We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Tuarascáil on gCoiste Roghnaitheoireachta. - Finance Bill, 1952—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–137 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1952
Enacted

No. 12 of 1952 ›

Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

In my remarks on the Finance Bill last night I referred to the outstanding feature of the discussion, that the Government had failed to disprove the case made by the former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, that they had in fact budgeted for a surplus. In the weeks which have elapsed since we commenced discussions on the Budget the effects of it have become more evident as day succeeded day. I referred last night to the effect which it will have on the quantity of foodstuffs which the people can afford, especially the working classes. I pointed out that bread, butter and flour and such essential foodstuffs will reach a price beyond the capacity of the poorer sections to pay, and that that will mean that the great increase in the quantity of butter consumed by our people in recent years will be retarded. That will have a bad effect on the health of our people. It is a bad thing that the Government should withdraw the subsidies while foodstuffs are so costly to produce and the costings are so high.

When concluding last night I was addressing my remarks to the effect which the tax on petrol will have on all sections of the community. We are told that it is intended merely to stop some of the unnecessary expenditure on petrol for luxury purposes. It will strike hardest at the business community and, incidentally, upon one of the biggest concerns in the State— Córas Iompair Éireann. It would be superfluous to relate again the circumstances which attended the former increase in the price of petrol. The Party which is now in power were vociferous when they were on this side of the House in charging the inter-Party Government with having been remiss in permitting an increase in the price of petrol, because it would react on bus fares and on all charges, thereby again affecting the working classes. Throughout this country all people engaged in the haulage business are now faced with a very large increase in the price of petrol. It will mean that they will have to pass on that increase to the people whose goods they are transporting. The additional cost of haulage will be reflected in the price our people will have to pay for goods when they go into the shops.

A call is going out to the farmers from various members of the present Cabinet to produce more so that we shall be in a position to export more food and, incidentally, to do with any surplus food imports which we may have at the moment. I do not think that the increase in the price of petrol will in any way assist that idea. I would remind Deputies that, particularly in the constituency which I represent, tractors are not owned by a great number of farmers but that contractors hire out their implements to farmers who cannot afford to buy such machinery. They do the ploughing, the haycutting, and so forth. At the end of the year they attend the harvest operations and they charge so much per day. As a result of the increased price of petrol their charges will, of course, be increased. That, surely, will not facilitate the expressed desire that costings be reduced so that the price of food may be kept at a level which will help to prevent the cost of living from mounting still higher.

In the course of the last general election the then Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, stated in Cork City that if Fianna Fáil were returned to office they would reimpose the taxes which they imposed under their Supplementary Budget in 1947. It was not enough that the candidates going forward in Fianna Fáil's interests in that city should reply to that statement. The Tánaiste, as he now is, spoke in Patrick Street, Cork, on the 12th May of last year and is reported in the Irish Press of the 13th idem to have said:—

"A Coalition Minister had said that Fianna Fáil, if elected, would increase the taxes on beer and tobacco. Why should such taxes be necessary? There is no reason why we should reimpose these taxes."

Not a single indication was given by the Fianna Fáil Party that they would impose taxes which strike hardest on the people.

Was any indication given by the Fianna Fáil Party that if elected to office they would reduce the food subsidies? I say none whatever. In fact, on the day this Government was elected to office one of the Independent Deputies who helped to put it into office said that he intended to vote for Deputy de Valera because he had confidence in the programme which Fianna Fáil published after the people had voted—a programme consisting of 17 points, No. 15 of which related to the maintenance of the food subsidies. We see in this Budget an absolute negation of all that was specifically stated in that manifesto. Consequently we feel that the people are desirous of an opportunity of recording their opinion and that when they get that opportunity they will do so in no uncertain terms.

The policy of this Government has tended to bring about increased unemployment, increased emigration and a stagnation in industry. There is a great danger that that position will now be worsened by demands for wage increases consequent on a rise of 10.2 points in the cost of living which will come into effect next July, and that there will be such chaos that it will be impossible for the country to maintain the progress which it was making under the inter-Party Government. I would impress on the Minister and the Government that the people of the country feel that the Government have not a mandate to pursue this policy which will inflict an unnecessary burden on all sections of the community—a burden of a magnitude not visualised at any time since we attained self-government. It was never conceived that in any Budget the people would be called upon to face such an impost, the result of which must be apparent to everybody, no matter on which side of the House he may sit.

Many people feel that Deputy Costello's claims are justified—that the present Government is budgeting for a surplus and that it is their intention to extract in the coming year from the pockets of the people any few pence which the people might otherwise be able to put aside and to bring that extra money into the Government coffers.

At the end of that period they can turn to the people and say: "See how we have saved the country; here is a well-balanced Budget; here is something left over. Now we can go to the country; we shall take a couple of pence off beer and cigarettes; we shall not touch the food subsidies but that will pass unnoticed in the jubilation arising from the reduction of the taxes on cigarettes and beer. The people will not notice the fact that we recanted everything we said about the food subsidies". Then they will go to the country hoping that the people will give to Fianna Fáil the over-all majority which was their stated goal at the last election.

Deputies Mac Fheórais, Dunne and Cowan rose.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corish.

Comment on this

Before Deputy Corish speaks, I want simply to record a protest against what is happening. I was here sitting in last night and I was next on the list to be called on after Deputy O'Sullivan. Deputy O'Sullivan has spoken against the Budget. As is well known, I was going to speak for the Budget.

Comment on this

In order to save us from being sold to the Americans.

Comment on this

Deputy Corish will speak against the Budget. I am making a respectful protest to the Chair.

Comment on this

You are making a disorderly interruption of Deputy Corish.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is for the Chair to decide.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I respectfully submit that Deputy Cowan's intervention is a disorderly interruption of Deputy Corish and that unless and until Deputy Corish gives way to Deputy Cowan, Deputy Cowan should be told to sit down.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is entitled to make a protest to the Chair.

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He is making a point of order in regard to the procedure of the House.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

He described it as a protest.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I shall hear Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Cowan raising a point of order? If he is, he is entitled to make it, but if he is not raising a point of order, then I respectfully submit that your ruling should be that he is engaging in a disorderly interruption of Deputy Corish.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He is raising a point of order.

Comment on this

He did not say so.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He is raising a point of order as to the way in which Deputies are to be called to speak in this House.

Comment on this

He is questioning your disinterested impartiality.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Cowan, on the point of order.

Comment on this

We all know that Deputy Dillon is the one Deputy who insists on the rights of private Deputies.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair wants to hear the Deputy on the point of order.

Comment on this

The point of order that I am submitting with respect to the Chair is that, having sat in here last night, and having come here this morning, intending to speak on the opposite side to Deputy O'Sullivan, it being the ordinary rule in this House that Deputies on opposing sides are called one after another, I should have been called after Deputy O'Sullivan.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair can only recognise Deputy Cowan as an Independent member of this House belonging to no Party. The Chair has no idea as to whether he is going to speak for or against the Budget.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Or against the Finance Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dillon might allow the Chair to continue without interruption. Independent Deputies cannot expect to be called as members of Parties are. Deputy Cowan can only say he speaks on his own behalf. Deputy Corish, I take it, is speaking on behalf of his Party and, as such, is entitled to precedence. That is the ruling I am making. Deputy Corish.

Comment on this

That is an astonishing constitutional proposition. I understood that every Deputy attending this House as a duly elected member of Dáil Éireann had no Party existence in the eyes of the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair must take cognisance of the fact that a Deputy is speaking for a Party, and therefore is entitled to precedence.

Comment on this

With profound respect, I wish to be put on record as dissenting from that ruling.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy can dissent as much as he likes.

Comment on this

I also wish to protest against your ruling, and I shall raise it before the Committee on Procedure and Privileges.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corish.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The Minister for Finance, in his introduction of the Bill and in his treatment of the Budget, went to great pains to quote the statement issued by the Trade Union Congress. He tried to give the impression to the House that in the majority of their statements, the Irish Trade Union Congress were more or less in favour of the Budget, and that the statement of the congress supported many of the observations that he had made on the economic situation in which the country finds itself. He attempted, as a matter of fact, to attribute to the statements of the Trade Union Congress a denial of the allegations by the Leader of the Opposition that the figure of £15,000,000 as a deficit was an incorrect figure. As usual, the Minister, whilst he did not misquote, did not finish his quotations. He picked out small separated paragraphs in the Trade Union Congress statement that suited his purpose. I think that if he were honest with the House he would recognise, as will any member of the House who cares to read the statement issued by the Trade Union Congress, that that statement was a scathing attack on the proposals contained in the Budget and in the Finance Bill which we are now discussing.

I merely want to quote one paragraph which has been so often quoted by the Minister and other members of the Fianna Fáil Party, with regard to the gap of £15,000,000. Page 5 of the Trade Union Congress statement says:—

"Firstly, it is necessary to discover whether or not the figure of £15,000,000 constitutes the gap in the current Budget. We do not doubt for a moment, despite suggestions to the contrary, that the various estimates both of revenue and expenditure were made as accurately as forecasting of this nature would allow."

The Minister did not quote the next sentence.

"Nevertheless, they remain estimates."

I think the Leader of the Opposition is entitled to challenge these figures. I think he made, in respect to many of his statments, a very good case as to why many of the Estimates presented by the Minister could be wrong. In any case the view as expressed by the Labour Party is the view I expressed this morning. I make a present of this to the Minister for the sake of my argument, that it is necessary to raise £15,000,000 to balance the Budget but the objection which we raise from this side of the House is to the method by which the Fianna Fáil Government proposes to raise this money. That is a simple issue. I suggest, therefore, that the reasonable comment, the comment of the majority of the people of this country, on the Budget is that it is totally unfair, unjust and especially unwarranted in view of the situation in which the country finds itself at present.

One thing which the Minister, in his introduction of this Bill and in speaking to the Budget, avoided saying was whether or not we were heading in this country towards inflation or deflation. I submit that if there were signs of an inflationary trend in this country, the Minister would be justified in some of the proposals contained in the Finance Bill but inasmuch as we are in a period of deflation, and that it is likely that that trend will be accentuated, this is the worst type of Budget that could be introduced.

In his reply, the Minister should tell the country, through the medium of this House, whether he believes we are in for a period of inflation or a period of deflation. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass, had no hesitation in making up his mind. Sometimes he is regarded here as the leader of the Government or the leader of the Fianna Fáil Party, and a considered statement by him on our economic situation should be taken very seriously. Speaking in Dáil Éireann on 25th March, the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, said:

"Almost every country in the world which, like ourselves, was concerned at the beginning of this year or towards the end of last year, at the danger of the inflationary forces, which were then active, getting out of hand, are now no longer worried, any more than we are, about the danger of runaway inflation. They are beginning to get much more worried about the possibility of deflation, of the downward spiral beginning to move."

I do not know whether he got that idea or that view from the Chancellor of the British Exchequer who, introducing the British Budget, spoke in more or less the same terms.

This is the worst Budget that could be introduced if, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce says, there is a deflationary trend. If it were inflation, it might be necessary or desirable to draw money from the taxpayers to deprive them of a certain amount of purchasing power, but in a deflationary situation surely that is not the remedy the Budget should propose. If there is a deflationary trend, this Budget will accentuate that trend.

While some people challenge our right to speak for the trade union movement, that is a responsibility which we undertake. We do not say that we get the majority of the support of the trade unionists of this country—that could be argued inside out—but at least we take this responsibility in this House and the trade union movement recognises that we take that responsibility of speaking for organised labour in this House. We must be concerned for the trade union movement with regard to the effects of this Budget.

The question of the withdrawal of the food subsidies has been mentioned at length. Bread will be increased in price by 38 per cent. from 1st July, sugar by 63 per cent., butter by 28 per cent. and it is expected that the price of tea will be increased by 100 per cent. In my opinion and in the opinion of those who have examined the figures, that will mean that the cost-of-living index—which we all agree is no real gauge of the actual cost of living—will go up by approximately one-eighth. Taking into consideration the increases in other items not included in the index—cigarettes, tobacco, stout, clothing and other things used from day to day — compared to January, 1951, in July of this year the cost of living will have risen by approximately 25 per cent. Now, 25 per cent. in a short period of 18 months is too steep an increase to be borne by the workers and the small farmers.

I have been taken to task by the Minister and other speakers on account of what was reported from my speech in some of the daily papers. I said rhetorically that this Budget would not put Chrysler cars off the road, that it would not prevent people from buying mink coats, that it would not prevent people who were in the habit of going to every race meeting in the country the whole year round, still going. I do not think anyone could misconstrue my mind or my remarks when I said that in my last speech. I venture to remark that there are people in my constituency who drive Chrysler cars and I have friends who wear mink coats and who vote for me. The Minister speaking here on Tuesday said that I wanted to deprive people of mink coats.

Comment on this

I regret to say that I could see no other implication in the Deputy's remarks.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

If the Minister is so stupid as to believe that I wanted to prevent people wearing mink coats or driving Chrysler cars——

Comment on this

And going to race meetings.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

—he is still more stupid than I thought he was.

Comment on this

That may be, but there it is.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

I wanted to convey to the Minister—it is not necessary to convey it to the ordinary people—that this Budget falls infinitely more heavily on the working class than on those who can afford to buy mink coats or drive Chrysler cars or attend all the race meetings held during the year. That is the one thing that has made the people so indignant, so mad at the Minister for Finance— to say that he wants £15,000,000 and proposes to get the bulk of it by depriving people of cheap butter, bread and sugar and by asking them to pay more for cigarettes and a bottle of stout. That is why I say this Budget does nothing to prevent people from still doing the things I have mentioned but does something to prevent people from eating more bread and butter at the present time.

Despite the comments of certain newspapers, our antics here on Tuesday were more in amusement at the Minister for Finance when he made his 35-minute apology for the abolition of the dance tax. He spent 35 minutes in an endeavour to tell the people and to explain to Deputies who sit behind him why he abolished the dance tax. He quoted Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Dillon and Deputy Cafferky as those who opposed the abolition of the dance tax in 1946. He attempted, whether dishonestly or not, to say that I spoke on Resolution No. 9 of the Budget in 1946 and that I welcomed wholeheartedly the abolition of the dance tax. Is the Minister trying to be dishonest? Is he trying to be just smart or does he imagine that no one but himself takes the trouble of looking back over the debates that took place here?

For the purpose of the record, and not for the information of the Minister because I know exactly what I said in 1946, I should like to quote what I said on that particular occasion. Speaking on Resolution No. 9 at column 102 of Volume 101 of the Official Report, I said:

"Another concession which should appeal to younger folk in the country is the abolition of the dance tax in its entirety. I am for and against the abolition of this tax."

The Minister could not understand how I could be for and against the abolition of the tax:—

"I think my argument is very reasonable. There are in this country, more so than in any other country in Europe a number of societies, religious; semi-religious and charitable, who run dances frequently for no other purpose except to raise funds for the benefit of the community and for such things as Catholic action, boy scouts, etc. Dances are also frequently promoted by sports clubs and football clubs. I am in thorough agreement with the abolition of the tax so far as these people are concerned because if the Minister and his officials knew what it cost to run a dance at the present day they would certainly realise that a whole lot of money cannot be made for these societies if a tax is levied."

Further on, I said:—

"I am, however, very much surprised to see that the Minister will allow commercial dances to be run free of tax as from the 1st August."

Did the Minister then understand that? Did the Minister understand that my concern was——

Comment on this

To be on both sides of the fence.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Has the Minister finished?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

——concern was for the football clubs and the other societies and organisations that run dances to support their clubs and organisations. My concern was not then, nor is it now, for the dance hall proprietors and the commercial dance halls. I will not labour the point. The Opposition speakers have attributed to the Minister what I believe to be the motive behind the abolition of this tax; it is to curry favour with the dance hall proprietors and have them contribute to the Fianna Fáil cumanns.

The dance tax is a very small part of the Budget. It will amount to only £140,000 in a full year, but the irony of the situation is that the Minister makes a present of so much money to the dance hall proprietors at a time when he believes the economy of this country is in grave danger and, on the other hand, asks the people to pay more for bread, butter, tea and sugar. Does he appreciate that that is the real reason why there is such a volume of criticism from the Opposition Benches? Does he appreciate that that is the real reason why there was such a volume of criticism in the the course of the Budget discussion from the members of his own Party who sit behind him?

The Minister may talk about the problem of people holding dances five miles away from their ordinary habitation in order to evade the tax in the rural areas. He can talk about the danger of drunken drivers and the debauchery that goes on. The fact remains that the abolition of this tax in the present situation is ironical. It is an insult to the people to repeal the tax on dancing and at the same time ask them to pay more for bread, butter, tea, sugar and for cigarettes and a bottle of stout.

We can come to only one conclusion. The principal reason why the tax was repealed was obviously to induce the dance hall proprietors to subscribe even more to the funds of the Fianna Fáil Party for the pending by-elections or perhaps for the next general election. These quotations from Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Dillon, Deputy Cafferky and myself in relation to the proposal in the 1946 Budget are just so much eyewash when we consider the present situation.

The Minister did not mention one word in relation to the withdrawal of the food subsidies. When I suggested he might mention food subsidies in his introductory speech on the Finance Bill the Minister, being such a great upholder of order and decorum here, said there was no provision for the withdrawal of the food subsidies in the Finance Bill. A very simple and a very clever way out. No matter what people may think about the increase in cigarettes, tobacco, stout, petrol and income-tax, the one thing that really concerns them at the present time is that, while they may be able to do without cigarettes or perhaps not smoke so many, and while they may be able to drink two bottles of stout in future instead of their customary three, the four items to which subsidies were applied were, still are, and always will be, the staffs of life. The people must buy these things.

Despite the furore created here and the furore throughout the country, the Minister never attempted in his introduction of the Finance Bill — and he did not do it in his Budget statement— to give any justification for the withdrawal of the food subsidies. These subsidies were first introduced to close the gap that existed between rates of wages and the cost of living. That gap has not yet been closed. Only when that gap is closed, then, and only then, should we consider a withdrawal of food subsidies.

I wonder why Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll wanted an assurance from the Fine Gael Party in relation to the restoration of food subsidies? Why the Fine Gael Party? I never thought Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll was particularly attracted to the Fine Gael Party. He had an assurance from the Labour Party. He had an assurance from the Clann na Poblachta Party. Why was he so wedded to the Fine Gael Party? He did not get any assurance with regard to either food subsidies or increased taxes from the Fianna Fáil Party. Indeed, even if there had been a specific statement from the Fine Gael Party with regard to food subsidies before Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll spoke, he would probably have asked then for an assurance from Independent Deputy Fagan. Anything for a way out.

The withdrawal of the food subsidies will, in my opinion, mean that the tourists will in future get cheaper food. I think I am correct in saying that. The tourist over the past few years was in the habit of paying extra for tea, bread, butter and sugar. In future he will get his food cheaper. I do not want to turn tourists away; I want to see as many tourists as possible coming into the country. But why should tourists get cheaper food as a result of the Minister's Budget? Why should tourists from America, from England or from any other country get cheaper food here from the 1st July next while our own working-class people, who can ill afford it, will have to pay more? To my mind that is an ironical way of encouraging the tourist industry. The tourists who come in here spend a good deal of money. The ordinary people do not understand why the tourists should in future get cheaper food while they themselves will have to pay more.

We export from this country at the present time foodstuffs or goods with a sugar content. The people who manufacture these goods will, in future, get their sugar cheaper. The cost of sugar will be cheaper to the factories. Does that mean that exports of chocolate crumb, jam and biscuits and so on will be cheaper in future on the British market?

Comment on this

Like the export of boots.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The point I want to make is this. They have been getting sugar at the top price, and now they will get it at a lower price. Will there be any change in the price which they will charge either inside or outside this country, and does it mean, in respect of chocolate crumb, jam and biscuits or in respect of any foodstuffs that have a sugar content, that these goods will be sold cheaper than they are at present on the British market from the 1st July next, and what effect will that have on the balance of payments about which the Minister is so very much concerned?

The Minister queried my figure when I said that the Finance Bill and the Budget, on which I was then speaking, gave to the cigarette and tobacco manufacturers of this country nearly £1,000,000. Again, I want to say that I reckon that figure to be £.9 million. Exception, I think, could not be taken if I gave the wrong figure of £1,000,000. I base that figure on this calculation, and if I am wrong I hope the Minister will correct me, that the Budget statement says that the 6d. increase in taxation which it was proposed to put on the packet of cigarettes would bring in to the Minister £5,500,000. I reckon, therefore, that 1d. should bring in £.9 million. As I say, if I am wrong I am open to correction by the Minister. If I divide six into £5,500,000 I get £.9 million. That is the basis of my calculation, and that is the reason why I give the figure of £.9 million. In any case, the Minister took me to task, and asked did I want to see unemployment in these Irish firms manufacturing cigarettes and blending and manufacturing tobacco. I did not. I want to see Carroll's progress and I want to see Sweet Afton sold and smoked. It is rather ludicrous, however, to suggest that Wills' and Player's are in need of any assistance from this State.

Comment on this

Do you want to close these factories down in the City of Dublin? Is that the policy of the Labour Party?

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It is not the policy of the Labour Party any more than it is to smash windows.

Comment on this

That is what the Irish Press calls his incisive northern accent.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Is there any indication that these two firms, which supply the majority of cigarettes in this country, are on the verge of bankruptcy? I do not know why Wills' or Gold Flake or Player's sell more than Sweet Afton; maybe it is a squeeze on the part of these two on Sweet Afton; maybe it is that Sweet Afton is an inferior cigarette and maybe it is that an inferior tobacco is used in it, or maybe it is that there is a squeeze from the Imperial Tobacco Company. I am making these suggestions to the Minister so that he will clarify the position for the country, and so that the people will get some reason as to why nearly £1,000,000 should be given to these cigarette and tobacco manufacturers.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not think that that question should be addressed to the representative of the Trade Union Congress who sits on the Prices Advisory Body which recommended this increase?

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The Minister was not always so fond of the Prices Advisory Tribunal, and he must remember, as a Minister in Government, that it is the Minister for Industry and Commerce who has the final say. The Minister for Finance may also have a say in it, but is it unreasonable to ask the Minister for Finance whether or not the people who manufacture Gold Flake and Player's cigarettes are on the verge of bankruptcy? I will take his word if it is Carroll's, Ruddle's and other Irish firms are meant, but I cannot for the life of me understand why the other two big cigarette manufacturers should have a present made to them of a substantial portion of this £.9 million.

Comment on this

Because Deputy Norton's Prices Advisory Body so recommended it.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Would the Minister answer the question that I put to him? Are the Imperial Tobacco Company, Wills' and Player's on the verge of bankruptcy if they do not get a substantial portion of this £.9 million? Will it mean that the workers in their factories in the City of Dublin will be sent on the unemployment list? I only want to ask him that question.

Comment on this

Apparently the Deputy seems — I am sorry for interrupting the Deputy.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

I am glad to give way.

Comment on this

I should like to put this question to the Deputy in order that we may have the matter made clear.

Comment on this

I demur from this reason —in order to have the matter thoroughly confused.

Comment on this

I appreciate the courtesy of Deputy Corish in permitting me to put this question. Is his case this: that the subsidiaries of the Imperial Tobacco Company should be permitted to sell their cigarettes at ld. per packet cheaper than Carroll's, and that Carroll's, the Irish-owned tobacco manufacturers, should be permitted to increase their price by ld. per packet? If that is his contention, I would like him to say what is likely to happen to Carroll's output, and how many of Carroll's cigarettes would be sold at ld. per packet of 20 dearer than those sold by the Irish subsidiaries of the Imperial Tobacco Company?

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Perhaps it might be a better solution to provide such assistance for Carroll's that they would be able to sell their cigarettes at ½d. or ld. per packet cheaper than Wills' or Player's?

Comment on this

Then we are to have selective taxation?

Comment on this

So you have.

Comment on this

Discriminatory taxation.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The Fianna Fáil Government have always boasted that their policy was to protect Irish industry, and if the Minister wants to do that, that is another way of doing it. Will the Minister answer the question, whether or not Wills' and Player's in this country and their subsidiaries are on the verge of bankruptcy?

The Minister took the Trade Union Congress and the Labour Party to task for their advocacy of the excess profits tax and he quoted the case of Socialist Britain. I think anyone will agree that the present Minister for Finance is far removed from Socialist Britain. Again, that is an apology as to why he cannot touch these people, and why our Minister for Finance will not touch the excess profits tax. He will not attempt to touch those people who have over £5,000 a year, and, further, he will not attempt to tax people who have salaries ranging over £2,000 per year because he says: "Look, for God's sake, leave them alone; if we tax them too much they will run out of the country." But he spent a quarter of an hour here the other night trying to tell us why he should not tax those people. He said that these people had their money in this country, and that, even if we were only to get £500,000 or £1,000,000 off them, we should not do anything that would disturb them in this country; but at one fell blow, by one stroke of his pen, he determines that the people will pay £8,000,000 more for their bread, butter, tea and sugar. In his own words, he said if he attempted to tamper with surtax he would drive the 700 people who were in the region of £5,000 per year out of the country.

Spleen would be attributed to me— I suppose will be attributed to me— because I ask that the people who have over £5,000 per year could bear just a little extra. I do not want to deny them their £5,000. I am not jealous of their £5,000. I do not want to see the £5,000 taken from them entirely and distributed amongst ten people. I merely want to put this simple suggestion to the Minister: if the ordinary family of five will have to pay at least 10/- extra for these four foodstuffs from 1st July next, if they will have to pay an extra £26 per year, surely the Minister could ask these people who are in the £5,000 bracket, the people who do make excess profits, the people who have Chrysler cars, who can buy mink coats, who can go to every race meeting, to bear proportionately a little more or even to bear proportionately what the man who has £5 per week is bearing.

The excess profits tax, the Minister says, would not be a good tax because it would encourage extravagance and would be too hard to collect. These may be fairly good excuses for departmental officials. They may be good excuses for the people who would be charged with collecting them. Surely it is not unreasonable to say that if there is a prospect of getting from excess profits, £6,000,000, £7,000,000 or £8,000,000 during next year it would be worth while getting after excess profits. The Minister may say that as far as this country is concerned it would not be any encouragement to business and industry here to expand.

Comment on this

What I will say is that there is no possibility of getting anything like that sum.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The Minister's opinion, I suppose, I will not say is as good, but may be far better than mine. I am entitled to advocate again that the extra profits levy or the excess profits tax be considered and be exacted. If the Minister is right when he says that this would be no encouragement for Irish industry, I would suggest that there would be compensation for the business or industry that would show evidence of wanting to expand their particular line of business or industry; that there would be some compensation by way of tax refund to those people who would plough back their profits into industry, to the people who would replace old machinery, to the business or industry that would bring their premises, factories or workshops up to date. I suggest that there could be many compensatory advances made to those people who showed evidence of being genuine and sincere in their efforts to expand and to make their industry or business progressive.

I said that the Minister was very solicitous for the 700 people who are in the £5,000 per annum bracket. The taxes and the cost of foodstuffs, I venture to remark, are higher in Britain. I think these gentlemen will think twice and three times before they leave this country, bad as the Minister says it is. I think the Minister might take a little courage in his hands and make an attempt to exact from people who have, for the purpose of balancing the Budget, so as to relieve the burden on those who have not and who can ill-afford to do what the Minister expects them to do in the coming 12 months.

He is solicitous, as I said, about these people. The Minister is afraid that, by touching certain rich people, he will drive them out of the country, but he is not a bit concerned for those people who, as a result of this Budget, will be left unemployed. He is not a bit concerned for the fact that those people will fly very much quicker than the people whom he is afraid to approach or to touch. They are doing it at the present time. They are going through Rosslare, Dún Laoghaire and the North Wall, flying across to Britain as fast as they can. This, from the Party who promised—it is not right, I suppose, to twit them about their election promises of 1932—to bring back the emigrants. Every single Fianna Fáil member behind the Minister knows that, as a result of this Budget, emigration will increase, because unemployment will increase. Emigration is a consequence of unemployment in this country.

I do not think there is anything more I want to say on the Finance Bill, but again may I revert to the Irish Trade Union Congress statement? The Minister gave much publicity to this statement, but he omitted to read some paragraphs. I quote one which sums up the attitude of the Irish Trade Union Congress to this infamous Budget. On page 5 of the statement there is this paragraph:

"Our principal criticisms of the Budget are therefore (a) that it imposes intolerable and insupportable burdens on the masses of the people,"

—does any Fianna Fáil Deputy deny that?—

(b) that it does violence to the principle of social justice in that the effect of the Budget changes is to impose relatively greater hardships on the poor than on the rich, (c) that it will cause a substantial increase in unemployment and emigration, (d) that its contribution to the real problems facing us is essentially negative, and (e) that it will hinder progress towards industrial expansion and economic stability. These are severe criticisms but we seriously and sincerely believe them to be entirely justified."

Any member of the House who reads that paragraph, in his own conscience if not verbally, must readily admit that these five criticisms by the Trade Union Congress are the criticisms that would be levelled against this Budget, not alone by every Deputy, but by every working man and every member of his family.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance politely inquired if Deputy Corish would give way while he clarified a matter that was obscure. I will give way to afford the Minister for Finance an opportunity now of clarifying something that is obscure. Deputy Captain Cowan stated last night deliberately that the justification for this Budget is that the Minister for Finance has before him only two alternatives; to scourge our people with the provisions of this Budget or the inevitable alternative of selling Ireland into subjection to the United States Treasury. Deputy Cowan says that, rather than see Ireland sold, he asks the people and his own constituents to sustain him in casting his vote for this Budget, which nothing could justify except the desperate need to preserve the independence of Ireland from sale for American dollars to the American Government. I will give way now for the Minister for Finance to say is that true or false. Will he answer it? Will he answer? Look at him. There he sits like a miserable mumchance, resting for his authority——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Expressions of that kind are entirely unsuited to Parliament.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon sold his independence a few days ago.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair will deal with Deputy Dillon. Expressions of that kind are unsuited to Parliament and should not be used.

Comment on this

And Deputy Dillon looks quite similar——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputy Burke please allow me?

Comment on this

"Mumchance" is a word I borrowed from Alfred, Lord Tennyson, but if you do not approve of it, Sir, I will very gladly withdraw it. I understood it to be classical and complimentary, but if Tennysonian English is disorderly, I withdraw it without qualification.

Look at that silent man! He is depending and his Government is depending for their existence on the vote of Deputy Captain Cowan. Deputy Captain Cowan is going before his constituents to say: "I have betrayed every undertaking; I have reneged on every promise; I have gone back on every ground on which I sought the suffrage of the voters of Dublin. Why? Because I have it in confidential information from the Government I now support that this Budget, with all the burdens it lays upon the people and which controverts every principle I defended in public life, is made necessary by the supreme consideration that nothing else will protect the sovereignty and independence of Ireland from sale for dollars to the United States Government." Unless that is true, Deputy Captain Cowan says he would vote against the Budget and that Government would fall.

There sitting opposite is the Minister representing that Government who not ten minutes ago asked and got the leave of a Deputy speaking to intervene to clarify a matter relating to tobacco taxation. I now offer him leave to clarify the statement made by Deputy Captain Cowan. Does he speak truth or does he speak falsehood? The Minister should tell the House and the House has a right to know. I want to know. Does Deputy Captain Cowan speak for the Government when he says that? Is the United States Government seeking to purchase the sovereignty and independence of this country for dollars? Is the necessity for this Budget that the domestic resources must be mobilised to prevent that sale and purchase being made? I will give way for the Minister to answer and the question can be answered monosyllabically. All I want is a "yes" or "no" to that question. Is the story told by Deputy Captain Cowan true or false? I dare the Minister to tell us now "yes" or "no" and I will give way for him to do so.

Look at him! Look at the miserable figure of a Minister who depends for his existence on the vote of a Deputy of whom he is manifestly ashamed! Where now are the incisive northern accents of the sprightly Minister for Finance? Where now is the commanding presence of the resourceful debater who can turn the sword on any assailant? Was there ever a more degraded spectacle in the public life of this country than a Minister who depends for his existence on the vote of a man whom he is ashamed to adopt and whom he does not dare to repudiate? Was ever political servitude more revolting than that of a creature who is prepared to claim the right to govern this country by the suffrage of a task master whose chains he must wear?

Comment on this

He was all right when he kept you as Minister for Agriculture for three years. He was a gentleman then.

Comment on this

The proudest boast I have is that it was his vote destroyed our Government and that on his vote this Government rests. That Government has sunk to this level: that it claims the right to live and to govern by the suffrage of a man it is afraid to repudiate and ashamed to vindicate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dillon has said the same thing in different words three or four times. Perhaps he would now come to the motion that the Bill be now read a Second Time.

Comment on this

In my respectful submission every syllable I have uttered to date is strictly relevant.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has repeated himself in different words several times.

Comment on this

Let the argument develop, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Repetition is against the rules of order.

Comment on this

Tennysonian language has been ruled out of order and I conclude that anything which differs from certain other standards must also fall. However, neither the dilatory progress of eloquence nor anything else will persuade the Minister for Finance to accept now what he is offered willingly, though he was so eager to claim it a quarter of an hour ago. Lest his hearing be defective to-day or his understanding slow, I want to tell him again that, now or at any time before I conclude, I will give way for as long as he wants to intervene to tell us whether Deputy Captain Cowan belongs to him or whether he belongs to Deputy Captain Cowan.

Let us face the fact. The policy of this Budget is clear and—to give the devil his due—has been proclaimed. It is this: our people are eating too much and living too well and the time has come to cut down their victuals, to reduce their consumption and to see that these commodities pass into the channel which the Central Bank and the Treasury think they should pass into, so that the Central Bank and the Treasury may use the proceeds for the accumulation of good respectable British consolidated stocks for the better protection of our currency and our Government funds. Is that true or not? Is that not Fianna Fáil policy —our people are eating too much and living too well; it is time to bring them down, to bring them back to a sense of realisation that God made them peasants and they ought to be proud and content to be respectable and respectful as peasants; and that if they dare to aspire to a standard of living not consistent with that our new Tory Party in this country— Fianna Fáil—will put them in their place and see that peace and quiet and calm and confidence will rule again in College Green and Foster Place?

Are not the members of the Fianna Fáil Party ashamed to be made instruments of that policy? Let us take the issue clearly that is joined between us. Fine Gael does not believe that God fixed the eternal destiny for our people to be pauper peasants. We believe that the destiny He fixed for this country and our people was as glorious as that for any country in the world and that our people, starting from abject poverty as the poorest peasants in Europe, have pushed forward steadily from starvation to sufficiency, from the servitude of tenants to the freedom of freeholders, from the wretchedness of a subject nation to that of an independent Republic, have now the right and their Government the duty to use the resources of this country, not for the accumulation of sterile savings in British Government securities primarily, but primarily for the development of this country and the winning for our people in Ireland a standard of living better than they had enjoyed heretofore and which we are satisfied they can and should have now.

Fianna Fáil policy is to cut down their victuals, reduce their consumption and export the proceeds and, as they grow poorer, to view with satisfaction a decline in imports. What more certain index is there of a falling standard of living than declining imports? Can anyone point to any nation in the world that raised the people's standard of living contemporaneously with a decline in their international trade? That is Fianna Fáil policy.

What is the policy of the Fine Gael Party? It is clear and certain. I am going to submit that, even if there was only three years in which to prove it, it proved itself dramatically. It is that, instead of trying artificially to depress the level of imports, we should expand our profitable exports until they are sufficient to pay for all our people require and that, whatever capital investment is necessary to that end, we should make it fearlessly, not from taxes levied from the poor, but from the millions that are available to a hard-working and solvent people resolved to employ them prudently and wisely.

Our policy was as clear as crystal. We brought it before the Dáil in a dual Budget, and we said that as to £72,000,000 of our annual expenditure, that is for a annually recurring charges which must be met out of annually recurring revenue, and that as to £9,000,000, these are capital projects and once that expenditure is made it need never recur again without the annual demand and approval of the Legislature. We funded that £9,000,000 over 30 years and, lest anyone might be tempted hereafter to fall down on amortisation duty, we made it a charge on the Central Fund.

Comment on this

You spent the money.

Comment on this

The Minister was as silent as Tennyson would have described it, but which I may not. Let him not quack now. I never mistake his version of Falls Road courtesy for anything but the birdlime that it is. We charged it on the Central Fund, but, before spending the money, we gave notice to the House that, if it authorised us to make this capital investment of £9,000,000, it meant that, for 30 years ahead, there would be an annual charge on the Budget of such and such a sum. That procedure was described by the present Minister for Finance as fraudulent, as disreputable, as concealing debts, as budgeting for a deficit under highfalutin' terms, and as a procedure which he would never soil his sanctimonious reputation with. Yet, when the time came to present his Budget, with his tail down, trailing along the floor behind him, there never was a biped with a caudal appendage—let me choose my words with care and with super-Tennysonian precautions——

Comment on this

Do not let your memory betray you after all the rehearsal you put into it.

Comment on this

I will not let my memory betray me.

Comment on this

Do not let your memory betray you after all the rehearsal you put into it.

Comment on this

The disgrace of the Minister is something I shall long remember because in his degradation we were all degraded. He came in here trailing his tail behind him——

Comment on this

Do not muff your lines.

Comment on this

What he said was fraudulent, what he said was disreputable and what he said disgraced financial procedure, was what he proposed himself to do. I grant that he blushed and to bring a blush to that leathery countenance requires much. He blushed and he blushes now, poor man, and so long as he serves under the rhinoceros-hide whip of Deputy Captain Cowan he will have many occasions to blush hereafter. He adopted that procedure of the dual Budget to redeem the money borrowed for capital purposes. He was right but he should have shaken dust and ashes on his head before he asked this House to approve of that departure on his part. He wound up his Budget speech on which this Finance Bill is founded and he charged his colleague, the Tánaiste, to make the same demand as he made in his concluding words:—

"Tell us, in common reason, why should we produce proposals of this kind if they were not urgently necessary?"

That is a fair question and I will stand or fall by the veracity and accuracy of my reply which I now make.

This Budget and this Finance Bill have two purposes. I ask the House to remember that the campaign to justify it began nine months ago. I now assert that that campaign began when it was decided to put Deputy de Valera, the present Taoiseach, out to grass. Deputy Flanagan, of South Mayo, says that he is a fossil who should be put over in the Museum with his boots. I do not say that but I say that the campaign was launched when Fianna Fáil took the decision to put de Valera out to grass. A long, bitter, acrimonious wrangle was going on in the Fianna Fáil Party room as to whether Deputy Aiken or Deputy Lemass should enjoy the succession.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has no reference to the Bill.

Comment on this

I am saying that I have been asked across the floor of the House: "Why did we bring in this Budget if it was not necessary?" I am answering and I have the right to do so. The Government have no right to ask me the question whether there was urgent financial need for the Budget or whether it was necessary to bring it in unless I have the right to answer. It was put by the Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, and by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass. I say that the Minister for Industry and Commerce ultimately won, that he then went to the Minister for Finance and put him this proposal: "You want to get out of public life; you want to retire to enjoy your parliamentary salary, your pension and the income from your fine businesses as consulting engineer. To that I am prepared to add the assurance that you will have a directorship of the Industrial Credit Corporation, the Agricultural Credit Corporation, Mianraí Teóranta and one or two other directorships in my gift——"

Comment on this

What was going to be left to the rest?

Comment on this

"——if you will carry the baby of introducing a Budget which will produce so substantial a surplus that I will have at the end of the financial year approximately £10,000,000 in hand and an excess revenue within my capacity during the ensuing year of £7,000,000. We want to put the old man out to grass. I can distribute largesse all over the place. Some of the hungry young warriors in the Party who are inclined to favour Deputy Aiken I can put in parliamentary positions and the disappointed like Deputy Allen, who hoped to get Tom Walsh's job, will get a step up. I will consolidate the Party in the absence of the Chief and God knows but I might be able to find some permanent niche for the busted flush, the two pairs, the threes or whatever is left, if anything is left of them, by the time I take over and start to prepare the ground for a general election in June in which with £17,000,000 in hand to distribute I should be able to do pretty well." Does that answer the Minister's query why he should introduce this Budget? The answer is because he hopes to be on velvet for the rest of his life and the Tánaiste who is an ambitious energetic young man hopes to get where for many a long day he never dared hope to get— into de Valera's boots while they are still warm.

That is plain talk but it is the truth and every Deputy in the Fianna Fáil Party knows that it is the truth. I see with amusement Lemass, Traynor, Boland, Briscoe and the Lemass gang squaring off to the Aiken rump whenever it puts its nose in. I saw Deputy Aiken, the Minister for External Affairs, demonstrating in one of the funniest speeches ever made in this House—I will deal with it later—in Volume 131, No. 5, what a great financier he is. I am told that since he became acting-Minister for Industry and Commerce hair or hide of him has not been shown in the Department of External Affairs because he wants to show that anything Lemass can do he can do better. This House is getting crowded with Annie Oakleys.

I remember Deputy de Valera, the present Taoiseach, when he was Leader of the Opposition whirling his petticoats á la Annie Oakley, when he was trying to scramble with his 17 point programme into the Government. He got in, point 15 of those 17 points being "We will never reduce the food subsidies." Then that dashing versatile gambler on his left suddenly got the brilliant idea that he might Annie Oakley the Chief. I think that he has done it but what he forgot was that there was a larger, more formidable Annie Oakley on his left and that Aiken has got the skirt on now and is whirling its frills in an Annie Oakley caracola which might yet split the Fianna Fáil Party. That is a danger none of them has reckoned with.

Comment on this

There is not a hope.

Comment on this

Hoarse and hollow laughs. Who is going to whistle now?

Comment on this

Did you sleep well last night?

Comment on this

Nobody can afford to sleep well in this country until we have rooted you out but we will root this Government out and shortly with two instruments, the truth and the votes of the people. The Minister for Finance has sought to make the case that his economic problems have been greatly exacerbated by the shortage of dollars because the inter-Party Government got 41,000,000 dollars from America and spent it all and that he has to find the money to pay the debt. I want to say now in his presence where he can intervene—and I will give way to let him clarify the matter if he wishes—that the day we left office the Government of Ireland owed to the United States Government £40,000,000.

Comment on this

It was at night.

Comment on this

Who is this poor fellow? Perhaps the Minister for Finance will intervene to tell me who is this colleague of his.

Comment on this

He is a better man than you are.

Comment on this

That would not be difficult, but who is he?

Comment on this

He is suffering from what happened yesterday.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

It was at night you left.

Comment on this

Keep quiet. He is a ridiculous looking specimen but he should not sound ridiculous. The day we left office——

Comment on this

The night.

Comment on this

——£40,000,000 was due to the United States Government and I now say that the Minister for Finance had £41,000,000 at his disposal wherewith to meet that debt on the day we left office, of which £27,000,000 was in the form of Irish Government securities and £24,000,000 was in the form of hard cash. There were on Deputy MacEntee's desk when he walked in to become Minister for Finance, 24 individual bags in each of which was £1,000,000 in legal tender. Mark the words "in legal tender". He had the option, if he wished to employ it, of saying to his secretary: "Take those bags in each of which there is £1,000,000; put them in the corner of my office and as each instalment falls due on the American loan for the next 20 years go to the corner, take out one of those bags of legal tender, go round to Merrion Square and place them on the American Ambassador's desk." If there is one syllable of that which is false I stand convicted. Now I will give way if the Minister wishes to deny that. Does he deny it? No, and I do not wish to shorten his time.

Comment on this

The Deputy is very anxious that I should deal with the questions put to me——

Comment on this

I want you to deal with Deputy Cowan's observations, too. I will give you plenty of time.

Comment on this

I am not going to go back and rehash the Deputy's speech for him again.

Comment on this

Deal with either.

Comment on this

We are having enough shepherd's pie from the Deputy this morning.

Comment on this

Is that all you have to say?

Comment on this

The Deputy said there is £46,000,000 worth of dollar obligations——

Comment on this

£40,000,000.

Comment on this

£46,000,000. I am giving the Deputy the right figure. There was £46,000,000 worth of dollar obligations on the day on which he left office. That is a fact. He said there was £24,000,000 on my desk.

Comment on this

£23,000,000.

Comment on this

Now, will the Deputy tell us what he did with the other £22,000,000?

Comment on this

Yes, yes. We invested it in the land of Ireland. We invested it in homes for our people, and we have put an end to the system of lending it to the British Government at 1? per cent. Were we wrong?

Comment on this

I will tell you what you did with it.

Comment on this

That is what we did, and we hold to-day Irish Government securities for £28,000,000 from the day we left office. Is there anyone in this House who considers that the securities of the Government of Ireland are in any respect inferior to the Government securities of Great Britain? I do not think they are, and if you go to the Stock Exchange and ask what the hoariest money-changer thinks of our securities he will tell you the same. But we are told in this House that, if you hold Irish Government securities, you hold nothing but debts due by peasants. But if you hold 2½ per cent. consolidated stock of the Government of Great Britain, what do you hold?— a promise that they will pay you £2 10/- in their money once a year for every £100 that they had from you. They will never pay your money back, and the £2 10/- they pay you now is worth about 16/-.

Comment on this

We will give you that next July.

Comment on this

This is the first declaration we have had from them that they are going to the country. Am I to interpret that from Deputy Carter as a declaration that the Government are going to face the music in July?

Comment on this

Suitably armed.

Comment on this

"Suitably armed." That Delphic observation calls to mind that we have had the civil war declared upon us by the Fianna Fáil Party; we have had the economic war declared upon the Irish people by the Fianna Fáil Party; and now we have the dollar war declared upon us by the Fianna Fáil Party. Does Deputy Carter suggest that he is going to declare a fourth war upon us and what are the weapons he proposes to carry?

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is the reference to the civil war relevant to this debate?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A discussion on the civil war would not be relevant but the Deputy has mentioned it in passing.

Comment on this

A Deputy proposes to come to the general election in July suitably armed. I understand Deputy Carter claims to be a warrior.

Comment on this

We will pay you £2 10s. a week in July.

Comment on this

£2 5s. was the figure Deputy de Valera said was enough, and breaking stones was the exact job.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dillon is in possession.

Comment on this

That is the lawyers' figure.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil says—and let us join issue with them clearly and precisely—that the only form of capital investment that is justified is one that establishes a source of direct revenue for the Exchequer. The Fine Gael Party repudiate that definition of capital investment. We say there are two types of capital investment eminently justified. One is capital investment in an enterprise such as the Electricity Supply Board which does finance itself annually, but we also hold that any capital investment which will expand the national income of this country, with a corresponding expansion in the tax yield, thus providing the only revenue wherewith to amortise the loan, is totally justified.

In 1948 we embarked upon a programme of so financing, and I want to suggest to the House that we have been amply vindicated by the event. In 1947 the gross output of the agricultural industry, as recorded at Table 53 of the Statistical Abstract for 1951, was valued at £112,000,000; in 1948 it was £119,000,000; in 1949 it was £127,000,000; in 1950 it was £133,000,000. But that is not all, because that is the agricultural output based on the thoroughly unsatisfactory method employed by our Central Office of Statistics. That gross output takes no cognisance of the increase in our live stock population or the increase in the fertility of our soil. Contemporaneously with that increased output I have figures, and I ask the House to look at them, for increased input in 1945. The value of input (seeds, fertilisers and feeding-stuffs)—and I ask the House to remember that all feeding-stuffs and fertilisers that go on to the farm ultimately manure the soil and enrich it—in 1945 was £5,000,000; in 1946 the input was £8,000,000; in 1947 it was £10,000,000; in 1948 it was £14,000,000; in 1949 it was £17,000,000; in 1950 it was £21,000,000. Was the bank of our land a better place to put our savings than the Bank of England? Or do Deputy Brennan and his successor, Deputy Cogan, in Wicklow— for Deputy Brennan is going to lose his seat: I told him two years ago to move up in the bed because he is in danger, and look at the danger now— make the case in Wicklow that the land of Ireland is not as secure a bank as the Bank of England?

Comment on this
Deputies

Watch your own seat.

Comment on this

We made the case that the land of Ireland was a better bank than the Bank of England and we will fight Fianna Fáil in every constituency in Ireland on that issue. When we resume responsibility for the Government of this country we will bank our people's savings in the land of Ireland and those who live on the land and get their living on it and if the bankers do not like that they can lump it and any bankers who were not born in this country, who do not live in this country and who are not subject to the law of this country had better learn now that they are not wanted in this country, that a time is coming when it will be made clear that there will be nobody a director of a bank in this country who is not an Irishman and whose first allegiance is not to the Irish people and the Irish nation. If we get rid of some of the tulips who are managing our banking system we might have decent workers, decent farmers and decent professional men in this country. These people are being run ragged at the present time by banks forcing them to redeem overdrafts that they did not expect to have to redeem at 48 hours' notice. I get no satisfaction in seeing three shops closed within five minutes' walk of Leinster House and the same type of thing is taking place in every small town in Ireland.

The Minister for Finance and the Central Bank told the Joint Stock Banks of this country to squeeze everybody that could be squeezed. It is the dirtiest transaction that has taken place in my memory and it has left a mark upon the mind of every decent man in Ireland that is not to be expunged until we get rid of those to whom our people gave no warrant of authority to crucify the community on their new cross of gold. We do not believe in that. We are not one bit alarmed at the prospect of investing money in Ireland rather than in the 2½ per cent. consolidated stock of Great Britain. We are perfectly aware that the return on our investment in Ireland for the good of our people will be sounder, better and more enduring than the return on any investment such as Fianna Fáil suggests we should make. I have read out for you the fruits of our policy of investment in the only industry of importance in this country, namely agriculture. The tariff quota industries set up by Fianna Fáil are merely badly-run relief works, mainly dependent for their existence on what they are able to levy on agriculture.

Comment on this

Burn everything Irish except her turf.(Interruptions.)

Comment on this