Committee on Finance. - Motion by the Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 206–383 of 383. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Whenever the voice of the people was challenged it was not challenged from this side of the House. I say the country wants to get rid of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
They certainly do and if the Deputy has any doubt about it I challenge him to try it out.
Comment on this
I will resign to-morrow morning if the Minister resigns in Dublin and the two of us can fight out the issue in North Tipperary. I will hand my resignation to the Ceann Comhairle to-morrow if the Minister is prepared to do the same.
Comment on this
Deputies have been continually interrupting for the last half-hour. Deputy Morrissey is entitled to make his speech without interruption. All interruptions are disorderly. Deputy Morrissey on the Vote on Account now.
Comment on this
Let the Minister sleep on that to-night and if he is prepared to go on he can ring me in the morning and the two of us will see the Ceann Comhairle in the afternoon. I would like to show some of the boys the hills and beauty spots of North Tipperary.(Interruption.)I will not resign for Deputy Allen because he is only a lightweight. I will resign for the Minister. The trouble about it is that if the Minister came down to North Tipperary he would get away with it.
Comment on this
The trouble is I am very easily led astray. Deputies on the Government Benches know what ishappening. They know the reaction in the country and they are trying to put the best face they can on it. It is very different, however, from the policy they pursued for 25 years. Then they were always asserting their readiness to go to the country. They were always reminding us of the number of occasions on which they went to the people, asked for their support and got it. They were ever ready to take up the gauntlet immediately it was thrown down. Why the strange reluctance during the last 12 months? Surely the Minister is not growing modest in his old age. The Minister has no doubts regarding his own position but I think he would find it very hard to convince that astute old war horse, the Taoiseach, that this is a favourable time to take a ramble up to the Park, whatever the Fianna Fáil Party wants.
Comment on this
Let me repeat: whatever the Fianna Fáil Party wants, the people in the country want them to get out.
Comment on this
Exactly, because then they will have what they had for three and a half years—the unity, peace, prosperity and employment that you have taken away from them.
Comment on this
Having listened to Deputy Morrissey I am rather intrigued to know what policy he proposes to put before the electorate when the next by-election takes place. In the last four by-elections Fine Gael have not had a policy to put before the people. It is not Deputy Cowan or Deputy Cogan who is whining. It is the front benchers of the Fine Gael Party and they have been whining ever since they were run out of this House under cover of darkness in May, 1951. Surely they do not think the people are so simple as to believe that Fine Gael or any other Party on the Opposition Benches could restore food subsidies, reduce taxation and at the same time maintain full employment. The inter-Party Government was notable to do that despite borrowing on a heavy scale and with £40,000,000 from Uncle Sam. They succeeded, too, in raising the equivalent of that sum internally at a cheap rate, but they were not able to maintain employment even on a respectable scale. Deputy Morrissey has suggested, as his Party has suggested, that we are out to create unemployment, that we want to restrict credit and that we want to injure the economy of the country. I notice at every county council meeting down the country, and particularly at the estimates meeting, that it was the hatchet men of the Fine Gael Party who refused to face the responsibility in their own counties of striking a rate. I was present at a meeting of the Longford County Council last Saturday and, to use an ugly expression, it would make one puke to listen to the pious platitudes of the hatchet men of Fine Gael, who refused to face their responsibilities and strike a rate. It fell to the lot of Independents and Fianna Fáil to strike a rate to maintain the services of the county. I do not think that that attitude of Fine Gael either inside this House or outside is calculated to impress the electorate. I do not care how juvenile they may be.
Deputy Morrissey referred to the increased cost of living and alleged that it had increased more since we took over the Government than it had during their term of office. It was demonstrated here last week by Deputy Cogan that the increase in the cost of living has not been any steeper during our period than it was in the time of the Coalition. It increased 11 points during the time of the Coalition or inter-Party Government as you were pleased to call yourselves.
Comment on this
That remark should not have been made. All Deputies are checked, as far as the Chair can possibly do it. I would ask Deputies to restrain themselves and to preserve order.
Comment on this
If we take it that the former Government carry as much responsibility as we do for the increased cost of living, there can be no bones broken on either side. It has been suggested here that Fianna Fáil were responsible for slowing down housing. The record of Fianna Fáil in the field of housing can bear comparison with that of any other Party in any country in Europe, because in regard to housing activities in my county, at any rate, and I assume in regard to every other county, any work that was done was carried out under the direction of a Fianna Fáil Government. Every housing scheme in the County of Longford stands to our credit.
It has been suggested that we increased the rate in respect of borrowing in aid of housing. I remember back in 1931 if the Longford Urban Council or any other council wanted a loan from the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, they paid 6¼ per cent. for it and very often they were refused it. Therefore, it is not the first time in the history of this country that the moneys borrowed under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act, were borrowed at 5 per cent., 6 per cent., or 6¼ per cent.
The Minister for Finance has given a very accurate account of the position regarding the finances of the State when he took over. It is very easy for Fine Gael, I suppose, being the strongest Party in the Opposition, to say that we removed the food subsidies.We did, because we had to. The inter-Party Government left us with many commitments to honour. We cannot do as they did in May, 1951. We cannot dissolve the House and run away from the demands of the Civil Service. We cannot send out letters to them three or four days before the election and say: "We will grant you your request but we are not going to honour it. We will let some other Government do that."
If the Opposition suggest that we put back subsidies on the previous scale, are they prepared to say what should be taxed? Where are we going to find the £10,000,000 that will be necessary to pay those subsidies? I have not heard from Deputy Morrissey a single sentence as to where this money is to be found. He blamed Deputy Cowan for not speaking to the Vote on Account but, similarly, I can say that Deputy Morrissey did not refer to the Vote on Account during his speech.
As far as I can see Fine Gael want to create an air of unreality. They accused us of cutting down on the grants for various works, forestry, lands, schemes connected with Bord na Móna and various other activities which Fianna Fáil started and maintain. We do not claim any special credit for housing or for works of a capital nature in this country but we do say that we have been honest with the people and that we have kept, if you like, trust with them. We told them at every stage where the difficulties lay and we did not seek to surround the financial situation with mist as the former Government did.
It has been said that the price of butter has been increased and it has been suggested that there was some way by which the Government could give an increased price for milk to the farmers and at the same time keep the price of butter below 4/- per lb.—at 3/9 or 3/10 per lb. It is apparent that that charge is unfounded. Any Deputy who argues against increasing the price of butter is arguing against the increased wage that was granted to the agricultural workers some time ago. In any industry, whether it be agriculture or any other form of industry, if youdo not take costings into account, you are bound to get into trouble. There was no way that I could see by which the price of butter could be kept down except perhaps by subsidising it, and the system of subsidisation has been tried and found wanting. People found that they were paying more in taxes than they received as benefits through subsidies.
With regard to employment, Fianna Fáil has been accused of adopting the policy of the Central Bank, of restricting credit and of cutting down on housing. To rebut that, we have only to look at the total number of houses built in each of the last two or three years. For the year 1950, the total number of houses built was 12,048, for 1951, 12,135 and for 1952, 13,018. That, to my mind, does not denote any falling off in the rate of house building. We cannot be accused, therefore, of slowing down the rate of housing. There must inevitably be, at some stage, a falling-off in housing activities because, like an army, if you advance in any given sector and do not wait some time to consolidate your ground now and again, you cannot keep advancing indefinitely.
Having regard to the extent of the public purse and the amount of money in it, I think the Government devoted a fair amount of money towards that activity. The number of grant houses completed by private persons and public utility societies was 4,867 in 1951 and the figure rose to 6,080 in 1952. The number of houses reconstructed with State aid was 1,963 in 1951 and 2,647 in 1952. That again does not denote any falling off in housing activity. Taking hospital construction, the erection of new hospitals has been speeded up as the following figures will show. Expenditure on the construction of hospitals in 1951-52 was £3,581,000 and in 1952-53 was £4,250,000. There again we cannot be accused of paring down on hospitalisation.
Turning to the industrial side, if Deputies want to talk about Bord na Móna and the activities of the E.S.B., they will observe that the total production of turf by Bord na Móna in1950 amounted to 214,528 tons and the figure rose to 700,000 tons in 1952. With regard to the production of electricity, notwithstanding the shortage of materials and higher costs, the total number of consumers connected in 1949-50 amounted to 13,686 while in 1951 the number had reached 15,803 and in 1951-52, 18,067. As well as that the Government encouraged the erection of stations for the generation of electricity at Bangor-Erris, at Lanesboro', at Arigna and on the Clady River in Donegal. I therefore reject the charge that we cut down on the capital side of the programme.
Turning to forestry, the numbers employed in the Forestry Department at the end of January, 1950 were 2,346, in 1951, 2,786 and in 1952 3,612. Taking the acreage, the acreage in 1950 was 7,610 and that had increased in 1952 to 15,000 acres.
Comment on this
I indicated before that the acreage of forestry was not relevant in this debate, as it was a matter for the main Estimate. I do not mind the Deputy giving the numbers employed but the acreage is not relevant.
Comment on this
We have been accused of cutting down on the capital side of the programme and I was merely trying to answer that accusation.
Comment on this
I am not preventing the Deputy making a statement with regard to the amount of capital or the amount of employment involved but details as to the acreage are surely more relevant to the main Estimate.
Comment on this
If the Fianna Fáil Government are making an effort to promote the capital side of the programme and to maintain employment as far as possible—as they are—then I cannot see where the charge of cutting down on capital services comes in. I cannot see how it is going to be sustained. It is well known that, in the past year or so, business has slowed up in everycountry in the world. Surely it will be admitted that world events can have a very great impact on our economy. The price of raw materials has increased. Transport charges have increased. Labour costs have increased. These three items, in themselves, create a very difficult situation for any Government. Having regard to those obstacles, I think that this Government have done a reasonable job of work in even keeping employment at the point to which it has been kept and in keeping the capital services moving.
Some months ago I asked the Minister for Local Government to give me particulars as to housing costs. I was told that a house in a rural area in 1939, either serviced or unserviced, cost £370. In 1948 the same house cost £968. In 1949 it cost £1,000 and in 1951 it cost £1,500. Now let us examine the figures in respect of an urban area. In 1939 the cost of a house in an urban area, either serviced or unserviced, was £408. In 1947 it cost £966. In 1948 it cost between £1,000 and £1,300. Between 1949 and 1951 the price ranged from £1,100 to £1,500.
Comment on this
I further inquired what proportion of the cost was borne by the State, the ratepayer and the tenant. I was given the following figures. I was told that the State contributed 46.2 percent.; that the ratepayer contributed 14.2 per cent., and that the tenant contributed 39.4 per cent. It will be seen, therefore, that when you talk about encouraging the building of houses, it takes money to build them. You must have the money and you must be prepared for a long-term plan.
Before I conclude, I want to say that I reject the charge made by Deputy Morrissey and other Fine Gael Deputies that Fianna Fáil are out to create a pool of unemployment, that they are out to restrict credit or to injure trade or industry in any way. Surely a Government with the record of service from 1932 onwards which Fianna Fáil have, and who succeeded in establishing most of the major schemes in this country, would not, at this stage, restrict the one or the other. I have not heard from any Deputy on the Opposition Benches a plan or a suggestion or a potential scheme by which they would better our methods. I am quite satisfied that if the Fine Gael Party could come into this House and say: "We will restore the food subsidies, we will decrease taxation, we will re-employ 60,000 of the 80,000 persons now unemployed," they would carry the country before them—but they cannot do it. That is the rub.
Comment on this
I think we did not guarantee full employment but we guaranteed that we would do our best.
Comment on this
The difficulty is that this Government is suffering from confused financial thought. That is reflected in the speeches of the various Fianna Fáil Deputies who have spoken in this debate and in the various policies which the Government have followed in the course of the past 20 months.
Deputy Carter concluded his speech with a plea to the Opposition to provide some plan. On the face of it, that seems quite a reasonable request but, in actual fact, it is not. In thefirst place, the Government have at their disposal information and figures which no Opposition Deputy has. Not even the leaders of the Opposition Parties have these facts and figures at their disposal to enable them to put a cut and dried policy before the Government. That, in effect, is what Deputy Carter's and, indeed, other Deputies' plea has been. In the second place, the present Government, by the extraordinary policy which they inaugurated when they introduced the Budget last year, took the lid off the jar which contained the demon. You all remember the old Eastern fable in which the demon was kept in the jar. If it got out of the jar all sorts of terrible things would happen to the world. That was the fable—but there was a moral in it.
I am afraid the Fianna Fáil Government have let out of the jar the demons of a higher cost of living, increased taxation, increased unemployment and a more stringent financial policy coupled with the restriction of credit. The emergence of all these factors at the one time has brought about a situation in this country which, unfortunately, it will be very difficult for any subsequent Government to control. Certainly, it renders it impossible for any Deputy to put forward what appears to be a clear cut policy to deal with the situation. If we are returned to power as a Government, we propose to deal with that situation in certain ways which, we believe, will have a beneficial effect on the country.
I have said that the Government is suffering from confused financial thinking. I propose, in support of that, to quote two utterances by two different Ministers. The Minister for Industry and Commerce says that: "All economic progress is the result of a gradual inflationary trend." He believes that gradual inflation is necessary for economic progress. I must say that I am inclined to agree with him. The Minister for Finance on the other hand says that it is necesary to curb inflation and reduce taxation, and by these two methods to bring about a financial and economic situation which, he thinks,will benefit the country. There you have one Minister saying that gradual inflation is the secret of economic progress, while another Minister says that inflation must be curbed. When you have two principal Ministers in the Government holding these disparate views and putting them forward in public, how on earth can the financial policy of the country proceed in a smooth way or how can the ship of State keep an even keel?
Deputy Carter gave figures of the number of houses built in 1951 and 1952, but did not indicate the type of house he was referring to. I am sure the figures he gave are quite correct. They indicate an increase. What he did not give was the number of houses, the building of which commenced in 1952. At the moment there is widespread unemployment in all branches of the building industry. That is borne out by the industrial analysis of the live register which reached every Deputy by post this morning. It shows that on building, contracting and works of construction, there are at the moment 22,000 unemployed, representing an increase of 4,444 over the figures for February, 1952. These figures show that a large number of men are not in employment in that trade—one which was cited to us as giving continuous employment. How can those figures be reconciled with the statement made by Deputy Carter? I am sure the figures he gave were quoted honestly. The point about them is that the building of the houses had not been commenced in 1952. We know that it usually takes a couple of months to complete a house. I ask Deputies to be very wary, and not to trust figures put forward to prove that employment is as high at present as it was 12 months ago.
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs spoke in this debate last week. In the course of his speech, he said that at the moment the Government were carrying out increased public works and that the Fianna Fáil Government, in fact, had not cut down on public works of any sort. Despite the Minister's statement, we have the industrial analysis of the live registerwhich has a heading: "Construction and maintenance of roads, bridges, railways, tramways, etc.", where it is pointed out that, at the moment, there are 12,000 unemployed representing an increase of practically 2,000 over last year. I am sure the Minister made his statement in all good faith, and that he wanted to prove that building was going on just as merrily this year as in the time of the inter-Party Government. The figures on the live register seem to belie that.
The Minister also said that we were quite wrong, in fact that we were dishonest, when we blamed the Government for emigration. He said that this country always had an emigration problem which no Government had ever been able to solve. That, of course, is partly true. It is rather hard on those who sit on this side of the House to have to listen to a statement like that from a member of the Government, particularly when we remember the Fianna Fáil Party saying that it would be necessary to build extra ships to bring back those who had emigrated, because there would be so much work for them to do in this country. Fianna Fáil were to create so much work that it would be necessary to do that. Of course, everyone realised at the time that that was an absurd statement to make. It shows how the pendulum has swung. We have now a responsible member of the Cabinet pleading that it is not fair to blame this Government for emigration —that it is a problem which has always confronted the country. Admittedly, we always have had emigration but was it not dishonest, years ago, to keep talking about emigration as being something which that particular Party would rectify when they got into power?
Perhaps, as a result of that attitude of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, we may see emigration being treated as something which is outside and above Party politics. The contribution to the alleviation of emigration made by the present Government has not been very great, considering that there are now upwards of 90,000 persons unemployed in this country.
Deputy Briscoe made a long speechin this debate. He referred to the shortage of skilled labour. He denied that there was a shortage four years ago. As a member of the Housing Council established by the late Minister for Local Government, Mr. Murphy, as part of the housing drive which he inaugurated and for which he did such very great work, I can remember very clearly the problem of getting sufficient plasterers, carpenters, plumbers and many other skilled tradesmen to carry out work for the Dublin Corporation. At that time, very stringent building regulations were introduced so that there would be sufficient skilled tradesmen for work on corporation houses and so that they would not be drawn into the pool of workers available for private builders who, in many cases, were prepared to pay a higher price for a workman. That was felt to be against the public interest. It is absurd, therefore, to say that the inter-Party Government had not a problem of labour shortage. That statement has been made in this House.
Deputy Cowan made a long speech this evening. He talked about the two schools of thought. I have shown that there are two diametrically opposite schools of thought in the Government. Until the Government Party make up their minds on that question, a financial policy which can lead to better conditions will not be introduced.
Deputy Cowan referred to Deputy Dillon and misquoted Deputy Dillon's statement in connection with Newfoundland. Deputy Dillon was making the case that Newfoundland lost its liberty because the Government of that country had so neglected their chief industry, fishing, that Newfoundland was in great financial danger and ceased to be free. Deputy Dillon made the case that this Government had so mishandled our financial and agricultural economy that we were in danger of being put in the same position. That was his case. Deputy Cowan misquoted him and tried to make out that Deputy Dillon in some way was almost in favour of this country losing its independence. That, of course, was quite absurd. Deputy Dillon was making the clear case that we were liable to be brought to the same sorrypass as Newfoundland was brought to owing to the way in which the Government is handling our economic and financial affairs.
In connection with the Civil Service and the arbitration award, we on this side of the House and I, personally, think that as the Government had so altered the economic situation by allowing the cost of living to increase it is only common justice to implement the award made by the Civil Service Arbitration Board. That is my own personal opinion and it is the opinion of the Fine Gael Party. We think the Government should have honoured that award. Not having kept the cost of living down they must give justice to the people who suffer as a result of that.
The Minister for Lands, in the course of a speech in this debate, referred to the £30,000,000 drop in imports of which he said £15,000,000 were consumer goods, the balance being goods of various other sorts. I am a businessman, I am not an economist; but as far as one can bring common sense to bear on economic matters and on matters like imports and exports, I think we are suffering very much because of the drop in our imports. That may suit for financial reasons, but I consider that it certainly has had a most disastrous effect on our economy.
As I look at it as a businessman, this country does a certain amount of trade in exports and imports. Of course there are invisible exports and invisible imports also. But we have dropped £32,000,000 in our turn-over and that means that £32,000,000 less of goods of various sorts came into this country in 1952. That is one of the reasons why our unemployment figures have jumped up. We made money by selling those goods, if they were consumer goods, and we gave employment to shop assistants of various sorts. In fact, men and women got employment in handling those goods, from the dockers and railway men at the ports to the shop assistant, who handed them across the counter. People got employment through theimport of consumer goods and they got still more employment as a result of the raw materials which came in. That is one of the reasons why our unemployment figures are up by 20,000 over last year. If we have a drop of £32,000,000 in our imports, we are bound to pay for it by increased unemployment, and I do not think that the financial benefit which was gained justified the human suffering which was brought about by that policy.
It is that question of policy which is the vital one in connection with this Vote on Account. The Government have inaugurated a financial system which has meant restriction of credit and financial stringency. That has inevitably resulted in less business being done in the country and less business possible to be done, because there is not the necessary financial accommodation to carry it out. That has had its inevitable result in the unemployment which we have at the present moment and the reduction in trade generally. This country finds itself at the present moment with increased unemployment, a higher cost-of-living, a higher level of taxation, and restriction of credit. Trade has decreased, and business has fallen off. It has been stated that the yield from the spirits, beer and tobacco duties has fallen. Certainly property values have fallen. It is not now possible to sell properties at the prices they realised a couple of years ago, even 12 months ago. Properties are harder to sell.
Another sign of the difficulties through which we are passing at present is the various drapers' sales which have been held at the most unusal times of the year. Drapers are people who follow the purchasing power of the community very closely and carry stocks which go out of fashion and lose their value very quickly. One of the signs, therefore, of difficult times is the increased number of drapers' sales. We have seen any number of these taking place in Dublin and in the other cities and towns of the country, heralded by large notices such as "Drastic Reductions". As individuals we may feel rather glad of this opportunity to buy something cheaply, but the drapers do not hand out thingsunless they have to and it is a sign that everything is not well in the community when these sales take place.
The Government have put forward a certain plea and will put it forward again. I am sure other Ministers who are still to speak will follow the same lines as the previous speakers who have stated that it is not the Government's fault entirely, that of course there have been financial difficulties in other countries, there have been restrictions of credit, there have been trade difficulties, and that we are suffering now from the difficulties consequent on the Korean War and the buying in of stocks by various belligerents. That is of course partly true. It is true that the Government are not entirely to blame and I would be very sorry to blame them for anything which I did not honestly consider to be their fault, but I do honestly consider that the financial policy which the Government inaugurated has had a most severe effect on the people. To my mind, the tragedy is that it was unnecessary.
I know that there is a school of thought which thinks that it was absolutely necessary, but I believe that men and women have suffered because that conservative school of thought considered that the Government should go on the lines on which they are going at present. I, and many other people like me who are conservative at heart in many ways, consider that we have been sacrificed here for an unnecessary financial and economic policy.
I want to say a few words on the question of the Estimates Committee that Deputy Sheldon proposes. I am very glad to see the Government taking up that question but I cannot help thinking that is has been taken up partly because it is a very convenient smokescreen in the present financial difficulties confronting the Government. I would have liked the Minister to discuss it somewhat more widely than he did. I would have liked to have heard it discussed by some members of his Party. In fact it has not received any real discussion at all.
The idea is that this Committee willconsist of 17 members—I may be wrong in that—but I think 17 members would be a very large Committee. I am a little bit nervous in connection with certain aspects of it. Such a Committee has been used very effectively in other countries, notably in the British House of Commons. I do not hold that because something works well in another Parliament it will necessarily work well here. The House of Commons has 620 members. We have 147 and out of that 147 the Government has to find its Ministers and its Parliamentary Secretaries. Presumably those who are more talented—I do not say that this holds good entirely—are selected for ministerial and other posts. The same applies to the Opposition. There are a number of Deputies actively engaged in the business of the House. I think it would be very difficult to get 17 members, qualified and competent to do the work, who will be able to give the time and the necessary interest to the financial matters with which it is suggested this Committee should deal. The work will be extremely difficult. Members who take up the work will find they will have very little time to spend here in the House at certain times of the year. Indeed they may well find they will have very little time to spend in their constituencies.
Other Parliaments have three, four and five times the number we have here and through sheer weight of numbers they may find that a certain method suits them. It may not, however, suit us. I do not intend to crab this Committee. I think it is an excellent idea and I would like it to get serious consideration. Discussing it with the Vote on Account is somewhat unfortunate because it is being discussed in a political atmosphere and at a time when financial business is very important. It is not, therefore, getting the attention it deserves in the way of discussion. Possibly other front bench members of the Government will discuss it later and give it the attention and consideration it deserves.
I think the Government has failed grievously in its conduct of the affairs of the nation. We have a highlyincreased cost of living; it is up by 23 per cent. We have unemployment at the rate of 88,000 and the figures are still rising. We have increased emigration. We have increased financial stringency. We have what business people call tightness of money. It is difficult to collect accounts. These are facts. Every man who has a shop or a business knows they are facts irrespective of his political opinions. The Government has failed in its policy. It has let the jinn or the demon out of the bottle—higher living costs, unemployment, increased emigration and financial stringency. It will be very difficult for any Government to put the demon back into the bottle again. The Government should either inaugurate a policy capable of dealing seriously with unemployment, with financial stringency and the high cost of living or resign and let the country decide who is best qualified to deal with these very pressing and tragic problems.
Comment on this
So far as I have been able to follow this debate, the Opposition has been labouring very hard to sustain the myth or the pretence created about this time last year that all the ills from which it can be said we suffer are attributable to the financial policy of the Government, while the Opposition holds a magic policy which, if adopted, would change the whole course of things. I have been trying to discover what this magic policy is and in what respect our policy differs from it. Let us start with the policy of the Government. It is a simple policy and one aimed at balancing current expenditure and current revenue. Do the Opposition agree with that, or do they hold that the current housekeeping expenses should be met by Government borrowing or by the realisation of Government assets? I find it very hard to induce them to answer that question in a straightforward manner. We do stand by it. Do they?
The next matter is in relation to capital investment. We believe it is permissible to use present assets, sterling or other, provided they can be used productively—that is, thatthey can be used in such a way that their produce under the new set of circumstances will be at least equivalent to that of the old. As far as our international trade and the balance of payments are concerned, we are aiming at balancing—that is, paying for our imports, visible and invisible, by our exports, visible and invisible, except to such extent that the balance represents a realisation of assets, in the manner I have indicated, for the community as a whole.
I have stated in general terms what we have been aiming at and I have asked whether the Opposition have different aims. The first question I have asked—and I repeat it—is: Do they believe in balancing current expenditure by current revenue? If they do, and if they go back to the position with which the Minister for Finance was faced in connection with the last Budget, they will find that there was a deficit of £15,000,000 which had to be met. Estimated expenditure exceeded estimated revenue by £15,000,000. What were they going to do about the £15,000,000? Were they going to reduce expenditure by that amount or increase revenue— which could only be got by taxation— by that amount, or were they going to try to do both—that is, on the one hand to try to reduce expenditure and, on the other hand, to increase revenue?
One of those courses had to be adopted but the Opposition did not want to face any of them. It was much more convenient for the Opposition to pretend there was no deficit, to pretend that the gap which was still left when we had reduced expenditure through the reduction of food subsidies —and to meet which we tried to get the necessary taxation—did not exist. They produced bogus arguments and figures here which, almost as soon as they were uttered, were demolished. Nevertheless it was a useful line on which to proceed. It could only be finally proved false when we came to the end of the year. Of course, they still stuck to these myths that we were looking for a revenue of £10,000,000 beyond what we required. We weretold that the Estimates of expenditure were written up; that they contained many items on which there would be a saving; that we were budgeting, in fact, for a surplus, so that when we came along to the next Budget we might be able to talk about the relief from taxation which we would bring to the community.
At the time when they were made, those suggestions were absurd, so absurd indeed that I found it very hard to believe that any person with any ordinary feeling of respect for argument would try to sustain them or bring them forward. They kept it up, however, and we have had an echo of it in some of the statements made even here in this debate. We were imposing unnecessary and unjust taxation—as if any democratic Government was likely to impose unnecessary taxation. As I pointed out last year, all the temptations were in the opposite direction. The temptation to democratic Governments is not to impose unnecessary taxation. The temptation is not to meet your current commitments by imposing the taxation necessary to provide the revenue.
The Opposition must think there are a lot of very foolish people in this country who can be misled by arguments of that sort. They think that when they indulge in their sophistries and get into what are commonly called the realms of high finance, the people can be fooled. The people are not so easily fooled. There is nobody in the country who will believe for one moment that any Government is likely to impose unnecessary or unjust taxation. It is a very hard thing for any Government to impose the taxation which is necessary in order to meet the commitments of the State. The position is that we found this £15,000,000 deficit and we had to make up our minds to meet it.
We are now coming close to the end of the financial year. Where is the surplus of millions of pounds at which we were supposed to be aiming? As far as can be judged at this stage, we are not even going to balance. The steps we have taken were not merely not more than enough; theyhave not been sufficient to meet the needs. The indication at the moment is that we will have a deficit.
What about all the saving through overestimation in the various items that were referred to last year? We pointed out that the experience of the previous years had shown that any such saving would be more than eaten up by the Supplementary Estimates that were almost certain to be introduced. There again our forecast has been proved right, to the extent that these supplementaries had to be introduced, and that over and above contingencies or forecasts for which provision was made, there were certain items for which provision could not have been made and which could only have been met by the savings that might accrue on various other items. At any rate, this myth of £10,000,000 unnecessary taxation has been blown to the winds as we knew it would be, as any intelligent person knew it would be, by the events of the year.
It is all book-keeping, we are told. I wonder is the suggestion that we should not keep accounts and that we should ignore what these accounts reveal to us? Are we to get into the position of the businessman who does not keep accounts? We often find fault with farmers for not keeping accounts and for keeping cattle that would be a source of loss to them because they did not pay for their keep. Are we to resort to that? When I was away recently, I heard a story on the radio, of a pioneer of the railway business, a man in England—I forget his name at the moment. He did a good deal of enterprising work in starting the English railways, particularly in Yorkshire. He prided himself that he did not keep accounts. According to the story to which I listened—I had never heard of it anywhere else—he did marvellously well for a time but then came the inevitable crash. Is that what the Opposition want to happen here—that we should not keep accounts, that we should go on in the blind assurance that everything is all right and then just wait for the crash?
I do not think any reasonable personwould maintain that. If, then, we get accounts, if we get an expert staff to keep these accounts, if our experts are experts in accountancy and in administering the affairs of the State, if they come along with a considered and impartial judgment—the servants of the State have not to bear any of the responsibilities that the Government have to bear; their sole responsibility is to present the truth as they see it to the Government—and if the Revenue Commisioners, in their forecast, and the officers of the Department of Finance present the Government with their considered statement of affairs as they find them, surely we ought to regard these accounts as worthy of credence.
I am not going to pretend that mistakes cannot take place, or that the most experienced person in estimating revenue or the total amount of expenditure in a particular Department or section may not make a mistake, but we surely should be able in that case to point out these mistakes and to ask an explanation of them. If there is an explanation, surely it should satisfy us and we should not put against it merely the statement, "I think differently," without any basis whatever. We have had in this debate, as we had in the debate on the Budget and the Vote on Account last year, a whole set of unsupported statements and assertions, unsupported by any tittle of fact. That is not the way in which business can be carried on. The person who would rely on unsupported statements like those for settling his policy, turning away from the position as revealed by careful accounts, would be just a fool.
So far as the current Budget is concerned, the position is that all the taxation and the reduction in expenditure were necessary in order to balance current expenditure with current revenue. Do the Opposition say we should borrow for that? I wish that that question were answered. Do they advocate in these circumstances deficit budgeting—that is, deliberately refraining from meeting current expenditure by current revenue? If that is the policy, I should like to hear about it.
For what purpose is deficit financing resorted to? We have heard a gooddeal of the dual Budget they proposed. They have not proposed anything of the kind, as far as I can see. What the Opposition did was to segregate in the Book of Estimates items of a capital character, or that they regarded a a capital character, from those which they regarded as of a non-capital character. They separated the items of a capital character which were to be voted year by year, as opposed to what are called below-the-line items which are authorised by various statutes. The Book of Estimates when they were in office gave us a total exactly in the same way as we have the total now.
It is true that in the Book of Estimates there were notes indicating that certain items were regarded as capital items. As for this segregation—I do not know that my colleague the Minister for Finance would quite agree with me—it is a mere presentation of the Estimates. I would not object to the segregation personally. There would be something to be said for the segregation provided we were all of one mind and that we all really agreed as to what were items of capital expenditure. If there could be agreement as to the items that could be regarded as of a capital character, then the segregation of these could be agreed to. The trouble is that when you have from year to year new items, there will be a difference of opinion and the Minister for Finance has to make up his mind as to whether certain items of expenditure are of a capital nature or not. All that was done by the previous Government, after all this talk about a dual Budget, was the segregation of the items in the book that were of a capital nature from the others. That segregation had always been done at Budget time because the Minister for Finance at Budget time indicated what items of expenditure he regarded as being of a capital character.
I am asked what was the purpose of this deficit budgeting. As I take it, the purpose is to put more purchasing power in the hands of the community. But remember that when you do that you necessarily deflate the buying value of the past savings and the current savings of individuals. As a matter of fact, there has been deficit budgeting in that sense because wehave not met our capital expenditure from savings. It is suggested that, by extra taxation, we have taken up purchasing power from the community. The fact is that money is being given back to the community as well. There has not been the diminution, by that taxation, of the total purchasing power of the community that has been suggested by the Opposition. The money has largely gone back again to the community. There has to a large extent been a redistribution of it. It will be seen, therefore, that the total purchasing power of the community has not been diminished to the extent of the extra taxation. There has been deficit budgeting. Take, for instance, capital expenditure. That capital expenditure has not been met by current savings. To a considerable extent, it has had to be met by the realisation of assets. The moment you realise assets and give that fresh purchasing power to the community, you do, in effect, what anybody who advocates deficit budgeting desires.
My first question to the Opposition, then, is: "Do you stand for balancing current expenditure by current revenue?" Next, they suggest that we, on our part, are against expenditure on capital investment. Nothing of the kind. We have been doing it for years. Before the Coalition Government took office we had for years been investing capital in various enterprises. The greater part of the total capital Budget is made up of the items classed as below-the-line issues. Last year the total anticipated capital expenditure was about £34,000,000. Of that, the ratio between voted capital items and below-the-line issue is roughly 9 to 25—£9,000,000 of the voted capital to £25,000,000 of the other, roughly. That shows the order of magnitude of the voted capital items to the below-the-line items. There has been no diminution of capital investment since we resumed office.
On the contrary, there has been an increase. My recollection is that in the year 1950-51 provision was made by the Coalition Government for the expenditure of £32,000,000 on capitalinvestment. They spent £22,000,000— £10,000,000 less. The next year they provided a sum of £29,000,000. We had the spending of it. The total amount that was spent was £32,000,000 and, as I have already pointed out, £34,000,000 was provided last year for capital purposes. Where is the reduction of capital expenditure there? At no time have we invested less than the Coalition Government. The pretence all the time is that somehow or other we have cut down capital expenditure. These are the two main divisions of the expenditure—current expenditure and capital expenditure. The difference between us is that we know that our capacity for prudent capital investment, as the Leader of the Opposition put it, is limited and that we have to be very careful indeed—much more careful, as has been made evident, than the Coalition Government were while they were in office.
When we look at the balance of international payments, we see at once that not more than one-half of the increase in the realisation of external assets was accompanied by a corresponding increase by way of capital investment. The rest of it, therefore, was used for consumption purposes and did not represent any capital investment. We have heard the Opposition talk about the "prudent realisation of our sterling assets." We do not regard it as a prudent realisation of our sterling assets if only one-half of the amounts realised are going to be used as capital investment. Then, if you take even that half and consider it, you will find that the proportion of expenditure which is nonproductive from a financial point of view but which is, of course, valuable from other points of view, is high; you will find that the proportion of what I might call expenditure of an economically productive nature is much too small. Therefore, we would say, and we are now trying to aim at it, that if we are to have a realisation of our sterling assets we must see that a higher proportion represents capital investment and a still higher proportion than in the past represents assets of a productive character.
The balance of payments statementhas been criticised. As far as I can find out, the Opposition are now trying to slide into the position of suggesting that the realisation of external assets was brought about by deliberate action on their part. There is no evidence that it was brought about by deliberate action on their part. The deliberate action was supposed to represent controlled and prudent realisation of these assets. There is nothing to suggest that it was either controlled or prudent. In fact, one of the desiderataof the present situation is that there should be a scheme in which there will be a controlled and prudent realisation of these assets.
Our complaint against the Opposition is that, when they were in office, the realisation was absolutely haphazard. There was no control, and of course, having no control, there could be no prudence shown in the matter. The £61.6 million was the deficit that we had to consider as having taken place in the year 1951. It was so great that if it were to continue for two or three years we would thereby have exhausted our net sterling reserves. That was the situation that we had to face and that the Minister for Finance in particular had to face. He faced it by taking the measures which, in the circumstances, he thought would result in a considerable diminution. If outside events helped us, we would do better than he set out to do, but if outside events, being beyond his control, were such as to move in the opposite direction, then his forecast would not be realised. But now, seeing that the situation has been changed and drastically changed, the £61.6 million seems to be taken as a matter of no consequence by the Opposition. That was not their attitude when they were in office and had responsibility themselves. When there was a question of only half that amount, of only £30,000,000, it was "alarming": it was a situation that was a cause for "the utmost concern". If that was so when it was only £30,000,000, surely it should be very much more so when the amount was double that and had come after this "alarming" £30,000,000 had been realised.
I think that there can be no real sincerity about arguments of that sort. It was "alarming" at £30,000,000. It was doubly alarming when it became £61.6 million because, as I have said, if that balance were continued for a few years, our net reserves, which gave us the position of being a creditor nation as against the unfortunate position of being a debtor nation, would have been exhausted.
What, then, is the point of difference: what is it that the Opposition have to say with regard to this whole matter? It is easy to talk of various things such as financial stringency and loss of purchasing power. All these things can be easily talked about by people who have not the responsibility of dealing with the situation of which they are the consequence. There has been a world trend. Deputy Dockrell rightly said that this Government were likely to point that out. Of course, we pointed it out. We cannot isolate ourselves in this country. We are not sufficiently large to do so. Even the largest countries do not seem to be able to isolate themselves from certain recurring slumps and booms or from changes that take place through conditions such as those which followed immediately the outbreak of the Korean war.
The Korean war suggested the likelihood of another World War. There was tremendous buying of things that were necessary to meet that at very high prices. Prices went up as the need grew or seemed to grow. That created a situation which had to redress itself, once it appeared that this immediate danger of a new World War was not being realised. The rectifying of that situation, the change from boom buying to that of having stocks which were bought at high prices and the disposal of them to unwilling buyers, was not easy. The buyers saw, as well as those who had built up the stocks, that the situation was not going to be exactly as it had been, and that prices were likely to come down. The result was that they withheld buying and it was that which brought about the general recession in trade as it is called.
We are suffering from that becausewe cannot isolate ourselves. Because these things happen, the Opposition want to force all that as a necessary consequence on what they call a financial policy as if there was anything new or strange about the financial policy of the Government. It certainly is nothing new or different from the policy that was advocated by the Opposition as far as they addressed themselves at all to arguments on the matter.
This year, as I have said, we are likely to end with a Budget that has not been balanced on current account, and certainly with a Budget that will not have been balanced on capital account, because although we did get a substantial loan from savings, it had to be added to considerably to meet capital expenditure. Therefore, more money was put into circulation— injected, so to speak, into the community.
What is the prospect for the coming year? I do not want to anticipate the budgetary statement by going into details. From the best information I have been able to get, it would look as if our expenditure on the Central Fund services is certain to go up by some £2,000,000. That is mainly due to debt charges. Some people think that they can borrow indefinitely, that they can borrow with no immediate consequences. Borrowing has consequences very soon afterwards, because the debt charges, the sinking fund and interest charges, have to be met. As I have said, the Central Fund services, due mainly to an increase in the debt charges, will be £2,000,000 more than last year.
As regards the Supply Services on the non-capital side, I want to stress again that no item that was regarded as a capital item by the Opposition when they were in office was treated by us as one to be met from current revenue. That was so as regards capital items that were held by them to be capital items, even though we did not agree that they were so. One of the reasons for doing that was that we wanted to make clear what the position was. We did not want to give an opportunity to people to misrepresentus. A second reason was that in the general situation we were not anxious to put on more taxation than was absolutely and incontrovertibly necessary.
The Central Fund services, as I say, are going up by £2,000,000. Substracting in this Book of Estimates not merely the £9? million on items that correspond to the items which the Opposition, when a Government, regarded as capital, but also other items of capital expenditure such as have been mentioned, there still remains a sum to be met in excess of the amount that is being expended this year on current items. Whatever that excess may be, it must be added to the £2,000,000 which I have indicated is likely to arise from the increased charges on the Central Fund services. That is, on the expenditure side, an increase of over £2,000,000; some would put the total at nearly £4,000,000, but at any rate, we will know fairly definitely when the end of the month comes. The present indications are of the order I have mentioned.
We shall have, then, an increase in expenditure next year. Can we look for an increase in revenue? The present rates of taxation have not given us the yields that we anticipated last year. When we were looking forward last year we expected that there would be a certain yield from taxation. The yield was estimated by the officers who have long experience of these things and their best estimate has been proved to be over the mark. We certainly will not have, therefore, at present rates of taxation, the revenue which will meet this increased expenditure. On the non-tax side there may be some increase of revenue that could be used to a certain extent as a set off but, looking forward, we do not see that, on the existing rates of taxation, revenue will meet expenditure.
The Minister for Finance is again faced with a difficult problem— fortunately, the problem as far as I can see, is not of the magnitude that it was last year—in making current revenue meet current expenditure. It will be a problem because we believe that taxation generally is as high as the community can afford, as high as it is wise,in the general interests of the community and even in the interests of the Exchequer, to push it. I do not want to say that we have absolutely reached the limit of taxation but we have reached a point at which every step forward must be watched with the greatest possible care.
Have we any possible reductions in these services that we can point to? The Opposition tell us that they will avoid all waste. That is a grand, easy way of talking—avoid waste. Let us see any items where there is waste. If waste can be discovered, certainly, it should ruthlessly be cut out. But it is not there that any really significant reduction can be made. If a reduction in expenditure is to be achieved, it must it seems to me, be a reduction in services.
Are we prepared to face such reduction of services? Will the Opposition stand in on that? That is not their record. I am not saying that Oppositions as a rule do it. I do not want to pretend that the present Opposition is very different from most Oppositions in that respect because the characteristic of Oppositions generally is that they want to achieve popularity by voting for the things which appear to give service to the community but they very rigorously oppose the voting of moneys that are necessary to finance them. That is characteristic of Oppositions and the present Opposition certainly, to say the least of it, is not an exception to the rule.
Look at the record. Will they point out to us any place where they have opposed services because we cannot afford them or because of the money that is necessary to meet them? I have not seen any evidence of that. Again, I am talking in general; I am not suggesting that the present Opposition is any worse than other Oppositions would be but the fact is that the Government, no matter what Government is in office, has to bear the full responsibility, the full unpopularity, of trying to raise the money to meet the services. They are fine fellows, both with the Opposition and with such people abroad as do not think of the day ofreckoning, as long as they are voting services but the moment they try to meet the cost of those services by securing through taxation generally the revenue that is necessary to meet the bill, then, of course, every ill that can be imagined is due to them.
We have no evidence that we will be supported in any measure that might be taken to reduce expenditure. We have our experience of last year. Last year, to reduce expenditure, we reduced the amount of the food subsidies. From the social point of view, it was the best point to deal with. They were originally put on for the purpose of tiding the State over a special situation which we expected would not last for any length of time and which would be non-recurrent. We were then the Government and when we introduced the subsidies we had the full blast of the Opposition, as it is to-day, bearing down upon us. These things which were regarded as so precious last year were scoffed at as being make-believe for the community in 1947. Now that we are carrying out our original view we are met with all the opposition possible and the suggestion that everything that has happened in this country in the last year has been the result of the reduction of the food subsidies.
We tried to find out what were the views of the Opposition with regard to subsidies. They were very coy about stating their attitude towards them. They are accusing us of doing things for the purpose of securing votes. I think I could with truth say that their change of attitude in regard to the subsidies was mainly due to the desire to capture votes, because most of the responsible people on the Front Bench had already given evidence that they regarded subsidies as an undesirable form of social service. Unlimited expenditure without tears—that is their policy. There can be no such thing.
If we are to have these social services we must find the money to meet them, and the question always to be decided is whether the services are worth the money spent upon them. If they are, if, generally, they make for the well-being of the community, then they are right and proper. If they donot make for the well-being of the community, if they are putting upon the community burdens which are too heavy for the community to bear, then they are not good. We ought in all these cases apply that test. Where we have brought in social services we have done so in the belief that these social services are on the whole of benefit to the community, but we have not been so foolish as to suggest that these services can be rendered and that the cost of them is not to be recovered from the community.
I do not think that there is very much more that I want to say at this time. When we come with more definite figures at the time of the Budget, I will have something more to say. But at the present time I am convinced that the policy which the Government are pursuing is the only policy possible, even assuming that one had a number of policies to choose from. There was no other policy possible for any Government which regarded itself as a responsible Government, responsible for the well-being of the community.
If we were so inclined, of course we could have continued realising our external assets. We could have continued having the "good time" which it was suggested by the former Minister for Finance had been given to the community. A good deal of that was something which had flowed in the natural order of events from the conditions which followed when the postwar recovery had taken place. We could continue a spendthrift policy, utilise all the existing savings of the past, spend them, and then what? Surely as a Government we ought to look forward a little bit beyond tomorrow or the next year. Our aim ought to be to secure the continued well-being of this community. If the continued well-being of the community is our aim, then we cannot lightly exhaust our reserves imprudently, as had been done over the couple of years in which the former Government was in office.
Comment on this
You might havethree times that number of unemployed in a year or two if you were to go on with the wrong policy.
Comment on this
We are not doing that. We have heard a lot about unemployment, that the Opposition had created full employment. It is an absurdity to say that they created full employment when shortly before they left office there were 61,000 unemployed, unless they say 61,000 is a solid core of unemployable persons. It is true that a seasonal reduction took place shortly afterwards, but that was due to the Employment Period Order of that time. Our view is this, and it is a common-sense view which any private individual or firm would take, that if you live beyond your means and beyond your income you will ultimately face a situation in which you will not be able to do the things which you could ordinarily do.
Comment on this
Whatever is the cause, it is not because we are balancing our Budget. That is not the cause of it. If it is, then will you say whether you want to balance your Budget? When there are reserves being realised, these reserves must be properly employed and not used for the consumption of the day. We have to look forward like a father of a family will look forward or anyone in charge of a business will look forward. A person with a couple of thousand pounds in the Bank can go on spending it and not earn anything until it is gone, but when it is gone, he will have to work twice as hard as he would have had to work if he had used these reserves reasonably. It is such an obvious thing that I am ashamed that in a deliberative assembly we should have to deal with it in this way, as if it were a matter of high finance above the heads of the ordinary people. We should approach these things in acommon-sense way and you will find that high finance in the long run is reasonable, informed common sense and nothing more.
We have the situation that we have either to give up some of these services or get money to finance them. There is no way out of that. If we are to borrow, then we will be only able to borrow for a relatively short time. As to the question of borrowing even for capital purposes, it will not be so easy at all to find the capital necessary to finance our capital programme. I have said that our capital programme has never been less than the capital programme of the Coalition. The whole capital programme has grown out of the plans for development which we originated after the war.
Comment on this
It is not nonsense; it is the truth. Will you point out any of them that has not originated from these plans, with the exception, possibly, of one, the Local Authorities (Works) Act? That is about the only one and, indeed, from a capital point of view, it was of very poor content, to say the least of it.
Comment on this
There were other things which would have been much more valuable. Drainage, as such, was being envisaged by us and set going. As far as other services are concerned, they were services which were much more valuable and gave a much better return for the employment than some of the schemes under the Works Act did.
As to emigration, we were accustomed to the cry about emigration in 1947. We were told in 1947 by various members of the Opposition that emigration had reached a level that had only been exceeded in the Famine years or in the years immediately following the Famine. When the figures came to be known, the truth was that there had been a reduction in emigration in that particular year. It was shown that it was only about 10,000 roughly—I am giving the round figure.The next year, when the Opposition, who had been crying out about the great increase in emigration, got into office, it increased from 10,000 to 28,000 in the very first year they were in office and in the next year it went up to 34,000. The next year after that it was estimated that it had gone up to 41,000. Some of these figures were given by the present Leader of the Opposition, when he was Taoiseach, and were then apparently regarded as fairly reliable. They were accepted as all right then, but the moment we gave them they were all wrong.
The position about emigration to-day is that, unfortunately, we have no real check which will tell us what is the emigration from the country at the moment. We could do it by having a yearly census. The question is whether the information is of sufficient value to warrant that. That would cost a certain number of thousands of pounds. Would it be warranted? If it is regarded as being warranted, we can have it, but, again, like other things, we have to pay for it. The question is, having obtained the information, is it worth what we have to pay for it? That matter is being examined by the Central Statistics Office to see if there is any way in which we can get a reasonably reliable figure, because only by means of a census can one get a figure which is reliable down to the last unit. Otherwise, one can, at best, only get a fair approximation.
We have a situation now in which we cannot get reliable figures because certain war-time checks have disappeared and the Opposition feels once more at liberty to mention any figure that comes into their heads and to make any far-fetched statement they see fit to make about emigration. It is again, according to the Opposition, soaring to the highest figure since the days immediately following upon the Famine.
We have been referred to as bookkeepers. If we had not kept our national accounts and if we did not indulge in this so-called book-keeping, I suppose the Opposition would be at liberty to play about with any figures they liked. One of the reasons why they dislike our book-keeping is becausethe figures are there and they cannot talk at random.
There is unemployment due mainly to a recession in various trades. We do not regard our financial policy as being responsible for either that unemployment or that recession.
Comment on this
It is as much the end of it as the statements made by the Opposition. As far as we are concerned, we do not look upon unemployment as being due to our financial policy. Our financial policy is the only policy possible for any responsible Government here. It is the only policy that has been put forward here. We have had all sorts of suggestions about money markets and so on. There are, I think, only about three or four places in the whole world sufficiently large to have money markets of the kind referred to. Personally, I would like to see a money market and this is not the first occasion on which that idea of a money market has been put forward. It was referred to and considered as far back as 1932. I think it was also considered by the Banking Commission. There are difficulties here. There are many countries that have no money market. I do not think there is a money market in Paris. There is one in London, one in New York and, I think, one in Amsterdam. There is no money market in Canada, which is a very well-developed country with a considerable trade and considerable economic strength. We will not get out of the difficulties of the present situation by adopting suggestions of that nature. Indeed, it would be delightful if we could.
We are supposed also to be responsible for financial stringency at the present time. We are supposed to be dictating to the commercial banks the policy they should follow. We are doing nothing of the kind. Neither have we dictated to the Central Bank as to what its policy should be. TheCentral Bank publishes its views and I take it they are the views of the directorate of the Central Bank. These views are put forward by people who have no political axe to grind and no purpose to serve except the purpose of giving truly the situation as they see it.
Comment on this
They are doing the best they can to preserve the integrity of our currency. They are ensuring that the position is maintained in which our currency will not depreciate. Is that not something?
Comment on this
How can the Taoiseach claim that when our money has depreciated and will probably depreciate still further?
Comment on this
And so has money in other countries depreciated. Does the Deputy think one can pay for wars, for the maintenance of large bodies of men, for the production of weapons of destruction and so on without some hardship being caused?
Comment on this
Then, remember that the effect of wars is that one has a situation in which the value of money is continually depreciating. Money has depreciated to-day in practically every country, because it is largely by utilising, so to speak, the capital values that have accumulated and the productive capacity which has been built up that wars are paid for. So long as we have wars, we will have certain evils following in their train. In the same way, one cannot have very high expenditure without some tears following in its train.
I was referring to financial stringency and the restrictions of credit. Of ourselves, we have done nothing tocause that. We did not wish for that. Financial stringency has been caused by matters outside our control. The only reason why we permitted such financial stringency or did not definitely oppose it was because we were satisfied that the evils that would follow from attempting to do that would be greater than the evils that have followed as a result of the policy that has, in fact, been pursued.
Comment on this
When there is a choice, one has to envisage the outcome of two particular courses of action. One has to ask oneself: if I do so and so to meet a certain set of circumstances, what will be the outcome? What will be the good? What will be the evil? If I take one course, I will have certain advantages and possibly certain disadvantages. Prudence in judgment consists in striking a proper balance, in choosing the lesser of two evils. That is precisely what human judgment is for, and we had to strike a balance between the evils that would flow even though we did not wish to adopt this course. We regretted that it should be so. We were not out for dear money or anything of that kind. We regretted the consequences of dear money, but we had to consider the consequences that would flow if we took positive steps in opposition to it, and we were satisfied that the community would suffer more had we adopted that alternative course.
If there are projects of a productive character which cannot be undertaken or pursued because the necessary capital is not forthcoming, that is undoubtedly a disadvantage, but very often that is not the case that comes to our notice. Very often, when weexamine some of these cases, we find that credit has not been given because those looking for credit were not creditworthy and there was, therefore, no likelihood that the money would be used in a really productive way. Wherever money is likely to be used in a productive way, I think the banks are only too anxious to have money spent in that way because they reap a certain advantage from it.
Comment on this
Is that the experience we have had? Are the banks anxious to give credit, even to people who can produce good security?
Comment on this
I will not go into the history of banking and the position of our banks, though it might be useful for certain members if I did. It might be useful to consider how banks grew up, what their original function was, how they became possessed of the assets they have, what inducement there was to pay to induce people to put their money on deposit in the bank so that they can use those assets for productive purposes. The opportunities for them at home were not very great and the opportunities for using them elsewhere were greater. Is it right that we should direct the banks as if they were some State institution whose primary responsibility was to the community as a whole? Through the Central Bank one of our purposes was to see that the community interest in regard to the creation of credit, and so on, would be primarily served and primarily kept in mind.
In regard to the banks I have made it clear that there is no desire on the part of the Government to restrict credit. I have been looking for definite examples and have not been able to find any where, with a reasonable prospect of productive use, accommodation was denied. If we had such examples, I would have felt very differently about it. I do know that the total amount for advances has diminished but there are reasons which can be given for that. I do not want to go into detail but there are reasons of various kinds that can be given for the reduction in the total amount of advances that took place a short whileago. It certainly was not taking place at the time this cry was first made even if the present figures prove the assertion that there has since been a diminution of bank advances.
I have heard Deputy Dockrell speaking here this evening about this restriction. I was wondering whether he had something to complain of in that regard from personal knowledge of his own business affairs or the affairs of some other people with whom he was connected in business. I would like to get these business examples because it is not our policy or our desire either to have dear money or restricted credit. These things—if they have happened— have happened without our desire but certain consequences do flow from them and some of these consequences are not entirely and wholly bad. That is one of the things the Central Bank and others who have spoken from the conservative point of view have been trying to stress, that in the long run— and it is only in the long run that these things can be judged—these have certain rectifying and beneficial effects for the community.
I agree that there may be certain temporary hardships and things we would have wished to avoid. I would be very glad and the Government would be very glad if there were steps that could be taken which would not have created evils worse than those we were trying to eradicate so that the cure would be worse than the disease, and we would have been very glad if there were ways in which there would be employment given to any people who in the present situation have become unemployed.
I am afraid this is a very wide subject in which there are so many aspects and so many reactions of one kind or another, that it would take a very long time indeed to deal with them satisfactorily as a whole. My challenge to the Opposition is: how any other policy but the policy we have pursued could be pursued, having the interest of the country at heart? If I were in Opposition and the present Opposition were advocating any of the policies they have indicated, I would oppose them as strongly as I could, in so faras I have been able to understand them as having any policy on the matter. It seems to me that their policy was a policy of careless spending. It was a spendthrift policy and very much the case of the prodigal wasting his substance. If it be said that the prodigal did not fare too badly, I would say it was because there was somebody else doing the work; he had a home to come back to when he had exhausted his substance and there was somebody else there, both the father and the other sons, who tried to have a place to which he was able to return. If the prodigal were the only person, there would be no place to come back to.
We are urging on the Dáil to pass this Vote on Account as an interim measure, indicating the expenditure that is necessary, and awaiting the Budget for a statement of the accounts as a whole.
Comment on this
I would like to take advantage of this Vote to draw the attention of the House to a number of problems that are facing the country. There are almost 90,000 unemployed people signing on the register of unemployed, men and women, boys and girls. Ninety thousand people, seeking work and wages to buy the necessities of life, are in this country at the present moment deprived of the work that is their right as human beings in this world. Still we have a problem like that glossed over by the Leader of the Government in his speech lasting well over one hour. It is quite true he mentioned unemployment but he did not mention any solution for unemployment. That is only half the number, I suggest. We must add to that those who are flying out of this country night by night, week by week and month by month.
In dealing with emigration, the Taoiseach said that in 1947 it was much less than a number of years after when the inter-Party Government were in power. That is quite correct but it is to the credit of nobody. What we in the Labour Party are anxious to see irrespective of what Government is there, is that the people will get work at home. It is quite true that there will be a natural emigration ofpeople who wish to go abroad, who wish to see other countries and who have a spirit of adventure. However, no political reasoning will convince me that there are not flying from my own county——
Comment on this
They are not going to Birmingham or Manchester where they have large numbers of unemployed.
Comment on this
They are flying to London as well as to other parts of England. In my own town I can produce the figures kept by trade unions of unemployed men and women who have left within the past 12 months. I agree with the Taoiseach that nobody can at the moment indicate the exact number or even the approximate number leaving the country, but it must be clear to everybody that there are people being forced out of the country because there is no work here for them.
In regard to the increase in the number of people taken into the Army, had that not happened would it not be clear that those very people would now be unemployed? They went into the Army probably to escape from unemployment. I wish to cast no aspersions on life in the Army or on anybody who takes up that as a profession, but it must be pretty clear that a number of boys throughout the country have decided that sooner than emigrate, they would join the Defence Forces. I think that the need for such an Army is not there but it is preferable to see these young men in the Army, actively engaged in training and in exercises, rather than standing in queues at the labour exchanges as they otherwise would.
It was reported in the newspapers a short time ago that the people of this country are eating much more in comparison with the people of a large number of other countries. If that is correct—and I have no reason to doubt it—then the 90,000 people who are unemployed must be eating very little because I am quite positive that thesepeople find that all they can do on unemployment assistance, ordinary unemployment benefit or disablement benefit under the national health, is to provide tea, bread and sugar never mind eating to an extent that is higher or better than the consumption of the inhabitants of any other country in the world. As well as the 90,000 unemployed plus those who are forced to flee the country, plus those who went into the Army, there is another army of boys and girls leaving school yearly who have not registered or who will not register for employment, some perhaps through a sense of shame at having to go to the labour exchange. For whatever reason, it is quite clear that 90,000 is nowhere near the number of people who are living in this country and who are unable to secure work and the wages that go with it.
I suggest that this country or the Government that is running it has no room for complacency, no room for congratulating itself that such a position exists. The cost of living is such that even those of us who are lucky enough to be able to earn a living in the country, and who through our trade union movement are lucky enough to have some sort of a decent wage, find it utterly impossible to provide the ordinary necessities of life for ourselves and our families. On the Government, and the Government alone, in my opinion, is the blame to be laid for such a state of affairs. Notwithstanding the promises given at the time of the 1951 election—point No. 15—that they would not remove food subsidies, immediately they got the chance they removed the subsidies on tea, sugar and butter. Within recent weeks, by a decision of the Government, the price of butter has again been increased, and if one can believe indications, in the near future the subsidy on bread will either be totally or partially removed.
The Government may now say: "It is in the interests of the people to do that or worse would befall them," but why were the people not told: "If we are returned to power we shall remove the subsidies"? The Taoiseach said in the course of his speech—at least I am fairly sure it was the Taoiseach said it—that the Opposition Parties did not indicate at Front Bench level their policy in connection with subsidies. He suggested that perhaps a number of back benchers with the idea of vote catching made certain promises. Let it be said clearly that it was stated on behalf of the Labour Party officially in this House that following an election, if such took place, they would not be associated in a Government with any Party who was not pledged to restore in full the subsidies removed by the present Government. That promise was made in this House on behalf of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
If my friend is seeking information, I am prepared to say to him that the Labour Party is not against extra taxation on everything if the purpose justifies what they are going to do. For instance should it be necessary to impose increased taxation on incomes so that the sick would have a little more, so that the unemployed could have better benefits or so that the food subsidies could be restored, I would have no hesitation, and I am quite sure no other Labour representative would have any hesitation, in voting for increased taxation.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I hope it will be published so that it will be known throughout the country.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton, I repeat, makes his own statements, but he will make that statement on behalf of the Labour Party any time he feels like it and no member of the Labour Party and no supporter of the Party will quarrel with him. In connection with the restriction of credit by the banks, the Taoiseach said, and perhaps it is quite true, that the Government have given no directions to the banks. In fact, I heard the Minister for Finance in the inter-Party Government make the same statement, but whether or not a direction has been given, there is no doubt but that there has been a very grave restriction of credit during the past year and a half. Many of us have received complaints in the matter—complaints about which the Taoiseach has asked for details. We have heard complaints that loans for creditworthy schemes—not loans to accommodate individuals for private luxury schemes but loans for credit-worthy schemes which would create employment—were hit on the head by bank managers or their directors without any reasons being given.
Comment on this
I offered to give the Minister for Industry and Commerce details of a specific case—and I may say that the man concerned is a prominent supporter of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
This man was in a position to obtain a dollar market for wool but when he sought a loan to enable him to purchase the wool in this country and to export it to America, for which he would receive a dollarpayment, he was refused. On a previous occasion in this House, I mentioned the circumstances of this case to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and I offered to give him the name of the individual concerned if he wished to hear it. I have not received any request in that matter from the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I now make the same offer to the Taoiseach. He will receive details of what happened in Limerick only 12 months ago.
Comment on this
A loan of £20,000,000 at 5 per cent. was recently floated in this country. As far as I can see, the result is that anybody who had hopes of getting an advance for house building will not be able to take advantage of the 1952 Housing (Amendment) Act by reason of the increased rate of interest. In my county, in particular, full advantage was taken of the earlier rate. Working people for whom, normally, it might have been the duty of the local authority to provide houses, were bestirring themselves, seeking Government grant and local authority grant and a loan over a 35-year period. In addition, they were using their own labour and providing houses for themselves and their families at no cost to the local authority. Since the flotation of that loan and since the announcement in regard to the increased rate of interest, that initiative has practically stopped. What, between the increased rate of interest, certain sections of the 1952 Act and the way in which they are interpreted by county managers, the working-class individual has not got an opportunity of building a home for himself.
I should like to give one typical instance of what can happen. A working man who earns over £8 a week is deprived of the grant from the county council. Should he prove that his income is under £8 a week he will get the grant but the county manager will refuse the loan. Should he prove that his income is over £8 a week he will get the loan but he will lose the grant.It is very obvious that the Housing (Amendment) Act, 1952, is of little use because it gives a full grant to the man who has not the money to build the house while the man who has the money to build a house gets either a reduced grant or no grant at all.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach claimed— perhaps rightly, to a certain extent— that world conditions have tended to increase the cost of living and to cause unemployment. I suggest, however, that the implementation of the Central Bank Report of the year before last by the Government is the cause of unemployment and of the high cost of living—notwithstanding the assurance given by the present Government.
It was clearly stated in the Central Bank report that a reduction of the gap between our imports and exports is desirable for this country and, to do that, they advised that as little employment be given by the Government as possible and that food subsidies be removed so that the ordinary people would have to go without, thus permitting the possible export of some food. Significantly enough, these things happened following upon the publication of the Central Bank Report. Unemployment has increased considerably. The cost of living has jumped up. The gap between imports and exports has been reduced. All is right in heaven for the Central Bank but all is wrong for the ordinary people of this country.
Comment on this
"If you only knew", the Taoiseach says to me. Perhaps they have new troubles which have come as a result of their false teachings. It appeared to them on that particular September that the ideal thing was to reduce to starvation level the ordinary people of this country. Certainly, at book value, things are perfect in Ireland. We are reducing the gap between imports and exports but we are increasing the stream of emigration and we have hungry men, women, boys and girls who must pay for thebeautiful things which have happened. Unless a very speedy change takes place in this country, you will have a social revolution. The working people are being driven too far. "—isms" that should be foreign to this country are receiving a fillip because of the hunger, want and unemployment which prevail at present.
There is very little use in trying to tell a hungry unemployed man who has a hungry wife and family at home that because of the Korean war or some other circumstances outside the control of the Government he is unemployed and food is dear. Professional troublemakers and paid agents of a foreign power will reap a rich harvest in this country unless the Government face facts and find a remedy or else admit that they have no solution and say that they are prepared to face the country in a general election. The Labour Party will issue a challenge in Wicklow —a rural constituency—against the background of the present position within a very short time.
I suggest to the Taoiseach that he should accept the result in Wicklow as the wish of the people of the country—that if he should win that seat he should continue in Government, but that should he lose it he should give the people the opportunity of electing a new Government.
Comment on this
I must confess that I listened to the speech of the Taoiseach with a considerable amount of amazement. I envy the Taoiseach. I think he must be the happiest man in public life, because whether he faces to the right or to the left he is able to convince himself all the time that he is right. Even if the whole world is against him, well then the world is wrong and he, nevertheless, is right. He can advocate, with every appearance of sincerity and conviction, one policy to-day, and a diametrically opposite policy in twelve months' time or less—sometimes in two months' time.
We heard the Taoiseach's references this evening to food subsidies—that they were a purely temporary expedient, a bad social service only justified on a very temporary basis tobe removed by a brave and honest Government at the earliest possible moment. Let us leave out the honesty. That was from the same man who subscribed his name to point 17 of the manifesto, the litany of pledges by himself and his Party, on the eve of his re-election to Government—no reduction or removal of food subsidies.
That was his considered opinion in the second week of June. Because of that manifesto, and because of that particular pledge, to a very great extent, he was elected Taoiseach. With an equal appearance of sincerity and conviction, he scoffs at food subsidies now on the grounds of bad finance, dishonest administration and that they are only a temporary expedient in a real emergency. Coincident with that set of gymnastics, he presumes to lecture Dáil Éireann and all its Parties on straightforwardness and honesty in public administration.
I listened to the Taoiseach this evening, to his scoffs at the magic secret of how other Parties could increase, or claim to increase, benefits of any kind and not increase taxation. I listened to the same Taoiseach, not once but many times, during the election campaign of 1948. What was his stock speech? What was it that always got the cheer and the laugh from the back-bench boys? "Oh, here are Parties, Fine Gael, Labour and others going around the country saying that they will reduce the taxes on tobacco and beer, and at the same time will increase the old age pensions"? He says: "Where is the magic trick? How can you increase benefits without increasing taxation?" That was the stock speech then. It was a popular speech, the type of speech that would go down in a child's school of simple juvenile arguments.
In the following three years—in the following year—we proved that it could be done by increasing production and stimulating trade. We proved that we could remove £5,000,000 of brutal taxation. We did that by giving confidence to the country and to the people in it. Trade and business boomed; the revenue was buoyant; everyone had more money; more was taken in in customs and excise duties,and there was less drawing out of the unemployed pool. We did all that without imposing any new taxation.
Now we have the same old cant: "How can you do it? What is the magic trick? Will you not let us know your trick?" Of course, the ballet boys behind will cheer the same as ever. They have been well drilled in their part; they know that the principal actor is up and that he has to be supported; but the tricks are getting a bit old, the audience is beginning to see through them, and there is the fact that he was proved wrong. He has faced two or three different ways in the last two years.
I have mentioned the food subsidies. What was the gist of his campaign and of his attack on the Government 18 months ago? "That the people were overtaxed; that the cost of living was too high; that we were borrowing money at a lunatic rate and were spending the borrowed money at an even greater rate of lunacy," the implication, of course, being: "Give us a chance and down will come the cost of living; the lunatic borrowing will be stopped and down will come taxation and expenditure." That was the attack made on us, and those were our crimes four years ago—borrowing money and spending it too quickly, taxation and the cost of living too high. Because of those crimes we were to be turfed out of public life.
With the same appearance of sincerity as we had here to-night, that was the gospel that was laid down—"the food subsidies are going to reduce the cost of living and we definitely cannot reduce them." Then he takes over, with all the money already borrowed and in the kitty. That money was borrowed not at 5¼ per cent. but at the cheapest rate at which money was ever borrowed here. Well over £20,000,000 was there. It had been left there unspent. Under £20,000,000 had been spent soundly and prudently by us in two years. We spent it in a way that got the admiration of the whole world. There was a special comment on the way that we spent it by the American European Mission. The balance that was left by us was spentin half the time that it took us to spend the sum I have mentioned, and then another £20,000,000 had to be borrowed by this Government. I do not say that that spending or that borrowing was unsound. We still stand, unlike the Taoiseach, for the things we stood for a couple of years ago—sound borrowing and investment of the money in sound projects. We do not change.
The next thing was the cost of living. The food subsidies were withdrawn. Up went the cost of living. The Prices Section of the Department of Industry and Commerce began to break down on their job. The hardest task we had for three years was to hold a line on the cost of living. It was a struggle that required whole-time alertness, where you had to turn your back on friends, where you had to turn your back on powerful syndicates and very mighty influences, but that line was held.
Those who had attacked us with regard to the cost of living and who then took over, what was their first despicable smoke-screen when they started, as the profiteers' pals, to let up the cost of living, what was the roguish, dishonest smoke-screen that they put up, knowing it could only be a temporary fog? That discredited lie that the cost of living rose immediately they took over because of the immense stack of recommendations in the Prices Advisory Body which were not acted on by me, but which I left for my unfortunate successor. With tears in their eyes they told the poor mugs that there was Deputy Lemass, the new Minister, trying to grope his way into his office amongst the stacks of files where the Prices Advisory Body had recommended increases and that were all left there for the new Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Diligently and persistently, parliamentary questions were put down week after week, the questioners knowing that civil servants do not lie and that in reply to a question the truth would come out. What came out? That the things remaining over where recommendations had been made and not dealt with were dried peas, beans, advertisements in certain newspapers, coal in certain provincial towns andmeat. That was the total. Those were the piles. Those were the stacks.
The next thing was that I was accused of getting into cahoots with the butchers and saying: "Charge what you like, boys; there will be no prosecutions." A lie that has a substratum, even a very thin line of truth at the foundation, is the most dangerous type of lie, the type of lie that is hardest to kill. That particular lie was used, spread and disseminated by the back bench boys at a time when I was not in a position to reply.
The facts were that I delayed acting on that recommendation which was for an increase all round in every lb. of meat over the whole beast. It was a recommendation that I was not prepared to approve of, no matter what it cost. The alternative claim was complete decontrol. That was more unthinkable, to give them a free hand to charge what they liked, the sky is the limit. That was the recommendation and that was the alternative claim.
At the same time, there was a certain amount of agitation about the low price fixed for hides as against the market price. I wanted to see to what extent I could meet part of the claim by giving a better price for hides, and during that couple of weeks' delay we got notice of two butchers caught overcharging and, by unanimous agreement at a departmental conference, we decided not to prosecute because the defence would be that the Prices Advisory Body had already recommended a substantial increase, and that was lying on my table. They wanted to get the whole thing investigated and explored, and during that fortnight there was no increase.
From that you get the build-up of the tale you had from the Minister for Industry and Commerce the other day. What was the gist, what was the point in the accusation? The point was, if everything he said was true, that, for a fortnight, I gave a free hand to the butchers. What was his action? To go in and investigate nothing, neither hides nor anything else, but to give a thing that was never contemplated— complete decontrol.
This is the second or third time thatI have contradicted those particular stories and I am not going to waste any more time. They will be repeated. To misquote an old saying: He who lies and runs away will live to lie another day and some people, certainly, will lie as centenarians.
The first charge against us was the excessive borrowing. The second was the high cost of living. The third was the high rate of taxation.
The British had their difficulties, quite different difficulties from those that we had. They had gone through a world war. They had come out with a mountain of debt. Their external trade was practically gone. Their livelihood in normal times was the sale externally of their industrial goods. They had to recapture the world market for the sale of their industrial goods. They had to reduce that mountain of debt. That was their problem.
Our problem was, if you like, the opposite. We had not a mountain of debt but we had a mountain of money and that mountain of money was paper money. For seven or eight years the country was starved of essential commodities—fertilisers, machinery, one hundred and one items of that kind. The solution of the British problem was to export more and more so as to reduce the mountain of debt. The solution of our problem was, within reason and within limits, the opposite—to convert a substantial amount of that paper money into goods of a durable kind, those that would increase production and those that were necessary in that direction.
But there was definitely a confusion between the British problems and the Irish problems. Even though our problems might be different and the solutions different, as a matter of prestige, etc., Great Britain would like to see us going the same road as they went. Therefore there was a conference between Mr. Butler and our Minister for Finance. Our Minister for Finance returned and this country had a deluge of Butlerism. We had austerity as severe as the Government could make it. We had it on all fronts—increased taxation, dearer money, restriction of credit, removal of subsidies, no matter whatthe consequence, a reduction of imports. Following the British line, keeping in perfect step, we had the Republican gosling doing the goose-step alongside Mr. Butler and his Commonwealth Ministers, although our situation was completely different.
Having taken that turn towards Butlerism, the Taoiseach and every one of them have had to change their tune. They have got to paint a different picture completely on the platform and in the Dáil from the one they had been painting six months earlier. With an air of conviction and simulated temper, with every appearance of sincerity, we had the Taoiseach making exactly opposite speeches from those which he had been making a few weeks before, but presenting himself as the only honest one amongst us, the only consistent person amongst us, and saying that we would all be on his side if we were only sufficiently honest. He makes the typical remark that we could do this if we were all of one mind. But history teaches us that the one mind must always be his mind and then, of course, there can always be agreement, but in any other set of conditions there cannot be agreement.
The Taoiseach tells us, too, that in fact taxation does not matter; that taxation does not matter as long as it is for current purposes; that in fact it all goes back; that it is merely taking it from the people and giving it back to the people again. That is the kind of stuff you would hear in an infant school. The cost of ammunition for the Army is current expenditure. We handed out £1,000,000 for ammunition. That is all going back into the pockets of the people in Macroom and elsewhere. We buy Tulyar and send the money out to India and "Mrs. Mulligan" will get the benefit of that.
We have that kind of talk here which is entirely unworthy of the Taoiseach and the position he occupies and the fact that we are dealing with a record-breaking Book of Estimates. The £100,000,000 mark is passed. That is a landmark behind us. We pass that with this Book of Estimates and we are facing into the straight now for the second £100,000,000. Commensurate with the growth there, we havethe cost of living going up into the stratosphere, to a great extent by the deliberate and calculated actions of the Government. We have the removal of subsidies, increased prices of butter and milk, decontrol of the essential commodities of livelihood, a licence to rob being given all round the place, with the cost of living reaching fantastic heights by the deliberate and calculated actions of the Government; with taxation, on the other hand, taking more out of the pockets of the people than they ever thought they would have to subscribe, with credit withdrawn and restricted, with the number of unemployed keeping steady and with the jump in our public expenditure.
In that situation we have them talking about expensive Health Bills. What is the good of spending millions on better health services if you double the price of butter, jump up the price of milk, jump up the price of meat, jump down the incomes of the people and put tens and tens of thousands more of them out of work? The best health measure that could be taken is to see that the people get all the necessaries of life. The way things are going, the one bit of expenditure under the Health Bill that will be more necessary in the future than it was in the past will be for the increased and rapid expansion of our hospital services.
Comment on this
Nobody who has spoken on this Vote on Account has denied that a very serious economic situation confronts us. It would be futile to deny that that situation exists and calls for early attention. It would be equally futile for Deputies to waste the time of the House and the money of the taxpayers by trying to fix responsibility for that situation. I do not think that that matter is important. What is really important is, how we are to remedy that situation. On neither the Government nor the Opposition side has it been suggested that the situation is not serious. But, frankly, I have not heard up to the present any remedy that holds out any prospect for the ordinary people of the country for the next 12 months.
I think I detected in the speech of the Taoiseach this evening what is, ina measure, responsible for that situation. He said that to increase taxation is the only way to increase revenue. I disagree with him entirely, and I confess I am astonished at the Taoiseach, after his long experience in public life and in Government, making such a statement, because the very facts this year prove how wrong that opinion is. Anybody who read the report of the recent meeting of the Licensed Vintners' and Grocers' Association knows quite well that that is an erroneous policy. If you want to increase revenue, you will not necessarily increase it by increased taxation, but by increasing the spending power of the citizen so that he will purchase these commodities on which the revenue tax is put.
That is the sensible approach. I have often wondered why this Government failed so badly during the past year and now I pin that failure down to the fact that the Government acted on the principle that one cannot produce revenue without increasing taxation. That is the kernel of the present mistaken policy and it will be a sorry day for the people if the Government continues to pursue that policy.
Rising taxation and rising expenditure have been bewailed by people on both sides of the House. High taxation is not in itself an evil so long as the national income keeps abreast of that taxation and so long as it does not impose an intolerable burden on the citizens. In fact, far from being an evil, it might be a good thing. It must be a good thing to have increased Government expenditure but one must always ensure that the people providing that expenditure are in a position to pay and there must be a corresponding increase in the national income.
Any Government at any time can reduce taxation. The present Government could reduce taxation. The last Government did. The present Government could reduce taxation by removing the social services the State provides. Would anybody suggest that would be a good remedy? The acid test of a Government's success will be gauged by the extent of its taxation provided revenue remains buoyant andprovided the citizens are in a position to pay for the amenities. In that case one has no reason for worry.
Our present problem is mainly due to rising prices and rising prices call for immediate and early attention. The last Government set up the Prices Advisory Body. As far as one can see their activities are confined to dealing with applications for increases. I think it is time they got to work to see whether there cannot be reductions in prices. The prices charged to-day for many household commodities cannot be justified. The staple food, bread and flour, is one item in which there should be drastic reductions and the Prices Advisory Body should be directed to investigate the profits being made by the flour millers. There are many other household commodities which could clearly be reduced in price. It is obvious from the variations which occur from shop to shop that there is room for reductions.
That is the obvious way in which to solve the problem of the cost of living. It is childish to suggest that one can meet the effect of rising costs by increasing wages because invariably wage increases are passed on to the consumer. Prices must have reached a ceiling by this. It is time they took a downward trend. I suggest that is a matter for consideration by the Prices Advisory Body. I know cases can be made for increases particularly in connection with imported goods. There are, however, commodities produced within the country from our own natural resources and the prices at which these are retailed to the consumer should be examined.
The Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance have on various occasions admitted that agriculture is our basic industry. I do not think the Taoiseach or the Minister for Finance has altered his opinion in that regard. The Tánaiste has, however, altered his opinion because for a long time he was inclined to shove agriculture into the second place. I am glad he now recognises he can no longer do that. Long after the Tánaiste and I have passed away agriculture will remain the predominant industry here. Recognising that fact the Government should now concentrate its efforts on puttingthe soil into a condition where it will produce the maximum of our requirements. Hitherto the facilities to operate the land in order to bring about that situation have not been placed at the disposal of our farmers.
People talk about our adverse trade balance. Has anyone stopped to consider what that adverse balance would be if we did not have our agricultural exports? What situation would the country be in were it not for our agricultural exports? Even Deputy Hickey could hardly contemplate that situation with complacence. Every schoolboy knows that agriculture is our main industry. Recognising that, is it not a cause of grave dissatisfaction that when economies had to be effected this year they were done in relation to the soil? The Government has reduced the grants under the Local Authorities (Works) Act by £250,000. They have, at the same time, increased the grants for land rehabilitation. Everybody knows that these two schemes are inter-dependent and one cannot operate successfully without the other. The Government is not approaching this matter in a sensible way when it curtails the money given to local authorities to put the main outfall in a proper condition in order to drain the farmers' land.
Comment on this
We will not go into that now. It is a waste of money increasing the grants for land reclamation if work under the Local Authorities (Works) Act is cut down. If one adopts my theory that rising taxation is in itself an evil the natural corollary to that is that one must keep as many people as possible in the country to pay taxation, and for that reason one must stem emigration.
Emigration is not entirely due to economics. In the area from which I come emigration is a terrible drain, and it has been particularly noticeable during the last five or six years. I think the reason for it is more or less social. Some of the people who emigrate are not those out of employment. Many go for the sake ofemployment. Many others go because employment in England is more congenial. A certain percentage goes because Irishmen are following their natural bent of wanting to see more of the world. There is the remainder who must, through force of economic circumstances, cross to England. I suggest that, in the West of Ireland, work could be found at home for those who follow mainly manual, outdoor work if a proper afforestation system were developed there.
As long as I can remember, people have been demandng the planting of a belt of trees from Donegal down the west coast to Kerry. It was not altogether for the purpose of employment or for the purpose entirely of stopping emigration. There are people who believe, rightly or wrongly, that the climate we have here would be improved and the vast amount of rain which falls lessened, if a proper shelter belt were planted down the west coast of Ireland. To what extent that is true I am not in a position to say but I have heard intelligent people admitting that there was something in it.
Whether that be a sufficient reason in itself or not, I consider there are certain justifications for it in other respects. First of all, you would provide employment for the very people who could most usefully be put to that type of employment. At the same time you are building up the national assets because in 20 or 25 years' time the trees you plant there will yield a good capital profit and they will provide the basis for different kinds of employment in that particular area which has been neglected for a long number of years. That is the area from which most of the emigration takes place.
If the Government were to decide to provide in this Estimate a huge sum of money for that purpose I do not think any Deputy on this side of the House would oppose it. That is the type of expenditure to which I would subscribe even though it swelled the national taxation bill because I believe you are providing the very basis of a sound economy for a country which could not only provide £150,000,000 butconsiderably more because the national income and the spending power of the citizens would be increasing; consequently the imposition of taxation would not be felt. Even high prices are not evil provided you have sufficient income to buy essential commodities. I have often said this to people: "Is it better to have a loaf of bread available at 6d. if you have only 3d. in your pocket or a loaf available at 1/- if you have 2/6?"
That is the way we must approach this problem. Monetary values have changed very considerably over the past five or six years. I do not think there is anyone foolish enough to suggest that we will ever revert to prewar standards. The people must adjust their minds to the money alterations. To sigh for the days when 1/- or £1 would buy so much more than it will buy to-day, is just waste of time. It is not at all likely that prices will revert to the comparatively low level of 1939. After all, if you compare the level of 1939 with the level of 1914 you get another shock. Every war seems to produce its own effects on the purchasing power of money and probably when the next war is over people will be sighing for the good old days of 1952-53.
The Taoiseach said it is permissible to use our assets provided they can be used productively. Frankly, I have no recollection that there was any use made of our external assets within the past 12 months. That is one of the greatest grievances we have. When any farmer of the country thinks that as a result of his labour from the year 1939 to 1945 or 1946, we built up something in the region of £400,000,000 or £500,000,000 credit in Great Britain, and he is told to-day that money is being utilised to improve the British farmers' land, to provide houses for the British people and to do all the things he wants to do at home, I do not think you could expect him to approve of that policy.
We have still considerable assets in England. We know that those assets are being used to develop the British farmers' land by way of grants, to provide houses and hospitals and weknow there is a shortage of money here for these purposes. It is time that we liquidated our external assets in the interests of our own people. I thoroughly agree with all Deputy Dr. O'Higgins has said, that from the point of view of public health and national health there are a few essentials. A man must have a good house for his children and good food. He must have good clothing for them and a decent school to which to send them. If he has those requirements I think God and nature and the child will provide for public health. But if you have a child reared in a bad house on bad food, with scanty clothing, no amount of expenditure of public money will make that child a strong and healthy one. We are moving in the wrong direction. We are putting the cart before the horse. Until we have arrived at a situation where every man has a good house for his children and has the necessary money to provide them with good food and clothing, there is no use in talking about spending millions of pounds of public money. Prevention is at all times better than cure and it is very false economy to allow a situation to exist which produces the very evils which we must spend millions of pounds to eradicate. It is a far better proposition to ensure that those diseases would not grow and then there would be no necessity for this expenditure on their eradication.
I do not wish to detain the House any longer on this matter. Lest I should not have an opportunity later, I would direct the Minister's attention to what I would call a serious error in economising to the extent of £250,000 in relation to local authorities works. Good work was being done under that particular scheme, and good work remains to be done. The restoration of that £250,000 might mean bringing into full production a goodly number of acres of land that are now no use to the State or the owner, and would be a far better proposition than expenditure in other directions.
Comment on this
Having listened to the leading speakers of both major political parties, it would indeed be very presumptuous for an independentDeputy to stand up to prove that he had a cure for the obvious evils which have tried the ingenuity of the best brains and the best abilities which have been from time to time in the last 30 years at the disposal of different Governments. I do not propose to do so. I should like merely, on this Vote on Account, to take my opportunity of attempting to influence to whatever extent I can the policy of the Government in a democratic Parliament. I think in this regard that one can answer to a certain extent Deputy Sheldon's motion. We must have regard and respect for the motion which has been put down by Deputy Sheldon because he has had a long experience during his membership of the Public Accounts Committee, on which, I understand, he has done extremely good work. I feel that a similar purpose to that which he is trying to achieve is at present being served—the "vetting" of Estimates and their reduction to a minimum consonant with the carrying out of policy. Here we have an opportunity on the Vote on Account of trying to halt the Minister in mid-air, as it were, in the process of framing his Budget, in the process of implementing his policy, and of formulating his proposals for the year to come.
I supported the Minister's policy last year with my eyes open. There were certain aspects of which, obviously, I, as an individual, might have disapproved. At the same time I think it is very unwise, and it would be very wrong of any Party to refuse to give a trial to the financial policy of the Government in power. What we must do now is to try to review the effects of that policy and to find out from the Minister whether he is quite content about the effects which his policy has achieved, and if he proposes to continue that policy, generally speaking.
I suggested in my Budget speech last year that it was not really possible to get away with a deflationary Budget. I suggested at the time that the inevitable result of last year's Budget would be—a result which has since taken place—a fairly substantialincrease in wages all round. Short of a stand-still policy for all wages, a deflationary policy by any Government was quite impossible. The increases in wages have had certain effects. The result has been an increase in the cost to the consumer, of the product of the industries concerned, the mopping up of excess moneys which might have been available to the consumer, a restriction in buying, the reduction in trade to which Deputy Dockrell referred, the laying-off of workers and that deflationary vicious circle to which I have already referred. I am not an economist, and do not pretend to be an economist, but a deflationary circle of that kind appears to me to be an equally dangerous event facing any Government. The Government have to face that situation now.
I have listened to the apologies of the different leading speakers for the Government. It is their job to gild the lily to the best of their ability, to put a good face on things, to reassure the people that things are not quite as bad as they imagine them to be. I was interested in the attempt made by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. He appears to have a magnificent facility in the manipulation of figures—I say that as no reflection on him—in such a way as simply to prove anything.
Let us accept the case made by Government speakers that unemployment is not as high as it is represented to be. The number of unemployed is about 90,000. A whole lot of trick-of-the-loop explanations have been put forward to prove that it is not quite 90,000. Let us agree with them that it is 80,000, or even go further along the road with them and say that it is 70,000, or come down to the inter-Party figure of 60,000. Surely if you go back even as far as that— and we are not invited to go that far— it is a completely reprehensible state of affairs that there are 60,000, 70,000, 80,000 or 90,000 unemployed. I do not mind what the figure is but you have that number of unemployed men, men willing and able to give their contribution to the building-up of the wealth of the community and they are denied that right by the ineptitude of whatever Government is in power. It doesnot matter what Government. I am criticising both Governments equally.
I think one of the dangers of a discussion of this kind in a democratic Parliament of this nature is that the Government distrusts the Opposition, probably with a certain amount of justification, because the Opposition's job is not to make things comfortable; it is to criticise, to make the best capital they can out of the situation, in the honest or dishonest belief—it does not matter which—that they would do better if given the chance. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs quoted many figures to demonstrate that things were not quite as bad as they seemed—figures in relation to housing, land development and agricultural statistics of different kinds, the general claim being that these capital investments of different kinds had increased during the two years' office of the Government.
In passing I should like to say that I think he was being a little unfair to the late Deputy Timothy Murphy, in his references to the housing programme. I think he was the man who was responsible for the planning of a long-term housing programme which, as the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs well knows, is a programme which gradually moves away and has little or nothing to do with the Minister of the time after the initial organisation has taken place. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs made one other rather frightening remark, and that was that the housing drive was falling away in the natural way—that it had nothing to do with the restriction of credit or any action of the Government but was due to the fact that our housing needs are largely becoming filled. He then went on to say that the inter-Party Government had left no plans to take up the slack of the unemployment which is inevitable. I consider that to be a very unfair and unrealistic comment. Two years is a long time: one and a half years is a longish time. Anticipation of this falling-off in employment in the building industry was a relatively simple thing. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has always told us with facility of the plans which weredrawn up in the emergency years, and which could be put into operation on the pressing of a button, to provide employment in the different aspects of our industries throughout the country.
I think it is the duty of the Government, once it takes over, to plan ahead, to look ahead. A Government can live from day to day or from year to year. A weakness in all our Governments is that we do not plan on, say, a five or a seven year basis. It is ridiculous for a Government to run, as we do, on a year to year basis without considering that the absorption of employment by different industries must tend to stop —as is happening now in the case of the building industry and some other projects. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs tried to console us also with the reflection that all the other countries—even countries with Socialist Governments—are finding themselves in much the same position. I do not think that is a completely fair statement. Most of the other countries in Europe have just been through a devastating war. Socialists, Conservatives, Liberals, Radicals—whatever they were—spent millions of pounds blasting one another to bits throughout Europe. That is none of our business now but it was an expensive pastime while it lasted. They had to reorganise their industries and to arrange the redistribution of the working potential towards the reconstruction of their States. There was a rebuilding of their factories and a re-establishment of their industries. They had all these preoccupations. In addition in the Socialist countries, at any rate—if they are hard up to-day they are hard up with excellent conditions of employment for their people, excellent educational facilities and excellent health services. They have spent a lot of money. Many of them are hard up but their people have known the benefit of the money which has been well spent. I am afraid we cannot say that we have a similar situation here.
When one is in Government one has friends who think that the sun shines out of you, who tell you everything you want to hear until you are sick of it. That is the case, no matter what Government may be in office. Then thereare your natural enemies—the Opposition; you cannot blame them. When a problem has defeated you, you tend to put the best side on it for public consumption. The tragedy is when you believe the fairy stories which you are putting across for public consumption. I think a little bit of this extraordinary insensitiveness to the unemployment figures by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs arises from his lack of appreciation of what unemployment means. Possibly, it has the same effect that we have often seen in regard to headlines about devastation from bombing during war time, and so forth. "A hundred thousand people bombed out of their homes,""Floods in Western Europe,""War in Korea," and so forth.
These headlines scarcely move you at all, but if you see a child knocked down by a car you realise in a flash the appalling hardship that affects people as a result of such a catastrophe. I think it is somewhat similar in relation to unemployment. People get so used to hearing about 60,000, 70,000, 80,000 or 90,000 unemployed that they do not realise that it means that 90,000 men are anxious to work to support their families but are deprived of the opportunity of doing so. It is the Government's job to find that opportunity for them. I know many a man in my own area who, if he is not already unemployed, is facing unemployment. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs agrees, apparently, that unemployment will increase. Apparently, too, there are no plans which would help to take up the slack as a result of the falling-off in the building of houses. Consequently, more people will become unemployed. I do not think the position is disastrous but it is terribly serious. It cannot be solved by digging your head in the sand. I would remind the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs that the political ostrich with his head in the sand is in a very delicate position vis-á-visthe public, especially during a general election or some similar occasion. He is quite at liberty to defend the Government: that is his job. He gave the impression, however, that these realproblems had not sunk deeply into his understanding and that, having explained the position here, having overcome the problems, having solved our difficulties by producing sets of figures, he could then go off and finish his job in Radio Éireann.
An aspect of our financial policy to which I should like to refer is the feeling that the attitude of the Department of Finance to financial matters is one which they appear to have assimilated from too close contact with what Deputy Dillon calls his Treasury counterparts across the water. I deprecate in the strongest terms any attempt, even by innuendo, to attack Civil Service groups: I think it is quite unforgivable. The suggestion that any Minister is dominated by his civil servants is an insult to ourselves because we appoint the Ministers—and I have no intention of doing it. At the same time, there is the impression abroad that we are trying to run Ireland on lines very similar to those adopted in Great Britain. I think the Opposition made a fair case for the suggestion that Tory policies in the last Budget in Great Britain had a considerable effect on policies here.
I do not think that is very important at this stage, but I have been slightly worried by references which I have read recently to this question of taxation—that the burden of taxation has reached its limit. We have heard the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Costello, and Deputy Dr. O'Higgins refer to that. Reference has also been made to it by the Taoiseach and other Government speakers. My attitude to taxation generally is this: that, where you have quite satisfied yourself that there is no wastage in the administration of the money raised through taxation from the community for the maintenance of State services, it is money which the taxpayers have contributed because they are conscious of their responsibility to the weaker members of the community— that is to say, to provide good conditions for our old people in their own homes or in the institutions, to provide good conditions in our hospitals, good health services, old age pensions,widows' and orphans' pensions, and other amenities.
I am not one who is terribly moved by the vehement rejection of increased taxation, which we have had from both sides of the House. I know, of course, that it is a popular political catchcry on which to go to the people who are paying the taxation by saying to them: "We will reduce it." It is likely to get votes. At the same time, I think that, if you are going to establish a social order in our society here, it must be accepted that taxation, direct or indirect, will have to be maintained at a very high rate.
It has been suggested that the taxation of industry is too heavy and will have to be mitigated to some extent. I have read that ad nauseamin the English Tory newspapers about the situation in Great Britain, of Mr. Butler going from one end of England to the other and in the House of Parliament there and continually saying that industry is over taxed, that the burden on it is too heavy. That may be true of Great Britain. I have not sufficient knowledge of the situation there to speak with any authority on that subject, but I think it would be quite wrong if we were to take that suggestion from Great Britain, and from their Chancellor of the Exchequer, and accept that it must be axiomatic, that it is a cure for our ills here.
Let us not fool ourselves about our industries. Our industries are wonderful and grand things to have, but they are largely pocket industries, largely, as I have said, subsidiaries of English companies which have come in here to get the protection of our tariffs and quotas. They are not our main source of revenue or our main source of employment. Consequently, to order your fiscal policy on the assumption that what is good for England is good for Ireland is I think, completely erroneous, and is likely to lead to disastrous results.
If it is the policy to have a reduction in indirect taxation, that is all to the good, but I doubt very much if a good case can be made for a reduction in direct taxation on people in industry who are already doing pretty well forthemselves. Most of our industrialists— I am not one of their greatest critics— have, I think, been doing pretty well for themselves. Consequently, if there is not any likelihood of a mitigation of taxation, they are, I think, the people who should bear most of the burden, and not the lower income groups, or the old age pensioners, the widows, orphans and others.
On this question of tax relief, I feel that it is not a necessarily sound suggestion for adoption here. The Minister may be able to give us an explanation as to how the question of tax relief can be reconciled with his continuous exhortations to save. Tax relief will allow more money into circulation, and in that way will prevent people from saving—the objective which the Minister has in mind.
I listened with particular care to Deputy Costello, the Leader of the Opposition, in order to hear the policies of the Fine Gael Party expounded. I also heard Deputy T. F. O'Higgins on the same subject. I am quite prepared to believe that miracles can happen. The English Tory Party of to-day is only a pale shadow of what that Party was 20 years ago. It is possible that you can get a progressive Fine Gael Party. I believe, as I have said, that miracles can happen. Consequently, I was prepared to hear that the Fine Gael Party had a solution for our present ills. I must be forgiven for being sceptical and cynical of them, but, at the same time, I am not sufficiently sceptical or cynical not to believe that they could not turn over a new leaf.
The conditions put forward by Deputy Costello seemed to resolve themselves into the repatriation of sterling assets, of having increased savings here and of the investment of those savings in a prudent way, and in the establishment of money markets. There was an important condition which was not dealt with at any length, and that was the emendation of the Central Bank Act. First of all, I could get no views at all, good, bad or indifferent, on this question of subsidies. He admitted that the wage increases appeared to have met to a certain extent the taking away of the subsidies. At the same time, Fine Gaeldo not appear to have any clear policy in relation to those subsidies, whether they are going to restore the subsidies, even in an attenuated form, or completely to the level at which they were before the Minister took over, that is, if they were ever returned by the people again into power.
My difficulty, of course is, that Deputy Costello insists, as a good Tory must insist, that taxation is already too heavy and must be reduced. I have asked a number of very reputable economists about this matter. The question I put to them last year, when Fine Gael said it was possible, was, how could you reduce taxation or keep taxation at its present level and restore subsidies? I understand that it is impossible. If it is not impossible, I am prepared to be convinced that it is possible but nobody on the Fine Gael benches has made any attempt to convince me that it is possible. Consequently and naturally I must remain unconvinced.
The repatriation of sterling assets and the prudent investment of funds is a tremendously important proposition. There is nothing new in it. It has gone on for some time. I see difficulties with it. Under Marshall Aid a lot of money was made available to the inter-Party Government, of which I was a member. A lot of that money was spent in the country. It was pumped into circulation. There was this great drawback that I saw in it. What the country needed at the time and still needs was what you might call a blood transfusion, and, instead of that, it got what you might call a champagne cocktail. I may explain it in this way. I think the Minister for Finance at the time was very anxious that the money should be spent in a prudent way, but the trouble was that the only people who seemed to want to take up the dollars were the wireless-set sellers, the luxury consumer goods sellers, the washing-machine people, the lipstick and hair-curler sellers. Money was put into all these silly things, which, of course, could not make any contribution at all to the betterment of the community generally. It appeared that the people who sell these productscould use the money and that the tractor owners, the farm equipment retailers, for whatever reason, could not use that money. They were perfectly at liberty to use it if they wanted to, but, whatever the cause, that money did not go into the projects which most of the then Government had at heart, the buying of farm equipment, the land.
Nobody has explained to me how it will be possible, in our free economy, to insist that, if you do get another large loan, if you do raise large sums of money by an intensive savings campaign or if you do lay your hand on more of the sterling assets, that the money will be prudently spent. It has not been demonstrated to me by Deputy Costello or any of the Fine Gael speakers how they will ensure that that money will be prudently spent. Of course, the alternative, money imprudently spent, has tremendous political attractions — the wonderful feeling of plenty of money in circulation which, I am afraid, the American Loan did give, plenty of luxury goods in the shops, plenty of buying and selling, plenty of people employed in the distributive and drapery trade—a completely unhealthy economy. Most of the things were produced by America or Great Britain. They kept young Americans and young Britons in occupations, but they did nothing at all to produce a healthy economy in Ireland. It just gave that superficial facade of prosperity which is all very pleasant. Now, there is no doubt about it, the Government has right on its side there.
Now the hangover, now the realisation that that money was borrowed money, not one penny of which should have gone in any way except the creation of wealth, either by capital goods in industry or the mechanisation of agriculture. That of course seems to me to be one of the major problems facing the country, it does not matter which Government is in power —the fact that they have no right of direction or no right of control of the expenditure of money, no matter how much they may like to have it.
It is silly of the Opposition to accuse the Government of deliberately having created unemployment. It is aludicrous suggestion. No sane politician who has to face the public, as the members of the Government will have to do, would deliberately create times of shortage or of unemployment or of restrictive credit or any of these other things. At the same time, it is wrong of the Government to say that unemployment, restricted credit or emigration are not the results of their policy. I do not think that is quite fair either. If there had been a considerable rise in employment figures and a reduction in emigration, the Government would have been quick, and rightly quick, to claim the credit for those improvements in the state of the country. While they would be at liberty to claim credit for those improvements if they had taken place, I am afraid they cannot evade their responsibility in relation to the rise in unemployment figures which has taken place over the last year.
I said in the beginning that I have no remedy, mythical or otherwise, that I can put forward as being guaranteed to solve the problems of the country. It is no use for the Government to tell the Opposition that they did not do any better or for the Opposition merely to criticise without being constructive at the same time. The responsibility rests on the shoulders of the men in power and they must freely and fully accept that responsibility.
We do tend to become rather too interested in the clever dialectics of this whole business of parliamentary control, democratic government, and to overlook the fact that our failures in government have disastrous, serious, hurtful and painful results on our people.
One of the most serious results which everybody foretold was in relation to the food subsidies. I wonder if the Minister would explain a statement in relation to the food subsidies which was made by the Minister for Lands, as reported in column 442 of the Official Report for the 13th March, in which he said:—
"The food subsidies were only cut down by over £4,000,000, but the Government lost more by the provision of the compensatory benefits to the sections of the community most in need, to the extent even of1/6 per week per person. These benefits cost the Exchequer more than it gained by the reduction in the food subsidies...."
That to me is rather a peculiar statement. If that is true, I cannot see why the Government, as a sane, adult political Party which is a long time on the road, should have gone to the extraordinary strategem, having removed the food subsidies, of paying out that money. What did they gain by the removal of the food subsidies? The political results, of course, were disastrous. Many of the results took effect before the compensatory rise in wages. Why were these hardships imposed by the Government, if, as they must have anticipated, the consequences would just be the same in the end, that they would lose the same amount in the end? There may be an explanation for that, but I should like to hear it, because it was forecast by people that the removal of the subsidies would have to be met. It seems to me an extraordinary operation which was carried out with very little apparent benefit and that it was a disastrous, hurtful and harmful measure.
For what it is worth, I will try to offer constructive or helpful suggestions to the extent that I can. Our problem is a very serious one and must be solved. Other nations have done it before. There is no doubt that the solution of our problem needs more than just good intentions. Nobody, I presume, has any doubt as to the good intentions of the Minister and the Government. I think they have the best interests of the people at heart. They have shown that in the past. But it does need more than good intentions in running the country; you must show results as well. Listening to the Taoiseach, I could not help feeling that the most important matter is not whether the Government policy is the same or very much the same as that of the Opposition. I do not give a damn whether it is or not. The only interest I have is whether the policy works, and the policy of the last year, I respectfully submit, has not worked. I believe that the results of the policy have been too serious for many of ourpeople to allow anybody to feel in any way complacent about it.
In the solution of the problem, they might go back to the problem facing the late Mr. Roosevelt in America in 1929 and 1930, when he adopted the device of getting together a "brains trust", as he called it, in an attempt to provide employment by capital projects of different kinds, such as the Tennessee Valley projects and projects of that nature. As to afforestation, our approach to that has not been as dynamic as it could have been. A tremendous amount of wealth lay there if previous Governments had attacked that problem in a forthright way.
Then there is another thorny problem, the use of turf or coal. One of the things which the Minister and the Government have done is that, without doubt, they have given us a hair-shirt policy. I do not think any people worth their salt mind stringency, mind a hard time or short rations. No nation has ever minded that if they knew that these things would pass and that there would be an end to them. When Sir Stafford Cripps was dealing with the British people they went on short commons. They went without the luxuries which we wallowed in at the time, with the proviso that there would be an end to these short commons. He promised that the results of his policy would be a better life for them and for their children. That, I think, is what we have felt, that we have had restriction, that we have had a hard time and hardship. I do not think anybody minds these things very much as long as they know there is to be an end to them. Listening to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs the other night, I do not think he anticipated that there will be an end to them. He anticipated a further rise in unemployment.
I want to make a suggestion in relation to the use of turf. I believe that any other nation facing such a problem as ours would not allow coal into the country—I represent a city constituency where this, I think, will be unpopular—as long as there wasturf available, which is a good fuel, and which is produced from the sweat and labour of our own people and which can work boilers and machinery and keep our industries going. That has been demonstrated in Athlone. Anything that can provide employment for our people, particularly in rural Ireland, is a sound policy and is worthy of consideration. I know that that is a terribly unpopular proposal to make, but it will provide more employment for our young men in the rural areas.
Some group of experts should be there to advise the Minister. I am sure most of our experts would be very willing to help in any way they could as to useful capital projects designed to provide employment, apart altogether from their overall value to the nation. The hydro-electric and the turbo-electric schemes are somewhat lackadaisical, perhaps, in their progress at the moment. I see no reason why many more such schemes should not be put into operation simultaneously. I see no reason why more rapid progress could not be made in that direction.
Industry is in the very capable hands of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He certainly needs no advice. I doubt if any Government has the courage to tackle the main problem with which we are confronted. I doubt if any Government is prepared to take the risks involved in relation to increasing the productivity of our land. The farmers have many loud-mouthed and articulate advocates here. They have plenty of people to defend them. I am interested only in facts and in finding a solution to our present problem. I have no particular animus against any group or section.
Irish agriculture is stagnant. It has been so for many years past. No real attempt has been made to increase production under any Government. Everybody knows my views on social services. It is not realistic for people to talk of social services and a proper social order until a solution has been found to our present problem by the creation of new wealth. Nobody seems to consider that aspect of the problem at all. Each Minister for Finance triesto go on performing the miracle of the loaves and fishes, dividing the same amount of money between larger and larger groups of people demanding better health and social services, increased old age pensions and blind pensions, improved educational facilities and so on. It is absurd to think that these aims can ever reach fruition unless there is a vast increase in the national wealth of the community. It is only playing with the problem to say that taxation has reached its limits, that there is no more money and that we must cut down on social services. That is an evasion of our problem.
The whole world is giving better social services to its people. Our people will demand such services. They will expect to get them. It is no use blaming them for wanting them because they will go on wanting them and they will go on blaming whoever is in power for not giving them. One cannot possibly give them in the present context of our national resources. Like a benevolent parent both sides of the House are anxious to give our people the best possible in every sphere of activity, social, educational, health and so forth. The cost of living is rising and our income is fixed. That is a problem which relates to everyone in his or her own private life just as much as it relates to the Government.
Neither side has said how the national wealth can be increased. One must do something about agriculture. One must tax the farmers. One must get more of the money that passes between farmers at fairs and that never goes near the banks. Everybody knows that that money is there. Everybody denies it is there. Nobody will make any attempt to get it. The larger part of our farming community pays no income tax. It is living in the 18th century. Yet, it is the farmers who get free grants and all sorts of other benefits provided for them, which Deputy Finan wants increased still further.
Comment on this
It is quite obvious that no attempt has been made to cut into the one real source of wealth in the country, the wealth that can be created from the land by the proper utilisation of the land and by the establishment of co-operative holdings. The present small holding is not an economic unit. The owner of such a holding cannot produce food at competitive prices. New Zealand can undersell the Irish farmer in relation to butter after shipping it across the world. The same is true of other commodities produced from the land. Some other country can always undersell us.
This is largely due to the failure of farming policy. It may be due to the fact that the farmer has not enough capital in some cases. It may be due to the fact that he cannot lay his hands on sufficient capital. It may be due to the fact that he is not prepared to sink whatever capital he has in his farm. It may be due to the fact that he has not the proper know-how. It may be due to the fact that his farm is not big enough. Agricultural policy has failed. The present Government has created no new approach. The present Minister has given us no reason to hope that he will increase the output from the land. There are too many large holdings not being worked at the present time. That is true of County Wicklow. It is also true of the Midlands, of Meath and Kildare and other counties as well. These people should not be allowed to continue sitting on the land. The land should be taken from them on the payment of proper compensation and given to those who are prepared to use it in order to produce the wealth we so badly need.
It is no good dodging around the problem. We must face it. We must accept it. There can be no increase in our standard of living, no real improvement in our social services, no real advance in any social sphere until we accept as axiomatic the fact that wehave a reserve of wealth waiting to be worked, waiting to produce, waiting to swell the nation's coffers so that we can give our people the things our people need.
I throw out these suggestions in order to remove the gag that is put on any discussion in relation to the land. Let somebody find a solution for our problem. Let somebody do something about our land. We are at the moment talking in vacuo.We are having a magnificent time with University dialectics, spitting fire at one another and doing nothing to solve the problem of the unemployed man who only asks for three meals a day and a job so that he can stay at home and support his family and not have to emigrate. We are doing nothing to give our people the things our people need, the things that we deny them at present. That is the first responsibility of any Government. That is the main responsibility facing the Government in the coming financial year.
Comment on this
It is, if I may say so, a privilege to speak after Deputy Dr. Browne's very thoughtful contribution to this debate. In the last part of his speech he mentioned the farming community and that there were many loud-mouthed and articulate representatives of that community in the House. I represent a constituency which is composed in large measure of small farmers and I am sure Deputy Dr. Browne would be interested to know that I agree with a great deal of what he has said. It is dangerous in these matters to speak in a way that might be misunderstood; worse still in a way that might be misrepresented by your political opponents. I do hope that whatever remarks I make now will be accepted in the same spirit as Deputy Dr. Browne's remarks were made.
It does not become a politician ever to sermonise and I certainly will make no attempt to sermonise. I cannot help remembering the message of the Gospel of the national feast day about the men who were sent out with different numbers of talents, one with five, one with three, and a third who was given only one. You all know thestory of the man who was given one talent and who put it in the ground and hid it. Deputy Dr. Browne threw out several suggestions to explain the lack of productivity by the farming community of this country and among them he mentioned the failure to utilise capital which they have. He also mentioned lack of capital.
It is undoubtedly true, and I do not think this statement will be denied by my political opponents, that very many of the smallest farming families in the West of Ireland have large sums of money at their back, usually, unfortunately, in the bank. It would be idle to suggest that this money was made out of the land which they own. It is the proceeds of decades of contributions by sons and daughters who have emigrated to America and England.
I very strongly agree with Deputy Dr. Browne that the small farming community and the middle farming community of the West of Ireland and elsewhere are burying their talents in the ground. They are keeping their money in the stocking because they are afraid to speculate it. There is usually a reason why a man should have money and should be afraid to speculate it. The reason, I submit, why these men are afraid to use the money which most of them undoubtedly have lies in the heritage of several centuries of occupation. It is not easy for a man to make the transition from servitude to freedom. It is not easy for a man to root out an attitude to life which has permeated his forbears for many generations. It can hardly be denied that if a man possessed a little wealth in the olden days the best, the safest and, in fact, the only course he could take was to hide that fact from the world at large. If it were known he had anything or if he showed by his industry that he was possessed of anything other than the merest essentials of life, his landlords or some other grabbing class who controlled him saw to it that he would be made pay.
In many other respects the Irish people have yet fully to realise that we now, in fact, are free. Most of the younger generations find it difficult to realise that what we are fighting fornow is the economic independence of the country, not portion of the British Empire or the British Commonwealth but their own free, independent, republican country to which each one of them not only can make a contribution but, if he can, is in duty bound to do so.
I do hope that my remarks in this respect will not be deliberately misunderstood or deliberately misinterpreted by my political opponents. The Clann na Talún Party, which is supposed to represent the farming community, has always inveighed against the people mentioned by Deputy Dr. Browne, the big ranchers of the Midlands and of certain portions of the West of Ireland. I do not intend to bring this debate back to the mudslinging level by saying that nothing very significant was done in their term of office as compared with what was done previously or subsequently. I will say that I have thought both Governments could concentrate more on afforestation.
I am very pleased to notice that the Estimate for expenditure for afforestation for the year 1953-54 has been increased not only beyond the figure for 1952-53 but also beyond any previous figure. I do think it is a great pity that any Deputy should try to make the case that this Government is not making any effort as regards afforestation and is cutting down upon the quota. It is simply not true to say that and I strongly submit that whatever Government is in power should double and redouble its efforts in this particular direction.
Another remark made by Deputy Dr. Browne was to the effect that in his opinion no nation minds stringency or having to do without things provided they know that there will be an end to it, provided they know that when the end does come, their sacrifices will have been worthwhile.
The Irish people have always shown that they are particularly well adapted to meeting emergencies when they know that the end aimed at is worth fighting for. I have the greatest confidence in the ability of the people to adopt the same attitude now or at any time in the future, but I do hope that now, that we have an essentiallyand predominantly economic rather than a political problem, the attitude of people of the Deputy O'Higgins type who always insist on introducing a political atmosphere, will not so cloud and confuse the mind of the Irish people that they will not know what they are striving for. I repeat that it is a privilege to be in this House in an atmosphere created by a thoughtful and impartial speech delivered by a man who believes sincerely in the future of the country and who tells this House frankly what his views are. We may disagree with some of them and agree with others.
I submit to the House that, for the first time in the history of our independent nation, we have now a predominantly economic problem as opposed to a predominantly political problem. This nation was divided following the civil war and the attitude of two totally divergent elements as regards its political future. I say that the people showed in no uncertain way where their sympathies lay as soon as they collected their thoughts following the civil war. As a result, a political programme was put through by the Fianna Fáil Party and it was given a mandate such as I believe it would be impossible to get in any country in the world during the period in question, under a system of proportional representation. I do not think anybody can say that Fianna Fáil fell down on the job they were given by the people.
Comment on this
We now find ourselves confronted by what is predominantly an economic problem. Much of the mud which was slung by members of the Opposition following the Budget measures of 1952 was certainly not designed to give the Irish people a real grasp of the problems they were faced with. The result was that you found them confused and doubtful about matters which should be perfectly clear and straightforward to them. I speak again on a difficult matter, from a political point of view, but I have no fear of speaking here or elsewhere about any matter, since I am speaking honestly and in perfect sincerity. I am referring to the matter of unemployment assistance. I havebeen told, time and time again, that no politician in the West of Ireland would dare raise the question of the dole in this House because he would be thereby committing political suicide. So long as I am here, I shall speak my mind and I shall not be sorry for having spoken it. I hear on every side of me criticism of the system of unemployment assistance. Why should men who are known to have money in the bank be given State assistance? Why should others have to pay more for essential commodities in order to supply certain sections of the community who do not need it with assistance from the State?
Before dealing fully with this question, it might be well to get the importance of it into its true perspective. These people who speak about unemployment assistance as a national scandal would give you the impression that vast sums of money, relative to the total revenue of the State, were being given out unnecessarily in doles. The Estimate for the coming year in respect to unemployment assistance is £1,538,000, an increase of about £70,000 over the Estimate for last year. As compared with that, the total Estimate for old age pensions for the coming year is £9,500,000.
The total Estimate for widows' and orphans' non-contributory pensions is £1,788,000. I think few people realise that old age pensions cost the State £9,500,000 a year. A comparison can be made in other ways, but perhaps it might be better to keep within the sphere of social assistance generally. I think nobody will deny that there are certain members of the community who must be assisted out of central funds. I think the day has long passed when any democratic State would be allowed to adopt the attitude of "every man for himself". I think that any sort of honest examination of this matter brings one to the conclusion that some amount should be paid by way of unemployment assistance or, failing that, that assistance under a different name, but of the same nature, should be paid to men who through no fault of their own genuinely cannot make ends meet.
I feel it my duty, however, to say that I have heard a great number of complaints in various parts of my constituency about abuses of a system which, I submit, is in itself just. I feel bound to say that a great number of people now consider that the abuses are so great that some alternative system of benefit should be devised and that the present unemployment assistance code should be abolished. Obviously people who say that are not themselves in receipt of unemployment assistance. Obviously those people who are in receipt of unemployment assistance have a very great power in the ballot-box. Be that as it may, I submit to the Government that it is the opinion of the majority of the people in my constituency that the system of unemployment assistance should be revised because of the abuses which have crept into the system, particularly over the period of the past five years.
I am inclined to agree with Deputy Dr. Browne's suggestion that drastic measures should be taken regarding the importation of coal. I believe that that is not a step that can be taken at once but it is a goal at which we should aim at the earliest possible opportunity. In the same way, I think—and this idea was not born as a result of a leading article in yesterday's or today's Evening Mail—that some effort should be made to prevent the sale of religious souvenirs at our shrines, such as Knock—souvenirs which have been imported from countries behind the Iron Curtain. I do not see why a country such as this should tolerate the importation of religious or other souvenirs from a country behind the Iron Curtain. Irish people have to find the money to purchase these souvenirs—souvenirs which, I may say, could very well be manufactured at home.
During the course of the debate this evening my mind travelled back to another debate which took place in this House. When I was speaking during that other debate, Deputy Coburn, who has now left the House, interrupted me. I made the suggestion that the land project as it then operated was not designed for the smaller farmers inthe West of Ireland. Deputy Coburn took pains to point out that I was taking a line contrary to that taken by the Taoiseach. He said that the Taoiseach suggested that the larger groupings required to be drained and that money should be directed towards an immediate increase in national production by increasing the productivity of the larger farms in the Midlands and elsewhere. Since that time, the Department have made a change in the system and it is gratifying to be able to say that the land project is now designed to suit, more particularly, the small farmers in the West of Ireland. Although, from a national point of view, they are not likely to affect national productivity as dramatically as the bigger farmers, the small farmers can and will make their significant contribution to the increased production which ought to follow from a more widespread use of the land project.
Comment on this
I will conclude my remarks on that subject by saying that I hope that no member of the Opposition will again attempt to make the case that we, as a Government, directed the sale of agricultural implements because we are a bankrupt nation. It might be better to remind the people who made that allegation that we voted an extra £274,000 for the land project at the time the Minister made that difficult but, I think, advantageous decision. I think, too, that it does not help the people of this country to understand the difficult economic problems that face us when they hear certain Deputies try to make the case that unemployment has been created by Fianna Fáil. One should not speak in this House without being able to give the appropriate references.
I sat in this House not very long ago and I heard a Deputy state—I think it was Deputy MacBride—that there was no unemployment problem during the period of office of the Coalition Government. That statement was made either last week or the weekbefore that: if I am challenged to produce the reference, I am confident that I can do so. May I ask, of what benefit is such a statement to the ordinary citizen who is trying to understand the economic problems of this State? As the Taoiseach pointed out this evening, the average number of unemployed in this country in 1950 was over 60,000. The average number in 1952 was also—and very unfortunately—over 60,000.
Surely it is no contribution to the solution of the problems of this country that a person should make a statement so patently false in the hope that it will be believed by the people and that, acting on it, they will vote accordingly. Undoubtedly, it is a very grave problem that there should be 60,000—much less a greater number —unemployed in this country at any given time. I can only hope that, in future, and particularly in the 12 months that lie ahead. Deputies sitting on the opposite benches will not appeal, as they appealed unsuccessfully, to the lowest aspects of mentality, saying: "Do you want to pay more for this, that or the other? If you do, vote Fianna Fáil." The people said: "Yes, we do," and they voted for Fianna Fáil, thereby proving that such Opposition tactics would not fool them, not even for two months. I have heard nothing from the Opposition in the course of the past fortnight or three weeks which would indicate any change of heart on their part. I have heard nothing from them which would achieve anything other than the making of political capital out of what are very real difficulties for our people. Fine Gael hope, as a result of their adroit manoeuvring, to build up a Party big enough to enable them to form a Government by themselves. But in case they should fail to do that, they want to keep Labour and Clann na Talún stringing along with them under a common name.
I think history has proved that, however genuine the men may be who form coalitions, they lead to nothing but political disaster. I think that has been proved in the case of Spain where they had 33 Cabinets in 15 years, inItaly where they had 30 years of coalition governments prior to Mussolini walking into Rome, and in France where, even though they had a good Prime Minister, he could not get enough support for a period that would enable him to do something good for his country. The Opposition should be honest enough to admit that, whatever they might expect to be able to do by taking their stand on good principles and on a good policy, there is nothing to be gained by them when they are prepared to abandon or compromise on their policy.
Comment on this
At any rate, this Government has taken its stand on a certain financial policy. That policy produced dramatic results in the last 12 months by a reduction in our very serious adverse trade balance, while internally it has gone a certain distance towards restoring stability in the State. The Government, in order to make that policy effective, recently asked certain sections of the community to make temporary sacrifices. Those who have read the various reports of O.E.E.C. will understand the reasons which the Government had for doing that—in asking certain sections of the community not to press their claims so that their budgetary policy might be carried into full effect.
I am suggesting that no alternative policy has been offered as an inter-Party policy or as a coalition policy, and that, consequently, it is very dishonest, from the political point of view, of the members of the Opposition to pretend to the Irish people that they, in fact, have a coalition or an inter-Party policy common to themselves which would solve the country's difficulties if the people were to put this combination of Parties back into power. They say that, despite the fact, as we all know, that these Partiescannot get promises binding each other or binding even members of these Parties to each other or to the country.
Some Deputy suggested that it was absurd that a small State like Ireland should have so many Embassies and Legations scattered all over the world. I am sure that suggestion will not be treated seriously by the people. It surely is as important for us to preserve our position internationally as it is to preserve it nationally. I hope that no member of the Opposition will ever again stoop to that type of tactic. When all is said and done, all that the Department of External Affairs is costing the country is £480,400 a year.
I will conclude by pointing out, as I did at the outset of my remarks, that it takes a long time for people to root out an attitude of mind born during centuries of foreign occupation and born of a want of faith. The best service that we can render to the Irish people is to persuade them to use all the money they have and that it is as important now, as never before, to put into operation the old maxim that you must speculate in order to accumulate. The politicians, too, should do their utmost to persuade the people that, by making false declarations in order to secure a State service or State assistance, or by giving false information or otherwise misleading investigating officers, they are not damaging the alien, but are damaging their own country, their consciences, their civic pride and their ability, not only to build up the country, but, having done so, to preserve it. If that civic pride, that sense of responsibility can be sedulously engendered in the younger generation, then they will be prepared to make whatever sacrifices are necessary. They will be able to consolidate, politically and economically, the enormous gains made by those who have immediately preceded them, particularly those great Irishmen who won for this country its freedom over the past 30 or 40 years.
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan appealed to the Opposition not to attempt to ask the people in the future whether they were prepared to vote for this or the other increase. Does heforget the photograph that appeared in his newspaper of a poor housewife, bent with grief because she had to pay 2/10 per lb. for butter? He forgets that. All the Government Deputies have forgotten the unemployed. Deputies on the Government Benches have remained silent about the problem of the 90,000 unemployed. The Taoiseach stated to-night that the problem was not of his making. There is a problem. They have no solution.
Various Deputies have pointed to increases in Estimates. I am very perturbed about the effect on my constituency of the reduction of £55,000 in respect of mineral development. We know that mineral development is confined more or less to the Avoca area. If a large number of men are unemployed in that area in addition to the 800 who are already unemployed in Bray, I do not know what the position will be in County Wicklow. I am not speaking now from the point of view of the by-election.
What solution have the Government for the problem of unemployment? Instead of a reduction in the sub-head, mineral development, of £55,000 there should be an increase. Deputy Seán Flanagan advocates production of turf. Rather strangely, he omitted to mention that last year there was a provision of £364,000 for turf production which is being reduced this year to £125,000. We are told that people will not burn it. Perhaps the people in the cities will not burn it. There is a serious problem facing County Wicklow.
Comment on this
We did not. We got a report from the expert. We kept men employed. You are reducing the provision by £55,000. Even if the inter-Party Government did close it down, I hope you will not follow the example.
Comment on this
There is a reduction of £55,000. Does that mean that more men will be unemployed in addition to the 800 already unemployed in Bray, that there will be more unemployment in rural areas? Deputy Briscoe gave us a lecture on the housing problem. He represents a Dublin constituency. People who represent Dublin have no knowledge whatever, I submit, of the problem of rural housing. Dublin Corporation arrange their loan. The county council must go to the Local Loans Fund and the interest in respect of loans from that fund has been increased to 5¼ per cent. Neither Deputy Briscoe nor the Minister for Lands can suggest that Wicklow County Council is a political body. The members of all Parties in the Wicklow County Council for 20 years, to my knowledge, have gone out of their way to provide decent housing for the people. What is the problem now with the increase in the rate of interest? On a £1,100 house there would be an extra charge of 8/6 per week. What public body will build houses in a rural area and ask an unfortunate farm labourer to pay 15/- or 18/- per week?
Comment on this
I am dealing with what we have to pay and what it is costing. A scheme of direct labour was operated for the past 30 years and was approved by both Governments. We were able to build good houses for the people. The position has changed since two years ago. Tradesmen, skilled men and labourers have been dismissed, not because our schemes are completed but because the council are unable to proceed with any further schemes owing to the high cost of the houses as a result of the interest charge. If we were in the position that Dublin Corporation is in, naturally, we might go ahead.
We are building a scheme now that the Minister has sanctioned for the white-collar workers who will pay the economic rent. We have built more houses in County Wicklow in proportionto the population than any other county in Ireland. Unfortunately, now we are unable to proceed with the housing scheme. I would ask Deputy Briscoe to use his power with the Government. I know that, like myself, he has been interested in social development for the last 20 or 30 years. If he comes down to Wicklow we will explain the position there to him. We have a scheme in operation. We have the machinery in perfect order. We are dispensing with men week after week as each house is completed. What is the cause of that? The high rate of interest charged by the Government.
A Deputy from Wicklow gets up and says that the farmers must get a cheaper rate of interest. He is supporting the Government that have put 1 or 2 per cent. on loans for the farmers. He pointed out here to-day that the farmer must get a special rate of interest, cheap credit. The Government put a 20 per cent. tariff on fertilisers coming into the country. He is supporting that Government. He pointed out in other speeches that you cannot give money at a cheaper rate than you borrow, but he wants cheaper money for the farmers.
The Minister for Finance pointed out that for political purposes the Opposition had complained about the building of houses. For 20 or 30 years all Parties joined together in an endeavour to provide houses for the people. That could not be termed political. The Minister asked why could not the Labour Party act in the same way as the T.U.C. acted towards the Tory Government in England, who promised that they would not look for any further increase in wages. The Labour Party or the trade unions tried to secure 12/6 for all sections of workers to compensate for the increase in the cost of living, but many men in the rural areas could not secure 12/6, or half the amount. That is the Central Bank's idea—create unemployment and the men that are in employment will quieten down and not look for any money and you will not have to import the food that the men would buy if they were in employment. The positionis so bad that we are told by the Minister for Lands that we are eating too much, that there is too much butter consumed in the country.
Comment on this
He referred to a statement made by the American experts that Ireland was consuming more butter and more food than any other country, even more than America.
Comment on this
He did not say they were consuming too much. That is the Deputy's attempt to interpret what he said.
Comment on this
The Minister will have an opportunity very soon in Wicklow of explaining and, if he is on the other side of the House, I am sure we will get our desires in County Wicklow. I would prefer him to be in the House what he is outside and not to become a different man when he comes into the House. We will deal with him when he comes to Wicklow, but not in any antagonistic way. They want us to eat less and they secured that.
Comment on this
He referred to the statement which was published that Ireland was consuming too much butter. There is less consumed now when we are paying 4/2 a lb. for stuff from New Zealand. The Government are making £200,000 a year by charging the poor people 4/2 a lb. for it. Deputy Briscoe on another occasion would be loud in his appeals for the Government to do their duty by the unemployed. One supporter of the Government to-night stated that he was very perturbed owing to the serious position and I am sure the Government must be very perturbed. If they have given any consideration to the problem, either the Taoiseach or theMinister should announce it to the House. Even members of their own Party are met with this problem of the unemployed in their constituency. Those who are in employment are not able to make ends meet. With the wages they receive, they are not able to buy sufficient food.
I have got the Minister for Lands statement now. As reported in column 447 of the Official Report of 13th March, the Minister stated:—
"In that connection, the Government are aware, and have been deeply affected by the fact, that butter output has declined substantially in this country, but consumption, on the other hand, has increased."
He referred to the T.U.C. in England. The Minister took his instructions from the English T.U.C. I am surprised that the Minister should refer to anything in that country as being good. The Minister for Finance went over and had a long interview with the Chancellor of the Exchequer, and we know what happened here as a result of that. No paragraphs appeared in the Press about it, but the paragraphs appeared when the Budget was introduced. We have been told that the Budget has not affected the unemployment problem. We know very well that the Budget and the extra taxation created unemployment. Deputy Briscoe and other Deputies are aware that the banks have restricted credit, not through the bank managers, but on the instructions of the directors.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance adopted the recommendations in the Central Bank's Report, but they were not accepted by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. When the Minister for Industry and Commerce at the Ard-Fheis found that the delegates were not in favour of the Central Bank Report, he agreed with the delegates, but when it came to the Cabinet meeting he agreed with the Minister for Finance. In this country at present we have a policy of austerity; 90,000 persons are unemployedand many more will be unemployed. We had two or three Ministers going round the country telling us that we were on the verge of bankruptcy. If that was true, we should not be spending £50,000 a year on the President's establishment. He is a modest citizen, and if he had his own way I am sure he would be the last to agree to have £50,000 spent on that establishment while there is so much unemployment in the country.
Comment on this
About 10,000 of the idle rich go up there once in the year. I do not want to speak disrespectfully of the occupant of that establishment, but he is living on an imperial scale. The traffic in the streets was stopped for hours when he went to be sworn in and thousands of people went up to the Phoenix Park to get their lemonade. We are trying to imitate what takes place in wealthy countries at a time when we are supposed to be on the verge of bankruptcy. If we are on the verge of bankruptcy, why not try and save money on the various Departments? Why not give a lead, instead of spending money in that way without having any solution for the unemployment problem? I do not want to say a word against the respected occupant of the position, but I am criticising the Government for the holding of the procession for the swearing in ceremony. Some Deputies got into a black coat for that occasion and they have been wearing it since. If we are in such a poor state we should not be spending money as we are spending it as present on the President's establishment.
Deputy Briscoe wants a couple of million pounds for the knocking down of the buildings in Dublin Castle and providing accommodation for all the officials.
Comment on this
Your policy has caused 4,000 or 5,000 skilled men in the building industry to be unemployed.
Comment on this
I hope you will get them back into employment. We brought them back from England to work on housing schemes. Why have housing schemes been stopped all over the country? If the Deputy inquires he will see that what I am stating is true.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not be interrupted. There is a continual buzz of conversation all round.
Comment on this
Unemployment presents a serious problem in my own constituency. There are at least 800 unemployed in Bray. Mineral development has been reduced by £55,000. That means probably there will be large numbers unemployed in Avoca because there will be no work available there.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Briscoe please allow Deputy Everett to make his speech in his own way. Deputy Briscoe is continually interrupting.
Comment on this
Will the Minister give some assurance that the unemployment problem will not be aggravated by the dismissal of men on mineral development in Avoca?
Comment on this
I want some assurance that some solution will be found. Large numbers are willing to work and the present situation must be remedied. Increased grants for the unemployed is not the proper solution. If the Government is really in earnest they will initiate some projects. There was a time when they felt so optimistic about development here that they were talking of bringing back those who had gone abroad for work. At that time they accepted it as their duty to provide work for the people. I admit that the solution is not an easy one. This problem should be dealt with on a co-operative basis by all Parties and not merely from a political point of view.
Unemployment can breed trouble. The Government should take its courage in its hands and try to solve the problem. The inter-Party Government left a residue of 30,000 unemployed. I admit that was a large number, but it is not so large as the number that are unemployed to-day. One Deputy mentioned that we were paying back the Marshall loan and that we had put this country into pawn with America. In actual fact, the country has been pawned to the English insurance companies.
Comment on this
There are other insurance companies and they must have their 5 per cent. It is odd that in England a huge loan could be raised at 4½ per cent. Was the Minister afraid he would not get the money at 3 per cent.? If money had been got at 3 per cent. we would not have large-scale unemployment at the moment. We would not have large numbers emigrating to work for other countries when they should really be working at home for their own people.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy's Government get money at 3½ per cent.?Was the loan fully subscribed at that rate?
Comment on this
Not fully subscribed, but almost fully. Certainly, the Government should not raise money at more than 4½ per cent. The difficulty we have with housing in County Wicklow is that the grants are not yet available on houses that were reconstructed over 12 months ago. Last week I received a letter saying that the people were still waiting for the money. Local authorities are paying an enormous sum in interest because the Government has failed to make available the money due to these authorities on housing schemes over the past three months, on road development and other public works.
Comment on this
The Minister should ensure that the Departments responsible should forward the moneys owing to local authorities and not have these public bodies paying 5 per cent. on their overdrafts.
Comment on this
Even if the Minister has that overriding authority, the matter does not arise on this Vote on Account.
Comment on this
The people have been promised that the money would be sent on and they are still waiting for it. Is the Government holding back the money? Is that the policy?
Comment on this
I am sure that what is true of Wicklow is true of every other country, but I am merely dealing with the grievances that exist in my own constituency. I will give theDeputy the names of those who have completed the reconstruction of their houses and are waiting for the grants.
Comment on this
That is purely administration and should be raised on the main Estimate and not on the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
I will not bother writing any more to the Department. I got so many definite assurances and yet nothing ever happened. I do not blame the Government for taking credit for the good they have done but that does not mean that we should not criticise when criticism is necessary. I am criticising the Government for its failure to solve the unemployment problem. I think all Parties should co-operate with the trade unions and other representative bodies in order to find a solution to this problem. Some Deputies have talked about certain people trying to take advantage of the serious situation that exists in regard to unemployment. That is the kind of situation in which certain people like to do their particular work, a situation of hunger, want, discontent and no hope for the future. Some people are taking advantage of the unemployment that exists to achieve their own ends. The Government should not allow that situation to arise. A speedy solution to the problem must be found and I hope there will be some statement of policy on the matter before this debate closes.