Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 1–127 of 436. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
In listening to the singularly uninformative speech of the Minister for Finance last night, I gained very strongly the impression that he was endeavouring, as far as possible, to give the House and the country the impression that he was disclaiming responsibility for the enormous expenditure proposed in the Book of Estimates presented by him to the Dáil this year. He used phrases such as: "The volume of Estimates must give us all food for thought" and he spoke about his anxiety as Minister for Finance looking at the ever-increasing cost of the public service. He implicitly if not explicitly criticised the members of this House for what he called their uncritical approach to the problems of Government expenditure and public finance. He said that in recent years we had become so accustomed to think in terms of millions that an entirely uncritical attitude had developed with regard to proposals for State expenditure. I wonder did he recall the statement made by his colleague, Deputy Dr. Ryan, the Minister for Health, last year, when speaking on the general resolution for the Budget, he said, as reported at column 1529, Volume 130, No. 10: "We speak in millions"? Was it an echo from that phrase that induced the Minister for Finance last night to say that the members of this House had developed uncritical faculties in dealing with matters of public finance?
I have always understood that the Estimates as presented in the annual Book of Estimates gave at least an indication of Government policy. The Minister himself last night made use of an expression to which I think, having regard to what I have said, some importance must be attached because while realising and recognising, to some extent at least, the fact that these Estimates as they are presented to the Dáil, do give an indication of Government policy, he added the rather significant phrase:—
"Because the Vote on Accounts founded as it is, on the detailed Estimates of public expenditure set out in the Volume of Estimates, presents a statistical survey of public policy as formulated by the Government".
Passing from that statement which is entirely unexceptional he went on to use a very different phrase: "And endorsed by Dáil Éireann." What is the significance of the phrase: "And endorsed by Dáil Éireann"? Am I not justified, at least in entertaining the suspicion, that the Minister is trying to make it appear to the public that it is these uncritical Deputies of Dáil Éireann who have so lost a sense of financial responsibility, so lost a sense of their duties to their constituents and to the public generally as to have no right critical approach to any matters of public finance and who have an irresponsible attitude to State expenditure, that he wanted the public to think: "I am the just man amongst all these irresponsible Deputies, I am the person who is forced to bring in this Book of Estimates having on the face of it the record figure of £100,500,000"?
I have always understood that the Book of Estimates constituted an indication of Government policy. It is presented to the Dáil whose duty it is to accept or reject these proposals but whether they are accepted or rejected, before they are, to use the phrase made use of by the Minister for Finance last night, "endorsed by Dáil Éireann", they represent Government policy by which the Government must stand or fall. There is no use in the Minister making the pretence, as I think he did last night, that he is thejust orthodox financier standing between the public and a rapacious Dáil, who have no sense of their responsibility and no critical faculty so far as a proper examination of the expenditure on State services is concerned.
If the Minister for Finance wishes his statement to be accepted as having any degree of bona fidesin it, then what he should have done is this. If he is satisfied, and apparently we are to take it from what he said that he is satisfied, that the rate of Government expenditure is excessive, that there must be a halt and that unless some effort is made to curb Government expenditure the problem of next year's Budget will be grave indeed, his duty was, not to bring in that Book of Estimates for £100,500,000 which it is proposed to expend on Government services for the coming year; his duty was to take a stand, even at the risk of losing his position as Minister for Finance on what he was trying to say throughout his entire speech—that he does not like the Book of Estimates, that he does not really stand over it and that it is the irresponsible and uncritical members of the Dáil, including his own colleague, Deputy Dr. Ryan who said last year that he spoke in millions, who are responsible for forcing him and his colleagues in the Government to bring this record figure for public expenditure before the Dáil this year. I think also that a greater degree of credence would have been given to his posturings last night had he not in the course of a speech in which he was dealing with this high degree of public expenditure which was searing his orthodox financial soul, taken occasion from time to time to make boastful references to the extent to which he himself and his colleagues in the Government had increased public expenditure on certain items over and above what the inter-Party Government had provided in their time. The Minister for Finance and his colleagues must face their responsibilities in this matter. They have brought in this record figure for public expenditure. It is is higher than it has ever been before. They have put it into a Book of Estimates in such a form that it is impossible to say which of these itemsare capital, which of these items are appropriate to be financed out of borrowings, which of the items must be paid for out of current expenditure and whether or not there is any financial policy with regard to capital expenditure on productive enterprises in this country. They brought it in in that form. They have recommended to the House Estimates of a character higher than they have ever been before —and for that they must take full responsibility.
There is no use in saying that there must be a curb on public expenditure Before that Book of Estimates was brought in was the time to curb public expenditure and to say, in the Minister's view and in the view of the Government, in what respects each or any of the items in that Book of Estimates could be pruned or curbed or cut. The Minister and his colleagues in the Government must now take responsibility for the fact that they have proposed to this House and to the people of the country an expenditure of £100,000,000 odd in the course of the coming year and at the close of a financial year during which this country has suffered from the economic and financial policy of the Government to such an extent as to bring havoc and human suffering to all sections of the people.
I have little doubt, without having the full or proper information before me—without even having an accurate estimate of the revenue and expenditure of the Government in the financial year which is just ending— that what all the Minister's posturings and posing mean is that the Government know that they must decrease taxation or get out of office; that they know that they can decrease taxation, having regard to the experience which they have gone through during the past year, and that they intend to decrease taxation.
I want to recall to the minds of Deputies of this House the forecast which we gave last year on the debate on the Budget Resolutions. We said then that the Minister for Finance was bringing in a harsh, oppressive, unjust and unnecessary Budget in order that he could pose before the country as afinancial purist dealing with a difficult situation which only a policy of austerity could solve and in order that, this year, he could show that he had accomplished that difficult and thankless task and is now in a position to ease the burden of taxation on the people. I have no doubt whatever that that is what is at the back of all the talk which has been going on in the past few days.
All the Ministers who have been touring the country over the week-end have been singing the same tune. They are all saying that the limit of taxable capacity has been reached by the people. The only light interlude that we had was that the Tánaiste— the Minister for Industry and Commerce—instead of having the country round corners, now has the country going across a hump. We have reached the limit of taxable capacity. Who brought this country to that limit and was there any justification for so doing? That is the investigation that we have to conduct during the course of the discussion on this Vote on Account.
The Minister disclaimed last night any idea of justifying his economic or his financial policy. Before this debate closes, however, I think that he will be forced—even in anticipation of his Budget statement—to give at least some justification for the measures that he took in April of last year and which have brought such suffering to every section of the community. I propose to give, in as short a space as possible, some attention to a critical examination of the philosophy underlying the financial policy of the Minister for Finance and the economic policy of the Government, as evidenced by their financial proposals last year, in the course of the remarks I have to make. I approach that task of critical examination of the Government's financial and economic policy with all the more assurance because we on this side of the House over the past year and a half have expounded in detail a policy, financial and economic, which would have solved all the economic and financial ills of which the Minister for Finance made such complaint lastnight and of which his colleagues have been complaining throughout the country for the past 18 months.
We do not come here as destructive critics. At the Fine Gael Árd Fheis of last year, at the Fine Gael Árd Fheis of this year, in speeches made in Kilkenny, Cavan, Carlow, Cork, Dublin and elsewhere, I gave details of our policy, following upon the policy initiated and put into operation by the inter-Party Government, and of all these matters which would have relieved the State expenditure of the appalling burden which is now placed upon it by the Minister for Finance's proposals and the policy of his Government. We gave details of our proposals. There has never been a single criticism by any member of the Government of any of these detailed proposals which we expounded as our policy and as our cure for the economic ills from which this country is suffering at present.
There is no use in the Minister for Finance throwing up his hands when introducing this Vote on Account and saying that there must be a limit to Government expenditure. It is quite clear that the only policy that the Minister for Finance has in reference to the Budget is what we, in some of the speeches that we made in recent times, have called the book-keeping approach to the Estimates and to the Budget. They are nothing but bookkeepers. So long as the account books on public finance are balanced and in proper order it matters not to orthodox finance, as expounded by the Minister for Finance, whether or not there is unemployment, progressively increasing emigration, stagnation of business, restriction of credit, a falling off in purchasing power and human suffering in every section of the community. That was the British teaching, example and practice during the years 1930 to 1936. That was the orthodox financial policy of the British Treasury between 1930 and 1936—a policy which was proved to be a failure. That is the foundation and the root of all the financial and economic policy of the present Minister for Finance and his colleagues in the Government. So long as the Public Accounts are balanced—so long as a good public accountant can say: "That is good accountancy"—then the Department of Finance is satisfied with that policy, and it matters not that the budgetary policy has no part in framing economic or financial policy for the purpose of dealing with the economic problems of the country.
Last year we heard the philosophy of the Minister for Finance when he introduced the Budget. During the course of his speech on that occasion we heard the Minister for Finance's urgent statements about the necessity for more production. I want to quote now from column 1114 of the Official Report of the 2nd April, 1952—Volume 130 No. 8. The Minister for Finance stated:—
"Agricultural produce in fact is the foundation of by far the greater part of our export trade."
With the realisation of that very fundamental fact, he then, in a later part of his speech, dealt with industrial production, and, speaking at column 1117 of the same volume, he proceeded to deal with the role that industry had to play in this country in reference to a contribution towards our export trade. He realised the value of agricultural production in our export trade and this is what he said about the contribution that is to be given by trade and industry to that export trade:—
"If these industries are to play their part in providing employment, those who are engaged in them must concern themselves not only with the home market but most urgently with the development of an export market for their products. Coupled with an increase in agricultural production for export, this would be a remedy for most of our problems."
That is an entirely unexceptional statement. He then goes on to speak about the necessity for efficiency and low costs and in connection with our export market he said:—
"The export market, however, is highly competitive, so that efficiency of production and low costs are of first importance."
Later, about the middle of column 1118, he said:—
"Nor should it be overlooked that the element of cost, which is so frequently submerged in a highly protected home market, is of predominant importance in the export trade."
Let us see how those principles have been worked out in practice as a result of budgetary policy. So far as agricultural production is concerned, Ministers are complaining that it is not as high as it should be. They are talking about agricultural production. Last night, the Minister for Finance again repeated the practice to which I referred in a recent speech that I made as to the policy of Ministers going around appealing for harder work and talking about more production, but providing no policy which would lead to greater production either agricultural or industrial.
In the speech which I made recently —I am quoting it for the purpose of brevity and so that I may not be repeating myself at too great length— this is what I said:—
"Ministers of the present Government indulge themselves in repeated exhortations to increase production, while at the same time pursuing a financial policy which has only had the inevitable effect of reducing production and increasing unemployment. We cannot be content with mere exhortations to harder work and increased production, but must, instead, take steps to change the conditions of production in such a way as to lead to that creation of wealth which alone can bring a greater measure of prosperity."
Last night, the Minister for Finance appealed for more production in the same general sort of way without giving the slightest indication as to what the policy was which would lead to such increased production and greater wealth. He said towards the close of his speech, following upon the statement to which I have already referred, that the volume of the Estimates "must give us all food for thought," and then he asked, "are we going to be able to raise thenecessary revenues," and said that the only way in which we can do that is by increased production.
What has been the effect of the financial policy of the Minister and his colleagues, as put into active operation during the financial year, and of the budgetary policy of April of last year? So far as agriculture is concerned we have now reached the point where it is almost visible that agricultural production for export is no longer economic. The red light must be flashed and flashed insistently before the minds of the Government, because, as a result of the financial policy put into operation by the last Budget, costs have been increased in every direction, both by the withdrawal of subsidies and by increased taxation, by the increase in prices and by the assault that was made on purchasing power. Agricultural wages, the same as for every other class in the community with the one exception— the civil servants—have been increased and have had to be increased
All that has been the effect of Government policy. So far as agricultural production is concerned, we have reached that point of extreme danger to the agricultural industry. I cannot emphasise that aspect of our economic condition too strongly. It will be dealt with in greater detail by a greater expert than I can claim to be on agriculture—by my colleague Deputy Dillon—in the course of the remarks which he will have to make on this Vote on Account. But it is of vital importance that the people of this country should realise what I have said. I do not wish to indulge in hyperbolic expressions. I content myself merely by saying that this serious condition is there by reason of the effect of the budgetary and economic policy of the present Government on trade, agriculture and industry.
Already, certain of those agricultural products have become uneconomic for export. We are facing the grave danger that some of our stable agricultural products will no longer be capable of being exported atan economic figure. That is a very serious danger for this country. The Minister for Finance, in the quotation which I have given from his speech made last year, realised that agricultural produce is "the foundation of by far the greater part of our export trade." If, as a result of the financial policy of the Government, that export trade is in jeopardy, then the condition of this country is very grave indeed.
What has been the effect upon our industrial production for export? That was the second limb on which the Minister based his policy of restoring financial order, as he called it, last year—increased agricultural production with increased industrial production for export. In the course of his remarks, which I have referred to and quoted, he laid emphasis on the fact, as Deputies know, that efficiency and low costs enter very largely into the question of our capacity to export our industrial products.
What is the position at present as regards industrial production? Everyone knows that industrial production here by reason of circumstances, historical and otherwise, is high cost production at the best of times, which makes it difficult for us to compete with other States in the export market; but, in respect of every single item that enters into the costs of industrial production, those costs have been increased enormously by the policy of the present Government as put into operation by the last Budget. Wages have been increased. Purchasing power in the hands of the community has been cut. There has been a refusal by the members of the community to purchase. There has been restriction in credit, no matter what members of the Government may say. There has been stagnation in trade.
How is it possible in that state of facts for any hope to emerge under the present Government and its financial policy for anything in the nature of industrial exports to come to the aid of our balance of payments situation as he hoped for last year?
We have got really to the pointwhere the effect of Government policy has been to damage our competitive position by increasing the costs of our industrial produce and we have done that at a time when in many commodities and on many items world costs are falling.
There is the picture of the result of Government financial policy in the last financial year on our agricultural industry and on our industrial production. Of course, we have balanced our international accounts—we all knew you could balance your international accounts—but at what a price. We have balanced our international accounts at the price of depression, deflation, unemployment and human misery. It is very easy to do that. We always knew that that could be done. The Central Bank pointed out the way and the Minister for Finance and his colleagues took the path pointed out to them by the Central Bank. But we would not take that path which led to these results of deflation, depression, unemployment and human misery.
In the course of the remarks I have to make I will have something to say on this problem of the balance of payments which was put last year in the forefront of the Minister's speech as the problem that had to be solved. Let us say that the problem has been solved. Let us assume, contrary to the facts, that the problem has been solved by the budgetary devices adopted last year by the Minister for Finance, by his assault on personal incomes, by his deliberate policy of creating unemployment. By increasing the price of essential materials, and thereby decreasing the purchasing power in the hands of the community, he has undoubtedly cut imports; he has undoubtedly cut consumption, but, equally undoubtedly, he has caused lack of confidence, depression in trade and industry, stagnation in business, unemployment, emigration and human misery and suffering throughout the country.
The Minister for Finance last year stated that the reason why he was having an early Budget was the urgent need to restore order in the public finances and in our general economy—column 1113 of the Budget Debate, 2nd April, 1952. Further on, at column 1154 he was dealing with his intention of having a loan and he said:
"With all due regard for the position of our existing bondholders—"
The existing bondholders now reading that phrase will certainly take a poor view of the concern the Minister had for them.
"—we shall do our part to make the new issue attractive to all classes of potential investors. We can say truthfully to them that in this Budget onerous as it may be, we have done what is essential, but no more than is essential to put the public finances in order and to revive confidence in the credit and stability of the State."
Take these two statements of the Minister for Finance now and judge them by the results of the Budget in the last 12 months. Can anybody say that there exists at the present time public confidence in the stability of the State? Is not the outstanding feature of our economy at the present moment the entire lack of confidence, the fear that nobody knows what the future holds, the fear of the unemployed, the fear of those who are in part-time employment that to-day, to-morrow and next week there may be no employment, the fear that those in full employment now will be in part-time employment in a short time or in full unemployment in perhaps a shorter time still? Can anybody say that the Minister had done nothing more than was necessary to restore public confidence in the credit of the State? Has he not done exactly the direct opposite to that by the financial proposals that he put into effect, proposals which were based, as I will show in a moment, upon the thesis that the people of this country had more income than they required for their needs and that they were eating too much and living too well? That was the philosophy behind the Budget.
The food subsidies were reduced. I will take the Minister's own figures, although I objected to them last year. The Minister said that he would save£3.9 million in this financial year on the cut in subsidies and he put £11.2 million on taxation. What has been the effect of the saving of that £3.9 million on food subsidies and of the extra taxation to the extent of £11.2 million on the economy of the people and on the human sufferings of individual citizens? It does not require any advocacy on my part. It needs no over-painting of the gloomy picture which obtains in practically every home throughout this country to show the effect of the Minister's onerous Budget on each individual citizen.
Anybody, whatever his walk of life may be, can truthfully say to the Minister that he did not truthfully say that he had done nothing more than was necessary to achieve order in the public finances by his onerous Budget of last year.
In the course of his financial statement the Minister stated that incomes generally had advanced beyond the cost of living. I want to get the exact quotation so that I may not be accused of misquoting the Minister. At column 1137 of the Official Report he said:—
"In agriculture and in industry earnings have advanced since 1938 by more than the cost of living. The food subsidies are now, in practice, nothing more than a State supplement to income generally..."
As reported in the following column, he said:—
"The Government have given careful consideration to this problem over recent months. They are satisfied that, as incomes generally have already advanced more than the cost of living and as essential foodstuffs are no longer scarce, there is now no economic or social justification for a policy of subsidising food for everybody."
There is the philosophy which is the basis of the Minister's financial outlook and policy. He and his colleagues in the Government were satisfied that incomes had advanced more than the cost of living. Nobody but the Minister and his colleagues believed that. Having stated that, being satisfied that incomes had advanced beyond the costof living, they came to the conclusion therefore that there was too much money in the hands of the people and that it had to be got from them by taxation, they proceeded to get it from them by unjust and unnecessary taxation.
There was too much money in the hands of our people last year, according to the Minister, and that is the philosophy behind the Budget. They had too much money for spending purposes and it had to be scooped in by heavy taxation. It had to be scooped in by an increase in the price of ten essential commodities which were released from subsidies. Food subsidies were cut or reduced to the extent of £3.9 million. The price of tea, sugar, butter, bread and other essential commodities was increased. That is how the Minister assaulted the personal incomes of the citizens of this country and prevented them from doing what they had a right to do, using their excessive income over their necessary expenditure in any way they liked, either by saving or otherwise. The people were living and eating too well, apparently, and as personal incomes had advanced beyond the cost of living they had to be taken from them in heavy taxation. As they were living too well the price of butter, tea, sugar and bread had to be increased so that their standard of living might be depressed as well as their capacity for purchasing commodities had to be curtailed.
That was not sufficient, however. Having stated that as his philosophy and finally put that philosophy into practice by means of cutting the subsidies and the unnecessary increase in taxation, the Minister then proceeded to give the real view at the back of his mind, because at column 1127, having stated what he called the necessary steps which must be taken to produce a healthy economy, he said:—
"As a necessary corollary to these two conditions of economic recovery there must be the greatest restraint in relation to increases in income, whether in the form of profits, wages or salaries."
Personal incomes had increasedbeyond the cost of living, according to the Minister. There was too much purchasing power in the hands of the community. They were living too well and he would see that they ceased to live so well. He would take the necessary measures to see that they would not have in their hands any excessive purchasing power to spend in a way he did not want them to spend. Accordingly, he attacked and assaulted their personal incomes in that way and then issued this warning: "I am taking from you the excessive income that you have over the cost of living and require that you must not try to get an increase of wages because of that."
Having given the history of the food subsidies in an earlier part of his speech, when he said that the original idea of the food subsidies was conceived and put into operation at a time when there was a Standstill Wages Order, he stated that it was in order to relieve the effect on incomes that could not go up because of the Standstill Wages Order and the increase in the prices of essential commodities that subsidisation was resorted to in 1947. But the Budget proposals of that year and the increases put on by the Supplementary Budget of that year were designed for that purpose, because when the Standstill Wages Order had gone the taxes remained and were put on again in increased force and pressure by the Minister last year. He warned as loudly as he dared at the time in these words to people, whether wage earners or salary earners, "you are not to look for any increase in wages or in salaries." Of course what the Minister had in mind was, "We will increase the price of essential commodities and we will tax your surplus income so that you cannot spend it upon consumer goods. You are to stay that way. You are not to try to get any compensation in the way of increased wages because of what I have done."
The Minister's purpose was thwarted and it was thwarted by the very necessities of the occasion and it would be still further thwarted. There would have been higher wages granted that perhaps ought to be granted, having regard to the impositions put on thepeople by the Minister, were it not for the fact that working people and people earning salaries were afraid of unemployment if they asked for more wages. At all events, workers and, to some extent, salaried people in public companies and otherwise were able, notwithstanding the Minister's warning contained in the statement I have adverted to, to gain certain additions to their wages and salaries.
So far as the Minister's intention was concerned, however, his object was to prevent any increase in wages or salaries as far as he could do it, and he did it as far as he could do it with the only people over whom he had any control, the civil servants, the teachers and other public servants of that kind. He has prevented those people from getting the increase to which they are justly entitled because of the conditions which the Minister has created deliberately and as a result of deliberate Budgetary policy last year which inevitably led to demands for increased wages and salaries in the Civil Service as well as in unemployment outside. That indicates the Minister's mentality in reference to these people over whom he and his colleagues had any control. He stated: "We are going to have a Standstill Wages Order," because that is what we meant when we stated: "We are going to assault your personal incomes, take away your excess purchasing power and prevent you from using that excessive purchasing power. We are not going to let you thwart our efforts by getting any compensation by way of increased wages or salaries."
What has been the cost of this to the community? It is incalculable, perhaps it is irreparable. If it is not irreparable, it certainly will remain as an injury to the economic fabric of the State for very many years after the present Government have ceased to be the Government. The position has almost become frozen. Any Government that succeeds the present Government will have a task of appalling difficulty to contend with.
The cost to the community has been incalculable. A sum of £3.9 million was saved to the Exchequer andorthodox finance was pleased because there was a book-keeping gain, there was a saving of £3.9 million. At what expense to the community? Wages have gone up. The costs of industrial production have gone up, and the costs of agricultural production have gone up to a point, as I have already said, at which both agricultural and industrial products have reached the stage where it is almost uneconomic to export them and so reap their contribution to our international payments problem.
We do not know the cost to the community, but in every respect as a result of these impositions and as a result of deliberate budgetary policy costs have increased. Rates are going up. Business has become stagnant. There has been a restriction of credit by the banks following what they believed to be Government policy. No matter what any member of the Government says, be it the Taoiseach or a Minister, there has been a restriction of credit in the last 12 months. One of the things that has contributed most to the disrepute in which the Government is held to-day by decent people is the insistent denial by Ministers that there has been no restriction of credit. Speak to any man whose credit has been restricted, speak to any man who has suffered at the hands of the banks because of the operation of that policy and he will tell one very quickly that there has been a restriction of credit. He will tell one very quickly as to whether or not it is an illusion, as the Minister and the Government would have it. He will tell one very quickly whether or not it is a hard and cruel fact. There has been a restriction of credit and a consequent restriction of business. The greatest damage that has been done, however, is the creation of a lack of confidence that pervades the entire economic atmosphere to-day as a result of Government policy. The cost to the community is incalculable. But orthodox finance has been justified. A sum of £3.9 million appears on the credit side of the financial accounts. Human misery and suffering appear nowhere on those accounts. With those orthodox finance is not concerned.
In the forefront of the Minister's statement last year he placed what he called the nature and magnitude of the problem of the deficit in the balance of payments. I have already said— indeed we have always said this—that that balance of payments deficit could easily be liquidated at the expense of depression, deflation, unemployment and human suffering. Apart from that altogether, Deputies and others in responsible positions who are capable of thinking clearly and in a detached way will remember the exposure through which we put the Minister and his White Paper in the autumn of last year when we exposed the fallacies, the inaccuracies, the falsehoods, the underlying incorrect assumptions, the erroneous statistics and the inaccurate calculations made in that White Paper. We pointed out to the Minister and to his colleagues at the time that they appeared to be making a fetish of the deficit in the adverse balance of trade; that they were obsessed by the fact that they must at all costs and with extreme urgency wipe out for all time the deficit in our international balance of payments.
We pointed out to them at the time from the figures available to us—and we have been justified by every figure that has since become available—that that deficit in the balance of payments which appeared to obsess the Minister and his colleagues in the Government was caused by accidental circumstances in a particular crisis due to international conditions in the year 1951; that because of those conditions and the international uncertainty stockpiling took place; that we in the inter-Party Government had as a deliberate policy encouraged and so far as governmental action was concerned had made effective the stockpiling of essential commodities against the possibility of international disruption of business and trade. Because of that there was inevitably a deficit in our balance of payments but we pointed out that the deficit would automatically tend to correct itself and at the time when we were discussing this White Paper in October, 1951, that automatic trend was even then coming into active operation and the deficit inthe balance of payments, which was then stated by the Minister to be in the order of £70,000,000, was nothing of the sort; that, in any event, in the course of a few months it would correct itself and that this year there would be very little, if any, deficit in our adverse trade balance.
The Minister, of course, stuck to his £70,000,000 as long as he could. Subsequently he reduced it to £60,000,000. In his Budget statement, having put this problem of the deficit in the balance of payments in the forefront of the problems that he alleged were then facing him, he proceeded to make two statements of a remarkable character, statements which show how fundamentally unsound and how erroneous were the assumptions on which the Budget was framed and based. At columns 1123 and 1124 of the Official Report on 2nd April, 1952, the Minister said:—
"Similarly, on the earnings side, while we may expect some increase in export prices the immediate outlook in agriculture would not justify us in counting upon any material increase in the quantity exported. The trade deficits for January and February of this year provide little ground for optimism and it seems clear that, without an improvement in personal savings and a reduction in inflationary Government finance, the deficits in the balance of payments will remain excessive. Allowing for a favourable turn in the terms of trade, for some drawing down of stocks and for increased tourist income, the balance of payments deficit which we faced at the beginning of 1952 was about £50,000,000."
That was one of the assumptions upon which the Minister framed his Budget. In the very forefront of his speech he referred to the problem of the deficit in the balance of payments and on the assumption that there was that year, 1952, a deficit at the rate of £50,000,000 —I am accepting it that the Minister was speaking at the time at the rate of £50,000,000; at all events he said it was going to be excessive—the balance of payments was to remain excessive.The balance of payments last year was practically nothing. I have reason to believe in point of fact that there was not merely no deficit but there was actually an increase in our sterling balance.
In the course of the year following this ridiculous statement by the Minister for Finance and his colleagues that the deficit in the balance of payments would be of the order of £50,000,000, his colleague, the Tánaiste and Minister for Industry and Commerce, attending various banquets was cutting a few millions off that £50,000,000 at every banquet he attended. Finally at a meeting of the Professional Bodies Association in Bray he said the deficit in the balance of payments was in the order of £10,000,000. Between April and October, it had come down to £10,000,000 according to the Minister's colleague.
Let it be £10,000,000 or let it be £12,000,000. I believe myself it would in fact be less than £10,000,000. Let it be a £10,000,000 deficit. Look at the returns for years past and one will find that year by year something in the order of £15,000,000 was coming into this country by way of capital investment from abroad, thereby not merely wiping out that £10,000,000 deficit but leaving an actual surplus of something in the order of £3,000,000 to £5,000,000. Instead of there being a deficit of the order of £50,000,000 last year, a deficit on which budgetary policy was framed, I believe we had a real balance in our international trade because of the policy put into operation by Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Finance in the inter-Party Government.
Again, the Minister was wrong in his diagnosis and in the assumptions upon which he based his Estimates when he said:—
"While we may expect some increase in export prices the immediate outlook in agriculture would not justify us in counting upon any material increase in the quantity exported."
The Minister stated there that there would be no material increase in our agricultural exports. There was anincrease of £20,000,000 over and above what we thought we would get last year. Over £100,000,000 worth of agricultural products were exported last year. Of course, the Minister for Finance in order to justify his assault upon personal incomes, in order to justify himself in the eyes of those people upon whom he was inflicting unemployment and hardship and making an assault upon their personal incomes, had to say that there was no significant increase in agricultural production. There was a dramatic increase last year in our exportable surplus of agricultural products but because of the assault that has been made by the Minister and his colleagues in the Government upon our entire economy that agricultural industry is now in grave jeopardy. We are at the point where the red light must be flashed. Because of the increase in costs of production in the agricultural industry, we may find ourselves in the position of not being able to export sufficient agricultural products to support our economy.
Those are some of the effects of the Minister's Budget. I looked in vain in this Book of Estimates for the capital items. Deputies will recall that our policy in the inter-Party Government was based upon the machinery of the dual Budget. We believe as a fundamental principle of economic policy that it was the Government's duty so to order our economic affairs, so to regulate our economy as to produce the maximum degree of employment. We started out to achieve that and we achieved it. Through the financial and economic policy we adopted, we regulated, as far as government can do it, the level of economic activity to provide the maximum possible of employment in the country. We succeeded, for the first time in the history of the country, in reaching the position where there was practically full employment when we left office in June, 1951. Now we have nearly 90,000 unemployed. We have far more than that 90,000 unemployed because added to that figure there must be the figure of those people who have emigrated in the last 12 months. We have no real guideor index to the number of people who emigrate but we do know you cannot really find the exact figure of unemployed in this country until you find the number of those who, because of lack of employment, have emigrated to England or elsewhere. As against that, we in the inter-Party Government appealed to our people in Great Britain to come back and build our houses over here. We asked them to come back and they came back. The skilled workers are now leaving the country in their hundreds every day.
There is a further consideration which may be a very tragic consequence. It may very well be that the pool of employment in England is reaching saturation point and that there will be no work for our people going over to England, because so many of them have gone. I heard it related a few weeks ago, at the time the flood disasters occurred in certain parts of Great Britain, that one Irishman said to another: "There may be some good in that because if we go over there we may get employment." That was said by one Irishman to another over the last six weeks.
The inter-Party Government left this country with a condition of full employment. We did it because our policy was based on the fundamental principle that it was the duty of a Government so to regulate its economic activities as to provide the fullest measure of employment possible. We did that through the instrumentality of the dual Budget. We set out on the face of our Book of Estimates the items which we regarded as those on which public money should be spent. Those items which we thought were, and which proved to be, items of productive capital enterprise were being financed out of public moneys lent to us by the people of this country. We financed that policy of productive capital enterprise through the device of a deficit in the balance of our international payments. We felt, as I have already stated and as has been said so frequently in this House, that by the policy of prudent and controlled repatriation of our sterling assets, we could develop our country—which was underdeveloped in men and materials—and, particularly, the soil of the land of Ireland. We believed we could develop our underdeveloped economy and give full employment to our people. We justified ourselves in that policy.
What is the policy of the present Government in relation to repatriation of external assets? The only deduction that can be made from the form in which this Book of Estimates is framed is that they have now abandoned altogether that policy of the repatriation of our external assets. That prudent, controlled repatriation of our depreciating sterling assets which we initiated and put into operation with such beneficial effect during the inter-Party Government's term of office has now been abandoned.
I know the Minister for Finance and his colleagues have repeatedly stated they are in favour of productive capital enterprise but nowhere have they given credence to, or expressed their faith in, the fundamental commonplace of modern economics that you cannot have repatriation of our sterling assets without a deliberate deficit in our balance of payments. The whole financial policy of the Minister for Finance was based last year and still, apparently, is based, upon the eradication of any deficit in our balance of payments. We had the policy of prudent and controlled repatriation of sterling assets which involved necessarily, as an economic commonplace, a deliberate creation of a deficit in our balance of international payments. We had the nature and the priority of the investment of that money controlled in accordance with strict financial probity.
The policy of the present Government is to leave our assets not merely to increase but to depreciate, as they have done in the last few years. We considered it better to repatriate them and use them here instead of allowing them to depreciate in England. The policy of the Minister for Finance, which he put in the forefront of his economic statement last year, to eradicate the deficit in our balance of payments has brought about the position that we have increased our holdings of sterling assets last year. Instead of repatriating those sterlingassets, using them over here for the purposes of productive enterprises, giving employment and developing our undeveloped resources they have left them over in England. I am afraid we must gather from the Government's attitude that they are still to be left over there.
There is nothing to be gleaned from this Book of Estimates except that it reverted to the old system of orthodox British Treasury policy. The Estimates were framed from an orthodox financial British Treasury point of view. Provided an accountant could say the books were balanced, it did not matter if there was no policy enshrined in them. It made no difference if the Budget was not used as it ought to be used, as an instrument of economic policy. The orthodox financial principles, which were put into operation in the British Treasury and which proved to be incorrect in 1930 and 1936 were given approval here by the present Minister for Finance.
There is no indication in this Book of Estimates, providing for £100,500,000 of proposed expenditure, of what is the policy of the Minister regarding the repatriation of sterling assets, or what is his policy in regard to productive capital enterprise or how it is to be financed. Amongst many errors of which he was guilty, the Minister made two cardinal mistakes last year. He, first of all, failed to go for a loan in the autumn of 1951 at a time when he could have got that loan at a very much lower rate of interest than he was ultimately forced to offer to a number of greedy financiers who fell on our loan with avidity because of its wholly unauthorised and unexpected rate of interest. That was the first mistake he made but he made a bigger mistake, one upon which he started out from the very time he occupied those benches after the change of Government, when he attacked the credit of the country itself. Having attacked the credit of the country and having raised that spurious crisis which it took us months to dissipate, and having formed in the minds of the people in this country and people abroad a feeling of lack of confidence in our credit, instead of going for the loan at a time when hecould have procured it at a comparatively reasonable rate of interest, he sought it at a time when he was forced to give a greater rate of interest than was necessary, as has since been clearly proved because the national loan now stands at a premium. In other words the taxpayers will be taxed to give to those people who invested in the national loan two or three pounds of a premium on every £100, over what they paid for it. That was another of the cardinal errors of the ministerial policy that has brought us to the position in which we find ourselves at present.
I want to say that, as far as my colleagues and I are concerned, we shall give, not merely lip service but full co-operation to any proposal for genuine economy and the elimination of waste in public expenditure but we believe that wise spending is the wisest policy for the country in future—wise spending, and not merely pleas by the Minister for Finance such as he made last night to "uncritical, irresponsible Deputies" not to be asking for more money or greater Government expenditure. We believe that wise spending is the wisest economic policy and that a policy of wise spending can be operated in the way that we gave an indication it could be operated—through the medium of the dual Budget, as an instrument of economic policy, and the prudent repatriation of our external assets. I have indicated as I said detailed constructive proposals which are designed, I believe, to effect a remedy for the economic ills from which we are now suffering. I have heard no detailed policy from the Minister beyond his statement that Treasury orthodoxy must be adhered to, that he must balance or burst and that it does not matter about policy.
We shall support and co-operate with any genuine effort to eliminate waste but as I say there are items in this Book of Estimates that are put in there solely for the purpose of buying votes, for the purpose of getting support politically to keep Ministers in office and without full advertence to the vital facts of the present situation. The Minister speaking last night of Governmentexpenditure and what this country may have to face in the years to come, if it should still have the misfortune of having the present Government in office, asked rhetorically: "What is the Dáil going to do about it?" I know what I should like the Dáil to do. I know what the people would like it to do and that is to say to the present Government to get out and let in some Government that will bring an end to the human misery that has been created by every aspect of Government policy in the last few years.
Comment on this
The rejoinder is to get the Taoiseach to visit the President to-day and you will get your answer.
Comment on this
I move that the following be adopted as a Standing Order of Dáil Éireann:—
There shall be appointed at the commencement of every session a Committee, to be known as "the Committee of Public Expenditure," to examine such of the Estimates presented to the Dáil as may seem fit to the Committee and to report what, if any, economies consistent with the policy implied in those Estimates may be effected therein.
The Committee shall consist of 17 members, none of whom shall be a member of the Government or a Parliamentary Secretary, and five of whom shall constitute a quorum.
The Committee shall be otherwise constituted according to the provisions of Standing Orders Nos. 67 and 70, and so as to be impartially representative of the Dáil.
The Committee may appoint sub-Committees and may refer to such sub-Committees any of the subjects which are within the purview of the Committee.
The Chairman of the Committeeshall be ex-officioa member of each sub-Committee.
The Committee and its sub-Committees shall have power to send for persons, papers and records and to adjourn from place to place. Three shall be a quorum of each sub-Committee.
The Committee shall have power to report from time to time.
First of all, I should like to thank the House for facilitating an early discussion of this motion. Naturally as a private Deputy, I am gratified to find that the Government is in general agreement with it. The motives of the Government in that agreement or the imputed motives of the Government are of no concern to me. I am only concerned in what I consider is a useful attempt to improve parliamentary control of expenditure. At first sight, it probably seems unfortunate that the time selected to propose this motion should have been the occasion of the debate on a Vote on Account which is normally a rather stormy parliamentary occasion. But, from one point of view, it is perhaps peculiarly fitting that it should arise at the same time as a Vote on Account, because the parliamentary functions which the motion seeks to promote are in contrast to the parliamentary functions normally discharged on the Vote on Account. The Vote on Account by custom is an occasion of a general debate on Government policy, almost to the exclusion of any discussions on the details of expenditure, that is details in the sense that this motion seeks to control. It is, however, proper that the debate on the Vote on Account should take that course because the purpose of such a Vote is to provide for the machinery of State during the period in which the Dáil will be considering the separate Estimates of the various Departments. What concerns me about that is that even the debates on separate Estimates are in practice and for very good reason, not unlike in their general character the debate on the Vote on Account, that is, a discussion of Government policy in relation to the activities of the individual Departments. However, if we consider aDepartment Estimate as something in the nature of an invoice for goods and services proposed to be rendered, I think it will be generally agreed that it is proper to inquire into more than the desirability of the items listed in the Estimates, in other words, into more than the policy implied. It is also proper to inquire how the amounts charged against separate items have been arrived at. However desirable as that may be, it is not in the ordinary course of events feasible to make such inquiries in the course of a debate on an Estimate in the Dáil.
Firstly, there is not just parliamentary time. Every Deputy is only too well aware that the time devoted to the Dáil Estimates is already very much cramped even with the debate almost entirely limited to a discussion of the policy provided by the Estimates, and the administration of the previous year. Secondly, although the Dáil is in Committee on Finance, in practice a Committee debate is not possible. I refer to the type of debate that normally takes place on the Committee Stage of a Bill. You can talk across the House and have a close examination of various details. That is not possible in a debate on an Estimate, largely because there is not time but also because—and I think this is a very material factor—there is no opportunity to call and examine witnesses. Yet it is clear that it is the duty of the Dáil to advert to the details of the moneys advanced to the Government and to ensure that, as far as possible, the best value will be got for every £ spent. In my view the detailed examination made by the Committee of Public Accounts on behalf of the Dáil, leaves no doubt that the details I mentioned are the concern of the Dáil. I am using this argument to establish that there is nothing novel in a suggestion that Parliament should be interested in the details of Estimates. I am maintaining that it is only the difficulties I have mentioned which so far have prevented Parliament from dealing with them directly. The size and the cost of the business of State have been growing so enormously that it is increasingly urgent that nothing should be left undone to secure everypossible economy which can be made while efficiency is maintained and—if I might borrow a phrase which has been used elsewhere in this respect—to see that 20/- value is got for every £ of the taxpayers' money that is spent. I should also like to say that my proposal is a natural evolutionary parliamentary growth.
I hope the House will bear with me while I recapitulate what I am sure every Deputy knows very well. I want to put this, so to speak, into its historical context. The parliamentary financial system which we operate here grew naturally from the system which was in use in the former United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. In Great Britain, Parliament had slowly and, indeed, at times painfully, asserted its supreme authority over public finance. Originally the business of State was financed from the King's Privy Purse. Parliament was only called on in an emergency to vote a supply to what was indeed the King's Government. The value of money changed, the business of State grew and calls on Parliament to vote supplies gradually increased. In the end, parliamentary supply superseded entirely the King's purse. As public business became a charge on moneys which Parliament had itself to find by taxation, Parliament became conscious of the need to satisfy itself as to what exactly happened those moneys. Various reforms were introduced. The one that I am concerned with now arose about 90 years ago with the creation of the office of Comptroller and Auditor-General and the Public Accounts Committee. This established parliamentary control because the Comptroller and Auditor-General was set up as an independent officer, independent of Government, independent of the Treasury. This system of parliamentary control grew with the years and was, I think, a very powerful weapon in securing economy and regularity in the public service. Probably this was partly what we might now consider the niggardly outlook which dominated Parliament during the latter half of the 19th century. In those days the spendingof public moneys, at any rate, was a harsh necessity and not at all a virtue. With the turn of the century and for a number of years in the present century there gradually emerged a different conception to the part the State should play in the life of the community. I need not now go into the causes of that: the effect was that expenditure by the State gradually increased in popularity. This brought new problems in the control of public expenditure.
Parliament soon realised that the control of audit alone and insistence on the application of rules for the spending of public money were not sufficient guarantees that there would be economy, much less than that there would be parliamentary control. The rate of public expenditure was rising, the business of the State was becoming more complex and, at the same time, public pressure was continually exerted to secure more and more expenditure of public money. It became obligatory to see that the utmost value was got for every one of the increasing number of pounds that had to be raised by taxation. It may be illogical, but it is none the less true that while the public favoured more and more expenditure by the State, the public was equally reluctant to see the necessary expenditure provided by taxation. Faced with that position, the British Parliament decided that the immediate problem was to secure that there was no waste in the administration of public money. Whenever a problem like that arises in the British Parliament, they resort almost invariably to a Select Committee. In this case they tried Select Committees on Estimates, and, during a period which covered the emergence of our own State and which, indeed, lasted until the beginning of the last war, various Select Committees met from time to time with a view to examining the question of some control of the details of Estimates. Unfortunately, it has to be admitted that they had very little effect. I do not know, but I assume that the nonsuccess of these Committees influenced the decision here not to set up a Committee on Estimates when our own State came into being, because the restof the British Parliamentary system was taken over. Since then we have continued to evolve on the same lines. aPossibly, the comparatively small amount which was involved may have been a factor in the decision not to set up such a Committee. However, I think everyone will agree that that is no longer a valid consideration.
My own interest in this matter arose through my being a member of the Public Accounts Committee for some years. Gradually, I must admit, as I slowly gained experience of the system——
Comment on this
——I realised that there was a gap, and that something more was desirable. I should also say that the details with which the Public Accounts Committee are concerned are about two years old if you take into account the time at which the Estimates were prepared—that is the Estimates which later have a bearing on the Appropriation Accounts to be considered by that Committee. My impression was that the Committee has not a great deal of effect on current affairs further than, if I may use the expression, of lending moral support to the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
Hear, hear! What will the Committee on the Estimates do? Provide it with a thumbscrew and a jackboot.
Comment on this
Although I was aware that, in Great Britain, similar problems are now being dealt with with some success, the mass of British parliamentary papers proved my undoing. I just could not manage to trace out in them what exactly was happening.
Comment on this
However, fortunately for me, I then discovered that the necessary research had just been completed by somebody else. I should liketo say that I think everyone who is interested in parliamentary finance is very deeply indebted to Dr. Basil Chubb for his book on "The Control of Public Expenditure." I am very glad, personally, to acknowledge that I am largely indebted to him for being in a position to propose this motion.
Comment on this
After 30 years of trial and error in Britain, they did produce an Estimates Committee which has had satisfactory results. The experience of the wartime Committee on national expenditure suggested that why the former Committee had gone wrong was that it had tied itself too closely to the actual Book of Estimates—in other words, that it had interpreted its terms of reference too literally and had attempted to show how reductions could be made in the particular Book of Estimates that came under its review.
The new approach was a more general one—of course, still through the Book of Estimates, but dealing more with the current operations of the various Departments. From time to time, the Committee pursue such items of interest as seem good to it by using a flexible system of sub-committees. In other words, it endeavours to influence the future more than the immediate present. However, the Committee there did begin to get results. I suggest that here we have everything to gain and nothing to lose by profiting by the research work of that Committee and of the years of trial and error which it has given to this matter.
I am proposing that the Committee should have the same lifetime as the Dáil, partly because its inquiries could not, I think, be tied to a particular time of the year or be related to any particular financial year, and partlybecause my experience as a member of our Public Accounts Committee leads me to the conclusion that changes in the personnel of such a Committee can be a weakness. I say that because it takes new members a considerable time to familiarise themselves with the work and procedure of the Public Accounts Committee. I have suggested a Committee of 17. I admit that is a pure matter of guesswork. It is only experience that will show what is really necessary. Variations in the size of the Committee should not present any difficulty. Such changes take place from time to time, even in the case of the present Public Accounts Committee. I suggest that it will have to be a fairly large Committee, but I think that once the initial inquiries have been made most of the work will devolve on the various sub-committees, the main Committee itself probably having to meet only to formulate reports. As happens in the case of the present Public Accounts Committee, I suggest that the Committee should report to the Dáil, but just as the Public Accounts Committee reports do, its decisions would, I imagine, impinge directly on the Department.
It is provided in the motion that economies should be consistent with the policy implied in the Estimates and that no conflict with ministerial responsibility can arise. That, I think, should satisfy both sides of the House. Ministers, I am sure, would not wish to feel that the Committee was getting behind them in their Departments, and I am sure the Opposition would be equally reluctant to think that Ministers could shelve some of their responsibilities. In the motion, therefore, policy is definitely put out of bounds so that the Committee would have nothing to do with it. I must admit, of course, that the bounds of policy are not very easy to define, but I think that anyone who reflects on it will see that, if the Committee were to deal with policy, it would only stultify itself. The only way in which the Committee can be effective is through harmonious work with the Government. It is not easy to indicate the type of business which may profitably bear examination. Ifit were as easy as that we probably would not need a Committee. Besides, I think it proper that the Committee should be left to decide that for itself. If I may be permitted, without prejudice to what the Committee might like to decide, I would like to indicate what seems to me the most profitable point of entry. That would be that the Committee could begin by investigating how the Estimates are prepared by Departments and what is Finance control over that. How does it operate? Such a general inquiry would present the various lines of inquiry to the Committee which it could then pursue through its sub-committee. I am, however, tempted to suggest one or two subjects which might, from my experience on the Public Accounts Committee, be useful to pursue.
The first is what is called O and M— Organisation and Methods. That is a division in the Department of Finance and the general purpose, very roughly speaking, is to see that efficient methods are used generally throughout the Civil Service and, where any particularly advantageous way of performing a service has been discovered by a Department, that the benefit of that discovery would be given to the entire service. This Committee might very well inquire if that system has been successful and how far it has been pushed. Has it been pushed to the limits of its usefulness?
Comment on this
As far as Finance will allow it to be pushed. But they blocked it at every turn because they said it cost too much.
Comment on this
It will not, because the Committee will be turned into a further thumbscrew to prevent expenditure on O and M. They would not even allow principal officers. They wanted junior executives to operate as O and M officers. We got them to make it higher executives.
Comment on this
Sheldon is the name.Deputy Hilliard is foolish enough to support the Minister. He is from County Meath.
Comment on this
There are also commercial activities of some Departments which may involve the preparation of trading accounts; the expenditure on civil defence; contract procedure in general——
Comment on this
——and the form of Government accounts. Since the latter and perhaps other subjects could lead to changes in the form of Estimates, which are considered by the Public Accounts Committee, liaison between the two Committees would seem to be desirable. Indeed it was favoured at one time in Great Britain that there should be a joint committee on Estimates and Accounts. The idea, of course, was that the Committee would then be able to keep under review the entire process from start to finish, lasting generally over about three years. There are certain attractions in that but I think it would be a pity to interfere in any way with the well established position of a well tried Committee like the Committee on Public Accounts. It cannot be denied that a Committee such as I suggest is a rational evolutionary development of the system.
Finally, I want to suggest that, apart from any consideration of the desirability of economies, this Committee would tend to increase parliamentary control, and that in itself is desirable. Control at the moment, as has been pointed out by Deputy Dillon, is a bureaucratic control. There is a continual outcry against that sort of thing and here is an opportunity for Parliament at least to try to get parliamentary control. Until it has tried and failed, it would be foolish to condemn the attempt.
My opinion is that parliamentary democracy is the best form of Governmentbut I do not believe that the bare fact of the democratic election of Parliament necessarily secures parliamentary democracy. That comes into being only when Parliament makes sure that it has immediate control over all the affairs of State, in short, when Parliament acts as a unified body and not merely as a meeting-place for political Parties. Necessarily, that also is a function of Parliament but that is not by any means the whole story. Parliamentary control of every possible aspect, particularly of the financial system, is to my mind essential if we are to have real parliamentary democracy. Control by the Department of Finance may be quite effective. Possibly there may not be economies to be made but Finance is, after all, a Department like the others.
Comment on this
Oh, no. There is an illusion. Finance is a Department like nothing else on God's earth. They are quite unique, God bless them.
Comment on this
They may have special qualifications. I am not concerned with that. I am contrasting the Department with the elected Parliament. Its control, whatever it may be, is not a substitute for parliamentary control. So, on the two grounds, of the necessity for seeking every possible economy in administration and the necessity, if parliamentary democracy is to be a reality, that we should at least attempt to secure parliamentary control in this matter, I recommend the motion to the House.
Comment on this
Ministers of State in this country are flesh and blood. They receive for their services £1,525 per annum. There is a limit to the persecution to which they can be submitted in the discharge of their public duties if they are to continue to serve. We have in this country a Department of Finance, second in quality to none, but it is unique and any administrative Minister in any Government thatever ruled in this country in the last 30 years will tell the Deputy that, when he has treaded his way through the Department of Finance with his annual Estimate, the idea that he is then going to tread his way through a Committee of this House with the same Estimate, that Committee being fortified by a Department of Finance which is heel-tapping on the reluctant decisions which have been dragged from it, under the pressure of the imminent publication of the Book of Estimates, is an illusion.
Ministers of State in this country give more work for less pay than in any country in the world and I do not exclude Iceland or Nicaragua. There is a limit to what you can ask them to do and if there is any further burden put upon their back, outside of the cherubim and seraphim in Heaven, no further candidates will be found for ministerial employment in Ireland.
I taught Deputy Sheldon a good deal of what he knows about the procedure of the Committee on Public Accounts. When he was a neophyte I guided his faltering footsteps. With his experience of this House, does he ask himself to-day why was he invited to have his motion discussed with this Vote on Account? I will tell him: Because the Taoiseach wants a nice, large smelly red herring that he can deliver a long lecture on about five minutes past seven to fill the front page of the Irish Pressso that the poor dupes down the country will think that we were discussing methods of reviewing the Estimates in Dáil Éireann on the Vote on Account and not the scabrous, loathsome reputation of the present Government, acquired during their last two scandalous years.
I do not give a fiddle-de-dee about your proposal about a Committee. I think it is as irrelevant as a cracked fiddle on an occasion of this kind. It was brought in here to-day by the Government as a smelly red herring to divert the eyes, ears and noses of the Irish people away from their dilapidated and collapsing condition. That is the fact.
I know Deputy Sheldon will not takeit amiss if I speak frankly and trenchantly to him, but I know the text which has inspired his observations here to-day. I know it is the kind of proposal that in the British House of Commons, Dingle Foot, Sir Waldron Smithers, and the father of the House of Commons, that old warrior who has now gone to the Lords, might very well sponsor. It is as practical as a child's toy in the present context. It is as irrelevant as Die Valkyrie to our present circumstances.
Our present circumstances call urgently on Dáil Éireann, which is the appropriate authority, to consider the very imminent danger that threatens this country. Our present circumstances call to mind that there has been declared on our people by the Fianna Fáil Government a war as menacing and as malignant as the civil war or the economic war. We staggered through the first two, but so certainly as this is carried to a conclusion we will suffer a reverse which may well end the existence of this State as an independent nation. I warn you, and I think I will be in a position to demonstrate to you that the warnings I have given this House in the course of the last two years have largely come to pass, we are now faced with a menace which may well bring down the whole economic fabric of our country and, if it does, do not forget what happened to Newfoundland. Do not forget that 15 years ago Newfoundland and Ireland stood in precisely the same constitutional position.
Comment on this
I am not. I am recalling warnings that I gave to silly little men years ago and I am telling them that we are advancing rapidly to the very forecast that the silliest of these little men remembers hearing from me 15 years ago. Newfoundland and Ireland stood in precisely the same constitutional position. Ireland became a sovereign and independent republic. Newfoundland suffered its basic industry to be bankrupted by the folly of those who disregarded essential economic facts and has subsided into theposition of a province in the Federation of Canada. Do not forget, though the independence of this country may have been sustained, restored and maintained by blood, that precisely the same disaster can be brought upon us by economic developments such as those which blotted out the constitutional independence of Newfoundland 15 years ago.
That is the road we are travelling and I will show Dáil Éireann, with absolute certainty to those who are not too blind to see, the identity of the madness that this Government has embarked upon with that of the insanity which the Newfoundland Government embarked upon and destroyed their country's freedom, except in so far as it is prepared to be a free province of another nation.
Before I turn to that question, however, I want to refer to a matter which I gave notice that I intended to raise on the Adjournment last night, but which, out of proper consideration for the staff of the establishment of this House, I decided not to raise at 11.30 last night as they had to get home some time and I do not think it is reasonable, except on a matter of the gravest possible and urgent concern, that they should be detained in this House until midnight while we are ventilating our grievances. I therefore forbore raising that question with the Minister for Agriculture last night. I raise it now on the broad question of the Government's policy and administration. We have been informed that, by the authority of this House, the price of butter was increased. The satellites of the Government informed us that that increase was ordained in order to ensure an increased price for creamery milk in this country.
Comment on this
That certainly would be a matter for the main Estimate and not for the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
I should like to know what price the farmers will get for that milk. I gladly turn from that question to larger ones. What should we think in this House of a Finance Minister who flounced in yesterday to tell us that the £10,000,000 surplus that has been realisedon his Budget has been spent in his despite by his colleagues? That is a new philosophy of Government: that the Minister for Finance who told us he did not know where he would get the money to pay the civil servants, the Minister for Finance who, 12 months ago, told us that bankruptey was panting red-tongued at our door, the Minister for Finance who told us that no sacrifice was too great to call upon from the nation to prevent ruin overtaking us and that all his exertions were bent to the task of bringing our expenses within the ambit of our revenue, waltzes into Dáil Éireann on the 11th March in that same financial year, not to announce that he has resigned rather than consent to expenditure which he feels is inconsistent with the common good, not to announce that he has found himself in head-on contest with his colleagues in the Government and has said "No" but the Government overruled him and he had therefore resigned his responsibility, but to wring his hands and say that they had spent the whole £10,000,000 and sent him in here with 14 Supplementary Estimates to get ex post factoapproval from Dáil Éireann to spend the money that he told Dáil Éireann we had not got?
He professes to be proud of that achievement. Is not that what he has done? Has not past history shown us that many a Finance Minister felt that his duty as Minister, and the responsibility laid upon him to protect the Exchequer, compelled him to come before Parliament and say: "I cannot recommend to Parliament that which I believe to be wrong. My colleagues in the Government have overborne me, but they cannot make me do wrong and I therefore elected to withdraw and leave it to others to do what I am not prepared to recommend to the Parliament to which I am responsible?" But not so; the valiant Minister of to-day told the country that ruin and bankruptcy were upon us 12 months ago, and he tells the Dáil 12 months later that his colleagues spent what they should not have spent and though he did his best to stop them they spent it in his despite, and they sent him in here to get Dáil Éireannto approve. I do not approve it. I despise the Minister who comes here with such an assignment.
We have had recent evidence here of a different kind of Minister, a Minister for Finance who found the revenue that was necessary to provide the services that the Government required but who, in the recollection of his colleagues, was never afraid to say when the appropriate time came: "There is the limit which I am prepared to recommend to Dáil Éireann. Mine is the ultimate responsibility for finance and I will not advise the Government or Dáil Éireann to spend another penny until such time as Dáil Éireann has an opportunity of considering the matter in advance and of considering in association with the proposals made the methods of raising the revenue requisite to finance the proposition." Such a Minister for Finance is truly a precious asset to any State. The vacillating weakling who trims his sail to every breeze that blows and clamours for the opportunity of unloading his responsibility of reviewing the Estimates supported by his Department on to this Parliamentary Committee which is now suggested to him has a standing alibi for any future folly that Minister might seek to commit. What are we to think of a Minister for Finance who comes here and presents a Volume of Estimates deliberately fraudulent and designed and drafted to mislead Dáil Éireann? I challenge him to deny that.
The Book of Estimates reads upon its face £100,548,000 for the Supply Services. Within 24 hours he is obliged to confess that he has incorporated in that book £4,000,000 which his bungling colleague, the Minister for Health, blurts out they have decided to borrow. I ask any part of this House, in front of me or behind me, is there any precedent for a Minister for Finance presenting a Book of Estimates, introducing a Vote on Account, and 4 per cent. of the total Estimate is a sum which the Government has decided to borrow and not to charge upon the Supply Services? Is there any precedent for any Minister for Finance getting facilitiesto speak for as long as he pleases in introducing his Vote on Account and never mentioning that? Is there any precedent for the information being got by a side-wind from a bungling colleague who did not know he was letting the cat out of the bag? Is that fraud? Is that conduct of which a Minister for Finance of Dáil Éireann should be proud? I say it is fraud. I say it is shameful fraud and it is a disgrace to this Parliament that such a transaction should have come to light.
These Estimates are fraudulent and their purpose is to initiate in the country a universal atmosphere of apprehension that there is about to descend upon us an avalanche of taxation, oppression, grief and woe. There is no need for that. There is ample scope for remission in the financial year that lies ahead. Nothing can bring upon us what these Estimates are designed to make us fear but the continued presence of that incompetent man, the present Minister for Finance, in his present position.
We have £6 million in these Estimates provided for a subsidy on lime. Every penny of that has been approved in principle by the Marshall Aid administration now ended for recoupment out of the Grant Counterpart Fund and there is provision in the Extra Exchequer Grants at the end of the Department of Agriculture Vote showing that the Government anticipates receiving from that source a sum of £10,000 in respect of certain services which it intends to provide. I refer to page 105 of the Book of Estimates:—
"Extra receipts payable to the Exchequer:—
...transfers, subject to approval of United States authorities, from American Grant Counterpart Special Account, in respect of technical assistance (£10,000)."
I say that there is precisely similar provision to be made in respect of that item of £600,000 for lime plus £250,000 spent in the Estimate last year. We are told that in this Book of Estimates £160,000 is to be provided for the cold storage of butter. Here the Minister was detected in his chicanery before he came to make his speech and he sought to glide gracefully over this bysaying that circumstances had since changed. But another colleague, bungling in another direction, said that this charge is not to be produced from taxation for a windfall has come in from another source. I know it has not to be produced by honest taxation in this House. It is to be produced by levying it on the price of butter and it is lifted off the Estimates and on to butter; we are told that that relieves the taxpayer and we are to read the Estimates in the light of that relief.
I see that £360,000 worth of machinery for the land rehabilitation project is to be sold for £200,000 in the coming financial year. At this stage I suggest that the Fianna Fáil Party should stand up and cheer, all together.
Comment on this
The itemised figures are not before us at the moment. We are dealing with the Vote on Account and the policy of the Government. Discussion on the Estimates will arise later.
Comment on this
No. I am setting out one by one the charges in the indictment of fraud and the attempt to mislead the House and the country. The warning I now want to give is related to what was said here when the present Minister for Finance declared the policy of his Government in the 1952 Budget. We told him then that his Budget was designed to raise prices, to raise interest rates and that that would certainly involve and must involve an increase in wages albeit that increase might not compensate those who received it for the additional cost to which they were put; that it would involve an increase all round in the rates levied by local authorities on land and property consequent on the increased cost of maintaining public institutions; that it would result in an increase in the raw materials of the agricultural industry in that the freight charges and all other charges as they accrue would pass on to the things which farmers had to buy in order toproduce on the land; and, in addition to that, that the farmers, after paying the increased wages and the increased costs which would flow directly from this Budget, would have to meet for their own families in their own households the increased cost of tea, butter, tobacco and all the other commodities which are used every day and which were directly affected by the Budget. In fact, working farmers in this country will have to pay those charges on the double.
Our policy had been to stabilise prices, to subsidise essential commodities and take the fluctuations in cost on the Exchequer. That was combined with a policy of bringing down as far as we could the price of raw materials and commodities that farmers have to use, of bringing up the productivity of the land on which they lived and had to work, of securing for them markets as profitable and as extensive as diplomatic negotiation could procure, and depending on the belief that the consequential expansion of the national income would give us, from stable taxation rates, an expanding revenue to meet whatever charges would come in course of payment for current services and amortisation of any debt we deemed prudent to raise for the capital development of the country or provision of capital amenities consistent with the standard of living to which our people were entitled.
The consequence of that policy is written all over the pages of the Statistical Abstractthat was published only a week ago. Let me read for the House the consequence, in terms of trade, in volume of trade and in agricultural statistics, of three short years of that policy. Our total exports in 1947 were £38.5 million; in 1948, £47.8 million; in 1949, £58.9 million; in 1950, £72,000,000, if you include re-exports; in 1951, £81.5 million; and in 1952, over £100,000,000 sterling, for the first time in the recorded history of Ireland.
I know there are cynics who would denigrate that achievement by saying that that is to talk in terms of money. But how does the record speak in terms of volume? Between 1947 and1952 the volume of our domestic exports increased by 50 per cent. Is there a country in Europe can compare its performance with that of the farmers of Ireland? These are the farmers who we are now told by Fianna Fáil, are lazy, antediluvian, refusing to increase production, the despair of Governments, the constant concern of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, who proposes to precipitate a revolution in agriculture in this country. He does not know what he is stirring up for himself. If he starts any revolution, Vesuvius will be nothing to what will go off under his posterior. Think of the impudence of upstarts in the Fianna Fáil Party addressing the agricultural community as if they were peons and serfs on the land of their own country. There is no agricultural community in Europe who have achieved what our farmers have achieved. There is no agricultural community in Europe which has staged such a come-back, from the dereliction and destitution wrought upon them by Fianna Fáil, to the staggering achievement they have to show in the year 1952. If we can help it, if we can drive Fianna Fáil to the country they will not get the chance of doing to our people for a third time what they so disastrously have done twice before.
Far from discussing academically the best method of furnishing the Department of Finance with further thumbscrews and jackboots for the persecution of the other Departments of State—their duty, put upon them by our statutes and most conscientiously done—our purpose here to-day is to consider what is the remedy for our present ills. I want to ask Oireachtas Éireann to agree with me that the remedy is not revolution, no tearing down of law, no crying of havoc, but the exercise of the constitutional right which resides in this House to tell that Government to go, to go now where we have a right to send them, lawfully, constitutionally and peacefully, to the people and let the people decide. I give this undertaking. If they will go and go now we will never challenge their right to form a Governmentin this country again. I say this deliberately, and I have a quarter of a century of political experience behind me: Go now and you will lose 25 seats in the constituencies of Ireland. You are hanging on to office by the votes of five men returned to this House to vote against you.
Comment on this
On the Vote on Account, surely I have the right to tell them to get out. Have I not? I am telling them to get out and I am telling them they are hanging on by the votes of five men elected to vote against them. I am telling them: Let go of that hook and put your ship to sea. Do not try to whistle in the dark. The graveyard gapes for you—the political graveyard, of course—and no amount of whistling will convert it from what it is irrevocably destined to be. The gravestones are gravestones of the political lives of 25 members sitting on those benches. Go out and look at one another and speculate who are destined to be ghosts so soon. Look around you. Is there a single one amongst you who feels safe? Looking at the flock I see before me, I would not give sixpence for the chances of any one of you and I give two to one against any half-dozen of you, including your newest recruit, a decent kindly man.
Even these men who sit before me have come to realise that the hope of this country is increased agricultural production. There is nothing else to maintain the standard of living that our people have been led to expect from the Government they replaced. Do not let us forget that it is the proudest boast of all that when Fianna Fáil took over this country from us the report of the United Nations Committee on nourishment the world over was that the Irish people were eating more and eating better than any other people in the world. What Government ever had a better envoifor three years' work than what was published last week:—
"The Irish people are eating more and eating better than any people in the world".
I ask no better honour from public life than that a Government of which I was a member had brought about that, but bear in mind it carries the implication, that if there is to be increased agricultural production in a country which is eating more and eating better than any other country in the world, it means that every pound's and every shilling's worth of added agricultural production must be designed for export for our people are eating what they can and they cannot eat any more.
Comment on this
Thanks be to God but do not forget the Government that did it. Do not forget that every one of you, every one of the Fianna Fáil Party, walked into the Lobby to defend the proposition that our people were eating too much and living too well and that by the Budget of 1952 they would be made to eat less and to live lower. These "Hear, hears!" sound strange to me when I look at the Deputy for Waterford, who campaigned against me, that our people were eating too much and eating too well and who wanted to come into Dáil Eireann to see that they did not eat so much. He deluded the voters of Waterford into sending him here for that purpose but let him go to Waterford now, when the result of that policy is visible and he will get his answer. It astonishes me to hear those who wrought that purpose and who walked through the Lobbies for that purpose say "Hear, Hear" to me when I say that our people are eating better and more than they ever ate before. There is no depth of hypocrisy or fraud to which Fianna Fáil and its satellites are not prepared to sink but there are 90,000 men and women in this country who have no work to do and who cannot be impressed by these spurious "Hear, Hears" of Fianna Fáil. They had work two years ago and their children and neighbours were not flying to Great Britain as they are flying now. They will not be deceived by the "Hear, Hears" of Fianna Fáil.
This is a grave evil but it is reparable. We could mend all that ifwe had the chance now, but there is an evil coming up the mountain which, if it matures, neither we nor any other Party in this House will be able to mend.
Comment on this
We got our chance and we reached a level of achievement attained by no other democratic Government in the world. We did what we set out to do and we got for our people the highest standard of living enjoyed by any agricultural community in the world. That is what we set out to do. We made the farmers prosperous and we insisted that the wage of the agricultural worker should march step by step with growing prosperity in agriculture. Did we not do that?
Comment on this
Come now to what is coming. The Deputy will have his opportunity in Wicklow very soon. We will be there on the 22nd March and we shall be ready with a candidate. Let him come down and sit on the fence, or waggle on the wire. But let us not trouble about him. He will look grotesque enough during the three weeks' campaign in Wicklow. As I have said, additional agricultural production must be for export. I wonder does this House know that if costs continue to increase as they are at present increasing, agricultural production in this country for export will become unprofitable? Should that come to pass, look you now in time at the dread results for this country. What will pay for all the goods we import on which cities and towns, like Dublin, Cork, Limerick, Waterford, Dundalk, Sligo and Ballina depend for their existence? What will pay for the imports used to produce the income which provides earnings for the doctor, the lawyer, the trade unionist, the civil servant and every other element in our community? There is no fund but that derived from the exports of agricultural industries, and the day when the export of agricultural produce becomes impossible, on that daythe fund will begin to dwindle. As it dwindles the individual farmer will suffer hardship but the hardship suffered by the wage earner and the salary earner will be double, treble or quadruple the injury sustained directly by the farmers who, the more they produce, the greater their loss will be. Wages in the agricultural industry have gone up 7/6 per week on the minimum wage but the tragedy is that the agricultural worker who is getting 7/6 more from the farmer is worse off now than he was before the Budget of 1952. Rates have gone up, because every institution in Ireland has had its costs forced up by the cost of everything it uses to maintain a modest standard of comfort for its inmates. These institutions cannot come to the Dáil for a Supplementary Estimate. They must go to the county council to get that. If they get it, the farmer has to pay additional rates to meet it.
The world price for fertilisers threatened to come down. Did we welcome that and say: "Here is relief in any case"? No; our Parliament put a duty of 20 per cent. on superphosphates of lime lest our farmers should enjoy that relief in the presence of other rising costs. Freight charges are up, and the farmer has to meet them. Out of the diminishing fund left to him, he has to meet the weekly bill for the commodities consumed by himself and his family in the home. I ask the House to face the fact of what that has resulted in. Do Deputies realise that the reason we are not exporting butter is because we are no longer able, economically, to produce butter in Ireland? We cannot sell butter abroad because our costs of production for butter are too high. We will never sell butter abroad—never.
Comment on this
See. The sage is here to lead us illuminated in the higher flights of abstract economics. The concrete fact is that we cannot export butter and that we will never export it again.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen and Deputy Cogan might, with advantage, withdraw to the Lobby and dance round one another with those pleasant paradoxes for the rest of the evening. I am concerned with the vital facts. The export of eggs has become uneconomic.
Comment on this
Will you tell us when butter was last exported at an economic price? Give us the date? Was it not back around 1924?
Comment on this
The export of eggs has become uneconomic. Consider what that means. The export of fowl has become uneconomic. Stop and think what that means. I warn this House —and I know whereof I speak. The export of bacon and ham and pork is just in the balance. If the costs of production in that branch of the agricultural industry go up another 5 per cent., the pig population of this country will melt away. Stop and think a moment what this means. It means that you are left with cattle and sheep. There is not a farmer in this House who does not know that, during the war, the sheep population of this country vanished from the face of our country through a complexity of circumstances. I am not going to go into those circumstances now but they could easily recur and, if they should, you are driven back to cattle. Stop there, and think a moment. A great many people in this country thought we had discovered in the United States of America a Golconda wherein to sell prime beef. I was looked down upon in this House when I sounded a note of warning and said that there is no permanent market there and that we should not depend on the United States market for prime beef—manufactured beef, perhaps, but prime beef, no. I was told I was a saboteur, a merchant of pessimism. What has come to pass? We are out of the United States market for prime beef— and we are out of it by competition. We cannot produce it in Ireland at a price the Americans are prepared to pay. By the mercy of God's Providence, we have the 1948 Trade Agreement to fall back upon. We have the other party to that agreement in a vicefrom which they cannot escape—no thanks to Fianna Fáil but thanks to our Government.
There is not a Deputy in this House who does not know that all that stands between the live-stock industry of this country and crisis is the trade agreement we made in 1948 which holds the other party as no agreement between two nations of such disparity in power ever held a second party before. But let us not rest to the point of folly on a false sense of security engendered by that trade agreement. If costs should further arise, agricultural exports from Ireland will decline.
I warn this House that, should that come to pass, there will unroll before us a dialectic of development identical with that which brought Newfoundland to its present sorry pass. Newfoundland woke one morning to discover that, by the dissipation of its resources on irrelevancies, its great fishing industry had become inefficient and uneconomic. Having exhausted every domestic resource, a deputation went to London to ask the British Treasury to accept Newfoundland as a temporary charge. The price they paid was that the Treasury in London named their Government. When the period of probation was passed, they were told to choose between hoeing their own row or making the inevitable and irrevocable surrender—and the best minds in the world advised them and told them that there was no choice available. The truth was that they could not choose to hoe their own row for they had not the means of hoeing it. They had only one choice and that was to purchase survival by the surrender of independence. They made it with what grace they could to an understanding partner who took them—the stranger— into their house and sheltered them from the consequences of their own folly. This historic nation has no house where it can, with dignity or decency, seek shelter from its own folly. This nation has no refuge to which it can repair. This nation must survive free or perish in shame. Do not let us forget that no measure of human courage, no readiness to make sacrifices on the part of the masses of the people, can replace the consequences of economicfolly imposed by a Government which is obsessed not only by vanity and folly but by a vacuous and shameful desire to denigrate the records of its predecessor.
This last, then, I want to say, in conclusion. Do not take up this Book of Estimates, as this debate concludes, and ask us the question: "What, then, must we do?" I want to answer that question now. There is only one thing Fianna Fáil can do to save this country, and that is to get out. We have no other advice to give you.
Comment on this
We think you are incompetent, dishonest, and that you are prepared to resort to any fraud for Party ends. We acknowledge that as of to-day you are the legitimate Government of this country and have the right to govern. We acknowledge the tragic fact that, so long as the busted flush of four Woolworth diamonds and one bleeding heart is still in your hands, you have a right to govern.
Comment on this
Remember by what authority you govern Ireland. Remember that no Government of Ireland from Castlereagh down to to-day, ever ruled this country by a baser or more shameful title. We told those who claimed the right to rule by such a spurious title in past times to go—and we had right to take arms against them. The tragedy of to-day is that anyone who is faithful to Ireland must, if called on, defend our Government against anyone who would seek to overthrow it with any weapon other than the votes of the people recorded in the ballot boxes. It is apt and good that we should all reflect with gratefulness to Providence that we have arrived at the milestone in our history when that is true and when our bitterest grievance must be that we are proud to defend the institutions that make yourrotten Government secure. We have a right to say to you in this House—and we say it now—that there is nothing you can do as a Government to repair the evil that you have wrought in the past two years. There is no advice that we have to give you except: "Go!" Go now, and take the rabble and the remnant by which you scrambled into office with you, and God grant that the Irish people will wipe them out and send you back decimated down to the stature which properly belongs to you.
Comment on this
Behind, as I say, this monstrous anger and bluff there lies the bitterness of disappointed men. The bluff is all very well—it is easy to cast one's mind back not many months ago when they themselves were unable to maintain their Government and unable to agree amongst themselves: when they were unable to project a policy that had any future for the people of this country and, above all, unable to make any serious decisions in regard to finance which would enable this country to pursue the path towards prosperity—to overcome the difficulties which every country in the world has had to face in the last two years, and to do that in a manner which would bring the least difficulties and the least unhappiness to our people.
We can well recall some of Deputy Dillon's previous speeches when he warned the country of the frightening effects of producing peat, and of the frightening effects of producing beet and wheat. We can recall many of his wild exaggerations, made in 1947, when he prophesied that he could make an agricultural paradise of this country overnight. The people of this country, who are sane and honestly try to debate economic issues, can judge between what I believe to be bluff and proper honest talk.
I shall mention one or two examples of Deputy Dillon's exaggerations. He tried to claim that the high consumptionof food which this country enjoys is due to the actions of the Coalition Government. Of course, if the Deputy looked at the figures for food consumption in 1947 he would know that we were at that time one of the highest consumers of food in the world. He would find, from an examination made by doctors of repute and renown into malnutrition in this country, that malnutrition was mercifully confined to a very tiny section of our people, and that, on the whole, our people had sufficient to eat in spite of all the difficulties we experienced during a world war, and in spite of the fact that we were virtually unable to pursue our constructive policy for a number of years owing to war conditions. Naturally, of course, food consumption was high in 1951. In Deputy Dillon's view that must be due entirely to the effects of his Government. That is quite typical of Deputy Dillon.
The same thing has occurred in connection with the figures which he used to give us for agricultural production. He always took, as the base year, a year of unexampled bad weather, and then proceeded to take credit for the good weather for the purpose of showing that there had been some increase in production one or two years later. He tried to deduce from that that all the work of the Coalition Government was miraculous in its effects.
We know very well that the farmers have had some measure of prosperity during the last three years, but the reason for that has nothing to do with Deputy Dillon or the Coalition Government. The reason is simply this, that prices here and in every other country in the world went up by 40 per cent. between 1947 and 1952, so that no matter how bad a Government could be, at least some of the farming community would inevitably make an increased profit and find some measure of prosperity.
I should like to remind the House, in connection with this vaunted boast of Deputy's Dillon's—of all his talk and bluster and all his promises—of what the figures actually showed, when they became available, in regard to agricultural production. What did they show? That production in the lastyear in which Deputy Dillon was in office was about the same as it was in 1939 and as it was in 1945, after five years of war. Despite the absence of fertilisers and of machinery, all that he had done was to restore production from the low levels of 1946 and 1947, when there was bad weather, to the 1945 figures. It does not matter how Deputy Dillon may twist the figures, or how he may talk about gross production or net production.
These are the figures, and all the talk by Deputy Dillon is quite typical of him. He takes a vastly excessive credit for agricultural results for which he had no responsibility. He has even tried to tempt the country councils into the idea that the rates were going up solely because of reasons for which the present Government would have responsibility. He mentioned an increase in food prices. I wonder is he prepared to recommend taxation to restore the subsidies so that that element in the rates can be kept down? What tax would he propose or suggest to restore the subsidies if he had the chance, and had some part in our very serious financial responsibilities?
Deputy Dillon made the suggestion that, in some way or other, agricultural exports were imperilled by the present Government. He has tried to panic the people, to the immense disadvantage of the country, into the idea that our exports were about to collapse due to the present Government's policy. What are the facts in regard to that? In the last year in which Deputy Dillon was in office, the only main branch of agriculture that was prospering was the cattle industry. The number of pigs was going down by thousands per month; the number of poultry declined by about 2,000,000 compared with the previous year; tillage was declining; the whole policy in regard to feeding stuffs was confused, and apparently had so deceived the farmers that they knew not where they were. Deputy Dillon had promised them dirt-cheap maize, and said it would remain at a level price even though the £ was devalued. Deputy Dillon confused the farmers in that way. He promised them and guaranteedthem a market for oats and potatoes, but he never fulfilled that promise. The Government of which he was a member was driven into doing so when Deputy Dillon was absent in America.
Every single figure that can be produced by the Statistics Office during Deputy Dillon's term of office shows that, in 1951, there was a growing crisis in regard to agricultural products other than cattle. That was the position, but, mercifully, it has been restored to some degree by the present Minister. In regard to pigs, it has been restored; in regard to eggs, there has been some measure of restoration, while in regard to tillage the rot that set in has at least been stopped. I believe that, at the end of the present season, we should be able to say, in regard to the sugar beet industry, that the position there is more satisfactory than it was last year. We know that Fine Gael propaganded against the growing of beet.
I think that I have demolished, to some extent, the absurd exaggerations of Deputy Dillon in regard to what he claimed he could do and to what his Government did. If Deputy Dillon can prove to me and can show that there was an increase in agricultural production over and above that which we left in 1945, I will be content to go very far in making the admission to him that he was right, but he cannot do that because his own Government produced certified figures of production which show that there was no genuine increase in production during the period he was in office. As I have said, the farmers did make some money because of a rise in agricultural prices for which Deputy Dillon had no more responsibility than the man in the moon. There had been a rise in the price of agricultural produce. That happened all over the world, and was not due to anything which the Coalition Government had done.
Deputy Costello made a speech, in which there was, if not a mild suggestion of panic, at least a mild suggestion of coming disaster for the country. I think that there, again, Deputy Costello was indulging in wild exaggeration, because he was trying toconceal the colossal error in judgment that he and his colleagues made on the occasion of the last Budget when they foretold that we would produce a surplus and that, therefore, the taxation imposed was of a kind deliberately meant to prevent people from spending money, to prevent people from buying goods, to prevent people from buying food. The colossal error of judgment he made at that time was obviously the reason for the wild and windy talk that we have heard from him.
We are bound to remind Deputy Costello that most of the burdens faced by this country through higher taxation were imposed upon us by the Coalition Government. If the people are facing staggering taxation and if taxation has reached its limits, it is because of the unregulated conduct of financial affairs by the Coalition Government during the last year of their office, when their Ministers worked in water-tight compartments, when there was no proper control of spending, when there was no planning of spending either current or capital. The result, as everybody knows, is that we were left very heavy bills to pay and we had only two alternatives.
We had the alternative of making such drastic cuts in current expenditure that the result would have been harmful to our people and, above all, would have been harmful to those with the lowest incomes. If you have to make gigantic cuts in expenditure in any Budget, naturally and inevitably you will hurt those in the lower income brackets because it is only in connection with big services, such as social welfare or health or with services for the development of the country such as agriculture, that one can make really enormous cuts. The cuts would have had to be enormous if we were to discharge the bills left to us by the Coalition and at the same time avoid an increase in taxation.
We will not let the people hear this debate take place without reminding them once more that a very great part of the bill we have to pay was devised by the Coalition Government. At least we can say that Deputy McGilligan,when he was Minister for Finance gave every warning of the difficulties that would arise. He made in fact all the prophecies to be found in an exaggerated form later in the Central Bank Report. Deputy McGilligan himself wrote a rather mild version of the Central Bank Report which was later, I think, exaggerated and given too great a degree of emphasis by the directors of the Central Bank when they published their report. Nevertheless, he gave the major warning. He warned what would happen if expenditure went on rising and if agricultural production did not increase.
Comment on this
There was this wild, uncontrolled spending. There was no real planning. There was no foresight on the part of the last Government that they were running into difficulties occasioned by matters outside their control. The higher prices rose, the more credit they let loose on this country by every ill-advised means. They broke every rule of modern economics. They, who now parade as the ideal economists and who pretend to follow the doctrines of the late Lord Keynes and of all the other people who rather like to run Socialist Governments, where the state takes a very large part in injecting vast sums of money into the economy or in withholding large sums of money, did not have any real theory behind their economic policy; they did not have any real economic policy. If they had, they would have followed the first golden rule that, when prices are rising very rapidly because of a world economic inflation, you avoid pouring additional money into circulation by not balancing a Budget and by other unwise policies and that you wait until prices havereached their limit and then, if they start going down, you start applying some of these hitherto untried remedies for unemployment and for all the difficulties that beset mankind.
What we had to face was, not a Government with a socialist policy and not a Government with a good laissez faire policy but a Government with merely a policy of confusion, due entirely to the fact that Ministers were unable to agree amongst themselves and that there were Ministers, such as the former Minister for External Affairs, who, so far as one can judge by his speeches, would print banknotes ad liband, also Ministers, such as the former Minister for Finance, who gave all the warnings to his own Government which should have made them try to accept some of the burden for themselves that we have had to face since in putting the economy of the country to rights.
Comment on this
I never thought I would hear such irresponsible stuff as I have just heard from any Minister.
Comment on this
That is my explanation. No matter what the Deputy may say, it was the irresponsible conduct of the Coalition Government which caused the major part of our difficulties. We have had to face these difficulties and to carry on the nation's finances as best we can. It is, of course, the oldest cry in the world of an inefficient manager of business: "Let costs rise more and more. Let there be losses in trade. It will all come right in the end. Carelessness will pay dividends." That is the oldest cry in the world of the inefficient manager of a business, of the dishonest manager of a business.
We had to face all these difficulties. We had to face the taking over of an economic régime where there had been a manager in charge who had been forced into exactly that kind of observation and that kind of practice. What we had to face and the policy we adopted has nothing whatever to do with following a Tory policy, following British policy or following any specific economic policy beyond that ofrestoring a balance to the Budget, of making ends meet and of making quite sure that the economic reputation of this country was maintained and that we could proceed with our own programme of national development without being faced with such financial difficulties as would prevent us from so doing.
We heard nothing from Deputy Costello, in fact, as to what he would propose to do even if he were placed in charge of the Government of this country. He had nothing but a policy of wailing despair. He did not make a single concrete proposal for reducing costs. He did not make a single concrete proposal by which we could reduce the cost of materials which have gone up for reasons beyond our control. He made no suggestion for a solution of the difficulty we face that agricultural prices are high and that they might bear hardly on the consumer, but that we simply cannot find the money with which to restore subsidies.
I would like to challenge any member of Fine Gael or the inter-Party Government to answer this question: How are they to deal with the trimming of the Estimates that will be required if taxation is to remain at its present level and at the same time reimpose the subsidies when the subsidies would at the moment cost 2/-in the £ on income-tax, 2½d. on every pint of stout, 3d. on every 20 cigarettes and 8d. on the gallon of petrol in addition to the taxes on these commodities? If any member of the Opposition would get up and say: "This is the solution of the difficulty —restore the subsidies and we will move a resolution reimposing that taxation," he will at least be an honest man, but we have had no such proposal from Deputy Costello. Deputy Costello has talked vaguely about the new system of finance in this Government, but he made no specific proposal for getting over the difficulties we face at this moment which are that Government costs have gone sky-high, that services must be maintained and that at the same time the cost of living has gone up in this and every other country.
I waited with interest to hear what Deputy Costello would say, whether he had any real positive policy which would get us over our difficulties. He referred vaguely to the balance of payments, and he suggested that unemployment could be brought about by causing the adverse trade balance to be cut off completely. What is the position? There is still an adverse trade balance. We have not entirely remedied the situation. We do not think the situation should be entirely remedied, but we can make sure that when our property is sold in Great Britain the result will be the import of machinery, to produce goods for the people of this country.
I do not know whether it is necessary at this point to enter into a long dissertation on this question of the balance of payments. I should have thought that during the last year at least some members of the House would have learned the facts. The facts are that you just cannot bring in money in pounds from Great Britain and hand it out to the workers of this country. The money can only come in goods which are imported into this country. Unless you can be sure when you are encouraging the repatriation of assets that the goods which come in are the right kind of goods, that they will help to produce more and enable us to become less dependent on the goods of other countries and to export more, what you are doing is encouraging the spending of money to no purpose and the reduction of our trade reserves abroad to our great disadvantage.
Nobody can deny that we cannot just bring the moneys back, put them on the train at Euston, land them at Dún Láoghaire, and hand them over to the Minister for Finance to spend. It does not work that way. It can only work by the sale of goods by Great Britain to this country. The view of our Party is that we are perfectly willing to make use of these assets so long as we can be certain that the results will be to produce more for the people of this country, to improve the national estate, and not merely to dissipate the money to no goodpurpose. I thought Deputy Costello had by now learned what our attitude was. Apparently, however, he still likes to pretend that you can allow assets to be repatriated without any kind of control, and the result will always be a good one. That is far from the case.
It might be as well to remind Deputies that there is not a very great volume of these assets left. People with woolly financial minds like to talk about £400,000,000 being invested in England and abroad without realising that as against that we owe money to countries abroad to the tune approximately of £250,000,000 and that our real credit abroad, our credit for trading purposes, the credit that enables us to buy huge quantities of goods from countries to whom we sell nothing, depends on the net amount that we own, not on the fact that we have large investments in Great Britain, because against these large investments must be measured, inevitably, the money that we owe abroad.
For us, as for every country, what counts for trading purposes is the net amount, and the net amount is round or about the £130,000,000 or £150,000,000 mark. I have not the exact figure. But certainly one can say that if we are to encourage the repatriation of assets we want to feel quite certain that it comes back to us in the form of goods which will help production and that we are not merely removing one of the important things for the life of the country, the power to trade abroad without difficulty, the power to have temporary deficits in our trade, and the power to pay customers all over the world without having to make foreign loans or to borrow temporarily. That is one of the sheet anchors of our independence.
All we ask is that if we are going to make use of these reserves they should be used wisely and for the benefit of the people of the country. In fact, about three-quarters of the talk about the adverse balance of payments on the part of the Opposition is just sheer political claptrap designed to deceive those people who have too much to do to make prolonged and detailed studiesinto the very difficult question of the adverse balances abroad and the whole of the conditions which have affected our trading since the war.
We have heard Deputy Costello implying by what he said that this Government are entirely responsible for the increase in the cost of living. I suppose we may have to repeat ad nauseamthat half of the increase in the cost of living since the outbreak of the Korean war took place during the lifetime of the last Government and that to charge us with being responsible for the increased prices of materials required for war purposes is ludicrous. Are we to be responsible, for example, for the increase in the price of timber in the two years from October, 1950, to October, 1952, of from 64 to 70 per cent., of the corresponding increase in the prices of copper and lead? Is the Taoiseach to be charged with and made responsible for the increased costs which affect the whole life of the community in such things as housing or the rate at which houses can be built? Are we to be made responsible for them? Is it not a fact that a great deal of the increase in the cost of living took place in the time of the Coalition Government and that the subsequent increases were due to difficulties which it would be impossible for us to overcome, with one exception, that if the financial affairs of this State had been better regulated and if expenditure had been more controlled and planning had been on a more long-term basis, it might have been possible for us to avoid taking the drastic action we had to take in connection with subsidies or, alternatively, costs might not have gone up so much or the taxation increases might have been more limited.
We have been charged with wanting the people to eat less. We are still one of the highest consumers of food in the world. In spite of the increase in the cost of food, at a very recent date the consumption of bread and butter had gone up in this country subsequent to the Budget increases. We appreciate that the cost of living is sky high in this and every other country. In spite of the difficultieswhich housewives are facing, the consumption of food so far as we know has not been noticeably affected by the Budgetary policy of the Government. One of the reasons for that is the compensation afforded by us to people with large families through the increase in the children's allowances and the compensation afforded by us by the Social Welfare Act. We were aware that there would have to be increases in wages. Increases in wages were foretold by the Minister for Industry and Commerce at the time of the Budget and there has been some compensation in that way.
Comment on this
I am trying to get away from some of the exaggerations of Deputy Costello and Deputy Dillon. They did not really produce any policy or propose any solution in regard to taxation. I think that one should try at least to initiate an argument on the financial position where the debate was not based purely on political abuse and exaggeration.
Comment on this
I have had to answer these wild charges. I thought it would have been possible to say something constructive and not merely something designed purely to induce panic in the people, but designed rather to help the people to consider the present situation properly. The people will have to make up their minds to one of two things; either the present Government led by the Taoiseach is entirely responsible for everything that has happened since the outbreak of the Korean war and that we are an isolated community cut off from outside sources and able to pursue our way independently or else make up their minds and agree with our view that we are facing a situation which has taken place all over the world.
There is nothing unique in the high living costs or the difficulties facing our people, except to the extent that we disagree as to whether the Government in operation from the outbreak of the war in Korea did all that wasrequired of it to prevent the crisis from becoming more serious than it need be. As regards the general situation, the situation here is the same as in other countries. I do not propose to bore the House by quoting from international documents, because I noticed the Opposition members became very restive on the last occasion that I did that. Every economic international organisation of repute in the world reported similar economic conditions everywhere.
There was a false boom all over Europe and all over a great part of the world. That boom was caused by the rapid growth of rearmament and a vast amount of unco-ordinated, un-strategic and unjustified stockpiling, not only of commodities essential in time of war but of every commodity in which it was anticipated the price would rise. That condition was universal. Increased prices were universal. The difficulties faced by the present Government, apart from those foisted on us by the Coalition Government are the same as the difficulties that have been faced by almost every other country. The rate of interest has increased in almost every other country in Europe. Denmark is a country which bears some comparison with our own in regard to its economy. There the rate of interest was as high as 5½ per cent. as far back as November, 1951. Governments all over the world have found it difficult to make ends meet. Current expenditure has gone up. Taxation has been increased. At least four countries in Western Europe are practising economies similar to our own. Some of those countries have Socialist Governments. They have been forced either to abolish completely or to reduce subsidies for exactly the same reason as we have had to reduce them; they could no longer afford to pay for their services and pay the taxation required for subsidies. Subsidies were a war-time measure to ensure that everybody would have enough money in a time of rising prices to purchase a guaranteed amount of foodstuffs. Subsidies have been reduced or abolished in other countries, includingthose with Socialist Administrations, Administrations more advanced in their economic views and in their desire to control the community even more severely than, for example, Deputy MacBride would want to control the community if he were allowed to put into operation all the strange policies he advocates.
Every country, with the exception of about two, has had difficulties with its balance of payments. Practically every country has found itself unable to pay America or some other country for goods purchased and has had to constrict or reduce imports. The lucky thing about us is that we still have these trade reserves and we have not had to use artificial measures such as those adopted in Australia where overnight imports were cut in half by a single stroke of the pen by the Minister for Finance. These things have been happening in countries that were undeveloped like our own, countries that remained neutral during the war, countries such as Denmark where the cost of defence until recently was not a very great part of its economic life, countries with conditions comparable to ours, countries that have been devastated by war. Indeed, the same conditions apply in countries that still enjoy a huge measure of Marshall Aid or mutual security aid in the form of gifts from the United States.
What is happening has happened before in the history of the world. No doubt it will happen again. There finally was a buyers' strike. Prices went up so much that we had the temporary prosperity of an entirely impermanent kind that results always from increasing prices. Now the same reports speak of a buyer's market where people are holding back from buying because they anticipate that prices will go down.
Instead of exaggerating the difficulties and prophesying disaster, the Opposition would spend its time to greater advantage if they told the people that it is unlikely that there will be any great break in prices because of the new post-war situation and because conditions are different from those that obtained after World War I. Therewill be a reduction in prices and a certain stabilisation of prices but it is not much use people postponing buying in the hope there will be a real break and a really enormous reduction in prices. We cannot be sure but we can only say that certain commodities have been reduced. Building material prices have gone down. There may be reductions in the prices of certain very costly metals.
The agricultural community all over the world is fairly well organised. It would be difficult now for any one country to flood another country with agricultural produce at low prices. There are now international cartels and organisations for the maintenance of prices. America is the one country that could cause a complete collapse in agricultural prices if it flooded the market with its surplus, but there is a price support plan in operation at the present time. There is no sign of any great reduction in prices and it would be better for the Opposition to advise the people to take a sane view of the present situation and to realise there cannot be any great reduction in the near future. That would be better than wild exaggeration, accusations and suggestions that we are deliberately inviting disaster.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that the people have the purchasing power but are not using it?
Comment on this
I have not said that. We are facing difficult times and the people are severely affected by the high cost of living. Taxation has reached its limit. I believe prices are levelling off. I am repeating in another form what the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said recently to encourage the idea that prices are becoming stabilised. The position is an interesting one and I am looking forward to hearing constructive speeches from the Opposition members on the point that the rise in prices has come to an end after an unbroken period of 17 years. This Government which, by Providence, is in office at the present time is facing a situation that no Government had to face since the final drop in prices during the world depressionsometime round 1934, 1935 and 1936, a depression somewhat reinforced by the economic war here from 1936. From 1936 onward—I think that was the operative date—prices slowly rose.
We are now facing an entirely new situation, a levelling off of prices for the first time in a great number of commodities. We managed to maintain the cost of living in a very stable condition from 1943 to 1946 but largely through subsidies and price controls but even during that time certain commodities were going up in price. They were controlled by artificial means. Now we are facing something new about which we have all to think anew, the ending of a very long epoch of rising prices. Although agricultural prices are still rising a little and although they rose last year 10 per cent. over what they were the year before it would seem the topmost level of prices has been really reached unless some new crisis occurs such as a devaluation of the £, another war scare, a fresh re-armament drive or some other circumstances. If present conditions remain the same we are facing an entirely new position.
It would not be easy for any Government to run this country because if prices level off the yield from taxes inevitably levels off and the amount that can be collected in taxes is limited as soon as prices stop rising and the purely artificial prosperity created by the fact that people can buy something and sell it at a higher price later on, ends.
The fact that that situation is ending is bringing new problems for the Government to face and it is a far more important factor in this debate than any of the nonsense that has been talked so far by Deputy Costello and others.
Comment on this
It is far more important. As the Minister for Industry and Commerce indicates, the price rises have not yet stopped because there are still wage adjustments proceeding. There have been reductions in the price of certaincommodities and one or two others have moved up in price. We must always depend on whatever action the British Minister for Agriculture takes in regard to the prices he is prepared to pay, to make the British more self sufficing in their food. If he chooses to increase the prices to the agricultural community in Great Britain it inevitably has an effect there. I cannot go further than suggesting a period of price stabilisation. It involves matters of very great importance to this country, among other things, the more urgent need for increased agricultural production than has been the case for 17 years. For 17 years prices slowly rose. For 17 years farmers could make some part of their profits from the rise in the price of any agricultural commodity from year to year. As soon as that situation ends the only way existing profits can be maintained is by an increase in the volume of production, an increase in the quantities produced by farmers. We are now running into that situation when all that will become a matter of very great importance.
Comment on this
Are you satisfied you can solve all the problems you are referring to by operating within the present system?
Comment on this
Unlike some Deputies in the Opposition, no sane member of any Government would promise to solve all the economic problems of any country. I do not promise to solve them either. All I can say is that we will do our best.
Comment on this
I want to deal with one matter which has caused very great misunderstanding among the people of this country. I have listened ad nauseamto speeches of members of the Opposition suggesting that the reason for high prices here, the reason for high taxation and the reason for the difficulties we are going through has been the fact that we followed slavishly the restrictive policy of the Central Bank shown in their report of 1951. I want to repeat here what I have said before in this House, thatyou could pick up any number of Central Bank reports from any number of countries—written from 1949 to 1951 —and countries where the directors have been appointed by Socialist Governments. In some cases, if you blacked out the name of the country, you would really imagine they could apply to this country. Central Bank reports from several other countries of Western Europe are almost identical. The only difference in the warnings they give are purely those relating to some local circumstances. I do not know what action Governments took in all these countries in supporting the policies advocated by the Central Bank. Some of them adopted one or other section of the policy; some of them followed one or more of the various theses given to them. However, I know that, in the case of the present Government, we did regard the policy advocated by the Central Bank as over-restrictive.
Comment on this
You swallowed every single word of the report.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going to listen to the facts. We are going to throw the truth back in his teeth.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going to be given the lie so far as that is concerned. The suggestion has been made that we slavishly followed the policy of the Central Bank as advocated in their report for 1951. It is about time that that particular lie was exposed and exposed for good. We did nothing of the kind. We simply took the advice of the Central Bank Report that there were inflationary conditions operating in this country as in others, that there was a danger of the inflation getting out of hand. We looked at the recommendations and this is precisely what we did about them.
The first recommendation was that it was advisable that large elements of below the line expenditure of a capital kind would be better paid out of taxation. We did not follow that policy. We paid out of borrowed money virtuallyfor every single service that could be paid out of borrowed money. That particular recommendation of the Central Bank was not adopted.
The second recommendation was that the public works programme should be drastically curtailed. The public works programme was not curtailed.
Comment on this
What about the Local Authorities (Works) Act?
Comment on this
I can give proof of that later. The Opposition do not like to hear these facts. There was no restriction in the public works programme so far as capital expenditure was concerned and if the Deputies care to look at the expenditure on capital account they will find in regard to these services there was no cutting down.
The next statement that was made was that there should be restriction of State investment. I shall proceed to give quite clear proof later that there was no restriction of State investment, that huge amounts of capital were spent and that in fact we ran the original Fianna Fáil programme of capital development at a much faster rate than it was ever run by the Opposition during their last full year of office.
The next suggestion that was made was that there should be a Budget surplus. We decided it would be sufficient to balance the Budget. No arrangements or proposals were made for having a surplus.
The next proposal that was made was that it might be well to eliminate subsidies. We eliminated portion of the subsidies and maintained another portion. We did what the Central Bank did not recommend; we gave compensation to a large number of people in the form of increased social services allowances. The Central Bank advocated at that time that there should be a State induced or State encouraged standstill in wages. We made it clear that there would be some compensation in regard to wage levelsas a result of the Budget proposals. The Minister for Industry and Commerce was more clear in his observations on this subject.
There was one suggestion of a very amazing character, that we should sterilise the American Loan Counterpart Fund. It was quite impossible to do that as the fund had to be used to discharge obligations which we incurred with the passing of the former Government. The other proposals made were that we should work for better exports and exports did increase during the last year. We adopted that proposal. It was a constructive, positive proposal. We did what we could to foster exports and there has been an improvement in exports since the time that report was published. The report also recommended further encouragement towards savings and I am glad to say that since the Budget the gross amount deposited in the Dublin Savings Bank and in Saving Certificates actually showed an increase over the corresponding period of 1950 in spite of the difficulties that were being faced by the people because of the higher cost of living.
I want to make these matters quite clear because we have heard for too long that we are supposed to have carried out every one of the dictates of the Central Bank whereas, as I have said, in regard to most of them we thought their policy was somewhat exaggerated and that their recommendations were in the nature of an extreme warning. We proceeded to carry on our own Fianna Fáil policy of reconstruction; we proceeded to borrow considerable sums of money to carry on the policy which the Party had advocated for many years, a policy which was partly adopted by the Coalition Government but in regard to which there was considerable muddling on their part and a great deal of exaggerated boasting. There has been a very large capital expenditure by the present Government. The result can be shown in some very simple figures which will be very unpleasant for the Opposition to hear.
Comment on this
A number of projects, all of which we planned, had been left over by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1947 for the improvement of the national stake. Planning for these projects by the Coalition Government was badly mismanaged and the money expended was badly spent.
I do not think they organised expenditure on these Fianna Fáil projects in the best way. I do not think, they planned the resumption of Fianna Fáil projects in the best way but, nevertheless, it was very hard for us to make any alteration when we resumed office because any alteration in the drastic capital expenditure programme would have involved the transfer of workers and other difficult problems which I think would have been insuperable. We have speeded up our own programme and the following has been the result. We shall take the year 1950, the last full year of the inter-Party Government and compare the results of that year with the results of our capital programme in 1952. This is going to be very unpleasant for members of the Opposition. The number of houses completed in 1952 as compared with the number in 1950 was up by 8 per cent. The number of housing grants allocated in 1952 was up by 26 per cent. The number of new schools, the building of which was in progress in January, 1953, as compared with 2 years before, was up by 62 per cent. Expenditure on hospital construction was up by 18 per cent. and the expenditure on land improvement was up by a rather peculiar figure—333 per cent. We heard a great deal about the land improvement scheme which in fact was originally commenced by Fianna Fáil in 1939 and which was altered by Deputy Dillon. We had again to alter the scheme but if we compare expenditure on the land rehabilitation scheme or, as we call it, the Land Reclamation Scheme, we find that it was 333 per cent. greater in 1952 than in 1950.
Take turf development. The lastGovernment waited for two years before they did anything about machine-won turf but the production of machine-won turf increased by 226 per cent. in the last two years. We had a great deal of talk about afforestation in the course of the debate on the last Estimate and Deputy MacBride did his utmost to deceive the people by suggesting that there had been a decrease in expenditure under the Vote. Actually the number of acres planted during the past 2 years went up by 102 per cent.
In connection with rural electrification, it should be remembered that the rural electrification scheme was introduced in 1947. Rural electrical schemes were initiated by Fianna Fáil and Fianna Fáil alone.
Comment on this
I am talking about rural electrification. I shall deal with the Shannon scheme later. The number of electricity consumers connected increased by 32 per cent. in the last two years. Now I come to the question of power schemes. We have to give credit to the Fine Gael Government for the Shannon power scheme. There have been many power schemes implemented since, but a curious thing the last Government did was to agree to the planning of only two power stations which were to be fired by foreign fuel. Since June, 1951, we have initiated the planning of six power stations, using entirely native fuel or water. That is an answer to what Deputy O'Higgins has stated.
Comment on this
Would you mind if I do not regard that as a complete answer?
Comment on this
I hope Deputies do not question these figures. They can ask questions in the Dáil if they wish to confirm the fact that we have speeded up national reconstruction and that we have completely run circles round the Opposition so far as achievement is concerned in practically every one of our reconstruction schemes.
Comment on this
I have said we have run circles around the Opposition. So far as emigration is concerned, I want to make one appeal to Deputies. It is about time that both sides stopped accusing their opponents of being responsible for emigration. If there is any good reason more than another for having had an alternative Government in office, I think that one reason would be that it is now established that emigration cannot be lightly solved.
Comment on this
There are four bad reasons for having the present Government in office—Cogan, Cowan, Browne and ffrench O'Carroll.
Comment on this
People who say that they are going to end emigration are dishonest because there is no easy solution for it.
Comment on this
In actual fact, so far as the last Government was concerned they stimulated emigration. Emigration went up from 10,000 in 1947 to 41,000 in 1950. I am not charging the last Government with being responsible for emigration. I have not got the type of dishonest mind possessed by Deputy MacBride, but, as I say, emigration increased from 10,000 in 1947 to 41,000 in 1950 and they did nothing to stop it.
It increased during their period of office. In so far as unemployment is concerned, it averaged 58,000 during their first years of office. It averaged something over 60,000 during 1952. That is the only way to regard, in general, the unemployment problem. Unemployment did increase very largely in January of this year. There was an increase then which could almost entirely be accounted for by the fact that people in rural districts and people who habitually have slackness of work during the winter found that conditions made it easier for them to register than in previous years. Nobody will tell me that if unemployment was 3,000 odd in December, 1952, more than December, 1951, and that it then shot up another 9,000 in one month, this was entirely due to the policy of thepresent Government. It is ludicrous nonsense to make that assertion.
Comment on this
Unemployment has been caused by factors such as excessive prices. Take country districts, for example. In the country districts, 30 per cent. of the houses, for which grants are provided by the Government and by the local authorities, are built without recourse to borrowing. Therefore, so far as those are concerned, there can be no question about the operation of the increased rate of interest. Yet there has been a certain amount of slackness even in this class of building. Until recently, the high price of timber and other housing materials, in addition to the increase in wages for workers as a result of the increase in the cost of living over the past few years, made the cost almost prohibitive, but I am glad to say that the cost of some building materials is coming down. People will thus be encouraged to go on with their plans for the building of their houses even though the cost of materials is still very high.
I should like to refer to the figures in relation to the number of persons who have applied for grants in respect of new houses in the past few months. Though the rate of interest has increased, the number of applications for grants in the months of November, December and January of 1952-53 is just about the same as it was in the year 1950-51: it is not any less. There was an abnormal number of applications in the intervening years. The proportion who have applied, although it shows a reduction, shows that there is still a very large number of people who want these grants in spite of the increased rate of interest and the other difficulties with which they have to contend.
Comment on this
The Minister should not look down his nose on them for that.
Comment on this
Rates of interest have gone up all over the world. They have gone up in Socialist countries. They have gone up in countries which have Governments who hold very advanced ideas. They have gone up in those countries as well as in the conservative types of countries. The rate of interest bears no relation to the political complexion of the Government in office. It would be a very good thing, I think, if we could, without causing other ill-effects, separate the rate of interest here from that of neighbouring countries. I think it would be excellent if we could do that for purposes such as housing. It is extremely difficult to detach the rate of interest in one country from that of another country.
I want to reiterate the main fact that the full programme of national reconstruction, which is so important in this country, has gone on in full force. We are doing everything we can to inspire new productive schemes. New industries are being promoted day by day. New committees are being formed to stimulate dollar export. Everything that can improve production is being done by the present Government. I am very proud to give that report on what we have done in regard to capital services. Listening to the Opposition, one gets the impression that, on the head of practically every one of these schemes— schemes which were originally Fianna Fáil schemes—there have been dramatic reductions, as though we were closing down on everything instead of expanding everything. I think it is just as well to inform the public that what the Opposition say is not, in fact, the case.
As I have said, countries with Socialist and Conservative administrations alike have faced the difficulty of price rise, have faced the break in prices and the question of people waiting to buy until they would see the price trend. There has been an increase in unemployment under every kind of administration. There has beenan increase of unemployment in Denmark—a country which has always had a very liberal administration and in which there has been a considerable amount of State activity. There was an increase of unemployment in the Netherlands before the floods took place—a country where there is a coalition of the Catholic and Socialist parties. There have been increases in unemployment in a great many countries in Western Europe—an increase generally caused by a buyers' strike.
Comment on this
That increase has taken place regardless of what the immediate Government policy happened to be. That has been the case in countries which were not at war, in countries which were neutral, in countries which did not have large defence expenditures and it has taken place in countries which were being heavily subsidised by the American Government for their defence expenditure. Grievous as has been the increase in unemployment we have got to deal with the matter; we have got to provide more employment under every heading. We have got to get over difficulties such as these. Out of about 116 local authority areas, the housing programme has been completed in 69. I think that in all but 16, houses required by local authorities in rural areas outside the county borough of Dublin are in some stage of progress. Eighty-four per cent. have bought the sites, are developing them or houses are actually being built on them. In about 69 out of 116 areas, local authority housing schemes are in sight of completion.
Comment on this
That creates a problem in regard to local unemployment. Unskilled and semi-skilled workers have gone to those areas expecting employment—employment which is now ceasing. In my own constituency of Longford-Westmeath the housing schemes are in sight of completion. The Coalition Government were well aware of the fact that these schemes werebeing completed but they did not leave any grandiose schemes on their shelves to absorb the employment content when the schemes would be completed. It is not easy to employ people when labour is not mobile. When people move to a district they do not want to move again. It is not easy to plan employment schemes so that people will get other employment but that problem is engaging the attention of the Government at the moment. The Government are very conscious of the fact that there will be a decline in employment through the completion of these housing schemes.
Comment on this
The general position is being examined with a view to providing employment schemes. When the position has fully been reviewed we shall know where we are in regard to this matter. There are many areas in which housing can still proceed. There is a certain amount of unemployment in Dublin because steps were not taken sufficiently early to provide sites for houses. We are not responsible for the deficiency in the provision of sites or for the difficulty in getting sites.
I want to leave the impression with the House that we intend to go on with this national reconstruction work. We have not strangled capital development in this country. We have encouraged it by every means possible. We have shown a far greater rate of progress in all the important policies designed to improve the national status than the last Government did in 1950 or 1951. We hope to be able to maintain that rate of activity provided we can be assured of stable conditions and provided the people of this country are not panicked by wild and exaggerated talk such as we heard in the speech delivered by Deputy J.A. Costello this afternoon.
Comment on this
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, who has just concluded, devoted a certain amount of his speech to unemployment. The Minister seemed to make light of the position that obtained in regard to theemployment figures during the period of the Coalition Government. It is true that we did not succeed in wiping out unemployment altogether, but I do say that we reached the stage where practically every person who was willing and able to work had full employment. In fact, I have personal knowledge of one Department of State where a scheme of works had to be closed down because there were no men available to do the work. In our time, we tried to approach this problem with a view to giving the maximum amount of employment to the greatest number of people at home. We cannot close our eyes to the fact that in this country at the present time we have 90,000 people unemployed. These figures indicate that the economic structure of the State is not in a very healthy condition.
A good deal has been said on the question of difficult times being ahead. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister for Finance and, again, this evening, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, all have said that we are facing difficult times. That seems to be the stock argument or cry of the Fianna Fáil Party. They seem to be for ever looking through glasses which are coloured and distorted with gloom and disaster around the corner.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce, when speaking in Letterkenny in 1947, made a speech that was in almost identical terms with the speech made here this evening by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. He said that there were serious times ahead and that it would take the Government all its time to tide the country over them. A few short months afterwards, he and the Government of which he was a member went out of office. The inter-Party Government took over and for three and a half years, particularly towards the end of that period when our policy had begun to take effect and show its fruits, the country was enjoying a degree of prosperity such as it had never known before. Why, even the members of the Fianna Fáil Party do admit grudgingly from time to time that that is so, but, even while they do, they still try to maintain the false facade that the Coalition Governmentdid everything wrong, and that they did everything right.
I believe that the critical condition in which the country finds itself to-day dates back to the disastrous speech which was made by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce in August, 1951, shortly after this Government took office. It was followed by another speech of the same kind by the present Minister for Finance. Both Ministers made blood-curdling statements, and said that bankruptcy was around the corner.
Comment on this
If Deputy Cogan has nothing else to do he should go down to the Library and, by wading through the newspapers, he will find a record of that speech. It was made some time during the summer recess of 1951.