Committee on Finance. - Vote 50—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).
Contributions 1–199 of 421. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When progress was reported last evening I was inquiring from the Minister whether it was not possible to break down the bulk buying of tea immediately. The Minister is no doubt aware that one of the heaviest increases in costs as a result of the removal of subsidies is in the increase in the price of tea. It is the general beverage of the poorer classes and I feel, and I think every Deputy in the House feels, that the sooner the central buying authority goes out of the way and that you have direct imports by former tea importers, the sooner the question of price will readjust itself to its competitive level. I am aware that the Minister pointed out on a previous occasion that there are considerable stocks on hand but I think there should be a ready avenue of disposal for those stocks by throwing trade open through the normal channels. It would be in the interests of the trade and in the interests of the people generally to have a wide variety of tea and a wide range of prices.
I am sure that my colleagues in the Labour Party will deal extensively with the problems that have arisen in connection with Córas Iompair Éireann. Córas Iompair Éireann is one of the largest employers operating under State auspices. We are painfully aware of the chaotic state in which that company finds itself in connection with its revenue but we have, too, a duty to those people who have given a lifetime of service in the transport system and who may now find themselves in some danger. I know that the Minister intends to have a conference with the various union leaders in connection with that matter to-morrow and I am sure the Minister will be able to resolve some part of the scare that has arisen because of the threat of pending dismissals. It may be that the situation is not as grave as rumour would have it. It may be that it is not as serious as some people would believe it is. I feel the Minister would be doing good work if he allayed to whatever extent he can rumours that are flying around in relation to the general employment position in Córas Iompair Éireann.
The problem is a complex one. We have the doleful record of this transport company. The Minister has indicated that Córas Iompair Éireann will lose this year an amount in excess of that already budgeted for. The transport system is in the melting pot. The Minister may have some idea of the best method of solving the present problem and we would be grateful to have some indication as to what that solution is. These continued losses are like an ulcer that becomes more infected year by year. The drain on the public purse will have to be arrested.
Representing the rural constituency of West Cork, I do not want anybody to labour under the misapprehension that we in that area think it is the duty of the Minister to establish industries in West Cork. That is a duty primarily for the people in the area. It is they who should create the stimulus that will ultimately lead to the establishment of industry there. There are, of course, problems in connection with the establishment of industry in that area. There is the difficulty of transport. There is the isolated nature of the peninsula. I would appeal to the Minister in so far as it lies within his power not to forget that particular area.
We are facing, too, in the rural areas the seemingly inevitable decay of the small provincial towns. That decay is not primarily due to the trade recession because it has shown itself over a number of years. The problem is one that must be handled on a national basis. It is not peculiar to my constituency, but in my constituency the decay is becoming more marked.
Finally, I regret the saving made on this Estimate by the removal in part of the subsidies. The result of this reduction will cause vicious impact on that section of the community least able to bear the burden.
Comment on this
Deputy S. Collins and Deputy Morrissey have both spoken on the present position of Córas Iompair Éireann. Deputy Morrissey maintained that the railway is an essential service. I believe it is an essential service. I do not intend to criticise the action taken by the previous Government, the board established by that Government or the powers that were given to it. We hear a good deal about the subsidisation of Córas Iompair Éireann. If the traffic that is now carried by rail was diverted to the roads, would not the taxpayer and the ratepayer have to pay more heavily still for the maintenance of the roads? Córas Iompair Éireann carries a good deal of heavy traffic by rail. The permanent way is maintained by the company. If that heavy traffic is diverted to the roads, no local authority will be in a position to cope with the maintenance of the roads and keep them in a condition in which they will stand up to the traffic passing over them. Despite the fact that the subsidy is a heavy one, in the long run it may prove to be a lighter burden on the people, because I believe that it would be cheaper to subsidise Córas Iompair Éireann rather than try to maintain the roads in a fit condition to carry all the heavy traffic that would be diverted to them. That is a matter that the Minister and the Government should seriously consider.
Comment on this
We all know that the roads were never meant to carry the traffic they are being asked to carry now and we all know that the people who are using the roads for a certain amount of their traffic are putting the less economic portion of their traffic on the railway. That is a well-known fact. The big, bulky commodity is sent by rail and they deliver the handy stuff themselves. I maintain that this question of whether or not subsidies should be continued to Córas Iompair Éireann is a very serious matter. I believe it will cost the country a much larger sum if it is not done. These people using 12-ton and 20-ton lorries should be made pay for the permanent way as well as those who use the railways. During the emergency the only means we had of carrying anything was the railway. No matter how bad the fuel was, Córas Iompair Éireann managed to carry on. When you had not a car or lorry—except a very small number—the railways carried the heavy traffic. If some people had their way, the subsidies would be cut off Córas Iompair Éireann and Córas Iompair Éireann would be closed down, throwing 20,000 men out of employment; but an emergency might arise again and the time might come when we would have no transport and would have to start over again at much greater expense.
I think the economies being carried out in Córas Iompair Éireann are not being effected in the best way. My experience of the Cork position is that Córas Iompair Éireann is furthering the centralisation of industry. From the 1st January to the 23rd May, 23 double-deck buses were sent from Cork to Dublin for repairs. We are told the reason is that the plant is in Dublin— but there is one thing, the money is collected in Cork. Now we have the latest development, in one of the biggest lathes in the southern part of Ireland being brought from Rocksavage, in Cork, to Dublin to do the work. The next answer, when men are being put off in Rocksavage, will be that the plant is in Dublin. This lathe is a loss to more people than Córas Iompair Éireann in the south. I understand it was used for extra heavy work by Rushbrooke Docks, the Cork Harbour Commissioners and the Rocksavage Engineering Works when they got a job too heavy for their particular work. The transfer of a lathe like that from a centre like Cork is a great injustice. I hope it will be restored as speedily as possible and not be kept in Dublin to provide the excuse that the work could not be done in Cork because that particular lathe and plant is in Dublin. That is the excuse made for shifting these double-deck buses to Dublin for repairs. I would suggest to the Minister that when he is having this conference with Córas Iompair Éireann he should point out to them that in big centres like Cork, Limerick and other places they should seriously consider that those people are entitled to have some part of the money that is collected from them returned to them in wages.
I am quite satisfied that the Minister is going to resume his policy of encouraging industry. That policy was interrupted by the war and later by the change of Government. We had evidence of that when he attempted to start a chassis factory at Inchicore and had procured some of the most up-to-date machinery and tools in the world. When the change of Government took place, the incoming Government decided that as Córas Iompair Éireann would not be able to use all the chassis they could manufacture there, Córas Iompair Éireann should not run that factory. They did not even consider the point that the Sugar Company, the Electricity Supply Board and other semi-State bodies would require chassis also. The machinery that was bought for that factory was sold, I believe, because it was for a Fianna Fáil project, because the idea had not been thought of by these people themselves. That was the only chance we had of developing a heavy engineering industry. It was a sad loss to the country that the men working there had to go over to work in Park Royal in England, manufacturing what should be manufactured here. Every city representative of Labour is aware of that.
Comment on this
We are aware of the orders that had to be given in the last year and a half, when those people could have been working in that chassis factory, if the machinery and tools had not been sold at almost scrap prices.
Comment on this
That does not come under review now—only the 12 months. There is no motion to refer this Estimate back.
Comment on this
We had another instance when the Lockheed repair shop at Shannon was closed up. They did away with the transatlantic airways and another batch was driven out of the country.
Comment on this
We know who were spending beyond their means and the unfortunate people know they will have to pay for that. I suggest to Deputy Keane to pass on from the question of people spending beyond their means.
Comment on this
The people showed pretty well who spent beyond their means. Mayo and Waterford proved that the people were not satisfied with that. I think we will go back to Cork for a while. I would like to know from the Minister if there is any hope regarding this airfield at Cork. In 1947 I put down a question about the Cork airfield and was told the position was being examined. Nearly every reply given since then has been the same. Notwithstanding that Deputy Cosgrave, when he was Parliamentary Secretary, went down there and had a few flights himself, no progress has been made. The people in Cork maintain that they should have an airfield as well as Dublin and Shannon.
I would like to get the definite reasons why it is not being proceeded with and why other companies are not allowed to co-operate if Aer Lingus do not co-operate. Over 300 planes have landed there is perfect safety. I would ask the Minister to make some definite statement in regard to the matter. Let him tell us whether we will get it or not. I understand that the company which is there is quite prepared to develop that area and make proper runways if they are promised a scheduled service there.
I would also like to know if there is any truth in the statement that the Lee hydro-electric scheme will be held up through lack of finance. That statement was made to me in Cork, and I was not in a position to either deny or affirm it. I would like if the Minister would assure the people of Cork that that particular scheme will go ahead as planned.
I think also that the Minister should seriously consider the question of accommodation for transatlantic tankers at Haulbowline. I know that Haulbowline is the property of the Department of Defence, but I think it comes within the Minister's sphere to see that ships coming to Rushbrooke for repairs or ships calling to Cobh or Cork should be able to be refuelled at Cobh. Those ships were refuelled there before the war. For that purpose a hulk was used against the jetty, but, apparently, the jetty was unable to stand up to the strain. I think that the Minister should do everything he could, in co-operation with his colleagues, to see that we get a jetty there with a depth of 31 feet of water.
I should also like to draw the Minister's attention to the prices of commodities. I do not think that the Prices Body are all that the Minister set out. There was a particular case brought to my notice some months ago. I am a member of a board of a voluntary hospital which purchased a wireless set for £18. The same week a sanatorium committee, of which myself and Deputy Keane are members, purchased exactly the same wireless set for £18, less 33? per cent. discount, which reduced the price of the set to £12. When I saw the manager's orders, I telephoned the secretary of the voluntary hospital and requested her to get in touch with her supplier with a view to getting the 33? per cent. discount. We were told that these terms applied only to local authority hospitals and that the retailer would be struck off the trader's list if he allowed the discount. It was the same retailer in both cases.
I made some inquiries as to the initial discount which was given when the retailer was able to sell the wireless set at a cost of £12 to a local authority hospital. I was told that this discount was 25 per cent., which would bring the manufacturer's price for this article to £9. This meant that, before the ordinary person got that wireless set, there was 100 per cent. extra cost put on it. I am afraid that is happening in regard to a lot of commodities and that retailers are being compelled to charge fixed minimum prices.
I put down a question to the Minister some months ago after hearing about these fixed minimum prices. The Minister told me that nothing could be done until the Restrictive Trade Practices Bill was brought into being. My view is that if there is a Prices Advisory Body it should look into these matters. It should be aware of the kind of cases about which I am talking. While a lot of people blame the manufacturers, I think there are too heavy charges altogether in regard to the distribution of goods in this country. I do not think any article should cost 100 per cent. more than the cost of manufacturing, distributing and delivering it to the consumer.
We hear the manufacturers being attacked repeatedly by the Labour people but I think that the rates allowed in a great many instances in regard to distribution are too high. I do not agree with the principle of a fixed percentage in any trade. Twenty-five per cent. may be all right on a cheap article costing about £2. When an article costs £20 or £30 and when it entails the same amount of labour to sell it, I do not think that the same 25 per cent. should apply in that case. I will agree that where more capital is spent in purchasing the higher priced goods the percentage should be put on a sliding rate. With all due respect to the Prices Body, I think they have a lot to be responsible for.
As regards Fuel Importers, I would like to draw the Minister's attention to the American coal. American coal was brought into Cork in 1947. There were 10,000 tons of it put down in a place called Church Road, Blackrock, and a pretty big rental was paid for storage. I understand that about 4,000 tons of it were sold to the sugar company and that the remainder was transferred to Cork Park again. Transferring coal from one place to another costs a lot of money. I think the coal should have been got rid of during the past five years. It is not a good thing to be keeping this supply of American coal in Cork and paying a high rental. There is a big supply of coal there, besides the 6,000 tons I am talking about, and which was brought in in recent years at a pretty high price.
Instead of having that coal stored up at a very high rental paid to Messrs. Fords—£90 per acre is the rental—the Minister should consider cutting his losses now and selling the coal at the same price as the English coal. A small amount of the coal could be kept on reserve if that is necessary, but some method should be devised which would not entail very heavy expenditure for storage. I understand that the contractor in Cork carries out the work of this body on a percentage basis. I suppose the more that is spent, the better for the contractor. I think it is a terrible mistake. I do not know whether or not coal deteriorates, but it is a great mistake to hold coal for five years and pay rent for the storage of it. That must cost a great deal of money.
I want to thank the Minister for the encouragement he has given to industry. I do not think the gloomy picture painted by Deputy Collins last night is a true one. Recently, unemployment figures have not increased. Every Deputy gets these figures, and should know that the unemployment figures have been decreasing for the past couple of months.
In Cork, we have four new factories on the Kinsale Road. We believe that there is every prospect of a reduction in the unemployment figures in the near future. I would ask the Minister to continue protection of our industries, especially while there is any unemployment in the country. It is better that our people should be employed than that we should employ people in foreign countries to produce goods for us.
Comment on this
The Minister's speech yesterday was noteworthy. It appeared from the account which he gave of last year's activities in the Department of Industry and Commerce that the year that has just passed marked the end, for a time at any rate, of industrial expansion. That being so, it is important that a survey should be made of future prospects of further industrial development. That survey should be undertaken by the Industrial Development Authority on a comprehensive basis, taking into account the possibilities of establishing new industries or of expanding existing industries. Such a survey would be possible only through some Government agency. It is obvious that individuals or groups could not undertake it and would not have available to them the information that would enable them to assess the situation accurately.
It is foolish to imagine that there is unlimited scope for industrial expansion based on the home market. The experience of the past year and, in fact, of some years since the end of the war, shows clearly the difficulties in the way of certain industries. The home market is dependent on 3,000,000 people. Even if the 3,000,000 people were a great deal more wealthy than they are, their power to absorb the output of certain industries would be limited. The experience which has been gathered in recent years, especially in particular industries, points to the need for a careful assessment of the market situation and a realistic approach to the prospects for particular industries.
There is no great need to give examples. I do not want to elaborate at length the cases I have in mind. There is certainly evidence based on the experience in recent years that in particular directions we have developed to the maximum extent the possibilities of the home market and that future development depends on export trade.
I need only mention the situation which has developed and which has continued for some time in the boot and shoe industry. That industry has had the maximum possible protection for a number of years, and the results show that, unless an export trade is possible, there are too many boot and shoe factories in the country for the supply of the home market. It may be that, if these factories vary the type of goods produced, they will capture part of the market that is not already available to them, but the quality of Irish-manufactured shoes leaves nothing to be desired. They are of a very high quality. The experience of recent years shows that these industries must get and maintain a hold on the export market if they are to survive and to continue in full production and to avoid having to go into part-time production at different times.
The same is true to an extent in other directions. There has been quite a substantial development in the dressed meat trade. The possibilities and the usefulness of such a trade require little elaboration. Recent price fluctuations in the United States indicate that the possibilities of a permanent trade with the United States may not be as hopeful as seemed to be indicated some time ago.
I believe that a work which the Industrial Development Authority, in collaboration with the foreign trade section of the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of External Affairs, could usefully undertake would be to survey accurately, as far as it is possible, from published statistics and from contacts with markets abroad, the present position, and thus enable industrialists and manufacturers in this country to have a picture of conditions and a picture of the prospects of permanent markets for particular goods.
Any haphazard approach to industrial development, in the belief that if industries are started half the battle is won, is likely to cause great hardship and great dislocation. Industries should be based on the prospects of a sure market or on as certain a market as it is possible for the experts who are available to Government Departments to decide. The benefit of surveys and experience should be given to the persons who are prepared to establish new industries or to expand existing industries.
I do not think there is any need for alarm because there was no industrial expansion in the last year. Deputies are familiar with the speeches and the announcements that have caused this temporary setback. It is true that there is a world-wide trade recession and that that recession has had its reactions on this country. It is equally true that, since this time last year, ministerial speeches, Government pronouncements, all the gloomy prophecies, the pessimism and the lack of confidence have had serious reactions on trade and on business. It is not unreasonable to expect that this would be so. I notice that, in a recent speech, the Minister urged people to buy, and to buy now. Maybe he has given belated recognition to the effect which all the gloomy speeches have had on the national economy. However, it is unreasonable to expect people to buy now on the advice of one Minister considering that the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and the members of the Government as a whole have, since their election last year, repeatedly told the people that they were spending too much, that they were living beyond their means, that they would have to restrict their expenditure and that they would have to curtail their outlay and outgoings. These gloomy speeches have aggravated the situation and it has culminated in the serious trade slump which has been experienced in this country during the last six or eight months. The situation has become more serious in some industries and trades than in others.
The Government did not rest at gloomy speeches and announcements. It went further. The Budget which was introduced this year contained proposals for increasing the price of foodstuffs. This inevitably pointed to a reduction in the volume of money which would be available for nonessentials or for expenditure in other directions. If people are obliged to pay more for food and for essentials, they will have less to spend in other directions unless there is a substantial rise in incomes. Due to the withdrawal in some cases of the food subsidies and to the partial abolition of the bread subsidy, the cost-of-living index has risen by 15 points since this time last year. The latest figures available show that the cost of living has increased by five points. It is reasonable to assume that it will have shown a further increase when the May figures are published.
I inquired some time ago, by way of parliamentary question, what effect the withdrawal of the food subsidies would have on the cost of living. The reply given to me stated that the increase would amount to ten points. Adding this to the rise that had occurred up to last February, we find the cost-of-living index number has increased by 15 points during the last 12 months. I do not suggest that the food subsidies have any inherent virtue, nor do I believe that anybody favours subsidies per se, but the sudden withdrawal of these subsidies will cause reactions that it is impossible to assess fully. The worst thing for any economy is a drastic change in any direction. The modification of the food subsidies and the consequential rise in the cost of essential foodstuffs will inevitably mean widespread demands for wage increases. Nobody can seriously suggest that the increases which have taken place in the social welfare benefits will offset the cost of essential foodstuffs, except, of course, for the classes to which these benefits are applicable. These benefits will not offset the rise that has occurred in the cost of essential foods, taking the community as a whole.
As I said already, the partial withdrawal of the food subsidies will mean widespread demands for wage increases. Can anyone imagine what will be the effect of these widespread demands for wage increases on an economy that shows no expansion, on an industry that has been working either part-time or short-time, and on a business that has felt the effects of credit restriction? I do not want to be misunderstood on this matter. Anyone can say that bank advances are up, but does anyone suggest that the bank advances given three, four, five or ten years ago are adequate to finance business to-day? Is it not quite obvious that, if credit is restricted, if traders are obliged to reduce overdrafts, if the bank accommodation afforded to them is limited in time or in extent, the effect will extend far beyond the particular trade concerned? Traders in every type of business in the country have felt the impact of credit restriction. This restriction has been reflected in a reduction in demand, and this, in turn, has been reflected in the number of persons unemployed.
A few moments ago Deputy McGrath said that the employment position had improved somewhat in recent months. Of course, that is only a seasonable improvement. The fact is that there are already 6,000 or 8,000 more persons on the unemployment register than this time last year, and but for the seasonal improvement which takes place at this time of the year the figure would be substantially higher. Up to recent weeks there were 13,000 more persons unemployed than this time last year. Any reduction in the unemployment figures, even a temporary reduction, is to be welcomed. If the present credit restriction continues a number of businesses, a number of industries and a number of manufacturing concerns that were keeping workers on in the hope of improved conditions will be obliged to terminate their services permanently. It is quite illogical for one Minister to hope that there will be an increase in the purchasing of particular goods, if at the same time Government policy, Government direction and the whole tenor of Government speeches informs the people that they are spending too much and living too well.
I believe that that situation has been greatly worsened by the campaign initiated this time last year by the Minister for Finance and continued right up to the present week. It is significant that the only Minister who has suggested that people should buy now is the Minister for Industry and Commerce. It may be that the results which have affected industry, the unemployment, the short time and the part-time which have characterised so many industries in the past six or eight months, have not yet caused other Ministers to recognise the serious situation that has arisen.
Reference has been made to the fact that our trade deficit has improved in recent months. We always said it would improve. We recognised that the trade deficit, which assumed serious proportions towards the end of 1950 and continued throughout the greater part of 1951, would not be a permanent feature of our economy. That situation was, in the main, caused by the influence of the Korean war. When the Korean war broke out, great numbers of industrial concerns, of individuals and Governments sought to buy wherever and whenever they could, and prices increased as stocks were accumulated. These anticipatory measures to protect countries' economies in different parts of the world would have been sound, if a world war had occurred or if the conflict had extended, but the situation that arose was not foreseen.
The war did not extend and prices proceeded to fall. Goods could be purchased more cheaply in the past six or eight months than in the previous 12 or 18 months, and the result has been that the prudent anticipation of a number of individuals, of Governments, including the Government here, caused temporary dislocation, but that temporary dislocation was elevated into a national hue and cry. The Party opposite were out for scalps, and they proceeded to make a concentrated assault on their predecessors, never thinking for a moment it could have a boomerang effect. The results in recent months indicate clearly that responsibility to a great extent for the present situation in this country must be laid on the Government. They could not shield the country, and nobody expects them to shield the country, from outside influences, to save the country from the impact of a slump which has extensive ramifications, but if, added to that slump and the difficulties which it creates, we have in speeches by the Taoiseach and right through every ministerial announcement, crisis, gloom and pessimism, suggestions that we are near disaster, that our situation is critical, that we are living beyond our means, spending too much and spending recklessly, and exhortations to reduce expenditure and curtail consumption, the situation is greatly aggravated.
It is quite significant that these speeches are in line with the recommendations made in the Central Bank Report published towards the end of last year. That report suggested that the Governors of the Central Bank advocated a reduction or withdrawal of food subsidies in order to reduce consumption, and a reduction in consumption is very likely because of the substantial rise in the cost of bread, butter, tea and sugar. Deputies forget the outcry there was when butter increased in price by 2d. per lb. in April of last year. It increased somewhere about this time last year by a further 2d. per lb.
It is now 10d. per lb. more than it was after the second increase and 1/-more than it was in April, 1951. Bread has increased and tea and sugar have increased. If people's incomes remain as they were, if the income of families remains static, they will be obliged to spend more on essential foodstuffs, and it is obvious that they will then have less to spend in other directions. Either the approach to this matter will have to be reconsidered, or the Government appear to be at variance in the directions being given and the speeches being made.
I think it is significant that the proposed national loan has again been postponed. I understood from the speech made earlier this week by the Minister that the Government would shortly be floating that loan. When I inquired from the Minister for Finance to-day I was told that the by-elections and the fact that this was the holiday period meant that the Government were postponing it again until the autumn. I asked further, whether the Government had had discussions with the associated banks with a view to inviting subscriptions by the banks to that loan. I have no doubt, although the Minister did not answer that part of the question, that discussions have taken place, and I have equally no doubt that the indications given prompted the Government to postpone the loan until the prospect appears more hopeful.
I agree with Deputy Morrissey, who said yesterday that the public should subscribe to the loan. It is a national loan, required for essential national undertakings, but unless the Government gets a much better reception than ordinary traders, industry, business and every type of enterprise that has sought bank accommodation or assistance in the past 12 months, it is impossible for this loan, if it is of any size, to be adequately subscribed. There will have to be a loosening up in the approach to the need for credit facilities for industry and commerce generally. If the present situation continues, to a large extent development in this country in the immediate future will depend on the extent to which State investment can be undertaken in particular directions.
The fact that such investment is necessary is in itself clear evidence that serious economic conditions had been reached in the country. Anyone who is familiar with the experience after the first world war, and, in fact, any war, and the experience during the 1929-30 slump, recognises that it is at times of economic crisis like these two periods that Government investment must be undertaken to the maximum extent.
It is a strange transformation in the short space of the past 12 months that the industrial expansion, the expansion in trade, the increase in employment, the general economic development which took place, to a considerable extent, by private enterprise, has been retarded and reversed. I find it difficult to believe that our economic fortunes can have undergone such a transformation in the short space of 12 months, but the fact that industrial expansion has, temporarily, at any rate, been retarded is in itself a warning to the Government. Whether employment is to be maintained and our economy sustained in the immediate future will depend on the extent to which the Government can invest through State organisations such as the Electricity Supply Board, Bord na Móna or Irish Shipping and undertake drainage, land rehabilitation, etc. It is to some extent a confession of failure that State investment is necessary on that scale. Deputies are familiar with the scheme which the late President Roosevelt initiated in 1932 to overcome the slump in the United States. His proposals recognised the need in the then existing circumstances for large-scale State investment.
I believe that there is and will be a substantial area in which State investment can be undertaken in this country for electrical development, drainage and so on, but the fact that it is, in some cases, at any rate, necessary points to the inability of private enterprise either to get the funds or to give the goodwill. I do not think that private enterprise in this country is lacking in initiative or ability. I think that there are many people willing and anxious, if given the facilities, to put money into industrial development, but the statistics in recent months give a serious warning. They show defects which will take more than one Minister to correct, and which, unless we want serious repercussions, must be corrected by Government action. However this Government secured office, it is the Government and the people expect from it leadership, initiative, drive and enthusiasm. In the last 12 months they have got none of these things. They have got pessimism, gloom, confusion and to some extent politics. If the situation is such as has been portrayed by Deputies on this and other Estimates, then it is essential that there should be a radical change in Government policy.
I was surprised that the Minister did not dwell at length on the situation from the point of view of employment. I am surprised also that he did not dwell on the general lack of confidence and the air of uncertainty which pervade trade and industry generally. It may be that he himself is overwhelmed by the gloom foretold by so many of his colleagues during the last 12 months. Action is required to remedy the dislocation which has been caused and the serious problem which exists in a number of industries to maintain employment. It is significant that in recent months emigration has increased and has shown no sign of abating although one of the present Government's foremost planks was the reduction of emigration. I do not think that the policy which has been operated has helped in any way to improve the situation and provide increased employment. The fact that in recent years it was possible each year to put an additional 1,000 persons into employment in industry, building houses, draining land or on the other development schemes discussed here shows what could be done and what should be done if the country had the leadership, initiative and guidance it requires.
The Minister said that he was considering the possibility of abandoning price control. Deputy Morrissey said that in any case in which the control had been removed there was an increase of price and I think that, in the main, that is so. I remember that the present Minister always said that when the price was about to go up we removed the control and when the price was about to fall we maintained the control. If that was true then it has continued since the Minister assumed office last year. When an article was decontrolled there was an increase in price. I do not think that there is a single commodity which did not show a rise. That is true with very few exceptions. While it may be true that in particular trades control is not effective at present, there are few indications that decontrol will mean a reduction in price. If that is so there does not appear to me to be any great case for withdrawing the control. If goods were sold at less than the controlled price the public got the benefit. If, on the other hand, the control is removed and there is an increase the public have no remedy. In present circumstances there is no great advantage from the point of view of the public in decontrolling prices.
Some six months ago I inquired here into the proposed increase in motor insurance premiums. As a result of that inquiry or coinciding with it, the Prices Advisory Body initiated an investigation. That investigation has now taken six months. When it was at a certain stage some figures were found to be unavailable. When they were subsequently received, they required further investigation. I think it is unreasonable, where all the facts, if not available, should have been available, that that body should take six months before making a recommendation. The public are entitled to more consideration, not so much from the Prices Advisory Body or the Department, but from the insurance companies concerned, who should provide these figures so that an inquiry of that nature could be conducted with the maximum speed. The results of that inquiry and whatever recommendation is made should be announced in the near future, so that people may be in a position to know what their commitments will be.
The Minister said that far-reaching and important decisions must be made in the near future regarding Córas Iompair Éireann. It is difficult to say much about Córas Iompair Eireann, because the matter has been discussed at length on a number of occasions in recent years. One aspect of the problem, however, which was referred to yesterday by Deputy Morrissey, I think, requires consideration. It is impossible to expect a national transport undertaking to continue to be run on an economic basis if, at the same time, competition by private hauliers continues to the extent to which it has developed since supplies of petrol became available at the end of the war. I do not think that anyone could contemplate a change which would revert to the previous conditions where competition existed between these private hauliers and the public transport concern. But it certainly appears to me at the moment that Córas Iompair Éireann is having the worst of both worlds and, possibly, the public as well. We should either make a drastic alteration such as has been done in Britain and revert to private hauliers on a large scale, and even consider the possibility of Córas Iompair Éireann entering into that or, on the other hand, see that the national transport concern is enabled to get a volume of the carriage of goods commensurate with its importance to the community.
It is certainly impossible for Córas Iompair Éireann to continue to employ the numbers employed in that concern if it is not provided either with an increased State subsidy or enabled to get a greater share of the transport of goods in the country. There is only a limited pool of goods to be carried and unless that pool is divided up between the various carriers in the country in a way in which these carriers can get sufficient to pay their way, then it is impossible for Córas Iompair Éireann or, in particular cases, for private hauliers to survive. The fact that Córas Iompair Éireann has been compelled to bear substantial increases of different kinds has in itself added immensely to its burden. Whatever decision is arrived at, it is time to take a definite decision one way or the other and arrive at a permanent policy, if it is possible to arrive at a permanent policy in the near future.
Deputy McGrath referred to the fact that if the transport of goods now carried by Córas Iompair Éireann was transferred to the roads it would mean a greatly increased burden on county councils. That is so and it will be a difficult problem for the county councils if any alteration is made in that direction. But whatever decision is taken, it should be a final decision and a decision which will enable the problem of transport to be taken out of the arena of politics and left to those concerned to deal with according to whatever situation may develop.
The Minister also referred to the fact that it was hoped to introduce legislation within the next few months to deal with the acquisition of the Great Northern Railway. I appreciate that that is a complicated matter but a number of people are, to say the least of it, inconvenienced by the delay in enacting that legislation and any efforts which are possible to expedite the introduction of that legislation should be made.
The Minister also dealt with the establishment of Córas Tráchtála. I welcome that decision. I think it is right to say that the board chosen for the purpose is a board in which anyone in the country could have the maximum amount of confidence. The persons concerned had in different ways unique experience of the problems to be dealt with and I hope that the results of that decision will enable the country to earn dollars, which are now needed more than ever.
It is, I think, significant that although our need for earning dollars is now greater than ever, there has been less attention paid to it in recent months, certainly in public pronouncements, than was the case some time previously. The decision to establish Córas Tráchtála was based on the report of a commission which was established almost two years ago and which made a very exhaustive examination of the situation and reported in record time. I understand from the Minister's pronouncement yesterday that he expects to have a full report in the near future on some investigations. I hope that that report, if it is possible, will be published so that business men and traders generally may understand the need for an export market and be given an indication of the problems to be dealt with.
There are one or two other matters to which I wish to refer. The recent alteration in the price of sugar has affected some exporting concerns. When sugar was rationed and when there were shortages, it was probably reasonable to limit the exports under licence, but in present conditions and when so many industries are encountering difficulties, we should push our exports to the maximum extent in any direction. While I appreciate that there may be peculiar difficulties in regard to the export trade between this country and Britain, I think that any industries manufacturing commodities from sugar, such as sweetened fat, syrups, or commodities involving a sugar extract, should be facilitated to the maximum extent.
I know that this matter has been under consideration between ourselves and the Board of Trade in England for some time. There is, however, one concern of which I have knowledge which has stocks available. I understand that our quota up to September, at any rate, is substantially greater than would be covered by the licences which have been given up to the present. I think that two things should be done in that regard: (1) A definite effort should be made to ascertain what are the future prospects and what imports the Board of Trade will allow; and (2) that until the quota already granted is absorbed licences should be freely given. If further restrictions are imposed after September, then the sooner these restrictions are notified to the exporters concerned the better, but if our quota is not being fully absorbed, then I would suggest that consideration should be given to the problems of some of these concerns that have accumulated stocks or are manufacturing on the basis that the full quota would be made available.
Comment on this
The most important problem with which every Deputy, and particularly members of the Government, are concerned is the present trade recession and the consequent increase in unemployment. Although the Government have in the past year pressed forward and introduced a good deal of legislation, which their predecessors had been produce mising for some time but did not implement, in the final analysis the future success or failure of the present Government will depend on how they deal with the present trade recession and unemployment. Apart from food prices, prices in general have, in the last year or so, shown a tendency to come down. It is very strange that in textiles, and in the clothing, leather and footwear industries, there is increased unemployment and there is on the part of the public resistance to buying. It is curious to observe that so long as the public feel that prices may continue to fall, they will resist buying in the hope that they will be able to make their purchases at lower prices later on, but when prices are rising, no matter how high prices rise, whether people are in a position to make purchases or not, they seem to desire to buy so that they can avoid having to purchase some things at a higher price later.
I welcome the recent public speech by the Tánaiste in which he encouraged members of the drapery trade to buy stocks again. I think it is most important that the Government should show confidence in the country's capacity to recover from this recession so that the public themselves may have confidence in the ability of industry to regain its former position and have confidence in the country, too. While people who are unemployed or those who are on short time have not the money to buy, nevertheless the vast majority of the people in this country are in a position to buy these goods but they feel that prices may fall still further and they have resisted buying. We must make up our minds that until the public realise that prices have become stabilised and until they commence buying again, unemployment will possibly continue in these lines.
While the prices of certain commodities have been reduced, food prices have undoubtedly risen sharply in the past year. They have risen possibly more in the past year than in many of the preceding years. Government policy in regard to food prices has been extremely unpopular. The Fianna Fáil Party before the election had promised the maintenance of subsidies but in the recent Budget a withdrawal of a large portion of the subsidies was effected. Whether such action was justified or not in the situation remains to be seen. The financial position of the country at the end of the year will show whether the tax burden imposed by the present Government was necessary or not. I feel sure, however, that it will show that the Opposition allegations that there was a surplus of £10,000,000 before the recent Budget was introduced, were completely unjustified.
Apart from the question of subsidies, there is the other matter of price control. Again, so far as the Government are concerned, their attitude towards price control in recent months has indicated a change of opinion. While there may be some justification for the removal of price control in regard to certain lines where prices are falling and where commodities are actually being sold below the controlled price, it is difficult to see any reason for the removal of price control on food and other commodities where supplies are still inadequate to meet current demands.
There are many other factors which come under this Estimate which are of great importance. I personally would like to have heard a lot more from the Tánaiste on the question of the reopening of a transatlantic air service. It is obvious from his public speeches that he is extremely keen that this service should be reopened, but, personally, I fail to see how such a service would ever become a commercial success.
Comment on this
Aer Lingus is now making a profit and, for its size, it is certainly one of the most successful air lines in the world, but surely the success of a transatlantic air line as a commercial enterprise must depend on our going into competition with the large American lines. Those lines, at least those of them which are privately owned, have managed to make a profit by providing great frequency of service and by cutting fares. It seems to me that if we are going to start a transatlantic air service with a small number of planes and with much less frequency in flights than those companies provide, we are going to lose heavily on the undertaking and that the extension of Aer Lingus to cover transatlantic lines will mean that our whole airways undertakings will be run at a loss. These are my personal views. The Minister may have information at his disposal to show that the reopening of the transatlantic air lines is a commercial proposition, but there are many of us here in this House who would like to hear his views on the subject and who would like to see this matter being discussed before any action is taken.
References have been made to Córas Iompair Éireann and to the necessity of doing something in regard to the financial position of that undertaking. I might remind the Minister that early in the year I pointed out to him that a large number of hotels which were owned by Córas Iompair Éireann— some of the finest hotels in the country —were run at a loss. When the Minister is examining the position in regard to Córas Iompair Éireann, surely it should be asked why, when private enterprise is in a position to make a good deal of money out of hotels throughout the country, Córas Iompair Éireann hotels are run at a loss?
Comment on this
I have not got the figures with me but I got the figures early in the last year. Half a million pounds' worth of hotels are owned by Córas Iompair Éireann.
Comment on this
In the current year I do not think there is any profit on the hotels at all.
The Minister, and other members of the House, have mentioned the question of haulage. I think that, as far as Córas Iompair Éireann is concerned, something will have to be done. Steps, one way or the other, will have to be taken, because it is becoming a very heavy burden on the taxpayer. It is also interesting to see that an extension of our shipping lines is proposed and that they are making a profit.
I think that, as far as this Estimate is concerned, the important problem that is facing us, and the most important problem for the Government, is how long it will take to recover from the present recession in trade. It is consoling at least to see that unemployment has not been increasing over the past few months. It is to be hoped that the bottom of the present recession has now been reached, and that the Government will press forward with confidence to encourage the establishment of industries: that they will encourage the people to have confidence in industry and in the country so that we may recover as far as possible from this set back.
I noticed from Deputy Cosgrave's remarks that he spoke of the confusion, gloom and uncertainty which, he said, had been created entirely by the Government side of the House. I think that is far from correct. When this Government came into power, it had to face the problems which had been left to it by its predecessors. It had to face the problem that the people had been told that everything was perfectly happy, that there was the possibility of tax reduction, that there was no necessity for increased taxes and that everything could be done by the rather mysterious method of public investment and the repatriation of our external assets. It had to face the task of getting the people of this country to understand that current expenditure has to be met out of current taxation.
Comment on this
There are many examples which could be given. There was endless juggling with figures which put us in the position that people were expecting medical services, social welfare schemes and a vast increase in State investment, and were calmly led to believe that there was the possibility of decreasing taxation.
Comment on this
Your Government made the promise of the mother and child scheme and ran away from it.
Comment on this
You were four years promising social security. You went into office promising it and you came out of office promising it, but you never had the courage to face up to your tax liabilities.
Comment on this
I think that a great deal of the confusion was created by Deputies making statements such as that they could restore the food subsidies and take £10,000,000 taxation off the Budget. That was the sort of nonsense that we were hearing from the Opposition. Surely that created far more confusion and uncertainty than any of the speeches——
Comment on this
Another matter which created a good deal of uncertainty and confusion was the tactics of the Opposition over the last couple of months by constantly telling the people that there was going to be a change of Government, by constantly telling the people that if they got the opportunity they would sweep into power. What created uncertainty in industry except those statements? As far as uncertainty and confusion are concerned, the Opposition have contributed far more than their share to it. I hope, now that the financial position has been made clear and that the people understand that current expenditure must be met out of taxation, that we are going to settle down, and that the country can have confidence in settling down to deal with the present trade recession. There is no reasonable Deputy who would suggest that this trade recession is due entirely to Government speakers. Not one. The difficulties have undoubtedly been aggravated by the controversy which has gone on. Any damage that has been caused or any aggravation that there has been of that trade recession, is due to the efforts of the Opposition. Their efforts to confuse the people have been far more responsible than the efforts of the Government to get the people of the country to face up to taxation.
Comment on this
The Opposition did. You had a chance of defeating the Government on the food subsidies and you ran away from it.
Comment on this
You resurrected the food subsidies for the purpose of making them an issue to win the by-elections. I shall conclude by saying that I hope, now that the financial position has been cleared up, we can all get down to work, restore full employment and expand industrial and agricultural production in the country.
Comment on this
We have heard many major points enunciated by previous speakers on this Estimate on the question of national economy and international economy. I propose to bring to the Minister's notice some items which concern local economy. I realise, of course, that the responsibility for starting industries rests more or less with the people of a locality. I want to refer to Fermoy in particular. The people there will not take the initiative themselves, that is those who are in a position to finance an industrial undertaking. The Electricity Supply Board, as the Minister is aware, has taken steps to educate the people in the rural areas to the value of rural electrification. I was wondering if the Minister would think it well to have some sort of an advisory body to canvass local people on the desirability of starting industries locally. The local T.D.s could point out to the members of that committee some people who should be canvassed in that regard. It could be pointed out to those people what great advantages would accrue to the country if they would put some of their frozen wealth in a local industrial undertaking instead of having it in the banks at 1½ per cent. or in foreign investments which may be giving them a yield of 2½ or 3 per cent. That is a suggestion that might apply in places other than Fermoy.
I want to refer now to some of the matters that I think call for attention so far as my constituency is concerned. I want to refer first to the Electricity Supply Board charges. It seemed to me ridiculous last year that the board should increase their charges on a rationed commodity. All of us who are consumers of electricity received notice that, unless we conserved the ration, the supply would be cut off. But, at the same time, the board increased the charges. I have an idea that the Minister himself resented that at the time. I may be wrong about that and, if so, I am subject to correction. I think the time has arrived when a halt should be put to the policy of the Electricity Supply Board in increasing their charges. It is very serious for people who are paying on a valuation basis. If a person's house or shop is revalued, the Electricity Supply Board charges go up automatically.
Then they come along and charge on the consumption of current. I do not want to criticise the Electricity Supply Board as far as their work is concerned. They supplied current to this country under very trying circumstances and at a time when it was very difficult to get the fuel, and so forth, necessary for the provision of the electricity. However, a small restraining influence in the proper quarter might have a good effect.
To judge by the speeches which we have heard during the course of this debate it would seem as if we are entering into an era of affluence. Perhaps, when we arrive at that happy state, we may be in a position to give the Electricity Supply Board the full pound of flesh which they have been looking for all the time since their board was established.
Deputy McGrath mentioned the railways and I must say that his remarks were very apposite. At meetings of local bodies and on the Estimate for the Department of Local Government I have advocated that we should take the 20-ton, 15-ton and ten-ton lorry off the road. I am agreeable to the five-ton lorry but I consider that anything over that weight should go on the permanent way. Irish industrialists ask us to support Irish industry and local industry. However, the owners of that local industry do not think it worth their while to support one of the biggest industries in this country —the railways. I think that no indusstry here is carrying as great a complement of men at the moment as the railways. The industries avail of the very large lorry and diesel oil and it is possible that their employees are not paid commensurate with the amount of work involved in running cargoes to Dublin.
I have known some of them to spare up to £70 a cargo compared with railway prices, and I consider that that is very unfair. If the matter comes within the scope of his Department, I suggest that the Minister should insist that anything over five tons should be carried on the permanent way in this country. If he does that, then he will do a good day's work for the railways in this country and, incidentally, a very good day's work for the taxpayers of this country. It is scandalous to see lorries passing through my town carrying up to 30 tons in all, between lorry and trailer. The ratepayers of the Republic of Ireland are like lambs, because it is obvious that there is no chance whatever of maintaining the roads while the weight of those large lorries is continually passing over them. The present form of economy with regard to these lorries is wrong. The loss is on both sides; the ratepayer is paying on the one hand and the taxpayer is paying on the other hand. The whole matter could be adjusted by the passage of one small Act to the effect that any lorry with a carrying capacity of over five tons will not be allowed to travel the roads. That would confine the weight of the lorries to five tons and under.
I believe that the Minister made a very serious mistake last January or February when he removed the controls on milk. That has been proved very vividly within the past few months. In a certain area in my county there was an invitation to tender for milk for the period 1st April to 30th September. No tender lower than 3/4 per gallon could be got. A sum of 3/4 per gallon equals 5d. per pint for milk. Some of us realised the reactions that would set in as a result of the Minister's Order. I may say, en passant, that some people whom I might have expected to try to benefit under that Order did not increase the prices except in exact comparison with the prices obtaining before the control was taken off. I might mention, however, that those people were in the minority. I appeal to the Minister to give the matter serious consideration and to make exhaustive inquiries as to the price of milk. If necessary, I will supply him with the name of the institution in question. As a matter of fact, I think it appeared in the public Press. I appeal to the Minister to reimpose the controls on milk.
Deputy McGrath also mentioned arrangements between combines and individual traders, retailers and wholesalers in regard to the control of prices. I think Cement Ltd. could be singled out as far as that matter is concerned. They set themselves up as a court of justice when there is a breach of their regulations. One of their rules is that two-ton lots of cement will be sold at a certain price and that there must be an extra charge for any amount less than that. The manager of a firm not far from my town supplied 2 cwts. of cement to an individual at the same rate as would apply for two tons of cement. Cement Ltd. fined him £30 and told him to pay that amount to a charitable institution. They warned him that if he did not do so they would withdraw their supplies from him and relegate him to the rank of a retailer. I will give the Minister the name of the concern in question, if he wishes it.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but it is a fundamental matter and it is a thing that could spread. Look at the Minister twirling his spectacles in his hands. Nobody realises more than he how important this matter is. Other manufacturing businesses could impose the same regulations.
I do not know whether Deputy Corish realises that a merchant some place around Wexford or Enniscorthy got £100 fine and was told to pay it into a charitable institution by the very same people.
Comment on this
There is a Bill before the House, Deputy, to deal with the matter to which you are referring.
Comment on this
Very good, Sir. I know Deputy Corish is going to take umbrage in regard to what I am about to say on agricultural machinery——
Comment on this
Machinery manufactured in this country can be sold cheaper across the water than it can be sold here.
Comment on this
A plough of a certain standard can be sold across to our friend, Seán Buí, at from £4 to £7 less than it is sold to the citizens of the Republic of Ireland. There may be some reciprocal agreement. I am not going to blame the manufacturers without, first of all, knowing all the points of the case, but I just want to mention the matter to the Minister. The manufacturers may be getting some alloy from the people over there and they may insist on their selling the plough there at a certain price. I am afraid that some of the manufacturers are not complying with the wish that we all have that they would make the best stuff that they can for the needs of the citizens of this country. Some of the agricultural implements being sent out are not of a satisfactory standard, and the day after delivery we have complaints about them. I will not go any further than that. I am sure a little salutary warning from the Minister would probably bring resolution after resolution from county committees of agriculture about it. It is a fact that the article is not up to the standard or anything near the standard.
I was delighted to hear Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll, the previous speaker, speaking about the satisfaction it gave him that the Minister had removed controls from certain commodities. He also spoke about the various other ailments that he has discovered within the past month that we are suffering from in this country. I can quite understand some people trying to save their face at a certain time in a fight, but I know I would prefer a fellow to throw his hands up and say he had enough if he was getting the worst of that fight than to try to save his face at this particular moment.
Comment on this
I am speaking, Sir, about the statement made by Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll some moments ago, that he was not too pleased with the way the Minister was handling things at the present time.
Comment on this
In the early stages of your contribution. You were very worried about the way things were going. You continued in that strain and then you made a volte face and went back to save your own face.
Comment on this
I can quite understand some of us with the ordinary limited outlook acting in this way, but when you have psychologists and psychiatrists——
Comment on this
The Deputy seems to misunderstand me. What he is saying has no relevance to the Estimate.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not reflect on the Chair. On any occasion on which Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll departed from the subject, he was so informed by the Chair.
Comment on this
There is no harm in drawing your attention to the fact that he has been throwing mud at the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I would like if the Minister would look into these few points about the control of prices, particularly with regard to Fermoy. I appreciate the Minister's position. I have tried it and I have told the people the truth on several occasions. I am not trying to exploit them. Unless they spend the money, and put it up themselves, the Department can do nothing. However, I am still of the opinion that if someone was sent down with departmental status, he might be able to convince those people it would be a good investment to spend their money on home industry.
This is the first time that I have met the Minister on this side of the House. I hope that he will carry on with the same outlook as he had prior to his departure from that side to this side. I have no hesitation in saying that he has done as much as any white man could do for Irish industry and I hope he will continue on those lines in the future, that is, while he is Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
On a point of order I have a motion down to refer back Vote 52. Could I have any indication from the Chair as to when I may be able to make my case in that respect?
Comment on this
The Chair will bear that in mind and the Deputy will be called as early as possible.
Comment on this
I take it the discussion on the main Vote will be allowed to continue before there is any cutting across.
Comment on this
I want the Minister when he is replying to tell us what the situation in this country is because of the conflicting statements which have come from himself principally inside the last six or eight months. At one time we are told that we are on the verge of bankruptcy, that we are doomed; we are eating too much, drinking too much, dressing too highly, spending too much on frivolous things and so forth. The next moment it seems we are getting along nicely and there is no need for all this caution. Where does the truth lie?
Comment on this
If the Deputy will allow me to intervene, there was no contradiction. We said the country was spending too much on imported goods.
Comment on this
What imported goods can we do without? I would ask the Minister to enlighten me on that.
Comment on this
The man in the street is completely bewildered because of the contradictory statements that have been made, and the result all over the country is that the industrialist, the manufacturer, the business man, the farmer and the workman are all tightening up and refusing to spend anything. Their object is to remain in a state of suspended animation because they do not know whether to go ahead or whether, if they do go ahead, they will not find themselves plunging deeper into the abyss and ruining themselves. A positive lead from the Government was never more essential than it is to-day. The Minister, because of the office he occupies, can do a great deal to put things back on an even keel.
Last year blood-curdling pronouncements were made which had the effect of paralysing trade and industry in the country. I notice that, in the speeches made by the Minister recently, he is beginning to realise now the enormous damage that was done and is endeavouring to set things right. I appeal to him to take his courage in his hands and to make a clear statement of fact. If we are slipping downhill, let the Minister tell us so. If we are not slipping downhill, the Minister should equally tell us so. It is very essential that he should.
I would like to compliment Deputy Keane on his courage in referring to a certain section of Irish industry. It was my experience when I was in charge of the Forestry Branch of the Department of Lands that certain Irish-made articles did not come up to standard.
Comment on this
I am well aware that many items that are turned out by Irish industry are second to none. What I am afraid of is that other industries are turning out inferior workmanship and sheltering behind the protection that is afforded to industry.
Comment on this
I had the experience of seeing an article made by an Irish firm being used by workmen and no less than three of those tools broke in one day. I am not condemning anybody. We are all anxious to support Irish industry. Bad workmanship and turning out inferior articles are bound to have a damaging effect.
If a person who is accustomed to buying an imported article buys Irish manufacture and finds that the Irish made article does not come up to the standard required, that experience creates a bad impression. We know that cement, aluminium, asbestos and steel goods manufactured here are second to none. The products are first-class. I have been told that Irish cement is the best in Europe. Asbestos holds a very high place all over the world because of its quality. I am referring in the main to hand tools of which I have had actual experience.
I am not familiar with the inner workings of the Department of Industry and Commerce. I do not know what powers the Minister has but he should interest himself in this matter and ask the manufacturers to turn out articles equal in quality to the imported articles. I am sure we would all be willing to pay a little more for the Irish article provided we get good quality. If he wants more information on this he can get it from his colleague, the Minister for Lands. I do not want to identify any particular article. I am merely putting the Minister wise. Some of the hand tools produced could do with a better finish. Samson or Finn McCool would jib at the clumsiness of some of them.
Would it be possible to divert more ships to the western ports? Such a diversion of traffic would help to revive these areas and possibly bring about a reduction in price because of lower transport costs. I am referring now to such ports as Ballina, Westport and Galway which lost nearly all their trade about the time of the First World War. A restoration of that trade would be of immense benefit.
Many people are perturbed about the price of butter. Statements have been made that butter will be much dearer than 3/10 per lb. Will the Minister tell us when he is replying how high he anticipates the price will go?
I think the removal of the food subsidies was both rash and foolish. The impact of that removal will fall heaviest on the poorest sections of the community. The results will be disastrous. I am sure the Minister was told during the recent election campaign about the flight that is taking place from the western areas. In some areas where there were 360 registered voters there were only 30 to 35 people there to cast their votes on polling day.
Comment on this
I was told that on good authority and I am merely passing on the information to the Minister in order to indicate to him how serious the flight is.
Comment on this
We know that is happening. I am sure the Minister was told both in Ballina and in Belmullet that it is quite common now to see four, five or six buses in Belmullet at 6 o'clock on Monday morning to take the young people away, some of them being as young as 14 years.
Comment on this
Of course they are migrants. The flight of migrants this year has been greater than ever in living history. The Minister should get his officials, in conjunction with those in the Department of Social Welfare, to examine the question and try to find a solution. I am not bringing in politics now regarding North Mayo; if there never was a by-election in North Mayo or South Mayo or Galway, the flight is appalling. The Minister cannot sit there complacently and say that these are migratory workers who will be back around Christmas. A vast number of them will stay away in another country. The removal of the food subsidies and other bad management and rash management are contributing their quotas to the number of people staying permanently abroad.
I am not making the absurd claim that any Government, by waving a magic wand, can cure emigration overnight. A real determined effort would extend over a period of 20 years, in my candid opinion; but if we lay the foundations now, then, in 20 years' time, we will have done a worthwhile work. The sudden, irresponsible and rash way in which the food subsidies were dealt with in this year's Budget has done more to disgust people with staying in their own country than anything that has happened for years and years. With that may be coupled the gloomy speeches that the country is "facing bankruptcy". The small farmer's son coming to 16 or 18 must face the future and ask himself: "Will I stay here and be a slave like my dad or will I go to England or America?" Then he takes up the paper and reads that the Deputy Prime Minister of the Government says that the country is on the verge of bankruptcy, that we are eating, drinking and spending too much. The first thing that young fellow will do is make up his mind: "Wherever I fix myself for life. Ireland is not the place for me, if this is the kind of start to make and if this is what home government would mean to me; I must watch that I do not waste my own life." We cannot blame such a fellow for taking that from the gloomy speeches.
I issue a warning that the Minister, the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach should be most careful in the statements they make. Any person who holds these positions, no matter what Government is in power, should remember that the people read the papers and take these statements as indications of what is happening. The statements made this time last year—gloomy, despondent statements, with no foundation, whatever was the idea in making them—should never have been made. The Minister knows that and is trying to retract. Even at this hour, he should come out in the open boldly and, when replying to the debate, if we are on the slope, he should tell us so, but let us have the truth. That is all I want.
Comment on this
We will be eating carrion crows before Christmas. We will be back to the O'Connell Monument before Christmas.
Comment on this
Will the Minister enlighten us, in replying, as to the effect of the removal of the subsidy on turf? Furthermore, if we can develop our huge bogs and induce people to use more turf, we will be taking a step in the right direction. I would like to see closer association between Bord na Móna and the Forestry Section in replanting cutaway bogs according as they are denuded of turf. Could we know what the effect is on Bord na Móna turf and hand-won turf of the removal of the fuel subsidy?
Comment on this
The action we are taking in this revised Estimate under Subhead K—that will not have any effect on the price of turf?
Comment on this
There was a figure there for £3,000,000 last year. That represented the payment of the accumulated losses on fuel during the war years. It has wiped out all the losses. No subsidy is paid now in respect of any form of fuel.
Comment on this
I am glad to know that. What is Bord na Móna or the Department doing to try to re-establish sale for turf in the city? The Minister may shake his head and say there is no hope while foreign coal is available. Coal is more attractive because it is smaller and more powerful and because people are accustomed to it. Let me repeat what I said in 1945, 1946 and 1947—Dublin people never got a chance with turf during the war years. It left the bogs dry and came to Dublin dry, but the damage was done there. Because of its nature, it must be protected from the weather.
Any farmer using it all his life knows that instinctively. Let me give the Minister some advice on that. If the Dublin people get a chance to buy dry turf such as every farmer has for his own house, they would use it as willingly as coal or timber.
Comment on this
That is one way to do it, but the next best thing—if it would not be wise, or if it would be impossible, for the Government to stop imports of coal—is to give the people dry turf, which Deputy McQuillan knows burns so cheerfully in every country house. What we asked the Dublin people to do during the war years was to burn, not turf but water. It came to the city dry, but then mismanagement occurred.
I pointed out to the Minister during those years what to do to give the people dry turf. We were asking them then to pay about £4 15s. a ton for turf and the least we might have done was to give them dry turf. We must get down to brass tacks, and if the people are to be induced to use even some turf, let them get it dry. That may mean a storage dump, but it is worth it. It is a fuel which is peculiar to Ireland, or at least it has not been developed in other countries—except Sweden and a few others—to any great extent. It is a valuable industry worth working up. It is not good enough to ask people to buy stuff that will not burn, or to pay so much a ton for rain water.
I am glad to learn that 51 new projects were commenced during the year. I hope that these will all be successful and will grow in production and prosperity from year to year. How many of these would have been initiated or helped out by An Foras Tionscal? Would there have been any?
Comment on this
The Minister is fond of telling us that he has no control of An Foras Tionscal, that there is to be no political influence there. That is grand, and is as it should be; but the Minister should take some interest in some of the smaller towns where industry is at a standstill for years. Those towns might very easily start to decay. No industries have been started in some of the towns, particularly in the West. The board has no initiative, but the Minister, in his position as Minister for Industry and Commerce, can do a great deal in regard to giving an impetus to the move to start an industry of some kind in these towns and putting a little bit of life into them. I am not suggesting that he should go outside the powers conferred on Foras Tionscal under the Act. That would be a wrong thing to do. I do suggest that the Minister should use his position, as Minister, to try and stir up a certain amount of enthusiasm in these towns to make use of the powers and the moneys which Foras Tionscal have at their disposal. I think that would be well worth while.
There are a few towns in my constituency in which I would like to see industries started, towns like Louisburgh, Newport, Belmullet, Westport, Ballinrobe, Charlestown, Ballyvary, Swinford, Kilkelly and Claremorris, just to mention a few. Westport has two factories already but there are plenty of people available to work in any new industry that might be established there. In Galway there is a small number of towns with a good working population in which industries could be got going. The Minister could stir up enthusiasm in those places.
I am only talking of towns in North Mayo, my constituency, and in Galway, but my remarks apply to all towns from Donegal to Kerry. It is all very well to say that if the people decide to put their money into an industry Foras Tionscal will be there with extraordinary power to help them out if the industry can be got going. In some cases a little bit of a push and the sowing of the germ of enthusiasm will do a great deal of useful work.
Comment on this
Some industrialists might take at their face value the Minister's promises regarding the establishment of a crop of factories in Mayo. Anybody listening to the Minister's speech at Ballina could not help but come to the conclusion that the death of a Deputy was a very useful thing.
Comment on this
Having regard to the Minister's statement in regard to the establishment of factories, some industrial fanatics might take it into their heads to start shooting. If five or six factories could be established in half an hour on a Saturday afternoon the prosperity of all the towns in the constituency where the by-election would be would be assured for all time. I think a statement of that kind is a departure from decency in public life. There is an advertisement for one factory all right and I have every hope that factory will be erected. The Minister allowed his desire in regard to the result of the by-election to get the upper hand of him when he went so far as to promise a crop of factories.
Comment on this
I would not have mentioned the matter were it not for the fact that one of the candidates repeatedly stated that there was no truth in the report. Therefore, the truth had to be made known.
Comment on this
I would say that was a departure from decency in public life. It is certainly something to which neither the Taoiseach nor the Tánaiste should descend.
Comment on this
During the by-election in West Donegal, Deputy Blowick planted the entire constituency with trees.
Comment on this
I want to say that I am proud of the new forests that I established in Donegal and I am sorry that I had not an opportunity of doing more. If Deputy Derrig, Minister for Lands, does half as much as I did in this respect in three and a half years he will be doing well. I started with my hands empty but the Minister for Lands started with his hands full.
Comment on this
To mention only a portion of the work, I started two forests on the Hill estate of 13,000 acres and one which stretches to the border of Tyrone of 4,700 acres. When the present Minister for Lands does that he can come here and shout.
Comment on this
I want to refer to the manner in which the food subsidies were approached. Withdrawing the food subsidies all of a sudden will produce disastrous results. I believe what Deputy Morrissey said in that connection, that for the Government to gain £7,000,000 it would cost the community well over £20,000,000. I believe that. The full repercussions of this action have not manifested themselves by any means yet. The withdrawal of the food subsidies will have repercussions during the next 12 months. The Government will gain as a result of withdrawing the food subsidies but Deputy Morrissey did not exaggerate the position when he said that it would cost the taxpayer more than three times what was saved. I am sure that by now the Minister is convinced of that. The Minister will be unable to contradict this statement of mine or of Deputy Morrissey's when he is replying.
Comment on this
I think it was Deputy Dr. Ryan, Minister for Social Welfare, who said that figures could prove anything but I am interested in the practical or the butter and bread side of things. We know what it is possible to do by means of statistics.
As far as the taxes on drink are concerned, there is an actual falling off. The other day the Minister for Finance, in reply to a question asked by Deputy Donnellan, gave some figures in this connection which showed a shocking state of affairs.
Comment on this
Deputy Donnellan chose his month very carefully, the month before the Budget of last year and after the Budget this year.
Comment on this
Very well, he may have done so but we will see what will happen in the next quarter. We will have the same results. The Government will have to go back on their own policy which was rash and ill-conceived. To my mind, they took one mad plunge without thinking where they were going and without caring what kind of a mess they would land the country in. The Government fully realise that now. It is good to see a certain amount of retraction of some of the wild statements that were made. It is an attempt to return to sanity.
There was great criticism of the inter-Party Government in regard to the cost of living. As a matter of fact, the general election, 13 months ago, was fought on the cost of living as it had been under the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
2d. on butter and 2d. on the gallon of petrol. These were the only things the prices of which were increased during our term of office.
Comment on this
If the removal of the food subsidies had to be undertaken for the reasons expressed by Government speakers, I say that action should not have been taken without consulting the people. It will have absolutely ruinous results all over the country and will cause a flight from the land. It will completely upset the balance of the economy of every single householder. If the food subsidies had to go they should have been taken off gradually over a number of years in order to give the people a chance to adjust their family budgets.
Comment on this
I move to refer back Vote 52—Aviation and Meteorological Services. I do that very deliberately because, within a very short period of time, the general taxpayers have been called on to pay millions of pounds to provide aviation and meteorological services in Shannon and Dublin. Both sides of the House are supposed to be in favour of private enterprise but private enterprise had established an airfield in Cork and that airfield was opened by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the last Government. He made a very flowery speech when opening that airfield. We have had a lot of lip sympathy from the present Minister for Industry and Commerce. The present Minister has given more lip sympathy and has been more in the air than the Lord Mayor of Cork. The present Minister and the former Parliamentary Secretary, who was acting for the former Minister, were both in the air about it and nothing has been done. The position is that Aer Lingus is adopting a dog-in-the-manger attitude. Aer Lingus will not let anybody operate from Cork because they have the right to operate from Cork but they will not themselves operate from Cork. There has been a large number of requests from people who will provide all the services and facilities that we require if they are permitted to operate a service. Aer Lingus and Aer Rianta, in a dog-in-the-manger attitude, will not let anybody move one way or the other. They say: "We will not do it and we will not let anybody else do it." Is not that a nonsensical position for Aer Rianta and Aer Lingus?
The Minister is responsible for Aer Rianta and Aer Lingus. The Minister is responsible for giving over £3,000,000 for Dublin and Limerick airports. The Minister will not give the £10,000 or the £5,000 that is required for the weather services in Cork.
If the Minister disputes any of these points, I can answer him because I have a file here that will explain the views of the present Minister and of the former Parliamentary Secretary. We are spending each year on air services over £500,000 and the people of the country as a whole are paying for that. The actual sum in the Estimate is £540,370. The general community are paying for that. Obstacles are being put in the way of the Cork airfield although Cork is the second city in this Republic.
Comment on this
The second city as far as the Minister and his predecessor were concerned. I know that we have here the first citizen of the second city but, if he likes, I will call him the first citizen of the first city. Bulletins are issued by the Irish Tourist Association boasting that there are new services from Dublin to Edinburgh and from Dublin to Cardiff. These bulletins are issued to every Deputy. Yet they are preventing in every possible way that they can a service going from Cork to Cardiff, which is the shortest and most sensible service to run.
Everybody knows that the obvious air run from Cardiff to this country is via Cork. Cork is the second city in the State, in spite of what Lord Mayor McGrath may say. It is an outrageous business that a State-sponsored company, that is being subsidised to the extent of over £500,000 a year, which has already got over £3,000,000 for capital expenditure, should prevent private enterprise in Cork from doing something.
Cork does not want anything from the State or from Aer Lingus or Aer Rianta. All it wants is permission from them to do something that they will not do themselves. If they will do it, we will give them all the help and co-operation possible in Cork. If they will not do it, we want them to stop preventing us from doing it.
A number of requests have been made and if Aer Lingus and Aer Rianta will take their finger out of the pie and give us a little bit of the freedom which we are supposed to have in a Republic, we will be able to operate air services in Cork on our own without taxing the taxpayers as we are taxing them in respect of Aer Lingus and in respect of facilities they are giving in Dublin and Shannon at the moment.
I would appeal to the Minister to use all the influence possible with Aer Lingus and Aer Rianta to get them to operate services from Cork to Britain and Cork to Dublin or, if they are not prepared to operate such services, to say that we can operate them.
I know the difficulty that the Minister is in. Aer Lingus is only a small boy as far as British European Airways are concerned and British European Airways have tied the Minister up in knots. British European Airways will allow the Minister and Aer Lingus—in spite of its gorgeous Gaelic title—to operate only as British European Airways decide they should operate. Once upon a time Cambrian Airways were very interested in running a service from Cork to Cardiff. However, the Sassenach part of Aer Lingus—British European Airways—decided that these people were getting a small bit troublesome so, in spite of their international airways, they said: "We will let you run a service to Jersey, if you will keep your mouth shut about Cork." Cambrian Airways ran a service to Jersey and there was nothing said about Cork. In spite of the inducements that British European Airways were giving to Cambrian Airways, there were a number of firms prepared to do the job if Aer Lingus would not do it. There are a number of people anxious to provide any facility required by the Department of Industry and Commerce, and they are prepared to do it now. However, they are faced with the problem that the Department of Industry and Commerce is travelling for Aer Lingus and that Aer Lingus is travelling for British European Airways, the result being that they find themselves up against a stone wall. We hope that the Minister will realise the need for having an internal air service. I hope too that he will realise the necessity for direct services between Cork, which is the southern end of this country, and Wales, which is the southern end of our neighbouring country. It would be quite a simple matter for the Minister to tell his nominees on these bodies to stop adopting the dog-in-the-manager attitude. In Cork we want nothing from the Government, from the Department of Industry and Commerce, from Aer Lingus or from Aer Rianta but freedom to give permission to people to operate scheduled flights from Cork to Cardiff and from Cork to Dublin.
Comment on this
Whoever said hear, hear should listen carefully to this matter from the Irish Independent which I am about to read. It is headed “British Consent Needed for New Air Services.” British consent is necessary before we can operate air services between Cork and Cardiff.
Comment on this
British consent is needed to operate air services from any country into Britain. Irish consent is necessary to operate air services from any country into Ireland.
Comment on this
I will now read the quotation.
"The Annexe to the Anglo-Irish Agreement of April 5th, 1946, governing the operation of scheduled air services between the two countries would have to be modified before Aer Lingus or any other company could be permitted to operate such a service between Cork and Britain, Mr. Lemass told Mr. Lehane (Ind.) at Question Time in the Dáil."
Is that correct?
Comment on this
British consent would be necessary to operate air services from Germany, France or America into Britain. Cardiff is in Britain.
Comment on this
We have a beautifully organised air service with a lovely Irish name—Aer Lingus—which is dictated to by the British Government and by British European Airways. Is not that correct?
Comment on this
Air services to Great Britain require the consent of the British Government, no matter who operates them.
Comment on this
Is it not correct that a British company, such as Cambrian Airways, could not operate a service between Cardiff and Cork without the permission of British European Airways?
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to listen again to his own words:—
"The Annexe to the Anglo-Irish Agreement of April 5th, 1946, governing the operation of scheduled air services between the two countries would have to be modified before Aer Lingus or any other company could be permitted to operate such a service between Cork and Britain, Mr. Lemass told Mr. Lehane (Ind.) at Question Time in the Dáil."
Comment on this
I am appealing to the Minister to try to do something to help private enterprise. Private enterprise has taken over this site, has developed it and is trying to do something about providing an airport for Cork. However, every possible obstacle is being put in its way by the Department of Industry and Commerce, by Aer Lingus, by Aer Rianta and by British European Airways. The taxpayer of this country has already contributed over £3,000,000 to capital services in Dublin and in Limerick. A very small capital expenditure would provide the scheduled services that are required in Cork but, as I stated already, Aer Lingus, being tied up with and being part and parcel of British European Airways, are just as much against Irish development as Coastlines, Limited, were against Irish development as far as shipping was concerned.
I would ask the Minister to try to break down the barrier against development in this country. Looking at the map, one will see that internal airways exist in Great Britain but they will notice that we have no internal airways in this country except a shuttle service from Shannon to Dublin. What annoys me so much in this respect is the fact that we do not appear to be our own masters. If Aer Lingus want to establish an airport in Cork, let them do it, and we will give them all the help, all the co-operation and all the facilities we possibly can. However, if Aer Lingus will not undertake the job, we should be allowed to do it ourselves and Aer Lingus should not be putting obstacles in our way. I would not mind so much if Aer Lingus were the culprit. Aer Lingus is a sheep masquerading as a wolf, because Aer Lingus is, in fact, British European Airways, which is opposed to development in this country. When we are prepared to do something, we are being prevented by a company with a nice Irish name. If British European Airways were to appear in their ordinary clothes, we would know them and be able to see them. However, when they appear in the clothes of Aer Lingus and of Aer Rianta we do not know who they are. They are trying to do something which from a patriotic point of view appears to me to be outrageous. I urge the Minister to realise that Cork is the second city—in spite of what Deputy McGrath, the Lord Mayor, has said—in the Republic and it is an outrageous thing that British European Airways——
Comment on this
—— should prevent us from having an air service from the second city to the capital. That is the principal reason I put down this motion to refer back the Estimate. Aer Lingus, Aer Rianta and British European Airways have treated us in a most outrageous manner. The Minister told us recently that he had called for an inquiry and an inquiry, I understand, was held. Whoever held the inquiry, I do not know, but there are people who are associated with the proposed airfield in Cork and whoever was responsible for that inquiry did not contact anyone who had anything to do with that airport. Presumably, they came back with a report without contacting the people who could tell them the situation in Cork and the possibilities of development, and who could point out the 101 aspects of the position which anybody genuinely interested in the matter of an airport for Cork should have been interested in. If they came to Cork at all—I do not know whether they did or not—they did not contact anybody who had anything to do with Cork airfield and they apparently sent in a report.
I put down several questions to the Minister with regard to it. The Minister himself sat for a very long period on that report, and, after months of that, it had to be considered by the Government. After months of that, the Government's decision has not yet been made available. It looks as if the people who were sent down—whether they were the agents of British European Airways or not, I do not know— did not take the trouble of examining the position in Cork. I have not seen the report of that inquiry, but whether it is good, bad or indifferent, I am condemning it here and now, because they did not make the slightest effort to look for information with regard to conditions in Cork. I can quite appreciate the position of British European Airways in trying to bypass Cork. The same thing is done by the Cunard and the White Star lines and other British steamship lines who try to bypass Cobh as much as they possibly can, but our Aer Lingus, with its gorgeous Irish title, is doing its best to bypass Ireland as much as it can. I think the Minister should change the names of Aer Rianta and Aer Lingus to British Airways and let us know where we are. Why disguise it? Why give it an Irish title when it is absolutely anti-Irish and against the development of anything in Ireland?
That is what is happening. I have with me here the Minister's view on the development of Cork Airport and also Deputy Cosgrave's view, but I do not want to use anything against anybody. I want to make the point, however, that it is of vital importance and vitally necessary that we should have an air service from the second city to the first city and, so long as we are asking the enemies of air development for our country to give us a decision as to whether we should have that link, so long will we be told that we will not have it.
Our position in Cork is that if Aer Lingus will provide it, we will go out and welcome it, even though we know that Aer Lingus are tied to British European Airways. We will give them all the help we possibly can and we will even give them more than the millions they have already got; but if they are not prepared to do it, I appeal to them to take their finger out of the pie and say that they are not going to do it and cease to adopt this dog-in-the-manager attitude. We can develop and operate that airport without the slightest difficulty and without asking this House to expend one ½d. There are a number of companies which are prepared to expend all the money required and even all the money that will be imposed on them by this Aer Lingus-Aer Rianta company. They are prepared to fall in with any requirements which these opposition services might wish to impose. Is it a reasonable thing then to ask the Minister to see to it that the people of the country will not be called upon continually to vote millions of money for Dublin and Shannon Airports and to support air services for people outside the boundaries of this country which are of very little use to the people within the boundaries of this country?
We ask Aer Lingus either to do the job itself or let somebody else do it. Surely that is a reasonable request to make. If they do it, we will welcome them and give them all the support, all the co-operation and all the help we possibly can. If they will not do it, will they drop this dog-in-the-manger attitude and let us do it? Let them stop putting blocks in the way of very efficient private enterprise which is prepared to do something in this matter for Cork. I know that the Minister realises—because I have some letters from him here—that there is a definite opening for an air service from Cork to Cardiff.
The Minister also realises that unless helicopters come very quickly there is a very genuine reason why there could not be an air service between Cork and Dublin. I do not want to quote the Minister's letter or the Parliamentary Secretary's letters because I do not think it would be fair, but I hope that the Minister will try to get rid of this insular attitude adopted by him and his predecessor, by Aer Lingus and by Aer Rianta—whether it is something imposed on them by outside I do not know. I have a fairly big newspaper headline here saying that British consent is necessary for an air service. The Minister should realise the importance of the second city in the Republic. He should use his influence with Aer Lingus and whatever influence he may have with British European Airways—if he has any—and stop them from preventing the development of air services between this country and Britain. If the Minister wants any specific details on any of the points I have mentioned, if he is in the slightest degree interested, I can give them to him.
The Minister has complained of the great difficulty incurred in disposing of hides by butchers and dressed meat manufacturers. Is it not a fact that the price of these hides was controlled at from 8d. to 1/- here while the price of these hides across the Border was 4/6 per lb.? Does not everybody in the House know that lorry loads and lorry loads of hides were smuggled across the Border to be sold at 4/6 a lb. while the controlled price here was from 8d. to 1/-? The traffic in hides across the Border was a delightful affair for anybody who got into it. I know of one gentleman who had 14 lorry loads of hides going across the Border. He let one lorry go around and collect all the customs officials and while they were following that one lorry he ran the other 13 lorries across the Border. I have not any great sympathy with the "unfortunate" people who are able to get 4/6 a lb. What I object to is that tanners in this country were paying 8d., 10d., or 11d. per lb. for hides and were turning out leather in competition with people who were paying 4/6 a lb. and some of them even got licences to ship their leather away in competition again with the people who paid 4/6. Is the Minister quite satisfied that the tanners are playing fair with the people of the country? Do his Department study the balance sheets of the leather factories and are they satisfied that they are true balance sheets? Is he satisfied that Irish tanneries which paid 8d., 10d., 11d. or 12d. for hides cannot compete with a factory across the Border or in Britain which pays 4/6 per lb.? Has he looked into that? Leather is issued to the boot manufacturers made from hides for which the tanners paid a quarter the world price. The Minister may shake his head, but will he answer this question? Is it not a fact that for a number of years tanners were getting hides at a quarter the world price?
Comment on this
It never went to 4/6. Is it not better to export boots and leather than to export hides?
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that for a number of years tanners in this country were buying hides at less than a quarter the world price?
Comment on this
All right. Is it a fact that when hides were 8d., 10d., or 11d. in this country there was wholesale smuggling across the Border where the price was 4/6?
Comment on this
I do not think so. The Deputy is leaving out of account the fact that about half the hides used here were imported and imported at world prices.
Comment on this
Everybody knows there is a racket in hides. The price was controlled at 8d. to 11d. while the world price was 4/- to 4/6 and there was a racket across the Border. Anybody living near the Border will tell you that. When the Minister complains about the glut of hides and the trouble he has to dispose of them he should advert to that fact.
The Minister suggested that a number of industries were available. I do not know how many he said, but I know there are plenty of towns in my area where industries could be very well established and plenty of workers. If the Minister would contact any of us who represent the area we would give him all the help he possibly could get.
I should also like to refer to another matter which I suppose will come under the Restrictive Trade Practices Bill and that is the cost of raw materials for agricultural machinery and agricultural requirements generally. It is an unusual situation that, for the raw materials required for agricultural purposes, we must pay through the nose because we have to buy in a protected market and are charged 100 per cent. or 50 per cent. higher than for the imported article. I do not want to decry Irish manufacturers, but some Irish manufacturers try to get away on the wagon. There is some Irish-manufactured stuff—I am dealing particularly with parts for agricultural machinery—that is of a very inferior quality and which enjoys a tariff of 100 per cent. or 50 per cent. The wretched stuff is more or less useless when we get it. The Minister should at least ensure, when he gives a tariff of 100 per cent. or 50 per cent. on plough points or anything else, that the quality complies with a certain standard. I suggest that the Minister should have a certain standard for all these requirements of agriculture which, after all, is the principal industry in the country. I just want to put these few points to the Minister in the hope that he will do something about them so that I will not have to raise them again on the Estimate next year.
Comment on this
The Minister, being in charge of the general trade and commerce of the country, has probably more than any other individual Minister the duty of watching over the living standards of the people of the country and on his individual decisions probably more than on those of any other individual in the Cabinet depend the general economic conditions of the State and the standard of living which the people will enjoy. It is, of course, generally understood and appreciated that in order effectively to increase the standard of living in the country it is necessary to increase the capital assets of the State and to improve, if possible, the utilisation of the available land and labour in the country.
The policy of the Minister's predecessors in relation to increasing capital formation in the State and improved utilisation of land and labour is well known throughout the country. It is not necessary to go over in any detail again the policy of the Minister's predecessors in that regard. The inter-Party Government believed that it was possible to encourage investment by the private sector of the community by reducing taxation, first of all, by increasing the effective demand of the community for goods and thereby stimulating the demand for home-produced goods. They also believed that in relation to and supplemental to investment by the private sector it was necessary to stimulate production, to endeavour to bring about conditions of full employment, and, if possible, in order to stop emigration that it was necessary for the Government themselves to undertake large-scale capital investment. That was the policy of the Minister's predecessors. It was carried out with remarkable success and the success was shown in the figures for production, the expansion in exports, and the increase generally over the period of the inter-Party Government of the standard of living of the people.
There were, however, a number of necessary adjuncts to the policy of capital investment which the Minister and his colleagues clearly do not appreciate. It was, for instance, appreciated by the Minister's predecessors that in order to undertake the large-scale capital investment programme which was, in fact, undertaken it was necessary to stimulate savings in order to finance that. It was appreciated by the inter-Party Government that if currency were not available to finance the capital investment programme it was necessary to call on past savings in the form of external assets and the inter-Party Government were prepared to disinvest some of our external assets in order to help to finance the capital investment programme which they undertook.
The second adjunct to the large-scale capital investment programme which the present Government appear not to be aware of is that, certainly in the short term at any rate, a large-scale capital investment programme will adversely affect the balance of payments. It will affect it, firstly, by an initial demand for machinery and goods; secondly, by a secondary demand for imported goods of every kind resulting from the increased demand of the State which has come about from the increased flow of incomes as the result of the investment and, thirdly, because, initially at any rate, there will be a reduction of exports because of the increased demand for consumer goods on the part of the people who have been given employment as a result of the investment undertaken by the State.
These necessary adjuncts and consequences of the capital investment programme which the Minister's predecessor undertook were accepted by the last Government and the last Government were prepared to face a large-scale deficit in the balance of payments in the belief, first of all, that it was necessary to finance capital investment projects and, secondly, because it would be of short-term duration and our external holdings were such that we could afford for a period of years to run deficits in the balance of payments without injuring irrevocably the Irish economy.
As I said, the present Government when they came into office did not fully appreciate the economic consequences of their predecessors' policy. First of all, they believed that because there were large-scale deficits in the balance of payments we were rapidly becoming a debtor country. It was pointed out time and again in this House, and it was recently revealed here again by the Minister for Finance in reply to a parliamentary question, that in fact the deficits in the balance of payments during the period of the inter-Party Government did not mean a reduction in our external assets and that when the inter-Party Government left office they left as many, if not more, external assets as they started with. The present Government also started with a misconception in regard to these external assets. They believed, and it was stated by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, that they constituted an army of occupation in England, that they were not to be touched and that it was better to leave them there.
Both these misconceptions concerning the deficit in the balance of payments and the repatriation of sterling assets meant that the Government last year initiated a policy deliberately directed towards reducing consumption in this State. Time and again we were told in this House in the last 12 months and in speeches reported in the newspapers, that the country was facing bankruptcy, that both the Government and the people were living beyond their means and that there was a vital necessity to do something about it. I believe the Government have done something about it.
They have done something about it in their Budget. Implicit and explicit in the Budget, running right through it, is the economic idea that this country and the people have got to reduce consumption. We have again heard the means by which the present Government propose to reduce consumption in this State. They propose to do it by increasing taxation, increasing prices, and reducing subsidies, thereby reducing the purchasing power in the hands of the people. By that means they hope to reduce the demand for consumer goods, to reduce the necessity for imports and to bring about a position by which we shall have no deficit in the balance of payments. I think the Government have been eminently successful in their efforts to bring about a reduction in consumption in this State. Thereby no doubt they will be enabled to reduce imports and perhaps bring about an improvement in the balance of payments. The price, though, that they are paying for their policy is to be seen in the trade recession which Deputies from all sides of the House acknowledge exists at the present time.
Some of the speeches that have been made here have endeavoured to remove responsibility from the present Government for the trade recession. It would be wrong to try to blame the Government for the world economic forces which at present are having a depressing effect on Irish economy. None the less we can say that if the Government policy of reducing consumption is the right one and if it is successful—I believe it certainly has been successful —then the necessary effect of that is to bring about a recession in trade in this country. The mopping up of pur chasing power which the Budget was designed to bring about can only have the effect of reducing consumption by ordinary men and women in this country and bringing about a falling-off in demand and in trade generally.
In discussing this Estimate we are entitled to find out from the Government what its policy is in regard to this trade recession which we all admit the country is experiencing at present. "Trade recession" is really a euphemism which means, in fact, unemployment and under-employment, which means very real misery in the household of the ordinary decent man and woman in this country. It means emigration; it means in many cases ruin and bankruptcy for many thousands of people. If these things can be avoided, it is the duty of the Government to take steps to avoid them and if the Government fails in that duty, it is unworthy of the confidence of the people of this country.
We have been searching for the last 12 months to try to ascertain what has been the approach of the present Government to the economic problems of the day. I think we have failed to find that out. We, in the inter-Party Government, were criticised very strongly by the members of the present Government when they were in opposition for our borrowing policy. In 1950, the then spokesman on financial matters of the Fianna Fáil Party, Deputy Aiken, criticised most adversely the inter-Party Government for increasing the level of the State's debt. The present Minister for Industry and Commerce last year on Deputy McGilligan's Budget again criticised the expansion in State debt that took place. Even a few months ago, the present Minister for Posts and Telegraphs again came back to criticise his predecessors for expanding the State debt. At the same time the present Government bring in Estimates which are designed to increase the State debt by £35,000,000—a much greater increase in any one year than their predecessors brought about. The present Minister for Finance criticised his predecessors for the increased interest charges which had to be paid out of the Exchequer every year but this year the provision for increased interest charges is up by £2,000,000.
The inter-Party Government was also criticised for its use of the American loan counterpart moneys but within five months the present Government spent more of these moneys than the inter-Party Government had spent in two and a half years. We were also told last year that we were living beyond our means. A couple of days ago in a public speech which was reported in the newspapers, the Minister deplored what he called "consumer resistance" and advised people to spend. We have that strange division of opinion—on the one hand statements that the Government and the people are living beyond their means and that consumption must be reduced and on the other hand the Minister telling the people that they must spend and deploring what he calls consumer resistance.
One of the greatest inconsistencies of all occurred in relation to the Government's attitude on food subsidies. I am not going into the ethics or morals of promising something in order to get Independent votes by a certain line of policy and then abandoning these promises, nor am I going to stress again, because I think it has been stressed adequately, the very real hardships which this decision of the Government is bringing on the people of the country. It may be possible for some sections of the people to buttress themselves against the full effects of the cut in the food subsidies but there are many sections of the community worthy of the greatest consideration by the Government and the Dáil who will be unable to do anything to defend themselves against the sharp upswing in living costs. These people are at present having to undergo a deterioration in their living standards as a result of the policy of the Government in cutting the food subsidies this year.
What I want to stress are the economic consequences of this policy. The Minister for Finance in proposing the cut in the food subsidies and again I think in the debate on the Supplies and Services Bill talked at very great length on the so-called economic reasons for cutting the food subsidies. He talked of the wasteful expenditure involved and actually admitted in that speech that he was always against them. Certainly it was the first time that the people could have been aware that the Minister was always against food subsidies. What the present Government have let the country in for is a deliberate rise in the living costs of the people. We in the inter-Party Government were criticised. I think, unfairly, for the small rise in the cost of living that took place in the three years while the inter-Party Government was in office. That rise in living costs was due, not to wage increases or increased costs of production in this country, but to a rise in import prices which showed itself in the cost of living.
Under the present Government living costs have again increased and, again, I think we must, in fairness, admit that for portion of their time at any rate the import prices which had affected the economy of the inter-Party Government during its three years, continued to rise. The present Government are not to blame for that.
But, here is a decision by a responsible Government of deliberately increasing living costs on the people of this country. The result of that must necessarily be the demands which we have seen in the last few months, and which are soon to become effective, for wage increases throughout the whole economy. We cannot blame any trade union for demanding a rise in basic wages at this time after the upswing in living costs if they come about as a result of this Government's decision. The Government must face, however, the consequences of the increase in wages and the increase in prices which are going to follow, and it is hard to see the logic of the Government's economic policy when, on the one hand, they are deploring the rise in the cost of living, the consumer resistance, and, on the other hand, by their own action, are setting in force a chain of circumstances which must inevitably lead to a further round of price increases.
We, I think, would be glad to know which way the Government is facing, whether, as Deputy Blowick said, we are facing bankruptcy or whether we are all right again; and, if so, what the Government proposes to do about the situation. At present, however, all we know is that the Government have brought in a Budget which, presumably, is the instrument of its economic and financial policy deliberately designed to cut consumption in the State. We said in the Budget debates, and we said throughout the country, that we do not believe in the specific designed by the present Government of reducing consumption. We believe in expanding purchasing power, so that there will be an increased demand for goods and increased economic activity in the State. That, in fact, was what was happening during the three years of the inter-Party Government, and it has been the reversal of that policy which has aggravated the present very serious trade recession which this country is now experiencing.
I believe that it is the responsibility of the Government to secure full employment in the State, a responsibility which it has failed to discharge. It is also its responsibility to see, in so far as it is capable of so doing, that emigration is reduced. This is another responsibility which it has failed to discharge.
The economic development of this country by means of large scale capital investment which was initiated by the Minister's predecessors is the sure way of maintaining the prosperity which was enjoyed during the three years of the inter-Party Government and of expanding the national economy. We have, this year, proposed expenditure, as I have said, of £35,000,000 on capital projects, but we have very little indication of how that £35,000,000 is going to be found. In fact, we have the declaration of the Minister for Finance, a strange declaration coming from a person in his responsible position, that he does not know where the money is going to come from. I think it would be a very amazing thing indeed if £35,000,000 was spent this year. It is indeed dangerous to prophesy, but it might very well easily be that not very much more than half the sum proposed to be spent this year will, in fact, be spent. We have got to see that every able-bodied man and woman in this state, who is able and willing to work, should get employment. It is the responsibility of the Government to bring about that state of affairs.
The large-scale Government investment, and the creation of capital assets, which was the policy of the inter-Party Government, must be continued. I can envisage, for many years to come, large-scale Government spending on works of a capital nature, and consequently large-scale Government borrowing to finance these projects. It is time now, I think, that proper direction and control over an investment policy should be given to a Government investment board. At present, schemes of a capital nature are prepared in a haphazard fashion in the Departments concerned, and are eventually pruned, or added to, by the Minister for Finance before he brings in his Budget proposals. I think, in order to avoid the haphazard nature of the capital investment which is being undertaken at the moment and which must be undertaken in the future in order to rationalise properly our capital investment, and in order to see that a proper return is got for that investment, a governmental agency, such as a Government investment board, should be set up whose task it would be to direct Government spending on work of a capital nature into the proper channels, and to see that there is no wasteful expenditure of Government funds on capital works.
At present there is no proper coordinating body by which over-all Government investment is controlled. The Taoiseach, some time ago in this House, referred to the fact that this matter of a Government investment board had been given consideration by him some years ago, that he had turned down the idea and that he still was against the idea. Some years ago, however, in 1939, the last normal year before the war, Government investment was on an infinitesimal scale. The total amount spent by the Fianna Fáil Government in that year, on all works of a capital nature, was a little over £1,000,000. We are now in the realms of an annual expenditure on capital works of something between £20,000,000 and £30,000,000. In these circumstances, it is advisable, I think, that this work of control and supervision should be given a separate agency in order to see that it is carried out effectively and efficiently, and so that there will be no wastage of Government funds.
Another item of Government policy which is sadly lacking is a proper savings campaign. More than 12 months ago, Deputy McGilligan announced, in his Budget speech, that it was proposed to bring in a national savings campaign. In the months that have intervened, Opposition spokesmen have advocated the need for a savings drive and have offered support in such a drive if the Government were prepared to institute it. The need for saving is very cursorily felt, I think, by the present Government, but when it comes to try and finance its works of a capital nature and when it comes to try and avoid the consequences of inflation, it will quickly realise the need for stimulating savings in the community. It may, indeed, be that it is too late now to start a savings campaign because of the deliberate policy of the Government to bring about forced savings by means of the Budget. At any rate, it is worth trying. If the public can be persuaded to save in order to help to finance the Government's investment programme I think it should be persuaded to do so. Over the past few months we have had the spectacle of the Government vacillating as to their economic policy, directing their attentions towards denigrating the efforts of their predecessors and in some instances deliberately engaging in falsehoods and, at any rate, in exaggerations when dealing with economic matters. The result of all that has been the rising unemployment, the rising stream of emigration and the trade recession which have been referred to throughout this debate.
An effort has been made to put the blame for the trade recession on the Opposition. It is a strange feat of logic, I think, to try and blame an Opposition for doing their task and to try to put the blame for the economic situation of the country on the Opposition Parties merely because they have tried to propound their policies and to point out where they believed the Government were wrong in the application of their policy. Inasmuch as the present Government have stated that they have a policy, it is the policy which was pointed out last September by the Central Bank Report. The Central Bank Report pointed out what it regarded as the gravity of our external trading position. It stated that the only means to remedy the situation was a drastic reduction in imports and it mentioned how that reduction could be brought about. The Government followed the policies set out in the Central Bank Report. Government machinery has deliberately been brought to bear in order to ensure that consumption in the State is reduced. That, we believe, is the wrong policy. That is the policy which has aggravated the present serious situation. Until the Government are prepared to throw over the wild cries in which they have been indulging for many months past and until they are prepared to adopt the policy of expanding our economy, which was introduced by their predecessors in office, we can expect and fear a continuing deterioration in the economic situation of this State.
Comment on this
It was pretty obvious from the Minister's speech yesterday that he was very ill at ease, not so much about the type of speech which he had to make as about the general economic situation in which this country finds itself at the present time.
The Minister has the reputation of being energetic, enthusiastic and daring and I do not think he lacks any of these qualities which have been attributed to him. If I were to make a criticism of the Department of Industry and Commerce, my first point would be that the Department is far too big for one Minister. It must be obvious to every Deputy and surely it must be obvious to every Minister that the Department of Industry and Commerce is of such enormous proportions that it is quite impossible even for a Deputy Lemass to keep his finger on the pulse of every section of that Department. To look after industry and to think about further industrial expansion in this country is surely a one-man and a whole-time job. It seems extraordinary that though the Taoiseach, with the approval of the Dáil, nominated five Parliamentary Secretaries not one of them was appointed to the Department of Industry and Commerce. That is forcibly brought home to us when we remember that a few short years ago, under a Fianna Fáil Government, two Parliamentary Secretaries were attached to the Department of Industry and Commerce. I suggest, therefore, that Deputy Lemass, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, would be well employed in looking after the industry and the general industrial development of this country, and nothing else.
If I were to advocate anything else in respect of the general administration of the Department of Industry and Commerce I should advocate a separate Ministry for Transport and Marine and Air Services. I think that would be only fair to the Dáil and to the people of this country in general. Surely a Minister for Industry and Commerce cannot personally give decisions on the hundreds of thousands of matters on which decisions must be given in that Department from month to month. It seems to me—and I do not blame them —that the officials of the Department of Industry and Commerce must make important decisions on their own. I believe that the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, as any other Minister, will take responsibility for any decision so made but possibly in his heart and in his conscience he will not agree with all the decisions that have been come to even though he is prepared to take full responsibility for them. Therefore, I urge the Minister for Industry and Commerce to look for assistance in the administration of his Department. Inasmuch as there is a crisis as far as transport is concerned, and that the accent, to some extent, is on shipping and air services, the Taoiseach would be well advised to appoint a Parliamentary Secretary to the Department of Industry and Commerce. I make that suggestion despite Deputy Lemass's reputation as an energetic, enthusiastic and hardworking Minister. Even though he may have all these qualities it is impossible for one person to preside over the enormous Department of Industry and Commerce.
To a large extent the Minister's speech was a description of details of administration in his Department. He was very careful not to express many important opinions which, in his capacity of Minister for Industry and Commerce, he might have expressed. He touched lightly on unemployment. There have been questions and allegations in this House as to who is responsible for the unemployed. I believe that the unemployed of this or of any country are the responsibility of the Government of the day. I believe that the Minister for Industry and Commerce in this country has prior responsibility for the unemployed inasmuch as it is his function to stimulate and to protect industry and, as a consequence of that, to see that employment is maintained at a reasonably high level.
We are entitled to hear, too, from the Minister—and perhaps he will refer to it at some later stage—as to what went on between the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance and their counterparts across in Great Britain when they went over there. These questions have been asked here for the last three or four months and I believe that we here in this House are entitled to know what happened between Deputy Lemass and Deputy MacEntee and the British Chancellor of the Exchequer and the President of the Board of Trade, or whoever they did happen to meet across in Great Britain. He went over there as Minister for Industry and Commerce. His expenses were paid over there. We, as the representative assembly in this country, sent him. Surely it would not be unreasonable to ask that he, in his capacity as Minister for Industry and Commerce, should give us some indication as to what was the nature of the talks that went on on that particular occasion because allegations have been made even by members of my own Party that during those discussions in which the Minister for Industry and Commerce took part, proposals were put forward and agreed to as to the type of Budget that should be introduced in this country.
Comment on this
I am merely relating it to the activities of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the last 12 months.
Comment on this
All the activities of the Minister for Industry and Commerce cannot be debated on the Estimate for his Department.
Comment on this
I rather assumed the debate on the Vote for Industry and Commerce would, in particular, refer to the activities of the Minister for Industry and Commerce over the last 12 months.
Comment on this
With respect I suggest this House pays the Minister a salary and we are entitled to know what he does. I am not making a point about the salary.
Comment on this
The question of the administration of the Department of Industry and Commerce is open to debate.
Comment on this
I will leave it at that, but I think we should have been told what the nature of the talks was.
Comment on this
They agreed to say nothing on every occasion. There was nothing issued. I do not intend to hold up the House or to particularise with regard to these discussions about the recession in trade. On the general question of unemployment I do not think that the country fully realises the serious situation in which this country finds itself at the present time. As to how serious the situation is with regard to unemployment my particular problem is this. As far as unemployment is concerned—and Wexford is an industrial town—when workers in Wexford town become unemployed they are not reflected in any figures which are issued from the Department of Social Welfare, because immediately they are sacked in Wexford town they go down to Rosslare Harbour and they are across to Great Britain inside 24 hours.
There have been comments here to-day about the major industry established in Wexford town, and that is the firm which manufactures agricultural implements. There have been many disparaging remarks both from a member of my own Party and from the leader of the Clann na Talmhan Party but in respect of that firm I want to say that if the present situation does not improve, that firm just will not be in existence much longer to manufacture the agricultural implements of which they complain.
I suggest that it is the Government's function to remedy a situation such as this. Out of a total number of 450 employees in the firm of Pierce's of Wexford, 135 have been sacked within the last fortnight. As an aside I want to say that if that had happened during the régime of the inter-Party Government every Fianna Fáil supporter from Wexford town would be kicking down my door and the fact would be plastered in two-inch headlines across the Irish Press. They do not seem to be concerned now. Neither does the organ of the Government Party appear to be concerned at all about unemployment.
I want to bring home to the Minister the fact that the situation is so serious that it is expected—and I hope it is untrue—that the balance of the employees in the firm of Pierce's of Wexford will be dismissed during this present week. That is a serious position as far as Wexford town is concerned because it is the main industry there, employing, as it does, from 450 to 500 people.
There is another firm which is adversely affected by the action of the present Government. I heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce make a quip across the floor to one of the speakers on the benches on my left, when he said we could reduce the imports into this country by £100,000,000. I would like to know what contribution he is making towards doing that. During the régime of the inter-Party Government there was an arrangement whereby a certain quota of car springs would be allowed into this country. It was fixed at about 1,000 per six months. That worked very well for the firm of Springs, Limited, in Wexford. They could maintain all their employees and they did take on additional staff. At the first opportunity of fixing the quota for the importation of springs, when Fianna Fáil came into power, the lid was off. Springs could come in ad lib. Springs can now come in ad lib. and the result is that men are being dismissed from Springs, Limited, in Wexford. There may be some answer. I would like the Minister for Industry and Commerce to give the answer. I do not know whether there are any complications. I do not know whether or not there is some ready-up with the car assemblers or the car distributors in this country, but I do know that young men in Wexford town are being dismissed; they proceed to Rosslaré Harbour and they go over to Fishguard to help in the rearmament drive in Great Britain— not so much to help in the rearmament drive in Great Britain but to get wages. It is an interesting fact for the Minister to know, and for the Minister for Social Welfare to know, that of the 135 employees who were dismissed from the foundry industry in Wexford over the last two weeks, a very small proportion of them have signed on the employment exchange, thus showing that the bulk of them have gone to Great Britain.
The joke of it is that even the Taoiseach tells this Dáil that there is no check on the number of young men or on the number of men and women of any ages who leave this country to take up employment in Great Britain. We may talk about our natural resources here; we may talk about the assets we have; we may talk, as Deputy McGrath did, about exporting certain items of machinery from a chassis factory. We know all about that and Deputy McGrath knows all about that, but the Taoiseach cannot even tell us how many people are emigrating, the most precious asset we have in this country, men and women, their ability to work in this country and to build this country. This Government is content to sit down and export them and make no appreciable effort to keep them here. As I said, the joke of it is that we have not even an idea how many of them go across to Great Britain.
I have heard Deputies here talking about the establishment of industries in different parts of the country. No matter how often it is repeated, people still do not seem to get it into their heads that this Government, or any other Government, do not build factories, do not establish industries. My one complaint about the Irish people would be—and we are inclined to regard ourselves as rebels; we are inclined to regard ourselves as people with initiative—that as far as initiative in industry or business is concerned, we are one of the most conservative people in the world. Many of us have had the experience of going to a particular town in our constituency where there were representatives of the Chamber of Commerce, representatives of this association, that association and the other association all gathered around a table trying to find out whether they will get an industry in the town, trying to find out what the Government will do to bring a particular industry to the town of X, Y, Z. The majority of the people sitting around the table would not be prepared to invest one shilling in the establishment of an industry in the particular town.
We do not seem to have a flair for investment at home. We do not seem to have a flair for putting our savings into Irish industry. Is it because we have no confidence in Irish industry? Is it because we have never got a lead from anybody in the matter of investment? I believe that the Industrial Development Authority is not a bad institution. I believe it was a good idea to set it up but I think that body is inclined to be a bit too conservative. This Government and every Irish Government will have to drive so far as Irish industry is concerned. There is no use in the Minister for Industry and Commerce—either the present Minister or any of his predecessors—standing up here and stating: "If there are bodies of people in particular towns who have the money and who want to set up industries, if they come to the Industrial Development Authority they will be advised as to the best industry they can set up."
I suggest it should be the function of the Industrial Development Authority to list the type of industries suitable for establishment here and to advertise them, so to speak, in different towns. It should be the function of that body to suggest to the people of New Ross, Fermoy, Mitchelstown or any other town that this, that or the other industry is suitable for establishment in the town. That body should find out if there are people in the town who will be prepared to invest their money in the particular industry. It is not their function to give guarantees as to the success of any industry. Their function is to give information and guarantee certain protection and certain facilities. This idea of the Industrial Development Authority sitting up in St. Stephen's Green waiting for people to knock at the door and say: "What industry have you for us to-day?" is absurd. I do not think Irish industry will be advanced so long as the Industrial Development Authority acts like that. I do not blame the authority for that. I do not blame the Minister. I suggest that inasmuch as that authority has been established the Minister should charge it now with the task of leading or driving the Irish people to invest money in Irish industry. At the moment all that body does is to invite people to come to it so that they can give them all the advice at their disposal and the matter rests there.
There is undoubtedly a great need for industrial expansion here especially in recent years. It is obvious that people are flying from the land for a variety of reasons. Some of them are flying because they cannot get a living on it. The workers will try first in the big towns, then in the smaller towns and, if they fail to get employment, they take ship to England. Another aspect of the matter is that as many people are not now required on the land as were required some years ago. That is due to the increase in mechanisation. The tractor and the other up-to-date farm equipment is now doing away with manual labour. The same number of people are not required on the land and industry will have to take up the slack.
Industry is not in a position to take up the slack and the emigration figures will continue to rise until industry is sufficiently developed to absorb the people who are flying from the land. We are not in a position to develop heavy industry to any great extent. I think it would be fatal to engage in heavy industries because, should another emergency arise, there will be a scarcity of raw materials. We will not be able to procure iron, steel and coal and heavy industry, should we be foolish enough to establish it, will come to a standstill. We must develop industries the raw materials of which can be produced out of our own resources. We must process the production from the land.
A good deal of discussion has centred round the crisis in the railways. My knowledge of railways and the railway system is very limited. It has always puzzled me—I am sure it has puzzled other Deputies—that we have never had a policy statement on transport. I do not remember any firm policy statement with regard to transport here. What Minister has said that we should use the railways for a certain type of transport and the roads for another type? Until that is done the situation as far as the railways are concerned will deteriorate very rapidly. All of us have contributed to the downfall of the railways. Up to 15 years ago I am sure 90 per cent. of the Deputies here travelled to Dublin by rail. To-day 90 per cent. travel by car. Though that may be a small contribution towards the downfall of the railways it must be obvious to everybody that the abnormal increase in the number of motor cars over the last four or five years is detrimental to the railways.
Córas Iompair Éireann has helped to kill the railways because the accent for years past has been on road transport, on buses and on heavy lorries. Deputy McGrath, Deputy Keane and Deputy Blowick touched the kernel of the situation when they suggested that an effort should be made to divert a certain type of traffic from road to rail. That can be done by legislation. That probably would be the quickest way of doing it. It can also be done by taxation. Certain transport can be taxed to such an extent that it will be forced on to the railways. As Deputy McGrath said, the railways are used by business and industry to take bulky goods and the joke of the situation is that Córas Iompair Éireann are giving that service at a relatively low cost.
The goods that might be of value to Córas Iompair Éireann are carried by the firm's own lorries or by hired lorries. The Minister must make up his mind that he cannot afford to scrap the railways. If we can develop them, they can be a tremendous asset; if the decision is to let them slide, we get nothing, as no one wants to buy a railway. We have a permanent way and rolling stock and a small country like this cannot afford to scrap a railway system.
I do not think the Government should take the initiative in establishing transatlantic air lines. I do not see what particular advantage it would be, even to a small percentage of the taxpayers. It is a good thing to have some nationalisation of the railway system or something of national importance but no one can say that a transatlantic air line would be of national importance. We would be confronted here for a number of years with voting substantial amounts for the preservation of the service in its initial stages.
Comment on this
The same was said for many years about the mercantile marine and an island nation was left isolated.
Comment on this
I am suggesting now that the people who would use a transatlantic air service would not be represented by any big proportion or even a small proportion of the taxpayers. It must be obvious that T.W.A., Pan-American Airways, Sabena, Canadian Pacific and others are engaged in cut-throat competition. While I have no doubt of the ability of Irishmen, this is not the time for us to try to compete with companies so long established and with such tremendous resources, apart from the fact that it would not be of any material advantage to the taxpayers.
I would like to make my annual plea —should I say "annual" when in opposition—for the development of harbours. It must be significant to Deputies on the east coast that we have only four harbours of importance —Drogheda, Dundalk, Dublin, and Rosslare. Wicklow could not be regarded as a major harbour and in its present condition Wexford certainly could not be regarded as a major harbour. The Minister—or the Minister for Finance, it may be—has approved of a generous grant, more generous than we expected at first. If the Minister is there in another two or three years——
Comment on this
Ha, I knew he was going for the position of Taoiseach. The grant has been given to Wexford harbour, I assume, to prove itself. I want to remind the Minister that if it is shown after these improvements have been made that Wexford harbour is capable of absorbing more trade, he should consider what has been regarded as the major scheme of development of the harbour. It is a bit premature to talk about that and I am sure that as long as there are Wexford Deputies in this House any Minister for Industry and Commerce will be reminded of this. Deputy Allen and any of us from Wexford will say that we have enterprising merchants there who will develop their business and their industries if the harbour gets a chance at all. If there is any prospect of bringing extra business to the town, these enterprising businessmen will be to the forefront.
Comment on this
Export and import. Regarding the Prices Advisory Body, it is true that it was experimental. It was a good idea but I would ask the Minister to consider having all the hearings in public, having the reports published and having included the reasons given for the increases sanctioned. There is nothing that bewilders the public more than an announcement that a firm went to the Prices Advisory Body, that the case was heard and the increase was granted. It is all very fine to say that the advisory body should be trusted, that it is a representative body and that the Minister ought to be trusted as a responsible Minister. What I suggest would go some distance in settling the minds and the feelings of the people generally as to the necessity for these increases. The ordinary man in the street does not know why soap goes up to-day and some other commodity tomorrow. He should be told that the price of the raw material has gone up, that Córas Iompair Éireann have increased their charges, that freights and insurance have gone up. Ministers' and Deputies' jobs would be far easier if people had more appreciation of the reasons for price increases.
The Minister made a significant remark in his opening statement, that he did not know whether a system of price control promoted increases or promoted reductions. I do not know if I got the full significance of his remark or not, but this suggested itself to me, that when a firm wanted an increase they went to the Prices Advisory Body to put their case—let us say that the price of the commodity was fixed at 5/—while there is no machinery and there is nobody to approach that firm when their expenses go down. In the case of drapery—I know that drapery is not controlled—if the raw material goes up the firm goes to the Prices Advisory Body and gets an increase, but when the raw material goes down they still have their 5/- or whatever it may be. That cannot be a perfect example, but it shows what I mean. The body gives sanction to a particular price but when the circumstances improve and the raw materials are cheaper and other expenses tend to decrease the firm still has the higher price and there is no application for a decrease. If the Department had some other body to get after firms to decrease their prices when circumstances change, that would provide a good balance. The present body is there more or less to keep prices static or to grant increases.
The question of food subsidies has been thrashed out during the past three or four months. I do not intend to comment on it beyond saying that, whether it was wise or unwise, the by-elections were held at the wrong time but at the right time for the Government.
Comment on this
That is what you would like to think. We used to be all Fianna Fáil but we voted according to our conscience.
Comment on this
The full effects of the Budget and especially of the withdrawal of the food subsidies are just not felt. Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll talked about the results of the elections. I want to say that the by-elections were held at the wrong time. Fianna Fáil played a very good game and if I were to pay them a tribute I would say that they are the best political strategists not only in this country but in the whole world.
Comment on this
You can take that as being a compliment or otherwise. To get a decent decision about the food subsidies it was unwise to hold the by-elections when they were held but the Government had an opportunity of distributing largesse in the form of social welfare, children's allowances——
Comment on this
I do not intend to continue for long more in that strain but when a woman wants a widow's pension she has to wait three months but on this occasion she got it a week before her time.
Comment on this
I am speaking about Deputy Dr. ffrench O'Carroll who was very careful not to talk about food subsidies to-day. He talked about mothers, children and social welfare. He prefaced his remarks on any subject he wanted to speak about by saying "apart from the food subsidies" and "leaving the food subsidies aside". That is the one thing he wanted to do. I want to congratulate the Fianna Fáil Party for having completely converted, for what reason I do not know, Deputy Dr. ffrench O'Carroll on the question of the food subsidies.
Comment on this
I just want to mention a few points to the Minister. One of these relates to the high price of binder twine. The farmers are most perturbed about this matter. The price of this commodity is now about 400 per cent. above what it was during the war. I should also like if he could give us any information as to the necessity for controlling the price of oatmeal at the present time. Invariably one is asked in the country why the price of this commodity continues to be controlled.
An edged tool factory recently closed down in Wexford. I am told that during the last two or three years the country was flooded with tools from foreign countries and that every trader in the country is fully stocked up with sufficient foreign tools to last a couple of years. Edged tools had protection in this country up to the time of the war. I believe there is no protection now for edged tools.
Comment on this
The firm would not take it. I am not trying to be controversial but my information is that the firm did not want protection.
Comment on this
The employees in the firm are probably more important than the firm itself. If the ports are open to dumping here of edged tools, that should be stopped. There is no question at all about that. It is not a question of Irish tools not being sold. I believe they can be sold at 20 per cent. under the price which foreign tools cost at the present day but, having regard to the fact that the traders have a two years' stock of those foreign edged tools, there is no opening for Irish edged tools at the present time. I would ask the Minister to do something about that. These are the few points I particularly wanted to raise. I would ask the Minister to say something about the binder twine and why it is as expensive as it is to-day.
I will not talk about the by-elections. My Labour colleague has made excuses about the Labour Party's failing so badly. Deputy Davin will be able to tell all about that. In any event, the Opposition failed to convince the people—I heard some Deputies endeavouring to convince them in Waterford—that the Government would starve the people out. It was mentioned that it was not an opportune time to hold the elections. If it was not, then no opportune time will ever come to the Opposition in their lifetime.
Comment on this
The Minister, in his statement introducing his Estimate, referred to many matters in connection with industry, harbours, turf and so forth. I should like at the outset to say that many of the difficulties which at the moment confront the Minister and the Government are simply difficulties which I anticipated this country would meet as far back as 20 years ago. I am surprised how innocent Ministers and even the Taoiseach seem to be thinking that this country can escape what is known as economic pressure. We imagine—and I think there is that imagination in this country—that because we are in an island nothing will happen to us here, that everything in the garden will be lovely. It is imagined that we will not meet with any opposition whatsoever. Yet, when we do meet with that opposition, we seem to fall flat on our backs as it were. That is a rather peculiar situation in view of the way in which we boast about being the finest people in the world.