Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill, 1952—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–134 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1952 ›
When I was speaking earlier to-day I referred to the considerable increase in the number of unemployed since the advent of this Government. In the industrial analysis supplied to all Deputies, 596 of these unemployed men are classified as general building, construction and repair workers, and the reason given for their being unemployed is "slackness in building and allied trades". Every Deputy must be well aware of this retrogression and of the reasons for it. It is a definite result of the restriction in credit, following the speeches made by leading members of the Government shortly after their taking office. The House will recall that, in connection with the inter-Party Government's extensive housebuilding operations, at no time was finance the limiting factor. The only hold-up was caused by the fact that there was not sufficient skilled labour available to do the work.
We can also recall that when we were encouraging our young men, who had previously emigrated to Britain, to come home again and engage on this work, they were told by our opponents that it would hardly be advisable for them to do so. However, they came home in great numbers and found employment here. The building trade also absorbed many lads who otherwise would be unemployed. I have in mind a family from my own town who were known for many miles away as excellent wheelwrights and where the trade had been handed down for generations. The father died leaving a young family. The eldest boy came to Dublin and got immediate employment as a carpenter. I met him again on the day of the North-West Dublin by-election. He was poorly clad and showing obvious signs of distress. When I asked what had happened, he said he had been tramping to the labour exchange for the last six months but had given up hope. He went out that night on the boat to England. He told me there were many others like him who were throwing in the sponge as they could not see any possibility of re-employment in the building industry in the near future. He had also noted that we had exported timber very shortly before that, that we had sent out supplies which some years ago we were so anxious to obtain for housebuilding.
It was certainly a sad experience for me — I am not speaking in the political sense — as it would be for any rural Deputy, when brought for the first time into close knowledge of the present conditions, where people are dwelling in very close confinement in houses completely unfit to give even normal accommodation to a reasonable-sized family. In our travelling around in East Cabra, we came across some pitiful cases. There was one of 14 adults and three children sleeping in three rooms. I did not think such conditions existed in this country. How can the Government be complacent in such circumstances? We know that very good work has been done, but we should not spare any effort in ensuring that by making the money available the skilled men will be retained to provide reasonable accommodation in the shortest possible time. It is, therefore, with considerable disquiet that people now look to the future.
We have had the conditions clearly put before the people in one constituency and they have answered in no uncertain fashion. I think one member of the Government commented on the fact that they looked now to the rural areas to try to make up for the very grave losses in a Dublin constituency. I would remind that Deputy that it was only in the cities that Fianna Fáil made any showing at the last general election, and the reason was obvious — they went out on a policy of criticism of the few points increase in the cost of living which had taken place, as we are told now by this Government, as a result of the breaking out of hostilities in Korea. Not a single member of the present Government, not a single Deputy opposite, would admit at that time that that was so. Those hostilities resulted in very much increased shipping charges, and we were affected to a considerable extent while, on the other hand, the increases we might have expected for commodities we had to sell had not time to take effect.
In my constituency industry is not a very important factor as it is principally agricultural, yet I see in the statistical report that there were 595 unemployed there on the 30th August last. That is very far from reassuring. We should also note that some 5,000 men have been absorbed into the Defence Forces since the advent of this Government. Many of those would now be on the unemployed list if they had not been recruited into the Army. Is it something to be proud of that in the unemployment analysis it is to be seen that there are 217 more unemployed discharged members of the Defence Forces to-day than there were when the present Government attained office? We cannot give any encouragement to their colleagues, now driving hackney cars or acting as lorry drivers — quite a number have been absorbed into the motor industry — that in the foreseeable future they will not lose their employment.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Government spoke quite candidly to-day of the concern it was occasioning him that in the City of Cork where a considerable number are employed in that very important industry, many have been laid off work. He contended that the increase now being effected in motor taxation could not be responsible for that. At Question Time to-day we were informed that the cost of tyres, petrol, oil, servicing of motor vehicles has risen by 28 per cent. since the advent of the Fianna Fáil Government this time. Surely that was enough of an impost, without saddling hackney owners and others, in cities and small towns, with this new threat to the employment which they have enjoyed heretofore. When Fianna Fáil got back into office they made some very strong appeals to the people of the country to increase production but they made no effort whatever to ensure that the cost of production would even be kept stable not to speak of being reduced. We can point to considerable increases in production costs in practically all spheres of activity in this country. In this connection, I refer in particular to the increased costs which the agricultural community now have to bear.
When the agricultural community answer the call and produce more they are then informed by the Minister that although costs are increasing the price obtaining for the commodities they produce is reduced. He points out that production has increased and that that is responsible for the reduction in the price they obtain for the finished product.
I regard that as being discouraging for production. Having answered the call, they are then mulcted for having done the duty which they were told was an obligation on them to do. Consequently, there is a growing feeling among producers that they must get some long-term guarantee and some assurance so far as it is in the power of the authorities to do so that increased production will not mean to them a lesser return on investment and on the work which they put into their efforts.
No matter how the Government may seek to gild the lily in an endeavour to prove that the picture is not really a black one, unemployment figures and emigration figures prove the contrary. When we are on our way to the Dáil and halt at Limerick Junction, we find dozens of young men and girls in the prime of life on their way to Great Britain seeking work denied to them at home. We cannot be complacent in view of these circumstances.
The people who are in employment have no guarantee that that employment will continue. Every section of the community is mulcted by the increased cost of living which shows no sign whatever of being stabilised even at its present level. Clothing has again increased in price during recent weeks in spite of statements made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce — and accepted by us— that he did not foresee an increase in the price of clothing in the near future. That, however, is occurring and, as other speakers have pointed out, there is a recession in trade. If firms are not actually leaving off staff at this time of the year, they are not recruiting the additional staff for the Christmas rush which they did in recent years. All that would indicate that the raid made upon the people's pockets and the housewives' purses in the last Budget has been so effective that the people now have not the wherewithal to meet the normal requirements of life.
We indicated earlier the 20 point increase that occurred in the cost of living but when the present Government were in opposition they took great pains to indicate that there were many items excluded in arriving at that index figure which should have been borne in mind, items such as the simple luxuries which the normal working man enjoys, the cigarette, the pint of stout. It was in regard to these that the present Government made the most severe attack on the working classes.
The House will recall that when they introduced their Supplementary Budget in October, 1947, the Government stated at that time that it was necessary so that they could meet their commitments in relation to the food subsidies. This year, by one fell blow, food subsidies were reduced and practically abolished and an increased tax far in excess of what was imposed in 1947 was put on the people.
Some Deputies may claim that the people could well do without these luxuries, the tax upon which was designed, we were told by the Minister for Finance, not to effect a reduction in our consumption, but to bring more money into the Exchequer. We now have a clear statement on the authority of that Minister that there were defects in the Budget. That statement was made when certain sections asked for increased pay to meet the increase in the cost of living.
That brings me back again to the point that some items which were taxed extremely heavily in that Budget were not in effect luxuries. Deputy Vivion de Valera, speaking at a rally in County Clare, as reported in the Irish Press of 5th January, 1948, said:—
"I know in the case of the pint that it is a very welcome addition to those who have to depend on a cold lunch and that the pint of stout is almost as much a necessity as the other. I can assure you that nobody regretted more than we did that there was no way in which we could get the amount required except by the particular device adopted."
There was surely an implication there that there was regret at having imposed these taxes at that time and also an admission that the money which it was expected to get from these taxes was not forthcoming. Surely his listeners at that rally in County Clare must have believed that the Government had mended its ways? At least, the Fianna Fáil Party was the Government when these taxes were imposed.
The people in the constituency of the Minister for Finance were assured at the last election that the charges made by the people on this side of the House that if Fianna Fáil got back into office the food subsidies would go were not correct. The people who have now slashed the food subsidies are those who have been in office for the past one and a half years. During the present Government's term of office we have had an increase in the number of unemployed. This increase is more than disturbing. There is the increased cost of living, an increase, may I remark, which started long before the subsidies were abolished. These increases, we are now told, are attributable to factors outside our control.
Who outside this country asked the Minister for Finance to abolish the food subsidies? Was not the retention of the food subsidies the subject matter of item 15 in the proclamation which was made in this Dáil when it met the first night, and which was submitted to the Independent Deputies who voted Fianna Fáil into office?
Comment on this
I have not much experience in this House and I am guided principally by having read up previous debates on Supplies and Services. In 1950 I could not find in Opposition statements a single strong reference beyond a continual wail about the cost of living and unemployment. That is why I refer to the matter now. It has always been the case that estimating the numbers of unemployed, the numbers emigrating and the cost of living gave the clearest indication as to whether a Government was pursuing a policy which was in the best interests of the country.
In explaining these views on this matter we are not merely expressing our own views, but the views of our executives, the views of our branches, and those of the people we meet when we journey home at the week-end. To-day there is a concerted clamour throughout the country by the people for an immediate chance to record their complete disapproval of the present policy of the Government.
It is their desire that a general election be held at the earliest possible date to give the people who had not the opportunity which the people in North-West Dublin had of uniting to give this country a Government which will provide for the people employment and a standard of living which will not attract the attentions of a Minister for Finance such as has occurred this year, in the form of a raid on their pockets so that they would not live too well. They cannot see any progress being made while the present Government remains in office. They see them at sixes and sevens and doing things for which they secured no mandate and which they gave no indication of their intention of doing, if they were returned to power.
We feel that it is desirable now that the people who elected the Deputies who voted this Government into office—not members of the Government Party, but Deputies who were elected on inter-Party tickets and who did that in opposition to the wishes of their electors—and the people who elected Fianna Fáil to reduce the cost of living, to reduce unemployment and to make the country so prosperous, should now get the opportunity which the people of North-West Dublin got and used so effectively.
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that the Fianna Fáil vote showed a considerable decrease in the three by-elections, that the inter-Party vote considerably increased; and that the transfer of votes in subsequent counts in the four elections would indicate a continuation of the inter-Party co-operative spirit; and that it is the intention of the people, given the opportunity, in all the other constituencies to do as the people did in the four by-elections and give the country again a Government led by Deputy John Costello which for three and a half years brought prosperity and peace to the country.
Comment on this
I am satisfied that since they came into power again, Fianna Fáil are a sadder and a wiser Party. For three long years, they carried on an unrelenting attack on the inter-Party Government. Everything they did was wrong, according to Fianna Fáil, and they stooped to the lowest tricks to bring about the downfall of that Government. They are now the Government again and we see changed times. We see more unrest than we saw perhaps in the past ten years, chiefly caused by the removal of the subsidies at such short notice. Bank restrictions were ordered by the Government, which brought about building restrictions. On top of that, motor taxation was increased and work under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, which was giving so much employment, has slowed up and almost closed down.
The land reclamation scheme which ought to be in full blast and publicised in every paper, national and local, has almost dried up also and we find a recession of trade, with unemployment piling up. We see men leaving the country and the building trade which was booming for a number of years has now practically stopped. We see the men who were indispensable, so far as the building trade is concerned, leaving the country, perhaps never to come back. In addition, we have had a year of strikes and unrest, a year in which the cost of living has soared and emigration and unemployment have been rife. Our middle-class people are denied under this Government the right to build their own homes.
So far as my own county is concerned, I see a trend within agriculture which I do not like at all — the farmers, in view of the cost of the commodities they have to buy to carry on their farming, are now engaged in sowing grass seed almost to their hall doors, because they feel there is no other hope for them. That is a sorry spectacle after a year or two of Fianna Fáil's return to power and they must feel ashamed of themselves. They told us that if the inter-Party Government were thrown out, there would be peace and plenty and work for all, if they were given the chance. Fianna Fáil have had their chance over a long number of years. I read in to-day's papers that the Taoiseach expects to be coming home next week — I hope, restored to full health and vigour. What is the picture which the Minister must present to him? It will not be one to make him happy but one which will make him realise that things have gone to the dogs since he went away.
Fianna Fáil are allowing trouble and unrest to develop throughout the country. In my town of Navan, over many months, I saw a long and bitter strike in the furniture trade. There were 600 or 800 men out on strike, fighting for a higher wage, and some of the big magnates who are strongest in the furniture trade in that area were quite happy about that strike, gloating that it would go on and that the final result might be that the smaller interests in the furniture trade would be squeezed out and one or two of them would control the furniture industry in the town. That was the picture: on one side, men crying for increased wages and, on the other, men carrying on big business delighted that the strike was continuing because it would squeeze out the small man. I am happy to say that the strike has been settled, but I am not so happy in the thought that these people who, for eight or ten long weeks, went through a hard and cruel time were left to fend for themselves and that the Government were not in the least worried.
These men in the furniture business who are earning £5 and £6 a week found that the cost of living was bearing so heavily on them that they had to demand increased wages, while in the country our agricultural workers are trying to live on half that wage. What must be the position of these people in the rural areas? Certainly there is distress and misery in almost all the homes of the agricultural workers and they never found things so tight. Many of them are now seeking home assistance and others are seeking increased benefits at the labour exchange. There is a complete wave of unrest throughout the country and I ask the Government to make some effort to right matters or to declare a general election and make way for some Government that will try to clean up the mess. The present position is certainly one of the most deplorable we have had over a long period. There is not the slightest excuse for it, because there should be full and plenty here and there should be work for all our people at a reasonable wage provided the Government adopts proper business methods. Instead of that they are devising all kinds of plans and practices to show that the inter-Party Government was a failure and that is why Fianna Fáil find themselves in the position in which they are to-day.
They should have taken over where the inter-Party Government left off. They should have ensured the continuation of the excellent schemes initiated by that Government, such as the Local Authorities (Works) Act. They should have continued the operation of that Act until such time as all the poor land and the bogs were drained in order to give the farmer more land and better land. They have made every effort to put down the "Dillon" scheme. If the land reclamation project was put into full operation the farmers would have thousands of acres of land, but the Government is making no effort to put the necessary drive into that scheme. A sum of £40,000,000 was earmarked for that scheme, to be spent at the rate of £2,000,000 per annum.
Comment on this
There was ten times as much spent this year as in the last year of the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
It must have been thrown into some lake then, because it was not spent on the land. Did the Minister not hear the reply given by the Minister for Agriculture to-day?
Comment on this
The ordinary man is absolutely fleeced. The lives of those at the bottom are too hard, while the lives of those at the top are too easy, and no effort is made to achieve a happy medium or to alleviate the lot of those people who are quite unable to bear the impositions cast upon them. The position of the ordinary farm labourer living on a small pittance, with seven or eight children to rear, is absolutely cruel. The Minister should go down the country and see things for himself. He will find things there that will rend his heart with sorrow. It should not be necessary for us to come here and paint the picture for him. Only this morning I received a letter from a widow in County Meath whose husband died suddenly last June at a football match in Mullingar. She says:—
"I am living here with my three children, aged 12 years, ten years and two years, and receiving 38/- widow's pension, plus 5/- home assistance. When my husband was alive the rent and rates of our cottage were only 1/9 per week, and when it was transferred to me the council increased the rent to 3/8 per week. I wonder, Mr. Giles, if you would kindly see if I could buy out the cottage at the old rent, as it would not be worth doing so under the new rent? I am unable to carry on any longer as I have to buy a bag of coal every week at 11/- per bag, and pay 4/8 per week for milk and keep 3/8 for rent. You can see that I have absolutely nothing left for food. I could not buy any coal last week trying to make up 14/8 for the rent collector on Tuesday, with the result that myself and the children are perished all this week for the want of a fire. I have no fire as I am writing this letter to you, and there is no place around that I could turn for any. It is almost a village here where we live. I will have to let the cottage go altogether, and then the children will have no home. I cannot go anywhere to work myself. My youngest child is only two years old and has a bad chest. He was in hospital on two occasions with it. Trusting in your kindness, that you will do something for me. Yours — Mrs. Mary Mooney."
That is just one letter from a decent woman who finds herself in a desperate financial position. She cannot cope with the rise in the cost of living. Her home assistance is useless. Her pension is merely a pittance.
I ask the Government to come to the aid of these people. There should be full and plenty for everybody in the country. Our resources are great. There is no reason why there should not be full employment at a reasonable wage for all our people. Doles and pittances will never make us a nation. Yet, that is all we have — unemployment, home assistance and doles. Our position is one that no Christian Government should tolerate. We have had 30 years of native Government, and yet we find ourselves in this extraordinary situation to-day. That widow I have mentioned is only one of the scores who find themselves in a position analogous to hers. Deputy Hilliard gets letters in the same way as I do. So does Deputy Matt O'Reilly. These people's situation is pitiable.
Our able-bodied men should be employed on the land and our farmers should be in a position to give that employment. Despite our independence over the last 30 years there is to-day no hope of solving our unemployment problem. The removal of the subsidies this year was, I think, the meanest act that Fianna Fáil has ever performed. The removal of the subsidies does not affect the well-to-do. They can buy full and plenty. The diet of the ordinary man is the loaf of bread, the cup of tea, and the egg if he can get it. Now the loaf of bread is a luxury. We will find our people back again to potatoes and salt under their own Government, something to which they never had to revert for long years under an alien Government.
I appeal to the Minister to do something to alleviate the position. All over my own county there are scores of young men begging for work. They are asking the county councils and the Deputies to find work for them. Those who are lucky enough to get work are on for three days and off for three days. I hope some plans will be made at an early date to provide work for our people over the Christmas period. If that is not done, we will find ourselves back to the hunger marches, the unrest and the strife. There should be no need for that. There is a remedy, and it should be applied.
Credit is restricted, and the farmer cannot now get a loan of £100 or £200 to improve his land and give employment in the improving of it. At the behest of the Government the banks will not give him credit. This Government is acting on the orders of the Government in London. This Government is allowing itself to be dictated to by a bully just as our people were dictated to for 700 years. If the banks were ordered to give credit to the farmers, our position would be a very happy one, for we would double production in a few years.
Fianna Fáil have tried to reverse all that was done by the inter-Party Government. During the three years in which that Government was in office we had peace, unity and progress. We had full employment. We had a full building programme. We had land reclamation. Emigration had almost ceased. The jail gates had been thrown open. There was no discontent. The moment Fianna Fáil returned to office there was unemployment, trouble and turmoil.
I appeal to the Government to make some effort to remedy the present situation and to hold out some hope to those who cannot fend for themselves. The Government should alleviate the position of the underdog. It should not allow aliens to come in here to live riotously. Every day I see tracts of land in my own county, in Dublin and Kildare, being bought up by foreigners. These lands are bought by syndicates, combines and companies in order to evade the 25 per cent. The Government has made no effort to put an end to that practice. I ask that a full inquiry be made into the position and a remedy found. When they buy they say the lands will be used for tillage. We see the results in 12 months: grass to the hall doors, whiteheaded bullocks in the fields and nothing else.
We who have to stand in the neighbourhood and see these things happen feel that it is a sad day. We put the British out of the North Wall but they are now coming in by other avenues and they are buying up property. If we do not take some action in the matter then Fianna Fáil and the nation will curse the day they allowed it to happen. Let the Government go back and work for the Irish people, for the little man who works in the bogs and in remote areas, for the people who are in misery — people whose husbands and sons could not obtain work at home and who had to go to a foreign country in order to make a living for themselves. No effort is being made by this Government to cure these ills. The policy of the inter-Party Government was full employment, a good building programme and peace and prosperity. Let Fianna Fáil go back and take over where we left off. Then there will be peace and plenty in this country.
Comment on this
I think that, by agreement, I may move a number of motions which stand in my name on the Order Paper concerning the price of bread and flour.
The first motion is Motion No. 23:
That the Bread (Prices) Order, 1952 (Amendment), Order, 1952 (S.I. No. 268 of 1952), be and is hereby annulled.
The second motion, Motion No. 24, is:
That the Flour and Wheatenmeal (Maximum Retail Prices) (No. 2) Order, 1952 (S.I. No. 269 of 1952), be and is hereby annulled.
The third motion is Motion No. 25:
That the Flour and Wheatenmeal Order, 1952 (Amendment), Order, 1952 (S.I. No. 270 of 1952), be and is hereby annulled.
The fourth motion is Motion No. 26 and it reads as follows:—
That Dáil Éireann is of opinion that a public investigation should be undertaken by the Prices Advisory Body, or some other tribunal, to determine whether or not the increases in the price of bread, flour and wheatenmeal provided by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the three recent Orders in this matter are essential and, in particular, to report to Dáil Éireann on each of the following matters:—
(a) The total additional cost which the consuming public will have to pay as a result of the said Orders—
(i) to firms engaged in the manufacture of bread,
(ii) to firms engaged in the combined business of milling wheaten flour and the manufacture of bread,
(iii) to firms engaged in the business of flour milling.
(b) The percentage of the increased receipts (which would result from the operation of the said Orders) by each of the three categories of firms referred to above which would be devoted to the payment of—
(i) increased wages,
(ii) profit and interest on capital,
(iii) increased directors' fees and salaries of higher executives.
(c) The extent to which any portion of the increased receipts accruing from the increased price of bread and flour is likely to be used by some of the larger firms involved for the purpose of extending their trade throughout the State to the detriment of the smaller provincial bakeries.
I tabled these motions immediately following upon the making of a number of Orders by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. At that time, the Dáil was not sitting. I felt it was essential that, as soon as possible, the Dáil should have an opportunity of considering the Orders made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
My reasons for tabling these motions were, in the first place, that any increase in the price of bread and flour was bound further to add to the spiral which had been set in motion by the Budget. In the second place, I felt that, in the situation which exists in the country at the moment where there is a constant race between prices and wages, it was highly detrimental that any increase in the price of one of the most essential commodities that the public consumes should be permitted by the Government without the fullest public investigation. I also felt that the announcement which was made in the Press a few days after the Orders had actually been made by the Minister was intended to convey that the increases were rendered wholly necessary as a result of increases in wages granted to operatives in the bakery and milling trades. On a very rough calculation of the amounts involved, I very soon came to the conclusion that the full amount involved was not likely to be passed on to the operatives in these trades. I felt that while portion of the amount might reach the workers by way of increased wages, a large portion of the money which was being extracted from the public would, in fact, never reach the workers and that it would go either to the Exchequer, by way of an additional tax on one of the most essential commodities that the public consume, or to swell the already not insubstantial profits of the master bakers and millers. The amount involved, as far as the consuming public is concerned, is not far below £500,000. As a result of these Orders the public will, in the future, have to pay between £450,000 and £500,000 more for bread and flour. That is quite a substantial sum of money. I have not yet been able to ascertain from the Minister the exact proportion of this amount which will reach the workers employed in the industry by way of increased wages.
As regards the increases in the price of bread, the Minister indicated that the amount involved in wage increases comes to £200,000. The amount involved, as far as the consuming public is concerned, in respect of bread is between £330,000 and £350,000. I must say that I am not satisfied that even the £200,000 mentioned by the Minister as being the figure necessary to cover the increase in wages is accurate. I should like to see a breakdown of that figure. If it is possible to say that the total amount involved in wages is £200,000 then it should be possible to show how that calculation is arrived at. Assuming, however, that £200,000 is the amount involved, we have still to learn where the balance is going — that is, a sum of £130,000 or £150,000. The Minister has said that this sum will go to the Exchequer. If it is going to the Exchequer it means that the consuming public are being taxed without a Vote from the Dáil to provide revenue for the Exchequer.
I think it is a dangerous precedent that revenue should be provided for the Exchequer in this manner. It would be a temptation to any Government to increase the price of bread by one farthing if, as a result of that increase, the Minister for Finance were to reap an additional £150,000. That is not the full figure because in addition the Orders in question provided for an increase in the price of flour of 1/3 per sack ex-mill. The total consumption of flour amounts to something in the neighbourhood of 3,000,000 cwt. annually and accordingly the increase permitted by the Minister's Orders provides for a sum of £165,000 or thereabouts.
Again we were told that this increase in the price of flour was intended to cover an increase in the wages of the operatives employed in the milling trade. Yet, after this announcement had been made, we saw that the operatives in the milling trade were negotiating for an increase in their wages. We saw that their case came before the Labour Court and that the award made by the Labour Court was not accepted. I think, if I am not mistaken, we even saw that strike notices had been issued by the operatives because they had not received an increase, so that at the time these Orders were made, as far as I know — I may be wrong in this; I am subject to correction on the point— the operatives in the mills had not received that increase at all.
Comment on this
So that, in effect, a sum of somewhere around £165,000 is being provided by these Orders to cover possible increases which the Labour Court might grant to the operatives.
Comment on this
This House is entitled to have full particulars of the number of persons employed, the total wage bill and the increases which are being granted or which are likely to be granted. We are dealing here with very large sums of public moneys which amount to close on £500,000.
Surely the House is entitled to a fairly full account as to how this additional money is to be spent. The net effect of these Orders is in effect to tax the consuming public to the extent of £500,000. This House is entitled to have full particulars as to how this £500,000 is going to be spent. I think it would be probably far more satisfactory if, instead of discussing these matters here, the Minister agreed to have the matter investigated by the Prices Advisory Body. A body of that kind is much better equipped than this House to investigate the matter fully. I should like to see full particulars furnished by some responsible body of the amount of wages paid by the mills, by the master bakers and, particularly, by the big firms that are engaged in milling and baking. I should like to see, side by side with that information, full particulars of the increases in wages that have been granted and of the amount necessary to cover these increases, instead of merely telling us in general terms that because the workers in the industry received, or were likely to receive in the future an unspecified amount, the public was called upon to pay an extra £500,000.
I must say that I could not help feeling that to a certain extent an attempt was being made to throw the blame for the full increase in the price of bread and flour on the workers in that particular industry. In point of fact, we know that a large portion of the increase is not going to the workers in the industry but is going into the Exchequer. The Minister, I think, admitted that in this House in reply to questions. The Minister does not agree?
Comment on this
The Minister will bear with me if I refer to questions that were asked in the Dáil by myself on the 23rd October last. As reported in column 211 of the Dáil Debates of the 23rd October, the Minister stated that the total amount of increased wages, so far as bakery operatives were concerned, was £225,000, and that the increase in the price of bread was going to produce £330,000. I then put the question to the Minister: "So there is £100,000 going into somebody's pocket?" and the Minister replied that it was going into nobody's pocket. He then said that it would go to the benefit of the subsidy, that the subsidy was being adjusted to get that money. I then asked: "It goes to the Treasury?" and the Minister for Finance, in his usual helpful fashion, came in to help the Minister, and said: "To the taxpayers' pocket." The Minister then said: "If anyone benefits, it is the taxpayer." I have not seen any indication that there is to be any remission of taxes or that the taxpayers will benefit in any way. We know that the taxpayer is being asked to pay more for his flour and bread and, so far as I know, he is not getting any relief. The whole of this matter is particularly disturbing having regard to the general feeling of uneasiness that exists in regard to the organisation of the millers and the milling trade, and also to the large bakery milling firms.
I think the Minister has already agreed in the House earlier to-day, and on another occasion, that the whole price structure relating to the production of flour and bread, and the whole organisation of the industry need to be overhauled. We know from investigations that were carried out recently that the cost of production of a sack of flour varies from 5/- to 19/- according to the way in which it is produced. We know that substantial sums are allowed to the millers under the heading of depreciation in the value of machinery, sums which I think are regarded, even in the Minister's own Department, as being grossly in excess of the sums that should be allowed.
Comment on this
We know also — and I think if the Minister looks through his files he will find a number of reports dealing with this question— that the basis upon which interest and profit are allowed to the milling firms depends upon an exaggerated assessment of the capital value of the firms involved.
I think that, if the Minister takes the trouble to read through the report that was made recently by the committee, presided over by Mr. Justice Lavery, in regard to the production of bread and flour, he will find that the statements which I am making are substantially correct. We know, too, that some of these firms have been making substantial profits in recent years. We know that some of the bakery firms have been paying high dividends, up to close on 20 per cent. In these circumstances, at a time when every section of the community, particularly the wage earners in the community, are being asked to reduce their standard of living, it would seem not unreasonable to suggest that the accounts of these firms should be carefully scrutinised before any increase is granted in the price of bread and flour.
We also know that the discounts allowed by millers to wholesalers, and to some of the bakeries, is a variable amount. It varies in some cases from 1/- per sack to well over 2/- per sack. Is it not possible that some saving could have been made in these discounts, or in the rate of interest payable or in the production costs of some of the millers, which would enable them to meet any increase in wages?
Now, quite apart from these particular considerations, it does seem, at a time when the wage earners and workers in the country are being exhorted not to make fresh demands for an increase in wages, and when everybody is being told that they must economise, that, before any increase is granted in the price of an essential commodity, there should be a full public investigation. It seems to me that, in this direction, the Government should be the first to give an example of restraint and caution. These Orders were made and an announcement was published a few days subsequently in the papers regarding them, but in so far as it gave any information at all, it was misleading information generally, because it sought to convey the impression on the public that the full increase in the price of bread was due to the workers, and that the workers in this industrial group could be blamed for the increase.
I would have thought that, in this situation, if it was found necessary to provide for any increase in the cost of the production of flour and bread, that that increase, in the course of production, so far as it is related to an increase in wages, should have been met by subsidy. These fresh increases, unless they are halted, will inevitably mean fresh demands for an increase in wages.
In one of the motions which is before the House, I have asked that the Minister should refer this question to the Prices Advisory Body or to some other tribunal. I do not wish to limit the Minister's discretion to the Prices Advisory Body. The Minister has from time to time, possibly for, I think, political reasons criticised the Prices Advisory Body. I, therefore, did not want to give the Minister the excuse that he did not like the Prices Advisory Body. If he does not like the Prices Advisory Body, I would be quite satisfied if he were to set up a special ad hoc inquiry to investigate this question publicly. My only insistence is that there should be an investigation, and that that investigation should take place under the searchlight of public opinion.
Personally, I would say that the Prices Advisory Body would be the best body before whom such an investigation could be carried out. I frankly cannot see any reason why the Minister does not accept that proposal. If the facts I am stating, and if the allegations I am making are incorrect, why not have a full public investigation? Why not allow the question of the costings of the millers and of the milling-baker firms be investigated publicly? If the facts are as stated by the Minister, why does he fear an investigation? Is there any reason, and if there is, the public is entitled to know it. I think I am not being unfair to the Minister in saying that there is general public uneasiness at the making of Orders of this kind behind closed doors without a public investigation. The Minister may retort that Orders of the kind were made before. They may have been, but they were not made in the circumstancs in which we say the Government should give an example itself. If any set of wage earners in any industry seek an increase in their wages, they have to submit their claim for the increase to a public investigation by the Labour Court. I see no reason why the same principle should not be applied in the case of producers of essential commodities such as bread and flour.
In the motion, I have asked that a number of specific matters should be referred for investigation, particularly by the Prices Advisory Body or by any other tribunal set up to investigate these increases. I have asked, first of all, that the investigation should ascertain the total amount which firms engaged in the manufacture of bread purely will receive as a result of the increased price; secondly, the amount which firms who are engaged in the combined operation of milling and baking will receive as a result of these Orders; thirdly, the total amount which the millers will receive as a result of these Orders.
In other words, I have asked that there should be a special report showing the breakdown of the incidence of the additional prices that are being charged. I have then asked that there should be a further breakdown showing the exact amount of the increase which is to be utilised for increased wages, for increased profits and interest on capital, for increased directors' fees and salaries of higher executives. As the Minister has told us that portion of this is to go into the Exchequer, then I think we should also know the exact amount of this money which will find its way into the Exchequer.
I have also suggested that there should be an investigation to determine what proportion, if any, of the increase in the price of bread is likely to be used by some of the bakery firms to extend their competition throughout the country against some of the smaller bakery establishments. We know that some of the big firms have apparently a sufficiently high margin to enable them to advertise very extensively in the daily newspapers. We can see the advertisements that are published regularly by some of the bigger firms, presumably in order to extend their competition. We also know that a great many of the bigger firms, particularly ones situated in Dublin, are extending their sphere of competition right through the country. It pays them to send vans for long distances away from Dublin in order to sell more bread in competition with the local and smaller bakers. These firms, of course, in many ways have an advantage over some of the provincial firms because the cost of transport and of raw materials to them is smaller. The public would be interested to know what proportion, if any, of these increases is likely to be utilised to enable these bakery firms to extend their range of competition.
I know that the Minister agrees that the whole of the milling and baking industry needs to be overhauled, that there should be an examination of the whole position. I am glad that he takes that viewpoint. Anyone who knows anything about the conditions in the industry will realise that it is highly unsatisfactory to find that, although the intentions that created the present situation were, I am sure, quite good, the results are such that one might not expect to find them anywhere but in a mental home.
There is a position in which some millers are subsidised not to produce flour, a position where some of them by a quota arrangement are restricted to producing only a certain quantity of flour; if they produce more than their quota they have to pay a fine. There is a situation wherein the costs of production vary from 5/- per sack to upwards of 19/- per sack.
I am quite certain the Minister realises that the conditions could not be more unsatisfactory than they are in that industry and I welcome the indication which he has given that he considers the time has come to have the whole position overhauled. But that is probably a long time objective, and I suggest that in the meanwhile, in order to relieve the public uneasiness which exists in relation to the recent increases which were granted, and in order particularly that the Government should itself set a good headline, he should agree to refer the question of these increases to the Prices Advisory Body or to any other tribunal he may care to set up.
I am not in any way insistent that it should be referred to a tribunal for investigation in the exact terms in which this motion is framed. The motion does cover some of the most essential questions which the public would like to see investigated. If the Minister has additional matters which he would like to see investigated in connection with the industry, he can easily include them in the motion and I would willingly accept any suggestion of his on the matter. In conclusion, I want to say that I can conceive no reason why the Minister should be afraid of a public investigation into this matter. If the facts are as he has stated, there is sufficient public uneasiness concerning this whole question to justify the fullest possible public investigation.
Comment on this
I intervene in this debate to protest against the action of Deputy Giles in introducing and parading before this House the intimate details of the family circumstances of a widow in his constituency. That would, of course, be quite permissible if the widow's name was not mentioned, but I think it is a detestable thing when a citizen of this State writes to a Deputy setting forth her particular troubles that her letter and her name should be read out in this House. I do not mind very much whether or not this lady gave Deputy Giles her consent to the reading of that letter. It is wrong that the troubles and the intimate circumstances of that family should be publicly paraded in this House. Deputy Giles referred to a series of misfortunes which have befallen this particular family, that the husband died suddenly when attending a football match and that one of the children had contracted some disease. All those details were paraded before this House without, I believe, any justification, cause or reason. We all know how the Balbriggan widow was ridiculed from the Government side of the House two or three years ago. Now the County Meath widow is introduced, but I hope that there is nobody on the Government side of the House who will ridicule her circumstances.
Comment on this
A point of order. Is Deputy Cogan not usurping the functions of the Chair in this matter?
Comment on this
Surely if a matter were in bad taste or against precedent, the Chair would have drawn attention to it.
Comment on this
While I am in the Chair, I will do my best to keep decorum in the House. I hope that Deputy Cogan will not follow the Deputy against whose action he is protesting.
Comment on this
I have no objection. I want to deal with the point raised by Deputy Giles. He said that this woman was receiving only a modest widow's pension, but he did not mention that that pension was very substantially increased over the past year. He did not mention the fact that, previous to the passing of legislation in this House last year, that pension would have been very considerably less than it is. He also failed to mention that this woman has received an increase in her children's allowances as a result of legislation during the past year. In fact, the main complaint which she made was against the county council of which Deputy Giles is a member, because, in the first place, they did not supplement her home assistance, she was allowed only 3/- per week, and, in addition, when her husband died, on the transfer of the tenancy of her cottage to herself, the rent was very considerably increased. I think that that is a very grave indictment of the county council of which Deputy Giles is a member. Instead of bringing this pathetic case into this House and parading the details of this woman's family circumstances here, he should have gone immediately to his own local authority and sought redress for her.
I feel that Deputy Morrissey, in widening the scope of this debate to deal with the higher cost of living and with unemployment, overlooked quite a considerable number of factors. He overlooked the fact that, during the tenure of office of the Government of which he was a member, this country was in receipt of very substantial home assistance from the United States.
Comment on this
We dissolved it because we could not pay the Deputy's price or the price of some of his colleagues.
Comment on this
Order! Insinuations are being made which should not be made in this House.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Deputy Cogan has referred to Marshall Aid as a kind of home assistance. Does the Chair think it suitable to let that term pass?
Comment on this
Home assistance is not repayable, while Marshall Aid is a loan which we have guaranteed to repay to the United States.
Comment on this
I think that we should deal with the question before the House.
Comment on this
I think that if we were to question everything which was said here very little progress would be made. What Deputies say depends on the outlook and taste of the Deputies concerned, while the Chair tries to keep order. I appeal to the House to treat things in that spirit.
Comment on this
I do not think that Deputy Blowick is so tender as to consider anything that I have said wrong. We have been assisted, and although it may have been by way of loan, that does not alter the fact that the Government, of which he was a member, accepted that assistance, and that some other Government, as Deputy Blowick has so wisely pointed out, and the people of Ireland, the taxpayers of Ireland, will have the task of repaying that loan at a very substantial rate of interest. Deputy Blowick placed that substantial burden on our people.
Comment on this
And Deputy Cogan was very anxious that we should take it, and was afraid that we would not take it.
Comment on this
Deputy Cogan should not be interrupted, but I would ask him to keep as close as possible to the motion before the House.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey brought all those issues into this debate which the Minister had opened mainly on the points raised in Deputy MacBride's motion, that is, the price of bread. I think it is no harm to remind Deputy Morrissey that in widening the scope of the debate and bringing in all those matters he overlooked quite a number of important factors. Deputy Morrissey said that whatever unemployment and trade recession exist are due entirely to what he called gloomy speeches delivered by Ministers. Now, if gloomy speeches can affect the trade, commerce and industry of this country to the extent Deputy Morrissey suggests then we are in for a very bad period as a result of the speech which he delivered to-day. I have never heard in this House a more pessimistic, gloomy or depressing speech. He told us that factories were closing down, that factory premises were available in large numbers and could not be sold, that newly-built houses were for sale all over the place and could not find a buyer. If Deputy Morrissey continues in this strain and is allowed to do so, all the auctioneers in this city and in the surrounding districts will be completely out of business. I do not think, however, that it is necessary for Deputy Morrissey to be so extremely pessimistic. I believe that we will overcome the difficulties which this nation must undoubtedly experience as a result, in the main, of world conditions. We must do so by our own efforts and by a spirit of enterprise and initiative, not by the gloomy and depressing forecasts and prophecies with which Deputy Morrissey has regaled the House and so depressed it.
"Every phase of the economic life of this country," he said, "is worse than last year." I do not think that is true. There are many phases of the economic life of this country which are substantially better than they were last year. The position of agriculture does not show any decline as compared with last year, and I think the prospects for agriculture for the coming year are reasonably good. If we were to follow the advice of Deputy Giles our prospects would not be so good. He said the farmers in County Meath are sowing grass. I did not think it was necessary to sow grass, but apparently they have sown it in Meath.
Comment on this
I am talking about County Meath. I always thought there was plenty of grass there. I do think it would be very foolish to extend the acreage of grass at the present day having regard to the reduction in the number of live stock and in the number of cows which are the fundamental source of live stock. Surely it does not make for an improvement in the situation to have Deputy Giles advising his supporters to lay down an increased acreage of grass. He should be advising them to increase the area under cultivation and provide the crops for which there is a ready and secure market in this country. As far as I know, there is no physical limit at the moment to the market for all the feeding barley and wheat that we can produce in this country in the coming year. If the acreage in these two crops is substantially increased there is no danger whatever of the market being glutted. If we face the future with courage and with confidence there is a great opportunity for expansion in the agricultural industry.
There has been over the past few years a substantial expansion in industry, and I hope that will continue. There are some industries which are finding the going hard, but there are others, as Deputy Crotty very fairly pointed out, which are holding their own and even improving their position. If we look around us and seek out ways and means of expanding agricultural and industrial production, we will be doing far more to provide employment for our people here in Ireland, and to overcome the economic difficulties that face us than we are going to do by wailing, as some Deputies have been wailing, about the existing conditions.
I want to say just a few words about the matter to which the Minister referred, and that is the bread and flour milling industry and the baking industry. There is considerable uneasiness, particularly all over the Leinster counties, in regard to the manner in which the city bakeries are extending their operations to the rural towns and villages. It may be said that that fierce competition of the city bakeries is a good thing, and that it will make for cheaper bread, but it does carry with it also very substantial dangers. If the bakers in the provincial towns are put out of business there is always the danger that competition, instead of being increased, will be eliminated. I think that would be bad for the provincial towns, and ultimately it would be bad for the country generally.
I know — and I think everybody in this House who is fair-minded will admit — that the whole question of milling and baking is a very complex and a very difficult one. We are all anxious, on the one hand, to ensure that the wheat is converted into flour and from flour into bread as efficiently and as cheaply as possible in the interests of the consumer; at the same time we are anxious to ensure that the milling industry is decentralised, and that the flour mills throughout the country which are operating are permitted to continue. It is not easy to combine those two ideas. In trying to protect the smaller mills throughout the provincial areas we may perhaps, be giving too large a margin to the larger and more efficient city mills. As I say, it is a problem that will require very careful attention, and it is one that should be attended to immediately. I am glad that the Minister did indicate in his opening speech that he intends having the whole matter reviewed.
I would rather welcome the statement that the Minister made that there is a certain change-over to the purchase of household flour as against bakers' bread. To a certain extent it may hit the baking industry but I am quite satisfied that the reasons the Minister gave in connection with that have a substantial measure of truth. The fact that we have rural electrification and the fact that we have better cooking appliances provided in greater numbers in the rural areas, encouraged people to go in for cooking their own bread in their own homes. I think that is all to the good and even though the bakers may not like it this is a free country and people are entitled to eat whatever they chose and to cook it for themselves if they think fit.
I was engaged recently in a controversy in the Press in regard to the matter of wheat and flour, and I found that the person who was opposing my views on the growing of wheat carried his opposition to its logical conclusion and demanded that our people should not be permitted to eat wheaten bread. That man is much more honest than some of the people in this House who have opposed wheat growing, inasmuch as he declared himself to be not only against the growing of wheat but also against the eating of wheaten bread. However, I feel that common sense ought to guide us in these matters and I am sure common sense will guide us.
In the years that lie ahead I hope we will have a much better-balanced economy than we have had in the past and that our land will be producing what is essential to this nation. I hope also that agriculture and industry will go forward not in opposition to each other but in close co-operation and by their development make this nation more self-reliant and more prosperous. If those on the Opposition side of the House who have been trying to depress us by their wails and their moans would just think of this nation as their own country, if they would think of the people of Ireland as their own people and seek to find ways and means of improving their position, they would be doing a useful service. The only effective means by which we can improve the standard of living of our people is to increase the output of agriculture and the output of industry. Those who claimed and sought to prove that you could for an indefinite period stave off poverty, those who claimed you could raise the standard of living of our people by relying upon external aid have, I think, been proved to be completely wrong. That is why I referred to external aid in the earlier part of my speech.
Comment on this
I do not agree with the pessimists that I have heard over there to-day on this matter. I heard the moaning of my colleague, Deputy O'Gorman, to-day, describing the condition of affairs in the constituency that we mutually represent.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
I cannot agree with the woebegone statements made here to-day by Deputy O'Gorman. Deputy O'Gorman considers that everything is bad when Fianna Fáil are in and everything is good when Fianna Fáil are out. That may be a special policy of his. I would like to take Deputy O'Gorman on a little tour of our constituency and show him the changes that have occurred there.
The evil that men do lives after them. Deputies opposite cannot get that into their heads. I have here figures given by Deputy Norton in connection with unemployment. How much of that unemployment was caused by the import of foreign shoddy? The effect of that did not make itself felt for six months afterwards. We did not feel the effect of it in Midleton town until the people who did the damage were gone. They had departed quietly leaving behind them 7,500,000 yards of foreign shoddy. Every draper's shop was packed with it. Then the workers in Midleton Worsted Mills were wondering how it was that there was no employment for them. But for the fact that the Minister for Industry and Commerce stepped in again and prohibited the import of those goods, unemployment would have continued, the stuff would have been shoved in. Thank God, all those people are now back in full employment in the town of Midleton despite the efforts here last week of Deputy Dillon, ably assisted by Deputy O'Gorman, when we had held up to us a piece of the 3/9 a leg stuff for flannel pants and were asked: "Why not allow this in?" by a Deputy representing a constituency in which the import of that kind of stuff had caused misery and unemployment.
When he could find no other grounds to go on, he attacked me because I had not money in worsted mills. Every penny I have in this world is invested in the biggest industry in this country, the land, and is giving employment on the land. It is far safer there than it would be in any industry with a danger of three of four years of a mixum gatherum government. In Midleton to-day there is full employment in these mills again. There are flour mills working there that had been kept going from 1932 although they were being closed down and were working only two days a week when Cumann na nGaedheal were in office. There is a further extension of these mills now to give more employment because the owners of the mills realise that they are now secure and can continue. That will mean increased employment in the town.
We then come to Deputy O'Gorman's own town. Youghal. There is far more employment in Youghal to-day than there was one and a half years ago when the mixum gatherum went out of office, and far more secure employment. I met Deputy O'Gorman down there recently when the Minister for Industry and Commerce was providing more employment there, opening a new cotton mill to give employment to the people in their own town.
We then come to the third town in Deputy O'Gorman's constituency, Cobh. For three and a half years I was endeavouring to get different Ministers for Industry and Commerce to implement the guarantee given by Mr. Seán Lemass, in November 1948, that he would give sufficient money from the State to enable the sheet mills there to be built up and put into operation. I spent three and a half years on the opposite benches hammering Ministers here, asking them by 18 questions, to have that money given to put that sheet mill into operation, a sheet mill where three-quarters of the machinery was lying there with grass and rust on it. We have got it going. Thank God, one of the first jobs the Minister did since he returned to office was to guarantee that money.
As a result, that sheet mill is now being built up to give employment. This is one of the things I would like the Minister to get ahead with. There is room in that industry, and portions of other mills that were brought in at the same period are still lying there, and it is time we got ahead with that work. I am assured by the general manager there that employment can be given in the steelworks not just for the 680 at present employed, but for well over 1,000, if the other mills are got going.
Take, then, what I always consider the Cinderella of our constituency— the town of Fermoy. Thank God, the military barracks there has now been taken over for a further industry, and the people of Fermoy, who have had to sit for 30 years looking at their children growing up without any hope of local employment, will now find that employment in the town.
Those are the four principal towns in my constituency. I am glad to announce that, at present, negotiations are in hand for taking over the military barracks at Little Island, the Rockgrove military camp, to give further employment, producing goods we now buy from the foreigner. Where is the need for the moans and groans over that position of affairs? I admit the people are hard hit. You cannot find the money needed to pay the debts of three years' squandermania, the interest and the sinking fund, unless you find it out of the pockets of the producers and workers. That money is being found, for the cheap pint and the cheap fag those opposite gave in 1948 and 1949 when they came in. You cannot do those things without repercussions. No old lad can turn around and go into the pub for six days of the week and get boozed every night and go continually to the bank manager when he wants to pay his rates or annuities. He cannot do it always; the time comes when the bank manager says he will get no more. You cannot borrow for the ordinary working of a country, for a country, after all, is in the same position as a family. You cannot borrow year after year — £9,000,000 this year, £15,000,000 the following year, £20,000,000 the next, and then wind up with £30,000,000 odd — and throw that burden on the State without the knowledge that the interest must be paid and the principal must be found.
When I saw Deputy Flanagan joining up with the inter-Party Government I thought he was going to be the means of finding the money—that the Monetary Reform man was going to print the notes. Apparently, they had not come quite to that stage at the time they left office, but I dare say they were not far from it.
We now have a Minister who will see that these various proposals are pushed ahead. I will no longer be met in the manner in which I was met by the previous Minister —"It is a very serious matter, it will need further consideration." Three months later, in reply to another question—" The matter is still being considered." Then, in the wind up, we had —"It has been referred to the Industrial Development Authority." That came at the end of three years of answers — that it was gone to Limbo.
Comment on this
The evil that men do lives after them, and the evil those people have done for three and a half years has had unfortunate repercussions. I am sick of hearing industrial people shouting and bawling at the farmers, saying they are not doing their bit, and should produce more. What is the incentive to more production on the land? The previous Minister used to stand up here amidst the cheers and plaudits of the Labour Party and others and solemnly announce: "I am going to give the farmers, not the 1/2 a gallon they were getting at the creameries for the milk up to the present, but a guarantee that for the next five years they will get 1/- per gallon." While Deputy James Dillon is a Deputy here he will never live that down. What was the result? There was a reduction of 50,000 milch cows the following year, followed by a reduction in 1951 of 24,600 more— 76,600 milch cows disappeared out of the herds in two years. At even 400 gallons a cow, they would give 30,000,000 gallons of milk, which would make 92,000 cwt. of butter. Last year we imported, to fill the gap left by the cows that were gone, 100,000 cwt. of foreign butter, and paid £1,886,000 for it For the first nine months of this year we have already imported 105,000 cwt., at a cost of over £2,000,000—into this country of milk and honey.
Comment on this
Why do you not give the price they are seeking?
Comment on this
The gentleman opposite was one of those who trotted around the Lobby to vote against the farmer getting a price for his milk
Comment on this
More farmers voted for me than for the Deputy.
Comment on this
They cannot get milk until the cow has been born and reared and is three years old. Even if we now arrest and stop the evil effects of that ill-advised speech made by Deputy Dillon in this House it will be three years before you will have the results.
Comment on this
I will not have a comparison made between Deputy Dillon's speech and Deputy Corry's speech.
Comment on this
If those gentlemen come back during the three years you will see the people queueing up.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but I am afraid that the Deputy has cast a reflection on a Deputy whose family has given life-long and patriotic service to this country, unlike the Corrys. Patriotism did not begin in 1916.
Comment on this
Having regard to the 1/-a gallon offered for milk, 76,600 cows have gone out of this country.
Comment on this
It was only when the Minister for Agriculture guaranteed a costings board to the farmers and guaranteed they would be paid the cost of production, plus a fair profit in their milk and butter that some hope was held out to them to prevent the disappearance of the cows of this country. There was that change. I hear a lot of talk both inside and outside this House. In fact, everywhere you go you hear the question being asked: " Why do not the farmers produce more?" How can you expect the workers in the principal industry in this country to work harder and produce more at roughly 50 per cent. of the wage that is given in any industry in this country? That is the position to the shame of all Governments.
Travelling around this year during the beet harvest I saw a gentleman driving up with a Córas Iompair Eireann lorry. It pulled up on the side of the road and the driver said: "Better hurry on, lads. My time is nearly up." The gentleman in the lorry, by the way, had somewhere in the region of £8 to £10 a week.
Comment on this
He was all right. He sat in the lorry while two or three unfortunate fellows with £3 10s. per week were forking in the beet. They climbed into the lorry and went to the railway station where they forked the beet out of the lorry. When they had it forked out, the fellow with £8 per week gave another look at his watch and said: "I am sorry I cannot take you home. My time is up." He left them to march three miles back in the rain. These men, in addition to keeping their families on £3 10s. or £3 12s. per week, had also to pay in the price of their beer and cigarettes and even in their bread to make up for the other gentleman in the shape of £1,800,000 Córas Iompair Éireann losses at the end of the year.
Comment on this
The Deputy ought to know that. While the previous Government admitted that the Córas Iompair Éireann losses would be there they forgot to make provision for them and left a debt of £1,800,000 after them.
Comment on this
We are asked to produce more on the land and I am giving the reasons why more production cannot be got from the land. You will not get more production from the land while you have the workers on the land with a status very little above that of a serf.
Comment on this
So long as the worker on the land can walk off and get double the wages in any other industry you will not get more production from the land. There is no good pretending that you will.
Comment on this
You have demands for more production while at the same time there are 51,000 less workers on the land to-day than there were five years ago.
Comment on this
The young men are not prepared to work longer hours on the land in all classes of weather to earn a wage of from £3 10s. 0d. to £4 a week while they can get a minimum of £6 per week in the factory.
Comment on this
The beet workers engaged harvesting this year's beet crop have, roughly, about £3 19s. 6d. per week, including wet time and holidays with or without pay. The man in receipt of the £7 to £8 per week takes the beet out of the field and the worse paid worker in the beet factory, who works inside sheltered from the rain, the cold and the frost, has a wage of £6 1s. 9d. That condition of affairs must end if we are to have more production. There is no good any Government, no matter what Government it is, trying to look for more production from the land whilst that rotten condition of affairs exists. There is no use in pretending anything else.
The foundations of our agriculture have broken down and the foundation of our agriculture is the milch cow. If you have 76,000 odd less milch cows, then you will have, roughly, about 70,000 less calves. You can work that out and you will find that you will have less three-year-old bullocks owing to the fact that the foundations of agriculture were undermined and wrecked by Deputy Dillon.
You have the same condition of affairs in regard to beet. There are 28,000 less acres of beet in the country this year than in 1947. At that rate we will be importing in three years hence all the raw materials for the sugar industry.
I should like to hear from somebody what steps are being taken to arrest that decline and what steps are being taken to prevent that industry going to the wall. You are not going to arrest it on the basis of £3 10s. to £4 a week for the worker at the beet, and there is no use in anybody in the House or outside it thinking that it can be arrested on that basis. The time has arrived when the ordinary worker, the farmer, the farmer's son and the farm labourer will have to get at least as decent a position as the worker in any industry in this State. These are workers in the principal industry of the State, and they have not got it, and they are not getting it. Their position is the position of the serf, and, so far as I can judge, the organisation of the professionals in this country is determined to keep them serfs.
We have seen the result. If production goes down on the land, and the land is our greatest asset, the food required for the people will have to be got somewhere else. It will have to be paid for and purchased on the same basis as that on which it was purchased recently. We had foreign sugar to the extent of 74,000 tons at £12 per ton more than was paid to the Irish worker in the field and in the factory for producing that sugar at home. Count that up—£12 per ton on 74,000 tons. That is what was paid to the foreigner for producing for the people what should have been produced at home and what would have been produced at home if the worker here in our greatest industry had been treated at least as decently as evidently the then Government was prepared to treat the heathen Chinese or the nigger.
I consider that the position in this industry is most dangerous. We have four factories set up, the complete raw material for which is produced on the land here. We have the raw material at home. What steps are going to be taken to arrest the rot that has developed there? Within the next few weeks, the representatives of the Beet Growers' Association will be meeting the sugar company and we want a line from the Government. We want a line to know whether we can now change the condition of affairs in which we had a reduction of 28,000 acres in a few years. We have practically the same condition of affairs in other respects. Last week, I had to raise on the Adjournment the dangerous position which had risen by reason of the breakdown of the Milk Costings Committee. Thank God, we had a Minister here who did not spend his quarter-hour on the Adjournment in the abuse and vilification to which we had been accustomed for three years. We had a Minister who was prepared to set out and see what he could do to get that committee back at work and he succeeded in getting it back to work.
I referred to the attitude of the professionals. We have in this country to-day a section of people who deny to the producers of food the same rights as are given to every other industrialist. We hear gentlemen coming in and saying: "You are not going to get anything on the money you have invested; you are not going to get anything for the money you paid for your stock and machinery; you are not going to get anything for the management of your farm or your stock of cows." But when the farmer goes into Messrs. Gouldings for his artificial manure these costings are included in the price of that manure. Is there to be one law for what we will call the industrialist and another for those who are running the biggest industry of all, agriculture? I am glad as I say that we had a Minister who was prepared to tackle that problem and to insist that the farmer should get his rights, a Minister, who, as the representative of the farmers, was determined to see that he got them. It is a change and a very big change.
To my mind those are the main problems confronting us. To-day I heard a good deal of discussion about flour. Last year on the advice of the Government farmers started to put an end to the importation of maize. They increased the acreage of feeding barley for that purpose. The market for barley opened at 48/- per barrel, £24 per ton. For the first fortnight the moisture content per barrel was roughly 22 per cent. We all know that in the early part of the season the barley is not fully ripe. The threshing of it may have been rushed and the moisture content will be as high as 22 per cent. That barley, with a moisture content of 22 per cent., was evidently worth £24 per ton. After the first rush during the first fortnight, the barley that subsequently went into the mills had as low a moisture content as 15 per cent. The price was still £24 per ton, 48/- per barrel. Who controls that? Who controls the undue and unjust profits made out of the difference between a moisture content of 22 per cent. and an average moisture content of 16 per cent.?
Comment on this
I have always conducted myself here, and if the Deputy will make a speech in a few minutes I will gladly listen to it.
Comment on this
The Beet Growers' Association have a certain amount of control, but it is not the Beet Growers' Association or Messrs. Arthur Guinness who really control the price of barley here. It is the people.
Comment on this
Is it the intention that we should produce here a real asset, feeding barley for our stock? If that is the intention, will any steps be taken now or will any guarantee be given that we will not have the same condition of affairs in the coming harvest as we had in this harvest?
Comment on this
If the Deputy does not restrain himself I will have to take action. Will the Deputy please allow Deputy Corry to proceed without interruption?
Comment on this
There is a difference shown of roughly 6 or 7 per cent. in the moisture content. That has been used by various Governments here as an excuse for not giving us the same price for our wheat as was paid for imported wheat. When we asked for the same price the Governments began to mutter about moisture content. If that is the kind of price arrangement that is permitted, we will very soon find ourselves in the position that the farmer will water his barley before he sends it in. It will pay him better to cut in the rain rather than cut in fine weather. These are matters that will have to be rectified if we are to attain the objective that I hope is ours, namely, a good increase in our wheat acreage, an increase in our barley acreage, some improvement in our position as regards our beet acreage and a change from the position in which the farmers, in despair, are clearing out their herds of milch cows. The story is a sad one. Can the position be rectified? I think the story is sufficiently gloomy to merit the attention of Deputies of all Parties.
Comment on this
I do not think that state of affairs should be allowed to continue. We hear a good deal about the "back to the land" movement. Mark you, it is not alone the agricultural labourer who is leaving the land to-day. The farmer's son to-day is no longer the same as his prototype of 20 years ago. The farmer's son is no longer content to be an unpaid labourer on his father's farm. If we intend to take the road back and put ourselves in the position of being able to look our workers in the face, and if we are not to be dependent on the men who will not be taken in any other employment, we must take steps immediately to rectify the position, for no man who has only his labour to sell will sell that labour for half the price he should get. He would be a foolish man if he did, and the agricultural community would be very foolish if they accepted the position wherein they would be expected to work harder, produce more and get less.
As I have said, I am sorry for delaying the House so long. As far as the industrial position of my constituency is concerned, I have no cause for worry. Employment has increased in the town of Youghal, in Midleton, in Cobh. A new industry is going into the town of Fermoy, and a new industry is going into Little Island. Those are five principal points that I have got to look after. As far as industry is concerned, and as far as employment in industry is concerned, I have no occasion to worry. My concern is that my constituency is a tillage constituency. My constituency is, you might say, the grain granary of Cork County. There was never any occasion to talk of compulsory tillage to the farmers of East Cork. They never had under the plough less than 40 per cent. of their holdings.
We are now faced with the condition of affairs there — owing to this policy of "increase this, increase that, increase the other thing but do not pay the farmer any more for what he produces"— which I have outlined. I remember when things were very cheap, butter being exported from this country at 70/- a cwt. You have now to go to the foreigner for butter. Despite the fact that special pains were taken and that special steps were taken to erect factories here to produce sugar for this nation, you have to go to the foreigner for your sugar. A definite decay has been setting in for a pretty considerable number of years now in our agriculture. That is the position that will have to be remedied if we are to exist as a nation. I suggest that it is not a matter that can be passed over lightly. It is a matter that will have to be remedied immediately.
In my own parish a gentleman by the name of Walls came down from town and started to build a sanatorium. The week he opened up operations I saw 18 agricultural labourers leave the farmers of my parish and go across to work for Mr. Walls at one and three-quarter times the wage they were getting as agricultural labourers. No man could blame them for doing so. However, I also saw something else. The man who leaves the land will never go back. The moment he finds the £6 or £7 a week, the moment he finds the one o'clock stop on Saturday, and knows that he need not bother his head again about his work until the following Monday morning, he will not go back to work on the land as an agricultural labourer. Consider his position for a moment. He earns £6 or £7 a week and from the one o'clock stop on Saturday until the following Monday morning he is free. There is nothing to compel him to go back to work on Sunday. There are no cows to be fed. There are no calves to be fed. There are no cows to be milked. There is no city drone looking for his milk at 8 o'clock in the morning. As far as his position is concerned, he is off work. The agricultural labourer and the farmer's sons and daughters have to face all that work. The moment the agricultural labourers get out of that situation they are not going to go back to it.
It is three years now since Mr. Walls started that operation. None of those farm labourers has gone back. I do not blame them. I wish them joy, happiness and prosperity. Since they cannot get it on the land of this country, I am glad to see them getting it somewhere else. It is things such as that which make any Deputy who looks at rural conditions feel bitter. Year after year, I have found Deputies who represent rural constituencies — Deputies who should have some consideration for the worker on the land and for the man who is producing on the land — trot into the Lobby and vote, for instance, against an increase in the price of milk to the farmers. I saw them trotting around the Lobby and voting against the farmer. Their attitude was that anything was good enough for the farmer. Now we see the result. Any Deputy who takes the trouble to go into the Library and examines the statistics in that connection will see those things for himself.
I urge the Minister to press ahead in respect of the steel industry in this country. There is room there for enormous expansion. There is room there for the employment of at least 300 or 400 more men. All that is needed is the push from the Minister. He should give that push. I admit that he has done a lot. I have to give credit to a Minister who comes along and, after three years of deadness, pushes ahead to give more employment to our people and to produce more here.
Comment on this
I dealt with that matter before the Deputy arrived. I do not wish to go back on it again; I am sure the Ceann Comhairle would not allow me to do so. Of the four towns in my constituency, there has been an increase in employment in three of them.
Comment on this
I am sorry that Deputy Corish will not be able to hear it from me now. If he takes the trouble, he can read what I said in the Official Report. I have described the situation as it is. No matter what Government may be in office, it is my duty as a public representative to call attention to shortcomings. I do not care who they may be, I will nail whoever is responsible, no matter on what side of the House they may sit; I have no hesitation in doing that.
I hope that when we come to discuss the Supplies and Services Bill next year, I shall be in a position to say that industry has gone still further ahead, so far as my constituency is concerned. When Christmas comes round again, I hope I shall be able to give an account of the new industry in Fermoy and the new industry in Little Island and to wonder what the boys were doing while they held the reins of office. I hope also to see a change, a radical change, in the position of our principal industry. As I stated already, I am sick hearing lectures from every industrialist who has 6 per cent. guaranteed to him and who comes along to lecture those who have no dividends guaranteed to them, who very often have only losses to look forward to. These people ask why the farmers do not produce more. I have given the reasons why the farmers will not produce more. I have given what I consider the reason for the cancer that has existed for some time in agriculture. I hope that it will be remedied. If it is not, well then we can farm in Cuba and in New Zealand.
We can go to Formosa and import the stuff we require from there. We have got to face the fact that we are now approaching a position in this country when the situation will have to be faced and dealt with by whatever Government is in power. I should like to see the Government coming along and saying: "Very well, the minimum wage in industry is £6. We are going to fix a wage of £6 per week for agricultural labourers in this country and we are going to see that the farmer, by means of guaranteed prices, will get the wherewithal to pay that wage." That is the cure and the only cure.
Comment on this
Deputy Larkin will be waking up some morning and he will be looking for the tin cow, if he knows what that means.
Comment on this
I am sorry Deputy Dunne did not arrive a little earlier. Had he done so, I am sure I would have him on his feet heartily supporting me as soon as I sit down.
Comment on this
The farmers have no money. The only people apparently who have money at the present day are the gentlemen who are working or at least pretending to work, and who can say at the end of the year: "Here is the balance sheet. There are my losses. Take it into the Dáil with you and get me a subsidy."