We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill, 1952—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 135–266 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill, 1952
Enacted

No. 30 of 1952 ›

I am not hard on Deputy Briscoe.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

You referred to the 6 per cent. men.

Comment on this

I am alluding to the aristocrats of Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this

The Minister's brother, for example.

Comment on this

I am sorry the Deputy was not in a little bit earlier.

Comment on this

I have been here for some time.

Comment on this

I suggested that the Deputy be taken into the fold so that he would print notes.

Comment on this

The Deputy walked in himself. He had not to be asked.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This does not arise.

Comment on this

Under the monetary reform system, which he was advocating, we would have no difficulty in dealing with the Budget deficiency. All he wanted was a printing press. At the period that those people opposite left office, we had very nearly arrived at that position.

Comment on this

The trouble is that the Deputy did not stop when he was finished.

Comment on this

I do not want to say anything to Deputy Morrissey.

Comment on this

Do not. You are right.

Comment on this

I should not like to say anything to Deputy Morrissey.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy would address the Chair, these interruptions might cease.

Comment on this

I should like to tell you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that Deputy Morrissey was responsible for a holdup in my constituency of three years in the rebuilding of the sheet mill. Deputy Morrissey can take a turn at replying to that if he wishes.

Comment on this

I thought you were finished.

Comment on this

We cannot afford a reduction in our agricultural output in this country and steps must be taken to rectify it. I think I have pointed to the one road that can be taken to rectify it and that, in my opinion, will change the trend and the condition of affairs under which the agricultural community are living. Unless that is done, you will have to import the food necessary to support those engaged in other pursuits within the country.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I think it would have been interesting to have heard a speech from Deputy Corry if he were in opposition and if the following situation faced the country. If the complaint of the farmers were that although they have worked harder and produced more they got less, if there were less acreage under wheat and beet, fewer milch cows, less milk and butter being produced—if that were the agricultural situation produced by a Government to which Deputy Corry was opposed, one could imagine the kind of speech that he would make here. Yet those are the conditions that he declared obtain in the country to-day—less tillage, the beet industry finished, men running from the land because the land cannot provide a decent standard of living for them, the milk industry and the dairy industry destroyed. That is the agricultural picture which he has painted for us. We can at least say that Deputy Corry in his speech put a very clear indictment against the Government's agricultural policy. Of course, we know at the same time that, despite what he may have said, he will vote to maintain in power the Government that has permitted this unfortunate and deplorable situation to exist.

I should like to return, if I may, to the more acute problems that now face the country. It is proper, and I think it has been the custom for some years back, that this debate should be availed of by Deputies to review the economic condition of the country during a particular 12 months' period, or a longer period perhaps. I think, applying that test to the conditions that we now see obtaining in the country, there is one clear fact which emerges. It is that this Government is the high price Government. The Fianna Fáil Government and Fianna Fáil are now synonymous with high prices, rising costs, high taxation and the general economic ills which are always associated with a period of inflation.

It is deplorable that that should be so when we recollect that it was on this debate two years ago, in 1950, that the present Minister led an onslaught on the inter-Party Government because of a complaint with regard to rising prices. I am sure that the attention of the House has been directed to the words which the Minister spoke in this House on the 23rd November, 1950, as reported at column 1,306, Volume 123, of the Dáil Debates on this Bill just over two years ago. The Minister then said:—

"The failure"—he is referring to the failure of the then Government—"to control prices, to prevent a rise in prices up to now, the accelerating rise that is now in progress, is perhaps the Government's greatest failure. It is, I think, no answer to the criticisms that have been expressed among sections of the public of the apparent indifference of the Government to that increase that, generally, economic conditions in the country are better now than they were in the war."

I adopt every single word used by the Minister two years ago as being a fair description of the present economic condition of this country and of the present deplorable failure of the Government to take effective, or any, measures.

In his speech two years ago the Minister referred to ministerial indifference. He referred to it in a most unfair way, because he knew that, at that time, the backwash of devaluation and the outbreak of the Korean War were causing conditions outside the control of our Government here; but he was prepared, and his Party were prepared, and it will be to their cost now whenever an election may come, to use any particular circumstances for the purpose of causing public discontent and uneasiness two years ago. They started a ramp about prices. The Minister himself castigated the former Government two years ago because of an increase in prices, and he referred in a determined manner to apparent ministerial indifference.

In other passages in his speech, he went along to make jibes which I regarded then, and regard now, as cheap jibes about various commodities which had gone up in price. He asked where was the Prices Section of the Department of Industry and Commerce, and what were they doing, and where was the great system of price control which he had established in the Department, and why was it not working.

Deputy Corry referred in his speech to the evil that men do living after them. The words which the Minister used two years ago can now be fairly used to test his conduct in office and his record over the last 12 months. Is it fair for the Opposition to ask, as he asked two years ago, where now is the Prices Section of the Department of Industry and Commerce, and where now are the controls necessary to maintain commodities at a fair price for the people? Meat has been decontrolled. It has been decontrolled by the Minister with a pious expression of opinion by the Department that it would result in a fall in the price of meat. Does the Minister now think that the pious hope expressed when meat was decontrolled has been satisfied?

Bacon was decontrolled. Again, we were supposed to experience an amazing drop in the price of rashers and hams. Again, has that been the result? Over the last 12 or 18 months, in relation to a variety of commodities, has the Minister taken effective steps to decontrol prices and to ensure that the prices obtaining will be the ordinary economic prices resulting from supply and demand? He is the Minister who, as a Deputy, charged his predecessor with shirking his responsibility in relation to rising prices and with not doing the job that he was told to do by the Dáil when he was appointed a Minister.

There is no Deputy, no matter on what side of the House he may be, who can be satisfied with the record of this Government over the last 12 miserable months. In relation to prices, they have done nothing. They sat back, fiddling while the people were surrounded by a forest of rising prices. It is for that reason that, I think, the people can regard this Government as a Government of high prices. I think it is about time that the Government, through his representative here in charge of the Department of Industry and Commerce should be made aware that we in the Opposition, representing the majority of the people in this country, are not going to stand for this kind of ministerial complacency, laziness and indifference any longer in relation to this problem of prices.

We are entitled to know what, if any, policy the Government have in relation to the cost of living. Two years ago, the then Government, facing as it was the effect of factors outside their control, took action which was sneered at by the present Minister. They established a Prices Advisory Council. They passed a standstill Order in relation to prices which, again, was jeered at and jibed at by the present Minister. But whatever defects that policy may have had, nevertheless it was a policy. When the Supplies and Services Bill was introduced two years ago, it was introduced by the member of the Government in charge of it as a measure designed to deal with the problem of rising prices, and contained concrete proposals in relation to the problem of the cost of living.

What a change we see now two years later! In introducing this Bill this morning, the Minister made no reference whatever to the problem of the cost of living, offered no proposals, concrete or otherwise, as to what policy the Government might have in relation to rising prices, offered no prognosis with regard to what was going to happen, made no suggestion, good, bad or indifferent, to the representatives of the people here with regard to this serious and acute problem. Did the Minister think that by saying nothing about it this debate might have been conducted without any reference to the problem of the cost of living? Was he so naive as to think he could set the tone which this debate should follow? If that were in his mind, he was very much mistaken because we in the Opposition know our responsibilities. As I say, we appreciate that we represent the majority of the people in this country, and we will not tolerate this kind of lack of policy and ministerial indifference in relation to what is the big economic problem of the moment.

I was astonished to see the apparent indifference of Fianna Fáil Deputies, representing city constituencies, in relation to this matter. Where are all the brave boys of two years ago? Where are Deputy Vivion de Valera, Deputy McCann and Deputy Briscoe? Where are all the other Deputies who two years ago followed the Minister as leader of the pack howling about rising prices? Why are their voices silent now? When any Government Deputies attempted to intervene in this debate why did they endeavour to talk about something else rather than this problem of the cost of living? It is noticeable that ministerial defence and protection in this debate were afforded, not by Fianna Fáil Deputies, but by their outriders, Deputy Cogan, Deputy Cowan and these other gentlemen. That is not satisfactory so far as this country is concerned.

I glanced through the debate on the Supplies and Services Bill two years ago, and it is well worth reading. I recommend it to every Fianna Fáil Deputy, because it will be remembered by every former Fianna Fáil supporter. They should read that debate, see what they said, and regard their conduct for the last two years. Deputy Briscoe was very vocal two years ago. Now he only sits and beams magnanimously at Deputy Cogan defending the Government. But two years ago Deputy Briscoe reminded the House that Fianna Fáil as a Party was formed to look after three things. He said that Fianna Fáil's traditional concern was in relation to the food, clothing and shelter of the people. As reported in column 1462, of Volume 123 of the Official Reports, he said:—

"There are three items of importance to the vast majority of our people — food, clothing and shelter. We on these benches subscribed to that particular principle on the formation of the Fianna Fáil Party. We agreed, and we laid it down as part of our policy, that there were three items to which the Government must give the utmost and the first consideration because of their effect on the vast majority of our people: food, clothing and shelter."

Then the Deputy went on:—

"Let us take food first. One would imagine that food subsidies existed when Fianna Fáil took office. Do the members of the Coalition groups not realise that the subsidisation of the essential foodstuffs for the vast majority of our people was a principle introduced by the Fianna Fáil Government?"

At column 1463 he referred to what was happening under the bad inter-Party Government in regard to food subsidies. He said:—

"When the change of Government came, taxation was not to go up; taxation was to come down. However, the price of food for the vast majority of the people was affected by the system of limiting the ration allowance, not with regard to the availability of any particular foodstuff, but with regard to the extent to which the Exchequer would suffer by a particular subsidy. That, in our opinion, we say quite frankly, was a bad change."

There we have a Fianna Fáil Deputy two years ago lecturing us on the principle of rationing food at a subsidised price to the vast majority of the people. Led by the Tánaiste and followed by the Fianna Fáil city Deputies, he was saying that the inter-Party Government were in some way reducing subsidies. "That, in our opinion," said Deputy Briscoe, "we say quite frankly, was a bad change." Where is Deputy Briscoe to-day? On the Supplies and Services Bill two years later not a word is said by him with regard to the type of Government that not only reduces or interferes with subsidies but wipes them out completely.

These are serious considerations, because I suggest to the House that in relation to prices and other matters this Government have no policy, good, bad or indifferent. If they do anything, they decide what they will do from day to day and from week to week as a result of political pressure exercised on them by groups represented by Deputy Cogan and Deputy Cowan on the one side and Deputy Dr. Browne on the other. That is the type of policy which is dictated by the exigencies of the different circumstances of each week. So far as the country can see, there is no clear programme being followed, no aim being sought and nothing concrete to be put before the people. That is, I think, illustrated very clearly by the type of speech which the House heard from the Minister to-day. It was clear from his speech that there is no policy in relation to prices and matters of that kind.

I know that when I refer to prices as one of the big economic problems of the moment I must also add to it the big problem of unemployment which exists to-day. Deputy Corry or any other Deputy of that kind should not try to cod this House. There is more unemployment in this country to-day than we have experienced for many years back. It is unemployment that did not accidently happen, but unemployment, unfortunately, that has been caused by the direct action of the present Government and, incidentally, by the present Minister. That is a serious situation.

Again, in relation to that, what policy do the Government put before the country? When they assumed office some 15 or 16 months ago this country was doing fairly well. Of course, we had not solved all the outstanding problems that faced the country but we had had only three years to do what we could. Things were going fairly well nevertheless. There was no unemployment. There were no spiralling prices. There was no heavy burden of taxation. There was plenty of money in circulation and, despite the suggestions of the Minister for Finance, there was no restriction in credit from the banks. Generally speaking, conditions in agriculture were booming and the country was passing through a very good period. That was the situation at the very moment when the present Government were charged, not by the people but by this Dáil, unfortunately, with responsibility for governing the country. Now we can look back on the immediate and startling change which took place. Again it was not a coincidence. It was not accidental. It was the result of the very unfortunate and irresponsible campaign initiated by the Minister and by other members of the Government by which the solvency and credit worthiness of this country were endangered, causing a business and trade recession, unemployment and the general economic ills about which we now complain.

I do not think that any member of the Government intended in June, 1951, when they came into office, to follow the deflationary financial policy which has been the cause of so much harm in this country in the last 12 months. In fact, I know that when they went into office, they just did not know what they were going to do; but they started a particular trend which has led to their actions of the past 12 months and to the present deplorable situation. The present Government, 13 or 14 men, and the present Government Deputies, some 60 odd, are the most unhappy people in Ireland to-day, and they are in that deplorable situation because of their actions in the last 12 months. I do not think that the results were foreseen. I am quite satisfied, no matter how many hard things I may have had to say on the political line about the present Government, that no group of men could possibly promise the people of Ireland, as Fianna Fáil did in June, 1951, that they would maintain the system of food subsidies if they intended to do the very reverse. That is not what happened. When they became a Government, particularly with the Minister for Finance playing politics and acting the giddy goat, they wanted to attack the condition of the country because they knew that if they did not get the people to believe when they were well off that they were badly off then the people would regard the financial policy which made that possible as being the correct policy. Since the country was prosperous when Fianna Fáil came into office the people had to be told that it was a false and phony prosperity, and they were told that very well by the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and other members of the Government. All of us were told that we were codding ourselves for three years before when there was full employment, expanding markets, good business conditions and all the rest, that that was all phony, that it was make-believe, and that now we had to face up to realities.

That campaign started off as a political expedient aimed against the previous Minister for Finance and the financial policy which the previous Government had been following, but unfortunately for the Government, disastrously for the country, that campaign got out of hand. It was like letting a car roll down a slope, it got faster and faster and eventually the people who started it could not control it. When the banks were told by the Minister for Finance that there was too much money in the country and that people were spending too much they began to restrict credit. Step by step conditions began to appear where there was uncertainty and doubt in the minds of business people and the people generally regarding the solvency of the country and the trade recession which presumably would have existed to a certain extent was magnified out of all proportion by the campaign indulged in by the Government. As a result we must complain here of the deplorable unemployment situation and the consequential problem of emigration.

While that campaign was going on it was suggested by members of the Government and by Fianna Fáil Deputies that the inter-Party Government had been doing something wrong when they borrowed from the investor in this country and sought investments here at home. I have references here but I do not want to go over all the speeches made by Deputies on the other side of the House in relation to the investment programme of the inter-Party Government. It will suffice to say that every supporter of Fianna Fáil down the country was firmly convinced that the inter-Party Government had been doing something terribly wrong when they asked the Irish investor, instead of putting his money in England, to invest it here at home. All of them, like a well-trained squad of soldiers, were in step in suggesting that that borrowing programme was something terribly wrong and that we were jeopardising our future by the financial policy we had supported. When all that campaign was over, when all the noise had died down, when the people had begun to think over what the issues had been, when all that was finished and unfortunately harm had been caused in business with regard to the solvency of the country, along came the Minister for Finance himself seeking a loan of £20,000,000 from the people of the country, a loan at a rate of interest higher than had ever been given. I think that that type of action by the Government has certainly not been consistent, certainly not been part of a definite policy or a definite programme.

It certainly gives evidence to the people of this country that there is a policy of drift and nothing else in Government circles. There is no clear, cogent line such as the people are entitled to expect from the Government, but rather is there a collection of hasty decisions made up in varying circumstances by, so far as we can see, different groups of Ministers. It is very hard for anyone to justify condemnation of an investment programme 12 months ago, and to justify that same investment programme as being a proper financial expedient 12 months later. That unfortunately is what is happening in this country. It is regrettable that the sufferers are not merely the Fianna Fáil outriders like Deputy Cogan and Deputy Cowan, but also the unfortunate people of this country, those who are out of work, those who are paying Fianna Fáil prices for the things they have to buy, paying Fianna Fáil taxes on all the commodities they use. Those are the people who suffer and who have to pay. In addition, as a result of what the Minister for Finance described in a letter to the newspapers as "a ha'porth of tar", everyone who now seeks to build a house will have to pay increased interest charges. That is the result of the action of the present Government. It is that situation which we are entitled to complain about here in this debate.

I know there are many other grounds upon which the present Government can be indicted. I do not intend to deal with them. It is certainly fair that the present Minister should be indicted here two years later on the same grounds, on the same Bill, on which he sought to indict the previous Government in the month of November, 1950, on prices and on employment. While the previous Government could at least say they were doing something—perhaps not the right thing, perhaps not the best thing, but they were doing something—that is not a defence available in mitigation to the present Minister here to-night, because he is doing nothing, good, bad or indifferent, to control the spiralling of prices. He is doing nothing to retain some reality in the value of the workers' pay packets. On the contrary, his actions and the actions of his Government in the last 12 months have been positive steps further to increase prices, further to reduce the real value of money. The abolition of food subsidies, the decontrol of meat, bacon and other commodities of that kind have contributed in their own way further to increase the cost of living. While we complain of these unfortunate results we also complain that the Government has no right, good, bad or indifferent, to be there at all or to be doing the things they have been doing in the last 12 months. They have not the support of the people. They were not put there by the people, and, so far as popular expression of views can be obtained, the people of the country are merely waiting for the moment to get rid of them.

It is regrettable that this political situation should exist in the country to-day. It is regrettable that any Government should find itself in the position that it knows it has not the support, the goodwill and the confidence of the people it seeks to govern. It is bad for the country and it is bad for the Government. It is bad for business and it is bad for the people generally that these unsettled political conditions should obtain, causing insecurity, causing lack of confidence, and causing apprehension, not merely in the minds of Deputies like Deputy Cogan and others but in the minds of the ordinary people.

We say to the Government, in the interests of the people and in the interests of the country generally, that the time has come to seek a proper mandate from the people of Ireland. If the Government can get it, well and good. We will accept it; we will abide by it. At least the country will be stronger in this fact that, whatever Government is elected, whether it is the present Government or any other Government, it will be put there with a policy and charged by the people with executing and carrying out that policy. In that way the air will be clearer, the country will be stronger and the future made more definite. If the Government just carries on, holds on to power, holds on to office, knowing that the people are going one way and the Government going the other way, then these unfortunate conditions I have described will continue to exist until, eventually, some circumstances or accident unfortunate to the Government will cause the dissolution of this unrepresentative Assembly.

I do suggest that the time has come for a new general election, and it is proper that that should be pointed out in this debate, which has been used actively by the Opposition in the past to draw attention to acute problems facing the people. It is clear that the Government's policy is not acceptable to the people of this country. At least that is our charge. That is what we suggest. We may be wrong; I do not think we are. Most Fianna Fáil Deputies recognise the fact that their policy has not the support of the people of this country. At least we are making that suggestion, we are making that charge, and we are doing it as a responsible Opposition asking the Government, in the interests of the country, in the interests of the Government itself, to seek a fresh mandate from the people. If they do that, and get back, they will be a lot happier, I am sure, and the country will be a lot stronger.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins, in the course of his address, referred to an occasion such as this as one on which this House should have a stocktaking as to the state of affairs which has existed over the past 12 months. In the course of his address he has pointed out to this House one or two of the very serious national ills which our people and our country are suffering from at the moment. It is very remarkable indeed that, on an occasion such as this, when emigration and unemployment, rising prices and soaring cost of living, should be discussed here, we hear so little contribution to this important debate from the members of the Government Party. The reason that the members of the Government Party are so silent on this occasion is that they have no contribution to make.

I should like to open my remarks to-night by asking the Tánaiste, in common decency, to pack up and get out. That appeal is in accordance with the expressed wishes of the majority of the people to-day. Everybody knows that the Opposition represents the majority of the people. Everybody knows that the Minister for Finance or the present Government got no mandate whatever from the people. The fact that Fianna Fáil's policy was rejected at the last general election is ample proof of that. The fact that Fianna Fáil's policy was rejected in Limerick recently is ample proof of that. The fact that the majority of the electors in Waterford — although the Government were lucky enough to pull through —viewed with disfavour and disgust the policy of the present Government, is proof of that. The large majority secured by the inter-Party candidate, belittling and disgracing in no small manner the policy of the present Government, would make any backbencher, even the dumbest of the dumb, of the Fianna Fáil Party blush. They are inclined to brazen it out and to hope that something will happen that will get them out of the knee-deep mud they are in at the present time.

While the present Government enjoys the fruits of office, the unfortunate taxpayer is being bled to the last drop and the unfortunate worker is being driven forcibly into the ranks of the unemployed. Thousands of our manhood are being forced to take the emigrant ship, to eke out an existance in the land of our traditional enemy. Thousands of our workers in recent months have obtained employment in Bradford, London, Liverpool and Hull. Many Irish workers have gone to help Britain to increase her coal production. Many Irish workers who were working full time in constant employment for the three years during which the inter-Party Government administered the affairs of this country now find themselves working in Sheffield, in the Welsh mines and on drainage schemes sponsored by the British Government.

As a result of the policy enforced by the present Government, the housewife finds it impossible properly to conduct the affairs of the home. As a result of the present Government's policy there are between 500 and 700 members of the Grocers' Assistants' Union unemployed and reporting at the hall in Parnell Square daily in the hope of getting a day's work. Shops are not doing sufficient business to keep the assistants employed. As a result of the recent disastrous Budget, publichouses that formerly employed five six and ten hands can cope with the present trade by employing two hands. Staffs have been halved. The licensed trade has been killed completely. The value of licensed premises has reduced considerably. A similar appalling state of affairs exists in the drapery trade.

At the same time as industries are reducing staffs and working short time and half-time, drainage schemes are coming to a standstill. Every local authority that gave employment to hundreds of men finds there is a very bleak period facing the workers between now and the 1st April next.

Members of the Fianna Fáil Party who are members of county councils know quite well that the numbers of men employed by county councils to-day compared with the figures for the three years while the inter-Party Government were in office reveal a drastic change as a result of the cutting down of the amounts granted for the relief of unemployment. Every Deputy from rural Ireland must view with alarm the prospect of a dreary, hard, cold winter. Approaching Christmas, thousands of the best of our manhood are receiving only the miserable allowances payable to the unemployed. Thousands of workers in rural Ireland are facing Christmas as unemployed men. Heads of families are unemployed; members of families are unemployed.

The Minister must be aware that, in addition to the appalling circumstances resulting from unemployment, the Department of Social Welfare is undertaking a review of the allowances payable to widows and orphans and quite a large number of widows' pensions will be discontinued or reduced. Then we are told that the times are bright and good. Two years ago, the Minister, when he was on this side, said that the inter-Party Government was plunging the people into debt, that it was responsible for unemployment and he hurled serious allegations against the Front Bench of that Government; but it is interesting to note that for every week that the inter-Party Government was in office there was 1,000 people put into employment. Yet you have Deputies brazen enough, courageous enough or bold enough to stand up here and tell us that their present policy is more beneficial to the people than that of the inter-Party Government.

Probably the result of the recent by-election in North-West Dublin has been brought about by the increase in the cost of living. Deputy Morrissey referred this morning to the reduction in the consumption of bread and the Minister, in reply, said that, in his opinion, it was due to the rural electrification scheme, that there was more bread being baked at home in rural Ireland, that that was responsible for the reduction in the purchases of bakers' bread. Surely no one takes that seriously. No one could possibly believe it. Does the Minister think that times are so good in rural Ireland that people can pay £40 or £60 for an electric cooker? Does he think the old age pensioners in rural Ireland have electric cookers; does he think the agricultural labourer or the cottage tenants have electric cookers; does he think that all Deputy Corry's farmers have them? Where are the electric cookers? Those who know rural Ireland, the districts that have been lucky enough to secure electricity under the rural electrification schemes, know that it was hard enough to get the people to take in the light, without asking them to take electric cookers. That sort of reply to Deputy Morrissey might sound lovely in the Mutt and Jeff strip, or in Comic Cuts or Our Boys, or in something to provide laughter. When the Tánaiste, the Leader of this House at the present time, tells us that as a result of rural electrification there is more bread being baked in the country in expensive apparatus, it is like something you might expect from someone about 24 hours released from a lunatic asylum. That sort of silly reply does not cut any ice with the ordinary people.

We had the Tánaiste to-day making a case as to why the people should not have cheap tea. He said the Irish people were very particular about the blends of tea they use. Does he seriously suggest that while there are thousands unemployed their wives would go in asking for a pound of tea at 5/8 if they could get it for 1/6? The Minister is of opinion they would take the 5/8 tea and leave the 1/6. The time has come when every housewife and every father of a family are watching every penny piece to see how they can make a shilling purchase two shillings' worth, whilst the present Government is permitting them to buy only 4d. worth for the shilling.

The present Government have no regard whatever for rising prices. Since they took office the prices of household commodities have gone up sky-high. Not only have the prices of tea, sugar, bread, butter, flour and oatenmeal gone up, but every item that goes on the housewife's table has gone up in price as well since the present Government came into office. The housewife cannot even have a headache in comfort when she now finds that the box of Aspros that was 3d. when we were in office is 4d. to-day. She cannot even have her headache cured at a reasonable price. They are 4d. to-day. Soaps, Lux, Rinso, washing-soda, everything in that line has gone up. We know quite well that, after Deputy Morrissey was Minister—and Dr. O'Higgins was Minister later—the present Minister made a speech, just as they left office, and said they neglected their duty and funked their responsibility. He said: "When I walked into the Department I found reeks of files piled high, of prices about to be increased, waiting for the Minister's signature, and the Minister did not sign them or would not sign them." That was the greatest charge he made against Deputy O'Higgins, that he would not sign recommendations of the Prices Advisory Body for price increases. The greatest charge the present Tánaiste had against Deputy Morrissey and Deputy O'Higgins was that they would not sign the necessary Orders to increase the prices of commodities, which would mean an increase in the cost of living. They were criticised for not sanctioning those increases. I say that Deputy Morrissey and Deputy O'Higgins acted wisely in not sanctioning the increases recommended on those occasions. Things would be more favourable if the present Minister had taken the same line as his predecessors in that respect.

Since this time 12 months, Electricity Supply Board charges have been increased. That means that every shop and business premises has to pay more for light, every house has to pay more for light and the ordinary ratepayers have to pay more for public lighting. It would have been wise if the Order made by the present Minister increasing electricity charges had been left unsigned.

Deputy Corry spoke of the plight of the farmers. He said there were no worries whatever in his constituency, no unemployment, no one complaining, no one grumbling, everyone satisfied with the cost of living, everyone well pleased, well dressed and well fed. I visited Deputy Corry's constituency quite recently and found that in a town four miles from his home, the town of Midleton, there were between 40 and 60 unemployed men. I found that there were people working in the distillery in Midleton on short time and half-time. I was speaking to some unemployed people in Midleton, who were-employed in the distillery in Midleton when the inter-Party Government were in office. The same conditions prevailed in other towns in Deputy Corry's constituency.

Deputy Corry spoke of the farmers and said that they were not getting a fair crack of the whip. He was right in that because the farmers are not getting a fair crack of the whip. Deputy Corry made sure that he did not refer to the imported butter. He referred to the oats, barley, wheat and beet, but he did not say anything about butter. Is it not amazing when one recalls the serious opposition to Deputy Dillon when he was Minister for Agriculture because he imported Danish butter? At the last general election and even after that voices were raised in the Fianna Fáil Party, which reechoed through every town and village and every hill and valley in the country: "What about the Danish butter?'

Labour representatives, Clann na Talmhan representatives, the Clann na Poblachta Party and the Fine Gael Party were charged with importing butter. We heard the present Minister for Agriculture, when he was Deputy Walsh, describing the despicable production that was being brought in here from Denmark. Every Fianna Fáil Cumann in the Twenty-six Counties was given instructions to arouse public ill-feeling against the imported butter. We were told that the Danish butter formed fours on the butter plate, stood to attention and that it grew a beard overnight in the cupboards. We were told all that about the Danish butter.

We were told that the moment Fianna Fáil got back into office the last ounce of butter would be imported and our people would no longer have to stand in the same house in which the Danish butter was forming fours and standing to attention. We were told that in shops, where the Danish butter was being sold, glass had to be broken, new windows installed, fresh ventilation provided and that the shop assistants found it impossible to mark time with the Danish butter on the counter.

We were also told that the very moment Fianna Fáil were back in office would be the end of imported butter. What happened? They were not very long in office when they obtained £2,000,000 worth of New Zealand butter. Brave and brazen the Minister for Agriculture told us in the Dáil a few weeks ago that it was the Government's intention to import more butter. The sad part of all this is that the unfortunate people who were given the description of the imported butter fell for it at the last general election but no one could stand in the same street with the butter that Deputy Dillon was responsible for importing. But once Deputy Walsh, the Minister for Agriculture, imports the butter it is lovely butter, very nice and tasty. That is what we are told. When Deputy Dillon brought in the butter, it stank but when Deputy Walsh, the Minister for Agriculture, brings it in it is very nice and tasty. Now there is not a word about the imported butter. Let us take for example the bacon and the hams.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

There is something rotten in the State of Denmark.

Comment on this

I remember during the days of the inter-Party Government the feelings of the Tánaiste and Deputy Walsh and occasionally the Minister for Justice were aroused when they recalled the days when hams and bacon were readily available. One of the first acts of the present Tánaiste was to take off the control on hams and bacon. We find that at the present time ham and bacon is a mere memory in the worker's home.

The young children of many workers never saw a rasher and do not know what a ham is like except to see it in a shop window. Their parents cannot purchase it because the price control was taken off and those responsible could charge what they liked for rashers and hams. When the inter-Party Government was in office that was not so. That Government realised that the poor man, the worker, the farm labourer, the widow and orphan and the old age pensioner were equally entitled to their ham and bacon as the industrialist and those who were living on a salary out of which bacon and ham could be purchased.

If any Deputy in rural Ireland visits the homes of the working class people to-day and if he asks the head of the family for details of the family diet, he will be told that there are hundreds in this country to-day who can only purchase one pound of butter per week since the present Government put 10d. per pound on it. When they imposed 10d. per pound on butter they might as well have put 5/- a pound on it because the butter was gone out of the reach of the ordinary worker.

There are school-children in rural Ireland to-day bringing two cuts of rough dry bread to their schools because their parents cannot afford to pay 3/10 per pound for butter. The unemployed man has butter in his home for Saturday and Sunday and there might be some left for him the following day, but Tuesdays, Wednesdays, Thursdays and Fridays are the days on which butter is a memory. On Fridays the longing for butter consumes the hungry little children sitting by the fireside who say: "To-morrow, please God, we will have butter on our bread."

There is the state of affairs that has been brought about. The tears are falling from the soft and tender eyes of many Irish mothers to see their children crying for butter on their crusts when they cannot provide it. Butter is a thing of the past and the Fianna Fáil Party smile with delight and push out their chests because they were brave and courageous to deprive the poor people of butter.

I remember when Dr. Ryan, the present Minister for Health, opened some institution in the parish of Rathgar about two months ago. In the course of his address, he referred to the diet of our people. I recall that he made reference to the nourishment of our people. On more than one occasion the present Minister for Health advised our people to eat plenty of butter, drink plenty of milk and eat plenty of eggs. I am speaking as one who represents a rural constituency and I must refer to the towns of: Birr, Tullamore, Edenderry, Clara, Banagher, Mountmellick, Portarlington, Rathdowney, Mountrath and Stradbally. In these areas, there are families who see butter three days a week. They are families who cannot afford to pay 6d. each for an egg— the price of eggs is between 5d. and 6d. each — or 6d. for a pint of milk. Take the case of the unemployed man, with a wife and five or six children. According to the recommendation of the Minister for Health, in order that they may be physically strong and healthy, they are to eat plenty of eggs, drink plenty of milk and use plenty of butter.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

And they should be able to save.

Comment on this

As Deputy Corish says, they were told that they should have saved money which they should invest in the Post Office Savings Bank. Everybody knows that the conditions that prevail in the homes in rural Ireland to-day have never been experienced in the history of this country. There are people in the large provincial towns drinking black tea because they cannot afford to buy milk. The Minister can make inquiries in the many homes in O'Mulloy Street, Tullamore, and O'Moore Place, Portlaoighise, and if the correct investigations is made, my statement will be borne out.

Old age pensioners, widows, orphans, invalids and others cannot afford to pay 3/10 per lb. for sufficient supplies of butter to do them the whole week, and sufficient supplies of milk to colour the tea three times a day every day of the week. They cannot purchase meat. Meat is only for the rich. It cannot be purchased by the poor, and everybody knows that. Fathers of families in this city and through the country know that meat has now become an article of diet for Sunday, and that it is only used for one meal on Sunday in most of the workers' homes in Ireland. Beef, mutton, cutlets, lamb, bacon, pork — everyone knows that the unemployed people cannot purchase these commodities. We all know that at his present rate of pay, with the cost of living as it is, the farm labourer cannot purchase them, and we know also that it is the policy of the present Government to make our people eat less, wear less and drink less.

How are our people forced into the position of eating less. They have been forced into that position because bread has gone up in price, with the result that less can be eaten; flour has gone up in price, meaning that less bread can be made; eggs and milk have reached a price only for the rich; meat is prohibitive; and vegetables in the city, in an agricultural country, have reached a price which the poor of Dublin cannot pay. That applies to parsnips, cabbages, beetroot, potatoes and other essential vegetables. Because of the prohibitive price of vegetables in the cities and large towns, people are forced to have tea three times a day, and, if tea can be made available at 1/6 or 1/8 per lb. they will use that tea in preference to tea at 5/4 or 5/8 per lb. The Minister differs from me in that.

While these conditions prevail in the homes, we find that, due to the present Government's policy, the rents charged for the new houses which were provided for these people are prohibitive, with the result that many people living in rural Ireland to-day under the conditions I have outlined must remain in the hovels instead of going into the newly provided houses. I have outlined the conditions with regard to the purchase of food, and we find that the lowest rent even to the unemployed man in my constituency is 12/6 per week. The rents of houses range from 12/6 to 35/- per week, with rates. In that regard, we find that the serious plight in which working-class people find themselves is definitely due to the policy pursued by the present Government.

I remember reading a statement by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, when he was on one of his rabbit-hunting tours in Westmeath, that the people were living beyond their means. I should like the Government, and particularly the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to tell us exactly whom they are referring to when they tell us that the people are living beyond their means. We were told that the people were spending too much. On what? We were told we were all living beyond our means. Was it the old age pensioner on 21/6 per week who was living beyond his means? Was the farm labourer with a little over £3 a week living beyond his means? Was the farmer with the oats and the barley he cannot sell living beyond his means? Is it these farmers, with the demands for increased rates and taxes, the increased cost of seeds and manures, and with shop bills coming in, who were living beyond their means?

Is the home assistance recipient living beyond his means, the person getting 7/6 per week from the local authority on which he is expected to purchase £3 worth to keep body and soul together for the week? How that is done is a mystery, but they are expected to do it. Are they living beyond their means? Are they the people the Minister is advising to save, the people who should have saved money which they should put into the Post Office Savings Bank? Is the tradesman living beyond his means? Deputy Alfred and Deputy Tom Byrne referred during the week to carpenters, plasterers, bricklayers, painters, plumbers and others engaged in the building trade, and said that there was no end to the number of these tradesmen who are unemployed in Dublin at the moment, and that goes for the whole Twenty-six Counties. Are these tradesmen living beyond their means? When the Taoiseach and the Minister told us that we were living beyond our means, whom were they referring to?

It was certainly not to the type of people to whom I am referring. Was he referring to the teachers? Are they living beyond their means? Time and again they have asked the present Government to set up the same machinery for investigating the necessity for an increase in their pay as was set up by the inter-Party Government. The present Minister for Education has refused point-blank to do that and has notified the I.N.T.O. to that effect. Are the teachers living beyond their means? Are the members of the Defence Forces, the privates in our Army who are looking for increased marriage allowances and rent allowances to meet the increased rate demand on their homes living beyond their means?

Were the publicans living beyond their means? The publicans were doing a flourishing trade, and a good trade until the recent taxation was imposed. Many of them in rural Ireland have decided now to keep the shutters up on one window because it is no longer worth their while taking them down and putting them up. The doors of public-houses are creaking and squeaking for want of oil on the hinges because they are not being opened and closed as frequently as they used to be, thanks to the policy of the present Government.

There are fewer employed in the breweries. There are fewer employed in the distilleries. Fewer will be employed on lorries in the future because of increased taxation. In my constituency some of the big firms have stated publicly that they will not tax all their lorries after 1st January next. That will mean a driver unemployed, a helper unemployed, a lorry less taxed, a lorry less on the roads, less petrol being consumed, fewer tyres being worn, less plugs being needed, less batteries being required and, therefore, less work in the garages. That is what will happen after 1st January next. The unfortunate hackney driver may put away his car and sign on at the local labour exchange after the 1st January next.

Every step taken by the present coalition—I deliberately use that word —of "Lemass-Cowan-Cogan" has been a step bringing more disgrace and more dishonour to the country and arousing more disgust amongst our people. I am sorry that the Taoiseach was not here in the House and in good health——

Comment on this

You are very worried. You said in 1948 when the Government changed that you thanked God you were here to see the day. Do not be a hypocrite.

Comment on this

I am sorry the Taoiseach was not in the House when the result of the by-election was announced because I believe that he would have been man enough to pack up and go when he saw the Lord Mayor of Dublin meet such a drastic defeat. Perhaps he will do it when he comes home and, if so, the sooner he comes and does it the better it will be for all of us.

Comment on this

Do not be a hypocrite. You said you were glad to see the day in 1948.

Comment on this

The quicker he packs up and leaves the better it will be.

Comment on this

Do not be a hypocrite.

Comment on this

The quicker the present bag of rags that is holding Fianna Fáil together packs up and gets out, the better it will be for all of us. We know very well the Tánaiste will not dissolve this Dáil. We know his sole ambition in life is to be Taoiseach and he wants to hang on to office even with the mangy support of those who have stooped to the lowest depths of indecency here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not seem to be relevant to this debate.

Comment on this

I am taking this opportunity of asking the Government in a plain, blunt, honourable, decent fashion to get out.

Comment on this

You put the Government out in 1948.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy please restrain himself?

Comment on this

But you could not carry on.

Comment on this

I am sorry if my speech has in any way aroused the feelings of Deputy S. Flynn.

Comment on this

It has not done so in the least.

Comment on this

I would be sorry to hurt the feelings of Deputy S. Flynn, but I know very well that his conscience must be pricking him very seriously at the present time.

Comment on this

Not in the least.

Comment on this

With reference to the loan floated by the Minister for Finance, the loan was generously subscribed and the Minister patted himself on the back because of its success. Observe the attractive rate of interest. Who will benefit by this loan? Who will pay for it? I would like to hear those questions answered. Is it not a fact that, as a result of this loan, local authorities will have to meet increased charges for loans advanced under the Small Dwellings Act? That means private building is finished. Decent people may have subscribed to this loan—I am not saying they did not — but a golden opportunity was given to adventurers and to racketeers to invest their spare cash, draw big interest and make a good profit at the expense of the poor and at the expense of those who will be driven out of employment and at the expense of the cottage tenant, who will have to pay more in rent and rates in order to help the speculators and the gamblers to get rich quick. Some decent people may have availed of the loan but there were all sorts of opportunists waiting for the right moment. We know that opportunists have always been connected with Fianna Fáil and we know that Fianna Fáil policy has always given a clear road to these opportunists to get rich quick at the expense of the worker and at the expense of the poor.

A golden opportunity was given to the speculators and the gamblers in this recent loan so that the rich might get richer and the poor might get poorer and thinner. The pinch has not been felt yet, but it will be felt. It will be felt next year, the year after that and for many a year to come. It will be felt in particular in the City of Dublin by the newly married and those about to be married who were engaged in the erection of their own homes. One of the first steps the present Government took was to deprive ordinary people of the opportunity of providing themselves with a home. They stretched forth their hungry hand over the young man anxious to set up a home for himself. They took the roof from over his head and deprived him of that home by means of which he could marry and bring up a family in Christian decency in his own country. He has been denied that right. We find Fianna Fáil speakers defending that policy.

Many sad events have happened from time to time in the history of our country but I think that the saddest event that has ever happened was the return of the present Government to office some 18 months ago. If an opportunity presented itself this moment, the present Government would not be 24 hours in office if an angry and raging people had an opportunity of deciding the matter—as they decided so well and wisely in North-West Dublin. The Fianna Fáil policy has been a policy of beggary, despair, discontent, dishonour and disgrace. I should be very anxious to know what one good thing they did since they took office. Can the Minister for Industry and Commerce stand up here now and tell us that he provided more employment, built more houses or provided more for the relief of our distressed people? If there were some favourable report to be obtained from the present Government, all the criticism that has been hurled from this side of the House would not be hurled. Turf camps in my area have been closed down—Boora Camp. Less have been employed on our bogs. Between 400 and 500 fewer people are employed by the Laois County Council.

Drainage work is at a standstill. The land project is slowing up. Farmers are consulting their auctioneers and asking: "Is now a good time to sell so that we can get out, because the present Government may be in office for another few years and it would be better to sell now than to have to sell later on." I find that the farmer is the most discontented person in the community to-day. Not alone is that true of the labouring man and the farmer but it is true also of the businessman. The Government can give him no guarantee as to the future. The only guarantee that has been given to him is: "Stay in existence while you can for when you go you are gone and there is nothing we can do for you."

Deputy Blowick spoke here last week about timber. The timber that the inter-Party Government bought and was keeping in this country for the erection of houses for our people has been exported to Belfast and to Britain for use in the construction of houses there. That is an example of the policy of the present Government. Then we are told that we are all living beyond our means.

Look at the present plight of the Old I.R.A. They are a section of our people which, year after year, is becoming smaller and smaller. Every day we take up the paper we read that one of them has passed to his eternal reward. Many of those Old I.R.A. men who fought for the establishment of this Parliament are living in rural Ireland. They are suffering the pinch brought about by the increase in the cost of living. Their pensions or allowances have not been increased. For those of them who got neither allowance nor pension there is the county home. The Government—this Government in particular—have a responsibility to those unfortunate ex-soldiers—if I may so describe them—of the Republic of Ireland. We find many of them in county homes. They may die in a public institution but the moment they die there is a Guard of Honour. There is a shooting party. Shots are fired over the grave and a bugler sounds the Last Post. The ceremony is there when they are dead but they may die in the workhouse or of hunger. Then the hat goes around for the widow and the orphans to help them to keep body and soul together. There is no bugle sounding to keep them alive. Every Deputy in the Fianna Fáil Party knows that many of the men who fought nobly and bravely for the freedom of this country are ending their days in workhouses and poorhouses.

Emigration is the greatest misfortune and disaster that can befall any country. What were we told by members of the Government? We were told that we are a roving nation. We were told that we like to move around, that it is bred in us to be travellers and to wish to see what is going on in other countries. Never, all during the long 16 years when Fianna Fáil were in office, and for the past 18 months since they returned to office, has there been such a drain from this country as we have at present. There are no figures or records of emigration— Fianna Fáil made sure of that. When they took office they made it quite clear that they would keep no records or statistics in regard to emigration. No Deputy can stand up here and say that so many thousand persons have emigrated or that so many hundreds of thousands have emigrated. Nobody can state definitely that less than 250,000 persons have emigrated. We do not know how many have gone, because there are no records. We know, however, that there is not a town or village in rural Ireland which has not homes to which the fathers, brothers or sisters are sending money from a foreign land to keep the home fires burning. We know that, day after day, our people are being forcibly driven out of their own country.

I ask any Fianna Fáil Deputy to compare the Fianna Fáil record in regard to emigration with the work which was done by the inter-Party Government and the efforts they made to stem it. For the first time in the history of Ireland, as a nation, we heard: "Ireland is building. Come home." An appeal was made over Radio Éireann, in the Press and in the British newspapers to our carpenters, our plasterers, our painters, our plumbers and our builders to come home from Britain, that there was work and plenty of work for them at home. Is the radio saying: "Come home" now? Are appeals being made from the Irish Embassy in London to Irishmen abroad to respond to the call and to fill in the form, one question of which was: "In what part of Ireland do you want to work?" I am referring to the form that was available when the inter-Party Government was in office. Are any such forms available now? Are any calls being made to the lonely and distressed ear of the Irish emigrant who is living to-day under the types of conditions to which the Taoiseach referred—and the Minister for Industry and Commerce was with him—in Galway? That was when they expressed their desire and their longing to bring home our emigrants. They said in Galway that the Irish emigrants are living under disastrous conditions. Reference was made to English lodging-houses.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is travelling rather wide now.

Comment on this

There is only one way of improving the conditions of Irishmen abroad and that is the way in which we were doing it while we were in office — calling them home to work in their own land, providing their own people with houses, our sick with hospitals, our farmers with drainage and storage, which are not available to them at present, and with the various services necessary for agriculture. There is work for millions in Ireland if we had a proper and sane Government that had the interests of the people at heart. We see young children leaving school who are immediately faced with the emigrant ship. It is a sad state of affairs when the father of a family, who has reared a boy or girl until he or she has reached the age of 16 or 17, and who has spent anything from £1,600 to £2,000 in his or her education, is compelled to permit that boy or girl to emigrate to help in the production of food or the production of materials for another country.

I am glad that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture is here because he represents a Gaeltacht district, and from the Gaeltacht come Irish traditions and a special love for the language. How many times have we seen young boys and girls, even from Connemara, with the Fáinne, fluent Irish speakers, having to go over to pick potatoes in Scotland?

Comment on this
Gerald Bartley Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Bartley) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy knows of the heavy exodus there was after the Coalition Government came in and stopped the turf scheme.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It was the Tánaiste stopped the turf scheme.

Comment on this

It was not the Tánaiste.

Comment on this

It is on the records of this House that it was the Tánaiste who stopped the production of turf. Anybody of common sense knows that the production of hand-won turf was stopped by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Go down and tell them that in Connemara.

Comment on this

Is it not a sad state of affairs, after all we have done for the promotion and fostering of the Irish language, that we have the best of our Irish speakers trying to learn English in England? That cannot be denied. I am sure that Deputy O'Donnell from Donegal must know that there are fluent Irish speakers from his constituency who had to emigrate.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I know that the biggest difficulty facing fluent Irish speakers in England was to learn English, so that they could hold their jobs there. What good was the Irish language to them? What good was carrying on the old Irish tradition to them? Is it not sad and pitiful for anybody who loves the country and loves the language to see this state of affairs? Is it not sadder still to see the blind eye and the deaf ear given to those who need work, and to see that the one section of the people in whom Fianna Fáil are interested, are the people who own dance halls, the ballroom proprietors? They are the only people for whom Fianna Fáil have done anything since they took office. They gave them a handsome present of £145,000.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise on this Bill.

Comment on this

On this Bill dealing with supplies and services, I hope I am not foolish in presuming that that was a service for the dance-hall proprietors.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not arise.

Comment on this

The policy of the present Government is one which has brought great discontent to every section of our people. I do not wonder at Deputy Cowan rising in this House to criticise the financial policy of the Government. I do not wonder at the Deputy, having been troubled in his conscience by Deputy Byrne's victory in North-West Dublin, rising in his seat to have a kick at the Tánaiste and his Government. The quicker Deputy Cowan puts this bag of rags out and goes out along with them, the better it will be for rural Ireland and for the unfortunate people who voted for Deputy Cowan at the last election, believing that he was going to support the inter-Party Government which he has reneged and, as a result of his reneging, has brought ruin, disaster, despair and discontent upon his own constituency, upon his own profession and upon the people of Ireland as a whole.

Comment on this

This debate on the Supplies and Services Bill gives Deputies an opportunity of dealing with the policy of the present Administration as it relates to the situation that we find in the country. I think we are justified in looking back on the methods by which the present Government came into power. In the last election, from platforms throughout the country, Fianna Fáil speakers rubbed home how the inter-Party Government had failed in its duty to the Irish people by permitting the cost of living to rise. When the Tánaiste stood up to make his opening speech in this debate to-day, I am sure a number of people in the country, the Deputies in his own Party, and those Deputies who support and maintain his Party in office, hoped, and quite reasonably so, that he would give some outline in his statement which might in some way alleviate the unhappy situation that exists in the country to-day. If we look at the country to-day and as it was 12 months ago, what is the sorry position that presents itself? Let us, first of all, take the position as it existed when the inter-Party Government went out of office.

I was not a Deputy then, but I was sufficiently in touch with the political life of the country and conditions generally, as they apply to rural Ireland, to know that there was happiness and contentment born of the fact that almost for the first time in the history of this State there was full employment. For successful government, the most necessary requisite is that our people should be working, more particularly those people who are entirely dependent on their weekly hire, because they have probably the best purchasing power amongst the community. It is fair to say that if good employment exists, there will be a good circulation of money, goods and services will be sought, and the country will be happy, contented and prosperous.

I do not think it is an exaggeration to say that that was the state of affairs which then existed and that it was the position when this Government came back into office. What is the position to-day? We have the official figures produced by the Statistics Office, by the Government itself, and no one can controvert them. These figures show that the number of unemployed, as compared with what the position was when the inter-Party Government was in power, has gone up by from 8,000 to 11,000. These figures in themselves indicate that there is something seriously wrong. One would have thought that, when the Minister was speaking this morning, he would have indicated what the policy of the Government was for dealing with this unsatisfactory state of affairs. I was not present for most of his speech, but I have read a report of it in the evening papers, and I find that it was confined almost entirely to the price of bread. Is it-not a sorry state of affairs to find that on the Supplies and Services Bill, the only statement the Minister had to make to this Irish Parliament was as to why the price of bread had gone up? I accept his explanation as giving the facts, but is it a satisfactory explanation?

The situation, as I can read it, is that he had to permit an increase in the price of bread because the employees were looking for an increase in their wages. It is not very hard to find the reason why they were looking for an increase in their wages. I think we can find a sufficient explanation for it in this year's Budget which enshrines the policy of the Government in power for the time being. I think that answers the question for everybody. You have at the moment a vicious circle which is going to continue to the detriment of the country so long as you have the present Government maintained in power by people who were not elected to put them there.

Ever since Fianna Fáil was returned to power, there has been a continuous rise in the cost of living. What gives stability to a country? The people who, by their work which produces goods and services, and thus ensure that money will be kept in circulation. That money provides employment for the people who, in turn, keep the factories going by purchasing the goods they produce. What do we find to-day? We find that unemployment has increased by between 8,000 and 11,000. Someone has to maintain them. If you have a number of people in a country doing nothing, somebody has to support them. I am not decrying the fact that they must be supported. Everyone has the right to live in his own country, and if a Government does not provide work for the people then the people have the right to make a claim on the social services which are offered to them. If you have a large number of people who are a deadweight on the State, through no fault of their own, is it not crystal clear that someone has to pay for that? Social services have to be provided for them, and the increased payments in respect to these social services fall back on the Irish people.

That is one of the reasons for increased taxation. When the inter-Party Government were in power they gave the people employment and a decent standard of life. With one or two exceptions, they did not look for extra taxes. Deputies in my constituency, when on the hustings at the last election, screamed with indignation — they frothed at the mouth almost — over the extravagance of their predecessors and the national debt which they had put on the country. They put that national debt to good purpose by employing the people. That was done at a normal rate of interest.

When the Fianna Fáil Party came into power they let the situation hang. For 12 months or more they had been repeatedly advised from these benches by people of financial acumen who had studied the situation, to go for a loan at a suitable rate of interest. They got that advice at a time when it was possible to obtain cheap money. Instead of doing that, they blackened their predecessors. I suppose it is fair politics, to a certain extent, for any Government or Party to blacken the Opposition or to paint as bad a picture as they can to put before the public. Possibly that is allowable and possibly it is justified, always provided that you do not ruin the country. As a result of that foolish and misguided policy, the Minister for Finance found that, in the interests of employment and of maintaining the services of the State, he had to do what his immediate predecessors did. He had to do what that Party denounced us for doing when we were in office. He had to go for a loan, but, as we know to our cost, the unfortunate part about the Fianna Fáil Party is that it is always too late. They went for the loan but did so too late. As they have told us they got the money. The head of the Minister for Finance is unbowed, but the country is not unbowed. The result is that ordinary working people throughout the length and breadth of the country, with no education on financial matters, think that this has been the greatest mistake in the history of this State since its inception, because now they know that the rate of interest on houses is to go up.

They know that dear money affects them just as much as it affects the financiers. They know that it will cause a slump in the building trade. Then we are back to unemployment and to the emigrant ship. Were we not waiting long enough to have our own native Government without having to face such a situation as has been created, causing disturbance in industry and in building, through the misguided policy of the Minister for Finance and his colleagues in the Fianna Fáil Government?

What is the position in the country towns to-day? Deputies who come from rural constituencies know just as well as I do the state of affairs existing to-day. They know that in the country towns the spectre of unemployment is haunting housewives of the working class and of the middle class. These housewives do not want very much down the country anyway. They want to be able to live, to maintain and feed their families and rear them in a decent state of comfort, and, above all, they want security. I maintain that that has been denied to the people of Ireland since this Government came into power.

In Gorey, near where I live, we had a thriving prosperous leather factory employing about 180 men. These men were given full employment all the time the inter-Party Government were in power. There was no trade recession and we were not forced to let men go during the three and a half years of the last Government. When Fianna Fáil came into power that state of affairs was soon changed. When they were exactly six months in power the 180 employees in that factory were reduced to 40; some 140 of them were thrown on the roads. They stayed in their own country. They were a dead weight around the neck of the people who were working. They had to draw unemployment benefit. As Deputies know, unemployment benefit does not go on indefinitely. But the unemployment in this particular factory went on and eventually we lost from the town of Gorey 50 or 60 wage earners, most of whom were married men rearing families in comfort until Fianna Fáil came into office. These men were added to the list of unemployed throughout the towns in the country. That gives us an idea of the unhappy position in this country at the present moment.

At the recent by-election the people of Dublin with no uncertain voice told the Fianna Fáil Government to quit. I think that is a fair statement. After all, if there is a two to one majority against a Government, the intimation to that Government is that the people no longer want them there. Perhaps Dublin has received more from this Government — or shall I put it in a better way? — that it has suffered less hardship under this Government than the rural constituencies.

When the Minister was speaking this morning many of us were hoping that he would outline some policy which would alter the state of affairs we are facing to-day, some policy which would be for the benefit of the country. What will happen in Dublin if the present rate of expansion goes on? The size of Dublin is far in excess of what it should be; it is top heavy. There are far too many industries in Dublin. Some of these industries should have been established in the country. What are we to look forward to if the present unhappy state of affairs continues? We can look forward to mass unemployment. What does that mean in Dublin? It means that an overburdened agricultural industry, which is the whole basis of our economic life, will be further taxed to maintain the people brought into Dublin by the extensive development here, and so produce a worsening of the unhappy industrial situation which is developing. We have too many industries centred in Dublin; we have too few industries centred in the country.

In view of the heavy rate of interest which Fianna Fáil have seen fit to bring about people may leave Dublin and go to live in the country because it is cheaper. But, if they do, the Minister, who is responsible for developing industry in this country, will want to give to these people some opportunity of living. But the difficulty about that is the curtailing of building which is bound to occur, and which will affect many of our factories scattered throughout the country. We have a furniture factory in Wexford and an electrical equipment factory in New Ross. Such factories as these are largely dependent on the building of houses, because new houses require electrical equipment and furniture. We have already large industrial unemployment in the country, and there will be a worsening of that situation. I do not know how long this Government will remain in office.

Anyway the people of the country are hoping that it will not be long. The question I am asked nearly every day of the week since the by-election in Dublin is: "Have you any chance of getting them out?" Presumably however they will hold on. Those who are supporting them will cling like leeches to them and they will all go down together. If they are going to hold on I hope that the Government will try to give us some sort of constructive policy. As they have floated a loan of £20,000,000 I hope that they will use that money to endeavour to develop the country and to rectify the unhappy state of affairs which they have created. If they are not prepared to do that I think that there is only one honourable thing for them to do. I understand that the Taoiseach is returning next week and I am sure I hope that he returns in good health. He has been away for some time now and when he realises the condition which things have got to in this country, a condition which, I submit, is not due to outside influences but solely and purely to mismanagement, misgovernment and a total lack of foresight in policy, I hope that the Taoiseach will do what the Irish people want him to do: dissolve Dáil Éireann and accept the will of the people.

Comment on this

My contribution to this debate will be brief. Possibly there is no person here who knows better than I do and than the Chair does the effect this Bill will have on rural constituencies such as we represent. When the present Government came into power they appointed a Parliamentary Secretary to the Government whose sole duty was to look after the Gaeltacht. I am trying to tell this House that the Gaeltacht is fast dwindling and if we continue at the rate we are going in a few years' time we will have no Gaeltacht left.

I do not want to talk of politics as far as the Gaeltacht is concerned, but I say that day after day the Gaeltacht is being denuded of its Irish speakers. Even worse, those Irish speakers are now practically cursing the day on which they became Irish speakers because they are suffering a handicap in not knowing the English language. I had hoped that my very good friend the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government would be able to stem the flow of emigration from the Gaeltacht but unfortunately that flow is gathering day after day. I thought that one of the first actions of the present Government would be to endeavour to follow in the footsteps of their predecessors and give us rural electrification in all the Gaeltacht areas. We in Donegal have the largest Gaeltacht in Ireland and yet, with the exception of a very small area in the Glencolumbcille district, we have no such thing as rural electrification and without it we cannot expect industries. If we are to continue merely paying lip service to the Gaeltacht as we have been doing for the last 25 years, however, then very shortly it will no longer be required.

I had placed great faith in the appointment of a Parliamentary Secretary to look after fisheries and a Parliamentary Secretary to look after the Gaeltacht, but we will very shortly have no Gaeltacht to look after and I am afraid that we will have no inshore fisheries to look after. I know that it may be outside the scope of the present Bill, but I wish to say that were it not for the fact that Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture endeavoured to set up fish-meal factories on our coasts, when these German trawlers about which we have heard so much got active and became the paying proposition we are led to believe they may have become, our inshore fisheries would have been completely wiped out. I want to see more fish-meal factories and more quick-freezing plants erected along our seaboard. I want to see canneries if possible and I think the Minister should do something about providing canneries wherein we could utilise our surplus fish, our surplus poultry and our surplus fruit and vegetables. These are things that could be done for our congested districts but unfortunately no effort whatsoever is being made to stem the flow of emigration from them.

The cost of living has gone up and that is no encouragement to any person to remain at home. We complain about the poor rate which rural Ireland must pay, but do not forget that when the cost of living goes up the cost of the inmates in our institutions goes up, and so sure as to-day follows yesterday the rates all over the country will go up next year. We must provide for the inmates in the various institutions — we have no option, and while Government policy is tending towards an increased cost of living we in the various local councils must surely follow that trend and increase our rates. That again hits the ratepayer and tends to drive him out of the country.

We heard a great deal about hand-won turf. I remember that in the days of the inter-Party Government we heard it said in this House that the inter-Party Government had killed the hand-won turf scheme in the congested districts and day after day that lie has had to be nailed. We have had to quote the Minister when he told us that hand-won turf was no longer economic and when instructions were sent down to the various county councils informing them that the production of hand-won turf would have to cease. We looked for a revival of this prosperous industry on the change of Government but we no longer heard of hand-won turf. That is a thing of the past and no one is interested any longer, but unfortunately the people who were engaged in the winning of the turf have no substitute employment and are thrown on the labour market, on employment assistance or on the dole. It is either the dole or emigration for them and with the increased cost of living who can blame them for emigrating? Nobody.

Again, the Tánaiste mooted the recommendation of Córas Iompair Éireann that it might be necessary to curtail the radius in which private lorry owners might operate. Do not forget that, first of all, we closed the railways; we threw ourselves on road transport and if we curtail the radius in which these private lorries may operate we are going to hit at anything that is left of the hand-won turf industry. We are going to nail and finish it.

I thought that under the Undeveloped Areas Act something would be done for what was originally known as the congested areas. I put down a question in this House as to the number of applications which were received from people in West Donegal. I am satisfied now, despite the fact that that Act has become law, that over the past 12 months not a solitary industry has been established in the biggest Gaeltacht in Ireland, West Donegal. Were it not for what my colleague, Deputy Blowick, did in the line of afforestation we would have no employment in that congested area. Were it not for the fact that Deputy Dillon had the foresight to establish in Killybegs fishmeal and quick-freezing plants we would have no industry whatever in South-West Donegal.

However, we have a rival to the industry there in three German trawlers. I have a question down on this matter; I do not wish to anticipate the answer but I would like to know how these crews were recruited for these three German trawlers. I would like to know were the unemployed fishermen of West Donegal consulted when these vacancies existed for fishermen on these German trawlers. It would be most interesting to hear the reply to the question I put down. We have an unemployed surplus of fishermen.

We have an unemployed surplus of navigators and deep-sea fishermen, and still we must employ foreign skippers for these foreign trawlers which we have purchased. I wonder how many of these fishermen employed on these three trawlers are Irish speakers? I would be most interested to know and I shall ply the House with questions until I find out. These are the small matters, if you wish, which could be seen to and which could be of assistance in retaining Irish speakers in Irish-speaking parts of Ireland. Recently I suggested that possibly some of our unemployed Irish musicians could be employed, say, by Radio Éireann in various ways.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That scarcely arises on Supplies and Services.

Comment on this

With the greatest respect, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, I submit it must arise. We are really discussing at the moment employment and unemployment and the methods by which we can banish this curse and evil of unemployment. Nothing, no matter how small, should be overlooked, in endeavouring to retain in this country the Irish people who are flowing out. Day after day we take up our newspapers and find that technicians and experts are being brought in here to advise us on various matters. We are not ashamed of our Irish experts, our Irish skilled and unskilled labourers but, for goodness' sake, I appeal to the Government: keep them at home; employ them at home. By doing that we will be building up the Ireland which we all hope to see.

Comment on this

I hoped that this debate would be finished by now and I was surprised when I came in to find the lines on which it was running. I was more surprised when I heard the speech we had from Deputy Dr. Esmonde. A very patethic case he put forward about the unhappy state which this country is in. He did tell us a number of things in regard to the inter-Party Government and particularly in regard to events just prior to the defeat of that Government. I think each and every one of us in this House knows that at that time there was another Esmonde in this House and he did not have the same views as those of Deputy Dr. Esmonde. We can have political cainism just as we can have the other kind. For some reason or another, Deputy Dr. Esmonde went out of his way to make some references to those Deputies who, like myself, generally support the Government.

I want to make it perfectly clear to Deputy Dr. Esmonde and to everybody else that I make no apology for so doing. I am supporting the Government because I believe it is a better Government than the kind of Government we would have if we had Deputy Blowick and a few other members back as Ministers of a Government that, in fact, did nothing during the period they were in office. Deputy Dr. Esmonde talks about the Social Welfare Acts. Deputy Esmonde, if he was acquainting himself with that period, will remember that in three years we could not get that Social Welfare Act on the Statute Book. Why was it not put on the Statute Book? Why was it being held up?— because the Minister who was trying to bring it in was prevented by the group of Deputies in the Party to which Deputy Dr. Esmonde now belongs. They prevented it seeing the light of day and they prevented it being an Act. That was the sort of Government we had at that time.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

It is perfectly so. We were anxious at that time also to put a little Bill through dealing with adoption and Deputies on all sides of the House were anxious to have it enacted. The Minister for Justice of the Fine Gael Party, now Deputy General MacEoin, refused to introduce that Bill and it was only when we got rid of the inter-Party Government that we were able to get that Bill introduced and passed into law.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It would have no relation to Supplies and Services.

Comment on this

On a point of order, would the Deputy mind explaining to the House what the Legal Adoption Bill has to do with Supplies and Services?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has already pointed that out to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the speech I heard from Deputy Dr. Esmonde, the main tenor of which was that an inter-Party Government was better than the present Government. There was the same story to relate in regard to restrictive practices. We have now a Bill before the House, and even Deputy Davin will not suggest that it is not relevant to this discussion.

Comment on this

No. I knew the other one was not and so did you.

Comment on this

As far as this Government is concerned, a Bill has been brought in for the purpose of establishing industry in the Gaeltacht and undeveloped areas. Every facility is available to help in the development of such industry. A Bill such as this can be discussed in a common-sense way but, apparently, we are just going to have the usual hash on this Bill that we have had on everything else. Deputy Dr. Esmonde talks about "the native Irish." I am quite certain that that is his approach to the people—"the native Irish." We have our "native Irish Government." During the last debate in which he participated he was talking about the "native negroes" that he knew so well out in Africa.

I want to make it perfectly clear to Deputy Dr. Esmonde and to anybody else who wants to know that I believe this Government is doing good work; I believe it will continue to do good work; I believe it is necessary that it should be maintained in office and, as far as I am concerned, my vote will keep it in office. I want that to be perfectly clear.

Comment on this

We are not worrying about your vote.

Comment on this

No, but apparently a lot of people are. I just want to make that perfectly clear.

Comment on this

That is as clear as anything can be.

Comment on this

I could not be more positive.

Comment on this

It is sticking out every day.

Comment on this

We have the usual talk here to the effect that the result of the Dublin North-West election means that when the Taoiseach comes back he should dissolve the Dáil and go to the country. Many people would be surprised and shocked if he took that step and I think Deputy Davin would be one of them.

Comment on this

No. If I got away 14 times, I would get away 15 times.

Comment on this

There is always a last time.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin should not forget that an election in his constituency was within the bounds of possibility in the last two years and he was the one man who prevented any steps being taken that might result in that election. Why? Because he was afraid of an election in his own constituency. Deputy Davin knows that perfectly well.

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Peadar Maher. He would not repeat that and he knows more than the Deputy and I know more than the Deputy knows about the circumstances.

Comment on this

Do not talk about the results of elections. Results of elections often bring surprises.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cowan would be advised to come back to the Supplies and Services Bill.

Comment on this

Are Deputy Cowan's remarks relevant to the Supplies and Services Bill?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have just informed the Deputy that they are not.

Comment on this

I was only keeping myself in line with the debate. The suggestion was that, because of a certain result in a Dublin constituency, there must be a general election. The same appeal was not made when the results in Waterford and North Mayo came in and they were just as important as the result in Dublin. There has been some criticism and there has been some praise of the electors of Dublin North-West.

Comment on this

Where Labour would not put a man in the field.

Comment on this

The people in Dublin North-West are a decent, generous and charitable people and when they are asked to do something for charitable reasons they do it.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Deputy Blaney will have your life.

Comment on this

I do not know what Deputy O'Sullivan means by that but, as far as I know, in every election that has taken place since the State was founded, when a relative of a deceased member went up for election, that relative was elected. I know of no case in which the relative was defeated whether the candidate was Fianna Fáil. Fine Gael, Labour or otherwise.

Comment on this

Why did not you give him a walk over in that case?

Comment on this

You did.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Deputy came to West Cork to make sure that Deputy Murphy would be elected.

Comment on this

Yes, the relative again. I say that the people of Dublin are a charitable people just as the people in any other constituency in Ireland are charitable people.

Comment on this

Like yourself.

Comment on this

I hope I have some of those qualities. If that factor were considered there would be less of the irresponsible speeches such as we had from Deputy Dr. Esmonde. I have said all I want to say. If there had been any likelihood of the Minister getting in I would not have said anything but I saw that Deputy Blowick was ready with his tomes for a long speech. I am quite certain that he will tell us the marvellous job he did in three and a half years in dividing estates and making land available for the ordinary people.

Comment on this

Would that be relevant?

Comment on this

I think it would be relevant to increased production.

Comment on this

What does the Chair say?

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick, as everybody knows, was the most promising Minister we had in any Government. No man promised more division of land than he did and no man divided so little.

Comment on this

No man sent up more migrants than he did. I know that.

Comment on this

And you were there to welcome them.

Comment on this

Certainly, like a man.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan made a remark in reply to Deputy O'Donnell——

Comment on this

I did not mention him.

Comment on this

——to the effect that there was not much afforestation——

Comment on this

I never mentioned forestry. It was land division.

Comment on this

You mentioned it in the earlier part of your speech.

Comment on this

Never.

Comment on this

As regards forestry, I want to tell Deputy Cowan that I am very proud of what was done for forestry and reafforestation during the time of the inter-Party Government. I do not want to sound my own trumpet, but I will sound the trumpet of the inter-Party Government for what they did. I am quite prepared to take the bricks for whatever we failed to do or omitted to do. More realism should be brought into the debates, particularly into a debate on such a serious matter as Supplies and Services. Talking about the Dublin North-West election and so on is of little use and it is time we got down to brass tacks. For Captain Cowan's information, whatever the inter-Party Government did, whether wrong or right, there are a few major problems still facing the country. If we of this generation and we members of this House are serious in tackling them even now, we should cut out the nonsense and get down to the work.

One of the serious problems is emigration which is only a reflection of a hundred and one ills here which we should tackle. Deputy Cowan in his earlier remarks would appear to treat afforestation lightly.

Comment on this

I never mentioned it.

Comment on this

He pressed you when in office.

Comment on this

Yes, while he was supporting the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this

I ask for the record. I never mentioned afforestation, or Deputy O'Donnell. I do not know whether it is within the rules of the House to produce the record of what was said.

Comment on this

There are many records we would like to go back on.

Comment on this

That is the old tactic, to say I said such a thing and then knock it down.

Comment on this

You did, in West Cork.

Comment on this

I never mentioned afforestation.

Comment on this

This time last year the House was in ecstasies about a Bill passing through here — the Undeveloped Areas Bill. I do not know where the fault lies but I am afraid that Act has been an absolute flop. I would not like to be guilty of jumping in too soon — like the boy who sowed the seeds one day and expected results the next — but I am anxious that something should be done for the Gaeltacht. Perhaps the Minister is not to blame; perhaps the Bill did not go far enough or perhaps it was not wide enough. I repeat what I said last year, that I believe the Minister framed the Bill and put it before the House with the best intentions. However, the Gaeltacht has been shamefully neglected under that Act. I do not say that the board established under it is responsible. Perhaps it is the lack of initiative that is responsible; perhaps the framework of the Act is responsible. Only one factory I know of in Mayo is under way and that is the one in Kiltimagh.

Comment on this

Is not there one in Ballina?

Comment on this

The one in Ballina is only talk. The order for biscuits is being talked about still but no biscuits have yet come out of it. I do not say it is all a fraud but so far there is no factory there or preparation for one. In Kiltimagh there are visible signs, in the site levelling, which is at least giving employment to some of the country lads. The Ballina factory has not shown above ground so far. Perhaps it is sprouting and the sprouts have not yet reached the surface.

Why is some effort not being made where the greatest population is and from which there is the greatest emigration — the mountainous areas of Mayo, Galway and Donegal? I was astonished to find that nothing had been done in Donegal.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that nothing can happen under that Act unless some private enterprise starts it.

Comment on this

Perhaps he wants socialism.

Comment on this

After one year's trial would the Minister examine the question as, if the initiative is not forthcoming, the Act is failing in its purpose. Every Act fails in spots, even with the best intentions, as the human mind cannot visualise every possibility and bring in a piece of legislation which will be absolutely the last word.

I do not blame the Minister. If the Act failed in that respect and if the initiative is not coming from the people of the locality, something should be done. I think the Minister was at one with me when we all hoped it would establish industries in the mountainous areas where there are big groups of population——

Comment on this

The Deputy will see, if he looks up what I said, that it was hoped to result in establishing industries in towns and nowhere else.

Comment on this

Does that mean the country is left out?

Comment on this

There are towns in Connacht, too.

Comment on this

If we want to maintain the towns we must do something for the rural population. I did not understand that from the Minister when the Bill was going through and I do not think there is anything in the Bill to say that.

Comment on this

Common sense suggests that people who are starting industries will go to the places where they will get water supplies, transport facilities, housing for the workers, and so on. If they are prepared to go to the undeveloped areas we will give them additional help, but only additional help.

Comment on this

It is by the result of a Bill that we know what it is doing and where it fails. The Minister must realse that it has failed signally in bringing employment into those areas.

Comment on this

We sowed the seed in 1952 and hope to reap the profit in 1953.

Comment on this

I am not going to adopt the attitude of taking the Minister by the throat simply because this Act did not work in the way the majority expected. Emigration is greatest where the land is of the poorest quality. In the mountainous areas, there is the greatest congregation of people and the heaviest population. Whenever there is poverty and privation, if you go to those areas you will find it at its worst. If the Bill is not remedying that, I would impress seriously on the Minister the need to overhaul the whole Act and remedy any faults that have come to light.

Comment on this

Two power stations in West Mayo is not bad.

Comment on this

That is in North Mayo.

Comment on this

It is County Mayo, all the same.

Comment on this

That is all to the good. If the factory in Ballina materialises it will do good, too. The one in Kiltimagh is going ahead and we are proud of it, but from Bangor Erris to Galway Bay there is a huge stretch of country, densely population, from which there is the greatest emigration and there is no factory, no power station and no attempt at anything. I hope the Minister will not think I am talking politics. The Bill was intended as a genuine effort to induce the population to remain there. In that area there is the hard core of native Irish speakers, where the tongue is spoken in its purity. That little hard core is diminishing day by day and we should do something about it. I want to impress that on the Minister, so that he will bring it to the notice of the Government and of his colleague the Minister for Lands. During my time in office — and I hope this will not be taken as blowing my own trumpet but taken just as a pointer in order to get the assistance of the Minister — we realised that if we want to maintain people in rural Ireland the best form of employment is in afforestation. I move the adjournment of the debate.

Comment on this