Finance Bill, 1952—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–195 of 371. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 12 of 1952 ›
Last night the naive suggestion came from the Opposition Benches that the blame for all emigration lay at the door of the Fianna Fáil Government. I was moved at the time to point out that emigration as a social ill has been with us for over 100 years and the blame for it can hardly be laid on any particular group of people at the moment. Emigration is one of these continuing evils which is used as a political shuttlecock when the moment is opportune. Successive Governments have claimed to make the attempt to cure emigration. Indeed, I think it was Deputy Norton who claimed that he would stem the tide. I understand a commission was set up in 1948 to inquire into this problem. This is 1952 and so far we have heard nothing.
Comment on this
Presumably they must have, or else they are locked up somewhere. A cure for emigration has not yet been found.
Comment on this
May I point out that Deputy Dr. Hillery does not speak as often as Deputy Breanndán Mac Fheórais and the latter might now extend the courtesy of listening?
Comment on this
Deputy Dr. Hillery should be allowed to speak without interruption, and so should every other Deputy.
Comment on this
In all the subjects that we discuss here we do not seem to give the problem of emigration the full consideration it deserves. We have only to look at the figures for the country as a whole to see the seriousness of the situation. In my county in the last 100 years the population has been reduced by 200,000 people. The figure becomes much more sinister in its import when we examine the age and sex relationship of the people who emigrate to the rest of the community. Those who are emigrating are the active able-bodied men and women and they leave behind them an increasing proportion of dependent people. In budgeting for services that we all think desirable we must appreciate that we are taking more and more money from a gradually diminishing earning section of the community for a gradually increasing dependent section.
A kindred social ill, also used as a political shuttlecock, is that of unemployment. Here, again, we have the blame tossed backwards and forwards. I believe that unemployment and emigration have a common cause, and the cure for both probably lies in the same direction. The only cure is the development of our own resources. In order to discover where exactly the blame may lie in relation to the cause of these twin evils, I would like now to examine the part played by the inter-Party Government in the development of our resources during that Government's period in office. Our primary resource is, of course, agriculture. The inter-Party Government rechristened the land improvement scheme and continued it during their régime. It is to their credit that they did continue it. While they were attempting to increase the productivity of the land through the medium of schemes already planned by Fianna Fáil the actual production figures from the land show a serious decline.
In my own county in 1942 we had 10,500 acres under wheat. In 1943-44 and all the years up to 1948 the wheat acreage never fell below 7,000; in 1949 the wheat acreage in Clare was 3,500. In other words, it halved itself in the first year of the inter-Party Government's régime. In 1951 the acreage was 2,500.
A similar decline in milk production is obvious to everyone living in the rural areas. This is due to the fact that the farmer was offered 1/- for his gallon of milk. He could not possibly feel compensated for the work he had to do at that price, and he gradually drifted away from milk production. The result was that we had to buy butter from abroad. I believe that we can much better afford to pay our own farmers a suitable sum for the milk they produce than we can afford to buy butter from abroad.
In looking to other resources in my on county, which is a maritime county. I am bound to look to the sea. Along the west coast and in the estuary of the Shannon, we find that only something over 249 people are engaged in fishing, and, in the last year for which I can get figures, the income from the fishing is set down at £5,000. Now, £5,000 from fishing in a maritime county is something to be deplored, and this situation exists after an expenditure of $128,000,000 loan, part of which could have been put into the development of the fishing industry.
Our main hope in improving our resources was the tapping of a new field, and that was in the development of the industrial aspect of our lives. This was undertaken by the Fianna Fáil Government and, between 1932 and 1947, 70,000 people were employed in new factories and industries. This is an important aspect of our lives which represents, I think, about 21 per cent. of our earning capacity, and during the three years of the Coalition Government it was entirely neglected in so far as the establishment of any major industry was concerned.
Comment on this
Our story of the development of our country will, probably, be more acceptable from an independent source, and so I will quote a Press report of what was said by Mr. Harry Clement, Deputy Chief of Mission in Dublin of the now defunct United States Marshall Aid Plan Agency:—
"You made a very spectacular progress since 1937, but, since 1947, you have not done so well. There are a lot of reasons for that, but the fact remains that, in the past few years, you have been falling behind the 23 other European countries that are in the Marshall Plan."
The fact that we fell behind every other country in the Marshall Plan, in spite of the amount of money that was available to us, is a serious reflection on the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
This is my speech and I will quote who I like. That is the history, as far as the development of our resources is concerned, that we have nothing, or very little, to show for the $128,000,000 of Marshall Aid that we received. About 90 per cent. of it was spent on consumer goods.
Last night I referred to other aspects of the financial management of the country by the Coalition Government. I referred to last year's Budget which was not balanced. It showed a deficit of £6.7 million. It also showed a failure to budget for the proposed social welfare scheme. The two combined, our actual running cost and the way it was managed, and our development, give us little faith in the Coalition Administration. They are now crying out for an election as a solution of the difficulties and of the mess which they have created. We have two offers from Deputy McGilligan. We have the offer of a ten-minute speech which could earn us £1,000,000 per minute. Presumably, that would be more borrowing.
Comment on this
Going on that assumption, I must refer to Deputy Costello's answer yesterday in the House when he was asked by the Minister for Finance: "What tax would you remove if you got into office now?" He said: "I would remove all of them." Removeing all of them, of course, means removing that part of the tax which will have to be raised to enable us not only to pay the debt but interest on what we borrowed. Now, if we are going to borrow more we are going to pay another lender, or if we are not going to borrow, then we shall have to do without a number of our services. At the same time, if we do not tax enough to enable us to pay the interest on what we have borrowed then, of course, we are not honouring our promises. I do not know if Deputy Costello intended that to be understood.
The removal of the food subsidies is closely related to the impositions in the Budget and has caused considerable hardship on a big section of our people. I do not propose to explain why it should be done, but I do propose to prevent the Opposition getting any political benefit from this or shouting about its being done. They knew it had to be done, and I think I can state the case better by quoting Deputy McGilligan on the subject. He saw that it had to be done, and, when he was probably deciding how to make up his mind between expert advice and political advice, he sought refuge in quoting certain Fianna Fáil spokesmen. Speaking in the Seanad on the 22nd June, 1950, on the Second Stage of the Finance Bill for that year, Deputy McGilligan, who was then Minister for Finance, is reported as follows at column 497:—
"In any event, there was one Senator—he named the Senator— who had the courage to say here that he would prefer to see the rations increased even though the price of the subsidised articles had to be increased. That is a line of argument that one can follow. The line of argument that I cannot follow is that made by people who say that rationing should be taken off and let the community bear the cost."
Then he quoted Deputy Childers, who was Parliamentary Secretary in the Fianna Fáil Government before 1948, as saying:—
"If heavy subsidies involve heavy taxation — a vicious principle, because it was merely a pretence in the long run...."
He then went on to quote the present Taoiseach as saying, when he was Taoiseach in 1947:—
"The Fianna Fáil Government does not in general favour subsidies; it is only as a very emergency policy that they are adopted at all."
Deputy McGilligan went on to say:—
"When the first bread subsidy was introduced, the then Minister for Supplies, Deputy Lemass, speaking on the 13th November, 1941, said,"
and he quoted the following from the speech of the then Minister for Supplies:—
"In announcing the decision of the Government, I made it clear that the sum of approximately £2,000,000 which was being provided this year for the purpose was the utmost that would be provided and, if any additional costs arose, these additional costs would have to be reflected in the ordinary way by an increased price of flour and bread."
Deputy McGilligan went on to say:—
"There was never any intention on the part of the last Government to spend huge sums of money on subsidising these articles. We are in this position that since we became the Government the rations on the whole have been increased. The tea ration has been increased. The butter ration has been increased. ...I certainly have heard no complaints seriously made with regard to the inadequacy of the ration."
Then he goes on to say:—
"Do not overlook what is being done with these subsidies. The inquiry which we recently had into bread and flour and the report of which I hope the public will soon have an opportunity of seeing, indicates that the community is being taxed not merely to subsidise the price at which bread is sold in the bakeries and in the bakers' shops but the community is actually paying a subsidy to provide the cost of transport of bread to houses in, say, Ailesbury Road and Merrion Road. The community is paying the costs of distribution and the costs of transport; these are being paid out of subsidy, to say nothing of the cost of these magnificent buildings, which almost rival Store Street, that one sees in different parts of the city. They, in the main, are being built out of subsidy. Once you have too many subsidies there is no way of seeing that they are applied to the purpose for which they were originally meant."
So, I think the Opposition Parties can hardly claim any credit for, or hope to gain any political benefit from, the removal of the subsidies. Acute consciousness of the political effect of removing the subsidies is evident in Deputy McGilligan's speech. He called on quotations from members of the ex-Fianna Fáil Government at the time to give him moral support.
Comment on this
Bad and all as this Budget is, and so far as I am concerned, it is the worst I have had to listen to in this House for a period of 30 years, it helps to serve more than one useful purpose. The contents of the Budget and the Finance Bill which proposes to implement it are so drastic that they apparently have dumbfounded the political henchmen or yes-men of the Fianna Fáil Party. I have been speaking to some of these renowned representatives of the Fianna Fáil Party inside and outside my constituency. Some of them appear to be deaf because they do not want to hear anything about the Budget or what is contained in the Finance Bill, and others are speechless because they cannot understand it or, if they do understand it, cannot explain it.
I have had the experience over a long period of years of addressing public meetings inside and outside my constituency, and when the Fianna Fáil spokesmen come along to listen— when they give you the honour of their attendance—one generally hears them say: "Up the Republic. Up Dev." They can continue to shout "Up Dev." if they have the courage to shout at all but, when they shout in the future, they will have to shout "Up the price of every commodity that every ordinary plain citizen has to eat or drink". From my experience since this Budget was introduced, I suspect that there will be very much less shouting in future at these political gatherings than there has been in the past.
The Minister is hardly fair to his political yes-men when he does not give them the dope to put across his point of view in the country. He will not go down to O'Connell Street or College Green himself and he will not give his henchmen the notes which he relies upon himself when he speaks in this House to explain this brutal Budget. The Minister is—and I do not say it for any personally unfriendly reasons—the most discredited man in Irish public life to-day. His Budget has brought that upon his head. He used to go down to College Green or outside the General Post Office or to Rathmines every time Fianna Fáil gave him a chance but he has not appeared in public, as far as I know, since he took the responsibility of introducing this measure.
Comment on this
He will get an opportunity of dancing free when the Finance Bill comes into full operation and it is very few people in the public life of this country who are able to give themselves that pleasure of their own free will, with the support of the people who sit behind and around him.
The Minister when speaking in this House and at social functions in the city, before he introduced the Budget or the Finance Bill, has more than once referred to this country as being on the border of bankruptcy. These were words deliberately used by the Minister, especially when he was speaking in the city since last July. Did anyone ever hear of an individual, a businessman, a manufacturing concern that under the law of this land could be declared to be bankrupt if the assets were greater than the debts or liabilities? If this country, which is at the top of the list of creditor nations, has something like £450,000,000 in the British Government controlled Bank of England, how can it be suggested by any sensible citizen, much less a Minister for Finance, that it is on the border of bankruptcy?
The people are asked to cut their consumption, to cut their savings, to reduce their standard of living by 10 per cent., so that the Minister and the bankers who are behind him in connection with this Budget will be able to put more of the Irish people's savings—hard-earned money—into the Bank of England, to enable the British Government to carry out a policy of rearmament. He is also asking them to put more of their savings into the Irish banks—they are called Irish banks but of course their spiritual headquarters are on the other side of the Channel, in Threadneedle Street —to allow those banks as their agents to invest more of the Irish people's savings in England, in the Bank of England, at 1 and 2 per cent. and to allow this Government and the same Minister for Finance to borrow money at home for the purpose of enabling farmers to use their land to better advantage, for the purpose of enabling the local authorities to build more houses, at 6 per cent. Put your savings into the British Bank of England at 1 and 2 per cent. and borrow the money at home to build houses and to develop our national resources, at 6 per cent.
Comment on this
Yes, some of it, on short-term loans, but I do not want to misrepresent the Minister. Most of it would be at a rate of interest ranging from 1 to 2 per cent. Is there any other country that would put up a Minister for Finance, in a Parliament where democracy is supposed to be the basis of existence, to put that across on the people? Am I misrepresenting the Minister or the Government when I make that assertion?
The Minister for Justice, when speaking in his constituency, Roscommon— he was speaking at a Comhairle Ceanntair meeting, not at a public meeting—appeared to be very disturbed because some of us from this side of the House have suggested and asserted—and I am repeating the assertion—that this is a British-manufactured Budget. Is not there evidence on the face of it? Look at the Daily Herald or any other of the British papers of 12th March and see the headlines of the British Budget introduced by Mr. Butler on the previous day. I do not say that they represent every one of the items contained in this Budget but the policy in this Budget is clearly the same as was enshrined in the British Budget introduced by the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Mr. Butler.
Are not we making provision in the Budget, in this Finance Bill, or by Government Order, to increase the rate of interest in the case of the Agricultural Credit Corporation from 4½ to 6 per cent.? Mr. Butler, if I understand him correctly—I read all the British papers and the Irish papers as far as I have time—has increased the rates of interest on loans to local authorities, loans to individuals, so that he can transfer the labour power from manufacturing industries manufacturing luxury articles, to munition factories, to carry out the policy of rearmament. Here, every one of us— Deputy Cogan as well as the rest of us—is backing the Government in encouraging our farmers and agricultural labourers to increase agricultural production, and at the very time when we are standing up here and outside— I have done it more often outside than in here—encouraging our farmers and labourers to increase agricultural production, the Minister for Finance, following the action of his political godfather, Mr. Butler, puts up the rate of interest on agricultural loans from 4½ to 6 per cent.
Who will stand outside a chapel gate next Sunday and say that that is sound agricultural policy for this country? Look at the Daily Herald with its big print—“Subsidies slashed 75 per cent.” Are we not copying exactly, so far as percentage is concerned, that slashing of subsidies here in this country? If we are doing so, it surely is not for the same reasons. Any man who would get up here or outside this House and suggest that conditions in this agricultural country, which is at the top of the list of creditor nations in the world, are similar in any respect to conditions in Great Britain is not fit to be a member of the House, or at least is not fair to himself or to the people he represents. Britain had to sell every brass farthing of her foreign investments in order to pay the cost of two world wars, commencing in 1914, and she only pays for the food she has to import to-day for her own citizens by exporting the most valuable portion and the highest possible percentage of the products of her manufacturing industries. Surely there is no comparison between Britain and the Irish Republic from that point of view. There is no justification—there may be in Great Britain, but that is not my business—for slashing the subsidies here.
Have we not even copied Mr. Butler in his Tory Budget by reducing the travel allowance from £50 to £25 as provided for in this Bill? We all know that the money allocated for travel allowances is used by Irish citizens for a different purpose than that for which it is used in Great Britain. British citizens use the allowance available to them to spend their holidays in Biarritz, Nice, Paris and other continental resorts, but the majority of people here apply for the allowance for the purpose of going to Lourdes, Fatima and Rome on pilgrimages. Now they are to be deprived of the allowance which they hitherto got on a airly reasonable basis, although the cost of maintenance in these places has increased considerably.
Comment on this
I hope I am travelling along the lines of the policy enshrined in the Budget and proposed to be implemented in this Bill. I have enough to deal with in keeping to it.
Comment on this
I hope the Deputy will confine himself to the motion: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time." Expenditure of money does not arise on this.
Comment on this
This Budget and Finance Bill have another very close resemblance to the British Budget. The Budget here was introduced for the first time two days after the end of the financial year. I never remember a Budget being introduced before the last week in April or the first week in May, but again we had to follow our political godfather, Mr. Butler, the Tory Chancellor of the Exchequer.
I want to ask the Minister or any Fianna Fáil back bencher what will be the effect of the increased rates of interest on loans provided in the future for farmers and particularly for local authorities for the building of houses and carrying out other schemes. Does anybody in his senses believe that the farmers who are now looking for loans from the Agricultural Credit Corporation or who may be obliged to look for them in future will look for these loans at a time, when the rate of interest has gone up from 4½ to 6 per cent.? May I ask also, as having a definite bearing on that, to what extent is the increase in the rates of interest on local loans going to increase the excessive profits made over the past 25 years by the Irish banks? The Irish banks, according to their own returns over a period of 25 years, have allocated to their shareholders profits to the extent of £36,000,000, which, as Deputy Hickey has pointed out, represents four times the paid up capital of the ten banks involved.
We are now proposing, through this Bill and the Government policy enshrined in it, to give an additional 1½ per cent. to the Irish banks at a time when we want agricultural production increased, and when the old rates of interest were having a very serious effect on the rents paid by tenants for houses built in the past few years by local authorities. Is it not a fact that slightly more than half the amount of the rents paid by tenants of local authority houses represents interest on money? It has been given to me by the Minister for Finance in writing, and I can produce the document in which it is indicated, that local authorities who borrow money to build houses over a 50-year loan period at a rate of 3¼ per cent. will, at the end of 50 years, have to repay, for every £1,000 they borrowed, £2,030. By increasing the interest from 4½ to 6 per cent. we are going to add to that liability at a time when the purchasing power of the tenants concerned is being almost wiped out or greatly reduced. I regret to say that in some of the principal towns in my own constituency there is a good deal of trouble and discontent arising out of the high rents which tenants are obliged to pay for houses built in the past few years. Interest represents more than 50 per cent. of that cost, and we now propose to add to it, and to create a further and much more serious problem than ever confronted the local authorities in this connection in the past.
I want to know from the Minister— I hope he will not shirk giving an answer—must we in this Republic of Ireland follow the British policy every time. Did the British put up the interest rate on loans through the agency of the private joint stock banks here or what is the explanation at a time like this, we being one of the principal creditor countries in the world, of this free Republic, with over £450,000,000 in the Bank of England, having to put up the interest rate on loans? Are we obliged, as a matter of agreement with the British Government, or is there some secret and hidden agreement under which the bankers of this country must put up the rates of interest automatically, whenever they go up in Great Britain?
One of the headings in the Daily Herald is: “Bank rate jumps to 4 per cent.” I heard a late Minister in the Fianna Fáil Government say that we have traditional reasons for always charging a higher bank rate than what is charged by the British Bank of England. As a representative of the people for over 30 years I want to know—and I insist upon finding out —why we must raise our bank rate automatically with Great Britain whenever Britain decides to raise it for quite different reasons altogether.
The Minister for Finance was called over to London for a friendly interview with his British boss. Apparently the British Chancellor of the Exchequer is his boss on financial matters. The Minister for Finance came back and issued a very brief statement in regard to what is supposed to have transpired. Nobody could interpret the meaning of that short statement. There was no reference in advance at any rate to the agreement if there was an agreement and apparently there was an agreement to raise the rate of interest on bank loans.
Comment on this
It has nothing to do with me what Mr. Butler does in Britain. It is for the British people to deal with him but it is our business to find out why we must follow Britain in these vital and fundamental matters. I will know the answer to my question before this Finance Bill is passed. I will keep asking the question until I get some kind of an answer from this mad Minister for Finance.
The removal of the subsidies has been referred to at length by innumerable speakers on the Budget and also on this Finance Bill. I am not going to prolong the discussion so far as that is concerned. I want to remind the Minister who is sitting in the Front Bench and I suppose he has as much responsibility for the Budget as the Minister for Finance——
Comment on this
I know the Minister for Defence is a strait-laced, decent, honourable man and would not say anything else. I expected that would be the answer. I am not asking the Minister to plead guilty to any crime but to plead guilty and defend so far as he can defend both inside and outside the House this Budget. I would like to hear the Minister on this before the Finance Bill goes through.
On 29th May, the eve of the general election, there appeared in the daily Press an advertisement for which I was told they paid over £10,000. The funds they had at their disposal at that time were said to be £54,000 or £55,000. In that advertisement it was clearly emphasised—the Minister can look at the paper if he has lost his memory in that regard—that the Government had no intention of removing the food subsidies. Is not this the most brazen repudiation and breach of a pledge publicly given that was ever heard of in the public life of this country since this State was established? They are slashing the subsidies to the extent of 75 per cent. I want to know in that connection whether the Government, including the Minister for Defence, before that vital decision was taken —a decision which is vital from a political and from an economic point of view—foresaw the effect it would have, not alone on the individual citizens including wage earners, but on the ratepayers?
Comment on this
I wonder whether they sat down and considered the effect of the removal of the subsidies on the payments to be made to the 70,000 odd people who are on an average in receipt of home assistance. The subsidies have been cut down by 75 per cent. and the cost of all essential foodstuffs will be increased as from 1st July. Surely the Government is not going to let the poor citizens of this State who up to now had to exist on 8/- a week still be obliged to exist on 8/- a week after the cost of the small number of commodities consumed by them has rapidly increased.
I wonder if the Minister for Defence, in collaboration with his colleague, the Minister for Finance, gave any consideration to these matters? If so, would they let us know whether the rates on all the various local authorities are going to be increased as on and from 1st July next? In connection with that particular aspect of administration, the inter-Party Government, during the three years and three months they were in office, reduced the number of people claiming and receiving home assistance from 73,852 to 57,549, a reduction of 16,303, in the period from 31st March, 1947, to 31st March, 1950. If anybody has any doubt about the accuracy of the figures I am quoting I would refer him to page 157 of the Statistical Abstract for the year 1951 where he will see the figures I have just quoted.
I am asking the Minister, who now occupies the Front Bench on behalf of the Government, whether any consideration has been given to the question of the effect upon the ratepayers of the country and upon the people in receipt of home assistance of the increased cost of food that will operate as on and from 1st July next? If so, what is going to be the average increase in the rates on local authorities that will follow the implementation of that portion of the Budget and the relevant section of the Finance Bill?
Nobody gives any serious consideration to the kind of stuff that is dished up to the House by Deputy Corry. Last night, he dealt at length with the debts which he alleged the inter-Party Government left to the present Government when they came into office on 13th June. I challenge the Minister for Defence or the Minister for Finance to give us a list and the country a list of the items and particulars in regard to the items of outstanding debts that were in the office of the Department of Finance on 13th June when the present Minister went in and after this Government was elected by the votes of Deputies Dr. Browne, Captain Cowan, Cogan and the other so-called Independents. Give us the list of outstanding debts that were in the office at that time. Give the list to the country and then we will know where we are.
Deputy Morrissey could give the details of one small bill which he found in his office shortly after Fianna Fáil was put out of office in February, 1948. It was a bill to clear up the mess Fianna Fáil left in Córas Iompair Éireann and amounted to £4,091,000—a very small sum! The least those opposite have to say about the debts that were alleged to have been handed over the better for them. They will get many more particulars about these issues if they will go down the country but everywhere their spokesmen will go in my constituency I will chase them and tell the truth.
Arising out of the question of alleged debts, what provision is being made in this Finance Bill for the increased pay which will have to be given to the civil servants, the Army, the Gardaí and the officers and employees of local authorities after this Budget comes into operation as on and from 1st July? Where is the provision for the increase? I can see it nowhere and I have examined the Estimates. If the Government sat down deliberately at the end of March and decided to bring in a Budget of this kind knowing perfectly well—if they are sane and sensible men—that it was going to affect the pay of civil servants, Gardaí, Army and every employee of the State and the local authorities, it was their bounden duty—if they are as honest as they say they are—to make provision in the Estimates for the increases which they knew would come into operation after 1st July next.
Comment on this
Are they going to bring in Supplementary Estimates or a Supplementary Budget in the autumn? These are questions to which the people of the country are entitled to an answer and they will have it before this debate ends.
I do not want to prolong the discussion, but one feels a certain amount of sympathy for a new young, decent Deputy like Deputy Dr. Hillery having notes handed to him about debts which the inter-Party Government left.
Comment on this
I said nothing derogatory about Deputy Dr. Hillery. I said that he had notes handed to him.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy sit down? Deputy Dr. Hillery made a reference to documents as any Deputy is entitled to do when he is making a statement. Deputy Dr. Hillery made a statement, and it is not right to say that he was handed a statement to read out.
Comment on this
I wonder did the Chair hear the gallant remark of the Deputy's when he said that Deputy Davin was a coward?
Comment on this
I think it is. The Deputy should be asked to withdraw the statement that Deputy Dr. Hillery was handed a statement.
Comment on this
That is for my judgment. It is a statement which should not be made regarding any Deputy. Deputy Dr. Hillery made his own statement.
Comment on this
I accept your ruling, a Cheann Comhairle, regarding every matter in this House, but thank God I still have my eyesight and the Deputy had a file and read it.
Comment on this
Deputy Dr. Hillery made reference to documents as every Deputy is entitled to do. He did no more.
Comment on this
I did not know that the Deputy was the man who referred to me as a coward. I do not care.
Comment on this
If Deputy Flanagan referred to Deputy Davin as a coward I would ask him to withdraw. He did not make that statement. If he did it should be withdrawn.
Comment on this
He can call me anything he likes within the rules of order and they are for you to decide, a Cheann Chomhairle. I now give way to Deputy Flanagan. He may, if he wishes, answer any of the questions I have addressed to the Minister for Finance.
Mr. Morrissey rose.
Comment on this
I do not intend to refer any more to what Deputy Davin said about Deputy Dr. Hillery but I object to it.
Comment on this
Deputy D.J. O'Sullivan made an interjection in the course of that argument too. It might simplify the procedure of the House if whichever speaker was on his feet was asked to stop every 30 seconds to permit Deputy O'Sullivan to issue a statement on whatever he was talking about. I do not claim to know everything that is to be known about economics; I do not claim to know a lot about economics; I beg leave of brilliant economists like Deputy O'Sullivan to make whatever statement I have to make on the subject of this Budget. I do so humbly and with trepidation. I do so on behalf of the constituency I represent in order to give the House the views of those people as I have heard them, views which I believe are their true views.
For six weeks after the Minister made his statement on the 2nd April, Fine Gael, Labour, the Independents supporting the Opposition Parties and Clann na Talmhan had an opportunity of showing to the people if they could a constructive alternative to the proposals put forward by the Minister for Finance. They had nothing whatever to say. Now, six or seven weeks afterwards they realise that they have passed up finally and for ever one of the best opportunities ever given to any Party if they were right. They failed. They failed because they were bragging, vulgar, vicious and virulent and, where Deputy Dillon is concerned, vindictive. He asked: "Is there anyone so dense in the Fianna Fáil Party as to believe...." Maybe we are dense, stupid clodhoppers. Let us just go back a few years—and it is not so very far back—to the time when this State was founded.
It was founded very shortly after the first of two world wars had shaken the foundation of the civilisation of Western Europe. I should imagine that nobody can deny that the first real evidence that this country had found its legs was the establishment in 1927 or thereabouts of the Shannon scheme. That is only 25 years ago and during that period we have had to contend with the effects of another world war between 1939 and 1945. During the vital years between 1927 and 1939 most of the progress in this State was made under the régime of Fianna Fáil from 1932 onwards. Will anybody stand up here and say that the war proved of any lasting benefit to this country? Will anybody contemplate otherwise than with horror the idea of another world conflict? The idea is being bandied about here; I heard some references to it here last night and I hate to think of it for the sake of this small country.
The really vital period, however, was when the effects of the Second World War had worn off, when the countries of Europe were beginning to find their feet again. Most of them would have been unable to do so without the assistance given very generously indeed by the United States by way of Marshall Aid and loan. Ireland came within the scope of Marshall Aid and loan. When the history of the last four years is eventually written, the use or misuse of the money received from America will be found to have decided the economic and financial future of this country. I personally distrust figures; I like to know the figures behind the figures. The Central Bank Report—much maligned—contains the statement that a great amount of the money received from America was spent on consumer or near-consumer goods. Is it or is it not true that a large amount of that money was so spent? I do not hear any answer to that question. The only conclusion I can come to is that what the Central Bank Report says must be true.
Now, as far as I am concerned, I am prepared to accept the word of the people who are most qualified and most competent to say what happened to the Marshall Aid money and I am prepared to accept what the chairman of the Central Bank says when he says a lot of that money was spent and should not have been spent on consumer and near-consumer goods. If it was spent, that was the money with which this State was going to rehabilitate itself. Fianna Fáil have been given the legacy, have been passed on the bill, have been asked to make up what they cannot make up because they cannot go back in time. They cannot go back to the time when they could get that money and use it again, not on consumer and near-consumer goods, which they would not have done. They cannot go back to the Americans and say: "It is not 1952. It is 1948. Give us the money all over again and we will show you what could have been done."
If you take the schoolboy or anybody from him up, the only answer to the economic position of this country, I repeat humbly, not as an economist, lies in the fact that you cannot now buy the same amount for the same money. A schoolboy in my time could buy 20 or 24 canned sweets for 1d. and he would be munching away for the rest of the day. Nowadays if he gets six or seven he considers himself lucky. At one time he could buy four biscuits and make a lunch of it.
Comment on this
I am not going to answer that. He, therefore, needs 3d. or 4d. to buy what he could buy with 1d. in 1934, 1935 or 1936. Similarly, with regard to every or almost every other item that one can or has to buy; one simply has to pay more and the only answer to it is to put more money in the hands of the people who have to buy. How can you do that except by increased production, increased agricultural production and increased industrial production.
As a western Deputy I want to answer, if I may, the question as to what the Fianna Fáil Government is doing to enable the people of the West, particularly the people of Mayo, to increase production industrially and agriculturally. I do believe that the most enlightened piece of legislation that was introduced in this House for many a year was the Undeveloped Areas Act, 1951. Be that to the eternal credit of Fianna Fáil and, I suppose, particularly the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Under it a factory is about to be set up in Kiltimagh, County Mayo, 12 miles from my own home which, it is hoped, will spread £30,000 in wages per annum around the town and districts of Kiltimagh. That is the answer to the economic problem of Ireland. That is the answer to the schoolboy who wants 4d. instead of 1d. to buy 24 canned sweets. That is the answer to the housewife who wants to keep her son at home so that he can bring in more money to put more money into the farm, to reclaim more land, to assist the Government in the schemes at their disposal. I only hope that others will follow where the town I have mentioned has given the lead, where they are given the opportunity by the Government to follow, through the Act which was brought in before the Budget and in itself was giving the answer to the Budget.
If I may, therefore, bring out the force, if there is any, in the argument that I have been making, I believe, and I must say I believe sincerely, that the proposals contained in the Budget and in the Finance Bill of 1952 are just and good and reasonable even if they are hard. But I do also say that the misfortune is that the increased production that the Government is trying to get has been, through force of circumstances outside the control of this Government, deferred behind the Budget in point of time. In other words, if we did not have the European War of 1939-1945 and if we had used the money so liberally given to us by America from 1948 onwards better than we did use it, then while I submit it would still have been necessary to introduce at least a certain amount of extra taxation, the effect of that extra taxation would not have been anything like as hard on the people and, in fact, would probably not have been really felt at all. After all, money is only a standard—a 1d., a 1/-, 2/— it depends on what you can get for it. If you have £5 in your pocket and you can buy certain goods with it, if the price of those goods goes to £10 but you also have £10 in your pocket at the same time, the net position is exactly the same. Historically we are forced by circumstances outside the control of any Government in this country, and certainly by factors outside the control of the Fianna Fáil Party in the last three years, to bring in these Budget proposals some time ahead of production schedule agriculturally and industrially that this Government envisages and hopes will come to pass.
I listened to Deputy Costello yesterday using Latin tags for the purpose of proving that there was going to be a Budget surplus. I must say I always distrust lawyers using lawyers' tags. There is another—ignorantia legis haud excusat. It is the maxim designed by lawyers for the benefit of lawyers. Anyone who chooses to study the moral law will know that ignorance of the moral law does excuse in certain cases.
Comment on this
It has this relevance, that I did not believe what Deputy Costello was talking about. I am not going to disbelieve it either. It is not a fact, it is a speculation. Let us wait for the facts to come about the next time the Minister is introducing his Budget. We will all know then whether there was a surplus and let the Opposition keep quiet in the meantime and let us stop using lawyer's tags designed for lawyers and not for the rehabilitation of our economy.
Comment on this
Apart from the matters I have mentioned, the present Government is making a sincere effort in the West to increase production and thereby to offset any hardships that may be occasioned by the Budget. They are going back to the policy of trying to produce electricity from the natural resources of this country—the turf which is in everybody's land in County Mayo—and they have started an extensive scheme in North Mayo, at Bangor Erris, to give more employment and designed eventually, I understand, to produce electricity for rural electrification purposes.
These and other measures are the real answer to the Budget. I do not think anybody can deny that there are factors working against any Government in this country. There are external factors, like the world prices for the various commodities we are forced to import and internal factors in the way of trade unions which are trying to get more wages. I am not saying that I am against trade unions.
Comment on this
I am surprised at the Deputy. The trade unions played a responsible part in the affairs of this country.
Comment on this
Will you keep your hackles down for a moment? The fact is, anything we can possibly produce in this country should be produced here so as to obviate the necessity of having to find money to pay another country for those goods. During the régime of the inter-Party Government, from 1948 to 1951, vast sums of money were poured out of this country to purchase goods that could have been, and should have been, produced within our shores. I do not believe that that could possibly be a healthy development in the economy of a State like this. However, we must import a certain amount of commodities which we cannot produce ourselves, and world factors of various kinds are showing up the prices that must be paid for these commodities. I am afraid these factors will continue to push up the prices still more in time to come. Does that mean or does that not mean increased State expenditure? Does that mean or does that not mean an increased burden if we are to continue the capital development of our country in these vital years? If we are ever to make up the leeway caused by the European war, we must do so in the course of the next ten or 15 years.
Comment on this
Finally, I would appeal to the remaining speakers on the Opposition Benches to approach this problem, even at this late stage, with some vestige of sincerity. I do not believe that any Party or Parties ever let themselves down as much in the history of this Parliament as the Opposition speakers have let themselves down in the course of the debates here.
Comment on this
I am certain of it. They have been shedding crocodile tears over the poor man's pint, over the poor man's tobacco and over the poor man's this, that and the other. They were delighted when Deputy Blowick handed to them the confidential document which was given to him by virtue of his position as ex-Minister. They were delighted when they saw that there were increased taxes imposed in the Budget, and they were very pleased to be given the opportunity of going to their constituents and saying that these taxes were imposed out of spite, as another Deputy has said.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I am entitled to request you to ask the Deputy to say what is the document to which he has reffered and who are those who were delighted at having received confidential information which was contained in a document which I got by virtue of being an ex-Minister. I think you should ask the Deputy to enlighten us on the vague charges he made against me. I ask you to do that for my protection.
Comment on this
Deputy Blowick is entitled to ask for an explanation as to the remarks you have made in connection with a confidential document.
Comment on this
The confidential document was a copy of the statement, incorporating the Budget proposals, which was being delivered by the Minister for Finance on the 2nd April.
Comment on this
Might I tell the Deputy that the Minister for Finance made a cod of himself in my absence here in the House. I made him withdraw what he said. If you go far enough I will make you withdraw your statements also unless you can back them.
Comment on this
I was about to conclude by saying that the Opposition members have tried to make cheap political capital without giving anything concrete or constructive in return. They have tried to cod the people by mere vulgarity and mere abuse. However, the people of this country are intelligent enough to know the difference between the type of propaganda which has been put out by every, or almost every speaker in the Opposition Benches instead of the assurances that they might or should be given if there were any vestige of reality about the statements being made on the Opposition Benches. They know that after six weeks the Opposition have nothing constructive to say. When they get the opportunity, as they will in due time, they will give their answer to the Opposition for the six weeks during which they neglected them, shed crocodile tears for them and asked them to vote for them on ad misericordiam basis and not on the basis of the intelligence which they have and will continue to have.
Comment on this
The Deputy who has just sat down was talking about making cheap, political capital about this Budget. There is nothing cheap about this Budget. In fact, that is about the last word that could be applied to it or applied in connection with it by anybody. The Deputy started his speech by accusing this side of being vulgar, vicious, vindictive and virulent. The Deputy, with a calmness, a coolness, a collectiveness and, might I say, a culture delivered his speech with a display of good temper that unfortunately one rarely sees exhibited in this House by those who are sufficiently long in it to have got something of the atmosphere of the place. He told us, when he had started to cool down a little, that he was going to give the House the views of his constituents on this Budget.
However, he conveniently forgot to give us a single view of any of his constituents on this Budget. The Deputy knows quite well the views of his constituents. He knows them so well that he would not dare to give them here. The Deputy, with a hypocrisy that I have rarely seen excelled here, appealed to us on this side of the House to approach this matter with at least some vestige of sincerity. I will leave it to the House as to what adjective—the Deputy was pretty free with his use of adjectives—they would apply to the speech to which we have just listened. I venture to say that even one of his colleagues and one of his greatest admirers in the constituency would not apply the word sincerity to the Deputy's speech. In fact, it would be the last word that would enter into his head in connection with the speech.
Comment on this
These cheap, pettifogging little lawyers' tricks do not cut any ice with me. The Deputy has a lot to learn, and so has his colleague, Deputy Cunningham. It is something that is a little bit outside Deputy Cunningham's understanding. If the Deputy is not, with his colleague, sent into the wilderness on account of this Budget, he may be allowed to remain here sufficiently long to get a few of the corners knocked off. We have been chipping them off a lot of his colleagues for a long number of years. Let him just keep on and see who will come out best in the end.
Comment on this
The Deputy told us that he was very conversant with the problem of the schoolboys. Judging by his speech, I am not surprised.
Comment on this
Not at all. We saw the viciousness displayed in his own countenance when he was addressing Deputy Davin.
Comment on this
The Deputy suffers from the same weakness as other people. He is a first-class hand at giving it out, but he is not able to take it. If he is not able to take it, he should not start giving it out.
(Interruption.)
Comment on this
I can give Deputy Flanagan one guarantee, that however low I may fall in his estimation he shall never fall as low in my estimation as Deputy Cogan. There is no possible chance of that ever happening. The Deputy told us that the way to solve the problems created by this Budget was to put more money in the hands of the people. The way the Budget will put more money in the hands of the people is by taking considerably more out of their pockets and not putting it into the hands of the taxpayer but into the hands of the Minister for Finance and the Revenue Commissioners. The Deputy talked about the Marshall Aid money and about the debts which the present Government had to meet.
Comment on this
I beg his pardon—it was Deputy Dr. Hillery. I know that the Deputies and the organisation to which they belong are doing all in their power to play up that. But may I warn Deputies on the other side that we have not even yet started to talk about debts and that when we do there will be something to be disclosed? That will make for even greater difficulties than the Budget.
Comment on this
Away back in 1948 we were told about fairy tales of that kind but we never heard them. Let us have them now.(Interruption.)
Comment on this
I am not talking to Deputy Cogan. Deputy Cogan takes himself more seriously than anybody in this House or outside takes him. I want to tell a few fairy tales.
Comment on this
Certainly. Deputy Dr. Hillery quoted from a statement which he said was made by Mr. Clement of E.C.A. I have my own view as to whether that statement by Mr. Clement was made in relation only to industrial production here. It was quoted in that way by Deputy Dr. Hillery. But, if Mr. Clement was correctly quoted by Deputy Dr. Hillery as to the advance made in industrial production and employment in this country between 1948 and 1951, then I want to tell Deputy Dr. Hillery and Mr. Clement that they are both wrong. I think I can probably claim to be more conversant with what happened in the industrial field during that period than either one or the other of them. The fact is—I am not claiming any credit for it, nor do I feel any way proud of it as a member of the Front Bench if you like, but I feel rather proud of it as an Irishman—that during that particular period there were more Irishmen and women put into industrial employment in this country than in any similar period since the State was established. That is beyond question.
These figures are not my figures; they are issued by the statistical department. I am not claiming now and I never claimed that that was entirely due to the fact that there was a change of Government in February, 1948. It was, however, due to the fact that, so far as the Government from 1948 to 1951 were concerned, they were at least as anxious as their predecessors were to get the maximum industrial expansion and production and the maximum number of people into industrial employment that they could get. We succeeded to an enormous extent, to the extent of putting 1,000 additional persons into industrial employment during every month we were in office. There is no question about that. I am not saying this to make any political or Party crack, but I hope that that rate of progress is being continued. However, we will know that when the statistical return for the year 1951 is made available.
This is a bad Budget. It is unnecessary to say that on the face of it it is bad. This Budget will hit every single member of the community. It will hit certain sections of the community to a greater extent than others. This Budget will impact adversely upon every trade and industry in this country. It will impact adversely upon the whole economic and commercial life of the country; it has done so already. There is no Deputy, I do not care where he sits, who is living in or adjacent to a village, town or city and who is in contact with what is happening in our country but knows that business generally, whether in regard to production or distribution, is in a more jittery condition to-day than it has been since the State was established; that people have lost confidence in this country and its future to a greater extent than ever before.
Comment on this
I was there last Friday. This is only the second time since I came in here that I have been interrupted by a colleague from Tipperary. I will pass on, however. The confidence of the people has been shaken. The people are uneasy, and I am putting it very mildly when I say that. The people are doubtful and dubious about the future. The people who have money are very reluctant, as is well known to Deputies in this House, to invest that money or to make use of it at the moment in this country. Is it not small blame to them? What have they been listening to since last August from the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and, on one occasion—and I am glad it was only on one occasion—from the Minister for Industry and Commerce? The Minister for Industry and Commerce had the ability to see more quickly than either of his two colleagues where that line would take us and he had, if you like, the manliness to mend his hand in this House at the first opportunity he got. What have the people been told since last August? They have been told that this country is on the verge of bankruptey.
Comment on this
There is no truth in it. Deputies who are living in Dublin City, Tipperary, Galway, Cork or any where else in this country—whatever political label they may attach to themselves or may have attached to themselves—know quite well that for the past five years this country has been better off than ever before since this State was founded.
Comment on this
Have we not already had proof of the progress which this country was making? What about the effect on employment and on production? The speech which Deputy Dr. Hillery made was quite fair. I have no quarrel with him at all and I may say that it was the first speech by him which I heard in this House. However, Deputy Dr. Hillery spoke about emigration and unemployment. He said that people on this side of the House were trying to put the entire blame for emigration on Fianna Fáil and he said that that was not fair and was wrong. I would agree with the Deputy but I should like to point out that, when Fianna Fáil were trying to put the whole blame for emigration on the inter-Party Government, he did not makes the same remarks then which he makes now about emigration. It is no pleasure to me or to any responsible person in this country to have to say that there is more emigration this month than last month or this year than last year. That is no credit to any of us, either in Government or in Opposition. We are not going to improve the position by ascribing unhealthy personal motives to the Parties on either side of the House.
The Minister for Finance made a reference yesterday in the course of his speech—and it was played up in the usual way by the descriptive artist from the Irish Press in this morning's issue of that paper—about people on this side of the House worshipping the porter barrel. One has to exercise a good deal of restraint to refrain from making the obvious comment on such a remark coming from the Minister for Finance. The Minister ought pause sometimes and ask himself whether, in fact, he is in a dug-out or a glasshouse when he is throwing some of his missiles.
I do not want to draw any comparisons between publicans and dance-hall proprietors. That will not solve any of our problems. There is an easy answer to this and there is a way out. There is something which has to be faced. There is one authority greater than this House. There is only one authority who can decide whether the Government is right or wrong— whether the Government is doing what the people want them to do or is acting in defiance of their wishes. That authority is the people who sent us here.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will also "hear, hear" to what I am now about to say. I think the issue is at least sufficiently balanced in this House to take it to the people outside and let them decide at the earliest possible moment——
Comment on this
If some of us were to look at the matter from a purely personal point of view we would never wish to be back again as Ministers. The Deputy need not be concerned about my coming back here. I have been coming back here for a long time now.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Minister for Finance is aware of the damage that has been done to the economic and commerical structure of this country by some of his own statements. I do not know if Deputies are generally aware of the brake that has been put upon the economic life of this country by the money restrictions that are in force. I know that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs will tell us in this House that there are no restrictions but there is not a man in business in this country to-day, from the smallest shopkeeper in the most remote part of the country to the biggest businessman in Dublin, who is not aware that the restrictions are there. I wonder if the Minister and his colleagues are aware of the effects which these restrictions are having on housing and employment in this country? Unless there is a change very quickly, private building will come to an end except in so far as the purchase of houses will be financed by local authorities.
Building societies have played a very big part in enabling thousands of people to start acquiring their own homes in this country but they are now in the position that they have decided practically to stop issuing money for the purchase of houses. I do not know how long that will last. The Minister smiles. I do not know whether the smile is meant in any personal way. I know what I am talking about in this connection. I do not think the Minister has anything to smile at. I think that it was a desirable form of saving by our people. They were saving for perhaps the highest possible purpose— the acquiring of a decent, modern, sanitary home of their own in which to bring up their children. All the speeches that may be made from the Government side of the House, all the attempts which may be made to gloss this Budget and all the efforts that may be made, unfairly, to put the blame on their predecessors in office will not succeed on this occasion. I do not believe that at any time since this State was founded there was ever such a demand by the people generally to be given an opportunity of expressing their views on how the Government have conducted the affairs of this country in the past 12 months. I sat on the Government side of the House for three and a half years. While I was a Minister in the inter-Party Government I read in the local papers in my own constituency charges by Fianna Fáil speakers who are now Ministers, and by their back benchers and supporters, that the inter-Party Government were not in office by the wishes of the people. Time after time we were challenged in this House to get out and get a mandate from the people for the work which we were doing.
Comment on this
Look, the people of the constituency which the Deputy and I have the honour to represent, gave a majority of 3,500 number one votes against Fianna Fáil at the last election.
Comment on this
I am not guilty of the interruptions and I would appeal to you Sir, if I may, to shelter me from them.
Comment on this
The Deputy is long enough in this House to know that he should not pay any attention to interrupters.
Comment on this
I quite agree. Does anybody suggest that this Government represents the people and that they have a majority of the people behind them? It is not I who should be asking them to get out and go to the people but those who were induced to support them by the publication of the 17 points after the June election, the 17 points which were drawn up on 15th June to capture those very votes and to justify those Deputies in voting for a Fianna Fáil Government. These are the people who should be asking them to get out. I wonder to what extent point 15 influenced some of the votes cast for Deputy de Valera against Deputy Costello, point 15 which contained a promise to maintain the food subsidies? Perhaps again I should not be rushing in and raising a smell which does not appeal to the Minister's very sensitive nostrils but I wonder to what extent these votes were influenced by the promise which the Minister gave in Rathmines Town Hall on 15th May in connection with the reimposition of the taxes on beer, spirits and tobacco?
These are the points we want answered. They are not going to be answered by personal abuse. That is not going to get them anywhere. Goodness knows, I am long enough in public life not to be falling over myself calling for a general election, whether or not I am going to be elected at the head or at the bottom of the poll. I have gone through 12 or 13 in my time and that is as many as I want but it is not a question of what my personal feelings are in the matter. It is not a question of whether I am returned or not. That does not matter two "thraneens" so far as the future of the country is concerned. What does really matter is the Government that will be sent back here by the people and the policy which will be carried out by that Government. We tried in a straightforward way for three and a half years to run this country in the interests of the people and not in the interests of any one section. Irrespective of what may be said by members of the Government, members of the Fianna Fáil Party and still less of what may be said by some of their henchmen, those of us who had the honour of being associated with that Government will always feel proud of the fact.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey has made a considerable amount of noise but he has said very little. Deputy Costello in opening the debate for the Opposition did, however, say something to which I feel it is necessary to reply. He said that the dissolution of the 13th Dáil did not arise from the fact, as the Minister for Finance asserted, that the then Government was afraid to face a discussion on their unbalanced Budget of 1951 but arose from the pressure that was brought to bear upon the Government by farmers to increase the prices of milk and several other farm products. From that statement, it would appear, if it is true, that Deputy Costello's Government, dominated mainly by the legal profession, was prepared to jettison its Commonwealth principles, its principles of loyalty to the Commonwealth and to become a rabid roaring Republican Government in order to hold the support of Deputy MacBride. It was prepared to jettison its Conservative principles, which it had held for 20 years, and become a rabid Socialist Government in order to oblige and to hold the support of Deputies Norton and Larkin but it was not prepared, because of its anti-agricultural bias, even to meet the farmers' representatives and to discuss agricultural prices with them in a reasonable way. That is the only inference which can be drawn from Deputy Costello's statements.
I still think that there was a good deal in the suggestion that it was not alone a desire to defeat the farmers and to eliminate the farmers' representatives in this House, that actuated the inter-Party Government in forcing the election in 1951. I think they were also definitely afraid to have their Budget of 1951 analysed by Deputies in this House, to have it considered in a deliberative way and to have its fallacies clearly revealed to the community. However, it does not really matter now what induced the inter-Party Government to force an election. All that matters is that the election resulted in the elimination of that Government. They thought it would result in the elimination of some constructive elements who put them into office but, instead of that, it resulted in their own elimination. Now they are howling for another election. They will get another general election in due course and it is quite likely and quite possible that they will regret it just as much as they now regret the last one, into which at least the Fine Gael section so joyfully entered in 1951.
Comment on this
Came out at the other side of the House—and that is one good thing. In considering this Finance Bill we should realise that it was a very good thing that they came out at the other side of the House. Twelve months ago, I told this House and the people as well that I was voting against the inter-Party Government because I considered them utterly and completely irresponsible. Is not their utter and complete irresponsibility now fully revealed to the world? Is it not quite clear that they grasped at any money that could be offered to them not only within this House but by the generosity of the American taxpayers who were eager to help this nation on its feet? They grasped at that money, not to assist and develop the nation, not to provide increased employment and increased opportunities for our people, but merely in order to buy time and to buy a little popularity so that they might hang on to office at least for the three years necessary to qualify for a ministerial pension.
We are to-day facing the fact that we had a Government for three years which each year increased expenditure very considerably. Nobody denies that public expenditure was increased steadily over the three years and three months that the inter-Party Government was in power. They did not increase taxation, because they considered that that would be an unpopular move and because they were in the happy position that they could call upon the American taxpayers to finance their expenditure. That is the position we have to remedy now. Supposing a young man setting out in business or on a farm and finding it just difficult to make ends meet, but struggling manfully to do so, were to find himself confronted by a rich uncle who would present him with £1,000 and say: "This will help to put you on your feet," and suppose that for a year he went on spending that £1,000 and as a result raised his standard of living in various ways; and suppose that the following year the same rich uncle came along and gave him £1,000 again and in the third year made a similar gift; would it not be a cold bleak dawn for that young man, having spent the money foolishly on raising his standard of living by luxuries and semi-luxuries and having made no provision for the future out of that money, to find that it was suddenly cut off in April, 1951, that he had to pay his way and try to meet his responsibilities from day to day without all this help and not only that but that we would have to face the prospect of repaying that debt?
That was the position that faced Deputy McGilligan in April, 1951, that was the position that he as one member of the Government clearly saw, and was at least courageous enough to state publicly was facing the country. Terrified at the prospect of having, for the first time in their three years of office, to pay their way and meet their liabilities out of this nation's own resources without any outside help, they rushed to the country, hoping that either they would be put out of office and the burden of paying their debts would fall on their successors or they would be returned with a sufficient majority to enable them to face the harsh Budget they would have to impose upon our people in the succeeding years. If the inter-Party Government had been returned to office they would have been faced with the same problem that has faced the present Government. Even if they desired to do so, even if they wished to borrow money from the United States on the scale that they had been borrowing it previously, they could not do so and they would have found it necessary to impose additional taxation. That is a fact which is clearly accepted. I doubt very much, however, if they would have had the courage to meet all their liabilities. They would have been coerced into imposing increased taxation, but I have a feeling that they would have tried in some way to disguise the financial position and to push at least some portion of the burden on ahead to be met at some future date.
It is one of the tragedies or one of the weaknesses of democratic government that an incompetent Government, a dishonest Administration, can purchase a certain amount of cheap popularity by incurring liabilities and passing them on to their successors. It is always a popular thing to spend money. It is a popular thing for a Government to spend money. We all know that. Those of us in local authorities know how popular it is to vote for the expenditure of more and more public money, but we always have to face the day of reckoning, the day when we have to impose the necessary taxation to meet that expenditure. That is the sort of corrective which prevents local authorities—and I suppose it applies equally to Governments—from extravagantly wasting the nation's assets. But because changes of Government are inevitable from time to time, when the case occurs where a Government has just scrambled into office by a combination of a great number of small Parties and is never sure of being able to hold office for very long, there is a great temptation upon such a Government to evade its liabilities, to pile up debts and leave those debts to be paid by their successors.
It is unfortunate that the inter-Party Government yielded to that temptation. They could have resisted it and, if they had, although they would have incurred a certain amount of unpopularity I believe they would have raised their standing in the eyes of all honest people in this nation. However, they did not resist the temptation. Notwithstanding the fact that they tried by every expedient— by cooking the Estimates, as one of their Ministers expressed it, by borrowing for services which were not reasonably appropriate for borrowing and which were current services, and by leaving debts unpaid—to buy popularity, they went to the country and were defeated. They were defeated, as I say, in this House in the main— apart from the Fianna Fáil Party—by Deputies who were simply disgusted by their attitude of dishonesty and irresponsibility.
I think it is well to realise, as Deputy Seán Flanagan did, that this nation has no future except what lies in the ability of our people to use our national resources to the best advantage. It is deplorable to think that over the last few years the resources of our agricultural industry have not been used to the best advantage. I asked a question to-day in relation to the importation of oats. Oats is a crop we can grow on the worst and most neglected land in this country. Oats have been grown in Ireland for thousands of years. Yet, last year we had a Minister for Agriculture who went, not to any neighbouring country but to Australia to purchase almost as much oats there as the farmers would have surplus here, thereby depriving our farmers to a great extent of their market for oats.
Is not that the kind of policy designed to keep this country poor and in the miserable position of having to scramble for Marshall Aid and assistance from an outside nation? Is not that the kind of policy which leads to emigration? Deputy Morrissey said he did not know how the problem of emigration could be solved. The first effort towards a solution of the problem is to ensure that we get from the land its maximum output while at the same time increasing its fertility. That is the fundamental basis to the prosperity of our country. Yet, last year we had a Minister for Agriculture who went to Australia for oats despite the fact that we did not want them and despite the fact that, as subsequent events showed, the importation of those oats depressed the market for the home-grown commodity.
That is the kind of policy we had during the three and a half years of inter-Party Government. That is a policy we must now correct. The taxes imposed under this Budget are undoubtedly heavy. Nobody denies that. One Opposition Deputy said that the Budget this year was the worst Budget in 30 years. It is a hard Budget but it is the first time since the establishment of the State that a Government has had to budget in one year to correct the neglect of four years. The Government had to take a harsh decision. That decision has been taken and the country appreciates the fact that a reasonable effort is now being made to put our nation in a sound position both financially and economically.
Some of the taxes pressed heavily on a small but wealthy section of the community. That is particularly true of income-tax. On the other hand, I think it is satisfactory that the burden in that respect has been reduced for nearly 90 per cent. of those who pay income-tax. I think it is very desirable that the State should give an incentive to every worker to earn as much as possible without cutting too deeply into his income. When a young man is struggling to better his position in life and when he manages to increase his income it is most desirable that the burden imposed upon him through the operation of the incometax code shall not be so severe as to take away from him the incentive to further increase his income.
I am one of those who believe that it is better for our young people to spend their leisure moments in dancing rather than in drinking. I may be wrong in that. That may be only a silly prejudice on my part but that is my belief. I think it should be the aim of any Government to ensure that dancing will be as cheap as possible for our young people and that, if there is any revenue made out of dancing, it will be utilised for the benefit of the district in which the dances are held—utilised for the local Fine Gael club, or the local Fianna Fáil club, or for the improvement of the schools or the provision of any amenity locally for which money may be required.
Comment on this
It is a sound policy to improve local amenities. We know that under the system in operation there were certain exemptions in relation to areas with a population of under 500. That created problems which could not be solved. Everybody knows the problems that were created because of that exemption. The tax was administratively impossible and it simply had to be abolished. There was only one alternative and that was to have no exemptions at all. I think the Government took the wise course in abolishing the tax and I think the Government should now ensure that the remission is passed on to those who enjoy that particular amenity so that dancing will in future be cheaper particularly in the larger towns and cities.
A good deal has been said about housing. Housing made considerable progress over the last few years; it is still making considerable progress. Housing is a function of local authorities and there is nothing to prevent local authorities going ahead with housing at the present time. I am a member of a local authority and we have this year a more ambitious and more extensive programme than we had last year and we are going ahead with housing at full speed.
I think it will be agreed by all Deputies, though not publicly admitted by the Opposition, that for the first time for many years we as a nation are meeting our liabilities in a proper way. We are shouldering our responsibilities. If some people regard this volume of taxation as harsh they must show us the alternative means by which that taxation can be reduced or the burden of expenditure lessened. The only way in which taxation can be reduced is by reducing expenditure. Has any Deputy on the Opposition Benches made even one suggestion as to how expenditure can be reduced? The inter-Party Government was in office for almost four years. Four Budgets were introduced by that Government and, so far from reducing expenditure, that Government increased it each year.
I know it is very difficult to reduce expenditure. I am not the only member of this House who is also a member of a local authority. I know the difficulties any public representative has to face when trying to cut down expenditure. Social services cannot be cut. The services which provide for the poor, the sick and the destitute cannot be cut. I do not think anybody would suggest they should be. The remuneration of civil servants cannot be cut. They are entitled to fair remuneration. The inter-Party Government, just before they went out of office, went out of their way to provide for substantial increases in the remuneration of a large number of civil servants, but, unfortunately, they did nothing whatever to provide the money to meet that liability.
Nothing is more silly than the suggestions of people like Deputy Davin who, with a sort of infantile mind, talk about the wealth of this country. They say that we have £450,000,000 invested abroad, but they never ask what are the net investments of this nation abroad. The net assets of this country abroad are less than £150,000,000. I think it will be admitted that, in a nation of 3,000,000 people, is less than £50 per head of the population. It is not a huge surplus on which we can rely, sit back and take things easy. Deputy McGilligan, of the inter-Party Government, its very brain if you like on financial and economic matters, admitted that in his Budget statement last year. He called that money, which is invested abroad, a sort of a cushion to protect this country from grave economic crises if our external trade was unbalanced for a considerable period of time, and said it provided a mass of manæuvre which protected our economic system.
Therefore, I think it will be admitted there is not any source upon which this nation can draw. We can no longer be Marshall-aided as we were during the three years when the inter-Party Government were in power. It was no thanks to them that we got that money and no fault of theirs that it was cut off. It was just an international accident, if you like. We cannot rely on drawing upon our external assets, as Deputy Davin has suggested. The only things we have to rely on are the land and industries of the country, and on the ability of our people to develop both our land and our industries to the fullest possible extent. We can do that, and it is a significant thing that, since this Budget was announced, the volume of employment has been steadily increasing. I believe it will continue to increase for the next couple of years, and that on the land and in our manufacturing industries, in our turf-producing industries and in our afforestation and land reclamation schemes, we will have all our surplus population employed, and that it will not be necessary to export from our country our young people in addition to those who, according to a Fine Gael Deputy, were exported during the last three years.
Comment on this
I would like to say a few words on this Bill. In opening, I should like to say that we have had a perfect preview of what we may expect when the by-elections come to be contested. There can be little doubt but that the House is now being used as a rehearsal ground for the period when the hustings will be occupied. However, I suppose we cannot complain about that. I listened to Deputy Davin this evening and was rather amused by the technique which he employed because he assumed, as he always assumes, that everything which flows from Deputy Davin's lips is fact. He is accustomed to give us these statements without any supporting evidence, good, bad or indifferent, and he always appears amazed and surprised if anyone in the House attempts to dispute or question any of the statements which he makes. He seemed to me to have the belief that the members of the Fianna Fáil Government were not united, so to speak, in respect to their decision to bring in this Budget for the imposition of taxes which are set out in it. He asked me questions as to whether I stood for this or for that or for something else. I want to tell the House, and to tell Deputy Davin, that, as a member of the Government which has found it necessary to impose these taxes, over quite a considerable period of time I sat in a committee with my colleagues to examine every possible aspect of the situation with which we were confronted. We did that before any decision was taken in respect to the imposition of any single item contained in the Budget. As far as I am concerned, I am perfectly satisfied that the action which the Government had to take, and which I supported, was a justifiable action if this nation was to be preserved.
It is an extraordinary state of affairs when we have a man of the long standing in this House of Deputy Davin imputing to the members of the Government and to members of the House dishonest statements. As far as the Government are concerned, they are asking the people of this country to meet the requirements which this Budget imposes on them. They are asking them to do that in exactly the same way as they would ask them to meet a crisis or an emergency, if such were to happen: they are asking them to supply them with the ways and means to provide for the protection of the people and the protection of the nation. We are not considering the fact that the pint is going to be a little dearer, or that tobacco is going to be dearer, or that bread, tea and sugar are going to be dearer, but we are asking them to give us the money which will accrue from these impositions in order that this nation may continue to live in the way in which it has lived for several years. I do not think we are asking too much when we ask the people to do that.
When this Government reassumed office we, naturally, had to examine the situation with which we were confronted. It may surprise Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Davin, who have already spoken, to learn that we were satisfied that we were confronted with a very serious situation. Personally, I am not too sure that if we had taken action at that period and had brought in a Supplementary Budget, we would have been acting wrongly. I think that, if we had approached the difficulties with which we were then confronted, and had taken action at that particular time, the people might have more clearly understood the situation then than they do now by reason of the fact that the impositions are now being brought in through the medium of the normal annual Budget.
We were confronted with a serious situation. We did consider that question but we decided on the action which we finally took of meeting the situation when the normal time came to bring in the annual Budget. I would like to assure Deputy Davin that, as far as I am concerned, I am quite prepared to meet my constituents at any time the necessity should arise and to justify the action which I have taken in respect of the Budget, and the action of all my colleagues. I will make clear to the public the reasons why that action was necessary.
It rather amused me to find Deputy Davin issuing threats from the bench from which he was speaking. He tried to make my flesh creep with threats of revelations which he would make to his constituents in the near future. Deputy Morrissey, in the course of his opening remarks, probably having allowed himself to be knocked out of step, so to speak, made a similar statement about revelations which he would make. I appealed to him to make them right here and now, that it was in this House that these serious allegations should be made and not out on the hustings. Deputy Morrissey gave me to understand that he was going to accede to my request but he did not make the slightest reference, after that opening remark, to any of these serious allegations or to the serious revelations which he was about to make but which he did not make.
Deputy Davin insisted on telling us that we were taking our orders from Mr. Butler, the Chancellor of the British Exchequer. He kept on repeating that in the course of his speech, to such an extent that I can only assume that he dreams on that subject now.
Comment on this
Is not that all part of the business of letting the nation down? That is what it is: let the nation down.
Comment on this
He spoke about our having to take our orders from the bankers here and the suggestion was that it was done through the medium of some instructions issued by Mr. Butler. I am pretty certain that Deputy Davin knows the position as well as I know it, perhaps better than I know it, but it does not suit him to use his knowledge in the way it should be used. He misuses it in order to convey to Deputies and to people outside this House that we have taken orders from some outside source. It is a scandalous statement for an Irish representative to make.
Comment on this
It comes very badly from a man who would not hold a rifle to say that about people who looked down the barrels of British rifles.
Comment on this
It is a scandalous statement for any responsible representative to make because I doubt if any decent Deputy would believe for a moment that any member of an Irish Government would be prepared to take orders from anyone but the members of this House and, through the members of this House, the people. That is the attitude, as far as the present Government is concerned, that we have adopted and will continue to act on.
Deputy Davin knows as well as I know that if the increase in the interest rate had not been permitted by this Government, the banks themselves could have raised the rate. They could have raised the interest rate without consulting the Government at all. What actually did happen was that the Minister for Finance ensured that the responsible bank officials would give him a complete and entire explanation of the necessity for the increase in the rate of bank interest and, when he had that complete and entire explanation, permission to raise the rate was accorded. Does not every Deputy who knows anything, good, bad or indifferent, about financial matters, know that if we did not permit the raising of the interest rate the deposits would have left the Irish banks and would, perhaps, have gone to some foreign banks where they would have got that higher interest Would Deputy Davin suggest for a moment that Mr. Butler was suggesting that we should prevent the deposits that lie in our Irish banks from going to England? That is what he is, in fact, suggesting but he did not intend it to be construed in that way. That is the sort of irresponsible statement that we have from Deputy Davin. He gets up and he makes this type of statement without the slightest title of supporting evidence and he makes that statement as if he fully believed what he was saying and tries to convince, and I am sure does convince, quite a number of the people who sit on the benches with him. Those of us who know Deputy Davin over a long number of years know that that is Deputy Davin's technique and that nothing that I or any other member of the House could say will change that technique.
We all know Deputy Davin by this. That is why we regard him in some respects as a rather humorous speaker. When he speaks on these subjects he does cause a certain amount of amusement. I can assure the Deputy that he affords me a considerable amount of amusement. He makes these statements that may, perhaps, be half true and, because they are half true, he can build on them and get some of his colleagues or some of the people outside to believe him. Deputy Morrissey, who is an ex-Minister and who has been in the House perhaps longer than most members, makes a statement alleging that there has been a restriction of credit, due, in the main, of course, to the fact that the Fianna Fáil Government has come into power— that, because they have come into power, there is a complete restriction of credit. What are the facts? Deputy Morrissey, like Deputy Davin, did not make the slightest effort to produce a single tittle of evidence in support of the statement he made.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey said there was a restriction of credit by Irish banks. What are the facts? I will give the facts. In 1950, credit to the amount of £104.7 million was afforded by the banks; on 31st December, 1951, the amount had increased to £120.9 million; and on 18th March, 1952, it had further increased to £123.1 million. What is the reason for a responsible Deputy like Deputy Morrissey standing up here and making that allegation, knowing that it was not correct, that it was not true? One would at least expect that Deputy Morrissey, before making a statement of the kind, would acquaint himself with these simple facts. Instead of there being a restriction of credit, there has been a gradual increase of credit.
Deputy Morrissey went on to give himself a clap on the back and I am not going to quarrel with him for that. He pointed to what had been done in the period of the Coalition Government and told us that over 1,000 people had been put into employment during that period. The facts as I know them are that, taking the industrial situation with the agricultural position, there was an aggregate reduction of something like 7,000 people in employment. It is no harm to refresh the minds of members of the House on the fact that during the same period around 30,000 people emigrated from this country. I am not going to say that the Government of the day was responsible for that emigration or took any pleasure in seeing 30,000 of our people leave our shores. It is an unfortunate trend, a trend for which, I am sure, every Party in the House will unite in endeavouring to find a remedy.
The difficulty must be apparent to every one of us, because, over the years, in spite of the efforts made through the establishment of factories, appeals for greater agricultural production and so on, the trend has continued and when we are assailed for being responsible for the increase in the unemployment figures to-day, Deputies should realise that there is no truth in the suggestion that we are any more responsible for it than was the last Government responsible for the reduction of something like 7,000 in the aggregate of employed people. The fact remains that it will be only by efforts to establish national industries and efforts to provide the amenities which we hope will keep the people at home that we will ever succeed in arresting this trend. I do not even know that these efforts would be successful.
I am giving all credit to the previous Government for their efforts to continue the housing programme. It is quite true that the housing programme of the previous Fianna Fáil Government was continued, and continued with energy, but I regret to say that the policy which the Fianna Fáil Government insisted on, of having prepared foundations at all times ready and at the disposal of the various corporations, so that when one scheme was being completed, the foundations were laid for another scheme to follow, was not continued. My information is that, while that housing policy was carried on with energy and industry, the general plan was not followed, with the result that when we came into office we found that we could not proceed at the same rate of production by reason of the fact that these prepared foundations were not available for the continuation of the plan which existed under Fianna Fáil.
Another unfair feature of the debate was the attacks on Independent Deputies which I heard throughout the discussion. I hold no brief for Independent Deputies. Deputy Flanagan, of the Monetary Party or whatever he calls himself, was at one time a member of the Fianna Fáil Party. I have no objection to his attitude in regard to the Fianna Fáil Government or the Fianna Fáil Party. He is perfectly entitled to adopt that attitude, to express his views in the way he expresses them and to act in the way he acts. I want to point out to the House that Deputies opposite were very glad to avail of the services of these Independent Deputies when they were responsible for the Government and all that they are doing, so far as I can see, is objecting to the independent mind acting in an independent manner. It may be that these Independents who are giving us their support at present may decide to change. If they do, that is their business. We have no commitments to them and they have no commitments to us, but we are prepared to assume that they are acting in an honourable way as honourable men and we ought to realise that, like each of us here, they, too, were elected by the Irish people and we ought to respect that fact. The attacks which have been made on some of these Independent Deputies shed no honour on this House or any member of this House. I would like to think that there should be a reconsideration of that situation because it is quite possible that we will have Independents in this House for a considerable time.
Deputy Alderman Alfie Byrne is an Independent. I do not think that anyone on this side of the House ever took exception to Deputy Alderman Alfie Byrne's actions in this House in the manner in which the Opposition are taking exception to the activities of the Independents who are now supporting the Government.
In conclusion, I want to assure Deputy Davin, as I did in the beginning, that I stand over every item in the Budget. I gave consideration with my colleagues over a long period of time to each of these items and I have already given to the House my reason and theirs for the necessity of enforcing these items in the annual Budget. I have also told the House that the people are being asked to pay these extra taxes in order that this nation may continue to survive and that it may not, as would have happened if the attitude of the last Government had been allowed to continue, be brought into a state of mortgage or bankruptcy. That is the reason why I, for one, am prepared to stand over every item in this Budget.
If Marshall Aid, which kept the Coalition Government in the happy position in which it was for three and a half years, had been used in the way it was intended to be used, to provide capital goods instead of luxury goods we would not be in the position in which we are to-day.
Comment on this
If the Minister would not mind, what luxury goods did the inter-Party Government purchase?
Comment on this
Of that vast sum of dollars, $6.9 million was spent on the provision of machinery and equipment that could be regarded as capital goods but the rest was spent upon bringing in corn, tobacco, wheat, flour, petrol, petroleum products, and so on—things that could, if necessary, have been avoided. The production of wheat could have provided a vast amount of employment in this country during the three-and-a-half-year period of the Coalition Government. Instead of providing that means of employment on the land, the Coalition Government decided to bring in wheat to the extent of $46.7 million worth. That is what I would describe as a luxury.
Comment on this
Naturally, we hope to get revenue from tobacco. Nobody is compelled to smoke tobacco.
Comment on this
It is a luxury. Nobody is compelled to smoke tobacco. I hope the people will continue to smoke it so far as I am concerned. I hope they will be patriotic enough to continue to smoke and to understand that in smoking they are helping to do the things which I have enumerated in the course of my remarks. If they do that they will be doing what I would consider to be a patriotic action.
The same thing applies to expenditure on petrol, motor vehicles and any of these other things that could very easily be avoided but the fact of the matter is that out of the $148,000,000 only $6.9 million was spent on providing means by which industries could have been established.
Comment on this
If three or four times that amount had been spent on bringing in machinery and establishing industries, we surely would be providing something for our people, we surely would be providing an income for the nation but they did not do that. I would like to say to the people, through this House, that, if we are left here long enough, we will do what the Coalition Government failed to do by reason of the fact that they could not coalesce.
Comment on this
Can the Minister explain how it was that the Government of which he was previously a member in 1947 sent E. C. A. a different story from the one he has now given?
Comment on this
The first thing I would like to deal with is the resentment the Minister for Defence showed at references from the Opposition side to the fact that this Budget if not actually dictated was certainly influenced by Mr. Butler, the Chancellor of the British Exchequer. I was not one of those who made any of these charges but let me say—let the Minister for Defence try to get around it if he likes —that four significant points emerged round about the 1st April last. The first significant point was a visit to Mr. Butler by the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce—a visit, by the way, about which we got no explanation in this House other than that our charming Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce went over to see whether Mr. Butler's health was all right. They went over to exchange views.
The second significant point, if Mr. Butler had no influence on the Budget, was the fact that our Minister for Finance sent a letter of encouragement promising support and various other things to the Chancellor of the British Exchequer on the day on which he was reading his Budget speech in the British House of Commons.
The third significant point that emerges is that the date of our Budget was stepped back a full month from the first Wednesday in May, which is the normal time for introducing the Budget, to the first Wednesday in April. Funnily enough, the same thing happened in England.
The fourth and final point is the remarkable similarity between the two Budgets, each of which was determined to put on taxes of a certain kind on the working people, small farmers and such.
I am not one of those who like to be guilty of making charges. I never referred to this matter before but when I find the Minister for Defence waxing wroth about the very natural, very correct, concern of certain Deputies on this side of the House when they see what they fear is a tendency towards dictation from the other side of the water, then I will say that no amount of frowning from the Government Benches will prevent us—me at any rate—from expressing my concern. I do not go around wearing my patriotism on the lapel of my coat for everybody to see, but I would like the Minister and his colleagues in the Government to understand that, while we do not go about flag-wagging, beating drums and telling the people what great patriots we are, we will keep a very close eye on what is happening and, like the Gobán Saor long ago, we will hold what we have got. We will certainly question any trend towards dictatorship from the other side of the water in the management of our affairs. It took us a long time to get where we are to-day—to get the management of our affairs in our own hands—and, having got it, we will hold it.
I would like to point out the deliberate misrepresentation by the Minister for Defence when he said that the inter-Party Government had spent the Marshall Aid loan counterpart fund dollars in a certain way. You would imagine from what the Minister for Defence said that nobody ever purchased leaf tobacco in the United States for dollars before. He mentioned petrol also. Even the most backward person down the country knows that if these things were not consumed in large quantities in this country the whole economy of the State, of the Department of Finance at least, would be upset. Tobacco gives some £22,000,000 in revenue, if I remember the Minister's figures correctly. Petrol also gives a fairly high yield. Petrol and tobacco were both paid for in dollars before ever Marshall Aid came here.
Comment on this
The Minister cannot fool us that way. We know quite well that, if Marshall Aid had never come, there was a certain allocation of dollars to this country from the dollar pool. When water from two different sources is poured into one vessel it is very hard to tell from which source a particular spoonful has come.
Comment on this
I know that the Minister does not like his misrepresentations and tricks to be laid bare. Nothing will stand on its own legs without a prop but the truth. If the Minister and his colleagues had not resorted to these tricks and capers in order to hoodwink the people there would be no need to prop them up, no need for them to get hot under the collar when these props are pulled away from under them.
Notwithstanding all this, I have a certain sympathy with the Minister. This sympathy arose when I heard Deputy Cogan calmly supporting certain proposals which the Minister put forward. I thought of three and a half or four years ago when the Deputy was abusing the present Minister for Finance in what I would say was a very nasty manner, a manner with which I would not agree, using innuendoes and insinuations which, with all the Minister's faults, were really unfair to him. I have a certain amount of sympathy with the Minister when I see him having to sit down and listen to this chameleon who has changed his coat so often.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan need not mind what I did. I do not want my earlier remarks to be interpreted as an attack by me on the Deputy. I do not believe in attacking any Deputy but I believe in my right to criticise what I think to be wrong actions on the part of any Deputy. Even in the case of a Deputy of my own Party I reserve that right to criticise. The Minister for Defence referred to an attack by Deputy Flanagan on certain Independents. I think that we have the right, I think that any person with any spark of decency has the right to criticise, to shame any Deputy who deliberately goes back on a policy which he has stated and which he has had pasted up in posters on every telegraph pole and blank wall in his constituency. In saying this, if I have done nothing else but at least to scare Deputies who might have the intention of turning their coats, then I have done a certain amount of good and there is no need for the Minister to object to it. I personally take no pleasure in it. In a sense I do not think it is my business except to criticise as a deterrent——
Comment on this
I do not agree that abuse ever gets anywhere. It serves no purpose. I hope that the Deputy is not calling fair criticism for a good purpose abuse. If he does then it is his own business. He is free to do that if he likes. I am not referring to any member of any Party, but if a Deputy goes forward on a set policy which he thinks right and has it posted up in his constituency and if he gets votes from the people by such a policy and then a short time or even a long time after he comes into the House he goes back on that policy, I would say that the Dáil is better without that person. While I do not agree with abuse, I, for one, think that it would be wrong for us calmly to sit here and by our very silence condone such coatturning. When I say that I do not mean any offence. I hope that no Deputy thinks that I am being offensive in that. My reason for speaking is that I took it from the remarks of the Minister for Defence that he held that we should criticise only if he allowed us to do so.