Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 128–280 of 436. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
The speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce was followed, as I said, a week later by a speech by the Minister for Finance. Apparently, he felt a little bit peeved at the fact that the Minister for Industry and Commerce should have stepped into his domain and spoken on matters which are supposed to belong more or less to the Department of Finance. People began to ask themselves, especially business people, whether there was any truth in the statements made by both Ministers. In my opinion, it was from that date that the freeze in the circulation in money set in. That resulted in strangling the life of the country. The Government are now reaping the whirlwind which they sowed at that time. I believe that both Ministers were dishonest in making those speeches and did not believe in what they were saying. The speeches were simply made for the purpose of blackening the inter-Party Government. The truth is that the Fianna Fáil Government were astonished at the bouyancy in the circulation of money which obtained in the period of theinter-Party Government, at the low rate of unemployment and at the prosperity which had been enjoyed in every home in this land. These speeches, I believe, were made by the two Ministers to try and discredit their predecessors in office. As I have said, they are now reaping the whirlwind.
The freeze policy which set in that time is reflected in the present condition of the country. The purchasing power of every single citizen has declined, and the inflow to the Department of Finance has been checked. These are some of the results of that freeze policy.
The Minister for Finance, last night, devoted a good part of his speech to the necessity of increasing our agricultural output. We all realise that the prosperity of this country depends, to a very large extent, on our agricultural exports. Unfortunately, we have very little to export. Deputies on all sides of the House agree on the necessity of increasing agricultural exports. The present Government has been making a great show about the increase in agricultural produce exported during the last 12 months. Some of that is due to increased production on the land. I believe that the greater part of it is due to the fact that the income of all classes of our people—workers, farmers and others—were assaulted by the Budget of last year, and the consequent inability of people to maintain the standard of living to which they had been accustomed. We all realise that the standard of living of our people has been seriously reduced. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs maintains that the people are as well fed now as ever they were. I know that they are not, because they are not in the position to buy the quantities of food that they were in a position to buy 12 months ago.
Comment on this
They are not able to live as well now as they had been accustomed to. Therefore, one of the reasons why agricultural exports have increased is because of the fact that our own people are not now in a position to buy our own home-produced food. Iwant to see the volume of agricultural exports doubled, if possible, but first of all I want to see our people properly fed and in a position to maintain a fairly decent standard of living. I say that the ability to do that has been taken completely out of the hands of many of our people by the policy of the present Government, and particularly by its policy as reflected in the Budget of last April. That Budget was deliberately designed to bring about an increase in agricultural exports.
Comment on this
Something like the standard they had before Fianna Fáil took over in 1932—starvation.
Comment on this
The Budget was deliberately designed to bring about a reduction in the standard of living so that exports would increase. It was designed to reduce imports of certain necessary commodities so that the balance of trade would be restored. The price of food was assailed in particular by the Budget. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs told us a few moments ago that there is more bread and butter being consumed at the present time in this country. I do not believe a word of it. I do not believe he has figures to substantiate that statement. It is extraordinary that a Minister can calmly tell the House that the people are now eating more bread and more butter although butter has gone from 2/10 to 4/2 per lb. and the loaf has gone from something like 6d. to 9½d. It is absolute trash and nonsense. I know that a good deal of the exports are made available because our own people are no longer in a position to purchase the commodities. Unemployment is rife in every area. I am not one of those who would use that particular facet of Irish life for the sake of politics.
A real approach should be made to the problem of unemployment. At present there are 90,000 unemployed. In that 90,000 there is a small hard core of people who would be more properly classed as unable to work, through some physical deformity or mental infirmity, or both. I submit that at least 90 per cent. of the 90,000 are able and willing to work.
I want to ask the supporters of the present Government and the Ministers what the unemployment figure would be if the train-loads of people who have left Connacht, in particular, within the last 12 months, to emigrate to foreign lands, were included. I suggest that it would be in the region of 120,000. There is no check now, we are told, on the figure for emigration. There is one means of checking the figure. Anyone who will go to the railway stations or bus stops in the West of Ireland will see what is happening. The Parliamentary Secretary must be aware of the position. His own area must be suffering pretty badly from emigration and unemployment at the moment.
The inter-Party Government set about increasing agricultural production. The first attack made by that Government on the problem was through the medium of drainage, not one particular kind of drainage but three different systems.
Comment on this
Deputy Davern wants to support a policy whereby grants for drainage are cut and the money is used to develop tourist roads. That is his method of increasing agricultural production. It is not mine. Deputy Davern, perhaps, does not live on the land. Deputy Davern, perhaps, does not know what it is to pay rent and rates for land that is under water and that is absolutely useless. He does not know perhaps, what it is to have the sheriff coming to the door to collect the rent and rates while Deputies supporting the Government can afford to sit back and laugh in this House when the problem is mentioned.
Comment on this
I am not shedding any tears. As a farmers' representative, it is my duty to bring to the notice of all Deputies what the farmers' problems are and I will do that no matter what interruptions come from Deputy Davern.
Comment on this
I am on the question of increased agricultural production and drainage and I will not be put off my stride. Let us consider what the present Government are doing. We aimed at spending quite a lot of money on drainage. We wanted to bring into production the 4,000,000 acres which all statisticians agree are absolutely useless at the moment because they are permanently under water, subject to periodic flooding or waterlogged. Our principal means of increasing agricultural production was to restore that 4,000,000 acres to the farmers. A small corner or a large proportion of that land is attached to practically every holding. We aimed at bringing it into production. In the year that the Local Authorities (Works) Act was passed we gave a grant to the 27 county councils of £1,900,000. Let Deputy Davern take a note of that.
Comment on this
In the following year— I am speaking subject to correction— the figure was reduced by £100,000 or £200,000. It was over the £1,500,000 mark. As anybody who has eyes to see or who understands the problems of rural Ireland must realise, magnificent work was done by the engineering staffs of the 27 county councils under that Act. The Act was deliberately designed and introduced because we found the land rehabilitation scheme initiated by Deputy Dillon, who was then Minister for Agriculture, was held up in a great number of cases for want of some intermediate drainage scheme.
Comment on this
I hope it will not be difficult for me to relate it to the subject of increased agricultural production, which I think would be relevant.
Comment on this
I will endeavour not to go into too much detail. The land rehabilitation scheme aimed at restoring4,000,000 acres to the farmers. That would have been about the best contribution that any Government could make to increased agricultural production.
May I make a few suggestions, Sir? If we are sincere when we talk about increased agricultural production, I suggest that there are three or four points to which the Government should pay attention. First, they should overhaul the whole system by which credit is made available to farmers and go back to the rate of interest that obtained when the inter-Party Government were in office. The Agricultural Credit Corporation is now charging 6 per cent. interest on loans—an increase of 1½ per cent. since the present Government took office.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going into questions of detail and they are not allowed on the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
These are matters that would properly arise on the Estimate for the Minister concerned.
Comment on this
The Deputy is discussing the general credit policy and is making suggestions on major policy.
Comment on this
As part of the scheme to increase agricultural production. That is general policy. While it may be a detail, I submit it is a very relevant and important detail. The second point I should like to make is that fertilisers should be made available at a cheaper price if we are sincere about increased agricultural production.
Comment on this
Obviously, there is not any use in trying to discuss increased agricultural production if I am not to submit my own suggestions.
Comment on this
I submit that this is much too wide a matter for any one Minister to deal with. I suggest that it is a matter for the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and two or three other Ministers. I submit that this could not be decided by the Minister for Agriculture, that this is Government policy, or should be Government policy. For instance, the Minister for Agriculture cannot put in force a lower rate of interest charges for loans to farmers without going into consultation with the Government as a whole. That is the reason I am mentioning very broad headings which would not be considered too detailed for this debate. The restriction of credit by banks to farmers all over the Twenty-Six Counties by refusing loans even to those who have registered land is a matter that the Taoiseach and the Government should take up at once if they are sincere in trying to bring about increased agricultural production.
Before I leave that point, might I say that the present budgetary policy which commenced on the first Wednesday in April last year has deliberately produced the result of increasing agricultural exports, but at the expense of the standard of living of our own people. That was a desperate step for any Government to take. Ireland has been famous for producing the very best quality of food in the world and now that we have got our freedom, Irish people who produce or contribute towards the production of food, whether they live in the cities or towns or in the country districts, should have the first claim on that food. It is foul and wrong for any Government deliberately to deny them the purchasing power which would give them a chance to live in a moderately comfortable way on their own home-produced food.
The cutting down of drainage under the Local Authorities (Works) Act and transferring that money to another purpose is a completely retrograde step. The grant for the LocalAuthorities (Works) Act has been cut down from £650,000 to £400,000.
Comment on this
I presume that is where some of the money will go. The supplementary agricultural grants are down by £50,000. The urban employment schemes are down by £34,000 and the rural employment schemes by £46,000. These are in the domain of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. There has been a decrease of £200,000 on subhead K (1) of the Vote of the Office of Public Works for the purchase of machinery for arterial drainage and similar schemes. These are steps in the wrong direction. Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary will say that the Office of Public Works has sufficient machinery to deal with any arterial drainage schemes envisaged for the next three, four or five years.
Comment on this
Many people down the country would not agree with the Parliamentary Secretary on that. They would not agree with the snail-like pace with regard to arterial drainage or the cutting down of the Local Authorities (Works) Act drainage all over the country. They do not understand, now that the land rehabilitation scheme has got into its stride and the Vote should be expanded to the extent of £4,000,000 for the reclamation of the 4,000,000 acres I spoke of some time ago, how it is that that particular Vote is only increasing by a miserable £400,000 when it should be increased by £1,000,000 at least.
Comment on this
A great number of people do not agree with the way in which the Local Authorities (Works) Act was carried out in the first two years.
Comment on this
At that time every Fianna Fáil Deputy was going around the country saying that it would increase the valuation of the lands. Every conceivable falsehood they could manufacture was manufactured in order to kill that scheme.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Blowick not to be allowed to proceed with his speech without being constantly interrupted? If you want disorder, you will get it.
Comment on this
I want to deal now with one particular Department which the Minister for Finance dealt with or tried to deal with last night. Incidentally, he cut a very ridiculous figure in trying to deal with the matter and showed how little he knew about it. I am referring to the Department of Forestry. The Minister devoted a large part of his speech to that and finished up by saying that not one penny return has come from the trees planted during Deputy Blowick's time. I can imagine Dublin Opinionin its next issue picturing the Minister for Finance dressed in knickerbockers with a pair of leggings and a battered tweed hat setting off with an axe on one shoulder and a pick on the other to the forests in order to teach the Minister for Lands how they should be dealt with.
Last night the Minister for Finance gave us some very misleading details about the work of the Forestry Department. He quoted the Estimates for the various years and the Appropriations-in-Aid. I do not agree that the figures he quoted were the correct figures. Let us deal with this Minister for Finance who has suddenly taken forestry to his bosom and thinks it will be a cure for all the ills of the country at the present moment. The Estimate for the Forestry Department in 1937-38 was £152,798; in 1938-39 it was £148,103. It was reduced by £4,000 that year by this Minister who is now so particular about it. In 1948-49 the Estimates were prepared before we took office and we had no option but to introduce them. But, in the year 1949-50, the second year in which I as Minister introduced the Estimate, it was increased from £148,103 in 1938-39 to £583,500; in 1950-51 it was £699,865; and in 1951-52 it was £1,243,440.
Comment on this
I may not have that figure. If I remember correctly, it wasbetween £300,000 and £400,000. I am subject to correction in regard to that, but the other figures are accurate. Let us now look at the Appropriations-in-Aid, that is the income from the Forestry Department. In 1937-38 they were £9,150; in 1938-39, £10,650; in 1949-50, £103,760; in 1950-51, £124,434; in 1951-52, £175,730. The present Government, including the Taoiseach, has never missed an opportunity of trying to belittle the forestry programme initiated during the inter-Party Government's régime. We know what the Fianna Fáil attitude towards forestry was in the past. They made no secret of it. Forestry was according to them too costly a luxury for this country. No particular attempt was made to bring the Forestry Division into full operation. The Minister did not tell us last night why the Appropriation-in-Aid has been increased from £9,150 in 1937-38 to £175,730 this year. Prior to our coming into office the Forestry Division was neglected.
There was a vast quantity of good matured timber purchased on estates up and down the country which was allowed to rot in some cases and in other cases to deteriorate into the firewood stage. I put 15 sawmills into operation in order to use that timber for our own people and to save imports. No mention was made of that last night. The Government has now taken over a Forestry Division, fully staffed and equipped. I took the trouble when I was Minister of travelling in the depths of winter all over the forests of England and Scotland to ensure that the best and most suitable machinery would be purchased for our forests here. We paid £160,000 for machinery.
Comment on this
The Deputy must make allowance for the changing value of money and also the change in the value of property.
Comment on this
I agree there has been a change, but we have had no explanation of the increase from £9,150 in 1938-39 to £175,000 in the present year. I hope that the second sawmillearmarked for Cork will be in production soon. There are 3,000,000 cubic feet of timber available there. There should be a return to the Department of something in the region of £400,000 a year from the work of those sawmills. The Minister for Finance talking about forestry is something of a joke. He castigated me and said that they were not reaping one penny from the trees planted in 1948, 1949 and 1950. That raised a laugh on both sides of the House. God help the present Minister for Lands, or any other Minister, trying to bring home to that little man the needs of his Department.
The present Government must revise the budgetary policy formulated last year. They seem to have devoted all their time during the year to trying to find some new class they could tax. They started on the housewives and the working man. Then we had the small farmer, the hackney driver and the lorry driver. I do not think there is any class that has not been assaulted by taxation. The standard of living has been reduced everywhere. I know it is humiliating for a Government to embark on a wild policy and then have to come back and eat humble pie, but even at this late hour it would be better to do that than to continue along the present lines.
We must face facts. Revenue has decreased from tobacco and drink because of the policy of the Government. In 1948, when these commodities were taxed, the people very promptly took the first opportunity of showing their disapproval, and we ran the country for three and a half years and brought prosperity to every home. The country was bursting with prosperity in 1951 when the present Government came into office. Unemployment had practically ceased. Young men who had emigrated had returned during those three and a half years to work again in their own land. Can anyone give me the name of even one young man who has come back under the present Government to find employment in his own country?
Comment on this
He has not come yet. It would be a formidable task if the Minister for Finance had to pay £250,000 for every man who returned to his native country. Can any member of the Fianna Fáil Party quote one person who has come home as a result of the present Government's policy?
Comment on this
There is a scandalous attempt being made by the Government at the present time to recapture some of the seats they lost in the last general election.
Comment on this
I hold that in this sum of £34,000,000 for which the Minister is asking the House now, there is a sum of money earmarked for the purpose of buying back popularity. From a political point of view that is a foolish thing, because a blind person could see through it. Public moneys should not be used for that purpose. It will not gain one vote for them. Their popularity is waning and the only thing that is left to the Government is to dissolve. After the next general election you will be over here again with the same sour faces that had my heart scalded during the three and a half years of the inter-Party Government. You can get an indicator if you like, in a small way, if you go to Wicklow.
Comment on this
I think it is time the whole policy of the Government was reviewed. This is one opportunity Deputies get of reviewing it. On the Estimates one is confined to the particular matters dealt with in the particular Estimate before the House. Not until we reach the Taoiseach's Estimate can we review Government policy. The greatest benefit the Government could confer on the countrynow is to dissolve. The reason they are determined to hold on is that they know what the people's answer will be and that is, as Deputy Dillon told them, minus 25 seats on their way back from the hustings.
Comment on this
I will have to pull against Deputy Blowick this time. The people of Ireland are paying dearly for the three and a half years' experiment of the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
They are paying dearly for the way that Government conducted their affairs. The bad turns men do live after them.
Comment on this
I must congratulate Deputy Blowick, Deputy Dillon and Deputy Costello for being past masters at misrepresentation. We were being told last year that we were budgeting for £10,000,000 more than we required. They castigated Fianna Fáil for what they said was dishonesty. The Deputies opposite worked themselves into a fury in trying to put that over on the people. They tried to convince the people that they were sincere and that they were telling the truth when they knew in their heart that no Minister for Finance of any democratic Party would budget for any more than was required. That was what the Minister for Finance did on the last occasion and will have to do again. Why are we in this position to-day?
Comment on this
Why have we to do things of which the Opposition are so critical and regard as being wrong? They should realise that anything we are doing is for the purpose of putting this country in the same condition as we left it in 1948, in a sound economic position, so that we would not lose our economic independence as we would be in danger of losing it had we anotherone or two years of inter-Party Government.
The problems which exist in this country exist in other countries and they are applying similar remedies as we are applying. We want to see this country fit for our children and our grandchildren to live in in years to come. There is no foundation for the accusations made by the Opposition that Fianna Fáil are dishonest. We had to do the hardest thing any political Party in the world ever had to do. We had to put the interests of our country before our Party. We did not try to barter or to introduce dishonest Budgets and bolster up our own Party on that unsound basis. If we did that we would be failing in our duty as Irishmen and Irishwomen who had the responsibility of dealing with the affairs of this Dáil. We found it necessary, in carrying out our duty, to take most unpopular decisions in order to rectify the maladministration of the inter-Party Government during their three and a half years in office. They tore down a number of things we had built up. In my own constituency in County Dublin I found a number of factories with the workers idle. I had found neglect in a number of other industries that we had encouraged and fostered to make them of national benefit.
Deputy Dillon is continually expressing concern for the farmers of this country. He thought very little of the farmers when he tried to misrepresent my motives in seeking protection for our tomato industry because it was a national undertaking. He said I was concerned about vested interests although this industry was giving a good deal of employment at the time. Deputy Dillon was more concerned with giving employment to Dutch workers than with the welfare of the farmers.
It was the same in regard to the fishing industry and in regard to milk. Deputy Dillon succeeded in misrepresenting the farmers that he is now crying for. He preferred to import maize than give any semblance of protection to those anxious to grow maize in this country. The Fianna Fáil tillage policy was a wise one, and it brought very good results during thewar. As soon as Deputy Dillon got in he repudiated that policy and was supported 100 per cent. by the alleged archangels of the workers, the Labour Party. He abandoned the tillage campaign to the detriment of our economy as a whole. This was the man who was concerned about balancing the Budget and who was so interested in the farmer. He was prepared to give every protection to him. On many occasions he expressed in this House his concern for the dairying industry. His heart was bleeding for them. This is the type of dishonest politics and dishonest propaganda of which we hear so much day after day in this House. The Opposition did everything they could to belittle this country and to belittle the national aspirations of people on this side of the House who cherished ideals as far as this country was concerned. The ideal of the Fianna Fáil Party was that some day we would be able to build up the economy of the nation so that Irish men and women would obtain a livelihood which would enable them to look after their children in a Christian manner.
Deputy Dillon wants us to go to the country, as does his colleague and ex-Minister, Deputy Blowick. What have they to give to the country? All they are capable of is destructive criticism, and the same bartering would go on again.
Deputy Dillon spoke about Newfoundland and its unstable economic position. If Deputy Dillon had another year in office as Minister for Agriculture this country would have been reduced to a similar situation as exists in Newfoundland.
What are we doing for employment here? We have done everything humanly possible. We have encouraged our farmers to get back into tillage. We have increased the price of wheat with a view to inducing more agricultural workers to return to the land. We have encouraged more beet growing and more turf-cutting. We have also taken steps to develop our factories, all the protection they required has been afforded to them. Road grants have also been increased. All this work has been carried out with one object inview, to create employment for our people.
Many times during the three years that the inter-Party Government were in office, I was obliged to complain here that certain factories had been deprived of protection and that a number of workers were in consequence idle. I had to draw the attention of the responsible Minister to the serious state of affairs in my constituency during that period. If the prosperity that the inter-Party Government allege was brought about by their administration was as great as they suggest, we should be living in a Utopia at the end of their term of office. Unfortunately the evil that men do lives after them and we are paying for the maladministration of the inter-Party Government now. I hope that sincere people in Ireland whatever their political views may be will not close their eyes to the position into which the inter-Party Government led this country and that they will realise that anything the present Government has been forced to do is in the interests of themselves and their children. I hope that no matter what propaganda is used down the country, the people will not be hoodwinked into selling their birthright.
One would imagine listening to Deputy Blowick that there was never a Forestry Department in Ireland until Deputy Blowick came along. The Forestry Department was in existence long before Deputy Blowick appeared on the political scene. The only difference between Deputy Blowick and his predecessor in the Fianna Fáil administration was that the Fianna Fáil Minister was anxious that lands which could not be utilised for any other purpose would be used for growing trees. Judging by a remark which I heard yesterday across the floor of the House, Deputy Blowick as Minister did not mind if trees were planted in the best arable land in the country. I hold that no trees should be grown in arable land; I believe we have enough waste land to grow timber and that arable land could be more profitably used for other purposes. The inter-Party Government started off on a campaign in regard to forestry in whichthey appeared to be more interested in setting up records than anything else. A tree might be only 2 months old, perhaps the size of a match, but so long as it was only stuck in the ground they did not mind, since is counted for record purposes. With eyewash of that kind they hoped to convince the country that they were doing something which in fact they were not doing.
We heard a good deal about the adverse trade balance and what it means. We know Deputy Dillon's outlook and that it has changed only very slightly from the time he was anxious to import maize, tomatoes and every single commodity he could import. The defence of the previous Government for their stockpiling policy was that they thought that we were going to have war but if, instead of importing finished articles, they imported the raw materials for these articles we could have kept our workers in employment. There are factories in my constituency which are still suffering from the stockpiling policy operated by the last Government. Many Opposition Deputies now have the effrontery to ask the present Ministers questions in regard to conditions for which they themselves are responsible.
They know well that nothing the present Minister will do can rectify the mistakes of the past. If there was a shred of honesty among the members of the Opposition to-day, they would recognise that the Fianna Fáil Government are endeavouring to repair the mistakes which the previous Government made. The Fianna Fáil Government was saddled with a very ugly job and, as I say, they are trying to rectify the mistakes of their predecessors. If the inter-Party Government were in office now, they would have to follow along the very same lines but instead of honestly admitting that, they resort to expediency and seek to make Party capital out of every action of the Government. I must again compliment them on being past masters in misrepresentation and in being completely dishonest in the manner in which they seek to present facts to the people.
My final appeal to anybody who wants Ireland to go ahead is not toallow himself to be swayed by the misrepresentations of ex-Ministers of the inter-Party Government and of Deputies on the Opposition Benches. These misrepresentations should not be heeded lest they should undo the good work which we have done in the past and with which we have been going ahead since we resumed office.
Comment on this
I think it would be a kindness to ask the House to forget quickly what Deputy Burke has been endeavouring to say. I was interested in the speech which was made this afternoon by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. He took it upon himself to lecture this House and the country on economic matters. On every possible occasion during the past two years, this junior member of the Government has endeavoured to outdo other members of the Government in long fulminations on economic matters, in explaining not only what makes this country tick economically but what causes every other country under the sun to tick economically. That may appeal to the ego of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs but it is often a very painful experience for the members of this House.
It is particularly painful when we find that the urge to lecture compels the Minister concerned to express immense satisfaction on the alleged achievements of his Government. He said to-day that he is very proud to be able to give the House and the country a report with regard to the astounding progress made by the Fianna Fáil Government in the past two years. He said he was proud to make that report—even though Deputy Dr. Browne and other Deputies pointed out to him that the effect of the good work of his Government, in terms of human misery, was that there are now 90,000 unemployed persons in this country. In addition, there has been a considerable increase in emigration. That did not depress the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. His happy little financial soul was delighted that the books were balancing and that everything was grand, in terms of figures. I cannot understand the mentality that would permit a member of an Irish Parliament to view with satisfactiona set of Government actions which have brought about the greatest unemployment problem in the history of this State. I do not know how the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs could regard that as something of which he and his country could be proud. I would dub anybody who would fall for that fallacy as a person unfitted not only to be a member of a Government elected by this House, but unfitted to be a member of this House. I could remind the House of many other matters with which the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs dealt, but, if I did so, I should fall into the same error of fulminating on important matters. I do not intend to do that.
This debate, at the commencement of the financial year, affords Deputies an opportunity of examining Government policy—if they have a policy— and of making suggestions of a concrete nature with regard to matters of policy. We on this side of the House intend to avail fully of this opportunity this year to examine Government policy, because we firmly believe that the country is now faced with a danger as great as any she has ever faced. We firmly believe that this country is face to face with a crisis of serious dimensions. It is not a crisis brought about by military pressure or matters of that kind.
It is a crisis caused by reason of the fact that our economic situation is such that we are not employing our own citizens, that we are compelling them to emigrate and that we are forcing on our people the acceptance of a substantial lowering of living standards. That critical situation is a challenge to Irish initiative, to political Parties and to people generally to find a solution for it. We on this side of the House have the solution. The Fine Gael Party have a policy which, we believe, will go a long way towards solving unemployment, towards stemming the trend of emigration and towards the solution of the perennial problems of underproduction in this country.
If, in the course of this debate, we find it necessary to criticise in a decisiveand determined manner the occupants of the Government Benches we do so only because they are standing in the way of our getting on with the work. We have ceased to regard them as in any way directing or leading the country. We have ceased to regard them seriously as the Government of this country. They are there and they will remain in office only so long as they can maintain the lifetime of this present Dáil. The very moment circumstances compel a dissolution of Dáil Eireann the way will be cleared for a new Government and for the implementation of a policy which will tackle the present problems which face the country. The danger is that the human weakness and frailty of those sitting on the Chair's left-hand side may cause the period of salvation of our people to be unduly delayed. I hope that that will not be so.
To understand any policy or to advance a solution for any problem, it is necessary to understand how the problem arose in order that remedies may be considered. It may be just a refining of the causes if I say that much of the problems that now face this country arise by virtue of the fact that Fianna Fáil are in office and that we are not. But, although that may appear to be merely a small political crack, I think that in fact it contains a great deal of truth in it.
The facts are that, before the present Fianna Fáil-Independent Coalition Government found itself in office, there was in operation here not a perfect fin-economic policy and not a perfect financial policy, but at least a planned effort to solve the perennial problems of unemployment and emigration. That policy which had been in operation under the inter-Party Government, grew, if you like, out of an effort by that Government in 1948 to get to grips with the situation which they found confronting the country.
In 1948, when the inter-Party Government went into office, they faced, as we are facing now, an unemployment problem of serious dimensions, not as serious as now but serious enough; they faced also an emigration problem not as serious as now but serious enough; they faced a taxation problemnot as serious as now but serious enough. The situation which faced the inter-Party Government when it went into office was this: employment was not available for our people at home, and, because it was not available, they had to emigrate. Those who still held employment here found taxation pressing heavily on them. There had been a Supplementary Budget only a few months before which imposed taxation on, amongst other things, beer, stout and cigarettes. Taxation at the time took a fair portion of the wages that any worker, who was lucky enough to hold a job at home, earned. The problems which faced the inter-Party Government required some solution. I make a present to the Government side of the House, if they make any point that no clear policy was announced before the inter-Party Government went into office, by saying that that is true. But a policy grew up very quickly, a policy designed initially from a short term point of view and later from a long term point of view, a policy designed to deal with the particular problems which then faced the Government and the country.
Now, that policy was an investment policy, a policy aimed at supplying to this country the great need for capital investment which had been referred to, and talked about for many years before, and the absence of which led to constant yearly unemployment, to the constant drain of emigration and to the many problems which then faced the country. The inter-Party Government set out on a course designed in a small way in the beginning to supply to this country the capital investment it required. There were many ways in which the then Government sought to fuse into the country's economy the capital it required. There was, first of all, a savings drive. It will be recalled by the House that, only a few months before the inter-Party Government came into office, the then Fianna Fáil administration had reduced the interest payable to the small depositor in Saving Certificates and in the Post Office Savings Bank.
Comment on this
The first thing that was done was to increase the interest payable on savings. The Government then decided to tackle the big problem of foreign disinvestment. In setting out on that course, the inter-Party Government had had many teachers in the past if they had any doubt as to the wisdom of repatriating some of this country's foreign assets for productive purposes here, and, not in a short space of time but over a long space of time, they would have expected that that policy would have appealed to the then Fianna Fáil Opposition. The last thing they would have expected would be an appeal for financial orthodoxy from people like the then Deputy MacEntee or Deputy Briscoe or Deputy Lemass or other Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party, because the present Minister for Finance had very definite views on this question of investment generally. It is almost 30 years since, in this House, the then Deputy MacEntee in the salad days of Fianna Fáil——
Comment on this
It is of importance and I think I will be able to show that it has a connection with the present policy of the Government.
Comment on this
We are discussing the policy of the Government in the present year and not 30 years ago.
Comment on this
I am endeavouring to discuss the reasons why the Government have no policy in relation to the problems which now face the country. To do so, I think I am in order in showing that the varying ideas with regard to the financial and economic policy have their result in the fact that there is no policy now. Speaking in this House—Volume 21, column 809, 3rd November, 1927—the then Deputy MacEntee, like the present Ministerfor Posts and Telegraphs, referred to other countries as an example of the financial policy we should follow. He said:—
"In France you have a practical example of that."
He was speaking about credit facilities.
"You have seen what France did, as this British observer says, by her own resources. She had not to borrow abroad. The money, credit and capital, as well as the labour to do this, was provided by France. How has that been accomplished? The Government controlled the credit and retained control of that credit, notwithstanding the inducements made to it by foreign financiers to surrender it. The Government was not under the control of the credit manufacturer, as the present Government in Ireland has been since the day the Provisional Government accepted their first loan from the Bank of Ireland early in 1922. Controlling that credit power, the Government of France compelled it to the service of the State. It never allowed it to restrict itself so as to cripple industry, but forced it to expand, when such expansion was necessary to carry through the great schemes of national reconstruction that the State had framed. Compare the blessings that the policy of that enlightened and patriotic Government brought to its people with the misery and suffering we have endured under Mr. Cosgrave, who has kept us all the time tied up in a strait-waistcoat of Threadneedle Street."
Deputy MacEntee went on to say:—
"The President is a fair sort of economist, an ardent disciple, I think, of the Manchester school, and an excellent specimen, I would say a relic, interesting and sometimes amusing, of an economic policy of bygone age. But, unfortunately for this country and its people, his economic development ended, I should say, before he was born. In the course of his speech he said that he listened to more economicheresies than he had ever listened to in his life."
The Deputy went on to say that the then Government regarded as an economic heresy anything that would separate them from the fiscal and financial control of John Bull. He said that the Government had gone about tying up their currency to the British £ and that the industry of this country was thereby in chains, because of the link with sterling.
That is a financial view and a financial policy expressed by the Fianna Fáil Party many years ago. That financial view and that financial policy was repeated by the present Minister for Finance some years later. On the 23rd September, 1931, he is reported in the Irish Pressas saying:—
"Even before the Fianna Fáil Party went into the Dáil, its members had directed public attention to the dangers to which our people were exposed by reason not only of our attachment to sterling but of the shortsighted policy of the Anglo-Irish bankers in investing their depositors' funds in British securities. The Free State Government, under President Cosgrave, has been on the side of Britain. The Anglo-Irish banks have been on the side of Britain. The Currency Commission has been on the side of Britain."
He made an appeal then that the Irish Government should break the link with sterling, control its own credit and everything would be perfect.
Those were expressions of policy on financial matters by the present Minister for Finance and we have to consider now, many years later, how time and office have tempered and changed the views that the Minister held in his early salad days.
I have said that most of the problems this country is now facing are due to the fact that the present Government is in office and we are out of office. The House should remember that one of the first statements made by the present Minister when he assumed office two years ago was directed to this whole question of capital investment, the control of credit and the policy that theinter-Party Government had had in operation.
Speaking in this House on the 18th July, 1951—Volume 126, column 1884— the Minister said:
"In our circumstances now and in pursuance of present policy, the overriding objective is to see that the community surrenders enough purchasing power to cover all the State outlay, current and capital, on the one hand to curtail expenditure regarded as being in the national interest or, on the other hand, to adopt methods of financing its expenditure which are undoubtedly injurious to the national economy."
There was the start of the difficulties that this country has faced. The Minister was speaking at a time when the State had gone as near achieving full employment as it ever had in its history. He was speaking at a time when the State had nearly got back to the year 1931, the year before Fianna Fáil came into power, when there was no emigration at all. He was speaking at a time when there had been a substantial fall in emigration. He was speaking at a time when taxation was pretty well contained within the ability of the people to bear and when prices were certainly not the problem that they are now. In that situation the Minister says:
"In our circumstances now and in pursuance of present policy, the overriding objective is to see that the community surrenders enough purchasing power to cover all the State outlay, current and capital..."
That was quite a challenge to the policy that we had in operation. The inter-Party Government's policy did not require the people to surrender their purchasing power to finance the capital projects of the State. Those were financed through savings—that to a certain extent would be a surrender of purchasing power but it would not be the compulsory surrender that the Minister was there talking about—and through foreign disinvestment. There was this challenge to the policy that we had in operation.
That speech of the Minister on the 18th July, 1951, was followed, two or three months later, by the Central Bank Report. That report in turn was followed, in the spring of last year, by the Budget that has been discussed here.
I hope to show that, in the intervening period between the speech on the 18th July, 1951, and the passage of the Budget the Government turned their back completely on the policy of their predecessor; that, in so doing, they went back to the policy which had been in operation before of starving the country of investment and that, as a result, unemployment began to assume critical proportions, emigration again began to increase, and as a result, we have had all the difficulties which now face the country.
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs took some pride because he said the Government had not taken the advice given in the Central Bank Report. For instance, he said with regard to the recommendation to remove subsidies that the Fianna Fáil Government had not done that, that they had only reduced the subsidies. That is like the plea that members of my profession from time to time hear, in fact have to make for a thief who stole some money. The thief makes the case: "I should not be regarded as a thief because I stole only £5 and not £10." It is absurd for the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, whose Government implemented the policy which was designed to take from our people their purchasing power by compelling them to pay more for the goods they had to buy to keep body and soul together, to take credit for the fact that they had not taken more purchasing power when they were about it. We all know that the Central Bank Report was swallowed hook, line and sinker by the neophyte economists who adorn the present Government.
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs also derived some pleasure from the fact that that report of the Central Bank was similar to reports made by other financial authorities to democratic Governments in Western Europe. I have no doubt that that is so. Ishould like to know from the Minister, however, how many other Governments swallowed it hook, line and sinker as his Government have done. I cannot think of any democratic Government which would be prepared to do what that report suggested should be done, deliberately to reduce living standards by compelling people to pay more for food and in that way absorbing excess purchasing power; deliberately causing unemployment by restricting public works and capital schemes of that kind so that the wages which might have been earned would not be added to the pool of purchasing power. I cannot think of any other Government in any part of the world who would be prepared to do that.
It may be suggested that the British Government in the Budget introduced a few weeks before our Budget here last year followed the same line. I have no doubt that the British Budget was used as a model to a certain extent for the present Minister's Budget last spring. Using it as a model, however, the Minister apparently did not appreciate the very great safeguards which the British Government introduced to ensure that living standards would not be harmed and that employment would not be seriously affected. We had here the most crude form of deflationary Budget introduced by any Government within recent years. The results that followed showed the macabre mentality that sponsored, formed and fashioned that financial instrument. The purchasing power of the people has disappeared. Having to pay more, being able to earn less, naturally they have suffered considerably in living standards.
It was also inevitable that with a Budget of that kind the business life of the community and available employment should have suffered. That has happened to a very marked and astounding degree during the last 12 months. I do not know whether members of the Government or Deputies on the other side appreciate how sensitive business conditions can be in any country. If a Government proceed positively to interfere with the confidence of the community, with creditfacilities and matters of that kind, then the harm they do in itself causes further harm. We all know that the unemployment caused initially by the Budget of last year in itself further reduced purchasing power in the hands of the community and that that further reduction caused further unemployment, and a spiral has been started the effects of which are now beginning to be apparent even to Deputies on the other side of the House. So serious is the unemployment problem now that we are finding it running at the rate of 1,000 persons per week. There are 1,000 people holding down jobs to-night who will not have them this night week. That is a very tragic situation when it is realised that 90,000 people unemployed is only part of the tragic story of the results of the last Budget.
One can only guess at the number of people who have emigrated during the past 12 or 18 months. No figures are available. It is impossible to know, at the moment at any rate, what the tide of emigration is now. Certainly, from my knowledge of the country and of my own constituency I would regard the trend of emigration now as being as serious as it was at any time during the last war. Travelling facilities between England and Ireland have eased. People can now travel without difficulty or investigation and the man who is unemployed on Monday can find himself looking for a job in London or Manchester two or three days later.
Comment on this
And vice versa.The Deputy appreciates that a number of people are coming back from England to this city.
Comment on this
I do not think it can be urged that we have returning emigrants attracted by prospects of employment here.
Comment on this
It is true that there are more coming back now. Conditions are very bad in England at the moment.
Comment on this
If the Deputy believes that, then my prognosis for the Fianna Fáil Party is very bad indeed. That is the greatest piece of pipe-dreamingI have ever heard. The fact is that emigration is now taking a greater toll than it ever did for many years past.
Comment on this
The Deputy is talking about the City of Dublin! We have in this city at the present moment an unemployment problem greater than we have ever had before. In the satellite town of Bray we have 3,000 people unemployed. What is the use of saying our emigrants are coming back here to find work in this city?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins should be allowed to make his speech in his own way without interruption.
Comment on this
Building has slumped. Every large source of employment is going through difficult times. Men are being laid off work every day. The Deputy's argument is nonsense. It is in that situation of unemployment and hardship that we are anxious the people should be given an alternative and should be given the opportunity of putting a better policy into operation. I do not for a moment concede that there is any policy in operation because it is a regrettable fact that over the last 18 months or two years we have had the Government jumping like so many grasshoppers from one crisis to another, following no consistent course and no consistent plan.
The present Minister for Finance may derive some satisfaction from knowing that he has done what we on this side of the House have been trying to do for a great number of years: he has finished the Fianna Fáil Party. There is no doubt that the last 18 months has wrought the destruction of any political support for the present Government here because of the results of the grasshopper financial policy it has put into operation.
Obviously, if our present ills are to be cured, some political Party with a programme will have to do that work. The Fianna Fáil Party has noprogramme. The Minister stood for the printing of banknotes in 1931. He now stands for a greater orthodoxy in finance than do the financial experts of the Bank of England, and in comparison with our present Minister for Finance the experts of the Bank of England are roaring "Reds". The present Tánaiste and Minister for Industry and Commerce stood for breaking the link with sterling in 1927. He is now the trumpeter of the Central Bank.
How can the people have any confidence in a Government composed of a multiplicity of minds? The first thing that must be done is to restore the confidence of our people. In the last two years serious attacks have been made on the credit-worthiness of this State. The hatchet men of the present Government went out armed with their little hatchets to chip away the credit-worthiness of this State. Their little bit of chipping has not, fortunately, done irreparable damage, but it has to a certain extent caused harm and dismay. It has caused 90,000 people to be unemployed. It has caused 60,000 or 70,000 people to emigrate. It has caused a substantial increase in taxation; it has caused a very serious increase in prices. But all that can be cured if confidence is restored.
The first thing necessary to restore confidence is to get the present Government out. In no other way can the people's confidence be restored in the financial or economic future of the country except by the election of a Government and a Party that knows the financial strength of the country and the policy to be operated to nurture that strength. The present Government has caused our present problems. The problems are far too big for them, and, in order to restore confidence, the present Government will have to resign. They must make way to enable others to solve the problems they have created.
Secondly, the next Government must realise, as the inter-Party Government realised, that mere book-keeping transactions, as the Leader of the Opposition said to-day, do not spell economic stability and soundness. The fact thatthe adverse trade balance has been reduced does not mean that the country is well governed, that social problems have diminished, that sources of employment have increased, or that the people generally are better off.
The greatest mistake the present Minister has made is that he has concerned himself in the last 18 months with the book-keeping orthodoxy of his financial policy. He shuddered with horror when he saw an adverse balance of trade, of some phenomenal figure according to him, in 1950 and 1951 and he proceeded to remedy that situation. It all tied up with the recommendations of the Central Bank and with other advices he got. He proceeded to introduce his famous deflationary policy, preventing the people from buying by stealing the money from them. He solved his balance of trade problems. He can have a present of that. But at what cost to the people? Instead of importing the building materials necessary to house our people and the other commodities urgently required we are now exporting thousands and thousands of human beings and we are running at a greater cost than ever before social services in an effort to maintain to some extent those who are unemployed at home. That is how we are paying the cost of the book-keeping rectitude that the present Minister preached as his gospel over the last 18 months or two years.
We realise that to solve the present problems will require a lot more than would have been necessary if the temporary interruption of the inter-Party Government had not taken place. We propose—as the Leader of the Opposition has stated time and time again—to continue our investment programme, if returned to power. We propose to repatriate some of this country's external assets. We make no apology that that was our policy in the past. The adoption of that policy in the past provided employment and gave a lasting return to the country. What we did before we will do again.
It has been suggested that the justification for the actual amount of money invested by the Central Bank in Britain has been the demand forliquidity. As the Leader of the Opposition stated recently at the Fine Gael Ard Feis, we propose to take steps to provide a domestic money market that will provide liquidity which has been offered as a justification for these investments abroad. That capital investment programme will be financed, firstly, by the reinvestment in this country of our people's assets and sterling credits at present invested abroad. It will be done in a sane, prudent manner by men who know what they are doing, whose policy was successful in the past and who do not go in for the claptrap with which some members of the present Government sought votes some 20 or 30 years ago. They do not talk about the financial straitjacket, Threadneedle Street, such as the present Minister talked about before he became a Minister.
The next thing we propose to do is what the present Minister spoke about on the 18th July, 1951 but did not do. We would take steps to increase the capital that would be available from savings. I think it can be said by Deputies on all sides of the House that the Leader of the Opposition consistently for the last 18 months or 2 years has stated time and time again the necessity for a savings drive in this country. He has suggested—and at times he has been sneered at for his pains—that the Minister would be giving better service to the State if he would create enthusiasm among local bodies, voluntary and other kinds of bodies, for a savings drive. The result could substantially increase the capital available for a long term investment programme.
We in Fine Gael suggest that such a savings drive is essential. If that is not done there are many other things that could be done to increase the voluntary savings of the people. An intelligent programme of tax relief for small savings and an increase in the relief of life insurance premiums could be provided. In addition much could be done with regard to industrial activity, providing for industrialists an inducement to save by tax reliefs worked out in various ways.
In any event, we on this side of the House do emphasise the necessity for increased savings. Unlike the Minister,we do not merely indulge in pious aspirations of that kind but we suggest a way of doing what we regard as necessary.
Comment on this
Our policy on subsidies apparently fell on deaf ears at the time of the Budget.
Comment on this
I suggest the Deputy should not talk too much about subsidies. Not so very long ago Deputy Browne had an opportunity seldom given to human beings of ensuring that the price of bread would not increase and that the prices of those other commodities would not increase. He was able to walk to the Lobby himself but he could not induce his colleague to rise from the seat.
Comment on this
By the time the Fine Gael Party programme is started I think we will find Deputy Browne very anxious to climb on the band wagon.
There are other matters with regard to capital investment with which the Leader of the Opposition has dealt fully. I cannot go into them in detail and I do not intend to do so. Suffice it to say that our policy is a constructive one. We do not merely come here or engage in this debate for the purpose of abusing the present Government and leaving it at that. We have a policy that will reduce the figure of 90,000 unemployed that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs thought something desirable in the country. We have a policy which will stem emigration.
Comment on this
I have been endeavouring to refer to it. It is a policy of capital investment which we hadin operation for three years, and will continue in operation if we get into power. It must be clear, certainly to the country if not to the House, that the present situation cannot continue for long. There is, so far as the people can see, no lead being given by the Government with regard to the problems which face the country. Different Ministers make different speeches and advocate different policies from time to time. The only Party in this House which has consistently followed, in government and out of government, the same financial and economic policy has been the Fine Gael Party, led by Deputy Costello, the Leader of the Opposition.
He has advocated and put forward consistently in the last two years, the assurance to the people that, financially and economically, we are as sound as any other country under the sun, that all we require to solve unemployment, emigration and allied problems is the intelligent investment here at home of the resources that we may have available, and that we are lucky as a country to have available for investment substantial external resources. That policy that he has consistently preached now assumes a more real significance because the alternative prudish book-keeping policy of the present Minister for Finance has been in operation for the last 18 or 19 months, and the people can see what harm it has done. The people can see, in terms of human suffering and misery, the appalling thing that was done when certain Deputies in this House, for reasons material only to themselves, caused a temporary stoppage of inter-Party policy. The alternatives are clear to the people now. It is for that reason I say that our policy now assumes a new significance.
We are shortly to have another Budget in this country. It is too early to say who will introduce that Budget. It is also too much of a gamble to imagine what policy will inspire that Budget but assuming, for the purposes of this debate only, that the Budget to be introduced in three or four weeks will be introduced by the present Minister for Finance, can the House justcontemplate the policy that is likely to inspire his Budget? No longer clad in the armour in which he garbed himself in April, 1952, when he posed here as the Iron Chancellor, telling the people that they would have to pay whether they liked it or not, he came into the House last night full of sweet reasonableness. In future, according to the Minister, taxation is to be assessed not merely by the capacity of the people to pay but by their willingness to pay. That is a new departure for the Minister for Finance. Possibly it is part of the lesson that was taught in North-West Dublin. The willingness of the people to pay is now to be an important item in Government financial policy. The willingness of the people to pay involves freedom of action for the individual who feels that an unfair tax is imposed and who refrains from buying rather than pay that unfair tax.
It was the willingness of the people that we on this side of the House endeavoured to bring before the Government and the Minister when his Budget was introduced almost 12 months ago. We made the charge then, and it is as well that the House should be reminded of it now, that the last Budget aimed at a surplus and that the Government intended to take some £9,000,000 or £10,000,000 more than was required from the people in taxation. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs chided the Opposition with that charge made on the occasion of the last Budget. We repeat it now. The Minister for Finance hoped that his Budget would yield a surplus of £9,000,000 or £10,000,000. There were some incalculables that he did not take into consideration. One was the popular opinion which his Budget formed and fashioned against taxation which the public believe to be unfair. To that extent the surplus might not realise what he hoped it to be. It may not be £10,000,000 but there is no doubt that there is going to be a substantial surplus on this year's trading.
There is no doubt that at the end of the present year the Minister will have £3,000,000 or £4,000,000 over to play with. It is for that reason that one can understand why Government Ministersin the last two weeks have been summoning up sufficient courage to say that the limit of the people's capacity for taxation has been reached. It has been reached of course; we all know that but did it ever happen before in this country that Government Ministers said it on the eve of a Budget? You know there was a time when it was possible to run the affairs of this country for the stupendous sum of £24,000,000 a year. That is a long time ago. When the country was being run on £24,000,000, in 1927, the present Minister said that was a colossal sum and that if his Party got into power they would run it for half the amount. Now 25 or 26 years later, when the yearly cost of running the State amounts to about £100,000,000, we find the Minister saying that the limit of taxation has been reached. I say these speeches have been made because the Government realise that the Opposition charge made in April last year, has now been proven to have been correct and that the Government is collecting £3,000,000 or £4,000,000 more than they require for expenditure. For that reason I have no doubt that the people can expect in the next Budget substantial tax relief.
There is no reason why the unsound tax imposed on spirits and beer should not be removed. It has not been a success. It has been one of the taxes that have cut across the willingness of the people to bear. The fund is there to give tax relief and I have no doubt such relief will be given, but no matter what relief may be given and must be given by the Minister in the coming Budget the fact will remain that harm has been done by the Government, that the confidence of the people has been severely shaken and that the need remains for a change in Government and a change of policy. We on this side of the House will continue to work towards that end knowing that we have a policy which can solve some of the problems which face the country.
I only hope that after almost two years of Fianna Fáil maladministration, the Deputies, who by their previous unthinking act brought this Government into being, will now as fair minded Deputies, assessing the situation as they are entitled to do,looking at what this Government's policy has done to the country, realising that outside this Dáil there is no support for the policies or personalities that have brought this about and realising the need of the hour—a restoration of national confidence—will give to the people an opportunity freely to elect a new Government to follow a policy better designed in the national interest. I only hope that those Deputies will avail of this opportunity to do that. I will not say that, if they do, they will wipe out the political guilt that has befallen them but certainly they will have made some amends. If an opportunity is given to dissolve this unrepresentative Dáil then the people undoubtedly will do the rest.
Comment on this
I am somewhat confused because I understood that the business before the House is the discussion of the Vote on Account. I felt that, in discussing this Vote on Account, we would be as far removed as possible from the atmosphere of the hustings at a general election. Deputy O'Higgins attempted to offer the public what he now regards as sufficient evidence of a new and, he alleges, a good Fine Gael policy on which they will ask the people for their votes to re-elect them as a Government. In that connection, Deputy O'Higgins could not restrain himself from pouring venom on certain Independent Deputies in this House. That comes rather strange from a Deputy of a Party which has a history of swallowing up all its friends and digesting them completely out of existence.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins has a grievance against those Deputies who refused to be swallowed by his Party. He has a grievance against those Deputies who planted their feet on the ground and refused to be swallowed by Fine Gael. He has a grievance against those Deputies who stood for the principles on which they were elected to this House. Deputy O'Higgins has tried to suggest thatbecause those Deputies exercised their rights to use their own discretion in this House——
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins concentrated on three main items during his speech. He talked of unemployment, of emigration and of capital—or the lack of it—in the sense of its being made available for development. He said that Fine Gael had no unemployment, that they had no emigration and that there was a rapid repatriation of capital for capital development works. The Deputy spoke the whole time without giving us any relevant facts or figures. I want now to put the real facts on record. According to Fine Gael—and according to Deputy O'Higgins, in particular—since we took office in 1951 we have increased unemployment in this country.
Comment on this
I want to put the facts on record. Then, perhaps, those Deputies who cannot but be fair will accept the facts and will refuse to listen to the type of tripe for which the speeches of Deputy O'Higgins are so notorious.
The average weekly number of persons in insurable employment in the year ending 31st December, 1950, was 489,800.
On the 31st December, 1951, the average number had risen to 498,900.
The last figure which is available— the 31st December, 1952—was in excess of 500,000.
Those are the facts and they can easily be confirmed if honest Deputieson the Opposition Benches will put down a question asking for the returns in respect of the sale of stamps—on which these records are produced. But, of course, there are some Deputies who do not want that information. It is much better to be able to say that unemployment has increased and to do without proving it. I have given the House the facts.
There are more people in employment to-day than there were two or three years ago.
Comment on this
Deputy Dockrell should know me well enough to realise that I can explain that also. I want to put an end to the untrue assertion that there are more unemployed to-day than there have been previously. There are more people in employment.
Now we come to the unemployed. It is suggested that, because a greater proportion of people are signing on now, less people are employed. I want to prove that more people are employed. Deputies on both sides of the House know very well that recently the category of persons signing on at the labour exchanges was extended to include persons who previously were not able to sign on or who, until the increase in benefit, did not find it worth their while to do so. The figures will show that of the 90,000 persons—or 87,000 odd—signing on at the labour exchanges, at least 9,000 are of the type I have just described. They are additional persons who were in being during the lifetime of the Coalition Government but who had no reason for signing on because they would not get the benefits that they receive now.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Briscoe not agree that 4,000 who were then signing on, have now joined the Army?
Comment on this
That is an absurd contention. The people who joined the Army are young men who were never on the unemployed register.
Comment on this
I want to come to the figures of what are called "unemployed." I notice that Deputy O'Donnell is leaving the House now— just as I am doing my best to give him the figures. I believe he would be afraid to hear them. It would spoil his style if he knew the facts. There are certain people who cannot deliberately distort facts. Therefore, it is best not to know them.
The average numbers of people on the live register, taking the country as a whole, were: in 1948, 61,900; in 1949, 61,000; in 1950, 53,800; in 1951, 51,600 and in 1952, 60,800. Since then there have been added the additional types that I have referred to. I want to say categorically that to my own knowledge, and, I am sure, Deputy Dockrell to his knowledge, knows it to be a fact that very many of our people who were previously employed in England have now come home and are to-day signing at our labour exchanges.
Comment on this
Well, you must be a very happy person to be left in such peace as not to be approached by those who have come home.
Comment on this
The Deputy admits that some have come home. I am glad that my reminder does bring that fact to his mind. We know that that is the position—that numbers of those who have come home are signing at our labour exchanges, and are getting their unemployment benefit here as a result of the reciprocal arrangement which permits them to draw unemployment benefit when they come down here from across the Border. To what extent, or number, that fact can be assessed I cannot say exactly, but I hope that the Department of Social Welfare will soon establish those figures and produce them for us sothat we will know what we are talking about.
We had Deputy Blowick here recently almost getting an attack as a result of the excitement which he had engendered in himself when talking about a reduction in employment in forestry, and of the numbers of people who were being sacked.
Comment on this
You do remember it, then. I would be the last person in this House deliberately to misquote or distort what any Deputy had said, but I distinctly remember Deputy Blowick almost crying tears for the persons who had lost their employment in afforestation since Fianna Fáil came back to office. The Deputy also pleaded with us not to let afforestation, as a scheme, sink by the method of planting a less acreage. The Deputy agrees that is so. Has the Deputy taken the trouble to ascertain what are the actual facts? These are the facts, and I am putting them on record again. I challenge any Deputy over there to say or prove that they are wrong. In 1950, the numbers employed on a forestry programme were 2,346.
Comment on this
I am quoting figures that have been ascertained from the Department concerned, and if the Deputy thinks that I am going to be wrong in a single digit I invite him to put down a question and I will apologise. I am telling him that these are the facts. In 1950, there were employed in afforestation 2,346 people. The number in 1951 was 2,786, and in 1952, 3,453. Up to the present, to 1953, the number employed is 3,612.
Comment on this
That is the attitude of mind of the people opposite: tell thepeople first that the numbers employed have been reduced, and, if they believe that, it will then save you saying: "Oh! if they have been increased we would employ more." Is not that the mentality?
Comment on this
The Deputy should not forget that he was one of what is now called the inter-Party Government, as distinct from the Coalition group, who stood for a programme of reafforestation to such an extent that we would be able to make petrol for the propulsion of our motor-cars from alcohol extracted from our surplus wood.
Comment on this
Deputy Blowick says "hear, hear", although he knows now, as a result of his three and a half years' experience as a Minister, that that is all "cod", and that it cannot be done.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have to allow Deputy Briscoe to make his speech without interruption.
Comment on this
I submit, Sir, that it is not easy to contain oneself when one hears a responsible Deputy talking through his hat.
Comment on this
I take it that the Deputy's interjection is meant metaphorically, because, actually, I have not got a hat on my head.
Comment on this
So best for the hat that you have not, because, otherwise, the roof would be blown off it.
Comment on this
I want to tell the Deputy a little more about forestry since there has been so much talk about it here, talk which has obviouslybeen inspired either by somebody who means evil, not to us but to the Fine Gael Party, or which he has conjured up in his mind. He does not seem to understand what he is talking about, and maybe cannot read or write. I have given the figures with regard to those employed on afforestation work. Deputy Blowick then talked about forestry itself. Does he know that in 1950 we had 7,400 acres of new plantations laid down?
Comment on this
Would that not arise more properly on the Estimate for forestry? It is general financial policy that is discussed on this Vote.
Comment on this
I wonder is Deputy Briscoe trying to capture the idea that I had 8,500 acres planted in 1950?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins and those on the opposite side who have spoken on this Vote on Account, related it, as far as they could and as effectively as they could, to three particular items: employment, emigration and capital expenditure. I feel, Sir, that part of the Government's capital expenditure, even if it is only a small amount, is in afforestation.
Comment on this
I have allowed employment to be discussed in general terms, but Deputies should not come down to the particular acreage under forestry or matters of that kind which would be quite relevant on the Forestry Estimate.
Comment on this
If we postpone the discussion for another day perhaps Deputy Blowick, in the meantime, will look up the records and fortify himself with the exact figures. Deputy O'Higgins said that the reduction in employment since the change of Government had brought about the greatest crisis the State had ever had. I have proved by the figures I have given, and they are correct, that whatever crisis may exist, it certainlyis not because there are less people in employment than there were.
Deputy O'Higgins talked on the same lines as were adopted by his Leader. Deputy Costello is convinced that when the next Budget is produced there will be reliefs in taxation. Deputies on the opposite side of the House are nodding their heads as if they are in full agreement with that view. I do not know where Deputy O'Higgins got the figures or facts but he has summed up the situation in this way, that the Minister budgeted deliberately last year, with all the hardship that policy inflicted on the community, for a surplus of £10,000,000. According to Deputy O'Higgins, who has now gone into the matter very clearly and carefully, that surplus will not be much more than £4,000,000. On the one hand he says: "When we become the Government again, we will reduce taxation." He puts that as an attractive promise. In the next breath he says: "Fianna Fáil will reduce taxation," in the accent of a warning and a threat. What way does he want it? I can tell the House quite honestly that I have no idea as to what the next Budget will be like. I do not know where Deputy O'Higgins got his figures. He may be psychic and be able to read the crystal and tell us what he sees.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins referred to this Party as the Fianna Fáil Independent Coalition Party. He referred to it in that way as being a term of contempt. That, from a member of the House whose Party only became the Government because it entered into coalition with others. He seeks to escape from the contempt attaching to a Coalition Government by saying: "We, the inter-Party Government, are not a Coalition Government." Where will all this end? Does not Fine Gael recognise that they have never been returned in sufficient numbers of themselves to become a Government and, consequently, can never say that they commanded the support of the majority of the people, and that the only reason they were in office since they left officein 1932 was the accident of mathematics, which enabled them to form a Coalition Government? Even since Fianna Fáil was returned and assumed office, Fine Gael is going through a process of taking in, swallowing and digesting Independents.
Comment on this
I bow to the Chair, but it is as relevant as the reference by Deputy O'Higgins to the Independents whom he abused because they were supporting Fianna Fáil, and he was able to argue that this was a coalition because of that. However, a nod from the Chair and I will obey. When we talk of employment and unemployment in connection with those who are normally engaged on work, we must recognise that there are certain occupations in which there are seasonal changes. We have a very big meat-producing industry to-day, canning and the export of carcass meat. I am sure the Clann na Talmhan Deputies, representing farmers, must know that there are certain times in the year when the supply of cattle is such that the industry seasonally closes down. There is also a policy adopted by the Department of Agriculture to stop and limit production in these factories at certain periods of the year. There are, therefore, seasons when certain of these people would be out of work. We cannot alter that. There is seasonal occupation in the beet industry. In agriculture, as a whole, there are certain periods when all the available labour cannot be employed. Deputy O'Higgins talked at length about the Fianna Fáil policy. He did not say anything about the Clann na Talmhan policy or Clann na Poblachta policy. He said a lot about the Fine Gael policy. He warned Clann na Talmhan and everyone else that Fine Gael would be the next Government.
Comment on this
He did not tell us what the policy was. Deputy Costello told us that the full comprehensive and complete programme as to how to deal with the industry and economy of ourcountry was contained in a speech delivered at the Fine Gael Árd-Fheis. I am sorry I was not an invited guest and did not hear it.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins did not give us a single item of importance that we could grasp and compare what we are doing with what he would propose to do. We cannot say: "Is your suggestion better than ours or is our suggestion better than yours?" He says: "What you are doing is no good. We have the solution. We can end unemployment and emigration the moment we take over." If I were a member of the Opposition and if I knew the solution to these problems I would feel it my bounden duty to disclose it to the House and put it on record. If the Government would not accept the suggestion they could take the consequences and when a change came the remedy could be applied. I do not think it is fair to the country or the House to say: "We have a solution and when we become the Government we will apply it", and not tell us what it is. I do not think it is fair to the constituents who elected him for a Deputy to leave them, the House and the country in a dilemma, such as Deputy O'Higgins has left us in to-night.
Deputy O'Higgins referred to the Book of Estimates that appeared in 1927. I think he said the figure was about £24,000,000. Deputy O'Higgins did not tell the House that in 1927 the wages paid to the workers on the Shannon scheme were 24/- per week. That is just as relevant in a comparison with these days as the figure of the Estimates.
Comment on this
We have forgotten these things. The Deputies who made these statements seem to forget that there are people who remember the conditions that existed in the days they talk about. Of course Deputy O'Higginsgot out of it by saying, "Older members than I am will remember that". The young man does not remember; that is the escape hatch. But I am reminding him that, if it is correct to say that the Estimates in those days totalled £30,000,000, the wages paid on a State scheme were 24/-a week and, as Deputy Walsh says, there was a different price for oats and other agricultural commodities. There was also a different price for milk.
Comment on this
Fine Gael were in office for three and a half years. I deliberately say Fine Gael, because it was Fine Gael's policy that was mainly put into effect. Certainly it was not the policy of the Labour Party. It certainly was not the Clann na Talmhan policy. It was a compromise policy, but, in the main, it was a Fine Gael policy. That is what I think it was and I am sure many members of the Opposition will not disagree with me. They took over as a Government after 16 years of Fianna Fáil Government. In that 16 years an industrial development took place and an increase in the standard of living, notwithstanding the interruption of the war period and all the other difficulties which had to be contended with before the outbreak of the world war. The safety of the State and its people was maintained.
After this 1932 to 1948 period was over, the new inter-Party Fine Gael Government took over. Many promises had been made on which people were elected, not one of which was implemented. As Deputy O'Higgins correctly stated—this is the first thing I can give him credit for saying correctly; he probably did not realisethe significance of it—a policy was hurriedly devised and afterwards a long-term policy was devised after the take over.