Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 3—General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–131 of 265. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
One aspect of the problem confronting the country in connection with this Budget with which I intended to deal last night and which was referred to by a Deputy of the Minister's Party is the problem of employment, or lack of employment, in rural Ireland as against the City ofDublin. The reply given by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach to-day bears out the fact that the economic policy of this Government seems to be directed more particularly to the advancement of industry in Dublin City than in the rest of the country combined; and when we hear of projects to the number of 33 or 34 in relation to new industries or additions to existing industries in this city, as given by the Parliamentary Secretary, we are entitled to say that the economic policy of this Government is undoubtedly one which is tending to force people to leave rural Ireland.
Secondly, because of lack of accommodation in the cities and towns, where rural workers may hope at times to get some form of employment, there is no alternative for them but to leave the country. It is poor consolation for people in rural Ireland to read in tomorrow morning's newspapers that more industries will be commenced in Dublin City. I do not know whether they will be or not. It will not satisfy the people who are unemployed or underemployed to be told that the Government policy is a continuation of the old policy of making Dublin topheavy, without regard for any other part of the Twenty-Six Counties.
There is another aspect of this Budget to which attention must be directed because of its connection with the failure of last year's Budget. Members of the Government Party were relieved when they heard that the food subsidies which were reduced so savagely last year would not be further tampered with this year. For the last two years Ministers of State emphasised the desirability of leaders of trade unions and others instructing and, if possible, coercing their members, at the behest of Ministers and the Taoiseach himself, not to seek increases in wages. They were completely illogical in their approach to the problem because the Minister for Finance and the members of his Government were directly responsible for placing the workers in the position that they had to seek increased wages in order to meet the cost of living imposed upon them by the present Administration.
In rural Ireland, in Cork City and I presume in Dublin City, a heavyburden was placed on local authority hospitals and voluntary hospitals by the reduction of the food subsidies last year. That burden will be continued by the Minister's refusal this year to restore the subsidies even though it is now quite clear that that action was mistaken. Patients in these hospitals had to pay higher maintenance fees because of the consequent increase in the cost of foodstuffs.
The Government's approach to this matter is completely false. The working people are entitled to fair treatment. Deputy Corry, as chairman of the South Cork Board of Assistance, is well aware of the heavy burden imposed on the ratepayers and on hospital patients as a result of the savage attack made by the Minister for Finance on the food subsidies.
Attention has been drawn to the problem of emigration. A question was raised in the British House of Commons on 7th May. The responsible Minister was asked if he was aware of the danger of people leaving Ireland and going into Britain carrying with them the dread disease of T.B. and if the Minister was prepared to introduce some system of screening these poor unfortunate emigrants from this country. The reply was that the matter was under consideration and that some method of having a check at the airports and shipping ports would be considered. Very few of our emigrants travel by air. Before our young people can emigrate to Britain they will probably have to be screened. That means that only the flower of the young people will be allowed into Britain and the poor crocks, like some of us, will be left.
I direct the attention of the House to the irresponsible action of the Minister, politically speaking, the dishonourable action, and the unjust action, in refusing to provide out of the carry-over that is available the money that is due to the rural postmen and other lowly-paid State employees. The Minister and the Government cannot evade their responsibility in this matter. The Minister stated in his Budget speech that there is a carry-over of £2,000,000. The Minister and the Government are prepared to give retrospectivepayment to other people who have very high salaries—the judges.
Our main problem concerns the unemployed who have to attend at the employment exchanges. In that connection I direct the attention of the Minister to Part VII, page 35 of the National Nutrition Survey where the following statement is made:—
"The average height in inches of the unemployed man's child at a given age is over two inches less than that of the average child of the lower professional group of the same age."
While the Minister devoted part of his Budget speech to the vital importance of providing additional money for defence and stated that the previous Government, between 1948 and 1951, did not meet their commitments with regard to defence, he conveniently passed over such a damning indictment of the modern conditions of Government in this country as is contained in this report. I say, and I am saying it for every member of the Labour Party, that while we are loyal to our country our first obligation as Christians and Irishmen must be to deal with the problem of the children of the unemployed men who are faced with being in future the so-called undesirables who, when having to go to Britain, will have to go through the process of screening. There is little use in talking about getting new guns and new automatic weapons, if we can afford them, or the leaders of our Army on manoeuvres in the country posing for pictures when at the same time resolving to keep the photographers away from the employment exchanges and from the homes of the unemployed where children are hungry and when, because of the continuation of the savage Budget introduced last year, the Minister is prepared to say to the unemployed in rural Ireland and in Dublin and Cork: "Continue as you are; draw the dole; if you are strong enough and if you will pass through the process of screening you can go to Britain and let the future look after your children."
Comment on this
In my ten years' experience of this House neverhave there been Financial Motions discussed more in the atmosphere of a general election than the present motions. There is very good reason why that should be the case. It is my intention to go into that matter and the reasons why we should have a general election. I should like to refer first to the statement made yesterday by Deputy Hickey in a very good speech on which I must compliment him. He referred to the fact that he had to go to the agricultural Credit Corporation with a certain man from his area who wanted a loan for the purchase of certain machinery for development in this country. That man was told that the interest on the loan would be over 12 per cent.
Comment on this
The interest was supposed to be 7 per cent. but he would be actually paying 14 per cent.
Comment on this
The Minister interjected: "Why does he not cut out smoking?" From the beginning to the end, that is the view of the Minister —cut out this, that and the other thing; we eat too much, we smoke too much, we drink too much, we dress too well, our standard of living is too high. We must cut out all these things and put on the hair shirt referred to by the Taoiseach many years ago. It has come back to what that great prophet, the Taoiseach, stated, that it is necessary to put on the hair shirt. That is what it amounts to.
In introducing last year's Budget the Minister stated that the reason for the extra taxation was that he had got to put the finances of this country in order; that it was his intention to put the finances in order and put this country on the road to prosperity. But, after 12 months, he has found out that instead of putting the finances of the country in order he has put them completely into disorder. This year he comes along with an "as you were" Budget, and there will be more disorder in the finances in the coming year. I know that it would be his intention to increase taxation but for something which happened during the last year. As a result of the by-electionin North-West Dublin the Government found that they could not continue putting on more taxation.
It made me laugh when I heard the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister, Deputy Beegan, in reply to Deputy A. Byrne, stating that sweets beat them in North-West Dublin. It must be very easy to beat the present Government when sweets beat them in North-West Dublin. Much less than sweets will beat them throughout the country in the near future. I also listened to Deputy Hickey, and later on to Deputy McQuillan referring to what you might call the currency problem and matters of that kind that I do not understand. From year to year the burden on the taxpayers is becoming greater and greater. If greater expenditure is required for things that are necessary, until such time as more money can be earned in this country by whatever method it is possible to do it, we are just taking it out of one pocket and putting it into another.
With regard to the finances of this country, my view is that there is only one section of the community that makes any new money. We hear quite a lot about professional people, bankers and others making new money. They do not make any new money. There is only one section that makes any new money and that is the people on the land. Any new money that is made comes from the land and from the workers on the land. It is on those people and what they produce that we have to depend for any new money that is made.
The Minister said in his Budget statement that taxation lies lightly on the land. That causes no little amusement, when one remembers the efforts made to squeeze the last penny out of the farmer. It is said that coming events cast their shadows before them and, from that point of view, the Minister's statement did not surprise me very much. Some time ago the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party in the Seanad, Senator Quirke, suggested that there should be a tax of £5 per head on cattle and live stock exported from this country. I have not the slightestdoubt that if Fianna Fáil had a majority behind them they would, as they did in days gone by, put the farmer once more on the verge of starvation. If the Minister had a majority, I have no doubt he would have imposed more penal taxes in his recent Budget.
The Minister must realise that in a very short space of time 78,000 people have left the land. The land is not the El Dorado he thinks it is, and the sooner the Minister gets away from the idea that he can impose further taxation on the farmers and on the workers on the land the better it will be for the country. In some cases local rates are as much as £2 in the £. The income-tax paid by the professional man or the businessman is really derived from the land and from the wealth the farmer produces. Any increase in wages is put upon the consumer and in the last analysis it is the man on the land who sweats and works to get from the land the food we eat and the raw material we export. He is the foundation of all wealth in this country and without him no other section could survive.
In my young days it was the custom for the parents to select the particular child to whom they would leave their holding or farm. Nowadays the trouble is to find a child who is prepared to remain on that holding or farm. All the sons and daughters are emigrating to England or to the cities and large towns to get away from the land. Nevertheless, the Minister tells us glibly that taxation lies lightly on the land. Our export trade in cattle and live stock is the only source of revenue worth a damn. The day we fail to keep up those exports we will find ourselves without any revenue, and without money we will not go very far.
A general election is in the offing. The cry is: "Put out the Government." It matters little to me what Party is in power if the proper policy is implemented. I and my supporters in Galway have come to the conclusion that the present Government should be deprived of power. What has happened during the last 12 months? Teais double the price to-day that it was last year. The price of bread has doubled and so has the price of butter. The inter-Party Government was taunted with importing butter. We were told it was yellow. We were told it was not fit for human consumption. We were told it would cause disease. Strange to relate, the colour changed, the smell changed, and it became fit for human consumption the moment Fianna Fáil changed the price from 2/8 per lb. to 4/2 per lb. Motor taxation has increased by over £800,000. The increase in the postal rates is anticipated to bring in £750,000. Unemployment has more than doubled. Emigration, especially from the West of Ireland—I am sure Deputy Killilea will agree with me in this— has never been greater since 1947 than it is now. Homes in rural Ireland are closed up and the sons and daughters have gone away. When I was on that side of the House I remember being taunted in regard to all the people that were lined up at the employment exchanges in Galway City, but never before in Irish history were there as many unemployed in Galway City as there are to-day. Over 1,000 people are unemployed there. That is the record of the past 12 months and it is on that record that I judge the present Government. I feel, as over 90 per cent. of the people of the Twenty-Six Counties feel to-day, that a general election is necessary and that the present Government should be put out.
On my way up from Galway yesterday a young man from my area told me that he came over here five years ago when the inter-Party Government was in power. He was a professional builder and he answered the call of the inter-Party Government to come back to his native country. For three and a half years he worked in the City of Dublin and there was plenty of employment. Yesterday he travelled with me having been home to visit his people. Last night, he took the boat to go across to England to try to find employment there. I said to him: "Is the position as bad as that in the City of Dublin?""Yes," he said, "on account of the increase in the bank rate, and so on, there is no use buildingany houses now unless you build a £6,000 or £7,000 house for the financiers. The day of building for the white collar worker or for the general worker in Dublin City is gone for the simple reason that, with the increased bank rate, there is no point in building houses for those people because they cannot afford to pay the rent." Therefore, the people who did come home and hearkened to the call when the inter-Party Government was in power are fleeing to-day as fast as ever they can.
That is the record of the past 12 months, but let us see what the position was slightly before that. When Fianna Fáil got in, or were put in as the case may be, we remember the cry of the Minister—it was a help to him in the last Budget if not in this one—that this country was robbed by the inter-Party Government. You would imagine we were looters or people of that description. The financial position was parlous and we had the country robbed. Nevertheless, he had to admit that when he and his Government came into office there was £24,000,000 of the Marshall Aid fund in the Treasury for him to use. While with one side of their mouths they shout how this country was robbed—there was not a penny left to do anything— with the other sides of their mouths they can justify paying £250,000 for a racehorse. With the self-same side of their mouths they can stand over the expenditure of £500,000 on transatlantic services and other items like that.
When the inter-Party Government assumed office the first thing they did was to give back £6,000,000 to the taxpayer. They removed the penal taxes Fianna Fáil had imposed on beer and tobacco. They kept the necessaries of life, such as bread, butter, sugar and tea within reasonable bounds so that the people could buy them. In passing, may I refer to the increase in sugar a few days ago by ½d. a lb.; of course, that is nothing! The inter-Party Government did their best in matters of that kind. During their term of office, we had an export trade in this country of over £100,000,000, the greatest ever in the history of thiscountry. The reason for that was that the section of the community I referred to, that is, the people on the land, knew the inter-Party Government were solid; they knew the line that Government was working on and that there was no trick-of-the-loop business. They knew that for their work and their produce they would be paid. They knew that all they had to do was to work and they would be paid. During that time we had, for the first time in the history of this country, an export trade of over £100,000,000.
Comment on this
Never was employment greater; never was unemployment lower than it was during the inter-Party Government term of office.
Comment on this
Never was it lower since the war. It is double what it was during the reign of the inter-Party Government. It is 90,000 to-day.
Comment on this
If you look up the records, you will see that it is true. Employment was never higher; unemployment was never lower than it was in our time. There have been many terrible changes since then: the price of tea has doubled; the price of sugar has doubled, you might say; the price of bread and the price of butter have doubled; there is taxation on tobacco, taxation on the workman's pint of stout, taxation on the packet of cigarettes. Then we are told this is a good Budget because it did not do any worse than it did last year. It was impossible for it to do any worse. Talking here will not remedy the situation, and I know that no talk will induce the Minister to make any changes.
I listened to Deputy Dillon in this House when he said that the Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, does not rule Fianna Fáil any longer. I was just wondering was that so. I did not express the opinion, but surely some very strange thing has happened because it is not his form, as I knew him for many years, to be in the corner he is in to-day and not to run to the country. I remember an occasion when he rushed at midnight to have the Dáil dissolved. Of course, I believe Deputy Dillon is right when he says that he does not rule any longer, because if he had the power he used to have some time ago he certainly would say: "We will go to the country and hear what the people have to say."
At least 90 per cent. of the people of this country are crying out to-day for a change of Government on account of the reasons I have given. The present Government are still clinging or trying to cling on to power despite what they must know well, that the people want a change. Dublin North-West proved it and I suppose within the next three weeks, if we do go that far, Wicklow and Cork East will prove the same thing. Then we are bound to have it anyway. My suggestion would be that in view of the hopeless mess into which the present Minister and the present Government have put this country over the past two years, they should come out to the people and make an open confession that, although they challenged the inter-Party Government that they did not keep down the cost of living, they themselves have failed and have made it impossible for the people to live here. Let them admit it, and allow back into power the inter-Party Government which was the best Government this country ever had.
The sooner the present Government go to the country and let the people return the inter-Party Government again, the better it will be for the country. Even if the by-elections are held, it will be necessary to have a general election within a short time. The Minister knows that his Party is finished and that back into power theywill never get again. It is not worth clinging to office and incurring the cost of two by-elections for the sake of three or four weeks longer in office. Owing to the terrible failure this Government have been, owing to the fact that they have doubled unemployment and that they are responsible for an emigration greater than was ever known in black '47, at least in the West of Ireland: owing to the fact that they are responsible for having homes closed up in the rural areas, I would ask them to dissolve the Dáil, go to the country and allow the people to give them their answer. That answer will be to put the inter-Party Government back into power. So far as we in Clann na Talmhan are concerned we shall take part in any such Government. Fianna Fáil have their organisers going through the country saying: "We shall get in all right; the Opposition do not want an election." The question is not what the Opposition want or what the Government want; it is what the people want. The people want an election and the people must get it. So far as we in the Clann na Talmhan Party are concerned, we shall work and cooperate, as we did previously, in an inter-Party Government, not for the sake of Labour, Fine Gael or Clann na Poblachta but because we believe it offers the only means to get us out of the mess into which the present Government and the Minister have put this country in the past two years. The quicker the people are given that opportunity the better.
Comment on this
As one who has grown up with national movements of many kinds in this country, I often wonder here whether I can believe my ears when I hear the ullagoning, the banshee wails and the cries of dire distress that are uttered in this House, as if this nation had lost its manhood and its nationality. The banshee wail is weird but at least it is consistent even though, like a jack-o'-lantern, it might lead the people astray; it is certainly leading the Opposition into all manners of inconsistencies in their discussion of the matters which they pretend are connected with this Financial Resolution. Last nightDeputy McGilligan, with that usual waspish venom with which he tries to smite his opponents, said that this Budget was designed in the interests of our external payments, but when Deputy McGilligan was in power and when he took office as Minister for Finance in the inter-Party Government he stated that his policy was one of economy and retrenchment. He told us last night about rising prices and all the rest of it but after he had been three years in office this is what he said on the 2nd May, 1951, as reported in Volume 125, column 1878, dealing with prices and the monetary situation:—
"The stresses to which our economy is at present subject arise largely from increased prices, and these in turn are due in the main to external circumstances. . . . There is reason to fear that we have not yet experienced the full consequences of the increased international demand for basic commodities."
That is what he said in 1951—that prices had not yet reached their full limit. He went on:—
"Concurrently with the rise in import prices there has occurred an increase in our trade deficit."
That is something perhaps that members of the Opposition have need to consider in their arguments on this Resolution.
Deputy McGilligan continued:—
"When what we produce for export does not go as far as before towards paying for our import needs we suffer, as a nation, a reduction in the standard of living we can afford."
How does that compare with his argument last night? He tried to condemn the Government for taking into consideration the balance of our external payments, but in 1951 he said that if that balance was not corrected, we, as a nation, would suffer a reduction in the standard of living we could afford. When the present Minister is trying to remedy that situation so that we can afford a decent standard of living, Deputy McGilligan has theaudacity to come to the House and condemn the Government for doing what he advocated in 1951. Not because he advocated it is the Government carrying out that policy but because they believe it is the right policy and a good policy.
His next statement on that occasion was:—
Increases in remuneration offer no escape from this unwelcome development."
Last night he condemned the Government for not going back another six months in the increased payments to civil servants and others, while he said in 1951 that increases in remuneration offer no escape from the unwelcome development which he admitted had taken place under his own administration. He stated further on that occasion:—
"Indeed they can only accelerate the process of inflation and cause social injustice as between those able to improve or maintain their position and those who cannot enlarge their income."
I have some regard for people who try to be consistent—even if you do not agree with them you may admire them —but people who come along in this blatant way and alter everything they previously said, just to try to condemn the Government and to give the country a false impression, surely are not acting in the interests of the nation or the national economy.
At column 1880 Deputy McGilligan adds:—
"Unless we are building up our productive capacity to an adequate degree, so that by increasing our exports or reducing our imports we can within a few years equalise——"
mark the word "equalise".
"——our external receipts and payments, we must inevitably suffer a decline in our living standards."
In column 1883 he further says:—
"The present position on external account is by no means satisfactory, and if it continues to develop unfavourably the application of corrective measures will be called for."
What are the things that Deputy McGilligan advocates in those statements? He advocates the equalisation of our balance of payments so that we can keep up our living standards. Last night, he seemed to take a different view but the Government feel this way about it. The balance of external payments is the barometer indicating the trend of our national economy and if we can provide for our own people and balance things in such a manner that we will be able to pay our commitments we are acting in the best interests of our people.
One of our patriots—I think it was John Mitchel—said: "Woe to that man or that nation whose destiny is depending on the will of another." We want to preserve the integrity of our currency in the interests of our own people so that we will not have to put our country in pawn to any nation on earth. Last year, we were told by members of the Opposition that our Minister for Finance was in collusion, if you please, with the British Chancellor of the Exchequer. This debate has become so monotonous and so much out of line with reality that I would ask the members to divert their minds, if not their eyes, for a few moments through the medium of the Cork Examinerto what is happening in the fair land of France at this moment.
If they visited the Parliament there they would see that the same problems are confronting that country as confront us here. The similarity is such that, perhaps, when the Opposition have studied it, they may accuse the Minister this year of being in collusion with the Premier of France because the French Premier is at the moment seeking a vote of confidence on his Financial Resolution. He is doing that, he states, in order to reorganise the administration and preserve the economy of the country. He speaks on the necessity for economic stability. He said the question was so serious that it was impossible to have either an internal or external policy of any kind while the national finances were in disorder.
Comment on this
That is what ourMinister for Finance has been doing over the last year. He has been trying to put our finances into order. I was very interested in a motion which was submitted to the House recently by Deputy Sheldon, who made a proposal concerning the examination of our accounts and our national economy. We have a Committee of the House which examines from time to time the finances of the various Departments. I, like other members of the House, have been connected for many years with local authorities and we have to consider our estimates at the end of the year and the sums that have been paid over the previous years. The figures are presented to us and, of course, it would be impossible to get to the root of many of the vital matters concerned in these items.
As I understood Deputy Sheldon's motion, it was one suggesting that a committee be set up to get away from the pattern of the Estimates for a time, examine the national economy and the payments to be provided for capital expenditure which it would be in the national interests to stimulate and other matters of that kind. It was a proposal to work out, if you like, the sum by a different method and see if you would arrive at anything like the same answer.
We had members of the Opposition, people like Deputy Rooney, juggling and muddling figures the other night and if he was there until the Lord called on him he would not arrive at any answer which would give any appearance of correctness in the measuring of our national finances. If we could get down to and examine the problem before us and forget this call for elections it would be much better for us. That is not what this Parliament was elected for. It was elected to do the work of the country in this Assembly for five years unless the Government in office was defeated in the House in the meantime. That is what the people were sent here for.
If any notice were to be taken of the views of the Opposition we would behave just as they did. We would have run away from the financial situation as they ran away from it a few years ago. If the Government wouldnever face an unpopular thing they would have their minds bent on what the people outside were thinking and what each individual was saying. They would do that rather than examine as a whole the national position and take the decision best suited to the interests of the nation.
We do not intend in any way to avoid our responsibilities in that respect. In endeavouring to do that the Minister's Budget has got many strange names. It was called a cruel Budget: It was called a tragic Budget and it was called an unimaginative Budget. If there is anything in this world that does not lend itself to the exercise of imagination it is finance. It would be a grand thing if you could imagine that money was to come from the air and that you need not provide for it by hard work and industry but it would be poor consolation to the workmen in C.I.E. to imagine that they had their wage of £5, £6 or £7 in their pockets when they had nothing at all there.
Instead of Deputy McGilligan bringing about a position of retrenchment and economy, as he said, he ran the country £81,000,000 more into debt and he left the balance of payments with which he was so concerned £61.6 million out of balance on the wrong side for this country. It is very hard, indeed, to listen to people speaking in this way after they had got the Marshall Aid as a help to provide for the war conditions which then prevailed.
We had Deputy Dillon saying here the other night that we have priced ourselves out of the external markets. He was referring to butter, if you please, and saying that we would not sell butter any more in the foreign market. Why? Because the farmers got an economic price, or something near it, for their milk and, of course, the price of butter is based on the price of milk. If the farmers had accepted Deputy Dillon's proposition of 1/- per gallon as a guaranteed price for their milk for the next five years, what would the position be to-day? Bad as it is as a result of his approach, most of the farmers wouldhave got out of their dairy cattle and we would not have milk any more than we have butter. It is strange that we have to import butter into this agricultural country. If Deputy Dillon, when he got the opportunity with the Marshall Aid money, was interested in our agricultural economy—mind you I would say he is but that his interest is entirely misplaced—had put aside £1,000,000 for each county for the replacement of uneconomic herds and had helped the farmers in that way— if he had done that for each of the Twenty-Six Counties—he would still have about £20,000,000 left to blow up the rocks of Connemara. But where did the money go? I do not know and I live in the largest county in Ireland. I do not think anyone could tell me or tell any person living in that county what help it got from the Marshall Aid money. I think that to find the answer one would have to search for many a day and that ultimately the banshee would catch one out at night.
It is an extraordinary thing that so many people speak with divers tongues in this House. They do not think, first, of the interests of the country or of the interests of their Party. If they thought of the interests of their own Party one might say that it was all right, but they put their own harebrained ideas even before the interests of their Party. Deputy Dillon has been so long out of a Party that he probably forgets there is any such thing except the Fianna Fáil Party, which he wants to attack, because it has remained together.
Comment on this
That is a type of the slighting remarks that we hear in this House from time to time. It is true that we have a number of Independent Deputies on both sides of the House. When a number of them got tired of the mixum-gatherum that made up the inter-Party Government, changed their views, went before the country and were re-elected to this House as opponents of the inter-Party Government and then proceeded to act on the principles on which they wereelected, we have nothing but sneers thrown at them across the House. Surely, if a man is elected as an Independent Deputy he has the right to exercise his independence in this House and is quite entitled to do so. He was elected to this House for that purpose.
It is not in keeping with this Government's recorded intentions—and we do not propose to do so now—to purchase popularity at the expense of the economy of this country. We propose to face the issues before us and to tell the people honestly what the position is. We told them last year that they had a difficult year to face. They faced it last year, as the people of this country have always done.
I am surprised at the ullagones and the wails we hear from Deputies in this House. Do we not know that, during all the difficult years of oppression, with their penal enactments and with the worst system of landlordism in Europe hanging over their heads, our people ploughed and sowed, they reaped and they mowed, even when eviction was threatening them. Those were the people who kept the economy of the country together. They kept up its spirit so that Davitt and Parnell could tell the Irish farmers to keep "a firm grip on their homesteads," and to preserve the land for the people. As Pearse has said, "Irish nationality is an ancient spiritual tradition." It will never fade while there are people in this country willing to make sacrifices in the national interest. Despite sentiments of the lowest kind which some Deputies attempt to arouse in the breasts of our people, of people, perhaps, who have to contend with the misfortunes of life and sometimes with the mismanagement of local authorities and Governments, yet the people must prefer the sursum corda—raise your hearts—to theDe Profundisand are prepared to face the future as their ancestors did.
We have been told that we promised great things up and down the country during the time of the last election. Undoubtedly, if the finances of the country had been preserved, as we think they should have been by theinter-Party Government when they were in power and when the control was in their hands, we would not be in the position to-day of having to make provision to meet all the debts which they left us unpaid. I do not want to recall these debts to-day. They have been recited so often that we are really tired hearing of them. We have something else to do now—to meet the obligations of the future and make provision for them. We intend to do that.
The inter-Party Government undermined the policy which we had prepared for the development of C.I.E. and for the modernising of the railways. Almost five years have been lost in putting that policy into effect. We have to start again with that policy at the point where we left off. Our intention is to try to modernise the system, to effect economics and, at the same time, give an efficient service. We had schemes for turf development and for rural electrification. Instead of setting up stations to be operated on foreign fuel, as the inter-Party did, these stations will now be operated by our natural waterpower and by the turf fuel which we produce from our own bogs. These schemes will give employment through the length and breadth of an area in Ireland where that particular type of development is best suited.
Of course, the Coalition Government sold the Constellations. They considered that as we are only a small nation, we should not participate in air transport. Do Deputies on the Opposition Benches not realise that there are nations in Europe which are not as big as the province of Munster and which are able to run international airways efficiently and successfully? Do they not realise also that when we bought these Constellations we were in a pioneering position so far as international airways were concerned? Holy Year was coming and people from America and other countries were interested in our airways and were making inquiries. As a result of the action of the Coalition Government in selling the Constellations which we hadpurchased we have lost that pioneering position for ever. Do Deputies on the Opposition Benches not realise even yet that, when we bought those Constellation aircraft, one of the big air companies set up a Lockheed service industry at Shannon where 354 skilled people were employed? Bristol was willing to give employment to those skilled people when the Coalition Government got rid of our Constellations.
There was a time, too, when the ships of all nations came into the very best ports on the highway between Europe and America and when we depended on those foreign ships for the transport of merchandise to and from our country. We should still be in that position to-day were it not for the industry and the initiative of Deputy Lemass, our Minister for Industry and Commerce. We were totally dependent on foreign ships and they could and often did place a tax on the goods leaving this country and another tax on them when they were entering Britain or elsewhere. Why should our airports, which are recognised to be among the best in the world, be used only by foreign air companies? Have we no faith in our own country? We hear a lot of talk in this House about capital expenditure. The Opposition say: "Bring home the money and invest it here in the interests of the country so that it will give employment." Yet the moment that is done the Coalition Government come along and undermine projects and leave the country in a worse position than it was even under an oppressive Government.
Much mention has been made about housing and about the attitude of the present Government to housing. As Deputy Hickey probably knows, I often had the task of trying to settle strikes in that industry in Cork and of trying to procure the raw materials to enable that industry to go ahead. I can say that there was a time when every bag of cement used in the southern counties was imported through the port of Cork. At that time there was no such thing as capital expenditure to extend our owncement factories so that we could build our houses in Cork, Kerry and elsewhere with our own cement.
Comment on this
A start had to be made. The cement factories were going. Instead of extending them the Coalition Government discouraged them.
Comment on this
Do we not all know that Deputy Dillon, from those Opposition Benches, tried to sabotage every build-up of national industry? Were the leaders of the cement industry in this country not blackguarded in this House?—and that is the only way I can describe it.
Comment on this
More than that, the Labour Party were opposed to the establishment of the cement industry here.
Comment on this
You were allowing yourselves to be dictated to by foreign combines in regard to the cement industry in this country.
Comment on this
I will say nothing here that I am not able to prove. Any Deputy can examine the records if he wishes to. The records will prove that I am telling the truth. We were told that the higher rate of interest was impending progress. I would refer Deputies to column 763 of Volume 30 of the Official Report. The then Cumann na nGaedheal Minister for Finance (Mr. Blythe) said:—
"It is understood——"
—mind you, "understood."
"—that some local authorities are anxious to carry out housing schemes under the Housing of the Working Classes (Ireland) Acts, . . . "
—they were only just starting to make the local loans available to them at that time. Mr. Blythe continued:—
"The loans will be repayable on the annuity basis over a maximum period of 35 years, and the rate of interest chargeable will be 5¾ per cent."
Now I ask Deputy Hickey to calculate the value of interest at the rate of 5¾ per cent. on the 5th June, 1929—when that statement was made—and what 5¾ per cent. interest is worth at the present time. Deputy Hickey knows that there are public utility societies in Cork which built houses for working people in Cork—houses on which the people have been paying 6 per cent. interest from that particular time.
Comment on this
The rate of interest of the Agricultural Credit Corporation was 5 per cent. to which legal expenses, titles and mortgages were to be added. Deputy Mulcahy, who at the time was Minister for Local Government, complained in Dáil Éireann when dealing with grants from the Road Fund that they wanted to pay workers higher wages out of the moneys received from the Central Fund. One can find that in the records, if anyone wants to search for it.
Comment on this
Would Deputy Palmer allow me to develop my point? Deputy Mulcahy said then that the local authorities had the audacity to try to increase the wages of the workers out of the money received from the Central Fund. We heard last night the Government condemned in all moods and tenses for the increasein motor taxation of £860,000. The motorists were the users of the road and where is that money going? That money was distributed to the local authorities this year and it will go into the pockets of the workers and for the buying of material to put the roads in proper shape for the motorists who are using them and paying for them.
Comment on this
I hope Deputy Mulcahy and those with him have not the same views regarding what should be done with that money as they had previously.
There are two items that disturb people very considerably. One is unemployment and the best method of giving employment in our own land. As president of the Association of Municipal Authorities, I was down in Wicklow some time ago—I also travel to various parts of the country—and the urban authorities there said: "When we have these 20 or 30 houses finished, we have the housing problem solved." Then people come in here with that knowledge and condemn the Government because people who were working in the building industry have not the same measure of employment as they had previously when these schemes were at their highest. In Cork, Dublin and other big cities that problem will not be solved for many years, but taking the all-over picture, should not any Government be planning for other works? When the houses are built, surely there are many schools which need renovation, reconstruction or absolute renewal; surely there are roads and bridges to be reconstructed, playgrounds to be provided and other schemes of work needed to beautify the surroundings of our towns?
Would it not be better than having them drawing the dole, to put a whole lot of unemployed clearing derelict sites and taking the ugly look off many towns and villages, and to provide money for works of that kind, even if they were only lifting the stones from these derelict sites in lorries? I remember our Minister for Local Government—andto give Deputy Keyes credit where credit is due, he had the same thing in mind—being anxious to clear these derelict sites. He sent down from his Department, as our Minister did also, a circular underlining that derelict sites were to be cleared. When it went to the local authorities, you had the attitude of the county managers or city managers: "We would do that with machinery a lot more cheaply; we should not put manual labour working at it." Would not the difference between what they are getting on the dole and a decent wage make up a lot of this, to put them out to do some work and leave the machinery off it and get the men to do it themselves?
The other day, a Sunday morning, a man called to my door, a man whom I knew previously, and I asked him where he had been. He said: "I was in England for the last three or four months driving a tractor and working from daybreak to dusk in a farm in Devonshire; 16/10 of my wages was deducted every week for income-tax and I had to pay 3/8 for a packet of cigarettes. If I wanted to go to Mass on Sunday the boss had to drive me there. For a couple of Sundays he did it but then he said to me: ‘Paddy, remember you are in England now; why do you have to go to Mass?' and I said: ‘Because I want to be something different from the cattle you have outside there in your stall.' I came home because £5 here is worth £7 in England, in my experience, and because the money you get there would not be worth what you lose in other respects—your religion and the traditions in which you were brought up."
We had Deputy Donnellan at the same sing-song a while ago about the unemployed being doubled. There were 60,000 unemployed when the inter-Party Government was in office. That has mounted up to some measure but not to the extent that is being bandied around this House. It has gone up by 11,000 approximately—it is a very big number, indeed—from 60,000 to 71,000.
Comment on this
Deputy Carter gave some figures here the other night showing that, by a reciprocal arrangement with the British Government, there were 4,000 odd-nearly 5,000— put on the Labour Exchange this year who previously were not entitled to benefit. As well as that he gave a figure of between 7,000 and 8,000 who were there all the time, who by reason of the change in the means test were now added to the unemployed list. That is 12,000 and taking 12,000 from 82,000 you get 70,000. Any Deputy who wishes can prove that by reading the Irish Trade Journalin the Library. Deputy Morrissey advised us last night to read certain things in the Library. Here is what I read on page 10 of that journal:—
"Certain amendments of the Unemployment Assistance Acts provided for in the Social Welfare Act, 1952 became operative as from 5th January, 1953. The effects of these changes account in large measure for the increase in the number of unemployment benefit claims current and the decrease in the number of unemployment assistance applications current. . . . Comparisons of the numbers of claimants to unemployment benefit and of applicants for unemployment assistance in 1953 with the corresponding figures in 1952 are not useful, in view of the changes made by the provisions of the Social Welfare Act, 1952, which came into operation as from 5th January, 1953. In addition, it is believed that the total numbers on the register were to some extent increased by the operation of this Act which, among other provisions, extended the means limits for qualification to unemployment assistance, entitled agricultural workers—who were not at all entitled before—to unemployment benefit, modified the contribution conditions for receipt of such benefit, increased rates of unemployment assistance, thus possiblyinducing persons who did not pursue applications formerly."
I am sorry there is unemployment and I am sorry there is emigration. When it mounted from 3,000 in 1946, to 10,000 in 1947, to 18,000 in 1949, to 34,000 in 1950 and to 41,000 in 1951, the inter-Party Government got so alarmed that they set up a commission to tell them what to do about it and that commission has not yet reported. That is the way they dealt with it.
Comment on this
Let me come now to the question of defence. We are told that we should not provide all the money which is being provided for the Army and their equipment. Deputy O'Higgins said with regard to the last emergency: "If a vote were to be recorded, I would say that the policy of neutrality was unwise." That is Deputy O'Higgins referring to the last emergency. If the policy of neutrality was unwise, evidently he wanted to fight somebody, to declare war on somebody.
Comment on this
I am sorry I have not got it here. It is on the records and I can get it at any time. The statement is in the records.
Comment on this
The Deputy was very careful to give other references, but we have no reference for this statement.
Comment on this
If neutrality was unwise, the Deputy wanted to declare war on somebody and, if he did, did hewant to equip his Army? We all remember that, in the days of the national struggle, our volunteers had to capture to-day what they were going to fight with to-morrow. Should we be in that position again?
Comment on this
If this country were in the danger zone in any future war. is that the position that people would like us to be in? Is it not a direct invitation to anybody to come in here. if we have nothing to fight with? Some people have said it was ridiculous to be talking about these arms in presentday circumstances, but they would have said the same in 1916. Deputy Dillon would have said the same in 1916, and in 1918, when 4,000,000 members of the British Army were demobilised after the Armistice and when even with all these, Britain had to send in her Black and Tans and Auxiliaries, and in spite of burning down our towns, was unable to beat the national spirit.
Comment on this
If we have an Army. we must equip it. If we do not do so. we are being unfair to them and to the country. We are expecting them to risk their lives, perhaps unarmed. when, with equipment, their lives would be safe, or they would be able to put up a decent show. But it is not with that that I am mainly concerned because I hope we will not be involved in war. The first method of protection surely is to provide against emergencies of that kind by having the nation protected and having its sons armed, and properly armed, to defend it. Deputy Mulcahy said that the Minister was like somebody going back to the scene of last year's crime and that some Fianna Fáil members were wearing haloes plucked from the graves of dead men. I speak in all charity when I say that he should be the last man in this House to use that analogy and I leave it at that.
Sneers were thrown at one Minister, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, the other day. I travelled with his father through the glens, the lanes and mountains of this country when he faced every danger and difficulty. I saw him offer to do almost impossible things, undertakings from which there was no chance whatever of escape. He marched with the columns and shared their dangers and, I may add, participated in their prayers in the houses of the plain people. Would those who throw these sneers across the House put the same doubtful questionings regarding Thomas Davis or Pádraic Pearse? No; they would shrivel up in shame for their own audacity. If we allow ourselves, as Thomas Davis said, to be influenced by sun, and wind, and rain, and not by the deeds and sacrifices of the past, we are a helpless and a hopeless nation.
Comment on this
The most important and immediate problems this Government have to face are unemployment, emigration and the rising cost of living, and the sooner they face these problems, the better it will be for themselves and the country, because people can have patience for a long time, but, when they see their families suffering, their patience becomes exhausted. Therefore, unemployment is the most immediate problem they have to face. When the Budget was introduced last year, I said it was the most vicious Budget ever introduced in this or any other country. Its effect on the Irish people was appalling. The first thing that Budget brought about was an increase in the price of the loaf from 6d. to 9d., one of the biggest blows the working class ever got. Many other things were done at that time which were a discredit to an Irish Parliament. On the introduction of that Budget everything that the people had to purchase went up considerably —bread, butter, tea and sugar. Heavy taxation was imposed on taximen and people with small vans. Some of them could not bear the taxation and were driven out of business. Others have advertised their taxis and vans for sale.
Dublin North-West cried halt andtold the Government they could go no further. The voters of Dublin North-West showed in a practical way that taxation had reached its limit. The Taoiseach and the Minister for Industry and Commerce said that taxation had reached its limit, that the burden of taxation was a crushing one and that no further taxation could be imposed. The people of Dublin North-West had said that already, very effectively.
The present Budget is merely a repetition of last year's Budget. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has increased the cost of living by increasing postage rates and charges for telephones and telegrams. That was done after the Taoiseach had said that the limit of taxation had been reached. A week ago ½d. per Ib. was put on sugar. These were new ways of introducing Budget Resolutions. The Minister for Industry and Commerce broadcast that further taxation would not be imposed—or words to that effect. At that time he must have known that he had given his consent to the increase in the price of sugar. There is no doubt about that.
The taxation of last year continues. The public, unfortunately, are bearing heavier burdens this year even than they did last year, because of the increase in unemployment. I should like to speak of nothing else but unemployment. A few months ago I said here that in every house in the City of Dublin, in Dublin North-West at any rate, there was either a husband or a son or a daughter unemployed. I am prepared to give proof of that fact. Boys and girls are leaving school and there is nowhere for them to go, unless they emigrate. Young girls, and especially young boys, are not wanted in other countries unless they have a skilled trade. The countries of the world are looking for skilled men and they are getting them in Ireland, particularly in Dublin.
Because the Government failed to use their influence in other countries, steel could not be obtained for the purpose of building ships in Ireland. Within the last year £537,000 went out of this country for ships that couldhave been built at home if the Government had got the steel for the purpose. The shipworkers from Dublin Docks went after the work and got some of it. It meant keeping two homes and living on half their wages. They are gallant men who are prepared to follow the work rather than draw the dole of 40/- or 45/- per week.
The cost of stamps, telephones, telegrams, wireless licences and sugar increased overnight.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce, on 6th March, said—column 2483 of the Official Debates:—
"Nobody is denying that the cost of living has gone up, that prices have risen. What has happened is, in my view, permanent."
When taxation has reached its limit, according to the Taoiseach, the Tanaiste says: "In my view it is permanent." There is little or no hope of the possibility of a reduction in the cost of living, although unemployment is increasing. Men who were drawing £7, £8 and £9 a week a 12 months ago are now drawing unemployment benefit of 40/- or 50/- per week. Prices are still rising. Yet these men are down to one-fourth of their income.
This week I asked the Minister a question as to whether he could hold out any prospect of an early increase in unemployment benefits or unemployment assistance. The Minister gave the shortest and most abrupt answer I ever heard. He said "No" and then sat down. There is no intention whatsoever of giving any increase in these benefits in order to compensate for loss of employment or for the rise in the cost of living.
Take the position of those on small wages and fixed pensions—Civil Service pensions, Garda pensions, the pensions of men who served 25 years in the Army and the I.R.A. Take the case of the civil servant who gave loyal and faithful service to the country, who went out, say, six years ago, on a pension of £200 per year. The value of that pension is reduced now, according to the experts, to £89. A civil servant who went out on a pension of £200 a few years ago after his long and faithful service, owing to the depreciationof money, has the value of his pension reduced to between £80 and £90 a year. Some people say £82 and others £84. Some people say that the value of the £ is now 8/9 and others 8/11. So far we have not got a definite figure as to the exact value of the £ to-day. Army pensioners, I.R.A. pensioners, Post Office pensioners, D.M.P. pensioners, Garda pensioners, teacher pensioners who went out when the cost of living was not so high as it is to-day got pensions to enable them to procure the necessaries of life and the value of money has now so depreciated that it does not procure for them half of what we thought it would procure.
The Government, out of the funds at their disposal, should give everybody a reasonably fair chance of meeting the continued high cost of living. Last year certain Deputies voted for an increase in the price of the loaf by voting for the withdrawal of the food subsidies and on the same day they voted to relieve the dance-hall proprietors of taxation amounting to £140,000 a year. The loaf went up from 6d. to 9d. and the dance-hall proprietors got relief to the extent of £140,000.
Comment on this
Emigration is at the rate of 100 a week at present from the City of Dublin alone. I am told that the number emigrating is well over 10,000 a year. Anybody over 40 years of age is not wanted by the agents who are seeking workers here. That means that all our young people are going away to find employment in other countries. In my young days I used to hear the song: I'm off to Philadelphia in the Morning.It is not to Philadelphia they are going to now; they have discovered Great Britain. But conditions are settling down in Great Britain and those who emigrated three, four or five years ago are now coming home because local labour is available in Great Britain and our people find that on the reduced wages with no overtime they cannot support themselves over there and their families at home. Therefore they arecoming home. That is one of the reasons why I say that the problem of unemployment is more urgent than anything we have been discussing for the last week or two. I have not access and never had any access to Government files. I am not an economist and I have not got the financial ability to say that I know what can be done. But that is what Ministers and Governments are for.
Comment on this
There are expert men in the Government and they have most expert men to advise them. They ought to have the courage to accept that advice and provide employment for all our people. Most Deputies received about a week ago a copy of a letter which was sent to the Minister for Finance by the whiskey industry in this country. The whiskey industry never got a subsidy from the Government or never asked for one; they were always able to carry on themselves and prosper. The tone of that letter was that the whiskey industry which was giving so much employment was being crushed out. The distillers complain that they are getting no chance from this Government. I am prepared to give this Government and the previous Government credit for all the things they did in the way of building up industry. The last speaker made some disparaging references to Deputy McGilligan. Deputy McGilligan was the man who was responsible for the establishment of the first sugar factory in this country and for bringing in the Shannon scheme. We would not be talking about electrification for the towns and villages of this country if it were not for the work he did at that period.
Comment on this
Every time you see an electric lamp lighting in any part of the country now you can say: "That is McGilligan's light". I remember when the Shannon scheme was introduced commenting severely on Deputy McGilligan's attitude in taking over the Dublin electricity supply and notgiving sufficient compensation. That was my quarrel with him at the time. When people speak disparagingly of him it is only right that we should remember that it took men of imagination like him to do those things in those days. As I say, every time electricity was introduced into a new area it was called "McGilligan's light".
Yesterday the Minister for Social Welfare said that he was not prepared to give any increase to those drawing unemployment benefit. Something must be done immediately to ease the lot of these people. A very large number of these people through no fault of their own are living in condemned tenement houses which are the heirlooms of the years gone by as no building schemes were started until our own Government got going. All our Governments have done exceptionally good work so far as housing is concerned. We send these people five miles outside the city to live. Some of them are unemployed. They are all paying a much higher rent than they did when they were living in the city proper. Their bus fares have doubled within the last two years. The cost of living has increased enormously. If the unemployed have to come into the city to sign on at the labour exchange for unemployment assistance they have to pay an exorbitant bus fare in order to collect the miserable amount of money to which they are entitled.
What has brought about the present condition? During the inter-Party Government regime we had apparently a very prosperous people.
Comment on this
The people spent money. They bought clothing and footwear and they thereby provided work for our clothing factories and our boot and shoe manufacturers. Suddenly for some reason, somebody thought it was time to get the inter-Party Government out and a campaign of gloomy speeches started. The people were told the clouds were gathering. A depression set in and, as a result of that depression, we are to-day concerned because of all our young men and girls who are emigrating to other countries to findwork and earn a living. The last speaker said that our young people across the water have lost their religion. That will not look well in print and I am sure he made the statement more in the heat of debate than anything else. It is not true to say that our young people who emigrate lose their religion. We must be fair to the splendid boys and girls who have gone away. Possibly one or two may lapse. Even if they do, I do not think that fact should be publicised. Has this Government, or any Government, paid sufficient attention to our emigrants, to the young people who leave our shores?
Comment on this
The Deputy is continuing to speak about the emigrants. The country has no jurisdiction over emigrants.
Comment on this
The last speaker rambled around every subject, where they worked and how they worked, and I merely want to draw attention to the conditions. Do we lose touch with them when they go away?
Comment on this
The conditions of emigrants when they leave this country are not relevant to this debate.
Comment on this
I will say no more, but I think we ought to pay more attention to them after they leave the country.
Comment on this
The Deputy has already said that and he should get away from the subject. It is not in order.
Comment on this
I will not press the point, but the last speaker drifted into every subject under the sun.
Comment on this
He went back to Thomas Davis. In passing, I want todraw attention to the fact that our Government is not paying sufficient attention to boys and girls who leave the country. They are only three or four hours' journey away but we wipe our hands completely of them. If they stayed at home they would be drawing unemployment assistance. I hope the Minister will do something for them. I know he takes an interest in all our people. I think the Government should provide decent employment for our people so that they will not have to emigrate to earn a living. There is a discounted group of unemployed in the City of Dublin at the moment. They are waiting anxiously for something to be done for them. I tried to get something done for them by way of relief work and the officials assured me that as soon as they get a relief grant they will be able to do something. I raised the matter here and I was told that there is £27,000 in the locker. We would spend £27,000 in three days.
Comment on this
I have relief schemes in mind involving the expenditure of £500,000 in the next six months in an effort to ease the situation. The permanent officials, all splendid men, tell me they will do this, that and the other when they get the money. I asked a question here about the money.
Comment on this
It is extraordinary that some speakers, like the last speaker and one or two others, can make long speeches and no one interrupts. For some reason when I stand up they just try to knock me down.
Comment on this
But they will not knock me down. I am speaking now for the thousands of unemployed in the City of Dublin who are trying to eke out an existence on a miserable dole. They have good hands; they are willing to work if they are given a chance. They had that chance when the inter-Party Government was in office. I favoured that system of government because it gave representation to everybody. The inter-Party Government gave us peace and prosperity for three and a half years. No one will stop me talking. This is my platform for the time being and people should try to help me to help the Government by supporting me instead of interrupting. Government Deputies say everything in the garden is lovely. Remember the schoolboy who whistled very loudly passing the graveyard? That is what the Government Deputies are doing now. You are saying everything in the garden is lovely.
Comment on this
I agree I should but it is difficult to keep within the rules of order when someone starts to interrupt.
Comment on this
The Government would be doing great work for the country if they could find a couple of million within the next week to help those who are unemployed. The workers should get a decent wage to meet the cost of living. If that cannot be given, then the Government should reduce the price of foodstuffs. A man with four or five children, drawing £2 10s. per week unemployment assistance, does not buy butter to-day. He has not seen butter for the last two years. He is living on tea, and bread and margarine three times a day. The unemployed do not know whether the butter is good or bad to-day because they are not able to buy it. I appealto the Minister to tackle the unemployment problem, without delay.
Comment on this
Having listened to many of the speeches on this Budget over the last seven or eight days I do not propose to imitate the other speakers by wandering and rambling around every aspect of our economic life. I propose to be brief and concise and I shall confine myself to the few points that are of interest. Last year I prefaced my Budget speech by saying that having heard the pros and cons for several days, I considered that the Budget had been flogged to death. This year it is going through a similar ordeal. If anyone had been flogged by the impositions of the Budget last year it was the plain, ordinary people throughout the country. In introducing this Budget a fortnight ago the Minister spoke at considerable lenght and in that long speech not one ray of hope was held out to the unfortunate taxpayers of the country by the Minister. It would appear from his statement that the taxpayers and the ratepayers must suffer on. As many of us here know, the taxpayers are bearing a load that many of them are incapable of standing up to. In Shakespearean parlance the Minister's speech was "much ado about nothing." We heard it for an hour and a half; we listened and we waited and hoped that at the end when he came to the serious part of his speech he would do something to obliterate the unhappy memories of last year.
We cannot shut our eyes to the fact that this year's Budget was a severe blow to the country. It is no pleasure to any Deputy in this House—whether he is on the Government side of the House or the Opposition side—to state here publicly that in the long history of this country and particularly since our own legislators took over we never had more unemployed in the country than we have at the present time. We must face up to that fact; it is sticking out the proverbial mile. I do not want to cash in on any difficulties which exist. I am sure no member of the Government side is happy or contented; it is a very serious problem forus who have been sent here to do our best for the people who honoured us with their support at various elections.
We are a small country as compared with other countries throughout the European and Asiatic continents. We are a people with a population of less than 3,000,000; yet after 30 years of self-government we find ourselves with the biggest list of unemployed we have ever had in that period. These facts are unpalatable and no one desires them. However, we must ask ourselves what is the cause of this? I do not want to get any political kudos out of it but it is my opinion that the taxes imposed on the ordinary people of this country last year were more than they could stand up to. The slashing of the food subsidies was responsible for the vast army of unemployed we have to-day for the simple reason that people who must pay wages to keep shop assistants, clerks and other workers in employment have found that, owing to the slackness that undoubtedly has taken place over the year or two, they are not able to give them an adequate wage to pay for the necessaries of life.
We hear many people here discussing the numbers of unemployed. I quote from the Industrial Analyses of the Live Registerof mid-March 1953, a Government sponsored monthly paper. In practically every one of the various avocations in industry there is a decrease in employment. One or two certainly have increased over the last year or two but, generally speaking, it is otherwise; in construction and maintenance of roads and bridges, there is a slackness. Everyone knows there is a considerable shrinkage in house building throughout the country; there is a general slackness in building, sugar manufacture and bacon curing; there is less employment on docks, harbours, piers and there is general slackness in hotels, restaurants, public houses, and so on.
It is not pleasant having to state that and none of us, I am sure, wants to make political capital out of it but when I hear people saying that the country was never better off in its history than it is at the present time,I find that very hard to believe. I do not want to speak from a political aspect; I want to speak as an ordinary businessman who has to make his living on the side of the street. I do not want to cash-in on the country's misfortune. We are living in a rather unfortunate age at the present time.
According to the various papers who commented on the Budget it is an "as you were" Budget, the same as last year. In my opinion, there was nothing left to tax. There was one time when the imposition of taxes was the duty solely of the Minister for Finance, but this year it was done in a rather gentle manner, if I can put it that way, by passing on to the shoulders of other Ministers some of the burdens that the Minister had to carry in former years. Some five or six months ago, coming up to November or December, the Minister for Local Government imposed rather heavy taxes on many articles that are necessary in everyday business life. We are all aware that very heavy taxation was imposed on commercial vehicles. We are also aware that the man who requires a motor car for his business or for any other purpose had to bear further increases, some of them pretty severe. In my own constituency the imposition of these very heavy taxes on lorries was responsible for putting some of the owners whom I know off the road.
We had also within the last three weeks or month the Estimate for Posts and Telegraphs in which the Minister of that particular Department imposed what you cannot deny were taxes, on postal services, telephones, telegrams, and so on. This is a further imposition on business. It may be a small increase; at the same time the impost was placed with a view to securing for the coffers of the country an extra £800,000. All those little pin pricks may seem small but they sink in deep and have the effect of hurting business people considerably.
We are living in a serious age, in a hard age for everybody. Everyone in the country is going through a pretty grim period. I do not want to stand up in this House and preach gloom and depression but I cannot blind myselfto the facts that I see around me every day, when I have men coming to me asking when all this is going to finish, these increases in this, that and the other. Every morning we take up the newspapers we expect to see some fresh impost placed on the ordinary people of the country. Last year the cost of money, the recession and the disturbance in the various trades all over the country was caused by the vicious Budget—I can describe it as nothing else—whose impositions fell hardest on people who are least able to stand up to them, perhaps than most of us. It is a very serious thing for a married man with £5 or £6 a week to find himself, due to the slashing of the subsidies, paying 4/2 for his butter instead of 2/10, finding his loaf of bread going up 10 or 15 per cent. from 6½d. to 9d. as I believe it did; sugar, which is an essential commodity for every Irish family, going up from 4½d. to 6½d. per lb. and having increased by another ½d. within the last three or four days as sanctioned by the Minister for Industry and Commerce; flour, a most necessary commodity in the ordinary Irish household, jumping up from 2/8 to 4/6 a stone; tea, petrol, postal rates, all increasing. When is it all going to end?
If taxation continues to soar at such a rate and there is no cessation in this vicious spiral, the day will come when the Government will not be able to get the taxes and the rates necessary to run the country. I realise that you cannot have governmental schemes without getting money but I feel that the Government has not a sufficient appreciation of the hardships which the ordinary man living in the country at present is undergoing. Life is becoming more difficult, as every one of us knows. It is all very fine to say that everything is rosy; everything is not rosy. Things have reached a serious stage throughout the country and it is the bounden duty of those of us who are in touch with the ordinary people to give expression here in this House to the views of these people. I come in contact every day of the week with people in my constituency and I know that many of them are put to the pin of their collar to make ends meet. Yetwe come here and talk in millions, as if money did not matter. We have got to realise that the further imposition of taxes on the ordinary people must stop and my voice will be heard on every occasion on which I can raise it in conveying that warning to the Government. I am just telling the Government that it has got to stop.
The Government, as far as I can see, are living beyond their means and are spending more than they are entitled to spend. I suggest to the Minister that we are spending large sums of money on schemes and on things that the people do not want. I do not want to mention these schemes seriatimbut I repeat that we are spending far too much money on schemes that the people do not want. I have heard other Deputies refer to Constellations and about doing away with the proposed transatlantic air services. I think that the abolition of some of these schemes was the best thing the inter-Party Government ever did. I consider that it would be farcical for this country to embark on such a scheme considering that many of the old-established lines are losing money or running these services at a loss. These big concerns do not operate air services across the Atlantic for pleasure. Their teeth are well worn; they are well up in all the fine points of business and commercial practice but if you read up the trading accounts and the balance sheets of some of these companies you will see that they are being run at a net loss. How can a small country like ours compete with these established services? I should be very glad to see an Irish air service if it were possible to have it but the undertaking is too big. We cannot afford all these luxuries, and a luxury it would be because we would not have much chance of competing with these other companies which are run on extremely efficient lines. I think it would be throwing away the taxpayers' money.
The present Fianna Fáil Government, plus the four or five Independents who keep them in office—I suppose I can put them in the same category—have always prided themselves on their solicitude for the poorersections of the community. At various elections in the South of Ireland for many years past it has always tickled me to hear the slogan: "Vote for Fianna Fáil, the poor man's Government." That cry must seem rather farcical now to some of those called upon to bear the heavy imposts inflicted by the present Government and who realise how difficult it is for the ordinary man to live. I do not want anybody's emotional chords to vibrate too much on hearing me speak in this way but it does seem rather ironical when we realise that those who are called upon to bear the heaviest burdens are the unfortunate lower-paid sections of our people.
In a speech which I made some five or six weeks ago in the debate on the Central Fund Bill—that would be a month or so before he introduced his Budget—I made a plea to the Minster that he should do something for the one section of our people or the one trade that has been hit harder than any other section—that is the licensed trade. I made that appeal to the Minister fortified by the knowledge that in the constituency which I represent many of those trying to make a living in the licensed trade have been almost crushed out of business by the severity of the taxes. I asked the Minister to do something for them especially, whatever about others. I had hoped that he would hearken to that appeal and I was very sorry to observe, when I heard him speak on the Budget, that he had done nothing for them. I read in one of to-day's papers—and I know that the remark applies equally to all parts of the country—that you can purchase licensed premises in Dublin for about 50 per cent. less than you could secure the same premises five or six years ago. There is no trade, if I might put it that way, that has been milked so dry by various Ministers as the licensed trade. I am not in the licensed business myself but I come in contact every day, in my wanderings around my constituency, with people who have to make their living in that trade and when I ask: "How is business?" the reply invariably is: "The licensed trade is a thing of the past". Every Deputy, irrespective ofwhat Party, realises that as well as I do.
I feel intensely for those people and I dislike intensely seeing a man's livelihood taken away from him. My opinion is that if something is not done for the licensed trade in this country very soon you will find that those engaged in that trade will be unable to meet their liabilities. That view has been confirmed in a letter which I received on my return to Leinster House this week from the director of one of the biggest distilleries in Ireland. He states:
"We enclose herewith a copy of a letter forwarded to the Minister for Finance by the Irish Potstill Distillers' Association.
We need hardly stress our grave anxiety at the damage being caused by the present excessive taxation to this old-established Irish industry which is so closely allied to the agricultural economy of the country.
In a wealthy country like the U.S.A., with a large rearmament programme, the relative whiskey duty up to 1951 was approximately 100/10 per proof gallon and a 16.7 per cent. increase of 16/10 per proof gallon (making a total of 117/8) had a disastrous effect on the trade in that country notwithstanding its great wealth.
Prior to the 1952 Budget, the whiskey duty in Ireland was 137/-per proof gallon and a 28.5 per cent. increase of 39/- brought the duty to the present fantastic figure of 176/-per proof gallon (nearly £3 per gallon higher than in America)."
That is the position in America which is one of the wealthiest—if not the wealthiest—countries in the world. We in poor Ireland have to pay £3 per proof gallon more than they do in America.
I have here another letter. Perhaps, it has not been quoted by the Minister but I intend to put it on the record to show that I have done my part on behalf of an old-established industry. This is a letter sent to the Minister for Finance, Department of Finance, Dublin, by the Irish Potstill Distillers'Association, Bow Street Distillery, Dublin, dated 8th May, 1953. It is as follows:—
"Dear Sir—I am directed by my association to convey to you their great disappointment and serious concern at your failure to alleviate the crippling rate of duty at present imposed on whiskey. Since you imposed an additional 39/- per proof gallon in April, 1952, there has been a fall in consumption of home-made spirits of over 200,000 proof gallons and a fall in revenue of all spirits of between £300,000 and £400,000.
My association feel bound to inform you that they cannot accept your statement made during your Budget speech on Wednesday that ‘the produce of the spirits duty last year was adversely affected by the fact that consumption had been met in part by using up stocks on hand rather than by withdrawing stocks from bond.' They desire to point out that in their opinion, based on an extensive and intimate knowledge of the trade in Ireland, this statement is not in accordance with the known facts.
My association, moreover, would like brought to your notice that it is their considered view that the higher rate of duty has permanently reduced consumption.
Great stress has been laid upon the importance of raising the volume of industrial production. Our industry would like to play its part but cannot do so if it is to be singled out for what amounts to persecution.
We must protest in the strongest terms against the unjust and shortsighted policy which burdens our old-established, self-supporting, native industry, and we would like to know if it is the policy of the Minister for Finance to increase the duty on whiskey on every occasion that he considers, rightly or wrongly, there is a prospect of fall in consumption in order to obtain revenue, quite regardless of the damage it may do to the industry."
That is from the Secretary of the Irish Potstill Distillers' Association and itis prefaced by a letter from one of the most reputable directors of an Irish distillery. This is a very serious matter. These men are not politicians. They do not have to play up or down to the gallery. They do not have to go on the hustings. They are businessmen who give a decent living to Irish workers but, as a result of the severity of the crushing taxes which, as they said in their letter, amount to persecution, people are being driven out of employment and many people who held good lucrative positions in such firms over the past 20 or 25 years have been put out of business.
That has a very serious effect in other ways. In my own constituency of East Cork, which is one of the best barley growing areas in Ireland, the contracts for barley this year have been cut by 50 per cent. That means that a man who grew ten or 15 acres of barley before has now to cut that acreage to half. That is a very serious matter as it will affect the monetary inflow for the support of his home and family. I am not advocating that anyone should take spirits. I enjoy a half one as well as any man here within reason but the matter to which I refer is a very serious one.
Comment on this
Last year, Deputy Cowan tried to encourage the poteen industry but we cannot even go ahead in regard to the legitimate stuff.
Comment on this
I am trying to impress upon the Minister the gravity of the situation in view of the serious statements from two of the most reputable firms in Ireland. If this serious situation continues there are bound to be repercussions in the agricultural industry in so far as barley growing is concerned. I do not want that to happen in my constituency. Contracts have been cut down by 50 per cent. this year. Much of the land in that area is suitable only for barley growing. Certain parts of it are not too suitable for wheat growing. Naturally, this is a very serious matter for many people.
As I said at the start, I do not intend rambling over the many points to which speakers have already referred. I have stressed a few realand, in my opinion, cogent points. It is necessary to impress on the Government the seriousness of the matter. I do not want to preach depression. There is no use in any businessman saying the country has gone burst. It has not. This is a very comfortable little country if Governments would get out of the habit of peering into the innermost recesses of the mind of a man who is engaged in trade.
There are many other points which I could mention, points in regard to valuations, but I do not want to go over them again, since I spoke about them before. In conclusion I would like to impress on the Government that they should ease somewhat the burden on many of the traders who have been hit so hard by the severe taxes of the 1951 Budget. Ireland belongs to us all whether we sit in the Opposition or in the Government. That does not make any difference. I never wanted to score political points. It makes me sick sometimes to hear nationality being spoken of on the Budget.
The Budget is a business. It is the business of the Minister for Finance, and bringing up what happened 150 or 200 years ago is completely extraneous. It has nothing at all to do with the Budget. The Budget is an ordinary trading account and balance sheet of the Government in relation to affairs during the preceding year and explores avenues to see where money can be got for the coming year. I think the time has come to call a halt to any more taxes. The people do not want any more taxes. As one who will be in the throes of an election, I sincerely hope that the people of East Cork, as well as those of Wicklow, will show they had just enough of the Government which is in power for the last two years. I say that in no disrespectful spirit, but the people have been severely hurt and they cannot live if you cripple them with further taxes. I would appeal to the Minister to think of the plain ordinary people and try to do something before he goes out of office very soon.
Comment on this
I wish to draw the attention of the Minister for Finance to a very important matter, to a reallycrying need. I refer to the need for a substantial increase in the capitation grant to secondary schools. The grants of £8 for junior students, that is up to and including the Inter Cert. examination, and £10 for seniors up to Leaving Cert., were fixed in 1929. If these were fair amounts to fix in 1929, surely they should be doubled at the present day. There has been no increase in spite of the devaluation of the £, the rise in outgoings of all sorts —repairs to buildings, new buildings, casual employees, such as charwomen and groundsmen, etc.—so that if the rate fixed in 1929 was a fair rate, as I think it was—it was not over-generous, but it was fair—surely, there should be now, considering all things, a very substantial increase given.
Secondary schools are privately owned. The Department does not contribute to their construction or repair. The great majority of them are in the hands of religious orders. When dealing with this matter, I am not speaking for any particular denomination or really for any particular type of secondary school.
Comment on this
Surely, that is a matter to be raised on the Estimate for the Department of Education.
Comment on this
With all respect, if the Chair can assure me that the Minister for Finance will not tie the hands of the Minister for Education——
Comment on this
The Deputy should know that on this Financial Motion there cannot be a discussion on the whole ambit of Government administration.
Comment on this
The motion before the House deals with taxation and the raising of revenue, not with administration.
Comment on this
I would make this appeal to the Minister for Finance that, if the money cannot be found within the present resources of the State and it is necessary to apply taxation to meet this very crying need, he should do so. There are about 60Catholic lay schools throughout the country.
Comment on this
I cannot allow the Deputy to proceed on that line. The matter that he is dealing with is one purely for the Department of Education.
Comment on this
I will not proceed with it now but I hope to take it up with the Minister for Education. I look upon it as a purely financial matter.
Comment on this
There are many financial matters that cannot be dealt with on this motion. Deputy Norton.
Mr. Norton rose.
Comment on this
The Chair has called on Deputy Norton. I would like to say a few words on this motion. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle promised that he would call on me.
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle or the Leas-Cheann Comhairle cannot promise. Deputies are called in the order in which they offer themselves. There is no preference given to any Party. Already, three members of the Clann na Talmhan Party have spoken on the motion.
Comment on this
The Chair cannot limit them to a day. The members of every Party get their due share of the time available, as far as the Chair can manage it.
Comment on this
This Budget affords the Dáil an opportunity of reviewing the policy of this Government during the past 12 months and at the same time of examining the direction in which the country is being asked to travel during the ensuing year. That being so, I propose to devote some time to an examination of the Government's record over the past 12 months with advertence to the circumstances in which it assumed office two years ago. No Government took office, with greater opportunities or greater possibilities than those which were available to this Government in 1951. We had for the first time, established politicalpeace in this country. The political strife—the acrimonious political strife—which was a feature of our national life from the establishment of this State had completely evaporated. The periodic executions, the internments and the general political unrest had been brought to an end by 1951, and the country was then entering on a period of political quietude such as it had never previously experienced.
In the economic field, the Government was presented with a situation such as this country had never previously experienced from the standpoint of the opportunities available to the Government. We then had a situation in which employment was rising, and rising rapidly. We had unemployment decreasing at a rate never previously experienced. In fact, our unemployment figures in 1951 were down to the lowest level that had operated in this State for many many years. The cost of living had been held relatively stable, notwithstanding many adverse international factors which tended to disturb the cost of living. Our industrial production was rising at a pace which afforded substantial scope for congratulation.
If proofs be needed of these assertions we can get them quite easily. The trade statistics show—taking industrial employment in what is described as the volume of production in transportable goods—that the index figure of production in 1947 was 119; in 1948, it increased to 130; in 1949, it jumped to 148; in 1950, it jumped to 168, and in June, 1951, it was 181. The latest figure on which I can lay hands is the figure for June, 1952. It shows that the figure had fallen from an index of 181 in June, 1951, to 163 in June, 1952.
So far as industrial employment in transportable goods was concerned, the statistics issued by the Central Statistics Office show that there were 133,000 persons employed in the production of these goods in December, 1951. That figure had fallen to 125,000 by December, 1952. I think that if the latest figures were available they would show that there was a still further fall, because our industrial production has continued to fall.
If one looks at the situation in respect to housing, and again quoting from the figures issued by the Central Statistics Office, which is under the Department of the Taoiseach, we find that there were 11,100 persons employed on local authority housing schemes in December, 1951. That figure had fallen to 8,600 by December, 1952. If the later figures were available I should say that they would show a still further diminution in the number of people employed on local authority housing schemes as well.
If we look at the broad figure of unemployment, we find that since May, 1951—since this month two years ago— the number of unemployed has increased by no less than 29,000. Even since last year's Budget, the number has risen by no less than 16,000. These increases have occurred, notwithstanding the very substantial increase in emigration which took place over this period and notwithstanding the recruitment of additional persons to the Army.
Let us examine the situation so far as the cost of living is concerned. Again, the official figures of the cost-of-living index show the enormous transformation that has taken place in a relatively short space of time. The index figure of all items comprising the cost-of-living index was 99 at mid-February, 1948. By mid-February, 1950, it was 100—an increase of one point. By mid-February, 1951, it was 103. What is the situation to-day? By mid-February, 1952, it had jumped from 103 to 114. Between February, 1952, and February, 1953, it jumped to 123. The net position, therefore, is that in mid-February, 1948, the index figure for the cost of living was 99. That figure was 103 in February, 1951. It is now 20 points up, the latest figure —for mid-February, 1953—being 123.
If we examine the situation regarding the increased prices for food, the position is equally revealing. In mid-February, 1948, the index figure for food was 97. By mid-February, 1951— after three years of inter-Party Government—it had increased one point, to 98. But since February, 1951, it has increased by 24 points to 122. Therefore, during the period of office of this Government, we have had a situationin which unemployment has increased by 29,000 and in which the cost of living has increased by no less than 20 per cent.—and even more than 20 per cent. so far as foodstuffs alone are concerned.
The situation to-day is that—thanks to last year's Budget and the increased burdens imposed by it on the people, together with the fact that last year's hardships are being continued by the Budget which we are now discussing— the purchasing power of the people has been crippled because of the high prices which they are compelled to pay for food. As a result of the substantial increase in the cost of foodstuffs —an increase of more than 20 per cent. —the people find that they have not sufficient money to purchase the barest necessaries of life, much less to be able to find a margin for the purchase of less essential commodities.
In these circumstances, is it any wonder that there has been a substantial recession in industry? The figures of declining production are available for anybody who is interested enough to examine them. As a result of the decline in industry and the recession in trade generally, our unemployment figures are mounting so that we can now say that we have a more serious unemployment situation to deal with than we have had for many and many a year.
Even the figures which I have quoted in respect of industrial production do not, in fact, give a full picture of the sag in industrial production in particular respects. Official figures show that the impact of the scarcity of money, consequent upon high prices, has been felt in some industries to an even greater extent than in others. Again, official figures show that production in furniture manufacture has fallen by 15 per cent.; the production of men's and boy's clothing has fallen by 12 per cent.; the production of boots and shoes has fallen by 14 per cent; the production of woollen and worsted manufactures has fallen by 16 per cent. and the production of vehicles has fallen by no less than 19 per cent. These are all serious figures—and not merely in themselves. They are an index of the fact that our whole economic position, consequent upon the Government'shandling of the situation, is now such that, unless effective measures are taken to grapple with it, we may be faced with a still more serious position in the months to come.
I looked up a Press cutting of a speech made by the present Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, at a luncheon given by the Publicity Club of Ireland. On the 12th October, 1951, the Tánaiste was reported as follows in the Irish Pressin reference to the economic position as he then saw it. He said that if we did not soon get to the position of maintaining our present standard of living, without drawing on reserves, then, sooner or later, we should have to pay for it. He said that whether it took the form of rising unemployment or increasing emigration, higher prices or higher taxation, it would represent the defeat of all our hopes for the future of this country. That situation looks as if it has now arrived. Since the Tánaiste made that speech we have had rising unemployment, increasing emigration, higher prices and higher taxation. The Tánaiste said in October, 1951, that if we did not do certain things we should pay for it in the future by these four evils. We have reached the stage now in which we are in the midst of and keeping company with the four evils which, the Tánaiste said, if they made their presence felt would represent the defeat of all our hopes for the future of this country. That is the economic position which the Tánaiste saw as likely to arise. Now it is present with us. We have a confession from the Tánaiste—by clear implication—that we have now arrived at a position in which all our hopes for the future of this country have been defeated. In the face even of that warning by the Tánaiste, there is no evidence whatever in the Budget speech that the Government realise the necessity to take effective steps to deal with a rapidly deteriorating economic position. What matter if the economic position were incapable of remedy, but the situation has been impacted upon us by the gloomy speeches made by Ministers, by the miserable prognostications of ruin andbankruptcy facing the country, that the country was “consuming too much” and must cut down its living standards—which means it must cut down also opportunities for employment in the production of goods.
The cumulative effect of all that has given us these four manifestations of which the Tánaiste warned the country when he spoke in the Publicity Club in October, 1951. Nobody will attempt to deny that there is serious slackness in every branch of industry. No one will attempt to deny that every shop in this country can tell its own sorry tale of falling sales, of a buyer's resistance produced by the fact that the people simply have not got the money to buy the goods which are in the shops. The shops in turn cannot take the products of the factories, because there is no demand for the goods they would normally be taking from the factories if there were a buoyancy in the demands of the people for those goods.
To-day we see over 82,000 persons trekking to the labour exchanges to get the inadequate benefits made available to them under the Social Welfare Act. The 82,000 people undertake that miserable trek each week looking for employment which they know is not there and every week adds to the grim total of the numbers who are losing employment and who are finding the employment exchange the only refuge—not a refuge where they can hope to get work but the only place they can get some income to sustain them in the trying ordeal through which they are passing as a result of the general recession in trade and industry.
Look at the situation we have reached in respect of housing. Nobody will deny that there has been a sag in housing, in the past 12 months in particular. That shows itself in our unemployment figures, as there are 6,000 more unemployed building and constructional workers to-day than there were 12 months ago. Everyone knows the reason for that. The Minister for Finance decided during the year, after maligning the creditworthiness of the country for 18 months, that he wouldask the people, against the background of his own malicious talk on the country's solvency, to lend him £20,000,000. As he said, in his own elegant phrase, he offered them 5 per cent. for the money because he did not want "to spoil the ship for a ha'porth of tar." As a result of the Minister's policy in offering 5 per cent. on a State loan, a much higher rate of interest than any local authority in Britain is borrowing at, we have reached the situation now in which anyone who wants to buy a house from a private builder has to pay 5 and 6 per cent. on the loan. As a result of such high interest charges being demanded, they are not able to face up to the responsibility involved in undertaking to repay those loans.
Any Deputy who is keenly interested in this matter—and I am sure Deputy Gallagher could supply starting information—has only to go to the building sites around this city, or around the City of Cork and ask the private builders what is their experience in the matter of selling houses. Every one of them will tell you that if they could get rid of the present vacant houses, lying there with no purchasers, they would clear out of private building altogether, as they know now that it is not easy—in fact, it is almost impossible—to sell houses if the repayment terms are 6 per cent, thanks to the dear money policy inaugurated by the Minister for Finance in his State loan of 5 per cent. during the year. Look at what the building figures show —6,000 more unemployed building and constructional workers last year, thanks to the dearer money policy of this Government.
In the City of Dublin alone, there are four times more unemployed building craftsmen than there were in July, 1951. I am quoting here from a trade union journal, the journal of an organisation which represents building trade workers. It uses this phrase:—
"It is safe to state that if to-day there are five craftsmen idle for each one who was idle in 1951, there are at least ten builders' labourers out of work at present for each one without a job two years ago."
Is not that a nice situation? That situation has been brought about largely through the sag in private building and the sag has been brought about by the inability of potential purchasers to pay the high interest rates demanded, either by the local authorities or the building societies. I do not blame the building societies. They have to borrow money from the banks and if the banks can get 5 per cent. on gilt-edged State loan, they are certainly not going to lend at less than 5 per cent. to a commercial building society. The Minister's policy of paying 5 per cent. on State loans has caused an additional 6,000 building and constructional workers to go to the employment exchanges, 6,000 who were in a job two years ago and had all the indications that they would remain in those jobs.
When the last Government was in office, so keen was the demand that you could not find a single building craftsman unemployed. They simply never went to the employment exchanges, there was no need for them to go as they were whipped up or were even being booked from job to job at that time. That is not the situation to-day. This trade union journal shows that there are five times more unemployed building craftsmen idle in Dublin than in July, 1951. Anyone who goes to the building sites around this city will find abundant testimony of the complete transformation in the building of private houses which has taken place, especially during the past 12 months, in consequence of the Government's dearer money policy.
We have been told by this Government, in some of the dreary and depressing speeches made over the past two years, that this country was eating too much, was consuming too much, that its standard of living was too high, and that we would have to get back to the situation of being a poor, distressful country—producing food for export, building up sterling assets in another country while our own people went without the commodities necessary to ensure a decent Irish life under concepts compatible with the Irish sense of human values. TheCentral Bank started the racket. The Central Bank attitude was that this country was enjoying too high a standard of living; that it had to cut down; that it was eating too much butter; that it should eat less and export the butter to Britain and build up in Britain reserves in the Bank of England, which would be used by the Bank of England at 1½ per cent., while we borrowed money to build our own houses at 6 per cent.
The Central Bank said at that time that there was too much employment available and that it was a dangerous situation because it tended to lift wages if there was a scarcity of workers, that the real remedy was to have a pool of unemployment and to keep it there as a challenge to the employed worker and the organised worker because so long as that pool of unemployment was there, it would act as a brake against the possibility that, because of a keen demand for workers, wages would tend to rise. We had from the Central Bank a recommendation that the large-scale schemes of public works should be eased off in order to get this pool of unemployment which would act as a brake on the possibility that wages would increase still further and we got the final piece of advice from the Central Bank that the food subsidies ought to be slashed because they were a concession to wages and in that respect incurred the displeasure of the Central Bank directors.
Look at what has happened in relation to these four items. That was the advice the Central Bank gave the Government. The Government said: "We do not propose to take that advice". Maybe they did not, but they have arrived at precisely the same situation. The Government have created a pool of unemployment of 82,000 people, a figure which would be much larger were it not for the fact that there is an Employment Period Order current at the moment which has brought down the number. The actual figure is nearer 100,000.
The Government has created a pool of unemployment and in respect of large-scale schemes of public works hasslashed to almost microscopic proportions the grants available under the Local Authorities (Works) Act and by its dearer money policy has prevented local authorities from undertaking large-scale schemes of public works because the rate of interest on borrowed money is now crippling. The Government have slashed the food subsidies which the Central Bank said were a concealed subsidy to wages. Look at these three situations now. Have the Government not done everything the Central Bank advised them to do? They may say they spurned that advice, but they arrived at precisely the same situation. Either they have done it on the advice of the Central Bank, or, thinking separately and independently, they decided to do what the Central Bank thought it was desirable to do.
We said when the Central Bank report was issued that if the Government took the advice of the Central Bank, certain things would happen. We said that the advice of the Central Bank was clearly the advice of people who wanted to see a deflationary régime inaugurated in this country, and that, if the Government took that advice, we would have mass unemployment, increased emigration, higher prices, a fall in production and a general economic depression. That was two years ago. Have we not arrived at that situation, the situation to which the Tánaiste referred at the Publicity Club luncheon? All that has been due to the fact that, whether they took the advice of the Central Bank or not, the Government have arrived at a situation in which all the advice tendered by the Central Bank has been implemented by the Government, either on the advice of the bank or as a result of their own deliberate policy.
We were told to eat less and to export more. We have now reached a situation which must be Gilbertian from the point of view of Irish economics. We get an announcement sprawled across the newspapers recently that it is an offence to eat Irish creamery butter in Dublin or BrayDid anyone ever imagine that we would reach a situation like that? Wecannot eat our own butter in Dublin or Bray—we have to get New Zealand butter. How, in the name of heavens, can we manage to develop our agricultural economy if we are to prevent our own people eating Irish butter? Can anybody imagine anything more ludicrous? Can anybody imagine the French Government saying that the French people could not eat French butter in Paris, that they must eat New Zealand, Australian or Irish butter? There have been less interesting comedies in the Abbey Theatre than that situation.
Comment on this
I thought the Deputy would be on my side. Does it not look like the economics of a madhouse to tell the the Irish people that they cannot eat Irish creamery butter in Dublin or Bray?
Comment on this
I think it is lunacy, not merely nonsense. That is the situation to which our agricultural industry has now deteriorated.
Comment on this
Nobody can look with equanimity, no matter what side of the House he sits on, at a situation in which a State Department issues a ukase that the Irish people cannot eatIrish butter in Dublin or Bray. The New Zealand butter has to be transported over 4,000 miles, but that is the palatable commodity which the Irish people in Dublin and Bray must eat. How are we ever to rejuvenate or reorganise our agricultural economy, or bring about any renaissance in our agricultural industry, on the economics of compelling our people in the capital city to refrain from eating their own butter?
Comment on this
A much more serious situation has probably arisen, thanks to the fact that the Government increased the price of butter from 2/10 to 4/2, in that less people are able to eat butter, whether Irish or New Zealand. The result, as Deputy McGrath must know, is that the margarine factories are doing a better trade than ever before. The Fianna Fáil Government has induced more Irish people to forsake Irish butter than any other Government in the history of the country. It has forced the Irish people off creamery butter and off country butter, and on to margarine, by the simple device of raising the price of butter from 2/10 to 4/2 per lb.
Comment on this
The Deputy is now happy that workers are engaged making margarine to supply to the people whom his Government have deprived of the old Irish privilege of eating creamery butter. That is a nice situation. That is one of the things that Fianna Fáil can chalk up to its credit at the next election—that they cut down the butter rations of the Irish people by the simple device of putting butter beyond their reach.