We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 3—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–192 of 399. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The condition of affairs we are dealing with, the disastrous effect this reiteration of the Budget of last year is likely to have, dictates that we would review the position with the greatest possible clarity and that we would eliminate as far as possible the clouded atmosphere that the Minister for Finance created by his sarcastic and sneering attitude regarding the Budget of last year. The attitude that he took up here in the Dáil on the discussion was continued by him in his broadcast. There are certain aspects that I would like to get clear.

In speaking on the radio, as reported in the Sunday Pressof the 10th May, he said that “over the period from February 1948 until the last Budget of the Coalition worked itself out on the 31st March 1952, the total net borrowing of the Exchequer had increased by £90,000,000,” and that “the huge increase on the current expenditure and this inordinate borrowing is at the heart of the budgetary problems withwhich the Government and the taxpayer are confronted today.”

He further indicated that a substantial part of the money borrowed by the previous Government had been spent not to stimulate production but on projects for which there was "little economic justification." We have that attitude of the Minister, instead of facing up to the problems that exist to day and that are largely created by the Budget of last year. The present Budget, however, is a serious enough one to be dealt with on its merits. There will be a temptation, particularly in view of the Minister's attitude, to deal with it as one of a series of serious blows struck by the Fianna Fáil Party to the economy of this country. I have no wish to blur in any way the appreciation of the present situation by discussing it except on its merits. One of the ways in which the Minister seeks to blur the realities of the present situation is by reference to the "unproductive and unnecessary expenditure" of the inter-Party Government, the "legacy if the debt" alleged by the Minister to have been left by them, and the results flowing from it.

The Minister must allow those who are dealing with these matters in Parliament to realise that there are official returns prepared by the Minister for Finance and his Department and that annually there is issued by the Government, at the time of the presentation of the Budget, tables in connection with the financial statement. Table 5, in the presentation for 1953, gives a statement showing the capital liabilities of the State on the 31st March, 1953, and a statement of the assets held by the State against these liabilities. In an appended note it gives the position in relation to the liability of the State with regard to housing. The figures are available over the years from 1947-48 to 1952-53, showing the gross liabilities and total assets, and they give facilities for ascertaining the increase in the net liability with regard to State expenditure and the increase in the liability with regard to housing.

When we look at these figures we find the total increase in the State's liability in relation to borrowing, on the one hand, and its added housing liability on the other. For the year 1948-49 the increase in the net liability, including housing, was £2,459,171; for the year 1949-50, £10,507,630; for the year 1950-51, £11,362,587; for the year 1951-52, £22,950,510; and for the year 1952-53, £12,822,841. The amounts of increase net liability during the inter-Party years are comparatively small compared with the additional net liability which has gone on the State in respect of housing and general capital expenditure in the past two years. That is one way in which the increased expenditure on capital items and the increased dead-weight debt is presented to the House.

It is presented in another way in the White Paper, "Estimates of Receipts and Expenditure," issued on the occasion of each Budget. When we look at the position with regard to the total expenditure on both supply and capital items in each of the past few years and the total amount of money that had to be provided to meet that expenditure, other than by way of tax or non-tax revenue, we get an impression of the State's borrowings in another way. For the financial year 1948-49, the total expenditure was £81,056,000 of which £9,265,000 had to be found by ways other than tax or non-tax revenue—by borrowing. For 1949-50, the total expenditure was £95,383,000 and the amount that had to be found other than through tax or non-tax revenue was £21,358,000; for 1950-51 the total expenditure was £99,419,000 and the amount that had to be found by borrowing was £22,063,000; in 1951-52 the total expenditure was £123,494,000 of which £39,589,000 had to be found in a way other than through tax or non-tax revenue; and in 1952-53 the total expenditure was £128,723,000, the total amount which had to be found by borrowing being £32,805,000.

The Minister now presents us with a Budget in which the total expenditure under supply and capital headingsis estimated to be £137,472,000, taking the Minister's figure that the capital that will be required to be added to tax and non-tax revenue to meet that amount as £36,300,000, the figure given by him in his Budget statement. Here, therefore, we have the amounts which the State had to find by borrowing down along: £9,265,000, £21,258,000 and £22,063,000 up to March, 1951, and, since March, 1951, £39,589,000 and £32,805,000, and the sum which the Minister now tells us he will have to obtain for capital services, £36,300,000.

This is the Minister who was crying out about the havoc which the Government that went before this Government brought on the country by its profligacy and borrowing. I do not object to the Government carrying out a constructive programme involving the use of capital, and the amounts quoted there may be amounts which are worth spending, but, if they are, let them not make the case for spending them that they are amounts which pale into insignificance when compared with the capital moneys spent during the three years of the Government which preceded this Government. We ask the Minister to look at the capital expenditure in the past two years. These amounts are stated in pretty clear detail in every one of the Budget statements as they are made each year and I would call the Minister's attention, for the purpose of getting him to address himself to this matter, to certain figures.

I have here the estimates of capital expenditure offered in the Budget statements of 1950-51, 1951-52, 1952-53 and 1953-54. I will give four figures in each case running from the budgetary statement of 1950-51 to 1953-54 inclusive:—Housing In the 1950-51 Budget the inter-Party Government indicated that they would require £14,120,000 capital for their housing work. In the last two years of the present Government the figures were £11.73 million and £12.05 million; in the current estimate it is £10.54 million. Was there any profligacy or unwarranted expenditure in the housing proposals of the Budget of 1950-51?

Similarly, under health, sanitary services, the figures running from1950-51 down are; £1.16 million, £0.78 million, £0.67 million and, in the estimate for this year, £1.80 million. Was there profligacy and extravagant expenditure in the proposals of the Government that preceded the present Government?

Under the heading of hospitals the figures were: £0.42 million, in 1950-51 £0.24 million, £0.38 million, and now £5.08 million, under the special circumstances indicated by the Minister for Health and the Minister for Finance. On those figures was there extravagance and profligacy in the past?

Under the heading agricultural development the figure in 1950-51 was £6,260,000, of which there was only £3.13 million spent. The estimates for subsequent years were £5.16 million, £3.99 million, £4.72 million for the coming year. Does the Minister find there the profligacy, extravagance and worthless expenditure that he speaks about?

Under the heading electricity development, in 1950-51 the estimate was £4.75 million. In the subsequent years the estimates were £4.75 million, £9.00 million, £8.00 million. The same question arises there with regard to the Minister's charge.

For turf development the estimate in 1950-51 was £1.50 million and the subsequent years' estimates were £1.10 million, £1.75 million, £1.27 million.

Under the heading telephones, the estimates were: 1950-51, £2.25 million and in the subsequent years £2.00 million, £1.75 million, £1.50 million.

For schools and State buildings the figures were: 1950-51 £1.12 million subsequent years, £1.17 million, £1.16 million, £1.30.

For afforestation the figures were: 1950-51, £0.36 million—actually there was £0.43 million spent— and in subsequent years the estimates were £0.85 million, £0.6 million, £0.68 million.

Under the heading, fisheries: in 1950-51, the figure was £0.20 million, which included a certain amount of mineral development and tourist expenditure. In the following year the figure was £0.11 million; a certain amount of mineral development beingincluded. In the subsequent year the figure was £0.16 million and for the coming year £0.15 million.

The estimates for transport were: in 1950-51, £1.86 million and in the subsequent years £1.54 million, £3.41 million, £4.40 million. In 1950-51 there was only £0.77 million spent.

The total actually spent in those years as far as I can find out was: 1950-51, £24.61 million; in the following year £35,000,000; in the subsequent year, £32.27 million and the estimate for this year is £36.30 million.

I ask the Minister what does he mean by obscuring and bedevilling consideration of financial matters with regard to capital expenditure and the use to which it is being put by the stuff that he has been going ahead with, by the stuff that he has been publishing in relation to the capital expenditure that I speak of. The fact is that the last Government embarked upon a sound and satisfactory scheme for using the country's credit to build up necessary developments here that the people, without State assistance of some kind or another, could not have carried out. It is not only neglecting his duty to the people but it is bedevilling for some queer purpose the whole financial situation and the political situation and the work of this Parliament when he comes in here and makes the statement that he has made, and when he goes on the air or to his various meetings and makes the charges that he has made.

The Minister may be wishing to confuse the situation a bit and the suggestion that he may be wishing to make is that Marshall moneys were borrowed for the purpose of paying for imports to this country that he would not approve of. That is not what the Minister is saying. The Minister is saying that the Government that was in office for three years before the present Government borrowed huge amounts of money and misspent them in unprofitable ways. I ask the Minister to take the figures that are given there and to reconcile them if he can with the statements that he has made and particularly to take the moneys borrowed by the Government and the credit available to the Governmentor actually spent under the headings that I have given.

On the question of the use made for trading purposes of the dollars obtained under Marshall Aid, we made use of Marshall Aid moneys that were made available so that within necessary limits the ordinary natural trading of the country and its trading connection with the dollar countries could be maintained over a period in which certain rectification and improvement in international trade was being worked for and was expected. The dollars that were provided for traders who were importing dollar materials here were made available to the Government, who made them available to the merchants and, in return, accumulated from those who used dollars sterling equivalent. The sterling equivalent of the Marshall Aid which was used for maintaining and assisting natural trade came into the possession of the Government and was used in the best way that the Government could use it to make the moneys profitable while they were in the custody of the Government. The Minister himself spent £24,500,000 of those moneys.

In his circulation Budget statement of April, 1952, page 32, he says:

"It is important, in view of the problems which we will have to face in the coming year, that the Dáil and the public should realise how the borrowings of £41,000,000 were raised and why the process must not, and indeed cannot, be repeated. We borrowed for Exchequer use small savings in the form of deposits in the Savings Banks and purchases of Saving Certificates. We also used the available income of the social insurance funds for ways and means advances. The net receipts from these sources were approximately £7,000,000. The American Loan Counterpart Fund provided £24,500,000. It is now exhausted. The remaining £9,500,000 we had to find by selling British Government securities of the Post Office Savings Bank and social insurance funds, replacing these securities by our own."

A sum of £41,000,000 for capital purposes was used by the Minister forFinance in the year 1952—that is plainly shown in the White Paper for the year ending 31st March, 1953—and £24,500,000 of that was Marshall Aid money which the Minister no doubt is charging up as having been borrowed by the previous Government. If it was, it was left behind for him to spend in the year 1952-53.

Comment on this

It was spent in 1951-52 on schemes which had been left behind by our predecessors.

Comment on this

It was used in the year ending on the 31st March, 1952, the year which the Minister was dealing with in his Budget statement.

Comment on this

To meet your commitments.

Comment on this

It is nearly time for the Minister to reiterate what these commitments were. It is nearly time for him to deal with the finances of this country on his own responsibility from the time his Government took over. He might as well claim from the Government which preceded him the advantages that accrued to this country from their wiping out of taxation in the beginning of 1948 and all that flowed from that. He might as well claim that as ensuing from the Government that preceded the inter-Party Government as to put the blame for what happened from June, 1951, on the Government that preceded him.

Comment on this

There were deficits of £3,000,000 on the 1950 Budget.

Comment on this

The Minister has had that very fully dealt with. I am asking the Minister to take the expenditure, to take the capital plans that were estimated for in the Budgets of our period and his own capital expenditure and capital plans and deal with the question to which I am addressing myself, the profligacy and the waste of these moneys. The Minister has had dealt with on very many occasions the question as to whether the Budget for the year 1950-51 was properly balanced or not and the figures are all there. There is very good reason, if the Minister wants to go into them again, why they will not be gone into.

Here we are dealing with a kind of remaking of the blow against the economy of this country made in last year's Budget and we want to clear away from that the obscurities and the confusion that the Minister is deliberately encircling them with. That is why I ask the Minister, in relation to his proposed expenditure here and his proposals for borrowing, in what way are they more profitable, in what way are they more worthy than the proposals that were made in the Budget of 1951-52, or in the Budget of 1949-50. The Minister no doubt will not address himself to that.

The total net increase in the State's liabilities due to borrowing and to housing commitments for the year 1948-49 was £2,459,000; for 1949-50, £10,507,000; for 1950-51, £11,362,000; for 1951-52, £22,950,000; and for 1952-53, £12,822,000. The Minister's proposals for borrowing this year are greater than were contemplated in any year up to the present, as is his bill for the supply services greater also. However, he will require £36,300,000 and he says that, due to his policy, the people have now become thrifty and the people are now saving.

The Minister gave me the impression on reading his Budget speech that he was a man suffering from shock, that he was a person guilty of a crime to whom the guilt had been brought home, and that he found himself in a daze and unable to reconstruct the mood or the atmosphere in which the crime was committed, because he saw all around him, as he must, the position with regard to unemployment, the position with regard to the cost of living, the position with regard to the break down of the initiative of so many people in industry and commerce on which this country is depending to provide the additional development and the additional employment in the country and to sustain even the employment that is in it. The Minister can just ignore that. He asks the people to look at the bright prospects ahead and says that the people have something to save and have something worth saving for.

Surely the Minister realises from his experience in the past, as he hasindicated very clearly, how difficult it has been for the Government to get loans. He almost gloats over the position in which a body like the Dublin Corporation finds itself: that it cannot stand on its own feet and rushes to the Minister for Finance for assistance and, in a hoity-toity way, the Minister says, "You must stand on your own feet." He is able to get the banks to face the problems now because the previous Government had very adequately and effectively put before the banks their responsibilities in the matter in present conditions.

But where does the Minister expect saving to come from for the ordinary development and maintenance of our industrial and commercial fabric and our agricultural fabric taking conditions as they are to-day, conditions in which the Government expects it will require £36,300,000 for the carrying on of its work? It is gratifying to see the Government pursuing in relation to capital development the road chalked out by its predecessors, much as the Minister sneered at the plans and the ideas they had. Even the Minister himself will admit that the most effective and the most important part of capital use and capital development here is the development that takes place at the hands of and due to the initiative of private enterprise. The Minister will admit that the most vital works requiring to be capitalised and sustained here are those concerned with the expansion of industry, the expansion of our manufacturing business and the improvement and development of our agriculture.

Where does the Minister see in the situation that confronts us that capital will be available for the improvements and maintenance of our ordinary economic life? Recently the Minister for Industry and Commerce appealed for increased outside capital to come in here for the purpose of developing our economic and industrial arm. That is very necessary and it will be very welcome. One of the things we did in husbanding Marshall Aid—and the £24,500,000 that the Minister blew in in six months would have served to foster that purpose—was to give our ownpeople a chance from their limited resources to provide a modicum of capital for carrying on Government work, assisted by the capital resources on which we had been able to lay our hands as a result of Marshall Aid, thereby leaving some native capital in the country for its own internal development.

The Minister must know that the result of his policy is to reduce employment and impoverish our people by reducing their earning while at the same time such residue of capital as is available from our trading is expressing itself in the piling up of further sterling assets to uphold the economy of people outside. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is appealing for foreign capital to come in here to help to build up the economic fabric of the country, while the Minister for Finance presents a Budget identical to the Budget introduced last year and he thereby endeavours to muddle and confuse the situation. He is not concerned, good, bad or indifferent with the situation that has been brought about and the condition of the country as a whole, remembering that the people must now bear a burden of taxation even greater than that imposed by the Minister last year.

Let us see what is happening this year. What is happening this year is that the taxation imposed on the country last year is reimposed this year on a country weakened by the results of last year's taxation and by the Government's policy of increasing the rate of interest. The amount of taxation raised in the year ending 31st March, 1952, was £73,161,000. Last year additional taxes were concocted and imposed under last year's Budget, Those additional taxes were expected to bring in, in addition to that £73,000,000, another £910,000 from income-tax; from the people who use tobacco an additional £5,500,000; from the people who drink beer an additional £2,360,000; from the people who drink spirits an additional £1,020,000 and from those who use petrol and oil an additional £500,000. In other words, additional taxes were added last year designed to take from our people, when the reduction to thedance hall proprietors was taken into consideration, £11,180,000 and on top of that additional burden of taxation the people had to find up to £8,000,000 extra for the food subsidies that had been withdrawn. This year they must suffer the same blow but that blow falls on a people who have suffered the results of the Minister's financial policy for the past 12 months. How have the people fared during the past 12 months?

The Irish Trade Journalpublished quarterly provides from time to time information with regard to the number of persons engaged in the production of transportable goods. If we look down the list of 32 groups of industries there we find that out of the 32 there are only four—bacon curing, bread, flour and confectionery and biscuit manufacturing, sugar and sugar confectionery and chemicals and drugs—in which there was more employment in December, 1952, than there was in December, 1950. In every other industry there—paper-making, grain milling, malting, tobacco, bricks and pottery, timber, brushes, wood furniture, the assembly of vehicles, metal industries, engineering, linen, jute and cotton, wollens and worsteds, wholesale clothing for men and boys, shirt-making, wholesale clothing for women and girls, miscellaneous wholesale clothing, the boot and shoe industry, hosiery, fellmongering, soap and candles—less people are employed to-day and one has the situation that for the transportable industries, taking the quarter ending in March, there were 1,951 less people employed in 1952 than in 1950 but there were 4,477 less people employed in 1952 than there were in 1951. There were 9,035 less people employed in June, 1952, than there were in June, 1951. There were 7,308 less people employed in September and there were 3,437 less people employed in December, 1952, than there were in December, 1951, but there were 7,228 less people employed in December, 1952, than in December, 1950.

That is the employment side of things. On the unemployment side one has the position, going back over the three years, that on the 10th May.1951, there were 46,250 men on the register, while on the 10th May, 1952, there were 53,272, and 71,632 on the 10th May, 1953. Has the Minister given any consideration as to what continued effect his budgetary imposition is going to have on unemployment in these industries? The Minister has indicated that there is an uprise in the situation. Will the Minister say if the uprise that he speaks of there is the same type of uplift that he shows when he speaks of our people having become more thrifty, being more grateful to the Government and more ready to support the general proposals of Government policy?

Does the Minister not know that to a very great extent the whole outlook of our industrial and commercial leaders is bedevilled and confused by the position with which the Minister has presented them? As we complained at the time of last year's Budget and as we reiterated when he acquiesced in the policy of raising the bank rate, the Minister has deliberately applied to this country a British-made policy, a policy made in Britain for the purpose of dealing with the British circumstances, where they wanted to withdraw both capital and men from the ordinary industrial and commercial avocations of an ordinary nation in order to bring resources of men and capital to their armament industries because of the general defence position in which they found themselves, and to their export industries because of the position in which they found their balance of payments, which was a real problem as distinct from the problem about which the Minister seems to have so much anxiety here. In connection with our industries for the production of consumption goods or goods generally required in this country and a comparatively small industrial export, the British-made policy was applied here with the inevitable effect that it was intended to have when applied in Britain. That is the policy which is being continued here now.

I will ask the Minister if he has adverted at all to a paper that was read by Sir Roland Nugent the other nightin Belfast at a meeting of the Statistical and Inquiry Society of Ireland. Speaking very humbly, not as an expert or as a technician, but as a man with a considerable amount of experience in affairs and very close association with the commercial life of the Six Counties, where he has been a former Minister of Commerce, with a very considerable amount of experience and knowledge of the trend of industrial life in Britain generally, he found it necessary in relation to the economic life of the Six Counties to posit to them that the least expensive and the least painful solution of the economic difficulties in which our people in the Six Counties found themselves would be to clear out, to go to some other place. Surely if any part of our country could survive the application of the policy devised for an economy of heavy industry, with a certain capacity for armament making and a considerable normal export trade; if any part of our country could weather or survive the application of such a policy as Britain has applied and as the Minister for Finance is applying to this country, it would be the North; yet there it is pointed out to them by one of their own, and an experienced one of their own, that all he can see for them if they are to avoid pain and if they are to avoid expense is to clear out.

Does the Minister not know in his heart and soul that that is the thought that is tormenting the youngest and the best of our people here, that in our present-day circumstances, leaving their school and entering on the threshold of normal life, they find every avenue of employment shut to them by reason of the fact that he has, by his policy, shut the door of so many industries on men and women who were already finding employment there? Has the Minister nothing to see in the opinions that are being expressed so evenly and so calmly by men such as Sir Roland Nugent? Does he see nothing in the situation there to get him to direct his eyes more closely to what is happening in this country and to look more carefully for the cause of the unfortunate happenings here? TheMinister pleads for the building up of a strong defence here for this country, which those who went before him for three years had neglected.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Those who went before him for three years have laid the foundations for a strong defensive spirit in this country.

Comment on this

A £50,000 Republic.

Comment on this

They applied in our normal political and economic affairs the principal and the spirit that gave us strength so that when we had to do any fighting to maintain the liberties of our people a spirit of unity would exist among every party, creed and class.

Comment on this

That is not what Deputy MacEoin says.

Comment on this

The Minister comes in here sneering at co-operation and unity, putting haloes around their heads, economic, political and independent haloes that are pinched from other people's graves. They wear haloes to-day that ought to be around the heads of some of the unemployed in this country whose prospects for life and prosperity in this country have been reduced by the antics and by the policies that are being pursued here. The Minister's anxiety for defence may be worthy enough but the Minister's approach and the way he throws it into the present discussion is just despicable. We are satisfied that there should be expenditure on the Army if it were only to take the young people who cannot get into employment of any other kind, to take them into one of our educational institutions, the Army, and let them understand there the spirit of discipline and comradeship without which this country cannot prosper.

Comment on this

I thought Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, your Minister for Defence, did not want to have them knocking sparks off their boots in barrack squares.

Comment on this

I am telling the Minister what we think, what thecountry thinks and what Deputy Dr. O'Higgins thinks, too. We would be anxious that some of the young men reaching the threshold of manhood, who perforce otherwise would have to leave the country, should be helped by the Army to hold themselves as citizens of this country for a while longer and perhaps permanently so with the passing of time, as a result of reaching a better and more sensible policy. We, happily, see quite a number of young men going into the Army. They will not all stay there. Some of them will, and no doubt will be a credit and an addition to the Army. Many of them will find what the Army is happily for them—a haven in which they can shelter themselves against the emigrant ship to-day—a haven in which as I say they can learn the comradeship that men find in the Army, the comradeship of every party, creed and class combined with advancement in discipline and education. But do not make a mock of the Army by boasting of the magnificent defence arrangements that have to be made to-day at great cost. That is the kind of stuff that should be left to the Irish PressandIrish Pressleaders and should not be brought in here to an Irish Parliament, where our concern is to lay secure foundations on which our people can find employment so that our finances may be properly, effectively and efficiently developed and maintained.

The Minister has, as I say, beclouded the atmosphere here with all kinds of smugness and self-praise to the effect that he has put this country on its feet again and that he has opened a bright prospect for it. For goodness' sake will the Minister take this House for what it was set up and meant to be and for what it has been maintained with so much patience, a House in which we can look frankly and clearly at the conditions of our people, understand the burdens they can bear and the policies they can pursue? As I say, there is a serious difficulty in not associating the present blow which the Government is striking at the country with some other blows they have struck and with some opportunities for advancement they havelost to this country already. The situation is too serious for anybody to seek to do anything except to get at the facts of that situation.

I would recommend to the Minister to look at the various aspects of the review of the economic position in the North as detailed in Sir Roland Nugent's paper on the industrial side, on the agricultural side, on the side of credit and on the side of taxation, and endeavour to see the distorted condition of affairs in this country as reflected against the picture that Sir Roland paints. The Minister is proposing to raise a considerable greater amount of taxation than he raised last year. He is over-budgeting this year in the same way as he over-budgeted last year. He misrepresents the position, he is denying the facts and he is bedevilling the discussion with a generally unsavoury approach.

The Minister has indicated that, as part of the cost of our defence preparations, he is going to dip his hand lightly into those funds that, at the end of the year for some years past, have been kept in the hands of the Inland Revenue Commissioners. In his statement introducing the Budget he said that on 1st April, 1948, the cash balance in the hands of the Revenue Commissioners amounted to almost £1.9 million. Will the House credit it that on the 1st April, 1948, the cash balance in the hands of the Revenue Commissioners were not £1.9 million but were £2,251,044 19s. 5½d?

Comment on this

I am very sorry but the Deputy is not reading that statement correctly.

Comment on this

I shall ask the Minister to deal with the matter because the Minister subsequently went on——

Comment on this

Several of the Deputy's colleagues have made that sort of mistake.

Comment on this

I am going to make it again, if it is a mistake, but I am first going to ask Deputies to consider what the Minister was getting at because he went on to say:—

"Over the three years to 1st April, 1951, they were maintained around this level."

Yet on the 1st April, 1949, they totalled £2,033,447, on the 1st April, 1950, £2,521,241 and on 1st April, 1951, £2,533,690 1s. 6d. Then the Minister went on to say:—

"As a result of fortuitous accretions over the past two years, however, the figure at 1st April last had risen to £2.5 million."

Comment on this

If the Deputy would pardon me, I do not want either the Deputy or myself to be confused in regard to these figures. Will he inform me where he has got these figures?

Comment on this

I shall take my last figures. The Minister says that as a result of fortuitous accretions over the past two years, the figures at 1st April last, that is 1/4/1953, had risen to £2,500,000. He quietly passes over the beautiful flow of things to 1st April, 1952. Reading through the accounts headed: "Statement showing the principal heads of revenue, balance in the hands of the Revenue Department at the commencement of the year, etc.", I find the figure was £2,860,934 2s. 9½d.

Comment on this

You see that is where the Deputy is confused. I said "cash balance in the hands of the Revenue Commissioners" but if the Deputy will look at that he will see that only the first items deal with the cash balances in the hands of the Revenue Commissioners. The others are cash in the Post Office Account and the Road Fund Account. I do not want to be making a petty point on it. I want to say in fairness to the Deputy that he either misunderstands what I said or the significance of the table.

Comment on this

Even if I take the Minister at what he says now and take the Post Office moneys out of it——

Comment on this

And the Road Fund.

Comment on this

Oh, no

Comment on this

Oh, yes. Let theDeputy try to be fair. It may be very difficult in our present relationship but at least let him read what I said. I said "the cash balances in the hands of the Revenue Commissioners". I am pointing out that it is only the first five items, I think, that relation to cash balances in the hands of the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

Very good. If the Minister wants to have it that way let him have it.

Comment on this

That is the way I want it.

Comment on this

The Minister's approach to this matter is entirely in keeping with his general approach to the presentation of the financial position—an approach which savours very markedly of deception. Part of the Minister's deceptive approach to the present situation is the way in which he introduced the defence position into it. The general position in which this country finds itself is that it is getting this year the same dose as it got last year. Last year it got a dose of high taxation. It got a dose of impoverishment as a result of the withdrawal of the subsidies. Twenty million was taken out of our people's pockets last year in additional cost for food on the one hand and additional taxation on the other. That was in excess of the £73,000,000 they had to pay the year before. Now the same blow has been struck at our people who suffered as a result of last year's policy and the policy that went before it.

The position is rather simply put in the March number of the Irish Trade Journal and Statistical Bulletinon page two of which we read:—

"For each month of 1951 up to and including August, the total live register was less than for the corresponding month of 1950, and for each month since September 1951, to date, the total has been in excess of the corresponding 1950 figure. The 1950-51 improvement was substantial in the first five months of 1951, varying from 5,000 to 9,000 but, by reference to 1950, there was a steady worsening of the position from Juneto the end of 1951, a decline of 2,800 in the June figure being converted to an increase of 6,700 in the December one. In the first three months of 1952 the monthly totals showed an average increase of 2,400 over the corresponding 1950 totals, and one of 9,500 over those for 1951. In the next three months the 1952 figures exceeded those for 1950 by about 5,800 on the average and were 11,100 above those for 1951. In the third quarter of 1952 the average increase in the totals amounted to about 8,400 as compared with 1950, and to about 9,000 as compared with 1951, while in the last quarter of the year the average excess over 1950 was 11,400 and over 1951, 7,000."

These are statistics in connection with the live register and show in every single case a reduction of employment in the various industries producing transportable goods. At least they represent an individual, if they do not represent a family, who has been driven into unemployment by the policy that the Minister put into operation last year. We had a forewarning of that policy the year before. It was a policy applied to this country that was intended for that part of industrial and commercial Britain, where the British-made policy was made to suit British circumstances and to create unemployment and drive it into different industries, the export and armament industries.

On top of that then we have the Minister's sneering references that our people have been taught thrift, that they have cut down their consumption and that they are lending to the Government. The Minister must know very well that he is piling up Government expenditure with plans that he may not be able to get savings to meet. Meantime he is reducing our people to a certain amount of hopelessness and preventing them, as well as industrialists, from having any chance of accumulating savings to put into the stabilising of our employment not to talk of increasing it.

Comment on this

I listened to Deputy Mulcahy's statement with great attention. He gave us a rather powerful dose of figures possible withthe intention of confusing the general issue. I have been through the country a good deal in the last week and have met quite a number of people. Everywhere I went all the people, whether they were supporters of the present Government or the recent Government, told me how satisfied they were with the Budget. I discovered that some of the reason for their being satisfied with the present Budget were very strange. One of the reasons was the deluge of figures that Deputy Costello gave and the effort he made to confuse the issue with this famous £10,000,000 when he tried to persuade the people that the Minister had collected from the public £10,000,000 and put it in a box with the intention of taking it out this year when the Budget was introduced for the purpose of balancing the Budget and reducing taxation.

That was one of the statements that convinced the people there was something wrong in the whole situation. Evidently Deputy Mulcahy has adopted the same policy. There are only two issues before the people of this country, One of these is to see that our sterling assets are restored and the other is to see that the Budget is balanced.

Comment on this

Build up Britain.

Comment on this

That sort of blooming nonsense will not affect anyone. In all your nonsense you never told us what you would do if you were elected to-morrow.

Comment on this

We showed you for three years.

Comment on this

You never mentioned one word about it but kept dosing up the figures to confuse the issue.

Comment on this

We did it for you.

Comment on this

So far as the people are concerned they seem to thoroughly understand what the issue is and they are fully satisfied that although we did not restore the sterling assets to what they were before, we were short only £9,000,000. The Budget was not balanced. It is just short £2,000,000. As far as the Budget is concerned, andconsidering that there was £15,000,000 against us two years ago and a bit more —possibly, roughly, some £20,000,000— I think it is a great feat that we should have succeeded in getting as far as we did.

There is another point, and it is that the country is quite satisfied with the progress of events. As far as the farmers are concerned, their industry is showing very substantial profits. The sales of agricultural produce have increased by £20,000,000 and in the last six or seven months industry has not been very far behind. Thank God, it was able to give us some support for the agricultural community, and will be able to do so again this year. So far as agriculture is concerned, I want to say that in the County Meath we have large areas of wheat this year. The crop has been well and properly put in. In fact, tillage has increased to a very great extent in the County Meath. All that shows the confidence which the people have in the Government. They are relieved to know that, if their affairs have not been completely fixed up, they are almost fixed up.

I do not think I would have said anything on this but for the fact that my stable companion, if you like to call him that—Deputy Giles—made some very wild statements here last week. I would call them very unfortunate statements. Some people would call them venemous statements. I do not blame him so much for that as I blame Deputy Dillon who gave him the lead. They both went back in their statements of the old Cumann na nGaedheal days or perhaps it was the young Fine Gael days, and said that our industries were completely abhorrent to them. Deputy Gile's statement was made on the 12th May and is reported in Volume 138 of the Dáil Debates, No. 13. It shows clearly what was in his mind, and it shows, too, the damage that it was intended to do. Speaking at column 1702 he said:—

"I stand for ordered industry, for decentralised industry, for Irish industry, but not for the thousands of tin-pot factories started by aliens and foreigners, with yellow streaks and black streaks, who do not caretwo hoots, but only to exploit the people with child labour and cheap girl labour. They want to get big dividends, and when they have money to spend they invest it in England and elsewhere. I want none of them, but the simple and plain people of the country."

That is a strange statement. There are eight or nine industries in the town of Navan. There is a furniture industry there which contributes to the national revenue by exporting quite an amount of furniture. There is also a carpet factory there. There is no child labour of any description employed in the factories there. A number of women are employed in the upholstery department of the furniture factory.

There is a boot factory in the town of Kells. Yesterday morning I actually saw the work going on there. I was pleased to learn that they are exporting quite a lot of their products to Scotland via Belfast, as well as to Holland, Norway and Sweden. That is the actual position, although Deputy Dillon says these factories could not live for a minute if they had not tariffs to support them and keep them up. That industry is giving employment to 200 people, 80 of them being women. The remainder are men, and the average wage paid is £4 10/- a week. Now, is there any charity when Deputy Giles gets up and makes such a statement as I have quoted? I do not blame him, but I blame the one who led him on, and that is Deputy Dillon.

These industries are fulfilling a very important part in this State. They are helping us to procure money from abroad. Is not that the best way that it could be done? The workers in those industries are employed under the very best conditions. The premises are air-conditioned so that there is no danger of their health being injured by dust. They have tea twice a day; they start work at 8.30 in the morning and finish at 5 o'clock in the evening. Is it the intention of those who make such statements as I have quoted to damage those industries? What are people outside of this country who would be anxious to help our industries by purchasing their products to thinkwhen they read a statement such as I have quoted, that child labour is employed in our factories and can point to the fact that that was said in the Dáil? I think that some steps should be taken to stop that sort of thing.

In conclusion, I want to refer to some figures which were given by the American economists who were here two years ago. The figures refer to the year 1948. The national income in that year was £334,000,000. Of that figure, agriculture produced 29 per cent.; industry, 21 per cent.; transport, 20 per cent., and other services between 7 and 8 per cent. Is it not quite clear from these figures that industry is beginning to play its part in the development and success of this country, and that it is giving the greatest possible help? Therefore, I objected, and felt very sore, when I read Deputy Giles's statement. I did not happen to be here when the statement was made. I hope and trust, for the sake of the country, and for the success of our industrial policy on which we are all now united, that members of the Dáil will be more careful about the statements they make in the future, and that never again will an opportunity be availed of to do harm to our industries. I hope that such statements will not be made in this Dáil again.

Comment on this

The Budget provides an opportunity for a general stocktaking of the economic condition of the country, and of the results of the economic policy of the Government in the course of the previous year. I think that, by any index that may be applied, it must be granted on all sides of the House that the economic position, in the course of last year, has disimproved and disimproved radically. It is in the light of that position that we have to examine the Budget. The present Budget, in effect, is a repetition of the economic policy which was imposed on the country last year, and it is that economic policy which has brought about the very critical deterioration in the overall economic position of the country.

I think it is necessary, however, that we should seek to examine, first, what the function of the budgetary policyof the Government should be. In olden times the Budget was merely a semiautomatic process whereby the Government assessed its anticipated housekeeping outlay, indicated the revenue which it would require and the manner in which that revenue would be raised. However, since the beginning of this century——

Comment on this

Surely it is not necessary to go back?

Comment on this

I do not think it should be necessary to go back but every indication that the Minister has given in introducing his Budget this year and last year shows that he does not even appreciate the elements of his function as Minister for Finance

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Unfortunately, that makes it necessary for me to go back.

Comment on this

We got on for a very long time in this House before Deputy MacBride became a member.

Comment on this

I want to refer to the high unemployment figures. We should be ashamed at the lack of progress in this country in the past 30 years which has largely been the result of the type of policy which the Minister is now imposing on the country.

It has come to be recognised—certainly since the first decade of this century—that the budgetary policy of the Government has the most fundamental effect on the economic condition of a country. It controls, in effect, the purchasing power of the community and directly affects development and employment conditions in the country. It can, by direct expenditure or by direct or indirect incentive, promote capital development and promote employment.

As I said a minute ago in reply to an interjection by the Minister, it would not be necessary to state what is an obvious consideration and a well-recognised fact were it not that the Government do not seem to appreciate and certainly the Minister does not seem to appreciate the functions of his economic policy. I think it is no overstatementof the position to say that it is now well within the power of a Government to create employment or to create unemployment at will by means of its budgetary and economic policy generally. By reducing the purchasing power of the people and by restricting credit, one knows in advance that unemployment will result, unless the reduction in the purchasing power of the people is offset by an increase in the national income. Inversely, it is quite obvious, even to the merest novice, that any reduction in purchasing power must create unemployment. At first, I was rather puzzled to determine whether the Government's attitude and in particular, the Minister's attitude in these matters sprang from an ignorance of these elementary considerations or whether it was part of a cynical disregard of the consequences of the Government's economic policy on unemployment and emigration.

I think that the Minister must certainly hold the record of any Minister for Finance introducing a Budget in a modern State. He was able to make a speech consisting of 66 pages of typewritten foolscap without once mentioning the unemployment condition in the country, without once indicating that he even realises its gravity, without once indicating that he proposes to take any steps to try and deal with the position, without once adverting to the conditions which have created that unemployment in the country and without showing any realisation of his responsibility to the country in regard to unemployment.

I do not think it is possible to give the Minister a fool's pardon in that connection because I think he should himself have been able to appreciate the results of his policy. Even if he did not, he had ample warnings—and not merely from the Opposition Benches. I remember that I gave such warnings last year when the Minister introduced his Budget but the Minister was inclined to deride my warnings that his budgetary policy was bound to create unemployment. He was inclined to laugh it off and to say that it was all nonsense. If I am not mistaken,he said last year that the unemployment position would improve as a result of his Budget.

In addition to any warnings which the Minister received from the Opposition Benches he was told in no uncertain terms by the directors of the Central Bank what the results of his deflationary policy would be and what the results of the policy which they advocated would be. Surely the Minister has not forgotten that the Central Bank, in their report, advised, among other things, the reduction of public works in view of what they termed "the unusually favourable condition of employment." That was a clear indication that, in their view, it was necessary to create a bigger unemployment figure. We have now reached the position where 12 per cent. of our working population are unemployed. I think that that is one of the highest figures on record for this country for a great many years.

Apart from the warnings which the Opposition gave and apart from the clear indication which the Central Bank gave of the inevitable results of the policy which the Minister pursued in his Budget last year, the Tanaiste gave a very good description of the factors that induce unemployment when he spoke in this House on the 14th February, 1952, on the subject of unemployment. In Volume 129, column 677, of the Official Report, the Tanaiste is reported as follows:—

"It is clear, therefore, that any contraction in demand, any factors operating to induce people to buy less, are bound to have repercussions upon the output and the employment given in these industries."

It is quite obvious that the effect of the Minister's budgetary policy was to induce people to buy less. It is quite obvious that they would have less to spend. The removal of the food subsidies, the imposition of additional taxation on consumer goods, the restriction of credits—all these things would inevitable lead to a reduction in the purchasing power of the people. The people would buy less; the shopkeepers, the producers, the manufacturers would also sell less; and, accordingly,unemployment would be inevitable. It appears, therefore, that the Minister must have embarked on his present economic policy with his eyes wide open, with the full knowledge that he was going to create unemployment and increase the surge of emigration. He now has had proof that that was the result of his policy.

I wonder if he realises, even now, the full extent of the unemployment position in the country. I know how easy it is when one is under fire, under criticism the whole time, to shelve consideration of facts which are presented. I wonder if the Minister appreciates fully the extent of the economic chaos which now exists. The tragic thing about the unemployment position is that it has been becoming comparatively worse in recent months. Unemployment varies, of course, according to the different seasons of the year. We know that it reaches its highest in the winter months and its lowest in the summer months and that comparison can be of assistance only by making it with a comparable period of another year. It would be well if the Minister would ponder on these figures. For the last Saturday in January, 1951, we had 65,877 persons unemployed; in the last Saturday of January, 1953, it was 87,283, an increase of 21,406. On the last Saturday of February, 1951, we had 63,032, while on the last Saturday of February, 1953, it was 89,579, an increase of 26,547. On the last Saturday of March, 1951, we had 59,670 unemployed, while on the last Saturday of March, 1953, we had 85,541, an increase of 25,871. I notice the Minister is smiling. It seems to amuse him, but I do not see that it is any laughing matter.

Comment on this

I regret it. I was not smiling at the Deputy, nor did I find the Deputy amusing. I only find him boring. I was smiling at Deputy Rooney, if the Deputy wants to know.

Comment on this

On the last Saturday in April, 1951, we had 54,913 unemployed, while on the last Saturday in April 1953, we had 84,041, an increase of 29,128. Accordingly, in the last four months, January, February, March and April we have had a progressivelydeteriorating position where the difference in increasing unemployment compared with 1951 had increased from 21,000 to 29,000 at a time of the year when unemployment should be decreasing rapidly. These are very serious figures. In the light of that situation, in the light of a crisis of that nature that the Minister should be able to introduce a Budget dealing with the economic position at great length without once referring to unemployment, without once indicating what steps he proposes to take, without once indicating that he even now realises that that unemployment is due to his policy, is a clear indication either that he does not appreciate his responsibility or that he is completely cynical as to the results of his policy.

It has been stated from time to time from Government benches that these unemployment figures are not accurate, that the introduction of the Social Welfare Act brought into the live register persons who had not been on it before. Of course I do not think that that bears examination. All that it did was to transfer a certain number of persons who were in receipt of public assistance benefit to the class that received unemployment insurance benefit. It does not affect the total on the live register.

Just to verify that I went to the trouble of looking up the employment figures. You find, for instance, that agricultural employment which stood at 470,000 in 1950 had fallen to 441,691 by the end of 1952. Industrial employment as exemplified by those who are employed in the manufacture of goods described in statistics as "transportable goods" fell from 133,000 in December, 1951, to 125,000 in September, 1952. Those employed by local authorities on building schemes fell from 11,100 in December, 1951, to 8,600 in December, 1952. That disposes of the suggestions that the figures are in any way distorted and do not reveal the true position.

Surely we must realise that the most serious ill which any country can suffer is a high rate of unemployment such as this—12 per cent. of our working population unemployed. It must be about the highest rate in Europe now.The Minister might well say "do not repeat things that are obvious" but it is necessary to repeat these things because apparently the Minister has ignored them and refuses to face them. Nobody with any pretence of having studied social questions or studied government can deny that unemployment from the social point of view is the greatest evil which any country can suffer. From the economic point of view it is completely wasteful. From the point of view of the national income, it is completely wasteful because it means that we are maintaining and supporting a large slice, 12 per cent, of the working population who are producing nothing, whose labour and whose efforts are all wasted.

It is wasteful also from the budgetary point of view which might possibly be of more concern to the Minister. I think it is no overestimation to say that probably each unemployed man draws benefits, directly or indirectly from the State, for himself or for his family, from public assistance or in the form of unemployment benefits, of at least £2 per week, and God knows that is miserable enough. When you have 90,000 unemployed, it is costing the Exchequer, the taxpayers of this country, £180,000 per week. This is no trifling amount. However serious unemployment may be for most countries, in the case of Ireland it is even more serious, because unemployment inevitable leads to emigration. The figures over a number of years show that when you have a high rate of unemployment, you have a high rate of emigration.

Comment on this

Is your colleague, Deputy Dillon, not in favour of emigration?

Comment on this

I have never heard Deputy Dillon say he was in favour of emigration. Certainly I am not but it is quite clear from the policy the Minister is pursuing that he has no concern whatever about it, because he is promoting conditions that must lead to emigration. Either he knows that or he does not. If he does not he isnot fit to be a Minister. If he does, he is encouraging emigration with his eyes wide open.

Deputy Mulcahy referred to the speech made by Sir Rowland Nugent in Belfast, and I think it would be well if I read one or two short passages from that speech. I think they are worth thinking over. Speaking in Belfast, as reported in the Irish Timesof May 16th, he said:—

"Emigration might prove the least expensive and least painful of Ulster's economic difficulties. The alternative to emigration was the ‘grim prospect' of trying to expand industry, already overdependent on overseas markets, in a contracting and unfavourable world market and to finance such expansion of industry, already starved of capital for decades, in a welfare State whose high taxation prevented those savings from which investment capital originated."

Is this the policy the Minister is pursuing? Is he pursuing a policy of promoting conditions that must lead to emigration because it might prove "the least expensive and least painful" solution of our economic ills?

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy seemed to approve of that speech. Perhaps you did not grasp that.

Comment on this

I do not think that Deputy Mulcahy, while I was here, said anything that would indicate that he approved of the policy of emigration.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

He did not.

Comment on this

On the contrary, it struck me that he was criticising the Minister for promoting conditions that lead to emigration.

Comment on this

He was commending the speech.

Comment on this

I am commending this speech for the Minister's consideration, and I think there is probably a good deal to be said for the more honest attitude of Sir Roland Nugent, who comes out and says that is his remedy,than for the attitude of the Minister who does not utter one word about it but promotes the conditions, with a vengeance, that must lead to a flood of emigration. Sir Roland Nugent went on:—

"Could we or should we try to solve our problems, not by increasing the means of employment to keep pace with a growing population, but, in part at least, by reducing that population by emigration? In a way, it seems mere common sense that, instead of bringing raw material and fuel to the worker and then exporting the product, the worker should go to, say, Canada, where there is ample raw material and fuel and to all appearances a market with almost unlimited possibilities for expansion and where he would find many compatriots already established... Unfortunately in Northern Ireland, the problem was already acute. We must have more capital and have it reasonably soon unless we decide to turn to emigration."

I do not know whether Sir Roland Nugent in that speech makes it quite clear that he favours that solution, but he puts it there as a query. He points out that the alternative to promoting organised emigration is to provide more capital development for the country. I do not think the Minister is so unintelligent, so simple as not to appreciate what the result of his budgetary policy is to be. I think he appreciated it fully last year when he introduced last year's Budget. He has introduced the same Budget this year and is pursuing the same policy. In the light of the experience he has gained during the year, if he had any doubt about it, he must now know that it is a policy that will create and continue to create unemployment and emigration. He is pursuing that policy with his eyes wide open, and I am therefore driven to the conclusion that he has answered in his own mind the question which Sir Roland Nugent asks—should we promote emigration? In the traditional way in which apparently the Department of Finance and the Central Bank have always answered the question, by saying "Yes. We do want to promoteunemployment and we do want to promote emigration. There should be an unemployment pool in the country." Otherwise, there is no explanation for the policy he is pursuing.

I do not know whether I should trouble myself with dealing with some of the references the Minister made in his Budget statement. Certainly he seems to undertake the standard of intelligence of the public when, for instance, he says: "Recovery in production and trade is already under way and this Budget will stimulate it." He could hardly believe that statement, having regard to the fall in production which has taken place, the fall in the production of industrial goods. Is it not sheer nonsense to ask people to produce more, while at the same time you contract credits, contract the purchasing power of the people and create unemployment and emigration? How can you expect higher production under these conditions?

The Minister, in his Budget statement, went on to say that it was satisfactory that the improvement in the balance of payments was achieved so quickly and—do listen to this—"with out any marked or general disturbance in the country's economy." Does the Minister believe that? Does anybody in the country believe that? There has been chaos in the country in the course of the last year, and the Minister knows it quite well. That is one of the reasons, I take it, that there is such reluctance to face the electorate, even in a by-election.

Comment on this

We do not want to lose you. That is the reason.

Comment on this

If you like, why not have a general election to-morrow? You will have the opportunity. Possibly, the Minister might not even hold his own seat. I do not know. I do not want to forecast. By all means, let me invite the Minister right now to have a general election. I would welcome it and, I believe, so would the majority of the people. I do not think the Minister would introduce another Budget if that occurred. Seriously, I do invite the Minister now tohave a general election. I take up his offer. Let him advise his leader to dissolve the Dáil and let him have a general election. Perhaps he might like a simpler beginning. Let his Party move the writ for the Wicklow by-election that they have been so reluctant to move.

Comment on this

What about East Cork?

Comment on this

The Wicklow seat has been vacant for some considerable period and there seems to be marked reluctance on the part of the Minister and his colleagues to face the electorate in Wicklow but should he, instead of facing the electorate in Wicklow, wish to go further, to take a plunge and face the country, by all means let him do it; we will welcome it. That is a fair offer. I think the Minister will get no opposition from this side of the House if he decides to give us an opportunity to test the country.

In this Budget speech the Minister repeated many of his well-worn Victorian tags for which the Central Bank and his Department have been famous for a great many years. I noticed that they did not like to commit themselves to inflation this year. There were some ambiguous sentences used by the Minister—I can find them for the Minister if he so desires—to the effect that we are poised between inflation and deflation. I admire the skill with which the Minister avoided committing himself this year to a positive attitude towards inflation and deflation.

I think this is worthy of notice, as indicating the mentality which lies behind the Minister's policy. He says that another matter that merits special mention is the diminution of the inflationary effect of State capital outlay. Presumably that is the diminution of employment, because that is the effect of reduced State outlay on public works. "The closer approach to monetary stability has been rescued...."— monetary stability—is that the sole criterion which motivates the Government? The question of unemployment, the question of emigration, do notmatter so long as the Minister has what he calls "monetary stability," and monetary stability in a year during which the cost of living has gone up by 20 per cent.

I heard the Minister waxing indignant to-day at question time with Deputy Norton because Deputy Norton implied in some supplementary question that the cost of living had gone up as a result of the Minister's policy —the Government's policy—it is not fair to blame the Minister solely for the policy because there is collective responsibility and apparently his colleagues do stand over him and his policy. But, taking the mid-February figures, in regard to food, at mid-February, 1951, the figure was 98 base 100, 1947, and in mid-February of this year it was 122, an increase of 24— from 98 to 122. Is that monetary stability?

The Minister seems to assume, I note from passages in his Budget statement that wages have now reached a stable position. Does he really believe that? Does he really believe that wages have yet caught up on the increases in the cost of living, increases which are continuing from day to day? We had a further increase only in the last 24 hours in the price of sugar. In the last 48 hours we had an increase in postal charges. Prices have been increasing steadily the whole time. Surely the Minister does not believe that the working population in this country can allow their real wages, the value of their wages, to be reduced in this manner without trying to compensate themselves by seeking increases in wages? Again, the Minister must have been making these statements with his tongue in his cheek.

The Minister went to great trouble in his Budget statement to decry or seek to ridicule the proposals that had been made by Deputy Costello for the formation of an investment board. I do not think he bothered putting forward any reasonable argument against it. He merely went to pooh-pooh it in general terms. Surely one of the main causes for the endemic underdevelopment and unemployment from which we suffer is the fact that we have been exporting our earnings, our capital, out of thecountry and investing it outside the country, instead of utilising it in Ireland. That is the fundamental thing that is wrong with our economy.

I had hoped that even the Minister and his colleagues had come to the point of realising that the general financial organisation, financial policy, had to be reversed, that the time had come when we had to take steps definitely to try to canalise our investments into Irish industries and Irish development. The only way in which that can be done in an organised and thorough manner is by the setting up of an investment board. May I again refer to the statement made by Sir Roland Nugent who, I am sure, cannot be described as an extreme economist? The suggestion he makes, apparently with regard to the difficulties of the Six Counties, and which is well worth considering is:—

"We must have more capital and have it reasonably soon, unless we decide to turn to emigration. I think it should be possible to devise a system by which savings actually made and invested in a suitable manner could be relieved from income-tax, while leaving the remaining income subject to full taxation. The basic principle of the method would be that already applied to covenants in favour of a charity. The taxpayer should be allowed to set aside every year a portion of income up to a specified maximum. This would be paid to a Government board which would add back the tax paid and allot the taxpayer shares in a Trust Company. There could be one Trust Company covering all objects, or a series of trusts—one dealing with investment in agriculture on the lines of an Agricultural Credit Bank, another, perhaps, helping family firms hit by death duties on the lines of the new Estates Duties Investment Trust Company, and another helping firms which desired to expand, and so on. Probably in a small area such as Ulster one, or, at most, two, such Trusts would suffice."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this

From the Irish Times, May 16th. That is a proposal somewhat analogous to the setting up of an investment board. Apparently the people in the Six Counties realise that their economy, too, has been starved of the investment which is required to provide employment for their people, realise that capital has been exported to England instead of being utilised in the Six Counties for development purposes.

We suffer from the same problem here intensified a thousand fold, because the rate of investment here has been much lower than in the Six Counties. We have holdings of somewhere about £500,000,000 invested outside this country. We hold more money invested outside this country than any other country in Europe. We boast of being a creditor nation. That boast is in reality an indictment of ourselves. In a country which is suffering from underinvestment and underdevelopment the greater the amount we have outside the country the greater is our fault in starving our whole economy of the money required for its development. That can only be overcome ultimately by the creation of an investment board which will, on an organised basis, plan for the repatriation of foreign investments and for the utilisation of those foreign investments in productive projects here.

The Minister in his Budget statement paid some passing tribute to the fact that he had received a good contribution from the Central Bank, presumably from the holdings of sterling assets in the name of the Central Bank. But I notice he was very silent as to the rate of interest which the Central Bank was receiving on these sterling assets. Is it still only receiving 1? per cent.? That is a matter upon which we might have some information when the Minister replies. It would also be of interest to obtain from the Minister some indication of the losses sustained by the Government on their holdings of sterling assets as a result of the catastrophic fall in the value of British gilt-edged securities in the course of last year.

Coming back to this question of being a creditor nation, I wonder hasit ever occurred to the Minister and his advisers that, in a situation such as the one through which we have lived in the last quarter of a century where the value of money in relation to its purchasing power has declined steadily, there is very little advantage in being a creditor, that all the advantages are in favour of the debtor, and that countries such as England, which are not unwise in financial matters, are never disturbed at the fact that they are debtor nations? It is quite obvious that in a situation such as this the debtor is in a favourable position. He has less to repay as the value of the money becomes less. On the other hand, the creditor who has lent money either by way of goods or cash has the pleasure of watching his money which he has lent to another country dwindling in value year by year.

Are we to continue maintaining these vast sums of investments abroad until they have depreciated to such an extent that they will serve no useful purpose at all? We have already lost very considerable sums in the course of the last few years by allowing this money to remain there depreciating continuously. I think that any person who examines the position must come to the conclusion that in a situation such as the one through which we have been living, all the advantages are in favour of the debtor and all the disadvantages accrue to the creditor nation.

I wonder, too, does it ever occur to the Minister's advisers to ask themselves what happens the money which we lend to Britain and the British Government. What does the British Government borrow this money for? What do they utilise these vast sums for? They borrow the money at a very cheap rate of interest from us. What do they use it for? They use it to build houses, they use it to promote industrial development, they use it to promote agricultural development, they use it to promote afforestation in England, they use it to pay for their social services. Would it not be better if we were to use this money for these purposes rather thanlend it to the British Government at a cheap rate of interest?

These things may sound at first somewhat removed from the Budget, but I think they are extremely relevant because, if I read the Minister's mind aright, if I interpret correctly the policy of the Minister and the Government and their advisers, they are imposing this deflationary policy, a policy which must lead to unemployment and emigration and which imposes hardship on the people, for the sole reason of being able to maintain and build up sterling assets. In my view, such a policy is criminal and is nationally unsound.

Comment on this

Before dealing with the various points with which I wish to deal I want to know where Deputy J. A. Costello got the £10,000,000 that we were alleged to have over last year. Last year Deputy Costello, a responsible Deputy and ex-Taoiseach, made a very foolish, wild and misleading statement and, remembering that statement, I hope the people now will judge his utterances this year on their merits in relation to that statement. Surely the people must appreciate now the irresponsibility of a statement alleging that the Minister for Finance, a member of a democratic Government, was trying to Budget for £10,000,000 more than was actually required. Deputy Costello stated here that we would have a surplus of £10,000,000 this year. I hope the people will consider these statements and weigh the support given to them by Deputy Costello's colleagues on the Opposition Front Bench, who follow the same line of thought and make the same foolish and misleading allegations. At the risk of being hackneyed, let me quote again:—

"The evil that men do lives after them;

The good is oft interred with their bones."

If those lines were ever applicable to any Party, they can charitably be applied to the ——

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

——the inter-Party Government.

Let us deal first of all with the agricultural industry. For years we, in Fianna Fáil, tried to encourage the farmers by grants and subsidies and other subventions.

Comment on this

And the economic war.

Comment on this

Do not play England's game. We did not force the economic war on the country. It was England who did that. I am surprised a responsible Deputy like you would come along and make a statement of that kind. We tried to do one thing: we tried to keep this country for the Irish people. England tried to break the spirit of old Ireland at that time as she did for hundreds of years before that and as she is trying to do now; and you and your followers helped her a long way on that road.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I assure the Deputy I did not.

Comment on this

I am sorry. It took Fianna Fáil a number of years to encourage the farmers to adopt a tillage policy. A number of our farmers always went in for tillage. A number of them never wanted to till and it took Fianna Fáil many years to induce them to adopt a tillage policy. As a result of that inducement we succeeded in getting a number of our farmers to go in for more tillage and that policy had certain beneficial results. More employment was given to our people and those who might otherwise have been compelled to seek employment in other countries were able to stay at home and work at home.

We made every effort to develop all phases of agriculture. In 1948 when Fianna Fáil went out of office numbers of workers were employed on the land. Several Ministers in the inter-Party Government alleged we had inspectors going around the country, that we had this, that and the other. When they left office in 1951 their Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, had killed an industry we had taken years to build up; he had changed the tillage policy to such a degree that thousands of our people were thrown out of employment. The Fianna Fáil Government has never believed in the policyof coercion or in the policy of compulsory tillage but certain steps had to be taken during the emergency period to render our people as self-supporting as it was possible to make them. Directly the inter-Party Government came into office they proceeded to misrepresent us, to allege that everything we did was done from a venomous point of view. We did nothing, according to them, on any laudable grounds.

I congratulate Deputy Dillon on successfully fulfilling two roles during his term in office: firstly, in trying as far as he could to run the agricultural workers off the land and, secondly, in encouraging our workers to go into foreign industries. Deputy Dillon appeared to have a particular liking for foreign industries in relation to agriculture, such as maize, tomatoes, fruit and various other commodities. He was very anxious to import these things. When I tried to get reasonable protection for our agricultural industries in County Dublin, Deputy Dillon, then Minister for Agriculture, was very versatile in misrepresenting what I asked him to do on occasions of that kind. He was, as a matter of fact, frivolous on occasions and he was supported by Clann na Poblachta, Fine Gael, Labour and all the rest of them. They were all clapping him on the back.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

On a point of order. Is this a debate on the Budget or a debate on Deputy Dillon?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I was waiting to see if the Deputy would come to the Budget.

Comment on this

It is such an eloquent speech I think it is desirable that a few more Deputies should listen to it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Relevancy is more important than eloquence. Perhaps the Deputy would make his statement relevant to the motion before the House.

Comment on this

I am speaking to the points that were made here.

Comment on this

On a point or order. I said that this is such an eloquentspeech I thought we might have the requisite number of Deputies to hear it.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

I was referring to the unemployment that was caused by our predecessors. We now have to try to make amends for their misdeeds. When I was dealing with a few points like that Deputy Sweetman thought well of interrupting me.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it an interruption to indicate that there is not a House present?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot pontificate on these finer points.

Comment on this

On numerous occasions I had to ask the previous Minister for Agriculture and the inter-Party Government was it their policy to kill the industries which we had established and which we were anxious to build up in our country in order to create employment, to make the country self-supporting and capable of exporting surplus produce. The Fianna Fáil Government gave every possible encouragement, by way of subsidies and other assistance, to our farmers and fruit growers. They were told that if we had not a market for anything they produced we would try to get a market abroad. In three years of inter-Party Government that whole trend of our agricultural economy was destroyed by the flippant Minister for Agriculture, supported by the other members of his Government. The responsibility lies with them, and it took us years to develop our agricultural industries to a satisfactory level. When you stop or change the trend of things in an industry of that kind and when people become discouraged and are turned away from a type of industry they have engaged in over a long number of years, it is not easy to get them back to their former ways.

Comment on this

Tomatoes are now 3/6 per lb

Comment on this

You are one of thegeniuses anxious to kill anything of an Irish outlook or any possibility of developing and Irish industry. It is that cat-crying which is responsible for having us as we are to-day.

Comment on this

Who will be so daft as to buy your tomatoes at 3/6 per lb.? People cannot afford it and you know it. It is like the butter.

Comment on this

To deal with another side——

Comment on this

You are getting away from the tomatoes.

Comment on this

Deputy McMenamin possibly, with his friend the Minister for Agriculture, has a greater interest in the Dutch tomato growers and giving employment to the Dutch workers than he has in our Irish workers.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy knows what we are discussing here is the financial policy of the Government.

Comment on this

That is true and that is what I am defending to the very best of my ability, the financial policy of the Government. I have cited what we have tried to do; we gave the maximum encouragement to our agricultural industry, to the tillage farmers, to our tomato growers, fruit growers, and so on. In every phase of our agricultural industry we have tried to create the maximum amount of employment. One of the reasons why I did go back over the last three years was that I had to point out to this House the harm that had been done to the country. The responsibility lies at the door of the inter-Party Government who did all the damage they could and put a number of people, who were in gainful employment up to the time they came in, out of employment. We are trying to remedy that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy but so far he seems to me to be very far away from the Financial Motion.

Comment on this

I bow to your able ruling, Sir, but I am merely asking a question. The last speaker dealt entirely with unemployment and I ampointing out where the unemployment started and what we are doing in an endeavour to create employment.

I will now refer once more to our industries in the light of the conditions in the constituency which I have the honour to represent. In County Dublin in 1951 I found a number of our factory workers idle. The reason they were idle was again the stockpiling policy of the inter-Party Government. Instead of importing raw material they imported the manufactured article. We are suffering from the effects of that policy still; a number of our wholesale houses in the City of Dublin and all over the country have also felt its effects. During that period a number of our people were thrown out of employment.

The present Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Seán Lemass, has done everything possible to give industrialists in this country all the protection necessary. He has gone further than that. He has introduced an Insurance Bill to encourage our industrialists even to export their goods. As a Party we have left no stone unturned to see that loans would be put at the disposal of our industrialists and everybody who wanted to go into industry. There again we have the spectacle in this House of responsible Ministers threatening, during the three years they were in office, to put certain industrialists behind double doors. It is no use getting up in this House using cat cries; we must definitely get down to hard facts as to what is responsible for the position in which we find ourselves to-day. I do not think I am being in the least uncharitable; I doubt if anybody could say that I ever was, but I must tell the truth. I lay the whole blame for the position we are in to-day at the door of the inter-Party Government. However, as a result of our budgetary policy this year and last year we are definitely bringing the country back to a satisfactory standard. No responsible Minister in any democratic country will impose taxation unless the national necessity demands that he should impose it. Surely no one would suggest we would do that for any other purpose.

We, as a Party, had to do the most unpopular things to improve the economy of the country. Even in 1948, when we were in opposition, Deputy Lemass then said: "We are giving you the country in a sound financial position: I hope we will get it back the same." Unfortunately we did not get it back the same. It was very unpleasant for any Government to have to adopt the attitude that we were compelled to adopt on the introduction of the 1952 Budget. We knew that everything we were about to do would be politically bad for us, but we decided to be honest with the people of Ireland and we put the interest of the people before the interest of our own Party. I am sure the people of Ireland realise that.

Comment on this

The unemployed do not realise it.

Comment on this

You are one of the archangels in this country alleged to be representing Labour, but you are one of those who backed Deputy Dillon when he was throwing people out of employment.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will address the Chair, and Deputy O'Leary will please restrain himself.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

The Deputy seems to have got "a thing" about Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

I hold them all responsible. I shall take the cue from Deputy Dockrell on this occasion. It is better to hold them all responsible and not one individual. Will that suit Deputy Dockrell?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Make your own speech.

Comment on this

During 1951 I went down to Balbriggan and to Lucan, and I was told that hundreds of workers had been thrown out of employment as a result of the policy of the inter-Party Government. Since 1951 the Minister for Industry and Commerce has been trying to clean up the mess left by his predecessor, and he is finding it very difficult to do so. Almost every day since, he has been finding lists of manufactured commodities importedby his predecessors. I ask members of the last Government, and Deputy O'Leary, one of their disciples who interrupted me a few moments ago, what was their idea in doing this or have they any policy at all? Possibly they had some interest in foreign industries and were anxious to provide work for foreign labour. That is the only explanation I can see of their policy. We are now supposed to wield a magic wand and to undo in one year, even in one night, all the damage they did for three years.

I respectfully suggest that whilst that may appear reasonable to Opposition Deputies, we have no magic wand for solution of the country's ills, but at least we did take up where we left off in 1948. We are going the right way about it, as the people of Ireland realise, and the cat calls of Deputy O'Leary and company are not going to put us off the track. Having given maximum protection and every possible encouragement to agriculturists and industralists, we hope to be able to provide full employment for our people as quickly as possible. We have tried to get an export market and we shall continue with our efforts in that direction. We have improved social services and we shall continue with that policy so far as the country can afford it. We are not neglecting anything. I would ask members of the inter-Party Government to examine their consciences. Future historians will have to deal lightly with them if they are not to appear in a very bad light because, if they have any consciences at all, they must realise that some of the statements they have made—and I say this advisedly—in trying to misrepresent us and the efforts we are making to rebuild the country, are not at all worthy of the people whom they have the honour to represent in this House.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

This Budget has a considerable air of rectitude about it. The Minister introduced it with the professed intention of doing a great deal of good for the country but actually that was an entirely specious argument. Boiled down, the Budget isbut an explanation, with some important omissions, of the present situation and with very little in it in the way of proposals for the alleviation of the many ills which beset us at the present moment. As well as introducing an air of rectitude, the Minister seemed to think that he was putting the ship of State on an even keel and that, notwithstanding the machinations of various persons and the alleged mishandling of the country during the period of office of the inter-Party Government, he was now making everything right. One of the matters to which the Minister did not refer was unemployment, nor did he speak about the state of trade in the country at the present time. These are two matters which hang together. You cannot have an unemployment figure of 84,000, as we have at the moment, without having the difficult position which exists in the present state of trade. The volume of trade has dropped and, not unnaturally, unemployment figures have risen enormously. With the colossal figure of unemployment which we have, the highest in the history of this country, we are carrying a burden which is really beyond the capacity of the country because not only have we to support these people, but we have to pay for the many ills which generally accompany unemployment. Unemployment spells increased hospitalisation and increased sick benefits.

I was interested to hear Deputy MacBride refer to the unemployment figures as being something in the neighbourhood of 90,000. He reckoned that each one of those individuals costs the State £2 per week. Strangely enough, I myself had arrived at a figure of £2 per week as being a very rough estimate of the direct financial payment which the community makes per week to an unemployed man. That will give some idea of what unemployment costs us in terms of money, but we cannot make any computation of what it costs us in terms of human misery except that we do know it brings all sorts of other difficulties along with it. I would remind the House that in the early 1930's it was reckoned that the colossal figures in respect of unemployment in Germany—I think they rose to something like 8,000,000—caused the rise of Hitlerism. I am not envisaging anything like that in this country. I merely mention that as the type of ill which follows on large unemployment figures.

We have, of course, in this country the outlet for our unemployed and that is the emigration ship. That is one of the most tragic things which we have in our economy. It is a very difficult subject indeed to deal with. Successive Governments have made certain efforts to deal with the problem but no Government has succeeded in solving it but at least what we may expect from a Government is that the financial policy they pursue is one which is designed to help the country at large and is being used as an instrument for the furtherance of the economic policy of the country. How on earth can trade improve with the handicaps it is carrying at the present moment and with 80,000 odd—I have a figure of 84,000—unemployed? That is the outward and visible sign of the financial policy followed by this Government. We know that the figure of 84,000 is one which is a great deal higher than it was three years ago under the inter-Party Government.

Deputy Burke spoke about unemployment during the period of the inter-Party Government. Actually, of course, there was a period when employment figures were never higher and unemployment figures were the lowest they had been for many years. Yet, the Minister when talking about the state of the country says:—

"It is satisfactory that the improvement in the balance of payments to which I have referred was achieved so quickly and without any marked or general disturbance of the country's economy."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Has the Deputy the reference?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Yes. It is column 1182, Volume 138, No. 10 of the Official Debates. The above seems a remarkable statement when we take cognisance of the fact that our unemployment figures were never higher than they are at the present momentand that our volume of trade has declined.

The Minister, in his Budget speech, referred with pride to the drop in our imports of £32.4 million. Indeed, the Minister referred with pride on previous occasions to the drop in our imports. I wonder does the Minister and the Government generally realise that if you stop goods and raw materials coming into the country to the extent of £32,000,000 you are inevitably bound to have a falling off in trade? You cannot take that amount of money out of the national turnover, because that is what it is, without having a consequent fall in trade and a rise in unemployment figures. That is exactly what has happened. That is exactly what we predicted would happen.

If you asked any sensible fair-minded and open-minded businessman what would happen if you cut down drastically the imports, he would say, of course: "You will be able to do less business and give less employment". That is what has happened. The financial policy which brought about a reduction in our imports to that extent has also brought about a restriction of credit. It has been denied that the Minister's financial policy has had that effect but every businessman knows that all over the country there has been in the last couple of years a considerable restriction of credit which can have only one effect, namely, a decrease in the volume of trade and a rise in unemployment.

During the Vote on Account when I, and, indeed, other people, referred to the bad effect the Government's financial policy was having on trade generally and on employment, the Minister said they were carrying out Government works and that there had been no fall in the amount of money the Government spent on public works of various types. In fact, he poohpoohed the idea that the financial policy had led to a trade slump or a trade recession. I am glad to see he has had a change of heart because the burden of his argument was that the general financial policy did not really matter and, in fact, had not changed because the Government were themselvespushing ahead with public works and that the ordinary commercial transactions, beside the Government works, almost paled into insignificance. The Minister, speaking at column 1181, Volume 138, No. 10, Dáil Debates, said:—

"... it is salutary to remind ourselves that, while the activities of the State have a considerable influence, they are not of predominant importance in our economy. Private decisions as to work, investment, consumption and savings play a major part in shaping the course of our economic and financial affairs."

I am very glad to see that the Minister recognises that private decisions play a major part in shaping the course of our financial and economic affairs, because it is the financial policy which the Minister inaugurated, and which his Government backed up, which has directly led to the fall in the volume of trade and the consequent rise in unemployment. The financial policy of the Government or, if you like, of this country should be an instrument used for the economic well-being and happiness of all our people. That is what the economic policy of a country should do, but the economic policy which the Government has been following during the past two years is one which has led inevitably to a trade slump and unemployment. I hope, now that the Minister realises the importance of the thousand and one decisions which are made every day in business and agriculture, that he will not continue to follow a policy which is bound to render the work that the ordinary individuals do impossible: in other words, that he will not continue to implement a financial policy that renders those decisions impossible.

The Minister referred with a good deal of pleasure to the fact that the balance of payments this year represented a deficit of £9,000,000, a figure which, he said, the Central Statistics Office had given to him. I should like if the Minister would give the House details of how that figure of £9,000,000 was arrived at. I do so because nodetails have been given so far, and the details are of very great importance. I should also like to ask him whether, in the figures which make up the deficit of £9,000,000, emigrants' remittances have been taken into account, and also what figure, if any, has been allowed for the payments made by tourists to the country. We have had a whole financial policy carried out on the assumption that the balance of payments must be reduced, and it has been reduced to £9,000,000. It is, naturally, of the greatest importance to know whether that figure of £9,000,000 takes into account all the factors in our economy. We, on this side of the House, consider that we have paid a very high price indeed for bringing the balance of payments down to £9,000,000. Therefore, it is of vital importance to know just how far every favourable factor has been taken into account.

I refer to the drop in imports of £32.4 millions. That, of course, means a very considerable reduction in imports of raw materials and goods. What many of us would like to know is whether there is not some other way less destructive of our national economy and less damaging to human beings than suddenly to cut off £32,000,000 worth of imports. Credit is our life blood. It is the life blood of all communities, whether business or agricultural. Any restriction in that direction has dangerous consequences and is bound to have dangerous consequences. Therefore, what many people are wondering to-day is just how far is this restriction absolutely necessary to our economy, especially when we take into consideration that we are operating inside the sterling area.

Deputy Mulcahy referred to the financial policies which were inaugurated in Great Britain and which seem to be slavishly followed over here. That is a question which many of us in this country are very concerned about at the present moment. We are mainly an agricultural country with a small amount of exports. The overwhelming amount of our exports go either to Northern Ireland or Great Britain,which are inside the same financial area as ourselves. Great Britain is one of the largest commercial and manufacturing countries in the world and follows a financial policy which is geared to assist in every possible way the tremendous overseas exports which she carries. We are an agricultural country. Many of our problems are different from those of Great Britain. How far are we wise in following the financial policies which are designed to help a great manufacturing country when we ourselves are a small agricultural country? What Deputy Mulcahy had to say is very relevant to the whole economy of Ireland. We seem to follow these policies without having a very clear idea as to whether or not they are good for us.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell us where we have followed these policies?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

You have followed the financial policy.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy be good enough to prove his assertion by giving us some facts?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

You follow the financial policy.

Comment on this

In what way?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

The restriction of credit.

Comment on this

Did the Minister not go over to Mr. Butler?

Comment on this

There has been no restriction of credit.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

There has.

Comment on this

There has not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Every person who has been engaged in business in this country in the past two or three years knows that there has been a restriction of credit.

Comment on this

For people who have had unwieldy or non-liquid stocks. I suppose they have to meet their bank obligations some time. Would the Deputy give us some other facts?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

That is one of overwhelming and overriding importance.

Comment on this

It does not happen to be true. Would the Deputy give us some other evidence? It may be true in the case of some business which is bordering on insolvency, but it is not true in the case of a sound business.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

The Minister is not correct. What he is stating is not a fact. At column 1210 of the Official Report of Wednesday, 6th May, 1953, the Minister in his Budget speech referred to the committee which he is going to set up to inquire into the incidence of direct taxation on production. I am glad to see that the Minister said:—

"One of the more recent, but most persistent contentions is that the present incidence of the tax——"

—that is, income-tax——

"——constitutes a positive deterrent to the modernisation and extension of productive capacity."

It has taken the Government a long time to learn that. I trust that the view which is somewhat timidly put forward there by the Minister will have a good effect when the committee meets. I should like the Minister to make the terms of reference of that committee wider than just "the incidence of direct taxation on production". I should like to see that committee go into the whole question of the income-tax code. That is another example of following blindly a code which was set up for a different set of circumstances. Income-tax was originally introduced in Great Britain and, again, it was considered a good method of raising revenue in a highly-industrialised country. We are not a highly-industrialised country: we are an agricultural country. I should like to see this committee inquire into how far the income-tax code can be simplified and rendered more capable of use in a country which is largely agricultural.

At column 1191 of his Budget speech the Minister tried to make a case for the decline in the consumption of spirits when he said:—

"It is believed that a declining trend in the consumption of spirits had set in before the last Budget and would have continued even if there had been no increase in duty. Indeed, a tendency for the consumption of spirits to decline has been a marked phenomenon in several countries over the past two or three years."

That contention is very strenuously resisted by the Irish Pot Distillers' Association. The Minister further says:—

"...there is good reason to believe that consumption was not affected to the extent that the reduction in clearances from bond would suggest..."

The Irish Pot Distillers' Association protest very strongly against that statement by the Minister. They say it is not true. They say that, in fact, there has been a fall in the consumption of home-made spirits of over 200,000 proof gallons and a fall in revenue of between £300,000 and £400,000. I appeal to the Minister on behalf of such a very old industry. Surely it is not in the interests of this country to allow such an industry to pay the extraordinary and enormous amount which they have to carry? It will mean inevitably that that industry will die and the trade will go entirely to the Scotch distilleries. There is a greater potential dollar export, I believe, and it would be a pity that this industry should be hampered to the extent it is in its home market when it could be such an earner of dollars for us.

In conclusion, I would point out that this Budget has really altered nothing. It is an "as-you-were" Budget. There is a great deal of talk in it but practically nothing of any consequence to deal with the very serious situation in which we find ourselves. It is very serious to have rising unemployment figures and at the same time the fall in trade which has gone on for the last two years. During the early part of the year we heard a good deal about efforts to reduce taxation. There is not a word of any consequence in thisBudget statement about that. There is no real effort to reduce taxation or the cost of government. There is very little in it about the real questions which are of vital importance and there is not real approach to the two fundamental things from which we are suffering—the high figures for unemployment, which are taxing the capacity of this country to the utmost and the other very real question which goes hand in hand with it, namely, the fall in the volume of trade.

The country expected the Minister to deal with these two questions, to put forward some proposals of a serious sort for rendering the effect of these two things less harsh on the country. That has not happened. We have had an unreal statement, nicely delivered, but a statement which does not help us in the very difficult times that lie ahead.

Comment on this

I will be very brief. I have listened to this debate over many days, and to the Minister inside the House and through the Press trying to blame the inter-Party Government for all the damage that has been done. In 1948 when the inter-Party Government was formed and took over, we had to reduce taxation by £6,000,000, which was put on by a Fianna Fáil Minister in 1947. We had also at that time to increase the old age pensions, to give the people of rural areas—who had to depend on 2/6 along with 12/6 old age pension—an increase of 5/-. I was glad to be in a Government that did that. We had a Minister—the late Tim Murphy, God rest him—who put direct labour housing schemes in operation at full steam throughout the length and breadth of Ireland. To-day I find in my own town, Enniscorthy, and throughout the County Wexford, housing schemes coming to an end, the men that we called home from Britain, the tradesmen, going back again every night as there is no prospect of employment. What is happening the forestry workers—I was listening to Deputy Burke—who are becoming unemployed because their Estimate was cut down by £250,000?

When we came into the inter-Party Government we found this countrywithout bacon. You would not see a pig on the road—until Deputy Dillon became Minister for Agriculture. The bacon factories were on short time. In my own town the men were working three days a week in Buttles Bacon Factory, until the inter-Party Government came in and pig production was given an upward trend and agriculture was put on the right road. We had two Ministers for Agriculture previous to that, Deputy Dr. Ryan and Deputy Smith. What was their policy? They threatened the farmer with an inspector for every acre. They slaughtered the calves and exported the heifers. That is why you have a scarcity of butter and milk in the country to-day, and why you have to import butter from New Zealand and shove it down the people's necks in Dún Laoghaire and Bray, according to the papers this morning.

I say to the Minister that the Budget was very bad for the poor people. There is no relief in it. A few days before that, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs announced increased charges for telephones and stamps. What did we find yesterday morning in the news? An extra half-penny on sugar. If this Government remains in office, I suppose we will have the Minister for Industry and Commerce telling us the advisory body tells him to increase the price of cigarettes and tobacco. Surely the ordinary Deputies sitting behind the Minister, if they are mixing with the public and the people who elected them, have heard complaints from the unemployed? Deputy Killilea comes from Galway. I see a statement about the serious unemployment problem in the City of Galway. The same thing applies all over and the Government is doing nothing about it. They are making no honest effort, but people are asking what they are to do because they cannot live on the dole. It is no remedy to have men signing at the labour exchanges, drawing benefit for the few stamps they have for six months and then going back on unemployment assistance. I have here an extract from the Irish Pressdated 29th October, 1945, with the heading “Cure for Emigration” which reads:—

"A very successful inter-cumanndebate was held under the auspices of the Fintan Lalor Cumann Fianna Fáil in the Rossa Hall, Rathmines, when the motion: ‘That Conscription is the only cure for Emigration was passed."

That is something for the members of the Government to think over. I am sure the Minister for Finance presided at that meeting because that is his area.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not seem to be relevant to the financial motion.

Comment on this

Emigration is very relevant at the moment. I want to bring to the Minister's attention also this extract from a speech delivered by my colleague, Deputy Hickey, on 27th November, 1951. The Deputy was referring to the Hospitals' Trust Fund and he said:

"When the inter-Party Government came into office I availed of that opportunity. I got an answer with full details and I found that the Hospitals' Trust Fund had been lent as far away as Newfoundland, Ceylon, New Zealand, Trinidad, Nigeria, Rhodesia and Scottish agricultural stock at 3 per cent. and a number of English corporations and municipalities at 3 per cent. and 3¼ per cent. That money was lent to these far-away places at rates of interest of from 2½ per cent. to 3½ per cent., while Cork Corporation had to pay 5 per cent. in order to build houses for our people."

I ask any member of the Government if he agrees that our money should be invested in foreign countries and if it is a sin to bring back the money invested there to put men to work in this country? Instead, we have this money given to far-away places, which should not happen. The like of the numbers queueing up at the labour exchange in my town of Enniscorthy has never been seen before. They have to have two shifts, and that is happening in other towns. I say that it is the duty of the Government to provide employment, to provide houses for our people, to clothe and feed our people and not to sit back and think thatthings are all right because they have bought Tulyar and were able to parade him at the Curragh for all the big boys to clap. Let them put the Taoiseach or the Minister on Tulyar and let him go round the labour exchanges and see if the unemployed will clap him then. The present Government are too long in office. They have had 18 years of office—they were out for three years and they got the fright of their lives.

Comment on this

The voters got the fright of their lives.

Comment on this

You got Deputy Cowan, Deputy Cogan and the rest of them to put you back, but this country would be on its feet now if you had not got back and there would be no unemployment. It would be growing stronger as it was growing stronger when the inter-Party Government were in power. Deputy Dillon did good for the farmers, as the farmers admit, and as Deputy Allen knows, but he could not say a good word about Deputy Dillon. Deputy Dillon, as Minister, put the farmers of Wexford on their feet. He provided lime at 16/- a ton.

Comment on this

We are sending it down from Skerries.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon says that we should not have any Irish tomatoes.

Comment on this

Poor people are not able to buy Irish tomatoes.

Comment on this

He gave them protection all the same.

Comment on this

The Government will have to wake up because the people will not stick this for too long. The most dangerous thing a country can have is an army of unemployed. I saw them marching in Wexford in 1934 and lying outside the county home as a protest against the county council, of which Deputy Allen was a member, and we could have them marching on Leinster House before long. I admire the spirit of the Civil Service. They marched and carried their banners and were not ashamed. By doing so, they made the Minister and the Government take notice, but so long as our workers allow themselves to be gulled by catchcries and flag waving, they need notexpect any better treatment. Every member of the Government got Labour votes—they are not all in office because of the votes of the big shots—and the day of reckoning will come. If the unemployed to-day had their opportunity they would sweep Fianna Fáil off the market.

Comment on this

We are not on the market.

Comment on this

They would sweep Fianna Fáil away—not only the men, but their wives and sons and daughters—and we will probably see that soon in Wicklow and in Cork. We have the high cost of living with butter 4/2 a lb. in an agricultural country and we boast about the Minister who increased butter to that price.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want the farmers to go back again to 3½d. per gallon?

Comment on this

The farmers shook you when they marched on Leinster House during the strike.

Comment on this

And they put them in jail.

Comment on this

They made the Government take notice.

Comment on this

You filled the jails often, and the graveyards, too.

Comment on this

I wonder was Deputy Rooney with them or against them in that march?

Comment on this

They made the Government take notice anyhow, and by their action they got the increase.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Leary should be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

We have had appeals by the President for unity, but when they see good Irishmen here insulting each other across the floor, the people outside have their own views. Why, if you are honest about unity, will you not stop talking about the civil war and stop insulting men on this side of the House who made sacrifices, too— as many as you did—but who were notpaid for them? If Deputy Allen wants to take a shot at me, he can do so. He should get up and make a speech on behalf of the people of Wexford, as I do. Does he think everyone there is satisfied with the present position, in which road workers are unemployed and Local Authority (Works) Act grants cut down, with men in rural areas idle and emigrating? The people did not expect that that would be the position under any Government, whether it was Fianna Fáil or the inter-Party Government. I am surprised at some of the people who are supporting the Government who were very vocal about certain things when the inter-Party Government were in power but who are very silent now.

The day the Irish people put out the politicians the better. They go on the platform and promise them the sun, moon and stars. The inter-Party Government promised them ten points. The Fianna Fáil Party promised them 17 points. They promised the people that they would not withdraw the food subsidies. I heard that being said in Wexford. I read it in the papers. They promised that if Fianna Fáil were returned to power, they would not reimpose the taxes on tobacco and they would not interfere with the food subsidies. They forgot all that. I do not blame the members on the front benches for that because there is not an all-Ireland team that switches as often as the present group of Ministers switch. The Minister for Education switched over to Lands. The Minister for Agriculture became the Minister for Health. There is not a team in Croke Park that has switched so often.

Comment on this

You people played with a few extra men.

Comment on this

You had to get the extra men this time.

Comment on this

You did not switch; you jumped into Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

They were not bad after all. They did not burn down the country or anything. They tried to build it up. They are the people who first started the sugar factories when you called them white elephants. Onemust give credit where it is due and not throw muck all the time.

Comment on this

We did not reduce the old age pensions.

Comment on this

You should never mention the old age pensions because what you are giving to-day is a disgrace.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil reduced them by taxation.

Comment on this

How much would you give?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cunningham has already spoken and should allow Deputy O'Leary to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

I do not mind Deputy Cunningham. He is new to the House. He will get sense by and by. We should be ashamed of old age pensions at the rate of 21/6 per week.

Comment on this

Why did not you tell the Coalition Government that?

Comment on this

We doubled it in our time.

Comment on this

We would have given them 30/- if we had been in power, only you got around Deputy Cowan and Deputy Cogan.

Comment on this

Any advance on 30/-?

Comment on this

Listen here——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy O'Leary would address the Chair, perhaps these interruptions might cease.

Comment on this

Sometimes they are healthy. Talking about old age pensions, I know an Old I.R.A. man who was out in 1916, in my own time. He went over to Britain and stayed there for nine years. He is back again and is drawing 34/- a week at 65 years of age. One man went to the labour exchange. He had years' stamps on his card. He was offered two years' benefit. He said he would not bother about it, if de Valera would not give him any more when Churchill gave34/- for nine years. That is a single man. I know cases of married men for whom I signed certificates, who are getting allowances for their wives, having spent a few years in Britain, to which they were compelled to go. Then we talk about 21/6. Deputies opposite do not tell us about all the people who are denied the old age pension through the means test because they have a few acres of land. There are several such cases in my own constituency. There is the case of a widow who, because she has a small bit of land, gets only 11/-.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These questions of administration arise on the Estimates, not on the Financial Resolutions.

Comment on this

I am replying to the interruptions.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no necessity to reply to interruptions.

Comment on this

The Minister should examine his conscience. The people are asked to increase production. How can production be increased if the majority of our people are unemployed, if farm labourers have to go over to Britain to till for the people on the other side? They will get £5 a week over there whereas we give them only £4 and in some cases less. If the Government want a happy, contented nation, they must give the people fair wages and a lower cost of living. Think of all the people who are unemployed. Think of the hundreds who are trying to exist on home assistance. I know, and Deputy Allen knows, that our county manager asked the local authority this year for £27,500 for home assistance cases in County Wexford. That reveals an appalling state of affairs. What is the position in Dublin, where everything is very dear, where it costs 2d. or 3d. in bus fare to get to Moore Street to purchase vegetables?

The people expected to get reliefs under this Budget. Shopkeepers expected reliefs. The public gallery was full of shopkeepers from the city onBudget day. Vintners expected reliefs. The wholesale bottlers expected reliefs so that employment could be provided. There is no sign of any relief. The Government are continuing the policy of blaming the inter-Party Government. That is no excuse. That will not go down in the country. The Government promised to bring down the cost of living but they increased it. You promised full employment but you denied it to the people. By increasing the interest for housing loans you are slowing up the housing programme. There are restrictions on credit. There is no use in the Minister saying there are not. You must have two very good securities now to get £100 from any bank manager. There are restrictions even on local authorities.

When the inter-Party Government were in power there was plenty of work. In the rural areas in my constituency there were very few unemployed. The people were employed at drainage, land reclamation, road works and housing schemes. To-day that employment is all gone. Nobody knows that better than Deputy Allen, because I am sure he has been approached by unemployed people looking for work from the county council as I have been. The unemployed are going to England whenever they can get a job. They are going every night.

Comment on this

They are coming back in greater numbers.

Comment on this

They must have been coming back for An Tóstal. Coming from Tipperary as he does, I thought the Deputy would be more honest.

Comment on this

There are three coming back for the one going out.

Comment on this

I should like to get that on record, that there are three coming back for the one going out. That may be the case in your area. I hope it is true with regard to the Golden Vale.

Comment on this

It is true.

Comment on this

I hope the unemployed will see that statement. They will be asking you next week about where they are coming back. Every boatleaving this country is taking them away. At Rosslare harbour every night, especially on Saturday nights, the boats are booked out. You can get the returns at Wexford and Enniscorthy stations and at Deputy Allen's own town of Gorey.

Comment on this

They are tourists going on holidays.

Comment on this

They are hungry people who are going away.

Comment on this

There is no use in bickering across the House about it because it will get us nowhere. You should try to get the Government to wake up to the fact otherwise all of you will lose your seats. The Minister will probably get back all right but the rank and file will be swept away.

Comment on this

That would be no great harm.

Comment on this

It would be a good job for the country. That is what we are here to do.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary would not like to see the old back benchers going. Would he not be too lonely?

Comment on this

There are a good many old back benchers gone. They were honest men, but the younger men are not as honest. They have only recently come into the Dáil and they have to be told what to do. Anything could happen in this country with the mass unemployment which we have. Nothing could be more dangerous than to have an army of unemployed and their dependents. They are a menace in every country. Something should be done about them. We are told that there is unemployment in England. Where do our people find employment when they go over there? Every boy and girl who leaves here can walk into a job there the next day. We cannot provide work for them here.

The housing schemes should be kept going no matter what Government is in power. The housing situation in the City of Dublin and in the country districts is very bad. There are not half enough houses for the people who require them. If we are to keep ouryoung men in the rural areas, we must provide houses for them so that they can settle down and work for the farmers. There are no prospects for them now in the rural areas or in the towns. Another problem which will have to be faced is the rents of the houses which are being provided which are beyond the reach of the working classes.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not deal with the question of rents on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

If we want to keep our people at home and if there is to be any future for the country, we must provide employment for the people. We read in the papers about special trains carrying people from the North of Ireland who are going to Canada to build up the British Commonwealth there. Northern Ireland is doing that, but we should not do it. All these young men will be dragged into a world war. They are leaving the Six Counties and they are being joined in Dublin by men from the South. That is very bad and, no matter what Government is in power, they should stop it. The only way to stop it is to provide work. Doles are no good; they are a pure waste of money. It would be far better to give the people employment on the roads and on housing schemes. There will be good security for the money expended. House property is the best security in any country and the Government need not be afraid to carry on with the housing schemes which were initiated by the late Deputy Murphy. There is work to be done there; plenty of houses are needed and the building of them will give employment.

We hear a lot of talk about attracting tourists to this country. If we want to attract tourists, we must have good roads. You could employ men on the roads all over the country for the next 20 years and even then you would not have proper roads.

Comment on this

When we were trying to get more money for the roads you voted against it.

Comment on this

That is only hearsay. The Minister for Social Welfarestopped the fuel scheme for old age pensioners. Did you agree to that? The old age pensioners were deprived of fuel for the summer and at the same time £30,000 could be spent on decorations for An Tóstal. I should like to hear the Deputy say something about that.

I should like to see every one of you getting up to speak. There is no use in one or two back benchers getting up. Let us hear what you all have to say and whether you all agree with the present policy of the Government. I do not believe you do. You know that the Budget is a bad one and that the position of the country at the present time is a very bad one owing to unemployment. It is your duty at Party meetings to tell the Government what should be done and what the people want, as the Opposition are doing. A good Opposition is a very healthy thing. You must have a good Opposition.

Comment on this

I agree with that.

Comment on this

We have not that in this House.

Comment on this

There must be some people with whom you do not agree. A good Opposition is wanted in every Parliament. You have been over there for 18 years and during the last two years you have disgraced yourselves. The last two years of Fianna Fáil administration, backed by the four Independents, has shaken the foundations of the State and put the people lower down than they ever were before. The people cannot to-day exist on the miserable few shillings they have. Talk about being rationed during the war period: the people are really rationed now because they have not the wherewithal to buy. Half one's money is taken out of one's pocket by way of taxation. The married man and his family are groaning under the cost of living. Yesterday sugar went up by ½d. per lb. Yet, we are told there is no increase in taxation and this is an "as-you-were" Budget. Probably to-morrow morning something else will have gone up in price. It is not the Minister who is solely responsible forthe position. The whole Government is responsible, and so are the people who sit behind the Minister. All the Deputies in the Government Benches represent the people. I do not know what they will say to the people when the by-elections come off. I do not know how Deputy Cogan will defend himself. We will have to wait and see, I suppose, and we will have to accept the decision, whatever way it goes. That is democracy. The Government met with a defeat in Dublin. It also met with a defeat in Limerick. Other Parties were defeated elsewhere. That is democracy. The people will have an opportunity shortly in Wicklow and East Cork. They will record on their ballot papers whether or not they approve of this year's Budget and last year's Budget.

One thing the inter-Party Government did was to bring peace to the country. We released the prisoners and we took the gun out of politics.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That scarcely arises on the Financial Motion before the House.

Comment on this

That is something Fianna Fáil cannot boast about. With regard to Coalitions or inter-Party Governments, representing the plain people as I do, living amongst them, mixing with them day in and day out and knowing their position, irrespective of what Government is in power I will be with them if they do the right thing for the people and, if they do not, I will be against them.

Comment on this

We are now entering the third week of the debate on this Budget and many of us who have listened to the last speaker and enjoyed his little bits of talent are not surprised that he is somewhat mixed and muddled remembering the position of the leaders of the Opposition, and when I say Opposition I can only refer to Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Because they are the people who hold the whip and they are the people who have dragged Deputy O'Leary and all the rest of them alongthe road they are travelling and led them off the straight path. When the Minister introduced his Budget the ex-Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan, came in here with a large brief. I am sure most of us expected to hear a speech lasting for some hours. Judging by all the speeches that have been made on the Opposition Benches most of the Opposition Deputies were apparently led away by the pronouncements made in the Irish Independentand theSunday Independentforecasting what would have to be done by the Minister when he introduced his Budget. Week in and week out, day in and day out we were told about the huge increases—the burdens as they were called—that would be placed on the shoulders of the people as a result of the Budget. Deputy McGilligan brings in a bundle of papers and puts them on the bench in front of him. When the Minister had finished his speech, Deputy McGilligan was so shocked because the bottom had fallen out of the case he intended to make, because the prophecies had not been fulfilled and because the speeches that had been made throughout the country failed in an attempt to incite the people into a state of rebellion over the huge increases that were foreshadowed, Deputy McGilligan spoke for about ten minutes.

Comment on this

That is all that is allowed.

Comment on this

He will speak again. That was a brief comment. Perhaps the Deputy does not understand the procedure.

Comment on this

I understand it pretty well. He had nothing to tell us.

Comment on this

He will later in this debate.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

We waited, believing there was something up the Fine Gael sleeve. We waited for Deputy J.A. Costello. Deputy Costello spoke for about two and a quarter hours. He quoted piles and piles of figures. He made an effort to criticise the Budget, but never in my life didI hear a more ineffective speech or one showing less evidence of an attempt to make a genuine case. We might have forgiven him that, but he made a second effort. We heard him over the radio and over the radio he merely repeated word for word what he had said here. I compared his speech last year with the speech he made this year and if he had made a record of his speech last year, brought in a gramophone and put it on the bench in front of him he could have played off the record because the two speeches were identical.

Comment on this

It was the same Budget, if not something worse.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello said the Minister had budgeted for a surplus. He made the greatest lawyer's quibble of a speech that I have ever heard. We waited then to hear the wise-cracker of the Fine Gael Party and in due time Deputy Dillon got up. He tried to make a case; I do not know if anybody here understood exactly what he was talking about. He talked about everything in the world except this Budget or what this Budget contained. He found himself so badly stuck for something to say that he had to make a statement that I certainly resent, that every Deputy on this side of the House resents and that the people of this country as a whole resent—and if there is anybody with guts left in the Labour Party, the Clann na Talmhan Party or the Fine Gael Party they, too, will resent it—that the Fianna Fáil Party had called upon a certain Deputy from South Galway to resign from the Dáil.

Comment on this

It was published.

Comment on this

That statement was published by a political correspondent; the wife of the person referred to took the precaution of contradicting it, and Deputy Dillon knows it just as well as I do. If Opposition Deputies are reduced to this kind of tactics and if they are prepared to sit down and listen to Deputy Dillon indulging in that kind of tripe they have much less guts than I ever thought they had. The man he referred to has given service to this country for many, many years.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has a bit of vengeance against him, and against Eamon de Valera, because they are the people who took up the fight in 1916 and threw a certain Party out of politics in this country. He is trying to avenge that to-day and he will keep trying to avenge it until the day he dies. The one man he tries to smash altogether is Eamon de Valera, the man who put that Party out of politics in this country because they proved themselves to be anti-national at the time.

Comment on this

The Molly Maguires.

Comment on this