We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Finance Bill, 1952—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 187–379 of 379. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1952
Enacted

No. 12 of 1952 ›

I would advise Deputy O'Leary to go and see how much the Labour Party got from certain oil interests in this country in 1935 and 1936.

Comment on this

At any rate, we got none from the sources from which you got it.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Let the Minister tell us now.

Comment on this

The Minister has the proof. Tell us now.

Comment on this

We are getting off the track. The point I want to make —and I want to repeat it again——

Comment on this

Is that you have gone to the dogs.

Comment on this

If I am repetitive it is because I am not being permitted to speak coherently because of the senseless interruptions emanating, principally, from Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

It is a good thing to make the Minister incoherent. It does not require much effort to do so.

Comment on this

As Deputy Cowan pointed out to this House this afternoon, Fianna Fáil have had a consistent policy in regard to the dance tax. Secondly, there is nothing unusual in the fact that political Parties are asked to express their policy in regard to one or other public issues or even in regard to things which are not public issues in the wide general sense but which affect particular sections of the community. Further, it is not unusual, if acceptable assurances are given, for the persons who feel that their interests will be promoted by a certain Party to come along and give it the material and public support which will be necessary in order to secure the election of that Party. These are commonplaces of politics. There is no use in Deputy Dillon's holding his nose as if there were something indecent, corrupt or wrong with it. It just happens. Everybody knows that it happens in that way. However, they do not have a corrupt influence, at any rate, so far as the attitude of Governments in this country is concerned. I assume that we try to administer the affairs of this country decently and honestly. The one thing that does, perhaps, deter us—and we have had an example of that in the Budget of 1951 —is the fact that we hate to do an unpopular thing. Therefore, even though our advisers give us impeccable advice —as Deputy McGilligan was given it in 1951—that several millions more might be required and that the only way of getting it is to increase the taxes on beer, spirits, petrol and tobacco, these are things which we do not like to do. Sometimes, again, as happened in May, 1951, we are not prepared to face up to our obligations and responsibilities in that regard. Otherwise, outside that, I do not think political Parties are influenced very much by subscriptions which they get. In the main, these subscriptions come from people who are sympathetic to the broad policies expressed by these Parties and who are anxious to see these policies made effective. Therefore, without looking for any special return, they are prepared to support us.

In regard to the question of the dance tax, on its merits, and having disposed——

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Hear, hear. On its merits.

Comment on this

Up to the present, this tax has been discussed on the basis of a letter——

Comment on this

It has not.

Comment on this

Ah! Deputy Dillon, I think on Section 6 of this Bill, opened the matter by referring to this letter. He was told by the Ceann Comhairle that he could more properly raise that issue on Section 14, and it was on Section 14 that the issue was raised by Deputy S. Collins, who opened the debate for the Opposition. The debate was continued on the same lines by a very suggestive speech by Deputy Norton. "No," he said, "the letter was not an issue." He kept repeating it time and time again—and all the time he was making it an issue. We had the same performance from Deputy Cosgrave. I have no doubt that if I had not got up, and if Deputy Dillon had got up before me we should have had from Deputy Dillon for the third time to-day a speech referring to that letter. Having, as I said, shown that there has been nothing unusual in regard to the letter, that the transaction was perfectly plain and open, I have only to repeat what I said yesterday.

Comment on this

It was a promise.

Comment on this

A statement to this effect—given in certain terms—that we were making no promise; we would consider the situation as we found it, but pointing out that we had in 1946 removed the tax and, in 1949, opposed the re-imposition of the tax, and again opposed the continuance of the tax in 1950. That was the general terms of the letter. I have not it in front of me. Arising out of that letter, this lady, at the instance, I assume, of the former——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Of the Tánaiste.

Comment on this

——of the former member of the Clan na Poblachta Party, who was, I think, a candidate at that election, who was chairman of the Dance-Hall Proprietors' Association, wrote this letter asking for subscriptions to the Fianna Fáil Party and asking for votes and influence and support for the Fianna Fáil Party, just the same as at the last general election, the official representatives of the licensed trade went out against Fianna Fáil——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Naturally, after the Supplementary Budget.

Comment on this

Naturally, of course. There was nothing improper, apparently, in that but, apparently, it is a very improper thing for the dance-hall proprietors to ask their members to support Fianna Fáil because Fianna Fáil has taken up and has maintained over the years a certain attitude in regard to taxing dancing as a form of public entertainment.

Comment on this

You took bribes.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

How much did you get?

Comment on this

You put 1/8 in the £ on the ratepayers by the letters you sent out.

Comment on this

A Deputy has accused me of taking bribes.

Comment on this

Your Party.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think the bribes were ascribed as being given to the Minister. I understand they were ascribed as being given to a Party. I must say, however, that the suggestion is undesirable and should not be used, but it has not been said that bribes were given to any particular person.

Comment on this

Of course, if I happen to be a member of the Fianna Fáil Party and the bribe is given to the Party, I must participate in the benefits derived from the bribe. The implication is quite clear.

Comment on this

The lady said you got £250 from her. Will you deny that?

Comment on this

I want to say that no member of the Fianna Fáil Party has any responsibility for what Miss Morris wrote.

Comment on this

Do you deny it?

Comment on this

I do not know what she wrote because I did not see her letter.

Comment on this

I will read it out for you.

Comment on this

I do not know what she wrote. I have not seen the letter. I do not know the lady.

Comment on this

Surely you have heard the letter read?

Comment on this

Whether I have or not is beside the point.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

How much did you get?

Comment on this

I know what "Dear Paddy" wrote.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give way and I will read out the letter?

Comment on this

No, but I will read out what "Dear Paddy" wrote. I do not propose to give way.

Comment on this

I thought you would not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister is entitled to speak without this barrage of interruptions.

Comment on this

He is destroying one of our greatest industries.

Comment on this

Apparently we have to discuss this question in the atmosphere which Deputy Dillon and the others have endeavoured to create around it. I only want to say in regard to this matter that I have no responsibility, nor has any member of the Fianna Fáil Party any responsibility, for any letter which was written by the secretary of the Dance-Hall Proprietors' Association. We have no control over the lady.

Comment on this

You have control of what was in the envelope.

Comment on this

If any proprietor of a dance-hall saw fit to subscribe to the funds of the Fianna Fáil Party, that was his business.

Comment on this

Or hers.

Comment on this

They got very good value.

Comment on this

There is nothing more improper in taking a subscription from a proprietor of a dance-hall than there is in taking a subscription from a proprietor of a greyhound racing track or the proprietor of a public-house, and we know there were very hefty subscriptions given by some proprietors in Dublin.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

We have the evidence; the Minister has not.

Comment on this

There was no conspiracy.

Comment on this

All Miss Morris said is that one dance-hall proprietor gave a subscription——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Of £250.

Comment on this

Whether it was or not, what subscriptions did Mr. O'Donoghue give?

Comment on this

She said much more than that.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Donoghue owns or controls the National Greyhound Racing Association.

Comment on this

He does not own it; he is the chairman.

Comment on this

He controls it and a lot of other things connected with it which are not for the benefit of the greyhound-racing industry.

Comment on this

We in the Irish Coursing Club are trying to keep coursing straight and we want a totalisator to keep it straight.

Comment on this

He gave such a generous subscription to the funds of Clann na Poblachta that he was able to run his son as a candidate for the Party in Kerry and South Kerry in 1948.

Comment on this

On a point of order. This is just a matter for the record. I am not interested in the merits or demerits of the Minister's line on this or as to what demerits there may be in it but I am concerned about laying down procedure in this House and starting rather dangerous precedents. The Minister is attacking a person, a named individual.

Comment on this

A decent man; that is what he is.

Comment on this

It does not matter. That has nothing to do with it. He is attacking a named person outside this House in a particular, personal way. I suggest to the Minister and to you, Sir, that that is not only improper and disorderly, but that it is highly undesirable and, if this is allowed to go, then I think no citizen outside this House will be safe from attack. Personally, I would not like to see that established here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have already said that statements of that kind are entirely undesirable and should not be made use of in this House in respect of any citizen of the State.

Comment on this

I wonder how that applies to Miss Morris, who was described in these terms by Deputy Norton this morning, as being a nigger— a nigger in the woodpile.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

If the Minister does not understand the expression, he must be very ignorant.

Comment on this

Deputies do not like their medicine. I am asking if there is anything wrong in taking a subscription from a dance-hall proprietor and nothing wrong in taking a subscription from a proprietor of a greyhound racing track, which he himself boasted about, about which he wrote a letter to the public. Every greyhound owner in Ireland got it.

Comment on this

It is wrong to take a bribe.

Comment on this

Was this a bribe? Are we to assume, then, that the subscription which "Dear Paddy" gave to Mr. Seán MacBride, as he then was, to the funds of Clann na Poblachta, was a bribe?

Comment on this

There was no undertaking.

Comment on this

Of course, there was. That is the whole point. There was an undertaking given that he would use his influence to remove the tax on greyhound racing and to secure consent for the establishment of totalisators on greyhound racing tracks.

Comment on this

Would not that be good for the industry?

Comment on this

It would not. We viewed the matter differently.

Comment on this

Why did you give them a licence for the track in Chapelizod? You did that yourself as Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

That promise to remove the tax on greyhound racing and to permit the establishment of totalisators on greyhound racing tracks was the consideration — and Mr. O'Donoghue makes no secret about it —which induced him to issue this letter to the greyhound owners of Ireland telling them that it was their duty and, he said, a very good investment, to subscribe to the funds of Clann na Poblachta.

Comment on this

It was general policy.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister has had a fair run. He has been 40 minutes now without once dealing with or trying in any way to sustain his case for the removal of this dance tax. He spent over 30 minutes on greyhound racing, Mr. O'Donoghue and Mr. O'Donoghue's letter. After 30 minutes on that at least we might have a few minutes from the Minister on whatever case he can attempt to make for the removal of this dance tax.

Comment on this

I am sorry, Sir. I know I have to ask for a certain amount of consideration. This proposal is not being considered by the Opposition on its merits. The suggestion has been that because somebody gave a subscription of £250, we were doing something improper in removing the entertainments tax on dancing. I am asking is there anything more improper in tendering a subscription of that sort and taking it from the proprietor of a dance-hall than there is in taking a subscription from the proprietor of a greyhoundracing track, having given that proprietor an assurance that if you were returned to power, you would use your influence to secure that the entertainments tax would no longer apply to greyhound racing and that permission would be given for the establishment of the totalisator on greyhound tracks.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That has been said by the Minister several times.

Comment on this

That is the question I want to put to the Opposition and the onus is on them to answer that question.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! I hope they will get an opportunity to answer it.

Comment on this

We have been consistent in our attitude in regard to certain things. Somebody has said "corrupted." I think it was Deputy MacEoin. He is a good judge of corruption.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is an expression that should be withdrawn in respect to any Deputy.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEoin has been named by the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The expression should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister has deliberately made statements like that both yesterday and to-day about a certain matter which in my opinion are completely untrue. I do not mind it at all because anything he says is only vulgar abuse.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have said that the expression should be withdrawn in respect to any Deputy. I do not think Deputy MacEoin spoke at all, so that the expression should be withdrawn not only specifically in regard to Deputy MacEoin, but in general in respect to any Deputy.

Comment on this

I unreservedly bow to your ruling, but I understood some person certainly to use the word. I do not know who the fellow was, as he was afraid to stand up, but some person certainly did use the word "corruption". It was heard by me and heard by my colleagues. I assumed, because of the intonation, that it was Deputy MacEoin. I am very sorry if I accused him in the wrong, and I withdraw the accusation unreservedly in his regard.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

To charge any Deputy with corruption is unparliamentary and it must be withdrawn without qualification.

Comment on this

I am withdrawing it without qualification, but what I want to know is what the Chair proposes to do in regard to the Deputy who used the word "corruption", if he has not the courage to stand up and repeat it. I do not know what Deputy used it, but I am perfectly certain that it was used, as my colleagues and I heard it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The ruling of the Chair is that the word should not be used in association with any Deputy. That ruling is general and it applies to all Deputies.

Comment on this

It was not used in association with any Deputy. It was used in association with the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

Look here, the whole does include the part.

Comment on this

Does anybody doubt that the dance-hall proprietors' performance was corruption by the Fianna Fáil Party?

Comment on this

What about six months' back pay for nothing? Was that corruption?

Comment on this

I do not know whether I would be entitled to pursue the matter which has been raised by Deputy MacEoin in regard to something which I said yesterday. I am perfectly prepared to have that matter raised in a formal way because I can say that Deputy MacEoin did mislead the House——

Comment on this

This is outrageous.

Comment on this

The Minister made a definite statement that I knew all about corruption, suggesting that the corruption is a personal matter to myself. May I assure the Minister just of this one fact: that when I invited him to seek the permission of the two people he was talking about to raise the matter in this House, he failed to do so.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This matter is a riddle to me.

Comment on this

It seems to me that we are at cross-purposes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not know anything about this.

Comment on this

I have not accused Deputy MacEoin of corruption. What I have accused him of, and what I am prepared to stand over if this House asks for an investigation to be made, is of misleading the House, when he was Minister for Justice, in order to protect his colleague, the then Minister for External Affairs, Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is a positive charge.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared, provided the Minister has not interfered with any of the files I left behind me, to have an investigation by the Committee of Procedure and Privileges into these files.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow this matter to develop. There is nothing before the House but the Finance Bill. I do not know exactly what the Deputy is referring to. I do not know to what Deputy MacEoin has been referring. The House must revert to the amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEoin referred to a statement made by the Minister in the House yesterday.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is clearly a matter upon which I cannot adjudicate because I have no knowledge of the circumstances.

Comment on this

I have the Official Report.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot accept ex parte statements of that kind. The matter must be raised in a regular way. The Deputy will get an opportunity of presenting the matter in a regular way to the House. At present I cannot do anything in a matter which is not before me.

Comment on this

Then I take it you will rule out of order the accusations made by the Minister again Deputy MacEoin.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

When personal accusations are made against any Deputy I shall deal with them as they arise. When a charge was made against Deputy MacEoin I immediately secured its withdrawal. There was a withdrawal of the charge of corruption against any Deputy. I cannot deal with a matter about which I do not know anything and which has not arisen before me.

Comment on this

The Minister has repeated the charge just now.

Comment on this

I have endeavoured to disabuse Deputy MacEoin of the idea that I had accused him of corruption in the sense of taking cash or other consideration for any favour. I did not accuse him of corruption in that sense.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There must be no charge against Deputy MacEoin or against any other Deputy of corruption. Inasmuch as Deputy MacEoin was specifically mentioned, I asked that the charge be withdrawn in his regard specially. That is the ruling.

Comment on this

I unreservedly withdrew it.

Comment on this

Why repeat it?

Comment on this

I withdrew the association of Deputy MacEoin's name with a lie. I was told that the word lie was unparliamentary and so it is. I withdrew it. I did not walk out of the House and then slink in again to vote.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us get back to Section 14.

Comment on this

I withdrew it and that is all.

Comment on this

You are addled.

Comment on this

I have been wondering for a long time what was the matter with the Deputy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The matter before the House is the section.

Comment on this

It is a long time since the Minister saw it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister for Finance on Section 14.

Comment on this

We can now come to discuss the section on its merits. As I pointed out when moving the Second Reading of the Bill, this dance tax is a complete anomaly. It is the only form of entertainment the participants in which are taxed. The people who engage in dancing as a social amusement and have to go to a public hall to do so are taxed for doing that. If they happen to be professionals, however, and they are dancing on the stage you can go and see them dancing and they are not taxed and you are not taxed. But if people go to a dance hall in Dublin and take their wives, fiancées or sweethearts, they are taxed even before going in. If one happens to have a wooden leg and wants to go out in the evening with the rest of a party, wooden leg and all, he is taxed on going into the hall. If you happen to be an amateur all-in wrestler and you go to Croke Park or anywhere else and throw your opponent about and subject yourself to torture, you will not be taxed. Anyone who goes to look on will not be taxed either. If you go to a racemeeting you will not be taxed for going.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Unless you win.

Comment on this

But if you happen to be interested in dancing and take your family out for the evening, again, as I said, you will be taxed. The whole thing is completely anomalous and that is why it was removed.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Why tax petrol, then?

Comment on this

I am talking about entertainments. I think it was Deputy Costello who suggested that one could swallow petrol. I do not know anybody who takes petrol as an entertainment or as a beverage.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Motor cars run on petrol.

Comment on this

Of course they do.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Why tax anything?

Comment on this

You can reduce any argument to an absurdity. But surely the onus is on the man who wants things to be taxed to prove that they ought to be taxed. Is not the onus on Deputy Corish to prove why dancing ought to be taxed, not to oppose the Government who are taking the tax off people? Surely it is the man who is advocating taxation who must prove that things must be taxed, that you cannot avoid taxing them. Does not the whole onus lie on those advocating the taxation of anything, whether it be entertainments, amusements, luxuries such as mink coats and Chrysler cars, or beer, spirits or tobacco?

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Or Frank Aiken's top hat.

Comment on this

When we come to top hats——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is nothing about hats in this section.

Comment on this

Except this, that occasionally when worn by certain persons they become a form of entertainment for others and therefore they might be drawn within the ambit of an entertainment tax. I was pointing out that this tax is, in essence, a complete anomaly. If it is wrong to tax football, hurling, swimming and boxing, it must be equally wrong to tax dancing. There cannot be any way out of that.

Comment on this

Tell the country people why you took it off and put it on to butter.

Comment on this

Not only that, but the developments which have followed from the reimposition of this tax in 1949 have been entirely undesirable. You have, as I pointed out, large dance halls springing up and offering great attractions outside ordinary urban areas.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Then there should be nothing in rural Ireland? Dublin is to have everything.

Comment on this

The Deputy should at least be rational in his interruptions and logical in his conclusions. Nobody is trying to keep dance halls from springing up in the country. What is happening was referred to by Deputy Norton to-day. He told us about a dance hall in the country where there were often 2,000 people trying to get in. I have no objection to people going to dances at the seaside or in the country or anywhere else. What I do think is undesirable is that they should be attracted a long way from their homes in order to go to these dances and that there should be exceptional cases of persons coming home under the influence of drink late at night who are a menace to themselves and other users of the roads.

Comment on this

Will the removal of the tax correct that?

Comment on this

It will at least make people look for amusement in the vicinity of their homes. Apart from the undesirable developments which have followed from the reimposition of this tax in the particular form in which it was reimposed, this tax has been proven to be very, very difficult indeed to administer.

Comment on this

Will the Minister admit that the removal of the dance tax was a political and financial blunder? He is trying to talk himself out of it.

Comment on this

As everybody knows, if a dance is held in a village the population of which does not exceed 500, or is held outside a certain radius from a centre of population of more than 500, it is free of tax. But the population of this country varies from year to year, and from census to census. The population of these towns varies from census to census. It could happen that on the day before a census was taken and enumerated admission to dance halls would be free of tax and on the following day be subject to tax.

Comment on this

How often do you take a census?

Comment on this

Every five years.

Comment on this

How often has this catastrophic thing occurred?

Comment on this

After all, if you are to have a tax administered at all it must be certain in its incidence. It must fall once and for all on a definite person.

Comment on this

Have sense. Incomes are assessed every year if under the law they are subject to tax.

Comment on this

That is quite a different matter.

Comment on this

It is not a different matter. One year you pay income tax and the next year you may not, all according to what your income is.

Comment on this

I cannot deal with the puerilities——

Comment on this

Puerilities, my foot!

Comment on this

——of Deputy O'Sullivan and the irrational interruptions of Deputy Dillon at the same time. Deputy Dillon goes on forever like the babbling brook. Sometime he really ought to put a stopper on himself. After all, he aspires to be again a member of the Government of this country. Surely he does not behave like this around the Cabinet table.

Comment on this

He never had to sit opposite the likes of you in the Cabinet. If he had his hair would be grey as well as thin by now.

Comment on this

The situation has, in fact, developed that the patrons of a dance hall may be subject to a dance tax one day and may be free from it the next. The converse may occur; they may be free from it one day and subject to it the next. Not only that, but one can—and I pointed this out in my speech on the Second Reading— hold a dance in a country mansion provided that mansion is three miles from anywhere in the sense that it is three miles from any village. One can charge 16/- or £1 or 30/- and call it a hunt ball or anything else. Patrons going there will not be subject to tax. But if a dance is held in the village and if the village has more than 500 persons in it —if it has 501 persons in it—one is immediately subject to tax, irrespective of the admission fee charged. If patrons are charged 5/- that 5/- is subject to tax. Is not that a completely illogical situation? Is it not illogical that a person can go into a country mansion and dance in the ballroom there free of tax provided that mansion is three miles from anywhere in the sense that it is three miles from any centre of population? A patron may be compelled to pay 30/- or £2—whatever the proprietor likes to charge for admission to this dance—and he will not be subject to tax.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

How often is that type of dance held?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Two or three times a year.

Comment on this

The Deputy is now asking me how often is a man justified in committing murder before he is hanged. That is what his argument amounts to. How often must an abuse of that kind occur or how long should an anomaly of that kind continue before it is remedied? What we are trying to do in this section is to prevent an abuse and remedy an anomaly. We realise—and Deputy McGilligan realised it in 1950—that there is an anomaly. We are trying to remedy a completely anomalous and illogical situation, and the only way in which it can be remedied is by reverting to the position that existed after the 1946 Finance Act was passed.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

What about young farmers' clubs?

Comment on this

We are reverting to the position of leaving dancing free of tax in the same way as boxing is free of it, football is free of it, swimming is free of it, cricket is free of it, hurling is free of it and every other amusement——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Cinemas.

Comment on this

Cinemas are not an amusement in which the audience are the actors. We are leaving it—dancing —free of tax in the same way as amusements in which the people participate as actual actors on the scene are left free of tax.

Comment on this

You took the tax off dancing and you put it on the age-old pensioners. That is what we would like to hear you answer.

Comment on this

It is most exhausting to the patience of the House and particularly to the speaker to continue to argue a case surrounded with a sort of barrage of completely nonsensical interruptions such as those of Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Leary.

Comment on this

Mine were most relevant.

Comment on this

I am sorry to see Deputy O'Leary sink to the depths that Deputy Dillon does. He ought to keep himself above that level.

Comment on this

You are sorry now that you took the tax off dancing.

Comment on this

The moral tone of this House is not rising and the tenor of the discussion so far has been—and Deputy Cowan was part of the discussion when he constituted himself an advocate of the Fianna Fáil Party— that after all the purchase of votes is pretty generally practised in politics and why should we not all accept that. I could not help thinking of the statues of Grattan and Flood and of an Irish Parliament sitting here. Did they ever dream that we would reach the depth of degradation in which the Government of Ireland would seek to justify itself by the arguments employed by Dutch Schultz before the Kefauver Committee?

"I did nothing worse than what others were doing. I only took the graft that was going. Why do you pick on me?"

Is not that a loathsome defence to hear made by an Irish Government in this Parliament? That is the defence that the Minister for Finance makes. If this is a bribe to sell a benefit, did not Deputy MacBride accept a bribe to sell a benefit? I do not think he did. In any event, there is the fundamental difference that, whatever was thought was promised, what Mr. O'Donoghue got was an inquiry the report of which is in the Minister's hands to-day. He is free to publish that report.

Comment on this

Absolute nonsense.

Comment on this

That is the distinction. The Minister says that he knew nothing of this business or of his colleague's undertaking. He has changed his tune because his colleague, Seán F. Lemass, in his letter of 10th May says that Miss Morris' letter on behalf of the Ballroom Proprietors' Association of May 6th has been considered by the Fianna Fáil Party Committee.

"The committee's view is that the entertainments duty on dances is an undesirable tax. As to its abolition in the present financial year, however, a decision must necessarily await the detailed examination of the Budget introduced in the Dáil immediately prior to its dissolution, but it would be the intention of the Fianna Fáil Party to repeal it as soon as practicable."

Comment on this

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

I will tell you. I have 20 minutes at my disposal and I will tell you. Does that not suggest that the Fianna Fáil Party felt that if a tax remission were permitted in the Budget situation they discovered when they became responsible the merits of that application would be considered with any rival application. But that is not what happened. This House yesterday voted to put 1d. on the bus fares in Dublin and Cork by way of tax on diesel oil to yield £100,000, and that is the money that will be used to pay the debt to the dance-hall proprietors.

Comment on this

Has Fianna Fáil let you into any of their secrets yet?

Comment on this

The Minister asked what could be more natural in democracy than that a body of persons who had reviewed political policy and had come to the conclusion that generally a particular political outlook pleased them and suggested to them a desirable repercussion on society as a whole, what was more natural than that they should solicit subscriptions to promote the interests of that Party? But that is not what the dance-hall proprietors said. They said that it would be appreciated that this association is entirely non-political. It was not interested in policy. It was not interested in the impact of Fianna Fáil on society.

Comment on this

Go down and look for the mayoral chain in Cork. There will be no division to-day. You are a rough old man but you should not draw my tongue on you too much. Go away or keep quiet.

"It will be appreciated that the association is entirely non-political, and that having failed utterly"— mark this—"to impress the previous Government or the Minister for Finance, though it pointed out the hardships caused to ballroom business, to clubs hiring the ballrooms, musicians, staffs, etc., the association has now no alternative but to support the Party who has indicated that they are prepared to repeal this tax as soon as it is practicable.

The association has decided that the support of Fianna Fáil——"

This is what the Minister has described as a realistic approach in politics,

"——should take the form of substantial financial help and also that all members both city and country should lend a hand in every possible direction to secure the return to power of the one Party who has given the association an indication that they as a Party are opposed to this undesirable entertainment tax on dances."

That letter is dated the 15th May, 1951. I ask the House to note the form of words:—

"The association has now no alternative but to support the Party who has indicated that they are prepared to repeal this tax as soon as it is practicable..."

The letter goes on to say that they are the one Party which has given the association an indication "that they as a Party are opposed to this undesirable entertainment tax on dances." I now ask the House to listen to the letter of Deputy Seán F. Lemass:—

"I have received your letter of May 6th which has been considered by the Fianna Fáil Party Committee. The committee's view is that the entertainments duty on dances is an undesirable tax. As to its abolition in the present financial year, however, a decision must necessarily await the detailed examination of the Budget introduced in the Dáil immediately prior to its dissolution, but it would be the intention of the Fianna Fáil Party to repeal it as soon as necessary."

Miss Morris is not moved by the general tenor of Fianna Fáil policy. She is moved by the specific words implied by Deputy Seán F. Lemass in his letter, that the entertainments tax on dances is an undesirable tax. But more is to come. She says:—

"It will be appreciated that in order to have the desired effect our financial aid must of necessity be generous. I may mention that one leading commercial ballroom in Dublin has headed the list of subscribers to this fund with a generous sum of £250 and other members of the executive have also indicated their willingness to subscribe very generously.

Whilst the association does not specify any particular amount to be subscribed, they request you, in your own interest, to give as much as possible. I shall deem it a great favour if you will reply promptly as time is getting short before the general election, and if we are to help it must be done immediately."

Now, I give this credit to Fianna Fáil that, faced with the duty of defending that transaction before the country, they summoned Deputy Cowan to their aid. Behold the advocate! The strain and the pain in the countenances of the criminals in the dock as their resourceful advocate sought to put a gloss upon their conduct reflected some credit on their hardened consciences. They summoned Deputy Cowan to their aid and, to give the devil his due, he followed most dutifully every hare that he thought could be chased, and one hare proved more rheumatic than the other. As they crept their way around the floor here they met with derisory laughter from all those who were listening, so that the tattered reputation of Fianna Fáil became not only tattered but aromatic. We were finally forced to this stage: "They are a poor lot, a mean lot, but, sure, what do you expect them to be? After all, they are only T.D.s and you do not expect much of T.D.s in this country." I say that is typical of the rotten, corrupting and blasting effect which Fianna Fáil have had on everything that they have touched in this country, that it is conceivable that men could get up in Dáil Éireann and say: "After all, they are only T.D.s, and what more could you expect from them?" I think we are entitled to expect from members of this Parliament the highest standard of honour and integrity.

Comment on this

Not like you in this House.

Comment on this

We all accept the obligation of sitting in this House and of working with individuals whom, quite possibly in other circumstances, we would not touch with the other end of a 40-foot pole but for the fact that the Irish people conferred on them the privileged position of being Deputies of Dáil Éireann and placed on every one of us the honourable obligation of going into their malodorous company and of appearing with them as equals.

It is a monstrous thing if the doctrine is to be enunciated here that there is an obligation on us to equate our standards of conduct with the lowest standard of conduct that Deputy Cowan can think up as practical for any legislator or public representative. I think we are entitled to demand, every one of us, high standards of conduct. I think the Minister ought to be ashamed to come into this House with the crawling, ghastly alibi: "I did nothing worse than others did; somebody else did something queer; I have evidence he did, and so my act is no worse than his."

That is a contemptible defence. I want to comment on it not only for the failure of the analogy between what the Minister referred to and his own conduct, but because it is base, humiliating and degrading that an Irish Minister should think it an adequate alibi to say: "Why pick on me; they are all at it; if I got money by the way, why pick on me; we all do it?" We do not all do it, and it should not go out to the people in this country that Dáil Éireann accepts the proposition that every political Party goes before them seeking their suffrages and claiming the right to be ruled by a morality entirely distinct from that which should rule the lives of ordinary men and women, and no ordinary man wishes to boast of the fact that he undertook to do something in the course of duty because he received payment for it over and above what he was entitled to get.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This section deals with a specific tax. The Deputy is now on the question of parliamentary morality.

Comment on this

I am saying that Fianna Fáil was avowedly paid £250 by a particular dance hall association to introduce this section into the Bill. I am saying that the Minister for Finance defended his conduct by saying that Deputy MacBride promised to do so and so, and "I denounce Deputy MacBride as having done something dishonourable." The Minister says: "If I can establish that he did something dishonourable why pick on me for doing something dishonourable?" I answer that I do not see any analogy between the two cases referred to. However, even if there were a perfect analogy, it would be completely wrong to say: "If somebody else did something wrong, why pick on me?"

This is the important point to remember. What actually transpired in connection with the greyhound racing committee which we have heard discussed to-day for 40 minutes was that a commission was set up to inquire into it.

Comment on this

And the tax was taken off.

Comment on this

There was no change in the tax.

Comment on this

There was.

Comment on this

What actually happened was that an inquiry was set up into the whole greyhound racing industry, including the greyhound breeding industry. The fact is that the report of that inquiry is in the Minister's hands, but he will not publish it. What the greyhound industry got was an inquiry to examine most exhaustively every turn and twist in the coursing business, the greyhound racing business, the breeding business, and the buying and selling of greyhounds. Let that report be published, and let legislation coinciding with its recommendations be enacted, and let anyone in this House get up and say that those recommendations were bespoken by people connected with that industry who were in bad faith. Now compare that with what happened. They did not ask for an inquiry; they did not ask for any investigation; they asked for cash on the nail, and they said: "If you give us so much cash, we will give you so much cash, and they gave the cash."

Comment on this

Right.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan says "right". He is a practical realist. He claps the desk and says "right". That is the whole issue. Is it right that the Government of Ireland should say to any group in this country: "If you will put down the cash, we will put down the taxpayers' cash." I say that is not proper; I say that is corruption; if it is not corruption, I want somebody to correct me. Is it proper for a vested interest in this country to walk into the executive of a political Party from whose membership the Government is drawn and to strike a bargain and say: "We will give you so much money. How much money will you pass to us through the Finance Act"? I say that is corrupt. Am I wrong in so saying? I understand Deputy Cowan to say that that procedure is right. He is the advocate and the defender of the Fianna Fáil Party who say: "If we can sell it to the country and get them to realise that it is the practical thing to do, we may get away with it." I do not think that Fianna Fáil can hope to effect that degree of degradation. Our people are no prudes; they are no fraudulent moralists; they know the difference between right and wrong, and they know the standard they expect of their public men; they do not expect them to be angels. They sent people like Deputy McGrath in here. They expect that even for people like Deputy McGrath there will be certain Rubicons across which they will not venture to put their feet. They expect that there will be certain standards of conduct from which our public men will not stray. Our people are very good judges of what conduct should be. It is for that reason that I sound this note of warning to the Fianna Fáil Party. Let them not try to ride off with the alibi——

Comment on this

Would somebody give him a lollypop?

Comment on this

——that "if our sin is a sin, it is not a very big one". Our people do not like that attitude. They expect a man who has done something wrong in public life to admit that wrong and to repair it. Our people will not swallow any doctrines advocating the complete abandonment of standards of decency in this country. I want to know do the Fianna Fáil Party, in the open light of day, endorse what they did behind closed doors, because this proposition was made at the meeting of the Executive Party Committee.

Comment on this

Read the letter again.

Comment on this

They agreed to take so much money for Section 14 of the Finance Bill. I assert that there is no precedent for a transaction of this kind in the public life of this country. Has Dáil Éireann ever before been asked to pass a section in an Act of Parliament to honour a bargain sealed for the payment of money to the political Party of which the Government is constituted? Is that an unfair description of this transaction? Is there any precedent in the 30 years of life of this Parliament for this Assembly being openly asked to enact legislation to fulfil a bargain sealed with a monetary payment by the vested interests of the political Party from which the present Government is drawn? Are we to allow this practice to pass as the accepted procedure of Oireachtas Éireann? There is no other Legislature in the world outside the banana Republics of South America where that could be done and got away with. Could you imagine what your reactions would be if you read in the newspaper that a proposal was brought before the Congress of the United States of America advocating that money should be appropriated for a vested interest which had paid a substantial sum to the democratic Parties of the United States on condition that they would enact legislation appropriating them a substantial amount of money?

Comment on this

I have heard that allegation time and again.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan would shrug his shoulders and say: "What could you expect from a degenerated, capitalistic society of the like?" I can imagine the expression on the Deputy's face when he would be speaking about the disintegrating capitalistic Government which was engaged on these imperialistic adventures. How many speeches has he made about it? I bet that Deputy Cowan has made the welkin ring at the awful spectacle of corruption that surrounds and permeates the public life of America. Yet, he is the man who has come before us to-day advocating that we should take this policy to our bosom with both arms and adopt it as the practical standard and the realist's approach to politics in Ireland. If he thinks there is disintegration in the public life of the United States of America, why does he want it here? I move to report progress.

Comment on this