Committee on Finance. - Vote 50—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).
Contributions 200–421 of 421. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When we go to other countries we can hold our own. Yet, when the least ill wind blows, we seem to lose our heads and everything goes wrong. So it is now with our industry. I want to state here and now what I have stated year in and year out, that you cannot make industry prosper in this country simply by the mere passing of an Act of Parliament. There is no short road to prosperity but we have got into our heads that all we have got to do is to erect a factory and things will go well.
It is one thing to erect a factory but it is another to keep it going. Factories have been erected in this country—we are all glad to see them—with a great flourish of trumpets. As the years went on and as they faced competition, we find that these factories in many places had to go on short time.
In some cases they have been closed down absolutely. We are sorry that that is so but it is well that we should recognise that fact so far as the establishment of industries is concerned.
We should also remember that the population is less than 3,000,000 and that their capacity to buy the output of the factories is limited. Outside our few cities and principal towns—Dublin, Waterford, Cork, Limerick, Drogheda, Dundalk, Tralee, Galway, Sligo—the vast majority of our people live on the land—simple people, who look after their crops, some of whom never saw a train or a bus and do not go in for great style in wearing apparel. All these factors have to be taken into consideration when we speak of industrial output or industrial development.
I regret the position industry is in at the moment but I am not surprised. I think the Minister, who has been 16 years in office, was not very long in office when he more or less issued a warning as regards industrial production. I think he said that the time had come when the people engaged in industry were past their apprenticeship and were fully grown tradesmen and that the time had arrived when, whether they liked it or not, they would have to meet a certain amount of outside competition.
We are all in favour of home industry and that nothing should be allowed in. Let me warn the members of this House that two can play at that game. Supposing the people with whom we trade, the people to whom we export cattle, pigs, bacon, butter, eggs, powdered milk and all the other things, were to say: "We will take no more of these things from you," what position would the country be in then? We must be prepared to put the good with the bad and to do the best we can in the very trying and difficult times through which we are passing.
One of the matters referred to by the Minister affects the constituency which I represent. It is the question of harbours. If I remember aright, the Minister expressed his disappointment at the progress made in the development of our harbours. He remarked that, although the moneys had been allocated which would enable the authorities concerned to carry out the improvements, he would like to see a little more progress made within the time.
I want to refer the Minister to one of these important schemes, namely, the dredging of the harbour in Dundalk, for which the sum approximating to £100,000 was allocated by his predecessor in office as far back as 1950. There has been some delay even in starting these most essential works. I do not know who is to blame. I realise that it is not a very simple matter. The work is intricate and requires a good deal of preliminary examination but if the plans are with the Department I would ask the Minister to see to it that as little time as possible is lost in notifying the harbour authorities that they may proceed to advertise the contract. The Minister knows the position of the harbour. At the moment it is silting up at a very fast rate, so much so, that there is danger of the port losing trade, leaving out of consideration increased trade which would result from the dredging scheme being carried out. I would ask the Minister to make a special note of that so that there will be no undue delay.
The Minister informed the House that there was a surprising number of new industries being considered by his Department and that the result would undoubtedly be the establishment of new factories. We all welcome that news. As the setting up of factories may affect my constituency, may I just quote the remarks made by the Minister on May 30th, 1950, when the Estimate for Industry and Commerce was being debated here? The Minister, Deputy Lemass, as he then was, stated in the House:
"So far as the preparation of an over-all industrial plan and the vigorous application of a policy to secure the implementation of that plan are concerned, there is no evidence."
In other words, there was no evidence that the then Government or the then Minister had any industrial plan and there was a lack so far as the vigorous application of any policy to secure the implementation of an industrial plan was concerned. The then Deputy Lemass gave a few cases in point. He said:
"One of the industries which it is practicable to establish here and which considerations of national security as well as other considerations of national interest require that we should establish—an industry which we very nearly came to have before the war—is the manufacture of nitrogenous fertilisers, sulphate of ammonia. I am not going to recount what happened before the war to delay and render futile the plans which were made then, but during the war, in accordance with the general policy adopted then of setting up organisations to plan post-war developments, a company called Ceimicí Teoranta was created by an Act of the Dáil. That company was charged with the responsibility primarily of preparing industrial plans for the manufacture here of such chemical products as were practicable in our circumstances, and, I told the Dáil when bringing the Bill before it, the immediate task entrusted to them was to bring to fruition this idea of manufacturing our own nitrogenous fertilisers, the setting up and operation of a sulphate of ammonia factory."
I am just quoting that in order to relate it to a position in an area within my county. I think the Minister will recall that many of the people in the area around Greenore and Carlingford lost their employment as a result of the closing down of the Dundalk and Greenore line. The closing down of that line meant the simultaneous closing of the port of Greenore. Various Deputies came to the Minister prior to the closing down of that line.
The Minister received them very cordially and gave them a very sympathetic hearing. If I am quoting the Minister's reply properly, I think he definitely promised that he would do his best to establish a factory in that area to recoup people, so to speak, for the loss they had sustained as a result of the closing of the railway line and of the port. I suggest to the Minister that he should put these promises which he made in May, 1950, into effect. If my memory serves me right, there was a rumour prior to 1950 —in 1947—to the effect that the Minister had more or less made up his mind that this particular factory should be established in County Louth. It was discussed at a meeting of the local council which I attended some seven or eight years ago. The manager of Ceimicí Teoranta was also present at this meeting. In view of the developments which have taken place in that area and due to the fact that the Minister knows the circumstances existing there due to the closing down of the railway and the port, he should lose no time in coming to a decision and putting into effect the promise which he gave to the people of the area when he met them some few months ago. I am not going to tie the hand of the Minister by asking him to give a specific promise, nor am I going to ask him to fix a specific date for the establishment of the factory. I know all the difficulties that exist with regard to such matters. I am aware that a great many inquiries have to be gone into and I realise that an industry dealing with chemicals is one which has to be very carefully examined. Therefore, I am prepared to give the Minister as much time as possible. If he is thinking of setting up such an industry, I would like him to remember that an area in County Louth was selected for its location.
In his statement in the Dáil on 30th May, 1950, the Minister, then Deputy Lemass, dealt with turf, machinery, cotton yarn, etc. I would like to impress upon him again that, on that particular occasion, he referred to a chassis factory which was to have been established by Córas Iompair Éireann. For some reason or other, that did not materialise. At column 789, Volume 121, of the Official Reports of the 30th May, 1950, the Tánaiste—then Deputy Lemass—said:
"We have registered in this country every year 5,500 new commercial vehicles; 23,000 or 24,000 new cars of all kinds are purchased here every year, but of them some 5,500 are commercial vehicles of the kind which that factory was designed to build. It would only be capable of producing 500 or 600 of these vehicles every year out of the 5,500 to be purchased. Is it possible at this stage to retrieve the project? Will the Minister, if he does not want to entrust the direction of that enterprise to Coras Iompair Eireann, set up another organisation for it? That machinery is available. That machinery which is being purchased by British scrap merchants is being resold to British manufacturers who will use it to make new motor vehicles to ship over here."
I suggest that it would be well if the Minister would pay attention now to the question of that factory. It would enable us to manufacture here these commercial vehicles which are so extensively used by Coras Iompair Eireann. I think this is the right time to make this suggestion. Whatever need there was for this factory when the Minister for Industry and Commerce, then Deputy Lemass, referred to it in May, 1950, I think there is greater need for it now, in view of the fact that, since that period, the Great Northern Railway has been acquired and is now, more or less, under the same management as Coras Iompair Eireann. Seeing that there is such a large Coras Iompair Eireann workshop at Inchicore and such large Great Northern Railway works at Dundalk, both of which have been renowned for their workmanship and for the manner in which they have turned out machinery, I feel it would be wise if the Minister could see his way to have this factory started again so as to dovetail the employees of these two big concerns in doing this particular work. There would then be less likelihood of a reduction in the number employed either at the Coras Iompair Eireann workshop in Inchicore or at the Great Northern Railway works in Dundalk. I throw out that suggestion for what it is worth.
In olden days it used to be stated that, in order to have a fast engine, it would have to be imported from Britain. However, as years went by, it was obvious that the employees of the Great Northern Railway were just as capable of building engines which were as good, if not better than, the imported ones. I feel the same can be said of the present staff at the Inchicore workshop and at the Great Northern Railway workshop in Dundalk. With a little experience, there is no reason why these two workshops, or any other big engineering firm, in the country would not be in a position to build the diesel engines, many of which have been imported during the last year or two.
When the Minister made the statement from which I have quoted in the Dáil on the 30th May, 1950, of course, he was in opposition. Naturally, people in opposition do not say kind words to the Government in power. Therefore, I am not surprised at some of the statements made by him on that occasion. He referred to the textile industry, and he said at column 799:
"So far as cotton yarn is concerned, there has been no development beyond the mill which was commenced in Athlone in 1947."
That is true, I admit. The Minister was speaking of the year before the inter-Party Government came into power. The Minister will admit that, while they were in office, they made some progress in connection with the extension of factories for the manufacture of cotton yarn. The Minister knows already, and I am sure he is glad to know it, that a new factory was established at Castlebar while the inter-Party Government held office. Therefore, it must be admitted that some little advance was made by them in regard to the setting up of industries in this State.
Comment on this
It is all the same to me which Government does it, so long as they do it for the country. I am not one of these small-minded types of men. I am traditionally broadminded and I could go to any part of the world and earn my living, so far as that is concerned.
Comment on this
My neighbour is all mankind of every description and I do not talk of a Dublin man or a Cork man.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned turf and I should like to relate his remarks about turf to his remarks about it in May, 1950.
Comment on this
30th May, 1950, at column 800 of the Official Debates. There the Minister was criticising the inter-Party Government with regard to turf. So far as I know, when the war was over, the present Minister for Finance, who was then Minister for Local Government, gave orders to all public bodies to discontinue the production of turf immediately coal became available. The Minister for Industry and Commerce was all out for turf then and he was right up to a point. He spoke about the relative value of turf and coal and referred to the White Paper issued in 1946 and said that he would make it a condition of every subsidy given to a local authority or to a private individual for the construction of a dwellinghouse, every help given through protection or otherwise to an industrial concern, that they must instal in every dwelling-house, factory, or institution equipment specially designed for the economic utilisation of turf fuel.
Comment on this
I merely wanted to recall those remarks to show that logic and consistency do not now seem to be thought much of. They do not seem to be characteristic of the people of the present age, myself included.
The Minister yesterday said that he was personally disappointed that there were certain big corporations or businesses as well as certain public institutions which were turning from coal and turf—particularly turf—to oil. I suggest that the Minister should not be so annoyed about that, or that he should take steps to see that that could not happen, in view of what he said on 30th May, 1950, in regard to giving no subsidies to people who would not use turf. The Local Government Department gives subsidies to public institutions—to district hospitals, county hospitals, county homes and so on—and it is very strange that the Minister did not see to it that these institutions were not allowed to turn from the use of turf to oil boilers.
I am not against turf. I believe that the production of turf is very essential in the areas in which it can be procured. If it gives employment in those areas, well and good, but I want to remind the Minister that there are a number of harbours along the east coast which depend almost 100 per cent. for their existence on imports of coal. There are Dundalk, Drogheda, Dublin, to a lesser extent, with the trade of the whole country so far as ocean-going vessels are concerned, Wexford, Waterford and so on. I suggest that these should not be forgotten when the use of turf is being advocated. We must consider the country as a whole and not just a particular district, and the Minister, in his responsible position, must weigh up the pros and cons of all these matters and take everything into consideration before coming to a definite decision.
We in County Louth and people in Dublin and along the east coast could not at all support the idea of compulsion in the use of turf in preference to coal, so long as we can get coal. We are getting coal and will get it. We are getting plenty of coal now, from our old enemy, England. She is giving us plenty of coal and always will give it to us. We need not be afraid that we will not get plenty supplies from Great Britain, because we are very great with them at the moment. There are no two greater men than Churchill and the Taoiseach at present, and seeing that we have cooperated with them even in framing our Budget, I am sure they will continue to give us any little coal we want. If war comes, we will get the same supplies as we got during the last war and that is that. I want the Minister to be very careful not to do anything to curtail in any way our coal supplies. While saying that, I wish the best of luck to Leitrim, Galway, Laois, Offaly, Clare and all the other counties in which turf production is a very essential part of their economy.
I come now to the question of the high cost of living and prices. It is not easy to control prices and meet every emergency. You just cannot work life mathematically and I am still a firm believer in the old method of controlling prices, competition. At least, let us have competition here and in the end there is no better safeguard. Undoubtedly the cost of living has increased very considerably. I do not want to make much use of that point because I know it is something which is very hard to prevent. I took the same attitude when the previous Fianna Fáil Government were in power and when the inter-Party Government were in power of defending the Minister responsible so far as prices are concerned.
When the Supplies and Services Bill was being debated here—I think Deputy Liam Cosgrave was in charge— I regret to say that we saw the fiercest attacks ever made here on anything. I think I never listened to a debate more calculated to destroy the economic position of the country. I felt bound to stand up and state what I believed to be the truth, that there was no appreciable increase in the cost of living at that period. It only came a few months afterwards. It came, as Deputy Cosgrave said, with the outbreak of the Korean war. I know that the cost of living had gone up as a result of the devaluation of the pound sterling. As the Minister stated, sterling is only holding on—to use a common expression—by the skin of its teeth. We hope at least that it will deteriorate no further because if it does it will have the effect of increasing the cost of living. There again the Government is in a difficult position and the only thing we can hope is that sterling will hold its position. Then things will possibly right themselves and the cost of living will not soar too high. Undoubtedly, of course, it has increased and I think that the Minister and those on the far side must agree that up to the moment we have not made things very awkward in that regard. I hope that that very happy state of affairs will continue.
I think that the Minister mentioned E.C.A. and some help we got from America which sent missions over here to tell us all about how to do things. For some reason apparently they were financing that themselves. I would like the Minister to tell us in a little more detail the reason for its being discontinued. Suggestions were made here that America was out to force this country to do something that was not in the national interest. I think it was Deputy Peadar Cowan who stated that we could balance our Budget if we were prepared to sell the country. I wonder if such talk arose from the fact the Minister mentioned, so I would like him to explain everything connected with E.C.A.
It is my intention to refer to the matter on the Taoiseach's Estimate, because I, as a member of this House, would not take lying down the charge that I was prepared to sell the soul of this country to America or to any other country. I would like the Minister or the Taoiseach, at the first opportunity, to make it clear that there were not men on this side of the House prepared to sell their country. I speak on behalf of my Party and of those who voted for us—more than half the country. The men who brought me into the world were racy of the soil, Irish, and played a noble part in the country's history down the centuries. Although I may be a humble member of this House, I refute the charge, whether it comes from the Taoiseach or from any other man, that I would be one of those men who would sell their country, as Esau sold his birthright, for a mess of pottage.
It is not too easy to keep our industries going full speed ahead. As far as I can see, the tendency has been to erect a few factories between each election so that we may have something to brag about. I do not think that it is good policy to over-industrialise with regard to any particular article. I think that one of the greatest misfortunes that can befall a young man is to be engaged in a factory which operates for four or five years and then suddenly closes down either partially or wholly, thus throwing him on the scrap heap. Many of these men may have married while others may be too old to go to anything else. No matter how great the pressure from members of his Party or indeed from this side of the House, the Minister should ensure that too many factories manufacturing the same type of article are not erected. There is one particular industry that the Minister should know about. I always held, as many people held, that too many factories were allowed to be erected, considering the population— less than 3,000,000. You cannot compel people to buy against their will. That is one of the things which Governments cannot do, and it would be a great pity if they were in a position to do so. I do not think that the present trade recession is due to a disinclination on the part of the people to buy. People are not buying, and there must be some reason for it, but I do not think that they are waiting for lower prices. It is just a thing which could arise in any year under any Government. The Minister should not allow the erection of too many factories manufacturing articles for which there is not sufficient consumption, considering our population and the position of a great part of our people. I refer to agricultural labourers and small farmers who just cannot purchase these goods at the prices which prevail at the moment.
Comment on this
I listened very attentively to the Minister introducing his annual Estimate in his usual forceful and informative way, proving to all of us—as I was glad to recognise—that he is fully restored to his usual good health and vigour after his recent illness.
I cannot understand why the Minister, with his background and outlook, should even share responsibility for the drastic reduction in the food subsidies, realising, as he must as Minister for Industry and Commerce over a long period, that this will have a revolutionary effect, not alone upon the national economy but upon the standard of living of all classes who live by their labour or rely on small State allowances as their only means of sustenance. I cannot follow, especially in view of the very definite pronouncements and pledges solemnly given to the citizens of the State during the previous year, his reasons for taking any responsibility for such a reversal of the policy of the Fianna Fáil-Cowan Government. It is a rather significant thing that the Government's decision to reduce food subsidies by 75 per cent. followed the British Government's decision to do likewise, almost to the same extent but, I am sure, for different reasons.
What explanation has the Minister to give to the people for such a complete reversal of policy in view of the public pledges solemnly given on the 29th May, 1951, in the public Press by way of costly advertisements paid for by the present Government to the effect that they had no intention either to interfere with or to reduce the food subsidies? Does not the Minister know —some of his colleagues may not know as they would not have the same association with working-class people as he has through the agency of his Department—that unless some political miracle happens this will lead to industrial unrest the extent of which I cannot foresee and I am pretty certain the Minister cannot foresee?
Deputy Blowick said that if the cost of living had been going down or if the subsidies had been gradually reduced there might be, so far as he was concerned, some explanation for the adoption of a policy of this kind. I certainly cannot understand, and I am sure the people of the country, especially those who are wage earners, cannot understand why the subsidies should be reduced at a time when the cost of living is actually going up. In my opinion, this will be a very costly saving for the country and for the community, if there is any such thing as a costly saving so far as Government administration is concerned.
In his lengthy statement, the Minister made merely passing references to many matters of major importance and I can only hope that in the light of the discussion that has taken place during the last two days he will make his own position and the position of his Government a good deal more clear when he comes to reply. I suppose he holds the view that is held by other colleagues of his, that there is no such thing as restriction of credit. No Deputy who is in touch with his constituency can swallow the statement that there has been no restriction of credit. A Deputy of this House, who is a good businessman, a solvent man and an honourable man and whose family has had very extensive dealings with the same bank for two generations, showed me a scathing letter quite recently which he had received from his bank for overdrawing his account by less than £100.
If I were that Deputy, I would have taken my account from that bank right away and left the bank manager to explain to his directors why such a document should be sent to an honourable, decent and good businessman whose father and himself had been working for the bank as unpaid servants for two generations.
I am not talking from hearsay on this matter. I speak with knowledge of what has been going on with regard to restriction of credit in my own constituency. The traders in that constituency and in the adjoining constituency were forced to establish a trade organisation for the purpose of dealing with the banks in connection with this matter. That is known to the Minister, and it is certainly known to many Deputies sitting behind him on the Fianna Fáil Benches. I assert here quite definitely—I do not care who contradicts it—that the restriction of credit has caused a good deal of unemployment in this country since the mad Minister for Finance made his famous speech on the 18th July last year. I would not dream of associating the Minister for Industry and Commerce, so far as his political outlook is concerned, so far as his ability or political honesty, if there is any such thing, is concerned, with his colleague, the mad Minister for Finance. He is a mad Minister. He is the man who, at a big meeting at the O'Connell Monument in Limerick recently, said the position was so bad that we would be eating carrion crows before Christmas, and that it was possible that the £ will be only worth a shilling in the Shannon Airport. He is not fit to be in the Cabinet.
Comment on this
Statements made by Ministers on matters of economic policy should have some bearing on the Vote under discussion. I am not blaming the Minister for Industry and Commerce for everything said by his colleague.
Comment on this
The Minister may be blamed for everything now because it is his Vote which is under consideration.
Comment on this
I do not propose to go that far. The Minister did not, except in a very passing way, deal with the question of unemployment or the extent to which unemployment has taken place or has decreased since the Government came into office. Will he do so in his reply in a more detailed way and give his reasons, at any rate, for the increased unemployment which has taken place? He referred in a passing way to the recent trade recession so far as it affected the drapery trade and the boot and shoe industry. I have weekly contacts with people who tour this country on behalf of some of the biggest drapery concerns, wholesale and retail, and I am informed by these people who, because of their daily contacts must know more than the Minister and even a little more than his advisers, that there is no improvement in the position so far as the drapery trade is concerned and very little, if any, so far as the boot and shoe industry is concerned. I was reliably informed in the precincts of Leinster House only a couple of hours ago that 50 per cent. of the boot and shoe operatives are still on short time, and the people, as far as we can see, are not going around in bare feet.
The recession in trade, according to the Minister's explanation, is due to the fact that the people are not buying, that they do not want to buy in the expectation that the price of clothes and the price of boots and shoes will go down. My experience of the wage-earning section of the community is that their wages are spent within a week from the day they are paid. That is true, at any rate, so far as the low-paid workers are concerned. The wages of a married man, minus probably 10 per cent., are handed to his wife or housekeeper and that money goes into circulation for the benefit of the community within a week from the day she gets it. With the reduction of the food subsidies the position will be changed in the most revolutionary way. That will be fully realised, as I have pointed out at public meetings in my constituency and elsewhere, when the women have to pay a higher price for these foodstuffs.
Let us take one of the wage-earning class who is in receipt of £6 a week. He probably gave £5 10s. 0d. of that to his wife or housekeeper before the subsidies were reduced to buy the essential foodstuffs and clothing and to pay other housekeeping bills and kept 10/- for himself for cigarettes, for beer, to put a bob on a horse, or to pay a shilling to go into a football or a hurling match on a Sunday.
What is the position now? Will the wife or the housekeeper not have to get more than £5 10s. out of the £6 if she is to purchase the same amount of food or if she is entitled to the same commodities as she has been in the habit of getting for £5 10s. heretofore? Will the old man who earns the money not have to get a little bit more than 10/-, if he is to get the same quantity of cigarettes or tobacco or the same number of bottles of stout or pints of beer as he formerly got when he was spending 10/- out of the £6 on luxury or semi-luxury commodities? That is a revolutionary change, for which, in my opinion, there is no justification. I regard it as political suicide. Deputy McGrath, the Lord Mayor of Cork, claims, of course, that this issue was put to the people at the recent by-elections and that the Government won a victory in these by-elections. The first preference votes of the people who opposed the Budget in the three by-elections were 10,000 more than those given for the Fianna Fáil candidates who stood for the full implementation of this brutal Budget——
Comment on this
In spite of the fact that they got paid in advance and were notified in advance that they would be paid certain allowances. I ask the Lord Mayor of Cork to go around Cork City with his big chain of office towards the end of July and ask the old ladies where they are going to get the money to pay the increased cost of food, and I can assure him he will get a different reception to what he got when he went around telling them what they were going to get before the by-elections.
Comment on this
We are always pleased to hear what Deputy McGrath, the Lord Mayor of Cork, has to say because he is always up to date but he will find out before the end of July or before the end of August where he stands with the people who got the increased allowances which were supposed to be compensation for the increased food prices they will have to pay.
Comment on this
I invite Deputy McGrath to ask his women constituents who are responsible for keeping the home what they think of the alleged compensation they will receive during the month of July, as against the increased amount they will be paying for foodstuffs as a result of the removal of the subsidies and increased taxation.
Comment on this
That is why you rushed the by-elections, lest they would find out what they would have to pay!
Comment on this
I did not know Deputy Corry was listening. I thought he came into the House only when the price of barley was being considered.
Comment on this
The Minister in the course of his speech made the extraordinary statement, based upon some kind of information he has received from 15 manufacturers or traders, that there is no such thing as excessive profit and no justification for the statements of those who allege that manufacturers or a certain type of traders get excessive profits. He went on to explain, that so far as some traders are concerned they get only 4¾ per cent. to 5½ per cent. nett profit. I am not a certified or chartered accountant but I worked in the accounts department of a certain undertaking and had responsibility for making out balance sheets and explaining these balance sheets to auditors and for a certain period I endeavoured to train other people in that kind of work.
I know that every manufacturer and trader sets aside in his balance sheet a certain amount for reserves. One of the most amazing things I discovered from some of the balance sheets of some manufacturers was the big amount they allocated as reserves. I found in the case of one manufacturing concern with a very big nominal capital but with a comparatively small paid-up capital, that by putting so much to reserve year after year for ten years they would have a higher figure as reserve than the paid-up capital of the company. I believe that is not an unusual thing. Is that not a way of hiding profits? If the firms the Minister referred to were carrying on their operations with the goodwill and consent of the Minister in that way, they were hiding their profits.
I see Deputy Briscoe listening to me. We all recognise him as an expert financial adviser to this Government. May I sk Deputy Briscoe is it not a fact that some firms in the City of Dublin, some well-known to himself, have issued bonus shares inside the last couple of years—out of what? Out of the hidden profits they were allowed to put into their balance sheets. Of course, the hidden profits would not be included in the 4¾ per cent. or the 5½ per cent. but they were issued as bonus shares. There are several ways of hiding the profits of firms. I think we would be entitled to know from the Minister, when he comes to reply, the names of the firms concerned so that those of us who are Deputies with the responsibility of criticising, even in a constructive way, the statements of the Minister in a matter of this kind, might have the right to look at the balance sheet of the firm or firms he had in mind to support his argument in this House. In any case he asserted that there was no justification for the allegations made here and outside this House in regard to the excessive profits of certain types of manufacturers and traders. I wonder what was the purpose of making that statement? Was it for the purpose of answering those who assert that, if you have to find increased taxation, some of that should be found by way of re-imposition of the Excess Profits Tax? I do not know why he brought it before the House. He related it to the question of price control and to my amazement proceeded to make a case in favour of the removal of price control. I hope the Minister will not be so silly as to proceed with a proposal of that kind, especially at a time when the food subsidies have been reduced in the drastic manner in which they have been reduced in the recent Budget.
He also referred to the question of the necessity—but he did not emphasise this too fully—for maintaining the policy of his predecessor in regard to reserve stocks. We heard a lot of criticism in this House during the first few months of office of the Fianna FáilCowan Government about using Marshall Aid money for the purpose of building up reserve stocks, at a time when the Minister and everybody sitting behind him, as well as everybody over here, were led to believe that we were on the verge of a third world war. Now, although he did not put it in very enthusiastic or clear language, he is in effect paying tribute to the foresight of his predecessor in this matter. He went on to talk about the position of one or two firms—I suspect I know one of them at any rate—that had according to him, incurred heavy losses by carrying out the wishes of his predecessor in regard to the stockpiling of raw materials. One of the firms which he asserts, or re-asserts, lost money as a result of stockpiling during the past two years, in the last balance sheet published shows an increased dividend to its shareholders and an increased allocation to the reserve fund of the company. That is one of the companies that, I know, will be able to show at the end of ten years' working a reserve fund equal to the paid up capital of the company. How can that company go to the Minister's Department and assert that it lost money, due, as is alleged, to the Minister's predecessor urging it to stockpile and build up reserves? How can it assert or reassert, if its balance sheet shows that it paid an increased dividend to its shareholders at the last annual meeting, that it lost money? I want to warn the Minister to be a little bit more careful before he commits the taxpayers to any compensation in the case of a firm of that kind.
The Minister also referred to the Industrial Development Authority, and more or less paid them a left-handed kind of compliment for the work they have been doing since he became Minister. We know what he said about that particular body when it was established by his predecessor under the previous Government. I was glad, however, to hear him go on record paying a tribute to the work carried out by this authority since it was established. He did say, of course, that its main function was neglected. I take it that when he referred to its main function he meant that from the beginning its work should have been devoted to the discovery of new industries. He suggested that too much of the members' time had been taken up on the administrative side. I am not sure that that is correct, but, at any rate, it is a good thing to learn from a present Minister that time has proved to him that the decision of his predecessor and of the inter-Party Government was justified by the establishment of this Industrial Development Authority.
I should like the Minister, and those who are his advisers in matters of this kind, to go a little bit further. The case was made in the House by Deputies from all sides in the past that the Industrial Development Authority should be closely associated with, if not merged with, the Industrial Credit Company. The recent appointment of the Chairman of the Industrial Development Authority to the position of Chairman of the Industrial Credit Company is a pointer in that direction. I welcome the policy that is behind that. I think there must be a certain amount of waste in members of the Industrial Development Authority devoting a considerable portion of their time to the framing or formulating of proposals for the establishment of new industries and then finding, at the end of their labours, that the necessary capital is not forthcoming for the very desirable purposes in view. I would encourage the Minister and everybody concerned to go ahead with the proposals for bringing about a merger between the Industrial Development Authority and the Industrial Credit Company. If that were done, it would, I think, serve a very useful purpose. It would avoid duplication and a waste of time so far as time is devoted by well-paid officers to the formulation of proposals for the establishment of new industries.
I was glad to hear from the Minister that the Industrial Development Authority had, since he became Minister, succeeded so far as to secure sanction for the establishment of five new industries. The Minister indicated that there were eleven schemes under active consideration for the establishment, I presume, of eleven more new industries. I hope that, when these new industries come to be placed, the Minister will remember the many statements which he made, going back over a long number of years, in connection with the necessity for the decentralization of industry, and that we are not going to have these five new industries which have been sanctioned, and the other eleven which I hope will come along later, situated in the principal city of the country. I hope they will find their way down to the centre of the country or to some places as far away from Dublin as possible.
The Minister said that he had advised the members of the Industrial Development Authority when formulating proposals for new industries, to provide for, or at least help in due time, to find industries in the country that will manufacture the £21,000,000 worth of the various commodities which we have been importing over a long period. I dare say that very big job will take some considerable time.
I do not want to delay the House unnecessarily in connection with this discussion. I want to bring to the Minister's notice a very serious complaint which could, I believe, be put right by the intervention of his Department. It is in connection with the conditions of employment in a certain firm that recently secured a big contract from the Post Office Department. Tenders were invited some short time ago for supply of 20,000 pairs of boots by the Stores Department of the Post Office. One of the firms that was lucky enough to secure a contract for half the quantity is situated at Emyvale in Co. Monaghan. I am reliably informed, and I want the Minister to have the matter put right without delay, that the firm which secured the contract for the supply of 10,000 pairs of boots is not paying trade union rates to its employees and has refused to do so.
I want the Minister to remember that there is such a thing as a Fair Wages Clause in Government contracts, and to insist, without delay, that the firm which was lucky enough to secure half the contract in this case will do what every other firm in the boot and shoe manufacturing industry is doing, namely, recognise the Fair Wages Clause and pay proper rates of wages to its workers. Otherwise, I think, the contract should be withdrawn from that particular firm. I think the request is a reasonable one. I trust the Minister and his advisers will look into the matter and have it put right within a reasonable time.
Deputy Coburn, Deputy Corish and other Deputies referred to the big amounts which are being allocated for the develpoment of harbours. I would like the Minister to ensure that the harbour authorities which are going to get the benefit of these big grants will give proper rates of wages and fair conditions of service to all their employees. I hope he will make it a condition that the members of those harbour authorities will do that. There are only a couple of them concerned— Drogheda and Dundalk. I made representations, on a couple of occasions recently, to the Minister's Department in connection with the conditions of a small section of the employees of the Dundalk Harbour Board—the members of the pilot service. They are engaged in a very dangerous occupation. I am sure the Minister has read the file and the nature of the complaint which has been verified, and that he would not, too willingly at any rate, approve of these conditions. I would ask him to make the necessary representations to the Dundalk Harbour Board to ensure that the pilots employed on that kind of dangerous work in the service of that harbour board are given reasonable Christian rates of wages and conditions of service. I leave the matter at that in the hope that the Minister will get his advisers to put the screw upon the people concerned. I listened to some of these people during the course of an interview in the Department of Industry and Commerce over a year ago. From their attitude on that particular occasion, they appeared to me the type of people whose outlook on the wages and conditions of those employed in the service of their board was the old Victorian outlook. If the members of the harbour board are not changed by the decent people of Dundalk, and whoever appoints them, then I hope that their attitude towards their workers and servants will be changed by the intervention of the Minister. I am sure he will agree to do so if he reads some of the complaints that have been sent to his Department in that matter.
Comment on this
I am glad that Deputy Byrne, who was with me at that interview in the Department, reminds me of that. On the few occasions on which I had reason, with others, to approach the Minister's officials, I always found them very helpful on matters of that kind.
The Minister, naturally, referred to the position of Córas Iompair Éireann. He said that it continues to deteriorate. The history of Córas Iompair Eireann and of its predecessors since this State was established is not a very happy one. Previous to my coming into this House there was a railway dispute. The late Mr. Justice O'Connor, with others, was appointed by Mr. Joseph McGrath, when he was head of the Department of Industry and Commerce, to inquire into and report on the position of Irish Railways, as they were known then, and their future, and to make recommendations in connection with these matters. As the Minister is aware, the report favoured the nationalisation of the railways. That recommendation had been made by previous commissions appointed by the British House of Commons, going back over a very long period. The next step was the amalgamation of these railways by the Government of which Deputy McGilligan was then a Minister. Deputy McGilligan and his colleagues refused to accept the report and recommendations of the O'Connor Commission. There was an amalgamation scheme under private ownership and with as little State interference as could possibly be justified under the circumstances of the time. That amalgamation scheme had a fairly long lease of life. Then we come along to 1932-33 when we had the unification under private ownership. That also was a failure from a financial point of view and from the point of view of providing an efficient service for the trading and travelling public. Before the time that the Fianna Fáil Party induced myself and six fellow-sinners, as we were then called, to put Fianna Fáil into office, they promised that they would nationalise the transport services of this country. The Minister completely forgot all about that matter and a year after his appointment as Minister for Industry and Commerce he brought in the unification scheme. The next step was taken in 1943-44. From a financial point of view, in particular, the position was very precarious at that time. The Minister will remember the vote in this House which led to a general election on the matter. Some of us survived that general election and came back to this House. We cannot forget the cause of that general election, the issues that were fought during it and what happened after it. When the final stages of the 1944 Bill were going through this House I remember the Minister standing up and sticking out his chest in his usual forceful way and saying—I take it that he will take my word for this, that he will not ask me to quote exactly what he said on that occasion and that he will not deny what I am going to say now—that he was certain that he was giving to the trading and the travelling public, and to the community as a whole, an efficient and cheaper railway and transport system with better conditions for the workers employed therein. That was the gist of what the Minister said on that occasion. After all the trouble which we had in this House and in the country following a general election which was caused as a result——
Comment on this
He said that it would be an efficient service with better conditions for the employees and that it would be cheap to the public.
Comment on this
I did not think the Minister would deny it. I assure him that I will take advantage of another opportunity to read every word of what he said on that occasion. I am giving a fair and honest-to-God summary of what I believe he said.
Comment on this
The scheme visualised at the time by the Minister was unification under private ownership. It had nothing to do with nationalisation: they could not touch or look at it. The Minister said that that scheme would solve the railway and transport problem from the point of view of the community and that it would involve no imposition on the taxpayers. Then, under his predecessor, we have the scheme of nationalisation. It was not violently opposed in this House. That scheme, too, was brought into operation because of financial difficulties. The Minister will not deny that. During those discussions it was pointed out not alone by your humble servant but by many Deputies belonging to different Parties in this House that one of their objections to the scheme of unification or nationalisation that followed on the failure of the unification scheme was that unless there was a complete and efficient guaranteed service between rail and road, no scheme either of unification or nationalisation could be a success.
Did Deputy McGilligan, or the Minister himself, or anybody who was in this House at that time, and who is here now, and who supported unification or nationalisation, ever dream that either one scheme or the other would tolerate a keen competition between the rail and the road sections of the same system? Is that not what is going on? The keenest possible competition is going on. My colleague on these Labour Benches, Deputy M.P. Murphy, gave an instance of that yesterday. On numerous occasions Deputy Corry has described what is going on between Cobh and Cork. Is it not going on in every section of the system? Is one section not competing against another? No company under private ownership, unification or nationalisation could survive that. Is it not the fault of the Minister and, to a certain extent, the fault of his predecessor in office, that policy decisions which may now have to be taken, according to the Minister, were not taken years ago? The Minister has now stated that serious policy decisions would have to be taken very soon. Why were these decisions not taken five years ago? Why were they not taken in 1944? Why were they not taken earlier and so avoid all this wasteful competition between two sections of the same system?
Comment on this
Deputy Corry can confirm that the executive of this nationalised system, as before it the unified system, is overloaded with a number of highly-paid accountants— accountants who have no practical experience or training in relation to this technical transport system or service.
Comment on this
The charges should be addressed to the Minister for Industry and Commerce who is responsible to this House, not made against any officials.
Comment on this
I said before and I repeat, because it is a fact, that the executive of this company is overloaded with a number of highly-paid accountants who have no training or experience in the transport industry. That is one of the causes of the failure. I compliment them on being able to collect anything from £2,000 to £4,5000 for any services they give but I think it is the people with £600 to £1,000 a year who are earning their salaries.
Comment on this
The Deputy is referring to people who have no opportunity here of defending themselves and they can be easily identified from what the Deputy is saying.
Comment on this
There are about a half dozen certified and uncertified accountants in charge of every section of the service.
Comment on this
Surely half a dozen people can be identified? The charge should be made against the Minister for Industry Commerce.
Comment on this
I have said it twice but I have not identified anybody. I have a limited knowledge and experience of railway work over a long period of years. What is much more important I have been a railway spokesman for at least 35 years for the clerical and administrative side of the railway services in this country, and you can get more reliable information through that channel than even you could get if you were doing the work from day to day. I have the double advantage. It is a public scandal to allow to go on any longer the competition that has been going on for so many years under this Minister for a short time now and under his predecessor as well. I am not going to absolve the Minister's predecessor from his share of the responsibility for what is going on. He knew as well as the present Minister knows it. I expect it is quite deliberate. What you want at the head of Coras Iompair Eireann is a small number of men strong enough, courageous enough and wise enough to be able to take decisions and, what is more important, to see that they are carried out.
Take the bus service in the city of Dublin. It is a public scandal. Deputy Briscoe will know something about this and he can say whether he does or not if he speaks afterwards. We have the public complaining in the Evening Mail and in other daily papers about the shortage of essential bus services in certain routes in the city area. On the other hand, we have an excess of bus services running parallel to the railway company's permanent way from Dalkey to Dublin. We had a costly kind of advertisement issued recently. I cannot tell you what the cost of it was but it looks lovely anyway. At the bus depots in Dalkey, Dún Laoghaire and Blackrock what do you think they were advertising? They were advertising an hourly service to and from these points for the railway and they have a two and three minute bus service. That is pinching the passengers from the railway in that railway company's premises.
The chief accountant of the railway writes up to the stationmaster periodically in very excited language and he asks him to furnish particulars and information as to what is the cause of the catastrophic drop in revenue by the railway on the Dalkey, Dún Laoghaire, Blackrock to Dublin route. Of course, he knows perfectly well. He should not be wasting time writing these letters. He knows perfectly well it is the intensive competition carried on by the bus service owned by the same company and for which a subsidy has to be paid by the taxpayer. Is there anybody in this House who will get up and defend that? The Minister or his predecesor should have given a policy instruction on this. They were afraid, for political reasons, to do it. If the Minister is not afraid to do it let him do it now and he will stop the rot. He will save the men.
Is it not a fact that the Minister is going to meet trade union leaders to-morrow? I understand the Minister has invited the railway trade union leaders to meet him to-morrow to give them bad news, but before he meets them hundreds of railway men have their dismissal notices in their pockets as a result of this chaotic, cut-throat competition between one section of the service and another. If the services were properly co-ordinated there would be no necessity for these men to have their dismissal notices in their pockets. The Minister's predecessor gave an undertaking, and carried it out, that there would be no dismissals arising out of redundancy following the coming into operation of the nationalisation scheme. The present Minister should have honoured that and should have stopped the company, pending the consultations with the trade union leaders, from issuing these dismissal notices to hundreds of men all over the country. Is not the Minister going to meet the railway trade union leaders in a nice kind of atmosphere, with the knowledge that hundreds of the company's employees who have given long and faithful service to the railway company have these dismissal notices about to come into operation at the end of this week?
That is not the atmosphere in which the Minister should meet them. I do not want to be anything else but helpful to the Minister in this connection. This great Córas Iompair Éireann, with its 20,000 odd employees, belongs to all the people of this country, not to the Fianna Fáil Party, to the Government, to Deputy Cowan, who runs the Government, to the Opposition or to any other section of the House. I want to say this to every responsible Deputy sitting on any side of this House that I want to see this company saved for the nation and for the sake of the good, well-paid employment it has given to the 20,000 odd employees.
I believe that if Deputy Morrissey was still in charge of the Department of Industry and Commerce he would not allow these dismissal notices to be sent out previous to a conference that would be called for the purpose of putting things right inside the company. I do not believe he would be allowed to do it if he were still a Minister of the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, gave an honourable undertaking, and that was carried out during his term of office when he was in charge of the Department of Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
Do you hear Deputy McGrath? Although he knows that some of his own constituents have their dismissal notices in their pockets and he was lobbying in Leinster House trying to get the Minister to receive a deputation because the Minister, according to him, had some responsibility for issuing these dismissal notices. Will you deny that? Get up and deny it.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation. The Deputy did not lead any deputation to meet the Minister. The Deputy obliged Deputy Keyes by asking the Minister for him to meet the Limerick workers. Deputy McGrath is able to look after the workers in Córas Iompair Eireann and is doing that.
Comment on this
Will Deputy McGrath deny here and now that there are constituents of his with dismissal notice in their pockets?
Comment on this
I will not deny it, but I did not go to the Minister to ask him to receive a deputation; I went to the members of the board appointed by him.
Comment on this
Only for the shouting that was done here in 1943, 1944 and 1945 the situation would not be what it is to-day.
Comment on this
Deputy McGrath has become a bit pale since he became Lord Mayor.
Comment on this
Deputy McGrath used the word "lying" in connection with a statement made by Deputy Davin. Deputy McGrath will withdraw that expression.
Comment on this
The Minister referred to the Transport Tribunal and said that the tribunal was meeting this week, I think, for the purpose of dealing with the branch lines. I have a shrewd suspicion that the position has been allowed to become chaotic because the present Minister and the Government —let him deny this if he can—think that the branch lines should be closed, but the Minister does not want to give that direction because he knows certain political consequences would follow as a result of that. He wants the tribunal to do the job for him.
Comment on this
The Minister and Deputy Cogan and Deputy Captain Cowan and Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll, and all the other Deputies who have put this Government into office and are keeping them there, are responsible. Let the Minister tell us now whether or not he thinks these branch lines should be closed and take the consequences of that decision. A policy decision should have been given on that matter many years ago and if it had been given we would not have now the chaos that exists.
We have uneconomic branch lines because competing services run parallel to them. That cannot last. That cannot go on much longer. These policy decisions must be given without further delay. Will the Minister tell the House his purpose in meeting the leaders of the railway trade unions to-morrow? I suspect he would not meet them if he was going to give the workers an increase in their pay or provide more employment or enable them to make more money to offset the removal of the food subsidies. I suspect he is meeting them to-morrow to ask them to make a human contribution to the chaos that exists, a chaos for which he must take a big share of the responsibility. It is the human element that will suffer as a result of all this.
Did not the Minister by means of his legislation for unification make provision for additional capital for the provision of rolling stock for the railway company set up under the policy of unification and subsequently continued under the policy of nationalisation? What proportion of the capital provided for that purpose has been used up to the present to purchase railway rolling stock? What percentage has been used for the provision of rolling stock imported into the country, rolling stock that uses petrol instead of turf or native coal? Is it not a fact that there has been no progress whatsoever made on the railway side? I suggest that if there was a clear intention and a clear policy on the part of the Minister and his Government, or even on the part of his predecessor, to preserve railway branch lines and main lines a greater effort should have been made with the money provided to make more modern rolling stock available, engines, wagons and passenger coaches. How many new engines were built in the Inchicore works in the Minister's constituency? How many wagons were made? How many new carriages were put into the service of the company since this additional capital was provided for the particular purpose?
Comment on this
Does the Minister know anything about the decrepit engines in the service of the company at the present time? If he does not, would he look for a return of the number of breakdowns in main line trains on recent occasions? Does he not know the cause of that? If he does not, will he now inquire into it?
The railway side has been deliberately allowed to fall into this chaotic condition. The workers will be expected to make a contribution to its recovery. That contribution should not be made by the dismissal of hundreds or thousands of railway and transport workers. I assert that not one man should be paid off from the service of the company until a genuine effort is made to co-ordinate rail and road services. That was the policy of the Minister's predecessor and that was the reason why he gave an undertaking there would be no dismissals as a result of the coming into operation of the scheme of nationalisation, and he honoured that undertaking.
The Minister will consult everyone. Has he consulted the Board of Córas Iompair Éireann? I believe he must have done so because he said here and at a social function in the city prior to that that he had told the directors of this company that the company would have to pay its way. There is only one way in which it can pay its way in the state in which it now is, and that is by the dismissal of hundreds of its workers.
Is there any truth in the statement that some thousands of workers will be affected by the Minister's policy in this matter? The Minister may deny that when he is replying. I hope he will be frank with the railway trade union leaders when he meets them to-morrow. I hope he will not place all the burden upon the railway trade union leaders who are now being consulted when the company is at the point of death and who were not consulted years ago, as they should have been, in connection with the contribution they could make.
Has the Minister received any proposals from the Board of Córas Iompair Éireann? If he has I think he should take the House and the country into his confidence. If policy decisions have to be taken by the Government those decisions will eventually have to be either confirmed or rejected by a majority of this House when they come before us for consideration and decision. If the Government has a policy for the safeguarding of the interests of this huge undertaking, in which so much of the taxpayers' money is invested, let the Minister tell the House and the country what that policy is when he comes to reply to this debate.
Do not go to the railway trade union leaders to-morrow and ask them to make a sacrifice without first putting the company's house in order. If the Minister can provide a better, more efficient, and ultimately cheaper transport system it is desirable and essential that a policy of co-ordination should be put into operation without further delay and a reasonable time given to see whether that policy of co-ordination will result in greater efficiency and a cheaper and better service for the community. I think we could have a better and more efficient system than the one we have now. My idea of a nationalised transport service is not to have bus services running parallel to and in competition with the railways. I believe we should have bus services connecting up with the junctions—Mallow, Limerick Junction, Ballybrophy and all the rest of them— with an inclusive fare by rail and by road. The railway cannot survive as it is carried on at present. The only way in which the position can be improved and a cheaper, more efficient and better service provided, while at the same time maintaining useful employment for 20,000 people, is by having a properly co-ordinated rail and road transport service under the aegis of Córas Iompair Éireann. I hope the Minister will take the House and the country into his confidence by stating what the true position is and the Government's policy in relation to such a very vital matter.
Comment on this
I was glad that Deputy Davin said at 8.45 p.m. that he would be brief and would not detain the House. Towards the end of his speech I got the impression that he was talking his way into becoming the adviser both to Córas Iompair Éireann and to the Government as to how to save and run the railways. I have debated with Deputy Davin for a number of years on this matter from two angles, and it was rather a pity that, on the eve of this meeting, Deputy Davin should have made this statement in the manner in which he made it and should not have left the matter to the meeting to see whether some formula could not be reached by agreement to bring about an improvement in the affairs of Córas Iompair Éireann.
I want to remind Deputy Davin and the House that before the 1932 election, to my knowledge and to Deputy Davin's knowledge, the vast bulk of railway workers, particularly at Inchicore, were on part-time and that the present Minister for Industry and Commerce gave an undertaking that one of the first things he would do as Minister for Industry and Commerce in the Fianna Fáil Government, if it came into office, would be to take in hands the putting in order, as far as possible, of the affairs of the company, so that, in the first instance, full and regular employment would be given to the workers on the railways. I challenge Deputy Davin or any of his colleagues to deny that from the moment of the change of Government in 1932 the building up and the improvement of the railways, as far as the employment of the workers was concerned, took a steady upward curve. That curve remained in that position, with the result that for many years not only did the workers have full employment but a great number of them had overtime as well. That position was held until the outbreak of war, and it was maintained as far as possible, notwithstanding even the post-war situation, the shortage of fuel and so forth.
I think Deputy Davin and the Labour Party ought to be convinced that the workers of the railways are the first persons to recognise that the present Minister for Industry and Commerce has always meant well for the workers in the railway system of Ireland—and they have always shown their appreciation of it. Does Deputy Davin not realise that there is no Labour representative in this Dáil from the Inchicore area, where there are thousands of railway workers? Is it not conclusive proof that the workers concerned place their faith in the present Minister and in the Fianna Fáil Government and they have not changed from that faith? What more do these gentlemen want? What more evidence is needed? Whether it is the Dublin Corporation or this Dáil, the railway workers have shown their support for Fianna Fáil and their faith in Deputy Lemass as Minister for Industry and Commerce.
It is all very well for Deputy Davin to talk about the railway from Bray through Dún Laoghaire to Dublin and buses running in competition with it. Does Deputy Davin not realise—he occasionally travels in that direction— that the public to-day require transport in the City of Dublin other than the facilities available by railway from Dún Laoghaire or Bray? Does he not realise that there has been great progress and that time is an essential factor in the life of most of our people, that a great number of people who work in the city travel from outlying districts and want to be able to get to their homes as quickly as possible and want the convenience of being set down as near as possible to their homes? Surely these buses would not be run in such numbers if there were not passengers for them? I agree with Deputy Davin that there is still a very considerable shortage of buses in Dublin, but he knows that provision was made for a substantial increase in the number of buses available for the public and that they are tied up as the result of certain disputes which are going on. I am making no reference to that in a carping attitude. I am trying to put the real facts before the House—and only for the House, as I know the public will not be fooled if the papers put before them the main contents of Deputy Davin's speech this evening.
There has been a variety of criticism on this Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce, particularly with reference to the policy of the Government and the direction of that policy by the Minister himself. I think the Minister will have to examine his conscience, because, side by side with the criticism, every speaker I listened to threw bouquets at him for his energy, for being the most dynamic person who ever occupied that seat in the Government, and so on. Criticism has been made without any proper realisation of the facts. Is it not admitted that, over a period of years, since the advent of Fianna Fáil as a Government from 1932 onwards, enormous strides were made in the introduction of new industries and the extension of old ones, that avenues were opened for additional employment and for better types of employment for our people?
Comment on this
Has the population increased? That is the acid test?
Comment on this
I want to approach this from a practical point of view—as I understand it and as most people understand it, including those on the other side of the House. Facilities were accorded for the development of industry. There were certain kinds of development—call it industry, if you like, or call it development for the purpose of giving employment—which was not possible under the heading of private enterprise and therefore State aided or State-owned institutions were set up. I have in mind the development of air services, not only in this country but as between this country and abroad. Everybody admits that Aer Lingus—which was nursed in its infancy and nurtured to maturity by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce—is, in fact, a success, and deserves the admiration it gets at home and the admiration it gets from those travelling people abroad.
In further development of such an undertaking, the Fianna Fáil Government inaugurated and put into being the transatlantic air service. That particular service would not only give additional employment in this country of the highest technical type to citizens but it would also have proved to be one of the most important hard currency earning institutions in the State. Deputy Davin bemoans the decline of the railways. He wants to have all bus transport abolished from Dublin to Bray——
Comment on this
——and force the people back on the railways, require them to walk from whatever stations they reach, get other forms of transport and to do that at certain regulated times. Deputy Davin was one of those who stood and supported the annihilation of the transatlantic air development service.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will be successful in giving back that service to the nation. I hope we will soon again see our own planes travelling under our own flag to other parts of the world piloted by Irishmen who are second to none in any part of the world. This service will bring a profit to the nation. It will bring it hard currency. It will help tourism. It will also bring to the nation that added prestige which was lost when the service was not put into operation.
Comment on this
It is very hard to talk reasonably or sensibly to people with a certain type of mentality. The very idea that this country should aspire to being on a par with other countries and to have the same facilities as other countries arouses the spectre of millionaires in Deputy Davin's mind and Maximoes in the mind of the Deputy of the dual purpose hen. That is the mentality that seems to be predominant in this House.
Comment on this
Surely it is not for me to appeal to Irishmen to regard themselves as being without doubt equal to any other people in any other part of the world.
Comment on this
We had some reference to tourism last night by Deputy Collins who painted a very melancholy picture. I am not sure whether it is from East or West Cork he comes.
Comment on this
It was a most melancholy performance, as Deputy Collins, almost with tears in his eyes, spoke about the possible drop in tourism. When we had to fight an election on the eve of 1948, we had to answer the charge that tourist development in this country meant taking the bread out of the people's mouths. To-day this House is converted to tourism and everybody realises that it is one of our greatest invisible exports. If we want it to be maintained in normal times—during abnormal times we can put it on its feet —then, obviously, we must make the fullest possible use of the facilities. I take it that very few millionaires travel on Aer Lingus. I do not think the number of millionaires is so great as to fill our planes each day in their flights backwards and forwards to England and the Continent.
Ordinary people to-day travel in planes. The people who travel in planes to-day are people like the bulk of us here in this House. Millions of people are accustomed to-day to travel by air, particularly in the most progressive nation of the world, the United States of America. Amongst those are people of our own kith and kin. They would have used Irish planes to a great extent in coming home.
Comment on this
The more I listen to Cork Deputies talking in this House, the more I realise that the internal difficulties of Cork are very varied and peculiar.
Comment on this
I will join with the Deputy in using our best influence to get the Minister for Industry and Commerce to try and have established in Cork, as soon as possible, a suitable airport so that planes can land.
Comment on this
I hope that some appreciation is given to the things that are being attempted. Last night, I heard Deputy Collins complaining that the linen industry, which was going to use the flax grown in West Cork, had been established in East Cork. Surely to goodness it was a good sign to see the linen thread industry started somewhere in Cork. It was a new industry which would give security to the flax growers of West Cork. Yet, we found there was criticism because of the place where it was being started.
Another suggestion was made. I heard Deputy Davin refer to it in passing. He hoped that all the proposed new industries would not be mainly centred in Dublin.
Comment on this
In my constituency or any other constituency. I think Deputy Davin has a holy horror of me. In his dreams he finds that every new industry is started in my constituency. In fact, there are very few industries in it. Perhaps, if the Deputy, when he goes to bed, lay on a different side he might see some other horrible person who might frighten him just as much.
Comment on this
Yes, the left side. We recently established a new Department. Of course, it was ridiculed when it was set up. Deputy McGilligan was the first to pour ridicule on it. That Department was established for a serious purpose. A special Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy J. Lynch, was assigned to it. The purpose of the Department was to establish industries in what were described as the undeveloped areas or in what I would call, under normal commercial standards, undevelopable areas. That particular section of the Department is operating. Any new industry set up in the undeveloped areas or in an undeveloped area will also get financial assistance in addition to encouragement and any other form of assistance it may require. Surely that should be sufficient evidence even to the most innocent-minded person in the House that the Government is serious in its attempt to decentralise industry and to bring industries to rural and urban Ireland.
I think it was in 1947—I am not quite sure—but shortly before the change of Government in 1948, the Fianna Fáil Government, through the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, introduced a new development for rural electrification. Apart from the amenities that would bring to the ordinary people in all parts of the country it would make electric power available, and that would no longer be a difficulty to be overcome by potential industrialists in establishing new factories.
All these things, of course, are forgotten. The approach to this Estimate is being made by minds still fresh from the recent by-elections. We are not to-night on the eve of an election, general or otherwise, and we are not trying to get votes.
Comment on this
The great man of courage. I believe that we should try to consider this Estimate with a view to seeing to what extent corrective measures can be brought to bear on things which may not be as good as they should be, to what extent improvements can be made or new suggestions put forward in the hope, as Deputy Davin rightly says, that the people as a whole will benefit irrespective of the political Party they belong to.
The Government must govern in the interests of the whole country. Therefore we should try, particularly with regard to this Estimate, to see that what is being done and what is contemplated shall have as far-reaching effects as possible for the benefit of all.
Comment on this
I am afraid I do not understand the accent. If the Deputy would repeat what he has said I shall be pleased to answer him.
Comment on this
The interests of all, including the seven rate collectors in Galway.
Comment on this
If there is anything wrong, this is the place to air it. I do not know. Deputy Davin carried on a line of argument with regard to industrial concerns that I have heard elsewhere. Would Deputy Davin do me a favour? Before he goes to bed to-night will he take a pencil and paper and do a problem in simple arithmetic which will cure him of one of the peculiar errors he is making in judgment and, as a result, the expressions that he is forced to utter here will cease? He talks about the profits made in certain industries. He talks about balance sheets of certain public companies. He talks about money put to reserve and the consequent issue of bonus shares. He described it as a complete contravention of what is decent and proper and of what is contemplated in price control. I suggest that he should, for instance, take the balance sheet of a well-known company that carries on the manufacture of tyres in Cork—a public company—Dunlops. He should find out what is the net profit made by that company before they put anything to reserve, before they do anything in the shape of bonus shares and before they divide any profits in the shape of dividends to their shareholders.
I would advise him to reduce the amount of pounds, say, £70,000, or so, to pence, by multiplying the pounds by 20 and the shillings by 12, and divide into that number of pence under separate headings the number of items made by that company and discover what amount of profit in farthings or halfpence or pence is contained in each article sold to the public by that company through its various agents. He will find that the individual items sold bear from the point of view of profit an amount so small that if the firm was made to put back into its sale prices by a reduction of price the full amount of net profits it would not reduce to the public the price of the article sold by an amount of any consequence.
I suggest to the Deputy that he should take any return of any public company that manufactures goods or that sells goods to the public and make the same calculation, and then I would like to meet him anywhere he likes within the precincts of this House and hear his expression of astonishment that he did not know that the profit of a company on invested capital, whether it be 10 per cent. or 20 per cent., means so little effectively in regard to the cost of the items sold.
Will Deputy Davin do that or will he prefer to continue in his state of ignorance of the actual facts and to continue, here and elsewhere, that manner of attack against industrialists, although he could easily find out that there is little foundation for his type of approach to the matter?
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy is he aware of the number of thousands of pounds in hidden profits in certain industrial concerns?
Comment on this
Do not agree to that. They may be subscribing to Fianna Fáil. That may be a sore question.
Comment on this
The Minister knows that there are thousands of pounds in hidden profits in certain concerns.
Comment on this
Deputy Blowick, an ex-Minister of State, wants us to believe by his almost crude interjection that it is possible for any industry or any firm to have hidden profits from the Revenue Commissioners and that by having them they are able to give a subscription to some political Party fund unknown to anybody. The Deputy, as an ex-Minister, knows that to be impossible even more than I know it, and I am convinced that it could not happen.
Comment on this
Who is that? My friend, Deputy Giles, the man who wants to go around with the razor, cutting throats?
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that the Revenue Commissioners say that, if all the profits were disclosed, tax would be 2/6 less? That has been given.
Comment on this
No. Deputy Sweetman is talking about people who make profits that are not easily ascertainable, that are not disclosed.
Comment on this
I referred to public companies where there are concealed profits and I said that the Minister must know that these concealed profits are in public companies. Is that fair enough?
Comment on this
I will make a statement which I can stand over. I am certain that the Minister knows what I am talking about.
Comment on this
I do not know whether or not the Deputy has already spoken in this debate. If he has, perhaps, because of the fact that we are in Committee, he may be allowed to speak again. I would suggest to him that he take the earliest opportunity to tell us about these undisclosed profits.
Comment on this
I have spoken in this debate, and I am not going to speak again. However, I will take the earliest opportunity to tell the House about these undisclosed profits.
Comment on this
I was just taking the opportunity to try to educate Deputy Davin. I hope he will continue to remain in the House until 10.30 p.m. and that he will be at school again at 10.30 in the morning. In company with others, the Deputy wants industrial development in this country undertaken by private enterprise. Yet, while wishing to attract people into private enterprise, he stands by with a chopper in his hand ready to knock their blocks off the moment they produce an item of profit for themselves. It must be realised that people will only engage in private enterprise in this country if they get some return for the capital and the ability they have put into it.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin does not thoroughly agree. He wants those who invest their money in an industry and build it up to say: "If we lose a bit the first year, we will put a bit more money into it. If we make a bit the second year, we must not keep it for ourselves, but we must give it out to some other firm."
The person who engages in private enterprise is as entitled to profit as the workman is to his hire or the professional man to his fee, and the sooner Deputy Davin and some of the people to whom he talks get that into their heads the sooner we will get rid of the fear that still attaches to the investment of money in industry in this country.
Comment on this
I am quite willing to give way to Deputy Davin so that he will explain to me how, and to what extent, I misrepresented him.
Comment on this
I was just trying to point out, as a result of listening to Deputy Davin's harangue, what the other side of the picture is. We are desirous of establishing industries in this country. A certain number of Deputies in this House have been hammering very hard on the phrase: "Repatriation of capital for investment at home." The only way Irish-owned capital will be gradually and ultimately fully repatriated for investment at home is when the owners of that capital can feel that they will always be able to get the same return for it as they did when it was invested abroad.
Comment on this
It is true of any individual who has money saved, and who has earned money in sufficient quantities to invest it so as to bring him in an income to protect him and his family in years of tenderness. Such a person will not invest his money in Irish industry unless he is assured and convinced that the earning power of that money will be as secure as it was abroad, and the sooner certain people realise that fact the better. Deputy Hickey does not think that we should pay any interest whatsoever on money.
Comment on this
I know that anybody who has money over and above his requirements and who wishes to augment his ordinary income will not invest it in private enterprise unless he is sure of a good return. If the idea that he should get no return for his investment was universally accepted in this House, instead of having repatriation of capital, whatever capital we have left in the country would fly out of it and the balance of our people after it.
Comment on this
The present Taoiseach had that idea prior to 1947. He proposed to rob the banks in order to keep the country going.
Comment on this
I have asked the Deputy to withdraw the remark he has made to the effect that the Taoiseach has robbed the banks.
Comment on this
I have asked Deputy Coburn to withdraw the remark he made in connection with the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
I do. I deny the statement attributed to me. I certainly did not say that the Taoiseach himself robbed banks.
Comment on this
The Deputy stated that Deputy de Valera, as Taoiseach, suggested in this House that we should rob banks.
Comment on this
I said that the Taoiseach said the money should be taken out of the banks rather than that anybody should be allowed to starve. That statement was made in this House, so that is that.
Comment on this
I am sorry that Deputy Davin has gone from the House, because I had not quite finished my instruction.
Comment on this
I am not trying to do it quite well, but to be as factual as I can. I am sure Deputy Morrissey will not disagree with what I have said.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not surprised that I got some moral support from Deputy Morrissey. I had not finished Deputy Davin's instruction, but I hope he will find it convenient to read the portion of my speech which he will not hear. I, and I am sure other members of the House, study publications with regard to industrial concerns, break-down and analyse the figures. When Deputies criticise the people who are responsible for building up an industry, for running it and so forth, they should examine the profit element—"the loot" element, as some people call it—and they will find that, compared with the cost of raw materials, the wages bill, etc., it is the smallest item. In some cases, depending on the particular industry, it will be found that profit only comes to a fraction of a percentage, perhaps I should say a percentage of a percentage. We want to give, in our industries, good employment and a reasonable standard of living to the workers. It was the Fianna Fáil Government that introduced the legislation controlling conditions of employment.
Comment on this
The Conditions of Employment Act is regarded by people in this country and by many people abroad who study what is known as social legislation as a great step forward in the interests of the workers.
Comment on this
It was the Fianna Fáil Government that introduced holidays with pay for industrial workers—again a great step forward. It was, in fact, an advance greater than even the trade unions of those days looked for, because it was never demanded.
Comment on this
That Deputy on the front bench has apparently got his perspective wrong. He says that we followed suit, but the Deputy will find that this was the first country to introduce that type of social legislation. I think it was Deputy Morrissey who pointed out at some international affair that this country led in social legislation, so far as industrial workers are concerned.
Comment on this
I am talking of conditions of employment. I am talking of the standard which the Fianna Fáil Government wished to accord to the worker in industry.
Comment on this
The only workers I know of with 45/- per week were Deputy Blowick's forestry workers.
Comment on this
We come now to another type of industry, the industry which for a variety of reasons it is not possible for private enterprise to undertake. I referred before to Aer Linte and the Turf Board as instances of what I have in mind. It was not possible for private enterprise to develop our turf resources and consequently it became the responsibility of the Government to help in making available to the people a natural fuel, with a consequent saving in the national economy and other matters incidental thereto. We have the Minerals Development Body and we have the establishment and extension of the cement factories. Last year, I criticised the then Government's failure to develop further the cement industry. That is now being done and within a short space of time we shall have reached a position in which all our cement requirements will be produced at home.
Comment on this
It is really painful to hear such comments. The Deputy says we were exporting it after the war, but he does not say why. Maybe the Deputy does not know why.
Comment on this
I do not know that it is reasonable that interjections of such an ignorant nature should be made, interjections which seek to ignore the facts, one after the other. It is true that, when the war ended and during the war, we had not sufficient materials to build houses for our people. It is true that we had a surplus of cement. I suppose the Deputy would have regarded it as good economics because we could not build houses, due to a shortage of other materials, to close down the cement factories and discard all the people employed there until such time as materials became available again. That is the mentality of the Deputy from County Dublin and I can understand it, coming from the man who invented the dual purpose hen. The State has made very extensive moves for the purpose of creating either State-aided or State-owned industries in a variety of ways.
It has been suggested that there should be a fusion of the Industrial Development Authority and the Industrial Credit Corporation. Deputy Davin thought that, if these two bodies were fused, we would have industry established and financed automatically. I do not think that even Deputy Morrissey, from his own experience of the situation, would subscribe to that proposal. It is far better to have the Industrial Development Authority as it is, limited to certain types of activities, putting propositions up to the Government for acceptance or rejection. When acceptance does take place, it becomes the responsibility of the Government to see how best the particular proposition can be financed and where the industry should be situated.
One of these bodies is supposed to be expert in financing certain types of commercial undertakings — private enterprise undertakings and not State industries—and the other is concerned solely with ascertaining whether a particular industry could be started here. The matter of the financing of the industry is a different problem which must be examined by those competent to do so as distinct from the other approach, the need for the industry. It must be obvious to anybody in the House that if we allowed the Industrial Credit Corporation or any other such financial institution to be the sole judge of the establishment of an industry, a great many industries would not be established because that body would see in advance that they would never be economic and would always have to have some form of subsidy. The Government in the past has subscribed to the idea and has pursued the policy that where something is of national importance, even if it does require a State subsidy, it shall be established. It may be a matter of labour content or a matter of the national economy, or a combination of both, but the fact is that there must be a different approach, in coming to a decision, from the approach to the purely financial aspect.