calculation. It is, however, a greater margin of error than 10 per cent. The margin of error which Deputy Costello, as Leader of the Opposition, suggested there was in the Minister's Budget is a smaller percentage margin of error than that in the figures the Minister put before the House when he introduced the White Paper last October.

The Minister was kind enough to circulate yesterday a new White Paper dealing with the balance of international payments proving that there was approximately an 11 per cent. margin of error in the figures he had previously published. If he was wrong in that respect he was equally wrong, again on his own showing, in yet another respect. In the early part of the fall of last year we remember how Deputies on the Government Benches said that the Budget that had been introduced by Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Finance would show a deficit of £14,000,000. That prognosticated estimate was subsequently reduced from £14,000,000 to £10,000,000. When that estimate was challenged the £14,000,000 suddenly became, even in the mouth of the Minister for Finance, only £6.7 million, showing a margin of error of 50 per cent. in the estimate that had previously been circulated to the House and to the country. Yet, we are now expected to accept blindfold the figures given to us in this Budget despite the fact that two major items have already been proved to be wrong.

Comment on this

And they have to stick in £3,000,000 worth of turf to get the £6,000,000.

Comment on this

I shall bring down that £6,000,000 in a moment. I have given the House evidence of the statistical estimated record of the Government. It is on that record of estimates, on which the Government has been invariably wrong in the last six months, that the Taoiseach has the hardihood now to come in here and say: "Boys, do not ask for details; we are surely right." The Taoiseach would have been better advised to accept the suggestion made by Deputy General Mulcahy that what the country wants is a White Paper showing the true, the accurate and the correct figures because each time a member of the Government speaks on these figures we have contradictions.

I do not think anybody will accept any figures that are put forward in these circumstances without very careful analysis. The House and the country is entitled to have all the information upon which such an analysis can be based. It is only by analysis of that kind that the true value of any estimate can be computed. At this time of the year no more than an estimate can be put forward in relation to receipts and expenditure in the current financial year. It is inevitable that a long period must elapse before anybody can state the absolute truth and before anybody can decide that receipts are as they were estimated to be or that expenditure is what it was computed to be. The only way in which one can justify any estimate is to put frankly before the people the basis upon which the calculations are brought out. In that way it is relatively easy for others to estimate from the information at their disposal and to decide as to whether their estimates or the Government's estimates are right.

The Minister divided his Budget speech under three different aspects. He gave a survey of the position as it exists. He gave a survey of last year and he gave survey of what he proposes to do in the current year. Dealing with the survey of last year, he took the estimates made up by Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Finance on 2nd May, 1951, and compared those with the actual position as it was on 31st March, 1951. With characteristic political dishonesty, he omitted many items that were relative to that comparison. When the Budget was introduced last May there were certain charges available for estimation. There were certain other charges that were not available for estimation, but in respect of which it was desirable to make some provision. The biggest of those was, of course, the increase in Civil Service remuneration.

If Deputy McGilligan had then provided any figure for the Civil Service remuneration that was at that time under arbitration it would clearly have been a pointer to the arbitrator, an indication to him as to the manner in which he was to base his award. Therefore the way that was adopted for the purpose of ensuring that there would be some fund there in excess of what appeared on the face of the tables to meet the arbitrator's award, without the necessity of giving a direct pointer to the arbitrator, was to exclude the excess carry-over that there undoubtedly was on the 1st April, 1951. The facts that have transpired since have shown clearly that Deputy McGilligan was right in that respect. But when the Minister came to make his computation on the 2nd April of this year he completely ignored all reference to that as well as in arriving at a Budget deficit of £6.7 million. That alleged Budget deficit was there after the Minister for Finance had gone round to every single Department, whipping it up and telling it that, no matter what happened, it was to put in before the 31st March every possible penny that would have to be paid.

It is clear, both from the figures in the Tables of Expenditure and in the figures published in Iris Oifigiúil since the 1st April, that every single penny of expenditure was rammed into last year for the political party purpose of making it appear that the 1951-52 Budget was not as it was intended it should be. If we look at the figures that have been given in Iris Oifigiúil every week since the close of the financial year we will find that expenditure this year is well below the expenditure of last year. Why? For the obvious reason that the Minister jammed into last year's accounts expenditure which should, in fact, have been left over to be paid during the current financial year, but expenditure which he wanted to include for a political party purpose. In last week's payments that difference, I think, came to something over £1,000,000. I have not had an opportunity yet of seeing this week's figures.

In addition to that, there was a Supplementary Estimate brought in for a fuel subsidy which, time after time in this House, Deputy Lemass had said should not be charged to any current Budget, but which should be included for the purpose of payment as a capital item—a capital item that we should consider was well worth while as one of the few things that we had to pay for getting through the last emergency. But, when we come to consider the figures that were put before us by the Minister in his Budget speech, we find that he included that fuel subsidy payment of £2.7 million as part of the current deficit that he alleges on last year. I have no means of ascertaining at this stage whether the total amount paid for the fuel subsidy was £2.7 million or whether it was in the total of £3.3 million that was included in the Supplementary Estimate introduced by the Minister about last Christmas. It may probably be, when the full details come to be published and see the light of day, that, in fact, the amount that is added in the balance and brought forward by Deputy MacEntee as Minister for Finance to upset Deputy McGilligan's Budget, is not £2.7 million but £600,000 of the £3.3 million.

We cannot tell that at the moment, but, even going on what the Minister has put forward, there is at once a reduction to £4,000,000 in the alleged deficit. In addition to that, we have the carry-over that was there for the purpose, amongst other things, of meeting and carrying the Civil Service award, which went back before the 1st April, 1951. The Civil Service award, as the Minister in his Budget speech suggested, went back prior to the commencement of the last financial year. In going back over that period, it provided, out of the 1951-52 Budget, a sum of approximately £350,000, which could more properly have been attributed to the year before. That has been included by Deputy MacEntee in his statement, that the Budget introduced by the inter-Party Government last year was not accurate.

Apart from those figures, I remember listening in the House before Christmas to a statement made about the subsidy required for Córas Iompair Éireann. That subsidy was inflated deliberately even then for the purpose of making it appear that there was a large Budget deficit. We were told in that speech that, not merely was there to be a provision for the deferred maintenance by charging it to the current year's Budget, but on that there was to be provision then made for future increases in the cost of stocks. According to the ordinary method of Government finance, these future increases would never be met until the year in which the payments accrued, but for a political Party purpose, and to try to prove what was not a fact, a sum of £800,000 was included in that Córas Iompair Éireann Estimate which was introduced as a supplementary before Christmas. I think the exact figure is £846,000. There was no reference by the Minister for Finance to that amount on the 2nd April.

When we come to consider the real genuineness, or otherwise, of the attack that was made by the present Minister for Finance from the moment he took over as Minister, it can be made perfectly clear, from the manner in which he deliberately and of his own volition added to the deficit, if such there was, that it was not genuine. If it was true that, when he came in on the 18th July, he knew there was going to be a deficit in the 1951-52 Budget, why did he add voluntarily of his Government's own accord another £400,000 at that time without making or attempting to make any provision whatever for it? If it was true that he regarded the financial position as so bad that there was bound to be a large deficit, why did he add the extra £400,000 to the subsidy included in the Department of Agriculture Vote without making or attempting to make any provision to recover that figure? It was done, of course, for Party purposes. It was done because the Fianna Fáil Party had to make some small gesture in one respect to the people whom they had deluded during the election campaign and during the campaign that led up to the election.

If one takes, as Deputy McGilligan did speaking immediately after the Budget, the various items that were added and analyse them, it will be found that instead of there being a true deficit on the 1951-52 Budget there will be, I believe, when we come to see the last analysis of the fuel subsidy figures, a very small surplus on that Budget. We cannot tell the exact fuel subsidy figure until such time as the Appropriation Accounts are put before the House. When we get those accounts, we will have an opportunity of analysing them in greater detail.

From my experience of business in the city—I am not speaking of my own personal experience but of my experience with those with whom I meet on every possible occasion—the feeling was that there was quite a deliberate policy adopted by the Government that there was to be no pressure before the 31st March for the collection of revenue. Everywhere I went I was informed by people that they found that in March of this year there was less pressure being put upon them for early payment of income-tax than there was in other years. I am quite satisfied that what must have happened, therefore, is that the Government must have indicated that so far as they were concerned they did not mind if revenue did not flow in as quickly as it might otherwise flow. All the indications in the city amongst business people were that from about the beginning of March there was less pressure than there normally would be, in any March towards the collection of tax. The effect of that would mean that income-tax would be well behind what it might be in other years. That would also bring about a position in which there would be a larger apparent deficit and a higher figure for the current year.

Comment on this

I think the Minister's statement was that there were more arrears of income-tax collected last year than in any other year.

Comment on this

The Minister's statement was that there were more arrears collected in April of last year than any year by reason of the bank strike.

Comment on this

The collection of income-tax was up.

Comment on this

And it would have been up a great deal more were it not for the Minister's policy.

Comment on this

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

I do not know what the position is in Donegal. I can only tell the Deputy what the position was in Dublin City. I want to try to avoid discussing the position in an area with which I am not familiar. Therefore, I shall keep to the area I know about. If the Deputy makes inquiry, he will find that the vast majority of income-tax is paid in Dublin City rather than in the outlying country areas. That fact is there. It is an unchallengable fact that in regard to the budgetary position of that year for Party purposes and solely for Party purposes, the Minister tried to make out that there was a deficit when, in fact, there was not.

In regard to what the Minister has termed "the economic survey", the Taoiseach, when coming near the end of his speech, suggested that it would be necessary to float a national loan in the near future. Every single member of the Fine Gael Party hopes that that loan, whenever it is floated, will be a success and that the country and the people as a whole will subscribe to it.

Our complaint with the Minister is that he did not do it long ago when he could have got the money far more cheaply than he can ever hope to get it now. We are confident that the security of this country is a good security in which people can safely invest their money. Not all the inefficiency and incompetence of the Fianna Fáil Government can prevent that. No matter how inefficient or how incompetent the Government are, it would still be good business for the people to put money in any national loan that is floated at any time, whether immediately or later on during the current year.

It is unfortunate that the Minister for Finance did not put that loan to the country on public issue at a time when it would have been done if there had not been a change of Government. We all know that before the inter-Party Government left office they sowed the seeds, made all the plans, published the advertisements and made known the terms of the Conversion Loan offer, an offer with a result which is going to mean that there will be a saving not merely in this year but for every year in the Vote of approximately £751,000 in interest and sinking fund.

That conversion was announced in the beginning of June before the change of Government and was a striking success. It was a success firstly from the point of view of what it is going to save the country as a whole; secondly, from the point of view of the number of those holders who converted into the new stock; and, thirdly, it was a success because of its accurate timing. It is because of its accurate timing that it redounds so much, as it does, to the credit of Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Finance. In regard to the four loans that were converted last June, the ultimate redemption will run as far as 1960 in the early cases and 1970 in the later cases.

It would have been quite possible for him to postpone the moment for conversion but with that true vision which he, as Minister for Finance, exhibited, he chose exactly the right moment and, as a result of his choice, this country is saving in the current year and will save in the years to come approximately £750,000. If the Government had shown the same vision in regard to their timing of the financial market, if the Government had shown the same vision as Deputy McGilligan showed in his conversion offer, if they had shown the same vision in regard to their flotation of a public loan, they would not now find themselves in the difficult position in which they undoubtedly are.

Last September a loan could probably have been floated to produce funds for productive development at a rate far lower than any loan can now be floated. It is due entirely to the fact that the Minister for Finance did not want, for Party purposes, to follow the line of Deputy McGilligan that he deferred the flotation of that loan and, in deferring it, lost this country the opportunity of taking advantage of the then interest rates which will cost this country, for the duration of whatever period the loan will be put forward, at least an additional 1 per cent. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is a great person for looking up statistics and making speeches with them. I think he cannot argue from his figures that since last September the rate of interest has not moved against us by 1 per cent.

Comment on this
Erskine Hamilton Childers Minister for Posts and Telegraphs (Mr. Childers) Fianna Fáil

The Minister is only thinking of the advice of any good stockbroker as against the Deputy's opinion.

Comment on this

The Minister had the opportunity and, unfortunately, he missed the tide. Having missed the tide, he is now trying to turn around and find some scapegoat instead of having the manliness to stand up and say that he and his colleagues were the people who let the country in for the additional interest that will undoubtedly have to be paid. It is that incompetence that has created a position now in which the Government will be forced to go to the country for a loan at a time which is not anything like as favourable as it then was.

It will have another effect also. One of the things that the Minister and his colleagues cried out to high heaven about on many occasions during the last four years was that the spending of Marshall Aid moneys in any form was bound to be inflationary in tendency and that there should have been an increase in the savings of the people. National loans are, of course, a way of mopping up savings that would otherwise be spent in the inflationary way about which the Minister and his colleagues were so fond of preaching. When they had the opportunity last August or September of issuing a loan for that purpose and preventing the injection of Marshall Aid funds in a purely inflationary way, on their own showing, they avoided doing it again, because, if they did so, they might be following the good headline set them by the inter-Party Government. That will cost the country heavily in the years ahead.

There is no use crying over spilt milk. The fact is that that opportunity has gone and that we must now look to the future and not to the past. So far as national loans for productive purposes are concerned, we on this side of the House will give the Government any help, any assistance, any publicity that we can towards ensuring that whatever moneys they seek for national development will be made available to them.

In his review of the current year's Budget, the Taoiseach posed the question more than once: Why would any Government introduce a Budget that was unpopular? But he did not answer one question categorically which has been asked not merely in this House, but all over the country: What was the intention of the Government in bringing in such a Budget? The Minister for Finance dealt with an economic survey in the beginning of his Budget speech and then dealt with the current Budget, but he did not relate that current Budget to the economic survey that he had made. The Taoiseach, like the Minister for Finance, did not state that it was to provide that there would not be further imports. He did not say that it was to provide anything more than a book-keeping method. He gave us a dissertation in one moment as to whether there was inflation and in another moment as to whether there was deflation. It was not merely a question of other people in the House not being able to understand whether he thought there was an inflationary or deflationary position. He admitted himself that he candidly did not know. If the Taoiseach is not in a position to state if there is an inflationary position, it seems extraordinary that such a deflationary Budget should have been introduced by the Minister for Finance.

Speaking the morning after the Budget was introduced, the leader of the Opposition made it perfectly clear that, in his view, unnecessary taxation was being taken out of the pockets of the people by this Budget for the purpose of creating an artificial surplus which next year, if the Fianna Fáil Party remained on that side of the House, they could take off and go to the country, believing that the public memory is short, and hoping that the public will only remember the remissions next year and forget the impositions of this year. I believe that that is unquestionably the policy at which Ministers were aiming.

One of the comments made in reference to that surplus Estimate in the Budget was in regard to the subsidies. As far as I can understand the figures put before us, the figure of £15,250,000 for subsidy in the current year includes the offset of £1.2 million mentioned by the Taoiseach earlier to-day as money coming in from the sale of white flour, butter wrappers, etc. If the subsidy figures mentioned by the Minister in his Budget statement are correct, then it means that the figures mentioned immediately afterwards by the Minister for Industry and Commerce have the effect, not of showing that the calculations made by Deputy Costello in regard to the subsidy were incorrect, but that Deputy Costello was even too conservative in estimating the excess that was being provided for.

As reported in column 1292 of the Official Reports, the Minister for Industry and Commerce gave as his reason for the calculation made by Deputy Costello of an unnecessary £2,000,000 being taken in taxation the fact that we were paying in the early part of this year up to 1st July last year's price for wheat and that after 1st July, in the period in which the new subsidy arrangements would operate, we would be paying a higher price and that in addition to that after the 1st July we would be paying for flour at 80 per cent. extraction instead of 85 per cent. These were the reasons which he gave. The Taoiseach did not deal with any reasons except that we were told to trust the figures he put before the people. Dr. Ryan said himself that he could not deal with the wheat or flour position because he did not understand it. Last year, after the 31st March, the total subsidies cost £12,500,000. This coming year they are estimated in the Book of Estimates to cost £15,250,000 after deduction of the Appropriation-in-Aid which appears in the Agricultural Vote.

If the Minister for Industry and Commerce is correct in saying that the higher price of next year's wheat harvest was one of the reasons why the calculation in regard to subsidies was wrong, then it would mean that we should compute an amount that would be spent in subsidy up to 1st July next not on the estimated figure for the forthcoming year in the present Book of Estimates but on the figure that was included for last year because his basis was that it was going to be on last year's costings we would be living up to 1st July. That would mean that for the first three months of this year our subsidies would cost us about £3.1 million.

It would mean that during the last nine months of the year, therefore, according to Deputy Lemass, the cost of the subsidies, when the higher prices were in operation, would be approximately £12,000,000.

Then the Minister for Finance came in and told us that the effect, in regard to subsidies, was a saving amongst the community of 2/- per head per week. Taking a population of 3,000,000 people and dividing that 3,000,000 people into £15,000,000, I agree that it would work out at about £5 per head, and £5 per head is practically the same as 2/- per week.

The Minister then went on to calculate that during the last nine months of this year there would be an average loss per head over the community of 1/6. If his first figure was correct— and I think it was—then equally his second figure must be three-quarters of the first, and not all the speciousness of the Taoiseach's arguments can prevent 1/6 being three-quarters of 2/-. It would seem, therefore, quite clear that no matter what payments are being made in regard to arrears or in regard to rate of flow, there are only two alternatives open to the House and to the Deputies in it, that either the calculation made by Deputy MacEntee that the cut in subsidy in his Budget of 1/6 a week was wrong or the statement that was made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the reason for the figure given by Deputy Costello being incorrect was that a higher price was going to be met in regard to wheat and flour during the latter part of the year and the extraction change in the latter part of the year was wrong. Both figures cannot be correct. We cannot possibly tell whether the Minister for Industry and Commerce is the incorrect person or the Minister for Finance, but it is quite clear, no matter how you take it, if you accept the position that there is to be a payment at the rate of 1/6 per head for our 3,000,000 people cut off from the 1st July to the 1st April, that if during that period the rate of subsidy is to be higher and if during that period the rate of repayment by the Exchequer is to be higher for the wheat coming in for the flour that is being ground, as the Tánaiste said, if the rate of subsidy is to be higher because of the difference in extraction, then it is quite certain that the saving of £6.8 million cannot be correct at the same time as is the statement that all that is being taken is the figure of 1/6 per head per week.

There is far more accuracy and far more logic in the figures put before us by Deputy Costello, which show that there is in fact a covert and a secret surplus of approximately £2,000,000 in the subsidy saving which the Government hope they will have available for next year for the purpose of bring in a surplus and hoping that the public memory will be short.

Comment on this

That statement is untrue.

Comment on this

I do not know whether Deputy MacEntee or Deputy Lemass is stating an untruth. All I know is that it is impossible for both of them to be accurate on these items.

Comment on this

If the Deputy took a course in statistics he could understand both Ministers.

Comment on this

The next question I want to discuss is the question of reserve stocks. Deputy Costello suggested that there was included in the current Budget an estimated amount for reserve stocks that were not going to be used during the current year. If the Fianna Fáil Party were honest and sincere in the barrage they kept up during the three years they were on this side of the House that there was a danger of international conflagration, then they would be laying in reserve stocks—and Deputy Costello in making an allowance for that stockpiling, did something that was very proper—if they believed the position was as they then stated it to be.

Last year in the Budget Deputy McGilligan made a specific calculation in respect of that. This year no such calculation is made but we have again from the Tánaiste a remark following Deputy Costello that the Government had included whatever provision they deemed was necessary for reserve stocks. The Tánaiste says that there is provision somewhere in this Budget for reserve stocks. I cannot understand where the provision is. It cannot be in the Estimates for capital services because the Estimates for capital services bear on the fly-leaf a statement as to what amount represents capital services within the meaning of the Volume of Estimates published in 1951-52. It is not in the Budget statement; it is not in the Tables analytical of that statement that was published at the time. Therefore, the only presumption can be that it is in the current estimates furnished to the House and submitted already partially in the Vote on Account that was passed on the 31st March. If it is there and if the Tánaiste was truthful when he stated that the Government have included provision in regard to reserve stocks, it must be in the current estimate and it must be that the Minister for Finance is unnecessarily taxing the community during the current year for those reserve stocks instead of providing that those reserve stocks would be paid for during the year in which they were being used.

The Taoiseach, in the course of his speech, poured scorn on the suggestion made by Deputy Costello that there was any over-estimation in the estimates before the House. Despite the effort the Fianna Fail Cabinet made to pay everything possible before the 31st March the total paid by various Government Departments fell short of the total of estimated expenditure and supplementary estimated expenditure by £3,800,000. The Government Departments, although they had the authority of this House, were unable to spend £3.8 million. Surely it is not unreasonable to suggest that they might be given a figure of £2,000,000 less than the estimated figure for the coming year. £2,000,000 is somewhere in the region of 2 per cent. The Taoiseach maintains that there is a necessity for a Budget of this severity, and if that is so surely it would not be too much to expect that a direction would go from the Government to the various Government Departments to the effect that, in the existing circumstances, each Department was to save 2 per cent. of the amount which had been put forward in the Book of Estimates. A saving of 2 per cent. would, to all intents and purposes, give the amount mentioned by Deputy Costello. Last year, in spite of all the effort that was made to spend £3.8 million was left unspent. This money could have been spent because it had been authorised by this House. All we suggest, and all Deputy Costello suggests, is that a Government which believes there is a situation which necessitates this Budget should instruct Government Departments that they were to save a mere modest 2 per cent. for the taxpayers of this country.

The position, as I see it, is that the Government are deliberately trying to make the position worse than it is, in pursuance of the policy commenced by the Minister for Finance on the 1st July last. In my view, they are trying to create worse scares. It is not the fact, and it would not be the fact, that the position called for a serious Budget which has outraged the country. What has outraged the country is the cynical disregard by Fianna Fáil for their election promises—the cynical disregard by them of the statements and the speeches which they made in this House prior to the last general election and during the three years of the inter-Party Government's régime. They are now in the position of having been hoisted with their own petard. They campaigned around the country during the whole of last May and they got their canvassers in every town, village and rural area to say that, if Fianna Fáil were the Government, there would be a reduction in the cost of living. The leaders were careful not to say too much in that respect from the public platforms. However, they had a good election propaganda machine. They left it to that election propaganda machine to do the dirty work, and I must admit quite candidly that it did the work most successfully. They certainly persuaded the people if there was a change of Government that, by a wave of a magic wand, the cost of living would be reduced overnight. Even Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll was persuaded that it was the big men of Fianna Fáil who were likely to cut the subsidies.

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll was going to increase subsidies.

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll was going to do all sorts of things. He had an election manifesto which he submitted all around SouthWest Dublin. I have it in my possession.

Comment on this

Would you like a copy?

Comment on this

I got it from a friend of mine, and I have it somewhere. It has a photograph of the Deputy—a flattering one. However, I am afraid the next time the Deputy has to go to the country and submit this photograph, while the photograph will be as flattering as ever, the people will not take quite as flattering a view of the statements on the inside.

Comment on this

We shall see.

Comment on this

We shall see. The Deputy will not be here to see.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

If the Deputy wishes to see, he will.

Comment on this

I was about to come to that. The people on the other side of the House were mesmerised by the claptrap perorations of the Minister for Finance at the end of his Budget statement. They are now suggesting that this is a great Budget—a Budget that is going to be good for the country. They have got the means of determining whether the Minister for Finance was correct in his last peroration at the end of his speech. They believe sincerely, and Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll believes sincerely, that this is a great Budget, and he believes that the people will vindicate this Budget. He has the remedy in his own hands. As I have said already, it is not even the amount which they are being asked to pay which outrages people but the fact that they now realise that they were codded by the Fianna Fáil Party who rampaged around the country during last May and announced that they were going to reduce the cost of living for the ordinary people, for the people of Cork as well as for the people in other places. That was untrue, and the whole election manifesto of Fianna Fáil was untrue, as the leaders of the Party were aware. There were certain Fianna Fáil Deputies and candidates at that time who believed what their leaders were telling them at private Party conferences to the effect that if there was a change of Government they would undo what, according to one of my colleagues in my own constituency, was due to the Korean War. The Tánaiste, immediately after he took office, said that the state of affairs was due solely to the Korean War. It is because of the fact that they had campaigned in that way that there is the present feeling of revulsion amongst many of the people who voted last June for the Deputies opposite.

Time will tell whether we shall get an opportunity of testing what the Minister for Finance stated at the end of his Budget speech. So far as we are concerned, we are quite happy and quite anxious that opportunity should come at the earliest possible moment. We shall get an opportunity—in a way which we all regret—of testing the position in East Limerick. But there is a way in which it can be tested not merely in one constituency but in many constituencies. If the members of the Government, and the Taoiseach himself, are sincere and honest in saying that they believe the people will stand behind them in this Budget there is a way in which they can test that belief without very much delay.

A logical argument was made in regard to certain figures in this Budget to the effect that unnecessary taxation is being imposed for the purpose of enabling the Party opposite to remain in power for a further 12 months, when, at the end of that time, they will remove that taxation, show that they have a surplus, and hope that the public memory is short. That may be good Party politics, but I submit that it will do the nation a lot of harm. The effect of this Budget will be more than merely the paying of the additional taxes that are imposed under it. It will mean substantially more unemployment and substantially more emigration. No matter what the Taoiseach may say, every aspect of this Budget is deflationary and every one of its effects is bound to be deflationary.

If, as Government statements allege, there is difficulty in regard to certain manufactures—a textile difficulty; a consumer resistance, if you like to use the word—then this is not the moment to enforce a deflationary Budget. If there is increasing unemployment, this is the time to utilise foreign assets for the purpose of avoiding it. It is no use to talk about the amount of goods that are imported as between capital goods and consumer goods. Obviously, if you are building a house the men who are working on it have to live and will buy consumer goods while they are putting up the house. The consumer goods that come in for the purpose of building up capital assets can be considered just as sound capital as many of the heavy industries that have been built up in other countries over a long period of years. It is inevitable that that must be the way in which a buildup will take place. Merely to pick out certain items of machinery and to suggest that those items of machinery alone are the only goods that are to be taken into account as capital goods is to work to an entirely false premise in any analysis of our import or our export situation.

The Budget speech of the Minister contains one very minute statement in relation to an amendment which it is proposed to make in relation to the 1947 Finance Act. It is an amendment in regard to the rate of stamp duty in respect of Irish companies and their subsidiaries. The suggestion was originally made by me to the Minister on the 31st October last in this House that as the provision had inadvertently been omitted from the Finance Act, 1947, it was causing some hardship. It is at least proper that I should gratefully accept the small concession that that amendment has now been included by the Minister. It is not a provision that means anything to the general body of taxpayers. It is simply that an oversight in the 1947 Finance Act is now being rectified and, it will not in any way hurt the revenue.

I want to refer to the statement of the Minister in respect of the purchase and production of wheat during the three years of inter-Party Government and also to the purchase of maize during that time. On many occasions in this House, and more often outside this House, we have heard suggestions that if Fianna Fáil had been in power during the years 1948 to 1951 more wheat would have been grown in this country than was actually grown. I think that city Deputies, such as Deputy Briscoe, genuinely believe that statement when it is made by their leader.

Comment on this

Yes, I believe it.

Comment on this

Lest it be not in the Library, though I think it is, the Deputy will be able to obtain from Deputy Aiken, the present Minister for External Affairs, a copy of the Estimate that was made by Fianna Fáil and submitted by the present Taoiseach, when he was Minister for External Affairs in the previous Fianna Fáil Government, to O.E.E.C. in 1947 in reply to the questionnaire which that body issued on the 23rd July, 1947. If Deputy Briscoe looks at the replies to that questionnaire he will notice that they are divided into certain parts. The first part refers to production. The second part refers to requirements and the third part is, therefore, the import deficit— being the substraction of one from the other. If Deputy Briscoe will take the figures that are included in that Estimate which was submitted by his leader to O.E.E.C. in 1947, and if he make the appropriate computation as between hectares and acres, he will find that during the régime of the inter-Party Government a larger area of wheat was, in fact, under production than the Fianna Fáil Government estimated in 1947. If Deputy Briscoe examines the figures of yield and production he will find, in the same way, that approximately 432,000 cwt. of additional wheat were produced at home as compared with the Estimate submitted in 1947 by the Fianna Fáil Government to O.E.E.C. If he wants to get the exact reference for the figures he will find them in the first place, as I say——

Comment on this

Is it not only natural that he would give a figure as low as possible on that occasion?

Comment on this

He will find the figures in the reply there and, secondly, in the report of the debates of this House on the 1st April. If the idea was to include in those returns figures as low as possible, then it would work out not merely in that regard but in other regards. In fact, when you come to consider the maize position, about which the Minister for Finance also had a lot to say, you will find, taking the average cost of maize for the years in question, that there was £19,000,000 less spent on maize during the years of the inter-Party Government than the Fianna Fáil Government proposed to spend in the same period.

Comment on this

That is not correct.

Comment on this

It is correct.

Comment on this

It is an assumption on which the Deputy is working.

Comment on this

It is a fact that a substantially smaller tonnage was imported during the years in question than was intended to be imported by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy taking credit for the 1948 wheat acreage for which the preparations were made by Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

I will take any year the Deputy wants. If we take the year 1950-51, the Deputy will find that in that year, under the Fianna Fáil estimate, it was proposed to have 247,000 acres of wheat and, in fact, there were 366,000 acres of wheat. He will find that in that year the proposal was that 144,000 metric tons were to be produced and sold to the mills and that the actual figure was substantially more. If he wants to take the figure in that year for maize, he will find the proposal was to import 600,000 metric tons of maize and that, in fact, all that was imported in the same period was 5,752,529 cwt., or approximately 280,000 tons.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that he was making a good case for getting Marshall Aid?

Comment on this

If you are going to make a good case you would make it accurately on both sides of the argument.

Comment on this

You would err on the right side anyway.

Comment on this

The fact is that the Fianna Fáil Government went on record as putting these records before the O.E.E.C. authorities. So far as I understand now, the defence put forward by a member of the Government Party is that they put fake figures before O.E.E.C. I do not believe they did that. Bad and all as I think they are, I do not think they would be guilty of that. I believe that was a genuine and honest estimate made by them of the position as they anticipated it was going to be.

Comment on this

They were bound to err on the right side.

Comment on this

It is like the White Paper on the balance of external payments—the error is very large. If there was a trifling error one could understand it. One could understand an error in regard to yield, because they might wish to put it to the Marshall Aid authorities that our land had been run down to such a tremendous extent, that the yield was going to be frightfully low, but there was no case put forward as to why they were making an underestimate of the area that was proposed. The fact, of course, was that the tendency that was going to be shown was inevitably a proper tendency following the years of the emergency. What I do object to is, not that tendency but the fact that a fake attempt is being made to make capital out of what was a natural scheme and a natural flow, and that that was put forward at a time when they had an opportunity, if they so wished, of making different plans.

Deputy de Valera said at one meeting that he believed that the proper figure as regards tillage for the country was 3,000,000 acres. In fact as I say, his estimates to the Marshall Aid authorities was that in 1950-51 we would have an area of only 1,600,000 acres. That shows a very substantial difference. He mentioned the figure of 3,000,000 in his Gresham Hotel speech as the natural area, but he estimated for the Marshall Aid authorities a tillage area of 1,600,000 acres excluding roots, and root crops in this country have always occupied around 200,000 acres. The crops included in this estimate were oats, wheat, rye, barley, beet and potatoes. There was no estimate made for root crops such as mangolds and turnips which, as I say, would represent an additional acreage of 200,000 acres. That would give a total of some 1,800,000 acres so that you would have a deficiency of 1,200,000 acres on the area mentioned by the Taoiseach in the speech to which I refer.

I am not quarrelling with his suggestion that it is desirable to increase tillage production. What I am quarrelling with is the allegation repeated again and again by Fianna Fáil that the trend in the emergency was a trend that would not have been operative if they had been in the Government later. They clearly showed from their own memorandum that it was a trend that was to operate to meet the effects of the emergency when very properly the land had to be exhausted to provide for the needs of our own people.

We are here discussing a Budget that has caused more public controversy throughout the country than any Budget that was ever introduced. I can understand the Taoiseach and his Ministers saying that they do not want to test the feeling of the country in relation to something about which the country had not yet heard anything; but that argument does not hold good in regard to this Budget. All over the country, even amongst people who were staunch supporters of Fianna Fáil, one hears the same question: When will we get a chance to put them out? That is a question that the Government, if they were honest democrats, would answer by requesting the Taoiseach to go to the Park at the earliest opportunity to call on the President for a dissolution under the Constitution.

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman has just said that this Budget has aroused keen interest throughout the country. The debate has been significant for one thing, and that is, that the Opposition have contented themselves with defending the actions of the Coalition Government and in particular the Budget which was introduced by them just prior to the dissolution. Despite the fact that this is an unpopular Budget and a drastic Budget, the people are taking a very keen interest in the debate here for the purpose of ascertaining for themselves whether this Budget was necessary or whether the country could have continued to carry on as the Coalition had been carrying on. There is no alternative.

Most of the Front Bench occupants in the Opposition have spoken in this debate. All the people have to do now is to decide whether this unpopular Budget is necessary at this time or whether we could have continued in the same manner as that in which the Coalition was acting. The people have heard many contradictory statements and they are no doubt confused by all the figures which have been given here on both sides. They are endeavouring to get out of their dilemma in regard to the divergent views expressed on this particular Budget, and in doing that they have certain incontrovertible facts to guide them. They can judge upon those facts, without recourse to mathematics, as to whether or not this Budget is necessary. They can decide for themselves without recourse to all the mathematics and all the arithmetic that has been served out here in the course of the debate.

Comment on this

We had two hours and 35 minutes of them this evening.

Comment on this

The taxpayer must of necessity probe into the facts and then decide which of the two alternatives presented to him is the better one. He can decide whether a Budget of this magnitude is necessary or whether we could have continued along the lines upon which the Coalition Government was working. He will not need to have recourse to statistics in order to find out what the facts are. He is aware that Marshall Aid, which this country enjoyed during the three years of Coalition Government, is no longer available. Not merely have we come to the end of our tether in that respect, but we must now start repaying that money got by way of loan.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

These are the facts.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

We gave a solemn undertaking to repay the Marshall loan.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

The nation said it and the nation will honour it.

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this

The people are painfully aware of the fact that there is a gap in our balance of payments and that our imports are exceeding our exports to an ever-increasing extent. They know that over the past few years there has been a serious diminution in savings. They know there has been a gigantic increase in the national debt. They know there has been an increase in consumption without any corresponding increase in production. They know that if we continue to dissipate our external assets at the rate at which they were being dissipated under the Coalition Government, those assets would last just two years more.

Comment on this

That is laughable.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Is that the sort of stuff they are teaching you nowadays?

Comment on this

These are the facts that present themselves to the ordinary man in the street. They are facts which cannot be refuted and they are there to guide him in making up his own mind as to whether or not the drastic and unpopular proposals in this Budget are necessary. Having familiarised himself with these facts he can then apply the test of the ordinary housekeeping of his own family. He knows perfectly well that if a family fails to pay its way it cannot carry on. Any sane man knows that in such a state of affairs there will ultimately be serious consequences which will make the remedy, if not entirely impossible, much more difficult and might lead to the stage where, as the Taoiseach pointed out to-day, we would have to reduce, as they have had to reduce in England, the quantity of food available to our people.

Comment on this

That is a good comparison.

Comment on this

Anybody who has the interest of the State at heart has no wish to see that set of circumstances develop. The one question the average man in the street will ask himself is: Why should any Minister for Finance introduce such an unpopular Budget as Deputy MacEntee has introduced on this occasion?

Was he merely trying to commit political suicide if it was not necessary, or why should he do this courageous thing if it were not necessary? Any man of ordinary common sense will realise that no Minister for Finance would attempt to introduce such Budget proposals in this or any other country if they were not absolutely necessary in the best interests of the State. The public generally are well aware that some of those Budgets which we have seen in the past were presented merely for the purpose of pleasing them and of postponing the evil day and that eventually the day of reckoning must come. The attitude of the Opposition in this respect of failing to face up to unpopular decisions is comparable to the quack doctor who attends a patient requiring a serious operation.

Comment on this

Up Fianna Fáil!

Comment on this

The quack doctor administers a sugar-coated pill for the purpose of holding himself in the good graces of his patient. He tells the patient that he is going to be all right and that drastic action will not be necessary. He brings the patient along from day to day and from week to week until it is too late, and the patient then has to face a serious operation or die. The quack doctor is concerned merely with the popularity which he will get. He will try to ensure that his patient will be pleased with the treatment that he is meeting out to him. He will try to hold the patient and get payment from him as his doctor, but when the medical specialist comes along he will tell the patient candidly and frankly that his health is in a serious state and that a major operation is necessary if his life is to be saved. He will tell him that he must face that operation if he is to overcome the decline in his health.

In that simile, you have a comparison with the past Administration and the present in so far as the Budget in this country is concerned. We are not prepared to keep administering sugar-coated pills to the body politic in this country, or to keep telling the people that they are all right, that they can carry on, that they are wealthy and that they never experienced better times, and that a wave of prosperity has hit the country. We feel bound to give them the facts as they exist, and make known to them that drastic action is necessary if they are to be saved from a serious situation. It is pretty evident to every man in this State that a Minister who faces up to that situation, unpopular and drastic as it may be, is merely doing his duty to the nation, and that he is not courting political popularity for the sake of getting people to believe that he is to them a saviour or for the purpose of holding on in power.

The Minister for Finance, every member of his Government and every member who sits behind him on these benches are quite prepared to face up to the realities of the situation as well as to any consequences in relation to the Budget which he has put before the people.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

But we will not allow ourselves to be stampeded into any situation. We are perfectly confident that, in due course, the wisdom and the good sense of this Budget will manifest itself to the people of the country, and that we will get back on our feet when the country will again reach a sound state in regard to its finances. The people, too, will realise what a sound and a wise Budget this has been.

I know that the Opposition would not be living up to their past record if they did not make every possible use of this opportunity for propaganda purposes. It is only natural that they should try to exploit the situation to the fullest, irrespective of whether it is foul or fair propaganda, so long as they can try to break the grip which Fianna Fáil holds with the plain people of this country.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The stranglehold.

Comment on this

We had a previous speaker, Deputy Sweetman, telling us that an effort was made to delay the collection of income-tax to prevent the revenue from being swollen so as to enlarge and magnify the deficit in the Budget. But he would not even go to the trouble of reading the Minister's Budget speech in which the Minister said at column 1129:

"Revenue, tax and untax, was then estimated at £81.1 million. It turned out to be £33.9 million, or £2.8 million more, mainly because of a rise in income-tax receipts largely due, in fact, to the collection of arrears carried over from previous years."

Not only did the Minister not issue instruction to those responsible for collecting income-tax to ease off in their demands, not merely did he not do that, but he actually collected arrears outstanding from the previous years. I quote that as an example of the small pieces of propaganda which the Opposition are ready to seize on to try to mislead the people by saying that the proposals in the Budget are unnecessary. I could also quote a Dublin Deputy—I see the Dublin Deputy in the House at the moment— who, in a conversation with people outside this House on Sunday week last, told them that the tax was removed off dance halls because a bribe was given to the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

To the Party. Is that denied?

Comment on this

Of course, it is.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! Deputy Brennan should be allowed to make his own statement.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Is that denied?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Higgins is constantly interrupting.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

If necessary, I will bring the witnesses, the people to whom he made the statement.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not usual to quote private conversations in the Dáil.

Comment on this

I agree with your ruling.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should resume his seat.

Comment on this

It is a rather serious statement, and I think I should be allowed to finish the statement made by the Deputy, even though in conversation, to a number of people outside.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Private conversations cannot be checked or verified and should not be repeated here.

Comment on this

He said the Deputy is present.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not going to call witnesses. This is not a court.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

It was done for the purpose of creating a wrong impression. The same Deputy mentioned that one of the Opposition Deputies, whom he also quoted——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that the Deputy should pass from that. It is quite undesirable that private conversations should be quoted here.

Comment on this

I will report the incident to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges because if I were allowed to develop the little story I was going to give to the House the facts would reveal that there was a more serious suggestion—that a more serious charge was made.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is quite undesirable and unusual to quote private conversations in this House.

Comment on this

Let him develop it outside this House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair will endeavour to conduct the business of the House.

Comment on this

It is only part of the campaign that was started and that has failed to stamped the people of this country into opposition to the Budget. The people have quite calmly studied the situation. They have already studied the facts as they exist and as I have put them before the House. They are quite satisfied that, in the best interests of this nation, the Budget, however unpopular or drastic it may be, was absolutely necessary. They know one further fact in addition to that which I have already quoted. They know that the things which have made a Budget of this type necessary can be laid at the door of the Coalition Government during their years in office. I do not hear any cries of "Up Limerick" now.

Comment on this

We do not hear any cries of "Up Dev" any place now.

Comment on this

His stock never was as high. Deputy Sweetman made various references to the cost of living and what Fianna Fáil had promised with regard to the cost of living. I have just as good a memory as any Deputy with regard to the election campaign and we certainly exposed what happened in a previous election by demonstrating the rise in the cost of living which had taken place in the meantime. We exposed a leading member of the Coalition—an indispensable member who had promised in the previous election that they could reduce the cost of living by 60 per cent. We hear a lot now being talked about the people being misled. If we exposed the increase in the cost of living it was for the purpose of exposing the fallacy in the promises made to the electorate on that occasion by one of the joint Leaders of the Opposition.

No member of this House, either on this or on the other side, is attempting to tell the people that this is a popular Budget, nor does any person in the community think for a moment that it was intended to be. The fact is that they know it is necessary, and because the facts before them prove it is necessary is the reason why all rightthinking people have looked upon it as a courageous step, that could only be taken by a strong Government that knew its own mind and whither it was going.

Some Deputies have criticised the various increases in taxation and the various reliefs. Personally, I think that any increase in tax at any time is unpopular for those who have to pay it, and I think that the increase in the price of butter, which is bound to come as a result of the subsidies being removed, will probably be felt the heaviest of all. I do think, too, that it will encourage the small farmer in this country to produce his own requirements in home-made butter instead of buying it from the national pool. It is a very costly item for him to have to buy. I believe that if it acts as an incentive towards achieving that result it will have done a very good thing, indeed, because I am afraid that it is not merely the town dweller who is buying butter from the national pool at the moment, but many of our small farmers throughout the country who could produce their own requirements in that respect, and thereby preserve the national pool to the extent where at least we would not have to import. It might even leave us in the position where we could export butter or, better still, chocolate crumb, which would help to close the gap in the balance of payments, which has so seriously widened over the past few years.

While the Budget may be unpopular and drastic, the people are prepared to face up to it, knowing it is necessary and in the belief that it will eventually, lead to a sounder economy, to a more prosperous nation and, above all, that it will enable the capital development programme to be proceeded with, which is bound to give more employment and create better times for all of us who live in this country.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The speech we have heard from Deputy Brennan is a very good example of the old story of the frightened boy who whistled very loudly passing the graveyard. I know that Deputy Brennan and, indeed, other Deputies, who find themselves committed to support the budgetary proposals now before the House, have a very unenviable task to accomplish. The task being unenviable does not excuse some of the speeches which have been made.

To suggest, as Deputy Brennan has suggested, that the people back and support this Budget and at the same time to deny the people the opportunity of expressing that support, if they support it, seems to me to be an extraordinary contradiction in terms. There is an easy way of finding out whether the people share the exultation which Deputy Brennan obviously suffers from, and that is to dissolve this House and go to the country and ask the people what they think, because it is perfectly apparent to the country now that the Front Bench opposite, the Government elected by this House, represents no one except the 70 Deputies or so who sit behind them.

They are a caretaker Government and the entire country at the moment is marking time for a general election. I think that it is opportune that we in this House should, as vehemently as we can, express that desire for an election to the people we represent.

I find it difficult to understand how this Budget was accepted by the Government and introduced into this House as representing the financial policy of the Government in view of the policy and the policies the country was told the Government would follow and pursue. The country will remember—and the House, I trust, will recollect—that after the last general election, between 30th May and 13th of last June, there was an interregnum period in this country, a period in which a wish had been expressed for a continuance of the inter-Party Government but, unfortunately, that wish was open to be defeated by the action of certain sections and certain Deputies in this House. In that interregnum period the Fianna Fáil Party decided to do something in an effort to secure the fruits of office again for themselves and their friends, and over the signature of the leader of the Fianna Fail Party, Deputy Eamon de Valera, they issued a statement of Fianna Fail's 17 points for a new Government. That statement was not directed to the people of the country because the 17 points had never been discussed during the previous election. It was directed to the four or five votes they thought they might get to enable them to form a Government. They chose very well in composing these 17 points. Each point in the programme was intended to appeal to one or other of the whims that compose the political philosophy of Deputy Dr. Browne, Deputy Dr. ffrench O'Carroll, Deputy Cowan, Deputy Cogan and Deputy Flynn.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What bearing has this on the Budget?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It has a considerable bearing. I suggest that I am trying to educate the House and the Chair by reminding——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it in order for a Deputy to reflect on the Chair? I understand that Deputy O'Higgins proposes to educate the Chair.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair was about to ask Deputy O'Higgins to withdraw that remark.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I certainly do and I am obliged to the Minister for reminding me of the slight irregularity in my speech. I trust now, with the assistance of the Minister, that I will be able to devote some time to him. I do not know whether the impression I got from the Minister's interjection, that he was anxious to avoid my continuing to discuss the 17 points, is well-founded. If the Minister's recollection is not very good, I may say that the 17 points were supposed to be what this Government in which he is now a Minister would do if elected. As I say, the 17 points were directed at these five independent Deputies. They were well directed. They were intended to appeal to some whim or fancy of some individual Deputy.

Of course, when they were framed it was fresh in the minds of the Fianna Fáil scribes who composed them that Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll was the man who stood firm for food subsidies and that he had been elected in SouthEast Dublin because he promised the people there that, if elected, not only would he maintain the existing food subsidies but substantially increase them. I have no doubt that that promise of Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll had to be considered when this policy was being drafted to enable this new Government to be formed. Therefore it was not surprising that one of the famous 17 points, point No. 15, dealt with Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll's pet subject of food subsidies. Point No. 15 was an undertaking that a Fianna Fáil Government, if formed, would make it its policy to maintain existing food subsidies and to control the prices of essential foodstuffs, and to operate an efficient system of price regulation for all necessary and scarce commodities. That promise contained in the 17 points was published in the Press of the 5th June last year. It was a clear and unequivocal assurance to the Irish people and to the five Deputies that any Fianna Fáil Government elected by this House would follow a policy which would ensure the maintenance of existing food subsidies and the efficient control of necessary and scarce commodities. That Government was formed.

We are discussing at the moment the first positive action taken by the Government then elected to put into operation the different proposals contained in the 17 point programme. While we are discussing that first positive action, we are also discussing the destruction of the solemn assurance contained in the Government's 17 point policy. Only nine months later, with callous disregard for their own word and for the signature of the leader, they are taking, and asking this House to take, positive action to abandon the existing food subsidies, and the only thing they can say in favour of their action is, "It is courageous anyway". It is courageous for a man to walk into a bank in Grafton Street and hold up the cashier, but it is not praiseworthy. Are we to be satisfied as representatives of the people that just because this action, to the mind of the dispirited Government back benchers, is a courageous one, therefore it is justified? I do not think that there is any parallel in democratic history for a political Party to disregard its solemn assurance to the people who elected it in a matter of major policy.

What about the people who elected this Government; not the people of Ireland, not the Irish voters, but the section who, intervening between the Opposition and the Government, put this Government in power? I assume the Government have no regard for their own pledged word, but what about the four or five Deputies who elected them? Are they going to disregard the policy they voted for and hope to see put into operation? Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll issued this clarion call to his constituency: "If elected by you I promise to focus attention constantly on the cost of living and to press for increased subsidies on food and essential commodities." Is Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll so indifferent to his pledged word that he is now going to remain silent when action by him can give to this country a change of policy and a new Parliament?

I sincerely trust that the few words I am uttering to-night will help Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll to behave like a man, and I sincerely hope that what I now intend to say will teach the Deputy the foolishness of his action when, three weeks ago, he walked into the Division Lobby to vote for this Budget.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell the House if he is now pretending to act like a man?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I do not know how to behave in any other way. I have never acted in any other way.

It is very tragic and nationally harmful that we should have in this House evidence of a betrayal of promise by a political Party. It would be all right and, perhaps, curable if this major departure from the policy the Government was formed to pursue ended in betrayal. Unfortunately, it does not. The present Minister for Finance has always played a very active part, as a member of this House, at the time of general elections. He likes to be the leader of the vanguard in the Fianna Fáil fight for votes. Unfortunately, at times, he says too much too often. During the last general election campaigned against those who sugDeputy MacEntee as he then was— campaigned against those who suggested that Fianna Fáil was going to tax beer and tobacco. He campaigned against the licensed trade, against Deputy Cowan and against the Deputies of the then Government for suggesting that Fianna Fáil might tax beer and tobacco. I recollect him speaking at Rathmines Town Hall on the 15th May, 1951. He is reported in the Irish Press as follows:—

"A number of persons in the licensed trade were spreading a rumour that Fianna Fáil, if returned to power, would reimpose the tax on drink which was imposed by the Supplementary Budget of 1947. There is no truth in such a rumour."

That is the statement of Deputy MacEntee as he then was. Now, as Minister for Finance he is asking this House not only to reimpose the taxes of the Fianna Fáil Supplementary Budget of 1947 but to increase them. He is asking the members of the House and the Irish people through us to accept his proposal as a sincere and honest effort at budgetary legislation for this country. The particular speech of the Minister's, part of which I have quoted, was not unadorned by pearls of his oratory. In the same speech he proceeded to deliver a homily to all candidates for election honours and to all politicians, budding or otherwise. He spoke as follows:—

"People in this election were being asked to decide whether politics in Ireland was to be a dirty game played by confidence tricksters who were prepared to promise anything to dupe people into voting for them. The pearl cast..."

Perhaps the Minister might care next time to finish the quotation. It is now time that we should bring these matters down to some reality. I have mentioned two matters contained in this Budget—foodstuffs and the taxation of beer and tobacco. A firm, unequivocal assurance was given on behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party, its supporters and fellow-travellers that neither would be interfered with if Fianna Fáil reassumed office.

Comment on this

When was that quotation given by me?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You were going to increase food subsidies.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll is involved in the food subsidies. The Minister for Finance is involved in the food subsidies and in the taxation of beer and tobacco.

Comment on this

What about the "Nuncio"?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

With relation to the items I have mentioned, very callous, calculated action has been taken in complete breach of the solemn assurances given. That is not only tragic and undemocratic, but it is something which every Deputy in this House should vote against and work against. It is something which the people of this country deeply resent. It is said in defence of the Minister's proposals that, no matter what we may say against them, they are at least courageous. Of course, it is very easy to say a thing is courageous when you can say nothing else for it. Do the people opposite realise that they are doing something that is sweeping the people from behind them? That is exactly what is taking place. If, as seems clear, the Fianna Fáil Party, during the last general election campaign, by implication—I will not say it was any more than implication—promised to follow a policy at least of maintaining existing subsidies and of not taxing beer and tobacco and now proceed to follow a policy diametrically opposite to their implied undertaking, we are entitled to demand by what right this change of policy has been put into operation. The Minister's only right to speak in this House comes under God from the people of this country. By no other right does he sit here, and he has only got the right to continue occupying the position of Minister in this House for so long as he acts in accordance with the wishes of the people. He would be anxious to claim, I know, that the people sent him here. If he and his colleagues in the Government climbed the steps of Government Buildings by reason of the support given to them as a result of the policy which they impliedly made known to the people, and if they now depart from that policy and from the undertakings given, their right to continue as a Government ceases.

It is often common enough in Parliament in democratic countries when a Government seeks to do a thing, no matter what the Opposition may be, to say: "We have a mandate from the people to do this." That, of course, is to be expected in relation to all major matters of policy. There is no Government in any country that is entitled to follow a line of major policy if it has not got some form of mandate from the people to put that policy into operation. The contrary would be a direct negation of democracy. If the contrary rule were accepted we might find Parties, if elected by Deputies here, and having assumed government, putting into operation some policy that might be completely anathema to the people of this country. I am afraid that that situation is now upon us.

No one would suggest that a sudden removal of food subsidies which amount in one financial year to a sum of £15,000,000 is not a major change of policy. It is a very serious change of policy, so serious that no Government has a right to embark upon it unless it can clearly demonstrate to this House that it has support from the people to do it. Now it is futile for Deputies to be arguing as to whether or not people will support these budgetary proposals. We all have our own views on it; the Minister has one view; Deputy Brennan has one view; I have one view. There is only one way of finding out, of getting an unanswerable verdict, and that is the clear course of going to the people who sent us here and asking them for their view. The course which I suggest is a course dictated by political honesty and by democratic principle, the dissolution of the Dáil.

I do not know whether that course will be followed by the Government or not. If it is not followed I can see in the coming months a very regrettable situation growing up here. If the Government does not submit these proposals to the people of Ireland they will be convicted of one thing clearly: political cowardice, of being afraid of their masters, afraid of the people and, being convicted of that, they can no longer parade around this country calling themselves the Government of Ireland because they will cease to be the Irish Government. In coming months we will have conducting our affairs a group of politicians who are afraid of the people of this country, who are carrying out a policy of which the people do not approve, and certainly they are not entitled to lead the people of this country.

I do not think that is a prospect that can appeal to any Deputy in this House. It cannot appeal to Government Deputies or to individual Government Ministers. It certainly does not appeal to a responsible Opposition such as we are. I should hope that it does not appeal to Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll, Deputy Dr. Noel Browne or any other Independent Deputy. All of us can and should take pride in our democratic institutions. Although we may quite often differ in Party and on politics, nevertheless in between elections we always take a conscious pride in the fact that an Irish Government democratically elected through the people by the Deputies of this House represents, for as long as it is there, the people of this country. It will be a sorry day for Ireland if we can no longer say that of our Government, and there is no doubt that we will be unable to say that if, in relation to this important major matter, the Government shirks its responsibility of consulting the people.

It might have been all right if somewhere in some Government Minister's speech in the last election or in some of their propaganda which they distributed throughout the country, if somewhere in some of the masses of advertisements, speeches, letters and different documents issued by them, there was at least a glimmering of an indication that they were going to do this if elected. If they could produce even one line in any one document indicating the glimmering of this policy, then, at least, they would be able to argue they told the people they would do this. We all know they cannot do that. We all know the contrary to be the position.

Apart from the matters I have mentioned, the solemn undertakings given on 5th July last year, we all can remember the advertisements issued by Fianna Fáil in the last election. Right beside the photograph of Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll on one's Evening Herald during the election one could see the big Fianna Fáil advertisement of the harassed housewife. There she was at the end of the week biting her nails with the pile of bills in front of her left hand and the little pile of silver, her husband's wages, in front of her right hand; she was thinking of the increase in the price of coal, the increase in the price of margarine, the increase in the price of butter, the increase in the price of meat, thinking that it had all been brought about by the bad, bold inter-Party Government; right underneath that photograph of the harassed housewife there was the Fianna Fáil slogan: “Housewives remember, Fianna Fáil started the system of food subsidies”; and then appealed to the housewife to come out to vote for Fianna Fáil.

There is no Deputy in this House who does not remember those advertisements here in this city. Fianna Fáil secured dozens of additional votes in the city that they had lost elsewhere in the country, because the people sincerely believed Fianna Fáil in some way was going to follow a policy which would mean to the housewife next time a smaller pile of bills to meet at the end of the week. There is no doubt that the Minister for Finance's constituents, Deputy Briscoe's constituents, all of them, when they voted for Fianna Fáil in the last election, believed sincerely, on the solemn assurance of the Fianna Fáil Party, that they were going to vote for a policy which would mean continuance of food subsidies, better control of prices and lower prices for all.

There is no shadow of doubt about that at all. Neither is there room for argument as to why the people voted for Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll. They voted for him because they believed that they were voting for a policy of maintaining and possibly even increasing the food subsidies.

Comment on this

There was the small matter of a mother and child scheme too.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You have not got it yet.

Comment on this

It is coming.

Comment on this

It is being nursed.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I will bet you £5 that you will not get one without a means test.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

In these circumstances it is not unreasonable, speaking on behalf of the majority of the people of this country, that we should demand an opportunity to change the Government if that is the only way this policy can be changed. It is not necessary to emphasise the matters which I have mentioned. They are so obvious to all of us that their repetition only becomes tedious. Apart from the complete reversal of policy and the dishonest betrayal of the voter which this Budget seems to perpetrate, it would appear that the reasoning and the thought and the imagination behind this Budget leave much to be desired.

This Budget is aimed at a period of inflation in this country. Often speakers refer to inflation when they desire to sound learned. I do not want to sound learned. I have never been able to ascertain from any group of people when, in fact, an inflationary period existed in this country. I remember that at the beginning of 1948, shortly after the inter-Party Government took office, the present Tánaiste, now Deputy Lemass, stated one week that we were in the middle of an inflationary period and the following week he stated that we were in the middle of a deflationary period. It is obvious, therefore, that a considerable difference of opinion existed amongst the leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party as to when this peculiar situation existed. We all know what an inflationary period may mean to the country. Whatever might be said on behalf of those who argued, some time ago, that inflation did exist, I can see very little that points to inflation in this country to-day. Since June last, by reason of an apparently deliberate ministerial policy, there has been a trade recession. Credit has been clamped down on by the banks. Less employment is available to our people. There is less activity in the country. More people are leaving the country. All these trends certainly seem to point against an inflationary position. Accordingly. I find it very difficult to understand why, in such a situation, the Minister for Finance should seek to absorb excess money when there is no excess. I find it difficult to understand why he should try to restrict the purchasing power of the worker when the worker has no margin whatsover left over from his earnings. I find it difficult to understand why the Minister should seek to foist a policy of that kind on the country.

I do not think the Minister has made any effort to justify the philosophy which imbues this Budget. I do not think he has made a cogent case that inflation exists and that deflationary methods are necessary. I do not care what sort of a case he may make in that regard. From what I see in the counties which I represent, and from conditions which I know to exist, this is not a period in which deflationary action is necessary or desirable by the Government. On the contrary, this is a time when the Government should take action to restore confidence to the country and to business. More money should be put into circulation by enabling greater purchasing power to be available by way of wages, and so forth, to the people of the country. This is the time when there should be an injection of purchasing power into the country. This is not the time for sticking in the syringe and drawing out purchasing power. It is in that connection that I question the policy contained in the Budget.

It is necessary that we should examine what will happen if the proposals contained in this Budget are implemented. It will have certain immediate effects and it will also have certain effects which may not be apparent for some time. The immediate effects will be felt by the less well-off sections of the community—the working people and the vast majority of the people of the country. These immediate effects will mean a marked restriction in purchasing power, apart altogether from the question of the necessary expenditure on the foodstuffs that a family must purchase in order to live. As a result of this Budget the working family will have to devote a larger percentage of their wages at the end of a week to the purchase of goods which are urgently required to keep body and soul together. That state of affairs has been deliberately designed by the framers of this Budget. It is in keeping with the views and the philosophy contained in the Central Bank Report, namely, the reduction of purchasing power available to the worker by increasing the price he has to pay for foodstuffs, thereby lowering whatever margin he might have left at the end of a week. Consider the position of a worker even in this city who earns £5 or £6 a week when these Budget proposals are put into effect. He will have to pay more for feeding his family. He will have to pay more for butter, tea, sugar and bread. Obviously, he will have less money left over for clothes, or other expenses which might be likely to occur, or even for savings. That restriction in purchasing power will have another effect which will be secondary.

In the coming months the shopkeeper around the corner from where this worker lives will find, slowly but surely, that his turnover is decreasing. The worker will not be able to go in and buy another pair of socks for his son or his daughter, or a Confirmation outfit for them when they are being confirmed. Less will be spent because the worker will not have the wherewithal to expend. That restriction in the trade of the shopkeeper will, in turn, have a corresponding effect on the general business community. The shopkeeper will require less stock in his shops by reason of the absence of demand, and the producer will eventually find no need to produce as much as he did before. Because of that he will not have the same necessity to employ as much labour. Accordingly, slowly but surely, the restriction in the purchasing power of the worker generally will mean that more unemployment will be created. That, in turn, will lead to a further restriction in purchasing power and a further trade recession. That seems the inevitable result of this Budget.

I do not believe that the Minister for Finance would introduce a budgetary proposal of that kind unless he had examined carefully the consequences that would flow from it. I believe that the provisions of this Budget were arrived at only after the most careful and grave consideration, and accordingly I must assume that the Minister and the Fianna Fáil Party intend to cause further unemployment in this country. I must assume that the Minister thinks that it is in some way desirable from the financial point of view that unemployment on an increased scale should exist in this country for the next 12 months. That is the inference which logic compels one to draw from the Budget itself.

I know, and Deputies will recollect, that only some four or five months ago when the Supplies and Services Act was being debated in this House, the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Costello, took certain steps to restore public confidence in the financial and economic structure of the country. When that Bill, now an Act, was before the House, considerable public anxiety had been caused by the Central Bank Report and the White Paper that had been issued by the Minister for Finance. In the Central Bank Report certain steps were suggested to the Government, steps which aimed at reducing the purchasing power of the community, cutting out the capital public works programme and subsidies, restricting bank credit and employment generally. Public anxiety was caused because proposals such as these should have been contained in a report issued from an institution such as the Central Bank. Because of that anxiety, because this Opposition felt a certain responsibility to the people of the country, the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Costello, tabled what was, in effect, a motion of no confidence in the present Government by reason of its apparent acceptance of the Central Bank Report.

All of us will recollect that when Deputy Costello had moved the motion to refuse a Second Reading to the Supplies and Services Bill, the Tánaiste spoke on behalf of the Government. The Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis was in session on the same day and while the Tánaiste was speaking in this House, the Taoiseach was speaking in the Mansion House, telling the boys in the Mansion House that the country was ruined and that the Central Bank Report proved it. At the same time the Tánaiste was saying here that the Central Bank Report and the philosophy behind it were anathema to him and to the Government and would not be followed in any particular. In that debate the Tánaiste on behalf of the Government informed this House and the country that they rejected completely the Central Bank Report with all its recommendations and philosophy and that on the other hand they believed the proper policy to be the energetic development of a capital works programme, as the one economic solution available to the country.

I recollect that in that debate the Tánaiste announced a capital programme for the expenditure of some £35,000,000. We are entitled to assume then that the Tánaiste in that statement was representing Government policy. We were entitled to assume that the policy disclosed in the Tánaiste's speech would thereafter be followed by the Government. We find, on the contrary, that in this Budget the Minister for Finance carefully and sedulously follows every recommendation contained in the report of the chairman of the Central Bank.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Deputy has misled the Dáil The Report of the Central Bank is the report of the board of the Central Bank.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I am afraid I did not catch what the Minister said.

Comment on this

I said that the Deputy had unwittingly misled the Dáil.

Comment on this

That is a ridiculous interpolation.

Comment on this

What did the Minister mutter?

Comment on this

What he muttered was not worth listening to. It was ridiculous.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The position, in any event, is that the policy contained in the Budget discloses an acceptance completely of the recommendations in the Central Bank Report. The Central Bank Report recommended the abolition of subsidies because, as stated in the report, the abolition of the subsidies would make the workers pay more for food and thereby reduce purchasing power.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy quoting from the Central Bank Report?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Actually I have not the report before me. I am giving what my recollection of it is.

Comment on this

Your recollection!

Comment on this

Quote the words.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I would advise Deputy Briscoe not to challenge me because I can find the quotation. Let me state again what my recollection is.

The Central Bank Report recommended the abolition of subsidies because the workers will then have to pay more for the present-subsidised rationed commodities and thereby there will be a reduction in the purchasing power available to the workers. That was a desirable situation, according to the Central Bank Report. It was a desirable situation that the worker should spend more on living and that the worker should be more concerned with the problem of life rather than having any money for leisure of relaxation. According to the framers of the Central Bank Report, that was a desirable situation.

Comment on this

That also appears in it?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Would Deputy Briscoe keep quiet?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy quoting the Central Bank Report or his interpretation of it? I will have an opportunity of replying to this.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The recommendation in respect of food subsidies in the Central Bank Report has been accepted by the Minister for Finance in this Budget because the Minister for Finance and his advisers and the Government think it desirable that the worker should be more concerned with the problem of providing food for himself and his family and more concerned with the problem of life itself. From the financial point of view, they believe it is not desirable that the worker at the end of the week should have any money to rattle in his pocket. Of course, that is a well-known financial theory. It is a view which will be shared by those who are concerned merely with the problem of storing up £ notes and it is a view that will be rejected completely, I am sure, by Deputy Captain Cowan. Deputy Captain Cowan is certainly one of the Deputies here who has always pleaded that the worker is entitled to a fair crack of the whip and that his pint should not be taxed. We all recollect that Deputy Captain Cowan was elected in the first instance because of his opposition to taxation on what he described himself, to use his own phrase, as the simple luxury of the working man.

Comment on this

I hope that was not the cause of my election.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It was, and it will be the cause of your defeat on the next occasion. I imagine that also would be a brand of philosophy which would not appeal to any responsible person who does not share the outmoded financial views which are merely relics of something that was acceptable in Victorian days. I know that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was pleased at one time to be coupled with the Minister for Finance as a Victorian ogre. I do not know whether or not that means that both of them are glad to accept all the views contained in that particular philosophy, but I think we should to-day have passed from the state wherein we regard the working man as entitled to nothing except the bare wherewithal to live. We should have passed far beyond that particular outlook. I would think that to-day the prosperity of any country should be measured not by the credit balance in the banks but on the standard of living available to the ordinary people. I would think that every Deputy here, and particularly Deputies like Deputy Captain Cowan, Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll and Deputy Dr. Browne, would share the view that our country's prosperity should be measured by the standard of living available to the ordinary working man.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

That is exactly what we do stand for.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Examine for a moment what Deputy Captain Cowan and Deputy Briscoe and Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll are being asked to vote for now by the Minister for Finance. Indeed, I do not know whether they will vote for it. Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll gave me some hope a short time ago that he might yet be a man. Here is what the Central Bank Report says:—

"Subsidies are not only a heavy burden on the Budget but also constitute a disguised addition to purchasing power, as the money saved through getting subsidised articles at a reduced price is set free for other expenditure. That can have a twofold adverse effect on the balance of payments by promoting an excessive demand for the subsidised articles, whether imported or domestic or exportable, and by facilitating an additional demand for unsubsidised articles."

Let us examine what that means—"facilitating an additional demand for unsubsidised articles."

Comment on this

That is not what the Deputy alleged was in the report.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It means that the worker will have something over after paying his food bill at the end of the week because he can get articles subsidised at a rationed price, and with that something over he can then make a money demand for articles that are not subsidised. Therefore the rationing of articles facilitates an additional demand for unsubsidised articles. Let me tie that up with what I was saying to Deputy Captain Cowan in relation to the workers' standard of living. The standard of living of the worker consists of many things. It consists not only of the food he can buy but also of what he can afford to do with his leisure and the different small pleasures he can afford to give himself in his leisure time.

Comment on this

I take the same view as the Labour Party.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

May I take it then that Deputy Captain Cowan will join Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll in voting against this Budget?

Comment on this

No. Fine Gael was condemned by the Labour Party on Sunday very effectively. (Interruptions.)

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It is always interesting to hear Deputy Captain Cowan referring to his different associations with different political Parties. He is the greatest political grasshopper in the place. He has hopped all over the House from one political Party to another. He is now in Fianna Fáil and he will end his political life in Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

It will be a long life.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I trust the Deputy did not say a long life because that might indicate that we are not going to have an election.

Comment on this

There will be no election this year. Have I not announced that already?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Would the Deputy tell the House if we may expect one next year? I move to report progress.

Comment on this