Vote of Confidence—Motion by Taoiseach (Resumed).
Contributions 1–136 of 284. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When I reported progress last night, I had been pointing out that the question before the House was directed to two members, Deputies Dr. Browne and Cowan. I also pointed out that, irrespective of the by-elections and irrespective of the viewpoint conveyed in the speeches from members of the different Parties, ultimately whatever decision was taken this evening would be the vote and responsibility of these two Deputies and their colleague, Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll. I went on to point out that nobody could cavil at them casting their votes any way they thought fit. That is the privilege of any member of this House no matter to what Party he belongs. But I did question thebasis on which they proposed to cast their vote and I questioned the basis on which in advance of the conclusion of the discussion they committed themselves to support the motion of confidence in the Government. It is as well not merely from the viewpoint of the life of the present Government but also from the point of view of trying to maintain some clarity in our political life that decisions of this character, which are so vital at the present time, would bear some relation to reality.
It is most difficult particularly for those of us who in many ways in the past and even to some degree at present have found ourselves on common ground with Deputies like Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Cowan in respect of major matters of policy and social affairs to follow the peculiar development of their minds in relation to the last two years. I recall that Deputy Dr. Browne in particular has repeatedly expressed not merely opposition to the policies that have been pursued by the present Government but very grave concern. He did indicate at the time of the election of the Government which he supported that he had certain expectations as to how their policy would work out. Later he indicated that he had been gravely disappointed in so far as that policy had quite clearly brought about a position in which there had been a very considerable increase in unemployment and a very considerable increase in prices without as he had originally hoped a parallel increase in wages and salaries to compensate wage and salary earners.
On these basic issues it seems to be very difficult to understand and appreciate the position in this debate. Even within the past 24 hours in so far as the policy of the Government is concerned there have been major questions of doubt raised particularly by Deputy Dr. Browne. To-day the two Deputies to whom I refer find themselves, whether they like it or not or whether they appreciate it or not, supporting a Government which by some peculiarity now finds itself with responsibility for the situation in this country which was asked for in the report of the Central Bank and which quite clearly, as faras I can understand, cannot be accepted or endorsed by Deputies with the outlook of Deputies Dr. Browne and Cowan.
It is a most startling development to find that the policies adumbrated in that report by the Central Bank which were publicly repudiated by the Government and which the Government says they were not bound to follow have worked out in practice to such a very close degree on major economic questions and that after two years of watching the working out of that policy it is still possible for these two Deputies to justify the continuance of their support of the present Government.
Apparently, their justification is to be found not in any conviction that the policy of the Government is the correct policy but rather on the attitude that they must condition their support to the present Government by their attitude to what they regard as the record of the Fine Gael Party. One might quite well agree that the record of the Fine Gael Party over the period 1922 to 1932 was one that met with the opposition of practically all progressive elements in this country. One might take it from what was said by Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Cowan, particularly Deputy Cowan, that the record of the Fianna Fáil Party particularly in the period 1939 to 1947 was one that was opposed by all progressives. In that way, we have got almost an equal balance. But that in itself is not sufficient to explain their votes, nor is it sufficient to justify the manner in which they propose to cast their votes.
I posed a question last night, and I think it was a fair question. It was this: do these two Deputies prefer to see a position in this country in which the only choice which is going to be offered to the people is that of a Government by Fianna Fáil or by Fine Gael because that, in effect, is the position that they are helping to create. They propose to continue their support of Fianna Fáil and they propose to disassociate themselves from any alternative which is practicable and which can exercise any restraining influence or act as a brake, on themore conservative elements in Fianna Fáil and, on the other hand, can exercise pressure on the more progressive elements in Fianna Fáil.
Fianna Fáil, like every other Party in this country, is not homogeneous. It has its progressives and its conservatives, and to the extent that Fianna Fáil constitutes the Government, it is, I think, the duty of those of us who have a progressive outlook to try and do what we can to strengthen the progressive elements in that Party and ensure that they will follow more progressive lines. I do not know of any way in which that can be done by placing ourselves in thraldom to Fianna Fáil. Those Independent Deputies who have now gone through two years of that political thraldom not merely have not taken a different viewpoint from the Government on any major measures, but seem to find it impossible to dissociate themselves from even the most minor matters of policy. Deputy Cowan, particularly, is not merely an apologist for Fianna Fáil, but one must feel that his most nauseating qualities are somewhat sickening to the members of Fianna Fáil themselves. That, I think, is not a position that is easy to understand. The frequent little sparring matches that we used to have between the Minister for Finance and Deputy Cowan have now passed away, and the two are like cooing doves, the Minister for Finance patting Deputy Cowan on the head.
As regards the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party to the Labour Party, one would gather from it and from the Irish Pressthat their hearts are bleeding for the Labour Party. We are told that the Labour Party are going to lose seats to Fine Gael, that the Labour Party is imperilled and with theSunday Presscalling Deputy Larkin to save the Labour Party from Deputy Norton. I wonder do they think that we are all children and that the Labour Party is run on the same basis as their Party — that, when the Leader comes into the room, all bow down. Deputy Norton is the elected Leader of the Labour Party, and to him we give our loyal support as the elected Leader, no more and no less. We have, within the Labour Party, that conception andunderstanding of Party loyalty which may appear somewhat peculiar to them. That kind of play-acting, while it might apparently bring results in regard to Deputy Cowan, is certainly going to have no effect in so far as the Labour Party is concerned, and Fianna Fáil knows that very well. But they are very clever politicians, and they realise that, with the help of their daily newspaper, it is very easy to cause confusion and create misunderstanding.
We have the latest example of that in this morning's Irish Presswith a seven-column heading: “Aiken's reply to Costello”. In smaller type we have a heading with what purports to be a quotation from the speech that I made last night. “We expect little from the Coalition: Larkin.” The statement I made was that when we entered the inter-Party Government we expected little from the inter-Party Government and I gave my reasons. It was an experiment. We were entering a field of activity where we had not got men who had experience of administration or the exercise of executive authority in Government Departments. The inter-Party were taking on responsibility for the first time and naturally we realised the difficulties and disadvantages of that. I made what I considered to be a reasonable, fairminded explanation as to why we did not expect undue results at that time.
Fianna Fáil is concerned at the moment not with what happened in 1948, but it is very much concerned with what is going to happen this afternoon, and as to what is the future that is facing them. They are very anxious to kill and destroy the idea in the minds of people in this country that there is any alternative to Fianna Fáil. To the extent that they can create, as they think, friction between the Labour Party and other Parties in opposition, and to the extent that they can create, by that type of deliberate distortion, misunderstanding, they hope to build up a wall of security around themselves, an atmosphere in which there will be complete division between all the Parties in opposition so that Fianna Fáil will be saved by that division. The Labour Party didparticipate in the inter-Party Government and to that extent they are still prepared to provide this country with an alternative to Fianna Fáil, subject to that alternative being in conformity with the central points in the Labour Party programme.
I think that in many ways we should give credit to Fianna Fáil for this, as I pointed out last night, that over a long period of years, even though there might be disagreement between the Labour Party and Fianna Fáil and even though for many years Fianna Fáil, as the Government of this country, did things that we thought were not proper and failed to do things that we thought were essential, yet the differences between us were not so sharp and a crisis did not arise; but with the continuance of the development of the more conservative aspects of Fianna Fáil policy and the growing reluctance on their part to give any heed to the viewpoint of the masses of the people and their growing disassociation with the actual lives of the people, breaking point finally came. The breaking point came in 1948 when we adopted our policy to meet what we thought was a critical situation. It was agreed upon at meetings of the Labour Party that on that point there was a growing demand and growing pressure from elements who have supported the Labour Party over many years. It was based simply upon the proposition that: "If we, the electorate, vote for Labour because we are opposed to Fianna Fáil how long are the votes we give to the Labour Party in the Dáil going to be used to permit Fianna Fáil to put through policies that we as ordinary electors are opposed to" and we finally had to make up our minds.
That applies to Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Cowan because nobody in their sane senses will suggest that the election of Deputy Cowan and Deputy Dr. Browne was on the basis of the policy that has operated for the last two years. I do not think, in the wildest imagination, that Deputy Cowan or Deputy Dr. Browne received the votes given to them on the basis that their votes to-day in this House would be to justify a policy that has increased unemployment by nearly27,000 in two years. They were not given votes to support a policy that has increased the cost of living from 103 to 126 points in two years. They were not given votes to allow that increase to take place while at the same time the wages and salaries were adjusted by a maximum of ten points. Deputy Dr. Browne was not even given votes to support the type of Health Bill that has been going through the House.
Therefore, it is quite proper when facing the realities of this vote of confidence to try to examine the basis on which these Deputies propose to cast their votes. I put the question to the members of Fianna Fáil as I put it to those Independent Deputies. Are we to pursue a policy in which, as I say, the alternative to a Fianna Fáil Government is a Government composed solely of Fine Gael? I wonder do ordinary back benchers of Fianna Fáil ever ponder that question. The Tánaiste said last night that, in his opinion, we had now reached a stage of development in this country, because of proportional representation, in which Governments would have very narrow majorities. If Fianna Fáil cannot be the Government, whom do they want in their place? It is a fair question, and it is a fair question to Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Cowan.
The country to-day cannot afford any longer government solely by Fianna Fáil or solely by Fine Gael. We have the record of Cumann na nGaedheal in ten years and we have had the record of Fianna Fáil. I think the majority of the people now feel that even though the progressive elements that are outside of those two Parties may be divided and splintered in this House much to our general misfortune, it is desirable that until such time as the present political situation has worked itself out there should be some kind of a break from either of the big Parties. That is the way the elections are going to work out for some time. There will be some period before any one Party in this country will have a clear and unequivocal overall majority.
If that is the case, then not merely the Labour Party but members of the Fianna Fáil Party and the Independentsmust make up their minds what combinations will develop. If Fianna Fáil objects, as they have been so strenuously telling us, to any association of the Labour Party and Fine Gael to-day, will they tell us what the alternative is? Are we merely to give, as Deputy Cowan and Deputy Dr. Browne have given, unquestioning and servile support to Fianna Fáil no matter what they do as a Government? When we come back here after a general election and Fianna Fáil is a minority, votes given to the Labour Party are to be cast to return Fianna Fáil as a minority Government; and having done that they are to sit with their fingers in their mouths for five years or less while the machinery of Fianna Fáil continues to churn out their particular policy whether we like it or not and whether the Fianna Fáil back benchers like it or not. I see Deputy McGrath smiling.
Comment on this
No wonder. You mean Fine Gael. You were thinking of the Coalition three years. It was a good curtain lecture.
Comment on this
I would like to remind the Minister for External Affairs that the history of the last two years is exactly the history of the worst period since the time of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy say what Social Welfare Bill the Cumann na nGaedheal Government passed from 1922 to 1932? Could he indicate one measure of social amelioration that they brought in? Did they not reduce the old age pensions?
Comment on this
In 1947 the Fianna Fáil Government refused a miserable half-crown to old age pensioners on the grounds that the Government could not afford £500,000. Now when they have learned a lesson they can afford another £11,000,000. Incidentally on the subject of social welfare no matter how anxious the Labour Party may be to provide for it, there is somethingmore basic. There is no use setting out to provide social welfare as a sop for 27,000 additional unemployed men and women.
Comment on this
I do not want to cover the ground again that I did last night in great detail. I want to mention one particular point. Deputy Dr. Browne has raised the question of the alternative. Deputy Dr. Browne has the same responsibility of any other member of this House for finding the alternative himself. If he fails to find it let him carry the responsibility outside. He has asked whether the Labour Party has its programme ready. I have already pointed out that the Labour Party does not propose to take a number of points from its general election programme and offer them to Deputy Dr. Browne, Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael or anybody else. We propose to contest an election on a Labour Party programme. We have to say quite clearly what we regard as essential. If nobody else feels they are essential, we are satisfied to stay where we are. We have no ministerial ambitions and from the point of view of the elections and the preparation of the Labour Party programme it is not a question of ambition. The Labour Party happens to have a democratic organisation and the question of that programme is now going through the process of that organisation.
In due time our programme will be presented not merely to the Party as a whole and to the public but also to Deputy Dr. Browne. Deputy Dr. Browne can quite easily set down the principal points of any programme on which the Labour Party could associate with other Parties and he will generally find that he and I would agree on the points which should be basic to any Government policy and they are the points he is not getting from Fianna Fáil. He realises that it is becoming vital to decide who is going to settle the financial and credit resources of this country. There is no difference between us on that. It has been indicated even by the Tánaiste that that is a problem that is presenting itself.
Deputy Dr. Browne, Deputy Cowan and I will agree that the present unemployment position is of such a character that it should be treated as an emergency. I wait with interest to see whether the Taoiseach, when replying, will give the undertaking to Deputy Cowan which that Deputy asked for. Deputy Cowan asked for an assurance that the present unemployment problem will be treated as an emergency. I can see the Labour Party giving that undertaking but I wonder will he get it from the Taoiseach and, when he is not given it, will he still vote for the Government? Every vote that is cast by these three Independents may be divided into the 27,000 unemployed and each of those votes is equal to 9,000 idle men and women.
Equally with those Deputies the Labour Party can agree on housing. It is significant that in the period of two years in which this Government has been kept in office by the votes of these Deputies employment on local authority housing, which is the most vital factor and the most vital sector of housing, has dropped from 11,000 to 7,000 men. These Deputies in the Labour Party would not agree with that. They give credit generously to the fact that it was a Labour Minister, the late Deputy Murphy, who not merely initiated the present housing campaign but put such tremendous impetus into it that it is still rolling along after two years of Fianna Fáil attempt not merely to delay it and hold it up by their financial policy but by a continuous tightening up of red-tape regulations. So much so that in Dublin even the local members of Fianna Fáil on the council have to intervene with their own Minister to get him to relax the regulations.
Comment on this
I understand that when we get the figures for Dublin this year, up to the 12 months ending in March, we may find that there has been a drop.
Comment on this
I would just point out that in 1951 in Dublin we lost nearly three months in our house building and we lost it by a decision made by the Minister for Local Government, which he subsequently reversed. That is one single instance.
Comment on this
It was in regard to the question of the granting of sanction for site development work and the submission of plans.
Comment on this
However, let us conclude on the point. As I said earlier, I do not expect that Deputy Cowan,Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll will change their decision on this vote. These things do not happen like that but I do think it is important that they should realise what their vote signifies. In my opinion, while Deputy Dr. Browne has maintained a very strong personal support over the past two years, I understand that, in respect of wide sections of the people, week after week that support is departed from, not because of his attitude on questions of health but because health is not the whole sum and that one cannot cover by a progressive policy on health the support of a conservative policy on the basis of economic issues which determine the health of the people. That is the dilemma that Deputy Dr. Browne has got himself into and in which only he can make a decision. He is quite at liberty, if he is satisfied that his present policy is the correct one, to sacrifice his political support and his political future. I do not for a moment think he has got any personal ambition or is concerned in any way with being in public life from the point of view of any prestige. I think, even possibly, to some extent, it applies to Deputy Cowan although he has a little more ambition than Deputy Dr. Browne.
Neither of these Deputies nor Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll is entitled to sacrifice, in addition to their personal political prestige, the support and the sincerity that was given to them by their supporters and I frankly think it is a fair and straightforward question to put to these Deputies, whether they believe the men and women outside this House who voted for them in 1951 are convinced that they have been pursuing the proper policy during the past two years and are convinced that the votes of these three Deputies will be passed correctly in accordance with their mandate when they give this vote of confidence to the Government. I frankly do not think so. But, whatever may be my opinion or the opinion of Deputy Dr. Browne or Deputy Cowan, there is one other factor that we are all agreed on, that is, that we are the servants of the people outside this House.
It appears to me that the reluctanceof these Deputies to vote against the Government is based on one very simple fact—it is the same basis as conditions the attitude of the Government — that at the present moment a general election will result in reduced support for the Fianna Fáil Party. It is more than likely that their Government will not continue. It may be quite true, as the Tánaiste says, that as a Party it is quite proper for them to utilise every device of the parliamentary machine and of the Constitution to remain in office as long as they can in the hope that their policy, from their point of view, will show results that will swing opinion back. But, in the meantime, outside this House, there is a majority of people who do not want to wait, who want to have their ordinary democratic right now, to pass judgment on this Government.
The Government, as I say, is quite entitled to go on for the full five years, if they can, but I question whether Deputy Cowan, Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll have an equal right to go against the clear expression of popular opinion in the by-elections and, quite clearly, against what must be the basic outlook of their own supporters and to allow this present situation to continue in which every vote cast by these three Independents represents 20,000 idle men and women and a balance of 9,000 idle men and women, when they cast their votes to keep this Government in office.
Comment on this
I listened very attentively to speakers on both sides of the House. I listened with very close attention to the speech made by Deputy Larkin last night and this morning, in which he gave the reasons for the political policy which Labour have pursued since 1948. His speech to my mind was a revealing and frank picture of the political situation as he saw it.
Deputy Larkin mentioned that it was the desire of each political Party in this House to achieve office without the support or assistance of any other political group. That is quite a reasonable statement. For many years past Fianna Fáil have adopted thatattitude. They were not prepared to take part in a Government unless they themselves had complete say. They were prepared to accept support from people on the side line but there was no part in that Government for people who were not members of the Fianna Fáil Party.
With regard to the Fine Gael view, it is quite reasonable for me to suggest that if they had the strength of Fianna Fáil they, too, would like to have a Government composed completely of Fine Gael Ministers but circumstances are such that at the moment and for many years to come I do not believe that the Fine Gael Party, even though they have shown a revival, will be in any position to assume office on their own. Consequently we have statements by the leaders of the Fine Gael Party that they welcome co-operation from other political groups in this House. In that respect they show more agility and a more intelligent approach than the Fianna Fáil Party have shown. The Labour Party, according to Deputy Larkin, would like to have enough Deputies in this House to give them a majority. As far as the Clann na Poblachta Party is concerned I was a member of that Party for a number of years and it was our desire always to have enough Deputies in this House to form a Government, but I gather from the statement made by the Leader of that Party recently that they no longer believe in a Government by Clann na Poblachta and that they have now changed to a policy that would give us a Government on the same lines as that in Switzerland.
Comment on this
That was never the intention when that political Party was formed. I have nothing more to say on it except that I agree with Deputy Larkin in this, that in 1947 and 1948 when Clann na Poblachta began the policy we had in the Clann was the Labour policy and we made no bones about it that we were in thorough agreement with the Labour Party on all major issues. We believed that we would succeed in winning the support of the people of the country whereLabour, to my mind, had failed up to that, but there was no fundamental difference between us with regard to policy.
I came into public life as a member of Clann na Poblachta, as a firm believer in that policy which I have since pursued as an Independent. It was no desire of mine to be here in this House as an Independent. It was as the result of disagreement on a fundamental issue that I left the Clann na Poblachta Party in 1951, and from 1948 until the present time I have never made any secret of the fact that I had as little time for Fine Gael as for Fianna Fáil. If I had in 1947 and 1948 a belief that either of these Parties would solve the difficulties that faced this country and put into operation a suitable economic policy, then people like myself would not be in public life in Clann na Poblachta— we would be members either of Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael. Consequently I find myself in a completely independent position in this House, with no allegiance to any political Party but with an allegiance to the policy which I pursued since I came into public life. I still say that, as far as I am concerned, as a young man I see no difference on fundamental matters between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. I know indeed that Fianna Fáil will disagree with me and feel very annoyed that such a suggestion is made. They can point, and rightly so, to many achievements in the field of social welfare and in certain advances made in the industrial life of the country. They can point to those achievements, and they deserve credit for them, but in fundamental matters I think there is no real difference. We have even to-day Deputy MacEntee across this House shouting that Fine Gael, or Cumann na nGaedheal as they were, reduced the old age pensions.
Fianna Fáil are making a vital mistake if they are harping on their achievements of the past with little to offer the youth in the future. That is the tragedy of this position that they have taken up to-day. It does not make the slightest difference to a young man or woman in Ireland, be it in Dublin or in rural areas, to-day what Cumann na nGaedheal didbetween 1922 and 1932. There is not one single extra vote going to go to Fianna Fáil for suggesting that Cumann na nGaedheal reduced the old age pensions in 1931. What the public want to see is what is going to happen from 1953 on, not what was the attitude of Fine Gael between 1948 and 1951.
Now, as I see it, Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil are fundamentally conservative in the major field, in one of the most important aspects of public life, that is the question of control of our own credit and financial system. I see no difference between the outlook of Fine Gael and that of Fianna Fáil in that matter.
Coming to the field of agriculture, I do not propose to go into it to any extent except to say this: Deputy Dillon is very fond of saying here in this House: "Let the facts speak for themselves." What progress has been made in the last 30 years under Cumann na nGaedheal or Fianna Fáil in the field of agriculture? It has to be admitted to-day that little or no progress has been made in that most important aspect of our life. They both have their differences of opinion on a system but neither of them has so far made a success in the field of agriculture.
Let us have a look at the methods adopted by these major Parties for solving the unemployment problem. That problem has been there since 1922 and little or no improvement has taken place. Emigration goes on merrily all the time. Without going into detail too much I would like to suggest that the main plank of agreement between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, the one thing in which one can see co-operation between both, is in their belief in private enterprise as a solution of our difficulties. Both of them have stated time and again that they believe that private enterprise, admittedly with a certain amount of State help, is going to be the solution to the problems in the West of Ireland and the problems of development generally. That is common ground. Both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael believe in that. Consequently there is to my mind a great difference between FiannaFáil and Fine Gael on the one hand and the Labour Party on the other.
Down the years Fianna Fáil have succeeded by good tactical manoeuvres in making Fine Gael to my mind really more conservative than they are. I am being perfectly frank in all this because I believe we must face facts. I would like to say that I believe this country has now reached a new stage in political development and that the causes of what we are discussing to-day in this House started away back in 1947 or 1948. Deputies will recollect that in 1947 there were three by-elections and that a new Party on the political scene, Clann na Poblachta, swept the decks in two of those by-elections. It must be remembered that they were new, they had no organisation worthwhile, but in spite of that they won two seats from Fianna Fáil, against the Government. That showed that in 1947 people were getting very dissatisfied with this big Fianna Fáil machine. In other words in 1947 and 1948 Fianna Fáil was slipping back. I do not propose to deal in any detail with what happened between 1948 and 1951 except to say that Clann na Poblachta played an important part in public life in those days, even earlier, from 1947, because they gave a feeling to the people that there was hope for the future, that there was a chance that other people could guide the destinies of this country apart from Fianna Fáil and the present Taoiseach. The Clann failed, and failed badly. We will leave it at that, but if they did nothing else they put new life into Fine Gael.
I remember that in Galway in 1948 Deputy MacEoin was speaking in the square and said that Clann na Poblachta was only a chip off Fianna Fáil and that the chip would return to the block in a very short time. Even there the belief was prevalent amongst Fine Gael that Clann na Poblachta represented the more progressive view of the Fianna Fáil Party and that much of the support coming to Clann na Poblachta was coming from former Fianna Fáil supporters who had become dissatisfied with the Fianna Fáil outlook and programme between 1938 and 1947.
In 1951 the people were bewildered and the general election showed that they had not made up their mind what they really wanted. Fianna Fáil got a chance. They had regained a certain amount of support from Clann na Poblachta but the remainder of the people decided to stay aloof and wait patiently until they would see what was going to happen. In the period 1947-48, Fianna Fáil got a bad fright and they got three years in dry dock to make changes. They came back here in 1951 a little chastened but with no new blood—or there may have been new blood but no young blood on the Front Bench. They spent the next three years carrying on as if there had been no break between 1948 and 1951; they carried on in the same way as they did between 1938 and 1947.
We are coming to a transition period in Irish politics. To my mind, the old generation represented both in Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael is losing its grip. A new approach on economic matters is needed here in this House. As I have already said, Fine Gael have shown more ability to adapt themselves to changing circumstances and changing times. I do not know what is going to happen here on this motion, but judging by the result of the by-elections, if there were a general election in the near future, Fianna Fáil is facing a period in the political wilderness. That may happen this evening or it may not happen for 12 months or two years; but I believe you cannot stop the avalanche, that the tide has turned and that Fianna Fáil is going to lose. Whether they can postpone their defeat this evening is another matter. They will have to face the wilderness, be it in 12 months' time or two years' time, and no action that they take in the meantime can stop the avalanche overwhelming them.
I have the greatest admiration for Deputy de Valera as Taoiseach. He is an individual, as Deputy Larkin said last night, who has his own place in Irish history. It might be no harm for Fianna Fáil now to put the ship into dry dock. There is a lot of timber on that boat that needs replacement. There is a new set of officers needed— and I think that a new captain on thebridge at this stage would be no harm. There should be more promotion from the ranks and a new crew taken in and a chance given to them. A period in the dry dock for Fianna Fáil would do them good. They would have a chance to study and see where mistakes were made and to put a more progressive policy before the people in future. That means, of course, that while they are there a new ship will be launched to guide the destinies of the State — and I, personally do not envy the captain with the crew. No doubt there will be many on that boat very fine members, good officers, but he will have some brigands as well. There is no doubt that on any boat like this you are bound to have a few who are out for plunder. You will have that on the next ship that sails — but that is inevitable in Irish public life.
Deputy de Valera has suggested that as far as Fianna Fáil are concerned they represent the Irish people. The inter-Party Government, as it was in the past, was a matter of different sections of the community pulling together. Fine Gael represented one section; Labour, Clann na Poblachta and Clann na Talmhan represented other sections. Surely if Fianna Fáil represents the people, as Deputy de Valera suggested, it must represent, in order to get the support it has here, the big farmer, the small farmer, the poor man, the rich man, the industrialist and the labour groups; and are not all those groups inside Fianna Fáil fighting their corner? Is not the same thing happening in an inter-Party Government, with only this difference, that in the inter-Party Government— I am not going to stick to the last inter-Party Government, but any type of inter-Party Government—they can fight their corner in a Cabinet or common room and in the interests of all concerned hammer out a policy?
Comment on this
If the Deputy does not mind a question — he can look afterhimself and does not need Deputy Morrissey——
Comment on this
I think it is a very constructive suggestion. I agree thoroughly with the Taoiseach. I do not think it is a good thing as a rule to buy a pig in a bag. I think it would be a good thing if the various Parties going to form an inter-Party Government or multi-Party Government would sit down and agree to hammer out a policy, so that the Independents and everyone else would know what they were facing. I have no objection to that and that is what I would like. I am trying to point out that as far as Fianna Fáil are concerned they are really a group of Parties that are held together by the personality of the Taoiseach himself.
Comment on this
As far as I am concerned, it should be quite clear to anyone who wishes to check on my attitude in this House what I propose to do in connection with this vote. This motion says: "That Dáil Éireann reaffirms its confidence in the Government". The word "reaffirms" is very significant as far as I am concerned. The day this present Government took office I saw no reason why I should have confidence in Fianna Fáil going back into power and I am afraid my judgment was right at the time. I say I am afraid, because the results have been sad in the last two years for many of our people. To my mind, this vote of confidence would mean that if I wanted to support the present Government on certain issues I would have to take responsibility, a certain amount of responsibility, for the budgetary policies that have been pursued in the last two years. I could not accept any responsibility whatever. I never agreed from the word "go" with the method adopted by Fianna Fáil in their efforts to clear up the alleged mess. If that mess did exist, they should have found another way out of the dilemma because further hardships were imposed.
I think the Taoiseach was very foolish in putting down this motion. It is quite clear that there have been issues in this House on which I gave support to the present Government, and I made clear in my remarks here on the day that the Taoiseach was elected that, even though I was not supporting him as Taoiseach, if good legislation was introduced I would have no hesitation at any time in giving my support to that legislation, and I have done so. At no time have I tried to take advantage of the Government's weakness with regard to numbers in this House for the sake of putting them out and I have no intention at any time of lending myself to any such proposal or action. But this is a different matter.
Last night the Tánaiste said that good times were coming. I have not been many years in this House but the longer I am here the more cynical I am becoming with regard to the good times promised. The Tánaiste said that the worst part of the blizzard was over and that good times were coming. He made the reasonable case from the political point of view that Fianna Fáil having weathered the storm were entitled to the political benefits of the victory which will come in the next two years, that they are entitled to get from the people an appreciation of Fianna Fáil's efforts. That is asking a little too much. I do not believe that in the next two or three years there is going to be a Utopia in this country. If the main reason why this motion was put down, as the Tánaiste said, is that Fianna Fáil want a chance in the next two years to reap the political benefits of their budgetary policy of the past two years, then I do not see how I can support them.
May I say that as an individual I dislike intensely the idea of having to face the electorate in a strenuous campaign? I know perfectly well that every Independent Deputy will have to face the power of the political Parties in an election. I have very many political scars left on me after the last election. I can say quite definitely that I owe no thanks to any political Party for assisting or helping me in thelast general election. As a matter of fact, I was more slandered by political groups on the Opposition side than by Fianna Fáil. Having looked at the matter calmly and conscientiously and taken into consideration the results of the by-elections, I feel that the most reasonable course for the present Government to pursue would be to ask for this vote of confidence in the polling booths and not in this House.
I say that in the knowledge that if there is a general election there will be a strengthening of Fine Gael. I believe that is bound to come, but we can do nothing about it. Even if the election is postponed for 12 months, it will be all the same. But I think a strong Labour Party, perhaps with Independents in this House, will ensure that we will not have an overall majority again in this House for any Party that will trample on the lives of the people, especially the poorer sections. I think there will be sufficient Deputies to ensure that that state will not be reached. In addition to that, I do not think we should treat the Irish people as fools. Having had experience of this type of majority dictatorship for 17 or 20 years, I would say that they will be very slow to hand the reins of office to another Party, who differ very little from that particular organisation, to allow them to pursue a similar course of action for four or five years. We need not worry about that. I do not know what will happen as far as this vote of confidence is concerned, and if the Government do stay on, I want to reiterate what I said on a former occasion, that if there is good legislation introduced in this House, no matter who likes or dislikes it, I will support it at any time.
Comment on this
Listening to Deputy McQuillan, I realise that it is a matter of considerable difficulty for those Independent Deputies who have been watching the progress of the country in the last few years to separate the two aspects of Fianna Fáil policies, that aspect which is concerned with putting the finances of the nation into order and that which relates to our permanent policy for the nationaldevelopment of the country. But at this stage it is essential for us on this side of the House to reiterate the statement that everything we have done in the past and everything that is going on at present indicates that we are in no way reactionary, that we have formulated most of the advanced policies, indeed virtually all of them, which have brought progress to the country in the belief that the people can stimulate economic activity through their own Government.
That idea was initiated by us and it still is our conception. The idea that the State can stimulate private enterprise, can assist private enterprise, can replace private enterprise where it is absent, is being pursued at a far higher level of activity than it was during the period of the inter-Party Government. So far as giving private permanent employment is concerned, employment that lasts, employment that is not based on false economic ideas, employment that is not purely temporary, we still have in our Party credit for most of the ideas, for most of the policies, and we can point to most of the results.
I hotly resent the suggestion either by members of the Labour Party or any Independent Deputy that we lack initiative, that we are reactionary, that in any sense we are a Party who are not prepared even to take risks when we think risks are worth taking in helping to stimulate industry in this country. We have at this moment a long term programme for agricultural and industrial development. We believe quite sincerely that if the people of the country can watch the progress of that programme and co-operate in making it a success we shall prove that we have, as we have had in the past, the know-how in regard to the regeneration of this country, in regard to overcoming all the evil results of our history. It is for that reason that we have asked for this vote of confidence in this House.
It has cost this country tens of millions of pounds in the past 20 years to half convert the Fine Gael Party to some of our ideas. Their blocking tactics in the past have made our problem in the future more difficult.They have delayed progress, have delayed in giving the people of this country confidence in their own institutions and in their ability to progress. The Fine Gael Party has been spoonfed with Fianna Fáil doctrines. The only normal thing in their policy is the result of their attempting, urged by Labour, to look through Fianna Fáil spectacles and these spectacles have never fitted and we do not believe they ever will fit.
I believe myself that a great number of their own supporters in the country have no genuine belief in some of the Fianna Fáil policies which they have half-adopted, and have been compelled to half-adopt through pressure that has been placed upon them by the Labour Party. You might say that pressed by the Labour Party, their policy has been a stilted imitation of some aspects of Fianna Fáil policy, served up with a rather doubtful sauce in order to make it more attractive. We have had evidence recently that they were prepared, if they think it pays them, to become more conservative again, and some of the observations they made on social welfare and health, and their failure to pass the Social Welfare Act in their term of office, were evidence of the fact that I do not believe they have a real genuine philosophy of their own. During their term of office they neglected many aspects of Fianna Fáil policy which was left to them in the form of plans in operation or about to come into operation and showed once again their conservative instincts. There was an obvious case for the expansion of the sugar-beet industry, but it was not expanded. There was an obvious case for the expansion of the machine-won turf industry, but no action was taken for two years. In regard to a number of major industrial developments they delayed taking any decision. In regard to the tourist industry, they failed to amend legislation governing the administration of the Tourist Board. That was left to us. They did not inaugurate any new policy of note. I think the only single new policy they had was that in connection with the Local Authorities (Works) Act. They boasted a lot about the land rehabilitation scheme, but what they were doing was changing theemphasis in regard to certain details of administration in respect of the land reclamation scheme and they gave it a new name — the land rehabilitation scheme.
They talked a lot about capital development, as though they had invented the idea, but the idea of encouraging private and public capital investment was the exclusive invention of Fianna Fáil, done in spite of opposition by Fine Gael. And after all the talk and boasted achievements, in this year we are spending far more money on our own Fianna Fáil capital development schemes than they spent, and we are doing it in a sound way. We are raising money in a sound manner.
During the course of the by-elections that have taken place, I tried to find any reference to how the Fine Gael Party would face the problems of the day, and during this debate I have listened to nothing but abuse with no positive suggestions. There have been vague suggestions that if they were returned to office they would prune public expenditure. They are well aware that we have got to make savings of some considerable amount in order to balance this year's Budget. They are well aware that we have had to desist from the habit of overspending during the financial year in order to balance the present Budget. But beyond trifling suggestions for economies we have had no definite proposal as to how they would prune expenditure or suggestions by means of which they would reduce taxation. We have had all sorts of vague suggestions about restoring subsidies but they have not given any evidence of showing where they are going to find the money to restore subsidies— whether they wish to leave the Budget unbalanced deliberately — or whatever action they propose they have not indicated it to this country.
They have talked vaguely about making use of external assets but they have given no details either to the country or to the House as to how they would make use of these assets. We have challenged them and said that there was not very much over£120,000,000 reserves left and asked them what they would do; what way they would diminish that reserve or at what point they would stop, or for what purpose they would reduce the reserves. We have had no positive statement from them whatever. We have made it clear that we are perfectly willing to make use of investments in England for productive purposes and that when the net reserve is reduced to an amount that bears some reference to one year's imports that care must be exercised. We have no conservative view about the repatriation of assets. We have had a lot of vague talk by members of Fine Gael without any indication of how they would use the assets if given an opportunity. Many vague references were made to the high rates of bank interest by some members of the Fine Gael Party but none of them committed himself to any action in that regard, and in fact, most of the suggestions they made in regard to economic policy were suggestions concerning matters about which if they were really sincere they would have commenced detailed investigation during their last term of office. Anything that looks advanced in Fine Gael policy in connection with economics must obviously be studied carefully and if they had any sincerity they would have set about the investigation of such fundamental problems as rates of interest and control of finances and so forth. It is very easy to talk vaguely about these matters but the proof of their sincerity would have been the investigation of these matters either by themselves or any kind of commission or committee they cared to set up. They set up no commission or committee and so far as external assets were concerned the strangest irony of the whole situation is the fact that they actually invested huge amounts of securities in Great Britain and it was only after they had left office that they were liquidated.
Comment on this
I said that the strangest irony in regard to their policy was that it so happened that during their term of office as a result of the method they used to spend the Marshall Aid loan they actually piled up British assets. I said that it was an ironic situation and that is what it is, although Deputy MacBride does not like it.
Comment on this
It was only found afterwards that as a consequence resulting from the failure to balance the Budget and failing to observe modern laws of economics that are understood by every country in Europe that an enforced liquidation of assets took place.
Comment on this
We claim on this side of the House that the Opposition have grossly exaggerated the difficult conditions of to-day.
We are well aware that times are difficult for housewives in this country and in all countries in Europe, in countries that never saw the war, in countries that remained neutral during the war and in countries that gained in prosperity as a result of the war. The difficulty of the cost of living is to be found everywhere, but we think that it is completely wrong and recklessly dishonest to exaggerate these things. We do not admit that misery and starvation are stalking the land. We have only to go around the country and to travel abroad to other countries to realise that we managed to survive a difficult period in our economic history reasonably well and that, provided there is some stability of Government and a lively vigorous Government with a forward constructive policy, economic conditions should improve. Ithink the lie No. 1 in regard to the whole of the latter during the election took shape in the deliberate attempt to persuade the people of this country that the increase in the cost of living was caused solely by this Government, that there was something unique about it, and that there were no other countries in the world in which the cost of living had risen to the same extent as it had here. Deputies opposite, during the election, poured forth their tearful sympathy with the people so cruelly treated, and they made bloodcurdling attacks on the Government which they alleged were solely responsible for the increase in the cost of living.
It is much easier to rant and exaggerate about that matter than it is to tell the dull facts, because facts to refute that sort of talk are dull and unimpressive to the people of a country who have to buy their requirements and who, like the people of every other country, find the cost extremely high. The propaganda indulged in suggests that we can remain isolated from the rest of the world and that no matter what happens outside the country, costs here can somehow be kept down. At one time subsequent to 1950 and the outbreak of the Korean war, if Deputies study in detail the commodities indices, they will find that a great many raw materials increased temporarily by 100 to 120 per cent. above the pre-June, 1950, cost. All these materials introduced into the manufacture of goods here had a tremendous effect on the cost of living. Members of the Opposition like to give the impression to the people that the price of agricultural produce can rise in this country by 40 per cent. since 1947 and that that will have no effect on food costs in general, whereas it must alter the scale of living costs inevitably.
It is just as well to give some facts in regard to the position in relation to the cost of living in this country compared with others. I got from the United Nations statistics, a statement of the principal countries in Western Europe and how the cost of living stood in 1950 as compared with 1938.
Comment on this
The Deputy can have the figures. He does not like to hear of what happened during the three years of the Coalition, during which they had an opportunity of proving all the assertions they made of gross profiteering and during which they had an opportunity of correcting the price control administration, examining it and making it better if they could. In 1950 in comparison with 1938, Ireland was about halfway down the list, so to speak, of ten principal European countries in the order of cost increases. There was a number of these countries in which the cost of living had gone up less than here, partly because of subsidies and partly because of the strength of their currencies, and there was a number in which the cost of living had gone up more than in this country, partly because of war destruction, partly through an evident lack of good price administration and partly because of inevitable losses associated with severe destruction. In any event Ireland was just about halfway down the list.
If the position is again examined in 1953, after the Korean war and after all the difficulties of rising costs, it will be found that this country is still about in the same position — about halfway down the list, with countries above it and countries below it. I shall not go into the figures in detail but they reveal that there has been nothing abnormal here in regard to that situation. The cost of living has gone up in two relatively undamaged countries in Europe and in a neutral country in Europe as much as it has here. Of course, it is very easy to try to persuade the people of the country that we are responsible for all of it but it is far more difficult to refute that statement because people are naturally human. They like to blame someone for the ills and the difficulties that beset them but, as I have said, if any Deputy cares to study in detail the United Nations figures for the increase in the cost of living he will see that the position is as I have described it.
I am not blaming the Coalition Government for the fact that Ireland was just halfway down the list as I have said. That is not my point. Ihave indicated the reasons for other countries being in a better position in regard to the cost of living — such as subsidies for which taxation has to be raised, and in these countries taxation would be higher than here — and the reasons on the other side of the fence so to speak. The point is that after the difficult position created by the Korean war there is no evidence, as far as I can see, that the cost of living became uncontrolled. In other countries which had to face similar difficulties to those which we had to face, control was maintained but certain countries, either because they were damaged during the war or partly for reasons of bad administration were not able to maintain effective control and the increase in the cost of living was greater in these countries than in this country. Some countries through the strength of their currencies continued to be slightly better than we were in regard to the cost of living, but in general, the position of this country was maintained.
Listening to the debate in this House one would get the impression that there had been no increase in wages since 1950. I think it is essential to stress again that, while the position is not as satisfactory as we should like it to be, the increase in wages that has taken place since 1950 has gone at least some distance to compensate for the increase in costs. I wish to stress again that we wish that to be so. We made it perfectly clear that under present circumstances the best thing for this country was to have a realistic approach to the cost of living and that the only way of doing that was to reduce the subsidies and to compensate for that by increased children's allowances and by making it evident that wages must increase. Listening to some Deputies you would imagine that there had been a complete standstill in wages since 1950, that no compensation had ever been given either in the form of children's allowances or increased benefits to the workers of this country, and that they were not in the same position in that regard as they were before costs increased. I think it well to stress that that is not the case.
In the course of his speech, theTaoiseach gave some account of the difficulties through which we have been passing. I think it is well to stress again that nothing exceptional that has happened in this country has not happened everywhere else. Previously, I recorded, for the future history of the Dáil, many quotations from the reports of international economic organisations which foretold very accurately exactly what would happen once the boom, stimulated by the Korean war, commenced. As I have said, the results have been similar in practically every other country. The only difference between this country and some other countries is the fact that the last Government, who pretend to be modern economists and who pretend, I presume, to understand modern economic theories with regard to the extent to which the State can influence economic development — which, I suppose, has best been propounded by the late Lord Keynes — thought they knew all about them but certainly they applied them in a completely crazy manner.
Economists, either those representing the socialist school or those of the more conservative type, do not differ very much any longer. They have more or less the same ideas. But the last Government, by failing to balance the Budget of 1951, broke every known modern economic principle. There was nothing modern in that whatever. There was nothing up to date about it. It was simply the result of careless government. It had no economic foundation. It was a policy that would not be recommended either by the socialist economic advisers in Great Britain or by what might be called the advanced semi-socialist administrative liberal Administration of Sweden. It was solely a political device to escape disaster and it made the difficulties for us, who succeeded that Government, all the greater. We had to clear up the mess and apply what we believed to be up-to-date economic principles. The result was unpleasant for everybody. Those results are now passing away. Even their prophecies proved wrong. They said that the present Budget would show a surplus of £10,000,000. In thatconnection, it is interesting to remind the members of the Labour Party that the economic adviser of their own T.U.C., at the time of the Budget, said that in his view the picture was false. He condemned the Budget, but he made it quite clear that he did not believe there would be a surplus—and he proved right in the event. There was no surplus.
I do not believe that members of the Labour Party should have any great satisfaction in the acts of Fine Gael. My own belief is that their support of Fine Gael is not justified in their own interests. If they really consider long-term policy and long-term progress, and forget the difficulties of the past two years, I do not believe they should have any great faith in the Fine Gael Party in the future. Members of the Labour Party disliked the corrective effects of our economic policy and were disappointed that the cost of living continued to rise for a time. They were disappointed at our having to reduce the subsidies. At least, I should like to draw to their attention the fact that we put through this House a Social Security Act, the fact that business is slowly but steadily improving, the fact that unemployment is steadily decreasing——
Comment on this
——and that it is not decreasing through the use of what might be described as "slush" money. It is decreasing because of confidence in the people and improvement in conditions. Unemployment is decreasing by reason of the passing away of the stockpiling period and because of the fact that industries are commencing operation on a bigger scale than ever as a result of Government policy.
Comment on this
I have not finished my statement with regard to unemployment. With regard to the State's influence in providing employment and overcoming the effects of the trade recession, we are doing all we can.
Comment on this
We are running rings around the Opposition in regard to the application of a capital programme policy. I think myself that it is a matter which seems to have escaped the attention of quite a number of Deputies in the Labour Party.
Comment on this
What have you done for the Dublin unemployed? Nothing.
Comment on this
More schools are in course of erection than at any time during the term of office of the Coalition Government. We are spending about five times as much on land reclamation as was spent in the last full year of the Coalition Government. We are employing more people on arterial drainage than were employed by the Coalition Government in their last full year of office. We are planting far more acres of forest than were planted by the Coalition Government in their last two years of office. We are providing more money for roads. We have multiplied the machine-won production of turf by three, compared with what was done in the last full year of the Coalition Government.
The number of consumers in the rural network of electricity has been increased by 30 per cent. We are providing 11 new power stations for using native fuels. During the whole term of Office of the Coalition Government, no power station was sanctioned which was to burn native fuel of any kind. We have schemes for harbour development. No work was done in that regard by the Coalition Government:it is now being done by the Fianna Fáil Government and it is giving employment. We have arranged for the ordering of new ships by Irish Shipping Limited. Nothing was done in that respect by the Coalition Government. Measures to expand tourism are now in operation and the number of new industries that are starting is constantly increasing. Therefore, so far as one of the major features of what is known as modern economic policy to overcome trade recession is concerned, not only are we doing more work but we are employing more people and spending more money than was ever spent by the Coalition Government. It is a major feature of what is known as modern economic policy. I do not believe myself that there are any panaceas in this world for some of the ills of mankind. Even when the Government spend large sums in regard to capital development, there may be certain adverse repercussions. Believing that the national development of this country has long been delayed through historical influences, all we can say is that we are employing this policy in full measure and are devoting a sum of nearly £40,000,000 this year to capital expenditure.
I took occasion to examine some of the economies in other European countries where there are, shall we say, advanced administrations or administrations that are not reactionary, where the interests of the workers are safeguarded and where the State assists private enterprise. I found that the money that will be spent in this country this year, as a percentage of the income of this country, is as high as in any other country in Europe. We have nothing to be ashamed of. There is no sign of any conservatism on our part. If you compare the capital expenditure, exclusive of any defence construction, in this country this year with that of any of the modern countries in Western Europe, the comparison is excellent, so far as we are concerned. There is no evidence of any kind of reactionary feature in the economic measures taken by the Government.
So far as the unemployment that now exists is concerned, the House hasheard from both the Taoiseach and the Minister for Industry and Commerce the measures taken to speed up works, the plans for which have been under consideration, in the Dublin area and other areas. I wish to stress again that we are fully aware of the present difficulties being experienced in the constructional trades and it is interesting to note that the previous Government never even thought of what was going to happen if local authority works ceased in certain places because the schemes were completed. No preparations were made by them to provide for that situation.
Comment on this
The Deputy, as usual, misunderstood me. I was speaking of areas in which local authority works have been more or less completed. If in a certain county, due to the good work of the county council, the vast majority of houses required have been built, there is immediately a problem of how to employ people in the building trade in the area. They have been trained for a particular class of work and they cannot be asked to go to knit socks in another place. It is a real problem, a problem the present Government have to face. Our attitude is, first, that we have far higher expenditure on capital works of every kind which create a good effect in every area and, secondly, we are hastening the examination of schemes where this unemployment is particularly severe, schemes which still exist and are still required. Everything is being done in that regard.
When I was interrupted by the Deputy, I wanted to say that we would much prefer to have these people given jobs of a more or less permanent character. We want to stimulate permanent employment, employment that can be assured for a number of years. We know more about how to give employment to people than any other Party, because it was we who initiated nearly all the schemes for giving employment and for solving this problem. We know the problem is not easy to solve, but we are tackling it asrapidly as we can. I want to make it quite clear that if the unemployment problem in Dublin and certain other areas cannot be solved by our bringing to fruition a regular series of schemes that are likely to continue for a number of years, quite definitely other measures of a more emergency character will have to be adopted; but it is very much better to have a series of schemes going into operation, giving sound employment over a number of years than to provide schemes of a purely emergency type. We are considering employment both from the point of view of the permanent series of schemes and the provision of emergency employment.
It is absolutely clear that, in the world in which we live, no Government could tolerate persistent unemployment in a trade where employment could be given by asking all the people to contribute their means to ensure that schemes will be provided. We in Fianna Fáil certainly hold to that point of view. There are some forms of unemployment that are very difficult to deal with — employment in skilled industries where workers have been trained in only one kind of work and where there may be a temporary recession, due either to excessive imports, as took place during the period of office of the Coalition Government, or some other cause such as a sudden ceasing or reduction of public demand. For example, recently there was some recession in the motor car assembly industry, but now one has only to look at the registration number plates in Dublin to realise that the demand is coming back again for private cars. The industry, I think, has gone through its period of recession and conditions in it are better.
In regard, however, to what might be described as the constructional trades, I hold the view that the Government has an obligation to do all it can and we are examining the position. My own belief is that we shall be able to tackle the problem satisfactorily. There is a certain hard core of unemployment about which I need not go into detail because it has already been mentioned by other speakers but which no Government,neither this nor the previous Government, has yet solved. Average unemployment during the years of the Coalition Government remained at a comparatively high figure compared with some other countries. They were not able to solve the problem. They had a level of some 7, 8 or 10 per cent. of unemployed as compared with the whole working population, whereas certain other countries, I think, largely because of defence commitments, were able to reduce that percentage.
The last Government were not able to solve the problem, and during their period of office about 100,000 people left the country in addition. To my mind, it is extremely dishonest for any person to say here that he can solve the problem of the hard core of unemployment, unless he gives very specifically an indication of how he proposes to do it. Most people who talk about the hard core of unemployment never give details and never explain how they are going to overcome some of the adverse reactions that might arise if they attempted to solve it. I have been speaking about the particular problem which we have faced recently, and my own belief is that Fianna Fáil has all the "know-how" and all the ability to solve that problem.
Deputy Larkin referred to our action in connection with the Central Bank Report. I do not know whether it is necessary for me again to state very definitely that we did not follow the proposals the Central Bank Report made to us. We took some of the statements made as a warning, but in regard to their principal proposals, we have done exactly the opposite. We believed that their advice should be examined and that their evidence in regard to statistical economic facts should be examined. Many of the facts they put forward were correct. We thought their proposals were much too drastic, but I want to say again that I as an individual and collectively as a member of the Government will not be associated with the slavish acceptance of the Central Bank Report put forward byDeputies of the Labour Party. I deny it.
The principal proposals were that we should cut down public works— we did not cut down expenditure on public works; as I have already indicated a record amount of money is being spent this year under the heading of public and capital works. The second proposal was that certain capital types of work should be paid out of current income and not by borrowing. We did not do that; we are borrowing money for all our capital works. The other main proposal made was that we should have a large Budget surplus to correct inflation. There never has been a Budget surplus; there was a slight Budget deficit last year, and this year, only by making economies on current expenditure and not on capital expenditure, will we succeed in balancing the Budget.
In regard to the principal heads of the Central Bank Report, we did not follow their suggestions, and the whole idea that this Government is a Government desiring to suppress the people, to restrict development, to prevent development and to cut down on expenditure for increasing production is a myth created by people whose only interest is to attack us without reference to the truth.
Deputy Larkin, speaking again about the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party, got confused, I think, as to the difference between correcting an economic situation and going ahead with a policy of full national development. I still think that a great many Independent Deputies seem to be confused in that regard. We have stated that so long as there is international peace, and so long as people outside this country do not create more trouble the prospects for this year are good. All the evidence is there. Exports have been increasing. We believe tillage will increase this year. Farmers have been adopting more scientific methods of development on a scale never before seen in this country. Industrial production is increasing in many fields. The trade agreement should be to our advantage. There is every sign of a reasonably prosperous future providedthere can be some continuity, provided we do not have the spectacle of a Government of conflicting views, a Government from which inevitably there springs dissension. It is because we have not had the opportunity of seeing the full results of our policy that we have asked for this vote of confidance from the House.
I do not think there is anything more I need say at this stage but, in conclusion, I want to emphasise again that the biggest difficulty we have had to face in the last two years is persuading the people who are obsessed quite naturally with their own domestic problems that most of the difficulties that have been experienced here have been experienced in other countries, countries which have known no war, which remained neutral all through the last war and which were undamaged. Yet, the cost of living in these countries rose as high as it did here and housewives in those countries experienced difficulties comparable to those experienced here. One of the most human factors in that situation is that if one goes abroad and meets a family and sits down with that family and starts talking about their problems the first thing one will be told, whether it is a rich or a poor country, whether it is a country that faced war or remained at peace, is that the principal difficulty is the increase in the cost of living. To try to persuade the people here that they are in a special position, that none of that need have happened is to my mind disgracefully dishonest. It has proved very troublesome from our point of view because it is so much easier to believe a thing like that than to accept the rather dull and uninteresting comparisons with other countries. I believe that by increasing production it should be possible to increase the income of the people.
We, in Fianna Fáil, believe that if production and output increases the workers should share with the employers in that enhanced prosperity through increased wages, wages which will have a real purchasing value. That is what we hope. We believe that if the farmers can take advantage of the Government's present policy in the assurance that for a number of yearsthat policy will not change, they will be assisted in their development. Increased output in agriculture will in turn make the towns prosperous and that, in turn, should bring about an increase in the real value of wages, which is a thing that has been extraordinarily difficult to achieve in any country faced with the difficulties we have had to face in the last few years.
Comment on this
The last speaker told us quite blandly before he sat down, in his usual rather insolent manner, that we are disgracefully dishonest in suggesting there has been an increase in the cost of living.
Comment on this
He said that it was, of course, only a habit for people here and in other countries to talk about the difficulties of meeting the increased cost of living: it did not matter which country one went into the people just talked about the difficulty of meeting the increased cost of living.
Comment on this
The difficulty with the Minister, and it is quite obvious from the speech we had from him to-day and from the speeches he has delivered from time to time here in this House and in the country, is that all his knowledge and experience of the matters about which he talks, the hardships on the poor, unemployment and so on is gained entirely from books of statistics and not from practical knowledge or practical experience.
I presume Deputy Dr. Browne was disgracefully dishonest yesterday when he asked:—
"Was the Government going to take steps to provide sufficient capital to make employment available on the scale required? The Opposition had not exaggerated the position with regard to the cost of living, unemployment and emigration. These were charges that must be met by the Government."
I hope the Taoiseach will meet those charges when he comes to make his two hours' speech this afternoon. Deputy Dr. Browne went on to say:—
"The people were well able to stand a hair-shirt policy. They were no weaker than the people of any other nation but what hurt them was that the hair-shirt seemed to be put on for lack of thought."
What hurt them was not the hair-shirt but the fact that it was put on by the present Government for lack of thought! Remember, this is not coming from a Deputy who intends to vote against this motion. This is coming from a Deputy who has announced that he will vote for it. He goes on:—
"The people were prepared to take hardship and hard living if they knew there was to be an end to it and if what they were working for to-day was to prepare a good comfortable living for themselves and their children. Unfortunately, the Government had created the impression that the hair-shirt was to stay and that is what the people would not have."
"Truth in the News" of to-day's issue.
Comment on this
The Deputy wants to know what is "Truth in the News". I will leave that to himself. That is an amazing statement coming from a man who at the conclusion of his speech announced he would vote for the motion.
Comment on this
I am not taking a line here or there. I am reading down several lines. I will hand the Deputy the paper if he wishes to see it. I have not omitted one word.
Comment on this
Is it not hard enough for me to have to read that much of the Irish Presswithout having to readmore of it? To come back to this piece of make-believe which has taken up the time of the House over the last three days. Everybody inside this House and outside it knows this is a “cod” motion. Everyone is perfectly aware of that. Even when the Taoiseach stood up to move the motion two out of three members of his own Party were present; of the one-third that were here when he started seven or eight cleared out during the course of his speech. I do not blame them.
Those of us who had the privilege of listening to the Taoiseach in this House for the last 26 or 27 years will say, I believe honestly, that it was the poorest effort he ever made in his life —so poor that, as I say, it depressed some of his own supporters so much they had to clear out of the House.
Comment on this
Is it an indication of importance that Deputies of that Party would be in the House? If so, it appears bad for you. You have only one Deputy—the new gossoon.
Comment on this
Things are coming to nice pass when I cannot understand another Tipperary man. I do not know whether that is my fault or that of the Deputy.
Comment on this
If the attendance of Fianna Fáil Deputies was an indication that the Taoiseach's speech was not good Deputy Morrissey's speech must be very bad.
Comment on this
My colleague and myself make no secret of the fact that this is a cod motion. Let the Deputy get this into his head——
Comment on this
The Taoiseach and some of his colleagues have been trying to carry on this debate as if it was the Fine Gael Party that was in thedock and not Fianna Fáil and as if it was the Fine Gael Party that was on trial and not Fianna Fáil. The Fianna Fáil Party are in the dock. They are on trial and have been put on trial by the people of this country. It is not what Fine Gael did between 1922 and 1932 that is the issue here to-day. Perhaps, I know more than anybody else in this House about what happened between 1922 and 1932. I was here. When I hear the Minister for Finance talking about the Cumann na nGaedheal Government cutting the old age pensions in 1923 or 1924 by 1/-, I am entitled to ask why he was not here to oppose it.
Comment on this
It was not I who raised it. It was raised by those on the other side. I never attempted to go back over it. I agree with Deputy McQuillan that we are too much inclined to go back instead of looking forward and looking to the present. I resent, as a member of this Party, any reference to the Fine Gael Party as if it was something that was not Irish or something that was foreign. I resent that. I challenge the Taoiseach or anybody else to point to any act of that Party that was in any way disgraceful. It it not we who shirk putting our record or our policy before the people. It is Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
We are told about the progress made by Fianna Fáil. We are told that Fianna Fáil did this, that and the other thing. Will Deputies get it into their heads that Fianna Fáil has been the Government of this country for 18 years out of the last 21 years? Surely to goodness, unless they were completely dead from their toes to the crown of their heads, they should have achieved something in 18 years? Are we to assume from what they say that if there had been a Government there other than Fianna Fáil nothing would have been done in that 17 or 18 years? Are we to assume that if there was a Labour Government, a farmers' Government, a Fine Gael Government or a Government composedof any Party they would have sat down in their seats and done nothing for 17 or 18 years?
That sort of nonsense coming from Fianna Fáil does not go down at the cross-roads now, nor will it go down anywhere else. When I hear of the progress made by the Fianna Fáil Party in the 17 or 18 years out of the 21 years, I apply two tests. We hear a lot of blather from the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs about the schemes and plans they have for unemployment. We heard about those plans in 1931 and 1932 from the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, but the result of their 18 years is that there has been more unemployment in this country in the last two years than there was when they first took office 21 years ago. That cannot be challenged. That is true. There is more unemployment since Fianna Fáil first took office 21 years ago, notwithstanding the fact that in the same period one-sixth of the entire population of this country, that is to say, 500,000 people emigrated. These are the two tests to apply to the progressive policy of Fianna Fáil. That cannot be challenged.
I want to assert that the only period in the last 21 years in which there was a very substantial improvement in the employment situation in this country was during the three years the inter-Party Government were in office. There is no question about that. I invite Deputies to go to the Library to look at the figures there and check them. These figures are furnished by the various State Departments. Deputy Dr. Browne also said yesterday that it would be unwise for Deputies anxious for industrial progress to bank on Fine Gael changing its spots. Deputy Larkin reminded Deputy Dr. Browne that he was a member of that Government for nearly three and a half years.
Comment on this
Is it not true to say that there was more industrial progress made in that three and half years than in any similar period since the State was founded? More peoplewere put into industrial employment. Official figures are there to prove that. There can be no doubt whatever about it and Deputy Dr. Browne knows that quite well.
Comment on this
I will give this figure to the Deputy. In the three and a half years 34,000 additional persons were put into industrial employment alone.
Comment on this
It all depends on how you look at figures. I challenge any member of the House to deny that during that period there were more persons put into industrial employment than at any similar period since this State was founded. There is no doubt about that. I hear a lot of blather from Fianna Fáil Deputies and from Deputies like Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Cowan about the workers, the poor and the trade unionists. I hear a lot about what Fianna Fáil is supposed to have done for the workers. Deputy Dr. Browne talks to us about Fianna Fáil being the friend of the workers. When were they? At what period were they? I challenge that. I have always done so and I do it now. They were always the enemy of the workers.
Comment on this
And in so far as they could do so they did all in their power to split not merely the Labour Party but the trade union movement in this country. That is true.
The workers and the poor of this country got a better break under the inter-Party Government than in any period since this State was founded. Wages and earnings were brought into closer relationship with the cost ofliving than at any time since the State was founded. Not merely was full employment provided for those in employment, but there was overtime not merely for the head of the family but in many cases for other members of the family as well. It is on record that during the inter-Party Government period, for the first time since the State was established, the earnings and wages of workers passed out the cost of living.
We had the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs this morning talking about the cost of living and comparing it with other countries. Apparently, the only time he lifts his eyes from the book of statistics is to place them on the ends of the earth. The cost of living got so out of hand in 1947 that Fianna Fáil, in order to try and befool the people, changed the cost-of-living index. The Taoiseach the other day — he is the man who always talks to us about falsehoods, about telling the truth and not having any prevarication — talked about the cost of living going up by 13 points. He did not tell us, but he was reminded of it afterwards, that when Fianna Fáil changed the cost-of-living index in 1947, they had in mind the Supplementary Budget which they were later to introduce. They took out of that index the articles and the commodities which they were going to increase under the Supplementary Budget. That was a dishonest device.
We took over in February, 1948, with the index at 100. For two and a half years, notwithstanding all that happened in that period, and notwithstanding the fact that there was more than one round of increases in wages and salaries during that period, the cost of living not merely never exceeded the 100, the figure at which we took it over from Fianna Fáil, but it actually dropped on one occasion below it.
Comment on this
I hope to have something to say about that later, and if I do not say it perhaps some member of the Labour Party, when speaking, will deal with it for me. That was the costof living in the three years, notwithstanding the outbreak of the Korean war. In the three years from February, 1948, to February, 1951, the cost-of-living index went up by three points, and only increased by these three points in the second six months of that last year. That was something of an achievement. There was some relationship between wages and prices during that period.
Comment on this
That was not achieved in any easy manner. It was achieved because we were ever watchful of the prices of every commodity, and particularly of essential food commodities. We were ruthless, and that is the only word to describe it, in seeing that there was going to be no over-charging by anyone for any commodity. Deputies will remember, particularly those who were here at the time, that I was challenged over and over again by Fianna Fáil Deputies when on this side of the House because I would not allow the butchers to increase the price of fresh meat.
Comment on this
That was the position, and there can be no challenging of that statement. I was pressed over and over again by people in the manufacturing industries and by people in the distributive trades to decontrol prices. The argument was always put to me that if I decontrolled prices and allowed free competition, it would lead to a reduction in prices — that is if they were allowed just to juggle their different cuts and so on. But I knew what would happen, and I did not do it. I was backed to the uttermost by every one of my colleagues in the line that I took. The result, as I say, was that for two and a half years, notwithstanding the fact that there were increases, and notwithstanding the factthat there were increases in the price of goods coming in from outside, and that complaints were being made to me by people that they were not getting the same margins of profits, I was quite straight in telling them that, in my opinion, they were getting a fair margin of profit, but that they were not going to get away with the immense margins of profit which they got away with during the war under Fianna Fáil. They were not going to be allowed to do what they did under Fianna Fáil when they had wages riveted to the desk with their standstill Orders. When Deputies from any side of the House talk about Fianna Fáil as the friend of the worker and of the poor, I ask them not to forget about the standstill Orders on wages by Fianna Fáil. May I tell the House that there was a standstill Order on wages in draft in the Department of Industry and Commerce as late as October, 1947. That was not during the war period.
We have had all this nonsense about the cost of living. We are told now that we are no different from anybody else and that it is dishonest to talk about these things. The Fianna Fáil Party are to-day the Government of this country, but let me remind the House of the campaign about the cost of living which Fianna Fáil conducted throughout the country in the last six months prior to the 1951 General Election, a campaign which was spearheaded by Deputy Cowan. Deputy Cowan put down a motion condemning me and calling for my resignation at a time when I was in hospital. Deputy Cowan was outraged then at the increase in the cost of living which had gone up two points in three years. He was so outraged that he demanded that his motion be taken in my absence. He said that the people were suffering so much from the high cost of living that a delay could not be contemplated by him.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan was outraged to the extent that he was shedding crocodile tears over the sufferings of his constituents due tothe two-point increase in the cost of living. The Deputy became almost purple in the face when the price of butter was increased from 2/8 to 2/10 per lb., but as Deputy Larkin pointed out this morning, when it went up from 2/10 to 4/2 per lb., he becomes the apologist for Fianna Fáil — a champion of its increases. It makes one almost sick.
Do Fianna Fáil Deputies remember the speeches which they made about the cost of living at that time, and all the tripe that was written about it in the Irish Pressand in theSunday Press—a three-point increase in three years compared with an increase of 23 points in less than two years under Fianna Fáil?
We claim that we put people into employment and good employment. We reduced the numbers that had been queueing up at the labour exchanges looking for jobs to the lowest figure ever touched since records were kept in this country. That is true. Will any Deputy deny that the inter-Party Government, with the support of practically every man in this House, outside the Fianna Fáil Party, brought a feeling of confidence into this country? It gave our people a feeling of confidence in their country such as we have not had for a quarter of a century and such as we have not had for the last two years. There was harmony in the country and people were happy.
I want to put this quite seriously to farmer Deputies in this House. Will any farmer Deputy in this House conscientiously stand up and say that the 1948 Agreement that was signed in London did not bring a period of prosperity to this country, both to agriculture and from agriculture flowing to every other section of the people and for the first time, remember, because in the inter-Party Government it was realised, and not merely realised but acted upon, that until such time that you put agriculture on its feet there was very little you could do for any other section of the people.
Comment on this
We went! London—we did not send civil servants there —and we made what I believe was an excellent agreement that has worked out in the event to the great benefit of this country. I do not think any Deputy from any side of the House, no matter which Party he belongs to, in his heart will question that. Because it did bring prosperity to the farmers of this country, the farmers were put in a position to meet the increased rates which had to be imposed to meet the new services and to give employment. Farmers were put in a position for the first time to be able to pay comparatively decent rates of wages not merely to their own employees but to those who are employed by the county council. That is true and it cannot be questioned.
Again, will Deputies ask themselves conscientiously, has Fianna Fáil any right to claim any credit for the enormous increase last year and this year in farming exports from this country? I do not think that farmers— and farmers know a lot more about this than I do—will suggest for a moment that calves that were born after June, 1951, became our exports in 1952. We hear a lot of talk about increased exports. We are all entitled to be pleased with the increased exports.
Comment on this
They are not. I want to go to another aspect of the 1948 agreement that was not referred to. There has been a good deal of talk by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and some of his colleagues— sometimes even Deputy Childers is let loose on it; he gets his riding instructions as he got them from the Minister for External Affairs to-day—about industrial exports in this country. It is true to say that quite a number of our industries have been able to keep in full production and some of them in nearly full production over the last two years because they were able to export a substantial percentage of their production to Great Britain. Why were they able to do that? Why could that not have been done before 1948— because of the famous or infamous article in the Trade Agreement of 1938which was the biggest obstacle on the industrial side which we had to get over in 1948, when we tried to get Article 1 of the 1938 Agreement out of the way.
Comment on this
But with this difference. We were unable to get it completely out of the way, but we did get the door open to the extent that has allowed us to export into Britain hundreds of thousands of pounds, if not millions of pounds, worth of industrial goods since 1948 up to the present moment. Deputies in the trade union movement and in the Labour movement and industrialists in this country know that to be quite true.
It is a fact that some of our industries in this country because of what we secured for industrial exports in 1948 are exporting as much as 40 per cent. of their entire production and I am glad to say that the quality of the goods is excellent, so excellent and the price so right that they are meeting and beating keen competition. I know one industry which has exported not merely to Great Britain but has exported to a continental country and has put its products into that continental country over a 25 per cent. tariff.
Comment on this
I want to ask any person in this House who has any sort of an open mind: is there any comparison to be made between the way in which this country was governed and the fruits that flowed from that Government to the community over the three and a half years when the inter-Party Government were in office and what has accrued in the last two years? In what are you asked to reaffirm your confidence? For what reason are you asked to reaffirm your confidence in this Government? Do not mind the Minister for Industry and Commerce who for, I think, the seventeenth time in the last 14 months — I have been ticking him off with a pencil—has stabilised the cost of living. As a matter of fact, he made a speech in which he had the cost of livingstabilised three days before he announced an increase of ½d. a lb. in the price of domestic sugar. Since 1927 the Minister for Industry and Commerce has always been promising us jam to-morrow. It is always around the corner. He has told us now that if you will only give him another chance we will have the jam, a double application, within the next two years.
Do not mind that kind of nonsense. What you are dealing with here is a Government who come in here looking for confidence from the Dáil instead of looking for it from the people, where it should be sought, a Government whose policy increased by no fewer than 30,000 persons the number of unemployed in this country within a year and a half. It is all right for the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and others to look at that in a book of statistics, but I sometimes try to visualise that figure, 30,000, as the entire population of the City of Waterford or more than a third of the population of my own county.
Some Deputies here, particularly those who talk from books, just think of that as a number. Very few of them think of the misery that is nearly always behind it. Are Deputies aware —if they are not they ought to be— that men in this city, many of whom came from rural areas, constituents of our own, and who have been in constant employment for the last four to six years, anyway, in the building trade in this country are now disemployed. While the present situation lasts, they are unlikely to be reemployed.
We have heard a lot of talk from the Taoiseach from time to time about the inter-Party Government being dependent on small groups. He made a speech during the recent by-election in which he said that a Government that was beholden to a small group was in an impossible position, it was pushed hither and thither, and that way lay disaster. I wonder what was he thinking about, or had he completely forgotten Deputies Cowan and Browne?
There are many things I would like to deal with, but do not want to be unfair to other Deputies. I do notwant to inflict any further suffering. I know what was inflicted on myself yesterday by the Minister for External Affairs for two hours and 20 minutes.
Comment on this
We are told by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs this morning, on the instructions of the Minister for External Affairs, that measures are being taken by Fianna Fáil, that the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste in this debate told us the plans they had for dealing with unemployment. Someone may have mentioned the word "plan" but that is all we heard. In any case we have been hearing about the Fianna Fáil "plan" for dealing with unemployment for 21 years at least.
Deputy Childers, who is in such close touch with business, economic and social life that he lectures the rest of us here, tells us that business is improving. I will offer a wager here of £1 to 1/- there is not a businessman from here to Donegal or from Donegal to Kerry that will subscribe to that and I do not care what his political views are. Business has been getting steadily worse over the last 12 months and at the moment — and this is part of the reason for the 30,000 additional unemployed — we are in the middle of the greatest business slump that ever hit this State since it was created. That is true and any Deputy in touch with the people in business outside, either employers or employees, knows that is true. Deputies who are in touch even with some of the biggest business premises in this city — it is true also outside the city — know quite well that in the last year and a half some of the biggest establishments have not made anything like enough money to pay their running expenses. We are to vote for a continuance of that and an aggravation of it?
In the light of what I have said and what has been said by other speakers on this side of the House, is it any wonder that the Government are afraid of their natural lives to go before the country? Does anyone think that if the Taoiseach was not absolutely convinced that he would suffer the greatest political defeat he ever suffered, that he would sit there in the humiliating position he has sat in for the last three days? No Government, no Head of a Government, has ever been in the pitiable, humiliating position that the present Government and its Leader have been in for the last three days.
I will say this for Deputy de Valera: I believe that if he thought he had even a sporting chance in a general election he would take that chance. He knows he has not. Must he not be driven to the sorest straits to which a human being can be driven, when he is trying to carry on with the support of Deputies Cowan and Browne?
It would almost make you weep to sit in this House yesterday afternoon and to see the Taoiseach, the Taoiseach, pretending to laugh and smile and enjoy the buffoonery of Deputy Cowan. I have differed from the Taoiseach politically all my lifetime, and I suppose I always will, but I never thought his respect for himself would drop so low that in order to obtain a vote from Deputy Cowan to keep him and his Government in office he was prepared to pretend that he was enjoying the bit of showmanship put up by Deputy Cowan here, while at the same time a man of the Taoiseach's make-up and temperament must have been almost sick looking at it. I believe the Taoiseach would go to the people if he thought he had a sporting chance, but he knows he has not. No man has gone more often to the country, no man has gone when it was not necessary more often to the country; and Deputy Dillon read out here last night statements that Deputy de Valera made in somewhat similar circumstances, except that his position was much stronger in 1947 in the by-elections. The speeches then made by Deputy de Valera were the most compelling arguments against the motion now before the House.
The members of the Fine Gael Party have no reason in the world, in repect of their work for any section of the community, to hang their heads in shame. We are entitled to our views and we will put our views in this House and outside it. We have always done so, and when the people went against us we took it from them. We sat here for 16 long years in opposition, when we had to put up with all the unbearable and ignorant arrogance that we got from the present members of the present Government, with all their cheap gibes, and some of them very unworthy ones. We stuck it and we kept going back to the people, general election after general election, and even when we came back here after a general election with reduced numbers it did not change our principles and our attitude in one iota.
There were certain definite fundamental principles that we believed the people respected and that they would ultimately give their support to them. We knew over a long number of years that, with that particular type of political magic that is peculiar to himself, the Taoiseach was able to hoodwink the people. We knew that the people's mind was on catch-cries, empty slogans, rather than on the hard realities and the economic facts of life. We knew that would pass and, mind you, we put in, even in opposition, even with reduced numbers, 16 years of service to the Irish people in this Irish Parliament—which I hope the Fianna Fáil Party will have the spirit to emulate when they cross over to this side of the House very soon. It is talked and sneered about in the Irish Pressand theSunday Pressand at cross-roads as if there was as great a difference between those who sit on these benches and on the Labour Benches as there is between oil and water. What is the difference?
Comment on this
I would like to hear it from some of the gentlemen opposite who are always talking about it, but I am not going to take lecturesfrom anybody on the Fianna Fáil side.
Comment on this
I am not going to take any lectures on what is due to the people of this country and the workers or the poor from anybody on the Fianna Fáil side. I am not going to take any lectures from the people on the far side that they are more concerned with the agricultural community than Fine Gael is. Agriculture and farmers, and Fianna Fáil farmers in this House, were put in a position of prosperity during the three years of the inter-Party Government that they had never known up to that period and they are still getting it.
Comment on this
We are told that there is something wrong in an inter-Party Government. We are told that there is something wrong in a Government that is not completely dominated by one man.