Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 3—General (Resumed).
Contributions 193–399 of 399. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I listened to Deputy Giles the other night. Poor Deputy Giles tried to copy the speeches made by the different Deputies but they all made such contradictory speeches that poor Deputy Giles contradicted himself in every second sentence of his speech. Anybody who reads it will discover that. Deputy Giles told us that because of the Fianna Fáil policy the farmers in Meath had now to turn to tillage, that they had given the road to the bullock. I sincerely hope it is true but I am afraid it is not. We listened to-night to Deputy O'Leary who, I am sorry to say, has left the House. Deputy O'Leary told us how this country progressed under the Coalition Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon. I do not think he ever bothered looking up the figures or he would not have made such a statement. Statistics prove that between 1950 and 1951 cattle under one year declined by 3,700; milch cows were down by 20,000; heifers and calves went down by 33,000; and pigs declined by 87,000. That was in 1950-51, the year when you would expect that the Coalition Minister would have put the live-stock industry of this country on its feet if there was any sincerity in his efforts and having regard to all the money he had been spending or had squandered, money obtained by borrowing and taken out of Marshall Aid funds.
Comment on this
He will be speaking after me and let him examine the figures for agriculture and say then whether these figures are not correct.
Comment on this
I would also like to tell him that during the Coalition term of office 50,000 people left this country. They did that in spite of the fact that from the years 1948-51 £46,000,000 was available to Ireland under the Marshall Aid Plan. They must admit now if they are any way honest at all that that money was mishandled and misappropriated. During that period of office we sent them on a few good sprees. We sent Deputy Dillon to America, for what purpose I do not know.
Comment on this
Why were you sent to Strasbourg? However, you were a better representative than Deputy Cowan.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan and Deputy Killilea have a national record and the Deputy on the Front Bench and the other Deputy who spoke have not a trace of one.
Comment on this
It is not very easy to keep to your speech when you have interruptions from the type of individuals who intervened a moment ago.
Comment on this
On a point of order. May a Deputy refer to a person in the House as "a type of individual"?
Comment on this
That is the difficulty for the Chair, to decide what he means. The Chair cannot decide on that matter.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy cannot resent my saying that there are different types of individuals here.
Comment on this
I was about to say that we sent Deputy Dillon to America. I think there was a question asked to which the answer was given that it cost about £2,000 for his voyage; then, of course, he asked for a little cash to entertain his friends out there, and he was given something like £250. There was no resentment by any of the people in the Opposition Benches supporting the Coalition Government at this sort of squandermania. They can examine the accounts of the present Government to see if there have been any such "skites" as that. They did not resent Deputy Dillon going out on sprees of that kind. I wonder who authorised him and whether there was any Government decision about it when they let him off on a "skite" to lash out £5,000,000 in one afternoon. "The trouble was," he said, "that we could not spend it quickly enough." The idea was to lash it out while it was there because it would help to blind the people of this country so that they would push the Coalition back into office.
For some time past a few Deputies in this House have been blackguarded day and night. Every time there was an opportunity they were blackguarded and attacked because they believed that the squandermania policy should be halted, and they told the Government that. I think it is quite clear in everybody's mind that when that Government were put out of office, or at least when they went out of office —they were not put out; they were afraid to remain any longer——
Comment on this
Those Deputies madetheir position quite clear, because after their election, when they were returned to this House again, they did not adopt the attitude that Fine Gael think every Independent Deputy must support Fine Gael. They never can see that an Independent Deputy should be anything but a Fine Gael Independent or should back any Government but a Fine Gael Government. When these Deputies came back here, having gone before the electorate and having told the electorate that they were dissatisfied with the Coalition Government—anybody who read their speeches at the time will realise that they told the people what they were going to do, that they were not going to support the Coalition Government any longer——
Comment on this
I heard his speech in this House and I heard him tell Deputy Everett that Deputy Everett was not a fit individual to be a Minister because he was mismanaging the affairs of the Post Office. How often did he tell us that?
Comment on this
I know it has not but if Deputy Everett wants to interrupt me I think I should be allowed to make it clear——
Comment on this
I know that Deputy Cogan was quite dissatisfied with the Coalition Government and he was one of the first members to say so in this House before the election.
Comment on this
Deputy Everett was so full of his own importance at the timeand had got such a swelled head about his position——
Comment on this
I am not personal, but Deputy Everett knows that Deputy Cogan made his position quite clear in regard to the Baltinglass affair.
Comment on this
That is not the point. I say he never made any such statement as that he was against the inter-Party Government in Wicklow before the election.
Comment on this
I never referred to what Deputy Cogan said in Wicklow. I have referred to the fact that certain Deputies rebelled against the Coalition Government as a result of the squandermania which that Government pursued, and I am entitled to refer to that. I am referring only to the speeches made in this House in my own presence and I know what they were. I even saw motions tabled about it.
We came in here after the election and we did not come in under any false pretences. We did not make any bargain with any of these Deputies. I do not believe they would make any bargain with us, as they got enough of the bargains they made before. What we did was to put forward a 17-point programme and we said to anybody who was prepared to stand behind us that we would pursue that policy. Those Deputies then saw that that was the only course to follow and they followed that course. Because they did that, an effort is made to-day to hound them out of political life.
Comment on this
We took up the responsibility of office after that election. Ithink the people of the country clearly realise now that we had a difficult task and that we had to face up to tremendous obligations, that burdens were left behind that would definitely mean an increase in taxation. The people who went out of office knew that and I think they were glad they went out of office because they had not made any effort to fulfil their promises. They knew they could not fulfil them, and that if they had to face another Budget there would be a stampede in this country and that they would be hounded out of political life, so they stepped out. We had to come in then and we had to undertake almost immediately the task of paying off some of the $128,000,000 to America. We had to start to see where the money was spent and whether it was spent wisely. We found that $77,000,000 was spent on wheat and corn which could have been grown here at home, if they had only continued the Fianna Fáil policy, a policy that was suitable to the Irish people.
Comment on this
Compulsory tillage has been strongly condemned for all time by the Opposition. I never found anything radically wrong with compulsory tillage and I am a farmer myself. The vast majority of the people I represent never found anything wrong with compulsory tillage. An enormous number of them agreed with it and an enormous number of them are crying out for compulsory tillage still.
Comment on this
I shall tell you why. It is as well that people like you should be educated about the conditions that exist in the country. We had in my part of the country farmers, each owning 300 or 400 acres of land, employing only a man and a dog to herd their herds. At the same time we had living in the bogs and in thewaste lands all over the county men with valuations ranging from £2 to £10 who, during the emergency, paid these large farmers £12 and £15 per acre for conacre to allow them to do the tillage these large farmers were supposed to carry out under the Compulsory Tillage Order. That is the reason the small farmers are still crying out for the compulsory tillage. They are prepared to do the tillage if they get the chance. They are prepared to till the land for these landowners and even to pay them well for the land they get to carry out tillage.
Comment on this
If you are as stpuid as all that, there is no use in my trying to educate you. That wheat could be grown in this country when we could have saved the $35,000,000 that was borrowed to spend on tobacco. We had started a policy of tobacco-growing in this country but there was no encouragement from Deputy Dillon at any time for that, any more than there was encouragement from him at any time he was dealing with national problems. We had $4,000,000 spent on motor vehicles and $5,000,000 on newsprint. I do not think any of these items could ever be regarded as capital development or that any of these items on which that money was spent could not be financed by moneys that could be procured here at home. Now, because we face up to these things, because we have once again come back to a programme under which we are trying to produce in this country an enormous amount of the commodities that the Coalition Government purchased for dollars, the people on the Opposition side cannot see why we should not travel along the road they travelled.
Deputy Colley, I think, pointed out the other night the havoc that was created in Dublin by the destructive policy of the Coalition Government, when, on the cancellation of the order for the Constellation aeroplanes, 600 skilled men were put out of employment. There was nothing for them to do but take the high road. We did not hear any protest from the Labour Party at that time. We didnot hear any protest from Labour when the peat schemes all over this country were closed down overnight and when Labour and other Parties in this House knew that the closing down of these schemes overnight without the provision of alternative employment, meant that workers had no alternative but to take the high road. The Government in office had not made provision for those people and if they had to go on the dole the amount of money they would have got would not keep them alive. Deputy O'Leary did not protest and did not ask what arrangements had been made to give those people employment. The chassis factory started at the Broadstone was closed down overnight and machinery parts were sold without being taken out of their boxes. That factory was one of the most important industries so far as this country was concerned. It is an industry which would be very essential to us now more than ever having regard to the amount of mechanisation we have in relation to agriculture. Day by day parts are required for tractors and machinery which the farmers use. I am sure that hundreds of Irishmen could be employed producing those parts at home instead of having to import them. There were no protests from all those people when all those things were being done but now we hear a terrible outcry.
In his speech Deputy O'Leary said they had increased the number of people employed by the county councils. If doing what the Coalition Government did, reducing the road grants to county councils by over £1,000,000, means giving extra employment I do not know what county councils will start doing now. Deputy O'Leary seems to have been purchased body and soul by the Fine Gael people and he sees nothing now except through Fine Gael glasses.
Comment on this
Is it in order to suggest that a Deputy has been bought by a Party? The Deputy himself objected a few minutes ago. Now he said that a Deputy has been bought, has been purchased.
Comment on this
The Deputy who is now asking that question made a suggestion that a number of Deputies were well paid for voting for the present Government.
Comment on this
When we took over from those people we had to face up to a big and difficult task. We had to make provision for further social services. I do not think anybody in this House can say we delayed long in doing that work. It was done almost immediately. We were not long in office and no election was pending at the time and no one can say that the almost immediate increase we gave in old age pensions was a sort of election bluff.
Comment on this
Will any Deputy on the Opposition show us any figure in any of the Estimates then prepared for the provision of increased social services by way of old age pensions, widows' pensions and any of the other social services that Fianna Fáil introduced and which are in operation at the moment? Not one halfpenny was made available. Deputy McGilligan is one man who had no intention of making it available. Most of us have listened to those people for a long time and our memories can go back to the 30th October, 1924, when we heard the famous statement that it was not the function of the Dáil to provide work and the sooner that was realised the better. That was a statement made by Deputy McGilligan then.
Comment on this
The Deputy will find it at column 562, Volume 9, of the Official Dáil Debates. I will give the Deputy the date. It is the 30th October, 1924.
Comment on this
I will read it if it willdo you any good, but I do not think it will. He stated:—
"There are certain limited funds at our disposal. People may have to die in this country and may have to die through starvation."
That is the man the Labour Party backed up—the individual the people who misrepresented themselves as being Republicans, put in as Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Their policy has never changed. That is one thing we must admire about Fine Gael. They changed the name of their Party several times but they never changed their tactics or their policy. They never for one moment became aware of the fact that there are poor people in this country who should be looked after. It was only when we took over that the question of children's allowances and widows' and orphans' pensions became effective; then they realised for the first time that there were poor people in this country who deserved some assistance.
All we hear now in every speech delivered by the Opposition is the price of the pint. I was amazed at Deputy Dillon when he referred to the price of the pint. I understand that the price of the pint is 1/2. I understand also that in certain publican's bars Deputies on the opposite side of the House know where the pint is 1/3. We never hear about that penny being reduced or taken off at all. We did not hear Deputy Dillon tell us whether he was prepared to take it off or not.
Comment on this
You took it off before and what did you do? You gave white flour to the wealthier sections of the community. You gave them plenty of tea at 6/- per lb. You put plenty of sugar on the table at 10d. per lb. You did all those things and you kept the poorer sections living on rationed food all that time.
Comment on this
It was much more than that. You kept them living on a half pound of butter per week. That is what Deputy O'Leary was crying about. No wonder the condition was falling on them when the Coalition went out of office. The people were all happy and living on the luxury of half a pound of butter per week, two ounces of tea and a half pound of sugar. Why should the people have lamented the passing of that Government?
Comment on this
It is impossible to hear what Deputy Killilea is saying on account of this barrage of ignorant interruptions.
Comment on this
You would not be sent to Strasbourg. They would try and get some more intelligent person. I was present in the House the other night at the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs and saw the Labour people here standing over the policy of putting the increases in the case of postage stamps and telephone charges on the community in general instead of on the users of the telephones and those who have to stamp letters for business —they were anxious to put this on the poor individuals about whom Deputy O'Leary was crying five minutes ago. His policy was that the increases should fall on those who, as he said himself, are living on fresh air rather than on business people who use the telephone or on people like myself and others who have to buy a good many postage stamps. If that is Labour policy, then God help us. We are anxious to know where they stand in connection with it.
To show how little Fine Gael know about the conditions under which small farmers live, we had Deputy J. A. Costello telling us here a fortnight agothat Fianna Fáil were now making provision for the farmer with a £50 valuation, even though he was able to drive around in his Chrysler car. Of course, they have been denying that Deputy Costello said that.
Comment on this
I have here what was said. If the Deputy will take the trouble he can go to the Library and get a copy of the Dáil Debates for the 15th April last, and at column 58 he will find the words which were uttered by Deputy Costello.
Comment on this
I will hand the Deputy the volume when I am finished since he does not seem able to follow what I am saying. Here is what the exTaoiseach said:—
"The farmer with a valuation of £50 and a deposit receipt in the bank—"
I forgot to mention about the deposit receipt when I referred to this a minute ago.
—will be inside the provisions of the Bill, but the wage earner with over £600 a year, and that £600 is computed out of his own earnings and those of his sons and daughters, will be outside the provisions of the Bill. The farmer with a valuation of £50 can go in his Chrysler car to avail himself of the provisions of this Bill . . ."
Comment on this
"The farmer with a valuation of £50 can go in his Chrysler car to avail himself of the provisions of this Bill".
Comment on this
When one reads a statement like that, one has to ask oneself how the poor Labour Party came to be gulled into the belief that Fine Gael had ever stood for a policy of social welfare. If we were to go back over the records, those dating back to the 1920's and 1930 period, we would find plenty to read in them as regards whatDeputy Norton and other leaders of the Labour Party thought of the Fine Gael Party. In view of what they said then, one would imagine that they would be ashamed to join up with Fine Gael or to have ever been associated with them.
Comment on this
We have had to face up to a lot of things, and what has annoyed the Opposition is the fact that at the moment we have brought about a position of stability. That is what is killing them, and that is why all the wild speeches are being made. They are annoyed that Fianna Fáil has brought about a position of stability, and they are making every effort to stampede the people of this country, but the people of this country are wise. It is rather funny, but it is true, that I have heard more talk about a by-election in Wicklow and about elections in general in this debate on the Budget than I have heard on the Budget itself. Most of those speeches have come from members of the Labour Party. If there was an election, whatever chance any of the Parties in this House would have of being on the winning side, one can say that the Labour Party would not have a hope in hell.
Comment on this
I think I could guarantee that whatever I offered I would not be asked to pay on your Party winning.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance last year faced up to the position that was there and brought in what was termed a most unpopular Budget.
Comment on this
That Budget was brought in by members of a Government who had their minds made up that they were going to face up to their responsibilities and take their stand on them. They faced up to the position with courage and determination in the same way as they did in 1932 when we took over the Government from the Fine Gael Party. We then started to build decent foundations for this State. The country was thus enabled to begin its onward march for the first time since we got what was termed our liberty here.
Comment on this
That was the time when the patriots of to-day were objecting to the removal of the Oath.
Comment on this
We carried the fight on all through the years since first we started in 1916. That has been our policy down to the present day. Our success in that fight has left Deputy Rooney in the position that he is able to take his seat in this House to-day.
Comment on this
If Deputy Rooney is trying to cast any reflection on any of the things that we did to bring about the freedom we enjoy to-day, I just want to say to him that we take pride in the fight and in the stand that we took all down through the years. I believe that the people of future generations will recognise that. They will recognise that we were responsible for the onward march that has been made in building up the country and in leaving it in the happy position in which we find ourselves to-day.
In conclusion, I want to say that I do not think there is any hope of a general election. It can only come about by the defeat of the Government, and that is a question that can only be decided by the members of this House. The Opposition are not anxious for it because they are not prepared, and would not be able to undertake the responsibility of a Government if confronted with that responsibility in the morning.
Comment on this
We have undertaken the responsibility of a Government and have carried on the work. We have, as I have said, brought about stability in the country. We have brought about what we hope is a standstill to a further increase in prices. We have brought about confidence and stability in Irish industry once again. Having made those things clear to the people, we can, with confidence, face them at any time we like. This challenge of an election, I would remind Deputies, was made by the Opposition away back in the days of the economic war. We called a general election in the middle of the economic war at a time when the Opposition least expected it. What was the answer the Irish people gave us?
Comment on this
A few moments ago the Deputy deprecated talking about elections. I suggest he should relate his remarks to the Financial Motion.
Comment on this
I am satisfied that the Irish people realise that Fianna Fáil brought about a position whereby they have stability and confidence in themselves so that they go about their day's work in their own way in the knowledge that they will get every encouragement, help and assistance from this Government. Let us hope that we will get a return for all the work we have been trying to do for them.
Comment on this
There are two corrections which I should like to make in relation to Deputy Killilea's speech. In the first place, he criticised Deputy McGilligan, who spoke immediately after the Minister for Finance introduced his Budget, because his speech was not as long as he expected it would be. Deputy Killilea must realise that Deputy McGilligan made that speech the moment the Minister sat down and it was just a résuméof the Minister's statement.
Comment on this
My second correction is that in the name of this Party, theFine Gael Party, the word "Fine" has two syllables. Deputy Killilea said that last year's Budget was the most unpopular Budget ever introduced by an Irish Government. I agree with the Deputy there. We are told by the Government Deputies that this year's Budget is a "standstill Budget". I suggest that it is the second instalment of the serial story which began last year when the Minister introduced his penal taxes on the people of this country. The Budget this year is no less unpopular than that of last year.
Two years ago, when the Deputies opposite faced the country at a general election, they criticised the inter-Party Government for, they alleged, the high cost of living during their period of office. The Fianna Fáil Party asked for a chance to come back into power to set that position right. With the aid of a group of Independent Deputies, they got the opportunity for which they asked. What have they done since they achieved office? The cost of living has increased week by week and month by month until, a very short while ago, the Taoiseach admitted that we have reached our taxable limit. I agree that we have reached that stage if we have not long passed it.
Since the Budget was introduced 12 months ago, with all its penal taxes, various other forms of taxation were employed to draw money from the community at large. Apart from the removal of subsidies last July, increased motor taxation was imposed as from 1st January. I believe that that increased motor taxation drew something in the neighbourhood of £800,000 from the pockets of the people of this country. If that is not taxation, it is difficult to understand the policy of the Minister. Although motor taxation drew something in the neighbourhood of £800,000 from the pockets of the people of this country, it did not appear in last year's Budget, but I must admit that when the Minister was introducing his Budget last year he warned the people that they would have to bear it.
Despite the Taoiseach's statement that he believes that the people of thiscountry have reached their taxable limit, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs introduced proposals a few weeks ago to draw another £750,000 from the pockets of the people. I do not know what the Health Bill will cost—I do not think the Minister himself can put a figure on it—but it will be a large sum of money.
Comment on this
Whatever it will cost, it will cost the ratepayers just as much. The rates of all the local authorities will have to be increased so as to provide an amount equivalent to that which is provided under the Health Bill. This year, the ratepayers of this country have had to meet drastic increases, and this further increase which will be imposed upon them can be described as another form of taxation. The same people will have to pay it. It may be placed under a different heading, but they will have to find the money in the end.
Another form of taxation introduced within the past 12 months is the high rate of interest offered to subscribers under the National Loan which the Minister floated. The Minister throws bouquets at himself and his Department because the loan was oversubscribed in a remarkably short space of time. If the Minister intends to float another loan and wants to beat his previous record then all he has to do is to offer, say, 6 per cent.——
Comment on this
It was not necessary to offer 5 per cent. for the loan last year. The urban district councils across the water can borrow money at a lower rate of interest than that. Three weeks after the last loan was floated by the Minister, Birmingham Corporation floated a loan at 4¼ per cent. and it was over-subscribed. The result of the high rate of interest which is repayable on our National Loan will be that our local authorities who have to borrow money from the Government for housing purposes will have to pay a greater rate of interest.
The local authorities are using thatborrowed money to build council houses. The taxpayers have to find a greater subsidy because the money borrowed to build the houses costs more. If the ratepayers do not meet that extra rate of interest, the rents of all labourers' cottages and council houses throughout the country must be increased.
Comment on this
The Deputy is overlooking the fact that the subsidisable limit has been considerably increased and that the net effect is that there will be no increase in the housing charges.
Comment on this
It is a change anyhow, and, so far as Dublin Corporation is concerned, it will be better off than it ever was.
Comment on this
I am speaking of local authorities throughout the country. Dublin Corporation borrow their own money.
Comment on this
The Minister stated in his Budget statement, in defence of his own National Loan, when he offered 5 per cent., that the Dublin Corporation floated a loan at 5 per cent. They did. They had no alternative. What chance have they of having a loan subscribed at a lower rate of interest than 5 per cent., a few months after the Minister offered 5 per cent.? They had no alternative but to offer the same rate of interest.
The Government's financial policy has damaged industry and agriculture. The building trade in Dublin City, which is the only area for which I am qualified to speak, is practically at a standstill. The purchasers who require money to buy their houses are unable to pay the increased rate of interest for loans.
Comment on this
The profits on building have never been too great. It is necessary for the Minister to help local authorities by providing money at alower rate of interest than is being granted under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts at the moment.
I suggest that the unemployment figures, which have increased greatly in the last two years and rapidly over the last 12 months, are attributable, in the main, to the building trade. Deputy Lynch. the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, said in his last statement here that there were more houses built during the last 12 months than ever before. I suggest that the Minister or some officer of his Department make inquiries from the building trade unions throughout the country. There were never more bricklayers, carpenters or plasterers idle than there are at the moment. Every Deputy has had representations made to him at various times to get employment in the building trade for some acquaintances or some friends of theirs and they are receiving the same answer all the time, that there is no work in the building trade in Dublin and district at present. It is at the lowest level that it ever reached. Deputy Lynch also stated in his speech that since Fianna Fáil took over office the second time 140 new industries have been started. I am not being critical when I ask him this question—where are they?
The Minister also said in his statement that he was going to implement the provisions of the Civil Service arbitration award. I think the Government should act like every other employer and that that award should be granted back to the time when negotiations started. It should be paid, not from the 1st April, but should go back to the time when negotiations started. The granting of this award will, I am sure, please civil servants in general, but there is a little drop of castor oil which they must swallow. There is that £3,500,000 to be saved on public administration—how is that going to be saved? Is it true that the various Departments of the Civil Service have already started to bring down the axe. Are minor civil servants quaking in their jobs, wondering when the axe is going to drop on them? I believe that is the position and there are very grave and serious whisperingsthroughout the city at the moment as to the position in that respect.
Unemployment figures have jumped within the last couple of years to the extent of over 20,000. Deputy Davern stated that there were three people coming back into this country for each one going out of it. He knows and everyone else knows that that is not true. Emigration is rising because unemployment is growing, because employment is dropping. It is very difficult for any man to get work of any description in the City of Dublin at present—or in the rest of the country, for that matter.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Minister that he take some sort of gallup poll to find out. If he went on a "pub crawl" through the city he would find out how business is doing in the city and he would see how the licensed trade is doing.
Comment on this
I have seen the light— but that brings me to the tax on spirits. It was generally expected that the Minister would see his way to remove some of the tax which he imposed on spirits and alcohol last year. A year ago, he and his Department expected to get £1,020,000 extra in revenue from the tax on spirits. In actual fact, he received £500,000 less than was received a year before this tax was imposed. In other words, he received approximately £1,500,000 less than he expected to get—because there was a drop of 20 to 25 per cent. in the consumption of liquor. The Minister stated that a possible reason for that was that, in anticipation of the Budget 12 months ago, people in the licensed trade withdrew spirits from bond to forestall any increases that might occur. The Minister might look up the list of withdrawals from bond for the last three years and he will see that in any of those months there was no appreciable difference.
It is a fact that a major brewery in Dublin, because of the reduction in business in the licensed trade, hassufficient malting barley now for the next two years. How is that going to affect other people in the country— C.I.E. and other transport concerns, distributing people and the farmers? That is only one brewery. There is a certain gentleman I know, who, for 30 years, was in business as an agent, buying barley on commission. That commission has now been taken from him for the first time in 30 years. His services are no longer required. That may not, at first glance, look very serious, but let us look at the position of the licensed trade at the moment. A man needs to be ten years in employment in Jameson's Distillery in this city to be secure in his job. A number of their employees have got notice. A number have been let go already, but still others have now got notice. I suggest that the Minister contact the Commercial Travellers' Association from which he will get some true idea as to how business is in the country. A friend of mine went down to County Kerry to collect £400 which was due by several traders in that county. His expenses for the week—hotel expenses, car expenses and everything else—were in the neighbourhood of £30 and he collected a cheque for £25. That indicates the position in which business is at the moment.
Comment on this
I do not think Deputy Palmer knows the commercial traveller. Deputy Killilea criticised individual Deputies' speeches but he failed to tell us why he supports all the increases in the cost of living. He said that 600 men lost employment through the sale of the Constellations. I made a rough calculation here and I find that, at £5 a week, it would mean £150,000 a year. I do not think the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when he contemplated the Constellations project, visualised that he would ever have 600 men employed on the Constellations end of our air services.
Apart from all the taxation we have had over the past 12 months which was not visible in the last Budget, otherexpenses have been put on the backs of the people—expenses in relation to air services, expenses in connection with the Health Bill and an increase in the price of sugar, which broke suddenly over the people of this city during the past few days. The only thing I can say is that the Minister, in relation to last year's Budget, appears to me to be like the person who tries to hit the jack-pot and, having failed, blames the machine.
Comment on this
This Budget must be regarded as a more severe blow to the community than the Budget last year, because last year there was not the degree of poverty which exists now, and at that time the people had not lost the good standard of living and the good conditions which had been brought to them by the inter-Party Government during their three and a half years' administration. In order to impose that savage Budget last year, the Minister alleged that the inter-Party Government had carried out a spending spree and, in order to counteract that spending spree, he apparently has embarked on a taxation ramp. We have only to examine what has happened since the tragic Budget of 1952 was introduced. We find stability, but stability of the wrong kind. Stability is what Deputy Killilea said the policy of this Government had brought about, but the stability, in fact, is stagnation, apart from the fact that it has caused a good deal of difficulty amongst different sections of the community.
The people were dazed by last year's Budget, and in this Budget they are again asked to shoulder these burdens. Last year, there was a considerable degree of opposition to it, because it was a fresh blow. The blow amounted to £19,000,000 last year—the amount of the extra burden the people were required to shoulder—but this year, in addition to the burden of £19,000,000 imposed last year, there are extra taxes in the form of increased motor taxation rates, extra charges for stamps and telephones, as well as increased charges for various commodities. When the Minister was framing this Budget, apparently hedid not take into consideration the notice to quit which the Fianna Fáil Government got from the Cabra area of North-West Dublin last November, in the by-election in which the Fianna Fáil policy was on test for the first time since these extra charges were imposed in the 1952 Budget.
The argument offered by Fianna Fáil in the months preceding November was that, in the by-elections of June, 1952, they did not get a severe reverse, but in fact the impact of the Budget had not become known until these increases became operative on 2nd July, 1952. In other words, the people were not given a proper opportunity of seeing exactly what the policy of the Government was going to impose upon them in the form of burdens. Reliefs were expected this year. The huge burden which the people were expected to carry last year seemed to be one which they would not be asked to carry again, and they expected reliefs, particularly in relation to the cost of living, but, instead of reliefs, they got a Budget which was described as the "same again," but which in fact is worse than last year's Budget for two reasons.
It is worse because the people now are less able to bear it and because they are not now in the good condition in which the inter-Party Government left them in 1951. It is obvious that the Minister's diagnosis of our economic needs is wrong, and he appears to be trying to apply the wrong cure, because we can see what the results of the past year were. We can see that 20,000 people lost their jobs since the Budget of 1952, and, although the Minister in his very fine oratory this year tried to console the minds of worried people, the fact is that this year he is imposing a greater burden upon them.
This is obviously a Butler Budget. It is the Budget which was introduced here last year when the Minister and the Minister for Industry and Commerce had returned from their visit to the British Chancellor of the Exchequer, and it is obvious that he has imposed this Budget, believing that he will keep in line in relation to sterling with Britain, but we find that it wentin the wrong direction. We find that, in Britain, the Butler Budget had the effect of increasing the purchasing power of the £ and that, since the Budget was introduced here, a Budget which was supposed to be in line with the Butler Budget, the purchasing power of the £ has fallen by nearly 2/-. The cost of living has gone up by about 20 per cent. since the change of Government took place. Let us remember that the cost of living was the principal issue in the general election campaign of 1951, that is when the Fianna Fáil Party were sympathising with the housewives and complaining that the cost of living had gone up by 3 per cent. They made sure not to tell the people that the inter-Party Government had increased the earnings of our people by nearly 20 per cent. The incomes of all classes of people, workers, farmers, traders and every other class, had gone up by practically 20 per cent., and against that the cost of living had gone up by something like 3 per cent.
When the change of Government took place there was a complete departure on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party from the 17-point programme they had put before the people at that time. It was the ten-point programme of the inter-Party Government split into 17 parts which they put before the people as being the policy they would follow. There was an item, No. 15, in it which last year they decided to delete. That deletion increased the cost of living and increased the difficulties of our people. Point 15 was the one which said that they intended to maintain subsidies and control prices. They immediately removed price control in respect of many essential commodities. In 1951, shortly after the change of Government, many items of food were allowed to rise. In the 1952 Budget, subsidies in respect of bread, sugar, butter, tea and flour were slashed.
Last year's Budget increased the price of the loaf of bread by approximately 3d. This year's Budget proposes to maintain that increase of 3d. on the loaf. Butter was 2/10 per lb. when the inter-Party Government were leaving office. It was increased by last year'sBudget to 3/10. Now butter is selling at 4/2 a lb. That represents an increase of 4d. per lb. on butter as compared with last year's price and an increase of 1/4 per lb., as compared with the price when the inter-Party Government were in office.
Sugar is now up to 8/2 per stone. It was 5/4 per stone during the inter-Party régime. The price of tea is approximately 5/4 as compared with 2/8 during the inter-Party régime. The price of flour is up to 4/3 per stone, compared with 2/1 when the inter-Party Government were in office. The price of meat on the average has increased by over 9d. a lb., nearly 1/-. Cigarettes and tobacco were increased in price last year. The people are asked to continue to bear the increase then imposed upon them.
The taxes on beer and spirits were increased last year and this year the people are again asked to bear the increases on these commodities. Petrol users who had to carry an extra 4d. a gallon on petrol last year must continue to bear it this year. The price of stamps, which was increased towards the end of 1951 by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, Deputy Childers——
Comment on this
That is very unfair because Deputy McGilligan indicated that these changes would take place. Do not hit below the belt.
Comment on this
——that it would be necessary to increase the postal charges but he did not indicate what the extra charges might be. However, when the present Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, Deputy Childers, came into office, he increased the postage rate to 2½d. per letter and imposed other increases on parcels, newspapers and, of course, letters going to foreigncountries. There is a very steep increase now in respect of letters going outside this country besides the increase of ½d. per letter for letters addressed to places within the State.
That is a very heavy burden on the business community and it will have its effect. The increases will cause a reduction in employment in many business firms where there are heavy charges in respect of stamps and telephones. I heard of a colossal figure in respect of telephones and postage even in the Department of Social Welfare and there are also similar charges for other Departments. Telephone users had been asked to bear a very heavy increase and are threatened with a further increase in a couple of months. The extra charges have been indicated.
Coming to the bright side of the Budget we find that this Budget again relieves the ballroom proprietors of the duty to pay dance tax. Last year, dance tax which in the previous year amounted to £140,000 was remitted. That dance tax is remitted again this year. When the dance tax of £140,000 was remitted last year, a battle began between the dance bands and owners of ballrooms for the 20 per cent. relief represented thereby. The benefit did not go to the patrons of the dances. If they had been paying 5/- for admission to dances, which meant 4/-admission and 1/- tax, they are still paying 5/- while the ballroom owners and dance bands are fighting for that 1/-. The patrons did not get the benefit of the remission.
Another bright spot in this Budget is the reduction in the cinema tax in respect of the lower priced seats. I expect that when that becomes effective a battle will begin between picture renters and cinema owners for the amount of the remission which should be made available to the patrons of the cinemas. That has happened in the case of the dance tax and I expect it will happen in this case also.
Last year's very severe Budget, which put these extra charges on bread, tea, butter and sugar, included a present of £1,000,000 for the tobacco manufacturers. It was almost £1,000,000 that the tobacco manufacturers were to get as a reward for the loss of business which they might suffer in consequenceof the extra tax being put on tobacco and cigarettes. No allowance was made this year for this £1,000,000 present that was made to them last year. There was no reference in this Budget as to whether a similar present will be made to them this year or not. We should be told whether the tobacco manufacturers will get £1,000,000 again this year, just as they got £1,000,000 last year at the expense of the working people, the consumers of bread, butter and sugar.
Income-tax was increased last year by 1/-. Some people say it is well for the person who pays income-tax. It is a surprising fact that a very great number of people are now paying income-tax because the income level is so low in relation to the purchasing power of money. When the income-tax code was introduced nearly a century ago, it was introduced for quite a different purpose. It was never intended that income-tax should apply to people who depend from one week to another on a bare income. We find now, however, that many people are paying income-tax for which that code was never designed. We also find that the extra 1/- put on these people last year is to be carried again by them this year.
When Deputy McGilligan became Minister for Finance he reduced the rate of income-tax. Strangely enough, when he did reduce the rate of income-tax to be paid by the various classes of people who would be liable, the revenue from that tax increased by 50 per cent. That was evidence of the great prosperity which was brought to our people during the inter-Party régime. In consequence of the increased incomes, which I mentioned earlier amounted to 20 per cent., the amount paid in the form of income-tax rose by 50 per cent. although the rate of income-tax to be paid by the individual was reduced.
One outstanding statement made by the Minister for Finance in his Budget speech last year was that he proposed to restore order in the public finances. For many a day to come that phrase will be laughed at when we see what his last Budget did. First of all, in his effort to restore order in the publicfinances, 20,000 people lost their jobs. We find that credit restriction set in to such an extent that activity in business fell and that employment was reduced in consequence. We find that there was a trade recession. We find that all classes of business were affected in consequence of the burdens which the people were required to shoulder. We find that industrial production fell by 12½ per cent. All this was the consequence of "restoring order in the public finances". We find that 10,000 people who had been working in factories lost their jobs during that year. We find that all kinds of private building came to a standstill and that the only building carried on was the local authority building, which was well under way and had been planned by the inter-Party Government before the present Government took office, and which was being completed in the ordinary way. We find in the Minister's Budget statement that local authority building is nearing completion. That is the building which was planned and implemented by the inter-Party programme. We find, however, that there are approximately 40,000 houses still needed in the country and yet we have the Minister making the statement that the building of houses is nearing completion. We find that this effort to restore order in the public finances reduced the purchasing value of the £ by nearly 2/- or 10 per cent. We find that public houses are almost like morgues. We find the boss behind the counter instead of an assistant. We find that the people have switched from butter to margarine and that the production of Irish butter is falling. There we have the result of the restoration of order in public finances. We see the consequences of that Budget in those facts which cannot be contradicted.
That Budget also had the effect of reducing the standard of living, which was a natural consequence. People have been forced to switch over from creamery butter to margarine. Business is very slack in the drapery trade and there has been a fall in the number employed. Working-class people, in order to make ends meet, cannot afford to purchase articles asfrequently as they did in the past. That is one of the reasons why business in the drapery trade is so slack. Children's footwear has become very expensive, and many mothers are complaining that the expense of keeping footwear on their children has become almost impossible to bear.
Many working-class families in County Dublin who were put into new cottages during the inter-Party régime are now unable to pay the rents of these cottages; in other words, they are unable to make ends meet. These difficulties arose owing to the cost of essential foodstuffs. People had to buy food with the money rather than to save it up and pay the rent. When the arrears amounted to a high figure it was necessary for the local authority to take action, and these people now find themselves out on the road owing to the difficulties imposed upon them by the 1952 Budget which was heralded in the Irish Pressand by the Fianna Fáil supporters as a great achievement.
All over the country ratepayers have been forced to carry a greater burden in the form of rates. This burden has been imposed upon them because the liabilities of the hospitals had increased. The cost of foodstuffs for the hospitals has increased considerably, and the hospital bills are staggering at the moment. Anybody who is on a hospital board can see the remarkable effect which that Budget had in relation to the cost of food for the patients. In consequence of that, the rates had to be increased. Similarly, that Budget caused the wages of various classes of local authority employees to be increased in order to meet the increased cost of living and, in turn, the ratepayers have been asked to shoulder an extra burden. Children with healthy appetites demand a lot from their parents in order to keep them well fed. If the cost of school meals is not met by the children going to the schools, it has to be met by the ratepayers.
No matter who does, someone will have to pay for this Budget and the ratepayers are only one of the manysections which have been hit very hard. We are now feeling the pinch as a result of the burdens imposed upon this country by the scare speeches of midsummer, 1951. Those were the speeches which launched this unfortunate policy upon the nation. Those were the speeches which caused the recession in trade and the increase in the number of unemployed persons by approximately 46,000 as compared with 1951.
The Fianna Fáil Party tries to make the people believe that if an inter-Party Government or a Fine Gael Government was in office at the moment the position would be the same as it is now. I ask the people who advance that argument to read the figures of unemployment for the first five months of 1951. I would ask them to take each month then in the year 1950 and they will find that there were less people unemployed in each of the first five months in 1951 than there were in 1950. These figures show the general trend and the direction in which the inter-Party Government were then moving; it was moving towards the position in which we would be able to say that no able-bodied man was deprived of the right of earning his living in his own way. We succeeded in reducing the figures for unemployment to the lowest figure ever recorded in this country. In June, 1951, we had brought the figure down to 38,000 persons. At the moment, there are approximately 84,000 people unemployed and we are not too far from June. On the 13th of next month, we can see the number of persons unemployed on that date and compare that figure with the number of persons who were registered as unemployed in 1951.
Let me examine now the adverse trade balance. That is one of the many items upon which the Minister tried to confuse the public mind. By using the figures procurable in relation to the adverse trade balance he endeavoured to make people believe that the policy operated by Fianna Fáil at the moment is the right policy and the only policy that could have been implemented. We had the Taoiseach himself stating that the policy presently pursued by Fianna Fáil is theonly one for this country. Are we in a position to judge whether he is right or whether he is wrong? Could it be possible that he is making a mistake? We believe we could prove him wrong to-morrow were we given the opportunity. We proved him wrong in the Limerick by-election and in that election the Taoiseach in his convention speech said that the fate of the nation was at stake and the people went out and gave the Fianna Fáil Party a fine whacking. That was a reverse for his statement in Limerick. His recent statement in relation to general policy can equally be contradicted so soon as the people are given an opportunity of doing so.
Let me quote now some figures in relation to the adverse trade balance. The figure in 1947 was £30,000,000 and to offset that adverse trade balance the total value of our exports amounted to £38,000,000. What were the constituents of that £30,000,000 adverse trade balance in 1947? Anybody who casts his memory back will remember the huge quantities of textiles that were imported in the summer of 1947. He will remember, too, that at least 1,000,000 pairs of boots and shoes were imported in that year; there were enough shoes and boots imported to last the people for years. Similarly, in 1947, vast quantities of Dutch chocolate were imported. These were some of the constituent items of that £30,000,000 adverse trade balance.
If I went into more detail I could probably show that other unnecessary items were imported at that time. Let me quote now what the Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan, said in May, 1948, when he stated that it was:—
"... impossible to view with equanimity a continued reduction in external assets on last year's scale."
That was the £30,000,000 adverse trade balance in 1947 related to the £38,000,000 exports.
"These assets can be consumed now only at the expense of a reduced standard of living for the future."
We set out to redress that position.We set out to reduce the adverse trade balance and increase the national income. We succeeded in doing both. In 1948 we reduced the adverse trade balance to £20,000,000. It was £30,000,000 in 1947. We increased exports in 1948 to over £40,000,000. In 1949 we reduced the adverse trade balance to £10,000,000 and in that year we increased the value of our exports to nearly £70,000,000. In 1950 we were going well until the Korean War broke out in July. All the prospects in 1950 were that our adverse trade balance would have been nil had circumstances remained the same. The Korean War broke out and Fianna Fáil did its part at that time in creating a scare, hoping to frighten some of the weaker-minded into believing that Fianna Fáil could put up an umbrella to prevent bombs falling on us here.
I have quoted those figures to prove that we were operating a policy which, while reducing the adverse trade balance, was increasing the value of our exports. That was the happy position in which we were and that is the reason why our people were at that time enjoying a greater measure of prosperity and a higher standard of living. In 1950, events were shaping towards a position in which we would be able to say that we had a plus instead of a minus in relation to our adverse trade balance. But the cold war began. The Korean War broke out. We had scaremongering on the part of Fianna Fáil, asking that the Army personnel be increased immediately, telling us to get ready to defend the country because there was going to be an invasion. From Korea, probably ! The minds of the people were geared into the position in which they believed war was going to come upon us. Very wise business people at the time said: "We are not going to leave ourselves in the position we were in in 1939 and 1940 when war came and our shelves were empty; we will buy, wherever we can, the various commodities normally required in a civilised community." It was those items which were purchased at that time by the traders, packed upon their shelves and in their stores in anticipation of a complete stoppage when the war aboutwhich Fianna Fáil were so vocal in 1950 came upon us.
Let me deal now with 1951. In 1951 the adverse trade balance amounted to approximately £61,000,000. Examining the position, we find that the Fianna Fáil Party was in office for more than six months of that year. The present Government came into office on the 13th June, 1951. We will give them the benefit of the fortnight in June; in the last six months of 1951 the adverse trade balance amounted to £49,000,000. If we subtract that from the total of £61,000,000 for that year the inter-Party Government can only be blamed for an adverse trade balance of £12,000,000 which bears some comparison with the figure of £10,000,000 in 1949. Fianna Fáil allowed the position to get out of control at that time and last year they came in here with a Budget inflicting a very heavy burden on the people, stating that burden was necessary by reason of the unwieldy adverse trade balance in 1951, during more than half of which they were in office.
We find some of the Fianna Fáil Deputies quoting Deputy Dillon when he said that our difficulty during the inter-Party term of office was to spend money that was made available through Marshall Aid. They tried to make out that the money, in fact, was spent and that we were on a spending spree. They criticised Deputy Dillon because he said that the inter-Party Government could not spend money quickly enough. Surely it was true that they could not spend money quickly enough when they left £24,000,000 on the table for Deputy MacEntee when he came in on the 13th June, 1951? There was £24,000,000 unspent. Deputy Dillon mentioned earlier that he did not get a chance of spending that money and he was criticised because he mentioned it. If anybody ever went on a spending spree it was the Fianna Fáil Party, because between the 13th June, 1951, and the end of January, 1952, approximately eight months, they had dissipated and spent that £24,000,000. At least they say they had; there is a suspicion that that money is not spent yet. However,they say it is spent and we will take their word for it at the present. They did not dispute the fact that £24,000,000 of American money was there on the table when they came into office.
Is this Budget going to improve trade? The Minister said it is and I would like to know from the Minister how he can come to that conclusion when he has seen the results of the policy which was operated by him during the last 12 months. I had a quotation from the Minister—I have not got it now—pointing out that in consequence of the policy being operated we are going to have economic recovery and industrial activity.
I do not think we will have either because the Budget of this year is more severe than last year's. The figures themselves can prove it. When we have gone through a year of credit restriction, a year of mounting unemployment, a year of the falling pound, a year of a perturbed banking system and all those things that go with it, I cannot see how we are going to have a recovery. It sounds very well and it is a great relief for the supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party to hear those encouraging words. However, it is not encouraging words people want at the moment; it is relief and it is a policy that will bring to them the good standard of living that they enjoyed during the inter-Party Government term of office; it is a policy which will bring to them a week's wages and a week's work.
Many people at the present time are complaining that the present allowances which they receive from the unemployment exchange—unemployment benefit, unemployment assistance, widows' pensions, old age pensions and all those other allowances—are not sufficient to meet present-day liabilities and present-day requirements. When the inter-Party Government were drafting the social legislation in relation to the unemployment benefit of 50/- per week and the other benefits, it was thought at the time that 50/- a week would make things easy for a man who might be unfortunate enough to lose his employment, not to have a week's wages and a week's work. Tha 50/- to-day is not the 50/-theinter-Party Government were thinking of early in 1951.
I am sorry that Deputy Killilea is not here now. I would like to remind him that he voted against an increase in the old age pension on 2nd March, 1951. The Social Welfare Bill was being put through the House at that time and it was carried by four votes, but one of the many people who voted against the Bill, which included an increase for the old age pensioner, was Deputy Killilea.
Comment on this
On a point of order. That statement is not correct. The Social Welfare Bill did not contain any provision for an increase in old age pensions.
Comment on this
I am glad that Deputy Cogan interrupted because I understand that he is another of the Deputies who voted against the increase in the old age pensions. If it was not in the Bill it was in the Vote; it was certainly introduced as a Supplementary Bill. The question of an increase in the old age pension was in that Vote. Deputy Cowan voted for it and so did Deputy Browne. Of course Deputy Cogan voted against the increase for old age pensioners and he will have to answer to them.
Comment on this
A few of us had to put a pistol to the head of the Government to get the promise of an increase in old age pensions.
Comment on this
It may be all right to make a statement like that but it would be very difficult to prove it.
Comment on this
Because the cost of living had increased by 3 per cent. and it was necessary for us to increase allowances for old age pensioners. It has gone up by 20 per cent. since. That is one time when Fianna Fáil voted against an increase for old age pensions. They do not have to go back so far to remember that in the autumn of 1947 a motion was tabled in this House by Deputy Costello and Deputy Dr. O'Higgins asking for relief in themeans test which would amount to an increase of 2/6 per week for the old age pensioner.
Comment on this
No, but I have read the records. The Minister for Social Welfare said that the country could not afford an extra 2/6 per week for the old age pensioners, and he was supported by the Fianna Fáil Party in opposing the motion for the increase of 2/6 a week in the old age pension.
Comment on this
Is that not what Deputy McGilligan said recently, that we are gone mad on the welfare State?
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil Party voted against an increase of 2/6 a week in the old age pension in the autumn of 1947. With the support of Deputy Cowan and others in 1948 we reversed that decision and we gave the old age pensioners an increase not of 2/6 a week but of 5/- a week. In addition to giving them that increase we reduced taxation by £6,000,000 by taking the penal taxes from beer, cigarettes and the other items on which taxes were imposed at that time. We left £6,000,000 back in the hands of our people to spend in their own way. Those people included 150,000 old age pensioners. We left the money with them so that they could spend it themselves in addition to the increase of 5/- a week which we gave them early in 1948.
This trade recession which has set in is artificial inasmuch as that it has been brought about by the Budget of 1952 which is being continued during the present year. We hear from commercial travellers, particularly, when business has dropped considerably. As I have said licensed premises are like morgues. While the Minister is going to keep the extra threepence on theloaf of bread and the extra 1/4 on the pound of butter, it might not be good politics for him to reduce the tax on spirits but it might be good economics. It might bring him more revenue than he got last year on spirits. The very heavy tax put on spirits last year caused a considerable fall in the revenue. Very probably if he took away the extra tax which was imposed on spirits, there would be an increase in the revenue. I think that economic rectitude, in which the Minister for Finance is so greatly interested, should compel him, in the interests of getting more revenue at a lower rate of tax, to take away the extra tax which he imposed on spirits last year.
The outlook for barley growers this year is very gloomy. We know that since the Fianna Fáil Party went back into office in 1951 they lost no opportunity in their efforts to reduce the price of barley. We found, when we took office in 1948, that the price of barley was controlled at 35/- per barrel while maltsters were importing barley at 85/- per barrel from the four corners of the earth. Deputy Dillon decided immediately to allow the barley growers to get the best price they could and to make the best bargain possible with the maltsters of this country, for all the malting barley they could grow. We had reached the stage when the maltsters were paying £4 4s. for barley to growers for suitable malting barley. We now find the position where these maltsters are not going to buy malting barley this year, because the barley which they bought last year has not been fully used in consequence of the very considerable drop in the consumption of spirits.
Along with their own Party, it has been obvious that Fianna Fáil has an organisation known as the Beet Growers' Association operating side by side with them. In fact, it was the Beet Growers' Association that negotiated the reduction in the price of barley with Messrs. Guinness early in 1952, in order to force farmers to grow wheat instead of barley. I am sure that other methods could have been utilised to encourage the growingof wheat other than the conspiracy which was entered into by the beet growers to bring about a reduction in the price of barley. We find a position now where the farmers this year will be lucky to get anything like £2 10s. or £3 per barrel for barley, compared with the price of £4 4s. when Deputy Dillon was in office. The agricultural conference, of course, was in progress in the Gresham Hotel with the Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture——
Comment on this
The Deputy is now going into points that might more suitably be raised on the Estimate for Agriculture.
Comment on this
Very well. I shall not raise them beyond mentioning that it was at the time that that conference was held that a reduction in the price of barley was being negotiated elsewhere. News is leaking out from Fianna Fáil Cumainn that the guaranteed price for wheat will be discarded next year. We should like to know from the Minister whether that is true. It is coming out from branch meetings and it is a matter in which the farmers are very interested.
Comment on this
Very well. It is a very important one so far as our agricultural economy is concerned. We found that one of the consequences of the Budget last year was that industrial production fell by 12½ per cent. Still we have heard the Minister say that the Budget he has introduced is going to stimulate industrial activity and economic recovery. The 1948 agreement, entered into by the inter-Party Government enabled our factories and factory workers to manufacture goods here and send them to Great Britain for sale in competition with goods manufactured in Great Britain. That was a great prospect for both workers and employers in industry and it is regrettable to see that already there is a decline, instead of an expansion, in industrial production. I should like to know what all this talk about industrial development and expansion means when wehave a drop of 12½ per cent. in the volume of production in twelve months.
We have in operation here a tariff policy which is not pursued in an orderly way. In fact, it is pursued in such a disorderly way that we are pricing ourselves out of the foreign markets, so far as manufactured goods are concerned, and at the same time our people are being required to pay through the nose for this tariff policy. The number of people engaged in industry has fallen by 10,000 in the last 12 months. Is it any wonder that industrial production has fallen by 12½ per cent. when we see 10,000 people formerly employed in factories, queueing up at labour exchanges? We had the position where, for every month of every year of the inter-Party régime, more people were going into factories and more factories were being built. During the three and a half years of the inter-Party Government approximately 200 new factories were completed and into those factories thousands of workers went. Since the change of Government several factories which were planned and under way before the change took place, have been completed. Some of them have skeleton staffs and some of them have not opened yet. Let us remember also that before the change of Government we had the highest number of people ever employed in industry. We had increased the number engaged in industry to 233,000 persons. When we came into office the number was approximately 180,000. In other words, we put into industry an extra 53,000 persons manufacturing goods, not alone for use in this country but for export to compete with manufactured goods of other countries.
We have now an unemployment figure of approximately 84,000 persons. Let us compare that figure with the 38,000 persons in 1951 before the change of Government. These figures show the difference between the policy of Fianna Fáil and the policy which was in operation by the inter-Party Government. A progressive reduction in the number of unemployed persons took place in each of the first five months of 1951 before the change of Government. Compared with 1950, therewere fewer people unemployed. When we look at the figure for unemployed persons in 1939, we can see that the Fianna Fáil Party are going back to the policy they had at that time. Official records show that there were 119,000 registered as unemployed in 1939. I suppose the Fianna Fáil Party will say that there are only 84,000 persons unemployed now, as compared with that figure in 1939, but I would prefer to see them comparing the figure with any figure they like to take during the years that the inter-Party Government was in office.
There has been a considerable drop in the number of tradesmen employed in this country, particularly in the building trade. Building has flopped in consequence of the mistake in offering a very high rate of interest for a national loan. Let us remember that that national loan last year, which was designed to purchase popularity for the Fianna Fáil Party, has done damage to this country which will take at least 25 years to repair. Let us remember that the day before that national loan and its interest were announced there were many people in comfortable circumstances in this country who had money invested in one security or another and they were living on the interest. They included unfortunate spinsters, unfortunate disabled persons and others who were not in a position to engage in active employment and were living on the incomes derived from their small capital. The interest they got amounted, in many cases, to 3 per cent., 3½ per cent. or even 4 per cent. The next thing was that the national loan was floated at 5 per cent.
What chance had those people of selling their shares and realising their capital which was yielding 3½ per cent. when the persons who might buy those shares could buy shares in the national loan and get a return of 5 per cent. and, in addition, their money back in the space of 20 years? This national loan has created a precedent and we must resign ourselves to the fact that we will be unable to outlive its consequences so far as the rate of interest is concerned.
Deputy Belton rightly mentioned that the corporation was forced to float a loan and give 5 per cent. as a small enticement in order to get money for the purpose of pursuing the city housing programme. The Minister for Finance mentioned that he intends to float another national loan this year and, even if he finds now that he made a mistake last year in offering 5 per cent. to persons who would invest in that national loan, he cannot this year decide to invite subscriptions to a national loan at 3, 3¾, 4 or even 4½ per cent. He will have to offer terms at least as good as the terms that were made last year. In order to purchase political popularity for his own Party he will have to do so.
Those who subscribe to that loan will get the advantage of it. Those who are unable to subscribe to it but who will be the guarantors, that is, the taxpayers, will be asked once more to shoulder a heavy burden in the form of taxation in order to pay the high rate of interest. Accordingly, it was a mistake, in my view, on the part of the Minister for Finance to make such a drastic change in the rate of interest for the loan last year.
Obviously the loan this year will be necessary if we are to pursue the policy of capital development in order that modern amenities can be provided for our people in various forms, such as electrification and various other services. The taxpayer will now be made liable for the payment of the high rate of interest in connection with this new national loan which, we hope, the Minister will be able again to say was over-subscribed even if, in the long run, it imposes an unnecessarily heavy burden.
Before the change of Government the cry was that the cost of living had gone up and they promised the people that they would bring about a reduction. When the inter-Party Government found it necessary to increase the price of butter from 2/8 per lb. to 2/10, people became hysterical. It was probably political hysterics. If they were hysterical over that increase, I would like to know their frame of mind now, when the price of butter has beenincreased by 1/4 to 4/2 per lb. The worst aspect of this is that they are required to pay 4/2 for New Zealand butter which can be sold at a profit to this country at 3/8 per lb. They are being asked, in other words, to pay a tax of 6d. per lb. on imported butter.
Let me at this stage remind the Minister for Agriculture of a statement he made towards the end of 1951, when he was feeling proud and feeling that he was going to settle everything. He stated that in February or March of 1953, people would not be eating one ounce of imported butter. What has happened? We now find that we are importing from New Zealand twice as much butter as ever and there is no prospect that the practice of importing butter will be ended.
Comment on this
I will refer in a general way to imported butter. Deputy Beegan has just mentioned that it is surprising the people will eat this foreign butter. The fact is that butter is not being eaten at the rate it was. If there is not as much imported butter eaten there is less Irish butter being eaten. The people of Dublin City and of Bray are to eat the imported butter whether they like it or not, while the remainder of the country will be given the advantage of the nice taste of fresh Irish creamery butter.
Comment on this
I think it is most unfair to ask the people of Dublin City and Bray to eat the foreign butter and give Irish creamery butter to the remainder of the country. That is something the inter-Party Governmentwould not do. They did not discriminate between one section of the community and the other. I am now going to refer to a statement made by Deputy Killilea.
Comment on this
Deputy Killilea complained that we gave only eight ounces of butter per week at the rationed price. I reminded him that, when his Party was in power, they were giving the people only two ounces of butter per week at the rationed price. Then he went on to criticise us in connection with the eight ounces of butter per week because we arranged that over and above that people could purchase all the butter they wanted at 3/6 per lb. I would like to tell Deputy Killilea that they are not getting the eight ounces now at the rate of 2/8 a lb. They are getting the eight ounces and all the rest at 4/2 a lb.
I would like to know from the Minister whether he is arranging this year to give a present of £1,000,000 to the tobacco manufacturers as he did last year.
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister that because there is no mention of the £1,000,000 in the Budget this year. I should like to have an assurance from him that the people whose bread, sugar and butter has been increased in price are not going to be required this year to subscribe £1,000,000 as a present for the tobacco manufacturers.
Comment on this
I think I am entitled to make the comparison between this year's Budget and last year's. Thecomparison I wanted to make was that when the price of bread was increased last year by almost 3d. per loaf, and when the prices of flour and of tea were doubled, with an increase also in the price of sugar, it was indicated that the tobacco manufacturers were to get £1,000,000. The same prices will be in operation for these commodities this year, except that the price of butter and sugar have been further increased. In view of that, I suggest that there is an opportunity of making a reduction of £1,000,000 this year if the tobacco manufacturers are not going to get the present they got last year.
Comment on this
I know that, and so we may take it that the Minister is not going to give the people this year the benefit of that £1,000,000 which he collected from them last year for the tobacco manufacturers. The only relief which the Minister gave in the Budget last year was to the ballroom proprietors under the heading of a dance tax. One of the few reliefs he has given in this year's Budget is some minor one to the cinema proprietors. I suppose we will see this year, as we saw last year between the dance bands and the ballroom proprietors, a fight between the cinema proprietors and the film renters as to how that particular relief will be applied.
The only other relief in this year's Budget relates to the partial award which has been grudgingly given by the Minister to the civil servants. It is to apply only from the period beginning 1st April. I suggest that no other employer would behave in that way. The civil servants are being deprived of the benefit of that award, which I suggest they are morally entitled to, for a period of approximately 21 weeks— that is from the date of the award to the 1st April. I was sorry to see Deputy Killilea laughing in a critical way at Deputy Dockrell when he mentioned this matter. Deputy Killilea would seem to agree with Deputy Corry and Deputy Flynn so far as their attitude to the civil servants is concerned.We know that Deputy Corry has described them as "drones." Apparently, that description seems to have a footing in the Fianna Fáil Party.
I hope the Minister will see his way to examine this matter and that he will do justice to the civil servants by following the practice of all other employers in cases where negotiations take place—that is by paying them for the period from the date of the award to the 1st April. That is a practice that is followed by all other classes of employers where negotiations take place. The Minister is holding the threat over the heads of thousands of temporary civil servants that, in consequences of the economy drive, he is going to put them out of employment. I do not believe that he is going to do that. We had a reply to a question recently relating to the number of civil servants employed by the State. That reply indicated that the number was barely sufficient to deal with the work that has to be done. That is the position certainly in some Departments that I have heard of myself. After all, the civil servants are human beings. They have families.
Comment on this
The Minister, apparently, has not found it out yet. I am trying to make him realise the fact that they have families. They have a certain standard of living to keep up. They have to meet their grocers' bills. They have to buy clothes as all other classes of people have to do. It is very unfair for the Fianna Fáil Party to impose burdens on all sections of the community, including the civil servants, and then for the Minister to say in his Budget statement that the various sections in the community have succeeded in securing compensation for the increase in the cost of living, while at the same time leaving out the civil servants from the general body of the people whom he regards as entitled to compensation to meet the increases. The result of that is that we find that people are now going back to a diet of tea, bread and margarinefrom which the inter-Party Government had lifted them. In our time, we had reached the stage where the workers were able to have bacon and eggs on their table in the mornings instead of a diet of tea, bread and margarine. We started off by putting an end to the racket in bacon and pigs which had existed up to the time of our coming into office.
Comment on this
It is obvious that Deputy MacCarthy is not familiar with the line of national economy here since 1951. He should be aware that there was a great scarcity of pigs in 1947. I wonder would he tell us how many of the housewives in Cork were able to get bacon in 1947?
Comment on this
We brought about a position where the workers were able to have bacon and eggs on their table. The Fianna Fáil Party has brought about a position whereby the workers are back again to the tea, bread and margarine or to the synthetic butter. Under the inter-Party Government we reached a stage where we were able to export both butter and bacon. We reached that stage by 1950.
When the inter-Party Government came into office the number of live stock in the country was the lowest recorded for 100 years. By the time the inter-Party Government left office the number of live stock in this country had reached the highest figure ever recorded in our history. Further, we had brought the value of our exports to the highest figure ever achieved. The value of our agricultural exports at the present time is due to the great work done by Deputy Dillon when he was Minister for Agriculture. He isresponsible for bringing up agricultural production to its present level. The Minister has indicated that it is slightly more now than the highest figure reached before the war—and it is going to go higher. That is the result of the very fine agricultural policy embarked upon by Deputy Dillon.
Comment on this
You reduced the number of cows. How you can produce cattle without cows is a mystery to me.
Comment on this
Deputy Cogan cannot controvert the fact that there were never more cattle, sheep and pigs in this country than when the inter-Party Government were leaving office.
Comment on this
Count the cattle. Cows are included in "cattle". If there were fewer cows in 1951, then there are even fewer again at the present time. Deputy Cogan is not using his influence in the Government to do anything about it. In fact, he did not bother when there were 140 farmers in Mountjoy Jail recently.
Comment on this
I heard Deputy Killilea mention mechanisation in connection with farming. There, again, is evidence of the policy pursued by Deputy Dillon during his term of office as Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
We know what the Deputy wants to do. He wants to talk it out. Better let Deputy Palmer in now, or Deputy Everett, who is champing at the bit.
Comment on this
I will get in to-morrow, please God. The Minister is notalways so very sympathetic in his consideration for Deputy Everett.
Comment on this
If ever any mechanisation in connection with farming took place in this country surely that happened during Deputy Dillon's time. He recommended the use of tractors. He pointed out that a tractor was able to do more in a day than six horses.
Comment on this
Turn the pages over again, Deputy. You are now back where you started. I think, Sir, that we had better call a count.
Comment on this
He is not helping me at all. I want to say, in conclusion— maybe the Minister wants an end to it; he does not like to hear the facts— that the inter-Party Government brought the country a long way towards an improved standard of living. The policy now being pursued, instead of bringing the country forward, is putting the country back to the position in which we found it in 1947. If the Minister thinks that the country ought to be brought back to the position in which it was in 1947, then let us hear from him in that respect, but I do not think there are many Deputies who will agree with that point of view.
In 1948, when the inter-Party Government took office, we found a position in which a county council had to get a licence from the Government in order to build a county council house.
Comment on this
The Deputy is travelling wide of theFinancial Motion when he deals with licences to build cottages.
Comment on this
The inter-Party Government embarked on a housing programme which only came under way towards the end of 1948: we were unable to get into gear any sooner. We vigorously pursued the programme of providing houses for our people. Our housing policy continued even after the change of Government. The present Minister for Local Government was very busy opening housing schemes that were planned, started and completed in consequence of the inter-Party Government's policy. Similarly, the present Minister for Industry and Commerce has been kept busy turning the keys of many new factories which were planned and started by the inter-Party Government. I may say that these factories would have been packed to capacity with staff if the inter-Party Government had remained in office— instead of having the position that we have to-day in which many of these factories have just skeleton staffs.
Comment on this
These people did not expect that to happen. I know quite a number of decent manufacturers who would not be allowed by the present Government to go into business. I can mention one man who sent his son to Denmark in order to study the sweet and fat trade. He bought thousands of pounds' worth of machinery which is still in wrappings because he will not be given permission by theMinister for Industry and Commerce to set up a sweet factory and go into the trade.
Comment on this
In that case I will conclude and, on another occasion, I will go into more detail. Apparently I am not allowed to go into detail on this matter now.
Comment on this
We heard to-night from the Minister's supporters that last year's Budget was the most unpopular Budget ever introduced in this House. Why was it unpopular? It was unpopular because it created unemployment. It was unpopular because it created hardship to the business community, and it was unpopular because it created a depression from which we have not yet recovered. Last year the Minister put his hand very deeply into the taxpayer's pocket. But his colleague, the Minister for Local Government, was not satisfied that the Minister should get all the credit. He came along immediately after the Minister for Finance and put his hand into the taxpayer's other pocket. He said that there was something there, too, and that he would increase the taxation in respect of motor-lorries and motor-cars. Then the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs came along and said that there was yet another pocket.
Comment on this
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, Deputy Childers, looked for £750,000. After all that, the Taoiseach came along and said that the taxpayers' pockets are empty and that taxes cannot be further increased because we have reached the limit of our taxable capacity. Despite that,the Minister for Industry and Commerce informed us to-day of a new tax which will affect the poor of this country in particular. He announced an increase of ½d. per lb. in the price of sugar. That will bring in further revenue to the Government.