Finance Bill, 1952—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 196–371 of 371. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 12 of 1952 ›
I doubt if it would be fair to the Minister for Defence. He did not add the last part. That is an interpolation of Deputy Cowan's.
Comment on this
The Minister should not be misquoted. He is not here to speak for himself and it is very unfair to him.
Comment on this
Deputy Seán Flanagan referred to Deputy Costello and said that he should rely on facts not on speculation, referring, I presume, to the proposed removal of some of the impositions which this Budget places on the people.
I have only one more remark to make in that connection. The people of this country know very well that when Deputy Costello was Taoiseach he had to remove unjust and unnecessarily harsh impositions which were imposed by the very same man who was Minister for Finance then and also holds that office now. There is no answer to that.
Deputy S. Flanagan referred to the Undeveloped Areas Act. I say to the Deputy that if he would take up the question of the reduction in certain Estimates with his Minister for Finance it would do a lot of good to the areas where the Undeveloped Areas Act cannot operate. I am referring to the cutting down in the Estimates for forestry and for local authority drainage, but I do not mean to dwell too long on this question. I would like to know the reason for all this chiselling down on land reclamation. I do not believe it was done because of lack of money, but because it was out of Deputy Dillon's brain the scheme came. It is second only to the Tennessee Valley authority scheme in the United States as regards land reclamation.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance can afford to smile, being a man who has never known what it is to have been blistered by paying rent and rates on land which has been rendered virtually useless through flooding. I can assure the Minister for Finance that if he talked to four out of five of my neighbours in Mayo, Galway, Donegal, Clare and Kerry, and even in the Midlands, he would not smile at their problems. There are very few counties, due to the geological shape of the country, which are not scourged by flooding.
There has been a lot of talk about emigration. Emigration has increased since the change of Government last June. Another change has come about also, and that is that from now on we will, apparently, have no means of checking the emigration figures owing to the abolition of the travel permit system. I am glad to see that that annoyance has been removed from all those who seek to travel into or out of this country. At the same time I would like if there were some means of knowing exactly how many boys and girls leave this country annually.
Comment on this
There was no exact means of knowing but I would say that the estimate was certainly right to within a few hundreds.
Comment on this
Emigration had increased. Speaking as one who comes from a county where, unfortunately, emigration has to be prevalent, I would like to put on record that the speeches which were made last August and September by Ministers, particularly the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance, were definitely interpreted by many youngsters in many parts of the country in the West of Ireland as a signal to "hop it", and to go while the going was good.
Comment on this
That is right. Certainly gloomy speeches from our Ministers accelerated the speed of any of them who had doubts about going. They soon made up their minds during the time we were hearing speeches about a crisis and so on. The complete about-turn which the Minister for Industry and Commerce made when the Dáil assembled on the 1st October, in which he reversed all that and went back on the speeches which he and his colleagues had made, did not stem the outward flow or dispel the gloomy pessimism which they had succeeded in establishing.
I have not the slightest doubt about the fact that most or nearly all of the impositions of this Budget are unnecessary. Deputy Cowan, as short as he is in this House, knows enough, I am sure, about the running of the country to realise that the removal of the subsidies was not called for.
Comment on this
I do not think that the extra taxes on petrol, tobacco and drink were all called for. Some slight adjustment may have been necessary, as there may have been an increase in wages and so forth, but the wholesale succession of sledge-hammer blows which the Minister for Finance delivered to us in his speech were uncalled for. Deputy Cowan knows enough about the finances of the country, and he has got enough information from Deputies on all sides of the House who have tabled parliamentary questions to elicit statistical information of a very valuable kind, particularly since the Budget. Any schoolboy out of the sixth standard who takes a pencil and paper must know that the charge made from this side of the House that a sum of £9,000,000 has been included in the Budget which is not needed for the running of the country in the coming financial year is correct. That must be apparent to everybody.
Comment on this
There is. Let me say to Deputy Cowan that whether or not there is truth in it, there is the very significant fact that the Minister for Finance has not justified it, and has failed to answer that charge. Deputy Cowan, I believe, knows that one of the principal reasons for the imposition of these unnecessary taxes is to deny the people of this country, and when I say the people of this country I am referring to the small farmer and to the working class people, £9,000,000 extra purchasing power. The net effect of this is that there will be £9,000,000 of agricultural produce—our own produce to which nobody but ourselves has a better right—denied to our people.
Comment on this
The Minister had two alternatives. One was to impose taxes, and the other was to sell this country to America for dollars.
Comment on this
The tinkers in their camps on the sides of the road are laughing at that joke. We cannot fool the people with that kind of answer.
Comment on this
The Minister is a very quiet man these times. He has become so dignified now that he will not even reply to an interruption.
Comment on this
Captain Cowan and all other Deputies must be aware of that fact. The people of the country are aware that the tax has been put on in order to help to restore the balance of trade to a great extent by either reducing imports or increasing exports on the other hand. If Deputies look at the speech I made last November when speaking on the Supplies and Services Bill they will see that I warned the Tanáiste, who at the time had been speaking inside and outside the House about increasing our exports, that if increasing our exports meant denying to our people some of the food to which they were entitled or lowering our standard of living I would have something to say about it. That has happened, and Deputy Cowan is well aware of it. I want to see our agricultural and industrial exports exceeding the amount we are importing.
Comment on this
I want to see that happening but, at the same time, I want to see the standard of living which our people have attained, maintained, and I do not want to see fathers and mothers of growing children denying to their families something we are producing at home, let it be a bit of beef, potatoes, butter or milk. For the sake of filthy lucre we are selling these commodities in England and in other countries in order to balance our trade and we are denying to our growing children the first-class food which we are producing in abundance.
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil Deputies should not be making a joke of this. I know of one town in my constituency where the mothers of families went down on their knees and cursed that man across there. Now, will the Fianna Fáil Deputies smile?
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan should cease interrupting. Since I took the Chair he has continued to interrupt.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not speaking. He should not interrupt in the continuous way he is interrupting.
Comment on this
I cannot let Deputy Davin make the statement that Deputy Cowan was let away with a lie.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is charging Deputy Cowan with telling a lie I cannot allow that statement.
Comment on this
I do not want to hear what he said. Deputy Davin will withdraw the statement that Deputy Cowan was guilty of a lie.
Comment on this
The Deputy will withdraw the statement. I cannot allow a Deputy of the House to be charged with telling a lie.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin will withdraw the statement or leave the House.
Deputy Davin withdrew from the Chamber.
Comment on this
I want to see exports, both agricultural and industrial, increased until we are in the happy position that we will be exporting more than we are importing. I think we are all agreed on that. There has been a growing amount of adverse criticism here on many occasions to the effect that farmers in this country are not producing as much out of the land as they used to, and even in the editorials of certain of our daily papers we read that the farmers are not pulling their weight in the matter of paying taxes—I presume it is income-tax that is in question. However, I will not go into that.
Let us take first the theory that the land of this country is not producing as much as it used to. What is the yardstick by which the return of agricultural production in this country is measured? For the information of Deputy Cowan and Deputy Cogan the principal yardstick is the amount that is exported. It must be apparent to anybody that, particularly since 1948, the amount of home-produced food consumed in this country has increased enormously. My comment on that is, more power to the people of this country; they are able to buy and use their own production. But I will not let any Deputy away with it that the land of this country is not producing as much as it used to or that the farmers, let them be big, middling or small farmers, are not working or producing as much. They are producing more, but we ourselves are consuming much more of our own production, and everybody must be well aware of that.
The second remark I want to make in connection with that is: What has our present Government done to induce the farmers or to assist farmers to increase production? One of the most outstanding things that has happened is that fertilisers, one of the mainstays of our agricultural economy, has been increased from £5 to £9 a ton, and I noticed that Deputy Cogan, who claims to be an Independent representing farmers, did not raise his voice in protest. He never put down a parliamentary question——
Comment on this
The facility with which Deputy Cogan can try to clothe himself with sanctity at times just leaves me cold. "It was not due to Government action." That is most interesting, and I am thankful to the Deputy for such a piece of enlightenment. Was it beyond the Government's power to subsidise fertilisers so that farmers could obtain them at a reasonable price? It amounts to this, that you can take up any attitude you like and try to defend it. I was disgusted during the 20 minutes or half-hour that you were speaking.
Comment on this
Deputy Blowick should address the Chair and not be addressing Deputies across the floor of the House.
Comment on this
There was no protest, particularly from Deputy Cogan, when the rate of interest on loans to farmers —I know it is a subject very dear to the Deputy's heart, because he is always advocating loans for farmers— was increased from 4½ to 6 per cent. There was not a word about that.
Comment on this
Could the Deputy tell me? He is such a mine of information and I am such an absolute blockhead that I do not know anything about these things. Perhaps he would tell me. Whoever is responsible for it, all these things go to reduce or at least to discourage agricultural production in this country. If those people are right who hold that the farmers are not paying income-tax, that they are rolling in wealth, that they are simply living on the fat of the land, why are so many people leaving the land? One remarkable thing emerges out of this criticism, that we never heard such criticism from anybody who ever had anything to do with the land. It is mostly from people who know no more about how those who live on the land make a living than the man in the moon.
Comment on this
We hear it from people who would be highly indignant if you suggested that they should interest themselves in a plot or garden they have themselves and whose chief agricultural contribution in the garden is nettles and thistles. Why are so many people flying from the land if the land is such a mine of wealth as it is supposed to be? Why is it that one-half of the year we are crying about the flight from the land; then the Minister for Finance in the springtime comes in here and the Budget is looming ahead; everybody is wondering where the money is going to come from and trying to find a scapegoat. I notice that for the last two or three years the scapegoat is more and more the farmer of this country.
Any farmer whose valuation is above a certain figure receives his full share of attention from the income-tax officials, just as any civil servant, shopkeeper or other business person. There is no escape. These officials will see whether he is running his land at a loss or at a profit or whatever position he is in, and he has just got to pay his bill. My advice to Deputies is this. If you know of any farmer who should be paying income-tax and who is evading it, I do not think you have the right to cloak him.
Comment on this
That is the point that was made from these benches that the farmer should be subjected to the same examination as the salaried man.
Comment on this
That carries the implication that the farmer is not subjected to the same examination. The farmer is just as liable and he is just as amenable to the laws of this country, including the income-tax laws, as any other citizen, and I resent the implication that the farmer by hiding away in a burrow is escaping it or dodging it in some way. He is not. Most of the farmers in this country are leaving the land. One of the problems with which we are faced is that while the older people are content to stay on the land and work it, the sons of these people are not satisfied to do likewise. They will go to the towns and cities in England and in this country because life there is much more attractive. It is cleaner and brighter and the pay is far better. This situation is creating a vacuum which is sucking our young boys and girls away from the land. Although we have a Department at the moment which is there to relieve congestion in certain parts of the country and to settle what is known as the land question, I can easily see in a short time the policy of the Government and the Department being put absolutely into reverse and the problem will be to find people who will live on the land. Any Deputy who will not subscribe to that does not know his rural Ireland whatever about his urban Ireland.
The impositions in this Budget have been dealt with in full and there is nothing to be gained by repeating what was said. Might I ask the Minister, however, if he chooses to sweep away the food subsidies what provision does he intend to make for some classes of the community? Amongst these classes are the small farmers rearing a family who are getting no relief under this Budget. Then there are the old age pensioners. I do not want the Minister to tell me that he is increasing the old age pension by 1/6 because I told him before that that was an insult. Then there are those who are out of employment and genuinely seeking work and cannot get it. What provision will be made for these people and their families? I would not like to think that the Minister sat down calmly and made provision for a lot of heavy imposts in this Budget without considering the consequences to very many sections of the people. What does he propose to do about these people and what provision is being made to relieve the load which will descend on them after the 1st July? These are but a few classes, and each of these classes comprises a very large number of people. I want an answer to these questions. I will not deal at any length with what was the supreme joke of the Budget, and that is calmly to remove the dance tax, which was bringing in a revenue of £140,000, and plank that sum on to the bread and butter of the people.
Comment on this
It was, and the people down the country know the explanation. It may be argued that £140,000 is not very much.
Comment on this
The argument was that the all-in wrestlers are taxed and, therefore, the dancers would be.
Comment on this
What about the shame of it? This was a tax on amusement which was not felt by anybody, despite Deputy Cogan's solemn assurance that dancing should be made free and as cheap as possible. That is all right if making provision for cheap dances does not bring hunger to homes where there are young growing children. If that is Deputy Cogan's idea of justice and of distributing the burden of taxation equally on the people, then God forbid that he will ever be a Minister for Finance. It would mean the sounding of the last trumpet for the few remaining people in the country to clear out in time.
I asked the Minister for Finance, when replying to the debate on the General Resolution, to state what has been done with the £26,000,000 worth of dollars which the inter-Party Government left after them and which came into his hands. Great play has been made with the fact that the inter-Party Government accepted Marshall Aid and thereby incurred debt. Let me remind the Minister for Finance and other Deputies who have been a long time in this House that the tail-end of every Budget speech introduced since 1932 was: "This leaves a deficit of so many millions which must be met by borrowing". I challenge any Deputy to produce a Budget from 1932 to 1947 in which the statement was not made by the present Minister in the early days of the Fianna Fáil Administration, later on by his Excellency the President when he was Minister for Finance, and in the years from 1945 to 1947 when Deputy Aiken was Minister for Finance: "This leaves a deficit which must be met by borrowing". These words must be familiar by now to the ears of Deputy Dillon and other Deputies. I have been here since 1943 and that statement was one of the first that I heard. We have been blamed for accepting Marshall Aid. We offer no apology for it. If, according to Fianna Fáil, it was wrong to accept Marshall Aid, why did not the Minister for Finance pay back the £26,000,000 or try to relieve the debt on the country? Will he tell us what has become of it? It is a tidy sum and the people are wondering into what boghole that £26,000,000 has vanished.
Comment on this
When the next general election comes about and the Minister goes down the country the farmers will tell him very soon what they think about Deputy Dillon and what they think about him. The Minister will not be one bit flattered by what they will tell him. The General Resolution was only passed by the narrowest of majorities; I think the voting was 72 to 69. I am no lover of the turmoil of a general election; I do not want one. This Budget, however, has gone back on the 17-point programme of Fianna Fáil, particularly item 15, and on the Minister's own assurance in Rathmines that it was all nonsense to suggest that they would reimpose the taxes on tobacco and drink. In view of the reception that the Budget has got I say that the Government had no authority to impose all these taxes without consulting the people. If we left this mess which we are supposed to have left behind us, why did the Minister and the Taoiseach and his fellow Ministers cloak that mess and not reveal it? Why did you save us? We never asked you to do it. We did not want you to save us. Why did you not reveal it when the financial business——
Comment on this
When the financial business was concluded last summer, why did you not dissolve the Dáil and say: "This crowd have left such and such behind them. In order to set that right, next April or May we will have to introduce a Budget and we are telling you in time what we have discovered—that we will have to remove the subsidies from food and to reimpose the taxes on tobacco, drink and petrol"? Of course the Minister could have kept the remission of the dance tax up his sleeve. Why did not the Taoiseach and the Ministers go before the people in the autumn and tell them about the shocking mess they discovered these inter-Party scoundrels left behind them? Has the Minister become so genial and so generous that he wanted to save our reputation and to let us down lightly?
I say to the Ministers in all seriousness that they have absolutely no authority from either God or the people to introduce such a Budget without consulting the people. I hope we realise that we get all our authority from God in the first instance. I say that you have no authority to introduce such a Budget without consulting the people. At this late hour the correct thing to do, in view of the voting on the General Resolution, is to consult the people about it. If the people say that the present Government are right that will be all right with me, whether I am returned or not, and no matter what position I shall hold after the election.
Comment on this
Before addressing myself to the Finance Bill, I want to protest against your ruling, Sir, in ordering Deputy Davin from the House.
Comment on this
The Deputy has no right to protest against my ruling in this fashion. If he wants to raise the question of my ruling there is a perfectly legitimate method of doing it. He can do it, and I invite him to do it.
Comment on this
The Deputy is disputing the instructions of the Chair. The ruling of the Chair may not now be challenged in the House. There is a perfectly regular method of challenging the ruling of the Chair. The Deputy can do that if he wishes.
Comment on this
I want to repeat, for the third time, that I will take whatever steps are necessary with the Committee on Procedure and Privileges, if needs be, to protest against the action taken in respect of a Deputy of this House——
Comment on this
I must ask the Deputy to discontinue the discussion of the ruling of the Chair in this connection. There is a perfectly legitimate way of challenging the ruling of the Chair. The Deputy can have recourse to that method if he wishes, but he cannot challenge my ruling here now.
Comment on this
Very well, I shall do that. During the course of his speech, the Minister for Defence, Deputy Traynor, complained that Deputy Davin made various statements without any verification whatsoever. I did not hear the Minister for Defence or anybody else complain of the totally unwarranted accusations made by Deputy Cogan against Deputy McGilligan, the former Minister for Finance. Among other things, Deputy Cogan accused Deputy McGilligan of corruption, bribery and deceit. He made these charges without any attempt whatsoever to justify his scandalous statements. We have known Deputy Cogan for many years in this House as the very shadowy Minister for Agriculture.
This afternoon he was more in the order of a shadow Minister for Finance. He told the House what he considered should be done and could be done. I do not care what Deputy Cogan does when he is Minister for Finance in that future Government, but when he referred to the weaknesses of democracy he was, in fact, making a case against himself. If he had used the word "infliction" it would have been a very good description of himself. It would be an infliction on any Parliament to have a man of the type of Deputy Cogan come in and make statements of the kind he made this afternoon without any question whatsoever, without being challenged and without making any attempt to prove his accusations against Deputy McGilligan, the former Minister for Finance.
Much has been said about the Budget and the Finance Bill and perhaps there is not very much more which remains to be said. However, everything which has been said against the Budget in this House is but a pale reflex of the indignation which is felt by the people throughout the length and breadth of the country in relation to the infliction of unnecessary extra taxation on them. The Government case, I take it, is that though the Budget is severe it is necessary for the financial health of the people and that the extra taxation would not be imposed if it were not necessary. The people are slow to accept that viewpoint. I do not think the Government have given any satisfactory reasons for this Budget. Though the inter-Party Government was in office for three and a half years, they did not find it necessary to impose additional taxation. In fact, they remitted the taxation which was imposed by the Fianna Fáil Government in their Supplementary Budget of 1947 and gave back to the people the extra money which was being filched from them by the then Fianna Fáil Minister for Finance. In addition to all that, the inter-Party Government increased social services. Employment increased and there was a greater measure of prosperity in the country.
The inter-Party Government made a really constructive effort to put the country on its feet by investing moneys in the land through the Dillon plan for land rehabilitation. At a period when there is a world shortage of food it is obvious that increased agricultural production is essential. The wealth of our country is in our land, and by reinvesting our money in our land and improving it and making it richer, we are providing ourselves with the most effective means of self-support. The question now arises whether or not we are applying the right method now. My own view is that surely the best method is to reinvest our money in our land by way of fertilisers, removing rocks and scrub, and revivifying the soil. The Taoiseach did not like the application of the land rehabilitation scheme to Connemara. He said at the Árd Fheis that it was foolish to take money from the Bank of London for the purpose of removing rocks in Connemara and throwing them into the sea. I do not agree with this point of view. I should like to see bulldozers at work in Connemara, just as in other parts of the country. If it is possible, with the aid of modern machinery, to rescue five, six or ten acres in Connemara for the people who live there, I think that even that small amount of land would mean more to these people than a very good farm in Limerick or elsewhere in Munster. The provision of fertilisers and modern farm machinery would, in my opinion, yield a better result than to leave our money in the Bank of London.
The Taoiseach said that the object of this Budget is to restore the £150,000,000 or the £160,000,000 which was drawn from the Bank of London and invested in this country. He said that that money should not have been withdrawn. That money began to pile up during the emergency when it was not possible for us to obtain goods from Britain in return for what we exported to her. The Taoiseach said that that money must be restored to the Bank of London and that, to do so, we must tighen our belts, eat less and export more. That is the confidence which this Fianna Fáil Government has in the future of this country. No matter where the money might come from, I think that, in our circumstances, there is no better way of using it than to invest it in the land and place our confidence in the soil to produce richer yields of crops. I do not see how it is possible to obtain increased production if our unemployment figure increases. I believe that this Budget will create greater unemployment. There has been an increase of 13,000 in the number of unemployed since this time last year. The rate of emigration has accelerated and I believe that it will intensify.
The Minister for Defence spoke of bank credit restriction this afternoon. Notwithstanding the total overall figures which he quoted, every section of the community is aware that bank credit restriction is taking place. I should be interested to know the actual context to which the overall figures quoted by the Minister actually relate. I brought at least one glaring case of credit restriction to the notice of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and I could bring plenty more. Credit has been restricted and that has resulted in business being restricted. Unemployment is bound to follow. What can we expect from this Budget but greater unemployment and more emigration? From the talk which we have heard from the Government one would think that the bailiffs were standing at the door. Even if they were there, I should let them wait until we were able to provide more employment for our people and in that way increase production. I believe that that would be the way to meet them—and not by putting back into the Bank of London the £150,000,000 or the £160,000,000 which was invested in the soil of this country. I sincerely hope that the workers will not stand for that state of affairs. They have already had too much of it.
The Taoiseach has his own method of making economics. Whenever the cost of living rises, in times of war or peace, he pegs down wages. That is what he did during the emergency. He told me, when I was a member of the Trade Union Congress, that he could not possibly allow the workers to continue to get wage increases, to the exclusion of other people, when there was only a limited supply of goods available on the market. That was his answer. We asked him did he seriously think that he could peg wages down and allow prices to rise until they had gone beyond control— prices had gone up 26 per cent. at that time, and they rose eventually to 100 per cent. or to 150 per cent. above the pre-war level—whilst the people whose earnings he tried to restrict here at home were allowed to go freely to Britain to earn all they could there and send home their earnings to compete against the purchasing power of our people for the limited supplies available on the markets here at home.
The Budget enacted in this Bill is another standstill wages Order. Some increases in wages have taken place, and I notice a statement of the Taoiseach and some other Ministers that wages had caught up with prices. That would seem to be a kind of mortal sin. I believe that wages should always have been kept on the same level as prices, but the position was that wages had to toil slowly up the spiral and seldom succeeded in getting up to the price level. Even before this Budget was introduced, wages had not succeeded in keeping pace with prices, as the figures given by the Trade Union Congress show, and demands were already being mooted by various unions for further wage increases.
Now, provided with this further incentive, the workers feel that substantial wage increases are absolutely necessary if they are to maintain the standard of living they have at present. I, for one, sincerely hope that they are not going to allow the standard of living which they at present enjoy to be reduced at the dictation of any Minister for Finance. I hope that they will assert their right to that standard of living which, after all, is only a minimum standard. I see no justification for the Minister's plea that we should eat less and export more simply to achieve the extreme glorification of restoring our foreign credit to the figure at which it stood prior to the advent of the inter-Party Government. It is alleged against that Government that they were guilty of the terrible crime of trying to repatriate some of that credit for the purpose of using it here at home. All I regret is that they did not take more of it home for the same purpose.
I protest against this Budget. I think it is an unnecessary and vicious Budget and that it will have the effect of making more difficult the problem of finding money for internal development. We are told that there is a capital development programme of £35,000,000 which must be got from the current savings of the people. How are we going to get it? You have increased the cost of everything—food, tobacco and cigarettes—the people are in the habit of using and these increases must inevitably reduce the purchasing power of the working-class community. The reduction in that purchasing power has been already felt in the textile trade and it will be felt in future in an ever-widening circle. Robbing our people of their purchasing power means that we are interfering with the development of industry internally and at the same time, by creating unemployment, preventing our people producing goods for export. I repeat that this is an unnecessary and vicious Budget, and I feel sure that when an appeal is made to the people they will give their answer on it most effectively.
Comment on this
I have been listening for the last two days to the most dishonest statements that have ever been contributed to a debate in this House since I became a member.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not have been at the two-day meeting of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
I want to put it to the House: Would any political Party in this or any other country try to impose extra taxation unless it was necessary? I do not suppose that in any country in the world any political Party would propose increased taxation unless it was necessary. The Minister, just the same as I and every other member of the Party, has to go before the people.
Comment on this
We have to answer too to the people for any stand we have taken in the past. It would be a very popular thing for us as a Party to bring in a dishonest Budget, such as the previous Government introduced before they left office. I ask anybody to consider the implications of a Budget such as this for our Party as a whole, particularly at a time like this when our Party is not as strong as it was some years ago. Ordinary human frailty at a time like that would suggest the doing of the dishonest thing, to bring in a Budget, dictated by expediency, that would be popular with everybody, or at least with the majority of voters in our respective constituencies. As a national Party, however, we felt that we should do the honest thing, no matter how unpopular it was, even if we were to fall by the wayside. The history of our Party shows that we have always tried to do the honest thing.
It is all very well to say that this is a vicious and a bad Budget but we were forced into the position of having to introduce this Budget. There was no alternative open to us if we were to have any regard for the economic stability of the country and for the welfare of future generations. Were we to introduce a more lenient Budget, we would be failing in what we have always believed, as a Party in this House, that we are here to represent the interests of all sections of our people, irrespective of class or creed, and to do the best for the people at all times. Hence, the Minister for Finance had to do the unpopular thing to save the country. I heard Deputy Costello, the former Taoiseach, and a man who is definitely an eminent lawyer, get up here and try to prove that the Minister for Finance was looking for more money than he required. Surely Deputy Costello does not imagine that the people of Ireland are so dull as to believe that the Minister for Finance would ask for a halfpenny more than he requires? We, as a Party, are doubly sure that the Minister would not ask for one halfpenny more than his advisers tell him is necessary. It was saddening to hear a man, who occupied the responsible position of Taoiseach at one time, taking up the time of this House on two occasions trying to put over on the Dáil the most dishonest misrepresentation to which it has had to listen, since I became a member of this House. If Deputy Costello had said: "You can tax this, that or the other and can put down certain social services and we can rig the ship of State some other way," then Deputy Costello would have been doing the honest thing. Instead, we have had this play-acting of his, trying to show that he could cut down £1,000,000 every minute, or words to that effect.
We have had to do very unpopular things in the national interest during our term of office. We have had to put up with misrepresentation of a gross and grave character. We found the Opposition at that period playing the game of another country and we are finding it so again to-day. I sat for a long time last night listening to one Deputy over there, who was making actually a Fianna Fáil speech, though he did not know it. He was talking about a way in which imports had increased during the second six months of last year. Of course imports increased.
Surely Deputies opposite did not expect that when we went in in June we would be able to set wheat and reap it in August? Imports increased because of the policy of the inter-Party Government in letting production go down. As a result of that policy, we found we had to do unpopular things. It is a popular thing for the Opposition to try to work up feelings against this Party and against this Government. It is the easiest thing in the world to do.
Comment on this
But when you have to face it from a practical viewpoint, you expect the ex-Ministers of the inter-Party Government to be able to make some constructive contribution. Instead, they carry out the same tactics as they found successful before in putting over on some of the people gross misrepresentation of the facts. May I ask some members of the Opposition why they have so often here taunted us with the Central Bank Report? Why should the independent members of the Central Bank make any report but an honest one on the finances of the country? They are definitely independent men, each and every one of them, men of outstanding integrity. The whole substance of their report was that we should produce more, export more and import less. It is the same headline as that adopted by all successive nations, not alone this one, that want to carry on with success. They know they must produce more, export more and import less. That is the kernel of the economic outlook of our nearest neighbouring nations and of other successful countries throughout the world. A system of barter under trade agreements has been adopted, where one country agrees to supply the other with necessities. I do not mind very much what the Fine Gael people say or do, as they are capable of saying and doing anything.
Comment on this
I always thought the Labour Party had some political philosophy and some definite outlook, but I changed my mind on that long ago.
Comment on this
I find that, instead of being a Labour Party now, they are just the tail of Fine Gael, with no policy. They say they represent the workers, and we hear a good deal about that from time to time. They have held big meetings and they have tried to tell us what we are, while they are the archangels who would do everything possible. I hope the people of Ireland will realise that this Budget was forced upon us by the dishonesty of the inter-Party Government during the last three years—and two years especially—in not facing up to the facts. By their gross mismanagement of affairs of State, they have allowed this country to slip down economically to what she is to-day. Those who had the responsibility of Government, who should have tried to do their best for the country, mismanaged it instead. They adopted a method of political expediency, putting things off from day to day, and that has left us in the way we are now.
I was sitting on the other benches over there years ago, when Deputy Lemass, now Minister for Industry and Commerce, got up and said to the new inter-Party Government: "We have given you over this country in a sound financial condition"—and there was no adverse report from the Central Bank then—"and we hope that we will get the country over from you in the same condition" We have not got it over in that condition. The only thing we got was: "Put them out; we have the cure for all ills." They have the same dishonest cure as they had in previous years.
Production has gone down. We tried to build up production in the factories and in agriculture, but that trend was gradually killed by the policy of the inter-Party Government. They are trying to put it over on the country that we are doing something we need not do. I hope that the people realise that no Government will put as much as one halfpenny increased taxation unless that increase is necessary. The Minister for Finance has a heavy burden to carry. I hold he is doing the only thing that an honourable Minister could do under the circumstances, and I wish him luck in his job.
Comment on this
At the outset I would like to make it quite clear that I do not intend to speak on high finance. High finance is something away and beyond me. In making that statement, I make no apology to anyone inasmuch as I know that that is a subject which has baffled in the past, and is to-day baffling some of the most reputable financiers in the world. I propose to speak to-night on the realities of life and the effects of them upon the people as a whole.
I was very pleased that the Minister for Finance in his Budget statement gave pride of place to the agricultural industry. The days in which agriculture was not admitted to be our most important industry here have gone. Both sides now recognise that there is only one industry which can save the country, and that is agriculture.
We all know that it is the policy of every Government to increase exports and reduce imports. From that point of view I think we ought to be a very happy people, because ours is one country which can do just that. In every farmyard up and down the country, be it great or small, and in every plot attached to a labourer's cottage, work goes on. The labourer's wife, who feeds two pigs or 20 or 30 fowl, plays her part in building up the agricultural industry.
What are we doing for agriculture? Are we giving it the care and attention we should give it? In any industry that is in need of expansion the board of directors of the particular concern will go out and look for the ways and means of expanding that industry. For years the best land in County Clare was left under water, under scrub and under rocks. It was useless from a production point of view, and it was left in that condition until Deputy James Dillon, as Minister for Agriculture, launched the land rehabilitation project and brought many acres back into production.
The industry is, of course, hampered from the point of view of an insufficiency of manual labour. The youth of our country has left it and successive Governments cannot escape their responsibility in that direction. One of the very few relaxations enjoyed in the rural areas heretofore was a game of cards in a neighbour's house followed by a dance. It was all very fine to tax dancing in the big cities and the towns but unfortunately rural amusements were not always exempt. Indeed, the time came when these places were subjected to police supervision almost as if illicit stills were being operated in them. People were charged and brought into court. The result has been that the young people are fleeing from the rural areas seeking a livelihood and entertainment elsewhere.
The two greatest evils from which we suffer at the present time are emigration and unemployment. These are so closely knit together that the solution of one must inevitably lead to a solution of the other. No Government has kept itself free from blame in regard to these twin evils and every Government must take some responsibility in regard to emigration in particular. It was our ancestors' misfortune 100 years ago to have the emigrant ship calling at our ports. That happened, as we know, under an alien régime. Having secured our freedom and independence, surely we should now be able to devise some system to keep our youth at home.
I have heard a good deal here about external assets. It is a sad reflection that whilst our money is being loaned to outsiders we have no money at home to provide employment. I cannot understand why that money was not repatriated for the purpose of establishing industries here to provide employment for our people. The money that is to-day helping to keep the wheels of English industry turning provides a lure to the bone and sinew of our community, the youth of our country, to cross the water and earn money there that they cannot earn at home.
It has puzzled me for some considerable time as to how we can afford to give a grant of so much per week in order to enable a man to walk around with his hands in his pockets. I cannot understand how we can pay him just to remain idle. Surely we ought to be able to find money somewhere to put him into productive employment. Instead of leaving him as a burden on the people, he should be an asset to the people and to his country.
As regards this Budget, it has been freely admitted, on all sides of the House, to be a hard and a harsh one. I cannot understand, in view of that, how Deputies can get up, even against the dictates of their consciences, and not only vote for it but, as has happened here this evening, advise us on this side to sit down and on no account to criticise it. I am not going to mention any names or to criticise the statements of any speaker. I do not believe in that. My idea is that the man in the street and the people in the country are the best critics of it, and that there can be no doubt that, when the time comes, as it will come some time, they will voice their opinions of this Budget in the silence and the secrecy of the ballot box.
As I have said, it is a hard and a harsh Budget. That is true of it even before it reaches its climax in July. I submit that it imposes great and grave hardships on two sections of our community. I shall take, first, the labouring man, I am not going, as someone across the House has said, to shed crocodile tears, but I am really genuine when I say that the Budget is going to deprive the labouring man of what was to him a beverage and not, on many occasions, a luxury. Even here in the city it is well known that the pint was to him a beverage. It is depriving him of that, but worse than that, it is depriving the publicans of the country of their right to live in it and to carry on a decent respectable business. No matter what may be thought of publicans, I want to say that they are decent people. They must be decent, because they are governed more harshly by the law than any other section of the community. They have to pay licence duty, they cannot open their doors until a certain hour in the morning and, whether they like it or not, they must close them at a certain hour at night. If they fail to obey the law they are brought into court and fined. Speaking from knowledge that I have of two big towns which are situate not far from where I live, I am aware that the sales of the publicans in those towns have already gone down by 50 per cent. and that before the end of the year many of them will have to put up the shutters, never to be taken down again.
I am putting these matters before the House in truth and honesty, and I make those statements without fear of contradiction from any side of the House. In conclusion, I want to remind the House of a saying which, I think, is applicable to the initiators of this Budget, and it is that those whom the gods wish to destroy they first make mad.
Comment on this
I have not very much to say on this Budget. I should like, however, to refer to some of the speeches that were made by the Opposition. Like my friend who has just sat down, I claim to have some knowledge of agriculture. I come from an area in North Tipperary where tillage is carried on on a very extensive scale. I should like to remind Deputy Murphy that during the three years the Coalition Government were in office the number of workers on the land decreased by about 75,000.
I wonder why that should happen? We have heard Labour Deputies complain about the great numbers of unemployed but it is only since this Budget was introduced, or some time before it, that we had the Labour Party, when dealing with this question of unemployment, complaining in this House as to why so much land was allowed to go out of tillage, thereby causing unemployment. Deputy Davin this evening asked how could Fianna Fáil Deputies now go down the country and say: "Up, Dev! Trust him". I can tell Deputy Davin that in more serious times than the present the people who supported Fianna Fáil shouted "Up, Dev!".
Deputy Blowick referred to agriculture and to the question of subsidies for fertilisers. I have been chairman of the county committee of agriculture in North Tipperary, and I know that during the three and a half years the Coalition were in office several requests were made to Deputy Dillon, when he was Minister for Agriculture, to subsidise fertilisers. These requests were supported by all the political Parties on the committee. In view of all the money that was available then, is it not surprising that we did not get some of it to improve our land and put it into good condition? The Marshall Aid moneys were being spent at that time and now we have to foot the bill. Instead of spending some of it in the way of subsidies for fertilisers I understand that $77,000,000 was spent on the wheat and corn which the last Government imported and which we could have, and should have, produced in our own country. We had the labour then to do it.
Deputy Murphy referred to the falling-off in the licensed trade throughout the country. I live fairly near a town and I can say that the licensed trade is not in half as bad a way as some people represent it to be. I do not like the attitude of the Opposition in coming in here and speaking about a general election. I think they should give a little more credit to Fianna Fáil for facing up to the position which confronted them. I know that this Budget is not any great honour to us. It may be severe and it certainly was not brought in for vote-catching purposes. I think that its introduction is a wise thing. As regards our independence, many of our people gave their lives for the freedom we enjoy to-day and they certainly made far greater sacrifices than the sacrifices which we are asking some of our people to make now.
I would appeal to the Deputies on the Opposition Benches to reconsider their attitude on this Budget. I know they will not agree with me because, as regards a lot of them, they seem to think that their only chance is an election. I wonder is it the good of the country they are thinking about when they speak about an election or some good which they think will come to themselves? My opinion is that it is for themselves they are fretting.
Reference has been made to emigration. Deputy Keyes mentioned it a short time ago. Emigration increased from 10,000 in 1947 to 40,000 in 1950. Well, I suppose, as other speakers have said, no Government can take very much responsibility for that. As far as I am concerned myself, I would like to say this, that if we have to face the country, then I, like other Deputies on this side, will be willing to go down if the voice of the people is against me. I would say that the Minister for Finance has shown great courage in putting this Budget before the people. He has taken that responsibility on himself. He has to depend on the votes of working people to a far greater extent than I have. He represents a city constituency. My belief is that the people will agree with him, and will accept this Budget in the spirit of good faith which he has shown in bringing it forward.
Comment on this
I want to protest against the introduction of the hardest Budget that has ever been placed before the people of this country. It will react most unfavourably on those sections of our people who are the hardest workers we have—I mean the small farmers and the workers generally throughout the country, the people who need most a cup of tea, a loaf of bread, a smoke of tobacco and, no matter what we may say against it, a pint of stout. Last August, a pint of stout was 10d. After that barley was slashed to the tune of 9/- a barrel. To-day the pint is 1/2 in the country, 1/3 in the city, an increase of 40 per cent. Deputies will admit that the worker in city, town or country, who is engaged in an exhausting occupation, needs a drink of stout and a loaf of bread. This Budget will undoubtedly react on the small farmers. Methods down the country to-day have changed. To-day we have not the same manpower as we had heretofore. In what way will the Budget react on the tillage contractors and the farmer who is fortunate enough to have a tractor, in the price of petrol? The price of petrol has increased enormously. Costs of production have increased. The price of stout to-day is 10/- a gallon. I cannot understand the mentality of any Minister or Government that thinks new milk is worth only 1/3 or 1/4 a gallon and that a gallon of Guinness's stout is worth 10/-.
In what way will the increase in the cost of everything that is needed for local institutions react on public bodies, urban councils and county councils? Prices have reached enormous heights. In what way will it react on the sorely tried taxpayer?
I was amazed at some of the speeches that came from the Government Benches. I am amazed at any businessman trying to persuade the people that this is a good Budget. Sales have decreased in most cases by 50 per cent. Then they talk about bad housekeeping. The Fianna Fáil Budget, in 1951, was £109,000,000. In 1947 the Budget was £60,000,000. These are the people that speak about bad housekeeping.
It was rather strange to hear a Deputy of the calibre of Deputy Dr. Browne speaking about agriculture and commenting on it and telling the people that farmers hold their land only in trust. I wonder did he ever hear much about the battering-ram or the crowbar brigade. I wonder did he ever read much about the great fight that Michael Davitt, John E. Redmond and honest John Dillon had to put up for the tenant farmers.
Comment on this
I had to say that much. I am sure there is not one farmer in Deputy Dr. Browne's constituency, and I would be almost sure that he never did a day's work on the land.
Comment on this
As a farmer, I feel pained and ashamed by the speeches made by some of the Independent Deputies. Deputy Cogan represents some type of farmers, but I know that if they are of the calibre of some of the farmers we have in the South, he will be in a sorry position when he seeks re-election.
I appeal to the Minister, even at this late hour, to change the face of that Budget. There is no doubt in the world that that can be done. In perfect honesty, I appeal to him to change it.
Comment on this
If this Finance Bill is voted on to-night and is carried in the House, we take it that all the new taxes as stated in the Budget will be imposed on the community. It was rather interesting to listen to Government speakers and to discover how easily they have taken this serious matter of new taxation. Deputy after Deputy on the Government Benches tried to convey to us and even to the country that they are courageous and that the Minister for Finance is courageous. The Deputy who last spoke on the Government side of the House even told us that the Minister had to secure his election to this House through the votes of the workers in the City of Dublin and suggested that he was a courageous man to take on himself responsibility for the imposition of this extra taxation on various items. What kind of courage is it when a Minister of State imposes this taxation within a short time of being elected to this House, having contributed in no small way towards the election of his Party by various promises, each of them in turn clearly indicating to the people and to his constituents that neither he nor his Party had any intention of reimposing the taxes which were repealed when the inter-Party Government were elected in February, 1948, the penal duties which were imposed by him and his colleagues when they were the Government in the fall of 1947 and which brought about their defeat in this House?
Every Deputy, every candidate of that Party on the other side of the House, throughout the length and breadth of this country indicated in no small way that they had no intention of introducing these taxes, these penal duties, on which the people gave a ver dict as to whether they should be imposed or not, by putting the Government out in 1948. Notwithstanding the fact that he made these promises to the people during his election campaign and in his manifesto on the eve of the election, we find, inside of nine months, that he not only reimposes them but imposes much more severe taxation.
What can the public think of any responsible person in public life, a man who has been about 30 years a member of Parliament and 16 or 17 years a Minister of State, head of various Departments, including the Department of Finance, who, without consideration, goes back on everything he said and now asks this House to endorse his Budget and the Financial Resolutions? His excuse is that the inter-Party Government left behind them a mess much greater than they anticipated. The Minister is continually repeating that. He said it in his Budget statement and again in introducing this Bill.
He made a long speech and tried to convince the public that the inter-Party Government left behind them a very serious mess. If that is so, why has not the Government done either of two things? When they discovered this serious mess, when they realised that they had to go back on everything they said, why did they not face the country some months ago, and put before the country these facts and secure a mandate? If they did not do that, why did they not set up a tribunal and impeach the ex-Ministers for misconduct? There were two ways of achieving their objective—go to the country, the highest tribunal of all, and seek a mandate, or set up a tribunal and impeach the former Ministers for misconduct or failure in their duty if what they said, that the former Minister did not balance the Budget, that he manipulated the figures, that he did everything but the right thing during his years in office, was true. The Minister has failed to reply to some of the ex-Ministers, who stated very categorically that what he was saying was not true, that he was not giving a true version of the situation and that, if returned to office to-morrow morning, they would be able to remit all these taxes and still carry on the affairs of the country, still carry on the industrial development and everything that goes with it.
You cannot have your loaf and eat it. You should have done one or the other of these two things, and I am entitled to ask the Minister, to ask the head of the Government and every Deputy who has spoken or who may speak in this debate, what is preventing them from facing the electorate? If you have the position so clear, why are you afraid to present it to the electorate? Why are you afraid to seek the verdict of the people, the highest tribunal of all, who put us here and can remove us out of this House? We have no say in the matter of how long we are going to be here. Why not face the people and seek a mandate from them? It is unfair and unjust, to say the least of it, to impose the burdens which this Budget imposes.
In all honesty, in all decency and in all fairness, do you think the ordinary man down the country can afford to pay 2/6 for a packet of cigarettes and a box of matches? How is the ordinary man down the country, who may be existing on only a very small income— perhaps working on the roads for three or four months out of the 12 —to get a packet of cigarettes or a pipeful of tobacco or a pint of beer? How is that man to feed his family? How is he to find the extra 17/9 for a ten-stone bag of flour? How is he to rear his kiddies until the end of August when he will go digging potatoes? What have they to live on? Have you ever been to rural Ireland, to the mountainy districts, the rural parts that are congested, where they have no potatoes, where all the seed is in the soil and they have to wait for the potatoes to grow and mature? What are those people to live on? Ask yourself what does the housewife think of this Budget. I know what she thinks of it, apart from politics. I know she thinks that the Government which is about to impose these taxes and to withdraw the subsidies is irresponsible and has given no consideration to the effects which their actions will have. Your own best supporters are saying it.
This is not a political issue; it is much more important than a political issue, because you are taking away their means of livelihood, the food that should be on their tables for the maintenance of their families and putting a barrier between them and the necessaries of life. Are you going to increase their income? Surely you will not suggest that the Social Welfare Bill which will become law in another month or two will provide it? How many down the country are insured workers and how many will benefit from it? They are few and far between and well you know it—much better than I know it, because you have been much longer in public life than I have and, as a married man, the father of a family, you should recognise the seriousness of the situation.
Comment on this
I am addressing the Minister through you, Sir, and asking him to appreciate the seriousness of the situation. This is not a political issue; it is a matter of life and death, a matter of the people going hungry and in need, due to your putting a barrier between their income and the requirements of life.
I cannot understand how Deputies from the constituency I represent— Deputy S. Flanagan, Deputy Moran and others—can stand up here and seek to make a case for this Budget, because they have no case to make. If the inter-Party Government are guilty, you have a way out, but you have no authority whatever to take it upon yourself to impose these burdens on the make-believe that chaos exists in the financial position of this country and that you feel bound to clear it up. If that mess exists, you should have no fear of going to the country, but we have reason to doubt that it does exist. You are only using this as a smokescreen to cover up the intentions you are trying to put into effect. You are deliberately trying to punish the people because they had the audacity to remove a Government in power for 16 years and warning them that, if they dare do it again, that will be the penalty imposed on them every time you and your Party get the chance.
That is the only conclusion I can come to as to the reason for the imposition of this taxation. You are now making them pay for what you consider the sins of the past, the removal of you and your Party from office three or four years ago. We know that, like a general in the field, you are playing for time and hoping that this Parliament will survive for another seven or eight months, so that, at the end of this financial year, you may be in a position, as no doubt you will, because you have a surplus at your disposal, to remit to a great extent some of these penal duties, and can then go to the people as the saviour of the nation, as the one and only Minister who could bring relief, crying crocodile tears because you had to impose this undue burden in the past year, but reminding the people that if they dared put Fianna Fáil out of office, the same burdens will be imposed upon them again in order to clear up the mess that may be brought about by a change of Government.
This is a political trick, as I said in the Budget debate, and surely it is unfair that the ordinary working man and woman, whether in rural Ireland or the City of Dublin, should have to pay for this political trick, for this piece of political manoeuvring, the objective of which is the consolidation of the Party in power. That is the only objective sought to be achieved, and the people have to pay the penalty, because if the Minister had any other explanation or any other way out, he would have no hesitation in facing the country; but he cannot substantiate or prove one iota of what he said with regard to the mess created by the inter-Party Government. I ask the Minister—Deputy Blowick asked him also and he failed to reply—what did they do with the £22,000,000 or £26,000,000 spent since they took office? They talked about the inter-Party Government going on a spree, about spendthrifts and about wasters. Let the Minister tell us where they wasted the money. On what was it wasted? Was it wasted on housing, on hospitalisation, on drainage, on afforestation, on any of the schemes which they undertook during their three years and four months in office? If these schemes are genuine and essential—and they must be since the Minister has retained them and is prepared to finance them to keep them going—then on what did they waste the money? The Minister has got advisers to procure all the information. The information is on the files. The Minister can get them and read them, and thus discover how they spent this money and how they wasted it. It is up to the Minister to let the House know.
Did Deputy Blowick waste money when he bought thousands and thousands of bales of wire to carry on afforestation in an emergency? Some years ago, I remember addressing a question to the Minister for Lands in regard to afforestation. The answer I got was that they could not go ahead with afforestation because they had not the wire and yet Deputy Moran comes along and says that Deputy Blowick spent thousands of pounds on procuring wire. Deputy Blowick anticipated an emergency and knew that in an emergency wire could not be got from abroad. He knew we would want that wire here in order to continue the programme as he was continuing it then. By having the wire that programme would not be hampered and men would not be thrown out of work. He secured machinery and all the necessary essentials to keep that work going if an emergency arose.
Would the Minister disagree with that? Does the Minister think that was waste of money? Why mislead the people about this spending spree and money wasting? What did the Minister do with the £28,000,000. We are entitled to know how he managed to spend £28,000,000 in nine months. The inter-Party Government spent £14,000,000 in 1½ years. There is the comparison. We want to know what the Minister did with the £28,000,000 and what achievements have been carried out.
Comment on this
We did nothing with it except pay your debts. That is where the £28,000,000 went to.
Comment on this
The people do not believe it either. Would the Minister like to test the people?
Comment on this
If those debts existed there was the alternative of impeaching the Minister for Finance or of facing the electorate. The people would give their answer.
Comment on this
I want an explanation from the Minister. I notice that the Irish Press referred to Deputy Dillon and myself as two peculiar Deputies because we opposed the removal of the tax on the dance halls many years ago. Nobody takes much notice of the Irish Press. Nobody takes any notice of the gentleman who writes that piece of political commentary. I think he should have remained in Fleet Street—an upstart who comes into this House in a short few months to criticise Deputies and try to misrepresent them to the people.
Comment on this
You would not be allowed into it. You are a Rathmines rowdy and you should go up there where they will tell you what they think about you.
Comment on this
The Deputy used the expression "a Rathmines rowdy." He will withdraw that expression.
Comment on this
Yes, Sir, if you say so. I withdraw that since it is your ruling. I would like to describe the Minister in much better terms and much more suitable terms if parliamentary procedure permitted me to do so, but I will get other opportunities elsewhere of doing so. What the Minister is is known to everybody outside this House. The Minister is not able to defend himself inside or outside of this House without blackguarding. If I and Deputy Dillon are referred to as being peculiar Deputies because we opposed the withdrawal of taxes on the dance halls some years ago, let me say that we felt we were right then and we are right now.
I believe entertainment is one of the things that should be taxed particularly at a time when we are imposing a tax on essential commodities — bread, butter, tea, sugar, tobacco and beer.
Which does the Minister consider the more humane and the more Christian, to impose a tax on the essentials of life or to impose a tax on entertainment that is carried on to extremes in every city, town and village in Ireland? Some of these people who run these dance halls and ballrooms in the City of Dublin are not Irishmen at all. They are foreigners. The remission of tax is not passed on to the dance fans or to those who patronise these ballrooms. No remission in that way is being granted. The people still pay the same fee to attend entertainment and dances.
The Minister thinks it is much more humane and Christian to impose a tax on the poor housewife with seven or eight children and permit the gentlemen in the City of Dublin, who are living on the backs of these people, to be relieved from tax and from responsibility to the State. He is letting the poor of Rathmines, Dublin, and every town in Ireland pay for these gentlemen and keep them enjoying themselves by keeping these ballrooms going.
We know why they are being relieved. It is because they are good subscribers to the Minister's Party funds. That is why they are being relieved from tax. They are a necessity. They are essential because they keep the Party fund flowing and they are always ready whenever they are required. Therefore, it is much better to help them than help the poor widows and orphans.
They then come along with a miserable 1/6 for the old age pensioner. You would not give that to a child of three years to go out on a message for you. Sweets, value 1/6 now, could be bought for 2d. when I was a boy. Beer, butter, tea and sugar are being increased. They are increasing the price of every requirement that he needs in order to sustain himself. I would like to know how the Minister can stand over that. The Minister may get up and make a long speech defending the Budget, but if he were so strong in his defence of this Budget the place where he would defend it would be on a public platform. We are asking the Minister to do that. Let the Minister not hesitate to do that.
We have no more guarantee of coming back than the Minister has, but we do say that we are opposed to this Budget. Nobody has a right to tax except the people, and the people should be given an opportunity of deciding whether it should be imposed or not. Side by side with this extra taxation, we find the cost of living mounting day in, day out. The Minister's Party were to reduce the cost of living. Every single item to be purchased in the shops has increased—cheese, beans, fats, etc. As a matter of fact, you cannot get a bag of flour at the present moment, as it is being hoarded, and people are waiting for the subsidies to be withdrawn. They are waiting to make the biggest profit. That is the position down the country at the present moment. Is the Minister for Finance aware of that?
Side by side with that, you have unemployment and emigration. You have one thing worse than another so far as the country is concerned. No explanation, no policy to deal with them, no future but a black future, hard work, less to eat, more production—that is the demand and that is the cry.
Many of the Estimates have been slashed, and that indicates less money to spend, less money for development. We have no guarantee that schemes such as housing, forestry or hospitalisation will continue. We are told that they depend on the public spirit of the people in lending money. In fact, the Budget speech was a clear indication that the Minister does not wish the people to assist; in fact, the Budget speech and the speeches of members of the Government during the past six months have been a clear indication to the people not to provide the Government with the necessary capital. The people have no confidence in the present Government. I have no doubt that if a loan were floated to-morrow morning it would not be filled. The sooner the Government face the country, and a Government are elected in which the people would have confidence and which they would be willing to assist, the better for the future of the country.
Deputies in the Fianna Fáil back benches are well aware of that, and the speeches of most of them have been an apology, a request for general absolution for standing behind the Minister and his colleagues in support of this harsh, cruel and unnecessary Budget. The peculiar thing about it is that any Deputy who criticises the Budget or the conduct of the Minister is severely criticised in turn by the organ which represents the Minister and his Party. We are described as "pro-British". All kinds of references are made to us, and we are called names because we are not in line with the Minister's outlook regarding taxation. We do not care how that newspaper describes us. Deputies on this side of the House are just as good patriots and nationalists as Deputies on the other side. In fact, if there were a comparison, I think that they could wear the hat.
I do not see what is wrong in Deputies pointing out the faults in the Budget or where the money could be found if it were essential. There are two or three ways in which the money can be found as an alternative to the present taxes—the reimposition of the tax on dance halls, the introduction of an excess profits tax, and many other untapped sources. I wonder why the Minister did not tap these sources. I suppose that it was the easiest way out; he did not want to be bothered examining these sources; he did not want to put an extra burden on his advisers in finding out how these sources could be tapped to provide this revenue which is essential, according to himself.
If anybody is unpatriotic, if anybody is working for the destruction of this State, if anybody is trying to drive the people out of Ireland, it is the Minister and his Party, not this side of the House. During the years the inter-Party Government were in office sound schemes were in operation; you had employment and decent wages. The Government met by giving increased wages to workers whatever little increase in the cost of living took place—and I say "little" with emphasis—in comparison with the increase which has taken place during the last nine months. Some classes of workers got an increase two or three times during those three years but what increases have been given to workers during the last nine months although the cost of living has increased far more in those nine months than it did during the three years the inter-Party Government were in power? Throughout rural Ireland then and in the City of Dublin it was a rare thing to find men seeking work. Everyone who wished to work was working. There are a number of people, of course, who will always be on the dole—people who do not want to work—but they are few and far between, and those who were anxious to obtain employment could find a variety of work. It was difficult, in fact, to get workers in the Cities of Dublin and Cork and other large towns. It was the same in rural Ireland with regard to drainage and housing. Very few houses were erected in the towns of my constituency over the past 50 years but there is not a town in the constituencies of North or South Mayo where there are not ten or 20 houses approaching completion, and many schemes were completed during the time of the inter-Party Government. We did more in the field of housing and hospitalisation than was done by all other Governments put together. Now there is very little housing development and hundreds of men are unemployed. Joiners and craftsmen are on the dole. They are emigrating to England and leaving their wives and families behind them.
The Minister cannot content himself in allowing the Dáil to go into recess for the summer leaving the country in the state it is in to-day, leaving the people to bear this burden of taxation. I believe that the Minister has yet a degree of sanity, a degree of responsibility, and I do not believe that he would want the House to adjourn for three months leaving the country in this state. I believe that the Minister should, in fairness to himself, to his Party, to the Dáil, and to the country in particular, seek the dissolution of the Dáil at the earliest possible moment. He should not ask us to pass the Finance Bill to-night or to-morrow as it is most unreasonable.
I would ask the back benchers of the Fianna Fáil Party to bring pressure to bear on the Government to dissolve the Dáil and seek the decision of the electorate. This is serious. I know people who, when the food subsidies are withdrawn, will find themselves in a very severe plight and will find it difficult to continue. The general opinion is that, unless something else is done, what has been promised, namely, the 1/6 in the old age pensions and the increase in family allowances, will not be sufficient to offset the increase in the cost of living, never mind the extra taxation. If there was no extra taxation, no withdrawal of food subsidies, this House would be seeking an increase in old age pensions, in family allowances and in assistance. To try to convey to the House and to the country that the increase in family allowances and the 1/6 on the old age pension will, to a great extent, offset the burden imposed by these taxes is to fool no one but yourself, and you are fooling yourself very much.
Most of what has been said here to-day has been said in the Budget debate. I might say a repetition. That repetition might not have taken place if the Minister was more reasonable in the introduction of the Finance Bill, but the Minister again tried to get a little mud to stick on the ex-Ministers and tried to hold them responsible for his mismanagement over the past nine months, for his failure to do what he promised the people he would do. He is now trying to throw the blame over on the inter-Party Government. If that is so, the inter-Party Government and the ex-Ministers in that Government are quite prepared to take up the challenge, not in this House, but in the right place. The Minister should have no hesitation in meeting that challenge if he is so sure of his figures, so sure of what he is trying to make the people believe over the last five or six months.
It is quite natural that he would try to present a bad picture to the House on the occasion of the presentation of his Budget, because he had to justify the campaign that was carried out in the early part of last summer. The present Government had to justify their conduct on the public platforms during the early part of last summer and late autumn. Therefore in the introduction of the Budget it is only natural that the Minister would adopt the attitude he has adopted in order to try to convince the people that what the present Government were saying then was true and that this was the result of it. Of course, the people know well it was not true; this House knows well it is not true; the Minister himself knows it is not true, but he feels if he keeps on saying it is he will eventually get the people to believe it. If he thinks that he is making a mistake. My colleagues and I compose a small farmers' organisation who represent the tenant farmers. We are a small group of Deputies but we claim to speak for a section of the people who are unorganised and who, to a degree, get very little consideration from this Government or any Government. They have sent us here to raise our voices on their behalf and to express their opinions. As a member of that Party I invite the Minister to do the one and only right thing: to seek a dissolution of the House and go to the country. He will then get the mandate which he expected to get but the mandate will be very unfavourable as regards this Budget.
Comment on this
The speech on the Finance Bill, as Deputy Cafferky said, must inevitably cover much of the discussion which we had on the Budget. In listening to the few Fianna Fáil Deputies who displayed courage in taking part in this debate I was interested in noticing the change of tune which their speeches now evidence. When the Budget was first introduced a few, very few, Fianna Fáil Deputies did endeavour to defend the Budget by praising the courage behind it, and all the rest, and the debate on the Budget was a debate along those particular lines.
It seems clear to me, however, from listening to Fianna Fáil Deputies, that they realise that even that particular excuse has not gone down in the country. They realise now—certain of their constituents must have told them —that there is no case possible that can be made for this Budget. This Budget is unjustified and unnecessary, and no excuse, good, bad or indifferent, will be accepted by the people for it. I know that Fianna Fáil Deputies in the last three or four weeks have had that information conveyed to them by their constituents in no uncertain way. I know the Minister has had it conveyed to him at Fianna Fáil meetings. The fact is that the Government, if it can be called a Government, realises that it is representative in no way of public opinion here, that it is following a policy that is disliked intensely by the people of this country. In those circumstances, it is perhaps fortunate that one can get from the present Taoiseach a description of what a Government course of conduct should be in a situation of that kind. I remember—and Deputies will recollect —the present Taoiseach as Deputy de Valera speaking in this House in July, 1951, after the then Government suffered a minor parliamentary defeat on the Estimate for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs, a minor defeat which gave the present Minister an opportunity for much parliamentary eloquence and tilting at parliamentary windmills.
Comment on this
I see the Deputy remembers it well. I am glad for the Deputy's correction; it was in 1949 as the Deputy says. At column 464, Volume 117 of the Official Debates of the 8th July, 1949, the present Taoiseach said:—
"I state, and I believe there is no contradicting it, that those who formed the Government of to-day have not got the authority of the people for doing so. They have got the authority of forming it by virtue of having a majority vote here... It is bad for the country that there should be a Government of that sort in times like the present.... If there was any courage, any real desire to govern in accordance with democratic principles in the hearts of the Government at the present time they would go to the country."
That was the present Taoiseach discussing a snap defeat by the former Government in relation to one of the particular Estimates. He had a lot more to say. At column 461 of the same volume he said, in relation to his views on what a Government led by him would be:
"We did not want to be in office on sufferance. We wanted to be in a position in which we would be able to do the work of the country properly and be able to say that we were the Government by the declared will of the people, tested in the most democratic way; that when we spoke we spoke for the country as a whole. That is not the position to-day."
And I adopt that last sentence. That is not the position to-day. We have in Ireland a Government that has no claim, right, title or interest to speak for the people of this country. We have not in office to-day a Government elected by the people of this country. We have, unfortunately, a Government in office by sufferance, by the sufferance of Deputies like Deputy Cogan, by the sufferance of a diverse tail composed of the flotsam and jetsam of political life. That is the type of Government that is in office to-day and, in those circumstances, the words used by the present Taoiseach three years ago are apt and appropriate to be repeated here to-day. It is proper that his words and his description should be applied to the present political situation and that the Government should adopt his suggestion, once their mandate is doubted, to seek it whence only a mandate can come, from the people of the country.
I mentioned that in relation to the political aspect of the financial proposals contained in the Finance Bill. They are being proposed, as I say, by a Government that is only a passing, or a caretaker Government. The present Minister for Finance will not occupy that office in six months' time, and the situation as regards the caretaker Government is that the people are marking time for a general election. There is no good in blinking facts. It is no use for Fianna Fáil Deputies to be coming in here and blustering about what brave men they all are. There is one way of showing political courage. If this Budget is a courageous Budget, let it be carried courageously before the people of this country. If it is courageous, necessary and believed in sincerely, there is a clear political duty to put it before the people. If that is not done, the most that can be said for the Budget is that it is a courageous Budget, composed by timid men. These facts are known and apparent to all of us.
Apart from the political aspect of the Budget, I want to call the attention of the House to other matters of perhaps more lasting effect which must concern any discussion on this Budget. The political situation can be cured. It will be cured very, very shortly, but permanent damage will, in my opinion, be done to the economic condition and future of the country by the proposals and theories now being put into operation by the Minister for Finance. All of us will recollect, and even the Independent or quasi-Independent Deputies who support the Government will recollect, the horror, amazement and shock which every public person experienced six or eight months ago when the Central Bank Report was published.
We were shocked not so much by the facts and figures there dealt with, because they were available to all of us and all of us knew them, but by the inferences drawn as to the financial and economic position of the country. We were all shocked on all sides of the House when we found an Irish corporation, or banking authority, suggesting as a course of conduct for this State certain matters which appeared to all of us to be completely unjustified and completely unwarranted. When the editor of the Irish Press quite foolishly published an editorial praising the Central Bank Report — of course the managing director got his knuckles rapped for it — it appeared for a while as if the Government were going to accept his proposals. However, a motion of no confidence was tabled by the Leader of the Opposition here in the House and discussed on the 31st October last. There can be no gainsaying the fact that the Tánaiste, who introduced the Second Reading of the Supplies and Services Bill around which the discussion centred, realising the then political situation, determined that the only safe political course to adopt was to discard publicly the Central Bank Report and every recommendation contained in it. Speaking from the seat where the Minister for Finance now sits, he did it in the most vehement, determined and vigorous speech. He held up the Central Bank Report to the Deputies of this House and he said: “This is foreign to us. We will have nothing to do with it. Let nobody think that we will.” All of us heard that. The friendly commentators — friendly to the Government but not to the Irish people — on political matters in the Irish Press praised the Tánaiste the following morning for having pricked the Opposition bubble and deflated the Opposition by publicly disowning the Central Bank Report. That is only six months ago, and surely six months is not such a long time that Governments, Tánaistes or nations can afford to forget major statements of policy.
There is no doubt about it that any financial or economic policy that affects the bread and butter of the ordinary people, their liberty to spend and their liberty to store or consume goods is a matter of major policy. It is unbelievable that anyone should think that we in this House are likely to forget that major statement of policy made by the Tánaiste on the 31st of October last. We will not, but it is well that we should realise what was then in issue and what the Central Bank Report was proposing as the cure for the economic and financial difficulties of the country as the banking authorities saw them.
I only want to deal here with matters very briefly, and just as headings. The first recommendation in the report related to the public works programme and to drainage schemes, such as land reclamation work, rural electrification, hospitalisation, housing and the various capital projects that in recent years had become the boast of the people of this country. The Central Bank Report dealt with the public works programme, as follows, at paragraph 17 of its report:—
"The public works programme differs from some other elements of State expenditure in being largely discretionary, thereby affording special opportunity for the exercise of a policy of contraction or expansion as economic circumstances may require. It is commonly accepted as an expedient for coping with problems of depression, especially unemployment."
The report, having referred to the different kinds of schemes, goes on to say:—
"... The general character of much of these works has been such as to place a strain on the balance of payments in several respects. They have, for example, entailed the immediate import of materials and equipment. They have, through their labour content, created a demand for imported as well as other consumer goods; and they do not promise a return which would be an effective substitute in the balance of payments for the extern income previously arising from the resources which they have absorbed...."
We have the authors of that report looking at a situation which they saw before a public works programme had been initiated. They look at a situation in which we had external assets yielding us an extern income of sterling credits built up in England. They look at the reduction of those external assets by the importation here of the raw materials necessary for a public works programme, machinery, and all the rest of it. Then they look at the results—wages going into the pockets of workers who before the schemes came into operation had only a few pence and had to exist on a few shillings dole. These workers have now sufficient money to buy more goods and more food and then they become an additional charge on the amount of consumer goods to be consumed in the country. The report says:—
"These workers have through their labour content created a demand for imported as well as for consumer goods."
So that the philisophy contained in that report means this: That it is sound from the economic and financial position of the country if all the workers starve, because by starving they will be demanding less and less of our consumer goods, and that is all to the good according to the philosophy that inspires these sentences.
Now the report goes on in dealing with public works to suggest that the Government should take steps to curtail the programme. Accordingly, one of the first criticisms that we made last October of the Central Bank Report was that without investigation, without examination, and for the least worthy of reasons, it was suggesting as a financial policy for a State suffering from emigration and a low standard of living that the public works programme should be discontinued. We felt that that was wrong, that it was utterly unjustified in the particular circumstances facing the country. No doubt we were all consoled when the Tánaiste rejected that recommendation as he rejected the other recommendations in the report.
Six months later, however, we find that the present Minister for Finance, who is obsessed by the balance of payments problem, who thinks that that is something serious from the country's point of view, is undoubtedly going to curtail rigorously the public works programme in the coming months. There is no doubt that he is going to do it. He has tendered a capital Budget to the country without any suggestion as to how it is to be balanced.
He has told the people that our investment programme of £35,000,000, to meet which he hopes to raise about half, can only be carried out if the people lend him the difference, and he does it in such a way that he knows the money will not be forthcoming. Accordingly, the Minister, I suspect, will think that, in some six or eight months, he will be justified in announcing here the abandonment of the capital investment programme, because the Minister clearly shares the views which inspired the Central Bank Report.
The Minister clearly believes that a public works programme which puts more wages in the pockets of the workers, which creates in them additional purchasing power, which entitles them to demand goods in shops, will result in this country importing, in the coming months, goods that the Minister would like to see us not importing. Accordingly, the only way that can be stopped is by ensuring that the workers do not get work, because, if they do not work, they do not get wages, and if they do not get wages they will not have the purchasing power to cause a balance of payments headache to the Minister. The Budget carries out that particular recommendation of the Central Bank Report. It does not do it openly. It does not do it courageously. It does it by default, by not holding out any hope of the necessary capital to carry out the capital investment programme this year.
Secondly, in the Central Bank Report there was a recommendation in relation to subsidies. On page 14, paragraph 18, the gentlemen who composed this report made the following recommendation in relation to subsidies, and it would be well if Fianna Fáil back benchers, those Deputies who nauseated us from time to time by their crocodile tears about the poor and the oppressed through the years, would listen carefully to the Central Bank's views of subsidies:—
"Subsidies are not only a heavy burden on the Budget but also constitute a disguised addition to purchasing power as the money saved through getting the subsidised article at a reduced price is set free for other expenditure."
The unfortunate worker who finds that he can get 1 lb. of butter at 10d. less than the economic price has 10d. over to buy some little thing for the house.
That 10d. with other tenpences might go to buy clothes or shoes or stockings for the children. The operation of the subsidies unfortunately, according to the authors of this report, sets free in his pocket money for other expenditure. It goes on to say:—
"They can have a twofold adverse effect on the balance of payments by promoting excessive demand for the subsidised articles whether imported or domestic but exportable and by facilitating additional demand for unsubsidised articles.
Therefore, according to the Central Bank Report, there was the unfortunate effect of subsidies operating on the balance of payments by releasing purchasing power. Subsidies allowed a permanent, consistent demand by the general body of the people for goods that were not subsidised and thereby reacted against the balance of payments.
It is very easy to cloak these particular ideas in language such as is used in the Central Bank report. Poor Fianna Fáil Deputies like Deputy Killilea do not understand and they swallow that sort of nonsense. What that means is that Deputy Killilea's constituents, the people who voted for him and other Fianna Fáil Deputies, have no right to have anything in their house except bread and butter, according to the gentlemen who inspired this particular philosophy. It is a wrong thing that workers should have any free money after they have busied themselves with the daily problem of living.
That second recommendation in the Central Bank Report was also, of course, repudiated entirely by the Tánaiste as something foreign to Fianna Fáil policy. Of course, we on this side of the House naturally accepted what he said. We expected him to say that in relation to subsidies because his Government had been formed, amongst other things, to maintain the policy of food subsidies. They had so declared on the 5th June last year. They had committed themselves and their fellow travellers to follow that particular policy and we were not surprised that the Tánaiste should reject any idea of interfering with subsidies.
The third recommendation in the Central Bank Report has been discussed so often that I shall not spend any time on it. The report in page 16 recommends rigórous restriction of bank credit for non-essential and less urgent purposes and says that the restriction is now imperative if the banks are to be in a position to afford reasonable accommodation in those directions which are most in accord with the public interest. The facts, generally, in relation to these important major recommendations in the Central Bank Report are that, despite the repudiation by the Tánaiste last October, we are now presented with a Budget which swallows the Central Bank Report completely—a Budget which abolishes subsidies, knocks the capital investment works programme on the head, restricts credit and endeavours to call in purchasing power from the hands of the ordinary people not merely by the withdrawal of subsidies but also by taxation, and so forth. In this Budget there is a complete acceptance of principles which the Tánaiste assured us only some months ago Fianna Fáil would not accept.
Subsidies which have been in existence for five years are about to be withdrawn—subsidies which have been taken into consideration in relation to all existing wage agreements, and subsidies which are an essential prop of the present wage level in the country. That step might be all right if one could be assured that no bar will be placed in the path of workers in their endeavour to restore the particular loss caused by the withdrawal of subsidies. That step might be all right if wage increases would be approved of and encouraged by the Government. However, I have no doubt whatsoever that that particular course will be resisted very strongly by the Government and by those who advise the Government, because on page 15 of the Central Bank Report the matter of wage increases is dealt with in great detail. According to the report, in September of last year — the time it was published — wages were as high as the country could afford: wage increases had reached a stage where if they went any higher, there was a danger of inflation. The recommendation to the Government was that every step should be taken to ensure that further wage increases should not take place because of the possible result in relation to inflation.
The Government have accepted three out of four major recommendations made by the Central Bank Report. The only one they have not accepted —because the question has not yet arisen — is the recommendation in relation to wage increases. I have no doubt that, having gone three-quarters of the road, the Government will not shy at going the entire way, and that in the coming months we will hear plausible excuses to prevent workers, organised and unorganised, from endeavouring to adjust the purchasing content of their wages. That is the position in which we find this House in relation to the Central Bank Report and in relation to its acceptance by the Government. It forces people to the conclusion that in recent month — since last June—by reason of the political instability of the Government and certain defects that arise from its formation, there has been a policy of drift in the country. We have had no leadership for the past ten months. No clear policy was being followed. There has been no clear mobilisation of power and effort behind a known programme. We have had none of the things which were so clearly noticeable during the three and a half years of inter-Party Government when the people, whether they agreed or disagreed with Government policy, knew clearly what was being aimed at.
Comment on this
I am very glad the Minister for Finance has come back, after his little bit of trouble, to join in these discussions. Whenever I hear the Minister for Finance laugh, I know that he is sitting on a tack. The fact is that, when the inter-Party Government were in office, whether the present Minister agreed or disagreed with their policy, at least he knew what that policy was. He knew well that the former Government was, over a number of years, deliberately endeavouring to repatriate a certain amount of our external assets and to put them to work at home. That was known policy. The Minister called it "frittering away our external credits", and so forth. Whatever way he might describe it, the policy was known to the people and could be discussed up and down the country. It was a policy which could be seen at work. Whenever the people saw houses built in Cavan, the Midlands, Cork and elsewhere they knew that, in the bricks, mortar and cement which made up these houses, there was a transfer of a certain amount of our external assets.
At the last general election the present Minister for Posts and Telegraphs went down to Mullingar, where he saw the grand housing scheme which his colleague, the present Minister for Local Government, had the honour of opening shortly after the Fianna Fáil Government came into office last June. He knew that some of our external assets were providing houses for his constituents. The policy of the inter-Party Government was a clear and definite policy. I realise that people criticised it. The two Ministers now in the House—the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs —bitterly opposed it. They have now translated their opposition into practice. Can the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs tell us what financial policy was operated during the past ten months? Is any clear indication of Government policy being given now to the people of this country? There was political mud-slinging and violent abuse by the Minister for Finance—a most extraordinary way of introducing a Budget statement—but there is no policy, programme or leadership.
We know well that in the past ten months leadership in financial and economic matters has not been directed from the Government of this country. We know that leadership has left Government buildings. A disedifying curtain-raiser to the introduction of the Budget was the fact that the Minister for Finance and the Tánaiste went across to London for a conference with the British Chancellor of the Exchequer. It was disedifying that some three or four weeks before the introduction of the Budget the Minister for Finance went across to London and engaged in discussions with the British Chancellor of the Exchequer and came back here unprepared to make any statement— good, bad or indifferent—on the nature of the discussions. Apparently leadership in these matters is no longer a matter of concern to the Irish Government. I believe it, and I think many people believe it, because this Government has not the ability which the inter-Party Government had—certainly not in relation to many matters of major policy.
I have said that in many economic and financial matters there is no evidence of a clear programme or a clear policy. That statement applies also to other aspects of the life of this country. Agriculture has suffered considerably in the past ten months because, again, the drive, initiative and programme has disappeared.
In relation to agriculture, whether Fianna Fáil agreed or disagreed with the former Minister for Agriculture, they knew what he was doing and the farmers knew what his policy was. They might criticise him and say that he was wrong but his was a clear, known policy. For the last ten months all that has gone. No one knows what the Fianna Fáil agricultural policy is. One week they are for compulsory tillage and the next week they are against it. One week they are for a higher price for barley and the next week they are for cutting the price down. The result is that there is no farmer who has the slightest glimmer of hope with regard to agriculture. All that has gone since Fianna Fáil reassumed office.
Then, of course, the crowning insult in relation to the Budget was the magnificent gesture of ministerial genercsity to the dance-hall proprietors. They alone amongst the Irish people are not in danger, are not hurt or are not faced with any problem of inflation. They alone amongst the Irish people have not too much money in their pockets and are not going to be asked to contribute anything towards redressing the adverse balance of payments. They are the lucky few who can afford to walk unharmed in the vicinity of the financial land-mine that threatens to engulf all the rest of us. By the generosity of the Minister they are given a sum of £140,000 back into their pockets to be spent by them on shoes for their children, on food for their houses, on wines for themselves, and on purchasing, if they so desire, imported goods to swell the adverse balance of trade. That is all a matter on which the people have their own particular views.
I suppose it is understandable, if not praiseworthy, that that particular section should be able to buy a tax concession by their political support of the Fianna Fáil Party in the last election. The sum involved is only £140,000. The Minister tried to make the case that it was hard to collect but £140,000 had been collected last year and the tax had been retained for a number of years. If the concession had not been given, the revenue from that tax would have been sufficient to increase every I.R.A. pension in the country. How many Fianna Fáil Deputies were elected because of appeals to I.R.A. pensioners throughout the country? Will they now go back and tell these pensioners that they have given this concession of £140,000 to Fianna Fáil's political followers and that had they not given this concession, the proceeds of that tax would have enabled them to increase every I.R.A. pension throughout the country. That is a matter which I hope Fianna Fáil Deputies will consider when marking time before the election comes about.
There is only one other point that I want to mention. It concerns a matter which for a long time I have been looking for an opportunity to discuss in this House. I am sorry that the Taoiseach is not here because during the summer months the Taoiseach went around the country on a new crusade, a crusade about emigration. When the Minister for Finance began to preach woe and disaster in financial matters, with the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the Minister for Industry and Commerce backing him up, the Taoiseach started on the other line. Emigration was so great in the country, we were told, that we were bleeding to death and across in England our emigrants were apparently going on gladly to the most terrible material and moral dangers. That particular campaign initiated by the Taoiseach was based on figures which were in my opinion I say here and now prepared for the particular purpose of his argument. They never had been published and never had been vouched. But whatever case the Taoiseach might have made in relation to emigration, we were entitled to expect from him a policy which would help to reduce, to curb and to stop emigration. We were entitled to expect from his speeches last summer that the members of his Government, if they were doing their job, would have been preparing an economic policy which would enable this country to end emigration, to provide employment and a decent standard of living for the people here at home. The only justification for his attacks on people who, from necessity, had to emigrate from this country could be that he was going to provide for them here at home employment and a decent standard of living. It is remarkable that now, a couple of months later, we should find the Government putting a policy into operation which is directly aimed at increasing unemployment and emigration. It cannot be controverted that the direct result of the policy contained in this Budget will be to reduce purchasing power, consequent on the abolition of subsidies. Business will suffer and further unemployment will come about. That will mean that there will be a sharp increase in emigration.
With that background, it is hard for people to understand, remembering all the speeches delivered by the Taoiseach in the last six months, why we should now find the Government proposing this policy as one the country should accept. It merely proves what I said a few moments ago, that there has been for the last ten months a complete absence of leadership and of policy in the Government. There is no planned policy. Policy is being decided from day to day. The Central Bank Report is being rejected one minute and accepted the next. There is a tug-of-war going on between the Minister for Finance and the Tánaiste in relation to these matters. Policy is being decided by different Ministers or groups of Ministers for themselves. I know that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is in the same camp as the Minister for Finance but there is no clear plan and no effort to define any clear policy. The country, accordingly, has suffered considerably in the last ten months. It may mean, as sometimes happens in regard to such matters, that a little Purgatory may prepare us for better things. It may have been good that the country should have had experience of Fianna Fáil in a Coalition in recent months.
It may have been a good thing that those who criticised the inter-Party policy and programme so vehemently, who shouted themselves hoarse about margarine going up a farthing and who waxed eloquent when meat went up in 1948 by 1d. a lb., should now try to justify their actions and words in the past in relation to their conduct in the last ten months. I have no doubt that the people of the country will benefit considerably by the example of the last ten months or so. I am referring to this Government as if it were practically out of office. I believe it is. I believe the days of this Government's life in office are numbered. No matter what the political plan may be in Fianna Fáil headquarters and no matter what the political hope may be among the Fianna Fáil back-benchers, no Government that is so unrepresentative of public opinion can expect to remain in office.
There are certain vacancies that will have to be filled here very shortly. I do not know whether those will be fought or not, but I am quite certain of this, the situation in the country is such that there is a demand now for the removal of the present Government from office, for the restoration of the bold, courageous programme and policy which the inter-Party Government was putting into operation, for the restoration of the leadership in economic and financial matters which, in the last four years, 1948 to 1951, gave to this country and the people who live in it the one bit of confidence and hope for the future which had been lacking for many years before. There is a demand for a return to that, and if anyone doubts that there is a simple way of testing what I am saying.
Comment on this
This is the third financial debate we have had since I became a Deputy less than 12 months ago. It appears to me that the cause of all this discussion here and outside is due to one simple fact, that the present Government believe in the policy of leaving our external assets where they are instead of utilising them for the benefit and privilege of the people of Ireland. May I quote the Minister in his Budget speech, April 2nd, Volume 130, No. 8, column 1125:—
"Now, at this point, let me stress that, even if sterling were freely convertible into dollars and other currencies, the present position of our balance of payments would force us to take the necessary corrective action. That action would be taken solely in our own interest, to maintain and safeguard the purchasing power of our own currency and to conserve our external reserves. The corrective action is rendered doubly necessary and doubly urgent, however, by reason of the present payments difficulties of the sterling area as a whole."
May I quote him further, from the same volume, column 1114: —
"The fact is that if the living standards of farmers and the community generally are to be sustained, it can only be on the basis of a greatly expanded agricultural and industrial output."
Surely, if we are going to give a contribution to the sterling area — and nobody in his sane senses will deny that it is just as vital for us who live and trade in the sterling area to maintain it — our best contribution would be not to leave this country undeveloped and hoard those assets, leaving them blocked up in British investments, but rather to bring them back to our own country and to endeavour, as the Minister himself has stated here, to increase our agricultural production?
I propose to show the House as best I can that this financial policy of the present administration will have a diametrically opposite effect to that which is envisaged in the Minister's Budget statement. I will deal, first of all, with subsidies. The removal of the subsidies will inflict not only on the individual but on every public institution in every county from the 1st July extensive extra charges for catering. I mix with hospital people as part of my job. The matrons of hospitals, of county homes, of every public institution, are wondering how they are going to balance their budgets. Is it not only common sense that they must turn to the source of revenue to look for more money? Up go the rates — that is No. 1 charge on the agricultural community. Deputies on all sides of the House will agree that the rates are high enough in every county and every urban district already.
Petrol has been increased by 4d. per gallon. It is always easy to put an extra tax on petrol—you are supposed to be taxing the rich, and you will get away with it on that account. When you increase the tax on petrol, you increase the charges for transport on every public institution. You are not putting increased charges, as is suggested here, only on the luxury limousines. Some Deputies have referred to "the mink coats of Merrion Square" driving about in their cars. You are putting the tax on the tractors of the farmers, and so putting up their charges and the cost of agricultural production. The Minister was asked in the last debate we had here, or by parliamentary question—I forget which —if he was going to remove that extra 4d. in the case of the farmer doing agricultural work—as his predecessor, Deputy McGilligan, removed it in his last Bulget—and the answer was "No"; the charge is to be left on them.
Again, what about the employment in garages? Are not the daily newspapers full of letters from people who say they intend to lay up their cars this summer or use them only about 50 per cent. of what they did before What about the bus fares? Of course, it does not matter to Córas Iompair Éireann, as they can get all the money they want, but again the load comes back on us. The bus fares go up, we have to pay the piper, and Córas Iompair Éireann come to us and we have to give them the money. Apart from that, the individual has to pay all the time. That is restricting the expenditure of money, as it is throwing it into the pool of Córas Iompair Éireann, which is a non-profitmaking company.
The taxes on beer, stout and whiskey were put on for the purpose of collecting revenue. They will defeat the very object for which they were imposed. Only the other day, in my constituency, a wholesaler in stout, who sells through out the country to the public houses here, there and everywhere, was asked by them to send out his lorry and take back the stout still unsold. The consumption of alcohol has gone down. From the point of view of those who believe in rabid teetotalism that may be a good thing. We have been told that this Finance Bill is devised for the purpose of getting in more money to balance a Budget which is supposed to show a deficiency. Will it do so? All the indications so far throughout the country show that as far as the bars are concerned, both public and private, it will not do so.
I think it was the Minister for Defence who made a reference to there not being any lack of credit; he quoted figures here which he said showed the banks had lent more money in the last 12 months than they had in previous years. I think if one analyses the position one will find that the banks are owed more money at the present time than they were ever owed at any time in the past. That is due to the fact that the shopkeepers who laid in stocks in anticipation of those stocks being consumed by the ordinary public still have the stocks sitting on their shelves; and those stocks will continue to sit on the shelves until such time as the Government adopts a policy of expansion, a policy of circulating money and encouraging trade so that the consuming public will be in a position to buy these stocks. Until that time that money will remain owing to the banks.
It is not only the shopkeepers who owe money to the banks. People who have drawn on their reserves, and more than their reserves, owe money to the banks; these people have mortgaged their reserves to try to make ends meet. It is nonsense to say that there is no restriction of credit. I am sure every Deputy has had the same experience in his constituency as I have had in mine. I have had constituents coming to me and asking me to put in a word for them with the bank. Some of them have excellent security. I do not want to quote particular cases, naturally, since these matters are private, but I have gone on several occasions with people who had good financial propositions to offer and who wanted some money to set up in business. Businesses are continually changing hands in the country. It is an inexorable law of nature that people grow old. When people get old they retire from business and very often when that time comes employees who have worked with them for years and who are anxious to set up in a business of their own wish to buy their employer's property. Very often these employees have considerable sums of money saved.
There is one case in my constituency which will illustrate my point. This particular individual required a certain sum from the bank. He had saved £1,000. He had been in the same employment for ten years and had saved that money; that was not a bad effort by any means. He had a life insurance policy for £600 and his wife was insured for £500. He wanted £3,000 altogether. He wanted the bank to advance him something over £1,000 and a little bit more to buy in stock. He found that could not be done because of credit restriction. I asked the officials in the bank what the reason was and I was told that there was so much money loaned out to buy in stock—stock that in the normal course of trade would have been consumed but had not been —that they had no money left to loan to anybody. Let me be fair: they also said that another reason was that more farm machinery was being bought than ever before. That is a good sign, I admit, and I would like to give Fianna Fáil a little bit of hope. So much for credit restriction.
We are told that the income-tax section in this Finance Bill will benefit the majority of income-tax payers. Naturally we must deal with the Finance Bill as a whole. We assume that this income-tax is imposed for the same purpose for which the other taxes are imposed; that is to say, for the purpose of getting in money to balance this mythical deficit about which the Government and the Fianna Fáil Party have been so vocal since they took office.
I cannot see how any family, irrespective of the number of children, will be any better off in the over-all situation created by this Finance Bill than it was before. Any allowances that may be given are offset by the increased charges that will have to be met. It is not only food which will be affected. There are other incidental expenses, such as education. As a result of this cruel and unjust taxation everything will go up in price. School fees are bound to go up. The cost of university education will be increased. I fail to see how the Minister can claim that these income-tax reliefs will offset the position for anybody. The Exchequer may benefit by getting in more money so that the Government can continue its dark, deep financial game. We are all wondering where it will end. We are all wondering whether it will end, as everybody thinks it will, with the end of the present Government in the very near future.
I think the Minister stated in his opening speech that about 700 people here paid surtax. These would be in the higher income group. These would be the people who are the industrialists and the big employers of labour.
Comment on this
I would like to correct the Deputy on that. I said that those who pay a substantial sum in surtax number at most about 700. They are not industrialists.
Comment on this
Those who pay big sums in income-tax will probably be people who have employees. This is an old game, and the popular game of taxing the man with the big money. It has been tried all over the world for the greater part of this century. It has been tried by left wing Governments; it has been tried by right wing Governments. It is a measure that hits only a few people but, even though it hits only a few, it reacts just as heavily on the ordinary individual as any other tax. To my mind excessive income-tax is responsible for many of the evils existent in the western hemisphere to-day. It impedes production. It is responsible in large measure for unemployment.
I do not think anyone on the Government Benches can be complacent about the situation that exists at the present time. In the town from which I come—the town of Gorey—we have a leather factory. At one time it employed 200 men. At the present time only 40 to 50 men are employed there, and they have only just gone back into employment. A fortnight or three weeks ago there were only 20 men in employment there.
The reason why they have been taken back into employment is because the stock piles—these, apparently, have been denied to a large extent from the benches opposite—that were held by these factories for the Government—by the Department of Posts and Telegraphs which, I understand, is the contracting Department for the Government—have recently been drawn upon to the extent of some 30 per cent.
That is only one factory. I can go to the other end of my constituency, to New Ross, where we have the Driver Harris electrical factory which is also on short time. I think that, if an analysis were made of the situation, it would be found that the real reason why the leather factory at Gorey and the electrical factory at New Ross have recently been on short time was due to the fact that there has been a restriction of credit and the application of a restrictive policy generally. Let us accept facts as we find them and be sensible. We say on this side of the House, with every measure of confidence and truth, that this country is underdeveloped. Deputies and Ministers on that side may deny that, but this is perhaps the most underdeveloped country in the western world to-day.
Comment on this
That is not our fault. It is the fault of our political history. We had to fight hard and long for our freedom. Many sacrifices were made, as many from these benches as from the benches opposite. The sacrifices were, I suppose, 50-50. Now that we have got our own Government we surely have the right to determine what we will do with our own assets, whether they are external or internal assets. We should use them for the benefit of our own people, and that is the key and the kernel of the whole situation here.
Comment on this
Some Fianna Fáil Deputies may smile at that. If they go down the country, face their constituents and talk the situation over with them they will find that what I say is the unanimous opinion of the people throughout the country.
Let me stress this point. I said just now that the Driver Harris factory at New Ross, which is an electrical equipment factory, is on short time. Why is it on short time? Because there is not the demand now that there was before for the ingredients that they produce, the flex for the wiring of houses. Why is the demand not as great as it was before? Let those opposite say what they will, the reason is that they are not building houses to the same degree or with the same rapidity that we built them. Am I not entitled to ask, in view of that situation, whether the Irish people are not entitled to have the money of their own citizens utilised to give them houses as well as to drain the land for rural electrification? Are they not entitled to have that money utilised at home for the development of our harbours and our fisheries and for the purpose of giving loans to farmers who cannot get loans? As far as I can find in the Budget speech of the Minister for Finance, the only thing he offers the farmers is a sum of £250,000 to be divided amongst about 300,000 of them. The position is not that the farmer can apply and get any of that £250,000 for the asking. In fact, he has to go to the Agricultural Credit Corporation and pay 6 per cent. on the loan he obtains. He has also to go to a Deputy, not once but probably half a dozen times, to help get his application put through and, in addition, he has to mortgage his farm and give an absolute gilt-edged security for the loan.
Comment on this
The farmers want money just as other people want it. A man may have had a bit of bad luck and may want to buy in stock rapidly. What chance has he, other than a loan system, in this State of getting money in the near future? I have had personal experience of this, and so has every Deputy on every side of the House. I know one man who buried a lot of his stock last autumn. He has been trying to get a loan to restock his land. He has had to mortgage his farm, and has done everything possible to get the loan. He will probably get it now any day, but how is he going to buy stock now? If he could have been able to get the money last autumn he could buy in stock at a reasonable price. How is he going to buy now on a rising market, and how is he going to make money to pay back what he owes? That is the sort of credit the farmers have.
Comment on this
I think that both Ministers and Deputies should waken up to the fact that the people of the country are not satisfied with them. It remains to be seen whether they will manage to survive with their razoredge majority. It seems to be quite obvious now that the people of the country do not want them. It is dogmatically and categorically evident that the people do not want this Administration any longer. If they are going to hold on by their razoredge majority, at least let them do the decent thing and face up to the situation that this country did not win its freedom for the purpose of running neck-and-neck with Threadneedle Street or with the British financiers, or for the purpose of putting into effect the policy of the Central Bank.
I do not want to be too hard on the Central Bank or on the Department of Finance. They have their job to do. If they did not warn the people of the dangers, the vicissitudes and the misfortunes that lay ahead, and if the State were drifting on the rocks, they would be the first people to get the blame. We would all say that they had not done their duty, but surely in a case like that while a Department of State, holding so much responsibility has a duty to picture the situation to the people and to the Government in power, it should not make it very much worse than it is.
I think myself that probably nobody was more surprised than the Department of Finance, or the Central Bank, when they realised that the Minister for Finance was going to introduce this extraordinary Budget. It has been stated from the benches opposite that our criticism is of a back-biting, malicious nature. In fact, they can use any number of adjectives they like. But surely this is a democratic country and we are entitled to state our views. We have been told that we have offered no alternative and have made no constructive statements from these benches. Deputy Dr. ffrenchO'Carroll told us that he could not vote because nobody on these benches would tell him what we would do if we got into power again. Now, has it not been stated in this House by Front Bench Leaders of this Party and of other Parties in Opposition, and has it not been stated publicly in the Press up and down the country that if we get the chance we will repeal these taxes. May I make this appeal to the Government? If you hang on by a thread, as you are hanging on by a thread, do one decent thing before you go out— that is, take this load off the real poor people in this country who can least afford to bear it.
Comment on this
This afternoon, in the course of the discussion on this Bill which unfortunately became a little frayed, a Deputy on the opposite benches who entered this House for the first time with me 11 months ago, said in a rather snobbish way and from his academic heights, that something very valuable on the financial situation would come forth from me. In speaking to-night on this Bill, I do so in the knowledge that I have not any great insight as regards finance matters. I speak, however, from the experience that I have gained from travelling up and down my constituency during the last month. During that period I have gleaned some of the facts which have accrued already from the introduction of this Budget. We have been lectured in this House not since the introduction of the Budget but ever since we entered it and since this Government was formed 11 months ago.
We have been told by various Ministers at various times that we have been living beyond our means, that we should tighten our belts and that it was necessary that we should march step by step with Britain in introducing an austerity programme.
We were presented with twins pretty late last year in the shape of the Central Bank Report and the White Paper issued by the Minister for Finance. They were very similar in their contents. There was a very vigorous debate on both of those documents and, as a result of the cogent and unquestionable arguments put up by the Opposition, the Tánaiste performed a complete volte face in repudiating the report of the Central Bank. In this Budget and in the financial approach to our economy for the coming year we see a complete reversal of the Tánaiste's statement at that time and we see now being implemented certain provisions in the Central Bank Report over which the quasi-Fianna Fáil Government could not stand at that time.
Statements were made, principally by the Minister for Finance and the banshee of the Government, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, which resulted in the creation of an actual crisis in this country. Such phrases were used as: "The situation is difficult to the verge of desperation." Can we say that these statements were fraught with any due consideration or, if they were, what type of measuring rod was used? Did they at any time realise the effect which these speeches would have on the entire business of the State?
Did they realise in their advocacy of restriction of credit, in the support which they gave to the banks in carrying out that policy, that they were denying to every small trader as well as to those engaged in bigger business the wherewithal to give credit to those who had accounts with them? Did they realise that the small farmer who could not afford to pay cash down for requirements by way of seeds, fertilisers, machinery, and so forth, to the local business people, when he could not get credit, would naturally have to curtail any plans he might have had to increase production this year? The effect of that will be experienced at the end of the year when the returns will indicate that we will not have the expansion in agricultural output which should accrue as a result of the moneys that were well invested in the past four years in reclaiming and refertilising land, in the provision of expert advisers, in the provision of up-to-date machinery to ensure that there would be available to the people the necessaries of life in the way of food at the lowest possible cost to them and that surplus which, according to the opening statement of the Minister for Finance, he regarded as being the most valuable contribution which this country could make towards remedying the position in relation to the balance of payments.
We have been told, I think it was by the Taoiseach, that, in implementing certain measures here, such as the cut in subsidies, the bringing forward of the Budget, the cut in the travel allowance—matters which are very like those introduced by the Chancellor of the Exchequer in Britain—that it is not because they did it that they were essentially wrong. We say that the conditions in Britain as they are to-day and conditions here cannot be compared, and that it is looking at it in an entirely wrong light to compare them.
We feel that this little country has had for hundreds of years to endure very grievous hardships, and now that we have the opportunity to build on the foundations laid some brief 30 or 35 years, we should not let pass any opportunity of giving our people houses in which they could rear their families with a degree of comfort and some insurance that certain physical defects which ensued from bad housing in the past would be very greatly reduced, if not entirely eliminated.
In pursuing the capital investment programme, the inter-Party Government did a great thing for this country. Despite all the taunts and jeers from Government back benchers, we feel that it is well worth investing money in the erection of houses, sanatoria, the reclamation of land, additional telephone facilities, afforestation, rural electrification—any and every scheme which will bring to all sections of our people a higher standard of living and ensure to them and their children in this country a means of livelihood, homes and incomes commensurate at least with the simple demands they make on the State.
Consequently, we regard any comparison between our problems and those of Britain as being entirely wrong. In the course of the debate not one item of expenditure by the inter-Party Government in their capital investment programme has been singled out as being an item which the new Government consider as having been in any way worthless. In fact, although we do not contend for one moment that they have followed step by step in the maintenance of these schemes, at least, they have not abandoned them. Any criticism we may have to offer is in relation to the administration of the schemes.
Despite the fact that throughout this country to-day, through the extensive political organisation supporting that Party, propaganda has been disseminated alleging that the inter-Party Government left a load of debt behind them. We have no particularising of any items in relation to these debts by the Minister and we have not heard an explanation from any Deputy as to why they left office early in 1948 and left such debt behind them that it took a national loan of £12,000,000 to clear it. There is not a word about those. Would one not think that a Party with a record like that would not dare to make any reference to leaving debts behind?
Is it not a fact that the system of budgeting introduced by Deputy McGilligan made very clear to the people the moneys which were for use in development and the moneys which were necessary for houskeeping purposes? It is regrettable that the Minister has intimated his intention not to continue that system of presenting the Budget as it would indicate clearly to the people that what they were asked to pay in taxes was necessary for the purpose of paying year-to-year expenses and, side by side with that, that it was their intention to embark on schemes of capital development which could well be met by borrowing. It has not been intimated to us that development should be restricted to the point that nothing should be done, except what could be paid for in a single year, and, in fact, in the Minister's statement we have the information that it is the Government's intention to seek a very substantial loan to maintain schemes in operation and to pursue a capital investment programme the particulars of which have not been presented to us. Would it be unfair to say that opportunities have been missed by this Government in relation to seeking the savings of the people for that purpose?
It is regrettable that the Marshall Aid moneys which were being employed by Deputy McGilligan, while Minister for Finance, to supplement the loans intended for capital investment should have been completely spent by this Government from 13th June last to the end of the year, that in that short period they should have disposed of such a great amount of money, and it is certainly strange that they should level criticism at their predecessors for having spent these moneys at a much slower rate. A certain amount of the Marshall Aid moneys was intended to be employed in a prudent manner as a shelter-belt for the protection of that capital investment programme, and consequently the complete spending of these moneys is very unfortunate. This evening, another Deputy on the Fianna Fáil side quoted from a statement of some American which was slighting in its references to the manner in which the previous Government was spending these moneys.
I cannot recall the name he mentioned, because at the time I could not identify him as having been prominent in any way, in an advisory capacity or with a roving commission, to visit various countries to see how the moneys were being administered, but I want to place on record a statement made by the E.C.A. administrator, Mr. Foster, in May, 1951. I claim that he is a better known authority on this matter, and I quote his statement to controvert the statement made by a Deputy on the Government side. In that month, Mr. Foster said:—
"The suspension of E.C.A. aid is the best possible recognition of the strides the Irish people have taken towards economic self-sufficiency under the impetus of the Marshall Plan. With the dollars and technical assistance provided through E.C.A. help, Ireland has accomplished agricultural and other economic reforms in three years that otherwise would have taken a generation to achieve. The economic recovery of Ireland and the sterling area as a whole has progressed to the point where Ireland no longer needs outside dollar assistance to maintain a healthy economy."
I regard that commentary as being unbiased, completely unconcerned with internal politics here, and an expression of the feelings of one who should know, of one who was responsible to his own country for the disbursement of moneys under the Marshall Plan, with a view to ensuring that they would be spent in such a manner as to bring to those countries an improvement which would be reflected in their standard of living and output.
I do not claim that anything like the full results of the expenditure of much of these moneys has yet been achieved. The thousands of acres of land which have been and are being reclaimed will give, in increasing amounts, results which will benefit this country for very many years. I know that to-day in the south we have a very great surplus of applications for the delivery of ground limestone—a surplus because the fine organisation dealing with the distribution of that limestone is incapable of handling the tremendous number of applications coming in.
That is a tribute to those who decided that that was a scheme worthy of introduction. My only regret is that to-day more of that limestone is not made available for the poorer lands and for those who, during the winter months, engaged in extremely hard manual labour in draining land and clearing it of scrub, and who now look to the distribution of this limestone and the supply of fertilisers to enable them to put back into that land, so unproductive for so long, the fertility which will be reflected in our agricultural output within a very short time.
Very early in the discussions on the Budget, in fact some 12 or 13 hours after the Minister had concluded his statement, Deputy Costello, the former Taoiseach, claimed from these benches that the Minister had budgeted for a surplus. He gave particulars of the items in respect of which he argued that there was overestimation. We have had a very lengthy discussion since then and it is accepted by independent authorities that the Government have not succeeded in rebutting what Deputy Costello put forward, that they were budgeting for a surplus.
We are told that the additional taxation now being imposed is for the purpose of getting more money. This is not the first time that Fianna Fáil got such ideas. In the autumn of 1947 a similar brainwave came upon them and they imposed taxes very much less in their severity than those which are now in operation as a result of the passing of the Budget. They were imposed for the purpose of bringing more money into the Exchequer but when the people get an opportunity of recording their opinion of that action they gave a very emphatic answer and removed that Government from office and elected the inter-Party Government in 1948. Within a matter of weeks, Mr. McGilligan, then Minister for Finance, did away with these penal taxes and notwithstanding that fact he got more money because the people actually consumed more than they would have done if the additional taxes had been allowed to continue.
We wonder, in the light of our experiences travelling around our own constituencies in the course of the past month, whether the Minister will receive the money which he expects? He must certainly think very well of conditions in the country, as a result of the inter-Party Government's administration, if he feels that the income of every section of our people is such that it can withstand the increase in the price of every little simple luxury which they buy, if next July they can face a 10.2 increase in the cost of living in addition to the increase in the cost of living which occurred since they were elected to office up to the Budget, and if the people will continue to buy the same amount of these commodities and bring to the Exchequer the amounts which the Minister requires to balance his Budget.
I know that there has been a big falling-off in the amount of cigarettes purchased throughout the country. I know that there has been a big falling-off in the amount of drink consumed. I know that to-day we see in the shop windows popular brands of cigarettes which could not be obtained, except you were a very steady customer, until this Budget was introduced. I know that the man who drinks a pint is now cut down to the bottle of stout or the half-pint. I know that dockers in the City of Cork—I am sure the same can be said for the dockers of Dublin—are denied what is to them certainly not a luxury—the pint which they take at mid-day together with the few sandwiches which they bring with them from home.
But what will the position be—bad as it is now—next July if this Government is still in existence and if the food subsidies are removed? I claim as emphatically as I can that the effects of the very greatly increased taxes on cigarettes and beer and the removal of the subsidies on flour, tea, sugar and butter hit hardest at the poorer sections of the community. In the rural areas people work in the open and often work under conditions which require a certain amount of drink, such as at threshings. They work under conditions which make it very difficult for them to do that work unless they have that beverage. These people will now be asked to pay more into the Exchequer than people who have a very much higher income and enjoy a much more leisured life. They are described as luxuries.
The man with the higher salary or the man who is better off has a choice of luxuries. The manual worker has not that choice. Is it a great luxury to him to enjoy a couple of bottles of stout after he has finished his day's work? To the worker who has his cigarette, if he works during the day, is that a very great luxury?
Is it not a fact that his work will be affected if he is suddenly broken off from the enjoyment of that cigarette? We have the indication that such is happening and that the people are so incensed by the needlessness of these impositions that they intend to economise in that respect and consume less. It is extraordinary that, in a situation such as this, following on the events leading up to it, the scare speeches, all this talk of the country being in an almost desperate position, we had not a gesture from the Government such as that given by the Prime Minister of Britain and by his Ministers before they imposed similar conditions upon a nation which had its back to the wall. They reduced their own salaries as a little gesture before embarking on such a course. Such was not done here.
Relief has been given in this Budget to one section of the community Indeed, it is a compliment to the criticisms offered from this side of the House that the Minister should spend so much time yesterday dealing with the necessity for the abolition of the dance tax. Very early in the debate some letters were read which passed between the Ballroom Proprietors' Association and the Fianna Fáil Party, whereby they assured Fianna Fáil that they would do all in their power to secure their return to office and whereby they, in return, were assured by the Fianna Fáil Party that it was only a matter of doing that and securing their re-election when, at the first opportunity, they would remit the dance tax.
In that letter we had one sum indicated—the sum of £250 from one dance hall proprietor. By way of a parliamentary question, I have since ascertained that there are 1,285 licensed dance halls in this country. I am sure that many more have been built since these figures were compiled.
We can infer from that, that quite a considerable sum must have accured to the Fianna Fáil organisation during the election campaign as a result of that assurance from the dance hall proprietors. That must have been the overriding factor in the Minister's decision to remit the dance tax. You had to admire the courage of those supporting the Government who put forward certain reasons why the tax should be taken off. One was that it was a difficult tax to collect. I think we know that before a dance can be held the stamps must be purchased. We know that in country areas at least dances are not held every night in the week. You may have one dance a fortnight, two in a month, and it is accepted that the officer responsible for ensuring that the tickets are properly stamped need not attend every one of these functions; one dance out of two would be sufficient. It would cause concern to the proprietor of the dance hall if the officer visited the hall on each occasion on which a dance was held. Let us compare the number of visits involved with the number necessary to ensure that cinema tickets are properly stamped. If that argument is put forward regarding dances surely it is more pertinent regarding cinemas where entertainments are held four or five nights per week in the country. If the officer must visit the cinema on each occasion when an entertainment is shown surely it must cost the State a greater sum to collect the duty than in the case of dances. We know that these officers engage in many other activities in the administration of that branch of government.
Furthermore, this is a grave disadvantage to the remote areas where little communities were given some little recognition by Deputy McGilligan. In his time the tax did not apply where the village had a population under 500. To use the Fianna Fáil argument, this reduced the cost of collecting the tax. It gave the village dance halls a chance as they were up against the difficulty of a dwindling population. If we are to stem the flight from the land, an object to which so much lip service is paid on so many occasions, we should allow these little communities to enjoy an occasional dance tax free. I should like to cite the instance of two young men who borrowed a considerable sum of money in order to build a dance hall, secure as they thought, in that advantage over the big commercial dance hall proprietors 20 miles away. They did that since Fianna Fáil left office because, as we know, at that time luxury building was forbidden. Now they are denied that little advantage and are hard put to it to compete with the very much stronger opposition of the big commercial ballrooms. The same difficulty applies to societies which were given tax free facilities formerly and are now on the same footing as commercial ballroom proprietors. I have heard Deputies on the opposite side of the House say that many sporting organisations would benefit as a result of the remission of the tax but is it not a fact that the owner of a ballroom will now require those societies to pay a higher rent for the hall? He will, naturally enough, because he would reap a greater profit by keeping the hall for his own use. Bands have already availed of this opportunity to raise their charges. I know a town not very far from here where the proprietor of a ballroom during Easter week-end made £170 additional profit as a result of the remission of the tax. Has any Deputy in the course of this discussion intimated that there has been 6d. reduction in admission charge to dance halls or that those who participate have benefited in the slightest degree from the remission of the tax?
They say that £140,000 is not worth talking about, that we only talk in millions, but it has been pointed out that £140,000 would service a loan for house building. Much of the tuberculosis which is rampant in this country can be traced to dancing into the small hours of the night on too many nights of the week, and with increased dancing and reduced food the future does not look too rosy from that point of view.
In July next the workers will pay more for their bread, considerably more than people with a higher standard of living in the higher income groups, because they have bread for 21 meals in the week, whereas people who enjoy a large salary have their cereal, their bacon and egg, for their breakfast and will not eat as much bread or consume as much butter as the workers. At mid-day how much bread will the rich man consume? A half-cut of bread, a dinner bun with his soup, and then he has his soup, meat, a choice of vegetables, sweet and coffee. He will not be so much affected by the Budget. In the evening, if he has not dinner, he has meat again with his tea and, again, will not be so much affected. The worker, however, going out to the bog, to the road or to any type of work, must take his little satchel with bread and butter, and he is the man who will be affected by this. I well recall that during the last general election campaign the Party which now holds office specifically stated that they would not impose penal taxes or reduce the food subsidies. One Deputy who had not the courage to vote one way or the other on the Budget and who, if his supporters had adopted a similar attitude in the general election and had refrained from voting, would not be here——
Comment on this
On a point of order. I took the Deputy to say that he knew a gentleman not far from the City of Dublin who made £170 additional profit because the tax was removed from his dance hall. Surely the Deputy should realise that the remission does not come into force until 1st August. Therefore I suggest that he is talking through his hat.
Comment on this
It is not a point of order. The Deputy can speak in his own good time. The people of his constituency can dance tax free knowing that they will have to pay more for their bread, butter and sugar.
Comment on this
He was one of the Deputies who were returned to this House after the last election because of the increase which had come about in the price of butter, in company with the additional Fianna Fáil Deputy who secured a seat in Cork City. On every doorstep there the one cry was advanced: "The inter-Party Government allowed the cost of living to rise; you are paying an additional 2d. per lb. for your butter." That was the predominant feature in the election address in Cork and I am sure it also was the predominant feature of election addresses in the Deputy's constituency.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy be sporting enough to withdraw the charge he made here against a ballroom proprietor? It is unfair to make a charge against anybody who cannot defend himself.
Comment on this
I warn the Deputy that if he persists in his present action he will be subjected to the same cross-examination from these benches when he is speaking.
Comment on this
The indications at the moment are that the Government will not be in existence long enough to enforce it.
Comment on this
We consider, Sir, that the present Government have no mandate; they went to the electorate last year, and threw the responsibility for the fact that the cost of living had been allowed to rise by a few points on the outgoing Government, but they are now about to impose crushing burdens on the people in relation to the cost of living.
I cannot follow Deputy Bartley's argument when he suggests that, as a result of the increase in the price of butter, certain farmers in his constituency will now resort to the production of butter at home. We are aware that this would entail a great loss, inasmuch as it requires more milk to make a lb. of butter at home than it does to make it when the milk is supplied to the creameries. He stated that when that would occur those farmers would be in a position to go into competition with the butter supplied from the creameries, thereby effecting a reduction in price. That is an argument which will certainly bear amplification, because any Deputy coming from a dairying area fails to understand what is intended by the argument.
Deputy Dr. Hillery who would be much more conversant than Deputy Bartley with the problems of the dairy farmers feels that the rise in the price of butter will ensure that the price of milk will be maintained to the creamery supplier. Again I cannot understand that reasoning, because the Minister for Agriculture has already intimated to a group which approached him recently seeking an increase in the price of milk that such an increase would be impossible. The Minister said that an increase in the price of milk would have a very unfavourable effect on the cost of living, and that the price of butter cannot be allowed to rise further. It bears out what we claimed here on the Budget debate, and that is that the fact of doing away with the subsidy on butter not alone affects the consumer but that serious malnutrition will result; the people will be unable to buy the amount of butter which would maintain themselves and their families in reasonable health. The removal of the subsidy on butter will also mean that the cushion has now gone which existed between the high cost of butter production and the price which the consumer was called upon to bear. We think that is something which will react badly before very long.
We have had included also in the statement of the Minister a sum designed to meet the cost of importing butter, but it is now apparent since we have an increase in the price of butter to the consumer here that a profit will be made on the butter now being imported. Consequently, that is one of the little items which will help to expand the amount which the Minister hopes to have in the kitty when he faces the electorate in 12 months' time. But we do not agree about the time factor; we think that he will have recovered from the effects of the campaign by that time.
Already the effects of the increased bank charges have come to roost not alone to the business people, but to local authorities throughout the country. The combination of the troubles in relation to restriction of credit and increased bank charges, added to the increased cost of living, means that we will have from now on— we see in the daily papers where it has already started—demands for increased wages by all people employed by local authorities. Despite the fact that, perhaps, all members of local bodies did not agree in condemning the Budget, they were agreed on the point that the increase in the cost of living warrants an increase to the employees of local authorities—to every road worker and to everybody else paid from rates. Therefore, it is not only by way of direct taxation that the country will suffer. The people will have to meet higher commitments when they get their rate demands, as a result of the application of the provisions of this Budget. This means that many people who felt that they were already severely burdened in that respect will now be called upon to bear a load which we feel they cannot bear. We know the effect on the rent of houses will be considerable and that members of local authorities will certainly be well put to it to find a solution to these new problems which directly arise out of the implementation of this Budget.
Many back benchers in the Fianna Fáil Party have adverted at quite some length to emigration and to unemployment. They were well advised; it shows that at least they have realised much more than the Minister for Finance that these two factors are extremely pertinent to a discussion on the affairs of the country. The Minister read a very lengthy statement in introducing his Budget, but did not refer once to either emigration or unemployment. There was a certain check on unemployment up to recently. In certain classes in the community where certain men were required for essential work it was desirable that a check would be kept on them at the ports. Now that is gone.
As a result we will not know from now on the classes of people who will seek employment abroad, which will certainly be a handicap to the employers who require such labour. One Deputy speaking earlier to-day referred to the high figures of emigration in 1950. They will, of course, appreciate that in that year many thousands left this country on pilgrimages and, therefore, that figure does not truly reflect the numbers that were going abroad to seek employment.