Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 281–436 of 436. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I have some of the points here. Many important developments took place in the previous 16 years. There were great hopes that as we were returning to normal the development policy laid down would be continued. We know what happened, I will not refer to it now, about killing certain developments between 1948 and 1951. We all know what they were. Since 1951, what has taken place in connection with industry? This is a report of progress in the last quarter of 1952: 18 factories or extensions of factories went into production; these included radios for export, biscuits, textiles, children's wear, food processing and canning. That represented definite and actual progress.
We heard some talk to-day about an industry in Mayo. We were asked when it was to start, what was the responsibility of the Government in getting it started in a hurry. The fact that did emerge was that this industry was only enabled to start because of a grant promised to private enterprise people after they had a certain amount of work done. An industry is being started and that is the main and important thing.
When we are talking of capital development as distinct from ordinary payments by the State which are not called capital expenditure, I do not know whether the Opposition is aware, although the country may be, that 17 harbours are being improved at a cost of £6,000,000. It may hurt the Opposition to know that the latest approved scheme for harbour work is at Wicklow.
Comment on this
I do not know whether it is permissible to talk of a particular scheme in relation to capital development.I wanted to deal in detail with the land rehabilitation or reclamation scheme and to give some figures, if I may.
Comment on this
There has been a lot of unfair talk that this Government are trying to kill what was called the land reclamation scheme.
Comment on this
I will give you a present of that. The land reclamation scheme was introduced in this House with a banging of drums such as was never heard even in the North on the 12th of July. A sum of £40,000,000 was to be spent on the land in ten years. I do not know how that amount of money could be spent on that particular work in ten years. An effort was made to start that. Accusations are being levelled against the Government now that they are in fact reducing the employment content of that scheme and the amount of money made available for it.
That has been said and I take it it is believed by some of the Deputies on the Opposition Benches. It has been stated that both the labour content of that scheme and the amount of capital invested in it are being reduced. That has been repeated here time and time again. What are the facts? In 1950-1951 the amount of money spent on land improvement was £568,666. In 1951-52, after the return of Fianna Fáil, the figure was increased to £1,619,332 and in 1952-53 the figure was again increased to £2,463,906. Does anybody suggest in the face of those vast increases that less is being spent on this work and that less employment is being given? It is about time that the spokesmen for the Opposition who make these assertions here should recognise that there are members of their own Parties who live in parts of the country where the people can see with their own eyes what is happening and who in many cases are themselves the beneficiaries of improved conditions and improvedcircumstances as a result of increased capital expenditure by the State.
Comment on this
And who see the gangs being dismissed at the present time from land rehabilitation work.
Comment on this
Deputy Blowick is a very innocent man. If the Dublin Corporation is carrying out a housing scheme on a particular site in a particular area they employ on that work a certain number of men. When the houses are built and handed over to the tenants that employment ceases but houses are being built in other parts where the employment content is as great, though possibly different people may be employed.
Comment on this
Deputy Blowick should realise that when a scheme is finished the employment on that particular scheme must cease.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been relevant up to now. I hope he will not go off the track at this stage.
Comment on this
I want to knock on the head the misleading information given to the House whether through ignorance or by way of progaganda. The suggestion was made that the Government deliberately slowed down the housing programme and that that affected the employment figures. What are the figures? The total number of houses completed in 1950 was 12,048; in 1951 it was 12,135 and in 1952 it was 13,018. How can it be suggested on those figures that there is in fact a slowing down of the housing programme with consequent disemployment of the people engaged in it?
I have been making a nuisance of myself to the present Minister for Finance pressing him over the last fouror five weeks to give me information by way of parliamentary question as to why the scheme to knock down and rebuild the greater portion of Dublin Castle has not been proceeded with. As a Deputy representing a Dublin constituency the Labour content in that scheme is of great importance to me. To-day I was told that if the partial scheme which had been approved by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1946 had been put into operation and not cancelled, as it was, by the inter-Party Government 100 skilled men would have been employed on the job and a certain number of unskilled men likewise. Deputy Alfred Byrne was a supporter of the inter-Party Government. He is not here this evening. He spends his time talking about the cost of living and unemployment, particularly the unemployment of the skilled worker who, he says has to leave our shores to find employment abroad. Why is he not here to-night to denounce the policy of the inter-Party Government of scrapping that scheme, apart from the fact that accommodation is needed to house our civil servants?
Comment on this
I am trying to relate the situation which confronts us at the moment. The main opposition to the Vote on Account before us is that the Fianna Fáil Government has brought about dislocation in everything in the nature of development that gave employment and that chaos, crisis and disemployment have followed. That is the main burden of the attack upon the Government. I am trying to show that the people who adopt that line of attack are those least qualified to do so, since they themselves are responsible for the unemployment that exists to-day. I am not saying they are running away from their responsibility. I am merely trying to put my finger on an actual instance to show how they, in their administration, can be held responsible now for the unemployment that exists in the City of Dublin and probably elsewhere too.
We have in this Vote on Accountparticulars of payments for extended health services. Those health services are very important, because they are germane to the welfare of our people. Deputies want a standard of living that will ensure good health for our people. Yet, they voted against the Health Bill, a Bill designed to achieve that object. It is the intention of our Government to keep our people physically fit, and for that reasons millions are being spent on various social and health services.
Deputy O'Higgins quoted a speech made by the present Minister for Finance as far back as 1927. Fianna Fáil made its first entrance into this House in August, 1927, and in the following November the present Minister for Finance, then Deputy McEntee, made a speech which was quoted to-night by Deputy O'Higgins. I wonder was it his purpose in his research back over the years from 1952 to 1927 to find something he could put his finger on in order to criticise the present Minister for Finance. If his performance could be directly laid to that very arduous labour of research, then we might be inclined to forgive him a lot of what he said to-night. Fianna Fáil were a Government for 16 years, beginning in 1932. They put into effect in a practical way all kinds of improvements and additions in order to raise the standard of living of our people, the employment possibilities and so forth. Deputy O'Higgins referred to something said in November, 1927, to adduce proof that Fine Gael should be returned at the next election.
Deputy O'Higgins invited us to resign. One of my colleagues said to him at the time: "Would not dissolution be more convenient than resignation?"
Comment on this
As the Taoiseach told the House when he was asked about that, Fianna Fáil will choose the moment when they will do that.
Comment on this
I do not intend to deal with all the items connected with agricultural production and assistance to agricultural production, but I would like to refer to one paragraph of my own little brief. Everything I say here I stand over. I challenge anybody to tell me what is in here is not correct, because this has been done not solely by me but is the result of research by people who are in a position to know the facts.
Comment on this
City politicians know nothing about agriculture. It is finance you are interested in.
Comment on this
I know this much: the land reclamation scheme was overhauled. Higher grants will be offered to farmers who do their own work. A supplementary grant, bringing the total spent in the year to a record figure, was passed at the end of the quarter. A total of 64,000 grants was approved for 300,000 acres during that period. That is progress.
I am not going to deal with land division. I did deal with forestry.
Comment on this
I was born in the centre of such activity as forestry. You are a city politician and you are only interested in finance.
Comment on this
I do not think I would be able to do the comedian. Under every head in the various Departments of State one can see if one examines the position, development everywhere. There is rapid telephone development.
Comment on this
I promise to remain silent while Deputy Crowe is speaking and I will listen with great interest. Deputy MacEoin says, by interjection, if you create more development you are spending more money. That leads me to the interjection by Deputy Browne when Deputy O'Higgins was speaking: Would he increase subsidies and reduce taxation? Perhaps Deputy MacEoin or Deputy Crowe will answer that?
Comment on this
He did not refer to Dr. Browne's intervention in the course of the speech of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs.
Comment on this
I was here for the intervention by Dr. Browne in relation to Deputy O'Higgins. He was going to increase subsidies and reduce taxation side by side and was asked by way of interjection if that was the policy intended? Deputy MacEoin says if you engage in greater developments you must spend more money.
Comment on this
In every Department of State there is live development taking place in industry, agriculture, fisheries, public works, housing, Gael-tacht development services, employment schemes, land division, forestry, health and tele-communications. In every one of those Departments there is increased expenditure, increased developmentand increased employment. What does the Opposition want us to do—stop development, stop this expenditure?
Comment on this
It is very easy for a Party that has never commanded even half a sufficient number in strength to form its own Government to shout to a Party that has been able by its own strength to command a Government, to get out. I do not know if the Fine Gael people would be so pleased if an election was put at their disposal.
Comment on this
The Deputies who have spoken have expressed the greatest horror at the result of their calculations that taxation will be reduced, as Deputy O'Higgins says, when the Budget is introduced. Why should Deputy O'Higgins or any other Deputy be afraid of or criticise a reduction in taxation? Should he not welcome it on behalf of the taxpayers and the citizens generally? Is it because the Deputy feels there might be an election and if taxation were reduced it would be to our credit? I do not know what the explanation is, but that is what the Deputy has announced for us.
Comment on this
I said that the Deputy claimed there would be nearly £5,000,000 as a surplus which would be used by the Minister for Finance to reduce taxation. I do not know where the Deputy got that information. I doubt if the Minister himself knows what the gap will be.
Comment on this
The Deputy made a few miscalculations in days gone by, and the Deputy had to go back to 1927 to quote the Minister.
Comment on this
I should think I was very kind in skipping the intervening period.
Comment on this
Reference has been made to the steps taken to reduce the gap in the balance of trade and to cut down the adverse trade balance. I do not know that anybody making these references has clearly stated whether it is a good thing, a bad thing or a necessary thing to attempt to reduce the adverse trade balance. For my part, I would think it necessary where there is a large gap in the balance of payments, that steps should be taken to reduce that. For the calendar year, 1952, it is estimated that the adverse trade balance has been reduced by a sum in excess of £50,000,000. I challenge the Opposition to say whether that is good or bad.
Comment on this
The Deputy would like to see our total credit balance wiped out in a matter of four or five years, so that we would not have temporary unemployment but complete unemployment. The Deputy was not in the House when I read out the figures showing that there were more people in employment now than there were in the time of the Coalition Government.
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan has the type of brain that nobody can educate in the ordinary things in life.
Comment on this
You are repeating yourself. You are giving us a rehearsal, doing the comedian on it.
Comment on this
I do not think Deputy Crowe believes that. He is probably in a state of mind when he feels conciliatory with everybody. He is quite happy.
Comment on this
If Deputy Crowe would cease making references to me, I would cease replying to him. Deputy O'Higgins says quite seriously that it is a bad thing to reduce the adverse trade balance.
Comment on this
I hope that when the time comes when Deputy O'Higgins can describe himself as one of the elders, to whom he referred to-night, he will look up his speech to-day and just ask himself if he was serious in saying that. Obviously if we do not reduce the adverse trade balance, our credit balance will be ultimately finally exhausted and if it is exhausted, as the result of an adverse trade balance, mainly on account of consumer goods, where will we have the money to repatriate for the capital expenditure schemes that Deputy O'Higgins said he had up his sleeve but of which he did not disclose even one? We are going to be here for some time longer I hope and, as the result of Fianna Fáil administration our reserves will be so protected that there will be some credit balance available on which we can draw for Deputy O'Higgins's capital expenditure schemes. If they are gone, whether that happens sooner or later, it will be bad for the country. It is true that if you suddenly bring about measures to reduce the adverse trade balance, and you keep out of the country some £50,000,000 worth of goods, you are retarding the velocity of the movement of money but that retarding of velocity may be felt only for a temporary period. Either these goods were needed or they were not needed. If they were needed, ways will be found to produce some of them,at first, and later, a good deal of them at home. That will save our credit balance abroad. We will have that credit balance available to provide for capital investment as the money is required.
Now we come to the Estimates themselves and the reference to the Budget. The Minister for Finance is accused of a heinous crime because he is attempting to have his books balanced in a manner in which the public can understand them. Deputy O'Higgins says, and so does Deputy Costello, that the balancing of the books is of no importance. The people who provide the money, so far as taxation and capital requirements, are concerned, will only do that if they have confidence that the balance sheet of the State is an honest balance sheet.
Comment on this
Do you think the people believe that in regard to this Vote on Account?
Comment on this
If Deputy O'Higgins thinks he is doing the country a good service in attempting to raise a doubt in the minds of the people that the books of the State are cooked or dishonest——
Comment on this
——then I make him a present of his method of attempting to gain office. Many countries have suffered disaster following dishonest methods of acquiring power.
Comment on this
I am not going to give way to Deputy Flanagan in any circumstances or at any time. I am quite prepared to argue with anybody else who wishes to argue with me. I am trying to put the point so that it can be clearly read on the records, firstly, that it is a good thing to get back asfar as we can, to a policy of self-sufficiency and secondly, that we should try so to plan our trade that we can have a surplus, if possible, in the balance of trade. Certainly, if we were in a situation in which we could have a surplus, would it not be better to have it?
Comment on this
All I can say to Deputy O'Higgins is—he may be wrong or I may be wrong—that I have been always taught to believe that if this country sells more than it buys, it would be much better than if it buys more than it sells. Otherwise the time will come when it will not be able to buy anything because the people will not have any more money. That is the A B C of that particular type of transaction, as I know it.
Comment on this
You could achieve that by starving the people and exporting all the food. Do you think that would be a good thing?
Comment on this
And the people of his constituency also passed their judgment on him.
Comment on this
On a point of order. That interruption by the Minister for Finance is, I submit, scandalous and is a breach of the privileges of the House.
Comment on this
There have been so many interruptions that it is very difficult for the Chair to hear what anybody says. Deputy Briscoe, without interruption.
Comment on this
The Deputy gave me permission to ask him a question which the Minister for Finance prevented me from doing.
Comment on this
I understood that Deputy O'Higgins suggested to me that this method of preserving a good standard meant a continuance of the policy of spending in excess of our exports and that the only way we could change that would be by bringing about starvation. It is a long time since we had the Adrigole incident in this country. There is no sense in saying that, in the interests of a credit balance, the State will permit any of its citizens to starve. After all, it was the Fianna Fáil Party that introduced the social welfare legislation which gives benefits to people— benefits which did not exist pre-1932 and benefits which were not improved upon between 1948 and 1951, because they were thought to be sufficient.
We believe that if we can preserve our falling assets and can hold them until they can be utilised in capital investment at home, we will ultimately complete the programme that was envisaged. That, I take it, is something everybody wants to see accomplished, i.e., self-sufficiency in the country.
Now we come again to the Estimates. I do not understand the reference that the Estimates or the Budget need not necessarily be balanced as one would expect any balance sheet to balance. I think it is of the utmost importance that when a Government or a Government Department issue a figure—whether it be in relation to matters of finance or other matters—the figure, purporting to be a fact, should be honest so that people can say: "This figure is a fact." If we should have a situation in which a figure did not mean anything—a situation in which it would not matter whether you said this or that in regard to a sum of money or anything else—then nobody would believe anything, nothing would be accomplished and the confidence of the people in whatever Government might be in power would be completely destroyed.
Up to the present, this country has had a good reputation as regards its public affairs—not only its national affairs but also its local affairs. Local authorities who have the right or the power to borrow money for capital expenditure enjoy to-day a fairly good position both with regard to the State itself, that underwrites it, and those who subscribe and take up allotments.
I do not understand what is behind this approach to a Vote on Account. On the one hand, the suggestion is that taxation has reached its limit and is too high—but, on the other hand, if it is reduced, it is also wrong. You cannot have it both ways. I agree with the Taoiseach in his statement that he believes that taxation has reached its very limit. That is my belief also. I hope it will not be necessary to impose extra taxation on our people. I am not holding out any hope when I express the wish that there will be some alleviation in some direction——
Comment on this
That is a safe bet. There will be. There is no doubt about it.
Comment on this
I hope the Deputy is right. Certainly, I will not walk into the Division Lobby and vote against a Budget that will reduce taxation— but maybe Deputy O'Higgins will. We have also to remember that every single thing that has been said about the cost of living has had no relation to the fact that, side by side with the increase in the cost of living, there have been increases—whether or not they are sufficient is another question —to our working people. Increases incosts follow increases in wages. That is bound to happen. I can speak of it only in reference to things of which I have experience. Take the Dublin Corporation, for example. Every time we give our workers an increase of 12/6 a week it means an extra 1/- on the rates. Every local authority that gives an increase of wages to its workers has to recoup that increase from the ratepayers. If the State wants to give increases to State employees it can do so only out of taxation.
In introducing the Vote on Account, the Minister explained a number of the larger figures that go to make it up. He pointed out increases in certain expenditure envisaged in the coming year as compared with previous years. I have listened to portion of one speech and to the whole of another speech this afternoon. I listened to Deputy J.A. Costello and to Deputy O'Higgins. I have heard nothing in those speeches that would make me question in my own mind anything contained in this Vote on Account.
I again repeat that to attack the Vote on Account on the grounds that there is less employment in the country is not correct. I have shown that the fact that a greater number of people are signing on at the labour exchanges is not because less people are employed: it is because a greater number of people are now available. I dispute the contention by Deputy O'Higgins that emigration has reached a higher figure than ever before.
Comment on this
Deputy Dockrell knows that he is not in a position to say that that is true because nobody can have the figures for a time, yet. They are not available. I can give the Deputy the figures on emigration up to a certain period. It is not correct to say that these figures are greater to-day than they were before. When Deputy Dockrell or anybody else says that they are greater than ever before and that he knows it to be true then all I can say is that it is wishful thinking on his part. He is guessing that it is true but he has no concrete evidence to prove that it is true. I have figures here of total emigration for the years 1947,1948, 1949 and 1950. In 1947, 10,000 people officially emigrated; in 1948, 28,000; in 1949, 34,000 and in 1950, 41,000.
Comment on this
Those were in the years when the inter-Party Government were inviting emigrants to come back and to take up posts at home.
These are their own figures. I am prepared to accept the figures published by any State office as being correct. It is not correct to say that emigration has reached the highest figure ever. How can that be argued? I referred to this matter on another occasion and it was then suggested to me by, I think, Deputy MacBride that the population of the country, according to the last census, showed an increase and not a decrease. It was suggested that was due to natural growth, over and above emigration. I should like to have proof from any member of the Opposition that the figure for emigration is higher to-day than ever it was. I should also like to have any member of the Opposition refute by evidence that there are less people in employment to-day than there were in the years 1948 to 1951. We can explain the figures and the cause for the increase in the numbers now signing on.
Comment on this
I gave them before. The Deputy was not here and I do not want to repeat everything that I said earlier. I also said that Deputy Byrne was not here and I am sorry that he was not. When the Government takes in hands large-scale building schemes, I hope that there will be approval from the Opposition for them, particularly in the City of Dublin. There will be a large labour content in those schemes and they will continue for a long period.
Comment on this
I think it would be agood thing if every Deputy concerned himself with his own constituency. I know that Deputy O'Donnell concerns himself with fishing operations in his constituency. He is quite right, and I do not blame him for that. Deputy O'Donnell should not blame me for trying to induce the Government to have large-scale schemes carried out in Dublin which will mean employment for large numbers.
Comment on this
Pulling down Dublin Castle? The Deputy knows as well as I do that there is necessity to do that. It is work that needs to be done. He knows the castle, I am sure, as well as I do. I am sure he used to be in and out there when the courts were sitting there.
Comment on this
The Deputy is taking me up in the wrong. I did not mean that at all. I was referring to Dublin Castle when the courts were sitting there, and when the Four Courts building was not in use. I did not mean any personal reflection at all—such as knowing it physically.
Comment on this
That is what I meant. The point is that rebuilding there would give employment. I do not believe that Deputy Byrne knew when he was supporting the Coalition Government that, in opposing the rebuilding of Dublin Castle, he was, in fact, keeping hundreds of skilled workmen in Dublin, the men he was talking about the other night, out of employment.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Byrne believe that, during the period of the Coalition Government, there were no unemployed in the City of Dublin?
Comment on this
I hope the Deputies opposite now recognise that employment could be given to a great number of skilled and unskilled workers on schemes such as I have referred to. I suggested that could have been done three years ago, and that Deputy Byrne did not know when he was supporting the Coalition Government that he was keeping hundreds of those skilled workmen out of employment.
Comment on this
What Deputy Byrne referred to the other night was the shortage of skilled labour then.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Dockrell mean that there was a shortage of skilled labour in 1948, 1949 and 1950?
Comment on this
I cannot make out Deputy Dockrell. Outside the House, he is quite a sane, honest to God man, but inside the House he will say anything. Surely, Deputy Dockrell is not saying that there were no skilled operatives available during the period of the Coalition Government.
Comment on this
And that there were none available then for knocking down and rebuilding parts of Dublin Castle?
Comment on this
I know as much about the availability of materials and labour for the building trade, as a result of my experience as a member of the Dublin Corporation, as Deputy Dockrell or any other Deputy. I say that we had no shortage of labour. We had a shortage of material at one time, from 1948 onwards, but as material became available to us we were able to employ workers. There is no use in the Deputy saying that there were no skilled workers available. Does DeputyDockrell want someone to put down a question to ascertain how many of that type of person were signing on in those years? We know that they were available. If Deputy Dockrell does not know, and if he doubts what I am saying, I invite him to read his own election literature issued in the 1948 election. He will see that one of the reasons he gave for seeking the support of the people was to find employment for the very people who, he now says, were not there.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy believe that? I am afraid that, as a result of that kind of mentality, it is becoming useless to talk here at all. I have often wondered why it is that Fine Gael always come back to this House with an insufficient number of members to form a Government. I have now come to the conclusion that the reason is that the public generally must regard them as I do now.
Comment on this
We feel that the situation in the country is such that it demands one action from the Government, and that is that it should remove itself from office and seek the opinion of the people who want a general election. They proved that at the by-election in North-West Dublin. The Government was represented in it by an exceptionally strong candidate, and yet the Government got the greatest licking that it has received since the Party was formed. As a result of the policy put into effect over the last year and a half by the present Minister for Finance, we have to-day a record number of unemployed. That is so, no matter how Deputy Briscoe may try to juggle with the figures. The situation is such that Deputy Dr. Browne this evening was forced to tell the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs that he could not excuse the figure of 90,000 unemployed.
The intervention of Deputy Browne was brought about by the manner in which the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was seeking to gloss over the situation that affects the country to-day. The unemployment which existsis a result of the financial policy this Government has been pursuing for the past year and a half. It was brought in earlier in Britain for a particular purpose. It had the desired effect there of making available men who were required for the army and auxiliary services. This country needed more men in productive work. We are now told that the action of the Government last year has had the result that the people are now taxed to the limit of their capacity and that, consequently, the Government cannot hope to tax them until they produce more, that if the people oblige by increasing production in agriculture and industry, the Government will be in a position to do what they have always done, that is, to dig their hands down as deep as they can in the pockets of the farmer, the worker and everybody who is seeking to eke out a livelihood in this country.
The result is the figure, which is undeniable, of 90,000 unemployed. It has been said that the figure is somewhat inflated by reason of certain changes in the Department of Social Welfare. Yet, when a question was put down to the Taoiseach on 4th March, the reply he gave was that the number of unemployed under the heading "building, contracting and works of construction" amounted to 14,656, in mid-January, 1951. That figure jumped to 16,136 in mid-January, 1952. What change was made in the Department of Social Welfare that caused that increase in that 12 months? There is the alarming figure of 21,581 under that heading in mid-January, 1953.
But the industrial analysis states that that figure is caused by slackness in the building trade and is not as a result of any attraction for people to register. These people are defined as people who were formerly engaged in building, contracting and works of construction. Is it not a fact that there is to-day a considerable slowing down in the building trade? Let us compare some of the figures. The monthly average number of houses completed in 1950 by local authorities was 670, and in 1952, 500—a reduction of 170. The monthly average number of such houses in progress in 1950 was 10,430; in 1952, 8,997. The monthly average number ofskilled men employed on local authority housing schemes in 1950 was 6,024; in 1952, 5,061. The total average number of men thus employed in 1950 was 13,392; in 1952, 10,677. I am sorry Deputy Briscoe has not waited to hear these figures and to compare them with his, and I would like to find out how he could arrive at the figures which he presented to the House.
Let us proceed to another section which could usefully employ labour in this country. We come to agriculture. In mid-January, 1951, the number of persons on the live register under the heading, agriculture, was 25,313. It increased to 26,408 in 1952 and, this year, to 30,467—an increase of 4,059. Is there an indication there that all the progress which we would all desire is taking place in agriculture? Is not there a reduction of 4,000 in the number employed in agriculture in the last 12 months?
Comment on this
The Deputy has asked for the quotation. The quotation is column 2021, Volume 136, No. 14, Dáil Debates, and the date is 4th March, 1953. The question was put by Deputy MacBride to the Taoiseach and the reply was given by the Parliamentary Secretary. Is the Deputy satisfied now? In the distributive trades, in 1951, the figure was 5,211; it was increased to 5,277 in 1952 and to 6,332 in 1953. I will not weary the House by going into all these figures. They are available to every Deputy.
It is clear to everybody, as Deputy Browne said this evening, that the present figure of 90,000 unemployed is alarming, and leaves no room for complacency. It has been said that some of the increase is due to seasonal unemployment but, when a comparison is made of the same month and the same week each year that would not appear to be the case. Does not every Deputy receive periodic reports giving the trend as well as the comparative figures for corresponding weeks and have not we all noticed that the trend has changed, that it is now of adefinite pattern, that as week succeeds week the number is mounting?
It should not be a matter of pleasure to the Government to know that the only effort they could make towards solving this problem was to make it more inviting for men to turn up at the labour exchange. It would be far better for the country if they were provided with the employment they want. The men do not want to be lined up there in queues, drawing dole. They would prefer work. We claim that the position that now exists is a result of the financial policy of the Government. The people who are unemployed, the people in the lower paid groups, the people with small salaries, the people with small farms, who have had to face the impact of a 22 point increase in the cost of living in the last year are, naturally, put to the pin of their collar to make ends meet.
Comment on this
Does the Parliamentary Secretary deny that there was an increase in the cost of living of that amount?
Comment on this
Perhaps before the Deputy concludes the reference will be found, and perhaps the Deputy will find it as distasteful as Deputy Cogan found the reference.
Comment on this
From February to May, 1951, there was an increase of seven points.
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe referred to seasonal unemployment caused at the moment in one section which is giving valuable employment, that is, the canning trade. He says that the cause of it is that cattle arenot available, that the raw material is somewhat restricted. Would it not be well to examine the reasons for that?
In my constituency in 1947 we had an abattoir where all classes of young cattle were slaughtered indiscriminately. It did not matter whether they were white heads or Shorthorns, dual-purpose animals, or animals intended for beef, they all met the same fate. They were exported during the period that Fianna Fáil was in office and, were it not for the fact that the business was stopped and stopped quickly, when Deputy Dillon became Minister for Agriculture, the number employed in the canning industry to-day would be much fewer.
The question of the balance of trade was dealt with by Deputy Briscoe. He referred to the fact that the improvement which had taken place was made possible because of a restriction of imports. The Government are anxious for an increase in exports. The live-stock industry can be thanked for a considerable increase in that respect. We must realise that, with the market there is for meat, our live-stock industry can be developed and made to serve a useful purpose. That is something which the Government now realise. They did not always hold that view. They gloried at one time in trying to achieve the death of that industry.
The Deputy who has just concluded is an ardent advocate of luxury building. He is quite incensed at the decision of the inter-Party Government to stop certain plans for the reconstruction of Dublin Castle and other buildings. If work is resumed on these schemes, how much will it contribute to improvement in the balance of payments position? How much will it assist in reducing the number of unemployed in the town of Mallow and throughout the country? I suggest that if the £250,000 by which the sum for the Local Authorities (Works) Act has been reduced was made available to local authorities far greater employment would be made available for the people in the country districts. The people who are flying from the land would be kept here. They would notbe enticed to leave the countryside if work were made available for them. Their work would result in increasing production for which the Minister for Finance appealed so strongly last night.
We do not think that it is an incentive to increase production to extract as much as possible from the pockets of the taxpayers. In recent months a raid has been made on the lower-salaried people in this country by the income-tax people. On every item which the people have had to buy in the past 12 months they have had to pay excessive taxes because of the policy of the Minister for Finance. That has brought about a situation in which the Taoiseach and his Ministers now indicate that the ceiling has been reached, that they cannot tax any further and that the position is that certain compensations have to be made to make up for the raids which have been made on the people's pockets, the raids by way of direct taxation, the direct raid on the housewives' purse by the withdrawal of the subsidies, and the indirect taxation which has resulted in consequence of the great increase in the cost of living. I maintain that the cost of living is still increasing, that the action of the Government in introducing this policy has had a snowball effect, that people are passing on to the consumer the expenses which they have to bear in their business.
The Minister for Defence came in here with a Supplementary Estimate which was inflated by increases in the cost of items in consequence of the Budget which the Minister introduced last year. There was a considerable increase in the price of oils and petrol and other items. I contend that the business people who have to meet this extra expenditure are passing it on to those who are buying the goods. Eventually, it comes down to this, that the people day after day are meeting these new commitments but they have not got any compensation to make up for the difference.
The most valuable section of the community is the agricultural section. What increase have the farmers got to meet the costs which are pouring downon them, particularly as a result of the withdrawal of the subsidies? The Agricultural Wages Board gave an increase of wages to the agricultural labourers, which was well deserved, as a result of the increased cost of living. Private firms have given increases to their workers because of the increase in the cost of living. The Government cannot give an increase to the Civil Service because they will have to find the money. But the business people are able to recoup themselves for any increases given to their employees by passing it on to the general public. Where is the farmer, who is producing foodstuffs for all of these people, to find the money?
Yesterday the Minister for Agriculture was extremely slow to give information to this House as to what the result of the recent development in the dairying industry has been. He was courageous enough to raise the price of butter. This Government are very courageous when it comes to putting on taxation and permitting prices to rise, but they are not so courageous when it comes to finding a solution as to where the money is to be found for these extra costs.
The people in the dairying area are awaiting a definite announcement as to what they are to get to meet the increased costs. They do not want to be lectured by people like the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. The agricultural community deeply resent being told by people such as that Minister that they must produce more; that they are falling down on the job.
When the farmers' and cottiers' wives produce more turkeys, what happens to the price? They are afraid to produce more unless they get some long-term guarantee. This country will not get the increased production which it requires if people compare the production costs in other countries with the costs in this country and if they say to that section of our people: "You are falling down on your job because you require higher prices for your produce than people in other countries." We say to them: "Hands off that section of the community. They should not be required to carry any other section on their backs. Give them theraw materials at the lowest possible price and then possibly they will come around to your way of thinking." While the farmers have to pay an exorbitant price for fertilisers in order to satisfy the Minister for Industry and Commerce they cannot do that. With a £3 levy on the hide, that industry in which Deputy Briscoe professes to be so interested cannot very well prosper. If people did not have to meet all these commitments possibly they would be able to answer the Minister's call much more readily.
The general feeling throughout the country is that the Government has lost complete control of administration. At the same time as they call upon the people to cut their cloth according to their measure they present to the country a Book of Estimates on the cover of which appears a record figure. They are proposing to spend more than ever before. Let no one think that the effects of taxation are not felt outside the walls of Government buildings and that they do not fall upon the local authorities throughout the country.
This week the local authorities are trying to strike a rate commensurate with the capacity and willingness, to use the Minister's own phrase, of the people to pay in order to meet the increased costs consequent upon the results of the last Budget. They will not be able to strike a lower rate. These councils have to meet wage increases. The cost of the voluntary hospitals and the domiciliary institutions has increased over the past year because of the increased cost of food. There is an increase in unemployment. There is an increase in emigration.
There is only one remedy the people can seek and that is a change of Government. The people in one constituency were given an opportunity of voicing their opinion of the Government and they voiced it in no uncertain fashion. The Government should realise as a result of that decision by the people that they have no mandate from the people for the policy they have initiated or the programme they have presented to this House. There is no comprehensive policy to-day.
Independent Deputies were in favour of the retention of the food subsidies. In fact one Independent Deputy advocated an increase in food subsidies. For that reason we think we are making a legitimate case when we say the Government is acting contrary to the intentions of the electorate. This Government never had a clear majority. It secured the support of Independents who sought election to the House on the inter-Party Government policy. If the people throughout the country got the same opportunity as the people did in North-West Dublin I think we would find a quick solution to our present troubles. It has ever been the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government to dig in deeper and deeper into the earnings of the worker, the income of the farmer and the turnover of the businessman. It has always been the policy of that Party to restrict the incentive to increased production and to the provision of more employment for our people, to restrict the incentive to maintain a higher standard of living. The results of that policy are apparent to-day.
It was strange to hear the Minister in such a subdued tone last night. He has certainly changed his approach from the time he made so many strong predictions, not to mention the Manor Street prophecy. Last night he referred to his sympathy with the capacity and willingness of the people to pay. I wonder how he will ascertain the willingness of the people to pay? It reminds me of a peculiar insertion in the form of attestation filled in by the L.D.F.: "Do you agree to accept such gratuities as shall arise from time to time?" When the Minister is sending out his demands for income-tax will he add another question to the many already on that form asking the taxpayer is he willing to contribute to the coffers of the Minister for Finance? If the taxpayer is not willing what remission will the Minister give him?
The people will not pay much heed to the Minister's professed sympathy with their willingness and capacity to pay the exorbitant sums he proposes to extract from them by every device he can possibly command. TheTaoiseach and other members of the Government have stated that we have now reached a position in which it is impossible to ask the people to pay more by way of taxation until such time, of course, as the people produce more and are well-off enough to bear further impositions. The Government should remember that there are sections of our community who have got no relief of any kind over the last 18 months. Not every section is organised to make its case quickly and effectively. Many sections who are not in a position to make themselves heard have been called upon to pay too much. One drastic feature of the present policy is that the simple luxuries have been heavily taxed. Food subsidies have been withdrawn. The result is that those who work hardest have to pay most. The increases in the price of bread, butter, tea and sugar have created a very grave problem for people whose incomes are not commensurate with the increases that have taken place.
I represent a constituency which is not an industrial one. Up to this we have known very little unemployment. To-day the principal town in that constituency has a record number of unemployed, caused by the recession in the building trade. The Government has been remiss in permitting that situation to develop. Our people in the rural areas have been left abandoned by the closing down of work under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, a measure which gave very valuable employment in those areas.
Money has been diverted recently into channels which will not solve the unemployment problem and which will bring no relief in a situation that urgently demands relief. It is intended to spend more money this year on the purchase of warlike stores. That money could be more usefully employed in ensuring that young men trained in the use of arms will be provided with a means of livelihood for themselves and their families. There is definite responsibility on whoever is in office to ensure that the largest possible sums of money are immediately directed into schemes which willgive the greatest amount of employment. It would be desirable that all questions which are in any doubt should be cleared up.
In relation to agriculture, the developments in that sphere in recent years have been such that the agricultural section of the community is recognised as contributing most to the nation's welfare. We are approaching the position that we cannot depend on outside sources to supply us with raw material. It is a strange thing that the ex-Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, was reviled for not having pursued a policy of self-reliance in this country. Yet his policy has been responsible for the expansion of the growing of feeding barley, which is to-day contributing in a very large measure towards the increased production of bacon and towards the fact that farmers are to-day able to carry more live stock on their holdings. It also means that we have eliminated the monopoly which existed in regard to grain-growing. Such a commodity as feeding barley which was required for the feeding of our live stock and could only be grown in particular areas, can now be grown practically anywhere in the country. Consequently, people are to-day in a position to produce possibly much cheaper than they would if depending on outside sources. This year we see some progress being made in the amount of that particular crop sown.
So far I have not heard any Government Deputy adverting to any spectacular increase in the acreage of tillage since the present Minister for Agriculture took over. From that we must draw the conclusion that they are not happy in that respect. Certainly if the farmers are given the opportunity to work, to produce as much as they wish to produce and are afforded the markets which they require for the sale of their live stock, we can look to the future with some confidence in that department.
At column 2057, Volume 136, of the Official Report of the 4th March, 1953, the Minister for Agriculture informed us that there is now no necessity to fix a price for crops because live stock is making such a price. What a tributeto the inter-Party Government! If the people are given the raw materials at the lowest possible prices and if they are afforded the prices they desire, they will answer the present call for increased production. However, they must be given an assurance in regard to prices. Too often we find it difficult to convince people who say to us: "If we do that prices will fall." We must give them some long-term guarantee that prices will not fall and force them out of production. Recent happenings in relation to poultry is causing considerable concern.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going into detail on the agricultural question. He should reserve those remarks for the main Estimate.
Comment on this
I merely intended to put a spotlight on that section of our people who are contributing most to our economic progress. It is in that direction we must look as holding the greatest possibilities for reducing our unemployment numbers and bringing to the people a higher standard of living. If the farmers cannot point to higher figures for production it is because for some years past they have been engaged upon much capital outlay. Many people are mechanising their holdings. An industry would claim credit for the natural disturbance that would be created if they were putting in new plant and a farmer is certainly deserving of as much consideration.
With the expansion of rural electrification and with the fine developments that are taking place among our young farmers we can depend on the agricultural community to pull their weight. They do not deserve in any way the strictures that have been laid upon them by some members of the present Government, strictures which might be regarded as justifiable by people who might not be fully aware of the conditions with which these people must contend.
I wish to put on record in this House the feelings of my constituents in regard to our economic position. Theyfeel that the difficulties now being encountered cannot be overcome without a change of Government. Travelling in buses, in trains and everywhere we go we hear everybody asking the one question: "When are you going to put them out?" The reply which was given so effectively in North-West Dublin will soon be repeated as effectively elsewhere in the country. As has happened in the past Fianna Fáil will hearken to the strong protests of an incensed electorate at having to bear a burden of taxation which they were assured at election times would never again be imposed. The present Minister for Finance had to guarantee that in his constituency and the Tánaiste was brought down to the City of Cork to give that guarantee so that Fianna Fáil would return their candidates at the last election.
We feel that the people who were fooled by these guarantees and who were so quickly disillusioned, are extremely anxious to seize the opportunity of recording their disapproval and of electing a Government which will carry out the programme which it presents to the electorate before the election and not afterwards.
Comment on this
I would like, first of all, to repeat a question I asked on the token Vote for the Taoiseach's Department a short time ago—that is, briefly, what is the Government's policy, and if some leader of the Government can tell us what the policy is, would that same speaker or would the Taoiseach give us an idea when the results of that policy will be shown? Everybody in this House will admit that the numbers of unemployed reflect very clearly the state of the country, and if we are to have regard for the figures that are published every week, all of us would admit that the situation, as reflected by these figures, is very alarming. As far as I can see, the front bench members of the Government have not expressed any alarm. They have not expressed the concern that they should have or should express when they have regard to a figure of 90,000 unemployed.
We hear of no proposals as to how that situation is to be alleviated. Noproposals of any kind in regard to schemes that would reduce the number substantially have been put forward by members of the Government. Instead we get parliamentary replies from Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries which do nothing more than explain that the abnormal increase in the numbers of unemployed is due to the operation of the Social Welfare Act. I think we can all agree that the Act has had a certain effect in increasing the number of unemployed but it is infinitesimal as compared with the abnormal increase over the general average of the last three, four or five years. I wonder, and the people I represent especially wonder, when the alleged beneficial results of Fianna Fáil administration in the last 18 months or two years will be shown. Deputy Burke, in the course of his remarks—I took a note of them—said that the policy of Fianna Fáil was designed to help our children's children. It seems to me that that was a correct summing up of the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party, but I do not think it is any consolation to the people at present unemployed, or to those who have been compelled to emigrate, to know that Fianna Fáil policy is designed to help our children's children. While the Government may be chiefly concerned with the welfare of these unborn children, I think most of us would be more directly concerned with those who are trying to live in the country at the present time.
As I have said, the state of the country economically is reflected fairly accurately by the figures of the unemployed. In regard to this question of unemployment there seems to be a certain attitude amongst some public men as to who should bear responsibility for the unemployed. It seems that some members of local authorities especially want to waive entirely their responsibilities for the maintenance of the people who happen to be unemployed in their respective areas. To my mind that is a callous and unchristian attitude. It reveals anything but a national outlook because I believe that the primary duty of public representatives is to provide for the unemployed people of the country.I believe that members of local authorities should not seek to evade their responsibility towards the people who happen to be unemployed in their respective areas, so long as there is work to be done, roads to be built, houses to be constructed, or while public work generally for which they have responsibility needs to be done.
Public representatives in the performance of their functions owe a certain duty to the unemployed. There is an outcry at the moment, possibly justified in many respects, against increases in rates but I am not one of those people who get hot and bothered about protests against an increase in the rates because my experience has been that it is those sections within the functional area of a local authority who are always clamouring to have roads repaired and other works carried out, who are the first to raise their voice in protest against any increase in rates. The question has often presented itself to me in this way. Say, for instance, there is a proposed increase of 2/- in the £ on the rates. That may seem a big increase to many people but even if we take a man whose valuation is £50, the increase would mean that he would merely have to pay £5 extra in his rates for the year. If he happens to be one of those to whom an abatement or a remission of rates would apply, the increase would be less than £5—either one-third or two-thirds less, I am not quite sure which.
A ratepayer of that type would be regarded in my county as being one of those having the highest valuations and although he would strongly object to paying £5 extra on rates in order to provide employment on many desirable schemes in the county he would probably have no hesitation in paying £20 for an overcoat, although he might be able to get one almost just as good for £15. Again he might be the type of person who is in the habit of going to the dogs or attending race meetings, and he would think nothing of gambling £10 or £20 on a race but ask him to pay a little more in rates to provide improved roads or to enable houses to be built for people who are not in a position to pay for such houses themselves, or to provide necessarysewerage or waterworks schemes and he will cry out as if he were asked to pay an extra £1,000. I am not at all advocating that rates should be increased but, generally speaking, if a county is well administered and if it is necessary to carry out schemes such as I have mentioned, I believe rating is the most equitable system for raising the necessary moneys to carry out these works. We must also appreciate that humble and poorly paid cottage tenants also make their contribution to the rates—indeed make as big a contribution in relation to the property they hold and the income they receive as any other section of the community.
So far as I can see or learn from the speeches made here by the Taoiseach and the members of his Government, there does not seem to be any immediate prospect for the people now registered as unemployed. I can say that the morale of the people in the last six months has been rudely shattered. The position to them seems to be hopeless. So far as my own home town of Wexford is concerned, I can say in all sincerity that the number of people laid off from week to week is increasing. In the spring-making industry, I think 24 men were laid off last night.
The nationally-known firm of Pierce's of Wexford is going through difficult times. Builders' providers have let off people. Needless to remark, as everybody knows well, road work under most county councils seems to be at a virtual standstill. That picture is not peculiar to my constituency. I think that every Deputy in this House could paint the very same picture so far as the area which he represents is concerned.
It would seem that, in the past few days, a campaign has been started— headed by the Minister for Finance— to endeavour to cut the Estimates. If that means cutting out wasteful expenditure, then I think it will have the support of every member of the House. I fear, however, that if this campaign which was initiated some days ago, which was continued last night by the Minister for Finance, and which is being maintained to-day, ispursued, and that if it meets with any success at all, there will be a going back, as far as this country is concerned, in the matter of the building up of essential things. How can any Minister for Finance, or how can a House of Parliament such as this, subscribe to the cutting of Estimates for the provision of schools, for the provision of clinics and hospitals, for the provision of houses and good harbours, for the provision of forests, water supplies and sewerage schemes? All these things need to be done— especially as, in the past few weeks, we have heard evidence from the Ministers in charge of the Departments concerned in regard to the services which I have mentioned.
The Minister for Education painted a bad picture in regard to the need for schools. In his Second Reading speech on the Health Bill, the Minister for Health told us very clearly that approximately half of the number of dispensaries in the country need to be rebuilt. All of us are aware, or should be aware, of the need which still exists for thousands of houses in Dublin City and in the country in general. Every one of us, and especially those of us who live near the seaboard, are aware of the necessity for good harbours. Every Deputy has subscribed to the view that we must engage in a big campaign of afforestation. Water and sewerage systems in parts of the country are primitive, where they exist at all, and for many years to come it will be necessary to provide money for these essential services.
People are scared by the size of the bill which is presented to the House. I think it is approximately one-third of the £100,000,000. That represents an increase of approximately £48,000,000 since 1946-47. We must all bear in mind that we were left a legacy of deficiencies. We were left a legacy of a bad housing situation, of bad water supply and sewerage schemes, of a bad hospital situation. When a native Government took over in this country in 1922 all these services needed to be made up. The efforts of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government and the Fianna Fáil Government up to 1939 did not, and could not, repair the damageor, should I say, the neglect of a foreign rule. There was a lull between the years 1939 to 1945 or 1946 because of the circumstances which then existed. Houses were not built and various other public works, all of which were very necessary, could not be engaged in. We are now trying to make up that leeway. In 1947 or 1948 the House agreed that 100,000 houses needed to be provided. I do not think we are near the completion of that job yet. So long as it needs to be done, it is futile and dishonest for anybody to think that, other than by cutting out wasteful and extravagant expenditure, this bill of £100,000,000 can substantially be reduced. My complaint would be that not enough money is provided for certain necessary schemes.
I think that one of the greatest paradoxes of this particular Book of Estimates is that, in respect of urban and rural relief schemes, there is a reduction of £80,000. I always believed that these urban and rural relief schemes were for the purpose of relieving unemployment. I cannot reconcile a reduction under this particular sub-head having regard to the figure of 90,000 unemployed. Neither can I reconcile the attitude of the Minister for Finance, or of the Government in general, with a reduction of £250,000 in the amount of moneys for drainage under the Local Authorities (Works) Act.
It is significant that that is the very same sum of money that is being paid for the well-ridden Tulyar. That will appear very significant to the many thousands of men in the rural areas who are now forced to sign on at the employment exchange or who are trying to gather up the price of their passage to enable them to go across to Great Britain and to seek work there.
Again, it seems to me a paradox that, in the present situation, grants for sanitary services are reduced by £40,000. I do not want to go into all this in detail now. There will have to be some drastic remedy for this desperate situation. Let us blame whom we like for the situation thathas been created but let us also remember that, no matter what Government may be in power and no matter who may support them, they have the responsibility of doing their utmost for our men and women who are trying to make ends meet and who feel very low indeed because nobody is giving any indication that there will be employment for them in the near future. That is why I say that their morale has been severely shattered; they regard their position as very hopeless indeed. The present Government must take responsibility for that.
The highlights of the speeches made by members of the present Government during the last three or four by-elections were that they were cleaning up the mess and paying the bills left by the inter-Party Government. That type of talk might be believed by supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party and it might be all right to make such statements at a church gate meeting. It has been said that by the withdrawal of the food subsidies and by the imposition of certain taxes a sum of £10,000,000 was obtained and that that £10,000,000 is being devoted to the payment of debts incurred by the inter-Party Government. That assertion has been made by members of the Fianna Fáil Party despite the fact that everybody knows that the only amount provided in last year's Book of Estimates for the repayment of the loan that was advanced when the inter-Party Government were in office amounted to £640,000. Therefore it is entirely dishonest to try to tell the people of this country—as they have been told by members of the Fianna Fáil Party in the course of the last three or four by-elections—that a sum of £10,000,000 had to be raised to pay the debts of the inter-Party Government. It is also dishonest to say—as has been said—that the alleged unnecessary stockpiling by the inter-Party Government has been responsible for mass unemployment in a particular industry.
I read to-night—if necessary, I can get the reference—a statement which was made in the House on the 7th November, 1951, by the Minister for Industry and Commerce when speakingon the Supplies and Services Bill. Referring to this question of stockpiling, he said that the importation of textiles would be cut down, but that, in the meantime, he could not foresee that there would be any reduction of employment in the textile industry.
I think that the analysis which has been circulated to Deputies, with regard to the unemployment figures, is most enlightening. I commend a study of it to the Deputies on the other side of the House. It shows an increase in unemployment between the 13th December and the 19th January of 5,445 in respect of building, contracting and works of construction. Yet, we have the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance protesting in this House that there has been no slowing down on housing, and that if there has been, it is the fault of the local authorities.
I do not know whether any direction has been given to the Government, or by the Department of Local Government with regard to housing progress or, perhaps, I should say the lack of it. We can only go on the figures before us and, on these I do not think it is hard to judge as to whether or not there has been a slowing down in the erection of houses by local authorities.
I shall quote, for the information of the House, the figures relating to local authority houses in course of construction. In February, 1948, the figure was 3,068; in February, 1949, 7,379; in August 1949, 10,000; January, 1950, 10,912; March, 1951, 10,000; August 1951, 9,892; August, 1952, 8,760 and December, 1952, 7,391. Here are the figures of workers employed on local authority housing: May, 1950, 13,673; May, 1951, 11,481; May, 1952, 11,106; and the 1st January, 1953, 8,632. As I say, I do not know whether or not a direction, or advice of any sort has been given by the Government, the Minister concerned or, the Department of Local Government with regard to housing, but the fact is that a big number of the 90,000 unemployed are workers who had been in the building industry.
It seems to me that it is nowbecoming much more difficult than it was to get sanction from the Department of Local Government for the different housing schemes sent up to them. Housing can be stopped in many more ways than by the Minister, the Parliamentary Secretary, or the Taoiseach saying "stop housing", or "go slow on housing". We have the most frivolous, the smallest and the most unnecessary type of query and complaint being sent from the Department to the local authority week after week, month after month or, I should say, after intervals of a month or two months or maybe three months, and by that method—whether they are trying to be more careful or to ensure that the local authority is providing the best type of house or not I do not know—housing has been slowed down.
I think I can speak with a fair amount of knowledge of one local authority, the Wexford Corporation. There is, on the part of the majority of its members, the desire to see houses built in Wexford town. It seems to me, however, that over the last six or 12 months delays from the Department have resulted in approximately 40 per cent. of the ordinary army of building workers with the Wexford Corporation being laid off. If that situation is to continue, it will mean that we are going to lose the skilled men we have in the building industry. If we do lose them, it will take quite a long time to get them back.
I think that the budgetary policy of the Minister for Finance, announced in April of last year, has to a very large extent, been responsible for the position in which we find ourselves to-day. I would refer in the first place, to the restriction of credit. The Minister for Finance has protested loudly that no direction was sent along the line with regard to the restriction of credit, and that he did not give any such direction either firsthand or secondhand, to the banks.
The fact, however, is that even though the rate of interest charged is high—6 per cent—any man who wants to engage in private building, or in any sort of a business venture, has a very poor chance of getting any type of loan from a bank if he is not ableto give abnormal security for it—so much security, in fact, that he would not really need a loan.
The discouraging forecasts made by the Fianna Fáil Government since its return to office as to what was going to happen to the country have also acted as a deterrent. That has been their effect on businessmen who are no longer in a speculative mood. People may say that speculation on the part of businessmen would be wrong. I do not mean it in that sense. What I mean is that they are not prepared to expand their business. The speeches of the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs this evening would not encourage them to expand their business. They just feel that they are doing all right, and will prefer to stay "pat." I think that the Budget policy of the Minister for Finance announced last April was fatal for this country.
The record over the last year shows that to be so. It is shown very clearly in the industrial analysis, particularly in the distributive trades where the increase in unemployment has been very steep indeed in respect of those ordinarily employed in grocery, meat, fish, poultry, food and especially drink. In that particular type of employment there has been a very big increase in the number of people who now find themselves unemployed. All of us know and the Minister must now admit that in one particular respect he failed miserably, that is, in his assessment as to what a tax on stout in this country would produce. I do not know what the Minister's intentions are but, if the Minister were to come into this House and propose, as would be welcomed by everybody in the country, a reduction in the price of stout, the best thing he could do would be to resign because that very action would be an admission of failure on his part as Minister for Finance.
I shall not detain the House any longer but I want to remind the House again that I have seen in the last few weeks what I never saw before— queues at a labour exchange. In the normal course of events, men havedifferent times for signing and one may see a cluster around a labour exchange but I have never seen queues there until the last six months. I will not describe them as crowds because there is no point in exaggerating the situation but there are many of our people going to Fishguard, Dún Laoghaire, and all the ports of embarkation on their way to Britain to seek employment merely because it is not available here. That is a situation about which the Government should be concerned but it seems to the ordinary person in the street that they are not concerned. They may be concerned privately. They may be concerned in Cabinet meetings but I submit that there should be some indication from the Taoiseach or from the Minister for Finance as to the prospects for these 90,000 unemployed people.
Comment on this
May I at first protest against the statements that were made here to-day by Deputy Dillon and others? There are in the benches opposite at least 75 per cent. of Deputies who would go into a dead faint to-morrow morning if they thought that the Government was going out of office. They would be found scattered along the street, laid out. Then we have them shouting for the Government to resign. Those people over there did not resign until they were absolutely certain that they would be kicked out and until they were absolutely certain that anything less than Deputy Flanagan's monetary reform scheme would not keep them going for another three months. They left when they had had the last roundup in as far as any bob could be borrowed from any end of the earth. Then they went and left their debts after them.
I heard challenges being made here by Deputy Dillon to-day in connection with certain members of this House, certain decent members, far decenter in their attitude in this House than Deputy Dillon has ever been. I allude to his statements here about Deputy Cogan, Deputy Cowan, Deputy Browne and Deputy ffrench O'Carroll. At least three of those Deputies were responsible for giving the inter-PartyGovernment their marching orders. They went to the country as the opponents of the inter-Party Government and were elected by the people as the opponents of the inter-Party Government.
Let us have no more of this balderdash that has been carried on in this House so long. Deputy Cowan signified from that bench his firm intention of voting against Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture. So did each of the other Deputies here and they went to the country on the programme that there was one thing they were not going to do: They were not going to let the inter-Party Government get back. They were re-elected on that policy. Let us have no more of this tripe.
I heard Deputy Corish telling us about the amounts that have been paid in interest. Would he like to hear the figures? I quote the reply I got from the Minister for Finance in this House on 23rd April, 1952—column 167. I asked the Minister for Finance the following question:—
"If he will state (1) the total amount payable and paid in interest and sinking fund in the financial year 1947-48, and (2) the total amount payable in interest and sinking fund in the financial year 1952-53."
I received the following reply from the Minister for Finance:—
"The amounts paid in 1947-48 and estimated as payable in 1952-53 for the service of the public debt are as follows:—
1947-48(Actual) | 1952-53(Estimated)
£ | £
For interest | 3,095,714 | 7,354,700
For sinking funds, etc. | 1,128,620 | 2,725,700
£4,224,334 | £10,080,400.”
We paid £5,800,000 a year for the luxury of having that circus here for three years, to be paid every year for the next 30 years.
Comment on this
If they want to know the difference between the policy of this Government and their policy, the policy of this Government is pay as you go; their policy was borrow again to pay the interest on what you borrowed last year. That is the difference between the two policies. Let me not hear any more tripe about that. They borrowed in 1947-48 to balance the Budget, £5,004,000, to pay for the cheap beer and the cheap cigarettes from the time they came in until the end of the financial year. Let us be clear about this. They became more courageous then. They found the bank manager to be a fairly generous fellow and in 1948-49 they borrowed £8,900,000; in 1949 they borrowed £20,500,000; in 1950-51 they borrowed £21,086,000; in 1951-52 they borrowed £38,938,000. They borrowed altogether £95,000,000 to run this country for three and a half years. Then they come in here and say that the poor people are taxed, the poor people are robbed.
On top of all the taxation that they had they borrowed that much to run the country. They then come in here with their tripe and commiserate with the poor people and the poor unemployed. If the amount that they borrowed had been put into establishing industry there would not be a man unemployed now. What did they do with it? Where did it go? These are the questions that I would like some of the gentlemen in this House to ask themselves.
I move to report progress.