Committee on Finance. - Finance Bill, 1952—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–186 of 379. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 12 of 1952 ›
Section 14 enshrines what one may describe as the most obnoxious and disreputable part of this Finance Bill. In view of the interjected assertions made yesterday by the Minister for Finance, it might be well to preface the discussion on this section by repeating verbatim to the House the letter which appears at column 1473 of the Official Debates of the 3rd April, 1952. It will be recollected that the Minister yesterday attempted to disown any connection with the dance-hall proprietors. The letter reads as follows:—
"Miss K. Morris,
Secretary,
Irish Ballroom Proprietors'
Association,
c/o Olympic Ballroom Company,
Pleasants Street,
Dublin.
A Chara,
I have received your letter of May 6th which has been considered by the Fianna Fáil Party Committee. The committee's view is that the entertainments duty on dances is an undesirable tax. As to its abolition in the present financial year, however, a decision must necessarily await the detailed examination of the Budget introduced in the Dáil immediately prior to its dissolution, but it would be the intention of the Fianna Fáil Party to repeal it as soon as practicable."
Comment on this
Now we shall read the letter of Miss Morris of the Ballroom Proprietors' Association. It might even supply an artificial toe for the Deputy.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I am waiting until the Deputy permits me to put the point of order.
Comment on this
No, a point of order. Is it in order to read this letter, for which no Minister has any responsibility? Is it relevant to the matter under discussion to read this letter?
Comment on this
It is a letter, I understand, from an association purporting to represent dance-hall proprietors?
Comment on this
There is a section in this Bill which proposes to terminate the entertainment duty upon dance halls as such. Therefore, it is relevant.
Comment on this
Therefore it will be relevant to read any correspondence relating to the entertainments duty?
Comment on this
I fear I have not made my point clear. A letter written by a Deputy of this House in relation to a matter which was clearly the business of the House would be relevant when the particular matter was under discussion, but, Sir, the letter which Deputy Collins now proposes to read is not written by a Deputy. It is written by another person over whom no Deputy in this House has any control.
Comment on this
Any letter written to a Deputy in this House in connection with this tax is relevant.
Comment on this
I rule it is relevant, but it has been read so often in this House that I must rule that repetition is not in order in this House. I shall allow it to be read on this occasion, but on other occasions I shall apply the rule regarding repetition.
Comment on this
Lest we offend the ordered susceptibilities of the Minister for Finance, let us revert to the filthy bargain in regard to which the excited but satisfied Miss Morris writes to the ballroom proprietors indicating to them the good fellowship and paternal solicitude of the Fianna Fáil Party, indicating that she wants an immediate response, that the response must be in the shape of financial aid, generous financial aid, and that already one doughty warrior had headed the list with a subscription of £250. Many more had promised equal and larger sums, and therefore she asks those whom she addresses to subscribe generously to this organisation. In a Budget imposing a catastrophic burden on the poorer sections of the community she has this one glimmer of relief, this one touch of glory in the abolition of the dance tax. For what purpose? The purpose has already been clearly stated since the Minister made the announcement. The poor dance-hall proprietors do not intend to pass on the relief to the dancing public. "Oh, no, munificent and paternal stepfather, the Fianna Fáil Party has given us an opportunity to reimburse ourselves for coming to their aid by way of a subscription to the Party funds, to reimburse us to the tune of £140,000 per annum, in case there may be any further tribulations before us." Not one halfpenny of the remission in this section goes to anybody but the proprietors of the dance halls, and they have already emphatically indicated that there will be no reduction, good, bad, or indifferent, to the dancing public.
Let us go in for the Minister's charming doctrine of estimation; underestimation when it serves the purpose, overestimation when it serves the purpose. But let us take a reasonable mien of estimation, and take it that 140 big dance-hall proprietors are affected. They get a remission of approximately £1,000 per head per year. Take that on the basis of even a 5 per cent. contribution to their munificent new stepfather, and you get some idea of how the coffers of the last general election were filled, and how the coffers of the pending election are likely to be filled.
Comment on this
What about the other dance halls which are not privately owned?
Comment on this
You poor old gossoon, will you keep quiet? You have been given a job you were never suited for.
Comment on this
I must ask Deputy Collins not to make references of that kind which are undesirable and unsuitable.
Comment on this
We are entitled to put on view before the Irish public the completely shady and disreputable background to the removal of this tax. It is a sordid political bargain made at a stage when the Party making it could not conceive their return to office and fulfilled under circumstances that bring public life into a "new low" of degradation. On the general Budget resolution, I deliberately quoted verbatim from date to signature all these letters. In case anybody thought I was trying to twist, misquote or misuse extracts, I quoted them in toto. The Minister has been invited time after time to deny what is revealed in all its naked implications in these letters and he has not been able to do so. But some of the hardy warriors behind him have made excuses and said that the tax was difficult to collect, that it was difficult to do this, that and the other.
I have adverted before to the fact that in this section the Exchequer is gratuitously throwing away £140,000 which, limited amount as it is, could have gone a long way to satisfy some of the irritating demands that Deputy Breathnach knows about of the old pensioned teachers and that Deputy Colley knows about of the Old I.R.A. men and all the other little pin pricks which have been causing irritation here over the years. Is there any justification other than a sordid political one, with dance crowds bigger than ever, with the earnings of dance halls bigger than ever, for the remission of this tax?
I do not want to labour this. It has already been held forth as one of the most disedifying episodes we have had over a long period. It is shabby, but it is in harmony with those who conceived the idea of giving the concession. It is a miserable bargain, a sordid bargain. It is something to which a salutary answer will be given in July, because no matter what difficulties we may have to face—and the Minister has painted a gloomy enough picture—there is nobody insane enough to think, in face of that published correspondence, in face of the evasion and the absence of denial, that there is not the smell of political intrigue and graft behind this Section 14.
Comment on this
I do not think it will be seriously challenged even by members of the Fianna Fáil Party that this is the toughest Budget this House has seen for the past 30 years. At one fell blow this Budget imposes new taxes on such staple articles of food as tea, sugar, bread, butter, flour and on such near necessaries as tobacco and beverages, having regard to the pattern of life of our people. All these additional taxes are being imposed on the plea that it is imperative, that these taxes are indispensable, that they represent the grim economic and fiscal position which the nation has reached and that nothing else but these taxes will rescue the nation from the difficult financial and economic position in which it is to-day.
That is the plea made by the Fianna Fáil Party. That is the plea for making poor people living below the subsistence line, the under-privileged and the almost submerged classes endure a Budget of this kind. They are asked to pay more out of their slender resources for tea, sugar, bread, butter and flour because they are told it is necessary that the nation must extract this tribute from their meagre resources in order that the nation may live and enjoy its independence of foreign Powers.
Yet in a Budget which demands these sacrifices we set out to give a donation of £1,000,000 to the tobacco manufacturers and we propose to give a gift of £140,000 to dance-hall proprietors. Let us forget this smelly and indecent correspondence which took place between the Fianna Fáil Party and the Secretary of the Dance-hall Proprietors' Association. Let us put that aside and not use it for the purpose of this discussion. Let us judge the Budget on its merits, put on one side the sacrifices it imposes on the masses of the people, many of them living below the subsistence level, and at the same time put on the other side the gift of £140,000 to dance-hall Proprietors. Is there any justification, when we are imposing such heavy burdens on backs quite incapable of bearing them, that we should at the same time give such a substantial gift to a small section of the community who clearly have demonstrated by their assets that they are in no sense in a comparable position with the masses of the people who will be asked to bear heavy burdens under this Budget? I saw a large dance-hall last week, outside which there was a mile and a half of motor cars, bumper to bumper. I made inquiries apropos this tax. I asked how many people patronised that dance-hall. I was told by people who had an interest in the hall that in the winter season the crowd is not as great as it is in the summer season. I was told that they take 2,000 people a night into this ballroom. When one reckons that up — 5/-, 7/6 or 10/- a night — and the auxiliary business that is done in association with a dance-hall — I think no fair-minded man can avoid coming to the conclusion that dance-hall proprietors are not a needy section of our people, and that in any case they are not first in the queue for economic or financial relief, having regard to what this Budget is doing in relation to large masses of our people.
We are taxing the old-age pensioner under the Budget. He has to live on tea, bread, butter and sugar. Those commodities represent meat and fish for him as well as bread and tea and butter and sugar. Tea, bread, butter and sugar are the commodities which he uses at all his meals because his meals in the main consist of these commodities. We will make him pay more and on to his miserable pittance of £1 per week we propose to add 1/6 to compensate him for the increased price of bread, butter, tea, sugar and flour and to compensate him also for the increased cost of tobacco and the increased cost of his bottle of beer or his half-glass of whiskey. To offset all that he will get 1/6 compensation. Presumably the reason why he cannot get more than 1/6 is because the country cannot afford to give him more than 1/6.
Does it not seem a vicious contradiction judged merely on the level of equity that we cannot give more than 18 pence per week compensation to an old-age pensioner while at the same time we can give a gift of £140,000 per year to the dance-hall proprietors? Is there any equity in that? Is there any element of fair play? Is there any attempt to reconcile the ideologícal factors which operate throughout the Budget when we grind down the masses of the people by compelling them to pay higher prices for foodstuffs and at the same time pick out the tobacco manufacturer and the dance-hall proprietor for reliefs — reliefs which the dance-hall proprietor class never dreamt it would get under this legislation?
I want to argue this on the basis of levels. There is a smell about these levels that I do not like. Probably there is an explanation for this provision exempting dance-hall proprietors from entertainment tax under this Finance Bill and under the Budget. Will some of the Fianna Fáil Deputies tell the House and the country why in a Budget that makes the masses of the people pay more for their food we should give a gift of £140,000 to the dance-hall proprietors? There is no sense of equity in a Budget which gives a gift of that dimension to dance halls while at the same time compelling unfortunate old age pensioners and other submerged, or partially submerged, classes to bear the burden of the impact which this Budget will have on their simple domestic lives. Is it fair to expect the poor old age pensioner to be compensated by throwing him 18 pence for seven days, less than threepence a day? Is it fair to say to him: "There is your threepence; that is your compensation now for the fact that tea, bread, butter, sugar, tobacco and beer have gone up in price; there is your threepence; you cannot get any more than threepence under this legislation; you cannot get any more than threepence from this Government because this Government wants to give a gift to the tobacco manufacturers and the dance-hall proprietors?"
It is an outrageous concept of justice that in a Finance Bill which is imposing the toughest burden our people have had to bend their backs to bear for the past 30 years we should select the dance-hall proprietors as an object of compassion in a House which, apparently, if it passes this Bill, has nothing but a shocking disregard for the sufferings that many people will endure if this Bill is put through in its present form.
Comment on this
I have listened to Deputy Norton speaking and I think his language was worthy of a better subject. We are discussing here the removal of the tax on dancing. Considerable play has been made by Deputy S. Collins and others with a document which, apparently, was circulated by some secretary of an association of dance-hall proprietors. One would think that at the last general election the question of the views of the majority of the members of this House was in some doubt. This tax was reimposed in 1948 by Deputy McGilligan.
Comment on this
At that time there was considerable opposition to it. There was strong opposition from the members of the Fianna Fáil Party. There was strong opposition from the members of Clann na Poblachta. In 1950 it again came before Dáil Éireann and it was debated at considerable length on two amendments, one tabled by Deputy Aiken and the other by Deputy Fitzpatrick. Deputy Fitzpatrick was a member of Clann na Poblachta. Deputy Davin, a member of the Labour Party, expressed very specific views in relation to this tax. He referred to it as an unpopular and irritating type of tax. At column 1691 of Volume 121 of the Official Report he said:—
"I opposed this unpopular and irritating type of tax when it was originally imposed by Deputy MacEntee when he was Minister for Finance in the Fianna Fáil Government. I argued in favour of its abolition last year because it was, like every new tax which was imposed, unpopular, and because I thought it was a very irritating type of tax in the way I know it to be administered in some parts of the country."
Deputy Davin proceeded to discuss the question at some length, but eventually he voted for the continuance of the tax.
Comment on this
I put a completely different point of view. In fact, I supported Deputy Fitzpatrick on an alternative form of tax which I suggested. In 1949 and 1950 the question of this tax was a live issue in this House. It was debated at length in both these years. Many Deputies here received deputations representing dance-hall proprietors, musicians, and representatives of workers engaged in the dance-halls. It was brought home very clearly to us, and we so put it to the Minister, that the continuance of the tax meant less employment in the dance-halls because dancing is, to a large extent in our cities and, anyway, in our big towns, an industry. One cannot get away from that. There are quite a number of people employed in and about dance-halls. One may laugh at that.
Comment on this
It is a fact that many people are employed in and about dance halls as musicians and as members of the staff.
Comment on this
And as chuckers-out, perhaps, though I have no experience of that. That case was made here, and it was as clear as a pikestaff. I see Deputy Dillon laughing.
Comment on this
I am laughing at the Fianna Fáil faces listening to your defence of the dance tax. They are getting gloomier and gloomier.
Comment on this
I think that whatever expressions are on Fianna Fáil faces are probably due to the fact that they are admiring the countenance of Deputy Dillon.
Comment on this
The case was made here at that time that unemployment was being created by this dancing tax. Deputy Fitzpatrick and myself— Deputy Fitzpatrick was a dance-hall proprietor and, in fact, became chairman of the organisation of dance-hall proprietors that was formed simply and solely because of the tax—made very strong representations in this House that the tax should be removed.
Comment on this
Even though this Government could not be bought?
Comment on this
It was offered and accepted by the present Government.
Comment on this
This association of dance-hall proprietors undoubtedly made a case through Deputies of this House for the abolition of this tax.
Comment on this
We will come to that. So that, whether there were subscriptions sent to Fianna Fáil or to anybody else, it was as clear as could be that when Fianna Fáil became the Government they would remove this tax. They had imposed it themselves. They found it an unsuccessful tax and they removed it. Deputy McGilligan restored it. I do not think there was any doubt whatever in the minds of the dance-hall proprietors that when there was a change of Government this tax would be removed.
Comment on this
Deputies profess to see something extraordinarily wrong in an organisation contributing to a political Party. It is being done every year. Very substantial sums are being paid to political organisations by organisations for one purpose or another. I know that in the case of the Labour Party, while I was there, there were substantial sums of money paid by trade unions to the Labour Party.
Comment on this
And those subscriptions were paid so that the Labour Party in this House would fight for certain claims of the Trade Union Congress. I know, from my own personal experience in 1948, that substantial sums were received from the licensed trade and from publicans because of the promises that we made then that the taxes on beer and spirits imposed under the Supplementary Budget would be removed if there was a change of Government as a result of the election. Now those are the facts. There is no doubt whatever about them.
Comment on this
I did not say that. I said that substantial sums were contributed to political parties by the licensed trade and by publicans on the very clear and precise promise that was made—that if a change of Government could be brought about those taxes imposed by the Supplementary Budget would be removed.
Comment on this
The Deputy can rest assured that they did not send their subscriptions to the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I do not think that the equity of associations contributing to political Parties arises on this section.
Comment on this
That is the whole kernel of the attack which is being made: that this alteration in the entertainment duty has been made because of subscriptions received by the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
When we have a letter before us from the Tánaiste, in reply to a promise of a political subscription, it is relevant.
Comment on this
——a certain amount of common sense in our approach to this problem. No political Party will refuse subscriptions at election time. At least, I am not aware of any up to date.
Comment on this
Everyone who gives a subscription hopes that some benefit will accrue therefrom. Even if a person subscribes to Deputy Dillon's election fund, he may hope that some benefit will accrue therefrom.
Comment on this
These are the facts, and Deputy Dillon knows them as well as I and every other Deputy in the House. It was clear that subscriptions were paid to Fianna Fáil by the dance-hall proprietors so that this tax would be removed. It has been removed, and we are now giving the legislative approval to that removal. In 1949 and in 1950 many Deputies in this House, for many reasons, opposed the tax. The tax amounts to approximately £100,000.
Comment on this
It amounts to £140,000. It is enough to increase military service pensions.
Comment on this
The tax amounts to £140,000. I am perfectly certain that we would have heard the same criticisms of the Minister if he put on that tax as we are now hearing because he took it off. The tax was originally imposed in 1939. I did not bother to go back as far as that date, but I am perfectly certain it was violently opposed then by Deputies in this House. It was removed, I think, in 1946, and there was a sigh of relief. Now, however, the case is being made that if that tax were retained old age pensioners could be paid an increase and that the Old I.R.A. could be paid an increase. That is the point Deputy O'Higgins made, and there is no sense in it; that £100,000 could not increase old age pensions.
Comment on this
I did not say that. I said that Old I.R.A. pensioners and military service pensioners could be paid an increase if the tax were retained.
Comment on this
This tax was imposed on dancing only in particular areas; it was not a tax on dancing all over the country. Any village with a population of less than 500 had not to pay the tax.
Comment on this
I do not know what is wrong with Deputy Dillon. I heard some references being made to horse medicine last night. Perhaps the Deputy may have taken some.
As I said, this tax was imposed in parts of the country only and, in addition, it was evaded in many areas. It was a tax which resulted in the loss of employment by musicians and by staff employed in dance halls. As Deputy Davin said, it was an irritating tax, and that was also the view of everybody else. There is something unfair about an irritating tax which only affects part of the country. Would Deputy Dillon tell us where is the fairness or the equity in a tax applicable to a dance held in a place with a population of 501 persons, which does not apply to a place having a population of 499 persons.
Comment on this
It is not a case for extending the tax. It is a case for the removal of an unfair and inequitable tax.
I would not like to prevent Deputy Dillon from repeating the speech which he made yesterday. I know he is anxious to get going on it and to read again this letter which we have heard read so often in the course of this debate. However, I feel that if Deputies looked on this tax in the way it should be regarded—from the point of view of equity—they would be satisfied that it should be removed. If they looked at it from the point of view that it caused unemployment, that it led to evasion and that it caused people to break the law in many parts of the country, they would agree with its removal.
I know a number of clubs and organisations in Dublin that run dances once or twice a year, usually for two purposes, one as a social venture for their own members and the second as a means of raising funds for an athletic club, a football club or for some such purpose.
Comment on this
Surely the tax would not apply in the former case? It would not apply if a club were running a dance for its own members.
Comment on this
It does apply.
Comment on this
As I said above, clubs here in Dublin run dances once or twice a year for two purposes; they run a dance as a social venture for their members. They run another dance for the purpose of raising funds —in other words, a local dance open to anybody who wishes to pay. This dance served two purposes. However, it is found that when the cost of the dance hall, the band and the tax is paid, that there is nothing left for the funds of the club. That is the experience of people endeavouring to run dances for the purpose of maintaining hurling, football and athletic clubs and even to help cut political organisations. Every Deputy in this House was aware that the person who is standing at the door of a dance hall with a bundle of tax tickets in his hand is very careful, where he is trying to make a few pounds, about the people to whom he gives tax tickets. That is happening everywhere, and there is no use in one trying to conceal the fact.
Comment on this
It is happening everywhere where the dance tax is in operation. Those members of a club or an organisation who are running a dance are very careful with the tax tickets; they do not give them all out, but they retain some of them and have a particular excuse ready if some official from the Department of Finance or from the Revenue Department comes in to inspect the place. Does anyone suggest that this is a desirable practice? It is anything but desirable. Clubs have been put into that position so as to maintain their own little organisations. This practice has been adopted by political organisations, by athletic organisations, by football clubs and by hurling clubs and by all other kinds of organisations. I maintain that a dance tax that has that result is a bad tax from the point of view of the country. I maintain that, if it cannot be enforced 100 per cent., it should be removed altogether.
Comment on this
——Parliament must take note of these things. It takes over £100,000,000 to run the State, and the dance tax brings in about £100,000 or £140,000. Are we to have that state of immorality brought about for the sake of £100,000 or £140,000? I think it is time that we ought to look straight at these matters. It is time that politicians should give up creating trouble because their opponents happened to get a subscription for election purposes. Any political Party that refuses a subscription certainly would be entitled to condemn the dance-hall proprietors or anybody else for contributing to a political Party, but it is only if they refuse to accept subscriptions to the political fund they can adopt that particular attitude.
I have spoken to quite a number of people in the city in regard to that. Very few people are being codded with all this nonsense and with all the fulminations that we have had from Deputy Collins, who was repeating, in a different key, the words of Deputy Dillon. These fulminations had no effect on the people, and particularly on the thousands of people who are engaged night after night in endeavouring to run dances for the purposes I have mentioned. The removal of the dance tax is generally welcome, as it would have been welcomed in 1949 and 1950 had we been successful in inducing the Minister to remove it. It was a bad tax. It was, as Deputy Davin described it, an irritating tax, and it is a great job it is gone now.
Comment on this
We have had extraordinary arguments in favour of the removal of this tax. With some of the arguments which Deputy Cowan mentioned I think there would be universal agreement. Any tax is unpopular and there are a number of taxes which are irritating but surely the question which concerns the Dáil and the country on this occasion is whether it is fair, just or reasonable to remove a tax on dance halls under a Budget which proposes substantial increases in the prices of essential foodstuffs.
Nobody for a moment suggests that essential services should not be carried on, that the money required to pay for these services should not be raised, that the money for the Army, Garda and Civil Service, and that whole variety of expenditure by the different Departments should not be met. Revenue must be raised to meet the commitments involved. In this Budget of over £100,000,000 a sum of £140,000 is not a substantial tax. A strong case can be made on the basis that it was difficult to collect, that there was to some extent an evasion, that it imposed trouble on those responsible for running dances, that it was irritating, and a variety of other arguments in favour of its abolition, but do not the same arguments apply to income-tax? With few exceptions, such as in the case of road tax, and probably taxes in respect of spirit licences and taxes collected at source, there is evasion. One of the responsibilities and functions of the officers of the Revenue Commissioners is to stop that evasion and to make tax collections as effective as possible.
In so far as the returns show, the efforts of the Revenue Commissioners indicate that the revenue derived from the dance tax was on the increase. That shows it was possible to collect it to an increasing extent. It shows equally that the alleged effect of that tax on the dance-hall industry was not jeopardising that industry and did not jeopardise the employment of those concerned in it. If it did jeopardise it I would like to inquire what effect the increase in the present Budget in the price of beer and tobacco would have. The Minister waxed eloquent on the effect on the tobacco companies of the suggestion that they should not be allowed to get every farthing of the increase that was recommended by the Prices Advisory Body and the effect it would have on employment. In the case of the dance-hall proprietors this tax will not be remitted to the public. The public will not get the benefit of the remission of the £140,000. That will be put in the hands of the dance-hall proprietors.
I do not think that anyone seriously suggests that the amount of money involved in the remission of this dance-hall tax is large in comparison with the Budget as a whole. We do not agree with the views that have been expressed here that people are not deceived. People are bewildered by the fact that in this Budget the price of petrol, which is used by a variety of people, including traders, business men, commercial travellers and by transport users of all kinds for business and trading purposes, is going up by 4d. per gallon, the price of the print by 3d., the price of a packet of 20 cigarettes by 7d., the price of tea by more than 100 per cent., the price of sugar by 2½d. per lb., the price of butter by 10d., the price of flour by 2½d. per stone and the price of the 2 lb. loaf by 2½d.
All these taxes affect, without exception, all citizens, most of them directly. Those that do not affect every individual directly affect him indirectly. Bread will be dearer. The essentials of life will cost more and yet it is decided in the Budget to make one extraordinary remission in taxation of something like £140,000 to the dance-hall proprietors.
I do not think anybody can seriously suggest that it is sound economy, or that it is good national economy or even sound public finance to increase the prices of a variety of essential foodstuffs, of a whole range of near essentials and increase the cost of transport, in a Budget, which this Finance Bill implements and which remits a tax on dancing of £140,000. When the Táiniste was speaking here on the day after the Budget he said, at column 1301, Volume 130, No. 9 of the Official Debates of 3rd April, 1952:—
"It is clear, however, that the abolition of rationing means that subsidised flour—flour subsidised at the new rate—will be available for the producers of fancy bread and biscuits who are now paying an uneconomically high price for the 75 per cent. extraction flour; and therefore some reduction in the price of biscuits and other foodstuffs produced from the 75 per cent. extraction flour is to be anticipated."
Later, in the same volume at column 1305, he said:—
"Therefore, there will come into operation, almost simultaneously, a substantial reduction in the price of jam, marmalades and other manufactured foodstuffs in which sugar is an ingredient."
It is an astonishing fact that this Budget will have as a direct result the effect of increasing the price of bread to the consumer, the price of butter, the price of flour, the price of tea and the price of sugar; in other words, the essentials of life will increase substantially in price. But under the same Budget jam, cakes, marmalades, biscuits and any commodities manufactured from sugar will be reduced in price; and under the same Budget it is proposed to remit the tax on dance halls. I do not think anybody seriously suggests that this tax remission is justified. It has been alleged that the Opposition has made a lot out of a small amount of money in relation to the whole Budget. As far as that is concerned the amount of money involved is not the important aspect of this question. Leaving aside entirely this letter about which there has been so much talk and to which reference has been made, I believe the important and serious aspect of this alteration in the tax rate is that it is made in a Budget which imposes substantial increases in the price of essential foodstuffs—substantial increases in the price of petrol, tobacco, in the price of a whole variety of commodities, but which also remits the tax on dance-halls.
It is easy to say that the tax is unpopular. It is easy to say that it is difficult to collect. Reference has been made here to past debates on previous Budgets when appeals were made to have this tax remitted but those making these references have omitted to point out that in these Budgets there was no increase imposed on the price of bread; there was no increase in the price of butter; there was no increase in the price of sugar, of tea, or of flour. As a result of this Budget substantial increases in the price of these commodities will occur.
I do not think that anyone for a moment believes the suggestion that this tax remission will mean a sudden revival in employment. The effect of the impact of Fianna Fáil government in the last 12 months has been to drive up the number of unemployed to such an extent that there are now 13,000 persons more unemployed than there were this time last year. Some Deputy, I think it was Deputy Captain Cowan, suggested that this is going to have an effect on employment. I do not think even the most ardent advocate of the remission of this tax will make that case for it.
Leaving aside altogether the question of the undertaking which was given prior to the election by the present Tánaiste on behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party, I think that the fact that this tax is being remitted has bewildered, confused and angered people, particularly people who were obliged to pay and will be obliged to pay substantially increased prices for essential foodstuffs. This tax, it retained, could increase by 25 per cent. the pensions of the Old I.R.A. They are only one section of the community that will be hit by these increases in the price of essential foodstuffs, and remember, this is part of the confidence trick that was played on the electorate by Fianna Fáil. In two speeches during the last election campaign two Ministers of the present Government said that there was no truth in the suggestion that the taxes relating to beer and tobacco would be reimposed, and at point 15 of the pamphlet containing the 17-point programme published in the Press on the 5th June after the result of the election, it was stated that one of the points in the Fianna Fáil policy would be to maintain subsidies, to control the price of essential foodstuffs, and the operation of an efficient system of price regulation for all necessary and scarce commodities.
That was part of the Fianna Fáil programme which succeeded in deluding some of the electorate. That was part of the programme that was designed to secure the reins of government on the basis of misleading either the electorate or some of the Deputies who subsequently supported it. That is the programme which has resulted in substantial depression in trade, a Budget which imposes increased income-tax, increased prices by the withdrawal or the variation of subsidy, increased taxes on petrol, on tobacco, on beer and on spirits, but it remits the dance tax because there was an undertaking given during the election that it would be remitted if Fianna Fáil were returned.
I do not think it is fair to ask people to pay more for bread, to pay more for flour, for butter, for tea and sugar, to expect them to pay more if they want to smoke the same number of cigarettes, to expect them to pay more for a pint of beer or stout, to expect petrol users to pay 4d. a gallon more for petrol, to ask income-tax payers to pay——
Comment on this
——a shilling in the £ more. The increased revenue which will be derived this year from the variation in the rate of income-tax amounts to £910,000 more than the figure which was secured last year. If this is less money, then the Minister will have to explain it again. I do not understand the effect of a tax which results in gathering in almost £1,000,000 to the Exchequer over that which was gathered in last year and which was put before the Dáil on the basis that less income-tax will be gathered this year than was gathered last year. The fact is that the people of this country, old age pensioners, widows and orphans, blind pensioners, Old I.R.A. pensioners, every citizen, whether he works for the State, whether he has retired as a pensioner, whether he is at present endeavouring to secure a wage increase by application before the Labour Court, whether he is a member of a trade union, whether he is self-employed or employed in business, in trade or in commerce, whether he is a farmer or a farm worker, he is going to pay more for bread, for flour, for tea, sugar, butter, beer, cigarettes and petrol, and if he is an income-tax payer, more on income-tax. But if he wants to dance at night he will not get the benefit of the dance tax remission.. Remember, nobody should be deluded into thinking that people are going to be allowed even to dance more cheaply, because they are not. The fact is that the dance-hall proprietors, under some preelection arrangement which was not made public until after the election, will be allowed to put into their pockets a sum of £140,000. It is a small sum; in relation to the size of this Budget it is a comparatively small figure.
What the public do not understand, however, what those Old I.R.A. pensioners who are seeking an increase and what all sections of the community fail to appreciate, is why this remission amounting to £140,000 is being given to the dance-hall proprietors under a Budget which raises the prices of essential foodstuffs, which imposes increased burdens on all sections and which in no way seeks to alleviate these increased hardships. I do not think that anybody can seriously suggest that the increase of 1/6 a week to the old age pensioners—and God knows they were entitled to it and needed it badly—will offset the rise in the price of bread, tea, sugar and flour and, if they they smoke, of tobacco and, if they drink, of beer and spirits.
Deputies often forget that there had already been a substantial rise in the cost of living since this time last year long before the present Budget was introduced. There was an increase in the cost of essential foodstuffs—butter, bacon, meat and eggs. In addition, there was an increase in transport charges for people travelling on buses and an increase in freight charges. It is in respect of these increases that negotiations and discussions are at present proceeding between the Trade Union Congresses and the representatives of employers regarding an increase in wages. That increase is needed to meet the rise which has already occurred not to mention, not even to think of, the rapid increase which will take effect on the 4th July, when the full impact of this Budget is felt.
It has been suggested that the slight increase in children's allowances and the old age pension will meet the rise in the cost of living. All of these are welcome and all of them are necessary to offset the increases which had already occurred since this time last year. Remember that this is the Government which was to maintain subsidies, control the price of essential foodstuffs and operate an efficient system of price regulation for all necessary and scarce commodities. Deputies are familiar with the speech of the present Minister for Finance during the recent election in which he said that a number of persons in the licensed trade were spreading the rumour that Fianna Fáil if they were returned to power would reimpose the taxes on drink which had been imposed in the Supplementary Budget of 1947. "There is no truth in any such rumour," he added. That speech was made at Rathmines and was reported in the Irish Independent on the 5th May, 1951. The present Tánaiste referred to a Coalition Minister who had made a speech saying that Fianna Fáil if returned would impose these taxes and asked why should these taxes be imposed.
Comment on this
What confidence can the electorate have in the speeches of public men when they saw how during the election campaign they were misled and deluded by them in dishonest speeches when they were seeking the votes of the public? "There is no truth in any such rumour." How wise were the publicans, how right they were, how accurate they were in their prognostications of what would happen on the return of Fianna Fáil. During the election campaign Fianna Fáil did not publish the correspondence into which they had entered behind the backs of the electorate with the dance-hall proprietors. They announced that they would maintain subsidies but the effect of the alterations proposed in the Budget will be to increase the price of bread, flour, butter, tea and sugar, although jams, cakes, biscuits, marmalade and any other commodity manufactured from sugar will be cheaper.
It is astonishing that this Budget and this tax remission in Section 14 of the Finance Bill should be passed by the House. It is astonishing that the case should be made for that remission that the tax was unpopular and irritating. Nobody on this side of the House questions that description of this tax or denies that in relation to the Budget as a whole it is a small sum, but it must be considered in the light of a Budget which increases the price of bread, tea, flour, sugar, and a whole range of essential foodstuffs for old age pensioners, widows and orphans and every section of the community, a Budget which increases income-tax by 1/- in the £ and petrol by 4d. It must be considered in the light of a policy which has already succeeded in increasing the number of unemployed by over 13,000 persons since this time last year. It must be considered in the light of a Government which has already witnessed an increase in the price of milk, bacon, eggs and beef, as well as the cost of transport, in the last 12 months to such an extent that trade union organisations are forced at present to seek an interim increase in wages in order to put into the pockets of workers, wage earners and those responsible for maintaining households some compensation for the depreciation in the value of money. When considered in the light of these things the remission is suggestive.
It has been suggested that in opposing this remission the Opposition are irresponsible, bluffing and doing something for political purposes which we would not do for economic purposes. No question of economy, justice or fair play has so far been brought before the House or the country to justify an increase in the price of bread, sugar or flour, cigarettes, petrol or income-tax. Income-tax is, to some extent, a difficult tax to collect and the Revenue Commissioners from time to time find evasions of that tax. Almost every tax, with few exceptions, presents difficulties of collection from time to time. The problem of these evasions and collecting the tax is a responsibility which the Revenue Commissioners discharge. The dance tax, however, has been represented as one which was evaded and was unpopular with dance-hall proprietors and those responsible for running dances. Nobody should be under any delusion that this will mean cheaper dances because it will not mean a reduction in the charge of admission. Even if it did, why should the House pass a Budget which remits the price of dancing when it increases the price of essential foodstuffs over and above the substantial increase in the cost of living which had already occurred during the past 12 months?
I do not think that any real case has been made for the remission of this tax. I do not think that there is any equity, any justice in a Budget which seeks to remit a tax on dances which in itself is not a very substantial amount of money in relation to the total sum covered by the Budget. It cannot be justified on the grounds that the section of the community it might benefit are as badly off or as much in need of subsidy from the Exchequer as those sections of the community whose subsidies are varied and decreased in respect of bread and eliminated in respect of tea, butter and sugar. Every wage earner, every individual in the community, will be obliged to pay more for all these essential commodities. I have put down a question to the Minister for Industry and Commerce for answer next week to try to elicit what reduction will take place in the price of jams, chocolates and sweets.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is this a Second Reading speech or is the Deputy speaking to the section? Even my colleague Deputy Dillon is yawning.
Comment on this
I have tried to elicit what reductions will take place in the price of these foodstuffs in order to discover what remission people will have in the case of some of these foodstuffs, because under this Budget they will pay more for bread, tea and all these other essential commodities, but the dance-hall proprietors will be enabled to get a remission of £140,000. I do not think any real case has been made for the remission of this tax, and I do not think there is any justice in remitting it when the Budget inflicts hardship, misery, difficulties and increased burdens on every section of the community. There could have been a case, and probably was, for remitting this tax in previous years, when we were maintaining foodstuffs at the same price, when beer, tobacco and all these other commodities were being retained at the existing level. There was some case to be made then for a remission of this dance tax, but there is no justification in a Budget which increases the burdens on each and every section and on every individual for remitting a tax in respect of dances which will not effect any reduction in the imposts being borne by all sections.
Comment on this
I want to emphasise the point made by Deputy Cowan that it is not unusual for political Parties——
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon is one of the gentlemen who has founded his case against this section on a particular letter which was written by a lady to members of her association——
Comment on this
——stating that she had received a letter from the then Deputy Lemass indicating that the Fianna Fáil Party were consistent in their views that dancing, as a form of entertainment, ought not to be taxed and that, as Deputy Cowan reminded us, we had, in fact, abolished the tax in 1946, had objected to its reimposition in 1949 and had again objected to it in 1950. If it had not been for the fact that Deputy McGilligan and the Coalition ran away from their Budget and fled to the country, we should have objected to it again in 1951. Therefore, as I have said, when Deputy Lemass, as he then was, and Minister for Industry and Commerce to-day, informed the secretary of the association representing the dance-hall proprietors who had approached him on the matter that we were consistent, the Deputy is not surely going to charge us with any impropriety, because we are consistent and always have been consistent in our attitude towards this tax.
Comment on this
——of his former associates, not excluding Deputy Dillon, told us that it would be exceedingly unusual and phenomenal if a political Party were to refuse subscriptions from organisations, and that it was not unusual for political parties to be asked to state what they would propose to do in regard to taxation or various forms of taxation, or indeed other subjects not at all related to taxation, such as the Adoption Bill, the short form of registration certificate or the export of horses — matters which no doubt came to Deputy Dillon's personal attention when he was Minister for Agriculture, and even a candidate in Monaghan at the various elections. It is quite the ordinary thing for organisations and individuals who feel that their interests can be improved to approach political parties and candidates and ask them to state their views and what they propose to do. It is quite a usual thing, too, for political parties to state these views. and, if their views in relation to these matters happen to meet with the approval of the organisations or individuals concerned, naturally——
Comment on this
——these organisations and individuals will come out and support the political Party which they think is going to govern the country according to their lights.
Comment on this
I am glad that Deputy Dillon has at least found this common ground with Deputy Dr. O'Higgins and Deputy McGilligan, because these two Deputies did meet a group of Dublin publicans prior to the 1948 election and were told that, if Fine Gael gave this group certain guarantees money would be no object, that it would be spent like water in order to secure the return of the Fine Gael Party with an over-all majority in Dáil Éireann.
Comment on this
Fine Gael was not the only organisation which had disinterested support of that sort. I happen to have in my possession a copy of a letter written by a certain gentleman enclosing a copy of another letter written by a former Minister of this State and a present Deputy. In the course of that letter, the then candidate at the general election of 1948. and subsequently Minister for External Affairs and present Deputy, gave certain assurances in regard to the entertainments duty on dog racing and in regard to the establishment of totalisators on dog racing tracks. As a consequence of that letter which he wrote to "Dear Paddy" and which he signed "Sean MacBride", "Dear Paddy" wrote a letter to his friend in which he said:—
"I am enclosing a statement of policy as affecting the greyhound industry which I have obtained from Mr. Seán MacBride, Clann na Poblachta leader, in reply to a questionnaire addressed to him. It is a very logical exposition of the position as affecting the industry. In addition to obtaining funds, I consider it the duty of every greyhound owner, and a good investment, to support this man's policy by sending me a subscription which will be duly acknowledged by his headquarters."
Was there anything corrupt in this little transaction between Deputy Seán MacBride, ex-Minister for External Affairs and "Dear Paddy"? Was there anything politically corrupt in it? Was there anything politically corrupt, so corrupt that "Dear Paddy" regarded a subscription to Clann na Poblachta as a very good investment ? You see, when people come into court they should come in with clean hands.
Comment on this
I want to say this, anyway, that the dance-hall proprietors stand much higher in public estimation than those who are associated with some other forms of sport.
Comment on this
This is the point. Deputy Dillon, as Minister for Agriculture, set up subsequently a committee to inquire into greyhound racing in this country and one of the matters which was to be investigated was the advisability of establishing totalisators on greyhound racing courses. Did Deputy Dillon set up this committee to inquire into that question, at the instance of Deputy MacBride, the Minister for External Affairs, who was acting on behalf of his friend who regarded a subscription to Clann na Poblachta as a sound investment, a very good investment?
Comment on this
This is the point. There had previously been an inquiry into the question of totalisators on greyhound racecourses but it did not matter that the issue had been decided. The point is this. Who moved Deputy MacBride? Was it "Dear Paddy" who moved him to induce his dear friend and colleague in the Coalition, the Minister for Agriculture, to set up this committee? You see, Deputy MacBride as he then was—I beg your pardon, Mr. Seán MacBride, as he was then only a candidate at the general election of 1948—had assured "Dear Paddy" that if he was returned to power and sufficiently influential, apparently licences to establish totalisators would be granted to the proprietors of the greyhound racing tracks and the entertainments tax upon dog racing would have gone into the pockets of the same individuals.
Comment on this
Just be quiet. These millionaires, the gentlemen who made millions out of the control of greyhound racing did not want the totalisators established.
Comment on this
On a point of order, whilst one might appreciate the Minister would refer to this particular sport or industry, is it in order for him to spend a quarter of an hour on such talk, on a section which deals with the repeal of the dance tax?
Comment on this
The section deals specifically with the dance tax. Are we to have a full discussion on the greyhound industry?
Comment on this
It is the greatest industry in this country. Do not stop the poor man coming up with his dog when he comes up to get something. Get the totalisator and he will get something with his dogs.
Comment on this
Order. The Minister must be given an opportunity to speak.
Comment on this
Deputy Fagan is very concerned about the poor man. Mind you, his colleague—perhaps I am anticipating——
Comment on this
Deputy MacBride turned me down about the totalisator. He was the first man who turned me down, in the presence of Deputy Dillon, when I asked for it. Deputy MacBride was the first man to turn me down in with the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
On a point of order, will we be allowed to discuss the films which are being shown currently in Dublin, as they are entertainment also?
Comment on this
This is a proposal to amend the entertainments duty. I am talking about former speeches in regard to amending the entertainments duty where, for one reason or another, the proposals came to nothing—perhaps for the same reason as nothing was done about changing the link with sterling currency.
Comment on this
I would like to protest. I think the Chair should take serious notice of the insolence of the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I think the Minister ought to be allowed to make his speech.
Comment on this
The Deputy was very much concerned about the letters which passed between Fianna Fáil and Miss Morris, and so was Deputy Séan Collins and Deputy Dillon, who do not like——
Comment on this
——to hear about the letters between "Dear Paddy" and Mr. Séan MacBride, this gentleman, as he was then. They do not like to hear that at all. I want to get back to Deputy Fagan's point.
Comment on this
On a point of order, will it be in order to discuss shrimp fishing, now that the shrimp boats are going to dance to-night?
Comment on this
Greyhound breeding is the biggest industry in the country, next to the horse-breeding industry.
Comment on this
I can see how Deputy Dillon's mind works. Quite clearly, there is an association of ideas on this plane. "Dear Paddy" was throwing a sprat in the form of a contribution to Clann na Poblachta in order to catch a whale of a totalisator and so Deputy Dillon wants us to discuss shrimp fishing.
Comment on this
This "Dear Paddy", throwing his sprat in the form of a subscription to Clann na Poblachta, thought it would enable "Dear Paddy" to get hold of the totalisator. He already owned the greyhounds; he already owned the racing track and the electric hare. He did not own the bookmakers, but if he could get hold of the totalisator—well, well, talk about the poor man's sport—he would be a millionaire.
Comment on this
In these circumstances, when Mr. MacBride, as he then was—Deputy MacBride as he is now— assured "Dear Paddy" that if he was elected he would undertake to use his influence to remove the tax on greyhound racecourses and consent to totalisators on greyhound racetracks, Mr. O'Donoghue—for that is the name of the gentleman in question—wrote a letter to all the greyhound owners in this country in the following terms:—
"I am enclosing a statement of policy as affecting the greyhound industry, which I have obtained from Mr. Seán MacBride, Clann na Poblachta Leader, in reply to a questionnaire addressed to him——"
—and I am not responsible for the syntax—
"——which is a very logical exposition of the position as affecting the two industries. In addition to obtaining funds, I consider it the duty of every greyhound owner—"
—mind you, this is the man who controls the principal track in this country and you cannot get your dog racing on it without his consent. He was telling the owners that he considered it the duty of every greyhound owner—I quote:—
"—and a good investment—to support this man's policy by sending me a subscription, which will be duly acknowledged by my headquarters."
Comment on this
If it was improper— and I do not concede that it was—for Deputy Lemass, as he then was, to inform the secretary of the Dance-Hall Proprietors' Association of the policy of Fianna Fáil in regard to the dance tax, surely it was equally improper for Mr. MacBride, as he then was—now Deputy MacBride—to inform the controller of the largest greyhound racing track in this country of the attitude of the Clann na Poblachta Party in regard to two things—(1) the entertainments duty on greyhound racing and (2) the granting of totalisator licences to the owners of greyhound racing tracks. If one thing was improper, the other thing was equally improper. As I say, I do not concede the first thing.
Next, if it was improper for the secretary of the Dance-Hall Proprietors' Association, at the instance of that association, to inform their members of the policy of Fianna Fáil in regard to the entertainments tax on dances—pointing out, in fact, that Fianna Fáil maintained the policy to which they had given effect in 1946, and that if they were returned to office they were prepared again to exclude dancing from the scope of the entertainments tax—then surely it was equally improper, on the basis of the assurances which Mr. MacBride—now Deputy MacBride—had given him, for Mr. O'Donoghue to go out looking for subscriptions for Clann na Poblachta.
As I have said, Deputy Cowan this morning put the case in its proper perspective. At the time of an election, every Party receives all sorts of communications and requests asking their attitude towards this problem and the other problem and you get subscriptions from various sources. Some people organise themselves into groups and go out to get subscriptions. Nobody will tell me, for instance, that the Fine Gael Party and the Clann na Poblachta Party did not, in the General Election of 1948 secure very generous subscriptions from the licensed trade in Dublin and throughout the rest of the country.
Comment on this
I am talking about something that happened outside this House. I know what I am talking about. I saw and have in my possession still a copy of a circular sent out in regard to that matter.
Comment on this
So we are going to believe that this appeal by the five Dublin publicans was not successful?
Comment on this
Are we asked to believe that? I have these documents— just as I have the copy of Deputy Mac-Bride's letter——
Comment on this
——and a number of other documents too, all of which can be produced and all of which——
Comment on this
Conversations across the floor of the House are not desirable.