We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Vote of Confidence—Motion by Taoiseach (Resumed).

Contributions 137–284 of 284. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Certainly, long before the Deputy came into this House and I will be long after he has disappeared from it.

Comment on this

You might get a bit of a fright.

Comment on this

The Deputy should have sense. He is a young man. He is not long here and he is afraid that he will not be here much longer.

Comment on this

Not a bit.

Comment on this

He knows that there is only one seat for Fianna Fáil in County Tipperary and he is hoping that he will get that one.

Comment on this

One for Fine Gael.

Comment on this

There is going to be one for Fianna Fáil and he is trying to make sure that his will be the oneby talking to get his name into the local papers.

Comment on this

Could this Tipperary dispute be settled in Tipperary?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think so.

Comment on this

I think it is most appropriate that a Cork man should move in as peacemaker. Children have to be chastised even by the most kindly parents occasionally.

Comment on this

We will hope he will end as he set out.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Morrissey should be allowed to proceed without interruption. All interruptions are disorderly and the Deputy ought to know that.

Comment on this

I do not know why they always interrupt me so much.

Comment on this

You asked for it. There was no need to mention farmers in this House.

Comment on this

There is no need to tell Deputies in this House that they made more money on their farms under the inter-Party Government in three years than in any similar period under Fianna Fáil! Well now, I thought you should like to be reminded of the good times that they had and I like to remind them that there is a chance even yet, that even to-day those good times may return to them again. There is one consolation to those of them who are farmers. Deputy Aiken is, like myself, a bit of a book-farmer, but those in Fianna Fáil who are farmers have this consolation, that whatever they may lose on the roundabouts by way of their seats they fully made up on the swings from the increases, and from the still greater increases that there will be from what they are producing off their lands.

Deputy Dillon said last night that the Taoiseach was appealing from the people to the appeal court that consists of three, or maybe four, Independent members of this House. So longas they are members of this House they have, of course, the right to vote as they choose, but I want respectfully to suggest that no Deputy can conscientiously vote for a continuance of a Government that has inflicted so much hardship and human misery in the last two years and been responsible for 30,000 additional unemployed, and the loaf increased from 6d. to 9d. and so on, increasing or causing hardship and misery. From the other side of the House we are told that people like the old age pensioners have been compensated for the increase in the cost of living. Give the old age pensioners one loaf of bread per day for seven days of the week and this comes to 3d. more than the additional allowance they got, not to talk about tea or sugar or butter or anything else. The thing is absurd. We have a lot of talk about Fine Gael, or Cumann na nGaedheal as they were, taking 1/-off the old age pensioners. May I resspectfully submit to those Deputies that the removal of the food subsidies reduced the old age pensioners and the blind pensioners, not by 1/- but by nearer to 3/- per week, even allowing for the 1/6 additional which they got. There are several ways, of course, of reducing money. It would have been a much easier thing and weighed less heavily on the old age pensioners and blind pensioners of this country if the Government, instead of taking away subsidies from their food, had reduced their pensions by 1/-. They would not have suffered as much, but that would not have suited Fianna Fáil.

Deputy Larkin forestalled me this morning. I had brought in a copy of "Truth in the News" and there is a ring around the heading to which he referred, but, of course, it was much more appropriate that Deputy Larkin should deal with it because he was the person concerned and in any case he could deal with it much more effectively than I could and he did so. One of the troubles is that 95 per cent. of the people who read this read nothing else.

Comment on this

There is a good paper on your side, too.

Comment on this

I wish we had.

Comment on this

Yes, it supports you 100 per cent.

Comment on this

We have not a paper on our side but if it is on our side, it will not suppress things and distort them.

Comment on this

They simply invent them.

Comment on this

I think that Deputy Cogan, as far as I have been watching the columns of the newspapers, has always got a pretty fair crack from the newspapers whether by way of speeches or letters to the papers, and I do not think that any paper has ever been unfair against the Deputy and I would not like to see anything unfair against any Deputy.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

He got enough space in the Wicklow People, anyhow.

Comment on this

Let any Deputy or Party compare the record of work for this country and for all sections of the people of the inter-Party Government and the Fianna Fáil Government. I wish this could be determined on its merits, but it is not going to be determined on its merits. The Government, if they carry this motion to-day, will carry it by the votes of three or perhaps four Independents. Not one of the three or four Deputies will be voting because he believes in the policy of the Government, because he agrees with the policy of the Government. Two of them at least will be voting, unfortunately, because of a vicious spite and hatred against a certain member of this House, and one of them because of a particularly violent dislike to another member of this House. Those are the facts, and all this talk by certain Independent Deputies, and all their denunciation of Fine Gael, was just a cloak for their real reasons for voting — just a cloak.

I was reminded last night by one of the Ministers that I disliked general elections. Of course I do. No one here who has any experience of elections wants joyfully to dance into the middle of one; but it is not what we like or we want that counts, it is what the people are demanding, that is what counts. There is not a single Deputy sitting in this House to-day but knowsthe people want a general election. Is there any Deputy in public life in the last 30 odd years who ever saw such real interest in what is happening here as there has been for the last two or three months? Have Deputies ever been so frequently accosted in the streets and on the reads by people asking them: "When are you going to have a general election?" Have not the people in the only chance which they got shown in no unmistakeable way that they want a general election and want it for one purpose only, to get rid of the present Government?

Comment on this

The Taoiseach had a perfect right to put down this motion but I object completely to the way in which it has been done. Since Tuesday afternoon until the Taoiseach will conclude and the vote will be taken, 28 hours will have been used in discussing the motion. If the Taoiseach wanted a vote of confidence I cannot see why, seeing that the Dáil is at the very busiest time of the year, he could not have approached the Whips and arranged that a motion of confidence be put before the House without any discussion. It could be all over in a quarter of an hour on last Tuesday or at any time fixed and the 28 hours could have been used to much more effect in transacting the business we are sent here to transact.

As a matter of fact, it could have been done in a much simplier way. Since the result of the by-elections became known, it has been quite clear that the people have turned very strongly against the present Government. The Taoiseach could take for granted, without any motion of confidence, what attitude Clann na Talmhan, Fine Gael, Labour and Clann na Poblachta would take in such a vote of confidence. A simple letter addressed to five or six Deputies would have decided the issue as the Taoiseach knows quite well, without a long waste of time.

Speakers on the Government side have tried to fight shy of the fact that it was the result of the by-elections which caused this vote of confidence. No matter how you side-step this result, the people in Cork and Wicklowand Dublin North West a short time ago made it quite clear that there is a big swing away from Government policy, in other words, a very determined vote of disapproval of the policy of the present Government.

When the present Government was seeking a vote here for the Taoiseach and subsequently for the Government, Deputy de Valera put forward a 15-point programme. I would like that the Taoiseach, when replying, or some Minister speaking after me, would point out which one of these 15 points has been fulfilled, which has been even tackled and which ones the present Government have not completely reneged on. It was the policy of the inter-Party Government taken over without a blush. The only thing they could say was that in seeking support of certain Deputies on the 13th June, 1951, Fianna Fáil, not having a policy of their own, could implement the policy of the inter-Party Government better than the inter-Party Government itself could. That was how they came into office. One of the points was that the food subsidies would be maintained, that they would not be cut. Since then the people have learned to regard that promise in the same way as they regarded the promise of Deputy MacEntee, the Minister for Finance, a few days before the last general election, when he assured his own constituents that the tax on tobacco and drink would not be reimposed if Fianna Fáil came back to power.

This vote of confidence has been brought on by the result of the by-elections. The result of the by-elections has been caused by the fact that Fianna Fáil have gone away from the people. It is not the people who went away from Fianna Fáil, they were forced away. Fianna Fáil has gone back on every single thing they took office and got into office to do. Of all the rosy and very catchy promises they have not fulfilled one of them. Not alone that, but some of the promises have been put completely into reverse, food subsidies being one. After spending three and a half years while we were the Government, blaring over loudspeakers and from every placewhere they could get an inch of space in their own paper, that the cost of living had gone sky high during the time of the inter-Party Government, they got into power. They secured their votes to a large extent on that constantly repeated fallacy that the cost of living had gone up during the time of the inter-Party Government.

I remember that not long since I challenged the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, here in the House as to what had gone up, with the exception of 2d. in the lb. of butter and I think 2d. in the gallon of petrol, during our time. After a lot of fumbling for papers over there he said the loaf of bread had gone up a farthing and I think he mentioned that the ordinary household spool of thread had gone up a halfpenny. Fianna Fáil is now learning that the Irish people cannot be trampled on, that they cannot be gulled and fooled as they have been by the present Government. They have been sitting on that side of the House since the 14th June, 1951, just two years, because they went into power on promises they had not the slightest intention of fulfilling and which they made no effort to fulfil since they went in.

Every single good work we started during our time has been smashed and cut and set aside. The policy of a certain crowd of people behind the scenes who were trying to impose their will or their views on our Government, and that we steadfastly rejected and I am proud now that we rejected them, Fianna Fáil has swallowed and put into operation. One of the results of that has been that we are exporting £20,000,000 worth more of agricultural produce this year than ever before, £20,000,000 more than last year. Some of that £20,000,000 has been due to an actual increase in production, due to the policy of the inter-Party Government, but the great bulk of the £20,000,000 has been achieved by a very different means, by the deliberately and carefully calculated policy of depriving our own people of the means to purchase our own food. I would go so far as to say that £15,000,000 of the increased agricultural exports which went across the Channel this year hasbeen nothing more or less than the result of Fianna Fáil policy in denying employment to those seeking work, in cutting down in every possible way and in allowing the cost of living to go up to such an extent that the working man, his wife and children, had less to eat last year and in the aggregate it has amounted, in my opinion, to very near £15,000,000 worth of agricultural produce. The Minister for Finance could very easily walk in here on Budget day and calmly announce that agricultural exports had increased by £20,000,000. The exports have increased because the present Government have denied to the people of the country the means to purchase the food they had been purchasing and to live up to the standard that we had established. That is the reason for the complete setback which the Government met with in the three recent by-elections.

During the period from 1948 to 1951 I occasionally had to go through the city in the evening, and there was scarcely any evening when there was not a meeting at some street corner addressed by some Fianna Fáil speaker. His theme was the way the cost of living had got out of control under the inter-Party Government, and assuring them that if Fianna Fáil got back into power the cost of living would be controlled. I listened to them on several occasions declaring that the inter-Party Government were a shocking crowd and allowed the cost of living to get out of control. Having listened to that for three and a half years, I do not blame people if some of that sunk in. Some of the people believed that. The people in the City of Dublin particularly believed it. So much so that they went a long way to putting Fianna Fáil into power and, when they did, the Taoiseach and other members of the Cabinet proceeded to trample on those who placed their confidence in them and showed them what they thought about them.

Mention was made that out of the six by-elections which have occurred in the last two years the Government succeeded in winning two, North Mayo and Waterford. It would not be out of place if I revealed once again, as Irevealed on a previous occasion, that from my own personal knowledge the people of North Mayo were fooled. I say deliberately that the electorate of North Mayo were fooled and fooled by no less a man than a Parliamentary Secretary in the present Government.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think that arises on this motion.

Comment on this

Let me use the word "misled".

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not that I am objecting to. I do not see how the manner in which that election was conducted arises.

Comment on this

I do not see why it should not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think the conduct of an election campaign was discussed by any Deputies. This motion is clearly asking the Dáil for a vote of confidence in the Government. How an election was conducted some years ago does not seem to arise on that.

Comment on this

The only reference which I wish to make is this. If the Taoiseach and the Government were relying on winning in North Mayo last year — if we could say they won — to show that the Government have maintained a steady position in the House. I want to say that that election was won principally through a deliberately misleading statement by the Parliamentary Secretary (Deputy Kennedy) in telling the people——

Comment on this

Is it in order for a Deputy to state that a Parliamentary Secretary made a deliberately false statement?

Comment on this

He made a deliberately false statement in my hearing in the town of Foxford and also in Ballycastle.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy knows that a deliberately false statement is a lie.

Comment on this

I want to say that I heard the statement in Foxford.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not matter. It is charging a Deputy with making a deliberately false statement and that is attributing a lie to him. The Deputy should withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

Very good, I will withdraw it and use the words "misleading statement", because it was a misleading statement. The statement was to the effect — Deputies can judge for themselves whether it was false or misleading—"Do the people of Foxford think that poor Dev is going to increase the price of food in the way that Deputy Blowick and other Clann na Talmhan and Fine Gael Deputies have set out?" That is the statement and quite a number of people were swayed by it, but they know the truth of it since.

The other reference I want to make to the same by-election is that the Minister for Industry and Commerce went down to Ballina the Saturday evening before the voting day and told the people of Ballina that they were to have a biscuit factory established.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow that.

Comment on this

Very well, I will not proceed further with it beyond saying that the biscuit factory never materialised.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy said that he was not going to refer to it further.

Comment on this

When the present Government came into power, the first thing they did was to make bloodcurdling speeches, particularly the Tánaiste and the Minister for Finance, which had the effect of freezing the credit of the country. By these speeches they wanted to discredit the inter-Party Government. They wanted to show that they were right in some way or other. They wanted to show that there was something seriously wrong in this country. Incidentally, what they were doing was taking advice that had been thrown at the heads of the inter-Party Government for three and a half years and rejected by them. That advice was to restrictcredit in the way Fianna Fáil has done. We see now the disastrous consequences of it. I must say that I did not see what would be the full consequences of it when we were receiving the advice. I see the consequences now. Private employers and people who might be inclined to put money into private enterprise had their credit frozen. People had put money into the building of houses and had from 50 to 70 men working for them. These workers are now in England because credit was frozen. People could not get credit to continue building and, when houses were built, there was nobody to buy them.

Fianna Fáil have stated that they are bringing down the unemployment figure from the 90,000 at which it stood a short time ago. If they are bringing it down, how are they bringing it down? They are bringing it down by the mean device of trying to put people off the dole. It is not the man who is drawing the dole wrongfully that is being put off. We know that some people are drawing the dole wrongfully, but it is not that type of person that is being put off. It is, perhaps, the father of a family who has no work or who has not a shilling who is being put off. The Government increased the cost of living on that man, and now the few shillings he was getting are cut off and he can starve. The resul can be seen by everybody. Anybody who goes to a railway station can see trainloads of our youngest and bes flying from the country as if from the plague.

I have not much contact with the City of Dublin, but some of the events that happened recently, particularly what happened yesterday afternoon outside this House, are enough to disquiet anyone. I can understand Deputies representing city constituencies being quite alarmed. I have been ten years coming to this House now and never before have I seen between 2,000 and 3,000 people in a crowd marching outside the House, and 300 police mobilised to keep the gates closed.

Comment on this

You are exaggerating.

Comment on this

I am not. I said from 2,000 to 3,000, and I am quite sure thatis an underestimate from what I saw. It might be said, and it has been hinted, on the Government side, that these people are not genuinely looking for work. That is not true. Anybody who went among them and looked at them would know that they were men with hard hands genuinely looking for work and with no hope of getting it. I do not see this matter getting much publicity in the papers. Certainly down in the West of Ireland it is not known. Never in my time, and certainly not in the inter-Party Government's time — that desperate period in the history of Ireland, according to Fianna Fáil—was one single unemployed man seen outside the gates of Leinster House. On the contrary, Fianna Fáil Ministers can look up the files and they will find that many works of development during our time had to be slowed down because there were not men to go to work on them. Deputy Davern may laugh, but I remember that the hydro-electric development works at Ballyshannon were in danger of completely closing down because men could not be found to do the work. The Minister for Social Welfare can back me out in that, and any Fianna Fáil speaker can rise within the next hour—there is still time—if that statement is untrue.

If Deputy Davern and Deputy Ó Briain, the Parliamentary Secretary, want to verify that, the figures are there. It was in the summer period of the year. I cannot remember what year, but there was a danger that the whole works would have to close down completely because there were not enough men to work them.

Comment on this

They are looking for men for Bord na Móna. The papers are full of advertisements and the labour exchanges are full of advertisementts.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary wants to bluff himself with that kind of nonsense, he can. If Bord na Móna are really looking for men, what were these men doing outside Leinster House yesterday morning? Were they all foreigners or was it down from the moon that they came?

Among them were some of my own neighbours who enjoyed plenty of employment during the inter-Party Government's time, in Dublin, and they were men who were not afraid of a day's work and would work against men from any part of the country. I saw some of them outside the gate yesterday, and certainly if they had a chance of coming in here I would not like to think of the tender way they would handle the Government.

Comment on this

Deputy Davern does not suggest there was no unemployment, I think?

Comment on this

No, there was unemployment always.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Blowick is speaking.

Comment on this

Unemployment has reached a position in this country where it has become dangerous. I will not dwell further on it than that. It is no longer something that can be joked about by the Government side of the House — where it seems to be a joke.

Side by side with the unemployment situation is the increase in rates of interest for loans and agricultural credit for farmers. It seems we simply must follow everything that the Government across the water does. I will not repeat all I said on the occasion of the Budget of 1952, but I know that Budget was dictated across the water. Mr. MacEntee went so far as to send a most warm letter to Mr. Butler on the occasion of his Budget. But the Chancellor of the Exchequer in the British House of Commons this year gave reliefs to every single citizen of the British community. Mr. MacEntee comes along, and what does he do? He copper-fastens everything he did last year, and in addition, insists on every one of the Ministers of his Government — finishing up with Deputy Childers, Minister for Posts and Telegraphs — contributing so much extra taxation towards what I might truly describe as a squeezing of extra revenue from the people. All last summer and winter were taken up by this House with Minister after Minister coming in seeking additional money.The Minister for Agriculture was the only exception. He had no schemes to put forward to tax the farmers but he has got his marching orders from the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance to cut down on the land reclamation scheme. I think he is asking £2,200,000 this year for reclamation but if Fianna Fáil are in office, of that £2,200,000 not much more than half will be spent on the farmers. And Deputy Davern may take me up on that if he likes.

Comment on this

You are very pleasant.

Comment on this

All these things have resulted in the biggest defeat of the whole lot — strangely enough — in Dublin North-West, in the city itself. Even in the country, where the people have longer distances to come to the poll and where a number are indisposed and old—even there, a majority came out, and a very determined majority, to see that Fianna Fáil knew exactly what they were thinking.

This motion of confidence in the Government, Sir, has been asked by the Taoiseach. I want to say this: that the people of the country want that motion defeated. It has been flung across the House that nobody on this side of the House wants an election. I think that Deputy Morrissey, speaking a few minutes ago, put it very decisively when he said: "It is not what we want in this House that matters; it is what the people want that matters." The people at the present time in my opinion want a chance to mark their ballot papers again. I will not prophesy, as Deputy Dr. Browne apparently does, what way they will vote, but at the present time the people are clamouring for a chance to mark their ballot papers and I have not the slightest doubt what way the majority will mark these papers when they get a chance. I hope they will get the chance soon.

I want to warn the Government— and there should be no need to warn them — that the greatest safety valve democracy has, is a general election. It gives the people a chance, if they are tired of the Government that is in, to put them out, and it gives a chance to the people to use in a constitutionalway the one weapon at their disposal. It is a very dangerous experiment for a Government to try to hold on to office. The last three by-elections should not have left any doubt in the mind of the Government as to what the people want. Every time I go home to my constituency I meet many people and many previous supporters of Fianna Fáil among them and what they say is not: "When are you going to have a general election?" but I am asked: "When are you going to put them out?"

Deputy Davern and the Parliamentary Secretary may smile, but I think there will be a very different smile on their faces in a short time. They are beginning to feel the blast very sharply now. It is very evident on that side of the House.

I was listening to most of the Taoiseach's speech on Tuesday and I was astonished that there was complete silence on the question of what they are going to do.

In this motion of confidence the Taoiseach in effect says: "I am Taoiseach. Here is my Government. I have been carrying on for the last two or three years since I got into power in any old way I liked. I want you to give me a vote of confidence to carry on in any old way I like for the future". That is exactly what the Taoiseach asks the Dáil. Neither himself nor the Tánaiste who is, I suppose, the principal spokesman for the Government, has given any indication of the plans they have for the relief of unemployment, how they propose to ease the cost of living, how they propose to put an end to the misery and poverty that have been brought into many homes, or what they propose to do about trade and business in the country. The doors of every business premises in the country have been virtually closed as a result of Government policy. Any Deputy who is in contact with shopkeepers must know that. Shopkeepers make no secret of the fact that their customers, ordinary farmers and workers, who were able to buy food for decent meals during the period of office of the inter-Party Government and for a while after it left office, are buying most sparingly, in bits and scraps, now. Shopkeepers havetold me that a great many of their customers, in the towns particularly, are not able to buy sufficient food for the maintenance of their families.

Comment on this

They said that only to please you.

Comment on this

I hope things are better in Tipperary than they are in Mayo. I am speaking of my own constituency and I claim to know the conditions there fairly intimately. One of the best indications of whether the Government is popular or not is the result of the national collection for Fianna Fáil. Some of the national collections I saw were pitiable fiascos compared to what they used to be a short time ago.

Comment on this

On the contrary, there has been a 50 per cent. increase.

Comment on this

They were not held at all in some places.

Comment on this

One saw two or three people standing at the chapel gate with a placard headed: "National Collection for Fianna Fáil. Support Eamon de Valera". The total of the subscription came to about 25/- or 27/-where I saw as much as £30 subscribed a short time before. That is a nice picture and it is about the best indication of how the public pulse is going. This is not a matter for laughing and joking. It is a serious matter, particularly for the poor working man's wife, who sees her husband out of work and who has to depend on the £1 or £2 which he brings from the labour exchange, who sees her children badly clad, under-nourished and badly fed. It is anything but a joke, I want to tell Deputy Davern.

Comment on this

That was no joke.

Comment on this

I would suggest to Deputy Cogan that he should not draw me on himself because Deputy Cogan has his share of responsibility for bringing all this about. Remember he has contributed his own share to the operation of this policy. It is a matter for which he will have to answer in his own constituency. It is a matterbetween himself and his conscience also.

Comment on this

North Mayo gave the Deputy his answer.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants me to tell him what happened in North Mayo I shall do so.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Blowick is inviting interruptions.

Comment on this

I did not mention North Mayo. I could tell the Deputy all about the demise of the Ballina biscuit factory. In fact, it was stillborn. Would Deputy Killilea tell us what has become of it?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is that not inviting interruptions?

Comment on this

No, Sir, it is not. I am inviting Deputy Killilea to speak after me and to give me the answer if he is able and if the Chair is gracious enough to call him. The last matter to which I should like to refer is the manner in which the Department that I administered during the period of office of the inter-Party Government is now being administered. I refer to the Department of Lands and Forestry. About 1940 the operations of the Land Commission were brought to a standstill. The Land Commission were prohibited from resuming and acquiring land for the relief of congestion. The staff were dissipated and scattered or were confined to merely routine work such as vesting. When the inter-Party Government came into office, they were faced with the problem of removing the ban which had been imposed on the work of the Land Commission, somewhere, I think, about the 14th April, 1941. I do not know whether that announcement was made through the Dáil or whether it was merely said that owing to the emergency the work of the Land Commission should stand over for a few years. I was not here at the time and I cannot say whether the House took that as a genuine excuse. The war, however, finished in 1945 and in 1948, when we took office, the Order had not been revoked. We know the way in which the Land Commission has been administered since.

Comment on this

The staff are all back.

Comment on this

The staff are not all back. I want to tell Deputy Killilea that 50 per cent. of the staff that are there now are staff I had to recruit when I went there. That was one of the drawbacks I had to contend with for the first 18 months, because the outdoor staff cannot be expected to take in a number of young men and in a short time turn them out as fully-fledged inspectors able to value land.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely that is a question of administration. The Deputy should confine himself to policy.

Comment on this

We are asked for a vote of confidence.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy may not discuss administration on this motion. He must confine himself to policy.

Comment on this

This is a question of Government policy. I am trying to deal with the policy of the Government in dealing with the Land Commission. Since they took over office, their policy has been a continuation of the policy which was operated for six or seven years prior to the advent of the inter-Party Government. The present Minister is not acquiring any fresh land. He is using the pool of land which the commissioners acquired during my time. He is using that pool and, apparently, having great fun in dividing it, but he is adding nothing to it, with the result that if there is another change of Government in a year's time or in two or three years' time, the incoming Minister will find things in the same condition as I found them in 1948.

Again, expenditure on the Forestry Department has been cut. I shall not dwell on that further than to say that if it is the Government's wish to make a genuine effort to stop the flight from the land and to stop emigration from the western seaboard from Kerry to Donegal, they have no finer instrument in their hands to achieve that purpose than the implementation of the forestry programme which I left to Deputy Derrig when he took overoffice on the 14th June two years ago.

Last year the Government introduced the Undeveloped Areas Act but, so far as I can see, that Act is being used as nothing more or less than an electioneering stunt in order to bamboozle and fool the people. The Minister for Industry and Commerce here last night indicated that the Act is not working out as well as he thought it would. He hopes that there will be 12 factories established west of the Shannon. Again, that is a Fianna Fáil hope for the future—"live horse and you will get grass". He said that 35 or 36 factories would be established in Dublin in the near future. That is more centralisation. That is the be-all and the end-all of the famous Undeveloped Areas Act of which we had such hopes. He says that 15 projects are under consideration and he has hopes that 12 of these will materialise.

For Deputy Killilea's information, I hope that they will materialise — more so than the biscuit factory for Ballina which the Minister for Industry and Commerce promised just a year ago. I suppose some people were fooled about that particular project.

Comment on this

We will get it in time.

Comment on this

I want to refer now to a statement which the Tánaiste made in this House last night in relation to the butter subsidy. I do not know why he made that statement. He must be very well aware that it is a serious misstatement. He said that it would take a subsidy of £1,000,000 to bring down the price of butter by ld. That is altogether wrong. I corrected him at the time he made the statement but yet he clung to his misstatement. Taking winter and summer production alike, it takes a little under three gallons of milk to produce a lb. of butter. A penny a gallon on milk represents £1,000,000. A sum of £1,000,000 devoted to the subsidy on butter would mean a reduction of 3d. in the lb. I do not know why the Tánaiste insisted on making that misstatement last night unless it was for the purpose of scaring the people— seeing that, already, butter has gone up from 2/10 a lb. under the inter-PartyGovernment to 4/2 a lb. under the Fianna Fáil Government—into believing that it will now take £16,000,000 to bring the price of butter down to the level at which it was during the inter-Party Government's term of office. It will not take one third of that sum. Butter has been taken off the tables of the working-class people, and their children are deprived of it. Those of them who are fortunate enough to be able to buy margarine are doing so. We are now in the position that we have 60,000 to 70,000 cwt. of a butter surplus.

I have no doubt that the Taoiseach and those Deputies who sit on the Government side of the House consider that it is a great comfort to the working man and his wife and family to know that, although they are denied the lb. of butter, somewhere in this country there is a huge store of 60,000 to 70,000 cwt. of butter which they can look at but cannot buy.

Comment on this

It is due to increasing the price of milk to the farmers.

Comment on this

It is not. Deputy Davern will get a rude awakening shortly.

Comment on this

It is up by 15 per cent.

Comment on this

How many of Deputy Davern's constituents have been denied the right or the means of purchasing a lb. of butter?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy stand for a reduction in the price of milk? I have asked the Deputy a straight question.

Comment on this

I will not be drawn along that line, good, bad or indifferent. I am sticking to one thing and that is that the people of this country consumed 760,000 cwt. of butter each year under the inter-Party Government. They were able to buy it and, thank God, they were able to eat it. Along with that, we had to import butter. What is the position to-day?

Comment on this

We imported butter, too.

Comment on this

You imported the New Zealand butter, the yellow butter,which received so much adverse criticism while the inter-Party Government were in office. You are imposing that imported butter on Dublin and on a radius around Dublin—so much so that the people there cannot buy a lb. of Irish creamery butter. But the people can read that, somewhere, in cold storage—probably on a ship on the Liffey—there are between 60,000 and 70,000 cwt. of the best Irish creamery butter. I suppose that, sooner or later, the English people will be subsidised, as they were before—in other words, bribed—to eat the butter which our own people are denied. It is like the extra £20,000,000 worth of food, meat and so forth that was exported and that represents an increase in our exports.

Comment on this

That is all nonsense.

Comment on this

If it is, then it is the Minister for Finance's nonsense. I should be only too happy to think that we would have an increase in our agricultural exports. Some Deputy may try to argue from what I have said that I am opposed to increased agricultural exports. I am not. I should like to see this country exporting £200,000,000 worth of agricultural exports instead of £100,000,000 worth but, first of all, I want to see that our own people are adequately fed and then by all means export the surplus. So long as we deny it to our own people, we cannot call it a surplus. I do not want to see food withheld from the tables of the working people and the poor in order to sell it abroad. I always encourage every farmer in my constituency whom I meet to produce as much as he possibly can. I always encourage him to knock as much as he can out of his land, and I am always prepared to give him any advice which I may be able to give him and which he may require.

Comment on this

Why did you not do it when you were in the Coalition Government?

Comment on this

Of course we did it. Why did you cut down drainage? Why was the drainage under the Local Authorities (Works) Act cut down from the £1,900,000 which we weregiving to the country councils when we were in office to £400,000 by the Fianna Fáil Government? The Deputies opposite have no business getting hot under the collar when they see the writing on the wall.

Comment on this

We are not one bit worried.

Comment on this

You are. We can see the pale faces from this side of the House and they give the lie to that statement by Deputy Killilea.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Blowick in favour of reducing the price of agricultural produce, thus compelling the Irish farmer to sell his produce at less than its market value?

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Not at all. I am afraid that that question is very much in Deputy Davern's line. That is not the way to approach the problem. There is a way to approach it. Deputy Lehane and Deputy Davern know the conditions that obtained under the inter-Party Government. I have not the slightest doubt that the prosperity that the people enjoyed at that time and a great deal of what might be called the just imposition of taxation will be restored to a large extent within a period of six months of the inter-Party Government's taking office again.

Comment on this

Do you want a restriction of exports?

Comment on this

I have already said that I should like to see our exports expanded. If I did not believe that there would be a vast improvement in conditions in this country generally, I should vote for this motion. I believe that the full and plenty, the prosperity, the almost full employment and the other benefits which the people of this country enjoyed under the inter-Party Government can be restored. For these reasons, Clann na Talmhan are voting against the Taoiseach's motion.

Comment on this

My only concern is to find out whether or not you want a restriction of exports in order to keepdown the price of agricultural produce?

Comment on this

Not at all. That would be like a doctor who proposes to cut off the head of a child simply because a rash appeared on the child's face. That would be a very silly way of approaching the problem.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

What would your suggestion be?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Blowick must be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I believe that the prosperity, the full employment and, above all else, the just imposition of taxation that obtained during the period of office of the inter-Party Government can be restored. I think it can truthfully be said that, under the Coalition Government, we had the lowest ever number of discontented people. I think that that happy position can be restored.

If the present Government had implemented their 15-point programme— which was our policy — and took up where we left off, it is very difficult to say what the result of the recent by-elections would have been, but I feel certain that the motion which this House is now discussing would not have been necessary. In other words, we should not be in the position in which we are to-day. We would not have unemployed people marching up and down the streets of our city and bus loads of Gardaí protecting Leinster House for the first time in the history of this State and we should not have train loads of our youth flying the country. We should not have 78,000 young men, between the ages of 15 and 45 years, fleeing from the land to take up occupations in our cities and towns and across the water. All that has happened in the short period since 1946.

To put it briefly, we aim at increased production and at assisting the principal industry of this country — agriculture — to get on its feet.

Comment on this

Reducing milk to 1/- a gallon.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These interruptions must cease and Deputy Blowick must be allowed to conclude his speech.

Comment on this

We aimed at restoring to the farmers the 4,000,000 acres approximately of arable land which are under water and about which Fianna Fáil seem to think nothing because they have cut down on all our schemes. Deputy Fanning shakes his head.

Comment on this

And no wonder.

Comment on this

There are several Deputies who want to speak. Every time a Deputy interrupts Deputy Blowick, he begins his speech all over again. I do not want to deprive him of his right to speak, but the fact is that there are only two hours left.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair cannot curtail the length of any speech.

Comment on this

I should be long sorry to draw out my remarks so much as to deprive any Deputy of speaking. We are opposing the motion for the reasons I have given. We believe we can restore prosperity and go a long way towards stopping emigration. The people in the recent by-elections have shown that they are angrily disposed towards the present Government and are determined to get shut of them. The unemployed marches are proof of that, together with the fact that Leinster House has to be guarded by a strong force of guards and military against the anger of the Dublin people. We believe that in a period of six months we can go a very long way towards restoring the prosperity the country enjoyed two years ago and will enjoy again in the near future.

Comment on this

I propose to be as brief as possible.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

This is three-quarters of one group in the House who have now spoken.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

I have been here since 10.30 a.m. I was first in and I had hoped to get five minutes.

Comment on this

I have been here since 10.30 a.m. yesterday trying to get in and I am entitled to speak.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I might point out to Deputy Corish that so far ten speakers have spoken for the motion, taking nine hours and 47 minutes and 11 speakers have spoken against, taking 11 hours and 38 minutes.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

I know your difficulty, Sir, in trying to give a proper opportunity to the different groups, but Deputy Cogan belongs to a group who describe themselves as Independents who generally support the Government. Two of these four members have already spoken, so that when the Deputy has spoken, 75 per cent. of the group will have spoken.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

Could we have quarter hour or ten minute speeches, so as to let us all get in? I only want five minutes to talk about unemployment.

Comment on this

You have been bluffing about it for long enough.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair cannot curtail speeches.

Comment on this

There is very little time left, and Deputy Byrne and Deputy Corish are endeavouring to waste it. In fairness to other speakers, I shall endeavour to be as brief as possible. I have been waiting since yesterday to get in. I have prepared a fair amount of notes but it would not be possible for me to use them, and I do not intend to do so. I intend so far as possible to give other Deputies a chance of speaking, and I am sorry that the previous speakers did not show that consideration, in view of the fact that there is a time limit on this debate.

Deputy Morrissey, when concluding his speech, made an observation which I think deserves to be refuted. He said that there were two Independent Deputies who support the Government because of a vicious spite against some other member of the House. He also said that there was another Independent member who supports the Government because of a vicious hatred and spite against another member, and I take it he is referring to myself,because over and over again the accusation has been made against me that I in some way bear hatred, ill-will or spite towards one member of the House. I want to make it clear beyond all question that I have never borne any ill-will or hatred for any member of the House. Every member of the House is my friend, and if any member is in need of any help I can give, he will get it. I think it is an appalling thing that the leading Opposition Party, Fine Gael, and certain sections of the Press should concentrate on this campaign of abuse which seeks to represent a Deputy's policy and actions in this House as being inspired and motivated solely by personal ill-will and of hatred for another Deputy.

It is true that, during the period of the inter-Party, I expressed strong disagreement with the policy pursued by the then Minister for Agriculture, but there was nothing personal in that opposition. It was based on policy, and policy alone, and the records of the House will show that again and again during the administration of that Minister and that Government, ex-Deputy O'Reilly and myself, two Independent farmer Deputies, introduced motions designed to change that policy. Let us hear no more of the suggestion that no Deputy can disagree with inter-Party policy unless he bears hatred, ill-will or spite to some member of that Government. It is a vicious slander from the Independent Deputies — the same accusation has been directed against Deputy Dr. Browne, Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll and Deputy Cowan. I want to say that I resent it and that it should not be repeated.

Notice taken that20Deputies were not present; House counted, and20Deputies being present,

Comment on this

Deputy Larkin last night raised the tone of the debate. He raised it to a certain extent above the gutter by concentrating upon the issues before us in a serious way. He spoke of the difficulties of a Party such as the Labour Party in a situation of the kind we have and he showed how difficultit would be for them to support any Party. As he said, when you take a cat by the tail—I think he was referring to the Fine Gael Party—it is often very hard to let go. He thereby indicated a certain difficulty that faces the country. There are people who say that this motion should not be put to the House, that the Government should go to the country. The only purpose of going to the country would be to secure a change of Government. If the Government went to the country and secured their return to power, it would mean that the same policy would be continued, so I take it that those people who appeal for a general election, whether genuinely or not, are asking for a change of Government. I would like to examine this question to find out what would happen if there was a general election and if the present Government was to become a minority. Would we immediately have an alternative Government, with a policy and programme, capable of taking over the reins of administration?

Deputy Larkin very properly indicated that there is no certainty of any such thing. He said that his Party would put a programme forward and submit a programme to Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil and, if that programme was accepted by either, they would then give conditional support to the Party that accepted it. After an election, therefore, we would have a long period of uncertainty and unrest, a period during which the Labour Party and Fine Gael would be fighting out the various issues between themselves. Deputy Larkin said that during the period of the inter-Party Government the Fine Gael Party worked in the broad light of day and in the darkness of the night to undermine and destroy the Labour Party. In face of that it is quite evident that Deputy Larkin is not likely in the event of an opportunity arising to form another inter-Party Government to make as soft a bargain as he did in 1948. At that time Fine Gael gained a certain number of seats and the Labour Party lost.

Labour came out of the experiment very badly. That is in accord with the history of Fine Gael. Fine Gael is akind of political Christie. They have a cupboard filled chock-full of the skeletons of the small Parties that tried to help them out and put them into power. They have the remains of a number of Farmers' Parties that they gobbled up and destroyed. That is the policy they have pursued all down the years. I take it they are determined to continue with that policy right to the end.

Now, the Labour Party has some sort of leadership. I do not think there is any leadership in Clann na Talmhan judging from our experience here to-day. Because the Labour Party has some leadership they will fight for their existence and not allow themselves to become skeletons in this political Christie's cupboard.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

On a point of order. The Deputy has used a particular reference in relation to a recent event in the newspapers. I think the association does not do the House any good and I would ask the Chair to draw the Deputy's attention to the implications of his remarks.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair did not understand the reference.

Comment on this

It may not be very creditable to the Fine Gael Party, but it is nevertheless true. They have destroyed their allies one by one. Clann na Poblachta came into this House, a strong, virile, vigorous Party of 10 or 11 members. At the end of the inter-Party régime there was nothing but the head and the tail. They were just the same as a herring that hunted with a hungry cat.

The Taoiseach opened this debate in his usual moderate and restrained way. He outlined the difficulties the country has experienced in building up and sustaining the nation. Whether or not we agree with him on everything, every Deputy must acknowledge that the Taoiseach is by far the ablest Leader this country has produced. He has great moral and physical courage, but it is not that alone that has marked him out. It is the fact that not only has he shown the moral courage and the necessary ability but he has also had patience, perseverance andvigilance in watching the nation's long-term interests and safeguarding them. He has sustained this nation against attack from outside and against the danger of want in time of emergency. He has sustained it against involvement in war. For that reason he deserves to be treated with respect.

One characteristic marks out the Opposition and that is its animosity, towards the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach's integrity has enabled this nation to become a free nation and to become firmly established as such. For that reason I think it is only right that his Government should be given an opportunity of proving that its policy over the last two years is from the long-term national point of view the safest and the best policy for the nation.

What is the alternative offered by the Opposition? It is nothing but a medley of conflicting and discordant suggestions from a number of Parties with conflicting interests. They have declared their intention not to prepare an agreed policy and put that policy before the nation. They are prepared to go to the country with rival policies. Should they prove successful they will resort to bargaining in relation to ministerial office. They may reach some kind of hotch-potch agreement which will enable them to carry on for some time. That was the history of the three and a half years of inter-Party Government. I know it because I was endeavouring during that time to secure something in the nature of a sound national policy.

I am one of those who agreed with the proposal that an attempt should be made to form an all-Party national Government. I recognised from the outset that the first fundamental for the establishment of such a Government was fair play and goodwill on the part of those who held ministerial office. Time and time again here we had one Minister who maliciously defamed his predecessors; one Minister more than any other was the chief culprit in that respect. I knew it was impossible in those circumstances to look forward to a national Government because Party politics and political partisanship were the main issues ofthat particular Minister and some of his colleagues. The Labour members of the inter-Party Government have a fairly creditable record in that respect. Unfortunately for me I had a share in putting one Independent Minister into office and he was the Minister who from the very outset misrepresented the position in which he found the country when he took office and misrepresented the position in relation to agriculture thereby seeking to defame and destroy, if possible, the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

He was not an Independent, of course.

Comment on this

We only discovered that after some time. In a very short time we found that he was working not for the Independents but to destroy the Independents, particularly Deputy O'Reilly and myself, in order to replace them by Fine Gael members. He succeeded in so far as Deputy O'Reilly was concerned. He has not yet succeeded as far as I am concerned.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Where is Deputy Deering from?

Comment on this

I am still Deputy for the County Wicklow and you may find that for a very long time hence I shall still be Deputy for the County Wicklow with God's help and if I have my health. Since I have referred to health, I should like to say that I never listened to a more disgraceful statement than that made by the Leader or whatever he is of the Fine Gael Party. He said that on this vote the Division Lobbies would be turned into hospital corridors. He suggested that it was a shameful and disgraceful thing for a man to suffer illness. Good health is a blessing which we all hold from the Almighty. We enjoy it from day to day, from hour to hour, or even from one moment to another. We do not know how long we may enjoy health and we do not know how soon we may be deprived of it but no man with any sense of decency would insult or offend a man who lost his health. The ex-Taoiseach was the one man who availed of a stretcher to bring one of his supporters into this House and there was not one opponent of the ex-Taoiseach'swho said a disrespectful word to that man when he was brought into the House.

I myself on that occasion had a deeper respect for that particular Deputy than I ever had before or since when I saw him come to cast his vote under great difficulties. If any citizen had to walk on a crutch through the poorest street in Dublin, you could take it that the lowliest loafer on the street would not offend or insult him. It was left to a leader of a political Party to spit upon any unfortunate Deputy who might have to be brought into the House to vote regardless of which side he might vote for.

The ex-Taoiseach made another statement which could hardly be allowed to pass. He spoke of two disreputable Independent Deputies upon whom the Government might have to depend on this vote. What right on earth has Deputy John Costello to describe any Deputy as being disreputable? What is his own record? What is the record of his colleagues? Let him look at the responsible Ministers he had assisting him when he was head of the Government. Let him look at General Mulcahy whose feast day is celebrated on the 8th December.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy is getting away from the motion.

Comment on this

Let him look at Field-Marshal Everett who achieved fame in the battle of Baltinglass. Let him look into the mirror and see the man who solemnly pledged himself, when seeking office, that he would uphold the connection between this country and the British Commonwealth and who availed of the first opportunity, whether under pressure or otherwise, to sever the last link with that Commonwealth. Could the man who so shamefully broke faith with his own supporters and with the people throughout the length and breadth of the country look into the mirror and describe himself as reputable? How could such a man dare accuse other Deputies of being disreputable?

Members of this House are proud of their reputations, proud of their statusas honourable representatives of the people. We try to carry out in the spirit and in the letter the policy which we advocated. I have always advocated a progressive national and agricultural policy. I must say that I have great respect for Deputy Larkin, particularly when he speaks in this House. He speaks with moderation and restraint, but I think he errs slightly when he refers to me as being conservative.

Comment on this

If I am wrong, I apologise.

Comment on this

As Professor Joad used to say, it all depends on what you mean by conservative. If conservatism means conserving or preserving the things that are good and desirable in Irish life, then by all means am I conservative, but if it means opposing reform, opposing improvement and opposing an improvement in the standard of life of our people, then I most emphatically protest against being described as a conservative. If we were to go into questions of policy, I think Deputy Larkin would find that I am at least as progressive in my outlook as any Deputy in this House. I believe that every boy and girl reared in this country ought to have a reasonable prospect of obtaining employment within this country and a decent home in which to live and enjoy the ordinary comforts of life.

I would always be prepared to support any action on the part of the State to remove the obstacles that stand in the way of all people securing full employment. I was interested to learn that a speaker, on behalf of the demonstration of unemployed workers in the city yesterday, declared that he had no confidence in the present Government, but he also said that they did not want Fine Gael. So it seems that there is a fairly strong feeling in this country that the removal of the present Government would not solve our economic and social difficulties. The Taoiseach was right, and so was Deputy Lemass, Minister for Industry and Commerce, when they indicated that this Dáil was elected for a period of five years by the electorate. ThisDáil is entitled to take that period in order to carry out its programme, the programme on which the majority of its members are agreed.

This Dáil has a perfect right to do that if it so desires. This is the Parliament of the nation. Sooner or later this Parliament must render an account to the people. It must give its account within a period of five years and it may, if it so desires, present that account within a shorter period. That is a matter for the Dáil itself and for the Government. Therefore, there is no merit in the suggestion that this Dáil has no right to propose a vote of confidence in the Government. We have got to ask ourselves what is this vote of confidence. It is a vote of confidence in the present Government. We have also got to ask ourselves what would be the net result of our action in voting against this motion. It would be a vote of confidence in the Opposition. Is there any Deputy on any side of the House who could have confidence in men like Deputy Costello, Deputy Donnellan, who has grown a little, Deputy Blowick, or the Leader of the Labour Party who is trying to save his small Party from being eaten up and destroyed by that devouring monster, Fine Gael?

I want to say that I believe we will be in a better position to judge the policy of the present Government when it has been carried out to its fullest extent. I believe that the country is in an improving condition. That is true, particularly of agriculture. One would think, listening to some of the silly speakers and some of the legal gentlemen we have in this House, that agriculture was in a state of decline and decay. I have never known agriculture to offer better prospects to the farmer than it does at the present time. Since the change of Government two years ago, the price of milk has been increased by almost 3d. per gallon, the price of wheat has been increased by 17/- per barrel, and the price of beet has been substantially increased by 11/- or 12/- a ton. In the last year of the inter-Party Government we were devoting £500,000 to land reclamation and improvement, while in the present year we have voted £3,000,000 for the same purpose, therebyindicating clearly that there is a progressive policy in operation in regard to agriculture. Since agriculture is the basis and foundation of our whole economic system, there is hope that we may see a further substantial improvement in conditions.

I do not intend to detain the House much longer since I know there are other speakers to follow, but I think that anyone who views the issue fairly will acknowledge that this vote of confidence by Dáil Éireann is justifiable in present circumstances. It remains for the Government, having secured this vote of confidence from the Dáil, to press froward with its programme of national development as rapidly as possible. I believe, in spite of my conservatism, that there is a good deal of further employment which the Government could give. Bord na Móna has proved to be a source of very substantial employment for our workers. Work in regard to afforestation and schemes of that kind should be pushed forward as rapidly as possible so that employment may be provided on a very substantial scale. No one wants to see any decent citizen, who is able and willing to work, in the position in which he is unable to secure employment.

Comment on this

The Central Bank does.

Comment on this

The fact in regard to the Central Bank, as every Deputy of the House is aware, is that when it asked in its report for a cutting down on works of capital development, the Government repudiated that suggestion most emphatically, and instead of cutting down on works of capital development, the Government very substantially increased expenditure on these works in the present year to a figure of over £40,000,000. That sum of money is being raised by the State on the security of the taxpayer and is being expended on works of capital development. I am in favour of extending that still further.

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, in the course of his speech, dealt with the housing problem and suggested that, as far as it relates to local authority schemes, it is on theway to being solved. I believe, however, that we should still further improve housing conditions in the rural areas. I do not think it is right that any small working farmer should not have as decent a house as the workers in Ballyfermot or in any of those other city areas. I am told that these corporation houses are very good houses. They are certainly very good if compared with the houses in which many of our small farmers are living to-day. Let us go ahead with works of improvement and development of that kind, works designed to provide employment and to raise the standard of living of our people and thereby induce our young men and young women to settle down in Ireland and establish homes here. That is our objective.

What is the objective of the Opposition —of Fine Gael? In spite of everything that I could do when the inter-Party Government was in power, there was a ruthless cutting down of the area under tillage. Last year, a campaign was organised by the Fine Gael Party to cut down the area under both wheat and beet. This year, thank God, there is a substantial increase in the acreage under these two crops. The people, in spite of Fine Gael and of everything they could do to hold them down and drive them into panic, to bewilder them and confuse them, are settling down and are determined to go ahead. I think that is what we all desire. We have a so-called Republican paper, the Sunday Independentin which a gentlemen named Skinner writes——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

On a point of order. Is the Deputy entitled to make a charge against a person outside of this House?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The names of people outside this House should not be mentioned in it

Comment on this

This newspaper, at weekly or monthly intervals, has been declaring that a general election will be held immediately—that the Dáil will be dissolved this week or next week.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It will be right next week.

Comment on this

It has been doing that, the whole object of that campaign being to disorganise business.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

This whole campaign is designed to prevent recovery, to prevent an improvement in the economic and business life of this country, to create confusion, discontent and uneasiness amongst our people. I think it is time that that kind of sabotage of our national economy was brought to a close. It is time that people should adopt a more responsible attitude. Our farming industry, as I have said, is improving and is capable of still greater improvement. The business life of the community is very sensitive to alarms of that kind. They disturb the people's minds. What we need is to restore confidence in our business people so that they will be enabled to provide further opportunities for employment for our people.

The people who are opposed to the present Government, and want to climb into office by hook or by crook, do not want the employment problem solved or more people put into permanent employment, and neither do they want to see the economic situation of the country improved. What they want is confusion and chaos in order to exploit it. I think, however, that the people are beginning to size up Fine Gael in that respect. They are beginning to see that they are nothing more than a Party of political opportunists who are mad for ministerial office and, if they can get it, are determined to keep it by any and every means at their disposal.

I had brought to my notice savage, vicious and ruthless statements that were made about me to my supporters in County Wicklow. Every member of the Fine Gael Party ought to be ashamed of the campaign that they waged. I was accused of selling my vote for a sum of £20,000.

Comment on this

Your name was not mentioned.

Comment on this

That statement was made to decent, respectable people.

Comment on this

We did not mention you. The people forgot about you.

Comment on this

The people of County Wicklow are sensible enough.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

They know that Senator McCrea, a decent man, was stabbed in the back and they know the hairy old hand that wielded the stiletto. They know that Fine Gael out-manoeuvred, outwitted and out-generalled the Labour Party and they did it with the help of a fifth column within the Labour Party.

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this

It can be proved.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

What about Deputy Corry's statements? The same thing could be said about him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cogan is in possession, and he should be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

Is there any chance of getting back to the motion?

Comment on this

If those people will keep quiet. One of the statements made by Deputy Morrissey was that every farmer Deputy must acknowledge that the inter-Party Government brought prosperity to agriculture. That statement was made very deliberately in the course of this debate. The inter-Party Government had nothing whatever to do with any improvement that has taken place in agricultural conditions since 1947. We all know that in 1947 we had a very severe winter and conditions were bad in the early summer of that year. Nevertheless the prices of live stock, cattle and sheep, rose sharply, as every cattle trader and every farmer knows. They rose during 1947, because of improved shipping conditions, to the level almost of the British price, and they have remained at that level ever since. It had nothing to do with the 1948 Agreement. It did not matter who entered into that agreement. The prices had risen before that agreement was signed and anyone who cares to go down to the Library and read the shipping statisticsor the prices of imports for that period will see that the price of cattle increased by almost 50 per cent. and in some cases by almost 100 per cent. in the latter half of 1947.

Every Deputy knows that; yet we have certain politicians trying to cash in and seek to secure some kudos for themselves upon the assertion that they brought about agricultural prosperity. Any increased prosperity that has come is the natural result of the relaxing of wartime conditions restricting shipping and causing a world shortage of food supplies, particularly of animal products. Whatever happens we can hope to look forward to that condition prevailing for a long time. It does not matter what Government is in power, that will happen. However, a Government can do immeasurable harm if we are to be influenced by the policy advocated by Deputy Dillon of cutting down the acreage under wheat, the acreage under beet and that of other cash crops for which there is a secure and permanent market.

We may face some risks in regard to the export market at all times. We never can control that market but at least we can control the home market and we can ensure that our farmers will obtain a reasonable return for their work. The farmers all over the country are waking up to the importance of that market. They are waking up to the value which the growing of wheat and particularly of beet has in their economy. They know these crops provide the proper rotation which improves their soil and lays the foundation for better leas and better grasses.

Those are the things that make for improvement in the standard of living. Because those things are possible under the present Government, because they are not possible under the Opposition, I am determined to support this motion, and I hope the Government will continue with that policy of intensive development of agricultural and industrial resources because that is the only way in which they can provide a better standard of living for our people and better social services. I hope they will also persist in improving social services in spite of any protests andany opposition that may be offered by one section of the Opposition. I believe in improving our social services. They will have the support, not perhaps of the Fine Gael Party but the support of all progressive elements within the nation.

Comment on this

This motion is one that is of very great importance and I am very sorry that so much time has been wasted. I have been sitting in the House yesterday and to-day and a very considerable amount of time has been wasted by people on both sides standing up, speaking for an hour and saying nothing. As far as I am concerned and as far as this motion matters, I am not in the slightest degree worried one way or the other whether there is an election to-morrow, an election next month or an election next year.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Any action I take will not have that consideration influencing my view to any possible degree. During the week-end I did take the opportunity of discussing this vote with the standing committee of the County Cork Farmers' Association and with as many other representatives or constituents of my area that I could contact. I feel in what I am doing now and in what I intend to do, I am backed and I am helped through the views and the information I have got from these sources.

Comment on this