Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 3—General (Resumed).
Contributions 132–265 of 265. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When our Government took it over, going into the cold store meant that you had to wear a gas mask.
Comment on this
Deputy Murphy will resume his seat. Deputy Norton is in possession and must be allowed to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
After the last election we had a declaration from this Government of a 17-point programme. One statement in that programme declared it to be the policy of Fianna Fáil to maintain food subsidies, to control the prices of essential foodstuffs and the operation of an efficient system of price regulation for all necessary commodities. I wonder what has happened that point in the programme— to maintain the food subsidies. Look at what has happened since then. When that declaration was made butter was 2/8 per lb.; is is now 4/2 a lb.—for New Zealand butter, too. The loaf was then 6¼d.; it is now 9¼d. Tea was then 2/8 per lb.; it is now 5/-per lb. Sugar was 4½d.; it increased since to 6½d., and the Government have increased it by another halfpenny within the past few days without even referring the matter to the Prices Advisory Body. Flour has increased from 2/8 to 4/6 per stone. All this was done under a Government which declared that it was its policy to maintain food subsidies.
I think the Minister for Finance in his Budget speech made some reference to the fact that consistency was not regarded as a great virtue. Apparently it is not because, having declared that it was the Government's policy to maintain the food subsidies, the Government slashed food subsidies to such an extent that the people now are not able to buy the same quantities of food as they could buy before this Government came into office.
Comment on this
So far as the food subsidies were concerned I approved of the food subsidies but I did not approve ofthe taxation on cigarettes, tobacco, cinema seats and liquor which was imposed at that time by the Government because I felt it was not necessary. So unnecessary was it that one of the first acts of the inter-Party Government was to repeal those penal taxes and put back £6,000,000 per year into the pockets of the people.
Comment on this
I am awfully sorry that I should cause so much discord in this House by making reference to these basic and unchallengeable truths. They are unpalatable. They will be made more unpalatable during the by-elections or the general election if that succeeds the by-elections. I know it is difficult for Deputies on the other side to sit and listen to these things. Deputy McGrath and Deputy Colley did not draft this 17-point programme. No doubt, they cheered when they read that it was the policy of Fianna Fáil to maintain food subsidies. I can understand the internal disorder that took place when, in face of a declaration of that kind, the very same Government which wrote this, slashed all the food subsidies, after promising to maintain them.
I want to get back to this vicious philosophy which is being offered to the Irish people as a remedy for their economic ills. We are told we are eating too much and consuming too much and that we ought to do with less, not to import so much, to export the butter and the other commodities which we are consuming and to build up sterling assets in Britain so as to enable the British to use our money at 1½ per cent. for the development of her Empire or the suppression of troublesome natives in parts of her Colonial Empire while the Cork Corporation and the Dublin Corporation have to pay more than 5 per cent. for any money they need for house building.
Comment on this
Only because the Deputy is the Lord Mayor. Otherwise I think it is all right, but I do not think he can annihilate it in one year of office. This policy of advising our people to create sterling assets in Britain is the most short-sighted policy that any country could be guilty of. I know that in high places, not far from this building, there are people who have the mentality that the only safe place for Irish money is the Bank of England. They think that, not only must we be anchored from the standpoint of parity with British currency, but that the safest place for Irish money is to deposit it in the Bank of England.
Comment on this
I do not like that either, but it is not nearly as serious as anchoring our pound to the British pound. Of course, we have this ludicrous position in this country that before an Irish bank can issue an Irish pound note it has to get a British pound note and deposit the British pound note with the Central Bank. Only then can it issue an Irish pound note.
Comment on this
Before an Irish Bank or the Central Bank can issue money it has to buy British securities, which is what Britain owes, not what Britain has, and hold these against any moneys issued by the Central Bank. There is not another country in the world that does that. There is not another country in the world that would tolerate that lunatic fiscal system that we practise here with enduring and magnificent reverence. That policy represents a frustration of all that our people ever hoped to achieve. I do not believe that the safest place for Irish money is the British bank. I believe that the safest place for Irishmoney is Irish land, Irish houses, Irish factories.
Comment on this
We did. Your complaint is that we repatriated too much of it. We were using it up, you said. Deputy McGrath's view is like the view of the Minister for Finance and like the view of the Central Bank——
Comment on this
——that this country will lose its lifeline unless it keeps the Bank of England well stocked with Irish external investments.
Comment on this
You have a very deep hankering after maintaining the economic and fiscal lifeline. What about the political lifeline?
Comment on this
In any case, this will not be questioned: The whole policy of investing our money in sterling assets has given us certain basic problems. It has given us the problem that our land is starved through want of capital. It has given us the problem that our industrial situation has not been exploited to the fullest, that we are still a relatively undeveloped country. Instead of using our money to develop and expand Irish agriculture and Irish industry, we are content to follow the investment policy of sending our badly needed money to Britain for 1½ per cent. interest instead of utilising that money to capitaliseIrish land, Irish industry and any other form of activity that would mean wider opportunities for employment here and greater wealth for the Irish nation.
Not only has that policy given us an inadequate industrial and agricultural development; it has given us mass unemployment, mass emigration. Emigration is now taking a greater toll of national life than tuberculosis and cancer together. These two ravaging diseases are not denuding the country of its population nearly as seriously as the mass emigration of our young manhood and womanhood is denuding it. There appears to be no end to this stream of humanity pouring out every day in the week because they cannot get employment here.
Comment on this
You have been sitting on it for the past two years. It does not seem as if you are terribly anxious to get it now with the tidal wave of humanity which is going to Britain at present. I want somebody who speaks for the Government to tell us what is the Government's policy for dealing with this economic situation. Somebody who has got a recipe for these difficulties ought to tell us what is the Government's policy. Are we to continue the policy of having 82,000 people unemployed? The biggest industry in this country at present is unemployment. There are 82,000 people looking for employment which is not there. Are we to be content with continually increasing emigration and to do nothing in face of the obvious trade recession which is apparent to all of us? Is it the Government's policy to drift and drift, to let these three evils continue to rot the whole basis on which our economy rests?
We are entitled to ask if the employment exchange is the only hope the Government can offer this year and next year for the idle men and women who cannot get work, with the emigrant ship the only alternative to the employment exchange. We are entitled to answers to these questionsbecause they intimately affect not merely the domestic life of our people but the whole of the national economy as well. One thing is certain, that everybody concerned with preserving the nation, everybody anxious to promote the national well-being must recognise that the present situation cannot continue without appalling and irreparable consequences to our whole economy, because if these serious problems are not dealt with, then the very existence of the Irish nation is at stake. If the present situation is allowed to continue, in my view it can only end in national decay and the frustration of all our hopes, as the Tánaiste referred to it in a recent speech.
I am sure even Fianna Fáil Deputies must have noticed a very substantial alteration in the Fianna Fáil policy in these fields to-day as compared with 20 years ago. Then we were told that Fianna Fáil had a plan for the provision of work and that every idle man and woman would get employment. Having looked at the plan, the Tánaiste stated that he was afraid that he would have to send to America to bring back the emigrants. Somebody told the present Minister for External Affairs that there was a large number of unemployed in this country and the answer was: "Well, should we not be glad to have them to do all the work that Fianna Fáil will make available for them?" These were the old salad days, but since then 500,000 people have left this country to take up employment in Great Britain and elsewhere because they could not find the work which they were promised then by Fianna Fáil. There is no sign of the work being there. The ships leaving this country and the trains crossing the Border are carrying their human cargo of Irish men and women away to seek the work which is not available for them here, notwithstanding the rosy promises of Fianna Fáil in other days.
In a recent discussion on his Estimate, the Taoiseach was asked what was the Government's policy for the relief of unemployment. The Taoiseach had no policy. He admitted that the Government could do nothing about the matter and, of course, the 82,000 unemployed lining up at the employmentexchanges each week are a living proof of the fact that the Government have no policy for dealing with the serious question of unemployment. Either of two things can happen. We want to get from the Government a declaration that they are going to deal with this problem or the Government should get out of office and let somebody else deal with it. This Government do not command the confidence of the Irish people. They were never elected by the Irish people. Whatever fragment of confidence they had from the people two years ago has by now evaporated because of the manner in which they have dealt with the nation's problems for the past two years. Our people have certainly paid a very high price for the luxury of having a Fianna Fáil Government for the past two years.
There are three main achievements for which nobody will deny the Government credit. They have increased prices to a level never previously experienced here. They have brought unemployment to an all-time high level. Under Fianna Fáil there are more Irish going to Great Britain than ever went at any time for the past 30 years. These are the three achievements of this Government. Everybody knows what contribution the people have made in human suffering because of the manner in which the Government dealt with these vital problems. This 13,000 word Budget which we had from the Minister merely perpetuates last year's vicious hardships on the people. It provides no solution for our three main problems of unemployment, emigration and high prices. It offers the people no solution for the problems of underdeveloped land and inadequate development of our industrial possibilities.
This Government which is so bankrupt in policy has one honourable course open to it. It is maintained in office to-day by a few so-called Independents who are afraid to go before the people and ask them to express judgment on their activities or inactivities during the past two years. If democratic Government is not to be a travesty of what real democracy should be, then this Government, having broken every pledge made to the electorate two years ago, havingshown no capacity to deal with the problems of the people, having treated unfairly and unjustly many sections of the people, ought to go before the electorate and ask them to pass judgment on the manner in which it has conducted the nation's affairs for the past two years. The people want a chance to express their views on this Budget and on last year's Budget. They want a chance to express their view on many other social and economic problems which confront the country.
This Government have admitted that they have no remedy for these serious problems. The obvious thing for them to do, therefore, is to give the people an opportunity of saying whether they want to continue in office a Government which they never elected or whether they want to hand over responsibility for the nation's affairs to a Government which will deal with these problems much more courageously and much more competently than the present Government and deal with the problems from the standpoint of removing the vicious hardships imposed by last year's Budget and continued this year.
Comment on this
This debate is about to come to a close and I think I am correct in saying that it has been one of the longest debates on a Budget which has taken place in this House for a considerable time. Deputies on the Government side of the House have stated that the Opposition were disappointed because the Government did not find it necessary to impose any new taxes. I can assure the Minister and his Party colleagues that we are not disappointed because the Minister did not see fit to impose any extra taxation. Our disappointment arises from the fact that the Minister has seen fit to continue the same taxes as he imposed a year ago, despite the fact that he knows those taxes have resulted in chaos. Deputies on the Government Benches need not congratulate themselves on the fact that no new taxation is imposed in the Budget. Within the last few days the price of sugar has increased. Within the last few days stamps, telephone calls and telegrams have gone up. Taxes may not have been imposed directly by the Ministerfor Finance, but his colleagues, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, have imposed new taxation on the people.
Possibly the Minister felt a year ago that it was essential that the taxes he imposed then should be imposed. He alleged at the time that they were necessary to right the wrongs of his predecessors. He asserted that it was his intention to bring about stability. He indicated that the lot of the workers would in general be much better as a result of such stability. He has discovered now that that is not so. What are the results? The results have been enumerated here by several speakers. The position in regard to unemployment has been described. Emigration has been discussed at length. The trade recession, and so forth, has been dealt with exhaustively. In the light of the knowledge the Minister now has one would have expected him to reconsider the financial position this year, to make some reductions in taxation and to give some reliefs. Instead of that, we find now that the people will have to endure these hardships for another year.
One can well imagine what the results will be. Unemployment will increase still further. Emigration will increase. The sufferings and the hardships of our people will increase. There does not seem to be any real hope for the future considering the speeches made by the Minister's colleagues over the last few days. Darker clouds are gathering on the horizon. It seems futile appealing to the Minister and to his colleagues. Most of our appeals seem to be in vain. There is only one way in which to make the Minister mend his hand and that is by dissolving the present Dáil and asking the people for their decision on this Budget. We do not know what the result might be. Some of us who are here to-day might not come back again, but I have no doubt that, if the Government sees fit to go to the country within the next month or five weeks, they will meet with a severe check in relation to their financialpolicy and their economic policy which has grown out of the Budget of 1952.
A good deal has been said about emigration and unemployment by those Deputies who represent the provinces of Munster and Leinster, but it is the Deputies from Connaught and the western counties generally who have reason to feel really aggrieved in relation to this problem because the situation there is without parallel. Large numbers are unemployed. Many are emigrating. Craftsmen and others who had been employed on building operations can no longer find employment. One Government Deputy justified the slackness in the building trade at present by saying that the standstill is due to the fact that there is no longer any need for houses; the problem has been solved. That may be so in some areas but it is not true all over the country. There are towns in which the problem is very far from being solved. It is regrettable that our craftsmen should now have to go abroad to seek a livelihood. The fact that they have to go abroad is due in large measure to the curtailment of credit brought about by the Minister's acceptance of the Report of the Central Bank last year. That report is now showing its results in the fact that we have practically the number of unemployed that the drafters of that report wished us to have.
The Taoiseach said in the course of his contribution to this debate that the Government has done a fairly good job of work; I think those were his actual words. Can he honestly say that the Government has done a fairly good job of work in the last two years? In what direction? I have yet to hear the Taoiseach or his colleagues show us where the work has been done. It certainly has not been done in the field of employment or development. There may be some increase in agricultural production due solely to the activities of the inter-Party Government during its three and a half years in office. The increase is also due, as Deputy Blowick said it would be last year, to the fact that the consumer can no longer afford to pay for our own agricultural produce and in that way there is a greater surplus for export.
The Minister may claim credit for a reduction in the balance of payments through the medium of increased agricultural exports but the reduction from £60,000,000 to £9,000,000 is not due to Government policy. Deputy J.A. Costello said last year that the balance of payments would right itself in the course of time. It has righted itself to a certain extent but, as the Minister informed us in his Budget statement, he can give no guarantee that there will not be a reverse and he said we could not look forward to the total elimination of even the £9,000,000. It may again go to £18,000,000, to £22,000,000 or £30,000,000. The Minister cannot claim credit for this reduction from £60,000,000 to £9,000,000 because to a certain extent that reduction is due to the policy of the inter-Party Government, a policy which is only now showing results. The result of the inter-Party Administration would be much more noticeable were it not for the interference of the present Administration and the present Minister for Finance.
As I said, it is western Deputies who have reason to complain about emigration and unemployment. We who live on uneconomic holdings in the West of Ireland, under the shadow of constant unemployment and emigration over a period of years can see very little encouragement in this Budget or the last Budget with a view to easing emigration and reducing unemployment. I am convinced that the Undeveloped Areas Act which passed through this House a year or so ago deserves to be scrapped. It has not brought about the desired change or the desired results which we anticipated. The Government should now admit that it was nothing more than a piece of propaganda to keep the people down in the West of Ireland hoping that there was prosperity around the corner. It is still around the corner as far as the people in the West of Ireland are concerned and as far as the people in County Mayo are concerned it has not yet arrived. If we are to have this Budget and this Government for another year, and if we continue in the strain in which we are expected to continue according to theMinister's address, it will be a considerable distance from the corner.
It is rather regrettable to think that out of 66 pages the Minister did not see fit to devote a whole page to the principal industry in this country, namely, agriculture. He neither saw fit nor thought it wise to devote one page out of 66 to that important subject. He rambled along with what I call a well drafted Party speech trying to defend his conduct over the last 12 months and, on the whole, it contained very little of sound common sense. reference to the agricultural industry to the effect that taxation pressed lightly on the land was a clear indication of his outlook in that direction and the outlook of his colleagues in the Cabinet. If that is the only interest he has as far as the agricultural industry is concerned and as far as the small farmer is concerned, then we can well expect a darker and a gloomier period ahead. However, we are hoping that the year will not close before we put an end to this present Administration.
No matter what we may say there is little we can do to convince the Minister or his colleagues. The only means of disposing of this cruel burden which he has seen fit to impose on the people over a period of 12 months and intends it to continue, is by asking the people to decide for or against it. The people do not want it. Not only do we believe that they do not want it but we believe that it is not essential. This extra taxation he has imposed over the last 12 months and sees fit to continue is not necessary.
The Minister tells us that he intends to economise to the tune of £3,000,000 to £4,000,000. It is a wonder he did not tell us that a year ago. If we could economise this year to the extent of from £3,000,000 to £4,000,000, surely he could have done that last year; or is it that, as Deputy Costello, the Leader of the Fine Gael Party, has said, the Minister is securing or wrenching from the taxpayers this extra amount in a hidden form which he will use, perhaps, at a later date for other purposes?
The capital programme and the programmeof development which the Minister has submitted in his Budget speech is not sufficient to meet the present circumstances. The unemployment and emigration that exist at the present moment will be relieved but very little by the development envisaged in his financial report. Unless something more is done in the field of development, particularly in the West of Ireland, in relation to forestry, drainage, land reclamation and the migrating of tenants from the congested districts, then we can see a very gloomy future ahead of us. I find it hard to be obliged to repeat this because over a period of years since I first entered this House away back in 1943, in every debate in which I took part I have referred to the necessity for migrating tenants from the congested districts, to the development of forestry on a large scale, to the drainage of land and other schemes of that kind, as a means of meeting the situation that exists in the West of Ireland.
It is no use for the Minister to tell us about what is happening in the City of Dublin or in the City of Cork. We agree that they have their problems and that there are thousands of unemployed in these cities, but it is an acknowledged fact that there is too much centralisation in the Cities of Dublin and Cork at the present time and that these two cities, important as they are in their own way, receive consideration out of proportion to their importance. They are becoming top heavy for a country of this size, top heavy to the extent that the rural community will find it difficult to maintain them from the point of view of administration and all the other paraphernalia appertaining to the Cities of Dublin and Cork.
The large number of non-productive workers, not only in Dublin and Cork but elsewhere in the country, is a clear indication that eventually you will have a crash. Unless the rural towns like Castlebar, Kiltimagh, Ballina, Westport and other towns in the province of Connaught receive the attention and consideration of the Government we will be heading slowly but surelytowards that crash and we will find that the community will not put up with it much longer.
I think the Minister appreciates that situation as also does the Taoiseach when he says that taxation has reached a level at which no Government can find a reason for increasing it further. While the Taoiseach says that taxation has reached saturation level and ensures that the Minister does not impose further taxation in the Budget, we have the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the Minister for Industry and Commerce within less than 60 hours of the introduction of the Budget coming along and imposing extra taxation on the community.
It may be said that a halfpenny on the stamp does not mean a lot to people, say, in the West of Ireland. It does mean a lot to those who have sons and daughters away, to those who have most of their family away, to those who have to pay for telegrams, letters, telephone calls. To the person who has to pay an extra halfpenny on the lb. of sugar if means a lot. Therefore, the Minister cannot deny that he is still carrying on, in an indirect manner, wrenching excessive taxes from the public.
We hear the Deputies from the opposite side of the House boasting about what they are doing at the present moment. So many houses more were erected than were erected by the inter-Party Government. I accept that the Minister has a certain amount of honesty, and he must confess that many of the housing schemes that are on the verge of completion, or were completed in the past 12 months, were schemes initiated by his predecessors, the late Deputy Murphy and his colleague, Deputy Keyes, who played a very important part in the solution of the housing problem in rural, urban and city areas. I know that in some of the towns in my constituency people who were looking for houses before I was born had to wait for these houses until the inter-Party Government came into office. I want to make it clear that it was as a result of inter-Party policy these people were at length provided with houses. It wasnot as a result of Labour policy, Fine Gael policy, Clann na Poblachta policy, or Clann na Talmhan policy but as a result of the policy operated by the combination of these groups on this side of the House.
It is as a result of the policy which these Parties jointly put into effect that the people now enjoy these houses and the people are hoping that the inter-Party Government will return when the present Administration is removed from office. As a result of these groups coming together, slums in some of the towns I represent in Mayo, Swinford, Ballina, Castlebar and elsewhere, were removed. There are very few slums to be found in these towns now and such need as still exists for houses will in the near future be satisfied.
Deputies on the Government side would like to convey the impression that progress in the field of migration of tenants from congested districts was the result of the policy pursued by the present Administration.
Comment on this
I do not want to go into detail but it is necessary to make it clear that the present move in that direction is due to the activities of the inter-Party Government and to the fact that some 80,000 acres of land were acquired when Deputy Blowick functioned as Minister for Lands and initiated that policy. If the interest which the inter-Party Government took in the development of industry and agriculture and in the provision of employment by various schemes such as drainage, land rehabilitation and housing were taken by the present Administration, we would not be in the position in which we find ourselves to-day.
Spokesmen on behalf of the Government, and the Minister in his Budget speech, pointed out the facilities provided for the farming community in the way of cheap cash for the purchase of machinery, live stock, fertilisers, etc. There is no cheap cash at all. I think no greater insult can be offered to thefarming community than to say that cheap cash is available to them. The Minister knows well there is no cheap cash. He knows that unless you have a good substantial account in the bank, you will get no money from the Agricultural Credit Corporation, even if you had half the City of Dublin as guarantors.
Comment on this
I am not discussing the Agricultural Credit Corporation. I am referring to the Minister's statement on page 15 of his speech in which he said:—
"The Government have provided incentives by guaranteeing high prices for agricultural produce, by arranging markets, by draining, reclaiming and fertilising the land, by making credit available for the purchase of stock and machinery and by providing educational and advisory services."
Where is this credit available and at what interest rate? Would the Minister tell me how a farmer, with a valuation of £10, can afford to avail of this cheap credit? Do Fianna Fáil Deputies not know well, Deputy Moran, Deputy Seán Flanagan and Deputy Calleary from Mayo not know well that no cheap credit is available? Unless you have a substantial account in the bank you will get no money from the people who are supposed to be lending this money to farmers to enable them to purchase fertilisers, machinery, stock and all the other things essential to secure increased production. The Minister talks about the confidence the people have in the Government and, to justify that statement, he pointed out the way the people responded to his appeal when he asked them to provide £20,000,000 by way of national loan. Who amongst us would not subscribe to that loan, if we could afford to do so, at the fine rate of interest which was offered? Who amongst us would not withdraw money from the bank or other sources if we could afford it, so as to get thebenefit of this 5 per cent. interest? Does the Minister wish to convey that it was solely because of confidence in him and his Government that the people subscribed to that loan? If you make the rate of interest 5½ per cent. or 6 per cent. for the next loan, we shall all be rushing to subscribe, if we can afford it. It would even pay us to borrow money from the bank and offer it to the Minister on these conditions. The confidence of the people who subscribed was in the rate of interest you offered. That rate of interest has had the effect of increasing rates of interest for everybody else who is obliged to borrow money, whether it be for the building of houses, the purchase of machinery or live stock, or the stocking of your shelves if you happen to be a businessman.
The position at the present moment is that we are facing a crisis, a crisis deliberately brought about by the present Government and the Minister, in unemployment, in emigration and in the cost of living—a Government that got into office on the cry that their aim was to reduce the cost of living, a Government that got into office by convincing the people that they would ensure greater employment and greater stability, that the cost of living would not go up and that the subsidies would remain, a Government that got into office on various other guarantees and promises that they gave before the election. Bad and all as it was to renege on promises which they gave before the election, they reneged on promises which they gave shortly after election to the people.
In bringing my remarks to a close, I say that if there is any honesty, any sincerity in the present Government, if the Taoiseach is the Taoiseach of former years, if he is the man he was in 1932 and almost down to the present time I might say, he will now consult the people. I remember that if he thought for a moment at one time that his policy was questioned and that the people wished to remove him from office, he would have no hesitation in dissolving the Dáil. I remember being here in 1944 and again, I think, in 1948, when the Taoiseach had a majority of14, a majority which would have enabled him to carry into effect any programme which he wished to implement. When he was told that he no longer enjoyed the confidence of the people he dissolved the Dáil immediately. Now when he is treading on very delicate ground and he knows full well that the people are opposed to his policy and that there would not be a hope of his Party coming back as a Government, he is still holding back and trying to make believe that he has the support of the people, despite what we say here. The Minister knows that that is not so. For that reason the Minister or the Party Whip should approach the Taoiseach and tell him to go to the country to see how he stands with the people. If he does so, I am sure he will get a better answer than even the Opposition can give him from this side of the House.
Comment on this
Deputy Cafferky, who has just concluded, represents South Mayo, and he has said many things that I would have said had I preceded him in the debate. He has dealt with many of the matters with which I as one of the representatives from North Mayo would be dealing in the normal way. I want to say briefly that I listened to the opening speech of the Minister for Finance, the speech of the Taoiseach and the speeches of the members of the Government Party. They are trying to give this House and the country the impression that we are very fortunate that we are not facing in this year's Budget further increased taxation. Evidently they want this House and the people to believe that they are very well off and very fortunate in having such a Government as the Fianna Fáil Government and that they are not being pinched by taxation.
The truth, however, is that almost everything you could think of, almost every item you could mention has been taxed or has increased in price since the present Government, with the support of a few Independents, took office. On numerous occasions in this House, other Deputies have referred to the increase in the cost of living, the increase in the prices of butter, tea, sugar, flour, bread, and the increase inmotor taxation which hits very heavily at least one section of the community who can ill afford to pay—the taximen down the country and in the City of Dublin.
I know many taximen in my part of the country, in Ballina, Foxford, Belmullet, Ballycastle and other towns who, as a result of Government policy in increasing the tax on their vehicles, are unable to replace their motor cars and who are, in some instances, unable to pay the hire-purchase instalments due on their cars. Many of those cars that have now been taken into the garages are being taken up by hire-purchase companies for the reason that the people are no longer able to earn a livelihood. One can well picture the plight of the wives and children of the people in such circumstances.
There are other sections of the community—the ordinary working people in the various towns throughout the length and breadth of the country— who are hard hit. I know people in Ballina and many other towns who in some cases, that of young ladies, earn a weekly wage from 30/- to £2 per week. There are others—the majority —who work for about £3 15s. or £4 per week. All these had to pay the increased charges for butter, tea, sugar, flour and bread and for the other articles of food for human consumption without any corresponding increase in their rates of pay. I am sure that is the position in 95 per cent. of the cases. I am well aware that these people have gone through a very difficult time and that they are feeling the pinch. Many of them have told me that if they were afforded an opportunity to-morrow morning of voting against the present Government they would gladly avail of it. I invite the Government to dissolve Dáil Éireann and give the people an opportunity of passing judgment on their conduct since they took over office. Believe me if they do that they will get their answer.
The Minister in the course of his speech said that the tax pressed lightly on the land. That statement has already been referred to by members of my Party. I do not propose to deal with it again at any great lengthexcept to ask, as Deputies Dillon, Blowick and others have asked—where else does wealth come from except from the land and from those engaged in working on the land? The land is the principal source of wealth in this country. That fact is admitted by every sensible-minded person in this country and for the Minister to suggest to this House, or to the country, that taxation presses lightly on the land is stupid, nonsensical and typical of the Minister. I think that if the Fianna Fáil Government, who held office for such a long period, made up their minds years ago on the importance of the land in the economic sense the picture would be very different from what it is to-day.
I remember years ago, long before ever I entered this House, or long before I had a notion of ever entering it, Fianna Fáil politicians going from church gate to church gate, frothing from the mouth, telling the Irish people what they would do if only they were afforded an opportunity of doing so. Cumann na nGaedheal or Fine Gael were then in office and the Irish people decided to turn them out and put Fianna Fáil in. As I see it and as thousands of Irish people see it too, the promises made then were promises that were made to be broken and broken they were. The economic war—and I do not propose to deal at length at this stage with the merits or otherwise of the economic war—certainly had very adverse effects on our Irish farmers.
Comment on this
I do not propose, Sir, to deal with that at any great length but I feel that I am entitled to say that during that particular period of depression many of our Irish farmers were so impoverished that they have not got back on their feet yet. I say in all seriousness that, with the exception of the years of the inter-Party Government, the Fianna Fáil Government which was in control for a long period of years did very little—in fact, I might say that they did nothing—to help those farmers to get back on their feet.
We know that during the period of the emergency, when Britain could not get foodstuffs from other countries, she was glad to take them from this country. Shipping at that time was uncertain over long distances. It was costly, too, and Britain naturally realised that she was to a great extent dependent on this country for supplies. During that period, too, we got increased prices for the cattle, eggs and other agricultural produce that we had for export. The prosperity which followed those increases was not due to Government policy, but rather to the demand there was in Britain for all the agricultural produce that we could send to her.
Comment on this
The Deputy seems to be covering the whole field of agriculture. Many of the points that he is making could be made on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture.
Comment on this
I am anxious to impress on the House the importance of the agricultural industry. The Minister, in his Budget statement, could only afford a couple of lines to it. I should like to see the Government spending more and more money on the main industry of the country by affording technical advice to our farmers, by assisting them to produce more and thus help the nation in a way that it has not been helped during our whole period of native government. The subsidisation of fertilisers, the drainage of our land and particularly the drainage of the main arteries, such as the River Moy would, I believe, tend to encourage our farmers to produce more, and in turn would enable our people to get out of the plight in which they find themselves to-day.
Deputy Cafferky, has already referred to the question of emigration. In that regard, the people in Mayo and in the West, generally, seem to be the most unfortunate people in the whole Republic. All down through the years the young people have been emigrating from Achill, Erris, Ballycroy and other Irish-speaking areas. A lot of lip sympathy is being offered to the people in these areas. They were toldof the wonderful things that were to be done for them under the Undeveloped Areas Act, and of all the prosperity that the operation of that Act would bring to them. I have yet to see any signs of that prosperity in my constituency where a big percentage of the people are Irish speakers. All down through the years, thousands of our boys and girls have been, and still are, emigrating from these Irish-speaking districts to England and America in order to earn a livelihood for themselves and help those who remain at home.
As one who is engaged in a small business in a country village, I am aware that the bulk of the money coming into North Mayo comes from those emigrants. I often wonder what their plight would be if they could not emigrate. In my opinion, this Government would be better employed in trying to devise schemes to provide work that would enable those young people to remain at home than in lending millions of pounds, the savings of the Irish people, at a cheap rate of interest to a country that we were taught to hate by the Party opposite. It is an extraordinary position that if one wants to build a house, or borrow money for any purpose, one has to pay 5½ per cent. or 6 per cent. for it, while the Irish people's savings are lent to Great Britain at 3 or 3½ per cent. I well remember seeing on the walls slogans such as: "Burn everything that comes from England except her coal", but I can see now that these slogans did not mean much.
In my constituency of North Mayo we have a very considerable acreage of bog. I wonder whether or not I am wasting my time in trying to impress on the Minister and on the Government the importance of bog development there. In my native parish of Kilasser, in Erris and Ballycroy, we have large tracts of bog and many workers available there for their development. I should like to see the Government going ahead with a scheme of full-scale bog development to supply their own requirements in turf for the people living in the towns and for our turf generating electric stations.
I feel it my duty to impress on theMinister the importance of keeping alive in our Irish-speaking areas a little bit of the old Gaelic culture and as much of the native language as is left. If the Minister himself is not interested in that, I know that some members of his Party are.
Housing development is still an urgent need in parts of Mayo. It is regrettable that it was not carried out at a time when houses, with water and sewerage laid on, that are now costing £1,200, £1,500 or £1,800 could be built for £500 or £600.
Comment on this
The Deputy would be in order in discussing the question of housing generally, but he is not in order in going into details on the cost of housing in Mayo.
Comment on this
With respect, I have made only a brief reference to it. I have heard other Deputies rambling all over the place——
Comment on this
The Chair is endeavouring to bring the Deputy within the bounds of relevance so that he will not go rambling all over the place.
Comment on this
I appreciate that, Sir. I have not spoken for very long on that subject and I feel that I am entitled to refer to it. It is unfortunate that, after all their grandiose promises over the years, the Fianna Fáil Government did not implement them. It is a pity that the Fianna Fáil Government did not build houses for our people in cheaper times so that we should not now have the position in which they have to pay anything from £2 to £3 10s. a week. If the houses had been built during cheaper times the people would not have to pay so much for them.
When Fianna Fáil found out, as a result of the change of Governmentwhich took place in 1948, that there are people in this country who are more competent to govern than they, they pretended to waken up suddenly to the whole situation and they adopted an attitude of "Anything you can do I can do better". I have great sympathy for the ordinary working man to-day who earns £3 10s. or £4 a week and who, out of that wage, has to pay anything from £2 to £2 10s. per week in rent. He will have a very lean time.
This debate has lasted a very considerable time and I do not propose to hold up the House any longer except to say that I would welcome an opportunity of facing the people of this country. I should like to see the Government go before the people, who, in the final analysis, are the judges.
Comment on this
This is North Mayo speaking. I cannot say whether or not I shall be returned to this House again but, at any rate, I shall be quite satisfied to accept the verdict of the people. I am not speaking from selfish motives. If I were to take the selfish and the narrow view, I suppose I could say that I could be more profitably employed in my own little business at home than speaking in this House. However, if I should be a candidate in the future for election to this House I shall be quite prepared to accept the verdict of the people. It makes very little difference, after all, whether or not Tommy O'Hara comes back to this House: the important thing is the welfare of the people of this country. During my short period of public life I have endeavoured to do my very best for them. After two defeats, I was elected to this House. I was defeated twice because I refused to tell lies and to make promises which I knew I could not keep. Although I was slow about it, I was returned to this House.
Comment on this
This has been a most peculiar debate. Scarcely ever have we witnessed, on an important occasion of this sort, such a display of flitteringand phantom spirits on the part of the Opposition. For at least four-fifths of the debate, the front bench opposite was manned by what you might describe as midshipmen, cadets, or perhaps only lance corporals.
Comment on this
The big guns were absent. I understand they were in gestation, heavy with big thoughts. They have now delivered themselves and nothing remains in the Chamber, after all these speeches, except a somewhat offensive smell of damp squibs. Only two members of the Opposition addressed themselves to the Budget. One of them was Deputy Declan Costello who is, perhaps, the youngest member of the House and the other was Deputy Cosgrave. On the Labour Benches, I think we had speeches from Deputies Larkin, Kyne and Desmond—speeches which were relevant to the matter under discussion. The remainder of the pronouncements were full of sound and fury, signifying very little indeed. There was a rattling of old bones, a screeching of outworn shibboleths——
Comment on this
——a pretence that this year's Budget is last year's Budget. It is nothing of the sort. As I have said, this year's Budget marks the second stage in the economic recovery of this country—the second stage——
Comment on this
——of an attempt to put the public finances of this State on a sound basis, to give workers and employers alike conditions in which they can thrive and prosper.
I have said that Deputy Declan Costello's speech was one which addressed itself to the Budget. It was, however, a long and laboured thesis— one which will not stand an examination in the light of the actual facts— but on the whole, I think it was agallant attempt to justify the absurd contention of Deputy Costello, Senior, that the revenue for 1952-53 was underestimated by £3,000,000.
In the younger Deputy's speech we had a series of misdirected questions. We were asked why, if we anticipated that we should make economies this year and were prepared to budget on the basis that these economies would be realised, we did not take that line last year. We did not, for this reason. We found that the public administration of our Departments was left in such a state of confusion by the Coalition Government that it was scarcely possible for us to secure control over expenditure. When you have had a Government which has thrown over the doctrine of collective responsibility and in which each Minister is a satrap working for himself and according to his own whims and wishes, naturally it takes time to co-ordinate the activities of the various Departments and to try to get the public administration working efficiently as a unit. We had to take time. We required time in order that we might review the activities of all these Departments. We required time to see where economies could be made without causing economic dislocation, to see where extravagant expenditure existed —and there was extravagant expenditure under the Coalition: Deputy Dillon boasted of that when he told us that he had spent millions of dollars in a half-hour one afternoon—and to see where, as I said, it could be curbed and restricted. Therefore, we were not able last year to pledge ourselves to the public that we would secure economies.
One of the criticisms which was made against last year's Budget was that we had not made any allowance for overestimation. Deputy J.A. Costello, the Leader of the Opposition, was, I think, the spokesman who first directed that criticism against the Budget.
We said that in the state of the administration, as we found it, and having regard to the course and trend which had been set by the Coalition Government over their three years, itwould not be safe to allow anything for overestimation. Under the Coalition Government, faulty estimation was quite a common thing—and if necessary I will quote instances. The Minister for Finance came in here, I think, in the year 1949-50, and said that he was allowing the sum of £600,000 to cover Supplementary Estimates that might be introduced during the year, and when the year's Budget closed I think the amount required for Supplementary Estimates had swollen to something like £9,000,000. When you have that sort of trend and course set in regard to departmental expenditure, you cannot undertake, having regard to the difficulties which we experienced, and which every person anticipated they would experience in trying to regularise the procedure under which public money was being spent and in trying to put it into some sort of order and get it under control, you could not, I repeat, say definitely that there would be overestimation in last year's Budget. On the contrary, you were quite entitled to say that, having regard to past experience, it would not be safe to allow anything for overestimation.
Accordingly, when we were challenged on the ground that we were imposing unnecessary taxation because we had not allowed for overestimation, we said that we did not believe that we would be justified in making that allowance. The outcome of last year's Budget has justified us up to the hilt. We have been fully vindicated. We estimated last year that supply services, after deducting voted capital services, would require £97,761,000. In actual fact, the amount which had to be found for supply services, after deducting voted capital services, was £98,466,000. We had allowed £5,750,000 for Supplementary Estimates. In fact, the amount which we required, speaking in round figures, was £8.8 million. We had not allowed, by £3,250,000, sufficient to cover the Supplementary Estimates that were introduced. That is my answer to Deputy Declan Costello. We would not have been justified last year in allowing anything for overestimation.
We have now got control of the ship.There are no longer any mutinous or insubordinate members among the crew. We have not people like Deputy Dillon flinging millions away without consulting anybody. We have not a Minister for External Affairs who will walk in and intimidate the Taoiseach and compel him to reverse a decision which was taken by his own Minister for Finance in regard to the expenditure of Marshall Aid dollars. That is not the situation. This Government is working as a team. It realises, as the Taoiseach says, that in present circumstances, with our present productive capacity, in the existing condition of our economy, the limits of taxation have been reached. We are determined to bring the cost of the public services into line with the people's capacity to pay and, as I said on the Vote on Account, into line with the people's willingness to pay, which is just as important in any democratic State.
Deputy Declan Costello also asked me why I did not allow something last year for the buoyance of the revenue. I did not allow it, for the simple reason that, having regard to the task which we had to face, to the gap which we had to close between expenditure and revenue, there was bound to be, in the ordinary normal course of human nature, unwillingness on the part of the taxpayer to shoulder the increased burden. He would be bound to protect himself in the only way left to him, that is, by reducing his consumption of certain of those taxable commodities. The only thing on which we can be criticised is that we underestimated in regard to one taxable commodity the extent of the increase in consumer resistance to the increased price. In respect of all the other commodities we just about hit the mark and, in all the circumstances, I think that was a very creditable achievement.
This year in framing the Budget we have assumed—and I think the results will show that our assumption is justified—that certain of these taxes will show a return to their old resilience, that they will begin to pick up and to yield in greater measure than last year what we expected them to give. As I have already confessed and as Iinformed the House on the Budget, there was a short fall in tax revenue last year of £1.8 million. It was £1.8 million less than we anticipated. This year we hope to make up a very substantial part of that and I am glad to say that there are already some indications that these hopeful expectations of mine are likely to be fulfilled. The commodity which disappointed us last year was spirits of all kinds. As I have already told Dáil Éireann, there was a very marked gap between the revenue actually received by us and the revenue which we had hoped to receive from that particular source. But there has been a remarkable change in the position since the introduction of this year's Budget. In the case of homemade spirits, the average clearances over the four months January, February, March and April amounted to about 36,000 gallons. The House will be gratified to learn that, within eight days after the Budget—from the 7th May to the 15th May—the clearances of home made spirits from bond amounted to no less than 50,000 gallons.
Comment on this
I do not notice any increased intoxication. I think our people are as sober as they were and I do not think they have grown any more convivial. The explanation is very simple. There was a considerable amount of forestalling before the Budget of Deputy McGilligan in 1951; then again in the autumn of 1951, when there was a lot of talk about a Supplementary Budget; then again last year, before my Budget of 1952. These accumulated stocks have now been liquidated and they have now to be replenished in order, I may assume, to be re-liquidated in due course by the taxpaying citizens.
The experience is just as remarkable in regard to imported spirits. The average clearances per month for the first four months of this year were of the order of 6,400 gallons and from 1st May up to 16th May of this year, the clearances amounted to 11,000 gallons. I think that so far as spirit duties are concerned, we have got offto a good start and there is every reason to anticipate that, so far as that particular head of the revenue is concerned, we do not have to go around with any gloomy expectations that the experience of last year will be repeated.
Comment on this
If I saw two swallows on a bottle, I would stop drinking.
Deputy Declan Costello also asked me why defensive equipment was not borrowed for last year. My personal view is that if our defences had not been allowed to run down, if our Army were being properly maintained, the expenditure on defensive equipment ought to be borne year by year out of the revenue for the year in which it arises. I do not think that in order to defend our own liberties and our own property and to preserve them for our children, we have a right to pass on to posterity the burden that should rest on ourselves, but we have to adjust these principles and policies to the financial circumstances in which we find ourselves. Accordingly, in this year's Budget, I am taking special financial measures to deal with that problem, but when Deputy Declan Costello asks me why we did not borrow for defensive equipment last year, I shall have to say that in fact we had to borrow for it, because last year's Budget showed a deficit of £2,048,000 and the amount expended on defensive equipment last year was £1,700,000. We may, therefore, assume that this defensive equipment was in fact borrowed for.
Deputy Declan Costello then went on to allege that the Government had been thrown into a state of mental confusion—I think he said obfuscation —by its obsession with this balance of payments problem. That is a very unkind thing for a junior Deputy to say about a senior Deputy who is, in fact, his own colleague, because the first person to make a weighty public pronouncement with regard to this question of the balance of payments was the Coalition Minister for Finance who, in May, 1948, said:—
"It is impossible to view with equanimity a continued reduction in external assets on last year's scale. These assets can be consumed now only at the expense of a reduced standard of living for the future."
That statement was followed up, three months later, by no less a person than the then Taoiseach, Deputy J.A. Costello, who said in this House, at column 2146 of Volume 112 of the Dáil Debates:—
"The adverse trade balance has gone to an extent which must cause anybody who thinks about it for one moment or who looks at the figures the utmost alarm for our economic and financial stability."
It would seem that, long before I came to occupy a bench on this side, there were other responsible public men who were as concerned as we have been with this balance of payments problem, but who, perhaps because they were pulled this way and that by the divergent forces in the Coalition Government, could not make up their minds to deal with the problem and so put it on the long finger and left us a sorry inheritance.
It has been suggested that this problem is a problem of our own creation. I have already referred to what Deputy McGilligan said in his Budget speech of 1948—I am quoting now from the brochure issued by the Department of Finance in May, 1950, page 20, in which Deputy McGilligan is given as having used these words:—
"To sum up, our economic position. . . is urgently in need of improvement if we are to be able to meet the exigencies of the future and weather possible depressions without impairment of our living standards or loss of amenities and comforts now regarded as essential."
So that, even in 1950 and 1951, this question of the balance of payments was a matter of concern to our predecessors. In 1951, in his Budget speech, my predecessor used these words:—
"A full answer to the question whether as a nation we are livingbeyond our means depends on a consideration of our balance of payments, present and prospective. A deficit in the balance of payments is a means of adding to our current resources—a means open to us because we have been able to finance additional imports by drawing on our sterling assets and incurring dollar indebtedness. Deficits in the balance of payments cannot, however, be sustained for more than a short period; they involve an initial loss of purchasing power over imports owing to the depletion of external capital and the income derived from it."
I do not want to weary the House by traversing all the arguments used in this debate to justify the neglect which our predecessors manifested towards this very serious problem, but when I am told, as I was told by Deputy Cafferky and others, that there was no need to be alarmed about the balance of payments position because it would right itself, I must ask those who make that wild and foolish assertion: in what country in the world has a balance of payments problem so serious as that with which we were faced in 1950-51 been left to right itself? The British did not do it. The French have not done it. The Dutch people have not done it. Even the Swedes were forced to take measures to deal with this situation and they are, perhaps, one of the most stable economies in Europe and, of course, we know that from a social point of view their Government is among the most progressive.
It was not, however, the view of my predecessor that this problem could be left to look after itself because, again speaking in this House, on 2nd May, 1951, in that famous pre-election Budget which was so manifestly cooked, he said—I am quoting from Volume 125, column 1883:—
"The present position on external account is by no means satisfactory, and if it continues to develop unfavourably the application of corrective measures will be called for."
When Deputy McGilligan used those words, did he anticipate that the balance of payments position, if left toitself, would right itself of its own volition and automatically? Not at all. He warned the Dáil that if it continued to develop unfavourably the application of corrective measures would be called for.
As I told the House in opening this debate, the position did continue to develop unfavourably. The deficit on the balance of payments for 1950 was of the order of £30,000,000. It had risen to £61.6 million for 1951 and, notwithstanding the corrective measures which we began to take, even in the middle of 1951, when I spoke in the debate of last year, I pointed out that at the beginning of the year, as the trend was then, we had reason to believe that the deficit on the balance of payments would be of the order of £50,000,000. Quite obviously, we could not have allowed that position to continue and we did take these corrective measures which Deputy McGilligan foresaw would be necessary but which he had not the courage or, if you like, the political hardihood, to take. He was thinking rather more of his place in the Government than of the fate of the country.
Comment on this
I am devoting a great deal of attention to Deputy Declan Costello's speech because I think it merits it. Obviously, he had taken great pains to prepare it. He did at least try to put up a reasoned argument against the financial policy of the Government. Unfortunately, while the Deputy had been at great pains, I am sorry to say that in many cases he had got his facts wrong and you cannot make a speech which will stand examination unless your facts are sound. He alleged that there had been a decrease, absolutely and relatively, in imports of capital goods. I would like in a few brief words to examine that position.
In 1951, the value of producers' capital goods imported ready for use was £19,000,000. For the year, 1952, according to the best information available to me—these figures will besubject to correction and the final corrected version, I think, will appear in the issue of the Trade Journalin due course—the value of these capital goods had fallen to £17,000,000. A large part, however, of these capital goods consisted of imports of machinery of one kind and another, electrical machinery and machinery of that sort, in which there has been a marked decline in price over recent months. In any event, out of the total import in 1951, producers' capital goods represented 9.3 per cent. In 1952, however, producer's capital goods was responsible for 9.9 per cent. It may not appear very great but, at any rate, it is an increase—trying to make a mental calculation—of the order of about 6½ per cent. over the volume of the previous year.
The Deputy went on to allege—and this statement was repeated almost ad nauseamby most of the speakers from the Fine Gael Benches and the Labour Benches—that the reduction in the deficit had been represented largely by a reduction in consumers' goods of the order usually consumed by the working-class people. I would like to contradict that because the position is that while we have had a reduction of some substance in imports we have also, however, had a marked increase in exports—that is much more important than anything else—and the increase in exports has been responsible in almost as great a measure as the reduction in imports for the decrease in the adverse trade balance.
Let me try to go a little further into this and see what has been responsible for the reduction in imports. First of all, in 1951, we imported textiles of the order of £26.6 million. In 1952, the import of textiles was cut to £14.4 million—a reduction of £12.2 million. In 1951, one of the serious problems which confronted this Government when it took office, in June, 1951, was the fact that the textile trade of this country had come to a standstill, that there had been wholesale imports of duty-free textiles, textiles either in finished form, or textiles which could have been made in this country. There was also a very heavy import of wearing apparel. In 1951, that representedan import of £4,000,000. In 1952, we had cut that to £1.5 million and in consequence of the action which we took to reduce the import of textiles and the import of wearing apparel into this country, our textile factories and our clothing factories and our making-up factories are now working in some cases as many as two shifts a day. There is no unemployment in the textile trade now, no unemployment in the clothing industry. Our people are working now, making the things which our predecessors allowed to be imported into this country.
Comment on this
I will deal with that in due course. I am going to show you what happened in this country in relation to employment over the last nine months. In respect of coal, we imported £12.2 million worth in 1951. In 1952, that import was cut to £10.1 million worth—a decrease of £2.1 million worth of foreign fuel imported to this country. For that decrease we have two things to thank—the fact that British coal has become more readily available but, above all, the fact that we are producing very much more native fuel than we were in the year 1951 or in the year 1950. That does not look as if the policy which is being pursued by this Government has caused unemployment. In the same way with regard to sugar, we imported £3.7 million worth in 1951. In 1952, we had cut the import to £3.1 million worth. We did that because our farmers, despite the Fine Gael agitation to try and induce them not to grow beet last year, did produce and give us more beet than they did in the year before.
Comment on this
In respect to maize, because of the policy of the maize king, the former Minister for Agriculture, the gentleman who spent millions of dollars buying maize in 1950—in 1951 we had to take his cargoes— the value of maize imports in that year was £5.9 million. In 1952, the imports had been reduced to £4,500,000;that is £1.4 million worth of animal feeding stuffs, previously imported, was grown on our own land and supplied by our own farmers. Similarly in respect to wheat: the import of wheat in 1951 amounted to £9.1 million; in 1952 it was £8.7 million. This year I hope it will be even less. That is how we dealt with the balance of payments, by reinstituting and pursuing the old Fianna Fáil policy, that so long as Irish hands are idle nothing that can be made in this country and nothing that can be grown in this country will be imported into it.
On the Labour Benches an attempt has been made during the course of this Budget debate to show that labour conditions have been deteriorating for the past 12 months. Let me make this clear. You cannot try to accomplish a major economic change in any country without causing some amount of economic dislocation. If a Government has been pursuing a policy of reckless expenditure regardless of the consequences, regardless of the fact that it was dissipating the savings of the people, the capital of the country, and that it was involving the country in foreign indebtedness, naturally for the period this spree is going on there will be an artificial inflation of economic activity. But when you try to put the ship on an even keel, keep control of your economy, try to ensure that you will not be submerged in debt and try to maintain a position in which you can face and accept your responsibilities as an independent nation, then there is bound to be a certain amount of economic dislocation and inconvenience in the early stages when the new policy of self-reliance and self-dependence is being initiated.
Undoubtedly, during the end of 1951 and the beginning of 1952 we had what was described here as a recession in trade. That trade recession was partially due to the fact, as I have said, that the abnormal stocks which had been built up after Deputy Costello had found it was folly in 1950 to plan on the hypothesis of peace, were being liquidated. That recession was due in part to the fact that the Marshall Aid money was no longer flowing into this country, that we were no longerborrowing American dollars to create a fictitious appearance of prosperity here.
Now when we have got back to realities and the country is trying to live within its means and ordering its economy accordingly, the period of inconvenience is passing and I propose to give some facts to show that. Take, for instance, the average earnings of industrial workers per week. In March, 1950, the figure was 84/4 in December, 1950, it was 89/3 in March, 1951, it was 91/7 in December, 1951, it had risen to 100/5 in March, 1952, it had fallen to 97/5; in June it had risen to 99/6; in September it had risen to 103/4; and in December to 110/2.
Comment on this
I am coming to that. I am not asking the country to blink any facts. I am telling the whole truth. This is not a speech such as Deputy McGilligan would deliver; this is a speech in which the facts will be put to the country.
Comment on this
Certainly, including the cost-of-living index. The Deputy will get everything he is looking for, because it is only when the country is aware of the truth of the matter that the country will begin to realise the benefits that will inevitably flow to the community as a whole from the policy which the Government has initiated or restored.
Comment on this
We will now turn and try to assess the value of the real earnings of the workers engaged. Taking the year 1938 as the base year and making the index of real earnings that year 100, we get this situation: inMarch, 1950, the value of real earnings per worker was 106.8 as against a base of 100 in the year 1938; in June, 1950, it had fallen to 105.7; in September, 1950, it had risen to 109.6; in December, 1950, it had risen to 109.9. In June, 1951, when you were in your heyday, but when Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Finance was warning you he might have to take corrective measures, the index for real earnings was 109.7. It fell to 107.2 in September, 1951; it rose to 109.9 in December, 1951; it fell to 105.2 in March, 1952; it was 105.5 in June, 1952; in September, 1952, it was 103.7; and in December, 1952, it was 109.8. That is to say that the index for real earnings in December, 1952, was higher than it was in June, 1951. It will be higher still this year when the next figure is published.
I have been challenged about the number of persons engaged in employment.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary is constantly interrupting. Deputy O'Leary must understand that the Chair has very wide power under Standing Orders. The Chair is loathe to use that power but, if the Chair is forced to use it, it will be used.
Comment on this
We come now to the number of persons engaged in work. I want to put the full facts before the House and before the country because it is only when the country realises the number of employed it will see what we, in fact, have been able to do. In June, 1951, there were 133,731 persons —we will give the round figure of 133,700—engaged in employment and the average earnings of these workers per week was 95/7 and the index of average hours worked per week was 99.6, taking October, 1948, as base 100. That was in fact less than the hours worked in October, 1948, and they were not getting very much more money than they had been getting then. InJune, 1952, the number of persons engaged had fallen to 125,000 in round figures and the index of average hours worked per week was, in that case, 96.6; but in December, 1952, the number of persons engaged had risen to 128,855 and the index of average hours worked per week was 100.9, showing that following the unavoidable economic dislocation and inconvenience which the change from a wildly inflationary policy to a policy of stability had occasioned there was a continuous improvement in earnings, in the number of people employed and, what is more remarkable still, as compared with the average for the year 1950, the output per wage earner engaged had risen from 131.3 to 135.2 for the year 1952. We have been hearing a great deal about unemployment. Moreover the character of the unemployment registered has changed very greatly.
Comment on this
I intend to proceed with my speech. The Deputy can make another speech on another occasion.
Comment on this
The character of the live register has, as I was saying, changed very substantially during the last year and I will give four figures to show that change. The number of persons who were in receipt of unemployment benefit at 3rd January, 1953. amounted to 29,339. The number of persons, on the other hand, who were in receipt of unemployment assistance. or the dole as it is popularly and rather contemptuously called, was 46,631. Now the Social Welfare Act of 1952, which Deputy McGilligan has condemned here and also condemned a week or so ago in Cork— I hope the Labour Party liked his references to pauperisations—came into effect on the 5th January, 1953, and at once there was a very significant change in the composition of the live register. The number of people on the dole fell from 46,631 to 34,732 and the number of people in receipt of unemploymentbenefit jumped up in one week from 29,339 to 45,667. There was a decrease of approximately 12,000 in the number of persons who were in receipt of unemployment assistance, or the dole as it is called, and there was an increase of over 16,000 in the number of persons who were in receipt of unemployment benefit. Deputies will not tell me that quite suddenly in a week these changes took place in actual employed status. They did not. What happened was that, thanks to the extended provisions of the Social Welfare Act, a great number of persons who previously had been living on the dole, from hand to mouth under the Coalition Government, became entitled to unemployment benefit. In addition to that——
Comment on this
In addition to that, because of the greater ease with which unemployment benefit could be obtained, a greater number of people became entitled to it outside of those who were transferred from the unemployment assistance portion of the register to the unemployment insurance part of the register. But there is something more remarkable still than that. We have been hearing a great deal about emigration during the course of this debate. There has been a marked immigration into this country over the past four months.
Comment on this
There has been a marked immigration of returning Irishmen and that marked immigration, that marked return of those who were driven out by the Coalition because for three years they refrained from fulfilling their pledge——
Comment on this
——to put a Social Welfare Act on the Statute Book, is due to the fact that these returning Irishmen now find that conditions here are much better than they are in Great Britain to the extent that, I think, about 5,000 in the last fourmonths are on the employment register and are claiming employment benefit on the basis of insurance stamps on British insurance cards.
Comment on this
Is not that a rather remarkable thing? While the Opposition has been bemoaning the conditions which obtain in this country, and wailing about the opportunities for employment which another country offers, we find our own people coming back here, taking an advantage, which they had not got before, of the new social legislation which the Fianna Fáil Government, with the help of those who are really concerned about the social conditions of our people. have put on the Statute Book.
We can take it this way: at the very minimum and on a conservative estimate the live register now represents 10,000 people who did not leave this country, whose status under the Social Welfare Act has changed and who are now entitled either to social assistance or to social welfare and are taking advantage of that fact. There are about 5,000 others, more or less, who have returned to this country within the past four months in order to take advantage of the new social welfare legislation which this Government has enacted and which Deputy McGilligan, speaking presumably for Deputy Costello, Deputy Mulcahy and all the rest of them, has been criticising and attacking up and down the country during the past fortnight or three weeks, telling us that we were demoralising the country, that the country had become too material. I do not want to say too much, but Deputy McGilligan does not belong to a profession which is notorious for disdaining material gain.
Comment on this
As we are on this question of the conditions of the people perhaps I may refer to a speech which was made by Deputy Desmond. I shall refer to it only briefly at this stage. Deputy Desmond quoted from the National Nutrition Survey, Parttable 2A, which is the table giving the mean heights and weights of schoolboys in amalgamated town areas, classified by age and by occupational group of father. He pointed out what was undoubtedly a fact, that the children of the unemployed worker tend to be shorter by a couple of inches than the children of people who belong to other occupations, or who are employed, either as unskilled manual workers, or as skilled manual workers. The difference is not at all as great as Deputy Desmond pointed out. At the age of 13, I notice that the average mean height of a child of an unemployed worker is 55.9 inches, of an unskilled manual worker, it is 56.7 inches, and of a skilled manual worker it is 57 inches.
I will confess—and I suppose it is only natural—that I do not attach the same importance to height as Deputy Desmond does, but when he did refer to the National Nutrition Survey he might have conveyed a little more information to the House, because quite the most interesting thing about that survey, I think, is the statement which appears at paragraph 16, page 23. Do not forget this examination took place over the years 1946 to 1948:—
"Among all the children examined, the proportion in good nutritional state amounted to about 75 per cent. of the total, while those in poor nutritional state came to less than 2½ per cent."
I do not think there is any ground for complacency in those figures. It is regrettable that any of our children should be in a poor nutritional state, but circumstances and conditions being what they are and human nature being what it is there will undoubtedly be some percentage of children in any community whose nutritional state might be described as poor no matter how paternal the Government might be. In any event, having regard to the circumstances which existed over the period from 1939 to 1948, is there any other country in Europe which would not have been proud to say that only 2½ per cent. of its children of all ages were in a poor nutritional state? I do not think it reflects any great discredit on the Government and thepeople of this country that those conditions prevailed here, and there is no reason to believe—and the figures which I have given for average earnings substantiate it—that the conditions as they exist to-day are any worse than they were then.
I would like to come now to Deputy Blowick. The charge which Deputy Blowick levelled against this Government was that one of the reasons that we had been able to reduce the balance of payments deficit was that the present Government had denied to its people the right to purchase home-produced food from Irish farmers and had sent instead £20,000,000 worth and more of it across to England. I wonder how the Deputy who made that statement sat at the same Cabinet table, in the same Cabinet room, with Deputy Dillon, who was not merely going to drown the British in eggs but was going to sell them our cattle for £1 or £2 a head cheaper than he could get from any other buyer. There was no complaint then when Deputy Dillon went over to England. I do not think they took Deputy Blowick along on that occasion. Deputy Blowick did not object when Deputy Dillon took himself, his cigarette and his large hat over to Great Britain and acted as the playboy of the western world telling the British people he had come to drown them in eggs. There was no talk then about denying our people the right to purchase these eggs or cattle. Just let us look at the facts. Agricultural production last year was above the 1938 level and in that regard we do not have to thank Deputy Dillon for anything.
Comment on this
I am sure Deputy Dillon would take umbrage at what I am going to say—but I like to think Divine Providence had a hand in it.
Comment on this
Agricultural production was above the 1938 level. Gross agricultural output was 1.7 per cent. higher in 1952 than in 1951. The gross value in 1952 was £156.4 million as against £143.9 million in 1951. Theproportion of the gross agricultural output exported in 1951 was £29.6 per cent., that is to say, out of a gross agricultural production of £143.9 million we exported £42.6 million worth, leaving behind a remnant of agricultural produce to be consumed here to the value of £101.3 million. In 1952, on the other hand, as I have shown, the gross agricultural output was worth £156.4 million. We exported about £52.5 million worth of that, or 33.6 per cent.; and there was left behind to be consumed by our own people £103.85 million worth. Therefore, in 1951 our own people were able to consume their own agricultural produce to the value of only £101,300,000 worth, but in 1952 they were able to consume £103,850,000 worth. That is a substantial increase over the preceding year and it does not at all bear out the statement to which Deputy Blowick has committed himself, that we were able to increase our agricultural exports because we were denying them to our own people.
Comment on this
I am telling it to the people. I have something more to tell the people. Let us see where these agricultural exports were. The Deputy wants me to tell some things to the people. I have already told the Deputy that we have reduced our imports of maize. I have already told the Deputy. if he will listen to me, that we have reduced our imports of maize and wheat. Now I am going to show what we did with our land during that period and what we did to increase our exports. The export of store cattle in this country rose from £13.7 million in 1951 to £17,000,000 in 1952.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Sullivan is talking about the slaughter of calves. Will he tell me how he escaped?
Comment on this
The Minister must be allowed to make his statement without interruption. Deputies have had every opportunity of making theirs.
Comment on this
This is a serious occasion and I am trying to review the circumstances which have made it possible for us to restore the economy of the country to a comparatively sound condition. I was pointing out to the House that the value of store cattle exports rose from £13.7 million in 1951 to £17,000,000 in 1952. The export of beef and veal, fresh, chilled or frozen, rose from £4,000,000 in 1951 to £6,000,000 in 1952. That would be worth considering because, let us not forget that Deputy Dillon, when Minister for Agriculture, did not like this development at all. He was not very fond of the dead meat trade. One day or other, perhaps, that full story will be exposed. Then the value of tinned beef rose from £2.3 million in 1951 to £4.7 million in 1952. The exports of dead poultry went up from £4.0 million to £4.3 million. Fresh hen eggs went up from £2.6 million in 1951 to £3.2 million in 1952. Cake and cake mixtures increased from £1.1 million in 1951 to £2.2 million in 1952. Chocolate crumb rose from £4.1 million to £4.9 million, sweetened fat jumped from £.5 million in 1951 to ten times the figure, £5,000,000, in 1952.
Comment on this
Whatever it may be, is anyone here prepared, in the light of these figures, to try to tell me that the agricultural industry in this country is not in a flourishing condition to-day? Yet we have Deputy Norton coming along and making the statement that trade in every form was falling. These figures completely refute that statement of Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
There is something more than that. Last night, Deputy Morrissey made a very striking admission in the course of his speech. He said that, with the exception of the price for land, prices have fallen in this country. He went on to indicate that the price of land had increased, that it was fetching, according to him, a higher price than ever. Has anybody ever heard of the price of land rising in a depressed economy? It is true that Deputy Morrissey tried to qualify this statement by saying that everything else had fallen but the price of land, the basic source of wealth in this country——
Comment on this
——has not fallen. It has maintained itself and it is increasing. It is true, of course—and nobody wants to deny circumstances as they exist to-day—that there has been a noticeable falling-off in the demand for houses, if you like, for public houses also. That might be because people are saving more. There is every reason to believe that people are saving more and that they are not seeking to drown their sorrows or apprehensions as to what the country was going to come to if a Coalition Government were able to maintain itself in office any longer.
Comment on this
They now see that there is a future for this country and that there is something to be gained by trying to make provision for themselves and their children and they are saving. As against that, and I say it quite frankly, there has been a reduction in the amount of speculative building. We must remember that for this industry there is not an everlastingly expanding market, that there was built up, owing to the arrears in housing, a huge demand during the war years and latterly, that this demand is tending to exhaust itself and that, in regard to housing as in other things, those who are engaged in the industry must realise that in this country, as elsewhere, we are entering on a buyers' market and that they must adjust their profits and costsaccordingly. I have no doubt that if builders take a realistic view of the situation and convince themselves that people are not going now to rush in to buy houses at inflated prices, if they are prepared now to take a more modest profit, that the speculative house-building industry will revive itself.
Let me come back again to the significance of Deputy Morrissey's admission. As you know he is an auctioneer. Every man engaged in that occupation will reinforce and re-echo what he has said, that the price of laud in this country is, not only not declining, but is, in fact, appreciating.
Deputy Belton tried to ascribe the present slackness in corporation and public authority building in this country to the rise in interest rates. It is true that interest rates have risen and it is quite true that, in the discharge of my statutory obligation under the Local Loans Fund Act, I have increased the rate of interest to those who borrow from that fund, but I have also substantially raised the limits of cost upon which the subsidy will be paid and that has gone far, so far as local authority borrowing from the Local Loans Fund is concerned, to neutralise the nominal increase in the rates charged for advances from the fund.
In the case of Dublin and Cork, in which the hard core of our housing problem remains to be dealt with, the position has become even more favourable, because whereas in Dublin and in Cork the corporation's contributions per dwelling was previously of the order of £45.9 per dwelling, with the readjustment in subsidy limits which I have granted, that figure has been reduced to £43.2. Thus, the Government, having regard to the present rates at which the corporation can now borrow has, in fact, come substantially to the relief of the corporations of Dublin and Cork in increasing the subsidy limit. We are encouraging them and we intend to give them every encouragement to go ahead and seek a solution of the housing problem.
Last night we had a speech fromDeputy McGilligan, which I can only describe as most mischievous. The Deputy, of course, as we know, is lean with envy and sour with frustrated ambition. Last night he tried to make trouble between the Government and the public servants, between the Government and the teachers and between the Government and the Hierarchy. One does not want to speak of these things at length and it is not necessary to do so, but the relationship between Church and State will not be served and the cause of the Church in this country will not be served by politicians for their own Party purposes, trying to drag the Hierarchy of Ireland into the mire of political controversy and that has been the aim of the Fine Gael Party and the aim of the most prominent among them, Deputy McGilligan.
Comment on this
Last night Deputy McGilligan was loud in his praise of the higher civil servants, those men upon whom the main burden of organising the administration of this country and advising the Government falls. I would like Deputies to go and read Deputy McGilligan's references to those same civil servants last year and if that reference is not readily availaable to them, to read the statements which he made regarding them in Cork on Saturday, 9th May. Last night he was full of concern for them. We were denying them justice. We were not paying them everything that was due to them, but what had the Deputy to say about the same public officers when he was talking to a Fine Gael branch in Cork on May 9th? That was, of course, the occasion when Deputy Dr. O'Higgins wished that the 73 individuals belonging to the Fianna Fáil Party in this House should be hanged. Deputy McGilligan lectured the Fine Gael people on the fact that we were now on the road to becoming a secularist and materialist bureaucracy be cause we passed a Social Welfare Act— an Act to which I understood he was committed in 1951, but somehow or other they contrived to dissolve the Dáil rather than pass it. He then went on to say:—
"The real progress has been that up to the last year food was subsidised and then, when the bureaucrats thought that living was too good, subsidies were on certain things diminished. . ."
The plain implication of that statement is——
Comment on this
——that these higher civil servants for whom his heart was bleeding last night were the persons who were responsible for any action which the Government had taken in regard to food subsidies. It seems to me that the two statements are inconsistent but one does not expect a great deal of consistency from Deputy McGilligan.
Comment on this
Whatever you may say about Deputy MacEntee, he has been associated with more social legislation for the people than Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Mulcahy or Deputy Costello ever were. The Administrations of which Deputy MacEntee has been a member were the Administrations that first introduced the Widows and Orphans Pensions Act, Childrens Allowances Act, unemployment assistance, the Conditions of Employment Act, the Social Welfare Act——
Comment on this
Yes, and pensions for the employees and the manual workers of local authorities. These are all the things we did.
Comment on this
It is an honourable record and we have not made our people more servile or more materialistic by doing these things and by discharging the Christian duty of a Christian Government to its people— not one bit, but we have not had much support in doing these things from Deputy O'Leary and the others.
Comment on this
Last night when distributing these bouquets to the civil servants, Deputy McGilligan also took occasion—I hope the members of the Labour Party are listening to me—to describe the recent legislation passed by this House as contributing to the pauperisation of the people and that the Government had embarked on a deliberate policy of pauperising the people. It would be well, as we are going to have by-elections in the near future, for the Labour Party to make up their minds as to whether they endorse that statement and whether they believe that these Acts of progressive social legislation to which I have referred—widows' and orphans' pensions, children's allowances, the enlargement of social welfare, the institution of social Orders—are Acts and enactments to pauperise the people.
Is it pauperisation to make better provision for the health of our people and to provide for the proper care of mothers in childbirth? Do the members of the Labour Party subscribe to and endorse Deputy McGilligan's statement that these measures are pauperising the people? Deputy O'Leary may interrupt me in this House, but these are the things that are going to be asked of his candidates when they stand as allies of Deputy McGilligan and his Party at the coming by-elections.
Comment on this
Mind you, the people are not going to be fooled by any references to a servile State. They know the state of servility to which they have been reduced by the Fine Gael Party, under the name of Cumann na nGaedheal, that was in Government from 1922 to 1932. They remember the 15/- per week that was paid to workers. They remember that workers' wages were brought down when that Party was in untrammelled control in this country.
Comment on this
Last night also Deputy Kyne and Deputy Browne and, I am sorry to say, Deputy Desmond, whose speech in this House impressed me as that of a sincere and meditative Labour Deputy really concerned for the welfare of the people of this country, with Deputy McGilligan, joined in sneering at the provision we were making for national defence. He said we would be much better employed taking that money and paying it over to the public servants, to those bureaucrats at whom he was sneering and jibing when he was speaking in Cork. The issue which is raised, was raised by Deputy Kyne—I want to particularise these matters—and Deputies McGilligan and Browne is whether, instead of providing for the defence of this country, to make what provision we can out of our limited resources to ensure that the freedom we have won and inherited will not be lost to us, we should dissipate the resources of this State by borrowing to make better provision for our public servants.
The issue which is raised there is very clear. It is simply this, and, again, the Labour people will have to answer it: Is this State to exist for the benefit of the people and the nation, or is it to be run and administered for the benefit of those who are paid by the State? That is the issue. So far as I am concerned, and I am sure so far as my colleagues are concerned, we will put the interests of the nation and the interests of the defence of this nation above any other consideration. Apparently, that is not the line which is going to be taken by those who are angling for the votes of public officials and public officers. But it will be for the people to say whether the State is to be run and administered for the benefit of the people or for the benefit of the officers of the State; whether, having freed themselves from one set of exploiters, they are to have another set over them, with, if you like, puppets and the marionettes sitting on these benches and pretending to be the people's Government.
Deputy McGilligan also last night sneered at the success of the last national loan. That national loan, Iwant to repeat again, is outstanding as an example of the confidence which the honest, thrifty people have in the present Government. We had a larger number of subscribers among people of smaller means than had ever been secured before. The list was over-subscribed, something at least that did not occur in the case of Deputy McGilligan's last loan. He went on to compare it with an issue which had been made in Jamaica some time ago, and said that the amount of money which the Jamaicans wanted had been secured 20 times over, but he did not tell us where Jamacia secured this loan. It just happens that in yesterday morning's Timesthere appeared this paragraph:—
"Mr. Bustamante in London.
Talks on £30,000,000 Loan.
The Chief Minister of Jamaica, Mr. Bustamante, arrived in London by air from New York yesterday for talks with the Government concerning a loan of £30,000,000 for Jamaica.
When he arrived at London Airport he said:—
‘The growing threat of Communism in the Caribbean area is becoming really serious. There are 150,000 unemployed—we must have the loan to help them. In many cases economic conditions are dreadful.' He said he would ask the British Government to take the whole of their sugar production."
Mr. Bustamante, for whose financial acumen Deputy McGilligan was so full of praise, is going to ship the whole of the sugar production of Jamaica to London. I am sure Deputy Blowick would take strong exception to that if he happened to be in the same Cabinet as Mr. Bustamante.
In any event, let us see what this means. Deputy McGilligan praises a Prime Minister who goes abroad to borrow; he thinks, of course, that he is to be commended for the fact that a foreign lender is generally prepared to lend to a foreign borrower if he thinks the security is good enough. Apparently, it was the same sort of motivation that operated with theCoalition Cabinet in 1948 when they decided to reverse their previous decision and apply for the Marshall Aid loan with, of course, the same consequences. What happens is this: that out of the sweat and toil of the native people, whether they happen to be Irish or Jamaicans, the interest has to be paid to the foreign lender and the remission of that interest abroad naturally operates with a highly deflationary influence on the economy of the country. It does tend to produce unemployment and to produce hardship, and it does tend to lower the standard of living, and that is a continuing influence to which we have been condemned by the financial policy of our predecessors.
As I pointed out in the Budget statement last year, I had to find £577,000 to pay for one-half year's interest on the Marshall Aid loan. This year, we have to find just twice that, or almost £1,200,000, and not one penny piece of that money will be spent in this country. Now, if the Government were paying £1,200,000 out in interest to our own people we know that our own people would spend the money here. It would continue to remain within our monetary system; it would continue to flow through the veins, so to speak, of our economic body; it would help to make it healthy, strong and productive, but this Marshall Aid money is going to be extracted out of, and will disappear from, our monetary system. We will be to some extent in the position in which the Irish people were when the Government in 1923 or 1924 signed the secret agreement under which we were sending £5,000,000 a year to Great Britain. It will produce, though to a lesser degree, exactly the same type of economic reaction in this country as that secret agreement did, and the gentleman who was responsible for that financial transaction had the audacity to get up here and criticise the terms upon which the last national loan was issued.
It is well known that if you want to get a thing you have to pay for it. People do not for one moment believe that the economy of this country couldcontinue to run on a 3½ per cent. basis. They showed that by refusing to subscribe to the last loan issued by my predecessor. Since they realise that we are now trying to make ends meet, that you have got a Government which acts responsibly and does not enter into commitments which it does not expect it will be able to fulfil, you have the people coming along subscribing not merely to the last national loan but doing something more: subscribing in a much greater proportion than they ever did before to the Dublin Corporation loan. On the day before yesterday, they over-subscribed the 5 per cent. C.I.E. loan of £2,500,000. Does anyone want to tell me that under Deputy McGilligan's administration, and under the administration of Deputy Morrissey, they would get 2,500,000 pennies, let alone £2,500,000 for C.I.E.? We are getting it now because our people realise that a firm grip has been taken on the affairs of this State, that we are no longer allowing things to drift, and that we are prepared to face up to our responsibilities and, what is more, prepared to ask our people to face up to them with us.
Now, I have heard a lot of talk here about by-elections. It seems to me that it would be a salutary thing for those who are talking about by-elections to recall the by-elections which took place last year about this time. We had a Budget, a severe Budget but a Budget, however, which thinking people regarded as what was necessary. We went down to Deputy O'Hara's constituency in North Mayo and won the by-election there. We went to Deputy Kyne's constituency in Waterford and won the by-election there.
Comment on this
Undoubtedly we did not win it in Limerick but it will be agreed that two gains out of three is not a bad record. If we did not win in North-West Dublin perhaps we may the next time. The people will not be so easily fooled. They will begin to realise that it is not the bread, sweets and turf that count. The honest, thrifty and provident people upon whom this country depends, and whoseconfidence this Government is glad to have, realise that a change has taken place in our fortunes, that we have now got firm ground under our feet and that they can make the progress which we all anticipated and hoped they would make after the war, in 1945. That progress was interrupted when a Coalition Government took office—and took officewith one idea. They took office in this country as if it were a conquered country and they decided to plunder it.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?