Tuarascáil on gCoiste Roghnaitheoireachta. - Finance Bill, 1952—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 138–264 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 12 of 1952 ›
I think you should tell the Deputies opposite that I am trying to exercise restraint and forbearance.
Comment on this
I sympathise with Deputy Brennan. The sight of Deputy Cogan makes his blood run cold. However, if the sight of Deputy Cogan makes Deputy Brennan's blood run cold, he should not try to heat up his feet by shouting at me. Get a hot brick and put it at your feet, but do not be vexing me.
There is a feature of our production which has displeased the Fianna Fáil Party. Deputies will find it at Table 54 of the Statistical Abstract. You will read there of the disposal of the output of the agricultural industry. In 1943 our people consumed £47,000,000 worth of commodities and exported £17,000,000 worth; in 1944 they consumed £79,000,000 worth; in 1945 they consumed £83,000,000 worth; in 1946 the amount consumed was £81,000,000 worth. In 1947 £89,000,000 worth was consumed; in 1948 our people consumed £93,000,000 worth; in 1949 and 1950, respectively, the amounts consumed were £92,800,000 worth and £92,000,000 worth. Then Fianna Fáil intervened. They scanned these figures and said: “Tut, tut; £83,000,000 worth of goods were consumed in 1945, and now these presumptuous peasants are actually consuming £93,000,000 worth of commodities instead of sending them across to Britain and earning money. We will soon put an end to that. They will have to go back to the 1945 level and cut down their consumption. If they could live on £83,000,000 worth of goods in 1945, they can live on it now.” Does anyone deny that that is the purpose of the Budget? I agree 100 per cent. with Deputy Blowick when he says that the primary purpose of the food we produce in this country is to feed our own people. When that is done, we will sell the surplus to those who will pay the best price for it over a long term.
Comment on this
My new acquaintance, Deputy Carter, quacks. Perhaps he does not know that the result of that policy is to be seen in the figures of our exports. In 1947, our exports were £39,000,000; in 1948, they were £49,000,000; in 1949, they were £60,000,000; in 1950, they were £72,000,000; in 1951, they were £86,000,000. In the first three months of this financial year our exports were £22,500,000. That compares with £16,000,000 in the first three months of 1950. Probably, if the same proportion is maintained, our exports in this calendar year will surpass £100,000,000, or two and a half times what they realised when Fianna Fáil last went out of office.
Comment on this
Deputy Cogan can do no good for himself by being respectable and respectful here. If he wants praise for himself let him go down to his patron, Major-General Dennis, and he will get it there. However, the patronage of his kind is not welcome by the rest of the Deputies in this House, and the fact that Deputy Cogan has it is not a commendation in our eyes. If the servants of the Ascendancy in the last century had it it did not make them any more respectable in the eyes of our people.
Comment on this
I would a damned sight sooner be the servant of General Mulcahy than the servant of Major-General Dennis.
The Fianna Fáil policy is to reduce imports and the people's standard of living. Our policy is to increase output and exports to a level where we are paying for whatever our people require. I submit to the House that the figures already available have shown that policy to have a potentiality for success. Does this House recall that the figures I have read out to them from the Statistical Abstracts of 1951 show that if we increase the total output of our agricultural industry by 25 per cent. We increase the volume of our agricultural exports by 100 per cent. If we increase the volume of our total agricultural production by 50 per cent. we increase the volume of our total agricultural exports by 200 per cent. There is no ambiguity on the issue of the price of bread and flour, tea and sugar and the other essential foodstuffs. It is the considered and resolved policy of Fianna Fáil to raise the price of bread, to raise the price of sugar, to raise the price of butter and to raise the price of tea. It is the considered and resolved policy of the Fine Gael Party that there shall be no increase in the price of bread, that there shall be no increase in the price of flour, that there shall be no increase in the price of sugar and that there shall be no increase in the price of tea. Mark that down and record it.
Comment on this
I do not give two damns for any of your supporters. I do not want their votes. I would be ashamed to form a Government by virtue of their support. Is that plain? I give you a present of the four disreputable rag bags.(Interruption.) Keep on and go to the country and we will wipe them out and you with them. Now let us come to the next question.
Comment on this
The inter-Party policy on butter was made clear and rejected. The milk producers have been led up the garden path by the present Minister for Agriculture because he was afraid to be honest and straight with them. The whole future of the dairying industry is thrown into the melting pot and there is no use in any Party pretending that the price of butter in this country can be precisely forecast until the future of the creamery industry is restored to some basis of permanence of which it has been deprived by the Minister for Agriculture in his policy of passing the buck to Professor Murphy and the Costings Commission which is at present sitting.
Comment on this
So far as the taxes on tobacco and beer are concerned, nobody can forecast with precision what the Exchequer exigencies will require in that respect. It is our belief that the Exchequer exigencies will allow them to be reduced. So far as the tax on dance halls is concerned, a low bargain was made with the dance hall proprietors to get paid for handing money out of the Exchequer for their benefit. There will not get the benefit which they covenanted for when the enterprising proprietor of a dance hall sent the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass, £250 for the Fianna Fáil funds and exhorted other dance hall proprietors to rival that generosity so that the weight of their influence would make itself felt in time. They have got as much influence with the Fine Gael Party as a fly on the window and they never will have more.(Interruption.)
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is Deputy Dillon to be allowed to make his speech?
Comment on this
If they want to shout, we will all join in.(Interruption.)
Comment on this
The more they clatter the more they show what they are. The only thing that would reconcile me to a postponement of the general election is to let the Irish people have another look at them. The Minister for Finance has complained most bitterly that he was afflicted with a shortage of dollars and that he had to go hat in hand to Mr. Butler to beg for dollars.(Interruption.)
Comment on this
The poor creature is fit for nothing else. That is right, tell him to shut his trap. The Minister for Finance waggling his hands and saying "shut your trap" scarcely breathes the courtesy of the Falls Road. There is a certain crudeness about that which I think even the incisive accent of the Minister for Finance will not smooth for Deputy Carter. He is not in the habit of being told to "shut his trap." Of course, he does not mean to insult the Deputy. The Minister went to London to see Mr. Butler and came back with tears in his eyes to tell us that he had only $16,000,000 wherewith to meet his dollar commitments and that the extremity in which he found himself was due to the profligate extravagance of his predecessor.
Now, remember that that case was made with some emphasis in this House. I want to tell the House something which I think will surprise them. For three and a half years the Government of which I was a member was bombarded with applications from the grocers' association for dollars to buy Californian dried fruit, prunes and raisins. The then Minister for Industry and Commerce and myself answered every memorandum that was put up by saying that there was a pre-emptive claim on the dollar resources to finance imports of the raw materials of agriculture and urban industries for capital equipment and machinery and that there was no justification for using dollars for consumer and luxury goods such as dried fruit, more especially as there were alternative sources of supply. We were denounced as being profligate. Will this House believe that on last Thursday the Department of Finance notified every grocer in this country who applied for dollars——
Comment on this
I am a shopkeeper and I operate a public house through a company of which I am a director. Is that wrong?
Comment on this
Is it proper that the propriety of my business activities should become the subject of controversy in this House?
Comment on this
I am a farmer and I am a barrister-at-law. Is there any other public protestation that it is necessary for me to make?
Comment on this
Does not the Minister think that the dignity of this legislative Assembly of which he and I have been members for a considerable time is more important than his dirty, disreputable effort to drag my private affairs into the business of this House? The firm of which I am a director received an allocation of $1,600.
Comment on this
I will not give way. The practice of drawing my business into a discussion in Dáil Éireann is disreputable and disgusting. There is nothing in my business that cannot be hung on the side of Nelson Pillar. The Minister is using in a most shameful and disgusting way the fact that he has access to the documents in his Department relating to my private business. He has said in this House now something of which he could only have cognisance as a result of perusing a file which contains an ordinary confidential application of a business firm. I do not give a damn. Monica Duff and Company, of which I am chairman and director, applied in common with every other grocer. While I was a member of the Government I was not a member of the firm. All these applications have been revived and allocations for the purchase of dried currants, raisins and prunes have been made to every grocer in Ireland who asked for them.
I ask Dáil Éireann is that consistent with the proposition that the Government are short of dollars? Is that consistent with the proposition that our Government are embarrassed and prejudiced and even in danger because they have not the dollars wherewith to meet the annual instalment that has fallen due on January 1st, 1952, for the American loan. I venture to say—and I have no means of checking the figure yet but I will have—that a sum in dollars has been allocated for the purchase of dried fruit in California in excess of the total requirements of the dollar service of the Marshall Aid debt for the current financial year.
Look at those dupes in the Fianna Fáil Party who have thundered throughout the country that the poor Minister for Finance is left without dollars to pay the debt while, at the same time, the dollars that they say he told them he had not got were being allocated to the grocers of this country to purchase currants, raisins and figs, if you please, in California. God knows, it must be a queer experience to be a Minister in a Party which tolerates the insult and affront that is habitually put upon them.
Comment on this
The Deputy is digging his own grave. A lot more will come out as a result of that speech.
Comment on this
The fraud practised by the Minister in that regard is as contemptible as it could possibly be. There is no confidential information about my business in the Minister's Department that he cannot dig out and drape all round this place. He is low enough, contemptible enough——
Comment on this
So far as I am concerned the Minister is welcome to take every record and put it wherever he damn well likes. I exonerate him from every bond of confidence, from every bond of secrecy and from every bond of honour, if he knows such a thing, in respect of any matter in that Department relating to my personal affairs, my functions as a Minister of State, my activities as Deputy of Dáil Éireann or of anyone belonging to me.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting anything about the Deputy proper. I am suggesting that the Deputy is making one darned fool of himself and that is why I say that he is digging his own grave. He wants us to pay 25 per cent. more in gold in order to get fruit elsewhere. We are getting it on the cheapest market.
Comment on this
Blather. Last week Turkey reduced the price of fruit by £30 a ton but the Minister is such a baby that he swallows any tripe which he is told, hook, line and sinker.
Comment on this
Gold my foot. You could buy all the dried fruit you want for sterling in the morning and there is not a grocer in Ireland who does not know that. But anybody can come in and stick his fingers in the Minister's eye because he knows that the Minister will believe him and is a vain silly-billy to boot.
Comment on this
I do not know by whom they were sponsored. They were not dealt with as coming back from any society. They were the personal applications of traders who made them.
Comment on this
That is not true. Listen. I assert now that the problem of the Government to-day is to get the dollars spent. If anything we have too many dollars. I assert that the reason this allocation of dollars was made for dried fruit—and now I have to do this and I ought not be forced to do it—is that our claim on the sterling pool for dollars is related to our draw on dollars in the preceding year. I assert that the Minister for Finance could not spend the dollars which he has at his disposal and that the reason he gave dollars for raisins was for the purpose of enabling him to make the case which he will have to make for the allocation of dollars from the sterling pool in respect of this country next year. That is a fact. There is no reason why anybody should not get dollars for the purchase of raisins. Too many dollars are available for our trade with the United States. But the Minister, properly, will seek the widest manæuvring area he can to maintain a claim against the British Treasury in respect of the largest sum of dollars he can claim for. To do that he must spend this year all the dollars to which he has access or he will be told next year that he did not spend all the dollars which were allocated to him in this year and his full claim in respect of next year will not be granted. There is no question of anybody sticking his fingers in the eye of the Minister for Finance to the detriment of the community. The dollars had to be spent.
The Minister is doing in respect of raisins and currants to-day what I had to do two years ago when I spent $7,000,000 in one afternoon on the purchase of maize and wheat so that when the new claim came to be made against Marshall Aid we could establish our need for an ample allocation. If we did not spend what was allocated to us in 1949 in respect of 1949, when the allocation fell to be made for 1950 we would be cut down and, therefore, we took good care to spend it. That is what the Minister for Finance is doing now. My only complaint is that he has sent out unfortunate dupes in his own Party to pledge their honour and their faith to their constituents that there is an acute dollar famine, that Deputy Cowan is right but that they do not care to say so and that the only way we can save ourselves is to crucify our own people or the rapacious dollar monster in Washington will starve us into subjection. The whole thing is a dirty fraudulent election device. That is why I want them on the hustings where I can debate that question before the people and ask the people's verdict on it—and, by heaven, out they are going to go. We will drag them if we have to. However, I think three by-elections ought pretty well knock the pins from under them.
Comment on this
Deputy Mrs. Rice has a percipient eye. Coming events cast their shadows before. Deputy Mrs. Rice is clairvoyant.
Comment on this
As a colleague of Deputy Dillon in County Monaghan, will he tell me whether, when the American Government were generous enough to extend Marshall Aid to this country, any conditions or any stipulations were imposed on the people here when that loan was being given to this country? If a person goes to a bank in this country and asks for a loan he has to give security and sometimes collateral security. Had any guarantee to be given by the Coalition Government to America when we got this money? I am asking that question just for my own information. Were any conditions or stipulations attached to the giving of that loan or was it given unreservedly and unconditionally?
Comment on this
The answer is unreservedly and unconditionally, in one of the most unprecedentedly generous and handsome gestures ever made by one sovereign State to another. There was no security. There was nothing but their willing acceptance of our promise to pay. I know that I cannot persuade the Minister for Finance to repudiate his disreputable prop, Deputy Cowan. I look forward, however, with confidence to my colleague, Deputy Mrs. Rice, when she returns to Monaghan joining with me in repudiating the disreputable alibi offered by Deputy Cowan. He voted for the Budget as the only means of protecting Ireland from being put in pawn to the United States Government.
Comment on this
Strange as it may seem, I do not accept the Deputy's statement altogether, because I think the American people are business people and I cannot for the life of me understand why they should give such an enormous amount of money to any country unconditionally.
Comment on this
Is it not hard to understand that there still survives in this world people who are prepared to help their neighbours without asking for their pound of flesh or their pint of blood? Thank God the Deputy and I have lived to see the day when the powers of darkness who have lowered their iron curtain and who got their pint of blood and their pound of flesh are successfully held at bay by a power that is as great or greater and which is prepared to help its neighbours.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy might take good heart from the answer. By her gracious intervention, she invited me to dwell on the noble gesture for which she has expressed such incredulous admiration. I am glad that Deputies had this opportunity of being educated in regard to what Deputy Mrs. Rice so crudely believes to be incredible magnanimity on the part of the American nation, in a way that will make you wonder why it dawns not only on her imagination but her convinced knowledge. Now I shall ask the Minister for Finance—perhaps he will intervene now—to say whether there were any conditions or any obligations imposed by the United States Government other than to repay. Will the Minister tell us whether there were any conditions? How odd! I was constrained to use the Tennysonian phrase "mumchance" some time ago but the Tennysonian silence of the Minister for Finance is arresting as compared with his exuberant desire to intervene ten minutes ago.
Comment on this
It took you a long time to think that one out. L'esprit d'escalier is never any good. I want in conclusion to deal for a moment with the speech of that grotesque figure the Minister for External Affairs. He certainly is a prize exhibit. I find at column 661 of Volume 131, No. 5, that in the discussion on the General Resolution he made some of the most astonishing allegations that have ever been made by a man, coherent or incoherent. I have put down eight extracts from his speech, by way of asking to-day a question of the Minister for Agriculture and I must urgently urge Deputies to be here to hear the answer because it is going to be one of the funniest situations that ever arose. Either the Minister for Agriculture is an incompetent boob according to what the Minister for External Affairs says or else the Minister for Agriculture will get up and show the Minister for External Affairs as an imbecile who should be locked up——
Comment on this
Oh, yes. I am about to quote the Minister for External Affairs on the Finance Bill. He is reported at column 663 as saying:—
"With all the blowing about it Deputy Dillon did when the election was coming in Connemara, with all the talk about shipping the rocks and mountains into the sea, all he did in his time was to clear two acres at a cost of £200 apiece and I will swear that there is not a farmer in the county who would give 50/-for what £200 of the taxpayers' money was spent on."
That statement was made by the Minister for External Affairs.
When that statement was first made in this House I asked the Minister for Agriculture what acre involved such cost and he said: "No acre. The most spent on one acre was £100." I said: "How many acres cost £100" and the answer was "One." This wretched man had charged up to the first acre reclaimed in Connemara the entire cost of staff, transport, machinery and everything else, which had been assembled for a programme to cover the whole area.
Comment on this
I quite agree but the Minister for External Affairs dealt with it at great length in the debate on the General Resolution. Apparently he had the benefit of a chat with the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, since the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs returned from his incognito travels on the continent. You will remember that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs had an interview with a number of Belgian trade unionists who had told him in explanation of how they had arrived at the solution of their major difficulties: "Mais, nous travaillons, Monsieur.” But these same gentlemen are now collecting the Belgian dole because they have no travail whereon to travail. Since the incognito member we sent out came home, a great many of our unfortunate Irish travailleurs have lost their travail. Not alone that, but they have been forced to go to the Minister's native land to seek travail there. I wish he would go over and ask his fellow countrymen to release these unfortunate Irish workers. We would gladly exchange him for them. It would be both a profitable and desirable exchange. Have Deputies ever reflected on the fact that there are more aliens in the present Government at the present time than in any Government in the world? Up to the time that Deputy Little left, we had three aliens in our Government. I do not think there is a Government in the civilised world of which that can be said.
Comment on this
When the Minister for External Affairs was asked was he serious in his statement he replied:—
"Absolutely serious. I will take any Deputy who wants to come to my constituency and show him land treated under that scheme at a cost of £50 or £60 per acre of the Irish taxpayers' money... that land would not produce enough of grass to feed a snipe."
I ask where this land is. Of course the thing is pure nonsense. He went on to speak of the adverse trade balance and he then took counsel with the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs but instead of giving us an account of what they were doing in Belgium the Minister for External Affairs only gave us an account of what they were doing in Sweden. He said that during the past 25 years the Swedes have vastly increased the output from their land and he went on to say:—
"We are producing from land which is on the average as good as there is in the world, a mere £104,000,000 worth."
Now, the Minister for External Affairs has access to the Statistical Abstract as well as I have. The gross output of our land was £104,000,000 when he left office in 1948. As a result of cleaning him out, the output of our land rose. In 1948 it was £119,000,000; in 1949 it was £127,000,000; in 1950 it was £133,000,000; and it rose further in 1951. I wonder if the poor man is still flapping around in the belief that this country is still in the same slough of despondency as it was in when he and his colleagues went out of office in 1948. It is not. We were going ahead like a house on fire when we left office in June, 1951.
Comment on this
I commend to Deputies to read the Minister for External Affairs as reported at column 675 of Volume 131. I sometimes mark these things to read them out, but when I come to read them in public I get ashamed of them. Listen to this. This man was himself Minister for Finance for some considerable time— Minister for Finance, God save the mark. I remember the first Budget he introduced. I thought it was one of the most brilliant things I ever listened to—he read it, of course—and when he sat down I said to myself: "I have done this man an injustice; he is quite intelligent." Then, when the debate came to an end and the poor man got up to answer off the cuff—well, I invite Deputies even to look at the report of his speech winding up that debate.
Comment on this
I am trying to paint the background of the man who spoke these words. Remember that he was a Minister for Finance. Here is his contribution to this year's discussion. He was talking about our sterling assets and our adverse trade balance and he said:—
"At the end of a couple of years— put it at four years if you like—we would have to take some other more extraordinary measures because at that time the external assets in the hands of Government Departments, the Central Bank and the commercial banks would have gone.
We could still carry on, however. We could do as they did in England and as they have done in other countries—make everybody who has £1 or 1/- invested abroad register it and give it over to the Government and get payment in Irish currency. That could be done. If we did that we could carry on for another three or four years—if every person who has shares in some British company, or shares in some American company, or a holding in some British Government stocks were made to sell them to the Minister for Finance for Irish pounds. We could always print Irish pounds to give to them, and we would have these external assets to meet our liabilities in case we had a continuing deficit of £60,000,000."
Does the Minister for External Affairs not know yet that everybody who has dollar currency must list it with the Department of Finance and must, in respect of every dividend cheque he receives, turn it in to the Department of Finance and accept Irish currency for the dollars? Remember that this unfortunate man was himself Minister for Finance for two years during that period. He is now Minister for External Affairs—and he does not know On the contrary, the fact that that is so makes his blood run cold. He is shocked to think of anyone suggesting that it should be done. It has been in operation here for the past nine years. Is there anyone who thinks it wrong to have it in operation, who thinks the Government should not have the right to sequester for the use of the community the necessary foreign currencies on a basis of 20 shillings per £1? They have had that power, they are using it and every other Government is doing likewise.
This is the root of the problem. People like Deputy Aiken think there is something wrong in our people have ing this power. "It is all right for the British—they are a big and independent people—or for the Americans; but the people of Éire how dare they aspire to control currency!" Just imagine the dollar holdings of some gentleman in Rathmines or Ballsbridge and think of the ignorant peasants of West Donegal asserting the right as members of the community to control the user of the dollar interest payable to an important person living in Ballsbridge or Montenotte on his foreign investments. It is shocking, says Deputy Aiken. Shocking, my foot! We have done it for the past ten years and will go on doing it for as long as it is necessary, without apologies to anyone, like any independent sovereign State in the world. It is only a banker in Foster Place or College Green who would have the brazen effrontery to suggest we should not do it—and if they were not domiciled in London they would be ashamed to make the claim. Even the most brazen faced banker I have ever met never dared make the claim that Deputy Aiken makes there, that this Government and this country should not do that. He did it himself, we did it and with God's help it will go on as long as the interest of our people requires it. As I say, I read these speeches made by Deputy Aiken and I mark them with the intention of quoting them here and then I become ashamed as they are too grotesque, too scandalous.
Comment on this
I have given the reference. The Deputy can read it—if he is able to read. I want to draw the attention of the House to this, that £600,000 of the Marshall Aid money has been invested in the debenture of the Agricultural Credit Corporation. I think that was a good thing to do. I want to invite the attention of the House to this interesting fact. Every penny of the Counterpart Fund is now invested. It has this advantageous aspect about it, that every penny so invested is earning 3½ per cent. and we have to pay only 2½ per cent. on it. In respect of every £100 of our own Counterpart Fund we have invested, the Irish Treasury has a profit of £1 per annum. That is a good deal of money when it comes to £40,000,000.
I want to ask the Minister for Finance these questions. Although he was left £23,000,000 in cash last autumn, if he thought it was improvident to invest £28,000,000 over the period of the previous two years, why did he borrow the whole £23,000,000 in five months? That is what he did. I want to ask the Minister for Finance, if there is a scarcity of dollars, why he provides them for the purchase of raisins. I want to ask the Minister for Finance whether he on behalf of the Government will adopt or repudiate Deputy Cowan. I want to ask the Minister for Finance if he concedes that, now having no majority in this House, while he undoubtedly has a constitutional right, has he a moral right to force these Budget proposals through without accepting the invitation of the principal Opposition to put them to the issue—the country—and that is the invitation I am authorised to issue now.
Take this Budget to the country and we will abide by the people's decision. Take it to the country now. If you want a Vote on Account to enable the Government of the country to be carried on while that decision is being taken, we will give it to you forthwith. It is a waste of time and money, it is a waste of everything that the country can least afford to spend at the moment to hold three by-elections and then a general election. You know that the Government will be defeated in the three by-elections; then you will have to hold a general election. From every point of view the sensible thing to do is hold the general election now and take a decision on the Budget.
I know that the Taoiseach is bound to the busted flush not to put them in peril until next spring. Deputy Captain Cowan stated that he would vote for the Budget because he did not want an election until the coming year. He has now changed the alibi and says that he voted for the Budget in order that the country shall not be sold into servitude to the United States of America. He spoke the truth the first time. Pension the busted flush. Make them Senators. Do anything you like with them. We do not give a damn. There may be some compensatory arrangement which could be made with them. It is intolerable that the interests of the whole State should be sacrificed to some seedy bargain struck with a few Independent Deputies in order to procure their vote on condition that they, in turn, were not exposed to the fury of the electorate for at least two years. Upon my word, I would almost let them keep their seats, if that could be done, in order to persuade the Government to take the verdict of the people on issues of such supreme importance. Offer them seats in the Seanad.
Comment on this
Deputy Captain Cowan stated here that he would vote for the Budget because he did not want a general election until next January. Is that not so? I do not know what trucking went on.
Comment on this
We do not know what trucking went on between the Independent there and the two generals who sacked him out of their Party a few years ago.
Comment on this
All I ask of Deputy Cogan is that he will be as respectful here in Dáil Éireann as he is to General Dennis down in County Wicklow. Let him conduct himself here as he conducts himself in his best blue suit when General Dennis summons him to attend. Do not let him act bellicosely here and crawl on all-fours when he is sent for by the general to present himself at the big house. Nothing is more disgusting than to have a person acting bellicose to those who accept him as their equal because he has been sent here as a representative of our people, and who crawls at the back door of the ascendancy big house when he is summoned to come and hear the pleasure of his lord and master.
Go to the country and let this matter be resolved in a peaceful and constitutional way. Then we can get on with the job. The issues are clear. They are straight. There is no ambiguity. Fianna Fáil wants to beat down the standard of living of our people and reduce their consumption of food and consumer goods so that these goods may be shipped abroad. We believe we can get production which will fill all the needs of our people. Fianna Fáil say that borrowing for the purpose of investing the proceeds in the land and in the homes of our people is improvident and wrong and if the people want their land to yield more than it has yielded in the past, let them suffer now for they must be sacrificed on the cross of gold as laid down by Foster Place in College Green.
We say that the best place to invest the savings of our people is in the land of our people. We say that our people should get their living from the land. We propose to continue that policy because we are impelled into continuing that policy by the results already demonstrable. It is a glorious thing that this country, and it is something in relation to which we are all entitled to a share of credit, with a civil war only 30 years behind us, can change its Government peacefully and constitutionally by the due process of constitutional function. The classic method of resolving differences which are fundamental, clear-cut and certain in a House of Parliament such as Dáil Éireann is to-day, divided almost fifty-fifty, is to go back to the people and take their pleasure.
I ask the Government to go to the people now and put the issues as defined peacefully before the people, abide by their decision and then look forward, as I confidently believe we will be able to look forward, after that election to a long period of stable progress in which Ireland will continue to be one of the best countries in Europe in which to live and make one's living and which will certainly be for generations ahead the most prosperous agricultural country in the whole world provided the Government now accepts the proposition that not only pounds, shillings and pence matter; peace, decency and dignity come into the calculation too.
Comment on this
This morning I received a deputation of North Wall dockers. They told me that to-day 300 men stood at the docks waiting to be called. Out of that 300 men only 23 were called for work that will extend probably over ten days. That is a very serious matter. It is up to the Government to take steps immediately to improve conditions there. If the families of these people have to bear grave hardships because of the unemployment of the breadwinners, while to all outward seeming living in the midst of great luxury, they may get out of hand. I ask the Government to take serious note of the conditions.
Later three of these men came to see me and to put forward a certain viewpoint. They pointed out that the cost of living has increased tremendously and they said that out of all the millions about which they read some money should be made available to them either through the medium of unemployment benefits or otherwise to enable them to live. They did not complain about the personal burden as far as they themselves were concerned; they complained about the burdens that their wives and children would have to bear. They complained about the increase in the price of the loaf from 6½d. to 9d. I appeal to the Government to restore the subsidy on bread at least. I warn the Government that it will be dangerous for them if they increase the price of the loaf on these people to whom I have referred and on the workers generally.
In conclusion, I want to ask the Government whether they will give some guarantee that bread will not be increased in price, and further that they will take some steps immediately to provide work for those who are anxious to work—married men with large families. I am informed that what I have already referred to has been going on at the North Wall for the last three months. There are 20 men offering themselves for every job that is available at the docks. For the type of work that is available there, a man has sometimes to be at the docks at 5 o'clock or 6 o'clock in the morning in order to try to get a call. The balance of the 300 men— that is to say 280 men—when they found that they were not getting a call, all they could do was to go straight over to the employment exchanges in Gardiner Street or Werburgh Street to sign on. I want to say that the Government must not sleep any longer over this question of unemployment. These men have told me that, if they were younger, they would take the boat to-night and clear off, but in their present position they cannot do that because the cost of keeping two homes would be too great for them. I promised that I would not take more than five minutes to draw the Government's attention to this most serious state of affairs in the City of Dublin.
Comment on this
The time has come for a factual and reasoned discussion, on the basis of the Second Reading of this Bill, of the economic approach of the Government as against the economic approach of the Opposition to the alleged current day problems. I hope, in the course of what I have to say, to take the main props of the case put by the Government and to shatter their foundations completely, and when concluding to offer what I consider to be a constructive and progressive method of dealing with the situation.
I start on the premise of accepting the case as made by the Government and of asking them which of the two legs of it they are standing on. We have gone through the painful experience in this country of seeing ministerial hysteria and Central Bank conservatism welding together, willy-nilly to arrest development. There is one patent fact in Ireland to-day on which there is no conflict, and that is that a complete wave of depression has hit the country. We have been sent here by the people to discharge, to the best of our ability, the responsibilities which they have placed on us and, therefore, we have to address our minds seriously to the cause and effect of the present situation, and, having done so in a deliberative and unimpassioned way, to try to arrive at a solution of it.
Now, it is perfectly true, and perfectly obvious to everybody, that the Government have been hoisted on their own petard. It is quite clear to everybody, even to the doughtiest and toughest of the hard core of Fianna Fáil support itself, that the Government have run themselves into a serious jam by their own hysteria. They have been caught in that position by their own verbosity, their lachrymose utterances and their own melancholic prognostications and have come back to choke themselves, and their only answer is a vindictive, a savage and a completely unwarranted attack on the unsuspecting ordinary citizen who, if he gave a mandate for anything at the last general election, gave it for a continuance of government in this country by anybody other than Fianna Fáil.
I am not going to digress on the niceties of the busted flush or on the manner in which they were acquired, but I want to state emphatically what I know to be true, and what the vast majority of the Irish people now realise is true, that we have a penal imposition put on the people of the country in this Finance Bill by a minority Government. I say deliberately and assertively by a minority Government. We, unfortunately, as a nation have to pay the penalty of having foisted back on this country as a Government people who have long outworn their usefulness and have long gone past the stage of giving any real service to the country.
The Minister for Finance comes into this House and, with his usual pert utterances, with usual playful, kittenish and adroit phrases, describes the inter-Party Government as a Party on a spree and as a Party of uninhibted spending. I postulate again specifically the question which I put when the General Resolution on the Budget was under discussion: Can the Minister for Finance, can any member of his Government, can any member of the extremely mute back benchers of his Party tell me that there is anything improper or wrong about the assertion that it is the duty of any Irish Government, no matter what Government it may be, to invest to the maximum possible extent that it can the resources of its own people in our own country for the benefit of the country? I want to ask the Minister for Finance in a pointed way: Can he describe to me why something that is regarded as being non-fallacious in normal business should become a fallacy in national business?
We had in this country a very large system of building societies. Under that system we encouraged the people to become the owners of their own houses on the basis of a limited deposit and of amortising the debt by the repayment of interest in capital over a period of 25 or 30 years. That system enabled the occupiers to meet their commitments and, in due course, to become the owners of their houses at the end of the period of the loan. By means of that combination of sinking fund and interest repayments, the houses become theirs without any attachment of debt. What initially might have seemed to be a wall of debt being built up, on the last payment being made becomes the occupier's clear, untrammelled property.
Apply the same principle to an investment of a national character, where the benefits are spread over a period far in excess of the period laid down for repayment. Whether it is the provision of a large regional sanatorium, long-term development in forestry, improvement of the quality of the land, what is wrong with the economic theory of treating the sum so invested in a project that will endure for the continued benefit of the people in the same way as we treat the purchase of a house by a private individual? There is nothing wrong in it. Everybody in the House knows that. When we talk about capital investment increasing the national debt, the Minister for Finance is being patently dishonest, because, at the close of the period over which the loan and sinking fund are repayable, there is no debt, but there is left a salient and positive feature either in bricks and mortar or in the improvement of the land, the value of which to our people will be untold. This is what was glibly and without due responsibility termed by the present Government when in opposition as putting the country in pawn.
There is nothing wrong or improper about an Irish Government facing a situation in which there is a serious deflationary tendency, using all the resources at hand to cushion the people by an improved standard of living and a better way of life against any rude shocks that may arise from that sudden deflationary tendency.
There is the kernel of difference and when the heat and abuse and the clash of personality are taken out of this discussion we come down to an analysis of the basic economic theory. I assert in a positive way that it is the duty of this country, even though we may be criticised for pledging the credit of posterity, to cushion the people against the shock of the day. Posterity, whose credit we are pledging, will be given the enduring benefit of that capital investment. I cannot see any reason why, in those circumstances, the load of cost and the burden of repayment should not be spread over those who will get positive benefits from the investment.
It is perfectly true that the complete intemperance and the ill-considered judgment of an Opposition, which never believed in their wildest dreams that they would be the Government again in any reasonable space of time, have driven them back into a situation where, for conservatism of thought and effort, they would outrival the early Victorians.
Countries are advancing. Nations are becoming more and more conscious of their general responsibility to the citizens. Where a situation threatens a country, where there is rising emigration, rising unemployment, disruption of the normal standard of life, it is the positive and bounden duty of a Government to seize time by the forelock and to ensure that it uses the national credits and resources to cushion the unfortunate people against that devastating and trade-destroying wave.
We have to analyse to-day the question as to what solution the Budget brings to our problems. I say positively that, far from being a solution, it will add immeasurably to our difficulties. What is the effect of penal taxes? What is the effect of increasing the price of bread, butter, tea and sugar? In what way will that encourage increased production in agriculture or industry? How does the Minister for Finance, with all his gymnastic capabilities, conceive that an Irish people earning less, taxed more, their larder raided to maintain services, will be able to produce more and, as the pièce de resistance, save an extra 10 per cent. of what is left?
Why not face stark reality? Why not face the issue as the ordinary man in the street sees it? Why give utterance to grandiose cross-talk as to external disinvestment and internal reinvestment, balance of payments or any other balance, when the crucial matter that faces us is the reaction of the man in the street, the ordinary worker, the small farmer, the ordinary middle-wage group to a situation in which the Government, with savage intensity, demands an extra price for bread, butter, tea and sugar and, in addition, imposes a varying degree of penal taxes?
It certainly will be a reaction that could not be described as being conducive to monumental effort. Where is the encouragement of the will to work? Where is the encouragement of the urge to increase production when some of our major agricultural problems remain unresolved, when industry in fact is damped down and when factories are closing and going on part time. You can kill the goose that lays the golden egg. You can overburden a willing people and the real basis of my quarrel with the Government on this Budget is that that is what they are doing. They budgeted to get a certain sum of money. Any Deputy, Government or otherwise, has only to walk from this House into his constituency to see the damage they have done, to see a people once geared up for a productive effort and a country expanding and urgently anxious to expand further, hit a body blow and staggering in uncertainty as to its future, but in the certainty of the incompetence and unnecessary harshness of the profligate Government which has been foisted upon them not by the votes of the people but for reasons of the political survival of certain individuals.
The issue is clear—whether it is the duty of a Government, instead of crushing people at their whim and caprice, to use every resource they have to help these people over whatever difficulties may lie ahead, because, fundamentally and in the final analysis, the problem of production and the problem of development come back to the individual citizens. What incentive to increased production, to increased efficiency at home, is the continued flight from the land and the continued overloading of the emigrant ship with boys and girls, going now in numbers greater than ever went before, to seek the necessaries of life elsewhere? What solution is that of our problem? Remember that the cumulative effect of this Budget has not yet been felt in all its naked reality, but already Deputies opposite, as well as Deputies here, are being pressed for references and for help in expediting—what? The flight of some young girl or boy out of this country. It is a tragedy for all of us that they go, because, once gone, it is not easy to get them back and our fundamental problem is bound up with the manpower and womanpower which we can put into production, be it agricultural or industrial.
The issue here is simple. This Budget has been attacked in a constructive way by the Leader of the Opposition. He has alleged something of which there has been no coherent repudiation. He has alleged that it deliberately conceals a budgetary arrangement for a surplus, to enable the Government to get by direct taxation the money necessary to keep our capital projects afloat. That is dishonesty to which I hate to see any Government being a party. I would much prefer to see a return of the onetime courage and progressiveness of Fianna Fáil as a young Party, to see them men enough to say: "We were wrong on the capital-issue; we were wrong on the question of capital investment at home, and we admit it. We will not bludgeon our people, but will you give us your support and help us in getting the savings of the Irish people for the purpose of development at home?" You would have got it from us without any restraint, and we could have saved the people these penal impositions, the real devastating, effects of which have yet to come.
I look back and can see vividly the faces of each different Fianna Fáil Deputy as there was unfolded the drastic story of the new taxation, and I can see in those countenances shock, frustration and abhorrence. They know as well as we know that this is something the Irish people do not want, and something which took them infinitely more by surprise than it took us, because we had known of the cavorting of the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance with the Chancellor of the Tory Government. We were able to read into the change in the tone of their speeches that the pattern had been cut for them. It was only for them to fill in the details.
We now know that they have been guilty of the incomprehensible sin of framing a Budget for Ireland, a creditor country with tremendous potentiality, on the same basis as that of one of the greatest debtor nations in the world, embroiled and entangled as it is in tremendous defensive commitments. In this country, none of these considerations obtrudes itself, and, as I said before, it is an extraordinary thing to see the wheel turn its full circle and to find that the people, who once condemned us as an Empire Party, as an over-conservative Party, outstripping us completely and dissipating completely for all time that illusion by their own solid proof of devotion to Foster Place and Thread-needle Street that must be very touching when they relate it to the continuous struggles of generations to wrest the country from their thrall. Sad, indeed, is it that a freedom so dearly won and so hazardously and frantically guarded can be destroyed by an indecent, filthy bargain, of which even the details cannot be disclosed to this House—an indecent union between a Tory Chancellor and a sans bowler hat, sans spats, sans umbrella Deputy Seán MacEntee, Minister for Finance, who might indeed be a ghoulish reincarnation of his Tory friend.
We come into this House arguing desperately and seriously for the survival of our own people, throwing down the challenge that is on the lips of every person throughout the length and breadth of this country—a challenge that meets the Fianna Fáil Party constantly on the retreat—that in a House, where a minority Government rules at the whim and caprice of Independents, they can go back to all their Ministers and ask them for a verdict. That is the cause of the indecent retreat and the reluctance that has now become apparent even in connection with by-elections. You know full well that the people do not consider this Government to have any real policy or any constructive, progressive theory for the development of Ireland for the Irish people.
On the Budget Resolution we had the wonderful, extraordinary statement of the Tánaiste that brought my mind back immediately to shades of Marie Antoinette, but a rather ghoulish reincarnation of that spirit in the present Tánaiste, who blatantly said to this House: "If butter will be dearer, jam will be cheaper; if bread will be dearer cakes will be cheaper." That statement came from a responsible Deputy Leader of the Government, when, in this Budget, they were cruelly raiding, with deliberate and positive intent, the larder of the working man, the labouring man, the poor, the aged, the widow, the orphan and the old age pensioner to complete the savage intensity of their unnecessary Budget.
Where is the argument or the logic to support such a case? We have Deputy Captain Peadar Cowan vociferously applauded and enthusiastically taken to the bosoms of some of the less experienced Fianna Fáil Deputies when he tried to cloak the Government's savagery and stupidity by casting slurs on the bounty of the United States of America. It serves us ill in this House to treat with contumely what was a magnificent gesture of generosity unparalleled in the history of democratic relationships between sovereign nations. The rotten, foul part of the slander is that it was done under the aegis of a gallant captain now with his army disbanded.
What can this little country, bewildered as it is under the shock and the bludgeoning effect of this Budget, think of a tottering Government with its rather unwholesome props? I do not wish to digress into personalities in regard to them. They have their responsibilities to the electorate, but there is one thing sure that they are wedded in a close union with the Government in their determination to avoid going to the people for a verdict. One thing emerges from this discussion and that is that this Government, with all the intensity that is in their power and with all the bargaining powers that are at their disposal, is going to avoid at all costs the verdict of the people because fear welds Deputies Dr. Browne, Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll, Cogan, Captain Peadar Cowan and each and every member of the Fianna Fáil Party, from the Taoiseach down to Deputy P. J. Burke, in an unholy and indecent union.
I want some responsible spokesman from the Government to tell us what is wrong—and that quickly—with the desire of a Government to use the available resources of its own people for improved housing condition, hospitalisation, land, facilities by way of Electricity Supply Board and water schemes for the Irish farmer and the Irish people? What is wrong with that type of investment, giving as it does employment and improved social conditions to the Irish people? What is right with your miserable half of 1 per cent. for the £400,000,000 invested in England and loaned to the people of England at a rate far below the rate we can offer to our own people at home?
Deputy Traynor, the Minister for Defence, came here yesterday to make a defence for the increase in the bank rate of interest. You are fooling no one, not even yourselves. That is dictated to you and forced on you by people over whom you have no control. You are aided and abetted, encouraged and helped by the melancholy and doleful Central Bank, who have forced you to say to the Irish people: "You are eating too much; you are living too well; you are dressing too well; you are too happy and we will damp down on that."
You should be ashamed of yourselves for denying to a progressive Irish people the right to progress, to develop, to march onwards to greater production, greater stability and the better standard of life which is within the reach and potential of our people with progressive intelligent planning. No, the vicious, tortured spite of people who seek only to discredit, whether right or wrong, the efforts of their predecessors is twisting now in your own very entrails because, whether you like it or not, whether you want it or not, before this year finishes, we will have you back to your masters. We are very confident, very sure that we will remove for all time the possibility of having foisted upon Irish public life an incubus of disillusioned, tired, over-conservative old men. Where is the future for this country? It lies in a very simple hypothesis, it lies in the return to the Government of the country of courage and vision, courage sufficient where the needs of the country demand it to brush away the conservative whispers of caution of the Department of Finance and the extolling of gloom by the Central Bank, the courage to reassert belief in the strength of the Irish people themselves, in their will to progress and in their capacity to make the country produce more and make a better State for us all. We urge greater production upon the farmers of the country, slashing the prices, as we did of barley; we urge greater production at a time when we are leaving unsolved one of the primary basic problems of our whole agricultural system: the survival or otherwise of our dairying industry.
Platitudes have been uttered by Ministers, each Minister careful to talk about any Department but his own. We talk of greater production to the Irish farming community then one of the first impacts of the Budget will be on local charges by way of a tremendous increase in maintenance charges in certain institutions. We tell the farmer to produce more while we crush him down a little more. Where is the sanity of that? Where is buoyancy of revenue to be found? It is to be found in encouraging people to do more by getting their willing cooperation, and as they earn more, as their standard of life improves, as the production from each holding becomes greater, then their increased prosperity will give us the opportunity to collect equitably and fairly the taxes necessary to run the State.
This Finance Bill will give effect to the budgetary proposals. The main portion of the money raised will be used for services, a large portion on the administrative cost of the Civil Service, a very worthy body but, I venture to suggest, a very unwieldy one, one which seems to have the capacity of ever increasing, not only in cost but in size. May I draw the attention of this Government, as I drew the attention of the last, to the increasing incubus that is on the revenue? I have no quarrel with the efficiency and capability of the service but I feel that if we ask everybody else to tighten their belts and to make a little more effort we can reduce the administrative cost of the State by getting a little extra from officers in the Civil Service, thereby reducing the necessary intake every year. It will have to stop somewhere or we will arrive at the grotesque position of being a minority group of people surrounded by a large wall of civil servants. That is a problem which I feel the service wants tackled because I think that there are many officers who would like more to do and who, having been given more work, would be entitled to a better remuneration.
Comment on this
With respect, this matter has entered the discussion on the Budget and has been adverted to by several speakers in this debate.
Comment on this
If you so rule I will depart from it. My observations on the subject are well-nigh complete.
Is it for spite, is it just because they were not able to conceive and operate the idea, that the Government are making this onslaught on local works, on land rehabilitation schemes, on all schemes which tend to put more money in circulation in rural Ireland and tend to improve the lot of the people who are destined to carry the burden of the work necessary to carry on the State? Is it just stupidity, or is it a combination of incompetence, viciousness and stupidity that damps all of those?
We on this side of the House ask ourselves what is the really true background of this Budget, and we find a ready answer. It is not a Budget of necessity. It is a Budget which, as we have asserted here, and as I reassert specifically, can be reduced by £10,000,000 within ten minutes of our return to office, which, for the sake of the Irish people, I trust will not be long delayed. The Budget is unnecessary because, we assert positively, there is no necessity for the price of bread, tea or sugar to be increased by one farthing from the 30th June to the 1st July. If this insipid, spineless little Deputy, who knows not whether to go to the right or to the left, seeks an assurance he can have one from me: With the return of any Party into office other than the incubus that is now in it, the price of bread, tea or sugar will not go up one farthing. To the hard-pressed trades that this Government have nearly obliterated goes this assurance, the review of taxation will ensure reductions to the extent of making their business again a real one. Let an assurance go out that we will stop the rising unemployment, consequent on the caprice of a combination of Victorianism, stupidity and spite.
The time has come for this country to be told, in no uncertain fashion, that we firmly and positively believe that this Budget is a hoax and a fraud. It conceals a tremendous budgeting for a surplus so that, like the great "I am", the Government can throw back a sop to their long-suffering and outraged supporters, hoping that it might temporarily allay the cancer that is eating them all, because slowly and surely, even into the toughest and hardest core of the Government's supporters is permeating the knowledge that they are worthless, stupid and incompetent. It is fully time that somebody answered our challenge. We have all got one master in this House—the ballot-box. Gone is the intimidation and the ugly threat that once was thine. Now, in the domestic peace and harmony at home, we can try this issue at the bar of public opinion—the bar of all our masters. We can try it without any difficulty. The cost of Presidential elections, by-elections and other types of elections can all be wiped out by a throw now for a general election, and then, "Good night, Fianna Fail".
Comment on this
We have heard a lot of talk from the Government Benches attacking the previous Government for the debts they left behind. I have heard no Deputy telling the House that a Supplementary Budget was brought in by Deputy Aiken when Minister for Finance, thereby increasing taxation. There was no Marshall Aid and no debts left behind. Fianna Fáil held office for 16 years and, by bringing in a Supplementary Budget in 1948, a general election took place which had the effect of putting them out of office.
I do not like when I hear the younger Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches who are new to this House attacking men like Deputy Costello and Deputy Dillon, who have had years of experience in this House and who have given facts and figures. The Leader of the Fine Gael Party made a statement to the effect that the present Government were over-budgeting to the extent of £10,000,000. I am certain that a man in his profession would not make such a statement in an Irish Parliament if he were not sure of his facts. As a worker, and living in a community of poor people, I can say that we are very much afraid at the moment of what the future will bring after the 1st July, when there will be a higher cost of living than ever before operated in this country. There will be increasing unemployment in rural areas due to the cutting down of the Marshall Aid money which was developing the land of the farmers in my county and in other counties and giving sound employment.
The present Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking in this House during the discussion on the Finance Bill in 1948, said in Volume 111, column 856 of the Official Reports of the 10th June, 1948:—
"You budgeted for £5,000,000 more than we had.
"Mr. McGilligan: And you would have put on £10,000,000."
In fact, Deputy McGilligan's statement was true. £10,000,000 has been put on.
Deputy MacEntee, as he then was, was terribly annoyed because there was a small increase in the price of petrol in 1948. He stated in Volume 111, column 916 of the Official Reports of 10th June, 1948:—
"Perhaps I do, but then I have suffered in a good cause.... I would prefer, if I might be allowed without interruption, to discuss the merits of this tax. I have said it is a regressive tax and I have said it is an oppressive tax. It is a tax which falls most heavily on the people least able to bear it. It is a tax which the man with the Rolls Royce will not notice very much. He has already to pay, perhaps, £120 or £150 to put his car on the road. He can well afford to buy petrol, but it is a different thing in the case of the struggling farmer and country doctor."
That was what the Minister said, as Deputy MacEntee, in 1948, and he came into this House a couple of weeks ago with a Budget containing a proposal to increase the price of petrol by 4d. Therefore, the agricultural community, who have resorted to tractors instead of horses, find they have to pay 4d. per gallon extra on their petrol. The Minister was asked in a parliamentary question in this House a fortnight ago, if he would give any concession in this regard, and he said that he would not. When in opposition, in 1948, he was talking about the increased tax on petrol, but he now comes into this House and puts a burden on the people such as they have never had to bear before.
I asked a parliamentary question in this House about the subsidy for the flour millers. I understand they are getting a subsidy of £7,000,000, £8,000,000 or £9,000,000. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that the subsidy does not go to the flour millers but to Grain Importers (Éire) Limited. Who are they? Deputy Dr. Esmonde, my colleague from Wexford, asked a parliamentary question about the personnel. The reply he got was that the people controlling the flour millers were Grain Importers (Éire) Limited. Why should we withdraw the subsidy to keep down the price? Why should we do it? The Fianna Fáil Government who held office in this House for 16 years are subsidising the catering establishment in this House which is charging high prices all the time. Five hundred pounds a year.
Comment on this
This is a subsidy that is not cut down. Surely these people in the restaurant should be able to do without that subsidy. Another post which ought to be abolished is that of President, if we want to be honest with the people and save the tax payer needless expense. We should also abandon this highfalutin practice of sending Ministers away, thus costing us dollars. I see that the Taoiseach announced yesterday that there are more representatives going away. Apart from that, Fianna Fáil are trying to keep the good graces of Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll so that he will vote with Fianna Fáil; he was doubtful on the night of the vote on the Budget and he did not vote at all. All this is going on while the people are struggling to live. Many of them cannot get employment and are going to Britain in droves. I have never seen so many people queueing at the labour exchange.
Over the last three and a half years there were parts of County Wexford where there was not a man unemployed but to-day, as a member of Wexford County Council, I see deputations coming into that county council seeking employment. This is due to the fact that the Marshall Aid money which was granted to this country to give employment and to develop the land of Ireland has been reduced from £60,000 to £30,000. Deputy Allen, of course, said there was not a dollar left in the till when his Party took office; we know at the moment that there is £30,000 worth of dollars to be expended by the Wexford County Council, but it is only half what we got during the inter-Party Government term of office.
In spite of all our difficulties, as I say, we are sending Minister away to Strasbourg, which is costing dollars even though there is a great deal of talk about the scarcity of dollars. The people are fed up with this racketeering. The Twenty-Six Counties is trying to do what the biggest States in the world are doing, sending representatives to all the nations of the world. This is being done at the taxpayer's expense and at the worker's expense. After all this, we are faced with the worst Budget that has ever been produced in any country and which is going to further depress the hard-pressed people of the country, the working classes.
We are told that certain reliefs are being given as regards income-tax. Who are the people who are going to be relieved by the income-tax concessions? It is not the man on the dole; it is not the man on the miserable national health insurance; it is not the thousands of people on home assistance. It is a very sad state of affairs to hear a Government talking like that in view of the miserable plight of many of our people. The hardest job in public life at the moment is visiting assistance officers in the area and going from him to the county manager and to the superintendent assistance officer to put up a case for an unfortunate man or woman to obtain a few shillings from the public authority. It is absurd to think that 1/6 will compensate old age pensioners for the removal of subsidies. The ratepayers in my constituency are giving 6/- a week to blind pensioners along with £1 a week, and here we have a Government which can only give to the old people, the fathers and mothers of 1916 and down along, a miserable 1/6 and tells them it compensates them for the cost of living.
Anyone who would say that in an Irish Parliament, having been voted in by the people, is not worthy of being elected. The people sent us in here to look after their interests. It is disturbing when I hear Deputies from my own constituency, and one Minister, standing up and telling us—he would not state it in the Bullring in Wexford or in the market square in Enniscorthy or Gorey—that 1/6 would compensate a person for the cost of living. I think the members of this Government should compel the Minister to bring back his Budget and let the Irish people dictate its terms instead of putting us on a par with Britain in regard to the price of cigarettes and other commodities, or getting up and saying that they are paying more for the same article in the Six Counties. There is a big difference in the chances of employment in Britain and those here. The workers in Britain can afford to pay more for their cigarettes and tobacco because they can work on Sundays if they like and work other overtime. But in this country many people cannot get a week's work. That makes all the difference.
The people who stand up in an Assembly like this and make ridiculous statements know that they only appear on the official records of Dáil Éireann, and do not appear in their daily papers. What they say is kept from the people. Nevertheless, the Irish people are pondering over the present situation? But whom do they blame? They blame four Independent Deputies who have no mandate to come in here and vote for Fianna Fáil any more than I had. They are keeping the present Government in office. I came here on a strecher to put them out, because I knew that if Fianna Fáil got back into power the penal laws would be enforced again. Of course Deputy Cowan, Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Cogan from Wicklow were approached the night before to vote Fianna Fáil back into power. They got a guarantee. I was lying up there on the stretcher when I heard Deputy Lemass saying that the Dáil would run its full constitutional term. That was one guarantee the Independents got. Deputy Cogan got another one in regard to the Land Commission or some other commission, because the next day he was in the Dáil looking for grants and loans for farmers. Deputy Cowan is expecting to get a judgeship I suppose to compensate him for his allegiance. I do not know what Deputy Dr. Browne will get.
Comment on this
This is in connection with the Finance Bill. Four Independent Deputies are keeping a minority Government in power that the people do not want. The people find themselves in a sad position to-day with a high cost of living, with an increased Budget, with less employment, growing emigration and a standstill all over the country. The grants under the Works Act have been cut down on all county councils. It is interesting to hear now the statements of Deputy MacEntee, the Minister for Finance, and the other Ministers, and then to read the statements back over the years and see what they said when 1d. was put on petrol in 1948. I wonder do the people outside ever think over the promises that were made during the general election by Fianna Fáil Ministers and Fianna Fáil members. There was no need to impose this Budget and reduce the food subsidies. Could they not have gone another way round? There were plenty of other ways of getting revenue without taking the bread, butter, tea and sugar off the people's tables. In spite of the hardships imposed, however, 1,128 people, namely, the dance hall proprietors, will get away scot-free with the potential revenue of £140,000. The only excuse that Fianna Fáil Deputies could offer for the removal of the dance tax was that it was too difficult to collect. That is no excuse. The dance hall tax should have been retained and that revenue would have benefited the poorer sections of the people. It was taken off to suit the dance hall proprietors but it will not mean cheaper dancing for the people who go to the dance halls. There will be an increase in the admission price. These are the things that any Deputy is faced with since this Government came into power.
The rents of houses which people are now going into have gone up. Probably the next thing we will have is a standstill Order to prevent people from seeking an increase in wages. That will be the next thing we will be fighting against here in order to satisfy the employing class and stop strikes. Someone said that Fianna Fáil represented the workers. The Deputies sitting behind the Minister ought to ask him to withdraw the Budget, bring it back to his officials and into the Fianna Fáil Party rooms. If that is not done, the Whips should be taken off and a free vote allowed. Fianna Fáil for once should give its members the right to a free vote so that we will see what side they will vote on. We were allowed a free vote when the inter-Party Government was in office. Why not have a free vote on this? That would test it without going to the country. Give the ordinary rank and file Fianna Fáil Deputies a chance to show how they will vote and I will guarantee to the Minister that there will be action by this House. If they are allowed a free vote, some of them will not vote for the Budget, they will stay at home. That is the best way to decide it.
There are Deputies sitting behind the Minister who are not satisfied with the Budget, who are greatly annoyed by it. The biggest problem they have when they go down the country is to explain why there are these increases in taxation, and that takes some explaning. They will not get away with everything. Fianna Fáil Deputies should try to explain why the Minister is budgeting for £10,000,000 more than is required, why the price of butter is to be increased by 10d. a lb. and why the price of bread will be increased, when the people were told that they would not be increased. These are the things the people will ask Fianna Fáil Deputies when they go before them.
Although before the election Fianna Fáil Deputies were crying out about the cost of living, since the Fianna Fáil Government came in the cost of living has gone up. Control has been taken off bread, butter, tea and sugar. Every item going into a household is increased. Because there is no control, people are finding that the price of some of these things is cheaper in some shops than in others. That is a bad policy. The Government are allowing the people to be fleeced by taking control off. We all know what goes on when there is no control. Some time ago the price of coal in different towns was reduced by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. A number of people were charging £10 a ton for coal when they should be only charging £8. That happened in a few towns, one of them in my own area in Wexford. These people had to reduce the price.
We are told the children's allowances are to be increased. They would want to be increased if we are to give the youngsters any milk, as milk is now 5d. a pint and will probably be dearer. Young children must get milk every day in the week. That was the advice given by Deputy Dr. Browne. Yet he walks into the Lobby and votes with Fianna Fáil for dearer butter for the youngsters and less bread. These are the things which the people in the country have to face, and yet we have to listen to Deputies defending this Budget and trying to score points at the expense of the Opposition. Deputy Dillon put questions to the Minister to-day which he could not answer. He said he would deal with them when he came to them. Ministers have stated that Deputy J. A. Costello's statement was untrue when he told them that they were budgeting for £10,000,000 more than was required.
I wonder what will happen in the City of Dublin when there are thousands of unemployed there? Will the few shillings increase which he will get by way of dole satisfy the unfortunate man who is put out of his job? Will that compensate him for taking his work away from him? The last thing that a working man wants is to queue up at the labour exchange. That was the thing that I detested most when I had to do it—to have to stand in a queue at the labour exchange in order to sign for a few miserable shillings. We are now told that there is to be an increase in the dole and in children's allowances. What good are these increases when the cost of living is going sky-high?
The Minister for Finance when in opposition said that he went out of office a poorer man than when he went into it. I am sure he will not go out of office poorer man. He will receive a pension of £500 a year after all the things he has done on the people. Even if he is defeated in his constituency, he can enjoy a pension of £500 at the expense of the taxpayer and yet he is worrying about the taxpayer. As reported in column 917, Volume 111 of the Official Reports, he said on the Finance Bill in 1948 when dealing with the petrol tax:—
"I hope the position will always continue in this country, since Deputy Collins has raised this matter, that when people have been 15 or 16 years in office they will go out of it, as I have gone out of it, a much poorer man than when I went into it. This is a tax which falls most heavily upon the people who are least able to bear it. The struggling businessman, the small haulier trying to keep a lorry or two upon the road, finds this tax oppressive. Perhaps the large transport undertaking will not find it so oppresive. The large transport undertaking will certainly be able to pass it on to the customers and it is the customers who will ultimately pay."
I hope Deputy Burke will listen to what the Minister for Finance said in 1948:—
"The people who live at Crumlin and Kimmage, in working-class houses, built under the Fianna Fáil Government—at which Deputy Collins sneers and gibes—will find this tax very oppressive because they will have to pay. When, I due time, bus fares have to be raised, it is those people who will have to pay for this tax.
Captain Cowan: They will not be raised."
Will Deputy Cowan tell the Minister, Deputy MacEntee, this evening, when he walks into the Lobby to support him, that the bus fares will not be raised? That is the assurance which Deputy Cowan gave to Deputy MacEntee in 1948.
The biggest mistake the Taoiseach ever made was to appoint Deputy MacEntee Minister for Finance. I had occasion recently to look over the Dáil debates for a number of years back, and I could not help noticing that all the present Minister held different ministerial posts in former Governments. They were changed from Local Government to Finance, from Finance to External Affairs, from Education to Lands, from Lands to Education, and so forth. They have all been changed about because they were failures, and they are not fit to hold posts as Ministers to-day.
Were it not for the tremendous work done by Deputy MacBride when he was Minister for External Affairs this country might not have got an allocation of £40,000,000 by way of Marshall Aid. The Fianna Fáil Party were then in opposition and they sneered and they jeered at it. They said that they would not take that money, and that if they did take it they would give it in fertilisers to the farmers. They ignored the unemployed and their policy was to give that money to the farmers. During the three and a half years of inter-Party Government many people who are now unemployed were provided with work because of the money which this country got from the United States by way of Marshall Aid. Every nation in the world was looking for dollars and Ireland got £40,000,000 to reclaim the land so as to bring about increased production. That money was well spent. It gave constant employment to many people who to-day are unemployed as a result of Fianna Fáil policy. It helped to drain our land, to clear our rivers, and so forth. There is unemployment in rural Ireland now. Men are roaming the country looking for work. They are approaching every member of the county council in an effort to obtain work. They are going to every housing scheme in the hope of being able to get some kind of a job. The position is becoming worse. Tractors have begun to take the place of the horse and have displaced many farm workers who are emigrating to Britain to work for the British farmers.
We heard a lot of talk about the Irish Trade Union Congress statement on the Budget. Deputies on the Government side of the House tried to score political points in respect of that statement. They read certain passages from it but they neglected to read other passages in it. We did not hear anybody on the Government side of the House read out this paragraph which deals with the effects of the Budget:—
"In the first place it is certain that the Budget proposals in themselves will cause a sharp reduction in living standards. The prices of essential foodstuffs will rise sharply as from July, bread by 38 per cent., sugar by 63 per cent., butter by 28 per cent., while it is expected that tea will be about doubled in price. Cigarettes have already risen by one-third and beer by from one-fifth to one-third. Each of these items enters into the budgets of practically all working-class families and together constitute roughly one-quarter of expenditure."
The cost of everything that goes into the poor man's house is increased under this Budget. Though the Minister, Deputy MacEntee, chose to quote certain parts of the Trade Union Congress statement he did not quote the above paragraph. At the last general election the people were led astray by false promises. They believed the Fianna Fáil speakers who said that if Fianna Fáil were returned to office the cost of living would be reduced.
The Tánaiste, who is also the Minister for Industry and Commerce, accompanied the Minister for Finance at discussions with the British Chancellor of the Exchequer in London. These twó Ministers came back here after these talks, and gave no indication whatsoever to the House of the trend of these talks. I remember the headlines in the Sunday Press before the two Irish Ministers left for the talks in London. We were told that the Minister was going over to talk to Mr. Butler, and that he held trump cards in his hand. It is not difficult to guess what happened at these discussions. The Irish Ministers were told to do what Mr. Butler told them, and to go back to the Dáil and, with their majority, to put that policy into action. The fact of the matter is that the people in Britain, who had been coming over here for holidays, noticed the difference in the standard of life in this country, and were making unfavourable comments about conditions in their own country. The tourists who came over here were able to report that drink, tobacco, cigarettes and lots of other things were in plentiful supply here, and could be purchased for much less than the prices prevailing in Britain.
When the Minister for Finance concluded the reading of his Budget speech he was clapped by the Deputies on his side of the House. Yes, he was clapped by Deputies who were elected to this House by the poor man's vote—clapped for announcing an increase in the cost of living. I wonder what these Deputies will have to say to their constituents after July next when the prices of foodstuffs go up. I should not like an election until after July and until the people feel the real effect of this Budget. When the women have to pay 10d. extra for a lb. of butter I hope the shopkeeper will tell them that it is as a result of this Fianna Fáil Budget and I hope that the housewife will not forget the fact that one of the planks of the Fianna Fáil programme was to promise to reduce the cost of living.
We heard an announcement on the Radio last night that, as a result of a shortage of petrol, there will be a tightening up of Aer Lingus flights. I wonder what will happen if, some evening, we hear an announcement on the Radio to the effect that the Korean peace talks have broken down and that world war has been declared. What will then be the position of our Irish farmers whose horses have been sent abroad to be canned and who are relying instead on tractors? What about the petrol supplies that are so vitally essential for the successful operation of our agricultural industry? What steps has the Minister for Agriculture taken to ensure adequate reserves of petrol and oil against a possible emergency? There would be utter chaos in this country if, some evening, we were told over the Radio that world war had broken out and that we had no petrol for our tractors. Not alone have our ordinary horses been exported but even the horses which were used to escort the President have been replaced by motor-cycles.
Those horses consume a considerable amount of the crops which our farmers produce. Now they have been sacrificed for British made motor bicycles and Russian petrol.
There is nothing constructive in the Government's policy so far as the future of the country is concerned. All the restrictions on emigration have been removed and it is no longer necessary to go to a Garda Station or to the United Kingdom Office here in town to seek passports. We heard a statement from a Fianna Fáil spokesman last night, which was later quoted over the wireless, that there was emigration from this country over 100 years ago but I do not think that there was ever such a volume of emigration as since the present Government came into power. The country is being drained of its manpower and womanhood. The Taoiseach talks about the restoration of the Irish language at the same time as he is allowing the country to be denuded of its people. In a short time no one will be left but old "crocks". There is free emigration now and our young people are taking full advantage of it. I would appeal in all sincerity to Deputies supporting the Minister, who know the country as well as I do, to consider the situation which now confronts our people, a situation which will become much worse when the food subsidies are removed on the 1st July.
Comment on this
I listened to the debates on the Budget and on this measure for a considerable time and I am beginning to find out at last the policy which the Opposition proposes to adopt. Deputy O'Leary definitely stated that his policy would be to impose taxation on dance halls.
Comment on this
So far as the Central Bank is concerned, the policy would seem to be to dismiss all of the directors. The Statistical Branch also came in for some correction, but I do not know what will take place there. The banks' policy was also subjected to a good deal of criticism and they were seriously threatened because it was alleged they curtailed credit. I am certain the present Government did nothing to curtail the credit usually afforded by the banks or gave any indication to the banks as to what they should do. Deputy McGilligan, when he was Minister for Finance in the late Government, was not so shy because, when he introduced his last Budget, he warned the banks and warned the people against the volume of credit. Therefore I take it that the policy of the Opposition would be, if there were by-elections, that the banks should not be allowed to give credit except under special conditions.
Comment on this
You would want to have the four-leafed shamrock to get the loan of a pound from a bank now.
Comment on this
The Parties composing the Opposition are almost unanimous in the view that our sterling assets or our foreign assets should be all brought home and spent—I do not know how. We got Marshall Aid here and, up to the present at any rate, the result of those spendings are not apparent. Opposition Deputies do not say how these foreign assets are to be repatriated and nobody tells us exactly how much of these moneys belong to the banks, to public bodies, to the Government and to private individuals. Do they propose to put before the people a policy of confiscating these assets belonging to private individuals which represent the savings of these people? Is that part of their policy? If it is, I think it is a new departure. It might bring results, but I think it would be a very dangerous policy to pursue.
The most important matter about which I should like to hear is the question of the subsidies. Their removal was severely criticised but not one Deputy on the opposite side told us they were going to restore them.
Comment on this
I was listening carefully. However, there are more Deputies to speak and they perhaps can satisfy my curiosity as to whether the subsidies would be continued by the Opposition if they were in power.
Comment on this
I only want to have my mind satisfied. If the Deputy has to speak yet, perhaps he would get his Party to come to a definite decision on that point. We heard Deputy O'Leary blaming the four Independents and he seemed to insinuate that at the last election they were part and parcel of the Coalition Government. They had resigned from the Coalition before there was any sign of an election.
Comment on this
In fact they were the cause of an election. They are Independents, and they had a right to go anyway they liked.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary has already spoken, and he should listen to other Deputies without interrupting them.
Comment on this
The Deputy would spancel the four Independents, to Fine Gael, Labour or some other Party. They were free lances, and they declared themselves so here. They voluntarily joined the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
They did not actually join the Party, but they came into the Fianna Fáil Lobby and voted for a Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
You had only one man who had the courage to do that, and that was Deputy Flynn. He was in your Party before.
Comment on this
I do not say that the other Independents joined the Fianna Fáil Party, but they voted for the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
The next thing I should like to know from the Opposition is: Suppose we had no general election at all, what would they have done? What would their policy be? Would they adopt the policy of the predominant Party, the Labour Party, who would have the balance of power?