Committee on Finance. - Motion by the Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 1–205 of 383. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
My first duty, and a pleasant duty it is, is to pay a tribute to the speech delivered by Deputy M.P. Murphy last Friday. In that speech, Deputy Murphy put forward some constructive suggestions, and I was particularly impressed by the suggestion that unemployment assistance, or, to give it its more usual name, the dole, should be payable in respect of men who contribute one or two days' work per week. This suggestion that, instead of paying out the dole and getting no return, we should seek to establish a system by which men would contribute some work, if only one or two days a week, is a constructive suggestion and a suggestion—I will deal with it more fully later—which is in striking contrast with the eruptions we have heard from the front Opposition Bench.
It is time for the leaders of the main Opposition Party to adopt a more constructive and reasonable approach to national problems. Their whole case —a laboured case, built up over the past year—is that the country was rolling in wealth and prosperity when the change of Government occurred and that, as a result of speeches delivered by certain Ministers, the whole situation changed for the worse. I do not accept the view that the country was rolling in prosperity when the Opposition Party went out of office. They would never have gone out of office were it not for the fact that they were faced with very grave and difficult problems following the sudden termination of Marshall Aid. That, of course, was not the explanation given to this House or to the country for the dissolution in 1951. Since then, the former Taoiseach has said that he dissolved the Dáil because certain Independent Deputies were seeking a higher price for milk. That might have been as good a reason as any for dissolving the Dáil, but it does not indicate that the position was as happy as some Deputies have sought to convey here.
I have listened to their case builtup over the past 12 months and it is my purpose to-day to tear that case to pieces. I shall start by indicating that one of the most frequent assertions here over the past year was that a certain Minister told the Irish people that they were eating too much during the inter-Party period.
Deputy Dillon repeated that assertion in the course of this debate and announced that the people of Ireland, under the inter-Party Government, were eating more and eating better than ever they did before or since. Deputy Blowick endorsed that statement and claimed that, since the change of Government, he and the rest of us have not been eating enough. He even went further and said that the rise in food exports over the last year was due to the fact that the Irish people were eating less than they could even afford previously.
I wanted to trace this matter back to its source and find out when and where the Minister for Finance did make the statement that the people of Ireland were eating too much. I made a little research to-day before I came into the House and I find that the statement was actually made by the Minister for Finance but it was made on the 28th February, 1951, when the Minister for Finance introduced his Vote on Account. The Minister for Finance at that time was Deputy Paddy McGilligan, Minister in the inter-Party Government. At column 789 of the Official Report dated the 28th February, 1951, he said:—
"The disturbing feature, of course, is the deficit in the balance of payments, particularly when that is marked by the great increase in consumption here, especially when that great increase in consumption is attached to the non-essential goods. The continuance of such a situation for any period would be highly dangerous."
That is the assertion in this House that the people of Ireland were eating too much. At column 787, the same Minister said:—
"The developments in 1950 are, of course, disquieting and it is clearthat we could not for very long expand consumption at the present excessive level..."
There again is another assertion that consumption in this country in 1951 was at an excessive level and that it would need to be curbed. Those statements were not chance impromptu statements made in the course of the discussion in the House but were part of a prepared speech deliberately made when the Minister introduced his Vote on Account in 1951. I think it is right that this House and the country generally should remember that that was the situation which prevailed when the Dáil was suddenly dissolved in 1951.
The Minister for Finance in the inter-Party Government was alarmed and disturbed at the position of the balance of payments and at the excessive consumption of non-essential goods by our people. In the course of that debate on the Vote on Account I remember that I referred to that situation and I said that as far as I could see the policy of the Government appeared to be to eat, drink and be merry. The then Minister for Finance got rather cross with me for suggesting that that was their policy but up to that statement by the Minister for Finance no steps were taken to remedy their position and no steps were taken by the Minister then except to dissolve the Dáil.
I want to examine the suggestion that the people—and by the people I mean and refer in the main to those in the lower income groups—were better off during the period of the inter-Party Government. I stated in this House—of course, nobody can dare contest it—that the cost of living went up by 23 per cent. Half of that increase in the cost of living occurred before the change of Government. The other half occurred since. That is an increase of 23 per cent. in the cost of living but against that you have got to consider that the lowest paid workers in this State or in any other State are the most important workers in the country. They are the men who work on the land.
Some time during the period of theinter-Party Government—I think it was in 1950—Deputy Dillon strutted into the House like a turkey cock in the early spring and announced proudly that agricultural workers' wages had been raised to £3 per week. Three pounds per week was the minimum wage that would be paid to any agricultural worker in any part of Ireland at that time. That was the position under the inter-Party Government. The position to-day is that the agricultural worker has £4 per week. In 1950 the worst-off agricultural worker—the man with the large family —had a wage of £3 per week. If he had a family of six he had a family allowance of 10/- which brought his weekly income up to £3 10s. To-day, that man's wage would be £4, plus 18/6 children's allowances which brings his income up to £4 18s. 6d. per week.
That is not a very big income. It does not provide for a seven-course meal three times a day but that is the income of the agricultural worker to-day and it is 40 per cent. higher than the income of the agricultural worker under the inter-Party Government although the cost of living has risen more than 23 per cent. I think it is quite clear from that that while the worker's position to-day is not good it was even worse under the inter-Party Government.
Those are facts which nobody can dispute. The farm workers' wage is related to that of the forestry workers, the road workers and of all those other people in the lower income groups. All their incomes, having regard to the children's allowances, have risen by 40 per cent. and the cost of living has risen by 23 per cent. so that, whatever may be said about their position to-day, it is not quite as bad as it was when the inter-Party Government held office. I think that is an important point and one which is very clearly recognised by the workers.
There is no use in Deputy Dillon or Deputy Blowick coming into this House and talking about the wealth that prevailed amongst the manual workers under the inter-Party Government. I am a small farmer and most of the people with whom I am acquainted are either small farmers,agricultural workers or road workers. I know them all. I know the conditions under which they live. I talked to them during the régime of the inter-Party Government as they prepared meals on the side of the road. There was no great feasting on the part of these men in those days. Their meals were frugal and modest. I am sure the same position prevails to-day and our aim should be to make conditions better but there is no use trying, as Deputy Blowick and Deputy Dillon tried, to completely distort the whole thing in order to make it appear that there has been a disastrous reduction in the standard of living of the most important workers in this State.
The next line of reasoning, if you can call it reasoning—I suppose "line of deception" would be a more apt definition—by the leader of the Opposition—I am not accusing the ordinary rank and file because I do not think they go in to the same extent for this sort of distortion and deception—is that Government policy over the past year and a half has been based on the Central Bank Report. We all read the Central Bank Report when it was issued and we are all aware of the recommendations contained in it. The Central Bank Report recommended a slowing down of all capital investment works. They recommended a slowing down of housing, turf development, the provision of hospitals and of all the other public works that are essential to the nation. Apparently the first reaction of the Government, when they had considered the report, was to make a decision on it. At the earliest opportunity after the publication of the report, that decision was conveyed to this House by the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass. I quote from the Official Report of the 7th November, 1951, in which Deputy Lemass is reported as follows:—
"I want to make it quite clear that the line which the Government intends to follow is diametrically opposed to that which the Central Bank suggests."
That is a very clear-cut and definite statement of policy. The facts, asborne out in the reports of progress over the year, prove that that policy was adhered to. The Central Bank recommended that there should be a slowing down of all development work. The fact is that there was a stepping-up of all development work. In other words, there was a complete rejection of the advice of the Central Bank and a policy was adopted which, as the Tánaiste said, was diametrically opposed to the recommendations of the Central Bank.
Comment on this
No. The results of the policy adopted in opposition to the policy recommended by the Central Bank were that over the past year there were very great increases in development work. The number of houses completed last year was 13,000 as against 12,000 the previous year. The amount provided for hospitals in 1951-52 was £3,000,000 as against £4,250,000 in the present year. The number of new schools being built in 1951 was 66; in 1952, it was 81 and in 1953 the number is 107. There is no slowing-down on development work, to judge by that report.
Let us examine the position in regard to the production of machine-won turf. In 1950, 214,000 tons of turf were produced. In 1951, 457,000 tons were produced and in 1952, 600,000 tons were produced.
Rural electrification has been stepped up in the past year. Through peat and water power, electricity generating stations have been erected and further new schemes are being planned.
The number of workers employed on forestry work in the last week of January, 1950, was 2,346. In the last week of January, 1951, the number was 2,786. In the last week of January, 1952, the figure was 3,453 and for the last week of January, 1953, the figure was 3,612. These facts indicate that there has been a progressive stepping-up in the numbers of workers employed in the Forestry Division on work which the Central Bank recommended should be slowed down. Similarly, with regard to the acreage planted by the ForestryDivision. In 1950, when Deputy Blowick was in charge of that Department — ably assisted by Deputy MacBride during his infrequent visits to this country—the acreage planted was 7,400. In 1951 the acreage planted was 9,400. In 1952 the acreage planted was 15,000.
Comment on this
They would, but it is necessary to show that the case so laboriously put forward by the Opposition that the recommendations of the Central Bank were accepted and put into operation by the present Government is absolutely false. I am sorry if it has been necessary for me to go into some detail on this matter but that case is made by the Opposition time and time again without ever giving any figures to support it and I think it is necessary, now and again, to produce concrete evidence of the facts and figures to disprove the rotten case made by the Opposition and to show how dishonest it is.
Comment on this
I heard it and the Deputy will hear it again. The most spectacular increase in development work comes under the heading of land reclamation. In accordance with the wishes of the Chair, I shall not go into the figures but I should like to say that there has been an increase of £1,000,000 under that heading. Therefore, under every heading on which the Central Bank recommended that there should be a slowing-up there has actually been a stepping-up.
Deputy Morrissey talks about unemployment. He does not seem to remember or to bear in mind the fact that the numbers of people inemployment have increased just the same as the numbers of people out of employment have increased. Deputies on the Opposition Benches do not seem to remember that we had the same problem under the inter-Party Government but that it was relieved somewhat by the spectacular increase in emigration. At that time, trade was booming in Great Britain. There was a big development with regard to armaments and men were urgently required, with the result that our unemployment problem was relieved, to a certain extent at any rate, by mass emigration. There is still emigration, but not on the same scale.
Comment on this
How do you, who made the statement, know? There are no figures available now, fortunately for the Government.
Comment on this
I hope they will be available, and the sooner the better. There is not very much use in Opposition Deputies trying to build a case on emigration. We have always had emigration. We have had it since the establishment of the State. When I mentioned that emigration had increased during the inter-Party régime, I did not hold that anything against the inter-Party, because I do not think they had any control over the fact that conditions in Great Britain made for increased emigration. This is a problem that will always remain difficult, and is one that we must face constructively. There is no use in tossing it from one side of the House to the other, with one side blaming the other for it. I am not blaming the inter-Party for it and never did when they were in power or out of power. I say it is a difficulty that faces any small nation such as ours which, in the main, is an agricultural nation, living close to a highly developed industrial state such as Great Britain.
We have the same problem with regard to the migration of our people from the rural areas to the cities. It too, is a difficult problem, and, if figures were produced showing theextent of that migration, they would be very disheartening indeed. It is, however, just one of those things that we have to fight against.
I think it is a step in the right direction to be able to point out that there has been some improvement in the general standard of living amongst the people in the rural areas. The trend there at present, with the modernisation and the mechanisation of agriculture, the raising of the wages of agricultural workers and the provision of fair prices for agricultural produce, is one which all of us hope will be continued. If it is, there will be the tendency, I hope, for our young people, reared in the rural areas, to continue to live there and work in our most important industry. That is a hope which everybody who has the real interests of Ireland at heart, and is not concerned merely with the making of political catch-cries, must cherish.
Another point which is very frequently made by the professional politicians—I suppose I must so call the leader of the Opposition as against the ordinary rank and file——
Comment on this
I have as an independent farmer. It is a class that I am rather proud of. The case has been made by those gentlemen that, last year, money was borrowed at too high a rate of interest. I admit that the rate of interest was high, but on the whole it was not higher than the rate of interest at which money was borrowed under the inter-Party Government from the United States. My reason for saying that is, that while the nominal rate of interest on Marshall Aid was only 2½ per cent., the fact remains that every penny of the money so obtained has to be paid back to an outside nation and not one penny of it can be recovered by way of taxation.
I was rather interested to know the exact contribution which this country will have to make by way of repayments under Marshall Aid. On 4th December last I addressed a question to the Minister for Finance with a view to finding out what liability we had actually incurred to the United States under that loan, which appeared at the time, I should say, to be very generous. I asked the Minister: "If he will state when repayment of the principal of the Marshall Aid loan will commence; what the total payment for interest and sinking fund will amount to in that year; what it will amount to ten years later, and what the amount will be during the last three years of repayment." I received the following reply:—
"Repayment of the principal of the Marshall Aid loan will commence on 30th June, 1956. Interest and sinking fund payments in the years specified by the Deputy and the equivalent in sterling converted at the current rate of exchange with the United States dollar ($2.80 to the £) are as follows:—
Financial Year | Amount Payable | Sterling Equivalent
$ | £
1956/57 | 3,845,188 | 1,373,281
1966/67 | 5,898,863 | 2,106,737
1981/82 | 9,611,625 | 3,432,723
1982/83 | 9,612,838 | 3,433,156
1983/84 | 9,454,400 | 3,376,571”
In other words, in 30 years' time when Deputy Morrissey—I am sorry he has left the House—will have become rather mature and when other Deputies who are now very juvenile will have grown up, we will be paying over $9,000,000 a year to the United States. We can all easily understand what a load that will be on the shoulders of our people. At present dollars are not easy to get and so we may assume that in the future they will not be easy to secure. That is a burden of debt which has been assumed by this country and which must be met, so that on the whole if Deputies compare the liability which we incurred under the recent National Loan with the liability incurred under Marshall Aid they will find that the burden in respect of Marshall Aid is by far the heavier oneon this State and on the economic position of the country.
When money is borrowed from citizens within the State the interest on it is payable within the State. We can assume that a certain amount of income-tax and of other forms of taxation will be recovered from it, and that indirectly it will go to provide a certain amount of employment within the State. When, however, the principal and the interest have to be paid to a foreign nation, and particularly when they have to be paid in dollars, the sum involved represents a very severe burden on a small nation such as this. I am not speaking now against the acceptance of Marshall Aid by the then Government. Nobody in this country, except perhaps Deputy Cowan, objected to that loan. Most people at the time considered that having regard to the dollar payment position there was no alternative. Looking back on it now it is not quite clear whether it was as good a——
Comment on this
——bargain or enterprise as we thought it was. However, the debt or liability was incurred and the nation has to face it. When it is said that the Government offered too generous terms in respect of the loan last year it must be borne in mind that the previous Government attempted to raise two loans at a lower rate of interest which were not subscribed to. It is very easy to float a loan at a low rate of interest, but if it is not taken up the Government's position is worse than ever.
Comment on this
No Government with a sense of responsibility could face the prospect of not having money that was urgently required to meet works of capital development, which were proceeding and which had to be paid for. No member of the Opposition would suggest that at present it is possible to obtain money at a cheaper rate. In matters of this kind, Governments as well as citizens are governed to a great extent by world financial conditions, conditions over which neither the present Government nor the previous Government had any control. People who say that the Government made the price of money dearer merely show their lack of knowledge or conception of the position.
The banking system, I suppose, is outside governmental control. That applies not only in the case of this Government but of other Governments. It is an international system, the operations of which are not always easy to foresee and which are impossible to control as far as Governments are concerned. I think it will be accepted by Deputies of all Parties that a reasonable attempt is being made to carry out this nation's affairs.
One accusation made against the Government was that by their policy over the last year they sought to create a situation of inflation. Against that the accusation was made that they were seeking to precipitate a condition of deflation. Recently in this House two statements were quoted. One was a statement made by the Minister for Finance in which he declared that inflation would have to be curbed. The other was a statement by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in which he said they would have to seek to prevent deflation. It was suggested by Deputy Cosgrave that there was a direct conflict between the two statements. Anyone who gives the matter any thought will see that there is no conflict between the two statements—that the wise policy is to avoid deflation and inflation, that the alternative to inflation and deflation is a condition ofprice stability, which is the condition towards which any Government with a sense of responsibility should direct its policy.
There are people who would say that the removal of the food subsidies last year was a step towards inflation inasmuch as it was calculated to lead to wage increase demands. Deputy Cosgrave made that point. I know something about wage increase demands. I know what they were under the inter-Party Government when nearly every day an ultimatum was presented by the trade unions or the Trade Union Congress for increased remuneration. I do not think that any uncontrolled inflation has been caused by the changes in food subsidies last year.
There are two policies that a wise Government must consider and weigh in a situation in which the cost of living makes it difficult for the lower income groups to live. One is the subsidisation of food. The subsidisation of food means a subsidy not only in respect of the food of the lower income groups but also the food of the richer people. The alternative is to provide children's allowances. Of the two, the provision of children's allowances is the more equitable and perhaps the better solution of the problem. An increase in children's allowances enables those most seriously affected by a rising cost of living to meet that situation.
It is worthy of note that the inter-Party Government within the last six months of their period of office watched while the cost of living rose by 11 per cent. but did nothing about it. They did not provide increased subsidies. They took no steps to deal with the situation. At least over the last year an attempt has been made, as I pointed out, to deal with this matter by increasing family allowances. That is the better solution to the problem. The man who has a large number of dependents is most seriously affected by a rising cost of living. An effort is being made to adjust the position so as to create a situation of price stability, in which we can look forward to money purchasingthe same amount of goods over a considerable period.
I have already pointed out how the farm worker's position has been improved by a rise of 40 per cent. in his income whereas the cost of living has risen by only 23 per cent. That is a line of approach to a final solution of the problem. For every rise in wages and salaries of the lower paid workers, namely, agricultural workers and manual workers generally, there ought not to be a corresponding stepping-up of the wages or salaries of every other section in the community. Such a corresponding stepping-up means that the farm worker is kept down far below the level of the rest of the community and a continuation of the situation in which the most important people in the community are by far the worst paid.
I was rather indignant when I heard a county manager recently declare that there should be permanently a differential of 12/6 between the farm workers' wages and the road workers' wages, that the farm workers' wages should be kept 12/6 below the wages of the road workers. That would be an intolerable position, particularly in an agricultural country, and it is one which should be resisted. Our aim should be to keep the higher paid workers level and bring up the deserving lower paid workers until you reach a certain amount of equity in the distribution of income.
It is some satisfaction to turn away from the futile and absurd proposals we have heard from the Opposition Benches and consider constructive suggestions for the improvement of the nation's position. We have listened for the last week, and indeed for the last year, to denunciations of every social and economic evil, and we have listened to these evils being blamed upon the Government by people who held governmental rank up to a few years ago and who during their tenure of office could make no attempt to deal with these problems and had to get out because they could make no attempt to deal with them.
Nothing was more amusing, and perhaps it was a little disgusting, thanthe exhibition given by Deputy Dillon last week when he barked across the House at the Government to get out. It reminds me of the person who sees the master of the house sitting in his favourite chair and for that reason is indignant. There is not anything constructive in barking across at the Government Benches and telling the Government to get out. It would be more constructive to put up some proposals for the improvement of the whole economic position of the country.
For that reason I should like to endorse the suggestion put forward by Deputy Murphy in regard to the unemployed. He suggested that, instead of paying the dole to workers throughout the country, they should be given two or three days' work per week. That in itself would not only help to relieve the position of the unemployed, but it would add something to the wealth of the nation. I believe that we have been toying with this problem too long. I do not think that anyone will suggest that in a free society where private enterprise is recognised you can have 100 per cent. full-time employment. Therefore there will always be a number of people who, in the competition for employment, will find themselves forced out, and it is the duty of the State to provide for these. The socialists say it is the duty of the State to provide work or maintenance, but I think the Christian solution of the problem is for the State to provide work, and I believe that that is something which is within the power of the State to do if the community are so organised that work will be provided in every area throughout the country.
I believe that we should set up in every parish a parish council and give to that council, as Deputy Murphy suggested, the money which is paid in doles and that they should provide part-time employment for the unemployed people within each parish. That is the Christian solution of the problem. The socialist solution of the problem is to herd these men to the labour exchanges, let them queue up, pay them some miserable sum ofmoney, and in that way make them slaves of the State.
The time has come when we must try in some way or other to get away from this idea of the welfare State or the slave State and when we must try to develop private enterprise in the first place, local initiative in the second place, and co-operative action on the part of the citizen for the development of the country and provision for the needs of the unemployed and the destitute. If a parish council were established in every parish and the clergy and all well-meaning people in each parish were asked to co-operate, it would be possible to find works of improvement within each parish which could be carried out by the unemployed instead of asking them to travel five, six or seven miles to the nearest labour exchange for a miserable allowance which is of course insufficient to maintain them.
Deputy Sheldon put forward a proposal which I think most Deputies will endorse. It was that the burden of expenditure, the sum total of expenditure, has grown so much that there must be some drastic steps taken to cope with State expenditure. Some effort must be made to reduce the cost of governing this nation and I think it is a desirable proposal that a small Committee of this House should be set up to examine the Estimates with a view to seeing how economies could be effected. We have a Committee of Public Accounts which examines expenditure with a view to seeing whether or not the money has been expended by the Departments in accordance with the law. But there is something more than that required. Some effort should be made to examine proposed expenditure to see whether the money is being used to the best advantage or not, to see whether every Department is absolutely essential or whether it is overstaffed. That is the kind of work that ought to be undertaken and that should have been undertaken long ago, but it is better to attempt it later than never.
An impartial and thorough investigation, I think, would reveal ways and means by which economies could be effected. It might not have such adrastic effect as Deputy Corry suggested. It might not result in the elimination of the number of civil servants that he suggested, but at least it would result in some cutting down of the staffs of the various Departments and it would lead to some economies. Of course, when we mention this matter we always come up against the problem of what is to be done with the people who would otherwise be employed by the State if we effect these economies. That is, of course, a bigger question and it is one which is tied up with the problem of the economic development of agriculture and of our industries.
Until we reach a stage where every square inch of Irish land is producing its maximum output we cannot claim we are making a reasonable attempt to provide employment for our people. The first essential is to make agriculture self-sufficient and policy must be directed towards that end. I have no use for the kind of patronising patter we got from the former Minister for Agriculture. That does not solve any problem. He claimed that the volume of agricultural output had gone up during his tenure when he knows, in fact, that it had gone down. Claims of that kind do not solve our agricultural problem. Two years ago on the Vote on Account Deputy McGilligan commented on the fact that during the three years in which his Government had been in office there had not been any increase in agricultural output.
That position has applied under successive Governments. It is a position that could be remedied, and it is in remedying that position and in further developing our industrial potentiality that we can provide employment for our young people instead of driving them into the Civil Service where many of them are lowly paid, particularly in the early years, and some, perhaps, right through to their retirement.
The attitude adopted by successive Governments towards agriculture has been unsound. On one occasion here I brought in a motion to secure a higher price for milk and all the Parties constituting the inter-PartyGovernment, including Deputy Everett, marched into the Division Lobby to vote against that increase.
Comment on this
Deputy Everett will admit that possibly the wrong people were put in jail. The people I would put in jail are the people who refused to give the farmers a fair price and allowed that situation to develop, the people who refused to give a costings investigation three years ago when I and others demanded it. Had we got that costings investigation then we would have been in a position to obtain accurately the cost of producing milk and securing a fair price for the farmers without the farmers themselves having to take the drastic step of withholding supplies. I know there was an undercover movement to force the farmers into a position where the Guards would have to arrest some of them. That was politically inspired. The arrests were made by the Guards without any instructions from the Government and in the course of their ordinary duties. The directions to the farmers, however, to force that situation came from the headquarters of various political Parties, the names of which I will not mention.
Comment on this
We want to get away from that kind of position and we want to make the situation such that it will not be necessary for the farmers to agitate for price increases by withholding supplies or by getting Deputies to raise the matter here by way of motion. I hope that situation will be arrived at in the near future and that we will have a national council of agriculture representative of all farmer organisations and that that council will advise not only the Minister for Agriculture but the whole Government in regard to agricultural policy in the future.
We should accept the fact that agriculture is our main industry and such a council of agriculture shouldrank next in importance to this House. It should be in a position to meet the Government on the same terms as the executive of the National Farmers' Union of Britain meets the British Government and settles or arranges agricultural policy for the coming year. That is one step that should be taken to improve our agricultural and economic position.
It should be possible to provide cheaper credit for agriculture and the most important type of credit now is short-term credit. Long-term credit will be necessary for such works as drainage, land reclamation and the fertilising of land under the lime and fertiliser scheme, a scheme first recommended here by me. Short-term credit of the type provided by the Irish Sugar Company in connection with the growing of beet is very essential. It should be possible to provide that type of credit within the present financial system. The bank rate has risen and the interest rate is very high. The Government is a very large financial concern. The Government raises and expends something in the region of £100,000,000 per annum. It should be possible out of that sum to provide £1,000,000 for short-term credit to agriculture at a very low rate of interest since the money would come out of revenue and not have to be borrowed. That is more important from the point of view of agriculture than increasing the existing grants. Small farmers find themselves up against the problem of shortage of credit very often. The ordinary small farmer who is anxious to improve his land or buy better equipment has no banking account. He is not known to the local bank manager and if he goes in and asks for money he will probably be thrown out. The only way he can secure a loan is by depositing money in the bank for 20, 30 or 40 years and at the end of that period he may be able to secure some accommodation.
Our banking system was never intended to help agriculture. The Agricultural Credit Corporation suffers from some of the faults and weaknesses of the banking system itself. That body is tied to the high rate of interest and it does not serve the interests of thefarming community in the way it should. Another way in which credit could be provided would be by the establishment of local credit societies for the financing of farming operations using the farmers' own money in the main. Steps along these lines should be taken in the very near future to improve agriculture.
We cannot allow the position to continue in which Irish agricultural output remains static while every other country in Western Europe is increasing its agricultural output. The main obstacle to expansion in agriculture is the lack of credit facilities, particularly for young farmers who are beginning to farm on their own and who have no capital behind them. They may be full of ambition and enthusiasm, but they have no financial backing and they are compelled to sit back and watch the older people continuing a policy which the young and the ambitious regard as inefficient. If the Government want to help agriculture to expand they ought to concentrate their energies on giving the maximum support and encouragement to our farmers' sons because they are the men upon whom the future of the industry depends.
I hope Deputy Sheldon's motion in regard to expenditure will be accepted by the House in the spirit in which it was put forward. I resent very much the patronising attitude adopted by Deputy Dillon towards a former Independent colleague of his. He said he taught Deputy Sheldon anything he knew about Government administration and finance. As a matter of fact, Deputy Sheldon probably has forgotten more than Deputy Dillon ever knew on this question. I think it was an exhibition of arrogance and intolerance for an old Deputy to insult in that way a young Deputy who is making a reasonable and fair contribution towards the solution of our administrative problems.
Comment on this
I think that is also true, because I do not think Deputy Sheldon was on the Public Accounts Committee at the same time as Deputy Dillon. He came on that Committee later andacquitted himself well. He gave very good service on that Committee over a number of years, perhaps much better service than did Deputy Dillon.
Comment on this
If there are lies told in this House there is no harm in having them contradicted on the records of this House. I hope the House will accept Deputy Sheldon's suggestion, and that we will, as a result, get a more efficient Civil Service than we have had in the past, and that an efficient Civil Service will strengthen the position of any Government with the public in asking for a higher degree of efficiency in private enterprise, in factories, in business and on the farms. I believe it is through increasing knowledge, increasing efficiency and with a policy of slightly more liberal credit facilities that we can build up not only industry but also our fundamental industry, agriculture, so that we will have permanently a higher standard of living for all our people irrespective of whether they live in town or country.
Comment on this
The Deputies will no doubt remember before Christmas when the Civil Service Arbitration Board was sitting figures on behalf of the Government official view were given at that arbitration hearing as to the estimated short fall in the revenue and as to the estimated increase in expenditure. The case Government spokesmen made at the Civil Service Arbitration Board hearing was that there would be a substantial budgetary deficit this year. More recently in this House the Minister for Finance, and also the Taoiseach, when pressed for the reasons for refusing to implement the findings of the Civil Service Arbitration Board, stated that there would be a substantial budgetary deficit.
The latest figures available for receipts into the Exchequer and forissues out of the Exchequer are those figures for the 7th March this year, approximately three and a half weeks before the financial year concludes. These figures make very interesting reading and certain conclusions can be drawn from them. The first is that at the present time there is a substantial budgetary surplus. The second one is that there will be little or no short fall in the revenue for which the Minister for Finance budgeted last year. The third is that it appears from the figures which we now have—and there are only three weeks more to run—that not only will there be a balanced Budget at the end of the year but that it is very likely there will be a surplus also. The fourth conclusion to be drawn is that if the very substantial Supplementary Estimates had not been brought in there would have been a very large budgetary surplus running into millions of pounds on the original Budget which the Minister for Finance introduced last year.
Probably the most important conclusion of all to be drawn from the figures which we now have is that, in view of the fact that the revenue is now running at the rate of something like £97,000,000 a year, that expenditure this year is much less than was budgeted for this year, and that the Estimates for the coming year were built around the Estimates for expenditure of last year and not around the actual results of expenditure last year, the Minister will not have a difficult task in reducing taxation when he brings in his forthcoming Budget.
I would like Deputies to look at the figures which are available to this House for revenue and expenditure on 7th March of this year. Those figures show that at that date the revenue was £89.7 million. At the 7th March last year the revenue was £79,000,000 and on the 31st March last year the revenue was £83.8 million. In those last three and a half weeks of the financial year revenue, therefore, increased by £4.8 million. We are entitled to expect, however, a much greater increase in revenue in the three and a half weeks from 7th March, 1953, because of the greatly increased rate of tax. That is borne out by the figures for the monthprevious to 7th March, 1953, which show that the revenue is running at the rate of £2.4 million a week. With three weeks to run Deputies will see that there should come into the Exchequer £7.2 million and with three and a half weeks to run it is quite clear that more than the sum of £97,000,000 approximately, the sum for which the Minister budgeted last year, should come into the Exchequer by the 31st March of this year. In my opinion the figures clearly demonstrate that there will be little or no short fall in the revenue this year.
I would ask Deputies to examine the expenditure for this year. Expenditure on 7th March was £93.3 million. It will be seen that that is approximately £4,000,000 over the revenue. That does not mean there is a budgetary deficit, however; at the present time it seems there is a budgetary surplus, because out of that £93,000,000 is to be deducted the amount spent on Capital Services. The amount spent for Capital Services in this financial year was to be £9.3 million. It is quite obvious that the major portion of that sum has now been spent and if you deduct even £7,000,000 from the figure of £93,000,000 for Capital Services which are not to be taxed for, and admitted by the Minister not to be taxed for, there is clearly a substantial budgetary surplus.
Last year's expenditure up to the 7th March was £89.7 million and on the 31st March was £101.2 million. In the three and a half weeks, expenditure increased by £11.5 million. I do not think that expenditure will increase by £11.5 million in the last three and a half weeks of this financial year for the reason that the food subsidies which were in operation last year are no longer in operation. As against that, there is the fact that since the 7th March the first payment on foot of the recent National Loan has had to be made. There has also been a Supplementary Estimate since the 7th March of £900,000 for the Office of the Minister for Social Welfare. In view of the reduction in the food subsidies, and allowing for these other items which will come in to be spent this year and which had not to be spent last year,it would appear that a reasonable estimate of expenditure would be the same figure as last year. It has also to be remarked, comparing the three or four weeks before the 7th March, that expenditure has not been running at the rate of £11,000,000 every three weeks. It has been running at less than £10,000,000. But even if we accept the fact that there is to be an estimated further expenditure for the last three and a half weeks of this financial year of £11.5 million, Deputies will see that the estimate for the total expenditure for this financial year will run about £104.8 million.
The outrun, therefore, of the Budget this year should be approximately £97,000,000 for revenue and £104.8 million for expenditure. That expenditure includes Central Fund Services and Supply Services, and out of the £104.8 million has to be deducted sums which the Minister said in his Budget speech last year were to be devoted to Capital Services and were not to be taxed for. Assuming that the expenditure on Capital Services was as estimated— and Deputies who support the Government have been boasting of the fact that there has been no reduction in capital expenditure by the Government—assuming that there is to be deducted £9.3 million for Capital Services from the total expenditure of £104.8 million, it will be seen that the total amount of expenditure to be taxed for this year is £95.5 million, or over £1,000,000 below what the estimated revenue will be. It will be appreciated, of course, by Deputies that these are very rough estimates in view of the fact that we are still three and a half weeks from the end of the financial year and uncertain as to what the ultimate figures will be. We do not know what the expenditure by the Government has been on Capital Services.
I should like to point out further that in addition to the reduction of £9.3 million for Capital Services for which the Minister budgeted, there will be substantial reductions in respect to the Supplementary Estimates which were introduced this year and which are included in that total expenditure which I have estimated at a roughguess at £104.8 million. One of the Supplementary Estimates which this House voted before Christmas had reference to a sum of £1,505,000 for the Office of the Minister for Agriculture.
I should like the House to examine the content of that Supplementary Estimate. No less than £500,000 of that Supplementary Estimate was to be paid for the land rehabilitation project and water supplies—a project which the Government themselves have admitted is a capital service and should not be taxed for. I say that the people should not be taxed this year in respect of that extra £500,000 to be expended under the land rehabilitation programme which the Government have admitted is work of a capital nature. Included in that Supplementary Estimate also was a sum of £150,000 for the ground limestone subsidy. That, again, is a sum which according to the Government should not be taxed for, because the money in the past has come not from the taxpayer's pocket but actually from the Grant Counterpart Fund which this Government authorised.
I should like to refer also to a sum of £555,000 included in the Supplementary Estimate which is a repayable advance for the importation of superphosphates. That in fact was a sum paid to the Sugar Company because the sales of superphosphates had fallen off, and was paid in respect to a bank overdraft which had to be met before the 31st December last. That is a repayable grant and surely the Government do not contend that the taxpayers should be taxed in respect of this £500,000 for a repayable grant to the Sugar Company which, if it has not been paid back already, will be paid back in the near future? There is another item of £300,000 because of a deficiency in money which is payable by the Sugar Company to the Exchequer. The Government had estimated that the Sugar Company would be able to pay into the Exchequer this year by means of Appropriations-in-Aid a sum of £400,000 but according to the Government, owing to the falling off in thesale of superphosphates, only £100,000 was paid in so that they have had to make a deduction in the original Estimates for the Appropriations-in-aid and they have added on to the Estimates a sum of £300,000. It is quite clear to me that that is a sum which the taxpayers should not be asked to pay for this year. If these figures are not correct I should be glad if the Minister, when replying, would deal with them and inform us how much of the Supplementary Estimate should be taxed for this year.
I should also like to refer to the recent Supplementary Estimate for the not negligible figure of £900,000 for the Office of Social Insurance. That Supplementary Estimate, it is said, is necessary in order to make payments under the provisions of the Social Welfare Act, 1952, because of a deficiency in the Social Insurance Fund. We do not know how that Social Insurance Fund has become deficient or how the expenditure has increased beyond the revenue. It would be very interesting to hear if the whole of that £900,000 represents the amount by which current expenditure has increased over revenue or if any of it is to go to pay for the erection of the Store Street building this year. If any portion of that £900,000 which has been voted to the Social Insurance Fund is to be spent on works of a capital nature, the taxpayer should not be asked to pay for it this year.
I would ask the members of the House to look at the Supplementary Estimate which was introduced in respect of the Department of Defence. Included in it is a sum of no less than £800,000 for warlike stores. This year, the Government are spending no less than £1,710,000 on warlike stores. In his Budget statement last year and in the tables which he circulated with it, the Minister admitted the financial probity of deducting for stockpiling expenditure in any given year if it could be shown that stocks had been bought which would be used over a given number of years—say, five or ten years. It is not financially correct totax the people for the whole amount of that stockpiling programme in one year: the taxation should be spread over a number of years. That financial mechanism was adopted by the Minister in his last Budget.
It seems to me that, following that principle, this sum of £1,700,000 should not be taxed for in this year. There should be a deduction of at least half of it for stockpiling purposes. The taxpayers should not be taxed this year for the full sum of £1,700,000 in respect of the stockpiling of warlike stores. It will be seen, therefore, that —in addition to the capital services which should be deducted from the expenditure for the financial year— other sums which are included in the Supplementary Estimates and which are not included in the Minister's statement should properly be deducted this year and should not be taxed for.
If the Minister carries out the proper financial policy and he does not deliberately tax people for things in respect of which they should not be taxed, he will certainly have a balanced Budget this year: very likely, he will have a surplus on his Budget when the full figures for the financial year are known. Whatever the result of the financial year may be, it is quite clear that, on his original Budget, the Minister would have had a very substantial surplus if he had not introduced Supplementary Estimates totalling something like £5,000,000 odd over and above the Supplementary Estimates which he said in his Budget speech he would bring in.
The Government have made the excuse that they are not in a position to implement the Civil Service Arbitration Award because of the deficit in the current account of the Budget. There is no doubt but that there is money to implement, at least in part, the Civil Service Arbitration Award. A very small body of people in this country who have been very adversely affected by the financial policy of the Government in the past 20 months are the Civil Service pensioners. The other day I asked the Minister for Finance a question as to the total cost of increasing the pensions paid to Civil Service pensioners to the rate set downin the Civil Service Arbitration Award, I was told that the figure is £62,000. In the second part of that question I asked the Minister whether he is prepared to grant the increase and the reply was: "No."
In view of the huge sums of money which the Government are now spending, in view of the fact that there will be little or no short-fall in the revenue this year, it is very niggardly indeed of the Government to refuse to grant £62,000 to alleviate the lot of pensioners who have ably served the State in the past.
It is quite clear that the statements made in this House concerning the Government's policy in introducing the Budget last year have not been denied. Indeed, they could not be denied because the policy behind the Budget is contained in black and white in the Dáil Reports. Every Deputy can read for himself the policy of the Government in introducing the Budget last year. Some Deputies and some Ministers have tried to gloss over what has happened in the past 20 months—and, in particular, since the Budget of last year—by saying that all that the Government were trying to do was to balance the accounts. They said that the Government were left with large commitments which had been incurred by their predecessors-in-office. They have tried to make the excuse that all that they were trying to do last year in their Budget was to balance the accounts. That argument has very effectively been dealt with elsewhere by the ex-Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan, and therefore I do not propose to deal with it again now. That was not the reason given by the Minister when introducing his Budget last year. He went much further than that. He talked about the large-scale consumption and about the serious deficit in our balance of payments. The reasons which he gave for bringing in the type of Budget which he introduced last year were the serious state into which our economy had got and the urgent necessity for doing something about the deficit in our balance of payments.
I should like to point out to the House again—as I have had occasionto do before—that the Government's view of the balance of payments was incorrect. The crisis which they believed existed did not exist. The Budget which was introduced last year was introduced because of faulty understanding of the economic situation of our country. At the time the Budget was introduced—and before, and since—the Minister and his colleagues have spoken of the alleged serious condition of our sterling holdings which had resulted in the deficits in the balance of payments over a number of years. Time and time again, and in the Budget debates last year, we have pointed out that deficits in the balance of payments do not necessarily mean a drawing-down of our sterling holdings and that because, from 1947 to 1951, there were deficits in the balance of payments amounting to £156.5 million, it did not mean that there would be a reduction of £156.5 million in our sterling holdings. In my opinion, the Government worked on the assumption that because there were these deficits which, we knew, were large, this country was losing its sterling holdings. Some Deputies—if not some Ministers—said that the political independence of this State was at stake.
Comment on this
Nobody is denying that. They were not drawn down by £156,000,000—as the Minister led the House and the country to assume. We have never denied that the question of the balance of payments is a problem but we think it is a lesser problem than some other problems. We said that we would give priority to full employment and to schemes of capital development and we said that the question of the balance of paymentswould right itself in time. We have plenty of time in which to build up our capital assets.
In fact, during those five years when there was a deficit in the balance of payments amounting to £56.5 million, there was an inflow of sterling into this country amounting to £66,000,000. There was the American loan of £45.6 million, and those large deficits, over those of 1951, were financed to the extent of £38.9 million only by drawing upon our sterling holdings. We have at the present time, in the form of sterling assets in England, a sum which it is not possible to gauge accurately, but which is certainly over £400,000,000 and may be over £500,000,000.
As I say, I regard the reason for the introduction of the Budget of last year as one designed to remedy a balance of payments situation, a situation which, I think, was wrongly presented to the Dáil and to the country by the Minister, a situation which was not critical, a situation which we said, and which events have proved to be right, would remedy itself in the course of time.
When the Minister introduced his Budget in April of last year, he said that there could be no hope, on the figures available to him then, of an expansion in our exports and that we had to reduce our imports. I wish to accuse the Minister of going the very worst possible way about reducing our imports. He reduced them by a simple financial device, by a device which was adopted in other countries —by England, Denmark, Canada and Australia and by many European countries which had a balance of payments problem—the device of mopping up surplus purchasing power, and in that the Minister was eminently successful. He was successful in mopping up purchasing power so that there was less demand for imports last year than there was the year before. If the Minister wished to reduce imports he could have introduced a system of licences or physical controls, but, instead, he adopted this financial mechanism of reducing purchasing power in the State so that imports in every category were reduced.
We have the fact that, of the reduction in imports last year over the year before, of £32.4 million, over half of that—£16.3 million— represented materials for industry. All classes of imports, not merely consumer goods, were reduced. We had reductions in materials for agriculture, reductions in capital equipment, reductions in materials for industry. In fact, all classes of imports were reduced because of this faulty diagnosis of our economic situation.
The effects, of course, of that policy which the Minister adopted—a policy which, as I say, the inter-Party Government realised could have been a simple one, if adopted, because it was adopted in other countries with similar results—was that consumption was reduced and effectively reduced in this State. It also did other things as well. It put up the cost of living between May, 1952, and August, 1952, by 7 per cent. The cost of living in May, 1952, had gone up by 14 per cent. Seven per cent., or half of that increase, went up between May and August of last year after the reduction of the food subsidies.
Industrial production has also been affected. Industrial production between the quarter ending September, 1951, and the quarter ending September, 1952, decreased by 12 per cent. I do not think one would need to have the eyes of a prophet to be able to say that production, since September of last year, has again decreased. The effect on industry and employment was, of course, that on 28th February, this year, we had 89,000 unemployed; on 21st February, a week before, the number of unemployed was 88,000. The figure for unemployment a year before that was 73,000, and two years before that, when the inter-Party Government were in office, the figure was 63,000. The number of unemployed has increased between February, 1951, and February of this year by 26,000. That, of course, was the natural result of the financial policy of the Government in reducing spending and reducing effective demand in the State so that less goods could be bought.
It has already been pointed out in the Dáil what the Government got, and what they paid for this financial policy. The Government got, as a result of cutting the food subsidies, an estimated sum of £6.6 million. Then they increased social welfare benefits and the net saving was £3.9 million. Therefore, they brought into the Exchequer last year an estimated—the estimate, of course, is one which we do not accept—£3.9 million. What was the economic, social and human payment for that £3.9 million? An increase in the cost of living by 7 per cent., a falling off in demand, a rise in unemployment and, above all, a rise in the costs structure of the State, due to necessary wage adjustments which had to be made as a result of the policy of deliberately increasing the cost of living. The wages in many sectors, but by no means in all sectors, of the community have been increased.
There has also been the deficit in C.I.E., due to the cutting of the food subsidies which necessitated an increase in wages. The deficit in C.I.E. was increased this year, so that you had the paradoxical situation of the Government, having allegedly saved on food subsidies, coming a few months later to the Dáil and asking for a much larger sum to meet the deficit on C.I.E. That deficit, as I say, was the result of cutting the food subsidies. There was also the necessity to increase the Vote for the Department of Health because of the increased cost of health services, due to the increased cost of food and the increase in wages.
You also have the fact that agricultural costs and agricultural prices have gone up, so that we are very near the position now when we will be pricing ourselves out of the world markets, and all for £3.9 million. That was the financial policy of the Government. Those were some of the results which that financial policy brought in its wake.
I would like to say this to the Minister: When he is framing his Budget this year, I would ask him to forget about the balance of payments problem, for a few years at any rate. I would ask him to concentrate on theunemployed. I would ask him to concentrate on trying to bring about a return to, at any rate, the 1951 figures. I would ask him to try to initiate a policy by which the State would contribute to bringing about a position of full employment. I would ask him to try to see how he can increase business activity in the State by means of alterations in the tax structure. I would ask him to see what means he would take in his Budget for stimulating investment, both governmental and in the private sector of the economy.
We have shown the way. The Opposition has demonstrated in its speeches the concrete proposals of policy which it believes should be put into operation to remedy the situation. We will not object if the Minister takes over that policy lock, stock and barrel, if it is going to improve this country. We will not object if the Government takes over our policy as long as it will bring remedial measures. If they do not take it over, I would ask them to let us take over Government instead.
Maybe the Government will have learned some lessons from the last year and a half. Maybe they will have learned the lesson that you cannot have a policy designed to reduce consumption and have full employment at the same time; that you cannot have an equilibrium in the balance of payments and a policy of repatriation of sterling assets at the same time; that you cannot deliberately bring about a rise in the cost of living without creating wage demands and setting up a cost inflation in the country; that you cannot borrow at 5 per cent. and increase the rate of Government borrowing by 1½ per cent. without raising the rents of the persons who wish to purchase their houses under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act.
The Government might also have learned, not from the economic scene but from the political scene, that you cannot go to the country any more with the old shibboleths; that the banners and slogans of 20 years ago have become a bit tattered and a bit weak, and that the people are now judgingGovernments on what they do and the results of their policy and not by what they say. I think the Government have probably learned that lesson and that is the reason why we are not having a general election this year.
Comment on this
I am watching carefully the development of Deputy Declan Costello as a politician in this House. He is certainly getting a tolerable grip of financial jargon which I am sure will be appreciated after recent events in his constituency.
There are several schools of financial thought but we have, as it were, two schools of financial thought—the official financial thought as advised to the Minister for Finance for the time being and the other type of financial thought advised to Deputy Costello, Senior, and Deputy Costello, Junior, by another side or by some person who did represent another side in the same Department. I do not think it matters an awful lot; I do not think it helps in any way to solve the problems that face us if we are simply going to consider them on the basis of financial jargon.
Comment on this
The Vote on Account gives us an opportunity of looking into policy and of considering what the results are and what they are likely to be. I propose to confine the few remarks I have to make to that consideration. The Vote gives us an opportunity also to consider the motion moved by Deputy Sheldon and which is generally welcomed by the House as something that will assist in the machinery of parliamentary control over expenditure. The motion has great advantages and I do not think anyone except Deputy Dillon considers that it was moved for the purpose of enabling the Government to escape a full consideration of their financial policy.
I have not only listened to but I have read very carefully the speeches that were made here by leading Deputies of the Fine Gael Party. I have read carefully the speeches of Deputy John A. Costello, Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Higgins, Junior. It surprised me to find that there is not one constructive suggestion within the whole volume of the debates covering their speeches.
An opportunity was availed of by Deputy Dillon to make his usual personal attack on myself and a number of Deputies. I can only speak for myself. In view of the fact that this attack has been repeated in this debate by Deputy Dillon, I want to make my own position as clear as I can.
I wanted a Social Welfare Bill, a Bill that would increase old age pensions, that would provide for increased children's allowances, that would provide for increased allowances for the sick and generally for the people who are unable to fend for themselves. That Bill is now law, is now in operation and under that Bill, many more people are entitled to unemployment insurance and unemployment assistance than were entitled to these allowances before the Bill became law.
I wanted an Adoption Bill. The present Government introduced an Adoption Bill and passed it into law. It is now in operation and funds have already been provided by the House for it. I wanted a Health Bill, and we have before the House a Bill introduced by the Minister for Health which does not go as far as I should like it to go, but at least it is a Bill before the House for discussion. I wanted to see provision made for our congested areas, for our undeveloped areas and for the Gaeltacht areas and these provisions have already been made by this House. Those are beneficial results which have arisen from the Administration which has been in power for the past couple of years, an Administration for whom I deliberately voted when the change of Government occurred in 1951.
There were other reasons at the time why a change of Government wasnecessary. Any Government that operates in this country must operate in a constitutional way and under and in accordance with the Constitution. If a Government are to act responsibly there should be only one head of that Government and that is the Taoiseach. During the last days of the inter-Party Government we had a position of gross irregularity and disorder where one Minister of the Government took upon himself to order or command another Minister to resign from the Government.
Comment on this
With all respect, it is relevant to the attacks which have been made on me by Deputy Dillon and other Deputies in the course of this debate.
Comment on this
The Deputy has now made it quite clear that he is responsible for everything the Government have done.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon was informed that attacks on Deputies were not relevant to the debate.
Comment on this
There has been an appeal made to the Government by every Opposition Deputy to have a general election, to resign and let them take over. If they took over, the case is made that we would have more stable financial conditions. I want to assert and to establish that if we were to have a return to the form of Government we had in the last couple of months before the change of Government we could not have order nor progress nor stability.
Comment on this
I happened to be in the position of helping to decide it. It was my responsibility to help to decide it and I decided in what I considered was the right way. Deputy Morrissey knows very well that a Government, like a house, divided against itself, cannot stand. DeputyMorrissey would not for one moment endeavour to arrogate to himself the right to dismiss any other Minister from a Government of which he was a member.
Comment on this
That was the sort of Government we had in the last couple of months of the inter-Party regime.
Comment on this
A Minister arrogating to himself the right to dismiss another Minister from the Government——
Comment on this
That does not arise on the Vote on Account. The question is the general financial policy of the Government during the past 12 months.
Comment on this
How could any Government have any financial or other policy when it was divided against itself in such a way? That is what the House is being asked to do and what the country is being asked to do—to replace the present Government by a Government that will operate in that way.
Comment on this
That is the very point I am dealing with. As DeputyMorrissey well knows, for reasons which I explained in this House, I decided to withdraw my support from the inter-Party Government. I said it deliberately and definitely, from the very seat from which I am now speaking, prior to the dissolution of the Dáil and to the general election, and I asked the people to vote for me because I was standing by certain principles which the inter-Party Government had refused to honour. How any person in his sane senses could imagine that by putting that proposal before my constituents I would vote for the inter-Party Government to come back into office is something I cannot understand. It is unfair and shameful to suggest that I was elected to do one thing and that I did the other thing after having been elected. No person could put his position more clearly or more definitely, and I am glad to know that the step I took in voting for the change of Government had the support of my constituents.
Comment on this
There was another reason. The financial position then, as it is now, was grave and serious. The national position was in jeopardy.
Comment on this
Money was needed to run the country. Would the decision to increase taxes have been taken, or would money have been borrowed from some source outside the country for the purpose of running the country, and, if borrowed from outside the country, what would we tender in exchange for it? I felt then, and I said it in this House, that there was danger to the freedom and the liberty of the people of this country. I believe still that there is danger to the freedom and the liberty of the people if this country will not pay its own way. When I opposed the decision of this House to accept Marshall Aid money, I stated that this was not a beggar or a mendicant nation. I repeat those words: it is not a beggar or a mendicant nation. If this country is to be run successfullyand satisfactorily and in the interests of the people, then whatever moneys are necessary to run the country must be put up and contributed by the people and by nobody else.
Certain drastic steps had to be taken last year to provide the finances necessary to run the State and to avoid danger to our freedom and our independence. Nobody liked those drastic steps. Least of all did I, as an Independent Deputy, like those steps. I would have much preferred it had there been no necessity for the imposition of these extra taxes and for the collection of these extra moneys, but as an Independent Deputy, I had to act with a sense of responsibility and I acted with a sense of responsibility by supporting the imposition of every one of these extra taxes, however unpopular that imposition might be and even if my support of it might result in my defeat at the next election. That responsibility was thrown upon me by events. I could not act in the irresponsible way in which Deputies who call themselves Independent have acted from time to time, clamouring on the one hand for increased expenditure under every conceivable head and, on the other hand, clamouring for a reduction of taxation on every score.
When people come to consider this particular aspect of our nation's history there will be a sense of appreciation, I think, of the responsible attitude taken here by the four or five Independent Deputies who have been abused on so many occasions by the Opposition Deputies. Every Deputy should act with a sense of responsibility. Overriding everything as far as I was concerned was my desire that this country should maintain its freedom, its independence and its integrity. I think we have succeeded in achieving that.
In the course of his speech Deputy Dillon referred to the state of Newfoundland. He held up that country as a parallel for Ireland. If there is any parallel between Newfoundland and Ireland it is the parallel that was there before these drastic steps were taken last year in order to ensure that this country would not go the way Newfoundlandhas gone. Deputy Dillon was apparently unable to see the analogy in the examples he himself put forward. Deputy Dillon and others want us to exhaust our domestic resources and our foreign resources so that we will find ourselves in the position of Newfoundland and will have to beseech some neighbour to take control of us.
Comment on this
This is what he said at column 289 of Volume 137 of the Official Report:—
"Newfoundland woke one morning to discover that, by the dissipation of its resources on irrelevancies, its great fishing industry had become inefficient and uneconomic. Having exhausted every domestic resource, a deputation went to London to ask the British Treasury to accept Newfoundland as a temporary charge. The price they paid was that the Treasury in London named their Government."
Is not that the real parallel? Is not that the parallel that would exist between this country and its neighbour if we were to dissipate our resources rather than make an effort to live within our resources? I do not know whether Deputy Dillon gave thought to this matter or whether it just blew up while he happened to be speaking but, in addition to referring to the position of Newfoundland, he referred very specifically to the position of this country, and what he said does not make very cheerful reading for Deputy Morrissey or for anybody else in the Fine Gael Party or in any other Party. What was his story? This country was down and out. That is the picture he tried to paint. He said we had nothing to exist on except our agricultural production and our agricultural exports. What has he to say about them? I will take them heading by heading.
Butter: We are not exporting butterbecause we are no longer able economically to produce butter in Ireland.
"We cannot sell butter abroad because our costs of production for butter are too high. We will never sell butter abroad—never."
That is what this famous agricultural expert says about butter. But, in case there might be some mistake, he goes further. He says:—
"The concrete fact is that we cannot export butter and that we will never export it again... The export of eggs has become un-economic... The export of fowl has become uneconomic... The export of bacon... and pork is just in the balance. If the costs of production in that branch of the agricultural industry go up by another 5 per cent., the pig population of this country will melt away. Stop and think a moment what this means. It means that you are left with cattle and sheep. There is not a farmer in this House who does not know that, during the war, the sheep population of this country vanished from the face of this country through a complexity of circumstances. I am not going to go into those circumstances now, but I think they could easily recur and, if they should, you are driven back to cattle. Stop there, and think a moment."
Butter, eggs, fowl, sheep, bacon, pork; no hope for this country in any one of those lines and we are left then with cattle. We are left with nothing but cattle to live on and nothing but cattle to depend on. How does Deputy Dillon deal with cattle:—
"We are out of the United States market for prime beef—and we are out of it by competition. We cannot produce it in Ireland at a price the Americans are prepared to pay."
He then goes on to the 1948 Agreement and this is all that we are left with, this proud nation to which Deputy Dillon refers:—
"By the mercy of God's providence we have the 1948 TradeAgreement to fall back upon. We have the other party to that agreement in a vice from which they cannot escape—not thanks to Fianna Fáil but thanks to our Government."
Then he makes this extraordinary statement at column 289 of the same volume:—
"There is not a Deputy in this House who does not know that all that stands between the live-stock industry of this country and crisis is the trade agreement we made in 1948 which holds the other party as no agreement between two nations of such disparity in power ever held a second party before."
Then we have the final and general summing up: "If costs should further rise, agricultural exports from Ireland will decline." That is rather an anticlimax but nevertheless it is what Deputy Dillon has said. Deputy Dillon, of the Fine Gael Party, has said that there is no hope for this country, that we are on the way of Newfoundland, that we are on the way out as a nation. I want to know is there any sensible Deputy or any sensible person in this country who would put back into office a Deputy who holds those views in regard to our capacity, our capability and our agricultural position?
It is not nice to have to read those things but it is just as well they should be read, studied and understood. When we are up against that sort of thing we find how nonsensical is the financial jargon we hear from Deputy Costello, Senior, and Deputy Costello, Junior. Does Deputy Morrissey believe that is the true position in Ireland? Does Deputy Morrissey believe that Deputy Dillon is painting a correct picture of this country? Does Deputy Morrissey think this country is down and out as Deputy Dillon suggests in that speech? Those are the views of Deputy Dillon in regard to agriculture. Does Deputy Morrissey think he should ever be invested with the responsibility of guiding the agricultural destinies in the future? Deputy Morrissey is silent.
Comment on this
I hope Deputy Dillon does not represent the views of Deputy Morrissey. I know he could not represent those views. It is very hard to know where one is——
Comment on this
——when listening to the speeches we have in this House. As a student of politics, I should like to know what Parties exist here, who lead them, and what their policy and objective are. Broadly speaking, the set-up is, the Fianna Fáil Party are the Government, and they are supported in office by a group of Independent Deputies. We have other Parties in the House. There is the Fine Gael Party, which, I understood, was led by Deputy Mulcahy. We have the Clann na Poblachta Party.
Comment on this
I assume I will be in order when I am called upon—and I hope to follow Deputy Cowan—in continuing this line?
Comment on this
I know what the Minister thinks about Deputy Cowan or rather what he did think and could never say.
Comment on this
I do not give two hoots what anybody thinks about me. I am putting forward this position and Deputy Morrissey, with long experience of throwing the neophyte out of his stride, will not succeed now. As I say, we have to understand where we are. We have the Labour Party and the Clann na Talmhan Party. Then we have certain other people who support those Parties in a general way. However, in this debate I read andlistened to the speech that was delivered by Deputy O'Higgins. Deputy O'Higgins made this very specific statement at column 352 of the same volume quoted above:
"The only Party in this House which has consistently followed, in Government and out of Government, the same financial and economic policy has been the Fine Gael Party, led by Deputy Costello, the Leader of the Opposition."
I just want to know where I am? Is Deputy Costello the Leader of Fine Gael? Is he the Leader of the Opposition? Does he lead the Labour Party? Does he lead the Clann na Talmhan Party or the Clann na Poblachta Party?
Comment on this
Yes, Sir, it has. Deputy Costello, who was followed on the same lines by Deputy Dillon, has said to the Government: "Get out. Your policy in this Book of Estimates is not a wise policy for the country. Get out and let us take over."
Comment on this
You should hear what the people outside are saying and they are not bound by parliamentary language.
Comment on this
I want to know where we are. Who wants the people to vote for whom? Is Deputy Costello saying that he is asking the people to vote for another Government in which there will be members of the Labour Party, members of the Clann na Talmhan Party, members of the Clann na Poblachta Party and members of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
I submit, with respect, Sir, that that is perfectly relevant to this discussion. If this Vote has been availed of to ask for a change of Government, who wants to take over?
Comment on this
There is a very big bluff being carried on and nobody knows that better than Deputy Morrissey.
Comment on this
There is a big bluff being carried on by Deputy Costello, Senior, Deputy Dillon and other members of the Fine Gael Party, who suggest that if there were an election to-morrow and if there were an increased number of seats for Fine Gael, Labour, Clann na Talmhan and Clann na Poblachta, Fine Gael could again form an inter-Party Government and could run this country. Deputy Morrissey knows that nobody can give any such guarantee.
Comment on this
The constitutional responsibility rests on one man and he will decide for an election at the time he thinks it will suit Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
There is no doubt about that and if Deputy Morrissey were Taoiseach he would hold an election at the time he would think would best suit himself.
Comment on this
It is not, and I think I can say with certainty, thatthere is no likelihood of a general election this year or next year.
Comment on this
Reading Deputy Dillon, one is inclined to become pessimistic, but when I read the Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates that were before us, I think I can come to the conclusion that, although every necessary precaution must be taken to avoid danger that might damage this country, the Minister for Finance is in a better position this year than he was in last year. Consequently, there are some rays of hope appearing from a study of the Book of Estimates, Supplementary Estimates, the Budget and other statements that have been made in regard to it. While there is this ray of hope, it is possible, I think, for the Minister this year to make certain concessions that will be welcomed by the public. As has been stated by the Taoiseach and Ministers, we seem to have reached the limit of taxation or, as the Minister for Finance said, the limit that the people will cheerfully bear. If the stringent steps taken last year will result in measures of relief this year, then I think we have a lot to be grateful for and a lot to be thankful for.
If, as I see it, there can be reliefs, I would suggest to the Minister and to the Government that there is no better way in which relief can be granted than in a provision for the award of the arbitration board that considered Civil Service salaries. There are many thousands of civil servants, whom we all know, living on rates of pay that are entirely inadequate. They have been living on these rates of pay for many years. Studying the award of the arbitration board, I felt that it was not a very generous award. There was nothing extravagant in it, and I feel that Governments are in the same position as anybody else. If Governments agree to enter into arbitration, then Governments are bound to accept the award of the arbitration board concerned.I have not fully convinced myself that arbitration is the best machinery that should be available for a determination of matters between the Government and the officers of the Government. I think that is a matter that requires much more consideration than it has got up to the present but, once the principle of arbitration has been accepted, once the machinery of arbitration has been adopted, then the findings of that arbitration should be honoured.
I said in this House before, a couple of weeks ago, in connection I think with the debate on the National Stud, that in my opinion the award of the arbitration board would be honoured. That is on record in the Official Debates in this House. At that time I was challenged by Deputy O'Higgins, who said that I might be called on to vote on that issue. It is surprising that no motion in regard to it was put down by Deputy O'Higgins or by any member of the Fine Gael Party, although I did understand that when the Tánaiste stated he was prepared to allow time for discussion of the matter, if the principal Opposition so wished, Deputy Dillon, apologising for staff upsets due to illness, said the matter would be considered. I am sure it has been considered but, while there has been a certain amount of sniping with regard to it, there has been no positive declaration by the Fine Gael Party that they want this arbitration award honoured, nor has there been any desire on their part to ask this House to request the Government to honour that award.
I understand that under the machinery of arbitration the Government had a period of three months to consider it, after which they must publish the findings of the tribunal and the Government, as I did say in the debate I referred to—if it was not in that debate I said it about the same time in some other debate—availed of every minute and every second that was set out in the machinery there before they published the award. They availed also of the second part of the machinery that apparently was agreed upon between the Civil Service andthe Government. That was that if the Government were unable without the introduction of a special Budget or a Supplementary Budget to honour the award, if they accepted it, the matter would be dealt with under the next Budget. I understand that is the precise agreement that exists—in other words, that the Government were entitled to say: "We could not honour this award now without introducing a Supplementary Budget, and rather than introduce a Supplementary Budget in the month of March we shall deal with the matter in the annual Budget which comes before the House in the month of April or May, as the case may be." I do not think that is an unreasonable attitude on the part of the Government, because it is within the machinery of the arbitration and nobody in this State understands better than civil servants themselves the meaning of words and the meaning of agreements.
To some extent, the matter has been confused by deputations and by interviews. I have been asked to receive deputations. I have said that I will receive any deputation that comes to see me in regard to it. It should have been obvious to anyone, writing such a request to me, that there was no necessity to see me on a matter of this kind. The arbitration award provides for certain specific increases to civil servants and it provides that these increases are to be paid from a certain date. Once the Government agreed to accept the principle of arbitration, once they agreed to accept the machinery of arbitration, I say that they are bound in honour to honour the award in all its implications including the back-dating to the specific date that was mentioned by the tribunal. I do not want any misunderstanding as to my position in relation to a matter of this kind.
Deputy Cogan has referred to the Socialist State and to the welfare State. These are matters which, perhaps, could well be the subject of consideration by Deputies of this House. As I see it, we have two main Parties here: they are the two main political Parties. Both of them believe in thesame system of Government. Neither of them is a Socialist Party though, in my opinion, one is more socialist than the other. We have very serious matters affecting us with regard to production and with regard to other matters of importance. I have put this before to Deputy Giles and to other Deputies—and I could put the same question to members on the Fianna Fáil Benches and I would get the same answer. There is no desire on the part of either of these Parties to have compulsion. In other words, there is no desire on either side of the House to compel farmers to grow more than they choose to grow at the moment and there is no compulsion on workers to work more than they say, within their own trade union organisations, they will work. Taking it by and large, that is the position.
Then we have these interminable conflicts in regard to which side of the House will get the farmers to produce more—and it all boils down to the question of which side of the House will pay the farmers most for producing more. Does anybody disagree that that, in fact, is the position? That can only be the position when you have two Parties—one in Government and the other, the main Opposition Party, operating under the same system. That can only be the position with both of them appealing for votes from the farmers when the only solution that each of them has is to give the farmer more to induce him to produce more. You will never get anywhere under such a system. One of our great troubles is that we have not a very clean-cut division between the people who believe in the present capitalist system and the people who believe in a socialist system.
Comment on this
I am coming to that. Deputy Giles knows well what I believe in. He will never have any doubt about that. Generally, when I express my mind I express it in such a way that there is no doubt as to what I mean. We have two mainpolitical Parties and each trying to gain more support in exactly the same way. There must be an end to that. It just cannot continue. This bidding by two political Parties, one against the other, with the people's money by giving better provisions to this section, to that section and to the other section, for the purpose of getting more votes and more support must come to an end. The farmers have a responsibility to this State and every other section and interest in the State have a responsibility to the State.
I came to the conclusion many years ago—and I have seen no reason to alter my views since—that this State or any other State cannot successfully be administered in modern times unless the State has the power to compel. If the State has not the power to compel farmers to grow more or to compel workers to work more then it has lost very vital powers which it ought to have. I have, as I do very often, resort to the writings of James Connolly for inspiration. In a book entitled Labour, Nationality and Religionthere occurs the following paragraph in which one will see what I believe. This is what James Connolly wrote as the last paragraph of this book—and Connolly was able to see very far in front of him:—
"The day has passed for patching up the capitalist system; it must go. And in the work of abolishing it the Catholic and the Protestant, the Catholic and the Jew, the Catholic and the Freethinker, the Catholic and the Buddhist, the Catholic and the Mahometan will co-operate together, knowing no rivalry but the rivalry of endeavour toward an end beneficial to all. For, as we have said elsewhere, Socialism is neither Protestant nor Catholic, Christian nor Freethinker, Buddhist, Mahometan, nor Jew; it is only human. We of the socialist working class realise that as we suffer together we must work together that we may enjoy together. We reject the firebrand of capitalist warfare and offer you the olive leaf of brotherhood and justice to and for all."
Lest there should be any doubt in anyone's mind, I believe in a system ofSocialism for this State and for every State in the world. I believe that it is only under a system of Socialism that you can have ordered progress and prosperity. I believe, with Connolly, that you cannot patch up the capitalist system, and what we really have here are the efforts of the two main Parties, each one trying to patch it up a little better than the other.
The day is past for patching up the capitalist system. "It must go." Those were the words of James Connolly, and in years to come the people of this country will realise the soundness of the advice that was given to them by James Connolly. I only wish that there were in this House more socialists than myself. May I appeal to my friends in the Labour Party to get back to the inspiration of James Connolly?
Comment on this
I am not interested in Deputy Cogan on this. I would appeal to the Labour Party to endeavour to find inspiration in the writings of Connolly. If they do that, then I think some of the difficulties which confront the country will pass quickly enough.
Comment on this
——and I will do the Deputy the credit of saying, a very dishonest speech up to the last five minutes.
Comment on this
Three definite statements, and only three, emerged from the Deputy's speech. The Deputy has nailed his flag to the mast, giving gladness to the heart of the Minister for Finance or rather gladness to the heart of Deputy Seán MacEntee. If that cloak is not purple it is pink. When I imagine the letters which Deputy MacEntee could write to the Evening Mailon the material which has now been put into his hands by Deputy Cowan, it is another reason why I am sorry he is Minister for Finance and is deprived of that pleasure, because he only remains Minister for Finance during the pleasure of Deputy Peadar Cowan. The three statements of Deputy Cowan were: (1) the power to compel the farmer to produce what and as much as Deputy Cowan thinks he should produce—Deputy Cogan was feeling quite happy on that—(2) the power to compel the worker to work for as long as Deputy Cowan thinks he should work, (3) the power and the intention— I propose in a moment or two to show, according to Deputy Cowan himself, that this is a power which he boasts of —to smash in this country what he is pleased to call capitalism.
Comment on this
That is too old a trick, and the Deputy should remember that he is not now in the District Court, but in Dáil Éireann.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not say that Deputy Kyne and Deputy Everett are very queer and yet they were with him when he was vice-chairman of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
For a quarter of a century I have been trying to advise the Minister to have a bit of sense. It is I, I suppose, who ought to have the sense, and know that it is futile to try to teach him even at this late hour. This, of course, is an old trick of Deputy Cowan's and of DeputyMacEntee's. Both know what I am coming to, particularly Deputy MacEntee—that the threat is to destroy what is called capitalism.
Comment on this
What is called capitalism in this State to-day is very different indeed from what it was at the time Connolly wrote those words.
Comment on this
Unlike Deputy Cowan this is not the first time that I heard, or read, what was written in that book. What Deputy Cowan means in effect and, in truth, is having the intention and desire, if he ever has the power, to destroy private enterprise in this country. That is what he means when he talks about capitalism.
Comment on this
The Minister should keep out of this. I have—I knew the Minister would be here—some cuttings from letters which the Minister wrote to the Evening Mail.
Comment on this
It would be better if, on all sides, Deputy Morrissey was allowed to make his speech without interruption.
Comment on this
I always get the measure of my effectiveness by the reactions I get from Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Cowan. These are the desires of Deputy Cowan: compulsion for the farmer, compulsion for the worker and the destruction of private enterprise. That is his creed which he has avowed here openly and unashamedly. Mind you, Deputy Cowan is perfectly entitled to say that.
Comment on this
You went a littlefurther, I think, than Deputy Dr. Browne did in Trinity College the other night.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan told us that the reason why he was supporting Fianna Fáil, and was continuing to support it, was because he wanted the public health scheme, and that Fianna Fáil produced it. He wanted higher old age pensions, higher national health insurance and higher unemployment assistance, and he says "I got them."
Comment on this
Look at the power behind the throne! He wanted a Legal Adoption Act and he says "I got it".
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan did it and Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll had nothing to do with it, and neither had the 66 members of the Fianna Fáil Party. Deputy Cowan on his own did it. Is it not a sad state of affairs that the people who boast of having the biggest single political Party in this country have now descended to the level that the two chief spokesmen for it on all occasions and on every occasion in this House are Deputy Cowan and Deputy Cogan and that the members of that Party sit there in silence?
How the Minister for Finance must be bubbling over. I can imagine some of the sentences, some of the phrases that he is turning over in his mind, and how he would glory in being free to use them. He used a couple in Liverpool last night but they were nothing to the ones he could use about Deputy Cowan if and when he gets free, and it may be very soon notwithstanding what Deputy Cowan has said. When that day comes I am going to sit back and enjoy the performance.
Comment on this
The Deputy succeeded in speaking for a long time. When he rose to speak, I said to Deputy Declan Costello, who was sitting behind me: "I will make a small bet with you, Declan. It is that there are three matters which Deputy Cowan will not refer to in any way whatever. He will make no reference to the Vote on Account; he will certainly make no reference to unemployment, and I am absolutely positive that he will never mention the words ‘cost of living.'" And he did not, not even by implication. Deputy Cowan talked about everything under the sun except the things that really matter. Then, at the tail-end of his speech, in a way which, frankly, I believed would be beneath Deputy Cowan, he tried, in the most petty and cheap way that I have ever heard, to cash in on the civil servants and the arbitration award. That will not deceive anyone for a moment.
Comment on this
He then taunted this side of the House for not putting down a motion on the matter. For what purpose? To give the Deputy the pleasure of doing what he has done on previous occasions: of speaking in favour of it and voting against it.
Comment on this
On a point of order. If such a suggestion is made by a Deputy, that a Deputy in this House spoke against a motion and voted for it——
Comment on this
——or the reverse, spoke for it and voted against it, I submit, with respect, that the records and the occasion should be referred to.
Comment on this
I will not. I will produce it when it suits me and neither the Deputy nor anybody else can compel me to do so.
Comment on this
You would not know anything about those things. Deputy Cowan is low enough at the moment but he is not so low, as defenceless, as to want your assistance.
Comment on this
Old antagonists. I will not say we are enemies and perhaps we might be nearer to being friends. I would not say I would be an enemy even of Deputy Cowan's. Perhaps I have a good deal more respect for his capacity and ability than most people in this House.
Comment on this
I am respectfully suggesting, Sir, that I am infinitely nearer to the Vote on Account, and I have been speaking for only ten minutes, than Deputy Cowan was for three-quarters of an hour and I suggest, with respect, that I am entitled, not merely to traverse what Deputy Cowan said, but to refer to the matters which he has carefully left unsaid. The Deputygave us here at length what he alleged were his reasons for supporting the present Government and what he alleged were his reasons for not supporting anybody in opposition to them.
Comment on this
What I want to refer to now Deputy Burke does not want to hear any more than Deputy Cowan. I want to refer to the cost of living. I want to refer to the effects of the Budget. Deputy Cowan said he supported every tax that was imposed in the Budget. He asserted that proudly, as a boast. Remember, when we are talking about the cost-of-living index, we are talking about the cost of essential items. Deputy Cogan told us the other day that the cost of living had increased as much in the period of office of the inter-Party Government as it has since the present Government took over. That is not true, of course. Deputy Cowan said it was fifty-fifty. Take it even on the percentage increase.
Comment on this
I know you did not. I reminded you that you did not although you wanted me to be brought out of a hospital bed to answer for the cost of living when it was 25 per cent. less than it is now. I am talking about your political pal, Deputy Cogan. When I look at Deputy Cogan and Deputy Cowan I have to agree with the old saying that politics make strange bedfellows. I can see Deputy Cogan subscribing to the James Connollys. Let me get back to the cost of living.
Comment on this
The Minister does not want to hear about it either. Deputy Cogan says that the cost of living has increased by 23 per cent.— 14 per cent. on essential items. DeputyCogan said, of course, it increased but that we were more to blame than the present Government, we increased it more. Who increased the price of bread and flour by 50 per cent.?
Comment on this
Who increased the price of butter from 2/8 to 4/2 a lb.? Who increased the price of tea from 2/8? Do Deputies want me to go down through any more items? When I heard Deputy Cowan talking to-day with a throb in his voice, or rather a whine, about the road workers and the forestry workers whom he is so fond of chumming with at the side of the road when, as he said himself, they are partaking of their meagre meal in the middle of the day——
Comment on this
No. Deputy Cogan. I would be long sorry to accuse Deputy Cowan of that. Whatever I may say about you, you do not whine. Deputy Cogan was telling us about it. He saw those unfortunate working men in the days when the inter-Party Government were in office and there was very little of what they had and very little substance. Deputy Cogan is perfectly satisfied that they are better off to-day I challenge Deputy Cogan—and he will very soon get the opportunity—to stand up in Wicklow and tell the working men there that they are better off to-day than they were two years ago. I challenge Deputy Cogan to get up in Wicklow and assert, as he asserted on this Vote here to-day, that in fact since Fianna Fáil took over, the standard of living has improved. There is no man in this House or outside it who, if he spoke his real mind, could rend Deputy Cogan on those statements more quickly and more effectively than his present political colleague, Deputy Cowan.
Deputy Cowan, whatever else he may pretend here, is not ignorant of the conditions in this city, or he ought not to be. He is not ignorant of the fact that business in this city and in this country since this Government took over, and particularly since the Budget, has hit a very low level. Heis not unconscious of the fact that there have been wholesale dismissals and wholesale reductions in staff, giving us a registered number of over 90,000 unemployed. Unless he has his head in the sand he is not unfamiliar with the fact that there are thousands of other workers who were on full time and many of them on overtime who are now on short time and living in fear of being dismissed completely.
Will Deputies read the annual reports of some of the public companies operating in this country as to the results of their trading over the last 12 years? In the case of one of the most important companies in this country their profits for last year's trading dropped from £194,000 to something over £50,000.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton was telling us they were making too heavy profits. He wanted to put them in jail.
Comment on this
It is a free country, Sir, and if the Minister or Deputy Burke wants to make an ignorant and unintelligent interruption I suppose even you cannot stop him, with all the powers you have.
Comment on this
They are making enough of them elsewhere. They can be checked and brought to account here, but when they get outside there is nobody to check them. Sometimes when you hear them making interjections you would imagine they thought they were outside at a cross-road.
Comment on this
We were always able to stand at the cross-road and the highroad and we will stand at the cross-roads in Wicklow.
Comment on this
I hope the Deputy will take notice of what the Chair is saying and Deputy Everett as well.
Comment on this
It is not that they are so much annoyed but that they are coming to realise exactly where they are. They are coming to realise what they started one and a half years ago. The Minister for Finance has now before him in a rather unpleasant way some of the results of the careless and irresponsible speeches which he and his colleague, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, made which created an artificial crisis in this country. In this country to-day we have depression in business; we have 90,000 unemployed and the number growing at the rate of nearly 1,000 per week; we have the highest cost of living ever reached in this country, and all that is due entirely to the fact that the Minister who introduced this Vote on Account went out deliberately and, unfortunately, succeeded in destroying the faith and the confidence of the people in the future of this country, in creating a feeling of uneasiness that amounted almost to fear, and in some cases to actual fear. He has brought about a state of affairs now that neither he nor his colleagues, with or without the assistance of Deputy Cogan and Deputy Cowan, can check.
It is all right for Deputy Burke to talk about the cross-roads. It is all right for the Minister for Finance to make silly interjections to me across the floor of the House. It is all right for Deputy Cowan to posture for three quarters of an hour. But that is little consolation to 90,000 persons lining up at the labour exchanges. The Minister may or may not be able to balance his Budget in a month's time, but there are thousands of families in this country to-day that as a result of last year's Budget and the policy pursued by the Party opposite will be unable to balance their budget in their homes.
Deputies who are in touch with realities know quite well that there are in this country to-day and havebeen for months, thousands of heads of households who are at their wits' end to make ends meet, but the Minister's pet financial theory must be carried out irrespective of the cost to the people. We heard a lot of humbug from Deputy Cowan and others. The difference between Deputy Cowan and some of the others is that he knows he is talking humbug. The Minister talks humbug sometimes, and I am very doubtful whether he is conscious of the fact. Sometimes he is and does it deliberately. This humbug has brought a lot of misery to this country and to the people.
We are told there was a danger of the country's birthright being sold to some outside Power. Nobody will believe that for a moment; even Deputy Cowan does not believe it. It is fashionable now for the Minister, by implication, and for Deputy Cowan and Deputy Cogan by direct assertion, to be as insulting as they possibly can to the American nation for giving us the Marshall Aid loan. Nobody but Deputy Cowan objected to the acceptance of that loan. There was nothing wrong in accepting that loan. There was, however, a good deal wrong when the change of Government took place, with the way in which the expenditure of it was abused. Deputy Cowan tells us that we were better off paying 5 per cent. to our own people than paying 2½ per cent. to America.
Comment on this
Let me finish. I would agree that, so far as it is possible to do it, the money should be raised within our own shores.
Comment on this
I would not care to tempt the Minister with a loan at 2½ per cent. from America or Great Britain. I would venture to make a decent bet that he would not refuse it. He would be glad to get a loan at 2½ per cent. from America or Great Britain. We do not want any more of that sort of cheap talk. That is the dishonest sort of clap-trap we hear on a Vote like this about surrenderingthe country's independence or selling the country's birthright in return for Marshall aid. Of course the Minister does not believe that. He knows it is not true. He knows quite well that there was no such danger.
The money which we required by way of loan could have been raised successfully within this country from our own people at less than 5 per cent., if the Minister had gone to the people for the loan at the time he should have gone. The Minister's predecessor had announced his intention in May, 1951, to go to the country for another loan and the Minister could have gone in 1951 for a loan and have got it at much less than 5 per cent. Even the Fianna Fáil Government would have got it at less than 5 per cent.
Comment on this
It is only a ridiculous misuse of words to say that my predecessor stated that he intended to go for a loan.
Comment on this
I will leave it to you to twist his words. I am telling you what is on record. The fact is that you did not go for a loan and, unfortunately, this country is paying for that through the nose. Unfortunately, everybody who has to raise a loan for the purchase of a house will pay through the nose for it. Unfortunately, every local authority which has to raise money for any local scheme, whether sewerage, drainage, house building or anything else, will pay through the nose for it. The Minister's bad judgment in relation to the timing of the loan has cost this country a great deal of money. Not merely has it cost the State a great deal of money, not merely will it cost local authorities and others who have to raise money and those who have to borrow from them a great deal of money, but it has made money dearer for every citizen in this State.
Deputy Cogan talked a lot of clap-trap about the Government not carrying out the recommendations made in the Central Bank Report. He proceeded to tell us there were more employed on forestry and more employed here, there and everywhere else. The fact of the matter is theGovernment has produced here the results that the directors of the Central Bank recommended them to produce: dearer money, fewer capital schemes and a greater pool of unemployment. These were the main recommendations of the Central Bank Report and these are the results of the effect given to those recommendations by this Government.
I am satisfied, indeed I would be very sorry to think otherwise, that the Government must be perturbed at the economic position. I am satisfied the Government must be particularly perturbed because of the great increase in unemployment. That is a matter that would cause grave concern to any Government with a sense of responsibility. While this Government may not have as great a sense of responsibility as I would like to see, they have, I hope, some sense of responsibility. We would like to hear what steps, if any, the Government proposes to take to deal with the unemployment menace. We would like to hear what steps, if any, they propose to take to restore confidence and faith in this country and in its future —the confidence and faith that they have to a great extent destroyed. I am perfectly satisfied—mark you, unlike a lot of politicians I am not falling over myself in my anxiety to have a general election; I do not like general elections; I have no hesitation in saying that——
Comment on this
Will the Minister ever have the sense to wait until I have finished? I was saying that to give more emphasis to what I was about to say when the Minister interrupted. I am perfectly satisfied that there is a demand to-day for a change of Government, such a demand as was never known since the foundation of this State. There is no question about that. If this Government were to do its duty it would throw off the deadweight of the Deputy Cowans and the Deputy Cogans, would take its courage in its hands, as it has done before, and go to the people. Then we will know who is right and who iswrong. Until that is done the situation here will not improve.